SCA 5: Taxation: school districts: parcel tax.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-22
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Senator Hill. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 8, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| May 7, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (May 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Set for hearing May 7. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted and re-refer to Com. on E. & C.A. (Ayes 4. Noes 3.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on GOV. & F., E. & C.A., and APPR. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 30. |
| Feb 27, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 16, 2019 | Be adopted | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 7, 2019 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Elections and Constitutional Amendments] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SCA 5 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SCA 5
Author: Hill (D) and Allen (D), et al.
Amended: 4/22/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 4-3, 4/24/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach, Hurtado, Nielsen
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 5/7/19
AYES: Umberg, Hertzberg, Leyva, Stern
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Taxation: school districts: parcel tax
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval under specified circumstances.
Existing law:
- Requires 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature for state tax increases (Article XIIIA, Section Three, as added by Proposition 13, 1978).
- States that taxes levied by local governments are either general taxes, subject to majority approval of its voters, or special taxes, subject to 2/3 vote; and bars school districts from imposing general taxes (Article XIII C).
- Applies those vote thresholds to charter cities, and sets forth a specific process for local agencies to levy new assessments, fees, and taxes (Proposition 218, 1996).
- Requires a 2/3 vote for the state or local agencies to issue general obligation bonds; however, voters subsequently allowed school districts, community college districts, and county offices of education to issue bonded indebtedness for school facilities with 55% approval (Proposition 39, 2000), if the district included in the proposition authorizing the issuance of the bonds:
- A requirement that the proceeds only be spent on the purposes specified, which includes the construction, reconstruction, rehabilitation, or replacement of school facilities, including furnishing and equipping school facilities, as well as acquiring or leasing real property, and not for any other purpose.
- A list of the facilities projects to be funded, and a certification that the district has evaluated safety, class size reduction, and information technology needs in developing the list.
- A requirement that the district conduct an annual independent performance audit to ensure funds are only being spent on projects on the list.
- A requirement that the district conduct an annual independent financial audit until all bond funds have been expended.
- Permits school and community college districts to impose “qualified special taxes” that apply uniformly to all taxpayers or real property within the district, and allow school, but not community college, districts to exempt persons over the age of 65 from the tax.
- Allows 15 other types of local agencies to impose similar taxes; however, while these local agencies can tax unimproved property at a lower rate than improved property, they can afford no other exemptions.
- Authorizes school districts to exempt persons receiving Supplemental Security Income regardless of age (AB 385, Lieber, Chapter 41, Statutes of 2006), and persons receiving Social Security Disability Insurance, whose yearly income was less than 250% of federal poverty guidelines (SB 874, Hancock, Chapter 791, Statutes of 2012).
- Applies additional accountability measures when local agencies seek to impose special taxes (SB 165, Alarcon, Chapter 535, Statutes of 2000), including to:
- Issue a statement indicating the specific purpose of the tax;
- Require that the proceeds be used only for the purpose in the statement;
- Create an account in which to deposit proceeds; and,
- Publish an annual report that includes the amount of funds collected and expended, along with the status of any project required or authorized by the tax measure.
This constitutional amendment:
- Allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval if a majority vote of the school district governing board approves the measure, and the proposition contains:
- A list of the specific purposes and programs that are to be funded.
- A requirement that the proceeds be used only for the purposes and programs specified in the proposition, and not for any other purpose.
- A requirement that the governing board of the school district conduct an annual independent financial audit of the amount of parcel tax proceeds collected and expended, and the specified purposes and programs funded.
- Defines “parcel tax” as “a special tax imposed upon a parcel of real property at a rate that is determined without regard to that property’s value.”
- Makes technical and conforming changes.
