AB 305: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-09-14
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on pregnancy or menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, or menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury. The bill would also provide, notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, that the impairment ratings for breast cancer and the aftereffects of the disease, known as sequelae, shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to or menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed physical psychiatric injury. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to pregnancy or menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury. The bill would also provide, notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, that the impairment ratings for breast cancer and the aftereffects of the disease, known as sequelae, shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of physical injury, the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of psychiatric injury, the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed injury. The bill would also provide, notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, that the impairment ratings for breast cancer and the aftereffects of the disease, known as sequelae, shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of physical injury, from being based on pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of psychiatric injury, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis causally related to menopause if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed injury. The bill would also provide, notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, that the impairment ratings for breast cancer and the aftereffects of the disease, known as sequelae, shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of physical injury, from being based on pregnancy, breast cancer, menopause, or osteoporosis. osteoporosis if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of psychiatric injury, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, breast cancer, menopause, or osteoporosis. osteoporosis if the condition is contemporaneous with the claimed injury. The bill would also provide, notwithstanding any other law, that the impairment ratings for breast cancer and the aftereffects of the disease, known as sequelae, shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. The physician is required to make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of physical injury, from being based on pregnancy, breast cancer, menopause, or osteoporosis. The bill would also prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in cases of psychiatric injury, from being based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment, pregnancy, breast cancer, menopause, or osteoporosis.
Existing law requires an employer to furnish to the Industrial Welfare Commission, upon request, reports or information regarding the wages, hours, and other information that the employer is required by law to keep regarding his or her employees. A violation of this provision is a crime.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to this provision.
Existing law requires an employer to furnish to the Industrial Welfare Commission, upon request, reports or information regarding the wages, hours, and other information that the employer is required by law to keep regarding his or her employees. A violation of this provision is a crime.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to this provision.
Notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 2.Section 4663 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4663.(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)Apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on either of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Menopause.
(C)Apportionment in the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment that is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury, or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B) that are contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury.
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
Notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 2.Section 4663 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4663.(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)Apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on any either of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Menopause.
(iii)Osteoporosis causally related to menopause.
(C)Apportionment in the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment that is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury, or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B) that are contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury.
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
Notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 2.Section 4663 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4663.(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)Apportionment in cases of the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Menopause.
(iii)Osteoporosis causally related to menopause.
(C)Apportionment in cases of the case of a psychiatric injury occurring on or after January 1, 2016, shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment that is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury, or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B) that are contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury.
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
This section shall only apply to injuries occurring before January 1, 2013.
(a)In determining the percentages of permanent disability, account shall be taken of the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement, the occupation of the injured employee, and his or her age at the time of the injury, consideration being given to an employees diminished future earning capacity.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement shall incorporate the descriptions and measurements of physical impairments and the corresponding percentages of impairments published in the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition).
(2)For purposes of this section, an employees diminished future earning capacity shall be a numeric formula based on empirical data and findings that aggregate the average percentage of long-term loss of income resulting from each type of injury for similarly situated employees. The administrative director shall formulate the adjusted rating schedule based on empirical data and findings from the Evaluation of Californias Permanent Disability Rating Schedule, Interim Report (December 2003), prepared by the RAND Institute for Civil Justice, and upon data from additional empirical studies.
(c)The administrative director shall amend the schedule for the determination of the percentage of permanent disability in accordance with this section at least once every five years. This schedule shall be available for public inspection and, without formal introduction in evidence, shall be prima facie evidence of the percentage of permanent disability to be attributed to each injury covered by the schedule.
(d)The schedule shall promote consistency, uniformity, and objectivity. The schedule and any amendment thereto or revision thereof shall apply prospectively and shall apply to and govern only those permanent disabilities that result from compensable injuries received or occurring on and after the effective date of the adoption of the schedule, amendment or revision, as the fact may be. For compensable claims arising before January 1, 2005, the schedule as revised pursuant to changes made in legislation enacted during the 200304 Regular and Extraordinary Sessions shall apply to the determination of permanent disabilities when there has been either no comprehensive medical-legal report or no report by a treating physician indicating the existence of permanent disability, or when the employer is not required to provide the notice required by Section 4061 to the injured worker.
(e)Notwithstanding any other law, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 2.Section 4660.1 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4660.1.This section shall apply to injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2013.
(a)In determining the percentages of permanent partial or permanent total disability, account shall be taken of the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement, the occupation of the injured employee, and his or her age at the time of injury.
(b)For purposes of this section, the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement shall incorporate the descriptions and measurements of physical impairments and the corresponding percentages of impairments published in the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) with the employees whole person impairment, as provided in the Guides, multiplied by an adjustment factor of 1.4.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), there shall be no increases in impairment ratings for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, or psychiatric disorder, or any combination thereof, arising out of a compensable physical injury. Nothing in this section shall limit the ability of an injured employee to obtain treatment for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, or psychiatric disorder, if any, that are a consequence of an industrial injury.
(2)An increased impairment rating for psychiatric disorder shall not be subject to paragraph (1) if the compensable psychiatric injury resulted from either of the following:
(A)Being a victim of a violent act or direct exposure to a significant violent act within the meaning of Section 3208.3.
(B)A catastrophic injury, including, but not limited to, loss of a limb, paralysis, severe burn, or severe head injury.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
(d)The administrative director may formulate a schedule of age and occupational modifiers and may amend the schedule for the determination of the age and occupational modifiers in accordance with this section. The Schedule for Rating Permanent Disabilities pursuant to the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) and the schedule of age and occupational modifiers shall be available for public inspection and, without formal introduction in evidence, shall be prima facie evidence of the percentage of permanent disability to be attributed to each injury covered by the schedule. Until the schedule of age and occupational modifiers is amended, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2013, permanent disabilities shall be rated using the age and occupational modifiers in the permanent disability rating schedule adopted as of January 1, 2005.
(e)The schedule of age and occupational modifiers shall promote consistency, uniformity, and objectivity.
(f)The schedule of age and occupational modifiers and any amendment thereto or revision thereof shall apply prospectively and shall apply to and govern only those permanent disabilities that result from compensable injuries received or occurring on and after the effective date of the adoption of the schedule, amendment, or revision, as the case may be.
(g)Nothing in this section shall preclude a finding of permanent total disability in accordance with Section 4662.
(h)In enacting the act adding this section, it is not the intent of the Legislature to overrule the holding in Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808.
(i)The Commission on Health and Safety and Workers Compensation shall conduct a study to compare average loss of earnings for employees who sustained work-related injuries with permanent disability ratings under the schedule, and shall report the results of the study to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature no later than January 1, 2016.
SECTION 1.Section 4660.2 is added to the Labor Code, to read:4660.2.Notwithstanding any other law, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 4663 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4663.(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)Apportionment in cases of physical injury shall not be based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Menopause.
(iii)Osteoporosis causally related to menopause.
(C)Apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment that is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury, or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B) that are contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury.
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
This section shall only apply to injuries occurring before January 1, 2013.
(a)In determining the percentages of permanent disability, account shall be taken of the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement, the occupation of the injured employee, and his or her age at the time of the injury, consideration being given to an employees diminished future earning capacity.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement shall incorporate the descriptions and measurements of physical impairments and the corresponding percentages of impairments published in the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition).
(2)For purposes of this section, an employees diminished future earning capacity shall be a numeric formula based on empirical data and findings that aggregate the average percentage of long-term loss of income resulting from each type of injury for similarly situated employees. The administrative director shall formulate the adjusted rating schedule based on empirical data and findings from the Evaluation of Californias Permanent Disability Rating Schedule, Interim Report (December 2003), prepared by the RAND Institute for Civil Justice, and upon data from additional empirical studies.
(c)The administrative director shall amend the schedule for the determination of the percentage of permanent disability in accordance with this section at least once every five years. This schedule shall be available for public inspection and, without formal introduction in evidence, shall be prima facie evidence of the percentage of permanent disability to be attributed to each injury covered by the schedule.
(d)The schedule shall promote consistency, uniformity, and objectivity. The schedule and any amendment thereto or revision thereof shall apply prospectively and shall apply to and govern only those permanent disabilities that result from compensable injuries received or occurring on and after the effective date of the adoption of the schedule, amendment or revision, as the fact may be. For compensable claims arising before January 1, 2005, the schedule as revised pursuant to changes made in legislation enacted during the 200304 Regular and Extraordinary Sessions shall apply to the determination of permanent disabilities when there has been either no comprehensive medical-legal report or no report by a treating physician indicating the existence of permanent disability, or when the employer is not required to provide the notice required by Section 4061 to the injured worker.
(e)On or before January 1, 2005, the administrative director shall adopt regulations to implement the changes made to this section by the act that added this subdivision.
(e)Notwithstanding any other law, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
SEC. 2.Section 4660.1 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4660.1.This section shall apply to injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2013.
(a)In determining the percentages of permanent partial or permanent total disability, account shall be taken of the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement, the occupation of the injured employee, and his or her age at the time of injury.
(b)For purposes of this section, the nature of the physical injury or disfigurement shall incorporate the descriptions and measurements of physical impairments and the corresponding percentages of impairments published in the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) with the employees whole person impairment, as provided in the Guides, multiplied by an adjustment factor of 1.4.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), there shall be no increases in impairment ratings for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, or psychiatric disorder, or any combination thereof, arising out of a compensable physical injury. Nothing in this section shall limit the ability of an injured employee to obtain treatment for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, or psychiatric disorder, if any, that are a consequence of an industrial injury.
(2)An increased impairment rating for psychiatric disorder shall not be subject to paragraph (1) if the compensable psychiatric injury resulted from either of the following:
(A)Being a victim of a violent act or direct exposure to a significant violent act within the meaning of Section 3208.3.
