SB 86: Department of Pesticide Regulation: chlorpyrifos: quarterly reports.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-29
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 29, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 299, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 29, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 8, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Set for hearing August 30. |
| Aug 29, 2020 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on EQ. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). (Ayes 3. Noes 0. Page 4420.) Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Aug 27, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). |
| Aug 25, 2020 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 58. Noes 13. Page 5200.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 14. Noes 4.) (August 20). |
| Aug 11, 2020 | August 11 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 30, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (July 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | July 27 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Jul 8, 2020 | July 13 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 18, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | July 2 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 17, 2019 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 17). Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Jun 13, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 11, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| May 1, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 795.) (April 24). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 24, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 11, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 10. |
| Jan 10, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | Unfinished Business SB86 Durazo et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 25, 2020 | SB 86 Durazo Senate Third Reading By Friedman | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 30, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
|
| Jun 17, 2019 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Special Consent SB86 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 86
Author: | Durazo | ||
Version: | 7/27/2020 | Hearing Date: | 8/30/2020 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Maria Montchal | ||
SUBJECT: Department of Pesticide Regulation: chlorpyrifos: quarterly reports
DIGEST: Requires the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) to submit quarterly reports on chlorpyrifos use, monitoring, and exposure to specified committees in the legislature and the Office of the Surgeon General.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Regulates the use of pesticides and authorizes the director of DPR to adopt regulations to govern the possession, sale, or use of specified pesticides, as prescribed (Food and Agriculture Code. (FAC) §11501, et seq.)
- Requires the director to endeavor to eliminate from use in the state any pesticide that endangers the agricultural or nonagricultural environment, is not beneficial for the purposes for which it is sold, or is misrepresented. (FAC § 12824)
- Requires DPR to designate, control and regulate restricted materials found to meet specified criteria, including, but not limited to, danger of impairment to public health, as specified. Authorizes DPR to adopt regulations that prohibit the use or possession of a restricted material in certain areas or under certain conditions. (FAC § 14001 et seq.)
- Requires that, except as may be provided in regulations adopted by the director, a pesticide use report (PUR) be submitted to the county agricultural commissioner within seven days after each use of a restricted material. (FAC § 14011.5)
- Defines a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC) as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or an increase in serious illness, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. (FAC § 14021)
- Requires the director, in consultation with the Office of Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) and the State Air Resources Control Board (ARB), to evaluate, as specified, the health effects of pesticides that may be or are emitted into the ambient air of California and that may be determined to be a TAC that poses a present or potential threat to human health. (FAC § 14022(a))
- Requires the operator of the property which is producing an agricultural commodity to report the use of pesticides applied to the crop, commodity, or site to the agricultural commissioner of the county in which the pest control was performed by the 10th day of the month following the month in which the work was performed. Requires an agricultural pest control business to report the use of pesticides applied by it for the production of an agricultural commodity to the agricultural commissioner within seven days of completion of the pesticide application (3 California Code of Regulations. (CCR) 6626)
This bill:
- Requires DPR to prepare and submit quarterly reports due 60 days after the end of each quarter to the Senate Committee on Health, the Senate Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement, the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality, the Assembly Committee on Health, the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment, the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, and the Office of the Surgeon General that provide all of the following information:
- The location and amount of granular chlorpyrifos in pounds used during the quarter;
- Potential reasons for an increase or decrease in granular chlorpyrifos use compared to the same quarter of the previous year;
- A description of how the DPR monitors exposure to granular chlorpyrifos, with an emphasis on inhalation or exposure through the skin and any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
- The location and amount of granular chlorpyrifos in pounds used during the quarter;
- Makes findings about the health impacts of chlorpyrifos and the steps California has taken to regulate and monitor it.
Background
- Pesticidal uses of chlorpyrifos. Chlorpyrifos has been used as a pesticide since 1965 in both agricultural and non-agricultural areas. It is used on corn, soybeans, fruit and nut trees, brussels sprouts, cranberries, broccoli, and cauliflower, as well as other row crops. Non-agricultural uses include golf courses, turf, green houses, and on non-structural wood treatments such as utility poles and fence posts. It is also registered for use as a mosquito adulticide, and for use in roach and ant bait stations in child resistant packaging. Products are sold as liquids, granules, water dispersible granules, wettable powders, and water soluble packets, and may be applied by either ground or aerial equipment.
- Impacts on human health. According to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, breathing the air where chlorpyrifos has recently been sprayed may result in headaches, blurred vision, watering of the eyes, excessive salivation, runny nose, dizziness, confusion, muscle weakness or tremors, nausea, diarrhea, and sudden changes in heart rate. The effect depends on the amount in the air and exposure time. Ingesting chlorpyrifos may cause similar symptoms. DPR has cited recent research showing that chlorpyrifos is a developmental neurotoxin in children and sensitive populations.
- Environmental impacts. According to the National Pesticide Information Center, studies have found chlorpyrifos in soils for over one year following application. Soil persistence may depend on the formulation, rate of application, soil type, climate and other conditions.
According to a 2016 US EPA Chlorpyrifos Refined Drinking Water Risk Assessment, chlorpyrifos has not been detected in drinking water supplies, but potential for exposure exists. There are several reasons why chlorpyrifos may not have been detected in drinking water, including sample site location, sampling frequency, as well as drinking water treatment. It’s unclear if water samples taken to date are located in watersheds vulnerable to chlorpyrifos contamination. - State regulation of chlorpyrifos. In 2015, DPR designated chlorpyrifos as a restricted material. Restricted materials are pesticides deemed to have a higher potential to cause harm to public health, farm workers, domestic animals, honeybees, the environment, wildlife, or other crops compared to other pesticides. Only trained, licensed professionals with a permit from a local county agricultural commissioner may use products containing a restricted material.
In 2017, OEHHA listed chlorpyrifos as a chemical known to cause developmental toxicity under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), which requires the State of California to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity (Health and Safety Code § 25249.8).
In September 2018, following extensive scientific review and public comment, DPR proposed designating chlorpyrifos as a “toxic air contaminant” (TAC), which California law defines as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to increases in serious illness or death, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health.
DPR recommended that county agricultural commissioners begin implementing the interim measures on January 1, 2019 while it completed a formal regulatory process. The interim recommendations include: banning all aerial applications of chlorpyrifos; discontinuing its use on most crops; requiring a quarter-mile buffer zone during all allowed applications of the pesticide and for 24 hours afterwards; and, requiring a 150-foot setback from houses, businesses, schools and other sensitive sites at all times, regardless of whether the site is occupied at the time of application. - Listing chlorpyrifos as a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC). Following the interim action, DPR adopted an emergency regulation listing chlorpyrifos as a TAC effective on April 1, 2019. The listing of a TAC requires DPR to determine, in consultation with the OEHHA, ARB, and the air pollution control districts or air quality management districts in the affected counties, the need for and appropriate degree of control measures for chlorpyrifos. Within two years of the determination of the need for control measures, DPR was required to develop control measures in consultation with the county agricultural commissioners, air pollution control districts, and air quality management districts in the affected counties. The permanent control measures adopted will replace the current recommended interim permit conditions.
- Cancellation of registration of products containing chlorpyrifos. On May 8, 2019, the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) announced that DPR, "Is acting to prohibit the use of the pesticide and TAC chlorpyrifos in California by initiating cancellation of the pesticide." This decision is due to mounting evidence that chlorpyrifos causes serious health effects in children and other sensitive populations at lower levels than was previously understood. DPR and the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) established a cross-sector working group to identify, evaluate, and recommend safer, more sustainable pest management alternatives to chlorpyrifos.
On August 14, 2019, DPR initiated cancellation proceedings regarding pesticide products containing the active ingredient chlorpyrifos and announced that chlorpyrifos product registrations will be made "inactive" on or before January 1, 2020. They announced, however, that the products are subject to existing stock provisions that allow for limited continued use and sale beyond that date.
On October 9, 2019, CalEPA announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020 following an agreement between DPR and pesticide manufacturers to withdraw their products. The CalEPA announcement notes that under the settlement, the companies agreed that sales of chlorpyrifos to growers in California will end on February 6, 2020, that growers will not be allowed to possess or use chlorpyrifos products in California after December 31, 2020, and until then all uses must comply with existing restrictions. These restrictions include a ban on aerial spraying, quarter-mile buffer zones, and limiting use to crop-pest combinations that lack alternatives. DPR will support aggressive enforcement of these restrictions. The development of safe, more sustainable alternatives to chlorpyrifos is being supported through the current state budget, which appropriates more than $5 million in grant funding for the purpose. - Federal Regulation of chlorpyrifos. While the US EPA made label changes and took other actions on chlorpyrifos over the years, most recently, in October 2015, under the Obama administration, the US EPA proposed to revoke all food residue tolerances for chlorpyrifos. Because tolerances are the maximum residue of a pesticide that can be in or on food, the proposed rule revoking all chlorpyrifos tolerances means that if this approach had been finalized, all agricultural uses of chlorpyrifos in the United States would have ceased.
In March 2017, under the Trump administration, the US EPA denied a petition that asked it to revoke all pesticide tolerances (maximum residue levels in food) for chlorpyrifos and cancel all chlorpyrifos registrations. The US EPA concluded that the science addressing neurodevelopmental effects remained unresolved and further research was needed. In rejecting the petition, the US EPA Administrator took what is known as a "final agency action" on the question of the safety and use of chlorpyrifos, suggesting that the matter would not likely be revisited until October 2022 when US EPA is formally required to re-evaluate the safety of the pesticide.
Currently, chlorpyrifos remains registered as it undergoes registration review, a program that re-evaluates all pesticides on a 15-year cycle. Registration review ensures pesticides will not cause unreasonable adverse effects when used according to label directions and precautions and that there is a reasonable certainty of no harm from dietary and residential exposure. - Chlorpyrifos in granular form. When CalEPA announced on October 9, 2019, that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020, it also stated, "A few products that apply chlorpyrifos in granular form, representing less than one percent of agricultural use of chlorpyrifos, will be allowed to remain on the market. These products are not associated with detrimental health effects. DPR will continue to monitor for any exposures associated with these products."
While initially evaluating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, DPR evaluated inhalation and exposure through skin in the context of "bystanders." This evaluation did not find that chlorpyrifos in granular form offgassed or left a residue on food crops. However, DPR did not assess occupational exposure to granular chlorpyrifos during the TAC process. Because it is a restricted material, application of granular chlorpyrifos requires a permit from the county agricultural commissioner, a recommendation by a licensed pest control advisor, and supervision by a licensed certified applicator. - Pesticide Use Reports. California's pesticide use reporting program is recognized as the most comprehensive in the world. In 1990, California became the first state to require full reporting of agricultural pesticide use in response to demands for more realistic and comprehensive pesticide use data. Under the program, all agricultural pesticide use must be reported monthly to county agricultural commissioners, who in turn, report the data to DPR.
Under the program, all agricultural pesticide use must be reported within seven days to county agricultural commissioners, who in turn report the data to DPR within one calendar month. Statute requires the director to summarize the contents of these PURs quarterly as to the type of material and amounts, and requires the summaries to be made a public record.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Scientists from the U.S. EPA have determined that the handling of chlorpyrifos in granular form results in unsafe levels of exposure to farmworkers, even when farmworkers follow all of the directions on chlorpyrifos labels, wear personal protective equipment, and use engineering controls. California continues to allow use of granular pesticides containing chlorpyrifos, despite the substantial risk these products present to farmworkers, children, and mothers.
“DPR has one of the most comprehensive data gathering tools in the nation that includes data gathering at the local level and at the state level. Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be incorporated into the existing data gathering infrastructure and the information provided to the Legislature.”
- Referral to the Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10. SB 86 was originally introduced by Senator Durazo on January 10, 2019, as a measure addressing school safety.
On July 27, 2020, Assembly amendments changed the subject of the bill to require DPR to submit quarterly reports on granular chlorpyrifos use to specified committees in the Legislature and to the Office of the Surgeon General. The measure passed the Assembly Floor on August 25, 2020 by a vote of 58-13.
