SB 743: School facilities: design-build projects.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-06
Existing law authorizes, until January 1, 2025, a school district governing board to enter into a design-build contract, as defined, in which factors in addition to price and cost may be considered in awarding a contract for the design and construction of a school facility that exceeds $1,000,000.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
This bill would specify that a certain school district entering into a design-build contract for projects that are subject to a project labor agreement retains the discretion to take specified actions related to the contract. The bill would require the contract to contain specified terms and conditions. The bill would prohibit a design-build entity or its subcontractor performing work on a project for a school district from engaging in any activity under the design-build contract beyond the design phase of the contract unless the school district issues certain notices, including a notice to proceed with the construction. The bill would, for purposes of procuring or awarding a design-build contract for a project, deem a school district to have complied with CEQA if the school district retains the discretion to take those specified actions and the contract contains those required terms and conditions.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Los Angeles Unified School District.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Project means all construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, and maintenance work that is subject to a project labor agreement that meets the requirements of Section 2500 of the Public Contract Code.
(2)School district means a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
(b)A school district entering into a contract awarded pursuant to this chapter for a project that is subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) shall retain the discretion to do all of the following:
(1)Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the Division of the State Architect for approval.
(2)Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project.
(3)Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the projects significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level.
(4)Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the projects final design and construction.
(c)A contract awarded pursuant to this chapter by a school district for a project shall include terms specifying conditions set forth in subdivision (b) and shall condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws, including the California Environmental Quality Act.
(d)A design-build entity or its subcontractors performing work on a project for a school district shall not engage in any activity, including demolition, excavation, grading, or construction, under a contract awarded pursuant to this chapter beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code, as applicable, and issues a notice to proceed with the construction.
(e)For purposes of procuring and awarding a design-build contract for a project pursuant to this chapter, a school district is deemed to have complied with the California Environmental Quality Act if the school district complies with subdivision (b) and a contract awarded pursuant to this chapter contains the terms and conditions described in subdivision (c).
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique fiscal and infrastructure difficulties being suffered by the Los Angeles Unified School District.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 6, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 275, Statutes of 2019. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 27, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 20, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 10). |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 7, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 27. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2019 | SB 743 Hertzberg Senate Third Reading By Smith | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB743 Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 743
Author:(Hertzberg)
As Amended Ver:April 29, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a specified school district to meet certain requirements and include those requirements as terms and conditions in a design-build contract for the purpose of meeting contracting provisions related to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
Major Provisions
- Defines "school district" as a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
- Requires a design-build contract awarded by a school district for a project to condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws, including the CEQA.
- Requires the school district to comply with and include the following terms in the design-build contract:
- The school district shall retain discretion to do all of the following:
- Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the Division of the State Architect for approval;
- Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with the CEQA, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project;
- Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project's significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level; and
- Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project's final design and construction.
- The school district shall retain discretion to do all of the following:
- Prohibits the design-build entity or its subcontractors performing work on a project for a school district from engaging in any activity, including demolition, excavation, grading, or construction, under a contract beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code, as applicable, and issues a notice to proceed with the construction.
COMMENTS:
Design-build. Under a design-build process, a K-12 school district or other public or private agency issues a bid for both design and construction of a facility. A general contractor may collaborate with an architect/engineer to submit a proposal, or a general contractor may submit the proposal and subcontract with an architect/engineer.
Under a design-bid-build process, the architect works independently on the design of the facility. Once construction begins, any problems identified by the contractor must be resolved, frequently with the school district acting as the mediator. Under design-build, the architect and contractor are working together from the beginning of the project, thereby reducing conflicts, delays, and additional costs during the construction phase. Design-build contracting can expedite the construction of a project, avoid conflicts between architects/engineers and contractors, and according to experiences from school and community college districts, reduce costs by reducing change orders once construction begins.
CEQA. CEQA is intended to inform the public of potential environmental effects of a proposed activity undertaken by a governmental agency, or an activity financed or that require approval by a governmental agency, and identify mitigation measures or alternatives to the proposed project. This is done through the development of an Environmental Impact Report (EIR). Public Resources Code 21151.8 specifically prohibits a local governing board of a school district from certifying an EIR unless the EIR identifies specified information (including whether the site is a current or former hazardous waste disposal site, the site contains one or more pipelines that carries hazardous substances, and the site is within 500 feet of a freeway or busy traffic corridor), and has made written findings to address the environmental impacts. Education Code Section 17213, citing the school district as a lead agency under CEQA, conforms the requirements for location of a school to the Public Resources Code and prohibits the purchase of property if the school is to be located on the aforementioned sites.
According to the Author:
According to the author, this bill applies only to the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD), as a result of a challenge to a design-build contract for a modernization project at Roosevelt High School.
