AB 1168: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-08-29
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-09-28: Vetoed by Governor.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if specified requirements are met. If a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS was initially executed on or after January 1, 2025, the bill would ensure a city or fire district retains its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS. The bill would set various conditions for a joint powers agreement, including, among other things, requiring uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS throughout the EMS area or subarea covered by the agreement.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require a specified city to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that specified options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if specified requirements are met. If a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS was initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, the bill would ensure a city or fire district retains its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS. The bill would set various conditions for a joint powers agreement, including, among other things, requiring uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS throughout the EMS area or subarea covered by the agreement.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require a specified city to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that specified options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if specified requirements are met. If a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS was initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, the bill would ensure a city or fire district retains its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent to clarify the effect of joint powers agreements regarding prehospital EMS on specified rights, obligations, and authorities, to reduce disruptions to EMS systems, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require a specified city to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that specified options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if specified requirements are met. If a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS was initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, the bill would ensure a city or fire district retains its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent to clarify the effect of joint powers agreements regarding prehospital EMS on specified rights, obligations, and authorities, to reduce disruptions to EMS systems, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require a specified city to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that specified options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district to retain to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if it provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through a joint powers agreement with a county and ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or if it is, as of January 1, 2024, providing prehospital EMS pursuant to statute and enters a joint powers agreement with a county for joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS. specified requirements are met. If a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS was initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, the bill would ensure a city or fire district retains its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent to clarify the effect of joint powers agreements regarding prehospital EMS on specified rights, obligations, and authorities, to reduce disruptions to EMS systems, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, city, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require a specified city or fire district to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that specified options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district that to retain its authorities regarding, and the administration of, prehospital EMS if it provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district provides the prehospital EMS as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, or that EMS through a joint powers agreement with a county and ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or that if it is, as of January 1, 2024, providing prehospital EMS pursuant to statute and enters into an a joint powers agreement with a county for joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, as described, does not make the city or fire district ineligible to contract with a county, as described above, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, to clarify the effect of joint powers agreements regarding prehospital EMS on specified rights, obligations, and authorities, to reduce disruptions to EMS systems, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services. The bill would require the a specified city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that the service options mentioned above specified options are not economically viable. viable, would reduce the level or quality of care in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district that provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district provides the prehospital EMS as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, or that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or that is, as of January 1, 2024, providing prehospital EMS pursuant to statute and enters into an agreement with a county for joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, as described, does not make the city or fire district ineligible to contract with a county, as described above, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis if the designated providers decline to continue services. The bill would require the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that the service options mentioned above are not economically viable. The bill would require the parties developing contracts pursuant to these provisions to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, and would require those standards to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district that provided, as of December 31, 2022, June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district provides the prehospital EMS as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, or that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or that is, as of January 1, 2024, providing prehospital EMS pursuant to statute and enters into an agreement with a county for joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, as described, does not make the city or fire district ineligible to contract with a county, as described above, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis if the designated providers decline to continue services. The bill would require the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that the service options mentioned above are not economically viable. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, December 31, 2022, prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district enters into provides the prehospital EMS as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or that contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to statute. is, as of January 1, 2024, providing prehospital EMS pursuant to statute and enters into an agreement with a county for joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS. The bill would state the Legislatures intent that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, as described, does not make the city or fire district ineligible to contract with a county, as described above, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis if the designated providers decline to continue services. The bill would require the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that the service options mentioned above are not economically viable. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The bill would become operative only if AB 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Existing law, the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act, governs local emergency medical services (EMS) systems and authorizes each county to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency. Existing law requires a county to enter into a written agreement with a city or fire district that contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as of June 1, 1980. Existing law requires, until that written agreement is reached, prehospital EMS to be continued at not less than the existing level and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts contracting for or providing those services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts.
This bill would require a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district enters into an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, as specified, or that contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to statute. The bill would state the Legislatures intent that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, as described, does not make the city or fire district ineligible to contract with a county, as described above, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, and to abrogate contrary judicial holdings.
Existing law defines exclusive operating area as an EMS area or subarea defined by the emergency medical services plan for which a local EMS agency, upon the recommendation of a county, restricts operations to one or more emergency ambulance services or providers, as specified. Existing law authorizes a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan.
This bill would require the local EMS agency, if a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area as mentioned above, to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which would be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process. The bill would authorize the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, as specified, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis if the designated providers decline to continue services. The bill would require the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified, if the county determines that the service options mentioned above are not economically viable. By creating new duties for local EMS agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law establishes the California Transportation Commission and vests the commission with certain powers, purposes, and responsibilities.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.Existing law establishes the California Transportation Commission and vests the commission with certain powers, purposes, and responsibilities.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
(a)Notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) ambulance services within the citys territorial jurisdiction pursuant to Section 1797.201, only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1)The city became a party to a joint powers agreement regarding ambulance services before the enactment of this chapter.
(2)The joint powers agreement provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the joint powers agreement.
(3)On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the joint powers agreement, effective July 1, 2021.
(4)The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
(b)(1)A joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2025, between a county board of supervisors and a city or fire district, shall not be construed as a written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital emergency medical services for that city or fire district within the meaning of Section 1797.201, and the city or fire district shall retain its existing administration of the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement.
(2)The following shall apply to a joint powers agreement developed pursuant to paragraph (1):
(A)The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement.
(B)The joint powers agreement shall provide, and the parties to the agreement shall be subject to, uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS throughout the EMS area or subarea covered by the agreement.
(C)Prehospital EMS under the joint powers agreement shall be subject to, and comply with, EMS system requirements and local EMS agency policies, procedures, and protocols, including, but not limited to, data collection and evaluation.
(D)The local EMS agency shall coordinate with the county and the city or fire district in the development of the joint powers agreement and shall monitor performance of prehospital EMS under the agreement.
(E)The entry into a joint powers agreement as described in this subdivision shall not alter, modify, abridge, diminish, create, or enlarge any rights, authorities, or obligations by any party to the joint powers agreement or any third party, including, but not limited to, any rights, authorities, or obligations pursuant to Section 1797.201, 1797.224, or 1798.
(c)If a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Section 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Section 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city specified in subdivision (a), unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)(A)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231, and, to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce.
(B)If the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization or official representative, the contractor shall do both of the following:
(i)Meet with the incumbent workforces recognized employee organization or official representative to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce.
