SB 45: Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-01-23
The California Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access For All Act of 2018, approved by the voters as Proposition 68 at the June 5, 2018, statewide primary direct election, authorizes the issuance of bonds in an amount of $4,000,000,000 pursuant to the State General Obligation Bond Law to finance a drought, water, parks, climate, coastal protection, and outdoor access for all program.
This bill would enact the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which, if approved by the voters, would authorize the issuance of bonds in an unspecified amount pursuant to the State General Obligation Bond Law to finance projects to restore fire damaged areas, reduce wildfire risk, create healthy forest and watersheds, reduce climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations, protect water supply and water quality, protect rivers, lakes, and streams, reduce flood risk, protect fish and wildlife from climate impacts, improve climate resilience of agricultural lands, and protect coastal lands and resources.
This bill would provide for the submission of these provisions to the voters at the ____, 2020, ____ election.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
This division shall be known, and may be cited, as the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020.
80201.The people of California find and declare all of the following:
(a)Californias changing climate creates increased risk of catastrophic wildfire, drought, severe heat events, sea level rise, as well as impacts to agriculture, water supply and water quality, and the health of the forests, watershed, and wildlife.
(b)These risks and impacts vary by region and can overwhelm the resources of local governments that must cope with severe climate change-related events.
(c)Reducing vulnerability to fire, flood, drought, and other climate-change related events require a statewide investment to increase climate resilience of communities and natural systems.
80202.For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:
(a)Committee means the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Finance Committee created pursuant to Section 80402.
(b)Disadvantaged community means a community with a median household income less than 80 percent of the statewide average.
(c)Fund means the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Fund created pursuant to Section 80210.
80203.An amount that equals not more than 5 percent of the funds allocated for a grant program pursuant to this division may be used to pay the administrative costs of that program.
80204.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), up to 10 percent of funds allocated for each program funded by this division may be expended, including, but not limited to, by grants, for planning and monitoring necessary for the successful design, selection, and implementation of the projects authorized under that program. This section shall not otherwise restrict funds ordinarily used by an agency for preliminary plans, working drawings, and construction as defined in the annual Budget Act for a capital outlay project or grant project. Planning may include feasibility studies for environmental site cleanup that would further the purpose of a project that is eligible for funding under this division. Monitoring may include measuring greenhouse gas emissions reductions and carbon sequestration associated with program expenditures under this division.
(b)Funds used for planning projects that benefit disadvantaged communities may exceed 10 percent of the funds allocated if the state agency administering the moneys determines that there is a need for the additional funding.
80205.To the extent feasible, a project that includes water efficiencies, stormwater capture for infiltration or reuse, or carbon sequestration features in the project design may be given priority for grant funding under this division.
80206.Moneys allocated pursuant to this division shall not be used to fulfill any mitigation requirements imposed by law.
80207.(a)To the extent feasible in implementing this division and except as provided in subdivision (b), a state agency receiving funding under this division shall seek to achieve wildlife conservation objectives through projects on public lands or voluntary projects on private lands. Projects on private lands shall be evaluated based on the durability of the benefits created by the investment. Funds may be used for payments for the protection or creation of measurable habitat improvements or other improvements to the condition of endangered or threatened species, including through the development and implementation of habitat credit exchanges.
(b)This section shall not apply to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 80230), Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 80250), Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 80260), Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 80280), or Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 80300).
80208.Funds provided pursuant to this division, and any appropriation or transfer of those funds, shall not be deemed to be a transfer of funds for the purposes of Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 2780) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code.
80209.For grants awarded for projects that serve a disadvantaged community, the administering entity may provide advanced payments in the amount of 25 percent of the grant award to the recipient to initiate the project in a timely manner. The administering entity shall adopt additional requirements for the recipient of the grant regarding the use of the advanced payments to ensure that the moneys are used properly.
80210.(a)The proceeds of bonds issued and sold pursuant to this division, exclusive of refunding bonds issued and sold pursuant to Section 80412, shall be deposited in the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury.
(b)Proceeds of bonds issued and sold pursuant to this division shall be allocated according to the following schedule:
(1)____ dollars ($____) for restoring fire damaged areas.
(2)____ dollars ($____) for reducing wildfire risk.
(3)____ dollars ($____) for creating healthy forests and watersheds.
(4)____ dollars ($____) for reducing climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations.
(5)____ dollars ($____) for protecting water supply and water quality.
(6)____ dollars ($____) for protecting rivers, lakes, and streams.
(7)____ dollars ($____) for reducing flood risks.
(8)____ dollars ($____) for protecting fish and wildlife and natural resources from climate impacts.
(9)____ dollars ($____) for improving climate resilience of agricultural lands.
(10)____ dollars ($____) for protecting coastal lands and resources.
80211.The Legislature may enact legislation necessary to implement programs funded by this division.
2.Restoring Fire Damaged Areas80220.The sum of ____ dollars ($____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the restoration of wildfire damaged areas. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, grants to public agencies for revegetation and other projects to reduce erosion, flood, and mudslide risk, clean up of hazardous sites, and habitat restoration.
3.Reducing Wildfire Risk80230.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the reduction in the risk of wildfire threat to lives, properties, and natural habitats. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, grants to assist with any of the following:
(a)Structure and community retrofit projects.
(b)Improvement in the alert and evacuation systems.
(c)Establishment of urban-wildland buffers in high fire hazard areas.
(d)Science-based vegetation treatment programs near urban areas.
4.Creating Healthy Forest and Watersheds80240.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the protection and restoration of forests, including redwoods, conifers, oak woodlands, chaparral, deserts, and other habitat types to ensure the long-term ecological health of these natural systems, to reduce risk of extreme wildfires, floods, and other climate impacts, and to improve water supply and water quality, carbon sequestration, community access, and other public benefits.
5.Reducing Climate Risks in Urban Areas and on Vulnerable Populations80250.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the reduction of climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, urban greening, urban forestry projects, and other projects to reduce urban heat island effects, to establish cooling centers, and to safeguard vulnerable populations.
6.Protecting Water Supply and Water Quality80260.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the protection of Californias water supply and water quality. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, the following:
(a)Safe drinking water projects.
(b)Water quality projects.
(c)Sustainable groundwater management projects.
7.Protecting Rivers, Lakes, and Streams80270.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the protection and restoration of rivers, lakes, and streams. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, the following:
(a)River parkway projects.
(b)Projects to implement the Lake Tahoe Environmental Improvement Program.
(c)Projects to restore the Salton Sea authorized pursuant to Public Law 105-372, the Salton Sea Reclamation Act of 1998.
(d)Projects for the acquisition or restoration of public lands within the Los Angeles River Watershed.
8.Reducing Flood Risk80280.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the reduction of flood risks, including the establishment of flood corridors, bypasses, and associated infrastructure.
9.Protecting Fish and Wildlife From Climate Impacts80290.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the protection of Californias fish and wildlife resources. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, the following:
(a)Salmon and other fishery restoration projects.
(b)Projects to protect wetlands and wildfire refuges for migratory birds.
(c)Establishment, protection, and restoration of wildlife corridors and habitat linkages.
(d)Conservation actions on private lands.
10.Improving Climate Resilience of Agricultural Lands80300.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the improvement in climate resilience of agricultural lands. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, the following:
(a)Grants to promote practices on farms and ranches that improve agricultural and open space soil health, carbon sequestration, and erosion control, water quality and water retention.
(b)California Farmland Conservancy Program established pursuant to Division 10.2 (commencing with Section 10200) of the Public Resources Code.
11.Protecting Coastal Lands and Resources80310.The sum of ____ dollars ($_____) shall be available for appropriation by the Legislature for the protection of coastal lands, waters and natural resources, and wildlife from climate impacts. Eligible projects include, but are not limited to, projects to restore coastal wetlands and projects to address sea level rise and temperature increase.
12.Fiscal Provisions80400.(a)Bonds in the total amount of ____ dollars ($____), and any additional bonds authorized, issued, and appropriated in accordance with this division pursuant to other provisions of law, not including the amount of any refunding bonds issued in accordance with Section 80412, may be issued and sold to provide a fund to be used for carrying out the purposes expressed in this division and to reimburse the General Obligation Bond Expense Revolving Fund pursuant to Section 16724.5 of the Government Code. The bonds, when sold, issued, and delivered, shall be and constitute a valid and binding obligation of the State of California, and the full faith and credit of the State of California is hereby pledged for the punctual payment of both the principal of, and interest on, the bonds as the principal and interest become due and payable.
(b)The Treasurer shall sell the bonds authorized by the committee pursuant to this section. The bonds shall be sold upon the terms and conditions specified in a resolution to be adopted by the committee pursuant to Section 16731 of the Government Code.
80401.The bonds authorized by this division shall be prepared, executed, issued, sold, paid, and redeemed as provided in the State General Obligation Bond Law (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 16720) of Part 3 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code), as amended from time to time, and all of the provisions of that law apply to the bonds and to this division.
80402.(a)Solely for the purpose of authorizing the issuance and sale, pursuant to the State General Obligation Bond Law (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 16720) of Part 3 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code), of the bonds authorized by this division, the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Finance Committee is hereby created. For purposes of this division, the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Finance Committee is the committee as that term is used in the State General Obligation Bond Law.
(b)The committee consists of the Director of Finance, the Treasurer, and the Controller. Notwithstanding any other law, any member may designate a representative to act as that member in his or her place for all purposes, as though the member were personally present.
(c)The Treasurer shall serve as the chairperson of the committee.
(d)A majority of the committee may act for the committee.
80403.The committee shall determine whether or not it is necessary or desirable to issue bonds authorized by this division in order to carry out the actions specified in this division and, if so, the amount of bonds to be issued and sold. Successive issues of bonds may be authorized and sold to carry out those actions progressively, and it is not necessary that all of the bonds authorized to be issued be sold at any one time.
80404.For purposes of the State General Obligation Bond Law, board, as defined in Section 16722 of the Government Code, means the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency.
80405.There shall be collected each year and in the same manner and at the same time as other state revenue is collected, in addition to the ordinary revenues of the state, a sum in an amount required to pay the principal of, and interest on, the bonds each year. It is the duty of all officers charged by law with any duty in regard to the collection of the revenue to do and perform each and every act that is necessary to collect that additional sum.
80406.Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, there is hereby appropriated from the General Fund in the State Treasury, for the purposes of this division, an amount that will equal the total of the following:
(a)The sum annually necessary to pay the principal of, and interest on, bonds issued and sold pursuant to this division, as the principal and interest become due and payable.
(b)The sum that is necessary to carry out the provisions of Section 80409, appropriated without regard to fiscal years.
80407.The board may request the Pooled Money Investment Board to make a loan from the Pooled Money Investment Account, including other authorized forms of interim financing that include, but are not limited to, commercial paper, in accordance with Section 16312 of the Government Code for the purpose of carrying out this division. The amount of the request shall not exceed the amount of the unsold bonds that the committee has, by resolution, authorized to be sold for the purpose of carrying out this division, excluding refunding bonds authorized pursuant to Section 80412, less any amount loaned and not yet repaid pursuant to this section and withdrawn from the General Fund pursuant to Section 80409 and not yet returned to the General Fund. The board shall execute those documents required by the Pooled Money Investment Board to obtain and repay the loan. Any amounts loaned shall be deposited in the fund to be allocated in accordance with this division.
