AB 1012: State Air Resources Board: mobile source regulations: lifecycle analysis.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-04-26
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law imposes various limitations on emissions of air contaminants for the control of air pollution from vehicular and nonvehicular sources. Existing law generally designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution. Existing law requires the state board to adopt and implement motor vehicle emission standards, in-use performance standards, and motor vehicle fuel specifications for the control of air contaminants.
This bill would require the state board, if it proposes a regulation to regulate a an on-road mobile source, to prepare a lifecycle analysis, as defined, of any technology required by the regulation. regulation, and in its discretion, any incumbent technology.
Existing law imposes various limitations on emissions of air contaminants for the control of air pollution from vehicular and nonvehicular sources. Existing law generally designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution. Existing law requires the state board to adopt and implement motor vehicle emission standards, in-use performance standards, and motor vehicle fuel specifications for the control of air contaminants.
This bill would require the state board, if it proposes a regulation that would require a mobile source to use a particular technology, to perform to regulate a mobile source, to prepare a lifecycle analysis that considers all of the environmental impacts of the required technology before the adoption of the regulation. analysis, as defined, of any technology required by the regulation.
Existing law imposes various limitations on emissions of air contaminants for the control of air pollution from vehicular and nonvehicular sources. Existing law generally designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution. Existing law requires the state board to adopt and implement motor vehicle emission standards, in-use performance standards, and motor vehicle fuel specifications for the control of air contaminants.
This bill would require the state board, if it proposes a regulation that would require a mobile source to use a particular technology, to perform a lifecycle analysis that considers all of the environmental impacts of the required technology before the adoption of the regulation.
(a)If the state board proposes a regulation to regulate a an on-road mobile source pursuant to this part, Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500), or any other law, the state board shall, as part of the environmental analysis conducted for the adoption of the regulation, prepare a lifecycle analysis of any technology required by the regulation. regulation, and, in its discretion, any incumbent technology.
(b)For purposes of this section, lifecycle analysis means an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions to the environment. The scope of environmental impacts in the analysis shall include, but is not limited to, the assessment from raw material extraction and processing, through the products manufacture, distribution, and use, to the recycling or final disposal of the materials composing it. The assessments shall include, but are not limited to, consideration of carbon dioxide emissions.
(a)If the state board proposes a regulation that would require a mobile source to use a particular technology in order to comply with an emissions standard or other requirement, to regulate a mobile source pursuant to this part, Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500), or any other law, the state board shall, before the adoption of the regulation, perform as part of the environmental analysis conducted for the adoption of the regulation, prepare a lifecycle analysis that considers all of the environmental impacts of the required technology. analysis of any technology required by the regulation.
(b)For purposes of this section, lifecycle analysis means an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions to the environment. The scope of environmental impacts in the analysis shall include, but is not limited to, the assessment from raw material extraction and processing, through the products manufacture, distribution, and use, to the recycling or final disposal of the materials composing it. The assessments shall include, but are not limited to, consideration of carbon dioxide emissions.
If the state board proposes a regulation that would require a mobile source to use a particular technology in order to comply with an emissions standard or other requirement, the state board shall, before the adoption of the regulation, perform a lifecycle analysis that considers all of the environmental impacts of the required technology.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2024 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 18, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 4, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on TRANS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Transportation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350 Humboldt | ** Against | |
| 350 Sacramento | ** Against | |
| Auto Care Association | ** Support | |
| Bioenergy Association of California | ** Support | |
| California Compost Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Fuels And Convenience Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Renewable Transportation Alliance | ** Support | |
| CAWA | ** Support | |
| Clean Energy | ** Support | |
| Clean Fleets Coalition | ** Support | |
| Climate Action California | ** Against | |
| Gladstein Neandross & Associates | ** Support | |
| Green Latinos | ** Against | |
| Hexagon Agility | ** Support | |
| Industrial Environmental Association | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts | ** Support | |
| Natural Gas Vehicles for America | ** Support | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council | ** Against | |
| Resource Recovery Coalition Of California | ** Support | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Against | |
| Southern California Gas Company | ** Support | |
| Union Of Concerned Scientists | ** Against | |
| Western Propane Gas Association | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1012
Author:(Quirk-Silva) – As Amended Ver:April 26, 2023
Policy Committee: | Transportation | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Air Resources Board (ARB), if it proposes a regulation to regulate an on-road mobile source, as part of the environmental analysis conducted for the adoption of the regulation, to prepare a lifecycle analysis (LCA) of any technology required by the regulation and, at ARB’s discretion, any incumbent technology.
