SB 41: Civil actions: damages.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-30
Existing law authorizes a person who suffers a loss or harm to himself or herself, or his or her property, from an unlawful act or omission of another to recover monetary compensation, known as damages, from the person in fault. Existing law specifies the measure of damages as the amount which will compensate for the loss or harm, whether anticipated or not, and requires the damages awarded be reasonable.
This bill would prohibit the estimation, measure, or calculation of civil damages from being based on, or considering, race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The principals of equal protection and due process are fundamental to our democracy and the concept of civil liberty.
(b)California has been a pioneer in civil rights, leading the way in prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, and other protected categories.
(c)However, in tort actions around the state and country, race, ethnicity, and gender are routinely used in calculating damage awards that are meant to provide restitution to victims. For example, since women in America make less wages, on average, than men, the damages awarded to women are substantially lower than those received by men.
(d)Nearly one-half of economists surveyed by the National Association of Forensic Economics said they consider race, and 92 percent consider gender, when projecting earning potential for an injured person, including children. Future lost earning potential is a significant component of the damages awarded in tort actions.
(e)To determine projected lost earning potential, court experts typically rely on the Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Population Survey. The results are a reflection of gender pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and they fail to account for possible progress or individual achievement.
(f)The consequence of this biasto use averages that represent generations of discriminatory practicesis to perpetuate systemic inequalities. Such practices disproportionately injure women and minority individuals by depriving them of fair compensation.
(g)Using race and gender-based tables can, by some estimates, under-value women and minorities by hundreds of thousands of dollars, including children who have not yet had the opportunity to work or identify career options. In particularly, such practices greatly disadvantage children of color, who are more likely to be impacted by environmental hazards created by the industrial facilities and factories located in low-income communities.
SEC. 2.Section 3361 is added to the Civil Code, to read:3361.Estimations, measures, or calculations of damages shall not be based on, and shall not consider, race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 136, Statutes of 2019. |
| Jul 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 19, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 11, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 4). |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 7, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 11, 2019 | Special Consent SB41 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2019 | SB 41 Hertzberg Senate Third Reading By Chiu | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 4, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB41 Hertzberg et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 41 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 41
Amended: 6/10/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/6/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 7/1/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Civil actions: damages
DIGEST:
This bill provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earning capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, or gender.
Assembly Amendments reformulate the damages covered by the bill and the categories that are protected.
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the United States Constitution, that no State shall deny
any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. (U.S. Const., Amend. XIV, Sec. 1.)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be denied equal protection of the laws. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 7(a).)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be disqualified from entering or pursuing a business, profession, vocation, or employment because of sex, race, creed, color, or national or ethnic origin. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 8.)
- Provides that every person who suffers detriment from the unlawful act or omission of another, may recover from the person in fault a compensation therefor in money, which is called damages. (Civ. Code § 3281.) “Detriment” is defined as loss or harm suffered in person or property. (Civ. Code § 3282.)
- Authorizes damages to be awarded, in a judicial proceeding, for detriment resulting after the commencement thereof, or certain to result in the future. (Civ. Code § 3283.)
- Provides that for the breach of an obligation not arising from contract, the measure of damages, except where otherwise expressly provided, is the amount which will compensate for all the detriment proximately caused thereby, whether it could have been anticipated or not. (Civ. Code § 3333.)
This bill:
- Sets forth a series of findings and declarations.
- Provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earning capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, or gender.
Background
When a person suffers loss or harm as the result of an unlawful act or omission of another, the person is authorized to recover monetary compensation therefor. This compensation is referred to as damages and may be awarded in a judicial proceeding. The damages may include those arising after the unlawful act or omission as well as those damages certain to result in the future.
These latter damages involve a certain amount of prediction and estimation. This bill prohibits reducing those damages based on consideration of certain protected characteristics. In essence, the race, ethnicity, or gender of a party to a civil action cannot be used to reduce a party’s damages.
Comments
According to the author:
Civil rights laws prohibit discrimination against protected classes in a variety of areas, yet no state or federal law prohibits the use of race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation in the calculation of damages awarded to injured parties. The result has been severe and unaddressed discrimination in court-awarded damages for certain protected classes. This practice deprives some individuals of fair compensation and perpetuates systemic inequality. SB 41 remedies this injustice by prohibiting judges, juries, and expert witnesses from considering a plaintiff’s race, gender, religion or sexual orientation in calculating civil damage awards.
Wage disparities
According to the United States Census Bureau and the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, the nationwide wage gap between men and women has shrunk since the 1960s when the federal Equal Pay Act was enacted. Yet, by 2012, female workers still earned just 78 cents for every dollar paid to a man. Three years later, the gap had only improved by two cents. According to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research (IWPR), unless further action is taken, the gender wage gap will not close entirely until 2059.[1]
As troubling as the gender pay gap is, disparities in earnings based on race and ethnicity are even larger. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2015, while the average white male earned $21 per hour, his Black and Latino counterparts received just $15 and $14, respectively.[2] These differences in pay cannot be fully explained by differences in education levels, either. The Pew Research Center’s data shows that college-educated Black and Latino men receive only about 80 percent of the pay that college-educated white men do.[3]
The intersection of gender, race, and ethnicity produce the greatest inequities of all: Black and Latina women earn 65 and 58 cents, respectively, for every dollar a white male earns.[4] The IWPR research estimates that Black women will not reach parity with white men until 2119; Latinas will reach parity in 2224.[5]
Past discrimination compounded
When a person suffers injury as the result of another, the injured party is entitled to damages. The principle underlying an award of damages is to compensate the injured party for any detriment suffered as a result of the relevant unlawful act or omission of the offending party from the point of injury into the future. In most personal injury and wrongful death cases, determining the proper level of damages will require an estimation of life expectancy and lost earnings.
The issue seeking to be addressed by this bill is that these estimations can be influenced by various considerations, such as race, ethnicity, and gender, to the detriment of the plaintiff. As seen above, research regarding earnings is often broken down by various demographics and characteristics. Given historic discrimination and the attendant pay gaps, damages for certain persons that are injured, especially women of color, are likely to be lower than their white male counterparts based on the data and tables available. In essence, the historic pay discrimination is compounded when used to lower damage awards for certain populations.
