SB 51: California Competes tax credit: refunds.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-30
(1)Existing law, the Financial Institutions Law, regulates the activities of various financial entities, including commercial banks, industrial banks, trust companies, credit unions, and savings and loan associations. The Banking Law defines and regulates state banks and commits the enforcement of banking laws to the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The California Credit Union Law provides for the licensure and regulation of credit unions by the Commissioner of Business Oversight and makes a willful violation of that law a crime.
The Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act, an initiative measure approved as Proposition 64 at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election, authorizes a person who obtains a state license under the act to engage in commercial adult-use cannabis activity pursuant to that license and applicable local ordinances. The Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act, among other things, consolidates the licensure and regulation of commercial medicinal and adult-use cannabis activities.
This bill would create the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law, to be administered by the Commissioner of Business Oversight and the Department of Business Oversight. The bill would create the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board and specify its composition, to include the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and commit to it the general responsibility for ensuring that this law functions in a safe and efficient way. The bill would prescribe the powers and duties of the board, including reviewing department enforcement reports, holding meetings that would be open to public comment, and issuing its own recommendations, which would be submitted to the Legislature and the Governor. The board would also be required to provide guidance on specified investment activities.
The bill would provide for the licensure and regulation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions for the purpose of providing banking services, as defined, to cannabis businesses. The bill would require a person who desires to be licensed as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to submit an application to the department, and would require that person to elect to form under either the Banking Law or the California Credit Union Law. The bill would authorize the department to charge an applicant for a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license a reasonable fee. The bill would require a licensee to comply with all requirements in the Financial Institutions Law, and either the Banking Law or the California Credit Union Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of those laws are inconsistent with a provision of the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law. By expanding the application of the California Credit Union Law, a willful violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to adopt policies and practices to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. The bill would prohibit a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union from engaging in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter issued under these provisions.
This bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to issue to an account holder special purpose checks that would be valid for only specified purposes. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to cash the checks it has issued, including those presented by parties that are not account holders, as specified. The bill would permit these checks to be used for the payment of state and local fees and taxes, payment of rent on property leased by, or on behalf of, the account holders cannabis business, payment of vendors physically located in California, as specified, and the purchase of state and local bonds, as specified. The bill would provide that a person or entity is not required to accept these checks. The bill would require a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to obtain and maintain insurance at all times that it is engaged in business, subject to certain requirements including that the insurance be in an amount acceptable to the commissioner. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to charge fees for its banking services, and would require, in these circumstances, that each limited charter bank and credit union conspicuously post on its internet website the types of fees and their amounts, as specified. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to enter into an agreement with another licensee to form a banking network, subject to the approval of the commissioner, to facilitate the provision of cannabis banking services.
The bill would require the Department of Business Oversight to adopt emergency regulations and would prohibit the department from issuing a license for these purposes prior to July 1, 2020, except as specified.
The bill would make the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law inoperative if the federal government removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the federal schedule of controlled substances or enacts legislation that establishes protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses. The bill would also require the department, if either of these events occur, to post notice of the occurrence on its internet website, send notice to both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel, and provide guidance for the orderly resolution of all cannabis limited charter banks or credit unions licensed, as specified. The bill would require each cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to resolve within one year in accordance with specified requirements and would authorize the department to take certain actions to carry out those provisions.
The bill would make other conforming changes and would also make a statement of legislative findings.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
(1)Existing law, the Financial Institutions Law, regulates the activities of various financial entities, including commercial banks, industrial banks, trust companies, credit unions, and savings and loan associations. The Banking Law defines and regulates state banks and commits the enforcement of banking laws to the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The California Credit Union Law provides for the licensure and regulation of credit unions by the Commissioner of Business Oversight and makes a willful violation of that law a crime.
The Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act, an initiative measure approved as Proposition 64 at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election, authorizes a person who obtains a state license under the act to engage in commercial adult-use cannabis activity pursuant to that license and applicable local ordinances. The Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act, among other things, consolidates the licensure and regulation of commercial medicinal and adult-use cannabis activities.
This bill would create the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law, to be administered by the Commissioner of Business Oversight and the Department of Business Oversight. The bill would create the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board and specify its composition, to include the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and commit to it the general responsibility for ensuring that this law functions in a safe and efficient way. The bill would prescribe the powers and duties of the board, including reviewing department enforcement reports, holding meetings that would be open to public comment, and issuing its own recommendations, which would be submitted to the Legislature and the Governor. The board would also be required to provide guidance on specified investment activities.
The bill would provide for the licensure and regulation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions for the purpose of providing banking services, as defined, to cannabis businesses. The bill would require a person who desires to be licensed as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to submit an application to the department, and would require that person to elect to form under either the Banking Law or the California Credit Union Law. The bill would authorize the department to charge an applicant for a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license a reasonable fee. The bill would require a licensee to comply with all requirements in the Financial Institutions Law, and either the Banking Law or the California Credit Union Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of those laws are inconsistent with a provision of the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law. By expanding the application of the California Credit Union Law, a willful violation of which is a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to adopt policies and practices to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. The bill would prohibit a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union from engaging in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter issued under these provisions.
This bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to issue to an account holder special purpose checks that would be valid for only specified purposes. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to cash the checks it has issued, including those presented by parties that are not account holders, as specified. The bill would permit these checks to be used for the payment of state and local fees and taxes, payment of rent on property leased by, or on behalf of, the account holders cannabis business, payment of vendors physically located in California, as specified, and the purchase of state and local bonds, as specified. The bill would provide that a person or entity is not required to accept these checks. The bill would require a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to obtain and maintain insurance at all times that it is engaged in business, subject to certain requirements including that the insurance be in an amount acceptable to the commissioner. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to charge fees for its banking services, and would authorize the commissioner, if requested by any person or whenever the commissioner deems appropriate, to review any fee charged. The bill would require a cannabis limited charter bank and credit union to provide the commissioner with a specified fee schedule, which information the department would be required to compile and post information on its Internet Web site. The bill would authorize a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union to enter into an agreement with another licensee to form a banking network, subject to the approval of the commissioner, to facilitate the provision of cannabis banking services.
The bill would require the Department of Business Oversight to adopt emergency regulations and would prohibit the department from issuing a license for these purposes prior to July 1, 2020, except as specified. The bill would require the department to provide a specified report to the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
The bill would also make a statement of legislative findings.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares:
(a)In November 2016, California voters passed Proposition 64, the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act, authorizing recreational use of marijuana subject to specified limits. Medicinal cannabis use has been legal under California law since 1996 with the passage of Proposition 215, the Compassionate Use Act of 1996.
(b)Since 1996, a network of producers, distributors, and dispensaries have developed in California to serve the needs of the medical cannabis community. All of these businesses are expected to expand, and new businesses are expected to join them, in order to serve recreational cannabis users.
(c)Cannabis remains illegal under federal law. The United States Drug Enforcement Administration classifies cannabis as a Schedule I drug. As a result, the majority of financial institutions that take deposits, including banks, thrifts, and credit unions, do not serve cannabis businesses. This status precludes cannabis-related businesses from depositing income in, or engaging in other banking-related activities with, federally insured and regulated financial institutions and from using a federal clearinghouse to process their payments.
(d)Since most financial institutions will not serve cannabis businesses because of the conflict of federal law with state law, these businesses are unable to open and use checking accounts, make or receive electronic payments, or accept credit or debit cards.
(e)While income from the sale of cannabis products is considered ill-gotten gains by the federal government, that income is still taxable. The Internal Revenue Service specifically states in Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income, that (i)llegal income, Income from illegal activities, such as money from dealing illegal drugs, must be included in your income on Form 1040, line 21, or on Schedule C or Schedule C-EZ (Form 1040) if from your self-employment activity.
(f)The need for banking services for the cannabis industry is at an all-time high, given that the industry is now expected to generate more than $8,000,000,000 in revenue annually.
(g)The lack of banking services has created both regulatory and public safety issues. State and local governments must be able to audit and perform accounting and other accountability functions affecting cannabis-related businesses. This is made significantly more difficult when the majority of transactions are completed with cash.
(h)With financial services unavailable to cannabis businesses, these businesses are less able to pay taxes and follow California regulations governing cannabis.
(i)Additionally, the lack of access to financial services has created public safety issues for businesses that need to pay high security costs to safeguard their income and their employees, who risk being robbed when managing and transporting cash.
(j)California voters have spoken in support of the new cannabis laws. Without a change in law regarding financial services, businesses providing services that are lawful under state law may elect to remain underground and not become regulated, tax-paying California businesses, as the voters intended.
(k)In furtherance of the will of the voters, the California government has a responsibility to enact appropriate implementing legislation for Proposition 64. The current conflict with federal law creates a significant problem requiring legislative attention. The state has a duty to provide a mechanism to help these lawful businesses to gain access to banking services that is consistent with the will of California voters.
SEC. 2.Section 99 of the Financial Code is amended to read:99.This division, Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000), Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000), Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000), Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000), Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000), and Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000) shall be known, and may be cited, as the Financial Institutions Law.
SEC. 3.Section 185 of the Financial Code is amended to read:185.Licensee has the following meanings:
(a)Any bank authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact banking or trust business.
(b)Any industrial bank authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact industrial banking business.
(c)Any trust company authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact trust business.
(d)Any foreign (other nation) bank that is licensed under Article 2 (commencing with Section 1780) of Chapter 20 or under Article 3 (commencing with Section 1800) of Chapter 20.
(e)Any person licensed by the commissioner as a money transmitter pursuant to Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000).
(f)Any person authorized by the commissioner to conduct the business of a savings association pursuant to Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000).
(g)Any credit union authorized by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Section 14154.
(h)Any foreign (other state) credit union licensed by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 16000) of Division 5.
(i)Any foreign (other nation) credit union licensed by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Chapter 12 (commencing with Section 16500) of Division 5.
(j)Any industrial loan company authorized by the commissioner to conduct insurance premium finance business pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000).
(k)Any corporation licensed by the commissioner as a business and industrial development corporation pursuant to Section 31154.
(l)Any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union authorized by the commissioner to conduct banking services pursuant to Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
SEC. 4.Section 301 of the Financial Code is amended to read:301.(a)This chapter is applicable to this division, Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000), Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000), Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000), Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000), and Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000).
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), this article, and Articles 2 (commencing with Section 320) and 3 (commencing with Section 350) are applicable to the administration of laws by the Division of Corporations.
(c)Sections 329, 330, 332, 335, 336, 357, 378, 379, and 381 are not applicable to the Division of Corporations.
SEC. 5.Section 329 of the Financial Code is amended to read:329.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Applicable law means:
(A)With respect to any bank, Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), and any of the following provisions:
(i)Article 6 (commencing with Section 405) of Chapter 3.
(ii)Article 3 (commencing with Section 1130) of Chapter 5 of Division 1.1.
(iii)Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 1200) of Division 1.1.
(iv)Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1320) of Division 1.1.
(v)Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 1460) of Division 1.1.
(vi)Article 1 (commencing with Section 1530) of Chapter 15 of Division 1.1.
(vii)Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 1550) of Division 1.1.
(viii)Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 1750) of Division 1.1.
(ix)Section 456.
(x)Section 457.
(xi)Section 459.
(xii)Section 460.
(xiii)Section 461.
(xiv)Section 1331.
(xv)Chapter 21 (commencing with Section 1850) of Division 1.1.
(xvi)Chapter 18 (commencing with Section 1660) of Division 1.1.
(xvii)Chapter 19 (commencing with Section 1670) of Division 1.1.
(B)With respect to any savings association, any provision of Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800) and Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000).
(C)With respect to any insurance premium finance agency, any provision of Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000).
(D)With respect to any business and industrial development corporation, any provision of Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000).
(E)With respect to any credit union, any of the following provisions:
(i)Section 14252.
(ii)Section 14253.
(iii)Section 14255.
(iv)Article 4 (commencing with Section 14350) of Chapter 3 of Division 5.
(v)Section 14401.
(vi)Section 14404.
(vii)Section 14408, only as that section applies to gifts to directors, volunteers, and employees, and the related family or business interests of the directors, volunteers, and employees.
(viii)Section 14409.
(ix)Section 14410.
(x)Article 5 (commencing with Section 14600) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(xi)Article 6 (commencing with Section 14650) of Chapter 4 of Division 5, excluding subdivision (a) of Section 14651.
(xii)Section 14803.
(xiii)Section 14851.
(xiv)Section 14858.
(xv)Section 14860.
(xvi)Section 14861.
(xvii)Section 14863.
(F)With respect to any money transmitter, any provision of Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000).
(G)With respect to any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union, any provision of Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
(2)Licensee means any bank, savings association, credit union, trust company, cannabis limited charter bank or credit union, money transmitter, insurance premium finance agency, or business and industrial development corporation that is authorized by the commissioner to conduct business in this state.
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of this code that applies to a licensee or a subsidiary of a licensee, after notice and an opportunity to be heard, the commissioner may, by order that shall include findings of fact which incorporates a determination made in accordance with subdivision (e), levy civil penalties against any licensee or any subsidiary of a licensee who has violated any provision of applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary of the licensee, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner. The commissioner shall have the sole authority to bring any action with respect to a violation of applicable law subject to a penalty imposed under this section.
Except as provided in paragraphs (1) and (2), any penalty imposed by the commissioner may not exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in any one action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000).
(1)If the commissioner determines that any licensee or subsidiary of the licensee has recklessly violated any applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any provision of any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner, the commissioner may impose a penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in an action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000).
(2)If the commissioner determines that any licensee or subsidiary of the licensee has knowingly violated any applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any provision of any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner, the commissioner may impose a penalty not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in an action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed 1 percent of the total assets of the licensee or subsidiary of a licensee subject to the penalty.
(c)Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from pursuing any other administrative action allowed by law.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from bringing an action in court to enforce any law or order the commissioner has issued, including orders issued under this section. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from seeking any other damages or injunction allowed by law.
(e)In determining the amount and the appropriateness of initiating a civil money penalty under subdivision (b), the commissioner shall consider all of the following:
(1)Evidence that the violation or practice or breach of duty was intentional or was committed with a disregard of the law or with a disregard of the consequences to the institution.
(2)The duration and frequency of the violations, practices, or breaches of duties.
(3)The continuation of the violations, practices, or breaches of duty after the licensee or subsidiary of the licensee was notified, or, alternatively, its immediate cessation and correction.
(4)The failure to cooperate with the commissioner in effecting early resolution of the problem.
(5)Evidence of concealment of the violation, practice, or breach of duty or, alternatively, voluntary disclosure of the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(6)Any threat of loss, actual loss, or other harm to the institution, including harm to the public confidence in the institution, and the degree of that harm.
(7)Evidence that a licensee or subsidiary of a licensee received financial gain or other benefit as a result of the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(8)Evidence of any restitution paid by a licensee or subsidiary of a licensee of losses resulting from the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(9)History of prior violations, practices, or breaches of duty, particularly where they are similar to the actions under consideration.
(10)Previous criticism of the institution for similar actions.
(11)Presence or absence of a compliance program and its effectiveness.
(12)Tendency to engage in violations of law, unsafe or unsound financial institutions practices, or breaches of duties.
(13)The existence of agreements, commitments, orders, or conditions imposed in writing intended to prevent the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(14)Whether the violation, practice, or breach of duty causes quantifiable, economic benefit or loss to the licensee or the subsidiary of the licensee. In those cases, removal of the benefit or recompense of the loss usually will be insufficient, by itself, to promote compliance with the applicable law, order, or written agreement. The penalty amount should reflect a remedial purpose and should provide a deterrent to future misconduct.
(15)Other factors as the commissioner may, in their opinion, consider relevant to assessing the penalty or establishing the amount of the penalty.
(f)The amounts collected under this section shall be deposited in the appropriate fund of the department. For purposes of this subdivision, the term appropriate fund means the fund to which the annual assessments of fined licensees, or the parent licensee of the fined subsidiary, are credited.
SEC. 6.Section 1003 of the Financial Code is amended to read:1003.Except where explicitly stated or the context provides otherwise, this division is applicable to the following:
(a)All corporations engaging in commercial banking, industrial banking, or the trust business.
(b)All national banking associations authorized to transact business in this state to the extent that the provisions of this division are not inconsistent with and do not infringe paramount federal laws governing national banking associations.
(c)All cannabis limited charter banks or credit unions that elect to form under this division to the extent that the provisions of this division are not inconsistent with Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
(d)All other corporations that subject themselves to the special provisions and sections of this division.
(e)All other persons, associations, copartnerships, or corporations who, by violating any of its provisions, become subject to the penalties provided for in this division.
SEC. 7.Section 1100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:1100.The articles of each bank shall contain the applicable one of the following statements:
(a)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, a commercial bank not authorized to engage in trust business, that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in commercial banking business and any other lawful activities which are not, by applicable laws or regulations, prohibited to a commercial bank.
(b)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, a commercial bank authorized to engage in trust business, that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in commercial banking business and trust business and any other lawful activities which are not, by applicable laws or regulations, prohibited to a commercial bank authorized to engage in trust business.
(c)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, an industrial bank not authorized to engage in trust business, that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in industrial banking business and any other lawful activities which are not, by applicable laws or regulations, prohibited to an industrial bank.
(d)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, an industrial bank authorized to engage in trust business, that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in industrial banking business and trust business and any other lawful activities which are not, by applicable laws or regulations, prohibited to an industrial bank authorized to engage in trust business.
(e)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, a trust company (other than a commercial bank authorized to engage in trust business), that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in trust business and any other lawful activities which are not, by applicable laws or regulations, prohibited to a trust company.
(f)In case the bank is, or is proposed to be, a cannabis limited charter bank, that the purpose of the corporation is to engage in the business of providing limited banking services to cannabis businesses under Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000). This subdivision shall become inoperative if Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000) becomes inoperative pursuant to Section 11101.
SEC. 7.SEC. 8.Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000) is added to the Financial Code, to read:2.5.Cannabis Limited Charter Banking And Credit Union Law1.General Provisions1.Short Title and Construction11000.This division is known, and may be cited, as the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law.
