SB 900: Department of Industrial Relations: worker status: employees and independent contractors.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-03-26
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 15, 2020 | May 14 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 8, 2020 | Set for hearing May 14. |
| Mar 26, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Feb 12, 2020 | Referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 1. |
| Jan 30, 2020 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 900 Hearing Date: May 14, 2020
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | March 26, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gideon L. Baum | ||
SUBJECT: Department of Industrial Relations: worker status: employees and independent contractors
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature revise and recast the provisions of the ‘ABC’ employee test and expand the exemptions in the test to include interpreters, translators, family and marriage therapists, amateur athletic officials, and others?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes a comprehensive set of protections for employees, including a time-sure minimum wage, meal and rest periods, workers’ compensation coverage in the event of an industrial injury, sick leave, disability insurance (DI) in the event of a non-industrial disability, paid family leave, and unemployment insurance (UI).
(Labor Code §§201, 226.7, 246, 512, 1182.12, & 3600 and UI Code §§1251 & 2601) - Provides that, except as otherwise stated, a person providing labor or services for remuneration must be considered an employee unless the hiring entity demonstrates that all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- The person is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact.
- The person performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.
- The person is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed.
(Labor Code §2750.3) - Provides that, for a itemized list of occupations, the applicable test for determining if an individual is an employee or an independent contractor is the predecessor test to Dynamex developed by the California Supreme Court in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341, if a specified list of conditions are met. Some of these occupations include:
- Licensed insurance brokers.
- Licensed physicians and surgeons, dentists, podiatrists, psychologists, lawyers, architects, engineers, private investigators, veterinarians, and accountants.
- A direct salesperson, provided that the salesperson’s compensation is based on actual sales, rather than wholesale purchases or referrals.
- Licensed cosmetologists.
- Commercial fishermen.
- Provides that the Borello employment test governs professional contracts if the contracting entity can demonstrate all of the following:
- The individual maintains a business location, which may include the individual’s residence, that is separate from the hiring entity. Nothing prevents an individual from choosing to perform services at the location of the hiring entity.
- If work is performed more than six months after the effective date of this section, the individual has a business license, in addition to any required professional licenses or permits for the individual to practice in their profession.
- The individual has the ability to set or negotiate their own rates for services performed.
- Outside of project completion dates and reasonable business hours, the individual has the ability to set their own hours.
- The individual is customarily engaged in the same type of work performed under contract with another hiring entity or holds themselves out to other potential customers for the same work.
- The individual customarily and regularly exercises discretion and independent judgment in the performance of the services.
- Defines “professional services” as the following services:
- Marketing, provided that the contracted work is original and creative in character and the result of which depends primarily on the invention, imagination, or talent of the employee or work that is an essential part of or necessarily incident to any of the contracted work.
- Administrator of human resources, provided that the contracted work is predominantly intellectual and varied in character and is of such character that the output produced or the result accomplished cannot be standardized in relation to a given period of time.
- Travel agents.
- Graphic design.
- Grant writer.
- Fine artist.
- Enrolled agent.
- Payment processing agent through an independent sales organization.
- Services provided by a still photographer, provided the individual does not license content to the putative employer more than 35 times in a year, as specified.
- Services provided by a freelance writer, provided the individual does not license content to the putative employer more than 35 times in a year, as specified.
- Provides that relationships between a contracting business and a business service provider is under the Borello test if all of the following criteria are satisfied:
- The business service provider is free from the control and direction of the contracting business entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact.
- The business service provider is providing services to the contracting business rather than to customers of the contracting business.
- The contract with the business service provider is in writing.
- If the work is performed in a jurisdiction that requires the business service provider to have a business license or business tax registration, the business service provider has the required business license or business tax registration.
- The business service provider maintains a business location that is separate from the business or work location of the contracting business.
- The business service provider is customarily engaged in an independently established business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed.
- The business service provider actually contracts with other businesses to provide the same or similar services and maintains a clientele without restrictions from the hiring entity.
- The business service provider advertises and holds itself out to the public as available to provide the same or similar services.
- The business service provider provides its own tools, vehicles, and equipment to perform the services.
- The business service provider can negotiate its own rates.
- Concistent with the nature of the work, the business service provider can set its own hours and location of work.
- The business service provider is not performing the type of work for which a license from the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) is required, pursuant to Section 7000 and following of the Business and Professions Code.
