SB 545: Driving under the influence: ignition interlock devices.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-01
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 9, 2019 | July 9 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 34. Noes 1.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | April 29 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 22, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB545 Hill et al. Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 545
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
SUMMARY: : Imposes a mandatory Ignition Interlock Device (IID) requirement on persons convicted of a first time offense for Driving Under the Influence (DUI). Adds the requirement to the existing IID pilot program. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person convicted of a first DUI to install and maintain an IID in the vehicle for a term of six months.
- Deletes the option for a court to impose a license suspension, without an IID, with an opportunity for a restricted driver’s license if the person in compliance with specified conditions.
- Extends the deadline for the pilot program from January 1, 2026, to January 1, 2027.
- Changes the date of the DMV report regarding the efficacy of the pilot program to on or before March 1, 2025. The report shall disaggregate data from before and after the changes to the pilot program contained in this bill.
- States that each IID manufacturer shall maintain a participant file for every person whom they provide an IID to under the pilot program.
- Requires the participant file to include information and records related to the installation, service, calibration, and removal of the device and shall include all data retrieved from the data storage system of the device.
- Requires a participant file to be stored in either paper or electronic format, as determined by the manufacturer.
- Requires a participant file to be stored and secured at all times in a manner that reasonably prevents unauthorized access to the records.
- Specifies that DMV, or a person authorized by DMV, shall have access to all participant files and the manufacturer shall provide online access to participant files that are stored electronically to the department.
- Makes conforming date changes to other provisions of law.
- Makes Legislative findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Creates a pilot project that requires a person convicted of a second or subsequent DUI (alcohol) to install and maintain an IID for 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a third offense and for 36 months for a fourth or subsequent offense. Proof of installation of the interlock device, along with other requirement, permits a person to get a restricted license after a specified period of time. Provides that the IID pilot project shall sunset on January 1, 2026. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; 13353.75, 23573, 23575.3.)
- Specifies that under the pilot program a person convicted of a DUI (alcohol) with no priors may be required to install a DUI by the court sentencing the defendant. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i-iii).)
- States that when a defendant is convicted of a DUI (alcohol) with no priors, only one of the following may occur:
- The court may order installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. If the court orders the ignition interlock device restriction, the term shall be determined by the court for a period not to exceed six months from the date of conviction. DMV shall place the restriction on the driver’s license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term; or
- The person may apply to DMV for a restriction of their driving privilege, as specified, if they comply with other requirements to enroll in a DUI education class, pay fees, and carry specified insurance (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i-iii).).
- The court may order installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. If the court orders the ignition interlock device restriction, the term shall be determined by the court for a period not to exceed six months from the date of conviction. DMV shall place the restriction on the driver’s license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term; or
- Prohibits any person who is under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code Section 23152(a).)
- Prohibits any person, while having 0.08% or more, by weight, of alcohol in his or her blood to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code Section 23152(b).)
- Prohibits any person, while under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle and concurrently do any act forbidden by law, or neglect any duty imposed by law in driving the vehicle, and consequently proximately causing bodily injury to any person other than the driver. (Vehicle Code Section 23153(a).)
- Prohibits any person, while having 0.08% or more, by weight, of alcohol in his or her blood to drive a vehicle and concurrently do any act forbidden by law, or neglect any duty imposed by law in driving the vehicle, and consequently proximately causing bodily injury to any person other than the driver. (Vehicle Code Section 23153(b).)
- Subjects a person who is convicted of a first DUI (without injury) of the following penalties:
- Possible 48 hours to 6 months in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus penalty assessments;
- Completion of a 3-month treatment program, or a 9-month program if the blood alcohol content (BAC) was .20% or more; and,
- Suspension or revocation of driving privileges for 6 months or 10 months, as specified. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352, 23536, 23538)
- Possible 48 hours to 6 months in jail;
- Subjects a person who is convicted of a second DUI (without injury) within 10 years of a prior specified offense of the following penalties:
- If the sentence includes probation:
- 96 hours to 1 year in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus penalty assessments;
- Completion of an 18-month or 30-month driving-under-the-influence program; and,
- Suspension of driving privileges for two years. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352, 23542.)
- 96 hours to 1 year in jail;
- If the sentence does not include probation:
- 90 days to 1 year in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus penalty assessments; and,
- Suspension of driving privileges for two years. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352, 23540.)
- 90 days to 1 year in jail;
- If the sentence includes probation:
- Subjects a person who is convicted of a third DUI (without injury) within 10 years of a prior specified offense of the following penalties:
- Imprisonment in county jail pursuant to realignment or for 120 days to 1 year in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus penalty assessments; and,
- Suspension of driving privileges for three years. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352, 23546.)
- Imprisonment in county jail pursuant to realignment or for 120 days to 1 year in jail;
- Provides that if a first-time DUI offender is found to have a BAC of .20% or above or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall refer the offender to participate in a 9-month licensed program, as specified. (Veh. Code, § 23538(b)(2).)
- States a person whose driving privilege is restricted by the court pursuant to this section shall arrange for each vehicle with an IID to be serviced by the installer at least once every 60 days in order for the installer to recalibrate and monitor the operation of the device. The installer shall notify the court if the device is removed or indicates that the person has attempted to remove, bypass, or tamper with the device, or if the person fails three or more times to comply with any requirement for the maintenance or calibration of the IID. There is no obligation for the installer to notify the court if the person has complied with all of the requirements of this article. (Veh. Code, § 23575(d).)
- States that the law requiring the court to order an IID for a person found guilty of driving on a suspended licenses, as specified, does not restrict a court from requiring installation of a IID and prohibiting operation of a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a IID for a person that did not commit an offense involving driving on a suspended license. The term of the restriction shall be determined by the court for a period not to exceed three years from the date of conviction. (Veh. Code, § 23575.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "SB 545, the Matthew Klotzbach Mandatory Ignition Interlock for DUI Offender Act of 2019, requires all DUI offenders to install an Ignition Interlock Device (IID) in order to reinstate their full driving privileges.
“More than 1,000 people die and over 20,000 are injured each year in California because of drunk driving. Over the ten-year period from 2006 to 2015, 9,226 people were killed on California roads in crashes involving a drunk driver over the current limit of .08 percent BAC, according to National Highway Transportation Safety Administration.
“There is clear evidence that IIDs help reduce drunk driving and keep our roads safe. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) states that IIDs are effective in reducing DUI recidivism, sometimes by as much as 62 to 75 percent. Similarly, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that ignition interlocks reduce repeat offenses for driving while intoxicated (DWI) by about 70 percent. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that states that implemented.
“Thirty-three states and Washington D.C. have already implemented all offender IID laws and the NTSB and CDC recommend that all states do the same. SB 545 will improve California’s existing DUI laws and will help reduce crashes, injuries, and deaths involving alcohol-impaired drivers.”
- 2016 Pilot Program: SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, established a pilot program requiring individuals convicted of two or more DUIs to put an IID on any car that they own or operate for specified periods of time, depending on the number of convictions. The pilot program includes an IID provision for 1st offense DUIs, but IIDs are not mandatory for a conviction on a 1st offense. The pilot program allows the court discretion to order installation of an IID on a 1st offense DUI that did not involve injury. A license suspension still goes into effect if the court does not impose an IID requirement. If the court does not impose an IID and the defendant elects to obtain a restricted license, the restriction will be in place for 12 months. The pilot program went into effect on January 1, 2019. The pilot program sunsets on January 1, 2026. DMV is required to submit a report to the legislature regarding the efficacy of the pilot program. Individuals that are convicted of a DUI that only involved drugs are not required to install an IID under the pilot program.