Arguments in Support:
This bill ensures that the district maintains control of the project and may make changes to the design or even abandon the project in order to address issues identified in an EIR. According to the LAUSD, the sponsor of the bill:
The expedited nature of design-build, while timely and cost-effective, sometimes runs into timing issues, when it comes to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review. In order to evaluate whether a proposed project complies with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it is necessary to have certain information known about the proposed project that can only be revealed through the design development stage.
These coinciding timelines can lead to differing interpretations about what has or has not been approved in a project. For example, it was recently concluded by some that because the Los Angeles Unified School District awarded a design-build contract, the school district had already officially approved the project, thus committing itself to an irreversible and definite course of action without conducting the appropriate environmental review under CEQA.
Arguments in Opposition:
None received
FISCAL COMMENTS:
This bill has been keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM EDUCATION: 7-0-0
YES: O'Donnell, Kiley, Diep, Kalra, McCarty, Smith, Weber
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 29, 2019
CONSULTANT: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0001284
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 743
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: School facilities: design-build projects
SUMMARY: Requires a specified school district to meet certain requirements and include those requirements as terms and conditions in a design-build contract for the purpose of meeting the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requirements. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the following definitions:
- “Project” means all construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, and maintenance work that is subject to a project labor agreement that meets the requirements of Section 2500 of the Public Contract Code.
- “School district” means a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
- Requires a design-build contract awarded by a school district for a project to condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws, including the CEQA.
- Requires the school district to comply with and include the following terms in the design-build contract:
- The school district shall retain discretion to do all of the following:
- Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the Division of the State Architect (DSA) for approval;
- Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with the CEQA, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project;
- Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project’s significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level; and
- Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project’s final design and construction.
- The school district shall retain discretion to do all of the following:
- Prohibits the design-build entity or its subcontractors performing work on a project for a school district from engaging in any activity, including demolition, excavation, grading, or construction, under a contract beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code, as applicable, and issues a notice to proceed with the construction.
- Specifies that for purposes of procuring and awarding a design-build contract for a project, a school district is deemed to have complied with the CEQA if the school district complies with and the contract awarded contains the terms and conditions in (3) above.
- Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique fiscal and infrastructure difficulties being suffered by the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD).
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes a process, until January 1, 2025, for a school district governing board to enter into a design-build contract for both the design and construction of education facility projects over $1 million. (Education Code (EC) Section 17250.20)
- Finds and declares that the design-build method of project delivery, using a best value procurement methodology, has reported benefits, including reduced project costs, expedited project completion and design features that are not achievable through the traditional design-bid-build method. (EC Section 17250.10)
- Specifies the elements required to be included in a design-build request for proposal (including significant factors, subfactors, methodology, rating and weighting schemes for evaluating proposals) and establishes, among others, prequalification, bonding and labor compliance program requirements. (EC Sections 17250.15 – 17250.40)
- Requires the governing board of a school district to competitively bid and award to the lowest bidder contracts involving the following:
- An expenditure of $50,000 or more for the purchase of equipment, materials, or supplies, services (except for construction services), and repairs.
- An expenditure of $15,000 or more for a public contract project defined as construction, reconstruction, erection, alteration, renovation, improvement, demolition, repair, painting or repainting of any publicly owned, leased, or operated facility. (Public Contract Code Sections 20111 and 22002)
- Establishes the CEQA and requires all lead agencies to prepare, or cause to be prepared by contract, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report (EIR) on any project they propose to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment. Specifies the process and requirements for compliance with CEQA. (Public Resources Code 21000 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has been keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Background on design-build contracting. Under current law, K-12 school districts are required to competitively bid any public works contract over $15,000 and award the contract to the lowest responsible bidder. Under this process, a school district would first hire an architect to design a school facility and then issue a bid for the construction phase, awarding the contract to the lowest responsible bidder. This process is commonly called "design-bid-build.” AB 1402 (Simitian), Chapter 421, Statutes of 2001, established a process called "design-build" that enables a school district to issue a bid for both the design and construction of projects over $10 million and authorizes school districts to consider factors other than cost. AB 1402 had an initial sunset of January 1, 2007, and required the Legislative Analyst's Office to submit a report with information on the experiences of districts that used the design-build process and make recommendations to the Legislature. In 2007, the sunset was extended to January 1, 2014, and the threshold for eligible projects was reduced from $10 million to $2.5 million. In 2015, AB 1358 (Chapter 752, Statutes of 2015), aligned the process for school districts awarding contracts through the design-build method with the design-build process established for state and local agencies, reduced the threshold for participation from $2.5 million to $1 million, and extended the sunset date to January 1, 2025.
