SB 438: Emergency medical services: dispatch.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-01
Existing law, the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, requires every local public agency to establish within its jurisdiction a basic emergency telephone system that includes, at a minimum, police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Existing law authorizes a public agency to incorporate private ambulance service into the system.
This bill would prohibit a public agency from delegating, assigning, or contracting for 911 emergency call processing services for the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the delegation or assignment is to, or the contract or agreement is with, another public agency. The bill would exempt from that prohibition a public agency that is a joint powers authority that delegated, assigned, or contracted for 911 call processing services on or before January 1, 2019, under certain conditions. The bill would also authorize a public agency that delegated, assigned, or contracted for 911 call processing services on or before January 1, 2019, to continue to do so with the concurrence of the public safety agencies that provide prehospital emergency medical services. If a public safety agency does not concur with the public agency to continue to delegate, assign, or contract for those services, the bill would authorize the public agency to continue to delegate, assign, or contract for those services for the remaining concurring public safety agencies. The bill would state the Legislatures intent to affirm and clarify a public agencys duty and authority to develop emergency communication procedures and respond quickly to a person seeking emergency services through the 911 emergency telephone system.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, authorizes each county to develop an emergency medical services (EMS) program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law delegates responsibility over the medical direction and management of an EMS system to the medical director of the local EMS agency, and requires the local EMS agency to maintain medical control over the EMS system in accordance with minimum standards established by the Emergency Medical Services Authority.
This bill would require a public safety agency that provides 911 call processing services for medical response to make a connection available from the public safety agency dispatch center to an EMS providers dispatch center, as specified. The bill would provide that the public safety agency is entitled to recover from an EMS provider the actual costs incurred in establishing and maintaining the connection. The bill would require the local EMS-agency-authorized EMS providers and the EMS system providers within the jurisdiction of the incident, to be simultaneously notified and dispatched at the same response mode. The bill would require a local EMS agency to review and approve or deny a public safety agencys plan to implement an emergency medical dispatcher or advanced life support program within 90 days of submission of the plan.
This bill would provide that medical control by a local EMS agency medical director, or medical direction and management of an EMS system, may not be construed to, among other things, limit the authority of a public safety agency to directly receive and process 911 emergency requests originating within the agencys territorial jurisdiction or authorize a local EMS agency to unilaterally reduce a public safety agencys response mode below that of the EMS transport provider, prevent a public safety response, or alter the deployment of emergency response resources within the agencys territorial jurisdiction. The bill would also clarify that a public safety agency does not transfer its authority to administer emergency medical services to a local EMS agency by adhering to the policies, procedures, and protocols adopted by a local EMS agency.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The provision of fire protection services, rescue services, emergency medical services, hazardous material response services, ambulance services, and other services related to the protection of lives and property is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the state.
(b)It is in the public interest that emergency services be deployed quickly and efficiently in the interest of saving lives and reducing the damage or destruction of property.
(c)The establishment of a uniform, statewide policy regarding a public agencys ability to receive and process emergency calls is a matter of statewide concern and an interest to all inhabitants and citizens of this state.
(d)The purpose of the act that added this section is to affirm and clarify a public agencys duty, responsibility, and jurisdiction to establish and improve emergency communication procedures and quickly respond to any person calling the telephone number 911 seeking fire, medical, rescue, or other emergency services.
SEC. 2.Section 53110 of the Government Code is amended to read:53110.(a)Every system shall include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services, and may include other emergency services, in the discretion of the affected local public agency, such as poison control services, suicide prevention services, and civil defense services. The system may incorporate private ambulance service. In areas in which a public safety agency of the state provides emergency services, the system shall include the public safety agency or agencies.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a public agency shall not delegate, assign, or enter into a contract for 911 call processing services for the dispatch of emergency response resources except as provided in subdivision (c) or if the delegation or assignment is to, or the contract or agreement is with, another public agency.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the following entities may delegate or assign to a nonpublic agency, or contract with a nonpublic agency for, 911 call processing services only as described in paragraphs (1) and (2).
(1)A joint powers authority that delegated, assigned, or contracted for 911 call processing services on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to delegate, assign, or contract for those services and may, upon the expiration of the delegation, assignment, or contract, renegotiate or adopt new contracts, if the membership of the joint powers authority includes all public safety agencies that provide prehospital emergency medical services and the joint powers authority consents to the continued delegation, assignment, or renegotiation or adoption of the contract.
(2)A public agency that has delegated, assigned, or contracted for 911 call processing services on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to do so with the concurrence of the public safety agencies that provide prehospital emergency medical services. If a public safety agency does not concur with the delegation, assignment, or contracting of the 911 call processing services within its jurisdictional boundaries, the following shall apply:
(A)The public agency may continue to delegate, assign, or contract for 911 call processing services as described in this paragraph for the remaining concurring public safety agencies, and the nonconcurring public safety agency shall discharge 911 call processing duties within its jurisdictional boundaries. Notwithstanding this subparagraph, if the delegation, assignment, or contract provided the option for one or more public safety agencies to withdraw from the delegation, assignment, or contract, the terms of that delegation, assignment, or contract shall prevail.
(B)If continuing the delegation, assignment, or contract described in subparagraph (A) is not feasible, the withdrawing public safety agency shall assume 911 call processing services for the service area originally subject to delegation, assignment, or contract.
(d)This section does not prohibit a public agency or public safety agency from entering into an agreement for backup 911 call processing services.
SEC. 3.Section 1797.223 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.223.(a)(1)A public safety agency that provides 911 call processing services for emergency medical response shall make a connection available from the public safety agency dispatch center to an emergency medical services (EMS) providers dispatch center for the timely transmission of emergency response information.
(2)A public safety agency shall be entitled to recover from an EMS provider the actual costs incurred in establishing and maintaining a connection required by this subdivision.
(3)An EMS provider that elects not to use the connection provided pursuant to this subdivision shall be dispatched by the appropriate public safety agency and charged a rate negotiated by the parties.
(4)If an EMS provider is not directly dispatched from a public safety agency, the response interval for calculations for that EMS provider shall not include the call processing times of the public safety agency and shall begin upon receipt of notification by the EMS provider of the emergency response caller data, either electronically or by any other means prescribed in paragraph (5).
(5)For purposes of this subdivision, connection means either a direct computer aided dispatch (CAD) to CAD link, where permissible under law, between the public safety agency and an EMS provider or an indirect connection, including, but not limited to, a ring down line, intercom, radio, or other electronic means for timely notification of caller data and the location of the emergency response.
(b)Unless a local EMS agency has approved an emergency medical dispatch (EMD) program in conformance with Section 1798.8, that allows for a tiered or modified response, the local EMS-agency-authorized EMS system providers, and the statutorily authorized EMS system providers within the jurisdiction of the incident, shall be simultaneously notified, or as close as technologically feasible, and dispatched at the same response mode.
(c)A public safety agency implementing an EMD program shall be subject to the review and approval of the local EMS agency, and shall perform 911 call processing services and operate the program in accordance with applicable state guidelines and regulations, and the policies adopted by the local EMS agency that are consistent with Section 1798.8.
(d)A local EMS agency shall review and approve or deny a public safety agencys plan to implement an EMD or advanced life support program within 90 days of submission of the plan. A public safety agency may elect to appeal any action of a local EMS agency as described in paragraphs (1) and (2):
(1)If a public safety agencys application for an EMD or advanced life support program is not timely approved or is denied, an appeal shall be conducted in conformance with the administrative adjudication proceedings set forth in Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(2)A final decision rendered pursuant to this subdivision may be appealed to a court of competent jurisdiction.
(e)This section does not authorize a public safety agency to alter the response of a local EMS-agency-authorized EMS transport provider, including EMS transport providers operating pursuant to Section 1797.224, unless authorized by a local EMS agency.
(f)Nothing in this section supersedes Section 1797.201.
SEC. 4.Section 1798.8 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1798.8.(a)Notwithstanding any provision of this division, medical control by a local EMS agency medical director, or medical direction and management of an emergency medical services system, as described in this chapter, shall not be construed to do any of the following:
(1)Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a public safety agencys authority to directly receive and process requests for assistance originating within the public safety agencys territorial jurisdiction through the emergency 911 system established pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 53100) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code. This paragraph does not supersede the local EMS agencys authority to adopt and implement emergency lifesaving instructions or EMD prearrival instructions.
(2)Authorize or permit a local EMS agency to delegate, assign, or enter into a contract in contravention of subdivision (b) of Section 53110 of the Government Code.
(3)Authorize or permit a local EMS agency to unilaterally reduce a public safety agencys response mode below that of the EMS transport provider, prevent a public safety response, or alter the deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the public safety agencys territorial jurisdiction.
