SB 433: Youth development and diversion.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-29
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 16, 2019 | May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2019 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Apr 2, 2019 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | April 3 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | March 27 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 13, 2019 | Set for hearing March 27. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and PUB. S. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 6, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 433 (Monning) - Youth development and diversion
Version: April 29, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 6 - 1, HUMAN S. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2019 | Consultant: Debra Cooper |
Bill Summary:
SB 433 would require the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), in collaboration with the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to establish and oversee a three-year, five-county pilot program for the purpose of advancing a comprehensive, coordinated, and expanded approach to youth diversion, with the goal of minimizing youth contact with the juvenile or criminal justice systems.
Fiscal Impact:
One-time costs of approximately $10 million to fund the three-year pilot consisting of:
- Resources for support staff at each of the pilot sites;
- Data collecting, analyzing, and sharing;
- Funding pre-arrest diversion programs.
Unknown, potentially significant costs to CDSS, for the duration of the pilot program, for administration, oversight, and accountability of the pilot program, and to provide necessary guidance to pilot counties.
Background:
According to the bill’s author, in 2017, more than 56,000 youth in California were arrested by law enforcement officers. Approximately 66% of those kids were arrested for misdemeanor and status offenses. Rather than receive supports and services to address their underlying needs via a public health and child development lens, far too many are funneled into the justice system where they experience further harms, increasing their chances of re-incarceration.
Some counties have already developed alternatives to arresting and incarcerating children for low-level offenses, showing improved outcomes for youth and public safety. For instance, in January 2017, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors established a Youth Diversion Subcommittee of the Countywide Criminal Justice Coordination Committee tasked with developing a plan to coordinate effective youth diversion in the county. The Division of Youth Diversion & Development (YDD) – a pre-arrest diversion program – within the County Health Agency’s Office of Diversion & Reentry was established tasked with coordinating diversion and intervention programs and offering a variety of developmentally appropriate, community-based youth services ranging from youth development and enrichment activities to those services that address behavior, effects of trauma, family violence, substance use disorders, and parenting skills.
AB 1812 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 36, Statutes of 2018) established the Youth Reinvestment Grant Program the first-ever state fund specifically dedicated to keeping young people out of the justice system and in the care of community organizations. Then Governor Brown signed a budget that includes $37.3 million for the Youth Reinvestment Fund, to be allocated as follows:
- 94 percent ($35,062,000) awarded to local jurisdictions through a competitive grant process for implementing evidence-based, trauma-informed, culturally relevant, and developmentally appropriate diversion programs in underserved communities with high rates of juvenile arrests and high rates of racial/ethnic disproportionality within those juvenile arrests.
- Three percent ($1,119,000) awarded to Indian tribes for implementing diversion programs for Indian children using trauma-informed, community-based, and health-based interventions.
- Up to three percent ($1,119,000) may be used by the Board of State and Community Corrections for the administration of the grant.
The grant is currently in development and awards are anticipated to be made by June 30, 2019
Proposed Law:
This bill would establish a three-year pilot known as the Office of Youth Development and Diversion (OYDD) Pilot Program. Specifically, the bill would:
- Require CDSS, in collaboration with CDPH to establish and oversee the OYDD pilot program with specified goals;
- Require counties interested in participating in the OYDD pilot program to apply to CDSS;
- Require CDSS to select up to five counties to participate in the OYDD Pilot Program;
- Require CDSS to be responsible for administration, oversight, and accountability of the pilot program, and for CDSS, in collaboration with CDPH and other partner agencies to provide guidance to pilot counties, support data collection and analysis to identify target populations, and track funding allocations and disbursements;
- Specify the limitations and requirements that funding for a county public health department or a county health services department overseeing a local OYDD can be used for;
- Require a county public health department or the county health services department to submit to CDSS data relating to the effectiveness of the pilot program;
- Require a county public health department or a county health services department that is overseeing a local OYDD to provide grants to community-based organizations for services that are community based and located in communities of local jurisdictions with the highest need and require that services be evidence-based or promising practices that are trauma-informed, culturally relevant, and developmentally appropriate diversion programs and alternatives to arrest, incarceration, and formal involvement with the juvenile and criminal justice systems;
- Prohibit grant money from being used for services provided by a police department or other law enforcement agency, a court, the district attorney’s office, the public defender’s office, the city attorney’s office, detention or probation services mandated by state or federal law.
Related Legislation:
AB 1812 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 36, Statutes of 2018) established the Youth Reinvestment Grant Program within the Board of State and Community Corrections to grant funds to local jurisdictions and Indian tribes for the purpose of implementing trauma-informed diversion programs for minors and required the board to be responsible for administration oversight and accountability of the grant program.
