AB 2539: Modeling agencies: licensure: models: employees.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-03-30
The California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973 establishes certain safety and other responsibilities of employers and employees. Violations of the act under certain circumstances are a crime. Existing law establishes the Department of Industrial Relations to, among other things, foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners, to improve their working conditions, and to advance their opportunities for profitable employment.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of talent agencies, as defined, by the Labor Commissioner. Existing law requires moneys collected for licenses and fines collected for violations of these provisions to be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund.
This bill would require a person engaging in the occupation of a modeling agency, as defined, to be licensed by the Labor Commissioner. Commissioner under the licensing provisions that apply to talent agencies. The bill would require a model, as defined, to be classified as an employee of a modeling agency and require a model to obtain a specified health certification from a licensed physician before being employed as a model. The bill would require a modeling agency to obtain that health certification before hiring a model, to post in a conspicuous place in its office a health advisory relating to eating disorders and sexual harassment or assault, and to maintain specified records relating to its employment of models. The bill would provide that a violation of the certification requirement by a modeling agency is a crime. By creating a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. the person for whom the models services are directly provided. The bill would require the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the State Department of Public Health to draft regulations relating to the modeling profession, as provided. to, no later than December 1, 2017, and in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models, as specified. The bill would impose specified license fees upon modeling agencies to be deposited into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund. exempt a person covered by certain wage orders by the Industrial Welfare Commission from these provisions. The bill would define various terms for its purposes and would make related findings.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973 establishes certain safety and other responsibilities of employers and employees. Violations of the act under certain circumstances are a crime. Existing law establishes the Department of Industrial Relations to, among other things, foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners, to improve their working conditions, and to advance their opportunities for profitable employment.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of talent agencies, as defined, by the Labor Commissioner. Existing law requires moneys collected for licenses and fines collected for violations of these provisions to be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund.
This bill would require a person engaging in the occupation of a modeling agency, as defined, to be licensed by the Labor Commissioner. The bill would require a model, as defined, to be classified as an employee of a modeling agency and require a model to obtain a specified health certification from a licensed physician before being employed as a model. The bill would require a modeling agency to obtain that health certification before hiring a model, to post in a conspicuous place in its office a health advisory relating to eating disorders and sexual harassment or assault, and to maintain specified records relating to its employment of models. The bill would provide that a violation of the certification requirement by a modeling agency is a crime. By creating a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the State Department of Public Health to draft regulations relating to the modeling profession, as provided. The bill would impose specified license fees upon modeling agencies to be deposited into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund. The bill would define various terms for its purposes and would make related findings.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Professional fashion models face pervasive and hazardous occupational demands to maintain extreme and unhealthy thinness. These occupational pressures create a dangerous work environment. Models experience a substantially elevated risk of eating disorders and other severe health problems associated with starvation.
(b)The majority of models enter the industry as minors, making them especially vulnerable to mistreatment and to the physical and psychological damage caused by eating disorders. Women working as professional fashion models are more likely to have a diagnosis of anorexia nervosa, dangerously low body mass index, and amenorrhea, which is a serious medical indicator of hormonal dysregulation that can have negative health consequences for life.
(c)As with all workers, professional fashion models are entitled to safe working conditions. The time, place, and means of the services provided by professional models are typically controlled by the company paying their compensation. Therefore, professional models are typically required to be classified as employees rather than Many models, including minors, are wrongly treated as independent contractors according to existing federal and state law. and currently do not receive workplace protections. Clarifying their classification as employees of the companies paying their compensation will enhance their workplace protections.
(d)The impact of the fashion industry on health reaches far beyond the hazardous occupational conditions that professional models endure. Through its dominant presence in the mass media and pervasive influence on setting cultural standards for apparel, particularly for girls and young women, the fashion industry helps to define, transmit, and reinforce an unrealistic standard of thinness, a well-documented risk factor for eating disorders.
(e)Scientific research has shown that viewing media images of extremely thin models leads to body dissatisfaction in adolescent girls and young women, especially those who already have heightened vulnerability to eating disorders. In addition, scientific studies have shown that body dissatisfaction in adolescence is a strong indicator that a young person may develop an eating disorder.
(f)Improving working conditions to reduce excessive thinness among professional models is likely to lead to healthier images of models weight. This change in media portrayals of models weight may help to achieve a larger societal value in making media images more healthful and less damaging to girls and young womens body image, ultimately reducing their risk for eating disorders.
1707.1.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)License means a license issued by the Labor Commissioner as a talent agency to carry on the business of a modeling agency under this chapter. Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1700).
(b)Licensee means a modeling agency that holds a valid license as a talent agency under this chapter. Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1700).
