AB 1193: Mental health services: assisted outpatient treatment.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-30
Existing law, the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project Act of 2002, known as Lauras Law, until January 1, 2017, authorizes each county to elect elect, through a resolution adopted by the county board of supervisors or through the county budget process and along with a finding that specified mental health programs may not be reduced as a result of participation, to offer certain assisted outpatient treatment services for their residents. Existing law authorizes participating counties to pay for the services provided from moneys distributed to the counties from various continuously appropriated funds, including the Mental Health Services Fund when included in a county plan, as specified.
This bill would delete the provisions requirement that authorize a county to elect to participate in the program, and instead would require each county to implement the provisions of Lauras Law unless the board of supervisors of a county that elects not to participate in the program by enacting a resolution passed by the county board of supervisors. make the finding described above. The bill instead would require a county that has not held a specified public hearing by January 1, 2017, to hold a hearing by January 1, 2018, and would require the board of supervisors to consider both whether specified programs may be reduced as a result of participation and options for providing services other than court-ordered outpatient treatment, thereby imposing a state-mandated local program. The bill would extend the January 1, 2017, repeal date of those provisions until January 1, 2022.
Existing law authorizes various persons to request the county mental health director to file a petition in the superior court for an order for assisted outpatient treatment for a person who meets specified criteria. Existing law requires the county mental health director to investigate the appropriateness of filing a petition.
This bill would additionally authorize a judge in a superior court courts mental health court, reentry court, or other collaborative justice court available for improving the mental health of the defendant, or a probate court, as specified, to request a petition for that order to be filed for a person who appears before the judge. By imposing additional duties on county mental health directors, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law, the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project Act of 2002, known as Lauras Law, until January 1, 2017, authorizes each county to elect to offer certain assisted outpatient treatment services for their residents. Existing law authorizes participating counties to pay for the services provided from moneys distributed to the counties from various continuously appropriated funds, including the Mental Health Services Fund when included in a county plan, as specified.
This bill would delete the provisions that authorize a county to elect to participate in the program, and instead would require each county to implement the provisions of Lauras Law unless the county elects not to participate in the program by enacting a resolution passed by the county board of supervisors. The bill would extend the January 1, 2017, repeal date of those provisions until January 1, 2022.
Existing law authorizes various persons to request the county mental health director to file a petition in the superior court for an order for assisted outpatient treatment for a person who meets specified criteria. Existing law requires the county mental health director to investigate the appropriateness of filing a petition.
This bill would additionally authorize a judge in a superior court to request a petition for that order to be filed for a person who appears before the judge. By imposing additional duties on county mental health directors, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would make additional conforming changes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
(a)In any county in which services are available as provided in Section 5348, a court may order a person who is the subject of a petition filed pursuant to this section to obtain assisted outpatient treatment if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that the facts stated in the verified petition filed in accordance with this section are true and establish that all of the requisite criteria set forth in this section are met, including, but not limited to, each of the following:
(1)The person is 18 years of age or older.
(2)The person is suffering from a mental illness as defined in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 5600.3.
(3)There has been a clinical determination that the person is unlikely to survive safely in the community without supervision.
(4)The person has a history of lack of compliance with treatment for his or her mental illness, in that at least one of the following is true:
(A)The persons mental illness has, at least twice within the last 36 months, been a substantial factor in necessitating hospitalization, or receipt of services in a forensic or other mental health unit of a state correctional facility or local correctional facility, not including any period during which the person was hospitalized or incarcerated immediately preceding the filing of the petition.
(B)The persons mental illness has resulted in one or more acts of serious and violent behavior toward himself or herself or another, or threats, or attempts to cause serious physical harm to himself or herself or another within the last 48 months, not including any period in which the person was hospitalized or incarcerated immediately preceding the filing of the petition.
(5)The person has been offered an opportunity to participate in a treatment plan by the director of the local mental health department, or his or her designee, provided the treatment plan includes all of the services described in Section 5348, and the person continues to fail to engage in treatment.
(6)The persons condition is substantially deteriorating.
(7)Participation in the assisted outpatient treatment program would be the least restrictive placement necessary to ensure the persons recovery and stability.
(8)In view of the persons treatment history and current behavior, the person is in need of assisted outpatient treatment in order to prevent a relapse or deterioration that would be likely to result in grave disability or serious harm to himself or herself, or to others, as defined in Section 5150.
(9)It is likely that the person will benefit from assisted outpatient treatment.
(b)(1)A petition for an order authorizing assisted outpatient treatment may be filed by the county mental health director, or his or her designee, in the superior court in the county in which the person who is the subject of the petition is present or reasonably believed to be present.
(2)A request may be made only by any of the following persons to the county mental health department for the filing of a petition to obtain an order authorizing assisted outpatient treatment:
(A)Any person 18 years of age or older with whom the person who is the subject of the petition resides.
(B)Any person who is the parent, spouse, or sibling or child 18 years of age or older of the person who is the subject of the petition.
(C)The director of any public or private agency, treatment facility, charitable organization, or licensed residential care facility providing mental health services to the person who is the subject of the petition in whose institution the subject of the petition resides.
(D)The director of a hospital in which the person who is the subject of the petition is hospitalized.
(E)A licensed mental health treatment provider who is either supervising the treatment of, or treating for a mental illness, the person who is the subject of the petition.
(F)A peace officer, parole officer, or probation officer assigned to supervise the person who is the subject of the petition.
(G)A judge of a superior court courts mental health court, reentry court, or other collaborative justice court available for improving the mental health of the defendant, or a probate court before whom the person who is the subject of the petition appears. appears as the subject of a proceeding pursuant to Section 5352.
(3)Upon receiving a request pursuant to paragraph (2), the county mental health director shall conduct an investigation into the appropriateness of filing the petition. The director shall file the petition only if he or she determines that there is a reasonable likelihood that all the necessary elements to sustain the petition can be proven in a court of law by clear and convincing evidence.
(4)The petition shall state all of the following:
(A)Each of the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment as set forth in subdivision (a).
(B)Facts that support the petitioners belief that the person who is the subject of the petition meets each criterion, provided that the hearing on the petition shall be limited to the stated facts in the verified petition, and the petition contains all the grounds on which the petition is based, in order to ensure adequate notice to the person who is the subject of the petition and his or her counsel.
(C)That the person who is the subject of the petition is present, or is reasonably believed to be present, within the county where the petition is filed.
(D)That the person who is the subject of the petition has the right to be represented by counsel in all stages of the proceeding under the petition, in accordance with subdivision (c).
(5)The petition shall be accompanied by an affidavit of a licensed mental health treatment provider designated by the local mental health director who shall state, if applicable, either of the following:
(A)That the licensed mental health treatment provider has personally examined the person who is the subject of the petition no more than 10 days prior to the submission of the petition, the facts and reasons why the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria in subdivision (a), that the licensed mental health treatment provider recommends assisted outpatient treatment for the person who is the subject of the petition, and that the licensed mental health treatment provider is willing and able to testify at the hearing on the petition.
(B)That no more than 10 days prior to the filing of the petition, the licensed mental health treatment provider, or his or her designee, has made appropriate attempts to elicit the cooperation of the person who is the subject of the petition, but has not been successful in persuading that person to submit to an examination, that the licensed mental health treatment provider has reason to believe that the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, and that the licensed mental health treatment provider is willing and able to examine the person who is the subject of the petition and testify at the hearing on the petition.
(c)The person who is the subject of the petition shall have the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a proceeding commenced under this section. If the person so elects, the court shall immediately appoint the public defender or other attorney to assist the person in all stages of the proceedings. The person shall pay the cost of the legal services if he or she is able.
(d)(1)Upon receipt by the court of a petition submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), the court shall fix the date for a hearing at a time not later than five days from the date the petition is received by the court, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays. The petitioner shall promptly cause service of a copy of the petition, together with written notice of the hearing date, to be made personally on the person who is the subject of the petition, and shall send a copy of the petition and notice to the county office of patient rights, and to the current health care provider appointed for the person who is the subject of the petition, if that provider is known to the petitioner. Continuances shall be permitted only for good cause shown. In granting continuances, the court shall consider the need for further examination by a physician or the potential need to provide expeditiously assisted outpatient treatment. Upon the hearing date, or upon any other date or dates to which the proceeding may be continued, the court shall hear testimony. If it is deemed advisable by the court, and if the person who is the subject of the petition is available and has received notice pursuant to this section, the court may examine in or out of court the person who is the subject of the petition who is alleged to be in need of assisted outpatient treatment. If the person who is the subject of the petition does not appear at the hearing, and appropriate attempts to elicit the attendance of the person have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the persons absence. If the hearing is conducted without the person present, the court shall set forth the factual basis for conducting the hearing without the persons presence.
(2)The court shall not order assisted outpatient treatment unless an examining licensed mental health treatment provider, who has personally examined, and has reviewed the available treatment history of, the person who is the subject of the petition within the time period commencing 10 days before the filing of the petition, testifies in person at the hearing.
(3)If the person who is the subject of the petition has refused to be examined by a licensed mental health treatment provider, the court may request that the person consent to an examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider appointed by the court. If the person who is the subject of the petition does not consent and the court finds reasonable cause to believe that the allegations in the petition are true, the court may order any person designated under Section 5150 to take into custody the person who is the subject of the petition and transport him or her, or cause him or her to be transported, to a hospital for examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider as soon as is practicable. Detention of the person who is the subject of the petition under the order may not exceed 72 hours. If the examination is performed by another licensed mental health treatment provider, the examining licensed mental health treatment provider may consult with the licensed mental health treatment provider whose affirmation or affidavit accompanied the petition regarding the issues of whether the allegations in the petition are true and whether the person meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment.