Background
Parcel taxes are not ad valorem or assessed based on the value of a property like property taxes; instead they are generally a flat rate assessed per parcel regardless of its size, or per square foot of a parcel or its improvements. Agencies can use revenues in almost any way that serves local needs, such as ongoing expenses, programs, or buildings. Counties collect parcel taxes with property taxes, and then remit funds to the agency imposing the tax. Property tax law generally guides parcel tax collection.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill would result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $438,000 to $584,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
Alameda Unified School District
Association Of California School Administrators
Big Creek School District
Cabrillo Unified School District
California Association Of School Business Officials
California Association Of Suburban School Districts
California Federation Of Teachers
California Retired Teachers Association
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Contra Costa County Superintendents Coalition
Foothill - De Anza Community College District
Fresno Unified School District
Healdsburg Unified School District
Jurupa Unified School District
Larkspur – Corte Madera School District
Las Virgenes Unified School District
Monterey County Office Of Education
Murrieta Valley Unified School District
Norwalk - La Mirada Unified School District
Paramount Unified School District
Peralta Community College District
Redwood City Education Foundation
San Bernardino County District Advocates For Better Schools
San Diego Community College District
San Diego Unified School District
San Francisco Unified School District
Santa Clara County Office Of Education
School Employers Association Of California
Schools For Sound Finance
Scotts Valley Unified School District
Service Employees International Union
Small School Districts Association
South Bay Union School District
Torrance Unified School District
Ventura County Office Of Education
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Charter School Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Taxpayers Association
Family Business Association of California
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Kern County Taxpayers Association
NAIOP of California
Orange County Taxpayers Association
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Sonoma County Taxpayers Association
Southwest California Legislative Council
Sutter County Taxpayers Association
West Coast Lumber and Building Materials Association
Western Manufactured Communities Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Despite significant increases in state funding for schools in recent years, districts are struggling to maintain quality educational services and programs amid escalating costs and declining enrollment. Teacher layoffs or furloughs and cut programs are among the results. Parcel taxes are one of the few means school districts have to supplement their funding. Yet the current requirement for a two-thirds supermajority vote to pass school parcel taxes has enabled a minority of voters to block efforts to provide vital local education funding. If communities want to invest in education and provide our students more resources, they should be able to do so. SCA 5 retains the requirement for supermajority approval of local school parcel taxes, but the legislation changes the supermajority threshold to a more realistic percentage.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Chamber of Commerce, “Under SCA 5, a parcel tax could be disproportionately directed at commercial property within the local jurisdiction, thereby undermining the protections that have been in place since Proposition 13 was adopted in 1978. The absence of any guarantee of uniformity in SCA 5 would allow discriminatory taxation against commercial property versus residential. The current two-thirds vote requirement for parcel taxes provides a mechanism by which voters can still approve tax increases while protecting the interests of a small minority of taxpayers. We appreciate the budget dilemmas that many school districts face today. The combination of declining enrollments and pressures from employment contracts and pension and health care obligations often force arduous budget decisions. Yet, most school districts that have proposed parcel taxes have gained the requisite supermajority approval, so voters usually are sympathetic to their needs. Further, the more stringent approval threshold requires districts to balance the needs of taxpayers, which usually results in a fair and nondiscriminatory tax. SCA 5 would upset this balance.”
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/18/19 11:39:08
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SCA 5 (Hill) - Taxation: school districts: parcel tax
Version: April 22, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 4 - 3, E. & C.A. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SCA 5, if approved by the voters, would allow a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55 percent voter approval under specified circumstances.
Fiscal Impact:
This bill would result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $438,000 to $584,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
Background:
Under the California Constitution, taxes levied by local governments are either (1) general taxes, subject to majority approval of its voters, or (2) special taxes, subject to 2/3 vote. Proposition 13 (1978) required a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature for state tax increases, and 2/3 vote of local voters for local special taxes. Proposition 62 (1986) prohibited local agencies from imposing general taxes without majority approval of local voters, and a 2/3 vote for special taxes. Proposition 218 (1996) extended those vote thresholds to charter cities, and limited local agencies’ powers to levy new assessments, fees, and taxes. The Constitution further bars school districts from imposing general taxes, but (pursuant to Proposition 39, 2000) allows school districts, community college districts, and county offices of education to issue bonded indebtedness for school facilities with 55 percent approval.
Parcel taxes are a flat rate assessed per parcel of land, regardless of its size or its improvements. They are a common form local tax, and can be imposed by cities, counties, or special districts. Agencies can use revenues in almost any way that serves local needs, such as ongoing expenses, programs, or buildings. Counties collect parcel taxes with property taxes, and then remit funds to the agency imposing the tax. Property tax law generally guides parcel tax collection.
Proposed Law:
This SCA would, among other things, do the following:
- Allow a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55 percent voter approval if a majority vote of the school district governing board approves the measure, and the proposition contains:
- A list of the specific purposes and programs that are to be funded.
