AB 1173: Water equipment: backflow prevention devices testing: certification.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-03-26
Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health, including, but not limited to, conducting research, studies, and demonstration programs relating to the provision of a dependable, safe supply of drinking water, enforcing the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, adoption of enforcement regulations, and conducting studies and investigations to assess the quality of water in domestic water supplies.
Existing law requires any person who owns a public water system to ensure that the system does certain things, including, but not limited to, that it will not be subject to backflow under normal operating conditions. Existing law, to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. A violation of these provisions, or an order by a local health officer pursuant to these provisions, is a misdemeanor.
This bill would require, if a local health officer does not maintain a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device be performed by a person who has received a California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices from one of specified entities or a similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the state board or the local health officer. Because a violation of these requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law authorizes local health officials to maintain programs, in cooperation with water suppliers, to protect against backflow through service connections into the public water supply system, and, with the consent of the water supplier, to collect fees from the water supplier to offset the costs of implementing these programs. Existing law requires that these programs be conducted in accordance with backflow protection regulations adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change by updating a reference from the State Department of Public Health to the State Water Resources Control Board.
Existing law authorizes local health officials to maintain programs, in cooperation with water suppliers, to protect against backflow through service connections into the public water supply system, and, with the consent of the water supplier, to collect fees from the water supplier to offset the costs of implementing these programs. Existing law requires that these programs be conducted in accordance with backflow protection regulations adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change by updating a reference from the State Department of Public Health to the State Water Resources Control Board.
(a)To assure ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, local health officers may maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. The local health officer may suspend, revoke, or refuse to renew the certificate of a tester, if, after a hearing before the local health officer or his or her designee, the local health officer or his or her designee finds that the tester has practiced fraud or deception or has displayed gross negligence or misconduct in the performance of his or her duties as a certified backflow prevention device tester. The local health officer may collect fees from certified testers to offset the cost of the certification program provided pursuant to this section. The certification standards shall be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the department. State Water Resources Control Board.
(b)If a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program pursuant to subdivision (a), testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device shall be performed by a person who has received a California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices by the California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA), American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International, American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA), or other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board or the local health officer.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Section 116805 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:116805.(a) Local health officers may maintain programs, in cooperation with water suppliers, to protect against backflow through service connections into the public water supply, and, with the consent of the water supplier, may collect fees from the water supplier to offset the costs of implementing these programs.
(b) The fees authorized under this section and under Section 116800 shall be limited to the costs of administering these programs. At the discretion of the water supplier, the fees collected from the water supplier by the local health officer may be passed through to water users.
(c) Programs authorized under this section and Section 116800 shall be conducted in accordance with backflow protection regulations adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board.
(d) Nothing in this article shall prevent a water supplier from directly charging those water users required to install backflow prevention devices for the costs of the programs authorized in this section and Section 116800.
(a) Local health officers may maintain programs, in cooperation with water suppliers, to protect against backflow through service connections into the public water supply, and, with the consent of the water supplier, may collect fees from the water supplier to offset the costs of implementing these programs.
(b) The fees authorized under this section and under Section 116800 shall be limited to the costs of administering these programs. At the discretion of the water supplier, the fees collected from the water supplier by the local health officer may be passed through to water users.
(c) Programs authorized under this section and Section 116800 shall be conducted in accordance with backflow protection regulations adopted by the department State Water Resources Control Board.
(d) Nothing in this article shall prevent a water supplier from directly charging those water users required to install backflow prevention devices for the costs of the programs authorized in this section and Section 116800.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 14, 2016 | In committee: Set, final hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 25, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 14, 2015 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 29, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 11, 2015 | Referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| May 28, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 28, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 55. Noes 22. Page 1623.) |
| May 28, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 55. Noes 22.) |
| May 14, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 3.) (May 13). |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 28, 2015 | AB 1173 WILLIAMS Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1173
Author: | Williams | ||
Version: | 3/26/2015 | Hearing Date: | 6/15/2016 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: Water equipment: backflow prevention devices testing: certification.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health, including, but not limited to, conducting research, studies, and demonstration programs relating to the provision of a dependable, safe supply of drinking water, enforcing the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, adoption of enforcement regulations, and conducting studies and investigations to assess the quality of water in domestic water supplies.
- Requires any person who owns a public water system to ensure that the system does certain things, including, but not limited to, that it will not be subject to backflow under normal operating conditions.
- Authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for the certification of backflow prevention device testers in order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance.
- Requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or health agency.
- Requires that certification standards be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the Department of Public Health.
This bill: states, that if a local health officer does not maintain a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, that the local water system must hire a person who has received a California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices from any one of the following: the California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA), American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International, American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA), or by other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the SWRCB or the local health officer to conduct the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device.
Background
- What is Backflow? Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system.
Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
- Backflow prevention? Backflow preventers are mechanical assemblies used to prevent contaminated fluids from entering the water supply system. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), a wide choice of devices exists that can be used to prevent backflow from adding contaminated fluids or gases into a potable water supply system. These include air gaps, barometric loops, vacuum breakers—both atmospheric and pressure type, double check with intermediate atmospheric vent, double check valve assemblies, and reduced pressure principle devices. US EPA reports that, generally, the selection of the proper device is based upon the degree of hazard posed by the cross-connection. Additional considerations are based upon piping size, location, and the potential need to periodically test the devices to ensure proper operation.
