SCA 3: Property taxation: change in ownership: inheritance exclusion.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-12-04
The California Constitution generally limits ad valorem taxes on real property to 1% of the full cash value of that property. For purposes of this limitation, full cash value is defined as the assessors valuation of real property as shown on the 197576 tax bill under full cash value or, thereafter, the appraised value of that real property when purchased, newly constructed, or a change in ownership has occurred. The California Constitution specifies various transfers that are not deemed to be a purchase or change in ownership of a property for these purposes, including the purchase or transfer of a principal residence from parents to their children, or, under certain circumstances, from grandparents to their grandchildren, and the purchase or transfer of the first $1,000,000 of the full cash value of all other real property transferred from parents or grandparents to their children or grandchildren.
This measure would limit the above-decribed $1,000,000 exclusion for purchases or transfers of real property other than a principal residence to purchases or transfers of nonresidential real property. The measure, except as provided, would provide that the transfer of the principal residence of a parent or grandparent is excluded from purchase or change in ownership under these provisions only if the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence within 12 months after the transfer. If the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as his or her principal residence, the measure would require that the residence be assessed at its full cash value as of the date of the transfer from the parent or grandparent to the transferee. The measure would provide that these changes apply to a purchase or transfer of real property on or after the effective date of the measure. The measure would also make various nonsubstantive changes.
Resolved by the Senate, the Assembly concurring, That the Legislature of the State of California at its 201920 Regular Session commencing on the third day of December 2018, two-thirds of the membership of each house concurring, hereby proposes to the people of the State of California, that the Constitution of the State be amended as follows:
(a)(1)The full cash value means the county assessors valuation of real property as shown on the 197576 tax bill under full cash value or, thereafter, the appraised value of real property when purchased, newly constructed, or a change in ownership has occurred after the 1975 assessment. All real property not already assessed up to the 197576 full cash value may be reassessed to reflect that valuation. For purposes of this section, newly constructed does not include real property that is reconstructed after a disaster, as declared by the Governor, where the fair market value of the real property, as reconstructed, is comparable to its fair market value prior to the disaster. For purposes of this section, the term newly constructed does not include that portion of an existing structure that consists of the construction or reconstruction of seismic retrofitting components, as defined by the Legislature.
However, the(2)(A)The Legislature may provide that, under appropriate circumstances and pursuant to definitions and procedures established by the Legislature, any person over the age of 55 years who resides in property that is eligible for the homeowners exemption under subdivision (k) of Section 3 of Article XIII and any implementing legislation may transfer the base year value of the property entitled to exemption, with the adjustments authorized by subdivision (b), to any replacement dwelling of equal or lesser value located within the same county and purchased or newly constructed by that person as his or her principal residence within two years of the sale of the original property. For
(B)For purposes of this section, any the following shall apply:
(i)Any person over the age of 55 years includes a married couple one member of which is over the age of 55 years. For purposes of this section, replacement
(ii)Replacement dwelling means a building, structure, or other shelter constituting a place of abode, whether real property or personal property, and any land on which it may be situated. For purposes of this section, a two-dwelling unit shall be considered as two separate single-family dwellings. This
(C)This paragraph shall apply to any replacement dwelling that was purchased or newly constructed on or after November 5, 1986.
In addition, the(3)The Legislature may authorize each county board of supervisors, after consultation with the local affected agencies within the countys boundaries, to adopt an ordinance making the provisions of this subdivision relating to transfer of base year value also applicable to situations in which the replacement dwellings are located in that county and the original properties are located in another county within this State. For purposes of this paragraph, local affected agency means any city, special district, school district, or community college district that receives an annual property tax revenue allocation. This paragraph applies to any replacement dwelling that was purchased or newly constructed on or after the date the county adopted the provisions of this subdivision relating to transfer of base year value, but does not apply to any replacement dwelling that was purchased or newly constructed before November 9, 1988.
The(4)The Legislature may extend the provisions of this subdivision relating to the transfer of base year values from original properties to replacement dwellings of homeowners over the age of 55 years to severely disabled homeowners, but only with respect to those replacement dwellings purchased or newly constructed on or after the effective date of this paragraph.
(b)The full cash value base may reflect from year to year the inflationary rate not to exceed 2 percent for any given year or reduction as shown in the consumer price index or comparable data for the area under taxing jurisdiction, or may be reduced to reflect substantial damage, destruction, or other factors causing a decline in value.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (a), the Legislature may provide that the term newly constructed does not include any of the following:
(1)The construction or addition of any active solar energy system.
(2)The construction or installation of any fire sprinkler system, other fire extinguishing system, fire detection system, or fire-related egress improvement, as defined by the Legislature, that is constructed or installed after the effective date of this paragraph.