- Provides that a relationship between a service provider and a referral agency is exempt from the ABC test and under the Borello test if the following is applicable:
- The service provider has formed a business entity as a sole proprietor, partnership, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or corporation.
- The service provider is free from the control and direction of the referral agency as a matter of contract and fact.
- If the work for the client is performed in a jurisdiction that requires the service provider to have a business license or business tax registration, the service provider has the required business license or business tax registration.
- If the work for the client requires the service provider to hold a state contractor’s license, the service provider has the required contractor’s license.
- The service provider delivers services to the client under service provider’s name, rather than under the name of the referral agency.
- The service provider provides its own tools and supplies to perform the services.
- The service provider is customarily engaged in an independently established business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed for the client.
- The service provider maintains a clientele without any restrictions from the referral agency and the service provider is free to seek work elsewhere, including through a competing agency.
- The service provider sets its own hours and terms of work and is free to accept or reject clients and contracts.
- The service provider sets its own rates for services performed, without deduction by the referral agency.
- The service provider is not penalized in any form for rejecting clients or contracts. This subparagraph does not apply if the service provider accepts a client or contract and then fails to fulfill any of its contractual obligations.
- Defines a referral agency as a business that connects service providers with clients and provides the following services: graphic design, photography, tutoring, event planning, minor home repair, moving, home cleaning, errands, furniture assembly, animal services, dog walking, dog grooming, web design, picture hanging, pool cleaning, or yard cleanup.
This bill:
- Revises and recasts the provisions described above as a separate article within the Labor Code;
- Exempts the following professions from the ABC test and applies the Borello test:
- Licensed professional clinical counselors, licensed professional clinical social workers, and licensed marriage and family therapists, unless the licensees listed above are currently or potentially governed by a collective bargaining agreement.
- Amateur athletic officials, such as umpires and referees.
- Adds security researchers, appraisers, and certified shorthand reporters to the list of exempted “professional services” described above.
- Refines the existing definition of “tutor” in the “referral agency” exemption to include a person who teaches a proprietary and privately developed curriculum, or provides private lessons and academic enrichment services using their own teaching methodology or techniques, provided the individual is not teaching the curriculum of, or contracted with, a public school.
- Expands the “referral agency” exemption language to include certified interpretation or translation services. To qualify, an interpreter or translator must be certified and credentialed by one of the following organizations: Judicial Council of California, Federal Courts, United States Department of State, American Translators Association, International Association of Conference Interpreters, Certification Commission for Health Care Interpreters, National Board of Medical Interpreters, National Interpreter Certification, or Center for Assessment of Sign Language Certification.
- Refines the existing “direct sales” definition and exemption to include licensed manufacturing home salespeople and individuals selling tools and equipment for the maintenance and repair of motorized vehicles from a bus, van, or truck.
COMMENTS
1. Assembly Bill 5 (2019), Senate Bill 900, and the Search for a Reasonable Employee Test:
In 2019, the Legislature passed, and the Governor signed, AB 5, which was a watershed piece of legislation in the history of Labor Law. Specifically, AB 5 codified a 2018 California Supreme Court decision, Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018), which into an onto itself was a revolutionary labor law precedent, creating a strict ABC test for determining who can be classified as an independent contractor. Importantly, however, AB 5 also provided explicit industrial categories where the long-standing Borello test would remain the standard for determining who is an employee.
Throughout the AB 5 process, all stakeholders acknowledged and understood that the codification of the new independent contractor test was an ongoing project. This year, members of both political parties introduced more than 30 bills, running the gamut from a full repeal to minor technical changes. SB 900 is a member of that cohort, but with several notable differences.
First, SB 900 revised the entire structure of AB 5. Instead of being one single section, with various components bolted on through compromise, the ABC test and exemptions were broken up into 10 distinct sections. The goal was to help both employer and workers navigate the various pieces of the ABC test.
Second, SB 900 attempts to tackle the various issue surrounding the ABC test in a holistic manner. Rather than focusing on a simple topic or industry, SB 900 addresses a variety of industries: interpreters, translators, licensed clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists, amateur referees, and specified salespeople. These are industries where independent contractor status is the historical norm, where reports of misclassification are extremely rare, and the workers themselves have asked for an exemption through their respective associations.