This bill would change the parameters of the pilot program that is currently operating by making installation of an IID mandatory for a 1st DUI offense. This bill would also extend the sunset date for the pilot program to January 1, 2027.
- Courts Have the Power to Require an IID for First Time DUI Offenders as Part of the Existing Pilot Program: The existing pilot program was crafted specifically to exclude first DUI offenders from the mandatory IID requirement. The existing IID pilot program gives courts discretion to impose an IID upon a first DUI offender. There are policy reasons to treat 1st DUI offenders differently from multiple DUI offenders. The pilot program requires mandatory IID on multiple offenders that failed to change their behavior subsequent to their initial DUI conviction. By allowing the courts discretion to impose an IID on first time offenders, it provides the court an opportunity to tailor the sentence in appropriate manner to the facts of the crime, the person’s history, and the person’s current circumstances.
A judge may determine that an IID is not the most appropriate remedy when a person has been convicted of a first time DUI and there is no evidence of alcohol abuse or other history of poor judgment. A court might find that imposition of an IID is not the best remedy if the defendant is part of a household where a single car is shared between the defendant and other family members and requiring an IID on that car will burden family members that have engaged in no wrongdoing.
"Society receives maximum protection when the penalty, treatment or disposition of the offender is tailored to the individual case. Only the trial judge has the knowledge, ability and tools at hand to properly individualize the treatment of the offender." (People v. Williams (1970) 30 Cal. 3d 470,482, citation and internal quotation marks omitted.)
- Courts Have the Power to Impose IID as a Condition of Probation: In addition to the specific authority for a court to impose an IID pursuant to the pilot program, a court can also impose an IID as a condition of probation. Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendant. (People v. Smith (2007) 152, Cal.App.4th 1245, 1249.) Courts may impose any “reasonable conditions” necessary to secure justice, make amends to society and individuals injured by the defendant’s unlawful conduct, and assist the “reformation and rehabilitation of the probationer.” (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.) A valid condition must be reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring such misconduct in the future. (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114, 1121.)
As part of the court’s power to impose probation conditions that appropriate to assist in the rehabilitation of the probationer and to deter misconduct in the future, the court can impose an IID requirement as a condition of probation in a DUI case.
The court is in a position to evaluate the particular circumstances of the individual to fashion penalties that are most appropriate to the nature of the DUI and the rest of their life circumstances. The ability of the court to fashion a sentence that accounts for the totality of the defendant’s situation provides justice on an individualized basis. - A DUI Conviction Results in Numerous Sanctions in Addition to the Possible Imposition of an IID: A conviction for a DUI results in exposure to jail time and mandatory minimum fine which is roughly $1400. Conviction of a DUI requires participation in a DUI/traffic educational program which can range from 3 months to 30 months, depending on the number of prior convictions a defendant has suffered. A conviction includes license suspension or revocation which can range from 6 months up to multiple years. Additionally, DUI conviction triggers the requirement that defendant carry additional insurance in the form of an SR-22 insurance certificate.
- Results from the 4 County Pilot Project: A four county pilot project involving mandatory IID installation upon conviction of any DUI offense began in 2009. That program was started by AB 91 (Feuer), Chapter 217, Statutes of 2009. As part of that pilot program, DMV was tasked with reporting on the efficacy of the program.
A June 17, 2016 DMV report on the IID pilot project evaluated the project from two perspectives, an “intent to treat” evaluation and “the restricted license evaluation.”
“Intent to Treat” was the group of individuals subject to the requirement that they install and IID, regardless of whether they installed an IID and complied with the law. “The restricted license evaluation” consisted of the individuals that were subject to the IID mandate and complied with the requirements of the program. DMV found that the IID-restricted license program had “mixed traffic safety impacts.”
For first offenders in the pilot project the study found in the Intent-to-Treat Evaluation:
FIRST DUI OFFENDERS
- The AB 91 program is not associated with an increase or decrease in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction over the 12-month time period.
- The AB 91 program is not associated with a reduction or increase in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident over the 12-month time period.
- First offenders in non-pilot counties have a 6.1% lower hazards or odds of a subsequent crash relative to those in the pilot counties over the 12-month time period. “California DMV, “ Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California.” p. xi, June 17, 2016” https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/b1eba1e5-9155-40ba-9a74-0e6e19a0d1bc/S5-251.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
For first offenders in the Restricted License Evaluation portion the study found that for people with an IID, while there was an initial lower rate DUI in the first 182 days following their conviction, that lower rate diminished over time. In addition, there was a higher rate of hazards or subsequent crashes with those with the IID and that trend increased over the 12 month period. (Id. p. xii)
The study also found that:
The study findings indicate a negative association between having an IID-restricted license and subsequent crash involvement for all DUI offender groups. For the first and second DUI offenders, higher crash risk among those with the AB 91 IID-restricted license increases over time relative to DUI offenders with a suspended license. Therefore, although the AB 91 IID program is associated with a significant reduction in DUI recidivism among all DUI offender groups, the program is also associated with an increase in crash involvement among all DUI offenders that are subject to the program. This is particularly problematic since a substantial proportion of these crashes are those involving injuries and/or fatalities (of the overall crash involvement measured in the study, the proportion of fatal/injury crashes ranged from mid-30% to low-40% for different DUI offender groups—which is consistent with what prior California evaluations have reported for these offender groups). (Id. p. xv)
- Argument in Support: According to Coalition of Ignition Interlock Manufacturers, “Under the current pilot program, which was established by the enactment of SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, first offenders who are involved in a crash that results in injury, as well as repeat offenders, are required to install and IID upon conviction. This bill provides for a comprehensive program by requiring that all first offenders install a device for six months. The bill provides an incentive for early removal by allowing for early installation credit for devices that are installed pre-trial and extends the pilot until January 1, 2027 to ensure that the best data is being collected on the efficacy of IIDs.
“According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), drunk driving killed 1,120 people in 2017 in California. Over the past 12 years, IIDs have prevented over 246,042 attempts to drive drunk in California. Installation of an IID allows for persons to resume their daily routine without impediment, while protecting public safety and teaching safe driving habits.
“Recent research has demonstrated that IIDs can significantly reduce the rate of recidivism among drivers convicted of DUI making them more effective than other prevention methods. Drivers with IIDs also had fewer alcohol-impaired driving crashes than drivers who had their driver’s licenses suspended because of a DUI conviction. The primary research, among other recent information, is a Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) study that conducted a systematic review that considered a total of 15 studies, and reached the following 4 conclusions:
1. While IIDs were installed, recidivism rates decreased by about 67%.
2. When IIDs were removed, recidivism rates reverted to rates similar to those of persons convicted of alcohol-impaired driving who had not used IIDs.
