AB 2695: Juvenile proceedings: competency.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-04-19
Existing law authorizes, during the pendency of any juvenile proceeding, the minors counsel or the court to express a doubt as to the minors competency. Existing law requires proceedings to be suspended if the court finds substantial evidence raises a doubt as to the minors competency. Existing law requires the court to appoint an expert, as specified, to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition and, if so, whether the condition or conditions impair the minors competency.
This bill would revise and recast these provisions to, among other things, expand upon the duties imposed upon the expert during his or her evaluation of a minor whose competency is in doubt, as specified. The bill would authorize the district attorney or minors counsel to retain or seek the appointment of additional qualified experts with regard to determining competency, as specified. The bill would require the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court relating to the qualifications of those experts, as specified. The bill would require the question of the minors competency to be determined at an evidentiary hearing, except as specified, and places the burden on the minor to establish a presumption of competency, unless it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she is incompetent. The bill would require the court, upon a finding of incompetency, to refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. If the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, competency within a reasonable period of time, the bill would require the court to dismiss the petition. The bill would authorize the court to invite specified persons and agencies to discuss any services that may be available to the minor after the courts jurisdiction is terminated, and would require the court to make certain referrals for the minor. The bill would require, among others, the presiding judge of a juvenile court, the probation department, and the county mental health department to develop a written protocol describing the competency process and a program to ensure that minors who are found incompetent receive appropriate remediation services. By Notwithstanding these provisions, the bill would prohibit remediation services from exceeding certain time periods, as specified.
By imposing additional duties on local officials, the this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law authorizes, during the pendency of any juvenile proceeding, the minors counsel or the court to express a doubt as to the minors competency. Existing law requires proceedings to be suspended if the court finds substantial evidence raises a doubt as to the minors competency. Existing law requires the court to appoint an expert, as specified, to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition and, if so, whether the condition or conditions impair the minors competency.
This bill would revise and recast these provisions to, among other things, expand upon the duties imposed upon the expert during his or her evaluation of a minor whose competency is in doubt, as specified. The bill would authorize the district attorney or minors counsel to retain or seek the appointment of additional qualified experts with regard to determining competency, as specified. The bill would require the question of the minors competency to be determined at an evidentiary hearing, except as specified, and places the burden on the minor to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she is incompetent. The bill would require the court, upon a finding of incompetency, to refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. If the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, the bill would require the court to dismiss the petition. The bill would authorize the court to invite specified persons and agencies to discuss any services that may be available to the minor after the courts jurisdiction is terminated, and would require the court to make certain referrals for the minor. The bill would require, among others, the presiding judge of a juvenile court, the probation department, and the county mental health department to develop a written protocol describing the competency process and a program to ensure that minors who are found incompetent receive appropriate remediation services. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
(a)(1)Whenever the court has a doubt that a minor who is subject to any juvenile proceedings is mentally competent, the court shall suspend all proceedings and proceed pursuant to this section.
(2)A minor is mentally incompetent for purposes of this section if he or she is unable to understand the nature of the proceedings, including his or her role in the proceedings, or unable to assist counsel in conducting a defense in a rational manner, including a lack of a rational and factual understanding of the nature of the charges or proceedings. Incompetency may result from the presence of any condition or conditions, including, but not limited to, mental illness, mental disorder, developmental disability, or developmental immaturity. Except as specifically provided otherwise, this section applies to a minor who is alleged to come within the jurisdiction of the court pursuant to Section 601 or 602.
(3)During the pendency of any juvenile proceeding, the court may receive information from any source regarding the minors ability to understand the proceedings. The minors counsel or the court may express a doubt as to the minors competency. The receipt of information or the expression of doubt of the minors counsel does not automatically require the suspension of proceedings. If the court has a doubt as to the minors competency, the court shall suspend the proceedings.
(b)(1)Unless the parties stipulate to a finding that the minor lacks competency, or the parties are willing to submit on the issue of the minors lack of competency, the court shall appoint an expert to evaluate the minor and determine whether the minor suffers from a mental illness, mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition affecting competency and, if so, whether the minor is competent.
(2)The expert shall have expertise in child and adolescent development and forensic evaluation of juveniles for purposes of adjudicating competency, shall be familiar with competency standards and accepted criteria used in evaluating juvenile competency, and shall have received training in conducting juvenile competency evaluations.
(3)The expert shall personally interview the minor and review all of the available records provided, including, but not limited to, medical, education, special education, probation, child welfare, mental health, regional center, and court records, and any other relevant information that is available. The expert shall consult with the minors counsel and any other person who has provided information to the court regarding the minors lack of competency. The expert shall gather a developmental history of the minor. If any information is unavailable to the expert, he or she shall note in the report the efforts to obtain that information. The expert shall administer age-appropriate testing specific to the issue of competency unless the facts of the particular case render testing unnecessary or inappropriate. In a written report, the expert shall opine whether the minor has the sufficient present ability to consult with his or her counsel with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and whether he or she has a rational and factual understanding of the proceedings against him or her. The expert shall also state the basis for these conclusions. If the expert concludes that the minor lacks competency, the expert shall make recommendations regarding the type of remediation services that would be effective in assisting the minor in attaining competency, and, if possible, the expert shall address the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time.