(4)Authorize or permit a local EMS agency to prevent a public safety agency from providing mutual aid pursuant to the California Emergency Services Act (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 8550) of Division 1 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(b)A public safety agencys adherence to the policies, procedures, and protocols adopted by a local EMS agency does not constitute a transfer of any of the public safety agencys authorities regarding the administration of emergency medical services.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 1, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 389, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 1, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 6.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (July 9). |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | July 3 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 18, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 13, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and HEALTH. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 4.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | April 24 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and HEALTH. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 4, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB438 Hertzberg et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | SB 438 Hertzberg Senate Third Reading By Eggman | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB438 Hertzberg et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Health] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 438 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 438
Amended: 7/11/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 5/1/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Grove, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
SENATE FLOOR: 32-4, 5/22/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Borgeas, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dodd
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-4, 9/3/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services: dispatch
SOURCE: California Professional Firefighters
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a public agency from entering into a contract for 911 call processing services unless the contract is with another public agency, with specified exceptions, and defines medical control, as provided.
Assembly Amendments establish additional exemptions, require a public safety agency to make a connection available from the public safety agency dispatch center to an emergency medical services (EMS) provider’s dispatch center, as specified, and make other changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point (PSAP).
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a public safety agency provides ambulance emergency services, to include such public safety agencies. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services.
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for emergency medical services (EMS), and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority, which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures.
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA) responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations.
- Requires every LEMSA to have a licensed physician as medical director, to assure medical accountability throughout the planning, implementation, and evaluation of the EMS system. Requires the medical direction and management of an EMS system to be under the medical control of the medical director.
- Requires authority for patient health care management in an emergency to be vested in the licensed or certified health care professional, including any paramedic or other prehospital emergency personnel, at the scene of the emergency who is most medically qualified regarding the provision of rendering emergency medical care. If no licensed or certified health care professional is available, requires the authority to be vested in the most appropriate medically qualified representative of public safety agencies who may have responded to the scene of the emergency.
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county.
This bill:
- Prohibits a public agency from delegating, assigning, or entering into a contract for “911” call processing services regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the delegation or assignment is to, or the contract is with, another public agency.
- Exempts from the prohibition in 1) above the following entities:
- A joint powers authority (JPA) that contracted for dispatch of emergency response resources on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to contract for dispatch of those resources and renegotiate or adopt new contracts, if the membership of the JPA includes all public safety agencies (PSAs) that provide prehospital EMS and the JPA consents to the renegotiation or adoption of the contract; or,
- A public agency that has contracted for 911 call processing services on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to do so with the concurrence of the PSAs providing prehospital EMS. If a PSA does not concur:
- The public agency may continue to contract for 911 call processing services for those agencies that do concur, while the non-concurring agency processes calls within its jurisdiction, and
- If continuing the contract is not feasible, the withdrawing public safety agency shall assume “911” call processing services for the service area originally subject to delegation, assignment, or contract.
- Requires a PSA that provides 911 call processing services for EMS to make a connection available from the PSA dispatch center to an EMS provider’s dispatch center for the timely transmission of emergency response information.
- Authorizes a PSA to recover the costs incurred in establishing and maintaining a connection required pursuant to 3) above, from an EMS provider.
- Requires an EMS provider that elects not to use the connection provided pursuant to 3) above, to be dispatched by the appropriate PSA and charged a rate negotiated by the parties.
- Prohibits the response interval calculations for an EMS provider that it not directly dispatched from a PSA from including the call processing times of the PSA, and requires the response interval calculations to begin upon receipt of notification by the EMS provider of the emergency response caller data, either electronically, or by any other means prescribed in 6) below.
- Defines “connection” for purposes of 5) above, to mean either a direct computer aided dispatch (CAD) to CAD link, where permissible under law, between the PSA and an EMS provider or an indirect connection, including, but not limited to, a ring down line, intercom, radio, or other electronic means for timely notification of caller data, and the location of the emergency response.
- Requires, unless an EMS agency has approved an emergency medical dispatch (EMD) program that allows for a tiered or modified response, the LEMSA-authorized EMS system providers, and the statutorily authorized EMS system providers within the jurisdiction of the incident, shall be simultaneously notified, or as close as technologically feasible, and dispatched at the same response mode. Requires a PSA implementing an EMD program to be subject to the review and approval of the LEMSA, and to perform 911 call processing services and operate the program in accordance with applicable state guidelines and regulations, as specified.
- Requires a LEMSA to approve or deny a PSA’s plan to implement an EMD or advanced life support program within 90 days of submission. Allows a PSA to appeal a decision in court, as provided. Specifies that this provision does not authorize a PSA to alter the response of specified EMS transport providers.
- States that medical control by a LEMSA medical director, or medical direction and management of an EMS system, pursuant to the provisions of this bill, will not be construed to do any of the following:
- Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA’s authority to directly receive and process requests for assistance originating within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system;
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to delegate, assign, or enter into a contract in contravention of 1) above;
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to unilaterally reduce a PSA’s response mode below that of the EMS transport provider, prevent a public safety response, or alter deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction; or,
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to prevent a PSA from providing mutual aid pursuant to the California Emergency Services Act.
- Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA’s authority to directly receive and process requests for assistance originating within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system;
- States that a PSA’s adherence to the policies, procedures, and protocols adopted by a LEMSA does not constitute a transfer of any of the PSA’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS.
Background
The Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act requires every local public agency to establish and operate an emergency telephone system using the digits 911. The purpose of the Act is to ensure an efficient statewide system for delivery of 911 calls to the appropriate local agency PSAPs that answer and respond to requests for emergency assistance.
A call to 911 first goes to the primary PSAP, which is always a law enforcement agency. When the primary PSAP receives a call, the dispatcher determines whether the call is related to law enforcement, fire, or medical needs and are routed appropriately to a secondary PSAP: law enforcement personnel, the local government with fire protection responsibility, or the EMS provider.
Beginning in 1978, the Legislature began to consider imposing some consistent structure on the delivery of EMS prior to a patient arriving at a hospital. In 1980, the Legislature enacted the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital EMS Act to create the modern-day EMS system (SB 125, Garamendi). Today, seven regional EMS systems covering multiple counties and 26 single county agencies have responsibility for developing protocols and standards for EMS response and care.
The EMS Act vests “medical control” with the LEMSA—the LEMSA’s medical director adopts policies and procedures for dispatch, patient destination policies, patient care guidelines, and quality assurance requirements to ensure that EMS under its jurisdiction meets state standards, such as response times. EMS may be provided under contract by private services, by contract or agreement with fire departments or other public agencies, or by both public and private entities. In order to provide comprehensive EMS coverage, a LEMSA may employ both private entities and public agencies. For example, depending on the location of the emergency, the medical needs of the patient, and the capabilities of the public and private agencies, one call may be routed to the private ambulance service that contracts with the LEMSA, while another call may be routed to a fire district to send an engine.
Concerned that private EMS dispatchers are not appropriately routing calls, firefighter union representatives want to ensure that public agencies are in charge of EMS dispatch.
Comments
1) Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The provision of fire protection services, rescue and emergency medical services, hazardous material emergency response, ambulance and other services related to the protection of lives and property is critical to the public peace, health and safety of the state. Likewise, the call processing and administration of such emergency response functions has traditionally been recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, many jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of a cost savings. SB 438 prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. It ensures that local government can determine the appropriate level of emergency response with its community and explicitly protects a government’s right and obligation to receive and process emergency calls to ensure effective, efficient and rapid deployment of emergency response apparatus. When dealing with emergency care and other vital services, like firefighting, privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. SB 438 ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible standard of emergency care.”
2) Who does it best? The EMS Act charges counties with a life-or-death responsibility: ensuring that their citizens receive adequate EMS. In discharging that responsibility, counties compare the offerings and capabilities of both public and private entities, and enter into agreements based on which entities can best provide the services. Some LEMSAs have fire departments dispatch EMS; others have chosen to award EMS dispatch contracts to private services that bring the substantial resources and expertise of nation-wide companies. The ability to choose between the two is key to being able to offer the best services to county residents; county supervisors decide to enter into a contract with a private entity only after considering the fiscal, administrative, and service delivery implications for their communities. SB 438 intervenes in this decision-making by prohibiting counties from contracting out for EMS dispatch services. By tying the hands of local elected officials, SB 438 potentially prevents LEMSAs from choosing the service provider that best meets their constituents’ needs, with potential implications for public health. Should the Legislature supplant its judgment for that of local officials that have direct responsibility for EMS delivery, and have awarded contracts accordingly?
