AB 2748: Environmental disaster: release of claims: statute of limitations: attorneys' fees.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-31
(1)Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, would release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and would not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(2)Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would, notwithstanding the above provision, establish a statute of limitations of 3 years for specified civil actions for injury, illness, or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos.
(3)Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(4)This bill would limit the application of its provisions to damages caused by an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, as specified, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. The bill would specify that its provisions do not apply to any action against a public entity, as defined.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for these regions.
(1)Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, would release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and would not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(2)Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would, notwithstanding the above provision, establish a statute of limitations of 3 years for specified civil actions for injury, illness, or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos.
(3)Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(4)This bill would limit the application of its provisions to damages caused by an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, as specified, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. The bill would specify that its provisions do not apply to any action against a public entity, as defined.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for these regions.
(1)Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, would release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and would not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(2)Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would, notwithstanding the above provision, establish a statute of limitations of 3 years for specified civil actions for injury, illness, or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos.
(3)Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(4)This bill would limit the application of its provisions to the Porter Ranch area, as defined, damages caused by an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, as specified, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for these regions.
Existing
(1)Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient would release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and would not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. The bill would prohibit any such payment from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
Under the bill, a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, would release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and would not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
Existing
(2)Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would change all those dates from 2 to 3 years. would, notwithstanding the above provision, establish a statute of limitations of 3 years for specified civil actions for injury, illness, or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos.
Under
(3)Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(4)This bill would limit the application of its provisions to the Porter Ranch area, as defined, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for these regions.
Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient would release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and would not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. The bill would prohibit any such payment from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after January February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would change all those dates from 2 to 3 years.
Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
This bill would prohibit a
Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, from being conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster or all future claims, or both. would not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. The bill would prohibit any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. The bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
Under the bill, a final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient would release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and would not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. The bill would prohibit any such payment from being conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
The bill would make any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
Existing law defines a nuisance as anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, as specified. Existing law defines a public nuisance as a nuisance that affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal, and makes every public nuisance a private nuisance as to those affected by it. Existing law provides that the abatement of a nuisance does not prejudice the right of any person to recover damages for its past existence.
This bill would create a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area, as defined, on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016. The bill would specify a mechanism for measuring the diminution in value.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility leak.
Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would change all those dates from 2 to 3 years.
Under existing law, except as attorneys attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. The Public Utilities Act prohibits any gas corporation from beginning the construction of, among other things, a line, plant, or system, or of any extension thereof, without having first obtained from the commission a certificate that the present or future public convenience and necessity require or will require that construction. Pursuant to existing law, the commission issued a certificate of public convenience and necessity to Southern California Gas Company for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility.
Existing law establishes the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources in the Department of Conservation and authorizes the State Oil and Gas Supervisor, with the approval of the Director of Conservation, to adopt rules and regulations that may be necessary to carry out the purposes for which the division was established. Pursuant to its existing authority, the supervisor has adopted onshore well regulations that are applicable, in part, to gas storage facilities.
Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
This bill would prohibit a payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, from being conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster or all future claims, or both.
Existing law defines a nuisance as anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, as specified. Existing law defines a public nuisance as a nuisance that affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal, and makes every public nuisance a private nuisance as to those affected by it. Existing law provides that the abatement of a nuisance does not prejudice the right of any person to recover damages for its past existence.
This bill would create a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area, as defined, on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016. The right of action would accrue when the claimant first offers the property for sale or seeks refinancing of the property. The bill would specify a mechanism for measuring the diminution in value.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility leak.
Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
This bill would change all those dates from 2 to 3 years.
Under existing law, except as attorneys fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. The Public Utilities Act prohibits any gas corporation from beginning the construction of, among other things, a line, plant, or system, or of any extension thereof, without having first obtained from the commission a certificate that the present or future public convenience and necessity require or will require that construction. Pursuant to existing law, the commission issued a certificate of public convenience and necessity to Southern California Gas Company for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility.
Existing law establishes the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources in the Department of Conservation and authorizes the State Oil and Gas Supervisor, with the approval of the Director of Conservation, to adopt rules and regulations that may be necessary to carry out the purposes for which the division was established. Pursuant to its existing authority, the supervisor has adopted onshore well regulations that are applicable, in part, to gas storage facilities.
Existing law defines a nuisance as anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, as specified. Existing law defines a public nuisance as a nuisance that affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal, and makes every public nuisance a private nuisance as to those affected by it. Existing law provides that the abatement of a nuisance does not prejudice the right of any person to recover damages for its past existence.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would facilitate the resolution of claims for property damage against Southern California Gas Company growing out of a major leakage of natural gas at its Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility that commenced in October 2015, in order to achieve just results while avoiding clogging the courts.
This bill would create a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area, as defined, on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016. The right of action would accrue when the claimant first offers the property for sale or seeks refinancing of the property. The bill would specify a mechanism for measuring the diminution in value.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility leak.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including gas corporations. The Public Utilities Act prohibits any gas corporation from beginning the construction of, among other things, a line, plant, or system, or of any extension thereof, without having first obtained from the commission a certificate that the present or future public convenience and necessity require or will require that construction. Pursuant to existing law, the commission issued a certificate of public convenience and necessity to Southern California Gas Company for the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility.
Existing law establishes the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources in the Department of Conservation and authorizes the State Oil and Gas Supervisor, with the approval of the Director of Conservation, to adopt rules and regulations that may be necessary to carry out the purposes for which the division was established. Pursuant to its existing authority, the supervisor has adopted onshore well regulations that are applicable, in part, to gas storage facilities.
Existing law defines a nuisance as anything injurious to health, indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, as specified. Existing law defines a public nuisance as a nuisance that affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood or any considerable number of persons, although the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon individuals may be unequal, and makes every public nuisance a private nuisance as to those affected by it. Existing law provides that the abatement of a nuisance does not prejudice the right of any person to recover damages for its past existence.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would facilitate the resolution of claims for property damage against Southern California Gas Company growing out of a major leakage of natural gas at its Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility that commenced in October 2015, in order to achieve just results while avoiding clogging the courts.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
(f)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an agreement relating to acts, omissions, or injuries in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(g)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 340.85 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, immediately following Section 340.8, to read:340.85.(a)Notwithstanding Section 340.8, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 340.8, in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(e)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.(a)In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(b)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(c)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution to achieve just and efficient results in civil litigation involving the unique circumstances of damages resulting from specific environmental disasters within the state.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
(f)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an agreement relating to acts, omissions, or injuries in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(g)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 340.85 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, immediately following Section 340.8, to read:340.85.(a)Notwithstanding Section 340.8, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 340.8, in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(e)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.(a)In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(b)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(c)This section shall not apply to any action against a public entity as defined in Section 811.2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution to achieve just and efficient results in civil litigation involving the unique circumstances of damages resulting from specific environmental disasters within the state.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
(f)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an agreement relating to the Porter Ranch area acts, omissions, or injuries in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 2.Section 340.85 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, immediately following Section 340.8, to read:340.85.(a)Notwithstanding Section 340.8 and consistent with subdivision (e), 340.8, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 340.8 and consistent with subdivision (e), 340.8, in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to the Porter Ranch area exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.(a)In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(b)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to the Porter Ranch area an environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Companys Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution to achieve just and efficient results in civil litigation involving the unique circumstances of damages resulting from specific environmental disasters within the state.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and shall not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. Any such payment shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(c)A temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
(f)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an agreement relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 2.Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:340.8.(a)In any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)In an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, abrogate, or change the law in effect on January 1, 2004, with respect to actions not based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance.
SEC. 2.Section 340.85 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, immediately following Section 340.8, to read:340.85.(a)Notwithstanding Section 340.8 and consistent with subdivision (e), in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 340.8 and consistent with subdivision (e), in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.(a)In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(b)(1)The provisions of this section shall only apply to an action relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
(2)As used in paragraph (1), the term Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and, including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution to achieve just and efficient results in civil litigation involving the unique circumstances of damages resulting from specific environmental disasters within the state.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and shall not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. Any such payment shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after January February 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
SEC. 2.Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:340.8.(a)In any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)In an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, abrogate, or change the law in effect on January 1, 2004, with respect to actions not based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance.
SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
(a)A partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not be conditioned upon the release by the polluter from liability to the recipient of for any claim unrelated related to the environmental disaster or all for any future claims, or both. claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims. Any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
(c)A final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall release the responsible polluter from liability to the recipient only for a claim related to the environmental disaster and shall not release any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or any claim unconnected to the environmental disaster. Any such payment shall not be conditioned upon the recipients agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
(d)Any agreement in violation of subdivision (a) or (c) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2017, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)For purposes of this section, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement is a payment of the recipients immediate out-of-pocket expenses, including, but not limited to, food, clothing, and shelter.
SEC. 2.Section 3484.5 is added to the Civil Code, to read:3484.5.(a)As used in this section, Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in Attachment B of the plan document.
(b)Any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016 shall have a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for that diminution in value. The diminution in value shall be calculated by determining the value of the real property on October 22, 2015, identifying similarly priced real property in neighboring communities on that date, then comparing the value of the owners real property on June 1, 2016, to the value of the properties in the neighboring communities that had been similarly priced, regardless of whether the owner has sold or refinanced the real property. The diminution in value shall be the value of the property in the Porter Ranch area on June 1, 2016, subtracted from an average value on June 1, 2016, of properties in neighboring communities that were priced similarly to the Porter Ranch area property as of October 22, 2015.
(c)This section shall apply only to actions filed on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:340.8.(a)In any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either three years from the date of injury, or three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)In an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, abrogate, or change the law in effect on January 1, 2004, with respect to actions not based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution in order to achieve just results while reducing court congestion as a result of the unique circumstances involving a major leak of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016.
A payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster or all future claims, or both.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 3484.5 is added to the Civil Code, to read:3484.5.(a)As used in this section, Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in attachment Attachment B of the plan document.
(b)Any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016 shall have a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for that diminution in value. The cause of action shall accrue when the owner first offers the property for sale or seeks refinancing of the property. The diminution in value shall be calculated by determining the value of the real property on October 22, 2015, identifying similarly priced real property in neighboring communities on that date, then comparing the value of the owners real property at the time the action accrues on June 1, 2016, to the value of the properties in the neighboring communities that had been similarly priced. priced, regardless of whether the owner has sold or refinanced the real property. The diminution in value shall be the value of the property in the Porter Ranch area on the date the action accrues June 1, 2016, subtracted from an average value on the date the action accrues June 1, 2016, of properties in neighboring communities that were priced similarly to the Porter Ranch area property as of October 22, 2015.
(c)This section shall apply only to actions filed on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:340.8.(a)In any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two three years from the date of injury, or two three years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(b)In an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiffs decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two three years from the date of the death of the plaintiffs decedent, or (2) two three years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)A civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance does not include an action subject to Section 340.2 or 340.5.
(2)Media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
(d)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit, abrogate, or change the law in effect on the effective date of this section January 1, 2004, with respect to actions not based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance.
SEC. 4.Section 1021.3 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:1021.3.In any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
SEC. 2.SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution in order to achieve just results while reducing court congestion as a result of the unique circumstances involving a major leak of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016.
(a)As used in this section, Porter Ranch area has the same meaning as defined in the document titled SS-25 Incident Aliso Canyon Gas Leak Odorous Emissions Mitigation Plan and Temporary Relocation Plan, dated December 15, 2015, included as Exhibit A in the stipulation and order, filed December 24, 2015, with the superior court of the County of Los Angeles in the People of the State of California v. Southern California Gas Company, Case No. BC602973, and including, but not limited to, the map titled SoCalGas Complaints and SCAQMD Air Sampling Locations located in attachment B of the plan document.
(b)Any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016 shall have a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for that diminution in value. The cause of action shall accrue when the owner first offers the property for sale or seeks refinancing of the property. The diminution in value shall be calculated by determining the value of the real property on October 22, 2015, identifying similarly priced real property in neighboring communities on that date, then comparing the value of the owners real property at the time the action accrues to the value of the properties in the neighboring communities that had been similarly priced. The diminution in value shall be the value of the property in the Porter Ranch area on the date the action accrues subtracted from an average value on the date the action accrues of properties in neighboring communities that were priced similarly to the Porter Ranch area property as of October 22, 2015.
(c)This section shall apply only to actions filed on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution in order to achieve just results while reducing court congestion as a result of the unique circumstances involving a major leak of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would facilitate the resolution of claims for property damage against Southern California Gas Company growing out of a major leakage of natural gas at its Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility that commenced in October 2015, in order to achieve just results while avoiding clogging the courts.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would facilitate the resolution of claims for property damage against Southern California Gas Company growing out of a major leakage of natural gas at its Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility that commenced in October 2015, in order to achieve just results while avoiding clogging the courts.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 54. Noes 23. Page 6443.). |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 25, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 28 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 23. Noes 13. Page 5313.). |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 30, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 29). |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (June 21). Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and E.Q. |
| Jun 6, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 53. Noes 18. Page 5240.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 26. Page 5167.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 53. Noes 18.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 26.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (June 2). |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 27. Page 5138.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 5076.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 27.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 31, 2016 | Reconsideration granted. (Page 4994.) |
| May 31, 2016 | Reconsideration granted. |
| May 9, 2016 | May 27-Motion to reconsider continued. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 30. Noes 32. Page 4692.). |
| May 5, 2016 | Motion to reconsider made by Assembly Member Gatto. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 30. Noes 32.). |
| May 3, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 28, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (April 26). |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 30, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 17, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | AB 2748 GATTO Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 23, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2748 Gatto By Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 29, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2016 | AB 2748 GATTO Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 5, 2016 | AB 2748 GATTO Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| Apr 26, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 2748
Author:(Gatto)
As Enrolled Ver:September 9, 2016
2/3 vote
ASSEMBLY: | 53-18 | (June 2, 2016) | SENATE: | 23-13 | (August 23, 2016) |
ASSEMBLY: | 54-23 | (August 30, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Proposes several remedies that will assist persons who are affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or the contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any current or future claim related to the environmental disaster or all future claims unrelated to the disaster, or both.