A recent study by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights presents the stark situation:
Courts rely on damages calculations by experts who use tables that predict, among other factors, plaintiffs’ lost earnings and wages on the basis of their race/ethnicity and gender. Typically, experts use the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey, which is updated quarterly, to determine projected lost earnings. Loss of earning potential is a significant component of damages and can “make the difference between a modest and sizable award.”
. . . [R]ace/ethnicity- and gender-specific tables preserve systemic and structural inequalities, reinforce current pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and fail to account for possible progress.
In short, they ascribe lower values to the lives of women and people of color. Despite this discriminatory impact, the use of such tables is the industry standard: approximately 44% of economists said they consider race when calculating future earnings income and 92% reported they consider gender. In a survey of 172 members of the National Association of Forensic Economists, when tasked with calculating the loss of a two-year-old African American boy unable to work in the future, 42.4% stated they would only use gender specific data, whereas 44.8% would use both race-specific and gender-specific data.[6]
Others have argued that the use of these tables to the detriment of historically marginalized groups is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution. One federal judge, the Honorable Jack B. Weinstein, has repeatedly rejected the use of these types of statistics for damages calculations, asserting, in part, constitutional grounds: “Equal protection in this context demands that the claimant not be subjected to a disadvantageous life expectancy estimate solely on the basis of a ‘racial’ classification.” (McMillan v. City of New York (E.D.N.Y. 2008) 253 F.R.D. 247, 255.) In addition, Professor Jennifer B. Wriggins of the University of Maine School of Law has called into question the constitutionality of using these types of statistics:
It [] fails to recognize human potential, and it legitimizes inequality to use this evidence in court to measure an injured individual’s damages. . . . [I]t inscribes past inequality—in wages and education—at least some of which derives from past discrimination on the basis of race and/or gender, on individuals and on the future. Admitting race-based tables, and gender-based tables, then, in tort litigation, is an example of treating like cases not alike, and for no compelling reason. It is therefore a violation of equal protection and should stop.[7]
This bill prohibits estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earning capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death from being reduced based on race, ethnicity, or gender. This ensures that historic discrimination is not compounded.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Association of Black Lawyers
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
Consumer Attorneys of California
Hollywood NOW
Riverside Temple Beth El
San Jose/Silicon Valley NAACP
Silicon Valley Community Foundation
W. Haywood Burns Institute
One individual
Civil Justice Association of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Hollywood Chapter of the National Organization for Women (Hollywood NOW) writes: “The use of these race- and gender-specific tables to calculate damage awards preserves systemic and structural inequalities, reinforces current pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and fails to account for possible progress. Moreover, it disproportionately impacts communities of color because it incentivizes companies to allocate riskier operations to communities where their exposure to financial liability is lower.
“The use of these discriminatory predictive tools has gone unaddressed by state and federal governments for too long, in large part because they manifest in the testimony of “expert witnesses” who are hired by defendants to justify lower awards for marginalized groups. All California plaintiffs deserve just compensation, regardless of their gender, race, religion or sexual orientation.
“For these reasons, Hollywood NOW supports SB 41.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Civil Justice Association of California (CJAC) writes: “There are routine and perfectly appropriate circumstances where these prohibited factors may be used in calculating damages. For example, estimating the costs of lifetime care depends on an analysis of life expectancy, which is influenced by gender. Loss of consortium claims also consider life expectancy. The inability to consider life expectancy would tend to adversely affect women, who have longer life expectancies as a class, and benefit men, whose life expectancies are generally shorter.
“CJAC supports the accurate calculation of damages in civil litigation, which would be impeded by the provisions of SB 41.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 7/1/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wicks
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
7/3/19 14:31:27
**** END ****
The Gender Wage Gap: 2018 Earnings Differences by Race and Ethnicity (March 2019) Institute for Women’s Policy Research, https://iwpr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/C478_Gender-Wage-Gap-in-2018.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Patten, Racial, Gender Wage Gaps Persist in U.S. Despite Some Progress (July 1, 2016) Pew Research Center, http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/07/01/racial-gender-wage-gaps-persist-in-u-s-despite-some-progress/ [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Ibid. ↑
See fn. 1. ↑
Dariely Rodriguez & Hope Kwiatkowski, How Race, Ethnicity, and Gender Impact Your Life’s Worth: Discrimination in Civil Damage Awards (July 2018) Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, https://lawyerscommittee.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/LC_Life27s-Worth_FINAL.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Jennifer B. Wriggins, Constitution Day Lecture: Constitutional Law and Tort Law: Injury, Race, Gender, and Equal Protection (2010) 63 Me. L.Rev. 263, https://digitalcommons.mainelaw.maine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1211&context=mlr [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 41
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:June 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits race, ethnicity, or gender from being utilized to reduce lost or impaired earnings related damage awards in a civil action.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death from being reduced on the grounds of race, ethnicity, or gender.
- Makes various findings and declarations that, generally, state that reductions of income-related damages sole based on demographic data associated with a plaintiff's membership in a protected class is against the public policy of the State of California.
COMMENTS:
Existing law provides that plaintiffs who are injured as the result of the negligence of another are entitled to seek compensatory damages. In many cases, especially if the plaintiff is killed or rendered permanently disabled, the plaintiff's future lost or impaired earnings are awarded as damages. California courts have held that while damages cannot be purely speculative, "recovery is allowed if claimed benefits are reasonably certain to have been realized but for the wrongful act of the opposing party." (Piscitelli v. Friedenberg (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 953, 989.) To assist juries in determining damage awards, California law permits the use of expert testimony, undergirded by various statistical tables, to provide evidence of a plaintiff's earning potential and life expectancy. (Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, No. 3900 et seq. (2019 edition).) The underlying goal of utilizing statistical tables for determining damages awards is justified. As noted, existing law prohibits speculative damage amounts, and expert testimony based on the tables assist juries in making rational decisions regarding damage awards. Accordingly, the damage tables utilized by experts must be the product of an actuarial process that examines a plaintiff's life expectancy, earning potential, and other lifestyle choices in an attempt to estimate the monetary value of the plaintiff's life and lifetime wage earning potential.
