SB 425: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-12
Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and specified other boards responsible for the licensure, regulation, and discipline of health care practitioners to separately create and maintain a central file of the names of all persons who hold a license, certificate, or similar authority from that board, including prescribed historical information for each licensee. Existing law makes the contents of any central file that are not public records confidential, except that the licensee or their counsel or a representative are authorized to inspect and have copies made of the licensees complete file other than the disclosure of the identity of an information source. Existing law authorizes a board to protect an information source by providing a copy of the material with only those deletions necessary to protect the identity of the source or by providing a comprehensive summary of the substance of the material.
This bill would delete the specification that the summary be comprehensive.
Existing law establishes a peer review process for certain healing arts licentiates, as defined, and requires the chief of staff of a medical or professional staff or other chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of any peer review body and the chief executive officer or administrator of any licensed health care facility or clinic to report specified information, including the denial or revocation of staff privileges, as defined, for a medical disciplinary cause or reason, within 15 days of the denial or revocation to the relevant state licensing agency. Existing law makes a violation of this reporting requirement punishable by a civil fine.
This bill would require any health care facility, as defined, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients to report any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct, as defined, made against a healing arts licensee by a patient, if the patient or the patients representative makes the allegation in writing, to the relevant state licensing agency within 15 days of receiving the written allegation and would require the relevant agency to investigate the circumstances underlying a received report. The bill would require such a report to be kept confidential and, with certain exceptions, such a report would not be subject to discovery or disclosure in a disciplinary hearing. The bill would make a willful failure to file the report by a health care facility or other entity punishable by a civil fine not to exceed $100,000 per violation and any other failure to make that report punishable by a civil fine not to exceed $50,000 per violation, as specified. The bill would also prohibit a person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity from incurring civil or criminal liability as a result of making a report.
The Medical Practice Act establishes the Medical Board of California for the licensure, regulation, and discipline of physicians and surgeons.
The act authorizes the board to deny a physicians and surgeons certificate to an applicant guilty of unprofessional conduct or of any cause that would subject a licensee to revocation or suspension of their license. The act authorizes the board in its sole discretion to issue a probationary physicians and surgeons certificate to an applicant subject to terms and conditions.
This bill would require the board to disclose a probationary physicians and surgeons certificate and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and to post the certificate and statement on the boards internet website for 10 years from issuance.
The act requires the board to take action against any licensee who is charged with unprofessional conduct and provides that unprofessional conduct includes the repeated failure by a certificate holder who is the subject of an investigation by the board, in the absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by the board.
This bill would delete the condition that the failure to attend and participate in an interview by the board be repeated. The bill would also delete an obsolete provision.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 2234 of the Business and Professions Code proposed by SB 786 to be operative only if this bill and SB 786 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
(a)The Medical Board of California, the Podiatric Medical Board of California, the Board of Psychology, the Dental Board of California, the Dental Hygiene Board of California, the Osteopathic Medical Board of California, the State Board of Chiropractic Examiners, the Board of Registered Nursing, the Board of Vocational Nursing and Psychiatric Technicians of the State of California, the State Board of Optometry, the Veterinary Medical Board, the Board of Behavioral Sciences, the Physical Therapy Board of California, the California State Board of Pharmacy, the Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology and Hearing Aid Dispensers Board, the California Board of Occupational Therapy, the Acupuncture Board, and the Physician Assistant Board shall each separately create and maintain a central file of the names of all persons who hold a license, certificate, or similar authority from that board. Each central file shall be created and maintained to provide an individual historical record for each licensee with respect to the following information:
(1)Any conviction of a crime in this or any other state that constitutes unprofessional conduct pursuant to the reporting requirements of Section 803.
(2)Any judgment or settlement requiring the licensee or the licensees insurer to pay any amount of damages in excess of three thousand dollars ($3,000) for any claim that injury or death was proximately caused by the licensees negligence, error or omission in practice, or by rendering unauthorized professional services, pursuant to the reporting requirements of Section 801 or 802.
(3)Any public complaints for which provision is made pursuant to subdivision (b).
(4)Disciplinary information reported pursuant to Section 805, including any additional exculpatory or explanatory statements submitted by the licentiate pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 805. If a court finds, in a final judgment, that the peer review resulting in the 805 report was conducted in bad faith and the licensee who is the subject of the report notifies the board of that finding, the board shall include that finding in the central file. For purposes of this paragraph, peer review has the same meaning as defined in Section 805.
(5)Information reported pursuant to Section 805.01, including any explanatory or exculpatory information submitted by the licensee pursuant to subdivision (b) of that section.
(b)(1)Each board shall prescribe and promulgate forms on which members of the public and other licensees or certificate holders may file written complaints to the board alleging any act of misconduct in, or connected with, the performance of professional services by the licensee.
(2)If a board, or division thereof, a committee, or a panel has failed to act upon a complaint or report within five years, or has found that the complaint or report is without merit, the central file shall be purged of information relating to the complaint or report.
(3)Notwithstanding this subdivision, the Board of Psychology, the Board of Behavioral Sciences, and the Respiratory Care Board of California shall maintain complaints or reports as long as each board deems necessary.
(c)(1)The contents of any central file that are not public records under any other provision of law shall be confidential except that the licensee involved, or the licensees counsel or representative, may inspect and have copies made of the licensees complete file except for the provision that may disclose the identity of an information source. For the purposes of this section, a board may protect an information source by providing a copy of the material with only those deletions necessary to protect the identity of the source or by providing a summary of the substance of the material. Whichever method is used, the board shall ensure that full disclosure is made to the subject of any personal information that could reasonably in any way reflect or convey anything detrimental, disparaging, or threatening to a licensees reputation, rights, benefits, privileges, or qualifications, or be used by a board to make a determination that would affect a licensees rights, benefits, privileges, or qualifications. The information required to be disclosed pursuant to Section 803.1 shall not be considered among the contents of a central file for the purposes of this subdivision.
(2)The licensee may, but is not required to, submit any additional exculpatory or explanatory statement or other information that the board shall include in the central file.
(3)Each board may permit any law enforcement or regulatory agency when required for an investigation of unlawful activity or for licensing, certification, or regulatory purposes to inspect and have copies made of that licensees file, unless the disclosure is otherwise prohibited by law.
(4)These disclosures shall effect no change in the confidential status of these records.
SEC. 2.Section 805.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:805.8.(a)As used in this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
(1)Agency means the relevant state licensing agency with regulatory jurisdiction over a healing arts licensee listed in paragraph (2).
(2)Healing arts licensee or licensee means a licensee licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) or any initiative act referred to in that division. Healing arts licensee or licensee also includes a person authorized to practice medicine pursuant to Sections 2064.5, 2113, and 2168.
(3)Health care facility means a clinic or health facility licensed or exempt from licensure pursuant to Division 2 (commencing with Section 1200) of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Other entity includes, but is not limited to, a postsecondary educational institution as defined in Section 66261.5 of the Education Code.
(5)Sexual misconduct means inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature.
(b)A health care facility or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients shall file a report of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee by a patient, if the patient or the patients representative makes the allegation in writing, to the agency within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct. An arrangement under which a licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients includes, but is not limited to, full staff privileges, active staff privileges, limited staff privileges, auxiliary staff privileges, provisional staff privileges, temporary staff privileges, courtesy staff privileges, locum tenens arrangements, and contractual arrangements to provide professional services, including, but not limited to, arrangements to provide outpatient services.
(c)The report provided pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be kept confidential and shall not be subject to discovery, except that the information may be reviewed as provided in subdivision (c) of Section 800 and may be disclosed in any subsequent disciplinary hearing conducted pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(d)A willful failure to file the report described in subdivision (b) shall be punishable by a fine, not to exceed one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) per violation, that shall be paid by the health care facility or other entity subject to subdivision (b). The fine may be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding brought by or on behalf of any agency having regulatory jurisdiction over the licensee regarding whom the report was or should have been filed. If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report under this section is a licensed physician and surgeon, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Medical Board of California. If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report required under this section is a licensed doctor of podiatric medicine, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Podiatric Medical Board of California. The fine shall be paid to that agency, but not expended until appropriated by the Legislature. A violation of this subdivision may constitute unprofessional conduct by the licensee. A person who is alleged to have violated this subdivision may assert any defense available at law. As used in this subdivision, willful means a voluntary and intentional violation of a known legal duty.
(e)Except as provided in subdivision (c), any failure to file the report described in subdivision (b) shall be punishable by a fine, not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation, that shall be paid by the health care facility or other entity subject to subdivision (b). The fine may be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding brought by or on behalf of any agency having regulatory jurisdiction over the person regarding whom the report was or should have been filed. If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report required under this section is a licensed physician and surgeon, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Medical Board of California. If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report required under this section is a licensed doctor of podiatric medicine, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Podiatric Medical Board of California. The fine shall be paid to that agency, but not expended until appropriated by the Legislature. The amount of the fine imposed, not exceeding fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per violation, shall be proportional to the severity of the failure to report and shall differ based upon written findings, including whether the failure to file caused harm to a patient or created a risk to patient safety; whether any person who is designated or otherwise required by law to file the report required under this section exercised due diligence despite the failure to file or whether the person knew or should have known that a report required under this section would not be filed; whether there has been a prior failure to file a report required under this section; and whether a report was filed with another state agency or law enforcement. The amount of the fine imposed may also differ based on whether a health care facility is a small or rural hospital, as defined in Section 124840 of the Health and Safety Code.
(f)A person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity shall not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a report required by this section.
(g)The agency shall investigate the circumstances underlying a report received pursuant to this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2221 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:2221.(a)The board may deny a physicians and surgeons certificate to an applicant guilty of unprofessional conduct or of any cause that would subject a licensee to revocation or suspension of their license. The board, in its sole discretion, may issue a probationary physicians and surgeons certificate to an applicant subject to terms and conditions, including, but not limited to, any of the following conditions of probation:
(1)Practice limited to a supervised, structured environment where the licensees activities shall be supervised by another physician and surgeon.
(2)Total or partial restrictions on drug prescribing privileges for controlled substances.
(3)Continuing medical or psychiatric treatment.
(4)Ongoing participation in a specified rehabilitation program.
(5)Enrollment and successful completion of a clinical training program.
(6)Abstention from the use of alcohol or drugs.
(7)Restrictions against engaging in certain types of medical practice.
(8)Compliance with all provisions of this chapter.
(9)Payment of the cost of probation monitoring.
(b)The board may modify or terminate the terms and conditions imposed on the probationary certificate upon receipt of a petition from the licensee. The board may assign the petition to an administrative law judge designated in Section 11371 of the Government Code. After a hearing on the petition, the administrative law judge shall provide a proposed decision to the board.
(c)The board shall deny a physicians and surgeons certificate to an applicant who is required to register pursuant to Section 290 of the Penal Code. This subdivision does not apply to an applicant who is required to register as a sex offender pursuant to Section 290 of the Penal Code solely because of a misdemeanor conviction under Section 314 of the Penal Code.
(d)An applicant shall not be eligible to reapply for a physicians and surgeons certificate for a minimum of three years from the effective date of the denial of their application, except that the board, in its discretion and for good cause demonstrated, may permit reapplication after not less than one year has elapsed from the effective date of the denial.
(e)The board shall disclose a probationary physicians and surgeons certificate issued pursuant to this section and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and shall post the certificate and statement on the boards internet website for 10 years from issuance.
SEC. 4.Section 2234 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:2234.The board shall take action against any licensee who is charged with unprofessional conduct. In addition to other provisions of this article, unprofessional conduct includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(a)Violating or attempting to violate, directly or indirectly, assisting in or abetting the violation of, or conspiring to violate any provision of this chapter.
(b)Gross negligence.
(c)Repeated negligent acts. To be repeated, there must be two or more negligent acts or omissions. An initial negligent act or omission followed by a separate and distinct departure from the applicable standard of care shall constitute repeated negligent acts.
(1)An initial negligent diagnosis followed by an act or omission medically appropriate for that negligent diagnosis of the patient shall constitute a single negligent act.
(2)When the standard of care requires a change in the diagnosis, act, or omission that constitutes the negligent act described in paragraph (1), including, but not limited to, a reevaluation of the diagnosis or a change in treatment, and the licensees conduct departs from the applicable standard of care, each departure constitutes a separate and distinct breach of the standard of care.
(d)Incompetence.
(e)The commission of any act involving dishonesty or corruption that is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of a physician and surgeon.
(f)Any action or conduct that would have warranted the denial of a certificate.
(g)The failure by a certificate holder, in the absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by the board. This subdivision shall only apply to a certificate holder who is the subject of an investigation by the board.
SEC. 4.5.Section 2234 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:2234.The board shall take action against any licensee who is charged with unprofessional conduct. In addition to other provisions of this article, unprofessional conduct includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(a)Violating or attempting to violate, directly or indirectly, assisting in or abetting the violation of, or conspiring to violate any provision of this chapter.
(b)Gross negligence.
(c)Repeated negligent acts. To be repeated, there must be two or more negligent acts or omissions. An initial negligent act or omission followed by a separate and distinct departure from the applicable standard of care shall constitute repeated negligent acts.
(1)An initial negligent diagnosis followed by an act or omission medically appropriate for that negligent diagnosis of the patient shall constitute a single negligent act.
(2)When the standard of care requires a change in the diagnosis, act, or omission that constitutes the negligent act described in paragraph (1), including, but not limited to, a reevaluation of the diagnosis or a change in treatment, and the licensees conduct departs from the applicable standard of care, each departure constitutes a separate and distinct breach of the standard of care.
(d)Incompetence.
(e)The commission of any act involving dishonesty or corruption that is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of a physician and surgeon.
(f)Any action or conduct that would have warranted the denial of a certificate.
(g)The failure by a certificate holder, in the absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by the board. This subdivision shall only apply to a certificate holder who is the subject of an investigation by the board.
