AB 2818: Property taxation: community land trust.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-27
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would require the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, a contract that is a 99-year ground lease between a community land trust, as defined, and the qualified owner, as defined, of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and that subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions, as defined.
By changing the manner in which county assessors assess property for property taxation purposes, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would require the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, a contract that is a 99-year ground lease between a community land trust, as defined, and the qualified owner, as defined, of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and that subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions, as defined.
By changing the manner in which county assessors assess property for property taxation purposes, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would require the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, a contract that is a 99-year ground lease between a community land trust, as defined, and the qualified owner, as defined, of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and that subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions, as defined.
By changing the manner in which county assessors assess property for property taxation purposes, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would require the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, a recorded instrument that contract that is a 99-year ground lease between a community land trust, as defined, and the qualified owner, as defined, of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and that subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, to affordability restrictions, including, among others, a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust, as defined, intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income. unit, to affordability restrictions, as defined.
By changing the manner in which county assessors assess property for property taxation purposes, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
This bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would also require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
Existing property tax law, in accordance with the California Constitution, provides for a welfare exemption for property used exclusively for religious, hospital, scientific, or charitable purposes and that is owned or operated by certain types of nonprofit entities, if certain qualifying criteria are met.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2017, would provide that property is within the welfare exemption if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for the welfare exemption, that has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which specified conditions apply. The bill, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, would prohibit this exemption from being denied on the basis that the subject property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence as so described or a single-family or multifamily residence as so described that is in the course of construction. The bill would require the exemption to apply to a property for no more than 5 years from the date any of certain restrictions are recorded against the property.
This bill would require the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, a recorded instrument that subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, to affordability restrictions, including, among others, a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust, as defined, intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
By imposing new duties upon local government officials, changing the manner in which county assessors assess property for property taxation purposes, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
This bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would also require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
Existing property tax law, in accordance with the California Constitution, provides for a welfare exemption for property used exclusively for religious, hospital, scientific, or charitable purposes and that is owned or operated by certain types of nonprofit entities, if certain qualifying criteria are met.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2017, would provide that property is within the welfare exemption if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for the welfare exemption, that has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which specified conditions apply. The bill, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, would prohibit this exemption from being denied on the basis that the subject property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence as so described or a single-family or multifamily residence as so described that is in the course of construction. The bill would require the exemption to apply to a property for no more than 5 years from the date any of certain restrictions are recorded against the property.
By imposing new duties upon local government officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would prohibit the county assessor, when valuing bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling dwelling, and the land on which it the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, if the dwelling or unit is on land leased to the owner by a community land trust, as defined, from valuing the dwelling or unit and the land at any value greater than the purchase price for that dwelling or unit. The bill would apply this prohibition only to a dwelling or unit and land that is owned and occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income, as defined. unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
This bill, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, in assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, would also require the value of the dwelling or unit and the land to be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
Existing property tax law, in accordance with the California Constitution, provides for a welfare exemption for property used exclusively for religious, hospital, scientific, or charitable purposes and that is owned or operated by certain types of nonprofit entities, if certain qualifying criteria are met.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2017, would provide that property is within the welfare exemption if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for the welfare exemption, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which specified conditions apply. This The bill, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, would prohibit this exemption from being denied on the basis that the subject property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence as so described or a single-family or multifamily residence as so described that is in the course of construction. The bill would require the exemption to apply to a property for no more than 5 years from the date any of certain restrictions are recorded against the property.
By imposing new duties upon local government officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that provision.
This bill would prohibit the county assessor, when valuing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and the land on which it is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, if the dwelling or unit is on land leased to the owner by a community land trust, as defined, from valuing the dwelling or unit and the land at any value greater than the purchase price for that dwelling or unit. The bill would apply this prohibition only to a dwelling or unit and land that is owned and occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income, as defined.
Existing property tax law, in accordance with the California Constitution, provides for a welfare exemption for property used exclusively for religious, hospital, scientific, or charitable purposes and that is owned or operated by certain types of nonprofit entities, if certain qualifying criteria are met.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2017, would provide that property is within the welfare exemption if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for the welfare exemption, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of creating and maintaining permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which specified conditions apply. This bill, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, would prohibit this exemption from being denied on the basis that the subject property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence as so described or a single-family or multifamily residence as so described that is in the course of construction.
By imposing new duties upon local government officials, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code requires the Legislature to reimburse local agencies annually for certain property tax revenues lost as a result of any exemption or classification of property for purposes of ad valorem property taxation.
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing law requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected, including, but not limited to, zoning, recorded contracts with governmental agencies, and various other restrictions imposed by governments.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that provision.
(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(11)(A)A contract where the following apply:
(i)The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling.
(ii)The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
(iii)One of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the affordability restrictions in the contract serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(I)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(II)The county counsel.
(III)The director of a county housing department.
(IV)The city attorney.
(V)The director of a city housing department.
(iv)The contract is recorded and is provided to the assessor.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(i)Affordability restrictions mean that all of the following conditions are met:(I)The dwelling or unit can only be sold or resold to a qualified owner to be occupied as a principal place of residence.(II)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to qualified owners.(III)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.(IV)The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to qualified owners by a renewable 99-year ground lease.(ii)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that satisfies all of the following:(I)Has as its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.(II)All dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owners primary residence or rented to persons and families of low or moderate income.(III)The land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.(iii)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.(iv)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.(v)Qualified owner means persons and families of low or moderate income, including persons and families of low or moderate income that own a dwelling or unit collectively as member occupants or resident shareholders of a limited equity housing cooperative.(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(11)(A)A contract where the following apply:
(i)The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling.
(ii)The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
(iii)One of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the affordability restrictions in the contract serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(I)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(II)The county counsel.
(III)The director of a county housing department.
(IV)The city attorney.
(V)The director of a city housing department.
(iv)The contract is recorded and is provided to the assessor.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(i)Affordability restrictions mean that all of the following conditions are met:(I)The dwelling or unit can only be sold or resold to a qualified owner to be occupied as a principal place of residence.(II)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to qualified owners.(III)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.(IV)The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to qualified owners by a renewable 99-year ground lease.(ii)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that satisfies all of the following:(I)Has as its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.(II)All dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owners primary residence or rented to persons and families of low or moderate income.(III)The land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.(iii)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.(iv)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.(v)Qualified owner means persons and families of low or moderate income, including persons and families of low or moderate income that own a dwelling or unit collectively as member occupants or resident shareholders of a limited equity housing cooperative.(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(11)(A)A contract where the following apply:
(A)
(i)The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling.
(B)
(ii)The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
(C)
(iii)One of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the affordability restrictions in the contract serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)
(I)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)
(II)The county counsel.
(iii)
(III)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)
(IV)The city attorney.
(v)
(V)The director of a city housing department.
(D)
(iv)The recorded instrument contract is recorded and is provided to the assessor.
(E)
(B)For purposes of this section, paragraph, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(i)Affordability restrictions mean that all of the following conditions are met:(I)The dwelling or unit can only be sold or resold to a qualified owner to be occupied as a principal place of residence.(II)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to qualified owners.(III)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.(IV)The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to qualified owners by a renewable 99-year ground lease.(ii)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that satisfies all of the following:(I)Has as its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.(II)All dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owners primary residence or rented to persons and families of low or moderate income.(III)The land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.(iii)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.(iv)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.(v)Qualified owner means persons and families of low or moderate income, including persons and families of low or moderate income that own a dwelling or unit collectively as member occupants or resident shareholders of a limited equity housing cooperative.(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(11)A recorded instrument contract where the following apply:
(A)The recorded instrument subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, to affordability restrictions.
(A)The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling.
(B)The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
(B)
(C)One of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves affordability restrictions in the contract serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(C)
(D)The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
(D)
(E)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(i)Affordability restrictions include all of the following: mean that all of the following conditions are met:
(I)The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, sold or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income a qualified owner to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
(II)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income. qualified owners.
(III)The rent collected from the dwelling or unit, if applicable, does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(IV)
(III)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income. qualified owners.
(V)
(IV)The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument. qualified owners by a renewable 99-year ground lease.
(ii) Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that satisfies both all of the following:
(I)Has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.
(II)All residences dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the as the qualified owners primary residence or rented to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(III)The land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which the a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
(iii)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(iv)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(v)Qualified owner means either of the following: persons and families of low or moderate income, including persons and families of low or moderate income that own a dwelling or unit collectively as member occupants or resident shareholders of a limited equity housing cooperative.
(I)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(II)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)In assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
(b)In assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
(c)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
(B)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)The rent collected from the dwelling or unit does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(D)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of the community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(E)Any restriction that ensures the dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(2)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
(A)All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
(B)The dwelling or unit is subject to affordability restrictions.
(3)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(4)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(5)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(6)Purchase price means a price that does not exceed the sale or resale formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(d)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 214.17 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:214.17.(a)Property is within the exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences in which both of the following conditions apply:
(1)All residences on the land are intended for ownership by a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the land on which the residence is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that residence for a renewable term of 99 years.
(2)The residence is subject to affordability restrictions.
(b)In the case of property not previously designated as open space, the exemption provided by subdivision (a) may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), or a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), that is in the course of construction.
(c)The exemption authorized pursuant to this section shall apply to a property for no more than five years from the date any restriction described in subparagraph (E) or (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) is recorded against the property.
(d)For purposes of this section, all of the following shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The residence can only be rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
(B)The sale or resale price of the residence is determined by a formula that ensures the residence has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)The rent collected from the residence does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(D)There is a purchase option for the residence in favor of the nonprofit organization intended to preserve the residence as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(E)Any restriction that ensures the residence is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(2)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(3)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(e)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SECTION 1.Section 402.1 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:402.1.(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(11)A recorded instrument where the following apply:
(A)The recorded instrument subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, to affordability restrictions.
(B)One of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(C)The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
(D)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(i)Affordability restrictions include all of the following:
(I)The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
(II)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(III)The rent collected from the dwelling or unit, if applicable, does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(IV)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(V)The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(ii) Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that satisfies both of the following:
(I)Has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.
(II)All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
(iii)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(iv)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(v)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(I)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(II)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.SEC. 5.SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.(a)In assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
(b)In assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
(c)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
(B)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)The rent collected from the dwelling or unit does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(D)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of the community land trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(E)Any restriction that ensures the dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserves preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(2)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
(A)All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
(B)The dwelling or unit is subject to affordability restrictions.