Consistent with Senate Rule 29.10 the Senate Rules Committee has referred the amended bill to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee for a hearing of the Assembly amendments.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 458 (Durazo, 2019) would have outlawed the use of pesticides containing chlorpyrifos until DPR issued control measures that are protective of children’s neurological development. This bill died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SOURCE:
American Academy of Pediatrics, California;
Earthjustice; United Farm Workers (co-sponsors)
SUPPORT:
Anahuak Youth Sports Association
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians for Pesticide Reform
Community Nature Connection
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
Environmental Working Group
Friends of The L.A. River
From Lot to Spot
Heal the Bay
Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Mujeres De La Tierra
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Pacoima Beautiful
Pesticide Action Network North America
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Prevention Institute
Sierra Club California
Urban Semillas
OPPOSITION:
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Chemistry Council
American Pistachio Growers
California Association of Pest Control Advisers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, INC.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California League of Food Producers
California Seed Association
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Nisei Farmers League
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Plant Health Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to Earthjustice, a co-sponsor, “Granular uses of chlorpyrifos are unsafe for workers. In the 2016 Risk Assessment, USEPA assessed work scenarios involving granular formulations of chlorpyrifos. The Risk Assessment found that combined dermal and inhalation exposures exceeded the level USEPA determined was safe for workers even when maximal personal protective equipment or engineering controls were assumed. Moreover, the granular half-life of this chemical, depending on the type of soil and conditions can last on aerobic soil between 11 to 180 days. The hazards of granular dust particles also pose a problem as they can adhere to work clothes. While washing may remove some of the residue, when clothes are incompletely cleaned and clothing comes in contact with skin the pesticide residue can be absorbed into the body. It is important to monitor the use of granular products of chlorpyrifos as the chemical remains dangerous as long as it is allowed to be in use.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the California Chamber of Commerce, “The findings in SB 86 are misleading as they do not acknowledge the work DPR has done to mitigate the risk of granular chlorpyrifos use or the differences between granular chlorpyrifos and chlorpyrifos applied through ground spray and aerial application. The findings of SB 86 claim that the use of granular chlorpyrifos results in unsafe levels of exposure to farm workers; can be found on food as a residue; and is tracked home by parents and siblings, which in
turn impact young children. These insinuations of danger are untrue and do not consider the facts and scientific studies conducted by DPR… Further, granular chlorpyrifos is different than other forms of chlorpyrifos in several ways. Granules are not saturated with chlorpyrifos, but coated in a mixture that helps fix the product to the granule. The active ingredient in granular chlorpyrifos is from 15% down to 2.5%, the balance being made up of inert ingredients resulting in a much lower active ingredient concentration.”
-- END --
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 86 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 86
Author: Durazo (D), et al.
Amended: 7/27/20
Vote: 21
PRIOR SENATE VOTES NOT RELEVANT
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-13, 8/25/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Department of Pesticide Regulation: chlorpyrifos: quarterly reports
SOURCE: American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Earthjustice
United Farm Workers
DIGEST:
This bill requires the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) to submit quarterly reports on chlorpyrifos use, monitoring, and exposure to specified committees in the legislature and the Office of the Surgeon General.
Assembly Amendments
delete the previous contents of the bill as it was passed in the Senate and do the following: require DPR to submit quarterly reports 60 days after the end of each quarter to the Legislature, containing information on the location and amount of granular chlorpyrifos use, potential reasons for changes in granular chlorpyrifos use compared to the previous year, and a description of how DPR monitors granular chlorpyrifos use, as specified; and make findings about the health impacts of chlorpyrifos and the steps California has taken to regulate and monitor it.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Regulates the use of pesticides and authorizes the Director of DPR (Director) to adopt regulations to govern the possession, sale, or use of specified pesticides, as prescribed. (Food and Agriculture Code. (FAC) §11501, et seq.)
- Requires the Director to endeavor to eliminate from use in the state any pesticide that endangers the agricultural or nonagricultural environment, is not beneficial for the purposes for which it is sold, or is misrepresented. (FAC § 12824)
- Requires DPR to designate, control and regulate restricted materials found to meet specified criteria, including, but not limited to, danger of impairment to public health, as specified. Authorizes DPR to adopt regulations that prohibit the use or possession of a restricted material in certain areas or under certain conditions. (FAC § 14001 et seq.)
- Requires that, except as may be provided in regulations adopted by the Director, a pesticide use report (PUR) be submitted to the county agricultural commissioner within seven days after each use of a restricted material. (FAC § 14011.5)
- Defines a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC) as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or an increase in serious illness, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. (FAC § 14021)
- Requires the Director, in consultation with the Office of Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) and the State Air Resources Control Board (ARB), to evaluate, as specified, the health effects of pesticides that may be or are emitted into the ambient air of California and that may be determined to be a TAC that poses a present or potential threat to human health. (FAC § 14022(a))
- Requires the operator of the property which is producing an agricultural commodity to report the use of pesticides applied to the crop, commodity, or site to the agricultural commissioner of the county in which the pest control was performed by the 10th day of the month following the month in which the work was performed. Requires an agricultural pest control business to report the use of pesticides applied by it for the production of an agricultural commodity to the agricultural commissioner within seven days of completion of the pesticide application (3 California Code of Regulations. (CCR) 6626)
This bill:
- Requires DPR to prepare and submit quarterly reports due 60 days after the end of each quarter to the Senate Committee on Health, the Senate Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement, the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality, the Assembly Committee on Health, the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment, the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, and the Office of the Surgeon General that provide all of the following information:
- The location and amount of granular chlorpyrifos in pounds used during the quarter;
- Potential reasons for an increase or decrease in granular chlorpyrifos use compared to the same quarter of the previous year; and
- A description of how the DPR monitors exposure to granular chlorpyrifos, with an emphasis on inhalation or exposure through the skin and any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
- Makes findings about the health impacts of chlorpyrifos and the steps California has taken to regulate and monitor it.
Background
- Pesticidal uses of chlorpyrifos. Chlorpyrifos has been used as a pesticide since 1965 in both agricultural and non-agricultural areas. It is used on corn, soybeans, fruit and nut trees, brussels sprouts, cranberries, broccoli, and cauliflower, as well as other row crops. Non-agricultural uses include golf courses, turf, green houses, and on non-structural wood treatments such as utility poles and fence posts. It is also registered for use as a mosquito adulticide, and for use in roach and ant bait stations in child resistant packaging. Products are sold as liquids, granules, water dispersible granules, wettable powders, and water soluble packets, and may be applied by either ground or aerial equipment.
- Impacts on human health. According to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, breathing the air where chlorpyrifos has recently been sprayed may result in headaches, blurred vision, watering of the eyes, excessive salivation, runny nose, dizziness, confusion, muscle weakness or tremors, nausea, diarrhea, and sudden changes in heart rate. The effect depends on the amount in the air and exposure time. Ingesting chlorpyrifos may cause similar symptoms. DPR has cited recent research showing that chlorpyrifos is a developmental neurotoxin in children and sensitive populations.
- Environmental impacts. According to the National Pesticide Information Center, studies have found chlorpyrifos in soils for over one year following application. Soil persistence may depend on the formulation, rate of application, soil type, climate and other conditions.
According to a 2016 US EPA Chlorpyrifos Refined Drinking Water Risk Assessment, chlorpyrifos has not been detected in drinking water supplies, but potential for exposure exists. There are several reasons why chlorpyrifos may not have been detected in drinking water, including sample site location, sampling frequency, as well as drinking water treatment. It’s unclear if water samples taken to date are located in watersheds vulnerable to chlorpyrifos contamination.
- State regulation of chlorpyrifos. In 2015, DPR designated chlorpyrifos as a restricted material. Restricted materials are pesticides deemed to have a higher potential to cause harm to public health, farm workers, domestic animals, honeybees, the environment, wildlife, or other crops compared to other pesticides. Only trained, licensed professionals with a permit from a local county agricultural commissioner may use products containing a restricted material.
In 2017, OEHHA listed chlorpyrifos as a chemical known to cause developmental toxicity under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), which requires the State of California to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity (Health and Safety Code § 25249.8).
In September 2018, following extensive scientific review and public comment, DPR proposed designating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, which California law defines as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to increases in serious illness or death, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health.
DPR recommended that county agricultural commissioners begin implementing the interim measures on January 1, 2019, while it completed a formal regulatory process. The interim recommendations include: banning all aerial applications of chlorpyrifos; discontinuing its use on most crops; requiring a quarter-mile buffer zone during all allowed applications of the pesticide and for 24 hours afterwards; and, requiring a 150-foot setback from houses, businesses, schools and other sensitive sites at all times, regardless of whether the site is occupied at the time of application.
- Listing chlorpyrifos as a TAC. Following the interim action, DPR adopted an emergency regulation listing chlorpyrifos as a TAC effective on April 1, 2019. The listing of a TAC requires DPR to determine, in consultation with the OEHHA, ARB, and the air pollution control districts or air quality management districts in the affected counties, the need for an appropriate degree of control measures for chlorpyrifos. Within two years of the determination of the need for control measures, DPR was required to develop control measures in consultation with the county agricultural commissioners, air pollution control districts, and air quality management districts in the affected counties. The permanent control measures adopted will replace the current recommended interim permit conditions.
- Cancellation of registration of products containing chlorpyrifos. On May 8, 2019, the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) announced that DPR, "Is acting to prohibit the use of the pesticide and TAC chlorpyrifos in California by initiating cancellation of the pesticide." This decision is due to mounting evidence that chlorpyrifos causes serious health effects in children and other sensitive populations at lower levels than was previously understood. DPR and the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) established a cross-sector working group to identify, evaluate, and recommend safer, more sustainable pest management alternatives to chlorpyrifos.
On August 14, 2019, DPR initiated cancellation proceedings regarding pesticide products containing the active ingredient chlorpyrifos and announced that chlorpyrifos product registrations will be made "inactive" on or before January 1, 2020. They announced, however, that the products are subject to existing stock provisions that allow for limited continued use and sale beyond that date.
On October 9, 2019, CalEPA announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020 following an agreement between DPR and pesticide manufacturers to withdraw their products. The CalEPA announcement notes that under the settlement, the companies agreed that sales of chlorpyrifos to growers in California will end on February 6, 2020, that growers will not be allowed to possess or use chlorpyrifos products in California after December 31, 2020, and until then all uses must comply with existing restrictions. These restrictions include a ban on aerial spraying, quarter-mile buffer zones, and limiting use to crop-pest combinations that lack alternatives. DPR will support aggressive enforcement of these restrictions. The development of safe, more sustainable alternatives to chlorpyrifos is being supported through the current state budget, which appropriates more than $5 million in grant funding for the purpose.
- Federal Regulation of chlorpyrifos. While the US EPA made label changes and took other actions on chlorpyrifos over the years, most recently, in October 2015, under the Obama administration, the US EPA proposed to revoke all food residue tolerances for chlorpyrifos. Because tolerances are the maximum residue of a pesticide that can be in or on food, the proposed rule revoking all chlorpyrifos tolerances means that if this approach had been finalized, all agricultural uses of chlorpyrifos in the United States would have ceased.
In March 2017, under the Trump administration, the US EPA denied a petition that asked it to revoke all pesticide tolerances (maximum residue levels in food) for chlorpyrifos and cancel all chlorpyrifos registrations. The US EPA concluded that the science addressing neurodevelopmental effects remained unresolved and further research was needed. In rejecting the petition, the US EPA Administrator took what is known as a "final agency action" on the question of the safety and use of chlorpyrifos, suggesting that the matter would not likely be revisited until October 2022 when US EPA is formally required to re-evaluate the safety of the pesticide.
Currently, chlorpyrifos remains registered as it undergoes registration review, a program that re-evaluates all pesticides on a 15-year cycle. Registration review ensures pesticides will not cause unreasonable adverse effects when used according to label directions and precautions and that there is a reasonable certainty of no harm from dietary and residential exposure.
- Chlorpyrifos in granular form. When CalEPA announced on October 9, 2019, that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020, it also stated, "A few products that apply chlorpyrifos in granular form, representing less than one percent of agricultural use of chlorpyrifos, will be allowed to remain on the market. These products are not associated with detrimental health effects. DPR will continue to monitor for any exposures associated with these products."
While initially evaluating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, DPR evaluated inhalation and exposure through skin in the context of "bystanders." This evaluation did not find that chlorpyrifos in granular form offgassed or left a residue on food crops. However, DPR did not assess occupational exposure to granular chlorpyrifos during the TAC process. Because it is a restricted material, application of granular chlorpyrifos requires a permit from the county agricultural commissioner, a recommendation by a licensed pest control advisor, and supervision by a licensed certified applicator.
