SB 688: Failure to pay wages: penalties.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-10
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 723, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 10, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 14. Noes 4.) (August 14). |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 26). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| May 21, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 6.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 14, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (April 23). |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 3. Noes 1.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 3, 2019 | SB 688 Monning Senate Third Reading By Kalra | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
|
| May 20, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB688 Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 688
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands the Labor Commissioner's (LC) citation authority for an employer's failure to pay minimum wages to include an employer's failure to pay contract wages, as defined.
Major Provisions
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner (LC), after inspection or investigation, to issue a citation to an employer who pays an employee less than contract wages, as defined.
- Defines "contract wages" as wages based upon an agreement, in excess of the applicable minimum wage, for regular, non-overtime hours.
- Provides that any bond which is forfeited because an employer fails to pay the amounts owed after a writ proceeding challenging a citation issued by the LC must be forfeited to the LC for appropriate distribution.
COMMENTS:
Wage theft is the illegal practice of paying workers less than they are entitled under the law. Wage theft affects employees and their families as well as other employers who properly pay their employees what they are owed. For years, California lacked an effective enforcement mechanism to combat the practice until it passed laws gradually giving the LC authority to address wage theft. In 2011, California increased penalties, bonding, and notice requirements to strengthen disincentives to violate wage law. In 2015, the LC was authorized to issue citations for violations of local minimum wage laws. In 2017, the LC was authorized to issue citations for workplace retaliation and to seek injunctive relief in instances in which the LC has reasonable cause to believe that workplace retaliation took place. This bill would give the LC an additional tool to combat wage theft.
According to the Author:
"Historically, the Labor Commissioner's authority to issue citations was limited to citations for civil penalties payable to the State for violations of certain minimum labor standards, including the failure to pay minimum wages. The Labor Commissioner's authority to issue citations for unpaid wages was given incrementally, and the Legislature presumably viewed the enforcement of minimum wages and overtime as more pressing issues. As the Labor Commissioner['s] use [of] citations as a means of prosecuting wage claims picked up during the period from 2012 to the present, the agency became increasingly aware of the inadequacy of the citation process as a means of recovering contract wages (that is, wages above the minimum wage). The fact that [the] Labor Commissioner lacks statutory authority to issue citations to recover contract wages is proving to be a significant gap in our ability to secure wages owed to – and desperately needed by – California's low and middle-income workers. This problem, undoubtedly wholly unanticipated by the Legislature, can only be fixed by providing the Labor Commissioner with statutory authority to cite for unpaid contract wages."
Arguments in Support:
The California Labor Federation, in support, argues that "SB 688 (Monning) will provide the Labor Commissioner with the authority to ensure workers are paid their appropriate contractual wages, in a timely [manner] by permitting unpaid contract wages to be collected through the issuance of citations."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable cost.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 32-6-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 7-0-0
YES: Kalra, Flora, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-1-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Kiley
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-4-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 25, 2019
CONSULTANT: Justin Delacruz / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0001340
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 688
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Judiciary | 9 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the Labor Commissioner’s (LC’s) citation authority to include an employer’s failure to pay contract wages, which are wages based upon an agreement for regular, non-overtime hours.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Under existing law, the LC may investigate wage theft claims and, if a violation has occurred, order the employer to pay the amounts owed. If the LC finds that an employer has failed to pay the legal minimum wage, the LC may issue a direct citation in order to recover any wages, penalty or damages owed.
- Contract wages. Contract wages are the agreed-upon wages in excess of the minimum wage for regular, non-overtime hours. Currently, the LC lacks the authority to directly cite an employer for an employer’s failure to pay contract wages and must seek resolution through civil action filed in superior court.
- Purpose. According to supporters, SB 688 will close a gap in the LC’s statutory authority to secure wages owed to workers.
- Administrative efficiencies. SB 688 will allow the LC to address contract wage claims at little additional cost. While there may be additional workload associated with this bill, this workload will be absorbable within existing resources. Moreover, this bill may generate administrative efficiencies by further allowing the LC to address multiple types of citations (such as for overtime or for failure to pay contract wages) in a single administrative hearing.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 688
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 32-6
SUBJECT: Failure to pay wages: penalties
KEY ISSUES:
- Should the Labor Commissioner’s existing power to issue a citation against an employer who fails to pay the minimum wage be extended to authorize citations for failure to pay the amount of wages promised under contract?
- Should the bond required when an employer seeks a writ of mandate to challenge the Labor Commissioner’s decision be forfeited, if forfeiture is appropriate, and transferred to the Labor Commissioner for distribution to the employee?
SYNOPSIS
SB 688 will enhance the power of the Labor Commissioner (Commissioner) to combat “wage theft,” a term that encompasses an employer’s failure to pay the minimum wage, overtime, or the promised or contracted wage. Existing law authorizes the Commissioner to investigate wage theft claims and, if a violation has occurred, order the employer to pay the amounts owed. If the Commissioner finds that an employer failed to pay the legal minimum wage, it may issue a citation directly to the employer in order to recover any penalty, wages, or damages owed. However, existing law does not similarly authorize the Commissioner to issue a citation against an employer who fails to pay the promised or contracted wage. Therefore, the Commissioner can only enforce an order to pay the contracted wage by bringing an action in superior court. SB 688 simply extends the Commissioner’s authority to issue a citation to include an order against an employer who fails to pay contracted wages, thereby shortening the time that it takes for the employee to recover stolen wages.
In addition, existing law allows an employer to contest a final decision of the Commissioner by seeking a writ of mandate, so long as the employer first posts a bond equal to the amount of wages or damages required under the Commissioner’s order. If the employer is found by the court to owe the amount determined by the Commissioner, and then fails to pay it, a portion of the bond equal to the amount that is owed is forfeited to the employee. This bill, however, would have the bond proceeds forfeited to the Commissioner for distribution to the employee, rather than directly to the employee(s). This change, as discussed in the analysis, will make for more orderly distributions where there are multiple employees or where the location of employees is uncertain.
The bill is supported by the California Labor Federation, the California Employment Lawyers, and the State Building and Construction Trades Council. The most recent amendments removed all opposition, for the reasons described in the analysis.