FISCAL EFFECT:
ARB estimates costs of approximately $7.1 million for 17 positions and contracts in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and $4.6 million in FY 2024-25 and ongoing to implement this bill (Cost of Implementation Account). Tasks include, but are not limited to, developing a lifecycle emission inventory database and regulation support tool to incorporate vehicle manufacturing, disposal, and recycling emissions into existing analysis; external engagement with experts and stakeholders on lifecycle emission impacts for varying mobile source types; contracts for external research on GHG and criteria and toxic emissions impacts for manufacturing and disposal for each mobile source sector; and other related tasks.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the author:
California is a global leader in policies dedicated to reducing carbon emissions, including in the transition away from fossil fuels. However, California also needs the most complete data possible when making policy decisions on mobile sources. [This] bill will require CARB to perform and include, as part of any already required environmental analysis in a relevant regulatory proceeding, a GHG emissions lifecycle analysis of the required technology. [This bill] is a pragmatic, transparency bill that will result in more data to better understand clean transportation decisions for climate change policy.
2) Background. For each regulation ARB develops, to comply with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), ARB prepares an environmental analysis to assess the potential for significant adverse and beneficial environmental impacts associated with the proposed regulation. This bill would require ARB, as part of that environmental analysis, to prepare an LCA of any technology required by a mobile source regulation. As defined in the bill, an LCA is an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions. The LCA must include the assessment of a product’s environmental effect, from raw material extraction and processing; manufacture, distribution, and use; to recycling or final disposal. The LCA also must consider carbon dioxide emissions.
Existing LCAs differ in their inputs and methods, such as data, system boundary, and assumptions, and have produced differing results. Practitioners and academics alike have long recognized challenges in the application of LCA for regulatory purposes. Some elements of an LCA are fairly speculative. Similarly, the LCA contemplated by this bill may need to rely on speculation and assumptions because there is insufficient data in a variety of areas to conduct accurate or reliable LCAs. CEQA requires analysis of indirect impacts where they are “reasonably foreseeable” and directs agencies to avoid analyzing effects that are speculative. It is, therefore, not clear how an LCA conducted pursuant to this bill relates to CEQA, if at all.
Writing in support, the California Renewable Transportation Alliance states:
CARB is required to perform an LCA under the Low Carbon Fuel Standard to calculate the carbon intensity values of transportation fuels. This analysis has been a significant contributing factor to the successful decarbonization of the state’s fuel inventory. However, California law does not require this type of comprehensive, all-inclusive analysis for vehicles. AB 1012 will create synergy between the evaluation of transportation fuels and the vehicles they operate. It will enable policy makers to better assess how required vehicle technologies help the state achieve the net GHG reductions needed to realize its ambitious goals.
Writing in opposition, a coalition of environmental organizations states:
This bill is unnecessary because CARB already does robust environmental analyses on their regulations. Their recent environmental analysis on the proposed advanced clean fleets rule is 176 pages long and includes the NOx, particulate matter, and greenhouse gas emission reductions associated with the rule’s adoption and even evaluated impacts associated with raw mineral extraction. Life cycle analyses are complicated, time consuming and, in the end, provide a number that is not useful on its own…this is just an additional burden on CARB to prove what we already know: that we need to replace polluting transportation with zero emission technologies as soon as possible.
Analysis Prepared by: Nikita Koraddi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION
Laura Friedman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1012 (
Author:Quirk-Silva) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2023
SUBJECT: State Air Resources Board: mobile source regulations: lifecycle analysis
SUMMARY: Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB), if it proposes a regulation to regulate a mobile source, to prepare a lifecycle analysis (LCA) of any technology required by the regulation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the LCA to be a part of the environmental analysis conducted for the adoption of the regulation.
- Defines “LCA” to mean an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions to the environment.
- Requires the scope of the environmental impacts in the analysis to include, but not be limited to, the assessment from raw material extraction and processing, through the product’s manufacture, distribution, and use, to the recycling or final disposal of the materials composing it.
- Requires the assessments to include, but not be limited to, consideration of carbon dioxide emissions.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes CARB as the air pollution control agency in California and requires CARB, among other things, to control emissions from a wide array of mobile sources and coordinate with local air districts to control emission from stationary sources in order to implement the Federal Clean Air Act. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 39602; HSC 39602.5)
- Requires CARB, pursuant to California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32 (Núñez), Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006), to adopt a statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions limit equivalent to 1990 levels by 2020 and to develop a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost effective reductions in GHGs. (HSC 38500)
- Requires, pursuant to SB 32 (Pavley), Chapter 249, Statutes of 2016, that CARB ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below 1990 levels by 2030. (HSC 38566)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Climate Crisis Act (AB 1279 (Muratsuchi), Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022), that it is the policy of the state to do both of the following:
- Achieve net zero GHG emissions as soon as possible but no later than 2045; and,
- Ensure that by 2045, GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below 1990 levels.