(3)The construction, installation, or modification on or after the effective date of this paragraph of any portion or structural component of a single- or multiple-family dwelling that is eligible for the homeowners exemption if the construction, installation, or modification is for the purpose of making the dwelling more accessible to a severely disabled person.
(4)The construction, installation, removal, or modification on or after the effective date of this paragraph of any portion or structural component of an existing building or structure if the construction, installation, removal, or modification is for the purpose of making the building more accessible to, or more usable by, a disabled person.
(5)The construction or addition, completed on or after January 1, 2019, of a rain water capture system, as defined by the Legislature.
(d)For purposes of this section, the term change in ownership does not include the acquisition of real property as a replacement for comparable property if the person acquiring the real property has been displaced from the property replaced by eminent domain proceedings, by acquisition by a public entity, or governmental action that has resulted in a judgment of inverse condemnation. The real property acquired shall be deemed comparable to the property replaced if it is similar in size, utility, and function, or if it conforms to state regulations defined by the Legislature governing the relocation of persons displaced by governmental actions. This subdivision applies to any property acquired after March 1, 1975, but affects only those assessments of that property that occur after the provisions of this subdivision take effect.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the Legislature shall provide that the base year value of property that is substantially damaged or destroyed by a disaster, as declared by the Governor, may be transferred to comparable property within the same county that is acquired or newly constructed as a replacement for the substantially damaged or destroyed property.
(2)Except as provided in paragraph (3), this subdivision applies to any comparable replacement property acquired or newly constructed on or after July 1, 1985, and to the determination of base year values for the 198586 fiscal year and fiscal years thereafter.
(3)In addition to the transfer of base year value of property within the same county that is permitted by paragraph (1), the Legislature may authorize each county board of supervisors to adopt, after consultation with affected local agencies within the county, an ordinance allowing the transfer of the base year value of property that is located within another county in the State and is substantially damaged or destroyed by a disaster, as declared by the Governor, to comparable replacement property of equal or lesser value that is located within the adopting county and is acquired or newly constructed within three years of the substantial damage or destruction of the original property as a replacement for that property. The scope and amount of the benefit provided to a property owner by the transfer of base year value of property pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the scope and amount of the benefit provided to a property owner by the transfer of base year value of property pursuant to subdivision (a). For purposes of this paragraph, affected local agency means any city, special district, school district, or community college district that receives an annual allocation of ad valorem property tax revenues. This paragraph applies to any comparable replacement property that is acquired or newly constructed as a replacement for property substantially damaged or destroyed by a disaster, as declared by the Governor, occurring on or after October 20, 1991, and to the determination of base year values for the 199192 fiscal year and fiscal years thereafter.
(f)For the purposes of subdivision (e):
(1)Property is substantially damaged or destroyed if it sustains physical damage amounting to more than 50 percent of its value immediately before the disaster. Damage includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of restricted access caused by the disaster.
(2)Replacement property is comparable to the property substantially damaged or destroyed if it is similar in size, utility, and function to the property that it replaces, and if the fair market value of the acquired property is comparable to the fair market value of the replaced property prior to the disaster.
(g)For purposes of subdivision (a), the terms purchased and change in ownership do not include the purchase or transfer of real property between spouses since March 1, 1975, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Transfers to a trustee for the beneficial use of a spouse, or the surviving spouse of a deceased transferor, or by a trustee of such a trust to the spouse of the trustor.
(2)Transfers to a spouse that take effect upon the death of a spouse.
(3)Transfers to a spouse or former spouse in connection with a property settlement agreement or decree of dissolution of a marriage or legal separation.
(4)The creation, transfer, or termination, solely between spouses, of any coowners interest.
(5)The distribution of a legal entitys property to a spouse or former spouse in exchange for the interest of the spouse in the legal entity in connection with a property settlement agreement or a decree of dissolution of a marriage or legal separation.
(h)(1)For purposes of subdivision (a), (a) and subject to paragraph (3), the terms purchased and change in ownership do not include the purchase or transfer of the principal residence of the transferor in the case of a purchase or transfer between parents and their children, as defined by the Legislature, and the purchase or transfer of the first one million dollars ($1,000,000) of the full cash value of all other nonresidential real property between parents and their children, as defined by the Legislature. This subdivision applies to both voluntary transfers and transfers resulting from a court order or judicial decree.
(2)(A)Subject to paragraph (3) and subparagraph (B), (B) of this paragraph, commencing with purchases or transfers that occur on or after the date upon which the measure adding this paragraph becomes effective, the exclusion established by paragraph (1) also applies to a purchase or transfer of real property between grandparents and their grandchild or grandchildren, as defined by the Legislature, that otherwise qualifies under paragraph (1), if all of the parents of that grandchild or those grandchildren, who qualify as the children of the grandparents, are deceased as of the date of the purchase or transfer.
