SB 672: Planning and zoning: regional housing need allocation: City of Brisbane.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-25
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | August 30 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | (Received at desk July 10 pursuant to JR 61(a)(10)). |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 3). Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and L. GOV. |
| May 21, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 14, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 22). |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Local Government] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| May 20, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB672 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 672
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Policy Committee: | Housing and Community Development | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Local Government | 8 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG), in the current and next planning period, from allocating to the City of Brisbane (City) a regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) share that exceeds the City’s RHNA allocation for the prior planning period, if specified conditions are met. Among the bill’s provisions:
- Requires the City zone to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period. (Note: the 615% reflects the amount of development it would take to reach 1,800 units on the Baylands site, given the City’s current RHNA of 263 units.)
- Requires the City demonstrate annually to HCD that demonstrable progress has been made to meeting its RHNA share on the site.
- Requires the City still zone to accommodate the remaining unmet share of the RHNA.
- Requires HCD, if the City fails to comply with the requirements of this bill, immediately determine the City’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General (AG).
- Requires the City, if the site is no longer viable to accommodate the proposed development, to find alternative sites to accommodate its RHNA within 180 days.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Anticipated annual costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars (GF) to HCD for additional staff for technical assistance, specialized review of zoning ordinances as updated throughout the planning period and determining if the City has made “demonstrable progress” toward meeting its commitments. These costs could be higher if referral to the AG is necessary.
- State-mandated local costs are not reimbursable by the state because affected agencies have the authority to levy fees to cover these costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to create an incentive, with state oversight, for the City to implement its commitment to developing affordable housing by providing a RHNA exemption under specified conditions. According to the author:
In November 2018, the voters in Brisbane made a significant commitment to regional housing when they approved Measure JJ which would permit the development of 1,800-2,200 units of housing on the Baylands. Given the complexity of the remediation and development process, Brisbane will be working for many years in coordination with the developer, state and regional agencies, and community members to keep this project on track. [This bill] allows Brisbane to focus its efforts on getting the Baylands – an important regional project – developed properly.
- Housing Allocation. The RHNA is a state-mandated process to identify the total number of housing units (by affordability level) each jurisdiction must accommodate in its Housing Element. As part of this process, HCD identifies the total housing need for the San Francisco Bay Area for an eight-year period (in the current cycle, 2015 to 2022). ABAG must then distribute this need to its local cities and counties in a manner consistent with the development pattern include in the Sustainable Communities Strategy. Once a local government has received its final RHNA, it must revise its Housing Element to show how it plans to accommodate its share of the region’s housing need.
This bill, by freezing Brisbane’s RHNA allocation, will require ABAG to redistribute the extra housing units that would otherwise have been allocated to Brisbane to other jurisdictions within ABAG’s region.
- Brisbane Baylands. The Brisbane Baylands project is a roughly 660-acre tract and located just south of San Francisco in the City of Brisbane. While the site location is desirable, decades of industrial uses, including a municipal landfill and a railyard, have left the site contaminated and will require substantial remediation prior to development.
The site has been owned since 1989 by the Universal Paragon Corporation (UPC), a real estate design and development firm based in San Francisco. UPC submitted a specific plan in 2006, which was later updated significantly and eventually became the “Developer Sponsored Plan” (DSP). The environmental impact report on the DSP was completed in 2015 and the planning commission completed its review the following year, with the proposal going to city council in the fall of 2016. The City ultimately developed Measure JJ as an alternative to the DSP. Measure JJ amends the general plan to rezone the Baylands site to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing, of which at least 15% must be affordable. The general plan amendment did not require voter approval, but the city council placed the measure on the November 2018 ballot, where it was approved by a 55% to 45% margin.
In January 2019, UPC delivered a letter of intent to the Brisbane City Council declaring its intent to revise the specific plan to conform to Measure JJ with a range of 1,800-2,200 units. The city council must approve the final specific plan. There is no guarantee that this approval will occur given the strong opposition garnered by the project. Even upon approval, it will likely take a number of years to plan, remediate and develop the Baylands site.
The bill seeks to facilitate the City’s commitment to developing housing on the Baylands site by freezing the City’s current RHNA requirement through 2030, if certain conditions are met by the City. However, because the City’s RHNA allocation in the next cycle is likely to be far less than the number of units the City pledged to build under measure JJ, it is unclear why this bill is necessary.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 672
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: regional housing need allocation: City of Brisbane.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) from allocating to the City of Brisbane (City) a regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) share that exceeds the City’s allocation for the prior planning period, if specified conditions are met. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits ABAG, in the current and next planning period, from allocating the City of Brisbane a RHNA share that exceeds the City’s RHNA allocation for the prior planning period, if all of the following apply:
- The City has taken action during the current planning period to zone or rezone sites sufficient to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period;
- The City maintains or rezones sites sufficient to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the next planning period;
- The City agrees to provide a copy of its Annual Progress Report (APR) to ABAG for each year of the current and next planning period; and,
- The City approves a specific plan within 24 months of the developer of the Brisbane Baylands project submitting a revised application that satisfies the applicable criteria of the City’s general plan, as amended by ballot initiative in November 2018.