(c)Model means an individual artist under Section 1701 covered under Wage Order 4 of the Industrial Welfare Commission who, in the course of his or her occupation, performs modeling services for, or who consents in writing to the transfer of his or her exclusive legal right to the use of his or her name, portrait, picture, or image for advertising purposes or for the purposes of trade directly to, a retail store, a manufacturer, an advertising agency, a photographer, a publishing company, or a modeling agency.
(d)Modeling agency means a person that compensates a model and that dictates the assignments, hours of work, or performance locations of the model. facilitates an employment opportunity as defined in Section 1701 for a model and that holds a valid license under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1700).
(e)Modeling services means the appearance by a model in photographic sessions or the engagement of a model in runway, live, filmed, or taped performances requiring him or her to pose, provide an example or standard of artistic expression, or to be a representation to show the construction or appearance of some thing or place for purposes of display or advertising.
(f)Person means any individual, company, society, firm, partnership, association, corporation, limited liability company, manager, or their agents or employees.
1707.2.(a)A model shall be classified as an employee of a modeling agency. the person for whom the models services are directly provided.
(b)(1)A modeling agency shall not hire a model without first obtaining the health certification described in Section 1707.4.
(2)Any modeling agency that does not obtain the certification described in subdivision (a) of Section 1707.4 is guilty of a misdemeanor and subject to a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000).
1707.3.(a)A person shall not engage in or carry on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license therefor from the Labor Commissioner. The license shall be posted in a conspicuous place in the office of the licensee. The license number shall be referred to in any advertisement for the purpose of the solicitation of a model for the modeling agency. under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1700).
(b) A filing fee of twenty-five dollars ($25) shall be paid to the Labor Commissioner at the time the application for issuance of a modeling agency license is filed.
(c)In addition to the filing fee required for application for issuance of a modeling agency license, every modeling agency shall pay to the Labor Commissioner annually at the time a license is issued or renewed the following:
(1)A license fee of two hundred and twenty-five dollars ($225).
(2)Fifty dollars ($50) for each branch office maintained by the modeling agency in this state.
1707.4.(a)A model shall obtain written certification from a licensed physician that he or she is in healthy physical condition and submit this certification to a modeling agency before being hired by a modeling agency. A model shall make his or her medical records available to the physician, and the physician shall review the models medical records as part of the certification of the models physical condition.
(b)Every modeling agency shall keep records, in a form approved by the Labor Commissioner, that include all of the following:
(1)A copy of the certification described in subdivision (a) for each model it employs.
(2)The dates of employment and the amount of compensation paid for each model.
(c)(1)Every modeling agency shall post in a conspicuous place in its office a health advisory relating to eating disorders that includes a phone number to the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board, a phone number to an entity where a model can report sexual harassment or assault, and any other information that may specified by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)Any modeling agency that violates the requirements of paragraph (1) shall be subject to a fine not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500) per day that those requirements are violated.
This chapter shall not apply to persons covered by Wage Order 11, regulating the Broadcasting Industry, or Wage Order 12, regulating the Motion Picture Industry, of the Industrial Welfare Commission.
1707.5.(a)The Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the State Department of Public Health shall draft regulations, in consultation with physicians and other health professionals with expertise in eating disorders, that do all of the following: shall, no later than December 1, 2017, and in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models, with an operative date of September 1, 2018, to be fully complied with by December 31, 2018 . The standard shall apply to services provided in California by models under this chapter and Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1700). The Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board may update these standards from time to time as it deems necessary.
(1)Include detailed requirements of the certification and record retention requirements described in Section 1707.4.
(2)Require no less than three medical check-ups per year by models.
(3)Require a model to obtain a nutrition consultation with a qualified health professional.
(4)Address any medical testing that should be done by a model to determine his or her fitness to perform his or her job duties and provide a model with information about the privacy of these test results.
(b)The regulations standard shall be adopted in accordance with the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code). address issues including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Protection of the models rights to health care privacy under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191) and all other provisions of law.
(2)Workplace safety, especially for minors, including protection from sexual exploitation and sexual predators.
(3)Prevention and treatment of eating disorders.
1707.6.(a)All books, records, and other papers kept pursuant to this chapter by a modeling agency shall be open at all reasonable hours to the inspection of the Labor Commissioner and his agents. Every modeling agency shall furnish to the Labor Commissioner upon request a true copy of these books, records, and papers or any portion thereof.
(b)Every modeling agency that violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a fine of five hundred dollars ($500).
1707.7.All moneys collected for licenses and all fines collected for violations of this chapter shall be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Professional fashion models face pervasive and hazardous occupational demands to maintain extreme and unhealthy thinness. These occupational pressures create a dangerous work environment. Models experience a substantially elevated risk of eating disorders and other severe health problems associated with starvation.
(b)The majority of models enter the industry as minors, making them especially vulnerable to mistreatment and to the physical and psychological damage caused by eating disorders. Women working as professional fashion models are more likely to have a diagnosis of anorexia nervosa, dangerously low body mass index, and amenorrhea, which is a serious medical indicator of hormonal dysregulation that can have negative health consequences for life.
