AB 2759: Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-16
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment criminal restitution order against an agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment against an agent agent, as defined, of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes. By allowing for additional payments to be made from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
Existing law requires the application filed with the Secretary of State to include specified information and documentation, and imposes criminal penalties for the filing of any documents that are false or untrue or contain any willful, material misstatements of fact.
This bill would require, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant to provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires, if, at any time, the money deposited in the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid award or offer of settlement, plus specified accumulated interest.
This bill would eliminate the requirement to pay that specified accumulated interest.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, a continuously appropriated fund, within the State Treasury administered by the Secretary of State, the sole purpose of which is to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud. Existing law provides that an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment, as specified, against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, may file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss to the claimant in the final judgment.
This bill would additionally apply those provisions if an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment against an agent of a corporation based upon those same circumstances. The bill would also make conforming changes.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)(1)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(2)Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorneys fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)(1)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(2)Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorneys fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent. The Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)(1)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(2)Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorneys fees. fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent. The Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)(1)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporations fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(2)Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorneys fees. The Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent consent, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or its their agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed.
SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As used in this chapter:
(a)Agent means a person who was an officer or director of a corporation, as defined in subdivision (e), at the time the fraudulent acts occurred and was acting in the persons capacity as the corporations officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
(a)
(b)Application means a request for payment from the fund submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to this chapter.
(b)
(c)Claimant means an aggrieved person who resides in the state at the time of the fraud and who submits an application pursuant to this chapter.
(c)
(d)Complaint, for the purpose of an application based on a criminal restitution order, means the facts of the underlying transaction or transactions upon which the criminal restitution order is based.
(d)
(e)Corporation means a domestic corporation as defined by Section 162 or 2509 or a foreign corporation that is qualified to transact business in California pursuant to Section 2105.
(e)
(f)Court of competent jurisdiction means a state or federal court situated in California.
(f)
(g)Final judgment means a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. The following are examples of final judgments:
(1)A civil judgment that has been entered against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, and includes findings of facts and conclusions of law.
(2)If the matter was submitted to arbitration, a copy of the arbitration decision and any other documentation supporting the arbitration award. An arbitration award against a corporation for conduct constituting fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law rendered in accordance with the rules established by the American Arbitration Association or another recognized arbitration body, and in accordance with Sections 1280 to 1294.2, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure where applicable, and where the arbitration award has been confirmed and reduced to judgment pursuant to Section 1287.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation corporation, or an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code or Section 3663 of Title 18 of the United States Code. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order shall comply with all of the requirements of this chapter.
(g)
(h)Fund means the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund created by Section 2280.
(i)Judgment debtor means a corporation or agent against which a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order has been entered for conduct constituting intentional fraud.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 2282 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.(a)(1)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation or an agent of a corporation based upon the corporations or the agents fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent's fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agents capacity as the corporations officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(2)Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorneys fees. The Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation or the agent of the corporation. and the agent, if any.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant shall provide the charging document and the restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this chapter.
(6)
(7)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the corporations or agents judgment debtors assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the corporations or agents judgment debtors insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(7)
(8)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the corporation or its agent. judgment debtor or debtors.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the insolvency of the corporation or its agent judgment debtor or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any any, are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse spouse, registered domestic partner, or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation or its agent and all agents named in the application that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice to the corporation shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation or its agent and all agents named in the application that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation or its agent. and all agents named in the application.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)If the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application pursuant to Section 2282.2, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this chapter.
(c)
(d)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or its their agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or its agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations or its their agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 7.Section 2290 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2290.If, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest at the rate set by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco on advances made to member banks under Sections 13 and 13a of the Federal Reserve Act, at the time of the award or settlement offer, not to exceed 2 percent per year. filed.
SEC. 6.SEC. 8.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 7.SEC. 9.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
SEC. 10.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)When an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation or an agent of a corporation based upon the corporations or the agents fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the fund, within the limitations specified in Section 2289, for the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.
(b)The application shall be delivered in person or by certified mail to the Secretary of State not later than 18 months after the judgment has become final.
(c)The application shall be made on a form prescribed by the Secretary of State and shall include each of the following:
(1)The name and address of the claimant.
(2)If the claimant is represented by an attorney for the application, the name, business address, and telephone number of the attorney. If the claimant is not represented by an attorney for the application, a telephone number where the claimant can be reached during regular business hours shall be included.
(3)The name and address of the corporation. corporation or the agent of the corporation.
(4)The identification of the final judgment, the amount of the claim that remains unreimbursed from any source, and an explanation of the claims computation.
(5)A copy of a final judgment and a copy of the civil complaint and any amendments thereto upon which the judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud, was made shall be deemed to satisfy compliance with the requirements prescribed in this paragraph. The claimant may also provide any additional documentation that he or she believes may help the Secretary of State in evaluating the application, including, but not limited to, evidence submitted to the court in the underlying judgment or a detailed narrative statement of facts in explanation of the allegations of the complaint upon which the underlying judgment is based.
(6)A description of searches and inquiries conducted by or on behalf of the claimant with respect to the corporations or agents assets liable to be sold or applied to satisfaction of the judgment. A courts determination or finding of the corporations or agents insolvency or lack of assets to pay the claimant shall be deemed to satisfy the requirements prescribed in this paragraph.
(7)Each of the following representations by the claimant:
(A)That the claimant is not a spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation nor a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation.
(B)That the claimant has complied with all of the requirements of this section.
(C)That the judgment underlying the claim meets the requirements of subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 2282, including all of the following:
(i)That the judgment was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, corporation or the agent of the corporation, with the intent to defraud.
(ii)That the judgment is unpaid in part or in whole.
(iii)That the underlying judgment and debt have not been discharged in bankruptcy, or the underlying judgment is statutorily nondischargeable, or, in the case of a bankruptcy proceeding that is open at or after the time of the filing of the application, that the judgment and debt have been declared to be nondischargeable by the judge or stipulated as nondischargeable by the parties in the proceeding and that the claimant has been granted permission by the bankruptcy court to proceed with collection or otherwise proceed with the claimants claims against the corporation. corporation or its agent.
(D)That the claimant does not have a pending claim and has not collected on the final judgment from any other restitution fund. If the claimant has a pending claim or has collected from another fund, a description of the nature of the pending claim and the recovery amounts from any restitution fund.
(d)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) the Secretary of State shall not condition an award of payment from the fund upon a claimant providing any additional information or documents other than those prescribed in subdivision (c).
(2)If the final judgment in favor of the claimant was by default, stipulated, a consent judgment, or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the Secretary of State may request additional documents and information from the claimant to determine whether the claim is valid.
(3)If the final judgment does not expressly set forth the amount of damages that were awarded for actual loss and compensatory damages that are payable from the fund pursuant to Section 2289, the Secretary of State may ask the claimant to provide copies of documentation pertaining to the amount of the actual and direct loss and the awarded compensatory damages or both of those findings. For purposes of this section, sufficient proof of money damages may include any of the following: copies of bank account statements showing or confirming particular transactions, copies of the front and back of checks made payable to the corporation that have been negotiated, credit card statements showing or confirming particular transactions, or similar documentation demonstrating financial loss directly resulting from the fraudulent acts by the corporation or its agent and the amount of compensatory damages awarded by the court.
(4)If there is no court determination or finding of the corporations insolvency of the corporation or its agent or lack of assets to pay the claimant, the Secretary of State may request additional information and documentation from the claimant to determine what assets, if any are available to satisfy the final judgment.
(e)The Secretary of State shall include with the application form a notice to the claimant of his or her obligation to protect the underlying judgment from discharge in bankruptcy, to be appended to the application.
(f)If a claimant is a spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, or is a personal representative of the spouse or an immediate family member of an employee, officer, director, managing agent, or other principal of the corporation, the claimant shall not be precluded for that reason alone from receiving an award where the claimant can otherwise meet the requirements of this section.
SEC. 2.Section 2282.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2282.1.(a)The Secretary of State shall provide notice to the corporation or its agent that a claimant has submitted an application for payment from the fund and shall also provide within that notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, the method to contest the payment from the fund.
(b)The notice shall be provided by certified mail addressed to the corporations last designated agent for service of process of record with the Secretary of State and notice shall be deemed complete five calendar days after the notice is mailed.
(c)If the corporation or its agent wishes to contest payment of an application by the Secretary of State, the corporation or agent shall mail or deliver a written response addressed to the Secretary of State within 30 calendar days of the notice of the application, and shall mail or deliver a copy of the response to the claimant. The written response of the corporation or agent shall not be directed to issues and facts conclusively established by the underlying judgment. If the corporation fails to mail or deliver a timely response, the corporation shall have waived the corporations right to present objections to payment of the application, and shall not thereafter be entitled to notice of any action taken or proposed to be taken by the Secretary of State with respect to the application.
SEC. 3.Section 2286 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2286.The Secretary of State shall give notice, as prescribed by the Secretary of State, to the corporation or its agent that the Secretary of State has made a decision to award funds to the claimant and shall provide a copy of the decision to the corporation. corporation or its agent.
SEC. 4.Section 2288 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2288.(a)Whenever the court proceeds upon a petition under Section 2287, it shall order payment out of the fund only upon a determination that the aggrieved party has a valid cause of action within the purview of Section 2282, and has complied with Section 2287.
(b)(1)The Secretary of State may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. The claimants judgment shall create a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence.
(2)If the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was by default, stipulation, consent or pursuant to Section 594 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or if the action against the corporation or its agent was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, the petitioner shall have the burden of proving that the cause of action against the corporation or its agent was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit.
