SB 645: Civil discovery: depositions.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 212, Statutes of 2019. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jun 5, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 4, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 4). |
| May 2, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 4.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 2). |
| Mar 19, 2019 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB645 Monning Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | SB 645 Monning Senate Third Reading By Mark Stone | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 4, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 8, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB645 Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 645 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 645
Amended: 7/5/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE FLOOR: 31-4, 4/8/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Chang, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-0, 8/12/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Civil discovery: depositions
SOURCE: Consumer Attorneys of California
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
DIGEST:
This bill limits the deposition testimony of dying deponents in specified civil cases.
Assembly Amendments
provide additional time for deposition testimony when there are more than 10 defendants appearing at the deposition.
- Provides, through the Civil Discovery Act, procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain “discovery,” including by, among other things, oral depositions. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2017.010 et seq.)
- Permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.420.) It further authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.470.)
- Governs, through the Rules of Court, complex cases, and defines them as an action that requires exceptional judicial management to avoid placing unnecessary burdens on the court or the litigants and to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, and promote effective decision making by the court, the parties, and counsel. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.400.)
- Limits a deposition to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if some person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(a).)
- Provides a series of exemptions from the presumptive limit of seven hours of deposition testimony. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(b).)
- Provides that nothing in the section laying out exemptions shall be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect against unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(c).)
- Provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent’s successor in interest, as specified, and an action may be commenced by the decedent’s personal representative or, if none, by the decedent’s successor in interest. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.30.) In such an action or proceeding by a decedent’s personal representative or successor in interest on the decedent’s cause of action, the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
This bill:
- Provides, notwithstanding Section 2025.290, that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff’s counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Permits a defendant to request and a court to grant, in its discretion, additional time as follows:
- up to an additional three hours of deposition testimony for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants if there are more than 10 defendants appearing at the deposition; or
- up to an additional seven hours of deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants if there are more than 20 defendants appearing at the deposition.
- Provides that the court may grant the additional time provided above if it finds that it is in the interest of fairness, which includes consideration of the number of defendants appearing at the deposition, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Background
Generally, deposition testimony is limited to seven hours per deponent, except as provided or as ordered by the court. In complex cases, however, depositions are exempt from the limit. One exception to this exemption is where a physician attests that the deponent suffers from a condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. In such a case, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day. Despite this provision protecting dying deponents, the statute has been interpreted to allow discretion, and such deponents have been subjected to depositions much longer than the 14 hours provided for in the statute.
In response, this bill places a clear cap of seven hours on the deposition testimony of a plaintiff deponent when: (1) the plaintiff suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis; (2) the action is for injury or illness resulting in such illness; and (3) a physician attests that such illness raises doubt as to the plaintiff’s survival beyond six months. Courts have the ability to extend such depositions where there are more than 10 defendants appearing at the deposition.
This bill is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California, the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, and the District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California. It is supported by a number of unions. It is opposed by various law firms.
Comments
According to the author:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to 7 hours. Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent’s survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in California Code of Civil Procedure [Section] 36.
Depositions
In California, a party generally may take the deposition of any person, including any other party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.010.) However, prior to 2012, California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, even though the modern discovery methods in California can be traced to the Civil Discovery Act of 1957 which, with minor changes, was patterned on the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Because California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, so long as counsel continued the deposition, they could have continued over any number of days and hours, leading up to the 30th day before the date initially set for a trial (or even longer if a court order or written agreement extends the statutory cut-off).
In response to abuses of the system and to harmonize with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was enacted into law. AB 1875 added California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290. Subdivision (a) of that section establishes a presumptive time limit of seven hours of total deposition testimony for each witness. This subdivision contains a sentence granting discretion to the court to allow additional time for testimony “if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstances impedes or delays the examination.”
Subdivision (b) of Section 2025.290 lays out the exemptions to the seven-hour presumption. Paragraph (3) exempts cases declared complex pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. The statute provides, however, an exception to the exemption. It states the complex case exception does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that “the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months.” In that instance, the deposition examination of the deponent by all counsel, other than the deponent’s counsel of record, must be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
The issue that has arisen, and that has motivated this legislation, is whether and how the clause in subdivision (a) providing the court discretion to grant additional time for a deposition applies to the “exception to the exemption” where a deponent in a complex case provides documentation that there is substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The relevant question is how courts should apply the two-day, 14-hour limitation provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
Providing additional protections to dying plaintiff
Committee analyses of AB 1875 reveal that the “exception to the exception” that was created by the bill was intended to address the same issues motivating the current bill: “This ‘exception to the exception’ is aimed, in many respects, at problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.” Some courts had been limiting oral depositions in asbestos cases, locally, but AB 1875 sought to make such limitations universal.
However, since that time, the statute has been interpreted by courts such that the seven to 14 hour limit on depositions for deponents in complex cases with an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months is subject to the broad discretion vested in the courts by the preceding section. (See Certainteed Corp. v. Superior Court (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1053, 1056.)
This bill provides a clear cap on the length of depositions of plaintiffs suffering from either mesothelioma or silicosis where certain conditions are met. First, the bill only covers civil actions arising from the injury or illness that results in the disease. Second, a licensed physician must attest in a declaration that the deponent plaintiff suffers from the disease and that such diagnosis raises “substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.” Finally, this seven-hour maximum can be extended by the court upon request by the defendant.
The deponents that would benefit from this legislation are in a uniquely vulnerable position. Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually is increasing. There is no cure for silicosis and more than 100 people die each year in this country as a result. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and have time to file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible. (See Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
This bill places a tight limit on the length of deposition testimony, affording courts discretion to extend to a total of 10 hours of total deposition if there are more than 10 defendants appearing at the deposition or up to 14 hours of total deposition where there are more than 20 defendants.