(ii)Request and review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region.
(C)Prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor developed pursuant to this subdivision, the contractor shall certify compliance with this paragraph.
(D)For the purposes of this paragraph, contractor means the designated provider or providers under paragraph (1), a county fire department or other county department created for these purposes pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2), a provider selected to serve a new exclusive operating area consistent with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), or the city described in paragraph (3).
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) ambulance services within the citys territorial jurisdiction pursuant to Section 1797.201, only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1)The city became a party to a joint powers agreement regarding ambulance services before the enactment of this chapter.
(2)The joint powers agreement provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the joint powers agreement.
(3)On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the joint powers agreement, effective July 1, 2021.
(4)The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
(b)(1)A joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, between a county board of supervisors and a city or fire district, shall not be construed as a written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital emergency medical services for that city or fire district within the meaning of Section 1797.201, and the city or fire district shall retain its existing authorities regarding, and administration of, of the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement. The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
(2)The following shall apply to a joint powers agreement developed pursuant to paragraph (1):
(A)The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement.
(B)The joint powers agreement shall provide, and the parties to the agreement shall be subject to, uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS throughout the EMS area or subarea covered by the agreement.
(C)Prehospital EMS under the joint powers agreement shall be subject to, and comply with, EMS system requirements and local EMS agency policies, procedures, and protocols, including, but not limited to, data collection and evaluation.
(D)The local EMS agency shall coordinate with the county and the city or fire district in the development of the joint powers agreement and shall monitor performance of prehospital EMS under the agreement.
(E)The entry into a joint powers agreement as described in this subdivision shall not alter, modify, abridge, diminish, create, or enlarge any rights, authorities, or obligations by any party to the joint powers agreement or any third party, including, but not limited to, any rights, authorities, or obligations pursuant to Section 1797.201, 1797.224, or 1798.
(c)If a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections Section 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections Section 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city specified in subdivision (a), unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)(A)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231, and, to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce.
(B)If the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization or official representative, the contractor shall do both of the following:
(i)Meet with the incumbent workforces recognized employee organization or official representative to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce.
(ii)Request and review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region.
(C)Prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor developed pursuant to this subdivision, the contractor shall certify compliance with this paragraph.
(D)For the purposes of this paragraph, contractor means the designated provider or providers under paragraph (1), a county fire department or other county department created for these purposes pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2), a provider selected to serve a new exclusive operating area consistent with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), or the city described in paragraph (3).
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.(a)Notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS emergency medical services (EMS) ambulance services within the citys territorial jurisdiction pursuant to Section 1797.201, only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1)The city became a party to a joint powers agreement regarding ambulance services before the enactment of this chapter.
(2)The joint powers agreement provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the joint powers agreement.
(3)On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the joint powers agreement, effective July 1, 2021.
(4)The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
(b)A joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, between a county and a city or fire district, shall not be construed as a written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital emergency medical services for that city or fire district within the meaning of Section 1797.201, and the city or fire district shall retain its existing authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement. The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
(c)If a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city specified in subdivision (a), unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)(A)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231, and, to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce.
(B)If the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization or official representative, the contractor shall do both of the following:
(i)Meet with the incumbent workforces recognized employee organization or official representative to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce.
(ii)Request and review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region.
(C)Prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor developed pursuant to this subdivision, the contractor shall certify compliance with this paragraph.
(D)For the purposes of this paragraph, contractor means the designated provider or providers under paragraph (1), a county fire department or other county department created for these purposes pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2), a provider selected to serve a new exclusive operating area consistent with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), or the city described in paragraph (3).
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments within county or regional EMS systems in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010 has created confusion and concern among the states local governments regarding the utility and desirability of entering into joint powers arrangements for EMS purposes because the decision held, in part, that a city was ineligible for, and did not have the right to administer emergency ambulance services within its territorial jurisdiction under, Section 1797.201 because the city delegated to a county the administration of those services through a joint exercise of powers agreement, which the parties had entered into nearly a decade before the enactment of this chapter.
(e)In enacting Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code, 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the effect of agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code on the rights, obligations, and authorities of counties, local EMS agencies, cities, fire districts, and EMS providers under the EMS act and to preserve the utility and desirability of those agreements for EMS purposes.
(f)This section and Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code 1797.232 do not authorize the substantial impairment of contractual obligations of an agreement to provide services within an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 and 1797.224 of the Health and Safety Code. 1797.224.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)Notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the citys territorial jurisdiction pursuant to Section 1797.201, only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1)The city became a party to a joint powers agreement regarding ambulance services before the enactment of this chapter.
(2)The joint powers agreement provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the joint powers agreement.
(3)On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the joint powers agreement, effective July 1, 2021.
(4)The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
(b)A joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, between a county and a city or fire district, shall not be construed as a written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital emergency medical services for that city or fire district within the meaning of Section 1797.201, and the city or fire district shall retain its existing authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement. The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
(c)If a citys assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city specified in subdivision (a), unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)(A)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231. 1797.231, and, to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce.
(B)If the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization or official representative, the contractor shall do both of the following:
(i)Meet with the incumbent workforces recognized employee organization or official representative to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce.
(ii)Request and review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region.
(C)Prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor developed pursuant to this subdivision, the contractor shall certify compliance with this paragraph.
(D)For the purposes of this paragraph, contractor means the designated provider or providers under paragraph (1), a county fire department or other county department created for these purposes pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2), a provider selected to serve a new exclusive operating area consistent with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), or the city described in paragraph (3).
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments within county or regional EMS systems in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 of the Health and Safety Code has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.(d)City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010 has created confusion and concern among the states local governments regarding the utility and desirability of entering into joint powers arrangements for EMS purposes because the decision held, in part, that a city was ineligible for, and did not have the right to administer emergency ambulance services within its territorial jurisdiction under, Section 1797.201 because the city delegated to a county the administration of those services through a joint exercise of powers agreement, which the parties had entered into nearly a decade before the enactment of this chapter.
(e)In enacting Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the effect of agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code on the rights, obligations, and authorities of counties, local EMS agencies, cities, fire districts, and EMS providers under the EMS act and to preserve the utility and desirability of those agreements for EMS purposes, to reduce resulting disruptions to existing county and regional EMS systems, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010. purposes.