3. Drivers with IIDs installed had fewer alcohol-related crashes than those who had licenses suspended for an alcohol-impaired driving conviction;
4. Overall crash rates for drivers with IIDs were similar to those for the general driving population.
“According to the 2016 California DMV study, interlocks are 74 percent more effective in reducing repeat
“DUI offenses compared to license suspension alone. An ignition interlock is more effective than license suspension, as up to 75 percent of convicted drunk drivers continue to drive on a suspended license.” - Argument in Opposition: According to the California Public Defenders Association, “Senate Bill 545 would, as its primary measure, make installation of ignition interlock devices on vehicles operated by individuals convicted of a first offense DUI mandatory. Under current law, effective January 1 of this year, courts have discretion to order first offenders to install an ignition interlock device (IID), but if they do not they must restrict that offenders privilege to drive to driving to and from work, in the necessary scope of work, and to and from any court ordered drunk driving program. This bill would also make its provisions effective immediately, as an urgency measure.
“It is instructive to examine the California history of IID’s as a condition of DUI probation. Until 2009 installation of an IID was ordered only for repeat drunk drivers because a large majority of those convicted of a first DUI are never convicted of a second, and it was felt that the risk of re-offending was so low that the deterrent or preventative effect of installing an IID did not justify the additional cost, inconvenience and hardship to the first offender.
“SB 1046 was passed in 2016 making IID’s for first offenders the norm statewide. Courts could order an IID for any first offender, but if they didn’t, they were required to impose the alternative penalty of a restricted license, that is, driving strictly limited to driving to and from work, to and from any court ordered drunk driving program, and in the necessary scope of work.
“SB 545 is not evidence based. The 2016 DMV Report concluded that the pilot program should not be extended statewide and that further study was warranted. On one hand the report noted that over the short term (six months) the pilot program resulted in fewer DUI convictions. However, the report found the reduced risk of recidivism had disappeared before the two-year mark. Even more worrisome, the 2016 DMV report found that the pilot program showed higher odds of crashes verses the comparison group. For the first 300 days after a DUI conviction and installation of the IID the incidence of crashes was virtually equal between the pilot program and the comparison groups, but between 300 and 730 days afterwards it was 58% higher and after 730 days it was 116% higher. Finally, the authors of the 2016 DMV report did not recommend that the pilot program be extended statewide, and did not believe the evidence justified such a course. As a matter fact, the report stated that the pilot program showed ‘mixed traffic safety results.’ Instead, the authors recommended that the matter be studied further, and gave several concrete steps in furtherance thereof.
“The authors found that license suspensions and revocations provide the best deterrent effect, and that cumulative and progressively more onerous punitive measures had the tendency to produce a negative effect because some drivers become overwhelmed and give up trying to satisfy all those conditions, thus voiding the deterrent effect that more measured, and achievable, sanctions could provide.
“SB 545 seeks to deny judges the discretion to exercise their wisdom and good judgment in a myriad of individual, and sometimes extraordinary, circumstances to vary from the inflexible norm in order to fashion just sentences as they see fit. This bill removes the courts discretion, in appropriate cases, to delete what may be, for some individuals, such a harsh and counterproductive penalty in favor of a more measured and effective condition. While we believe that IIDs for first offenders was imprudently enacted without sufficient supporting evidence of need, we recognize that is now history. What we urge is that this bill be rejected because it imposes a ‘one size fits all’ form of justice and removes a very modest and measured form of alternative, discretionary justice. As the DMV report notes, such measured justice may very well be a more effective deterrent than more inflexible and onerous provisions. - Related Legislation:
- AB 974 (Cooley), would have allowed a court to require a person convicted of two offenses of DUI within 10 years to submit to continuous alcohol testing at that person’s own cost. AB 974 was never heard in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- SB 144 (Mitchell), would eliminate a number of fees for criminal defendants, including fees for IIDs. SB 144 is set for hearing in the Assembly Public Safety Committee on July 9, 2019.
- AB 974 (Cooley), would have allowed a court to require a person convicted of two offenses of DUI within 10 years to submit to continuous alcohol testing at that person’s own cost. AB 974 was never heard in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, established a pilot program requiring individuals convicted of two or more DUIs, as specified, to put an IID on any car that they own or operate.
- SB 61 (Hill), Chapter 350, Statutes of 2015, extended the IID pilot project in Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento, and Tulare Counties until July 1, 2017.
- SB 55 (Hill), of the Legislative Session of 2013-2014, would have required, as a condition of being issued a restricted driver’s license, being reissued a driver’s license, or having the privilege to operate a motor vehicle reinstated for a 2nd or subsequent conviction for a DUI offense, installation for a specified period of time an ignition interlock device on all vehicles a person owns or operates. SB 55 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 598 (Huff), Chapter 193, Statutes of 2009, allowed individual convicted of more than one DUI within a 10 year period to get a restricted driver’s license upon installation of an IID, enrolling in DUI class, and meeting other specified criteria. Individuals are not eligible for the restricted license until they have served between 90 days to one year of the suspension, depending on offense and number of priors.
- AB 91 (Feuer), Chapter 217, Statutes of 2009, established a pilot program in Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento, and Tulare Counties, administered by DMV to require the installation of IIDs on the vehicles of all persons convicted of a DUI, as specified.
- AB 2784 (Feuer), of the 2007-08 Legislative Session, would have required a person convicted of a DUI, as specified, to install an IID, as specified, in order to be reissued a license, receive a restricted license, or receive a reinstated license. AB 2784's provisions were removed from that bill in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations and replaced with the provisions of SB 1361. AB 2784 was gutted, amended, and subsequently vetoed.
- SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, established a pilot program requiring individuals convicted of two or more DUIs, as specified, to put an IID on any car that they own or operate.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
Alcohol Justice
Automobile Club of Southern California
California Alcohol Policy Alliance
California Ambulance Association
California Medical Association
California Peace Officers Association
California Police Chiefs Association
Coalition of Ignition Interlock Manufacturers
FiA Foundation
KidsAndCars.Org
Mothers Against Drunk Driving
National Safety Council
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Prevention Institute
San Diego City Attorney's Office
San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Trauma Foundation
Vision Zero Network
1 private individual
Oppose
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Analysis Prepared by: David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 545 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 545
Amended: 4/23/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/9/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
SUBJECT: Driving under the influence: ignition interlock devices
DIGEST:
This bill adds a mandatory ignition interlock device (IID) requirement on first time DUIs to an existing IID pilot program and to require an extension of the IID installation requirement if a person has a failed start 60 days prior to the end of their installation requirement.
Existing law:
- Provides it is unlawful for any person who is under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code § 23152(a).)
- Provides that it is unlawful for any person, while having 0.08 percent or more, by weight, of alcohol in his or her blood to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code § 23152(b).)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI is subject to the following penalties when given probation:
- possible 48 hours to six months in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus approximately 310% penalty assessments;
- completion of a three-month treatment program or a nine-month program if the BAC was .20% or more;
- six month license suspension or 10 month suspension if anine-month program is ordered; and
- restricted license may be sought upon proof of enrollment or completion of program, proof of financial responsibility and payment of fees. However, the court may disallow the restricted license. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352 (a)(1); 13352.1; 13352.4; 23538(a)(3).)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury is subject to the following penalties:
- 16 months, two or three years in state prison or 90 days to one year in county jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus 250% penalty assessments; and
- one year driver's license suspension. Or,
- Provides, when probation is given:
- five days to one year in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus 250% penalty assessments;
- one year license suspension;
- three-month treatment program or a nine-month program if the BAC was .20% or more, and;
- the additional penalties that apply to a first DUI without injury. (Vehicle Code § 23554.)