Staff Comments:
Staff notes that the bill’s author has requested $10 million in this year’s budget process to fund the development of local pilot OYDD offices. The $10 million are anticipated to cover the cost for four support staff at each of the pilot program sites for three years, collecting and analyzing pilot data, and funding the pre-arrest diversion programs.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Hurtado, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 433
Author: | Monning | ||
Version: | April 11, 2019 | Hearing Date: | April 22, 2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Marisa Shea | ||
Subject: Youth development and diversion
SUMMARY
This bill requires the State Department of Social Services (CDSS), in consultation with the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to establish and oversee a three year, five county pilot program for the purpose of advancing a comprehensive, coordinated, and expanded approach to youth diversion, with the goal of minimizing youth contact with the juvenile or criminal justice systems.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Establishes CDSS within the Health and Human Services Agency to observe and report to the Governor on the conditions of public social services throughout the state and formulate, adopt, amend or repeal regulations and general policies relating to public social services, except health care services and medical assistance. (WIC 10550 et seq.)
- Declares that the provision for public social services is a matter of statewide concern and provides that CDSS is designated as the single state agency with full power to supervise every phase of the administration of public social services, except health care services and medical assistance, as specified. (WIC 10600)
- Establishes DPH within the Health and Human Services Agency to be vested with all the duties, powers, purposes, functions, responsibilities, and jurisdiction of the former State Department of Health Services as they relate to public health, licensing and certification of health facilities, and other functions as provided. (HSC 131000 et seq.)
This Bill:
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature to create a pilot program to award grants and select counties to develop Offices of Youth Development and Diversion (OYDD) to advance a comprehensive, coordinated, and expanded approach to youth diversion across pilot counties, with the goal of minimizing youth contact with the juvenile or criminal justice systems, and to promote positive youth development.
- Requires CDSS, in collaboration with DPH, to establish and oversee a three year pilot program known as the OYDD Pilot Program. Further requires CDSS to award grants pursuant to the OYDD Pilot Program to eligible counties for the establishment of an OYDD that shall be administered by the county public health department or the county health services department.
- Provides the following goals for the OYDD Pilot Program:
- To ensure that a pilot county’s children and youth are healthy, ready to learn, and successful in school, and live in stable, safe, and supported families and communities;
- To ensure that a pilot county is family friendly and supports the family unit;
- To focus on the prevention of public health problems and on supporting and enhancing the strengths of children, youth, and their families;
- To complement a pilot county’s community development efforts;
- To strengthen a community-based network of services in a pilot county;
- To ensure that children and youth with the highest needs receive maximum benefit and that equity is a guiding principle of the funding process;
- To distribute funds based on the best practices and successful and innovative models in order to ensure maximum impact;
- To the maximum extent feasible, distribute funds equitably among services for all age groups, from infancy to transition age;
- To ensure children are provided with gender responsive, culturally relevant, and trauma-informed services;
- To strengthen collaboration around shared outcomes among all service providers for children, youth, and their families, including collaboration among public agencies and nonprofit organizations; and
- To fill gaps in services for youth and leverage other resources whenever feasible.
- Defines certain terms for the purposes of the OYDD Pilot Program.
- Requires CDSS to select up to five counties to participate in the OYDD Pilot Program, including one pilot program in southern California, one pilot program in northern California, and one pilot program in central California.
- Requires a pilot program to be operated in a county that has identified high rates of juvenile and transition-age youth arrests or counties with high rates of racial or ethnic disparities in juvenile and transition-age youth arrests, and further requires local stakeholders to express interest in and demonstrate commitment to hosting a pilot project site.
- Requires CDSS be responsible for the administration, oversight, and accountability of the pilot program.
- Requires CDSS, in collaboration with DPH, to perform all of the following duties:
- Provide guidance to pilot counties, including guidance regarding available federal, state, and local funds for the purposes of training and matching funds;
- Support data collection and analysis to identify target populations with the highest need and to measure program outcomes and impact; and
- Track funding allocations and disbursements in accordance with the pilot program timelines.
- Requires CDSS to post on its Internet Web site a report of the grantees, projects, and outcomes, including the county public health department or county health service department data submitted to CDSS as required, upon the completion of the pilot program.
- Limits a county public health department or a county health services department overseeing a local OYDD funding to administration of the local OYDD, evaluation of the OYDD goals and service and technical assistance and capacity building for services providers and community-based partners providing services to youth through the local OYDD.
- Provides that pilot program funds shall be used by an OYDD to support new program activities or to augment existing funds that expand current program activities, and requires pilot program funds not replace any federal, state, or local funds that have been appropriated for the same purpose.
- Requires funds be disbursed from the local OYDD to community-based organizations that are nongovernmental and not law enforcement agencies to deliver services to underserved communities with high rates of juvenile arrests.