(3)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(4)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(5)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(6)Purchase price means a price that does not exceed the sale or resale formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(d)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 214.17 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:214.17.(a)Property is within the exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences in which both of the following conditions apply:(1)All residences on the land are intended for ownership by a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income as their primary residence, and the land on which the residence is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that residence for a renewable term of 99 years.(2)The residence is subject to affordability restrictions.(b)In the case of property not previously designated as open space, the exemption provided by subdivision (a) may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), or a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), that is in the course of construction.(c)The exemption required authorized pursuant to this section shall apply to a property for no more than five years from the date any restriction described in subparagraph (E) or (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) is recorded against the property.(d)For purposes of this section, all of the following shall apply:(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:(A)The residence can only be rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied as a principal place of residence.(B)The sale or resale price of the residence is determined by a formula that ensures the residence has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.(C)The rent collected from the residence does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.(D)There is a purchase option for the residence in favor of the nonprofit organization intended to preserve the residence as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.(E)Any restriction that ensures the residence is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.(ii)The county counsel.(iii)The director of a county housing department.(iv)The city attorney.(v)The director of a city housing department.(2)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.(3)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.(4)Qualified owner means either of the following:(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.(e)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 5.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)When valuing In assessing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling dwelling, and the land on which it the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, if the dwelling or unit is on land leased to the owner by a community land trust, the assessor shall not value the dwelling or unit and the land at any value greater than the purchase price for that dwelling or unit. unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
(b)This section shall only apply to a dwelling or unit and land that is owned and occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income.
(b)In assessing a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative or by a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the limited equity housing cooperative, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of the dwelling or unit by persons and families of low or moderate income, the value of the dwelling or unit and the land shall be presumed to be the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of that dwelling or unit.
(c)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The dwelling or unit can only be sold or rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied by the owner as his or her as a principal place of residence.
(B)The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures affordability the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)The rent collected from the dwelling or unit does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)
(D)There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of the community land trust. trust intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(E)Any restriction that ensures the dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserves the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(2)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
(A)All residences on the land are sold to, and occupied by, to a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income, income as their primary residence, and the land on which it the dwelling or unit is situated that is required is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit is leased to those owners by the nonprofit corporation for a renewable term of 99 years, including renewal option. years.
(B)The leasehold interest is limited by dwelling or unit is subject to affordability restrictions recorded on the land lease or other similar recorded instrument. restrictions.
(3)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(3)
(4)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(5)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(6)Purchase price means a price that does not exceed the sale or resale formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(d)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 214.17 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:214.17.(a)Property is within the exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of has as one of its primary purposes the creating and maintaining of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences in which both of the following conditions apply:
(1)All residences on the land are intended for ownership and occupancy as a primary residence by a qualified owner to be occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income, income as their primary residence, and the land on which it the residence is situated that is required is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that residence is leased to those owners by the nonprofit corporation residence for a renewable term of 99 years, including renewal options. years.
(2)The leasehold interest is limited by residence is subject to affordability restrictions recorded on the land lease or other similar recorded instrument. restrictions.
(b)In the case of property not previously designated as open space, the exemption provided by subdivision (a) may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), or a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), that is in the course of construction.
(c)The exemption required pursuant to this section shall apply to a property for no more than five years from the date any restriction described in subparagraph (E) or (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) is recorded against the property.
(c)
(d)For purposes of this section, both all of the following shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The residence can only be sold rented, sold, or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied by the owner as his or her as a principal place of residence.
(B)The sale or resale price of the residence is determined by a formula that ensures affordability the residence has a purchase price that is affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)The rent collected from the residence does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)
(D)There is a purchase option for the residence in favor of the community land trust. nonprofit organization intended to preserve the residence as affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(E)Any restriction that ensures the residence is to remain affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
(F)Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which one of the following public agencies or officials has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for persons and families of low or moderate income:
(i)The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency.
(ii)The county counsel.
(iii)The director of a county housing department.
(iv)The city attorney.
(v)The director of a city housing department.
(2)Limited equity housing cooperative has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 817 of the Civil Code.
(2)
(3)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Qualified owner means either of the following:
(A)A limited equity housing cooperative.
(B)Persons and families of low or moderate income.
(d)
(e)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 5.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)When valuing an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling and the land on which it is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, if the dwelling or unit is on land leased to the owner by a community land trust, the assessor shall not value the dwelling or unit and the land at any value greater than the purchase price for that dwelling or unit.
(b)This section shall only apply to a dwelling or unit and land that is owned and occupied by persons and families of low or moderate income.
(c)For purposes of this section, all of the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The dwelling or unit can only be sold or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied by the owner as his or her principal place of residence.
(B)The resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures affordability to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)There is a purchase option in favor of the community land trust.
(2)Community land trust means a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of creating and maintaining permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
(A)All residences on the land are sold to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income, and the land on which it is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit is leased to those owners by the nonprofit corporation for a term of 99 years, including renewal option.
(B)The leasehold interest is limited by affordability restrictions recorded on the land lease or other similar recorded instrument.
(3)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 2.Section 214.17 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:214.17.(a)Property is within the exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if that property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Section 214, that is organized for the specific and primary purpose of creating and maintaining permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences in which both of the following conditions apply:
(1)All residences on the land are intended for ownership and occupancy as a primary residence by persons and families of low or moderate income, and the land on which it is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that residence is leased to those owners by the nonprofit corporation for a term of 99 years, including renewal options.
(2)The leasehold interest is limited by affordability restrictions recorded on the land lease or other similar recorded instrument.
(b)In the case of property not previously designated as open space, the exemption provided by subdivision (a) may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), or a single-family or multifamily residence, as described in subdivision (a), that is in the course of construction.
(c)For purposes of this section, both of the following shall apply:
(1)Affordability restrictions include, but are not limited to, any of the following:
(A)The residence can only be sold or resold to persons and families of low or moderate income to be occupied by the owner as his or her principal place of residence.
(B)The resale price of the residence is determined by a formula that ensures affordability to persons and families of low or moderate income.
(C)There is a purchase option in favor of the community land trust.
(2)Persons and families of low or moderate income has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)This section shall apply to lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Notwithstanding Section 2229 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, no appropriation is made by this act and the state shall not reimburse any local agency for any property tax revenues lost by it pursuant to this act.
SEC. 5.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
SECTION 1.Section 402.1 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:402.1.(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
(a)In the assessment of land, the assessor shall consider the effect upon value of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of the land may be subjected. These restrictions shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Zoning.
(2)Recorded contracts with governmental agencies other than those provided in Sections 422, 422.5, and 422.7.
(3)Permit authority of, and permits issued by, governmental agencies exercising land use powers concurrently with local governments, including the California Coastal Commission and regional coastal commissions, the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission, and the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency.
(4)Development controls of a local government in accordance with any local coastal program certified pursuant to Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Development controls of a local government in accordance with a local protection program, or any component thereof, certified pursuant to Division 19 (commencing with Section 29000) of the Public Resources Code.
(6)Environmental constraints applied to the use of land pursuant to provisions of statutes.
(7)Hazardous waste land use restriction pursuant to Section 25226 of the Health and Safety Code.
(8)(A)A recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easement, as described in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the preservation, protection, or enhancement of land in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition or use.
(B)A recorded greenway easement, as described in Section 816.52 of the Civil Code, that is granted in favor of a public agency, or in favor of a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has as its primary purpose the developing and preserving of greenways.
(9)A solar-use easement pursuant to Chapter 6.9 (commencing with Section 51190) of Part 1 of Division 1 of Title 5 of the Government Code.
(10)A contract where the following apply:
(A)The contract is with a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that has received a welfare exemption under Section 214.15 for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
(B)The contract restricts the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost in accordance with Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)The contract includes a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
(D)The local housing authority or an equivalent agency, or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
(E)The contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
(b)There is a rebuttable presumption that restrictions will not be removed or substantially modified in the predictable future and that they will substantially equate the value of the land to the value attributable to the legally permissible use or uses.
(c)Grounds for rebutting the presumption may include, but are not necessarily limited to, the past history of like use restrictions in the jurisdiction in question and the similarity of sales prices for restricted and unrestricted land. The possible expiration of a restriction at a time certain shall not be conclusive evidence of the future removal or modification of the restriction unless there is no opportunity or likelihood of the continuation or renewal of the restriction, or unless a necessary party to the restriction has indicated an intent to permit its expiration at that time.
(d)In assessing land with respect to which the presumption is unrebutted, the assessor shall not consider sales of otherwise comparable land not similarly restricted as to use as indicative of value of land under restriction, unless the restrictions have a demonstrably minimal effect upon value.
(e)In assessing land under an enforceable use restriction wherein the presumption of no predictable removal or substantial modification of the restriction has been rebutted, but where the restriction nevertheless retains some future life and has some effect on present value, the assessor may consider, in addition to all other legally permissible information, representative sales of comparable lands that are not under restriction but upon which natural limitations have substantially the same effect as restrictions.
(f)For the purposes of this section the following definitions apply:
(1)Comparable lands are lands that are similar to the land being valued in respect to legally permissible uses and physical attributes.
(2)Representative sales information is information from sales of a sufficient number of comparable lands to give an accurate indication of the full cash value of the land being valued.
(g)It is hereby declared that the purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section is to provide for a method of determining whether a sufficient amount of representative sales information is available for land under use restriction to ensure the accurate assessment of that land. It is also hereby declared that the further purpose and intent of the Legislature in enacting this section and Section 1630 is to avoid an assessment policy which, in the absence of special circumstances, considers uses for land that legally are not available to the owner and not contemplated by government, and that these sections are necessary to implement the public policy of encouraging and maintaining effective land use planning. This statute shall not be construed as requiring the assessment of any land at a value less than as required by Section 401 or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when this information is available.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 2, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 12 p.m. |
| Aug 25, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 6301.). |
| Aug 25, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 25 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 5228.). |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 18, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 1, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 29, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 29). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 5141.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. (Page 5120.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0.) |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 4943.) |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 27, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 25, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 17, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 16, 2016 | Read second time and amended. |
| May 12, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (May 9). |
| May 9, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to REV. & TAX. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| May 2, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 17, 2016 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 22, 2016 | Read first time. |
| Feb 21, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 25, 2016 | AB 2818 CHIU Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 22, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2818 Chiu By Allen | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 1, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 29, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2016 | AB 2818 CHIU Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2016 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2818
Author:(Chiu and Thurmond)
As Amended Ver:August 17, 2016
Majority vote. Taxy Levy
ASSEMBLY: | 80-0 | (June 1, 2016) | SENATE: | 39-0 | (August 22, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: REV. & TAX.
SUMMARY: Requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, affordability restrictions imposed on housing units and the land on which the units are situated, as specified.
The Senate amendments:
- Require the affordability restrictions a county assessor must consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, to be provided in a recorded contract that is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust (CLT) and the qualified owner, as specified.
- Revise the definition of "affordability restrictions" to mean that all of the following conditions are met:
- The dwelling or unit can only be sold or resold to a qualified owner to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
- The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to qualified owners.
- There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a CLT intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.
- The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to qualified owners by a renewable 99-year ground lease.
- Revise the definition of "community land trust" to mean a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(3) that satisfies all of the following:
- Has as its primary purpose the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences.
- All dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owner's primary residence or rented to persons and families of low or moderate income (LMI).
- The land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
- Revise the definition of "qualified owner" to mean persons and families of LMI, including persons and families of LMI that own a dwelling or unit collectively as member occupants or resident shareholders of a limited equity housing cooperative (LEHC).
- Add a joint author.
EXISTING LAW:
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value.