(f)This section and Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code do not authorize the substantial impairment of contractual obligations of an agreement to provide services within an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 and 1797.224 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through a joint powers agreement with a county that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, on or before December 31, 2022, shall retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.(b)A city or fire district that is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to Section 1797.201 and enters a1797.232.(a)Notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the citys territorial jurisdiction pursuant to Section 1797.201, only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1)The city became a party to a joint powers agreement regarding ambulance services before the enactment of this chapter.
(2)The joint powers agreement provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the joint powers agreement.
(3)On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the joint powers agreement, effective July 1, 2021.
(4)The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
(b)A joint powers agreement with a county regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, between a county and a city or fire district, shall not be construed as a written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital emergency medical services for that city or fire district within the meaning of Section 1797.201, and the city or fire district shall retain its existing authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201. 1797.201, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement. The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
(c)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating agency area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised composed of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, city, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city or fire district specified in subdivision (a), unless that city or fire district is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city or fire district specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231.
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city or fire district specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city or fire district. city.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments within county or regional EMS systems in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 of the Health and Safety Code has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)In enacting this section and Section 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, under Section 1797.201,(e)In enacting Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the effect of agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code on the rights, obligations, and authorities of counties, local EMS agencies, cities, fire districts, and EMS providers under the EMS act to preserve the utility and desirability of those agreements for EMS purposes, to reduce resulting disruptions to existing county and regional EMS systems, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010.
(f)This section and Section 1797.232 of the Health and Safety Code do not authorize the substantial impairment of contractual obligations of an agreement to provide services within an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 and 1797.224 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.(b)1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an a joint powers agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, on or before December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(c)(b)A city or fire district that is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to Section 1797.201 may enter an and enters a joint powers agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS and shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201. The joint powers agreement shall provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
(d)(c)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating agency by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options: doing one of the following:
(A)Creating a separate county department to provide such services.(B)(A)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department. department or a separate county department created for those purposes.
(C)Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under subdivision (a) or (c), to provide such services.(D)Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.(B)Creating a new exclusive operating area, which shall encompass, at minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process under Section 1797.224. The exclusive operating area shall not include the city or fire district specified in subdivision (a), unless that city or fire district is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process.
(3)If the county determines that the service options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the countys best interests, then the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section specified in subdivision (a) shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(6)A contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed pursuant to this subdivision shall comply with the requirements of subdivisions (c) and (d) of Section 1797.230 and subdivisions (b), (c), and (d) of Section 1797.231.
(7)If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the city or fire district specified in subdivision (a) shall provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in paragraphs (2) to (5), inclusive, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city or fire district.
(d)For purposes of this section, joint powers agreement means an agreement for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)In enacting this section and Section 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, under Section 1797.201, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(b)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, on December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(c)A city or fire district that is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to Section 1797.201 may enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS and shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(d)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
(A)Creating a separate county department to provide such services.
(B)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department.
(C)Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under subdivision (a) or (c), to provide such services.
(D)Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
(3)If the county determines that the service options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, then the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e)of (e) of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(4)In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision, the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(5)Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include the local EMS agencys EMS system requirements and the response time standards from paragraph (4).
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
(f)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agencys ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)In enacting this section and Section 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, under Section 1797.201, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that provided, as of December 31, 2022, June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS, EMS entered into on or before December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(b)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, on December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(c)A city or fire district that is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to Section 1797.201 may enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS and shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(d)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
(A)Creating a separate county department to provide such services.
(B)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department.
(C)Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under subdivision (a) or (c), to provide such services.
(D)Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
(3)If the county determines that the service options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, then the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e)of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)In enacting this section and Section 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, under Section 1797.201, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, December 31, 2022, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) and enters as part of an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(b)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, on December 31, 2022, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(c)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, which contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to statute is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to Section 1797.201 may enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS and shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(d)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
(A)Creating a separate county department to provide such services.
(B)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department.
(C)Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under subdivision (a) or (c), to provide such services.
(D)Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
(3)If the county determines that the service options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, then the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e)of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.This act shall become operative only if Assembly Bill 716 of the 202324 Regular Session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Local governments provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) is a matter of public safety and critical to the public peace, health, and safety of the State of California. Recognizing that the states communities have diverse needs and resources, local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition in California that the Legislature intends to retain.
(b)This division is designed to encourage coordination and planning among local governments in order to achieve the most effective prehospital EMS on a countywide or regionwide basis.
(c)One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regionwide EMS and leverage their combined resources to carry out their prescribed functions under this division is through agreements for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(d)Achievement of the foregoing policies and the policies set forth in Sections 1797.1, 1797.2, 1797.5, and 1797.6 has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question, by the holding of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise its statutory rights and obligations under, Section 1797.201 following the citys entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(e)In enacting this section and Section 1797.232, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a citys or fire districts entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that citys or fire districts authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, under Section 1797.201, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010.
SEC. 2.Section 1797.232 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1797.232.(a)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) and enters an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code regarding prehospital EMS, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(b)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 6500) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(c)A city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, which contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to statute shall be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201.
(d)If a citys or fire districts assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section causes a local EMS area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The local EMS agency shall provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating areas designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which shall be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process under Sections 1797.85 or 1797.224.
(2)If the designated providers decline to continue services under paragraph (1), the county may provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
(A)Creating a separate county department to provide such services.
(B)Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department.
(C)Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under subdivision (a) or (c), to provide such services.
(D)Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
(3)If the county determines that the service options in paragraph (2) are not economically viable, then the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to Section 1797.201 under subdivision (a) or (b) of this section shall enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with subdivision (e)of Section 14136 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(e)This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency granted under this division, including, but not limited to, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1798).
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 70 of the Streets and Highways Code is amended to read:70.(a)The California Highway Commission is hereby abolished, and the California Transportation Commission succeeds to, and is vested with, all the duties, powers, purposes, responsibilities, and jurisdiction of the California Highway Commission.(b)A reference in any law or regulation to the California Highway Commission shall be deemed to refer to the California Transportation Commission.(c)The California Transportation Commission shall have the possession and control of all licenses, permits, leases, agreements, contracts, orders, claims, judgments, records, papers, equipment, supplies, bonds, moneys, funds, appropriations, buildings, land, and other property, real or personal, held for the benefit, use, or obligation of the California Highway Commission.(a)The California Highway Commission is hereby abolished, and the California Transportation Commission succeeds to, and is vested with, all the duties, powers, purposes, responsibilities, and jurisdiction of the California Highway Commission.
