SB 63: Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 468, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 17, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (July 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | June 24 hearing: Heard for testimony only. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 1). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jan 8, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 7. |
| Jan 7, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 10, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB63 Hertzberg et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2019 | SB 63 Hertzberg Senate Third Reading By Maienschein | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Special Consent SB63 Hertzberg et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 63 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 63
Amended: 9/3/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/1/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/9/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
DIGEST:
This bill excludes from gross income loan amounts discharged from a college when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong.
Assembly Amendments
add in language to comply with Revenue and Taxation Code Section 41 and make other clarifying changes.
Existing law:
- Provides that "gross income" includes all income from whatever source derived, including compensation for services, business income, gains from property, interest, dividends, rents, and royalties, unless specifically excluded.
- Provides that debt that is forgiven or cancelled by a lender is generally treated as income on a tax return, and consequently is taxable.
- Provides that in the case of an individual, gross income does not include any amount which would be included by reason of student loan forgiveness if such discharge was pursuant to a provision of such loan under which all or part of the debt of the individual would be discharged if the individual worked for a certain period of time in certain professions for any of a broad class of employers.
- Provides an exclusion from gross income for income that would otherwise result from a forgiven student loan, as defined, of an eligible individual. The forgiven student loan is defined as a loan discharged after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, and must result from the closure of Corinthian Colleges or similar closures. An eligible individual is a student that successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done.
This bill:
- Provides an exclusion from gross income for income that would otherwise result from a forgiven student loan, as defined, of an eligible individual for taxable years beginning on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2024.
- Provides an individual would be an eligible individual if any of the following apply during the taxable year:
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement.
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to:
- Subdivision (c) of Section 685.206 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as it read January 1, 2019, because the individual successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done; or
- Paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 685.214 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as it read January 1, 2019, because the individual could not complete a program of study due to the school closing.
- The individual attended a Brightwood College school on or before December 5, 2018, and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school that is otherwise ineligible for discharge.
- The individual attended a location of The Art Institute of California and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school that is otherwise ineligible for discharge.
Background
Cancellation of debt. When a lender cancels a borrower’s debt, federal and state law generally treat the amount of debt cancelled as income taxable to the borrower. The Supreme Court has defined “income” as “any instance of undeniable accession to wealth, clearly realized, over which the taxpayer has complete control” (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955).) When debt is cancelled, money that would have been used to pay that loan is now free to be used on whatever the taxpayer wants. Since some assets have been freed, the taxpayer has experienced an accession to wealth and is financially better off. Additionally, under the rule of symmetry, a borrower does not treat a loan as income and the lender does not treat the loan as a deduction. When a borrower’s wealth increases due to a loan, it is also offset by the obligation to repay the same amount later. If the lender cancels the debt, the symmetry is broken: the borrower is financially better off without having to repay the obligation. If cancelled debt were not treated as income, the borrower would receive permanently tax-free cash.
In the case of student loan forgiveness, the amount of debt forgiven generally represents taxable income for income tax purposes in the year the lender cancels the debt, with some exceptions provided under federal law to which the state conforms. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income for the following reasons: if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions, if the forgiveness is due to a taxpayer’s death or disability, or if the forgiveness happens when the taxpayer is insolvent.
Federal Student Aid, an Office of the U.S. Department of Education, has a program that forgives student loans in a limited number of circumstances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student’s school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school’s closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures is generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
School closure. The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the U.S Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As an accrediting body, ACICs serves as the gatekeeper between colleges and billions of dollars in federal financial aid. As of June 2016, it accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise. Scrutiny of ACICS continued through 2016 and intensified after another large chain of for-profit institutions—ITT Technical Institute—accredited by ACICS collapsed.
In December 2016, the U.S Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency’s quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45 percent of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation’s largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operators, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely a year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, the U.S Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration’s 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
Senate Bill 150. In response to the Corinthian College closures, the Legislature passed SB 150 (2015, Nguyen) to exclude student loans—that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong—from gross income. The bill sunsets on December 31, 2019.
Section 41. In 2014, Governor Brown signed SB 1335 (Leno, 2014), which added Section 41 to the Revenue and Taxation Code. In the hopes of applying the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax expenditure programs, including tax credits, Section 41 requires any bill introduced on or after January 1, 2015, that allows a new income tax credit to contain specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax credit will achieve. In addition, Section 41 requires detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax credit meets its goals, purposes, and objectives. This year, the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure proposals including sales and use tax exemptions, comply with Section 41’s requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "[a]nnual General Fund revenue loss of $450,000 in [fiscal year (FY)] 2019-20, $500,000 in [FY] 2020-21 and $300,000 in [FY] 2021-22."
