SB 533: Fort Ord Reuse Authority: prevailing wages.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-03-28
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 4, 2020 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | April 24 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 533 Hearing Date: April 24, 2019
Author: | Monning | ||
Version: | March 28, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
SUBJECT: Fort Ord Reuse Authority: prevailing wages
KEY ISSUES
Should work performed within the territory of Fort Ord for which a contractor or subcontractor is required to pay prevailing wages pursuant to a resolution of the Ford Ord Reuse Authority, deed restriction, or covenant be deemed a “public work” for purposes of the Labor Code?
Should the Legislature specify that these requirements apply retroactively to work performed prior to the effective date of these provisions?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Requires that not less than the general prevailing rate of per diem wages be paid to all workers employed on a "public works" project costing over $1,000 dollars and imposes misdemeanor penalties for violation of this requirement. (Labor Code §1771)
- Defines "public work" to include, among other things, construction, alteration, demolition, installation or repair work done under contract and paid for in whole or in part out of public funds. [Labor Code §1720(a)]
- Defines “paid for in whole or in part out of public funds” as, among other things, “Fees, costs, rents, insurance or bond premiums, loans, interest rates, or other obligations normally required in the execution of a contract that are paid, reduced, charged at less than fair market value, waived or forgiven.” [Labor Code §1720(b)]
- Requires that the applicable general prevailing rate of per diem wages be determined by the Director of the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) for each locality in which the public work is to be performed and for each craft, classification, or type of worker needed to execute the public works project. (Labor Code §1773)
- Provides that private residential projects built on private property are not subject to the requirements of public works provisions, unless the projects are built pursuant to an agreement with a state agency, redevelopment agency, or local public housing authority. [Labor Code §1720(c)(1)]
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner, or their designee, to issue civil wage and penalty assessments on a contractor or subcontractor, or both, that fails to pay prevailing wages in connection with a public work. (Labor Code §1741)
- Establishes the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Act authorizing specified local agencies to establish the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) as a public corporation of the state and authorizes the authority’s board to adopt the Fort Ord Reuse Plan, as specified. Existing law requires the board of the authority to prepare, adopt, review, revise from time to time, and maintain a plan for the future use and development of the territory occupied by Fort Ord in the County of Monterey. (Government Code §§67650-67700)
- Specifies that the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Act becomes inoperative when the board determines that 80 percent of the territory designated for development or reuse in the plan has been developed or reused, as specified, or June 30, 2020, whichever occurs first, and on January 1, 2021, the provisions of the Act are repealed. (Government Code §67700)
This bill:
- Specifies that work performed within the territory of Fort Ord for which a contractor or subcontractor is required to pay prevailing wages pursuant to a resolution of the board, deed restriction, or covenant shall be deemed “public works.”
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner, for the purpose of enforcing compliance with specified prevailing wage and payroll record provisions, to issue civil wage and penalty assessments to a contractor or subcontractor that violates these provisions.
- Specifies that these requirements shall apply retroactively to work performed prior to the effective date of these provisions.
- Specifies that the requirements and remedies provided by these provisions are in addition to any requirements and remedies otherwise provided by law.
- Requires contractors and subcontractors entering into any contract to perform public work within the territory of Fort Ord to register with the Department of Industrial Relations, as specified.
- Specifies that notwithstanding the sunset provisions for the Fort Ord Reuse Authority, these provisions shall remain in effect until all work covered has been completed, all enforcement actions have concluded, and the time limitations for such enforcement actions have expired.
COMMENTS
1. Background on “Public Works” and Prevailing Wage:
Existing law requires that not less than the general prevailing wage rate of per diem wages, as determined by the director of the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), be paid to all workers employed on a “public works” projects. The prevailing wage rate is the basic hourly rate paid on public works projects to a majority of workers engaged in a particular craft, classification or type of work within the locality and in the nearest labor market area. The determination of whether a project is deemed a "public work" is important because the Labor Code requires (except for projects of $1,000 or less) that the prevailing wage be paid to all workers employed on public works projects.
In general, "public works" is defined to include construction, alteration, demolition, installation or repair work done under contract and "paid for in whole or in part out of public funds." Almost twenty years ago, there was much administrative and legislative action over what constituted the term "paid for in whole or in part out of public funds." These debates culminated in the enactment of SB 975 (Alarcón), Chapter #938, Statutes of 2001, which codified a definition of "paid for in whole or in part out of public funds" as well as exempted certain affordable housing, residential and private development projects, as specified. Currently, “paid for in whole or in part out of public funds” is defined as, among other things, “fees, costs, rents, insurance or bond premiums, loans, interest rates, or other obligations normally required in the execution of a contract that are paid, reduced, charged at less than fair market value, waived or forgiven.”