(B)A purchase or transfer of a principal residence shall not be excluded pursuant to subparagraph (A) if the transferee grandchild or grandchildren also received a principal residence, or interest therein, through another purchase or transfer that was excludable pursuant to paragraph (1). The full cash value of any real property, other than a principal residence, that was transferred to the grandchild or grandchildren pursuant to a purchase or transfer that was excludable pursuant to paragraph (1), and the full cash value of a principal residence that fails to qualify for exclusion as a result of the preceding sentence, shall be included in applying, for purposes of subparagraph (A), the one-million-dollar ($1,000,000) full cash value limit specified in paragraph (1).
(3)(A)Except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (C), the transfer of a principal residence of a parent or grandparent shall be excluded pursuant to this subdivision only if the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence within 12 months after the transfer. For purposes of this paragraph, a residence shall be deemed to be used as the principal residence of the transferee if it receives the homeowners exemption provided under subdivision (k) of Section 3 of Article XIII.
(B)If the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as his or her principal residence, the exclusion provided for in this subdivision shall no longer apply, and the residence shall be assessed at its full cash value as of the date of the transfer from the parent or grandparent to the transferee, as adjusted in accordance with subdivision (b).
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), a transfer of a principal residence shall be excluded as provided in paragraph (1) or (2), as applicable, if the transferee dies prior to using the residence as his or her primary residence within the 12-month period specified in subparagraph (A). The transfer of the property to a child or grandchild of a deceased transferee, as described in this subparagraph, that otherwise qualifies for exclusion shall be excluded in the manner specified in paragraph (1) or (2), as applicable, subject to the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The changes made to this subdivision by the measure adding this paragraph shall apply to a purchase or transfer of real property on or after the effective date of this paragraph.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the Legislature shall provide with respect to a qualified contaminated property, as defined in paragraph (2), that either, but not both, of the following apply:
(A)(i)Subject to the limitation of clause (ii), the base year value of the qualified contaminated property, as adjusted as authorized by subdivision (b), may be transferred to a replacement property that is acquired or newly constructed as a replacement for the qualified contaminated property, if the replacement real property has a fair market value that is equal to or less than the fair market value of the qualified contaminated property if that property were not contaminated and, except as otherwise provided by this clause, is located within the same county. The base year value of the qualified contaminated property may be transferred to a replacement real property located within another county if the board of supervisors of that other county has, after consultation with the affected local agencies within that county, adopted a resolution authorizing an intercounty transfer of base year value as so described.
(ii)This subparagraph applies only to replacement property that is acquired or newly constructed within five years after ownership in the qualified contaminated property is sold or otherwise transferred.
(B)In the case in which the remediation of the environmental problems on the qualified contaminated property requires the destruction of, or results in substantial damage to, a structure located on that property, the term new construction does not include the repair of a substantially damaged structure, or the construction of a structure replacing a destroyed structure on the qualified contaminated property, performed after the remediation of the environmental problems on that property, provided that the repaired or replacement structure is similar in size, utility, and function to the original structure.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, qualified contaminated property means residential or nonresidential real property that is all of the following:
(A)In the case of residential real property, rendered uninhabitable, and in the case of nonresidential real property, rendered unusable, as the result of either environmental problems, in the nature of and including, but not limited to, the presence of toxic or hazardous materials, or the remediation of those environmental problems, except where the existence of the environmental problems was known to the owner, or to a related individual or entity as described in paragraph (3), at the time the real property was acquired or constructed. For purposes of this subparagraph, residential real property is uninhabitable if that property, as a result of health hazards caused by or associated with the environmental problems, is unfit for human habitation, and nonresidential real property is unusable if that property, as a result of health hazards caused by or associated with the environmental problems, is unhealthy and unsuitable for occupancy.
(B)Located on a site that has been designated as a toxic or environmental hazard or as an environmental cleanup site by an agency of the State of California or the federal government.
(C)Real property that contains a structure or structures thereon prior to the completion of environmental cleanup activities, and that structure or structures are substantially damaged or destroyed as a result of those environmental cleanup activities.
(D)Stipulated by the lead governmental agency, with respect to the environmental problems or environmental cleanup of the real property, not to have been rendered uninhabitable or unusable, as applicable, as described in subparagraph (A), by any act or omission in which an owner of that real property participated or acquiesced.
(3)It shall be rebuttably presumed that an owner of the real property participated or acquiesced in any act or omission that rendered the real property uninhabitable or unusable, as applicable, if that owner is related to any individual or entity that committed that act or omission in any of the following ways:
(A)Is a spouse, parent, child, grandparent, grandchild, or sibling of that individual.
(B)Is a corporate parent, subsidiary, or affiliate of that entity.
(C)Is an owner of, or has control of, that entity.
(D)Is owned or controlled by that entity.
If this presumption is not overcome, the owner shall not receive the relief provided for in subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1). The presumption may be overcome by presentation of satisfactory evidence to the assessor, who shall not be bound by the findings of the lead governmental agency in determining whether the presumption has been overcome.