2.Definitions11005.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Applicant means a person or entity that submits an application to be licensed by the state to provide banking services to a cannabis business pursuant to this division.
(b)Banking services means the provision of depository services with respect to cash or other funds and the issuance and acceptance of special purpose checks, including the acceptance and maintenance of deposit proceeds, consistent with the requirements and limitations provided by this chapter.
(c)Board means the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board.
(d)Cannabis business means a person licensed to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 (commencing with Section 26000) of the Business and Professions Code. The term cannabis business also includes an ancillary business or profession that serves a person licensed to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 (commencing with Section 26000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)Cannabis limited charter bank or credit union means a person that receives a license following the approval of an application pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 11040).
(f)Commissioner means the Commissioner of Business Oversight.
(g)Department means the Department of Business Oversight.
(h)Licensee means a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union.
2.Administration1.The Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board11010.(a)There is hereby created the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board. The board shall be comprised of the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control. The Director of Finance shall serve as an ex officio, nonvoting member. Board members shall not be compensated for their services.
(b)The board shall be generally responsible for ensuring that the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law provides a safe and efficient way to pay state and local taxes and fees, to pay rent associated with the account holders cannabis business, to issue special purpose checks, and legally invest in Californias economy, while reducing burdens placed on local government that result from collecting and managing large sums of cash.
11011.In light of the particular challenges arising from cannabis business activities, the department shall submit reports of enforcement activities to the board for review annually or as the board may require. The board shall meet once a year, or more often as needed, at the boards discretion, to review enforcement activity reports from the department. These meetings shall be noticed and open to public comment. The board shall evaluate the reports and the comments of the public and draft recommended actions to be taken legislatively or administratively, which shall be submitted to the Legislature and Governor. Recommendations provided to the Legislature shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
11012.The board shall provide guidance and education to registered broker-dealers and licensed investment advisors on how to accommodate account holders of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions in purchasing, holding, and selling any of the investments described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 11050.
2.Licensing11020.(a)A person may act as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union after obtaining a license pursuant to this division.
(b)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license is not transferable or assignable.
11021.A licensee shall comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law (Division 1 (commencing with Section 99)) and either the Banking Law (Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000)) or the California Credit Union Law (Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000)), as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of those laws are inconsistent with a provision of this division, in which case the provisions of this division shall prevail.
11025.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act (31 U.S.C. Sec. 5311) and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
11026.The department shall adopt emergency regulations pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code to implement this division. The adoption of these regulations is deemed to be an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety.
11027.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), the department shall not issue a license under this chapter before July 1, 2020.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the department may issue a license under this chapter before July 1, 2020, if the following conditions are met:
(1)The regulations required by Section 11026 have been adopted.
(2)The Commissioner of Business Oversight makes a written finding that the requirement in paragraph (1) has been met and the department is prepared to issue licenses, consistent with the regulations required by Section 11026, and posts the written finding on the departments internet website.
3.Application11040.An applicant that desires to be licensed to act as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this division shall submit a completed application to the department in a form prescribed by the commissioner that satisfies the requirements of this chapter. An applicant that desires to be licensed to act as a limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this division shall elect to form under either the Banking Law (Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000)) or the California Credit Union Law (Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000)), and shall comply with all requirements imposed by those laws, as applicable, except to the extent any requirement of those laws is inconsistent with the provisions of this chapter. The name of a cannabis limited charter bank shall include the ending cannabis limited charter bank or the abbreviation C.L.C.B. or CLCB. The name of a cannabis credit union shall include the ending cannabis credit union or the abbreviation C.C.U. or CCU.
11042.The department may charge an applicant a reasonable fee for a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license, not to exceed the costs of regulation.
4.Authorizations11050.(a)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may issue to an account holder special purpose checks that shall be valid for only the purposes specified in subdivision (b). The following text shall be printed on each check in at least 12-point type, with the name of the issuing bank included: This check is issued by [insert name of bank] and may only be deposited or cashed at this cannabis limited charter bank or credit union or another cannabis limited charter bank or credit union that agrees to accept the check.
(b)Subject to the limitations of subdivision (d), a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may only be used for the following purposes:
(1)To pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
(2)To pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holders cannabis business.
(3)To pay a vendor that is physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the account holders cannabis business.
(4)To purchase the following:
(A)Bonds, interest-bearing notes, or interest-bearing warrants of this state for which the faith and credit of this state are pledged for the payment of principal and interest.
(B)Bonds or warrants, including, but not limited to, revenue warrants, of any county, city, metropolitan water district, California water district, California water storage district, irrigation district in the state, municipal utility district, or school district of this state.
(c)Subject to the limitations of subdivision (d), state and local government offices are authorized to accept a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union.
(d)An individual or entity, private or public, is not required to accept a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this section.
(e)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union is authorized to cash a special purpose check presented to it by a person or entity that is not an account holder, if that limited charter bank or credit union previously issued that special purpose check to an account holder, and the check was used for one of the authorized purposes specified in subdivision (b).
11052.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall obtain and maintain private insurance in an amount acceptable to the commissioner for the cannabis depository institution and its assets at all times while it is engaged in banking services. Private insurance shall not be unsatisfactory to the commissioner. In seeking and retaining private insurance, a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may do all things and assume and discharge all obligations required of it that are not in conflict with state law.
11054.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may enter into an agreement with one or more other limited charter licensees in order to form a banking network. That agreement shall be subject to the approval of the commissioner. The network shall be for the purpose of assisting each other in providing services to cannabis businesses and each other. A network of this type shall not include any institution that is not a licensee under this division.
11056.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may provide accounts to people and entities other than cannabis businesses, pursuant to rules that may be adopted by the commissioner.
11058.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may charge fees for the banking services that it provides. Each cannabis limited charter bank and credit union that charges fees shall conspicuously post on its internet website the types of fees, and the amounts of fees, it charges for its services, in a format intended to provide transparency.
5.Prohibited Practices11100.(a)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall not engage in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter issued under this division.
(b)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall not engage in any activity under Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000) or Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000) other than activity required to accept deposits and perform actions described in Chapter 4.
(c)Except as otherwise specified in Section 11101, only a cannabis limited charter bank may merge with one or more cannabis limited charter banks. The provisions of Article 1 (commencing with Section 4880) of Chapter 4 of Division 1.6 applicable to mergers between California state banks shall apply to the merger.
(d)Except as otherwise specified in Section 11101, only a credit union licensed to provide services to cannabis businesses may merge with one or more credit unions licensed to provide services to cannabis businesses. The provisions of Article 1 (commencing with Section 15200) of Chapter 9 of Division 5 shall apply to the merger.
(e)Except as otherwise specified in Section 11101, a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall not be eligible to convert to a federal bank or federal credit union or to another type of business entity.
6.Operative Conditions11101.(a)This division shall become inoperative if either of the following occurs, whichever occurs first:
(1)The federal government, by legislative or executive action, removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the schedule of controlled substances, as defined in the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 812; 21 C.F.R. 1308).
(2)The federal government enacts legislation that establishes protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
(b)Within 30 days of the occurrence of either event set forth in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a), the department shall do both of the following:
(1)Post notice of that occurrence on the homepage of its internet website, and send notice to both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel. The notice shall specify the date that this division shall become inoperative, which shall be one calendar year following the effective date of the events specified in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).
(2)Provide guidance for the orderly resolution of all cannabis limited charter banks or credit unions licensed pursuant to this division. The resolution may involve, but is not limited to, conversion to a state bank pursuant to Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000), conversion to a state voluntary liquidation of a cannabis limited charter bank pursuant to Division 1 (commencing with Section 99) the merger, dissolution, or conversion of a cannabis limited charter credit union pursuant to Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000), or a sale, merger, or conversion of a cannabis limited charter bank pursuant to Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800).
(c)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall have up to one calendar year to orderly resolve in a manner acceptable to applicable state and federal regulators.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (c), a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall comply with all applicable sections of this code and the Corporations Code regarding filings with the Secretary of State.
(e)If an existing cannabis limited charter bank or credit union licensed pursuant to this division fails in good faith to comply with subdivision (c), the department may take any action under this code it deems necessary, including signing documents on behalf of the cannabis limited charter bank or credit union, to carry out the purposes of this section.
SEC. 8.SEC. 9.Section 14001.1 of the Financial Code is amended to read:14001.1.This division is applicable to any person, other than a federal credit union engaging in the business of a credit union in this state. For purposes of this division, person shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5065 of the Corporations Code. This division is also is applicable to any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union that elects to form under this division to engage in providing credit union services to cannabis businesses except to the extent that the provisions of this division are inconsistent with Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
SEC. 10.Section 14101 of the Financial Code is amended to read:14101.The articles of incorporation of every credit union shall set forth the following:
(a)The name of the corporation, which shall include the phrase credit union.
(b)(1)The following statement:
The purpose of the corporation is to engage in credit union business and any other lawful activities which are not prohibited to a credit union by applicable laws or regulations.
(2)In the case of a corporation formed under this part that is subject to the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law, in addition to the statement required under paragraph (1), the articles shall set forth a statement that the specific purpose of the corporation is to engage in providing limited credit union services to cannabis businesses under Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000). This paragraph shall become inoperative if Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000) becomes inoperative pursuant to Section 11101.
(2)(3)By December 31, 2003, each credit union that immediately prior to the enactment of this section was authorized to operate as a credit union shall amend its articles to comply with the provisions of paragraph (1). Notwithstanding Section 7813.5 of the Corporations Code, the amendment of the articles of a credit union as required by paragraph (1) may be adopted by approval of the board alone.
(c)The name and street address in this state of the corporations initial agent for service of process in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 8210 of the Corporations Code.
(d)The names and addresses of five or more persons appointed to act as initial directors.
(e)The street address of the corporation.
(f)The mailing address of the corporation, if different from the street address.
SEC. 9.SEC. 11.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 10.SEC. 12.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to eliminate public safety issues presented with managing and transporting cash because of the lack of access to financial services for cannabis businesses, to enable state and local governments to accurately perform accounting and other regulatory functions over the cannabis industry, and to enable cannabis businesses to comply with laws regulating the cannabis industry, it is necessary that this bill take effect immediately.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 5.The Legislature finds and declares:
(a)In November 2016, California voters passed Proposition 64, the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act, authorizing recreational use of marijuana subject to specified limits. Medicinal cannabis use has been legal under California law since 1996 with the passage of Proposition 215, the Compassionate Use Act of 1996.
(b)Since 1996, a network of producers, distributors, and dispensaries have developed in California to serve the needs of the medical cannabis community. All of these businesses are expected to expand, and new businesses are expected to join them, in order to serve recreational cannabis users.
(c)Cannabis remains illegal under federal law. The United States Drug Enforcement Administration classifies cannabis as a Schedule I drug. As a result, the majority of financial institutions that take deposits, including banks, thrifts, and credit unions, do not serve cannabis businesses. This status precludes cannabis-related businesses from depositing income in, or engaging in other banking-related activities with, federally insured and regulated financial institutions and from using a federal clearinghouse to process their payments.
(d)Since most financial institutions will not serve cannabis businesses because of the conflict of federal law with state law, these businesses are unable to open and use checking accounts, make or receive electronic payments, or accept credit or debit cards.
(e)While income from the sale of cannabis products is considered ill-gotten gains by the federal government, that income is still taxable. The Internal Revenue Service specifically states in Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income, that (i)llegal income, such as money from dealing illegal drugs, must be included in your income on Form 1040, line 21, or on Schedule C or Schedule C-EZ (Form 1040) if from your self-employment activity.
(f)The need for banking services for the cannabis industry is at an all-time high, given that the industry is now expected to generate more than $8,000,000,000 in revenue annually.
(g)The lack of banking services has created both regulatory and public safety issues. State and local governments must be able to audit and perform accounting and other accountability functions affecting cannabis-related businesses. This is made significantly more difficult when the majority of transactions are completed with cash.
(h)With financial services unavailable to cannabis businesses, these businesses are less able to pay taxes and follow California regulations governing cannabis.
(i)Additionally, the lack of access to financial services has created public safety issues for businesses that need to pay high security costs to safeguard their income and their employees, who risk being robbed when managing and transporting cash.
(j)California voters have spoken in support of the new cannabis laws. Without a change in law regarding financial services, businesses providing services that are lawful under state law may elect to remain underground and not become regulated, tax-paying California businesses, as the voters intended.
(k)In furtherance of the will of the voters, the California government has a responsibility to enact appropriate implementing legislation for Proposition 64. The current conflict with federal law creates a significant problem requiring legislative attention. The state has a duty to provide a mechanism to help these lawful businesses to gain access to banking services that is consistent with the will of California voters.
SEC. 2.Section 99 of the Financial Code is amended to read:99.This division, Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000), Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000), Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000), Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000), Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000), and Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000) shall be known, and may be cited, as the Financial Institutions Law.
SEC. 3.Section 185 of the Financial Code is amended to read:185.Licensee has the following meanings:
(a)Any bank authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact banking or trust business.
(b)Any industrial bank authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact industrial banking business.
(c)Any trust company authorized by the commissioner pursuant to Section 1042 to transact trust business.
(d)Any foreign (other nation) bank that is licensed under Article 2 (commencing with Section 1780) of Chapter 20 or under Article 3 (commencing with Section 1800) of Chapter 20.
(e)Any person licensed by the commissioner as a money transmitter pursuant to Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000).
(f)Any person authorized by the commissioner to conduct the business of a savings association pursuant to Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000).
(g)Any credit union authorized by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Section 14154.
(h)Any foreign (other state) credit union licensed by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 16000) of Division 5.
(i)Any foreign (other nation) credit union licensed by the commissioner to conduct business pursuant to Chapter 12 (commencing with Section 16500) of Division 5.
(j)Any industrial loan company authorized by the commissioner to conduct insurance premium finance business pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000).
(k)Any corporation licensed by the commissioner as a business and industrial development corporation pursuant to Section 31154.
(l)Any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union authorized by the commissioner to conduct banking services pursuant to Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
SEC. 4.Section 301 of the Financial Code is amended to read:301.(a) This chapter is applicable to this division, Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000), Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000), Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000), Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000), and Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000).
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), this article, and Articles 2 (commencing with Section 320) and 3 (commencing with Section 350) are applicable to the administration of laws by the Division of Corporations.
(c)Sections 329, 330, 332, 335, 336, 357, 378, 379, and 381 are not applicable to the Division of Corporations.
SEC. 5.Section 329 of the Financial Code is amended to read:329.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Applicable law means:
(A)With respect to any bank, Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800), and any of the following provisions:
(i)Article 6 (commencing with Section 405) of Chapter 3.
(ii)Article 3 (commencing with Section 1130) of Chapter 5 of Division 1.1.
(iii)Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 1200) of Division 1.1.
(iv)Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1320) of Division 1.1.
(v)Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 1460) of Division 1.1.
(vi)Article 1 (commencing with Section 1530) of Chapter 15 of Division 1.1.
(vii)Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 1550) of Division 1.1.
(viii)Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 1750) of Division 1.1.
(ix)Section 456.
(x)Section 457.
(xi)Section 459.
(xii)Section 460.
(xiii)Section 461.
(xiv)Section 1331.
(xv)Chapter 21 (commencing with Section 1850) of Division 1.1.
(xvi)Chapter 18 (commencing with Section 1660) of Division 1.1.
(xvii)Chapter 19 (commencing with Section 1670) of Division 1.1.
(B)With respect to any savings association, any provision of Division 1.6 (commencing with Section 4800) and Division 2 (commencing with Section 5000).
(C)With respect to any insurance premium finance agency, any provision of Division 7 (commencing with Section 18000).
(D)With respect to any business and industrial development corporation, any provision of Division 15 (commencing with Section 31000).
(E)With respect to any credit union, any of the following provisions:
(i)Section 14252.
(ii)Section 14253.
(iii)Section 14255.
(iv)Article 4 (commencing with Section 14350) of Chapter 3 of Division 5.
(v)Section 14401.
(vi)Section 14404.
(vii)Section 14408, only as that section applies to gifts to directors, volunteers, and employees, and the related family or business interests of the directors, volunteers, and employees.
(viii)Section 14409.
(ix)Section 14410.
(x)Article 5 (commencing with Section 14600) of Chapter 4 of Division 5.
(xi)Article 6 (commencing with Section 14650) of Chapter 4 of Division 5, excluding subdivision (a) of Section 14651.
(xii)Section 14803.
(xiii)Section 14851.
(xiv)Section 14858.
(xv)Section 14860.
(xvi)Section 14861.
(xvii)Section 14863.
(F)With respect to any money transmitter, any provision of Division 1.2 (commencing with Section 2000).
(G)With respect to any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union, any provision of Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
(2)Licensee means any bank, savings association, credit union, trust company, cannabis limited charter bank or credit union, money transmitter, insurance premium finance agency, or business and industrial development corporation that is authorized by the commissioner to conduct business in this state.
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of this code that applies to a licensee or a subsidiary of a licensee, after notice and an opportunity to be heard, the commissioner may, by order that shall include findings of fact which incorporates a determination made in accordance with subdivision (e), levy civil penalties against any licensee or any subsidiary of a licensee who has violated any provision of applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary of the licensee, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner. The commissioner shall have the sole authority to bring any action with respect to a violation of applicable law subject to a penalty imposed under this section.
Except as provided in paragraphs (1) and (2), any penalty imposed by the commissioner may not exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) a per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in any one action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000).
(1)If the commissioner determines that any licensee or subsidiary of the licensee has recklessly violated any applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any provision of any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner, the commissioner may impose a penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000) per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in an action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000).
(2)If the commissioner determines that any licensee or subsidiary of the licensee has knowingly violated any applicable law, any order issued by the commissioner, any provision of any written agreement between the commissioner and the licensee or subsidiary, or any condition of any approval issued by the commissioner, the commissioner may impose a penalty not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per day, provided that the aggregate penalty of all offenses in an action against any licensee or subsidiary of a licensee shall not exceed 1 percent of the total assets of the licensee or subsidiary of a licensee subject to the penalty.