- Certification of backflow prevention device testers? Because the only way a water system or the local health officer becomes aware of a broken or failed backflow system is when an incident has occurred resulting in the contamination of the water supply leading to a public health incident or the risk of a public health incident, the proper testing of backflow prevention assemblies is crucial to the prevention of backflow and is a cornerstone of a cross-connection control program. In order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, statute authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. Additionally, regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency.
Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water systems are responsible for hiring testers that have "demonstrated their competency."
Should a backflow prevention device not be properly tested or maintained and result in an incident, the water system is responsible for the damage caused by that failure.
- What happens when a backflow prevention fails? If a backflow preventer fails potable water supplies are compromised and contaminants enter the water. Contaminants that may enter the potable water include, but are not limited to, untreated river, sea or lake water, pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, propane gas, boiler water with chemicals, anti-freeze, numerous chemicals, water from car wash establishments, dyes, sewage, worms, heavy metals such as arsenic, petrochemicals, water from flush toilets or other drains.
The presence of contaminants from backflow in water can lead to adverse health effects, including both acute and long term effects like gastrointestinal illness, reproductive problems, cancer and neurological disorders which can lead to hospitalization or death.
While there is currently no federal reporting requirement for backflow cases, US EPA published a white paper in 2001 that gives several examples of backflow and risks associated with backflow incidents:
In 1982 a Colorado high school’s drinking water was contaminated with antifreeze from a malfunctioning valve from the schools solar heating system.
In 1991 a small amount, 2.5 gallons, of herbicide backsiphoned into a Utah water system affecting 2,000 homes, a nursing home and a day-care facility.
In 1987 a child in Minnesota suffered acute copper toxicity when the backflow from a carbon dioxide machine contaminated a restaurants potable system. There was a similar incident from a soft drink machine at a fair in Springfield Missouri in 1995.
In 1989, backpressure from a propane tank car forced propane into the water supply in a town in Arkansas. Three people in separate buildings were injured from explosions after flushing toilets and two houses were destroyed and a business was damaged by explosions and subsequent fires.
In 1995 in Monterey, California, sodium nitrate from a boiler and cooling system backflowed into the potable water supply of the county courthouse because of a faulty backflow prevention device. In this incident 19 people became sick from drinking coffee from the courthouse snack bar.
In February, 1990 a cross-connection between an auxiliary irrigation system supporting a golf course and country club and the Seattle Water Department’s distribution system resulted in total and fecal coliform contamination of the drinking water supply that was detected by a neighboring water system that purchased water from the Seattle Water Department.
In the summer of 1990 1,100 guests of a country club in Tennessee suffered intestinal disorders in two mass incidents after consuming the clubs contaminated water supplies from an auxiliary well that had become contaminated with sewage due to a cross-connection.
Information from US EPA about current incidents was not available. However, the white paper shows that over several decades these types of incidents appear to be declining. It can be derived from the white paper that increased regulation and improved technology have contributed to the decline of backflow incidents. However, the white paper does also strongly note that on-going testing and maintenance continues to be crucial in order to ensure public health protection.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “To ensure that testing of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, Health & Safety Code Section 116810 currently provides that “local health officers may maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers.” In practice, only a few jurisdictions maintain their own programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers…
“The lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs. Inconsistencies from the three private certification bodies and the local health officers create discrepancies in water supply standards and do not protect the public from cross-contamination. As a result, backflow protection device testers must maintain two or three separate, duplicative certifications to work in more than one jurisdiction in California. Statewide consistency is needed regarding what certifications are acceptable… AB 1173 clarifies the certification standards required for backflow prevention device testers.”
- Codifying certification standards. According to the author and sponsor, there is inconsistency in California over the qualification of the three current private certification agencies and insufficient guidance on acceptable certification.
It is unclear how codifying all three of the current bodies in statute as qualified bodies addresses that inconsistency and lack of guidance.
By codifying these agencies and requiring water systems to accept all three certifications, this legislation is assuming that all three certification bodies not only have adequate and similar certification processes but are also all equally protective of public health. It also assumes that these certification bodies will always be adequately compliant with law and regulations and sufficiently protective of public health. Several questions arise from this legislation:
- How is it in the best interest of the state and the Legislature to limit a water system’s ability to choose between the various certification bodies and instead require the systems to accept any of these certifications?
- How is requiring water systems to accept all three bodies’ certifications, without any discretion to determine whether the system believes a tester’s certification is adequate, in the state’s best interest?
- If a water system is required to accept a tester’s certification despite reservations, and then an incident occurs because of inadequate testing or maintenance, how is it that the water system is responsible/liable for the harm and damage caused when the state took away the system’s discretion to choose certification bodies for that tester?