SUMMARY: Gives the Labor Commissioner the authority to issue a citation against an employer who fails to pay a contracted wage and, in the event of an appeal of the Commissioner’s decision, alters the manner in which bond proceeds are distributed. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that if the Labor Commissioner (Commissioner) determines that an employer has paid an employee less than the wage set by contract, the Commissioner may issue a citation to the employer in order to recover restitution of the amounts owed, in the same manner that the Commissioner may, under existing law, issue a citation to an employer who pays less than the legal minimum wage.
- Provides that when an employer contests a citation by writ of mandate, and then fails to pay wages or damages owed within 10 days of any final judgment or settlement, a portion of the bond posted as a precondition of seeking a writ of mandate shall be forfeited to the Commissioner for appropriate distribution.
- Defines “contract wages” for purpose of the above provisions to mean wages based upon an agreement, in excess of the applicable minimum wage, for regular, non-overtime hours.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Commissioner to investigate employee complaints and provide for a hearing in any action to recover wages, penalties, and other demands for compensation, including liquidated damages if the complaint alleges payment of a wage less than the minimum wage fixed by an order of the Industrial Welfare Commission or by statute. (Labor Code Section 98.)
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner to place a lien on an employer’s real property for amounts due under the final order and in favor of the employee or employees named in the order. Specifies that the lien shall be filed with the county recorder of any county in which the employer’s real property is located. (Labor Code Section 98.2 (g).)
- Makes an employer who pays any employee a wage less than the legally applicable minimum wage or industrial wage order subject to a civil penalty, restitution of wages, liquidated damages payable to the employee, and any applicable penalties imposed, as specified. (Labor Code Section 1197.1 (a).)
- Provides that if the Commissioner finds after an inspection or investigation that a person has paid less than the applicable minimum wage, the Commissioner may issue and serve a written citation upon that person, as specified; and requires the Commissioner to take all appropriate actions to enforce the citation and recover any civil penalties, unpaid wages, or any other appropriate penalties or damages. (Labor Code Section 1197.1 (b).)
- Requires a person who contests a citation to file a request for an appeal and an informal hearing with the Commissioner within 15 days after service of the citation, and requires the Commissioner, or the Commissioner’s agent, to hold a hearing within 30 days and to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation or penalties at the conclusion of the hearing; and requires the Commissioner to issue and serve the decision within 15 days after the hearing. (Labor Code Section 1197.1 (c).)
- Allows a person to challenge the Labor Commissioner’s decision by filing a petition for a writ of mandate in superior court within 45 days of service of the decision, provided that the person first files a bond with the Labor Commissioner equal to the total amount of any minimum wages, liquidated damages, and overtime compensation due, as specified in the Commissioner’s decision. (Labor Code Section 1197.1 (c)(2)-(3).)
- Provides that if an employer fails to pay the amount of minimum wages, liquidated damages, or overtime compensation owed within 10 days of the entry of judgment, dismissal or withdrawal of writ, or the execution of a settlement agreement, an appropriate portion of the bond required in 6), above, shall be forfeited to the employee. (Labor Code Section 1197.1 (c)(4).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: “Wage theft” takes many forms. It occurs when an employer fails to pay an employee for all hours worked, pays less than the legal minimum wage, fails to provide overtime pay, requires workers to perform “off-the-clock” work, or fails to provide required meal and rest breaks. California law allows workers to file wage theft claims with the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement (DLSE), and requires the California Labor Commissioner (Commissioner) to investigate the claim and, if appropriate, order the employer to pay the wages that are owed. Unfortunately, workers have had less success in actually recovering on orders and judgments made in their favor. A 2013 report by the UCLA Labor Center and the National Employment Law Project (NELP), aptly titled “Hollow Victories,” concluded that workers victimized by wage theft “face serious challenges in recovering their hard-earned wages – even after state authorities have found in the workers’ favor and have issued a legally binding judgment ordering the employers to pay.” Based on a review of wage complaints filed with DLSE between 2008 and 2011, the report found that about 31% of claims filed were settled after a formal or informal hearing process, about 30% are dismissed, and about 39% resulted in a decision in favor of the employee, with an order to the employer to provide restitution to the employee and pay civil penalties. However, of this final group of claims that resulted in a decision in the employee’s favor, the report concluded that only 17% of employees recovered the wages owed to them. The report cited a number of likely reasons for these abysmal, even shocking, recovery rates. Most prominent, however, was the finding that offending employers hid assets, dissolved, disappeared, declared bankruptcy, or otherwise made themselves judgment proof. In addition, the report noted that DLSE collection units lack sufficient resources. (Elaine Ho, Tia Koonse, and Anthony Mischel, Hollow Victories: The Crisis in Collecting Unpaid Wages for California Workers, UCLA Labor Center and NELP, 2013.)
While this bill cannot completely address the larger problems that prevent workers from recovering stolen wages from dissolved or recalcitrant employers – even when they have already won a judgment in their favor – it will nonetheless allow many workers to recover wages in a more timely manner by allowing the Labor Commissioner to issue and serve a citation directly upon the employer, instead of requiring the more time-consuming step of filing a civil action in superior court.
Past Legislative Efforts to Enhance Enforcement: The 2013 report by the UCLA Labor Center and NELP mirrored the findings of other regional and national studies dating to 2008. Of course workers and the organizations that represent them did not need studies to tell them what they were experiencing first hand, and what they had pressed the Legislature to take action on even before the troubling 2013 report. For example, AB 469 (Chap. 655, Stats. 2011) enhanced civil penalties for wage theft and made it a misdemeanor for an employer to willfully fail to pay a final court judgment or administrative order. While the Commissioner has possessed the power to issue citations for state minimum wage and overtime violations since 1983, AB 970 (Chap. 783, Stats. 2015) authorized the Commissioner to issue citations for violations of local wage laws, as well. This bill builds upon this existing framework by authorizing the Commissioner to issue citations when the employer pays the legal minimum wage, but fails to pay the promised or contracted wage.