(c)Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from pursuing any other administrative action allowed by law.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from bringing an action in court to enforce any law or order he or she has issued, including orders issued under this section. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impair or impede the commissioner from seeking any other damages or injunction allowed by law.
(e)In determining the amount and the appropriateness of initiating a civil money penalty under subdivision (b), the commissioner shall consider all of the following:
(1)Evidence that the violation or practice or breach of duty was intentional or was committed with a disregard of the law or with a disregard of the consequences to the institution.
(2)The duration and frequency of the violations, practices, or breaches of duties.
(3)The continuation of the violations, practices, or breaches of duty after the licensee or subsidiary of the licensee was notified, or, alternatively, its immediate cessation and correction.
(4)The failure to cooperate with the commissioner in effecting early resolution of the problem.
(5)Evidence of concealment of the violation, practice, or breach of duty or, alternatively, voluntary disclosure of the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(6)Any threat of loss, actual loss, or other harm to the institution, including harm to the public confidence in the institution, and the degree of that harm.
(7)Evidence that a licensee or subsidiary of a licensee received financial gain or other benefit as a result of the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(8)Evidence of any restitution paid by a licensee or subsidiary of a licensee of losses resulting from the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(9)History of prior violations, practices, or breaches of duty, particularly where they are similar to the actions under consideration.
(10)Previous criticism of the institution for similar actions.
(11)Presence or absence of a compliance program and its effectiveness.
(12)Tendency to engage in violations of law, unsafe or unsound financial institutions practices, or breaches of duties.
(13)The existence of agreements, commitments, orders, or conditions imposed in writing intended to prevent the violation, practice, or breach of duty.
(14)Whether the violation, practice, or breach of duty causes quantifiable, economic benefit or loss to the licensee or the subsidiary of the licensee. In those cases, removal of the benefit or recompense of the loss usually will be insufficient, by itself, to promote compliance with the applicable law, order, or written agreement. The penalty amount should reflect a remedial purpose and should provide a deterrent to future misconduct.
(15)Other factors as the commissioner may, in his or her opinion, consider relevant to assessing the penalty or establishing the amount of the penalty.
(f)The amounts collected under this section shall be deposited in the appropriate fund of the department. For purposes of this subdivision, the term appropriate fund means the fund to which the annual assessments of fined licensees, or the parent licensee of the fined subsidiary, are credited.
SEC. 6.Section 1003 of the Financial Code is amended to read:1003.Except where explicitly stated or the context provides otherwise, this division is applicable to the following:
(a)All corporations engaging in commercial banking, industrial banking, or the trust business.
(b)All national banking associations authorized to transact business in this state to the extent that the provisions of this division are not inconsistent with and do not infringe paramount federal laws governing national banking associations.
(c)All cannabis limited charter banks or credit unions that elect to form under this division to the extent that the provisions of this division are not inconsistent with Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
(c)(d)All other corporations that subject themselves to the special provisions and sections of this division.
(d)(e)All other persons, associations, copartnerships, or corporations who, by violating any of its provisions, become subject to the penalties provided for in this division.
SEC. 7.Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000) is added to the Financial Code, to read:2.5.Cannabis Limited Charter Banking And Credit Union Law1.General Provisions1.Short Title and Construction11000.This division is known, and may be cited, as the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law.
2.Definitions11005.For purposes of this chapter:
(a)Applicant means a person or entity that submits an application to be licensed by the state to provide banking services to a cannabis business pursuant to this division.
(b)Banking services means the provision of depository services with respect to cash or other funds and the issuance and acceptance of special purpose checks, including the acceptance and maintenance of deposit proceeds, consistent with the requirements and limitations provided by this chapter.
(c)Board means the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board.
(d)Cannabis business means a person licensed to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 (commencing with Section 26000) of the Business and Professions Code. The term cannabis business also includes an ancillary business or profession that serves a person licensed to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 (commencing with Section 26000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)Cannabis limited charter bank or credit union means a person that receives a license following the approval of an application pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 11040).
(f)Commissioner means the Commissioner of Business Oversight.
(g)Department means the Department of Business Oversight.
(h)Licensee means a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union.
2.Administration1.The Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board11010.(a)There is hereby created the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board. The board shall be comprised of the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control. The Director of Finance shall serve as an ex officio, nonvoting member. Board members shall not be compensated for their services.
(b)The board shall be generally responsible for ensuring that the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law provides a safe and efficient way to pay state and local taxes and fees, to pay rent associated with the account holders cannabis business, to issue special purpose checks, and legally invest in Californias economy, while reducing burdens placed on local government that result from collecting and managing large sums of cash.
11011.In light of the particular challenges arising from cannabis business activities, the department shall submit reports of enforcement activities to the board for review annually or as the board may require. The board shall meet once a year, or more often as needed, at the boards discretion, to review enforcement activity reports from the department. These meetings shall be noticed and open to public comment. The board shall evaluate the reports and the comments of the public and draft recommended actions to be taken legislatively or administratively, which shall be submitted to the Legislature and Governor. Recommendations provided to the Legislature shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
11012.The board shall provide guidance and education to registered broker-dealers and licensed investment advisors on how to accommodate account holders of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions in purchasing, holding, and selling any of the investments described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 11050.
2.Licensing11020.(a)A person may act as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union after obtaining a license pursuant to this division.
(b)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license is not transferable or assignable.
11021.A licensee shall comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law (Division 1 (commencing with Section 99)) and either the Banking Law (Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000)) or the California Credit Union Law (Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000)), as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of those laws are inconsistent with a provision of this division, in which case the provisions of this division shall prevail.
11025.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act (commencing with 31 U.S.C. Sec. 5311) and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
11026.The department shall adopt emergency regulations pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code to implement this division. The adoption of these regulations is deemed to be an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety.
11027.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (c), the department shall not issue a license under this chapter before July 1, 2020.
(b)On or before June 30, 2020, the department shall report to the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance regarding the status of the regulations and the implementation of this chapter.
(c)Notwithstanding (a), the department may issue a license under this chapter before July 1, 2020, if the following conditions are met:
(1)The regulations required by Section 11026 have been adopted.
(2)The report required by subdivision (b) has been received by the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
(3)The Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance have met in an open and public meeting to consider the report required by subdivision (b).
(4)The Commissioner of Business Oversight makes a written finding that the requirements of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, have been met and the department is prepared to issue licenses, consistent with the regulations required by Section 11026, and posts the written finding on the departments Internet Web site.
3.Application11040.An applicant that desires to be licensed to act as a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this division shall submit a completed application to the department in a form prescribed by the commissioner that satisfies the requirements of this chapter. An applicant that desires to be licensed to act as a limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this division shall elect to form under either the Banking Law (Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000)) or the California Credit Union Law (Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000)), and shall comply with all requirements imposed by those laws, as applicable, except to the extent any requirement of those laws is inconsistent with the provisions of this chapter.
11042.The department may charge an applicant a reasonable fee for a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union license, not to exceed the costs of regulation.
4.Authorizations11050.(a)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may issue to an account holder special purpose checks that shall be valid for only the purposes specified in subdivision (b). The following text shall be printed on each check in at least 12-point type, with the name of the issuing bank included: This check is issued by [insert name of bank] and may only be deposited or cashed at this cannabis limited charter bank or credit union or another cannabis limited charter bank or credit union that agrees to accept the check.
(b)Subject to the limitations of subdivision (d), a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may only be used for the following purposes:
(1)To pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
(2)To pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holders cannabis business.
(3)To pay a vendor that is physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the account holders cannabis business.
(4)To purchase the following:
(A)Bonds, interest-bearing notes, or interest-bearing warrants of this state for which the faith and credit of this state are pledged for the payment of principal and interest.
(B)Bonds or warrants, including, but not limited to, revenue warrants, of any county, city, metropolitan water district, California water district, California water storage district, irrigation district in the state, municipal utility district, or school district of this state.
(c)Subject to the limitations of subdivision (d), state and local government offices are authorized to accept a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union.
(d)An individual or entity, private or public, is not required to accept a special purpose check issued by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this section.
(e)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union is authorized to cash a special purpose check presented to it by a person or entity that is not an account holder, if that limited charter bank or credit union previously issued that special purpose check to an account holder, and the check was used for one of the authorized purposes specified in subdivision (b).
11052.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall obtain and maintain private insurance in an amount acceptable to the commissioner for the cannabis depository institution and its assets at all times while it is engaged in banking services. Private insurance shall not be unsatisfactory to the commissioner. In seeking and retaining private insurance, a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may do all things and assume and discharge all obligations required of it that are not in conflict with state law.
11054.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may enter into an agreement with one or more other limited charter licensees in order to form a banking network. That agreement shall be subject to the approval of the commissioner. The network shall be for the purpose of assisting each other in providing services to cannabis businesses and each other. A network of this type shall not include any institution that is not a licensee under this division.
11056.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may provide accounts to people and entities other than cannabis businesses, pursuant to rules that may be adopted by the commissioner.
11058.A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union may charge fees for the banking services that it provides. Each cannabis limited charter bank and credit union shall provide to the commissioner a fee schedule, listing the types and sizes of fees it charges for the services it provides. The department shall compile the information provided to it pursuant to this section and shall post that information on its Internet Web site in a format intended to provide transparency. The commissioner may, if requested by any person or whenever the commissioner deems appropriate, review any fee charged by a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union pursuant to this section.
5.Prohibited Practices11100.(a)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall not engage in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter issued under this division.
(b)A cannabis limited charter bank or credit union shall not engage in any activity under Division 1.1 (commencing with Section 1000) or Division 5 (commencing with Section 14000) other than activity required to accept deposits and perform actions described in Chapter 4.
SEC. 8.Section 14001.1 of the Financial Code is amended to read:14001.1.This division is applicable to any person, other than a federal credit union engaging in the business of a credit union in this state. For purposes of this division, person shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5065 of the Corporations Code. This division is also applicable to any cannabis limited charter bank or credit union that elects to form under this division except to the extent that the provisions of this division are inconsistent with Division 2.5 (commencing with Section 11000).
SEC. 9.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (August 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Calderon. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 24). Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 13, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F. and B. & P. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 35. Noes 1.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 24). |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 3). Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & F.I. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | April 10 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 8, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F.I. and GOV. & F. |
| Jan 7, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Dec 5, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 4. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Business and Professions] | Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB51 Hertzberg et al. Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 31, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:August 30, 2020
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows a taxpayer to receive its California Competes Tax Credit (CCTC) as a refund if the taxpayer meets specified job creation goals and reinvests the refund in certain capital equipment for media production facilities. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a taxpayer that has created at least 5,000 prevailing wage, full-time or full-time equivalent jobs each year for 10 years (qualified taxpayer) to receive its CCTC as a refund from the Tax Relief and Refund Account. This refund cannot exceed the amount of “total taxes” imposed by the state and paid by the qualified taxpayer during the taxable year.
- Requires a qualified taxpayer who receives the CCTC as a refund to reinvest the refund into immobile capital equipment that supports infrastructure improvements, expansion or developments for media production facilities in California.
- Prohibits a qualified taxpayer from reinvesting a CCTC refund for the improvement of immobile capital equipment unless the improvements are made under a project labor agreement and using a skilled and trained workforce.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Additional cost pressures to expand the CCTC program. This bill does not increase the overall amount of credits the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) may allocate each year. However, this bill will pressure the Legislature to expand the program because it creates a more flexible refundable credit for certain firms.
- Possible accelerated General Fund revenue loss of millions of dollars in the year a qualified taxpayer receives a refund from the Tax Relief and Refund Account. Under current law, the timing of the revenue loss associated with each CCTC agreement depends on whether the taxpayer carries over unused credit amounts into future years. This bill could accelerate revenue losses by allowing a qualified taxpayer to receive a refund of the remaining credit amount instead of carrying over unused credit amounts into future years.
- One-time modest administrative costs to GO-Biz to make application changes and modify the existing review processes and checklist.
- Unknown costs to FTB to develop regulations and implement a process to determine refund amounts for a qualified taxpayer.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The CCTC program provides tax benefits to businesses in exchange for meeting contractual hiring and investment targets. Current law allows up to $180 million in annual credits. The CCTC is a nonrefundable income tax credit, meaning that if the credit amount exceeds a taxpayer’s liability, the taxpayer must carry over remaining amounts to offset future tax liability. GO-Biz administers the CCTC program and reviews submitted applications, and GO-Biz typically first scores applications based on the requested credit amounts and the investment and hiring goal. A company with a tax credit agreement can only claim the credit after it has met its agreed-upon hiring and investment goals. Credit amounts can range from the tens of thousands of dollars to the tens of millions.
- How would this bill work? This bill allows a qualified taxpayer to receive its CCTC as a refund against any state taxes paid. In theory, this bill could allow a taxpayer with little-to-no income tax liabilities but significant other state tax liabilities to benefit from the CCTC program in a way it currently cannot. This bill does not change the underlying CCTC process: GO-Biz would process the credit application and determine the credit amount. Once that credit agreement is reached and once the taxpayer can claim the credit, FTB would determine the refund amount.
- Staff comments. This bill creates a new business refundable CCTC for qualified firms. Remaining questions and issues include:
- Hiring requirements lack detail. This bill requires a taxpayer to have created 5,000 jobs each year over 10 years. However, as the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation notes in its analysis, this bill’s drafting allows the CCTC applicant to count in its application any employees who are fired and then re-hired as well as employees already hired, thereby providing a “windfall” benefit to the applicant. The author plans to submit a Letter to the Senate Daily Journal to clarify that a taxpayer must prospectively create 5,000 new jobs each year for a period of ten years.
- Lack of definition of “total taxes.” This bill limits the refund to the amount of total taxes imposed by the state and paid by the taxpayer in the taxable year when the refund is claimed. This bill does not define “total taxes,” which could include tax programs administered by FTB, the Employment Development Department (EDD) and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA). Moreover, this bill does not explicitly allow the sharing of taxpayer information between various departments, which may make it difficult to ensure compliance.
- Purpose. According to supporters, this bill “will make California Competes more workable and attractive to film and television companies that commit to investing in jobs over the next ten years.”
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: August 30, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:August 30, 2020
2/3 vote. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 36-1
SUBJECT: California Competes tax credit: refunds.
SUMMARY: Provides a refundable California Competes Tax Credit (CCTC) for a very narrow group of qualified taxpayers. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2021, that a qualified taxpayer, to the extent the credit exceeds tax liability, may elect to be paid a refund for the CCTC from the Tax Relief and Refund Account. The amount refunded shall not exceed the amount of total taxes imposed by the state and paid by the qualified taxpayer during the taxable year.
- Requires the qualified taxpayer to, upon request, provide necessary information, including certification from Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) that the taxpayer is a qualified taxpayer, as determined by and in the form and manner prescribed by the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), to be eligible for a refund of the credit.
- Requires a qualified taxpayer that receives a refund to reinvest the refund into immobile capital equipment that supports infrastructure improvements, expansion, or developments for media production facilities in the state.
- Provides that a qualified taxpayer may not reinvest refunds for the improvement of immobile capital equipment unless the improvements are made under a project labor agreement and using a skilled and trained workforce.
- Defines a "qualified taxpayer" as a taxpayer that has created at least 5,000 prevailing wage, full-time or full-time equivalent jobs in the state each year for a period of 10 years.
- Defines "full-time equivalent" as the workload of the full-time equivalent job that is comparable to one year of full-time work. One year of full-time work is measurable by the number of hours worked in one year, or by total wages paid in one year for the industry divided by the average annual salary.
- Defines "immobile capital equipment" in the same manner as defined in the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 1250(c).
- Defines "project labor agreement" in the same manner as defined in the Public Contract Code Section 2500(b)(1).
- Defines "skilled and trained workforce" in the same manner as defined in the Public Contract Code Section 2500 et seq.
- Provides that the FTB may prescribe any regulations necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of this bill, including any regulations to prevent improper claims from being filed or improper payments from being made with respect to the refund of the credit. The FTB is also authorized to prescribe rules, guidance, and procedures, or other guidance to carry out the purposes of this bill.
EXISTING LAW establishes the CCTC for the purpose of awarding individually negotiated tax credits to businesses that operate in California. The amount of the award is based on a number of conditions, including, but not limited to, the number of jobs being created, the compensation-level of employees, the amount of investments made, and the location of the project or business. Priority is provided to projects and businesses located in high unemployment and high poverty areas.
FISCAL EFFECT: Pending
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
California must support proven and successful job creation tools. This means investing in full-time jobs with quality wages and benefits. The [CCTC] has been a meaningful tool to incentivize investment in good jobs while keeping companies accountable to their job commitment promises.
SB 51 will allow the [CCTC] program to continue to catalyze critical investments in California that create thousands of high-wage jobs by providing additional flexibility for businesses participating in the CCTC program. The bill will allow CCTC awardees to apply part or all of that award to additional tax offsets (not exceeding total state tax liability) provided they make a long-term, high-wage job creation and economic investment commitment within our state.
- Supporters state that this bill "will allow the California Competes credit awards to be utilized more broadly to offset other California taxes provided that the taxpayer makes a significant financial commitment to long term jobs by creating 5000 full-time equivalent (prevailing wage) jobs per year." Additionally, supporters argue that this bill "will make California Competes more workable and attractive to film and television companies that commit to investing in jobs over the next ten years. In addition, this bill provides a refund, under certain circumstances, and that refund must be reinvested in projects that work under a project labor agreement."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: In 2013, the Legislature enacted AB 93 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 69, Statutes of 2013, and SB 90 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 70, Statutes of 2013, measures which reformed California's economic development policies by eliminating enterprise zones and other geographically-targeted economic development areas, instead allowing three new tax benefits:
- The New Employment Credit, where the FTB allocates credits for wages paid by taxpayers to qualified employees within former enterprise zones, and other areas that suffer from high levels of poverty and unemployment. The credit lasts from the 2014 taxable year until the 2019 taxable year. The Legislature extended the credit until 2026 [SB 855 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 52, Statutes of 2018].