- A requirement that the proceeds be used only for the purposes and programs specified in the proposition, and not for any other purpose.
- A requirement that the governing board of the school district conduct an annual independent financial audit of the amount of parcel tax proceeds collected and expended, and the specified purposes and programs funded.
Related Legislation:
- SCA 22 (Allen, 2018) would have allowed a school district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax on real property with the approval of 55 percent, instead of two-thirds, of voters of the district if certain conditions are met. The measure was held under submission on the Suspense File of this Committee.
- SCA 6 (Wiener, 2017) would have lowered the vote threshold for local government agencies to levy a special tax for transportation infrastructure projects from 2/3 to 55 percent. The bill was held under submission on the Suspense File of this Committee.
- SCA 3 (Leno) of 2013, SCA 5 (Simitian) of 2011, SCA 6 (Simitian) of 2009, SCA 17 (Simitian) of 2008, SCA 8 (Simitian) of 2005, and ACA 4 (Simitian) were all substantially similar to SCA 5. None of these measures were enacted.
Staff Comments:
SOS indicates that printing and mailing costs associated with placing a measure on the statewide ballot are approximately $73,000 per page, depending on the length of the ballot. The fiscal estimates noted above reflect the addition of 6-8 pages in the Voter Information Guide. Actual costs would depend upon the length of the title and summary, analysis by the Legislative Analyst’s Office, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SCA 5 Hearing Date: 5/7/19
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | 4/22/19 | ||
Urgency: |
| Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Darren Chesin | ||
Subject: Taxation: school districts: parcel tax
DIGEST
This measure allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval under specified circumstances.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that taxes levied by local governments are either general taxes, subject to majority approval of its voters, or special taxes, subject to two-thirds vote (Article XIII C). Proposition 13 of 1978 required a two-thirds vote of each house of the Legislature for state tax increases, and a two-thirds vote of local voters for local special taxes. Proposition 62 of 1986 prohibited local agencies from imposing general taxes without majority approval of local voters, and a two-thirds vote for special taxes. Proposition 218 of 1996 extended those vote thresholds to charter cities and limited local agencies’ powers to levy new assessments, fees, and taxes. The Constitution further bars school districts from imposing general taxes. Additionally, the California Constitution has historically required a two-thirds vote for issuing bonds since 1879, but voters subsequently allowed school districts, community college districts, and county offices of education to issue bonded indebtedness for school facilities with 55% approval when complying with specified requirements (Proposition 39 of 2000).
- Provides that cities, counties, and special districts may impose special taxes, except ad valorem taxes on real property or a transaction tax or sales tax on the sale of real property within the local jurisdiction, with a two-thirds vote of the jurisdiction’s voters.
This measure:
- Allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval if a majority vote of the school district governing board approves the measure, and the proposition contains:
- A list of the specific purposes and programs that are to be funded.
- A requirement that the proceeds be used only for the purposes and programs specified in the proposition, and not for any other purpose.
- A requirement that the governing board of the school district conduct an annual independent financial audit of the amount of parcel tax proceeds collected and expended, and the specified purposes and programs funded.
- Makes various technical and conforming changes.
BACKGROUND
Proposition 13 and Proposition 62. Proposition 13 was added to the California Constitution in June 1978 and was designed to provide real property tax relief by imposing a set of limitations upon the assessment and taxing powers of state and local governments. This included a required two-thirds vote of each house of the Legislature for state tax increases as well as a two-thirds vote of local voters for local special taxes.
In 1986, Proposition 62 prohibited local agencies from imposing general taxes without majority approval of local voters and a two-thirds vote for special taxes. Proposition 218 of 1996 extended those vote thresholds to charter cities, and limited the powers of local agencies to levy new assessments, fees, and taxes. Local agencies generally propose to increase taxes by adopting an ordinance or a resolution at a public hearing. Proposition 39 of 2000 further barred school districts from imposing general taxes, but allows school districts, community college districts, and county offices of education to issue bonded indebtedness for school facilities with 55% percent approval.