- Pesticide Use Reports. California's pesticide use reporting program is recognized as the most comprehensive in the world. In 1990, California became the first state to require full reporting of agricultural pesticide use in response to demands for more realistic and comprehensive pesticide use data. Under the program, all agricultural pesticide use must be reported monthly to county agricultural commissioners, who in turn, report the data to DPR.
Under the program, all agricultural pesticide use must be reported within seven days to county agricultural commissioners, who in turn report the data to DPR within one calendar month. Statute requires the director to summarize the contents of these PURs quarterly as to the type of material and amounts, and requires the summaries to be made a public record.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Scientists from the U.S. EPA have determined that the handling of chlorpyrifos in granular form results in unsafe levels of exposure to farmworkers, even when farmworkers follow all of the directions on chlorpyrifos labels, wear personal protective equipment, and use engineering controls. California continues to allow use of granular pesticides containing chlorpyrifos, despite the substantial risk these products present to farmworkers, children, and mothers.
“DPR has one of the most comprehensive data gathering tools in the nation that includes data gathering at the local level and at the state level. Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be incorporated into the existing data gathering infrastructure and the information provided to the Legislature.”
- Referral to the Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10. SB 86 was originally introduced by Senator Durazo on January 10, 2019, as a measure addressing school safety.
On July 27, 2020, Assembly amendments changed the subject of the bill to require DPR to submit quarterly reports on granular chlorpyrifos use to specified committees in the Legislature and to the Office of the Surgeon General. The measure passed the Assembly Floor on August 25, 2020, by a vote of 58-13.
Consistent with Senate Rule 29.10 the Senate Rules Committee has referred the amended bill to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee for a hearing of the Assembly amendments.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 458 (Durazo, 2019) would have outlawed the use of pesticides containing chlorpyrifos until DPR issued control measures that are protective of children’s neurological development. The bill died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill would, according to DPR, result in annual quarterly reporting costs of approximately $340,000 (DPR fund). DPR indicates additional staff time will be necessary to create the analyses and opinions of multiple staff and outside experts to determine potential reasons for change in use and potential exposure, two requirements not currently included in the existing quarterly report.
According to DPR, County Agricultural Commissioners’ costs would likely increase and absent additional funding, Commissioners would need to reprioritize their resources or make additional claims on the DPR fund.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/30/20)
American Academy of Pediatrics, California (co-source)
Earthjustice (co-source)
United Farm Workers (co-source)
Anahuak Youth Sports Association
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians for Pesticide Reform
Community Nature Connection
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
Environmental Working Group
Friends of the LA River
From Lot to Spot
Heal the Bay
Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Mujeres De LA Tierra
Natural Resources Defense Council
Pacoima Beautiful
Pesticide Action Network North America
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Prevention Institute
Sierra Club
Urban Semillas
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/20)
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Chemistry Council
American Pistachio Growers
California Association of Pest Control Advisers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California League of Food Producers
California Seed Association
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Nisei Farmers League
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Plant Health Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to Earthjustice, a co-sponsor, “Granular uses of chlorpyrifos are unsafe for workers. In the 2016 Risk Assessment, USEPA assessed work scenarios involving granular formulations of chlorpyrifos. The Risk Assessment found that combined dermal and inhalation exposures exceeded the level USEPA determined was safe for workers even when maximal personal protective equipment or engineering controls were assumed. Moreover, the granular half-life of this chemical, depending on the type of soil and conditions can last on aerobic soil between 11 to 180 days. The hazards of granular dust particles also pose a problem as they can adhere to work clothes. While washing may remove some of the residue, when clothes are incompletely cleaned and clothing comes in contact with skin the pesticide residue can be absorbed into the body. It is important to monitor the use of granular products of chlorpyrifos as the chemical remains dangerous as long as it is allowed to be in use.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Chamber of Commerce, “The findings in SB 86 are misleading as they do not acknowledge the work DPR has done to mitigate the risk of granular chlorpyrifos use or the differences between granular chlorpyrifos and chlorpyrifos applied through ground spray and aerial application. The findings of SB 86 claim that the use of granular chlorpyrifos results in unsafe levels of exposure to farm workers; can be found on food as a residue; and is tracked home by parents and siblings, which in turn impact young children. These insinuations of danger are untrue and do not consider the facts and scientific studies conducted by DPR… Further, granular chlorpyrifos is different than other forms of chlorpyrifos in several ways. Granules are not saturated with chlorpyrifos, but coated in a mixture that helps fix the product to the granule. The active ingredient in granular chlorpyrifos is from 15% down to 2.5%, the balance being made up of inert ingredients resulting in a much lower active ingredient concentration.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-13, 8/25/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Berman, Chen, Cooper, Frazier, Gray, Mayes, McCarty, Wicks
Prepared by: Maria Montchal / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/30/20 18:15:56
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 86
Author:(Durazo)
As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) to submit a quarterly report, as specified, on the use of the pesticide, chlorpyrifos, in granular form.
Major Provisions
- Makes legislative findings about the hazards posed by exposure to chlorpyrifos and about the process California has taken to regulate and monitor the pesticide.
- Requires DPR, beginning with the first quarter of 2021, to prepare and submit quarterly reports, due sixty days after the end of each quarter, to specified Senate and Assembly Committees and the Office of the Surgeon General.
- Requires that the report provide all of the following information:
- The amount of chlorpyrifos in granular form used during the quarter, reported in pounds and by location of use;
- Potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year; and,
- A description of how DPR monitors exposure to the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form with a particular emphasis on dermal and inhalation exposure, and any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
COMMENTS:
Chlorpyrifos: Chlorpyrifos is an insecticide, acaricide, and miticide used primarily to control foliage and soil-borne insect pests on a variety of food and feed crops. Chlorpyrifos is an organophosphate that inhibits the functioning of the nervous system (acetylcholinesterase inhibition). This is how it kills insects. Acute exposure can have similar effects on humans (sweating, salivation, vomiting, low blood pressure and heart rate, seizures, and death). Recent research has shown that chlorpyrifos is also a developmental neurotoxin in children and sensitive populations, and that the threshold for chlorpyrifos-induced neurodevelopmental effects is approximately 10-fold lower than the threshold for acetylcholinesterase inhibition. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, California, "Chlorpyrifos is highly toxic, with demonstrated severe health effects far below current average exposure levels."
Chlorpyrifos use in California: Following extensive scientific review; public comment; and, prior regulatory action designating chlorpyrifos as a restricted material, listing chlorpyrifos as a chemical known to cause developmental toxicity under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), and listing chlorpyrifos as a toxic air contaminant (TAC), on October 9, 2019, the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020 following an agreement between DPR and pesticide manufacturers to withdraw their products. Under the settlement, the companies agreed that all sales of chlorpyrifos products to growers in California will end on February 6, 2020; and, growers will no longer be allowed to possess or use chlorpyrifos products in California after December 31, 2020.
Chlorpyrifos in granular form: When CalEPA announced the end of the use of most chlorpyrifos in California, it also stated, "A few products that apply chlorpyrifos in granular form, representing less than one percent of agricultural use of chlorpyrifos, will be allowed to remain on the market. These products are not associated with detrimental health effects. DPR will continue to monitor for any exposures associated with these products."
While initially evaluating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, DPR evaluated inhalation and dermal exposure in the context of "bystanders." This evaluation did not find that chlorpyrifos in granular form offgassed or left a residue on food crops. DPR did not assess occupational exposure to granular chlorpyrifos during the TAC process.
This bill requires DPR to prepare and submit quarterly reports about the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form to specified California Senate and Assembly Committees and to the Office of the Surgeon General.
According to the Author:
"SB 86 protects the health of children and frontline communities from the brain-toxic pesticide chlorpyrifos… Scientists from the U.S. EPA have determined that the handling of chlorpyrifos in granular form results in unsafe levels of exposure to farmworkers, even when farmworkers follow all of the directions on chlorpyrifos labels, wear personal protective equipment, and use engineering controls. California continues to allow use of granular pesticides containing chlorpyrifos, despite the substantial risk these products present to farmworkers, children, and mothers… Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be incorporated into the existing data gathering infrastructure and the information provided to the Legislature."
Arguments in Support:
According to Earthjustice, "SB 86 [is] a bill that will provide important information to the Legislature on granular products of chlorpyrifos that remain available for use in California. The oversight function of the Legislature has come into sharper focus especially this year. Protecting public health of farmworkers and frontline communities is an essential function of state government. The data submitted to the legislature under SB 86 will empower the policy committees to track the use of granular uses of chlorpyrifos and its health impacts on farmworkers… It is important to monitor the use of granular products of chlorpyrifos as the chemical remains dangerous as long as it is allowed to be in use."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to a coalition of opponents, "Our organizations do not oppose information on granular chlorpyrifos use being made available to the Legislature and public. However, this bill is unnecessary as [DPR] reports this data annually. Further, we are opposed to the findings of the bill as they are misleading and mischaracterize both the use and risk of granular chlorpyrifos… DPR already compiles an annual use report for all pesticides in California and quarterly reporting would result in unnecessary costs… The findings in SB 86 are misleading as they do not acknowledge the work DPR has done to mitigate the risk of granular chlorpyrifos use or the differences between granular chlorpyrifos and chlorpyrifos applied through ground spray and aerial application…"
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, DPR states that, should this bill be enacted, the annual costs of quarterly reporting will be approximately $340,000 (DPR fund). DPR indicates additional staff time will be necessary to create the analyses and to solicit opinions of multiple staff and outside experts to determine potential reasons for change in use and potential exposure, two requirements not currently included in the existing quarterly report. DPR also states that County Agricultural Commissioners' costs would likely increase, and absent additional funding, Commissioners would need to reprioritize their resources or make additional claims on the DPR fund.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM RULES: 11-0-1
YES: Cooley, Carrillo, Flora, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove, Maienschein, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Robert Rivas, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cunningham
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 7-2-0
YES: Quirk, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi, Obernolte
NO: Flora, Mathis
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-4-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Megan Dahle, Fong, Voepel
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 27, 2020
CONSULTANT: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003221
Date of Hearing: August 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 86
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) to submit a quarterly report to the Legislature and Office of the Surgeon General on the use of the granular form of the pesticide chlorpyrifos. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires DPR, beginning with the first quarter of 2021, to prepare and submit reports, due sixty days after the end of each quarter, to specified Assembly and Senate committees and the Office of the Surgeon General.
- Requires the report to include the following information:
- The amount of chlorpyrifos in granular form used during the quarter, reported in pounds and by location of use.
- Potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year.
- A description of how DPR monitors exposure to the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form with a particular emphasis on dermal and inhalation exposure, and any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
- Makes various legislative findings.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to DPR, the annual costs of quarterly reporting will be approximately $340,000 (DPR fund). DPR indicates additional staff time will be necessary to create the analyses and opinions of multiple staff and outside experts to determine potential reasons for change in use and potential exposure, two requirements not currently included in the existing quarterly report.
According to DPR, County Agricultural Commissioners’ costs would likely increase and absent additional funding, Commissioners would need to reprioritize their resources or make additional claims on the DPR fund.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, DPR has one of the most comprehensive data gathering tools in the nation that includes data gathering at the local level and at the state level. The author states, “Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be incorporated into the existing data gathering to provide that information.”
- Background. Chlorpyrifos is used primarily to control foliage and soil-borne insect pests on a variety of food and feed crops, however, it has been used as a pesticide since 1965 in both agricultural and non-agricultural areas. On October 9, 2019, CalEPA announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020 following an agreement between DPR and pesticide manufacturers to withdraw their products. The CalEPA announcement notes that under the settlement, the companies agreed that:
- All sales of chlorpyrifos products to growers in California will end on February 6, 2020;
- Growers will no longer be allowed to possess or use chlorpyrifos products in California after December 31, 2020; and,
- Until then, all uses must comply with existing restrictions, including a ban on aerial spraying, quarter-mile buffer zones and limiting use to crop-pest combinations that lack alternatives. DPR will support aggressive enforcement of these restrictions.
When CalEPA announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020, it also stated, "A few products that apply chlorpyrifos in granular form, representing less than one percent of agricultural use of chlorpyrifos, will be allowed to remain on the market. These products are not associated with detrimental health effects. DPR will continue to monitor for any exposures associated with these products."
- Reporting. Current regulations require a pest control business to report a pesticide use report (PUR) to the County Agricultural Commissioner (Commissioner) within seven days of application and a property owner to report a PUR by the tenth day of the month following the month in which the work was performed. Statute requires Commissioners to submit the PURs it receives to DPR within one calendar month after they are received. DPR indicates that it then examines submitted PUR data, which is initially self-reported, to verify its accuracy for publication in the California Pesticide Information Portal (CalPIP) and in the annual PUR summary. It is likely the DPR Director’s current quarterly summaries do not verify the data received from the Commissioners, thus creating additional costs and creating a special status for this restricted chemical.