(4)This subdivision applies only to replacement property that is acquired or constructed on or after January 1, 1995, and to property repairs performed on or after that date.
(j)Unless specifically provided otherwise, amendments to this section adopted prior to November 1, 1988, are effective for changes in ownership that occur, and new construction that is completed, after the effective date of the amendment. Unless specifically provided otherwise, amendments to this section adopted after November 1, 1988, are effective for changes in ownership that occur, and new construction that is completed, on or after the effective date of the amendment.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Senator Hill. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 8, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| May 7, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (May 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Set for hearing May 7. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on E. & C.A. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and E. & C.A. |
| Jan 7, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Dec 5, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 4. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 16, 2019 | Be adopted | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 7, 2019 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Elections and Constitutional Amendments] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SCA 3 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SCA 3
Introduced: 12/4/18
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/24/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach, Nielsen
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 5/7/19
AYES: Umberg, Hertzberg, Leyva, Stern
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Property taxation: change in ownership: inheritance exclusion
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment provides that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion only apply when the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law (California Constitution, Article XIII).
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or when ownership changes (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, as added by Proposition 13, 1978).
- Restricts assessed value inflationary growth of real property to 2% per year.
- Contains two change in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and grandparents and grandchildren, which were then approved by voters:
- Proposition 58 (1986) exempts from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children (ACA 2, Hanigan).
- Proposition 193 (1996) similarly exempts transfers from grandparents to grandchildren, so long as the grandparent is deceased (ACA 17, Knowles).
- Applies these exclusions to all inherited primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers, as well as to up to $1 million in aggregate full cash value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
- Excludes transfers from either the parent to the child or from the child to the parent; however, transfers from grandchildren to grandparents cannot be excluded.
- Requires taxpayers to file the appropriate claim form with the county assessor of the county in which the property is located to apply the exclusion.
- Permits exclusions to be applied retroactively if the claim is filed within three years of the date of the transfer, or before the property has been transferred to a third party, whichever is earlier. Taxpayers can file a claim to apply prospectively at any time.
- Defines “children” to include:
- Any child born to either or both parents, except one adopted by another person before age 18.
- Any stepchild or spouse of that stepchild while the relationship of stepparent and stepchild exists. As of January 1, 2005, a registered domestic partner is a parent to a partner's child.
- Any son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the parent(s) while the in-law relationship exists.
- Any child statutorily adopted by the parent(s) by the age of 18.
- Any foster child of a state-licensed foster parent if that child was not, because of a legal barrier, adopted by the foster parent before the child aged out of the foster care system (AB 402, Ma, Chapter 450, Statutes of 2007).
- Limits the grandparent-grandchild exclusion to only apply if the parent of the grandchild, who was a child of the grandparent, was deceased as of the date of transfer between March 27, 1996, and January 1, 2006. However, transfers made after that date can be excluded when a son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the grandparent is not deceased (SB 555, Machado, Chapter 264, Statutes of 2005). A grandparent - grandchild transfer cannot be excluded even if a living parent disclaims any interest in the grandparent's property.
- Provides that, as of January 1, 2005, an in-law child includes a registered domestic partner, and a registered domestic partner is a parent to a partner's child.
- Allows taxpayers to claim the homeowners’ exemption for their principal residences, defined as the taxpayer's true, fixed and permanent home, and principal establishment to which they intend to return if absent.
This constitutional amendment:
- Limits the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusions for transfers of a principal residences to only those cases in which the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence within 12 months after the transfer, evidenced by claiming the homeowner’s exemption.
- Provides that if the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as his or her principal residence, the exclusion no longer applies, and the residence must be reassessed as of the date of the transfer unless the transferee dies prior to using the residence as his or her primary residence within the 12-month period.
- Restricts the exclusion for other real property subject to the $1 million limit only to nonresidential property.
- Applies to transfers made on or after its effective date.
- Makes a technical change.
Background
In October 2017, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) published “the Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion,” indicating that the Legislature may want to review the exclusion. LAO wrote:
“The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents’ lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner‑occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.”