With mixed success, the Legislature has in the past attempted to impose liens on the property of employers who engage in wage theft. For example, SB 588 (Chap. 803, Stats. 2015) allows the Commissioner to file a lien or levy on an employer’s property when there is a judgment against the employer. Like the bond requirement discussed above, a lien helps ensure that, once there is a final judgment or order, there will still be sufficient assets to effectuate the judgment or order. While SB 588 allows the Commissioner to file a lien, the 2013 report by the UCLA Law Center and NELP recommended legislation that would allow an employee who files a wage claim to simultaneously file a lien against the employer’s property. Citing the results of a Wisconsin law that did just that, the report concluded that workers’ liens would be the most effective way to make sure that workers see the wages to which they are clearly entitled. (Ho, et.al., supra, pp. 16-19.) Heeding this advice, AB 1164 (Lowenthal, 2013) and AB 2416 (Stone, 2014) attempted, unsuccessfully, to allow an employee to file a lien on the employer’s property, similar to the “mechanic’s lien” that is available to construction workers. Neither bill reached the Governor’s desk. In short, while the bill under consideration provides the Commissioner with an important tool, there is still more that could be done to make sure that workers can actually collect on favorable orders and judgments.
Distribution of Bond Proceeds: In addition to enhancing the Commissioner’s citation authority, this bill also makes a change to the manner in which, in contested cases, bond proceeds reach the victim of wage theft. Existing law allows an employer to contest a final decision of the Commissioner by seeking a writ of mandate, so long as the employer first posts a bond equal to the amount of wages or damages specified in the Commissioner’s order. If the employer is ultimately found by the court to owe that amount, and then fails to pay it, a portion of the bond equal to the amount of wages owed is forfeited to the employee. This bill, however, will have the bond proceeds forfeited to the Commissioner for distribution to the employee or employees. According to the author’s office, this change – which was apparently suggested by the Department of Industrial Relations – will make for more orderly distributions of awards, especially when there are multiple employees or the location of employees is uncertain. In effect, the change makes the Commissioner, instead of a surety bond company, responsible for the appropriate distribution of money to the employee. This change is consistent with other provisions of existing law. Most notably, as set forth in Labor Code section 96.7, the Commissioner acts as a trustee for all unpaid wages, and is required to diligently locate any worker who is owed wages. Wages for workers who cannot be located are deposited into the Industrial Relations Unpaid Wage Fund. The Commissioner, it would seem, is better positioned to fulfill these duties than is the surety bond company.
Recent Amendments on Potential Personal Liability Remove Opposition: Until the most recent amendments, SB 688 authorized the Commissioner to issue a citation to any person “who pays or causes to be paid a rate of compensation that is less than set by contract.” The Chamber of Commerce, and the several business and trade associations that signed its opposition letter, feared that this language would not only expose the employer, but also officers, managers, human resources personnel, and other employees, to personal liability. The author amended the bill to remove the questionable clause in a prior committee, and this appears to have removed all opposition to the bill.
Arguments in Support: According to the California Labor Federation (CLF), “wage theft” is a significant problem in California, one that “cuts across many industries, from the underground economy to the warehouses storing goods for the world’s largest corporations.” Beyond the obvious harm to workers, CLF points out that wage theft also “creates an unfair playing field for responsible employers who cannot compete with businesses that cheat workers.” CLF points out that the Labor Commissioner may currently “assess unpaid minimum wages and overtime wages through a citation issued against the employer and other responsible individuals. These citations may be prosecuted together in a single administrative hearing if the citations are appealed. Contract wages, however, may be sought by the Labor Commissioner only through a civil action filed in superior court.” CLF believes that SB 688, by giving the Commissioner the authority to cite a failure to pay contracted wages “will provide the Labor Commissioner with the authority to ensure workers are paid the appropriate contractual wages, in a timely manner by permitting unpaid contact wages to be collected through the issuance of citations.”
The California Employment Lawyers Association (CELA), supports SB 688 because, while existing law allows the Labor Commissioner to cite violations of the minimum wage law, it does not allow the Commissioner “to assess and prosecute [failure to pay] contract wages. Thus, the Labor Commissioner is presently unable to prosecute companion contract wage violations in the same administrative proceeding in which minimum wages and overtime pay are [also] prosecuted.” In most cases, CELA contends, “the Labor Commissioner is unable to commit sources to address the contract violations in a separate court proceeding and the violations are not rectified.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 688
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 32-6
SUBJECT: Failure to pay wages: penalties
SUMMARY: Expands the Labor Commissioner’s (LC) citation authority for an employer’s failure to pay minimum wages to include an employer’s failure to pay contract wages, as defined. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner (LC), after inspection or investigation, to issue a citation to an employer who pays an employee less than contract wages, as defined.
- Defines “contract wages” as wages based upon an agreement, in excess of the applicable minimum wage, for regular, non-overtime hours.
- Provides that any bond which is forfeited because an employer fails to pay the amounts owed after a writ proceeding challenging a citation issued by the LC must be forfeited to the LC for appropriate distribution.
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a civil penalty, restitution of wages, liquidated damages and other penalties, as specified, on an employer who pays an employee less than minimum wage.
- Permits the LC, after inspection or investigation, to issue a citation to an employer who has paid an employee less than minimum wage.
- Authorizes a person against whom a citation has been issued to contest the citation or proposed assessment of penalties by notifying the LC, within 15 business days after service of the citation, and requesting an informal hearing.
- Requires the LC to hold an informal hearing within 30 days of such a request and, at the end of the hearing, determine whether the penalties will be affirmed, modified, or dismissed.
- Provides that the decision of the LC must consist of a notice of findings, findings, and an order, which shall be served on all parties to the hearing within 15 days after the hearing.
- Authorizes a person seeking to challenge the decision to file a petition for writ of mandate with the appropriate superior court within 45 days of service of the notice of findings, findings, and order.
- Requires a petitioner seeking a writ of mandate to first post a bond with the LC equal to the total amount specified in the citation.