This bill also requires DPR to include in the report potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year; a description of how DPR monitors exposure to the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form with a particular emphasis on dermal and inhalation exposure; and, any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
It is unclear how DPR, as is required by the bill, would ascertain the potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year. If the author intends for DPR to check directly with applicators, growers, or county agricultural commissioners on the reasons for a change in the amount of chlorpyrifos used, instead of simply making an educated guess, she may wish to consider giving DPR additional time to complete this research.
According to DPR, this bill requires the department to cull through the various monitoring programs and pull out information specific to chlorpyrifos and report it quarterly. The committee may wish to consider whether this is the best use of resources and if it will provide better and more protective information to prevent dangerous chlorpyrifos exposure.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 30, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 86
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Department of Pesticide Regulation: chlorpyrifos: quarterly reports
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) to submit a quarterly report, as specified, on the use of the pesticide, chlorpyrifos, in granular form. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes legislative findings about the hazards posed by exposure to chlorpyrifos and about the process California has taken to regulate and monitor the pesticide.
- Requires DPR, beginning with the first quarter of 2021, to prepare and submit quarterly reports, due sixty days after the end of each quarter, to the Senate Committee on Health, the Senate Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement, the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality, the Assembly Committee on Health, the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment, the Assembly Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials, and the Office of the Surgeon General.
- Requires that the report provide all of the following information:
- The amount of chlorpyrifos in granular form used during the quarter, reported in pounds and by location of use;
- Potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year; and,
- A description of how DPR monitors exposure to the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form with a particular emphasis on dermal and inhalation exposure, and any information relating to that exposure during the quarter.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates the use of pesticides and authorizes the director of DPR (director) to adopt regulations to govern the possession, sale, or use of specified pesticides, as prescribed. (Food and Agriculture Code (FAC) §11501, et. seq)
- Requires the director to endeavor to eliminate from use in the state any pesticide that endangers the agricultural or nonagricultural environment, is not beneficial for the purposes for which it is sold, or is misrepresented. (FAC § 12824)
- Authorizes, the director, after a hearing, to cancel the registration of, or refuse to register, any pesticide that fulfills these, among other, criteria:
- That has demonstrated serious uncontrollable adverse effects either within or outside the agricultural environment;
- The use of which is of less public value or greater detriment to the environment than the benefit received by its use;
- For which there is a reasonable, effective, and practicable alternate material or procedure that is demonstrably less destructive to the environment; or,
- That, when properly used, is detrimental to vegetation, except weeds, to domestic animals, or to the public health and safety. (FAC § 12825)
- Requires DPR to designate, control and regulate restricted materials found to meet specified criteria, including, but not limited to, danger of impairment to public health, hazard to applicators and farmworkers, and hazard to the environment. Authorizes DPR to adopt regulations that prohibit the use or possession of a restricted material that he or she finds and determines is injurious to the environment or to any person, animal, crop, or other property. (FAC § 14001, et. seq)
- Requires that, except as may be provided in regulations adopted by the director, a pesticide use report (PUR) be submitted to the county agricultural commissioner within seven days after each use of a restricted material. (FAC § 14011.5)
- Requires each county agricultural commissioner to submit to the director a copy of each PUR received, and any other relevant information the director may require. Requires that copies of the reports from the county agricultural commissioner be rendered to the director within one calendar month after they are received. (FAC § 14012 (b))
- Requires the director to summarize the contents of these PURs quarterly as to the type of material and amounts, and requires the summaries to be made a public record. Authorizes the director to publish or distribute the summaries. (FAC § 14012 (b))
- Defines a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC) as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or an increase in serious illness, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. (FAC § 14021)
- Requires the director, in consultation with the Office of Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) and the State Air Resources Control Board (ARB), to evaluate, as specified, the health effects of pesticides that may be or are emitted into the ambient air of California and that may be determined to be a TAC that poses a present or potential threat to human health. (FAC § 14022)
- Requires the director to determine, in consultation with OEHHA, the ARB, and the air pollution control districts or air quality management districts in the affected counties, the need for and appropriate degree of control measures for each pesticide listed as a TAC. (FAC § 14023 (e))
- Requires, for pesticides determined to need control measures, the director, in consultation with the agricultural commissioners, air pollution control districts and air quality management districts in the affected counties, to develop control measures designed to reduce emissions sufficiently so that the source will not expose the public to the levels of exposure that may cause or contribute to significant adverse health effects. (FAC § 14024 (a))
- Requires, if no demonstrable safe level or threshold of significant adverse health effects has been established by the director, the control measures to be designed to adequately prevent an endangerment of public health through the application of best practicable control techniques, which include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Label amendments;
- Applicator training;
- Restrictions on use patterns or locations;
- Changes in application procedures;
- Reclassification as a restricted material; and,
- Cancellation. (FAC § 14024 (a) – (b))
- Requires the operator of the property which is producing an agricultural commodity to report the use of pesticides applied to the crop, commodity, or site to the agricultural commissioner of the county in which the pest control was performed by the 10th day of the month following the month in which the work was performed. (3 California Code of Regulations (CCR) 6626 (a))
- Requires an agricultural pest control business to report the use of pesticides applied by it for the production of an agricultural commodity to the agricultural commissioner of the county in which the pest control was performed within seven days of completion of the pesticide application. (3 California Code of Regulations (CCR) 6626 (b))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author,
"SB 86 would require DPR to submit quarterly reports to legislative committees that provide information on the amount of chlorpyrifos use in granular form and the department’s plans for monitoring the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form. SB 86 protects the health of children and frontline communities from the brain-toxic pesticide chlorpyrifos.
Chlorpyrifos in granular form consists of granules either coated or saturated with chlorpyrifos. Chlorpyrifos in granular form takes longer to break down in the environment than it takes to break down in liquid form. Chlorpyrifos in granular form may persist in the environment for as long as 180 days.
Scientists from the U.S. EPA have determined that the handling of chlorpyrifos in granular form results in unsafe levels of exposure to farmworkers, even when farmworkers follow all of the directions on chlorpyrifos labels, wear personal protective equipment, and use engineering controls. California continues to allow use of granular pesticides containing chlorpyrifos, despite the substantial risk these products present to farmworkers, children, and mothers.
DPR has one of the most comprehensive data gathering tools in the nation that includes data gathering at the local level and at the state level. Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be incorporated into the existing data gathering infrastructure and the information provided to the Legislature."
Chlorpyrifos uses: According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), chlorpyrifos is an organophosphate insecticide, acaricide, and miticide used primarily to control foliage and soil-borne insect pests on a variety of food and feed crops. Chlorpyrifos has been used as a pesticide since 1965 in both agricultural and non-agricultural areas. Nationwide, the largest agricultural market for chlorpyrifos in terms of total pounds of active ingredient is corn. It is also used on soybeans, fruit and nut trees, Brussels sprouts, cranberries, broccoli, and cauliflower, as well as other row crops. Non-agricultural uses include golf courses, turf, green houses, and on non-structural wood treatments such as utility poles and fence posts. Chlorpyrifos is also registered for use as a mosquito adulticide, and for use in roach and ant bait stations. Products are sold as liquids, granules, water dispersible granules, wettable powders, and water soluble packets, and may be applied by either ground or aerial equipment.
Chlorpyrifos concerns: Chlorpyrifos is an organophosphate that inhibits the functioning of the nervous system (acetylcholinesterase inhibition). This is how it kills insects. According to DPR, acute exposure can have similar effects on humans (sweating, salivation, vomiting, low blood pressure and heart rate, seizures, and death). DPR affirms that recent research has shown that chlorpyrifos is also a developmental neurotoxin in children and sensitive populations, and that the threshold for chlorpyrifos-induced neurodevelopmental effects is approximately 10-fold lower than the threshold for acetylcholinesterase inhibition. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, California, "Chlorpyrifos is highly toxic, with demonstrated severe health effects far below current average exposure levels."
In 2015, DPR designated chlorpyrifos as a restricted material. Restricted materials are pesticides deemed to have a higher potential to cause harm to public health, farm workers, domestic animals, honeybees, the environment, wildlife, or other crops compared to other pesticides. Only trained, licensed professionals with a permit from a local county agricultural commissioner may use products containing a restricted material.
In 2017, OEHHA listed chlorpyrifos as a chemical known to cause developmental toxicity under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), which requires the State of California to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity (Health and Safety Code § 25249.8).
California's pesticide program: DPR is vested with the authority to regulate the registration, sale, and use of pesticides in California and has a mission of protecting public health and the environment. This authority is derived from several laws that cover all aspects of pesticide use in all media: air; ground and surface water; food; and, in agricultural, industrial, institutional, occupational and home-and-garden settings. Statutory regulatory authority allows DPR to regulate application rates; ensure pesticide efficacy; designate pesticides as restricted materials; develop criteria to prevent unacceptable pesticide residues in food and water; license applicators and dealers; and, adopt rules to protect workers and the public from overexposure. This full exercise of DPR’s authority extends to the suspension or cancellation of a pesticide’s registration. Cancellation prohibits use of a pesticide after an administrative adjudicatory hearing.
Chlorpyrifos as a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC): DPR’s TAC program is one of several regulatory options DPR can use to control exposure to potentially hazardous airborne pesticides. The Legislature created the statutory framework for the evaluation and control of chemicals as TACs with the enactment of California's Toxic Air Contaminant Act (AB 1807, Tanner, Chapter 1047, Statutes of 1983). The statute defines TACs as air pollutants that may cause or contribute to increases in serious illness or death, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. DPR is responsible for the evaluation of pesticides as TACs.
In September 2018, following extensive scientific review and public comment, DPR proposed designating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, and on April 1, 2019, DPR finalized the listing of chlorpyrifos as a TAC.
DPR’s cancellation of the registration of products containing chlorpyrifos: On May 8, 2019, the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) announced that DPR, "Is acting to prohibit the use of the pesticide and TAC chlorpyrifos in California by initiating cancellation of the pesticide." According to CalEPA, "The decision to prohibit chlorpyrifos follows mounting evidence, including recent findings by the state’s independent Scientific Review Panel on [TACs], that the pesticide causes serious health effects in children and other sensitive populations at lower levels of exposure than previously understood. These effects include impaired brain and neurological development." CalEPA also announced at the time that the administration was convening a cross-sector working group to identify safer alternatives to avoid replacing chlorpyrifos with an equally harmful pesticide, and proposing the appropriation of $5.7 million in new funding in that year’s state budget to support the transition to safer, more sustainable alternatives.
On August 14, 2019, DPR initiated cancellation proceedings regarding pesticide products containing the active ingredient chlorpyrifos and announced that chlorpyrifos product registrations will be made "inactive" on or before January 1, 2020. They announced, however, that the products are subject to existing stock provisions that allow for limited continued use and sale beyond that date.
On October 9, 2019, CalEPA announced that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020 following an agreement between DPR and pesticide manufacturers to withdraw their products. The CalEPA announcement notes that under the settlement, the companies agreed that:
- All sales of chlorpyrifos products to growers in California will end on February 6, 2020;
- Growers will no longer be allowed to possess or use chlorpyrifos products in California after December 31, 2020; and,
- Until then, all uses must comply with existing restrictions, including a ban on aerial spraying, quarter-mile buffer zones and limiting use to crop-pest combinations that lack alternatives. DPR will support aggressive enforcement of these restrictions.
Chlorpyrifos in granular form: When CalEPA announced on October 9, 2019, that virtually all use of the pesticide chlorpyrifos in California will end in 2020, it also stated, "A few products that apply chlorpyrifos in granular form, representing less than one percent of agricultural use of chlorpyrifos, will be allowed to remain on the market. These products are not associated with detrimental health effects. DPR will continue to monitor for any exposures associated with these products."
While initially evaluating chlorpyrifos as a TAC, DPR evaluated inhalation and dermal exposure in the context of "bystanders." This evaluation did not find that chlorpyrifos in granular form offgassed or left a residue on food crops. DPR did not assess occupational exposure to granular chlorpyrifos during the TAC process. Because it is a restricted material, application of granular chlorpyrifos requires a permit from the county agricultural commissioner, a recommendation by a licensed pest control advisor, and supervision by a licensed certified applicator.
