SB 652: Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 154, Statutes of 2019. |
| Jul 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 19, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and JUD. |
| May 7, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 1, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HOUSING with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Mar 19, 2019 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and HOUSING. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 8, 2019 | SB 652 Allen Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Consent Calendar SB652 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Housing] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 652
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
Proposed Consent
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions
KEY ISSUE: should a landlord or homeowner’s association (HOA) be prohibited from adopting or enforcing any rule that prevents a tenant or HOA MEMBER from displaying a religious item on an entry door or door frame, subject to reasonable exceptions?
SYNOPSIS
SB 652 responds to a handful of incidents where a homeowner’s association (HOA) reportedly asked a resident to remove a mezuzah from the entry door or doorframe of the separate HOA property. The mezuzah is a small scroll – usually no larger than an average bookmark – that many Jews place on entry doors to fulfill a Biblical obligation. As the author and sponsor stress, this is not a choice, but rather is a religious duty of observant Jews. This bill would prohibit a “property owner” (defined to mean an HOA, an HOA board, or landlord) from adopting or enforcing any rule that prohibits the display of one or more “religious items” on an entry door or doorframe. The bill defines “religious item” to mean any item displayed “because of sincerely held religious beliefs.” The bill also carves out reasonable exceptions, such as allowing an HOA or landlord to prohibit the display of anything that threatens public health or safety, violates existing law, contains obscenities, or is larger than 36 by 12 inches, for example.
The problem this bill addresses in not large numerically, as there appears to have been only a few instances across the country where someone was asked to remove a mezuzah or similar religious item. Although the bill was prompted by these handful of incidents involving mezuzahs, the language of the bill is a bit broader in that it would prohibit the display of any religious item on a door or doorframe so long as the display reflects “sincerely held religious beliefs.” Existing law provides protections against religious discrimination in housing, and more specifically the Davis-Stirling Act specifically allows HOA members to display signs, banners, and posters. However, the author and sponsor apparently believe that these protections are not clear or sufficient enough to protect the display of religious items. The bill is co-sponsored by the Anti-Defamation League and the Jewish Public Affairs Council. The bill has no known opposition.
This bill is eligible for placement on the Committee’s Consent calendar because it has received no negative votes and has no opposition, and – in light of current case law – it would probably be found a reasonable accommodation of religion. Be that as it may, the bill is oddly and unnecessarily narrow. For example, the bill would not offer protection for a tenant or HOA member who wanted to post an item that expressed a nonreligious belief, and more curiously, it would not even protect a tenant or HOA member who wanted to post a religious item, but somewhere other than on an entry door or doorframe. Therefore, as the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider expanding its reach to protect other kinds and forms of expression of sincerely held beliefs, both religious and nonreligious.
SUMMARY: Prohibits property owners from adopting or enforcing any rule that prohibits the display of religious items, as defined, in specified areas, subject to certain exceptions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a property owner from enforcing or adopting a restriction that prohibits the display of a religious item on any entry door or entry doorframe of a dwelling. Defines “property owner” for this purpose to mean a home-owners association (HOA) created for the purpose of managing a common interest development, the board of directors of an HOA, or a landlord. Defines “religious item” for this purpose to mean an item displayed because of sincerely held religious beliefs.
- Specifies that the prohibition in 1), above does not prohibit the enforcement or adoption of a rule that restricts any display that does any of the following:
- Threatens the public health or safety.
- Hinders the opening or closing of any entry door.
- Violates any federal, state, or local law.
- Contains graphics, language, or any display that is obscene or otherwise illegal.
- Individually or in combination has a total size that is greater than 36 by 12 inches.
- Specifies that an HOA may require a separate interest owner to remove a religious item as necessary to perform maintenance on a door or doorframe.
EXISTING LAW:
- Guarantees free exercise and enjoyment of religion without discrimination or preference. Specifies, however, that this liberty of conscience does not excuse acts that are licentious or inconsistent with the peace or safety of the State. Prohibits the Legislature from making any laws respecting the establishment of religion. (California Constitution, Article I, Section 4.)
- Prohibits government from making any law respecting the establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. (U.S. Constitution, Amendment I, applied to the states through Amendment XIV.)
- Prohibits the governing documents of a common interest development from prohibiting the posting or displaying of noncommercial signs, posters, flags, banners, on or in an owner’s separate interest, subject to certain exceptions. (Civil Code Section 4710.)
- Prohibits a landlord from prohibiting a tenant from temporarily posting or displaying political signs relating to an election or legislative vote, the initiative, referendum, or recall process, or issues before a public body for a vote, subject to certain exceptions. (Civil Code Section 1940.4.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author and sponsor, SB 652 responds to a handful of isolated incidents where a homeowner’s association (HOA) demanded that a resident remove a mezuzah from the entry door or doorframe of the separate HOA property. The mezuzah is small scroll – usually no larger than an average bookmark – that many Jews place on entry doors to fulfill a Biblical obligation. As the author and sponsor stress, hanging the mezuzah is not a choice, but rather is a religious duty of observant Jews. This bill would prohibit a “property owner” (defined to mean an HOA, an HOA board, or landlord) from adopting or enforcing any rule that prohibits the display of one or more “religious items” on an entry door or doorframe. The bill defines “religious items” to mean any item displayed “because of sincerely held religious beliefs.” The bill also carves out reasonable exceptions that would allow an HOA or landlord to prohibit the display of anything that threatens public health or safety, violates existing law, hinders the opening or closing of the door, contains obscenities, or is larger than 36 by 12 inches. The bill also takes account of situations in which an item must be removed for maintenance purposes.