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Professional Firefighters (source)
Anderson Fire Protection District
Bodega Bay Fire Protection District
CAL FIRE Local 2881
California Fire Chiefs Association
California State Firefighters' Association
Central County Fire Department
City of Alameda Fire Department
City of Corona Fire Department
City of Dinuba
City of Lodi Fire Department
City of Oceanside
City of Oxnard Fire Department
City of Palo Alto Fire Department
City of Petaluma
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Rocklin
City of San Luis Obispo Fire Department
City of San Marcos
City of Santa Rosa Fire Department
City of Torrance - Fire Department
City of Tracy
City of Watsonville
City of Watsonville Fire Department
Cosumnes Fire Department
City of Dinuba
East Contra Costa Fire Protection District
City of Fairfield
Fire Districts Association Of California
Five Cities Fire Authority
Fresno Fire Department
Lathrop Manteca Fire Protection District
Marin County Fire Chiefs Association
Meeks Bay Fire Protection District
Montecito Fire Department
Monterey County Fire Chiefs Association
Newport Beach Fire Department
North Central Fire Protection District
North County Fire Authority
North County Fire Protection District
North Tahoe Fire Protection District
Novato Fire District
City of Ontario
City of Alameda
Orange County Fire Authority
City of Rancho Cucamonga
Rincon Fire Department
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District
San Joaquin County Regional Fire Dispatch Authority
San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District
Seaside Fire Department
South San Joaquin County Fire Authority
Southern Marin Emergency Medical Paramedic System
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Stockton Fire Department
Tiburon Fire Protection Distirct
City of Tulare
City of Fullerton
City of Placentia
County of Fresno
County of Madera
County of Mendocino
County of Sacramento
County of San Joaquin
County of Santa Clara
County of Siskiyou
County of Stanislaus
County of Tulare
Del Norte County Board of Supervisors
Escalon Community Ambulance
League of California Cities
Mokelumne Rural Fire District
Ripon Fire District
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-4, 9/3/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Kiley, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Burke, Choi, Frazier, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Mathis
Prepared by: Anton Favorini-Csorba / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
9/4/19 9:30:56
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 438
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:July 11, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits, with some exceptions, a public agency from delegating, assigning, or entering into a contract for "911" call processing or emergency notification duties regarding the dispatch of emergency response services, unless the contract or agreement is with another public agency. Requires a public safety agency (PSA) that provides "911" call processing services for medical response to make a connection available from the PSA dispatch center to an emergency medical services (EMS) provider's dispatch center for the timely transmission of emergency response information. States that medical control by a local emergency medical services agency (LEMSA) medical director, or medical direction and management of an EMS system, pursuant to the provisions of this bill, will not be construed to limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA's authority to directly receive and process requests for assistance originating within the PSA's territorial jurisdiction through the emergency "911" system.
COMMENTS:
The Warren 911 Act authorizes cities and counties to form contracts regulating the implementation of a 911 system. The basic structure of the 911 system is designed to ensure that when a person dials 911, a law enforcement agency serving as a primary Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP) receives 911 requests from the area where the person is calling. If a 911 caller requests emergency medical assistance, the primary PSAP may retain the caller if it directly provides EMS dispatch, or may transfer the caller to a secondary PSAP for emergency medical response. The medical secondary PSAP can be a public agency, public/private partnership, or private EMS provider designated or recognized by the LEMSA as serving the entire EMS area or portion of the EMS area.
According to the Author:
According to the author, in emergency situations, life can be lost in a matter of seconds. With that in mind, the call processing and administration of emergency response functions is traditionally recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, many jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of cost savings. Efforts to privatize public services often result in increased costs to citizens, a reduction in services provided, and in the worst cases, a failure to deliver timely services. The author states that this bill prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. Privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. The author concludes that this bill ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible standard of emergency care.
Arguments in Support:
The California Professional Firefighters and the California Fire Chiefs Association are the sponsors of this bill and state, under this bill, public agencies are authorized to delegate, assign, or subcontract its 911-call processing or emergency notification duties with respect to dispatching emergency response services only to another public agency, which includes joint power authorities (JPAs) and cooperative agreements. This bill enables a JPA, which currently outsources local emergency dispatch services in some counties, to continue to do so, as well as renegotiate and adopt future contracts, if the JPA consents and its membership includes all affected public safety agency pre-hospital EMS providers.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, County Health Executives Association of California, Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California, and the Emergency Medical Services Medical Directors Association of California, are opposed to this bill. They state that several LEMSAs in California already utilize public agencies for medical dispatch. However, this bill would dismantle existing medical dispatch structures in counties that structured their system using private entities, some in combination with public agencies, in order to provide proper medical call processing and resource deployment, such as ensuring the closest ambulance responds to a medical emergency. They believe this will have significant impacts on the medical communication plans and processes in 17 counties including: Fresno, Glenn, Kings, Madera, Merced, Monterey, San Benito, San Joaquin, Santa Cruz, Shasta, Solano, Sonoma, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tulare, Yolo, and Yuba.
The opponents also note, that additionally, while proponents have stated that this bill is not intended to undermine LEMSA medical control, the proposed language in Section 1798.8 to the Health and Safety Code alters existing medical control statute by placing limitations on how medical control is applied to the governance of EMS systems. This weakens the medical control authority of the LEMSA, as recognized by the California Supreme Court, in the case of County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997 15.Cal. 4th 909).
Arguments in Opposition unless Amended:
The League of California Cities (LCC) is opposed to this bill unless it is amended. LCC notes that it agrees with the proposed change that would make it clear that county LEMSAs do not have the power to dictate when a city fire department or fire district units are dispatched in response to a 911 call in their own jurisdictions. However, LCC strongly opposes the provision that would permanently bar any local jurisdiction that does not have an existing contract for private EMS dispatch services, from entering into such an agreement in the future. LCC states that this provision not only limits cities' flexibility to provide EMS resources in times of financial distress, but also sets a precedent against future public-private contracting of any other services that may be in the best interest of cities. LCC would be willing to support this bill if it was limited to ensuring that PSAs can deploy emergency response resources within agencies' respective territorial jurisdictions.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Council.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 32-4-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Borgeas, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Dodd
ASM HEALTH: 13-0-2
YES: Wood, Mayes, Aguiar-Curry, Bonta, Carrillo, Flora, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Burke
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0001318
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 438
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 18, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 32-4
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services: dispatch.
SUMMARY: Prohibits, with some exceptions, a public agency from delegating, assigning, or entering into a contract for “911” call processing or emergency notification duties regarding the dispatch of emergency response services, unless the contract or agreement is with another public agency. Requires a public safety agency (PSA) that provides dispatch of prehospital emergency response resources to make a connection available from the PSA dispatch center to an emergency medical services (EMS) provider’s dispatch center for the timely transmission of emergency response information. Specifies that a PSA’s adherence to the policies, procedures, and protocols adopted by a local Emergency Medical Services Agency does not constitute a transfer of any of the PSA’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS. States that medical control by a local emergency medical services agency (LEMSA) medical director, or medical direction and management of an EMS system, pursuant to the provisions of this bill, will not be construed to limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA’s authority to directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes the following entities to contract for dispatch of emergency response resources only as described:
- A joint powers authority (JPA) that contracted for dispatch of emergency response resources on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to contract for dispatch of those resources and renegotiate or adopt new contracts, if the membership of the JPA includes all PSAs that provide prehospital EMS and the JPA consents to the renegotiation or adoption of the contract; or,
- A public agency that has contracted for dispatch of emergency response resources on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to contract for dispatch of those resources and may renegotiate or adopt new contracts if the public agency and the PSAs providing prehospital EMS consent to the renegotiation and adoption of the contract.
- Requires a PSA that provides dispatch of prehospital emergency response resources to make a connection available from the PSA dispatch center to an EMS provider’s dispatch center for the timely transmission of emergency response information.
- Authorizes a PSA to recover the costs incurred in establishing and maintaining a connection required pursuant to 2) above, from an EMS provider.
- Requires an EMS provider that elects not to use the connection provided pursuant to 2) above, to be dispatched by the appropriate PSA and charged the same rates as any other EMS provider being dispatched by that PSA.
- Prohibits the response interval calculations for an EMS provider that it not directly dispatched from a PSA from including the call processing times of the PSA, and requires the response interval calculations to begin upon receipt of notification by the EMS provider of the emergency response caller data, either electronically, or by any other means prescribed in 6) below.
- Defines “connection” for purposes of 5) above, to mean either a direct computer aided dispatch (CAD) to CAD link, where permissible under law, between the PSA and an EMS provider or an indirect connection, including, but not limited to, a ring down line, intercom, radio, or other electronic means for timely notification of caller data, and the location of the emergency response.
- Requires, unless an EMS agency has approved an emergency medical dispatch (EMD) program that allows for a tiered or modified response, all local EMS providers approved by the LEMSA and all statutorily-authorized EMS system providers, to be simultaneously notified, or as close as technologically feasible, and dispatched at the same response code. Requires a PSA implementing an EMD program to be subject to the review and approval of the LEMSA, and to operate the program in accordance with applicable state guidelines and regulations.
- Requires a PSA’s plan to implement an EMD or advanced life support program to be deemed approved within 60 days of submission, unless the LEMSA takes affirmative action to the contrary, and if the plan satisfies state guidelines and regulations.