- The CCTC Committee can award the CCTC up to an annually capped amount to taxpayers who apply. The Committee is comprised of the Treasurer, the Director of Finance, the Director of GO-Biz, one appointee of the Speaker of the Assembly, and one appointee from the Senate Committee on Rules. SB 855 also extended the Committee's authority to allocate $180 million in credits each year through the 2022-23 fiscal year.
- A state-only (3.9375%) sales and use tax exemption on purchases of manufacturing equipment made by taxpayers within specific North American Industrial Classification System codes, capped at $200 million annually per taxpayer, effective July 1, 2014, and ending July 1, 2022. In 2017, the Legislature expanded and extended this exemption, as part of an agreement to extend the Global Warming Solutions Act [AB 398 (E. Garcia), Chapter 135, Statutes of 2017].
- Background: In 2013, the Legislature enacted AB 93 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 69, Statutes of 2013, and SB 90 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 70, Statutes of 2013, measures which reformed California's economic development policies by eliminating enterprise zones and other geographically-targeted economic development areas, instead allowing three new tax benefits:
The CCTC Committee is responsible for awarding the Competes Credit to businesses. The CCTC program provides tax benefits to select businesses in exchange for meeting contractual hiring and investment targets. Businesses may claim the tax credit only if they meet negotiated targets set forth in written agreements with GO-Biz. Up to $780 million in CCTC awards are available in total between fiscal year (FY) 2013-14 and 2017-18 ($30 million in year one, $150 million in year two, and $200 million per year in each of the following three years). For FYs 2018-19 through 2022-23, the annual awards are limited to $180 million. The amounts are adjusted depending on whether amounts had not been awarded in prior years or if amounts were recaptured.
To receive a credit, taxpayers must first apply during one of the application periods. There are usually three application periods per FY. According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, over 3,000 applications have been submitted between the start of the program and June 2017, with an average of about 300 applications per application period. Once the applications are submitted, GO-Biz evaluates the applications in two phases. In the first phase, the applications are scored and ranked based only on the amount of tax credit that the business has requested and the total dollar value of their proposed hiring and investments over five years. An applicant that requests a smaller tax credit, relative to the proposed amount of hiring and investment, receives a higher score. Only the highest scoring applicants move on to the second phase. However, firms that would expand in a high-unemployment or high-poverty city or county automatically move on to the second phase. In the second phase, GO-Biz reviews all of the other information that the applicants have provided. State law requires GO-Biz to base the amount of the tax credit award on several factors, such as the extent of unemployment or poverty in the area where the project would be located and other state or local incentives available to the applicant. In addition, GO-Biz may consider other factors in determining whether to award a tax credit. GO-Biz maintains a great deal of discretion when evaluating applications.
- What does this bill do? This bill, in general, allows a qualified taxpayer to receive a refund from the Tax Relief and Refund Account to the extent the CCTC exceeds tax liability. However, the refund may not exceed the amount of total taxes imposed by the state and paid by the qualified taxpayer during the taxable year. Because the refund may not exceed the total tax paid by the qualified taxpayer, it is not a typical "refundable tax credit," but is a refund for taxes paid. This bill would require the taxpayer to reinvest the refund into immobile capital equipment that supports infrastructure improvements, expansion, or developments for media production facilities in the state.
- Who's getting the special treatment? This bill defines a "qualified taxpayer" as a taxpayer that has created at least 5,000 prevailing wage, full-time or full-time equivalent jobs in the state each year for a period of 10 years. Clearly, a taxpayer that falls within this definition is likely to be a very large company. Looking through the CalCompetes Awardee list, Tesla's application has the highest net increase in full-time employees at 4,426 for a single agreement. Second on the list is FN Logistics with 3,039 full-time employees. However, a qualified taxpayer would also be required to reinvest the refund into immobile capital equipment that supports infrastructure for media production facilities in the state, which means that even some of the larger awardees may not be able to take advantage of the credit unless they are engaged in media production. Although there is no definition for “media production”, some of the larger past awardees in this industry have included NBC Universal, Dreamworks Animation, Hulu, and Amazon. If media production companies are the ones that this bill is targeting, it may be more appropriate to modify the California Film Tax Credit instead of modifying the CCTC. Additionally, it is not clear why companies engaged in media production receive special treatment. As mentioned above, Tesla has promised to make a substantial investment in California as well as promised to hire over 4,000 employees, but will likely not benefit from this bill. If the goal, as stated by the author, is to "support proven and successful job creation tools," perhaps the refundability of the CCTC should be provided to all awardees that promise to hire a large number of employees.
- What taxes is this bill offsetting? The refund available to a qualified taxpayer is limited to the amount of total taxes imposed by the state and paid by the qualified taxpayer during the taxable year. This bill does not define "total taxes"; as such, the taxes allowed to be offset by this bill is not clear. Obviously, "total taxes" likely includes those taxes other than the Personal Income Tax Law and the Corporation Tax Law, or a taxpayer would not be able to receive a refund. Hypothetically, these other taxes may include the sales taxes, but it is unclear if it would also include property taxes or payroll taxes since those may not be "imposed by the state." Assuming other taxes may be offset by this bill, it may be difficult for FTB and GO-Biz to ensure compliance without legislation allowing the sharing of taxpayer information between various departments. The author may wish to specify which taxes may be offset by the CCTC to prevent confusion and delay.
- Windfall? The author's office states this bill focuses on businesses "willing to commit to and create a significant number of new prevailing wage jobs for the next 10 years." Unfortunately, this bill does not actually require a company to hire 50,000 new employees. The only requirement is that a company must have created, at some unknown point and time frame, 5,000 jobs per year for 10 years. Additionally, there is nothing preventing a company from firing those 5,000 employees and rehiring them the following year since there is no net-increase requirement for employment. In an industry like media production, where some jobs are for a short period of time, it is not uncommon for workers to be brought on and then let go over the course of several years. To ensure that the state receives a benefit for refunding a portion of the taxpayer's paid taxes, the author may wish to clarify that the hiring of 5,000 workers is prospective and cumulative.
Finally, the requirement that a refund be used to invest in immobile capital equipment may not actually provide the state with new economic activity. As an example, if NBC Universal qualified for a refundable CCTC as provided by this bill, it is likely that the immobile capital equipment requirement will be satisfied by NBC Universal's existing agreement to invest $36 million in the 2022 tax year and $96 million in the 2023 tax year[1]. As such, the state may be providing additional funds to companies without receiving any additional economic benefit.
- Lack of specificity: This bill requires a qualified taxpayer to reinvest refunded amounts into immobile capital equipment that supports infrastructure improvements, expansion, or developments for media production facilities in the state. Unfortunately, the accompanying definitions provide little guidance with respect to what would qualify as “immobile capital equipment”. The definition in this bill for "immobile capital equipment" basically states that a property qualifies so long as it can be depreciated[2]. Furthermore, the immobile capital has to support infrastructure improvements, expansion, or developments for media production facilities in the state, but no definition for "media production facilities" is provided. Without a clearer guidance, it becomes very difficult for the FTB or GO-Biz to effectuate the intent of this bill and also makes it very difficult for FTB and GO-Biz to ensure compliance.
- What is a "Tax Expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, United States Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures," since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each of them (in the form of forgone revenues). This bill would expand an existing tax expenditure program by allowing the CCTC to be made refundable for a narrow class of taxpayers, and by allowing the CCTC to offset unknown state taxes.
- Committee’s tax expenditure policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. AB 263 (Burke), Chapter 743, Statutes of 2019, extended the requirements in R&TC Section 41 to all tax expenditure measures under the PIT Law, the CT Law, and the Sales and Use Tax Law introduced on or after January 1, 2020. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. This bill is subject to this Committee's tax expenditure policy because it expands the existing CCTC. Unfortunately, this bill is not in compliance because it does not outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote[3]. Sunsets are required because eliminating a tax expenditure generally requires a 2/3rd vote. It may be argued that the sunset of 2022-23 on the CCTC Committee's authority to allocate the CCTC functions as a sunset. However, the credit itself does not sunset until 2030. After discussing the language with Legislative Counsel, it is unclear if eliminating the refundability portion of this bill would trigger a 2/3rd vote, even if done after the 2022-23 FY ends. Although it is not clear, this bill should arguably contain a five-year sunset to allow the Legislature an opportunity to review the effectiveness of the credit.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Entertainment Union Coalition
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2019
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
Provides for the licensure and supervision of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions authorized to offer limited depository services to cannabis businesses.
Major Provisions
- Adds a new division within the Financial Institutions Law (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 11000 et seq.).
- Provides for the licensure of a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union (hereafter referred to as a "cannabis depository institution" or "CDI") by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and requires such licensees to comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of that law is inconsistent with the provisions of this bill, in which case the provisions of this bill would prevail.
- Requires a CDI to adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Authorizes a CDI to accept deposits and issue to an account holder special purpose checks that may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holder's cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to the account holder's cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or a local agency.
- Requires a CDI to obtain and maintain private insurance for itself and its assets, in an amount acceptable to DBO.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in banking activity (this bill does not define this term) with any financial institution that lacks a limited charter.
- Declares that in order to eliminate public safety issues presented with managing and transporting cash because of the lack of access to financial services for cannabis businesses, to enable state and local governments to accurately perform accounting and other regulatory functions over the cannabis industry, and to enable cannabis businesses to comply with laws regulating the cannabis industry, it is necessary that this bill take effect immediately.
- States the Legislature's intent that banks and other financial institutions support and maintain good faith relationships with banks doing business with properly licensed cannabis businesses in the state.
COMMENTS:
Federal law prevents some cannabis businesses from accessing financial services provided by banks and credit unions, including basic checking accounts and electronic payment services that nearly all business rely to facilitate transactions with their customers. Federal guidelines have provided comfort to several hundred banks and credit unions across the country to serve the cannabis industry; however, these financial institutions are doing so at their own risk of negative regulatory action and criminal prosecution.
Although some banks and credit unions accept the elevated legal risk and compliance costs to serve some cannabis businesses, some licensed cannabis businesses in California do not have access to banking services. Unbanked cannabis businesses transact primarily in cash, which makes the businesses and surrounding community targets for violent criminal activity. Cash businesses also present challenges to state and local tax collection and enforcement efforts.
This bill envisions a partial solution to the cannabis banking problem through the creation of cannabis depository institutions (CDIs). Upon approval by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) of a charter application, a CDI would be authorized to provide a very limited selection of services to its customers: the acceptance of deposits and the issuance and redemption of special purpose checks.
In order to achieve the vision of SB 930, the state government and the private sector would need to overcome significant challenges to deliver the public benefits that this bill seeks. These challenges include the availability of deposit insurance, frictions in getting cash in and out of a CDI, and developing an appropriate and comprehensive regulatory and supervision structure within DBO. These challenges are discussed in more detail in the Assembly Banking Committee analysis dated June 24, 2019.
According to the Author:
[Cannabis] is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses that cannot find a willing financial institution to accept their business have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue – businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession.
Arguments in Support:
Organizations that support the bill discuss the challenges faced by unbanked cannabis businesses and express support for finding solutions to the problem.
Arguments in Opposition:
Organizations in opposition state their concerns with the cannabis industry and desire to stop the commercial expansion of the cannabis industry.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing costs to DBO in the range of $2 million each year to adopt emergency regulations, process applications, conduct examinations and enforce the provisions of the bill. These cost estimates rely on optimistic assumptions that enough banks participate in the proposed closed loop system to make it viable. Costs would be lower to the extent the system never becomes operational, though DBO would still incur initial costs of developing regulations and program development. (Financial Institutions Fund, Credit Union Fund)
- Unknown, but likely modest costs for the Treasurer, Controller, and the chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control to participate in the Board and develop recommendations to the Legislature.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 36-1-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas
ASM BANKING AND FINANCE: 10-0-2
YES: Limón, Chen, Bauer-Kahan, Burke, Cervantes, Gabriel, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Choi, Melendez
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-1
YES: Low, Brough, Arambula, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Eggman, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-1-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Michael Burdick / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081 FN: 0001846
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
Provides for the licensure and supervision of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions authorized to offer limited depository services to cannabis businesses.
Major Provisions
- Adds a new division within the Financial Institutions Law (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 11000 et seq.).
- Provides for the licensure of a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union (hereafter referred to as a "cannabis depository institution" or "CDI") by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and requires such licensees to comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of that law is inconsistent with the provisions of this bill, in which case the provisions of this bill would prevail.
- Requires a CDI to adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Authorizes a CDI to accept deposits and issue to an account holder special purpose checks that may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holder's cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to the account holder's cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or a local agency.
- Requires a CDI to obtain and maintain private insurance for itself and its assets, in an amount acceptable to DBO.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in banking activity (this bill does not define this term) with any financial institution that lacks a limited charter.
- Declares that in order to eliminate public safety issues presented with managing and transporting cash because of the lack of access to financial services for cannabis businesses, to enable state and local governments to accurately perform accounting and other regulatory functions over the cannabis industry, and to enable cannabis businesses to comply with laws regulating the cannabis industry, it is necessary that this bill take effect immediately.
COMMENTS:
Federal law prevents some cannabis businesses from accessing financial services provided by banks and credit unions, including basic checking accounts and electronic payment services that nearly all business rely to facilitate transactions with their customers. Federal guidelines have provided comfort to several hundred banks and credit unions across the country to serve the cannabis industry; however, these financial institutions are doing so at their own risk of negative regulatory action and criminal prosecution.
Although some banks and credit unions accept the elevated legal risk and compliance costs to serve some cannabis businesses, some licensed cannabis businesses in California do not have access to banking services. Unbanked cannabis businesses transact primarily in cash, which makes the businesses and surrounding community targets for violent criminal activity. Cash businesses also present challenges to state and local tax collection and enforcement efforts.
This bill envisions a partial solution to the cannabis banking problem through the creation of cannabis depository institutions (CDIs). Upon approval by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) of a charter application, a CDI would be authorized to provide a very limited selection of services to its customers: the acceptance of deposits and the issuance and redemption of special purpose checks.
In order to achieve the vision of SB 930, the state government and the private sector would need to overcome significant challenges to deliver the public benefits that this bill seeks. These challenges include the availability of deposit insurance, frictions in getting cash in and out of a CDI, and developing an appropriate and comprehensive regulatory and supervision structure within DBO. These challenges are discussed in more detail in the Assembly Banking Committee analysis dated June 24, 2019.
According to the Author:
[Cannabis] is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses that cannot find a willing financial institution to accept their business have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue – businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession.
Arguments in Support:
Organizations that support the bill discuss the challenges faced by unbanked cannabis businesses and express support for finding solutions to the problem.
Arguments in Opposition:
Organizations in opposition state their concerns with the cannabis industry and desire to stop the commercial expansion of the cannabis industry.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing costs to DBO in the range of $2 million each year to adopt emergency regulations, process applications, conduct examinations and enforce the provisions of the bill. These cost estimates rely on optimistic assumptions that enough banks participate in the proposed closed loop system to make it viable. Costs would be lower to the extent the system never becomes operational, though DBO would still incur initial costs of developing regulations and program development. (Financial Institutions Fund, Credit Union Fund)
- Unknown, but likely modest costs for the Treasurer, Controller, and the chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control to participate in the Board and develop recommendations to the Legislature.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 36-1-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas
ASM BANKING AND FINANCE: 10-0-2
YES: Limón, Chen, Bauer-Kahan, Burke, Cervantes, Gabriel, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Choi, Melendez
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-1
YES: Low, Brough, Arambula, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Eggman, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-1-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 13, 2019
CONSULTANT: Michael Burdick / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081 FN: 0001596
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
Policy Committee: | Banking and Finance | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
Business and Professions | 18 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: Yes State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill enacts the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law to allow for the licensure and supervision of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions authorized to offer limited depository services to cannabis businesses. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) to license a cannabis depository institution (CDI) and authorizes a CDI to accept deposits and issue an account holder special purpose checks that may be used only for specified purposes.
- Authorizes state and local agencies to accept special purposes checks and specifies that no private or public entity is required to accept special purpose checks.
- Requires a CDI to obtain and maintain private insurance for itself and its assets and authorizes a CDI to enter into an agreement with other CDIs to form a banking network.
- Creates the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board (Board), comprised of the California State Treasurer, the California State Controller and the chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and requires DBO to submit to the board a report of annual enforcement activities. The Board must evaluate these reports and public comments and make recommendations to the Legislature and the Governor on recommended actions.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing costs to DBO in the range of $2 million each year to adopt emergency regulations, process applications, conduct examinations and enforce the provisions of the bill. These cost estimates rely on optimistic assumptions that enough banks participate in the proposed closed loop system to make it viable. Costs would be lower to the extent the system never becomes operational, though DBO would still incur initial costs of developing regulations and program development. (Financial Institutions Fund, Credit Union Fund)
- Unknown, but likely modest costs for the Treasurer, Controller, and the chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control to participate in the Board and develop recommendations to the Legislature.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. Federal law prevents cannabis businesses from accessing financial services provided by banks and credit unions, including basic checking accounts and electronic payment services that nearly all business rely on to facilitate transactions with their customers. As a result, most cannabis businesses in California lack basic banking services. According to a survey conducted by the California Growers Association in 2017, more than two-thirds of its membership is unbanked, with cultivators having the lowest level of access along the supply chain. Unbanked cannabis businesses are forced to transact primarily in cash, which presents public safety challenges and makes it difficult for state and local agencies collect taxes and enforce state laws.
- The proposed banking solution. SB 51 proposes a “closed-loop” banking system that allows cannabis businesses, state and local agencies, and other vendors to accept checks. CDIs would be authorized to provide limited services, including the acceptance of deposits and the issuance and redemption of special purpose checks. These checks may be used only to pay fees and taxes to state and local government agencies, pay rent, pay vendors located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the cannabis business, and purchase bonds or similar debt instruments issued by state or certain local agencies. These checks may not be used in any other capacity and balances may not be transferred to other banks outside the system.