(c)As with all workers, professional fashion models are entitled to safe working conditions. The time, place, and means of the services provided by professional models are typically controlled by the company paying their compensation. Therefore, professional models are typically required to be classified as employees rather than independent contractors according to existing federal and state law. Clarifying their classification as employees will enhance their workplace protections.
(d)The impact of the fashion industry on health reaches far beyond the hazardous occupational conditions that professional models endure. Through its dominant presence in the mass media and pervasive influence on setting cultural standards for apparel, particularly for girls and young women, the fashion industry helps to define, transmit, and reinforce an unrealistic standard of thinness, a well-documented risk factor for eating disorders.
(e)Scientific research has shown that viewing media images of extremely thin models leads to body dissatisfaction in adolescent girls and young women, especially those who already have heightened vulnerability to eating disorders. In addition, scientific studies have shown that body dissatisfaction in adolescence is a strong indicator that a young person may develop an eating disorder.
(f)Improving working conditions to reduce excessive thinness among professional models is likely to lead to healthier images of models weight. This change in media portrayals of models weight may help to achieve a larger societal value in making media images more healthful and less damaging to girls and young womens body image, ultimately reducing their risk for eating disorders.
1707.1.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)License means a license issued by the Labor Commissioner to carry on the business of a modeling agency under this chapter.
(b)Licensee means a modeling agency that holds a valid license under this chapter.
(c)Model means an individual who, in the course of his or her occupation, performs modeling services for, or who consents in writing to the transfer of his or her exclusive legal right to the use of his or her name, portrait, picture, or image for advertising purposes or for the purposes of trade directly to, a retail store, a manufacturer, an advertising agency, a photographer, a publishing company, or a modeling agency.
(d)Modeling agency means a person that compensates a model and that dictates the assignments, hours of work, or performance locations of the model.
(e)Modeling services means the appearance by a model in photographic sessions or the engagement of a model in runway, live, filmed, or taped performances requiring him or her to pose, provide an example or standard of artistic expression, or to be a representation to show the construction or appearance of some thing or place for purposes of display or advertising.
(f)Person means any individual, company, society, firm, partnership, association, corporation, limited liability company, manager, or their agents or employees.
1707.2.(a)A model shall be classified as an employee of a modeling agency.
(b)(1)A modeling agency shall not hire a model without first obtaining the health certification described in Section 1707.4.
(2)Any modeling agency that does not obtain the certification described in subdivision (a) of Section 1707.4 is guilty of a misdemeanor and subject to a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000).
1707.3.(a)A person shall not engage in or carry on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license therefor from the Labor Commissioner. The license shall be posted in a conspicuous place in the office of the licensee. The license number shall be referred to in any advertisement for the purpose of the solicitation of a model for the modeling agency.
(b) A filing fee of twenty-five dollars ($25) shall be paid to the Labor Commissioner at the time the application for issuance of a modeling agency license is filed.
(c)In addition to the filing fee required for application for issuance of a modeling agency license, every modeling agency shall pay to the Labor Commissioner annually at the time a license is issued or renewed the following:
(1)A license fee of two hundred and twenty-five dollars ($225).
(2)Fifty dollars ($50) for each branch office maintained by the modeling agency in this state.
1707.4.(a)A model shall obtain written certification from a licensed physician that he or she is in healthy physical condition and submit this certification to a modeling agency before being hired by a modeling agency. A model shall make his or her medical records available to the physician, and the physician shall review the models medical records as part of the certification of the models physical condition.
(b)Every modeling agency shall keep records, in a form approved by the Labor Commissioner, that include all of the following:
(1)A copy of the certification described in subdivision (a) for each model it employs.
(2)The dates of employment and the amount of compensation paid for each model.
(c)(1)Every modeling agency shall post in a conspicuous place in its office a health advisory relating to eating disorders that includes a phone number to the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board, a phone number to an entity where a model can report sexual harassment or assault, and any other information that may specified by the Labor Commissioner.
(2)Any modeling agency that violates the requirements of paragraph (1) shall be subject to a fine not to exceed five hundred dollars ($500) per day that those requirements are violated.
1707.5.(a)The Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the State Department of Public Health shall draft regulations, in consultation with physicians and other health professionals with expertise in eating disorders, that do all of the following:
(1)Include detailed requirements of the certification and record retention requirements described in Section 1707.4.
(2)Require no less than three medical check-ups per year by models.
(3)Require a model to obtain a nutrition consultation with a qualified health professional.
(4)Address any medical testing that should be done by a model to determine his or her fitness to perform his or her job duties and provide a model with information about the privacy of these test results.