(B)A catastrophic injury, including, but not limited to, loss of a limb, paralysis, severe burn, or severe head injury.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the impairment ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
(d)The administrative director may formulate a schedule of age and occupational modifiers and may amend the schedule for the determination of the age and occupational modifiers in accordance with this section. The Schedule for Rating Permanent Disabilities pursuant to the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) and the schedule of age and occupational modifiers shall be available for public inspection and, without formal introduction in evidence, shall be prima facie evidence of the percentage of permanent disability to be attributed to each injury covered by the schedule. Until the schedule of age and occupational modifiers is amended, for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2013, permanent disabilities shall be rated using the age and occupational modifiers in the permanent disability rating schedule adopted as of January 1, 2005.
(e)The schedule of age and occupational modifiers shall promote consistency, uniformity, and objectivity.
(f)The schedule of age and occupational modifiers and any amendment thereto or revision thereof shall apply prospectively and shall apply to and govern only those permanent disabilities that result from compensable injuries received or occurring on and after the effective date of the adoption of the schedule, amendment, or revision, as the case may be.
(g)Nothing in this section shall preclude a finding of permanent total disability in accordance with Section 4662.
(h)In enacting the act adding this section, it is not the intent of the Legislature to overrule the holding in Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808.
(i)The Commission on Health and Safety and Workers Compensation shall conduct a study to compare average loss of earnings for employees who sustained work-related injuries with permanent disability ratings under the schedule, and shall report the results of the study to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature no later than January 1, 2016.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 4663 of the Labor Code is amended to read:4663.(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(A)
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)Apportionment in cases of physical injury shall not be based on any of the following conditions: conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Breast cancer.
(iii)
(ii)Menopause.
(iv)
(iii)Osteoporosis.
(C)Apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment that is contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury, or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B) that are contemporaneous with the claimed psychiatric injury.
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)Any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall in that report address the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination. A(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries. If
(B)Apportionment in cases of physical injury shall not be based on any of the following conditions:
(i)Pregnancy.
(ii)Breast cancer.
(iii)Menopause.
(iv)Osteoporosis.
(C)Apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury shall not be based on psychiatric disability or impairment caused by sexual harassment or caused by any of the conditions listed in subparagraph (B).
(3) If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of that a prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) shall not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
SECTION 1.Section 1174 of the Labor Code is amended to read:1174.Any person employing labor in this state shall:
(a)Furnish to the commission, at its request, reports or information that the commission requires to carry out this chapter. The reports and information shall be verified if required by the commission or any member thereof.
(b)Allow any member of the commission or the employees of the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement free access to the place of business or employment of the person to secure any information or make any investigation that they are authorized by this chapter to ascertain or make. The commission may inspect or make excerpts, relating to the employment of employees, from the books, reports, contracts, payrolls, documents, or papers of the person.
(c)Keep a record showing the names and addresses of all employees employed and the ages of all minors.
(d)Keep, at a central location in the state or at the plants or establishments at which employees are employed, payroll records showing the hours worked daily by and the wages paid to, and the number of piece-rate units earned by and any applicable piece rate paid to, employees employed at the respective plants or establishments. These records shall be kept in accordance with rules established for this purpose by the commission, but in any case shall be kept on file for not less than three years. An employer shall not prohibit an employee from maintaining a personal record of hours worked, or, if paid on a piece-rate basis, piece-rate units earned.
Every Any person employing labor in this state shall:
(a)Furnish to the commission, at its request, reports or information that the commission requires to carry out this chapter. The reports and information shall be verified if required by the commission or any member thereof.
(b)Allow any member of the commission or the employees of the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement free access to the place of business or employment of the person to secure any information or make any investigation that they are authorized by this chapter to ascertain or make. The commission may inspect or make excerpts, relating to the employment of employees, from the books, reports, contracts, payrolls, documents, or papers of the person.
(c)Keep a record showing the names and addresses of all employees employed and the ages of all minors.
(d)Keep, at a central location in the state or at the plants or establishments at which employees are employed, payroll records showing the hours worked daily by and the wages paid to, and the number of piece-rate units earned by and any applicable piece rate paid to, employees employed at the respective plants or establishments. These records shall be kept in accordance with rules established for this purpose by the commission, but in any case shall be kept on file for not less than three years. An employer shall not prohibit an employee from maintaining a personal record of hours worked, or, if paid on a piece-rate basis, piece-rate units earned.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 15, 2016 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 6, 2015 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 18, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 60. Noes 20. Page 2997.). |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 28. Page 2990.) |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 60. Noes 20.). |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Ayes 52. Noes 28.) |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 9, 2015 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 8, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 24. Noes 15. Page 2593.). |
| Sep 8, 2015 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 10 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 8, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 4, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 31, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 27, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 27). |
| Jul 13, 2015 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jun 30, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 29, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 25, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 24). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 15, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on L. & I.R. |
| May 21, 2015 | Referred to Com. on L. & I.R. |
| May 11, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 11, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 59. Noes 18. Page 1389.) |
| May 11, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 7, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 6, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 4.) (May 6). |
| May 4, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| Feb 13, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 12, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2015 | AB 305 GONZALEZ Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 8, 2015 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB305 Gonzalez By Block | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2015 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 13, 2015 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2015 | AB 305 GONZALEZ Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
AB 305
(Gonzalez)
As Enrolled September 14, 2015
2/3 vote
ASSEMBLY: |
59-18 |
(May 11, 2015) |
SENATE: |
24-15 |
(September 8, 2015) |
ASSEMBLY: |
60-20 |
(September 9, 2015) |
|
|
|
Original Committee Reference: INS.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of certain gender-related characteristics in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits granting the disabling effects of breast cancer a lower disability rating than granted to the disabling effects of prostate cancer.
Prohibits the use of pregnancy, or menopause, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a physical injury.
Prohibits the use of sexual harassment, pregnancy, or menopause, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a psychiatric injury.
The Senate amendments:
Clarify that the bill applies only to injuries that occur on or after January 1, 2016.
Delete osteoporosis from the list of conditions prohibited to be used for apportioning permanent disability.
Renumber the requirement that breast cancer obtain the same rating as prostate cancer so that it constitutes a stand-alone Labor Code Section.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits to workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, or to prior non-industrial causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these prior causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would incur costs (special funds) of $4.25 million in the first year, and $4 million annually thereafter to implement the provisions of the bill. In addition, as a direct employer, the State would incur unknown, but potentially significant increased permanent disability costs due to breast cancer. This bill also would result in unknown, but potentially significant increased litigation costs to the State as a direct employer.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, "[w]hile current law prohibits workers compensation claims from being denied based on certain protected class characteristics, it does not clearly prohibit gender or other characteristics from being taken into account when apportioning an injury. Additionally, current law requires physicians to identify "other factors" when apportioning an injury. This leaves a loophole in which an injury can be attributed to conditions predominantly or only found among the workers' gender." Proponents assert that lawyers who represent injured workers report that they have cases where women have had the conditions cited in the bill used as a reason to reduce permanent disability benefits.
Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of the bill and opponents of the bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least seven years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. The California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA), in its letter in support of this bill, cites several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. Without getting into too much case-specific detail, two things appear from the cited examples: first, the characteristics used to reduce permanent disability awards appear to be risk factors or broad characteristics like those the Vaira case (see below) prohibits; second, in each example, it is claimed that "the doctor determined" the offending apportionment factor. Opponents have argued that "dumb doctors" making ill-advised, discriminatory apportionment statements are not a basis to change the law – they are a basis for the attorney representing the injured worker to argue to a workers compensation judge that the doctor recommended an illegal or inappropriate factor that does not support apportionment. Opponents state that they are unaware of any workers' compensation judge or Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) decision that has adopted or endorsed apportionment on the basis of the considerations cited by CAAA.
Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. However, causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment. While the current apportionment statute was adopted in the 2004 workers' compensation reform, the principle dates back nearly a century in California law.
Case law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation. This is the rule Governor Brown alluded to in his AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011, Veto Message (see below).
Is case law gender discrimination? Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by the bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
Breast cancer vs. prostate cancer. A key provision in the bill that proponents argue cures gender discrimination is the mandate that breast cancer and prostate cancer be treated the same in terms of disability ratings. Since 2004, the AMA guides has been the basis in California law for making PD determinations.
The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide "a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments". The Guides define "impairment" as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. The Guides deal chapter by chapter with specific areas of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discuss how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a PD rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment, and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to "rate by analogy" or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment.
Proponents of the bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective in this context. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16% to 20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women.
However, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene's gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence in women.
A review of how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries shows that there is a comparable WPI rating. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26% to 35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. Thus, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Psychiatric injuries. Psychiatric injuries, and the addition of sexual harassment as a prohibited apportionment factor for psychiatric injuries, poses some unique issues in addition to the issues associated with physical injuries.
First, due to the "contemporaneous" element of the bill, it appears that sexual harassment cannot be used to apportion a permanent disability caused by a psychiatric injury, but this sexual harassment must be contemporaneous. Most logically, the psychiatric injury would have to be caused by a sexual harassment. If that is the case, then it is difficult to understand how the sexual harassment could operate to reduce any permanent disability. On the other hand, if the psychiatric injury is not caused by the sexual harassment, but by some other stressor that causes psychiatric injury, it is difficult to understand how a contemporaneous sexual harassment would be involved.
Second, but partially related to the first point, psychiatric injuries are treated differently than physical injuries in two significant ways: a) in order to qualify for compensation, the psychiatric injury must be predominantly work caused, and b) psychiatric injuries that are not the primary injury, but rather are consequences of the primary injury, are no longer included in the PD calculation. Opponents argue that all of these uncertainties, coupled with the unique way the law treats psychiatric injuries, will inevitably lead to costly litigation.
Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155, addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor. The Veto Message to AB 1155 provided:
This bill would state that workers' compensation injury determinations shall not include consideration of race, religious creed, color, national origin, age, gender, marital status, sex, sexual orientation, or genetic characteristics.
The courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any of these classifications is antithetical to our states' non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best, that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers' compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the courts.
This bill takes a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, the bill proposes to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. This bill identifies specific factors that proponents argue are inappropriate apportionment factors, and prohibits their use regardless of whether there is factual causation.
This bill prohibits the use of certain gender-related characteristics in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016.
The workers compensation system must be free of gender-bias. No group should receive less in benefits because of an immutable characteristic. However, this bill is based on a misunderstanding of the American Medical Association's evidence-based standard, which is the foundation of the permanent disability ratings, and replaces it with an ill-defined and unscientific standard.
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0002539
AB 305
Page 5
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
AB 305
(Gonzalez)
As Amended September 3, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: |
59-18 |
(May 11, 2015) |
SENATE: |
24-15 |
(September 8, 2015) |
Original Committee Reference: INS.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of certain gender-related characteristics in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits granting the disabling effects of breast cancer a lower disability rating than granted to the disabling effects of prostate cancer.
Prohibits the use of pregnancy, or menopause, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a physical injury.
Prohibits the use of sexual harassment, pregnancy, or menopause, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a psychiatric injury.
The Senate amendments:
Clarify that this bill applies only to injuries that occur on or after January 1, 2016.
Delete osteoporosis from the list of conditions prohibited to be used for apportioning permanent disability.
Renumber the requirement that breast cancer obtain the same rating as prostate cancer so that it constitutes a stand-alone Labor Code Section.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits to workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, or to prior non-industrial causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these prior causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would incur costs (special funds) of $4.25 million in the first year, and $4 million annually thereafter to implement the provisions of this bill. In addition, as a direct employer, the state would incur unknown, but potentially significant increased permanent disability costs due to breast cancer. This bill also would result in unknown, but potentially significant increased litigation costs to the state as a direct employer.
COMMENTS: Purpose. According to the author, "[w]hile current law prohibits workers compensation claims from being denied based on certain protected class characteristics, it does not clearly prohibit gender or other characteristics from being taken into account when apportioning an injury. Additionally, current law requires physicians to identify "other factors" when apportioning an injury. This leaves a loophole in which an injury can be attributed to conditions predominantly or only found among the workers' gender." Proponents assert that lawyers who represent injured workers report that they have cases where women have had the conditions cited in the bill used as a reason to reduce permanent disability benefits.
Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of this bill and opponents of this bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least seven years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. The California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA), in its letter in support of this bill, cites several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. Without getting into too much case-specific detail, two things appear from the cited examples: first, the characteristics used to reduce permanent disability awards appear to be risk factors or broad characteristics like those the Vaira case (see below) prohibits; second, in each example, it is claimed that "the doctor determined" the offending apportionment factor. Opponents have argued that "dumb doctors" making ill-advised, discriminatory apportionment statements are not a basis to change the law – they are a basis for the attorney representing the injured worker to argue to a workers compensation judge that the doctor recommended an illegal or inappropriate factor that does not support apportionment. Opponents state that they are unaware of any workers' compensation judge or Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) decision that has adopted or endorsed apportionment on the basis of the considerations cited by CAAA.
Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. However, causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment. While the current apportionment statute was adopted in the 2004 workers' compensation reform, the principle dates back nearly a century in California law.
Case law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation. This is the rule Governor Brown alluded to in his AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011, Veto Message (see below).
Is case law gender discrimination? Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by this bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
Breast cancer vs. prostate cancer. A key provision in this bill that proponents argue cures gender discrimination is the mandate that breast cancer and prostate cancer be treated the same in terms of disability ratings. Since 2004, the AMA guides has been the basis in California law for making PD determinations.
The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide "a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments". The Guides define "impairment" as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. The Guides deal chapter by chapter with specific areas of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discuss how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a PD rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment, and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to "rate by analogy" or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment.
Proponents of this bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective in this context. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16% to 20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women.
However, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene's gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence in women.
A review of how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries shows that there is a comparable WPI rating. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26%-35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. Thus, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Psychiatric injuries. Psychiatric injuries, and the addition of sexual harassment as a prohibited apportionment factor for psychiatric injuries, poses some unique issues in addition to the issues associated with physical injuries.
First, due to the "contemporaneous" element of this bill, it appears that sexual harassment cannot be used to apportion a permanent disability caused by a psychiatric injury, but this sexual harassment must be contemporaneous. Most logically, the psychiatric injury would have to be caused by a sexual harassment. If that is the case, then it is difficult to understand how the sexual harassment could operate to reduce any permanent disability. On the other hand, if the psychiatric injury is not caused by the sexual harassment, but by some other stressor that causes psychiatric injury, it is difficult to understand how a contemporaneous sexual harassment would be involved.
Second, but partially related to the first point, psychiatric injuries are treated differently than physical injuries in two significant ways: a) in order to qualify for compensation, the psychiatric injury must be predominantly work caused, and b) psychiatric injuries that are not the primary injury, but rather are consequences of the primary injury, are no longer included in the PD calculation. Opponents argue that all of these uncertainties, coupled with the unique way the law treats psychiatric injuries, will inevitably lead to costly litigation.
Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155, addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor. The Veto Message to AB 1155 provided:
This bill would state that workers' compensation injury determinations shall not include consideration of race, religious creed, color, national origin, age, gender, marital status, sex, sexual orientation, or genetic characteristics.
The courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any of these classifications is antithetical to our states' non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best, that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers' compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the courts.
This bill takes a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, the bill proposes to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. This bill identifies specific factors that proponents argue are inappropriate apportionment factors, and prohibits their use regardless of whether there is factual causation.
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0002229
AB 305
Page 8
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 305
Amended: 9/3/15 in Senate
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/24/15
AYES: Mendoza, Jackson, Leno, Mitchell
NOES: Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/27/15
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, Leyva, Mendoza
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-18, 5/11/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
SOURCE: California Applicants’ Attorneys Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
DIGEST: This bill prohibits apportionment if pregnancy or menopause is contemporaneous with the injured worker’s claimed injury. This bill also requires that breast cancer not be less than the comparable impairment rating for prostate cancer.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/3/15 remove “osteoporosis casually related to menopause” from the list of conditions where apportionment is prohibited.
Existing law:
Establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
Requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
Requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
Creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating. (Labor Code §4660.1)
Requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of PD include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the PD was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
This bill:
Requires that WPI ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable WPI ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Prohibits apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy or menopause if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury.
Prohibits apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury caused by sexual harassment or any of the conditions listed above if the conditions are contemporaneous with the psychiatric injury.
Comments
1. A Brief Word on the AMA Guides: The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide “a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments”. The Guides define “impairment” as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. Excluding the introductory chapters, each chapter of the AMA Guides deals with a specific area of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discusses how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a PD rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to “rate by analogy” or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment (see Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808).
However, some proponents of the bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective, specifically in the area of gender-specific injuries. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16%-20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women. This line of argument, however, has some difficulties.
First, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene’s gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence.
When we look at how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries, we see comparable WPI ratings. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26%-35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. In short, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Second, as was noted above, a higher WPI indicates a higher level of impairment, and the removal of a prostate is only rated as a 16%-20% WPI if the prostate removal led to sexual dysfunction or urinary incontinence. According to the American Cancer Society, 25% to 75% of men who have their prostate removed will be impotent, depending on the age and health of the men.
The American Cancer Society does not note similar challenges after recovering from a mastectomy, which is the surgical removal of the mammary glands. If a mastectomy resulted in comparable impairment, a doctor would be able to provide a WPI rating comparable to the removal of the prostate through SB 863 and Guzman. The American Cancer Society does note that 20% to 30% of women develop neuropathic pain near the site of the surgery, though most women report that these symptoms are not severe. If they were severe pain, it is likely that they would be ratable through the AMA Guides chapter on Pain.
As was noted above, AB 305 makes breast cancer sequelae (or consequences of injury or disease) equally ratable as prostate cancer sequelae. The likely consequence of this is that it would require that mastectomies are rated the same as prostate removal.
2. A Brief Word on Apportionment: Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. WCAB case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
Not speculative;
Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability.
(See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of physician failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would incur costs (special funds) of $4.25 million in the first year, and $4 million annually thereafter to implement the provisions of the bill.