(4)The Judicial Council Council, in conjunction with groups or individuals representing judges, defense counsel, district attorneys, counties, advocates for people with developmental and mental disabilities, state psychologists and psychiatrists, professional associations and accredited bodies for psychologists and psychiatrists, and other interested stakeholders, shall adopt a rule of court identifying the training and experience needed for an expert to be competent in forensic evaluations of juveniles, and juveniles. The Judicial Council shall develop and adopt rules for the implementation of the other requirements in this subdivision.
(5)Statements made to the appointed expert during the minors competency evaluation, statements made by the minor to mental health professionals during the remediation proceedings, and any fruits of those statements shall not be used in any other hearing against the minor in either juvenile or adult court.
(6)The district attorney or minors counsel may retain or seek the appointment of additional qualified experts who may testify during the competency hearing. The experts report and qualifications shall be disclosed to the opposing party within a reasonable time before, but no later than five court days before, the hearing. If disclosure is not made in accordance with this paragraph, the expert shall not be allowed to testify, and the experts report shall not be considered by the court unless the court finds good cause to consider the experts report and testimony. If, after disclosure of the report, the opposing party requests a continuance in order to further prepare for the hearing and shows good cause for the continuance, the court shall grant a continuance for a reasonable period of time.
(7)If the expert believes the minor is developmentally disabled, the court shall appoint the director of a regional center for developmentally disabled individuals described in Article 1 (commencing with Section 4620) of Chapter 5 of Division 4.5, or his or her designee, to evaluate the minor. The director of the regional center, or his or her designee, shall determine whether the minor is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)), and shall provide the court with a written report informing the court of his or her determination. The courts appointment of the director of the regional center for determination of eligibility for services shall not delay the courts proceedings for determination of competency.
(8)An experts opinion that a minor is developmentally disabled does not supersede an independent determination by the regional center regarding the minors eligibility for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)).
(9)Nothing in this section shall be interpreted to authorize or require either of the following:
(A)Placement of a minor who is incompetent in a developmental center or community facility operated by the State Department of Developmental Services without a determination by a regional center director, or his or her designee, that the minor has a developmental disability and is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)).
(B)Determinations regarding the competency of a minor by the director of the regional center or his or her designee.
(c)The question of the minors competency shall be determined at an evidentiary hearing unless there is a stipulation or submission by the parties on the findings of the expert. The minor has the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she is incompetent. It shall be presumed that the minor is mentally competent, unless it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that the minor is mentally incompetent.
(d)If the court finds the minor to be competent, the court shall reinstate proceedings and proceed commensurate with the courts jurisdiction.
(e)If the court finds, by a preponderance of evidence, that the minor is incompetent, all proceedings shall remain suspended for a period of time that is no longer than reasonably necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that the minor will attain competency in the foreseeable future, or the court no longer retains jurisdiction. During this time, the court may make orders that it deems appropriate for services. Further, the court may rule on motions that do not require the participation of the minor in the preparation of the motions. These motions include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Motions to dismiss.
(2)Motions regarding a change in the placement of the minor.
(3)Detention hearings.
(4)Demurrers.
(f)Upon a finding of incompetency, the court shall refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. Service providers and evaluators shall adhere to the standards stated in this section and the California Rules of Court. Services shall be provided in the least restrictive environment consistent with public safety. Priority shall be given to minors in custody. Service providers shall determine the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time, and if the opinion is that the minor will not attain competency within a reasonable period of time, the minor shall be returned to court at the earliest possible date. The court shall review remediation services at least every 30 calendar days for minors in custody and every 45 calendar days for minors out of custody.
(g)(1)Upon receipt of the recommendation by the remediation program, the court shall hold an evidentiary hearing on whether the minor is remediated or is able to be remediated unless the parties stipulate to, or agree to the recommendation of, the remediation program. If the recommendation is that the minor has attained competency, and if the minor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the minor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that he or she remains incompetent. If the recommendation is that the minor is unable to be remediated and if the prosecutor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that the minor is remediable. If the prosecution contests the evaluation of continued incompetence, the minor shall be presumed incompetent and the prosecution shall have the burden to prove by a preponderance of evidence that the minor is competent. The provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply at this stage of the proceedings.
(2)If the court finds that the minor has been remediated, the court shall reinstate the proceedings.
(3)If the court finds that the minor has not yet been remediated, but is likely to be remediated, remediated within a reasonable period of time, the court shall order the minor to return to the remediation program.
(4)If the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, competency within a reasonable period of time, the court shall dismiss the petition. The court may invite persons and agencies with information about the minor, including, but not limited to, the minor and his or her attorney, the probation department, parents, guardians, or relative caregivers, mental health treatment professionals, the public guardian, educational rights holders, education providers, and social services agencies, to the dismissal hearing to discuss any services that may be available to the minor after jurisdiction is terminated. If appropriate, the court shall refer the minor for evaluation pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of Division 5 or Article 3 (commencing with Section 6550) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 6.
(5)In no case shall remediation extend beyond two years, or a period of time equal to the maximum term of detention for the most serious charge on the petition, whichever is shorter, on a petition that contains a felony offense. In no case shall remediation extend beyond one year, or a period of time equal to the maximum term of detention provided by law for the most serious offense, whichever is shorter, on a petition that contains only misdemeanor offenses.
