AB 1159: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: natural and working lands: market-based compliance mechanisms.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-07
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-07: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 358, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases and authorizes the state board to include the use of market-based compliance mechanisms in the regulation of emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act declares the policy of the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
The act also requires the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with specified entities, including the state board, to determine on or before January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. The act requires these targets to be integrated into the above-described scoping plan and other state policies. The act prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
This bill would instead require the state board to additionally ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases and authorizes the state board to include the use of market-based compliance mechanisms in the regulation of emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act declares the policy of the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
The act also requires the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with specified entities, including the state board, to determine on or before January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. The act requires these targets to be integrated into the above-described scoping plan and other state policies. The act prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
This bill would instead require the state board to additionally ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases and authorizes the state board to include the use of market-based compliance mechanisms in the regulation of emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act declares the policy of the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
The act also requires the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with specified entities, including the state board, to determine on or before January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. The act requires these targets to be integrated into the above-described scoping plan and other state policies. The act prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
This bill would instead prohibit natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding from generating credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any require the state board to additionally ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding. reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases and authorizes the state board to include the use of market-based compliance mechanisms in the regulation of emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act declares the policy of the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
The act also requires the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with specified entities, including the state board, to determine on or before January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. The act requires these targets to be integrated into the above-described scoping plan and other state policies. The act prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
This bill would instead prohibit projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism. natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding from generating credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases and authorizes the state board to include the use of market-based compliance mechanisms in the regulation of emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act declares the policy of the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
The act also requires the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with specified entities, including the state board, to determine on or before January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. The act requires these targets to be integrated into the above-described scoping plan and other state policies. The act prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
This bill would instead prohibit projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Natural carbon sequestration means actions that are undertaken on natural and working lands to remove and provide storage of atmospheric greenhouse gases in vegetation and soils. This shall include preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, which may include compost application, cover crops, hedgerows, planned grazing, urban forestry, riparian restoration, restoration of tidal flows to wetlands, and other forms of wetland restoration, among other relevant actions.
(2)Natural lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(3)Nature-based climate solutions means activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions in natural and working lands.
(4)Vulnerable communities has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (d) of Section 71340 of the Public Resources Code.
(5) Working lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Food and Agriculture, the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c), and other relevant state agencies, shall determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. These targets shall be integrated into the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 and other state policies.
(2)Projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall support the states efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
(3)The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions, and that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
(4)On or before January 1, 2025, the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, and the Department of Food and Agriculture, shall review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy established pursuant to Section 39740.2 to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1).
(5)The review and update pursuant to paragraph (4) shall include all of the following:
(A)Descriptions of the actions and projects undertaken on natural and working lands to date.
(B)Quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(C)A description of how the relevant agencies calculated emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(D)A summary of the benefits to low-income communities, disadvantaged communities, vulnerable communities, disadvantaged farmers, and Native American tribes.
(E)An evaluation of the efficacy of the priority nature-based solutions, pathways, and priority actions for greenhouse gas reductions, climate resilience, and climate change adaptation.
(F)Identification and description of any barriers to achieving the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(G)Recommendations to address the barriers identified in subparagraph (F) to achieve the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(H)Recommendations from the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)The Natural Resources Agency and the state board shall jointly establish an expert advisory committee that is composed of university researchers, technical assistance providers, practitioners and other experts in the field of climate change and natural and working lands science and management, and Indigenous and environmental justice representatives, to inform and review modeling and analyses for natural and working lands, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations on addressing barriers to efficient implementation of this section.
(d)No later than January 1, 2025, the state board shall develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track greenhouse gas emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with the Natural Resources Agency and the Department of Food and Agriculture, additional benefits from natural and working lands over time. In estimating and tracking greenhouse gas emissions and reductions and carbon sequestration from natural and working lands, the state board shall take into account, where feasible, both of the following:
(1)Greenhouse gas emissions and reductions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide related to natural and working lands.
(2)Potential impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to, increased fire risk, warming temperatures, and decreasing precipitation, on the ability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and sequester carbon from natural and working lands.
(e)On or before January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the Natural Resources Agency shall publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Natural carbon sequestration means actions that are undertaken on natural and working lands to remove and provide storage of atmospheric greenhouse gases in vegetation and soils. This shall include preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, which may include compost application, cover crops, hedgerows, planned grazing, urban forestry, riparian restoration, restoration of tidal flows to wetlands, and other forms of wetland restoration, among other relevant actions.
(2)Natural lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(3)Nature-based climate solutions means activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions in natural and working lands.
(4)Vulnerable communities has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (d) of Section 71340 of the Public Resources Code.
(5) Working lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Food and Agriculture, the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c), and other relevant state agencies, shall determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. These targets shall be integrated into the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 and other state policies.
(2)Projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall support the states efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
(3)The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions, and that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
(4)On or before January 1, 2025, the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, and the Department of Food and Agriculture, shall review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy established pursuant to Section 39740.2 to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1).
(5)The review and update pursuant to paragraph (4) shall include all of the following:
(A)Descriptions of the actions and projects undertaken on natural and working lands to date.
(B)Quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(C)A description of how the relevant agencies calculated emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(D)A summary of the benefits to low-income communities, disadvantaged communities, vulnerable communities, disadvantaged farmers, and Native American tribes.
(E)An evaluation of the efficacy of the priority nature-based solutions, pathways, and priority actions for greenhouse gas reductions, climate resilience, and climate change adaptation.
(F)Identification and description of any barriers to achieving the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(G)Recommendations to address the barriers identified in subparagraph (F) to achieve the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(H)Recommendations from the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)The Natural Resources Agency and the state board shall jointly establish an expert advisory committee that is composed of university researchers, technical assistance providers, practitioners and other experts in the field of climate change and natural and working lands science and management, and Indigenous and environmental justice representatives, to inform and review modeling and analyses for natural and working lands, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations on addressing barriers to efficient implementation of this section.
(d)No later than January 1, 2025, the state board shall develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track greenhouse gas emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with the Natural Resources Agency and the Department of Food and Agriculture, additional benefits from natural and working lands over time. In estimating and tracking greenhouse gas emissions and reductions and carbon sequestration from natural and working lands, the state board shall take into account, where feasible, both of the following:
(1)Greenhouse gas emissions and reductions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide related to natural and working lands.
(2)Potential impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to, increased fire risk, warming temperatures, and decreasing precipitation, on the ability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and sequester carbon from natural and working lands.
(e)On or before January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the Natural Resources Agency shall publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Natural carbon sequestration means actions that are undertaken on natural and working lands to remove and provide storage of atmospheric greenhouse gases in vegetation and soils. This shall include preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, which may include compost application, cover crops, hedgerows, planned grazing, urban forestry, riparian restoration, restoration of tidal flows to wetlands, and other forms of wetland restoration, among other relevant actions.
(2)Natural lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(3)Nature-based climate solutions means activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions in natural and working lands.
(4)Vulnerable communities has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (d) of Section 71340 of the Public Resources Code.
(5) Working lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Food and Agriculture, the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c), and other relevant state agencies, shall determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. These targets shall be integrated into the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 and other state policies.
(2)Projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall support the states efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
(3)(A)The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions. reductions, and that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
(B)To ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.(4)On or before January 1, 2025, the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, and the Department of Food and Agriculture, shall review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy established pursuant to Section 39740.2 to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1).
(5)The review and update pursuant to paragraph (4) shall include all of the following:
(A)Descriptions of the actions and projects undertaken on natural and working lands to date.
(B)Quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(C)A description of how the relevant agencies calculated emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(D)A summary of the benefits to low-income communities, disadvantaged communities, vulnerable communities, disadvantaged farmers, and Native American tribes.
(E)An evaluation of the efficacy of the priority nature-based solutions, pathways, and priority actions for greenhouse gas reductions, climate resilience, and climate change adaptation.
(F)Identification and description of any barriers to achieving the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(G)Recommendations to address the barriers identified in subparagraph (F) to achieve the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(H)Recommendations from the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)The Natural Resources Agency and the state board shall jointly establish an expert advisory committee that is composed of university researchers, technical assistance providers, practitioners and other experts in the field of climate change and natural and working lands science and management, and Indigenous and environmental justice representatives, to inform and review modeling and analyses for natural and working lands, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations on addressing barriers to efficient implementation of this section.