- Requires property to be reassessed to current fair market value whenever it is purchased, newly constructed, or when ownership changes, with specified exceptions, and provides a rebuttable presumption that the fair market value is the purchase price.
- Defines "purchase price" as the total consideration provided by the purchaser or on the purchaser's behalf, valued in money, whether paid in money or otherwise.
- Requires county assessors, when determining assessed valuation, to consider the effect on property of the value of any enforceable restrictions against the use of the land, including but not limited to:
- Zoning restrictions;
- Development controls in accordance with local coastal or protection programs;
- Statutory environmental constraints;
- Hazardous waste land-use restrictions;
- Recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easements;
- Solar-use easements; or,
- Recorded contracts with a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program. The contract must restrict use of the land for owner-occupied affordable housing for at 30 years, include a deed of trust in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance, and be provided to the assessor. The local housing authority or equivalent agency must also make a finding that the long-term deed restrictions serve a public purpose. [Revenue & Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 402.1]
AS PASSED BY THE ASSEMBLY, this bill:
- Required the county assessor, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, to consider affordability restrictions provided in a recorded instrument to the county assessor, as specified.
- Provided that the recorded instrument must subject a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by LMI households, to affordability restrictions.
- Provided that a finding must be made, by one of the following public agencies or officials, that the affordability restrictions serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for LMI households:
- The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency;
- The county counsel;
- The director of a county housing department;
- The city attorney; or,
- The director of a city housing department.
- Provided that "affordability restrictions" include all of the following:
- The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, or resold to LMI households to be occupied as a principal place of residence;
- The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price affordable to LMI households;
- The rent collected from the dwelling or unit, if applicable, does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from LMI households;
- There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a CLT intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to LMI households; and,
- The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to LMI households by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
- Defined a "community land trust" as a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under R&TC Section 214, that satisfies both of the following:
- Has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences; and,
- All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by LMI households as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
- Defined a "qualified owner" as either of the following:
- A LEHC; or,
- Persons and families of LMI.
- Defined a "limited equity housing cooperative" as having the same meaning as the term in Civil Code Section 817.
- Defined "persons and families of low or moderate income" as having the same meaning as the term in Health and Safety Code Section 50093.
- Imposed a state-mandated local program and provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
- Provided that no appropriation is made and the state will not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to this bill.
- Took effect immediately as a tax levy.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill would result in an unknown annual property tax revenue loss, potentially in the low millions of dollars over several fiscal years (see Senate Appropriatons Committee Staff Comments). Reductions in local property tax revenues, in turn, increase General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50% (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors). Administration costs related to this bill are expected to be minor.
COMMENTS:
- Community Land Trusts: CLTs provide an affordable housing model to help LMI households that may not otherwise be able to purchase a home. The CLT acquires and develops properties for sale to LMI households, but retains ownership of the underlying land and leases the land to the homeowner for a nominal fee through a long-term ground lease (usually a 99-year term). The home is therefore more affordable because the homeowner is only buying the building and not the land underneath. If the homeowner decides to sell the property, the home must be resold to another LMI household, and the original owner will only be eligible for a smaller share of its appreciated value. Since the CLT is the owner of the land, it will be a party to all future sales and enforce resale restrictions. According to the California CLT Network, it appears that many CLTs in California also have robust rental portfolios restricted for LMI households.
A CLT is generally formed as a membership-based, non-profit organization with a professional staff, led by a member-elected board of directors and funded by land rent fees. Members include CLT homeowners, neighbors, and other local residents, providing community buy-in over local development. Many CLTs also provide homeowners with homebuyer education and financial literacy courses. While a subsidy is often needed to start a CLT, outside funding is no longer necessary once homes are occupied, which provides steady fee revenues, and are resold, which recycles the original subsidy thereby allowing homes to remain permanently affordable.
According to the National CLT Network, virtually all CLT leases pass along the cost of property taxes to the homeowner. The homeowner is either directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with both the home and underlying land, or is directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with the home and then pays any property taxes associated with the underlying land via its lease fee to the CLT.
- Assessment of Restricted Homes: Existing law requires every assessor to assess property subject to tax at its full value. In the assessment of land, the assessor must consider the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of land may be subject, such as zoning, easements, environmental restrictions, and recorded contracts with governmental agencies including those outlining affordable housing restrictions. However, "[a]s a general rule, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it; only enforceable government restrictions under [R&TC] Section 402.1 are recognized as limiting the full fee simple interest." (Assessor's Handbook Section 502, ADVANCED APPRAISAL December 1998, Reprinted January 2015, pg. 6). The inability of private parties to reduce the taxable value of their property through self-imposed private encumbrances has long been recognized by the courts. (Carlson v. Assessment Appeals Board (1985) 167 Cal. App. 3d 1004).
Last year, AB 668 (Gomez) Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015, provided that specified self-imposed private encumbrances could result in assessments of reduced property taxes if the applicable contract is recorded and provided to the assessor. Authorized contracts are limited to those by a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption to sell low-income families participating in a special no-interest loan program affordable housing, similar to the model utilized by Habitat for Humanity. As a result, assessors must now consider the non-profit's organization-imposed restrictions when determining a property's assessed valuation.
- How Are CLTs Assessed? According to the author, CLTs in California experience an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price. In other cases, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price (i.e., $150,000)." As such, OakCLT believes that the total assessed value (improvements and land) of a CLT property should be based upon the restricted sales price of the home.
- Purpose of This Bill – Consistent Assessments: This bill follows the precedent established by AB 668 and requires the county assessor to consider the effect of private party affordability restrictions on a property's use when determining that property's assessed valuation. In order to benefit from such consideration, a recorded contract must be provided to the county assessor that subjects the property to specified affordability restrictions. A public agency or official must also find that the affordability restrictions in the contract serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for LMI households.
Analysis Prepared by: FN: 0004734
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2818 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2818
Author: Chiu (D) and Thurmond (D)
Amended: 8/17/16 in Senate
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/29/16
AYES: Hertzberg, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Lara, Moorlach
NO VOTE RECORDED: Pavley
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Property taxation: community land trust
SOURCE: California Community Land Trust Network
DIGEST: This bill adds contracts with specified affordability restrictions to the list of items an assessor must consider when determining the value of land.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/17/16 require contracts that qualify for the assessor’s consideration under the bill be recorded, and make technical changes.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law.
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or ownership changes.
- Presumes for property tax purposes that a property’s full cash or fair market value is its purchase price.
- Defines the purchase price to include the total consideration provided by the purchaser, or on the purchaser’s behalf, valued in money, paid in money or otherwise.
- Directs assessors to consider enforceable restrictions, such as zoning and environmental restrictions, as well as recorded contracts with government entities when valuing land.
- Establishes a rebuttable presumption that such a restriction is permanent, and that the value of the land is substantially equivalent to the value attributable to its legally permissible use.
- Allows to assessor to overcome the presumption by showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the restriction will be lifted in the predictable future.
- Provides, generally, that assessors can only consider enforceable government restrictions when determining value; private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it. However, in response to differing assessment methods, the Legislature recently added onto the list of enforceable restrictions contracts applied to homes constructed and sold by Habitat for Humanity that meet all of the following requirements (AB 668, Gomez, Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015):
- With a nonprofit 501(c) (3) that has received a welfare exemption from property tax for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
- That restrict the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost, as defined.
- That include a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
- Where the local housing authority or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
- That are recorded and provided to the assessor.
This bill:
- Enacts provisions for contracts with Community Land Trusts (CLTs), similar to those in place Habitat for Humanity, that require the assessor to consider contracts that:
- Are a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multi-family dwelling,
- Subject a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions,
- In which the county counsel, the director of a county housing department, the city attorney, the director of a city housing department, makes a finding that the affordability restriction in the contract serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing, and
- The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
- Defines “affordability restrictions” to mean all of the following conditions have been met:
- The property can only be sold or resold to qualified owners, using the current definition in the Health and Safety Code for persons and families of low to moderate income, to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
- The sale or resale price of the property is determined by a formula that ensures that its purchase price is affordable to qualified owners.
- The CLT has a purchase option on the property intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.
- The property remains affordable to persons and families of low- or moderate-income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
- Defines a “community land trust”:
- As a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Internal Revenue Code 501(c)(3),
- That has as its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences,
- As all dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owner’s primary residence or rented to persons and families of low- or moderate-income, and
- As the land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
- Defines other terms.
- States that reimbursement for any state mandated costs be made pursuant to existing statute, but also provides that no reimbursement shall be made for reduced property tax revenue.
Background
Formed by local agencies, employers, nonprofits, or grassroots organizations, CLTs are typically non-profit organizations that seek to promote affordable housing by acquiring and retaining ownership of real property in a specific geographic area using capital or land from private donations or public sources. While the first CLTs were formed in rural areas in the 1970s, nearly 200 exist nationwide today, with approximately 20 in California. CLTs mostly operate in higher-income urban and suburban areas, and under federal law, must:
- Not be sponsored by a for-profit organization;
- Be established to acquire parcels of land, held in perpetuity, primarily for conveyance under long-term ground leases; transfer ownership of any structural improvements located on such leased parcels to the lessees; and retain a preemptive option to purchase any such structural improvement at a price determined by formula that is designed to ensure that the improvement remains affordable to low- and moderate-income families in perpetuity;
- Have corporate membership that is open to any adult resident of a particular geographic area specified in the bylaws of the organization; and whose board of directors must be equally comprised of leaseholders, community representatives, and other individuals representing the public interest.
In addition to operating rental units, CLTs use a creative ownership model to fund affordable housing sales. First, the CLT divides the underlying land, which it owns in perpetuity, from the home, which is sold to the qualifying resident. The CLT leases the land to the resident via a 99-year ground lease. Only residents considered low- to moderate income in that area can buy the home, which is subject to resale price restrictions contained in the ground lease that stipulate the resale price formula that provides for a fair, but below-market, return on the resident’s investment. Additionally, restrictions only allow sales to other low-to-moderate income individuals. The CLT maintains the option to repurchase any structure on its land. When the CLT owns the land, it pays property taxes, but residents are assessed after purchasing the property from the CLT.
The CLT affordable housing model does not cleanly fit the general practice of determining value for property tax purposes, which generally sets the purchase prices of the entire property as its base year value, because the CLT sells only the structure, but retains ownership of the land under the 99-year ground lease. As such, CLTs report inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes: in some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price, while in others, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price.” AB 2818 seeks to address this inconsistency by adding the CLT model onto the list of enforceable restrictions state law directing assessors to consider when determining value.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in an unknown annual property tax revenue loss, potentially in the low millions of dollars over several fiscal years. Reductions in local property tax revenues, in turn, increase General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors). Administration costs related to this bill are expected to be minor.