Suggested Amendment. If the committee wishes to address the concern over the lack of consistency and opportunity for various certification entities to be eligible to work in this field, then a more appropriate solution would be to designate the state to approve the certification entities: amendments would be needed to:
- Require each public water system to implement a cross-connection control program that complies with regulations adopted by SWRCB and with guidelines adopted by SWRCB.
- Authorize SWRCB to establish guidelines for cross-connection control. The guidelines may include, but not be limited to, requirements for cross-connection programs, certification of cross-connection control specialists and backflow prevention testers, and provisions for accreditation by the state board or by persons approved by the state board, of entities that certify the individuals as cross-connection control specialists or backflow prevention testers.
SOURCE:
The California State Pipe Trades Council
SUPPORT:
American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International
California State Association of Electrical Workers
International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
OPPOSITION:
American Water Works Association, California-Nevada Section
Association of California Water Agencies
California Municipal Utilities Association
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Water Association
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors
WateReuse California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the sponsor of the bill, the California State Pipe Trades Council, “The current Health & Safety Code provision for local certification of backflow protection device testers by local health officers does not reflect the actual practice in most jurisdictions of relying on private state certifications of backflow protection device testers… The Health & Safety Code should be updated to clarify that, where a local agency does not have its own certification program, backflow connections may be tested by technicians certified by one of these [specified] certification bodies. This change will streamline approval of backflow protection device testers by local jurisdictions, create statewide consistency regarding what certifications are acceptable, and simplify compliance by installers and customers.”
The International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO), which jointly develops, with ASSE International, a tester certification standard deemed acceptable by the bill, argues that, “The lack of guidance on these private certifications, however, has created a patchwork of acceptable certifications across the state, burdening backflow prevention device testers, causing confusion to customers and increasing customer costs. Backflow prevention device testers certified by ASSE, for example, are frozen out of the market when a local jurisdiction or water agency arbitrarily determines that it will accept only AWWA certifications. This reduces the choice of testers for property owners and increases costs.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
California Water Service argues that, “We believe that this legislation could jeopardize the safety of water systems across California for several reasons: First, the legislation presupposes that each of the three certification agencies it lists are equivalent to each other and have certification standards sufficient to ensure the health and safety of the public. These types of decisions are best left to industry experts… Second, far from promoting competition in the industry, the legislation will serve to eliminate competition. By dictating which organizations have appropriate certification standards, the legislation would create a significant entry barrier to new certification organizations, even if they are superior, as the only way they would be able to enter the marketplace is by having a future Legislature amend California Code to include them as one of the approved organizations. Picking winners is the opposite of competition… Finally, the legislation presupposes that each of three listed certifying agencies will continue to have the same standards as they do today. If this legislation were enacted, each of the three listed organizations would be guaranteed that they will be able to certify the testers of backflow prevention devices even if their certification standards precipitously decline.”
-- END --
AB 1173 (Williams) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1173
Author: |
Williams |
||
Version: |
3/26/2015 |
Hearing Date: |
7/15/2015 |
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Rachel Machi Wagoner |
||
SUBJECT: Water equipment: backflow prevention devices testing: certification.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health, including, but not limited to, conducting research, studies, and demonstration programs relating to the provision of a dependable, safe supply of drinking water, enforcing the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, adoption of enforcement regulations, and conducting studies and investigations to assess the quality of water in domestic water supplies.
Requires any person who owns a public water system to ensure that the system does certain things, including, but not limited to, that it will not be subject to backflow under normal operating conditions.
Authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for the certification of backflow prevention device testers in order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance.
Requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or health agency.
Requires that certification standards be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the Department of Public Health.
This bill: states, that if a local health officer does not maintain a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, that the local water system must hire a person who has received a California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices from any one of the following: the California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA), American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International, American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA), or by other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the SWRCB or the local health officer to conduct the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device.
Background
What is Backflow? Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system.
Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
Backflow prevention? Backflow preventers are mechanical assemblies used to prevent contaminated fluids from entering the water supply system. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), a wide choice of devices exists that can be used to prevent backflow from adding contaminated fluids or gases into a potable water supply system. These include air gaps, barometric loops, vacuum breakers—both atmospheric and pressure type, double check with intermediate atmospheric vent, double check valve assemblies, and reduced pressure principle devices. US EPA reports that, generally, the selection of the proper device is based upon the degree of hazard posed by the cross-connection. Additional considerations are based upon piping size, location, and the potential need to periodically test the devices to ensure proper operation.
Certification of backflow prevention device testers? Because the only way a water system or the local health officer becomes aware of a broken or failed backflow system is when an incident has occurred resulting in the contamination of the water supply leading to a public health incident or the risk of a public health incident, the proper testing of backflow prevention assemblies is crucial to the prevention of backflow and is a cornerstone of a cross-connection control program. In order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, statute authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. Additionally, regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency.
Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water systems are responsible for hiring testers that have "demonstrated their competency."
Should a backflow prevention device not be properly tested or maintained and result in an incident, the water system is responsible for the damage caused by that failure.
What happens when a backflow prevention fails? If a backflow preventer fails potable water supplies are compromised and contaminants enter the water. Contaminants that may enter the potable water include, but are not limited to, untreated river, sea or lake water, pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, propane gas, boiler water with chemicals, anti-freeze, numerous chemicals, water from car wash establishments, dyes, sewage, worms, heavy metals such as arsenic, petrochemicals, water from flush toilets or other drains.