(d)No later than January 1, 2025, the state board shall develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track greenhouse gas emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with the Natural Resources Agency and the Department of Food and Agriculture, additional benefits from natural and working lands over time. In estimating and tracking greenhouse gas emissions and reductions and carbon sequestration from natural and working lands, the state board shall take into account, where feasible, both of the following:
(1)Greenhouse gas emissions and reductions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide related to natural and working lands.
(2)Potential impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to, increased fire risk, warming temperatures, and decreasing precipitation, on the ability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and sequester carbon from natural and working lands.
(e)On or before January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the Natural Resources Agency shall publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Natural carbon sequestration means actions that are undertaken on natural and working lands to remove and provide storage of atmospheric greenhouse gases in vegetation and soils. This shall include preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, which may include compost application, cover crops, hedgerows, planned grazing, urban forestry, riparian restoration, restoration of tidal flows to wetlands, and other forms of wetland restoration, among other relevant actions.
(2)Natural lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(3)Nature-based climate solutions means activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions in natural and working lands.
(4)Vulnerable communities has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (d) of Section 71340 of the Public Resources Code.
(5) Working lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Food and Agriculture, the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c), and other relevant state agencies, shall determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. These targets shall be integrated into the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 and other state policies.
(2)Projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall support the states efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
(3)(A)The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions.
(B)Notwithstanding any other law, To ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism. mechanism for any greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
(4)On or before January 1, 2025, the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, and the Department of Food and Agriculture, shall review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy established pursuant to Section 39740.2 to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1).
(5)The review and update pursuant to paragraph (4) shall include all of the following:
(A)Descriptions of the actions and projects undertaken on natural and working lands to date.
(B)Quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(C)A description of how the relevant agencies calculated emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(D)A summary of the benefits to low-income communities, disadvantaged communities, vulnerable communities, disadvantaged farmers, and Native American tribes.
(E)An evaluation of the efficacy of the priority nature-based solutions, pathways, and priority actions for greenhouse gas reductions, climate resilience, and climate change adaptation.
(F)Identification and description of any barriers to achieving the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(G)Recommendations to address the barriers identified in subparagraph (F) to achieve the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(H)Recommendations from the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)The Natural Resources Agency and the state board shall jointly establish an expert advisory committee that is composed of university researchers, technical assistance providers, practitioners and other experts in the field of climate change and natural and working lands science and management, and Indigenous and environmental justice representatives, to inform and review modeling and analyses for natural and working lands, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations on addressing barriers to efficient implementation of this section.
(d)No later than January 1, 2025, the state board shall develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track greenhouse gas emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with the Natural Resources Agency and the Department of Food and Agriculture, additional benefits from natural and working lands over time. In estimating and tracking greenhouse gas emissions and reductions and carbon sequestration from natural and working lands, the state board shall take into account, where feasible, both of the following:
(1)Greenhouse gas emissions and reductions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide related to natural and working lands.
(2)Potential impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to, increased fire risk, warming temperatures, and decreasing precipitation, on the ability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and sequester carbon from natural and working lands.
(e)On or before January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the Natural Resources Agency shall publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Natural carbon sequestration means actions that are undertaken on natural and working lands to remove and provide storage of atmospheric greenhouse gases in vegetation and soils. This shall include preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, which may include compost application, cover crops, hedgerows, planned grazing, urban forestry, riparian restoration, restoration of tidal flows to wetlands, and other forms of wetland restoration, among other relevant actions.
(2)Natural lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(3)Nature-based climate solutions means activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions in natural and working lands.
(4)Vulnerable communities has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (d) of Section 71340 of the Public Resources Code.
(5) Working lands has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency, in collaboration with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Food and Agriculture, the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c), and other relevant state agencies, shall determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce greenhouse gas emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. These targets shall be integrated into the scoping plan prepared pursuant to Section 38561 and other state policies.
(2)Projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall support the states efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
(3)(A)The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions.
(B)Notwithstanding any other law, emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
(4)On or before January 1, 2025, the Natural Resources Agency, in consultation with the state board, the California Environmental Protection Agency, and the Department of Food and Agriculture, shall review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy established pursuant to Section 39740.2 to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1).
(5)The review and update pursuant to paragraph (4) shall include all of the following:
(A)Descriptions of the actions and projects undertaken on natural and working lands to date.
(B)Quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(C)A description of how the relevant agencies calculated emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits.
(D)A summary of the benefits to low-income communities, disadvantaged communities, vulnerable communities, disadvantaged farmers, and Native American tribes.
(E)An evaluation of the efficacy of the priority nature-based solutions, pathways, and priority actions for greenhouse gas reductions, climate resilience, and climate change adaptation.
(F)Identification and description of any barriers to achieving the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(G)Recommendations to address the barriers identified in subparagraph (F) to achieve the range of targets pursuant to paragraph (1).
(H)Recommendations from the expert advisory committee established pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)The Natural Resources Agency and the state board shall jointly establish an expert advisory committee that is composed of university researchers, technical assistance providers, practitioners and other experts in the field of climate change and natural and working lands science and management, and Indigenous and environmental justice representatives, to inform and review modeling and analyses for natural and working lands, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations on addressing barriers to efficient implementation of this section.
(d)No later than January 1, 2025, the state board shall develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track greenhouse gas emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with the Natural Resources Agency and the Department of Food and Agriculture, additional benefits from natural and working lands over time. In estimating and tracking greenhouse gas emissions and reductions and carbon sequestration from natural and working lands, the state board shall take into account, where feasible, both of the following:
(1)Greenhouse gas emissions and reductions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide related to natural and working lands.
(2)Potential impacts of climate change, including, but not limited to, increased fire risk, warming temperatures, and decreasing precipitation, on the ability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and sequester carbon from natural and working lands.
(e)On or before January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the Natural Resources Agency shall publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 7, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 358, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 7, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2023 | Enrolled measure version corrected. |
| Aug 28, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 2823.). |
| Aug 24, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 26 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 24, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2180.). |
| Aug 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 21, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on N.R. & W. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Jun 7, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on E.Q. and N.R. & W. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 1902.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 18). |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Mar 23, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2023 | AB 1159 Aguiar-Curry Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 24, 2023 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB1159 Aguiar-Curry | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Natural Resources and Water] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | AB 1159 Aguiar-Curry Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Forest Carbon Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Forestry Association | ** Support | |
| Hoopa Valley Tribe | ** Support | |
| Pacific Forest Trust | ** Support | |
| The Conservation Fund | ** Support | |
| Trout Unlimited | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1159
Author:(Aguiar-Curry)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires that all greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
Senate Amendments
Strikes language prohibiting natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any GHG emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding, and replaces with clarifying language applying to all GHG reduction projects.
COMMENTS
Under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Act), California has goals to reduce GHG emissions to at least 85% below the 1990 level by 2045, and meet a goal of zero net carbon emissions by 2045.
Under the Act, the Air Resources Board (ARB) adopted the cap-and-trade program as a market-based compliance mechanism to establish a declining limit on major sources of GHG emissions throughout California. Covered entities can invest in "offsets" to satisfy a small percentage of their overall compliance obligation. Any reduction of GHG emissions used for compliance purposes must be real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional.
California's natural and working lands have the ability to sequester carbon from the atmosphere and greatly accelerate our progress to mitigate climate change and our ability to reduce worsening climate change impacts.
AB 1757 (C. Garcia, R. Rivas), Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022 requires ARB, by January 1, 2024, with other specified state entities, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHGs for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. AB 1757 provides that any emissions reduction project that receives state funding is not eligible to generate credits under cap-and-trade. The intent was to ensure that there is no "double payment" for stored carbon or avoided emissions from natural and working lands projects.
