SB 417: California Victim Compensation Board: claim.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-07-10
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 28, Statutes of 2020. |
| Jul 10, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 8, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 2. Page 3896.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Jun 16, 2020 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Jun 15, 2020 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 4889.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 3, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (June 2). |
| May 26, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 26, 2020 | Referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 29. Noes 5. Page 3151.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 22, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 21, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 3120.) (January 21). |
| Jan 14, 2020 | Set for hearing January 21. |
| Jan 13, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 29, 2020 | Unfinished Business SB417 Portantino Urgency Clause Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 15, 2020 | SB 417 Portantino Third Reading Urgency By Gonzalez | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 27, 2020 | Senate 3rd Reading SB417 Portantino Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 417 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 417
Author: Portantino (D)
Amended: 5/26/20
Vote: 27 - Urgency
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 1/21/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 29-5, 1/27/20
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Dahle, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas, Chang, Glazer, Grove, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 6/15/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Victim Compensation Board: claim
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill appropriates $5,087,040 to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board (Board) for the payment of specified erroneous conviction claims.
Assembly Amendments
increase the appropriation amount to $5,087,040 for the payment of six additional erroneous conviction claims approved by the Board.
ANALYSIS: Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
This bill appropriates General Fund revenues to the Board for the payment of the following erroneous conviction claims:
- Moonshadow Naomi Taggart, $136,780. On April 11, 2014, the Kern County District Attorney (DA) charged Moonshadow Naomi Taggart with two counts related to the possession of methamphetamine, and alleged that she had served prior prison terms for possession of a controlled substance, for car theft, and for possession of a controlled substance for sale. Following her guilty plea, the trial court sentenced her to a four-year split sentence, with one year to be served in the Kern County Jail, and the remainder on mandatory supervision, but she was released from jail shortly after sentencing.
On September 10, 2014, Taggart was arrested and charged with possession of a stolen vehicle. After entering a guilty plea to buying and receiving a stolen vehicle, and admitting to two prison priors, she was sentenced to two years in prison. On March 31, 2015, Taggart was granted early release, conditioned upon her promise not to leave Kern County without permission from the Kern County Board of Parole. A parole officer made two attempts to contact Taggart at her residence of record without success, and on June 26, 2015, a warrant was issued for her arrest.
On August 17, 2015, Taggart was arrested out-of-state and transported to California, and the Kern County DA charged her with escape from the Kern County Sheriff’s Parole Program while also alleging the initial prison priors. A jury convicted Taggart of escape and the trial court imposed an aggregate term of five years (three years for escape, plus two years for the two prison priors). The court also imposed a consecutive term of two years and eight months related to the previous case of possession of a stolen vehicle, as well as a concurrent term of four years for the previous case of drug possession. Taggart’s total sentence was seven years and eight months.
Taggart appealed the escape conviction, claiming insufficient evidence, and she was discharged to post-release community supervision during the pendency of the appeal. She had been continuously confined for 977 days since the escape arrest. On January 23, 2019, the appellate court reversed Taggart’s escape conviction, finding that sheriff’s parole did not constitute “lawful custody” because she was only minimally constrained and not deprived of physical freedom as she was not confined to a residence or specific facility. Accordingly, there was no custody from which she could escape. The appellate court did, however, find that Taggart’s departure from Kern County constituted a parole violation for the other two cases, for which she may be returned to custody to serve the reminder of those sentences. At the resentencing, the trial court imposed a four-year sentence for possessing a stolen vehicle and a concurrent four year sentence for drug possession, but deemed both sentences were already served in full as Taggart had accrued a total of 2,367 days credit, and terminated her post-release community supervision.
On June 28, 2019, Taggart applied to the Board seeking compensation for erroneous conviction related to the escape charge. The Attorney General (AG) responded and agreed that she was actually innocent of the escape conviction and entitled to $136,780 for 977 days of imprisonment. The Board’s Hearing Officer agreed that Taggart was actually innocent of escape, but recommended compensation for 449 days of incarceration because she had served 528 days for her valid convictions of drug possession and possession of a stolen vehicle. At the Board’s meeting to consider the proposed decision, the AG opposed the reduction in compensation because the trial court would not have resentenced her to prison for the two valid convictions if she had not been erroneously convicted of escape. The Board ultimately agreed with the AG and determined, based on a preponderance of evidence, that Taggart’s erroneous incarceration included the concurrent period she served for the valid convictions, and recommended compensation in the amount of $136,780 for all 977 days of her incarceration.
- Lionel Omar Rubalcava, finding of factual innocence, $874,440. Lionel Omar Rubalcava was convicted for attempted murder and spent over 17 years in prison. On November 18, 2019, Rubalcava was declared factually innocent.
On April 2, 2002, Raymond Rodriguez was shot in a drive-by shooting in the city of San Jose. Rodriguez’s brother was with him at the time of the shooting. Both Rodriguez, who survived the shooting, and his brother claim to have seen, at the time of the shooting, a small portion of the shooter’s face through an open portion of a tinted window, though neither said they recognized the shooter. Soon after the shooting, police located the burned out remains of the shooter’s vehicle. Two days after the shooting, an incident occurred in which Rubalcava appeared in his car in front of Rodriguez’s house. Subsequently, police showed Rodriguez, who was recovering in hospital, a picture of Rubalcava, whom Rodriguez identified as the shooter, as did his brother.
Rubalcava was soon thereafter arrested for attempted murder and tried for the crime in the Santa Clara County Superior Court. There was no physical evidence linking Rubalcava to the crime, and Rubalcava presented compelling evidence of an alibi at the time of the shooting. Nonetheless, after a short trial, the jury convicted Rubalcava of attempted murder. On January 23, 2006, the Court of Appeal confirmed Rubalcava’s conviction.
On October 15, 2018, with the assistance of the Northern California Innocence Project (Innocence Project), Rubalcava filed a petition with the Santa Clara County Superior Court to have his conviction vacated. The petition included a statement from Rodriguez indicating he was uncertain about his identification of Rubalcava as the person who shot him. As a consequence, the Santa Clara County District Attorney conducted an investigation with the Innocence Project. The investigation revealed that, since being shot, Rodriguez had made considerable changes to his life. He was no longer addicted to drugs and he was no longer affiliated with a street gang. Rodriguez also admitted to investigators he was never entirely sure of his identification of Rubalcava as the person who shot him. Though Rodriguez’s brother continued to identify Rubalcava as the person who shot his brother, the district attorney lost confidence in Rubalcava’s conviction. On March 18, the district attorney joined Rubalcava’s petition of the court to vacate his conviction.
On April 24, 2019, the Santa Clara Superior Court granted Rubalcava’s petition and vacated the entire judgement against him. Rubalcava was released from prison on May 15, 2019, after serving 6,246 days imprisoned for a crime he did not commit. Rubalcava’s entire term of imprisonment was solely attributable to the wrongful conviction.
On January 2, 2020, the Board granted Rubalcava’s application for compensation for wrongful conviction and found that he is factually innocent. The Board concluded Rubalcava is entitled to $874,440, or $140 for each day of erroneous incarceration.
- Ruben Martinez, finding of factual innocence, $635,600. Starting in 2005 through 2007, an auto body shop in Los Angeles was robbed on five separate occasions, at gunpoint, purportedly by the same male perpetrator. The robber forcibly took money from the business safe and from customers and employees. The only physical evidence of the robberies was a palm print left during the first robbery, which occurred on December 25, 2005.
On June 1, 2007, Martinez was charged in Los Angeles County Superior Court with nine counts of second-degree robbery while armed with a firearm, each count associated with the five robberies of the auto body shop. Martinez’s palm print did not match the palm print left at the scene of the first robbery. In addition, Martinez insisted upon his innocence of all of the robberies and presented alibi evidence from his wife, brother-in-law and two work supervisors contending Martinez had been at work on the occasion of two of the robberies. The only evidence presented against Martinez was eyewitness identification of Martinez as the robber by five employees and customers of the body shop. A jury in Martinez’s first trial did not reach a verdict; however, a second jury convicted him to a sentence of 47 years and 8 months.