- Requires the City, in the current and next planning period, to include in its APR information regarding demonstrable progress on meeting the 615 % RHNA share.
- Provides that if the City fails to provide information in its APR showing demonstrable progress, as determined by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), or fails to comply with the other requirements of this bill, HCD shall immediately determine that Brisbane’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- Provides that this bill does not waive or reduce the City’s obligation to ensure that its housing element inventory accommodates, at all times throughout the housing planning period, its remaining unmet share of its regional housing need.
- Provides that if at any time the site used to comply with this bill is deemed no longer adequate to meet the 615% zoning requirement, the City must identify and make available additional sites to accommodate its RHNA within 180 days.
- States legislative intent regarding the unique circumstances relating to the RHNA allocation needs in the county.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires every city and county to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a housing element, to guide the future growth of a community. The housing element must identify and analyze existing and projected housing needs, identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning to meet the housing needs of all income segments of the community, and ensure that regulatory systems provide opportunities for, and do not unduly constrain, housing development.
- Requires local governments located within the territory of a metropolitan planning organization (MPO) to revise their housing elements every eight years, following the adoption of every other regional transportation plan. Local governments in rural non-MPO regions must revise their housing elements every five years.
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing be determined through the RHNA process, which is composed of three main stages: a) the Department of Finance and HCD develop regional housing needs estimates; b) council of governments (COGs) allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and, c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires COGs to provide specified data assumptions to HCD from each COG’s projections.
- Requires the housing element to contain an assessment of housing needs and an inventory of resources and constraints relevant to meeting those needs.
- Requires a locality’s inventory of land suitable for residential development to be used to identify sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and that are sufficient to provide for the locality’s share of the regional housing need for all income levels.
- Requires, where the inventory of sites does not identify adequate sites to accommodate the need for groups of all household income levels, rezoning of those sites to be completed in a specified time period. Requires this rezoning to accommodate 100% of the need for housing for very low- and low-income households for which site capacity has not been identified in the inventory of sites on sites that shall be zoned to permit rental multifamily residential housing by right during the planning period.
- Prohibits a local jurisdiction from reducing or permitting the reduction of the residential density, or from allowing development at a lower residential density for any parcel, unless the jurisdiction makes specified written findings.
- Requires each jurisdiction to submit an annual progress report (APR) to HCD regarding its progress in meeting its RHNA allocation.
- Authorizes HCD to notify the Attorney General if it at any time finds a jurisdiction out of compliance with its housing element.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The Brisbane Baylands project is a roughly 660-acre tract and located just south of San Francisco in the City of Brisbane. The site location is highly desirable, as it is located close to rapidly developing southeast San Francisco and at the confluence of multiple modes of transportation. However, decades of industrial uses, including a municipal landfill and a railyard, have made the land toxic and costly to develop.
The site has been owned since 1989 by the Universal Paragon Corporation (UPC), a real estate design and development firm based in San Francisco. UPC underwent various concept plans for the site before submitting a specific plan in 2006, which was later updated significantly and eventually became the “Developer Sponsored Plan” (DSP). In 2009, the City began developing an alternative, the “Community Proposed Plan” (CPP) with input from residents. The key difference between the two plans was that the CPP did not include any housing, while the DSP included 4,434 housing units. The environmental impact report on the DSP was completed in 2015 and the planning commission completed its review the following year, with the proposal going to City Council in the fall of 2016. The City countered with an updated CPP. The City ultimately developed Measure JJ as an alternative to the DSP. Measure JJ amends the general plan to rezone the Baylands site to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing, of which at least 15% must be affordable. While the general plan amendment did not require voter approval, the City Council opted to place the measure on the November 2018 ballot, where it was approved by a 55% to 45% margin.
Before housing can be built on the Baylands site, a great deal of remediation will be necessary, which will take a number of years. Additionally a new specific plan must be developed for the entire site because the old plan was aligned with the DSP. The revised specific plan must address issues such as securing an adequate water supply, protecting key habitat areas, flood protection and sea-level rise, and providing revenue-positive development for the City. In January 2019, UPC delivered a letter of intent to the Brisbane City Council declaring its intent to revise the specific plan to conform with Measure JJ with a range of 1,800-2,200 units. The City Council must approve the final specific plan. There is no guarantee that this approval will take place, given the strong opposition garnered by the project. Even upon approval, it will take a number of years to plan, remediate, and develop the Baylands site.
The bill is intended to facilitate the City’s commitment to development of housing on the Baylands site while holding the City accountable for doing so. It does by keeping the City’s RHNA requirement the same through the rest of this housing element cycle (2015-2022) and the next one (2023-2030), if certain conditions are met by the City, including:
- That it zone to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period. Note that the 615% reflects the amount of development it would take to reach 1,800 units on the Baylands site given the City’s current RHNA of 263 units.