As a direct employer, the State would incur increased permanent disability costs due to breast cancer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
AB 305 also would result in increased litigation costs to the State as a direct employer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
California Applicant’s Attorneys (co-source)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council (co-source)
American Association of University Women – AAUW of CA
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
California State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police
Engineers & Scientists of California
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
Long Beach Police Officers Association
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Organization of SMUD Employees
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Professional & Technical Engineers
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association
San Bernardino Public Employees Association
San Diego County Court Employees Association
San Luis Obispo County Employees Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
The United Nurses Association of California
Union of Health Care Professionals
United Food & Commercial Workers
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
9to5 of California
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
County of Los Angeles
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
League of California Cities
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Occupational & Environmental Medical Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The sponsor of this bill, the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA), argues that AB 305 will eliminate gender bias from apportionment when determining permanent disability ratings. CAAA argues that factors such as pregnancy and menopause are used as factors to lower permanent disability. CAAA also cites several cases where apportionment is purported to have occurred due to risk factors and immutable characteristics, rather than proven conditions. CAAA also notes that AB 305 will make breast cancer eligible for the same disability rating as prostate cancer. Finally, CAAA argues that the workers’ compensation system treats being a woman as a pre-existing condition, and that AB 305 will ensure that women receive the level of permanent disability they deserve.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents argue that AB 305 is an attempt to undermine an employer’s use of apportionment when determining liability for permanent disability awards. Specifically, opponents note that apportionment is more than a decade old and ensures that employers do not need to pay for non-industrial injuries. Further, opponents point to case law and statute which protects injured workers from abusive apportionment, including apportionment on the basis of gender. Opponents further argue that AB 305 will increase litigation, raise indemnity costs on employers, and increase systemic instability and subjectivity.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-18, 5/11/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Williams, Wood
NOES: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Beth Gaines, Grove, Harper, Jones, Kim, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Wagner, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chang, Gallagher, Atkins
Prepared by: Gideon L. Baum / L. & I.R. / (916) 651-1556
9/4/15 11:58:53
**** END ****
AB 305
Page 8
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 305
Amended: 6/30/15 in Senate
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/24/15
AYES: Mendoza, Jackson, Leno, Mitchell
NOES: Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/27/15
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, Leyva, Mendoza
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-18, 5/11/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
SOURCE: California Applicants’ Attorneys Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
DIGEST: This bill prohibits apportionment if pregnancy, menopause, or menopause-caused osteoporosis is contemporaneous with the injured worker’s claimed injury. This bill also requires that breast cancer not be less than the comparable impairment rating for prostate cancer.
Existing law:
Establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
Requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
Requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
Creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating. (Labor Code §4660.1)
Requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of PD include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the PD was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
This bill:
Requires that WPI ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable WPI ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Prohibits apportionment in cases of physical injury based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
Pregnancy;
Menopause; and
Osteoporosis casually related to menopause.
Prohibit apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury caused by sexual harassment or any of the conditions listed above if the conditions are contemporaneous with the psychiatric injury.
Comments:
A Brief Word on the AMA Guides: The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide “a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments”. The Guides define “impairment” as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. Excluding the introductory chapters, each chapter of the AMA Guides deals with a specific area of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discusses how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a Permanent Disability (PD) rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment, and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to “rate by analogy” or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment (see Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808).
However, some proponents of the bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective, specifically in the area of gender-specific injuries. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16%-20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women. This line of argument, however, has some difficulties.
First, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene’s gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence.
When we look at how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries, we see comparable WPI ratings. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26%-35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. In short, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Second, as was noted above, a higher WPI indicates a higher level of impairment, and the removal of a prostate is only rated as a 16%-20% WPI if the prostate removal led to sexual dysfunction or urinary incontinence. According to the American Cancer Society, 25% to 75% of men who have their prostate removed will be impotent, depending on the age and health of the men.
The American Cancer Society does not note similar challenges after recovering from a mastectomy, which is the surgical removal of the mammary glands. If a mastectomy resulted in comparable impairment, a doctor would be able to provide a WPI rating comparable to the removal of the prostate through SB 863 and Guzman. The American Cancer Society does note that 20% to 30% of women develop neuropathic pain near the site of the surgery, though most women report that these symptoms are not severe. If they were severe pain, it is likely that they would be ratable through the AMA Guides chapter on Pain.
As was noted above, AB 305 makes breast cancer sequelae (or consequences of injury or disease) equally ratable as prostate cancer sequelae. The likely consequence of this is that it would require that mastectomies are rated the same as prostate removal.
A Brief Word on Apportionment: Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. WCAB case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
Not speculative;
Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability.
(See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of physician failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would incur costs (special funds) of $4.25 million in the first year, and $4 million annually thereafter to implement the provisions of the bill.
As a direct employer, the State would incur increased permanent disability costs due to breast cancer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
AB 305 also would result in increased litigation costs to the State as a direct employer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
California Applicant’s Attorneys (co-source)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council (co-source)
American Association of University Women – AAUW of CA
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
California State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police
Engineers & Scientists of California
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
LA County Professional Peace Officers Association
Long Beach Police Officers Association
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Motor Carrier Supervisors
Organization of SMUD Employees
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Professional & Technical Engineers
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association
San Bernardino Public Employees Association
San Diego County Court Employees Association
San Luis Obispo County Employees Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
The United Nurses Association of California
Union of Health Care Professionals
United Food & Commercial Workers
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
9to5 of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/15)
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
County of Los Angeles
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
League of California Cities
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Occupational & Environmental Medical Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The sponsor of this bill, the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA), argues that AB 305 will eliminate gender bias from apportionment when determining permanent disability ratings. CAAA argues that factors such as pregnancy and menopause are used as factors to lower permanent disability. CAAA also cites several cases where apportionment is purported to have occurred due to risk factors and immutable characteristics, rather than proven conditions. CAAA also notes that AB 305 will make breast cancer eligible for the same disability rating as prostate cancer. Finally, CAAA argues that the workers’ compensation system treats being a woman as a pre-existing condition, and that AB 305 will ensure that women receive the level of permanent disability they deserve.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents argue that AB 305 is an attempt to undermine an employer’s use of apportionment when determining liability for permanent disability awards. Specifically, opponents note that apportionment is more than a decade old and ensures that employers do not need to pay for non-industrial injuries. Further, opponents point to case law and statute which protects injured workers from abusive apportionment, including apportionment on the basis of gender. Opponents further argue that AB 305 will increase litigation, raise indemnity costs on employers, and increase systemic instability and subjectivity.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-18, 5/11/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Williams, Wood
NOES: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Dahle, Beth Gaines, Grove, Harper, Jones, Kim, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Wagner, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chang, Gallagher, Atkins
Prepared by: Gideon L. Baum / L. & I.R. / (916) 651-1556
8/31/15 18:29:02
**** END ****
AB 305 (Gonzalez) Page 3 of 3
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 305 (Gonzalez) - Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
|
|
Version: June 30, 2015 |
Policy Vote: L. & I.R. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: No |
Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: July 13, 2015 |
Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
For injuries occurring after January 1, 2016, AB 305 would (1) prohibit apportionment if pregnancy, menopause, or menopause-caused osteoporosis is contemporaneous with the injured worker’s claimed injury, (2) prohibit apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury in specified instances, and (3) require that breast cancer not be less than the comparable impairment rating for prostate cancer.
Fiscal Impact:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) would incur costs (special funds) of $4.25 million in the first year, and $4 million annually thereafter to implement the provisions of the bill.
As a direct employer, the State would incur increased permanent disability costs due to breast cancer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
The bill also would result in increased litigation costs to the State as a direct employer. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant.
Background:
Current law establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that occurs during the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either (1) securing the consent of DIR to self-insure, or (2) securing insurance against liability from an insurance company authorized by the State.
Under current law, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI).
When physicians prepare a report regarding whether a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine both (1) causation, and (2) what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can make the determination whether and to what extent if apportionment is appropriate.
Additionally, current law creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40 percent and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability, also known as a PD rating. AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of zero percent, while the removal of a prostrate generally rates at 16 to 20 percent WPI. Thus, prostrate removal currently translates into a higher PD rating than female breast removal.
Proposed Law:
With respect to injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, this bill would do the following:
Prohibit apportionment in cases of physical injury based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury: (1) pregnancy; (2) menopause; and (3) osteoporosis casually related to menopause.
Prohibit apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury caused by sexual harassment or any of the conditions listed above if the conditions are contemporaneous with the psychiatric injury.
Require that WPI ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable WPI ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
Related Legislation:
AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011 addressed apportionment by broadly prohibiting the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
Staff Comments: The Office of the Legislative Counsel has keyed this bill “non-fiscal.” However, the purview of this Committee, pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5, is to review and analyze bills that would, among other things, result in a substantial expenditure of state money. Thus, even though AB 305 was keyed “non-fiscal,” the Committee requested the bill to examine the extent to which it might potentially increase both workload and state costs. AB 305 has the potential to create significant fiscal pressure on the state in the following ways: (1) increased litigation, leading to higher Workers Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) utilization, (2) increased PD costs due to breast cancer for the State of California as a direct employer (particularly for peace officers), and (3) increased litigation costs for the State of California as an employer.
Regarding WCAB utilization, it is assumed that there are about 90,000 claims annually where PD is owed. If, according to the April 2007, Commission on Health and Safety and Workers’ Compensation (CHSWC) report, 10.5 percent of disability evaluations include an apportionment component, then there will be roughly 9,000 claims per year where the conditions listed in the bill would have an impact.
The extent to which the effects of menopause, pregnancy, osteoporosis and a psychiatric injury from either those conditions or sexual harassment will actually result in the apportionment of disability is unknown. However, the prevalence of these conditions in women would likely produce more litigation to differentiate and identify the root cause of an apportionable impairment. If the 9,000 claims were to be disputed, but absent the bill they would not have been litigated, AB 305 would create a 13 percent increase in judicial workload of disputed cases. DIR estimates the additional workload would result in increased costs of about $4 million annually.
-- END --
AB 305 (Gonzalez) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
Senator Tony Mendoza, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 305 Hearing Date: June 24, 2015
Author: |
Gonzalez |
||
Version: |
June 15, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Gideon Baum |
||
Subject: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment.
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature prohibit apportionment if pregnancy, menopause, or menopause-caused osteoporosis is contemporaneous with the injured worker’s claimed injury?
Should the Legislature require that breast cancer not be less than the comparable impairment rating for prostate cancer, despite the fact that breast cancer does not generally create a comparable level of impairment?
ANALYSIS
Existing law establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
Existing law requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
Existing law requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
Existing law creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating. (Labor Code §4660.1)
Existing law requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
This bill would require that WPI ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable WPI ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
This bill would prohibit apportionment in cases of physical injury based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
Pregnancy;
Menopause; and
Osteoporosis casually related to menopause.