(b)The regulations shall be adopted in accordance with the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
1707.6.(a)All books, records, and other papers kept pursuant to this chapter by a modeling agency shall be open at all reasonable hours to the inspection of the Labor Commissioner and his agents. Every modeling agency shall furnish to the Labor Commissioner upon request a true copy of these books, records, and papers or any portion thereof.
(b)Every modeling agency that violates subdivision (a) shall be subject to a fine of five hundred dollars ($500).
1707.7.All moneys collected for licenses and all fines collected for violations of this chapter shall be paid into the State Treasury and credited to the General Fund.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 27, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (April 6). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 31, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Mar 30, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 8, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and HEALTH. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 6, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 20, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2539
Author:(Levine) – As Amended Ver:March 30, 2016
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board (Standards Board) to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models and sets forth other workplace requirements for models and modeling agencies. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a person from engaging in or carrying on the occupation of a modeling agency without first obtaining a license under existing law related to talent agencies.
- Classifies a model as an employee of the person for whom the model's services are directly provided.
- Requires the Standards Board, in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models no later than December 1, 2017. Requires this standard to be operative September 1, 2018 and fully complied with by December 31, 2018.
- Requires the standard to address issues including, but not limited to: (1) protection of the model's rights to health care privacy under federal law and all other provisions of law; (2) workplace safety, especially for minors, including protection from sexual exploitation and sexual predators; and (3) prevention and treatment of eating disorders.
- Provides that this bill shall not apply to persons covered under certain wage orders regulating the broadcasting industry and the motion picture industry.
- Defines "model" to mean an artist covered under Wage Order 4 of the Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC) who, in the course of his or her occupation, performs modeling services for, or who consents to the transfer of his or her legal right to the use of his or her name, portrait, picture or image for advertising purposes of trade directly to, a retail store, a manufacturer, an advertising agency, a photographer, a publishing company, or a modeling agency.
- Defines "modeling services" to mean the appearance by a model in photographic sessions or the engagement of model in runway, live, filmed, or taped performances requiring him or her to pose, provide an example or standard of artistic expression, or to be a representation to show the construction or appearance of some thing or place for purposes of display or advertising.
- Defines a "modeling agency" as a person that facilitates an employment opportunity for a model and that holds a valid license under existing law related to talent agencies
FISCAL EFFECT:
Administrative costs of approximately $420,000 to $450,000 (Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund) for the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) and Cal/OSHA to develop health and safety standards and to process additional wage claims. These estimates reflect anticipated workload for the first two years of implementation. Ongoing costs for DLSE are estimated to be approximately $112,000 annually.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill protects the health and well-being of models and will also change the messages the fashion industry sends to society about health and beauty. This bill provides that models are employees and receive all worker protections of employees. The bill also requires the adoption of health guidelines for models.
- Support. According to the Model Alliance, supporters of the bill, eating disorders are widespread in the fashion industry and are too often dismissed or overlooked. The bill requires the OSHA Standards Board, in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models.
The supporters of this bill also state that many (but not all) modeling agencies are licensed as talent agencies under existing law, affording models the protections that apply to talent agencies, such as registration with the Labor Commissioner and other requirements. This bill would prohibit a person from engaging in or carrying on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license under the existing law related to talent agencies. Supporters believe that requiring modeling agencies to be licensed and regulated as talent agencies increases the level of financial transparency and accountability in the modeling industry, and protect models from sexual and financial exploitation.
- Opposition. The Association of Talent Agents (ATA) opposes this bill and state it is unworkable. They state the bill is redundant because it seeks to require what is already required – that modeling agencies engaged in the occupation of procuring or attempting to procure employment for "artists" services (including models) be licensed by the Labor Commissioner. They note that the Labor Commissioner has issued rulings on the fact that models are artists covered under the Talent Agents Act (TAA), and therefore the bill serves no discernable purpose.
The ATA also raises concerns over statutorily mandating models as employees. They argue that the law is clear that the classification of a worker as either an employee or an independent contractor depends, among other things, on the circumstances of the work performed and the degree of control over the worker. Because the bill requires models to be classified as employees in every case regardless of the circumstances of the particular job, ATA argues the bill does not reflect the realities of the work environment and unfairly prejudices models who exhibit control over their work and structure their business as independent contractors.
The ATA also opposes the proposed development of an OSHA workplace health and safety standard for models. They are concerned that the bill provides no definition for what constitutes "healthy" and discourages diversity among body shapes within the industry, with respect to both slender and plus-size models. ATA also expresses concern that the development of such a standard would impose duties upon the modeling agencies, such as making sure that each model it represents has met the standard and is healthy to perform modeling services.