80408.Notwithstanding any other provision of this division, or of the State General Obligation Bond Law, if the Treasurer sells bonds that include a bond counsel opinion to the effect that the interest on the bonds is excluded from gross income for federal tax purposes under designated conditions or is otherwise entitled to any federal tax advantage, the Treasurer may maintain separate accounts for the bond proceeds invested and for the investment earnings on those proceeds, and may use or direct the use of those proceeds or earnings to pay any rebate, penalty, or other payment required under federal law or take any other action with respect to the investment and use of those bond proceeds, as may be required or desirable under federal law in order to maintain the tax-exempt status of those bonds and to obtain any other advantage under federal law on behalf of the funds of this state.
80409.For the purposes of carrying out this division, the Director of Finance may authorize the withdrawal from the General Fund of an amount or amounts not to exceed the amount of the unsold bonds that have been authorized by the committee to be sold for the purpose of carrying out this division, excluding refunding bonds authorized pursuant to Section 80412, less any amount loaned pursuant to Section 80407 and not yet repaid and any amount withdrawn from the General Fund pursuant to this section and not yet returned to the General Fund. Any amounts withdrawn shall be deposited in the fund to be allocated in accordance with this division. Any moneys made available under this section shall be returned to the General Fund, with interest at the rate earned by the moneys in the Pooled Money Investment Account, from proceeds received from the sale of bonds for the purpose of carrying out this division.
80410.All moneys deposited in the fund that are derived from premium and accrued interest on bonds sold pursuant to this division shall be reserved in the fund and shall be available for transfer to the General Fund as a credit to expenditures for bond interest, except that amounts derived from premiums may be reserved and used to pay the cost of bond issuance before any transfer to the General Fund.
80411.Pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 16720) of Part 3 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the cost of bond issuance shall be paid or reimbursed out of the bond proceeds, including premiums, if any. To the extent the cost of bond issuance is not paid from premiums received from the sale of bonds, these costs shall be allocated proportionally to each program funded through this division by the applicable bond sale.
80412.The bonds issued and sold pursuant to this division may be refunded in accordance with Article 6 (commencing with Section 16780) of Chapter 4 of Part 3 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code, which is a part of the State General Obligation Bond Law. Approval by the voters of the state for the issuance of the bonds under this division shall include approval of the issuance of any bonds issued to refund any bonds originally issued under this division or any previously issued refunding bonds. Any bond refunded with the proceeds of a refunding bond as authorized by this section may be legally defeased to the extent permitted by law in the manner and to the extent set forth in the resolution, as amended from time to time, authorizing that refunded bond.
80413.The proceeds from the sale of bonds authorized by this division are not proceeds of taxes as that term is used in Article XIIIB of the California Constitution, and the disbursement of these proceeds is not subject to the limitations imposed by that article.
SEC. 2.Section 1 of this act shall take effect upon the approval by the voters of the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020.
SEC. 3.Section 1 of this act shall be submitted to the voters at the ____, 2020, statewide ____ election in accordance with provisions of the Government Code and the Elections Code governing the submission of a statewide measure to the voters.
SEC. 4.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to fund wildfire, drought, and flood protection programs at the earliest possible date, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 30, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 29, 2020 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 29. Noes 6. Page 3167.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 3141.) (January 23). |
| Jan 21, 2020 | Set for hearing January 23. |
| Jan 21, 2020 | January 21 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jan 14, 2020 | Set for hearing January 21. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Senate Rule 29.3(b) suspended. (Ayes 29. Noes 8.) |
| Sep 5, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2019 | May 6 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (April 3). |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on EQ. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (March 26). Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Mar 13, 2019 | Set for hearing March 26. |
| Mar 5, 2019 | March 12 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 5, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | Set for hearing March 12. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on N.R. & W., EQ., and GOV. & F. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 29, 2020 | Senate 3rd Reading SB45 Allen et al. Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 45 (Allen) - Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 45 would enact the Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which authorizes the sale of $5.51 billion in general obligation bonds, upon approval by voters at the November 3, 2020 statewide general election. Bond funds would be used for projects related to wildfire prevention, safe drinking water, drought preparation, and flood protection.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on January 23, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
- Bond costs: Total principal and interest costs of approximately $8.99 billion to pay off the bonds ($5.51 billion in principal and $3.48 billion in interest), with average annual debt service payments of $300 million (General Fund), when all bonds are sold, and assuming a 30-year maturity and an interest rate of 3.5% (the rate secured by the Treasurer for new 30-year bonds at the most recent sale). If interest rates increase to 5% in the near future, annual debt service would be approximately $358 million (General Fund) and total principal and interest costs over the repayment period would be approximately $10.75 billion.
- Administrative costs: The bill would allow for up to 5 percent of the bond allocation to any entity to be used for administrative costs, except when necessary in specified situations related to disadvantaged communities, where up to 10 percent could be used. Over the lifetime of the bond and contingent upon future appropriations in the budget, roughly $250 million of the bond funds could be used for administration.
- Ballot costs: One-time costs in the range of $414,000 to $552,000 to the Secretary of State (SOS) for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in the November 2020 statewide election. (General Fund).
Author Amendments:
If approved, the amended measure would direct bond proceeds in the following ways:
- $2.2 billion for wildfire prevention and community resilience from climate impacts:
- $175 million for OES, in conjunction with CalFire, for a prehazard mitigation grant program.
- $280 million for CNRA and its departments, boards, and conservancies for projects to reduce the risk of wildfire spreading into populated areas from wildlands and to improve forest health and fire resiliency.
- $75 million for CalFire to enhance California’s fire prevention, fuel management, and fire response.
- $300 million for CNRA for implementation of the Regional Fire and Forest Capacity Program to find coordinated and integrated regional approaches to the restoration of watersheds, reduction in the conditions that lead to catastrophic wildfire, and the protection of natural resources throughout California.
- $225 million to CNRA and its departments, boards, and conservancies for the restoration and improvement of forest health.
- $50 million for CDPR to plan for and implement projects to reduce the risks of fire, flood, inundation, sea level rise, and other risks associated with climate change.
- $460 million for various conservancies for climate resilience, wildfire prevention, and natural resource protection.
- $395 million for improving climate resilience of urban areas and vulnerable populations.
- $240 million for the Strategic Growth Council for regional climate planning and implementation.
- $1.47 billion for the protection of California’s water supply and water quality:
- $190 million for grants to provide safe drinking water.
- $200 million for the Wildlife Conservation Board for groundwater sustainability projects that provide wildlife habitat and support implementation of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
- $130 million for the Department of Water Resources for implementation of SGMA.
- $250 million for the protection and restoration of rivers, lakes, and streams.
- $240 million for urban streams and river parkways.
- $140 million for flood management projects.
- $100 million for recycled water projects.
- $90 million for water data collection and monitoring.
- $100 million for CNRA for implementation of the settlement agreement to restore the San Joaquin River.
- $30 million for water infrastructure upgrades.
- $620 million for protecting fish and wildlife from climate risks:
- $600 million for the WCB for the protection of California’s fish and wildlife resources in response to changing climate conditions.
- $20 million for DFW to improve climate resilience of fish and wildlife habitat.
- $190 million for protecting agricultural land from climate risks:
- $100 million for CDFA to improve climate resilience on agricultural lands and ecosystem health.
- $90 million for DOC for protection and restoration of farmlands and rangelands.
- $970 million for protecting coastal lands, oceans, bays, waters, natural resources, and wildlife from climate risks:
- $100 million for SCC for wetland restoration projects consistent with the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority Act.
- $700 million for SCC to improve coastal resiliency.
- $50 million to the Ocean Protection Trust Fund for climate resiliency.
- $10 million for DFW to implement climate-ready fisheries management approaches.
- $10 million for DFW to support the management of kelp ecosystems.
- $100 million for SCC for grants to remove or upgrade outdate or obsolete dams and water infrastructure.
- $60 million for climate resilience, workforce development, and education:
- $30 million to the CCC for climate resilience and natural disaster prevention projects and programs that promote workforce development.
- $5 million to California Community Colleges for workforce development programs for prescribed fire treatments, forest and woodland restoration, fire hardening, defensible space management, and approved community defense techniques.
- $15 million for the University of California for a Fire Outreach and Extension Program.
- $10 million for the California State Universities for fire education purposes.
-- END --
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 45 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 45
Author: Allen (D), Portantino (D) and Stern (D), et al.
Amended: 1/23/20
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 7-1, 3/26/19
AYES: Stern, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 4/3/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/24/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach, Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 1/23/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SUBJECT: Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
DIGEST:
This bill proposes the Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, subject to voter approval in the November 3, 2020, statewide general election. This bill proposes the issuance of $5.51 billion in general obligation bonds to implement its provisions.
Existing law:
- Authorizes, pursuant to Section One of Article XVI of the California Constitution and the State General Obligation Bond Law, the issuance of general obligation bonds.
- Authorizes, further, the Legislature to place general obligation bonds on the ballot for specific purposes with a two-thirds vote of the Assembly and Senate.
This bill:
- Enacts the Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which, if approved by the voters, would authorize the issuance of bonds in the amount of $5.51 billion pursuant to the State General Obligation Bond Law to finance projects for a wildfire prevention, safe drinking water, drought preparation, and flood protection program.
- Submits these provisions to the voters at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election.
- Allocates the funds authorized by this bill as follows:
- $2.2 billion for wildfire prevention and community resilience from climate impacts, as follows:
- $175 million to Office of Emergency Services, in conjunction with CalFire, for a prehazard mitigation grant program.
- $280 million to California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) and its departments, boards, and conservancies for projects to reduce the risk of wildfire spreading into populated areas from wildlands and to improve forest health and fire resiliency.
- $75 million for the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection to enhance California’s fire prevention, fuel management, and fire response.
- $300 million to CNRA for implementation of the Regional Fire and Forest Capacity Program to find coordinated and integrated regional approaches to the restoration of watersheds, reduction in the conditions that lead to catastrophic wildfire, and the protection of natural resources throughout California.
- $225 million to CNRA and its departments, boards, and conservancies for the restoration and improvement of forest health.
- $50 million for California Department of Parks and Recreation (CDPR) to plan for and implement projects to reduce the risks of fire, flood, inundation, sea level rise, and other risks associated with climate change.
- $460 million to various conservancies for climate resilience, wildfire prevention, and natural resource protection.
- $395 million for improving climate resilience of urban areas and vulnerable populations.
- $240 million for the Strategic Growth Council for regional climate planning and implementation.
- $1.47 billion for the protection of California’s water supply and water quality, as follows:
- $190 million for grants to provide safe drinking water.
- $200 million to the Wildlife Conservation Board (WCB) for groundwater sustainability projects that provide wildlife habitat and support implementation of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
- $130 million to the Department of Water Resources for implementation of SGMA.
- $250 million for the protection and restoration of rivers, lakes, and streams.
- $240 million for urban streams and river parkways.
- $140 million for flood management projects.
- $100 million for recycled water projects.
- $90 million for water data collection and monitoring.
- $100 million to CNRA for implementation of the settlement agreement to restore the San Joaquin River.
- $30 million for water infrastructure upgrades.
- $620 million for protecting fish and wildlife from climate risks, as follows:
- $600 million to the WCB for the protection of California’s fish and wildlife resources in response to changing climate conditions.
- $20 million for Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) to improve climate resilience of fish and wildlife habitat.
- $190 million for protecting agricultural land from climate risks, as follows:
- $100 million for California Department of Food and Agriculture to improve climate resilience on agricultural lands and ecosystem health.
- $90 million to Department of Conservation for protection and restoration of farmlands and rangelands.
- $970 million for protecting coastal lands, oceans, bays, waters, natural resources, and wildlife from climate risks, as follows:
- $100 million to the State Coastal Conservancy (SCC) for wetland restoration projects consistent with the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority Act.
- $700 million for SCC to improve coastal resiliency.
- $50 million to the Ocean Protection Trust Fund for climate resiliency.
- $10 million for DFW to implement climate-ready fisheries management approaches.