Depositions are only one of the many tools available in discovery. For example, interrogatories can provide access to much of the same information defendants seek in extended depositions and provide it in a timelier, more efficient, and not excessively redundant manner that does not overly tax the health of a dying plaintiff. If a plaintiff does not adequately respond to such interrogatories, there are mechanisms for defendants to compel further responses. In addition, this bill is narrowly aimed only at those deponents for whom time is in short supply, and therefore, special consideration is arguably warranted. Ultimately, this bill provides a reasonable limitation on deposition testimony in a narrow subset of cases based on documented and extremely critical health concerns.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-source)
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California (co-source)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California (co-source)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Conference of Machinists
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Federation of California
Contra Costa AFL-CIO Labor Council
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environmental Working Group
Heat and Frost Insulators and Allied Workers, Local 16
Inland Boatmen’s Union of the Pacific
International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, District Council 16
Local #5 Retirees Club
National Lawyers Guild, Labor and Employment Committee
Northern California District Council of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Physicians for Social Responsibility, San Francisco Bay Area
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Teamsters California State Council of Cannery and Food Processing Unions
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Worksafe
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/13/19)
Bassi Edlin Huie and Blum
Bennett, Samuelsen, Reynolds, Allard, Cowperthwaite, and Gelini
Berkes Crane Robinson and Seal LLP
Bishop Barry PC
CMBG3 Law LLC
Glazier Yee LLP
Gordon and Rees Scully Mansukhani
Hugo Parker LLP
Imai, Tadlock, Keeney and Cordery LLP
Knox Ricksen LLP
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard and Smith LLP
Polsinelli LLP
Sack Rosendin, LLP
Selman Breitman LLP
Sinunu Bruni LLP
Spanos Przetak
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The State Building and Construction Trades Council of California writes: “Victims of mesothelioma, a disease caused only by exposure to asbestos that predominantly afflicts construction workers and their families, often have no idea when they were exposed to asbestos earlier in life. Symptoms of the disease do not appear for years after exposure but, once present, victims commonly survive less than a year after diagnosis. Likewise, victims of silicosis, caused by exposure to crystalline dust from cutting stone, quartz, or tile, are often years removed from their exposure to silica dust before symptoms are present and might also have been exposed to it by family members. The symptoms for both diseases are painful and chronic and lead to a significantly reduced lifespan and quality of life. The symptoms make it extremely difficult to endure hours-long depositions from defense attorneys looking to reassign liability to other entities. Extended depositions are already hard on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from either illness.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Knox Ricksen LLP writes in opposition: “Our overworked trial courts have been handling these problems for years. Judges and discovery referees remain in the best position to assess whether time limits or other restrictions should be placed on depositions. Quite often the courts have agreed with defendants that more time is needed to complete a deposition. There is no evidence or study available that supports an untested theory that an arbitrary time limit with little or no discretion to expand an appropriate solution to a perceived problem.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-0, 8/12/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gray, Kiley, Mayes, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Wood
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/14/19 14:49:37
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 645
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:July 5, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Limits the amount of time a plaintiff in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis may be deposed by defendants if a doctor determines the plaintiff is unlikely to live for more than six months.
Major Provisions
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff's counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Provides that notwithstanding 1), upon request by a defendant, a court may, grant an additional three hours if there are more than ten defendants.
- Provides that notwithstanding 1), upon request by a defendant, a court may, grant an additional seven hours if there are more than 20 defendants.
- Provides that the extension specified in 2) and 3) may be granted if the court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
COMMENTS:
California's Civil Discovery Act regulates the litigation discovery process with the goals of promoting the disclosure of all facts relevant to determining the disposition of the case. To that end, the Civil Discovery Act authorizes parties to use depositions, interrogatories, document inspection, physical and mental examinations, requests for admissions, and the exchange of expert witness information during discovery. However, recognizing that California's liberal discovery process can open the door for delay and harassing tactics from all sides, the Civil Discovery Act generally limits the time for cross-examination in depositions to seven hours unless the parties agree to extend deposition timing, the witness is an expert, or a case involves an unusually complex matter.
Throughout the decades that California courts have handled asbestos-related litigation, courts have issued case management orders that have highly standardized and regulated the litigation process. Nonetheless, asbestos-related litigation is deemed a complex matter under the California Rules of Court, and thus the seven hour cap on the duration of depositions does not apply. Although existing case management orders limit the cross examination of a plaintiff in depositions to 20 hours, and existing law provides an avenue to reduce this cap to 14 hours, the proponents of this measure contend that the existing limits on cross-examination present an extreme hardship to plaintiffs suffering from exposure to asbestos. Accordingly, this bill seeks to bring the timing restrictions of deposition of asbestos plaintiff's in-line with the restrictions that apply to most other (noncomplex) civil cases.
According to the Author:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to seven hours. Upon request by defendants, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to three more hours for a total of no more than 10 hours of total deposition time by defense counsel if it finds an extension is in the interests of fairness, and the health of the deponent does not appear endangered by the grant of additional time.
Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent's survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in the Code of Civil Procedure.
Arguments in Support:
This measure is supported by the Consumer Attorneys of California and a coalition of labor organizations. Representative of the coalition, the Consumer Attorneys of California state:
SB 645 will set a sensible deposition time limit of seven hours for dying victims of mesothelioma and silicosis. Defendants would be authorized by this bill to seek up to three hours of additional deposition testimony, for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants, if a court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Depositions are stressful and taxing, even for healthy people. There is no need for marathon depositions which create additional emotional and physical harm to victims during their final days of life. Due process for the defendants is assured by unlimited interrogatories providing written answers to all questions that defendants might pose and other court orders, including case management orders, providing extensive and unlimited discovery via documents and medical records.
Arguments in Opposition:
This measure is opposed by several asbestos litigation law firms. One, Spanos Przetak, PLC, writes:
Given the shifting landscape of defendants involved in asbestos litigation, most defendants are no longer product manufacturers or distributors but local businesses such as plumbing supply companies, contractors and landowners. A bright line rule limiting the questioning of plaintiffs to seven hours is not only unnecessary, it will unfairly prevent defendants from conducting critical discovery.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 31-4-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Chang, Nielsen
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-0-3
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001223
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 645
Author:(Monning)
As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Limits the amount of time a plaintiff in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis may be deposed by defendants if a doctor determines the plaintiff is unlikely to live for more than six months.
Major Provisions
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff's counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Provides that notwithstanding 1), upon request by a defendant, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to an additional three hours of deposition testimony for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants.
- Provides that the extension specified in 2) may be granted if the court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
COMMENTS:
California's Civil Discovery Act regulates the litigation discovery process with the goals of promoting the disclosure of all facts relevant to determining the disposition of the case. To that end, the Civil Discovery Act authorizes parties to use depositions, interrogatories, document inspection, physical and mental examinations, requests for admissions, and the exchange of expert witness information during discovery. However, recognizing that California's liberal discovery process can open the door for delay and harassing tactics from all sides, the Civil Discovery Act generally limits the time for cross-examination in depositions to seven hours unless the parties agree to extend deposition timing, the witness is an expert, or a case involves an unusually complex matter.
Throughout the decades that California courts have handled asbestos-related litigation, courts have issued case management orders that have highly standardized and regulated the litigation process. Nonetheless, asbestos-related litigation is deemed a complex matter under the California Rules of Court, and thus the seven hour cap on the duration of depositions does not apply. Although existing case management orders limit the cross examination of a plaintiff in depositions to 20 hours, and existing law provides an avenue to reduce this cap to 14 hours, the proponents of this measure contend that the existing limits on cross-examination present an extreme hardship to plaintiffs suffering from exposure to asbestos. Accordingly, this bill seeks to bring the timing restrictions of deposition of asbestos plaintiff's in-line with the restrictions that apply to most other (noncomplex) civil cases.
According to the Author:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to seven hours. Upon request by defendants, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to three more hours for a total of no more than ten hours of total deposition time by defense counsel if it finds an extension is in the interests of fairness, and the health of the deponent does not appear endangered by the grant of additional time.
Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent's survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in the Code of Civil Procedure.
Arguments in Support:
This measure is supported by the Consumer Attorneys of California and a coalition of labor organizations. Representative of the coalition, the Consumer Attorneys of California state:
SB 645 will set a sensible deposition time limit of 7 hours for dying victims of mesothelioma and silicosis. Defendants would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 3 hours of additional deposition testimony, for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants, if a court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Depositions are stressful and taxing, even for healthy people. There is no need for marathon depositions which create additional emotional and physical harm to victims during their final days of life. Due process for the defendants is assured by unlimited interrogatories providing written answers to all questions that defendants might pose and other court orders, including case management orders, providing extensive and unlimited discovery via documents and medical records.
