AB 1068: Public Utilities Commission: ex parte communications.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-13
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-13: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 826, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. The bill would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time before the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would instead authorize an interested person to submit a written ex parte communication during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding if the commission materially modifies the proposed decision during that time period, as specified.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. The bill would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time before the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would instead authorize an interested person to submit a written ex parte communication during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding if the commission materially modifies the proposed decision during that time period, as specified.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and proceedings. The bill would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time before the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. proceedings, and would instead authorize an interested person to submit a written ex parte communication during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding if the commission materially modifies the proposed decision during that time period, as specified.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. The bill would require the commission, if it modifies a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding during the 3 business days before its scheduled vote on the proposed decision, to hold the proposed decision until the next scheduled voting meeting.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet period. periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. The bill would require the commission, if it modifies a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding during the 3 business days before its scheduled vote on the proposed decision, to hold the proposed decision until the next scheduled voting meeting.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes a decisionmaker to permit oral communications only if all parties are given not less than 3 working days notice, prohibits individual ex parte meetings during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize oral communications with the personal staff of a commissioner, if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, to be permitted, which would not be subject to the notice requirement described above. This bill would specify that the prohibition on individual ex parte meetings during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision does not apply to individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, and would authorize individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity to occur during the week of a commission business meeting, as defined. The bill would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet period.
Existing law establishes various requirements for ex parte communication between the Public Utilities Commission and interested parties for ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and, among other things, authorizes the commission, by order or rule, to prohibit ex parte communications. Existing law authorizes a decisionmaker to permit oral communications only if all parties are given not less than 3 working days notice, prohibits individual ex parte meetings during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, authorizes written ex parte communications by an interested person to be permitted if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication, and requires the commission to establish a quiet period during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision during which oral and written ex parte communications are prohibited.
This bill would authorize oral communications with the personal staff of a commissioner, if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, to be permitted, which would not be subject to the notice requirement described above. This bill would specify that the prohibition on individual ex parte meetings during the 3 business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision does not apply to individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, and would authorize individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity to occur during the week of a commission business meeting, as defined. The bill would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. The bill would delete the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet period.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit oral ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction before the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted.
(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(d)(1)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the first two business days of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication during those two business days if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(2)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the last business day of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication on that day if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit oral ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction before the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted.
(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(d)(1)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the first two business days of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication during those two business days if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(2)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the last business day of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication on that day if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit oral ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction before the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted.
(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(d)(1)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the first two business days of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication during those two business days if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(2)If the commission materially modifies a proposed decision during the last business day of the three-day quiet period before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, an interested person may submit a written ex parte communication on that day if copies of the written ex parte communication are concurrently transmitted to all parties at the same time as the written ex parte communication is submitted to the commission and the scope of the written ex parte communication is limited to the portion of the proposed decision that was materially modified.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit oral ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted.
(c)If the commission modifies a proposed decision during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, the commission shall hold the proposed decision until the next scheduled voting meeting.(d)(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit oral ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted.
(c)If the commission modifies a proposed decision during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the proposed decision, the commission shall hold the proposed decision until the next scheduled voting meeting.
(c)(d)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)(A)(i)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice, except as specified in clause (ii). notice. Individual ex parte meetings shall not be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision.
(ii)Notwithstanding clause (i), oral communications with the personal staff of a commissioner, if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, may be permitted.(B)(i)No individual ex parte meetings shall be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision, except as specified in this subparagraph.(ii)Clause (i) does not apply to individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity.(iii)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 1701.9, individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity may occur during the week of a commission business meeting. For purposes of this clause, the week of a commission business meeting includes each business day of a week during which a public meeting of at least three commissioners occurs and at which the commissioners discuss and vote on a related proposed decision, policy, rule, or other issue.(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by an interested person shall be permitted at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral ex parte communications shall not be permitted, except as specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (h) of Section 1701.3. permitted.
(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
(a)Except as specified in subdivision (h), this section shall apply only to ratesetting cases, except, if the commissioner assigned pursuant to Section 1701.1 has determined that a ratesetting case does not require a hearing, the procedures prescribed by subdivisions (b), (d), (f), and (i) shall not apply.
(b)The assigned commissioner shall determine before the first hearing whether the commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge shall be designated as the principal hearing officer. The principal hearing officer shall be present for more than one-half of the hearing days. The decision of the principal hearing officer shall be the proposed decision.
(c)An alternate decision may be issued by the assigned commissioner or the assigned administrative law judge who is not the principal hearing officer. Any alternate decision may be filed with the commission and served upon on all parties to the proceeding any time before the issuance of a final decision by the commission, consistent with the requirements of Section 311.
(d)The commission shall establish a procedure for any party to request the presence of a commissioner at a hearing. The assigned commissioner shall be present at any closing arguments in the case.
(e)The principal hearing officer shall present the proposed decision to the full commission in a public meeting. The alternate decision, if any, shall also be presented to the full commission at that public meeting.
(f)The presentation to the full commission shall contain a record of the number of days of the hearing, the number of days that each commissioner was present, and whether the decision was completed on time.
(g)The commission shall provide by rule for peremptory challenges and challenges for cause of the administrative law judge. Challenges for cause shall include, but not be limited to, financial interests and prejudice. All parties shall be entitled to unlimited peremptory challenges in any case in which the administrative law judge has within the previous 12 months served in any capacity in an advocacy position at the commission, been employed by a regulated public utility, or has represented a party or has been an interested person in the case.
(h)(1)Ex parte communications in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings are subject to the disclosure requirements of this article. The commission, by order or ruling, may prohibit ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
(2)(A)(i)Oral communications may be permitted by a decisionmaker if all parties are given not less than three working days notice. No notice, except as specified in clause (ii).
(ii)Notwithstanding clause (i), oral communications with the personal staff of a commissioner, if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity, may be permitted.
(B)(i)No individual ex parte meetings shall be held during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on the decision. decision, except as specified in this subparagraph.
(ii)Clause (i) does not apply to individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity.
(iii)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 1701.9, individual ex parte meetings with the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity may occur during the week of a commission business meeting. For purposes of this clause, the week of a commission business meeting includes each business day of a week during which a public meeting of at least three commissioners occurs and at which the commissioners discuss and vote on a related proposed decision, policy, rule, or other issue.