- That it demonstrate annually to HCD that demonstrable progress has been made to meeting its RHNA share on the site.
- That the City still zone to accommodate the remaining unmet share of the RHNA.
The bill also includes penalties if the conditions are not met, including:
- For any failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, HCD must immediately determine that the City’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- If the site is no longer viable to accommodate the proposed development then the City has 180 days to find alternative sites to meet its RHNA.
- Bill Summary and Author’s Statement. According to the author, “In November 2018, the voters in Brisbane made a significant commitment to regional housing when they approved Measure JJ which would permit the development of 1,800-2,200 units of housing on the Baylands. This would more than double the housing stock in Brisbane. Passing Measure JJ was a watershed moment for Brisbane and the state. Measure JJ reverses nearly 50 years of votes against development of the Baylands. It represents the type of local leadership we need throughout the Bay Area and the state if we are going to put a real dent in the housing crisis.
“Given the complexity of the remediation and development process, Brisbane will be working for many years in coordination with the developer, state and regional agencies, and community members to keep this project on track. SB 672 allows Brisbane to focus its efforts on getting the Baylands – an important regional project – developed properly. The bill does this by ensuring consistency in Brisbane’s regional housing needs allocations during this planning cycle and the next, in recognition of the commitment already made by the city’s voters to double its housing stock.”
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that this bill contains an incentive, but with state oversight, and will implement the City’s commitment to the development of housing.
- Arguments in Opposition. None on file.
- Double-Referral. This bill was heard in the Housing and Community Development Committee on July 3, 2019, and passed with an 8-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Brisbane [SPONSOR]
League of California Cities
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Date of Hearing: July 3, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 672
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: regional housing need allocation: City of Brisbane
SUMMARY: Prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) from allocating the City of Brisbane a regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) share that exceeds the City’s allocation for the prior planning period, if specified conditions are met. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits ABAG, in the current and next planning period, from allocating the City of Brisbane a RHNA share that exceeds Brisbane’s RHNA allocation for the prior planning period, if all of the following apply:
- Brisbane has taken action during the current planning period to zone or rezone sites sufficient to accommodate 615 percent or more of its RHNA for the current planning period;
- Brisbane maintains or rezones sites sufficient to accommodate 615 percent or more of its RHNA for the next planning period;
- Brisbane agrees to provide a copy of its APR to ABAG for each year of the current and next planning period; and
- The City of Brisbane approves a specific plan within 24 months of the developer of the Brisbane Baylands project submitting a revised application that satisfies the applicable criteria of the city’s general plan, as amended by ballot initiative in November 2018.
- Requires Brisbane, in the current and next planning period, to include in its APR information regarding demonstrable progress on meeting the 615 percent RHNA share.
- Provides that if Brisbane fails to provide information in its APR showing demonstrable progress, as determined by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), or fails to comply with the other requirements of this bill, HCD shall immediately determine that Brisbane’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- Provides that this bill does not waive or reduce Brisbane’s obligation to ensure that its housing element inventory accommodates, at all times throughout the housing planning period, its remaining unmet share of its regional housing need.
- Provides that if at any time the site used to comply with this bill is deemed no longer adequate to meet the 615 percent zoning requirement, the City of Brisbane must identify and make available additional sites to accommodate its RHNA within 180 days.
- States legislative intent regarding the unique circumstances relating to the RHNA allocation needs in the county.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires every city and county to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a housing element, to guide the future growth of a community. The housing element must identify and analyze existing and projected housing needs, identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning to meet the housing needs of all income segments of the community, and ensure that regulatory systems provide opportunities for, and do not unduly constrain, housing development.
- Requires local governments located within the territory of a metropolitan planning organization (MPO) to revise their housing elements every eight years, following the adoption of every other regional transportation plan. Local governments in rural non-MPO regions must revise their housing elements every five years.
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing be determined through the RHNA process, which is composed of three main stages: (a) the Department of Finance and HCD develop regional housing needs estimates; (b) council of governments (COGs) allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and (c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires COGs to provide specified data assumptions to HCD from each COG’s projections.
- Requires the housing element to contain an assessment of housing needs and an inventory of resources and constraints relevant to meeting those needs.
- Requires a locality’s inventory of land suitable for residential development to be used to identify sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and that are sufficient to provide for the locality’s share of the regional housing need for all income levels.
- Requires, where the inventory of sites does not identify adequate sites to accommodate the need for groups of all household income levels, rezoning of those sites to be completed in a specified time period. Requires this rezoning to accommodate 100% of the need for housing for very low- and low-income households for which site capacity has not been identified in the inventory of sites on sites that shall be zoned to permit rental multifamily residential housing by right during the planning period.
- Prohibits a local jurisdiction from reducing or permitting the reduction of the residential density, or from allowing development at a lower residential density for any parcel, unless the jurisdiction makes specified written findings.