Scope of Problem and Existing Law: It appears that there have been only a few isolated incidents of HOAs requiring members to remove mezuzahs, and the Committee is not aware of any landlord who has forced a tenant to remove a mezuzah, or any other religious item. Nonetheless, as the sponsors point out, even if such demands are rare, when they occur they force observant Jews to make a difficult choice: disobey a religious mandate or face whatever consequences that might stem from ignoring the demands of a landlord or HOA board.
Existing Rights of HOA Members: While existing law offers some protection to the expressive rights of HOA members, those protections do not unequivocally protect a member’s right to display a religious item like a mezuzah. For example the Davis-Stirling Act, which regulates HOAs and common interest developments, contains a provision that prohibits HOA governing documents from having ant provisions that “prohibit posting or displaying of noncommercial signs, posters, flags, or banners on or in a member’s separate interest, except as required for the protection of public health and safety, or if the posting would violate a local, state, or federal law.” This existing provision specifies that items may be made of paper, cardboard, cloth, plastic, or fabric, and that they may be posted or displayed from “the yard, window, door, balcony, or outside wall of the separate interest.” Similar to this bill, existing law allows an HOA to prohibit excessive displays, such as those using lights, or items that exceed specified sizes. (Civil Code Section 4710.) To the extent that a “religious item” is a sign, poster, flag, or banner, one could argue that existing law already prohibits an HOA from adopting or enforcing any rule that bans the display of religious items. But arguably there is a questions of whether a mezuzah, cross, or crescent hung from a door a “sign.” This bill will remove that ambiguity by making it clear that whether a religious item is a “sign” or not does not matter. The bill will protect any “item” which is displayed because of a sincere religious belief. In other ways, existing law may be more protective than this bill. If a religious item takes the form of “sign” or “poster,” it is not restricted to the door or doorframe; it can be posted or displayed from “the yard, window, door, balcony, or outside wall of the separate interest.”
In addition to the existing restrictions on prohibiting displays in the Davis-Sterling Act, the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), more generally, prohibits religious discrimination in housing. If an HOA prohibition singled out religious items in general, or items associated with one specific religion in particular, such as a mezuzah, it would arguably violate FEHA as a practice that discriminates on the basis of religion. Even though a restriction on displays on entry doors and doorframes might appear neutral on its face, it would be discriminatory in its disparate impact (if not intent), because the Jewish faith requires specifically that the mezuzah be displayed on entry doors, whereas items associated with different religions may be displayed in other ways or other places. However, given that HOAs are known for sometimes imposing exceedingly granular regulations on decorations and the like, under FEHA it would be difficult to prove that the rule was motivated by religious discrimination – as opposed to the seeming motivation of such HOA restrictions: bland and rigid uniformity.
Existing Expressive Rights of Tenants: Although a tenancy is unquestionably a property right –possessing at least some of the sticks in the heralded “bundle of rights” – a tenant’s property rights, unfortunately, are not afforded the same respect as the property rights of others. For example, while the HOA member has a right to display any reasonably-sized sign, poster, flag, or banner, on any subject, the tenant’s rights are restricted to political signs relating to an election, ballot measure, or a vote before a public board, and it may only be displayed for the period beginning 90 days before the election or vote to 15 days after. While HOA members could plausibly argue that existing law protects their right to display a religious item (so long as it is a sign or poster), the tenant’s rights are clearly restricted to temporary political signs regarding an election or vote by an official body. This bill would make it clear that a tenant, like an HOA member, has a right to post a religious item on a door or doorframe.
Why Restrict this Bill to Religious Items on Entry Doors? The right afforded to HOA members and tenants in this bill is extremely limited, only applying to a “religious item” and, even then, only when the item is posted on an entry door or doorframe. While these limitations are easy to understand given the specific concern that prompted the bill – the right of Jews to display a mezuzah – but, as a policy matter, the limitations are rather odd and very narrow. If someone’s sincerely held religious convictions moved them to post a similarly-sized religious item in a window – or for that matter on a door other than an “entry” door – this bill would offer them no protection whatsoever. Moreover, the First Amendment’s establishment clause has been construed to not only prohibit government from favoring one religion over another religion; it also prohibits government favoring religion over nonreligion. (See e.g. Epperson v. Arkansas, 393 U.S. 97.) Yet, this bill singles out for special protection the display of “religious items,” defined as items reflecting “sincerely held religious beliefs.” But why would governments – which the First Amendment requires to be neutral as to religion and nonreligion – only protect a person’s right to display items that express sincerely held religious beliefs? To be sure, our Constitutional case law, at least under one theory of the establishment clause, permits governments to “accommodate” religious beliefs or practices. However, the accommodation theory has generally been applied in the context of a government policy that would punish or deny a benefit to persons for exercising their religion. (For an overview of the competing approaches to the establishment clause and the cases associated with each approach, see Erwin Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law: Principles and Policies, 3d Ed., pp. 1192-1199.) Under this bill, the state would be prohibiting a private actor (who is not subject to either the free exercise or the establishment clause) from restricting a person’s right to express beliefs. As a policy matter, if not as a constitutional matter, there is no reason for the government to only protect the expression of religious beliefs, and, more curiously, only when that religious expression is effectuated by posting on an entry door or door frame.