This bill would also prohibit apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury caused by sexual harassment or any of the conditions listed above if the conditions are contemporaneous with the psychiatric injury.
This bill would also remove the requirement that a physician include an apportionment determination in a permanent disability report.
COMMENTS
1. A Brief Word on the AMA Guides:
The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide “a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments”. The Guides define “impairment” as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. Excluding the introductory chapters, each chapter of the AMA Guides deals with a specific area of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discusses how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a Permanent Disability (PD) rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment, and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to “rate by analogy” or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment (see Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808).
However, some proponents of the bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective, specifically in the area of gender-specific injuries. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16%-20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women. This line of argument, however, has some difficulties.
First, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene’s gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence.
When we look at how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries, we see comparable WPI ratings. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26%-35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. In short, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Second, as was noted above, a higher WPI indicates a higher level of impairment, and the removal of a prostate is only rated as a 16%-20% WPI if the prostate removal led to sexual dysfunction or urinary incontinence. According to the American Cancer Society, 25% to 75% of men who have their prostate removed will be impotent, depending on the age and health of the men.
The American Cancer Society does not note similar challenges after recovering from a mastectomy, which is the surgical removal of the mammary glands. If a mastectomy resulted in comparable impairment, a doctor would be able to provide a WPI rating comparable to the removal of the prostate through SB 863 and Guzman. The American Cancer Society does note that 20% to 30% of women develop neuropathic pain near the site of the surgery, though most women report that these symptoms are not severe. If they were severe pain, it is likely that they would be ratable through the AMA Guides chapter on Pain.
As was noted above, AB 305 makes breast cancer sequelae (or consequences of injury or disease) equally ratable as prostate cancer sequelae. The likely consequence of this is that it would require that mastectomies are rated the same as prostate removal. The Committee may wish to consider if a mastectomy should be automatically rated as if it led to both sexual dysfunction and incontinence, despite the fact it generally does not.
2. A Brief Word on Apportionment:
Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. WCAB case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
Not speculative;
Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability.
(See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of physician failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade. Staff notes that it is currently unclear if such a small sample of apportionment examples demonstrates systemic inequality towards women or notable examples of physician error.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
3. Several Implementation Challenges Facing AB 305 and Apportionment:
AB 305 poses several unique questions on its full impact on the workers’ compensation system.
“Contemporaneous” and the WCAB
As was noted above, apportionment of a PD rating cannot occur if pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis casually related to menopause is contemporaneous with the physical injury. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines contemporaneous as “existing or happening during the same time period”. For specific injuries, such as a fall or a car accident, this could be a straight forward analysis: a doctor would simply exclude pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis from his or her apportionment determination.
For injuries that are the product of cumulative trauma, however, this may be a more complicated analysis. For cumulative trauma injuries, existing law requires that the injured worker must file a workers’ compensation a year from when the worker knew or should have known that the cumulative trauma injury was caused by work. It is unclear how AB 305 would impact apportionment with cumulative trauma injuries.
Would, for example, menopause being considered contemporaneous if it existed at the time of the filing? Or would the injured worker need to prove that she was going through menopause during employment? What if the worker was going through menopause but not osteoporosis during employment, but had osteoporosis at the time of filing a claim? Likely, these are fact-intensive analyses which may be clarified by future WCAB decisions, which would necessitate significant litigation. Therefore, it is likely that AB 305 would increase litigation costs for employers, particularly in the area of cumulative trauma claims.
Enshrining Gender Discrimination into the Workers’ Compensation System
Currently, California’s workers’ compensation system does not treat different groups of injured workers differently than others. As was noted above, the AMA Guides look solely at impairment; PD is awarded on the severity of injury. While adjustments may be made for occupation and age, there are no adjustments for race, gender, or religion. AB 305 changes that by excluding from apportionment conditions that are specific to women, despite the fact that some male injured workers may experience similar conditions.
For example, according to the National Osteoporosis Foundation (NOF), up to 25% of all men over 50 may have osteoporosis – and men over 50 are more likely to break a bone due to osteoporosis than get prostate cancer. Currently, both men and women could have their PD apportioned if osteoporosis was a non-industrial cause of injury. Under AB 305, however, women would be able to litigate that their menopause (which, according to NOF is only a risk factor for osteoporosis, not determinative) caused their osteoporosis, and therefore is non-industrial. Under AB 305, a male injured worker would have few to no legal avenues to contest the apportionment of his osteoporosis.
By creating a gender disparity for male and female injured workers, AB 305 may adversely impact some male injured workers and undermine the equity of the workers’ compensation system.
4. An Additional Note on Apportionment:
As was discussed above, AB 305 faces significant implementation. However, that does not mean that apportionment in and of itself is a policy that does not need additional legislative scrutiny. Rather, it may be time for a larger stakeholder discussion on if apportionment works as intended.
Surprisingly, there has been little recent study on apportionment. The last study on the impact of apportionment was done by the WCIRB in 2008, and that study found that about 6% of all PD dollars were apportioned. However, there have been significant increases in indemnity payments and litigation frequency, as well as loss-adjusted expenses (LAE), which tends to be a proxy for litigation costs.
Noting the strong evidence that apportionment is more likely in litigated cases, the current impact of apportionment on PD claims and dollars is an important policy question, and it is a policy question about which we know very, very little. Does apportionment still reduce PD dollars by 6%, or has it increased? Does apportionment make litigation more likely? Or does litigation make apportionment more likely? And would apportionment change the way either an applicant or defendant would litigate the case?
More fundamentally, however, there is an even more basic question with apportionment: does it actually save money, or is it a cost driver? If apportionment increases the likelihood of litigation or makes litigation more severe, it is possible that it actually serves as a cost driver in the system – one that is automatic with the physician’s completion of a PD report. While this is very unlikely, the reality is that we simply do not know the full impacts of apportionment.
Noting the significance of apportionment for employers and injured workers, stakeholders may wish to consider requesting that the Commission on Health and Safety and Workers’ Compensation (CHSWC) authorize a study on the current impacts of apportionment on litigation and PD dollars.
5. AB 305 and Retroactivity:
When AB 305 was heard in the Assembly Insurance Committee on May 5, 2015, both members and stakeholders raised concerns about AB 305 and the possibility of retroactive application of its provisions. At that time, Assemblymember Gonzalez said that was not her intent and committed to future amendments. AB 305 was amended on June 15, 2015, removing the retroactive provisions. The author’s office stated that the purpose of the amendments was to eliminate the possibility of retroactive application of AB 305’s provisions, and the sponsor’s letter also states the same.
Therefore, noting the strong legislative intent, it is unlikely that a court would find that the provisions of AB 305 are retroactive. The Committee may wish to further clarify this point by considering the following amendment, which would make AB 305’s apportionment provisions apply to injuries on or after January 1, 2016.
On page 6, page 1, strike “Apportionment” and insert: “For injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, apportionment”.
6. Proponent Arguments:
The sponsor of this bill, the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA), argues that AB 305 will eliminate gender bias from apportionment when determining permanent disability ratings. CAAA argues that factors such as pregnancy and menopause are used as factors to lower permanent disability. CAAA also cites several cases where apportionment is purported to have occurred due to risk factors and immutable characteristics, rather than proven conditions. CAAA also notes that AB 305 will make breast cancer eligible for the same disability rating as prostate cancer. Finally, CAAA argues that the workers’ compensation system treats being a woman as a pre-existing condition, and that AB 305 will ensure that women receive the level of permanent disability they deserve.
7. Opponent Arguments:
Opponents argue that AB 305 is an attempt to undermine an employer’s use of apportionment when determining liability for permanent disability awards. Specifically, opponents note that apportionment is more than a decade old and ensures that employers do not need to pay for non-industrial injuries. Further, opponents point to case law and statute which protects injured workers from abusive apportionment, including apportionment on the basis of gender. Opponents further argue that AB 305 will increase litigation, raise indemnity costs on employers, and increase systemic instability and subjectivity.
8. Prior Legislation:
AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011 addressed apportionment by broadly prohibiting the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. AB 1155 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who said the following is his veto message:
The
courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any
of these classifications is antithetical to our states'
non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that
apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes
to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle
that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would
not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This
bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of
whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best,
that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers'
compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate
interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the
courts.
SUPPORT
California Applicant’s Attorneys (co-sponsor)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council (co-sponsor)
American Association of University Women – AAUW of CA
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
California State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police
Engineers & Scientists of California
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
LA County Professional Peace Officers Association
Long Beach Police Officers Association
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Organization of SMUD Employees
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Professional & Technical Engineers
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association
San Bernardino Public Employees Association
San Diego County Court Employees Association
San Luis Obispo County Employees Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
The United Nurses Association of California
Union of Health Care Professionals
United Food & Commercial Workers
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
9to5 of California
OPPOSITION
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
County of Los Angeles
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
League of California Cities
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Occupational & Environmental Medical Association
-- END --
AB 305 (Gonzalez) Page 8 of 8
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
Senator Tony Mendoza, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 305 Hearing Date: June 24, 2015
Author: |
Gonzalez |
||
Version: |
June 15, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Gideon Baum |
||
Subject: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment.
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature prohibit apportionment if pregnancy, menopause, or menopause-caused osteoporosis is contemporaneous with the injured worker’s claimed injury?
Should the Legislature require that breast cancer not be less than the comparable impairment rating for prostate cancer, despite the fact that breast cancer does not generally create a comparable level of impairment?
ANALYSIS
Existing law establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
Existing law requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
Existing law requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
Existing law creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating. (Labor Code §4660.1)
Existing law requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
This bill would require that WPI ratings for breast cancer and its sequelae shall in no event be less than comparable WPI ratings for prostate cancer and its sequelae.
