SB 442: State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: commercialization of investigation results.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 477, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 10 a.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 21, 2019 | August 21 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | June 18 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 24, 2019 | Referred to Com. on W., P., & W. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 7, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 6, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (May 6). |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB442 Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | SB 442 Dodd Senate Third Reading By Medina | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB442 Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 442 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 442
Amended: 9/3/19
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/23/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Borgeas, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-0, 5/6/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/9/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 74-0, 9/13/19
(ROLL CALL NOT AVAILABLE)
SUBJECT: State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: scientific research permits and commercialization permits
SOURCE: University of California
DIGEST:
This bill provides a framework for qualified institutions or individuals to commercialize discoveries that emanate from state park system units, subject to certain conditions.
Assembly Amendments
delete language codifying scientific collection permits; add language requiring institutions or individuals to publish investigation results in the public domain prior to commercializing the investigation results; add an Internet Web site reporting requirement for State Parks; and add provisions regarding benefits sharing agreements.
Existing federal law:
- Establishes the National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA), which requires all Federal agencies in the executive branch to assess the environmental effects of a proposed agency action and any reasonable alternatives before making a decision on whether, and if so how, to proceed. In addition to agency projects, NEPA also applies to private programs or policies if those program or policies require Federal agency decisions on approvals, permits, or funding.
- Establishes the Federal Technology Transfer Act, which improves access to federal laboratories by non-federal organizations and enables federal laboratories to enter into Cooperative Research and Development Agreements (CRADAs) and to negotiate licenses for patented inventions made at the laboratory.
Existing state law:
- Establishes the Department of Parks and Recreation (State Parks). With 280 state park units, 340 miles of coastline, and thousands of miles of trails, California’s state park system is one of the largest and most diverse state park systems within the United States.
- The mission of State Parks is to “provide for the health, inspiration and education of the people of California by helping to preserve the state's extraordinary biological diversity, protecting its most valued natural and cultural resources, and creating opportunities for high-quality outdoor recreation.”
- Prohibits, with limited exception, the commercial exploitation of resources in units of the state park system.
- Allows qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units, upon receiving prior approval of the director of State Parks.
- Allows the taking of mineral specimens for recreational purposes from state beaches, state recreation areas, or state vehicular recreation areas upon receiving prior approval of the director.
- Establishes the State Parks and Recreation Fund, which receives revenue from the collection of fees, rents, and other returns for the use of any state park system area. Moneys in this fund are available upon appropriation by the Legislature.
- Establishes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which requires state and local agencies to identify the significant environmental impacts of their actions and to avoid or mitigate those impacts, if feasible. CEQA requirements apply to public agency projects including activities directly undertaken by a governmental agency and activities financed in whole or in part by a governmental agency. CEQA also applies to private projects that involve governmental participation, financing, approval, or permitting.
- Prohibits a person from knowingly and willfully excavating upon, removing, destroying, injuring, or defacing any historic or prehistoric ruins, burial grounds, archeological or vertebrate paleontological site, or any other archeological, paleontological, or historical feature situated on public lands, unless the public agency with jurisdiction over those lands provides express permission.
This bill provides a framework for institutions and individuals, as specified, to commercialize discoveries that stem from state park system units, subject to certain limitations. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units, upon approval of the Director of State Parks.
- Defines “investigation results” to be the results of scientific research, scientific investigation, or the progeny of biological samples collected through approved scientific investigation pursuant to (1).
- Establishes a commercialization permit, to be issued at the discretion of the director of State Parks, that would authorize applicants to commercialize particular investigation results only if the applicant has done both of the following:
- Published or otherwise placed into the public domain the investigation results.
- Entered into a benefits sharing agreement with State Parks, subject to the requirements that the benefits sharing agreement:
- Is limited to the particular investigation results and the specific commercial application identified in the agreement.
- Describes State Parks’ compensable interest in the commercial application of the particular investigation results. These interests may include, among other considerations, monetary and nonmonetary benefits to be provided to State Parks resulting from the commercial application.
- Is not approved solely for its revenue producing potential.
- Authorizes the director of State Parks to enter into a benefits sharing agreement with a commercialization permit applicant, if the applicant has:
- Identified the commercial application and the particular investigation results to be used in the commercial application.
- Described how the commercial application identified will provide a compelling public benefit to the state, particularly benefits that advance resource protection and management.
- Demonstrated that no further collection of specimens or disturbance of state park system resources will be required for the commercial application.
- Agreed to any other required terms and conditions of State Parks and paid any required application and administrative fees to State Parks.
- Authorizes State Parks to set and collect application fees for commercialization permits and applications in an amount not to exceed reasonable costs of State Parks.
- Requires State Parks to deposit fees collected for commercialization permits and proceeds from benefit sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund to be available to State Parks, upon appropriation by the Legislature, for the management and restoration of natural resources of the state park system and administration of the requirements relating to commercialization permits.
- Clarifies that moneys deposited in the State Parks and Recreation Fund pursuant to 6) above, are in addition to and do not supplant or replace any existing state funding for the operation and maintenance of the state park system.
- Requires State Parks to post, and update annually, information regarding approved commercial applications, including the applicant’s name, the park unit affected, a brief description of the project permitted, and a summary of the benefits sharing agreement, on its internet website.
- Clarifies that commercialization permit applicants must comply with state and federal laws and regulations, including permit requirements.
- Requires any person or entity that commercializes or seeks to commercialize investigation results obtained within the state park system without a director-approved benefits sharing agreement to pay 75 percent of gross revenue from the commercialization of the investigation results to State Parks, in addition to all other remedies in law or equity that State Parks may have.
Background
Scientific Research and Collecting Permits. As noted above, existing state law authorizes qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within State Parks. The California Code of Regulations (CCR) further grants State Parks the authorization to issue permits for such investigation (Title 14, CCR, §4309). These permits are called “Scientific Research and Collecting Permits” and may be obtained by submitting an application package that includes, among other things, proof of insurance, credentials for the principal investigator or person overseeing field work, maps/coordinates for each distinct study location, a full study proposal, and copies of any additional local, state and/or federal permits required. Permits are only granted for proposals that demonstrate distinct benefit to State Parks. Additionally, permits to collect specimens are issued only if the specimen is an integral part of, and necessary to, the specific project involved. State Parks does not issue permits for general classroom collecting, either supervised or unsupervised, due to the cumulative impact that students may have on state park resources.
Bioprospecting. Bioprospecting is the process of discovery and commercialization of information or products created from genetic or biochemical resources. Though the word “prospecting” is associated with extractive industries such as logging and mining, bioprospecting does not typically require large-scale resource consumption; primary products often include microbes and other biological matter that can be sampled in gram-sized amounts.
The past several decades have seen rapid growth in the field of bioprospecting. The microbe Thermus aquaticus, discovered in Yellowstone National Park (YNP) in 1966, yielded early success in the field. T. aquaticus was found to be capable of surviving intense heat, and in the early 1980s an enzyme of T. aquaticus called Taq polymerase was used to advance the development of polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a Nobel-prize winning technique that allows DNA to be copied rapidly.
More than thirty years later, PCR serves as the basis for a multi-million dollar industry where it has contributed significantly to a wide number of technologies, including DNA fingerprinting, disease diagnostics, and forensic analysis. Today, Taq polymerase and other microorganisms continue to inspire the development of novel technologies. Microorganisms found in extreme environments are being used to develop a wide range of practical applications including cancer treatments and meat alternatives.