- Will it work? SB 51’s proposed closed-loop banking solution may offer a partial and temporary cash management solution until a more viable federal solution emerges. If enough CDIs become operational, there are narrow cases where this new network of institutions could help cannabis businesses manage their cash. Given the practical challenges these businesses face in completing even the most mundane business activities, even a partial and temporary solution could be worth pursuing.
However, this committee must also balance the significant state costs of starting this new banking system with the distinct possibility that not enough CDIs will become operational to create a viable system. Like with last year’s bill (SB 930 (Hertzberg), which was held on this committee’s Suspense File), there are significant obstacles toward successful implementation of this bill. They include:
- Insurance. This bill requires CDIs to obtain private insurance, a requirement that will be difficult to comply with and will add significant costs to participating CDIs. Typically, deposits at traditional banks and credit unions are insured by federal agencies with risk pooled across institutions and backed by the federal government. In contrast, a private entity willing to insure a CDI will likely charge high premiums given the risk associated with cannabis banking.
- Federal law. SB 51 does not guarantee that CDIs will be protected from federal law enforcement. As the Assembly Banking and Finance Committee analysis notes, one unfortunate side effect of this bill could be the concentration of cannabis business assets into one or several easily identifiable institutions, making them an easier target of federal law enforcement action.
- Costs for banking customers. A CDI’s revenue will primarily come from fees charged to customers for services. Because CDIs may offer only limited services and will have high operational costs and insurance premiums, customers are likely to be charged very high fees.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 36-1
SUBJECT: Financial institutions: cannabis
SUMMARY: Provides for the licensure and supervision of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions authorized to offer limited depository services to cannabis businesses. Restricts the activities of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions to accepting deposits and issuing and redeeming special purpose checks. Prohibits a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union from engaging in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter. Declares that this act is an urgency statute and shall go into effect immediately.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of commercial cannabis activities by various state agencies.
- Authorizes Department of Business Oversight (DBO) to license and regulate financial institutions, including banks and credit unions (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.).
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Classifies cannabis as a Schedule 1 substance under the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S. Code 812 et seq.) and places regulatory restrictions on research, supply, and access to Schedule 1 substances.
- Requires financial institutions to report suspected illegal activity to the federal government (31 U.S. Code 5311 et seq.), including activity of suspected cannabis businesses that operate under state law.
- Provides that all property purchased using proceeds from an illegal activity is subject to forfeiture (18 U.S. Code 1961 et seq.).
THIS BILL:
- Adds a new division within the Financial Institutions Law (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 11000 et seq.).
- Defines “banking services” as the provision of depository services with respect to cash or other funds and the issuance and acceptance of special purpose checks, including the acceptance and maintenance of deposit proceeds, as specified.
- Defines “cannabis business” as a person licensed by the state of California to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 of the Business and Professions Code and an ancillary business that serves such a licensed person.
- Provides for the licensure of a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union (hereafter referred to as a “cannabis depository institution” or “CDI”) by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and requires such licensees to comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of that law is inconsistent with the provisions of this bill, in which case the provisions of this bill would prevail.
- Requires a CDI to adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Authorizes a CDI to accept deposits and issue to an account holder special purpose checks that may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or a local agency.
- Authorizes the state and local agencies to accept special purpose checks.
- Specifies that no private or public entity is required to accept special purpose checks.
- Authorizes a CDI to cash a special purpose check presented by a person that is not an account holder if the check was used for an authorized purpose, as specified in #6 above.
- Requires a CDI to obtain and maintain private insurance for itself and its assets, in an amount acceptable to DBO.
- Authorizes a CDI to form a banking network with other CDIs to assist each other in providing services to cannabis businesses, subject to the approval of DBO. Prohibits this network from including any institution that is not a CDI.
- Authorizes a CDI to charge fees for the banking services it provides and requires the CDI to conspicuously post a fee schedule to its website.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in banking activity (this bill does not define this term) with any financial institution that lacks a limited charter.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in any activity beyond those necessary to accept deposits and perform actions expressly authorized by this bill.
- Creates the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board, comprised of the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control. Requires DBO to submit annual reports related to enforcement activities and requires the Board to evaluate the reports and make recommendations to the Legislature and Governor.
- Provides that the division shall become inoperative if either:
- The federal government remove cannabis from the schedule of controlled substances, or
- The federal government enacts legislation that establishes protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
- Within thirty days of a triggering event as described immediately above in #16, requires DBO to provide guidance for orderly resolution of all CDIs, as specified. A CDI would have up to one year to resolve in a manner acceptable to state and federal regulators.
- Makes findings and declarations related to the history of cannabis legalization in California, federal policy related to cannabis, and the need for banking services in the cannabis industry.
- Declares that in order to eliminate public safety issues presented with managing and transporting cash because of the lack of access to financial services for cannabis businesses, to enable state and local governments to accurately perform accounting and other regulatory functions over the cannabis industry, and to enable cannabis businesses to comply with laws regulating the cannabis industry, it is necessary that this bill take effect immediately.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Treasurer Fiona Ma. According to the Author, “Despite its legal status in California, cannabis’ federal classification as a Schedule I drug prohibits cannabis-related businesses from depositing income with federally-insured financial institutions. This is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses alike have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue – businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession. Further, the Department of Finance estimates that tax receipts will only continue to grow in the coming years, and it is unacceptable for cannabis businesses to have to continue arriving to government offices with duffel bags of cash to fulfill their tax obligations.”
Background. Federal law prevents some cannabis businesses from accessing financial services provided by banks and credit unions, including basic checking accounts and electronic payment services that nearly all business rely to facilitate transactions with their customers. As briefly explained in the Existing Federal Law section above, federal law categorizes cannabis as a controlled substance and prohibits the possession and distribution thereof. Additionally, federal law places requirements on financial institutions to deter money laundering through reporting of suspected illegal activity, which includes commercial activities related to cannabis. [1] Federal law enforcement agencies, such as the Department of Justice, and federal regulators, including the Federal Reserve, National Credit Union Administration, and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp, have discretion in how these laws are implemented and enforced. Federal guidelines have provided comfort to several hundred banks and credit unions across the country to serve the cannabis industry; however, these financial institutions are doing so at their own risk of negative regulatory action and criminal prosecution.
Although some banks and credit unions accept the elevated legal risk and compliance costs to serve some cannabis businesses, some licensed cannabis businesses in California do not have access to banking services. According to a survey conducted by the California Growers Association in 2017, more than two-thirds of its membership is unbanked, with cultivators having the lowest level of access along the supply chain. Unbanked cannabis businesses transact primarily in cash, which makes the businesses and surrounding community targets for violent criminal activity. Cash businesses also present challenges to state and local tax collection and enforcement efforts.
This bill envisions a partial solution to the cannabis banking problem through the creation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions (hereafter referred to as “cannabis depository institution” or “CDI”). Upon approval by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) of a charter application, a CDI would be authorized to provide a very limited selection of services to its customers: the acceptance of deposits and the issuance and redemption of special purpose checks. These special purpose checks are limited to four general uses: 1) the payment of fees and taxes to local and state government agencies, 2) the payment of rent on property leased by, or on behalf of, a cannabis business, 3) payments to vendors physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the cannabis business, and 4) the purchase of bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or specified local agencies. CDIs are also authorized to form a network exclusively with other CDIs to assist each other in providing services to cannabis businesses.
Under this bill, CDIs are prohibited from engaging in most banking activities. This bill prohibits CDIs from offering common banking services, such as:
- merchant accounts that allow businesses to accept electronic payments (e.g., debit and credit cards);
- processing Automated Clearing House (ACH), Fedwire, or other electronic payment transactions that rely on networks that include any non-CDI financial institutions; and
- making, offering, brokering, or servicing loans.
In order to meet the needs of the cannabis industry, a substantial number of CDI branches will be necessary. Given the prohibitions against processing electronic payments and funds transfers, CDI branches must be in reasonable physical proximity to users of CDIs. Account holders will need access to a nearby branch in order to make regular cash deposits that significantly reduce the incentive for theft and robbery at their premises. Furthermore, CDI branches must be conveniently located and widely accessible to entice potential payees of special purpose checks to voluntarily agree to accept such checks.
Prior Related Legislation. SB 930 (Hertzberg, 2018), substantially similar to this bill, would have authorized the creation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions and authorized the use of special purpose checks issued by those institutions for specified purposes. The measure was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
California Cannabis Manufacturer Association writes in support, “SB 51 creates a limited purpose state charter bank license that would be administered and regulated by the Department of Business Oversight. Privately-funded banks that receive this charter would be able to provide limited banking and custodial services to licensed cannabis and cannabis-related businesses. Under SB 51, banks could issue checks to accountholders to be used for the following purposes:
• Pay state and local taxes and fees,
• Pay vendors from California for goods and services provided to the cannabis business,
• Pay rent, and
• Purchase state and local bonds and other debt instruments.”
In addition, Eaze Solutions, Inc. states, “The passage of Proposition 64 legalized cannabis in California in 2016. However, due to incongruity in state and federal law there are many challenges for the industry – none more dangerous than the lack of access to traditional financial institutions. Many banks refuse to provide services to state sanctioned cannabis business due to the risk of criminal or civil liability under federal drug and banking laws. This leaves many cannabis businesses unable to operate in a normal business fashion using checks, credit cards, or electronic transfers, and forces them to transact in all cash creating serious public safety concerns for everyone involved. Large amounts of cash can make cannabis businesses, their employees, and their customers targets of violent crime. Furthermore, state and local government agencies that collect tax and fee payments in cash from the cannabis industry incur added expenses, demands on staff time, and risks to employee safety.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
Eagle Forum of California argues, “Cannabis is still listed as a schedule I drug by the Federal Government. Related cost could be unnecessary and premature if The Federal “States Act” passes Congress. Subsides an “addiction-based industry” using tax payer dollars. Estimated it could cost approximately $2 million per year for the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) for the chartering of new banks and credit unions. There are unknown potentially significant costs to the State Treasurer’s Office, the State Controller’s Office, the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and the Department of Finance. CA should not be favoring and accommodating one industry over another which this bill clearly does.”
POLICY ISSUES:
There is a slight lack of clarity in this bill in regards to of the challenges mentioned and outlined in the Assembly Committee on Banking and Finance, June 24, 2019 Analysis. These challenges can be partially resolved through rulemaking and supervision by DBO. Strong state oversight reduces the risk that unscrupulous actors would be able to establish a CDI to defraud or prey on cannabis businesses that are desperate for a banking solution. DBO uses a rigorous set of criteria when reviewing an applicant for a bank or credit union charter, and the department will heavily scrutinize an applicant’s private insurer to verify that the insurance policy will be available to compensate depositors if the CDI encounters financial troubles.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
State Treasurer Fiona Ma (Sponsor)
Aeon Botanika
Alameda; City Of
BeGreenLegal
Black American Political Association of California
Budberry
Calasian Chamber Of Commerce
California Cannabis Industry Association
California Cannabis Manufacturers Association
California Chapter of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuna Laws
California State Treasurer
City of Alameda
City of Irvine
City of Sacramento
City of Santa Monica
County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors
Eaze Solutions, Inc.
El Capitan Advisors
Gallegos Law Firm
Green Believers
Hard Car Security
La Vida Verde
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Loudpack
Lovingly and Legally
MMMG LLC. dba Medmen
National Cannabis Industry Association
Origin House
Rezai Khorsandi & Lahijani ALC
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Cannabis Retailers Alliance
Santa Monica; City Of
Sespe Creek Collective
Southern California Coalition
The Artist Tree
TreeHouse
Undeniable INC
United Cannabis Business Association
Vanguard Concepts, LLC
VCC Brands
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Alliance Financial Network Inc.
Eagle Forum of California
Siskiyou County Sheriff's Office
Analysis Prepared by: Danielle Sires / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
The Bank Secrecy Act as amended by the USA Patriot Act (31 U.S. Code 5311 et seq.) ↑
Date of Hearing: June 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Monique Limón, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 51
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 36-1
SUBJECT: Financial institutions: cannabis
SUMMARY: Provides for the licensure and supervision of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions authorized to offer limited depository services to cannabis businesses. Restricts the activities of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions to accepting deposits and issuing and redeeming special purpose checks. Prohibits a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union from engaging in banking activity with any other financial institution that lacks a limited purpose charter. Declares that this act is an urgency statute and shall go into effect immediately.
Specifically, this bill:
- Adds a new division within the Financial Institutions Law (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 11000 et seq.).
- Defines “banking services” as the provision of depository services with respect to cash or other funds and the issuance and acceptance of special purpose checks, including the acceptance and maintenance of deposit proceeds, as specified.
- Defines “cannabis business” as a person licensed by the state of California to engage in commercial cannabis activity under Division 10 of the Business and Professions Code and an ancillary business that serves such a licensed person.
- Provides for the licensure of a cannabis limited charter bank or credit union (hereafter referred to as a “cannabis depository institution” or “CDI”) by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and requires such licensees to comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law, as applicable, except to the extent that any requirement of that law is inconsistent with the provisions of this bill, in which case the provisions of this bill would prevail.
- Requires a CDI to adopt policies and practices that allow it to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Authorizes a CDI to accept deposits and issue to an account holder special purpose checks that may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by, or on behalf of, the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or a local agency.
- Authorizes the state and local agencies to accept special purpose checks.
- Specifies that no private or public entity is required to accept special purpose checks.
- Authorizes a CDI to cash a special purpose check presented by a person that is not an account holder if the check was used for an authorized purpose, as specified in #6 above.
- Requires a CDI to obtain and maintain private insurance for itself and its assets, in an amount acceptable to DBO.
- Authorizes a CDI to form a banking network with other CDIs to assist each other in providing services to cannabis businesses, subject to the approval of DBO. Prohibits this network from including any institution that is not a CDI.
- Authorizes a CDI to charge fees for the banking services it provides and requires the CDI to conspicuously post a fee schedule to its website.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in banking activity (this bill does not define this term) with any financial institution that lacks a limited charter.
- Prohibits a CDI from engaging in any activity beyond those necessary to accept deposits and perform actions expressly authorized by this bill.
- Creates the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Advisory Board, comprised of the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control. Requires DBO to submit annual reports related to enforcement activities and requires the Board to evaluate the reports and make recommendations to the Legislature and Governor.
- Provides that the division shall become inoperative if either:
- The federal government remove cannabis from the schedule of controlled substances, or
- The federal government enacts legislation that establishes protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
- Within thirty days of a triggering event as described immediately above in #16, requires DBO to provide guidance for orderly resolution of all CDIs, as specified. A CDI would have up to one year to resolve in a manner acceptable to state and federal regulators.
- Makes findings and declarations related to the history of cannabis legalization in California, federal policy related to cannabis, and the need for banking services in the cannabis industry.
- Declares that in order to eliminate public safety issues presented with managing and transporting cash because of the lack of access to financial services for cannabis businesses, to enable state and local governments to accurately perform accounting and other regulatory functions over the cannabis industry, and to enable cannabis businesses to comply with laws regulating the cannabis industry, it is necessary that this bill take effect immediately.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of commercial cannabis activities by various state agencies.
- Authorizes DBO to license and regulate financial institutions, including banks and credit unions (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.).
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Classifies cannabis as a Schedule 1 substance under the Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S. Code 812 et seq.) and places regulatory restrictions on research, supply, and access to Schedule 1 substances.
- Requires financial institutions to report suspected illegal activity to the federal government (31 U.S. Code 5311 et seq.), including activity of suspected cannabis businesses that operate under state law.
- Provides that all property purchased using proceeds from an illegal activity is subject to forfeiture (18 U.S. Code 1961 et seq.).
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will create costs to DBO for the chartering of new banks and credit unions. The overall cost is dependent on the number of new banks and credit unions created, but is estimated to be approximately $2 million per year. These costs include $1.86 million in the first year and $1.78 million ongoing for conducting field examinations on the new banks and credit unions and $270,000 in the first year and $260,000 ongoing for developing and adopting emergency regulations and for enforcement. This bill will also result in unknown, potentially significant costs to the State Treasurer’s Office, the State Controller’s Office, the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and the Department of Finance for additional workload to prepare for the annual advisory board meeting and to travel to and attend that meeting.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE
According to the author’s office:
Despite its legal status in California, cannabis’ federal classification as a Schedule I drug provides limitations in how cannabis-related businesses can do business with federally-insured financial institutions. This is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses that cannot find a willing financial institution to accept their business have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue – businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession. Further, the Department of Finance estimates that tax receipts will only continue to grow in the coming years, and it is unacceptable for cannabis businesses to have to continue arriving to government offices with duffel bags of cash to fulfill their tax obligations.
- BACKGROUND
Federal law prevents some cannabis businesses from accessing financial services provided by banks and credit unions, including basic checking accounts and electronic payment services that nearly all business rely to facilitate transactions with their customers. As briefly explained in the Existing Federal Law section above, federal law categorizes cannabis as a controlled substance and prohibits the possession and distribution thereof. Additionally, federal law places requirements on financial institutions to deter money laundering through reporting of suspected illegal activity, which includes commercial activities related to cannabis. [1] Federal law enforcement agencies, such as the Department of Justice, and federal regulators, including the Federal Reserve, National Credit Union Administration, and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp, have discretion in how these laws are implemented and enforced. Federal guidelines have provided comfort to several hundred banks and credit unions across the country to serve the cannabis industry; however, these financial institutions are doing so at their own risk of negative regulatory action and criminal prosecution.
Although some banks and credit unions accept the elevated legal risk and compliance costs to serve some cannabis businesses, some licensed cannabis businesses in California do not have access to banking services. According to a survey conducted by the California Growers Association in 2017, more than two-thirds of its membership is unbanked, with cultivators having the lowest level of access along the supply chain. Unbanked cannabis businesses transact primarily in cash, which makes the businesses and surrounding community targets for violent criminal activity. Cash businesses also present challenges to state and local tax collection and enforcement efforts.