According to the author, "While the granular products may be used less frequently, they are not less dangerous for the farmworkers who are using them. In the 2016 Risk Assessment, US EPA assessed work scenarios involving granular formulations of chlorpyrifos, and found skin and inhalation exposures combined exceeded the level [US] EPA determined was safe for workers."
DPR provided the following data on the use of chlorpyrifos over the last five years in California (pounds per year applied).
Pounds of Chlorpyrifos Applied in CA per Year | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019* |
All formulations | 1,107,417 | 903,238 | 948,004 | 602,658 | 12,802 |
Granular formulations | 14,121 | 14,315 | 12,861 | 11,966 | 6,589 |
* 2019 data has not been finalized and may contain errors.
DPR reports that on average from 2016-2018, about 550 applications to apply granular chlorpyrifos were submitted per year, as reported through the PUR. In 2019 about half that were submitted.
Pesticide use reports in California: According to DPR, California's pesticide use reporting program is recognized as the most comprehensive in the world. In 1990, California became the first state to require full reporting of agricultural pesticide use in response to demands for more realistic and comprehensive pesticide use data. Under the program, all agricultural pesticide use must be reported within seven days to county agricultural commissioners, who in turn report the data to DPR within one calendar month. Statute requires the director to summarize the contents of these PURs quarterly as to the type of material and amounts, and requires the summaries to be made a public record.
DPR currently makes PUR information available to the public through its California Pesticide Information Portal (CalPIP), which includes a comprehensive database of all pesticide use reports, and through the Pesticide Use Annual Summary Reports, which includes annual data summaries, indexed by chemical or by commodity. These summaries include analyses of pesticide use trends, including the use of organophosphate pesticides, and are available from 1989 to present. The summaries take about a year and a half to publish because, DPR indicates, they scrutinize the self-reported PUR data to verify its accuracy.
DPR’s website states that, "DPR is currently reviewing CalPIP and the Pesticide Use Annual Summary Report to improve their utility and accessibility."
This bill requires DPR to prepare and submit quarterly reports, due sixty days after the end of each quarter, on the amount of chlorpyrifos in granular form used during the quarter to specified California Senate and Assembly Committees and to the Office of the Surgeon General. Current regulations require a pest control business to report a PUR to the county agricultural commissioner within seven days of application and a property owner to report a PUR by the tenth day of the month following the month in which the work was performed. Statute requires the county agricultural commissioner to submit the PURs it receives to DPR within one calendar month after they are received. DPR indicates that it then examines submitted PUR data, which is initially self-reported, to verify its accuracy for publication in CalPIP and in the annual PUR summary. This takes some time. The author may wish to consider extending the timeframe by which DPR must submit the report to allow for data to be received and verified by DPR for accuracy.
This bill also requires DPR to include in the report potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year; a description of how DPR monitors exposure to the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form with a particular emphasis on dermal and inhalation exposure; and, any information relating to that exposure during the quarter. It is unclear how DPR, as is required by the bill, would ascertain the potential reasons for any increase or decrease in the use of chlorpyrifos in granular form in the quarter as compared to the same quarter of the previous year. If the author intends for DPR to check directly with applicators, growers, or county agricultural commissioners on the reasons for a change in the amount of chlorpyrifos used, instead of simply making an educated guess, she may wish to consider giving DPR additional time to complete this research.
Federal action on chlorpyrifos: Federal regulatory action on chlorpyrifos stretches back about two decades, when, in 2000, the US EPA finalized chlorpyrifos risk assessments for re-registration and identified the need to address health and environmental risks from chlorpyrifos exposure. At that time, the registrants of chlorpyrifos voluntarily entered into an agreement with US EPA to eliminate, phase out, and modify certain uses. The agreement included eliminating most homeowner uses of chlorpyrifos, except ant and roach baits in child resistant packaging and fire ant mound treatments.
While the US EPA made label changes and took other actions on chlorpyrifos over the years, most recently, in October 2015, under the Obama administration, the US EPA proposed to revoke all food residue tolerances for chlorpyrifos. Because tolerances are the maximum residue of a pesticide that can be in or on food, the proposed rule revoking all chlorpyrifos tolerances means that if this approach had been finalized, all agricultural uses of chlorpyrifos in the United States would have ceased. On November 3, 2016, the US EPA submitted Chlorpyrifos: Revised Human Health Risk Assessment for Registration Review (revised risk assessment), which concluded that exposure to chlorpyrifos from diet (i.e., residues of chlorpyrifos on food crops) and drinking water could lead to unacceptably high population exposures and determined that some reproductive-aged women, infants, and children consumed levels of chlorpyrifos substantially above the acceptable level for these vulnerable life stages. US EPA also identified numerous scenarios that could result in unsafe exposures for agricultural workers and bystanders.
As evidence of need for continued scrutiny of granular chlorpyrifos, proponents of the bill point to page 7 of the revised risk assessment, which states, "Using the updated [model for deriving toxicological points of departure] and [specified] uncertainty… all agricultural occupational handler scenarios, all primary seed treatment handler scenarios, and all secondary seed treatment (planter) scenarios are of concern with label-specified and maximum levels of personal protective equipment (PPE) or engineering controls."
In March 2017, under the Trump administration, Scott Pruitt, the head of US EPA at the time, rejected the above scientific conclusion of US EPA’s chemical safety and public health experts and rejected a petition filed a decade prior by the Pesticide Action Network and the Natural Resources Defense Council asking that the agency revoke all pesticide tolerances for chlorpyrifos and cancel all chlorpyrifos registrations. In rejecting the petition, Pruitt took what is known as a "final agency action" on the question of the safety and use of chlorpyrifos, suggesting that the matter would not likely be revisited until October 2022 when US EPA is formally required to re-evaluate the safety of the pesticide.
Judicial action on chlorpyrifos: In a long running court case on chlorpyrifos that dates back to 2007, on August 9, 2018, three appellate judges of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ordered US EPA to prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos within 60 days. The court ruled that there was, "no justification for [US EPA’s] decision in its 2017 order to maintain a tolerance for chlorpyrifos in the face of scientific evidence that its residue on food causes neurodevelopmental damage to children." Following the ruling, US EPA sought a rehearing, saying that the appeals court lacked jurisdiction to review Pruitt’s March 2017 ruling. The US EPA stated that the court should have simply directed him to reconsider the evidence rather than order a ban. As a result, the Ninth Circuit took the rare step of granting US EPA's request to have the full panel of the appeals court rehear oral arguments. On April 17, 2019, the 11-judge appeals court panel ruled that US EPA must, within 90 days, review its 2017 decision to reverse its previous decision to prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos on food crops. On July 18, 2019, US EPA announced that it would not ban the use of chlorpyrifos because the data supporting objections to the use of the pesticide was "not sufficiently valid, complete or reliable." The agency added that it would continue to monitor the safety of chlorpyrifos through 2022.
Arguments in Support:
According to Earthjustice,
"SB 86 [is] a bill that will provide important information to the Legislature on granular products of chlorpyrifos that remain available for use in California. The oversight function of the Legislature has come into sharper focus especially this year. Protecting public health of farmworkers and frontline communities is an essential function of state government. The data submitted to the legislature under SB 86 will empower the policy committees to track the use of granular uses of chlorpyrifos and its health impacts on farmworkers… It is important to monitor the use of granular products of chlorpyrifos as the chemical remains dangerous as long as it is allowed to be in use."
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, California,
"Chlorpyrifos is highly toxic, with demonstrated severe health effects at far below current average exposure levels. One long-term Columbia University study found that toddlers with higher levels of chlorpyrifos exposure displayed developmental delays by age three, and were more than five times as likely to be on the autism spectrum and more than 11 times as likely to display symptoms of attention disorders than their peers. In the 2016 Risk Assessment, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) found that combined dermal and inhalation exposures exceeded the level USEPA determined was safe for workers even when maximal personal protective equipment or engineering controls were assumed… Given the scientific evidence of the harm caused by chlorpyrifos, it is imperative that specific data on granular uses be provided to the legislature, empowering them to make responsible decisions regarding this product."
According to the United Farm Workers,
"This year, the world faces a global health pandemic. The Governor and policymakers are relying on science and medical experts to minimize harm to our public health. And, as scientists and medical experts throughout the country continue to conclude that NO SAFE FORM and NO SAFE LEVEL of chlorpyrifos exists, the United Farm Workers will not rest until this brain damaging chemical is legislatively banned in this state."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to a coalition of opponents,
"Our organizations do not oppose information on granular chlorpyrifos use being made available to the Legislature and public. However, this bill is unnecessary as California’s Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) reports this data annually. Further, we are opposed to the findings of the bill as they are misleading and mischaracterize both the use and risk of granular chlorpyrifos. [The letter lists the following arguments.]
- DPR already compiles an annual use report for all pesticides in California and quarterly reporting would result in unnecessary costs… Under the [existing] reporting program, all agricultural pesticides must be reported monthly to the county agricultural commissions, who then report the compiled data to DPR… All reports are compiled by DPR staff and indexed by chemical or commodity and made available online to the public… There should be considerations of the increased cost of quarterly reports before requiring the shifting of funds.
- The findings in SB 86 are misleading as they do not acknowledge the work DPR has done to mitigate the risk of granular chlorpyrifos use or the differences between granular chlorpyrifos and chlorpyrifos applied through ground spray and aerial application… The findings of SB 86 claim that the use of granular chlorpyrifos results in unsafe levels of exposure to farm workers; can be found on food as a residue; and is tracked home by parents and siblings, which in turn impact young children. These insinuations of danger are untrue and do not consider the facts and scientific studies conducted by DPR…
- DPR extensively evaluates each pesticide before it can be registered for use in California for human health and environmental impacts…
- California has the most advanced system in the nation to ensure that no produce is sold to consumers with pesticide residue levels that would negatively impact human health…
- Application of granular chlorpyrifos is severely restricted and any applicator must follow the label requirements for application."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Academy of Pediatrics, California (Co-Sponsor)
Earthjustice (Co-Sponsor)
United Farm Workers (UFW) (Co-Sponsor)
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians for Pesticide Reform
Community Nature Connection
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
Environmental Working Group (EWG)
Friends of the L.A. River
From Lot to Spot
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Mujeres de la Tierra
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Pesticide Action Network North America
Physicians for Social Responsibility-Los Angeles
Sierra Club
1 Individual
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Chemistry Council
American Pistachio Growers
California Association of Pest Control Advisers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California League of Food Producers
California Seed Association
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Nisei Farmers League
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Plant Health Association
Analysis Prepared by: Shannon McKinney
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 86
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0 (not applicable)
SUBJECT: Public health: pesticide: chlorpyrifos
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of a pesticide that contains the active ingredient chlorpyrifos commencing June 1, 2021, and makes legislative findings about child development, the health risks to children as a result of chlorpyrifos exposure, and the Department of Pesticide Regulations (DPR’s) recent initiation of the process to cancel registrations for pesticide products containing chlorpyrifos.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates the use of pesticides and authorizes the director of DPR (director) to adopt regulations to govern the possession, sale, or use of specified pesticides, as prescribed. (Food and Agriculture Code (FAC) §11501, et. seq)
- Requires the director to endeavor to eliminate from use in the state any pesticide that endangers the agricultural or nonagricultural environment, is not beneficial for the purposes for which it is sold, or is misrepresented. (FAC § 12824)
- Authorizes, the director, after hearing, to cancel the registration of, or refuse to register, any pesticide that fulfills these, among other, criteria:
- That has demonstrated serious uncontrollable adverse effects either within or outside the agricultural environment;
- The use of which is of less public value or greater detriment to the environment than the benefit received by its use;
- For which there is a reasonable, effective, and practicable alternate material or procedure that is demonstrably less destructive to the environment; or,
- That, when properly used, is detrimental to vegetation, except weeds, to domestic animals, or to the public health and safety. (FAC § 12825)
- Requires DPR to control and regulate restricted materials found to meet specified criteria, including, but not limited to, the danger of impairment to public health, hazard to applicators and farmworkers, and hazard to the environment. Authorizes DPR to adopt regulations that prohibit the use or possession of a restricted material that he or she finds and determines is injurious to the environment or to any person, animal, crop, or other property. (FAC § 14001, et. seq)
- Defines a Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC) as an air pollutant that may cause or contribute to an increase in mortality or an increase in serious illness, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. (FAC § 14021)
- Requires the director, in consultation with the Office of Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) and the State Air Resources Control Board (ARB), to evaluate, as specified, the health effects of pesticides that may be or are emitted into the ambient air of California and that may be determined to be a TAC that poses a present or potential threat to human health. (FAC § 14022)
- Requires, upon completion of the evaluation and in consultation with OEHHA, the director to prepare a report, as specified, on the health effects of the pesticide that may be determined to be a TAC. Requires the report to be reviewed by the scientific review panel, as specified.