This bill would prohibit apportionment in cases of physical injury based on any of the following conditions if those conditions are contemporaneous with the claimed physical injury:
Pregnancy;
Menopause; and
Osteoporosis casually related to menopause.
This bill would also prohibit apportionment in cases of psychiatric injury caused by sexual harassment or any of the conditions listed above if the conditions are contemporaneous with the psychiatric injury.
COMMENTS
1. A Brief Word on the AMA Guides:
The AMA Guides were first published in 1971 to provide “a standardized, objective approach to evaluating medical impairments”. The Guides define “impairment” as a loss, loss of use, or derangement of any body part, organ system, or organ function. Excluding the introductory chapters, each chapter of the AMA Guides deals with a specific area of the body or a specific type of permanent impairment and discusses how to measure impairment in a specific individual. This impairment measurement is a percentage known as the whole person impairment (WPI), with a higher WPI percentage signifying a higher level of impairment.
WPI serves as the foundational calculation for the purposes of calculating a Permanent Disability (PD) rating. In bringing the AMA Guides into the workers’ compensation system in 2004, the goal was to make the measurement of impairment, and by extension PD ratings, more objective and uniform throughout the state and based on the best available medical evidence. Further, as a part of the 2012 reform, the Legislature codified case law that allows doctors to “rate by analogy” or to use other chapters of the AMA Guides if those chapters better explain the nature of the impairment (see Milpitas Unified School District v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Guzman) (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 808).
However, some proponents of the bill have argued that the AMA Guides are not objective, specifically in the area of gender-specific injuries. Specifically, proponents point to the fact that the AMA Guides rate the removal of female breasts at a WPI of 0%, while the removal of a prostate would rate a 16%-20% WPI, arguing that such a rating shows bias against women. This line of argument, however, has some difficulties.
First, the male prostate is not a strong equivalent to female breasts. The prostate is an exocrine gland that secretes fluid, assisting the mobility of sperm after ejaculation. As will be discussed in more detail below, removing the prostate can lead to both incontinence and impotence. The closest female equivalent, or homologue, to the prostate is the skene’s gland, which is located on the surface of the vulva. Alternatively, one could also look at urthereal disease, which would lead to incontinence.
When we look at how the AMA Guides rate the female equivalent injuries, we see comparable WPI ratings. For example, vulval disease where sexual intercourse is not possible would be 26%-35% WPI. Additionally, urthereal disease which leads to stress incontinence would be a 25% WPI at a minimum. In short, when looking at comparable injuries, both men and women appear to receive comparable ratings through the AMA Guides.
Second, as was noted above, a higher WPI indicates a higher level of impairment, and the removal of a prostate is only rated as a 16%-20% WPI if the prostate removal led to sexual dysfunction or urinary incontinence. According to the American Cancer Society, 25% to 75% of men who have their prostate removed will be impotent, depending on the age and health of the men.
The American Cancer Society does not note similar challenges after recovering from a mastectomy, which is the surgical removal of the mammary glands. If a mastectomy resulted in comparable impairment, a doctor would be able to provide a WPI rating comparable to the removal of the prostate through SB 863 and Guzman. The American Cancer Society does note that 20% to 30% of women develop neuropathic pain near the site of the surgery, though most women report that these symptoms are not severe. If they were severe pain, it is likely that they would be ratable through the AMA Guides chapter on Pain.
As was noted above, AB 305 makes breast cancer sequelae (or consequences of injury or disease) equally ratable as prostate cancer sequelae. The likely consequence of this is that it would require that mastectomies are rated the same as prostate removal. The Committee may wish to consider if a mastectomy should be automatically rated as if it led to both sexual dysfunction and incontinence, despite the fact it generally does not.
2. A Brief Word on Apportionment:
Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. WCAB case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
Not speculative;
Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability.
(See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of physician failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade. Staff notes that it is currently unclear if such a small sample of apportionment examples demonstrates systemic inequality towards women or notable examples of physician error.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
3. Several Implementation Challenges Facing AB 305 and Apportionment:
AB 305 poses several unique questions on its full impact on the workers’ compensation system.
“Contemporaneous” and the WCAB
As was noted above, apportionment of a PD rating cannot occur if pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis casually related to menopause is contemporaneous with the physical injury. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines contemporaneous as “existing or happening during the same time period”. For specific injuries, such as a fall or a car accident, this could be a straight forward analysis: a doctor would simply exclude pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis from his or her apportionment determination.
For injuries that are the product of cumulative trauma, however, this may be a more complicated analysis. For cumulative trauma injuries, existing law requires that the injured worker must file a workers’ compensation a year from when the worker knew or should have known that the cumulative trauma injury was caused by work. It is unclear how AB 305 would impact apportionment with cumulative trauma injuries.
Would, for example, menopause being considered contemporaneous if it existed at the time of the filing? Or would the injured worker need to prove that she was going through menopause during employment? What if the worker was going through menopause but not osteoporosis during employment, but had osteoporosis at the time of filing a claim? Likely, these are fact-intensive analyses which may be clarified by future WCAB decisions, which would necessitate significant litigation. Therefore, it is likely that AB 305 would increase litigation costs for employers, particularly in the area of cumulative trauma claims.
Enshrining Gender Discrimination into the Workers’ Compensation System
Currently, California’s workers’ compensation system does not treat different groups of injured workers differently than others. As was noted above, the AMA Guides look solely at impairment; PD is awarded on the severity of injury. While adjustments may be made for occupation and age, there are no adjustments for race, gender, or religion. AB 305 changes that by excluding from apportionment conditions that are specific to women, despite the fact that some male injured workers may experience similar conditions.
For example, according to the National Osteoporosis Foundation (NOF), up to 25% of all men over 50 may have osteoporosis – and men over 50 are more likely to break a bone due to osteoporosis than get prostate cancer. Currently, both men and women could have their PD apportioned if osteoporosis was a non-industrial cause of injury. Under AB 305, however, women would be able to litigate that their menopause (which, according to NOF is only a risk factor for osteoporosis, not determinative) caused their osteoporosis, and therefore is non-industrial. Under AB 305, a male injured worker would have few to no legal avenues to contest the apportionment of his osteoporosis.
By creating a gender disparity for male and female injured workers, AB 305 may adversely impact some male injured workers and undermine the equity of the workers’ compensation system.
4. An Additional Note on Apportionment:
As was discussed above, AB 305 faces significant implementation. However, that does not mean that apportionment in and of itself is a policy that does not need additional legislative scrutiny. Rather, it may be time for a larger stakeholder discussion on if apportionment works as intended.
Surprisingly, there has been little recent study on apportionment. The last study on the impact of apportionment was done by the WCIRB in 2008, and that study found that about 6% of all PD dollars were apportioned. However, there have been significant increases in indemnity payments and litigation frequency, as well as loss-adjusted expenses (LAE), which tends to be a proxy for litigation costs.
Noting the strong evidence that apportionment is more likely in litigated cases, the current impact of apportionment on PD claims and dollars is an important policy question, and it is a policy question about which we know very, very little. Does apportionment still reduce PD dollars by 6%, or has it increased? Does apportionment make litigation more likely? Or does litigation make apportionment more likely? And would apportionment change the way either an applicant or defendant would litigate the case?
More fundamentally, however, there is an even more basic question with apportionment: does it actually save money, or is it a cost driver? If apportionment increases the likelihood of litigation or makes litigation more severe, it is possible that it actually serves as a cost driver in the system – one that is automatic with the physician’s completion of a PD report. While this is very unlikely, the reality is that we simply do not know the full impacts of apportionment.
Noting the significance of apportionment for employers and injured workers, stakeholders may wish to consider requesting that the Commission on Health and Safety and Workers’ Compensation (CHSWC) authorize a study on the current impacts of apportionment on litigation and PD dollars.
5. AB 305 and Retroactivity:
When AB 305 was heard in the Assembly Insurance Committee on May 5, 2015, both members and stakeholders raised concerns about AB 305 and the possibility of retroactive application of its provisions. At that time, Assemblymember Gonzalez said that was not her intent and committed to future amendments. AB 305 was amended on June 15, 2015, removing the retroactive provisions. The author’s office stated that the purpose of the amendments was to eliminate the possibility of retroactive application of AB 305’s provisions, and the sponsor’s letter also states the same.
Therefore, noting the strong legislative intent, it is unlikely that a court would find that the provisions of AB 305 are retroactive. The Committee may wish to further clarify this point by considering the following amendment, which would make AB 305’s apportionment provisions apply to injuries on or after January 1, 2016.
On page 6, page 1, strike “Apportionment” and insert: “For injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2016, apportionment”.
6. Proponent Arguments:
The sponsor of this bill, the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA), argues that AB 305 will eliminate gender bias from apportionment when determining permanent disability ratings. CAAA argues that factors such as pregnancy and menopause are used as factors to lower permanent disability. CAAA also cites several cases where apportionment is purported to have occurred due to risk factors and immutable characteristics, rather than proven conditions. CAAA also notes that AB 305 will make breast cancer eligible for the same disability rating as prostate cancer. Finally, CAAA argues that the workers’ compensation system treats being a woman as a pre-existing condition, and that AB 305 will ensure that women receive the level of permanent disability they deserve.
7. Opponent Arguments:
Opponents argue that AB 305 is an attempt to undermine an employer’s use of apportionment when determining liability for permanent disability awards. Specifically, opponents note that apportionment is more than a decade old and ensures that employers do not need to pay for non-industrial injuries. Further, opponents point to case law and statute which protects injured workers from abusive apportionment, including apportionment on the basis of gender. Opponents further argue that AB 305 will increase litigation, raise indemnity costs on employers, and increase systemic instability and subjectivity.