In August, 2018, the Los Angeles Times identified several homes owned by prominent, wealthy individuals who were subsequently renting out homes after applying the exclusion on residences inherited from their parents. The article stated that in Los Angeles County, as many as 63% of homes subject to the exclusion were used as second residences or rental properties last year. The author wants to require grandchildren to make any property to which the exclusion applies their principal place of residence.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the State Board of Equalization (BOE) estimates the revenue gain due to reassessment at $1,780 per instance when a transferee does not make the transferred property their principal residence within 12 months after the transfer. BOE’s administrative costs would be minor and absorbable. This measure will result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State in the range of $438,000 to $584,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
California Professional Firefighters
California Teachers Association
San Francisco Unified School District
Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District
Schools for Sound Finance
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “SCA 3 is about equity and fairness. It would modify the property tax inheritance exclusion law prospectively to require children and grandchildren that inherit a home to actually live in the home in order to keep their Prop 13 base year and to avoid reassessment. California local governments shouldn’t be subsidizing inherited rental properties that are making the owners money. Local governments rely on property taxes as a significant portion of their budgets. This funds libraries, parks, police and fire protection just to name a few. California is the only state to provide this tax break, which was designed to protect families from sharp tax increases on the death of a loved one not to subsidize owners who rent out their homes for extra income.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, “HJTA strongly opposes changes to Proposition 58 and the intergenerational transfer provision. Article 13A Section 3 of the California Constitution states that, ‘any change in state statute that leads to any taxpayer paying a higher tax…’ is a tax. SCA 3 will result in double taxation because property owners are already paying income taxes on inherited property they rent out. In the latter instance, children shouldn’t be forced to pay higher property taxes because they decide to not make the home their primary residence. This will only serve to make rents more expensive and exacerbate our affordable housing crisis.”
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/18/19 13:18:46
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SCA 3 (Hill) - Property taxation: change in ownership: inheritance exclusion
Version: December 4, 2018 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 5 - 2, E. & C.A. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SCA 3, if approved by the voters, would provide that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion only apply when only transferees use the residence as their principal residence.
Fiscal Impact:
- The State Board of Equalization (BOE) estimates the revenue gain due to reassessment at $1,780 per instance when a transferee does not make the transferred property their principal residence within 12 months after the transfer. BOE’s administrative costs would be minor and absorbable.
- This bill would result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $438,000 to $584,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
Background:
The California Constitution provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. Specifically, under Propositoin 13 (1978), the Constitution (1) limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1 percent of full cash value, and (2) directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is a change in ownership. Proposition 13 also set a constitutional limit on assessed value inflationary growth of real property of 2 percent per year.
However, the Legislature enacted two change in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and then grandparents and grandchildren, which were then approved by voters. Proposition 58 (1986) exempted from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children which voters extended to grandchildren ten years later, so long as the grandparent is deceased. These exclusions apply to all inherited primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers. They also apply to up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
A qualifying parent-child transfer can be from the parent to the child or vice-versa; however, transfers from grandchildren to grandparents cannot be excluded. Transfers of interests in legal entities do not qualify. The exclusion only applies when the appropriate claim form is filed with the county assessor of the county in which the property is located. The exclusions can be applied retroactively if the claim is filed within three years of the date of the transfer, or before the property has been transferred to a third party, whichever is earlier. A claim can be filed to apply prospectively at any time.
In October, 2017, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) published “the Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion,” indicating that the Legislature may want to review the exclusion. LAO wrote:
“The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents’ lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner‑occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.”
In August, 2018, the Los Angeles Times identified several homes owned by prominent, wealthy individuals who were subsequently renting out homes after applying the exclusion on residences inherited from their parents. The article stated that in Los Angeles County, as many as 63 percent of homes subject to the exclusion were used as second residences or rental properties last year.
Proposed Law:
This SCA would provide that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusions only apply when the transferee uses the residence as a principal residence within 12 months after the transfer, meaning that they claim the homeowner’s exemption. If the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as a principal residence, the exclusion no longer applies, and the residence must be reassessed as of the date of the transfer unless the transferee dies prior to using the residence as his or her primary residence within the 12-month period. The SCA would apply to transfers made after its effective date. The measure also provides that any other real property subject to the $1 million exclusion for other property must be nonresidential.
Related Legislation:
- SCA 4 (Galgiani, 2019) would, among other things, limit the exclusion for the purchase or transfer of a principal residence between parents and their children and between grandparents and their grandchild or grandchildren to instances in which the residence continues as the principal residence of the transferee. The measure is currently pending in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
Staff Comments:
SOS indicates that printing and mailing costs associated with placing a measure on the statewide ballot are approximately $73,000 per page, depending on the length of the ballot. The fiscal estimates noted above reflect the addition of 6-8 pages in the Voter Information Guide. Actual costs would depend upon the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
The 2017-18 average assessed value of all properties receiving the homeowners' exemption was $394,000. Per the California Association of Realtors, the October 2018 median home sale price for a single family residence in California was $572,000. The affected assessed value difference is $178,000. At the 1 percent basic property tax rate, the revenue gain is $1,780 per instance when a transferee does not make the transferred property their principal residence within 12 months after the transfer. The annual number of such instances that would occur in a given year is unknown.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SCA 3 Hearing Date: 5/7/19
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | 12/4/18 | ||
Urgency: |
| Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Darren Chesin | ||
Subject: Property taxation: change in ownership: inheritance exclusion
DIGEST
This measure provides that the property tax parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusions only apply when only the transferee uses the residence as their principal residence.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that all real property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. The Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is a change in ownership (Proposition 13 of 1978). Proposition 13 also set a constitutional limit on assessed value inflationary growth of real property of 2% per year.