Finally, largely due to its scope, SB 900 remains a work-in-progress. While some refinements will be discussed below, many significant pieces remain under discussion. It is likely that these pieces will not land until a full discussion can be pursued between the proponents of this measure, the author’s office, and the opponents.
2. Franchises, Vazquez and SB 900:
Traditionally, franchises have occupied a unique and distinct place in economic law. This is due to their unique structure: instead of an individual creating a business and attempting to establish their own brand, the individual buys a license to operate under an already established brand as a franchisee. In doing so, they no longer need to worry about logistics, advertising, and other issues: the franchisor, through licensing fees, advertises the brand, and coordinates logistics, menu choices, and the like. Still, the day-to-day operations (and risk) fall to the franchisee: managing locations, employees, and complying with relevant law.
Historically, California has been at the forefront of the franchise model. The first McDonald’s was in San Bernardino; the first Taco Bell restaurant was Downey; the first Del Taco was in Yermo; the first A&W Restaurant was in Sacramento (with the A&W Root Beer being first brewed in Lodi); the first Jack in the Box was in San Diego; and the first Carl’s Jr. was in Los Angeles. In short, it was in California that the modern franchise that we know today was born.
Unfortunately, not all franchise models equal. Some franchise models, particularly in the janitorial space, appear to be little more than a thinly disguised dodge of labor law. This reality came to the forefront in Vazquez v. Jan-Pro Franchising International, Inc., No. 17-16096 (9th Cir. 2019). Unlike traditional franchise models, Jan-Pro corporate did not simply provide logistics and advertising: rather, someone want to utilize Jan-Pro’s services worked directly with Jan-Pro’s main corporate partners and Jan-Pro received the funds directly, yet the work was performed by the franchisee. In other words, it would be as if someone ordered a burger from McDonald’s corporate headquarters in Illinois, paid McDonald’s headquarters, and then McDonald’s had someone from California create the burger and put it in the customer’s hands. In Vazquez, the 9th Circuit recognized that such a franchise model violates Dynamex and ruled that such franchisees were in fact employees.[1]
Yet, troublingly, the Vazquez decision did not differentiate between the classic franchise business model and the newer, Jan-Pro like franchise models. This potentially creates legal liability for franchises like McDonald’s, despite the fact these franchisors are essentially independent small businesses.
SB 900 attempts to thread the needle on the franchise model question by focusing solely on the classic franchise model and extending Borello as the relevant test to only the franchisee, not his or her individual workers. SB 900 does this by:
- Requiring that the franchisee have a physical location that is open to the public;
- Requiring that the franchisor has at least 3 employees;
- Requiring that the franchisee primarily acquires or builds their own customer base; and
- Requiring that the customers primarily pay directly for goods and services.
Note: in both c) and d), the word ‘primarily’ is used: this because some franchise agreements include credit card processing: the franchisee processes the credit card payment, but the franchisor receives the payment. This is why the word ‘primarily’ must be used, despite the fact that the franchisor is the final party receiving the funds.
Additionally, the exemption described above only covers the franchisee: not the franchisee’s employees, agents, or contractors.
2. SB 900 and Interpreters:
Language interpretation has long existed as an area where both independent contractors and employees have co-existed in a variety of different settings. For example, in the workers’ compensation system, both employees and independent interpreters provided interpretation services in a variety of settings: medical appointments, depositions, and administrative hearings.
AB 5 has dramatically altered this landscape. While an independent contractor can continue to exist, it is with great difficulty: the independent contractor must find a company that is willing to contract with the interpreter under the business-to-business language, which (as discussed below) is difficult. Additionally, AB 5 bars an independent interpreter from working with a referral agency to boost their incoming business unless that referral agency is willing to become their employer. For an independent interpreter, that defeats the entire point of working with a referral agency.
SB 900 address this by permitting certified interpreters to be able to utilize a referral agency and remain an independent contractor. Certified interpreters are interpreters certified by an independent, third party entity as proficient in the language they seek to provide interpretive services AND proficient in interpreting services in the specific context they seem to provide interpretive services. For many employment settings (like schools) and languages, such certification is not possible – these interpreters would not be able to avail themselves of a referral agency as independent contractor. This is further discussed below.