- Provides that a condition described in 1) above, in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
- Extends the statute of limitations for filing a civil action for injury, illness, or death caused by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance from two years to three years from the date of injury, illness, or death; or the date when the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury, illness, or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- Provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- Exempts any action against a public entity from all of the above provisions.
- Makes the provisions of 1) through 4) above, applicable only to those persons affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
The Senate amendments:
- Exempt any action against a public entity from all of the provisions of the bill.
- Make all sections of the bill applicable only to those persons who are affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: A rupture of a natural gas well in the Aliso Canyon complex owned by the Southern California Gas Company and adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch was detected in October of 2015. It poured toxic fumes into the surrounding neighborhoods for months until it was permanently sealed in mid-February of 2016. At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. According to the Los Angeles Times, county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has stated that before moving back, residents should know whether the methane plumes left any "residue" outside or in their homes and United States (U.S.) Senator Barbara Boxer has said the tests should be conducted by a private organization, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the South Coast Air Quality Management Disrict. (http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-porter-canyon-gas-leak-20160215-story.html) Researchers at University of Southern California (USC) intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents. Professor Ed Avol, professor of clinical medicine in the Department of Preventive Medicine of the Keck School of Medicine at USC, an expert on respiratory health and the public health impacts of air pollution, explained the components of the chemical soup emitted at Aliso Canyon and the complexity of determining the health effects of those chemicals on area residents:
A 2013 report released by the South Coast Air Quality Management District found that Exide's arsenic emissions endangered the health of 110,000 people who live near the plant. Over decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium and other toxic metals, according to state environmental records. It has also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid into the soil and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions.
Payments From a Polluter do not Release the Polluter From Liability for Future Claims. Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, either with new consideration (if made by oral agreement), or with or without new consideration (if made in written agreement). However, a general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist at the time of executing the release if those claims would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor if they had been known by the creditor. (Civil Code Section 1542.) Furthermore, California law prohibits, as "against the policy of the law," any "contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent." (Civil Code Section 1668.)
Consistent with Civil Code Sections 1542 and 1668, this bill proposes to prohibit an environmental polluter from requiring recipients of short-term reimbursements (such as payments for expenses such as housing or cleaning) to release a defendant polluter from current and future claims as a condition of accepting such payments. It provides that payments or reimbursements made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter and any of its related agents or entities to any recipients shall not be conditioned upon the recipient's release of any claims unrelated to the environmental disaster and all future claims and makes such settlements void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
Extended Statute of Limitations for Injuries and Deaths Caused by Toxic Chemicals. The collective term "statute of limitations" is commonly applied to a great number of acts that prescribe the periods beyond which actions may not be brought. (3 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2012) Actions, sec. 433, p. 432.) The general purpose is to prevent the assertion of "stale claims." (Ibid.) In other words, the statute of limitations "requires diligent prosecution of known claims thereby providing necessary finality and predictability in legal affairs, and ensuring that claims will be resolved while the evidence bearing on the issues is reasonably available and fresh." (Kaiser Foundation Hospitals v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 329, 336.)
This bill proposes to extend that time period from two years to three years for persons who have been affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
Attorneys' Fees. Unlike the systems of many other countries, the "American" rule in litigation provides that each party is responsible for paying his or her own attorney fees, regardless of who prevails. "Attorneys' fees authorized by contract, statute, or law are an item of allowable costs." (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2008) Judgment, sec. 150, p. 684.)
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. This provision would apply to persons affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
"This bill would prohibit the use of release clauses and limit the scope of waivers in settlements pertaining to the Exide Technologies facility and Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility.
"This bill could eliminate the incentive for defendants to settle legal disputes stemming from these two unrelated incidents, something that clearly is not in the public interest. Nothing has been shown to indicate that current law is insufficient to hold polluters accountable. I would point to the many direct enforcement actions and lawsuits that have been filed on behalf of the state and affected communities."
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0005085
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2748
Author:(Gatto)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 53-18 | (June 2, 2016) | SENATE: | 23-13 | (August 23, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Proposes several remedies that will assist persons who are affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or the contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any current or future claim related to the environmental disaster or all future claims unrelated to the disaster, or both.
- Provides that a condition described in 1) above, in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
- Extends the statute of limitations for filing a civil action for injury, illness, or death caused by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance from two years to three years from the date of injury, illness, or death; or the date when the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury, illness, or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- Provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- Exempts any action against a public entity from all of the above provisions.
- Makes the provisions of 1) through 4) above, applicable only to those persons affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
The Senate amendments:
- Exempt any action against a public entity from all of the provisions of the bill.
- Make all sections of the bill applicable only to those persons who are affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: A rupture of a natural gas well in the Aliso Canyon complex owned by the Southern California Gas Company and adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch was detected in October of 2015. It poured toxic fumes into the surrounding neighborhoods for months until it was permanently sealed in mid-February of 2016. At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. According to the Los Angeles Times, county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has stated that before moving back, residents should know whether the methane plumes left any "residue" outside or in their homes and United States (U.S.) Senator Barbara Boxer has said the tests should be conducted by a private organization, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the South Coast Air Quality Management Disrict. (http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-porter-canyon-gas-leak-20160215-story.html) Researchers at University of Southern California (USC) intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents. Professor Ed Avol, professor of clinical medicine in the Department of Preventive Medicine of the Keck School of Medicine at USC, an expert on respiratory health and the public health impacts of air pollution, explained the components of the chemical soup emitted at Aliso Canyon and the complexity of determining the health effects of those chemicals on area residents:
A 2013 report released by the South Coast Air Quality Management District found that Exide's arsenic emissions endangered the health of 110,000 people who live near the plant. Over decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium and other toxic metals, according to state environmental records. It has also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid into the soil and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions.
Payments From a Polluter do not Release the Polluter From Liability for Future Claims. Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, either with new consideration (if made by oral agreement), or with or without new consideration (if made in written agreement). However, a general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist at the time of executing the release if those claims would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor if they had been known by the creditor. (Civil Code Section 1542.) Furthermore, California law prohibits, as "against the policy of the law," any "contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent." (Civil Code Section 1668.)
Consistent with Civil Code Sections 1542 and 1668, this bill proposes to prohibit an environmental polluter from requiring recipients of short-term reimbursements (such as payments for expenses such as housing or cleaning) to release a defendant polluter from current and future claims as a condition of accepting such payments. It provides that payments or reimbursements made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter and any of its related agents or entities to any recipients shall not be conditioned upon the recipient's release of any claims unrelated to the environmental disaster and all future claims and makes such settlements void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
Extended Statute of Limitations for Injuries and Deaths Caused by Toxic Chemicals. The collective term "statute of limitations" is commonly applied to a great number of acts that prescribe the periods beyond which actions may not be brought. (3 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2012) Actions, sec. 433, p. 432.) The general purpose is to prevent the assertion of "stale claims." (Ibid.) In other words, the statute of limitations "requires diligent prosecution of known claims thereby providing necessary finality and predictability in legal affairs, and ensuring that claims will be resolved while the evidence bearing on the issues is reasonably available and fresh." (Kaiser Foundation Hospitals v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 329, 336.)
This bill proposes to extend that time period from two years to three years for persons who have been affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. Given the difficulty of pursuing civil actions based upon injuries caused by toxic substances, it is therefore reasonable to extend the statute of limitations for all plaintiffs who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals for persons affected by the pollution at these two sites, as provided by this bill.
Attorneys' Fees. Unlike the systems of many other countries, the "American" rule in litigation provides that each party is responsible for paying his or her own attorney fees, regardless of who prevails. "Attorneys' fees authorized by contract, statute, or law are an item of allowable costs." (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2008) Judgment, sec. 150, p. 684.)
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. This provision would apply to persons affected by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with either the environmental disaster that occurred at Southern California Gas Company's Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon. Given the similarity between a claim for property damaged arising from trespass on land under cultivation (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.9) and the private nuisance of toxic chemical pollution on property envisioned by this bill, allowing the collection of reasonable attorneys' fees in both situations seems reasonable.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004792
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2748
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-2, 6/21/16
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wieckowski
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/29/16
AYES: Wieckowski, Hill, Jackson, Leno, Pavley
NOES: Gaines, Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill enacts the following with regard to claims relating to environmental disasters that have occurred at Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon: (1) partial or interim payments or reimbursements, as defined, would not release any responsible polluter or agent from liability for a claim, and may not be made on condition of securing a release of liability, but may be credited against such liability; (2) temporary or final settlements made in connection with a claim would not release liability for any claim unknown at the time of settlement, or that occurs after settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster; (3) establishes a three year statute of limitation for civil actions for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, as specified; and (4) authorizes the court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/19/16 clarify that these provisions shall not apply to an action against a public entity, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/18/16 strike “Porter Ranch area” and instead apply the bill’s provisions to environmental disasters that have occurred at Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility.
Existing law:
- Declares anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, to be a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479)
- Requires an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another to be brought within two years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 335.1.)
- Requires an action for trespass upon or injury to real property to be brought within three years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 338.)
- States in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two years from the date of injury, or two years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(a).)
- States in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or (2) two years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(b).)
This bill:
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Specifies, for purposes of the above two provisions, that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
- States that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- States that a partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient:
- shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims;
- shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim; and
- may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
- States that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
- States that these provisions shall not apply to an action against a public entity, as specified.
Background
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.” (Matt McGrath, California Methane Leak Largest in US History, British Broadcasting Company (Feb. 26, 2016) <http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-35659947 [as of June 12, 2016].)
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. “Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years.” (Molly Peterson, Vernon Battery Recycler Exide Seeks a Second Chance with Toxic Regulators, Southern California Public Radio (June 3, 2013) <http://www.scpr.org/ news/2013/06/03/37535/vernon-battery-recycler-exide-seeks-a-second-chanc/ [as of June 12, 2016].) “For decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control has allowed the plant to operate without the full permit required by federal law. Instead, it has run on interim status, a temporary designation intended to give companies time to qualify for permits and meet legal standards for safe handling and disposal of toxic materials. (Jessica Garrison, et. al., Toxic Waste Watchdog Can Be Glacially Slow, Los Angeles Times (December 27, 2013) <http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-toxic-oversight-20131226-dto-htmlstory.html [as of June 12, 2016].) The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 110,000 people in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.” (Id.)
More recently, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.” (Tony Barboza, How a Battery Recycler Contaminated L.A. Area Homes for Decades, Los Angeles Times (December 21, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-exide-cleanup-story-so-far-20151121-story.html [as of June 12, 2016].)
This bill enacts specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill also restricts the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
Comments
The author writes:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) provides a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) would establish a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the potential danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (Garcia, 2016) would, among other things, require a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
SB 380 (Pavley, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016), among other things, continues a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) appropriates $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
SB 93 (De Leon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015) requires the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H20
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/16)
American Chemistry Council
American Insurance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16
AYES: Alejo, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Lopez, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Gallagher, Harper, Jones, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Steinorth, Wagner, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chang, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Grove, Holden, Kim, Linder, Nazarian
8/22/16 20:38:00
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2748
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-2, 6/21/16
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wieckowski
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/29/16
AYES: Wieckowski, Hill, Jackson, Leno, Pavley
NOES: Gaines, Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill enacts the following with regard to claims relating to environmental disasters that have occurred at Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon: (1) partial or interim payments or reimbursements, as defined, would not release any responsible polluter or agent from liability for a claim, and may not be made on condition of securing a release of liability, but may be credited against such liability; (2) temporary or final settlements made in connection with a claim would not release liability for any claim unknown at the time of settlement, or that occurs after settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster; (3) establishes a three year statute of limitation for civil actions for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, as specified; and (4) authorizes the court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/18/16 strike “Porter Ranch area” and instead apply the bill’s provisions to environmental disasters that have occurred at Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility.
Existing law:
- Declares anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, to be a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479)
- Requires an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another to be brought within two years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 335.1.)
- Requires an action for trespass upon or injury to real property to be brought within three years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 338.)
- States in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two years from the date of injury, or two years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(a).)
- States in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or (2) two years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(b).)
This bill:
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Specifies, for purposes of the above two provisions, that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
- States that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- States that a partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient:
- shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims;
- shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim; and
- may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
- States that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to Southern California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon gas storage facility or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
Background
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.” (Matt McGrath, California Methane Leak Largest in US History, British Broadcasting Company (Feb. 26, 2016) <http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-35659947 [as of June 12, 2016].)
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. “Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years.” (Molly Peterson, Vernon Battery Recycler Exide Seeks a Second Chance with Toxic Regulators, Southern California Public Radio (June 3, 2013) <http://www.scpr.org/ news/2013/06/03/37535/vernon-battery-recycler-exide-seeks-a-second-chanc/ [as of June 12, 2016].) “For decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control has allowed the plant to operate without the full permit required by federal law. Instead, it has run on interim status, a temporary designation intended to give companies time to qualify for permits and meet legal standards for safe handling and disposal of toxic materials. (Jessica Garrison, et. al., Toxic Waste Watchdog Can Be Glacially Slow, Los Angeles Times (December 27, 2013) <http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-toxic-oversight-20131226-dto-htmlstory.html [as of June 12, 2016].) The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 110,000 people in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.” (Id.)