Analysis Prepared by: Misty Feusahrens / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 6, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Roger Hernández, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2539 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:March 30, 2016
SUBJECT: Modeling agencies: licensure: models: employees
SUMMARY: Establishes various requirements regarding models and modeling agencies, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines "model" to mean an artist covered under Wage Order 4 of the Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC) who, in the course of his or her occupation, performs modeling services for, or who consents to the transfer of his or her legal right to the use of his or her name, portrait, picture or image for advertising purposes of trade directly to, a retail store, a manufacturer, an advertising agency, a photographer, a publishing company, or a modeling agency.
- Defines "modeling services" to mean the appearance by a model in photographic sessions or the engagement of model in runway, live, filmed, or taped performances requiring him or her to pose, provide an example or standard of artistic expression, or to be a representation to show the construction or appearance of some thing or place for purposes of display or advertising.
- Defines a "modeling agency" as a person that facilitates an employment opportunity (as specified) for a model and that holds a valid license under existing law related to talent agencies.
- Prohibits a person from engaging in or carrying on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license under existing law related to talent agencies.
- Provides that a model shall be classified as an employee of the person for whom the model's services are directly provided.
- Requires the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board (Standards Board), no later than December 1, 2017, and in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models.
- Specifies that the standard shall have an operative date of September 1, 2018, to be fully complied with by December 31, 2018.
- Specifies that the standard shall address issues including, but not limited to:
- Protection of the model's rights to health care privacy under federal law and all other provisions of law.
- Workplace safety, especially for minors, including protection from sexual exploitation and sexual predators.
- Prevention and treatment of eating disorders.
- Provides that this bill shall not apply to persons covered under IWC Wage Order 11 (regulating the broadcasting industry) or IWC Wage Order 12 (regulating the motion picture industry).
- Contains related legislative findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973 to address certain safety and other responsibilities of employers and employees, making violations of Cal OSHA, under certain circumstances, a crime.
- Establishes the Department of Industrial Relations to foster, promote, and develop the welfare of the wage earners, to improve, their working conditions, and to advance their opportunities for profitable employment.
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of talent agencies by the Labor Commissioner, as defined.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: This bill is designed to address health impacts affecting fashion models, largely through framing the concern as a workplace health and safety issue.
According to the author:
"It is clear that the fashion industry has a health problem–one that is not being adequately addressed through voluntary guidelines. However, as has been stated by many models in the industry, the health problem is also a labor problem.
The fashion industry’s idea of beauty is extreme and without workplace health and safety standards, models will continue to be forced to sacrifice their health for their careers."
Similarly, according to The Model Alliance:
"…[M]odels in the U.S. lack…basic workplace protections. Strict rules that govern child actors’ working hours and provisions for tutors during professional commitments are not applied to child models, who often work long hours and drop out of school to make the most of their earning ability during their teenage years. Many models lack affordable health care, which is particularly troubling considering the psychological and health costs on models who anxiously struggle to control their bodies over short-lived careers and are isolated by their frenetic and nomadic lifestyles…
…We cannot promote healthy images without taking steps to promote healthy bodies and minds, and that starts with giving the faces of this business a unified voice…Correcting these abuses starts with seeing models through a different lens: not as dehumanized images, but as workers who deserve the same rights and protections as anyone else."[1]
Therefore, the author states that the goal of this bill is to develop workplace health and safety standards to protect models. In addition, the bill is designed not only protect the health of the workers themselves, but also that of young people who try to emulate and aspire to be models.
Health Consequences and Models
In recent years, there has been "widespread concern that the fashion industry, by promulgating ever-diminishing extremes of thinness, is creating a 'toxic' environment in which eating disorders flourish."[2]
A recent article in the British Journal of Psychiatry summarized some of the concerns as follows:
"The current fashion for extreme thinness among models unnecessarily puts their physical and psychological health in jeopardy. Starvation disrupts growth and reproductive function and can have profound and persistent effects on brain development. These risks are particularly profound in young women who, in a binge-priming environment, may be more prone to develop other addictive behaviours. Along with an increased risk of substance and alcohol use and misuse, the risk of developing an eating disorder will also be increased. The longer-term health implications on models’ bone and reproductive health are unknown but evidence suggests the outcomes are not promising."[3]
According to an online survey[4] of 85 fashion models conducted by The Model Alliance, 31.2 percent of the surveyed models reported having eating disorders, and 64.1 percent reported having been asked to lose weight. Nearly half of the surveyed models reported doing "fasts," cleanses or other efforts to restrict their food intake over a short period of time in order to lose weight.
In addition, due to the fact that many models are considered to be independent contractors rather than employees (whether or not they are in fact properly classified), nearly 30 percent of the surveyed models reported that they lacked health insurance.
Beyond the Catwalk – Possible Societal Implications of Modeling
Concern has also been expressed that extreme thinness in fashion models impacts not only the models themselves, but also has larger societal implications – particularly for adolescent girls.
The National Association of Anorexia Nervosa and Associated Disorders reports that the media and model images have a tremendous influence on young people. Specifically, they cite[5] evidence that:
- The body type portrayed in advertising as the ideal is possessed naturally by only 5 percent of American females.