Discoveries within state park system units show that similar discoveries and innovations may be possible in California. In one recent instance, a novel strain of bacteria – collected in a unit of the state park system through a University of California Davis scientific investigation – facilitated the development of a treatment for the devastating tomato wilt pathogen. Additional experiments performed with the same bacteria have showed promise in treating Sudden Oak Death, an invasive plant pathogen that is ravaging the California Live Oak population as well as other species.
Federal Benefits-Sharing Model. The story of T. aquaticus provides a case study for the commercialization of results or products emanating from scientific research on public lands. Despite the wide success of PCR in a variety of technologies, YNP did not receive any share in the financial benefits that arose from its commercialization. This led the National Park Service (NPS) to begin exploring benefit-sharing options. In 1998, YNP and the biotechnology firm Diversa entered into a landmark CRADA benefits-sharing agreement that promised a portion of Diversa’s future profits from research involving specimens in YNP would go toward park resource preservation. The YNP-Diversa agreement was challenged in court, which upheld the agreement but required the NPS to review the potential impacts of the agreement through a NEPA analysis. At the same time, Congress passed the National Parks Omnibus Act of 1998, which increased the emphasis on scientific research activities in the national parks and authorized the NPS to enter into equitable and efficient benefit-sharing arrangements with the research community and private industry.
In 2010, following the release of its final Benefits-Sharing Environmental Impact Statement, the NPS issued a Record of Decision to implement benefits-sharing agreements across all national parks. The NPS released policies and procedures for its Benefits Sharing Program in 2013, which specifies different types of benefit-sharing agreements and provides guidelines on technology transfer.
Comments
What constitutes benefits sharing? All scientific research conducted within state parks provides some type of benefit; scientific studies support the mission of State Parks by providing reports, data, and other information that add to the understanding of the park’s resources, processes, and values. Benefits sharing would allow State Parks to receive monetary or other benefits from a discovery or product resulting from scientific investigation in a unit of the state park system. Incorporating benefits sharing into State Parks’ existing framework for scientific investigation enhances the public benefits arising from research in state parks and may result in improved conservation of resources.
National Parks as a model. The NPS Benefits Sharing Program, described above, is a federal program that shares many of the same objectives sought by this bill. Although State Parks and the NPS operate under different laws and authorities, the NPS Benefits Sharing Program serves as a model that may help to inform benefit sharing with State Parks.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- State Parks estimates first-year costs of $642,000 and ongoing costs of $540,000 (SPRF), including a one-time cost of $75,000 to develop regulations for implementation of the commercialization program. The remainder of estimated costs consist of one-time and ongoing staffing costs associated with the permitting process and the development of benefit sharing agreements. Costs will be offset by permit fee revenue.
- State Parks anticipates generating additional revenue through the benefits-sharing agreements and notes one existing party is currently prepared to enter into a benefits sharing agreement and begin the commercialization of completed research. However, State Parks does not yet have an estimate of the resulting revenues.
University of California (source)
California Tomato Research Institute
Marrone Bio Innovations
Novozymes
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/10/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.”
The bill’s sponsor, the University of California, states that, “Current law prohibits the commercialization of resources discovered in California State Parks, regardless of the resource, institution, or proposed use under most circumstances. While in many instances this restriction is a valid protection of precious natural resources and parks, the restriction can also serve to restrict the state from realizing potential groundbreaking scientific discoveries.”
They continue, “Allowing for the commercialization of research products extracted from state park resources in certain specific, limited instances, will help to provide researchers and scientists with an enhanced opportunity to realize and develop beneficial inventions and discoveries for the citizens of California. While the potential possibilities for such discoveries is impossible to estimate, we have already seen that these discoveries have the potential to improve agricultural output, reduce reliance on toxic alternatives, and potentially mitigate issues plaguing the California ecosystem. Equally important is that these benefits can be realized with minimal impact to actual state park resources.”
Prepared by: Sydney Chamberlin, William Craven / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
9/13/19 21:35:12
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 442
Author:(Dodd)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill creates a framework by which individuals and institutions can commercialize scientific research or collection conducted within the state park system subject to certain limitations and requirements including signing a benefits-sharing agreement with the Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR).
Major Provisions
Currently commercial exploitation of resources in state parks is prohibited. This bill provides an exception to that for commercialization of results of approved scientific research and investigations provided that such applicants make their scientific investigation results available publicly and enter into a benefits-sharing agreement with the DPR. An entity seeking to commercialize research must also show that any commercial application provides a compelling public benefit to the state and requires no further disturbance of the park system. This bill permits the DPR to collect fees for such permits and establishes a penalty of 75% of gross revenues for commercializing research results without an approved benefits-sharing agreement.
COMMENTS:
The DPR manages 280 state park units on 1.4 million acres and over 340 miles of coastline that preserve one of the largest and most diverse array of natural environments. The DPR allows individuals and institutions to conduct research that is minimally disruptive and does not cause damage to environment within the park system upon approval of a research permit. Current code and department regulations prohibit collected material from being used for commercial purposes.
Scientific Research and Collection in State Parks. The DPR currently has a permitting program for conducting scientific activities in state park system lands. Permits are only granted to qualified applicants for proposals that demonstrate a distinct benefit to the DPR and minimize impacts to the park system. Currently, the department does not have a fee associated with the research permits, and requires a final report on the project to be submitted to the department along with any materials published as a result of the permit.
Bioprospecting. Bioprospecting is the process of discovering and commercializing research and products developed from biological resources. While “prospecting” tends to conjure up images of large-scale extractive industries like mining, bioprospecting can typically be done with minimal impact to flora and fauna. Primary sources of bioprospecting products are microbes and other biological material that can be sampled in small amounts. In California, a scientific investigation led by a University of California, Davis team discovered a novel strain of bacteria found in forest soil collected from a state park unit. This microbe has promising anti-fungal properties and has led to the development of a treatment for the devastating tomato wilt pathogen.
Research Commercialization at the Federal Level. The National Parks Service (NPS) also encourages science and research within its system. The NPS has an extensive scientific research permitting program. Additionally, the NPS allows the commercializing of discoveries from its parks and it developed and implemented a benefits-sharing program in 2013 to allow the NPS to receive monetary or other compensation from the commercial use of a discovery or invention resulting from research originating under an NPS permit. Each year the NPS issues more than 3,000 scientific research and collecting permits and makes information on permits available online. Since the benefits-sharing program is in its infancy, the NPS has not started to publish statistics on the program. However, a 2017 Department of the Interior annual report on technology transfers notes that the NPS had one agreement active in 2017.