- States that medical control by a LEMSA medical director, or medical direction and management of an EMS system, pursuant to the provisions of this bill, will not be construed to do any of the following:
- Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA’s authority to directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system;
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to delegate, assign, or enter into a contract in contravention of 1) above;
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to reduce a PSA’s response mode or deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction; or,
- Authorize or permit a LEMSA to prevent a PSA from providing mutual aid pursuant to the California Emergency Services Act.
- Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a PSA’s authority to directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system;
- States that a PSA’s adherence to the policies, procedures, and protocols adopted by a LEMSA does not constitute a transfer of any of the PSA’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point. Defines public agency to include the state, any city or county, or any public district that provides or has authority to provide firefighting, policy, ambulance, or other emergency services. Prohibits these provisions of law from prohibiting or discouraging the formation of multijurisdictional or regional systems.
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a PSA provides ambulance emergency services, to include such PSAs. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services.
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for emergency medical services (EMS), and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures.
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a LEMSA responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations.
- Requires every LEMSA to have a licensed physician as medical director, to assure medical accountability throughout the planning, implementation, and evaluation of the EMS system. Requires the medical direction and management of an EMS system to be under the medical control of the medical director
- Requires a LEMSA, using state minimum standards, to establish policies and procedures approved by the medical director of the LEMSA to assure medical control of the EMS system. Authorizes the policies and procedures approved by the medical director to require basic life support emergency medical transportation services to meet any medical control requirements including dispatch, patient destination policies, patient care guidelines, and quality assurance requirements.
- Requires authority for patient health care management in an emergency to be vested in the licensed or certified health care professional, including any paramedic or other prehospital emergency personnel, at the scene of the emergency who is most medically qualified regarding the provision of rendering emergency medical care. If no licensed or certified health care professional is available, requires the authority to be vested in the most appropriate medically qualified representative of public safety agencies who may have responded to the scene of the emergency.
- Permits a committee to be established in any county that desires to establish a unified command structure for patient management at the scene of an emergency within that county, comprised of representatives of the agency responsible for county emergency medical services, the county sheriff’s department, the California Highway Patrol, public prehospital-care provider agencies serving the county, and public fire, police, and other affected emergency service agencies within the county.
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county.
- Permits a LEMSA to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if the LEMSA develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, in emergency situations, life can be lost in a matter of seconds. With that in mind, the call processing and administration of emergency response functions is traditionally recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, many jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of cost savings. Efforts to privatize public services often result in increased costs to citizens, a reduction in services provided, and in the worst cases, a failure to deliver timely services. The author states that this bill prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. Privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. The author concludes that this bill ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible standard of emergency care.
- BACKGROUND. EMSA is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional LEMSAs. California has 33 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources.
The EMS Act comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health and Safety Code §1797.201, generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, §1797.201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts….”
Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.- 911. The Warren 911 Act authorizes cities and counties to form contracts regulating the implementation of a 911 system. The basic structure of the 911 system is designed to ensure that when a person dials 911, a law enforcement agency serving as a primary Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP) receives 911 requests from the area where the person is calling. If a 911 caller requests emergency medical assistance, the primary PSAP may retain the caller if it directly provides EMS dispatch, or may transfer the caller to a secondary PSAP for emergency medical response. The medical secondary PSAP can be a public agency, public/private partnership, or private EMS provider designated or recognized by the LEMSA as serving the entire EMS area or portion of the EMS area.
- County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of litigation, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and the San Bernardino County. The court case involved, among other issues, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three issues: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until they enter into an agreement with a LEMSA to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the LEMSA. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the LEMSA to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
- San Joaquin County EMS dispatch. The primary example of the type of privately-operated EMS dispatch operation that this bill seeks to prohibit is in San Joaquin County. In 2006, the San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors awarded an ambulance service contract to American Medical Response (AMR) that included the requirement that AMR provide a dispatch center capable of serving as the primary point of contact for all emergency medical dispatch requests. A JPA, known as the San Joaquin Joint Radio Users Group, consisting of 13 fire districts and two small ambulance operators, was formed to negotiate with AMR for emergency dispatch communication services, which was later named the Valley Regional Emergency Communication Center (VRECC). VRECC annually processes approximately 155,000 emergency calls serving a population of 1.3 million people. When a person dials 911 in San Joaquin County, the call is initially answered by a primary PSAP operated by a law enforcement agency. If the caller reports a medical emergency, the primary PSAP transfers the caller to VRECC, which provides emergency medical dispatch services including pre-arrival medical instructions and dispatches emergency ambulances and fire first responders in accordance with the medical control policies of the LEMSA medical director.
Proponents of this bill argue that VRECC does not always alert a city fire department about some medical emergency calls, even when the fire department could arrive at the scene faster than an AMR ambulance.
d) Rural 911 dispatch and response. Most rural counties run their 911 dispatch through their Sheriff’s office and contract with both PSAs and private ambulance providers for transport. This bill is drafted to provide Sonoma County with an exception to the prohibition on contracting with a private entity for dispatch, as long as the JPA includes all of the PSAs that provide prehospital EMS. The bill also provides an exemption to Fresno and Tulare as long as the PSAs’ providing prehospital EMS in those counties consent to any renegotiation and adoption of the contract. The bill does not define what constitutes consent and it is unclear how a LEMSA would have to restructure their emergency medical services plan if one public agency decided they no longer want to participate in the JPA.
- SUPPORT. The California Professional Firefighters and the California Fire Chiefs Association are the sponsors of this bill and state, under this bill, public agencies are authorized to delegate, assign, or subcontract its 911-call processing or emergency notification duties with respect to dispatching emergency response services only to another public agency, which includes JPAs and cooperative agreements. This bill enables a JPA, which currently outsources local emergency dispatch services in some counties, to continue to do so, as well as renegotiate and adopt future contracts, if the JPA consents and its membership includes all affected public safety agency pre-hospital EMS providers. The sponsors state that this bill does nothing to exempt city or special district fire agencies from medical control policies required by the LEMSAs established by counties. It simply recognizes that these accountable public agencies have responsibility for dispatch and response modes that best protect their communities. The sponsors conclude that every dispatch and resource mode must always meet or exceed LEMSA medical control policies.
- OPPOSITION. The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, County Health Executives Association of California, Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California, and the Emergency Medical Services Medical Directors Association of California, are opposed to this bill. They state that several LEMSAs in California already utilize public agencies for medical dispatch. However, this bill would dismantle existing medical dispatch structures in counties that structured their system using private entities, some in combination with public agencies, in order to provide proper medical call processing and resource deployment, such as ensuring the closest ambulance responds to a medical emergency. They believe this will have significant impacts on the medical communication plans and processes in 17 counties including: Fresno, Glenn, Kings, Madera, Merced, Monterey, San Benito, San Joaquin, Santa Cruz, Shasta, Solano, Sonoma, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tulare, Yolo, and Yuba.
The opponents note that, while recent amendments would allow these counties to keep their existing medical dispatch structure in place for the duration of their current contracts, any use of a private entity for medical dispatch in the future would be subject to the “consent” of all public safety agencies that provide prehospital emergency services. This bill does not provide a remedy should this consent not be reached, nor does it require those entities that do not consent to be willing to provide medical dispatch beyond their jurisdiction to ensure that there is no system fragmentation.
The opponents also note, that additionally, while proponents have stated that this bill is not intended to undermine LEMSA medical control, the proposed language in Section 1798.8 to the Health and Safety Code alters existing medical control statute by placing limitations on how medical control is applied to the governance of EMS systems. This weakens the medical control authority of the LEMSA, as recognized by the California Supreme Court, in the case of County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997 15.Cal. 4th 909). The State Supreme Court explained in enacting the EMS Act in 1980, “the Legislature conceived of ‘medical control’ in fairly expansive terms, encompassing matters directly related to regulating the quality of emergency medical services, including policies and procedures governing dispatch and patient care.” Other subjects of medical control include those policies designed to improve the “speed and effectiveness” of emergency response as well as “how the various providers will interact at the emergency scene.”