(3)(A)If an ex parte communication meeting is granted to any party, all other parties, upon request, shall also be granted individual ex parte meetings of a substantially equal period of time and shall be sent a notice of that opportunity at the time the request is granted.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply if the decisionmaker participating in the ex parte communication meeting is a member of the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity and no other decisionmaker to whom subparagraph (A) applies is a participant.
(4)Written ex parte communications by any an interested person may shall be permitted at any time without restriction if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
(5)Written and oral ex parte communications shall not be part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding.
(i)Any party has the right to present a final oral argument of its case before the commission. Upon request to present a final oral argument before the commission, the argument shall be scheduled in a timely manner. A quorum of the commission shall be present for the final oral arguments.
(j)The commission may, in issuing its decision, adopt, modify, or set aside the proposed decision or any part of the decision based on evidence in the record. The final decision of the commission shall be issued not later than 60 days after the issuance of the proposed decision. Under extraordinary circumstances the commission may extend this date for a reasonable period. The 60-day period shall be extended for 30 days if any alternate decision is proposed pursuant to Section 311.
SEC. 2.Section 1701.9 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:1701.9.The following provisions apply during the pendency of a commission proceeding, except these provisions do not apply during an adjudicatory or quasi-legislative proceeding:
(a)The commission may meet in closed session to deliberate on a proposed decision, order, or resolution after providing three-day advance notice to the public.
(b)The commission shall establish a quiet period during the three business days before the commissions scheduled vote on a decision, during which oral and written ex parte communications shall not be permitted. permitted, except as specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (h) of Section 1701.3.
(c)The requirement specified in subparagraph (F) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 11123 of the Government Code shall not apply to a meeting of the commission during a quiet period that is held by teleconference.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 13, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 826, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 13, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 21, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 77. Noes 0. Page 3537.). |
| Sep 13, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 32. Noes 3. Page 2728.). |
| Sep 11, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 14, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 1.) (July 3). |
| Jun 21, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| May 17, 2023 | Referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| May 9, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 8, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 66. Noes 0. Page 1487.) |
| Apr 24, 2023 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | From Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 20, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (April 19). |
| Mar 28, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (March 22). |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2023 | AB 1068 Valencia Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1068 Valencia By Padilla | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2023 | AB 1068 Valencia Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2023 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 22, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California African American Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Asian Pacific Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Broadband & Video Association | ** Support | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Hispanic Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Water Association | ** Support | |
| Pacific Gas And Electric Company | ** Support | |
| San Diego Gas & Electric Company | ** Support | |
| Sonoma Clean Power | ** Against | |
| Southern California Gas Company | ** Support | |
| The Utility Reform Network | ** Against |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1068
Author:(Valencia)
As Amended Ver:September 8, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Deletes current prohibitions on written ex parte communication (communications about an issue before the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) that is provided outside the formal proceeding process) in specified proceedings at the CPUC.
Senate Amendments
- Authorize, expressly, the CPUC to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings;
- Expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction during the final three business days before the CPUC's scheduled vote on a decision, in the specified proceedings, if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties at the same time as the original communication and the communication is limited to the portion of the CPUC's decision that was materially modified.
COMMENTS
CPUC proceedings – CPUC proceedings are formal judicial processes used to evaluate a variety of requests related to the industries that the CPUC regulates. A proceeding can be a request, complaint, or application, or it can be a CPUC initiated investigation or rulemaking. The purpose of a proceeding is to establish an evidentiary record on which to base CPUC decisions. Statute directs the CPUC to identify each of its proceedings according to the following categories:
- Adjudication – enforcement cases and complaints, except those challenging the reasonableness of rates or charges.
- Quasi-legislative – those that establish policy, including, but not limited to, rulemakings and investigations that establish rules affecting an entire industry.
- Ratesetting – cases in which rates are established for a specific company.
- Catastrophic Wildfire – those involving recovery of costs related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU), as added and defined by AB 1054 (Holden), Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019.
Ex parte communications. Ex parte communications are oral or written communication about an issue before the CPUC that is stated or provided outside the formal proceeding process. There are many statutory and CPUC rules and restrictions governing ex parte communications within proceedings. One of the primary purposes of placing restrictions on ex parte contacts with decision-makers by parties is to prevent a party from gaining an unfair advantage in a contested matter.
Quiet period. A "quiet period" is a period, in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, during which no oral or written ex parte communications is permitted and the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session during that period. The quiet period expires at the end of the CPUC meeting for which the matter was scheduled to be voted upon. If the CPUC holds the decision to a future voting meeting, it may establish a subsequent quiet period in advance of the voting meeting. Statute also requires that if the CPUC holds a closed session meeting during the quiet period it must provide a three days advance public notice, including notification to all the parties.
Purpose. This bill seeks to address transparency and fairness concerns around the CPUC's ability to modify certain decisions during the quiet period, at which point no party is able to weigh in. Amendments taken in the Senate seek to strike a balance between allowing parties the opportunity to weigh in on decisions, where previously it was forbidden, while ensuring all parties to the proceeding receive adequate notice of the communication.
According to the Author
According to the author, "Good government practice should allow a transparent process for interested stakeholders to "petition the government" at any time. California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) decisions affect every Californian. Given its impactful role, open and transparent communications between the CPUC and the public are constructive and necessary. AB 1068 will provide greater accountability and transparency to the CPUC's decision-making process by ensuring all interested stakeholders are able to participate, which is beneficial to all stakeholders and good for our democracy."
Arguments in Support
The sponsors of this bill, San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) relay examples of the challenges to provide feedback on proposed decisions that are modified, in some cases significantly, during the quiet period. They contend that such incidents can drastically limit the ability of parties to provide helpful information to inform the CPUC's decision-making.
Arguments in Opposition
Sonoma Clean Power writes in late opposition to this measure, noting “grave concerns with reducing transparency and giving well-funded actors like IOUs a new advantage” via the changes to ex parte rules made by this bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS
Pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, this bill did not receive a hearing in the Senate Appropriations Committee due to a determination that any state costs of the bill are not significant.