- Provides that if an employer fails to pay the amounts owed within ten days of the entry of judgment, dismissal or withdrawal of the writ, or the execution of a settlement agreement, a portion of the bond equal to the amount owed, or the entire bond if the amount owed exceeds the amount of the bond, shall be forfeited to the employee.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS: Note: This bill is double-referred to Assembly Judiciary Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
Wage theft is the illegal practice of paying workers less than they are entitled under the law. Wage theft affects employees and their families as well as other employers who properly pay their employees what they are owed. For years, California lacked an effective enforcement mechanism to combat the practice until it passed laws gradually giving the LC authority to address wage theft. In 2011, California increased penalties, bonding, and notice requirements to strengthen disincentives to violate wage law. In 2015, the LC was authorized to issue citations for violations of local minimum wage laws. In 2017, the LC was authorized to issue citations for workplace retaliation and to seek injunctive relief in instances in which the LC has reasonable cause to believe that workplace retaliation took place. This bill would give the LC an additional tool to combat wage theft.
According to the author, “[h]istorically, the Labor Commissioner’s authority to issue citations was limited to citations for civil penalties payable to the State for violations of certain minimum labor standards, including the failure to pay minimum wages. The Labor Commissioner’s authority to issue citations for unpaid wages was given incrementally, and the Legislature presumably viewed the enforcement of minimum wages and overtime as more pressing issues. As the Labor Commissioner[’s] use [of] citations as a means of prosecuting wage claims picked up during the period from 2012 to the present, the agency became increasingly aware of the inadequacy of the citation process as a means of recovering contract wages (that is, wages above the minimum wage). The fact that [the] Labor Commissioner lacks statutory authority to issue citations to recover contract wages is proving to be a significant gap in our ability to secure wages owed to – and desperately needed by – California’s low and middle-income workers. This problem, undoubtedly wholly unanticipated by the Legislature, can only be fixed by providing the Labor Commissioner with statutory authority to cite for unpaid contract wages.”
The California Labor Federation, in support, argues that “SB 688 (Monning) will provide the Labor Commissioner with the authority to ensure workers are paid their appropriate contractual wages, in a timely [manner] by permitting unpaid contract wages to be collected through the issuance of citations.”
Prior and Related Legislation
SB 306 (Hertzberg) Chapter 460, Statutes of 2017 authorized the LC to issue citations for workplace retaliation and to seek injunctive relief where the LC has reasonable cause to believe that workplace retaliation has taken place.
AB 970 (Nazarian) Chapter 783, Statutes of 2015 authorized the LC to issue citations for violations of local minimum wage laws.
AB 469 (Swanson) Chapter 655, Statutes of 2011 increased penalties, bonding, and notice requirements to strengthen disincentives to violate wage laws.
AB 1359 (Margohn) Chapter 1145, Statutes of 1983 empowered the LC to issue citations for minimum wage violations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
State Building And Construction Trades Council of CA
Other (Opposition Removed-No Position on Bill)
California Association Of Winegrape Growers
California Beer And Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Construction And Industrial Materials Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Framing Contractors Association
California Hospital Association
California League Of Food Producers
California Pool & Spa Association
California Professional Association Of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
National Federation Of Independent Business
Official Police Garages Of Los Angeles
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Justin Delacruz / L. & E. /
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 688 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 688
Amended: 4/25/19
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 3-1, 4/10/19
AYES: Hill, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jackson
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-1, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Failure to pay wages: penalties
DIGEST:
This bill expends existing provisions for failure to pay minimum wages to wages or compensation that is due under a contract. Specifically, this bill authorizes the Labor Commissioner to issue a citation to an employer to recover restitution of amounts owed, if, upon inspection or investigation, it is determined that the employer has paid or caused to be paid a wage less than the wage set by contract in excess of the applicable minimum wage.
Existing law:
- Establishes within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), the Division of Fair Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) tasked with administering and enforcing labor code provisions concerning wages, hours and working conditions. (Labor Code §56)
- Prohibits an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another, who pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the minimum wage fixed by an applicable state or local law shall be subject to a civil penalty, restitution of wages, liquidated damages payable to the employee, and any applicable penalties imposed, as specified. (Labor Code §1197.1)
- Provides that if the Labor Commissioner, who is Chief of the DLSE, determines that a person has paid or caused to be paid a wage less than the minimum under applicable law, the Labor Commissioner may issue a citation to the person in violation, as specified. Each citation must be in writing and must describe the nature of the violation, including reference to the statutory provision alleged to have been violated. (Labor Code §1197.1)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner (LC) to promptly take all appropriate action to enforce the citation and to recover the civil penalty assessed, wages, liquidated damages, and any applicable penalties imposed in connection with the citation.
- Authorizes a person who desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessments to notify the LC within 15 days after service of the citation of the request for an appeal and an informal hearing. The LC or his or her deputy or agent must then hold a hearing within 30 days at which point the citation or proposed penalties, wages or damages must be affirmed, modified, or dismissed. [Labor Code §1197.1(c)]
- Authorizes an individual cited to file a petition for a writ of mandate. As a condition to filing this petition, the petitioner seeking the writ must first post a bond with the LC equal to the total amount of any minimum wages, liquidated damages, and overtime compensation that are due and owing as specified in the citation being challenged.
- Provides that if the employer fails to pay the amount of minimum wages, liquidated damages, or overtime compensation owed within 10 days of the entry of judgment, dismissal or withdrawal of writ, or the execution of a settlement agreement, a portion of the undertaking, equal to the amount owed, or the entire undertaking if the amount owed exceeds the undertaking, shall be forfeited to the employee. [Labor Code §1197.1(c)(4)]
This bill:
- Extends existing provisions for failure to pay minimum wages to wages or compensation, in excess of the minimum wage, that is due under a contract.
- Authorizes the LC to issue a citation to an employer to recover restitution of amounts owed, if, upon inspection or investigation, it is determined that the employer has paid or caused to be paid a wage less than the wage set by contract in excess of the applicable minimum wage.
- Defines “contract wages” as wages based upon an agreement, in excess of the applicable minimum wage, for regular, nonovertime hours.
- Specifies that, should the employer fail to pay the amounts owed, the bond required for an appeal through a writ of mandate must be forfeited to the LC for appropriate distribution.
- Makes several changes to existing provisions replacing “his or her” with gender-neutral pronouns per ACR 260 (Low, Resolution Chapter 190, Statutes of 2018) which directed a coordinated effort to revise existing statutes with inclusive language.