Parcel Taxes. One common form of local tax is a parcel tax, which can be imposed by cities, counties, or special districts. Parcel taxes are not ad valorem or assessed based on the value of a property like property taxes. Instead, parcel taxes are generally a flat rate assessed per parcel regardless of size, per square foot of a parcel, or its improvements. Agencies can use revenues in almost any way that serves local needs, such as ongoing expenses, programs, or buildings. Counties collect parcel taxes with property taxes, and then remit funds to the agency imposing the tax. Existing property tax law generally guides parcel tax collection.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: California school and community college districts are struggling to keep quality educational programs and services, teachers and staff. Despite recent state funding increases, an estimated two thirds of school districts will have deficits in Fiscal Year 2019-20. California’s community colleges continue to be funded, per student, at levels significantly lower than that of California State Universities and the University of California.
Parcel taxes allow school and community college districts to raise revenue and supplement funds received from the state and outside sources, however, they remain inaccessible to most communities given the high two-thirds voter threshold. SCA 5 would allow school and community college district voters to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax with 55% voter approval, rather than a two-thirds vote requirement.
If a 55% voting threshold had been in place, significantly more parcel tax measures would have been approved. Between 1983 and 2012, 271 school district parcel tax measures failed to get a two-thirds vote. Of those measures 192 – about 71% – received at least 55% support. More than 80% of the 26 local school parcel tax measures that failed in California from 2012 to 2017 would have passed if a supermajority vote of 55% was required for approval, instead of a two-thirds vote.
If communities want to invest in education and provide our students with more resources, they should be able to do so. SCA 5 retains the requirement for supermajority approval local school parcel taxes, but changes the supermajority threshold to a more realistic percentage. - Argument in Support. In a letter supporting SCA 5, the Association of California School Administrators, stated, in part:
The success of California depends on the success of our education system. SCA 5 gives communities a more democratic process to properly fund their education priorities. Lowering the voter threshold would also make the passage of parcel taxes consistent with the threshold now required to pass school and community college facility bonds.
SCA 5 is critical given the present state of education funding. Despite increased state funding investments to public education in recent years, California continues to rank near the bottom among the states in K-12 per student spending. At the same time, polls consistently find California voters identify education as their top funding priority. It is time to give local voters the opportunity to fund those educational programs that are important to them. Parcel taxes are one of the few avenues available to local school districts to raise revenue to supplement state funding. SCA 5 will increase opportunities for local communities to make choices regarding local and stable funding streams.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing SCA 5, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, stated, in part:
Lowering the two-thirds vote is unnecessary. Many communities, including Orange County, have passed numerous local special taxes for transportation purposes. With appropriate justification, the threshold can clearly be reached. According to the website California City Finance, a review of school district parcel taxes since 2012 showed that in November elections, 52 of 69 or 75 percent were approved.
Of all the taxes that could be imposed to fund education, parcel taxes are clearly the most inequitable. Because they are assigned either as a flat rate tax per parcel or based on square footage, they are extremely regressive. The fact that an average middle class family pays the same tax as an individual in a multi-million dollar mansion clearly represents a disproportionate negative impact on the majority of Californians. Additional parcel taxes that add potentially hundreds of dollars to property tax bills will do nothing to ease California’s affordable housing issues, where only 30 percent of state residents can afford a median-priced home. This is all the more reason why the two-thirds vote for such exactions needs to remain in place. Only homeowners pay parcel taxes, but everyone gets to vote on them.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
ACA 1 (Aguiar-Curry), which is pending on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file, lowers the vote threshold for the approval of local general obligation bonds and certain special taxes from two-thirds to 55%.
SCA 22 (Allen) of 2018, allowed a school district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax on real property with the approval of 55%, instead of two-thirds, of voters of the district if certain conditions are met. SCA 22 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
SCA 6 (Wiener) of 2017, would lower the vote threshold for local government agencies to levy a special tax for transportation infrastructure projects from two-thirds to 55%. SCA 6 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
SCA 3 (Leno) of 2013, SCA 5 (Simitian) of 2011, SCA 6 (Simitian) of 2009, SCA 17 (Simitian) of 2008, SCA 8 (Simitian) of 2005, and ACA 4 (Simitian) of 2003, were all substantially similar to SCA 5. None of these measures were enacted.