VOTES:
ASM UTILITIES AND ENERGY: 13-0-2
YES: Garcia, Jim Patterson, Bauer-Kahan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Holden, Muratsuchi, Reyes, Santiago, Schiavo, Wallis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-2
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Robert Rivas, Sanchez, Weber, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bryan, Pellerin
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-0-14
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Boerner, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Berman, Bonta, Juan Carrillo, Cervantes, Gabriel, Hart, Kalra, Lee, McCarty, Ortega, Luz Rivas, Ting, Ward
SENATE FLOOR: 32-3-5
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Grove, Jones, Laird, McGuire, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Menjivar, Min, Stern
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Cortese, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón
UPDATED
VERSION: September 8, 2023
CONSULTANT: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0002336
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1068 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1068
Author: Valencia (D)
Amended: 9/8/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 12-1, 7/3/23
AYES: Bradford, Dahle, Ashby, Becker, Durazo, Eggman, McGuire, Newman, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Wilk
NOES: Gonzalez
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero, Dodd, Grove, Min, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-0, 5/8/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Public Utilities Commission: ex parte communications
SOURCE: San Diego Gas & Electric Company
Southern California Gas Company
DIGEST:
This bill deletes current prohibitions on written ex parte communication in specified proceedings at the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/8/23 are intended to address concerns raised by opponents, including those seeking restrictions to written ex parte communications.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the CPUC with five members appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate and authorizes the CPUC to exercise ratemaking and rulemaking authority over all public utilities, as defined, subject to control by the Legislature. (Article XII of the California Constitution; Public Utilities Code §301 et seq.)
- Requires the CPUC to determine whether each proceeding is a quasi-legislative, an adjudication, a ratesetting proceeding, or a catastrophic wildfire proceeding. (Public Utilities Code §1701.1)
- Authorizes the CPUC during certain periods of a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, to establish a “quiet period” during which no oral or written ex parte communications, as defined, are permitted and during which the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session. (Public Utilities Code §1701.3)
- Authorizes the CPUC to meet in closed session during the quiet period of a ratesetting case and at any point during the pendency of the catastrophic wildfire proceeding, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §1701.8)
- Defines ex parte communications as any oral or written communication between a decisionmaker and an interested person that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop or other public proceeding. (Public Utilities Code §1701.1)
This bill:
- Authorizes, expressly, the CPUC, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings.
- Authorizes, expressly, a written ex parte communication to occur at any time before the three business days before the CPUC’s scheduled vote on a decision, with some restrictions, during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
- Deletes the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would instead authorize an interested person to submit a written ex parte communication during the three business days before the CPUC’s scheduled vote on a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding if the CPUC materially modifies the proposed decision during that time period.
Background
CPUC proceedings. CPUC proceedings are a formal judicial process used to evaluate a variety of requests related to the industries that the CPUC regulates, including investor-owned gas, electric, telephone, and water utilities, as well as, providers of transportation for-hire, broadband, and communications services. A proceeding can be a request, complaint, or application, or it can be a CPUC initiated investigation or rulemaking, etc. The purpose of a proceeding is to establish an evidentiary record on which to base CPUC decisions. Statute directs the CPUC to identify each of its proceedings according to the following categories:
- Adjudication – enforcement cases and complaints, except those challenging the reasonableness of rates or charges.
- Quasi-legislative – those that establish policy, including, but not limited to, rulemakings and investigations that establish rules affecting an entire industry.
- Ratesetting – cases in which rates are established for a specific company.
- Catastrophic Wildfire – proceedings involving recovery of costs related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU), as added and defined by AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019).
Ex parte communications. Ex parte communications are oral or written communication about an issue before the CPUC that is stated or provided outside the formal proceeding process. There are many statutory and CPUC rules and restrictions governing ex parte communications within proceedings. One of the primary purposes of placing restrictions on ex parte contacts with decision-makers by parties is to prevent a party from gaining an unfair advantage in a contested matter.
Quiet period. A “quiet period” is a period, in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, during which no oral or written ex parte communications is permitted and the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session during that period. The quiet period expires at the end of the CPUC meeting for which the matter was scheduled to be voted upon. If the CPUC holds the decision to a future voting meeting, it may establish a subsequent quiet period in advance of the voting meeting. Statute also requires that if the CPUC holds a closed session meeting during the quiet period it must provide a three days advance public notice, including notification to all the parties.
Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act. The purpose of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act is to ensure that public agencies conduct the people’s business openly so that the public may observe and be informed. Under Bagley-Keene, all meetings require notice to the public. Certain statutes authorize the CPUC to hold closed sessions in specific circumstances (as noted above). The CPUC most frequently holds closed sessions in circumstances where there is pending litigation, personnel issues, or for purposes of a ratesetting deliberative meeting, and as authorized in catastrophic wildfire proceedings.
Comments
Need for this bill. The sponsors of this bill, San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) relay examples of the challenges to provide feedback on proposed decisions that are modified, in some cases significantly, during the quiet period. They contend that such incidents can drastically limit the ability of parties to provide helpful information to inform the CPUC’s decision-making. Specifically, they cite two examples where late modifications drastically altered the proposed decision. From their support letter:
- In 2022, the CPUC issued modifications to the PD [proposed decision] Adopting an Opt-In Tariff to Encourage Residential Electrification (CPUC Decision 22-11-022) the week of the voting meeting, and these modifications adopted a rate higher than an existing rate. Written ex parte communications, which were permitted at the time, explained the duplicative nature of the rate, and how the Demand Flexibility proceeding would provide a more holistic approach that would better benefit customers. The CPUC rescheduled the PD to the following meeting and approved the modifications without addressing the concerns that had been raised. The written ex parte communications were important enough to delay, but did not alter the outcome of the decision.
- In 2020, CPUC Decision 20-02-045 addressing SDG&E and SoCalGas’s Triennial Cost Allocation Proceeding (TCAP) application reversed course in the eleventh hour. Among other things, the TCAP PD would have approved a $5 residential fixed charge, but the day before the voting meeting substantive modifications were issued. The Revised PD denied this charge, adopted a $1 increase to the minimum bill, and punted statewide policy on gas rate design to the new Gas Planning proceeding. The TCAP proceeding was a 17-month process. In one day, the CPUC made significant policy changes without an opportunity for ex parte communications from the applicant. The decision was made without any feedback from parties before the voting meeting, and without complete consideration of customer impact.