- Provides that if a first-offender DUI is found to have a blood concentration of .20% BAC or above or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall refer the offender to participate in a nine-month licensed program. (Vehicle Code § 23538 (b)(2).)
- Provides that a first-time DUI offender sentenced to a nine-month program because of a high BAC or a refusal shall have their license suspended for 10 months. The law further provides that their license may not be reinstated until the person gives proof of insurance and proof of completion of the required program. (Vehicle Code § 13352.1.)
- Provides that a person convicted of a first-time DUI may apply for a restricted license for driving to and from work and to and from a driver-under-influence program if specified requirements are met, paying all applicable fees, submitting proof of insurance and proof of participation in a program. (Vehicle Code § 13352.4.)
- Provides that a second or subsequent DUI offender can get his or her license reinstated earlier if he or she agrees to install an IID along with his or her enrollment in the required program, proof of insurance and payment of specified fees. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352(a)(3)(B); (a)(4) (B); (a)(5)(C); (a)(6)(B); (a)(7)(B)&(C))
- Created an IID pilot project in Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento and Tulare Counties requiring a person convicted of a DUI to install an IID for five months upon a first offense, 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a third offense and for 36 months for a fourth or subsequent offense. It required the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the IID pilot project to reduce the number of first-time violations and repeat DUI offenses. This pilot project was repealed on January 1, 2019, when a statewide pilot project took effect. (Vehicle Code § 23700; 23701)
- Creates a pilot project that requires a person convicted of a second or subsequent DUI or DUI causing injury to install and maintain an IID for 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a third offense and for 36 months for a fourth or subsequent offense. Proof of installation of the interlock device, along with other requirement, permits a person to get a restricted license after a specified period of time. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; 13353.75)
- Provides that the existing IID pilot project shall sunset on January 1, 2026.
This bill:
- Requires a person convicted of a first DUI to install and maintain and IID for the period of the person’s restricted license.
- Requires an IID installer to notify DMV if a person has any failed starts and would provide that if a person submits a failing breath sample within the last 60 days of an installation period that person will have to maintain the IID for an additional 60 days.
- Makes a number of legislative findings and declarations.
Background
- The Original Pilot Project
In 2009, AB 91 (Feuer) created an IID pilot project in four counties which mandated the use of an IID for all DUI offenders. DMV issued a report in June 2016 on the specific deterrent of the pilot project.
The rationale for a pilot project was to see what impact a mandatory IID program has on recidivism in California. While the impact of IID has been studied elsewhere, with mixed results, the comparisons are not perfect because while some of the other states began mandating IID at the same time they strengthened other sanctions, California has had a complex group of sanctions including high fines, jail time, licensing sanctions, mandatory drinker-driver treatment programs and optional IID in place since the mid-1980’s with sanctions being evaluated, changed and strengthened on an ongoing basis since. The thought was that with a pilot project, DMV can evaluate how best a mandatory IID system should work in California. By evaluating four counties, the counties without the mandatory programs act like a control group for the researchers at DMV. Evaluating how the DUI sanctions work is something DMV researchers have been doing with great success since 1990. DMV’s reports have helped inform the Legislature on where changes needed to be made and have helped reduce recidivism in California.
SB 1046 (Hill, Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016) deleted the four county pilot project when it created a statewide IID pilot project for repeat offender DUI.
- Results from the Four County Pilot Project
A June 17, 2016, DMV report on the IID pilot project evaluated the project from two perspectives, an “intent to treat” evaluation and “the restricted license evaluation.”
For first offenders in the pilot project the study found in the Intent-to-Treat Evaluation:
FIRST DUI OFFENDERS
- The AB 91 program is not associated with an increase or decrease in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction over the 12-month time period.
- The AB 91 program is not associated with a reduction or increase in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident over the 12-month time period.
- First offenders in non-pilot counties have a 6.1% lower hazards or odds of a subsequent crash relative to those in the pilot counties over the 12-month time period. “California DMV, “ Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California.” p. xi, June 17, 2016” [https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/b1eba1e5-9155-40ba-9a74-0e6e19a0d1bc/S5-251.pdf?MOD=AJPERES]
For first offenders in the Restricted License Evaluation portion the study found that for people with an IID, while there was an initial lower rate DUI in the first 182 days following their conviction, that lower rate diminished over time. In addition, there was a higher rate of hazards or subsequent crashes with those with the IID and that trend increased over the 12 month period. (Id. p. xii)
The study also found that:
The study findings indicate a negative association between having an IID-restricted license and subsequent crash involvement for all DUI offender groups. For the first and second DUI offenders, higher crash risk among those with the AB 91 IID-restricted license increases over time relative to DUI offenders with a suspended license. Therefore, although the AB 91 IID program is associated with a significant reduction in DUI recidivism among all DUI offender groups, the program is also associated with an increase in crash involvement among all DUI offenders that are subject to the program. This is particularly problematic since a substantial proportion of these crashes are those involving injuries and/or fatalities (of the overall crash involvement measured in the study, the proportion of fatal/injury crashes ranged from mid-30% to low-40% for different DUI offender groups—which is consistent with what prior California evaluations have reported for these offender groups). (Id. p. xv)
- Mandatory Installation of IID for first offenders
This bill requires any person convicted of a first DUI to install an IID on all the cars he or she owns for a six months. A person would get credit for an IID installed during the time of the person’s restricted license but prior to conviction.
Existing penalties for a first time DUI include the $390 to $1,000 fine, which with penalty assessments is approximately $1,599-$4,100; a three- or nine-month program; restricted license for six months and various fees for getting their license reinstated and getting reinsured. Is the additional mandatory installation of an IID appropriate? DMV has cautioned over the years that adding sanctions can cause some of those convicted to opt out of the licensing system:
There is a tendency over time to add new requirements or introduce new programs that DUI offenders must comply with in order to relicense. However, as DeYoung argued in his recent paper (2013), continuing to add new requirements may result in discouraging DUI offenders altogether from complying with all conditions to reinstate their driving privilege and indirectly forcing them out of reach of the postlicensing control system. Therefore, before a new requirement is added to the already complicated set of DUI countermeasures in California, any such new requirements must demonstrate “convincing traffic safety benefits” (DeYoung, 2013). (Id. at p. xviii)
According to the most recent report from DMV on DUI Sanctions.
DUI arrests decreased by 8.6% in 2015, following decreases of 3.5% in 2014 and 7.2% in 2013.