Background
In 2011, in response to widespread wage theft in California, AB 469 (Swanson, Chapter 655, Statues of 2011) was enacted to propose a number of changes aimed at preventing or combating the intentional theft of earned wages by unscrupulous employers. Among other things, the bill (1) provided that in addition to being subject to a civil penalty, any employer who pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the minimum fixed shall be subject to paying restitution of wages to the employee; (2) made it a misdemeanor if an employer willfully violates specified wage statutes or orders, or willfully fails to pay a final court judgment or final order of the Labor commission for wages due; (3) and extended the period within which the division may commence a collection action, as defined, from one year to three years.
According to the author and sponsors of AB 469, the bill was necessary because enforcement of labor laws related to wage violations was weak and largely ineffective. As noted in the Senate Labor Committee policy analysis for that bill, “In 2009, only 216 employers in the entire state of California were cited by the DLSE violating minimum wage and overtime laws. DLSE assessed $650,550 in penalties for these violations but collected only $230,154. During that same year, DLSE found $22,381,286 in wages due, but recovered only $13,062,164. When these results are put in the context of the billions of dollars stolen in the underground economy, it is clear they are too feeble to constitute a meaningful deterrent.”
Need for this bill?
According to the author:
“As the Labor Commissioner uses citations as a means of prosecuting wage claims picked up during the period from 2012 to the present, the agency became increasingly aware of the inadequacy of the citation process as a means of recovering contract wages (that is, wages above the minimum wage). The fact that Labor Commissioner lacks statutory authority to issue citations to recover contract wages is proving to be a significant gap in our ability to secure wages owed to – and desperately needed by – California’s low and middle-income workers. This problem, undoubtedly wholly unanticipated by the Legislature, can only be fixed by providing the Labor Commissioner with statutory authority to cite for unpaid contract wages. Regarding the number of cases that may be impacted, the Division estimates that there would be about 400 Bureau of Field Enforcement (BOFE) cases a year where the Division would cite for contract wage violations (about 20% of all BOFE citations).”
This bill addresses this deficiency in law by extending existing enforcement provisions for failure to pay wages or compensation that is due under a contract. Additionally, the bill specifies that the bond required for an appeal through a writ of mandate (upon failure to pay amounts owed) must be forfeited to the LC for appropriate distribution. The reason for this revision is that these cases often involve multiple affected employees and this technical adjustment effectively makes the LC responsible for the appropriate distribution of wages instead of the court. As set forth in Labor Code section 96.7, the LC acts as a trustee for all unpaid wages, and is required to diligently locate any worker who is owed wages.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
State Building and Construction Trades Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/14/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to proponents, currently, the Labor Commissioner may assess unpaid minimum and overtime wages through a citation issued against an employer and other responsible individuals. Proponents argue that violations of the minimum wage and overtime pay requirements are often accompanied by nonpayment of contract wages. However, the Labor Commissioner does not have the authority to assess and prosecute contract wages and is unable to prosecute companion contract wage violations in the same administrative proceeding as minimum wage and overtime violations. They note that contract wages may be sought by the Labor Commissioner only through a civil action filed in superior court. This bill will provide the Labor Commissioner with the authority to ensure workers are paid their appropriate contractual wages, in a timely matter by permitting unpaid contract wages to be collected through the issuance of citations.
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
5/15/19 15:10:40
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 688 (Author:Monning)
Version: March 27, 2019
Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Failure to pay wages: penalties
DIGEST
This bill would empower the California Labor Commissioner to cite employers and other persons for failure to pay workers the promised rate of pay. Existing law limits that citation power to situations involving failure to pay the minimum wage.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Wage theft is a common occurrence in California’s economy. Research suggests that the average year-round worker earns a little over $3,000 each year that they never receive. This dynamic unjustly enriches unscrupulous employers, deprives low-income workers of the full benefit of their labor, and skews the marketplace against honest, law-abiding businesses. One of the California Labor Commissioner’s primary responsibilities is to detect and rectify incidents of wage theft. Under current law, however, the Labor Commissioner’s powers are significantly limited. If employers pay workers less than the minimum wage (including paying them nothing at all), the Labor Commissioner has the authority to issue a citation to the employer. So long as the employer pays at least minimum wage, however, the Labor Commissioner is powerless to issue citations, even when an employer steals wages by paying workers at a lower rate than what was promised to them. This bill would extend the Labor Commissioner’s citation powers to include situations in which an employer pays minimum wage, but not the contract rate. Separately, the bill would direct courts to distribute judgments for unpaid wages to the Labor Commissioner for distribution to the aggrieved workers.
The bill is author-sponsored. Support is from low-income worker advocates. Opposition is from employers and business associations, who assert that it is unnecessary and will add to what they characterize as an already intolerable level of potential litigation. This bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee on a vote of 3-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Establishes within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) tasked with administering and enforcing labor code provisions concerning wages, hours, and working conditions. (Lab. Code § 56)
- Provides that an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another, who pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the minimum wage fixed by an applicable state law, local law, or industrial wage order, shall be subject to a civil penalty, restitution of wages, liquidated damages payable to the employee, and any applicable penalties imposed, as specified. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(a).)
- Provides that if the Labor Commissioner, who is Chief of the DLSE, finds upon inspection or investigation that a person has paid less than the applicable minimum wage, the Labor Commissioner may issue and serve a written citation upon that person, describing the nature of the violation, including reference to the statutory provision alleged to have been violated. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(b).)
- Directs the Labor Commissioner to promptly take all appropriate action to enforce the citation and to recover the civil penalty assessed, wages, liquidated damages, and any applicable penalties imposed in connection with the citation. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(b).)
- Requires a person who desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessments to file a request for an appeal and an informal hearing with the Labor Commissioner within 15 days after service of the citation. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(c).)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner or the Labor Commissioner’s deputy or agent to hold the appeal hearing within 30 days and to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation or proposed penalties, wages, or damages at the conclusion of the hearing. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(c).)
- Directs the Labor Commissioner to issue and serve a decision within 15 days after the hearing. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(c).)
- Allows a person to challenge the Labor Commissioner’s decision by filing a petition for a writ of mandate in the appropriate superior court within 45 days of service of the decision, provided that the person first files a bond with the Labor Commissioner equal to the total amount of any minimum wages, liquidated damages, and overtime compensation that are due and owing as specified in the Labor Commissioner’s decision. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(c)(2 and 3).)