- Requires the county public health department or the county health services department to submit data relating to the effectiveness of the pilot program to CDSS. This data may include, but is not limited to, any of the following:
- Reductions in law enforcement responses to incidents involving children and transition-age youth, reductions in court caseloads and processing, reductions in the number of days that children and transition-age youth spent in detention, reductions in the placement of minors in congregate care, reductions in school and placement disruptions, and reductions in facility staff turnover;
- Improvement in the health and wellness of children and transition-age youth, school and community stability, education attainment, and employment opportunities; and/or
- Projected state and local cost savings as a result of the diversion programming.
- A county public health department or county health services department that is overseeing a local OYDD shall adhere to the following timelines:
- Within the first six months, the county shall do the following:
- Appoint or hire staff to administer and operate the pilot program;
- Engage a multisector stakeholder advisory body, including representation from youth and caregivers;
- Establish a multidisciplinary team that shall meet periodically to review and discuss the implementation, practices, and impact of the program. Further requires the team to include, but not be limited to, representatives from the following: county board of supervisors; community-based organizations; local law enforcement; county health and human services department; youth advocacy groups; school districts; county public health departments; and county probation departments; and
- Identify local capacity and opportunities for youth development and diversion services, in consultation with the county probation department.
- Within the first 18 months, the county shall do the following:
- Establish an oversight entity;
- Develop a centralized referral system;
- Identify county and external funding sources for community-based diversion program;
- Update the county’s environmental scan and conduct a countywide assessment to determine the level of readiness among law enforcement agencies;
- Identify law enforcement agencies for initial expansion or development of diversion based on the level of readiness and local needs assessment; and
- Establish contracts with community-based providers for youth development and diversion services.
- Within the first 24 months, the county shall do all of the following:
- Identify the final cohorts of law enforcement agencies and community-based partners for implementation;
- Identify needs for capacity building among law enforcement and community-based partners;
- Provide technical assistance and training for law enforcement and community-based partners;
- Use assessment and evaluation results to facilitate data-driven decision making and system improvement;
- Convene diversion practitioners and other stakeholders countywide to communicate progress and identify priorities;
- Use assessment and evaluation results to facilitate data-driven decision making; and
- Convene diversion practitioners and other stakeholders countywide to communicate progress and identify priorities.
- Requires a local OYDD pilot program to be fully implemented and operation not later than 24 months after the funds are received by the county.
- Within the first six months, the county shall do the following:
- Provides that the three year pilot program timeline commences once funds are received by the county public health department or by the county health services department.
- Requires the county public health department or health services department that is overseeing the local OYDD to provide grants to community based organizations for services that are community based and located in communities of local jurisdictions with the highest need, as identified by stakeholders as provided.
- Requires the services that receive pilot program funding to be evidence-based or promising practices that are trauma-informed, culturally relevant, and developmentally appropriate diversion programs and alternatives to arrest, incarceration, and formal involvement with the juvenile and criminal justice systems. Further provides that services may include, but are not limited to any of the following:
- Educational services, including academic, tutoring, and college readiness services;
- Mentoring services;
- Behavioral health services;
- Mental health services;
- Recreational, cultural, and after school programs;
- Health services, including prevention, education, and behavioral and mental health services;
- Vocational training, job placement, and employment, including apprenticeships;
- Youth empowerment and leadership development;
- Youth violence prevention programs;
- Family and parent support services;
- Driver’s education programs;
- Support for collaboration among grantees to enhance service delivery and provider capacity building, as well as for community development efforts; and/or
- Restorative justice services.
- Prohibits pilot program grant funding from being used for services provided by a police department or other law enforcement agency, a court, the district attorney’s office, the public defender’s office, or the city attorney’s office. Further prohibits the use of grant funding for detention or probation services mandated by state or federal law.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “a disproportionate number of young people arrested for misdemeanor and status offenses are children of color, children with disabilities, foster children, and youth who identify as LGBTQ. Justice system involved youth often suffer from abuse, abandonment, neglect, trauma, and developmental disabilities that influence their behaviors. Rather than receive supports and services to address their underlying needs via a public health and child development lens, far too many young people are funneled into the justice system, where they experience further harm and increased chances of re-incarceration.”
Due to these disparities and outcomes, the author has introduced SB 433 to establish a 3 year pilot program under CDSS that will provide grants for up to five counties for the purpose of establishing an OYDD. The author states that “OYDDs will use public and mental health approaches to effectively address children and families’ unmet health needs in their communities, while avoiding unnecessary, harmful youth incarceration.”