(c)The Secretary of State may move the court at any time to dismiss the petition when it appears there are no triable issues and the petition is without merit. The motion may be supported by affidavit of any person or persons having knowledge of the facts, and may be made on the basis that the petition, and the judgment referred to therein, does not form the basis for a meritorious recovery claim within the purview of Section 2282; provided, however, the Secretary of State shall give written notice at least 10 calendar days before hearing on the motion to the claimant.
SEC. 5.Section 2289 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2289.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter and regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, or the number of judgments against a corporation, corporation or its agent, the liability of the fund shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with the intent to defraud.
(b)When multiple corporations or its agents are involved in the same event or series of events that are the basis of the claimants final judgment and the conduct of two or more of the corporations or its agents results in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, the claimant may seek recovery from the fund based on the judgment against any one of the corporations, corporations or its agents, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(c)When multiple claimants are involved in a corporate fraud, or in misrepresentation or deceit by a corporation, corporation or its agents, resulting in a judgment meeting the requirements of Section 2282, each claimant may seek recovery from the fund individually, subject to the limitations of subdivision (a).
(d)Claimants who are spouses, registered domestic partners, or persons other than natural persons, that have obtained an eligible final judgment shall be considered one claimant.
SEC. 6.Section 2293.1 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2293.1.If the Secretary of State pays from the fund any amount in settlement of a claim or toward satisfaction of a final judgment against a corporation, corporation or its agent, the corporation or its agent shall be required to pay to the fund the amount paid plus interest at the prevailing legal rate applicable to a judgment rendered in any court of this state, within 30 calendar days of the date that the Secretary of State provided notice of the payment of the award or compromise. If the corporation or its agent fails to make the required payment to the fund within the required time, the corporation shall be suspended until the payment is made. A discharge in bankruptcy shall not relieve a corporation or its agent from the penalties and disabilities provided in this chapter.
SEC. 7.Section 2294 of the Corporations Code is amended to read:2294.The Secretary of State shall not make any award to a claimant from the fund if the claimant has received payment from any other restitution funds or for the portions of the judgment that the claimant has collected from the corporation or its agent or any other defendant in the underlying judgment.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 16, 2016 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 390, Statutes of 2016. |
| Sep 16, 2016 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 2, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 12 p.m. |
| Aug 25, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 6301.). |
| Aug 25, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 25 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 5250.). |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 8, 2016 | Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Jun 16, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 15, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 15). |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F.I. and JUD. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 5108.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 4, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 5, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & F. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 5). Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Mar 10, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 25, 2016 | AB 2759 LEVINE Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 22, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2759 Levine By Vidak | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 8, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 15, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2016 | AB 2759 LEVINE Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly 1st Extraordinary Session on Finance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 5, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Banking and Finance] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2759
Author:(Levine)
As Amended Ver:August 17, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 80-0 | (June 1, 2016) | SENATE: | 39-0 | (August 22, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Seeks to compensate victims of corporate fraud committed by corporate officers from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a civil judgment against a corporate officer or obtains a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts of a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the VCFCF in the same manner as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do.
- Eliminates the requirement in existing law that the VCFCF must pay interest to a claimant on an unpaid claim in the event that it does not have enough money to pay a claim when it is initially submitted for payment.
- Defines relevant terms.
The Senate amendments:
- Eliminate the provision specifying that attorney fees are not costs that can be recovered from the VCFCF and declaring that the limitation on attorney fees is declaratory of existing law.
- Clarify that a victim who obtains a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts of a corporate officer may also recover from the VCFCF.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriation analysis:
- Secretary of State: Potential increase in administrative costs, likely minor and absorbable (General Fund) to a) revise and distribute forms and notices, b) process a greater number of claims for reimbursement against agents of corporations, and, c) enforce and collect repayments to the VCFCF for claims paid on individual restitution orders.
- VCFCF payments: Potentially significant to major increase in future payments made from the VCFCF due to extending compensation eligibility to include claims against agents of corporations. For every 10 to 20 claims paid at the $50,000 cap per claim, costs would be $0.5 million to $1 million (Special Fund*). The VCFCF is projected to receive revenues of $1.7 million in Fiscal Year (FY) 2016-17, with an ending reserve balance of $12.4 million. Annual payments out of the VCFCF have been in the range of $1.5 million to $1.8 million. Staff notes the current level of fee revenues, in the absence of regular repayments to the VCFCF, will be insufficient to sustain future increases in payments from the VCFCF. Repayments to the Secretary of State on claims paid from the VCFCF are rare, with no repayments provided over the last three years.
- Repeal of interest: Minor future reductions to VCFCF claim payment amounts that will no longer have interest applied to the outstanding award payment during the period that the VCFCF balance is insufficient to fully satisfy the award. To date, no interest has been assessed or paid on VCFCF payments.
COMMENTS: According to the Secretary of State's Office, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund had a balance of approximately $11,900,000 as of January 2016. According to information provided by the author:
The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has not received any applications based upon a criminal restitution order against AGA Financial Inc. However, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has received numerous claims based upon four criminal restitution orders naming James Koenig and Asset Real Estate and Investment Company in a related criminal proceeding. The first three criminal restitution orders named victims who testified at trial. Administrative review has been completed for all of the submitted Applications based upon the first three restitution orders and the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has paid out more than $1.1 million dollars to victims named in the three orders.
The court issued its fourth restitution order, on June 24, 2015, naming victims who had not testified at trial. The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund received nearly 300 claims based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order. Unfortunately, James Koenig has filed a Notice of Appeal with respect to the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order which is still pending. California Corporations Code sections 2281(f) and 2282(a) preclude the payment of claims while an appeal is pending. Therefore, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Fund is statutorily precluded from awarding applications based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order until the appeal has run its course.
According to the author:
We know that there are victims of corporate fraud that are unable to access the victims of corporate fraud compensation fund. That is because to access the fund an individual must have been a victim of a corporation that has been convicted. Very rarely are corporations charged with crimes almost always it is an individual who is charged with a crime. This bill will correct this problem and allow many individuals who should have access to the fund access.
Access to the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund. If a plaintiff successfully obtained a judgment against an officer of a corporation based upon the tortious act by the officer him or herself; the act of the officer on behalf of the corporation; or the act of the officer violated the "Responsible Corporate Officer Doctrine," the plaintiff's theory of liability would be based upon misdeeds of the corporation that are attributable to the officer (and vice versa). It therefore seems reasonable to provide such a plaintiff with the same remedies available to a plaintiff who obtains a judgment against the corporation itself.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004564
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2759 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2759
Amended: 8/17/16 in Senate
SENATE BANKING & F.I. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/15/16
AYES: Glazer, Vidak, Galgiani, Hall, Hueso, Lara, Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund
DIGEST: This bill authorizes victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (compensation fund) for fraudulent acts committed by an officer or director of a corporation, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/17/16 strike the provision of the bill that states nothing shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees, unless they are ordered by a court, as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes the compensation fund within the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State, and provides that the fund exists for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud (Corporations Code Section 2280).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment, as defined, in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund (Corporations Code Section 2282).
- Prescribes a series of rules that must be followed by persons seeking to apply to the Secretary of State seeking payment from the fund and imposes a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials (Corporations Code Sections 2281 through 2288).
- Caps the liability of the fund at $50,000 per claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud (Corporations Code Section 2289).
- Provides that, if, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest, as specified, not to exceed 2% per year (Corporations Code Section 2290).
- Directs to the fund one-half of the $5 disclosure fee required to be paid by corporations when they file their annual Statements of Information with the Secretary of State (Corporations Code Sections 1502 and 2117).
This bill:
- Defines an agent for purposes of the compensation fund as a person who was an officer or director of a corporation at the time fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in his or her capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
- Amends the definition of a final judgment for purposes of the compensation fund to include a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation or agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, as specified (this bill adds the italicized language).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based on the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund, as specified (this bill adds the italicized language).
- Adds to the documentation that must be provided by an applicant for compensation from the compensation fund by providing that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant must provide the charging document and restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, the claimant must also provide documentation showing that the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent, as defined.
- Provides that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner has the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent, as defined. Authorizes an active corporation, which has submitted a response to the application for restitution from the compensation fund, to appear in court in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent, as defined.
- Deletes the requirement for the state to pay interest on amounts awarded from the compensation fund, when money in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement.
- Makes conforming changes to other provisions of the compensation fund statutes.
Background
The compensation fund was created in 2002 (SB 55, Shelley, Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002) on the heels of the Enron scandal, but was largely untapped until 2011. Administrative changes implemented by the Secretary of State’s Office beginning in 2011, together with enactment of SB 1058 (Lieu, Chapter 564) in 2012, helped facilitate payment from the fund to victims. To date, the fund has paid out 603 claims, totaling $10.6 million. The following chart shows payouts from the fund during each of the past five calendar years, using data provided by the Secretary of State’s Office.
Year | Awards Paid To Victims |
2015 | $1,844,675 |
2014 | $3,894,450 |
2013 | $1,778,933 |
2012 | $2,445,807 |
2011 | $0 |
The fund receives approximately $1.7 million per year, through a $2.50 disclosure fee paid by for-profit corporations. The fund balance is currently $12 million.
Comments
This bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer or director, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer or director after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the compensation fund, in the same way a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation could do.
This bill contains language that requires the corporate officer to have engaged in the fraudulent acts while acting in his or her official capacity as a corporation’s officer or director. This language ensures consistency with the original intent of the compensation fund, and ensures that victims may not pursue restitution from the fund, if they are defrauded by someone who happens to be a corporate officer, but who was not acting in his or her official capacity as an officer or director of a corporation when perpetrating that fraud.