- THE VISION OF SB 930
This bill envisions a partial solution to the cannabis banking problem through the creation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions (hereafter referred to as “cannabis depository institution” or “CDI”). Upon approval by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) of a charter application, a CDI would be authorized to provide a very limited selection of services to its customers: the acceptance of deposits and the issuance and redemption of special purpose checks. These special purpose checks are limited to four general uses: 1) the payment of fees and taxes to local and state government agencies, 2) the payment of rent on property leased by, or on behalf of, a cannabis business, 3) payments to vendors physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the cannabis business, and 4) the purchase of bonds or similar debt instruments issued by the state or specified local agencies. CDIs are also authorized to form a network exclusively with other CDIs to assist each other in providing services to cannabis businesses.
Under this bill, CDIs are prohibited from engaging in most banking activities. This bill prohibits CDIs from offering common banking services, such as:
- merchant accounts that allow businesses to accept electronic payments (e.g., debit and credit cards);
- processing Automated Clearing House (ACH), Fedwire, or other electronic payment transactions that rely on networks that include any non-CDI financial institutions; and
- making, offering, brokering, or servicing loans.
In order to meet the needs of the cannabis industry, a substantial number of CDI branches will be necessary. Given the prohibitions against processing electronic payments and funds transfers, CDI branches must be in reasonable physical proximity to users of CDIs. Account holders will need access to a nearby branch in order to make regular cash deposits that significantly reduce the incentive for theft and robbery at their premises. Furthermore, CDI branches must be conveniently located and widely accessible to entice potential payees of special purpose checks to voluntarily agree to accept such checks.
- IMPLEMENTATION CHALLENGES
In order to achieve the vision of SB 930, the state government and the private sector would need to overcome significant challenges to deliver the public benefits that this bill seeks. This section outlines several of the most considerable challenges, but the list should not be viewed as exhaustive.
Private Insurance
This bill requires CDIs to obtain and maintain private insurance in an amount acceptable to the Commissioner of DBO. Typically, deposits at traditional banks and credit unions are insured by federal agencies[2] with risk pooled across a wide breadth of financial institutions and ultimately backed by the federal government. Private deposit insurance is not widely available, and there appears to be only one provider in the country, American Share Insurance (ASI).
The insurance requirement in this bill may be difficult to comply with. Since this concept was introduced as a legislative proposal in March 2018, Assembly Banking Committee staff has not learned of any entity that is willing to insure a CDI. Setting insurance premium rates is predicated on risk analysis informed by empirical evidence. In the case of CDIs, there are no historical data to estimate the risk of an insured loss. Furthermore, CDIs would primarily serve an industry that operates in direct violation of federal law, exposing a CDI to federal enforcement actions that could result in the seizure of all assets held by the CDI on behalf of cannabis businesses. The lack of historical data and the concentration of risk in an illegal industry pose significant barriers for a private insurer to engage in this line of business. If an insurer is willing to accept the risk, the premiums may be expensive, leading to larger fees for cannabis businesses.
How do account holders and owners of CDIs facilitate certain transactions?
Due to the prohibition on banking activities between a CDI and a financial institution that does not hold a CDI charter, it is unclear how certain transactions would be conducted given that CDIs will have no mechanism for electronic funds transfer. For example, this bill permits account holders to use special purpose checks to purchase state and local bonds. However, it seems unlikely that a bond dealer or broker would accept a special purpose check that the dealer or broker would need to redeem for cash at a CDI.
In another example, it is not clear how owners of CDIs will be able to receive dividends or other distributions of a CDI’s profits. It appears that many transactions will require two or more steps, including withdrawing cash from a CDI and depositing that cash in an account with a traditional financial institution, which may expose account holders and payees to the type of violent criminal activity that this bill seeks to prevent.
The restriction on banking activities with traditional financial institutions could also complicate large cash transactions. A CDI would not be authorized to initiate an armored carrier transfer of cash to a traditional bank, so an account holder or owner of a CDI would be required to arrange the transfer. The traditional bank receiving the inbound cash would be required to comply with more complex filing requirements specified by the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network. A risk-averse receiving bank could decide to decline receipt of such cash shipments if the receiving bank was unable to verify that the CDI had adequate compliance procedures in place.
Timing of Rulemaking and Application Process
This bill lacks specificity regarding which sections of existing Financial Institutions Law (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.) would apply to CDIs. The bill provides that CDIs must comply with all requirements of the Financial Institutions Law, as applicable, except to the extent that those requirements are inconsistent with the requirements proposed by this bill. Rather than specify which requirements of existing law apply to CDIs, this bill would defer that responsibility to DBO and does not provide clear intent from the Legislature on how DBO should make those decisions.
Due to the lack of specificity in the bill, the rulemaking process conducted by DBO is likely to be lengthy. Despite the authority granted to DBO by this bill to adopt emergency regulations, the rulemaking process will be cumbersome as the department examines each section of the Financial Institutions Law to determine its applicability to CDIs. Given the unique characteristics of the proposed CDI and the lack of any similar institution operating in the state or anywhere in the country, DBO will likely encounter sections of existing law that may be difficult to tailor to a CDI. DBO will also be required to clarify vague or undefined provisions in this bill, such as the prohibition of undefined “banking activities” between a CDI and a traditional financial institution. It is reasonable to assume that the rulemaking process could take a year or more based on prior rulemaking activities conducted by DBO, meaning DBO may not be able to accept CDI applications until the beginning of 2021.
Upon completion of rulemaking, DBO will be able to accept applications from persons interested in establishing a CDI. Some of the factors that DBO considers when reviewing a charter application include:
- the character, reputation, and financial standing of the organizers or incorporators and their motives in seeking to organize the proposed bank,
- the character, financial responsibility, banking or trust experience, and business qualifications of the proposed officers of the bank,
- the character, financial responsibility, business experience, and standing of the proposed stockholders and directors,
- the adequacy of banking facilities to support its operations,
- the reasonableness to achieve and maintain profitability, and
- the viability of the Business Plan given the economic condition, growth potential, and competition of the proposed market area.
To the extent that an applicant has weaknesses in any of these factors, the application process will be delayed and the application could ultimately be denied. Due to the unique risks posed by a CDI, it is reasonable to assume that the initial application process could take longer than nine months. In a rather optimistic scenario, the first CDI could be approved by the beginning of 2022.
Fee structures
Unlike traditional banks that receive a significant portion of their income from net interest margins[3] and fees from large transactions, CDIs’ revenue will solely rely on a very limited number of services to generate fee income from account holders. The fees charged by a CDI will need to be sufficient to recover the cost of operations, including significantly high cash handling expenses, relatively high insurance premiums and costs for complying with anti-money laundering policies and procedures.
Verifying a special purpose check was used for authorized purpose
This bill authorizes a CDI to cash a special purpose check presented to it by a person that is not an account holder, if that CDI previously issued the check to an account holder and the check was used for one of the purposes authorized by this bill. The bill does not specify how a CDI should verify that the check was used for an authorized purpose. It is likely that DBO will need to provide further clarification through regulations of how licensees should comply with this requirement. These requirements may include the verification of lease agreements and verifying the licensing status and approved payees of cannabis businesses.
CDIs would not be immune to federal law enforcement actions
As proposed by this bill, CDIs would not be insulated from federal law enforcement action. The operations of cannabis businesses violate federal law, and their assets can be seized by law enforcement agencies under the authority of the RICO Act (18 U.S. Code 1961 et seq.). By concentrating the assets of many cannabis businesses in one or several easily-identifiable CDIs, CDIs could be a target of federal law enforcement seeking to prosecute money laundering or drug trafficking cases. Potential insurers will likely factor this risk into the premiums they charge to insure a CDI.
What happens to CDIs if federal policy changes?
As more states legalize cannabis activity, there is a growing conversation in Congress about potential changes to federal policy. Currently, Congress is considering both the SAFE Banking Act, which would provide a safe harbor for banks and credit unions to open their doors to licensed cannabis businesses that comply with state laws. The SAFE Banking Act has over 200 cosponsors in the House and is expected to pass the lower chamber this summer. Powerful interest groups are strongly supporting the bill, including the American Bankers Association, the Credit Union National Association, and a group of 18 bipartisan state governors. While some analysts expect the bill to struggle in the Senate, others have opined that the measure may be attached to an omnibus spending bill. If enacted, the law would likely provide sufficient comfort to community banks and credit unions to more openly serve the cannabis industry.
Upon sufficient federal policy change that lowers the risk for traditional financial institutions to serve the cannabis industry, it is reasonable to assume that cannabis businesses will desire the full suite of banking services that CDIs cannot offer – merchant accounts, electronic payments and funds transfer, and loan products. The threat of obsolescence could deter the private sector from investing the time and resources in pursuing a CDI charter.
- DBO SUPERVISION PROVIDES PROTECTIONS
Despite the lack of clarity in this bill, some of the challenges outlined in the previous section can be partially resolved through rulemaking and supervision by DBO. Strong state oversight reduces the risk that unscrupulous actors would be able to establish a CDI to defraud or prey on cannabis businesses that are desperate for a banking solution. DBO uses a rigorous set of criteria when reviewing an applicant for a bank or credit union charter, and the department will heavily scrutinize an applicant’s private insurer to verify that the insurance policy will be available to compensate depositors if the CDI encounters financial troubles. While state oversight cannot fix all of the structural challenges posed by this bill, regulation and oversight should prevent bad actors from taking advantage of businesses that have few alternatives.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
State Treasurer Fiona Ma (Sponsor)
Aeon Botanika
Alameda; City Of
BeGreenLegal
Black American Political Association of California
Budberry
Calasian Chamber Of Commerce
California Cannabis Industry Association
California Cannabis Manufacturers Association
California Chapter of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuna Laws
California State Treasurer
City of Alameda
City of Irvine
City of Sacramento
City of Santa Monica
County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors
Eaze Solutions, Inc.
El Capitan Advisors
Gallegos Law Firm
Green Believers
Hard Car Security
La Vida Verde
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Loudpack
Lovingly and Legally
MMMG LLC. dba Medmen
National Cannabis Industry Association
Origin House
Rezai Khorsandi & Lahijani ALC
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Cannabis Retailers Alliance
Santa Monica; City Of
Sespe Creek Collective
Southern California Coalition
The Artist Tree
TreeHouse
Undeniable INC
United Cannabis Business Association
Vanguard Concepts, LLC
VCC Brands
Opposition
Alliance Financial Network Inc
Eagle Forum of California
Siskiyou County Sheriff's Office
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Burdick / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 51 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 51
Amended: 4/29/19
SENATE BANKING & F.I. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/3/19
AYES: Bradford, Chang, Caballero, Durazo, Hueso, Portantino
NOES: Morrell
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/24/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Wiener
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-1, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jones
SUBJECT: Financial institutions: cannabis
SOURCE: State Treasurer Fiona Ma
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the creation of limited charter banks and credit unions, as specified, and authorizes the use of special purpose checks issued by these institutions for certain purposes, including the payment of state and local taxes, rent, and goods and services, and the purchase of state and local securities, as specified.
Existing law:
- Provides for Proposition 215 (The Compassionate Use Act of 1996), which exempts from specified criminal penalties the possession or cultivation of medical marijuana by patients and primary caregivers; and Proposition 64 (The Control Regulate, and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act of 2016), which provides for the licensure and regulation of commercial adult marijuana activities by various state agencies.
- Provides for the Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act (Business and Professions Code Section 60000 et seq.) and its implementing regulations (California Code of Regulations Title 16, Division 42, Section 5000 et seq.), administered by the California Bureau of Cannabis Control.
- Provides for the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and gives DBO authority to administer the Financial Institutions Law. The three divisions of the Financial Institutions Law that are relevant for purposes of this bill include Division 1, related to administration, enforcement, and liquidation and conservation (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.); Division 1.1, the Banking Law (Financial Code Section 1000 et seq.); and Division 5, California Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 14000 et seq.).
This bill:
- Contains findings and declarations related to passage of Proposition 64 in 2016, authorizing the recreational use of cannabis, and to passage of Proposition 215 in 1996, authorizing the medicinal use of cannabis; the significant challenges that cannabis businesses have accessing traditional banking services; the regulatory and public safety issues arising from cannabis businesses’ lack of access to banking services; and the responsibility of the state, consistent with the will of California voters, to provide a mechanism to help lawful cannabis businesses gain access to banking services.
- Establishes a new Division 2.5 within the Financial Code (Section 11000 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (CLCL), administered by DBO. Sunsets this division on the earlier of either of the following:
- The federal government, by legislative or executive action, removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the schedule of controlled substances, as defined in the federal Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. Sec.812; 21 C.F.R. Part 1308).
- The federal government enacts legislation that would establish protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
Provides that, within 30 days of an event described above, DBO must post notice of that occurrence on its Internet Web site, send notice to both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel, and provide guidance for the orderly of entities chartered under Division 2.5, as specified.
- Defines the terms banking services, board, cannabis business, cannabis limited charter bank (CLCB), and cannabis limited charter credit union (CLCCU) for purposes of the CLCL.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to issue special purpose checks, which are valid only for specified purposes, and to cash special purpose checks, as specified. Requires each special purpose check to include the following text, in at least 12-point type: “This check is issued by [insert name of CLCB or CLCCU] and may only be deposited or cashed at this CLCB/CLCCU or another CLCB/CLCCU that agrees to accept the check.”
- Allows special purpose checks to be used only for specified purposes, but clarifies that no individual or entity, whether private or public, is required to accept a special purpose check issued by a CLCB or a CLCCU. Special purpose checks may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by or on behalf of the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or interest-bearing notes or warrants backed by the full faith and credit of the state, or bonds or warrants of any local jurisdiction, as specified.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to cash special purpose checks they previously issued, if those checks are presented to them by non-account holders and the checks were used for one of the aforementioned authorized purposes.
- Requires persons wishing to form as a CLCB or CLCCU to obtain a license from DBO, as specified, and to comply with all requirements of Division 1 of the Financial Institutions Law (which generally cover administrative and enforcement functions) and with either Division 1.1 of the Financial Code (the Banking Law) or Division 5 of the Financial Code (the California Credit Union Law), as applicable, but further provides that any requirement of any of those laws that is inconsistent with Division 2.5 does not apply to that CLCB or CLCCU.
- Requires CLCBs and CLCCUs to adopt policies and practices that allow them to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and to cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Requires CLCBs and CLCCUs to obtain and maintain private insurance for themselves and their assets at all times they are engaged in banking services, and authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to do all things and assume and discharge all obligations required of them in this regard, which are not in conflict with state law.
- Authorizes, subject to the approval of DBO, CLCBs and CLCCUs to enter into agreements with one or more other limited charter licensees in order to form a banking network for the purpose of helping each other provide services to cannabis businesses and each other, but expressly provides that a network of this type may not include any institution that is not a cannabis limited charter depository.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to charge fees for the services they provide and requires each of these entities to conspicuously post the types and amounts of fees it charges on its Internet website in a format intended to provide transparency.
- Requires DBO to adopt emergency regulations to implement the CLCL and provides that DBO may not issue CLCB or CLCCU licenses before July 1, 2020, except as specified.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 930 (Hertzberg, 2018) was substantially similar to this bill. SB 930 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee Suspense file.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, SB 51 will create costs to DBO for the chartering of new banks and credit unions. The overall cost is dependent on the number of new banks and credit unions created, but is estimated to be approximately $2 million per year. These costs include $1.86 million in the first year and $1.78 million ongoing for conducting field examinations on the new banks and credit unions and $270,000 in the first year and $260,000 ongoing for developing and adopting emergency regulations and for enforcement. SB 51 will also result in unknown, potentially significant costs to the State Treasurer’s Office, the State Controller’s Office, the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and the Department of Finance for additional workload to prepare for the annual advisory board meeting and to travel to and attend that meeting.
State Treasurer Fiona Ma (source)
Aeon Botanika
Budberry
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Cannabis Industry Association
California Cannabis Manufacturers Association
California NORML
City of Alameda
City of Irvine Councilmember Melissa Fox
City of Sacramento
City of Santa Monica
Eaze
El Capitan
Gallegos Law Firm
Green Believers
Hard Car Security
La Vida Verde
Los Angeles County
Loudpack
Lovingly & Legally
MedMen
National Cannabis Industry Association
Origin House
Rezai, Khorsandi & Lahijani
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Cannabis Retailers Alliance
Sespe Creek Collective
Southern California Coalition
The Artist Tree
TreeHouse
Undeniable INC
United Cannabis Business Association
Vanguard Concepts
VCC Brands
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
Siskiyou County Sheriff’s Department
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: State Treasurer Fiona Ma, sponsor of SB 51, states, “SB 51 is a significant step toward integrating cannabis-related businesses into the California economy in a safe and transparent manner.” Numerous other supporters submitted identical letters of support in which they asserted that SB 51 offers a practical solution to the problems faced by an unbanked cannabis industry. The cannabis industry “is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses alike have been forced t operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Siskiuou County Sheriff’s Department opposes this bill, on the basis that it will further exacerbate an out-of-control and largely unethical marjijuana industry and will promote wholesale money laundering. Siskiyou County has more than 1500+ illegal marijuana sites on private property, and more in public land areas. The organization believes that this bill, if passed, will lead to more criminalization and victimization.
Prepared by: Eileen Newhall / B. & F.I. /
5/18/19 11:57:47
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 51 (Hertzberg) - Financial institutions: cannabis
Version: April 29, 2019 | Policy Vote: B. & F.I. 6 - 1, GOV. & F. 6 - 1 |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Debra Cooper |
Bill Summary:
SB 51 would authorize the creation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions and authorize the use of special purpose checks issued by those institutions for specified purposes.
Fiscal Impact:
- This bill would create costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) for the chartering of new banks and credit unions. The overall cost is dependent on the number of new banks and credit unions created, but would be estimated to cost approximately $2 million per year. (Financial Institutions Fund, Credit Union Fund) These costs would include:
- $1.86 million in the first year and $1.78 ongoing for conducting field examinations on the new banks and credit unions.