(b)Any A reference in any law or regulation to the California Highway Commission shall be deemed to refer to the California Transportation Commission.
(c)The California Transportation Commission shall have the possession and control of all licenses, permits, leases, agreements, contracts, orders, claims, judgments, records, papers, equipment, supplies, bonds, moneys, funds, appropriations, buildings, land land, and other property, real or personal, held for the benefit, use, or obligation of the California Highway Commission.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 28, 2024 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 5, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 69. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 28 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 32. Noes 2.). |
| Aug 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 13, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2024 | Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 12, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Limón. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (September 1). |
| Aug 14, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 12). |
| Jul 5, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 28). |
| Jun 7, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and GOV. & F. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 72. Noes 2. Page 1902.) |
| May 26, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1850.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 2.) (May 18). |
| May 18, 2023 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1580.) |
| May 17, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 2, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 26). |
| Apr 20, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on E.M. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on E.M. |
| Apr 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on E.M. (Ayes 12. Noes 1.) (April 11). |
| Mar 20, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and E.M. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27, 2024 | AB 1168 Bennett Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1168 Bennett By Limón | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | AB 1168 Bennett Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Emergency Management |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Emergency Management] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 911 Ambulance Provider's Medi-Cal Alliance | ** Support | |
| Alameda Fire Department | ** Support | |
| Ambulance Association of Orange County | ** Against | |
| American Ambulance | ** Against | |
| American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees, Afl-Cio | ** Against | |
| American Medical Response West | ** Against | |
| Association of California Healthcare Districts | ** Against | |
| Association Of California Healthcare Districts The | ** Against | |
| Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service | ** Against | |
| Board of Supervisors County of Tuolumne | ** Against | |
| Butte County Administration | ** Against | |
| California Ambulance Association | ** Against | |
| California Fire Chiefs Association | ** Support | |
| California Professional Firefighters | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Against | |
| Calstar Air Medical Services | ** Against | |
| City of Hanford Fire Departments | ** Support | |
| City of Oceanside | ** Support | |
| City of Oxnard | ** Support | |
| City of San Marcos | ** Support | |
| City of Santa Rosa | ** Support | |
| City of Ukiah | ** Support | |
| Clovis Fire Department | ** Support | |
| County Health Executives Association Of California | ** Against | |
| County of Alameda Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Butte Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Contra Costa Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Fresno Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Kern Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Kings Department of Public Health | ** Against | |
| County of Lassen Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County Of Madera | ** Against | |
| County of Mariposa Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Merced Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Modoc Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Monterey Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Napa Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| county of nevada board of supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Orange | ** Against | |
| County Of Orange Board Of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| county of placer board of supervisors | ** Against | |
| County Of Plumas | ** Against | |
| County of Plumas Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Sacramento Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of San Bernardino | ** Against | |
| County of San Bernardino County Administrative Office | ** Against | |
| County of San Mateo Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Shasta Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County Of Solano, Board Of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Trinity Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Tulare Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| county of tuolumne board of supervisors | ** Against | |
| County of Ventura | ** Against | |
| County of Yolo | ** Against | |
| County of Yolo Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Covalent Health | ** Against | |
| Desert Ambulance Service, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Emergency Medical Service Administrators Association of California | ** Against | |
| EMS Medical Directors Association of California | ** Against | |
| Fire Districts Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Gold Coast Health Plan | ** Against | |
| Health Officers Association Of California | ** Against | |
| International Association of EMTs and Paramedics | ** Against | |
| League Of California Cities | ** Support | |
| LifeWest Ambulance | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles County Ambulance Association | ** Against | |
| MaxCare Ambulance | ** Against | |
| Medic Ambulance | ** Against | |
| North Coast EMS | ** Against | |
| Northern California Ems, INC. | ** Against | |
| Opposition | ** Against | |
| Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684 | ** Support | |
| Plumas County | ** Against | |
| Riggs Ambulance | ** Against | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Against | |
| Sanger Fire Department | ** Support | |
| San Joaquin County Emergency Medical Services Agency | ** Against | |
| Sierra County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency | ** Against | |
| Southern Marin Fire Protection District | ** Support | |
| Trinity County Board Of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Tuolumne County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Urban Counties of California | ** Against | |
| Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431 | ** Support | |
| Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364 | ** Support |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett)
As Enrolled Ver:August 29, 2024
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Requires the City of Oxnard to be treated as if it had retained the right to administer or contract for prehospital ambulance emergency medical services (EMS) notwithstanding a court case that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services. Establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if it withdraws from the JPA.
Senate Amendments
- Specify that entry into a JPA does not alter, modify, abridge, diminish, create, or enlarge any rights, authorities, or obligation by any party to the JPA, or any third party;
- Clarify that the requirement for uniform operating procedures within a county applies only to the parties to the agreement; and,
- Delete a reference to existing law regarding the effect on exclusive operating areas in order to clarify that this bill is not intended to disrupt the makeup, or process for creating, operating areas.
Governor’s Veto Message
This bill would allow the City of Oxnard to function as if it had retained its administrative authority to operate prehospital emergency medical ambulance services and authorize Oxnard to exclusively operate ambulance services throughout the city. This would bypass a 2021 court ruling that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services.
Current law establishes a statewide emergency medical services (EMS) response system to provide integrated services statewide with regional coordination. This bill risks inconsistency in EMS delivery and could compromise the uniformity of EMS operations by authorizing a single city to bypass existing regional agreements. I agree with the author and sponsors that ensuring equitable, efficient, and quality access to emergency care is a state priority. However, this bill would create a unique operational model in Ventura County that is different from the law applicable in the other 57 counties. Though this bill is narrow, I am concerned that it will set a precedent for other cities to pursue similar legislation in the future, further fragmenting the EMS system.
COMMENTS
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional local emergency medical services areas (LEMSAs). California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The Emergency Medical Services Act (EMS Act) comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the EMS Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health & Safety Code (HSC) §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as "201 rights," was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act's potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district "until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts..." Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required "Section 201" cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) (Oxnard). In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county's authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: a) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; b) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; c) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, d) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of the county if/when the City of Oxnard re-asserts their "201" rights.