California Student Aid Commission
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closure of Brightwood Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chain. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Marnie Brown / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
9/9/19 21:55:53
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 63
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides, under the Personal Income Tax Law, an exclusion from gross income for student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because the school closes or does something wrong.
Major Provisions
Provides that an individual is an eligible individual for a taxable year if any of the following apply during the taxable year:
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan because the individual successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done or because the individual could not complete a program of study due to the school closing [Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Section 685.206(c) and Section 214(a)(1), as it read on January 1, 2019];
- The individual attended Brightwood College school on or before December 5, 2018; is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school; and the discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above; or,
- The individual attended a location of Art Institute of California, is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school, and that discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above.
COMMENTS:
The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As of June 2016, ACICS accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise.
In December 2016, the Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency's quality standards. The largest group of these colleges – accounting for 45% of enrollment – belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation's largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges, including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operator, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely one year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, the Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration's 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about one-third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
Generally, forgiven student loan debt represents taxable income. However, certain exemptions do apply. Certain federal loan repayment programs, such as the Public Interest Loan Forgiveness Program, will provide tax-free loan forgiveness if certain work conditions are met. Moreover, students have received student loan relief in certain instances when schools engaged in predatory behavior. For instance, SB 150 (Nguyen), Chapter 6500, Statutes of 2015, excludes from gross income student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong from gross income. The Legislature passed SB 150 in response to the Corinthian College closures, and this gross income exclusion expires on December 31, 2019.
According to the Author:
SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closures of Brightwood and Art Institute Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chains. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.
Arguments in Support:
None received for current version of the bill.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis, "[a]nnual General Fund revenue loss of $450,000 in [fiscal year (FY)] 2019-20, $500,000 in [FY] 2020-21 and $300,000 in [FY] 2021-22."
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM REVENUE AND TAXATION: 10-0-1
YES: Burke, Brough, Chu, Gray, Mayes, Mullin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, McCarty, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0001807
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 63
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill provides, from January 1, 2019 until January 1, 2024, a gross income exclusion for student loans discharged under the following conditions: a) pursuant to a discharge agreement; b) because the taxpayer successfully asserts the school did something wrong or because the school closed; or, c) the taxpayer attended a Brightwood College school or an Art Institute of California location during a specified timeframe. This bill also requires the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) to evaluate the effectiveness of the tax exclusion.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual General Fund revenue loss of $450,000 in 2019-20, $500,000 in 2020-21 and $300,000 in 2021-22.
- Minor costs for LAO to conduct the required evaluation.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Generally, forgiven student loan debt represents taxable income. However, certain exemptions do apply. Certain federal loan repayment programs, such as the Public Interest Loan Forgiveness Program, will provide tax-free loan forgiveness if certain work conditions are met. Moreover, students have received student loan relief in certain instances when schools engaged in predatory behavior. For instance, SB 150 (Nguyen), Chapter 6500, Statutes of 2015, excludes from gross income student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong from gross income. The Legislature passed SB 150 in response to the Corinthian College closures, and this gross income exclusion expires on December 31, 2019.
- Purpose. According to supporters, SB 63 will protect students who are unable to obtain the college degree they were working to earn due to forces outside of their control. The author notes this bill will help students impacted by the closures of the Brightwood and Art Institute Colleges and help ensure that federal loan debt assistance will not be considered gross income for tax purposes.
- Discharge agreement not defined. This bill provides for a gross income exclusion for discharged student loans under three specified scenarios, including when the loans are discharged “pursuant to a discharge agreement.” This language is similar to language from SB 150 of 2015. However, SB 150 defined “discharge agreement” to mean an agreement related to the purchase the assets of Corinthian Colleges. This bill does not include a similar definition. The author may wish to clarify this provision or remove it altogether.
- Section 41 costs. Section 41 of the Revenue and Taxation Code calls for tax expenditure legislation to include the legislative intent of the proposed tax expenditure and a process by which to evaluate its effectiveness. Generically, a bill that complies with Section 41 includes a report or formal evaluation utilizing specified data sources.
As noted in this committee’s analysis of AB 263 (Burke), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, Section 41 reporting requirements can be costly. Costs may be significant if the requested data is not easily obtainable or if the scope of requested research is overly ambitious. Moreover, the evaluating entity, such as the LAO or FTB, may need additional resources if it is required to conduct many Section 41 evaluations in the same year, even if each individual report is absorbable within existing resources.
This bill requires LAO to review the effectiveness of the proposed state income exclusion. This is unlikely to be a complicated analysis. However, LAO may need to request additional resources if tasked with other Section 41 reporting requirements.