According to the Author:
SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters state allowing for the commercialization of research products extracted from state park resources in certain specific, limited instances, will help provide researchers and scientists with an enhanced opportunity to realize and develop beneficial inventions and discoveries for the citizens of California. Supporters say discoveries already made have the potential to improve agricultural output, reduce reliance on toxic alternatives, and potentially mitigate issues plaguing the California ecosystem. They also say that these benefits can be realized with minimal impact to actual state park resources as the proposed program strikes the appropriate balance between protection and access within California’s state parks.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the DPR estimates first-year costs of $642,000 and ongoing costs of $540,000 to develop regulations for the implementation of the commercialization program and ongoing staffing cost associated with the permitting process and benefit-sharing agreement development. These costs would be offset by permit fee revenue. The DPR also anticipates generating additional revenue through the benefits-sharing agreements.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE: 14-0-0
YES: Eduardo Garcia, Gallagher, Bigelow, Choi, Chu, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Kalra, Levine, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Wood, Mathis
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Jared Ferguson / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096 FN: 0001828
Date of Hearing: August 21, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 442
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:August 13, 2019
Policy Committee: | Water, Parks and Wildlife | Vote: | 14 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill authorizes the Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) to permit the commercialization of research, scientific investigations or progeny of a specimen within units of the state park system. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires applications to commercialize research results or specimens to require a separate benefits-sharing agreement.
- Allows applicants to commercialize the results of research, scientific investigations or progeny of a specimen pursuant to the following:
- The results of the applicants’ work will be placed in the public domain.
- The applicant will not commercialize their work until the benefits-sharing agreement is completed with DPR.
- The benefit-sharing agreement is executed, as specified.
- Allows DPR to set and collect application fees in amounts not to exceed reasonable costs.
- Requires DPR to deposit the fees and the proceeds collected from the benefits-sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund (SPRF), to be available, upon appropriation by the Legislature, for the management and restoration of state park system, but not to supplant and existing funding for operations and maintenance.
- Requires DPR to annually post and update information regarding approved commercialization applications on its website, as specified.
- Requires any entity that commercializes or seeks to commercialize the results of their work without an approved benefits-sharing agreement to pay 75% of gross revenue from the commercialization to DPR.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- DPR estimates first-year costs of $642,000 and ongoing costs of $540,000 (SPRF), including a one-time cost of $75,000 to develop regulations for implementation of the commercialization program. The remainder of estimated costs consist of one-time and ongoing staffing costs associated with the permitting process and the development of benefit sharing agreements. Costs will be offset by permit fee revenue.
- DPR anticipates generating additional revenue through the benefits-sharing agreements and notes one existing party is currently prepared to enter into a benefits sharing agreement and begin the commercialization of completed research. However, DPR does not yet have an estimate of the resulting revenues.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.
- Background. DPR currently has a permitting program for conducting scientific activities in state park system lands. These permits are called “Scientific Research and Collecting Permits” and may be obtained by submitting an application package that includes, among other things, proof of insurance, credentials for the principal investigator or person overseeing field work, maps and coordinates for each distinct study location, a full study proposal, and copies of any additional local, state and federal permits required. Depending on the type of research, other permits from the Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) and federal agencies might also be needed.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 442
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: scientific research permits and commercialization permits
SUMMARY: Establishes a framework by which institutions and individuals can commercialize scientific research and discoveries that emanate from California’s state park system. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes the Director of Parks and Recreation to issue scientific research permits to qualified institutions of higher learning, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigations within state park system units, including nondestructive collection of specimens for scientific research purpose.
- Creates a commercialization permit, which may be issued at the director’s discretion, that allows qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to commercialize the results of scientific investigations or progeny of a specimen conducted pursuant to a scientific research permit.
- The director may only issue a commercialization permit if the applicant has done all of the following:
- Identified the research results or particular specimen to be commercialized and its specific commercial application.
- Demonstrated that the commercial application will provide a compelling public benefit to the state and is compatible with the Department of Parks and Recreation’s (DPR’s) mission.
- Demonstrated that no further collection of specimens or disturbance of state park system resources will be required.
- Executed a benefit-sharing agreement with the DPR that includes a percentage of monetary or other nonmonetary benefits to the DPR resulting from the commercial application.
- Agreed to any other required terms or conditions of the DPR and paid any required application or administrative fees.
- Requires commercialization permits to be limited to the research results or the particular specimen progeny as identified in the application.
- Authorizes the DPR to set and collect application and permit fees for scientific research and commercialization permits, not to exceed the reasonable regulatory cost of issuing and enforcing the permits.
- Requires the DPR to deposit fees collected and proceeds collected from benefit-sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund, to be available to the department upon appropriation by the legislature.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes within the California Natural Resources Agency the DPR with the mission to “provide for the health, inspiration, and education of the people of California by helping to preserve the state’s extraordinary biological diversity, protecting its most valued natural and cultural resources, and creating opportunities for high-quality outdoor recreation.”
- Prohibits the commercial exploitation of resources in units of the state park system with the following exceptions:
- Slant or directional drilling for oil or gas underlying the Tule Elk State Reserve in Kern County.
- Commercial fishing in state marine conservation areas, marine cultural preservation areas, and marine recreational management areas. [Public Resources Code (PRC) § 5001.65]
- Encourages qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within the state park system upon approval of the director. (PRC § 5001.65)
- Allows the DPR to grant a permit to remove, treat, disturb, or destroy plants or animals or geological, historical, archaeological or paleontological materials [California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 14, § 4309]
- Allows, upon receiving prior approval of the director, the taking of mineral specimens for recreational purposes from state beaches, recreation areas, or vehicular recreation areas. (PRC § 5001.65)
- Creates the State Parks and Recreation Fund in the State Treasury to receive revenues collected by the DPR and allows the DPR to collect fees, rents, and other returns for the use of any state park system area, with the amounts to be determined by the department. (PRC § 5010)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: This bill codifies the DPR’s scientific research and collection permits and creates a framework by which individuals and institutions can commercialize research or collection conducted within the state park system subject to certain limitations and requirements.
Author’s Statement:
SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.
Background: The DPR manages 280 state park units on 1.4 million acres and over 340 miles of coastline that preserve one of the largest and most diverse array of natural environments. The DPR allows individuals and institutions to conduct research that is minimally disruptive and does not cause damage to environment within the park system upon approval of a research permit. Current code and department regulations prohibit collected material from being used for commercial purposes.
At the national level, the National Parks Service (NPS) also encourages science and research within its system. The NPS has an extensive scientific research permitting program. Additionally, the NPS allows the commercializing of discoveries from its parks and it has recently developed and implemented a benefits-sharing program to allow the NPS to receive monetary or other compensation from the commercial use of a discovery or invention resulting from research originating under an NPS permit.
Scientific Research and Collection in State Parks. The DPR currently has a permitting program for conducting scientific activities in state park system lands. These permits are called “Scientific Research and Collecting Permits” and may be obtained by submitting an application package that includes, among other things, proof of insurance, credentials for the principal investigator or person overseeing field work, maps/coordinates for each distinct study location, a full study proposal, and copies of any additional local, state and/or federal permits required. Depending on the type of research, other permits from the Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) and federal agencies might also be needed.
Permits are only granted for proposals that demonstrate a distinct benefit to the DPR. Additionally, permits to collect specimens are issued only if the specimens are an integral part of, and necessary to, the specific project involved. Currently, the department does not have a fee associated with the research permits, and requires a final report on the project to be submitted to the department along with any materials published as a result of the permit.
Applicants requesting the DPR’s scientific research and collection permit currently undergo an additional screening process to determine whether the proposed work requires environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). This determination is made at the discretion of the DPR, and depends on the scope and nature of the research that is being proposed. If CEQA review is required, applicants are notified of additional steps that are needed. The majority of proposed scientific investigations, however, do not require review under CEQA.