- $10 million for DFW to support the management of kelp ecosystems.
- $100 million to SCC for grants to remove or upgrade outdated or obsolete dams and water infrastructure.
- $60 million for climate resilience, workforce development, and education, as follows:
- $30 million to the California Community Colleges (CCC) for climate resilience and natural disaster prevention projects and programs that promote workforce development.
- $5 million to CCC for workforce development programs for prescribed fire treatments, forest and woodland restoration, fire hardening, defensible space management, and approved community defense techniques.
- $15 million to the University of California for a Fire Outreach and Extension Program.
- $10 million to the California State Universities for fire education purposes.
- $2.2 billion for wildfire prevention and community resilience from climate impacts, as follows:
- Makes a number of findings regarding climate change and the need to invest in projects and programs to help make the state more resilient to changes in climate.
- Requires, to the extent practicable, when disbursing funds available pursuant to this bill, an administering state agency shall prioritize projects that do any of the following:
- Reduce near-term risks of climate impacts while promoting long-term resilience.
- Promote equity, foster community resilience, and protect the most vulnerable by prioritizing projects that meaningfully benefit disadvantaged communities and vulnerable populations.
- Incorporate natural and green infrastructure solutions that enhance and protect natural resources, rural environments, and urban environments, including those that preserve or restore ecological or engineered systems in ways that support natural system functions, services, and quality, and that reduce risk.
- Avoid solutions that would likely worsen climate impacts or transfer risks unreasonably from one area, location, or social group, to another.
- Advance solutions to prevent displacement of low-income residents that could occur as an unintended consequence of a project that causes an increase in the cost of owning or renting property.
- Defines a number of terms, including:
- “Natural infrastructure” means using natural ecological systems or processes to reduce vulnerability to climate change-related hazards or other related climate change effects while increasing the long-term adaptive capacity of coastal and inland areas by perpetuating or restoring ecosystem services. This includes, but is not limited to, the conservation, preservation, or sustainable management of any form of aquatic or terrestrial vegetated open space, such as beaches, dunes, tidal marshes, reefs, seagrass, flood plains, parks, rain gardens, and urban tree canopies to mitigate high heat days. It also includes systems and practices that use or mimic natural processes, such as permeable pavements, bioswales, and other engineered systems, such as levees, that are combined with restored natural systems to provide clean water, conserve ecosystem values and functions, and provide a wide array of benefits to people and wildlife.
- “Resilience” means the ability of an entity or system, including an individual, a community, or a natural system, and its component parts to absorb, accommodate, or recover from the effects of a hazardous event in a timely and efficient manner, including through ensuring the preservation, restoration, or improvement of its essential basic structures and functions. In the case of natural and working lands, resilience includes the preservation, restoration, or enhancement of the ability to sequester carbon.
- “Vulnerable population” means a subgroup of population within a region or community that faces a disproportionately heightened risk or increased sensitivity to impacts of climate change and that lacks adequate resources to cope with, adapt to, or recover from such impacts.
Comments
Governor’s Proposal. The proposed 2020-21 Budget includes a proposed $4.75 billion Climate Resilience Bond to be placed on the November 2020 ballot. The specific language of the Governor’s proposal has not been released. The proposed funding categories include:
- $2.925 billion for drinking water, flood, and drought;
- $750 million for wildfire;
- $500 million for sea level rise;
- $325 million for extreme heat; and
- $250 million for community resilience.
Assembly Proposal. Members of the Assembly are reportedly working on their own bond proposal. It is not clear when their proposal will be made public, how much funding it will authorize, nor the specific projects and programs it would fund.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Bond costs: Total principal and interest costs of approximately $8.99 billion to pay off the bonds ($5.51 billion in principal and $3.48 billion in interest), with average annual debt service payments of $300 million (General Fund), when all bonds are sold, and assuming a 30-year maturity and an interest rate of 3.5% (the rate secured by the Treasurer for new 30-year bonds at the most recent sale). If interest rates increase to 5% in the near future, annual debt service would be approximately $358 million (General Fund) and total principal and interest costs over the repayment period would be approximately $10.75 billion.
- Administrative costs: The bill would allow for up to five percent of the bond allocation to any entity to be used for administrative costs, except when necessary in specified situations related to disadvantaged communities, where up to 10 percent could be used. Over the lifetime of the bond and contingent upon future appropriations in the budget, roughly $250 million of the bond funds could be used for administration.
- Ballot costs: One-time costs in the range of $414,000 to $552,000 to the Secretary of State for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in the November 2020 statewide election. (General Fund).
Agriculture & Land-Based Training Association
Allstate
American Rivers
Arroyos & Foothills Conservancy
Bear Yuba Land Trust
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Association of Recreation & Park Districts
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Council of Land Trusts
California Farmer Justice Collaborative
California Food & Farming Network
California Habitat Conservation Planning Coalition
California Invasive Plant Council
California Outdoor Recreation Partnership
California Park & Recreation Society
California State Parks Foundation
California Trout
California Waterfowl Association
Citizens for Los Angeles Wildlife
City of Santa Monica
Clean Water Action
Climate Resolve
Climateplan
Committee on Clean Water, Natural Resources, & Parks
Community Nature Connection
County of Santa Clara
Defenders of Wildlife
Ducks Unlimited
East Bay Regional Park District
Eastern Sierra Land Trust
Endangered Habitats League
Environment California
Escondido Creek Conservancy
Friends of Harbors, Beaches & Parks
Friends of Joshua Tree
Friends of the LA River
Hills for Everyone
John Muir Land Trust
Laguna Greenbelt, Inc.
Local Government Commission
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Madrone Audubon Society
Mammoth Lakes Trails & Public Access Foundation
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mountains Recreation & Conservation Authority
Ocean Conservancy
Outdoor Afro
Outdoor Industry Association
Pacific Forest Trust
Paula Lane Action Network, Sonoma County
Peninsula Open Space Trust
Pesticide Action Network North America
Placer Land Trust
Planning & Conservation League
Rails to Trails Conservancy
Santa Clara County Open Space Authority
Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority
Santa Cruz County Flood Control & Water Conservation District
Save The Bay
Save the Redwoods League
Sempervirens Fund
Sierra Business Council
Sierra Foothill Conservancy
Sierra Nevada Alliance
Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation & Open Space District
Sonoma County Regional Parks
Sonoma County Water Agency
Surfrider Foundation
Sustainable Conservation
Tahoe City Public Utility District
Tahoe Mountain Sports
The Nature Conservancy
The Trust for Public Land
The Wilderness Society
Truckee Donner Land Trust
Watershed Conservation Authority
Westfield State University
Wildlands Conservancy
Wildlife Corridor Working Group
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/23/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, SB 45 will provide the necessary investment to help our state become more resilient to climate change. If passed by the voters, this bond will provide funding for concrete on-the-ground measures that will help reduce the severity, frequency, and impacts of climate-related natural disasters including fires, drought, flood and mudslides. According to California’s Fourth Climate Assessment, the cost of climate change for California alone could be more than $113 billion annually by 2050.
The wildfire season is becoming longer and more intense each year due to hotter temperatures and wide scale tree death resulting from prolonged drought. In fact, between 2010-2017 an estimated 129 million trees died, leaving behind massive amounts of highly combustible fuel. This phenomenon has led to the worst fires on record. Over the 13 months starting in October of 2017 the state endured four massive fires that caused 118 deaths, burned 700,000 acres, and destroyed 27,000 properties. In California, frequent coastal flooding exacerbated by sea-level rise is expected to threaten nearly half a million people, $100 billion in property, and 3,500 miles of roads within the next 80 years. The number of hazardous sites, like wastewater plants, which are susceptible to 100-year flood events is expected to increase by nearly 2.5 times over a similar period, drastically increasing the risk of pollutant disasters if adaptation measures are not taken. Droughts are an expected feature of California’s arid climate, but the four-year period between fall 2011 and fall 2015, which correlated with the hottest two years on record in 2014 and 2015, was the driest since record keeping began in 1895. The winter of 2017 provided only a brief respite before historic rainfall lows again in the winter of 2018.
SB 45 proposes a general obligation bond to inject much needed revenue to address these impacts. The measure proposes to fund projects to reduce fire risk and restore already damaged areas; restore and protect impacted wetlands, watersheds, waterways, coastal resources, and fish and wildlife populations; reduce impacts in local communities and on vulnerable populations; and improve the resiliency of the state’s water supplies and agricultural lands.
Prepared by: Dennis O'Connor / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
1/28/20 15:07:48
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 45 (Allen) - Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
Version: September 10, 2019 | Policy Vote: N.R. & W. 7 - 1, E.Q. 5 - 1, GOV. & F. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: January 21, 2020 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
SB 45 would enact the Wildfire Prevention, Safe Drinking Water, Drought Preparation, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which authorizes the sale of $4.189 billion in general obligation bonds, upon approval by voters at the March 3, 2020 statewide general election. Bond funds would be used for projects related to wildfire prevention, safe drinking water, drought preparation, and flood protection.
Fiscal Impact:
- Bond costs: Total principal and interest costs of approximately $6.833 billion to pay off the bonds ($4.189 billion in principal and $2.644 billion in interest), with average annual debt service payments of $228 million (General Fund), when all bonds are sold, and assuming a 30-year maturity and an interest rate of 3.5% (the rate secured by the Treasurer for new 30-year bonds at the most recent sale). If interest rates increase to 5% in the near future, annual debt service would be approximately $273 million (General Fund) and total principal and interest costs over the repayment period would be approximately $8.175 billion.
- Administrative costs: The bill would allow for up to 5 percent of the bond allocation to any entity to be used for administrative costs, except when necessary in specified situations related to disadvantaged communities, where up to 10 percent could be used. Over the lifetime of the bond and contingent upon future appropriations in the budget, roughly $200 million of the bond funds could be used for administration.
- Ballot costs: One-time costs in the range of $414,000 to $552,000 to the Secretary of State (SOS) for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in the March 2020 statewide election. (General Fund).
Background:
$31 Billion in General Obligation Bonds Approved in Prior Two Decades for Environmental Purposes. Since 2000, voters have approved about $31 billion in general obligation bonds in statewide elections to pay for different types of natural resources and environmental protection-related projects. The two most recent such bonds were (1) Proposition 1 in 2014, which provided $7.5 billion primarily for water supply infrastructure, water quality improvements, and habitat restoration activities; and (2) Proposition 68 in 2018, which provided $4.1 billion primarily for state and local parks and habitat conservation and restoration activities.
Most Bond Funding Has Been Committed or Appropriated for Projects. Almost 90 percent of Proposition 1 funding has been appropriated, with most of that committed to specific projects.
Proposed Law:
SB 45 would enact the Wildlife, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which places a $4.2 billion bond before voters in the March 2020 election. If approved, the measure would direct bond proceeds in the following ways:
- $1.619 billion for wildfire prevention and community resilience from climate impacts:
- $175 million for OES, in conjunction with CalFire, for a prehazard mitigation grant program.
- $195 million for CNRA and its departments, boards, and conservancies for projects to reduce the risk of wildfire spreading into populated areas from wildlands and to improve forest health and fire resiliency.
- $75 million for CalFire to enhance California’s fire prevention, fuel management, and fire response.
- $250 million for CNRA for implementation of the Regional Fire and Forest Capacity Program to find coordinated and integrated regional approaches to the restoration of watersheds, reduction in the conditions that lead to catastrophic wildfire, and the protection of natural resources throughout California.
- $225 million to CNRA and its departments, boards, and conservancies for the restoration and improvement of forest health.
- $50 million for CDPR to plan for and implement projects to reduce the risks of fire, flood, inundation, sea level rise, and other risks associated with climate change.