- States the intent of the Legislature that CARB design emission reduction measures to meet the statewide emissions limits for GHGs in a manner that minimizes costs and maximizes benefits for California’s economy, improves and modernizes California’s energy infrastructure and maintains electric system reliability, maximizes additional environmental and economic cobenefits for California, and complements the state’s efforts to improve air quality. (HSC 38501)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: The Legislature has set a number of goals to reduce GHG emissions and address climate change. The Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32 (Nunez), Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006) and subsequent companion legislation SB 32 (Pavley), Chapter 249, Statutes of 2016 requires California to reduce statewide GHG emissions to 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. AB 1279 (Muratsuchi), Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022 establishes the policy of the state to achieve carbon neutrality as soon as possible, but no later than 2045. CARB is responsible for developing a Scoping Plan to detail how the state will achieve its GHG emissions reduction targets mandated by law.
Nearly 40% of California's GHG emissions are generated by the transportation sector, which includes both the light-duty (passenger) and medium- and heavy-duty fleets. Heavy-duty diesel trucks also contribute to unhealthy levels of ozone, inhalable particulate matter, carbon monoxide, NOx, and sulfur dioxide, affecting local air quality. In the transportation sector, measures to reduce GHG emissions include requiring the use of low carbon fuels, cleaner vehicles, and strategies to promote sustainable communities and improved transportation choices that reduce growth in number of vehicle miles traveled.
For each regulation, to comply with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), CARB prepares an environmental analysis to assess the potential for significant adverse and beneficial environmental impacts associated with proposed regulations for emissions from mobile sources such as cars, trucks, tractors, and other on-road vehicles and off-road equipment.
This bill would require CARB to prepare an LCA of any technology required by a mobile source regulation, as a part of that environmental analysis. LCA is a method to account for the environmental impact of a product throughout its life cycle, including resource extraction, production, and all other supply-chain impacts. Determining the total net emissions of alternative energy sources requires a thorough understanding of how it is made. Existing LCAs differ in their methods, such as data, system boundary, and assumptions, and have produced differing results. Despite the complexities of using LCA in a regulatory context, a desire to design policies that achieve GHG emissions reductions has motivated an increase in the use of LCA for policy development, particularly in the context of fuels. Currently CARB utilizes LCAs for the Low Carbon Fuel Standard program to determine the carbon intensity of various fuel production pathways.
In addition to performing LCAs for energy sources, this bill would require CARB to perform a LCA on the vehicle components if it proposed a regulation that required the use of particular technology. As an example, producing lithium-ion batteries for electric vehicles is more material-intensive than producing traditional combustion engines, and the demand for these materials is rising. Battery materials come with other costs, too. Mining raw materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel is labor-intensive, requires chemicals and large amounts of water—frequently from areas where water is scarce—and can leave contaminants and toxic waste behind. 60% of the world’s cobalt comes from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, where questions about human rights violations such as child labor continue to arise. Even though California’s electric grid is not currently carbon-free and even when accounting for the initial emissions associated with manufacturing the battery, many analyses conclude that electric cars still emit less CO2 than gas-powered cars over their entire lifetime.
Practitioners and academics alike have long recognized challenges in the application of LCA for regulatory purposes (Hunt et al., 1996). For example, Lave et al. (1995) stated with respect to one LCA method commonly used today, "Equally credible analyses can produce qualitatively different results, so the results of any particular LCA cannot be defended scientifically.” More recently, Ekvall (2019), noted: “[I]t was clear almost from the start that results from different LCAs can contradict each other. This is still true, despite many attempts to harmonize, standardize, and regulate LCA. From history, we learn that it is not realistic to expect LCA to deliver a unique and objective result. It should not be regarded as a single unique method; it is more fruitful to consider it a family of methods.” Applying this conclusion to the example of batteries given above, LCA methodologies and data input can greatly influence conclusions about the carbon intensity of batteries. Early battery LCAs may not accurately represent different production facilities and studies may not include battery recycling in their calculations.