This bill is eligible for placement on the Committee’s Consent calendar because it has received no negative votes and has no opposition, and – in light of current case law – it would probably be found a reasonable accommodation of religion. Be that as it may, the bill is oddly and unnecessarily narrow. For example, the bill would not offer protection for a tenant or HOA member who wanted to post an item that expressed a nonreligious belief, and more curiously, it would not even protect a tenant or HOA member who wanted to post a religious item, but somewhere other than on an entry door or doorframe. Therefore, as the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider expanding its reach to protect other kinds and forms of expression of sincerely held beliefs, both religious and nonreligious.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Anti-Defamation League (co-sponsor)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee, California (co-sponsor)
American Jewish Committee
Bend the Arc: Jewish Action
California Catholic Conference
Hindu American Foundation
Jewish Federation of Silicon Valley
National Association of Social Worker
San Francisco Interfaith Council
Union of Orthodox Congregations of America
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 652
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions
SUMMARY: Prohibits a property owner, defined as a common interest development (CID), a landlord, or a sublessor, from enforcing or adopting a restrictive covenant or any other restriction that prohibits one or more religious items from being displayed or affixed on any entry door frame to a dwelling. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that this bill does not prohibit, to the extent permitted by the California Constitution and the U.S. Constitution, the enforcement or adoption of a restrictive covenant or any other restriction prohibiting the display or affixing of a religious item on any entry door or door frame to a dwelling that:
- Threatens public health or safety;
- Hinders the opening or closing of any entry door;
- Violates any federal, state, or local law;
- Contains graphics, language, or any display that is obscene or otherwise illegal; and,
- Individually or in combination with any other religious item displayed or affixed on any entry door or door frame that has a total size greater than 36 by 12 square inches.
- Prohibits CID governing documents from limiting or prohibiting the display of one or more religious items on the entry door of the member’s separate interest.
- Requires a member to remove a religious item from the door of their separate interest when an HOA is performing maintenance, repair, or replacement of the door or door frame. Requires the HOA to serve notice to the member regarding the work and allows the member to display or affix the religious item upon completion of the work.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a landlord from banning tenants from posting or displaying political signs, as specified, unless the sign exceeds a specified size; violates a local, state, or federal law; or violates a lawful provision in a common interest development (CID) governing document.
- Prohibits the governing documents of a CID from limiting or prohibiting the display of the United States flag by one of its members (e.g., one of the residents of the CID) on or in the member’s individual separate interest (e.g., the member’s individual housing unit) or within the member’s exclusive use common area.
- Prohibits a CID from banning its members from posting or displaying non-commercial signs, poster, flags, or banners on or in a member’s separate interest, except as required for the protection of public health or safety or if the posting or display would violate a local, state, or federal law.
FISCAL EFFECT: None.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill: According to the author, “Many religions require or encourage members of their faith to display religious items in or outside their homes. For example, observant Jews hang a mezuzah on their entry doorpost. A mezuzah is a small, unobtrusive object – often less than six inches long and an inch wide – containing a verse from the Torah on parchment. For millennia, Jews have posted mezuzahs (“mezuzot” in Hebrew) on the entry doorframes of their homes in fulfillment of a religious obligation rooted in the Bible. A mezuzah is not a decorative choice for Jews, but rather a religious obligation that they have to abide by. For those living in houses, condominiums, or apartment buildings that are subject to homeowner association (HOA) or rental policies, this religious requirement could conflict with these policies. Many HOA and rental agreements have aesthetic or other rules that bar hanging anything on an entry doorframe. There have been several incidents where observant members of the Jewish community have been prevented from placing a mezuzah on an entry doorframe of their home. Such decisions taken by HOAs leave the affected people unable to freely practice their religious obligations and in some instances they must resort to leaving their residence and seek another place to live. Five states (Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Rhode Island and Texas) have adopted laws that prohibit the adoption or enforcement of policies barring the placement of religious items within a certain size limit on residents’ entry doors or doorframes. SB 652 would prohibit a property owner from enforcing or adopting a restrictive covenant or any other restriction disallowing the display or affixing of a religious item on an entry door or a doorframe. The measure makes clear that the displayed item(s) cannot pose a threat to the health or safety of others, hinder the opening or closing of an entry door, violate federal, state, or local laws, or contain obscene graphics or language that is otherwise illegal.”