California Community Land Trust Network (source)
AMCAL Multi-Housing
Bay Area Community Land Trust
Beverly-Vermont Community Land Trust
Bolina Community Land Trust
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Housing Consortium
Community Land Trust Association of Western Marin
The Dellums Institute of Social Justice
Enterprise Community Partners
Greenlining Institute
Grounded Solutions Network
Habitat for Humanity
Housing Land Trust of Sonoma County
Irvine Community Land Trust
Marty’s House Affordable Housing Corporation
Northern California Land Trust
Oakland Community Land Trust
PolicyLink
Preserving Affordable Housing Assets Longterm Incorporated
San Diego Community Land Trust
San Diego Housing Federation
San Francisco Community Land Trust
Sustainable Economies Law Center
T.R.U.S.T. South LA
Urban Strategies Council
11 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are nonprofit organizations that employ a unique and innovative method to permanently preserve the availability of affordable homeownership opportunities. CLTs achieve this goal by separating the ownership of land from the ownership of a home (the improvements). A CLT home is sold to a qualifying low or moderate-income family, but the cost of the land is not passed on through the transaction. Instead, the nonprofit CLT retains ownership of the land and maintains a supportive relationship with homeowners to help ensure their success. While the homeowner does not possess title to the land, they lease the land from the CLT for a nominal monthly administrative fee which grants them exclusive rights to the land. Homeowners are able to capture a portion of the equity when the home is sold but not all of it, keeping the home affordable for the subsequent homeowner. Homeowners that own CLT homes throughout the state have experienced an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases the homes are assessed at the "fair market value" which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and its restrictions on the resale price. In other cases, homes are assessed somewhere in between market and the actual restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. The ongoing affordability of CLT homes critically relies on the accurate and fair assessment of the home. In some cases, the property taxes are nearly double what they should be, particularly when assessed at the market value. Even 10 to 20 percent higher taxes can make these homes no longer affordable, putting the homeowner in jeopardy of foreclosure or unable to properly maintain the physical property. AB 2818 would require assessors to consider the underlying land lease and the affordability restrictions on a CLT home to determine the value of the property for the purpose of assessment.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
8/18/16 17:28:29
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2818
:
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/29/16
AYES: Hertzberg, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Lara, Moorlach
NO VOTE RECORDED: Pavley
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Community Land Trust Network
DIGEST: This bill adds contracts with specified affordability restrictions to the list of items an assessor must consider when determining the value of land.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law.
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or ownership changes.
- Presumes for property tax purposes that a property’s full cash or fair market value is its purchase price.
- Defines the purchase price to include the total consideration provided by the purchaser, or on the purchaser’s behalf, valued in money, paid in money or otherwise.
- Directs assessors to consider enforceable restrictions, such as zoning and environmental restrictions, as well as recorded contracts with government entities when valuing land.
- Establishes a rebuttable presumption that such a restriction is permanent, and that the value of the land is substantially equivalent to the value attributable to its legally permissible use.
- Allows to assessor to overcome the presumption by showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the restriction will be lifted in the predictable future.
- Provides, generally, that assessors can only consider enforceable government restrictions when determining value; private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it. However, in response to differing assessment methods, the Legislature recently added onto the list of enforceable restrictions contracts applied to homes constructed and sold by Habitat for Humanity that meet all of the following requirements (AB 668, Gomez, Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015):
- With a nonprofit 501(c) (3) that has received a welfare exemption from property tax for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
- That restrict the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost, as defined.
- That include a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
- Where the local housing authority or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose.
- That are recorded and provided to the assessor.
This bill:
- Enacts provisions for contracts with Community Land Trusts (CLTs), similar to those in place Habitat for Humanity, that require the assessor to consider contracts that:
- Are a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multi-family dwelling,
- Subject a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions,
- In which the county counsel, the director of a county housing department, the city attorney, the director of a city housing department, makes a finding that the affordability restriction in the contract serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing, and
- The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
- Defines “affordability restrictions” to mean all of the following conditions have been met:
- The property can only be sold or resold to qualified owners, using the current definition in the Health and Safety Code for persons and families of low to moderate income, to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
- The sale or resale price of the property is determined by a formula that ensures that its purchase price is affordable to qualified owners.
- The CLT has a purchase option on the property intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.
- The property remains affordable to persons and families of low- or moderate-income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
- Defines a “community land trust”:
- As a nonprofit corporation organized pursuant to Internal Revenue Code 501(c)(3),
- That has as its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences,
- As all dwellings and units located on the land owned by the nonprofit corporation are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied as the qualified owner’s primary residence or rented to persons and families of low- or moderate-income, and
- As the land owned by the nonprofit corporation, on which a dwelling or unit sold to a qualified owner is situated, is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
- Defines other terms.
- States that reimbursement for any state mandated costs be made pursuant to existing statute, but also provides that no reimbursement shall be made for reduced property tax revenue.
Background
Formed by local agencies, employers, nonprofits, or grassroots organizations, CLTs are typically non-profit organizations that seek to promote affordable housing by acquiring and retaining ownership of real property in a specific geographic area using capital or land from private donations or public sources. While the first CLTs were formed in rural areas in the 1970s, nearly 200 exist nationwide today, with approximately 20 in California. CLTs mostly operate in higher-income urban and suburban areas, and under federal law, must:
- Not be sponsored by a for-profit organization;
- Be established to acquire parcels of land, held in perpetuity, primarily for conveyance under long-term ground leases; transfer ownership of any structural improvements located on such leased parcels to the lessees; and retain a preemptive option to purchase any such structural improvement at a price determined by formula that is designed to ensure that the improvement remains affordable to low- and moderate-income families in perpetuity;
- Have corporate membership that is open to any adult resident of a particular geographic area specified in the bylaws of the organization; and whose board of directors must be equally comprised of leaseholders, community representatives, and other individuals representing the public interest.
In addition to operating rental units, CLTs use a creative ownership model to fund affordable housing sales. First, the CLT divides the underlying land, which it owns in perpetuity, from the home, which is sold to the qualifying resident. The CLT leases the land to the resident via a 99-year ground lease. Only residents considered low- to moderate income in that area can buy the home, which is subject to resale price restrictions contained in the ground lease that stipulate the resale price formula that provides for a fair, but below-market, return on the resident’s investment. Additionally, restrictions only allow sales to other low-to-moderate income individuals. The CLT maintains the option to repurchase any structure on its land. When the CLT owns the land, it pays property taxes, but residents are assessed after purchasing the property from the CLT.
The CLT affordable housing model does not cleanly fit the general practice of determining value for property tax purposes, which generally sets the purchase prices of the entire property as its base year value, because the CLT sells only the structure, but retains ownership of the land under the 99-year ground lease. As such, CLTs report inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes: in some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price, while in others, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price.” AB 2818 seeks to address this inconsistency by adding the CLT model onto the list of enforceable restrictions state law directing assessors to consider when determining value.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in an unknown annual property tax revenue loss, potentially in the low millions of dollars over several fiscal years. Reductions in local property tax revenues, in turn, increase General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors). Administration costs related to this bill are expected to be minor.
California Community Land Trust Network (source)
AMCAL Multi-Housing
Bay Area Community Land Trust
Beverly-Vermont Community Land Trust
Bolina Community Land Trust
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Housing Consortium
Community Land Trust Association of Western Marin
The Dellums Institute of Social Justice
Enterprise Community Partners
Greenlining Institute
Grounded Solutions Network
Habitat for Humanity
Housing Land Trust of Sonoma County
Irvine Community Land Trust
Marty’s House Affordable Housing Corporation
Northern California Land Trust
Oakland Community Land Trust
PolicyLink
Preserving Affordable Housing Assets Longterm Incorporated
San Diego Community Land Trust
San Diego Housing Federation
San Francisco Community Land Trust
Sustainable Economies Law Center
T.R.U.S.T. South LA
Urban Strategies Council
11 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are nonprofit organizations that employ a unique and innovative method to permanently preserve the availability of affordable homeownership opportunities. CLTs achieve this goal by separating the ownership of land from the ownership of a home (the improvements). A CLT home is sold to a qualifying low or moderate-income family, but the cost of the land is not passed on through the transaction. Instead, the nonprofit CLT retains ownership of the land and maintains a supportive relationship with homeowners to help ensure their success. While the homeowner does not possess title to the land, they lease the land from the CLT for a nominal monthly administrative fee which grants them exclusive rights to the land. Homeowners are able to capture a portion of the equity when the home is sold but not all of it, keeping the home affordable for the subsequent homeowner. Homeowners that own CLT homes throughout the state have experienced an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases the homes are assessed at the "fair market value" which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and its restrictions on the resale price. In other cases, homes are assessed somewhere in between market and the actual restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. The ongoing affordability of CLT homes critically relies on the accurate and fair assessment of the home. In some cases, the property taxes are nearly double what they should be, particularly when assessed at the market value. Even 10 to 20 percent higher taxes can make these homes no longer affordable, putting the homeowner in jeopardy of foreclosure or unable to properly maintain the physical property. AB 2818 would require assessors to consider the underlying land lease and the affordability restrictions on a CLT home to determine the value of the property for the purpose of assessment.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 6/1/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
8/15/16 20:22:33
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2818 (Chiu) - Property taxation: community land trust
Version: June 22, 2016 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 1, 2016 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 2818 would add contracts with affordability restrictions to the list of items an assessor must consider when determining the value of land.
Fiscal Impact:
The bill would result in an unknown annual property tax revenue loss, potentially in the low millions of dollars over several fiscal years (see Staff Comments). Reductions in local property tax revenues, in turn, increase General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors). Administration costs related to the bill are expected to be minor.
Background:
Under the California Constitution, all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted. The Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1 percent of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or ownership changes.
Formed by local agencies, employers, nonprofits, or grassroots organizations, Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are typically non-profit organizations that seek to promote affordable housing by acquiring and retaining ownership of real property in a specific geographic area using capital or land from private donations or public sources. CLTs initially formed in rural areas in the 1970s; however, nearly 200 exist nationwide today, with approximately 20 in California. CLTs mostly operate in higher-income urban and suburban areas, and under federal law, must meet specified criteria.
In addition to operating rental units, CLTs use a creative ownership model to fund affordable housing sales. First, the CLT divides the underlying land, which it owns in perpetuity, from the home, which is sold to the qualifying resident. The CLT leases the land to the resident via a 99-year ground lease. Only residents considered low- to moderate income in that area can buy the home, which is subject to resale price restrictions contained in the ground lease that stipulate the resale price formula that provides for a fair, but below-market, return on the resident’s investment. Additionally, restrictions only allow sales to other low-to-moderate income individuals. The CLT maintains the option to repurchase any structure on its land. When the CLT owns the land, it pays property taxes, but residents are assessed after purchasing the property from the CLT.
To determine value, current law effectively presumes that a property’s purchase price in the transaction is its full cash or fair market value. The law further defines the purchase price to include the total consideration provided by the purchaser, or on the purchaser’s behalf, valued in money, paid in money or otherwise. However, assessors must consider enforceable restrictions, such as zoning and environmental restrictions, as well as recorded contracts with government entities when valuing land. State law establishes a rebuttable presumption that such a restriction is permanent, and that the value of the land is substantially equivalent to the value attributable to its legally permissible use. The assessor can overcome the presumption by showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the restriction will be lifted in the predictable future. The law does not require assessment of any land at less than its full value or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when such information is available.