Requires the director, following receipt of the findings of the scientific review panel, to conduct a public hearing and then list, by regulation, pesticides determined to be TACs. (FAC § 14023 (a) – (d))
- Requires the director to determine, in consultation with OEHHA, the ARB, and the air pollution control districts or air quality management districts in the affected counties, the need for and appropriate degree of control measures for each pesticide listed as a TAC. (FAC § 14023 (e))
- Requires, for pesticides determined to need control measures, the director, in consultation with the agricultural commissioners, air pollution control districts and air quality management districts in the affected counties, to develop control measures designed to reduce emissions sufficiently so that the source will not expose the public to the levels of exposure that may cause or contribute to significant adverse health effects. (FAC § 14024 (a))
- Requires, if no demonstrable safe level or threshold of significant adverse health effects has been established by the director, the control measures to be designed to adequately prevent an endangerment of public health through the application of best practicable control techniques, which include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Label amendments;
- Applicator training;
- Restrictions on use patterns or locations;
- Changes in application procedures;
- Reclassification as a restricted material; and,
- Cancellation. (FAC § 14024 (a) – (b))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "SB 86 would prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos starting on June 1, 2021, which aligns with [the California Environmental Protection Agency’s (CalEPA’s)] announcement to prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos in California in two years or less… This bill highlights what I believe is an important consensus among the Newsom Administration, CalEPA, DPR and the legislature on two very important points. First, there is agreement on the science on chlorpyrifos. We agree that chlorpyrifos harms the brain-development of babies and young children and we agree that the harm must stop. Second, there is agreement that we must and will cancel the registration of chlorpyrifos in California to prohibit its use as quickly as possible as and no later than in two years’ time. SB 86 provides certainty and accountability to pregnant mothers and families that our state will protect them from the harms of chlorpyrifos. Federal action and inaction on chlorpyrifos requires codification of the promise we are making in California on chlorpyrifos. Every day and every additional day chlorpyrifos continues to be used in California; it poses a serious threat and danger of brain damage to babies and young children."
Chlorpyrifos uses: According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), chlorpyrifos is an organophosphate insecticide, acaricide, and miticide used primarily to control foliage and soil-borne insect pests on a variety of food and feed crops. Chlorpyrifos has been used as a pesticide since 1965 in both agricultural and non-agricultural areas. Nationwide, the largest agricultural market for chlorpyrifos in terms of total pounds of active ingredient is corn. It is also used on soybeans, fruit and nut trees, Brussels sprouts, cranberries, broccoli, and cauliflower, as well as other row crops. Non-agricultural uses include golf courses, turf, green houses, and on non-structural wood treatments such as utility poles and fence posts. Chlorpyrifos is also registered for use as a mosquito adulticide, and for use in roach and ant bait stations. Products are sold as liquids, granules, water dispersible granules, wettable powders, and water soluble packets, and may be applied by either ground or aerial equipment.
DPR notes that several dozen chlorpyrifos products are registered in California by approximately 20 different companies. The major uses for chlorpyrifos in California include nut trees, alfalfa, citrus, cotton, and several other food crops. Although the use of chlorpyrifos in California has declined by approximately 50% since 2005, growers used nearly one million pounds of chlorpyrifos on agricultural crops in 2017. In California, methods of application have included aircraft, orchard and vineyard tractor airblast sprayers; tractor ground boom; granular; application using irrigation systems; and, others. The major use areas for chlorpyrifos include the Central Valley, Central Coast region, and Imperial County.
Chlorpyrifos concerns: Chlorpyrifos is an organophosphate that inhibits the functioning of the nervous system (acetylcholinesterase inhibition). This is how it kills insects. According to DPR, acute exposure can have similar effects on humans (sweating, salivation, vomiting, low blood pressure and heart rate, seizures, and death). DPR affirms that recent research has shown that chlorpyrifos is also a developmental neurotoxin in children and sensitive populations, and that the threshold for chlorpyrifos-induced neurodevelopmental effects is approximately 10-fold lower than the threshold for acetylcholinesterase inhibition. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, California, "Chlorpyrifos is highly toxic, with demonstrated severe health effects far below current average exposure levels."
In 2015, DPR designated chlorpyrifos as a restricted material. Restricted materials are pesticides deemed to have a higher potential to cause harm to public health, farm workers, domestic animals, honeybees, the environment, wildlife, or other crops compared to other pesticides. Only trained, licensed professionals with a permit from a local county agricultural commissioner may use products containing a restricted material.
In 2017, OEHHA listed chlorpyrifos as a chemical known to cause developmental toxicity under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65), which requires the State of California to publish a list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity (Health and Safety Code § 25249.8).
California's pesticide program: DPR is vested with the authority to regulate the registration, sale, and use of pesticides in California and has a mission of protecting public health and the environment. DPR notes that this authority is derived from several laws that cover all aspects of pesticide use in all media: air; ground and surface water; food; and, in agricultural, industrial, institutional, occupational and home-and-garden settings. Statutory regulatory authority allows DPR to regulate application rates; ensure pesticide efficacy; designate pesticides as restricted materials; develop criteria to prevent unacceptable pesticide residues in food and water; license applicators and dealers; and, adopt rules to protect workers and the public from overexposure. This full exercise of DPR’s authority extends to the suspension or cancellation of a pesticide’s registration. Cancellation prohibits use of a pesticide after an administrative adjudicatory hearing.
DPR’s Toxic Air Contaminant (TAC) program: DPR’s TAC program is one of several options DPR can use to control exposure to potentially hazardous airborne pesticides. The Legislature created the statutory framework for the evaluation and control of chemicals as TACs with the enactment of California's Toxic Air Contaminant Act (AB 1807, Tanner, Chapter 1047, Statutes of 1983). The statute defines TACs as air pollutants that may cause or contribute to increases in serious illness or death, or that may pose a present or potential hazard to human health. DPR is responsible for the evaluation of pesticides as TACs.
According to DPR, the TAC process consists of two phases: risk assessment (evaluation and identification) and risk management (control). The program's first phase involves an extensive evaluation of the candidate pesticide to assess potential adverse health effects and to estimate levels of exposure associated with its use. Following the evaluation, the law requires the preparation of a report for each pesticide that includes: an assessment of exposure of the public to ambient concentrations of the pesticide; a risk assessment; an overview of the environmental fate and use of the pesticide; and the results of air monitoring studies to measure the levels of the candidate pesticide present in ambient air. The report is reviewed by OEHHA and the ARB, and is made available for public review. The draft then undergoes peer review for scientific soundness by the Scientific Review Panel, a panel of experts representing a range of scientific disciplines. Based on the results of this comprehensive evaluation, the director of DPR determines whether the candidate pesticide is a TAC. If the director determines the pesticide meets the criteria to be a TAC, DPR declares the pesticide a TAC in regulation, and adds it to the TAC list.
Once a candidate pesticide has been declared a TAC, it enters phase two of the program—the mitigation, or control, phase. In the mitigation phase, DPR determines, in consultation with OEHHA, the ARB, and air pollution control districts or air quality management districts, the need for, and appropriate degree of, control for the TAC. If reductions in exposure are needed, DPR must develop control measures to reduce emissions to levels that adequately protect public health. In developing control measures, DPR is required to consult with the agricultural commissioners, air pollution control districts, and air quality management districts in the counties where the pesticide is used. Control measures may be implemented by several methods, including regulatory actions, local permit conditions, and product cancellation.
Recent state action on chlorpyrifos: In September 2018, following extensive scientific review and public comment, DPR proposed designating chlorpyrifos as a TAC. In November 2018, DPR recommended that, while it completes the formal regulatory process to list chlorpyrifos as a TAC, county agricultural commissioners begin implementing interim measures on January 1, 2019. The interim measures included: prohibiting all aerial applications of chlorpyrifos; discontinuing its use on most crops; requiring a quarter-mile buffer zone during all allowed applications of the pesticide and for 24 hours afterwards; and, requiring a 150-foot setback from houses, businesses, schools and other sensitive sites at all times, regardless of whether the site is occupied at the time of application. DPR notes that they believe that all California counties are following these recommendations.
Following the interim recommendation, DPR finalized the listing of chlorpyrifos as a TAC, effective on April 1, 2019.
DPR’s cancellation of the registration of products containing chlorpyrifos: On May 8, 2019, CalEPA announced that DPR, "Is acting to prohibit the use of the pesticide and TAC chlorpyrifos in California by initiating cancellation of the pesticide." According to CalEPA, "The decision to prohibit chlorpyrifos follows mounting evidence, including recent findings by the state’s independent Scientific Review Panel on [TACs], that the pesticide causes serious health effects in children and other sensitive populations at lower levels of exposure than previously understood. These effects include impaired brain and neurological development."
As mentioned in the previous section on the TAC program, listing chlorpyrifos as a TAC requires DPR, in consultation with the OEHHA, the ARB, and the air pollution control districts or air quality management districts in the affected counties, to determine the need for, and develop the appropriate degree of control measures for, chlorpyrifos. As a result, DPR determined that sufficient additional control measures are not feasible. CalEPA announced that DPR intends to move forward in a responsible manner by beginning the process of canceling the registrations for products containing chlorpyrifos, and at the same time, convening a cross-sector working group to identify safer alternatives to avoid replacing chlorpyrifos with an equally harmful pesticide. DPR also will consult with county agricultural commissioners and local air pollution control districts before filing for cancellation. CalEPA notes that the cancellation process could take up to two years. During the cancellation process, DPR’s recommendation to county agricultural commissioners for tighter interim permit restrictions on the use of chlorpyrifos will remain in place.
Funding for safer alternatives: When CalEPA announced the intention to cancel the registration of chlorpyrifos, it, and California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), announced that, "The Governor will propose $5.7 million in new funding in the May Revision budget proposal to support the transition to safer, more sustainable alternatives, and plans to convene a working group to identify, evaluate and recommend alternative pest management solutions."
These proposals appear in the 2019 Budget Act (AB 74, Ting, Budget Act of 2019) as Item 3930-001-0001, which appropriates $2,225,000 to DPR, $2,100,000 of which is available to fund pest management research grants (available for encumbrance or expenditure until June 30, 2022), and Item 8570-001-0001, which appropriates $3,500,000 to CDFA to fund pesticide alternatives grants and biologically integrated farming projects (available for encumbrance or expenditure until June 30, 2022).
According to DPR’s Budget Change Proposal (BCP), the funding request breaks down as follows. DPR requests $125,000 to convene a cross-sector work group that will identify, evaluate, and develop safer, practical, more sustainable alternative pest management tools for California growers, and $2,100,000 million to provide funding for projects that develop and implement integrated pest management practices that reduce pesticide risks to human health and the environment. The funds will be used specifically to seek alternatives to chlorpyrifos that advance safer, more sustainable pest management solutions.
Also in the BCP, CDFA requests $1.5 million to supplement the CDFA’s Pesticide Alternatives Grant program to support the registration of pest management tools on specialty crops and to focus on funding alternatives to chlorpyrifos that advance safer, more sustainable pest management solutions. CDFA also requests a one-time appropriation of $2 million to revitalize the Biologically Integrated Farming Systems program to provide training and demonstration projects for integrated pest management.
CalEPA asserts that in combination, the working group and funding for alternatives will produce short-term solutions and prioritize the development of long-term solutions to support healthy communities and a thriving agricultural sector.
At the time of the printing of this analysis, AB 74 was enrolled and awaiting the Governor’s signature.
Federal action on chlorpyrifos: Federal regulatory action on chlorpyrifos stretches back about two decades, when, in 2000, US EPA finalized chlorpyrifos risk assessments for reregistration and identified the need to address health and environmental risks from chlorpyrifos exposure. At that time, the registrants of chlorpyrifos voluntarily entered into an agreement with US EPA to eliminate, phase out, and modify certain uses. The agreement included eliminating most homeowner uses of chlorpyrifos, except ant and roach baits in child resistant packaging and fire ant mound treatments.