SEC. 5.Section 4.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 2234 of the Business and Professions Code proposed by both this bill and Senate Bill 786. That section of this bill shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2020, (2) each bill amends Section 2234 of the Business and Professions Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Senate Bill 786, in which case Section 4 of this bill shall not become operative.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 12, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 849, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 19, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 21, 2019 | August 21 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 19. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| Jun 17, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B. & P. and JUD. |
| May 28, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 28, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 5.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2. Page 798.) (April 23). |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 8). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Set for hearing April 8. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E.D. and JUD. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB425 Hill Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | SB 425 Hill Senate Third Reading By Gallagher | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB425 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 8, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 425 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 425
Amended: 9/5/19
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/8/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 33-5, 5/28/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Bates, Grove, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/10/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
DIGEST:
This bill requires every health care facility in the state, health care service plans, or other entities with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional to provide care for patients (such as postsecondary educational institutions), to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct made against a licensed health care professional by a patient, if the patient makes the allegation in writing, to the licensee’s licensing board, within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct; and makes other changes related Medical Board of California (MBC) disciplinary action and enforcement.
Assembly Amendments specify that the report is confidential, not be subject to discovery and clarify that in factoring the penalty for failure to report, MBC may take into consideration whether a health facility reported allegations to law enforcement.
Existing law:
- Establishes a number of reporting requirements outlined in the Business and Professions Code designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation.
- Requires, beginning July 1, 2019, certain licensed health care professionals (physicians and surgeons, osteopathic physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, acupuncturists, chiropractors, and naturopathic doctors) to notify patients of their probationary status. For physicians and surgeons licensed by the MBC and Osteopathic Medical Board (OMBC), requires that probationary status be disclosed if there is a final adjudication by MBC or OMBC following an administrative hearing, or admitted findings or prima facie showing in a stipulated settlement establishing certain violations of the law, including the commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct or relations with a patient or client. (BPC § 2228.1)
- Authorizes an interim order suspending (ISO) a license for MBC licensees if the affidavits show that the licensee has engaged in, or is about to engage in, acts or omissions constituting a violation of the Medical Practice Act, or is unable to practice safely due to a mental or physical condition, and that permitting the licensee to continue to engage in the profession for which the license was issued will endanger the public health, safety, or welfare. (Government Code § 11529)
This bill:
- Requires a health care facility, the administrator or chief executive officer of a health care service plan, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a licensed health care professional is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients (including but not limited to a private postsecondary educational institution), to file a report of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct (defined as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature) made against a licensed health care professional by a patient, if the patient makes the allegation in writing, to the licensee’s licensing board, within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Specifies that any failure to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $50,000 per violation, paid by the health care facility or other entity required to report. Specifies that a willful failure (a voluntary and intentional violation of a known legal duty) to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $100,000 per violation. States that a person is immune from any civil or criminal liability for reporting the alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Authorizes MBC, upon receipt of information that the public health, safety, or welfare requires emergency action, to place a physician’s and surgeon’s license on suspension pending formal proceedings. Specifies that this emergency order of suspension shall be issued to the licensee informing the licensee of the facts or conduct warranting the emergency suspension, pending an investigation. Authorizes a licensee whose license has been suspended on emergency order to request a hearing for an ISO, which must be held within 180 days licensee’s request.
- Requires, when issuing a probationary license, the record relating to that probationary license to remain on MBC’s Web site for 10 years.
- Specifies that failure of a licensee (as opposed to repeated failure under current law), absent good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by MBC is unprofessional conduct.
Background
Mandatory Reporting of Health Practitioner Discipline. There are a number of reporting requirements designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation, including BPC Section 805 which requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report when a licensee’s application for staff privileges or membership is denied, or the licensee’s staff privileges or employment are terminated or revoked for a medical disciplinary cause. Licensees include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants. The reporting entities are also required to file a report when restrictions are imposed or voluntarily accepted on the licensee’s staff privileges for a cumulative total of 30 days or more for any 12-month period. The report must be filed within 15 days after the effective date of the action taken by a health facility peer review body.
BPC Section 805.01 is a similarly extremely important requirement. The law requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report within 15 days after the peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action which must be reported pursuant to section 805. This reporting requirement is only required if the recommended action is taken for incompetence, or gross or repeated deviation from the standard of care involving death or serious bodily injury to one or more patients in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to any person or the public; the use of, or prescribing for or administering to him/herself, any controlled substance; or the use of any dangerous drug, or of alcoholic beverages, to the extend or in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to the licentiate, or any other persons, or the public, or to the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licentiate to practice safely; repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, furnishing or administering of controlled substances or repeated acts of prescribing, dispensing, or furnishing of controlled substances without a good faith effort prior examination of the patient and medical reason therefor and; sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination.
The purpose of 805 reports is to provide licensing boards with early information about these serious charges so that they may investigate and take appropriate action to further consumer protection at the earliest possible moment. Accordingly, for any allegations listed above, the Legislature determined that an 805.01 report must be filed once a formal investigation has been completed, and a final decision or recommendation regarding the disciplinary action to be taken against a licensee has been determined by the peer review body, even when the licensee has not yet been afforded a hearing to contest those findings.
Peer Review. In peer review, health care practitioners evaluate their colleagues' work to determine compliance with the standard of care. Peer reviews are intended to detect incompetent or unprofessional practitioners early and terminate, suspend, or limit their practice if necessary. Peer review is triggered by a wide variety of events including patient injury, disruptive conduct, substance abuse, or other medical staff complaints. A peer review committee investigates the allegation, comes to a decision regarding the licensee's conduct, and takes appropriate remedial actions. Any physician, for whom an 805 report may be required to be filed, is entitled to specified due process rights, including notice of the proposed action, an opportunity for a hearing with full procedural rights (including discovery, examination of witnesses, formal record of the proceedings and written findings). Furthermore, a physician may seek a judicial review in the Superior Court pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.5 (writ of mandate). The due process requirements do not apply to peer review proceedings conducted in state or county hospitals, to the University of California hospitals or to other teaching hospitals as defined.
Recent Events and Allegations of Misconduct. The Legislature has a long history of interest in, and focus on, statutory reporting requirements that are designed to inform health professional licensing boards about their licensees. In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017. At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
Comments
According to the author, “SB 425 closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee.
“Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation.
“State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, this bill will result in unknown, potentially significant costs to the Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS), the Physical Therapy Board, and the Board of Psychology; $1.8 million to the MBC to accept and investigate a projected threefold increase in complaints; $800,000 in projected staff and facility costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs’ Division of Investigations, Investigative Enforcement Unit to investigate a larger number of cases and; costs likely to exceed $2 million to the Department of Justice annually ongoing for additional staff in the Health Quality Enforcement section, which provides legal representation to the MBC.
Board of Chiropractic Examiners
California Acupuncture Board
California Board of Psychology
California Hospital Association
Center for Public Interest Law
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
Speech Language Pathology and Audiology and Hearing Aid Dispensers Board
University of California
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters cite the USC case referenced above in their support of this measure. According to CAOC references the author’s SB 1448 when noting that this bill will “continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust.” Consumer Watchdog cites cases at other universities involving physicians and sexual misconduct, stating that “in each of these cases, the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm’s way…SB 425 will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve.”
According to the California Hospital Association, “Nothing is more important than ensuring that all patients are safe and protected from sexual abuse. California’s hospitals currently report sexual abuse or misconduct to the California Department of Public Health and local law enforcement. There is, however, a gap in the reporting obligation that puts patients at risk. The California Hospital Association (CHA) supports SB 425 (Hill), which would close that gap by creating a new reporting mechanism for any entity that employs or utilizes a broad range of health care providers. We applaud Senator Hill for championing this critically important issue and strengthening California law.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/10/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
9/10/19 23:01:47
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 425
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a health care facility or other entity with an arrangement authorizing a licensed health care provider to provide care, such as a college student health center, to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct, as specified, and makes changes to the disciplinary and enforcement provisions for the Medical Board of California.
Major Provisions
- Requires reporting of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee by a patient, if the patient or the patient's representative makes the allegation in writing, to the relevant licensing agency within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Requires a sexual misconduct report to be kept confidential and specifies that it is not be subject to discovery, except that the information may be reviewed if the source is kept confidential or the report is summarize, and may be disclosed in any subsequent disciplinary hearing conducted pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Makes a willful failure to file a sexual misconduct report punishable by a fine, not to exceed $100,000 per violation, and not to exceed $50,000 for non-willful failures, that must be paid by the health care facility or other entity.
- Provides that a person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity will not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a required report.
- Deletes from the requirement that healing arts boards keep disciplinary reports confidential the term "comprehensive," allowing them to protect the identity of information sources by using summaries of the reports rather than "comprehensive summaries."
- Requires the Medical Board of California to disclose a probationary physician's and surgeon's certificate and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and to post the certificate and statement on the board's internet website for 10 years from issuance.
- Deletes the condition that the failure to attend and participate in an interview by the Medical Board of California must be repeated before constituting unprofessional conduct.
COMMENTS:
Existing law establishes mandatory reporting requirements for purposes of informing regulatory licensing boards of potential consumer harms. The purpose of the requirements is to inform the boards of potential unprofessional conduct, consumer harm, and other cases that might merit disciplinary action. Mandatory reporting helps facilitate the flow of information to boards so that they may investigate potential violations. Boards may have limited resources, and consumers may not know how to file a complaint or are simply hesitant to. Licensees subject to mandatory reporting include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants.
According to the Author:
This bill "closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee. Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation. State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks."
Arguments in Support:
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) writes in support, this bill will "continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust."
Consumer Watchdog writes in support, "the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm's way…[this bill] will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve."
The University of California writes in support, this bill "will clarify reporting obligations across our system. We commend this effort to ensure consumer protection is at the heart of California's licensing laws."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS), the Physical Therapy Board and the Board of Psychology (special funds).
- $1.8 million to the MBC to accept and investigate a projected threefold increase in complaints (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- $800,000 in projected staff and facility costs to DCA Division of Investigations, Investigative Enforcement Unit to investigate a larger number of cases (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- Costs likely to exceed $2 million to the Department of Justice annually ongoing for additional staff in the Health Quality Enforcement section, which provides legal representation to the MBC (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 33-5-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Grove, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 19-0-0
YES: Low, Brough, Arambula, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting
ASM JUDICIARY: 12-0-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0001761
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 425
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a health care facility or other entity with an arrangement authorizing a licensed health care provider to provide care, such as a college student health center, to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct, as specified, and makes changes to the disciplinary and enforcement provisions for the Medical Board of California.
Major Provisions
- Requires reporting of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee by a patient, if the patient or the patient's representative makes the allegation in writing, to the relevant licensing agency within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Requires a sexual misconduct report to be kept confidential and specifies that it is not be subject to discovery, except that the information may be reviewed if the source is kept confidential or the report is summarize, and may be disclosed in any subsequent disciplinary hearing conducted pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Makes a willful failure to file a sexual misconduct report punishable by a fine, not to exceed $100,000 per violation, and not to exceed $50,000 for non-willful failures, that must be paid by the health care facility or other entity.
- Provides that a person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity will not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a required report.
- Deletes from the requirement that healing arts boards keep disciplinary reports confidential the term "comprehensive," allowing them to protect the identity of information sources by using summaries of the reports rather than "comprehensive summaries."
- Requires the Medical Board of California to disclose a probationary physician's and surgeon's certificate and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and to post the certificate and statement on the board's internet website for 10 years from issuance.
- Deletes the condition that the failure to attend and participate in an interview by the Medical Board of California must be repeated before constituting unprofessional conduct.
COMMENTS:
Existing law establishes mandatory reporting requirements for purposes of informing regulatory licensing boards of potential consumer harms. The purpose of the requirements is to inform the boards of potential unprofessional conduct, consumer harm, and other cases that might merit disciplinary action. Mandatory reporting helps facilitate the flow of information to boards so that they may investigate potential violations. Boards may have limited resources, and consumers may not know how to file a complaint or are simply hesitant to. Licensees subject to mandatory reporting include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants.
According to the Author:
This bill "closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee. Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation. State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks."
Arguments in Support:
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) writes in support, this bill will "continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust."
Consumer Watchdog writes in support, "the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm's way…[this bill] will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve."
The University of California writes in support, this bill "will clarify reporting obligations across our system. We commend this effort to ensure consumer protection is at the heart of California's licensing laws."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS), the Physical Therapy Board and the Board of Psychology (special funds).
- $1.8 million to the MBC to accept and investigate a projected threefold increase in complaints (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- $800,000 in projected staff and facility costs to DCA Division of Investigations, Investigative Enforcement Unit to investigate a larger number of cases (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- Costs likely to exceed $2 million to the Department of Justice annually ongoing for additional staff in the Health Quality Enforcement section, which provides legal representation to the MBC (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 33-5-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Grove, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 19-0-0
YES: Low, Brough, Arambula, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting
ASM JUDICIARY: 12-0-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 27, 2019
CONSULTANT: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0001599
Date of Hearing: August 21, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 425
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 19 - 0 |
Judiciary | 12 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires health facilities, including hospitals and clinics, and other entities, including college student health centers, to report to healing arts licensing boards such as the Medical Board of California (MBC) any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct within 15 days of receiving a written allegation of such conduct by a healing arts licensee. It also:
- It also imposes the following maximum fines on a facility, to be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding brought by, or on behalf of, any agency having regulatory jurisdiction over the licensee regarding whom the report was filed:
- For willful failure to report, a fine of up to $100,000.
- For other failure to report, a fine of up to $50,000.
- Requires the MBC to disclose information about a doctor’s probationary status to an inquiring member of the public and the bill requires the board to post the information about the probation on its internet website for ten years.
- Makes failure to attend or participate in a board interview without good cause unprofessional conduct.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS), the Physical Therapy Board and the Board of Psychology (special funds).
- $1.8 million to the MBC to accept and investigate a projected threefold increase in complaints (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- $800,000 in projected staff and facility costs to DCA Division of Investigations, Investigative Enforcement Unit to investigate a larger number of cases (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- Costs likely to exceed $2 million to the Department of Justice annually ongoing for additional staff in the Health Quality Enforcement section, which provides legal representation to the MBC (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is responsive to increased reports of sexual assault and misconduct of health care providers. It intends to ensure reports of sexual assault or misconduct are made to healing arts boards that oversee license professionals. Specifically, this bill respond to recent and troubling revelations about nearly three decades of allegations of sexual assault against a single gynecologist at the USC student health center.