And,
The 1-year DUI reoffense rate for first DUI offenders arrested in 2014 was 3.7% compared to 7.6% in 1990. The 1-year reoffense rate for second DUI offenders was 4.7% compared to 9.7% in 1990. Each of these represents slightly over 50% fewer reoffenses compared to that of 1990 arrestees. (California DMV “2017 Annual Report of the California DUI Management Information System” p. iv and v” [https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/ connect/848b335c-1360-4473-a35d-4da3345c666a/S5-257.pdf?MOD= AJPERES&CVID=)]
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- IID program update: Unknown, potentially-significant costs to DMV in the mid- to high hundreds of thousands of dollars in one-time costs to make information system changes to reflect the IID program requirements proposed by this measure, with lower ongoing annual costs thereafter. It is unclear if the cost recovery mechanism in existing law could be used to cover these expenses without the department updating relevant regulations already promulgated, which itself would incur additional one-time costs. (Special fund*)
- IID verification & processing: Unknown, potentially-significant increases in annual costs for additional manual transaction time and workload required at DMV field offices and headquarters to verify and process a likely-significant increase of IID installations for applications for restricted driver licenses. It is unclear if the fee that DMV has determined to cover costs to operate the existing IID program would be sufficient to cover costs associated with the expansion proposed by this measure. If not, the department would need to revise the fee amount to cover the higher costs involved, which itself would lead to additional costs. (Special fund*)
- IID vendor oversight: Unknown investigation and enforcement costs to the Bureau of Electronic Appliance Repair, Home Furnishings and Thermal Insulation related to potentially-higher complaints filed against IID vendors resulting from a likely-significant increase in mandated IID users. (Special Fund**)
* Motor Vehicle Account
** Electronic and Appliance Repair Fund
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
Alcohol Justice
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Automobile Club of Southern California
California Medical Association
California Peace Officers’ Association
California Police Chiefs Association
Coalition of Ignition Interlock Manufacturers
FIA Foundation
KidsAndCARs
MADD
National Safety Council
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California
Prevention Institute
San Diego City Attorney’s Office
San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Trauma Foundation
Vision Zero Network
An individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT: According to MADD:
Ignition interlocks are effective in reducing repeat drunk driving offenses by 67 percent while the devise is installed compared to license suspension alone. (CDC)
Interlocks help reduce repeat offenses even after the device is removed by 39% compared to offenders who never installed an interlock. (Marcques, 2010)
First-time offenders are serious offenders. Research from the CDC indicates that first time offenders have driven drunk at least 80 times before they are arrested.
The Peace Officers’ Research Association of California states, “Ignition Interlock devices are proven to save lives. PORAC has always supported the use of these devices in lieu of driver’s license suspensions because it allows a person to go about routine: getting to their jobs; therefore, providing for their families. At the same time, these devices prove to be an effective deterrent to drinking and driving.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Public Defenders Association states:
It is instructive to examine the California history of IID’s as a condition of DUI probation. Until 2009 installation of an IID was ordered only for repeat drunk drivers because a large majority of those convicted of a first DUI are never convicted of a second, and it was felt that the risk of re-offending was so low that the deterrent or preventative effect of installing an IID did not justify the additional cost, inconvenience and hardship to the first offender.
There have been past legislative attempts to make IID mandatory for all first time offenders. In 2009, an effort was made to make IID’s mandatory for all first offenders. That attempt foundered on the shoals of common sense and the lack of empirical evidence that would support the need for such a measure. As a compromise, AB 91 was passed, establishing a pilot program requiring IIDs for first offenders in four counties and a DMV report in order to see whether there was the necessary evidence to justify its expansion statewide.
Two separate DMV reports demonstrate that the state wide expansion of mandatory IID’s for first time offenders is not warranted and may be counterproductive. The mandated 2014 DMV report on the pilot program’s effectiveness concluded that the pilot program did not justify a statewide expansion stating that “the pilot program was not associated with a reduction in the number of first-time and repeat DUI convictions in the pilot counties. In other words, no evidence was found that the pilot program has a general deterrent effect.” (emphasis added) (CAL-DMV-RSS-14-247) The Legislature extended the pilot program for two years to see whether additional time would provide supporting evidence for a statewide expansion. A new report produced by DMV in 2016 (CAL-DMV-RSS-16-251) concluded that the results of the pilot program were mixed and warranted further study.
SB 1046 was passed in 2016 making IID’s for first offenders the norm statewide. Courts could order an IID for any first offender, but if they didn’t they were required to impose the alternative penalty of a restricted license, that is, driving strictly limited to driving to and from work, to and from any court ordered drunk driving program, and in the necessary scope of work.
SB 545 is not evidence based. The 2016 DMV Report concluded that the pilot program should not be extended statewide and that further study was warranted. On one hand the report noted that over the short term (six months) the pilot program resulted in fewer DUI convictions. However, the report found the reduced risk of recidivism had disappeared before the two year mark. Even more worrisome, the 2016 DMV report found that the pilot program showed higher odds of crashes verses the comparison group. For the first 300 days after a DUI conviction and installation of the IID the incidence of crashes was virtually equal between the pilot program and the comparison groups, but between 300 and 730 days afterwards it was 58% higher and after 730 days it was 116% higher. Finally, the authors of the 2016 DMV report did not recommend that the pilot program be extended statewide, and did not believe the evidence justified such a course. As a matter fact, the report stated that the pilot program showed “mixed traffic safety results.” Instead, the authors recommended that the matter be studied further, and gave several concrete steps in furtherance thereof. The authors found that license suspensions and revocations provide the best deterrent effect, and that cumulative and progressively more onerous punitive measures had the tendency to produce a negative effect because some drivers become overwhelmed and give up trying to satisfy all those conditions, thus voiding the deterrent effect that more measured, and achievable, sanctions could provide.
SB 545 seeks to deny judges the discretion to exercise their wisdom and good judgment in a myriad of individual, and sometimes extraordinary, circumstances to vary from the inflexible norm in order to fashion just sentences as they see fit. This bill removes the courts discretion, in appropriate cases, to delete what may be, for some individuals, such a harsh and counterproductive penalty in favor of a more measured and effective condition. While we believe that IIDs for first offenders was imprudently enacted without sufficient supporting evidence of need, we recognize that is now history. What we urge is that this bill be rejected because it imposes a “one size fits all” form of justice and removes a very modest and measured form of alternative, discretionary justice. As the DMV report notes, such measured justice may very well be a more effective deterrent than more inflexible and onerous provisions.
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
5/18/19 13:01:40
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 545 (Hill) - Driving under the influence: ignition interlock devices
Version: April 23, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 29, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 545 would require the use of an ignition interlock device (IID) for all persons convicted of a first driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI) offense, as specified, and would require an extension of the IID use requirement if a person had a failed start, as defined, within 60 days prior to the end of the requirement.
Fiscal Impact:
- IID program update: Unknown, potentially-significant costs to the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) in the mid- to high hundreds of thousands of dollars in one-time costs to make information system changes to reflect the IID program requirements proposed by this measure, with lower ongoing annual costs thereafter. It is unclear if the cost recovery mechanism in existing law could be used to cover these expenses without the department updating relevant regulations already promulgated, which itself would incur additional one-time costs. (Special fund*)
- IID verification & processing: Unknown, potentially-significant increases in annual costs for additional manual transaction time and workload required at DMV field offices and headquarters to verify and process a likely-significant increase of IID installations for applications for restricted driver licenses. It is unclear if the fee that DMV has determined to cover costs to operate the existing IID program would be sufficient to cover costs associated with the expansion proposed by this measure. If not, the department would need to revise the fee amount to cover the higher costs involved, which itself would lead to additional costs. (Special fund*)
- IID vendor oversight: Unknown investigation and enforcement costs to the Bureau of Electronic Appliance Repair, Home Furnishings and Thermal Insulation related to potentially-higher complaints filed against IID vendors resulting from a likely-significant increase in mandated IID users. (Special Fund**)
*Motor Vehicle Account
**Electronic and Appliance Repair Fund
Background:
California employs a complex system of DUI sanctions, including fines, incarceration, licensing restrictions and suspensions, and mandatory DUI treatment programs. Moreover, DMV immediately suspends a driver license if a person is administratively found to have been operating a vehicle with a specified quantity of alcohol in their blood. Also included within the state’s system of sanctions is the requirement, until January 1, 2026, that every person criminally convicted of driving under the influence of alcohol with a prior DUI conviction (regardless of whether it caused injury) to install and maintain an IID for a specified period of time. For those convicted of a DUI for the first time, the court may order the person to use an IID for up to six months. Alternatively, if the court does not order the IID installation, the person may apply for a restricted license, as specified. If a person uses a functioning IID during the period of the person’s restricted licensure but before the criminal DUI conviction, DMV is required to credit the time of the use of a functioning IID towards any required period of IID use upon conviction.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require a person, upon the first criminal conviction of a DUI to install and maintain an IID for six months and would delete provisions allowing a restricted license in lieu of an IID for first-time offenders.