(h)The presiding judge of the juvenile court, the probation department, the county mental health department, the public defender and other entity that provides representation for minors, the district attorney, the regional center, if appropriate, and any other participants that the presiding judge shall designate, shall develop a written protocol describing the competency process and a program to ensure that minors who are found incompetent receive appropriate remediation services.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)During the pendency of any juvenile proceeding, the minors counsel or the court may express a doubt as to the minors competency. A minor is incompetent to proceed if he or she lacks sufficient present ability to consult with counsel and assist in preparing his or her defense with a reasonable degree of rational understanding, or lacks a rational as well as factual understanding, of the nature of the charges or proceedings against him or her. If the court finds substantial evidence raises a doubt as to the minors competency, the proceedings shall be suspended.
(b)Upon suspension of proceedings, the court shall order that the question of the minors competence be determined at a hearing. The court shall appoint an expert to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition and, if so, whether the condition or conditions impair the minors competency. The expert shall have expertise in child and adolescent development, and training in the forensic evaluation of juveniles, and shall be familiar with competency standards and accepted criteria used in evaluating competence. The Judicial Council shall develop and adopt rules for the implementation of these requirements.
(c)If the minor is found to be incompetent by a preponderance of the evidence, all proceedings shall remain suspended for a period of time that is no longer than reasonably necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that the minor will attain competency in the foreseeable future, or the court no longer retains jurisdiction. During this time, the court may make orders that it deems appropriate for services, subject to subdivision (h), that may assist the minor in attaining competency. Further, the court may rule on motions that do not require the participation of the minor in the preparation of the motions. These motions include, but are not limited to, the following:
(1)Motions to dismiss.
(2)Motions by the defense regarding a change in the placement of the minor.
(3)Detention hearings.
(4)Demurrers.
(d)If the minor is found to be competent, the court may proceed commensurate with the courts jurisdiction.
(e)This section applies to a minor who is alleged to come within the jurisdiction of the court pursuant to Section 601 or 602.
709.(a)(1)Whenever the court has a doubt that a minor who is subject to any juvenile proceedings is mentally competent, the court shall suspend all proceedings and proceed pursuant to this section.
(2)A minor is mentally incompetent for purposes of this section if he or she is unable to understand the nature of the proceedings, including his or her role in the proceedings, or unable to assist counsel in conducting a defense in a rational manner, including a lack of a rational and factual understanding of the nature of the charges or proceedings. Incompetency may result from the presence of any condition or conditions, including, but not limited to, mental illness, mental disorder, developmental disability, or developmental immaturity. Except as specifically provided otherwise, this section applies to a minor who is alleged to come within the jurisdiction of the court pursuant to Section 601 or 602.
(3)During the pendency of any juvenile proceeding, the court may receive information from any source regarding the minors ability to understand the proceedings. The minors counsel or the court may express a doubt as to the minors competency. The receipt of information or the expression of doubt of the minors counsel does not automatically require the suspension of proceedings. If the court has a doubt as to the minors competency, the court shall suspend the proceedings.
(b)(1)Unless the parties stipulate to a finding that the minor lacks competency, or the parties are willing to submit on the issue of the minors lack of competency, the court shall appoint an expert to evaluate the minor and determine whether the minor suffers from a mental illness, mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition affecting competency and, if so, whether the minor is competent.
(2)The expert shall have expertise in child and adolescent development and forensic evaluation of juveniles for purposes of adjudicating competency, shall be familiar with competency standards and accepted criteria used in evaluating juvenile competency, and shall have received training in conducting juvenile competency evaluations.
(3)The expert shall personally interview the minor and review all of the available records provided, including, but not limited to, medical, education, special education, probation, child welfare, mental health, regional center, and court records, and any other relevant information that is available. The expert shall consult with the minors counsel and any other person who has provided information to the court regarding the minors lack of competency. The expert shall gather a developmental history of the minor. If any information is unavailable to the expert, he or she shall note in the report the efforts to obtain that information. The expert shall administer age-appropriate testing specific to the issue of competency unless the facts of the particular case render testing unnecessary or inappropriate. In a written report, the expert shall opine whether the minor has the sufficient present ability to consult with his or her counsel with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and whether he or she has a rational and factual understanding of the proceedings against him or her. The expert shall also state the basis for these conclusions. If the expert concludes that the minor lacks competency, the expert shall make recommendations regarding the type of remediation services that would be effective in assisting the minor in attaining competency, and, if possible, the expert shall address the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time.
(4)The Judicial Council shall adopt a rule of court identifying the training and experience needed for an expert to be competent in forensic evaluations of juveniles, and shall develop and adopt rules for the implementation of the other requirements in this subdivision.
(5)Statements made to the appointed expert during the minors competency evaluation, statements made by the minor to mental health professionals during the remediation proceedings, and any fruits of those statements shall not be used in any other hearing against the minor in either juvenile or adult court.
(6)The district attorney or minors counsel may retain or seek the appointment of additional qualified experts who may testify during the competency hearing. The experts report and qualifications shall be disclosed to the opposing party within a reasonable time before, but no later than five court days before, the hearing. If disclosure is not made in accordance with this paragraph, the expert shall not be allowed to testify, and the experts report shall not be considered by the court unless the court finds good cause to consider the experts report and testimony. If, after disclosure of the report, the opposing party requests a continuance in order to further prepare for the hearing and shows good cause for the continuance, the court shall grant a continuance for a reasonable period of time.