- Provides that if the person ultimately becomes responsible to pay because the court enters judgment against the person, the person withdraws or dismisses the writ petition, or a settlement is reached, and the person fails to pay the amount owing within 10 days, a portion of the bond, equal to the amount owed, or the entire bond if the amount owed exceeds the undertaking, shall be forfeited to the employee. (Lab. Code § 1197.1(c)(4).)
This bill:
- Provides that the Labor Commissioner may issue citations for unpaid contract wages.
- Specifies that if a person has posted a bond with the Labor Commissioner in fulfillment of the precondition for filing a writ of mandate, and the person then fails to pay the amount of minimum wages, contract wages, liquidated damages, or overtime wages owed within 10 days of entry of judgment against the person, dismissal or withdrawal of the writ, or the execution of a settlement agreement, a portion of the bond equal to the amount owed shall be forfeited to the Labor Commissioner – instead of the employee – for appropriate distribution.
- Makes other technical, non-substantive changes.
COMMENTS
- The problem of wage theft
The phrase “wage theft” refers to what happens when employers pay their workers less than they are entitled to by law or contract, thus depriving the workers of their earnings, unjustly enriching the employer, and giving unscrupulous employers a competitive advantage over their honest counterparts, all at the same time.
Unfortunately, wage theft is common. According to a 2017 Economic Policy Institute report on the subject, workers in the 10 most populous states in the country lost a combined $8 billion annually, or an average of $3,300 per year for year-round workers, for minimum wage violations alone.[1] Wage theft is not just an underground economy matter, either. A recent study by researchers at Good Jobs First found 2,167 wage and hour cases with total penalties of $6.8 billion involving Fortune 500 companies or Fortune Global 500 companies.[2] Wage theft also represents a civil rights issue, since it affects women and people of color at disproportionately high rates.[3]
California law seeks to address wage theft in a number of ways. One of them is Labor Code Section 1197.1. This statute empowers California’s Labor Commissioner to issue citations to employers when, after inspection or investigation, the Labor Commissioner determines that someone has failed to pay their workers the applicable minimum wage. In its current form, however, Labor Code Section 1197.1 does not permit the Labor Commissioner to issue citations for failure to pay any wages earned beyond the minimum wages. To obtain unpaid wages above the minimum wage, the worker or Labor Commissioner would have to utilize other remedies, such as filing a lawsuit in civil court.
Thus, for example, if an employer promises to pay a worker 25 dollars ($25) an hour, but actually only pays the worker minimum wage, the Labor Commissioner’s citation authority is powerless to address the situation. Similarly, in an instance in which the employer promises to pay a worker 25 dollars ($25) an hour, but then absconds without paying the worker a single penny, the Labor Commission’s citation powers will be limited to recovering only that fraction of the money owed which corresponds to the applicable minimum wage. In either scenario, the worker is not made whole, perhaps not even close.
By empowering the Labor Commissioner to issue citations for the contract rate of wages, this bill would enable the Labor Commissioner to seek all of the wages owed to a worker through citation.
2. Personal liability under Labor Code Section 1197.1
Most provisions of the California Labor Code apply to employers only. The Labor Commissioner’s power to issue citations for minimum wage violations extends further, by contrast. Specifically, Labor Code Section 1197.1 applies to “[a]ny employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another person” who fails to pay at least minimum wage. (Emphasis added.) Thus, in addition to the employer itself, managers, supervisors, human resources directors, and any other individual who is responsible for causing a worker to get paid less than minimum wage could theoretically be issued a citation by the Labor Commissioner. Through the Private Attorney General’s Act, a worker could also seek such to recover unpaid wages and any associated penalties by stepping into the shoes of the Labor Commissioner.
Seizing on this aspect of Labor Code Section 1197.1, the Chamber of Commerce and its fellow opponents to the bill argue that expanding the Labor Commissioner’s citation power to include failure to pay contractually promised pay rates will further expose managers, supervisors, and human resources directors to personal liability.
Since Labor Code Section 1197.1 already allows the Labor Commissioner to hold individual managers, supervisors, and human resources directors accountable when they are the ones responsible for causing an employee to be paid less than minimum wage, however, the policy argument is not about whether these individuals should be held subject to personal liability at all. Instead, the Chamber and its fellow opponents assert that there is something qualitatively different about enforcing minimum wage rates as opposed to contractually-promised wage rates. The former are easy to track, the opponents contend, whereas contract rates can vary between employees. The implication, presumably, is that mistaken underpayments are more likely in the case of contractual wages than with minimum wage. The Chamber raises, for example, the specter of a one penny error leading to an avalanche of personal liability if SB 688 is passed.
In response to these concerns, the author proposes to offer an amendment in Committee that would eliminate the possibility of any personal liability accruing from the failure to pay contract wages over and above the minimum wage.
3. Distribution of unpaid wages
In addition to expanding the Labor Commissioner’s citation powers to include failure to pay contractually promised wage rates, this bill also alters a minor aspect of how unpaid wages get distributed to workers once they are recovered. Under existing law, a person who wishes to contest a Labor Commissioner’s decision regarding a citation can do so by filing a petition for a writ of mandate in the appropriate superior court. However, as a precondition for doing so, the person has to post a bond with the Labor Commissioner in the amount of all the wages, penalties, and liquidated damages owed according to the Labor Commissioner. In the event that the person ends up owing money because the court enters judgment against the person, the person withdraws or dismisses the writ petition, or a settlement agreement is executed, the person has 10 days to pay that amount. If the person does not, then existing law states that the proceeds of the bond shall be distributed to the worker to the degree necessary to satisfy the debt.
This bill would instead have the proceeds of the bond given to the Labor Commissioner for appropriate distribution. According to the author, this change is needed to facilitate orderly distribution of the funds.
4. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill that would:
- eliminate the possibility of personal liability for non-payment of contractual wages above and beyond the minimum wage;
- allow the Labor Commissioner to cite an employer and seek restitution for non-payment of contract wages; and
- provide a definition for “contract wages.”