Arguments in Opposition:
This bill is opposed by the Civil Justice Association of California, as well as several large litigation law firms and a coalition of insurance providers. The Civil Justice Association of California states:
The limitations imposed by SB 645 would overrule case management orders created by courts with heavy asbestos calendars, after months or even years of vetting and evaluation. These "CMOs" have been crafted to include provisions fair to both sides, and typically permit 20 hours of total deposition testimony. It is inappropriate for the Legislature to overrule the reasoned decisions of judges who deal with asbestos litigation every day.
Asbestos litigation often involves 40, 50, 60 or more defendants in a single case. In order to properly defend themselves in an asbestos claim, these defendants must examine plaintiffs to determine when and how alleged exposures to asbestos-containing products occurred. The seven-hour limit contained in SB 645 applies regardless of the number of defendants in the case, which is 100% within the discretion of the plaintiff. If 60 defendants are limited to seven total hours of testimony, that works out to just seven minutes per defendant.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 31-4-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Chang, Nielsen
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-0-3
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001054
Date of Hearing: June 4, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 645
Author:(Monning) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 31-4
SUBJECT: Civil discovery: depositions: TERMINALLY ILL PLAINTIFFS
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE MAXIMUM TIME PROVIDED FOR DEFENDANTS TO DEPOSE PLAINTIFFS IN a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis BE LIMITED TO SEVEN TO TEN HOURS?
SYNOPSIS
Over the course of the last decade, the Legislature has made several attempts to limit the ability for civil discovery, and depositions of plaintiffs in particular, to be utilized as a tool to stall litigation or needlessly harass plaintiffs. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto, Chap. 346, Stats. 2012), which limits depositions to seven hours in order to protect vulnerable parties from abusive litigation tactics. However, this rule provides a series of exceptions—including when a court believes there is a need for additional time to fairly examine the deponent, and when the case is governed by a case management order or designated as complex. Additionally, existing court-issued case management orders limit the amount of time for depositions in cases involving asbestos exposure to 20 hours and existing law caps the amount of time a critically ill plaintiff can be deposed to 14 hours.
According to the author of this measure, despite the efforts of California courts and recent legislation, plaintiffs suffering from mesothelioma or silicosis are being subjected to depositions that are needlessly prolonged. The author, noting the particularly heinous nature of these diseases, contends that additional protections are needed for plaintiffs in these cases, especially those deemed terminally ill by a licensed physician. Accordingly, this bill would limit the amount of time a plaintiff in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis who is determined by a physician to be unlikely to live for more than six months, may be deposed by defendants to seven hours, and provide defendants the ability to seek an additional three hours of deposition time if a court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness and would not adversely impact the plaintiff’s health. This measure is similar to, if not slightly more restrictive than, SB 632 (Monning, 2017) that passed this Committee before being sent to the Inactive File on the Assembly Floor.
This bill is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California, the District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California, and the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, and is supported by a coalition of labor organizations who note the significant hardships that prolonged depositions impose on critically ill plaintiffs. This bill is opposed by the Civil Justice Association of California as well as several large litigation law firms and a coalition of insurance providers who argue that the restrictions on deposition time would harm their due process rights and significantly limit their ability to generate evidence to mount a legal defense. As noted, this Committee passed a similar version of this bill in 2017.
SUMMARY: Limits the amount of time a plaintiff in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis may be deposed by defendants if a doctor determines the plaintiff is unlikely to live for more than six months. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff’s counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Provides that notwithstanding 1), upon request by a defendant, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to an additional three hours of deposition testimony for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants.
- Provides that the extension specified in 2) may be granted if the court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, in the Civil Discovery Act, procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain discovery from another party to the matter, including by, among other things, oral depositions. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2017.010 et seq.)
- Permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.420.)
- Authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.470.)
- Provides that a deposition is limited to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290 (a).)
- Provides that the seven hour of total testimony limit does not apply under any of the following circumstances:
- If the parties have stipulated that the limit will not apply to a specific deposition or to the entire proceeding;
- To any deposition of a witness designated as an expert as defined;
- To any case designated as complex by the court pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court, unless a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months, in which case the deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony;
- To any case brought by an employee or applicant for employment against an employer for acts or omissions arising out of or relating to the employment relationship;
- To any deposition of a person who is designated as the most qualified person to be deposed as defined; or
- To any party who appeared in the action after the deposition has concluded, in which case the new party may notice another deposition, as provided. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290 (b).)
- Provides that the exemptions described in 5) shall not be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect against unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290 (c).)
- Provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent’s successor in interest, and an action may be commenced by the decedent’s personal representative or, if none, by the decedent’s successor in interest. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 377.30.)
- Provides that in an action that survives the death of a plaintiff pursuant to 7), the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 377.34.)
- Defines a complex case and provides factors that the court considers in determining whether an action is considered complex. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
- Requires the court, in deciding whether an action is a complex case, to consider whether the action is likely to involve any of the following factors:
- Numerous pretrial motions raising difficult or novel legal issues that will be time-consuming to resolve;
- Management of a large number of witnesses or a substantial amount of documentary evidence;
- Management of a large number of separately represented parties;
- Coordination with related actions pending in one or more courts in other counties, states, or countries, or in a federal court; or
- Substantial post-judgment judicial supervision. (Ibid.)
- Specifies that an action is provisionally deemed to be a complex case if it involves one or more of the following types of claims:
- Antitrust or trade regulation claims;
- Construction defect claims involving many parties or structures;
- Securities claims or investment losses involving many parties;
- Environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties;
- Claims involving mass torts;
- Claims involving class actions; or
- Insurance coverage claims as provided. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: California’s Civil Discovery Act regulates the litigation discovery process with the goals of promoting the disclosure of all facts relevant to determining the disposition of the case. To that end, the Civil Discovery Act authorizes parties to use depositions, interrogatories, document inspection, physical and mental examinations, requests for admissions, and the exchange of expert witness information during discovery. However, recognizing that California’s liberal discovery process can open the door for delay and harassing tactics from all sides, the Civil Discovery Act generally limits the time for cross-examination in depositions to seven hours unless the parties agree to extend deposition timing, the witness is an expert, or a case involves an unusually complex matter.
Throughout the decades that California courts have handled asbestos-related litigation, courts have issued case management orders that have highly standardized and regulated the litigation process. Nonetheless, asbestos-related litigation is deemed a complex matter under the California Rules of Court, and thus the seven hour cap on the duration of depositions does not apply. Although existing case management orders limit the cross examination of a plaintiff in depositions to 20 hours, and existing law provides an avenue to reduce this cap to 14 hours, the proponents of this measure contend that the existing limits on cross-examination present an extreme hardship to plaintiffs suffering from exposure to asbestos. Accordingly, this bill seeks to bring the timing restrictions of deposition of asbestos plaintiff’s in-line with the restrictions that apply to most other (noncomplex) civil cases.