(f)
(7)If the expert believes the minor is developmentally disabled, the court shall appoint the director of a regional center for developmentally disabled individuals described in Article 1 (commencing with Section 4620) of Chapter 5 of Division 4.5, or his or her designee, to evaluate the minor. The director of the regional center, or his or her designee, shall determine whether the minor is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)), and shall provide the court with a written report informing the court of his or her determination. The courts appointment of the director of the regional center for determination of eligibility for services shall not delay the courts proceedings for determination of competency.
(g)
(8)An experts opinion that a minor is developmentally disabled does not supersede an independent determination by the regional center whether the minor is eligible regarding the minors eligibility for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)).
(h)
(9)Nothing in this section shall be interpreted to authorize or require either of the following:
(1)The court to place
(A)Placement of a minor who is incompetent in a developmental center or community facility operated by the State Department of Developmental Services without a determination by a regional center director, or his or her designee, that the minor has a developmental disability and is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act (Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500)).
(2)The director of the regional center, or his or her designee, to make determinations
(B)Determinations regarding the competency of a minor. minor by the director of the regional center or his or her designee.
(c)The question of the minors competency shall be determined at an evidentiary hearing unless there is a stipulation or submission by the parties on the findings of the expert. The minor has the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she is incompetent.
(d)If the court finds the minor to be competent, the court shall reinstate proceedings and proceed commensurate with the courts jurisdiction.
(e)If the court finds, by a preponderance of evidence, that the minor is incompetent, all proceedings shall remain suspended for a period of time that is no longer than reasonably necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that the minor will attain competency in the foreseeable future, or the court no longer retains jurisdiction. During this time, the court may make orders that it deems appropriate for services. Further, the court may rule on motions that do not require the participation of the minor in the preparation of the motions. These motions include, but are not limited to, all of the
following: (1)Motions to dismiss. (2)Motions regarding a change in the placement of the minor. (3)Detention hearings.
(4)Demurrers.
(f)Upon a finding of incompetency, the court shall refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. Service providers and evaluators shall adhere to the standards stated in this section and the California Rules of Court. Services shall be provided in the least restrictive environment consistent with public safety. Priority shall be given to minors in custody. Service providers shall determine the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time, and if the opinion is that the minor will not attain competency within a reasonable period of time, the minor shall be returned to court at the earliest possible date. The court shall review remediation services at least every 30 calendar days for minors in custody and every 45 calendar days for minors out of custody.
(g)(1)Upon receipt of the recommendation by the remediation program, the court shall hold an evidentiary hearing on whether the minor is remediated or is able to be remediated unless the parties stipulate to, or agree to the recommendation of, the remediation program. If the recommendation is that the minor has attained competency, and if the minor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the minor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that he or she remains incompetent. If the recommendation is that the minor is unable to be remediated and if the prosecutor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that the minor is remediable. If the prosecution contests the evaluation of continued incompetence, the minor shall be presumed incompetent and the prosecution shall have the burden to prove by a preponderance of evidence that the minor is competent. The provisions of subdivision (c) shall apply at this stage of the proceedings.
(2)If the court finds that the minor has been remediated, the court shall reinstate the proceedings.
(3)If the court finds that the minor has not yet been remediated, but is likely to be remediated, the court shall order the minor to return to the remediation program.
(4)If the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, the court shall dismiss the petition. The court may invite persons and agencies with information about the minor, including, but not limited to, the minor and his or her attorney, the probation department, parents, guardians, or relative caregivers, mental health treatment professionals, the public guardian, educational rights holders, education providers, and social services agencies, to the dismissal hearing to discuss any services that may be available to the minor after jurisdiction is terminated. If appropriate, the court shall refer the minor for evaluation pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 5300) of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of Division 5 or Article 3 (commencing with Section 6550) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 6.
(h)The presiding judge of the juvenile court, the probation department, the county mental health department, the public defender and other entity that provides representation for minors, the district attorney, the regional center, if appropriate, and any other participants that the presiding judge shall designate, shall develop a written protocol describing the competency process and a program to ensure that minors who are found incompetent receive appropriate remediation services.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 27, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 18, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 20, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 12). |
| Mar 10, 2016 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 12, 2016 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 18, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2695
Author:(Obernolte) – As Amended Ver:April 19, 2016
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill revises the procedure for when there is a question about the mental competence of a juvenile charged with a crime. Specifically, this bill:
- States that whenever the court has a doubt that a minor who is subject to any juvenile proceedings is mentally competent, the court shall suspend all proceedings and make a determination of competence.
- Specifies that a minor is mentally incompetent if he or she is unable to understand the nature of the proceedings, including his or her role in the proceedings, or unable to assist counsel in conducting a defense in a rational manner, including a lack of a rational and factual understanding of the nature of the charges or proceedings.
- Provides a process for establishing competency. States that unless the parties stipulate to a finding that the minor lacks competency, or the parties are willing to submit on the issue of the minor’s lack of competency, the court must appoint an expert, with expertise in child and adolescent development and forensic evaluation of juvenile, to evaluate the minor through interviews with minor and counsel and review of available records, and determine whether the minor is competent.
- If the expert finds that the minor lacks competency, the expert must make recommendations regarding the type of remediation services the minor requires. Requires the court upon a finding of incompetency, to refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. Service providers shall determine the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time, and if the opinion is that the minor will not attain competency within a reasonable period of time, the minor shall be returned to court at the earliest possible date.