PRIOR ACTION
Senate Governance & Finance Committee: | 4-3 |
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: Alameda Unified School District
Association of California School Administrators
Big Creek School District
California Association of School Business Officials
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California County Superintendents Educational Services Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Retired Teachers Association
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Contra Costa County Superintendent of Schools
Fresno Unified School District
Foothill –De Anza Community College District
Healdsburg Unified School District
Jurupa Unified School District
Larkspur-Corte Madera School District
Las Virgenes Unified School District
Monterey County Office of Education
Murrieta Valley Unified School District
Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District
Paramount Unified School District
Peralta Community College District
Redwood City Education Foundation
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools
San Diego Community College District
San Diego Unified School District
San Francisco Unified School District
Santa Clara County Office of Education
School Employers Association of California
Schools For Sound Finance
Scotts Valley Unified School District
Small School Districts’ Association
South Bay Union School District
Sunnyvale School District
Torrance Unified School District
Ventura County Office of Education
Oppose: Building Owners and Managers Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Charter School Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Taxpayers Association
Family Business Association of California
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Taxpayers Association
NAIOP of California
Orange County Taxpayers Association
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Sonoma County Taxpayers Association
Southwest California Legislative Council
Sutter County Taxpayers Association
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SCA 5 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/19 |
Author: | Hill | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 4/22/19 | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Taxation: school districts: parcel tax
Allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval under specified circumstances.
Background
The California Constitution states that taxes levied by local governments are either general taxes, subject to majority approval of its voters, or special taxes, subject to 2/3 vote (Article XIII C). Proposition 13 (1978) required a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature for state tax increases, and 2/3 vote of local voters for local special taxes. Proposition 62 (1986) prohibited local agencies from imposing general taxes without majority approval of local voters, and a 2/3 vote for special taxes. Proposition 218 (1996) extended those vote thresholds to charter cities and limited local agencies’ powers to levy new assessments, fees, and taxes. The Constitution further bars school districts from imposing general taxes. Additionally, the California Constitution has historically required a 2/3 vote for issuing bonds since 1879, but voters subsequently allowed school districts, community college districts, and county offices of education to issue bonded indebtedness for school facilities with 55% approval when complying with specified requirements (Proposition 39, 2000).
Prior to Proposition 62, school districts imposed parcel taxes to fund education; however, the initiative prompted school districts to seek specific legislative authorization to ratify the existing taxes, and clarify their authority to impose new ones. In response, the Legislature allowed school and community college districts to impose “qualified special taxes” that applied uniformly to all taxpayers or real property within the district, and allowed school, but not community college, districts to exempt persons over the age of 65 from the tax (AB 1440, Hannigan, 1988). In 1991, the Legislature additionally allowed 15 types of local agencies to impose similar taxes; however, the measure allowed local agencies to tax unimproved property at a lower rate than improved property, and contained no other exemptions (SB 158, Committee on Local Government, 1991). Thus far, all qualified special taxes imposed are parcel taxes.
Parcel taxes are not ad valorem or assessed based on the value of a property like property taxes; instead they are generally a flat rate assessed per parcel regardless of its size, or per square foot of a parcel or its improvements. Agencies can use revenues in almost any way that serves local needs, such as ongoing expenses, programs, or buildings. Counties collect parcel taxes with property taxes, and then remit funds to the agency imposing the tax. Property tax law generally guides parcel tax collection.
In 2006, the Legislature allowed school districts to also exempt persons receiving Supplemental Security Income regardless of age (AB 385, Lieber, 2006), and then persons receiving Social Security Disability Insurance, whose yearly income was less than 250% of federal poverty guidelines (SB 874, Hancock, 2012). Special taxes, such as parcel taxes, are subject to additional accountability (SB 165, Alarcón, 2000), which requires local agencies to:
- Issue a statement indicating the specific purpose of the tax;
- Require that the proceeds be used only for the purpose in the statement;
- Create an account in which to deposit proceeds; and,
- Publish an annual report that includes the amount of funds collected and expended, along with the status of any project required or authorized by the tax measure.
Advocates for school and community college districts want to lower the threshold for school district parcel taxes from a 2/3 to 55% voter approval.
Proposed Law
Senate Constitutional Amendment 5 allows a school or community college district to impose, extend, or increase a parcel tax by 55% voter approval if a majority vote of the school district governing board approves the measure, and the proposition contains:
- A list of the specific purposes and programs that are to be funded.
- A requirement that the proceeds be used only for the purposes and programs specified in the proposition, and not for any other purpose.
- A requirement that the governing board of the school district conduct an annual independent financial audit of the amount of parcel tax proceeds collected and expended, and the specified purposes and programs funded.