- Provides, also pursuant to the Constitution, for two changes in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and grandparents and grandchildren. Proposition 58 of 1986 exempted from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children, which voters extended to grandchildren ten years later, so long as the grandparent is deceased (Proposition 193 of 1996). Both of those measures were placed on the ballot by the Legislature. These exclusions apply to all inherited primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers. They also apply up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
- Provides that a qualifying parent-child transfer can be from the parent to the child or from the child to the parent; however, transfers from grandchildren to grandparents cannot be excluded.
- Defines “children” for these purposes.
This measure:
- Provides that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusions would only apply when the transferee uses the residence as their principal residence within 12 months after the transfer, meaning that they claim the homeowner’s exemption.
- Provides that if the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as their principal residence, the exclusion no longer applies, and the residence must be reassessed as of the date of the transfer unless the transferee dies prior to using the residence as their primary residence within the 12-month period.
- Applies only to transfers made after the effective date of the measure once approved by the voters.
- Provides that any other real property subject to the $1 million exclusion for other property must be nonresidential, and makes a technical change.
BACKGROUND
LAO Report. In October, 2017, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) published a report titled “The Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion,” indicating that the Legislature may want to review the exclusion. In the report, the LAO wrote:
“The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents’ lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner‑occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.”
The combination of the Proposition 13 method of property taxation and the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion can be highly beneficial, with benefits that grow the longer the same family owns the property. Most properties’ assessed valuation is well below its market value because of the 2% cap on inflationary property value growth, so a typical property in the state is about two‑thirds of its market value, according to LAO. LAO adds that the exclusion that SCA 3 limits is applied to between 60,000 and 80,000 properties statewide each year, or about 10% of total property transfers. Additionally, LAO states that 5% of all property transfers in the state in the last decade apply the exclusion, the vast majority of which are single-family homes. LAO also states that the exclusion has a significant cost, estimating that exclusions reduced statewide property tax revenues by around $1.5 billion from what they would be in the absence of the exclusion in 2015-16. Additionally, the exclusion can be applied to the same property an infinite number of times, thereby providing a benefit that increases the more the value of the property grows and the longer the same family holds it.
These Dudes Abide Current Law. In August, 2018, the Los Angeles Times identified several homes owned by prominent, wealthy individuals who were subsequently renting out homes after applying the exclusion on residences inherited from their parents. The article stated that in Los Angeles County, as many as 63% of homes subject to the exclusion were used as second residences or rental properties last year.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: SCA 3 is about equity and fairness. It would modify the property tax inheritance exclusion law (prospectively) to require children and grandchildren that inherit a home to actually live in the home in order to keep their Proposition 13 base year and to avoid reassessment. California local governments shouldn’t be subsidizing inherited rental properties that are making the owners money. Local governments rely on property taxes as a significant portion of their budgets. This funds libraries, parks, police and fire protection just to name a few. California is the only state to provide this tax break, which was designed to protect families from sharp tax increases on the death of a loved one not to subsidize owners who rent out their homes for extra income.
SCA 3 would prospectively modify the property tax inheritance law, allowing inheritors to keep their parents’ or grandparents’ assessed value for property taxes if they live in the home as their primary residence within 12 months of inheriting the property. If they decide to rent out the home, it would be reassessed to market rate and the property taxes would be adjusted accordingly.
The LAO estimates a reduction in tax revenue by a few billion dollars per year due to these exemptions, accounting for about 2.5% percent of total statewide property tax revenue. Additionally, the significant difference in annual property tax rates between new homeowners and inheritors of similar properties has contributed to inequality exacerbation. Lastly, LAO property data from Los Angeles County suggests that around 60% of inherited homes may be used as rental income, and are not the inheritor’s primary residence.
Those that benefit from a rental income from a property they inherited should have to pay their fair share of property taxes. Local governments should not have to bear the brunt of this exclusion when those that inherit properties are renting them out for income. Local police, fire, libraries, parks etc. are already financially struggling across the state and shouldn’t suffer unnecessarily more because of this inheritance exclusion law. - Argument in Support. In a letter supporting SCA 3, the California Teachers Association stated, in part:
The existing loophole in the tax reassessment of transferred properties that are not used as the principal residence of the heir reduces funding that schools currently receive from local property taxes. By closing the loophole, school districts would receive additional property tax revenues which, in turn, would make the guaranteed Proposition 98 portion of the state budget go further to address student needs.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing SCA 3, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assocition stated, in part:
HJTA strongly opposes changes to Proposition 58 and the intergenerational transfer provision. Article 13A Section 3 of the California Constitution states that, “any change in state statute that leads to any taxpayer paying a higher tax…” is a tax. SCA 3 will result in double taxation because property owners are already paying income taxes on inherited property they rent out. In the latter instance, children shouldn’t be forced to pay higher property taxes because they decide to not make the home their primary residence. This will only serve to make rents more expensive and exacerbate our affordable housing crisis.