As a general rule, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it; only enforceable government restrictions are recognized. Until recently, assessors could only consider contracts with government agencies when determining the effect upon value of enforceable restrictions except for land preservation easements held by non-profit entities. Last year, the Legislature added onto the list of enforceable restrictions contracts in response to differing assessment methods applied to homes constructed and sold by Habitat for Humanity (AB 886, Gomez, 2015) that meet specified requirements.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, in addition to defining terms, add to the list of enforceable restrictions that the assessor must consider recorded instruments where the following apply:
- The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multi-family dwelling.
- The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
- The county counsel, the director of a county housing department, the city attorney, the director of a city housing department, makes a finding that the affordability restriction in the contract serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing.
- The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
Staff Comments:
Available data indicate that only one CLT is building new homes that will be ready for sale within the next two years. About 20 homes per year are planned with an equal split between low and moderate income buyers. Under this bill, the property tax savings for a moderate income homebuyer are estimated to be $650 and $1,800 for a low income homebuyer, based on current median area home prices and income levels at that location. Thus, the revenue impact of this measure is estimated to be a property tax revenue loss of $24,500 annually for the next two years.
However, over the long term, CLTs could develop and sell up to 2,500 homes in California. Assuming (1) similar property tax savings for low and moderate income buyers, and (2) an equal split between low and moderate income buyers, the associated property tax revenue loss would be about $3 million. The distribution of this amount across various fiscal years in unknown.
Generally speaking, the property tax reduction in the out years would increase as CLTs continue to become more common.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Robert M. Hertzberg, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: | AB 2818 | Hearing Date: | 6/29/16 |
Author: | Chiu | Tax Levy: | Yes |
Version: | 6/22/16 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Property taxation: community land trust
Adds contracts with affordability restrictions to the list of items an assessor must consider when determining the value of land.
Background
Article XIII of the California Constitution provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. The Constitution limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or ownership changes (Proposition 13, 1978).
Community Land Trusts. Formed by local agencies, employers, nonprofits, or grassroots organizations, Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are typically non-profit organizations that seek to promote affordable housing by acquiring and retaining ownership of real property in a specific geographic area using capital or land from private donations or public sources. While the first CLTs were formed in rural areas in the 1970s, nearly 200 exist nationwide today, with approximately 20 in California. CLTs mostly operate in higher-income urban and suburban areas, and under federal law, must:
- Not be sponsored by a for-profit organization;
- Be established to acquire parcels of land, held in perpetuity, primarily for conveyance under long-term ground leases; transfer ownership of any structural improvements located on such leased parcels to the lessees; and retain a preemptive option to purchase any such structural improvement at a price determined by formula that is designed to ensure that the improvement remains affordable to low- and moderate-income families in perpetuity;
- Have corporate membership that is open to any adult resident of a particular geographic area specified in the bylaws of the organization; and whose board of directors must be equally comprised of leaseholders, community representatives, and other individuals representing the public interest.
In addition to operating rental units, CLTs use a creative ownership model to fund affordable housing sales. First, the CLT divides the underlying land, which it owns in perpetuity, from the home, which is sold to the qualifying resident. The CLT leases the land to the resident via a 99-year ground lease. Only residents considered low- to moderate income in that area can buy the home, which is subject to resale price restrictions contained in the ground lease that stipulate the resale price formula that provides for a fair, but below-market, return on the resident’s investment. Additionally, restrictions only allow sales to other low-to-moderate income individuals. The CLT maintains the option to repurchase any structure on its land. When the CLT owns the land, it pays property taxes, but residents are assessed after purchasing the property from the CLT.
Assessors’ considerations. To determine value, the law effectively presumes that a property’s purchase price in the transaction is its full cash or fair market value. The law further defines the purchase price to include the total consideration provided by the purchaser, or on the purchaser’s behalf, valued in money, paid in money or otherwise. However, assessors must consider enforceable restrictions, such as zoning and environmental restrictions, as well as recorded contracts with government entities when valuing land. State law establishes a rebuttable presumption that such a restriction is permanent, and that the value of the land is substantially equivalent to the value attributable to its legally permissible use. The assessor can overcome the presumption by showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the restriction will be lifted in the predictable future. The law does not require assessment of any land at less than its full value or as prohibiting the use of representative comparable sales information on land under similar restrictions when such information is available.
As a general rule, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it; only enforceable government restrictions are recognized as limiting the full fee simple interest. Until recently, assessors could only consider contracts with government agencies when determining the effect upon value of enforceable restrictions except for land preservation easements held by non-profit entities. Last year, the Legislature added onto the list of enforceable restrictions contracts in response to differing assessment methods applied to homes constructed and sold by Habitat for Humanity (AB 886, Gomez, 2015) that meet all of the following requirements:
- With a nonprofit 501(c)(3) that has received a welfare exemption for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program.
- That restrict the use of the land for at least 30 years to owner-occupied housing available at affordable housing cost, as defined,
- That include a deed of trust on the property in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance with the terms of the program, which has no value unless the owner fails to comply with the covenants and restrictions of the terms of the home sale.
- Where the local housing authority or, if none exists, the city attorney or county counsel, has made a finding that the long-term deed restrictions in the contract serve a public purpose, and
- That are recorded and provided to the assessor.
Some CLTs argue that assessment of community land trust property varies considerably in the state. Seeking to improve consistency of assessment of CLT properties statewide, CLTs want to explicitly include their model on the list of enforceable restrictions assessors must consider when valuing land.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 2818 adds to the list of enforceable restrictions that the assessor must consider recorded instruments where the following apply:
- The contract is a renewable 99-year ground lease between a community land trust and the qualified owner of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or an owner-occupied unit in a multi-family dwelling.
- The contract subjects a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is leased to the qualified owner by a community land trust for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit, to affordability restrictions.
- The county counsel, the director of a county housing department, the city attorney, the director of a city housing department, makes a finding that the affordability restriction in the contract serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing.
- The recorded instrument is provided to the assessor.
The measure defines several terms, including “affordability restrictions” to mean that all of the following must be met:
- The property can only be sold or resold to qualified owners, defined as persons and families of low to moderate income, to be occupied as a principal place of residence.
- The sale or resale price of the property is determined by a formula that ensures that its purchase price is affordable to qualified owners.
- The community land trust has a purchase option on the property intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to qualified owners.
- The property remains affordable to persons and families of low or moderate income by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Community Land Trusts (CLTs) are nonprofit organizations that employ a unique and innovative method to permanently preserve the availability of affordable homeownership opportunities. CLTs achieve this goal by separating the ownership of land from the ownership of a home (the improvements). A CLT home is sold to a qualifying low or moderate-income family, but the cost of the land is not passed on through the transaction. Instead, the nonprofit CLT retains ownership of the land and maintains a supportive relationship with homeowners to help ensure their success. While the homeowner does not possess title to the land, they lease the land from the CLT for a nominal monthly administrative fee which grants them exclusive rights to the land. Homeowners are able to capture a portion of the equity when the home is sold but not all of it, keeping the home affordable for the subsequent homeowner. Homeowners that own CLT homes throughout the state have experienced an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases the homes are assessed at the "fair market value" which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and its restrictions on the resale price. In other cases, homes are assessed somewhere in between market and the actual restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. The ongoing affordability of CLT homes critically relies on the accurate and fair assessment of the home. In some cases, the property taxes are nearly double what they should be, particularly when assessed at the market value. Even 10 to 20 percent higher taxes can make these homes no longer affordable, putting the homeowner in jeopardy of foreclosure or unable to properly maintain the physical property. AB 2818 would require assessors to consider the underlying land lease and the affordability restrictions on a CLT home to determine the value of the property for the purpose of assessment.”
2. Need. The CLT affordable housing model does not cleanly fit the general practice of determining value for property tax purposes, which generally sets the purchase prices of the entire property as its base year value, because the CLT sells only the structure, but retains ownership of the land under the 99-year ground lease. As such, CLTs report inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes: in some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price, while in others, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price.” OakCLT believes that the total assessed value, both improvements and land, of a CLT property should be based upon the restricted sales price of the home. AB 2818 seeks to address this inconsistency by adding the CLT model onto the list of enforceable restrictions state law directing assessors to consider when determining value.
3. Parity, part one. For many years, assessors could not consider enforceable restrictions imposed by private parties when determining the value of land except for land conservation easements. After several years of unsuccessful legislative efforts to create valuation uniformity, the Legislature last year directed assessors to consider the Habitat for Humanity “silent second,” housing affordability model, where Habitat records a deed of trust that has no value other than to ensure compliance with their affordable housing program. AB 2818 enacts a similar policy for the CLT model.
4. Parity, part two. State law affords Habitat for Humanity, and other organizations like it, an additional benefit not currently contemplated by AB 2818: a welfare exemption from property tax for the period of time after they acquire the property, but before they sell it to a qualified buyer. The California Constitution allows for welfare exemptions for a variety of organizations and uses of property. State law details these exemptions which provide that the property owner need not pay property tax, presuming that the organization will more charitably use any funds that would have used to pay the tax, and therefore any government services it would have funded.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Revenue and Taxation 9-0
Assembly Appropriations 14-0
Assembly Floor 80-0
Support and Opposition
(6/23/16)
Support: AMCAL Multi-Housing, Bay Area Community Land Trust, Beverly-Vermont Community Land Trust, Bolina Community Land Trust, California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies, California Housing Consortium, Community Land Trust Association of Western Marin, The Dellums Institute of Social Justice, Enterprise Community Partners, Greenlining Institute, Grounded Solutions Network, Habitat for Humanity, Housing Land Trust of Sonoma County, Irvine Community Land Trust, Marty’s House Affordable Housing Corporation, Northern California Land Trust, Oakland Community Land Trust, PolicyLink, Preserving Affordable Housing Assets Longterm Incorporated; San Diego Community Land Trust, San Diego Housing Federation, San Francisco Community Land Trust, Sustainable Economies Law Center, T.R.U.S.T. South LA, Urban Strategies Council, 11 individuals.
Opposition: None received.
-- END --
(Without Reference to File)
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2818
Author:(Chiu)
As Amended Ver:May 31, 2016
Majority vote. Tax levy
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Revenue & Taxation | 9-0 | Ridley-Thomas, Brough, Dababneh, Gipson, Mullin, O'Donnell, Patterson, Quirk, Wagner | |
Appropriations | 14-0 | Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Daly, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Quirk, Santiago, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY: Requires the county assessor to consider, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, affordability restrictions imposed on housing units and the land on which the units are situated, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the county assessor, when valuing real property for property taxation purposes, to consider affordability restrictions provided in a recorded instrument to the county assessor, as specified.
- Provides that the recorded instrument must subject a single-family dwelling or unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated that is required for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit by low or moderate income (LMI) households, to affordability restrictions.
- Provides that a finding must be made, by one of the following public agencies or officials, that the affordability restrictions serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for LMI households:
- The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency;
- The county counsel;
- The director of a county housing department;
- The city attorney; or,
- The director of a city housing department.