Common interest developments: There are over 52,000 CIDs in the state that comprise over six million housing units, or approximately one quarter of the state's housing stock. CIDs include condominiums, community apartment projects, housing cooperatives, and planned unit developments. They are characterized by a separate ownership of dwelling space coupled with an undivided interest in a common property, restricted by covenants and conditions that limit the use of common area and the separate ownership interests, and the management of common property and enforcement of restrictions by an association. CIDs are governed by the Davis-Stirling Act (the Act) as well as the governing documents of the association, including bylaws, declaration, and operating rules.
Existing protections: Both the federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) and the state Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) broadly prohibit discrimination based on religion. The FHA prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, and financing of dwellings, and in other housing-related transactions, because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, and disability. The FEHA protects against discrimination based on “religious creed,” “religion,” “religious observance,” “religious belief,” and “creed,” defined as all aspects of religious belief, observance, and practice, including religious dress and grooming practices. Neither, however, specifically addresses religious items on doors.
Double-referred: This bill was also referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary where it will be heard should it pass out of this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Anti-Defamation League (co-sponsor)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee (co-sponsor)
American Jewish Committee
Bend the Arc: Jewish Action
California Catholic Conference
Hindu American Foundation
Jewish Federation of Silicon Valley
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
San Francisco Interfaith Council
Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 652 |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 652
Author: Allen (D), Glazer (D), Hertzberg (D), Jackson (D), Rubio (D), Stern (D) and Wiener (D), et al.
Amended: 4/22/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Wiener, Morrell, Bates, Caballero, Durazo, McGuire, Moorlach, Roth, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions
SOURCE: Anti-Defamation League
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
DIGEST:
This bill requires landlords and homeowners associations to allow their tenants and members to affix religious items to the door or doorframe of the tenants’ and members’ homes.
ANALYSIS: Existing federal law makes it unlawful for a housing provider to:
- Refuse to sell or rent after the making of a bona fide offer, or to refuse to negotiate for the sale or rental of, or otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any person because of religion; or
- Discriminate against any person in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling, or in the provision of services or facilities in connection therewith, because of religion. (42 U.S.C. § 3604(a) and (b).)
Existing state law:
- States, as part of the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), that housing discrimination on the basis of religion is against public policy. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
- Declares that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without religious discrimination is a civil right. (Gov. Code § 12921.)
- Makes it unlawful for the owner of any housing accommodation to discriminate against or harass any person because of the religion of that person. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
This bill:
- Provides that, with the exception of the permissible limitations set forth in (2), below, landlords, sublessors, homeowner associations, and homeowner association boards shall not enforce or adopt any restriction that prohibits one or more religious items from being displayed or affixed on any entry door or entry door frame to a dwelling.
- Provides that, to the extent permitted by constitutional guarantees to free exercise of religion, landlords, sublessors, homeowner associations, and homeowner association boards may adopt or enforce restrictions prohibiting the display or affixing of a religious item on any entry door or entry door frame to a dwelling that:
- threatens the public health or safety;
- hinders the opening or closing of any entry door;
- violates any federal, state, or local law;
- contains graphics, language, or any display that is obscene or otherwise illegal; or
- has a total size greater than 36 by 12 square inches, either individually or in combination with any other religious item displayed or affixed on any entry door or doorframe, provided that it does not exceed the size of the door.
- Defines “religious item” to mean “an item displayed because of sincerely held religious beliefs.”
- Requires a member to remove a religious item from the door of their separate interest when an HOA is performing maintenance, repair, or replacement of the door or door frame. Requires the HOA to serve notice to the member regarding the work and allows the member to display or affix the religious item upon completion of the work.
Comments
- Examples of the problem the bill is intended to address. The following incidents illustrate the problem that the bill is intended to address:
- An HOA in Connecticut threatened to fine a resident $50 if she would not remove the mezuzah she had affixed to her doorframe. The HOA permitted religious displays – such as Christmas wreaths – on doors, but restricted any adornments from being placed on exterior walls. The HOA construed doorframes as constituting part of the exterior walls.
- An HOA in Florida ordered a resident to remove a mezuzah, citing its by-laws prohibiting owners and occupants from attaching, hanging, affixing or displaying anything on the exterior walls, doors, balconies, railings, and windows of the building.
- Shortly after she moved in, an HOA in New York State fined a resident $50 for affixing a mezuzah to her doorframe. The HOA cited its then-existing bylaws, which prohibited residents from changing or altering the exterior of their home without permission. The rule included affixing of signs, advertisements, or statuary.
- The federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) and state Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) likely protect mezuzot and similar religious displays. Both the FHA and FEHA prohibit housing discrimination based on religion. Thus landlords and homeowner associations cannot have covenants or lease terms that treat some religions better than others. In addition, courts have interpreted the federal act to outlaw generally applicable rules or practices that unintentionally discriminate based on religion by disparately impacting one or more religious groups. (Tex. Dep’t of Hous. & Cmty. Affairs v. Inclusive Cmtys. Project, Inc. (2015) 576 U.S.___ [135 S.Ct. 2507]. FEHA would probably be interpreted similarly. (Price v. Civil Service Com. (1980) 26 Cal.3d 257, 271; Kamen v. Lindly (2001) 94 Cal.App.4th 197, 203 (federal interpretations of civil rights laws “are unusually strong persuasive precedent” for construction of the FEHA).)