The Secretary of State’s office estimates that this bill will increase payments from the compensation fund by about 50%. This large increase reflects the fact that people, rather than corporations, are typically charged in cases involving corporate fraud. In Ponzi schemes, especially, the corporation is typically defunct by the time the case goes to trial. Attorneys who prosecute these types of cases assert that there is often no value in prosecuting the corporation, because it no longer exists; instead, they prosecute the people who ran the Ponzi scheme and served as the face of the corporation. Although these prosecutions can result in convictions, they rarely result in compensation being paid out from the compensation fund, because the corporations are rarely named in the restitution orders that stem from these convictions. This bill amends the law to more clearly reflect the entities that are prosecuted in connection with corporate fraud.
To Which Applications Will This Bill Apply? Under existing law, an application is not timely until a final judgment has been issued. Once a judgment becomes final, existing law also provides victims 18 months in which to submit their applications for restitution. According to the Secretary of State’s Office, this bill will apply to applications filed prospectively on and after the effective date of this bill and to applications that were filed prior to the effective date of this bill, but which are within the law’s 18-month timeframe. Thus, if an application pending with the Secretary of State’s Office on January 1, 2017, is within the 18-month timeframe, that application will be reviewed using the rules contained in this bill. If a victim’s 18-month timeframe ends prior to the effective date of the bill, that application will be reviewed using the rules in effect before January 1, 2017.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 55 (Shelley, Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002) enacted the California Corporate Disclosure Act, created the compensation fund, and directed the Secretary of State to promulgate regulations regarding administration of the Fund and the eligibility of victims to receive compensation from the Fund.
SB 1058 (Lieu, Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012) codified a series of rules for victims seeking to apply to the Secretary of State for compensation from the fund, imposed a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials. Made additional changes intended to help facilitate the payment of money out of the fund to victims of corporate fraud.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in a potential increase in administrative costs, likely minor and absorbable, to revise and distribute forms and notices, process a greater number of claims for reimbursement against agents of corporations, and enforce and collect repayments to the compensation fund for claims paid on individual restitution orders. The bill will result in minor future reductions to claim payment amounts, which will no longer have interest applied to the outstanding award payment during the period that the compensation fund balance is insufficient to fully satisfy the award. The bill will result in a potentially significant to major increase in future payments made from the compensation fund. For every 10 to 20 claims paid at the $50,000 cap per claim, costs would be $0.5 million to $1 million. The compensation fund is projected to receive revenues of $1.7 million in FY 2016-17, with an ending reserve balance of $12.4 million. Annual payments out of the compensation fund have been in the range of $1.5 million to $1.8 million. The current level of fee revenues, in the absence of regular repayments to the compensation fund, will be insufficient to sustain future increases in payments from the fund. Repayments to the Secretary of State on claims paid from the compensation fund are rare, with no repayments provided over the last three years.
Crime Victims United of California
11 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
Department of Finance
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Crime Victims United of California “strongly supports closing the loophole with regard to those victims who are permitted to access the Fund. But for the fact that it was an individual within a corporation rather than the corporation itself that committed the fraudulent act(s) against the victim, they would have access to funds that could be critically important in helping to rebuild their lives. This is a common sense measure that will provide particular benefit for elderly victims who have relied on their savings for retirement and their golden years and who may not otherwise be able to cover their living expenses.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Prior to the August 17, 2016 amendments, the Department of Finance observed that “in recent cases where the award of attorney fees was granted, the attorney fees have increased the compensation fund award by an average of more than 400 percent. The addition of attorney fees, as specified in this bill, would significantly accelerate the depletion of the fund resulting in inordinate delays in the distribution of funds to the victims.” It is unknown whether the August 17, 2016 amendments will remove the Department’s opposition to the bill.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Eileen Newhall / B. & F.I. / (916) 651-4102
8/18/16 17:28:28
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2759
: 8/15/16
SENATE BANKING & F.I. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/15/16
AYES: Glazer, Vidak, Galgiani, Hall, Hueso, Lara, Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill authorizes victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (compensation fund) for fraudulent acts committed by an officer or director of a corporation, as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes the compensation fund within the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State, and provides that the fund exists for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud (Corporations Code Section 2280).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment, as defined, in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund (Corporations Code Section 2282).
- Prescribes a series of rules that must be followed by persons seeking to apply to the Secretary of State seeking payment from the fund and imposes a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials (Corporations Code Sections 2281 through 2288).
- Caps the liability of the fund at $50,000 per claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud (Corporations Code Section 2289).
- Provides that, if, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest, as specified, not to exceed 2% per year (Corporations Code Section 2290).
- Directs to the fund one-half of the $5 disclosure fee required to be paid by corporations when they file their annual Statements of Information with the Secretary of State (Corporations Code Sections 1502 and 2117).
This bill:
- Defines an agent for purposes of the compensation fund as a person who was an officer or director of a corporation at the time fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in his or her capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
- Amends the definition of a final judgment for purposes of the compensation fund to include a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation or agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, as specified (this bill adds the italicized language).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based on the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund, as specified (this bill adds the italicized language).
- Provides that nothing in the aforementioned provision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent.
- Adds to the documentation that must be provided by an applicant for compensation from the compensation fund by providing that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant must provide the charging document and restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, the claimant must also provide documentation showing that the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent, as defined.
- Provides that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner has the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent, as defined. Authorizes an active corporation, which has submitted a response to the application for restitution from the compensation fund, to appear in court in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent, as defined.
- Deletes the requirement for the state to pay interest on amounts awarded from the compensation fund, when money in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement.
- Makes conforming changes to other provisions of the compensation fund statutes.
Background
The compensation fund was created in 2002 (SB 55, Shelley, Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002) on the heels of the Enron scandal, but was largely untapped until 2011. Administrative changes implemented by the Secretary of State’s Office beginning in 2011, together with enactment of SB 1058 (Lieu, Chapter 564) in 2012, helped facilitate payment from the fund to victims. To date, the fund has paid out 603 claims, totaling $10.6 million. The following chart shows payouts from the fund during each of the past five calendar years, using data provided by the Secretary of State’s Office.
Year | Awards Paid To Victims |
2015 | $1,844,675 |
2014 | $3,894,450 |
2013 | $1,778,933 |
2012 | $2,445,807 |
2011 | $0 |
The fund receives approximately $1.7 million per year, through a $2.50 disclosure fee paid by for-profit corporations. The fund balance is currently $12 million.
Comments
This bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer or director, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer or director after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the compensation fund, in the same way a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation could do.
This bill contains language that requires the corporate officer to have engaged in the fraudulent acts while acting in his or her official capacity as a corporation’s officer or director. This language ensures consistency with the original intent of the compensation fund, and ensures that victims may not pursue restitution from the fund, if they are defrauded by someone who happens to be a corporate officer, but who was not acting in his or her official capacity as an officer or director of a corporation when perpetrating that fraud.
The Secretary of State’s office estimates that this bill will increase payments from the compensation fund by about 50%. This large increase reflects the fact that people, rather than corporations, are typically charged in cases involving corporate fraud. In Ponzi schemes, especially, the corporation is typically defunct by the time the case goes to trial. Attorneys who prosecute these types of cases assert that there is often no value in prosecuting the corporation, because it no longer exists; instead, they prosecute the people who ran the Ponzi scheme and served as the face of the corporation. Although these prosecutions can result in convictions, they rarely result in compensation being paid out from the compensation fund, because the corporations are rarely named in the restitution orders that stem from these convictions. This bill amends the law to more clearly reflect the entities that are prosecuted in connection with corporate fraud.
To Which Applications Will This Bill Apply? Under existing law, an application is not timely until a final judgment has been issued. Once a judgment becomes final, existing law also provides victims 18 months in which to submit their applications for restitution. According to the Secretary of State’s Office, this bill will apply to applications filed prospectively on and after the effective date of this bill and to applications that were filed prior to the effective date of this bill, but which are within the law’s 18-month timeframe. Thus, if an application pending with the Secretary of State’s Office on January 1, 2017, is within the 18-month timeframe, that application will be reviewed using the rules contained in this bill. If a victim’s 18-month timeframe ends prior to the effective date of the bill, that application will be reviewed using the rules in effect before January 1, 2017.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 55 (Shelley, Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002) enacted the California Corporate Disclosure Act, created the compensation fund, and directed the Secretary of State to promulgate regulations regarding administration of the Fund and the eligibility of victims to receive compensation from the Fund.
SB 1058 (Lieu, Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012) codified a series of rules for victims seeking to apply to the Secretary of State for compensation from the fund, imposed a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials. Made additional changes intended to help facilitate the payment of money out of the fund to victims of corporate fraud.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in a potential increase in administrative costs, likely minor and absorbable, to revise and distribute forms and notices, process a greater number of claims for reimbursement against agents of corporations, and enforce and collect repayments to the compensation fund for claims paid on individual restitution orders. The bill will result in minor future reductions to claim payment amounts, which will no longer have interest applied to the outstanding award payment during the period that the compensation fund balance is insufficient to fully satisfy the award. The bill will result in a potentially significant to major increase in future payments made from the compensation fund. For every 10 to 20 claims paid at the $50,000 cap per claim, costs would be $0.5 million to $1 million. The compensation fund is projected to receive revenues of $1.7 million in FY 2016-17, with an ending reserve balance of $12.4 million. Annual payments out of the compensation fund have been in the range of $1.5 million to $1.8 million. The current level of fee revenues, in the absence of regular repayments to the compensation fund, will be insufficient to sustain future increases in payments from the fund. Repayments to the Secretary of State on claims paid from the compensation fund are rare, with no repayments provided over the last three years.