Child Welfare Services
California’s child welfare services (CWS) system is an essential component of the state’s safety net. Social workers in each county receive reports of abuse or neglect, investigate and resolve those reports. Abused and neglected children who have been removed from their homes fall under the jurisdiction of the county’s juvenile dependency court. The dependency court holds legal jurisdiction over the child, while the child is served by the CWS system social worker. This system seeks to ensure the safety and protection of the children, and where possible, preserve and strengthen families through visitation and family reunification. The CWS system provides multiple opportunities for the custody of the child, or the child’s placement outside of the home, to be evaluated, reviewed and determined by the judicial system, in consultation with the child’s social worker to help provide the best possible services to the child. It is the state’s goal to reunify a foster child or youth with their biological family whenever possible. In instances where reunification is not possible, it is the state’s goal to provide a permanent placement alternative such as adoption or guardianship, with the second highest placement priority of the CWS system being to unite children with other relatives or nonrelative extended family members.
As of July 1, 2018 there were an estimated 51,969 children in California’s child welfare system.
Juvenile Detention Facilities
California’s county probation officers are responsible for caring for children who are arrested and subsequently made wards of the juvenile court. Children may be housed in camps or ranches, or in the juvenile hall, which is a jail-like facility dedicated to youth offenders. Juvenile delinquency facilities are in the policy jurisdiction of the Senate Public Safety Committee, where this bill was heard prior to this Committee’s hearing.
Los Angeles County’s Youth Diversion and Development Program
Los Angeles County established a Youth Diversion and Development (YDD) division within the County Health Agency’s Office of Diversion and Reentry in November 2017. The YDD division was created as a result of recommendations for youth diversion provided to the County Board of Supervisors from a Youth Diversion Subcommittee of the Countywide Criminal Justice Coordination Committee. The Youth Diversion Subcommittee was created by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors in January 2017, in part because Los Angeles County is home to the largest juvenile justice system in the nation.[1] The OYDD Pilot Program created by this bill is loosely modeled after Los Angeles County’s YDD division.
The YDD division was created to advance an “evidence-informed, coordinated, and comprehensive model of youth diversion and youth development that empowers community-based organizations as the primary providers of youth diversion services in lieu of arrest with the goal of equitably reducing young people’s involvement in the justice system in Los Angeles County.”[2] Additionally, the YDD division is intended to build the infrastructure needed in order to connect youth with these community-based activities and services. The YDD division is set up to contract with diversion providers in the community who will receive funding, tailored capacity building, connections to potential partners for referral and service coordination, and other resources as a result of these contracts.
This new model has not yet been fully implemented by Los Angeles County, but once diversion partnerships have been established through YDD division contracts with community-based providers, law enforcement agencies will begin referring eligible and suitable youth to those providers in lieu of arrest or citation. Diversion providers will carry out or refer clients to individualized developmentally appropriate community-based services including, but not limited to: youth development enrichment activities; case management, care coordination, and systems navigation; trauma responsive preventive services and treatment for physical, mental health and substance abuse needs; housing and transportation support; educational and vocational support; credible mentorship; family engagement and support; and restorative or transformative justice practices.[3]
Related/Prior Legislation:
AB 1998 (Campos, Chapter 880, Statutes 2016) required the Board of State and Community Corrections, by January 1, 2018, to develop recommendations for best practices and standardizations for counties on how to disaggregate juvenile justice caseload and performance and outcome data by race and ethnicity. AB 1998 also consolidated and revised the data that is required to be collected and reported for two major state juvenile justice grant programs, as specified.
COMMENTS
This bill establishes a three year pilot project by which CDSS provides grant funding for up to 5 counties for the creation of a county OYDD. The OYDD is to be administered by the county public health department or the county health services department. The OYDD envisioned by this bill is loosely modeled after the Los Angeles County Youth Development and Diversion program and this bill provides goals, timelines, and requirements for the pilot counties’ OYDD. The author’s goal for the OYDD pilot program is the upstream diversion of youth who may otherwise end up justice system involved. Thus, local OYDDs are intended to partner with community organizations to provide services to development and diversion services to youth before they are justice system involved. However, if OYDD programs intend to provide services to youth that are already probation involved, clarifications may be needed.
If this bill passes out of this committee, the author’s office may wish to clarify within in the bill that counties will apply to CDSS to participate in this pilot program.
SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Arguments in Support:
The National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter, writes:
“This bill follows in the footsteps of the Legislature’s recent efforts to reform the criminal justice system. It has been recognized that mass incarceration and mandatory sentencing laws have resulted in a bloated system that is unequally applied, does not reduce recidivism or address the underlying reasons as to why people are involved with our justice system.
Youth need special treatment when it comes to the criminal justice system. Many counties in the state have begun to shift youth to diversion and intervention programs which address the underlying needs of the child through a public health and development lens. This will prevent youth from entering a system that foster recidivism and creates further harm.”