This bill clarifies that all GHG emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
According to the Author
AB 1757 includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
Arguments in Support
The Hoopa Valley Tribe writes, "Our Tribe has developed significant partnerships with California public agencies, including [the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection] and the State Coastal Conservancy, to carry out habitat restoration projects, water quality improvements, and fuel reduction work that protects critical infrastructure and public safety. None of these activities implicate double-counting of emissions reductions in the state's accounting. Yet AB 1757's overly broad language suggests that if we receive state grants for such activities, we might be unable to generate carbon offset revenue that would support ongoing land management and the wellbeing of Tribal members. This outcome would hinder important State and Tribal priorities, and it would be profoundly unfair to cut us off from the [ARB] carbon offset market if we should choose to participate in future."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in negligible state costs pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 11-0-0
YES: Luz Rivas, Flora, Addis, Friedman, Hoover, Mathis, Muratsuchi, Pellerin, Ward, Wood, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0-0
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones‑Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: July 3, 2023
CONSULTANT: Paige Brokaw / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0001329
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1159 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 1159
Author: Aguiar-Curry (D)
Amended: 7/3/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/28/23
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 10-0, 7/10/23
AYES: Min, Seyarto, Allen, Dahle, Eggman, Grove, Laird, Limón, Padilla, Stern
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hurtado
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 5/30/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: natural and working lands: market-based compliance mechanisms
SOURCE: The Conservation Fund
DIGEST:
This bill amends a provision of AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) to (rather than prohibit any project receiving any and all state funds from generating credits for a market-based compliance mechanism) only prohibit the specific greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of state funding from generating credits for a market-based compliance mechanism.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §38500 et seq.):
- Establishes the California Air Resources Board (CARB) as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases (GHGs).
- Requires CARB to approve a statewide GHG emissions limit equivalent to the statewide GHG emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 (AB 32, 2006) and to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030 (SB 32, 2016).
- States that it is the policy of the state that the protection and management of natural and working lands (NWL) is an important strategy in meeting the state’s GHG emissions reduction goals, and that the protection and management of those lands can result in the removal of carbon from the atmosphere and the sequestration of carbon in, above, and below the ground. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §9001 et seq.)
- States, under the California Climate Crisis Act (AB 1279, Muratsuchi, Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022), that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions no later than 2045 and maintain net negative GHG emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045 statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 level.
Under AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) (HSC §38561.5):
- Directs California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to, in collaboration with CARB, California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA), the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), the expert advisory committee, and other relevant state agencies, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based climate solutions that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 (“Targets”), which will be integrated into the AB/SB 32 Scoping Plan Updates.
- Directs CARB to, no later than January 1, 2025, develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track GHG emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with CNRA and CDFA, additional benefits from NWLs over time.
- Directs CARB to ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the Targets shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions. (“(b)(3)(A)”)
- States that notwithstanding any other law, emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism. (“(b)(3)(B)”)
This bill removes language that would make NWLs’ emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding ineligible to generate credits under a market-based compliance mechanism and instead require CARB to ensure that all GHG emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
Background
- Natural and Working Lands (NWLs). California’s NWLs include rangelands, forests, woodlands, wetlands, grasslands, shrubland, farmland, riparian areas, and urban green space. They cover more than 90 percent of the State and supply life-sustaining resources including clean water, air, food, and fiber. With their potential to sequester carbon, reduce GHG emissions, and increase the capacity for California to withstand inevitable climate impacts, these lands are a critical component of California’s integrated climate change strategy. However, some sources show that California’s NWLs are a net GHG source, losing more carbon than they are sequestering, with wildfire being the largest cause of carbon loss. A number of entities in California’s executive branch are developing policy and implementing programs to mitigate disturbances on natural and working lands and protect these lands from conversion to more intensive land uses.
- NWLs and carbon neutrality. Under last year’s AB 1279, it is now California’s statutorily enshrined policy to achieve carbon neutrality as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to do so by way of reducing GHG emissions to at least 85% below their 1990 level.
If emissions are reduced by 85% in 2045, the 15% that remains are termed “residual emissions” and in order to achieve carbon neutrality they must be offset by an equivalent amount of carbon dioxide removal (CDR). Specifically, achieving an 85% reduction from the 1990 level (as AB 1279 requires) would mean there are still 65 million metric tons of CO2-equivalent emissions in 2045. To be carbon neutral then, California would need to demonstrate 65 MMTCO2e worth of CDR, which could be provided by a mix of nature-based carbon sequestration on NWLs and engineered carbon removal.
Nature-based carbon sequestration has received considerable attention because it is, to many, the most attractive solution to achieving carbon neutrality. There is no plausible plan for California to have truly zero emissions in 2045; all signs point towards at least some residual emissions from some sectors. For those who question the promise of engineered carbon removal, nature-based carbon sequestration then must play a larger role in counterbalancing any residual emissions in 2045 and beyond. - CARB’s AB 1757 guidance. In December of 2022, CARB issued a guidance document for AB 1757 implementation, which addressed some of the very same issues AB 1159 does, but it did so through interpreting the intentions underlying AB 1757.
In the document, CARB stated that the intention of HSC §38561.5(b)(3)(B) was to avoid offsets being generated alongside state funding with the primary purpose being to help the state achieve the AB 1757 targets, despite no allusion to the “primary purpose” of the funds in the statute. The guidance document went on to state that “A project receiving compliance offset credits in the Cap-and-Trade Program can still receive State funding for actions that do not have as their primary purpose climate mitigation and increases in quantified stored carbon or avoided GHG emissions.”
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Last year, the Legislature passed AB 1757 (C. Garcia and R. Rivas), which required the Natural Resources Agency to determine a range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based carbon solutions for GHG reductions. AB 1757 also includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
“This bill clarifies that the prohibition established in AB 1757 against generating credits under a market-based compliance mechanism - if a project or activity receives state funds - only applies to actions and projects that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing GHG emissions.
“This clarification will allow land managers to seek and receive state acquisition and restoration grants for projects on properties that generate carbon sequestration credits (without the use of state funds) to move forward with legal certainty.” - Defining “double-counting” and “double-dipping”. Within the provisions of AB 1757, the two subparagraphs implicated in this bill, (b)(3)(A) and (b)(3)(B), are colloquially referred to as the “double-counting” and “double-dipping” prohibitions, respectively.
Double-counting is an important concept that has been included in CARB’s compliance offset protocol, as well as other regulations and legislation. Subparagraph (b)(3)(B) effectively restates existing law, emphasizing the importance of making sure that any action taken to reduce (or avoid) one ton of emissions is only accounted for once, in one place. If double-counting were to occur, a single ton of reductions in reality may be accounted for on two different emissions ledgers. Taken together, this would create a situation where emissions on paper are lower than emissions in reality. Needless to say, emissions in reality are what matter for mitigating climate change, and emissions on paper are only useful insofar as they reflect reality.
Double-dipping is a comparatively ill-defined concept, referring to the practice of receiving state funds on the front-end (say, through a state grant for habitat restoration), and also earning revenue on the back-end as well (say, through generating and selling forest offsets). There does not appear a clear objective standard to delineate between “stacking incentives” and “double-dipping”, which complicates the issue considerably.
A project double-dipping could be undesirable because it suggests that project
may have received enough funding to have occurred, and yet it may still have sought more funding and more profitability. In part, this seems to be a matter of efficiency. If $1 million in state funding could either induce two projects to remove 10,000 tons of carbon a piece and break even, or induce one project to remove 10,000 tons of carbon and make a profit, the state’s GHG goals would have been better served by the former. The more pressing aspect of protecting against double-dipping comes in its implications for additionality. - Defining “additionality”. Additionality is an essential component of carbon-offset projects. To qualify as a genuine carbon offset, the reductions achieved by a project need to be ‘additional’ to what would have happened if the project had not been carried out (e.g. continued as business-as-usual). For instance, if a project is viable in its own right, say through a conservation easement, or because of government funding, regulation or other policies, then it cannot be used as an offset project as it would have been undertaken regardless of investment secured through carbon markets.
The concept of additionality is important as only carbon credits from projects that are “additional to” the business-as-usual scenario represent a net environmental benefit. Without the “additionality” requirement, there is no guarantee that the emissions reduction activities will lead to a reduction of GHGs into the atmosphere. Therefore, in simple terms, if carbon credits are awarded to activities that would have happened anyway, emissions are allowed to rise without a corresponding cut elsewhere, therefore making the process meaningless.
Unfortunately, additionality is not an objective feature of a project, but rather a determination that is made based on assumptions and claims about what would have happened without the investment. This has led to controversy embroiling numerous projects, such as where old-growth forests under no risk of being logged were misrepresented by project proponents as requiring offset funds to protect the trees.
The existing language of (b)(3)(B), created by AB 1757, is maximally protective of additionality, and it errs on the side of disqualifying some projects that may indeed provide truly additional GHG removals rather than risk providing support for any non-additional project. The current language in this bill attempts to thread the needle and allow certain projects to receive state funds and still generate offsets. The intent is for the language to allow GHG reductions and removals that are not the result of state funding to generate offsets, even if some part of a larger project does receive state funding. However, verifying that a GHG reduction or removal is “a result of” state funding is much easier said than done.