Crime Victims United of California
11 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
Department of Finance
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Crime Victims United of California “strongly supports closing the loophole with regard to those victims who are permitted to access the Fund. But for the fact that it was an individual within a corporation rather than the corporation itself that committed the fraudulent act(s) against the victim, they would have access to funds that could be critically important in helping to rebuild their lives. This is a common sense measure that will provide particular benefit for elderly victims who have relied on their savings for retirement and their golden years and who may not otherwise be able to cover their living expenses.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Department of Finance observes that “in recent cases where the award of attorney fees was granted, the attorney fees have increased the compensation fund award by an average of more than 400 percent. The addition of attorney fees, as specified in this bill, would significantly accelerate the depletion of the fund resulting in inordinate delays in the distribution of funds to the victims.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
8/15/16 20:33:32
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2759 (Levine) - Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 11, 2016
Bill Summary:
AB 2759 would extend the authority of victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF), administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), beyond claims against a corporation to include fraudulent acts committed by an agent of a corporation, as well as attorney’s fees if ordered by a court in the final judgment, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Secretary of State: Potential increase in administrative costs, likely minor and absorbable (General Fund) to (1) revise and distribute forms and notices, (2) process a greater number of claims for reimbursement against agents of corporations, and, (3) enforce and collect repayments to the VCFCF for claims paid on individual restitution orders.
- VCFCF payments: Potentially significant to major increase in future payments made from the VCFCF due to extending compensation eligibility to include claims against agents of corporations. For every 10 to 20 claims paid at the $50,000 cap per claim, costs would be $0.5 million to $1 million (Special Fund*). The VCFCF is projected to receive revenues of $1.7 million in FY 2016-17, with an ending reserve balance of $12.4 million. Annual payments out of the VCFCF have been in the range of $1.5 million to $1.8 million. Staff notes the current level of fee revenues, in the absence of regular repayments to the VCFCF, will be insufficient to sustain future increases in payments from the VCFCF. Repayments to the SOS on claims paid from the VCFCF are rare, with no repayments provided over the last three years.
- Repeal of interest: Minor future reductions to VCFCF claim payment amounts that will no longer have interest applied to the outstanding award payment during the period that the VCFCF balance is insufficient to fully satisfy the award. To date, no interest has been assessed or paid on VCFCF payments.
*Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund
Committee Amendments:
With regard to the payment of attorney’s fees, deletes the following statement on page 4 in lines 27-29: “Additionally provides that the Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2759 (Levine) - Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: August 8, 2016 | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 2759 would extend the authority of victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF), administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), beyond claims against a corporation to include fraudulent acts committed by an agent of a corporation, as well as attorney’s fees if ordered by a court in the final judgment, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Secretary of State: Potential increase in administrative costs, likely minor and absorbable (General Fund) to (1) revise and distribute forms and notices, (2) process a greater number of claims for reimbursement against agents of corporations, and, (3) enforce and collect repayments to the VCFCF for claims paid on individual restitution orders.
- VCFCF payments: Potentially significant to major increase in future payments made from the VCFCF due to extending compensation eligibility to include claims against agents of corporations and the payment of attorney’s fees. For every 10 to 20 claims paid at the $50,000 cap per claim, costs would be $0.5 million to $1 million (Special Fund*). The VCFCF is projected to receive revenues of $1.7 million in FY 2016-17, with an ending reserve balance of $12.4 million. Annual payments out of the VCFCF have been in the range of $1.5 million to $1.8 million. Staff notes the current level of fee revenues, in the absence of regular repayments to the VCFCF, will be insufficient to sustain future increases in payments from the VCFCF. Repayments to the SOS on claims paid from the VCFCF are rare, with no repayments provided over the last three years. Additionally, authorizing payment for attorney’s fees, potentially retroactively, will place additional pressure on the VCFCF.
- Repeal of interest: Minor future reductions to VCFCF claim payment amounts that will no longer have interest applied to the outstanding award payment during the period that the VCFCF balance is insufficient to fully satisfy the award. To date, no interest has been assessed or paid on VCFCF payments.
*Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund
Background:
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF) within the State Treasury, which is administered by the SOS, for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of corporate fraud. Existing law requires foreign and domestic corporations to pay a $5 disclosure fee when filing specified statements with the SOS, one-half of which must be deposited into the VCFCF. (Corporations Code §§ 1502, 2117, 2280.)
Existing law provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final court judgment against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file a specified application with the SOS within 18 months after judgment has become final, for payment from the VCFCF for the amount unpaid on the judgment which represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages. (Corporations Code § 2282(a)-(c).)
Existing law caps the liability of the VCFCF at $50,000 per any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment qualified for recovery under the VCFCF, as specified, or the number of judgments against a corporation. (Corporations Code § 2289 (a).)
Under existing law, if, at any time, the money deposited in the VCFCF is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the SOS is required to, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest, not to exceed 2 percent per year. (Corporations Code § 2290.)
This bill seeks to allow victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the VCFCF for fraudulent acts committed by a corporation’s officer or director, as specified.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend the authority of victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the VCFCF beyond claims against a corporation to include fraudulent acts committed by an agent of a corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the SOS for payment from the compensation fund, as specified under existing law. This bill would also require further documentation, as follows:
- if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant must provide the charging document and the restitution order; and,
- if the defendant is an agent, the claimant must also provide documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill.
- Expands what constitutes a final judgment to also include a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against an agent of the corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to specified state or federal law.
- Provides that nothing in the applicable section is to be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent. Additionally provides that the Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
- Defines “agent” to mean a person who was an officer or director of a domestic or foreign corporation, as specified, at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts. This bill would also define “judgment debtor” for the purposes of these statutes.
- Repeals a requirement for the state to pay interest on amounts awarded from the VCFCF, when money in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement.
- Makes other clarifying or conforming changes to other provisions of the VCFCF statutes.
Related Legislation:
SB 1058 (Lieu) Chapter 564/2012 revises and recasts the provisions governing administration of the VCFCF by the SOS, by codifying certain existing regulations promulgated by the SOS to administer the VCFCF, codifying changes to other existing regulations promulgated by the SOS, and adding new statutory language to facilitate the approval of valid claims from the VCFCF.
AB 55 (Shelley) Chapter 1015/2002, among its numerous provisions, created the VCFCF within the State Treasury, for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of corporate fraud who have been otherwise unable to collect on their judgment.
Staff Comments:
The SOS has indicated the provisions of this bill could significantly reduce restitution funds available to claimants victimized by corporate fraud by authorizing attorney’s fees to be paid from the fund, placing additional pressure on funds intended to help provide relief to victims when corporate fraud occurs, potentially risking the sustainability of the fund.
Fees collected from SOS-registered business entities to support the existing fund are insufficient to award court-approved restitution for the actual victims themselves. While there is insufficient information to accurately estimate the overall fiscal impact of authorizing payment for attorney’s fees, the SOS notes that in recent cases involving the award of attorney’s fees, the fees have increased the VCFCF award by an average of more than 400 percent. The addition of attorney fees will significantly accelerate the depletion of the fund resulting in inordinate delays in the distribution of funds to the victims.
The SOS indicates that historically the VCFCF had not awarded attorney’s fees (until the court decision Kelly Morris v. The Office of the Secretary of State of the State of California, Case No. 34-2014-80001900, judgment October 2015). The reference in the bill stating the payment of attorney’s fees awarded by a court are declaratory of existing law may additionally invite claims for attorney’s fees in previously awarded cases creating a significant unintended fiscal impact on the VCFCF.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2759 (Author:Levine)
Version: June 16, 2016
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: RD
SUBJECT
Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund
DESCRIPTION
This bill would authorize victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the existing Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF), administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), for fraudulent acts committed by an agent of the corporation (as opposed to the corporation, itself) for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, as specified. For these purposes, “agent” would mean a person who was: (1) an officer or director of the corporation, as specified, at the time the fraudulent acts occurred; (2) named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts; and (3) acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
If restitution is sought from the VCFCF based upon a criminal restitution order and the defendant is an “agent,” this bill would add to the documentation that an applicant must provide to the SOS. Furthermore, in any appeal of a denial of an application that was based on a criminal restitution order against an agent of a corporation, the petitioner would have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an “agent,” and an active corporation would be permitted to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its “agent.” Lastly, this bill would specify that victims of corporate fraud may not recover attorney’s fees and would declare that this does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
BACKGROUND
AB 55 (Shelley, Ch. 1015, Stats. 2002), was enacted as part of the 2002 California Corporate Reform Package, a series of measures designed to strengthen the state’s corporate accountability laws. The bill, among other things, created the Victim of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (hereinafter “VCFCF,” or “fund”) within the State Treasury, for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of corporate fraud who have otherwise been unable to collect on their judgment. The bill also set the Secretary of State (SOS) in charge of administering the fund and adopting regulations regarding the administration of the fund and eligibility of victims to receive compensation. The Fund reportedly collects approximately $1.7 million a year from the $2.50 it receives of a $5 disclosure fee for statement filings by both out-of-state and in-state corporations.
In October of 2011, a Sacramento Bee article highlighted that the Fund was not doing what it was created to do—compensate victims of corporate fraud. (Dan Morain, Fraud victims fund is a travesty (Oct. 9, 2011).) The following year, in 2012, SB 1058 (Lieu, Ch. 564, Stats. 2012) was enacted to codify and streamline much of the administration and requirements of this program, while still allowing for the SOS to promulgate regulations in furtherance of the statutory requirements. In doing so, among other things, the bill established a 90 day deadline for a victim to receive a determination on their application, and increased the overall limit that may be recovered by a claimant for a single judgment to $50,000 from $20,000.
This bill now seeks to allow victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the VCFCF for fraudulent acts committed by a corporation’s officer or director, as specified.