More recently, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.” (Tony Barboza, How a Battery Recycler Contaminated L.A. Area Homes for Decades, Los Angeles Times (December 21, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-exide-cleanup-story-so-far-20151121-story.html [as of June 12, 2016].)
This bill enacts specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill also restricts the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
Comments
The author writes:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) provides a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) would establish a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the potential danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (Garcia, 2016) would, among other things, require a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
SB 380 (Pavley, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016), among other things, continues a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) appropriates $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
SB 93 (De Leon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015) requires the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H20
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/16)
American Chemistry Council
American Insurance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16
AYES: Alejo, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Lopez, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Gallagher, Harper, Jones, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Steinorth, Wagner, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chang, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Grove, Holden, Kim, Linder, Nazarian
8/19/16 18:44:30
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2748
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-2, 6/21/16
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wieckowski
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/29/16
AYES: Wieckowski, Hill, Jackson, Leno, Pavley
NOES: Gaines, Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill enacts the following with regard to claims relating to environmental disasters in the Porter Ranch area or surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon: (1) partial or interim payments or reimbursements, as defined, would not release any responsible polluter or agent from liability for a claim, and may not be made on condition of securing a release of liability, but may be credited against such liability; (2) temporary or final settlements made in connection with a claim would not release liability for any claim unknown at the time of settlement, or that occurs after settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster; (3) establishes a three year statute of limitation for civil actions for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, as specified; and (4) authorizes the court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter, as specified.
Existing law:
- Declares anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, to be a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479)
- Requires an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another to be brought within two years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 335.1.) Requires an action for trespass upon or injury to real property to be brought within three years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 338.)
- States in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two years from the date of injury, or two years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(a).)
- States in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or (2) two years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(b).)
This bill:
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Specifies, for purposes of the above two provisions, that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
- States that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- States that a partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient:
- shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims;
- shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim; and
- may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
- States that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
Background
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.” (Matt McGrath, California Methane Leak Largest in US History, British Broadcasting Company (Feb. 26, 2016) <http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-35659947 [as of June 12, 2016].)
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. “Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years.” (Molly Peterson, Vernon Battery Recycler Exide Seeks a Second Chance with Toxic Regulators, Southern California Public Radio (June 3, 2013) <http://www.scpr.org/ news/2013/06/03/37535/vernon-battery-recycler-exide-seeks-a-second-chanc/ [as of June 12, 2016].) “For decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control has allowed the plant to operate without the full permit required by federal law. Instead, it has run on interim status, a temporary designation intended to give companies time to qualify for permits and meet legal standards for safe handling and disposal of toxic materials. (Jessica Garrison, et. al., Toxic Waste Watchdog Can Be Glacially Slow, Los Angeles Times (December 27, 2013) <http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-toxic-oversight-20131226-dto-htmlstory.html [as of June 12, 2016].) The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 110,000 people in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.” (Id.)
More recently, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.” (Tony Barboza, How a Battery Recycler Contaminated L.A. Area Homes for Decades, Los Angeles Times (December 21, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-exide-cleanup-story-so-far-20151121-story.html [as of June 12, 2016].)
This bill enacts specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill also restricts the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
Comments
The author writes:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) provides a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) establishes a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the potential danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (Garcia, 2016), among other things, requires a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
SB 380 (Pavley, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016), among other things, continued a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) appropriated $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
SB 93 (De Leon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015) required the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H20
American Insurance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western Plastics Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16
AYES: Alejo, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Lopez, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Gallagher, Harper, Jones, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Steinorth, Wagner, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chang, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Grove, Holden, Kim, Linder, Nazarian
Prepared by: Tobias Halvarson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/4/16 9:30:06
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2748
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 4-2, 6/21/16
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wieckowski
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/29/16
AYES: Wieckowski, Hill, Jackson, Leno, Pavley
NOES: Gaines, Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill enacts the following with regard to claims relating to environmental disasters in the Porter Ranch area or surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- partial or interim payments or reimbursements, as defined, would not release any responsible polluter or agent from liability for a claim, and may not be made on condition of securing a release of liability, but may be credited against such liability;
- temporary or final settlements made in connection with a claim would not release liability for any claim unknown at the time of settlement, or that occurs after settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- establishes a three year statute of limitation for civil actions for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, as specified; and
- authorizes the court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter, as specified.
Existing law:
- Declares anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, to be a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479)
- Requires an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another to be brought within two years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 335.1.) Requires an action for trespass upon or injury to real property to be brought within three years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 338.)
- States in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two years from the date of injury, or two years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(a).)
- States in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or (2) two years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(b).)
This bill:
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Extends to three years the statute of limitation for an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
- Specifies, for purposes of the above two provisions, that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
- States that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- States that a partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient:
- shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims;
- shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim; and
- may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
- States that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
Background
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.” (Matt McGrath, California Methane Leak Largest in US History, British Broadcasting Company (Feb. 26, 2016) <http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-35659947 [as of June 12, 2016].)
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. “Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years.” (Molly Peterson, Vernon Battery Recycler Exide Seeks a Second Chance with Toxic Regulators, Southern California Public Radio (June 3, 2013) <http://www.scpr.org/ news/2013/06/03/37535/vernon-battery-recycler-exide-seeks-a-second-chanc/ [as of June 12, 2016].) “For decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control has allowed the plant to operate without the full permit required by federal law. Instead, it has run on interim status, a temporary designation intended to give companies time to qualify for permits and meet legal standards for safe handling and disposal of toxic materials. (Jessica Garrison, et. al., Toxic Waste Watchdog Can Be Glacially Slow, Los Angeles Times (December 27, 2013) <http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-toxic-oversight-20131226-dto-htmlstory.html [as of June 12, 2016].) The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 110,000 people in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.” (Id.)
More recently, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.” (Tony Barboza, How a Battery Recycler Contaminated L.A. Area Homes for Decades, Los Angeles Times (December 21, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-exide-cleanup-story-so-far-20151121-story.html [as of June 12, 2016].)
This bill enacts specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill also restricts the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
Comments
The author writes:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) provides a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) establishes a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the potential danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) requires the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (Garcia, 2016), among other things, requires a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
SB 380 (Pavley, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016), among other things, continued a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) appropriated $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
SB 93 (De Leon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015) required the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H20
American Insurance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western Plastics Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-18, 6/2/16
AYES: Alejo, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Lopez, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Gallagher, Harper, Jones, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Steinorth, Wagner, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chang, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Grove, Holden, Kim, Linder, Nazarian
8/3/16 18:21:33
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 2748
Author: | Gatto | ||
Version: | 6/2/2016 | Hearing Date: | 6/29/2016 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: Environmental disaster: release of claims: statute of limitations: attorneys’ fees.
ANALYSIS:
- Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, upon a new consideration, or in writing, with or without new consideration. A general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him or her must have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor.
- Under this bill, a partial or interim payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient, does not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims.
- This bill prohibits any such partial or interim payment or reimbursement from being conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim.
- This bill would allow such a payment or reimbursement to any recipient to be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
- Under this bill, a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, would release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and would not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
- The bill makes any agreement in violation of those prohibitions that is entered into on or after February 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Existing law establishes statutes of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos, as specified. For injury or illness, the statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of injury, or 2 years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, an injury, the physical cause of the injury, and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. For wrongful death, the statute of limitations is no later than either 2 years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or 2 years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- This bill, notwithstanding the above provision, establishes a statute of limitations of 3 years for specified civil actions for injury, illness, or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance other than asbestos.
- Under existing law, except as attorneys’ fees are specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is left to the agreement of the parties.
- This bill authorizes the courts, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- This bill would limit the application of its provisions to the Porter Ranch area, as defined, or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
Background
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.”
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years. For nearly three decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control allowed the plant to operate on interim permit status. The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.
More recently, as reported by the Los Angeles Times, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.”
This bill would enact specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill would also limit the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. The author states:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
- Good for some but not all? The author has outlined the devastation and havoc that the above environmental disasters have caused for the communities around the sites and is proposing the changes to law in this bill to protect these communities into the future. But if this is good public protection policy for the communities in these two areas, shouldn’t the Legislature provide the same protections for other communities that may be similarly affected by future environmental disasters? It is unclear why this bill is limited to Porter Ranch and Exide. The committee may wish to amend the bill to make it statewide policy.
Related/Prior Legislation
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) would provide a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) would establish a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Rules.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (C. Garcia, 2016) would, among other things, require a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
Prior Legislation:
SB 93 (de León, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015) requires the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
SB 380 (Pavley, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016) among other things, continues a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) appropriates $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Judiciary Committee on June 21, 2016. It passed out of committee with a vote of 4-2.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H2O
OPPOSITION:
American Chemistry Council
American Insurance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western Plastics Association
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
A coalition of environmental groups, writing in support, states:
[c]urrently, polluters that cause environmental disasters can condition any sort of aid on a waiver of liability for their harms. This limits the relief of those who have been wronged at their most desperate hour. When a person is forced out of their home and has nowhere to turn, it is unconscionable to condition an offering of shelter by a guilty polluter on a waiver of the right to sue. This bill does not, however, limit the ability for parties to reach a final settlement once a claim is actually brought to court and is consistent with a preference for settlements being reached where justice is best served.
Another issue is that final settlements can lead to a waiver of any future claims that arise from the disaster. Families should not surrender future claims for unforeseen harms that arise later when settling current claims. Settling for a harm to personal property today should not be contingent on waiving a future claim for health problems a family may discover later on. This is not reopening claims that have already been settled, but rather it is not allowing polluters to escape liability because citizens seek a settlement today, not contemplating the horrific problems that may arise later.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
A coalition of business groups, writing in opposition, states:
Release clauses are one of the primary incentives for defendants to settle disputes and avoid prolonged, expensive litigation. Indeed, California law and case law both recognize the ability for parties to contract to extinguish claims (See, e.g., Civil Code §1541). The Civil Code also states that a general release does not extend to claims which the person granting the release does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release (Civil Code §1542). Notwithstanding this provision, parties to a dispute are permitted to agree to waive the protections of Civil Code Section 1542, which must be accompanied by evidence that the releasing party intended to release unknown claims. (McCray v. Casual Comer, Inc. (C.D. Cal. 1992) 812 F.Supp. 1046). It is critical to preserve litigants’ ability to waive Section 1542 to maximize the potential to settle potential litigation. Indeed, when a business settles a claim with a party, the business should have certainty that the same party will not sue the business the day after a settlement is reached regarding a claim that could have been raised at the time of settlement. Yet, AB 2748 would essentially assure such an outcome, thereby eliminating the incentive to settle. . . . Parties should be permitted to enter into a mutually agreeable settlement to avoid prolonged litigation and thus promote the long-held California policy to encourage settlement over litigation; however, AB 2748 attempts to dictate contractual provisions and, in doing so, will guarantee an influx of litigation.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2748 (Author:Gatto)
Version: June 2, 2016
Hearing Date: June 21, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TH
SUBJECT
Environmental Disaster: Release of Claims: Statute of Limitations: Attorney Fees
DESCRIPTION
This bill would enact the following with regard to claims relating to environmental disasters in the Porter Ranch area or surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- partial or interim payments or reimbursements, as defined, would not release any responsible polluter or agent from liability for a claim, and may not be made on condition of securing a release of liability, but may be credited against such liability;
- temporary or final settlements made in connection with a claim would not release liability for any claim unknown at the time of settlement, or that occurs after settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- establishes a three year statute of limitation for civil actions for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, as specified; and
- authorizes the court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter, as specified.
BACKGROUND
Two sites of significant environmental contamination have featured repeatedly in the media this year: the release of natural gas from an underground storage facility in Porter Ranch, and the environmental impacts related to decades-long operation of a battery recycling facility in Vernon. The leak at Porter Ranch, first detected on October 23, 2015, came from one of 115 wells connected to the fifth largest underground natural gas storage facility in the United States. Southern California Gas Company, who owns the facility, made several attempts to stop the leak, but was unsuccessful in its efforts until February 18, 2016, by which time almost 100,000 tonnes of methane had escaped into the atmosphere. Concerns over the health impacts from the release led to the evacuation of 11,000 residents and a declaration of a state of emergency by Governor Brown. According to the BBC, “[a]t its peak, the flow doubled the rate of methane emissions from the entire Los Angeles basin,” and the “impact on the climate is said to be the equivalent of the annual emissions of half a million cars.” The scale of the leak makes it the largest in U.S. history, and, according to researchers, “had a far bigger warming effect than the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.” (Matt McGrath, California Methane Leak Largest in US History, British Broadcasting Company (Feb. 26, 2016) <http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-35659947> [as of June 12, 2016].)