(4)The person who is the subject of the petition shall have all of the following rights:
(A)To adequate notice of the hearings to the person who is the subject of the petition, as well as to parties designated by the person who is the subject of the petition.
(B)To receive a copy of the court-ordered evaluation.
(C)To counsel. If the person has not retained counsel, the court shall appoint a public defender.
(D)To be informed of his or her right to judicial review by habeas corpus.
(E)To be present at the hearing unless he or she waives the right to be present.
(F)To present evidence.
(G)To call witnesses on his or her behalf.
(H)To cross-examine witnesses.
(I)To appeal decisions, and to be informed of his or her right to appeal.
(5)(A)If after hearing all relevant evidence, the court finds that the person who is the subject of the petition does not meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(B)If after hearing all relevant evidence, the court finds that the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, and there is no appropriate and feasible less restrictive alternative, the court may order the person who is the subject of the petition to receive assisted outpatient treatment for an initial period not to exceed six months. In fashioning the order, the court shall specify that the proposed treatment is the least restrictive treatment appropriate and feasible for the person who is the subject of the petition. The order shall state the categories of assisted outpatient treatment, as set forth in Section 5348, that the person who is the subject of the petition is to receive, and the court may not order treatment that has not been recommended by the examining licensed mental health treatment provider and included in the written treatment plan for assisted outpatient treatment as required by subdivision (e). If the person has executed an advance health care directive pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 4650) of Part 1 of Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, any directions included in the advance health care directive shall be considered in formulating the written treatment plan.
(6)If the person who is the subject of a petition for an order for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) refuses to participate in the assisted outpatient treatment program, the court may order the person to meet with the assisted outpatient treatment team designated by the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program. The treatment team shall attempt to gain the persons cooperation with treatment ordered by the court. The person may be subject to a 72-hour hold pursuant to subdivision (f) only after the treatment team has attempted to gain the persons cooperation with treatment ordered by the court, and has been unable to do so.
(e)Assisted outpatient treatment shall not be ordered unless the licensed mental health treatment provider recommending assisted outpatient treatment to the court has submitted to the court a written treatment plan that includes services as set forth in Section 5348, and the court finds, in consultation with the county mental health director, or his or her designee, all of the following:
(1)That the services are available from the county, or a provider approved by the county, for the duration of the court order.
(2)That the services have been offered to the person by the local director of mental health, or his or her designee, and the person has been given an opportunity to participate on a voluntary basis, and the person has failed to engage in, or has refused, treatment.
(3)That all of the elements of the petition required by this article have been met.
(4)That the treatment plan will be delivered to the county director of mental health, or to his or her appropriate designee.
(f)If, in the clinical judgment of a licensed mental health treatment provider, the person who is the subject of the petition has failed or has refused to comply with the treatment ordered by the court, and, in the clinical judgment of the licensed mental health treatment provider, efforts were made to solicit compliance, and, in the clinical judgment of the licensed mental health treatment provider, the person may be in need of involuntary admission to a hospital for evaluation, the provider may request that persons designated under Section 5150 take into custody the person who is the subject of the petition and transport him or her, or cause him or her to be transported, to a hospital, to be held up to 72 hours for examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider to determine if the person is in need of treatment pursuant to Section 5150. Any continued involuntary retention in a hospital beyond the initial 72-hour period shall be pursuant to Section 5150. If at any time during the 72-hour period the person is determined not to meet the criteria of Section 5150, and does not agree to stay in the hospital as a voluntary patient, he or she shall be released and any subsequent involuntary detention in a hospital shall be pursuant to Section 5150. Failure to comply with an order of assisted outpatient treatment alone may not be grounds for involuntary civil commitment or a finding that the person who is the subject of the petition is in contempt of court.
(g)If the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program determines that the condition of the patient requires further assisted outpatient treatment, the director shall apply to the court, prior to the expiration of the period of the initial assisted outpatient treatment order, for an order authorizing continued assisted outpatient treatment for a period not to exceed 180 days from the date of the order. The procedures for obtaining an order pursuant to this subdivision shall be in accordance with subdivisions (a) to (f), inclusive. The period for further involuntary outpatient treatment authorized by a subsequent order under this subdivision may not exceed 180 days from the date of the order.
(h)At intervals of not less than 60 days during an assisted outpatient treatment order, the director of the outpatient treatment program shall file an affidavit with the court that ordered the outpatient treatment affirming that the person who is the subject of the order continues to meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment. At these times, the person who is the subject of the order shall have the right to a hearing on whether or not he or she still meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment if he or she disagrees with the directors affidavit. The burden of proof shall be on the director.
(i)During each 60-day period specified in subdivision (h), if the person who is the subject of the order believes that he or she is being wrongfully retained in the assisted outpatient treatment program against his or her wishes, he or she may file a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, thus requiring the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program to prove that the person who is the subject of the order continues to meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment.
(j)Any person ordered to undergo assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to this article, who was not present at the hearing at which the order was issued, may immediately petition the court for a writ of habeas corpus. Treatment under the order for assisted outpatient treatment may not commence until the resolution of that petition.
SEC. 2.Section 5348 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5348.(a)For purposes of subdivision (e) of Section 5346, a county that provides assisted outpatient treatment services pursuant to this article shall offer assisted outpatient treatment services including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Community-based, mobile, multidisciplinary, highly trained mental health teams that use high staff-to-client ratios of no more than 10 clients per team member for those subject to court-ordered services pursuant to Section 5346.
(2)A service planning and delivery process that includes the following:
(A)Determination of the numbers of persons to be served and the programs and services that will be provided to meet their needs. The local director of mental health shall consult with the sheriff, the police chief, the probation officer, the mental health board, contract agencies, and family, client, ethnic, and citizen constituency groups as determined by the director.
(B)Plans for services, including outreach to families whose severely mentally ill adult is living with them, design of mental health services, coordination and access to medications, psychiatric and psychological services, substance abuse services, supportive housing or other housing assistance, vocational rehabilitation, and veterans services. Plans shall also contain evaluation strategies, which shall consider cultural, linguistic, gender, age, and special needs of minorities and those based on any characteristic listed or defined in Section 11135 of the Government Code in the target populations. Provision shall be made for staff with the cultural background and linguistic skills necessary to remove barriers to mental health services as a result of having limited-English-speaking ability and cultural differences. Recipients of outreach services may include families, the public, primary care physicians, and others who are likely to come into contact with individuals who may be suffering from an untreated severe mental illness who would be likely to become homeless if the illness continued to be untreated for a substantial period of time. Outreach to adults may include adults voluntarily or involuntarily hospitalized as a result of a severe mental illness.
(C)Provision for services to meet the needs of persons who are physically disabled.
(D)Provision for services to meet the special needs of older adults.
(E)Provision for family support and consultation services, parenting support and consultation services, and peer support or self-help group support, where appropriate.
(F)Provision for services to be client-directed and that employ psychosocial rehabilitation and recovery principles.
(G)Provision for psychiatric and psychological services that are integrated with other services and for psychiatric and psychological collaboration in overall service planning.
(H)Provision for services specifically directed to seriously mentally ill young adults 25 years of age or younger who are homeless or at significant risk of becoming homeless. These provisions may include continuation of services that still would be received through other funds had eligibility not been terminated as a result of age.
(I)Services reflecting special needs of women from diverse cultural backgrounds, including supportive housing that accepts children, personal services coordinator therapeutic treatment, and substance treatment programs that address gender-specific trauma and abuse in the lives of persons with mental illness, and vocational rehabilitation programs that offer job training programs free of gender bias and sensitive to the needs of women.
(J)Provision for housing for clients that is immediate, transitional, permanent, or all of these.
(K)Provision for clients who have been suffering from an untreated severe mental illness for less than one year, and who do not require the full range of services, but are at risk of becoming homeless unless a comprehensive individual and family support services plan is implemented. These clients shall be served in a manner that is designed to meet their needs.
(3)Each client shall have a clearly designated mental health personal services coordinator who may be part of a multidisciplinary treatment team who is responsible for providing or assuring needed services. Responsibilities include complete assessment of the clients needs, development of the clients personal services plan, linkage with all appropriate community services, monitoring of the quality and follow through of services, and necessary advocacy to ensure each client receives those services that are agreed to in the personal services plan. Each client shall participate in the development of his or her personal services plan, and responsible staff shall consult with the designated conservator, if one has been appointed, and, with the consent of the client, shall consult with the family and other significant persons as appropriate.
(4)The individual personal services plan shall ensure that persons subject to assisted outpatient treatment programs receive age-appropriate, gender-appropriate, and culturally appropriate services, to the extent feasible, that are designed to enable recipients to:
(A)Live in the most independent, least restrictive housing feasible in the local community, and, for clients with children, to live in a supportive housing environment that strives for reunification with their children or assists clients in maintaining custody of their children as is appropriate.
(B)Engage in the highest level of work or productive activity appropriate to their abilities and experience.
(C)Create and maintain a support system consisting of friends, family, and participation in community activities.
(D)Access an appropriate level of academic education or vocational training.
(E)Obtain an adequate income.
(F)Self-manage their illnesses and exert as much control as possible over both the day-to-day and long-term decisions that affect their lives.
(G)Access necessary physical health care and maintain the best possible physical health.
(H)Reduce or eliminate serious antisocial or criminal behavior, and thereby reduce or eliminate their contact with the criminal justice system.
(I)Reduce or eliminate the distress caused by the symptoms of mental illness.