Martinez requested the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office (LA DA) consider his case for factual evidence. The subsequent LA DA investigation uncovered additional alibi evidence that “unmistakably” demonstrated Martinez was working at a site remote from the body shop at the time of two of the robberies. Because the LA DA believed the same perpetrator “clearly” committed all five of the robberies, the LA DA lost confidence in all of Martinez’s robbery convictions. On November 5, 2019, the LA DA motioned in Los Angeles Superior Court for the overturn of Martinez’s conviction, at which point Martinez was released from prison on his own recognizance. Two days later, the LA DA moved to vacate Martinez’s robbery convictions, dismiss with prejudice the underlying case and issue a factual finding of innocence. On November 12, 2019, the court ordered vacated all nine convictions, dismissed the entire case with prejudice in the interest of justice and expressly found “the defendant to be factually innocent” in each of all nine charges.
On January 15, 2020, Martinez submitted an application with the Board for compensation as an erroneously convicted person. On January 24, 2020, the Board granted Martinez’s application for compensation, in amount of $635,600, for his 4,540 days of erroneous incarceration.
- Michelle Marie Poulos, finding of factual innocence, $60,340. On June 28, 2001, Poulos pleaded guilty to a single count of criminal threats against June Patti, who was Poulos’ former romantic partner. Patti was the only witness to the threats Poulos was to have made against her. In exchange for her plea, Poulos received a suspended two-year prison sentence and was placed on three-year probation.
A year later, Poulos admitted violating the terms of her probation for felony possession of methamphetamine in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. On September 19, 2002, the trial imposed the previously suspended two-year prison sentence for criminal threats against Patti and a concurrent term of two years for methamphetamine possession.
Poulos was released from prison on September 25, 2003 after having served 431 days, consisting of 59 days pre-sentencing and 372 days post-sentencing, as well as 372 concurrent days for methamphetamine possession.
Thirteen years later, on January 23, 2017, the Los Angeles Superior Court granted Poulos’ motion to vacate and dismiss her criminal threat conviction, for which prosecution had “lost trust in the witness Patti.” The court found Patti had “lied and fabricated information,” which resulted in harm to Poulos. Prior to the motion to vacate Poulos’ conviction, in 2014, the court found another individual, Susan Mellen, had been erroneously convicted for murder based on Patti’s false testimony.
Poulos then challenged her conviction for methamphetamine possession, reasoning that she would have been ordered to participate in a drug rehabilitation program, not prison, were it not for her erroneous criminal threat conviction. Poulos noted she completed a drug treatment program while in prison. While the Los Angeles County Superior Court initially denied Poulos’ motion, upon remand, the court, on May 24, 2019, granted the motion to vacate the conviction for methamphetamine possession in the interest of justice. The court chose not to find Poulos’ factually innocent of methamphetamine possession.
As the court weighed her motion for relief from the methamphetamine conviction, Poulos submitted an application to the Board on January 17, 2019, for compensation for erroneous incarceration. At that time, the law required an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration be submitted within two years of acquittal, pardon or release from custody. However, legislation took effect on January 2, 2020, while Poulos’ case was stayed, that expanded the deadline for submitting application to 10 years following dismissal of charges. (See SB 269 (Bradford), Chapter 473, Statutes of 2019.) In light of this change in the law, the Board deemed her application timely and requested a response letter from the Attorney General. On February 28, 2020, the Attorney General concluded Poulos was entitled to a recommendation for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On March 23, 2020, the Board granted Poulos’s application for compensation, in the amount of $60,340, for 431 days of erroneous incarceration.
- Lawrence M. Martin, finding of factual innocence, $1,015,980. On September 18, 1997, Martin was arrested by San Jose State University Police Officer Stoker for possession of a knife and a usable amount of marijuana. Martin was released from custody prior to November 4, 1997, awaiting trial. On May 11, 1998, a jury in Santa Clara County convicted Martin of possession of a concealed “dirk or dagger” and of less than 28.5 grams of marijuana. On May 12, 1998, the court found that a) Martin had four prior serious and violent felony convictions within the meaning of California’s “Three Strikes Law” and b) Martin had served three prior prison terms. On August 11, 1998, the court sentenced Martin to 25 years to life for possession of a concealed dirk or dagger with serious or violent felonies within the meaning of the Three Strikes Law and a consecutive term of three years for the prior prison terms.
Between his arrest and conviction, Martin was arrested on November 4, 1997, for tampering with a vehicle and again, on January 16, 1998. He was charged and convicted of a misdemeanor on May 12, 1998 and sentenced to 90 days concurrent with his sentence described above. On January 16, 1998, Martin was convicted of misdemeanor possession of controlled paraphernalia, for which he was sentenced to one day in county jail.
On December 15, 2017, The Santa Clara County Superior Court vacated Martin’s conviction for possession of a dirk or dagger because, in fact, Martin was in possession of a common pocket knife. On December 18, Martin submitted a claim with the Board requesting compensation for erroneous conviction. The Attorney General, on February 14, 2020, declared Martin to be factually innocent and conceded Martin is entitled to compensation for wrongful conviction for the crime of possessing a dirk or dagger. On March 18, 2020, VCB granted Martin’s claim for compensation, awarding him $1,015,980 for 7,257 days of wrongful incarceration. The compensation does not include time Martin served for the crimes of tampering with a vehicle and possession of a controlled substance.
- Ricky Leo Davis, finding of factual innocence, $490,280. In 1985, Ricky Leo Davis was convicted and sentenced for the brutal murder of Jane Hylton in 1985. Hylton, along with her 13-year-old daughter, Angela, had moved back into Hylton’s mother’s house, following Hylton’s separation from her husband. Also living in the house were Davis, at the time 20 years old, and his girlfriend, Constance Dahl.
Late on the night of July 6, Davis, Dahl, and Hylton’s daughter Angela entered Hylton’s mother’s home together. Davis and Dahl reported they had returned from a party, while Angela maintained she had been out with three teenaged boys. Davis, Dahl and Angela entered the home and, together, found Hylton’s body. Hylton had been stabbed to death, and also had a bite mark on her left shoulder.
Police investigated Hylton’s murder. Davis insisted he and Dahl were at the party until 3:00 a.m. Since the police were unable to identify the teens whom Angela said she had been with, and DNA testing technology was not yet available, the case went cold.
Seventeen years later, in 2002, police subjected Dahl to repeated interrogation, and he eventually confessed she bit Hylton while Hylton and Davis fought. Davis was charged with Hylton’s murder in El Dorado County Superior Court. On August 17, 2005, a jury found Davis guilty of murder. He was sentenced to 16 years to life in prison. Because he was at that time serving a federal sentence for a bank robbery, Davis began his sentence for Hylton’s murder on July 14, 2008. While in prison, Davis was convicted for assault of another inmate and sentenced to a two-year term to run consecutive with his sentence for murder.
In 2012, El Dorado County Superior Court appointed the Northern California Innocence Project to investigate Davis’ conviction and to file a motion for post-conviction DNA testing. The El Dorado District Attorney’s Office agreed to testing. The DNA test revealed the presence of the same DNA in the bite mark on Hylton’s shoulder and the DNA under her fingernails. Crucially, that DNA did not match Davis’ DNA. Subsequently, investigators matched the DNA from Hylton’s body with one of three formerly teenage boys who had been with Angela the night of the murder. One of those individuals, now a man in his fifties, became a suspect in the murder case.
On February 13, 2020, the El Dorado County District Attorney moved to dismiss the murder charge against Davis, reporting Dahl’s confession was not trustworthy, since unequivocal DNA evidence demonstrated Davis innocence. Davis was immediately released from custody.
On March 30, 2020, Davis submitted an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On April 27, 2020, the Board granted Davis $490,280 for 3,502, the number of days he spent incarcerated erroneously.
- Samuel Bonner, finding of factual innocence, $1,873,620. Samuel Bonner was incarcerated for over 36 years for a conviction of first-degree murder and robbery. On February 10, 2020, he was declared factually innocent of both charges.
On November 11, 1982, Bonner drove Watson Allison to Leonard Polk’s residence, at 850 Orizaba Avenue. Polk was observed by witnesses, including a Long Beach Police Officer, speaking with Allison alongside Bonner’s car. Bonner was never seen exiting in the vehicle. Witnesses saw Bonner’s vehicle drive away, but shortly thereafter, neighbors and the police officers saw Allison make several trips from Polk’s apartment, carrying Polk’s television, stereo speakers and a large duffel bag, and placing the items in Polk’s vehicle. The police officer saw Allison enter Polk’s vehicle alone, and drive off in it.