2. Background on the Fort Ord Reuse Authority:
Following the end of the Cold War, the federal government closed or realigned almost three dozen military bases in California. In an effort to coordinate the transition of the former army base located at Fort Ord in Monterey County, the Legislature enacted the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Act through SB 899 (Mello, 1994), creating the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA). FORA is governed by a board of 13 voting members comprised of representatives from the surrounding cities, Monterey County, and 10 ex officio nonvoting members that includes representatives from public educational institutions, school districts, the military, water and transportation agencies, and state and federal legislators.
Among other things, FORA is required to prepare, adopt, review and revise from time to time, and maintain a plan for the future use and development of the 45 square mile/28,000 acre territory of Fort Ord, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, and public open space. FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997.
3. Fort Ord Reuse Authority Master Resolution:
Following the creation of the FORA, the governing board adopted the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Master Resolution on March 14, 1997. Among other things, the resolution included a section titled “Procurement Code” which included provisions concerning the required payment of prevailing wages for all workers employed on construction. In March 2007, the Master Resolution was amended to provide further clarity on its prevailing wage policy, stating that:
“Not less than the general prevailing rate of wages for work of a similar character in Monterey County, as determined by the Director of the Department of Industrial Relations under Division 2, Part 7, Chapter 1 of the California Labor Code, will be paid to all workers employed on the First Generation Construction performed on parcels subject to the Fort Ord Base Reuse Plan. This subsection applies to work performed under Development Entitlements as defined in §1.01.050 of this Master Resolution and by contract with a FORA member or a FORA member agency including their transferees, agents, successors-in-interest, developers or building contractors. All contractors performing “First Generation Construction” must be registered and in good standing with the California Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) as defined in California Labor Code section 1725.5 [with limited exceptions from this requirement for bid purposes only under Labor Code section 1771.1(a).]”
(FORA Master Resolution §3.03.090)
In addition to the Master Resolution, the policy requiring the payment of prevailing wages has been included in requests for qualifications/proposals as the land has been developed, as well as in deed restrictions as land has been transferred from Ford Ord to cities for development. One such example, FORA entered into an “Implementation Agreement” with the City of Marina in 2001 for the transfer of property. In the recorded agreement, the FORA required the City to use or transfer any such property in compliance with the Master Resolution and included stipulations that “Any development of the property will be and is subject to the provisions of the Reuse Plan, the policies and programs of the Fort Ord Reuse Authority, including the Authority’s Master Resolution…” “This Deed Restriction and Covenants…is hereby deemed and agreed to be a covenant running with the land binding all of the Owner’s assigns or successors in interest.” (Monterey/Santa Cruz County Building and Construction Trades Council v. Cypress Marina Heights, (2011) 191 Cal.App.4th, 1500)
4. Need for this bill?
Although specifically required under the Master Resolution, deed restrictions and covenants, there appears to be disagreement on whether or not projects within the territory of Fort Ord should be required to pay prevailing wages to all workers.
There have been legal actions taken against some developers for failure to pay prevailing wages on these projects. In one such case, Monterey/Santa Cruz County Building and Construction Trades Council v. Cypress Marina Heights, the developer argued that the Master Resolution’s provisions did not apply to its project because those provisions were limited to public works and to those in privity (close, mutual or successive relationship) with FORA. They also argued that those covenants did not run with the land. The Superior Court of Monterey County found in favor of the plaintiffs and granted summary judgment and awarded attorney’s fees, and the developer appealed. The Sixth District Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment and held that:
- city's redevelopment agency was obligated by master resolution to require developer to pay the prevailing wage to workers on redevelopment of former military base property;
- redevelopment agency had to include in its deeds to project developer covenants requiring developer to pay the prevailing wage;
- developer was required by covenants to pay prevailing wage;
- unions and association of local contractors had standing to bring action; and
- trial court did not abuse its discretion in awarding plaintiffs attorney fees.
According to proponents, other similar cases have been litigated and have also been found to require the payment of prevailing wages on these projects. However, as the author argues, because the Master Resolution is not in State Code, the Department of Industrial Relations does not have authority to enforce prevailing wage requirements forcing workers to have to file lawsuits to receive their rightful wage.