(J)Have freedom from dangerous addictive substances.
(5)The individual personal services plan shall describe the service array that meets the requirements of paragraph (4), and to the extent applicable to the individual, the requirements of paragraph (2).
(b)A county that provides assisted outpatient treatment services pursuant to this article also shall offer the same services on a voluntary basis.
(c)Involuntary medication shall not be allowed absent a separate order by the court pursuant to Sections 5332 to 5336, inclusive.
(d)A county that operates an assisted outpatient treatment program pursuant to this article shall provide data to the State Department of Health Care Services and, based on the data, the department shall report to the Legislature on or before May 1 of each year in which the county provides services pursuant to this article. The report shall include, at a minimum, an evaluation of the effectiveness of the strategies employed by each program operated pursuant to this article in reducing homelessness and hospitalization of persons in the program and in reducing involvement with local law enforcement by persons in the program. The evaluation and report shall also include any other measures identified by the department regarding persons in the program and all of the following, based on information that is available:
(1)The number of persons served by the program and, of those, the number who are able to maintain housing and the number who maintain contact with the treatment system.
(2)The number of persons in the program with contacts with local law enforcement, and the extent to which local and state incarceration of persons in the program has been reduced or avoided.
(3)The number of persons in the program participating in employment services programs, including competitive employment.
(4)The days of hospitalization of persons in the program that have been reduced or avoided.
(5)Adherence to prescribed treatment by persons in the program.
(6)Other indicators of successful engagement, if any, by persons in the program.
(7)Victimization of persons in the program.
(8)Violent behavior of persons in the program.
(9)Substance abuse by persons in the program.
(10)Type, intensity, and frequency of treatment of persons in the program.
(11)Extent to which enforcement mechanisms are used by the program, when applicable.
(12)Social functioning of persons in the program.
(13)Skills in independent living of persons in the program.
(14)Satisfaction with program services both by those receiving them and by their families, when relevant.
SEC. 3.Section 5349 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.A county that does not wish to implement this article may opt out of the requirements of this article by a resolution passed by the county board of supervisors that states the reasons for opting out and any facts or circumstances relied on in making that decision. To
5349.(a)This article shall be operative in those counties in which the county board of supervisors, by resolution or through the county budget process, authorizes application of this article.
(b)Any county that has not held a public hearing by January 1, 2017, to determine whether this article shall be operative shall hold that hearing by January 1, 2018. At the hearing, the board of supervisors shall consider the options available in the county for providing services to persons whose recent history of hospitalization or violent behavior, and noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicate that he or she may be likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
(1)Options for providing services other than court-ordered outpatient treatment.
(2)Whether any voluntary mental health program serving adults, or any childrens mental health program, may be reduced as a result of the implementation of this article.
(c)To the extent otherwise permitted under state and federal law, counties that implement this article may pay for the provision of services under Sections 5347 and 5348 using funds distributed to the counties from the Mental Health Subaccount, the Mental Health Equity Subaccount, and the Vehicle License Collection Account of the Local Revenue Fund, funds from the Mental Health Account and the Behavioral Health Subaccount within the Support Services Account of the Local Revenue Fund 2011, funds from the Mental Health Services Fund when included in county plans pursuant to Section 5847, and any other funds from which the Controller makes distributions to the counties for those purposes. Compliance with this section shall be monitored by the State Department of Health Care Services as part of its review and approval of county performance contracts.
SEC. 4.Section 5349.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.1.(a)Counties that implement this article, shall, in consultation with the State Department of Health Care Services, client and family advocacy organizations, and other stakeholders, develop a training and education program for purposes of improving the delivery of services to mentally ill individuals who are, or who are at risk of being, involuntarily committed under this part. This training shall be provided to mental health treatment providers contracting with participating counties and to other individuals, including, but not limited to, mental health professionals, law enforcement officials, and certification hearing officers involved in making treatment and involuntary commitment decisions.
(b)The training shall include both of the following:
(1)Information relative to legal requirements for detaining a person for involuntary inpatient and outpatient treatment, including criteria to be considered with respect to determining if a person is considered to be gravely disabled.
(2)Methods for ensuring that decisions regarding involuntary treatment as provided for in this part direct patients toward the most effective treatment. Training shall include an emphasis on each patients right to provide informed consent to assistance.
SEC. 5.Section 5349.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.5.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted on or before January 1, 2022, deletes or extends that date.
(b)The State Department of Health Care Services shall submit a report and evaluation of all counties implementing any component of this article to the Governor and to the Legislature by July 1, 2015. The evaluation shall include data described in subdivision (d) of Section 5348.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)In any county in which services are available as provided in Section 5348, a court may order a person who is the subject of a petition filed pursuant to this section to obtain assisted outpatient treatment if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that the facts stated in the verified petition filed in accordance with this section are true and establish that all of the requisite criteria set forth in this section are met, including, but not limited to, each of the following:
(1)The person is 18 years of age or older.
(2)The person is suffering from a mental illness as defined in paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 5600.3.
(3)There has been a clinical determination that the person is unlikely to survive safely in the community without supervision.
(4)The person has a history of lack of compliance with treatment for his or her mental illness, in that at least one of the following is true:
(A)The persons mental illness has, at least twice within the last 36 months, been a substantial factor in necessitating hospitalization, or receipt of services in a forensic or other mental health unit of a state correctional facility or local correctional facility, not including any period during which the person was hospitalized or incarcerated immediately preceding the filing of the petition.
(B)The persons mental illness has resulted in one or more acts of serious and violent behavior toward himself or herself or another, or threats, or attempts to cause serious physical harm to himself or herself or another within the last 48 months, not including any period in which the person was hospitalized or incarcerated immediately preceding the filing of the petition.
(5)The person has been offered an opportunity to participate in a treatment plan by the director of the local mental health department, or his or her designee, provided the treatment plan includes all of the services described in Section 5348, and the person continues to fail to engage in treatment.
(6)The persons condition is substantially deteriorating.
(7)Participation in the assisted outpatient treatment program would be the least restrictive placement necessary to ensure the persons recovery and stability.
(8)In view of the persons treatment history and current behavior, the person is in need of assisted outpatient treatment in order to prevent a relapse or deterioration that would be likely to result in grave disability or serious harm to himself or herself, or to others, as defined in Section 5150.
(9)It is likely that the person will benefit from assisted outpatient treatment.
(b)(1)A petition for an order authorizing assisted outpatient treatment may be filed by the county mental health director, or his or her designee, in the superior court in the county in which the person who is the subject of the petition is present or reasonably believed to be present.
(2)A request may be made only by any of the following persons to the county mental health department for the filing of a petition to obtain an order authorizing assisted outpatient treatment:
(A)Any person 18 years of age or older with whom the person who is the subject of the petition resides.
(B)Any person who is the parent, spouse, or sibling or child 18 years of age or older of the person who is the subject of the petition.
(C)The director of any public or private agency, treatment facility, charitable organization, or licensed residential care facility providing mental health services to the person who is the subject of the petition in whose institution the subject of the petition resides.
(D)The director of a hospital in which the person who is the subject of the petition is hospitalized.
(E)A licensed mental health treatment provider who is either supervising the treatment of, or treating for a mental illness, the person who is the subject of the petition.
(F)A peace officer, parole officer, or probation officer assigned to supervise the person who is the subject of the petition.
(G)A judge of a superior court before whom the person who is the subject of the petition appears.
(3)Upon receiving a request pursuant to paragraph (2), the county mental health director shall conduct an investigation into the appropriateness of the filing of the petition. The director shall file the petition only if he or she determines that there is a reasonable likelihood that all the necessary elements to sustain the petition can be proven in a court of law by clear and convincing evidence.
(4)The petition shall state all of the following:
(A)Each of the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment as set forth in subdivision (a).
(B)Facts that support the petitioners belief that the person who is the subject of the petition meets each criterion, provided that the hearing on the petition shall be limited to the stated facts in the verified petition, and the petition contains all the grounds on which the petition is based, in order to ensure adequate notice to the person who is the subject of the petition and his or her counsel.
(C)That the person who is the subject of the petition is present, or is reasonably believed to be present, within the county where the petition is filed.
(D)That the person who is the subject of the petition has the right to be represented by counsel in all stages of the proceeding under the petition, in accordance with subdivision (c).
(5)The petition shall be accompanied by an affidavit of a licensed mental health treatment provider designated by the local mental health director who shall state, if applicable, either of the following:
(A)That the licensed mental health treatment provider has personally examined the person who is the subject of the petition no more than 10 days prior to the submission of the petition, the facts and reasons why the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria in subdivision (a), that the licensed mental health treatment provider recommends assisted outpatient treatment for the person who is the subject of the petition, and that the licensed mental health treatment provider is willing and able to testify at the hearing on the petition.
(B)That no more than 10 days prior to the filing of the petition, the licensed mental health treatment provider, or his or her designee, has made appropriate attempts to elicit the cooperation of the person who is the subject of the petition, but has not been successful in persuading that person to submit to an examination, that the licensed mental health treatment provider has reason to believe that the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, and that the licensed mental health treatment provider is willing and able to examine the person who is the subject of the petition and testify at the hearing on the petition.
(c)The person who is the subject of the petition shall have the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a proceeding commenced under this section. If the person so elects, the court shall immediately appoint the public defender or other attorney to assist the person in all stages of the proceedings. The person shall pay the cost of the legal services if he or she is able.