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. The League of California Cities (LCC) is opposed to this bill unless it is amended. LCC notes that it agrees with the proposed change that would make it clear that county LEMSAs do not have the power to dictate when a city fire department or fire district units are dispatched in response to a 911 call in their own jurisdictions. However, LCC strongly opposes the provision that would permanently bar any local jurisdiction that does not have an existing contract for private EMS dispatch services, from entering into such an agreement in the future. LCC states that this provision not only limits cities’ flexibility to provide EMS resources in times of financial distress, but also sets a precedent against future public-private contracting of any other services that may be in the best interest of cities. LCC would be willing to support this bill if it was limited to ensuring that PSAs can deploy emergency response resources within agencies’ respective territorial jurisdictions.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. AB 1544 (Gipson) establishes the Community Paramedicine or Triage to Alternate Destination Act of 2020 to establish state guidelines to govern the implementation of community paramedicine programs or triage to alternate destination programs by LEMSAs in California. AB 1544 is pending in the Senate Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 3115 (Gipson) of 2018 was similar to AB 1544. AB 3115 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
- SB 944 (Hertzberg of 2018) would have enacted the Community Paramedicine Act of 2018, to permit LEMSAs, with approval by EMSA, to develop a program to provide community paramedic services in one or more of the following five specialties: i) providing short-term postdischarge followup; ii) providing directly observed tuberculosis therapy; iii) providing case management services to frequent emergency medical services users; iv) providing hospice services to treat patients in their homes; and, v) providing patients with transport to an alternate destination, which can either be an authorized mental health facility, or an authorized sobering center. SB 944 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
- AB 2961 (O’Donnell) Chapter 656, Statutes of 2018, requires a LEMSA to report ambulance patient offload time (APOT) to EMSA, and requires EMSA to calculate APOT by jurisdiction and by each facility within a jurisdiction, and report this data to the Commission on EMS twice per year, and to submit a report to the Legislature by December 1, 2020.
- AB 1223 (O’Donnell), Chapter 379, Statutes of 2015, requires EMSA to adopt a statewide standard methodology for the calculation and reporting by a LEMSA of APOT, and permits LEMSAs to adopt policies and procedures for calculating and reporting APOT using the statewide methodology.
- AB 1129 (Burke), Chapter 377, Statutes of 2015, requires an emergency medical care provider, when submitting data to a LEMSA, to use an electronic health record system that is compatible with specified standards, and that includes those data elements that are required by the LEMSA.
- AB 503 (Rodriguez), Chapter 362, Statutes of 2015, authorizes health facilities to release patient-identifiable medical information to an EMS provider and LEMSA when specific data elements are requested for the purpose of quality assessment and improvement.
- PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. The author is proposing to amend this bill as follows:
- As currently drafted this bill partially “grandfathers” some existing private contracts, until the contract expires, but only if all PSAs agree to continue the contract. The author is proposing amendments to allow the contracting arrangements to continue either: i) without the PSA that wishes to provide its own dispatch, or, ii) if the contract arrangement will not work without all PSAs’ participation, requiring the withdrawing PSA to provide dispatch for the service area originally subject to the contract.
- As currently drafted this bill would provide “deemed approval” within 60 days of a PSA’s submission of an EMD plan or advanced life support program, unless the LEMSA takes affirmative action to the contrary. The author is proposing to amend these provisions to instead require a LEMSA to make a determination to approve or deny a plan within 90 days, and, if a LEMSA denies an EMD plan, to provide for administrative adjudication.
- As currently drafted, this bill requires all local EMS providers approved by a LEMSA, and all statutorily-authorized EMS providers to be notified simultaneously by the dispatcher. The author is proposing to amend these provisions to clarify that the notification must only be provided to EMS providers within the jurisdiction of the incident, and that EMS providers must operate in compliance with the LEMSA’s policies.
- As currently drafted, this bill limits a LEMSA’s ability to reduce a PSA’s response mode or the deployment of PSA emergency response resources within the PSA’s territorial jurisdiction. The author is proposing to clarify that any reduction of services cannot be below that of the contracted EMS transport provider.
- To clarify that the bill only limits contracting of 911 “call processing” and does not apply to OES notifications.
- Technical amendments to correct two typos.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Bodega Bay Fire Protection District
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
California State Firefighters' Association
Central County Fire Department
City of Alameda
City of Corona Fire Department
City of Dinuba
City of Fairfield
City of Lodi Fire Department
City of Oceanside
City of Palo Alto Fire Department
City of Petaluma
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Santa Rosa Fire Department
City of Tracy
City of Tulare
City of Ventura Fie Department
City of Watsonville
East Contra Costa Fire Protection District
Lathrop Manteca Fire Protection District
Marin County Fire Chiefs Association
Montecito Fire Department
Monterey County Fire Chiefs Association
Newport Beach Fire Department
North County Fire Authority
North County Fire Protection District
Novato Fire District
Orange County Fire Authority
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District
San Joaquin County Regional Fire Dispatch Authority
San Luis Obispo Fire Department
San Ramon Valley Fire Protection District
Seaside Fire Department
South San Joaquin County Fire Authority
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Oppose
California State Association of Counties
City of Placentia
County Health Executives Association of California
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California
EMS Medical Directors Association of California
Fresno County
Madera County
Mendocino County Board of Supervisors
Rural County Representatives of California
San Joaquin County
Santa Clara County
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
Siskiyou County
Stanislaus County
Urban Counties of California
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 438 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 438
Amended: 5/2/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 5/1/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Grove, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services: dispatch
SOURCE: California Professional Firefighters
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a public agency from entering into a contract for 911 call processing regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the contract is with another public agency, with specified exceptions.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point (PSAP).
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a public safety agency provides ambulance emergency services, to include such public safety agencies. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services.
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for emergency medical services (EMS), and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority, which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures.
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA) responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations.
- Requires every LEMSA to have a licensed physician as medical director, to assure medical accountability throughout the planning, implementation, and evaluation of the EMS system. Requires the medical direction and management of an EMS system to be under the medical control of the medical director.
- Requires authority for patient health care management in an emergency to be vested in the licensed or certified health care professional, including any paramedic or other prehospital emergency personnel, at the scene of the emergency who is most medically qualified regarding the provision of rendering emergency medical care. If no licensed or certified health care professional is available, requires the authority to be vested in the most appropriate medically qualified representative of public safety agencies who may have responded to the scene of the emergency.
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county.
This bill:
- Prohibits a public agency from delegating, assigning, or entering into a contract for “911” call processing or emergency notification duties regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the delegation or assignment is to, or the contract is with, another public agency.
- Allows a joint powers authority that contracted for dispatch of emergency response resources on or before January 1, 2019, to continue to contract for dispatch of those resources and may renegotiate or adopt new contracts, if the membership of the joint powers authority includes all public agencies that provide prehospital EMS and the joint powers authority consents to the renegotiation or adoption of the contract.
- Prohibits provisions of law governing medical control or medical direction and management of an EMS system, notwithstanding any provision of the EMS Act, from being construed to:
- Limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a public safety agency’s authority to directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the public safety agency’s territorial jurisdiction through the emergency “911” system; or,
- Authorize or permit a local EMS agency to delegate, assign, or enter into a contract in contravention of the prohibition on contracting for EMS dispatch established by the bill.
- Provides that medical control or medical direction and management of an EMS system shall not be construed to authorize or permit a local EMS agency to reduce a public safety agency’s response mode or deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the public safety agency’s territorial jurisdiction.
- Provides that a public safety agency’s voluntary consent to conform its prehospital response or response mode to comply with an emergency medical dispatch protocol adopted by a local EMS agency does not constitute a transfer of any of the public safety agency’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS.
Background
The Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act requires every local public agency to establish and operate an emergency telephone system using the digits 911. The purpose of the Act is to ensure an efficient statewide system for delivery of 911 calls to the appropriate local agency PSAPs that answer and respond to requests for emergency assistance.
A call to 911 first goes to the primary PSAP, which is always a law enforcement agency. When the primary PSAP receives a call, the dispatcher determines whether the call is related to law enforcement, fire, or medical needs and are routed appropriately to a secondary PSAP: law enforcement personnel, the local government with fire protection responsibility, or the EMS provider.
Beginning in 1978, the Legislature began to consider imposing some consistent structure on the delivery of EMS prior to a patient arriving at a hospital. In 1980, the Legislature enacted the EMS Act to create the modern-day EMS system (SB 125, Garamendi). Today, seven regional EMS systems covering multiple counties and 26 single county agencies have responsibility for developing protocols and standards for EMS response and care.
The EMS Act vests “medical control” with the LEMSA—the LEMSA’s medical director adopts policies and procedures for dispatch, patient destination policies, patient care guidelines, and quality assurance requirements to ensure that EMS under its jurisdiction meets state standards, such as response times. EMS may be provided under contract by private services, by contract or agreement with fire departments or other public agencies, or by both public and private entities. In order to provide comprehensive EMS coverage, a LEMSA may employ both private entities and public agencies. For example, depending on the location of the emergency, the medical needs of the patient, and the capabilities of the public and private agencies, one call may be routed to the private ambulance service that contracts with the LEMSA, while another call may be routed to a fire district to send an engine.
Concerned that private EMS dispatchers are not appropriately routing calls, firefighter union representatives want to ensure that public agencies are in charge of EMS dispatch.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The provision of fire protection services, rescue and emergency medical services, hazardous material emergency response, ambulance and other services related to the protection of lives and property is critical to the public peace, health and safety of the state. Likewise, the call processing and administration of such emergency response functions has traditionally been recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, many jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of a cost savings. SB 438 prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. It ensures that local government can determine the appropriate level of emergency response with its community and explicitly protects a government’s right and obligation to receive and process emergency calls to ensure effective, efficient and rapid deployment of emergency response apparatus. When dealing with emergency care and other vital services, like firefighting, privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. SB 438 ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible standard of emergency care.”