- $129 million for various conservancies for climate resilience, wildfire prevention, and natural resource protection.
- $395 million for improving climate resilience of urban areas and vulnerable populations.
- $125 million for the Strategic Growth Council for regional climate planning and implementation.
- $1.17 billion for the protection of California’s water supply and water quality:
- $190 million for grants to provide safe drinking water.
- $190 million for the Wildlife Conservation Board for groundwater sustainability projects that provide wildlife habitat and support implementation of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act.
- $410 million for the protection and restoration of rivers, lakes, and streams.
- $140 million for flood management projects.
- $100 million for the SWRCB for recycled water projects.
- $10 million for water data collection and monitoring.
- $100 million for CNRA for implementation of the settlement agreement to restore the San Joaquin River.
- $30 million for water infrastructure upgrades.
- $520 million for protecting fish and wildlife from climate risks:
- $500 million for the WCB for the protection of California’s fish and wildlife resources in response to changing climate conditions.
- $20 million for DFW to improve climate resilience of fish and wildlife habitat.
- $190 million for protecting agricultural land from climate risks:
- $100 million for CDFA to improve climate resilience on agricultural lands and ecosystem health.
- $90 million for DOC for protection and restoration of farmlands and rangelands.
- $630 million for protecting coastal lands, oceans, bays, waters, natural resources, and wildlife from climate risks:
- $100 million for SCC for wetland restoration projects consistent with the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority Act.
- 360 million for SCC to improve coastal resiliency.
- $50 million to the Ocean Protection Trust Fund for climate resiliency.
- $10 million for DFW to implement climate-ready fisheries management approaches.
- $10 million for DFW to support the management of kelp ecosystems.
- $100 million for SCC for grants to remove or upgrade outdate or obsolete dams and water infrastructure.
- $60 million for climate resilience, workforce development, and education:
- $30 million to the CCC for climate resilience and natural disaster prevention projects and programs that promote workforce development.
- $5 million to California Community Colleges for workforce development programs for prescribed fire treatments, forest and woodland restoration, fire hardening, defensible space management, and approved community defense techniques.
- $15 million for the University of California for a Fire Outreach and Extension Program.
- $10 million for the California State Universities for fire education purposes.
SB 45 would cap administrative costs of any grant program it authorizes at not more than 5 percent of funds allocated, and would allow 10 percent of funds to be used for planning and monitoring necessary for projects to be successfully implemented. However, there is an exception—grant programs for disadvantaged communities or socially disadvantaged farmers or ranchers can exceed the 10 percent cap if the state agency administering the grant approves.
SB 45 would require that at least 35 percent of the funds available be allocated for projects serving disadvantaged communities, vulnerable populations, or economically distressed areas. At least 15 percent of funds must be allocated for projects serving severely disadvantaged communities.
Staff Comments:
Governor’s Proposed 2020-21 Budget Includes $4.75 Billion Climate Resilience Bond. The Administration is proposing a bond for the November 2020 ballot and has indicated that, if approved, it intends to expend the funds over the next five years to reduce climate risks. Specifically, the Governor’s proposal includes:
- $2.925 billion for drinking water, flood, and drought;
- $750 million for wildfire;
- $500 million for sea level rise;
- $325 million for extreme heat; and
- $250 million for community resilience.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 45 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/19 |
Author: | Allen | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 4/4/19 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
Enacts the Wildlife, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which places a $4.3 billion bond before voters at an unspecified election.
Background
When public agencies issue bonds, they borrow money from investors, who provide cash in exchange for the agencies’ commitment to repay the principal amount of the bond plus interest. Bonds are usually either revenue bonds, which repay investors out of revenue generated from the project the agency buys with bond proceeds, or general obligation bonds, which the public agency pays out of general revenues and are guaranteed by its full faith and credit.
Section One of Article XVI of the California Constitution and the state’s General Obligation Bond Law guide the issuance of the state’s general obligation debt. The Constitution allows the Legislature to place general obligation bonds on the ballot for specific purposes with a two-thirds vote of the Assembly and Senate. Voters also can place bonds on the ballot by initiative, as they have for parks, water projects, high-speed rail, and stem cell research, among others. Either way, general obligation bonds must be ratified by majority vote of the state’s electorate. Unlike local general obligation bonds, approval by the state’s electorate does not automatically trigger an increased tax to repay the bond. The Constitution commits the state to repay investors from general revenues above all other claims, except payments to public education. California voters approved $38.4 billion of general obligation bonds between 1974 and 1999, which increased significantly to $112 billion between 2000 and 2010. Last year, voters approved the $4 billion California Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access for All Act of 2018 (SB 5, De Leon, 2017), the $3 billion Veterans and Affordable Housing Bond Act (SB 3, Beall, 2017), and the $1.5 billion Children’s Hospital Bond Act of 2018 (Proposition 4). However, voters defeated Proposition 3, the California Water Infrastructure and Watershed Conservation Bond Initiative, which would have authorized $8.87 billion in bonds for water infrastructure, groundwater supplies and storage, surface water storage and dam repairs, watershed and fisheries improvements, and habitat protection and restoration.
Bond acts have standard provisions that authorize the State Treasurer to sell a specified amount of bonds, and generally include several uniform provisions that:
- Establish the state’s obligation to repay them, and pledge its full faith and credit to repayment,
- Set forth issuance procedures, and link the bond act to the state’s General Obligation Bond Law,
- Create a finance committee with specified membership, chaired by the State Treasurer,
- Charge the committee with determining whether it is “necessary or desirable” to issue the bonds, and
- Add other mechanisms necessary for the State Treasurer and the Department of Finance to implement the bond act, including allowing the board to request a loan from the Pooled Money Investment Board to advance funds for bond-funded programs prior to the bond sale, among others.
In bond acts, the Legislature generally:
- Sets forth categories of projects eligible for bond funds, such as library construction or school facility modernization,
- Chooses an administrative agency to award the funds, such as the State Librarian or the State Allocation Board,
- Details the criteria to guide the administrative agency’s funding in each category,
- Enacts enforcement and audit provisions, and
- Provides for an election to approve the bond act.
Should the voters approve the bond act, the Legislature then appropriates funds to the chosen agencies to fund projects consistent with the criteria, generally as part of the Budget Act. The Department of Finance (DOF) then surveys agencies to determine the need for bond funds based on a project’s readiness, and then asks the State Treasurer to sell bonds in a specified amount. After the bond sale, DOF determines which bond acts and agencies receive bond proceeds.
In recent years, the Legislature has enacted, and voters approved, several bonds for parks and natural resources purposes:
- Safe Neighborhood Parks, Clean Water, Clean Air, and Coastal Protection Act of 2000, which authorized $2.1 billion in bonds, approved by voters as Proposition 12 (AB 18, Villaraigosa), and
- California Clean Water, Clean Air, Safe Neighborhood Parks, and Coastal Protection Act of 2002, which authorized $2.6 billion in bonds, approved by voters as Proposition 40 (AB 1602, Keeley),
In addition, voters approved an initiative measure:
- The Safe Drinking Water, Water Quality and Supply, Flood Control, River and Coastal Protection Bond Act of 2006, which authorized $5.4 billion in bonds (Proposition 84).
According to the State Treasurer, almost all of the Proposition 12 and 40 bonds have been sold; around $210,000 hasn’t yet been issued. However, $1.34 billion from Proposition 84 has not yet been issued. Voters also enacted Proposition 1E of 2006, which authorized the sale of $4.09 billion in general obligation bonds for flood control, of which $1.21remains unissued (AB 140, Nunez, 2006). Additionally, the Legislature enacted, and voters approved, Proposition 1, which authorized $7.1 billion in new bonds for water quality and supply infrastructure (AB 1471, Rendon, 2014), and the $4 billion California Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access for All Act of 2018, as mentioned above (SB 5, De Leon, 2017).
Seeking additional funds to invest in climate change mitigation and resiliency, the author wants to propose to voters a general obligation bond that funds various projects to reduce the severity, frequency, and impacts of climate-related events.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 45 enacts the Wildlife, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020, which places a $4.3 billion bond before voters at an unspecified election. If approved, the measure directs proceeds of bonds issued and sold to be deposited in the Wildlife, Drought, and Flood Protection Fund, which the bill creates in the State Treasury. SB 45 sets forth defined allocations for the proceeds of bonds, including:
- $200 million to the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to restore areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters.
- $1 billion to reduce wildfire risk, including:
- An unspecified amount to OES for a prehazard mitigation grant program allocated to assist the state and local agencies leverage additional funds.
- An unspecified amount to the Natural Resources Agency, and to its departments, boards, and commissions, for projects to reduce the risk of wildfire spreading into populated areas from wildlands, and to support the development and implementation of the Regional Fire and Forest Capacity Program. The Agency must identify the highest risk areas, and make regional allocation recommendations to the Legislature based on wildfire risk and affected population. Grants for fire risk reduction must be secured with management plans, conservation easements, or other agreements that ensure project benefits persist longer than the debt incurred by the measure. Preference is awarded to projects that maintain permanent benefits.
- $600 million to the Natural Resources Agency and its departments, boards, and commissions to create healthy forests and watersheds. Projects must be based on the best science available, and undertaken to protect and restore ecological values and promote conditions more resilient to wildfire, climate change, and other disturbances. Grants for fire risk reduction must be secured with management plans, conservation easements, or other agreements that ensure project benefits persist longer than the debt incurred by the measure. Preference is awarded to projects that maintain permanent benefits.
- $300 million for appropriation by the Legislature to reduce climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations.
- $600 million for appropriation by the Legislature to protect water supply and water quality.
- $300 million for appropriation by the Legislature to protect rivers, lakes, and streams.
- $300 million for appropriation by the Legislature to the Department of Water Resources for multi-benefit flood management projects.
- $300 million for appropriation by the Legislature to the Wildlife Conservation Board to protect fish and wildlife and natural resources from climate impacts.
- $100 million for appropriation by the Legislature to the Department of Food and Agriculture to improve climate resilience of agricultural lands.
- $100 million for appropriation by the Legislature to the Department of Conservation to protects and restore farmland and rangelands.
- $300 million for appropriation by the Legislature to protect coastal lands, waters, natural resources, and wildlife, including:
- An unspecified amount for projects identified by the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority to address sea level rise, flood management, and wetlands restoration, and
- An unspecified amount for projects identified by the California Coastal Conservancy.
- $150 million to the Strategic Growth Council (SGC) for regional climate strategies to improve climate resilience. SGC must collaborate with state conservancies, regional climate collaboratives, and public agencies from each region of the state to determine appropriate geographic boundaries for the strategies, which must include assessments of climate vulnerabilities, risks, and specified vulnerabilities. $100 million must be used for competitive grants for implementing regional climate strategies.
- $50 million for appropriation by the Legislature to enhance workforce development, of which $30 million must be made available to the California Conservation Corps, of which 50% can be made available for local conservation corps.
SB 45 caps administrative costs of any grant program it authorizes at not more than 5% of fund allocated, and allows 10% of funds to be used for planning and monitoring, as defined, necessary for projects to be successfully implemented. However, grant programs for disadvantaged communities or socially disadvantaged farmers or ranchers can exceed the 10% cap if the state agency administering the grant approves. Agencies may provide advance payments to projects in disadvantaged communities or for socially disadvantaged farmers or ranchers to initiate the project in a timely manner, subject to additional requirements the agency may adopt to ensure proper use of funds. SB 45 bars funds from being used to fulfil any environmental mitigation requirements, except for purposes of providing safe drinking water or improving water quality.