Bioprospecting. Bioprospecting is the process of discovering and commercializing research and products developed from biological resources, typically plant, fungal, or microbial. Historically, around one third of all the U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved chemical entities were derived from natural sources. While “prospecting” tends to conjure up images of large-scale extractive industries like mining, bioprospecting can typically be done with minimal impact to flora and fauna. Primary sources of bioprospecting products are microbes and other biological material that can be sampled in small amounts.
Biopiracy. Bioprospecting has sometimes been conducted in an unethical and exploitative manner. This practice, coined “biopiracy,” is described as the commercialization of indigenous people’s knowledge of nature for profit without authorization or compensation to the indigenous people themselves.
Bioprospecting and Research Commercialization in the United States. Highlighted as a bioprospecting success story in the United States is the discovery of Thermus aquaticus (T. aquaticus) a thermophile (heat loving) microbe in the geothermal springs of Yellowstone National Park (YNP) by a researcher in the 1960s. In the 1980s, an enzyme isolated from T. aquaticus, due to the microbe’s ability to survive intense heat, was key to the development of polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a Nobel Prize winning process that allows DNA to be replicated rapidly. PCR is indispensable to current biomedical research, being used in DNA forensics, medical diagnoses, and genetic engineering. The patents for the enzyme and the PCR process are estimated to have earned billions of dollars in royalties.
Researchers continue to search for new extremophiles (microorganisms which can survive in extreme environments) and other organisms in biologically diverse areas around the world. Enzymes isolated from extremophiles have recently helped scientists develop a wide variety of potential commercial applications, from methods for improving biofuel production to helping agricultural crops withstand drought and diseases.
In California, recent research within the state park system shows potential for similar innovations. A scientific investigation led by a University of California, Davis team discovered a novel strain of bacteria found in forest soil collected from a state park unit. This microbe has promising anti-fungal properties and has led to the development of a treatment for the devastating tomato wilt pathogen. In additional experiments, the same bacteria has promise in treating Sudden Oak Death, a fungal-like pathogen that has been devastating live oaks in California’s coastal forests.
Benefits-Sharing on the Federal Level. In 2013, the National Park Service (NPS) issued service-wide policy and procedures for benefit-sharing from the commercializing of research or collection conducted in parks. Though the T. aquaticus serves as the prime example of successful commercializing of products, YNP did not receive any share of the financial benefits that arose from its commercializing. As a result, YNP began exploring benefit-sharing options for the park. In 1997, YNP entered into a Cooperative Research and Development Agreement (CRADA) under the Federal Technology Transfer Act of 1986 (FTTA) with a biotechnology firm. Subsequently, the U.S. Congress enacted the National Parks Omnibus Management Act of 1998, which included in Title 2 of the act authorization for the NPS to enter into benefits-sharing agreements with the research community and private industry.
In 2010, the NPS completed its final benefits-sharing environmental impact statement, and issued a record of decision to implement benefits-sharing agreements across all national parks. The NPS finalized and released the policies and procedures for its benefits-sharing program in 2013, which specifies different types of benefit-sharing agreements both monetary and non-monetary and provides guidelines on technology transfer. Under the program if a park seeks benefit-sharing of monetary benefits, it must first be designated as a federal laboratory by the NPS Director. The park can then negotiate a CRADA with a non-federal researcher or company. Benefit-sharing agreements are decided on a case-by-case basis by each national park unit.
Each year the NPS issues more than 3,000 scientific research and collecting permits and makes information on permits available online. Since the initiation of the NPS’s benefits-sharing program, the NPS has not seen a significant change in the number of research permits issued. As the program is in its infancy, the NPS has not started to publish statistics on the program. However, a 2017 Department of the Interior annual report on technology transfers notes that the NPS had one CRADA active in 2017.
Department of Fish and Wildlife Research Permits. The Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) also issues scientific research and collecting permits pursuant to the code (Fish and Game Code §§ 1002, 1002.5, and 1003) for mammals, birds, fish, amphibians, reptiles, or any other form of plant or animal life including marine algae and plants. The department’s regulations prohibit the commercial sales of wildlife taken or use of the wildlife for commercial purposes (Title 14, California Code of Regulations § 650).
Suggested Committee Amendments: The committee may wish to consider amendments that do the following:
- Establish the authorization for research and commercialization permits in a separate section and state in PRC § 5001.65 that commercialization of results of scientific research or investigations is permissible with the requirements prescribed by the new section.
- Remove repetitive language regarding the ability of the director to issue research and commercialization permits.
- Require any applicant wishing to commercialize research to have published or placed into public domain the results of their research or investigation, to not commercialize their research until entering into a benefit-sharing agreement, and to enter into a benefits sharing agreement with the DPR.
- Permit the director to enter into benefits-sharing agreements with an applicant provided the applicant:
- Identifies the research results or particular progeny to be used in the commercial application.
- Describes how the application will provide a compelling public benefit to the state, particularly those that enhance resource protection and management.
- Demonstrates that no further disturbance of state park system resources will be required.
- Agrees to any other terms or conditions of the DPR and paid any application fees.
- Prohibit the approval of a benefit-sharing agreement solely on its revenue producing potential.
- Note that an applicant or permit holder must still comply with state and federal law and regulations, including permit requirements.
- Add a requirement that the DPR post and update annually on its internet website information regarding approved commercialization permits.
Previous and Related Legislation:
AB 1228 (Bloom, 2017), authorized the DFW to issue experimental fishing permits to allow commercial or recreational fishing activity that would otherwise be prohibited in order to collect data or conduct other research that could inform the potential opening of a new fishery or an area currently closed to fishing. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
Supporting Arguments: Supporters state allowing for the commercialization of research products extracted from state park resources in certain specific, limited instances, will help provide researchers and scientists with an enhanced opportunity to realize and develop beneficial inventions and discoveries for the citizens of California. Supporters say discoveries already made have the potential to improve agricultural output, reduce reliance on toxic alternatives, and potentially mitigate issues plaguing the California ecosystem. They also say that these benefits can be realized with minimal impact to actual state park resources as the proposed program strikes the appropriate balance between protection and access within California’s state parks.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Tomato Research Institute
Marrone Bio Innovations
Novozymes, Inc.
University of California
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Jared Ferguson / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 442 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 442
Amended: 3/25/19
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/23/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Borgeas, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-0, 5/6/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford
SUBJECT: State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: scientific research permits and commercialization permits
SOURCE: University of California
DIGEST:
This bill provides a framework for qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, or individuals to commercialize discoveries that emanate from state park system units, provided that the proposed commercial application provides a compelling public benefit to the state, is compatible with the mission of the Department of Parks and Recreation (State Parks), and is developed according to a benefit sharing agreement with State Parks.
Existing federal law:
- Establishes the National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA), which requires all federal agencies in the executive branch to assess the environmental effects of a proposed agency action and any reasonable alternatives before making a decision on whether, and if so how, to proceed. In addition to agency projects, NEPA also applies to private programs or policies if those program or policies require federal agency decisions on approvals, permits, or funding.
- Establishes the Federal Technology Transfer Act (FTTA), which improves access to federal laboratories by non-federal organizations and enables federal laboratories to enter into Cooperative Research and Development Agreements (CRADAs) and to negotiate licenses for patented inventions made at the laboratory.