Background on asbestos and asbestos litigation. Asbestos is the term used to define six naturally occurring silicate minerals. All are composed of long and thin fibrous crystals that may be released into the atmosphere if scraped or otherwise disturbed. Because asbestos was once viewed as a “miracle mineral” for its heat and fire-resistant and flexible properties, it was once incorporated into many commercial household and building products, even though many people knew asbestos was a health hazard. (Kaminsky and Campbell, The Lawyer’s Guide to Lead Paint, Asbestos, and Chinese Drywall (2010) pp. 87- 90.) However, according to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, asbestos is classified as a known human carcinogen by state, federal, and international agencies and was identified in 1986 as a Toxic Air Contaminant by the California Air Resources Board.
As noted, asbestos fibers can be scraped off and released into the atmosphere and cause health problems if they are inhaled. For instance, asbestos exposure can result in pleural disease (pleural thickening in the lungs), asbestosis (scarring of the lung tissue), lung cancer, and mesothelioma—a fatal cancer in the lining of the chest or abdomen. (Kaminsky and Campbell, supra, pp. 93-95.) However, given the long latency period between the initial asbestos exposure and the first onset of disease, oftentimes, civil tort and product liability claims may not occur until long after exposure, resulting in actions that likely involve multiple plaintiffs, defendants, experts, and witnesses. Troublingly, many victims of asbestos exposure—often industrial, commercial, military, and residential construction workers—are in significant pain and do not survive the litigation. Given these various issues, courts designate asbestos cases as complex, and manage asbestos claims differently than other cases.
Over the decades that tort litigation involving asbestos exposure have been commenced, most asbestos manufacturers and dozens of suppliers and other businesses in which workers were exposed to asbestos have filed for bankruptcy protection. Given the long latency period of asbestos, and to ensure that asbestos victims are able to recover, a national asbestos trust fund was established to permit victims to recover from now-bankrupt defendants. According to the RAND Corporation’s Institute for Civil Justice, the trust fund has paid over $15 billion in claims since the 1980s and approximately $30 billion remains in the fund. Nonetheless, plaintiffs, especially those who previously worked in the shipping industry, are still filing lawsuits against solvent corporations, especially those using asbestos to manufacture products, thus requiring these claims to be adjudicated in superior court.
Generally, California law limits cross-examination in depositions to seven hours. California’s Civil Discovery Act generally traces the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The Federal Rules generally limit oral depositions to one seven-hour day of testimony. (Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30 (d)(1).) However, when California initially enacted the Civil Discovery Act, it omitted the seven hour restriction on discovery. Prior to 2012, attorneys could continue to seek to depose parties until 30 days prior to the date the case was set for trial. In response to ongoing complaints that unlimited depositions were being abused by litigants to ask repetitive questions of opposing parties and delay litigation, plaintiffs and defense counsel agreed to a compromise whereby most depositions would be limited to seven hours and only cases meeting a limited number of circumstances would be permitted to exceed the limit. (AB 1875 (Gatto) Chap. 346, Stats. 2012.)
Despite the seven-hour presumption, the law allows a court to grant additional time for deposition questioning if additional time is needed to “fairly examine the deponent” or if “the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination.” Furthermore, in addition to specified causes of action, the seven-hour rule does not apply if the parties stipulate to longer depositions or the deponent is an expert. Relevant to this bill, the seven-hour rule does not apply in cases governed by a case management order or designated by the court as complex—in order words, cases involving many parties, multiple witnesses, or coordination between several courts. Generally, a case involving environmental or toxic tort claims, including asbestos exposure claims, involving many parties are provisionally designated as complex cases. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
Although existing law provides several exemptions to the seven-hour limit, the existing law provides an additional exemption permitting new time restrictions on a deposition if a physician provides a declaration attesting that a “deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months.” (Section 2025.290.) In those circumstances, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. (Ibid.)
This bill. Recognizing the significant hardship that prolonged dispositions impose on plaintiffs in mesothelioma or silicosis cases, this bill would adopt a seven hour limit for cross-examination of these plaintiffs in the event that a licensed physician attests that there exists substantial medical doubt of the survival of the plaintiff beyond six months. Additionally, recognizing the need to ensure that all defendants to a civil action are provided the ability to question the plaintiff, this bill provides the court the ability to grant an additional three hours of deposition time, upon a motion by the defendants, if the court determines such an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Author Statement. In support of this measure the author highlights the tremendous strain and hardship that a prolonged deposition poses to plaintiffs who are dying from mesothelioma and silicosis. The author contends that the nature of these conditions makes sitting for a deposition particularly onerous. In support of this bill, the author states:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to seven hours. Under the bill, upon request by defendants, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to three more hours for a total of no more than ten hours of total deposition time by defense counsel if it finds an extension is in the interests of fairness, and the health of the deponent does not appear endangered by the grant of additional time.
Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent's survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in the Code of Civil Procedure.
Strict time limits for depositions and maintaining defendant’s due process. Recognizing the complex nature of asbestos exposure cases, existing law deems these matters to be complex civil litigation. This designation, in turn, renders many of the existing provisions of the Civil Discovery Act designed to expedite civil matters inapplicable to the complex action. In asbestos litigation, there are frequently dozens of named defendants, typically corporations that utilized asbestos in the manufacturing of an unrelated product. Throughout the discovery process, the defendants seek to ascertain whether or not the plaintiff was actually exposed to their specific product and if such exposure could be shown, or disproved, with reasonable medical probability to have contributed to the plaintiff's injury. To ensure that the discovery process does not become unwieldy to the point that justice is compromised, several of California’s largest superior courts have issued general case management orders to handle asbestos litigation. (See e.g. Super. Ct. L.A. County, Aug. 11, 2014 Order, Sections V.B. and V.C., at pp. 5-6.) Most of the case management orders permit up to 20 hours of cross-examination of plaintiffs in asbestos- related cases.
In opposition to this measure, the Civil Justice Association of California, as well as several representatives from the insurance industry, argue that the proposed seven hour limit on depositions would overrule otherwise valid case management orders, significantly undermine defendant’s due process rights, and inhibit their ability to fully generate evidence that may be used to exculpate their clients from mesothelioma or silicosis related claims. Furthermore, they suggest that this bill would undermine the heavily negotiated compromise that was ultimately enacted in AB 1875. The opposition further argues that the provisions of this bill permitting defendants to seek an additional three hours of deposition testimony will swamp superior courts with motions seeking additional discovery.
The opponent’s arguments are not without merit. As discussed above, asbestos litigation is generally highly complex and involves numerous defendants. While the 20-hour disposition limit established by the existing case management orders is very likely more than necessary, this bill would cut that time by more than half. It is unclear whether seven to ten hours of deposition time is sufficient in cases with dozens of defendants. The opposition notes that this bill proposes a stricter time limit than prior legislation seeking to address lengthy depositions of critically ill mesothelioma plaintiffs. As this bill advances, the author and supporters may wish to engage with the opponents to determine whether there is a middle ground that would adequately protect terminally ill plaintiffs while protecting the due process rights of defendants.