- Related legislation. AB 461 (Muratsuchi), Chapter 525, Statutes of 2017, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017, and before January 1, 2022, excludes from gross income student loan debt that is forgiven or repaid under the income-based and other repayment programs administered by the U.S. Department of Education.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 63
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
FOR VOTE ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
SUMMARY: Provides, under the Personal Income Tax Law, an exclusion from gross income for student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an individual is an eligible individual for a taxable year if any of the following apply during the taxable year:
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement;
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan because the individual successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done or because the individual could not complete a program of study due to the school closing [Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Section 685.206(c) and Section 214(a)(1), as it read January 1, 2019];
- The individual attended a Brightwood College school on or before December 5, 2018, and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school, and that discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above; or,
- The individual attended a location of The Art Institute of California and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school, and that discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above.
- Provides that a student loan is a student obligation note or other debt evidencing a loan to any individual for the purpose of attending a for-profit higher education company or for the purpose of consolidating or refinancing a loan used to attend a for-profit higher education company, which is either a guaranteed student loan, an educational loan, or a loan eligible for consolidation or refinancing under the Higher Education Act.
- Provides that the exclusion from income shall apply to discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2024, and shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
- Provides specific goals, along with detailed performance indicators, in compliance with Revenue and Taxation Committee (R&TC) Section 41.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Provides that "gross income" includes all income from whatever source derived, including compensation for services, business income, gains from property, interest, dividends, rents, and royalties, unless specifically excluded.
- Provides that debt that is forgiven or cancelled by a lender is generally treated as income on a tax return, and consequently is taxable.
- Provides that in the case of an individual, gross income does not include any amount which would be included by reason of discharge of any student debt if such discharge was pursuant to a provision of such loan under which all or part of the indebtedness of the individual would be discharged if the individual worked for a certain period of time in certain professions for any of a broad class of employers. [Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 108(f).]
EXISTING STATE LAW provides an exclusion from gross income for discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, that would otherwise result from a student loan forgiven as a result of the closure of Corinthian Colleges and similar closures, or if the student successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done.
FISCAL EFFECT: The Franchise Tax Board estimates a General Fund revenue loss of $450,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, $500,000 in FY 2020-21, and $300,000 in FY 2021-22.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closures of Brightwood and Art Institute Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chains. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.
- Supporters state "[w]hen college campuses close, students face a challenging path forward. An especially difficult situation arises from the fact that California's tax code considers forgiven loan debt to be taxable. While these students are eligible to obtain forgiveness of student loans at the federal level, without legislative intervention, they will have to pay taxes on that forgiveness at a time when they are least able to afford it. This bill protects students who, due to forces outside of their control, are unable to obtain the college degree they were working to earn."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As an accrediting body, ACICS serves as the gatekeeper between colleges and billions of dollars in federal financial aid. As of June 2016, ACICS accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise. Scrutiny of ACICS continued through 2016 and intensified after another large chain of for-profit institutions—ITT Technical Institute—accredited by ACICS collapsed.
In December 2016, the Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency's quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45% of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation's largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges, including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operator, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely one year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, the Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration's 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
- Rationale of Taxing Forgiven Debt: The practice of taxing debt cancellation reflects sound tax policy because it recognizes the fact that an individual's net worth has increased by the cancellation of debt. According to Commissioner v. Glenshaw, the Court defined "income" as an accession to wealth that is clearly realized and over which the taxpayer has complete dominion. (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955).) When debt is cancelled, money that would have been used to pay that loan is now free to be used on whatever the taxpayer wants. Therefore, because certain assets have been freed, the taxpayer has experienced an accession to wealth. Additionally, under the rule of symmetry, a loan is not considered income to the borrower nor is it a deduction to the lender. A borrower's increased wealth when the loan is taken out is also offset by the obligation to pay the same amount. If the debt is cancelled, the symmetry is destroyed. The borrower is in a much better position after the debt is cancelled. Additionally, as noted by Debora A. Grier, Professor of Law of Cleveland State University, in her statement before the United States Senate Committee on Finance, without this tax rule, "the borrower will have received permanently tax-free cash in the year of the original receipt," i.e. the year in which the borrower received the loan.
- Student Loan Cancellation: In the case of student loan forgiveness, the amount of debt forgiven generally represents taxable income for income tax purposes in the year the lender cancels the debt, with some exceptions provided under federal law to which the state conforms. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income for the following reasons: if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions, if the forgiveness is due to a taxpayer's death or disability, or if the forgiveness happens when the taxpayer is insolvent.
However, the Federal Student Aid, an Office of the Department of Education, has a program that forgives student loans in a limited number of additional circumstances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student's school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school's closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures are generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
- What does this bill do? This bill excludes loan amounts discharged from gross income when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. This bill applies to taxpayers granted a discharge of student loan debt under any of the following circumstances:
- The taxpayer successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done;
- The taxpayer is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement;
- The taxpayer could not complete a program of study because the school closed; or,
- The taxpayer attended either Brightwood College or the Art Institute.