- Requires each jurisdiction to submit an annual progress report (APR) to HCD regarding its progress in meeting its RHNA allocation.
- Authorizes HCD to notify the Attorney General if it at any time finds a jurisdiction out of compliance with its housing element.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of the Bill: According to the author, “SB 672 allows Brisbane to focus its efforts on getting the Baylands – an important regional project – developed properly. The bill does this by ensuring consistency in Brisbane’s regional housing needs allocations during this planning cycle and the next, in recognition of the commitment already made by the city’s voters to double its housing stock. SB 672 is not a gift. That is, the benefit to Brisbane under the bill is only available if the city continues to make steady progress with the Baylands development under the oversight of the Department of Housing and Community Development.”
Background: The genesis of this bill is a project called the Brisbane Baylands. This roughly 660-acre tract is located just south of San Francisco in the city of Brisbane. The site location is highly desirable, as it is located close to rapidly developing southeast San Francisco and at the confluence of multiple modes of transportation. However, decades of industrial uses, including a municipal landfill and a railyard, have made the land toxic and costly to develop.
Development Proposal for Brisbane Baylands: The site has been owned since 1989 by the Universal Paragon Corporation (UPC), a real estate design and development firm based in San Francisco. UPC underwent various concept plans for the site before submitting a specific plan in 2006, which was later updated significantly and eventually became the “Developer Sponsored Plan” (DSP). In 2009, the city began developing an alternative, the “Community Proposed Plan” (CPP) with input from residents. The key difference between the two plans was that the CPP did not include any housing, while the DSP included 4,434 housing units. The environmental impact report on the DSP was completed in 2015 and the planning commission completed its review the following year, with the proposal going to city council in the fall of 2016. The City countered with an updated CPP. The City ultimately developed Measure JJ as an alternative to the DSP. Measure JJ amends the general plan to rezone the Baylands site to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing, of which at least 15 percent must be affordable. While the general plan amendment did not require voter approval, the City Council opted to place the measure on the November 2018 ballot, where it was approved by a 55 percent to 45 percent margin.
Before housing can be built on the Baylands site, a great deal of remediation will be necessary, which will take a number of years. Additionally a new specific plan must be developed for the entire site because the old plan was aligned with the DSP. The revised specific plan must address issues such as securing an adequate water supply, protecting key habitat areas, flood protection and sea-level rise, and providing revenue-positive development for the city. In January 2019, UPC delivered a letter of intent to the Brisbane City Council declaring its intent to revise the specific plan to conform with Measure JJ with a range of 1,800-2,200 units. The City Council must approve the final specific plan. There is no guarantee that this approval will take place, given the strong opposition garnered by the project. Even upon approval, it will take a number of years to plan, remediate, and develop the Baylands site.
The bill is intended to facilitate Brisbane’s commitment to development of housing on the Baylands site while holding the city accountable for doing so. It does by keeping Brisbane’s RHNA requirement the same through the rest of this housing element cycle (2015-2022) and the next one (2023-2030) if certain conditions are met by the City, including:
- That it zone to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period. Note that the 615% reflects the amount of development it would take to reach 1,800 units on the Baylands site given Brisbane’s current RHNA of 263 units.
- That it demonstrate annually to HCD that demonstrable progress has been made to meeting its RHNA share on the site.
- That Brisbane still zone to accommodate the remaining unmet share of the RHNA.
The bill also includes penalties if the conditions are not met, including:
- For any failure to comply with the requirements of this bill, HCD must immediately determine that Brisbane’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- If the site is no longer viable to accommodate the proposed development then Brisbane has 180 days to find alternative sites to meet its RHNA.
Related Legislation:
SB 235 (Dodd, 2019) allows the City of Napa and the County of Napa to reach an agreement under which the County will be allowed to count certain housing units built within the city toward the County’s RHNA requirement. The bill was approved 8-0 by this Committee and is pending hearing in the Assembly Committee on Local Government.
Double referred: This bill was also referred to the Assembly Committee on Local Government where it will be heard should it pass out of this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Brisbane (Sponsor)
League of California Cities
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 672 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 672
Amended: 4/25/19
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/22/19
AYES: Wiener, Morrell, Bates, Caballero, Durazo, McGuire, Moorlach, Roth, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: regional housing need allocation: City of Brisbane
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) from allocating to the City of Brisbane a regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) share that exceeds the City’s allocation for the prior planning period, if specified conditions are met.
Existing law:
- Requires every city and county to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a housing element, to guide the future growth of a community. The housing element must identify and analyze existing and projected housing needs, identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning to meet the housing needs of all income segments of the community, and ensure that regulatory systems provide opportunities for, and do not unduly constrain, housing development.
- Requires local governments located within the territory of a metropolitan planning organization (MPO) to revise their housing elements every eight years, following the adoption of every other regional transportation plan. Local governments in rural non-MPO regions must revise their housing elements every five years.