The presence of contaminants from backflow in water can lead to adverse health effects, including both acute and long term effects like gastrointestinal illness, reproductive problems, cancer and neurological disorders which can lead to hospitalization or death.
While there is currently no federal reporting requirement for backflow cases, US EPA published a white paper in 2001 that gives several examples of backflow and risks associated with backflow incidents:
In 1982 a Colorado high school’s drinking water was contaminated with antifreeze from a malfunctioning valve from the schools solar heating system.
In 1991 a small amount, 2.5 gallons, of herbicide backsiphoned into a Utah water system affecting 2,000 homes, a nursing home and a day-care facility.
In 1987 a child in Minnesota suffered acute copper toxicity when the backflow from a carbon dioxide machine contaminated a restaurants potable system. There was a similar incident from a soft drink machine at a fair in Springfield Missouri in 1995.
In 1989, backpressure from a propane tank car forced propane into the water supply in a town in Arkansas. Three people in separate buildings were injured from explosions after flushing toilets and two houses were destroyed and a business was damaged by explosions and subsequent fires.
In 1995 in Monterey, California, sodium nitrate from a boiler and cooling system backflowed into the potable water supply of the county courthouse because of a faulty backflow prevention device. In this incident 19 people became sick from drinking coffee from the courthouse snack bar.
In February, 1990 a cross-connection between an auxiliary irrigation system supporting a golf course and country club and the Seattle Water Department’s distribution system resulted in total and fecal coliform contamination of the drinking water supply that was detected by a neighboring water system that purchased water from the Seattle Water Department.
In the summer of 1990 1,100 guests of a country club in Tennessee suffered intestinal disorders in two mass incidents after consuming the clubs contaminated water supplies from an auxiliary well that had become contaminated with sewage due to a cross-connection.
Information from US EPA about current incidents was not available. However, the white paper shows that over several decades these types of incidents appear to be declining. It can be derived from the white paper that increased regulation and improved technology have contributed to the decline of backflow incidents. However, the white paper does also strongly note that on-going testing and maintenance continues to be crucial in order to ensure public health protection.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “To ensure that testing of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, Health & Safety Code Section 116810 currently provides that “local health officers may maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers.” In practice, only a few jurisdictions maintain their own programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers…
“The lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs. Inconsistencies from the three private certification bodies and the local health officers create discrepancies in water supply standards and do not protect the public from cross-contamination. As a result, backflow protection device testers must maintain two or three separate, duplicative certifications to work in more than one jurisdiction in California. Statewide consistency is needed regarding what certifications are acceptable… AB 1173 clarifies the certification standards required for backflow prevention device testers.”
Codifying certification standards. According to the author and sponsor, there is inconsistency in California over the qualification of the three current private certification agencies and insufficient guidance on acceptable certification.
It is unclear how codifying all three of the current bodies in statute as qualified bodies addresses that inconsistency and lack of guidance.
By codifying these agencies and requiring water systems to accept all three certifications, this legislation is assuming that all three certification bodies not only have adequate and similar certification processes but are also all equally protective of public health. It also assumes that these certification bodies will always be adequately compliant with law and regulations and sufficiently protective of public health. Several questions arise from this legislation:
How is it in the best interest of the state and the Legislature to limit a water system’s ability to choose between the various certification bodies and instead require the systems to accept any of these certifications?
How is requiring water systems to accept all three bodies’ certifications, without any discretion to determine whether the system believes a tester’s certification is adequate, in the state’s best interest?
If a water system is required to accept a tester’s certification despite reservations, and then an incident occurs because of inadequate testing or maintenance, how is it that the water system is responsible/liable for the harm and damage caused when the state took away the system’s discretion to choose certification bodies for that tester?
Potential Amendment. If the committee wishes to address the concern over the lack of consistency and opportunity for various certification entities to be eligible to work in this field, then a more appropriate solution would be to designate the state to approve the certification entities: an amendment would be needed to designate SWRCB to develop a state approval process for these entities.
SOURCE:
The California State Pipe Trades Council
SUPPORT:
California State Association of Electrical Workers
International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
OPPOSITION:
Association of California Water Agencies
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Water Association
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the sponsor of the bill, the California State Pipe Trades Council, “The current Health & Safety Code provision for local certification of backflow protection device testers by local health officers does not reflect the actual practice in most jurisdictions of relying on private state certifications of backflow protection device testers… The Health & Safety Code should be updated to clarify that, where a local agency does not have its own certification program, backflow connections may be tested by technicians certified by one of these [specified] certification bodies. This change will streamline approval of backflow protection device testers by local jurisdictions, create statewide consistency regarding what certifications are acceptable, and simplify compliance by installers and customers.”