Concerns about parity and transparency. There were numerous reforms of ex parte communications adopted in response to the post-San Bruno Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) explosion and issues related to the communication between then-CPUC commissioners and PG&E. Additionally, other communications between commissioners and regulated utilities came to light regarding decisions surrounding the retirement of the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station. The Utility Reform Network (TURN) argues that changes to the ex parte rules must not erode the sunshine and parity afforded to all parties within a proceeding. They argue that the last-minute ex parte communication during the quiet period favors well-resourced organizations, especially the regulated utilities. In this regard, the author amended the bill an attempt to restrict the instances when written ex parte communications is allowed, by requiring the proposed decision to be modified prior to authorizing written ex parte communications within the three business days leading to a decision. These changes are intended to address concerns that parties to proceedings will submit comments on all matter of the proceedings and potentially disadvantage other parties who have limited resources to weigh in quickly. However, the CPUC will need to define the thresholds for what constitutes a material difference to a proposed decision and police the timing and scope of the written ex parte communications in order to ensure consistency with the statutes. In so far as the CPUC is not able to provide clear guidance to parties within its rules, there could be some disputes among parties regarding which written ex parte communications should be authorized and which should not be.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 599 (Hueso, Chapter 703, Statutes of 2022) revised and recasts provisions relating to “quiet periods” and the authority for closed session meetings during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings at the CPUC.
SB 605 (Hueso, 2020) contained identical language as in SB 599. The bill was held by the author in the Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee.
SB 1358 (Hueso, Chapter 519, Statutes of 2018) required the assigned commissioner, rather than the full CPUC commission, to determine whether a proceeding requires a hearing.
SB 215 (Leno & Hueso, Chapter 807, Statutes of 2016) proposed a suite of reforms of the rules, operations and procedures of the CPUC pertaining to the laws and rules related to ex-parte communications and criteria and process for disqualification of commissioners to a proceeding.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/12/23)
San Diego Gas & Electric Company (co-source)
Southern California Gas Company (co-source)
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Broadband & Video Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Water Association
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/12/23)
Sonoma Clean Power
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, San Diego Gas & Electric Company and the Southern California Gas Company urge that changes to the ex parte rules are needed to address last-minute modifications to proposed decisions. They state:
The CPUC must establish a quiet period prohibiting oral and written ex parte communications the Monday-Wednesday before a voting meeting, which occurs on a Thursday. The purpose of the quiet period is for the CPUC to not receive any additional communication from interested parties before they vote. However, the CPUC may issue modifications to a PD [proposed decision] the Monday-Wednesday before a vote. In these instances, it is undemocratic to shut the door on any communication specific to the late modifications. AB 1068 recognizes the importance of ex parte communications and allows only written ex parte to be transmitted to CPUC commissioners, as well as all interested parties on the proceeding service list at the same time. This allows for parties to provide information regarding the late PD modifications, and for all parties to receive those same communications in real time. The bill also requires that late modified PDs be held until the next meeting, which will provide additional time for parties to weigh in on the changes made by the CPUC.
ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, Sonoma Clean Power expresses “grave concerns with reducing transparency and giving well-funded actors like the investor-owned utilities a new advantage over public advocates.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-0, 5/8/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Boerner, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Berman, Bonta, Juan Carrillo, Cervantes, Gabriel, Hart, Kalra, Lee, McCarty, Ortega, Luz Rivas, Ting, Ward
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U. & C. / (916) 651-4107
9/12/23 13:33:48
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 1068 Hearing Date: 7/3/2023
Author: | Valencia | ||
Version: | 6/21/2023 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Public Utilities Commission: ex parte communications and proposed decisions
DIGEST: This bill makes changes to rules governing proceedings at the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) related to written ex parte communications and requiring the CPUC to delay a vote on a proposed decision that is modified to the following voting meeting.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the CPUC with five members appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate and authorizes the CPUC to exercise ratemaking and rulemaking authority over all public utilities, as defined, subject to control by the Legislature. (Article XII of the California Constitution; Public Utilities Code §301 et seq.)
- Requires the CPUC to determine whether each proceeding is a quasi-legislative, an adjudication, a ratesetting proceeding, or a catastrophic wildfire proceeding. (Public Utilities Code §1701.1)
- Authorizes the CPUC during certain periods of a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, to establish a “quiet period” during which no oral or written ex parte communications, as defined, are permitted and during which the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session. (Public Utilities Code §1701.3)
- Authorizes the CPUC to meet in closed session during the quiet period of a ratesetting case and at any point during the pendency of the catastrophic wildfire proceeding, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §1701.8)
- Defines ex parte communications as any oral or written communication between a decisionmaker and an interested person that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop or other public proceeding. (Public Utilities Code §1701.1)
This bill:
- Expressly authorizes the CPUC, by order or rule, to prohibit oral ex parte communications, rather than all ex parte communications, in ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, and would expressly authorize a written ex parte communication to occur at any time without restriction during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
- Deletes the prohibition on written ex parte communications during the quiet periods of ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings.
- Requires the CPUC, if it modifies a proposed decision in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding during the three business days before its scheduled vote on the proposed decision, to hold the proposed decision until the next scheduled voting meeting.
Background
CPUC proceedings. CPUC proceedings are a formal judicial process used to evaluate a variety of requests related to the industries that the CPUC regulates, including investor-owned gas, electric, telephone, and water utilities, as well as, providers of transportation for-hire, broadband, and communications services. A proceeding can be a request, complaint, or application, or it can be a CPUC initiated investigation or rulemaking, etc. The purpose of a proceeding is to establish an evidentiary record on which to base CPUC decisions. Statute directs the CPUC to identify each of its proceedings according to the following categories:
- Adjudication – enforcement cases and complaints, except those challenging the reasonableness of rates or charges.
- Quasi-legislative – those that establish policy, including, but not limited to, rulemakings and investigations that establish rules affecting an entire industry.
- Ratesetting – cases in which rates are established for a specific company.
- Catastrophic Wildfire – proceedings involving recovery of costs related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU), as added and defined by AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019).
Ex parte communications. Ex parte communications are oral or written communication about an issue before the CPUC that is stated or provided outside the formal proceeding process. There are many statutory and CPUC rules and restrictions governing ex parte communications within proceedings. One of the primary purposes of placing restrictions on ex parte contacts with decision-makers by parties is to prevent a party from gaining an unfair advantage in a contested matter.
Quiet period. A “quiet period” is a period, in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, during which no oral or written ex parte communications is permitted and the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session during that period. The quiet period expires at the end of the CPUC meeting for which the matter was scheduled to be voted upon. If the CPUC holds the decision to a future voting meeting, it may establish a subsequent quiet period in advance of the voting meeting. Statute also requires that if the CPUC holds a closed session meeting during the quiet period it must provide a three days advance public notice, including notification to all the parties.
Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act. The purpose of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act is to ensure that public agencies conduct the people’s business openly so that the public may observe and be informed. Under Bagley-Keene, all meetings require notice to the public. Certain statutes authorize the CPUC to hold closed sessions in specific circumstances (as noted above). The CPUC most frequently holds closed sessions in circumstances where there is pending litigation, personnel issues, or for purposes of a ratesetting deliberative meeting, and as authorized in catastrophic wildfire proceedings.
Comments
Need for this bill. The sponsors of this bill, San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) relay examples of the challenges to provide feedback on proposed decisions that are modified, in some cases significantly, during the quiet period. They contend that such incidents can drastically limit the ability of parties to provide helpful information to inform the CPUC’s decision-making. Specifically, they cite two examples where late modifications drastically altered the proposed decision. From their support letter:
- In 2022, the CPUC issued modifications to the PD [proposed decision] Adopting an Opt-In Tariff to Encourage Residential Electrification (CPUC Decision 22-11-022) the week of the voting meeting, and these modifications adopted a rate higher than an existing rate. Written ex parte communications, which were permitted at the time, explained the duplicative nature of the rate, and how the Demand Flexibility proceeding would provide a more holistic approach that would better benefit customers. The CPUC rescheduled the PD to the following meeting and approved the modifications without addressing the concerns that had been raised. The written ex parte communications were important enough to delay, but did not alter the outcome of the decision.
- In 2020, CPUC Decision 20-02-045 addressing SDG&E and SoCalGas’s Triennial Cost Allocation Proceeding (TCAP) application reversed course in the eleventh hour. Among other things, the TCAP PD would have approved a $5 residential fixed charge, but the day before the voting meeting substantive modifications were issued. The Revised PD denied this charge, adopted a $1 increase to the minimum bill, and punted statewide policy on gas rate design to the new Gas Planning proceeding. The TCAP proceeding was a 17-month process. In one day, the CPUC made significant policy changes without an opportunity for ex parte communications from the applicant. The decision was made without any feedback from parties before the voting meeting, and without complete consideration of customer impact.
Concerns about parity and transparency. In opposition to this bill, The Utility Reform Network (TURN) argues that the proposed changes to the ex parte rules would erode the sunshine and parity afforded to all parties within a proceeding. They argue that the last-minute ex parte communication during the quiet period favors well-resourced organizations, especially the regulated utilities.
Tradeoffs of each proposal. As currently drafted this bill authorizes written ex parte during the quiet periods for ratesetting and catastrophic wildfire proceedings and requires the CPUC to delay decisions to the following voting meeting when a proposed decision is modified during the quiet period. Both of the proposed changes to CPUC proceedings in this bill come with tradeoffs. In the case of authorizing written ex parte communication during the quiet period, both TURN and the CPUC have proposed changes to prohibit this communication in order to ensure transparency and parity for parties. There were numerous reforms of ex parte communications adopted in response to the post-San Bruno Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) explosion and issues related to the communication between then-CPUC commissioners and PG&E. Additionally, other communications between commissioners and regulated utilities came to light regarding decisions surrounding the retirement of the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station. However, requiring the CPUC to postpone a proposed decision to the next voting meeting when a proposed decision is modified (a common occurrence) may lead to further delays in CPUC decision-making. Many parties, including the Legislature, have raised concerns with the slow-pace of decision-making at the CPUC. As such that proposal could lead to additional delays.
Need for amendments. Given the two proposals, authorizing written ex parte during quiet periods and postponing modified decisions are not both needed, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to remove the language requiring modified decisions to be delayed to the following voting meeting.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 599 (Hueso, Chapter 703, Statutes of 2022) revised and recasts provisions relating to “quiet periods” and the authority for closed session meetings during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings at the CPUC.
SB 605 (Hueso, 2020) contained identical language as in SB 599. The bill was held by the author in the Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee.
SB 1358 (Hueso, Chapter 519, Statutes of 2018) required the assigned commissioner, rather than the full CPUC commission, to determine whether a proceeding requires a hearing.
SB 215 (Leno & Hueso, Chapter 807, Statutes of 2016) proposed a suite of reforms of the rules, operations and procedures of the CPUC pertaining to the laws and rules related to ex-parte communications and criteria and process for disqualification of commissioners to a proceeding.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT:
San Diego Gas & Electric Company, Co-sponsor
Southern California Gas Company, Co-sponsor
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Broadband & Video Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Water Association
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
OPPOSITION:
The Utility Reform Network
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, SDG&E and SoCalGas urge that changes to the ex parte rules are needed to address last-minute modifications to proposed decisions. They state:
The CPUC must establish a quiet period prohibiting oral and written ex parte communications the Monday-Wednesday before a voting meeting, which occurs on a Thursday. The purpose of the quiet period is for the CPUC to not receive any additional communication from interested parties before they vote. However, the CPUC may issue modifications to a PD [proposed decision] the Monday-Wednesday before a vote. In these instances, it is undemocratic to shut the door on any communication specific to the late modifications. AB 1068 recognizes the importance of ex parte communications and allows only written ex parte to be transmitted to CPUC commissioners, as well as all interested parties on the proceeding service list at the same time. This allows for parties to provide information regarding the late PD modifications, and for all parties to receive those same communications in real time. The bill also requires that late modified PDs be held until the next meeting, which will provide additional time for parties to weigh in on the changes made by the CPUC.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Utility Reform Network (TURN) opposes this bill contending this bill would erode ex parte rules that provide transparency and equal opportunity for parties. TURN states:
The current reporting requirements for oral communications ensure that anything that could influence the final decision is on the record. And the current “quiet period” sets a deadline that prevents last-minute oral and written communications. Without these limits and reporting requirements, heavily resourced parties, typically the Investor-Owned Utilities, would be able to rely on back-channel communications with the Commissioners’ personal advisors to influence Commission decisions up until the last moment before a Commission vote.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1068
Author:(Valencia)
As Amended Ver:March 27, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
This bill removes restrictions on written ex parte (conversations outside of the formal California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) process) during the three-day quiet period of a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, so long as copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication occurs. The current language in this bill creates a conflict with existing law, where the CPUC would be required to both allow written ex parte communication (per this bill) and authorized to disallow ex parte communications (per existing statute unchanged by this bill).