This bill was heard in the Senate Banking & Financial Institutions Committee on June 15, 2016, and passed out on a vote of 7-0.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF or fund) within the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud. (Corp. Code Section 2280). Existing law requires foreign and domestic corporations to pay a $5 disclosure fee when filing specified statements with the SOS, one-half of which must be deposited into the VCFCF. (Corp. Code Secs. 1502, 2117.)
Existing law provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment, as defined, in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file a specified application with the SOS within 18 months after judgment has become final, for payment from the compensation fund, as specified, for the amount unpaid on the judgment which represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages. (Corp. Code Sec. 2282(a)-(c).).
Existing law prescribes a series of rules that must be followed by persons seeking to apply to the SOS seeking payment from the fund and imposes a series of requirements on the SOS regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials. (Corp. Code Secs. 2281-2288).
Existing law caps the liability of the VCFCF at $50,000 per any one claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, regardless of the number of persons aggrieved in an instance of corporate fraud, or misrepresentation or deceit resulting in a judgment qualified for recovery under the VCFCF, as specified, or the number of judgments against a corporation. (Corp. Code Sec. 2289(a).).
Existing law provides that, if, at any time, the money deposited in the VCFCF is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the SOS shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest, as specified, not to exceed 2 percent per year. (Corp. Code Sec. 2290.)
Existing law defines final judgment to mean a judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order for which appeals have been exhausted or for which the period for appeal has expired, enforcement of which is not barred by the order of any court or by any statutory provision, which has not been nullified or rendered void by any court order or statutory provision, and for which the claimant has not otherwise been fully reimbursed. Existing law provides certain examples of a final judgment, including, in relevant part, a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to specified state and federal law. An application for payment from the fund that is based on a criminal restitution order must comply with specified requirements. (Corp. Code Sec. 2281(f).)
This bill would expand the above example of a final judgment to provide that a final judgment also includes a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against an agent of the corporation for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to specified state or federal law.
This bill would add authority for a victim of corporate fraud to recover from the VCFCF based on a criminal restitution order against an agent of the corporation, just as a victim of corporate fraud could recover from the fund based on a final judgment against a corporation. Specifically, this bill would provide that, when an aggrieved person obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the SOS for payment from the compensation fund, as specified under existing law. This bill would also require further documentation, as follows:
- if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant must provide the charging document and the restitution order; and,
- if the defendant is an agent, the claimant must also provide documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill.
This bill would specify that nothing in the law above authorizing victims of corporate fraud to seek recovery from the fund based upon a final judgment or criminal restitution order against a corporation or an agent of the corporation, as specified, shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees. This bill would specify that the Legislature finds and declares that this prohibition against collection of attorney’s fees does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
This bill would provide that if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner (in an appeal upon denial of the claimant’s application) shall have the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined in this chapter. An active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application, as specified under existing law, may be permitted by the court to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent, as defined.
This bill would define “agent” to mean a person who was an officer or director of a domestic or foreign corporation, as specified, at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and was acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts. This bill would also define “judgment debtor” for the purposes of these statutes.
This bill would repeal a requirement for the state to pay interest on amounts awarded from the compensation fund, when money in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement.
This bill would make other clarifying or conforming changes to other provisions of the VCFCF statutes.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author, “[c]urrently the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund only allows for payment to victims who are victims of a corporation. This can be problematic given that in most cases it is an individual as opposed to an actual corporation that is charged and found guilty and ultimately restitution is ordered from. AB 2759 opens up for compensation from the [fund] to victims of an agent of a corporation as defined by the bill. [ . . .]”
2. Bill would ensure that more victims of corporate fraud can seek restitution from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund
As discussed in the Background, California law establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (VCFCF) to provide restitution to victims of corporate fraud who are unable to recover against a corporation against which they have received a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction (i.e. a California state or federal court). Specifically, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment, as defined, in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, California law authorizes the aggrieved person, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, to file a specified application with the Secretary of State (SOS) within 18 months after judgment has become final, for payment from the VCFCF, for the amount unpaid on the judgment which represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages. (Corp. Code Sec. 2282(a)-(c).).
This bill would now authorize victims of corporate fraud who have a final judgment against a corporate agent, but not the corporation itself, to seek recovery against the VCFCF as well. First, this bill would expand existing law, to recognize that a final judgment can include a criminal restitution order[1] issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against not only a corporation, but also against an agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, pursuant to specified state or federal law. The bill would then expressly authorize an aggrieved person who obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporate officer or director, to file an application with SOS for payment from the compensation fund, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made. The victim would have to file the application in largely the same manner and form as a victim who has a final judgment against the corporation, as well as some additional documentation supporting their final judgment against the agent, as discussed further below.
Under existing law, a victim of corporate fraud could potentially seek to reach the personal assets of directors of officers of a corporation by pursuing common law theories, such as alter ego liability or by piercing the corporate veil. They could also seek to recover against directors or officers for their own tortious conduct. To this end, while directors or officers do not incur personal liability for corporate torts merely because of their official position unless they participate in the wrong or authorize or direct that it be done, they are liable for their own tortious acts on behalf of the corporation. (5 Witkin Sum. Cal. Law Torts Sec. 33 (citations omitted).) Indeed, a corporate officer or director may be liable under the rules of tort and agency for their tortious acts committed on behalf of the corporation, whether or not the corporation is also liable. (15 Cal. Jur. Corporations Sec. 305.) A corporate officer or director is, in general, personally liable for all torts that he or she authorizes or directs or in which the officer or director participates notwithstanding that he or she acted as an agent of the corporation and not on his or her own behalf. Thus, one who directs and participates in a corporate tort may be personally liable for both compensatory and punitive damages even if he or she derives no personal gain from the act. Additionally, the rule that all persons participating in an intentional tort are liable for the full amount of damages suffered applies to intentional torts committed by those acting in their official capacities as officers or directors of a corporation even though the corporation is also liable. (Id.) Thus, to allow for recovery where a criminal restitution order has been obtained against an agent of a corporation, based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, would appear to be consistent with the underlying intent of the VCFCF, which allows for corporate fund victims to obtain restitution from the fund if the final judgment were against the corporation itself.
At the same time, this bill provides for reasonable measures to ensure that the SOS receives adequate documentation from which to make a determination to grant or deny an application. Under the bill, to receive compensation from the fund based on a final judgement that is a criminal restitution order and if the defendant is an agent, the claimant would have to provide the SOS with the charging document and the restitution order. If the defendant is an agent, the applicant must also provide the SOS documentation showing the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent as defined in this bill to mean an officer or director of a corporation at the time the fraudulent acts occurred, who was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts, and who was acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts. In doing so, the bill would, again, arguably stay true to the underlying purpose of the Fund being to help make whole as many victims of corporate fraud as possible, while also providing for reasonable protections to ensure that the SOS receives the documentation it needs to approve or deny an application and that the VCFCF provides restitution only where the misdeeds of the corporation are essentially attributable to the director or officer.
3. Burden would be on the claimant to prove the defendant named in a criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent upon appeal of an application
Under existing law, a claimant against whom the Secretary of State (SOS) has rendered a decision denying an application may, within six months after the mailing of the notice of the denial, file a verified petition in superior court for an Order Directing Payment Out of the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund based upon the grounds set forth in the application to the SOS. (Corp. Code Sec. 2287(a).) In such an action, existing law provides that the SOS may defend any action on behalf of the fund and shall have recourse to all appropriate means of defense and review, including examination of witnesses and the right to relitigate any issues that are material and relevant in the proceeding against the fund. However, the claimant's judgment creates a rebuttable presumption of the fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit by the corporation, which presumption shall affect the burden of producing evidence. (Corp. Code Sec. 2288(b).) That being said, if the civil judgment, arbitration award, or criminal restitution order in the underlying action on which the final judgment in favor of the petitioner was, for example, by default, stipulation, or consent, or if the action against the corporation was defended by a trustee in bankruptcy, existing law shifts the burden onto the petitioner to prove that the cause of action against the corporation was for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit. (Corp. Code Sec. 2288(b)(2).)
This bill would now add that in an appeal, above, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the claimant has the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent as defined by this bill to mean that the person was: (1) an officer or director of a corporation at the time the fraudulent acts occurred; (2) named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts; and (3) acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts. This bill would also grant the court the ability to permit an active corporation, that has submitted a response to the application as allowed under existing law, to appear in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent as defined in this bill. Arguably, these issues would have to have been resolved by the court in the first instance, for the victim to obtain the criminal restitution order against the director or officer to begin with, in light of the fact that a corporate director or officer does not incur personal liability for corporate torts merely because of their official position, unless they participate in the wrong or authorize or direct that it be done. (See Comment 3, above.)
4. Retroactive application of provision declaring attorney’s fees not included
In general, legislation is construed to be prospective unless the Legislature specifically states that it should be applied retroactively or is declaratory of existing law, as this bill would do with respect to a provision on attorney’s fees. Specifically, this bill would provide that nothing in the law or this bill authorizing victims of corporate fraud to seek recovery from the fund based upon a final judgment or criminal restitution order against a corporation or an agent of the corporation, as specified, shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees. At the same time, however, this bill would also declare that this prohibition against collection of attorney’s fees does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law. Staff notes, however, that existing law actually suggests that attorney’s fees could potentially be recovered, insofar as it authorizes an aggrieved person to apply “for the amount unpaid on the judgment [up to $50,000] that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages.” (See Corp. Code Sec. 2282 and 2289.) Feasibly, a prevailing victim could receive attorneys’ fees as costs pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which provides that upon motion, “a court may award attorneys’ fees to a successful party against one or more opposing parties in any action which has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest if: (a) a significant benefit, whether pecuniary or nonpecuniary, has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons, (b) the necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate, and (c) such fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any.” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1021.5.)