SB 533 would deem as “public works,” work performed within the territory of Fort Ord for which a contractor or subcontractor is required to pay prevailing wages pursuant to a resolution of the board, deed restriction, or covenant. The bill would also authorize the Labor Commissioner to issue civil wage and penalty assessments to enforce compliance with existing prevailing wage and payroll record provisions in labor code. The bill also specifies that these requirements shall apply retroactively to work performed prior to the effective date of these provisions.
5. Staff Comment:
The language of this bill is proposed as an addition to Government Code provisions governing the Fort Ord Authority with cross references to Labor Code sections dealing with prevailing wages and payroll records. The bill also requires the Labor Commissioner to enforce the prevailing wage requirement and requires contractors and subcontractors to register with the Department of Industrial Relations to perform public work within the territory of Fort Ord. Traditionally, when bills come through this committee with the goal of extending prevailing wage requirements onto a specific type of work, they are included under the definition of “public works” and included in the Labor Code beginning with Section 1720. These Labor Code provisions already include Labor Commissioner enforcement of prevailing wages, as well as registrations with the Department of Industrial Relations.
The author may wish to explore the option of amending the Labor Code instead of the Government to capture the same requirements and be consistent with existing provisions dealing with public works and prevailing wage requirements on other projects.
6. Proponent Arguments:
According to the Monterey/Santa Cruz Counties Building and Construction Trades Council, once formed, the Fort Ord Reuse Authority adopted a Master Resolution to govern its operations of which section 3.03.090 expressly requires prevailing wages to be paid to workers on construction projects at Fort Ord. They argue that for these reasons, any claim that SB 533 increases labor costs or expands prevailing wages is inaccurate, as prevailing wages have always been part of the Authority’s mandate at Fort Ord.
Additionally, proponents argue that Fort Ord construction projects have also received the benefit of public funding. They note that the Authority disposes of Fort Ord property by conveying it to its “member agencies,” i.e. Monterey County and the local cities, at no cost. The member agencies then convey parcels for development to private developers at a reduced price, typically what is considered the “fair reuse value” as opposed to the “fair market value,” to account for developer fees, prevailing wage requirements, on-site mitigation, building removal, etc. They argue that because the developers (and the member agencies) pay less than fair market value, their construction projects are, in all likelihood, considered “public works” for purposes of the Labor Code.
Nevertheless, they argue, over the years, developers, contractors, and even public agencies have claimed they are not responsible for enforcing the payment of prevailing wages. They note that when wage complaints are made internally, they do not appear to be investigated by the developer or any public agency. Proponents argue that as a result of this lack of accountability, wage theft has gone unchecked, forcing workers to either continue working for less or pursue their wages via lawsuit or state wage complaints, both of which are lengthy, difficult, and risk retaliation. They argue that the best way to avoid wage theft is for developers and contractors to abide by the law in the first place, and to provide for real and effective oversight. They believe this bill is necessary to clarify that Fort Ord projects are public works subject to Labor Code requirements and state oversight.
7. Opponent Arguments:
The California Building Industry Association (CBIA) is opposed to the bill and write:
“We have identified SB 533 as a Housing-Killer because of the bad precedent it would establish and the added costs the bill will impose on the production of homes in California. The bill, for the first time, mandates that a project is a “public works”, not because it meets the criteria of a public works project (see, Labor Code Section 1720), but simply because of its geographic location. The bill creates a framework for expanding prevailing wage obligations to private residential construction projects with the unprecedented notion that the state will enforce regardless of actual jurisdiction.
SB 533 also mandates that the determination of “public works” be applied retroactively in this geographic location after more than a decade of construction work. This means that any contractor involved in construction in this region would be subject to brand new bankrupting fines, penalties and liquidated damages for decades old work, with no ability to remedy the situation.”
8. Related Legislation:
SB 189 (Monning, 2019), pending in Senate Appropriations Committee: would extend the sunset date on the FORA provisions from June 30, 2020 to June 30, 2022. Additionally, the bill would significantly restrict the powers and responsibilities of FORA’s board, outline a limited set of powers for the new board, details the FORA dissolution process, and exempts the FORA transition plan from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). SB 189 also requires specific action from the FORA regarding its dissolution, including implementing a transition plan that negotiates and secures one or more successor agencies to implement all obligations under the transition.
SUPPORT
Monterey/Santa Cruz Counties Building and Construction Trades Council
OPPOSITION
California Building Industry Association
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):