- Require DMV to credit any time that a person maintained a functioning IID during the period of that person’s restricted licensure, but prior to the criminal conviction, toward any term of maintaining such a device required by law upon conviction.
- Require the extension of the mandatory-IID-use period by 60 days if a person submits a breath sample within the last 60 days of required IID use with a breath alcohol concentration of over 0.03 percent, by weight of alcohol, in the person’s blood.
- Extend the IID requirements related to DUI convictions in existing law from January 1, 2026 to January 1, 2027.
- Require DMV to include disaggregated data from before and after the implementation of the statewide IID use requirement in the department’s report to the Transportation Agency about the implementation and efficacy of mandatory IID use by people convicted of DUIs.
- Make specified legislative findings and declarations.
Related Legislation:
SB 144 (Mitchell, 2019) would, among other things, delete the requirement that a person who is required to use an IID pay the costs of the IID program and the requirement that the person pay the fee to DMV to recover costs to operate the program. SB 144 is pending a hearing in this Committee.
SB 1046 (Hill, Ch. 783, Stats. 2016), until January 1, 2026, required the use of an IID for a specified period of time as a mandatory condition of receiving a restricted or reinstated driver privileges for all persons convicted of a repeat DUI and allowed the court to mandate IID use for defendants receiving a first DUI conviction.
SB 61 (Hill, Ch. 350, Stats. 2015) extended the sunset on the IID pilot project established by AB 91 (Feuer, Ch. 217, Stats. 2009) to July 1, 2017.
SB 55 (Hill, 2014) would have required a repeat DUI offenders to install an IID on their vehicles for a specified period of time in order to get a restricted license or to reinstate a driver license, as specified. SB 55 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 520 (Ammiano, Ch. 657, Stats. 2011) allowed a person convicted of alcohol-related reckless driving (i.e., a “wet reckless”) to apply for a restricted license early if the person complied with specified requirements, including installation of an IID.
AB 91 (Feuer, Ch. 217, Stats. 2009) established a four-county pilot program within the DMV that required a person convicted of driving under the influence to install an IID, as specified, on all vehicles the person owned or operated.
Staff Comment: Using statistical information compiled by DMV in its 2017 Annual Report of the California DUI Management Information System, from 2010 to 2015 (the last year that this specific report includes), it appears that first-time DUI offenders make up roughly two-thirds of DUI suspension and revocation actions, on average, for both administrative license suspensions (i.e., “admin per se” actions) and court-ordered license suspensions and revocations. This is out of an annual average of 144,306 total DUI-related post-conviction license suspensions and revocations from 2010 to 2015. Staff notes, however, that the total rate of all DUI-related convictions has been decreasing annually over this period. By expanding mandatory IID use to first-time offenders as proposed by SB 545, DMV would need to expand the IID program considerably to serve the higher number of participants. Costs, consequently, would increase to accommodate this increase in workload.
California has not qualified for federal incentive grant funding for IID usage due to the condition that state law require the IID mandate apply to all first-time DUI offenders. To the extent the state could qualify for, elect to apply, and subsequently receive such federal funding, it could serve to offset a portion of the costs of this measure.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 545 Hearing Date: April 9, 2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | February 22, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Driving Under the Influence: Ignition Interlock Devices
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: SB 1046 (Hill) Chapter 783, Stats. 2016
SB 61 (Hill) - Chaptered 350, Stats. 2015
SB 55 (Hill) - held in Assembly Appropriations (2013)
AB 520 (Ammiano) - Chapter 657, Stats. 2011
SB 598 (Huff) - Chapter 193, Stats. 2009
AB 91 (Feuer) - Chapter 217, Stats. 2009
SB 1190 (Oropeza) - Chapter 392, Stats. 2008
SB 1361 (Correa) - Vetoed (2008)
SB 1388 (Torlakson) - Chapter 404, Stats. 2008
AB 2784 (Feuer) - until August 28, 2008 version
SB 177 (Migden) - did not move (2007)
AB 4 (Bogh) - held in Assembly Appropriations (2005)
AB 979 (Runner) - Chapter 646, Stats. 2005
AB 638 (Longville) - prior to 7/2/2003 amends
died on Concurrence (2003)
AB 1026 (Levine) - failed Senate Public Safety (2003)
AB 762 (Torlakson) - Chapter 756, Stats. 1998
Support: Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety; Alcoholic Justice; American Academy of Pediatrics, California; California Medical Association; California Peace Officers’ Association; California Police Chiefs Association; KidsAndCARs; MADD; National Safety Council; North American Office & United Nations Representative; Peace Officers’ Research Association of California; Prevention Institute; San Diego City Attorney’s Office; San Diego County Board of Supervisors; Trauma Foundation; Vision Zero Network
Opposition: California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to add a mandatory IID requirement on first time DUIs to an existing IID pilot program and to require an extension of the IID installation requirement if a person has a failed start 60 days prior to the end of their installation requirement.
Existing law provides it is unlawful for any person who is under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code § 23152(a).)
Existing law provides that it is unlawful for any person, while having 0.08 percent or more, by weight, of alcohol in his or her blood to drive a vehicle. (Vehicle Code § 23152(b).)
Existing law provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI is subject to the following penalties when given probation:
- possible 48 hours to 6 months in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus approximately 310% penalty assessments;
- completion of a 3-month treatment program or a 9-month program if the BAC was .20% or more;
- 6 month license suspension or 10 month suspension if 9-month program is ordered; and
- Restricted license may be sought upon proof of enrollment or completion of program, proof of financial responsibility and payment of fees. However, the court may disallow the restricted license. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352 (a)(1); 13352.1; 13352.4; 23538(a)(3).)
Existing law provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury is subject to the following penalties:
- 16 months, 2 or 3 years in state prison or 90 days to 1 year in county jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus 250% penalty assessments; and
- 1 year driver's license suspension.
Or, when probation is given:
- 5 days to one year in jail;
- $390 to $1,000 fine plus 250% penalty assessments;
- 1 year license suspension;
- 3 month treatment program or a 9-month program if the BAC was .20% or more; and
- the additional penalties that apply to a first DUI without injury. (Vehicle Code § 23554.)
Existing law provides that if a first-offender DUI is found to have a blood concentration of .20% BAC or above or who refused to take a chemical test, the court shall refer the offender to participate in a 9-month licensed program. (Vehicle Code § 23538 (b)(2).)
Existing law provides that a first-time DUI offender sentenced to a 9-month program because of a high BAC or a refusal shall have their license suspended for 10 months. The law further provides that their license may not be reinstated until the person gives proof of insurance and proof of completion of the required program. (Vehicle Code § 13352.1.)