Existing state law:
- Establishes the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to restore, protect and manage the state’s natural, historical and cultural resources for current and future generations using creative approaches and solutions based on science, collaboration and respect for all the communities and interests involved.
- Establishes within the CNRA the State Parks. With 280 state park units, 340 miles of coastline, and thousands of miles of trails, California’s state park system is one of the largest and most diverse state park systems within the United States.
- The mission of State Parks is to “provide for the health, inspiration and education of the people of California by helping to preserve the state's extraordinary biological diversity, protecting its most valued natural and cultural resources, and creating opportunities for high-quality outdoor recreation.”
- Prohibits, with limited exception, the commercial exploitation of resources in units of the state park system.
- Allows qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units, upon receiving prior approval of the director of State Parks.
- Allows the taking of mineral specimens for recreational purposes from state beaches, state recreation areas, or state vehicular recreation areas upon receiving prior approval of the director.
- Establishes the State Parks and Recreation Fund, which receives revenue from the collection of fees, rents, and other returns for the use of any state park system area. Moneys in this fund are available upon appropriation by the Legislature.
- Establishes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which requires state and local agencies to identify the significant environmental impacts of their actions and to avoid or mitigate those impacts, if feasible. CEQA requirements apply to public agency projects including activities directly undertaken by a governmental agency and activities financed in whole or in part by a governmental agency. CEQA also applies to private projects that involve governmental participation, financing, approval, or permitting.
- Prohibits a person from knowingly and willfully excavating upon, removing, destroying, injuring, or defacing any historic or prehistoric ruins, burial grounds, archeological or vertebrate paleontological site, or any other archeological, paleontological, or historical feature situated on public lands, unless the public agency with jurisdiction over those lands provides express permission.
This bill provides a framework for institutions and individuals, as specified, to commercialize discoveries that stem from state park system units, subject to certain limitations. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes a scientific research permit, to be issued at the discretion of the director of State Parks, that would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to:
- Conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units.
- Engage in nondestructive collection of scientific specimens for scientific research purposes.
- Establishes a commercialization permit, to be issued at the discretion of the director of State Parks that would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to commercialize the results of scientific investigations or progeny of a specimen, or both of those things, conducted pursuant to a scientific research permit.
- Authorizes the director of State Parks to issue a commercialization permit only if the qualified institution of higher education, nonprofit research institution, or individual seeking the permit has done all of the following:
- Identified the research results or the particular specimen progeny, or both, to be commercialized and the specific commercial application.
- Demonstrated that the commercial application identified pursuant to (a) will provide a compelling public benefit to the state and is compatible with State Park’s mission.
- Demonstrated that no further collection of specimens or disturbance of state park system resources will be required for the commercial application identified for the commercial application identified pursuant to 1a) above.
- Executed a benefit sharing agreement with State Parks that includes a percentage of monetary or other nonmonetary benefits to be provided to State Parks resulting from the commercial application identified pursuant to 1a) above.
- Agreed to any other required terms and conditions of State Parks and paid any required application and administrative fees to State Parks.
- Limits commercialization permits to the research results or the particular specimen progeny, as applicable, that are identified by the permittee.
- Authorizes State Parks to set and collect application and permit fees for scientific research permits and commercialization permits in an amount not to exceed the reasonable regulatory cost of issuing and enforcing those permits.
- Requires State Parks to deposit fees collected for scientific research permits, commercialization permits, or benefit sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund to be available to State Parks, as specified.
Background
Scientific Research and Collecting Permits. As noted above, existing state law authorizes qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within State Parks. The California Code of Regulations (CCR) further grants State Parks the authorization to issue permits for such investigation (Title 14, CCR, §4309). These permits are called “Scientific Research and Collecting Permits” and may be obtained by submitting an application package that includes, among other things, proof of insurance, credentials for the principal investigator or person overseeing field work, maps/coordinates for each distinct study location, a full study proposal, and copies of any additional local, state and/or federal permits required. Permits are only granted for proposals that demonstrate distinct benefit to State Parks. Additionally, permits to collect specimens are issued only if the specimen is an integral part of, and necessary to, the specific project involved. State Parks does not issue permits for general classroom collecting, either supervised or unsupervised, due to the cumulative impact that students may have on state park resources.
Bioprospecting. Bioprospecting is the process of discovery and commercialization of information or products created from genetic or biochemical resources. Though the word “prospecting” is associated with extractive industries such as logging and mining, bioprospecting does not typically require large-scale resource consumption; primary products often include microbes and other biological matter that can be sampled in gram-sized amounts.
The past several decades have seen rapid growth in the field of bioprospecting. The microbe Thermus aquaticus, discovered in Yellowstone National Park (YNP) in 1966, yielded early success in the field. T. aquaticus was found to be capable of surviving intense heat, and in the early 1980s an enzyme of T. aquaticus called Taq polymerase was used to advance the development of polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a Nobel-prize winning technique that allows DNA to be copied rapidly.
More than thirty years later, PCR serves as the basis for a multi-million dollar industry where it has contributed significantly to a wide number of technologies, including DNA fingerprinting, disease diagnostics, and forensic analysis. Today, Taq polymerase and other microorganisms continue to inspire the development of novel technologies. Microorganisms found in extreme environments are being used to develop a wide range of practical applications including cancer treatments and meat alternatives.
Discoveries within state park system units show that similar discoveries and innovations may be possible in California. In one recent instance, a novel strain of bacteria – collected in a unit of the state park system through a University of California, Davis, scientific investigation – facilitated the development of a treatment for the devastating tomato wilt pathogen. Additional experiments performed with the same bacteria have showed promise in treating Sudden Oak Death, an invasive plant pathogen that is ravaging the California Live Oak population as well as other species.
Federal Benefits-Sharing Model. The story of T. aquaticus provides a case study for the commercialization of results or products emanating from scientific research on public lands. Despite the wide success of PCR in a variety of technologies, YNP did not receive any share in the financial benefits that arose from its commercialization. This led the National Park Service (NPS) to begin exploring benefit-sharing options. In 1998, YNP and the biotechnology firm Diversa entered into a landmark CRADA benefits-sharing agreement that promised a portion of Diversa’s future profits from research involving specimens in YNP would go toward park resource preservation. The YNP-Diversa agreement was challenged in court, which upheld the agreement but required the NPS to review the potential impacts of the agreement through a NEPA analysis. At the same time, Congress passed the National Parks Omnibus Act of 1998, which increased the emphasis on scientific research activities in the national parks and authorized the NPS to enter into equitable and efficient benefit-sharing arrangements with the research community and private industry.
In 2010, following the release of its final Benefits-Sharing Environmental Impact Statement, the NPS issued a Record of Decision to implement benefits-sharing agreements across all national parks. The NPS released policies and procedures for its Benefits Sharing Program in 2013, which specifies different types of benefit-sharing agreements and provides guidelines on technology transfer.
Comments
What constitutes benefits sharing? All scientific research conducted within state parks provides some type of benefit; scientific studies support the mission of State Parks by providing reports, data, and other information that add to the understanding of the park’s resources, processes, and values. Benefits sharing would allow State Parks to receive monetary or other benefits from a discovery or product resulting from scientific investigation in a unit of the state park system. Incorporating benefits sharing into State Parks’ existing framework for scientific investigation enhances the public benefits arising from research in state parks and may result in improved conservation of resources.