Design-build. Under a design-build process, a K-12 school district or other public or private agency issues a bid for both design and construction of a facility. A general contractor may collaborate with an architect/engineer to submit a proposal, or a general contractor may submit the proposal and subcontract with an architect/engineer. The school district must also establish a process to prequalify design-build entities using a standard questionnaire developed by the Department of Industrial Relations.
Rather than selecting the contractor based solely on the lowest offer, a school district may use criteria in addition to cost, which may include qualification, experience, proposed design approach, life cycle costs, project features and project functions. Based on the criteria selected by a governing board, the proposals are scored and awarded to the bidder whose proposal is considered to be the best value to the school district. Under a design-bid-build process, the architect works independently on the design of the facility. Once construction begins, any problems identified by the contractor must be resolved, frequently with the school district acting as the mediator. Under design-build, the architect and contractor are working together from the beginning of the project, thereby reducing conflicts, delays, and additional costs during the construction phase. Design-build contracting can expedite the construction of a project, avoid conflicts between architects/engineers and contractors, and according to experiences from school and community college districts, reduce costs by reducing change orders once construction begins.
In addition to K-12 schools and California Community Colleges (CCC) districts, a number of design-build authorizations have been given to various cities and counties, state building projects, and transit districts.
CEQA. CEQA is intended to inform the public of potential environmental effects of a proposed activity undertaken by a governmental agency, or an activity financed or that require approval by a governmental agency, and identify mitigation measures or alternatives to the proposed project. This is done through the development of an EIR. Public Resources Code 21151.8 specifically prohibits a local governing board of a school district from certifying an EIR unless the EIR identifies specified information (including whether the site is a current or former hazardous waste disposal site, the site contains one or more pipelines that carries hazardous substances, and the site is within 500 feet of a freeway or busy traffic corridor), and has made written findings to address the environmental impacts. Education Code Section 17213, citing the school district as a lead agency under CEQA, conforms the requirements for location of a school to the Public Resources Code and prohibits the purchase of property if the school is to be located on the aforementioned sites.
Purpose of this bill. This bill is sponsored by the LAUSD and applies only to LAUSD to clarify that the district is authorized to enter into a design-build contract prior to compliance with the CEQA as long as the district meets certain requirements and the contract contains specified terms and conditions.
According to LAUSD:
The expedited nature of design-build, while timely and cost-effective, sometimes runs into timing issues, when it comes to California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review. In order to evaluate whether a proposed project complies with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it is necessary to have certain information known about the proposed project that can only be revealed through the design development stage.
These coinciding timelines can lead to differing interpretations about what has or has not been approved in a project. For example, it was recently concluded by some that because the Los Angeles Unified School District awarded a design-build contract, the school district had already officially approved the project, thus committing itself to an irreversible and definite course of action without conducting the appropriate environmental review under CEQA.
In 2018, the Los Angeles Conservancy challenged a design-build contract for a modernization project at Roosevelt High School, stating, “…the District has pre-committed itself in a manner that precludes alternatives under CEQA by entering into a contract for design and construction of the Project that included specific requirements for the design.”
Design-build contracting method and CEQA. One of the main issues raised by this bill is whether there is a conflict between the design-build contracting method and when a school district “approves” a project under CEQA. The purpose of establishing the design-build contracting method is to allow a school district to award a contract that allows an architect and a contractor to work together from the outset of the project to achieve efficiency and reduce costs. CEQA requires an entity to prepare and certify the completion of the EIR on a project it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment in order to address impacts identified in the EIR or seek alternative options to the project. Title 14, Section 15352 of the California Code of Regulations defines “approval” as the “decision by a public agency, which commits the agency to a definite course of action in regard to a project intended to be carried out by the person. The exact date of approval of any project is a matter determined by each public agency according to its rules, regulations, and ordinances. Legislative action in regard to a project often constitutes approval.”
Can a school district enter a design-build contract before demonstrating CEQA compliance? Central to this bill is the question of whether or not a school district can enter into a design-build contract prior to showing compliance with the CEQA. There have been differing opinions as to what constitutes “approval” or “commitment” to a project. Some would argue that it is allowed as long as the contract is conditional on CEQA compliance being obtained. In other incidences, such as in Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood (2008) 45 Cal.4th 116, neighbors opposed to a project converting a home to apartments for low-income seniors sued the City of West Hollywood for violating CEQA by not completing an EIR before approving a loan and a conditional agreement. The California Supreme Court found that the contract, loan, and comments made by city officials showed commitment to the project. The Supreme Court affirmed the importance of considering the surrounding facts and context of the project under contract, stating:
A CEQA compliance condition can be a legitimate ingredient in a preliminary public-private agreement for exploration of a proposed project, but if the agreement, viewed in light of all the surrounding circumstances commits the public agency as a practical matter to the project, the simple insertion of a CEQA compliance condition will not save the agreement from being considered an approval requiring prior environmental review.