- Who does it best? The EMS Act charges counties with a life-or-death responsibility: ensuring that their citizens receive adequate EMS. In discharging that responsibility, counties compare the offerings and capabilities of both public and private entities, and enter into agreements based on which entities can best provide the services. Some LEMSAs have fire departments dispatch EMS; others have chosen to award EMS dispatch contracts to private services that bring the substantial resources and expertise of nation-wide companies. The ability to choose between the two is key to being able to offer the best services to county residents; county supervisors decide to enter into a contract with a private entity only after considering the fiscal, administrative, and service delivery implications for their communities. SB 438 intervenes in this decision-making by prohibiting counties from contracting out for EMS dispatch services. By tying the hands of local elected officials, SB 438 potentially prevents LEMSAs from choosing the service provider that best meets their constituents’ needs, with potential implications for public health. Furthermore, some counties have existing contracts with private EMS dispatchers that would be undermined by SB 438’s prohibition, potentially upending EMS delivery in those counties. Should the Legislature supplant its judgment for that of local officials that have direct responsibility for EMS delivery, and have awarded contracts accordingly?
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Professional Firefighters (source)
Alameda County Fire Chief’s Association
Alameda Fire Department
Alpine Fire Protection District
Anderson Fire Protection District
Apple Valley Fire Protection District
Big Bear Fire Department
Bodega Bay Fire Protection District
Bonita Sunnyside Fire Protection District
Branciforte Fire Protection District
California City Fire Department
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Metropolitan Fire Chiefs Association
Cambria Community Services District Fire Department
Central County Fire Department
Chino Valley Fire District
Chula Vista Firefighters Local 2180
City of Atascadero Fire & Emergency Services
City of Carlsbad Fire Department
City of Chula Vista Fire Department
City of Colton
City of Corona Fire Department
City of Culver City
City of Dinuba Fire Department
City of Dixon Fire Department
City of Fountain Valley Fire Department
City of Huntington Beach Fire Department
City of Lodi Fire Department
City of Loma Linda Fire Department
City of Ontario
City of Oxnard Fire Department
City of Palm Springs Fire Department
City of Palo Alto Fire Department
City of Petaluma Fire Department
City of Rohnert Park Department of Public Safety
City of Sacramento Fire Department
City of San Diego Fire-Rescue Department
City of San Marcos
City of Santa Cruz Fire Department
City of Santa Rosa Fire Department
City of Santee Fire Department
City of South Lake Tahoe Fire Department
City of Stockton Fire Department
City of Ventura Fire Department
City of Vista
Cordelia Fire Protection District
Cosumnes Fire Department Community Services District
Fire Districts Association of California
Firefighters Local 1186
Foresthill Fire Protection Department
Fresno County Fire Protection District
Gilroy Fire Department
Humboldt Bay Fire
Lake County Fire Protection District
Lathrop-Manteca Fire Protection District
Linda Fire Protection District
Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District
Marina Fire Department
Mid-Coast Fire Brigade
Montecito Fire Department
Monterey County Fire Chiefs Association
Monterey Firefighters Association
Newport Beach Fire Department
Newport Beach Firefighters Local 3734
North County Fire Authority
North County Fire Protection District
North Tahoe and Meeks Bay Fire Protection Districts
Northshore Fire Protection District
Novato Fire District
Orange City Fire Department
Orange County Fire Chief’s Association
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District
San Benito-Monterey Chapter CALFIRE Local 2881
San Bernardino County Fire Protection District
San Joaquin County Regional Fire Dispatch Authority
Santa Clara County Fire
Scotts Valley Fire Protection District
Seaside Fire Department
Sonoma County Fire District
South Placer Fire District
Southern Marin Emergency Medical Paramedic System
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Stanislaus Consolidated Fire Protection District
Thornton Rural Fire Protection District
Tiburon Fire Protection District
Tracy Firefighters Association Local 3355
United Firefighters of Los Angeles
Waterloo Morada Fire District
Williams Fire Protection Authority
One Individual
American Medical Response
California State Association of Counties
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Fresno
Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California
Emergency Medical Services Medical Directors Association of California
Montezuma Fire Protection District
Ripon Consolidated Fire District
Rural County Representatives of California
San Joaquin County Joint Radio Users Group
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
San Mateo County Health
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
Sonoma Valley Fire & Protection Authority
Urban Counties of California
Prepared by: Anton Favorini-Csorba / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/3/19 14:20:29
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
BILL NO: SB 438
AUTHOR: | Hertzberg | ||
VERSION: | March 25, 2019 | ||
HEARING DATE: | May 1, 2019 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services: dispatch
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a public agency from entering into a contract for 911 call processing regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the contract is with another public agency, or the contract is made by cooperative agreement.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point. Defines public agency to include the state, any city or county, or any public district that provides or has authority to provide firefighting, policy, ambulance, or other emergency services. Prohibits these provisions of law from prohibiting or discouraging the formation of multijurisdictional or regional system. [GOV §53100, et seq.]
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a public safety agency provides ambulance emergency services, to include such public safety agencies. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services. [GOV §53110]
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for emergency medical services (EMS), and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. [HSC §1797, et seq.]
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA) responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. [HSC §1797.200, et seq.]
- Requires every LEMSA to have a licensed physician as medical director, to assure medical accountability throughout the planning, implementation, and evaluation of the EMS system. Requires the medical direction and management of an EMS system to be under the medical control of the medical director [HSC §1797.202, HSC §1798]
- Requires authority for patient health care management in an emergency to be vested in the licensed or certified health care professional, including any paramedic or other prehospital emergency personnel, at the scene of the emergency who is most medically qualified regarding the provision of rendering emergency medical care. If no licensed or certified health care professional is available, requires the authority to be vested in the most appropriate medically qualified representative of public safety agencies who may have responded to the scene of the emergency. [HSC §1798.6]
- Permits a committee to be established in any county that desires to establish a unified command structure for patient management at the scene of an emergency within that county, comprised of representatives of the agency responsible for county emergency medical services, the county sheriff’s department, the California Highway Patrol, public prehospital-care provider agencies serving the county, and public fire, police, and other affected emergency service agencies within the county. [HSC §1798.6]
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. [HSC §1797.201]
- Permits a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if the local EMS agency develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. [HSC §1797.224]
This bill:
- Prohibits a public agency from delegating, assigning, or entering into a contract for “911” call processing or emergency notification duties regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources except under one of the following circumstances:
- The delegation or assignment is to, or the contract is with, another public agency;
- The delegation, assignment, or contract is made pursuant to a joint powers agreement, as specified; or,
- The delegation, assignment, or contract is made by cooperative agreement.
- Prohibits provisions of law governing medical control or medical direction and management of an EMS system, notwithstanding any provision of the EMS Act, from being construed to limit, supplant, prohibit, or otherwise alter a public safety agency’s authority to do either of the following:
- Directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the public safety agency’s territorial jurisdiction through the 911 system; or,
- Determine the appropriate deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the public safety agency’s territorial jurisdiction.
- Prohibits a public safety agency’s voluntary consent to limit, modify, or alter the nature of its prehospital response or response mode pursuant to an emergency medical dispatch protocol approved by a LEMSA from constituting a transfer of any of the public safety agency’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in emergency situations, life can be lost in a matter of seconds. With that in mind, the call processing and administration of emergency response functions has traditionally been recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, some jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of a cost savings. Efforts to privatize public services often result in increased costs to citizens, a reduction in services provided, and in the worst cases, a failure to deliver timely services. This bill prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. Privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. This bill ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible response and standard of emergency care.
- Background on EMS. While EMSA is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services, day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional LEMSAs. California has 33 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county local EMS agencies.
The EMS Act comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health and Safety Code §1797.201, generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, §1797.201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts….” Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
The Warren 911 Act authorizes cities and counties to form contracts regulating the implementation of a 911 system. The basic structure of the 911 system is designed to ensure that when a person dials 911, a law enforcement agency serving as a primary Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP) receives 911 requests from the area where the person is calling. If a 911 caller requests emergency medical assistance, the primary PSAP may retain the caller if it directly provides EMS dispatch, or may transfer the caller to a secondary PSAP for emergency medical response. The medical secondary PSAP can be a public agency, public/private partnership, or private EMS provider designated or recognized by the LEMSA as serving the entire EMS area or portion of the EMS area. - County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of a legal battle, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and the San Bernardino County. The court case involved, among other things, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three questions: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until they enter into an agreement with a LEMSA to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the LEMSA. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the LEMSA to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
- San Joaquin County EMS dispatch. The primary example of the type of privately-operated EMS dispatch operation that this bill seeks to prohibit is in San Joaquin County. In 2006, the San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors awarded an ambulance service contract to American Medical Response (AMR) that included the requirement that AMR provide a dispatch center capable of serving as the primary point of contact for all emergency medical dispatch requests. A joint powers authority, known as the San Joaquin Joint Radio Users Group, consisting of 13 fire districts and two small ambulance operators, was formed to negotiate with AMR for emergency dispatch communication services, which was later named the Valley Regional Emergency Communication Center (VRECC). VRECC annually processes approximately 155,000 emergency calls serving a population of 1.3 million people. When a person dials 911 in San Joaquin County, the call is initially answered by a primary PSAP operated by a law enforcement agency. If the caller reports a medical emergency, the primary PSAP transfers the caller to VRECC, which provides emergency medical dispatch services including pre-arrival medical instructions and dispatches emergency ambulances and fire first responders in accordance with the medical control policies of the LEMSA medical director.