- Provides a process to move the case forward until the minor attains competency, or the minor remains in a remediation program. In no case will the remediation extend beyond two years, - current law is three years - or a period of time equal to the maximum term of detention for the most serious charge, whichever is shorter, if the petition involves a felony; or one year, or the time equal to the maximum term, on a petition that contains only a misdemeanor.
- States that if the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, the court shall dismiss the charges, and states that the proceedings above apply to juveniles before the criminal court.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown, but likely in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars, reimbursable mandate costs (GF) for county probation departments to provide a higher level of remediation services to minors. If 500 minors are housed for an additional five days and the cost for the higher level of services is an additional $100 per day, the annual cost would be $250,000. However, pursuant to Proposition 30 (November 2012) any legislation enacted after September 30, 2012, that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by realignment only apply to local agencies to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase.
- Minor absorbable costs to the Judicial Council to establish a new Rule of Court.
- Minor and absorbable costs to the courts.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, “There are a number of deficiencies in the existing laws that lay out the procedures for determining whether minors are able to understand and participate in court proceedings. As a result, juveniles that may lack competency are being underserved and left without proper protection.
“AB 2695, sponsored by the Judicial Council, would address these issues and revise the provisions for assessing a minor’s competency and set guidelines for how to proceed if they are deemed incompetent. It is the result of a two-year working group, consisting of members of California’s Family and Juvenile Law Advisory Committee, Collaborative Justice Courts Advisory Committee and Mental Health Issues Implementation Task Force. Among the stakeholders that participated in the working group were judges, a chief probation officer, a deputy district attorney, a deputy public defender and a private defense attorney.
“Together with input from public comment, the working group drafted a set of amendments to the Welfare and Institutions Code that would clarify and improve these procedures. The result, AB 2695, presents a cohesive set of guidelines for competency proceedings that will better protect minors who are facing competency questions.” - Opposition. The California Public Defenders Association (DPDA) states, “Certainly Welfare and Institutions Code section 709 in its current configuration leaves much to be desired with respect to policies and procedures regarding juvenile adjudicative competency. However, AB 2695, as currently proposed, fails to improve upon current law and in many respects creates an even more problematic process regarding children whose competency has been called into question in juvenile delinquency proceedings. CPDA further opposes AB 2695’s provisions that gives the juvenile court authorization to refer minors for services after the court’s jurisdiction has been terminated due to the substantial likelihood the minor will not attain competency in a reasonable amount of time."
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2695
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2016
SUMMARY:
Revises the procedure when there is a question about the mental competence of a juvenile charged with a crime. Specifically, this bill:
- States that whenever the court has a doubt that a minor who is subject to any juvenile proceedings is mentally competent, the court shall suspend all proceedings and make a determination of competence.
- Specifies that a minor is mentally incompetent if he or she is unable to understand the nature of the proceedings, including his or her role in the proceedings, or unable to assist counsel in conducting a defense in a rational manner, including a lack of a rational and factual understanding of the nature of the charges or proceedings.
- States that incompetency may result from the presence of any condition or conditions, including, but not limited to, mental illness, mental disorder, developmental disability, or developmental immaturity.
- Allows the court to receive information from any source regarding the minor’s ability to understand the proceedings.
- States that the minor’s counsel or the court may express a doubt as to the minor’s competency, but the receipt of information or the expression of doubt of the minor’s counsel does not automatically require the suspension of proceedings.
- Provides that if the court has a doubt as to the minor’s competency, the court shall suspend the proceedings.
- States that unless the parties stipulate to a finding that the minor lacks competency, or the parties are willing to submit on the issue of the minor’s lack of competency, the court shall appoint an expert to evaluate the minor and determine whether the minor is competent.
- Requires the expert to have expertise in child and adolescent development and forensic evaluation of juveniles for purposes of adjudicating competency, to be familiar with competency standards and accepted criteria used in evaluating juvenile competency, and to have received training in conducting juvenile competency evaluations.
- Requires the expert to personally interview the minor and review all of the available records provided, including, but not limited to, medical, education, special education, probation, child welfare, mental health, regional center, and court records, and any other relevant information that is available.
- Requires the expert to consult with the minor’s counsel and any other person who has provided information to the court regarding the minor’s lack of competency, to gather a developmental history of the minor, to administer age-appropriate testing specific to the issue of competency, unless the facts of the particular case render testing unnecessary or inappropriate.
- Specifies that in a written report, the expert shall opine whether the minor has the sufficient present ability to consult with his or her counsel with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and whether he or she has a rational and factual understanding of the proceedings against him or her.
- Specifies that if the expert concludes that the minor lacks competency, the expert shall make recommendations regarding the type of services that would be effective in assisting the minor in attaining competency, and, if possible, the expert shall address the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court identifying the training and experience needed for an expert to be competent in forensic evaluations of juveniles, and shall develop and adopt rules for the implementation of the other requirements in this subdivision.
- Specifies that statements made to the appointed expert during the minor’s competency evaluation, statements made by the minor to mental health professionals during the remediation proceedings, and any fruits of those statements shall not be used in any other hearing against the minor in either juvenile or adult court.
- Allows the district attorney or minor’s counsel to retain or seek the appointment of additional qualified experts who may testify during the competency hearing.