Ultimately, whether or not a project that has received other state funding should be eligible for generating offset credits does not have one objectively correct answer. It is a matter of determining an appropriate counterfactual to compare against, and carefully accounting for the carbon removed or avoided, such that it can be credibly used to justify a continuing emission elsewhere. This has proven to be an endlessly contentious and confounding task. - AB 1757 is downstream of CARB’s Compliance Offset Protocol. Double-counting and additionality are separate but closely-interlinked concepts; if done incorrectly, either component can lead to carbon reductions or removals being accounted for on paper that do not represent a true ton of carbon in the real world. They are so important, in fact, that both of these protections (and more) are ostensibly included in CARB’s Compliance Offset Protocol for U.S. Forest Projects. Regardless of the language included or omitted from this code section, that Offset Protocol remains and the implicated projects are subject to both.
That being said, the recurring conflicts about additionality, double-counting, permanence, and other elements of the Compliance Offset Protocol have unfolded despite the Protocol’s existence. Getting at the root of those problems is likely more a matter of engaging the Offset Protocol itself, and less a matter of piggybacking off of those concepts in subsequent legislation, be it AB 1757 or AB 1159.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/23/23)
The Conservation Fund
Pacific Forest Trust
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/23/23)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 5/30/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
Prepared by: Eric Walters / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/23/23 15:11:24
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Dave Min, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: July 10, 2023
Author: | Aguiar-Curry | ||
Version: | July 3, 2023 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Catherine Baxter | ||
Subject: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: natural and working lands: market-based compliance mechanisms
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes, pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §§38500 et seq.), the State Air Resources Board (ARB) as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases (GHGs) (HSC §38510), and directs ARB to:
- Approve a statewide GHG emissions limit equivalent to the statewide GHG emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. HSC §§38550 and 38566, respectively.
- Establishes a policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative GHG emissions thereafter. HSC §38562.2.
- Prepare and approve a scoping plan to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. HSC §38561.
- Declares it is a policy of the state that the protection and management of natural working lands (NWLs), as defined, is an important strategy in meeting the state’s GHG emissions reduction goals, and that the protection and management of those lands can result in the removal of carbon from the atmosphere and the sequestration of carbon in, above, and below the ground. Public Resources Code §9001.5.
- Directs the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA), in coordination with the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA), ARB, the Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), and other relevant state agencies, to establish the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy that creates a framework to advance the state’s climate goals, as specified. HSC §39740.2.
- Directs CNRA, by January 1, 2024, in collaboration with specified entities, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience (HSC §38561.5). Further:
- Defines “natural carbon sequestration” to mean actions that are undertaken on NWLs to remove and provide storage of atmospheric GHGs in vegetation and soils. This includes preservation, conservation, restoration, and sustainable management of these lands, as specified.
- Defines “nature-based climate solutions” to mean activities, such as restoration, conservation, and land management actions, that increase net carbon sequestration or reduce GHG emissions in NWLs.
- Requires the targets to be integrated into the scoping plan and other state policies.
- Requires projects and actions developed to achieve the targets to support the state’s efforts to achieve carbon neutrality, take into account climate impacts, increase resilience to climate change impacts, reduce GHG emissions, and enhance carbon sequestration in a manner that maximizes ecological health and biodiversity, and complements other climate and resources goals.
- Directs ARB to ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets are accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions.
- Provides that emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
- Directs CNRA, by January 1, 2025, in consultation with specified state agencies, to review and update the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy to achieve the targets. Requires this review and update to include specified information, including quantified progress on emissions reductions, natural carbon sequestration, and cobenefits; among others.
- Directs CNRA and ARB to jointly establish an expert advisory committee, as specified, to inform and review modeling and analyses for NWLs, to advise state agencies on implementation strategies and standardized accounting, and to provide recommendations to address barriers to relating to implementation.
- Directs ARB, by January 1, 2025, to develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track GHG emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with CNRA and CDFA, additional benefits from NWLs. Directs ARB to account for certain things in these methods, including, for example, the potential impacts of climate change on the ability to reduce GHG emissions and sequester carbon from NWLs.
- Directs CNRA, by January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, to publish data on its internet website on progress made in achieving the targets, including on state expenditures made to implement these targets.
Background
Natural and Working Lands. California’s NWLs include forests, woodlands, rangelands, shrublands, grasslands, wetlands, farmlands, riparian areas, and urban green space. They cover more than 90 percent of the state and supply life-sustaining resources including clean water, air, food, and fiber. With the potential to sequester carbon and increase the state’s capacity to withstand climate impacts, NWLs, when healthy, can play a critical role in California’s integrated climate change strategies. However, when unhealthy, they can also be a source of GHG emissions, losing more carbon than they sequester due to wildfire, drought, disease, invasive species, soil disturbance, poor management, harvest, and conversion to higher intensity uses, among others. Climate change is projected to exacerbate many of these issues and associated losses, although human interventions in the form of preservation, conservation, restoration, and improved management of NWLs could slow or reverse these losses over the long-term. A number of entities in California’s executive branch are developing policies and implementing programs to mitigate disturbances on NWLs lands and protect these lands from conversion to more intensive land uses.
NWLs can serve as a GHG source and sink. The Earth has a natural carbon cycle, in which carbon cycles between the land, ocean, and atmosphere. As part of this cycle, over decades or centuries, fire and plant respiration and decomposition move carbon from the land to the atmosphere while plant growth and other processes move carbon from the atmosphere to the land.
In California, according to ARB’s latest NWL’s Inventory, the state’s lands were a net source of GHG emissions from 2001 to 2011, then a net sink from 2012 to 2014. These trends highlight the ability of NWLs to be both a source and a sink of GHGs, as well as the importance of looking at NWL data and trends over multi-year and multi-decadal time periods, as opposed to looking only at annual changes. Further, given recent climate and wildfire trends as well as declining ecosystem health, experts believe the state’s NWLs are currently acting as a source of emissions and ARB estimates they will remain a net source through at least 2045.
It is important to note that GHG flux estimates come with a high degree of uncertainty. It is extremely challenging to parse the complex interactions between natural carbon cycles and human activity. Land use, management, and climate change, among other factors, all can impact whether these lands act as a sink or a source and can start negative feedback loops in which conversions of NWLs to higher intensity uses, poor management, and climate change cause these lands to release more carbon than they sequester.
Co-benefits of nature-based solutions. While there is some uncertainty around the scale of GHG mitigation and sequestration potential of NWLs under a changing climate, these solutions can provide substantial co-benefits to ecosystems and communities, including habitat resilience, groundwater recharge, water and air quality improvements, flood risk reduction, creating open space for communities, and protecting communities from extreme heat.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill would remove language that would make NWLs’ emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding ineligible to generate credits under a market-based compliance mechanism and instead require ARB to ensure that all GHG emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “Last year, the Legislature passed AB 1757 (C. Garcia and R. Rivas), which required [CNRA] to determine a range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based carbon solutions for GHG reductions. AB 1757 also included provisions to ensure any emission reduction work that is used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for natural carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction.
This bill removes the overly broad provision and instead clarifies that all GHG reductions and removals used for any market based mechanism are in addition to what would otherwise occur. This clarification will ensure all natural sequestration projects are only able to sell offset credits that are above and beyond what would occur under regulatory obligations or restoration efforts. This bill will allow land managers to seek and receive state acquisition and restoration grants for projects on properties that generate carbon sequestration credits with legal certainty.”
According to the California Forestry Association, this bill “would clarify existing law to allow land managers to receive state funding for forest restoration, wildfire prevention, post-fire recovery, and forest health projects without violating a prohibition on participating in California Air Resources Board Compliance Offset projects.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received.
COMMENTS
Referral. This bill was referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee first and this Committee second. The Senate Environmental Quality Committee passed the bill 7-0 on June 28, 2023, and amended the bill to:
- Remove the language that specifies that emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
- Require ARB to ensure that that all GHG emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
Elements of the bill under the Senate Environmental Quality Committee’s jurisdiction were discussed there and are included here for context and completeness only.
This bill. Existing law, established via AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022), (1) directs ARB to ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets developed by CNRA for natural carbon sequestration and nature-based climate solutions are accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions; and (2) provides that emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
According to The Conservation Fund, AB 1159’s sponsor, the second part of that direction has already had considerable negative impact on desirable projects since AB 1757 took effect. The Conservation Fund owns and manages more than 73,000 acres on California’s North Coast. Their work seeks to improve habitat for the endangered Northern Spotted Owl, state-threatened coho salmon, and steelhead trout. According to The Conservation Fund, revenue generated through the sale of carbon offsets via cap-and-trade is instrumental to doing their work.