(d)(1)Upon receipt by the court of a petition submitted pursuant to subdivision (b), the court shall fix the date for a hearing at a time not later than five days from the date the petition is received by the court, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays. The petitioner shall promptly cause service of a copy of the petition, together with written notice of the hearing date, to be made personally on the person who is the subject of the petition, and shall send a copy of the petition and notice to the county office of patient rights, and to the current health care provider appointed for the person who is the subject of the petition, if any such that provider is known to the petitioner. Continuances shall be permitted only for good cause shown. In granting continuances, the court shall consider the need for further examination by a physician or the potential need to provide expeditiously assisted outpatient treatment. Upon the hearing date, or upon any other date or dates to which the proceeding may be continued, the court shall hear testimony. If it is deemed advisable by the court, and if the person who is the subject of the petition is available and has received notice pursuant to this section, the court may examine in or out of court the person who is the subject of the petition who is alleged to be in need of assisted outpatient treatment. If the person who is the subject of the petition does not appear at the hearing, and appropriate attempts to elicit the attendance of the person have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the persons absence. If the hearing is conducted without the person present, the court shall set forth the factual basis for conducting the hearing without the persons presence.
(2)The court shall not order assisted outpatient treatment unless an examining licensed mental health treatment provider, who has personally examined, and has reviewed the available treatment history of, the person who is the subject of the petition within the time period commencing 10 days before the filing of the petition, testifies in person at the hearing.
(3)If the person who is the subject of the petition has refused to be examined by a licensed mental health treatment provider, the court may request that the person consent to an examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider appointed by the court. If the person who is the subject of the petition does not consent and the court finds reasonable cause to believe that the allegations in the petition are true, the court may order any person designated under Section 5150 to take into custody the person who is the subject of the petition and transport him or her, or cause him or her to be transported, to a hospital for examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider as soon as is practicable. Detention of the person who is the subject of the petition under the order may not exceed 72 hours. If the examination is performed by another licensed mental health treatment provider, the examining licensed mental health treatment provider may consult with the licensed mental health treatment provider whose affirmation or affidavit accompanied the petition regarding the issues of whether the allegations in the petition are true and whether the person meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment.
(4)The person who is the subject of the petition shall have all of the following rights:
(A)To adequate notice of the hearings to the person who is the subject of the petition, as well as to parties designated by the person who is the subject of the petition.
(B)To receive a copy of the court-ordered evaluation.
(C)To counsel. If the person has not retained counsel, the court shall appoint a public defender.
(D)To be informed of his or her right to judicial review by habeas corpus.
(E)To be present at the hearing unless he or she waives the right to be present.
(F)To present evidence.
(G)To call witnesses on his or her behalf.
(H)To cross-examine witnesses.
(I)To appeal decisions, and to be informed of his or her right to appeal.
(5)(A)If after hearing all relevant evidence, the court finds that the person who is the subject of the petition does not meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(B)If after hearing all relevant evidence, the court finds that the person who is the subject of the petition meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, and there is no appropriate and feasible less restrictive alternative, the court may order the person who is the subject of the petition to receive assisted outpatient treatment for an initial period not to exceed six months. In fashioning the order, the court shall specify that the proposed treatment is the least restrictive treatment appropriate and feasible for the person who is the subject of the petition. The order shall state the categories of assisted outpatient treatment, as set forth in Section 5348, that the person who is the subject of the petition is to receive, and the court may not order treatment that has not been recommended by the examining licensed mental health treatment provider and included in the written treatment plan for assisted outpatient treatment as required by subdivision (e). If the person has executed an advance health care directive pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 4650) of Part 1 of Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, any directions included in the advance health care directive shall be considered in formulating the written treatment plan.
(6)If the person who is the subject of a petition for an order for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (d) refuses to participate in the assisted outpatient treatment program, the court may order the person to meet with the assisted outpatient treatment team designated by the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program. The treatment team shall attempt to gain the persons cooperation with treatment ordered by the court. The person may be subject to a 72-hour hold pursuant to subdivision (f) only after the treatment team has attempted to gain the persons cooperation with treatment ordered by the court, and has been unable to do so.
(e)Assisted outpatient treatment shall not be ordered unless the licensed mental health treatment provider recommending assisted outpatient treatment to the court has submitted to the court a written treatment plan that includes services as set forth in Section 5348, and the court finds, in consultation with the county mental health director, or his or her designee, all of the following:
(1)That the services are available from the county, or a provider approved by the county, for the duration of the court order.
(2)That the services have been offered to the person by the local director of mental health, or his or her designee, and the person has been given an opportunity to participate on a voluntary basis, and the person has failed to engage in, or has refused, treatment.
(3)That all of the elements of the petition required by this article have been met.
(4)That the treatment plan will be delivered to the county director of mental health, or to his or her appropriate designee.
(f)If, in the clinical judgment of a licensed mental health treatment provider, the person who is the subject of the petition has failed or has refused to comply with the treatment ordered by the court, and, in the clinical judgment of the licensed mental health treatment provider, efforts were made to solicit compliance, and, in the clinical judgment of the licensed mental health treatment provider, the person may be in need of involuntary admission to a hospital for evaluation, the provider may request that persons designated under Section 5150 take into custody the person who is the subject of the petition and transport him or her, or cause him or her to be transported, to a hospital, to be held up to 72 hours for examination by a licensed mental health treatment provider to determine if the person is in need of treatment pursuant to Section 5150. Any continued involuntary retention in a hospital beyond the initial 72-hour period shall be pursuant to Section 5150. If at any time during the 72-hour period the person is determined not to meet the criteria of Section 5150, and does not agree to stay in the hospital as a voluntary patient, he or she shall be released and any subsequent involuntary detention in a hospital shall be pursuant to Section 5150. Failure to comply with an order of assisted outpatient treatment alone may not be grounds for involuntary civil commitment or a finding that the person who is the subject of the petition is in contempt of court.
(g)If the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program determines that the condition of the patient requires further assisted outpatient treatment, the director shall apply to the court, prior to the expiration of the period of the initial assisted outpatient treatment order, for an order authorizing continued assisted outpatient treatment for a period not to exceed 180 days from the date of the order. The procedures for obtaining any an order pursuant to this subdivision shall be in accordance with subdivisions (a) to (f), inclusive. The period for further involuntary outpatient treatment authorized by any a subsequent order under this subdivision may not exceed 180 days from the date of the order.
(h)At intervals of not less than 60 days during an assisted outpatient treatment order, the director of the outpatient treatment program shall file an affidavit with the court that ordered the outpatient treatment affirming that the person who is the subject of the order continues to meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment. At these times, the person who is the subject of the order shall have the right to a hearing on whether or not he or she still meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment if he or she disagrees with the directors affidavit. The burden of proof shall be on the director.
(i)During each 60-day period specified in subdivision (h), if the person who is the subject of the order believes that he or she is being wrongfully retained in the assisted outpatient treatment program against his or her wishes, he or she may file a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, thus requiring the director of the assisted outpatient treatment program to prove that the person who is the subject of the order continues to meet the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment.
(j)Any person ordered to undergo assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to this article, who was not present at the hearing at which the order was issued, may immediately petition the court for a writ of habeas corpus. Treatment under the order for assisted outpatient treatment may not commence until the resolution of that petition.
SEC. 2.Section 5348 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5348.(a)For purposes of subdivision (e) of Section 5346, a county that chooses to provide provides assisted outpatient treatment services pursuant to this article shall offer assisted outpatient treatment services including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Community-based, mobile, multidisciplinary, highly trained mental health teams that use high staff-to-client ratios of no more than 10 clients per team member for those subject to court-ordered services pursuant to Section 5346.
(2)A service planning and delivery process that includes the following:
(A)Determination of the numbers of persons to be served and the programs and services that will be provided to meet their needs. The local director of mental health shall consult with the sheriff, the police chief, the probation officer, the mental health board, contract agencies, and family, client, ethnic, and citizen constituency groups as determined by the director.
(B)Plans for services, including outreach to families whose severely mentally ill adult is living with them, design of mental health services, coordination and access to medications, psychiatric and psychological services, substance abuse services, supportive housing or other housing assistance, vocational rehabilitation, and veterans services. Plans shall also contain evaluation strategies, which shall consider cultural, linguistic, gender, age, and special needs of minorities and those based on any characteristic listed or defined in Section 11135 of the Government Code in the target populations. Provision shall be made for staff with the cultural background and linguistic skills necessary to remove barriers to mental health services as a result of having limited-English-speaking ability and cultural differences. Recipients of outreach services may include families, the public, primary care physicians, and others who are likely to come into contact with individuals who may be suffering from an untreated severe mental illness who would be likely to become homeless if the illness continued to be untreated for a substantial period of time. Outreach to adults may include adults voluntarily or involuntarily hospitalized as a result of a severe mental illness.
(C)Provision for services to meet the needs of persons who are physically disabled.
(D)Provision for services to meet the special needs of older adults.
(E)Provision for family support and consultation services, parenting support and consultation services, and peer support or self-help group support, where appropriate.
(F)Provision for services to be client-directed and that employ psychosocial rehabilitation and recovery principles.
(G)Provision for psychiatric and psychological services that are integrated with other services and for psychiatric and psychological collaboration in overall service planning.
(H)Provision for services specifically directed to seriously mentally ill young adults 25 years of age or younger who are homeless or at significant risk of becoming homeless. These provisions may include continuation of services that still would be received through other funds had eligibility not been terminated as a result of age.
(I)Services reflecting special needs of women from diverse cultural backgrounds, including supportive housing that accepts children, personal services coordinator therapeutic treatment, and substance treatment programs that address gender-specific trauma and abuse in the lives of persons with mental illness, and vocational rehabilitation programs that offer job training programs free of gender bias and sensitive to the needs of women.