The International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO), which jointly develops, with ASSE International, a tester certification standard deemed acceptable by the bill, argues that, “The lack of guidance on these private certifications, however, has created a patchwork of acceptable certifications across the state, burdening backflow prevention device testers, causing confusion to customers and increasing customer costs. Backflow prevention device testers certified by ASSE, for example, are frozen out of the market when a local jurisdiction or water agency arbitrarily determines that it will accept only AWWA certifications. This reduces the choice of testers for property owners and increases costs.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
California Water Service argues that, “We believe that this legislation could jeopardize the safety of water systems across California for several reasons: First, the legislation presupposes that each of the three certification agencies it lists are equivalent to each other and have certification standards sufficient to ensure the health and safety of the public. These types of decisions are best left to industry experts… Second, far from promoting competition in the industry, the legislation will serve to eliminate competition. By dictating which organizations have appropriate certification standards, the legislation would create a significant entry barrier to new certification organizations, even if they are superior, as the only way they would be able to enter the marketplace is by having a future Legislature amend California Code to include them as one of the approved organizations. Picking winners is the opposite of competition… Finally, the legislation presupposes that each of three listed certifying agencies will continue to have the same standards as they do today. If this legislation were enacted, each of the three listed organizations would be guaranteed that they will be able to certify the testers of backflow prevention devices even if their certification standards precipitously decline.”
-- END --
AB 1173 (Williams) Page 7 of 7
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1173
Author: |
Williams |
||
Version: |
3/26/2015 |
Hearing Date: |
7/1/2015 |
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Rachel Machi Wagoner |
||
SUBJECT: Water equipment: backflow prevention devices testing: certification
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health, including, but not limited to, conducting research, studies, and demonstration programs relating to the provision of a dependable, safe supply of drinking water, enforcing the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, adoption of enforcement regulations, and conducting studies and investigations to assess the quality of water in domestic water supplies.
Requires any person who owns a public water system to ensure that the system does certain things, including, but not limited to, that it will not be subject to backflow under normal operating conditions.
Authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for the certification of backflow prevention device testers in order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance.
Requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or health agency.
Requires that certification standards be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the Department of Public Health.
This bill: states, that if a local health officer does not maintain a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, that the local water system must hire a person who has received a California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices from any one of the following: the California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA), American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International, American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA), or by other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the SWRCB or the local health officer to conduct the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device.
Background
What is Backflow? Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system.
Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
Backflow prevention? Backflow preventers are mechanical assemblies used to prevent contaminated fluids from entering the water supply system. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), a wide choice of devices exists that can be used to prevent backflow from adding contaminated fluids or gases into a potable water supply system. These include air gaps, barometric loops, vacuum breakers—both atmospheric and pressure type, double check with intermediate atmospheric vent, double check valve assemblies, and reduced pressure principle devices. US EPA reports that, generally, the selection of the proper device is based upon the degree of hazard posed by the cross-connection. Additional considerations are based upon piping size, location, and the potential need to periodically test the devices to ensure proper operation.
Certification of backflow prevention device testers? Because the only way a water system or the local health officer becomes aware of a broken or failed backflow system is when an incident has occurred resulting in the contamination of the water supply leading to a public health incident or the risk of a public health incident, the proper testing of backflow prevention assemblies is crucial to the prevention of backflow and is a cornerstone of a cross-connection control program. In order to ensure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, statute authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. Additionally, regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency.
Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water systems are responsible for hiring testers that have "demonstrated their competency."
Should a backflow prevention device not be properly tested or maintained and result in an incident, the water system is responsible for that failure.
What happens when a backflow prevention fails? If a backflow preventer fails potable water supplies are compromised and contaminants enter the water. Contaminants that may enter the potable water include, but are not limited to, untreated river, sea or lake water, pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, propane gas, boiler water with chemicals, anti-freeze, numerous chemicals, water from car wash establishments, dyes, sewage, worms, heavy metals such as arsenic, petrochemicals, water from flush toilets or other drains.
The presence of contaminants from backflow in water can lead to adverse health effects, including both acute and long term effects like gastrointestinal illness, reproductive problems, cancer and neurological disorders which can lead to hospitalization or death.
While there is currently no federal reporting requirement for backflow cases, US EPA published a white paper in 2001 that gives several examples of backflow and risks associated with backflow incidents:
In 1982 a Colorado high school’s drinking water was contaminated with antifreeze from a malfunctioning valve from the schools solar heating system.
In 1991 a small amount, 2.5 gallons, of herbicide backsiphoned into a Utah water system affecting 2,000 homes, a nursing home and a day-care facility.
In 1987 a child in Minnesota suffered acute copper toxicity when the backflow from a carbon dioxide machine contaminated a restaurants potable system. There was a similar incident from a soft drink machine at a fair in Springfield Missouri in 1995.
In 1989, backpressure from a propane tank car forced propane into the water supply in a town in Arkansas. Three people in separate buildings were injured from explosions after flushing toilets and two houses were destroyed and a business was damaged by explosions and subsequent fires.
In 1995 in Monterey, California, sodium nitrate from a boiler and cooling system backflowed into the potable water supply of the county courthouse because of a faulty backflow prevention device. In this incident 19 people became sick from drinking coffee from the courthouse snack bar.