Proponents of this bill argue that VRECC does not always alert a city fire department about some medical emergency calls, even when the fire department could arrive at the scene faster than an AMR ambulance. - Double referral. This bill was heard in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee on April 10, 2019, and passed with a 6-1 vote.
- Prior legislation. SB 944 (Hertzberg of 2018) would have enacted the Community Paramedicine Act of 2018, to permit LEMSAs, with approval by EMSA, to develop a program to provide community paramedic services in or more of the following five specialties: (1) providing short-term postdischarge followup; (2) providing directly observed tuberculosis therapy; (3) providing case management services to frequent emergency medical services users; (4) providing hospice services to treat patients in their homes; and, (5) providing patients with transport to an alternate destination, which can either be an authorized mental health facility, or an authorized sobering center. SB 944 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2961 (O’Donnell, Chapter 656, Statutes of 2018) requires a LEMSA to report ambulance patient offload time (APOT) to EMSA, and requires EMSA to calculate APOT by jurisdiction and by each facility within a jurisdiction, and report this data to the Commission on EMS twice per year, and to submit a report to the Legislature by December 1, 2020.
AB 1223 (O’Donnell, Chapter 379, Statutes of 2015) requires EMSA to adopt a statewide standard methodology for the calculation and reporting by a LEMSA of APOT, and permits LEMSAs to adopt policies and procedures for calculating and reporting APOT using the statewide methodology.
AB 1129 (Burke, Chapter 377, Statutes of 2015) requires an emergency medical care provider, when submitting data to a LEMSA, to use an electronic health record system that is compatible with specified standards, and that includes those data elements that are required by the LEMSA.
AB 503 (Rodriguez, Chapter 362, Statutes of 2015) authorizes health facilities to release patient-identifiable medical information to an EMS provider and LEMSA when specific data elements are requested for the purpose of quality assessment and improvement.
- Support. This bill is sponsored by the California Professional Firefighters (CPF), which states that few private emergency dispatch outsourcing models exist, but where they have been implemented, the results have proven disastrous and ineffective. In such cases, CPF argues that it has made emergency response more complicated by motivations of profit over public safety. CPF states that by placing emergency medical response decisions exclusively in the hands of a private contractor, the potential for cost-based medical decisions increases, which, in turn, threatens the standard of care. CPF points to a for-profit model in San Joaquin County that has severely limited the public fire department’s participation in the local EMS system. Stockton and Tracy firefighter-paramedics are routinely not dispatched to (or, in some cases, even informed of) calls, giving preference to the corporate providers. CPF states that this has resulted in documented delays in response. And, when decisions on how – or whether – to respond are made by a private, for-profit contractor, which is accountable to its shareholders, not the taxpaying public, there is a loss of accountability. Numerous city fire departments and fire districts support this bill, making similar arguments.
- Opposition. The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, County Health Executives Association of California, Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California, and the Emergency Medical Directors Association of California (coalition) write jointly in opposition that this bill will restrict the use of non-governmental operated public safety answering points, including 911 EMS dispatch centers, and would circumvent the existing oversight of LEMSA medical directors ensure the appropriate deployment and use of EMS resources. The coalition argues that this bill attempts to overturn the precedent set in County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino in 1997, where the California Supreme Court found that the Legislature conceived of “medical control” in fairly expansive terms, encompassing matters directly related to regulating the quality of EMS, including policies and procedures governing dispatch and patient care.” Should this bill become law, the coalition argues that public safety agencies would be permitted to act outside the medical control of the LEMSA medical director in the response and delivery of prehospital emergency care. The coalition states that this would fragment the EMS system and may result in considerable variation in the care provided to patients and risks patient safety as deviations from LEMSA policies and procedures may occur without any ability for the LEMSA to issue corrective action. Ripon Consolidated Fire District and Montezuma Fire District are also both opposed to this bill. Both of these fire districts are members of the San Joaquin County Joint Radio Users Group, which has contracted with American Medical Response (AMR) for emergency fire dispatch, and states that this bill eliminates their ability to continue contracting with AMR, or any private entity, for public safety fire dispatch.
- Oppose unless amended. AMR states that it is opposed unless amended. According to AMR, this bill would terminate or interfere with current contractual relationships, destabilize the state’s EMS systems, lower quality of care, and potentially eliminate hundreds of unionized emergency dispatcher positions. AMR states that it operates the only dual accredited dispatch center in California, and that nationally it dispatches over 10 million 911 calls a year. According to AMR, there is no publicly operated dispatch center in this state that can perform at a higher level than theirs. AMR states that it has no interest in controlling fire department resources, as long as it does not interfere with, or financially damage, its ability to provide emergency ambulance services. AMR argues this bill goes beyond controlling resources, and seeks to force private EMS providers into paying public agencies charges on the backs of patients, and give up control of their resources to inexperienced fire departments that have never dispatched or triaged 911 calls. AMR states that it is open to alternative language and will continue discussions with the sponsor on possible amendments.
- Policy comment. This bill amends two bodies of law: the Government Code provisions concerning the 911 system, and the Health and Safety Code provisions that govern the EMS Act. According to information provided by the sponsor of this bill, the amendments to the EMS Act are intended to buttress the prohibition on contracting out 911 services in the Government Code. According to the sponsor, these amendments simply ensure that a LEMSA does not exert its authority under the “medical control” provisions of the EMS Act to prevent fire departments from receiving emergency medical response dispatch calls. However, the language in this bill is broad, giving the public safety agency the ability to “determine the appropriate deployment of public safety emergency response resources within the public safety agency’s territorial jurisdiction” regardless of the medical control direction coming from the LEMSA. As opponents point out, this language could allow a fire department to refuse to answer a dispatch call, or redirect resources from the scene of an emergency. The author may wish to consider amendments to narrow the language in this bill to ensure the intent of the sponsor that fire departments continue to receive emergency medical response dispatch calls, without subverting the appropriate medical control of the LEMSA.