3. Refinements and Points for Additional Discussion:
As the bill moves through the process, the author may wish to consider the following areas of refinement for future amendments and additional discussion with interested stakeholders:
Interpreters, Translators, and Real-Time Captioners
In reaching out to Committee staff, several interpreters note that the provisions of SB 900 are limited to certified interpreters, yet not all languages have certifications. Additionally, some interpreters argue that the current list of applicable certifications does not include several vitally important certification organizations. Finally, one of the certifications listed in SB 900 inaccurately reflects the name of the organization awarding the certification.
Additionally, several translators have reached out to Committee staff, noting that their job responsibilities are significantly different from interpreters. Specifically, multiple translators must coordinate while translating a piece of media, and this coordination may not be permitted under the current structure of SB 900.
Finally, as drafted, SB 900 does not explicitly treat real-time captioners for the deaf and hard of hearing in the same manner as sign language interpreters. This is an oversight, and the author may wish to address this issue, and the issues listed above, in future amendments.
Revisiting the Business-to-Business Provisions
When AB 5 was before this Committee, the author agreed to amendments to exempt business-to-business arrangements from the ABC test. The idea was to ensure that a contract between two independent, unrelated businesses (such as a baker and a website designer) could work together without undue encumbrance. Unfortunately, several constituents have reached out to the Committee and reported the language isn’t working as intended. Specifically, they report that, despite complying with the business-to-business provisions, other businesses will not contract with them due to fear of liability.
This fear of liability is pushing companies to contract with out-of-state contractors, where the risks are much lower. This is not fulfilling the promise of the original business-to-business provision.
Additionally, many healthcare providers, such as physical therapists, respiratory therapists, and pharmacists report that the current structure of the business-to-business language makes it virtually impossible for these professions to contract with medical groups, as they historically have for decades.
The author may wish to address this issue.
4. A Brief word on Collective Action and Individual Control of the Means of Production:
It is not, however, difficult to foresee which of the two parties must, upon all ordinary occasions, have the advantage in the dispute, and force the other into a compliance with their terms. The masters, being fewer in number, can combine much more easily… Many workmen could not subsist a week, few could subsist a month, and scarce any a year without employment.
- Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter 8 (1776)
One of the core shibboleths of modern labor law is that there is a fundamental inequality of power between the employer and the employee. The employee, who is selling his or her labor in order to receive subsistence, only has ownership of his or her labor. The employer, with access and ownership over the factors of production (land, tools, capital, and raw materials) can drive a hard bargain in providing that subsistence and earn profits from the surplus labor of his or her employees.
If, for example, an individual agricultural worker working with hundreds of other agricultural workers demanded an additional $1.00 per bushel of crops, the employer can say no with impunity. The employee has no meaningful leverage over the employer: the employer owns the land, the capital-intensive tools, the crops, and the water. The employee only controls his or her labor, and limited-skill labor is replaceable. The employee risks his or her sustenance for that extra $1.00 per bushel; the employer risks nothing by saying no.
On the other hand, if all of the agricultural workers rose up as one and refused to work without receiving an additional $1.00 per bushel, the employer would face a very different problem – without the crop harvested for market, neither profit nor the ability to recoup costs is possible. Theoretically, the employer could attempt to replace all of his employees, but there are costs associated with replacing so many workers on such a short basis. Instead, the employer may decide to reduce his or her profit, returning some of the surplus value of the employee’s labor to him or her through increased wages.
Yet, not all workers fall within this framework. In occupations with significant barriers to entrance and occupational licensure, for example, the dynamic is quite different. For one, the occupational license is property and is a necessary factor of production. For example, a barber or cosmetologist cannot provide services without a license. The same is true for doctors, lawyers, accountants, veterinarians, and many others already exempted from AB 5.
And it is also true for several of the exemptions in SB 900: specifically, licensed professional clinical counselors, licensed professional clinical social workers, and licensed marriage and family therapists. These licensed professionals own and control the factors of production; by additionally controlling their own labor, they also control the means of production. These occupations have been independent contractors for decades. It is unclear why such arrangements need to change under AB 5. If a licensed clinical counselor wants to contract with a medical group, why should the Legislature bar a licensed professional from doing so?
5. Legitimate State Action and the Right to Organize:
In correspondence with the Committee, some opponents have expressed concerns that revisiting the provision of AB 5 imperil the ability of workers to remain organized. Specifically, opponents have raised the concern that some of occupations described in AB 5 are, in some settings, employees and covered by a collective bargaining agreement. This is also true of AB 5, of course: some physicians, doctors, engineers, accountants, and administrators of human resources are employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement, yet they currently exempted under existing law.