Arguments in Opposition:
The Chief Probation Officers of California, writes:
“While the goals and intent of the bill are commendable and of significant importance, we are concerned about the approach this bill takes in setting up new Offices of Youth Development and Diversion. The stated focus of these offices is duplicative to existing probation programs and county infrastructure which already administer diversion services and programs in coordination with community-based organizations and other government agencies, to meet the measure’s state goals as well as the needs of youth and families.
As such, there will be significant time, costs, and personnel required to set up new Offices of Youth Development and Diversion and to coordinate all the entities named in the bill. Knowing that the focus is on getting resources to the youth and corresponding programs, we believe the goals of the bill can be achieved by working in coordination with probation, community-based organizations, and other county departments within current local models and partnerships.”
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Public Safety: | 6 - 1 |
POSITIONS
Support:
Alum Rock Counseling Center
California Alliance of Child and Family Services
California Public Defenders Association
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Root & Rebound
Southwest Key Programs
The Center for Juvenile Law and Policy
Oppose:
Chief Probation Officers of California
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 433 Hearing Date: April 9, 2019
Author: | Monning | ||
Version: | March 28, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SJ | ||
Subject: Youth Development and Diversion
HISTORY
Source: National Center for Youth Law
Prior Legislation: AB 1812 (Com. on Budget), Ch. 36, Stats. 2018
Support: Alliance for Boys and Men of Color; American Academy of Pediatrics, California; Anti-Recidivism Coalition; California Public Defenders Association; Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice; ConXión; Courage Campaign; County Health Executives Association of California; Community, Agency for Resources, Advocacy, and Services; County of Santa Clara; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; Fight Crime: Invest in Kids, California; GRACE; Healing Dialogue and Action; Intertribal Court of Southern California; Juvenile Court Judges of California; Los Angeles Conservation Corps; National Association of Social Worker, California; National Center for Lesbian Rights; Pacific Juvenile Defense Center; Root & Rebound; W. Haywood Burns Institute; Women’s Foundation of California; Young Women’s Freedom Center; Youth Mentoring; Youth Alliance
Opposition: California Probation Officers of California
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to require the state Department of Social Services, in collaboration with the State Department of Public Health, to establish and oversee a 3-year pilot program known as the Office of Youth Development and Diversion Pilot Program.
Existing law establishes the state Department of Social Services (CDSS). (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 10550.)
Existing law declares that provision for public social services is a matter of statewide concern. Provides that CDSS is designated as the single state agency with full power to supervise every phase of the administration of public social services, except health care services and medical assistance, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 10600.)
Existing law establishes the State Department of Public Health within the Health and Human Services Agency. (Health & Saf., § 131000.)
This bill declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:
- Create a pilot program to be overseen by CDSS to award grants to select counties to develop pilot Offices of Youth Development and Diversion (OYDD).
- Advance a comprehensive, coordinated, and expanded approach to youth diversion across pilot counties, with a goal of minimizing youth contact with the juvenile or criminal justice systems.
- Promote positive youth development amongst children, teens, and transition-age youth, with an emphasis on youth who would otherwise be entering into the juvenile and criminal justice systems or penetrating deeper into the juvenile and criminal justice systems.
This bill requires DSS, in collaboration with the State Department of Public Health (DPH) to establish and oversee a three-year pilot program known as the OYDD Pilot Program.
This bill requires CDSS to award grants pursuant to the program to eligible counties to establish a local OYDD. Requires the local OYDD to be administered by the county public health department or the county health services department.
This bill provides that the goals of the program include all of the following:
- To ensure that a pilot county’s children and youth are healthy, ready to learn, and successful in school, and live in stable, safe, and supported families and communities.
- To ensure that a pilot county is family friendly and supports the family unit.
- To focus on the prevention of public health problems and on supporting and enhancing the strengths of children, youth, and their families.
- To complement a pilot county’s community development efforts.
- To strengthen a community-based network of services in a pilot county.
- To ensure that children and youth with the highest needs receive maximum benefit and that equity is a guiding principle of the funding process.
- To distribute funds based on best practices and successful and innovative models in order to ensure maximum impact.
- To the maximum extent feasible, to distribute funds equitably among services for all age groups, from infancy to transition age.
- To ensure children are provided with gender responsive, culturally relevant, and trauma-informed services.
- To strengthen collaboration around shared outcomes among all service providers for children, youth, and their families, including collaboration among public agencies and nonprofit organizations.
- To fill gaps in services for youth and leverage other resources whenever feasible.
This bill provides the following definitions:
- “Evidence-based practice” means a practice with an emphasis on achieving measurable outcomes that ensure that the services provided and the resources used are effective. Evidence-based practices involve using research-based and scientific studies to identify interventions that reliably produce significant reductions in recidivism when correctly applied to offender populations through the use of the following four principles of effective intervention:
- Risk Principle, which focuses attention on the crucial question of who is being served and targets services for higher risk offenders.