- $270,000 in the first year and $260,000 ongoing for developing and adopting emergency regulations and for enforcement.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs to the State Treasurer’s Office, the State Controller’s Office, the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and the Department of Finance for additional workload to prepare for the annual advisory board meeting and to travel to and attend that meeting. (GF / Special Fund)
Background:
Proposition 215 in 1996 legalized medicinal marijuana in California and Proposition 64 in 2017 legalized adult-use cannabis use in California as of January 2018. However, the cannabis industry has been locked out of the traditional banking system.
Together, the Bank Secrecy Act, the USA Patriot Act, and the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act make it illegal for traditional financial institutions to handle funds stemming from criminal activity, including violations of federal drug laws, and subject financial institutions to possible regulatory sanctions for placing their safety and soundness at risk. The RICO Act also subjects all property bought with the proceeds of illegal activity to forfeiture. Neither the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) nor the National Credit Union Administration have been willing to provide deposit insurance to banks and credit unions that knowingly provide banking services to cannabis businesses. Additionally, no federal clearinghouse has been willing to clear a check known to have been written by or to a cannabis business and banks and credit unions will not issue credit or debit cards to businesses they know to be cannabis businesses.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Make various Legislative findings and declarations related to the passage of Proposition 64 in 2016 and Proposition 215 in 1996 and the challenges that the cannabis industry faces with limited access to traditional banking services;
- Establishes the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (CLCL) administered by DBO, which would sunset either when the federal government removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the schedule of controlled substances or the federal government enacts legislation that would establish protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses. This bill would provide that, within thirty days of an event described above, DBO must post notice of that occurrence on its Internet website, send notice to both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel, and provide guidance for the orderly resolution of cannabis limited charter banks (CLCBs) and cannabis limited charter credit unions (CLCCUs);
- Authorize CLCBs and CLCCUs to issue special purpose checks, which are valid only for specified purposes, and to cash special purpose checks, as specified;
- Authorize special purpose checks to be used only for specified purposes, but clarifies that no individual or entity, whether private or public, is required to accept a special purpose check issued by a CLCB or a CLCCU;
- Authorize CLCBs and CLCCUs to cash special purpose checks they previously issued, if those checks are presented to them by non-account holders and the checks were used for one of the aforementioned authorized purposes;
- Require persons wishing to form as a CLCB or CLCCU to obtain a license from DBO, as specified, and to comply with all administrative requirements and enforcement functions Financial Institutions Law and with specified provisions of Banking Law or California Credit Union Law, as applicable;
- Require CLCBs and CLCCUs to adopt policies and practices that allow them to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and to cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network;
- Require CLCBs and CLCCUs to obtain and maintain private insurance for themselves and their assets at all times they are engaged in banking services, and authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to do all things and assume and discharge all obligations required of them in this regard, which are not in conflict with state law;
- Subject to the approval of DBO, authorize CLCBs and CLCCUs to enter into agreements with one or more other limited charter licensees in order to form a banking network for the purpose of helping each other provide services to cannabis businesses and each other, but expressly provides that a network of this type may not include any institution that is not a cannabis limited charter depository;
- Authorize CLCBs and CLCCUs to charge fees for the services they provide and require each of these entities to conspicuously post the types and amounts of fees it charges on its Internet website in a format intended to provide transparency;
- Require DBO to adopt emergency regulations to implement the CLCL and provides that DBO may not issue CLCB or CLCCU licenses before July 1, 2020, except as specified;
- Establish the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Law Advisory Board (board) and provide that the board comprises the State Treasurer, State Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control as voting members; and the Director of the Department of Finance as an ex-officio, nonvoting member. Amongst other things, requires the board to hold a noticed, public meeting at least once a year, or more often as needed, to review enforcement activity reports from DBO and to draft recommended legislative or administrative actions. This bill would prohibit board members from being compensated for their services.
Related Legislation:
SB 930 (Hertzberg, 2018), substantially similar to this bill, would have authorized the creation of cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions and authorized the use of special purpose checks issued by those institutions for specified purposes. The measure was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
It is unknown how many CLCBs and CLCCUs will be created from this bill. The costs assume 12 new CLCBs and/or CLCCUs would be created, which would require eight additional examiners (two examiners per every three new institutions) to examine the banks and credit unions and an additional manager for the examiners. The overall cost would increase or decrease accordingly, dependent on the number of CLCBs and CLCCUs created.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 51 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/19 |
Author: | Hertzberg | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 3/25/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brown | ||
Financial institutions: cannabis
Authorizes the creation of both cannabis limited charter banks and credit unions and authorizes the use of special purpose checks issued by these institutions for specified purposes.
Background
Federal law relating to cannabis. Federal law prohibits the manufacture, possession, sale, or distribution of cannabis. In 1970, Congress enacted the Controlled Substances Act (CSA), which sets forth five schedules of specified drugs. For a drug to be designated a Schedule I controlled substance, CSA states the substance must have “a high potential for abuse," and have "no currently accepted medical use” in the United States. Federal law lists cannabis as a Schedule I controlled substance.
State law relating to cannabis. In 1996, California voters approved Proposition 215, known as the Compassionate Use Act of 1996 (CUA). Under CUA, qualified patients with specified illnesses—and their primary caregivers—cannot be prosecuted for possessing or cultivating cannabis upon the written or oral recommendation or approval of an attending physician. In other words, CUA allowed qualified patients and primary caregivers to obtain cannabis for medicinal use.
The Legislature clarified CUA by enacting SB 420 (Vasconcellos, 2003), which established and maintained a voluntary program—The Medical Marijuana Program—where qualified patients could be issued Medical Marijuana Identification Cards (identification cards) when deemed appropriate by their attending physician. Qualified patients with identification cards were exempt from criminal liability for possession, transportation, delivery, or cultivation of cannabis. SB 420 directed the Department of Public Health to administer the program and required county health departments to issue identification cards to patients and primary caregivers who voluntarily registered.
The cannabis industry remained largely unregulated at the state level until 2015, when the Legislature enacted the Medical Marijuana Regulation and Safety Act (MMRSA). MMRSA comprised a package of legislation that comprehensively regulated many aspects of medicinal use cannabis including cultivation, manufacturing, transportation, distribution, sale, and product safety. In 2016, several bills made slight changes to MMRSA, including renaming MMRSA to the Medical Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act.
On November 8, 2016, California voters approved Proposition 64—the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (the Act)—which legalized commercial adult-use cannabis for adults age 21 and older. Prop. 64 provides for the licensure and regulation of both commercial adult-use and medicinal use cannabis activities by various state agencies.
Less than a year later in June 2017, the Legislature enacted SB 94 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2017), which integrated MMRSA with the Act to create the Medicinal and Adult Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act (MAUCRSA). Among other things, MAUCRSA consolidated the licensure and regulation of both commercial adult-use and medicinal use cannabis activities. It established a system of 20 plus license categories, which includes distributor, retailer, and microbusiness, among others. Generally, licenses bear a clear designation indicating whether the license is for commercial adult-use or medicinal cannabis with an “A” or “M” respectively.
Cannabis taxes. Prop. 64, and subsequently MAUCRSA, imposes two specific taxes on cannabis: the excise tax and the cultivation tax. A customer who purchases cannabis or cannabis products in the state is subject to the cannabis excise tax, which is equal to 15 percent of the average market price of any cannabis or cannabis products retail sale. A cannabis retailer is responsible for collecting the cannabis excise tax from the customer and remitting it to the distributor. The distributor then remits the cannabis excise tax to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA).
The cultivator, who grows the cannabis, is subject to the cultivation tax, which applies to all harvested cannabis at the following rates:
- $9.25 per dry-weight ounce of cannabis flower.
- $2.75 per dry-weight ounce of cannabis leaves.
- $1.29 per ounce of fresh cannabis plant.
The cultivation tax is collected by the distributor (or manufacturer), and then remitted to CDTFA. The cultivation tax does not apply to cannabis cultivated for personal use.
Federal banking laws and money laundering. The Money Laundering Control Act of 1986 made money laundering—the concealment of the origins of illegally obtained money—a federal crime. Regardless of state law, financial institutions can commit money laundering by conducting financial transactions involving substances explicitly prohibited by CSA, such as cannabis.
Under the Bank Secrecy Act of 1970, financial institutions must assist government agencies in detecting and preventing money laundering: they must conduct sufficient due diligence to assess the risk of doing business with each of its customers. For example, financial institutions must understand its customers’ area of business as well as the nature of its customers’ accounts. They must report any transaction exceeding $10,000, and any suspicious or illegal activities to the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). If financial institutions do not abide by the Bank Secrecy Act, FinCEN has the authority to seek substantial civil penalties, which often reach well into the millions of dollars, as well as criminal prosecution.
Additionally, under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act of 1970, the federal government can prosecute all individuals involved in a corrupt organization. RICO subjects all property bought with the proceeds of illegal activity to forfeiture.
The Cole Memo. On August 29, 2013, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) issued the Cole Memo, which provided guidance to federal prosecutors regarding cannabis enforcement. The Cole Memo suggested that the federal government may ignore some CSA violations in states that legalize and regulate cannabis use. It instructed DOJ attorneys and law enforcement officials to focus on the following enforcement priorities:
- Preventing the distribution of cannabis to minors.
- Preventing revenue from cannabis sales from going to criminal enterprises, gangs, and cartels.
- Preventing the diversion of cannabis from states where it is legal to other states where it is illegal.
- Preventing state-authorized cannabis activity from being used as a cover or pretext for the trafficking of other illegal drugs or other illegal activity.
- Preventing violence and the use of firearms in the cultivation and distribution of cannabis.
- Preventing drugged driving and other adverse public health consequences associated with cannabis use.
- Preventing the growth of cannabis on public lands.
- Preventing the public safety and environmental dangers posed by cannabis production on public lands.
- Preventing cannabis possession or use on federal property.
The Cole Memo’s priorities guided the DOJ 's enforcement of CSA relating to cannabis nationwide. However, on January 4, 2018, the DOJ rescinded the Cole Memo, which means U.S. Attorneys can resume enforcing all federal cannabis laws in states with legalized cannabis use, like California.
Since cannabis is still illegal under federal law, cannabis businesses have been locked out of the banking system. The author wants to help the recently legal industry access a banking system that is walled off from the traditional banking sector.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 51 establishes the creation of cannabis limited charter banks (CLCBs) and cannabis limited charter credit unions (CLCCUs) to provide limited banking services to the cannabis industry. Under the administration of the Department of Business Oversight (DBO), CLCBs and CLCCUs can accept and maintain cash deposits as well as issue special purpose checks that can only be used for the following:
- To pay fees or taxes to the state or local jurisdiction.
- To pay rent on property that is associated with the account holder’s cannabis business.
- To pay vendors located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the account holder’s cannabis business.
- To purchase bonds or interest-bearing notes or warrants backed by the full faith and credit of the state, or bonds or warrants of any local jurisdiction.
CLCBs’ and CLCCUs’ special purpose checks must contain the text “This check is issued by [insert name of CLCB or CLCCU] and may only be deposited or cashed at this CLCB/CLCCU or another CLCB/CLCCU that agrees to accept the check” in at least 12-point type. While special purpose checks can be used for the specific purposes stated above, neither an entity nor a person is required to accept them.
CLCBs and CLCCUs can charge fees for their services, and must post both the types and amounts of fees on its Internet website in a format intended to provide transparency.
CLCBs and CLCCUs may form banking networks only with other CLCBs and CLCCUs, and these institutions are required to obtain private insurance for themselves and their assets. They must adopt policies and practices that allow them to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and to cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
The bill sunsets CLCBs and CLCCUs if either of the following take place:
- The federal government removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the federal Controlled Substances Act.
- The federal government enacts legislation that would establish protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
If CLCBs and CLCCUs sunset, the bill requires DBO to post the occurrence on its Internet website, notify both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel, and provide guidance for licensed CLCBs and CLCCUs on how to proceed going forward.
Additionally, it establishes the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank Advisory Board (Board), which comprises the Treasurer, the Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control as voting members. The Director of Finance sits on the Board as a non-voting ex-officio member. SB 51 prohibits board members from receiving compensation for their services.
SB 51 requires DBO to issue emergency regulations and prohibits DBO from issuing licenses to CLCBs and CLCCUs until July 1, 2020. The bill requires DBO to report to the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions (SBFI), and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance (SGF) regarding the status of its regulations and the implementation of this bill.
DBO may issue licenses prior to July 1, 2020, if all of the following have taken place:
- DBO adopts the emergency regulations required;
- The DBO Commissioner makes a written finding and posts it on the department’s website; and
- SBFI and SGF have met in an open and public meeting to discuss the report DBO has submitted.
SB 51 contains findings and declarations as well related to the following:
- The passage of both Proposition 64 and Proposition 215.
- The significant challenges the cannabis business faces with limited access to traditional banking services.
- The regulatory and public safety issues arising from the cannabis industries lack of access to banking.
- The responsibility of the state to provide a mechanism to help the cannabis industry gain access to banking services.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The use and consumption of medical marijuana was legalized in California in 1996, and Proposition 64 legalized adult-use cannabis as of January 2018. However, due to cannabis’ federal classification as a Schedule I drug, cannabis-related businesses are not able to deposit income with federally-insured financial institutions. The California cannabis industry is expected to generate more than $5 billion in revenue by 2020. This is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses alike have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue. The Department of Finance estimates that tax receipts will only continue to grow in the coming years. Unlike most businesses however, cannabis businesses arrive to government offices with duffel bags of cash to fulfill their tax obligations. Standard oversight and accountability measures, like audits, become very difficult when most transactions are completed in cash. Additionally, these businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession.”
2. A new approach. SB 51 envisions CLCBs or CLCCUs that are completely walled off from the traditional banking sector. These limited charter banks will form networks with each other and establish branches throughout the state. CLCBs and CLCCUs will open accounts for California licensed cannabis businesses and will provide their customers with two types of services: accepting and holding deposits as well as issuing special purpose checks. Thus, a cannabis business with an account at a CLCB or CLCCU will be able to use special purpose checks, rather than cash, to pay for certain products and services as well as to pay their taxes. These special purpose checks will be readily accepted and cash will be taken off the streets, mitigating some of the existing public safety risks. Plus, cannabis businesses will have an easier way to pay their state and local taxes. Instead of walking around with suitcases full of cash, taxpayers can simply write a special purpose check.
The bill’s success heavily depends on the number of CLCBs and CLCCUs that form. More institutions mean more access for taxpayers to deposit special purpose checks. If a property owner receives a special purpose check from a cannabis business but does not have an account at
a CLCB or CLCCU, the property owner has little, if any, ability to convert that check to cash, since other banks cannot accept them. Even if the property owner has access to a nearby CLCB or CLCCU, it is unclear how much that property owner would be charged for turning the special purpose check into cash at the limited charter depository. The fewer CLCBs and CLCCUs that form under the authority created by this bill, the harder it will be for cannabis businesses wishing to use special purpose checks in lieu of cash to find people and businesses to accept them.
3. Taxes. The author argues that SB 51 will help taxpayers have an easier time paying taxes. However, it is unclear if state agencies would keep an account at one of these banking institutions. State agencies would likely not deposit state money in a bank account that is not insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). If they did, the agencies would be subjecting state monies to potential federal seizure. State agencies could still accept special purpose checks, but they would have to cash the special purpose check at one of these institutions, and then transport cash to an FDIC insured bank. Local governments will face the same issue. If they choose to keep an account with a cannabis depository institution, they risk subjecting local funds to potential federal seizure. Additionally, a cannabis depository institution would need to be located in or near a local government for them to realistically consider accepting special purposes checks (see Comment # 5). Otherwise, the local governments would have to transport cash farther distances to be able to deposit a special purpose check, and transfer the cash to an FDIC insured bank.
4. Let’s get going. The Committee has held three separate hearings on cannabis tax collection and related issues over the past two years: California Cannabis in a Turbulent Time on February 14, 2017; Preparing for California’s Green Gold Rush on July 19, 2017; and First 60 Days of Prop. 64 on March 1, 2018. The three hearings showed that cannabis issues are complex and tough to solve. While SB 51 contains a delayed implementation date of July 1, 2020, and a requirement for DBO to issue emergency regulations, will the emergency regulations be ready by July 1, 2020? If not, it is unlikely that any businesses will apply to become a cannabis depository institution or choose to keep money within a newly developed institution. The Committee may wish to consider eliminating the requirement to report to the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions, and the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance to allow DBO to focus on finishing the emergency regulations.
5. Electronic transmissions. Even though SB 51 authorizes different CLCBs and CLCCUs to enter into banking networks with one another, this authority does not extend to electronic transmission of money. Only a change in federal law would grant CLCBs or CLCCUs access to federal payment rails, which allow different banks to transmit money electronically to each other. This access will not be granted as long as cannabis remains illegal at the federal level. As a result, CLCBs and CLCCUs will have to devise ways to accept and deposit checks issued by their brother or sister CLCBs and CLCCUs that do not include federal payment rails.
6. Public safety. Due to the federal status of cannabis and the inability for many cannabis businesses to access bank accounts, the industry is a predominately cash business. Cannabis businesses worry that large amounts of cash on hand make them a target for theft and crime. The Committee may wish to consider adding an urgency clause due to the public safety issues that arise from large amounts of cash that exchange hands on a daily basis.
7. Incoming! On April 3rd, the Senate Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions approved SB 51 by a vote of 6 to 1. The Committee on Governance and Finance is hearing the measure as the committee of second reference.