- Background. Exciting law requires a health care facility or clinic to report physician or surgeon to the medical board under two situations, both of which require the actions of an internal “peer review body” – that is, a designated group of other medical and professional staff at the facility or clinic.
First, the chief of staff and the executive administrator of a health care facility or clinic must file a report if, as a result of an actions of a peer review body, the licensed health care provider’s staff privileges are denied, revoked or otherwise restricted, or the provider’s employment is terminated, for a medical disciplinary reason. Second, a reporting requirement is triggered if the peer review body determines a licensed health care provider was incompetent (exhibiting gross deviation from professional standards), inappropriate or excessively prescribed dangerous or controlled substances to themselves or others or engaged in sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination. These requirements do not apply to student health care centers.
This bill would create an additional trigger by requiring a health care facility or any other entity, including a student health care center that arranges for the provisions of medical care by licensed health care providers, to report allegations or sexual misconduct within 15 days of receiving a written allegation of sexual misconduct against a provider. Existing law requires a report to be made 15 days of an action or determination by the peer review body, but there is no specified time frame for when the peer review body must take its action or make its determination. This bill requires the appropriate licensing board to be alerted once a written allegation is made.
- Support. The bill is supported by consumer groups, the major medical boards, the California Hospital Association and the University of California. Although the bill was originally opposed by the California Medical Association and other health care professional associations, the author has taken amendments in prior committees that appear to have removed all opposition.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 425
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 33-5
SUBJECT: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
KEY ISSUE: Should a licensed health care facility, including a college student health center, be required to report allegations of sexual misconduct made against a licensed health care provider to the appropriate licensing board, within 15 days of receiving a written allegation?
SYNOPSIS
SB 425 is one of two bills to come before the Committee this year that respond to recent and troubling revelations about nearly three decades of allegations of sexual assault against a single gynecologist at the USC student health center. (AB 1510, by Committee Member Reyes, would create a one-year window to revive otherwise time-barred claims.) Not only did USC allow the doctor to continue examining young women, despite multiple allegations, it did not report the doctor to the California Medical Board until 2016. Existing law requires the executive officers of licensed health care facilities and clinics to file so-called “805 reports” with the medical board whenever (1) a licensed health care provider loses staff privileges or employment for a medical disciplinary reason, or (2) when the facility’s peer review body makes a determination that a licensed health care provider is incompetent or has engaged in misconduct, including sexual misconduct. A failure to make these required reports results in a fine of $100,000 per violation for a willful failure to report, and up to $50,000 per violation for all other failures to report. Because the licensing provisions for “health care facilities” and “clinics,” as defined and provided for in the Health & Safety Code, apparently exempt student health centers operated by a university, USC was arguably exempt from the 805 reporting requirements. SB 425 would make two important changes to existing reporting laws. First, the bill imposes reporting requirements upon licensed health care facilities and “other entities,” which is defined to expressly include postsecondary institutions. Second, whereas existing law requires facilities and clinics to report sexual misconduct to the medical board after a determination by an internal “peer review body,” SB 425 will require a report within 15 days of receipt of a written allegation of sexual misconduct. In addition, the bill makes other changes related to the board’s disciplinary powers and disclosure requirements. Although the bill was originally opposed by the California Medical Association and other health care professional associations, the author has taken many amendments in prior committees that appear to have removed all opposition. The bill is supported by consumer groups, the major medical boards, the California Hospital Association, and the University of California.
SUMMARY: Requires health care facilities and related entities to report allegations of sexual misconduct against health care providers to the relevant medical board, and makes other changes to disciplinary and enforcement powers of the boards. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a health care facility or other entity, including a postsecondary institution that makes arrangements under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients, to report any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made by a patient against the licensee, if the patient or the patient’s representative makes the allegation in writing. Specifies that the report shall be made to the relevant agency within 15 days of receipt of the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct. Requires the agency that receives the report to investigate the circumstances underlying the report.
- Specifies that the report required by this bill shall be kept confidential and shall not be subject to discovery, except as specified.
- Provides that the willful failure to file a report is punishable by a fine not to exceed $100,000 per violation, while a non-willful failure to file a report is punishably by a fine not to exceed $50,000.
- Provides that no person shall incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a report required by this bill.
- Requires the Medical Board to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate and the operative statement of issues relating to the probation to an inquiring member of the public and shall post the certificate and statement on the board’s internet website for ten years from issuance.
- Provides that, in the absence of good cause, the failure of a licensee under investigation to attend and participate in an interview by the Medical Board constitutes professional misconduct.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates the practice of medicine under the Medical Practice Act and establishes the Medical Board of California for the licensure, regulation, and discipline of physicians and surgeons. (Business & Professions Code Sections 2000-2525.5.)
- Establishes various medical licensing boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs that provide for the licensing and regulation of health care providers and authorizes the licensing boards to deny, suspend, or revoke a license in cases of professional misconduct, including sexual misconduct. (Business & Professions Code Sections 500 et seq., and Sections 725-733.)
- Requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility or clinic to file a report with the relevant licensing board within 15 days after a peer review body denies, revokes, or terminates the staff privileges or employment of a licensed health care provider for a medical disciplinary reason. Specifies that no person shall incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a required report. (Business & Professions Code Section 805.)
- Requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility or clinic to file a report with the relevant licensing board within 15 days after a peer review body makes a determination that a licensed health care provider is incompetent, has abused the power to prescribe or administer controlled substances, or has engaged in sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination. (Business & Professions Code Section 805.01.)
- Provides that the willful failure to file a report as described in 3) and 4) above is punishable by a fine not to exceed $100,000 per violation, while a non-willful failure to file a report is punishably by a fine not to exceed $50,000. (Business & Professions Code Sections 805 (k)-(l), 805.01 (g)-(h).)
- Requires the state’s medical licensing boards to create and maintain a central file of the names of, and disciplinary information about, all persons who hold a license or certificate from the board. Provides that information pertaining to disciplinary action against a licensee is subject to public disclosure; however, certain confidential information may only be disclosed to the relevant licensing agency, the licensee, and the licensee’s counsel or legal representative, as specified. (Business & Professions Code Sections 800, 803.1, 805.1 and 805.5.)
- Provides that repeated failure by a licensed physician or surgeon, in the absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by the Medical Board constitutes unprofessional conduct. (Business & Professions Code Section 2234(g).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: SB 425 is one of two bills to come before the Committee this year that respond to recent and troubling revelations about nearly three decades of allegations of sexual assault against a single gynecologist at the USC student health center. (AB 1510 (Reyes) would create a one-year window to revive claims alleging that a sexual assault occurred at a student health center.) Not only did USC allow the doctor to continue examining and treating young women at the student health center – despite multiple allegations and reports over the years – it apparently did not report the doctor to the California Medical Board until 2016.
Although USC may have had a moral obligation to report the doctor’s egregious conduct to the medical board for appropriate disciplinary action, it is not entirely clear that the university had statutory duty to do so. Existing law requires the executive officers of licensed health care facilities and clinics to file so-called “805 reports” with the medical board whenever (1) a licensed health care provider loses staff privileges or employment for a disciplinary cause or (2) when the facility’s peer review body makes a determination that a licensed health care provider is incompetent or has engaged in misconduct, including sexual misconduct. A failure to make these required reports results in a fine of $100,000 per violation for a willful failure to report, and up to $50,000 per violation for all other failures to report. However, the licensing provisions for “health care facilities” and “clinics,” as defined and provided for in the Health & Safety Code, exempt “student health centers operated by public institutions of higher education” [Health & Safety Code Section 1206(j).] Even though USC is not a “public” institution of higher education, like other student health centers it is not licensed as a “health care facility” or a “clinic” under the Health & Safety Code and, therefore, not subject to reporting requirements in the Business & Professions Code. Moreover, student health care centers – unlike health care facilities and clinics licensed under the Health & Safety Code – do not have “peer review” bodies that make determinations about misconduct. At any rate, had the law clearly and unequivocally required student health centers like the one at USC to report misconduct, an unknown number of young women might have been spared the harm and humiliation of being sexually assaulted by someone they had trusted to provide them with medical care.
To ensure that future allegations of sexual misconduct by medical professionals are promptly reported to the relevant licensing board, no matter where the misconduct occurs, SB 425 will make two important changes to existing reporting laws. First, the bill imposes reporting requirements upon a licensed health care facility or “other entity” that makes arrangements for licensed health care providers to practice or provide care to patients. Second, whereas existing law requires facilities and clinics to report sexual misconduct to the medical board after a determination by an internal “peer review body,” SB 425 will require a report within 15 days of receipt of a written allegation of sexual misconduct. In addition, the bill makes other changes related to the board’s disciplinary powers and disclosure requirements.
What Triggers a Report: From Peer Review Determination to Written Allegation: In addition to expressly applying reporting requirements to a health care center operated by a college or university, SB 425 makes a substantial change as to what will trigger a report. Existing law requires a health care facility or clinic to report a physician or surgeon to the medical board under two situations, both of which require the actions of an internal “peer review body” – that is, a designated group of other medical and professional staff at the facility or clinic. First, the chief of staff and the executive administrator of a health care facility or clinic must file a report if, as a result of an action of a peer review body, the licensed health care provider’s staff privileges are denied, revoked, or otherwise restricted, or the provider’s employment is terminated, for a medical disciplinary reason. (Business & Professions Code Section 805.) Second, a reporting requirement is triggered if the peer review body determines that a licensed health care provider was incompetent (exhibiting gross deviation from professional standards), inappropriate or excessively prescribed dangerous or controlled substances to themselves or others, or engaged in sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination. (Business & Professions Code Section 805.01.)
This bill would not replace these provisions of existing law or displace the work of peer review bodies; however, it would create an additional trigger by requiring a health care facility or any other entity, including a student health care center that arranges for the provision of medical care by licensed health care providers, to report allegations of sexual misconduct within 15 days of receiving a written allegation of sexual misconduct by a patient (or the patient’s representative) against a licensed health care provider. Existing law requires a report to be made within 15 days of an action or determination by the peer review body, but there is no specified time frame for when the peer review body must take its action or make its determination. SB 425 will ensure that, once a written allegation is made, the appropriate licensing board will be alerted and take appropriate steps. This is especially critical in the case of student health centers, which do not necessarily have peer review bodies.
The California Medical Association and professional medical associations opposed earlier versions of this bill because it feared that the bill eliminated the preliminary role of the peer review body and therefore might lead to unsubstantiated allegations, or even “rumors” of misconduct, inefficiently and prematurely triggering a report to the licensing reports. However, the author has taken amendments addressing concerns about reporting mere “rumors” of sexual misconduct by requiring that the allegation be in writing. Earlier concerns about licensing boards being “burdened” by a flood of unsubstantiated allegations is muted by the fact that the state’s major licensing boards support this bill.
Modest Changes in Disclosure and Enforcement Provisions: While SB 425 clearly extends reporting requirements to student health centers and creates an additional, more prompt, reporting requirement when there is a written allegation of sexual misconduct, in most other ways, the bill either tracks existing reporting requirements or makes modest improvements. For example, a willful failure to report is punishable by a fine not to exceed $100,000, while all other failures to report are punishable by a fine not to exceed $50,000, which is identical to the existing penalties for failure to make an “805” report. Similar to existing law, SB 425 generally makes the reports confidential, but allows review of the information in the manner provided in existing law. Finally, consistent with existing law, SB 425 provides that a person shall not incur civil or criminal liability for filing a report as required by this bill, which is true for persons who file “805” reports under existing law. However, SB 425 makes modest changes in disclosure and enforcement provisions. First, the bill requires the medical board to disclose information about a doctor’s probationary status to an inquiring member of the public and the bill requires the board to post the information about the probation on its internet website for ten years. In addition, SB 425 will enhance a licensing board’s ability to investigate licensees by providing that failure to attend or participate in a board interview, without good cause, constitutes unprofessional conduct. (Existing law only makes “repeated” failure to attend or participate unprofessional misconduct.)
In short, SB 425 appropriately builds upon familiar and long-standing reporting requirements, while at the same time ensuring that these requirements apply to all clinics and health care facilities and making sure that allegations of sexual assault reach the relevant licensing board in a more certain and timely manner than they do under the existing peer review process. Had SB 425 been in place thirty years ago, the USC doctor who assaulted an unknown number of unsuspecting students, over a nearly thirty year period, might have been properly booted from the profession after the first allegation was made against him.
Arguments in Support: According to the California Board of Psychology, SB 425 “adds a critical reporting tool to ensure that when written allegations of sexual misconduct with a patient are made against a licensee at a licensed health facility, it is also reported to the Board for investigation and potential discipline. This new reporting requirement is similar to reports currently required under Business and Professions Code Section 805, but with the added safeguard that adverse action against the healing arts licensee’s privileges does not have to occur before the health facility/peer review body reports the allegations to the Board. The Board of Psychology believes that the additional sexual misconduct reporting requirements in SB 425 (Hill) is not only warranted but is long overdue.”
The Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) that SB 425 “aims to close legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified.” CAOC adds that last year Governor Brown signed SB 1448, which required doctors and other professional to notify patients if they are placed on probation in cases of sexual misconduct. CAOC believes that “SB 425 will continue this important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Acupuncture Board
California Chiropractic Examiners Board
California Psychology Board
California Hospital Association
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
University Of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 425
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 17, 2019
NOTE: This bill is double referred and, if passed by this Committee, will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
SENATE VOTE: 33-5
SUBJECT: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
SUMMARY: Requires a health care facilities or other entity with an arrangement authorizing a licensed health care provider to provide care to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct made against a licensed health care professional by a patient, if the patient makes the allegation in writing, to the licensee’s licensing board, within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct; specifies various penalties for failure to report; and makes changes to the disciplinary and enforcement provisions for the Medical Board of California.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes various practice acts that license and regulate health care professionals, which are administered by various boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), which provide for the. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 500-4999.129 )
- Specifies various acts that constitute unprofessional conduct and grounds for disciplinary action for licensed health care professionals, including sexual abuse, misconduct, or relations with a patient, client, or customer. (BPC §§ 725-733)
- Establishes various reporting and record keeping requirements related to the practice of licensed healthcare providers for purposes of consumer protection. (BPC §§ 800-809.9)
- Requires healing arts boards to create and maintain a central file of the names of all persons who hold a license or similar authority from a board confidentially containing an individual historical record for each licensee including, among other things, disciplinary information. (BPC § 800)
- Specifies that the contents of a central file that are not public records must remain confidential, except that the licensee involved, or their counsel or representative, have the right to inspect and have copies made of the licensee’s complete file, other than provisions that could potentially disclose the identity of an information source. A board is authorized to protect an information source by redacting the source’s identifying information or providing a comprehensive summary of the material. (BPC § 800(c)
- Defines “805 report” as a written report required to be submitted following certain actions of a peer review body, as specified. (805(a)(7))
- Defines “peer review body” as specified multi-member bodies that review the basic qualifications, staff privileges, employment, medical outcomes, or professional conduct of licentiates to make recommendations for quality improvement and education, as specified. (BPC § 805(a))
- Requires a peer review body and a licensed health care facility or clinic to file an “805 report” with the relevant agency within 15 days after the effective date on which specified disciplinary actions occur as a result of an action of a peer review body. (BPC § 805(b))
- Makes a willful failure to file an “805 report” punishable by a fine of $100,000 per violation, and any other failure is punishable by a fine of $50,000. (BPC § 805(k) & (l))
- Requires a licensed health care facility to file a separate report with the relevant state agency within 15 days after a peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action against a licensee that must be reported as an “805 report,” if the peer review body determines, following a formal investigation, that specified acts occurred, including, sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination. (BPC § 805.01(b))
- Makes a willful failure to make the separate report punishable by a fine of $100,000 per violation, and any other failure is punishable by a fine of $50,000. (BPC § 805.01(g) & (h))
- Regulates the practice of medicine under the Medical Practice Act and establishes the Medical Board of California for the licensure, regulation, and discipline of physicians and surgeons. (BPC §§ 2000-2525.5)
- Authorizes the Board to deny a physician’s and surgeon’s certificate to an applicant guilty of unprofessional conduct or of any cause that would subject a licensee to revocation or suspension of their license and authorizes the Board in its sole discretion to issue a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate to an applicant subject to terms and conditions. (BPC § 2221)
- Requires the Board to take action against any licensee who is charged with unprofessional conduct and provides that unprofessional conduct includes the repeated failure by a certificate holder who is the subject of an investigation by the Board, in the absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by the Board. (BPC § 2234)
THIS BILL:
- Defines “agency” as the relevant state licensing agency with regulatory jurisdiction over healing arts licensees.
- Defines “healing arts licensee” or “licensee” as a licensee licensed by a healing arts board under the BPC or a person authorized to practice medicine as a medical school graduate or medical school faculty, as specified.
- Defines “health care facility” as a clinic or health facility licensed or exempt from licensure, as specified.
- Defines “other entity” as including a postsecondary educational institution, as defined.
- Defines “sexual misconduct” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature.
- Defines “willful” as a voluntary and intentional violation of a known legal duty.
- Requires a health care facility or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients to file a report of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee by a patient, if the patient or the patient’s representative makes the allegation in writing, to the agency within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Specifies that an arrangement under which a licensee is allowed to practice or provide care for patients includes, but is not limited to, full staff privileges, active staff privileges, limited staff privileges, auxiliary staff privileges, provisional staff privileges, temporary staff privileges, courtesy staff privileges, locum tenens arrangements, and contractual arrangements to provide professional services, including, but not limited to, arrangements to provide outpatient services.
- Requires a sexual misconduct report to be kept confidential and specifies that it is not be subject to discovery, except that the information may be reviewed if the source is kept confidential or the report is summarize, and may be disclosed in any subsequent disciplinary hearing conducted pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Makes a willful failure to file a sexual misconduct report punishable by a fine, not to exceed $100,000 per violation, and not to exceed $50,000 for non-willful failures, that must be paid by the health care facility or other entity.
- Specifies that non-willful failures to report must be proportional to the severity of the failure to report and must differ based upon written findings, including:
- Whether the failure to file caused harm to a patient or created a risk to patient safety;
- Whether any person who is designated or otherwise required by law to file the report required under this section exercised due diligence despite the failure to file or whether the person knew or should have known that a required report would not be filed;
- Whether there had been a prior failure to file a required report;
- Whether a report was filed with another state agency or law enforcement; and
- Whether a health care facility is a small or rural hospital, as defined.
- Specifies that the fine may be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding brought by or on behalf of any agency having regulatory jurisdiction over the licensee regarding whom the report was or should have been filed as follows:
- If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report under this section is a licensed physician and surgeon, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Medical Board of California.
- If the person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report required under this section is a licensed doctor of podiatric medicine, the action or proceeding shall be brought by the Podiatric Medical Board of California.
- The fine shall be paid to that agency, but not expended until appropriated by the Legislature.
- Specifies that a violation of the sexual misconduct reporting requirement may constitute unprofessional conduct by a licensee, and allows a person who is alleged to have violated the assert any defense available at law.
- Provides that a person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity will not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a required report if made in good faith.
- Requires the agency receiving a sexual misconduct report required under this bill to investigate the circumstances underlying the report.
- Deletes from the requirement that healing arts boards keep disciplinary reports confidential the term “comprehensive,” allowing them to protect the identity of information sources by using summaries of the reports rather than “comprehensive summaries.”
- Requires the Medical Board of California to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and to post the certificate and statement on the board’s internet website for 10 years from issuance.
- Deletes the condition that the failure to attend and participate in an interview by the Medical Board of California must be repeated before constituting unprofessional conduct.
- Deletes an obsolete provision and makes other conforming and non-substantive changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- No impact to the Department of Justice.
- No or minimal costs to significant costs (low millions, special fund) across the various Boards and Bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs.
- The following healing arts boards identified minimal or no fiscal impact:
- Optometry: No Impact
- Physicians Assistants: No Impact
- Occupational Therapy: Minimal
- Dental Board: No Impact
- Dental Assistants: No Impact
- Veterinary Medicine: No Impact
- Speech/Hearing: Minor and absorbable. No significant increase in complaints expected.
- Chiro: Minor and absorbable.
- Registered Nursing: Minor and absorbable. Anticipates a 1% increase in sexual abuse complaints, which is absorbable at this time.
- Voc Nurse/Psych Tech: Minor and absorbable.
- The following healing arts boards identified a fiscal impact. However, the increase to workload is undetermined or not quantifiable:
- Behavioral Science: Potential significant increase in complaints. Could be absorbable but may need additional resources if the increase is greater than anticipated.
- Physical Therapy: Increase in enforcement costs and may require additional staff (Board staff, expert witnesses, investigators) if sexual misconduct complaints increase.
- Psychology: Unknown impact. Based on current reporting, impact would be minor and absorbable, based on the assumption that the licensee and the facility would both file a complaint, and therefore the two complaints would be worked as one.
- Both the Medical Board of California and the Division of Investigations (DOI)/Investigative Enforcement Unit (IEU) reported a significant increase in workload that cannot be absorbed within existing resources and will require additional staffing and funds as a result of this bill.
- $3.8 million and 12.5 positions for the Medical Board.
- $811,000 and 4.0 Investigators and 1.0 AGPA.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author, this bill “closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee. Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation. State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks.”
Background. Existing law establishes mandatory reporting requirements for purposes of informing regulatory licensing boards of potential consumer harms. The purpose of the requirements is to inform the boards of potential unprofessional conduct, consumer harm, and other cases that might merit disciplinary action. Mandatory reporting helps facilitate the flow of information to boards so that they may investigate potential violations. Boards may have limited resources, and consumers may not know how to file a complaint or are simply hesitant to.
Licensees subject to mandatory reporting include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants.
Types of Mandatory Reporting. There are two types of reporting requirements similar to what would be required under this bill, (1) a report based on provider practice restrictions or changes and (2) a report based on specific acts. Both are separate reports that must be made by health facilities to a licensing agency and are triggered during a process called “peer review.”
Peer review is a process by which a body of health care practitioners evaluate their colleagues' work to determine compliance with the standard of care. Peer review aims to protect patients from incompetent or unprofessional practitioners. It can be proactive or reactive. In general, peer review is triggered by behavior that suggests patients or coworkers may be at risk, including patient injury, disruptive conduct, substance abuse, or other medical staff complaints. Once a complaint is received, a peer review committee investigates the allegation, comes to a decision regarding the licensee's conduct, makes a recommendation, and, if necessary, takes remedial actions.
The practice restriction report, called an “805 report,” is triggered when, based on the medical disciplinary findings of a peer review body, a licensee’s application for staff privileges or membership is denied, the licensee’s staff privileges or employment are terminated or revoked, or the licensee’s staff privileges, membership, or employment are mandatorily or voluntarily restricted for 30-days or more for any 12-month period.
The specific acts report is triggered when a peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action if, after a formal investigation, the peer review body determines that any of the following may have occurred:
- Incompetence, or gross or repeated deviation from the standard of care involving death or serious bodily injury to one or more patients in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to any person or the public;
- The use of, or prescribing for or administering to him/herself, any controlled substance; or the use of any dangerous drug, or of alcoholic beverages, to the extend or in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to the licentiate, or any other persons, or the public, or to the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licentiate to practice safely;
- Repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, furnishing or administering of controlled substances or repeated acts of prescribing, dispensing, or furnishing of controlled substances without a good faith effort prior examination of the patient and medical reason therefor; or
- Sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination.
This bill would establish a reporting requirement similar to those two. It also mirrors the 15-day timeline, the $50,000-$100,000 penalties. The difference would be the trigger. Under this bill, the required reports would be triggered upon receipt of a written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct instead of actions by a peer review body.
Contracting Entities. In 2018, the L.A. Times published a report on an investigation into allegations of sexual abuse by Dr. George Tyndall, who worked as a gynecologist for over 30 years at USC’s student health facility. USC has agreed to pay $215 million to former patients in a proposed settlement.
The student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as an employment matter and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. The Medical Board of California was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the existing mandatory reporting requirements.
In light of cases like this, this bill seeks to include schools and other entities that contract with healthcare providers but are not technically health facilities.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) writes in support, this bill will “continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust.”
Consumer Watchdog writes in support, “the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm’s way…[this bill] will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve.”
The University of California writes in support, this bill “will clarify reporting obligations across our system. We commend this effort to ensure consumer protection is at the heart of California’s licensing laws.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file
AMENDMENTS:
- Because the reports required under this bill have been amended to only include mandatory reports, the author should amend the bill to delete the condition that the reports be made in “good faith”:
Page 8, lines 1-2, delete “section if made in good faith.” and insert “section.”:
(f) A person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health care facility, or other entity shall not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a report required by this section if made in good faith. section.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
Board of Chiropractic Examiners
Board of Psychology
California Acupuncture Board
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
University of California
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 425 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 425
Amended: 5/21/19
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/8/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
DIGEST:
This bill requires every health care facility in the state, health care service plans, or other entities with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional to provide care for patients (such as postsecondary educational institutions), to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct made against a licensed health care professional by a patient, if the patient makes the allegation in writing, to the licensee’s licensing board, within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct; and makes other changes related Medical Board of California (MBC) disciplinary action and enforcement.
Existing law:
- Establishes a number of reporting requirements outlined in the Business and Professions Code designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation.
- Requires, beginning July 1, 2019, certain licensed health care professionals (physicians and surgeons, osteopathic physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, acupuncturists, chiropractors, and naturopathic doctors) to notify patients of their probationary status. For physicians and surgeons licensed by the MBC and Osteopathic Medical Board (OMBC), requires that probationary status be disclosed if there is a final adjudication by MBC or OMBC following an administrative hearing, or admitted findings or prima facie showing in a stipulated settlement establishing certain violations of the law, including the commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct or relations with a patient or client. (BPC § 2228.1)
- Authorizes an interim order suspending (ISO) a license for MBC licensees if the affidavits show that the licensee has engaged in, or is about to engage in, acts or omissions constituting a violation of the Medical Practice Act, or is unable to practice safely due to a mental or physical condition, and that permitting the licensee to continue to engage in the profession for which the license was issued will endanger the public health, safety, or welfare. (Government Code § 11529)
This bill:
- Requires a health care facility, the administrator or chief executive officer of a health care service plan, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a licensed health care professional is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients (including but not limited to a private postsecondary educational institution), to file a report of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct (defined as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature) made against a licensed health care professional by a patient, if the patient makes the allegation in writing, to the licensee’s licensing board, within 15 days of receiving the written allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Specifies that any failure to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $50,000 per violation, paid by the health care facility or other entity required to report. Specifies that a willful failure (a voluntary and intentional violation of a known legal duty) to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $100,000 per violation. States that a person is immune from any civil or criminal liability for reporting the alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Authorizes MBC, upon receipt of information that the public health, safety, or welfare requires emergency action, to place a physician’s and surgeon’s license on suspension pending formal proceedings. Specifies that this emergency order of suspension shall be issued to the licensee informing the licensee of the facts or conduct warranting the emergency suspension, pending an investigation. Authorizes a licensee whose license has been suspended on emergency order to request a hearing for an ISO, which must be held within 180 days licensee’s request.
- Requires, when issuing a probationary license, the record relating to that probationary license to remain on MBC’s Web site for 10 years.
- Specifies that failure of a licensee (as opposed to repeated failure under current law), absent good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by MBC is unprofessional conduct.
Background
Mandatory Reporting of Health Practitioner Discipline. There are a number of reporting requirements designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation, including BPC Section 805 which requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report when a licensee’s application for staff privileges or membership is denied, or the licensee’s staff privileges or employment are terminated or revoked for a medical disciplinary cause. Licensees include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants. The reporting entities are also required to file a report when restrictions are imposed or voluntarily accepted on the licensee’s staff privileges for a cumulative total of 30 days or more for any 12-month period. The report must be filed within 15 days after the effective date of the action taken by a health facility peer review body.