- Provides that "affordability restrictions" include all of the following:
- The dwelling or unit can only be rented, sold, or resold to LMI households to be occupied as a principal place of residence;
- The sale or resale price of the dwelling or unit is determined by a formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price affordable to LMI households;
- The rent collected from the dwelling or unit, if applicable, does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from LMI households;
- There is a purchase option for the dwelling or unit in favor of a community land trust (CLT) intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to LMI households; and,
- The dwelling or unit is to remain affordable to LMI households by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument.
- Defines a "community land trust" as a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for exemption under Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214, that satisfies both of the following:
- Has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences; and,
- All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by LMI households as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years.
- Defines a "qualified owner" as either of the following:
- A limited equity housing cooperative (LEHC); or,
- Persons and families of LMI.
- Defines a "limited equity housing cooperative" as having the same meaning as the term in Civil Code Section 817.
- Defines "persons and families of low or moderate income" as having the same meaning as the term in Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50093.
- Imposes a state-mandated local program and provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
- Provides that no appropriation is made and the state will not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to this bill.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value.
- Requires property to be reassessed to current fair market value whenever it is purchased, newly constructed, or when ownership changes, with specified exceptions, and provides a rebuttable presumption that the fair market value is the purchase price.
- Defines "purchase price" as the total consideration provided by the purchaser or on the purchaser's behalf, valued in money, whether paid in money or otherwise.
- Requires county assessors, when determining assessed valuation, to consider the effect on property of the value of any enforceable restrictions against the use of the land, including but not limited to:
- Zoning restrictions;
- Development controls in accordance with local coastal or protection programs;
- Statutory environmental constraints;
- Hazardous waste land-use restrictions;
- Recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easements;
- Solar-use easements; or,
- Recorded contracts with a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program. The contract must restrict use of the land for owner-occupied affordable housing for at 30 years, include a deed of trust in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance, and be provided to the assessor. The local housing authority or equivalent agency must also make a finding that the long-term deed restrictions serve a public purpose. (R&TC Section 402.1)
- Authorizes the Legislature to exempt from taxation property used exclusively for religious, hospital, or charitable purposes, as specified. (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 4(b)). The Legislature has implemented this "welfare exemption" in R&TC Section 214.
- Grants the welfare exemption to property used exclusively for rental housing and related facilities for lower income households, as defined in H&SC Section 50053, operated by non-profit organizations, as specified.
- Grants the welfare exemption to property acquired by a nonprofit corporation organized and operated for the specific and primary purpose of building and rehabilitating single or multi-family residences. (R&TC Section 214.15.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, moderate property tax revenue loss as a result of the reduced assessed value of CLT-provided homes. For example, CLTs are more common in expensive areas in California, such as the San Francisco Bay Area and Los Angeles. If, in a single year, 30 CLT homes were sold to households who had income levels at 80% of the area median income in both Los Angeles and the San Francisco Bay Area, and an additional 30 homes were sold across the rest of the state, estimated property tax losses would be in the range of $336,000, resulting in General Fund costs of approximately $168,000. These costs would grow as CLTs continue to become more common.
COMMENTS:
- Community Land Trusts: CLTs provide an affordable housing model to help LMI households that may not otherwise be able to purchase a home. The CLT acquires and develops properties for sale to LMI households, but retains ownership of the underlying land and leases the land to the homeowner for a nominal fee through a long-term ground lease (usually a 99-year term). The home is therefore more affordable because the homeowner is only buying the building and not the land underneath. If the homeowner decides to sell the property, the home must be resold to another LMI household, and the original owner will only be eligible for a smaller share of its appreciated value. Since the CLT is the owner of the land, it will be a party to all future sales and enforce resale restrictions. According to the California CLT Network, it appears that many CLTs in California also have robust rental portfolios restricted for LMI households.
A CLT is generally formed as a membership-based, non-profit organization with a professional staff, led by a member-elected board of directors and funded by land rent fees. Members include CLT homeowners, neighbors, and other local residents, providing community buy-in over local development. Many CLTs also provide homeowners with homebuyer education and financial literacy courses. While a subsidy is often needed to start a CLT, outside funding is no longer necessary once homes are occupied, which provides steady fee revenues, and are resold, which recycles the original subsidy thereby allowing homes to remain permanently affordable.
According to the National CLT Network, virtually all CLT leases pass along the cost of property taxes to the homeowner. The homeowner is either directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with both the home and underlying land, or is directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with the home and then pays any property taxes associated with the underlying land via its lease fee to the CLT.
- Limited-Equity Housing Cooperatives: Housing co-ops are democratically controlled corporations in which each household owns a share, entitling the member to occupy a unit of housing. The co-op is usually financed through one mortgage that covers the entire property, with members paying monthly carrying charges to cover mortgage payments and operating expenses, including property taxes. The co-op model can be used for virtually any type of housing construction covering high-end, mid-range, and affordable developments, with LEHCs specifically developed to offer permanently affordable homeownership opportunities for LMI households. Share prices in these co-ops are usually low, member households are limited to owning only one share, and price restrictions are put on the sale of shares to prevent speculative resale and preserve affordability.
Given the similar participatory community-based models of CLTs and LEHCs to provide access to affordable housing for LMI households, it is not uncommon to have LEHC-owned homes situated on CLT-leased land. Although existing law specifies that increases in LEHC share prices cannot exceed 10% annually and any profits from the sale of the co-op as a whole must be dedicated to public or charitable entities, existing law does not specify that ownership is limited to LMI individuals. As such, non-LMI individuals may be able to benefit from reduced property tax assessments if they own a share in a LEHC.
- Assessment of Restricted Homes: Existing law requires every assessor to assess property subject to tax at its full value. In the assessment of land, the assessor must consider the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of land may be subject, such as zoning, easements, environmental restrictions, and recorded contracts with governmental agencies including those outlining affordable housing restrictions. However, "[a]s a general rule, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it; only enforceable government restrictions under [R&TC] Section 402.1 are recognized as limiting the full fee simple interest." (Assessor's Handbook Section 502, ADVANCED APPRAISAL December 1998, Reprinted January 2015, pg. 6). The inability of private parties to reduce the taxable value of their property through self-imposed private encumbrances has long been recognized by the courts. (Carlson v. Assessment Appeals Board (1985) 167 Cal. App. 3d 1004).
Last year, AB 668 (Gomez) Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015, provided that specified self-imposed private encumbrances could result in assessments of reduced property taxes if the applicable contract is recorded and provided to the assessor. Authorized contracts are limited to those by a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption to sell low-income families participating in a special no-interest loan program affordable housing, similar to the model utilized by Habitat for Humanity. As a result, assessors must now consider the non-profit's organization-imposed restrictions when determining a property's assessed valuation.
- How Are CLTs Assessed? According to the author, CLTs in California experience an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price. In other cases, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price (i.e., $150,000)." As such, OakCLT believes that the total assessed value (improvements and land) of a CLT property should be based upon the restricted sales price of the home.
- Purpose of This Bill – Consistent Assessments: This bill follows the precedent established by AB 668 and requires the county assessor to consider the effect of private party affordability restrictions on a property's use when determining that property's assessed valuation. In order to benefit from such consideration, a recorded instrument must be provided to the county assessor that subjects the property to specified affordability restrictions. The recorded instrument must also contain a finding by a public agency or official that the restrictions serve the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for LMI households.
Requiring county assessors to consider the impact of private party enforceable restrictions when valuing real property for property taxation purposes is intended to result in more consistent assessments of homes on CLT-leased land. However, this bill suggests but does not explicitly provide that the assessment consideration is limited only to CLT homes and land subject to affordability restrictions via a 99-year ground lease, and whether all CLTs serving LMI households in such a manner qualify for the assessment consideration. Any remaining ambiguity may result in continued inconsistency by county assessors when valuing CLT property.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0003345
Date of Hearing: May 25, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2818
Author:(Chiu) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2016
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill modifies how certain homes located on land set aside for low to moderate income (LMI) households are assessed for the purposes of property taxes and extends a welfare exemption for the purposes of property taxation to certain community land trusts (CLTs). Specifically, this bill:
- Presumes that the assessed value for a home, and the land on which the home is situated for occupation and use by an LMI household, is the purchase price of the home.
- Presumes that the assessed value of a home owned by a limited equity housing cooperative (LEHC) and the underlying land on which the home is situated for occupation and use by an LMI household, is the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of the home.
- States that a property is within the welfare exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if the property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation otherwise qualifying for the exemption under Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214. The nonprofit must have as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable homes under the following conditions:
- All residences on the land are intended for ownership by a qualified owner to be occupied by LMI households as their primary residence, and the land on which the residence is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that residence for a renewable term of 99 years; and,
- The residence is subject to affordability restrictions.
- Provides, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, that the exemption may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residence in existence or in the course of construction.
- Provides that the exemption is only applicable to a property for no more than five years from the date any affordability restriction is recorded against the property.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Moderate to significant property tax revenue loss as a result of 1) expanding the welfare exemption to certain CLTs; and 2) the reduced assessed value of CLT-provided homes. The number of CLTs is expanding, and over 1,600 CLT-provided homes are currently under construction or in the planning stages.
For example, CLTs are more common in expensive areas in California, like the San Francisco Bay Area and Los Angeles. If in a single year 30 CLT homes were sold to households who had income levels at 80% of the area median income in both Los Angeles and the San Francisco Bay Area, and an additional 30 homes were sold across the rest of the state, estimated property tax losses would be in the range of $336,000, resulting in General Fund costs of approximately $168,000. These costs would grow as CLTs continue to become more common.
- Unknown but potentially moderate to significant property tax revenue loss due to the extension of the welfare exemption to CLTs during the development process.
COMMENTS:
- Background on Community Land Trusts: CLTs provide an affordable housing model to help low-to-moderate income households that may not otherwise be able to purchase a home. The CLT acquires and develops properties for sale, but retains ownership of the underlying land and leases the land to the homeowner for a nominal fee through a long-term ground lease. The home is therefore more affordable because the homeowner is only buying the building and not the land underneath. While a subsidy is often needed to start a CLT, outside funding is no longer necessary once homes are occupied, which provides steady fee revenues, and are resold, which recycles the original subsidy thereby allowing homes to remain permanently affordable.
According to the National Community Land Trust Network, virtually all CLT leases pass along the cost of property taxes to the homeowner. The homeowner is either directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with both the home and underlying land, or is directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with the home and then pays any property taxes associated with the underlying land via its lease fee to the CLT.
- Background on Limited-Equity Housing Cooperatives: Housing co-ops are democratically controlled corporations in which each household owns a share, entitling the member to occupy a unit of housing. The co-op is usually financed through one mortgage that covers the entire property, with members paying monthly carrying charges to cover mortgage payments and operating expenses, including property taxes.
Given the similar participatory community-based models of CLTs and LEHCs to provide access to affordable housing for LMI households, it is not uncommon to have LEHC-owned homes situated on CLT-leased land. Although California law specifies that increases in LEHC share prices cannot exceed 10% annually, and any profits from the sale of the co-op as a whole must be dedicated to public or charitable entities, existing law does not specify that ownership is limited to LMI individuals.