While US EPA made label changes and took other actions on chlorpyrifos over the years, most recently, in October 2015, under the Obama administration, the US EPA proposed to revoke all food residue tolerances for chlorpyrifos. Because tolerances are the maximum residue of a pesticide that can be in or on food, the proposed rule revoking all chlorpyrifos tolerances means that if this approach had been finalized, all agricultural uses of chlorpyrifos would cease. In November 2016, US EPA revised its human health risk assessment to show risks from dietary exposure (i.e., residues of chlorpyrifos on food crops) and drinking water. It did not result in a change to the proposal, but after considering the advice of the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act Scientific Advisory Panel, US EPA modified the methods used to support that finding.
In March 2017, under the Trump administration, Scott Pruitt, the head of US EPA at the time, rejected the above scientific conclusion of US EPA’s chemical safety experts and rejected a petition filed a decade prior by the Pesticide Action Network and the Natural Resources Defense Council asking that the agency revoke all pesticide tolerances for chlorpyrifos and cancel all chlorpyrifos registrations. In rejecting the petition, Pruitt took what is known as a "final agency action" on the question of the safety and use of chlorpyrifos, suggesting that the matter would not likely be revisited until 2022 when US EPA is formally required to re-evaluate the safety of the pesticide.
Judicial action on chlorpyrifos: In a long running court case on chlorpyrifos that dates back to 2007, on August 9, 2018, three appellate judges of the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ordered US EPA to prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos within 60 days. The court ruled that there was, "no justification for [US EPA’s] decision in its 2017 order to maintain a tolerance for chlorpyrifos in the face of scientific evidence that its residue on food causes neurodevelopmental damage to children." Following the ruling, US EPA sought a rehearing, saying that the appeals court lacked jurisdiction to review Pruitt’s March 2017 ruling. The US EPA stated that the court should have simply directed him to reconsider the evidence rather than order a ban. As a result, the Ninth Circuit took the rare step of granting US EPA's request to have the full panel of the appeals court rehear oral arguments. On April 17, 2019, the 11-judge appeals court panel ruled that US EPA must, within 90 days, review its 2017 decision to reverse its previous decision to prohibit the use of chlorpyrifos on food crops.
This bill prohibits the use of a pesticide that contains the active ingredient chlorpyrifos commencing June 1, 2021.
Arguments in support: The United Farm Workers argues, "SB 86 is aligned with the Newsom Administration’s recent announcement to cancel the use of chlorpyrifos, which the Administration states could take anywhere from 6 months to two years… Because the executive branch of our state government cannot guarantee an end date to end the use of the brain-damaging chemical and there is no guarantee the cancellation process will lead to a ban, as it was reported in the media, SB 86 is needed… The science is conclusive. Leading scientific and medical authorities have concluded that chlorpyrifos harms children’s brain development, reduces children’s IQ, and puts children at risk of learning disabilities. Upon review of the science, the U.S. EPA, under the Obama administration, concluded there is no safe level of exposure and acted to ban its use. However, under the Trump administration, this ban was overturned… The American Academy of Pediatrics reported, "There is a wealth of evidence demonstrating the detrimental effects of chlorpyrifos exposure to developing fetuses, infants, children, and pregnant women.""
Arguments in opposition: A coalition of opponents, including the American Chemistry Council, the California Farm Bureau Federation, the Agricultural Council of California, and the California Chamber of Commerce, argues, "This bill is unnecessary and undermines the science done by California’s regulatory agencies. SB 458 (Durazo), which similarly would have banned the use of chlorpyrifos, was already held this year in the Senate Appropriations Committee. Further, on May 8, 2019, the Governor, along with [Cal EPA], initiated the regulatory process to cancel the registration of chlorpyrifos in California. To assist in this process, the California Budget for fiscal year 2019-2020 appropriates $5.7 million from the General Fund for a stakeholder process at the Department of Pesticide Regulation (DPR) and $5.6 million from the General Fund to develop alternatives to chlorpyrifos. This is the proper venue for this action, provides due process and scientific analysis in decision making, and makes this bill moot. The passage of this bill would only serve to waste taxpayer resources invested in the regulatory process."
Related legislation: SB 458 (Durazo) would have established the Protect Children from Brain-Damaging Chlorpyrifos Act of 2019, which would have prohibited the use of pesticides that contain chlorpyrifos in California until the Director of DPR adopts specified control measures for chlorpyrifos. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Earthjustice (Co-sponsor)
United Farm Workers (Co-sponsor)
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Californians for Pesticide Reform
Center for Food Safety; The
Center on Race, Poverty & The Environment
Central California Environmental Justice Coalition
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Pesticide Action Network
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Chemistry Council
American Pistachio Growers
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Pest Control Advisers
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bean Shippers Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners & Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Pear Growers
California Seed Association
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Nisei Farmers League
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Plant Health Association
Analysis Prepared by: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. /
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 86 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 86
Amended: 5/1/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/24/19
AYES: Leyva, Wilk, Chang, Durazo, Glazer, McGuire, Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: School safety: lockdown drills
DIGEST:
This bill, commencing with the 2020–21 school year, requires comprehensive school safety plans to include procedures requiring either, at the discretion of the school district or county office of education, a lockdown drill or a multioption response drill, to be conducted in an age-appropriate manner at least once per school year at each school.
Existing law:
- Requires every person and public officer managing, controlling, or in charge of any public, private, or parochial school, other than a two-year community college, to cause the fire alarm signal to be sounded not less than once every calendar month and shall conduct a fire drill at least once every calendar month at the elementary level and at least four times every school year at the intermediate levels. (Education Code § 32001)
- Requires each school district or county office of education to be responsible for the overall development of all comprehensive school safety plans for its schools operating kindergarten or any of grades 1 through 12. The schoolsite council or a school safety planning committee is responsible for developing the comprehensive school safety plan. (EC § 32281)
- Requires school safety plans to include:
- An assessment of the current status of school crime committed on school campuses and at school-related functions.
- Identification of appropriate strategies and programs that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety and address the school’s procedures for complying with existing laws related to school safety, including, among other things:
- Disaster procedures, including an earthquake emergency procedure system and a procedure to allow public agencies (such as the American Red Cross) to use school facilities for mass care and welfare shelters.
- Procedures to notify teachers of dangerous students.
- Procedures for safe ingress and egress of students, parents, and school employees to and from school.
- A safe and orderly environment conducive to learning.
- Procedures for conducting tactical responses to criminal incidents, including procedures related to individuals with guns on school campuses and at school-related functions. The procedures to prepare for active shooters or other armed assailants shall be based on the specific needs and context of each school and community. (EC § 32282)
- Authorizes the portions of a school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents to be developed by school district or county office administrators in consultation with law enforcement officials and with a representative of the employee bargaining unit, if he or she chooses to participate. The school district or county office may elect not to disclose those portions of the comprehensive school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents. (EC § 32281)
- Defines “tactical responses to criminal incidents” as steps taken to safeguard students and staff, to secure the affected school premises, and to apprehend the criminal perpetrator(s). (EC § 32281)
- Requires school safety plans to be evaluated at least once a year, and requires an updated file of all safety-related plans and materials to be readily available for inspection by the public. (EC § 32282)
- Requires each school to adopt its school safety plan by March 1 and review and update its plan annually by March 1. Each school is required to annually report, in July, on the status of its school safety plan, including a description of key elements of the school safety plan in the annual school accountability report card. (EC § 32286)
- Requires the schoolsite council or school safety planning committee to hold a public meeting before adopting the school safety plan. Each school is required to forward its school safety plan to the school district or county office for approval, and school districts or county offices are required to annually notify the California Department of Education, by October 15, of any school that is not in compliance. (EC § 32288)
- Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), if he or she determines that there has been a willful failure to make any report, to notify the school district or county office and assess a fine of up to $2,000 against the district or county office. (EC § 32287)
This bill, commencing with the 2020–21 school year, requires comprehensive school safety plans to include procedures requiring either, at the discretion of the school district or county office of education, a lockdown drill or a multioption response drill, to be conducted in an age-appropriate manner at least once per school year at each school. Specifically, this bill also:
- Requires school officials to consider the emotional impact of the drill on pupils when planning, preparing, and conducting the drill.
- Defines “lockdown” to mean “a situation that presents an immediate and ongoing danger to the safety of pupils, faculty, staff, and visitors by a person using firearms or other types of weapons or displaying erratic behavior.”
- Defines “multioption response drill” to mean “an approach where individuals evacuate the area, create barricades, and in last resort situations, actively resist a person using a firearm or other type of weapon.”
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Given the unfortunate threats to California’s schools today, students, volunteers, staff, teachers, and administrators cannot be prepared enough for the unknown. From devastating wildfires to active shooters on campus, we need to ensure all people on school campuses are prepared to act immediately with the children’s utmost safety in mind. Existing Education Code requires regularly scheduled fire drills for elementary schools, intermediate level and secondary schools at least twice a year. Unfortunately, existing statute doesn’t include training for any threats that may be acted out towards a school jeopardizing the safety of all on campus. Some school districts have taken it upon themselves to provide this training for intruders on campus or possibly active shooters on campus, but it is necessary to make sure all schools are on the same page regardless of their geographic location.”
- School violence prevention audit. An audit by the California State Auditor, released in 2017, cites FBI data showing that active shooter incidents became more common between 2000 and 2015, and kindergarten through grade 12 facilities and higher education institutions have been the second most common location for these shootings to occur, both nationally and within California. The report notes that state law does not require schools to include procedures for responding to active shooter events in their school safety plans and that state law could improve these plans by requiring the inclusion of procedures to respond to active shooter incidents. The audit also found deficiencies in oversight and guidance by district and county offices of education as well as at the state level by California Department of Education, and that some schools have failed to meet the requirement to review safety plans annually.
- Comprehensive school safety plans. As detailed above, existing law provides for the development of comprehensive school safety plans for each school operated by a school district, county office of education, or charter school, including the procedures for conducting tactical responses to criminal incidents. Private schools are not subject to the school safety plan requirements. Additionally, the safety plan requirements do not require public schools to conduct a drill related to the safety plan, including lockdown drills.
The school safety plan requirements are detailed. For example, a safety plan must include an assessment, identification of appropriate strategies and programs that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety, including procedures to notify teachers of dangerous pupils and procedures for the safe ingress and egress of pupils, parents, and school employees to and from the school. Moreover, school safety plans must be developed in cooperation with local law enforcement agencies and updated each year. Additionally, the school district or county office of education may elect not to disclose those portions of the comprehensive school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents.
- Multioption response drills. A recent study published in the Journal of School Violence, “One Size Does Not Fit All: Traditional Lockdown Versus Multioption Responses to School Shootings,” compared two different approaches to responses to active shooting situations: a traditional lockdown approach where individuals find cover in a classroom and lock the door, and a multi-option approach where individuals evacuate the area, create barricades, and, in last resort situations, actively resist the gunman. The study found that “drills informed by the multi-option response paradigm were found to end more quickly and result in fewer people being shot.”
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 541 (Bates, 2019) is substantially similar to this bill, but also applies to charter schools and private schools. SB 541 is pending on the Senate floor.
AB 1747 (Rodriguez, Chapter 806, Statutes of 2018) expanded the required elements of school safety plans, including procedures to respond to active shooter situations, required schools to conduct annual active shooter drills, and required the California Department of Education to provide additional guidance and oversight of safety plans.
AB 3205 (O’Donnell, Chapter 401, Statutes of 2018) required school districts with modernization projects under the state School Facility Program, for school facilities constructed before January 1, 2012, to include interior locks as part of the project.
SB 1203 (Bates, 2018) was substantially similar to this bill and would have required each public, charter, and private school to establish lockdown training procedures. SB 1203 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 58 (Rodriguez, 2015) would have made each county office of education the entity responsible for the overall development of all comprehensive school safety plans and requires school safety plans to include procedures in response to individuals with guns on school campuses. AB 58 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 49 (Lieu, 2013) would have required school safety plans to include procedures related to response to a person with a gun on campus, extended from annually to every third year the frequency of review of safety plans, and required charter school petitions to include a description of a school safety plan. SB 49 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee in 2013.
SB 634 (Price, 2013) would have required comprehensive school safety plans to include procedures for conducting school safety drills, required each school during each school year to conduct a minimum number of school evacuation drills relating to fire incidents, authorized schools to conduct other specified school evacuations, and required schools to conduct at least one law enforcement school lockdown drill. SB 634 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill’s requirement for school districts to conduct a lockdown or multioption response drill each year is likely to create a new reimbursable state mandate. A precise estimate is unknown, but Proposition 98 General Fund costs could be $15 million annually. This estimate assumes that each teacher in the state would require one hour to conduct the drill each year.