This bill clarifies that LAUSD, for the purpose of complying with CEQA, may enter into a design-build contract as long as the district complies with and the contract contains the following terms and conditions:
- The school district retains discretion to: a) terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the DSA for approval; b) modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with the CEQA; c) balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project’s significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level; and d) disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project’s final design and construction.
- Commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract is conditioned upon compliance with applicable state laws, including the CEQA.
These provisions ensure that the district maintains control of the project and may make changes to the design or even abandon the project in order to address issues identified in an EIR. The bill also prohibits the design-build entity or its subcontractors from engaging in any activity, including demolition, excavation, grading, or construction beyond the design phase unless the school district files a notice of approval with the county where the project is located and issues a notice to proceed with the construction.
It is unclear whether design-build contracts awarded in other school districts have been challenged.
Related legislation. AB 695 (Medina), pending on the Senate Floor, extends from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2030 the authority for CCC districts to use the design-build method, and applies the existing provisions regarding the use of a skilled and trained workforce on state, school district, and local government design-build projects to community college design-build contracts advertised for bid or awarded on or after July 1, 2020.
Prior legislation. AB 1358 (Dababneh), Chapter 752, Statutes of 2015, aligned the process for school districts awarding contracts through the design-build method with the design-build process established for state and local agencies, lowered the threshold for projects eligible to use design-build to $1 million, and extended the authorization for school districts to use design-build contracting to January 1, 2025.
SB 785 (Wolk), Chapter 931, Statutes of 2014, aligned the design-build process for the Department of General Services, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, and several local agencies.
SB 1509 (Simitian), Chapter 736, Statutes of 2012, extended the sunset for K-12 and CCC authorization to use design-build from January 1, 2014, to January 1, 2020.
SB 614 (Simitian), Chapter 471, Statutes of 2007, extended the authority to use design-build to the CCCs, reduced the threshold for eligible projects from $10 million to $2.5 million and extended the sunset for school districts and CCC districts to use design-build to January 1, 2014.
AB 1402 (Simitian), Chapter 421, Statutes of 2001, established, until January 1, 2007, the authorization for school districts to use the design-build contracting method for projects over $10 million and authorized school districts to consider factors other than cost.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Los Angeles Unified School District (sponsor)
State Construction and Building Trades Council
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 743 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 743
Amended: 4/29/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/10/19
AYES: Leyva, Wilk, Chang, Durazo, Glazer, McGuire, Pan
SUBJECT: School facilities: design-build projects
SOURCE: Los Angeles Unified School District
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies that, upon entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Los Angeles Unified School District shall retain the discretion to terminate the contract before final project design submittal and modify the project as needed to ensure project compliance with CEQA.
Senate Floor Amendments of 4/29/19 are technical and further clarify that the contents of this bill only pertain to school district construction projects subject to CEQA.
Existing law:
- Establishes the design-build method of construction project delivery, in which both the design and construction of a project are procured from the same entity, for use by school districts.
- Establishes the CEQA to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project, through the preparation of an Initial Study, Negative Declaration, or Environmental Impact Report (EIR).
- Encourages local agencies with projects subject to CEQA to integrate the CEQA requirements with planning and environmental review procedures otherwise required by law or by local practice so that all those procedures, to the maximum feasible extent, run concurrently, rather than consecutively.
This bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for purposes of the section being added:
- “Project” means all construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, and maintenance work that is subject to a project labor agreement.
- “School district” means a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
- Species that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the CEQA shall retain the discretion to do all of the following:
- Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design for the school district construction project is submitted to the Division of the State Architect for approval.
- Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with CEQA, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project.
- Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project’s significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level.
- Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project’s final design and construction.
- Requires design-build contracts to include terms specifying the conditions set forth above and condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws.
- Prohibits a design-build entity or its subcontractors from engaging in any activity under a design-build contract beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to existing Public Resources Code law.
- Specifies that, for purposes of procuring and awarding a design-build contract, a school district is deemed to have complied with CEQA if the school district complies with the discretions above.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “The design-build method of project delivery provides many efficiencies to school construction projects, including cost-effective use of public funds and expedited project completion. However, in order to evaluate whether a proposed project is in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it is necessary to have certain information known about the proposed project that can only be revealed through the design development stage. However, the project design cannot be initiated by the design-builder until they are awarded the design-build contract. As such, oftentimes the design-build contract is awarded before the environmental review under CEQA has been approved by the Board of Education. It’s also important to know that awarding of the design-build contract does not authorize the construction of the project until it satisfies its respective CEQA and Division of State Architect requirements.