According to the author, “California is a global leader in policies dedicated to reducing carbon emissions, including in the transition away from fossil fuels. However, California also needs the most complete data possible when making policy decisions on mobile sources. [This] bill will require CARB to perform and include, as part of any already required environmental analysis in a relevant regulatory proceeding, a GHG emissions lifecycle analysis of the required technology. [This bill] is a pragmatic, transparency bill that will result in more data to better understand clean transportation decisions for climate change policy.”
In support, the California Renewable Transportation Alliance writes, “While CARB is required to perform an LCA under the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) to calculate the carbon intensity values of transportation fuels, state law does not require this type of all-inclusive analysis for the use of vehicle technologies. The LCA has been a significant contributing factor to the successful decarbonization of the state’s transportation fuels. [This bill] will create synergy between these efforts and enable policymakers to evaluate whether required technologies can achieve the net GHG reductions necessary to meet the state’s intended goals.”
In opposition, a coalition including the Union of Concerned Scientists writes, “The primary objective of CARB’s regulations is often to achieve federal air quality standards set forth in the State Implementation Plan which is developed via a public process. Although GHG emission reductions are a desirable co-benefit of CARB’s regulations, they are mainly focused on reducing smog-forming oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and particulate matter (PM). The zero-emission technologies that CARB’s regulations require have been determined through robust, public rulemaking processes to be the most effective means of reducing toxic air contaminants.
We believe that [this bill] would impose an unnecessary and potentially harmful burden on CARB. This bill does not require a comparison between incumbent polluting technologies and the proposed zero-emission technologies, and it may hinder the state’s progress towards transitioning to zero-emission technologies by adding an unnecessary and complicated step to the rulemaking process. Furthermore, if CARB does not conduct an LCA on the combustion technologies as well, it could open the door for polluting industries to perform their own analyses using different assumptions and undermine the state’s transition to a zero-emission future.”
Committee comments: This bill defines LCA as an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions to the environment. This bill requires the scope of environmental impacts in the analysis to include the assessment from raw material extraction and processing, through the product’s manufacture, distribution, and use, to the recycling or final disposal of the materials composing it.
As a part of the Advanced Clean Fleet Regulation which aims to accelerate the transition to zero-emission medium- and heavy-duty vehicles, CARB performed an environmental analysis, as required under CEQA. This analysis includes impacts from mineral resources.
This bill does not specify what CARB would be required to do with the information it obtained from performing a LCA. As a result, it is unclear what the impact of having CARB perform LCAs would be. Based on the author’s statement, the bill would provide “data to better understand clean transportation decisions for climate change policy”, but it is unclear how that would happen.
This bill does not require an LCA of existing technology. Without an LCA of existing technology there is no baseline to compare with the LCA of new technology. Without this the utility of a LCA number for the new technology may not be very meaningful. New technology required by regulations should be compared to a baseline in order to provide value to decision makers. For example, this creates an uneven playing field whereby the zero-emission technologies would have a GHG value assigned to them, while the polluting combustion technologies would not.
Amendments: The committee recommends the bill be amended to require CARB to prepare an LCA of existing technology. Amendments to the current version of the bill are shown below in bold and underlined.
39601.3. (a) If the state board proposes a regulation to regulate an on-road mobile source pursuant to this part, Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500), or any other law, the state board shall, as part of the environmental analysis conducted for the adoption of the regulation, prepare a lifecycle analysis of any technology required by the regulation, and based on their discretion, any incumbent technology.
(b) For purposes of this section, “lifecycle analysis” means an analysis that involves a thorough inventory of the energy and materials that are required across the industry value chain to produce the product and that calculates the corresponding emissions to the environment. The scope of environmental impacts in the analysis shall include, but is not limited to, the assessment from raw material extraction and processing, through the product’s manufacture, distribution, and use, to the recycling or final disposal of the materials composing it. The assessments shall include, but are not limited to, consideration of carbon dioxide emissions.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Renewable Transportation Alliance (sponsor)
Auto Care Association
Bioenergy Association of California
California Compost Coalition
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Renewable Transportation Alliance
Cawa
Clean Energy
Clean Fleets Coalition
Gladstein Neandross & Associates
Hexagon Agility
Industrial Environmental Association
Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts
Natural Gas Vehicles for America
Resource Recovery Coalition of California
Southern California Gas Company
Western Propane Gas Association
Opposition
350 Humboldt
350 Sacramento
Climate Action California
Green Latinos
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
Union of Concerned Scientists
Analysis Prepared by: Christine Casey / TRANS. / (916) 319-2093
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Transportation
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):