- Need Principle, which requires that priority be given to addressing known criminogenic risks and factors to determine what programs will be most effective.
- Treatment Principle, which conveys the importance of using behavioral treatment approaches to achieve the best possible outcomes and requires attention to the question of how programs are delivered.
- Fidelity Principle, which draws attention to how effectively programs are delivered and reiterates the necessity that programs be implemented as designed.
- “Health and wellness” means physical, social, and mental well-being.
- “High rate” means a rate that exceeds the state average.
- “Pilot program” means a program implemented on a temporary and limited basis in order to test and evaluate the effectiveness of the program, develop new techniques, or gather information.
- “Promising practice” means a program or practice that has some research demonstrating its effectiveness but does not meet the full criteria for an evidence-based designation.
- “Target populations” includes children, teens, and transition-age youth who are homeless or in danger of homelessness, have dropped out of high school, have a disability or other special needs, including substance abuse and mental health needs, have low-income parents, are undocumented, are new immigrants or English learners, are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, or intersex (“LGBTQQI”), or at risk of entering or transitioning from the foster care, juvenile justice, or criminal justice systems.
- “Transition-age youth” means individuals who are 18 to 25 years of age.
- “Trauma-informed” means an approach that involves an understanding of adverse childhood experiences and responses to symptoms of chronic interpersonal trauma and traumatic stress across the lifespan of an individual.
This bill requires CDSS to select up to five counties to participate in the OYDD Pilot Program, including one pilot project in southern California, one pilot project in northern California, and one pilot project in central California.
This bill requires a pilot project to be operated in a county that has identified high rates of juvenile and transition-age youth arrests or counties with high rates of racial or ethnic disparities in juvenile and transition-age youth arrests.
This bill provides that local stakeholders shall express interest in and demonstrate commitment to hosting a pilot project site.
This bill requires CDSS to be responsible for administration, oversight, and accountability of the pilot program.
This bill requires CDSS, in collaboration with DPH and other partner agencies, to perform all of the following duties:
- Provide guidance to pilot counties, including guidance regarding available federal, state, and local funds for the purposes of braiding and matching funds.
- Support data collection and analysis to identify target populations with the highest need and to measure program outcomes and impact.
- Track funding allocations and disbursements in accordance with the pilot program timelines.
- Post on its internet website a report of the grantees, projects, and outcomes, including all of the information submitted to the DSS, as specified, by a county public health department or a county health services department upon completion of the three-year pilot program.
This bill provides that funding for a county public health department or a county health services department overseeing a local OYDD shall be limited to the following:
- Administration of the local OYDD and evaluation of the OYDD goals and services.
- Technical assistance and capacity building for service providers and community-based partners providing services to youth through the local OYDD.
This bill requires that funds be used by an OYDD to support new program activities or to augment existing funds that expand current program activities. Provides that funds shall not replace any federal, state, or local funds that have been appropriated for the same purpose.
This bill requires funds to be disbursed from the local OYDD to community-based organizations that are nongovernmental and not law enforcement agencies to deliver services in underserved communities with high rates of juvenile arrests.
This bill requires the county public health department or the county health services department to submit data relating to the effectiveness of the pilot program to CDSS. Provides that information may include, but is not limited to, any of the following:
- Reductions in law enforcement responses to incidents involving children and transition-age youth, reductions in court caseloads and processing, reductions in the number of days that children and transition-age youth spent in detention, reductions in the placement of minors in congregate care, reductions in school and placement disruptions, and reductions in facility staff turnover.
- Improvement in the health and wellness of children and transition-age youth, school and community stability, educational attainment, and employment opportunities.
- Projected state and local cost savings as a result of the diversion programming.
This bill requires a county public health department or a county health services department that is overseeing a local OYDD to adhere to the following timelines:
- Requires the county to do all of the following within the first six months:
- Appoint or hire staff to administer and operate the pilot program.
- Engage a multisector stakeholder advisory body, including representation from youth and caregivers.
- Establish a multidisciplinary team to meet periodically to review and discuss the implementation, practices, and impact of the program. Requires the team to include, but not be limited to, representatives from the following:
- County board of supervisors.
- Community-based organizations.
- Local law enforcement.
- County health and human services department.
- Youth advocacy groups.
- School districts.
- County public health department.
- Identify local capacity and opportunities for youth development and diversion services.
- Requires the county public health department or the county health services department to do all of the following within the first 18 months:
- Establish an oversight entity.
- Develop a centralized referral system.
- Identify county and external funding sources for community-based diversion programming.
- Update the county’s environmental scan and conduct a countywide assessment to determine the level of readiness among law enforcement agencies.
- Identify law enforcement agencies for initial expansion or development of diversion based on the level of readiness and local needs assessment.
- Establish contracts with community-based providers for youth development and diversion services.