- Hard to enforce? SCA 3 conditions the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion on descendants claiming the homeowner’s exemption from property tax, which is a $7,000 reduction in taxable value when the home is the principal place of residence of the owner on January 1st of the year the exemption is claimed. The property must be the taxpayer's true, fixed and permanent home, and principal establishment to which they intend to return if absent. Assessors use vehicle registration, voter registration, bank accounts, and state income tax filings to determine whether a property qualifies. Once granted, the exemption continues until the taxpayer notifies the assessor or ownership changes. However, SCA 3’s effectiveness depends on local assessors verifying that descendants applying the transfer are indeed living there, and some assessors may not prioritize enforcing the requirement.
- Just homes. SCA 3 limits the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion for other property up to $1 million solely to nonresidential property. As a result, the exclusion will continue to apply to commercial, industrial, agricultural, and vacant property not zoned residential, but not to vacation homes, second homes, residential rental properties, multi-unit residential properties, and vacant property zoned residential. Assessors could revalue a mixed property if the transferee does not occupy the residential portion as a principal residence.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SCA 4 (Galgiani) of 2019, which is pending in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee, would, among other things, limit the exclusion for the purchase or transfer of a principal residence between parents and their children and between grandparents and their grandchild or grandchildren to instances in which the residence continues as the principal residence of the transferee.
PRIOR ACTION
Senate Governance & Finance Committee: | 5-2 |
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: California Professional Firefighters
California Teachers Association
San Francisco Unified School District
Schools For Sound Finance
Oppose: Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SCA 3 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/19 |
Author: | Hill | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 12/4/18 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Property taxation: change in ownership: inheritance exclusion
Provides that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion only apply when only the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence.
Background
Article XIII of the California Constitution provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. Article XIIIA of the Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is a change in ownership (Proposition 13, 1978). Proposition 13 also set a constitutional limit on assessed value inflationary growth of real property of 2% per year.
However, the Legislature enacted two change in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and then grandparents and grandchildren, which were then approved by voters. Proposition 58 (1986) exempted from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children (ACA 2, Hanigan), which voters extended to grandchildren ten years later, so long as the grandparent is deceased (Proposition 193, 1996; ACA 17, Knowles). These exclusions apply to all inherited primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers. They also apply to up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
A qualifying parent-child transfer can be from the parent to the child or from the child to the parent; however, transfers from grandchildren to grandparents cannot be excluded. Transfers of interests in legal entities do not qualify. The exclusion only applies when the appropriate claim form is filed with the county assessor of the county in which the property is located. The exclusions can be applied retroactively if the claim is filed within three years of the date of the transfer, or before the property has been transferred to a third party, whichever is earlier. A claim can be filed to apply prospectively at any time.
State law implements the exclusion to define “children” to include:
- Any child born to either or both parents, except one adopted by another person before age 18.
- Any stepchild or spouse of that stepchild while the relationship of stepparent and stepchild exists. As of January 1, 2005, a registered domestic partner is a parent to a partner's child.
- Any son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the parent(s) while the in-law relationship exists.
- Any child statutorily adopted by the parent(s) by the age of 18.
- Any foster child of a state-licensed foster parent if that child was not, because of a legal barrier, adopted by the foster parent before the child aged out of the foster care system (AB 402, Ma, 2007).
Between March 27, 1996, and January 1, 2006, the grandparent-grandchild exclusion only applied if the parent of the grandchild, who was a child of the grandparent, was deceased as of the date of transfer. However, transfers made after that date can be excluded when a son-in-law or daughter-in-law of the grandparent is not deceased (SB 555, Machado, 2005). A grandparent - grandchild transfer is not excluded even if a living parent disclaims any interest in the grandparent's property. As of January 1, 2005, an in-law child includes a registered domestic partner, and a registered domestic partner is a parent to a partner's child.
In October, 2017, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) published “the Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion,” indicating that the Legislature may want to review the exclusion. LAO wrote:
“The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents’ lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner‑occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.”
In August, 2018, the Los Angeles Times identified several homes owned by prominent, wealthy individuals who were subsequently renting out homes after applying the exclusion on residences inherited from their parents. The article stated that in Los Angeles County, as many as 63% of homes subject to the exclusion were used as second residences or rental properties last year. The author wants to require grandchildren to make any property to which the exclusion applies their principal place of residence.