8. Prior Legislation:
AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011 addressed apportionment by broadly prohibiting the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. AB 1155 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who said the following is his veto message:
The
courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any
of these classifications is antithetical to our states'
non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that
apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes
to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle
that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would
not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This
bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of
whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best,
that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers'
compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate
interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the
courts.
SUPPORT
California Applicant’s Attorneys (co-sponsor)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council (co-sponsor)
American Association of University Women – AAUW of CA
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association, AFL-CIO
California State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police
Engineers & Scientists of California
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
LA County Professional Peace Officers Association
Long Beach Police Officers Association
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Organization of SMUD Employees
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Professional & Technical Engineers
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association
San Bernardino Public Employees Association
San Diego County Court Employees Association
San Luis Obispo County Employees Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
The United Nurses Association of California
Union of Health Care Professionals
United Food & Commercial Workers
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
9to5 of California
OPPOSITION
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
County of Los Angeles
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
League of California Cities
Marin County Board of Supervisors
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Occupational & Environmental Medical Association
-- END --
AB 305
Page 6
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 305
(Gonzalez)
As Amended April 30, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Insurance |
9-4 |
Daly, Calderon, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Frazier, Gatto, Gonzalez, Rodriguez |
Beth Gaines, Travis Allen, Grove, Mayes |
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of certain gender-related characteristics in the calculation of permanent disability benefits. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits granting the disabling effects of breast cancer a lower disability rating than granted to the disabling effects of prostate cancer.
Prohibits the use of pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a physical injury.
Prohibits the use of sexual harassment, pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a psychiatric injury.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits to workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, or to prior non-industrial causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these prior causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, "[w]hile current law prohibits workers compensation claims from being denied based on certain protected class characteristics, it does not clearly prohibit gender or other characteristics from being taken into account when apportioning an injury. Additionally, current law requires physicians to identify "other factors" when apportioning an injury. This leaves a loophole in which an injury can be attributed to conditions predominantly or only found among the workers' gender." Proponents assert that lawyers who represent injured workers report that they have cases where women have had the conditions cited in this bill used as a reason to reduce permanent disability benefits.
Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. However, causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment.
Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155 (Alejo), addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor. The veto message to AB 1155 provided:
"This bill would state that workers' compensation injury determinations shall not include consideration of race, religious creed, color, national origin, age, gender, marital status, sex, sexual orientation, or genetic characteristics.
The courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any of these classifications is antithetical to our states' non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best, that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers' compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the courts."
This bill takes a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, this bill proposes to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 veto message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. This bill identifies specific factors that proponents argue are inappropriate apportionment factors, and prohibits their use regardless of whether there is factual causation.
Case law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation. This is the rule Governor Brown alluded to in his AB 1155 veto message.
Gender discrimination. Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by this bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of this bill and opponents of this bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least 7 years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. The California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA), in its letter in support of this bill, cites several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. Without getting into too much case-specific detail, two things appear from the cited examples: first, the characteristics used to reduce permanent disability awards appear to be risk factors or broad characteristics like those the Vaira case prohibited; second, in each example, it is claimed that "the doctor determined" the offending apportionment factor. Opponents have argued that "dumb doctors" making ill-advised, discriminatory apportionment statements are not a basis to change the law – they are a basis for the attorney representing the injured worker to argue to a workers compensation judge that the doctor recommended an illegal or inappropriate factor that does not support apportionment. Opponents state that they are unaware of any workers' compensation judge or WCAB decision that has adopted or endorsed apportionment on the basis of the considerations cited by CAAA.
Contemporaneous. Recent amendments to this bill provide that, in order for the gender-related factor to be a prohibited basis for apportionment, that factor must occur "contemporaneous" with the industrial injury that is causing permanent disability. The amendment is intended to ensure that prior factual conditions that may have been associated with a prohibited characteristic may still be used for apportionment. For example, if a pregnant woman suffers a back injury due, in some factually causative way, to pregnancy, and she has an existing back injury, this prior back injury is acceptable for purposes of apportionment when she suffers an industrial back injury 5 years after her pregnancy. Or, in the case of a psychiatric injury, a sexual harassment at the hands of a college professor five years prior to the industrial psychiatric injury that contributes to the permanent disability would not be prohibited as a basis to apportion the permanent disability.
While acknowledging that the purpose of this amendment serves to narrow this bill, and eliminate one of the concerns that remote, but factual, prior injuries would be used to argue against legitimate apportionment, opponents fear that the language fails to accomplish that goal, and that old, factual injuries will still be used to argue against apportioning job-related disability for non-job-related factors. This is a consistent theme in opponents' objections to this bill – that much of the practical effect of this bill will be to establish vague and uncertain factors that cannot be used to apportion permanent disability, with a resulting substantial increase in frictional litigation costs.
In this regard, it is important to note how courts treat legislative enactments that add new language to statutes. One of the most important rules of statutory construction is that "significance should be given to every word, phrase, sentence and part of an act" and that the Legislature does not engage in idle acts or adopt words that are mere surplusage. Thus, when the Legislature chooses to use certain words in a statute, the courts will assume that something specific was meant by those words, and seek to ascertain what that meaning is. From the opponents perspective, the addition of the "contemporaneous" amendment will enable a broad range of litigation in an effort determine what the Legislature intended.
In addition, this concern about how courts will interpret other terms in the bill, and the frictional litigation costs associated with those court proceedings, underpins many of the opposition's arguments with the substantive factors the bill proposes. Even those insurers and employers who profess that "we don't apportion to those factors" fear frictional expenses associated with litigants' efforts to obtain advantage by broad use of vague terms.
Menopause. Without question, menopause is a gender-based characteristic that ought not be used as a basis to apportion permanent disability. Opponents even state that "we don't do that." However, the effect of adding menopause to the apportionment statute causes opponents great concern. They point out that courts have held that menopause is not a disability. They also point out that there are any number of symptoms that may or may not be associated with menopause, and if any of those symptoms is associated with a factual pre-existing condition that contributes to permanent disability, there will be costly litigation because attorneys would be duty-bound to pursue the argument that menopause, and not the symptom, is the actual basis for the proposed apportionment.
Pregnancy. As with menopause, it is difficult to argue that permanent disabilities ought to be apportioned due to pregnancy. Indeed, many employers and insurers argue that this is not done, nor is it allowed in the workers' compensation system. However, they point out that adding this characteristic to the statute poses problems. First, they argue that it confuses the idea of causation to injury with causation to disability. They suggest that pregnancy can contribute to injury, but it is hard to understand how it is a condition that causes permanent disability. However, by adding pregnancy to the apportionment statue, uncertainties are created that will cause extended litigation to determine the precise meaning of the statutory change.
Osteoporosis. Osteoporosis presents a fundamental difference of perspective as between proponents and opponents. This is a predominantly (although not exclusively) female medical condition involving loss of bone mass, and the resulting risk of broken bones and other complications. Proponents argue that it is fundamentally wrong to reduce a woman's permanent disability award for a physical injury that occurs on the job due to this inherently gender-specific causation factor. Opponents, on the other hand, argue that it is fundamentally wrong to require employers to pay for disability that is factually unrelated to employment.
Psychiatric injuries. Psychiatric injuries, and the addition of sexual harassment as a prohibited apportionment factor for psychiatric injuries, poses some unique issues in addition to the issues associated with physical injuries.
First, due to the "contemporaneous" element of the current version of the bill, it appears that sexual harassment cannot be used to apportion a permanent disability caused by a psychiatric injury, but this sexual harassment must be contemporaneous. Most logically, the psychiatric injury would have to be caused by a sexual harassment. If that is the case, then it is difficult to understand how the sexual harassment could operate to reduce any permanent disability. On the other hand, if the psychiatric injury is not caused by the sexual harassment, but by some other stressor that causes psychiatric injury, it is difficult to understand how a contemporaneous sexual harassment would be involved.
Second, but partially related to the first point, psychiatric injuries are treated differently than physical injuries in at least two significant ways: 1) in order to qualify for compensation, the psychiatric injury must be predominantly work caused, and 2) psychiatric injuries that are not the primary injury, but rather are consequences of the primary injury, are no longer included in the total PD calculation. Opponents argue that all of these uncertainties, coupled with the unique way the law treats psychiatric injuries, will inevitably lead to costly litigation. In making this argument, the opposition asserts that they are in no way seeking to justify an employer that commits or allows sexual harassment in the workplace. Nonetheless, they find it difficult to understand exactly how the bill changes the law, and thus have the concerns noted above.
Breast cancer. Breast cancer is the one aspect of this bill that has nothing to do with apportionment. Rather, this bill prohibits giving a lower PD rating to a woman based on the "sequelae" associated with breast cancer as compared with the sequelae associated with prostate cancer. ("Sequelae" means pathological conditions resulting from a disease.) This would be a public policy judgment that the permanent disability "value" associated with breast cancer (women) should be the same as the permanent disability "value" associated with prostate cancer (men). In essence, it would be a public policy judgment that these two cancers have comparable effects on their respective victims.
The 2004 workers' compensation reform (SB 899 (Poochigian), Chapter 34, Statutes of 2004) sought to reduce the subjectivity of the permanent disability system, and replace it with a more objective method of determining PD. One of the ways SB 899 sought to accomplish this goal was to adopt the AMA Guides as the basis for calculating the level of impairment caused by industrial injuries. The underlying premise was that objective, scientific evaluations and determinations of the consequences of various disabling conditions ought to displace the prior system which relied upon subjective evaluations and litigation, with judges making the final determinations. The AMA Guides are used in a number of states as the best source of objective, medically expert-based classifications of impairment.
This bill proposes, with respect to breast cancer, to replace the judgment that went into the AMA Guides with a public policy judgment that equates two different conditions that proponents argue are similar as a matter of public policy. Opponents object that this entry into subjective policy judgments is a slippery slope that will, eventually, undermine the AMA guides as arbiter of objective evidence-based medical impairment evaluations.