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing be determined through the RHNA process, which is composed of three main stages: (a) the Department of Finance and Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) develop regional housing needs estimates; (b) council of governments (COGs) allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and (c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires COGs to provide specified data assumptions to HCD from each COG’s projections.
- Requires the housing element to contain an assessment of housing needs and an inventory of resources and constraints relevant to meeting those needs.
- Requires a locality’s inventory of land suitable for residential development to be used to identify sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and that are sufficient to provide for the locality’s share of the regional housing need for all income levels.
- Requires, where the inventory of sites does not identify adequate sites to accommodate the need for groups of all household income levels, rezoning of those sites to be completed in a specified time period. Requires this rezoning to accommodate 100% of the need for housing for very low- and low-income households for which site capacity has not been identified in the inventory of sites on sites that shall be zoned to permit rental multifamily residential housing by right during the planning period.
- Prohibits a local jurisdiction from reducing or permitting the reduction of the residential density, or from allowing development at a lower residential density for any parcel, unless the jurisdiction makes specified written findings.
- Requires each jurisdiction to submit an annual progress report (APR) to HCD regarding its progress in meeting its RHNA allocation.
- Authorizes HCD to notify the Attorney General if it at any time finds a jurisdiction out of compliance with its housing element.
This bill:
- Prohibits the ABAG, in the current and next planning period, from allocating to the City of Brisbane a RHNA share that exceeds Brisbane’s RHNA allocation for the prior planning period, if all of the following apply:
- Brisbane has taken action during the current planning period to zone or rezone sites sufficient to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period.
- Brisbane maintains or rezones sites sufficient to accommodate 615% or more of its RHNA for the next planning period.
- Brisbane agrees to provide a copy of its APR to ABAG for each year of the current and next planning period.
- Requires Brisbane, in the current and next planning period, to include in its APR information regarding demonstrable progress on meeting the 615% RHNA share.
- Provides that if Brisbane fails to provide information in its APR showing demonstrable progress, as determined by HCD, or fails to comply with the other requirements of this bill, HCD shall immediately determine that Brisbane’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- Provides that this bill does not waive or reduce Brisbane’s obligation to ensure that its housing element inventory accommodates, at all times throughout the housing planning period, its remaining unmet share of its regional housing need.
- Provides that if at any time the site used to comply with this bill is deemed no longer adequate to meet the 615% zoning requirement, the City shall comply with that zoning requirement within 80 days.
- States legislative intent regarding the unique circumstances relating to the RHNA allocation needs in the county.
Background
The genesis of this bill is a project called the Brisbane Baylands. This roughly 660-acre tract is located just south of San Francisco (between San Francisco International Airport and downtown San Francisco, near Hunters Point/Candlestick). The site location is highly desirable, as it is located close to rapidly developing southeast San Francisco and at the confluence of multiple modes of transportation. However, decades of industrial uses, including a municipal landfill and a railyard, have made the land toxic and costly to develop.
In 1989, the Baylands site was purchased by Universal Paragon Corporation (UPC), a real estate design and development firm based in San Francisco. UPC underwent various concept plans for the site before submitting a specific plan in 2006, which was later updated significantly and eventually became the “Developer Sponsored Plan” (DSP). (A specific plan guides zoning rules, subdivisions, public facilities, and future development agreements for a specific geographic area.) In 2009, the city began developing an alternative, the “Community Proposed Plan” (CPP) with input from residents. The key difference between the two plans was that the CPP did not include any housing, while the DSP included 4,434 housing units. The environmental impact report on the DSP was completed in 2015 and the planning commission completed its review the following year, with the proposal going to city council in the fall of 2016.
By 2017, the growing housing crisis in the Bay Area and beyond led local elected officials, legislators, and housing advocates to pressure Brisbane to build housing on the Baylands site. Legislators considered introducing legislation to fast-track development at the site with limited local discretion. The City objected, asking for more time to develop the CPP. The City ultimately developed Measure JJ as an alternative to the DSP. Measure JJ amends the general plan to rezone the Baylands site to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing, of which at least 15% must be affordable. While the general plan amendment did not require voter approval, the City Council opted to place the measure on the November 2018 ballot, where it was approved by a narrow 200-vote margin.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. The author states that in November 2018, the voters in Brisbane made a significant commitment to regional housing when they approved Measure JJ. This bill permits the development of 1,800-2,200 units of housing on the Baylands, more than doubling the City’s housing stock. Passing Measure JJ was a watershed moment for Brisbane and the state. This bill, which reverses early 50 years of votes against development of the Baylands, represents the type of local leadership we need throughout the Bay Area and the state if we are to solve the housing crisis. Given the complexity of the remediation and development process, Brisbane will be working for many years in coordination with the developer, state and regional agencies, and community members to keep the project on track and moving towards the ultimate goal of developing housing that will double the size of the city. This bill creates an environment where Brisbane can focus its efforts on getting this important regional project developed properly. This bill does this by ensuring consistency in Brisbane’s RHNA allocations during this planning cycle and the next, in recognition of the significant commitment already made by the city’s voters. This bill is not a gift; the benefit to Brisbane under this bill is only available if the City continues to steadily move the Baylands development forward under the oversight of HCD.