BPC Section 805.01 is a similarly extremely important requirement. The law requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report within 15 days after the peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action which must be reported pursuant to section 805. This reporting requirement is only required if the recommended action is taken for incompetence, or gross or repeated deviation from the standard of care involving death or serious bodily injury to one or more patients in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to any person or the public; the use of, or prescribing for or administering to him/herself, any controlled substance; or the use of any dangerous drug, or of alcoholic beverages, to the extend or in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to the licentiate, or any other persons, or the public, or to the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licentiate to practice safely; repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, furnishing or administering of controlled substances or repeated acts of prescribing, dispensing, or furnishing of controlled substances without a good faith effort prior examination of the patient and medical reason therefor and; sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination.
The purpose of 805 reports is to provide licensing boards with early information about these serious charges so that they may investigate and take appropriate action to further consumer protection at the earliest possible moment. Accordingly, for any allegations listed above, the Legislature determined that an 805.01 report must be filed once a formal investigation has been completed, and a final decision or recommendation regarding the disciplinary action to be taken against a licensee has been determined by the peer review body, even when the licensee has not yet been afforded a hearing to contest those findings.
Peer Review. In peer review, health care practitioners evaluate their colleagues' work to determine compliance with the standard of care. Peer reviews are intended to detect incompetent or unprofessional practitioners early and terminate, suspend, or limit their practice if necessary. Peer review is triggered by a wide variety of events including patient injury, disruptive conduct, substance abuse, or other medical staff complaints. A peer review committee investigates the allegation, comes to a decision regarding the licensee's conduct, and takes appropriate remedial actions. Any physician, for whom an 805 report may be required to be filed, is entitled to specified due process rights, including notice of the proposed action, an opportunity for a hearing with full procedural rights (including discovery, examination of witnesses, formal record of the proceedings and written findings). Furthermore, a physician may seek a judicial review in the Superior Court pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.5 (writ of mandate). The due process requirements do not apply to peer review proceedings conducted in state or county hospitals, to the University of California hospitals or to other teaching hospitals as defined.
Recent Events and Allegations of Misconduct. The Legislature has a long history of interest in, and focus on, statutory reporting requirements that are designed to inform health professional licensing boards about their licensees. In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017. At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
Medical Board Enforcement Enhancement Provisions Contained In This Bill. The sexual abuse and sexual misconduct allegation reporting requirements in this bill apply broadly to health care professionals licensed by a number of boards within the DCA. Four specific provisions in the bill are aimed at increasing the ability of MBC to take timely enforcement action, three of which were approved as legislative proposals at a 2018 board meeting.
One provision, providing MBC authority to issue an emergency order of license suspension pending formal proceedings, and requiring a hearing on an ISO to be held, if requested by the licensee, within 180 days related to issuance of an emergency order, was not approved by MBC.
Comments
According to the author, “SB 425 closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee.
Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation.
State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, this bill will result in minor and absorbable costs for many licensing boards that could receive reports as a result of the measure and a significant increase in workload for MBC and the Division of Investigations, specifically $3.8 million for MBC.
California Board of Psychology
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/20/19)
California Chapter of the American College of Cardiology
California Medical Association
California Society of Plastic Surgeons
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The MBC supports three provisions in the bill related to MBC enforcement which it believes will help to prevent delays in the Board’s enforcement process, which “negatively impact the Board’s enforcement timelines” and which will increase transparency by providing access to information that is public, but not available on MBC’s Web site after a probationary period is complete. MBC’s position does not reference provisions related to receiving reports about sexual abuse and misconduct allegations involving a MBC licensee, nor does MBC have a position on provisions related to ISOs.
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) and Consumer Watchdog cite the USC case referenced above in their support of this measure. According to CAOC references the author’s SB 1448 when noting that this bill will “continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust.” Consumer Watchdog cites cases at other universities involving physicians and sexual misconduct, stating that “in each of these cases, the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm’s way…SB 425 will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents state that this bill completely bypasses the peer review process put in place for hospitals by requiring every healing arts licensee working within a hospital to report any complaint of sexual misconduct or allegation of sexual misconduct to the appropriate licensing board within 15 days, and are asking that this provision to be deleted from the bill. According to the opponents, “While we appreciate the procedural steps that the Medical Board must take to file a complaint, and the need to remove dangerous licensees from practice expediently, we do not believe this large jump from 30 to 180 days is warranted”, in reference to the provisions of the bill authorizing an MBC license to be suspended for 180 days before MBC files a formal accusation. Opponents are also concerned about unprofessional conduct being levied against
MBC licensees for “repeated failures” to respond to a request for interview and note that repeated needs to be defined.
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
5/21/19 17:49:37
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 425 (Hill) - Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
Version: April 30, 2019 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 9 - 0, JUD. 7 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
Senate Bill 425 would require every health facility in the state, health plan, or other entity with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional, including a postsecondary educational institution, to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by a licensed health care practitioner to that practitioner’s licensing board within 15 days, and imposes a fine for failure to report. Would require the Medical Board of California (MBC) to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate issued by it and the operative statement of issue to an inquiring member of the public and on the MBC’s website, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- No impact to the Department of Justice.
- No or minimal costs to significant costs (low millions, special fund) across the various Boards and Bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs.
The following healing arts boards identified minimal or no fiscal impact:
Board | Impact |
Optometry | No Impact |
Physicians Assistants | No Impact |
Occupational Therapy | Minimal |
Dental Board | No Impact |
Dental Assistants | No Impact |
Veterinary Medicine | No Impact |
Speech/Hearing | Minor and absorbable. No significant increase in complaints expected. |
Chiro | Minor and absorbable. |
Registered Nursing | Minor and absorbable. Anticipates a 1% increase in sexual abuse complaints, which is absorbable at this time. |
Voc Nurse/Psych Tech | Minor and absorbable. |
The following healing arts boards identified a fiscal impact. However, the increase to workload is undetermined or not quantifiable:
Board | Impact |
Behavioral Science | Potential significant increase in complaints. Could be absorbable but may need additional resources if the increase is greater than anticipated. |
Physical Therapy | Increase in enforcement costs and may require additional staff (Board staff, expert witnesses, investigators) if sexual misconduct complaints increase. |
Psychology | Unknown impact. Based on current reporting, impact would be minor and absorbable, based on the assumption that the licensee and the facility would both file a complaint, and therefore the two complaints would be worked as one. |
Both the Medical Board of California and the Division of Investigations (DOI)/Investigative Enforcement Unit (IEU) reported a significant increase in workload that cannot be absorbed within existing resources and will require additional staffing and funds as a result of this bill.
- $3.8 million and 12.5 positions for the Medical Board.
- $811,000 and 4.0 Investigators and 1.0 AGPA.
Author Amendments:
The author amendments would:
- Define the term “health care facility” to mean a clinic or health facility licensed or exempt from licensure, as specified in existing law (Health and Safety Code §1200 et. seq.).
- Clarify the patient must make the allegation of any sexual abuse or sexual misconduct in writing, for the health care facility or other entity, as specified, to be required to file a report, within 15 days or receiving the written allegation by the patient.
- Require the health care facility or other specified entity pay the violation fine associated with the willful failure to file the report.
Committee Amendments:
The committee amendments would:
- Define “sexual misconduct” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature.
- Remove the proposed provisions requiring an employee, who has knowledge of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct by a licensee, to file a report with the regulatory agency and administration of the health care facility or clinic within 15 days of knowing of the allegation.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 425 (Hill) - Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct.
Version: April 30, 2019 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 9 - 0, JUD. 7 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
Senate Bill 425 would require every health facility in the state, health plan, or other entity with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional, including a postsecondary educational institution, to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by a licensed health care practitioner to that practitioner’s licensing board within 15 days, and imposes a fine for failure to report. Would require the Medical Board of California (MBC) to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate issued by it and the operative statement of issue to an inquiring member of the public and on the MBC’s website, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- No impact to the Department of Justice.
- No or minimal costs to significant costs (low millions, special fund) across the various Boards and Bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs.
The following healing arts boards identified minimal or no fiscal impact:
Board | Impact |
Optometry | No Impact |
Physicians Assistants | No Impact |
Occupational Therapy | Minimal |
Dental Board | No Impact |
Dental Assistants | No Impact |
Veterinary Medicine | No Impact |
Speech/Hearing | Minor and absorbable. The Board does not anticipate a significant increase in complaints as a result of this bill. |
Chiro | Minor and absorbable. The Board does not anticipate a significant increase in workload as a result of this bill. |
Registered Nursing | Minor and absorbable. The Board anticipates a 1% increase in sexual abuse complaints, which at this time is absorbable. |
Voc Nurse/Psych Tech | Minor and absorbable. The Board cannot quantify the impact, however feels the potential would be minor and can absorb within existing resources. |
The following healing arts boards identified a fiscal impact. However, the increase to workload is undetermined or not quantifiable:
Board | Impact |
Behavioral Science | The Board feels this bill makes a significant change and could cause a significant increase in complaints. However, the Board states the increase could be minimal enough to absorb, with the opportunity to ask for additional resources should the increase prove to be greater than anticipated. |
Physical Therapy | The Board anticipates this bill will create an increase in enforcement costs and may require additional staff if sexual misconduct complaints increase. Any increase in complaints will result in additional workload for Board staff, expert witnesses, and investigators. |
Psychology | The Board feels this bill will create a fiscal impact, however the impact is not quantifiable. If the Board uses its current reporting as an estimate, the impact would be minor and absorbable based on the assumption that the licensee and the facility would both file a complaint, and therefore the two complaints would be worked as one. |
Both the Medical Board of California and the Division of Investigations (DOI)/Investigative Enforcement Unit (IEU) reported a significant increase in workload that cannot be absorbed within existing resources and will require additional staffing and funds as a result of this bill.
- $3.8 million and 12.5 positions for the Medical Board.
- $811,000 and 4.0 Investigators and 1.0 AGPA.
For more details and assumptions, please see Staff Comments.
Background:
- Boards and Bureaus regulate licensees for consumer protection. The public can submit a complaint to licensing board staff. Complaints are confidential. For complaints that are subsequently investigated and meet the necessary legal prerequisites, a Deputy Attorney General (DAG) in the Office of the Attorney General drafts formal charges, known as an “Accusation”. A hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) is subsequently scheduled, at which point settlement negotiations take place among the DAG, licensee (and the licensee’s attorney), and licensing board staff. If a licensee contests charges, the case is heard before an ALJ who subsequently drafts a proposed decision. The licensing board then adopts the decision, or makes changes to the decision before final action. In 2018, the L.A. Times published a report on an investigation into allegations of sexual abuse by a gynecologist for over 30 years at USC’s student health facility.
Proposed Law:
The bill includes the following provisions, among others:
- Requires a health facility, clinic, or entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee practices or provides care for patients, to report any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee within 15 days of receiving the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Requires specified employees, or healing arts licensees, who has knowledge of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct by a healing arts licensee to file a report with the agency that has regulatory jurisdiction over the healing arts licensee and the administration of the health facility or clinic or other entity within 15 days of knowing about the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Establishes a $100,000 fine amount per violation for a willful failure to file the report. Authorizes the fine to be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding. The fine must be paid to appropriate regulatory agency, but not expended until appropriated by the Legislature. A violation of this subdivision may constitute unprofessional conduct by the licensee.
- Establishes a fine not to exceed $50,000 per violation for any failure to file. The fine may be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding. The amount of the fine per violation, must be proportional to the severity of the failure to report and must differ based upon specified written findings and may also differ based on whether a health care facility or clinic is a small or rural hospital, as defined.
- A person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health facility or clinic, or other entity must not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making a report required by this section if made in good faith.
Related Legislation:
SB 275 (Pan, 2019) additionally requires an order of revocation of a registration or license to be included in a specified decision or proposed decision that contains a finding of fact that a person licensed or registered under the Psychology Licensing Law engaged in sexual behavior, as defined, with a client, or with a former client within 2 years following termination of therapy. The bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
Below is additional fiscal detail and assumptions, as provided to the Committee:
- Up to $168,000 (special fund), ongoing, for 0.5 Management Services Technician and 1.0 Associate Governmental Program Analyst to review and process the anticipated new 423 reports. In 2017-18, the Board received 141 misconduct reports and assumes the figure to increase three times, for a total of 423 new complaints. The new complaints would come directly to the Board and not through a peer review body. The MBC estimates each case will take 60 hours to investigate, as they anticipate the new cases to be more complex. 339 cases times at 60 hours equals a total of 20,340 additional hours.
- $1.4 million (special fund), ongoing, for 11.0 Investigators resources. Each investigator will handle approximately 1,776 hours per year.
- $2 million (special fund) for the Attorney General’s office, as 1/3 of the cases investigate will move forward to prosecution.
- $250,000 (special fund) for workload at the Office of Administrative hearings due to increased hearings (MBC estimates 20% of the 100 cases will go to the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) for a hearing.)
With respect to the HQIU and IEU workload assumptions, the DCA share:
- On average the IEU receives an average of 49 sexual misconduct cases per year. The IEU anticipates the number of these cases tripling, resulting in approximately 98 additional cases. The IEU estimates each case will take 60 hours to investigate, as they anticipate the new cases being more complex. 98 cases times at 60 hours equals a total of 5,880 additional hours. One Investigator position equates to 1,776 hours per year and the AGPA would process and review the additional 98 cases.
DCA anticipates medium-level effort for system updates that can be accommodated by redirecting existing maintenance resources. The actual cost will be driven by the extent to which programs create new enforcement codes. Existing functionality in the BreEZe, CAS, and License Search systems can support many of the bill’s requirements, such as public display of a probationary license, limiting that display to 10 years, and new fine amounts.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 425 (Author:Hill)
Version: April 11, 2019
Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
AMConsultant:
SUBJECT
Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
DIGEST
This bill requires every health facility in the state, health care service plan, or other entity with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional to provide care for patients, including a postsecondary educational institution, to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by a licensed health care practitioner to that practitioner’s licensing board within 15 days, and imposes a fine for failure to report. The bill also requires the Medical Board of California (MBC) to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate issued by it and the operative statement of issue to an inquiring member of the public and on the MCB’s website, as specified. The bill also makes various other changes.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2018, an investigation by the Los Angeles Times (L.A. Times) reported on multiple unresolved complaints, the earliest of which dated back 30 years, of alleged sexual misconduct by a doctor who worked at the University of Southern California’s (USC) student health center. It seems that not a single complaint was ever reported to the MBC. In response to this, the author has brought forward this bill to ensure that what happened at USC will never happen again.