Proposed Law
Senate Constitutional Amendment 3 provides that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusions only apply when the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence within 12 months after the transfer, meaning that they claim the homeowner’s exemption. If the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as his or her principal residence, the exclusion no longer applies, and the residence must be reassessed as of the date of the transfer unless the transferee dies prior to using the residence as his or her primary residence within the 12-month period. SCA 3 applies to transfers made after its effective date. The measure also provides that any other real property subject to the $1 million exclusion for other property must be nonresidential, and makes a technical change.
State Revenue Impact
The State Board of Equalization (BOE) estimates revenue gain due to reassessment at $1,780 per instance when a transferee does not make the transferred property their principal residence within 12 months after the transfer.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SCA 3 is about equity and fairness. It would modify the property tax inheritance exclusion law prospectively to require children and grandchildren that inherit a home to actually live in the home in order to keep their Prop 13 base year and to avoid reassessment. California local governments shouldn’t be subsidizing inherited rental properties that are making the owners money. Local governments rely on property taxes as a significant portion of their budgets. This funds libraries, parks, police and fire protection just to name a few. California is the only state to provide this tax break, which was designed to protect families from sharp tax increases on the death of a loved one not to subsidize owners who rent out their homes for extra income.”
2. Forced sales? Currently, older generations can transfer property to their lineal descendants without a reassessment, passing along the savings that have accrued under California’s Proposition 13 method of property taxation. SCA 3 adds a key requirement for future transfers of principal residences: the descendants must live in that residence to enjoy the tax benefit. If the descendants do not, property taxes could increase significantly. As a result, many descendants who cannot or do not wish to relocate may have to sell the homes where their parents or grandparents raised them, or come up with other funds sufficient to pay the additional taxes. However, by ending a tax benefit for converting inherited properties into rental properties, SCA 3 could help ameliorate the state’s affordable housing crisis by ending the significant incentive to hold these properties off the home sales market.
3. Good deal. The combination of the Proposition 13 method of property taxation and the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion can be highly beneficial, with benefits that grow the longer the same family owns the property. Most properties’ assessed valuation is well below its market value because of the 2% cap on inflationary property value growth, so a typical property in the state is about two‑thirds of its market value, according to LAO. LAO adds that the exclusion that SCA 3 limits is applied to between 60,000 and 80,000 properties statewide each year, or about 10% of total property transfers. Additionally, LAO states that 5% of all property transfers in the state in the last decade apply the exclusion, the vast majority of which are single-family homes. LAO also states that the exclusion has a significant cost, estimating that exclusions reduced statewide property tax revenues by around $1.5 billion from what they would be in the absence of the exclusion in 2015-16. Additionally, the exclusion can be applied to the same property an infinite number of times, thereby providing a benefit that increases the more the value of the property grows and the longer the same family holds it.
4. Equitable? Proposition 13’s tax benefits grow the longer the taxpayer stays in their home. As a result, older generations benefit more than younger ones. The grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion increases this benefit the longer the home stays in the hands of the same family.
As a result, the existing shift in tax burden to younger homeowners from older ones is exacerbated by the exclusion SCA 3 would limit. LAO points out that the children of homeowners tend to be financially better off as adults relying on date from the Panel Survey of Income Dynamics, which suggests that Californians who grew up in a home owned by their parents had a median income over $70,000 in 2015, compared to less than $50,000 for those whose parents were renters. LAO adds that several nationwide studies have found that children of homeowners tend to be better off as adults in various categories including educational attainment and homeownership. Additionally, most younger people have to borrow money and take on a mortgage to purchase a home, whereas inherited homes are usually paid off.
5. Hard to enforce? SCA 3 conditions the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion on descendants claiming the homeowner’s exemption from property tax, which is a $7,000 reduction in taxable value when the home is the principal place of residence of the owner on January 1st of the year the exemption is claimed. The property must be the taxpayer's true, fixed and permanent home, and principal establishment to which they intend to return if absent. Assessors use vehicle registration, voter registration, bank accounts, and state income tax filings to determine whether a property qualifies. Once granted, the exemption continues until the taxpayer notifies the assessor or ownership changes. However, SCA 3’s effectiveness depends on local assessors verifying that descendants applying the transfer are indeed living there, and some assessors may not prioritize enforcing the requirement.
6. Just homes. SCA 3 limits the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion for other property up to $1 million solely to nonresidential property. As a result, the exclusion will continue to apply to commercial, industrial, agricultural, and vacant property not zoned residential, but not to vacation homes, second homes, residential rental properties, multi-unit residential properties, and vacant property zoned residential. Assessors could revalue a mixed- property if the transferee does not occupy the residential portion as a principal residence.
7. Double-referred. The Senate Rules Committee ordered a double-referral for SCA 3, first to the Governance and Finance Committee, and second to the Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
Support and Opposition
(4/19/19)
Support: California Professional Firefighters, California Teachers Association, San Francisco Unified School District, Schools for Sound Finance.
Opposition: Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):