Seeking to prevent entrenched societal biases from undermining the civil justice system and perpetuating historic discrimination, this bill would prohibit past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death damages from being reduced on the basis of the plaintiff's race, ethnicity, or gender. Additionally, this bill makes significant findings that the use of broad statistical tools for discerning damages are arcane and in conflict with the public policy of California as they exacerbate existing biases. Finally, this bill makes findings that although this bill is limited to the demographic data sets contained in and derived from the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Current Population Survey, that is frequently used by expert witnesses in personal injury or wrongful death cases, nothing in this bill should be construed to authorize a generalized reduction of damages based on any protected class.
According to the Author:
Civil rights laws prohibit discrimination against protected classes in a variety of areas, yet no state or federal law prohibits the use of race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation in the calculation of damages awarded to injured parties. The result has been severe and unaddressed discrimination in court-awarded damages for certain protected classes. This practice deprives some individuals of fair compensation and perpetuates systemic inequality. SB 41 remedies this injustice by prohibiting judges, juries, defense attorneys and expert witnesses from using a plaintiff's race, gender, religion or sexual orientation to reduce civil damage awards.
Arguments in Support:
This bill is sponsored by Consumer Attorneys of California, who argue against the unfairness of the existing system for awarding income-related damages in civil cases. In support of this bill they state:
Language in statute must be clear and carefully drafted in order to accomplish the goal of the bill, to prohibit game playing and manipulation of damages based on this racially biased data. The proposed committee amendments strike the correct balance to carefully craft a solution to ensure all injured individuals are entitled to the same potential earnings, without an unfair "discount" to wrongdoers based on the plaintiff's race, gender, or both.
Arguments in Opposition:
None
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Fong, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001059
Date of Hearing: June 4, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 41
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Civil actions: damages
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE LAW PROHIBIT A REDUCTION OF INCOME-RELATED CIVIL DAMAGES FROM BEING SOLELY BASED ON THE PLAINTIFF’S MEMBERSHIP IN A PROTECTED CLASS, SUCH AS RACE, ETHNICITY, AND GENDER?
- SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE MAKE VARIOUS FINDINGS generally stating THAT reductions of income-related civil damages SOLELY based ON demographic data associated with a plaintiff’s membership in a protected class IS AGAINST THE PUBLIC POLICY OF THE STATE OF CAlIFORNIA?
SYNOPSIS
Generally, California’s existing tort laws and civil jury instructions promote the awarding of civil damages in a manner that is highly individualized to a specific plaintiff and the associated harms that the plaintiff suffered. However, the existing law also permits the introduction of expert testimony based on an analysis of actuarial tables, derived from federally generated demographic data, to estimate certain damages that are somewhat speculative. This testimony is particularly relied upon when calculating awards for lost or impaired earning capacity over a plaintiff’s lifetime. The federal data and associated statistical tables are based on historic income trends for various genders, races, and ethnicities. Due to America’s long history of wage discrimination based on gender, race, and ethnicity, these tables, unfortunately, reflect the long-entrenched biases of American society toward these protected classes. Due to the heavy reliance on this data when determining lost earnings awards in cases involving personal injury or wrongful death, too frequently historic wage discrimination creeps into damages awards. Accordingly, a white male plaintiff is likely to receive a significantly greater damage award than a similarly situated woman or minority male.
Recognizing the inherent unfairness created by relying on actuarial tables that reflect society’s existing wage gap to award civil damages, as proposed to be amended, this bill would prohibit estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death from being reduced on the grounds of race, ethnicity, or gender. Additionally, this bill contains a robust series of legislative findings stating the intent of the Legislature that no person should be discriminated against in the calculation of their lost earnings on the account of a general application of statistical tables that discriminate against protected classes.
This measure is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California who argue against the inherent unfairness and discriminatory impact of the existing system for award damages for lost or impaired income. As currently in print, this measure is opposed by the Civil Justice Association of California (CJAC), who object to the bill’s prohibition of the use of actuarial tables to calculate life expectancy of the plaintiff. However, in an attempt to address these concerns, as proposed to be amended, the applicability of this bill will be limited to lost earnings or impaired earning capacity only. The amendments are incorporated into and reflected in the analysis. It is unknown whether CJAC will remove its opposition to the bill as a result of the proposed amendments. This bill was approved by the Senate with bi-partisan support.
SUMMARY: Prohibits race, ethnicity, or gender from being utilized to reduce lost or impaired earnings related damage awards in a civil action. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death from being reduced on the grounds of race, ethnicity, or gender.
- Finds and declares all of the following:
- The principals of equal protection and due process are fundamental to our democracy and the concept of civil liberty;
- California has been a pioneer in civil rights, leading the way in prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, and other protected categories;
- However, in tort actions around the state and country, race, ethnicity, and gender are routinely used in calculating damage awards that are meant to provide restitution to victims. For example, since women in America make less wages, on average, than men, the damages awarded to women are substantially lower than those received by men;
- Nearly one-half of economists surveyed by the National Association of Forensic Economics said they consider race, and 92 percent consider gender, when projecting earning potential for an injured person, including children. Future lost earning potential is a significant component of the damages awarded in tort actions;
- To determine projected lost earning potential, court experts typically rely on the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey. The results are a reflection of gender pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and they fail to account for possible progress or individual achievement;
- The consequence of this bias—to use averages that represent generations of discriminatory practices—is to perpetuate systemic inequalities. Such practices disproportionately injure women and minority individuals by depriving them of fair compensation;
- Using race and gender-based tables can, by some estimates, under-value women and minorities by hundreds of thousands of dollars, including children who have not yet had the opportunity to work or identify career options. In particularly, such practices greatly disadvantage children of color, who are more likely to be impacted by environmental hazards created by the industrial facilities and factories located in low-income communities;
- Any generalized reduction of civil damages, using statistical tables alone, based on a plaintiff’s membership in a protected class, as defined in Section 51 of the Civil Code is counter to the public policy of the State of California; and
- Nothing in this bill shall be construed to explicitly permit the generalized reduction of damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity based on protected classifications not identified in the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey unless otherwise permitted by existing law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be denied equal protection of the laws. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, Section 7 (a).)