- We've been here before: In response to the Corinthian College closures, the Legislature passed SB 150 (Nguyen), Chapter 650, Statutes of 2015, to exclude student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong from gross income. The provisions of R&TC Section 17144.7 expire on December 31, 2019.
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, United States Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures," since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each of them (in the form of forgone revenues). This bill would enact a new tax expenditure program in the form of gross income exclusion for discharged student loan debt.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added R&TC Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure[1] proposals comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote[2]. This bill, as currently drafted contains an appropriate five-year sunset and complies with the Section 41 requirements.
- What does this bill do? This bill excludes loan amounts discharged from gross income when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. This bill applies to taxpayers granted a discharge of student loan debt under any of the following circumstances:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Student Aid Commission
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
A "tax expenditure measure" is defined as legislation meeting either of the following criteria: (1) the measure proposes to extend, expand, or enact a credit, deduction, exclusion, exemption, or other tax preference (i.e., a tax expenditure program); or, (2) the measure proposes to eliminate or reduce one or more tax rates. ↑
An "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean 10 years. ↑
Date of Hearing: June 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 63
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
SUMMARY: Provides, under the Personal Income Tax Law, an exclusion from gross income for student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an individual is an eligible individual for a taxable year if any of the following apply during the taxable year:
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement;
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan because the individual successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done or because the individual could not complete a program of study due to the school closing [Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Section 685.206(c) and Section 214(a)(1), as it read January 1, 2019];
- The individual attended a Brightwood College school on or before December 5, 2018, and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school, and that discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above; or,
- The individual attended a location of The Art Institute of California and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school, and that discharge is not covered by one of the provisions above.
- Provides that a student loan is a student obligation note or other debt evidencing a loan to any individual for the purpose of attending a for-profit higher education company or for the purpose of consolidating or refinancing a loan used to attend a for-profit higher education company, which is either a guaranteed student loan, an educational loan, or a loan eligible for consolidation or refinancing under the Higher Education Act.
- Provides that the exclusion from income shall apply to discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2024, and shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Provides that "gross income" includes all income from whatever source derived, including compensation for services, business income, gains from property, interest, dividends, rents, and royalties, unless specifically excluded.
- Provides that debt that is forgiven or cancelled by a lender is generally treated as income on a tax return, and consequently is taxable.
- Provides that in the case of an individual, gross income does not include any amount which would be included by reason of discharge of any student debt if such discharge was pursuant to a provision of such loan under which all or part of the indebtedness of the individual would be discharged if the individual worked for a certain period of time in certain professions for any of a broad class of employers. (Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 108(f).)
EXISTING STATE LAW provides an exclusion from gross income for discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, that would otherwise result from a student loan forgiven as a result of the closure of Corinthian Colleges and similar closures, or if the student successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done.
FISCAL EFFECT: The Franchise Tax Board estimates a General Fund revenue loss of $450,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, $500,000 in FY 2020-21, and $300,000 in FY 2021-22.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closures of Brightwood and Art Institute Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chains. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.
- Supporters state "[w]hen college campuses close, students face a challenging path forward. An especially difficult situation arises from the fact that California's tax code considers forgiven loan debt to be taxable. While these students are eligible to obtain forgiveness of student loans at the federal level, without legislative intervention, they will have to pay taxes on that forgiveness at a time when they are least able to afford it. This bill protects students who, due to forces outside of their control, are unable to obtain the college degree they were working to earn."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As an accrediting body, ACICS serves as the gatekeeper between colleges and billions of dollars in federal financial aid. As of June 2016, ACICS accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise. Scrutiny of ACICS continued through 2016 and intensified after another large chain of for-profit institutions—ITT Technical Institute—accredited by ACICS collapsed.
In December 2016, the Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency's quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45% of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation's largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges, including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operator, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely one year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, the Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration's 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
- Rationale of Taxing Forgiven Debt: The practice of taxing debt cancellation reflects sound tax policy because it recognizes the fact that an individual's net worth has increased by the cancellation of debt. According to Commissioner v. Glenshaw, the Court defined "income" as an accession to wealth that is clearly realized and over which the taxpayer has complete dominion. (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955).) When debt is cancelled, money that would have been used to pay that loan is now free to be used on whatever the taxpayer wants. Therefore, because certain assets have been freed, the taxpayer has experienced an accession to wealth. Additionally, under the rule of symmetry, a loan is not considered income to the borrower nor is it a deduction to the lender. A borrower's increased wealth when the loan is taken out is also offset by the obligation to pay the same amount. If the debt is cancelled, the symmetry is destroyed. The borrower is in a much better position after the debt is cancelled. Additionally, as noted by Debora A. Grier, Professor of Law of Cleveland State University, in her statement before the United States Senate Committee on Finance, without this tax rule, "the borrower will have received permanently tax-free cash in the year of the original receipt," i.e. the year in which the borrower received the loan.