SCA 5 also makes technical and conforming changes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Despite significant increases in state funding for schools in recent years, districts are struggling to maintain quality educational services and programs amid escalating costs and declining enrollment. Teacher layoffs or furloughs and cut programs are among the results. Parcel taxes are one of the few means school districts have to supplement their funding. Yet the current requirement for a two-thirds supermajority vote to pass school parcel taxes has enabled a minority of voters to block efforts to provide vital local education funding. If communities want to invest in education and provide our students more resources, they should be able to do so. SCA 5 retains the requirement for supermajority approval of local school parcel taxes, but the legislation changes the supermajority threshold to a more realistic percentage.”
2. More or less. Majority rule is a two-edged sword: democratically elected governments are supposed to enact policies that the voters want, but both federal and state systems of government restrict the majority’s ability to oppress minority interests. For the great majority of public issues, 50% plus one of a legislative body or an electorate rule. But for some issues, the United States and California Constitutions provide that a majority is not enough and a higher threshold is necessary, such as amending the U.S. Constitution, impeaching a president, or overriding a veto. States largely import the 2/3 vote from the United States Constitution into their own for many of the same purposes, but sometimes require 2/3 vote on taxes or other measures. In a series of voter initiatives, Californians have elevated general obligation bond issues, local special tax increases, and legislatively enacted state tax increases to this level, but local voters can enact general taxes, and state voters can approve tax initiatives increasing state taxes by majority vote. As such, local agencies need a majority vote to assess taxes and spend the proceeds on whatever purposes they want to, but 2/3 if they restrict the use of the tax proceeds.
SCA 5 adds another layer onto the complex system above. If enacted, school and community college districts could enact special taxes for transportation purposes at 55% vote, paralleling Proposition 39’s similar allowance for school bonds. However, the measure does not affect thresholds for any other kind of tax, which raises two questions: first, what should be the voting threshold for local special taxes? The Legislative Analyst’s Office says there is no right answer, as requirements vary across states, but adds that the process should be easy enough for voters to understand and reflect overarching objectives for voter participation in tax decisions. Second, should the thresholds be different based on the use of the tax proceeds, like education? The Committee may wish to consider the reasons for affording parcel taxes for school and community college district special treatment when contemplating the overall system of voter thresholds necessary to increase taxes.
3. Who pays? An old piece of tax policy wisdom attributed to Louisiana Governor Russell Long states that, “Don’t tax you, don’t tax me, tax the man behind the tree.” Opponents of parcel taxes invoke this quote when criticizing them because residents who do not own land, such as renters, can vote in a parcel tax election and receive the benefit of the proceeds, but do not pay them except as passed through in rents. Meanwhile, non-resident landowners cannot vote in the election, and do not derive tangible benefits from the proceeds, but must pay the tax if the voters approve it. Current law allows school districts to exempt taxpayers 65 years or older, which provides another class of voters who do not bear the incidence of the tax but who in many cases have the ability to pay it. The Committee may wish to consider whether reducing the voter approval threshold necessary to impose parcel taxes is equitable.
4. Transparency. The Legislature has enacted measures in recent years to attempt to increase transparency in local parcel tax elections. In 2014, the Legislature required entities imposing parcel taxes to report specified information to the State Controller, who must incorporate this information in local government financial transaction reports (AB 2109, Daly). The Legislature additionally required local agencies imposing parcel taxes to send a notice with specified contents regarding the tax to nonresident landowners (AB 2458, Daly, 2016). Last year, the Legislature required tax collectors to add specified information regarding parcel tax exemptions to their Web sites and property tax bills, while directing school districts to add similar information to its Web sites (AB 2458, Weber).