Lease terms or covenants that ban adornments on doors and doorframes may be facially neutral, but by preventing all occupants from displaying a mezuzah, these rules exclude those Jewish people who sincerely believe they cannot inhabit a dwelling without a mezuzah. In other words, such rules have just the sort of “disparate impact” on Jewish residents that courts have found to be unlawful housing discrimination.
Thus the display of religious items like mezuzot on doors and doorframes is probably already protected under existing law. Nonetheless, this bill codifies that principle. At the same time, the bill provides landlords and homeowner associations with a roadmap for what limitations on religious displays on doors and doorframes are permissible, thus supplying the sort of helpful guidance and clarity that can reduce future disputes and litigation over the matter.
- Similar laws in other states. If this bill were enacted, California would join four other states – Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Rhode Island, and Texas – that provide specific state statutory protections for the displays of religious items in doorways and doorframes. (See Conn. Gen. Stat. § 47-230a; Fla. Stat. § 718.113; 765 ILCS 605/18.4; R.I. Gen. L. § 34-37-5.5; and Tex. Prop. Code § 202.018.) The remaining states do not have state statutes governing the display of religious items, but would be subject to the federal FHA which, as detailed in Comment 2, above, almost certainly provides protection for such displays.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Anti-Defamation League (co-source)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California (co-source)
American Jewish Committee
Bend the ARC: Jewish Action
Hindu American Foundation, Inc.
Jewish Federation of Silicon Valley
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
San Francisco Interfaith Council
Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America
One individual
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
For millennia, Jews have posted mezuzahs (“mezuzot” in Hebrew) on the entry doorframes of their homes in fulfillment of a religious obligation rooted in the Bible. A mezuzah is not a decorative choice for Jews, but rather a religious obligation that they have to abide by. For those living in houses, condominiums, or apartment buildings that are subject to homeowner association (HOA) or rental policies, this religious requirement could conflict with these policies. Many HOA and rental agreements have aesthetic or other rules that bar hanging anything on an entry doorframe. There have been several incidents where observant members of the Jewish community have been prevented from placing a mezuzah on an entry doorframe of their home. Such decisions taken by HOAs leave the affected people unable to freely practice their religious obligations and in some instances they must resort to leaving their residence and seek another place to live.
As sponsor of the bill, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) writes:
On occasion… a landlord or association will insist that Jewish residents remove or refrain from posting their mezuzahs. Jewish residents may be forced to vacate their homes, or look to rent or buy elsewhere, as a consequence. Across the country and throughout California, the… ADL has fielded inquiries from Jews shocked to find themselves in this position. Simply put, they could not have imagined that anyone would object to a mezuzah or be unmoved once learning of its religious necessity. ADL advocates for passage of [SB 652] in California so no Jewish person here should have to confront this predicament.
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/1/19 14:35:20
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 652 Hearing Date: 4/30/2019
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | 4/22/2019 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Erin Riches | ||
SUBJECT: Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions
DIGEST: This bill requires landlords and homeowners associations (HOAs) to allow their tenants and members to affix small religious items to the door or doorframe of the tenants’ and members’ homes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Prohibits a landlord from banning tenants from posting or displaying political signs, as specified, unless the sign exceeds a specified size; violates a local, state, or federal law; or violates a lawful provision in a common interest development (CID) governing document.
- Prohibits the governing documents of a CID from limiting or prohibiting the display of the United States flag by one of its members (e.g., one of the residents of the CID) on or in the member’s individual separate interest (e.g., the member’s individual housing unit) or within the member’s exclusive use common area.
- Prohibits a CID from banning its members from posting or displaying non-commercial signs, poster, flags, or banners on or in a member’s separate interest, except as required for the protection of public health or safety or if the posting or display would violate a local, state, or federal law.
This bill:
- Prohibits a property owner, defined as a CID, a landlord, or a sublessor, from enforcing or adopting a restrictive covenant or any other restriction that prohibits one or more religious items from being displayed or affixed on any entry door frame to a dwelling.
- Provides that this bill does not prohibit, to the extent permitted by the California Constitution and the US Constitution, the enforcement or adoption of a restrictive covenant or any other restriction prohibiting the display or affixing of a religious item on any entry door or door frame to a dwelling that:
- Threatens public health or safety.
- Hinders the opening or closing of any entry door.
- Violates any federal, state, or local law.
- Contains graphics, language, or any display that is obscene or otherwise illegal.
- Individually or in combination with any other religious item displayed or affixed on any entry door or door frame that has a total size greater than 36 by 12 square inches.
- Prohibits CID governing documents from limiting or prohibiting the display of one or more religious items on the entry door of the member’s separate interest.
- Requires a member to remove a religious item from the door of their separate interest when an HOA is performing maintenance, repair, or replacement of the door or door frame. Requires the HOA to serve notice to the member regarding the work and allows the member to display or affix the religious item upon completion of the work.