The contamination resulting from smelter operations in the City of Vernon by Exide Technologies, by contrast, continued over a significantly longer period of time. “Exide melts down more than 22 million batteries each year, to recycle and reuse the lead in them. It’s run the Vernon facility since 2000, but one company or another has been doing the same work there for more than 90 years.” (Molly Peterson, Vernon Battery Recycler Exide Seeks a Second Chance with Toxic Regulators, Southern California Public Radio (June 3, 2013) <http://www.scpr.org/news/2013/06/03/37535/vernon-battery-recycler-exide-seeks-a-second-chanc/> [as of June 12, 2016].) “For decades, the Department of Toxic Substances Control has allowed the plant to operate without the full permit required by federal law. Instead, it has run on interim status, a temporary designation intended to give companies time to qualify for permits and meet legal standards for safe handling and disposal of toxic materials. (Jessica Garrison, et. al., Toxic Waste Watchdog Can Be Glacially Slow, Los Angeles Times (December 27, 2013) <http://www.latimes.com/local/la-me-toxic-oversight-20131226-dto-htmlstory.html> [as of June 12, 2016].) The South Coast Air Quality Management District has cited the plant at least 41 times since 2003, often for excessive lead emissions, and the District reported in March of 2013 that “arsenic emissions from the plant created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 110,000 people in an area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.” (Id.)
More recently, “[as] demands to close the plant mounted from community groups and elected officials, the company revealed in 2014 it was under federal criminal investigation,” and in March of 2015, “the company signed an agreement with the U.S. attorney’s office to close [the site] permanently.” Under the terms of that agreement, “Exide and its employees [will] avoid prosecution for years of environmental crimes, including illegal storage, disposal and shipment of hazardous waste, while agreeing to pay $50 million to demolish and clean the plant and surrounding communities, including $9 million set aside for removing lead from homes.” (Tony Barboza, How a Battery Recycler Contaminated L.A. Area Homes for Decades, Los Angeles Times (December 21, 2015) <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-exide-cleanup-story-so-far-20151121-story.html> [as of June 12, 2016].)
This bill would enact specified procedural changes that allow individuals harmed by these two environmental catastrophes to seek awards of attorney fees, as well as additional time to bring civil actions. This bill would also limit the ability of responsible polluters to limit their civil liability by offering litigants certain payments in advance of litigation or through settlement agreements.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law declares anything which is injurious to health, including, but not limited to, the illegal sale of controlled substances, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, or an obstruction to the free use of property, so as to interfere with the comfortable enjoyment of life or property, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal, or basin, or any public park, square, street, or highway, to be a nuisance. (Civ. Code Sec. 3479)
Existing law requires an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another to be brought within two years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 335.1.)
Existing law requires an action for trespass upon or injury to real property to be brought within three years. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 338.)
Existing law states in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of the action shall be no later than either two years from the date of injury, or two years after the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(a).)
Existing law states in an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance, the time for commencement of an action shall be no later than either (1) two years from the date of the death of the plaintiff’s decedent, or (2) two years from the first date on which the plaintiff is aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, the physical cause of the death and sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8(b).)
This bill would extend to three years the statute of limitation for an action for injury or illness based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
This bill would extend to three years the statute of limitation for an action for the wrongful death of any plaintiff’s decedent based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified.
This bill would specify, for purposes of the above two provisions, that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another.
This bill would state that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
This bill would state that a partial or interim payment or reimbursement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient:
- shall not release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims;
- shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim; and
- may be credited against the liability of the polluter, agent, or entity to the recipient for any current or future claim that is related to the environmental disaster.
This bill would state that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified, by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent, or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions, or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
Between the devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage field, the last year has shed light on the lack of sufficient legal remedies to help victims deal with the ramifications of environmental disasters. In the case of the Aliso Canyon gas well leak, according to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, is estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents, but given the fact that the long- term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak. Other types of environmental disasters likely bear similar threat to communities and therefore deserve the same relief.
AB 2748 endeavors to provide victims of environmental disasters better access to remedies available to them through our judicial system. This legislation has taken the lessons learned as a result of these most recent environmental crises in the state, to provide legal relief to not only those who have already suffered, but also future victims of serious, catastrophic pollution. . . . The bill offers three provisions to provide key protections to those who suffered from the environmental catastrophes in the Porter Ranch area and surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon:
- first, the proposed legislation will ensure that any temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster;
- second, the bill will extend the current statute of limitations for civil actions for injury or illness or wrongful death based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance to three years; and
- third, it will authorize the court to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant for residents who bring private actions.
- Extending statutes of limitation
Statutes of limitation are a fundamental element of California law. By limiting the time period within which a party can bring a cause of action against another, statutes of limitation provide finality to disputes that otherwise might never end. Without statutes of limitation, ancient wrongs committed while someone was young might become the subject of litigation years later in their old age. Statutes of limitation “are designed to promote justice by preventing surprises through the revival of claims that have been allowed to slumber until evidence has been lost, memories have faded, and witnesses have disappeared. The theory is that even if one has a just claim it is unjust not to put the adversary on notice to defend within the period of limitation and that the right to be free of stale claims in time comes to prevail over the right to prosecute them.” (Order of R. Telegraphers v. Railway Express Agency, Inc. (1944), 321 U.S. 342, 348-349.)
This bill would extend by one year the statute of limitation for an action alleging injury, illness, or wrongful death, based upon exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, as specified. Writing in support, the Consumer Attorneys of California state:
The goal of extending the statute of limitations is to give victims additional time to take legal action as they become increasingly aware of the cause of their adverse health effects. In some cases, proper diagnosis has also proven to be a challenge where victims may report a non-specific illness to their doctors but are unaware of the link. For example, in the early stages of the Porter Ranch disaster, victims would see their doctors and were sent home with instructions not to worry about their headaches, nosebleeds, nausea, and labored breathing. In less well publicized cases with exposure to other hazardous substances, the victims may not know for some time about a causal link. Giving these people more time to bring a claim for their harms keeps the courtroom doors open and the wrongdoers accountable.
The additional year provided by this bill to bring a claim against an environmental polluter would potentially allow some litigants more time to research and substantiate their claim before proceeding to suit. However, it should be noted that existing law already allows statutory tolling of claims beyond two years in cases where a plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of, (1) an injury, (2) the physical cause of the injury, and (3) sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, beyond the two year limitation period. (See Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 340.8.)
- Awarding attorney fees
This bill would authorize a court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in any action for private nuisance arising out of an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon for which an environmental polluter has been adjudged civilly liable. Generally in the United States, the “American rule” is that parties are to bear their own expenses in civil litigation.[1] In Alyeska Pipeline Co. v. Wilderness Society (1975) 421 U.S. 240, the United States Supreme Court held that it was the province of the legislative branch to craft exceptions to the “American rule,” and that courts were not free to shift such costs absent express legislative authorization. (Id. at 269-270.) In 1977, the Legislature enacted Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5, which appeared to be “in significant measure … an explicit reaction to the United States Supreme Court’s Alyeska decision.” (Woodland Hills Residents Assn., Inc. v. City Council (1979) 23 Cal.3d 917, 934.)
Section 1021.5 provides courts with authority to award attorney fees in actions to enforce important rights in the public interest that confer a significant benefit on a large class of persons, and was intended to encourage litigation deemed to be in the public interest by persons acting as a private attorney general. This doctrine rests on the recognition that privately initiated lawsuits are often essential to the effectuation of public policies embodied in constitutional or statutory provisions, and that without some mechanism authorizing the award of attorney fees, private actions to enforce such public policies would be financially impracticable. As explained recently by the California Supreme Court, “section 1021.5 [addresses] the problem of affordability of such lawsuits. Because public interest litigation often yields nonpecuniary and intangible or widely diffused benefits, and because such litigation is often complex and therefore expensive, litigants will be unable either to afford to pay an attorney hourly fee or to entice an attorney to accept the case with the prospect of contingency fees, thereby often making public interest litigation as a practical matter . . . infeasible.” (Conservatorship of Whitley (2010) 50 Cal.4th 1206, 1219 [internal citations and quotation marks omitted].) The standard set by Section 1021.5 is rigorous and is conditioned upon three requirements being met: (1) a significant benefit is provided to the general public; (2) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and (3) such fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any.
The Legislature has created other statutory exceptions to the “American rule” where awarding attorney fees in private litigation affecting a narrow class of individuals would nonetheless advance a policy preference of deterring future instances of certain unwanted behaviors. For example, the Fair Employment and Housing Act authorizes a court to award attorney fees to a prevailing plaintiff in specified circumstances involving unlawful employment discrimination. (See Gov. Code Sec. 12965.) This bill would similarly authorize attorney fee shifting in specified private nuisance cases based on individualized environmental harms. Like employment discrimination, authorizing this remedy against polluters may dissuade future actors from engaging in similar unwanted behavior. However, it should be noted that this bill fails to define with precision which “environmental disasters” relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon are subject to this fee shifting provision. The Committee may, therefore, wish to better identify the class of actions to which this provision applies in order to avoid additional litigation among parties over fee awards.
- Limiting settlement authority
This bill would expressly limit the ability of parties to release responsible polluters from liability for claims made in connection with an environmental disaster relating to the Porter Ranch area or contamination surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon in two principal ways. First, the bill would provide that partial or interim payments or reimbursements made with respect to an environmental disaster shall not: (1) release the polluter from liability to the recipient for any claim related to the environmental disaster or for any future claim by the recipient against the polluter, or for both current and future claims; or (2) be conditioned upon the recipient’s agreement to release the polluter from liability for any current or future claim. This bill would also prohibit a temporary or final settlement made in connection with an environmental disaster from releasing any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement, occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster. A coalition of environmental groups, writing in support, states:
[c]urrently, polluters that cause environmental disasters can condition any sort of aid on a waiver of liability for their harms. This limits the relief of those who have been wronged at their most desperate hour. When a person is forced out of their home and has nowhere to turn, it is unconscionable to condition an offering of shelter by a guilty polluter on a waiver of the right to sue. This bill does not, however, limit the ability for parties to reach a final settlement once a claim is actually brought to court and is consistent with a preference for settlements being reached where justice is best served.
Another issue is that final settlements can lead to a waiver of any future claims that arise from the disaster. Families should not surrender future claims for unforeseen harms that arise later when settling current claims. Settling for a harm to personal property today should not be contingent on waiving a future claim for health problems a family may discover later on. This is not reopening claims that have already been settled, but rather it is not allowing polluters to escape liability because citizens seek a settlement today, not contemplating the horrific problems that may arise later.
However, a coalition of business groups, writing in opposition, states:
Release clauses are one of the primary incentives for defendants to settle disputes and avoid prolonged, expensive litigation. Indeed, California law and case law both recognize the ability for parties to contract to extinguish claims (See, e.g., Civil Code § 1541). The Civil Code also states that a general release does not extend to claims which the person granting the release does not know or suspect to exist in his or her favor at the time of executing the release (Civil Code § 1542). Notwithstanding this provision, parties to a dispute are permitted to agree to waive the protections of Civil Code Section 1542, which must be accompanied by evidence that the releasing party intended to release unknown claims. (McCray v. Casual Comer, Inc. (C.D. Cal. 1992) 812 F.Supp. 1046). It is critical to preserve litigants’ ability to waive Section 1542 to maximize the potential to settle potential litigation. Indeed, when a business settles a claim with a party, the business should have certainty that the same party will not sue the business the day after a settlement is reached regarding a claim that could have been raised at the time of settlement. Yet, AB 2748 would essentially assure such an outcome, thereby eliminating the incentive to settle. . . . Parties should be permitted to enter into a mutually agreeable settlement to avoid prolonged litigation and thus promote the long-held California policy to encourage settlement over litigation; however, AB 2748 attempts to dictate contractual provisions and, in doing so, will guarantee an influx of litigation.
While existing law does provide that a general release will not extend to claims not known or suspected to exist at the time of executing the release, which, if known would materially affect a settlement, (Civ. Code Sec. 1542.), existing law does not necessarily protect individuals who knowingly release future or unknown claims in a state of duress of circumstance that the author intends to prohibit via this bill.
- Pending litigation
In the past, this Committee has raised concerns about bills that interfere with pending litigation. Any such interference could result in a direct financial windfall to a private party, prevent a court from deciding an action based upon the laws in place at the time the cause of action accrued, or create a situation where the legislative branch is used to circumvent the discretion and independence of the judicial branch.
The author has informed the Committee that several lawsuits are currently underway involving the gas release at Porter Ranch and contamination from the Exide Technologies facility in Vernon. However, it does not appear that this bill would impact suits that have already been commenced since its provisions do not appear to operate retroactively.
“Generally, statutes operate prospectively only.” (McClung v. Employment Dev. Dept. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 467, 475.)
[T]he presumption against retroactive legislation is deeply rooted in our jurisprudence, and embodies a legal doctrine centuries older than our Republic. Elementary considerations of fairness dictate that individuals should have an opportunity to know what the law is and to conform their conduct accordingly; settled expectations should not be lightly disrupted. For that reason, the principle that the legal effect of conduct should ordinarily be assessed under the law that existed when the conduct took place has timeless and universal appeal. (Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244, 265 (internal citations omitted).)
“A statute does not operate [retroactively] merely because it is applied in a case arising from conduct antedating the statute’s enactment, or upsets expectations based in prior law. Rather, the court must ask whether the new provision attaches new legal consequences to events completed before its enactment.” (Landgraf, 511 U.S. at 269-70 (internal citations omitted).) “This is not to say,” however, “that a statute may never apply retroactively.” (McClung, 34 Cal.4th at 475.) In California, “[a] statute’s retroactivity is, in the first instance, a policy determination for the Legislature and one to which courts defer absent some constitutional objection to retroactivity.” (Id., at 475.) Under California law, “a statute may be applied retroactively only if it contains express language of retroactivity or if other sources provide a clear and unavoidable implication that the Legislature intended retroactive application.” (Myers v. Philip Morris Companies, Inc. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 828, 844.)