The specific amendments are as follows:
Amendment 1
On page 2, in lines 7 and 8, strike out “or who pays or causes to be paid a rate of compensation that is less than set by contract,”
Amendment 2
On page 3, in lines 3 and 4, strike out “law or applicable contract,” and insert:
law,
Amendment 3
On page 3, in line 5, after the period insert:
In addition, if, upon inspection or investigation, the Labor Commissioner determines that an employer has paid or caused to be paid a wage less than the wage set by contract in excess of the applicable minimum wage, the Labor Commissioner may issue a citation to the employer in violation to recover restitution or those amounts owed.
Amendment 4
On page 6, below line 4, insert:
(l) “Contract wages,” as used in this section, means wages based upon an agreement, in excess of the applicable minimum wage, for regular, nonovertime hours.
5. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
As the Labor Commissioner uses citations as a means of prosecuting wage claims picked up during the period from 2012 to the present, the agency became increasingly aware of the inadequacy of the citation process as a means of recovering contract wages (that is, wages above the minimum wage). The fact that Labor Commissioner lacks statutory authority to issue citations to recover contract wages is proving to be a significant gap in our ability to secure wages owed to – and desperately needed by –California’s low and middle-income workers. This problem, undoubtedly wholly unanticipated by the Legislature, can only be fixed by providing the Labor Commissioner with statutory authority to cite for unpaid contract wages.
In support, the California Employment Lawyers Association writes:
violations of the minimum wage and overtime pay requirements are often accompanied by nonpayment of contract wages. However, neither Labor Code section 558 nor 1197.1 allow the Labor Commissioner to assess and prosecute contract wages. Thus, the Labor Commissioner is presently unable to prosecute companion contract wage violations in the same administrative proceeding in which minimum wages and overtime pay are prosecuted. In most instances, the Labor Commissioner is unable to commit the resources to address the contract violations in a separate court proceeding and the violations are not rectified. […] SB 688 will help strengthen and streamline the state’s ability to secure the hard-earned wages owed to California workers […].
6. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 19 co-signing business and trade associations write:
[M]inimum wage violations per Section 1197.1 not only expose an employer to civil penalties, but also its owners, officers, or individual employees overseeing wage and hour compliance (e.g., managers, supervisors, human resources directors, etc.) to personal liability. Personal liability creates an unfair burden on these individuals because of the overall financial stress (i.e., pending litigation must be disclosed on personal documents such as home loans) not to mention the emotional stress caused by litigation.
[…] Minimum wage is an easily, objectifiable determination considering minimum wage is not a specific contractual rate that may be different for each separate employee; rather, it is a well-known rate set by state law or local ordinance. […] However, the ability to ensure that all employees are being paid at the rate of pay set pursuant to contract is not as easily determined. The extremely broad language of SB 688 can mean any discrepancy including $0.01 accounting error then stacks up. So now an employer and a lower level employee could have $100 and $250 penalties imposed against them for even an unintentional one penny Labor Code violation under Section 1197.1. […]
In light of all the existing penalties already contained in existing law and the exposure to personal liability, we do not believe SB 688 is warranted.
In partial response to this opposition, the author intends to amend the bill to remove the imposition of personal liability for non-payment of contract wages above and beyond the minimum wage.
SUPPORT
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
State Building and Construction Trades Council
OPPOSITION
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Framing Contractors Association
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California Pool and Spa Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 229 (Hertzberg, 2019) elaborates on the process by which a Labor Commissioner’s citation for workplace retaliation may be challenged, or, alternatively, reduced to a court judgment or order for injunctive relief. SB 229 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 362 (Roth, 2019) requires the Labor Commissioner to post on its website a searchable database of all the unpaid wages and monetary compensation the Labor Commissioner has collected on behalf of employees but has not yet been able to distribute. SB 362 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 306 (Hertzberg, Ch. 460, Stats. 2017) gave the Labor Commissioner the power to issue citations for workplace retaliation and to seek injunctive relief in instances in which the Labor Commissioner has reasonable cause to believe that workplace retaliation has taken place.
AB 970 (Nazarian, Ch. 783, Stats. 2015) authorized the Labor Commissioner to issue citations for violations of local minimum wage laws.
AB 469 (Swanson, Ch. 655, Stats. 2011) increased penalties, bonding, and notice requirements to strengthen disincentives to violate wage law.
AB 1359 (Margohn, Ch. 1145, Stat. 1983) empowered the Labor Commissioner to issue citations for minimum wage violations.
**************
Cooper and Kroeger, Employers Steal Billions from Workers’ Paychecks Each Year (May 10, 2017) Economic Policy Institute https://www.epi.org/files/pdf/125116.pdf (as of Apr. 13, 2019) at pp. 2-3. ↑
Mattera, Grand Theft Paycheck: The Large Corporations Shortchanging Their Workers’ Wages (June 2018) Good Jobs First and Jobs With Justice Education Fund https://www.goodjobsfirst.org/sites/default/files/docs/pdfs/wagetheft_report_revised.pdf (as of Apr. 13, 2019) at p. 8. ↑
Bernhardt et al., Broken Laws, Unprotected Workers: Violations of Employment and Labor Laws in America’s Cities (2009) National Employment Law Project https://s27147.pcdn.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/BrokenLawsReport2009.pdf (as of Apr. 13, 2019) at p. 5. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 688 Hearing Date: April 10, 2019
Author: | Monning | ||
Version: | March 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
SUBJECT: Failure to pay wages: penalties
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature extend existing citation and penalty provisions for failure to pay minimum wages to wages or compensation that is due under a contract?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), the Division of Fair Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) tasked with administering and enforcing labor code provisions concerning wages, hours and working conditions. (Labor Code §56)
- Prohibits an employer or other person acting either individually or as an officer, agent, or employee of another, who pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the minimum wage fixed by an applicable state or local law shall be subject to a civil penalty, restitution of wages, liquidated damages payable to the employee, and any applicable penalties imposed, as specified. (Labor Code §1197.1)
- Provides that if the Labor Commissioner, who is Chief of the DLSE, determines that a person has paid or caused to be paid a wage less than the minimum under applicable law, the Labor Commissioner may issue a citation to the person in violation, as specified. Each citation must be in writing and must describe the nature of the violation, including reference to the statutory provision alleged to have been violated. (Labor Code §1197.1)
- The Labor Commissioner (LC) shall promptly take all appropriate action to enforce the citation and to recover the civil penalty assessed, wages, liquidated damages, and any applicable penalties imposed in connection with the citation.