Existing Law
Authorizes the CPUC to prohibit ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding by order or ruling. (Public Utilities Code Section 1701.3(h)(1))
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
CPUC proceedings. CPUC proceedings are formal judicial processes used to evaluate requests related to the industries that the CPUC regulates and establish an evidentiary record on which to base CPUC decisions. The two types of CPUC proceeding addressed in this bill are ratesetting cases, in which utility rates are established for a specific company, and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, which involve cost-recovery related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU), as added and defined by AB 1054 (Holden), Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019.
Ex parte communications. Ex parte communications are oral or written communication about an issue before the CPUC that is stated or provided outside the formal proceeding process. Restrictions on ex parte conversations are intended to prevent a party from gaining an unfair advantage in a contested matter and maintain confidence that the record of the proceeding reflects the full scope of the decision making process. These restrictions were enacted in response to CPUC proceedings in which ex parte communications improperly played a role, including proceedings related to the natural gas pipeline explosion in San Bruno, California, in 2010, and proceedings to evaluate options for cost distribution related to the shutdown of San Onofre Nuclear Generating Stations (SONGS). Violations of ex parte rules are subject to fines and other penalties. In ratesetting and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, CPUC rules and restrictions restrict ex parte communications in the following ways:
- Ex parte communications are forbidden during a "quiet period" for three business days prior the CPUC's scheduled vote on a decision.
- Following an ex parte communication, parties and decisionmakers are both required to file a notice within three days specifying the date, time, location, type of communication, decisionmaker and party involved, topic and a substantive description of the communication, and provide a copy of any written material shared.
Writing during a Quiet Period. This bill relaxes the restrictions on ex parte communications during the quiet periods in ratesetting and catastrophic wildfire cases, during which all ex parte communication is currently forbidden, to permit written ex parte communication without restriction during the quiet period, as long as copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. This change may solve the issue of pertinent developments or reversals of direction by the CPUC during the quiet period which, under current rules, render interested parties unable to weigh in before the final decision is issued. However, any loosening of ex parte communication rules risks providing opportunities for heavily resourced parties, like the IOUs, to influence CPUC decisionmaking in ways not necessarily accessible to other stakeholders, and would signal a roll-back of reforms that arose after egregious violations impacted public safety and cost ratepayers billions of dollars.
This bill requires the CPUC to allow written ex parte communication during the three-day quiet period of a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, but does not address another part of statute which authorizes the CPUC to disallow ex parte communications in such proceedings. This creates a conflict which must be resolved.
According to the Author
According to the author, "Good government practice should allow a transparent process for interested stakeholders to "petition the government" at any time. California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) decisions affect every Californian. Given its impactful role, open and transparent communications between the CPUC and the public are constructive and necessary. AB 1068 will provide greater accountability and transparency to the CPUC's decision-making process by ensuring all interested stakeholders are able to participate, which is beneficial to all stakeholders and good for our democracy."
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by San Diego Gas and Electric and the Southern California Gas Company, among others, who contend "Allowing interested parties to transmit ex parte communication in writing at any time is critical as this may be the only opportunity for parties to provide input to the CPUC on last-minute changes."
Arguments in Opposition
This bill is opposed by The Utility Reform Network (TURN), which asserts it "has witnessed many times where controversial issues have been influenced by private communications with ratepayers facing higher rates as a result" and that "AB 1068 would serve to eliminate key provisions that bring sunlight to Commission decision-making and level the playing field between differently resourced intervenors."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES
ASM UTILITIES AND ENERGY: 13-0-2
YES: Garcia, Jim Patterson, Bauer-Kahan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Holden, Muratsuchi, Reyes, Santiago, Schiavo, Wallis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-2
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Robert Rivas, Sanchez, Weber, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bryan, Pellerin
UPDATED
VERSION: March 27, 2023
CONSULTANT: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0000237
Date of Hearing: April 19, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1068
Author:(Valencia) – As Amended Ver:March 27, 2023
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows, without restriction, written ex parte communications by an interested person to a ratesetting case or a catastrophic wildfire proceeding before the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author intends this bill to allow more—and transparent—communication between the CPUC decisionmakers and interested parties to CPUC proceedings. According to the author:
Good government practice should allow a transparent process for interested stakeholders to “petition the government” at any time. California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) decisions affect every Californian. Given its impactful role, open and transparent communications between the CPUC and the public are constructive and necessary. AB 1068 will provide greater accountability and transparency to the CPUC’s decision-making process by ensuring all interested stakeholders are able to participate, which is beneficial to all stakeholders and good for our democracy.
- Background. A proceeding is the formal process by which the CPUC considers information and makes decisions. Statute directs the CPUC to classify each of its proceedings as one of the following types:
- Quasi-legislative—a case that establishes policy, including, but not limited to, rulemaking and investigation that establishes rules affecting an entire industry.
- Adjudication—an enforcement case or a complaint, except one challenging the reasonableness of rates or charges.
- Ratesetting—a case in which the CPUC establishes rates for a specific company.
- Catastrophic Wildfire—a case involving recovery of costs related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU).
Statute provides rules governing communications with and among CPUC decisionmakers, and those rules differ by proceeding type. These rules are to ensure every interested party knows of the information upon which a CPUC decisionmaker bases their decisions. The rules are the result of statutory modifications following communication between CPUC staff and commissioners, on the one hand, and regulated entities, on the other, that many found to be inappropriate. This bill concerns only communication regarding a ratesetting proceeding or a catastrophic wildfire proceeding.
Statute defines “ex parte communication” as:
Any oral or written communication between a decisionmaker and an interested person concerning any matter before the commission that the commission has not specified in its Rules of Practice and Procedure as being a procedural matter and that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop, or other public proceeding, or on the official record of the proceeding on the matter.
For ratesetting proceedings and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, statute gives the CPUC discretion over whether to allow, or disallow, ex parte communications, subject to statutory disclosure requirements. Similarly, statute authorizes the CPUC to allow written ex parte communications related to a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication.
This bill, instead, in the context of ratesetting proceedings and catastrophic wildfire proceedings, requires the CPUC to allow written ex parte communications by an interested person at any time, without restriction, if copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. At the same time, the bill leaves unchanged the provision of existing law, described above, that provides the CPUC the authority to disallow ex parte communications in a ratesetting case or catastrophic wildfire proceeding. Thus, if this bill were to become law, statute would both allow the CPUC to limit ex parte communication and bar the CPUC from limiting ex parte communication. It is unclear how the CPUC, in implementing this bill, would reconcile this discrepancy.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by San Diego Gas and Electric and the Southern California Gas Company, among others, who contend “Allowing interested parties to transmit ex parte communication in writing at any time is critical as this may be the only opportunity for parties to provide input to the CPUC on last-minute changes.”