- Requires an expert’s report and qualifications to be disclosed to the opposing party within a reasonable time before, but no later than five court days before, the hearing.
- States that the question of the minor’s competency shall be determined at an evidentiary hearing unless there is a stipulation or submission by the parties on the findings of the expert.
- Specifies that the minor has the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she is incompetent.
- Provides that if the court finds the minor to be competent, the court shall reinstate proceedings and proceed.
- States that if the court finds, by a preponderance of evidence, that the minor is incompetent, all proceedings shall remain suspended for a period of time that is no longer than reasonably necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that the minor will attain competency in the foreseeable future, or the court no longer retains jurisdiction.
- Requires the court upon a finding of incompetency, to refer the minor to services designed to help the minor attain competency. Service providers shall determine the likelihood of the minor attaining competency within a reasonable period of time, and if the opinion is that the minor will not attain competency within a reasonable period of time, the minor shall be returned to court at the earliest possible date.
- Requires the court to review remediation services at least every 30 calendar days for minors in custody and every 45 calendar days for minors out of custody.
- Requires the court receipt of the recommendation by the remediation program, to hold an evidentiary hearing on whether the minor is remediated or is able to be remediated unless the parties stipulate to, or agree to the recommendation of, the remediation program.
- Specifies that if the recommendation is that the minor has attained competency, and if the minor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the minor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that he or she remains incompetent.
- Specifies that if the recommendation is that the minor is unable to be remediated and if the prosecutor disputes that recommendation, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove by a preponderance of evidence that the minor is remediable.
- States that if the court finds that the minor has been remediated, the court shall reinstate the proceedings.
- Provides that if the court finds that the minor has not yet been remediated, but is likely to be remediated, the court shall order the minor to return to the remediation program.
- States that if the court finds that the minor will not achieve competency, the court shall dismiss the charges.
- States that the proceedings above apply to juveniles before the court for criminal for criminal charges.
EXISTING LAW:
- States that during any juvenile proceeding, the minor's counsel or the court may express a doubt as to the minor's competency. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that a minor is incompetent to proceed if he or she lacks sufficient present ability to consult with counsel and assist in preparing his or her defense with a reasonable degree of rational understanding, or lacks a rational as well as factual understanding, of the nature of the charges or proceedings against him or her. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (a).)
- If the court finds substantial evidence raises a doubt as to the minor's competency, the proceedings shall be suspended. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (a).)
- States that upon suspension of proceedings, the court shall order that the question of the minor's competence be determined at a hearing. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (b).)
- Requires the court to appoint an expert to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a mental disorder, developmental disability, developmental immaturity, or other condition and, if so, whether the condition or conditions impair the minor's competency. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (b).)
- Requires the expert to have expertise in child and adolescent development, and training in the forensic evaluation of juveniles, and shall be familiar with competency standards and accepted criteria used in evaluating competence. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (b).)
- States that the Judicial Council shall develop and adopt rules for the implementation of these requirements. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that if the minor is found to be incompetent by a preponderance of the evidence, all proceedings shall remain suspended for a period of time that is no longer than reasonably necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that the minor will attain competency in the foreseeable future, or the court no longer retains jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (c)(1).)
- Provides that during the time proceedings are suspended, the court may make orders that it deems appropriate for services that may assist the minor in attaining competency. Further, the court may rule on motions that do not require the participation of the minor in the preparation of specified motions (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (c)(1).)
- States that if the minor is found to be competent, the court may proceed commensurate with the court's jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (d).)
- Specifies that if the expert believes the minor is developmentally disabled, the court shall appoint the director of a regional center for developmentally disabled individuals, as specified, to evaluate the minor. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (f).)
- Specifies that the director of the regional center, or his or her designee, shall determine whether the minor is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, and shall provide the court with a written report informing the court of his or her determination. (Wel. & Inst., § 709, subd. (f).)
- States that an expert's opinion that a minor is developmentally disabled does not supersede an independent determination by the regional center whether the minor is eligible for services under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act. (Welf. & Inst., § 709, subd. (g).)
- Specifies that if a doubt arises in the mind of the judge as to the mental competence of an adult defendant, he or she shall state that doubt in the record and inquire of the attorney for the defendant whether, in the opinion of the attorney, the defendant is mentally competent. (Pen. Code, § 1368, subd. (a).)
- Provides that if counsel informs the court that he or she believes the adult defendant is or may be mentally incompetent, the court shall order that the question of the defendant's mental competence is to be determined in a hearing. (Pen. Code, § 1368, subd. (b).)
- In any case where the adult defendant or the defendant's counsel informs the court that the defendant is not seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint two psychiatrists, licensed psychologists, or a combination thereof; (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (a).)
- Allows one of the psychiatrists or licensed psychologists to be named by the defense and one to be named by the prosecution, when two experts are appointed. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (a).)
- States a presumption that the defendant is mentally competent unless it is proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is mentally incompetent. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (f).)
- States that at the end of three years from the date of commitment or a period of commitment equal to the maximum term of imprisonment, as specified, whichever is shorter, but no later than 90 days prior to the expiration of the defendant's term of commitment, a defendant who has not recovered mental competence shall be returned to the committing court. (Pen. Code, § 1370, subd. (c)(1).)