Support and Opposition (4/19/19
Support: State Treasurer Fiona Ma (sponsor);.Aeon Botanika; Begreenlegal; Budberry; Calasian Chamber Of Commerce; California Cannabis Industry Association; California Norml; City of Irvine; City Of Sacramento; City of Santa Monica; Eaze Solutions, Inc.; El Capitan Advisors; Fiona Ma Treasurer; Gallegos Law Firm; Green Believers; Hardcar; La Vida Verde; Loudpack; Lovingly and Legally SPC; Med Men; NCIA; Origin House; Rural County Representatives of California; Rezai, Khorsandi and Lahijani; Sespe Creek; SFCRA; Southern California Coalition; The Artist Tree; Tree House; Undeniable, INC; United Cannabis Business Association; Vanguard Concepts; VCC Brands
Opposition: Siskiyou County Sheriff'S Office, 305 Butte Street, Yreka, Ca 96097
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BANKING AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 51 Hearing Date: April 3, 2019
Author: | Hertzberg | ||
Version: | March 25, 2019 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eileen Newhall | ||
Subject: Financial institutions: cannabis
SUMMARY
This bill authorizes the creation of limited charter banks and credit unions, as specified, and authorizes the use of special purpose checks issued by these institutions for certain purposes, including the payment of state and local taxes, rent, and goods and services, and the purchase of state and local securities, as specified.
EXISTING LAW
- Provides for Proposition 215 (The Compassionate Use Act of 1996), which exempts from specified criminal penalties the possession or cultivation of medical marijuana by patients and primary caregivers; and Proposition 64 (The Control Regulate, and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act of 2016), which provides for the licensure and regulation of commercial adult marijuana activities by various state agencies.
- Provides for the Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act (Business and Professions Code Section 60000 et seq.) and its implementing regulations (California Code of Regulations Title 16, Division 42, Section 5000 et seq.), administered by the California Bureau of Cannabis Control.
- Provides for the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) and gives DBO authority to administer the Financial Institutions Law. The three divisions of the Financial Institutions Law that are relevant for purposes of this bill include Division 1, related to administration, enforcement, and liquidation and conservation (Financial Code Section 99 et seq.); Division 1.1, the Banking Law (Financial Code Section 1000 et seq.); and Division 5, California Credit Union Law (Financial Code Section 14000 et seq.).
THIS BILL
- Contains findings and declarations related to passage of Proposition 64 in 2016, authorizing the recreational use of cannabis, and to passage of Proposition 215 in 1996, authorizing the medicinal use of cannabis; the significant challenges that cannabis businesses have accessing traditional banking services; the regulatory and public safety issues arising from cannabis businesses’ lack of access to banking services; and the responsibility of the state, consistent with the will of California voters, to provide a mechanism to help lawful cannabis businesses gain access to banking services.
- Establishes a new Division 2.5 within the Financial Code (Section 11000 et seq.) called the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking and Credit Union Law (CLCL), administered by DBO. Sunsets this division on the earlier of either of the following:
- The federal government, by legislative or executive action, removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the schedule of controlled substances, as defined in the federal Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. Sec.812; 21 C.F.R. Part 1308).
- The federal government enacts legislation that would establish protections for depository institutions that provide financial services to cannabis-related legitimate businesses.
- The federal government, by legislative or executive action, removes cannabis and cannabis-related substances from the schedule of controlled substances, as defined in the federal Controlled Substances Act (21 U.S.C. Sec.812; 21 C.F.R. Part 1308).
Provides that, within thirty days of an event described above, DBO must post notice of that occurrence on its Internet website, send notice to both the Secretary of State and the Office of Legislative Counsel, and provide guidance for the orderly of entities chartered under Division 2.5, as specified.
- Defines the terms banking services, board, cannabis business, cannabis limited charter bank (CLCB), and cannabis limited charter credit union (CLCCU) for purposes of the CLCL.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to issue special purpose checks, which are valid only for specified purposes, and to cash special purpose checks, as specified. Requires each special purpose check to include the following text, in at least 12-point type: “This check is issued by [insert name of CLCB or CLCCU] and may only be deposited or cashed at this CLCB/CLCCU or another CLCB/CLCCU that agrees to accept the check.”
- Allows special purpose checks to be used only for specified purposes, but clarifies that no individual or entity, whether private or public, is required to accept a special purpose check issued by a CLCB or a CLCCU. Special purpose checks may only be used to:
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Pay rent on property that is leased by or on behalf of the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Pay a vendor physically located in California for expenses related to goods and services associated with the account holder’s cannabis business.
- Purchase bonds or interest-bearing notes or warrants backed by the full faith and credit of the state, or bonds or warrants of any local jurisdiction, as specified.
- Pay fees or taxes to the state or a local jurisdiction.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to cash special purpose checks they previously issued, if those checks are presented to them by non-account holders and the checks were used for one of the aforementioned authorized purposes.
- Requires persons wishing to form as a CLCB or CLCCU to obtain a license from DBO, as specified, and to comply with all requirements of Division 1 of the Financial Institutions Law (which generally cover administrative and enforcement functions) and with either Division 1.1 of the Financial Code (the Banking Law) or Division 5 of the Financial Code (the California Credit Union Law), as applicable, but further provides that any requirement of any of those laws that is inconsistent with Division 2.5 does not apply to that CLCB or CLCCU.
- Requires CLCBs and CLCCUs to adopt policies and practices that allow them to achieve the principles and goals outlined in the federal Bank Secrecy Act and to cooperate with the federal Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- Requires CLCBs and CLCCUs to obtain and maintain private insurance for themselves and their assets at all times they are engaged in banking services, and authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to do all things and assume and discharge all obligations required of them in this regard, which are not in conflict with state law.
- Subject to the approval of DBO, authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to enter into agreements with one or more other limited charter licensees in order to form a banking network for the purpose of helping each other provide services to cannabis businesses and each other, but expressly provides that a network of this type may not include any institution that is not a cannabis limited charter depository.
- Authorizes CLCBs and CLCCUs to charge fees for the services they provide and requires each of these entities to conspicuously post the types and amounts of fees it charges on its Internet website in a format intended to provide transparency.
- Requires DBO to adopt emergency regulations to implement the CLCL and provides that DBO may not issue CLCB or CLCCU licenses before July 1, 2020, except as specified.
- Establishes the Cannabis Limited Charter Bank and Credit Union Law Advisory Board (board) and provides that the board is comprised of the State Treasurer, State Controller, and the Chief of the Bureau of Cannabis Control as voting members, and the Director of the Department of Finance as an ex-officio, nonvoting member.
- Holds the Board generally responsible for ensuring that the CLCBL provides a safe and efficient way to pay state and local taxes and fees, pay rent associated with the account holder’s cannabis business, issue special purpose checks, and legally invest in California’s economy.
- Requires the Board to hold noticed, public meeting at least once a year, or more often as needed, to review enforcement activity reports from DBO and to draft recommended legislative or administrative actions for submission to the Legislature and the Governor, as specified.
- Requires the Board to provide guidance and education to registered broker-dealers and licensed investment advisors on how to accommodate CLCB and CLCCU account holders who wish to purchase allowable state and/or local securities.
- Expressly prohibits Board members from being compensated for their services.
- Holds the Board generally responsible for ensuring that the CLCBL provides a safe and efficient way to pay state and local taxes and fees, pay rent associated with the account holder’s cannabis business, issue special purpose checks, and legally invest in California’s economy.
- Makes related conforming amendments.
COMMENTS
- Purpose: This bill is sponsored by Treasurer Fiona Ma to help mitigate several of the problems resulting from cannabis businesses’ lack of access to banking services.
- Author’s Statement: The author states, “The use and consumption of medical marijuana was legalized in California in 1996, and Proposition 64 legalized adult-use cannabis as of January 2018. However, due to cannabis’ federal classification as a Schedule I drug, cannabis-related businesses are not able to deposit income with federally-insured financial institutions. The cannabis industry is expected to generate between $8-20 billion annually. This is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses alike have been forced to operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue.
“The Department of Finance estimates that the state will collect $600 million in cannabis taxes in the upcoming year. Unlike most businesses however, cannabis businesses arrive to government offices with duffel bags of cash to fulfill their tax obligations. Standard oversight and accountability measures, like audits, become very difficult when most transactions are completed in cash. Additionally, these businesses face security risks because of the volume of cash in their possession.” - Why Are Depository Institutions Reluctant to Bank Cannabis Businesses? Virtually everyone who has attempted to solve the problem this bill’s author and sponsor are seeking to solve has faced the reality that the vast majority of traditional banks and credit unions will not knowingly provide banking services to cannabis businesses or, in many cases, to businesses that serve cannabis businesses. Reluctance to serve the cannabis industry is based on a minimum of four different federal laws: the Controlled Substances Act, Bank Secrecy Act, USA Patriot Act, and Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. The Controlled Substances Act classifies marijuana as a Schedule I drug, whose manufacture, distribution, dispensing, and possession are illegal under most circumstances. The other three listed laws make it illegal for financial institutions to handle funds stemming from criminal activity, including violations of federal drug laws, and subject financial institutions to possible regulatory sanctions for placing their safety and soundness at risk by failing to take appropriate actions to avoid illegal activity. The RICO Act additionally subjects all property bought with the proceeds of illegal activity to forfeiture.
A feasibility study prepared for former State Treasurer John Chiang summarized the issues this way: “The fact that cannabis remains a schedule one illegal drug at the federal level, in the same class as heroin and LSD, places a “Sword of Damocles” over the state in that the federal government could, if desired, prosecute anyone involved in the cannabis industry (directly or indirectly) under federal drug laws; and confiscate all funds and cannabis-related property. Accordingly, the banking industry is faced with at least four challenges when servicing the industry:
“1. The bank may be at risk of criminal or civil liability under federal drug and banking laws.
2. The industry is new, rapidly evolving, and large. This creates business risks even without federal enforcement of the federal drug laws.
3. There is a significant administrative burden to properly file the required federal reports governing cannabis banking transactions, and the penalties for incorrect filings may be severe.
4. The “Know Your Customer” requirements are more significant than normal because similar transactions may be allowed (e.g., proceeds from the sale of cannabis within the state) or not allowed (e.g., illegal proceeds from sale of cannabis to another state).
“As a result, banks are only gradually entering this market. This limits the ability of cannabis businesses to operate in a normal business fashion using checks, credit cards, electronic transfers, and so on.” (“State-backed Financial Institution (Public Bank) for the State of California Servicing the Cannabis Industry Feasibility Study, 2018,” Level 4 Ventures, available at: https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/comm-external-urls/cannabis-feasibility-full-report.pdf).
The feasibility study referenced immediately above noted that, “even with no state intervention, private financial institutions are gradually entering the cannabis market. This trend is expected to continue.” However, the report also acknowledged that the number of institutions in California willing to knowingly serve the cannabis industry does not meet the demand among this industry for banking services. This bill is an attempt to help bridge that gap. - How Will All of This Work? If this bill is enacted, the author and sponsor envision that one or more CLCBs or CLCCUs will form in one or more areas of the state. Once formed and operational, a CLCB or CLCCU will open accounts for California licensed cannabis businesses and accept cash and special purpose check deposits from those businesses. CLCBs and CLCCUs will be authorized to engage in only two activities: 1) accepting and holding deposits for their account holders and 2) issuing special purpose checks to their account holders. A cannabis business with an account at a CLCB or CLCCU will be able to use special purpose checks, rather than cash, to pay taxes and to pay for certain products and services, but only if the entity to which the cannabis business presents the special purpose check wishes to accept it. Because traditional banks and credit unions will be unlikely to deposit or cash special purpose checks, these checks cannot be considered legal tender. They are, in essence, cannabis scrip, which can only be exchanged with a business or other entity that agrees to accept them.
One potential benefit of the system proposed by this bill involves the increased ability of cannabis businesses to pay their state and local taxes with special purpose checks, without having to physically carry large bags of cash into state and local taxing agencies. However, this benefit will only be realized if the state and local taxing agencies accept special purpose checks for tax payments.
Other advantages may also flow from the authority granted by this bill, but may be limited in geographic scope, at least initially. For example, in certain geographic areas of the state whose economies are heavily reliant on cannabis, and whose residents and business owners frequently interact with cannabis businesses, the special purpose checks envisioned by this bill may be readily accepted, and, as such, may help take some cash off the streets and mitigate some of the existing public safety risks that result from cannabis business’s lack of access to banking services. If everyone has an account at the local CLCB or CLCCU, being presented with a special purpose check is not a problem; one just deposits it into one’s account. Even in areas where the economy is less dependent on cannabis, and where most residents and businesses do not interact with cannabis businesses, these special purpose checks may help cannabis businesses interact with one another, without having to exchange large amounts of cash. One’s out-of-town landlord may not want to accept a special purpose check, but the vendor that serves multiple cannabis businesses probably will.
However, in other areas of the state whose economies are less reliant on cannabis, and where residents and businesses interact to a much more limited extent with cannabis businesses, these special purpose checks may not be readily accepted. If a landlord receives a special purpose check from a cannabis business but does not have an account at a CLCB or CLCCU, the landlord has little, if any, ability to convert that check to cash. Even if the landlord has access to a nearby CLCB or CLCCU, something that is not assured, it is unclear how much that landlord would be charged for turning the special purpose check into cash at the limited charter depository. The fewer CLCBs and CLCCUs that form under the authority created by this bill, the harder it will be for cannabis businesses wishing to use special purpose checks in lieu of cash to find people and businesses to accept them.
It should also be noted that, even though this bill authorizes different CLCBs and CLCCUs to enter into banking networks with one another, this authority does not extend to electronic transmission of money from one to another. This bill does nothing to grant CLCBs or CLCCUs access to federal payment rails, access that cannot be granted as long as cannabis remains illegal at the federal level.
The idea in this bill may hold promise, but its success will be heavily dependent on the number of CLCBs and CLCCUs that form, on their geographic locations across the state, and on their abilities to devise ways to accept and deposit checks issued by their brother- or sister- CLCBs and CLCCUs.
- Will Private Insurance Be Available? What About Sufficient Collateral to Ensure Liquidity? Several of the unanswered questions surrounding the limited purpose depository institution charter authorized by this bill include the level of private deposit insurance and collateral DBO will require, the extent to which insurers authorized to do business in this state will provide the required insurance, the cost of that insurance, and the extent to which limited charter banks and credit unions will have access to required amounts of collateral. No cannabis business, regardless of how desperate it is to move away from an all-cash business model, is likely to deposit its money in an institution that might not fully insure its deposits, nor in one that cannot promise instant liquidity, when it wishes to withdraw its funds.
- Should This Bill Spell Out the Specific Requirements to Which CLCBs and CLCCUs are Subject? This bill opts to use general control language to describe the requirements to which CLCBs and CLCCUs are subject, rather than spelling out each and every requirement in detail. For example, Financial Code Section 11021, proposed to be added by this bill, states that a CLCB and CLCCU shall comply with all requirements of Division 1 of the Financial Code, and with either Division 1.1 (CLCBs) or Division 5 (CLCCUs), except that, to the extent any requirement of those laws is inconsistent with a provision of the Cannabis Limited Charter Banking Law, the provisions of the cannabis law shall prevail. The challenge posed by this broad language is its lack of specificity. Which requirements are inconsistent? Should they be ignored or should they be modified to remove the inconsistency? If the latter, how, exactly, should they be modified?
Without further clarity around these questions, it is unlikely that any businesses will apply to become CLCBs or CLCCUs, because their governing boards and risk committees will be unclear about DBO’s specific compliance expectations. The question is not, “will entities want or need this clarity” but rather, “where will the clarity originate?” The Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee analysis of last year’s SB 930 suggested amendments to provide such clarity through statute. This bill’s author rejected that amendment, preferring instead for DBO to provide any clarity that proved necessary in its implementing regulations. It is currently unclear how much clarity DBO expects to provide around these questions in the emergency regulations this bill requires the department to promulgate by July 1, 2020. - How Much Will This Cost? According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of SB 930, last year’s bill would have resulted in ongoing costs to DBO in the range of $2 million annually to adopt regulations, process applications, conduct examinations, and enforce the provisions of the bill. These cost estimates rely on optimistic assumptions that enough banks and credit unions participate in the closed-loop system to make it viable. Costs would be lower if no institutions apply for or are granted cannabis limited charters, although DBO would still incur initial costs to promulgate regulations and develop a new regulatory program.
- Support:
- State Treasurer Fiona Ma is sponsoring SB 51, just as she sponsored last year’s SB 930 in her capacity as a member of the Board of Equalization. Treasurer Ma asserts that “SB 51 is a significant step toward integrating cannabis-related businesses into the California economy in a safe and transparent manner.”
- Numerous other supporters submitted identical letters of support in which they asserted that SB 51 offers a practical solution to the problems faced by an unbanked cannabis industry. The cannabis industry “is a massive industry that we can only expect will continue to grow; yet cultivation, distribution, and retail businesses alike have been forced t operate on a cash-only basis. This is not only impractical from an accounting perspective, but also presents a significant public safety issue.”
- State Treasurer Fiona Ma is sponsoring SB 51, just as she sponsored last year’s SB 930 in her capacity as a member of the Board of Equalization. Treasurer Ma asserts that “SB 51 is a significant step toward integrating cannabis-related businesses into the California economy in a safe and transparent manner.”
- Opposition: The Siskiuou County Sheriff’s Department opposes this bill, on the basis that it will further exacerbate an out-of-control and largely unethical marjijuana industry and will promote wholesale money laundering. Siskiyou County has more than 1500+ illegal marijuana sites on private property, and more in public land areas. This bill, if passed, will lead to more criminalization and victimization.
- Prior and Related Legislation:
- SB 930 (Hertzberg, 2018) was substantially similar to this bill. SB 930 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee Suspense file.
LIST OF REGISTERED SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Support
Treasurer Fiona Ma (sponsor)
Aeon Botanika
Budberry
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Cannabis Industry Association
California NORML
City of Irvine Councilmember Melissa Fox
City of Santa Monica
Eaze
El Capitan
Gallegos Law Firm
Green Believers
Hard Car Security
La Vida Verde
Loudpack
Lovingly & Legally
National Cannabis Industry Association
Origin House
Rezai, Khorsandi & Lahijani
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Cannabis Retailers Alliance
Sespe Creek Collective
Southern California Coalition
The Artist Tree
TreeHouse
Undeniable INC
United Cannabis Business Association
Vanguard Concepts
VCC Brands
Opposition
Siskiyou County Sheriff’s Department
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):