According to the Author
The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or "201" rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows Oxnard, to regain their right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS services, this bill contains a "failsafe" provisions that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, while the County decides whether or not it wants to continue providing services outside the city. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
Arguments in Support
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today's EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area.
Arguments in Opposition
The Health Officers Association of California (HOAC), is opposed to this bill and states that counties are required by the EMS Act to create a local EMS system that is timely, safe, and equitable for all residents. To do so, counties honor .201 authorities and contract with both public and private agencies to ensure coverage of underserved areas regardless of the challenges inherent in providing uniform services throughout geographically diverse areas. HOAC states that this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action that attempted to argue an agency’s .201 authorities – that is, the regulation that allows eligible city and fire districts which have continuously served a defined area since the 1980 EMS Act to administer EMS including providing their own or contracted non-exclusive ambulance service. In the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, the court determined that their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissibly broaden Health and Safety Code section 1797.201’s exception in a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermine the purposes of the EMS Act.”
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, EMSA estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation. Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 12-1-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Weber
NO: Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Villapudua
ASM EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Rodriguez, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Calderon, Schiavo
NO: Megan Dahle
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-2-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2-6
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Essayli, Friedman, Gallagher, Mathis, Jim Patterson
SENATE FLOOR: 33-2-5
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Blakespear, Caballero, Cortese, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Dahle, Niello
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Becker, Bradford, Dodd, Grove
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-0-10
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Flora, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Gallagher, Lackey, Mathis, Ortega, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: August 29, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0005142
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the City of Oxnard to be treated as if it had retained the right to administer or contract for prehospital ambulance emergency medical services (EMS) notwithstanding a court case that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services. Establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if it withdraws from the JPA.
Senate Amendments
- Specify that entry into a JPA does not alter, modify, abridge, diminish, create, or enlarge any rights, authorities, or obligation by any party to the JPA, or any third party;
- Clarify that the requirement for uniform operating procedures within a county applies only to the parties to the agreement; and,
- Delete a reference to existing law regarding the effect on exclusive operating areas in order to clarify that this bill is not intended to disrupt the makeup, or process for creating, operating areas.
COMMENTS
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional local emergency medical services areas (LEMSAs). California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The Emergency Medical Services Act (EMS Act) comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the EMS Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health & Safety Code (HSC) §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as "201 rights," was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act's potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district "until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts..." Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required "Section 201" cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) (Oxnard). In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county's authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- Inequities in service? According to information supplied by the author, a study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas consistently had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. Specifically, the study evaluated ambulances from time of assignment to time arriving on scene using two different thresholds for priority (anything over eight minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards) and non-priority calls (anything over 15 minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards). Oxnard Fire Department then combined this with data from the US Department of Urban Development regarding Low and Moderate Income (LMI) residents. Their analysis found that areas with a population of LMI residents over 50% had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulances (4,373) compared to areas with areas with a population of LMI residents that was less than 50% (2,270).
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: a) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; b) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; c) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, d) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of the county if/when the City of Oxnard re-asserts their "201" rights.
According to the Author
The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or "201" rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows Oxnard, to regain their right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS services, this bill contains a "failsafe" provisions that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, while the County decides whether or not it wants to continue providing services outside the city. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
Arguments in Support
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today's EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. CPF states that this has left Oxnard unable to address the systemic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services.
Arguments in Opposition
The Health Officers Association of California (HOAC), is opposed to this bill and states that counties are required by the EMS Act to create a local EMS system that is timely, safe, and equitable for all residents. To do so, counties honor .201 authorities and contract with both public and private agencies to ensure coverage of underserved areas regardless of the challenges inherent in providing uniform services throughout geographically diverse areas. HOAC states that this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action that attempted to argue an agency’s .201 authorities – that is, the regulation that allows eligible city and fire districts which have continuously served a defined area since the 1980 EMS Act to administer EMS including providing their own or contracted non-exclusive ambulance service. In the case of the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, the court determined that their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissibly broaden Health and Safety Code section 1797.201’s exception in a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermine the purposes of the EMS Act.”
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, EMSA estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation.
Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 12-1-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Weber
NO: Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Villapudua
ASM EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Rodriguez, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Calderon, Schiavo
NO: Megan Dahle
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-2-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2-6
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Essayli, Friedman, Gallagher, Mathis, Jim Patterson
SENATE FLOOR: 33-2-5
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Blakespear, Caballero, Cortese, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Dahle, Niello
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Becker, Bradford, Dodd, Grove
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004273
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the City of Oxnard to be treated as if it had retained the right to administer or contract for prehospital ambulance emergency medical services (EMS) notwithstanding a court case that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services. Establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if it withdraws from the JPA.
Senate Amendments
- Specify that entry into a JPA does not alter, modify, abridge, diminish, create, or enlarge any rights, authorities, or obligation by any party to the JPA, or any third party;
- Clarify that the requirement for uniform operating procedures within a county applies only to the parties to the agreement; and,
- Delete a reference to existing law regarding the effect on exclusive operating areas in order to clarify that this bill is not intended to disrupt the makeup, or process for creating, operating areas.
COMMENTS
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional local emergency medical services areas (LEMSAs). California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The Emergency Medical Services Act (EMS Act) comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the EMS Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health & Safety Code (HSC) §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as "201 rights," was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act's potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district "until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts..." Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required "Section 201" cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) (Oxnard). In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county's authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- Inequities in service? According to information supplied by the author, a study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas consistently had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. Specifically, the study evaluated ambulances from time of assignment to time arriving on scene using two different thresholds for priority (anything over eight minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards) and non-priority calls (anything over 15 minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards). Oxnard Fire Department then combined this with data from the US Department of Urban Development regarding Low and Moderate Income (LMI) residents. Their analysis found that areas with a population of LMI residents over 50% had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulances (4,373) compared to areas with areas with a population of LMI residents that was less than 50% (2,270).
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: a) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; b) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; c) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, d) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of the county if/when the City of Oxnard re-asserts their "201" rights.
According to the Author
The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or "201" rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows Oxnard, to regain their right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS services, this bill contains a "failsafe" provisions that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, while the County decides whether or not it wants to continue providing services outside the city. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
Arguments in Support
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today's EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. CPF states that this has left Oxnard unable to address the systemic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services.