The bill also incorporates standard provisions in general obligation bond law, either explicitly or by reference, with some modifications. The bill defines many of its terms, includes an urgency and clause, and also states legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 45 will provide the necessary investment to help our state become more resilient to climate change. If passed by the voters, this bond will provide funding for concrete on-the-ground measures that will help reduce the severity, frequency, and impacts of climate-related natural disasters including fires, drought, flood and mudslides. According to California’s 4th Climate Assessment, the cost of climate change for California alone could be more than $113 billion annually by 2050. The wildfire season is becoming longer and more intense each year due to hotter temperatures and wide scale tree death resulting from prolonged drought. In fact, between 2010-2017 an estimated 129 million trees died, leaving behind massive amounts of highly combustible fuel. This phenomenon has led to the worst fires on record. Over the 13 months starting in October of 2017 the state endured four massive fires that caused 118 deaths, burned 700,000 acres, and destroyed 27,000 properties. In California, frequent coastal flooding exacerbated by sea-level rise is expected to threaten nearly half a million people, $100 billion in property, and 3500 miles of roads within the next 80 years. The number of hazardous sites, like wastewater plants, which are susceptible to 100-year flood events is expected to increase by nearly 2.5 times over a similar period, drastically increasing the risk of pollutant disasters if adaptation measures are not taken. Droughts are an expected feature of California’s arid climate, but the four-year period between fall 2011 and fall 2015, which correlated with the hottest two years on record in 2014 and 2015, was the driest since record keeping began in 1895. The winter of 2017 provided only a brief respite before historic rainfall lows again in the winter of 2018. SB 45 proposes a general obligation bond to inject much needed revenue to address these impacts. The measure proposes to fund projects to reduce fire risk and restore already damaged areas; restore and protect impacted wetlands, watersheds, waterways, coastal resources, and fish and wildlife populations; reduce impacts in local communities and on vulnerable populations; and improve the resiliency of the state’s water supplies and agricultural lands.”
2. Sixteen tons. Setting the right amount of state general obligation debt is difficult; both the State Treasurer and the Legislative Analyst’s Office state that there is no correct level. Instead, experts suggest that states should look at three criteria: affordability, comparability, and optimality.[1]
California currently has $72.9 billion of general obligation and $13 billion of lease revenue debt outstanding, which is affordable. The Governor’s 2018 Five-Year Infrastructure Plan estimates that the Debt Service Ratio, or the ratio between debt service and general fund revenues, as 6.18% in 2018-19, 5.88% in 2019-20, and 5.72% in 2020-21. The State Treasurer estimates a debt service ratio of 6.09% in 2018-19. Annual expenditures on debt service have grown from $2.9 billion in 2000-01 to $8.1 billion in 2018-19, and estimated to increase to $8.5 billion in 2021-22. Additionally, 95% of outstanding debt is paid at a fixed rate of interest. While debt service percentages are reasonable, every dollar spent on debt service reduces the funding that is available for other priorities.
California’s comparability to other states is less favorable, but improving. The State Treasurer’s 2018 Debt Affordability Report, issued last October, contains the following chart:
Debt Ratios Of 10 Most Populous States, Ranked By Ratio Of Debt To Personal Income | ||||
State | Moody’s/ S&P/ | Debt to personal income(b) | Debt per capita(b) | Debt as a % |
Texas | Aaa/AAA/AAA | 0.9% | $410 | .73% |
North Carolina | Aa1/AA/AA | 1.5% | $611 | 1.2% |
Michigan | Aaa/AAA/AAA | 1.5% | $673 | 1.37% |
Florida | Aaa/AAA/AAA | 2.0% | $889 | 2.02% |
Georgia | Aaa/AAA/AAA | 2.4% | $986 | 1.94% |
Ohio | Aa1/AA+/AA+ | 2.5% | $1,118 | 2.08% |
Pennsylvania | Aa3/A-/AA- | 2.6% | $1,311 | 2.33% |
California New York | Aa3/AA-/AA- Aa1/AA+-/AA+ | 3.9% 5.2% | $2,188 $3,082 | 3.30% 4.08% |
Illinois | Baa3/BBB-/BBB | 5.6% | $2,919 | 4.70% |
Moody’s Median All States | 2.3% | $987 | 2.05% | |
Median For The 10 Most Populous States | 2.45% | $1,052 | 2.05% | |
(a) Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s, and Fitch Ratings as of August, 2018 (b) Figures as reported by Moody’s in its 2018 State Debt Medians Report released June 2017. As of calendar year end 2016. (c) State GDP numbers have a one-year lag. | ||||
Determining optimality or whether government is investing in the quantity and quality of public capital desired by residents, and financing the appropriate share with debt, is more difficult. LAO recommends that the Legislature consider the Governor’s annual Five-Year Infrastructure Plan as a starting point to developing a coordinated approach to infrastructure funding, and establish a committee to focus on statewide infrastructure.
3. The good news. Ratings issued from the three major credit rating agencies often inform investors and the public regarding the state’s creditworthiness, and assess any investment risk from investing in California general obligation bonds. Rating agencies Fitch, Standard and Poor’s, and Moody’s praise California’s deep and diverse economy, recent balanced and on-time budgets, reduced budget deficits, and improved reserves and liquidity. However, the agencies also state that California faces challenges: a highly volatile revenue system, constitutionally-imposed governance restrictions, high housing costs that threaten economic growth, minimal prefunding of retiree health care benefits, and a large backlog of maintenance and infrastructure needs, among others. Once considered an outlier, the “credit spread” between California bonds and other states as measured by the benchmark 30-year Municipal Market Data (MMD) Index has tightened significantly in the last ten years; credit spreads represent the difference in yield between two bonds of similar maturity but different credit quality. The Debt Affordability Report notes that California’s credit spread has declined from a high of more than 150 basis points at the end of 2009 to four basis points as of September 2018. The report also says that California’s GO bonds even yielded less than the national MMD benchmark through year 13, and less than five basis points higher for the remainder of the 30-year benchmark. The report added that these spreads are 15 to 28 basis points better than they had been at the beginning of the 2017-18 fiscal year.
4. The bad news. California has a distinct problem: of the $152.7 billion in general obligation bonds that voters have authorized, more than $36 billion hasn’t been issued yet, with voters approving the $4 billion Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access for All Act of 2018 in June, as well as the $3 billion Veterans and Affordable Housing Bond Act of 2018 and the $1.5 billion Children’s Hospital Bond Act of 2018 last November. Among others, the state hasn’t issued more than $6.5 billion to fund high speed rail, $6.7 billion from the recent water bond, and $8 billion more K-12 and community college education facility bonds (Proposition 51, 2016), among others. While the state has made great progress reducing the amount of authorized, unissued bonds in recent years, many bond-funded projects have not yet received required approvals.
5. Related legislation. On April 7, the Committee approved SB 14 (Glazer) by a vote of 5 to 1, which enacts the Higher Education Facilities Bond Act of 2020, which places an $8 billion bond before voters at the March 2020, statewide primary election.
6. Incoming! On March 26, the Committee on Natural Resources and Water approved SB 45 by a vote of 5 to 1. On April 3, the Committee on Environmental Quality approved the bill by a vote of 7 to 1. The Committee on Governance and Finance is hearing the measure as the committee of third reference.
7. Urgency. As an urgency statute, SB 45 must be approved by 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature. Regular legislation takes effect on the January 1 following its passage, but urgency bills take effect as soon as they are passed, signed, and chaptered.
Support and Opposition
(4/19/19)
Support: Allstate Insurance Company; Arroyos & Foothills Conservancy; Audobon California; Bear Yuba Land Trust; California Association Of Local Conservation Corps; California Association Of Recreation & Park Districts; California Council Of Land Trusts; California Habitat Conservation Planning Coalition; California Outdoors Recreation Partnership (Corp); California Park & Recreation Society; California State Parks Foundation; California Trout; California Waterfowl Association; Citizens For Los Angeles Wildlife; City Of Santa Monica; Community Nature Connection; East Bay Regional Park District; Eastern Sierra Land Trust; Endangered Habitats League; Escondido Creek Conservancy; Escondido Creek Conservancy, The; Friends Of Harbors, Beaches And Parks; Friends Of Joshua Tree; Friends of the Los Angeles River; Hills For Everyone; John Muir Land Trust; Laguna Greenbelt Inc.; Local Government Commission; Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust; Madrone Audubon Society; Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation; Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District; Nature Conservancy; The; Ocean Conservancy; The; Outdoor Industry Association (Oia); Pacific Forest Trust; Paula Lane Action Network; Placer Land Trust; Rails-To-Trails Conservancy; Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority; Save the Redwoods League; Sempervirens Fund; Sierra Business Council; Sierra Business Council; Sierra Nevada Alliance; Sierra-Foothill Conservancy; Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation And Open Space District; Sonoma County Regional Parks; Tahoe City Public Utility District; Tahoe Mountain Sports; The Trust For Public Land; The Wilderness Society; Truckee Donner Land Trust; Westfield State University
Oppositon: Unknown.
-- END --
Robert Wassmer and Ronald Fisher “Debt Burdens of California State and Local Governments: Past, Present and Future.” As requested and supported by the California Debt and Investment Advisory Commission. July 2011. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 45
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | 3/5/2019 | Hearing Date: | 4/3/2019 |
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | David Ernest García | ||
SUBJECT: Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
DIGEST: This bill requires, in an unspecified election, a General Obligation Bond to be put before the voters in the amount of $4.3 billion, with financial provisions as specified, for the purposes of funding projects that (1) restore areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters resulting from climate change; (2) reduce wildfire risk; (3) create healthy forests and watersheds; (4) reduce climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations; (5) protect water supply and water quality; (6) protect rivers, lakes, and streams; (7) are multibenefit flood management projects; (8) protect fish and wildlife and natural resources from climate impacts; (9) improve climate resilience of agricultural lands; (10) protect coastal lands, waters, natural resources, and wildlife; (11) improve regional climate resilience; and (12) enhance workforce development.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, except under certain circumstances, a two-thirds vote of the Legislature, and a majority vote of the people at an election, before the state may issue a general obligation bond. (California Constitution §1 et seq.)
- Prescribes the state’s responsibilities regarding the issuance and sale of general obligation bonds. (Government Code (GOV) §16720 et seq.)
- Provides—pursuant to SB 5 (De León, Chapter 852, Statutes of 2017), which was approved by the voters in the form of Proposition 68, known as the California Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access For All Act of 2018—a general obligation bond of $4 billion for resources-focused projects.
This bill:
- Makes findings and declarations, and defines terms for the purposes of the bill.
- Requires, in an unspecified election, a general obligation bond to be put before the voters in the amount of $4.3 billion, with financial provisions, as specified.
- Allocates the revenues of the bond as follows:
- $200 million for restoring areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters resulting from climate change, as specified.
- One billion for reducing wildfire risk, as specified.
- $600 million for creating healthy forests and watersheds, as specified.
- $300 million for reducing climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations, as specified.
- $600 million for protecting water supply and water quality, as specified.
- $300 million for protecting rivers, lakes, and streams, as specified.
- $300 million for multibenefit flood management projects, as specified.
- $300 million for protecting fish and wildlife and natural resources from climate impacts, as specified.
- $200 million for improving climate resilience of agricultural lands, as specified.
- $300 million for protecting coastal lands, waters, natural resources, and wildlife, as specified.
- $150 million for improving regional climate resilience, as specified.
- $50 million for enhancing workforce development, as specified.
- $200 million for restoring areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters resulting from climate change, as specified.