Soon after, Polk’s neighbors entered Polk’s apartment and found him dead from a gunshot wound. Officers issued a search for Bonner’s vehicle and found it that evening parked near Allison’s home. On November 12, 1982, police arrested Bonner and searched his person, his vehicle and his home, but found none of Polk’s property. During questioning, Bonner was not forthright with Allison’s name and whereabouts, or his own whereabouts on the night of Polk’s murder, and he was subsequently released.
On November 22, 1983, officers found Polk’s property in Allison’s garage. Officers found a partial palm print on a piece of Polk’s stereo equipment, and located an automobile fuse on Bonner’s person similar to one found in the street in front of Polk’s residence. The fuse was next to a footprint and a cloth speaker cover from one Polk’s stolen speakers. Officers arrested Bonner on November 22, 1982. He and Allison were each charged with two counts: one count of first-degree murder with a special circumstance, robbery, and the special allegation of personal use of a handgun in commission of the murder, and count two, robbery.
Bonner and Allison were tried separately. Evidence presented against Bonner included testimony of a “jailhouse informant” who stated that Bonner confessed to shooting Polk, and the partial palm print and automobile fuse indicating that Bonner was at the scene of the crime.
The jury found Bonner guilty of murder in the first degree with the special circumstance of robbery, and of robbery, but not of the special allegation, personal use of a handgun in the commission of a murder. On December 5, 1983, the court sentenced Bonner to 25 years to life without the possibility of parole.
Years later, Bonner filed a petition to vacate his murder conviction and to consider charging him with new counts based on a change in the felony murder law. The court vacated Bonner’s convictions and chose not to resentence him, because: (1) the jury found Bonner was not the killer; (2) Bonner’s conviction was based upon the theory of felony murder, and statute regarding felony murder had changed since Bonner’s conviction; and (3) the prosecution did not turn over exculpatory evidence to Bonner, including the informant’s full criminal record and evidence that the informant committed perjury.
Bonner was released on July 11, 2019. On April 24, 2020, the Board granted Bonner’s application for compensation for erroneous incarceration and awarded him $1,873,620 as compensation for his 13,383 days incarcerated.
Background
The State Board of Control was established in 1945. It was revised and renamed the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by AB 2491 (Jackson, Chapter 1016, Statutes of 2000), and subsequently renamed the California Victim Compensation Board by SB 836 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, Chapter 31, Statutes of 2016). SB 836 transferred the authority to approve general government claims for which no legal available appropriation exists to the Department of General Services, and the Board currently administers the Victim Compensation Program, the Revenue Recovery Program, Claims of Erroneously Convicted Felons, the Good Samaritan Act, and the Missing Children Reward Program.
Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno, Chapter 800, Statutes of 2013), a person who has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside is eligible for payment in a claim against the state. Upon application by the petitioner, the Board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the Board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner’s claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the Board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; and (b) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the Board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served, including any time spent in custody that is considered part of the term of incarceration, such as time served in a county jail.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time General Fund appropriation to the Board in the amount of $5,087,040 in 2020-21 for the payment of seven specified erroneous conviction claims.
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/17/20)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 6/15/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O’Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Diep, Gray, Mathis
Prepared by: Mark McKenzie / APPR. / (916) 651-4101
6/17/20 16:55:02
**** END ****
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 417
Author:(Portantino)
As Amended Ver:May 26, 2020
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
This bill, an urgency measure, is one of two annual state claims bills introduced pursuant to California Victim Compensation Board (Board) determinations and required to be authored by one of the chairs of the appropriations committee of either house. This bill appropriates approximately $5.1 million from the General Fund to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board to pay the claims of the seven individuals, who were erroneously convicted of a crime.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Current law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno), Chapter 800, Statutes of 2013, if a person has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside, the finding is grounds for payment of a claim against the state and upon application by the petitioner, the board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence: a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; b) the claimant did not contribute to the arrest or conviction for the crime; and c) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served in a state prison subsequent to the claimant's conviction.
- Purpose. This bill appropriates approximately $5.1 million from the General Fund to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board to pay the claims of the following individuals, who were erroneously convicted of a crime.
Moonshadow Naomi Taggart. On April 11, 2014, the Kern County District Attorney (DA) charged Moonshadow Naomi Taggart with two counts related to the possession of methamphetamine, and alleged that she had served prior prison terms for possession of a controlled substance, for car theft, and for possession of a controlled substance for sale.
Following her guilty plea, the trial court sentenced her to a four-year split sentence, with one year to be served in the Kern County Jail, and the remainder on mandatory supervision, but she was released from jail shortly after sentencing. On September 10, 2014, Taggart was arrested and charged with possession of a stolen vehicle. After entering a guilty plea to buying and receiving a stolen vehicle, and admitting to two prison priors, she was sentenced to two years in prison. On March 31, 2015, Taggart was granted early release, conditioned upon her promise not to leave Kern County without permission from the Kern County Board of Parole.
A parole officer made two attempts to contact Taggart at her residence of record without success, and on June 26, 2015, a warrant was issued for her arrest. On August 17, 2015, Taggart was arrested out-of-state and transported to California, and the Kern County DA charged her with escape from the Kern County Sheriff's Parole Program while also alleging the initial prison priors. A jury convicted Taggart of escape and the trial court imposed an aggregate term of five years (three years for escape, plus two years for the two prison priors). The court also imposed a consecutive term of two years and eight months related to the previous case of possession of a stolen vehicle, as well as a concurrent term of four years for the previous case of drug possession. Taggart's total sentence was seven years and eight months.
Taggart appealed the escape conviction, claiming insufficient evidence, and she was discharged to post-release community supervision during the pendency of the appeal. She had been continuously confined for 977 days since the escape arrest. On January 23, 2019, the appellate court reversed Taggart's escape conviction, finding that sheriff's parole did not constitute "lawful custody" because she was only minimally constrained and not deprived of physical freedom as she was not confined to a residence or specific facility. Accordingly, there was no custody from which she could escape. The appellate court did, however, find that Taggart's departure from Kern County constituted a parole violation for the other two cases, for which she may be returned to custody to serve the reminder of those sentences.
At the resentencing, the trial court imposed a four-year sentence for possessing a stolen vehicle and a concurrent four-year sentence for drug possession, but deemed both sentences were already served in full as Taggart had accrued a total of 2,367 days credit, and terminated her post-release community supervision.
On June 28, 2019, Taggart applied to the Victim Compensation Board seeking compensation for erroneous conviction related to the escape charge. The Attorney General (AG) responded and agreed that she was actually innocent of the escape conviction and entitled to $136,780 for 977 days of imprisonment. The Board's Hearing Officer agreed that Taggart was actually innocent of escape, but recommended compensation for 449 days of incarceration because she had served 528 days for her valid convictions of drug possession and possession of a stolen vehicle. At the Board's meeting to consider the proposed decision, the AG opposed the reduction in compensation because the trial court would not have resentenced her to prison for the two valid convictions if she had not been erroneously convicted of escape. The Board ultimately agreed with the AG and determined, based on a preponderance of evidence, that Taggart's erroneous incarceration included the concurrent period she served for the valid convictions, and recommended compensation in the amount of $136,780 for all 977 days of her incarceration.
Lionel Omar Rubalcava. Lionel Omar Rubalcava was convicted for attempted murder and spent over 17 years in prison. On November 18, 2019, Rubalcava was declared factually innocent.
On April 2, 2002, Raymond Rodriguez was shot in a drive-by shooting in the city of San Jose. Rodriguez's brother was with him at the time of the shooting. Both Rodriguez, who survived the shooting, and his brother claim to have seen, at the time of the shooting, a small portion of the shooter's face through an open portion of a tinted window, though neither said they recognized the shooter. Soon after the shooting, police located the burned out remains of the shooter's vehicle.
Two days after the shooting, an incident occurred in which Rubalcava appeared in his car in front of Rodriguez's house. Subsequently, police showed Rodriguez, who was recovering in hospital, a picture of Rubalcava, whom Rodriguez identified as the shooter, as did his brother.