Arguments in Opposition
The Health Officers Association of California (HOAC), is opposed to this bill and states that counties are required by the EMS Act to create a local EMS system that is timely, safe, and equitable for all residents. To do so, counties honor .201 authorities and contract with both public and private agencies to ensure coverage of underserved areas regardless of the challenges inherent in providing uniform services throughout geographically diverse areas. HOAC states that this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action that attempted to argue an agency’s .201 authorities – that is, the regulation that allows eligible city and fire districts which have continuously served a defined area since the 1980 EMS Act to administer EMS including providing their own or contracted non-exclusive ambulance service. In the case of the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, the court determined that their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissibly broaden Health and Safety Code section 1797.201’s exception in a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermine the purposes of the EMS Act.”
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, EMSA estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation.
Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 12-1-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Weber
NO: Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Villapudua
ASM EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Rodriguez, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Calderon, Schiavo
NO: Megan Dahle
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-2-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2-6
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Essayli, Friedman, Gallagher, Mathis, Jim Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004273
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1168 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1168
Author: Bennett (D)
Amended: 8/19/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 10-0, 6/28/23
AYES: Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Roth, Rubio, Wahab, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/12/23
AYES: Caballero, Seyarto, Blakespear, Durazo, Glazer, Skinner, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Dahle
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2, 5/30/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
SOURCE: League of California Cities
DIGEST:
This bill requires the City of Oxnard to be treated as if it had retained the right to administer or contract for prehospital ambulance EMS notwithstanding a court case that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services, establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if it withdraws from the JPA.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/19/24 delete language stating that, for purposes of JPAs between counties and cities or fire districts, a city or fire district retains its “existing authorities regarding” prehospital EMS, so that the bill only refers to the city or fire district retaining its “existing administration of” prehospital EMS. Additionally, floor amendments added requirements to JPAs regarding prehospital EMS between a county and a city or fire district, including requiring the JPA to provide uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS, and require prehospital EMS under the JPA to be subject to EMS system requirements and local EMS agency policies and procedures.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for EMS, and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1797, et seq.]
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. [HSC §1797.200, et seq.]
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. [HSC §1797.201]
- Permits a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if the local EMS agency develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. [HSC §1797.224]
- Permits a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that will provide those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service; and permits a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for the purpose of contracting with a county. [HSC §1797.230, §1797.231]
- Requires, when a fire agency is contracting with a county to provide emergency ambulance services through a subcontract with a private ambulance service, the written subcontract with the private ambulance service to be awarded pursuant to a competitive bidding process, and to set forth issues to be considered during the competitive bidding process, including whether safeguards are in place to prevent an entity submitting a bid from participating in the deliberations of the fire agency awarding the subcontract. [HSC §1797.231(b)]
This bill:
- Requires a city, notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the city’s territorial jurisdiction under a specified provision of law known as “201 rights,” only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
- The city became party to a joint powers agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services before the enactment of the EMS Act;
- The JPA provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the JPA;
- On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the JPA, effective July 1, 2021; and,
- The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
- Prohibits a JPA regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2025, between a county and a city or fire district, from being construed as a “written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital EMS for that city or fire district” within the meaning of the provision of law governing 201 rights, and requires the city or fire district to retain its existing administration of the prehospital EMS pursuant to 201 rights, if any, following entry into the JPA.
- Requires the following to apply to a JPA developed pursuant to 2) above:
- Requires the JPA to provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement;
- Requires the JPA to provide, and the parties to the agreement to be subject to, uniform operational procedures for prehospital EMS throughout the EMS area or subarea covered by the agreement;
- Requires prehospital EMS under the JPA to be subject to, and comply with, EMS system requirements and local EMS agency policies, procedures, and protocols, including data collection and evaluation;
- Requires the local EMS agency to coordinate with the county and the city or fire district in the development of the JPA and to monitor performance of prehospital EMS under the agreement; and,
- Prohibits the entry into a JPA from altering, modifying, abridging, creating, or enlarging any rights, authorities, or obligations by any party to the JPA or any third party, including any 201 rights or rights under other provisions of existing law.
- Establishes a process for what happens if a city asserts its 201 rights pursuant to 1) above and it causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, as follows:
- Requires the local EMS agency to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which is required to be deemed an exclusive operating area created with a competitive process, as specified;
- Permits the county, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph a) above, to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
- Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes; or,
- Creating a new exclusive operating area, which is required to encompass, at a minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process, as specified under existing law. Prohibits the exclusive operating are from including the city specified in 1) above, unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process;
- If the county determines that the options in b) above are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the county’s best interests, requires the city specified in 1) above to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with provisions of law permitting a county to authorize a sole franchise to provide emergency medical transport, as specified;
- Requires contracting parties, in developing contracts under this bill, to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which are required to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area;
- Requires contracts developed under this bill to include the local EMS agency’s EMS system requirements and the response time standards;
- Requires a contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed under this bill to comply with specified provisions of existing law governing the contracting process for emergency ambulance services, and governing the subcontracting process when fire agencies subcontract ambulance services to a private ambulance service, as specified, and to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce;
- Requires the contractor, when the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization, to meet with the incumbent workforce’s recognized organization to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce, and to request a review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region. Requires the contractor to certify compliance with this paragraph prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor; and,
- Requires the city or fire district specified in 1) above, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under a) above, to provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in b) to e) above, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city or fire district.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agency’s ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201 rights.” Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in my district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. This bill permits Oxnard to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption this bill also contains a failsafe that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. Finally, this bill clarifies that entities retain their 201 rights when joining a JPA, unless they explicitly give up those rights. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they join a JPA.
- “201 rights.” Health and Safety Code §1797.201, generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to passage of the EMS Act. This section was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 1797.201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts….” Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the local EMS agency medical director.