Although this bill imposes limits on depositions, the bill models several areas of existing law. Despite the concerns of the opposition, the seven hour limit on deposition time in asbestos related cases does not significantly depart from several other areas of existing law. As noted, a seven hour limit is the default for most civil litigation matters. Furthermore, existing law already provides for limits in complex civil litigation cases in the event that a deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. That provision of existing law limits deposition testimony to 14 hours total over two days. Proponents of this bill argue that the nature of mesothelioma and silicosis are unique even among terminal illness related to toxic torts. The State Building and Construction Trades Council, a co-sponsor of this bill, specifically addresses this issue noting:
It is a particularly painful disease that fills the lung cavity with fluid causing a drowning sensation and leading ultimately to death. Likewise, victims of silicosis, caused by exposure to crystalline dust from cutting stone, quartz, or tile, are often years removed from their exposure to silica dust before symptoms are present and might also have been exposed to it by family members. Silica dust is classified as a lung carcinogen and can cause shortness of breath, scarring of the lungs, labored breathing, and respiratory failure among other symptoms.
Although this bill would impose a slightly stricter limit than those granted to ill deponents in complex cases generally, due to the especially pernicious nature of mesothelioma and silicosis, and the disease’s specific impacts on a plaintiff’s lungs and associated ability to speak for long period of time, these differences appear to be reasonable.
Testimony during a deposition is not required for a defendant to succeed on a motion for summary judgment. In addition to several statewide defense counsel organizations, several large law firms have written in opposition to this measure and these opponents cite several cases in support of their contention that in asbestos litigation all defendants are required to conduct a detailed and thorough examination of the plaintiff before seeking a motion for summary judgment. (See e.g. Scheidling v. Dinwiddie Construction Co. (1999) 69 Cal.App.4th 64; Weber v. John Crane, Inc. (2006) 143 Cal. App. 4th 1433.) Essentially, the opponents are arguing that any time limit on depositions would curb their ability to seek a motion for summary judgment. Although it is true that a party must present affirmative evidence to support a motion for summary judgment, the Scheidling case does not hold that the defendant is required to obtain that evidence solely from a deposition, but instead holds that a detailed discovery process is required before summary judgment can be sought. The Scheidling case holds that merely submitting arguments without any supporting evidence is not sufficient to obtain summary judgment; however the case does not pass judgment regarding the manner in which the evidence is collected by the defendant. (Scheidling, supra, at p. 84.) Additionally, the Weber case undermines the opponents’ contention that a deposition is critical to obtaining summary judgment in asbestos litigation. In fact, the defendants in Weber relied heavily on the plaintiff’s deposition testimony to support their motion for summary judgment and the court held that plaintiff’s personal lack of knowledge regarding exposure to their product was insufficient to grant summary judgment without supporting evidence. (Weber, supra, at p. 1439.) If anything the Weber decision reflects the highly individualized decisions that courts make when rendering summary judgements and that all tools of discovery are essential to litigation. (Id,. at p. 1442.)
Dispositions are not the only means to obtain evidence in civil litigation. Several of the law firms opposing this bill cite case law that holds that cross-examination is the “greatest legal invention ever created for the discovery of truth.” (Fost v. Superior Court (2000) 80 Cal.App.4th 724,733.) This holding reflects the general premise embedded in California law that a liberal discovery process is essential to a functioning civil justice system. However, cross examination during a deposition is not the only tool for eliciting information in litigation, and while this bill unquestionably limits the time period for which defendants can obtain information via a disposition, nothing in this bill limits other forms of discovery. This bill does not impact other discovery tools that would be helpful to defendants in generating affirmative evidence that a plaintiff’s mesothelioma or silicosis was not the result of exposure to the defendant’s products or occurred at a defendant’s worksite. For example, a defendant could seek a request production of a plaintiff’s tax information for the years in which the plaintiff was exposed to asbestos. If such information does not show that the plaintiff was employed in a manner that would have exposed them to a defendant’s products or a job site, the defendant would be permitted to utilize this evidence in arguing for summary judgment in light of the Scheidling and Weber decisions.
Further, opponents note that this bill overlooks the potentially complex legal issues posed by asbestos litigation. They contend that significant time is necessary for all defendants to question a plaintiff on all aspects of the case. Overlooking the fact that much of this questioning may be repetitive if conducted by every defendant, this argument also ignores the existence of other avenues for eliciting this information from a defendant. For example, examining potential issues regarding the “peculiar risk” doctrine could be accomplished utilizing a request for admission just as easily as it could be via a deposition. The Civil Justice Association of California complains that, “answers to such interrogatories are typically so general that precise exposure information requires deposition testimony.” However, as highlighted by the Weber case, disposition testimony alone frequently fails to elicit sufficiently precise information to sustain a summary judgment. Furthermore, should a defendant believe that a plaintiff is failing to properly respond to written discovery requests, it should be noted that nothing in this bill would preclude a defendant from seeking a court order to compel the plaintiff’s cooperation or permit additional written discovery containing sufficiently precise answers to defense counsel’s inquiries.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is supported by the Consumer Attorneys of California and a coalition of labor organizations, particularly those representing workers in the building and construction trades. Representative of the coalition the Consumer Attorneys of California highlight the hardship posed to terminally ill plaintiffs by prolonged depositions and the availability of discovery tools outside of the deposition process. They state:
SB 645 will set a sensible deposition time limit of 7 hours for dying victims of mesothelioma and silicosis. Defendants would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 3 hours of additional deposition testimony, for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants, if a court finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Depositions are stressful and taxing, even for healthy people. There is no need for marathon depositions which create additional emotional and physical harm to victims during their final days of life. Due process for the defendants is assured by unlimited interrogatories providing written answers to all questions that defendants might pose and other court orders, including case management orders, providing extensive and unlimited discovery via documents and medical records.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by the Civil Justice Association of California, as well as several large litigation law firms and a coalition of insurance providers. The opposition argues that this bill will hamper their due process rights and objects to this bill’s potential for overriding existing case management orders related to asbestos cases and prior legislative efforts to deal with deposition timelines in civil litigation. The Civil Justice Association of California states:
The limitations imposed by SB 645 would overrule case management orders created by courts with heavy asbestos calendars, after months or even years of vetting and evaluation. Plaintiff and defense lawyers alike participated in the processes leading to the adoption of these case management orders. These “CMOs” have been crafted to include provisions fair to both sides, and typically permit 20 hours of total deposition testimony. It is inappropriate for the Legislature to overrule the reasoned decisions of judges who deal with asbestos litigation every day.
Asbestos litigation often involves 40, 50, 60 or more defendants in a single case. In order to properly defend themselves in an asbestos claim, these defendants must examine plaintiffs to determine when and how alleged exposures to asbestos-containing products occurred. The seven-hour limit contained in SB 645 applies regardless of the number of defendants in the case, which is 100% within the discretion of the plaintiff. If 60 defendants are limited to seven total hours of testimony, that works out to just seven minutes per defendant. We believe that this constitutes nothing less than a denial of due process for those defending claims.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-sponsor)
District Council of Iron Workers (co-sponsor)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California (co-sponsor)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
Asbestos Workers Local 16 Retirees Club
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Labor Federation
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Consumer Federation of California
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20
Environmental Working Group
Inlandboatman’s Union of the Pacific
International Union of Painters and Allied Trades- District Council 16
National Lawyers Guild Labor & Employment Committee
Northern California District Council of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Physicians for Social Responsibility- SF Bay Area Chapter
Professional and Technical Engineers
Teamsters California State Council of Cannery and Food Processing Unions
United Steel Workers
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Worksafe
Opposition
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Association of Defense Counsel of Northern California and Nevada
California Defense Counsel
Civil Justice Association of California
Hugo Parker, LLP
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Polsinelli, LLP
Selman Breitman LLP
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 645 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 645
Introduced: 2/22/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SUBJECT: Civil discovery: depositions
SOURCE: Consumer Attorneys of California
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
DIGEST:
This bill limits the deposition testimony of dying deponents in specified civil cases.