- Provides, in the Unruh Civil Rights Act, that all persons within the jurisdiction of this state are free and equal, and no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. (Civil Code Section 51.)
- Provides that every person who suffers detriment from the unlawful act or omission of another, may recover from the person in fault monetary compensation therefor, which is called damages. (Civil Code Section 3281.)
- Defines for the purpose of 3), “detriment” to mean a loss or harm suffered to the person or one’s property. (Civil Code Section 3282.)
- Authorizes damages to be awarded, in a judicial proceeding, for detriment resulting after the commencement thereof, or certain to result in the future. (Civil Code Section 3283.)
- Provides that for the breach of an obligation not arising from contract, the measure of damages, except where otherwise expressly provided, is the amount which will compensate for all the detriment proximately caused thereby, whether it could have been anticipated or not. (Civil Code Section 3333.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: In the event a person suffers a physical injury as the result of an unlawful act or omission by another, the injured party is entitled to monetary damages. In calculating the damages, future impacts may be taken into consideration, including the loss of potential earnings. These calculations can be complex and take into account a myriad of factors. The calculations are also supposed to be highly specific in addressing the harms caused to a specific plaintiff. However, decades of wage discrimination against women and racial or ethnic minorities is too frequently being built into damage awards for minority plaintiffs due to a reliance on actuarial tables derived from federal Bureau of Labor Statistics data. The societal biases entrenched in that data has, in turn, been incorporated into the actuarial calculations made by expert witnesses in personal injury cases. To ensure that these biases are kept out of the civil justice system, this bill seeks to reduce the reliance on demographic data in the calculation of civil damages. In support of the measure the author states:
Civil rights laws prohibit discrimination against protected classes in a variety of areas, yet no state or federal law prohibits the use of race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation in the calculation of damages awarded to injured parties. The result has been severe and unaddressed discrimination in court-awarded damages for certain protected classes. This practice deprives some individuals of fair compensation and perpetuates systemic inequality. SB 41 remedies this injustice by prohibiting judges, juries, defense attorneys and expert witnesses from using a plaintiff’s race, gender, religion or sexual orientation to reduce civil damage awards.
Current processes for determining damage awards seek to apply an analytical framework. Existing law provides that plaintiffs who are injured as the result of the negligence of another are entitled to seek compensatory damages. In many cases, especially if the plaintiff is killed or rendered permanently disabled, the plaintiff’s future lost or impaired earnings are awarded as damages. California courts have held that while damages cannot be purely speculative, “recovery is allowed if claimed benefits are reasonably certain to have been realized but for the wrongful act of the opposing party.” (Piscitelli v. Friedenberg (2001) 87 Cal.App.4th 953, 989.) To assist juries in determining damage awards, California law permits the use of expert testimony, undergirded by various statistical tables, to provide evidence of a plaintiff’s earning potential and life expectancy. (Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, No. 3900 et seq. (2019 edition).) The underlying goal of utilizing statistical tables for determining damages awards is justified. As noted, existing law prohibits speculative damage amounts, and expert testimony based on the tables assist juries in making rational decisions regarding damage awards. Accordingly, the damage tables utilized by experts must be the product of an actuarial process that examines a plaintiff’s life expectancy, earning potential, and other lifestyle choices in an attempt to estimate the monetary value of the plaintiff’s life and lifetime wage earning potential.
Existing tools for measuring damages result in the civil justice system mirroring entrenched societal biases. As noted, the existing actuarial tables for determining potential damages frequently examine a plaintiff’s ability to generate future income. Despite California’s significant body of anti-discrimination law, utilizing expert testimony that relies upon these statistical tables enables juries to unconsciously discriminate on the basis of race, gender, and ethnicity. According to the United States Census Bureau and the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, as of 2012, female workers only make 78 cents for every dollar made by a man. This wage gap is not simply limited to a male-female dichotomy. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2015, white American males made an average of $21 per hour. (The Gender Wage Gap: 2018 Earnings Differences by Race and Ethnicity (March 2019) Institute for Women’s Policy Research.) This is compared to $15 for their black peers and $14 per hour for their Latino peers. Even in white collar professions a racial wage gap persists, the Pew Research Center noted that minority men with a college degree tend to earn only 80 percent of their white counterparts. (Patten, Racial, Gender Wage Gaps Persist in U.S. Despite Some Progress (July 1, 2016) Pew Research Center.) The wage gap is especially acute when race and gender are both taken into account. According to the Pew Research Center, black and Latina women earn 65 and 58 cents, respectively, for every dollar that a white male earns. (Ibid.)
Given the outsized emphasis that personal injury damages place on lost or impaired wages, the racial and gender wage gaps play out in the amount of damages a person can achieve. For example, utilizing the wage information detailed above, a Latina woman suffering an injury that resulted in a similar loss of earning potential would receive almost fifty percent less in potential wage-related damages when compared with a white man. According to the Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights Under the Law, the practice is, “particularly problematic when calculating damages for child victims who have not yet worked,” as the actuarial tables currently utilized cannot account for a child’s educational attainment and chosen profession. (Rodriguez & Kwiatkowski, How Race, Ethnicity, and Gender Impact Your Life’s Worth: Discrimination in Civil Damage Awards (July 2018) Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law.) Accordingly, the worst societal biases about minority achievement are foisted onto child plaintiffs.
This bill. Seeking to prevent entrenched societal biases from undermining the civil justice system and perpetuating historic discrimination, as proposed to be amended, this bill would prohibit past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death damages from being reduced on the basis of the plaintiff’s race, ethnicity, or gender. Additionally, this bill makes significant findings that the use of broad statistical tools for discerning damages are arcane and in conflict with the public policy of California as they exacerbate existing biases. Finally, the bill makes findings that although this bill is limited to the demographic data sets contained in and derived from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey, that is frequently used by expert witnesses in personal injury or wrongful death cases, nothing in this bill should be construed to authorize a generalized reduction of damages based on any protected class.