Rubalcava was soon thereafter arrested for attempted murder and tried for the crime in the Santa Clara County Superior Court. There was no physical evidence linking Rubalcava to the crime, and Rubalcava presented compelling evidence of an alibi at the time of the shooting. Nonetheless, after a short trial, the jury convicted Rubalcava of attempted murder.
On January 23, 2006, the Court of Appeal confirmed Rubalcava's conviction.
On October 15, 2018, with the assistance of the Northern California Innocence Project (Innocence Project), Rubalcava filed a petition with the Santa Clara County Superior Court to have his conviction vacated. The petition included a statement from Rodriguez indicating he was uncertain about his identification of Rubalcava as the person who shot him.
As a consequence, the Santa Clara County District Attorney conducted an investigation with the Innocence Project. The investigation revealed that, since being shot, Rodriguez had made considerable changes to his life. He was no longer addicted to drugs and he was no longer affiliated with a street gang. Rodriguez also admitted to investigators he was never entirely sure of his identification of Rubalcava as the person who shot him. Though Rodriguez's brother continued to identify Rubalcava as the person who shot his brother, the district attorney lost confidence in Rubalcava's conviction. On March 18, the district attorney joined Rubalcava's petition of the court to vacate his conviction.
On April 24, 2019, the Santa Clara Superior Court granted Rubalcava's petition and vacated the entire judgement against him. Rubalcava was released from prison on May 15, 2019, after serving 6,246 days imprisoned for a crime he did not commit. Rubalcava's entire term of imprisonment was solely attributable to the wrongful conviction.
On January 2, 2020, the Victim Compensation Board (VCB) granted Rubalcava's application for compensation for wrongful conviction and found that he is factually innocent. The VCB concluded Rubalcava is entitled to $874,440, or $140 for each day of erroneous incarceration.
Ruben Martinez. Starting in 2005 through 2007, an auto body shop in Los Angeles was robbed on five separate occasions, at gunpoint, purportedly by the same male perpetrator. The robber forcibly took money from the business safe and from customers and employees. The only physical evidence of the robberies was a palm print left during the first robbery, which occurred on December 25, 2005.
On June 1, 2007, Martinez was charged in Los Angeles County Superior Court with nine counts of second-degree robbery while armed with a firearm, each count associated with the five robberies of the auto body shop. Martinez's palm print did not match the palm print left at the scene of the first robbery. In addition, Martinez insisted upon his innocence of all of the robberies and presented alibi evidence from his wife, brother-in-law and two work supervisors contending Martinez had been at work on the occasion of two of the robberies. The only evidence presented against Martinez was eyewitness identification of Martinez as the robber by five employees and customers of the body shop. A jury in Martinez's first trial did not reach a verdict; however, a second jury convicted him to a sentence of 47 years and 8 months.
Martinez requested the Los Angeles District Attorney's Office (LA DA) consider his case for factual evidence. The subsequent LA DA investigation uncovered additional alibi evidence that "unmistakably" demonstrated Martinez was working at a site remote from the body shop at the time of two of the robberies. Because the LA DA believed the same perpetrator "clearly" committed all five of the robberies, the LA DA lost confidence in all of Martinez's robbery convictions. On November 5, 2019, the LA DA motioned in Los Angeles Superior Court for the overturn of Martinez's conviction, at which point Martinez was released from prison on his own recognizance. Two days later, the LA DA moved to vacate Martinez's robbery convictions, dismiss with prejudice the underlying case and issue a factual finding of innocence. On November 12, 2019, the court ordered vacated all nine convictions, dismissed the entire case with prejudice in the interest of justice and expressly found "the defendant to be factually innocent" in each of all nine charges.
On January 15, 2020, Martinez submitted an application with the VCB for compensation as an erroneously convicted person. On January 24, 2020, the VCB granted Martinez's application for compensation, in amount of $635,600, for his 4,540 days of erroneous incarceration.
Michelle Marie Poulos. On June 28, 2001, Poulos pleaded guilty to a single count of criminal threats against June Patti, who was Poulos' former romantic partner. Patti was the only witness to the threats Poulos was to have made against her. In exchange for her plea, Poulos received a suspended two-year prison sentence and was placed on three-year probation.
A year later, Poulos admitted violating the terms of her probation for felony possession of methamphetamine in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. On September 19, 2002, the trial imposed the previously suspended two-year prison sentence for criminal threats against Patti and a concurrent term of two years for methamphetamine possession.
Poulos was released from prison on September 25, 2003 after having served 431 days, consisting of 59 days pre-sentencing and 372 days post-sentencing, as well as 372 concurrent days for methamphetamine possession.
Thirteen years later, on January 23, 2017, the Los Angeles Superior Court granted Poulos' motion to vacate and dismiss her criminal threat conviction, for which prosecution had "lost trust in the witness Patti." The court found Patti had "lied and fabricated information," which resulted in harm to Poulos. (Prior to the motion to vacate Poulos' conviction, in 2014, the court found another individual, Susan Mellen, had been erroneously convicted for murder based on Patti's false testimony.)
Poulos then challenged her conviction for methamphetamine possession, reasoning that she would have been ordered to participate in a drug rehabilitation program, not prison, were it not for her erroneous criminal threat conviction. Poulos noted she completed a drug treatment program while in prison.
While the Los Angeles County Superior Court initially denied Poulos' motion, upon remand, the court, on May 24, 2019, granted the motion to vacate the conviction for methamphetamine possession in the interest of justice. The court chose not to find Poulos' factually innocent of methamphetamine possession.
As the court weighed her motion for relief from the methamphetamine conviction, Poulos submitted an application to VCB on January 17, 2019, for compensation for erroneous incarceration. At that time, the law required an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration be submitted within two years of acquittal, pardon or release from custody. However, legislation took effect on January 2, 2020, while Poulos' case was stayed, that expanded the deadline for submitting application to 10 years following dismissal of charges. (See SB 269 (Bradford), Chapter 473, Statutes of 2019.) In light of this change in the law, VCB deemed her application timely and requested a response letter from the Attorney General.
On February 28, 2020, the Attorney General concluded Poulos was entitled to a recommendation for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On March 23, 2020, VCB awarded Poulos $60,340 for 431 days of erroneous incarceration.
Lawrence M. Martin. On, September 18, 1997, Martin was arrested by San Jose State University Police Officer Stoker for possession of a knife and a usable amount of marijuana. Martin was released from custody prior to November 4, 1997, awaiting trial. On, May 11, 1998, a jury in Santa Clara County convicted Martin of possession of a concealed "dirk or dagger" and of less than 28.5 grams of marijuana. On May 12, 1998, the court found that a) Martin had four prior serious and violent felony convictions within the meaning of California's "Three Strikes Law" and b) Martin had served three prior prison terms. On August 11, 1998, the court sentenced Martin to 25 years to life for possession of a concealed dirk or dagger with serious or violent felonies within the meaning of the Three Strikes Law and a consecutive term of three years for the prior prison terms.
Between his arrest and conviction, Martin was arrested on November 4, 1997, for tampering with a vehicle and again, on January 16, 1998. He was charged and convicted of a misdemeanor on May 12, 1998 and sentenced to 90 days concurrent with his sentence described above. On January 16, 1998, Martin was convicted of misdemeanor possession of controlled paraphernalia, for which he was sentenced to one day in county jail.
On December 15, 2017, The Santa Clara County Superior Court vacated Martin's conviction for possession of a dirk or dagger because, in fact, Martin was in possession of a common pocket knife. On December 18, Martin submitted a claim with VCB requesting compensation for erroneous conviction. The Attorney General, on February 14, 2020, declared Martin to be factually innocent and conceded Martin is entitled to compensation for wrongful conviction for the crime of possessing a dirk or dagger. On March 18, 2020, VCB granted Martin's claim for compensation, awarding him $1,015,980 for 7,257 days of wrongful incarceration. The compensation does not include time Martin served for the crimes of tampering with a vehicle and possession of a controlled substance.
Ricky Leo Davis. Ricky Leo Davis was wrongfully convicted and sentenced for the brutal murder of Jane Hylton in 1985.