- Assessment of Restricted Homes: Existing law requires every assessor to assess property subject to tax at its full value. Generally, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances on it. This means that for CLTs, the assessed value of the property may include both the land the home, even though the home was sold to a family at a below-market price. As an example: A CLT located in Marin County may sell a home to a family for $300,000 even though the market value of that home, and the underlying property, in the private market would be $1 million.
Last year, AB 668 (Gomez) Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015, provided that specified self-imposed private encumbrances could result in assessments of reduced property taxes if the applicable contract is recorded and provided to the assessor. Authorized contracts are limited to those by a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption to sell low-income families participating in a special no-interest loan program affordable housing, similar to the model utilized by Habitat for Humanity. As a result, assessors must now consider the non-profit's organization-imposed restrictions when determining a property's assessed valuation.
This bill aims to extend the same consideration granted to Habitat for Humanity, via AB 668, to CLTs. In the example of the homeowner in Marin, the homeowner would pay taxes on an assessed value of $300,000 instead of the full value of the property, which is $1 million.
- Welfare exemption. This bill provides that non-profits with affordable housing models similar to CLTs qualify for the welfare exemption and prohibits the exemption from being denied on the basis that the property does not yet have a housing development in use onsite. The exemption would be effective for five years after affordability restrictions are recorded against the property.
- Purpose. According to the author’s office, AB 2818 helps address inconsistencies in how homes on CLTs are assessed for the purposes of property taxes. The ongoing affordability of CLT homes relies on the accurate and fair assessment of the home, and the author argues that this bill would achieve this as well as create a uniform standard so that CLTs can receive a property tax exemption when developing additional affordable properties.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 9, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Sebastian Ridley-Thomas, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2818 (
Author:Chiu) – As Amended Ver:May 2, 2016
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Property taxation: community land trust
SUMMARY: Presumes that the assessed value of specified dwellings or units and the land on which they are situated is the purchase price of only the dwelling or unit, and that the property tax welfare exemption may apply to property on which specified residences will be constructed, but construction has not yet commenced. Specifically, this bill:
- Presumes, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, that the assessed value of an owner-occupied single-family dwelling or owner-occupied unit in a multifamily dwelling, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated for its convenient occupation and use by low or moderate income (LMI) households, is the purchase price of the dwelling or unit.
- Presumes, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, that the assessed value of a dwelling or unit owned by a limited equity housing cooperative (LEHC) or a member-occupant or resident shareholder of the LEHC, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated for its convenient occupation and use by LMI households, is the purchase price of the share conveying an exclusive right to occupancy and possession of the dwelling or unit.
- Provides, for lien dates occurring on and after January 1, 2017, that a property is within the welfare exemption provided by Sections 4 and 5 of Article XIII of the California Constitution if the property is owned and operated by a nonprofit corporation otherwise qualifying for the exemption under Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
- All residences on the land are intended for ownership by a qualified owner to be occupied by LMI households as their primary residence, and the land on which the residence is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that residence for a renewable term of 99 years; and,
- The residence is subject to affordability restrictions.
- Provides, in the case of property not previously designated as open space, that the exemption may not be denied to a property on the basis that the property does not currently include a permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residence in existence or in the course of construction.
- Provides that the exemption is only applicable to a property for no more than five years from the date any affordability restriction is recorded against the property.
- Provides that "affordability restrictions" include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
- A dwelling, unit, or residence that can only be rented, sold, or resold to LMI households for purposes of their principal place of residence;
- The sale or resale price of the dwelling, unit, or residence is determined by a formula that ensures it has a purchase price affordable to LMI households;
- The rent collected from the dwelling, unit, or residence does not exceed the maximum rent allowable to be collected from LMI households;
- There is a purchase option for the dwelling, unit, or residence in favor of the community land trust (CLT) intended to preserve the dwelling or unit as affordable to LMI households;
- Any restriction that ensures the dwelling, unit, or residence is to remain affordable to LMI households by recorded deed, deed restriction, ground lease, covenant, memorandum, or other recorded instrument; or,
- Any restriction in a recorded instrument from which a public agency or official has made a finding that the restriction serves the public interest to create and preserve the affordability of residential housing for LMI households. The public agency or official must be one of the following:
- The director of the local housing authority or equivalent agency;
- The county counsel;
- The director of a county housing department;
- The city attorney; or,
- The director of a city housing department.
- Defines "community land trust" as a nonprofit corporation otherwise qualifying for an exemption under R&TC Section 214, that has as one of its primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable single-family or multifamily residences to which both of the following conditions apply:
- All residences on the land are sold to a qualified owner to be occupied by LMI households as their primary residence, and the land on which the dwelling or unit is situated is leased by the nonprofit corporation to the qualified owner for the convenient occupation and use of that dwelling or unit for a renewable term of 99 years; and,
- The dwelling or unit is subject to affordability restrictions.
- Defines "limited equity housing cooperative" as having the same meaning as the term in Civil Code Section 817.
- Defines "persons and families of low or moderate income" as having the same meaning as the term in Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50093.
- Defines "qualified owner" as either a LEHC or persons and families of LMI.
- Defines "purchase price" as the price that does not exceed the sale or resale formula that ensures the dwelling or unit has a purchase price that is affordable to LMI households.
- Imposes a state-mandated local program and provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
- Provides that no appropriation is made and the state will not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to this bill.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value.
- Requires property to be reassessed to current fair market value whenever it is purchased, newly constructed, or when ownership changes, with specified exceptions, and provides a rebuttable presumption that the fair market value is the purchase price.
- Defines "purchase price" as the total consideration provided by the purchaser or on the purchaser's behalf, valued in money, whether paid in money or otherwise.
- Requires county assessors, when determining assessed valuation, to consider the effect on property of the value of any enforceable restrictions against the use of the land, including but not limited to:
- Zoning restrictions;
- Development controls in accordance with local coastal or protection programs;
- Statutory environmental constraints;
- Hazardous waste land-use restrictions;
- Recorded conservation, trail, or scenic easements;
- Solar-use easements; or,
- Recorded contracts with a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption for properties intended to be sold to low-income families who participate in a special no-interest loan program. The contract must restrict use of the land for owner-occupied affordable housing for at 30 years, include a deed of trust in favor of the nonprofit corporation to ensure compliance, and be provided to the assessor. The local housing authority or equivalent agency must also make a finding that the long-term deed restrictions serve a public purpose. (R&TC Section 402.1)
- Authorizes the Legislature to exempt from taxation property used exclusively for religious, hospital, or charitable purposes, as specified. (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 4(b).) The Legislature has implemented this "welfare exemption" in R&TC Section 214.
- Grants the welfare exemption to property used exclusively for rental housing and related facilities for lower income households, as defined in H&SC Section 50053, operated by non-profit organizations, as specified.
- Imposes a "certification requirement" for low-income housing owners seeking the welfare exemption. Specifically, the law requires a project's owner to "[c]ertify that the funds that would have been necessary to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of, or reduce rents otherwise necessary for, the units occupied by lower income households."
- Authorizes nonprofit corporations organized and operated for the specific and primary purpose of building and rehabilitating single or multi-family residences to qualify for the welfare exemption when property is acquired rather than when construction commences. (R&TC Section 214.15.) Generally, unimproved land is not exempt from when the property is initially acquired through when onsite activity commences, despite plans by the owning entity to build exempt property on vacant land in the future.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. The State Board of Equalization (BOE) analysis of this bill is pending.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
Non-profits throughout the state have experienced an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes for CLT units. In some cases the units are assessed at the "fair market value" which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and its restrictions on the resale price. In other cases homes are assessed somewhere in between market and the actual restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. The ongoing affordability of CLT homes critically relies on the accurate and fair assessment of the home. In some cases, the property taxes are nearly double what they should be, particularly when assessed at the market value. Even 10 to 20 percent higher taxes can make these homes no longer affordable, putting the homeowner in jeopardy of foreclosure or unable to properly maintain the physical property. AB 2818 would create a uniform standard so that CLTs can receive a property tax exemption. Non-profits purchase existing multi-family structures and land to convert or develop into a CLT. During the time the non-profit is developing the CLT and obtaining financing, the property can be assessed at the market value. This can be prohibitive for a non-profit. AB 2818 would exempt CLTs from assessment at the full market value during the development process. Under existing law, CLTs can obtain a welfare exemption after occupancy of a rental property but not before the property is developed.
- Arguments in Support: Proponents of this bill state:
California is deep within the throes of an affordability crisis with diminishing opportunities for families of modest means to purchase their own homes. AB 2818 affirmatively responds to our state's shortfall of affordable homeownership opportunities for low-income families, and affords community land trusts the same equitable treatment under California law already extended to more common forms of affordable housing provision.
- Community Land Trusts: CLTs provide an affordable housing model to help LMI households that may not otherwise be able to purchase a home. The CLT acquires and develops properties for sale to LMI households, but retains ownership of the underlying land and leases the land to the homeowner for a nominal fee through a long-term ground lease (usually a 99-year term). The home is therefore more affordable because the homeowner is only buying the building and not the land underneath. If the homeowner decides to sell the property, the home must be resold to another LMI household, and the original owner will only be eligible for a smaller share of its appreciated value. Since the CLT is the owner of the land, it will be a party to all future sales and enforce resale restrictions. According to the California Community Land Trust Network, it appears that many CLTs in California also have robust rental portfolios restricted for LMI households.
A CLT is generally formed as a membership-based, non-profit organization with a professional staff, led by a member-elected board of directors and funded by land rent fees. Members include CLT homeowners, neighbors, and other local residents, providing community buy-in over local development. Many CLTs also provide homeowners with homebuyer education and financial literacy courses. While a subsidy is often needed to start a CLT, outside funding is no longer necessary once homes are occupied, which provides steady fee revenues, and are resold, which recycles the original subsidy thereby allowing homes to remain permanently affordable.
According to the National Community Land Trust Network, virtually all CLT leases pass along the cost of property taxes to the homeowner. The homeowner is either directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with both the home and underlying land, or is directly assigned to pay property taxes associated with the home and then pays any property taxes associated with the underlying land via its lease fee to the CLT.
- Limited-Equity Housing Cooperatives: Housing co-ops are democratically controlled corporations in which each household owns a share, entitling the member to occupy a unit of housing. The co-op is usually financed through one mortgage that covers the entire property, with members paying monthly carrying charges to cover mortgage payments and operating expenses, including property taxes. The co-op model can be used for virtually any type of housing construction covering high-end, mid-range, and affordable developments, but LEHCs are specifically developed to offer permanently affordable homeownership opportunities for LMI households. Share prices in these co-ops are usually low, member households are limited to owning only one share, and price restrictions are put on the sale of shares to prevent speculative resale and preserve affordability.
Given the similar participatory community-based models of CLTs and LEHCs to provide access to affordable housing for LMI households, it is not uncommon to have LEHC-owned homes situated on CLT-leased land. Although California law specifies that increases in LEHC share prices cannot exceed 10% annually and any profits from the sale of the co-op as a whole must be dedicated to public or charitable entities, existing law does not specify that ownership is limited to LMI individuals. If this broad scope is inconsistent with the author's intent, amendments should be considered to harmonize the definition of "qualified owner" utilized in this bill.