The provisions in this bill, on their face, appear to impact prospective actions only, and the Committee has received no indication from the author that any of these provisions are meant to impact litigation currently underway.
Support: California Coastal Protection Network; California Labor Federation; California League of Conservation Voters; Clean Water Action; Coalition for Clean Air; Consumer Attorneys of California; Courage Campaign; Environmental Justice Coalition for Water; Environmental Working Group; Food and Water Watch; Natural Resources Defense Council; State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO; Sierra Club California; Trust for Public Land; Wholly H2O
Opposition: American Chemistry Council; California Chamber of Commerce; California Independent Petroleum Association; California League of Food Processors; California Manufacturers and Technology Association; California Metals Coalition; California Railroad Industry; Chemical Industry Council of California; Civil Justice Association of California; National Federation of Independent Business; Western Plant Health Association; Western Plastics Association; Western States Petroleum Association
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 887 (Pavley, 2016) would provide a framework for reforming oversight of natural gas storage facilities by, among other things, mandating minimum standards for gas storage well inspections, monitoring, and testing; training of personnel; leak monitoring, planning for emergency response; developing and incorporating best practices into regulations; and an assessment of risk to determine setback distances for gas storage wells. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources.
SB 1304 (Huff, 2016) authorizes the board of supervisors of a county to provide for reassessment of property destroyed or damaged by a major misfortune or calamity in an area or region subsequently proclaimed by the Governor to be in a state of emergency, and specifies that “damage” includes a diminution in the value of property as a result of environmental contamination. This bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
AB 1902 (Wilk, 2016) would establish a 3 year statute of limitations for commencing a civil action for injury, illness, or wrongful death based on exposure to methane, benzene, mercaptan, or any other hazardous material or toxic substance resulting from the Southern California Gas Company Aliso Canyon SS-25 gas leak, as specified. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1903 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Public Utilities Commission to authorize a study by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment of the long-term health impacts of the significant natural gas leak from the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage facility located in the County of Los Angeles that started on approximately October 23, 2015, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications.
AB 1904 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the Legislature, on or before January 1, 2019, that includes an assessment of the danger of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities in the state to public health and safety and the environment, and that identifies alternative odorants for possible use in natural gas storage facilities, as specified. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Rules.
AB 1905 (Wilk, 2016) would require the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency, on or before July 1, 2017, to commission an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities. This bill was held under submission by the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 2153 (Garcia, 2016) would, among other things, require a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries to remit to the State Board of Equalization a manufacturer battery fee of $1 for each lead-acid battery it sells for deposit into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, as specified, and would provide for certain credits against liability for a person who remits manufacturer battery fees if that person is held responsible by any court, regional board, agency, or any other authority for certain hazardous substance violations. This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
Prior Legislation:
SB 93 (De Leon, Ch. 9, Stats. 2015) requires the Director of Finance to transfer up to $176,600,000 as a loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account for the Department of Toxic Substances Control to use for activities related to the lead contamination in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon.
SB 380 (Pavley, Ch. 14, Stats. 2016), among other things, continues a moratorium on injection of natural gas at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility until specified criteria are met, requires the feasibility of the storage facility to be addressed and requires the California Public Utilities Commission, with input from others, to determine the amount of gas necessary at the facility for safety, regional reliability and to ensure just and reasonable rates.
AB 118 (Santiago, Ch. 10, Stats. 2016) appropriates $176,600,000 from the Toxic Substances Control Account in the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for activities related to the cleanup and investigation of lead-contaminated properties in the communities surrounding the Exide Technologies facility in the City of Vernon, including job training activities, and actions taken to pursue all available remedies against potentially responsible parties.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 53, Noes 18)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 3)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 30, Noes 32)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 3)
**************
Costs of litigation, in contrast, are generally recoverable by the prevailing party in civil litigation as a matter of right. Code of Civil Procedure Section 1032 states that, “except as otherwise expressly provided by statute, a prevailing party is entitled as a matter of right to recover costs in any action or proceeding.” ↑
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2748
Author:(Gatto) – As Amended Ver:June 1, 2016
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: TOXIC CHEMICALS: CLAIMS FOR PERONAL INJURY AND DAMAGE TO PROPERTY
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD STATE LAW PROHIBIT A PAYMENT OR REIMBURSEMENT MADE IN CONNECTION WITH ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTERS AT THE ALISO CANYON NATURAL GAS WELL OR THE EXIDE TECHNOLOGIES BATTERY PLANT BY THE RESPONSIBLE POLLUTER BEING CONDITIONED UPON RELEASE OF THAT POLLUTER FROM CURRENT AND FUTURE LIABILITY TO THE RECIPIENT OF THE PAYMENT OR REIMBURSEMENT AND MAKE SUCH A CONDITION IN A CONTRACT UNENFORCEABLE AS A MATTER OF PUBLIC POLICY?
- SHOULD THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR FILING A CIVIL ACTION BASED UPON INJURIES FROM TOXIC CHEMICALS AT THE ALISO CANYON NATURAL GAS WELL OR THE EXIDE TECHNOLOGIES BATTERY PLANT BE EXTENDED BY ONE YEAR SO THAT A CLAIM MUST BE FILED WITHIN THREE YEARS OF THE DATE OF INJURY OR DEATH, OR THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE WHEN THE INJURY OR DEATH IS KNOWN, OR REASONABLY SHOULD BE KNOWN TO HAVE BEEN CAUSED BY SUCH EXPOSURE?
- SHOULD STATE LAW SPECIFY THAT, IN ANY ACTION FOR PRIVATE NUISANCE AGAINST AN ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTER DEFENDANT ARISING OUT OF ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTERS AT THE ALISO CANYON NATURAL GAS WELL OR THE EXIDE TECHNOLOGIES BATTERY PLANT FOR WHICH THE DEFENDANT IS ADJUDGED TO BE CIVILLY LIABLE, THE COURT MAY AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS’ FEES TO THE PREVAILING PLAINTIFF?
SYNOPSIS
This bill is one of many to be introduced this legislative session in response to the rupture of the Aliso Canyon natural gas well adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch that was detected in October of 2015 and not sealed until mid-February of 2016 and the Exide Technologies facility located in the City of Vernon, about five miles southeast of downtown Los Angeles. Recognizing the inherent difficulty of pursuing legal action in response to environmental disasters like the one that occurred at Aliso Canyon and Exide, this bill, as proposed to be amended, provides three remedies that will assist persons living in Porter Ranch or near Exide who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals. First, it provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with one of those two environmental disasters shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster or all future claims, or both. Second, it extends the statute of limitations for a civil action for injuries and deaths caused by toxic chemicals at those two facilities. The statute of limitations on a civil action generally begins to run at the time when the injurious act is committed (“after the cause of action shall have accrued”), for injuries and deaths caused by toxic chemicals, the statute begins to run at either the time of the injury, the date when the plaintiff either becomes aware that his or her injury was caused by a chemical, or the date when the plaintiff reasonably should have become aware of such causation, whichever is later. This bill seeks to extend the statute of limitations for filing a civil action based upon injuries from toxic chemicals at these two facilities to three years of the date injury or date of discovery of the connection between the injury and the exposure to the toxin. Third, this bill provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of one of these two environmental disasters for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. As currently in print this bill is supported by a large coalition of labor, environmental, and consumer groups and opposed by a large coalition of industry and business groups. It is unknown how and whether the author’s proposed amends will affect the bill’s support and opposition.
SUMMARY: Proposes several remedies that will assist persons living near the Aliso Canyon natural gas well or the Exide Technologies Plant who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with the environmental disasters at the Aliso Canyon natural gas well or the Exide Technologies Plant by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent and/or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, and shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement or that occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster.
- Provides that a condition described in 1), above, in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
- Extends the statute of limitations for filing a civil action for injury, illness, or death caused by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance in connection with the environmental disasters at the Aliso Canyon natural gas well or the Exide Technologies Plant from two years to three years from the date of injury, illness, or death; or the date when the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury, illness, or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- Provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of the environmental disasters at the Aliso Canyon natural gas well or the Exide Technologies Plant for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
- Makes legislative findings and declares that a special law is necessary and that a general law cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution to achieve just and efficient results in civil litigation involving the unique circumstances of damages resulting from specific environmental disasters within the state.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another must be brought within two years. (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 335.1.)
- Provides that an action for trespass upon or injury to real property must be brought within three years. (CCP Section 338 (b).)
- Provides that when a trespass is of a permanent nature, the cause of action accrues when the trespass is first committed and that all damages, past and prospective, are recoverable in one action, and the entire cause of action accrues when the injury is suffered or the trespass committed. (Field-Escandon v. DeMann (1988) 204 Cal.App.3d 228, 233.)
- Specifies that all contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent, are against the policy of the law. (Civil Code Section 1668.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Aliso Canyon Gas Leak. A rupture of a natural gas well in the Aliso Canyon complex owned by the Southern California Gas Company and adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch was detected in October of 2015. It poured toxic fumes into the surrounding neighborhoods for months until it was permanently sealed in mid-February of 2016. According to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, are estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. (https://www.edf.org/climate/aliso-canyon-leak-sheds-light-national-problem.) In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. According to the Los Angeles Times, county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has stated that before moving back, residents should know whether the methane plumes left any "residue" outside or in their homes and United States Senator Barbara Boxer has said the tests should be conducted by a private organization, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the South Coast Air Quality Management Disrict. (http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-porter-canyon-gas-leak-20160215-story.html) Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents. Professor Ed Avol, professor of clinical medicine in the Department of Preventive Medicine of the Keck School of Medicine at USC, an expert on respiratory health and the public health impacts of air pollution, explained the components of the chemical soup emitted at Aliso Canyon and the complexity of determining the health effects of those chemicals on area residents:
Right now, we don’t think the methane exposure is as much an issue as some of the other contaminants and the potentially toxic chemicals that may come from byproduct reactions. . . . Methane makes about 90 percent of natural gas. Methane and other chemicals emitted in natural gas can react in the open-air environment and create other gases and chemicals, such as hydrogen sulfide. . . . Methyl mercaptans and other odor markers can break down to form other chemicals in the atmosphere. It is these mercaptans and their possible byproducts that may be a health concern. . . . [W]e wonder if there are long-term, low-level effects associated with extended exposure that are not being followed or being seriously considered. We do not believe these have been systematically addressed. . . . The issues we usually consider run the whole gamut from respiratory to cardiovascular to potentially neurological. Stress is also a concern. If there is a lot of stress, it triggers generic inflammation mechanisms in your body, which may lead to physical biological responses.
Regarding the number of people directly affected by the leak, Southern California Public Radio (KPCC) reported that nearly 8,000 households were relocated during the gas leak and as of mid-March, 2016, were still living in temporary housing. http://www.scpr.org/news/2016/03/18/58662/porter-ranch-judge-gives-displaced-one-more-week-o/
Meanwhile, numerous civil actions have been filed by Porter Ranch residents and property owners against the operator of the well, Southern California Gas Company, because of personal injuries and property damage alleged to have been caused by the gas leak. Given the fact that the long-term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak.
Exide Technologies Facility. Exide Technologies is located in the City of Vernon, about five miles southeast of downtown Los Angeles. The facility occupies 15 acres in a heavily industrial region with surrounding residential areas. Facility operations included recycling lead-bearing scrap materials obtained from spent lead-acid batteries. This facility operated under an interim status for over 30 years. During that time, inspectors documented more than 100 violations, including lead and acid leaks, an overflowing pond of toxic sludge, enormous cracks in the floor and hazardous levels of lead in the soil outside.
The Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) permanently suspended operations at Exide in 2014 and the facility closed in 2015 after DTSC notified Exide that its application for a new permit would be denied. The DTSC then ordered Exide to test and clean up residential properties and conducted its own testing.
The DTSC's analysis indicates that releases from the facility deposited lead dust across an area of southeast Los Angeles County, resulting in contamination extending 1.7 miles from the facility and impacting up to 10,000 properties, including residences, parks, and schools. The South Coast Air Quality Management District also cited the facility numerous times, and reported that arsenic emissions from Exide created an elevated risk of cancer for as many as 11,000 people in the area stretching from Boyle Heights to Huntington Park.
In August 2015, the Legislature and the Governor approved $7 million of emergency funding to test up to 1,500 residential properties, parks, schools, and daycare centers in the surrounding community; develop a comprehensive cleanup plan; and begin cleanup of the highest priority sites based on the degree of lead contamination and other exposure factors. To date, the DTSC has overseen the sampling of 714 properties and the cleanup of 208 properties. The DTSC has also established an Advisory Group of community leaders, local residents, business leaders, scientists, and elected officials to help guide closure and cleanup efforts.
Payments From a Polluter do not Release the Polluter From Liability for Future Claims. Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, either with new consideration (if made by oral agreement), or with or without new consideration (if made in written agreement). However, a general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist at the time of executing the release if those claims would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor if they had been known by the creditor. (Civil Code Section 1542.) Furthermore, California law prohibits, as “against the policy of the law,” any “contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent.” (Civil Code Section 1668.)