- Status of the Baylands project. Before housing can be built on the Baylands site, a great deal of remediation will be necessary, which will take a number of years. But first, a new specific plan must be developed for the entire site because the old plan was aligned with the DSP. The revised specific plan must address issues such as securing an adequate water supply, protecting key habitat areas, flood protection and sea-level rise, and providing revenue-positive development for the city. In January 2019, UPC delivered a letter of intent to the Brisbane City Council declaring its intent to revise the specific plan to conform with Measure JJ. The City is also working with Home For All, a local community engagement initiative, to solicit public input. The City Council must approve the final specific plan.
- No guarantees. It is important to note that Measure JJ did not grant approval for any actual housing; rather, it approved a general plan amendment to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing. Before that housing can be developed, UPC must revise the specific plan and get it approved by the City Council. Measure JJ passed by a very narrow margin, and garnered strong opposition; the opposition ballot argument stated that Brisbane would be “crushed by a behemoth of a development” and that “the people who live and work on the Baylands will suffer greater health risk due to the contaminants in the air, soil, and groundwater.” It is possible that these opponents will resurface when it is time for the City Council to approve the specific plan, which could potentially delay the project. To help address these concerns, this bill is conditioned upon the City Council approving the specific plan for the site within 24 months of receiving it from the developer.
- Why can’t Brisbane meet its RHNA obligation elsewhere? The City argues that this bill is needed because it will take a number of years to plan, remediate, and develop the Baylands site. The City could meet its RHNA obligation in the meantime by building housing elsewhere within city limits. The City states, however, that it has limited site to accommodate housing, due at least in part to the fact that the city is nestled against the San Bruno Mountains. In addition, the lack of vacant sites, and ownership patterns of small lots under multiple ownership, make it difficult to find areas available for significant amounts of housing.
Status of Brisbane’s current RHNA obligation. The City’s total obligation for the fifth housing element cycle (2015-2022) is 293 units, for which 56 permits have been issued. Almost all of these permits are for above moderate income; the City has not issued a single permit for very low or low-income housing. The City’s actual obligation for the current cycle is 83 units, but a shortfall of 210 units was carried over from the prior cycle. This bill requires Brisbane to zone for 615% of its RHNA requirement, the equivalent of 1,802 units, in line with the minimum 1,800 units authorized for the Baylands project.
RHNA Obligation | Permits Issued | |
Very low income | 114 | 0 |
Low income | 67 | 0 |
Moderate income | 82 | 8 |
Above moderate | 30 | 48 |
Total | 293 | 56 |
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 235 (Dodd, 2019) allows the City of Napa and the County of Napa to reach an agreement under which the County will be allowed to count certain housing units built within the city toward the County’s RHNA requirement. The bill is pending committee assignment in the Assembly.
SB 695 (Portantino, 2019) allows jurisdictions to count foster youth placements toward their RHNA requirements and allows jurisdictions to deem certain senior or disabled households towards their very low income RHNA requirement. The bill is on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
City of Brisbane (source)
League of California Cities
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/10/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The City of Brisbane states that providing a consistent RHNA allocation to the City during the current and subsequent planning periods will enable it to focus on implementing a voter approved plan that could more than double the housing in the city.
Prepared by: Erin Riches / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
5/14/19 16:22:45
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 672 Hearing Date: 4/22/2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | 4/3/2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Erin Riches | ||
SUBJECT: Planning and zoning: regional housing need allocation: City of Brisbane
DIGEST: This bill prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) from allocating to the City of Brisbane a regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) share that exceeds the city’s allocation for the prior planning period, if specified conditions are met.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires every city and county to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a housing element, to guide the future growth of a community. The housing element must identify and analyze existing and projected housing needs, identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning to meet the housing needs of all income segments of the community, and ensure that regulatory systems provide opportunities for, and do not unduly constrain, housing development.
- Requires local governments located within the territory of a metropolitan planning organization (MPO) to revise their housing elements every eight years, following the adoption of every other regional transportation plan. Local governments in rural non-MPO regions must revise their housing elements every five years.
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing be determined through the regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) process, which is composed of three main stages: (a) the Department of Finance and HCD develop regional housing needs estimates; (b) COGs allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and (c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires COGs to provide specified data assumptions to HCD from each COG’s projections.
- Requires the housing element to contain an assessment of housing needs and an inventory of resources and constraints relevant to meeting those needs.
- Requires a locality’s inventory of land suitable for residential development to be used to identify sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and that are sufficient to provide for the locality’s share of the regional housing need for all income levels.