- 47 percent of girls in 5th through 12th grade reported wanting to lose weight because of magazine pictures.
- 69 percent of girls in 5th through 12th grade reported that magazine pictures influenced their idea of a perfect body shape.
- 42 percent of 1st through 3rd grade girls want to be thinner.
- 81 percent of 10 year olds are afraid of being overweight.
Recent Efforts in Other Countries
The author states that this bill is part of a growing global movement to address worries about models’ workplace safety and related public health concerns. For example:
- In 2006, organizers of Madrid Fashion Week became the first to implement a code of conduct to ban models deemed underweight according to their body mass index (BMI), a ratio of weight to height. Italy followed suit shortly thereafter, requiring models to provide a certificate of health before they can work the runway.
- In 2013, Israel went a step further by adopting legislation stipulating that fashion and commercial models must meet minimum BMI requirements.
- Most recently, in 2015, France’s National Assembly passed a law that requires models to have a medical certificate deeming them fit to work.
Provisions Proposed by this Bill
In general, this bill proposes to enact three main provisions related to models and modeling. First, this bill prohibits a person from engaging in or carrying on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license under existing law related to talent agencies. Second, this bill provides that a model shall be classified as an employee of the person for whom the model's services are directly provided. Third, this bill requires the OSHA Standards Board to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models, as specified.
Requiring Modeling Agencies to be Licensed Talent Agencies
Since 1959, California law has regulated "talent agencies" by, among other things, requiring the licensure of such agencies with the Labor Commissioner. This statute has largely been referred to as the Talent Agents Act (TAA).
Existing law defines a "talent agency" as a person or corporation who engages in the occupation of procuring, offering, promising, or attempting to procure employment or engagements for an artist or artists. Talent agencies may, in addition, counsel or direct artists in the development of their professional careers. (Labor Code Section 1700.4(a)).
Existing law defines an "artist" to mean actors and actresses rendering services on the legitimate stage and in the production of motion pictures, radio artists, musical artists, musical organizations, directors of legitimate stage, motion picture and radio productions, musical directors, writers, cinematographers, composers, lyricists, arrangers, models, and other artists and persons rendering professional services in motion picture, theatrical, radio, television and other entertainment enterprises. (Labor Code Section 1700.4(b)).
In general, a talent agency does not charge an up-front fee but instead procures employment for an artist and then charges a commission fee or similar compensation. However, prior to 1999, California law did not regulate persons engaged in the solicitation of advance-fee payments from an artist prior to employment being secured. At the time, concerns were expressed that unscrupulous individuals were posing as talent agents or talent managers and were requesting large payments in exchange for promises of employment that they could never deliver.
That changed with the enactment of AB 884 (Kuehl), Chapter 626, Statutes of 1999. Among other things, AB 884 required a contract between an advance-fee talent service and an artist to be in writing and to contain specified provisions, including a right to cancel the contract and to receive a refund, as specified. The bill also required an advance-fee talent service to file a bond or deposit in the amount of $10,000 with the Labor Commissioner. Subsequent legislation, AB 2860 (Kuehl), Chapter 878, Statutes of 2000, corrected a drafting error to narrow the law to avoid regulating individuals who served merely as photographers, costume designers, drama coaches or in similar occupations but not engaging in advance-fee talent services. In 2005, legislation was enacted to close an alleged loophole in which unscrupulous individuals were finding a way around the law by continuing to charge up-front fees for photographs or "casting kits" while indicating that these services will lead to employment. That measure was enacted as SB 1687 (Murray) Chapter 2008, Statutes of 2004. The advanced-fee talent services provisions were further revised and recast under AB 1319 (Krekorian), Chapter 286, Statutes of 2009.
The supporters of this bill argue that many (but not all) modeling agencies are already licensed as talent agencies under existing law, affording models the protections that apply to talent agencies, such as registration with the Labor Commissioner and other requirements. This bill would prohibit a person from engaging in or carrying on the occupation of a modeling agency without first procuring a license under the existing law related to talent agencies.
Employment Status and Misclassification
Employee misclassification has become a serious problem in the United States, and particularly in California. When companies misclassify workers as independent contractors instead of as employees, these workers do not receive worker protections, including minimum wages, overtime pay, and other protection to which they would otherwise be entitled. Additionally, businesses do not deduct taxes, 401(k), Social Security, or Medicare payments from the paychecks of independent contractors, which results in a loss of state tax income from the businesses as well as a potential loss of income from the individual worker who may not properly report income. Because employers do not pay unemployment taxes for independent contractors, workers who are misclassified cannot obtain unemployment benefits if they lose their jobs.