“Recently in the Los Angeles Unified School District, opponents to a project argued that by awarding the design-build contract, the school district had already approved the project and committed itself to an irreversible and definite course of action without conducting the appropriate environmental review under California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
- Design-build contracting. Existing law authorizes school districts to use the design-build method for delivering construction projects. Whereas traditional project delivery requires the owner to manage two separate, and often adversarial, contracts with a designer and a builder, design-build projects involve a single point of responsibility, with the designer and builder working together from the beginning. Also central to the design-build method is best value procurement. Best value procurement means selecting project bidders based on experience, past performance, and features in addition to lowest price.
- CEQA. CEQA is California’s broadest environmental law, with courts interpreting it to afford the fullest protection of the environment within the reasonable scope of the statutes. The Act applies to all discretionary projects proposed to be conducted or approved by a California public agency, including private projects requiring discretionary government approval.
The overall purpose of CEQA is to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project through an EIR, prevent or minimize damage to the environment through development of project alternatives, enhance public participation in the environmental review process through scoping meetings, public notice, public review, hearings, and the judicial process, and improve interagency coordination through early consultations, scoping meetings, notices of preparation, and State Clearinghouse review.
Under CEQA, projects carried out by public agencies are subject to the same level of review as private projects requiring approval by public agencies. The intent is to ensure that no project that would cause significant environmental effects shall be approved as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or mitigation measures that would lessen those effects. Lastly, local agencies are encouraged to integrate CEQA with other environmental review, planning, and information gathering so as to cut costs and time and to apply the conservation of financial, governmental, physical, and social resources towards better mitigation.
- At what point during the life of a project must an agency show CEQA compliance? An agency with a project subject to CEQA must complete an EIR before “committing” to the project. The point at which an agency is committed to a project is not precisely defined in statute. The courts have ruled that the degree to which a lead agency commits to a proposed project, taking into account the surrounding facts and context, ultimately determines when an EIR must be completed for CEQA compliance purposes.
In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood (2008) 45 Cal.4th 116, the California Supreme Court stated the following about when an agency has shown project commitment:
When an agency has not only expressed its inclination to favor a project, but has increased the political stakes by publically defending it over objections, putting its official weight behind it, devoting substantial public resources to it, and announcing a detailed agreement to go forward with the project, the agency will not be easily deterred from taking whatever steps remain toward the project’s final approval.
- Can a school district enter a design-build contract before demonstrating CEQA compliance? Central to this bill is the question of whether or not a school district can enter into a design-build contract prior to showing compliance with the CEQA. Some have argued yes, as long as the contract is conditional on CEQA compliance being obtained. In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood, the Court affirmed the importance of considering the surrounding facts and context of the project under contract, stating:
A CEQA compliance condition can be a legitimate ingredient in a preliminary public-private agreement for exploration of a proposed project, but if the agreement, viewed in light of all the surrounding circumstances commits the public agency as a practical matter to the project, the simple insertion of a CEQA compliance condition will not save the agreement from being considered an approval requiring prior environmental review.
Given the Court’s statement, it appears that only on a case-by-case basis can it be known if executing a project contract will trigger the point at which an agency must show CEQA compliance.
- Existing law appears to pit design-build projects against CEQA’s chain of required events. CEQA law is ambiguous about when an EIR showing CEQA compliance must be completed, and agencies have been sued for entering contract with project builders prior to completing an EIR. Design-build projects by definition combine project designers and builders into one contract, meaning no design functions can begin until a contract is executed. Therefore, there appears to be no way for school districts with design-build projects from avoiding a period of time when they are legally vulnerable under CEQA—the period of time between first entering the design-build contract and completing an EIR. According to sponsor of the bill, an EIR typically takes about one year to complete.
- This approach has merit, but why only apply it to Los Angeles Unified School District? This bill seeks to address a fundamental way in which design-build projects and CEQA may be misaligned. By codifying that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to CEQA retains the discretion to (a) terminate the contract before final project design submittal and (b) modify the project as needed pursuant to an EIR, and requiring design-build contracts to include these provisions, this bill makes it clear that simply entering into a design-build contract does not mean a district is “committed” to the project as defined by the California Supreme Court in Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood.
However, as currently drafted this bill only applies to Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). According to the author, LAUSD is the only school district that is known to have been sued over a design-build project because of ambiguity within the statutes governing the CEQA. Even so, there could be other school districts that will face legal challenges moving forward or that currently opt out of design-build contracting for fear of legal recourse related to CEQA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Los Angeles Unified School District (source)
State Building and Construction Trades Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/29/19)
None received
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. /
5/1/19 15:24:29
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 743 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 743
Amended: 3/27/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/10/19
AYES: Leyva, Wilk, Chang, Durazo, Glazer, McGuire, Pan
SUBJECT: School facilities: design-build projects
SOURCE: Los Angeles Unified School District
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies that, upon entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Los Angeles Unified School District shall retain the discretion to terminate the contract before final project design submittal and modify the project as needed to ensure project compliance with CEQA.