- Student Loan Cancellation: In the case of student loan forgiveness, the amount of debt forgiven generally represents taxable income for income tax purposes in the year the lender cancels the debt, with some exceptions provided under federal law to which the state conforms. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income for the following reasons: if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions, if the forgiveness is due to a taxpayer's death or disability, or if the forgiveness happens when the taxpayer is insolvent.
However, the Federal Student Aid, an Office of the Department of Education, has a program that forgives student loans in a limited number of additional circumstances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student's school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school's closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures are generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
- What does this bill do? This bill excludes loan amounts discharged from gross income when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. This bill applies to taxpayers granted a discharge of student loan debt under any of the following circumstances:
- The taxpayer successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done;
- The taxpayer is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement;
- The taxpayer could not complete a program of study because the school closed; or,
- The taxpayer attended either Brightwood College or the Art Institute.
- We've been here before: In response to the Corinthian College closures, the Legislature passed SB 150 (Nguyen), Chapter 650, Statutes of 2015, to exclude student loans that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong from gross income. The provisions of R&TC Section 17144.7 expire on December 31, 2019.
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, United States Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures," since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each of them (in the form of forgone revenues). This bill would enact a new tax expenditure program in the form of gross income exclusion for discharged student loan debt.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure[1] proposals comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote[2]. This bill, as currently drafted contains an appropriate five-year sunset but does not comply with the Section 41 requirements.
- What does this bill do? This bill excludes loan amounts discharged from gross income when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. This bill applies to taxpayers granted a discharge of student loan debt under any of the following circumstances:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Student Aid Commission
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
A "tax expenditure measure" is defined as legislation meeting either of the following criteria: (1) the measure proposes to extend, expand, or enact a credit, deduction, exclusion, exemption, or other tax preference (i.e., a tax expenditure program); or, (2) the measure proposes to eliminate or reduce one or more tax rates. ↑
An "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean 10 years. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 63 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 63
Amended: 4/22/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/1/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
DIGEST:
This bill excludes from gross income loan amounts discharged from a college when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong.
Existing law:
- Provides that "gross income" includes all income from whatever source derived, including compensation for services, business income, gains from property, interest, dividends, rents, and royalties, unless specifically excluded.
- Provides that debt that is forgiven or cancelled by a lender is generally treated as income on a tax return, and consequently is taxable.
- Provides that in the case of an individual, gross income does not include any amount which would be included by reason of student loan forgiveness if such discharge was pursuant to a provision of such loan under which all or part of the debt of the individual would be discharged if the individual worked for a certain period of time in certain professions for any of a broad class of employers.
- Provides an exclusion from gross income for income that would otherwise result from a forgiven student loan, as defined, of an eligible individual. The forgiven student loan is defined as a loan discharged after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, and must result from the closure of Corinthian Colleges or similar closures. An eligible individual is a student that successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done.
This bill:
- Provides an exclusion from gross income for income that would otherwise result from a forgiven student loan, as defined, of an eligible individual for taxable years beginning on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2024.
- Provides an individual would be an eligible individual if any of the following apply during the taxable year:
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement.
- The individual is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to:
- Subdivision (c) of Section 685.206 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as it read January 1, 2019, because the individual successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done; or
- Paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 685.214 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, as it read January 1, 2019, because the individual could not complete a program of study due to the school closing.
- The individual attended a Brightwood College school on or before December 5, 2018, and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school that is otherwise ineligible for discharge.
- The individual attended a location of The Art Institute of California and is granted a discharge of any student loan made in connection with attending that school that is otherwise ineligible for discharge.
Background
Cancellation of debt. When a lender cancels a borrower’s debt, federal and state law generally treat the amount of debt cancelled as income taxable to the borrower. The Supreme Court has defined “income” as “any instance of undeniable accession to wealth, clearly realized, over which the taxpayer has complete control” (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955).) When debt is cancelled, money that would have been used to pay that loan is now free to be used on whatever the taxpayer wants. Since some assets have been freed, the taxpayer has experienced an accession to wealth and is financially better off. Additionally, under the rule of symmetry, a borrower does not treat a loan as income and the lender does not treat the loan as a deduction. When a borrower’s wealth increases due to a loan, it is also offset by the obligation to repay the same amount later. If the lender cancels the debt, the symmetry is broken: the borrower is financially better off without having to repay the obligation. If cancelled debt were not treated as income, the borrower would receive permanently tax-free cash.
In the case of student loan forgiveness, the amount of debt forgiven generally represents taxable income for income tax purposes in the year the lender cancels the debt, with some exceptions provided under federal law to which the state conforms. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income for the following reasons: if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions, if the forgiveness is due to a taxpayer’s death or disability, or if the forgiveness happens when the taxpayer is insolvent.