COMMENTS
- Purpose of the bill. The author states that many religions require or encourage members of their faith to display religious items in or outside their homes. For example, observant Jews hang a mezuzah on their entry doorpost. For millennia, Jews have posted mezuzahs on the entry doorframes of their homes in fulfillment of a religious obligation rooted in the Bible. Sometimes, this religious requirement conflicts with HOA and rental agreements with aesthetic or other rules that bar hanging anything on an entry doorframe. There have been several incidents where observant members of the Jewish community have been prevented from placing a mezuzah on an entry doorframe of their home. Such decisions taken by HOAs leave the affected people unable to freely practice their religious obligations and in some instances they must resort to leaving their residence altogether. This measure would protect Jewish and other households against such incidents, while making clear that the displayed item cannot pose a threat to the health or safety of others, hinder the opening or closing of an entry door, violate federal, state, or local laws, or contain obscene graphics or language that is otherwise illegal.
- CID background. A CID is a form of real estate in which each homeowner has an exclusive interest in a unit or lot and a shared or undivided interest in common-area property. Condominiums, planned unit developments, stock cooperatives, community apartments, and many resident-owned mobilehome parks all fall under the umbrella of CIDs. There are more than 50,000 CIDs in California comprising over 4.8 million housing units, or approximately one-quarter of the state’s housing stock. CIDs are governed by HOAs. The Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act provides the legal framework under which CIDs are established and operate. In addition to the requirements of the Act, each CID is governed according to the recorded declarations, bylaws, and operating rules of the association, collectively referred to as the governing documents.
- What is a mezuzah? This bill is specifically intended to protect the right of a Jewish household to display a mezuzah on its front door or doorpost. A mezuzah, which is often only about six inches long and about an inch wide, comprises a piece of parchment contained in a decorative case and inscribed with specific Hebrew verses from the Torah. Some interpret Jewish law to require a mezuzah in every doorway of the home that leads to living space (e.g., not bathrooms or closets). Jewish law requires that for homes outside Israel, the mezuzah shall be affixed to doors within 30 days of moving into a rented house or apartment. For a purchased home or apartment in Israel, the mezuzah is permanently affixed immediately upon moving in, as it is assumed that when a Jew lives in Israel, it shall remain their permanent residence. Mezuzahs are special objects and must be treated with care and according to Jewish laws and traditions.
- Don’t protections already exist? Both the federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) and the state Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) broadly prohibit discrimination based on religion. The FHA prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, and financing of dwellings, and in other housing-related transactions, because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, and disability. The FEHA protects against discrimination based on “religious creed,” “religion,” “religious observance,” “religious belief,” and “creed,” defined as all aspects of religious belief, observance, and practice, including religious dress and grooming practices. Neither, however, specifically addresses religious items on doors.
- Other states. The author notes that five states (Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Rhode Island, and Texas) have adopted laws that specifically prohibit the adoption or enforcement of policies barring the placement of religious items within a certain size limit on residents’ entry doors or doorframes.
- Double referral. This bill was passed by the Judiciary Committee on an 8-0 vote on April 2nd. This committee will focus on the CID provisions of this bill.
Related Legislation:
SB 329 (Mitchell, 2019) — makes all forms of housing subsidy voucher a “source of income,” on the basis of which a landlord may not discriminate against a tenant. This bill will be heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee on April 30th.
SB 222 (Hill, 2019) — includes “military or veteran status” among the categories protected against housing discrimination under the FEHA. Also makes a Veterans Assistance Supportive Housing (VASH) voucher a “source of income,” on the basis of which a landlord may not discriminate against a tenant. This bill will be hearing in the Senate Appropriations Committee on April 29th.
AB 446 (Choi, 2019) — adds “victim of abuse” as a protected housing status under the FEHA. This bill passed the Assembly Housing Committee on a 8-0 vote and will be heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee on April 24th.
AB 53 (Jones-Sawyer, 2019) — prohibits a landlord from denying the rental or lease of a housing accommodation without first satisfying specified requirements related to the application process. This bill will be heard in Assembly Housing Committee on April 24th.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
April 24, 2019.)
SUPPORT:
Anti-Defamation League (Co-Sponsor)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee (Co-Sponsor)
American Jewish Committee
Bend The Arc: Jewish Action
Hindu American Foundation, Inc.
Jewish Federation Of Silicon Valley
National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter
OPPOSITION:
None received.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 652 (Author:Allen)
Version: February 22, 2019
Hearing Date: April 2, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Entry doors: display of religious items: prohibitions
DIGEST
This bill would require landlords and homeowners associations to allow their tenants and members to affix small religious items to the door or doorframe of the tenants’ and members’ homes.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Torah is one of Judaism’s primary religious texts. It contains a commandment for adherents to affix a mezuzah – a small container enclosing a scroll of sacred text – on the frame of the doorways to their homes. Occasionally, however, landlords and homeowner associations refuse to allow their tenants and members to hang mezuzot, citing generally applicable covenants or lease terms that prohibit adornments on doorways and doorframes. Under case law interpreting the federal Fair Housing Act and California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act, the enforcement of such rules against Jewish residents would likely be considered unlawful housing discrimination because, although the lease terms or covenants do not single out any religious group on their face, their practical effect is to force Jewish residents to forgo the housing or deny a fundamental article of their religious faith. This bill would clarify that tenants and homeowner association residents have the right to display religious items on the doorways and doorframes of their homes. At the same time, the bill would set forth permissible limitations that landlords and homeowner associations may impose on the display of these religious items. Although the bill would certainly encompass mezuzot, it would apply equally to any other religious item hung on a door or doorframe.