Existing law:
- Establishes the design-build method of construction project delivery, in which both the design and construction of a project are procured from the same entity, for use by school districts.
- Establishes the CEQA to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project, through the preparation of an Initial Study, Negative Declaration, or Environmental Impact Report (EIR).
- Encourages local agencies with projects subject to CEQA to integrate the CEQA requirements with planning and environmental review procedures otherwise required by law or by local practice so that all those procedures, to the maximum feasible extent, run concurrently, rather than consecutively.
This bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for purposes of the section being added:
- “Project” means all construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, and maintenance work that is subject to a project labor agreement.
- “School district” means a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
- Species that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the CEQA shall retain the discretion to do all of the following:
- Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the Division of the State Architect for approval.
- Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with CEQA, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project.
- Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project’s significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level.
- Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project’s final design and construction.
- Requires design-build contracts to include terms specifying the conditions set forth above and condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws.
- Prohibits a design-build entity or its subcontractors from engaging in any activity under a design-build contract beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to existing Public Resources Code law.
- Specifies that, for purposes of procuring and awarding a design-build contract, a school district is deemed to have complied with CEQA if the school district complies with the discretions above.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “The design-build method of project delivery provides many efficiencies to school construction projects, including cost-effective use of public funds and expedited project completion. However, in order to evaluate whether a proposed project is in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it is necessary to have certain information known about the proposed project that can only be revealed through the design development stage. However, the project design cannot be initiated by the design-builder until they are awarded the design-build contract. As such, oftentimes the design-build contract is awarded before the environmental review under CEQA has been approved by the Board of Education. It’s also important to know that awarding of the design-build contract does not authorize the construction of the project until it satisfies its respective CEQA and Division of State Architect requirements.
“Recently in the Los Angeles Unified School District, opponents to a project argued that by awarding the design-build contract, the school district had already approved the project and committed itself to an irreversible and definite course of action without conducting the appropriate environmental review under California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
- Design-build contracting. Existing law authorizes school districts to use the design-build method for delivering construction projects. Whereas traditional project delivery requires the owner to manage two separate, and often adversarial, contracts with a designer and a builder, design-build projects involve a single point of responsibility, with the designer and builder working together from the beginning. Also central to the design-build method is best value procurement. Best value procurement means selecting project bidders based on experience, past performance, and features in addition to lowest price.
- CEQA. CEQA is California’s broadest environmental law, with courts interpreting it to afford the fullest protection of the environment within the reasonable scope of the statutes. The Act applies to all discretionary projects proposed to be conducted or approved by a California public agency, including private projects requiring discretionary government approval.
The overall purpose of CEQA is to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project through an EIR, prevent or minimize damage to the environment through development of project alternatives, enhance public participation in the environmental review process through scoping meetings, public notice, public review, hearings, and the judicial process, and improve interagency coordination through early consultations, scoping meetings, notices of preparation, and State Clearinghouse review.
Under CEQA, projects carried out by public agencies are subject to the same level of review as private projects requiring approval by public agencies. The intent is to ensure that no project that would cause significant environmental effects shall be approved as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or mitigation measures that would lessen those effects. Lastly, local agencies are encouraged to integrate CEQA with other environmental review, planning, and information gathering so as to cut costs and time and to apply the conservation of financial, governmental, physical, and social resources towards better mitigation.
- At what point during the life of a project must an agency show CEQA compliance? An agency with a project subject to CEQA must complete an EIR before “committing” to the project. The point at which an agency is committed to a project is not precisely defined in statute. The courts have ruled that the degree to which a lead agency commits to a proposed project, taking into account the surrounding facts and context, ultimately determines when an EIR must be completed for CEQA compliance purposes.
In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood (2008) 45 Cal.4th 116, the California Supreme Court stated the following about when an agency has shown project commitment:
When an agency has not only expressed its inclination to favor a project, but has increased the political stakes by publically defending it over objections, putting its official weight behind it, devoting substantial public resources to it, and announcing a detailed agreement to go forward with the project, the agency will not be easily deterred from taking whatever steps remain toward the project’s final approval.