Staff notes that, indeed, it may be preferable to preserve existing law so that parties can receive attorneys’ fees where they are awarded pursuant to Section 1021.5, though, potentially, it could cause the VCFCF to deplete at a faster rate. At the minimum, however, as a matter of public policy, it is preferable to ensure that legislation apply prospectively, so as not to change the outcome of ongoing cases in favor of one party. In this case, while the bill would not change the outcome of the underlying litigation, if a victim were to attempt to recover the cost of their attorney fees from the fund as well, this bill could make what might have been a successful claim, unsuccessful if the application is made within 90 days of January 1, 2017 (as the SOS has 90 days to render a decision on an application). Accordingly, the following amendment is suggested to amend the provision to accurately reflect existing law:
Suggested amendment
On page 4, line 24-27, amend the bill to read:
(2) Nothing in this subdivision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees, unless they are ordered by a court in the final judgment against a corporation or a criminal restitution order against an agent. The Legislature finds and declares that this paragraph does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
5. Bill strikes provision authorizing interest
When this Committee heard SB 1058 (Lieu, Ch. 564, Stats. 2012; see Background), one of the issues was whether a claimant should be owed interest on an original award, if the money deposited in the Fund is insufficient to satisfy an approved award or offer of settlement. The author of that bill, having in large part modeled the bill’s provisions after the Department of Real Estate’s (DRE) Consumer Recovery Account, which provided for four percent interest under these same circumstances, originally required that the SOS pay the claimant an additional four percent interest per year, to be added to the original award or offer once the Fund is replenished. At the time, the SOS expressed concern that while the “DRE has the ability to transfer money from a related account and to administratively raise licensing fees if the balance in the fund falls below a certain level” and can therefore afford to provide a four percent interest rate, the VCFCF would be unable to sustain such accrual of interest. In contrast to the $2.50 per disclosure fee paid into the VCFCF by any corporation filing its statement with the SOS, the DRE could collect between $4 and $7 for their fund, depending on the type of licensee paying the fee.
Ultimately, recognizing the following competing interests at play, this Committee suggested a compromise whereby the claimant could recover interest at the rate set by the Federal Reserve Bank, as specified, at the time of the award or settlement offer, not to exceed 2 percent per year:
With the underlying purpose of the Fund being to help make whole as many victims of corporate fraud as possible, to a reasonable degree, public policy would favor a lower interest rate that is sustainable to the Fund. In other words, it would be to the detriment of other victims to cause further depletion of the Fund at a rate that outpaces the fees going into the Fund. At the same time, once an award is made or settlement is agreed upon to compensate a victim from the Fund, a victim is arguably harmed further by not having the award or settlement satisfied immediately. This is especially the case when the victim has been defrauded out of their life savings and the award or settlement is their only remaining lifeline to recovery. (Sen. Judiciary Com. analysis of SB 1058 (2011-2012 Reg. Session) Apr. 24, 2012, p. 9.)
This bill would now strike the language allowing for the claimant to recover interest in addition to their original award, if the Fund was depleted at the time of their award.
Support: Crime Victims United of California; three individuals
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
SB 1058 (Lieu, Ch. 564, Stats. 2012) See Background.
AB 55 (Shelley, Ch. 1015, Stats. 2002) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 80, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 20, Noes 0)
Assembly Banking and Finance Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
A criminal restitution order is an order by a court, as part of a sentence in a criminal case, ordering a defendant to compensate the victim for losses suffered as a result of the crime. All states have laws providing that convicted defendants pay restitution to their victims. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BANKING AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 15, 2016
Author: | |||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
SUMMARY
Authorizes victims of corporate fraud to pursue compensation from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (compensation fund) for fraudulent acts committed by an officer or director of a corporation, as specified.
DESCRIPTION
- Defines an agent for purposes of the compensation fund as a person who was an officer or director of a corporation at the time fraudulent acts occurred and who was acting in the person’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director when committing the fraudulent acts.
- Amends the definition of a final judgment for purposes of the compensation fund to include a criminal restitution order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation or agent of the corporation, for fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, with the intent to defraud, as specified (this bill would add the italicized language).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based on the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, or obtains a criminal restitution order against an agent based upon the agent’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud while acting in the agent’s capacity as the corporation’s officer or director, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund, as specified (this bill would add the italicized language).
- Provides that nothing in the aforementioned provision shall be interpreted to authorize the collection of attorney’s fees, and includes legislative findings that this clarification does not constitute a change in, but rather is declaratory of, existing law.
- Adds to the documentation that must be provided by an applicant for compensation from the compensation fund by providing that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order, the claimant must provide the charging document and restitution order, and if the defendant is an agent, the claimant must also provide documentation showing that the defendant named in the restitution order is an agent, as defined.
- Provides that, if the final judgment is a criminal restitution order against an agent, the petitioner has the burden of proving that the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as an agent, as defined. Authorizes an active corporation, which has submitted a response to the application for restitution from the compensation fund, to appear in court in the action regarding the sole issue of whether the defendant named in the criminal restitution order qualifies as its agent, as defined.
- Deletes the requirement for the state to pay interest on amounts awarded from the compensation fund, when money in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement.
- Makes conforming changes to other provisions of the compensation fund statutes.
EXISTING LAW
- Establishes the compensation fund within the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State, and provides that the fund exists for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud (Corporations Code Section 2280).
- Provides that, when an aggrieved person obtains a final judgment, as defined, in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person may, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the compensation fund (Corporations Code Section 2282).
- Prescribes a series of rules that must be followed by persons seeking to apply to the Secretary of State seeking payment from the fund and imposes a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials (Corporations Code Sections 2281 through 2288).
- Caps the liability of the fund at $50,000 per claimant per single judgment finding fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud (Corporations Code Section 2289).
- Provides that, if, at any time, the money deposited in the fund is insufficient to satisfy any duly authorized award or offer of settlement, the Secretary of State shall, when sufficient money has been deposited in the fund, satisfy the unpaid awards or offer of settlement, in the order that the awards or offers of settlement were originally filed, plus accumulated interest, as specified, not to exceed 2% per year (Corporations Code Section 2290).
- Directs to the fund one-half of the $5 disclosure fee required to be paid by corporations when they file their annual Statements of Information with the Secretary of State (Corporations Code Sections 1502 and 2117).
COMMENTS
- Purpose: This bill is intended to expand access to the compensation fund by victims of corporate fraud, by authorizing the fund to be used to compensate victims of corporate fraud that is perpetrated by an officer or director of a corporation, who was acting in his or her official capacity as officer or director when committing that fraud.
- Background: The compensation fund was created in 2002 (SB 55, Shelley, Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002) on the heels of the Enron scandal, but was largely untapped until 2011. Administrative changes implemented by the Secretary of State’s Office beginning in 2011, together with enactment of SB 1058 (Lieu) in 2012, helped facilitate payment from the fund to victims. To date, the fund has paid out 603 claims, totaling $10.6 million. The following chart shows payouts from the fund during each of the past five calendar years, using data provided by the Secretary of State’s Office.
Year | Awards Paid To Victims |
2015 | $1,844,675 |
2014 | $3,894,450 |
2013 | $1,778,933 |
2012 | $2,445,807 |
2011 | $0 |
The fund receives approximately $1.7 million per year, through a $2.50 disclosure fee paid by for-profit corporations. The fund balance is currently $12 million.
- Discussion: This bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer or director, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer or director after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the compensation fund, in the same way a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation could do.
The bill contains language that requires the corporate officer to have engaged in the fraudulent acts while acting in his or her official capacity as a corporation’s officer or director. This language ensures consistency with the original intent of the compensation fund, and ensures that victims may not pursue restitution from the fund, if they are defrauded by someone who happens to be a corporate officer, but who was not acting in his or her official capacity as an officer or director of a corporation when perpetrating that fraud.
The Secretary of State’s office estimates that this bill will increase payments from the compensation fund by about 50%. This large increase reflects the fact that people, rather than corporations, are typically charged in cases involving corporate fraud. In Ponzi schemes, especially, the corporation is typically defunct by the time the case goes to trial. Attorneys who prosecute these types of cases assert that there is often no value in prosecuting the corporation, because it no longer exists; instead, they prosecute the people who ran the Ponzi scheme and served as the face of the corporation. Although these prosecutions can result in convictions, they rarely result in compensation being paid out from the compensation fund, because the corporations are rarely named in the restitution orders that stem from these convictions. This bill amends the law to more clearly reflect the entities that are prosecuted in connection with corporate fraud. - To Which Applications Will This Bill Apply? Under existing law, an application is not timely until a final judgment has been issued. Once a judgment becomes final, existing law also provides victims 18 months in which to submit their applications for restitution. According to the Secretary of State’s Office, this bill will apply to applications filed prospectively on and after the effective date of this bill and to applications that were filed prior to the effective date of this bill, but which are within the law’s 18-month timeframe. Thus, if an application pending with the Secretary of State’s Office on January 1, 2017 is within the 18-month timeframe, that application will be reviewed using the rules contained in this bill. If a victim’s 18-month timeframe ends prior to the effective date of the bill, that application will be reviewed using the rules in effect before January 1, 2017.
- Summary of Arguments in Support: Crime Victims United of California and three private individuals support the bill, because it will allow people who have been defrauded by corporate officers, and who are currently ineligible to see restitution from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, to apply for restitution.
- Summary of Arguments in Opposition: None received.
- Amendments:
- The author’s office has agreed to the following technical amendment:
Page 2, line 6, after “occurred” insert a comma and the following: was named in a final criminal restitution order in connection with the fraudulent acts,
- The author’s office has agreed to the following technical amendment:
- Prior and Related Legislation:
- AB 55 (Shelley), Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002: Enacted the California Corporate Disclosure Act, created the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, and directed the Secretary of State to promulgate regulations regarding administration of the Fund and the eligibility of victims to receive compensation from the Fund.