Existing law:
- Provides, through the Civil Discovery Act, procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain “discovery,” including by, among other things, oral depositions. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2017.010 et seq.)
- Permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.420.) It further authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.470.)
- Governs, through the Rules of Court, complex cases, and defines them as an action that requires exceptional judicial management to avoid placing unnecessary burdens on the court or the litigants and to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, and promote effective decision making by the court, the parties, and counsel. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.400.)
- Provides that a deposition is limited to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if some person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(a).)
- Provides a series of exemptions from the presumptive limit of seven hours of deposition testimony. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(b).)
- Provides that nothing in the section laying out exemptions shall be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect against unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(c).)
- Provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent’s successor in interest, as specified, and an action may be commenced by the decedent’s personal representative or, if none, by the decedent’s successor in interest. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.30.) In such an action or proceeding by a decedent’s personal representative or successor in interest on the decedent’s cause of action, the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
This bill:
- Provides, notwithstanding Section 2025.290, that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff’s counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Permits a defendant to request and a court to grant, in its discretion, up to an additional three hours of deposition testimony for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants. The court may grant such an extension if it finds that it is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Background
Generally, deposition testimony is limited to seven hours per deponent, except as provided or as ordered by the court. In complex cases, however, depositions are exempt from the presumptive seven-hour limit. One exception to this exemption is where a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. In such a case, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
Despite this provision protecting dying deponents, the statute has been interpreted to allow discretion in granting additional time, and such deponents have been subjected to depositions much longer than the 14 hours provided for in the statute.
In response, this bill places a clear cap of seven hours on the deposition testimony of a plaintiff deponent when: (1) the plaintiff suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis; (2) the action is for injury or illness resulting in such illness; and (3) a physician attests that such illness raises doubt as to the plaintiff’s survival beyond six months. Courts have the ability to extend such depositions by up to three hours upon request by the defendant. This bill is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California, the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, and the District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California. It is supported by a number of unions representing the workers who are negatively affected by these diseases. It is opposed by various law firms that represent defendants in asbestos litigation and associated groups.
Comments
According to the author:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to 7 hours. Under the bill, upon request by defendants, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to 3 more hours for a total of no more than 10 hours of total deposition time by defense counsel if it finds an extension is in the interests of fairness, and the health of the deponent does not appear endangered by the grant of additional time. Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent’s survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in California Code of Civil Procedure [Section] 36.
Depositions
In California, a party generally may take the deposition of any person, including any other party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.010.) However, prior to 2012, California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, even though the modern discovery methods in California can be traced to the Civil Discovery Act of 1957 which, with minor changes, was patterned on the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Because California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, so long as counsel continued the deposition, they could have continued over any number of days and hours, leading up to the 30th day before the date initially set for a trial (or even longer if a court order or written agreement extends the statutory cut-off).
In response to abuses of the system and to harmonize with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was enacted into law. AB 1875 added California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290. Subdivision (a) of that section establishes a presumptive time limit of seven hours of total deposition testimony for each witness. This subdivision contains a sentence granting discretion to the court to allow additional time for testimony “if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstances impedes or delays the examination.”
Subdivision (b) of Section 2025.290 lays out the exemptions to the seven-hour presumption. Paragraph (3) exempts cases declared complex pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. The statute provides, however, an exception to the exemption. It states the complex case exception does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that “the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months.” In that instance, the deposition examination of the deponent by all counsel, other than the deponent’s counsel of record, must be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
The issue that has arisen, and that has motivated this legislation, is whether and how the clause in subdivision (a) providing the court discretion to grant additional time for a deposition applies to the “exception to the exemption” where a deponent in a complex case provides documentation that there is substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The relevant question is how courts should apply the two-day, 14-hour limitation provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
Providing additional protections to dying plaintiff
Committee analyses of AB 1875 reveal that the “exception to the exception” that was created by the bill was intended to address the same issues motivating the current bill: “This ‘exception to the exception’ is aimed, in many respects, at problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.” Some courts had been limiting oral depositions in asbestos cases, locally, but AB 1875 sought to make such limitations universal.
However, since that time, the statute has been interpreted by courts such that the seven to 14 hour limit on depositions for deponents in complex cases with an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months is subject to the broad discretion vested in the courts by the preceding section. (See Certainteed Corp. v. Superior Court (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1053, 1056.)
This bill provides a clear cap on the length of depositions of plaintiffs suffering from either mesothelioma or silicosis where certain conditions are met. First, the bill only covers civil actions arising from the injury or illness that results in the disease. Second, a licensed physician must attest in a declaration that the deponent plaintiff suffers from the disease and that such diagnosis raises “substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.” Finally, this seven-hour maximum can be extended by up to three hours by the court upon request by the defendant.
The deponents that would benefit from this legislation are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma (a disease caused by asbestos exposure) is approximately one year.[1] Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually is increasing.
Silicosis is a lung disease caused by breathing in tiny bits of silica, which is a mineral found in sand, rock, and mineral ores such as quartz.[2] Millions of workers in the United States are exposed to respirable crystalline silica, or silica dust, in certain occupations such as construction, mining, glass manufacturing, and foundry work.[3] Exposure to silica particles causes scarring in the lungs over time and can cause major lung damage, lung cancer, and pulmonary tuberculosis. There is no cure for silicosis and more than 100 people die each year in this country as a result.
Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and have time to file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible. (See Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
This bill places a tight limit on the length of deposition testimony, affording courts discretion only to extend to a total of 10 hours. However, depositions are only one of the many tools available in discovery. For example, the use of interrogatories can provide access to much of the same information defendants would seek in extended depositions and provide it in a timelier, more efficient, and not excessively redundant manner that does not overly tax the health of a dying plaintiff. If a responding plaintiff does not adequately respond to such interrogatories, there are mechanisms for defendants to compel further responses through the court. In addition, this bill is narrowly aimed only at those deponents for whom time is in short supply, and therefore, special consideration is arguably warranted. Ultimately, this bill provides a reasonable limitation on deposition testimony in a narrow subset of cases based on documented and extremely critical health concerns.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-source)
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California (co-source)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California (co-source)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Conference of Machinists
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Federation of California
Contra Costa AFL-CIO Labor Council
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environmental Working Group
Heat and Frost Insulators and Allied Workers, Local 16
Inland Boatmen’s Union of the Pacific
International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, District Council 16
Local #5 Retirees Club
National Lawyers Guild, Labor and Employment Committee
Northern California District Council of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Physicians for Social Responsibility, San Francisco Bay Area
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Teamsters California State Council of Cannery and Food Processing Unions
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Worksafe
Association of Defense Counsel of Northern California and Nevada
Bassi Edlin Huie and Blum
Bennett, Samuelsen, Reynolds, Allard, Cowperthwaite, and Gelini
Berkes Crane Robinson and Seal LLP
Bishop Barry PC
California Defense Counsel
Civil Justice Association of California
CMBG3 Law LLC
Glazier Yee LLP
Gordon and Rees Scully Mansukhani
Hugo Parker LLP
Imai, Tadlock, Keeney and Cordery LLP
Knox Ricksen LLP
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard and Smith LLP
Polsinelli LLP
Sack Rosendin, LLP
Selman Breitman LLP
Sinunu Bruni LLP
Spanos Przetak
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The State Building and Construction Trades Council of California writes: “Victims of mesothelioma, a disease caused only by exposure to asbestos that predominantly afflicts construction workers and their families, often have no idea when they were exposed to asbestos earlier in life. Symptoms of the disease do not appear for years after exposure but, once present, victims commonly survive less than a year after diagnosis. Likewise, victims of silicosis, caused by exposure to crystalline dust from cutting stone, quartz, or tile, are often years removed from their exposure to silica dust before symptoms are present and might also have been exposed to it by family members. The symptoms for both diseases are painful and chronic and lead to a significantly reduced lifespan and quality of life. The symptoms make it extremely difficult to endure hours-long depositions from defense attorneys looking to reassign liability to other entities. Extended depositions are already hard on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from either illness.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Civil Justice Association of California, echoing sentiments shared in many of the letters in opposition, point to the large number of defendants that are usually named in the relevant litigation. They argue that in order to properly defend themselves in an asbestos claim, the defendants need to examine plaintiffs to determine the underlying facts regarding the plaintiff’s exposure. They argue this bill denies them due process by undermining their ability to so question the plaintiff.
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
4/5/19 13:46:44
**** END ****
Jacek M. Mazurek, et al., Malignant Mesothelioma Mortality – United States, 1999-2015 (March 3, 2017) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention website, https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/66/wr/ mm6608a3.htm [as of Mar. 18, 2019]. ↑
American Lung Association, Learn About Silicosis, https://www.lung.org/lung-health-and-diseases/lung-disease-lookup/silicosis/learn-about-silicosis.html [as of Mar. 18, 2019]. ↑
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Silica, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/silica/ [as of Mar. 20, 2019]. ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 645 (Author:Monning)
Version: February 22, 2019
Hearing Date: April 2, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Civil discovery: depositions
DIGEST
This bill limits the deposition testimony of dying deponents in specified civil cases.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Generally, deposition testimony is limited to seven hours per deponent, except as provided or as ordered by the court. In complex cases, however, depositions are exempt from the presumptive seven-hour limit. One exception to this exemption is where a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. In such a case, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
Despite this provision protecting dying deponents, the statute has been interpreted to allow discretion in granting additional time, and such deponents have been subjected to depositions much longer than the 14 hours provided for in the statute.
In response, this bill places a clear cap of seven hours on the deposition testimony of a plaintiff deponent when: (1) the plaintiff suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis; (2) the action is for injury or illness resulting in such illness; and (3) a physician attests that such illness raises doubt as to the plaintiff’s survival beyond six months. Courts have the ability to extend such depositions by up to three hours upon request by the defendant. This bill is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California, the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, and the District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California. It is supported by a number of unions representing the workers who are negatively affected by these diseases. It is opposed by various law firms that represent defendants in asbestos litigation and associated groups.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
1) Provides, through the Civil Discovery Act, procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain “discovery,” including by, among other things, oral depositions. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2017.010 et seq.)
2) Permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.420.) It further authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.470.)
3) Governs, through the Rules of Court, complex cases, and defines them as an action that requires exceptional judicial management to avoid placing unnecessary burdens on the court or the litigants and to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, and promote effective decision making by the court, the parties, and counsel. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.400.)
4) Provides that a deposition is limited to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(a).)
5) Provides a series of exemptions from the presumptive limit of seven hours of deposition testimony, including cases designated as complex, as specified, unless a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months, in which case the deposition shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(b).)
6) Provides that nothing in the section laying out exemptions shall be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect against unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.290(c).)
7) Provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent’s successor in interest, as specified, and an action may be commenced by the decedent’s personal representative or, if none, by the decedent’s successor in interest. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.30.) In such an action or proceeding by a decedent’s personal representative or successor in interest on the decedent’s cause of action, the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
This bill:
1) Provides, notwithstanding Section 2025.290, that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma or silicosis, a deposition examination of the plaintiff by all counsel, other than the plaintiff’s counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
2) Permits a defendant to request and a court to grant, in its discretion, up to an additional three hours of deposition testimony for no more than 10 hours of total deposition conducted by the defendants. The court may grant such an extension if it finds that it is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
COMMENTS
- Intent of the bill
According to the author:
SB 645 will protect dying mesothelioma and silicosis victims by limiting cross‐examination in a deposition to 7 hours. Under the bill, upon request by defendants, a court may, in its discretion, grant up to 3 more hours for a total of no more than 10 hours of total deposition time by defense counsel if it finds an extension is in the interests of fairness, and the health of the deponent does not appear endangered by the grant of additional time. Without these limits, marathon depositions will continue to inflict undue emotional and physical harm on victims during their final days of life – even hastening death. SB 645 requires a licensed physician to attest that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma or silicosis and which raises substantial medical doubt of the deponent’s survival beyond six months. This tracks existing law in California Code of Civil Procedure [Section] 36.
- Background on depositions
A deposition is a witness’ out-of-court testimony reduced to writing for later use in a
court proceeding. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(d)(1), oral depositions generally must be limited to one day of seven hours in duration. Likewise, several states similarly provide for presumptive limits to depositions in certain contexts. For example, Arizona provides that the oral deposition of any party or witness, including expert witnesses, whenever taken, shall not exceed four hours in length, except pursuant to stipulation of the parties, or, upon motion and a showing of good cause. (Ariz. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 30(d); see also Tex. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 190.2.)
In California, a party generally may take the deposition of any person, including any other party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2025.010.) However, prior to 2012, California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, even though the modern discovery methods in California can be traced to the Civil Discovery Act of 1957 which, with minor changes, was patterned on the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Because California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, so long as counsel continued the deposition, they could have continued over any number of days and hours, leading up to the 30th day before the date initially set for a trial (or even longer if a court order or written agreement extends the statutory cut-off).
In response to abuses of the system and to harmonize with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was enacted into law. AB 1875 added California Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290. Subdivision (a) of that section establishes a presumptive time limit of seven hours of total deposition testimony for each witness. This subdivision contains a sentence granting discretion to the court to allow additional time for testimony “if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstances impedes or delays the examination.”
Subdivision (b) of Section 2025.290 lays out the exemptions to the seven-hour presumption. Paragraph (3) exempts cases declared complex pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. The statute provides, however, an exception to the exemption. It states the complex case exception does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that “the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months.” In that instance, the deposition examination of the deponent by all counsel, other than the deponent’s counsel of record, must be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
The issue that has arisen, and that has motivated this legislation, is whether and how the clause in subdivision (a) providing the court discretion to grant additional time for a deposition applies to the “exception to the exception” where a deponent in a complex case provides documentation that there is substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The relevant question is how courts should apply the two-day, 14-hour limitation provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
3. Providing additional protections to dying plaintiff
Committee analyses of AB 1875 reveal that the “exception to the exception” that was created by the bill was intended to address the same issues motivating the current bill: “This ‘exception to the exception’ is aimed, in many respects, at problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.” Some courts had been limiting oral depositions in asbestos cases, locally, but AB 1875 sought to make such limitations universal.