In contrast, the bill is opposed by The Utility Reform Network (TURN), which asserts it “has witnessed many times where controversial issues have been influenced by private communications with ratepayers facing higher rates as a result” and that “AB 1068 would serve to eliminate key provisions that bring sunlight to Commission decision-making and level the playing field between differently resourced intervenors.”
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 22, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1068 (
Author:Valencia) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2023
SUBJECT: Public Utilities Commission: ex parte communications
SUMMARY: Exempts certain meetings from ex parte rules at the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), specifically by removing the three day notice requirement for meetings with commissioners’ staff, removing the oral ex parte prohibition during quiet periods for meetings with commissioners’ staff, and removing the written ex parte prohibition during quiet periods.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the CPUC to determine whether each proceeding is a quasi-legislative, an adjudication, a ratesetting or a catastrophic wildfire proceeding. (Public Utilities Code § 1701.1)
- Defines ex parte communications as any oral or written communication between a decisionmaker and an interested person that does not occur in a public hearing, workshop or other public proceeding. Specifies that decisionmakers, for purposes of ex parte communications, shall include the personal staff of a commissioner if the staff is acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity. (Public Utilities Code § 1701.1)
- Requires the CPUC to establish a “quiet period” in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding during the three business days before the CPUC’s schedule vote on a decision, during which no oral or written ex parte communications are permitted and during which the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session. (Public Utilities Code § 1701.9)
- Prohibits individual ex parte meetings during the three business days before the CPUC’s scheduled vote on a decision in a ratesetting proceeding. (Public Utilities Code § 1701.3)
- Authorizes the CPUC to meet in closed session during the quiet period of a ratesetting case and at any point during the pendency of the catastrophic wildfire proceeding, as specified. (Public Utilities Code § 1701.8)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal and will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations for its review.
BACKGROUND:
CPUC proceedings – CPUC proceedings are formal judicial processes used to evaluate a variety of requests related to the industries that the CPUC regulates. A proceeding can be a request, complaint, or application, or it can be a CPUC initiated investigation or rulemaking. The purpose of a proceeding is to establish an evidentiary record on which to base CPUC decisions. Statute directs the CPUC to identify each of its proceedings according to the following categories:
- Adjudication – enforcement cases and complaints, except those challenging the reasonableness of rates or charges.
- Quasi-legislative – those that establish policy, including, but not limited to, rulemakings and investigations that establish rules affecting an entire industry.
- Ratesetting – cases in which rates are established for a specific company.
- Catastrophic Wildfire – those involving recovery of costs related to damages associated with a wildfire caused by electric investor-owned utility (IOU), as added and defined by AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019).
Ex parte communications – Ex parte communications are oral or written communication about an issue before the CPUC that is stated or provided outside the formal proceeding process. Ex parte communications include communications that are one-way from a decisionmaker to an interested person. One of the primary purposes of placing restrictions on ex parte conversations is to prevent a party from gaining an unfair advantage in a contested matter. Violations of ex parte rules are subject to fines and other penalties. There are many statutory and CPUC rules and restrictions governing ex parte communications within proceedings, and are specific to the different proceeding types:
- Adjudication – ex parte communications are prohibited.[1]
- Quasi-legislative – ex parte communications are permitted and not subject to disclosure requirements, except if the CPUC determines otherwise.[2]
- Ratesetting and Catastrophic Wildfire – ex parte communications are permitted, subject to certain disclosures and limitations. Ex parte communications are forbidden from being part of the evidentiary record of the proceeding. Ex parte communications are also forbidden during the three business days before the CPUC’s scheduled vote on a decision, known as a “quiet period.” Parties are required to file advanced notice of a planned ex parte meeting—if allowed in the proceeding—three working days’ prior to the meeting.[3] Following an ex parte communication, parties and decisionmakers are both required to file a notice within three days specifying the date, time, location, type of communication, decisionmaker and party involved, topic and a substantive description of the communication, and provide a copy of any written material shared.[4] The CPUC is prohibited from taking a vote on a matter if a prohibited ex parte communication occurs until all parties have been provided a reasonable opportunity to respond to the communication.[5]
Quiet period – A “quiet period” is a period, in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding, during which no oral or written ex parte communications is permitted and the CPUC is authorized to meet in closed session. Recent statutory changes mandate that the CPUC establish a quiet period three business days before the CPUC’s scheduled vote on a decision in a ratesetting or catastrophic wildfire proceeding.[6] The quiet period expires at the end of the CPUC meeting for which the matter was scheduled to be voted upon. If the CPUC holds the decision to a future voting meeting, it shall establish a subsequent quiet period in advance of the next voting meeting. Statute requires that if the CPUC holds a closed session meeting during the quiet period it must provide a public notice three days in advance.[7]
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “Good government practice should allow a transparent process for interested stakeholders to “petition the government” at any time. California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) decisions affect every Californian. Given its impactful role, open and transparent communications between the CPUC and the public are constructive and necessary. AB 1068 will provide greater accountability and transparency to the CPUC’s decision-making process by ensuring all interested stakeholders are able to participate, which is beneficial to all stakeholders and good for our democracy.”
- How did we get here? Rules governing CPUC practice have been around since its creation; however, over the last decade, a period of enormous reform to the CPUC’s rules arose in response to the tragic natural gas pipeline explosion in San Bruno, California, and the public revelations of CPUC violations during subsequent investigations. During the summer and fall of 2014, Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), bowing to legal pressure from the City of San Bruno, began to release a growing number of emails between the utility and CPUC officials. PG&E released 65,000 emails from over a five-year period that PG&E says it believes “violated CPUC rules governing ex parte communications.” The initial release of emails revealed efforts by PG&E executives to influence the CPUC’s assignment of the administrative law judge to the San Bruno proceeding. Many of the other emails exposed regular, private, familiar communications between PG&E and certain CPUC commissioners, including former CPUC President Michael Peevey, as well as senior CPUC officials. Following PG&E’s initial release of the emails, both the state Attorney General and the United States Department of Justice opened investigations into communications between the CPUC and regulated entities. Investigators working with the Attorney General’s Office even raided the CPUC offices and the homes of former CPUC Commissioner President Peevey and PG&E former-Vice President Brian Cherry.