In 2022, The Conservation Fund secured more than $850,000 in state grants in partnership with Trout Unlimited and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the improvement of salmon and trout habitat. Due to the state funding limitation in AB 1757, however, The Conservation Fund chose to decline those grants in order to maintain continued eligibility to sell carbon offsets.
Additionally, the Hoopa Valley Tribe has raised substantial concerns about the impacts of AB 1757. They state, “Our Tribe has developed significant partnerships with California public agencies, including CalFire and the State Coastal Conservancy, to carry out habitat restoration projects, water quality improvements, and fuel reduction work that protects critical infrastructure and public safety. None of these activities implicate double-counting of emissions reductions in the state’s accounting. Yet AB 1757’s overly broad language suggests that if we receive state grants for such activities, we might be unable to generate carbon offset revenue that would support ongoing land management and the wellbeing of Tribal members.”
Based on amendments adopted in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, this bill would address this issue by removing the second part of the direction listed above, and rewriting the first part, as follows:
The state board shall ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the targets established pursuant to paragraph (1) shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions, and that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals used for any market-based compliance mechanism are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur.
According to the sponsors and other stakeholders consulted, the current version of this bill addresses the concerns raised.
Previous legislation
AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) requires CNRA to determine, by January 1, 2024, an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045, to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience.
SB 27 (Skinner, Chapter 237, Statutes of 2021) directed CNRA to establish the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy.
SUPPORT
The Conservation Fund (sponsor)
California Forest Carbon Coalition
California Forestry Association
Hoopa Valley Tribe
Pacific Forest Trust
Trout Unlimited
OPPOSITION
None Received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 1159
Author: | Aguiar-Curry | ||
Version: | 4/12/2023 | Hearing Date: | 6/28/2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eric Walters | ||
SUBJECT: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: natural and working lands: market-based compliance mechanisms
DIGEST: This bill amends a provision of AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) to (rather than prohibit any project receiving any and all state funds from generating credits for a market-based compliance mechanism) only prohibit the specific greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of state funding from generating credits for a market-based compliance mechanism.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §38500 et seq.):
- Establishes the California Air Resources Board (CARB) as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases (GHGs).
- Requires CARB to approve a statewide GHG emissions limit equivalent to the statewide GHG emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 (AB 32, 2006) and to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030 (SB 32, 2016).
- States that it is the policy of the state that the protection and management of natural and working lands (NWL) is an important strategy in meeting the state’s GHG emissions reduction goals, and that the protection and management of those lands can result in the removal of carbon from the atmosphere and the sequestration of carbon in, above, and below the ground. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §9001 et seq.)
- Under the California Climate Crisis Act (AB 1279, Muratsuchi, Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022), states that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions no later than 2045 and maintain net negative GHG emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045 statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 level.
- Under AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) (HSC §38561.5):
- Directs California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to, in collaboration with CARB, California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA), the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), the expert advisory committee, and other relevant state agencies, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based climate solutions that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 (“Targets”), which will be integrated into the AB/SB 32 Scoping Plan Updates.
- Directs CARB to, no later than January 1, 2025, develop standard methods for state agencies to consistently track GHG emissions and reductions, carbon sequestration, and, where feasible and in consultation with CNRA and CDFA, additional benefits from NWLs over time.
- Directs CARB to ensure that all emissions reductions from projects and actions developed to achieve the Targets shall be accounted for in a manner that does not result in double counting of emissions reductions. (“(b)(3)(A)”)
- States that notwithstanding any other law, emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism. (“(b)(3)(B)”)
- Directs California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to, in collaboration with CARB, California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA), the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), the expert advisory committee, and other relevant state agencies, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based climate solutions that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 (“Targets”), which will be integrated into the AB/SB 32 Scoping Plan Updates.
This bill revises (b)(3)(B) to prohibit NWL projects and actions that receive state funding from generating credits under any market-based compliance mechanism only for any GHG emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
Background
- Natural and Working Lands (NWLs). California’s NWLs include rangelands, forests, woodlands, wetlands, grasslands, shrubland, farmland, riparian areas, and urban green space. They cover more than 90 percent of the State and supply life-sustaining resources including clean water, air, food, and fiber. With their potential to sequester carbon, reduce GHG emissions, and increase the capacity for California to withstand inevitable climate impacts, these lands are a critical component of California’s integrated climate change strategy. However, some sources show that California’s NWLs are a net GHG source, losing more carbon than they are sequestering, with wildfire being the largest cause of carbon loss. A number of entities in California’s executive branch are developing policy and implementing programs to mitigate disturbances on natural and working lands and protect these lands from conversion to more intensive land uses.
- NWLs and carbon neutrality. Under last year’s AB 1279, it is now California’s statutorily enshrined policy to achieve carbon neutrality as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to do so by way of reducing GHG emissions to at least 85% below their 1990 level.
If emissions are reduced by 85% in 2045, the 15% that remains are termed “residual emissions” and in order to achieve carbon neutrality they must be offset by an equivalent amount of carbon dioxide removal (CDR). To put more concrete numbers to it, achieving an 85% reduction from the 1990 level (as AB 1279 requires) would mean there are still 65 million metric tons of CO2-equivalent emissions in 2045. To be carbon neutral then, California would need to demonstrate 65 MMTCO2e worth of CDR, which could be provided by a mix of nature-based carbon sequestration on NWLs and engineered carbon removal.
Nature-based carbon sequestration has received considerable attention because it is, to many, the most attractive solution to achieving carbon neutrality. There is no plausible plan for California to have truly zero emissions in 2045; all signs point towards at least some residual emissions from some sectors. For those who question the promise of engineered carbon removal, nature-based carbon sequestration then must play a larger role in counterbalancing any residual emissions in 2045 and beyond. - Cap-and-trade compliance. The original cap-and-trade program was recommended by CARB as a central approach to flexibly and iteratively reduce emissions over time. Beginning on January 1, 2013, the cap-and-trade regulation set a firm, declining cap on total GHG emissions from sources that make up approximately 80% of all statewide GHG emissions. Sources included under the cap are termed “covered entities.” The cap is enforced by requiring each covered entity to surrender one “compliance instrument” for every emissions unit (i.e., metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent or MTCO2e) that it emits at the end of a compliance period.
Two main forms of compliance instruments are used: allowances and offsets. Allowances are generated by the state in an amount equal to the cap and may be “banked” (i.e., allowing current allowances to be used for future compliance). An offset is a credit intended to represent a real, verified, permanent, and enforceable emission reduction project from a source outside a capped sector (e.g., a certified carbon-storing forestry project). Under AB 398 (E. Garcia, Chapter 135, Statutes of 2017), the amount of offsets a covered entity may use to comply with cap-and-trade was reduced from 8% of its total emissions to 4% of its total emissions, though this number will rise to 6% in 2026 onward. Allowances and offsets both have some controversy surrounding their design and implementation in California’s cap-and-trade program. - Concerns around offsets. Carbon offsets are widely used by individuals, corporations, and governments to mitigate their GHG emissions on the assumption that offsets reflect equivalent climate benefits achieved elsewhere. These climate-equivalence claims depend on offsets providing real and additional climate benefits beyond what would have happened, counterfactually, without the offsets project. In California, according to the latest Independent Emissions Market Advisory Committee (IEMAC) report, offsets constitute a significant source (6.3%) of the supply of compliance instruments in the market, with forest offsets producing about 80% of offset supply to date.
The central idea behind a carbon offset is that it can substitute for GHG emission reductions that an organization would have made on its own. Given the inherent difficulty of proving an impact as compared to something that did not happen, the financial incentives for expert practitioners to advocate for more lenient policies, and the huge diversity of offset-generating projects, it is no wonder the discussions of carbon offsets have been complex and fraught. The stakes are incredibly high as well; if emitting one ton of GHGs is justified because of an offset, and that offset turns out to not be real, then emissions will continue to rise unabated regardless of the accounting performed. - CARB’s AB 1757 guidance. In December of 2022, CARB issued a guidance document for AB 1757 implementation, which addressed some of the very same issues AB 1159 does, but it did so through interpreting the intentions underlying AB 1757.
In the document, CARB stated that the intention of HSC §38561.5(b)(3)(B) was to avoid offsets being generated alongside state funding with the primary purpose being to help the state achieve the AB 1757 targets, despite no allusion to the “primary purpose” of the funds in the statute. The guidance document went on to state that “A project receiving compliance offset credits in the Cap-and-Trade Program can still receive State funding for actions that do not have as their primary purpose climate mitigation and increases in quantified stored carbon or avoided GHG emissions.” This is a notable contrast to the text of AB 1757, which reads “emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.”