5. Parcel taxes in California. In April, 2015, the Public Policy Institute of California issued “Parcel Taxes as a Local Revenue Source in California,” which contained revealing data regarding the way in which local agencies use parcel taxes. Between 2003 and 2012, school districts placed 329 parcel tax measures before voters during the same period, with 60% passing. PPIC notes that only 114 of California’s 963 school districts had one or more successful parcel tax elections during this period, mostly concentrated in the Bay Area. The report argues that the higher frequency of parcel taxes in the Bay Area is partly explained by higher income levels. PPIC argues that the use of the parcel tax is growing, and that it has many advantages over other taxes: it has no deadweight loss, and assigns taxes in line with benefits. However, PPIC cautions that the tax has a major shortcoming in that many large parcels have little value, and are limited in their capacity to support a parcel tax. The California Tax Foundation in its September, 2014, report entitled “Piecing Together California’s Parcel Taxes” argues that the parcel tax needs consistency, and local governments need oversight and greater accountability to taxpayers. The Foundation suggests statewide reforms to parcel taxes in California to provide consistency, certainty, simplicity, and transparency to promote complementary tax bases among all local governments. The Foundation’s specific recommendations include to:
- Consolidate all parcel tax elections to occur with statewide elections,
- Direct local agencies to calculate inflation adjustments using an index specific to that geographic region,
- Allow the Board of Equalization an oversight role over parcel taxes,
- Standardize tax bases to reduce exemptions to ensure that parcel taxes can be deducted from federal income taxes,
- Require all parcel taxes to have sunset dates,
- Cap the combined parcel and property tax rate to no more than 1.2% of value,
- Mandate agencies imposing parcel taxes to provide consistent information regarding the tax in an annual report,
- Prohibit the use of assessors’ use codes when levying a parcel tax, and
- Allow longer than a 60-day period to file a legal challenge over the validity of the tax.
6. Definitions. SCA 5’s reduced voter threshold applies to parcel taxes defined as “a special tax imposed upon a parcel of real property at a rate that is determined without regard to that property’s value.” This definition differs from the statutory one that provides a qualified special tax is one that is “uniformly applied to all taxpayers.” In 2013, George Borikas successfully challenged Alameda Unified School District’s Measure H, which imposed a parcel tax in which the rate could vary based on the size use of the property, the result of which was that a commercial property could pay more than a residential property. The Fourth District Appellate Court determined that Alameda’s tax didn’t meet the statute’s uniformity requirement, because the school district statute didn’t also contain the language in SB 158 allowing for a lower rate on unimproved property (Borikas v. Alameda Unified School District, 214 Cal. App. 4th 135). In 2014, the Committee approved a measure that would have partially addressed the case; however, the measure died in the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee (SB 1021, Wolk, 2014). Last year, the Legislature enacted AB 2954 (Bonta) which allows a school district to apply a lower parcel tax rate to unimproved property than improved property. In January, the Second District Appellate Court acted on a challenge to Los Angeles County Regional Park and Open Space District’s parcel tax of 1.5 cents per square foot of structural improvements (Dondlinger v. Los Angeles County Regional Park and Open Space District, Case #B284932). The Court held that the tax met the uniformity requirement, despite the challenge from a taxpayer who argued that it did not “because it taxes property differently based on different uses of structural improvements on the property.” The Committee may wish to consider whether a different definition is necessary, and if so, whether SCA 5’s broader one is desirable.
7. Related legislation. Last year, the Committee approved SCA 22 (Allen), which is substantially similar to this bill. The measure was subsequently held on the Senate Appropriation Committee’s Suspense File.
8. Double-referred. The Senate Rules Committee ordered a double referral for SCA 5, first to the Governance and Finance Committee, and second to the Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
Support and Opposition
(4/19/19)
Support: Alameda Unified School District; Association of California School Administrators; Big Creek School District; California Association of School Business Officials (Casbo); Cabrillo Unified School District; California Association of Suburban School Districts; California Federation of Teachers; California Retired Teachers Association; California School Boards Association; California School Employees Association; California State PTA; California Teachers Association; Contra Costa County Superintendents Coalition; Healdsburg Unified School District; Jurupa Unified School District; Las Virgenes Unified School District; Monterey County Office of Education; Murrieta Valley Unified School District; Norwalk - La Mirada Unified School District; Paramount Unified School District; San Bernardino County District Advocates For Better Schools (Sandabs); San Diego Unified School District; San Francisco Unified School District; Santa Clara County Office of Education; School Employers Association Of California; Schools for Sound Finance; Scotts Valley Unified School District; Small School Districts Association; South Bay Union School District; Torrance Unified School District; Ventura County Office of Education
Opposition: California Association of Realtors. California Chamber of Commerce; California Farm Bureau Federation; California Taxpayers Association; Family Business Association of California; Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association; Kern County Taxpayers Association; Orange County Taxpayers Association; San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership; Sonoma County Taxpayers Association; Southwest California Legislative Council; Sutter County Taxpayers Association; West Coast Lumber and Building Material Association; Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):