Hylton, along with her 13-year-old daughter, Angela, had moved back into Hylton's mother's house, following Hylton's separation from her husband. Also living in the house were Davis, at the time 20 years old, and his girlfriend, Constance Dahl.
Late on the night of July 6, Davis, Dahl, and Hylton's daughter Angela entered Hylton's mother's home together. Davis and Dahl reported they had returned from a party, while Angela maintained she had been out with three teenaged boys. Davis, Dahl and Angela entered the home and, together, found Hylton's body. Hylton had been stabbed to death. She also had a bite mark on her left shoulder.
Police investigated Hylton's murder. Davis insisted he and Dahl were at the party till 3:00 a.m. The police were unable to identify the teens whom Angela said she had been with. DNA testing technology was not yet available. The case went cold.
Seventeen years later, in 2002, police subjected Dahl to repeated interrogation. Eventually, Dahl confessed she bit Hylton while Hylton and Davis fought. Davis was charged with Hylton's murder in El Dorado County Superior Court. On August 17, 2005, a jury found Davis guilty of murder. He was sentenced to 16 years to life. Because he was at that time serving a federal sentence for a bank robbery, Davis began his sentence for Hylton's murder on July 14, 2008.
While in prison, Davis was convicted for assault of another inmate and sentenced to a two-year term to run consecutive with his sentence for murder.
In 2012, El Dorado County Superior Court appointed the Northern California Innocence Project to investigate Davis' conviction and to file a motion for post-conviction DNA testing. The El Dorado District Attorney's Office agreed to testing. The DNA test revealed the presence of the same DNA in the bite mark on Hylton's shoulder and the DNA under her fingernails. Crucially, that DNA did not match Davis' DNA.
Subsequently, investigators matched the DNA from Hylton's body with one of three formerly teenage boys who had been with Angela the night of the murder. One of those former boys—now a man in his fifties—became a suspect for Angela's murder.
On February 13, 2020, the El Dorado County District Attorney moved to dismiss the murder charge against Davis, reporting Dahl's confession was not trustworthy, since unequivocal DNA evidence demonstrated Davis innocence. Davis was immediately released from custody.
On March 30, 2020, Davis submitted an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On April 27, 2020, VCB granted Davis $490,280 for 3,502, the number of days he spent incarcerated erroneously.
Samuel Bonner. Samuel Bonner was incarcerated for over 36 years for a conviction of first-degree murder and robbery. On February 10, 2020, he was declared factually innocent of both charges.
On November 11, 1982, Bonner drove Watson Allison to Leonard Polk's residence, at 850 Orizaba Avenue. Polk was observed by witnesses, including a Long Beach Police Officer, speaking with Allison alongside Bonner's car. Bonner was never seen exiting in the vehicle. Witnesses saw Bonner's vehicle drive away.
Shortly after, neighbors and the police officers saw Allison make several trips from Polk's apartment, carrying Polk's television, stereo speakers and a large duffel bag, and placing the items in Polk's vehicle. The police officer saw Allison enter Polk's vehicle, alone, and drive off in it.
Soon after, Polk's neighbors entered Polk's apartment and found him shot dead.
Officers issued a search for Bonner's vehicle. They found it that evening parked near Allison's home. On November 12, police arrested Bonner and searched his person, his vehicle and his home, but found none of Polk's property. During questioning, Bonner was not forthright with Allison's name, Allison's whereabouts or his own whereabouts on the night of Polk's murder. Officers released Bonner.
On November 22, 1983, officers found Polk's property in Allison's garage. Officers found a partial palm print on a piece of Polk's stereo equipment. Officer's located an automobile fuse on Bonner's person similar to one found in the street in front of Polk's residence. The fuse was next to a footprint and a cloth speaker cover from one Polk's stolen speakers. Officers arrested Bonner, again, on November 22, 1982. He and Allison were each charged with two counts: one count of first-degree murder with a special circumstance, robbery, and the special allegation of personal use of a handgun in commission of the murder, and count two, robbery.
Bonner and Allison were tried separately. Evidence presented against Bonner included:
- Testimony of a "jailhouse informant" that Bonner had confessed to the informant he shot Polk.
- The partial palm print and fuse placed Bonner at the scene of the crime.
The jury found Bonner guilty of murder in the first degree with the special circumstance of robbery and of robbery, but not of the special allegation, personal use of a handgun in the commission of a murder. On December 5, 1983, the court sentenced Bonner to 25 years to life without the possibility of parole.
Years later, Bonner filed a petition to vacate his murder conviction and consider charging him with new counts based on a change in the felony murder law. The court vacated Bonner's convictions and chose not to resentence him, because:
- The jury found Bonner was not the killer.
- Bonner's conviction was based upon the theory of felony murder, and statute regarding felony murder had changed since Bonner's conviction.
- The prosecution did not turn over exculpatory evidence to Bonner, including the informant's full criminal record and evidence the informant committed perjury.
Bonner was released on July 11, 2019. On April 24, 2020, VCB granted Bonner's application for compensation for erroneous incarceration and awarded him $1,873,620 as compensation for his 13,383 days incarcerated.
According to the Author:
Arguments in Support:
None on file
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, one-time General Fund appropriation to the Victim's Compensation Board of $5,087,040.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 29-5-5
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Dahle, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas, Chang, Glazer, Grove, Wilk
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, McCarty, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Megan Dahle
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 26, 2020
CONSULTANT: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081 FN: 0002846
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 417
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:May 26, 2020
Policy Committee: | Not applicable | Vote: | Not applicable |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: Yes State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill, an urgency measure, is one of two annual state claims bills introduced pursuant to California Victim Compensation Board (Board) determinations and required to be authored by one of the chairs of the appropriations committee of either house. This bill appropriates approximately $5.1 million from the General Fund to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board to pay the claims of the following individuals, who were erroneously convicted of a crime:
- Moonshadow Naomi Taggart: $136, 780.
- Lionel Omar Rublacava: $874,440.
- Ruben Martinez: $635, 600.
- Michelle Marie Poulos: $60,340.
- Lawrence M. Martin: $1,015,980.
- Ricky Leo Davis: $490,280.
- Samuel Bonner: $1,873, 620.
FISCAL EFFECT:
One-time General Fund appropriation to the Victim’s Compensation Board of $5,087,040.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Current law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno), Statutes of 2013, if a person has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside, the finding is grounds for payment of a claim against the state and upon application by the petitioner, the board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; (b) the claimant did not contribute to the arrest or conviction for the crime; and (c) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served in a state prison subsequent to the claimant’s conviction.
- Purpose. This bill appropriates approximately $5.1 million from the General Fund to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board to pay the claims of the following individuals, who were erroneously convicted of a crime.
Moonshadow Naomi Taggart. On April 11, 2014, the Kern County District Attorney (DA) charged Moonshadow Naomi Taggart with two counts related to the possession of methamphetamine, and alleged that she had served prior prison terms for possession of a controlled substance, for car theft, and for possession of a controlled substance for sale.
Following her guilty plea, the trial court sentenced her to a four-year split sentence, with one year to be served in the Kern County Jail, and the remainder on mandatory supervision, but she was released from jail shortly after sentencing. On September 10, 2014, Taggart was arrested and charged with possession of a stolen vehicle. After entering a guilty plea to buying and receiving a stolen vehicle, and admitting to two prison priors, she was sentenced to two years in prison. On March 31, 2015, Taggart was granted early release, conditioned upon her promise not to leave Kern County without permission from the Kern County Board of Parole.
A parole officer made two attempts to contact Taggart at her residence of record without success, and on June 26, 2015, a warrant was issued for her arrest. On August 17, 2015, Taggart was arrested out-of-state and transported to California, and the Kern County DA charged her with escape from the Kern County Sheriff’s Parole Program while also alleging the initial prison priors. A jury convicted Taggart of escape and the trial court imposed an aggregate term of five years (three years for escape, plus two years for the two prison priors). The court also imposed a consecutive term of two years and eight months related to the previous case of possession of a stolen vehicle, as well as a concurrent term of four years for the previous case of drug possession. Taggart’s total sentence was seven years and eight months.