A number of reports in the last several years have chronicled the societal consequences of and impacts upon American workers of misclassification of workers as independent contractors versus employees. The United States Government Accountability Office conducted a study of misclassification of workers as independent contractors and found that employee misclassification cost the United States government $2.72 billion in revenue from Social Security, unemployment and income taxes in 2006 alone. (GAO, Employee Misclassifications: Improved Outreach Could Help Ensure Proper Worker Classification, GAO-07-859T (May 8, 2007), pg. 1.)
Similarly, in California EDD reported that the number of misclassified employees increased 54 percent from 2005 to 2007, reaching 15,751 workers in 2007. During this 3-year period, the EDD recovered a total of $111,956,556 in payroll tax assessments, $18,537,894 in labor code citations, and $40,348,667 in assessments on employment tax fraud cases. (See California Employment Development Department, Annual Report: Fraud Deterrence and Detection Activities, report to the California Legislature (June 2008)) A Daily Journal article reported on the recent increase in worker misclassification and one person interviewed for the article noted that worker misclassification is attractive to employers because they can cut their labor costs by up to 30 percent by moving to an independent contractor model. (Ho, Independent Contractor Status Raises IRS Eyebrows: Contractor Status is Cheaper for Employers; Some Workers are Crying Foul, Daily Journal (May 17, 2010).)
These concerns led to the passage of SB 459 (Corbett) from 2011, which established significant civil penalties for the intentional misclassification
"Statutory Employees" and Previous Legislation
In general, most individuals are determined to be employees under common law, which involves evaluating a number of specific factors. However, a "statutory employee" is defined as an employee by law under a specific statute.
For example, Unemployment Insurance Code Section 621 deems certain groups of workers to be employees for purposes of certain employment tax purposes. These "statutory employees" include corporate officers, specified agent/commission drivers, traveling salespersons, certain home workers, and certain artists and authors.
AB 950 (John A. Pérez) of 2011 would have deemed port drayage drivers to be employees for employment law purposes. AB 950 was moved to the Inactive File on the Assembly floor.
AB 202 (Gonzalez) from 2015 provided that specified professional sports "cheerleaders" shall be deemed to be employees for state employment law purposes.
As stated above, this bill would provide that a model shall be classified as an employee of the person for whom the model's services are directly provided. Although the facts of a given case can vary, supporters of this bill cite to case law such as Zaremba v. Miller, 113 Cal. App. 3d Supp. 1 (1980), which found that the relationship of employer-employee existed between a model and a photographer.
In addition, a 2006 California Supreme Court case involved a model who worked on a job assignment that lasted only one day. Smith v. L'Oreal, 39 Cal. 4th 77 (2006). In that case, the model performed work as a "hair model" at a show featuring L'Oreal products and a hair stylist. The model sat on stage in front of an audience as her hair was colored and styled, and then walked the runway a few times. After the show, the defendant did not pay the model the $500 in wages it owed her, but waited over two months to do so. The court concluded that an employee who worked on a job assignment of short duration was not excluded from the provisions of existing law that require payment of wages immediately upon discharge from employment, and that this occurs either when an employee is involuntarily terminated from an ongoing employment relationship or when an employee is released after completing the specific job assignment or time duration for which the employee was hired.
OSHA Standard
As discussed above, particular concern has been expressed regarding various health and safety issues involving models and modeling. Therefore, this bill would require the OSHA Standards Board, in consultation with accredited specialists in the prevention and treatment of eating disorders, to adopt an occupational safety and health standard for models. The bill specifies that the standard shall address issues including, but not limited to (1) protection of the model's rights to health care privacy under federal law and all other provisions of law, (2) workplace safety, especially for minors, including protection from sexual exploitation and sexual predators, and (3) prevention and treatment of eating disorders.
Arguments in Support
Supporters of this bill, including The Model Alliance, argue that this bill would address numerous labor, health and safety issues faced by fashion models in California.
They contend that most professional models are young women who begin their careers as adolescents and work in a largely unregulated industry. Models routinely face pressures including nudity, sexual demands, starvation dieting and difficulty getting paid monies owed. These abuses they suffer may have long-lasting repercussions on their health and wellbeing.
Many models experience pressures to be unhealthily thin. Models have reported becoming sick and some have even died from complications due to anorexia—in one case, just after stepping off a runway.
They argue that lack of financial transparency and resulting wage theft is a widespread problem in the modeling industry. Most models have low bargaining power and are frequently not paid all of their earned wages, are paid wages late, are paid only after complaining about non-payment, are paid in “trade,” meaning clothes, or are simply not paid at all.
The labor abuses in the modeling industry are as common as they are difficult for models to report without risking their job. Like fashion itself, the modeling industry moves in short cycles and there is a huge reservoir of fresh talent, which leaves models feeling easily replaceable. They argue that ensuring that modeling agencies are licensed and regulated as talent agencies would increase the level of financial transparency and accountability in the modeling industry and protect models from sexual and financial exploitation. In addition, models deserve protection necessary for a safe and healthy work environment.