Consistent with Sections 1542 and 1668 of the Civil Code, this bill proposes to prohibit an environmental polluter from requiring recipients of short-term reimbursements (such as payments for expenses such as housing or cleaning) to release a defendant polluter from current and future claims as a condition of accepting such payments. It provides that a temporary or final settlement of any kind made in connection with the environmental disasters at the Aliso Canyon natural gas well or the Exide Technologies Plant by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter, to any claimant, shall release the responsible polluter, agent and/or entity from liability to the claimant only for acts, omissions or injuries that are believed by the claimant to have occurred prior to the date of the settlement, but shall not release any claim that is unknown to the claimant at the time of the settlement or that occurs subsequent to the settlement, or that is unrelated to the environmental disaster. It also makes settlements that violate this provision void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
According to the author:
AB 2748 will ensure that any payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter, will not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster.
This will protect victims of environmental disasters when they’re at their most vulnerable. The residents of Porter Ranch have experienced this firsthand, as many have claimed that So Cal Gas has conditioned relocation reimbursements upon the recipient’s waiver of all future claims against So Cal Gas. This is unconscionable. So Cal Gas’s payment/reimbursement of recipients’ relocation expenses and other out-of-pocket expenses do not come close to rectifying the true harm inflicted upon these residents.
Extended Statute of Limitations for Injuries and Deaths Caused by These two Disasters. The collective term “statute of limitations” is commonly applied to a great number of acts that prescribe the periods beyond which actions may not be brought. (3 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2012) Actions, sec. 433, p. 432.) The general purpose is to prevent the assertion of “stale claims.” (Ibid.) In other words, the statute of limitations “requires diligent prosecution of known claims thereby providing necessary finality and predictability in legal affairs, and ensuring that claims will be resolved while the evidence bearing on the issues is reasonably available and fresh.” (Kaiser Foundation Hospitals v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 329, 336.)
Whereas the statute of limitations on a civil action generally begins to run at the time when the injurious act is committed (“after the cause of action shall have accrued” (Section 312)), the statute begins to run, for injuries and deaths caused by environmental hazards, at either the time of the injury, or the date when the plaintiff either becomes aware of, or the date when the plaintiff reasonably should have become aware of an injury that is caused by the toxin, whichever is later. (Section 340.8 (a).)
SB 331 (Romero, Chap. 873, Stats. of 2013) codified the doctrine of delayed discovery set forth in Section 340.8, overturning a court decision, McKelvey v. Boeing North American, Inc. (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 151, that imputed knowledge of causation of injuries to plaintiffs who claimed to be injured by toxic chemicals because of extensive media coverage of the incident causing the release of chemicals and the toxic nature of the chemicals that were released. This Committee’s analysis included the following explanation for the need to overturn the holding of that case:
As proposed to be amended, the bill also provides that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a plaintiff on inquiry notice that the plaintiff's injury or decedent's death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another. This provision seeks to limit the recent case . . . in which the court imputed knowledge to the plaintiffs based on extensive media coverage, thereby placing them on inquiry notice sufficient to begin the statute of limitations running.
Supporters argue that the doctrine of delayed discovery is critical in hazardous substance exposure cases because in most cases injuries, illnesses, or deaths caused by exposure to hazardous substances are not immediately known. In fact, they argue, exposure to hazardous substances usually leads to chronic conditions that are often not known until long after the exposure began. The sponsor contends that the three-part test best protects the public in toxic tort litigation because it directly addresses the common scenario of facts gradually accumulating over time until they reach a sufficient level to put the toxic tort plaintiff on inquiry notice that the injury derived from a wrongful act.
Indeed, SB 331 stated the intent of the Legislature in enacting Section 340.8 was to overturn McKelvey and codify the holding of two other cases (that established the delayed discovery doctrine):
It is the intent of the Legislature to codify the rulings in Jolly v. Eli Lilly & Co. (1988) 44 Cal.3d 1103, Norgart v. Upjohn Co. (1999) 21 Cal.4th 383, and Clark v. Baxter HealthCare Corp. (2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 1048, in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as set forth in this measure, and to disapprove the ruling McKelvey v. Boeing North American, Inc. (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 151, to the extent the ruling in McKelvey is inconsistent with paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as set forth in this measure.
Thus, under the delayed discovery doctrine, the statute of limitations begins to run when “a person becomes aware of facts which would make a reasonably prudent person suspicious” that the defendant caused his or her injuries, in which case “he or she has a duty to investigate further and is charged with knowledge of matters which would have been revealed by such an investigation.” (Mangini v. Aerojet-General Corp. (1991) 230 Cal. App. 3d 1125, 1150.) “A patient who actually learns of the dangerous side effects” of a toxin to which she has been exposed “ignores her knowledge at her peril, but the law only requires an investigation when a plaintiff has a reason to investigate.” (Nelson v. Indevus Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1208.)
While it is known that the residents of Porter Ranch were exposed to toxic chemicals, it is unknown what the effect of such exposure, especially on a long-term basis, on residents will be. As Professor Avol, of the U.S.C. School of Medicine, points out (above), the “long-term, low-level effects associated with extended exposure” to the toxins released at Aliso Canyon have not previously been followed or even seriously considered. Future injuries could “run the whole gamut from respiratory to cardiovascular to potentially neurological” and may be exacerbated by stress. However, such difficulty in identifying injuries and their connection to certain toxins is not unique to the incident in Porter Ranch or Exide. It is typical of the type of injuries caused by exposure – both short and long-term – to toxic chemicals, regardless of how exposure occurs and what the toxic substance happens to be. At some point in the future, when a resident of Porter Ranch or the area around Exide learns the connection between an injury and the gas leak (or reasonably should make such a connection), the statute of limitations will begin to run for that particular plaintiff. Under current law, a plaintiff will have two years after discovering the connection between the leak and his or her injury to bring a cause of action against the defendants. As proposed to be amended, this bill proposes to extend that time period to three years. Given the difficulty of pursuing civil actions based upon injuries caused by toxic substances, it is therefore reasonable to extend the statute of limitations for the plaintiffs at Porter Ranch and Exide, as proposed by this bill.
Likewise, according to DTSC, the Exide facility deposited lead dust across an area of southeast Los Angeles County, resulting in contamination extending 1.7 miles from the facility and impacting up to 10,000 properties, including residences, parks, and schools.
As proposed to be amended, the extended statute of limitations in this bill will go into effect on February 1, 2017, applying to these two environmental disasters that are valid on that date and effectively extending the statute of limitations for those claims by one year.
Attorneys’ Fees. Unlike the systems of many other countries, the “American” rule in litigation provides that each party is responsible for paying his or her own attorney fees, regardless of who prevails. “Attorneys’ fees authorized by contract, statute, or law are an item of allowable costs.” (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2008) Judgment, sec. 150, p. 684.) Code of Civil Procedure Section 1033.5 (a)(10) provides that, “The following items are allowable as costs . . . (10) Attorney’s fees, when authorized by any of the following: (A) Contract; (B) Statute; (C) Law.” Therefore, except as specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is generally left to the agreement of the parties.
There are certain statutory exceptions that permit the prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney fees incurred during the litigation from the losing party. For example, reasonable attorneys’ fees are recoverable by the prevailing party in a civil action against a public entity where it is shown that the public entity acted in an “arbitrary and capricious manner;” (Government Code Section 800 (a)), to the prevailing party in an action brought under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (Government Code Section 12965 (b)); or to the prevailing party in an action for a violation of the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Civil Code Sections 51.5, 51.6, 52 (a)). Most similar to this bill, current law authorizes attorneys’ fees to be awarded in an action for property damage arising from a trespass on land under cultivation or used for raising livestock. (CCP Section 1021.9.)
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of the two environmental disasters – Aliso Canyon and Exide - for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. Given the similarity between a claim for property damaged arising from trespass on land under cultivation (CCP Section 1021.9) and the private nuisance of toxic chemical pollution on property envisioned by this bill, allowing the collection of reasonable attorneys’ fees in both situations seems reasonable.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumer Attorneys of California write the following in support of AB 2748:
The devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at South California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon storage field have resulted in massive community and environmental impacts in the last year alone. These disasters have also shed light on the lack of key environmental and consumer protections to help victims of these disasters who are now dealing with the consequences of these environmental disasters. AB 2748 would address this by establishing key consumers protections for not only these devastated communities, but for any future large scale environmental catastrophe that we encounter in the future.
People who live near any environmental disasters may be aware of the disaster but unaware of the adverse heath affects for years. Moreover, environmental pollution is often not known until years later. For example, residents in the Porter Ranch area or people who live close to the Exide battery plant may be aware of their illness and not make the link between their illness and the disaster until years later. AB 2748 would extend the current statute of limitations to three years. The goal of extending the statute of limitations is to give victims additional time to take legal action as they become increasingly aware of the cause of their adverse health effects. In some case, proper diagnosis has also proven to be a challenge where victims may report a non-specific illness to their doctors but are unaware of the link. For example, in the early stages of the Porter Ranch disaster, victims would see their doctors and were sent them home with instructions of not to worry about their headaches, nosebleeds, nausea, and labored breathing. In less well publicized cases with exposure to other hazardous substances, the victims may not know for some time about a causal link. Giving these people more time to bring a claim for their harms keeps the courtroom doors open and the wrongdoers accountable.
SIMILAR RECENT OR PENDING LEGISLATION. AB 118 (Santiago) provides additional funding from the Toxic Substances Control Account to test the remaining properties, schools, daycare centers, and parks in the 1.7 mile radius and remove contaminated soil at the properties that have the highest lead levels and greatest potential exposure to residents; provides resources to expand community engagement in the testing and cleanup process, enhance coordination and job training for community residents, and promote the use of local business and labor for contracting purposes; and appropriates $176.6 million from the Toxic Substances Control Account to be supported by a loan from the General Fund. AB 118 was recently signed into law. (Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016.)
AB 1902 (Wilk) extends the period of time for a plaintiff to file a civil action for injuries, illness or death caused by exposure to toxic hazards, but only if the plaintiff is exposed to certain toxic hazards between January 1, 2015 and December 31, 2016 while living within a 12-mile radius of the Aliso Canyon gas leak. AB 1906 died in this Committee on April 5, 2016.
AB 1903 (Wilk) directs the Public Utilities Commission and the State Department of Public Health to jointly study the long-term health impacts of the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak. AB 1903 was recently approved by the Assembly and is pending referral to a policy committee in the Senate.
AB 1904 (Wilk) directs the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the legislature that assesses the danger to public health and safety and the environment of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities and identify potential alternative odorants, effective immediately (as an urgency measure). AB 1904 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1905 (Wilk) directs the Natural Resources Agency to conduct an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities immediately (as an urgency measure). AB 1905 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 380 (Pavley) places a moratorium on natural gas injections at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility and establishes requirements to resume injections, including each well at the facility has been evaluated and those posing risk of failure have been repaired or plugged, to take effect immediately (as an urgency measure). SB 380 was recently signed into law. (Chapter 14, Statutes of 2016.)
SB 886 (Pavley) requires the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR) to immediately place a moratorium on natural gas injections at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility and prevent use of wells drilled pre-1954 and requires the PUC to determine the feasibility of eliminating (or minimizing) the use of the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, to take effect immediately (as an urgency measure). SB 886 was recently approved by the Senate and is pending referral to a policy committee in the Assembly.
SB 887 (Pavley) requires DOGGR to prescribe standards for natural gas storage wells and inspect all natural gas storage wells annually and prescribes other requirements. SB 887 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources Committee. SB 887 was recently approved by the Senate and is pending referral to a policy committee in the Assembly.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
SUPPORT
California Coastal Protection Network
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Clean Air
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Environmental Working Group
Food and Water Watch
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Trust for Public Land
Wholly H20
OPPOSITION
American Chemistry Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Railroad Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Civil Justice Association of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Plant Health Association
Western Plastics Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:
Author:(Gatto)
As Amended Ver:
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 7-3 | Mark Stone, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Ting | Wagner, Gallagher, Maienschein |
SUMMARY: Proposes several remedies that will assist persons (including but not limited to those living in Porter Ranch) who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any current or future claim related to the environmental disaster or all future claims unrelated to the disaster, or both.
- Provides that a condition described in 1) above, in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
- Extends the statute of limitations for filing a civil action for injury, illness, or death caused by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance from two years to three years from the date of injury, illness, or death; or the date when the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury, illness, or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- Provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another must be brought within two years. (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 335.1.)
- Provides that an action for trespass upon or injury to real property must be brought within three years. (CCP Section 338 (b).)
- Specifies that all contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent, are against the policy of the law. (Civil Code Section 1668.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: A rupture of a natural gas well in the Aliso Canyon complex owned by the Southern California Gas Company and adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch was detected in October of 2015. It poured toxic fumes into the surrounding neighborhoods for months until it was permanently sealed in mid-February of 2016. At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. According to the Los Angeles Times, county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has stated that before moving back, residents should know whether the methane plumes left any "residue" outside or in their homes and United States (U.S.) Senator Barbara Boxer has said the tests should be conducted by a private organization, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the South Coast Air Quality Management Disrict. (http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-porter-canyon-gas-leak-20160215-story.html) Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents. Professor Ed Avol, professor of clinical medicine in the Department of Preventive Medicine of the Keck School of Medicine at USC, an expert on respiratory health and the public health impacts of air pollution, explained the components of the chemical soup emitted at Aliso Canyon and the complexity of determining the health effects of those chemicals on area residents:
Right now, we don't think the methane exposure is as much an issue as some of the other contaminants and the potentially toxic chemicals that may come from byproduct reactions... [W]e wonder if there are long-term, low-level effects associated with extended exposure that are not being followed or being seriously considered. We do not believe these have been systematically addressed... The issues we usually consider run the whole gamut from respiratory to cardiovascular to potentially neurological. Stress is also a concern. If there is a lot of stress, it triggers generic inflammation mechanisms in your body, which may lead to physical biological responses.