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0000305
AB 305
Page 7
Date of Hearing: May 6, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
AB 305
Gonzalez – As Amended April 30, 2015
SUBJECT: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability: gender discrimination
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of certain gender-related characteristics in the calculation of permanent disability benefits. Specifically, this bill:
Prohibits granting the disabling effects of breast cancer a lower disability rating than granted to the disabling effects of prostate cancer.
Prohibits the use of pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a physical injury.
Prohibits the use of sexual harassment, pregnancy, menopause, or osteoporosis, if these conditions are contemporaneous with the industrial injury causing the disability, to apportion permanent disability with respect to a psychiatric injury.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits to workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, or to prior non-industrial causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these prior causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, "[w]hile current law prohibits workers compensation claims from being denied based on certain protected class characteristics, it does not clearly prohibit gender or other characteristics from being taken into account when apportioning an injury. Additionally, current law requires physicians to identify "other factors" when apportioning an injury. This leaves a loophole in which an injury can be attributed to conditions predominantly or only found among the workers' gender." Proponents assert that lawyers who represent injured workers report that they have cases where women have had the conditions cited in the bill used as a reason to reduce permanent disability benefits.
Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. However, causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment.Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155 (Alejo), addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike AB 305, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor. The Veto Message to AB 1155 provided:
"This bill would state that workers' compensation injury
determinations shall not include consideration of race, religious
creed, color, national origin, age, gender, marital status, sex,
sexual orientation, or genetic characteristics.
The courts
already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any of
these classifications is antithetical to our states'
non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that
apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes
to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle
that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would
not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This
bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of
whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best,
that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers'
compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate
interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the
courts."
AB 305 takes a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, the bill proposes to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. AB 305 identifies specific factors that proponents argue are inappropriate apportionment factors, and prohibits their use regardless of whether there is factual causation.
Case law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation. This is the rule Governor Brown alluded to in his AB 1155 Veto Message.
Gender discrimination. Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by the bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of the bill and opponents of the bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least 7 years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. The California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA), in its letter in support of the bill, cites several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. Without getting into too much case-specific detail, two things appear from the cited examples: first, the characteristics used to reduce permanent disability awards appear to be risk factors or broad characteristics like those the Vaira case prohibited; second, in each example, it is claimed that "the doctor determined" the offending apportionment factor. Opponents have argued that "dumb doctors" making ill-advised, discriminatory apportionment statements are not a basis to change the law – they are a basis for the attorney representing the injured worker to argue to a workers compensation judge that the doctor recommended an illegal or inappropriate factor that does not support apportionment. Opponents state that they are unaware of any workers' compensation judge or Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) decision that has adopted or endorsed apportionment on the basis of the considerations cited by CAAA.Contemporaneous. Recent amendments to the bill provide that, in order for the gender-related factor to be a prohibited basis for apportionment, that factor must occur "contemporaneous" with the industrial injury that is causing permanent disability. The amendment is intended to ensure that prior factual conditions that may have been associated with a prohibited characteristic may still be used for apportionment. For example, if a pregnant woman suffers a back injury due, in some factually causative way, to pregnancy, and she has an existing back injury, this prior back injury is acceptable for purposes of apportionment when she suffers an industrial back injury 5 years after her pregnancy. Or, in the case of a psychiatric injury, a sexual harassment at the hands of a college professor 5 years prior to the industrial psychiatric injury that contributes to the permanent disability would not be prohibited as a basis to apportion the permanent disability.
While acknowledging that the purpose of this amendment serves to narrow the bill, and eliminate one of the concerns that remote, but factual, prior injuries would be used to argue against legitimate apportionment, opponents fear that the language fails to accomplish that goal, and that old, factual injuries will still be used to argue against apportioning job-related disability for non-job-related factors. This is a consistent theme in opponents' objections to the bill – that much of the practical effect of the bill will be to establish vague and uncertain factors that cannot be used to apportion permanent disability, with a resulting substantial increase in frictional litigation costs.
In this regard, it is important to note how courts treat legislative enactments that add new language to statutes. One of the most important rules of statutory construction is that "significance should be given to every word, phrase, sentence and part of an act" and that the Legislature does not engage in idle acts or adopt words that are mere surplusage. Thus, when the Legislature chooses to use certain words in a statute, the courts will assume that something specific was meant by those words, and seek to ascertain what that meaning is. From the opponents perspective, the addition of the "contemporaneous" amendment will enable a broad range of litigation in an effort determine what the Legislature intended.
In addition, this concern about how courts will interpret other terms in the bill, and the frictional litigation costs associated with those court proceedings, underpins many of the opposition's arguments with the substantive factors the bill proposes. Even those insurers and employers who profess that "we don't apportion to those factors" fear frictional expenses associated with litigants' efforts to obtain advantage by broad use of vague terms.Menopause. Without question, menopause is a gender-based characteristic that ought not be used as a basis to apportion permanent disability. Opponents even state that "we don't do that." However, the effect of adding menopause to the apportionment statute causes opponents great concern. They point out that courts have held that menopause is not a disability. They also point out that there are any number of symptoms that may or may not be associated with menopause, and if any of those symptoms is associated with a factual pre-existing condition that contributes to permanent disability, there will be costly litigation because attorneys would be duty-bound to pursue the argument that menopause, and not the symptom, is the actual basis for the proposed apportionment.
Pregnancy. As with menopause, it is difficult to argue that permanent disabilities ought to be apportioned due to pregnancy. Indeed, many employers and insurers argue that this is not done, nor is it allowed in the workers' compensation system. However, they point out that adding this characteristic to the statute poses problems. First, they argue that it confuses the idea of causation to injury with causation to disability. They suggest that pregnancy can contribute to injury, but it is hard to understand how it is a condition that causes permanent disability. However, by adding pregnancy to the apportionment statue, uncertainties are created that will cause extended litigation to determine the precise meaning of the statutory change.
Osteoporosis. Osteoporosis presents a fundamental difference of perspective as between proponents and opponents. This is a predominantly (although not exclusively) female medical condition involving loss of bone mass, and the resulting risk of broken bones and other complications. Proponents argue that it is fundamentally wrong to reduce a woman's permanent disability award for a physical injury that occurs on the job due to this inherently gender-specific causation factor. Opponents, on the other hand, argue that it is fundamentally wrong to require employers to pay for disability that is factually unrelated to employment.
Psychiatric injuries. Psychiatric injuries, and the addition of sexual harassment as a prohibited apportionment factor for psychiatric injuries, poses some unique issues in addition to the issues associated with physical injuries.
First, due to the "contemporaneous" element of the current version of the bill, it appears that sexual harassment cannot be used to apportion a permanent disability caused by a psychiatric injury, but this sexual harassment must be contemporaneous. Most logically, the psychiatric injury would have to be caused by a sexual harassment. If that is the case, then it is difficult to understand how the sexual harassment could operate to reduce any permanent disability. On the other hand, if the psychiatric injury is not caused by the sexual harassment, but by some other stressor that causes psychiatric injury, it is difficult to understand how a contemporaneous sexual harassment would be involved.
Second, but partially related to the first point, psychiatric injuries are treated differently than physical injuries in at least two significant ways: 1) in order to qualify for compensation, the psychiatric injury must be predominantly work caused, and 2) psychiatric injuries that are not the primary injury, but rather are consequences of the primary injury, are no longer included in the total PD calculation. Opponents argue that all of these uncertainties, coupled with the unique way the law treats psychiatric injuries, will inevitably lead to costly litigation. In making this argument, the opposition asserts that they are in no way seeking to justify an employer that commits or allows sexual harassment in the workplace. Nonetheless, they find it difficult to understand exactly how the bill changes the law, and thus have the concerns noted above.Breast cancer. Breast cancer is the one aspect of the bill that has nothing to do with apportionment. Rather, the bill prohibits giving a lower PD rating to a woman based on the "sequelae" associated with breast cancer as compared with the sequelae associated with prostate cancer. ("Sequelae" means pathological conditions resulting from a disease.) This would be a public policy judgment that the permanent disability "value" associated with breast cancer (women) should be the same as the permanent disability "value" associated with prostate cancer (men). In essence, it would be a public policy judgment that these two cancers have comparable effects on their respective victims.
The 2004 workers' compensation reform (SB 899 (Poochigian), Statutes 2004, Chapter 34) sought to reduce the subjectivity of the permanent disability system, and replace it with a more objective method of determining PD. One of the ways SB 899 sought to accomplish this goal was to adopt the AMA Guides as the basis for calculating the level of impairment caused by industrial injuries. The underlying premise was that objective, scientific evaluations and determinations of the consequences of various disabling conditions ought to displace the prior system which relied upon subjective evaluations and litigation, with judges making the final determinations. The AMA Guides are used in a number of states as the best source of objective, medically expert-based classifications of impairment.
AB 305 proposes, with respect to breast cancer, to replace the judgment that went into the AMA Guides with a public policy judgment that equates two different conditions that proponents argue are similar as a matter of public policy. Opponents object that this entry into subjective policy judgments is a slippery slope that will, eventually, undermine the AMA guides as arbiter of objective evidence-based medical impairment evaluations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
9to5 California, National Association of Working Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO
CA Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
CA Conference of Machinists
California Applicants' Attorney Association (CAAA)
California Nurses Association (CNA)
Engineers & Scientists of California
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
Professional & Technical Engineers
The Teamsters
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
Opposition
Acclamation Insurance Management Services (AIMS)
Allied Managed Care (AMC)
ALPHA Fund
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers' Compensation
California Grocers Association
California League of Food Processors
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Newspaper Publishers Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
Workers' Compensation Action Network
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):