In early February 2015, after a newspaper published details of the search warrant, Southern California Edison disclosed a meeting that occurred two years prior in Warsaw, Poland between then-CPUC President Peevey and a utility executive in which they discussed how to resolve the shutdown plans for the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Stations (SONGS). The facility had a failed steam generator that required SONGS to be permanently retired. In November 2014, the CPUC approved a settlement agreement between utilities and ratepayer advocates that split the costs of retiring the facility and the associated replacement power, with ratepayers shouldering $3.3 billion of the $4.7 billion total costs. In light of the information about the meeting in Poland, some of the parties to the settlement agreement rescinded their support. In early December 2015, the CPUC voted 4-0 to fine Southern California Edison $16.7 million for violations of ex parte communications rules regarding the SONGS closure proceeding.
Following these revelations, numerous legislative reforms were introduced to “clean-up” the rules governing the CPUC, especially its ex parte rules. The most relevant to this bill was the passage of SB 215 (Leno & Hueso, Chapter 519, Statutes of 2018) which includes requirements that the CPUC adopt procedures on the disqualifications of commissioners due to bias or prejudice; redefines a “decisionmaker” for purposes of ex parte communication to include the personal staff of a commissioner acting in a policy or legal advisory capacity; provides for penalties for violations of ex parte communication rules; and prohibits ex parte communication from being part of the proceeding’s record, among other changes.
- Talking during a Quiet Period. This bill makes two changes related to CPUC quiet periods in ratesetting cases, during which ex parte communication is currently forbidden. First, it relaxes the quiet period ban on oral ex parte communication for ratesetting agenda items, by allowing in-person meetings with commissioner advisors. Second, it permits written ex parte communication at any time without restriction during the proceeding, including the quiet period, as long as copies of the communication are transmitted to all parties on the same day as the original communication. This is a large shift away from previous reform efforts meant to tighten the rules around communication, in order to keep CPUC decisions as true to the public record as possible and to provide all interested parties the ability to contribute to the discussion. From a transparency perspective, this bill creates the opportunity for parties to meet with an advisor—who often plays an influential role in CPUC decisions—to get the last word, without other parties knowledge or ability to weigh in. Moreover, this bill exempts ex parte communication with advisors from the three-day advanced notice requirement, meaning any public notice of an ex parte communication occurring during a quiet period would likely only be provided after the vote is taken.
Opponents to the bill take issue with these changes, noting that without these protections and limits on side communications, heavily resourced parties, like the IOUs, would “be able to rely on back-channel communications with the Commissioners’ personal advisors to influence Commission decisions up until the last moment before a Commission vote.” Such a change seems outside the spirit of transparency and good governance, and would signal a roll-back of the large reforms that arose after egregious violations impacted public safety and cost ratepayers billions of dollars.
Proponents of this bill note circumstances where modifications to CPUC decisions arise during quiet periods, and parties to the proceeding are given no opportunity to respond. For instance, they cite a 2020 decision[8] where the proposed decision approved a $5 residential fixed charge for both San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and SoCalGas. The proponents claim the day before the voting meeting, a revised decision was issued denying the charge for SDG&E, and instead adopting a $1 increase to the minimum bill.[9] The proponents note the proceeding was “a 17-month process, the direction of which [was] reversed in the eleventh hour without stakeholder input.” Like this example, it is accurate to note the CPUC does have the ability to revise ratesetting proceeding decisions during the quiet period, at which point no party is able to weigh in.
Given this balance to ensure due process and transparency, it may be appropriate to permit some form of communication during a quiet period, especially under circumstances where a revised decision is issued. The proposed changes in this bill to permit written ex parte communication creates the opportunity for a flurry of letter writing leading up to a vote; however the CPUC currently has minimal control over written ex parte filings. Current statute states that if ex parte violations occur, the CPUC is prohibited from taking a vote on a matter until all parties have been provided a reasonable opportunity to respond to the communication.[10] As such, written ex parte communication could be used as a tactic by parties to delay decisions the CPUC sees as being ready to be voted on. Such opportunities to abuse ex parte rules seem problematic. Given the desire to ensure due process and transparency, the author and committee may wish to consider amending this bill to remove any exemptions for oral ex parte communications, including striking the three-day notice exemption for communications with advisors, while retaining the exemption for written ex parte communications.
- Prior Legislation.
SB 599 (Hueso) revises and recasts provisions relating to “quiet periods” and the authority for closed session meetings during ratesetting cases and catastrophic wildfire proceedings at the CPUC. Status: Chapter 703, Statutes of 2022.
SB 605 (Hueso, 2020) contained, among other provisions, similar provisions as this bill related to quiet periods and closed sessions for CPUC ratesetting and catastrophic wildfire proceedings. Status – Died, Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee.
SB 1358 (Hueso) required the assigned commissioner, rather than the full CPUC commission, to determine whether a proceeding requires a hearing. Status – Chapter 519, Statutes of 2018.
SB 215 (Leno & Hueso) proposed a suite of reforms of the rules, operations and procedures of the CPUC pertaining to the laws and rules related to ex parte communications and criteria and process for disqualification of commissioners to a proceeding. Status – Chapter 807, Statutes of 2016.
SB 660 (Leno & Hueso, 2015) would have proposed a suite of reforms of the governance, rules, operations and procedures of the CPUC, including reforming laws and rules related to ex parte communications, criteria and process for disqualification of commissions to a proceeding, and authorizing the CPUC to appoint the chief administrative law judge. Status – Vetoed.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CalChamber
Sempra Energy and its Affiliates: San Diego Gas & Electric Company and Southern California Gas Company – sponsor
Oppose
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
PUC § 1701.1 (e)(3) and PUC § 1701.2 (g) ↑
PUC § 1701.4 (c) ↑
PUC § 1701.3 (h) ↑
PUC § 1701.1 (e)(3)(A) ↑
PUC § 1701.1 (e)(5) ↑
PUC § 1701.9 (b), as changed under SB 599 (Hueso, Chapter 703, Statutes of 2022) ↑
PUC § 1701.9 (a) ↑
D. 20-02-045, Decision Addressing San Diego Gas & Electric Company and Southern California Gas company Triennial Cost Allocation Proceeding Appication,A. 18-07-024, February 27, 2020; https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Published/G000/M328/K289/328289863.PDF ↑
Order #15, pg. 105, D 20-02-045, Ibid. ↑
PUC § 1701.1 (e)(5) ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):