The bill is author sponsored and supported by other organizations, including the Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC). The bill is opposed by organizations representing medical professionals, including the California Medical Association (CMA). The bill passed the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee on a vote of 9-0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes various practice acts in the Business and Professions Code (BPC) governed by various licensing boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), which provide for the licensing and regulation of health care professionals. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 500 et seq.)[1]
- Establishes various violations that constitute unprofessional conduct, including that the commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct, or relations with a patient, client, or customer constitutes unprofessional conduct and grounds for disciplinary action. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 725 et. seq & 726.)
- Authorizes the licensing boards to deny, suspend, or revoke a license and provides various procedures around the denial, suspension, or revocation of a license. (Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 475 et. seq)
- Requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report when a licentiate’s application for staff privileges or membership is denied, or the licentiate’s staff privileges or employment are terminated or revoked for a medical disciplinary cause. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805)
- Licentiates include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives, and physician assistants. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805(a)(2).)
- The reporting entities are also required to file a report when restrictions are imposed or voluntarily accepted on the licensee’s staff privileges for a cumulative total of 30 days or more for any 12-month period. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805(b)(3).)
- The report must be filed within 15 days after the effective date of the action taken by a health facility peer review body. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805(c).)
- A willful failure to make the required report is punishable by a fine of $100,000 per violation, and any other failure is punishable by a fine of $50,000. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805(k) & (l).)
- Requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report within 15 days after the peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action against a licentiate that must be reported pursuant to Section 805 of the Business and Professions Code. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805.01)
- This reporting requirement is only required if the recommended action is taken for the following reasons:
- Incompetence, or gross or repeated deviation from the standard of care involving death or serious bodily injury to one or more patients in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to any person or the public.
- The use of, or prescribing for or administering to the licentiate, any controlled substance; or the use of any dangerous drug, or of alcoholic beverages, to the extent or in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to the licentiate, or any other persons, or the public, or to the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licentiate to practice safely.
- Repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, furnishing or administering of controlled substances or repeated acts of prescribing, dispensing, or furnishing of controlled substances without a good faith effort prior examination of the patient and medical reason therefor.
- Sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805.01(b)(1)-(4).)
- A willful failure to make the required report is punishable by a fine of $100,000 per violation, and any other failure is punishable by a fine of $50,000. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 805.01(g) & (h).)
- This reporting requirement is only required if the recommended action is taken for the following reasons:
This bill:
- Requires a health facility or clinic, the administrator or chief executive officer of a health care service plan, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients, including but not limited to a private postsecondary educational institution, to file a report of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a healing arts licensee to the licensee’s licensing board within 15 days of receiving the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Specifies that an arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients includes, but is not limited to, full staff privileges, active staff privileges, limited staff privileges, auxiliary staff privileges, provisional staff privileges, temporary staff privileges, courtesy staff privileges, locum tenens arrangements, and contractual arrangements to provide professional services, including, but not limited to, arrangements to provide outpatient services.
- Defines certain terms:
- “Agency” means the relevant state licensing agency with regulatory jurisdiction over a healing arts licensee.
- “Health care service plan” means a health care service plan licensed under Chapter 2.2 (commencing with Section 1340) of Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code.
- “Healing arts licensee” or “licensee” means a licensee licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) or any initiative act referred to in that division. “Healing arts licensee” or “licensee” also includes a person authorized to practice medicine pursuant to specified sections of existing law.
- “Other entity” includes, but is not limited to, a postsecondary educational institution as defined in Section 66261.5 of the Education Code.
- Requires an employee or a licensed health care professional that works in any health facility or clinic, health care service plan, or other entity, who has knowledge of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct by a healing arts licensee, to file a report with both the licensee’s licensing board and the administration of the health facility or clinic, health care service plan, or other entity within 15 days of knowing about the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Imposes a fine for failure to make the required report.
- The fine for a willful failure is not to exceed $100,000.
- The fine for any other failure is not to exceed $50,000.
- The fine may be imposed in any civil or administrative action or proceeding, as specified.
- Provides a person, including an employee or individual contracted or subcontracted to provide health care services, a health facility or clinic, a health care service plan, or other entity, will not incur any civil or criminal liability as a result of making the required report.
- Requires the MBC to disclose a probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate issued by it and the operative statement of issues to an inquiring member of the public and on the board’s website for 10 years from issuance.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
SB 425 closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee.
Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation.
State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks.
The author notes that in May 2018, an investigation by the L. A. Times disclosed multiple unresolved complaints of alleged sexual misconduct involving a gynecologist who worked at USC’s student health center for almost 30 years. The author states that “none of the prior complaints were reported to the Medical Board of California.”
According to the Author, this prompted him, as then-chair of the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee, to conduct a hearing on sexual misconduct reporting in the medical profession. The author states that:
The differing reporting standards for various health facilities were among the issues raised in the hearing. Some health facilities, because of their size or type, have no requirement to report allegations of patient sexual abuse or sexual misconduct involving medical professionals to any licensing board. Other health facilities have in-house peer review groups that decide whether a complaint should be forwarded to the appropriate licensing board. Existing law also enables physicians and surgeons to prolong their licensing board’s inquiry into allegations by repeatedly failing to show up for investigative interviews.
Lucy Chi, a 2014 graduate of USC’s Masters of Health Administration program, testified during the hearing about the need to toughen the requirements for hospitals and clinics to report allegations of patient sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by doctors. Ms. Chi, one of hundreds of women who have sued USC for its handling of complaints involving its former gynecologist, also offered a statement in support of SB 425.
“As a victim of Dr. George Tyndall and a current health administrative professional, I believe any delays in reporting physician sexual misconduct would endanger countless patients,” said Ms. Chi. “If USC had reported Dr. Tyndall's sexual misconduct, I, along with countless other victims, would have been spared sexual abuse by our physician. It's truly disheartening that due to legal loopholes, a predator was allowed to sexually abuse his patients for almost 30 years. I wholeheartedly support Senator Hill's proposed amendments to existing law.”
2. Background
In 2018, the L.A. Times published a report on an investigation into allegations of sexual abuse by Dr. Georg Tyndall[2] who worked as a gynecologist for over 30 years at USC’s student health facility. USC has agreed to pay $215 million to former patients in a proposed settlement. The L.A. Times reported:
The complaints began in the 1990s, when co-workers alleged he was improperly photographing students’ genitals. In the years that followed, patients and nursing staff accused him again and again of “creepy” behavior, including touching women inappropriately during pelvic exams and making sexually suggestive remarks about their bodies.
In recent years, some colleagues feared that he was targeting the university’s growing population of Chinese students, who often had a limited understanding of the English language and American medical norms.
Still, Tyndall was allowed to continue practicing. It was not until 2016, when a frustrated nurse went to the campus rape crisis center, that he was suspended.
An internal USC investigation determined that Tyndall’s behavior during pelvic exams was outside the scope of current medical practice and amounted to sexual harassment of students. But in a secret deal last summer, top administrators allowed Tyndall to resign quietly with a financial payout.
The university did not inform Tyndall’s patients. Nor did USC report him at the time to the Medical Board of California, the agency responsible for protecting the public from problem doctors.
USC told The Times in a statement that it was under no legal obligation to report Tyndall. [emphasis added] The statement said that “in hindsight,” USC should have reported him. The university said it belatedly filed a complaint with the medical board March 9 after a request by Tyndall to be reinstated. It was about a month after Times reporters began questioning university employees about Tyndall.[3]
The student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as an employment matter and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. The MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in Section 805 or 805.01 of the Business and Professions Code.
For a detailed explanation and analysis of the peer review process under existing law, please refer to the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development analysis regarding this bill.[4]
3. Enforcement mechanism and penalty
The bill imposes a fine of no more than $100,000 for a willful failure of a health facility or clinic, the administrator or chief executive officer of a health care service plan, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a healing arts licensee is allowed to practice or provide care to file the required report, and a fine of no more than $50,000 for any other failure to file the required report. The fines are required to be proportional to the severity of the failure to report and based upon written findings including: whether the failure to file caused harm to a patient or created a risk to patient safety; whether any person who is designated or otherwise required by law to file the report exercised due diligence despite the failure to file or whether the person knew or should have known that a report required under this section would not be filed; and whether there has been a prior failure to file a report required under this section. The amount of the fine may also differ based on whether a health care facility or clinic is a small or rural hospital.
Some opponents have raised concerns about the amount of the fines; however, they are consistent with existing law. The fines in the bill are identical to the existing fines under the peer review reporting requirements found in Sections 805 and 805.01 of the Business and Professions Code. The proportionality provisions relating to the amount of the fine are also in Sections 805 and 805.01 of the Business and Professions Code. As the intent of this bill is to encourage reporting, making the fines equivalent to existing fines makes sense from a policy standpoint.
4. Blanket immunity for making required report
Liability has the primary effect of ensuring that some measure of recourse exists for those persons injured by the negligent or willful acts of others; the risk of that liability has the primary effect of ensuring parties act reasonably to avoid harm to those to whom they owe a duty. As a general rule, California law provides that everyone is responsible, not only for the result of their willful acts, but also for an injury occasioned to another by their want of ordinary care or skill in the management of their property or person, except so far as the latter has, willfully or by lack of ordinary care, caused their own injury. (Civ. Code § 1714(a).)
Blanket immunity provisions are generally disfavored as a matter of public policy because they, by their nature, prevent an injured party from seeking a particular type of recovery. However, the Legislature has in limited circumstances allowed for measured immunity from liability to promote other policy goals that could benefit the public. Immunity provisions are sometimes allowed when necessary to ensure the willingness of individuals to continue taking on certain roles that may involve some risk. Under Section 805 of the Business and Professions Code, a person is prohibited from incurring any civil or criminal liability as the result of making a report required by that section; however, Section 805.01 of the Business and Professions Code does not include any immunity from civil or criminal liability for making a report required under that section. In order to ensure the new reporting requirement under the bill is not used by a bad actor to make false complaints against a licensee, the author has proposed to amend the blanket immunity provision. The specific amendments are as follows:
Amendment
On page 8, at line 7, delete “section.” and insert:
section if made in good faith.
5. Concerns raised by the opposition
The CMA writes:
As currently written, this bill creates an enormous administrative burden on all healing arts licensees as well as their respective licensing boards by requiring every potential complaint, whether or not it is substantiated, actually spoken by the patient, or simply a rumor in a staff break room, to be reported to the licensing board of the licensee who is the subject of the complaint.
This concern was also expressed by other organizations. In the prior committee, the author indicated it was not his intent that “a rumor” be reported under the requirements of the bill.
The California Association of Health Plans and Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies write:
While we appreciate the intent of the bill and strongly believe that the accurate and timely reporting of provider misconduct is critical to ensuring the safety of individuals receiving medical care, we are concerned that requiring health plan CEOs and staff to report provider misconduct may not necessarily result in the most complete or detailed accounting of an incident.
It is our member’s experience that enrollees typically contact their health plan with questions regarding coverage and provider billing and premiums, but not provider conduct issues. Given the sensitivity around this type of reporting, all health plan staff, regardless of position, would need to be trained to understand how, when and what information should or could be reported and shared.
As health care service plans do not themselves employ or make arrangements for healing arts licensees to practice or provide care, the author has agreed to remove health care service plans from the reporting requirement provision of the bill.
5. Statements in support
The CAOC writes:
The bill aims to close legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee.
Another supporter, Consumer Watchdog, writes:
Committee members need look no further than univeristy and student helath center authorities’ silience in the face of years of compliants about Univeristy of Southern California (USC) gynecologist, Dr. George Tyndall, to recognize the urgent need for SB 425’s mandate that accusations of a doctor’s sexual misconduct or assault of patients be immediately reported to regulators for investigation.
USC received complaints about Dr. Tyndall’s sexual misconduct towards female patients for decades, yet the university only began an investigation after a nurse reported his conduct to the campus rape crisis center, in 2016. The result of the investigation was that USC quietly paid Dr. Tyndall to go away, but never disclosed the findings of their investigation to students, the Medical Board of California, or law enforcement.
SUPPORT
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
OPPOSITION
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
California Association of Health Plans
California Chapter of the American College of Cardiology
California Medical Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 275 (Pan, 2019) additionally requires an order of revocation of a registration or license to be included in a specified decision or proposed decision that contains a finding of fact that a person licensed or registered under the Psychology Licensing Law engaged in sexual behavior, as defined, with a client, or with a former client within 2 years following termination of therapy. The bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 798 (Hill, Ch. 775, Stats. 2017) among other things applied existing peer review provisions to licensed midwives, as specified.
SB 1236 (Price, Ch. 332, Stats. 2012) among other things applied existing peer review provisions to physician assistants, as specified.