This bill expands the existing comprehensive school safety plans mandate resulting in additional costs that are estimated to be in the low tens of thousands of dollars each year (Proposition 98 General Fund). Alternatively, it could lead to pressure for the state to increase the K-12 Mandates Block grant.
Los Angeles Unified School District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
None received
Prepared by: Brandon Darnell / ED. /
5/18/19 11:57:48
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 86 (Portantino) - School safety: lockdown and multioption response drills
Version: May 1, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires a school district’s comprehensive school safety plan to include procedures requiring a lockdown drill or a multioption response drill at least once per school year.
Fiscal Impact:
- The bill’s requirement for school districts to conduct a lockdown or multioption response drill each year is likely to create a new reimbursable state mandate. A precise estimate is unknown, but Proposition 98 General Fund costs could be $15 million annually. This estimate assumes that each teacher in the state would require one hour to conduct the drill each year.
- This bill would expand the existing comprehensive school safety plans mandate resulting in additional costs that are estimated to be in the low tens of thousands of dollars each year (Proposition 98 General Fund). Alternatively, it could lead to pressure for the state to increase the K-12 Mandates Block grant.
Background:
Existing law requires each school district or county office of education to be responsible for the overall development of all comprehensive school safety plans for its schools operating kindergarten or any of grades 1 through 12. The schoolsite council or a school safety planning committee is responsible for developing the comprehensive school safety plan. School safety plans are to include identification of appropriate strategies and programs that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety and address the school’s procedures for complying with existing laws related to school safety, including child abuse reporting procedures, disaster procedures, policies regarding students who commit specified offenses that would lead to suspension or expulsion and procedures to notify teachers of dangerous students.
Existing law authorizes the portions of a school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents to be developed by school district or county office administrators in consultation with law enforcement officials and with a representative of the employee bargaining unit, if he or she chooses to participate. The school district or county office may elect not to disclose those portions of the comprehensive school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents.
Existing law authorizes a petition for the establishment of a charter school to be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after specified conditions are met. The governing board of the school district is prohibited from denying a petition for the establishment of a charter school unless it makes written factual findings setting forth specific facts to support specific findings, including the procedures that the school will follow to ensure the health and safety of students and staff.
Proposed Law:
This bill, commencing with the 2020-21 school year, requires an LEA’s comprehensive school safety plan to include procedures requiring either, at the discretion of the school district or county office of education, a lockdown drill or a multioption response drill, which shall be conducted in an age-appropriate matter at least once per school year at each school. School officials shall consider the emotional impact of the drill on pupils when planning, preparing, and conducting the drill.
This bill defines lockdown as a situation that presents an immediate and ongoing danger to the safety of pupils, faculty, staff, and visitors by a person using firearms or other types of weapons or displaying erratic behavior. The bill defines multioption response drill as an approach where individuals evacuate the area, create barricades, and in last resort situations, actively resist a person using a firearm or other type of weapon.
Related Legislation:
SB 541 (Bates) requires every public and private school that provides educational services to pupils in kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and has an enrollment of 50 or more pupils or more than one classroom, to conduct a lockdown drill at least once per school year.
AB 1747 (Rodriguez, Chapter 806, Statutes of 2018) expands the required elements of school safety plans to include procedures regarding active shooter situations.
SB 1203 (Bates, 2018) would have required schools to establish lockdown training procedures. This bill failed passage in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments:
The bill’s requirement for school districts to conduct a lockdown or multioption response drill each year is likely to create a new reimbursable state mandate resulting in significant Proposition 98 General Fund costs. A precise estimate is unknown, but assuming one hour for each teacher in the state (approximately 300,000) is necessary to provide training and conduct the drills each year, the statewide cost would be $15 million annually.
Additionally, this bill would expand the existing comprehensive school safety plans mandate, which requires the development of a safety plan for each school operated by a school district or county office of education. These plans include a number of components, including strategies that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety and disaster procedures. By adding procedures for conducting a lockdown or multioption response drill, this bill would require school districts to revise their existing plans and adopt them. Consistent with previous determinations by the Commission on State Mandates regarding school safety plans, the Commission is likely to determine the procedures required by this bill to be a higher level of service and therefore a reimbursable state mandate. Based on the existing statewide cost estimate for the comprehensive school safety plans mandate, these costs are estimated to be in the low tens of thousands of dollars each year (Proposition 98 General Fund). Alternatively, if school districts elect not to submit mandate claims to the Commission, there could be pressure for the state to increase the K-12 Mandate Block grant. The amount of funding provided through the block grant is tied to the mandates that the Commission has approved as well as the costs for those mandates. School districts that choose to participate in the block grant receive a per-student amount to cover the cost of the various state mandated activities in lieu of submitting mandate claims for reimbursement. Charter schools may participate in the block grant, but are not eligible to submit mandate claims nor receive reimbursement from the state.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 86 Hearing Date: April 24, 2019
Author: | Portantino | ||
Version: | March 20, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brandon Darnell | ||
Subject: School safety: lockdown drills.
SUMMARY
This bill, commencing with the 2020-21 school year, requires a school district that maintains kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to conduct a lockdown drill at least four times per school year.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
1) Every person and public officer managing, controlling, or in charge of any public, private, or parochial school, other than a two-year community college, shall cause the fire alarm signal to be sounded not less than once every calendar month and shall conduct a fire drill at least once every calendar month at the elementary level and at least four times every school year at the intermediate levels. (Education Code § 32001)
2) Requires each school district or county office of education to be responsible for the overall development of all comprehensive school safety plans for its schools operating kindergarten or any of grades 1 through 12. The schoolsite council or a school safety planning committee is responsible for developing the comprehensive school safety plan. (EC § 32281)
3) Requires school safety plans to include:
a) An assessment of the current status of school crime committed on school campuses and at school-related functions.
b) Identification of appropriate strategies and programs that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety and address the school’s procedures for complying with existing laws related to school safety, including, among other things:
i) Disaster procedures, including an earthquake emergency procedure system and a procedure to allow public agencies (such as the American Red Cross) to use school facilities for mass care and welfare shelters.
ii) Procedures to notify teachers of dangerous students.
iii) Procedures for safe ingress and egress of students, parents, and school employees to and from school.
iv) A safe and orderly environment conducive to learning.
v) Procedures for conducting tactical responses to criminal incidents, including procedures related to individuals with guns on school campuses and at school-related functions. The procedures to prepare for active shooters or other armed assailants shall be based on the specific needs and context of each school and community. (EC § 32282)
4) Authorizes the portions of a school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents to be developed by school district or county office administrators in consultation with law enforcement officials and with a representative of the employee bargaining unit, if he or she chooses to participate. The school district or county office may elect not to disclose those portions of the comprehensive school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents. (EC § 32281)
5) Defines “tactical responses to criminal incidents” as steps taken to safeguard students and staff, to secure the affected school premises, and to apprehend the criminal perpetrator(s). (EC § 32281)
6) Requires school safety plans to be evaluated at least once a year, and requires an updated file of all safety-related plans and materials to be readily available for inspection by the public. (EC § 32282)
7) Requires each school to adopt its school safety plan by March 1 and review and update its plan annually by March 1. Each school is required to annually report, in July, on the status of its school safety plan, including a description of key elements of the school safety plan in the annual school accountability report card. (EC § 32286)
8) Requires the schoolsite council or school safety planning committee to hold a public meeting before adopting the school safety plan. Each school is required to forward its school safety plan to the school district or county office for approval, and school districts or county offices are required to annually notify the California Department of Education, by October 15, of any school that is not in compliance. (EC § 32288)
9) Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), if he or she determines that there has been a willful failure to make any report, to notify the school district or county office and assess a fine of up to $2,000 against the district or county office. (EC § 32287)
ANALYSIS
This bill, commencing with the 2020-21 school year, requires a school district that maintains kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to conduct a lockdown drill at least four times per school year.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “School shootings have become an all-too-frequent occurrence in the United States and unfortunately California is not immune, despite our strong gun laws. While lockdown drills have been conducted by California schools for the past 20+ years, they are carried out at the discretion of each school and are not mandated for frequency, like fire and earthquake drills. This law would ensure administrators, teachers and students across the state are more equitably prepared by establishing a minimum frequency of age-appropriate lockdown drills.”
- School violence prevention audit. An audit by the California State Auditor, released in 2017, cites FBI data showing that active shooter incidents became more common between 2000 and 2015, and kindergarten through grade 12 facilities and higher education institutions have been the second most common location for these shootings to occur, both nationally and within California. The report notes that state law does not require schools to include procedures for responding to active shooter events in their school safety plans and that state law could improve these plans by requiring the inclusion of procedures to respond to active shooter incidents. The audit also found deficiencies in oversight and guidance by district and county offices of education as well as at the state level by California Department of Education, and that some schools have failed to meet the requirement to review safety plans annually.
- Comprehensive school safety plans. As detailed above, existing law provides for the development of comprehensive school safety plans for each school operated by a school district, county office of education, or charter school, including the procedures for conducting tactical responses to criminal incidents. Private schools are not subject to the school safety plan requirements. Additionally, the safety plan requirements do not require public schools to conduct a drill related to the safety plan, including lockdown drills.
The school safety plan requirements are detailed. For example, a safety plan must include an assessment, identification of appropriate strategies and programs that will provide or maintain a high level of school safety, including procedures to notify teachers of dangerous pupils and procedures for the safe ingress and egress of pupils, parents, and school employees to and from the school. Moreover, school safety plans must be developed in cooperation with local law enforcement agencies and updated each year. Additionally, the school district or county office of education may elect not to disclose those portions of the comprehensive school safety plan that include tactical responses to criminal incidents.
In light of the comprehensive nature of school safety plans and the existing structure for their development, staff recommends that the bill be amended to delete Section 1 of the bill and instead add the requirements of the bill to the requirements of the comprehensive school safety plan, as specified in Section 32282 of the Education Code, but only at least once per school year.
4) Author amendment. A recent study published in the Journal of School Violence, “One Size Does Not Fit All: Traditional Lockdown Versus Multioption Responses to School Shootings,” compared two different approaches to responses to active shooting situations: a traditional lockdown approach where individuals find cover in a classroom and lock the door, and a multi-option approach where individuals evacuate the area, create barricades, and, in last resort situations, actively resist the gunman. The study found that “drills informed by the multi-option response paradigm were found to end more quickly and result in fewer people being shot.” Accordingly, the author would like to amend the bill to:
- Require a lockdown drill or multioption response drill, at the discretion of the local educational agency, to be conducted in an age-appropriate manner.
- Require school officials to consider the emotional impact of the drill on pupils when planning, preparing, and conducting the drill. Staff recommends that the bill amended to reflect the author’s intent.
- Related and previous legislation. SB 541 (Bates, 2019) requires every public school, including charter schools, and every private school that has an enrollment of 50 or more pupils or more than one classroom, that provides educational services to pupils in kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to conduct a lockdown drill at least once per school year. SB 541 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1747 (Rodriguez, Chapter 806, Statutes of 2018) expands the required elements of school safety plans, including procedures to respond to active shooter situations, requires schools to conduct annual active shooter drills, and requires the California Department of Education to provide additional guidance and oversight of safety plans.
SB 1203 (Bates, 2018) would have required each public, charter, and private school to establish lockdown training procedures. SB 1203 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 3205 (O’Donnell, Chapter 401, 2018) requires school districts to install indoor classroom locks in schools built before 2012.
AB 58 (Rodriguez, 2015) would have made each county office of education the entity responsible for the overall development of all comprehensive school safety plans and requires school safety plans to include procedures in response to individuals with guns on school campuses. AB 58 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 49 (Lieu, 2013) would have required school safety plans to include procedures related to response to a person with a gun on campus, extended from annually to every third year the frequency of review of safety plans, and required charter school petitions to include a description of a school safety plan. SB 49 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee in 2013.
SB 634 (Price, 2013) would have required comprehensive school safety plans to include procedures for conducting school safety drills, required each school during each school year to conduct a minimum number of school evacuation drills relating to fire incidents, authorized schools to conduct other specified school evacuations, and required schools to conduct at least one law enforcement school lockdown drill. SB 634 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SUPPORT
Los Angeles Unified School District
Woke AF
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):