Given the fact that the long-term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak.
Payments From a Polluter do not Release the Polluter From Liability for Future Claims. Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, either with new consideration (if made by oral agreement), or with or without new consideration (if made in written agreement). However, a general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist at the time of executing the release if those claims would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor if they had been known by the creditor. (Civil Code Section 1542.) Furthermore, California law prohibits, as "against the policy of the law," any "contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent." (Civil Code Section 1668.)
Consistent with Sections 1542 and 1668 of the Civil Code, this bill proposes to prohibit an environmental polluter from requiring recipients of short-term reimbursements (such as payments for expenses such as housing or cleaning) to release a defendant polluter from current and future claims as a condition of accepting such payments. It provides that payments or reimbursements made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter and any of its related agents or entities to any recipients shall not be conditioned upon the recipient's release of any claims unrelated to the environmental disaster and all future claims and makes such settlements void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
Extended Statute of Limitations for Injuries and Deaths Caused by Toxic Chemicals. The collective term "statute of limitations" is commonly applied to a great number of acts that prescribe the periods beyond which actions may not be brought. (3 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2012) Actions, sec. 433, p. 432.) The general purpose is to prevent the assertion of "stale claims." (Ibid.) In other words, the statute of limitations "requires diligent prosecution of known claims thereby providing necessary finality and predictability in legal affairs, and ensuring that claims will be resolved while the evidence bearing on the issues is reasonably available and fresh." (Kaiser Foundation Hospitals v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 329, 336.)
This bill proposes to extend that time period to three years. Given the difficulty of pursuing civil actions based upon injuries caused by toxic substances, it is therefore reasonable to extend the statute of limitations for all plaintiffs who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals, and not just for the plaintiffs at Porter Ranch, as proposed by this bill.
Attorneys’ Fees. Unlike the systems of many other countries, the "American" rule in litigation provides that each party is responsible for paying his or her own attorney fees, regardless of who prevails. "Attorneys' fees authorized by contract, statute, or law are an item of allowable costs." (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2008) Judgment, sec. 150, p. 684.)
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. Given the similarity between a claim for property damaged arising from trespass on land under cultivation (CCP Section 1021.9) and the private nuisance of toxic chemical pollution on property envisioned by this bill, allowing the collection of reasonable attorneys' fees in both situations seems reasonable.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002831
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2748
Author:(Gatto) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: TOXIC CHEMICALS: CLAIMS FOR PERONAL INJURY AND DAMAGE TO PROPERTY
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD STATE LAW PROHIBIT A PAYMENT OR REIMBURSEMENT MADE IN CONNECTION WITH AN ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER BY THE RESPONSIBLE POLLUTER BEING CONDITIONED UPON RELEASE OF THAT POLLUTER FROM CURRENT AND FUTURE LIABILITY TO THE RECIPIENT OF THE PAYMENT OR REIMBURSEMENT AND MAKE SUCH A CONDITION IN A CONTRACT UNENFORCEABLE AS A MATTER OF PUBLIC POLICY?
- SHOULD THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR FILING A CIVIL ACTION BASED UPON INJURIES FROM TOXIC CHEMICALS BE EXTENDED BY ONE YEAR SO THAT A CLAIM MUST BE FILED WITHIN THREE YEARS OF THE DATE OF INJURY OR DEATH, OR THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE WHEN THE INJURY OR DEATH IS KNOWN, OR REASONABLY SHOULD BE KNOWN TO HAVE BEEN CAUSED BY SUCH EXPOSURE?
- SHOULD STATE LAW SPECIFY THAT, IN ANY ACTION FOR PRIVATE NUISANCE AGAINST AN ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTER DEFENDANT ARISING OUT OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER FOR WHICH THE DEFENDANT IS ADJUDGED TO BE CIVILLY LIABLE, THE COURT MAY AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS’ FEES TO THE PREVAILING PLAINTIFF?
SYNOPSIS
This bill is one of many to be introduced this legislative session in response to the rupture of the Aliso Canyon natural gas well adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch that was detected in October of 2015 and not sealed until mid-February of 2016. Recognizing the inherent difficulty of pursuing legal action in response to environmental disasters like the one that occurred at Aliso Canyon, this bill proposes three remedies that will assist persons (including but not limited to those living in Porter Ranch) who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals. First, it provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster or all future claims, or both. The author has also agreed to clarifying amendments that provide that such a condition in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
Second, it extends the statute of limitations for a civil action for injuries and deaths caused by toxic chemicals. Whereas the statute of limitations on a civil action generally begins to run at the time when the injurious act is committed (“after the cause of action shall have accrued”), for injuries and deaths caused by toxic chemicals, the statute begins to run at either the time of the injury, the date when the plaintiff either becomes aware that his or her injury was caused by a chemical, or the date when the plaintiff reasonably should have become aware of such causation, whichever is later. This bill seeks to extend the statute of limitations for filing a civil action based upon injuries from toxic chemicals from two years to three years of the date injury or date of discovery of the connection between the injury and the exposure to the toxin. As currently drafted, the extended statute of limitations in this bill will go into effect on January 1, 2017, applying to all claims that are valid on that date and effectively extending the statute of limitations for those claims by one year. It does not revive time-lapsed claims, however. There may be some unfairness in the case of a claim that expires soon before the new statute of limitations goes into effect, if this bill should become law. Therefore, the analysis suggests that the author may wish to consider, should this bill move forward out of this Committee, whether the statute of limitations provision should be amended to clarify that some claims which would otherwise be time-barred when the extended statute of limitations takes effect should be revived and also subject to the extended statute of limitations.
Third, this bill provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
As currently in print, the bill also seeks to create a right of action against Southern California Gas Company for any person owning real property in the Porter Ranch area, as defined, on October 23, 2015, who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016; specifies that the cause of action will accrue when the claimant first offers the property for sale or seeks refinancing of the property; and specifies a mechanism for measuring the diminution in value. Because of a number of problematic aspects to the proposal that are briefly discussed in the analysis, the author has agreed that this provision should be deleted in its entirety from the bill. This amendment, as well as the author’s proposed clarifying amendments described above, is reflected in the summary and analysis below. This bill is supported by the Consumer Attorneys of California and has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Proposes several remedies that will assist persons (including but not limited to those living in Porter Ranch) who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a payment or reimbursement made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter or any agent or entity related to the responsible polluter to any recipient shall not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any current or future claim related to the environmental disaster or all future claims unrelated to the disaster, or both.
- Provides that a condition described in 1), above, in a settlement agreement is void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
- Extends the statute of limitations for filing a civil action for injury, illness, or death caused by exposure to a hazardous material or toxic substance from two years to three years from the date of injury, illness, or death; or the date when the plaintiff becomes aware of, or reasonably should have become aware of sufficient facts to put a reasonable person on inquiry notice that the injury, illness, or death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another, whichever occurs later.
- Provides that in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, the court, upon motion, may award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another must be brought within two years. (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 335.1.)
- Provides that an action for trespass upon or injury to real property must be brought within three years. (CCP Section 338 (b).)
- Provides that when a trespass is of a permanent nature, the cause of action accrues when the trespass is first committed and that all damages, past and prospective, are recoverable in one action, and the entire cause of action accrues when the injury is suffered or the trespass committed. (Field-Escandon v. DeMann (1988) 204 Cal.App.3d 228, 233.)
- Specifies that all contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent, are against the policy of the law. (Civil Code Section 1668.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: A rupture of a natural gas well in the Aliso Canyon complex owned by the Southern California Gas Company and adjacent to the upscale San Fernando Valley community of Porter Ranch was detected in October of 2015. It poured toxic fumes into the surrounding neighborhoods for months until it was permanently sealed in mid-February of 2016. According to the Environmental Defense Fund, 96,000 metric tons of methane, a powerful climate pollutant, are estimated to have been released into the atmosphere as a result of the leak, having the same 20-year climate impact as burning nearly one billion gallons of gasoline. (https://www.edf.org/climate/aliso-canyon-leak-sheds-light-national-problem.) In the months following detection of the leak, thousands of residents were relocated to temporary housing. Many reported health issues such as headaches, nausea, nosebleeds and dizziness.
At this point, it is difficult to know what the long-term effects of the nearly six-month leak on the local environment and population will be. According to the Los Angeles Times, county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich has stated that before moving back, residents should know whether the methane plumes left any "residue" outside or in their homes and United States Senator Barbara Boxer has said the tests should be conducted by a private organization, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the South Coast Air Quality Management Disrict. (http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-porter-canyon-gas-leak-20160215-story.html) Researchers at USC intend to study the long-term health effects of the gas leak on area residents. Professor Ed Avol, professor of clinical medicine in the Department of Preventive Medicine of the Keck School of Medicine at USC, an expert on respiratory health and the public health impacts of air pollution, explained the components of the chemical soup emitted at Aliso Canyon and the complexity of determining the health effects of those chemicals on area residents:
Right now, we don’t think the methane exposure is as much an issue as some of the other contaminants and the potentially toxic chemicals that may come from byproduct reactions. . . . Methane makes about 90 percent of natural gas. Methane and other chemicals emitted in natural gas can react in the open-air environment and create other gases and chemicals, such as hydrogen sulfide. . . . Methyl mercaptans and other odor markers can break down to form other chemicals in the atmosphere. It is these mercaptans and their possible byproducts that may be a health concern. . . . [W]e wonder if there are long-term, low-level effects associated with extended exposure that are not being followed or being seriously considered. We do not believe these have been systematically addressed. . . . The issues we usually consider run the whole gamut from respiratory to cardiovascular to potentially neurological. Stress is also a concern. If there is a lot of stress, it triggers generic inflammation mechanisms in your body, which may lead to physical biological responses.
Regarding the number of people directly affected by the leak, Southern California Public Radio (KPCC) reported that nearly 8,000 households were relocated during the gas leak and as of mid-March, 2016, were still living in temporary housing. http://www.scpr.org/news/2016/03/18/58662/porter-ranch-judge-gives-displaced-one-more-week-o/
Meanwhile, numerous civil actions have been filed by Porter Ranch residents and property owners against the operator of the well, Southern California Gas Company, because of personal injuries and property damage alleged to have been caused by the gas leak. Given the fact that the long-term effects of the chemical exposure are largely unknown, residents of Porter Ranch may not know for years how and if they have been injured by the gas leak.
Payments From a Polluter do not Release the Polluter From Liability for Future Claims. Existing law provides that an obligation is extinguished by a release given to the debtor by the creditor, either with new consideration (if made by oral agreement), or with or without new consideration (if made in written agreement). However, a general release does not extend to claims the creditor does not know or suspect to exist at the time of executing the release if those claims would have materially affected his or her settlement with the debtor if they had been known by the creditor. (Civil Code Section 1542.) Furthermore, California law prohibits, as “against the policy of the law,” any “contracts which have for their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt any one from responsibility for his own fraud, or willful injury to the person or property of another, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent.” (Civil Code Section 1668.)
Consistent with Sections 1542 and 1668 of the Civil Code, this bill proposes to prohibit an environmental polluter from requiring recipients of short-term reimbursements (such as payments for expenses such as housing or cleaning) to release a defendant polluter from current and future claims as a condition of accepting such payments. It provides that payments or reimbursements made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter and any of its related agents or entities to any recipients shall not be conditioned upon the recipient’s release of any claims unrelated to the environmental disaster and all future claims and makes such settlements void and unenforceable as a matter of public policy.
According to the author:
AB 2748 will ensure that any payment or reimbursement, made in connection with an environmental disaster by the responsible polluter, will not be conditioned upon the release by the recipient of any claim unrelated to the environmental disaster.
This will protect victims of environmental disasters when they’re at their most vulnerable. The residents of Porter Ranch have experienced this firsthand, as many have claimed that So Cal Gas has conditioned relocation reimbursements upon the recipient’s waiver of all future claims against So Cal Gas. This is unconscionable. So Cal Gas’s payment/reimbursement of recipients’ relocation expenses and other out-of-pocket expenses do not come close to rectifying the true harm inflicted upon these residents.
In order to clarify what type of payments are intended to be covered by this provision, as well as the fact that a condition which violates the bill’s prohibitions will be void and unenforceable, the author proposes a number of clarifying amendments to this section of the bill.
Extended Statute of Limitations for Injuries and Deaths Caused by Toxic Chemicals. The collective term “statute of limitations” is commonly applied to a great number of acts that prescribe the periods beyond which actions may not be brought. (3 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2012) Actions, sec. 433, p. 432.) The general purpose is to prevent the assertion of “stale claims.” (Ibid.) In other words, the statute of limitations “requires diligent prosecution of known claims thereby providing necessary finality and predictability in legal affairs, and ensuring that claims will be resolved while the evidence bearing on the issues is reasonably available and fresh.” (Kaiser Foundation Hospitals v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (1977) 19 Cal.3d 329, 336.)
Whereas the statute of limitations on a civil action generally begins to run at the time when the injurious act is committed (“after the cause of action shall have accrued” (Section 312)), the statute begins to run, for injuries and deaths caused by environmental hazards, at either the time of the injury, or the date when the plaintiff either becomes aware of, or the date when the plaintiff reasonably should have become aware of an injury that is caused by the toxin, whichever is later. (Section 340.8 (a).)