- County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of a legal battle, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and the San Bernardino County. The court case involved, among other things, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three questions: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until they enter into an agreement with a local EMS agency to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the local EMS agency. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the local EMS agency to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021). In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the County, entered into a JPA regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the County established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is in Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider. According to the court, in the 2010s, the City of Oxnard grew dissatisfied with the provision of ambulance services by Gold Coast Ambulance, determining that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses than residents in more affluent areas, among other complaints. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the County of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the County not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the County from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained its 201 rights because it was indirectly contracting for those services as part of the JPA when the EMS Act was adopted. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. Among other points, Oxnard argued that because the statute does not specifically require the city to be “directly” contracting for services to have 201 rights, the court should not “insert what has been omitted.” However, the court, citing precedent, stated that 201 rights permit a city only to “continue to do what it had been doing as of June 1, 1980,” not “resume what it had ceased to do.” The court stated that in this case, Oxnard “ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971.” Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County’s consent. The appellate court’s judgment was entered on April 30, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/15/24)
League of California Cities (source)
Alameda Fire Department
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
City of Oceanside
City of San Marcos
City of Ukiah
Clovis Fire Department
Fire Districts Association of California
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Sanger Fire Department
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/15/24)
Ambulance Association of Orange County
American Ambulance
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service
California Ambulance Association
California State Association of Counties
CALSTAR Air Medical Services
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Alameda Board of Supervisors
County of Butte Board of Supervisors
County of Contra Costa Board of Supervisors
County of Fresno Board of Supervisors
County of Kern Board of Supervisors
County of Kings Department of Public Health
County of Lassen Board of Supervisors
County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors
County of Orange Board of Supervisors
County of Madera
County of Mariposa Board of Supervisors
County of Merced Board of Supervisors
County of Modoc Board of Supervisors
County of Monterey Board of Supervisors
County of Napa Board of Supervisors
County of Nevada Board of Supervisors
County of Placer Board of Supervisors
County of Plumas Board of Supervisors
County of Sacramento Board of Supervisors
County of San Bernardino County Administrative Office
County of San Mateo Board of Supervisors
County of Shasta Board of Supervisors
County of Solano Board of Supervisors
County of Trinity Board of Supervisors
County of Tulare Board of Supervisors
County of Tuolumne Board of Supervisors
County of Ventura
County of Yolo Board of Supervisors
Covalent Health
Desert Ambulance Service, INC.
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California
EMS Medical Directors Association of California
Gold Coast Health Plan
Health Officers Association of California
International Association of EMTs and Paramedics
Lifewest Ambulance
Los Angeles County Ambulance Association
MaxCare Ambulance
Medic Ambulance
Northern California EMS, INC.
Rural County Representatives of California
Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency
Urban Counties of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the League of California Cities (League) to clarify a city or fire district’s right to retain its authority over emergency ambulance services if a city or fire district enters into a JPA agreement with a county for emergency ambulance services. According to the League, the need for local control when the EMS Act was created was explicitly recognized in the Act with the inclusion of 201 rights. Unfortunately, the League states that 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA. The League states that the findings in the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura call into question any future efforts to enter into a JPA to provide ambulance services for fire agencies that currently have 201 rights for fear that those rights will be lost, even though an agency is working to provide the best service to the residents in the immediate and surrounding area. The California Professional Firefights, along with the local affiliates of the International Association of Fire Fighters representing firefighters in Oxnard, the City of Ventura, and Ventura County, make similar arguments in support, stating that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of providing efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of 201 rights, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over these services. The finding in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura has left Oxnard unable to address the systematic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services. Signatories to JPA agreements should not lose their 201 rights because they cooperated with other public agencies to provide better services to residents.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, the County Health Executives Association of California, and the Health Officers Association of California, submitted a joint letter of opposition. These groups state that this bill seeks to overturn an extensive statutory and case law record that has repeatedly affirmed county responsibility for the administration of EMS and with that, the flexibility to design systems to equitably serve residents throughout their jurisdiction. These groups state this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action where the court determined their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissibly broaden Health and Safety Code Section 1797.201’s exception in such a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermined the purposes of the EMS Act.” This abrogation of Oxnard v. County of Ventura could have significant implications on how EMS is structured today. The EMS Administrators Association of California, the EMS Medical Directors Association of California, numerous individual counties, and other groups make similar arguments in opposition.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2, 5/30/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Megan Dahle, Vince Fong
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Essayli, Friedman, Gallagher, Mathis, Jim Patterson
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/20/24 17:20:33
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1168 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1168
Author: Bennett (D)
Amended: 7/13/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 10-0, 6/28/23
AYES: Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Roth, Rubio, Wahab, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/12/23
AYES: Caballero, Seyarto, Blakespear, Durazo, Glazer, Skinner, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Dahle
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2, 5/30/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
SOURCE: League of California Cities
DIGEST:
This bill requires the City of Oxnard to be treated as if it had retained the right to administer or contract for prehospital ambulance EMS notwithstanding a court case that found that the City of Oxnard did not have the right to administer ambulance services, establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if it withdraws from the JPA.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for EMS, and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. [HSC §1797, et seq.]
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. [HSC §1797.200, et seq.]
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. [HSC §1797.201]
- Permits a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if the local EMS agency develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. [HSC §1797.224]
- Permits a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that will provide those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service; and permits a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for the purpose of contracting with a county. [HSC §1797.230, §1797.231]
- Requires, when a fire agency is contracting with a county to provide emergency ambulance services through a subcontract with a private ambulance service, the written subcontract with the private ambulance service to be awarded pursuant to a competitive bidding process, and to set forth issues to be considered during the competitive bidding process, including whether safeguards are in place to prevent an entity submitting a bid from participating in the deliberations of the fire agency awarding the subcontract. [HSC §1797.231(b)]
This bill:
- Requires a city, notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, to be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the city’s territorial jurisdiction under a specified provision of law known as “201 rights,” only if all of the following requirements are satisfied:
- The city became party to a joint powers agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services before the enactment of the EMS Act;
- The JPA provided a county with the sole authority to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other parties to the JPA;
- On December 17, 2020, the city provided notice of its withdrawal from the JPA, effective July 1, 2021; and,
- The city ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS ambulance services on or before December 31, 2022.