- Requires the county public health department or the county health services department to do all of the following within the first 24 months:
- Identify the final cohorts of law enforcement agencies and community-based partners for implementation.
- Identify needs for capacity building among law enforcement and community-based partners.
- Provide technical assistance and training for law enforcement and community-based partners.
- Use assessment and evaluation results to facilitate data-driven decisionmaking and system improvement.
- Convene diversion practitioners and other stakeholders countywide to communicate progress and identify priorities.
- Use assessment and evaluation results to facilitate data-driven decisionmaking.
- Convene diversion practitioners and other stakeholders countywide to communicate progress and identify priorities.
- Requires a local OYDD pilot program to be fully implemented and operational not later than 24 months after funds are received by the county.
This bill provides that the three-year pilot program timeline commences once funds are received by the county public health department or by the county health services department.
This bill requires a county public health department or a county health services department that is overseeing a local OYDD to provide grants to community-based organizations for services that are community based and located in communities of local jurisdictions with the highest need.
This bill requires that services be evidence-based or promising practices that are trauma-informed, culturally relevant, and developmentally appropriate diversion programs and alternatives to arrest, incarceration, and formal involvement with the juvenile and criminal justice systems.
This bill provides that services may include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
- Educational services, including academic, tutoring, and college readiness services.
- Mentoring services.
- Behavioral health services.
- Mental health services.
- Recreational, cultural, and after school programs.
- Health services, including prevention, education, and behavioral and mental health services.
- Vocational training, job placement, and employment, including apprenticeships.
- Youth empowerment and leadership development.
- Youth violence prevention programs.
- Family and parent support services.
- Driver’s education programs.
- Support for collaboration among grantees to enhance service delivery and provider capacity building, as well as for community development efforts.
- Restorative justice services.
This bill prohibits grant money from being used for services provided by a police department or other law enforcement agency, a court, the district attorney’s office, the public defender’s office, or the city attorney’s office. Prohibits grant money from being used for detention or probation services mandated by state or federal law.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author:
In 2017, more than 56,000 youth in California were arrested by law enforcement officers. Approximately 66% of those kids were arrested for misdemeanor and status offenses. A disproportionate number were children of color, children with disabilities, foster children, and youth who identify as LGBTQ. System-involved youth often suffer from abuse, abandonment, neglect, trauma, and developmental disabilities that influence their behaviors. Rather than receive supports and services to address their underlying needs via a public health and child development lens, far too many are funneled into the justice system where they experience further harms, increasing their chances of re-incarceration.
Some counties have already developed alternatives to arresting and incarcerating children for low-level offenses, showing improved outcomes for youth and public safety. For example, in 2017 Los Angeles County developed an Office of Youth Development and Diversion to coordinate its diversion and intervention programs and offer a variety of developmentally appropriate, community-based youth services ranging from youth development and enrichment activities to those services that address behavior, effects of trauma, family violence, substance use disorders, and parenting skills.
…
SB 433 establishes a 3-year pilot program under the California Department of Social Services that will provide grants for up to five California counties to establish an Office of Youth Development and Diversion (OYDD).
The pilot program would be administered by the California Department of Social Services at the state level, and locally administered by the county’s public health or health services departments. The measure would provide grants to pilot counties to establish an OYDD that would act as a centralized hub for fostering health–centered responses and services to justice-involved youth.
Each county participating in the pilot program will be required to contract with service providers, collect data, track youth outcomes, and report to its board of supervisors and the Legislature on the impact that the OYDDs had on youth involved with the criminal justice system.
The specific impacts on state-level agencies are spelled out in the language of the bill, which directs the Department of Social Services to establish and oversee the pilot program…
…
Most of the “on the ground” implementation of the program will be done by the local county health departments of the participating counties.
- Los Angeles County’s Youth Diversion & Development Program
In January 2017, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors established a Youth Diversion Subcommittee of the Countywide Criminal Justice Coordination Committee tasked with developing a plan to coordinate effective youth diversion in the county. The subcommittee developed recommendations for youth diversion, which the Board of Supervisors adopted in November 2017. In doing so, the Division of Youth Diversion & Development (YDD) within the County Health Agency’s Office of Diversion & Reentry was established. The stated purpose of the division is to “advance an evidence-informed, coordinated, and comprehensive model of youth diversion and youth development that empowers community-based organizations as the primary providers of youth diversion services in lieu of arrest with the goal of equitably reducing young people's involvement with the justice system in Los Angeles County.” (<http://dhs.lacounty.gov/wps/portal/dhs/!ut/p/b0/04_Sj9CPykssy0xPLMnMz0vMAfGjzOLdDAwM3P2dgo0MQvxNDQINfDxCjJ0tDA3MTPULsh0VAeUsKvs!/> [as of Apr. 2, 2019].)