Federal Student Aid, an Office of the U.S. Department of Education, has a program that forgives student loans in a limited number of circumstances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student’s school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school’s closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures is generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
School closure. The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the U.S Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As an accrediting body, ACICs serves as the gatekeeper between colleges and billions of dollars in federal financial aid. As of June 2016, it accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise. Scrutiny of ACICS continued through 2016 and intensified after another large chain of for-profit institutions—ITT Technical Institute—accredited by ACICS collapsed.
In December 2016, the U.S Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency’s quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45 percent of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation’s largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operators, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely a year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, the U.S Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration’s 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
Senate Bill 150. In response to the Corinthian College closures, the Legislature passed SB 150 (Nguyen, Chapter 650, Statues of 2015) to exclude student loans—that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong—from gross income. The bill sunsets on December 31, 2019.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, “The Franchise Tax Board (FTB) indicates that this bill would result in General Fund revenue losses of $450,000 in 2019-20, $500,000 in 2020-21, and $300,000 in 2021-22. The bill would not significantly affect the department’s costs.”
California Student Aid Commission
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/14/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closure of Brightwood Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chain. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.”
Prepared by: Marnie Brown / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/18/19 11:42:19
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 63 (Hertzberg) - Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
Version: April 22, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SB 63 would exclude from gross income student loan amounts forgiven when the taxpayer is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong.
Fiscal Impact:
The Franchise Tax Board (FTB) indicates that this bill would result in General Fund revenue losses of $450,000 in 2019-20, $500,000 in 2020-21, and $300,000 in 2021-22. The bill would not significantly affect the department’s costs.
Background:
Tax expenditure programs (TEPs) are special tax provisions that reduce the amount of revenues the “basic” tax system would otherwise generate in order to provide (1) benefits to certain groups of taxpayers, and/or (2) incentives to encourage certain types of behavior and activities, such as charitable giving. Specifically, current law provides for, among other things, various income and corporation tax credits and deductions, as well as exemptions from the sales and use tax. The Department of Finance is required to publish a list of TEPs (currently totaling several hundred), which currently total $65 billion annually.
Debt that is either forgiven or cancelled by a lender is generally treated as taxable income. With respect to student loan forgiveness, the amount forgiven generally represents taxable income the year the debt is cancelled (with certain exceptions), including loan discharges for closed schools. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions.
Federal Student Aid, (within the U.S. Department of Education) has a program that forgives student loans in specified instances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student’s school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school’s closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures are generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
In December 2016, the U.S Department of Education officially revoked accreditor recognition for the Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Subsequently, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different agency, but 85 colleges could not; in other words, they failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency’s quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45 percent of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation’s largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges, including both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Another of the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, owned by the second largest for-profit college operators, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely a year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, U.S Department of Education restored federal recognition to ACICS, which allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
In response to the Corinthian College closures earlier in the decade, the Legislature passed SB 150 (2015, Nguyen) to exclude student loans—that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong—from gross income. That bill sunsets December 31, 2019.
Proposed Law:
This bill would exclude loan amounts discharged from gross income, for taxable years 2019 through 2023, when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. This bill would apply to taxpayers granted discharge under any of the following circumstances: (1) the taxpayer successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done, (2) the taxpayer is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement, (3) the taxpayer could not complete a program of study because the school closed, and (4) the taxpayer attended either Brightwood College or the Art Institute.
Related Legislation:
- AB 461 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 525, Statutes of 2017), for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017, and before January 1, 2022, excludes from gross income student loan debt that is forgiven or repaid under the income-based and other repayment programs administered by the U.S. Department of Education.
- SB 150 (Nguyen, et al., Chapter 650, Statutes of 2015) excludes from gross income several types of student loan debt that is discharged on or after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, including debt that is discharged, pursuant to discharge agreements between certain schools that closed, or other situations in which a student could not complete a program of study due to a school closing or doing something wrong.
Staff Comments:
FTB’s revenue estimate for the bill assumes that California borrowers would have approximately $25 million of student loans forgiven in 2019 because a school closes or does something wrong. Because state tax law currently allows an exclusion from gross income for discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2015, and before January 1, 2020, FTB estimates that eight percent of the 2019 discharges would be subject to the provisions of this proposal and the remainder would be excluded under current law.