Existing law provides that a person convicted of a first-time DUI may apply for a restricted license for driving to and from work and to and from a driver-under-influence program if specified requirements are met, paying all applicable fees, submitting proof of insurance and proof of participation in a program. (Vehicle Code § 13352.4.)
Existing law provides that a second or subsequent DUI offender can get his or her license reinstated earlier if he or she agrees to install an Ignition Interlock Device (IID) along with his or her enrollment in the required program, proof of insurance and payment of specified fees. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352(a)(3)(B); (a)(4) (B); (a)(5)(C); (a)(6)(B); (a)(7)(B)&(C))
Existing law created an IID pilot project in Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento and Tulare Counties requiring a person convicted of a DUI to install an IID for 5 months upon a first offense, 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a 3rd offense and for 36 months for a 4th
or subsequent offense. It required DMV to report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the IID pilot project to reduce the number of first-time violations and repeat DUI offenses. This pilot project was repealed on January 1, 2019 when a statewide pilot project took effect. (Vehicle Code § 23700; 23701)
Existing law creates a pilot project that requires a person convicted of a second or subsequent DUI or DUI causing injury to install and maintain an IID for 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a 3rd offense and for 36 months for a 4th or subsequent offense.. Proof of installation of the interlock device, along with other requirement, permits a person to get a restricted license after a specified period of time. (Vehicle Code §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; 13353.75)
Existing law provides that the existing IID pilot project shall sunset on January 1, 2026.
This bill would require a person convicted of a first DUI to install and maintain and IID for the period of the person’s restricted license.
This bill would require an IID installer to notify DMV if a person has any failed starts and would provide that if a person submits a failing breath sample within the last 60 days of an installation period that person will have to maintain the IID for an additional 60 days.
This bill makes a number of legislative findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
SB 545, the Matthew Klotzbach Mandatory Ignition Interlock for DUI Offender Act of 2019, requires all DUI offenders to install an Ignition Interlock Device (IID) in order to reinstate their full driving privileges. 32 other states already require this. The bill contains assistance for low-income offenders which only requires them to pay 10% of the IID cost.
More than 1,000 people die and over 20,000 are injured each year in California as a result of drunk driving.
In 2009, the Legislature passed Assembly Bill 91 with nearly unanimous bipartisan support by votes of 78-0 in the Assembly and 31-4 in the Senate. The bill created a four-county pilot program in the Counties of Los Angeles, Sacramento, Alameda, and Tulare requiring ignition interlock devices (IID’s) for all DUI offenders.
In 2016, the Department of Motor Vehicles released a report on the pilot program from 2010 to 2016, stating that the department “found a strong and reliable association between possession of an AB 91 IID restricted license and reduced DUI recidivism. The report found that “the AB 91 IID group is associated with 73% lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers and 74% lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers.”
In 2016, a report released by Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) found that IIDs in California had prevented over 1 million instances of drinking and driving since 2010.
In 2016, Senate Bill 1046 was introduced to expand the pilot program’s IID requirement for all DUI offenders statewide. The bill passed in the Senate with unanimous bipartisan support by a vote of 39-0 and passed by votes of 10-0 in the Assembly Committee on Transportation, 16-0 in the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions, and 20-0 in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
An amendment to SB 1046 at the last minute made IIDs for first offenders optional instead of mandatory, contrary to findings in the Department of Motor Vehicles report that showed DUI offenders with IIDs are associated with 73 percent lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers and 74 percent lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers.
Effective January 1, 2019, IIDs are optional for first offenders as a result of SB 1046.
SB 545 mandates IIDs for first offenders consistent with the original pilot program and based on the findings by the Department of Motor Vehicles of “a strong and reliable association between possession of an AB 91 IID restricted license and reduced DUI recidivism.
2. The Original Pilot Project
In 2009, AB 91 (Feuer) created an IID pilot project in four counties which mandated the use of an IID for all DUI offenders. DMV issued a report in June 2016 on the specific deterrent of the pilot project.
The rationale for a pilot project was to see what impact a mandatory IID program has on recidivism in California. While the impact of IID has been studied elsewhere, with mixed results, the comparisons are not perfect because while some of the other states began mandating IID at the same time they strengthened other sanctions, California has had a complex group of sanctions including high fines, jail time, licensing sanctions, mandatory drinker-driver treatment programs and optional IID in place since the mid-1980’s with sanctions being evaluated, changed and strengthened on an ongoing basis since. The thought was that with a pilot project, DMV can evaluate how best a mandatory IID system should work in California. By evaluating four counties, the counties without the mandatory programs act like a control group for the researchers at DMV. Evaluating how the DUI sanctions work is something DMV researchers have been doing with great success since 1990. DMV’s reports have helped inform the Legislature on where changes needed to be made and have helped reduce recidivism in California.
SB 1046 (Hill) deleted the four county pilot project when it created a statewide IID pilot project for repeat offender DUI.
3. Results from the 4 County Pilot Project
A June 17, 2016 DMV report on the IID pilot project evaluated the project from two perspectives, an “intent to treat” evaluation and “the restricted license evaluation.”
For first offenders in the pilot project the study found in the Intent-to-Treat Evaluation:
FIRST DUI OFFENDERS
- The AB 91 program is not associated with an increase or decrease in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction over the 12-month time period.
- The AB 91 program is not associated with a reduction or increase in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident over the 12-month time period.
- First offenders in non-pilot counties have a 6.1% lower hazards or odds of a subsequent crash relative to those in the pilot counties over the 12-month time period. “California DMV, “ Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California.” p. xi, June 17, 2016” https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/b1eba1e5-9155-40ba-9a74-0e6e19a0d1bc/S5-251.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
For first offenders in the Restricted License Evaluation portion the study found that for people with an IID, while there was an initial lower rate DUI in the first 182 days following their conviction, that lower rate diminished over time. In addition, there was a higher rate of hazards or subsequent crashes with those with the IID and that trend increased over the 12 month period. (Id. p. xii)
The study also found that:
The study findings indicate a negative association between having an IID-restricted license and subsequent crash involvement for all DUI offender groups. For the first and second DUI offenders, higher crash risk among those with the AB 91 IID-restricted license increases over time relative to DUI offenders with a suspended license. Therefore, although the AB 91 IID program is associated with a significant reduction in DUI recidivism among all DUI offender groups, the program is also associated with an increase in crash involvement among all DUI offenders that are subject to the program. This is particularly problematic since a substantial proportion of these crashes are those involving injuries and/or fatalities (of the overall crash involvement measured in the study, the proportion of fatal/injury crashes ranged from mid-30% to low-40% for different DUI offender groups—which is consistent with what prior California evaluations have reported for these offender groups). (Id. p. xv)
4. Mandatory Installation of IID for first offenders
This bill would require any person convicted of a first DUI to install an ignition interlock device on all the cars he or she owns for a 6 months. A person would get credit for an IID installed during the time of the person’s restricted license but prior to conviction.