Despite flaws, actuarial tables do serve a useful purpose in some contexts. As currently in print, this bill would prohibit the use of actuarial tables in all contexts related to the calculation and reduction of damages for plaintiffs in personal injury or wrongful death cases. In opposition to the in-print version of this bill, the Civil Justice Association of California notes, “there are routine and perfectly appropriate circumstances where these prohibited factors may be used in calculating damages. For example, estimating the costs of lifetime care depends on an analysis of life expectancy, which is influenced by gender.” Indeed, it has been shown that women on average do live longer than men. Additionally, statistical evidence exists to suggest that certain racial or ethnic groups have longer life expectancies than others. (Cantu, et al. New estimates of racial/ethnic differences in life expectancy with chronic morbidity and functional loss: evidence from the National Health Interview Survey, Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology Vol. 28,3 (2013), 283-97.) Although socio-economic disparities, many rooted in long-existing cultural biases, certainly play a role in life expectancy disparities between ethnicities, biological and evolutionary factors may play a role as well. For example, Americans of Hispanic origin tend to experience similar life expectancies to highly educated white Americans regardless of their income or educational level and significantly exceed the life expectancy of whites without high degree of educational attainment. (Ibid.)
Given the important role ethnicity and gender play in life expectancy, it may be worthwhile to permit the use of demographic data and actuarial tables when calculating life expectancy. Recognizing that demographic data utilized to calculate life expectancy does not reflect embedded discrimination to the same degree that it does when examining wage data. In seeking to address the concerns of the opposition, the author is proposing to amend the bill to only apply to estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death. A full mock-up of this proposed amended is provided below.
Subtraction by addition? Additional concerns about the in-print version of the bill were raised to the author and this Committee by advocates on behalf of members of several protected classes not included in the bill. They suggest that the bill as currently in print, by only listing race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation, could be inferred to permit the use of actuarial tables to specifically discriminate against unmentioned protected classes.
The author and sponsors offer that such a distinction was never the intent of this measure. This bill is designed to limit the use of demographic data, specifically data that is derived from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey, because the use of this data frequently perpetuates existing wage discrimination on the basis of gender, race, or ethnicity in civil damage awards. Nonetheless, the author and sponsors of this measure concede that the existing language in the bill is more expansive than the current demographic data utilized by most actuarial tables derived from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey. The author concedes that the more expansive language may generate confusion or potentially create a presumption that other protected classes not mentioned are not protected by this bill. Accordingly, in order to bring the bill directly in line with the demographic data utilized by the actuarial tables this bill is designed to target, the author is prudently proposing to amend the bill to only focus on race, gender, ethnicity in order to provide sufficient clarity regarding the bill’s intent. Accordingly, in order to reflect this change, as well as the amendments discussed above, the proposed Section 3361 of the Civil Code is proposed to be amended to read as follows:
Estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity resulting from personal injury or wrongful death damages shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, or gender. religion, or sexual orientation.
Furthermore to ensure that there is no confusion regarding the intent of this bill, the author is proposing that two additional findings be added to the bill. These findings would broadly state that the policy of the State of California is that no protected class should be subject to a reduction in damages based on generic statistical data alone, and that nothing in this bill should be construed as an invitation to discriminate against any protected class not included in this bill. The two additional findings would read as follows:
(h) Any generalized reduction of civil damages, using statistical tables alone, based on a plaintiff’s membership in a protected class, as defined in Section 51 of the Civil Code is counter to the public policy of the State of California
(i) Nothing in this bill shall be construed to explicitly permit the generalized reduction of damages for lost earnings or impaired earnings capacity based on protected classifications not identified in the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey unless otherwise permitted by existing law.
In conjunction with the protections provided in this bill, California’s existing jury instructions should ensure that each plaintiff is treated as an individual when damages are calculated. California’s current jury instructions make significant strides in instructing jurors to treat each plaintiff individually and to exclude any class-based distinctions a jury may inadvertently make. With regards to lost past or future earnings, the jury instructions state that any award should be based on, “on [the plaintiff’s] prospective earnings for the balance of [the plaintiff’s] life expectancy at the time of [the plaintiff’s] injury undiminished by any shortening of that expectancy as a result of the injury.” (Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, No. 3903C, citing, Fein v. Permanente Medical Group (1985) 38 Cal.3d137, 153.) Furthermore, should a plaintiff have a preexisting disability or other condition, California’s jury instructions explicitly direct jurors to disregard the disability’s impact on the nature of the injury, and instead focus on the actual harm caused to the plaintiff by the defendant’s conduct. (Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, No. 3928.)
Despite these instructions, without this bill, the calculation of the impact of an injury on long-term lost earnings still could be based on broad-based demographic data, thereby lessening the individualized treatment of each plaintiff. Coupled with the existing jury instructions, this bill appears to advance the goal of further tailoring damage awards to plaintiff’s individual situations and lessen the risk that entrenched biases unfairly impact damage awards.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by Consumer Attorneys of California, who argue against the unfairness of the existing system for awarding income-related damages in civil cases. In support of the bill they state:
Language in statute must be clear and carefully drafted in order to accomplish the goal of the bill, to prohibit game playing and manipulation of damages based on this racially biased data. The proposed committee amendments strike the correct balance to carefully craft a solution to ensure all injured individuals are entitled to the same potential earnings, without an unfair “discount” to wrongdoers based on the plaintiff’s race, gender, or both
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Civil Justice Association of California wrote in opposition to the in-print version of the bill, specifically, the prohibition on the use of actuarial tables for calculating life expectancy. It is not clear if the proposed amendments will fully eliminate their opposition. In opposition to the in-print measure of the bill the Civil Justice Association of California states:
There are routine and perfectly appropriate circumstances where these prohibited factors may be used in calculating damages. The inability to “reduce” damages based upon gender would appear to preclude any consideration of life expectancy. CJAC supports the accurate calculation of damages in civil litigation, which would be impeded by the provisions of SB 41.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Attorneys of California (sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers
California Low Income Consumers Coalition
Silicon Valley Community Foundation
Opposition
Civil Justice Association of California (in-print version)
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 41 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 41
Amended: 5/2/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Civil actions: damages
DIGEST:
This bill provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future personal injury or wrongful death damages shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the United States Constitution, that no State shall deny any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. (U.S. Const., Amend. XIV, Sec. 1.)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be denied equal protection of the laws. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 7(a).)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be disqualified from entering or pursuing a business, profession, vocation, or employment because of sex, race, creed, color, or national or ethnic origin. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 8.)