However, since that time, the statute has been interpreted by courts such that the seven to 14 hour limit on depositions for deponents in complex cases with an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months is subject to the broad discretion vested in the courts by the preceding section. (See Certainteed Corp. v. Superior Court (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1053, 1056.)
This bill provides a clear cap on the length of depositions of plaintiffs suffering from either mesothelioma or silicosis where certain conditions are met. First, the bill only covers civil actions arising from the injury or illness that results in the disease. Second, a licensed physician must attest in a declaration that the deponent plaintiff suffers from the disease and that such diagnosis raises “substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.” Finally, this seven-hour maximum can be extended by up to three hours by the court upon request by the defendant.
The deponents that would benefit from this legislation are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma (a disease caused by asbestos exposure) is approximately one year.[1] Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually is increasing.
Silicosis is a lung disease caused by breathing in tiny bits of silica, which is a mineral found in sand, rock, and mineral ores such as quartz.[2] Millions of workers in the United States are exposed to respirable crystalline silica, or silica dust, in certain occupations such as construction, mining, glass manufacturing, and foundry work.[3] Exposure to silica particles causes scarring in the lungs over time and can cause major lung damage, lung cancer, and pulmonary tuberculosis. There is no cure for silicosis and more than 100 people die each year in this country as a result.
Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and have time to file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible. (See Code Civ. Proc. § 377.34.)
The State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, a co-sponsor of this bill, explains what many of these victims face from initial injury through litigation:
Victims of mesothelioma, a disease caused only by exposure to asbestos that predominantly afflicts construction workers and their families, often have no idea when they were exposed to asbestos earlier in life. Family members who develop mesothelioma were more likely than not exposed to asbestos that their construction worker family member brought home on his or her clothes. Symptoms of the disease do not appear for years after exposure but, once present, victims commonly survive less than a year after diagnosis. It is a particularly painful disease that fills the lung cavity with fluid causing a drowning sensation and leading ultimately to death. Likewise, victims of silicosis, caused by exposure to crystalline dust from cutting stone, quartz, or tile, are often years removed from their exposure to silica dust before symptoms are present and might also have been exposed to it by family members. Silica dust is classified as a lung carcinogen and can cause shortness of breath, scarring of the lungs, labored breathing, and respiratory failure among other symptoms.
The symptoms for both diseases are painful and chronic and lead to a significantly reduced lifespan and quality of life. The symptoms make it extremely difficult to endure hours-long depositions from defense attorneys looking to reassign liability to other entities. Extended depositions are already hard on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from either illness.
The author, sponsors, and various organizations in support present additional examples of how the discovery process is abused in these cases and the effects it has on victims. In contrast, a group of law firms, writing individually in opposition to the bill, argue that this amendment is unnecessary as these issues are almost always worked out among counsel where appropriate. They argue this restraint on depositions unjustifiably limits their ability to properly question plaintiffs.
The Civil Justice Association of California, echoing sentiments shared in many of the letters in opposition, point to the large number of defendants that are usually named in the relevant litigation. They argue that in order to properly defend themselves in an asbestos claim, the defendants need to examine plaintiffs to determine the underlying facts regarding the plaintiff’s exposure. They argue this bill denies them due process by undermining their ability to so question the plaintiff. However, one law firm representing plaintiffs in such cases writes in response that defendants are provided extensive information almost immediately in the relevant litigation as a result of standing case management orders, including answers to standard interrogatories and access to employment, medical, Social Security, and military records.
The California Defense Counsel also writes in opposition. They argue that this bill would undermine an agreement that they made in 2012 regarding a previously enacted statute setting the presumptive limit on depositions. From a policy perspective, changes in how a law operates to the detriment of vulnerable Californians is arguably a sound basis to revisit any statute, previous agreements notwithstanding. Constitutionally speaking, one legislative body cannot limit or restrict its own power or that of subsequent Legislatures, and the act of one Legislature does not bind its successors. (In re Collie (1952) 38 Cal. 2d 396, 398, cert. denied, (1953) 345 U.S. 1000.) The power to legislate includes by necessary implication the power to amend existing legislation, and the amendment of a legislative act is itself a legislative act. (City of Sausalito v. County of Marin (1970) 12 Cal. App. 3d 550, 563-564.)
This bill places a tight limit on the length of deposition testimony, affording courts discretion only to extend to a total of 10 hours. However, depositions are only one of the many tools available in discovery. For example, the use of interrogatories can provide access to much of the same information defendants would seek in extended depositions and provide it in a timelier, more efficient, and not excessively redundant manner that does not overly tax the health of a dying plaintiff. If a responding plaintiff does not adequately respond to such interrogatories, there are mechanisms for defendants to compel further responses through the court. In addition, the bill is narrowly aimed only at those deponents for whom time is in short supply, and therefore, special consideration is arguably warranted. Ultimately, this bill provides a reasonable limitation on deposition testimony in a narrow subset of cases based on documented and extremely critical health concerns.
SUPPORT
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-sponsor)
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California (co-sponsor)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California (co-sponsor)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Conference of Machinists
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Federation of California
Contra Costa AFL-CIO Labor Council
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environmental Working Group
Inland Boatmen’s Union of the Pacific
International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, District Council 16
Local #5 Retirees Club
National Lawyers Guild, Labor and Employment Committee
Physicians for Social Responsibility, San Francisco Bay Area
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Teamsters California State Council of Cannery and Food Processing Unions
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Worksafe
OPPOSITION
Association of Defense Counsel of Northern California and Nevada
Bassi Edlin Huie and Blum
Bennett, Samuelsen, Reynolds, Allard, Cowperthwaite, and Gelini
Berkes Crane Robinson and Seal LLP
Bishop Barry PC
California Defense Counsel
Civil Justice Association of California
CMBG3 Law LLC
Glazier Yee LLP
Gordon and Rees Scully Mansukhani
Hugo Parker LLP
Imai, Tadlock, Keeney and Cordery LLP
Knox Ricksen LLP
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard and Smith LLP
Polsinelli LLP
Selman Breitman LLP
Sinunu Bruni LLP
Spanos Przetak
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending: None known
Prior:
SB 632 (Monning, 2018) would have limited the deposition in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma to seven hours for a deponent who suffers from mesothelioma. It would have allowed the court, in its discretion, to grant an additional seven hours of deposition if it found that the extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. A version of the bill passed through this Committee. It died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) See Comment 2.
**************
Jacek M. Mazurek, et al., Malignant Mesothelioma Mortality – United States, 1999-2015 (March 3, 2017) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention website, https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/66/wr/ mm6608a3.htm [as of Mar. 18, 2019]. ↑
American Lung Association, Learn About Silicosis, https://www.lung.org/lung-health-and-diseases/lung-disease-lookup/silicosis/learn-about-silicosis.html [as of Mar. 18, 2019]. ↑
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Silica, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/silica/ [as of Mar. 20, 2019]. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):