- Can a school district enter a design-build contract before demonstrating CEQA compliance? Central to this bill is the question of whether or not a school district can enter into a design-build contract prior to showing compliance with the CEQA. Some have argued yes, as long as the contract is conditional on CEQA compliance being obtained. In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood, the Court affirmed the importance of considering the surrounding facts and context
of the project under contract, stating:
A CEQA compliance condition can be a legitimate ingredient in a preliminary public-private agreement for exploration of a proposed project, but if the agreement, viewed in light of all the surrounding circumstances commits the public agency as a practical matter to the project, the simple insertion of a CEQA compliance condition will not save the agreement from being considered an approval requiring prior environmental review.
Given the Court’s statement, it appears that only on a case-by-case basis can it be known if executing a project contract will trigger the point at which an agency must show CEQA compliance.
- Existing law appears to pit design-build projects against CEQA’s chain of required events. CEQA law is ambiguous about when an EIR showing CEQA compliance must be completed, and agencies have been sued for entering contract with project builders prior to completing an EIR. Design-build projects by definition combine project designers and builders into one contract, meaning no design functions can begin until a contract is executed. Therefore, there appears to be no way for school districts with design-build projects from avoiding a period of time when they are legally vulnerable under CEQA—the period of time between first entering the design-build contract and completing an EIR. According to sponsor of the bill, an EIR typically takes about one year to complete.
- This approach has merit, but why only apply it to Los Angeles Unified School District? This bill seeks to address a fundamental way in which design-build projects and CEQA may be misaligned. By codifying that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to CEQA retains the discretion to (a) terminate the contract before final project design submittal and (b) modify the project as needed pursuant to an EIR, and requiring design-build contracts to include these provisions, this bill makes it clear that simply entering into a design-build contract does not mean a district is “committed” to the project as defined by the California Supreme Court in Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood.
However, as currently drafted this bill only applies to Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). According to the author, LAUSD is the only school district that is known to have been sued over a design-build project because of ambiguity within the statutes governing the CEQA. Even so, there could be other school districts that will face legal challenges moving forward or that currently opt out of design-build contracting for fear of legal recourse related to CEQA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Los Angeles Unified School District (source)
State Building and Construction Trades Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/11/19)
None received
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. /
4/18/19 10:58:03
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 743 Hearing Date: April 10, 2019
Author: | Hertzberg | ||
Version: | March 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Ian Johnson | ||
Subject: School Facilities: design-build projects
SUMMARY
This bill clarifies that, upon entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Los Angeles Unified School District shall retain the discretion to terminate the contract before final project design submittal and modify the project as needed to ensure project compliance with CEQA.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Establishes the design-build method of construction project delivery, in which both the design and construction of a project are procured from the same entity, for use by school districts.
- Establishes the CEQA to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project, through the preparation of an Initial Study, Negative Declaration, or Environmental Impact Report (EIR).
- Encourages local agencies with projects subject to CEQA to integrate the CEQA requirements with planning and environmental review procedures otherwise required by law or by local practice so that all those procedures, to the maximum feasible extent, run concurrently, rather than consecutively.
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Establishes the following definitions for purposes of the section being added:
- “Project” means all construction, alteration, demolition, installation, repair, and maintenance work that is subject to a project labor agreement.
- “School district” means a school district that operates a labor compliance program that received final approval from the Department of Industrial Relations before January 1, 1997.
- Species that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) shall retain the discretion to do all of the following:
- Terminate the contract at any time before a final project design is submitted to the Division of the State Architect for approval.
- Modify the project design or feature in a manner the school district decides is necessary to comply with CEQA, including, but not limited to, incorporation of mitigation measures identified in an environmental review document for the project to mitigate environmental impacts that the project may cause, or the adoption of alternatives to the project.
- Balance the benefits of the proposed project against any of the project’s significant environmental effects if the effects cannot be otherwise avoided or mitigated to a less than significant level.
- Disapprove the project design and not proceed with the project’s final design and construction.
- Requires design-build contracts to include terms specifying the conditions set forth above and condition the commencement of any activity beyond the design phase of the contract in compliance with applicable laws.
- Prohibits a design-build entity or its subcontractors from engaging in any activity under a design-build contract beyond the design phase unless the school district issues a notice pursuant to existing Public Resources Code law.
- Specifies that, for purposes of procuring and awarding a design-build contract, a school district is deemed to have complied with CEQA if the school district complies with the discretions above.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “The design-build method of project delivery provides many efficiencies to school construction projects, including cost-effective use of public funds and expedited project completion. However, in order to evaluate whether a proposed project is in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), it is necessary to have certain information known about the proposed project that can only be revealed through the design development stage. However, the project design cannot be initiated by the design-builder until they are awarded the design-build contract. As such, oftentimes the design-build contract is awarded before the environmental review under CEQA has been approved by the Board of Education. It’s also important to know that awarding of the design-build contract does not authorize the construction of the project until it satisfies its respective CEQA and Division of State Architect requirements.