(J)Provision for housing for clients that is immediate, transitional, permanent, or all of these.
(K)Provision for clients who have been suffering from an untreated severe mental illness for less than one year, and who do not require the full range of services, but are at risk of becoming homeless unless a comprehensive individual and family support services plan is implemented. These clients shall be served in a manner that is designed to meet their needs.
(3)Each client shall have a clearly designated mental health personal services coordinator who may be part of a multidisciplinary treatment team who is responsible for providing or assuring needed services. Responsibilities include complete assessment of the clients needs, development of the clients personal services plan, linkage with all appropriate community services, monitoring of the quality and follow through of services, and necessary advocacy to ensure each client receives those services that are agreed to in the personal services plan. Each client shall participate in the development of his or her personal services plan, and responsible staff shall consult with the designated conservator, if one has been appointed, and, with the consent of the client, shall consult with the family and other significant persons as appropriate.
(4)The individual personal services plan shall ensure that persons subject to assisted outpatient treatment programs receive age-appropriate, gender-appropriate, and culturally appropriate services, to the extent feasible, that are designed to enable recipients to:
(A)Live in the most independent, least restrictive housing feasible in the local community, and, for clients with children, to live in a supportive housing environment that strives for reunification with their children or assists clients in maintaining custody of their children as is appropriate.
(B)Engage in the highest level of work or productive activity appropriate to their abilities and experience.
(C)Create and maintain a support system consisting of friends, family, and participation in community activities.
(D)Access an appropriate level of academic education or vocational training.
(E)Obtain an adequate income.
(F)Self-manage their illnesses and exert as much control as possible over both the day-to-day and long-term decisions that affect their lives.
(G)Access necessary physical health care and maintain the best possible physical health.
(H)Reduce or eliminate serious antisocial or criminal behavior, and thereby reduce or eliminate their contact with the criminal justice system.
(I)Reduce or eliminate the distress caused by the symptoms of mental illness.
(J)Have freedom from dangerous addictive substances.
(5)The individual personal services plan shall describe the service array that meets the requirements of paragraph (4), and to the extent applicable to the individual, the requirements of paragraph (2).
(b)A county that provides assisted outpatient treatment services pursuant to this article also shall offer the same services on a voluntary basis.
(c)Involuntary medication shall not be allowed absent a separate order by the court pursuant to Sections 5332 to 5336, inclusive.
(d)A county that operates an assisted outpatient treatment program pursuant to this article shall provide data to the State Department of Health Care Services and, based on the data, the department shall report to the Legislature on or before May 1 of each year in which the county provides services pursuant to this article. The report shall include, at a minimum, an evaluation of the effectiveness of the strategies employed by each program operated pursuant to this article in reducing homelessness and hospitalization of persons in the program and in reducing involvement with local law enforcement by persons in the program. The evaluation and report shall also include any other measures identified by the department regarding persons in the program and all of the following, based on information that is available:
(1)The number of persons served by the program and, of those, the number who are able to maintain housing and the number who maintain contact with the treatment system.
(2)The number of persons in the program with contacts with local law enforcement, and the extent to which local and state incarceration of persons in the program has been reduced or avoided.
(3)The number of persons in the program participating in employment services programs, including competitive employment.
(4)The days of hospitalization of persons in the program that have been reduced or avoided.
(5)Adherence to prescribed treatment by persons in the program.
(6)Other indicators of successful engagement, if any, by persons in the program.
(7)Victimization of persons in the program.
(8)Violent behavior of persons in the program.
(9)Substance abuse by persons in the program.
(10)Type, intensity, and frequency of treatment of persons in the program.
(11)Extent to which enforcement mechanisms are used by the program, when applicable.
(12)Social functioning of persons in the program.
(13)Skills in independent living of persons in the program.
(14)Satisfaction with program services both by those receiving them and by their families, when relevant.
SEC. 3.Section 5349 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.This article shall be operative in those counties in which the county board of supervisors, by resolution or through the county budget process, authorizes its application and makes a finding that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no childrens mental health program, may be reduced as a result of the implementation of this article. A county that does not wish to implement this article may opt out of the requirements of this article by a resolution passed by the county board of supervisors that states the reasons for opting out and any facts or circumstances relied on in making that decision. To the extent otherwise permitted under state and federal law, counties that elect to implement this article may pay for the provision of services under Sections 5347 and 5348 using funds distributed to the counties from the Mental Health Subaccount, the Mental Health Equity Subaccount, and the Vehicle License Collection Account of the Local Revenue Fund, funds from the Mental Health Account and the Behavioral Health Subaccount within the Support Services Account of the Local Revenue Fund 2011, funds from the Mental Health Services Fund when included in county plans pursuant to Section 5847, and any other funds from which the Controller makes distributions to the counties for those purposes. Compliance with this section shall be monitored by the State Department of Health Care Services as part of its review and approval of county performance contracts.
SEC. 4.Section 5349.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.1.(a)Counties that elect to implement this article, shall, in consultation with the State Department of Health Care Services, client and family advocacy organizations, and other stakeholders, develop a training and education program for purposes of improving the delivery of services to mentally ill individuals who are, or who are at risk of being, involuntarily committed under this part. This training shall be provided to mental health treatment providers contracting with participating counties and to other individuals, including, but not limited to, mental health professionals, law enforcement officials, and certification hearing officers involved in making treatment and involuntary commitment decisions.
(b)The training shall include both of the following:
(1)Information relative to legal requirements for detaining a person for involuntary inpatient and outpatient treatment, including criteria to be considered with respect to determining if a person is considered to be gravely disabled.
(2)Methods for ensuring that decisions regarding involuntary treatment as provided for in this part direct patients toward the most effective treatment. Training shall include an emphasis on each patients right to provide informed consent to assistance.
SEC. 5.Section 5349.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5349.5.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2017, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute that is enacted on or before January 1, 2017, 2022, deletes or extends that date.
(b)The State Department of Health Care Services shall submit a report and evaluation of all counties implementing any component of this article to the Governor and to the Legislature by July 1, 2015. The evaluation shall include data described in subdivision (d) of Section 5348.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 28, 2015 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 13, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 4, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 28). |
| Apr 15, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 14). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 14, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1193
Page 2
Date of Hearing: May 13, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1193
(Eggman) – As Amended April 30, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Health |
Vote: |
16 - 0 |
|
Judiciary |
|
10 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill addresses local implementation of Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT, or Laura's Law). Specifically, this bill:
Allows specified judges to file a petition to obtain an order authorizing assisted outpatient treatment.
Requires any county that has not held a public hearing by January 1, 2017, to determine whether to implement AOT, to hold that hearing by January 1, 2018. Specifies what factors shall be considered at the hearing.
Removes the current requirement that a county make a finding that "no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children’s mental health program, may be reduced as a result of the implementation" of AOT.
Extends the sunset date on statutes authorizing AOT to January 1, 2022 (from 2017).
FISCAL EFFECT:
State-reimbursable mandate local costs associated with the requirement to hold public hearings in the range of $2 million GF.
Potential additional state-reimbursable mandate local costs, possibly in the range of hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, if authorizing a judge to request a petition compels a greater number of AOT investigations and reports.
In addition, counties could incur significant unknown costs associated with implementation of AOT if they choose to do so, but these costs are not state- reimbursable as it remains at the county's discretion.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. The author believes this bill will ensure counties consider the preferences of their residents with respect to implementation of AOT. The author states the current process of opting in makes AOT implementation too difficult for counties to participate, evidenced by the fact that only a fraction of the counties have implemented AOT. The author contends mplementing AOT statewide will ensure that those at highest risks for hospitalization can obtain the necessary treatment services to keep them in the community, and notes this bill allows counties to retain control by opting out if they choose not to participate.
Background. Enacted in 2002, Laura’s Law was named for Laura Wilcox, a 19-year-old college student in Nevada County who was killed by a severely mentally ill man who was not adhering to prescribed mental health treatment. Laura’s Law permits counties to provide court-ordered outpatient treatment services for people with serious mental illness. To implement the order, a court must find that a person’s recent history of hospitalizations or violent behavior, coupled with noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicates the person is likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled without treatment. The intent of Laura's Law is to prevent a small number of individuals who meet narrow eligibility criteria from becoming gravely disabled or threatening. A county board of supervisors must pass a resolution in order to implement Laura's Law. To date, about nine counties have implemented Laura's Law in some form; counties have generally configured the implementation to align with local priorities.
Support. This bill is sponsored by the California Psychiatric Association and supported by physician groups, hospitals, and Nick and Amanda Wilcox, parents of the young woman for whom Laura's Law is named. They cite success of implemented AOT programs, and desire to increase the reach of this important option for outpatient treatment.
Opposition. Disability Rights California opposes this bill because it removes a key protection, namely, the prohibition on reducing voluntary mental health services when implementing AOT programs. Counties and their behavioral health agencies oppose this bill unless amended to remove all provisions, except the sunset extension. Counties cite increased county workload and reduction in county authority to decide whether to address the option to implement AOT, among other concerns.
Related Legislation.
AB 59 (Waldron) removes the sunset on Laura’s Law so that the program is indefinitely extended, eliminates the requirement that the board of supervisors in a county must find voluntary mental health programs will not be reduced as a result of implementation of AOT, and allows the professional staff of the facility where a person has been detained for involuntarily inpatient treatment to recommend a petition for AOT for that person.
AB 193 (Maienschein) Allows probate courts to recommend a referral for an LPS conservatorship to the county officer providing conservatorship investigations.
Prior Legislation.