- Amendments from Governance and Finance Committee. When this bill was heard in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee, the author agreed to an amendment requested by the Committee, but because of the double-referral, it was agreed that the amendment would be adopted in this committee. This amendment is intended to exempt Redcom Dispatch in Santa Rosa, which is a Joint Powers Authority established to provide emergency fire and medical response dispatch throughout Sonoma County. Redcom Dispatch is operated by AMR pursuant to a contract approved by Redcom Dispatch’s board, which is composed of all of the cities and fire districts with EMS responsibilities in its jurisdiction. The amendment is as follows:
On page 3, between lines 37 and 38, insert:
(c) Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a joint powers authority that contracted for dispatch of emergency response resources on or before January 1, 2019, may continue to contract for those resources and may renegotiate or adopt new contracts, if the membership of the joint powers authority includes all public agencies that provide prehospital emergency medical services and the joint powers authority consents to the renegotiation or adoption of the contract.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Professional Firefighters (sponsor)
Alameda County Fire Chief’s Association
Alameda Fire Department
Alpine Fire Protection District
Anderson Fire Protection District
Apple Valley Fire Protection District
Big Bear Fire Department
Bodega Bay Fire Protection District
Bonita Sunnyside Fire Protection District
Branciforte Fire Protection District
California City Fire Department
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Metropolitan Fire Chiefs Association
Cambria Community Services District Fire Department
Central County Fire Department
Chino Valley Fire District
Chula Vista Firefighters Local2180
City of Atascadero Fire & Emergency Services
City of Carlsbad Fire Department
City of Chula Vista Fire Department
City of Colton
City of Corona Fire Department
City of Culver City
City of Dinuba Fire Department
City of Dixon Fire Department
City of Fountain Valley Fire Department
City of Huntington Beach Fire Department
City of Lodi Fire Department
City of Loma Linda Fire Department
City of Ontario
City of Oxnard Fire Department
City of Palm Springs Fire Department
City of Palo Alto Fire Department
City of Petaluma Fire Department
City of Rohnert Park Department of Public Safety
City of Sacramento Fire Department
City of San Diego Fire-Rescue Department
City of San Marcos
City of Santa Cruz Fire Department
City of Santa Rosa Fire Department
City of Santee Fire Department
City of South Lake Tahoe Fire Department
City of Stockton Fire Department
City of Ventura Fire Department
City of Vista
Cordelia Fire Protection District
Cosumnes Fire Department Community Services District
Fire Districts Association of California
Firefighters Local 1186
Foresthill Fire Protection Department
Fresno County Fire Protection District
Gilroy Fire Department
Humboldt Bay Fire
Lake County Fire Protection District
Lathrop-Manteca Fire Protection District
Linda Fire Protection District
Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District
Marina Fire Department
Mid-Coast Fire Brigade
Montecito Fire Department
Monterey County Fire Chiefs Association
Monterey Firefighters Association
Newport Beach Fire Department
Newport Beach Firefighters Local 3734
North County Fire Authority
North County Fire Protection District
North Tahoe and Meeks Bay Fire Protection Districts
Northshore Fire Protection District
Novato Fire District
Orange City Fire Department
Orange County Fire Chief’s Association
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District
San Benito-Monterey Chapter CALFIRE Local 2881
San Bernardino County Fire Protection District
San Joaquin County Regional Fire Dispatch Authority
Santa Clara County Fire
Scotts Valley Fire Protection District
Seaside Fire Department
Sonoma County Fire District
South Placer Fire District
Southern Marin Emergency Medical Paramedic System
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Stanislaus Consolidated Fire Protection District
Thornton Rural Fire Protection District
Tiburon Fire Protection District
Tracy Firefighters Association Local 3355
United Firefighters of Los Angeles
Waterloo Morada Fire District
Williams Fire Protection Authority
One Individual
Oppose: American Medical Response (unless amended)
California State Association of Counties
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Fresno
Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California
Emergency Medical Services Medical Directors Association of California
Montezuma Fire Protection District
Ripon Consolidated Fire District
Rural County Representatives of California
San Joaquin County Joint Radio Users Group
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
San Mateo County Health
Shasta County Board of Supervisors
Sonoma Valley Fire & Protection Authority
Urban Counties of California
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 438 | Hearing Date: | 4/10/19 |
Author: | Hertzberg | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 3/25/19 | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
Emergency medical services: dispatch
Prohibits local agencies for contracting with private entities for emergency medical services (EMS) dispatch.
Background
The Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act requires every local public agency to establish and operate an emergency telephone system using the digits 911. The purpose of the Act is to ensure an efficient statewide system for delivery of 911 calls to the appropriate local agency Public Safety Answering Points (PSAPs) that answer and respond to requests for emergency assistance. The Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act also authorizes the state to oversee the development and operation of the 911 system. Under the 911 Act, every 911 system must include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. These systems may include private ambulance service.
A call to 911 first goes to the primary PSAP, which is always a law enforcement agency. When the primary PSAP receives a call, the dispatcher determines whether the call is related to law enforcement, fire, or medical needs and are routed appropriately to a secondary PSAP: law enforcement personnel, the local government with fire protection responsibility, or the emergency medical services (EMS) provider.
Beginning in 1978, the Legislature began to consider imposing some consistent structure on the delivery of emergency medical services prior to a patient arriving at a hospital. In 1980, the Legislature enacted the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to create the modern-day EMS system (SB 125, Garamendi). The EMS Act created the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) within state government to coordinate and integrate all state activities concerning EMS, as well as to establish minimum standards, policies, and procedures that local agencies must meet and follow when delivering EMS. The EMS Act allowed counties to develop an EMS program and designate a Local EMS Agency (LEMSA) to implement the state standards and develop medical protocols. Under the EMS Act, cities and fire districts can only provide EMS if they were providing it on January 1, 1980, and cannot expand the territory that they serve beyond what they served at that time unless through an agreement with a LEMSA. Today, seven regional EMS systems covering multiple counties and twenty-six single county agencies have responsibility for developing protocols and standards for EMS response and care.
The EMS Act vests “medical control” with the LEMSA—the LEMSA’s medical director adopts policies and procedures for dispatch, patient destination policies, patient care guidelines, and quality assurance requirements to ensure that EMS under its jurisdiction meets state standards, such as response times. EMS may be provided under contract by private services, by contract or agreement with fire departments or other public agencies, or by both public and private entities. In order to provide comprehensive EMS coverage, a LEMSA may employ both private entities and public agencies. For example, depending on the location of the emergency, the medical needs of the patient, and the capabilities of the public and private agencies, one call may be routed to the private ambulance service that contracts with the LEMSA, while another call may be routed to a fire district to send an engine.
Concerned that private EMS dispatchers are not appropriately routing calls, firefighter union representatives want to ensure that public agencies are in charge of EMS dispatch.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 438 prohibits a public agency from delegating, assigning, or contracting for 911 call processing or emergency notification duties regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the delegation or assignment is to, or the contract is with, another public agency or made pursuant to a joint powers agreement or cooperative agreement.
SB 438 also provides that medical control does not affect a public safety agency’s authority to:
- Directly receive, process, and administer requests for assistance originating within the agency’s jurisdiction through the 911 system; or
- Determine the appropriate deployment of public safety and emergency response resources within the agency’s jurisdiction.
SB 438 says that a public safety agency’s voluntary consent to limit, modify, or alter the nature of its prehospital response or response mode under a dispatch protocol approved by a local EMS agency does not constitute a transfer of any of the agency’s authorities regarding the administration of emergency medical services.
SB 438 makes findings and declarations to support its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The provision of fire protection services, rescue and emergency medical services, hazardous material emergency response, ambulance and other services related to the protection of lives and property is critical to the public peace, health and safety of the state. Likewise, the call processing and administration of such emergency response functions has traditionally been recognized as one of the highest priorities and obligations of government. However, many jurisdictions choose to outsource their local emergency services, under the guise of a cost savings. SB 438 prohibits a public agency from outsourcing its local emergency dispatch services to a private, for-profit entity. It ensures that local government can determine the appropriate level of emergency response with its community and explicitly protects a government’s right and obligation to receive and process emergency calls to ensure effective, efficient and rapid deployment of emergency response apparatus. When dealing with emergency care and other vital services, like firefighting, privatization results in an inherent pressure: the demand to turn a profit while caring for people in their most vulnerable moments. SB 438 ensures that the safety of all Californians is in the hands of a public agency, ensuring the best possible standard of emergency care.”
2. Who does it best? The EMS Act charges counties with a life-or-death responsibility: ensuring that their citizens receive adequate emergency medical services. In discharging that responsibility, counties compare the offerings and capabilities of both public and private entities, and enter into agreements based on which entities can best provide the services. Some LEMSAs have fire departments dispatch EMS; others have chosen to award EMS dispatch contracts to private services that bring the substantial resources and expertise of nation-wide companies. The ability to choose between the two is key to being able to offer the best services to county residents; county supervisors decide to enter into a contract with a private entity only after considering the fiscal, administrative, and service delivery implications for their communities. SB 438 intervenes in this decision-making by prohibiting counties from contracting out for EMS dispatch services. By tying the hands of local elected officials, SB 438 potentially prevents LEMSAs from choosing the service provider that best meets their constituents’ needs, with potential implications for public health. Furthermore, many counties have existing contracts with private EMS dispatchers that would be undermined by SB 438’s prohibition, potentially upending EMS delivery in those counties. Should the Legislature supplant its judgment for that of local officials that have direct responsibility for EMS delivery, and have awarded contracts accordingly?
3. Doctor, Doctor. Medical control as a concept extends beyond just what treatment to provide once medical professionals arrive on the scene. In order to function well and provide needed patient care in a timely fashion, the EMS system depends on all EMS providers, whether public or private, following the medical protocols established by the LEMSA. Recognizing this need, the California Supreme Court ruled that LEMSAs have broad authority to dispatch EMS resources as a part of medical control (County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino, 1997 15.Cal.4th 909). By providing that dispatch is outside of the medical control of LEMSAs, SB 438 potentially allows public safety agencies to disregard the direction of the LEMSA medical director on when and how to respond to calls. Without the mandate to follow the LEMSA’s dispatch protocols, a fire department could be free to ignore EMS calls or choose to deploy its resources elsewhere, even in the midst of responding to a medical emergency. Furthermore, some calls might not get routed to private ambulance services, even if they are better positioned to respond to the incident. The Committee may wish to consider the public health and safety impacts of SB 438.
4. Double referral. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double referral of SB 438: first to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee to hear issues of local authority, and second to the Senate Health Committee.
Support and Opposition
(4/5/19)
Support: California Fire Chiefs Association; California Professional Firefighters; Fire Districts Association of California.
Opposition: American Medical Response West; California State Association of Counties; County Health Executives Association of California; County Health Executives Association of California (Cheac); Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California (Emsaac); Ems Medical Directors Association of California (Emdac); Fresno; County of; Rural County Representatives of California; Urban Counties Caucus.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):