In February, 1990 a cross-connection between an auxiliary irrigation system supporting a golf course and country club and the Seattle Water Department’s distribution system resulted in total and fecal coliform contamination of the drinking water supply that was detected by a neighboring water system that purchased water from the Seattle Water Department.
In the summer of 1990 1,100 guests of a country club in Tennessee suffered intestinal disorders in two mass incidents after consuming the clubs contaminated water supplies from an auxiliary well that had become contaminated with sewage due to a cross-connection.
Information from US EPA about current incidents was not available. However, the white paper shows that over several decades these types of incidents appear to be declining. It can be derived from the white paper that increased regulation and improved technology have contributed to the decline of backflow incidents. However, the white paper does also strongly note that on-going testing and maintenance continues to be crucial in order to ensure public health protection.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “To ensure that testing of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, Health & Safety Code Section 116810 currently provides that “local health officers may maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers.” In practice, only a few jurisdictions maintain their own programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers…
“The lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs. Inconsistencies from the three private certification bodies and the local health officers create discrepancies in water supply standards and do not protect the public from cross-contamination. As a result, backflow protection device testers must maintain two or three separate, duplicative certifications to work in more than one jurisdiction in California. Statewide consistency is needed regarding what certifications are acceptable… AB 1173 clarifies the certification standards required for backflow prevention device testers.”
Codifying certification standards. According to the author and sponsor, there is inconsistency in California over the qualification of the three current private certification agencies and insufficient guidance on acceptable certification.
It is unclear how codifying all three of the current bodies in statute as qualified bodies addresses that inconsistency and lack of guidance.
By codifying these agencies and requiring water systems to accept all three certifications, this legislation is assuming that all three certification bodies not only have adequate and similar certification processes but are also all equally protective of public health. It also assumes that these certification bodies will always be adequately compliant with law and regulations and sufficiently protective of public health. Several questions arise from this legislation:
How is it in the best interest of the state and the Legislature to limit a water system’s ability to choose between the various certification bodies and instead require the systems to accept any of these certifications?
How is requiring water systems to accept all three bodies’ certifications, without any discretion to determine whether the system believes a tester’s certification is adequate, in the state’s best interest?
If a water system is required to accept a tester’s certification despite reservations, and then an incident occurs because of inadequate testing or maintenance, how is it that the water system is responsible/liable for the harm and damage caused when the state took away the system’s discretion to choose certification bodies for that tester?
SOURCE:
The California State Pipe Trades Council
SUPPORT:
California State Association of Electrical Workers
International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
OPPOSITION:
Association of California Water Agencies
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Water Association
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the sponsor of the bill, the California State Pipe Trades Council, “The current Health & Safety Code provision for local certification of backflow protection device testers by local health officers does not reflect the actual practice in most jurisdictions of relying on private state certifications of backflow protection device testers… The Health & Safety Code should be updated to clarify that, where a local agency does not have its own certification program, backflow connections may be tested by technicians certified by one of these [specified] certification bodies. This change will streamline approval of backflow protection device testers by local jurisdictions, create statewide consistency regarding what certifications are acceptable, and simplify compliance by installers and customers.”
The International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO), which jointly develops, with ASSE International, a tester certification standard deemed acceptable by the bill, argues that, “The lack of guidance on these private certifications, however, has created a patchwork of acceptable certifications across the state, burdening backflow prevention device testers, causing confusion to customers and increasing customer costs. Backflow prevention device testers certified by ASSE, for example, are frozen out of the market when a local jurisdiction or water agency arbitrarily determines that it will accept only AWWA certifications. This reduces the choice of testers for property owners and increases costs.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
California Water Service argues that, “We believe that this legislation could jeopardize the safety of water systems across California for several reasons: First, the legislation presupposes that each of the three certification agencies it lists are equivalent to each other and have certification standards sufficient to ensure the health and safety of the public. These types of decisions are best left to industry experts… Second, far from promoting competition in the industry, the legislation will serve to eliminate competition. By dictating which organizations have appropriate certification standards, the legislation would create a significant entry barrier to new certification organizations, even if they are superior, as the only way they would be able to enter the marketplace is by having a future Legislature amend California Code to include them as one of the approved organizations. Picking winners is the opposite of competition… Finally, the legislation presupposes that each of three listed certifying agencies will continue to have the same standards as they do today. If this legislation were enacted, each of the three listed organizations would be guaranteed that they will be able to certify the testers of backflow prevention devices even if their certification standards precipitously decline.”
-- END --
AB 1173
Page 2
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 1173
(Williams)
As Amended March 26, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Environmental Safety |
5-0 |
Alejo, Gonzalez, Gray, McCarty, Ting |
|
Appropriations |
13-3 |
Gomez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Quirk, Rendon, Weber, Wood |
Bigelow, Jones, Wagner |
SUMMARY: Requires, if a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program for backflow prevention device testers, that the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device be performed by a person who has received specified California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices. Specifically, this bill:
Requires, if a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program for backflow prevention device testers, that the testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device be performed by a person who has received California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices by one of the following:
California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA);
American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International;
American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA); or,
Other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) or the local health officer.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill may result in increased costs for the SWRCB of $140,000 annually (Safe Drinking Water Revolving Fund) to review certification providers.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "The lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs… Statewide consistency is needed regarding what certifications are acceptable… AB 1173 clarifies the certification standards required for backflow prevention device testers."