As initially introduced, AB 1159 reflected CARB’s guidance by stating that “projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.” However, subsequent amendments to the bill taken in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee further refine the language, and as such deviate considerably from CARB’s December 2022 guidance.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Last year, the Legislature passed AB 1757 (C. Garcia and R. Rivas), which required the Natural Resources Agency to determine a range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based carbon solutions for GHG reductions. AB 1757 also includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
“This bill clarifies that the prohibition established in AB 1757 against generating credits under a market-based compliance mechanism - if a project or activity receives state funds - only applies to actions and projects that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing GHG emissions.
“This clarification will allow land managers to seek and receive state acquisition and restoration grants for projects on properties that generate carbon sequestration credits (without the use of state funds) to move forward with legal certainty.” - Defining “double-counting” and “double-dipping”. Within the provisions of AB 1757, the two subparagraphs implicated in this bill, (b)(3)(A) and (b)(3)(B), are colloquially referred to as the “double-counting” and “double-dipping” prohibitions, respectively.
Double-counting is an important concept that has been included in CARB’s compliance offset protocol, as well as other regulations and legislation. Subparagraph (b)(3)(B) effectively restates existing law, emphasizing the importance of making sure that any action taken to reduce (or avoid) one ton of emissions is only accounted for once, in one place. If double-counting were to occur, a single ton of reductions in reality may be accounted for on two different emissions ledgers. Taken together, this would create a situation where emissions on paper are lower than emissions in reality. Needless to say, emissions in reality are what matter for mitigating climate change, and emissions on paper are only useful insofar as they reflect reality.
Double-dipping is a comparatively ill-defined concept, referring to the practice of receiving state funds on the front-end (say, through a state grant for habitat restoration), and also earning revenue on the back-end as well (say, through generating and selling forest offsets). There does not appear a clear objective standard to delineate between “stacking incentives” and “double-dipping”, which complicates the issue considerably.
A project double-dipping could be undesirable because it suggests that project
may have received enough funding to have occurred, and yet it may still have sought more funding and more profitability. In part, this seems to be a matter of efficiency. If $1 million in state funding could either induce two projects to remove 10,000 tons of carbon a piece and break even, or induce one project to remove 10,000 tons of carbon and make a profit, the state’s GHG goals would have been better served by the former.
The more pressing aspect of protecting against double-dipping comes in its implications for additionality, which is a complicated and thorny topic. - Defining “additionality”. Additionality is an essential component of carbon-offset projects. To qualify as a genuine carbon offset, the reductions achieved by a project need to be ‘additional’ to what would have happened if the project had not been carried out (e.g. continued as business-as-usual). For instance, if a project is viable in its own right, say through a conservation easement, or because of government funding, regulation or other policies, then it cannot be used as an offset project as it would have been undertaken regardless of investment secured through carbon markets.
The concept of additionality is important as only carbon credits from projects that are “additional to” the business-as-usual scenario represent a net environmental benefit. Without the “additionality” requirement, there is no guarantee that the emissions reduction activities will lead to a reduction of GHGs into the atmosphere. Therefore, in simple terms, if carbon credits are awarded to activities that would have happened anyway, emissions are allowed to rise without a corresponding cut elsewhere, therefore making the process meaningless.
Unfortunately, additionality is not an objective feature of a project, but rather a determination that is made based on assumptions and claims about what would have happened without the investment. This has led to controversy embroiling numerous projects, such as where old-growth forests under no risk of being logged were misrepresented by project proponents as requiring offset funds to protect the trees.
The existing language of (b)(3)(B), created by AB 1757, is maximally protective of additionality, and it errs on the side of disqualifying some projects that may indeed provide truly additional GHG removals rather than risk providing support for any non-additional project. The current language in this bill attempts to thread the needle and allow certain projects to receive state funds and still generate offsets. The intent is for the language to allow GHG reductions and removals that are not the result of state funding to generate offsets, even if some part of a larger project does receive state funding. However, verifying that a GHG reduction or removal is “a result of” state funding is much easier said than done.
Ultimately, whether or not a project that has received other state funding should be eligible for generating offset credits does not have one objectively correct answer. It is a matter of determining an appropriate counterfactual to compare against, and carefully accounting for the carbon removed or avoided, such that it can be credibly used to justify a continuing emission elsewhere. This has proven to be an endlessly contentious and confounding task. - Real world impacts of (b)(3)(B). The sponsors of this measure, The Conservation Fund, state that in the nine months since AB 1757 was signed into law there have already been considerable negative impacts on desirable projects. The Conservation Fund has owned and managed more than 75,000 on California’s North Coast since 2004. Their work has improved habitat for the endangered Northern Spotted Owl, state-threatened coho salmon, and steelhead trout. The Conservation Fund claim that the revenue generated through the sale of carbon offsets via cap-and-trade is instrumental to doing their work. In 2022, The Conservation Fund secured more than $900,000 in state grants in partnership with Trout Unlimited and California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the improvement of salmon and trout habitat.
Due to the passage of AB 1757, The Conservation Fund has chosen to decline those grants. Notably, it would seem that if The Conservation Fund had followed the direction CARB’s December 2022 guidance document, much of that work could have continued, all while continuing to generate offsets.
Additionally, the Hoopa Valley Tribe has raised substantial concerns about the impacts of AB 1757 as well. They state, “Our Tribe has developed significant partnerships with California public agencies, including CalFire and the State Coastal Conservancy, to carry out habitat restoration projects, water quality improvements, and fuel reduction work that protects critical infrastructure and public safety. None of these activities implicate double-counting of emissions reductions in the state’s accounting. Yet AB 1757’s overly broad language suggests that if we receive state grants for such activities, we might be unable to generate carbon offset revenue that would support ongoing land management and the wellbeing of Tribal members.” If AB 1757 is preventing important work the Legislature wishes to see be done, then it is important to remedy the situation. - AB 1757 is downstream of CARB’s Compliance Offset Protocol. Double-counting and additionality are separate but closely-interlinked concepts; if done incorrectly, either component can lead to carbon reductions or removals being accounted for on paper that do not represent a true ton of carbon in the real world. They are so important, in fact, that both of these protections (and more) are ostensibly included in CARB’s Compliance Offset Protocol for U.S. Forest Projects. Regardless of the language included or omitted from this code section, that Offset Protocol remains and the implicated projects are subject to both.
It is worth considering what the fundamental purpose of the original (b)(3)(A) and (B) was, and what this legislation seeks to achieve. Subparagraph (b)(3)(A) simply stated that offsets were not to be double-counted. This was already existing law under the Compliance Offset Protocol. Subparagraph (b)(3)(B) seems most importantly to be assuring the additionality of offsets. Additionality, too, is a requirement of the Compliance Offset Protocol. This legislation attempts to revise the double-dipping provision in a way that upholds additionality, but even without this language, projects would need to demonstrate their additionality under the Offset Protocol.
That being said, the recurring conflicts about additionality, double-counting, permanence, and other elements of the Compliance Offset Protocol have unfolded despite the Protocol’s existence. Getting at the root of those problems is likely more a matter of engaging the Offset Protocol itself, and less a matter of piggybacking off of those concepts in subsequent legislation, be it AB 1757 or AB 1159. If concerned stakeholders believe that CARB has a faulty conception of additionality in the Offset Protocol, there is no way to rewrite (b)(3)(B) so well that it overcomes that. Conversely, if the Offset Protocol were “fixed” so to speak, there would be no need for (b)(3) in its entirety.
Given the continued existence of additionality provisions in the Compliance Offset Protocol, and the significant issues the bill’s supporters raise of unintended consequences, a question arises as to the necessity of (b)(3)(B) at all. The committee may wish to consider striking (b)(3)(B) altogether, and including the phrase “To ensure that all greenhouse gas emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur” in (b)(3)(A). - You only get one second chance. This is clearly a complicated issue. The motivation behind introducing clean-up legislation five months after the passage of AB 1757 was to assuage project operators’ and investors’ concerns about an uncertain—or even prohibitory—regulatory environment around California’s NWLs. Given that, then it is of the utmost importance that the Legislature get it right this time and not continue to amend and re-amend this code section, creating market uncertainty.