Existing penalties for a first time DUI include the $390 to $1,000 fine, which with penalty assessments is approximately $1,599-$4,100; a 3 or 9 month program; restricted license for 6 months and various fees for getting their license reinstated and getting reinsured. Is the additional mandatory installation of an IID appropriate? DMV has cautioned over the years that adding sanctions can cause some of those convicted to opt out of the licensing system:
There is a tendency over time to add new requirements or introduce new programs that DUI offenders must comply with in order to relicense. However, as DeYoung argued in his recent paper (2013), continuing to add new requirements may result in discouraging DUI offenders altogether from complying with all conditions to reinstate their driving privilege and indirectly forcing them out of reach of the postlicensing control system. Therefore, before a new requirement is added to the already complicated set of DUI countermeasures in California, any such new requirements must demonstrate “convincing traffic safety benefits” (DeYoung, 2013). (Id. at p. xviii)
According to the most recent report from DMV on DUI Sanctions.
DUI arrests decreased by 8.6% in 2015, following decreases of 3.5% in 2014 and 7.2% in 2013.
And,
The 1-year DUI reoffense rate for first DUI offenders arrested in 2014 was 3.7% compared to 7.6% in 1990. The 1-year reoffense rate for second DUI offenders was 4.7% compared to 9.7% in 1990. Each of these represents slightly over 50% fewer reoffenses compared to that of 1990 arrestees. (California DMV “2017 Annual Report of the California DUI Management Information System” p. iv and v” https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/848b335c-1360-4473-a35d-4da3345c666a/S5-257.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&CVID=
If re-offense rates are down, should we add additional sanctions to first offense DUIs?
5. Failed start
This bill adds to all of the IID pilot project a provision that sates if a person has a “failed start” in the last 60 days of their required installment, the required time for the interlock shall be extended by 60 days. A “failed start” means any attempt to start the vehicle with a breath alcohol concentration exceeding 0.03% BAC.
Is this extension appropriate? Is it possible to get a false “failed start”?
6. Legislative Findings
The first Legislative Finding in this bill states:
In 2016, the Department of Motor Vehicles released a report on the pilot program from 2010 to 2016, inclusive, stating that the department “found a strong and reliable association between possession of an AB 91 IID restricted license and reduced DUI recidivism. Across all DUI offender levels, those with an IID restricted license have lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction, and lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident when compared to drivers with suspended or revoked licenses.” The report also found that “[t]he AB 91 IID group is associated with 73% lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers and 74% lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident relative to the comparison group of suspended drivers.”
The entire quote of the first portion of the finding states:
It bears emphasizing that the current study found a strong and reliable association between possession of an AB 91 IID restricted license and reduced DUI recidivism. Across all DUI offender levels, those with an IID restricted license have lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction, and lower odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident when compared to drivers with suspended or revoked licenses. For first DUI offenders these differences tend to diminish with time. For second offenders these differences disappear after approximately 2 years. For third DUI offenders the difference in subsequent DUI recidivism did not diminish over the 42-month follow-up period. (Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California. at p. xiv)
The references to the 73% and 74% are within the first 182 days of installation with the report indicating “this trend tends to diminish over the 12 month study period.” (Emphasis in original) (Id. at xii)
If there are going to be Legislative findings in a bill quoting a report, should they include the whole quote?
7. Arguments in Support
According to MADD:
Ignition interlocks are effective in reducing repeat drunk driving offenses by 67 percent while the devise is installed compared to license suspension alone. (CDC)
Interlocks help reduce repeat offenses even after the device is removed by 39% compared to offenders who never installed an interlock. (Marcques, 2010)
First-time offend4ers are serious offenders. Research from the CDC indicates that first time offenders have driven drunk at least 80 time before they are arrested.
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California supports bill stating:
Ignition Interlock devices are proven to save lives. PORAC has always supported the use of these devices in lieu of driver’s license suspensions because it allows a person to go about routine: getting to their jobs; therefore, providing for their families. At the same time, these devices prove to be an effective deterrent to drinking and driving.
8. Argument in Opposition
In Opposition the California Public Defenders Association states:
It is instructive to examine the California history of IID’s as a condition of DUI probation. Until 2009 installation of an IID was ordered only for repeat drunk drivers because a large majority of those convicted of a first DUI are never convicted of a second, and it was felt that the risk of re-offending was so low that the deterrent or preventative effect of installing an IID did not justify the additional cost, inconvenience and hardship to the first offender.
There have been past legislative attempts to make IID mandatory for all first time offenders. In 2009, an effort was made to make IID’s mandatory for all first offenders. That attempt foundered on the shoals of common sense and the lack of empirical evidence that would support the need for such a measure. As a compromise, AB 91 was passed, establishing a pilot program requiring IIDs for first offenders in four counties and a DMV report in order to see whether there was the necessary evidence to justify its expansion statewide.
Two separate DMV reports demonstrate that the state wide expansion of mandatory IID’s for first time offenders is not warranted and may be counterproductive. The mandated 2014 DMV report on the pilot program’s effectiveness concluded that the pilot program did not justify a statewide expansion stating that “the pilot program was not associated with a reduction in the number of first-time and repeat DUI convictions in the pilot counties. In other words, no evidence was found that the pilot program has a general deterrent effect.” (emphasis added) (CAL-DMV-RSS-14-247) The Legislature extended the pilot program for two years to see whether additional time would provide supporting evidence for a statewide expansion. A new report produced by DMV in 2016 (CAL-DMV-RSS-16-251) concluded that the results of the pilot program were mixed and warranted further study.
SB 1046 was passed in 2016 making IID’s for first offenders the norm statewide. Courts could order an IID for any first offender, but if they didn’t they were required to impose the alternative penalty of a restricted license, that is, driving strictly limited to driving to and from work, to and from any court ordered drunk driving program, and in the necessary scope of work.
SB 545 is not evidence based. The 2016 DMV Report concluded that the pilot program should not be extended statewide and that further study was warranted. On one hand the report noted that over the short term (six months) the pilot program resulted in fewer DUI convictions. However, the report found the reduced risk of recidivism had disappeared before the two year mark. Even more worrisome, the 2016 DMV report found that the pilot program showed higher odds of crashes verses the comparison group. For the first 300 days after a DUI conviction and installation of the IID the incidence of crashes was virtually equal between the pilot program and the comparison groups, but between 300 and 730 days afterwards it was 58% higher and after 730 days it was 116% higher. Finally, the authors of the 2016 DMV report did not recommend that the pilot program be extended statewide, and did not believe the evidence justified such a course. As a matter fact, the report stated that the pilot program showed “mixed traffic safety results.” Instead, the authors recommended that the matter be studied further, and gave several concrete steps in furtherance thereof. The authors found that license suspensions and revocations provide the best deterrent effect, and that cumulative and progressively more onerous punitive measures had the tendency to produce a negative effect because some drivers become overwhelmed and give up trying to satisfy all those conditions, thus voiding the deterrent effect that more measured, and achievable, sanctions could provide.
SB 545 seeks to deny judges the discretion to exercise their wisdom and good judgment in a myriad of individual, and sometimes extraordinary, circumstances to vary from the inflexible norm in order to fashion just sentences as they see fit. This bill removes the courts discretion, in appropriate cases, to delete what may be, for some individuals, such a harsh and counterproductive penalty in favor of a more measured and effective condition. While we believe that IIDs for first offenders was imprudently enacted without sufficient supporting evidence of need, we recognize that is now history. What we urge is that this bill be rejected because it imposes a “one size fits all” form of justice and removes a very modest and measured form of alternative, discretionary justice. As the DMV report notes, such measured justice may very well be a more effective deterrent than more inflexible and onerous provisions.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):