- Authorizes a person who desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessments to notify the LC within 15 days after service of the citation of the request for an appeal and an informal hearing. The LC or his or her deputy or agent must then hold a hearing within 30 days at which point the citation or proposed penalties, wages or damages must be affirmed, modified, or dismissed. [Labor Code §1197.1(c)]
- Authorizes an individual cited to file a petition for a writ of mandate. As a condition to filing this petition, the petitioner seeking the writ must first post a bond with the LC equal to the total amount of any minimum wages, liquidated damages, and overtime compensation that are due and owing as specified in the citation being challenged.
- Provides that if the employer fails to pay the amount of minimum wages, liquidated damages, or overtime compensation owed within 10 days of the entry of judgment, dismissal or withdrawal of writ, or the execution of a settlement agreement, a portion of the undertaking, equal to the amount owed, or the entire undertaking if the amount owed exceeds the undertaking, shall be forfeited to the employee. [Labor Code §1197.1(c)(4)]
This bill:
- Extends existing provisions for failure to pay minimum wages to wages or compensation that is due under a contract.
- Specifies that, should the employer fail to pay the amounts owed, the bond required for an appeal through a writ of mandate must be forfeited to the Labor Commissioner for appropriate distribution instead of the employee as is currently required.
- Makes several changes to existing provisions replacing “his or her” with gender-neutral pronouns per ACR No. 260 of 2018 which directed a coordinated effort to revise existing statutes with inclusive language.
COMMENTS
1. Background:
In 2011, in response to widespread wage theft in California, AB 469 (Swanson) was enacted to propose a number of changes aimed at preventing or combating the intentional theft of earned wages by unscrupulous employers. Among other things, the bill (1) provided that in addition to being subject to a civil penalty, any employer who pays or causes to be paid to any employee a wage less than the minimum fixed shall be subject to paying restitution of wages to the employee; (2) made it a misdemeanor if an employer willfully violates specified wage statutes or orders, or willfully fails to pay a final court judgment or final order of the Labor commission for wages due; (3) and extended the period within which the division may commence a collection action, as defined, from one year to three years.
According to the author and sponsors of AB 469, the bill was necessary because enforcement of labor laws related to wage violations was weak and largely ineffective. As noted in the Senate Labor Committee policy analysis for that bill, “In 2009, only 216 employers in the entire state of California were cited by the DLSE violating minimum wage and overtime laws. DLSE assessed $650,550 in penalties for these violations but collected only $230,154. During that same year, DLSE found $22,381,286 in wages due, but recovered only $13,062,164. When these results are put in the context of the billions of dollars stolen in the underground economy, it is clear they are too feeble to constitute a meaningful deterrent.”
2. Need for this bill?
According to the author:
“As the Labor Commissioner uses citations as a means of prosecuting wage claims picked up during the period from 2012 to the present, the agency became increasingly aware of the inadequacy of the citation process as a means of recovering contract wages (that is, wages above the minimum wage). The fact that Labor Commissioner lacks statutory authority to issue citations to recover contract wages is proving to be a significant gap in our ability to secure wages owed to – and desperately needed by – California’s low and middle-income workers. This problem, undoubtedly wholly unanticipated by the Legislature, can only be fixed by providing the Labor Commissioner with statutory authority to cite for unpaid contract wages. Regarding the number of cases that may be impacted, the Division estimates that there would be about 400 Bureau of Field Enforcement (BOFE) cases a year where the Division would cite for contract wage violations (about 20% of all BOFE citations).”
This bill would address this deficiency in law by extending existing enforcement provisions for failure to pay wages or compensation that is due under a contract. Additionally, the bill would specify that the bond required for an appeal through a writ of mandate (upon failure to pay amounts owed) must be forfeited to the Labor Commissioner for appropriate distribution. The reason for this revision is that these cases often involve multiple affected employees and this technical adjustment effectively makes the Labor Commissioner responsible for the appropriate distribution of wages instead of the court. As set forth in Labor Code section 96.7, the Labor Commissioner acts as a trustee for all unpaid wages, and is required to diligently locate any worker who is owed wages.
3. Proponent Arguments
None received.
4. Opponent Arguments:
The California Chamber of Commerce and a coalition of employers are opposed arguing that California already has some of the most onerous and complex labor laws in the country where one unintentional and minor violation of the Labor Code can result in the threat of financially devastating civil litigation against an employer. Among other things, they argue that SB 688 imposes personal liability on an employee for unintentional wage and hour violations. They cite a court case in which the Court of Appeal held that penalties extend to individuals who may not be the employer, so long as they are sufficiently responsible for the violations that occurred.(Atempa v. Pedrazzani (2018) 27 Cal. App. 5th 809, 820)
Opponents are concerned about this expansion of personal liability since Section 1197.1 currently only applies to the payment of minimum wage, which they argue is an easily, objectifiable determination considering minimum wage is not a specific contractual rate that may be different for each separate employee. They believe that expanding personal liability to employees for any unintentional or minor underpayment of contractual wages is unfair especially when the liability includes penalties, restitution of wages, liquidated damages, additional applicable penalties, attorney’s fees, and costs.
Lastly, they argue that SB 688 is duplicative and unnecessary given all the other penalty provisions in the Labor Code that an employee can recover for the same wage error including penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), Labor Code Section 558, Industrial Wage Commission (IWC) Wage Order provisions, and numerous other Labor Code sections (§§ 203, 226, 226.7, etc.). In light of all the penalties already contained in existing law and the exposure to personal liability, opponents do not believe SB 688 is warranted.
5. Double referral:
SB 688 has been double referred and, if approved by this committee today, will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
6. Prior Legislation:
AB 469 (Swanson), Chapter 655, Statutes of 2011, discussed above, increased penalties, bonding and notice requirements to strengthen disincentives to violate wage law.
SUPPORT
None received
OPPOSITION
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Framing Contractors Association
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Western Growers Association
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):