SB 331 (Romero, Chap. 873, Stats. of 2013) codified the doctrine of delayed discovery set forth in Section 340.8, overturning a court decision, McKelvey v. Boeing North American, Inc. (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 151, that imputed knowledge of causation of injuries to plaintiffs who claimed to be injured by toxic chemicals because of extensive media coverage of the incident causing the release of chemicals and the toxic nature of the chemicals that were released. This Committee’s analysis included the following explanation for the need to overturn the holding of that case:
As proposed to be amended, the bill also provides that media reports regarding the hazardous material or toxic substance contamination do not, in and of themselves, constitute sufficient facts to put a plaintiff on inquiry notice that the plaintiff's injury or decedent's death was caused or contributed to by the wrongful act of another. This provision seeks to limit the recent case . . . in which the court imputed knowledge to the plaintiffs based on extensive media coverage, thereby placing them on inquiry notice sufficient to begin the statute of limitations running.
Supporters argue that the doctrine of delayed discovery is critical in hazardous substance exposure cases because in most cases injuries, illnesses, or deaths caused by exposure to hazardous substances are not immediately known. In fact, they argue, exposure to hazardous substances usually leads to chronic conditions that are often not known until long after the exposure began. The sponsor contends that the three-part test best protects the public in toxic tort litigation because it directly addresses the common scenario of facts gradually accumulating over time until they reach a sufficient level to put the toxic tort plaintiff on inquiry notice that the injury derived from a wrongful act.
Indeed, SB 331 stated the intent of the Legislature in enacting Section 340.8 was to overturn McKelvey and codify the holding of two other cases (that established the delayed discovery doctrine):
It is the intent of the Legislature to codify the rulings in Jolly v. Eli Lilly & Co. (1988) 44 Cal.3d 1103, Norgart v. Upjohn Co. (1999) 21 Cal.4th 383, and Clark v. Baxter HealthCare Corp. (2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 1048, in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as set forth in this measure, and to disapprove the ruling McKelvey v. Boeing North American, Inc. (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 151, to the extent the ruling in McKelvey is inconsistent with paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 340.8 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as set forth in this measure.
Thus, under the delayed discovery doctrine, the statute of limitations begins to run when “a person becomes aware of facts which would make a reasonably prudent person suspicious” that the defendant caused his or her injuries, in which case “he or she has a duty to investigate further and is charged with knowledge of matters which would have been revealed by such an investigation.” (Mangini v. Aerojet-General Corp. (1991) 230 Cal. App. 3d 1125, 1150.) “A patient who actually learns of the dangerous side effects” of a toxin to which she has been exposed “ignores her knowledge at her peril, but the law only requires an investigation when a plaintiff has a reason to investigate.” (Nelson v. Indevus Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1208.)
While it is known that the residents of Porter Ranch were exposed to toxic chemicals, it is unknown what the effect of such exposure, especially on a long-term basis, on residents will be. As Professor Avol, of the U.S.C. School of Medicine, points out (above), the “long-term, low-level effects associated with extended exposure” to the toxins released at Aliso Canyon have not previously been followed or even seriously considered. Future injuries could “run the whole gamut from respiratory to cardiovascular to potentially neurological” and may be exacerbated by stress. However, such difficulty in identifying injuries and their connection to certain toxins is not unique to the incident in Porter Ranch. It is typical of the type of injuries caused by exposure – both short and long-term – to toxic chemicals, regardless of how exposure occurs and what the toxic substance happens to be. At some point in the future, when a resident of Porter Ranch learns the connection between an injury and the gas leak (or reasonably should make such a connection), the statute of limitations will begin to run for that particular plaintiff. Under current law, a plaintiff will have two years after discovering the connection between the leak and his or her injury to bring a cause of action against the defendants. As proposed to be amended, this bill proposes to extend that time period to three years. Given the difficulty of pursuing civil actions based upon injuries caused by toxic substances, it is therefore reasonable to extend the statute of limitations for all plaintiffs who are injured or killed by toxic chemicals, and not just for the plaintiffs at Porter Ranch, as proposed by this bill.
As currently drafted, the extended statute of limitations in this bill will go into effect on January 1, 2017, applying to all claims that are valid on that date and effectively extending the statute of limitations for those claims by one year. It does not revive time-lapsed claims, however. There may be some unfairness in the case of a claim that expires soon before the new statute of limitations goes into effect, if this bill should become law. For example, one plaintiff’s claim may expire on December 31, 2016 and be time-barred, whereas another plaintiff’s claim that would otherwise expire the next day, on January 1, 2017, would be extended by an additional year. The author may wish to consider, should this bill move forward out of this Committee, whether the statute of limitations provision should be amended to clarify that some claims which would otherwise be time-barred when the extended statute of limitations takes effect should be revived and also subject to the extended statute of limitations.
Attorneys’ Fees. Unlike the systems of many other countries, the “American” rule in litigation provides that each party is responsible for paying his or her own attorney fees, regardless of who prevails. “Attorneys’ fees authorized by contract, statute, or law are an item of allowable costs.” (7 Witkin, Cal. Procedure (5th ed. 2008) Judgment, sec. 150, p. 684.) Code of Civil Procedure Section 1033.5 (a)(10) provides that, “The following items are allowable as costs . . . (10) Attorney’s fees, when authorized by any of the following: (A) Contract; (B) Statute; (C) Law.” Therefore, except as specifically provided for by statute, the measure and mode of compensation of attorneys is generally left to the agreement of the parties.
There are certain statutory exceptions that permit the prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney fees incurred during the litigation from the losing party. For example, reasonable attorneys’ fees are recoverable by the prevailing party in a civil action against a public entity where it is shown that the public entity acted in an “arbitrary and capricious manner;” (Government Code Section 800 (a)), to the prevailing party in an action brought under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (Government Code Section 12965 (b)); or to the prevailing party in an action for a violation of the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Civil Code Sections 51.5, 51.6, 52 (a)). Most similar to this bill, current law authorizes attorneys’ fees to be awarded in an action for property damage arising from a trespass on land under cultivation or used for raising livestock. (CCP Section 1021.9.)
This bill would authorize the court, in any action for private nuisance against an environmental polluter defendant arising out of an environmental disaster for which the defendant has been adjudged civilly liable, upon motion, to award reasonable attorneys’ fees to a prevailing plaintiff against the defendant. Given the similarity between a claim for property damaged arising from trespass on land under cultivation (CCP Section 1021.9) and the private nuisance of toxic chemical pollution on property envisioned by this bill, allowing the collection of reasonable attorneys’ fees in both situations seems reasonable.
Author’s Proposed Amendments to Remove Section Two, a Cause of Action Against Southern California Gas Company for Diminished Value. This provision raises a number of concerns.
First, it may constitute an unconstitutional “Bill of Attainder.” The Constitution instructs Congress that "No Bill of Attainder … shall be passed." (U.S. Const. art. I, § 9, cl. 3.) A bill of attainder is "a law that legislatively determines guilt and inflicts punishment upon an identifiable individual without provision of the protections of a judicial trial." (Nixon v. Adm'r of Gen. Servs.(1977) 433 U.S. 425, 468.) The U.S. Supreme Court has applied a functional test of the existence of punishment, analyzing whether the law under challenge, viewed in terms of the type and severity of burdens imposed, reasonably can be said to further nonpunitive legislative purposes. (Nixon v. Adm'r of General Servs. (1977) 433 U.S. 425, 475-476.) “Where such legitimate legislative purposes do not appear, it is reasonable to conclude that punishment of individuals disadvantaged by the enactment was the purpose of the decisionmakers.” (Ibid.)
AB 2748 establishes that any Porter Ranch resident “who suffers a diminution in value of that real property resulting from the leakage of natural gas from the Aliso Canyon Gas Storage Facility during 2015 and 2016 shall have a right of action against Southern California Gas Company.” The bill basically declares that So Cal Gas is civilly liable to anyone whose property lost value, without the plaintiff needing to prove causation and other elements of a claim. Therefore, this provision at the very least has some elements of a Bill of Attainder and therefore raises some constitutional concerns.
Second, it may be a “Special Law,” that is prohibited by the California State Constitution. The California Constitution prohibits the Legislature from adopting “special laws” when general laws are potentially applicable. Porter Ranch residents, like all persons in the state whose property and health are affected by toxic chemicals, have potential causes of action and potential claims for diminished property value. If the Legislature is going to establish a right to collect damages against a polluter based upon a diminution of property value against a polluter, such change in the law should apply to all similarly situated persons, not just Porter Ranch residents. Otherwise, a provision that provides special remedies to one group of plaintiffs could be considered an unconstitutional “special law.”
Third, it seeks to award damages for diminution of value for a nuisance that may be abatable when California law only allows damages for diminution in value to be recovered for permanent (not temporary or continuing) nuisances. (Gehr v. Baker Hughes Oil Field Operations, Inc. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 660, 666-668.) Recovery is limited, in the case of a continuing nuisance, to actual injury suffered prior to commencement of each action. One reason a plaintiff in a continuing nuisance case may not recover diminution in value damages is that the “[p]laintiff would obtain a double recovery if she could recover for the depreciation in value and also have the cause of that depreciation removed.” (Spaulding v. Cameron (1952) 38 Cal.2d 265, 269.) Another reason is that “if the defendant is willing and able to abate the nuisance, it is unfair to award damages on the theory that it will continue.” (Id. at p. 268.)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumer Attorneys of California write the following in support of AB 2748:
The devastating Exide battery plant lead contamination disaster in Boyle Heights and the natural gas leak at South California Gas Company’s Aliso Canyon storage field have resulted in massive community and environmental impacts in the last year alone. These disasters have also shed light on the lack of key environmental and consumer protections to help victims of these disasters who are now dealing with the consequences of these environmental disasters. AB 2748 would address this by establishing key consumers protections for not only these devastated communities, but for any future large scale environmental catastrophe that we encounter in the future.
People who live near any environmental disasters may be aware of the disaster but unaware of the adverse heath affects for years. Moreover, environmental pollution is often not known until years later. For example, residents in the Porter Ranch area or people who live close to the Exide battery plant may be aware of their illness and not make the link between their illness and the disaster until years later. AB 2748 would extend the current statute of limitations to three years. The goal of extending the statute of limitations is to give victims additional time to take legal action as they become increasingly aware of the cause of their adverse health effects. In some case, proper diagnosis has also proven to be a challenge where victims may report a non-specific illness to their doctors but are unaware of the link. For example, in the early stages of the Porter Ranch disaster, victims would see their doctors and were sent them home with instructions of not to worry about their headaches, nosebleeds, nausea, and labored breathing. In less well publicized cases with exposure to other hazardous substances, the victims may not know for some time about a causal link. Giving these people more time to bring a claim for their harms keeps the courtroom doors open and the wrongdoers accountable.
We also support the inclusion of reasonable attorney’s fees for consumers who bring private nuisance actions. Most consumer protection laws contain such a clause. Plaintiffs suing polluters who cause private nuisance should not have to bear the costs of attorney’s fees to assert their rights. Because this provision requires that the defendant be adjudged as liable for private nuisance first, it is fair to require the defendant to also carry liability to plaintiff for plaintiffs’ reasonable attorneys’ fees.
Finally, we also applaud the bill’s no waiver or rights provision. Victims of the Porter Ranch gas leak have claimed that So Cal Gas and its subcontractors (relocation companies) have conditioned reimbursements upon the recipient’s waiver of all future claims against So Cal Gas. By no measure does So Cal Gas’s payment/reimbursement of recipients’ relocation expenses and other out-of-pocket expenses rectify the true harm here. Requiring such a waiver allows So Cal Gas to disclaim any liability for plaintiffs’ new or exacerbated medical conditions.
SIMILAR PENDING LEGISLATION. AB 1902 (Wilk) extends the period of time for a plaintiff to file a civil action for injuries, illness or death caused by exposure to toxic hazards, but only if the plaintiff is exposed to certain toxic hazards between January 1, 2015 and December 31, 2016 while living within a 12-mile radius of the Aliso Canyon gas leak. AB 1906 died in this Committee (with reconsideration granted) on April 5, 2016.
AB 1903 (Wilk) directs the Public Utilities Commission and the State Department of Public Health to jointly study the long-term health impacts of the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak. Pending in the Assembly Utilities and Commerce Committee.
AB 1904 (Wilk) directs the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment to submit a report to the legislature that assesses the danger to public health and safety and the environment of odorants currently used in natural gas storage facilities and identify potential alternative odorants, effective immediately (as an urgency measure). AB 1904 is pending in the Assembly ES&TM Committee.
AB 1905 (Wilk) directs the Natural Resources Agency to conduct an independent scientific study on natural gas injection and storage practices and facilities immediately (as an urgency measure). AB 1905 is pending in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 380 (Pavley) places a moratorium on natural gas injections at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility and establishes requirements to resume injections, including each well at the facility has been evaluated and those posing risk of failure have been repaired or plugged, to take effect immediately (as an urgency measure). SB 380 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 886 (Pavley) requires the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR) to immediately place a moratorium on natural gas injections at the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility and prevent use of wells drilled pre-1954 and requires the PUC to determine the feasibility of eliminating (or minimizing) the use of the Aliso Canyon gas storage facility, to take effect immediately (as an urgency measure). SB 886 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources Committee.
SB 887 (Pavley) requires DOGGR to prescribe standards for natural gas storage wells and inspect all natural gas storage wells annually and prescribes other requirements. SB 887 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Attorneys of California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Governmental Organization
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):