The bill is sponsored by the Anti-Defamation League and the Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California. There is no known opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Makes it unlawful for a housing provider to:
- refuse to sell or rent after the making of a bona fide offer, or to refuse to negotiate for the sale or rental of, or otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any person because of religion; or
- discriminate against any person in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling, or in the provision of services or facilities in connection therewith, because of religion. (42 U.S.C. § 3604(a) and (b).)
Existing state law:
- States, as part of the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), that housing discrimination on the basis of religion is against public policy. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
- Declares that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without religious discrimination is a civil right. (Gov. Code § 12921.)
- Makes it unlawful for the owner of any housing accommodation to discriminate against or harass any person because of the religion of that person. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
This bill:
- Provides that, with the exception of the permissible limitations set forth in (2), below, landlords, sublessors, homeowner associations, and homeowner association boards shall not enforce or adopt any restriction that prohibits one or more religious items from being displayed or affixed on any entry door or entry door frame to a dwelling.
- Provides that, to the extent permitted by constitutional guarantees to free exercise of religion, landlords, sublessors, homeowner associations, and homeowner association boards may adopt or enforce restrictions prohibiting the display or affixing of a religious item on any entry door or entry door frame to a dwelling that:
- threatens the public health or safety;
- hinders the opening or closing of any entry door;
- violates any federal, state, or local law;
- contains graphics, language, or any display that is obscene or otherwise illegal; or
- has a total size greater than 36 square inches, either individually or in combination with any other religious item displayed or affixed on any entry door or doorframe.
- Defines “religious item” to mean “an item displayed because of sincerely held religious beliefs.”
COMMENTS
- Examples of the problem the bill is intended to address
The following incidents illustrate the problem that the bill is intended to address:
- An HOA in Connecticut threatened to fine a resident $50 if she would not remove the mezuzah she had affixed to her doorframe. The HOA permitted religious displays – such as Christmas wreaths – on doors, but restricted any adornments from being placed on exterior walls. The HOA construed doorframes as constituting part of the exterior walls.[1]
- An HOA in Florida ordered a resident to remove a mezuzah, citing its by-laws prohibiting owners and occupants from attaching, hanging, affixing or displaying anything on the exterior walls, doors, balconies, railings, and windows of the building.[2]
- Shortly after she moved in, an HOA in New York State fined a resident $50 for affixing a mezuzah to her doorframe. The HOA cited its then-existing bylaws, which prohibited residents from changing or altering the exterior of their home without permission. The rule included affixing of signs, advertisements, or statuary.[3]
2. The federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) and state Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) likely protect mezuzot and similar religious displays
Both the FHA and FEHA prohibit housing discrimination based on religion. Thus landlords and homeowner associations cannot have covenants or lease terms that treat some religions better than others. In addition, courts have interpreted the federal act to outlaw generally applicable rules or practices that unintentionally discriminate based on religion by disparately impacting one or more religious groups. (Tex. Dep’t of Hous. & Cmty. Affairs v. Inclusive Cmtys. Project, Inc. (2015) 576 U.S.___ [135 S.Ct. 2507]. FEHA would probably be interpreted similarly. (Price v. Civil Service Com. (1980) 26 Cal.3d 257, 271; Kamen v. Lindly (2001) 94 Cal.App.4th 197, 203 (federal interpretations of civil rights laws “are unusually strong persuasive precedent” for construction of the FEHA).)
Lease terms or covenants that ban adornments on doors and doorframes may be facially neutral, but by preventing all occupants from displaying a mezuzah, these rules exclude those Jewish people who sincerely believe they cannot inhabit a dwelling without a mezuzah. In other words, such rules have just the sort of “disparate impact” on Jewish residents that courts have found to be unlawful housing discrimination.
Thus the display of religious items like mezuzot on doors and doorframes is probably already protected under existing law. Nonetheless, this bill codifies that principle. At the same time, the bill provides landlords and homeowner associations with a roadmap for what limitations on religious displays on doors and doorframes are permissible, thus supplying the sort of helpful guidance and clarity that can reduce future disputes and litigation over the matter.
3. Similar laws in other states
If this bill were enacted, California would join four other states – Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Rhode Island, and Texas – that provide specific state statutory protections for the displays of religious items in doorways and doorframes. (See Conn. Gen. Stat. § 47-230a; Fla. Stat. § 718.113; 765 ILCS 605/18.4; R.I. Gen. L. § 34-37-5.5; and Tex. Prop. Code § 202.018.) The remaining states do not have state statutes governing the display of religious items, but would be subject to the federal FHA which, as detailed in Comment 2, above, almost certainly provides protection for such displays.