Background
- Proposition 68 and Proposition 3. California voters have been asked to weigh in on at least two propositions that intended to fund resource-focused projects. Their ballot summaries follow:
- Proposition 3. Authorizes $8.877 billion in state general obligation bonds for various infrastructure projects. Fiscal Impact: Increased state costs to repay bonds averaging $430 million per year over 40 years. Local government savings for water-related projects, likely averaging a couple hundred million dollars annually over the next few decades.
Proposition 3 failed. - Proposition 68. Authorizes $4 billion in general obligation bonds for: parks, natural resources protection, climate adaptation, water quality and supply, and flood protection. Fiscal Impact: Increased state bond repayment costs averaging $200 million annually over 40 years. Local government savings for natural resources-related projects, likely averaging several tens of millions of dollars annually over the next few decades.
Proposition 68 passed.
- Proposition 3. Authorizes $8.877 billion in state general obligation bonds for various infrastructure projects. Fiscal Impact: Increased state costs to repay bonds averaging $430 million per year over 40 years. Local government savings for water-related projects, likely averaging a couple hundred million dollars annually over the next few decades.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 45 will provide the necessary investment to help our state become more resilient to climate change. If passed by the voters, this bond will provide funding for concrete on-the-ground measures that will help reduce the severity, frequency, and impacts of climate-related natural disasters including fires, drought, flood and mudslides. According to California’s 4th Climate Assessment, the cost of climate change for California alone could be more than $113 billion annually by 2050.
“The wildfire season is becoming longer and more intense each year due to hotter temperatures and wide scale tree death resulting from prolonged drought. In fact, between 2010-2017 an estimated 129 million trees died, leaving behind massive amounts of highly combustible fuel. This phenomenon has led to the worst fires on record. Over the 13 months starting in October of 2017 the state endured four massive fires that caused 118 deaths, burned 700,000 acres, and destroyed 27,000 properties. In California, frequent coastal flooding exacerbated by sea-level rise is expected to threaten nearly half a million people, $100 billion in property, and 3500 miles of roads within the next 80 years. The number of hazardous sites, like wastewater plants, which are susceptible to 100-year flood events is expected to increase by nearly 2.5 times over a similar period, drastically increasing the risk of pollutant disasters if adaptation measures are not taken. Droughts are an expected feature of California’s arid climate, but the four-year period between fall 2011 and fall 2015, which correlated with the hottest two years on record in 2014 and 2015, was the driest since record keeping began in 1895. The winter of 2017 provided only a brief respite before historic rainfall lows again in the winter of 2018.
“SB 45 proposes a general obligation bond to inject much needed revenue to address these impacts. The measure proposes to fund projects to reduce fire risk and restore already damaged areas; restore and protect impacted wetlands, watersheds, waterways, coastal resources, and fish and wildlife populations; reduce impacts in local communities and on vulnerable populations; and improve the resiliency of the state’s water supplies and agricultural lands.” - Work in progress. As noted by the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee, SB 45 is very much a work in progress. Given that this two-thirds vote bill will require conversations with leadership in both houses and the administration, staff is not recommending a complete series of substantive amendments because doing so would be premature.
The Committee may wish to ask the author to continue the ongoing working relationship with staff as the bill progresses, and to bring the bill back to committee if necessary. - Climate change and infectious and vector-borne diseases and public health impacts. Climate change can lead to public health impacts by facilitating disease spread and exacerbating chronic health conditions. Already, California has seen an increase in the length of the growing season and pollen production amounts of ragweed, a common cause of severe seasonal allergies.
Increased temperatures can promote bacterial contamination in foods and lead to increases in harmful algal blooms that have been tied to skin, gastrointestinal, respiratory, and neurological signs and symptoms.
Reductions in the number and sizes of recreational bodies of water due to decreased rainfall can further lead to increased concentration of pollutants and bacterial contaminants from more users in fewer and smaller areas.
There is concern about the spread of vector-borne diseases, as the distribution of vectors (e.g. ticks, mosquitoes) carrying pathogens spread into new habitats as regional climates change. Droughts, which will increase with climate change, can also favor mosquito breeding because streams that would normally be flowing become a series of stagnant pools in which mosquitoes breed. For example, previous research has shown that human outbreaks of the mosquito-transmitted Saint Louis encephalitis are correlated with periods of several days when the temperature exceeds 30°C (95°F), as has been the case in previous California epidemics (Githeko et al. 2000).
In addition to expanding habitats, hot temperatures also facilitate the spread of West Nile Virus (WNV) by speeding up both the replication of the virus and the development of the mosquito that carries it. Mosquitoes digest blood meals more rapidly at higher temperatures, leading them to feed more often.
The author may wish to consider incorporating projects that address these concerns as eligible for funding in chapter 5 of the bill. - Regional efforts on climate adaptation. SB 45 contains provisions requiring the Strategic Growth Council (SGC) to collaborate with state conservancies, regional climate collaboratives, and public agencies from each region of the state to determine appropriate geographic boundaries for regional and subregional strategies. Additionally, SB 45 requires those regional strategies to include an assessment of climate vulnerabilities and risks and identification of environmental, economic, and social climate vulnerabilities, including impacts to vulnerable populations. SGC is not the appropriate body to do that work, however.
SGC was established in 2008 by SB 732 (Steinberg, Chapter 729, Statutes of 2008) and is responsible for coordinating a variety of state programs and activities related to sustainable communities and the environment. SGC is comprised of ten members: the Director of the Office of Planning and Research (OPR), The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, the Secretary of Environmental Protection Agency, the Secretary of Transportation, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, the Secretary of Business, Consumer Services, and Housing, the Secretary of Department of Food and Agriculture, and three public members (one each being appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, the Senate Committee on Rules, and the Governor).
OPR, on the other hand, serves the governor and the administration as staff for long-range planning, research, policy development and legislative analysis. The office formulates plans regarding land use, climate change, urban expansion, infrastructure development and resource protection while acting as a liaison to local governments, small businesses and the military.
In 2015, the Legislature passed, and the Governor signed, SB 246 (Wieckowski, Chapter 606, Statutes of 2015), which established a framework for adaptation coordination among state agencies by creating the Integrated Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Program within OPR to bring together state, regional, and local entities. The bill also created a clearinghouse of information and tools to help stakeholders efficiently address adaptation.
Additionally, SB 246 formed a Technical Advisory Council (TAC) to provide scientific and technical expertise, and regional and local perspectives, to assist state agencies. The advisory council consists of 17 non state-affiliated and five agency-affiliated scientific and technical experts.
The Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee noted that chapter 12 of SB 45 needed “more meat on the bones.” That proverbial meat could come from the work already being done at OPR under SB 246.
Finally, it must be noted that SB 45 is vague about exactly who is going to be putting together the regional strategies. While it may be appropriate for each region to be a part of putting together their own regional strategy, the state must have a role in overseeing and approving final regional strategies.
Given that OPR is the more appropriate entity to perform the aforementioned work, the author should work with the administration to incorporate OPR into SB 45 before the bill passes off the Senate Floor. Additionally, the author should work with the administration to determine the best way for the scientific, technical, state, regional, and local experts on the TAC to provide guidance to SGC when it awards grants pursuant to this bond. - Water sources. Regarding water supply, chapter 6 of SB 45 specifies that “preference shall be given to projects that provide treatment for contamination or access to an alternative drinking water source or sources for small community water systems or state small water systems in disadvantaged communities whose drinking water source is impaired by chemical, including nitrate contaminants, and other health hazards identified by the water board.”
It is unclear whether “in disadvantaged communities” is meant to modify both small community water systems and state small water systems, or just the latter. The next sentence, however, specifies, “Eligible recipients are public water systems or public agencies that serve disadvantaged communities.” This second sentence makes “in disadvantaged communities” in the first sentence unnecessary.
A technical and clarifying amendment is needed to strike “in disadvantaged communities” from the first sentence.
Additionally, the first sentence leaves open the option that funding from the bond may be used for projects that used bottled or hauled water as an “alternative drinking water source or sources.”
The Committee may wish to amend SB 45 to clarify that only “viable long-term” alternative sources of water are eligible for funding. - Natural disasters. SB 45 contains funding to “restore areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters resulting from climate change.” (Emphasis added.) While science can now conclusively attribute some individual extreme events to climate change, is it appropriate for the state to fund restoration projects from a flood that science can attribute to climate change, but not a wildfire started by sparking electric transmission lines?
Moreover, what would happen if, in the immediate aftermath of a natural disaster, scientists are unable to attribute the event to climate change? Or if scientists are only able to make that connection months to years after the event occurred?
The Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee required an amendment addressing this concern as a condition of securing passage (see the next comment), but only did so in section 80220.
The Committee may wish to consider striking the requirement that climate change be the cause of a natural disaster in order to fund restoration projects from section 80208 as well.
The author has stated that the intent of the bill is only to fund restoration projects from natural disasters that could be made worse by climate change without requiring proof that climate change caused the natural disaster or made it worse. As written, however, restoration projects from any natural disaster, including earthquakes, could be funded.
As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider amending the bill to ensure that the contents of the chapter accurately reflect the author’s intent. - Amendments from the Natural Resources and Water Committee. The Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee required amendments to SB 45 in order for the bill to secure passage. Due to the constraints of legislative deadlines, that Committee agreed to allow the author to take their amendments in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee. These amendments are:
AMENDMENT 1
In section 80202, add a definition of “wildland urban interface.” This will be drafted by staff prior to the Environmental Quality Committee hearing. [Note: this amendment was not provided at the time of the publication of this analysis and will be taken in the Senate Appropriations Committee.] Also make technical change to the definition of “conservation actions on private lands” by deleting “adaptative” and “of protection.”
AMENDMENT 2
In Sec. 80202(e) delete “vital.”
AMENDMENT 3
In section 80220, delete “resulting from climate change” and add, after “infrastructure to” “enhance public safety and”
AMENDMENT 4
In section 80232 add after “of”: “the regional fire and forest capacity program” and add a new (c) that states: “Grants to fire safe councils and resource conservation districts for development and implementation of community wildfire protection plans that promote and create incentives for structural and community retrofit projects, defensible space, and other projects to improve fire resilience.”
AMENDMENT 5
For sections 80232 and 80240 add a provision that the grants must result in durable benefits such as this: “Grants made for the purpose of fire risk reduction shall be secured with management plans, conservation easements, or other agreements that ensure that the benefits of the proposed project persist longer than the debt incurred pursuant to this division. Granting agencies shall incorporate a preference for projects that maintain permanent benefits.”
Also in 80232, delete “and implementation of regional priority plans to improve forest health and fire resiliency.”
Also in 80232 (a) add “that are near communities” after “areas”.
AMENDMENT 6
Delete “Forest Carbon Plan” from Sec. 80240 and clarify that the reference to Section 717 is within the Public Resources Code.
In 80240(b), add at end: “Funds from this subdivision expended on Central Valley floodplain restoration shall be dedicated to the implementation of multibenefit flood management projects that reduce risks to public safety and provide improvements to wildlife habitat.”
AMENDMENT 7
In 80280 (a), add “inland and” before “coastal.”
Also, add new (h): “ Projects to assist in implementation of approved sustainable groundwater management plans.”
AMENDMENT 8
In 80290(a), add at end: “including projects to benefit fall run Chinook salmon.”
In 80290(c) change the phrase to read: “the construction or repair of corridors or the removal of barriers.”
In 80290(j), add “improve agricultural diversion efficiency and” before “eliminate”, delete “requirements”, after “Services” add “2014 Central Valley Salmon and Steelhead,”, and delete everything after “Plan.” [Note: the description of this amendment is not accurate to the bill in print. Instead, the subdivision will be amended to read: Multibenefit projects that improve agricultural diversion efficiency and eliminate entrainment of migratory fish species consistent with the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan and the National Marine Fisheries Service’s 2014 Central Valley Salmon and Steelhead Recovery Plan.]