National Parks as a model. The NPS Benefits Sharing Program, described above, is a federal program that shares many of the same objectives sought by this bill. Although State Parks and the NPS operate under different laws and authorities, the NPS Benefits Sharing Program serves as a model that may help to inform benefit sharing with State Parks.
How will benefits be negotiated? This bill does not outline any particular framework for creating or negotiating agreements. In the federal model, the NPS defines different types of benefit sharing agreements that form a framework for negotiating agreements. These agreement types vary depending on what entity NPS seeks to partner with, who is to provide and receive benefits, and what NPS contributes to the partnership. However, the NPS is subject to federal laws, including the FTTA, that require such a framework. It is not immediately obvious whether such a framework would be necessary or beneficial for the state in entering benefits sharing agreements.
Compelling benefits. SB 442 places constraints on the types of commercial applications that would warrant a commercialization permit. Viable commercial applications would need to be compatible with State Parks’ mission while providing a compelling public benefit to the state. It is not clear what criteria may be used to establish which proposals are the most compelling in this context. Furthermore, while a commercial application may be compatible with State Parks’ mission, a stronger criterion might require the application to advance State Parks’ mission.
Non-monetary benefits. Non-monetary benefits obtained through a benefits-sharing agreement might include, for example, donation of equipment, training of staff, technology transfer, data collection, or surveying.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the fiscal impact of this bill includes unknown, likely minor special fund costs (State Parks and Recreation Fund) to State Parks for expanding their current permitting program to include the types of permits authorized in this bill. A benefit sharing agreement requirement from this bill could potentially generate some special fund revenue (State Parks and Recreation Fund) for the state.
University of California (source)
California Tomato Research Institute
Marrone Bio Innovations
Novozymes
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.”
The bill’s sponsor, the University of California, states that, “Current law prohibits the commercialization of resources discovered in California State Parks, regardless of the resource, institution, or proposed use under most circumstances. While in many instances this restriction is a valid protection of precious natural resources and parks, the restriction can also serve to restrict the state from realizing potential groundbreaking scientific discoveries.”
They continue, “Allowing for the commercialization of research products extracted from state park resources in certain specific, limited instances, will help to provide researchers and scientists with an enhanced opportunity to realize and develop beneficial inventions and discoveries for the citizens of California. While the potential possibilities for such discoveries is impossible to estimate, we have already seen that these discoveries have the potential to improve agricultural output, reduce reliance on toxic alternatives, and potentially mitigate issues plaguing the California ecosystem. Equally important is that these benefits can be realized with minimal impact to actual state park resources.”
Prepared by: Sydney Chamberlin, William Craven / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
5/8/19 15:24:20
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 442 (Dodd) - State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: scientific research permits and commercialization permits
Version: March 25, 2019 | Policy Vote: N.R. & W. 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2019 | Consultant: Paul Jacobs |
Bill Summary:
This bill would authorize the Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) to issue scientific research permits and commercialization permits to qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals.
Fiscal Impact:
Unknown, likely minor special fund costs (State Parks and Recreation Fund) to DPR for expanding their current permitting program to include the types of permits authorized in this bill. A benefit sharing agreement requirement from this bill could potentially generate some special fund revenue (State Parks and Recreation Fund) for the state.
Background:
DPR currently oversees 280 state park units, 340 miles of coastline, and thousands of miles of trails in California. Commercial exploitation of resources in state park system is currently prohibited, with the exception of certain types of oil or gas extraction underlying the Tule Elk State Reserve in Kern County, and commercial fishing in certain marine areas. Upon approval by DPR, qualified institutions and individuals are currently allowed to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units.
A public agency must comply with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) when it undertakes a project that may cause either a direct physical change in the environment or a reasonably foreseeable indirect change in the environment. This requirement includes permits issued by government agencies.
Proposed Law:
This bill provides a framework for institutions and individuals, as specified, to commercialize discoveries that emanate from California State Parks, subject to certain limitations. Specifically, this bill would:
- Establish a scientific research permit, to be issued by DPR, which would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific research within state park system units.
- Establish a commercialization permit, to be issued by DPR and subject to certain constraints, which would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to commercialize the results of scientific investigations conducted pursuant to a scientific research permit. Among other things, commercialization permittees are required to execute a benefit sharing agreement with DPR that includes a percentage of monetary or other nonmonetary benefits to be provided to DPR.
- Authorize DPR to set and collect application and permit fees for scientific research permits and commercialization permits in an amount not to exceed the reasonable regulatory cost of issuing and enforcing those permits.
- Require State Parks to deposit fees collected for scientific research permits, commercialization permits, or benefit sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund to be available to State Parks, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for the protection, conservation, and restoration of resources of the state park system.
Staff Comments:
DPR’s current Scientific Research and Collection permitting program already is well established and structured to provide the types of scientific research and commercialization permits authorized in this bill. According to DPR, it is unclear how many additional permits DPR will issue with the expansion of their existing program if this bill is implemented. Staff concludes that DPR could handle the additional workload from this bill with existing resources, or additional part-time staff, until it is determined that the number of additional permits created from this bill merits the need for additional permanent staff for DPR. As with their current program, SB 442 authorizes DPR to set and collect application and permit fees to cover the department costs to implement this bill.
Under DPR’s current Scientific Research and Collection permitting process, applicants undergo a screening process to determine whether the proposed work requires environmental review under CEQA. This determination is made at the discretion of DPR, and depends on the scope and nature of the research that is being proposed. If CEQA review will be required for permits issued pursuant to this bill, DPR could incur additional costs as the lead agency for the environmental review process. Currently, the majority of proposed scientific investigations within the state parks do not require review under CEQA. Therefore, staff estimates potential CEQA review costs for permits issued by DPR pursuant to this bill are likely to be minor.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 442 Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: | March 25, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sydney Chamberlin, William Craven | ||
Subject: State parks: resource exploitation exceptions: scientific research permits and commercialization permits
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Existing California law:
- Establishes the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to restore, protect and manage the state’s natural, historical and cultural resources for current and future generations using creative approaches and solutions based on science, collaboration and respect for all the communities and interests involved.
- Establishes within the CNRA the Department of Parks and Recreation (State Parks). With 280 state park units, 340 miles of coastline, and thousands of miles of trails, California’s state park system is one of the largest and most diverse state park systems within the United States.
- The mission of State Parks is to “provide for the health, inspiration and education of the people of California by helping to preserve the state's extraordinary biological diversity, protecting its most valued natural and cultural resources, and creating opportunities for high-quality outdoor recreation.”
- Prohibits the commercial exploitation of resources in units of the state park system, with the exception of:
- Slant or directional drilling for oil or gas with the intent of extracting deposits underlying the Tule Elk State Reserve in Kern County, permissible in accordance with PRC §6854.
- Commercial fishing, unless otherwise provided, in state marine conservation areas, state marine cultural preservation areas, and state marine recreational management areas.
- Allows qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units, upon receiving prior approval of the director.
- Allows the taking of mineral specimens for recreational purposes from state beaches, state recreation areas, or state vehicular recreation areas upon receiving prior approval of the director.
- Establishes the State Parks and Recreation Fund, which receives revenue from the collection of fees, rents, and other returns for the use of any state park system area. Moneys in this fund are available upon appropriation by the Legislature.