The Los Angeles County YDD program is a pre-arrest diversion program. Youth arrested for status, misdemeanor, and non-707(b) felony offenses are eligible for the program. (Youth Development and Diversion Summit, Understanding Los Angeles County’s New Model to Help Youth Thrive and Succeed, <http://file.lacounty.gov/SDSInter/dhs/1034535_YDDSummitPresentation3_1_18.pdf> [as of Apr. 2, 2019].) As of January 2019, Los Angeles County’s program was still in the implementation stage. (Los Angeles County, Executive Office, Board Directed Priorities: January 2019 Update at p. 13 <http://file.lacounty.gov/SDSInter/bos/supdocs/132676.pdf >; see also <http://file.lacounty.gov/SDSInter/bos/bc/1047835_ProgressReportonCountywide ImplementationofYouthDiversionandDevelopmentEfforts_ItemNo.29-AAgendaofNov72017_.pdf> [as of Apr. 2, 2019].)
A presentation from the Los Angeles County’s Youth Diversion and Development Summit provides insight into how the diversion program is envisioned to operate. (<http://file.lacounty.gov/SDSInter/dhs/1034535_YDDSummitPresentation3_1_18.pdf> [as of Apr. 2, 2019].) The County’s YDD is a central office that provides countywide coordination of youth diversion efforts and contracts with community-based organizations to provide diversion services. Under the YDD model, a law enforcement officer refers eligible and suitable youth to a community-based diversion partner in lieu of arrest or citation. The community-based organization then conducts an intake assessment and develop an individualized diversion plan taking into account the youth’s risks, needs, and interests. Upon completion of successful diversion, the youth’s case is dismissed and the youth does not have a criminal record. In the event a youth is unable to complete the diversion program, the youth’s case may be returned to the referring agency. Importantly, diversion partners share critical information with each other, and collect data needed to perform program- and county-level assessments.
- Effect of This Bill
This bill would require CDSS to collaborate with DPH to establish and oversee a 3-year youth diversion and development pilot program. CDSS would oversee the pilot program. The department would select up to five counties to take part in the pilot and award grants to those counties. CDSS would be required to provide guidance to the counties, including on how to acquire additional funding, support data collection and analysis, and report on projects and outcomes at the conclusion of the pilot program. Each participating county would establish an OYDD that would be administered by the county public health or health services department. The OYDD would disperse funds to community-based organizations to deliver services to the youth participating in the diversion program. The bill outlines specific goals, timelines, and requirements for the local OYDD, including submitting specified data to CDSS, timelines for implementing the program, and requirements for qualifying services that may be offered by community-based organizations.
This bill raises a number of questions, including:
What is the selection process to determine which counties to include in the pilot?
Should the definition of “transition-age youth” include 18 to 25 year olds, or should it be narrowed?
Are the timelines established in the bill, including the requirement that all OYDD be fully implemented within 24 months of receipt of funding, reasonable?
Given that LA County has not fully implemented its own youth diversion program and does not yet have data on outcomes, is it premature to establish this pilot program?
- Argument in Support
The Pacific Juvenile Defense Center writes:
Currently, the California criminal and juvenile justice system punishes youth despite their need for help. Detention, generally used as a disciplinary measure, and going through the justice system is traumatic in itself and not responsive to the youth’s mental development and treatment needed. …Providing youth alternatives to the criminal and juvenile justice system would advance the comprehensive approach to diversion and rehabilitation without additional trauma resulting from and imposed by the justice system.
Existing law does not include Department of Social Services involvement with youth in the criminal and juvenile systems, nor does it go far enough to ensure youth have alternatives to the criminal justice system.
SB 433 provides an alternative to juvenile and criminal systems in providing the holistic, rehabilitative approach envisioned by the Legislature. SB 433 minimizes additional trauma, reduces recidivism, reduces long term mental health issues and promotes community safety.
- Argument in Opposition
According to the California Probation Officers of California:
We…share the mission of providing services to youth to assist them in developing prosocial networks and systems of support. Probation has a long history of actively engaging in youth prevention and diversion and successfully working with youth to keep them from entering the juvenile justice system and providing for diversion services.
Toward this end, while the goals and intent of the bill are commendable and of significant importance, we are concerned about the approach this bill takes in setting up new Offices of Youth Development and Diversion. The stated focus of these offices is duplicative to existing probation programs and county infrastructure which already administer diversion services and programs in coordination with community-based organizations and other government agencies, to meet the measure’s stated goals as well as the needs of youth and families.
As such, there will be significant time, costs, and personnel required to set up new Offices of Youth Development and Diversion and to coordinate all the entities named in this bill. Knowing that the focus is on getting resources to the youth and corresponding programs, we believe the goals of the bill can be achieved by working in coordination with probation, community-based organizations, and other county departments within current local models and partnerships.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):