- Provides that every person who suffers detriment from the unlawful act or omission of another, may recover from the person in fault a compensation therefor in money, which is called damages. (Civ. Code § 3281.) “Detriment” is defined as loss or harm suffered in person or property. (Civ. Code § 3282.)
- Authorizes damages to be awarded, in a judicial proceeding, for detriment resulting after the commencement thereof, or certain to result in the future. (Civ. Code § 3283.)
- Provides that for the breach of an obligation not arising from contract, the measure of damages, except where otherwise expressly provided, is the amount which will compensate for all the detriment proximately caused thereby, whether it could have been anticipated or not. (Civ. Code § 3333.)
This bill:
- Sets forth a series of findings and declarations.
- Provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future personal injury or wrongful death damages shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
Background
When a person suffers loss or harm as the result of an unlawful act or omission of another, the person is authorized to recover monetary compensation therefor. This compensation is referred to as damages and may be awarded in a judicial proceeding. The damages may include those arising after the unlawful act or omission as well as those damages certain to result in the future.
These latter damages involve a certain amount of prediction and estimation. This bill prohibits reducing those damages based on consideration of certain protected characteristics. In essence, the race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation of a party to a civil action cannot be used to reduce a party’s damages.
Comments
According to the author:
Civil rights laws prohibit discrimination against protected classes in a variety of areas, yet no state or federal law prohibits the use of race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation in the calculation of damages awarded to injured parties. The result has been severe and unaddressed discrimination in court-awarded damages for certain protected classes. This practice deprives some individuals of fair compensation and perpetuates systemic inequality. SB 41 remedies this injustice by prohibiting judges, juries, and expert witnesses from considering a plaintiff’s race, gender, religion or sexual orientation in calculating civil damage awards.
Wage disparities
According to the United States Census Bureau and the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, the nationwide wage gap between men and women has shrunk since the 1960s when the federal Equal Pay Act was enacted. Yet, by 2012, female workers still earned just 78 cents for every dollar paid to a man. Three years later, the gap had only improved by two cents. According to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, unless further action is taken, the gender wage gap will not close entirely until 2059.[1]
As troubling as the gender pay gap is, disparities in earnings based on race and ethnicity are even larger. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2015, while the average white male earned $21 per hour, his Black and Latino counterparts received just $15 and $14, respectively.[2] These differences in pay cannot be fully explained by differences in education levels, either. The Pew Research Center’s data shows that college-educated Black and Latino men receive only about 80 percent of the pay that college-educated white men do.[3]
The intersection of gender, race, and ethnicity produce the greatest inequities of all: Black and Latina women earn 65 and 58 cents, respectively, for every dollar a white male earns.[4] The IWPR research estimates that Black women will not reach parity with white men until 2119; Latinas will reach parity in 2224.[5]
Past discrimination compounded
When a person suffers injury as the result of another, the injured party is entitled to damages. The principle underlying an award of damages is to compensate the injured party for any detriment suffered as a result of the relevant unlawful act or omission of the offending party from the point of injury into the future. In most personal injury and wrongful death cases, determining the proper level of damages will require an estimation of life expectancy and lost earnings.
The issue seeking to be addressed by this bill is that these estimations can be influenced by various considerations, such as race, ethnicity, and gender, to the detriment of the plaintiff. As seen above, research regarding earnings is often broken down by various demographics and characteristics. Given historic discrimination and the attendant pay gaps, damages for certain persons that are injured, especially women of color, are likely to be lower than their white male counterparts based on the data and tables available. In essence, the historic pay discrimination is compounded when used to lower damage awards for certain populations.
A recent study by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights presents the stark situation:
Courts rely on damages calculations by experts who use tables that predict, among other factors, plaintiffs’ lost earnings and wages on the basis of their race/ethnicity and gender. Typically, experts use the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey, which is updated quarterly, to determine projected lost earnings. Loss of earning potential is a significant component of damages and can “make the difference between a modest and sizable award.”
. . . [R]ace/ethnicity- and gender-specific tables preserve systemic and structural inequalities, reinforce current pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and fail to account for possible progress.
In short, they ascribe lower values to the lives of women and people of color. Despite this discriminatory impact, the use of such tables is the industry standard: approximately 44% of economists said they consider race when calculating future earnings income and 92% reported they consider gender. In a survey of 172 members of the National Association of Forensic Economists, when tasked with calculating the loss of a two-year-old African American boy unable to work in the future, 42.4% stated they would only use gender specific data, whereas 44.8% would use both race-specific and gender-specific data.[6]
Others have argued that the use of these tables to the detriment of historically marginalized groups is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution. One federal judge, the Honorable Jack B. Weinstein, has repeatedly rejected the use of these types of statistics for damages calculations, asserting, in part, constitutional grounds: “Equal protection in this context demands that the claimant not be subjected to a disadvantageous life expectancy estimate solely on the basis of a ‘racial’ classification.” (McMillan v. City of New York (E.D.N.Y. 2008) 253 F.R.D. 247, 255.) In addition, Professor Jennifer B. Wriggins of the University of Maine School of Law has called into question the constitutionality of using these types of statistics:
It [] fails to recognize human potential, and it legitimizes inequality to use this evidence in court to measure an injured individual’s damages. . . . [I]t inscribes past inequality—in wages and education—at least some of which derives from past discrimination on the basis of race and/or gender, on individuals and on the future. Admitting race-based tables, and gender-based tables, then, in tort litigation, is an example of treating like cases not alike, and for no compelling reason. It is therefore a violation of equal protection and should stop.[7]
This bill prohibits estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future personal injury or wrongful death damages from being reduced based on race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation. This ensures that historic discrimination is not compounded.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Association of Black Lawyers
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
Consumer Attorneys of California
Hollywood NOW
Riverside Temple Beth El
San Jose/Silicon Valley NAACP
Silicon Valley Community Foundation
W. Haywood Burns Institute
One individual
Civil Justice Association of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Hollywood Chapter of the National Organization for Women (Hollywood NOW) writes in support: “The use of these race- and gender-specific tables to calculate damage awards preserves systemic and structural inequalities, reinforces current pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and fails to account for possible progress. Moreover, it disproportionately impacts communities of color because it incentivizes companies to allocate riskier operations to communities where their exposure to financial liability is lower.