AB 2266 (Waldron, 2014) increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 2266 failed in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1265 (Conway, 2013) increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 1265 also failed in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1193
Page 8
Date of Hearing: April 28, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
AB 1193
(Eggman) – As Introduced February 27, 2015
SUBJECT: MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES: ASSISTED OUTPATIENT TREATMENT
KEY ISSUES:
GIVEN THAT A NUMBER OF COUNTIES HAVE OPTED TO FULLY IMPLEMENT THE ASSISTED OUTPAITENT TREATMENT PROGRAM (AOT), ALSO KNOWN AS “LAURA’S LAW,” SHOULD ALL COUNTIES IN THE STATE BE REQUIRED TO OFFER AOT, UNLESS THEY OPT OUT OF THE REQUIREMENT TO DO SO?
SHOULD ALL COUNTIES BE REQUIRED TO ADOPT THE AOT PROGRAM WITHOUT HOLDING ANY PUBLIC HEARINGS, UNLESS THEY DECIDE NOT TO OFFER THE PROGRAM?
SHOULD THE JANUARY 1, 2017 DATE, WHEN THE INVOLUNTARY OUTPATIENT MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT PROGRAM DEMONSTRATION PROJECT IS SCHEDULED BY STATUTE TO EXPIRE, BE EXTENDED UNTIL JANUARY 1, 2022, FIVE YEARS AFTER ITS CURRENT SUNSET DATE?
SHOULD ANY SUPERIOR COURT JUDGE BE ABLE TO INITIATE THE PROCESS FOR OBTAINING A COURT ORDER FOR ASSISTED OUTPATIENT TREATMENT OF A PERSON APPEARING BEFORE THE JUDGE, EVEN THOUGH THE JUDGE MAY NOT BE FAMILIAR WITH EITHER THAT PERSON’S MENTAL HEALTH HISTORY, OR ALL OF THE OPTIONS FOR LESS INTRUSIVE MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT PROGRAMS THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY?
SYNOPSIS
The Involuntary Assisted Outpatient Mental Health Treatment Program (AOT), also known as “Laura’s Law,” was initially adopted in 2001, reauthorized in 2006, and reauthorized again in 2012. The law allows any county that wishes to provide “assisted outpatient treatment services,” as defined, to do so, but requires the county wishing to offer the program to make certain findings, including that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children’s mental health program, will be reduced as a result of the implementation of AOT. The program has been authorized for over 10 years and a number of small and large counties have either implemented AOT, or approved implementation: Nevada, Yolo, San Diego, Orange, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Contra Costa, Placer, and Mendocino. Given the positive, but somewhat limited “on the ground” experience with AOT in California, the bill proposes three significant changes to the program. First, it makes AOT an opt-out program, allowing a county that does not wish to implement the program to pass a resolution of the county board of supervisors stating the reasons for opting out and any facts or circumstances relied on in making that decision. Second, it extends for five years the date when the program is set to sunset, from January 1, 2017 until January 1, 2022. Third, it allows any superior court judge to request that the mental health director evaluate the person for AOT. This bill is sponsored by the California Psychiatric Association and supported by California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians, California Hospital Association, NAMI Contra Costa County, and the National Association of Social Workers. It is opposed by the California State Association of Counties (Oppose unless amended), California Association of Social Rehabilitation Agencies, County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California (Oppose unless amended), Disability Rights California, and Urban Counties Caucus (Oppose unless amended).
SUMMARY: Delete the provisions in current law that authorize, but do not require counties in the state to participate in the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project Act of 2002, known as Laura’s Law, extend the repeal date of January 1, 2017 until January 1, 2022, and allow any superior court judge to refer a person appearing before the judge for AOT evaluation. Specifically, this bill:
Deletes the provisions that authorize a county to participate in the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project Act of 2002, and instead requires all counties with available funding to implement the program, unless they opt out of implementation.
Extends the January 1, 2017, repeal date for the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project Act of 2002 until January 1, 2022, thereby extending the program for an additional five years.
Authorizes a judge in a superior court to request that the county mental director investigate whether it would be appropriate to file a petition seeking a court order for AOT relating to a person who appears before that judge.
EXISTING LAW:
Permits counties to provide AOT for people with serious mental illnesses when a court determines that a person’s recent history of hospitalizations or violent behavior, and noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicates the person is likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled without the court-ordered outpatient treatment. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 5346. All further statutory references are to this Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
Requires the board of supervisors of a county, in order to authorize an AOT program in the county to adopt the program by resolution or through the county budget process and make a finding that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children’s mental health program, may be reduced as a result of its implementation. (Section 5349.)
Allows a court, after finding that an individual meets the criteria for assisted outpatient treatment, and there is no appropriate and feasible less restrictive alternative, to order the individual to receive assisted outpatient treatment for an initial period not to exceed six months. If the director of the assisted outpatient program determines that the individual requires further assisted outpatient services, requires that director, prior to expiration of the time period of the treatment, to apply to the court for an extension of the services, not to exceed 180 days. (Section 5346(d), (g).)
Sunsets this authorization on January 1, 2017. (Section 5349.5(a).)
Grants any person subject to a petition for an order of assisted outpatient treatment the right to legal counsel at all steps of the hearing process. (Section 5346(d)(4)(C).)
Requires the Department of Health Services to submit a report and evaluation to the Governor and the Legislature of all counties implementing an assisted outpatient treatment program by July 1, 2015. (Section 5349.5(b).)
Establishes the Lanterman-Petris Short Act (LPS Act), which authorizes a person to be involuntarily detained for inpatient mental health treatment when, as a result of a mental disorder, the person is a danger to him or herself or to others, or is “gravely disabled”. Defines “gravely disabled” to mean a condition in which a person, as a result of a mental disorder, is unable to provide for his or her basic personal needs for food, clothing or shelter. (Sections 5008 (h)(1)(A) and 5150.)
Allows, under the LPS Act, a person who is gravely disabled to be involuntarily detained for further inpatient mental health treatment for an additional 14 days, as provided, which can be extended for 14 days if the person presents an imminent threat of taking his or her own life or 30 days if the county has authorized the program and the person remains gravely disabled. (Section 5250, 5257, 5260.)
Allows, under the LPS Act, a court to order an imminently dangerous person to be confined for further inpatient intensive health treatment for an additional 180 days, as provided. (Section 5300 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The AOT Demonstration Project allows courts in participating counties to order a person into an AOT program if the court finds that the individual either meets existing involuntary commitment requirements pursuant to Section 5150 (is gravely disabled, or is a danger to self or others), or the person meets non-5150 criteria, including that the person has refused treatment; their mental health condition is substantially deteriorating; and AOT would be the least restrictive level of care necessary to ensure the person's recovery and stability in the community. The law is only operative in those counties where the county board of supervisors, by resolution or budget action, authorizes its application and makes a finding that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children's mental health program, will be reduced in order to implement the law.
According to the author, “Assisted outpatient treatment is a community-based treatment program to assist individuals who, as a result of their severe mental illness, are unable to access community mental health services voluntarily. In fact, AOT is a less restrictive alternative to involuntary hospitalization, where an individual suffering from a severe mental illness is detained for up to 72 hours if they have presented a danger to themselves or others.”
Indeed, studies of involuntary outpatient programs have shown that the programs have impressive results. For example, a Duke University/North Carolina State University study in the 1990s showed that “subjects who underwent sustained periods of outpatient commitment beyond that of the initial court order had approximately 57% fewer readmissions and 20 fewer hospital days than control subjects.” That same study, however, showed that “sustained outpatient commitment reduced hospital readmissions only when combined with a higher intensity of outpatient treatment” and concluded that “use of outpatient commitment is not a substitute for intensive treatment; it requires a substantial commitment of treatment resources to be effective.”
Counties have a financial incentive to implement AOT programs, according to other recent studies. For example, a 2013 study showed that New York state’s AOT law, “Kendra’s Law,” resulted in substantial cost savings. “In the New York City sample, net costs declined 43% in the first year after assisted outpatient treatment began and an additional 13% in the second year. In the five-county sample, costs declined 49% in the first year and an additional 27% in the second year.” (Swanson et al, Am J Psychiatry 2013; 170:1423–1432.)
County Experience with implementation of AOT. The AOT Demonstration Project was first implemented in Nevada County. According to the treatment provider that provides AOT services in Nevada County, Turning Point Community Programs, initiating the AOT process begins with a referral submitted by family members, relatives, cohabitants, treatment providers or their supervisors, or peace officers. If the person meets the AOT eligibility requirements, a preliminary care plan is developed. If the individual voluntarily engages with the treatment after initial contact, a petition is no longer necessary and the patient no longer meets the criteria for AOT referral. However if the client declines the preliminary care plan, the AOT team proceeds with a petition and a public defender is assigned to the client. The court must be notified within 10 days of the intervention, and a hearing must be set within five days of the filing of the petition and the judge either grants or rejects the AOT petition. If ordered, AOT is valid for up to 180 days.
According to Nevada County, in the seven years the county has implemented Laura's Law, 37 AOT commitments have been ordered by the court, and six individuals have failed to complete their orders due to hospitalization, incarceration, or death. Nevada County indicates that the number of hospitalization days for program participants has been cut in half, and no patient has encountered problems with law enforcement since their commitment. In Orange County, two individuals have been ordered to fulfill an AOT commitment. The other county programs have been recently implemented and do not yet have any court ordered AOT commitments.