The National Eating Disorders Association states that eating disorders affect nearly 30 million Americans at some time in their lives. They are highly complex, serious mental health conditions which impact every organ system in the body, and have the highest mortality rate of any mental illness. Once an eating disorder takes hold, it is very difficult to reverse. The physical, emotional, and financial toll these illnesses take on families can be devastating. They state that eating disorders are widespread in the fashion industry – a high-pressure business that relies on the labor of young models. These are devastating illnesses that are too often dismissed or overlooked. This legislation not only aims to set desperately-needed health standards for the modeling industry, it quite literally has the power to save lives.
The California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO argues that this bill seeks to ensure that models have effective health and safety protections under the law by requiring that all modeling agencies be licensed with the Labor Commissioner and clarifying that models are statutory employees. These provisions will help ensure that models are covered and protected by existing and proposed health and safety standards. They also note that the under the process for a proposed health and safety standard for models, employers, workers, and other experts will come together to discuss the specifics of these standards and draft a clear regulatory framework that reflects the best available medical evidence and will, once in effect, keep workers safe from the ravages of sexual exploitation, eating disorders, and other health and safety concerns that may arise during the advisory committee process.
Arguments in Opposition
Opponents, including the Association of Talent Agents (ATA) argue that this bill creates major disruption and legal confusion for state licensed talent agencies, doesn't resolve the real issue, and is unworkable.
First, ATA notes that the definition of "model" in this bill includes the name and likeness of the model. They contend that this is beyond the scope of artists' services contained in the TAA and causes confusion.
Second, they argue that the bill is redundant because it seeks to require what is already required – that modeling agencies engaged in the occupation of procuring or attempting to procure employment for "artists" services (including models) be licensed by the Labor Commissioner. They state that the Labor Commissioner has issued countless rulings on the fact that models are artists covered under the (TAA), and that therefore the bill serves no discernable purpose.
Third, ATA opposes the provision of the bill that statutorily mandates that models shall be employees. They argue that the law is clear that the classification of a worker as either an employee or an independent contractor depends, among other things, on the circumstances of the work performed and the degree of control over the worker. Because the bill requires models to be classified as employees in every case regardless of the circumstances of the particular job, ATA argues that it conflicts with well-established law, does not reflect the realities of the work environment and unfairly prejudices models (and other artists) who exhibit control over their work and structure their business as independent contractors.
ATA also opposes the proposed development of an OSHA workplace health and safety standard for models, as provided for in this bill, stating: "The bill provides no definition for what constitutes 'healthy' and encourages possible discrimination against artists with disabilities if their condition falls outside of definition of healthy. The bill also discourages diversity among body shapes within the industry, with respect to both slender and plus-size models. To the extent the purpose of the bill is to make 'media images more healthful', the bill impermissibly restricts freedom of expression." In addition, ATA expresses concern that the development of such a standard would impose duties upon the modeling agencies, such as making sure that each model it represents has met the standard and is healthy to perform modeling services.
Finally, ATA objects to the provision of the bill that excludes certain employees covered under IWC Wage Order 11 (regulating the broadcasting industry) or IWC Wage Order 12 (regulating the motion picture industry). They state that this causes an untenable and impossible-to-comply- with regulatory system. The models and modeling agencies work in all areas of the entertainment business. To mandate completely different standards for the same model and the same modeling agency when rendering the same services for different platforms cannot work.
ATA concludes that they and their member companies are committed to promoting the health and well-being of all artists. While they appreciate the intent of the bill, they claim that it is unworkable.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Academy for Eating Disorders
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
Eating Disorder Hope
Eating Disorder Therapy LA
Multi-Service Eating Disorder Association
National Eating Disorders Association
Numerous Individuals
Schroder Davis PLC
Strategic Training Initiative for the Prevention of Eating Disorders
The Model Alliance
Opposition
Alvarado Rey Agency
Angel City Talent
Association of Talent Agents
BBA Talent
CESD Talent Agency
Clear Talent Group
Commercial Talent
Don Buchwald & Associates Inc.
Go 2 Talent Agency
Maverick Artists Agency, Inc.
Nous Model Management
Rebel Entertainment Partners, Inc.
Sports Unlimited Talent Agency
The Corsa Agency
Analysis Prepared by: Eva Lieu/Ben Ebbink / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091
http://modelalliance.org/introductory-note ↑
Janet L. Treasure, Elizabeth R. Wack and Marion E. Roberts. "Models as a high-risk group: the health implications of a size zero culture." British Journal of Psychiatry (2008): 192(4):243-244. ↑
Id. ↑
http://modelalliance.org/industry-analysis ↑
http://www.anad.org/get-information/about-eating-disorders/eating-disorders-statistics/ ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):