4. Possible extension of the bill to cover interior doorways and doorframes
In its current form, the bill’s protections for the display of religious items is limited to entry doors or doorframes. However, for some branches of Judaism, the commandment to hang mezuzot extends to some interior doorways as well. With that in mind, as the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider dropping the modifier “entry” from the bill, thus extending the bill’s protections to all doors and doorframes within the dwelling as well.
5. Possible extension of protection to cultural affinity, in addition to sincerely held religious belief
The bill in print defines a “religious item” as one displayed because of “sincerely held religious belief.” This addresses the most compelling circumstance: where enforcement of a lease term or covenant against the display of religious items would force tenants or residents in homeowner associations to choose between their housing and sincerely held religious beliefs. An argument can be made, however, that defining “religious items” in such a narrow fashion leaves out others who may also be deserving of the same protection.
In the case of mezuzot, for example, some Jewish people sincerely believe that hanging a mezuzah is a biblical commandment and that, as a result, they absolutely cannot reside in a dwelling if there is no mezuzah affixed to the doorframe. Such sincere adherents to this belief would be protected under this bill. Yet there are also many people of Jewish ancestry who identify strongly with Jewish customs, without necessarily sincerely ascribing to the associated religious tenets. If such culturally Jewish people wanted to display a mezuzah, this bill, as currently drafted, would not technically protect their ability to do so.
As the bill progresses, the author may wish to consider expanding the definition of “religious items” so as to provide protection for those who may not believe in a particular religious doctrine, but nonetheless identify with the customs associated with that religion such that they desire to display religious items on their doorway or doorframe.
6. Arguments In Support of the Bill
According to the author:
For millennia, Jews have posted mezuzahs (“mezuzot” in Hebrew) on the entry doorframes of their homes in fulfillment of a religious obligation rooted in the Bible. A mezuzah is not a decorative choice for Jews, but rather a religious obligation that they have to abide by. For those living in houses, condominiums, or apartment buildings that are subject to homeowner association (HOA) or rental policies, this religious requirement could conflict with these policies. Many HOA and rental agreements have aesthetic or other rules that bar hanging anything on an entry doorframe. There have been several incidents where observant members of the Jewish community have been prevented from placing a mezuzah on an entry doorframe of their home. Such decisions taken by HOAs leave the affected people unable to freely practice their religious obligations and in some instances they must resort to leaving their residence and seek another place to live.
As sponsor of the bill, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) writes:
On occasion… a landlord or association will insist that Jewish residents remove or refrain from posting their mezuzahs. Jewish residents may be forced to vacate their homes, or look to rent or buy elsewhere, as a consequence. Across the country and throughout California, the… ADL has fielded inquiries from Jews shocked to find themselves in this position. Simply put, they could not have imagined that anyone would object to a mezuzah or be unmoved once learning of its religious necessity. ADL advocates for passage of [SB 652] in California so no Jewish person here should have to confront this predicament.
SUPPORT
Anti-Defamation League (sponsor)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California (sponsor)
One individual
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 188 (Mitchell, 2019) proposes to define race, for purposes of workplace discrimination law, to include “traits historically associated with race,” including hair texture and protective hairstyles like braids, twists, and locks. SB 188 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
SB 222 (Hill, 2019) proposes to include “military or veteran status” among the categories protected against housing discrimination under the FEHA. The bill also makes a Veterans Assistance Supportive Housing (VASH) voucher a “source of income” on the basis of which landlords may not discriminate against a tenant. SB 222 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Committee on Judiciary.
SB 329 (Mitchell, 2019) proposes to make all forms of housing subsidy voucher a “source of income” on the basis of which landlords may not discriminate against a tenant. SB 329 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Committee on the Judiciary.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1427 (Hill, 2018) would have included “military or veteran status” among the categories protected against housing discrimination under the FEHA. The bill also would have made a VASH voucher a “source of income” on the basis of which landlords could not discriminate against a tenant. In his message vetoing SB 1427, then Governor Brown expressed his belief that landlord participation in the VASH program should be voluntary.
SB 1053 (Leno, 2016) would have made all forms of housing subsidy voucher a “source of income” on the basis of which landlords could not discriminate against tenants. SB 1053 died in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
**************
Connecticut Condo Bans Mezuzot — But Not Crosses (Mar. 23, 2012) Times of Israel https://www.timesofisrael.com/connecticut-condo-bans-mezuzot-but-not-crosses/ (as of Mar. 23, 2019). ↑
Kollin, Condo Bans Religious Symbol on Doorposts (Feb. 3, 2007) South Florida Sun Sentinel https://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/fl-xpm-2007-02-03-0702020721-story.html (as of Mar. 23, 2019). ↑
Lovece, Condo Fined $10,000 for Forbidding Religious Item on Apartment Door Habitat Magazine https://www.habitatmag.com/Publication-Content/Board-Operations/2009/2009-November/Condo-Fined-10-000-for-Forbidding-Religious-Item-on-Apartment-Door (as of Mar. 23, 2019). ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):