“The use of these discriminatory predictive tools has gone unaddressed by state and federal governments for too long, in large part because they manifest in the testimony of “expert witnesses” who are hired by defendants to justify lower awards for marginalized groups. All California plaintiffs deserve just compensation, regardless of their gender, race, religion or sexual orientation.
“For these reasons, Hollywood NOW supports SB 41.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Civil Justice Association of California writes in opposition: “There are routine and perfectly appropriate circumstances where these prohibited factors may be used in calculating damages. For example, estimating the costs of lifetime care depends on an analysis of life expectancy, which is influenced by gender. Loss of consortium claims also consider life expectancy. The inability to consider life expectancy would tend to adversely affect women, who have longer life expectancies as a class, and benefit men, whose life expectancies are generally shorter.
“CJAC supports the accurate calculation of damages in civil litigation, which would be impeded by the provisions of SB 41.”
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/3/19 13:51:52
**** END ****
The Gender Wage Gap: 2018 Earnings Differences by Race and Ethnicity (March 2019) Institute for Women’s Policy Research, https://iwpr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/C478_Gender-Wage-Gap-in-2018.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Patten, Racial, Gender Wage Gaps Persist in U.S. Despite Some Progress (July 1, 2016) Pew Research Center, http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/07/01/racial-gender-wage-gaps-persist-in-u-s-despite-some-progress/ [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Ibid. ↑
See fn. 1. ↑
Dariely Rodriguez & Hope Kwiatkowski, How Race, Ethnicity, and Gender Impact Your Life’s Worth: Discrimination in Civil Damage Awards (July 2018) Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, https://lawyerscommittee.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/LC_Life27s-Worth_FINAL.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Jennifer B. Wriggins, Constitution Day Lecture: Constitutional Law and Tort Law: Injury, Race, Gender, and Equal Protection (2010) 63 Me. L.Rev. 263, https://digitalcommons.mainelaw.maine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1211&context=mlr [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 41 (Author:Hertzberg)
Version: December 3, 2018
Hearing Date: April 30, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Civil actions: damages
DIGEST
This bill provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of damages shall not be based on, and shall not consider, race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
When a person suffers loss or harm as the result of an unlawful act or omission of another, the person is authorized to recover monetary compensation therefor. This compensation is referred to as damages and may be awarded in a judicial proceeding. The damages may include those arising after the unlawful act or omission as well as those damages certain to result in the future.
These latter damages involve a certain amount of prediction and estimation. This bill eliminates the consideration of certain protected characteristics from the ultimate calculation of damages. In essence, the race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation of a party to a civil action cannot be used to determine their damages.
The bill is author-sponsored. There is no known opposition. The Consumer Attorneys of California support this bill as proposed to be amended in the Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the United States Constitution, that no State shall deny any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. (U.S. Const., Amend. XIV, Sec. 1.)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be denied equal protection of the laws. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 7(a).)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that a person may not be disqualified from entering or pursuing a business, profession, vocation, or employment because of sex, race, creed, color, or national or ethnic origin. (Cal. Const., Art. 1, § 8.)
- Provides that every person who suffers detriment from the unlawful act or omission of another, may recover from the person in fault a compensation therefor in money, which is called damages. (Civ. Code § 3281.) “Detriment” is defined as loss or harm suffered in person or property. (Civ. Code § 3282.)
- Authorizes damages to be awarded, in a judicial proceeding, for detriment resulting after the commencement thereof, or certain to result in the future. (Civ. Code § 3283.)
- Provides that for the breach of an obligation not arising from contract, the measure of damages, except where otherwise expressly provided, is the amount which will compensate for all the detriment proximately caused thereby, whether it could have been anticipated or not. (Civ. Code § 3333.)
This bill:
- Sets forth a series of findings and declarations.
- Provides that estimations, measures, or calculations of damages shall not be based on, and shall not consider, race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.
COMMENTS
- Stated intent of the bill
According to the author:
Civil rights laws prohibit discrimination against protected classes in a variety of areas, yet no state or federal law prohibits the use of race, gender, religion, or sexual orientation in the calculation of damages awarded to injured parties. The result has been severe and unaddressed discrimination in court-awarded damages for certain protected classes. This practice deprives some individuals of fair compensation and perpetuates systemic inequality. SB 41 remedies this injustice by prohibiting judges, juries, and expert witnesses from considering a plaintiff’s race, gender, religion or sexual orientation in calculating civil damage awards.
- Wage disparities
According to the United States Census Bureau and the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, the nationwide wage gap between men and women has shrunk since the 1960s when the federal Equal Pay Act was enacted. Yet, by 2012, female workers still earned just 78 cents for every dollar paid to a man. Three years later, the gap had only improved by two cents. According to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, unless further action is taken, the gender wage gap will not close entirely until 2059.[1]
As troubling as the gender pay gap is, disparities in earnings based on race and ethnicity are even larger. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2015, while the average white male earned $21 per hour, his Black and Latino counterparts received just $15 and $14, respectively.[2] These differences in pay cannot be fully explained by differences in education levels, either. The Pew Research Center’s data shows that college-educated Black and Latino men receive only about 80 percent of the pay that college-educated white men do.[3]
The intersection of gender, race, and ethnicity produce the greatest inequities of all: Black and Latina women earn 65 and 58 cents, respectively, for every dollar a white male earns.[4] The IWPR research estimates that Black women will not reach parity with white men until 2119; Latinas will reach parity in 2224.[5]
- Past discrimination compounded
When a person suffers injury as the result of another, the injured party is entitled to damages. The principle underlying an award of damages is to compensate the injured party for any detriment suffered as a result of the relevant unlawful act or omission of the offending party from the point of injury into the future. In most personal injury and wrongful death cases, determining the proper level of damages will require an estimation of life expectancy and lost earnings.