Taggart appealed the escape conviction, claiming insufficient evidence, and she was discharged to post-release community supervision during the pendency of the appeal. She had been continuously confined for 977 days since the escape arrest. On January 23, 2019, the appellate court reversed Taggart’s escape conviction, finding that sheriff’s parole did not constitute “lawful custody” because she was only minimally constrained and not deprived of physical freedom as she was not confined to a residence or specific facility. Accordingly, there was no custody from which she could escape. The appellate court did, however, find that Taggart’s departure from Kern County constituted a parole violation for the other two cases, for which she may be returned to custody to serve the reminder of those sentences.
At the resentencing, the trial court imposed a four-year sentence for possessing a stolen vehicle and a concurrent four-year sentence for drug possession, but deemed both sentences were already served in full as Taggart had accrued a total of 2,367 days credit, and terminated her post-release community supervision.
On June 28, 2019, Taggart applied to the Victim Compensation Board seeking compensation for erroneous conviction related to the escape charge. The Attorney General (AG) responded and agreed that she was actually innocent of the escape conviction and entitled to $136,780 for 977 days of imprisonment. The Board’s Hearing Officer agreed that Taggart was actually innocent of escape, but recommended compensation for 449 days of incarceration because she had served 528 days for her valid convictions of drug possession and possession of a stolen vehicle. At the Board’s meeting to consider the proposed decision, the AG opposed the reduction in compensation because the trial court would not have resentenced her to prison for the two valid convictions if she had not been erroneously convicted of escape. The Board ultimately agreed with the AG and determined, based on a preponderance of evidence, that Taggart’s erroneous incarceration included the concurrent period she served for the valid convictions, and recommended compensation in the amount of $136,780 for all 977 days of her incarceration.
Lionel Omar Rublacava. Lionel Omar Rublacava was convicted for attempted murder and spent over 17 years in prison. On November 18, 2019, Rublacava was declared factually innocent.
On April 2, 2002, Raymond Rodriguez was shot in a drive-by shooting in the city of San Jose. Rodriguez’s brother was with him at the time of the shooting. Both Rodriguez, who survived the shooting, and his brother claim to have seen, at the time of the shooting, a small portion of the shooter’s face through an open portion of a tinted window, though neither said they recognized the shooter. Soon after the shooting, police located the burned out remains of the shooter’s vehicle.
Two days after the shooting, an incident occurred in which Rublacava appeared in his car in front of Rodriguez’s house. Subsequently, police showed Rodriguez, who was recovering in hospital, a picture of Rublacava, whom Rodriguez identified as the shooter, as did his brother.
Rublacava was soon thereafter arrested for attempted murder and tried for the crime in the Santa Clara County Superior Court. There was no physical evidence linking Rublacava to the crime, and Rublacava presented compelling evidence of an alibi at the time of the shooting. Nonetheless, after a short trial, the jury convicted Rublacava of attempted murder.
On January 23, 2006, the Court of Appeal confirmed Rublacava’s conviction.
On October 15, 2018, with the assistance of the Northern California Innocence Project (Innocence Project), Rublacava filed a petition with the Santa Clara County Superior Court to have his conviction vacated. The petition included a statement from Rodriguez indicating he was uncertain about his identification of Rublacava as the person who shot him.
As a consequence, the Santa Clara County District Attorney conducted an investigation with the Innocence Project. The investigation revealed that, since being shot, Rodriguez had made considerable changes to his life. He was no longer addicted to drugs and he was no longer affiliated with a street gang. Rodriguez also admitted to investigators he was never entirely sure of his identification of Rublacava as the person who shot him. Though Rodriguez’s brother continued to identify Rublacava as the person who shot his brother, the district attorney lost confidence in Rublacava’s conviction. On March 18, the district attorney joined Rublacava’s petition of the court to vacate his conviction.
On April 24, 2019, the Santa Clara Superior Court granted Rublacava’s petition and vacated the entire judgement against him. Rublacava was released from prison on May 15, 2019, after serving 6,246 days imprisoned for a crime he did not commit. Rublacava’s entire term of imprisonment was solely attributable to the wrongful conviction.
On January 2, 2020, the VCB granted Rublacava’s application for compensation for wrongful conviction and found that he is factually innocent. The VCB concluded Rublacava is entitled to $874,440, or $140 for each day of erroneous incarceration.
Ruben Martinez. Starting in 2005 through 2007, an auto body shop in Los Angeles was robbed on five separate occasions, at gunpoint, purportedly by the same male perpetrator. The robber forcibly took money from the business safe and from customers and employees. The only physical evidence of the robberies was a palm print left during the first robbery, which occurred on December 25, 2005.
On June 1, 2007, Martinez was charged in Los Angeles County Superior Court with nine counts of second-degree robbery while armed with a firearm, each count associated with the five robberies of the auto body shop. Martinez’s palm print did not match the palm print left at the scene of the first robbery. In addition, Martinez insisted upon his innocence of all of the robberies and presented alibi evidence from his wife, brother-in-law and two work supervisors contending Martinez had been at work on the occasion of two of the robberies. The only evidence presented against Martinez was eyewitness identification of Martinez as the robber by five employees and customers of the body shop. A jury in Martinez’s first trial did not reach a verdict; however, a second jury convicted him to a sentence of 47 years and 8 months.
Martinez requested the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office (LA DA) consider his case for factual evidence. The subsequent LA DA investigation uncovered additional alibi evidence that “unmistakably” demonstrated Martinez was working at a site remote from the body shop at the time of two of the robberies. Because the LA DA believed the same perpetrator “clearly” committed all five of the robberies, the LA DA lost confidence in all of Martinez’s robbery convictions. On November 5, 2019, the LA DA motioned in Los Angeles Superior Court for the overturn of Martinez’s conviction, at which point Martinez was released from prison on his own recognizance. Two days later, the LA DA moved to vacate Martinez’s robbery convictions, dismiss with prejudice the underlying case and issue a factual finding of innocence. On November 12, 2019, the court ordered vacated all nine convictions, dismissed the entire case with prejudice in the interest of justice and expressly found “the defendant to be factually innocent” in each of all nine charges.
On January 15, 2020, Martinez submitted an application with the VCB for compensation as an erroneously convicted person. On January 24, 2020, the VCB granted Martinez’s application for compensation, in amount of $635,600, for his 4,540 days of erroneous incarceration.
Michelle Marie Poulos. On June 28, 2001, Poulos pleaded guilty to a single count of criminal threats against June Patti, who was Poulos’ former romantic partner. Patti was the only witness to the threats Poulos was to have made against her. In exchange for her plea, Poulos received a suspended two-year prison sentence and was placed on three-year probation.
A year later, Poulos admitted violating the terms of her probation for felony possession of methamphetamine in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. On September 19, 2002, the trial imposed the previously suspended two-year prison sentence for criminal threats against Patti and a concurrent term of two years for methamphetamine possession.
Poulos was released from prison on September 25, 2003 after having served 431 days, consisting of 59 days pre-sentencing and 372 days post-sentencing, as well as 372 concurrent days for methamphetamine possession.
Thirteen years later, on January 23, 2017, the Los Angeles Superior Court granted Poulos’ motion to vacate and dismiss her criminal threat conviction, for which prosecution had “lost trust in the witness Patti.” The court found Patti had “lied and fabricated information,” which resulted in harm to Poulos. (Prior to the motion to vacate Poulos’ conviction, in 2014, the court found another individual, Susan Mellen, had been erroneously convicted for murder based on Patti’s false testimony.)
Poulos then challenged her conviction for methamphetamine possession, reasoning that she would have been ordered to participate in a drug rehabilitation program, not prison, were it not for her erroneous criminal threat conviction. Poulos noted she completed a drug treatment program while in prison.
While the Los Angeles County Superior Court initially denied Poulos’ motion, upon remand, the court, on May 24, 2019, granted the motion to vacate the conviction for methamphetamine possession in the interest of justice. The court chose not to find Poulos’ factually innocent of methamphetamine possession.
As the court weighed her motion for relief from the methamphetamine conviction, Poulos submitted an application to VCB on January 17, 2019, for compensation for erroneous incarceration. At that time, the law required an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration be submitted within two years of acquittal, pardon or release from custody. However, legislation took effect on January 2, 2020, while Poulos’ case was stayed, that expanded the deadline for submitting application to 10 years following dismissal of charges. (See SB 269 (Bradford), Chapter 473, Statutes of 2019.) In light of this change in the law, VCB deemed her application timely and requested a response letter from the Attorney General.