- SB 1058 (Lieu), Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012: Codified a series of rules for victims seeking to apply to the Secretary of State for compensation from the fund, imposed a series of requirements on the Secretary of State regarding the steps he or she must take once an application for payment from the fund is submitted; the timeframes within which he or she must render a final written decision; and the steps that may be taken by claimants whose applications for payment from the fund are denied, and who wish to appeal those denials. Made additional changes intended to help facilitate the payment of money out of the fund to victims of corporate fraud.
- AB 55 (Shelley), Chapter 1015, Statutes of 2002: Enacted the California Corporate Disclosure Act, created the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund, and directed the Secretary of State to promulgate regulations regarding administration of the Fund and the eligibility of victims to receive compensation from the Fund.
LIST OF REGISTERED SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Support
Crime Victims United of California
Three private individuals
Opposition
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2759
Author:(Levine)
As Amended Ver:May 27, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 10-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Weber, Holden, Maienschein, Ting | |
Banking | 11-0 | Dababneh, Travis Allen, Achadjian, Bonilla, Brown, Chau, Gatto, Kim, Low, Ridley-Thomas, Mark Stone | |
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY: Seeks to compensate victims of corporate fraud committed by corporate officers from the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the Fund as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do.
- Specifies that attorney fees are not costs that can be recovered from the Fund and declares that the limitation on attorney fees is declaratory of existing law.
- Eliminates the requirement in existing law that the Fund must pay interest to a claimant on an unpaid claim in the event that it does not have enough money to pay a claim when it is initially submitted for payment.
- Defines relevant terms.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriation committee, expanding the type of claims eligible against the Fund will result in unknown additional expenditures. Estimated fund expenditures in 2016-17 are $1.5 million. Additional valid claims would likely increase expenditures by several hundred thousand dollars annually. According to the Secretary of State (SOS), the Fund had a balance of $11.9 million as of January 2016.
COMMENTS: According to the Secretary of State's Office, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund had a balance of approximately $11,900,000 as of January 2016. According to information provided by the author:
The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has not received any applications based upon a criminal restitution order against AGA Financial Inc. However, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has received numerous claims based upon four criminal restitution orders naming James Koenig and Asset Real Estate and Investment Company in a related criminal proceeding. The first three criminal restitution orders named victims who testified at trial. Administrative review has been completed for all of the submitted Applications based upon the first three restitution orders and the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has paid out more than $1.1 million dollars to victims named in the three orders.
The court issued its fourth restitution order, on June 24, 2015, naming victims who had not testified at trial. The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund received nearly 300 claims based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order. Unfortunately, James Koenig has filed a Notice of Appeal with respect to the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order which is still pending. California Corporations Code sections 2281(f) and 2282(a) preclude the payment of claims while an appeal is pending. Therefore, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Fund is statutorily precluded from awarding applications based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order until the appeal has run its course.
Statement of the Author. According to the author:
We know that there are victims of corporate fraud that are unable to access the victims of corporate fraud compensation fund. That is because to access the fund an individual must have been a victim of a corporation that has been convicted. Very rarely are corporations charged with crimes almost always it is an individual who is charged with a crime. AB 2759 will correct this problem and allow many individuals who should have access to the fund access.
Access to the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund. If a plaintiff successfully obtained a judgment against an officer of a corporation based upon the tortious act by the officer him or herself; the act of the officer on behalf of the corporation; or the act of the officer violated the "Responsible Corporate Officer Doctrine," the plaintiff's theory of liability would be based upon misdeeds of the corporation that are attributable to the officer (and vice versa). It therefore seems reasonable to provide such a plaintiff with the same remedies available to a plaintiff who obtains a judgment against the corporation itself.
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003146
Date of Hearing: May 4, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2759
Author:(Levine) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
Banking and Finance | 11 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer, to collect damages from the Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund) as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation is currently able to do.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Expanding the type of claims eligible against the Fund will result in unknown additional expenditures. Estimated fund expenditures in 2016-17 are $1.5 million. Additional valid claims would likely increase expenditures by several hundred thousand dollars annually. According to the SOS, the Fund had a balance of $11.9 million as of January 2016.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund), which is administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), provides a measure of relief to persons who have been victims of corporate fraud and won a judgment against a corporation, but who are unable to collect the judgment from the corporation after diligent efforts to do so. The Fund, which was established through legislation in 2002, is funded by fees on corporate filings. In SB 1058 (Lieu), Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012, codified, with some modifications, the rules governing the process of filing claims, recovering restitution, and challenging denials as promulgated by the SOS. SB 1058 also increased the maximum amount that one claimant may recover for any single judgment from $20,000 to $50,000.
- Purpose. This bill allows a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment, to collect damages from the Fund, just as is currently provided to a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud. This proposal is based on the reality that few victims of corporate fraud are able to obtain judgments against corporations, and that there are few claims made against the Fund. As a result, the Fund is not adequately serving its intended purpose. This bill would allow more victims of corporate fraud to access the funds for which they are intended.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Matthew Dababneh, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2759 (
Author:Levine) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2016
SUBJECT: Corporations: agents: victims of corporate fraud compensation fund
SUMMARY: Seeks to compensate victims of corporate fraud committed by corporate officers. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund) as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Fund in the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State (SOS) for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud. (Corporations Code Section 2280. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Requires the SOS to adopt regulations in furtherance of the administration of the Fund. (Ibid.)
- Allows an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person to, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the SOS for payment from the Fund. (Section 2282 (a).)
- Limits the amount of recovery by a person described in 3), above, to the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages. (Section 2282 (a).)
- Raises money for the Fund by directing one-half of the five dollar disclosure fee required to be paid by corporations when they file their annual Statements of Information with the SOS. (Sections 1502 and 2117.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Currently, the Fund is structured by statute to provide relief to victims of corporate malfeasance when the convicted entity is a corporation. In cases where an individual, acting in their capacity of an agent of the corporation is convicted of fraud the victim is unable to access the Fund because it is limited to corporations, and not individuals. For example, the CEO of AGA Financial and two accomplices were convicted of running the largest Ponzi scheme in California history. The many victims of the fraud perpetrated by AGA Financial are unable to get relief from the Fund because the individual officers of AGA were convicted, not the corporation.
In 2002, in response to well-publicized scandals involving Enron and other corporations, the Legislature created the Fund. (See AB 55 (Shelley (Chap. 1015, Stats. of 2002).) The purpose was to help innocent victims of corporate fraud who had won judgments but were unable to collect judgment, either because the corporation was bankrupt, had disappeared, or was otherwise unable or unwilling to pay up. The Fund was financed by a fee on corporate filings, held in the State Treasury, and administered by and pursuant to rules promulgated by the SOS. In order to collect money from the Fund, the victim must have won a judgment and been unable to collect from the corporation despite diligent efforts to do so.
In 2012, the Legislature updated and revised the law regarding the Fund, codifying the SOS regulations in SB 1058 (Lieu-Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012). SB 1058 also sought to improve the claim process to make it more likely that valid claims would be compensated. Among other things, SB 1058 established a new deadline of 90 days for a victim to receive a determination; increased the recovery cap for a single applicant from $20,000 to $50,000; and restricted the ability of the fraudulent corporation to contest payments or block appeals by prohibiting consideration of issues and fact already established by the judgment.
According to the SOS, the Fund had a balance of approximately $11,900,000 as of January 2016. According to information provided by the author:
The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has not received any applications based upon a criminal restitution order against AGA Financial Inc. However, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has received numerous claims based upon four criminal restitution orders naming James Koenig and Asset Real Estate and Investment Company in a related criminal proceeding. The first three criminal restitution orders named victims who testified at trial. Administrative review has been completed for all of the submitted Applications based upon the first three restitution orders and the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has paid out more than $1.1 million dollars to victims named in the three orders.
The court issued its fourth restitution order, on June 24, 2015, naming victims who had not testified at trial. The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund received nearly 300 claims based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order. Unfortunately, James Koenig has filed a Notice of Appeal with respect to the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order which is still pending. California Corporations Code sections 2281(f) and 2282(a) preclude the payment of claims while an appeal is pending. Therefore, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Fund is statutorily precluded from awarding applications based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order until the appeal has run its course.
According to the author:
We know that there are victims of corporate fraud that are unable to access the victims of corporate fraud compensation fund. That is because to access the fund an individual must have been a victim of a corporation that has been convicted. Very rarely are corporations charged with crimes almost always it is an individual who is charged with a crime. AB 2759 will correct this problem and allow many individuals who should have access to the fund access.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
5 Individuals
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Farouk / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
Date of Hearing: April 5, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2759
Author:(Levine) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2016
SUBJECT: CORPORATIONS: AGENTS: VICTIMS OF CORPORATE FRAUD COMPENSATION FUND
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD An individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, BE SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED to collect damages from the Fund as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do?
SYNOPSIS
The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund), which is administered by the Secretary of State (SOS), provides a measure of relief to persons who have been victims of corporate fraud and won a judgment against a corporation, but who are unable to collect the judgment from the corporation after diligent efforts to do so. The Fund – which is funded by fees on corporate filings – was created by the Legislature in 2002 amidst well-publicized examples of fraud, malfeasance and other forms of corporate shenanigans. The rules governing the process of filing claims, recovering restitution, and challenging denials are promulgated by the SOS. In 2012, the SOS regulation were effectively codified by SB 1058 (Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012), which also modified some rules to facilitate recovery on valid claims. Among other things SB 1058 streamlined the deadlines for responding to a claimant, including requiring the SOS to render a final decision on the claim within 90 days of receipt of a completed application. SB 1058 also increased the maximum amount that one claimant may recover for any single judgment from $20,000 to $50,000.
This bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the Fund as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do. This proposed change in the law is based upon the reality that few victims of corporate fraud are able to obtain judgments against corporations, and that there are few claims made against the Fund. As a result, the Fund is not adequately serving its intended purpose. This bill would allow more victims of corporate fraud to access the funds for which they are intended. This author-sponsored has no support or opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Seeks to compensate victims of corporate fraud committed by corporate officers. Specifically, this bill allows an individual who is a victim of corporate fraud and who wins a judgment against a corporate officer, but is unable to collect the judgment from the officer after diligent efforts to do so, to collect damages from the Fund as a similarly situated victim of corporate fraud with a judgment against a corporation would be able to do.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund (Fund) in the State Treasury, administered by the Secretary of State for the sole purpose of providing restitution to the victims of a corporate fraud. (Corporations Code Section 2280. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Requires the Secretary of State to adopt regulations in furtherance of the administration of the Fund. (Ibid.)
- Allows an aggrieved person who obtains a final judgment in a court of competent jurisdiction against a corporation based upon the corporation’s fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, made with intent to defraud, the aggrieved person to, upon the judgment becoming final and after diligent collection efforts are made, file an application with the Secretary of State for payment from the Fund. (Section 2282 (a).)
- Limits the amount of recovery by a person described in 3), above, to the amount unpaid on the judgment that represents the awarded actual and direct loss, any awarded compensatory damages, and awarded costs to the claimant in the final judgment, excluding punitive damages. (Section 2282 (a).)
- Raises money for the Fund by directing one-half of the five dollar disclosure fee required to be paid by corporations when they file their annual Statements of Information with the SOS. (Sections 1502 and 2117.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 2002, in response to well-publicized scandals involving Enron and other corporations, the Legislature created the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund. (See AB 55 (Shelley (Chap. 1015, Stats. of 2002).) The purpose was to help innocent victims of corporate fraud who had won judgments but were unable to collect judgment, either because the corporation was bankrupt, had disappeared, or was otherwise unable or unwilling to pay up. The Fund was financed by a fee on corporate filings, held in the State Treasury, and administered by and pursuant to rules promulgated by the Secretary of State (SOS). In order to collect money from the fund, the victim must have won a judgment and been unable to collect from the corporation despite diligent efforts to do so.
In 2012, the Legislature updated and revised the law regarding the Fund, codifying the SOS regulations in SB 1058 (Chapter 564, Statutes of 2012). SB 1058 also sought to improve the claim process to make it more likely that valid claims would be compensated. Among other things, SB 1058 established a new deadline of 90 days for a victim to receive a determination; increased the recovery cap for a single applicant from $20,000 to $50,000; and restricted the ability of the fraudulent corporation to contest payments or block appeals by prohibiting consideration of issues and fact already established by the judgment.
One of the justifications for enacting SB 1058 was the fact that the Fund was underutilized. According to the Committee’s analysis of SB 1058:
Reports suggesting that the Fund is severely underutilized lend support to the author's effort to improve and facilitate the claim restitution process. As reported by the Sacramento Bee as of early October of 2011, the fund continues to collect money but apparently benefits relatively few claimants. According the Bee, more than 700 valid applicants – i.e., those who have already won a judgment from a court – have applied for restitution from the Fund. But as of April of this year no more than 10 – and perhaps as few as seven – claims have been paid out. Although it is not entirely clear why this is so, the Bee concluded that one factor is an overly burdensome and repetitious application process.
It was believed, at the time when SB 1058 was pending, that the Fund would be utilized more frequently if there were fewer procedural obstacles for victims of corporate fraud to access the Fund. According to this Committee’s analysis of SB 1058:
[T]he Secretary of State – who is charged with administering the program and promulgating rules – ‘acknowledges the fund is not running as intended.’ In fact, the Bee reported, the fund was so underused that in 2010 then-Governor Schwarzenegger and the Legislature borrowed $10 million from the fund to help balance the budget. (Sacramento Bee April 11, 2012; see also Dan Morain, "Fraud Victims Fund is a Travesty," Sacramento Bee October 9, 2011.)
Current Condition of the Fund. According to the Secretary of State’s Office, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund had a balance of approximately $11,900,000 as of January 2016. According to information provided by the author:
The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has not received any applications based upon a criminal restitution order against AGA Financial Inc. However, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has received numerous claims based upon four criminal restitution orders naming James Koenig and Asset Real Estate and Investment Company in a related criminal proceeding. The first three criminal restitution orders named victims who testified at trial. Administrative review has been completed for all of the submitted Applications based upon the first three restitution orders and the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund has paid out more than $1.1 million dollars to victims named in the three orders.
The court issued its fourth restitution order, on June 24, 2015, naming victims who had not testified at trial. The Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund received nearly 300 claims based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order. Unfortunately, James Koenig has filed a Notice of Appeal with respect to the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order which is still pending. California Corporations Code sections 2281(f) and 2282(a) preclude the payment of claims while an appeal is pending. Therefore, the Victims of Corporate Fraud Fund is statutorily precluded from awarding applications based upon the June 24, 2015 criminal restitution order until the appeal has run its course.
Statement of the Author. According to the author:
We know that there are victims of corporate fraud that are unable to access the victims of corporate fraud compensation fund. That is because to access the fund an individual must have been a victim of a corporation that has been convicted. Very rarely are corporations charged with crimes almost always it is an individual who is charged with a crime. AB 2759 will correct this problem and allow many individuals who should have access to the fund access.
Three Theories for Holding Agents and Officers Liable for Unlawful Acts: 1) “Tortious Act by Officer.” Directors and officers of a corporation are liable to the corporation (and to third party victims, including stockholders) “for losses resulting from their malfeasance, misfeasance, or their failure or neglect to discharge the duties imposed by their offices.” (15 Cal. Jur. (3d ed. 2012) Corporations, sec. 302, p. 478.)
2) “Piercing the Corporate Veil.” A corporation is a legal entity distinct from its owners that provides legal protection to its owners and officers from personal liability for its obligations. However, there are some circumstances when courts will hold that the shareholders, officers, and directors are personally liable for corporate obligations because the corporation is abusing its privilege of conducting business in the corporate form. In those circumstances, the protective “veil” of the corporation is pierced, resulting in personal liability to directors and officers. In order to pierce the corporate veil, the following two requirements generally must be satisfied:
(1) that there be such unity of interest and ownership that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individual no longer exist and (2) that, if the acts are treated as those of the corporation alone, an inequitable result will follow. (Automotriz del Golfo de California S. A. de C. v. v. Resnick (1957) 47 Cal.2d 792, 796 [306 P.2d 1].)
3) “Responsible Corporate Officer Doctrine.” The responsible corporate officer doctrine was developed by the United States Supreme Court to hold corporate officers in responsible positions of authority personally liable for violating strict liability statutes protecting the public welfare. (Hustis & Gotanda, The Responsible Corporate Officer: Designated Felon or Legal Fiction? (1994) 25 Loy. U. Chi. L.J. 169, 176.) It is a common law theory of liability separate from piercing the corporate veil or imposing personal liability for direct participation in tortious conduct. In United States v. Dotterweich (1943) 320 U.S. 277, the Supreme Court addressed whether the president/general manager of a corporation, as well as the corporation itself, could be liable under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. § 301 et seq.; the Act), which imposed criminal liability on “[a]ny person” who shipped adulterated or misbranded drugs in interstate commerce. (Dotterweich, supra, 320 U.S. at p. 278.) The Court focused on two facts: (1) The Act was public welfare legislation; and (2) the Act imposed strict liability for a violation. (Id., at pp. 280–281.)
In United States v. Park (1975) 421 U.S. 658, 832, the Supreme Court further defined the scope of the responsible corporate officer doctrine. In that case, the chief executive officer of a national corporation was found liable under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act for unsafe storage of food that was contaminated by rodents. Finding he was liable, the Court enunciated the following standard for corporate officer liability under the Act:
[T]he Government establishes a prima facie case when it introduces evidence sufficient to warrant a finding by the trier of the facts that the defendant had, by reason of his position in the corporation, responsibility and authority either to prevent in the first instance, or promptly to correct, the violation complained of, and that he failed to do so. The failure thus to fulfill the duty imposed by the interaction of the corporate agent's authority and the statute furnishes a sufficient causal link. The considerations which prompted the imposition of this duty, and the scope of the duty, provide the measure of culpability. (Park, supra, 421 U.S. at p. 660.)
In the years following Dotterweich and Park, lower federal courts have applied the responsible corporate officer doctrine to other federal statutes, including the Clean Water Act (U.S. v. Iverson (9th Cir. 1998) 162 F.3d 1015, 1024) and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 (United States v. Johnson & Towers, Inc. (3d Cir. 1984) 741 F.2d 662, 666–667). Similarly, state courts have applied the doctrine to state statutes, including California's Hazardous Waste Control Act (People v. Matthews (1992) 7 Cal.App.4th 1052, 1057–1062) (People v. Roscoe (2008) 169 Cal.App.4th 829, 835-837).)
Access to the Victims of Corporate Fraud Compensation Fund. If a plaintiff successfully obtained a judgment against an officer of a corporation based upon any of the above theories – the tortious act by the officer him or herself; the act of the officer on behalf of the corporation; or the act of the officer violated the “Responsible Corporate Officer Doctrine,”- the plaintiff’s theory of liability would be based upon misdeeds of the corporation that are attributable to the officer (and vice versa). It therefore seems reasonable to provide such a plaintiff with the same remedies available to a plaintiff who obtains a judgment against the corporation itself.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):