SB 146 (Wayland, Ch. 381, Stats. 2011) among other things applied existing peer review provisions to professional clinical counselors, as specified.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
The individual healing arts licensing acts also contain specific provisions relating to acts specific licensees, including what constitutes unprofessional conduct and how a licensing board may discipline its licensees. ↑
Dr. Tyndall has denied any wrongdoing and his attorney, Leonard Levine, has said that his client “continues to maintain that he engaged in no criminal conduct and that his medical examinations were always within the standard of care.” Hamilton & Ryan, USC’s tentative $215-million settlement in Tyndall abuse cases likely just the beginning of financial pain for the university. L.A. Times (Oct. 19, 2018) available at https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-usc-settlement-proposal-20181019-story.html (as of Apr. 17, 2019). ↑
Ryan & Hamilton, USC gynecologist to keep treating students despite years of misconduct complaints, L.A. Times (May 15, 2019), available at https://www.latimes.com/nydn-news-national-usc-allowed-doctor-treating-students-complaints-1-3991836-story.html (as of Apr. 17, 2019). ↑
Sen. Bus. Prof. and Econ. Dev., SB 425 (Hill, 2019), available at http://lis.calegis.net/LISWeb/faces/bills/billxmlxsl.xhtml;jsessionid=h6I3TJU34dWRSToxFk9sELAuQg76-NNgSKTEj3BkalMPhi9NRxsY!1783751731# (as of Apr. 17, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 425 Hearing Date: April 8, 2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | February 21, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject: Health care practitioners: licensee’s file: probationary physician’s and surgeon’s certificate: unprofessional conduct
SUMMARY:
Requires every health facility in the state, health care service plans, or other entities with any arrangement authorizing a licensed health care professional to provide care for patients (such as postsecondary educational institutions), to report allegations of sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by a licensed health care practitioner to the individual’s licensing board within 15 days. Makes other changes related Medical Board of California (MBC) disciplinary action and enforcement.
Existing law:
- Establishes various practice acts in the Business and Professions Code (BPC) governed by various boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) which provide for the licensing and regulation of health care professionals. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 500 et seq.) Establishes a number of reporting requirements outlined in the BPC designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation.
- Establishes various violations that constitute unprofessional conduct. (BPC §§ 725 et. seq)
- Requires any psychotherapist or employer of a psychotherapist who becomes aware, through a client that the client had alleged sexual intercourse, sexual behavior, or sexual contact with a previous psychotherapist during the course of a prior treatment, to provide a brochure to the client (the brochure is prepared by the DCA) that delineates the rights of, and remedies for, clients who have been involved sexually with their psychotherapists. Requires the psychotherapist or employer to discuss the brochure with the client. For purposes of the brochure, defines “sexual contact” as the touching of an intimate part of another person, and “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues. (BPC §§ 728 (a) and (c)(2))
- Requires healing arts boards to create and maintain a central file of the names of all persons who hold a license or similar authority from a board confidentially containing an individual historical record for each licensee including, among other things, disciplinary information. Specifies that the contents of a central file that are not public records must remain confidential, except that the licensee involved, or their counsel or representative, have the right to inspect and have copies made of the licensee’s complete file, other than provisions that could potentially disclose the identity of an information source. In order to protect an information source, a board may either redact the source’s identifying information or provide a comprehensive summary of the material. (BPC § 800)
- Beginning July 1, 2019, requires certain licensed health care professionals (physicians and surgeons, osteopathic physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, acupuncturists, chiropractors, and naturopathic doctors) to notify patients of their probationary status.
- For physicians and surgeons licensed by the MBC and Osteopathic Medical Board (OMBC), requires that probationary status be disclosed if there is a final adjudication by MBC or OMBC following an administrative hearing, or admitted findings or prima facie showing in a stipulated settlement establishing certain violations of the law, including the commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct or relations with a patient or client. (BPC § 2228.1)
- Requires an accusation to be filed against a licensee within three years after MBC discovers the act or omission alleged as the ground for disciplinary action, or within seven years after the act or omission alleged as the ground for disciplinary action occurs, whichever occurs first, as specified. (BPC § 2230.5)
- Requires MBC to automatically revoke the license of any person who, at any time after January 1, 1947, has been required to register as a sex offender pursuant to the provisions of Section 290 of the Penal Code, regardless of whether the related conviction has been appealed. Authorizes the licensee to request a hearing, conducted in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), within 30 days of the revocation. (BPC § 2232)
- Authorizes an interim order suspending (ISO) a license for MBC licensees if the affidavits show that the licensee has engaged in, or is about to engage in, acts or omissions constituting a violation of the Medical Practice Act, or is unable to practice safely due to a mental or physical condition, and that permitting the licensee to continue to engage in the profession for which the license was issued will endanger the public health, safety, or welfare. ISOs shall be issued only after a hearing, unless it appears from the facts in the affidavit that serious public injury would be a result of waiting for the hearing. (Government Code § 11529)
- Provides that when an ISO is issued, and an accusation or petition to revoke probation is not filed and served within 30 days, the ISO is dissolved. Provides a licensee with certain rights and privileges when the licensee is served with an accusation or petition to revoke probation, including: a hearing within 30 days of the request, unless the licensee stipulates to a later hearing and; a decision within 15 days of the date MBC receives a decision from an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) on the matter. If MBC does not issue a decision in this timeframe, the ISO is nullified, unless MBC can show good cause for a delay. (Id.)
This bill:
- Requires a health facility or clinic, the administrator or chief executive officer of a health care service plan, or other entity that makes any arrangement under which a licensed health care professional is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients (including but not limited to a private postsecondary educational institution), to file a report of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct made against a licensed health care professional to the licensee’s licensing board within 15 days of receiving the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct. Specifies that an arrangement under which a licensee is allowed to practice in or provide care for patients includes, but is not limited to, full staff privileges, active staff privileges, limited staff privileges, auxiliary staff privileges, provisional staff privileges, temporary staff privileges, courtesy staff privileges, locum tenens arrangements, and contractual arrangements to provide professional services, including, but not limited to, arrangements to provide outpatient services.
- Requires an employee or a licensed health care professional that works in any health facility or clinic, health care service plan, or other entity, who has knowledge of any allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct by a licensed health care professional, to file a report with both the licensee’s licensing board and the administration of the health facility or clinic, health care service plan, or other entity within 15 days of knowing about the allegation of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct. Specifies that failure of an employee or licensed health care professional to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct may constitute unprofessional conduct
- Specifies that any failure to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $50,000 per violation. Specifies that the amount of the fine shall be proportional to the severity of the failure to report and shall differ based upon written findings, including whether the failure to file caused harm to a patient or created a risk to patient safety; whether any person who is designated or otherwise required to file the report exercised due diligence despite the failure to file; or whether the person knew or should have known that a report required would not be filed; and whether there has been a prior failure to file a report. Specifies that a willful failure (a voluntary and intentional violation of a known legal duty) to file the report of alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct is punishable by a fine of up to $100,000 per violation.
- States that a person is immune from any civil or criminal liability for reporting the alleged sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.
- Authorizes MBC, upon receipt of information that the public health, safety, or welfare requires emergency action, to place a physician’s and surgeon’s license on suspension pending formal proceedings. Specifies that this emergency order of suspension shall be issued to the licensee informing the licensee of the facts or conduct warranting the emergency suspension, pending an investigation. Authorizes a licensee whose license has been suspended on emergency order to request a hearing for an ISO, which must be held within 180 days licensee’s request.
- When issuing a probationary license, requires the record relating to that probationary license to remain on MBC’s website for 10 years.
- Specifies that failure of a licensee (as opposed to repeated failure under current law), absent good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by MBC is unprofessional conduct.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author,
“SB 425 closes legal loopholes that can allow a subject of repeated sexual abuse and misconduct complaints to work at a health facility for years because the relevant regulatory board is not notified by the facility of the allegations against a licensee.
Allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct by doctors and other medical professionals must be reported swiftly to the appropriate licensing board for review so that regulators can determine whether to conduct an independent, confidential investigation.
State regulatory boards cannot fulfill their responsibilities to protect patients and other consumers, if they are not notified of these serious allegations involving their licensees. The failure to do so shields bad actors while exposing patients to greater risks.”
The Author notes that in May 2018, a news investigation by the Los Angeles Times disclosed multiple unresolved complaints of alleged sexual misconduct involving a gynecologist who worked at the University of Southern California’s student health center for almost 30 years. The Author states that “none of the prior complaints were reported to the Medical Board of California.”
According to the Author, this prompted him, as then-chair of this Committee, to conduct a hearing on sexual misconduct reporting in the medical profession. The Author states that:
“The differing reporting standards for various health facilities were among the issues raised in the hearing. Some health facilities, because of their size or type, have no requirement to report allegations of patient sexual abuse or sexual misconduct involving medical professionals to any licensing board. Other health facilities have in-house peer review groups that decide whether a complaint should be forwarded to the appropriate licensing board. Existing law also enables physicians and surgeons to prolong their licensing board’s inquiry into allegations by repeatedly failing to show up for investigative interviews.
Lucy Chi, a 2014 graduate of USC’s Masters of Health Administration program, testified during the hearing about the need to toughen the requirements for hospitals and clinics to report allegations of patient sexual abuse and sexual misconduct by doctors. Ms. Chi, one of hundreds of women who have sued USC for its handling of complaints involving its former gynecologist, also offered a statement in support of SB 425.
‘As a victim of Dr. George Tyndall and a current health administrative professional, I believe any delays in reporting physician sexual misconduct would endanger countless patients,” said Ms. Chi. “If USC had reported Dr. Tyndall's sexual misconduct, I, along with countless other victims, would have been spared sexual abuse by our physician. It's truly disheartening that due to legal loopholes, a predator was allowed to sexually abuse his patients for almost 30 years. I wholeheartedly support Senator Hill's proposed amendments to existing law.”
- Mandatory Reporting of Health Practitioner Settlements, Indictments, Convictions, and Discipline. There are a number of reporting requirements designed to inform licensing boards about possible matters for investigation, including:
- BPC Section 801.01 requires the MBC, Osteopathic Medical Board of California (OMBC), California Board of Podiatric Medicine (BPM) and Physician Assistant Board (PAB) to receive reports of settlements over $30,000 or arbitration awards or civil judgments of any amount. The report must be filed within 30 days by either the insurer providing professional liability insurance to the licensee, the state or governmental agency that self-insures the licensee, the employer of the licensee if the award is against or paid for by the licensee or the licensee if not covered by professional liability insurance.
- BPC Section 802.1 requires a licensees of MBC, OMBC, BPM and PAB to report indictments charging a felony and/or any convictions of any felony or misdemeanor, including a guilty verdict or plea of no contest to their licensing board.
- BPC Section 802.5 requires a coroner who receives information, based on findings reached by a pathologist that indicates that a death may be the result of a physician and surgeon, podiatrists or physician assistant’s gross negligence or incompetence, to submit a report to MBC, OMBC, BPM and PAB, as appropriate. The coroner must provide relevant information, including the name of the decedent and attending licensee as well as the final report and autopsy.
- BPC Sections 803, 803.5 and 803.6 require the clerk of a court that renders a judgment that a licensee has committed a crime, or is liable for any death or personal injury resulting in a judgment of any amount caused by the licensee’s negligence, error or omission in practice, or his or her rendering of unauthorized professional services, to report that judgment to the appropriate healing arts licensing agency within 10 days after the judgment is entered. In addition, the court clerk is responsible for reporting criminal convictions to some licensing agencies (MBC, OMBC, BPM, Board of Chiropractic Examiners, PAB or other appropriate allied health board) and transmitting any felony preliminary hearing transcripts concerning a licensee to those boards.
- BPC Section 805 is one of the most important reporting requirements that allows boards to learn key information about licensees. Section 805 requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report when a licensee’s application for staff privileges or membership is denied, or the licensee’s staff privileges or employment are terminated or revoked for a medical disciplinary cause. Licensees include physicians and surgeons, doctors of podiatric medicine, clinical psychologists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, dentists, licensed midwives or physician assistants. The reporting entities are also required to file a report when restrictions are imposed or voluntarily accepted on the licensee’s staff privileges for a cumulative total of 30 days or more for any 12-month period. The report must be filed within 15 days after the effective date of the action taken by a health facility peer review body.
- BPC Section 805.01 is a similarly extremely important requirement. The law requires the chief of staff and chief executive officer, medical director, or administrator of a licensed health care facility to file a report within 15 days after the peer review body makes a final decision or recommendation to take disciplinary action which must be reported pursuant to section 805. This reporting requirement became effective January 2011 and is only required if the recommended action is taken for the following reasons:
- Incompetence, or gross or repeated deviation from the standard of care involving death or serious bodily injury to one or more patients in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to any person or the public.
- The use of, or prescribing for or administering to him/herself, any controlled substance; or the use of any dangerous drug, or of alcoholic beverages, to the extend or in such a manner as to be dangerous or injurious to the licentiate, or any other persons, or the public, or to the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licentiate to practice safely.
- Repeated acts of clearly excessive prescribing, furnishing or administering of controlled substances or repeated acts of prescribing, dispensing, or furnishing of controlled substances without a good faith effort prior examination of the patient and medical reason therefor.
- Sexual misconduct with one or more patients during a course of treatment or an examination.
The purpose of 805 reports is to provide licensing boards with early information about these serious charges so that they may investigate and take appropriate action to further consumer protection at the earliest possible moment. Accordingly, for any allegations listed above, the Legislature determined that an 805.01 report must be filed once a formal investigation has been completed, and a final decision or recommendation regarding the disciplinary action to be taken against a licensee has been determined by the peer review body, even when the licensee has not yet been afforded a hearing to contest those findings.
- Peer Review. In peer review, health care practitioners evaluate their colleagues' work to determine compliance with the standard of care. Peer reviews are intended to detect incompetent or unprofessional practitioners early and terminate, suspend, or limit their practice if necessary. Peer review is triggered by a wide variety of events including patient injury, disruptive conduct, substance abuse, or other medical staff complaints. A peer review committee investigates the allegation, comes to a decision regarding the licensee's conduct, and takes appropriate remedial actions. There has historically been some reluctance among licensees to serve on peer review committees due to the risk of involvement in related future litigation, including medical malpractice lawsuits against a licensee under review. There are also concerns about “sham peer review” which uses the peer review system to discredit, harass, discipline, or otherwise negatively affect a practitioner's ability to practice or exercise professional judgment for a non-medical or reason unrelated to patient safety. Other criticisms of peer review include over legalization of the process, lack of transparency in the system, and the burdensome human and financial toll peer review brings not only to the hospital but also to a licensee under review.
In 1989, several due process provisions for physicians subject to an 805 report were adopted and codified under Section 809 et. seq. of the Business and Professions Code. Any physician, for whom an 805 report may be required to be filed, is entitled to specified due process rights, including notice of the proposed action, an opportunity for a hearing with full procedural rights (including discovery, examination of witnesses, formal record of the proceedings and written findings). Furthermore, a physician may seek a judicial review in the Superior Court pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.5 (writ of mandate). The due process requirements do not apply to peer review proceedings conducted in state or county hospitals, to the University of California hospitals or to other teaching hospitals as defined.