If ensuring additionality of offsets to the extent desired does indeed require more than simply amending this code section, doing so would be a significant undertaking that would require more time and stakeholder participation than would be feasible this year. The author, committee, and subsequent committees may wish to consider holding this measure over until next year and committing to working with the affected and engaged parties to address the root causes of concerns around double-counting, double-dipping, and offsets without creating unintended consequences. - Committee amendments. Staff recommends the committee adopt the bolded amendments contained in comment 5 above.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1757 (C. Garcia, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) directs the CNRA to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHG emissions for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. It also includes provisions to avoid double counting emission reductions, updates the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy, develops GHG tracking protocols, and biennially post progress made in achieving the targets on CNRA’s internet website.
AB 2649 (C. Garcia, 2022) would have set goals for natural carbon sequestration, as defined, for California of at least 60 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent by December 31, 2030 and 75 million metric tons by December 31, 2035. It also would have provided direction on integrating these goals into specified state plans, as well as reporting requirements to the Legislature. AB 2649 died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 284 (R. Rivas, 2021) would have required CARB to identify a 2045 climate goal, with interim milestones, for the state’s NWLs to sequester carbon and reduce atmospheric GHG emissions. AB 284 died on the Senate floor.
SOURCE:
The Conservation Fund
SUPPORT:
None received
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1159
Author:(Aguiar-Curry)
As Amended Ver:April 12, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Clarifies that, to ensure all greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any GHG emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
Under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Act), California has goals to reduce GHG emissions to at least 85% below the 1990 level by 2045, and a goal of zero net carbon emissions by 2045.
Under the Act, the Air Resources Board (ARB) adopted the cap-and-trade program as a market-based compliance mechanism to establish a declining limit on major sources of GHG emissions throughout California. Covered entities can invest in "offsets" to satisfy a small percentage of their overall compliance obligation. Any reduction of GHG emissions used for compliance purposes must be real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional.
California’s natural and working lands have the ability to sequester carbon from the atmosphere and greatly accelerate our progress to mitigate climate change and our ability to reduce worsening climate change impacts.
AB 1757 (Cristina Garcia), Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022, requires the ARB, by January 1, 2024, with other specified state entities, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHGs for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. AB 1757 provides that any emissions reduction project that receives state funding is not eligible to generate credits under cap-and-trade. The intent was to ensure that there is no "double payment" for stored carbon or avoided emissions from natural and working lands projects.
This bill clarifies that, to ensure all GHG emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any GHG emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
According to the Author
AB 1757 includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
Arguments in Support
The Hoopa Valley Tribe writes, "Our Tribe has developed significant partnerships with California public agencies, including CalFire and the State Coastal Conservancy, to carry out habitat restoration projects, water quality improvements, and fuel reduction work that protects critical infrastructure and public safety. None of these activities implicate double-counting of emissions reductions in the state’s accounting. Yet AB 1757’s overly broad language suggests that if we receive state grants for such activities, we might be unable to generate carbon offset revenue that would support ongoing land management and the wellbeing of Tribal members. This outcome would hinder important State and Tribal priorities, and it would be profoundly unfair to cut us off from the [ARB] carbon offset market if we should choose to participate in future."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill would result in ongoing annual costs of approximately $213,000 (Cost of Implementation Account) for one positon to track new and existing state funding sources for natural and working lands project types and determine if they render funded projects ineligible for compliance offsets, continue to assess California-based compliance offset projects for compliance with this bill, provide guidance to natural and working lands project proponents and other government jurisdictions on eligibility requirements for ARB’s compliance protocols, and coordinate with the Natural Resources Agency and other entities as needed on state grant programs to develop procedures to determine if a natural and working lands funding source should be designated as reducing GHG emissions or increasing sequestration.
VOTES
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 11-0-0
YES: Luz Rivas, Flora, Addis, Friedman, Hoover, Mathis, Muratsuchi, Pellerin, Ward, Wood, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: April 12, 2023
CONSULTANT: Paige Brokaw / NAT. RES. / FN: 0000550
Date of Hearing: May 3, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1159
Author:(Aguiar-Curry) – As Amended Ver:April 12, 2023
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill clarifies that, to ensure all greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any GHG emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
FISCAL EFFECT:
ARB estimates ongoing annual costs of approximately $213,000 (Cost of Implementation Account) for one positon to track new and existing state funding sources for natural and working lands project types and determine if they render funded projects ineligible for compliance offsets, continue to assess California-based compliance offset projects for compliance with this bill, provide guidance to natural and working lands project proponents and other government jurisdictions on eligibility requirements for ARB’s compliance protocols, and coordinate with CNRA and other entities as needed on state grant programs to develop procedures to determine if a natural and working lands funding source should be designated as reducing GHG emissions or increasing sequestration.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the author:
Last year, the Legislature passed AB 1757 (C. Garcia and R. Rivas), which required the Natural Resources Agency to determine a range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based carbon solutions for GHG reductions. AB 1757 also includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
2) Background. AB 1757 (C. Garcia), Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022, among other things, requires the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA), by January 1, 2024, in collaboration with other state agencies, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHGs for 2030, 2038, and 2045, to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience.
Under ARB’s cap-and-trade program, covered entities can invest in “offsets” – projects that sequester carbon in forests, flooded rice fields, biogas control systems for manure management on dairy cattle and swine farms, and others – to satisfy a small percentage of their overall compliance obligation. Any reduction of GHG emissions used for compliance purposes must be real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional.
AB 1757 provides that any emissions reduction project and action that receives state funding is not eligible to generate credits under cap-and-trade. The intent was to ensure there is no “double payment” for stored carbon or avoided emissions from natural and working lands projects. This creates a scenario for project proponents in which they either receive financial recognition for stored carbon and avoided emissions as an offset project completed under an ARB-approved compliance offset protocol or receive state funding with the primary purpose being to help the state achieve its climate targets developed pursuant to AB 1757.
The Hoopa Valley Tribe writes:
Our Tribe has developed significant partnerships with California public agencies, including CalFire and the State Coastal Conservancy, to carry out habitat restoration projects, water quality improvements, and fuel reduction work that protects critical infrastructure and public safety. None of these activities implicate double-counting of emissions reductions in the state’s accounting. Yet AB 1757’s overly broad language suggests that if we receive state grants for such activities, we might be unable to generate carbon offset revenue that would support ongoing land management and the wellbeing of Tribal members. This outcome would hinder important State and Tribal priorities, and it would be profoundly unfair to cut us off from the Air Resources Board carbon offset market if we should choose to participate in future.
Similarly, the Conservation Fund, a national nonprofit organization, owns and manages more than 75,000 acres on California’s north coast. The Conservation Fund’s restoration and progressive management regimes have improved habitat for the endangered Northern Spotted Owl and state-threatened Coho salmon and steelhead trout. Instrumental to the ability of The Conservation Fund to manage these vast forestlands is the revenue generated through the sale of carbon offsets via the cap-and-trade program. In 2022, The Conservation Fund secured more than $900,000 in state grants in partnership with Trout Unlimited and California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the improvement of salmon and trout habitat. With the passage of AB 1757, according to the author, The Conservation Fund must now decline those grants.
ARB has issued guidance to interpret how AB 1757 applies to various projects. In the context of state funding for sustainable forest management practices or conservation easements projects, ARB explains:
A project receiving compliance offset credits in the Cap-and-Trade Program can still receive State funding for actions that do not have as their primary purpose climate mitigation and increases in quantified stored carbon or avoided GHG emissions.
In addition to its issued guidance, ARB works with offset project registries and third-party verifiers on a case-by-case basis to verify projects are in compliance with AB 1757 before issuing offset credits. The author intends this bill to be consistent with ARB’s guidance.
Analysis Prepared by: Nikita Koraddi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Luz Rivas, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1159 (
Author:Aguiar-Curry) – As Introduced Ver:February 16, 2023
SUBJECT: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: natural and working lands: market-based compliance mechanisms
SUMMARY: Clarifies that projects and actions that receive state funding, excluding federal funds dispensed by state agencies, for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are prohibited from being eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the GHG emissions reduction limit, pursuant to AB 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022) to be at least 85% below the 1990 level by 2045, and establishes a goal of zero net carbon emissions by 2045, commonly known as carbon neutrality. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 38500 et seq.)
- Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to prepare and approve a Scoping Plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions from sources or categories of sources of GHGs. Requires ARB to consult with all state agencies with jurisdiction over sources of GHGs. Requires the Scoping Plan to identify and make recommendations on direct GHG emissions reduction measures, among other things. Requires ARB to update Scoping Plan at least once every five years. (HSC 38561)
- Authorizes ARB to include in their California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Act) regulations the use of market-based compliance mechanisms to comply with the regulations. (HSC 38570)
- Requires any reduction of GHG emissions used for compliance purposes to be real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional. (HSC 38562(d)(1)-(2))
- Establishes a goal of reducing at least five million metric tons of GHG emissions per year through the development and application of compost on working lands. (Public Resources Code 42649.87)
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2024, the Natural Resources Agency (NRA), in collaboration with ARB, the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA), the Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA), the expert advisory committee, and other relevant state agencies, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based climate solutions that reduce GHGs for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience. Requires these targets to be integrated into the Scoping Plan. (HSC 38561.5 (b)(1))
- Prohibits emissions reduction projects and actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism. (HSC 38561.5 (b)(3)(B))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Need for the bill. According to the author:
Last year, the Legislature passed AB 1757 (C. Garcia and R. Rivas), which required the Natural Resources Agency to determine a range of targets for natural carbon sequestration and for nature-based carbon solutions for GHG reductions. AB 1757 also includes well-intended provisions to ensure any emission reductions work used toward achieving targets is not double-counted and that projects or actions that receive state funding are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based mechanisms. However, the existing law under AB 1757, is overly broad, and could be interpreted to apply to all state funds, not just funds intended for carbon sequestration or GHG emissions reduction. This interpretation has the potential to halt projects that return ancestral lands to tribes because these projects rely on state funds for the acquisition and restoration grants, but also generate carbon sequestration projects.
This bill clarifies that the prohibition established in AB 1757 against generating credits under a market-based compliance mechanism - if a project or activity receives state funds - only applies to actions and projects that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing GHG emissions.
This clarification will allow land managers to seek and receive state acquisition and restoration grants for projects on properties that generate carbon sequestration credits (without the use of state funds) to move forward with legal certainty.
- California’s climate goals. Under the Act, California has adopted GHG reduction targets to reduce GHG emissions to at least 85% below the 1990 level by 2045, and establishes a goal of zero net carbon emissions by 2045.
Under the Act, ARB adopted the cap-and-trade program as a market-based compliance mechanism to establish a declining limit on major sources of GHG emissions throughout California, and ARB creates allowances equal to the total amount of permissible GHG emissions (i.e., the “cap”). Each year, fewer allowances are created and the annual cap declines. Under the program, covered entities can invest in “offsets” – projects that sequester carbon in forests, flooded rice fields, biogas control systems for manure management on dairy cattle and swine farms, and others – to satisfy a small percentage of their overall compliance obligation. Any reduction of GHG emissions used for compliance purposes must be real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional.
- Natural and working lands. Current law defines natural lands as lands consisting of forests, grasslands, deserts, freshwater and riparian systems, wetlands, coastal and estuarine areas, watersheds, wildlands, or wildlife habitat, or lands used for recreational purposes such as parks, urban and community forests, trails, greenbelts, and other similar open-space land. Working lands include lands used for farming, grazing, or the production of forest products. Natural and working lands cover approximately 90% of the state’s 105 million acres, including California Native American tribes’ ancestral and cultural lands and waters.
In response to the Governor’s executive order N-82-20, the state released the draft Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy in 2021, which describes how these lands can deliver on our climate change goals and identifies options to track nature-based climate action and measure progress.
Although natural and working lands can remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it in soil and vegetation, disturbances such as severe wildfire, land degradation, and conversion can cause these landscapes to emit more carbon dioxide than they store.
California’s natural and working lands and the critical ecosystem services they provide, including their ability to sequester carbon from the atmosphere, are at risk. Actions to protect, restore, and sustainably manage the health and resiliency of these lands can greatly accelerate our progress to mitigate climate change and our ability to reduce worsening climate change impacts. Recent research has shown that California's working lands have the ability to sequester up to 100 million metric tons of carbon dioxide per year.
AB 1757 (C. Garcia, R. Rivas, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2022) requires ARB, by January 1, 2024, with NRA, CalEPA, and CDFA, to determine an ambitious range of targets for natural carbon sequestration, and for nature-based climate solutions, that reduce GHGs for 2030, 2038, and 2045 to support state goals to achieve carbon neutrality and foster climate adaptation and resilience.
- Current law impacts on offset eligibility. AB 1757 provides that any emissions reduction project that receives state funding is not eligible to generate credits under cap-and-trade. The intent was to ensure that there is no “double payment” for stored carbon or avoided emissions from natural and working lands projects.
This creates an either/or scenario for project proponents: either receive financial recognition for stored carbon or avoided emissions as an offset project completed under an ARB-approved compliance offset protocol or receive state funding with the primary purpose being to help the state achieve its climate targets developed pursuant to AB 1757.
The author argues that provision effectively prohibits landowners from using state funds, even those that may have a federal origin, to implement ecological land management for the betterment of habitat without jeopardizing their ability to generate carbon offsets.
For example, The Conservation Fund, a national nonprofit organization, since 2004 has owned and managed more than 75,000 acres on California’s north coast. The Conservation Fund’s restoration and progressive management regimes have improved habitat for the endangered Northern Spotted Owl and state-threatened Coho salmon and steelhead trout. Instrumental to the ability of The Conservation Fund to manage these vast forestlands is the revenue generated through the sale of carbon offsets via the cap-and-trade program. In 2022, The Conservation Fund secured more than $900,000 in state grants in partnership with Trout Unlimited and California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the improvement of salmon and trout habitat. With the passage of AB 1757, according to the author, The Conservation Fund must now decline those grants.
ARB issued guidance to interpret how AB 1757 applies to various project. In the context of state funding for sustainable forest management practices or conservation easements projects, ARB explains, “A project receiving compliance offset credits in the Cap-and-Trade Program can still receive State funding for actions that do not have as their primary purpose climate mitigation and increases in quantified stored carbon or avoided GHG emissions.” In addition to its issued guidance, ARB works with offset project registries and third-party verifiers on a case-by-case basis to verify projects are in compliance with AB 1757 before issuing offset credits under the project. The intent with AB 1159 is to be consistent with ARB’s guidance.
It is important to note that the Act explicitly requires any reduction or avoidance of GHG emissions used for market mechanism compliance purposes be additional, amongst other criteria. Meeting the criterion of additional GHG reductions ensures the integrity of the ARB offset credit and its eligibility for use in the cap-and-trade program.
The provision in AB 1757 at the heart of this bill starts with “notwithstanding any other law,” which null and voids the requirement to assess whether the proposed offset provides additional GHG reductions or avoidance. Striking the “notwithstanding” verbiage would restore compliance with the Act under this provision. Further, to be consistent with the Act, but without creating a higher standard, the bill could be amended to require only the eligibility of GHG emissions in addition to those that would otherwise occur for offset compliance.
- Rewording AB 1757. AB 1159 proposes to amend the AB 1757 provision to instead provide that “projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism.”
Many state-funded projects have the intended purpose of restoration or other environmental benefit and have the incidental benefit of GHG reductions. Examples include, but are not limited to, land acquisition for conservation, forest health management or fire prevention projects, or wetland restoration. Landowners of those properties want to maintain the opportunity for offset compliance, which provides a funding source for further land management. Hence, the inclusion of the word “primary” in AB 1159.
However, maintaining the intent of the state’s GHG reduction laws necessitates the need to avoid “double dipping” (getting paid twice for the same GHG reduction project) and “double counting” (counting a project’s GHG reductions twice under different programs or goals).
To achieve that, the language from AB 1757 needs to address the nuances of state-funded projects – specifically, the proportion of those projects funded with state funds for GHG emission reductions so that it is clear that the prohibition is on generating offsets from the project or action the state paid for to reduce GHGs.
- Committee amendments. To make both the intent and interpretation of AB 1757 clearer, the Committee may wish to amend subdivision (B) as follows:
(B) Notwithstanding any other law To ensure that all greenhouse gas emission reductions and removals are in addition to any reductions and removals that would otherwise occur, natural and working lands projects and actions that receive state funding for the primary purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not eligible to generate credits under any market-based compliance mechanism for any greenhouse gas emissions reduced or removed as a result of the state funding.
While these amendments will provide further clarity, the author and stakeholders may need to continue to identify the various permutations of project funding, such as an acquisition project that involves multiple funding sources, including both state funding and offset revenue, to further refine this provision of law to recognize all potential project eligibility.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Hoopa Valley Tribe
Trout Unlimited
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / NAT. RES. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):