On February 28, 2020, the Attorney General concluded Poulos was entitled to a recommendation for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On March 23, 2020, VCB awarded Poulos $60,340 for 431 days of erroneous incarceration.
Lawrence M. Martin. On, September 18, 1997, Martin was arrested by San Jose State University Police Officer Stoker for possession of a knife and a usable amount of marijuana. Martin was released from custody prior to November 4, 1997, awaiting trial. On, May 11, 1998, a jury in Santa Clara County convicted Martin of possession of a concealed “dirk or dagger” and of less than 28.5 grams of marijuana. On May 12, 1998, the court found that 1) Martin had four prior serious and violent felony convictions within the meaning of California’s “Three Strikes Law” and 2) Martin had served three prior prison terms. On August 11, 1998, the court sentenced Martin to 25 years to life for possession of a concealed dirk or dagger with serious or violent felonies within the meaning of the Three Strikes Law and a consecutive term of three years for the prior prison terms.
Between his arrest and conviction, Martin was arrested on November 4, 1997, for tampering with a vehicle and again, on January 16, 1998. He was charged and convicted of a misdemeanor on May 12, 1998 and sentenced to 90 days concurrent with his sentence described above. On January 16, 1998, Martin was convicted of misdemeanor possession of controlled paraphernalia, for which he was sentenced to one day in county jail.
On December 15, 2017, The Santa Clara County Superior Court vacated Martin’s conviction for possession of a dirk or dagger because, in fact, Martin was in possession of a common pocket knife. On December 18, Martin submitted a claim with VCB requesting compensation for erroneous conviction. The Attorney General, on February 14, 2020, declared Martin to be factually innocent and conceded Martin is entitled to compensation for wrongful conviction for the crime of possessing a dirk or dagger. On March 18, 2020, VCB granted Martin’s claim for compensation, awarding him $1,015,980 for 7,257 days of wrongful incarceration. The compensation does not include time Martin served for the crimes of tampering with a vehicle and possession of a controlled substance.
Ricky Leo Davis. Ricky Leo Davis was wrongfully convicted and sentenced for the brutal murder of Jane Hylton in 1985.
Hylton, along with her 13-year-old daughter, Angela, had moved back into Hylton’s mother’s house, following Hylton’s separation from her husband. Also living in the house were Davis, at the time 20 years old, and his girlfriend, Constance Dahl.
Late on the night of July 6, Davis, Dahl, and Hylton’s daughter Angela entered Hylton’s mother’s home together. Davis and Dahl reported they had returned from a party, while Angela maintained she had been out with three teenaged boys. Davis, Dahl and Angela entered the home and, together, found Hylton’s body. Hylton had been stabbed to death. She also had a bite mark on her left shoulder.
Police investigated Hylton’s murder. Davis insisted he and Dahl were at the party till 3:00 a.m. The police were unable to identify the teens whom Angela said she had been with. DNA testing technology was not yet available. The case went cold.
Seventeen years later, in 2002, police subjected Dahl to repeated interrogation. Eventually, Dahl confessed she bit Hylton while Hylton and Davis fought. Davis was charged with Hylton’s murder in El Dorado County Superior Court. On August 17, 2005, a jury found Davis guilty of murder. He was sentenced to 16 years to life. Because he was at that time serving a federal sentence for a bank robbery, Davis began his sentence for Hylton’s murder on July 14, 2008.
While in prison, Davis was convicted for assault of another inmate and sentenced to a two-year term to run consecutive with his sentence for murder.
In 2012, El Dorado County Superior Court appointed the Northern California Innocence Project to investigate Davis’ conviction and to file a motion for post-conviction DNA testing. The El Dorado District Attorney’s Office agreed to testing. The DNA test revealed the presence of the same DNA in the bite mark on Hylton’s shoulder and the DNA under her fingernails. Crucially, that DNA did not match Davis’ DNA.
Subsequently, investigators matched the DNA from Hylton’s body with one of three formerly teenage boys who had been with Angela the night of the murder. One of those former boys—now a man in his fifties—became a suspect for Angela’s murder.
On February 13, 2020, the El Dorado County District Attorney moved to dismiss the murder charge against Davis, reporting Dahl’s confession was not trustworthy, since unequivocal DNA evidence demonstrated Davis innocence. Davis was immediately released from custody.
On March 30, 2020, Davis submitted an application for compensation for erroneous incarceration. On April 27, 2020, VCB granted Davis $490,280 for 3,502, the number of days he spent incarcerated erroneously.
Samuel Bonner. Samuel Bonner was incarcerated for over 36 years for a conviction of first-degree murder and robbery. On February 10, 2020, he was declared factually innocent of both charges.
On November 11, 1982, Bonner drove Watson Allison to Leonard Polk’s residence, at 850 Orizaba Avenue. Polk was observed by witnesses, including a Long Beach Police Officer, speaking with Allison alongside Bonner’s car. Bonner was never seen exiting in the vehicle. Witnesses saw Bonner’s vehicle drive away.
Shortly after, neighbors and the police officers saw Allison make several trips from Polk’s apartment, carrying Polk’s television, stereo speakers and a large duffel bag, and placing the items in Polk’s vehicle. The police officer saw Allison enter Polk’s vehicle, alone, and drive off in it.
Soon after, Polk’s neighbors entered Polk’s apartment and found him shot dead.
Officers issued a search for Bonner’s vehicle. They found it that evening parked near Allison’s home. On November 12, police arrested Bonner and searched his person, his vehicle and his home, but found none of Polk’s property. During questioning, Bonner was not forthright with Allison’s name, Allison’s whereabouts or his own whereabouts on the night of Polk’s murder. Officers released Bonner.
On November 22, 1983, officers found Polk’s property in Allison’s garage. Officers found a partial palm print on a piece of Polk’s stereo equipment. Officer’s located an automobile fuse on Bonner’s person similar to one found in the street in front of Polk’s residence. The fuse was next to a footprint and a cloth speaker cover from one Polk’s stolen speakers. Officers arrested Bonner, again, on November 22, 1982. He and Allison were each charged with two counts: one count of first-degree murder with a special circumstance, robbery, and the special allegation of personal use of a handgun in commission of the murder, and count two, robbery.
Bonner and Allison were tried separately. Evidence presented against Bonner included:
- Testimony of a “jailhouse informant” that Bonner had confessed to the informant he shot Polk.
- The partial palm print and fuse placed Bonner at the scene of the crime.
The jury found Bonner guilty of murder in the first degree with the special circumstance of robbery and of robbery, but not of the special allegation, personal use of a handgun in the commission of a murder. On December 5, 1983, the court sentenced Bonner to 25 years to life without the possibility of parole.
Years later, Bonner filed a petition to vacate his murder conviction and consider charging him with new counts based on a change in the felony murder law. The court vacated Bonner’s convictions and chose not to resentence him, because:
- The jury found Bonner was not the killer.
- Bonner’s conviction was based upon the theory of felony murder, and statute regarding felony murder had changed since Bonner’s conviction.
- The prosecution did not turn over exculpatory evidence to Bonner, including the informant’s full criminal record and evidence the informant committed perjury.
Bonner was released on July 11, 2019. On April 24, 2020, VCB granted Bonner’s application for compensation for erroneous incarceration and awarded him $1,873,620 as compensation for his 13,383 days incarcerated.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 417 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 417
Amended: 1/13/20
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 1/21/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: California Victim Compensation Board: claim
DIGEST:
This bill appropriates $136,780 to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board (Board) for the payment of a specified erroneous conviction claim.
ANALYSIS: Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
This bill appropriates General Fund revenues to the Board for the payment of the claim related to the erroneous conviction of Moonshadow Naomi Taggart.
- On April 11, 2014, the Kern County District Attorney (DA) charged Moonshadow Naomi Taggart with two counts related to the possession of methamphetamine, and alleged that she had served prior prison terms for possession of a controlled substance, for car theft, and for possession of a controlled substance for sale. Following her guilty plea, the trial court sentenced her to a four-year split sentence, with one year to be served in the Kern County Jail, and the remainder on mandatory supervision, but she was released from jail shortly after sentencing.