In the past ten years that AOT has been authorized, eight counties – Nevada, Yolo, San Diego, Orange, San Francisco, Contra Costa, Placer, and Mendocino -- have chosen to fully implement the program. (A ninth county, Los Angeles, has implemented AOT on a limited basis). In addition, according to the author, there are formal processes in motion that may lead to adoption before the Board of Supervisors in the following counties: El Dorado, Contra Costa, San Mateo, Kern, Santa Barbara, and Ventura.
County hearings - one person’s bureaucratic hurdle is another person’s public process. According to the author, the procedural requirements in current law are an obstacle for counties that wish to implement AOT programs. The author states:
Since Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT) was approved by the legislature in 2002, only nine counties have implemented it. . . . The current opt-in process makes AOT implementation difficult for counties to participate in, evidences [sic.] by the fact that only a fraction of counties have implemented AOT. Implementing AOT statewide will ensure that those at highest risk for hospitalization can obtain the necessary treatment services to keep them in the community. While this bill implements Laura’s Law statewide it does provide for counties to retain control by allowing them to opt out of participation in Laura’s Law if they so choose.
While it is true, as the author contends, that only a small percentage of the counties in the state have gone through the process to approve AOT, it is unclear why others have not done so (i.e. an issue of procedure or policy). As the Duke Study shows, AOT programs require “a substantial commitment of treatment resources to be effective.” It could be that counties do not have the personnel or financial resources to implement AOT in a manner that would be successful. If so, then it is appropriate for counties not to adopt the program.
Many counties may have considered and rejected implementation of AOT. This bill would force those counties to either implement a program they have previously rejected, or to hold another public hearing to reject adoption of the program they have already rejected in a public process. As the Urban Counties Coalition writes in opposition to the bill (unless it is amended to revert to the opt-in system in current law):
[W]e are opposed to the provision which would make it mandatory for every county to adopt Laura’s Law unless the county elects not to participate through a resolution. Since the enactment of Laura’s Law, it has been permissive due to the potential additional costs and policy issues that can vary among counties. In urban counties, 5 counties have adopted Laura’s Law in the past two years (Contra Costa, Los Angeles, Orange, San Diego, and San Francisco), therefore, we do not believe this section of the bill is necessary. In addition, this bill would mandate counties adopt Laura’s Law which would create a new burden on counties that may have already heard this issue recently in public hearings.
Opt-in versus opt-out. Despite the fact that AOT remains controversial in some communities and certainly some advocacy groups, the author seeks to remove the provision in current law which makes the program optional (“upon adoption of a resolution or budget act by the board of supervisors of a county and a finding that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children’s mental health program will be reduced as a result of its implementation”). Instead, this bill would make the program mandatory, unless the county board of supervisors adopts a resolution opting out of the program. While the author’s goal of statewide adoption of AOT is admirable, clearly not all counties wish to adopt the program. In light of the author’s well-meaning desire to encourage counties to consider adoption of the program while acknowledging the right of counties to reject the program, perhaps it would be appropriate to require a county that has not yet held a public hearing to consider adoption of AOT to do so. This would promote county consideration of the program, while taking into consideration the fact that some counties have already determined that AOT is inappropriate and should not be forced to reopen their decisions. Based upon these concerns, the following amendment is suggested to the author:
Page 14, at lines 14 – 17: strike out in their entirety
Page 14, at line 18, strike out “circumstances relied on in making that decision.” And insert the following:
This article shall be operative in those counties in which the county board of supervisors, by resolution or through the county budget process, authorizes its application.
Any county which has not held a public hearing by January 1, 2017 to determine whether this article shall be operative shall do so by January 1, 2018. At the hearing, the board of supervisors shall consider the options available in the county for providing services to persons whose recent history of hospitalization or violent behavior, and noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicate that they may be likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled, including but not limited to the following:
Options for providing services other than court-ordered outpatient treatment.
Whether any voluntary mental health program serving adults, or any children’s mental health program, may be reduced as a result of the implementation of this article.
Extension of the sunset provision. The AOT program was originally scheduled to expire by law on January 1, 2008, but was reauthorized in 2006, and reauthorized again in 2012. The 2012 legislation, Assembly Bill 1569 (Allen, Chapter 441, Statutes of 2102) was controversial. It was opposed by all of the groups that oppose this bill, but also many others that do not oppose this bill that removes the sunset in its entirety, including the American Civil Liberties Union of California, California Council of Community Mental Health Agencies, California Mental Health Planning Council, Mental Health America of California, and the National Association for Rights Protection and Advocacy. Based upon the fact that fewer groups oppose this much more far-reaching bill, it appears that the AOT program is more widely accepted and less controversial that it was at one time, but is not without critics.
Disability Rights California has “concerns about AOT programs and we believe that voluntary services are more effective and should be expanded, we believe that the sunset provision is important to protect the rights of people with mental health disabilities in California.” Meanwhile, the California Association of Mental Health Peer Run Organizations questions whether AOT is as effective as less coercive alternative treatments and writes:
Clearly it is the services that make the difference and produce positive results. Through the MHSA (Prop 63), California has put its money into a voluntary network of community services that are person centered and holistic and based on the recovery model. The results of a 2012 UCLA study of MHSA Full Service Partnerships found that every dollar spent on mental health services in California saved roughly $0.88 in costs to the criminal justice and health and housing services by reducing the number of arrests, incarcerations, ER visits, and hospitalizations. These same kinds of results were found in the Petris Center Evaluation, May 2010; a large reduction in homelessness, a rise in the proportion of consumers living independently, less use of mental health related emergency services, less incarcerations, and a rise in employment. AB 34 and 2034, the pilot programs that the full service partnerships are modeled on, produced the same kind of positive results.
Given these concerns and the importance of receiving more data about the implementation successes and failures, the Committee may find it prudent to reauthorize this program for another relatively short period, such as the five years suggested by the author.
Additional portal necessary for entry into AOT via the county courts? Current law allows specific individuals to request that the county mental health director file a motion for a court order requiring a person to participate in AOT:
Any person 18 years of age or older with whom the person who is the subject of the petition resides.
Any person who is the parent, spouse, or sibling or child 18 years of age or older of the person who is the subject of the petition.
The director of any public or private agency, treatment facility, charitable organization, or licensed residential care facility providing mental health services to the person who is the subject of the petition in whose institution the subject of the petition resides.
The director of a hospital in which the person who is the subject of the petition is hospitalized.
A licensed mental health treatment provider who is either supervising the treatment of, or treating for a mental illness, the person who is the subject of the petition.
A peace officer, parole officer, or probation officer assigned to supervise the person who is the subject of the petition. (5346(b)(2).)
All of these individuals are very familiar with either the person who is the potential subject of an AOT petition, or the county’s mental health resources, or both. On the other hand, this bill would authorize a “judge of a superior court before whom the person who is the subject of the petition appears” to request the county mental director to investigate whether it would be appropriate to file a petition for AOT relating to that person. A judge (who could be presiding over a traffic, family, juvenile, probate, or criminal matter) may not be familiar with either the person and his or her mental health history, or the resources available for mental health treatment of that person in the county. Therefore, the Committee may question whether this language is too broad and whether it would be more appropriate to limit this provision to judges who are familiar with the mental health background of the individual appearing before them and the mental health resources available in their county.
Disability Rights California writes, “Existing law provides a list of individuals who may request that a county mental health department file an AOT petition, based on the individual’s knowledge of and connection to the person who will be the subject of the petition. This bill would add to this list a Superior Court judge before whom the subject of the petition appears. A judge presiding over an unrelated legal matter would not necessarily have sufficient information about the individual who is subject to the petition to request that an AOT petition be filed. Adding to the existing list of people who can request a petition increases the possibility that the petitions may be filed without adequate basis, therefore further limiting individual rights.”
Based upon these concerns, the following amendment is suggested to the current language in the bill:
(G) A judge of a superior court court’s
mental health court, reentry court, or
other collaborative justice court available for improving the mental
health of the defendant, or a probate court before whom the
person who is the subject of the petition appears
as the subject of a proceeding pursuant to Section 5352.
Related pending legislation. AB 59 (Melendez) Removes the sunset on Laura’s Law so that the program is indefinitely extended and eliminates the requirement that the board of supervisors in a county must find, prior to authorizing the program, that other mental health programs, including but not limited to children’s mental health services will not be reduced as a result of implementation of AOT, and allows the professional staff of the facility where a person has been detained for involuntarily inpatient treatment to recommend a petition for AOT for that person.
AB 193 (Maienschein) Allows probate courts to recommend a referral for an LPS conservatorship to the county officer providing conservatorship investigations.
Previous legislation. AB 2266 (Waldron, 2014) would have increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 2266 failed in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1265 (Conway, 2013) would have increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 1265 also failed in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1569 (Allen), Chapter 441, Statutes of 2012, extended authorization for "Laura's Law" to January 1, 2017 and required DHCS to submit a report to the Legislature regarding the program by July 1, 2015.
AB 1421 (Thomson), Chapter 1017, Statutes of 2002, authorized counties to provide court-ordered outpatient treatment services for people with serious mental illnesses when a court finds that a person's recent history of hospitalizations or violent behavior, coupled with noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicate the person is likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled without the court-ordered outpatient treatment.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Psychiatric Association (sponsor)
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
California Hospital Association
NAMI Contra Costa County
National Association of Social Workers
Opposition
California State Association of Counties (Oppose unless amended)
California Association of Social Rehabilitation Agencies
County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California (Oppose unless amended)
Disability Rights California
Urban Counties Caucus (Oppose unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
AB 1193
Page 5
Date of Hearing: April 14, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Rob Bonta, Chair
AB 1193
(Eggman) – As Introduced February 27, 2015
SUBJECT: Mental health services: assisted outpatient treatment
SUMMARY: Mandates county implementation of the Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT) Demonstration Project, known as Laura's Law, and authorizes a superior court judge to request a petition to obtain AOT for a person who appears before the judge. Specifically, this bill:
Mandates county implementation of Laura's Law unless the county elects not to participate in the program by enacting a resolution passed by the county board of supervisors;
Authorizes a superior court judge to request a petition for AOT for any person appearing before the judge; and
Deletes the January 1, 2017 repeal date of Laura's Law and extends the program until January 1, 2022.