- States that if, at the end of one year from the date of commitment or a period of commitment equal to the maximum term of imprisonment provided by law for the most serious offense charged in the misdemeanor complaint, whichever is shorter, the defendant has not recovered mental competence, the defendant shall be returned to the committing court. (Pen. Code, § 1370.01, subd. (c)(1).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “There are a number of deficiencies in the existing laws that lay out the procedures for determining whether minors are able to understand and participate in court proceedings. As a result, juveniles that may lack competency are being underserved and left without proper protection.
“AB 2695, sponsored by the Judicial Council, would address these issues and revise the provisions for assessing a minor’s competency and set guidelines for how to proceed if they are deemed incompetent. It is the result of a two year working group, consisting of members of California’s Family and Juvenile Law Advisory Committee, Collaborative Justice Courts Advisory Committee and Mental Health Issues Implementation Task Force. Among the stakeholders that participated in the working group were judges, a chief probation officer, a deputy district attorney, a deputy public defender and a private defense attorney.
“Together with input from public comment, the working group drafted a set of amendments to the Welfare and Institutions Code that would clarify and improve these procedures. The result, AB 2695, presents a cohesive set of guidelines for competency proceedings that will better protect minors who are facing competency questions.” - Current Juvenile Competency Standards and Procedures: Adult mental incompetency is currently defined as lacking sufficient present ability to consult with counsel and assist in preparing a defense with a reasonable degree of rational understanding or lacking a rational as well as factual understanding of the nature of the charges or proceedings. While those same factors would be considered in evaluating the competency of a minor, the court would also consider the minors developmental maturity. Unlike an adult, a minor may be determined to be incompetent based on developmental immaturity alone (Timothy J. v. Superior Court, 150 Cal.App.4th 847 (2007)).
The current statute governing juvenile competency procedures was put in place in 2010. (AB 2212 (Fuentes), Chapter 671, Statutes of 2010.) The language of that statute created some procedural gaps regarding how a juvenile should be treated if they are found to be incompetent. That statute also does not provide thorough guidelines regarding the experts responsible for evaluating the minor. - Adults and Juveniles Have Different Cognitive Abilities: Researchers in the science of human development, however, generally agree that from a developmental standpoint an adolescent is not an adult.
"The evidence now is strong that the brain does not cease to mature until the early 20s in those relevant parts that govern impulsivity, judgment, planning for the future, foresight of consequences, and other characteristics that make people morally culpable . . . Indeed, age 21 or 22 would be closer to the 'biological' age of maturity." [Adolescent Brain Development and Legal Culpability, American Bar Assn. Criminal Justice Section, Juvenile Justice Center (Winter 2003).]
Lack of culpability is at the heart of the Court of Appeal decision in Timothy J., supra, holding that developmental immaturity is grounds for a finding of not competent. The Court stated:
"As a matter of law and logic, an adult's incompetence to stand trial must arise from a mental disorder or developmental disability that limits his or her ability to understand the nature of the proceedings and to assist counsel (internal citation omitted.) The same may not be said of a young child whose developmental immaturity may result in trial incompetence despite the absence of any underlying mental or developmental abnormality. Dr. Edwards testified that minors are different from adults because their brains are still developing and as myelination occurs during puberty, the minor develops the ability to think logically and abstractly. Both experts concluded that because of his age, [the minor's] brain has not fully developed and he was unable to think in those ways.
"Their conclusions are supported by the literature, which indicates that there is a relationship between age and competency to stand trial and that an adolescent's cognitive, psychological, social, and moral development has a significant biological basis. [Steinberg, Juveniles on Trial: MacArthur Foundation Study Calls Competency into Question (2003) 18 Crim. Just. supra, 20, 21.]
"While many factors affect a minor's competency to stand trial, 'the younger the juvenile defendant, the less likely he or she will be to manifest the type of cognitive understanding sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the Dusky standard'.” (Internal citation omitted.) According to Steinberg, the frontal lobes oversee high-level cognitive tasks such as hypothetical thinking, logical reasoning, long-range planning, and complex decision-making. During puberty, that area of the brain matures as the myelination process takes place. (Steinberg, supra, 18 Criminal Justice, at p. 20.)
"The research indicates that such factors as age, intelligence level, mental health history and severity of diagnosis, history of remedial education, and prior arrest or justice system history are relevant in determining a minor's trial competency (internal citation omitted.) One researcher found that 30 percent of the 11 to 13 year olds, and 19 percent of the 14 and 15 year olds, performed at the level of mentally ill adults who have been found incompetent to stand trial in matters of understanding and reason" (internal citation omitted.) - Argument in Support: According to The Judicial Council, “AB 2695 is the result of a long stakeholder process that brought judges, district attorneys, public defenders, and other stakeholders to the table. Statewide best practices, subject matter experts, recent state Supreme court cases, and stakeholder goals were all considered in reaching the good compromise measure before you.
“AB 2695 will create consistency statewide in conducting competency hearings in delinquency cases, while still allowing counties to pursue diversion programs that have been effective with their local populations. The bill will clarify procedures, firmly identify the burden of proof, and require courts to provide services to minors in an attempt to help restore and maintain competency.