On September 10, 2014, Taggart was arrested and charged with possession of a stolen vehicle. After entering a guilty plea to buying and receiving a stolen vehicle, and admitting to two prison priors, she was sentenced to two years in prison. On March 31, 2015, Taggart was granted early release, conditioned upon her promise not to leave Kern County without permission from the Kern County Board of Parole. A parole officer made two attempts to contact Taggart at her residence of record without success, and on June 26, 2015, a warrant was issued for her arrest.
On August 17, 2015, Taggart was arrested out-of-state and transported to California, and the Kern County DA charged her with escape from the Kern County Sheriff’s Parole Program while also alleging the initial prison priors. A jury convicted Taggart of escape and the trial court imposed an aggregate term of five years (three years for escape, plus two years for the two prison priors). The court also imposed a consecutive term of two years and eight months related to the previous case of possession of a stolen vehicle, as well as a concurrent term of four years for the previous case of drug possession. Taggart’s total sentence was seven years and eight months.
Taggart appealed the escape conviction, claiming insufficient evidence, and she was discharged to post-release community supervision during the pendency of the appeal. She had been continuously confined for 977 days since the escape arrest. On January 23, 2019, the appellate court reversed Taggart’s escape conviction, finding that sheriff’s parole did not constitute “lawful custody” because she was only minimally constrained and not deprived of physical freedom as she was not confined to a residence or specific facility. Accordingly, there was no custody from which she could escape. The appellate court did, however, find that Taggart’s departure from Kern County constituted a parole violation for the other two cases, for which she may be returned to custody to serve the reminder of those sentences. At the resentencing, the trial court imposed a four-year sentence for possessing a stolen vehicle and a concurrent four-year sentence for drug possession, but deemed both sentences were already served in full as Taggart had accrued a total of 2,367 days credit, and terminated her post-release community supervision.
On June 28, 2019, Taggart applied to the Board seeking compensation for erroneous conviction related to the escape charge. The Attorney General (AG) responded and agreed that she was actually innocent of the escape conviction and entitled to $136,780 for 977 days of imprisonment. The Board’s Hearing Officer agreed that Taggart was actually innocent of escape, but recommended compensation for 449 days of incarceration because she had served 528 days for her valid convictions of drug possession and possession of a stolen vehicle. At the Board’s meeting to consider the proposed decision, the AG opposed the reduction in compensation because the trial court would not have resentenced her to prison for the two valid convictions if she had not been erroneously convicted of escape. The Board ultimately agreed with the AG and determined, based on a preponderance of evidence, that Taggart’s erroneous incarceration included the concurrent period she served for the valid convictions, and recommended compensation in the amount of $136,780 for all 977 days of her incarceration.
Background
The State Board of Control was established in 1945. It was revised and renamed the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by AB 2491 (Jackson, Chapter 1016, Statutes of 2000), and subsequently renamed the California Victim Compensation Board by SB 836 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, Chapter 31, Statutes of 2016). SB 836 transferred the authority to approve general government claims for which no legal available appropriation exists to the Department of General Services, and the Board currently administers the Victim Compensation Program, the Revenue Recovery Program, Claims of Erroneously Convicted Felons, the Good Samaritan Act, and the Missing Children Reward Program.
Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno, Chapter 800, Statutes of 2013), a person who has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside is eligible for payment in a claim against the state. Upon application by the petitioner, the Board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the Board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the Board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; and (b) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the Board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served, including any time spent in custody that is considered part of the term of incarceration, such as time served in a county jail.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $136,780 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Moonshadow Naomi Taggart, approved by the Board on November 4, 2019.
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/22/20)
None received
Prepared by: Mark McKenzie / APPR. / (916) 651-4101
1/22/20 15:23:45
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 417 (Portantino) - California Victim Compensation Board: claim
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Pursuant to the Committee’s rules, the Suspense File rule does not apply to this bill as claims are considered valid obligations of the state. Additionally, claims may have time sensitivity.
Bill Summary:
SB 417, an urgency measure, would appropriate $136,780 to the Executive Officer of the California Victim Compensation Board (Board) for the payment of a specified erroneous conviction claim.
Fiscal Impact:
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $136,780 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Moonshadow Naomi Taggart, approved by the Board on November 4, 2019.
Background:
The State Board of Control was established in 1945. It was revised and renamed the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by Chapter 1016/2000 (AB 2491, Jackson), and subsequently renamed the California Victim Compensation Board by Chapter 31/2016 (SB 836, Budget and Fiscal Review Committee). SB 836 transferred the authority to approve general government claims for which no legal available appropriation exists to the Department of General Services, and the Board currently administers the Victim Compensation Program, the Revenue Recovery Program, Claims of Erroneously Convicted Felons, the Good Samaritan Act, and the Missing Children Reward Program.
Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno), Chapter 800/2013, a person who has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside is eligible for payment in a claim against the state. Upon application by the petitioner, the Board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the Board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the Board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; and (b) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the Board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served, including any time spent in custody that is considered part of the term of incarceration, such as time served in a county jail.
Proposed Law:
This bill, an urgency measure, would appropriate $136,780 to the Board for compensation related to the erroneous conviction of Moonshadow Naomi Taggart.
Staff Comments:
On April 11, 2014, the Kern County District Attorney (DA) charged Moonshadow Naomi Taggart with two counts related to the possession of methamphetamine, and alleged that she had served prior prison terms for possession of a controlled substance, for car theft, and for possession of a controlled substance for sale. Following her guilty plea, the trial court sentenced her to a four-year split sentence, with one year to be served in the Kern County Jail, and the remainder on mandatory supervision, but she was released from jail shortly after sentencing.
On September 10, 2014, Taggart was arrested and charged with possession of a stolen vehicle. After entering a guilty plea to buying and receiving a stolen vehicle, and admitting to two prison priors, she was sentenced to two years in prison. On March 31, 2015, Taggart was granted early release, conditioned upon her promise not to leave Kern County without permission from the Kern County Board of Parole. A parole officer made two attempts to contact Taggart at her residence of record without success, and on June 26, 2015, a warrant was issued for her arrest.
On August 17, 2015, Taggart was arrested out-of-state and transported to California, and the Kern County DA charged her with escape from the Kern County Sheriff’s Parole Program while also alleging the initial prison priors. A jury convicted Taggart of escape and the trial court imposed an aggregate term of five years (three years for escape, plus two years for the two prison priors). The court also imposed a consecutive term of two years and eight months related to the previous case of possession of a stolen vehicle, as well as a concurrent term of four years for the previous case of drug possession. Taggart’s total sentence was seven years and eight months.
Taggart appealed the escape conviction, claiming insufficient evidence, and she was discharged to post-release community supervision during the pendency of the appeal. She had been continuously confined for 977 days since the escape arrest. On January 23, 2019, the appellate court reversed Taggart’s escape conviction, finding that sheriff’s parole did not constitute “lawful custody” because she was only minimally constrained and not deprived of physical freedom as she was not confined to a residence or specific facility. Accordingly, there was no custody from which she could escape. The appellate court did, however, find that Taggart’s departure from Kern County constituted a parole violation for the other two cases, for which she may be returned to custody to serve the reminder of those sentences. At the resentencing, the trial court imposed a four year sentence for possessing a stolen vehicle and a concurrent four year sentence for drug possession, but deemed both sentences were already served in full as Taggart had accrued a total of 2,367 days credit, and terminated her post-release community supervision.
On June 28, 2019, Taggart applied to the Victim Compensation Board seeking compensation for erroneous conviction related to the escape charge. The Attorney General (AG) responded and agreed that she was actually innocent of the escape conviction and entitled to $136,780 for 977 days of imprisonment. The Board’s Hearing Officer agreed that Taggart was actually innocent of escape, but recommended compensation for 449 days of incarceration because she had served 528 days for her valid convictions of drug possession and possession of a stolen vehicle. At the Board’s meeting to consider the proposed decision, the AG opposed the reduction in compensation because the trial court would not have resentenced her to prison for the two valid convictions if she had not been erroneously convicted of escape. The Board ultimately agreed with the AG and determined, based on a preponderance of evidence, that Taggart’s erroneous incarceration included the concurrent period she served for the valid convictions, and recommended compensation in the amount of $136,780 for all 977 days of her incarceration.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):