EXISTING LAW:
Permits counties to provide AOT services for people with serious mental illnesses when a court determines that a person’s recent history of hospitalizations or violent behavior, and noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicates the person is likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled without the court-ordered outpatient treatment.
Allows a court, after finding that an individual meets the criteria for AOT, and there is no appropriate and feasible less restrictive alternative, to order the individual to receive AOT for an initial period not to exceed six months. If the director of the assisted outpatient program determines that the individual requires further assisted outpatient services, requires that director, prior to expiration of the time period of the treatment, to apply to the court for an extension of the services, not to exceed 180 days.
Allows the following individuals to file a petition for an order authorizing AOT for another individual:
A county mental health director or his/her designee;
The spouse, parent, sibling or child 18 years or older of an individual that is the subject of a petition;
Any person over 18 residing with the individual;
The director of any public or private agency, treatment facility, charitable organization, or licensed residential care facility providing mental health services to the individual;
The director of a hospital in which the individual is hospitalized;
A licensed mental health treatment provider who is either supervising the treatment of, or treating for a mental illness for the individual;
A peace officer, parole office, or probation officer assigned to supervise the individual.
Sunsets the AOT Demonstration Project on January 1, 2017.
Grants any person subject to a petition for an order of AOT the right to legal counsel at all steps of the hearing process.
Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to submit a report and evaluation to the Governor and the Legislature of all counties implementing an AOT program by July 1, 2015.
Establishes the Lanterman-Petris Short Act (LPS Act), which authorizes a person to be involuntarily detained for inpatient mental health treatment when, as a result of a mental disorder, the person is a danger to him or herself or to others, or is “gravely disabled.” Defines “gravely disabled” to mean a condition in which a person, as a result of a mental disorder, is unable to provide for his or her basic personal needs for food, clothing or shelter.
Allows, under the LPS Act, a person who is gravely disabled to be involuntarily detained for further inpatient mental health treatment for an additional 14 days, as provided, which can be extended for 14 days if the person presents an imminent threat of taking his or her own life or 30 days if the county has authorized the program and the person remains gravely disabled.
Allows, under the LPS Act, a court to order an imminently dangerous person to be confined for further inpatient intensive health treatment for an additional 180 days, as provided.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, only nine counties have implemented AOT. Laura's Law is a community-based treatment program to assist individuals who, as a result of their severe mental illness, are unable to access community mental health services voluntarily. In fact, AOT is a less restrictive alternative to involuntary hospitalization, where an individual suffering from a severe mental illness is contained for 72 hours if they have presented a danger to themselves or others. The current process of opting in makes AOT implementation too difficult for counties to participate, evidenced by the fact that only a fraction of the counties have implemented AOT. Implementing AOT statewide will ensure that those at highest risks for hospitalization can obtain the necessary treatment services to keep them in the community. The author writes that while this bill implements Laura's Law statewide, this bill does allow counties to retain control by allowing them to opt out if they choose not to participate in Laura's Law.
BACKGROUND. The AOT Demonstration Project allows courts in participating counties to order a person into an AOT program if the court finds that the individual either meets existing involuntary commitment requirements pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code Section 5150 (is gravely disabled or is a danger to self or others), or the person meets non-5150 criteria including that the person has refused treatment, their mental health condition is substantially deteriorating, and AOT would be the least restrictive level of care necessary to ensure the person's recovery and stability in the community. The law is only operative in those counties in which the county board of supervisors, by resolution, authorizes its application and makes a finding that no voluntary mental health program serving adults, and no children's mental health program, was reduced in order to implement the law.
COUNTY IMPLEMENTATION. Currently, Nevada, Orange, Yolo, and the City and County of San Francisco have approved full implementation of Laura's Law; Los Angeles County implemented the law on a limited basis. According to the treatment provider that Nevada County contracts with for services, Turning Point Community Programs, Initiating the AOT process begins with a referral submitted by family members, relatives, cohabitants, treatment providers or their supervisors, or peace officers. If individuals meet AOT eligibility requirements, a preliminary care plan is developed. If the individual voluntarily engages with the treatment after initial contact, a petition is no longer necessary and the patient no longer meets the criteria for AOT referral. However if the client declines the preliminary care plan, the AOT team proceeds with a petition and a public defender is assigned to the client. The court must be notified within 10 days of the intervention, and a hearing must be set within five days of the filing of the petition and the judge either grants or rejects the AOT petition. If ordered, AOT is valid for up to 180 days.
According to Nevada County, in the seven years the county has implemented Laura's Law, 37 AOT commitments have been ordered by the court, and six individuals have failed to complete their orders due to hospitalization, incarceration, or death. Nevada County indicates that the number of hospitalization days for program participants has been cut in half, and no patient has encountered problems with law enforcement since their commitment. In Orange County, two individuals have been ordered to fulfill an AOT commitment. The other county programs have been recently implemented and do not yet have any court ordered AOT commitments.
SUPPORT. Nick and Amanda Wilcox, in support of this bill and of Laura's Law which is named after their daughter who was shot and killed at the age of 19 by a man with untreated severe mental illness. The Wilcox’s write that since implementation in Nevada County in 2008, money and lives have been saved and now over 40% of Californians have access to AOT through Laura's Law. With growing acceptance and visible success, the family believes time has come to require further implementation unless counties have specific reasons to opt out. The Wilcox’s state that hurdles such as funding have been handled by previous legislation and threats of litigation from mental health advocacy groups have yet to manifest any legal challenges in the largest counties with implementation.
The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians, states in support this bill that Laura's Law was signed into law in 2002 and allows for court ordered assisted outpatient psychiatric treatment in counties that have implemented the program. Currently, there is no requirement that counties implement Laura's Law. The supporters state that this bill is an important measure that will expand implementation of Laura's Law by requiring that counties implement the program, unless the county elects not to participate by vote of the county board of supervisors.
The California Medical Association (CMA) states in support that this bill would delete the provisions in current law that authorize a county to voluntarily elect to implement the provisions of Laura's Law thereby making it a mandatory program. By making this important law mandatory, this bill will ensure that each county in the state has the ability and resources to provide AOT and will result in better health outcomes for the patients that are treated while at the same time provide cost savings to the locality by avoiding costly hospitalizations and incarcerations.
OPPOSITION. Disability Rights California (DRC) writes in opposition that this bill removes many provisions in current law that protects the rights of individuals subject to AOT. DRC states that this bill removes the requirement that a county board of supervisors approve an AOT program and the county prohibition to reduce voluntary mental health services when implementing AOT programs. According to DRC, this bill increases in the maximum duration of an AOT order from six to twelve months; broadens the group of people who can request an AOT petition; and removes the program's sunset provision. DRC states that to the extent it continues to be authorized in California, counties should retain local control and AOT should be at their election and not imposed on them by the state. DRC notes that existing law provides that certain people who are involved in providing mental health treatment to an individual, including a licensed mental health treatment provider and the director of a hospital, public or private agency, treatment facility, charitable organization or licensed residential care facility, any request that the county mental health department file an AOT petition on behalf of that individual. This bill would add "the professional staff" of an agency or facility that provided involuntary treatment to an individual to that list." DRC argues that this increases the possibility that the petitions may be filed without adequate basis, therefore further limiting individual rights.
RELATED LEGISLATION. AB 59 (Waldron) authorizes county participation in the AOT Demonstration Project without requiring counties to make findings that no existing mental health programs will be reduced as a result of AOT implementation, and increases the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 59 is pending in this Assembly Health Committee.
PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
AB 2266 (Waldron) of 2014, would have increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 2266 failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1265 (Conway) of 2013 increased the maximum period of imposed outpatient treatment under the AOT Demonstration Project from six months to one year. AB 1265 also failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1569 (Allen), Chapter 441, Statutes of 2012, extends authorization for “Laura's Law” to January 1, 2017, and require the DHCS to submit the report by July 1, 2015.
SB 1606 (Yee) of 2008 would have required the Department of Mental Health to conduct a study of individuals whose mental health needs are not currently being met, because they do not meet existing eligibility criteria for AOT, but have mental health needs that may not be met through voluntary services. This bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1421 (Thomson), Chapter 1017, Statutes of 2002, permits counties to provide court-ordered outpatient treatment services for people with serious mental illnesses when a court finds that a person's recent history of hospitalizations or violent behavior, coupled with noncompliance with voluntary treatment, indicate the person is likely to become dangerous or gravely disabled without the court-ordered outpatient treatment.
DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double referred, upon passage of this Committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Psychiatric Association (sponsor)
California Chapter
of the American College of Emergency Physicians
California
Hospital Association
California Medical Association
California
Treatment Advocacy Coalition
Dignity Health
Nick and
Amanda Wilcox (parents of Laura for whom Laura’s Law was named)
The
ARC California
United Cerebral Palsy Collaboration
Opposition
California Association of Mental Health Peer Run
Organizations
California Association of Social Rehabilitation
Agencies
California Council of Community Mental Health
Agencies
California Psychological Association
Disability
Rights California
Mental Health America of California
Analysis Prepared by: Paula Villescaz / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):