“For these reasons, the Judicial Council supports AB 2695, . . .” - Argument in Opposition: According to The California Public Defenders Association, “. . . First, recently the California Supreme Court decided in In re R.V. (2015) 61 Cal.4th 181, that notwithstanding the absence of the presumption of competency or specifically stating who has the burden to establish incompetency in the current version of Welfare and Institutions Code section 709, minors are presumed competent in juvenile delinquency proceedings and carry the burden to prove otherwise. However, the high court only found this to be necessarily true regarding minors age 14 or older. With respect to minors under the age of 14, the court observed that, “any possible interplay between the presumption of competency and the presumption of incapacity is limited to cases involving minors under the age of 14 years. In such cases, the presumption of competency arises only if the minor is subject to adjudication under the juvenile law, that is, only after the prosecution has overcome the presumption of incapacity with clear and convincing proof that the minor knew the wrongfulness of his or her conduct. The presumption of competency presents no inconsistency with a presumption of incapacity that has been rebutted.” (In re R.V., supra, 61 Cal.4th, at pp. 197-198.) Stated simply, prior to presuming children under the age of 14 are competent to proceed in juvenile delinquency proceedings, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove by clear and convincing evidence that the minor knew the wrongfulness of his or her conduct, making the minor subject to adjudication under juvenile law in the first instance. AB 2695 as currently configured would be inconsistent with current California law and the California Supreme Court’s interpretation of the interplay between juvenile adjudicative competency and the presumption of incapacity of children under the age of 14.
"CPDA further opposes AB 2695’s provisions that gives the juvenile court authorization to refer minors for services after the court’s jurisdiction has been terminated due to the substantial likelihood the minor will not attain competency in a reasonable amount of time. Although on its face this appears to be a lofty goal, i.e., to refer minors for services that the minor may appear to need. However, the problem with this provision is its lack of understanding of the nature of the problem of incompetency. One of the reasons these children will have been found to be incompetent in the first instance is because they lack a rational understanding and appreciation for the nature of the proceedings against them. The goal of being referred to services is having the ability, capacity and appreciation of how the services apply to the alleged offender and how the alleged offender can utilize such services going forward. Moreover, many of these children would not have been legally responsible for the alleged conduct, and will be unable to be vindicated as a result of their inability to assist counsel in a meaningful way, or due to their inability to understand and appreciate the nature of the proceedings against them. Lastly, to what extent would the court be making the referrals is problematic. Would the referrals be made as orders of the court, or suggestions; and to what extent could the minor be held responsible if he or she, or his or her family did not participate in the referred services? AB 2695 in its current configuration leaves these and many other questions unanswered.
"Finally, CPDA opposed AB 2695’s provision that would require each county to develop a protocol describing the competency process and program for the county to ensure minors that are found incompetent receive appropriate remediation services. The problem with this provision is it will lead to inconsistency throughout the state. It is one thing to have protocols that provide for time, place and manner of competency proceedings within a given county, but many of these protocols will also call for how long a child can the incarcerated pending competency proceedings; how long a case can be suspended before a child can bring a motion to dismiss; what types of information can be presented in motions to dismiss; etc. California should have statewide timelines regarding the length of detention for children pending competency proceedings, especially in light of the limited qualified evaluators available to perform competency evaluations on children and the limited services children receive pending competency evaluations and proceedings while in custody. We should also have statewide procedures rather than individual county protocols because of the potential for local courts to refuse to follow its own county protocol, which was the case that arose recently in In re Albert C., Second District Court of Appeal Case No. B256480, Los Angeles County Superior Court No. MJ21492, review granted 02/24/16 by the California Supreme Court, Case No. S231315.
"Certainly Welfare and Institutions Code section 709 in its current configuration leaves much to be desired with respect to policies and procedures regarding juvenile adjudicative competency. However, AB 2695, as currently proposed, fails to improve upon current law and in many respects creates an even more problematic process regarding children whose competency has been called into question in juvenile delinquency proceedings."
- Related Legislation:
- AB 1962 (Dodd), requires the State Department of State Hospitals, to establish guidelines for minimum education and training standards for a psychiatrist or licensed psychologist to be considered for appointment by the court to conduct adult mental competency evaluations. AB 1962 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1962 (Dodd), requires the State Department of State Hospitals, to establish guidelines for minimum education and training standards for a psychiatrist or licensed psychologist to be considered for appointment by the court to conduct adult mental competency evaluations. AB 1962 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 368 (Liu), Chapter 471, Statutes of 2011, requires that the court appoint an expert, as specified, to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a developmental disability. Requires the court to appoint the director of a regional center for developmentally disabled individuals, or his or her designee, to evaluate the minor if the expert believes the minor is developmentally disabled.
- AB 2212 (Fuentes), Chapter 671, Statutes of 2010, provides that a minor is incompetent to proceed if he or she lacks sufficient present ability to consult with counsel and assist in preparing his or her defense with a reasonable degree of rational understanding, or lacks a rational as well as factual understanding, of the nature of the charges or proceedings against him or her. Requires proceedings to be suspended if the court finds substantial evidence raises a doubt as to the minor’s competency.
- SB 368 (Liu), Chapter 471, Statutes of 2011, requires that the court appoint an expert, as specified, to evaluate whether the minor suffers from a developmental disability. Requires the court to appoint the director of a regional center for developmentally disabled individuals, or his or her designee, to evaluate the minor if the expert believes the minor is developmentally disabled.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Judicial Council of California
Opposition
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
Analysis Prepared by:
David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):