- Establishes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which requires state and local agencies to identify the significant environmental impacts of their actions and to avoid or mitigate those impacts, if feasible. CEQA requirements apply to public agency projects including activities directly undertaken by a governmental agency and activities financed in whole or in part by a governmental agency. CEQA also applies to private projects that involve governmental participation, financing, approval, or permitting.
- Prohibits a person from knowingly and willfully excavating upon, removing, destroying, injuring, or defacing any historic or prehistoric ruins, burial grounds, archeological or vertebrate paleontological site, including fossilized footprints, inscriptions made by human agency, rock art, or any other archeological, paleontological, or historical feature situated on public lands, unless the public agency with jurisdiction over those lands provides express permission.
Existing Federal law:
- Establishes the National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA), which requires all Federal agencies in the executive branch to assess the environmental effects of a proposed agency action and any reasonable alternatives before making a decision on whether, and if so how, to proceed. In addition to agency projects, NEPA also applies to private programs or policies if those program or policies require Federal agency decisions on approvals, permits, or funding.
- Establishes the Federal Technology Transfer Act (FTTA), which improves access to federal laboratories by non-federal organizations and enables federal laboratories to enter into Cooperative Research and Development Agreements (CRADAs) and to negotiate licenses for patented inventions made at the laboratory.
Scientific Research and Collecting Permits. As noted above, existing state law authorizes qualified institutions and individuals to conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within State Parks. The California Code of Regulations further grants State Parks the authorization to issue permits for such investigation (14 CCR § 4309). These permits are called “Scientific Research and Collecting Permits” and may be obtained by submitting an application package that includes, among other things, proof of insurance, credentials for the principal investigator or person overseeing field work, maps/coordinates for each distinct study location, a full study proposal, and copies of any additional local, state and/or federal permits required. Permits are only granted for proposals that demonstrate distinct benefit to State Parks. Additionally, permits to collect specimens are issued only if the specimen is an integral part of, and necessary to, the specific project involved. State Parks does not issue permits for general classroom collecting, either supervised or unsupervised, due to the cumulative impact that students may have on state park resources.
Bioprospecting. Bioprospecting is the process of discovery and commercialization of information or products created from genetic or biochemical resources. Though the word “prospecting” is associated with extractive industries such as logging and mining, bioprospecting does not typically require large-scale resource consumption; primary products often include microbes and other biological matter that can be sampled in gram-sized amounts.
The past several decades have seen rapid growth in the field of bioprospecting. The microbe Thermus aquaticus, discovered in Yellowstone National Park (YNP) in 1966, yielded early success in the field. T. aquaticus was found to be capable of surviving intense heat, and in the early 1980s an enzyme of T. aquaticus called Taq polymerase was used to advance the development of polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a Nobel-prize winning technique that allows DNA to be copied rapidly.
More than thirty years later, PCR serves as the basis for a multi-million dollar industry where it has contributed significantly to a wide number of technologies, including DNA fingerprinting, disease diagnostics, and forensic analysis. Today, Taq polymerase and other microorganisms continue to inspire the development of novel technologies. Microorganisms found in extreme environments (called “extremophiles”) are being used to develop a wide range of practical applications including cancer treatments and meat alternatives.
Discoveries within California state parks show that similar innovations may be possible in California. In one recent instance, a novel strain of bacteria – collected in a unit of the state park system through a University of California Davis scientific investigation – facilitated the development of a treatment for the devastating tomato wilt pathogen. Additional experiments performed with the same bacteria have showed promise in treating Sudden Oak Death, an invasive plant pathogen that is ravaging the California Live Oak population as well as other species.
Federal Benefits-Sharing Model:
The story of T. aquaticus provides a case study for the commercialization of results or products emanating from scientific research on public lands. Despite the wide success of PCR in a variety of technologies, YNP did not receive any share in the financial benefits that arose from its commercialization. This led the National Park Service (NPS) to begin exploring benefit-sharing options. In 1998, YNP and the biotechnology firm Diversa entered into a landmark CRADA benefits-sharing agreement that promised a portion of Diversa’s future profits from research involving specimens in YNP would go toward park resource preservation. The YNP-Diversa agreement was challenged in court, which upheld the agreement but required the NPS to review the potential impacts of the agreement through a NEPA Analysis. At the same time, Congress passed the National Parks Omnibus Act of 1998, which increased the emphasis on scientific research activities in the national parks and authorized the NPS to enter into equitable and efficient benefit-sharing arrangements with the research community and private industry.
In 2010, following the release of its final Benefits-Sharing Environmental Impact Statement, the NPS issued a Record of Decision to implement benefits-sharing agreements across all national parks. The NPS released policies and procedures for its Benefits Sharing Program in 2013, which specifies different types of benefit-sharing agreements and provides guidelines on technology transfer.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill provides a framework for institutions and individuals, as specified, to commercialize discoveries that emanate from California State Parks, subject to certain limitations. Specifically, this bill would:
- Establish a scientific research permit, to be issued at the discretion of the director of State Parks, that would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to:
- Conduct nondestructive forms of scientific investigation within state park system units.
- Engage in nondestructive collection of scientific specimens for scientific research purposes.
- Establish a commercialization permit, to be issued at the discretion of the director of State Parks that would allow qualified institutions of higher education, nonprofit research institutions, and individuals to commercialize the results of scientific investigations or progeny of a specimen, or both of those things, conducted pursuant to a scientific research permit.
- Authorize the director of State Parks to issue a commercialization permit only if the qualified institution of higher education, nonprofit research institution, or individual seeking the permit has done all of the following:
- Identified the research results or the particular specimen progeny, or both, to be commercialized and the specific commercial application.
- Demonstrated that the commercial application identified pursuant to (a) will provide a compelling public benefit to the state and is compatible with State Park’s mission.
- Demonstrated that no further collection of specimens or disturbance of state park system resources will be required for the commercial application identified for the commercial application identified pursuant to (a).
- Executed a benefit sharing agreement with State Parks that includes a percentage of monetary or other nonmonetary benefits to be provided to State Parks resulting from the commercial application identified pursuant to subdivision (a).
- Agreed to any other required terms and conditions of State Parks and paid any required application and administrative fees to State Parks.
- Require issued commercialization permits to be limited to the research results or the particular specimen progeny, as applicable, that are identified by the permittee pursuant to 3(a).
- Authorize State Parks to set and collect application and permit fees for scientific research permits and commercialization permits in an amount not to exceed the reasonable regulatory cost of issuing and enforcing those permits.
- Require State Parks to deposit fees collected for scientific research permits, commercialization permits, or benefit sharing agreements into the State Parks and Recreation Fund to be available to State Parks, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for the protection, conservation, and restoration of resources of the state park system.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “SB 442 would provide a limited exception that permits certain individuals and qualified institutions of higher education to commercialize discoveries that emanated from California State Parks. This bill aims at promoting research and scientific discoveries that will ultimately benefit the state. I believe this narrow exception strikes a fair balance between protecting our precious natural resources and making necessary scientific progress.”
The bill’s sponsor, the University of California, states that, “[c]urrent law prohibits the commercialization of resources discovered in California State Parks, regardless of the resource, institution, or proposed use under most circumstances. While in many instances this restriction is a valid protection of precious natural resources and parks, the restriction can also serve to restrict the state from realizing potential groundbreaking scientific discoveries.”