- Requires, where the inventory of sites does not identify adequate sites to accommodate the need for groups of all household income levels, rezoning of those sites to be completed in a specified time period. Requires this rezoning to accommodate 100% of the need for housing for very low- and low-income households for which site capacity has not been identified in the inventory of sites on sites that shall be zoned to permit rental multifamily residential housing by right during the planning period.
- Prohibits a local jurisdiction from reducing or permitting the reduction of the residential density, or from allowing development at a lower residential density for any parcel, unless the jurisdiction makes specified written findings.
- Requires each jurisdiction to submit an annual progress report (APR) to HCD regarding its progress in meeting its RHNA allocation.
- Authorizes HCD to notify the Attorney General if it at any time finds a jurisdiction out of compliance with its housing element.
This bill:
- Prohibits the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG), in the current and next planning period, from allocating to the City of Brisbane a RHNA share that exceeds Brisbane’s RHNA allocation for the prior planning period, if all of the following apply:
- Brisbane has taken action during the current planning period to zone or rezone sites sufficient to accommodate 350% or more of its RHNA for the current planning period.
- Brisbane maintains or rezones sites sufficient to accommodate 350% or more of its RHNA for the next planning period.
- Brisbane agrees to provide a copy of its APR to ABAG for each year of the current and next planning period.
- Requires Brisbane, in the current and next planning period, to include in its APR information regarding demonstrable progress on meeting the 350% RHNA share.
- Provides that if Brisbane fails to provide information in its APR showing demonstrable progress, as determined by HCD, or fails to comply with the other requirements of this bill, HCD shall immediately determine that Brisbane’s housing element is out of compliance and report it to the Attorney General.
- Provides that this bill does not waive or reduce Brisbane’s obligation to ensure that its housing element inventory accommodates, at all times throughout the housing planning period, its remaining unmet share of its regional housing need.
- Provides that if at any time the site used to comply with this bill is deemed no longer adequate to meet the 350% zoning requirement, the city shall comply with that zoning requirement within 80 days.
- States legislative intent regarding the unique circumstances relating to the RHNA allocation needs in the county.
COMMENTS
- Purpose of the bill. The author states that in November 2018, the voters in Brisbane made a significant commitment to regional housing when they approved Measure JJ. This measure would permit the development of 1,800-2,200 units of housing on the Baylands, more than doubling the city’s housing stock. Passing Measure JJ was a watershed moment for Brisbane and the state. This measure, which reverses early 50 years of votes against development of the Baylands, represents the type of local leadership we need throughout the Bay Area and the state if we are to solve the housing crisis. Given the complexity of the remediation and development process, Brisbane will be working for many years in coordination with the developer, state and regional agencies, and community members to keep the project on track and moving towards the ultimate goal of developing housing that will double the size of the city. This bill creates an environment where Brisbane can focus its efforts on getting this important regional project developed properly. This bill does this by ensuring consistency in Brisbane’s RHNA allocations during this planning cycle and the next, in recognition of the significant commitment already made by the city’s voters. This bill is not a gift; the benefit to Brisbane under this bill is only available if the city continues to steadily move the Baylands development forward under the oversight of HCD.
- Background: the Baylands. The genesis of this bill is a project called the Brisbane Baylands. This roughly 660-acre tract is located just south of San Francisco (between San Francisco International Airport and downtown San Francisco, near Hunters Point/Candlestick). The site location is highly desirable, as it is located close to rapidly developing southeast San Francisco and at the confluence of multiple modes of transportation. However, decades of industrial uses, including a municipal landfill and a railyard, have made the land toxic and costly to develop.
In 1989, the Baylands site was purchased by Universal Paragon Corporation (UPC), a real estate design and development firm based in San Francisco. UPC underwent various concept plans for the site before submitting a specific plan in 2006, which was later updated significantly and eventually became the “Developer Sponsored Plan” (DSP). (A specific plan guides zoning rules, subdivisions, public facilities, and future development agreements for a specific geographic area.) In 2009, the city began developing an alternative, the “Community Proposed Plan” (CPP) with input from residents. The key difference between the two plans was that the CPP did not include any housing, while the DSP included 4,434 housing units. The environmental impact report on the DSP was completed in 2015 and the planning commission completed its review the following year, with the proposal going to city council in the fall of 2016.
By 2017, the growing housing crisis in the Bay Area and beyond led local elected officials, legislators, and housing advocates to pressure Brisbane to build housing on the Baylands site. Legislators considered introducing legislation to fast-track development at the site with limited local discretion. The city objected, asking for more time to develop the CPP. The city ultimately developed Measure JJ as an alternative to the DSP. Measure JJ amends the general plan to rezone the Baylands site to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing, of which at least 15% must be affordable. While the general plan amendment did not require voter approval, the city council opted to place the measure on the November 2018 ballot, where it was approved by a narrow 200-vote margin.