AMENDMENT 9
In 80301 (a)(1), delete everything after “lands.”
In (b), add “and rangeland” after “farmland.” - Author amendments. The author would like to include the following amendments:
- Section 80232 (b). Other projects that reduce wildfire risk to populated areas, protect habitat,
wildfire,wildlife, or watershed resources, and increase wildfire resilience through enhancing the long-term ecological health of natural systems. - Section 80250 (b). Establishment of cooling centers, clean air centers, hydration stations, and facilities to safeguard vulnerable populations from extreme heat events and other disasters.
- Section 80270 (f). Projects that restore anadromous fish access to historic spawning grounds by implementing passage improvements
atto resolve migration barriersthrough mechanisms approved by state and federal wildlife agenciesrelated to the Central Valley rim dams consistent with the Natural Resources Agency’s California Water Action Plan and the 2014 Central Valley Salmon and Steelhead Recovery Plan.
- Section 80232 (b). Other projects that reduce wildfire risk to populated areas, protect habitat,
TRIPLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee on March 26, 2019, and passed out of committee with a vote of 7-1. If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
1 Individual
Bear Yuba Land Trust
California Farmer Justice Collaborative
California Outdoor Recreation Partnership (CORP)
California Park & Recreation Society
California State Parks Foundation
Clean Water Action
Community Nature Connection
Community Water Center
Defenders of Wildlife
Ducks Unlimited
East Bay Regional Park District
Eastern Sierra Land Trust
Escondido Creek Conservancy
Friends of the LA River
Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Outdoor Afro
Outdoor Industry Association (OIA)
Pacific Forest Trust
Placer Land Trust
Rural Communities Assistance Corporation (RCAC)
Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority
Santa Cruz County Flood Control and Water Conservation District- Zone 7
Save the Bay
Save the Redwoods League
Self-Help Enterprises
Sierra Business Council
Sierra Foothill Conservancy
Sierra Nevada Alliance
Sonoma County Regional Parks
Tahoe City Public Utility District
Tahoe Mountain Sports
The Trust for Public Land
Truckee Donner Land Trust
Watershed Conservation Authority
Westfield State University
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 45 Hearing Date: March 26, 2019
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | March 5, 2019 Amended | ||
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | William Craven | ||
Subject: Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
California’s voters approved Proposition 68, a resources-focused general obligation bond act in the amount of $4 billion, in June, 2018. That bond was known as the California Drought, Water, Parks, Climate, Coastal Protection, and Outdoor Access For All Act of 2018. It was a measure adopted by the Legislature and introduced as SB 5 (De Leon).
In November 2018, California voters disapproved Proposition 3, a water-focused general obligation bond act in the amount of $9 billion. That measure was a citizen initiative which was titled the California Water Infrastructure and Watershed Conservation Bond Initiative.
PROPOSED LAW
This urgency bill:
Proposes the Wildfire, Drought, and Flood Protection Bond Act of 2020 which would authorize $4.3 billion in general obligation bonds to finance a variety of resource projects that are focused on increasing adaptation to climate change or increasing the resilience of various categories of resources projects to climate change. Generally, this proposed bond would finance projects to restore natural lands damaged by wildfires; reduce wildfire risk; improve forest and watershed health; reduce climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations; protect water supply and water quality; protect rivers, lakes and streams; reduce flood risk; protect fish and wildlife from climate impacts; improve the resilience of agricultural lands; and protect coastal lands. Specific provisions are included below.
- Authorizes an amount of not more than 5% of the funds allocated for a grant program to be used to pay administrative costs.
- Authorizes up to 10% of the funds to be used for planning and monitoring necessary for the successful design and implementation of projects.
- Allows grants to disadvantaged communities or socially disadvantaged farmers and ranchers to exceed the 10% threshold.
- Prohibits grants to be used to fulfill any environmental mitigation requirements imposed by law.
- Authorizes advance payments of up to 25% of a grant for projects that serve disadvantaged communities or socially disadvantaged farmers and ranchers.
Categories of Funding.
This bond would authorize the following funding for the referenced categories:
- $200 million for restoring areas impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters resulting from climate change.
- $1 billion for reducing wildfire risk.
- $600 million for creating healthy forests and watersheds.
- $300 million for reducing climate impacts on urban areas and vulnerable populations.
- $600 million for protecting water supply and water quality.
- $300 million for protecting rivers, lakes, and streams
- $300 million for flood management projects
- $300 million for protecting fish and wildlife and natural resources from climate impacts.
- $200 million for improving climate resilience of agricultural lands.
- $300 million for protecting coastal lands, waters, natural resources and wildlife.
- $150 million for improving regional climate resilience.
- $50 million for enhancing workforce development.
Categorical Descriptions.
- For the $200 million for restoration activities impacted by wildfire, flood, drought, or other natural disasters, those funds are available upon appropriation by the Legislature to the Office of Emergency Services (OES). Eligible projects include grants to public agencies for revegetation and other projects to reduce erosion, flood, and mudslide risk; cleanup of damaged or hazardous sites; upgrades to damaged or destroyed infrastructure to enhance safety; and to make the infrastructure more resilient to future disasters. These funds may be used to matching grant requirements for the Federal Emergency Management Agency or other federal programs.
- For the $1 billion for reducing wildfire risk in the wildland urban interface (WUI) the bill proposes an unspecified amount to OES for its pre-hazard mitigation grant program for which eligible projects include grants to local and state agencies for projects that reduce wildfire risks to people and property consistent with approved local hazard mitigation plans. Also eligible are grants to local and state agencies for improvements to warning and evacuation systems, creation of safety centers, and improvements in fire and disaster response communication and infrastructure.
A second unspecified amount would go to the Natural Resources Agency (Agency) and its departments, boards, and conservancies for projects to reduce the risk of wildfire spreading into populated areas from wildlands and to support the development of the regional fire and forest capacity program to improve forest health and fire resiliency. Under this program, the Agency would be required to present the Legislature with information regarding the highest risk areas and recommend allocations by region based on wildfire risk and affected population. Eligible projects include restoration of natural ecosystem functions in high fire hazard areas with preference given to those projects that provide multiple benefits and projects that reduce wildfire risk to populated areas.
In both categories, all the funds are subject to appropriation by the Legislature.
- For the proposed $600 million for the creation of healthy forests and watersheds, all the funds are subject to appropriation, and would be directed to the Agency and its departments, boards, and conservancies for the protection, restoration, and improvement of forests, including redwoods, conifers, oak woodlands, chaparral, deserts, coastal forests, and other habitat types. Projects shall be consistent with the California Forest Carbon Plan. Eligible projects include restoration of large intact forests, prevention of forest fragmentation through subdivision, and restoration of natural fire regimes and climate resilient conditions. Other eligible projects include, but are not limited to, restoration of wet meadows, watersheds, floodplains, and wetlands, and reduction of tree-pest mortality and impacts from invasive species.
- For the proposed $300 million for urban and vulnerable populations, the funds would be available upon appropriation for the following: multi-benefit green infrastructure projects that reduce heat island effects; establishment of cooling centers, clean air centers, hydration stations, and other facilities to safeguard vulnerable populations; improvements to public infrastructure that provide climate resilience benefits, including storm water capture, permeable pavement projects, and others; as well as improvements to city, county, and regional parks to enhance natural resources and water conservation.
- For the proposed $600 million for water supply and quality protection, the funds would be subject to appropriation, and eligible projects include safe drinking water loans and grants for public water system improvements, and upgrades to at-risk rural and small community water systems. A preference would be given to smaller or disadvantaged communities with identified water quality impairments. Also eligible are sustainable groundwater management projects that use captured stormwater or floodwater, source watershed projects for the headwaters rivers of the state water project, and projects that improve water data management.
- For the proposed $300 million for the protection of rivers, lakes, and streams, all of the funding is available by appropriation, and there is a preference for natural infrastructure projects. Eligible projects include multi-benefit river and urban stream parkway projects, climate projects identified in the Lake Tahoe Environmental Improvement Program, projects pursuant to the Salton Sea Management Program, multi-benefit projects in the Los Angeles River Watershed (noting that these would be implemented in ways that recognize the statutorily specified roles of both the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy and the Rivers and Mountain Conservancy for the upper and lower segments of the Los Angeles River), watershed protection programs pursuant to the Sierra Nevada Watershed Improvement Program, and projects to restore anadromous fish access to historic spawning grounds.
- For the proposed $300 million for multi-benefit flood projects, the funds are available by appropriation, and include projects that reduce risks to public safety and improve wildlife habitat. Eligible project types include levee setbacks, connecting rivers to flood plains, enhancement of floodplains and bypasses, offstream groundwater recharge, and land acquisitions and easements necessary for these project types. Projects should be guided by local hazard mitigation plans to the extent feasible.
Specifically authorized projects include multi-benefit flood management projects on inland and coastal infrastructure and that provide ecosystem, wildlife, or groundwater recharge benefits; natural infrastructure projects that reduce flood intensity and slow water runoff; projects that capture clean or otherwise productively use storm water; projects that provide matching grants for, or otherwise leverage funding from the Federal Emergency Management Agency or other federal mitigation and resiliency funding, projects that provide benefits to anadromous and other native fish species; projects that improve the ability of lands to buffer extreme precipitation events; projects that restore streams to a more natural state by removing culverts and paved channels to enable more storm water to be absorbed; and projects that help implement approved sustainable groundwater management plans.
- For the proposed $300 million for fish and wildlife resources that would be appropriated to the Wildlife Conservation Board, eligible projects include specified salmon and other fishery preservation projects; projects to protect and restore wetlands; including refuges for migratory birds; projects for the protection and restoration of wildlife corridors and habitat linkages; land acquisition projects that protect land from development; restoration and stewardship projects that restore or manage land to improve its resilience to climate change and natural disasters; projects for conservation actions on private lands, including incentives and technical assistance for private landowners to implement conservation actions; projects to protect threatened and endangered species, including projects within natural community conservation plans or habitat conservation plan and which may include land acquisition through either easement or fee title; projects that benefit fish and wildlife that involve acquisition of water from willing sellers or lands with water rights from willing sellers; projects for the development and implementation of regional conservation investment strategies that include climate resilience elements; and multi-benefit projects that improve agricultural water diversion efficiency and eliminate entrainment of migratory fish species, as specified.
- For the proposed $100 million to improve climate resiliency on agricultural lands, that funding is available by appropriation to the Department of Food and Agriculture. Eligible projects include grants to promote agricultural and soil health, carbon sequestration, and erosion control, water quality, and water retention. Also, grants to promote on-farm water use efficiency with a focus on multi-benefit projects that improve groundwater management, surface water use efficiency, or that improve drought and flood tolerance are eligible, as are invasive species projects and restoration activities recommended by the Invasive Species Council of California.
- For the proposed $100 million to protect and restore farmlands and rangelands through activities and grants funded by the Department of Conservation (department), eligible projects include the acquisition of fee title or easements that improve climate resilience and provide multiple benefits, including grants for the protection and restoration of agricultural lands, and restoration activities to control or eradicate invasive species. The department shall establish a preference for small and medium-sized farms.
- For the proposed $300 million to protect coastal lands and resources, these funds are available upon appropriation and eligible projects include those that restore wetlands and forests, ameliorate sea level rise, reduce risks of coastal flooding or inundation, and sustain native species populations impacted by ocean acidification and warming seas. Within this chapter, unspecified sums would be available to the San Francisco Bay Area Restoration Authority and to the California Coastal Conservancy. Projects funded pursuant to this chapter shall be consistent with the sea level rise guidelines established by the California Coastal Commission and the State Coastal Conservancy, if applicable.