- Assessment of Restricted Homes: Existing law requires every assessor to assess property subject to tax at its full value. In the assessment of land, the assessor must consider the effect of any enforceable restrictions to which the use of land may be subject, such as zoning, easements, environmental restrictions, and recorded contracts with governmental agencies including those outlining affordable housing restrictions. However, "[a]s a general rule, private parties cannot reduce the taxable value of their property by imposing private encumbrances upon it; only enforceable government restrictions under [R&TC] Section 402.1 are recognized as limiting the full fee simple interest." (Assessor's Handbook Section 502, ADVANCED APPRAISAL December 1998, Reprinted January 2015, pg. 6). The inability of private parties to reduce the taxable value of their property through self-imposed private encumbrances has long been recognized by the courts. (Carlson v. Assessment Appeals Board (1985) 167 Cal. App. 3d 1004).
Last year, AB 668 (Gomez) Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015, provided that specified self-imposed private encumbrances could result in assessments of reduced property taxes if the applicable contract is recorded and provided to the assessor. Authorized contracts are limited to those by a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption to sell low-income families participating in a special no-interest loan program affordable housing, similar to the model utilized by Habitat for Humanity. As a result, assessors must now consider the non-profit's organization-imposed restrictions when determining a property's assessed valuation.
- How Are CLTs Assessed? According to the author, CLTs in California experience an inconsistent methodology for assessing property taxes. In some cases, the units are assessed at "fair market value," which does not take into consideration the underlying land lease and restrictions on home resale price. In other cases, the units are assessed in between the market and restricted value with varying explanations for the inconsistency. For example, the Oakland CLT (OakCLT) states that while it technically owns the land, "there is no value to the land that it can realize apart from the nominal below-market monthly lease fee ($50/month) collected…the value of the land under an OakCLT home is fully included in the restricted sales price (i.e., $150,000)." As such, OakCLT believes that the total assessed value (improvements and land) of a CLT property should be based upon the restricted sales price of the home.
- Purpose of This Bill – Consistent Assessments: This bill does not prescribe the assessment methodology that should be used in valuing a dwelling or unit and the CLT-leased land on which it is situated, but establishes a presumption that the value of the dwelling or unit and the land is the purchase price of the dwelling or unit only, and not the CLT-leased land on which it is situated (or in the case of a dwelling or unit owned by a LEHC, the purchase price of the share conveying exclusive right to occupancy). However, under existing law, there is already a rebuttable presumption that assessment of fair market value is the property's purchase price. The reason why the property may be assessed higher than the purchase price is that current law does not allow the assessor to consider the impact of private party enforceable restrictions. As such, the Committee may wish to consider the extent to which the standard established by this bill contrasts with existing precedent that requires assessors to consider the effect of restrictions on a property's use, in lieu of specifying what purchase price should be used for assessment purposes, and may not achieve its desired intent.
This bill suggests but does not explicitly provide that the specified purchase price presumption is limited to CLTs subject to affordability restrictions via ground leases. Additionally, this bill outlines a number of factors that may constitute applicable affordability restrictions, but does not distinguish between factors that influence purchase or rental price unique to CLTs and factors that establish restrictions with a governmental agency. For example, the affordability restrictions include either a rule providing that only LMI households can occupy the home or a recorded instrument ensuring LMI affordability, potentially allowing other non-profit housing models aside from CLTs to qualify for the assessment considerations proposed by this bill. If this is broad scope is inconsistent with the author's intent, amendments should be considered to better identify what non-profit housing models qualify for the welfare exemption proposed by this bill and require certain restrictions to be executed in combination with one another.
- Property Tax Welfare Exemption: The California Constitution exempts from property taxes, in whole or in part, "property used exclusively for religious, hospital, or charitable purposes and owned or held in trust by corporations or other entities (1) that are organized and operating for those purposes, (2) that are nonprofit, and (3) no part of whose net earnings inures to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual." With regards to housing owned and used by these nonprofit entities, courts have ruled that this "welfare exemption" applies to uses that are either primary to or incidental to and reasonably necessary for the accomplishment of the exempt purposes of the organization. For example, in Cedars of Lebanon Hospital v. County of Los Angeles (1950) 35 Cal. 2d 729, the court exempted any housing facility for interns, resident doctors, student nurses, and certain hospital employees deemed essential to the operation of a complete modern hospital on a 24-hour basis.
The California Constitution also provides that the welfare exemption applies to "buildings under construction, land required for their convenient use, and equipment in them if the intended use would qualify the property for the exemption." Generally, a vacant property is not considered being used for a charitable purpose by the non-profit that otherwise qualifies for the welfare exemption, although the exemption would become effective as soon as construction or other activity begins onsite. However, existing law does provide that non-profits with an affordable housing model similar to that utilized by Habitat for Humanity may qualify for the welfare exemption as soon as the property is acquired and prior to commencement of construction. In providing special treatment for this affordable housing model, the Legislature issued findings proclaiming that its exempt activities are distinct from other affordable housing providers because its exempt purpose is not to own and operate a housing project on an ongoing basis, but to make housing and the land reasonably necessary for the use of that housing available for prompt sale to low-income residents. In other words, the Legislature found that the holding of real property for the future construction of housing on that property is central to the affordable housing model's exempt purposes and activities, and therefore constitutes "use."
Existing law also provides that the welfare exemption also applies to property owned and operated exclusively for rental housing occupied by lower-income households, defined as 30-60% of area median income (AMI). A proportionate partial exemption is granted if lower-income households occupy only a percentage of rental housing. The property must be financed with tax-exempt bonds or government grants with rents of the lower-income households below deed restrictions set by the terms of the financing, financed with low-income housing tax credits (LIHTC), or comprised of at least 90% lower-income households. Owners must also certify that property tax savings from the exemption are used to "maintain the affordability of, or reduce rents otherwise necessary for, the units occupied by lower income households."
- Do CLTs Qualify for the Welfare Exemption? This bill defines "community land trust" as a nonprofit corporation, otherwise qualifying for the welfare exemption, that has as one of its primary purposes creating and maintaining permanently affordable housing. However, it is not clear that CLTs always qualify for the welfare exemption. CLTs are a relatively new affordable housing model and exist in a variety of permutations. Although a CLT will always be the ground lessor of any housing development it manages, and it appears the primary goal is to promote affordable homeownership, many CLTs in California provide rental opportunities in addition to ownership opportunities.
Homes owned by individuals or LEHCs on CLT land do not qualify for the welfare exemption. While LEHCs are nonprofit corporations, they exist solely as a means to hold property and do not serve a charitable purpose. Generally, facilitating housing for a finite number of people in their own private homes, albeit for LMI households, also does not constitute a charitable purpose. Rental housing is more complex. Some CLTs rent units they own directly to tenants while some lease their land to an affordable housing developer that then rents units it owns to tenants. Under either rental model, the welfare exemption would apply if the property was financed with deed-restricted tax-exempt bonds or government grants or the LIHTC, or served the requisite threshold of lower-income individuals. Since CLTs also serve moderate-income households (income that does not exceed 120% AMI), not every CLT rental property qualifies for the exemption in whole or in part. Accordingly, it is unclear how many CLTs currently qualify for the welfare exemption and the manner in which they may qualify.
- Purpose of This Bill – Special Exemption: This bill provides that non-profits with affordable housing models similar to CLTs qualify for the welfare exemption and prohibits the exemption from being denied on the basis that the property does not yet have a housing development in use onsite. The exemption would be effective for five years after affordability restrictions are recorded against the property.
Although this bill is modeled on existing law that provided specified affordable housing developments a property tax exemption between the time vacant land is purchased and construction begins, operational differences between the CLT model and the Habitat for Humanity model result in a much broader exemption being granted to CLTs. In effect, this bill would grant all CLTs a welfare exemption for five years upon recordation of affordability restrictions, or until the unit is sold to a new owner, even if the CLT would not otherwise qualify for an exemption. Habitat for Humanity is generally a "short-term" holder of property – as soon as property ownership is transferred from the organization to a low-income household, the property is returned to the tax rolls. However, some CLTs maintain ownership of the development and rent units directly to tenants, which may include those of moderate-income who would not ordinarily qualify under the welfare exemption. Since this bill would grant the welfare exemption to nonprofits that have as one of their primary purposes the creation and maintenance of permanently affordable homes intended for ownership, rental housing traditionally excluded from the exemption would now qualify for it in limited instances. Even if the unit is immediately resold, the exemption would still have been granted to construct a unit restricted for purchase by a moderate-income household, representing an expansion of the current exemption.
The Committee may wish to consider the precedent set by extending the welfare exemption to more unimproved properties and more households, and whether it may incentivize other taxpayers to seek a similar exemption. The Committee may also wish to consider whether a five-year exemption is too long of a "grace period" to begin construction, or whether CLTs that do not begin construction after five years must owe deferred property taxes to the county, since initial plans should at least be underway if affordability restrictions must be in place, prior to receiving the exemption. Finally, as referenced earlier, this bill suggests but does not explicitly provide that the specified welfare exemption is limited to CLTs subject to affordability restrictions via ground leases. This bill also outlines a number of factors that may constitute applicable affordability restrictions, but does not distinguish between factors that influence purchase or rental price unique to CLTs and factors that establish restrictions with a governmental agency. If this broad scope is inconsistent with the author's intent, amendments should be considered to require certain restrictions to be executed in combination with one another to better identify what non-profit housing models qualify for the welfare exemption proposed by this bill.
- Technical Amendments: Committee staff suggests adoption of the following amendments:
- On Page 4, Line 29, strike "preserves" and insert "preserve";
- On Page 5, Line 1 and Page 5, Line 37, strike "creating and maintaining" and insert "creation and maintenance"; and,
- On Page 6, Line 20, strike "required" and insert "authorized".
- Related Legislation: AB 668 (Gomez) Chapter 698, Statutes of 2015, requires assessors to consider self-imposed private encumbrances on the value of a property if the contract is executed by a non-profit corporation granted a welfare exemption to sell affordable housing to low-income families participating in a special no-interest loan program and the contract is recorded and provided to the assessor.
- Prior Legislation: AB 1559 (Wiggins) Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999 provides an extension of the welfare exemption to vacant land in the case of a nonprofit corporation with a charitable purpose to acquire and hold real property for the future construction or rehabilitation of affordable housing for sale at cost to low-income families.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AMCAL Multi-Housing, Inc.
Bolinas Community Land Trust
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Housing Consortium
Enterprise Community Partners
Greenlining Institute
Grounded Solutions Network
Habitat for Humanity of Orange County
Housing Land Trust of Sonoma County
Irvine Community Land Trust
Oakland Community Land Trust
Policy Innovation + Justice Project, Dellums Institute for Social Justice
PolicyLink
San Diego Community Land Trust
San Diego Housing Federation
San Francisco Community Land Trust
Urban Strategies Council
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):