- Status of the Baylands project. Before housing can be built on the Baylands site, a great deal of remediation will be necessary, which will take a number of years. But first, a new specific plan must be developed for the entire site because the old plan was aligned with the DSP. The revised specific plan must address issues such as securing an adequate water supply, protecting key habitat areas, flood protection and sea-level rise, and providing revenue-positive development for the city. In January 2019, UPC delivered a letter of intent to the Brisbane City Council declaring its intent to revise the specific plan to conform with Measure JJ. The city is also working with Home For All, a local community engagement initiative, to solicit public input. The city council must approve the final specific plan.
- No guarantees. It is important to note that Measure JJ did not grant approval for any actual housing; rather, it approved a general plan amendment to allow for up to 2,200 units of housing. Before that housing can be developed, UPC must revise the specific plan and get it approved by the city council. Measure JJ passed by a very narrow margin, and garnered strong opposition; the opposition ballot argument stated that Brisbane would be “crushed by a behemoth of a development” and that “the people who live and work on the Baylands will suffer greater health risk due to the contaminants in the air, soil, and groundwater.” It is possible that these opponents will resurface when it is time for the city council to approve the specific plan, which could potentially delay the project.
- Why can’t Brisbane meet its RHNA obligation elsewhere? The city argues that this bill is needed because it will take a number of years to plan, remediate, and develop the Baylands site. The city could meet its RHNA obligation in the meantime by building housing elsewhere within city limits. The city states, however, that it has limited site to accommodate housing, due at least in part to the fact that the city is nestled against the San Bruno Mountains. In addition, the lack of vacant sites, and ownership patterns of small lots under multiple ownership, make it difficult to find areas available for significant amounts of housing.
- Status of Brisbane’s current RHNA obligation. The city’s total obligation for the fifth housing element cycle (2015-2022) is 293 units, for which 56 permits have been issued. Almost all of these permits are for above moderate income; the city has not issued a single permit for very low or low-income housing. The city’s actual obligation for the current cycle is 83 units, but a shortfall of 210 units was carried over from the prior cycle.
RHNA Obligation | Permits Issued | |
Very low income | 114 | 0 |
Low income | 67 | 0 |
Moderate income | 82 | 8 |
Above moderate | 30 | 48 |
Total | 293 | 56 |
- Committee concerns. California is currently experiencing a serious housing crisis and it is essential to expedite construction of critically needed housing units. In order to make this happen, it is important for every jurisdiction to strive to meet its full RHNA obligation and help provide housing to Californians of all income levels. The committee recognizes, however, that the City of Brisbane faces a unique situation: although it has identified a site that will provide for a large amount of housing, the site will take a number of years to develop.
To address the committee’s concerns, the author and sponsor worked with the committee to craft language, which is included in the April 3, 2019 version of the bill, to limit its scope as follows:
- Include legislative intent and findings to indicate the uniqueness of the Brisbane situation.
- Limit the bill to the current and immediately subsequent housing element cycle (e.g., through 2030).
- Require Brisbane to maintain or rezone sites sufficient to accommodate 350% or more of its RHNA in the subsequent planning period as well as the current planning period (e.g., rather than just freezing it at the current year).
- Require Brisbane to report annually on the status of the Baylands project to both ABAG and HCD.
- Require HCD to report Brisbane to the Attorney General’s office if Brisbane fails to meet the requirements of this bill or to provide evidence of demonstrable progress on the project.
- Committee amendments. Brisbane’s current RHNA allocation is 293 units; Measure JJ amends the general plan to allow for 1,800 to 2,200 units. This bill currently requires Brisbane to zone for 350% of its RHNA allocation, which is the equivalent of a little over 1,000 units. The author will accept amendments to increase the requirement to 615%, the equivalent of 1,802 units, in line with the minimum 1,800 units authorized for the Baylands project. In order to help ensure the project keeps moving forward on a timely basis, the committee may also wish to consider amending this bill to condition it upon the city council approving the specific plan for the site within 24 months of receiving it from the developer.
Related Legislation:
SB 235 (Dodd, 2019) — allows the City of Napa and the County of Napa to reach an agreement under which the county would be allowed to count certain housing units built within the city toward the county’s (RHNA) requirement. This bill will be heard in the Senate Appropriations Committee on April 22nd.
SB 695 (Portantino, 2019) — allows jurisdictions to count foster youth placements toward their RHNA requirements and allows jurisdictions to deem certain senior or disabled households towards their very low income RHNA requirement. This bill will be heard in the Human Services Committee on April 22nd.
AB 738 (Mullin, 2019) — allows San Mateo County or a city within its jurisdiction to count housing units it has funded in another city within San Mateo County, toward its own RHNA requirement. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Housing Committee.
AB 1239 (Cunningham, 2019) — reduces a jurisdiction’s RHNA obligation by 25% if it has enacted an ADU ordinance. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Housing Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
April 17, 2019.)
SUPPORT:
Brisbane; City of (Sponsor)
OPPOSITION:
None received.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):