Backflow: Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system. Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
Backflow prevention: Backflow preventers are mechanical assemblies used to prevent contaminated fluids from entering the water supply system. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), a wide choice of devices exists that can be used to prevent backflow from adding contaminated fluids or gases into a potable water supply system. These include air gaps, barometric loops, vacuum breakers – both atmospheric and pressure type, double check with intermediate atmospheric vent, double check valve assemblies, and reduced pressure principle devices. US EPA reports that, generally, the selection of the proper device is based upon the degree of hazard posed by the cross-connection. Additional considerations are based upon piping size, location, and the potential need to periodically test the devices to insure proper operation.
Certification of backflow prevention device testers: The California Department of Public Health asserts that proper testing of backflow prevention assemblies is crucial to the prevention of backflow and is a cornerstone of a cross-connection control program. In order to assure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, statute authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers (Health and Safety Code Section 116805). Additionally, regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency (California Code of Regulations, Title 17, Section 7605(b)). Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water suppliers are responsible for hiring testers that have "demonstrated their competency."
This bill, in the absence of a local program, requires water suppliers to hire testers holding AWAA, ASSE, ABPA, or other similar certification deemed acceptable by the SWRCB or the local health officer.
Analysis Prepared by: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0000421
AB 1173
Page 2
Date of Hearing: May 13, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1173
(Williams) – As Amended March 26, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Vote: |
5 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices to be performed by a certified person, as specified, if the local health officer does not maintain a local certification program. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that if a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program for backflow prevention device testers, testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device shall be performed by a person who has received California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices by one of the following:
California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWWA);
American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International;
American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA); or,
Other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) or the local health officer.
Clarifies existing law to be consistent with the relocating of the Safe Drinking Water Program from the Department of Public Health to the SWRCB.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Increased costs for SWRCB of $140,000 annually (Safe Drinking Water Revolving Fund) to review certification providers.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, the lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs. The author further asserts the inconsistencies from the three private certification bodies and the local health officers create discrepancies in water supply standards and do not protect the public from cross-contamination. This bill provides statewide consistency.
Background. Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system.
Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
Backflow Prevention Device Testers. In order to assure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, current law authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers.
Additionally, current regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency. Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water suppliers are responsible for hiring testers that have demonstrated their competency.
This bill, in the absence of a local program, requires water suppliers to hire testers holding AWWA, ASSE, ABPA, or other similar certification deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board or the local health officer.
Support and Opposition. According to the sponsor of the bill, the California State Pipe Trades Council, current requirements for local certification of backflow protection device testers by local health officers does not reflect the actual practice in most jurisdictions of relying on private state certifications of backflow protection device testers. This bill streamlines approval of backflow protection device testers by local jurisdictions, creates statewide consistency regarding what certifications are acceptable, and simplifies compliance.
California Water Service opposes the bill and notes that if this legislation were enacted, each of the three listed organizations would be guaranteed that they will be able to certify the testers of backflow prevention devices even if their certification standards significantly decline.
The author may wish to require the SWRCB to periodically review and approve the listed certification entities to maintain the integrity of the certification process.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1173
Page 4
Date of Hearing: April 28, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Luis Alejo, Chair
AB 1173
(Williams) – As Amended March 26, 2015
SUBJECT: Water equipment: backflow prevention devices testing: certification
SUMMARY: Provides that if a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program for backflow prevention device testers, testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device shall be performed by a person who has received specified California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices. Specifically, this bill:
Clarifies that the standards for certification of backflow prevention device testers developed by local programs shall be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board, not the Department of Public Health.
Provides that if a local health officer does not maintain a local certification program for backflow prevention device testers, testing and maintenance of a backflow prevention device shall be performed by a person who has received California-specific certification for testing backflow prevention devices by one of the following:
California-Nevada Section of the American Water Works Association (AWAA);
American Society of Sanitary Engineering (ASSE) International;
American Backflow Prevention Association (ABPA); or,
Other similar certification provider deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board or the local health officer.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires any person who owns a public water system to ensure that the system will not be subject to backflow under normal operating conditions. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 116555(a)(2))
Authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for the control of cross-connections by water users, within the users’ premises, where public exposure to drinking water contaminated by backflow may occur. (HSC § 116800)
Authorizes local health officers to maintain programs, in cooperation with water suppliers, to protect against backflow through service connections into the public water supply, and, with the consent of the water supplier, to collect fees from the water supplier to offset the costs of implementing these programs. (HSC § 116805)
Authorizes local health officers, to assure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers. (HSC § 116810)
Authorizes the local health officer to suspend, revoke, or refuse to renew the certificate of a tester, if, after a hearing, the local health officer or his or her designee finds that the tester has practiced fraud or deception or has displayed gross negligence or misconduct in the performance of his or her duties as a certified backflow prevention device tester. (HSC § 116810)
Authorizes the local health officer to collect fees from certified testers to offset the cost of the certification program. (HSC § 116810)
Requires the certification standards to be consistent with the backflow protection regulations adopted by the Department of Public Health. (HSC § 116810)
Requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or health agency. (California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 17, § 7605(b))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "To ensure that testing of backflow prevention devices are performed by persons qualified to do testing and maintenance, Health & Safety Code Section 116810 currently provides that “local health officers may maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers.” In practice, only a few jurisdictions maintain their own programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers…
"The lack of guidance on acceptable private statewide certification of backflow protection device testers has resulted in inconsistent requirements throughout the state, burdening plumbing installers, stifling competition, and increasing customer costs. Inconsistencies from the three private certification bodies and the local health officers create discrepancies in water supply standards and do not protect the public from cross-contamination. As a result, backflow protection device testers must maintain two or three separate, duplicative certifications to work in more than one jurisdiction in California. Statewide consistency is needed regarding what certifications are acceptable… AB 1173 clarifies the certification standards required for backflow prevention device testers."