- For the $150 million for regional climate strategies funded by the Strategic Growth Council, those funds are subject to appropriation for collaborative regional strategies that may be based on the nine regions in California identified in the Fourth Climate Change Assessment. Regardless, the entire geographic area of California shall be covered.
Each regional strategy, which may be based on regional or local plans, shall include an assessment of climate vulnerabilities including environmental, social, and economic factors, including impacts to vulnerable populations. Of these funds, $100 million shall be available for competitive grants for the implementation of climate strategies, and $50 million would be in discretionary grants that are consistent with the chapter.
- For the $50 million available for appropriation for climate resiliency projects that promote workforce development and career pathway opportunities in fire prevention and management, watershed restoration, forestry, forest and vegetation management, park and open-space operations and management, fisheries management, nature-based recreation and tourism, and sustainable forest products industries. Of these funds, $30 million shall be appropriated to the California Conservation Corps, and it, in turn, may expend up to half those funds in grants to certified local conservation corps.
- The bond has fiscal provisions associated with general obligation bond legislation, and those provisions will be reviewed by the Governance and Finance Committee.
This bill requires a 2/3 vote in both houses.
This bill does not yet specify the date of the 2020 election that this measure will be presented to the voters.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, SB 45 will provide the necessary investment to help our state become more resilient to climate change. If passed by the voters, this bond will provide funding for concrete on-the-ground measures that will help reduce the severity, frequency, and impacts of climate-related natural disasters including fires, drought, flood and mudslides. According to California’s Fourth Climate Assessment, the cost of climate change for California alone could be more than $113 billion annually by 2050.
The wildfire season is becoming longer and more intense each year due to hotter temperatures and wide scale tree death resulting from prolonged drought. In fact, between 2010-2017 an estimated 129 million trees died, leaving behind massive amounts of highly combustible fuel. This phenomenon has led to the worst fires on record. Over the 13 months starting in October of 2017 the state endured four massive fires that caused 118 deaths, burned 700,000 acres, and destroyed 27,000 properties. In California, frequent coastal flooding exacerbated by sea-level rise is expected to threaten nearly half a million people, $100 billion in property, and 3500 miles of roads within the next 80 years. The number of hazardous sites, like wastewater plants, which are susceptible to 100-year flood events is expected to increase by nearly 2.5 times over a similar period, drastically increasing the risk of pollutant disasters if adaptation measures are not taken. Droughts are an expected feature of California’s arid climate, but the four-year period between fall 2011 and fall 2015, which correlated with the hottest two years on record in 2014 and 2015, was the driest since record keeping began in 1895. The winter of 2017 provided only a brief respite before historic rainfall lows again in the winter of 2018.
SB 45 proposes a general obligation bond to inject much needed revenue to address these impacts. The measure proposes to fund projects to reduce fire risk and restore already damaged areas; restore and protect impacted wetlands, watersheds, waterways, coastal resources, and fish and wildlife populations; reduce impacts in local communities and on vulnerable populations; and improve the resiliency of the state’s water supplies and agricultural lands.
2. Other supporters, all of whom are listed below, include a significant number of private businesses, public agencies, local governments, special districts, agricultural associations, nonprofit land trusts, resource conservation districts, conservation and environmental nonprofits, and others. While their interests may not be identical, they all agree that climate change has drastically affected wildfires, drought, and floods and wildlife habitat in the state and that funding is vitally necessary to address the realities of climate change in ways that will save both money and lives.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received
COMMENTS
- This bill is a work in progress that will require conversations with leadership in both houses and the administration. Thus, at this stage, staff is not recommending a complete series of substantive amendments pending the author’s discussions with leadership and the governor’s office. The Committee may ask the author to continue the ongoing working relationship with staff as the bill progresses and to bring the bill back to committee at an appropriate time.
- The amendments recommended below will be taken in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee to enable the bill to be heard in a timely fashion as assigned by the Senate Rules Committee.
- Amendment 5 proposes that forestry related investments be durable, which is to say, that the benefits last as long as the bond, typically 30 years. As the bill moves forward, the author may want to consider similar provisions for other chapters, noting that this approach would not be appropriate for every provision in the bond since some provisions are designed to fund shorter-term projects. That said, shorter term projects, especially sequential short-term projects, can be designed to provide longer-term benefits that are appropriate for revenue bond funding.
- Following the suggested amendments, staff has included open issues to be addressed as the bill moves forward.
Triple-referral The Rules Committee referred this bill to the Committee on Natural Resources and Water, the Committee on Environmental Quality, and to the Committee on Governance and Finance. Therefore, if this bill passes this committee, it will be referred to the Committee on Environmental Quality, which will consider the issues within their jurisdiction.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
In section 80201, add a definition of “wildland urban interface.” This will be drafted by staff prior to the Environmental Quality Committee hearing. Also make technical change to the definition of “conservation actions on private lands” by deleting “adaptative” and “of protection.”
AMENDMENT 2
In Sec. 80202(e) delete “vital.”
AMENDMENT 3
In section 80220, delete “resulting from climate change” and add, after “infrastructure to” “enhance public safety and”
AMENDMENT 4
In section 80232 add after “of”: “the regional fire and forest capacity program” and add a new (c) that states: “Grants to fire safe councils and resource conservation districts for development and implementation of community wildfire protection plans that promote and create incentives for structural and community retrofit projects, defensible space, and other projects to improve fire resilience.
AMENDMENT 5
For sections 80232 and 80240 add a provision that the grants must result in durable benefits such as this: “Grants made for the purpose of fire risk reduction shall be secured with management plans, conservation easements, or other agreements that ensure that the benefits of the proposed project persist longer than the debt incurred pursuant to this division. Granting agencies shall incorporate a preference for projects that maintain permanent benefits.”
Also in 80232, delete “and implementation of regional priority plans to improve forest health and fire resiliency.”
Also in 80232 (a) add “that are near communities” after “areas”.
AMENDMENT 6
Delete “Forest Carbon Plan” from Sec. 80240 and clarify that the reference to Section 717 is within the Public Resources Code.
In 80240(b), add at end: “Funds from this paragraph expended on Central Valley floodplain restoration shall be dedicated to the implementation of multibenefit flood management projects that reduce risks to public safety and provide improvements to wildlife habitat.”
AMENDMENT 7
In 80280 (a), add “inland and” before “coastal.”
Also, add new (h): Projects to assist in implementation of approved sustainable groundwater management plans.”
AMENDMENT 8
In 80290(a), add at end: “including projects to benefit fall run Chinook salmon.”
In 80290(c) change the phrase to read: “the construction or repair of corridors or the removal of barriers.”
In 80290(j), add “improve agricultural diversion efficiency and” before “eliminate”, delete “requirements”, after “Services” add “2014 Central Valley Salmon and Steelhead,”, and delete everything after “Plan.”
AMENDMENT 9
In 80301 (a)(1), delete everything after “lands.”
In (b), add “and rangeland” after “farmland.”
Open Issues.
As the bill moves forward, there may be substantive provisions including but not limited to those identified below that should be considered.
- In the unspecified allocation to Agency of the $1 billion forestry funds for activities in the wildland urban interface, should activities be directly focused on making communities safer rather than on backcountry forest management? Should portions of this funding be sub-allocated to conservancies and the Wildlife Conservation Board? Should vegetation management focus on the removal of fuels on the forest floor and ladder fuels and less on the removal of big trees, especially the removal of big trees (which are generally more fire resistant and which sequester more carbon) further from communities? Should there be limitations on the use of prescribed fire in Chaparral in favor of mechanical thinning, since the short-term benefits are few and the long-term damage could be significant? Should this funding be limited to the Regional Fire and Forest Capacity Program?
- Similar questions arise when considering the $600 million proposal in Chapter 4 which is allocated to the Agency. The potential for overlap between these two funding sources is significant, so additional language distinguishing the two will likely be needed.
- Should language be inserted that requires the long-term durability of most of these investments? In addition to the recommended language in the committee amendments on forestry investments, such durability language may be appropriate for the entirety of the bond except for the specific programs that are short-term by definition. The exception that is most obvious relates to conservation actions on private lands which the bond defines as flexible and that are managed dynamically. Of course, even in this context the bond allows for conservation easements and fee title acquisition which would solve the durability question as would sequential short-term projects that would meet the durability standard.
- Should the flood provisions (Chapter 8) be expanded to make eligible the levee subvention program? And should this flood language be made more specific for the types of projects that are allowed—there seem to be two categories of eligible projects.
- Should there be more meat on the bones for the innovative grants proposed for the Strategic Growth Council? The potential for collaborative regional climate strategies is significant and could bring together entities in unusual coalitions. However, perhaps even some findings would be useful public education since this is a new proposal.
- Should the $600 million water fund have groundwater cleanup as an eligible use?
- Should the definition of “action” be narrowed so that projects with adverse environmental impacts are specifically excluded? This could include dams in the wrong locations as well as seawalls and similar projects in the ocean that have had adverse impacts upcoast or downcoast from the proposed project.
- Should the state consider a long-term reinsurance policy to leverage greater funding for adapting to climate change, paying damages related to climate change, and buying down the public sector funding risk from climate change?
- Overall, the bond clearly lays out the framework for the projects proposed for funding in a way that avoids funding specific projects, which is the preferred method for funding investments at this scale. It may be the case that more specifics will be needed to fine-tune specific aspects within this framework. Additionally, it may help to re-organize certain chapters to consolidate all of the funding that is eligible for a given topic.
SUPPORT
Agriculture and Land-Based Training Association
Allstate
American Rivers
Arroyos & Foothills Conservancy
Bear Yuba Land Trust
Big Sur Land Trust
Bolsa Chica Land Trust
California Association of Resource Conservation Districts – if amended
California Climate and Agriculture Network – if amended
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Farmer Justice Collaborative
California Food & Farming Network
California Habitat Conservation Planning Coalition
California Invasive Plant Council
California Outdoor Recreation Partnership
California Park & Recreation Society
California State Parks Foundation
California Trout – if amended
California Urban Forests Council
California Waterfowl Association
Citizens for Los Angeles Wildlife
City of Santa Monica
Clean Water Action – if amended
Climate Resolve
Committee on Clean Water, Natural Resources, and Parks
Community Nature Connection
Community Water Center – if amended
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Regional Park District
Eastern Sierra Land Trust
Endangered Habitats League
Environment California
Escondido Creek Conservancy
Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks
Friends of the LA River
Hills for Everyone
Laguna Greenbelt, Inc.
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability – if amended
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Madrone Audubon Society, Sonoma County
Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mountains Recreation & Conservation Authority
Ocean Conservancy
Outdoor Afro
Outdoor Industry Association
Pacific Forest Trust
Paula Lane Action Network, Sonoma County
Peninsula Open Space Trust
Pesticide Action Network North America
Placer Land Trust
Planning and Conservation League
Rural Communities Assistance Corporation – if amended
Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority
Santa Cruz County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
Save The Bay
Save the Redwoods League
Self-Help Enterprises – if amended
Sempervirens Fund
Sierra Business Council
Sierra Foothill Conservancy
Sierra Nevada Alliance
Sonoma Ag + Open Space
Sonoma County Ag & Open Space
Sonoma County Regional Parks
Sonoma Water
Surfrider Foundation
Sustainable Conservation
Tahoe City Public Utility District
Tahoe Mountain Sports
The Nature Conservancy
The Trust for Public Land
The Wilderness Society
TreePeople – if amended
Truckee Donner Land Trust
Watershed Conservation Authority
Westfield State University
Wildlands Conservancy
Wildlife Corridor Working Group
OPPOSITION
None Received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):