Recently in the Los Angeles Unified School District, opponents to a project argued that by awarding the design-build contract, the school district had already approved the project and committed itself to an irreversible and definite course of action without conducting the appropriate environmental review under California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
- Design-build contracting. Existing law authorizes school districts to use the design-build method for delivering construction projects. Whereas traditional project delivery requires the owner to manage two separate, and often adversarial, contracts with a designer and a builder, design-build projects involve a single point of responsibility, with the designer and builder working together from the beginning. Also central to the design-build method is best value procurement. Best value procurement means selecting project bidders based on experience, past performance, and features in addition to lowest price.
- CEQA. CEQA is California’s broadest environmental law, with courts interpreting it to afford the fullest protection of the environment within the reasonable scope of the statutes. The act applies to all discretionary projects proposed to be conducted or approved by a California public agency, including private projects requiring discretionary government approval.
The overall purpose of CEQA is to disclose to the public the significant environmental effects of a proposed discretionary project through an Environmental Impact Report (EIR), prevent or minimize damage to the environment through development of project alternatives, enhance public participation in the environmental review process through scoping meetings, public notice, public review, hearings, and the judicial process, and improve interagency coordination through early consultations, scoping meetings, notices of preparation, and State Clearinghouse review.
Under CEQA, projects carried out by public agencies are subject to the same level of review as private projects requiring approval by public agencies. The intent is to ensure that no project that would cause significant environmental effects shall be approved as proposed if there are feasible alternatives or mitigation measures that would lessen those effects. Lastly, local agencies are encouraged to integrate CEQA with other environmental review, planning, and information gathering so as to cut costs and time and to apply the conservation of financial, governmental, physical, and social resources towards better mitigation.
- At what point during the life of a project must an agency show CEQA compliance? An agency with a project subject to CEQA must complete an EIR before “committing” to the project. The point at which an agency is committed to a project is not precisely defined in statute. The courts have ruled that the degree to which a lead agency commits to a proposed project, taking into account the surrounding facts and context, ultimately determines when an EIR must be completed for CEQA compliance purposes.
In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood (2008) 45 Cal.4th 116, the California Supreme Court stated the following about when an agency has shown project commitment:
“When an agency has not only expressed its inclination to favor a project, but has increased the political stakes by publically defending it over objections, putting its official weight behind it, devoting substantial public resources to it, and announcing a detailed agreement to go forward with the project, the agency will not be easily deterred from taking whatever steps remain toward the project’s final approval.”
- Can a school district enter a design-build contract before demonstrating California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) compliance? Central to this bill is the question of whether or not a school district can enter into a design-build contract prior to showing compliance with the CEQA. Some have argued yes, as long as the contract is conditional on CEQA compliance being obtained. In Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood, the Court affirmed the importance of considering the surrounding facts and context of the project under contract, stating:
“A CEQA compliance condition can be a legitimate ingredient in a preliminary public-private agreement for exploration of a proposed project, but if the agreement, viewed in light of all the surrounding circumstances commits the public agency as a practical matter to the project, the simple insertion of a CEQA compliance condition will not save the agreement from being considered an approval requiring prior environmental review.”
Given the court’s statement, it appears that only on a case-by-case basis can it be known if executing a project contract will trigger the point at which an agency must show CEQA compliance.
- Existing law appears to pit design-build projects against CEQA’s chain of required events. CEQA law is ambiguous about when an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) showing CEQA compliance must be completed, and agencies have been sued for entering contract with project builders prior to completing an EIR. Design-build projects by definition combine project designers and builders into one contract, meaning no design functions can begin until a contract is executed. Therefore, there appears to be no way for school districts with design-build projects from avoiding a period of time when they are legally vulnerable under CEQA—the period of time between first entering the design-build contract and completing an EIR. According to sponsors of the bill, an EIR typically takes about one year to complete.
- This approach has merit, but why only apply it to Los Angeles Unified School District? This bill seeks to address a fundamental way in which design-build projects and CEQA may be misaligned. By codifying that a school district entering into a design-build contract for a project subject to CEQA retains the discretion to (1) terminate the contract before final project design submittal and (2) modify the project as needed pursuant to an EIR, and requiring design-build contracts to include these provisions, this bill would make it clear that simply entering into a design-build contract does not mean a district is “committed” to the project as defined by the California Supreme Court in Save Tara v. City of West Hollywood.
However, as currently drafted this bill would only apply to Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). According to the author, LAUSD is the only school district that is known to have been sued over a design-build project because of ambiguity within the statutes governing the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Even so, there could be other school districts that will face legal challenges moving forward or that currently opt out of design-build contracting for fear of legal recourse related to CEQA.
SUPPORT
Los Angeles Unified School District
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):