Backflow: Backflow is the undesirable reversal of the flow of liquid, gas or solid into the potable water supply. Water supply systems are maintained at a pressure significant enough to enable water to flow from the tap. However, when pressure fails or is reduced, which may happen if a water main bursts, pipes freeze, or there is unexpectedly high demand on the water system, water or substances from the ground, storage, or other sources may be drawn up into the system. Additionally, non-potable substances may be pushed into a potable water supply if the pressure in the downstream piping system exceeds the pressure in the potable water system. Either of these backflow conditions can enable contaminated water or substances to enter the potable water distribution system, potentially risking public health and safety.
Backflow prevention: Backflow preventers are mechanical assemblies used to prevent contaminated fluids from entering the water supply system. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), a wide choice of devices exists that can be used to prevent backflow from adding contaminated fluids or gases into a potable water supply system. These include air gaps, barometric loops, vacuum breakers—both atmospheric and pressure type, double check with intermediate atmospheric vent, double check valve assemblies, and reduced pressure principle devices. US EPA reports that, generally, the selection of the proper device is based upon the degree of hazard posed by the cross-connection. Additional considerations are based upon piping size, location, and the potential need to periodically test the devices to insure proper operation.
Certification of backflow prevention device testers: The California Department of Public Health asserts that proper testing of backflow prevention assemblies is crucial to the prevention of backflow and is a cornerstone of a cross-connection control program. In order to assure that testing and maintenance of backflow prevention devices are performed by qualified persons, statute authorizes local health officers to maintain programs for certification of backflow prevention device testers (HSC § 116805). Additionally, regulation requires backflow preventers to be tested by persons who have demonstrated their competency in testing of these devices to the water supplier or local health agency (CCR, Title 17, § 7605(b)). Per statute and regulation, in jurisdictions where the local health officer has not established a program for certification of backflow prevention device testers, water suppliers are responsible for hiring testers that have "demonstrated their competency."
This bill, in the absence of a local program, requires water suppliers to hire testers holding AWWA, ASSE, ABPA, or other similar certification deemed acceptable by the State Water Resources Control Board or the local health officer.
Arguments in support: According to the sponsor of the bill, the California State Pipe Trades Council, "The current Health & Safety Code provision for local certification of backflow protection device testers by local health officers does not reflect the actual practice in most jurisdictions of relying on private state certifications of backflow protection device testers… The Health & Safety Code should be updated to clarify that, where a local agency does not have its own certification program, backflow connections may be tested by technicians certified by one of these [specified] certification bodies. This change will streamline approval of backflow protection device testers by local jurisdictions, create statewide consistency regarding what certifications are acceptable, and simplify compliance by installers and customers."
The International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO), which jointly develops, with ASSE International, a tester certification standard deemed acceptable by the bill, argues that, "The lack of guidance on these private certifications, however, has created a patchwork of acceptable certifications across the state, burdening backflow prevention device testers, causing confusion to customers and increasing customer costs. Backflow prevention device testers certified by ASSE, for example, are frozen out of the market when a local jurisdiction or water agency arbitrarily determines that it will accept only AWWA certifications. This reduces the choice of testers for property owners and increases costs."
Arguments in opposition: California Water Service argues that, "We believe that this legislation could jeopardize the safety of water systems across California for several reasons: First, the legislation presupposes that each of the three certification agencies it lists are equivalent to each other and have certification standards sufficient to ensure the health and safety of the public. These types of decisions are best left to industry experts… Second, far from promoting competition in the industry, the legislation will serve to eliminate competition. By dictating which organizations have appropriate certification standards, the legislation would create a significant entry barrier to new certification organizations, even if they are superior, as the only way they would be able to enter the marketplace is by having a future Legislature amend California Code to include them as one of the approved organizations. Picking winners is the opposite of competition… Finally, the legislation presupposes that each of three listed certifying agencies will continue to have the same standards as they do today. If this legislation were enacted, each of the three listed organizations would be guaranteed that they will be able to certify the testers of backflow prevention devices even if their certification standards precipitously decline."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The California State Pipe Trades Council (Sponsor)
California State Association of Electrical Workers
International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Opposition
California Water Service
Analysis Prepared by: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):