Recognizing that peer review is necessary to maintain and improve quality medical care, Congress, in 1986, enacted the Health Care Quality Improvement Act (HCQIA). HCQIA established standards for hospital peer review committees, provided immunity for those who participate in peer review, and created the National Practitioner Databank (NPDB). The NPDB is a confidential repository of information related to the professional competence and conduct of health care practitioners. Credentialing bodies are required to check the NPDB database before granting privileges or reappointing privileges to licensees. Entities such as hospitals, professional societies, state boards, and plaintiffs' attorneys are given access to the NPDB. In enacting the NPDB, Congress intended to improve the quality of health care by encouraging state licensing boards, hospitals, and other health care entities, and professional societies to identify and discipline those who engage in unprofessional behavior and to restrict the ability of incompetent health care practitioners who attempt to move from state to state without disclosure or discovery of previous medical malpractice payment and adverse action history. The NPDB is a central repository of information about: (1) malpractice payments made for the benefit of health care practitioners; (2) licensure actions taken by state licensing boards; (3) professional review actions taken against licensees by hospitals and other health care entities, including health maintenance organizations, group practices, and professional societies; (4) actions taken by the Drug Enforcement Administration, and (5) Medicare/Medicaid Exclusions.
Private standard setting is also common in peer review. Organizations like the Joint Commission (formerly the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations), which accredits hospitals, health care providers and other health care settings across the country have established peer review standards for the entities it accredits. In order to receive Joint Commission accreditation, hospitals must have peer review and other quality assurance measures. Eligibility for federal funds such as Medicare and Medicaid often depends on accreditation.
A 2008 California study on peer review found variation and inconsistency in entity peer review policies and standards, including on the definition, procedures, commencement, practice and subject of peer review. Peer review means different activities to different entities, and can be triggered by a number of ways but is mostly part of the quality/safety/risk process of an entity. In addition, risk management/peer review issues are combined with mundane issues related to the “business” of an entity. All medical entities set their own standards for peer review, some more rigorous than others, and some adhere to them more meticulously than others. Additionally, each entity creates its own peer review policies, which can vary substantially. If a licensee is found to have provided substandard care, that individual may leave or be forced to leave the entity but can practice elsewhere, potentially endangering other patients. The peer review process is often lengthy and can take months or even years. There are also variations in the name of the peer review body, the number of members, and the length of time a member serves on a committee. It usually takes years before a peer review action is taken.
The study also identified poor tracking of peer review events and highlighted confusion on 805 reporting. According to the study, few cases lead to actual 805 reporting because of (a) disagreement or legal interpretation on whether 809 due process is required before every 805 report is submitted, and, (b) 809 due process leads to a substantial delay in the process (often 2 to 5 years). In addition, although entities make a sincere effort to conduct peer review, it rarely leads to actual 805 or 809 actions, perhaps due to the confusion over when to file a report. The study found that in addition, entities have devised other methods to correct a physician behavior before filing an 805 report. The most common cases referred to a high level peer review are: disruptive licensee behavior/impairment, substandard technical skills, substance abuse, and failure to document/record patient treatment. It is also possible that some licensees would never be subject to peer review because they have practices that are not subject to any peer review requirements. The study also demonstrated a lack of coordination among state agencies and licensing agencies, noting that there is no systematic communication or coordination among various boards and agencies that would coordinate patient quality and safety issues. There is much complexity on the complaint process, enforcement process, and public disclosure rules.
In 2009, the California Supreme Court issued an opinion relating to peer review in Mileikowsky v. West Hills Hospital Medical Center in which the Court discussed the importance of the peer review process and pointed out the following: “The primary purpose of the peer review process is to protect the health and welfare of the people of California by excluding through the peer review mechanism those healing arts practitioners who provide substandard care or who engage in professional misconduct. This purpose also serves the interest of California's acute care facilities by providing a means of removing incompetent physicians from a hospital's staff to reduce exposure to possible malpractice liability. Another purpose, if not equally important, is to protect competent practitioners from being barred from practice for arbitrary or discriminatory reasons.”
In California, there are additional types of peer review bodies than committees in hospitals. Specifically, peer review can be undertaken by: medical or professional staffs of properly licensed free clinics and ambulatory surgical centers; health care service plans; any medical, psychological, marriage and family therapy, social work, dental or podiatric professional society having as members at least 25 percent of the eligible licensees in the area in which the society functions; and committees organized by any entity consisting of or employing more than 25 licensees of the same class, including practice groups, which functions for the purpose of reviewing the quality of professional care provided by members or employees of that entity.
- Recent Events and Allegations of Misconduct. The Legislature has a long history of interest in, and focus on, statutory reporting requirements that are designed to inform health professional licensing boards about their licensees. In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017.
At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
- Healing Arts Board Enforcement. The enforcement process begins with a complaint. Complaints can be submitted by the public, generated internally by licensing board staff, or based on information a licensing board receives from various entities through mandatory reports outlined above. Complaints are confidential. For complaints that are subsequently investigated and meet the necessary legal prerequisites, a Deputy Attorney General (DAG) in the Office of the Attorney General drafts formal charges, known as an “Accusation”. A hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) is subsequently scheduled, at which point settlement negotiations take place between the DAG, licensee (and the licensee’s attorney) and licensing board staff. Often times these result in a stipulated settlement, similar to a plea bargain in criminal court, where a licensee admits to have violated charges set forth in the accusation and accepts penalties for those violations. If a licensee contests charges, the case is heard before an ALJ who subsequently drafts a proposed decision. The licensing board then adopts the decision, or makes changes to the decision before final action.
Licensing boards within DCA rely on disciplinary guidelines to ensure consistency in disciplinary penalties for similar offenses on a statewide basis and create uniform guidelines for violations of a particular practice act. Guidelines are used by ALJs, attorneys, licensees and others involved in a regulatory program’s disciplinary process.
- Medical Board Enforcement Enhancement Provisions Contained In This Measure. The sexual abuse and sexual misconduct allegation reporting requirements in this bill apply broadly to health care professionals licensed by a number of boards within the DCA. However, the measure also contains provisions specific to enforcement by MBC against physicians and surgeons.
Four specific provisions are aimed at increasing the ability of MBC to take timely enforcement action, three of which, highlighted below, MBC approved as legislative proposals at a 2018 board meeting.
- Striking the qualifier “comprehensive” for the summary MBC provides a licensee or the licensee’s counsel of materials provided by a confidential information source is designed to speed up the investigation process. MBC may receive a request for this comprehensive summary, provides what they determine to be a comprehensive summary, and the licensee may argue that it isn’t comprehensive enough and may even refuse to set up an interview with MBC until they receive a more “comprehensive” summary.
- Striking the qualifier “repeated” for failure by a licensee, in absence of good cause, to attend and participate in an interview by MBC is designed to address delays in MBC’s enforcement process.
- Requiring probationary license information to remain on MBC’s website for 10 years, after probation is completed, is modeled after current requirements for licensee probation history to remain on MBC’s website and designed to increase the public availability of information. Probationary licenses may be issued for a variety of reasons, including, substance abuse issues, criminal conviction history, and disciplinary action taken by another state, to name a few. While the information remains publicly available and MBC provides it upon request, it is not required to be posted online and is taken down once the probationary period ends.
The fourth provision specific to MBC, related to issuance of an emergency order, was not approved by MBC. Currently, MBC can issue ISOs, pursuant to Government Code provisions outlined above and also temporary restraining orders, or other restrictions pursuant to Penal Code § 23 issued as part of a criminal hearing process, as a condition of bail. Restrictions are also imposed via a stipulated agreement to not practice or a stipulated agreement to a restriction. The MBC can also require physicians to cease practice if they fail to comply with a term or condition of their probation.
An ISO is considered extraordinary relief and a standard of proof must be met in order for an ISO to be granted. This action allows MBC to stop a licensee from practicing prior to formal disciplinary action being taken. An ISO might completely restrict a license, or might impose restrictions, such as restrictions on prescribing, on the license. Before an ISO can be requested, there are a number of steps that MBC must take (gathering medical records, obtaining patient consent, medical consultant review, etc.) in order to prove that a licensee’s continued practice presents an immediate danger to public health, safety, or welfare. Once the investigation progresses and the case is reviewed by a DAG, a determination is made as to whether there is enough evidence to warrant requesting an ISO, which must still be granted by an ALJ. Even after the ISO is requested, if an ALJ determines there is insufficient evidence, the ISO request can be denied.
After the issuance of an ISO, existing law gives MBC 30 days to file a formal accusation against a licensee (SB 304, Lieu, Chapter 515, Statutes of 2013 extended the timeframe from 15 to 30 days). This means that investigations should be nearly complete prior to petitioning for an ISO. MBC may be delayed in filing the initial ISO if evidence is still being gathered for the clear and convincing threshold to be met for the filing of an accusation.
This bill provides MBC authority to issue an emergency order of license suspension pending formal proceedings, and requires a hearing on an ISO to be held, if requested by the licensee, within 180 days.
- Related Legislation This Year. AB 1030 (Calderon and Petrie-Norris) requires MBC, on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, to develop an informational pamphlet for patients undergoing gynecological examinations. (Status: The measure is pending in the Assembly Committee on Health.)
- Arguments in Support. The Medical Board of California supports three provisions in the bill related to MBC enforcement which it believes will help to prevent delays in the Board’s enforcement process, which “negatively impact the Board’s enforcement timelines” and which will increase transparency by providing access to information that is public, but not available on MBC’s website after a probationary period is complete. MBC’s position does not reference provisions related to receiving reports about sexual abuse and misconduct allegations involving a MBC licensee, nor does MBC have a position on provisions related to ISOs.
Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) and Consumer Watchdog cite the USC case referenced above in their support of this measure. According to CAOC references the Author’s SB 1448 when noting that this bill will “continue the important work of protecting vulnerable populations from individuals who abuse positions of trust.” Consumer Watchdog cites cases at other universities involving physicians and sexual misconduct, stating that “in each of these cases, the failure to investigate multiple, credible allegations of sexual misconduct placed thousands of additional patients in harm’s way…SB 425 will help ensure patient complaints are treated seriously and investigated with the alacrity they deserve.”
- Arguments in Opposition. Opponents state that this bill completely bypasses the peer review process put in place for hospitals by requiring every healing arts licensee working within a hospital to report any complaint of sexual misconduct or allegation of sexual misconduct to the appropriate licensing board within 15 days, and are asking that this provision to be deleted from the bill. According to the opponents, “While we appreciate the procedural steps that the Medical Board must take to file a complaint, and the need to remove dangerous licensees from practice expediently, we do not believe this large jump from 30 to 180 days is warranted”, in reference to the provisions of the bill authorizing an MBC license to be suspended for 180 days before MBC files a formal accusation. Opponents are also concerned about unprofessional conduct being levied against MBC licensees for “repeated failures” to respond to a request for interview and note that repeated needs to be defined.
- Policy Questions.
- Is due process impacted? A peer review process, for the health care professionals subject to that, and in the facilities where peer review exists, allows other health care professionals to consider whether standard of care provisions were followed or violated. Peer review proceedings and records are confidential and they are not subject to discovery – they will remain that way under this bill, as it does not impact those laws and protections that remain important. While the bill does establish a new mechanism for boards to initiate efforts to determine whether practice act violations have taken place, it does not eliminate peer review, nor does it ensure that a licensing board will even take swift action, given the significant delays in enforcement by health care licensing boards that are routinely brought to the Legislature’s attention. This parallel track of standard of care consideration may take place today, as both peer review work and health care professional licensing board investigations are confidential; a health care licensing board may receive an anonymous complaint about an individual who is subsequently under peer review. The filing of a report outlined in this bill begins a licensing board’s efforts, as the report is just the first step in a very lengthy process conducted in accordance with the APA, and offering due process for licensees. However, a health care professional’s livelihood depends on the status of their license and as such, care needs to be exercised to guarantee fairness in each process.
- How will health care facility employees and health care professional licensees know that they could face a fine of up to $50,000 for failing to report allegations to a licensing board? Do colleagues always know who a particular health care professional is licensed by and how to make that board aware of allegations? Ensuring that licensing boards are made aware of serious allegations like sexual abuse and sexual misconduct is key to patient and public safety protection. The inability of health care professional licensing boards to be proactive is frequently raised in discussions about legislation, in oversight hearings, and in media reports. While steps aimed at providing boards key information about their licensees, particularly for information about the types of allegations this bill focuses on, is important, it is also important that licensees are made aware of the new obligation for reporting outlined in this bill. The Author may wish to clarify that health facilities, health care service plans, other entities authorizing a licensed health care professional to provide care for patients (such as postsecondary educational institutions) properly inform employees of their reporting responsibility. The Author may wish to clarify that health care professional licensing boards provide information to licensees about this requirement.
- What is the appropriate amount of time MBC should have, upon issuing an emergency order for license suspension, before a licensee is able to have an ISO hearing before an ALJ? Many factors in MBC enforcement action may not necessarily be within MBC’s control, such as the length of time an investigation takes, the evidence a DAG believes is necessary to include in an accusation, or the ability to come before an ALJ, to name a few.
MBC currently has 30 days to prepare the necessary materials for an ISO hearing. This bill would provide MBC up to 180 days before a licensee receives an ISO hearing, if their license is suspended on emergency order. The timeframe for the ISO hearing needs to be discussed further with stakeholders, including the Office of the Attorney General and Office of Administrative Hearings, to determine exactly how long MBC would need, after receiving credible and troubling information about licensee actions that warrant an emergency suspension in the first place, before everything is in place for the licensee to receive an ISO hearing before an ALJ. Consideration as to the types of information MBC receives demonstrating “that the public health, safety, or welfare requires emergency action” should also be given, balancing the need for timely enforcement action with due process afforded licensees.
NOTE:
Double-referral to Senate Judiciary Committee, second.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Watchdog
Medical Board of California
Opposition:
California Chapter of the American College of Cardiology
California Medical Association
California Society of Plastic Surgeons
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):