FTB estimates that 20 percent of those forgiven student loans would be attributable to borrowers who are insolvent, and thus excludable from income under current law. Of the remaining forgiven student loans, FTB assumes that borrowers eligible for this bill’s exclusion would have an average tax rate of 3 percent, resulting in an estimated $50,000 revenue loss for the 2019 tax year, increasing to $700,000 in the 2020 tax year and decreasing each year thereafter.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 63 | Hearing Date: | 5/1/19 |
Author: | Hertzberg | Tax Levy: | Yes |
Version: | 4/22/19 > | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brown | ||
Personal Income Tax Law: exclusion: student loan debt forgiveness
Excludes from gross income student loan amounts forgiven when the taxpayer is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong.
Background
Tax expenditures. California law allows various income tax credits, deductions, exemptions, and exclusions. The Legislature enacts such tax incentives either to compensate taxpayers for incurring certain expenses, such as child adoption, or to influence certain behavior, such as charitable giving. The Legislature uses tax incentives to encourage taxpayers to do something that but for the tax credit, they would otherwise not do. The Department of Finance is required annually to publish a list of state tax expenditures, currently totaling around $65.2 billion per year.
Cancellation of debt. When a lender cancels a borrower’s debt, federal and state law generally treat the amount of debt cancelled as income taxable to the borrower. The Supreme Court has defined “income” as “any instance of undeniable accession to wealth, clearly realized, over which the taxpayer has complete control” (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955).) When debt is cancelled, money that would have been used to pay that loan is now free to be used on whatever the taxpayer wants. Since some assets have been freed, the taxpayer has experienced an accession to wealth and is financially better off. Additionally, under the rule of symmetry, a borrower does not treat a loan as income and the lender does not treat the loan as a deduction. When a borrower’s wealth increases due to a loan, it is also offset by the obligation to repay the same amount later. If the lender cancels the debt, the symmetry is broken: the borrower is financially better off without having to repay the obligation. If cancelled debt were not treated as income, the borrower would receive permanently tax-free cash.
In the case of student loan forgiveness, the amount of debt forgiven generally represents taxable income for income tax purposes in the year the lender cancels the debt, with some exceptions provided under federal law to which the state conforms. Generally, a taxpayer excludes student loan forgiveness from his or her income if the forgiveness is contingent upon the student working for a specific number of years in certain professions. For example, if a taxpayer participates in a public service loan forgiveness program, a teacher loan forgiveness program, or a law school loan repayment assistance program, the taxpayer can exclude the cancelled debt from income. A taxpayer can also exclude his or her forgiven student loan debt from income due to death or disability. In other words, if the taxpayer dies or becomes disabled and can no longer repay the loan, then the taxpayer does not have to include the loan forgiveness as income. Additionally, if a taxpayer’s student loan is forgiven and the taxpayer is insolvnent, then he or she does not have to include the amount forgiven in gross income.
Federal Student Aid, an Office of the U.S. Department of Education, has a program that forgives student loans in a limited number of circumstances. One of these situations is a closed school discharge, which means a student loan may be forgiven if a student’s school closes while he or she is enrolled, and he or she cannot complete their program of study. A closed school discharge also applies if a student withdraws from the school within 120 days of the school’s closure. However, forgiven student loans that are due to school closures is generally considered taxable income for federal tax purposes.
School closure. The Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools (ACICS) is a non-profit education corporation that is currently recognized by the U.S Department of Education as an independent and autonomous national accrediting body. As an accrediting body, ACICs serves as the gatekeeper between colleges and billions of dollars in federal financial aid. As of June 2016, it accredited 245 higher education institutions, which offered undergraduate and graduate diplomas and degrees in both traditional and non-traditional formats. In 2015, ACICS came under scrutiny for the collapse of Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit institution that was accredited by ACICS until its sudden demise.
Founded in 1995, Corinthian's for-profit colleges once included over 100 campuses across the country, where over 100,000 students were enrolled. However, a bachelor’s degree from a Corinthian College could cost as much as $75,000. The vast majority of the school’s revenue came from federal student loans, but federal loans were unable to cover all of the tuition, so students had to take out private loans. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau alleges that Corinthian kept tuition high in order to force students to borrow from the college at higher rates. The Corinthian loans came with origination fees of six percent and interest rates of around 15 percent, as of 2011, much higher than the three percent and seven percent interest on federal student loans. Corinthian was also longtime target for federal and state regulators, with a host of investigations and lawsuits charging falsified placement rates, deceptive marketing, and predatory recruiting, targeting the most vulnerable low-income students. In 2015, the U.S Department of Education forced the company to close or sell off its locations over concerns about its high interest loans and misleading employment statistics.
Scrutiny of ACICS continued through 2016 and intensified after another large chain of for-profit institutions accredited by ACICS—ITT Technical Institute—collapsed. ITT Technical Institute operated over 130 schools, which served roughly 45,000 students. For years, ITT faced numerous state and federal investigations and legal actions. In 2014, the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau sued ITT, alleging that they used high-pressure tactics to coerce students into high-interest private loans that were likely to default. In 2015, the SEC charged the institutions’ CEO and CFO with fraud for concealing from investors potentially huge losses in two student loan programs. Eventually ACICS, which was under investigation by a subcommittee of the U.S Senate, withdrew its accreditation of ITT determining that ITT was not in compliance and “unlikely to become in compliance” with its criteria.