This concern, though, is a fundamental right: the right to organize. Where SB 900 falls short of protecting employees from organizing, or from protecting currently organized employees, the opponents and the author should work together to ensure that this deficiency is addressed.
However, some opponents have put forward a different argument: they say that the Legislature should not revisit AB 5 because they wish to force formerly legal independent contractors to become employees to have the chance to organize these workers. This is a call for the State of California to use its sovereign power to destroy independent small businesses in an attempt to boost union density. These interested stakeholders call upon the Legislature to adopt an “ends justify the means” approach: despite their protestations and economic harm, these workers are wrong and that, in some future date, these workers will be better off as employees and members of a union.
This is a different argument altogether.
6. Proponent Arguments:
The California Association of Marriage and Family Therapists argues the following:
“The California Association of Marriage and Family Therapists (CAMFT) and our 32,000 members applauds your proposal to restore business to business contracting contained in SB 900. This change will allow Marriage and Family Therapists (MFTs) to contract with health agencies to provide therapeutic services to patients. As a result, this change will help to increase access to behavioral health and substance use disorder treatment.
Out-patient mental health care is a primary and typical setting where California residents seek their mental health treatment. A well-established model within these practices is the independent contractor role of the provider. The AB 5 (Dynamex) change to the contractor/employee test has a direct and adverse effect on how marriage and family therapists (MFTs) administer treatments. This change has decreased specialty services and groups, reduced access to care, and significantly increased costs to the patients.
MFTs do not work the typical 9-5, 40-hour week, similar to other types of professions. MFTs are typically working at multiple sites working within a specialty area (i.e., domestic violence groups), which can result in 5-hour time blocks per setting. The business-to-business contracting model is a win-win for the employer, the contractor, and the patient for these types of arrangements.
As the largest mental health provider type in the state, we strive to improve access to mental health care for all Californians. SB 900 to ease artificial barriers to care in a time when our communities need access more than ever.”
7. Opponent Arguments:
The California Labor Federation argues the following:
“SB 900 (Hill) exempts from AB 5 several occupations such as clinical social workers, counselors, and marriage and family therapists, as well as creating loopholes for translators and interpreters and other jobs. These are all workers who are potentially on the frontlines of the COVID-19 crisis, working in health care settings and other public places. In addition, many of these workers are directly employed and are represented by unions. The ostensible “protection” in the bill regarding no exemption for those covered “currently or potentially governed by a collective bargaining agreement” does nothing to prevent employers from undermining and chipping away at union protections. For one, misclassified workers, or potentially those exempted from AB 5, lose the right to organize. As a result, there is no potential to be covered by a CBA and those workers lose the right to organize to negotiate on their own behalf….
There are millions of workers risking their lives during this crisis, and before and after this crisis, to do their jobs. There are also millions of employers who follow the law and treat their workers with respect. These employers provide health benefits, good wages, and retirement security. Many provide more paid sick days than the law requires. They have paid into the UI fund, purchased workers’ compensation insurance, and done their part to support the public safety net. This proposal is fundamentally unfair to those companies since their competitors can use independent contracts and escape their obligations. This is the unfair playing field that AB 5 was intended to address. The rational response will be for these companies to join the race to the bottom and seek to shift their workforce into this new category.”
8. Prior Legislation:
AB 5 (Gonzalez), Chapter 296, Statutes of 2019, is discussed above.
SUPPORT
Associated Builders and Contractors Northern California Chapter
Association of Independent Judicial Interpreters of California
California Association of Marriage and Family Therapists
California Manufactured Housing Institute
Calpace
Cornwell Quality Tools
Deposition Reporters Association of California (DRA)
Mac Tools
Matco Tools
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Snap-On
OPPOSITION
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California School Employees Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Engineers & Scientists of California, Local 20, Ifpte, Afl-cio
Professional & Technical Engineers, Local 21, Ifpte, Afl-cio
SEIU California
UAW Local 2865
Union of American Physicians and Dentists
Unite-here, Afl-cio
United Domestic Workers of America / Afscme, Afl-cio
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
-- END --
One interesting note: Vazquez notes that the state court in Massachusetts found that that this arrangement did NOT violate the state’s ‘ABC’ independent contractor test. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):