The issue seeking to be addressed by this bill is that these estimations can be influenced by various considerations, such as race, ethnicity, and gender, to the detriment of the plaintiff. As seen above, research regarding earnings is often broken down by various demographics and characteristics. Given historic discrimination and the attendant pay gaps, damages for certain persons that are injured, especially women of color, are likely to be lower than their white male counterparts based on the data and tables available. In essence, the historic pay discrimination is compounded when used to lower damage awards for certain populations.
A recent study by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights presents the stark situation:
Courts rely on damages calculations by experts who use tables that predict, among other factors, plaintiffs’ lost earnings and wages on the basis of their race/ethnicity and gender. Typically, experts use the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey, which is updated quarterly, to determine projected lost earnings. Loss of earning potential is a significant component of damages and can “make the difference between a modest and sizable award.”
. . . [R]ace/ethnicity- and gender-specific tables preserve systemic and structural inequalities, reinforce current pay gaps and workforce discrimination, and fail to account for possible progress.
In short, they ascribe lower values to the lives of women and people of color. Despite this discriminatory impact, the use of such tables is the industry standard: approximately 44% of economists said they consider race when calculating future earnings income and 92% reported they consider gender. In a survey of 172 members of the National Association of Forensic Economists, when tasked with calculating the loss of a two-year-old African American boy unable to work in the future, 42.4% stated they would only use gender specific data, whereas 44.8% would use both race-specific and gender-specific data.[6]
Others have argued that the use of these tables to the detriment of historically marginalized groups is a violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution. One federal judge, the Honorable Jack B. Weinstein, has repeatedly rejected the use of these types of statistics for damages calculations, asserting, in part, constitutional grounds: “Equal protection in this context demands that the claimant not be subjected to a disadvantageous life expectancy estimate solely on the basis of a ‘racial’ classification.” (McMillan v. City of New York (E.D.N.Y. 2008) 253 F.R.D. 247, 255.) In addition, Professor Jennifer B. Wriggins of the University of Maine School of Law has called into question the constitutionality of using these types of statistics:
It [] fails to recognize human potential, and it legitimizes inequality to use this evidence in court to measure an injured individual’s damages. . . . [I]t inscribes past inequality—in wages and education—at least some of which derives from past discrimination on the basis of race and/or gender, on individuals and on the future. Admitting race-based tables, and gender-based tables, then, in tort litigation, is an example of treating like cases not alike, and for no compelling reason. It is therefore a violation of equal protection and should stop.[7]
This bill prohibits the consideration of race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation when making estimations, measurements, or calculations of damages. This ensures that historic discrimination is not compounded.
However, there are concerns that completely prohibiting the consideration of these categories may actually work to the detriment of these groups. There may be situations where considerations of one’s race or gender, for instance, is probative of the extent to which they were damaged by an unlawful act. In order to ensure there are no unintended consequences in this regard, the author has agreed to accept the following amendment in Committee to ensure that considerations of these categories cannot work to the detriment of the injured party and that this only applies to the relevant types of cases, namely personal injury and wrongful death:
Amendment
Replace Section 3361 with the following: “Estimations, measures, or calculations of past, present, or future personal injury or wrongful death damages shall not be reduced based on race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation.”
As so amended, the Consumer Attorneys of California support this bill:
Language in statute must be clear and carefully drafted in order to accomplish the goal of the bill, to prohibit game playing and manipulation of damages based on this racially biased data. The proposed committee amendments strike the correct balance to carefully craft a solution to ensure all injured individuals are entitled to the same potential earnings, without an unfair “discount” to wrongdoers based on the plaintiff’s race, gender, or both.
SUPPORT
California Association of Black Lawyers
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
Consumer Attorneys of California
Silicon Valley Community Foundation
One individual
OPPOSITION
Civil Justice Association of California
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending: None known
Prior: AB 2282 (Eggman, Ch. 127, Stats. 2018) made clarifying changes to the existing provisions regarding the use of a job applicant’s prior salary to prohibit use of prior salary to justify any disparity in compensation. It also clarified that an employer may make a compensation decision based on a current employee’s existing salary, so long as the wage differential resulting from that compensation decision is justified by other specified factors in current law.
AB 1676 (Campos, Ch. 856, Stats. 2016) required that prior salary shall not, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation.
SB 358 (Jackson, Ch. 546, Stats. 2015) addressed significant loopholes in the Equal Pay Act that had prevented meaningful enforcement by, among other things, requiring employers to justify any gender pay differential with a legitimate non-sex-based factor and prohibiting retaliation against employees for disclosing or discussing their wages with co-workers.
**************
The Gender Wage Gap: 2018 Earnings Differences by Race and Ethnicity (March 2019) Institute for Women’s Policy Research, https://iwpr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/C478_Gender-Wage-Gap-in-2018.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Patten, Racial, Gender Wage Gaps Persist in U.S. Despite Some Progress (July 1, 2016) Pew Research Center, http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/07/01/racial-gender-wage-gaps-persist-in-u-s-despite-some-progress/ [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Ibid. ↑
See fn. 1. ↑
Dariely Rodriguez & Hope Kwiatkowski, How Race, Ethnicity, and Gender Impact
Your Life’s Worth: Discrimination in Civil Damage Awards (July 2018) Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, https://lawyerscommittee.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/LC_Life27s-Worth_FINAL.pdf [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Jennifer B. Wriggins, Constitution Day Lecture: Constitutional Law and Tort Law: Injury, Race, Gender, and Equal Protection (2010) 63 Me. L.Rev. 263, https://digitalcommons.mainelaw.maine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1211&context=mlr [as of Apr. 28, 2019]. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):