In December 2016, the U.S Department of Education officially revoked ACICS recognition as an accreditor. The decision gave institutions currently accredited by ACICS 18 months to find accreditation elsewhere. Since the decision, 111 colleges gained accreditation with a different
agency, but 85 colleges could not. In other words, these institutions failed to demonstrate that they were able to meet any other agency’s quality standards. The largest group of these colleges—accounting for 45 percent of enrollment—belongs to Education Corporation of America (ECA), one of the nation’s largest for-profit college operators. The corporation operates many colleges including both Brightwood College and Virginia College.
Also notable among the 85 colleges was the Art Institute, which was owned by the second largest for-profit college operators, Education Management Corporation (EDMC). Before declaring bankruptcy, EDMC sold most of its schools, including the Art Institute to the Dream Center Foundation, a non-profit company with no experience in higher education. Barely a year after the takeover, Dream Center was facing eviction on at least nine campuses and owed creditors more than $40 million. Dream Center has announced that it will be closing multiple campuses across the country.
In November 2018, U.S Department of Education—under the leadership of Secretary Betsy Devos—decided to restore federal recognition to ACICS, reversing the Obama Administration’s 2016 decision. This decision allowed those 85 colleges to avoid closure and continue to operate; however, one month later, ACICS suspended accreditation to both Brightwood College and Virginia College. Saddled with eroding student enrollments, strapped finances, and an uncertain accreditation future, ECA closed about a third of its schools, including all 25 of the Brightwood College campuses.
Senate Bill 150. In response to the Corinthian College closures, the Legislature passed SB 150 (2015, Nguyen) to exclude student loans—that are forgiven when the borrower is unable to complete a program of study because a school closes or does something wrong—from gross income. The bill expires December 31, 2019.
The author wants to help students affected by the closures of Brightwood College and the Art Institute, as well as other students in similar situations.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 63 excludes loan amounts discharged from gross income when the borrower is unable to complete a program because the school closed or did something wrong. SB 63 applies to taxpayers granted discharge under any of the following circumstances:
- The taxpayer successfully asserts that the school did something wrong or failed to do something that it should have done.
- The taxpayer is granted a discharge of any student loan pursuant to a discharge agreement.
- The taxpayer could not complete a program of study because the school closed.
- The taxpayer attended either Brightwood College or the Art Institute.
As a tax levy, SB 63 goes into effect immediately, and applies to discharges of indebtedness occurring on or after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2024.
State Revenue Impact
According to the FTB, SB 63 results in revenue losses of $450,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $500,000 in 2020-21, and $300,000 in 2021-22.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 63 ensures that students impacted by the abrupt closure of Brightwood Colleges are not penalized for the failure of the for-profit college chain. This bill ensures that federal loan debt assistance is not considered gross income for tax purposes.”
2. Tradeoffs. Existing tax law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for taxpayers. This bill would extend an existing expenditure, which results in less General Fund revenues. Without General Fund moneys, the government has less funding to pay for important public services such as education and public safety. As a result, the state will have to reduce spending or increase taxes to match the foregone revenue. The Committee may wish to consider whether SB 63 is worth the spending cuts and/or tax increases.
3. SB 150 v SB 63. SB 150 (Nguyen, 2015) provides an income exclusion for taxpayers when their student loans are forgiven, and the taxpayers are unable to complete a program of study because a school closed or did something wrong. The bill includes a specific section to make sure that Corinthian College students were capture amongst these provisions. However, the bill expires January 1, 2020. SB 63 extends the provisions of SB 150 until January 1, 2025. Instead of containing a specific section referencing Corinthian College students, SB 63 contains two sections referencing Brightwood College and the Art Institute, to ensure that students affected by these two closures are protected under SB 63.
4. Reverse conformity. State tax law does not automatically conform to changes in federal tax law, except under specified circumstances. Instead, the Legislature must affirmatively conform to federal changes. Generally, when the federal government changes its tax laws, the state catches up by enacting its own legislation to reduce differences between the two codes, thereby easing the tax preparation burden on taxpayers, tax preparers, and the Franchise Tax Board. Currently, loans forgiven for students that are unable to complete a program due to the school closing or doing something wrong is not includable in state taxable income but is generally includable for federal income tax purposes. If SB 63 becomes law, taxpayers would continue to exclude the forgiven loan from income for state tax purposes, but include it for federal tax purposes, extending the states nonconformity with federal tax law.
Support and Opposition
(4/26/19)
Support: California Student Aid Commission.
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):