They continue, “[a]llowing for the commercialization of research products extracted from state park resources in certain specific, limited instances, will help to provide researchers and scientists with an enhanced opportunity to realize and develop beneficial inventions and discoveries for the citizens of California. While the potential possibilities for such discoveries is impossible to estimate, we have already seen that these discoveries have the potential to improve agricultural output, reduce reliance on toxic alternatives, and potentially mitigate issues plaguing the California ecosystem. Equally important is that these benefits can be realized with minimal impact to actual state park resources.”
Another supporter, Marrone Bio Innovations, adds that “[t]he current statute is a relic of a time period that did not recognize the potential of the undiscovered scientific benefits derived from the natural resources. Federal agencies, such as the National Park Service, as well as many other national governments have similar policies, laws and regulations in place, largely derived from the U.N. Conventional on Biodiversity, to simultaneously protect natural resources and to derive societal benefits from indigenous resources collected on public lands. With this cautiously crafted exception, we can take steps to promoting scientific discoveries that can and will provide natural and organic solutions that afflict the environment.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received.
COMMENTS
What constitutes benefits sharing? All scientific research conducted within state parks provide some type of benefit; scientific studies support the mission of State Parks by providing reports, data, and other information that add to the understanding of the park’s resources, processes, and values. Benefits sharing would allow State Parks to receive monetary or other benefits from a discovery or product resulting from scientific investigation in a unit of the state park system. Incorporating benefits sharing into State Parks’ existing framework for scientific investigation enhances the public benefits arising from research in state parks and may result in improved conservation of resources.
National Parks as a model. The NPS Benefits Sharing Program, described above, is a federal program that shares many of the same objectives sought by this bill. Although California State Parks and the NPS operate under different laws and authorities, the NPS Benefits Sharing Program serves as a model that may help to inform benefit sharing in California State Parks.
How will benefits be negotiated? Applicants seeking a commercialization permit will be directed to negotiate benefits-sharing agreements with State Parks’ Partnerships Division. The bill does not outline any particular framework for creating or negotiating agreements. In the federal model, the NPS defines three different types of benefit sharing agreements that form a framework for negotiating agreements. These agreement types vary depending on what entity NPS seeks to partner with (e.g., organizations, educational institutions, etc.), who is to provide and receive benefits, and what NPS contributes to the partnership. However, the NPS is subject to federal laws, including the FTTA, that require such a framework. It is not immediately obvious whether such a framework would be necessary or beneficial for the state in entering benefits sharing agreements.
The NPS model also allows national parks to enter into agreements with other agencies or contract with non-federal entities to provide consultation services as part of agreement negotiations, so long as the NPS has oversight of the negotiations, remains involved in the negotiation, makes all decisions, and is the approving authority for the negotiated agreement. This provides a mechanism for the NPS to receive assistance in benefits-sharing negotiations.
Should this bill pass the Committee, the Committee may wish to direct the author to engage staff in discussing the manner in which benefit-sharing agreements are to be negotiated.
Compelling benefits. SB 442 places constraints on the types of commercial applications that would warrant a commercialization permit. Viable commercial applications would need to be compatible with State Parks’ mission while providing a compelling public benefit to the state. It is not clear what criteria may be used to establish which proposals are the most compelling in this context. Furthermore, while a commercial application may be compatible with State Parks’ mission, a stronger criterion might require the application to advance State Parks’ mission.
The Committee may wish to direct the author to continue working with staff on clarifying application criteria for commercialization.
Qualified institutions of higher education. As written, SB 442 would authorize State Parks to approve permits for “qualified institutions of higher education”. It is unclear what criteria are to be used to establish which higher education institutions are qualified, or what the word “qualified” means in this context. One possible option involves the Carnegie Classification, a framework that classifies colleges and universities. Under this framework, institutions may be classified as:
- Doctoral Universities
- Master’s Colleges and Universities
- Baccalaureate Colleges
- Baccalaureate/Associate’s Colleges
- Associate’s Colleges
- Special Focus Institutions
- Tribal Colleges
In terms of scientific research, doctoral universities tend to have the highest levels of research activity, and are further classified under the Carnegie framework as R1 (Very High Research Activity), R2 (High Research Activity) and R3. However, other institutions – including baccalaureate colleges and associate’s colleges – often seek to engage students in scientific research, and can produce meaningful results. Additional work is needed to clarify what limits, if any, should be placed on institutions of higher education in seeking a scientific research or commercialization permit from State Parks.
If the bill moves forward, the Committee may wish to direct the author to continue working with staff to determine which higher education institutions will be qualified to seek scientific research and commercialization permits from State Parks.
Non-monetary benefits. Non-monetary benefits obtained through a benefits-sharing agreement might include, for example, donation of equipment, training of staff, technology transfer, data collection, or surveying. The NPS example provides some illustrations of the type of non-monetary benefits State Parks might receive through SB 442:
- In 1999, as part of benefits-sharing agreement, a biotechnology company used its expertise in DNA analysis to develop a pedigree for endangered Yellowstone wolves at no charge to the federal government. This pedigree was the first ever established for a wild wolf population, and helped park managers better understand the dynamics and genetic health of Yellowstone’s wolf population.
- In another example involving a benefits-sharing agreement, a biotechnology company donated DNA extraction kits and trained Yellowstone staff to detect the infectious disease Brucellosis in bison.
As these examples show, non-monetary benefits to State Parks are likely to vary and will depend on the specifics of the research and commercial application being considered.
What kinds of research might lead to benefit sharing with State Parks? In principle, any scientific investigation might lead to a commercial application. However, some types of research more easily facilitate this process than others. SB 442 requires that any commercial application be developed without requiring further collection of specimens or disturbance of park resources. Given this constraint and the compelling benefit constraints discussed above, likely types of research for benefit sharing might include biological and biochemical projects that study naturally occurring processes and derive practical applications from them. The study of microorganisms, in particular, is likely to play a role in any benefit-sharing program. Microorganisms are highly adaptable and can live almost anywhere. Furthermore, research involving microorganisms does not typically require large collections of soils or other resources.
Will the potential to commercialize findings spur interest in conducting research in State Parks? Although it is impossible to know for sure, the NPS model provides some insight. According to the NPS, more than 3,000 Scientific Research and Collecting permits are issued by national parks each year. The NPS Benefits Sharing Program has not contributed to any noticeable changes in the number of Scientific Research and Collecting permits issued annually.
Sudden Oak Death. Coastal forests in California and Oregon have been devastated by Sudden Oak Death, an invasive fungus-like plant pathogen. The disease kills some oak species and also infects rhododendrons, camellias, and other common plants. It is estimated to have killed more than one million oak and tanoak trees over the last decade.
Scientific research projects may require CEQA. In California, private activities with the potential to impact the environment are subject to CEQA if they must receive discretionary approval, including permits, from a government agency. To accommodate this law, applicants requesting State Parks’ Scientific Research and Collection permit currently undergo a screening process to determine whether the proposed work requires environmental review. This determination is made at the discretion of State Parks, and depends on the scope and nature of the research that is being proposed. If CEQA review is required, applicants are notified of additional steps required. It is worth pointing out that the majority of proposed scientific investigations do not require review under CEQA.
SUPPORT
University of California (Sponsor)
California Tomato Research Institute
Marrone Bio Innovations
Novozymes
OPPOSITION
None Received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):