- Prohibits a JPA regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024, between a county and a city or fire district, from being construed as a “written agreement with the city or fire district regarding the provision of prehospital EMS for that city or fire district” within the meaning of the provision of law governing 201 rights, and requires the city or fire district to retain its existing authorities regarding, and the administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to 201 rights, if any, following entry into the JPA. Requires the JPA to provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
- Establishes a process for what happens if a city asserts its 201 rights pursuant to 1) above and it causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, as follows:
- Requires the local EMS agency to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city, which is required to be deemed an exclusive operating area created with a competitive process, as specified;
- Permits the county, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph a) above, to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
- Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes; or,
- Creating a new exclusive operating area, which is required to encompass, at a minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process, as specified under existing law. Prohibits the exclusive operating are from including the city specified in 1) above, unless that city is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process;
- If the county determines that the options in b) above are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the county’s best interests, requires the city specified in 1) above to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with provisions of law permitting a county to authorize a sole franchise to provide emergency medical transport, as specified;
- Requires contracting parties, in developing contracts under this bill, to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which are required to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area;
- Requires contracts developed under this bill to include the local EMS agency’s EMS system requirements and the response time standards;
- Requires a contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed under this bill to comply with specified provisions of existing law governing the contracting process for emergency ambulance services, and governing the subcontracting process when fire agencies subcontract ambulance services to a private ambulance service, as specified, and to the extent allowed by law, provide for the recruitment, and preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce;
- Requires the contractor, when the incumbent workforce is represented by a recognized employee organization, to meet with the incumbent workforce’s recognized organization to review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce, and to request a review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region. Requires the contractor to certify compliance with this paragraph prior to the county entering into a contract with the contractor; and,
- Requires the city or fire district specified in 1) above, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under a) above, to provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in b) to e) above, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city or fire district.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agency’s ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
- Makes this bill contingent on the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner), which limits the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services, prohibits the ground ambulance provider from billing more than the specified amount, and, requires the health plan or insurer to directly reimburse a ground ambulance provider according to authorized reimbursement amounts, as specified.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201 rights.” Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in my district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. This bill permits Oxnard to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption this bill also contains a failsafe that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. Finally, this bill clarifies that entities retain their 201 rights when joining a JPA, unless they explicitly give up those rights. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they join a JPA.
- “201 rights.” Health and Safety Code §1797.201, generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to passage of the EMS Act. This section was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, §1797.201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts….” Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the local EMS agency medical director.
- County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of a legal battle, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and the San Bernardino County. The court case involved, among other things, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three questions: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until they enter into an agreement with a local EMS agency to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the local EMS agency. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the local EMS agency to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021). In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the County, entered into a JPA regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the County established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is in Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider. According to the court, in the 2010s, the City of Oxnard grew dissatisfied with the provision of ambulance services by Gold Coast Ambulance, determining that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses than residents in more affluent areas, among other complaints. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the County of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the County not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the County from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained its 201 rights because it was indirectly contracting for those services as part of the JPA when the EMS Act was adopted. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. Among other points, Oxnard argued that because the statute does not specifically require the city to be “directly” contracting for services to have 201 rights, the court should not “insert what has been omitted.” However, the court, citing precedent, stated that 201 rights permit a city only to “continue to do what it had been doing as of June 1, 1980,” not “resume what it had ceased to do.” The court stated that in this case, Oxnard “ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971.” Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County’s consent. The appellate court’s judgment was entered on April 30, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- EMSA estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation.
- Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/31/23)
League of California Cities (source)
Alameda Fire Department
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
City of Oceanside
City of Ukiah
Clovis Fire Department
Fire Districts Association of California
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Sanger Fire Department
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/31/23)
Ambulance Association of Orange County
American Ambulance
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service
California Ambulance Association
California State Association of Counties
CALSTAR Air Medical Services
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Butte Board of Supervisors
County of Contra Costa Board of Supervisors
County of Fresno Board of Supervisors
County of Kern Board of Supervisors
County of Kings Department of Public Health
County of Lassen Board of Supervisors
County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors
County of Madera
County of Mariposa Board of Supervisors
County of Merced Board of Supervisors
County of Modoc Board of Supervisors
County of Monterey Board of Supervisors
County of Napa Board of Supervisors
County of Nevada Board of Supervisors
County of Placer Board of Supervisors
County of Plumas Board of Supervisors
County of Sacramento Board of Supervisors
County of San Bernardino County Administrative Office
County of San Mateo Board of Supervisors
County of Shasta Board of Supervisors
County of Solano Board of Supervisors
County of Trinity Board of Supervisors
County of Tulare Board of Supervisors
County of Tuolumne Board of Supervisors
County of Ventura
County of Yolo Board of Supervisors
Covalent Health
Desert Ambulance Service, INC.
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California
EMS Medical Directors Association of California
Gold Coast Health Plan
Health Officers Association of California
International Association of EMTs and Paramedics
Lifewest Ambulance
Los Angeles County Ambulance Association
MaxCare Ambulance
Medic Ambulance
Northern California EMS, INC.
Rural County Representatives of California
Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency
Urban Counties of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the League of California Cities (League) to clarify a city or fire district’s right to retain its authority over emergency ambulance services if a city or fire district enters into a JPA agreement with a county for emergency ambulance services. According to the League, the need for local control when the EMS Act was created was explicitly recognized in the Act with the inclusion of 201 rights. Unfortunately, the League states that 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA. The League states that the findings in the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura call into question any future efforts to enter into a JPA to provide ambulance services for fire agencies that currently have 201 rights for fear that those rights will be lost, even though an agency is working to provide the best service to the residents in the immediate and surrounding area. The California Professional Firefights, along with the local affiliates of the International Association of Fire Fighters representing firefighters in Oxnard, the City of Ventura, and Ventura County, make similar arguments in support, stating that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of providing efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of 201 rights, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over these services. The finding in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura has left Oxnard unable to address the systematic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services. Signatories to JPA agreements should not lose their 201 rights because they cooperated with other public agencies to provide better services to residents.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, the County Health Executives Association of California, and the Health Officers Association of California, submitted a joint letter of opposition. These groups state that this bill seeks to overturn an extensive statutory and case law record that has repeatedly affirmed county responsibility for the administration of EMS and with that, the flexibility to design systems to equitably serve residents throughout their jurisdiction. These groups state this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action where the court determined their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissibly broaden Health and Safety Code Section 1797.201’s exception in such a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermined the purposes of the EMS Act.” This abrogation of Oxnard v. County of Ventura could have significant implications on how EMS is structured today. The EMS Administrators Association of California, the EMS Medical Directors Association of California, numerous individual counties, and other groups make similar arguments in opposition.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-2, 5/30/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Flora, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Megan Dahle, Vince Fong
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Essayli, Friedman, Gallagher, Mathis, Jim Patterson
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
9/2/23 15:01:36
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1168 (Bennett) - Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
Version: July 13, 2023 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 10 - 0, GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
AB 1168 would allow the City of Oxnard the right to administer prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation.
- Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
Background:
Current law establishes the Emergency Medical Services (EMS) System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act to provide for a statewide system for EMS and establishes the EMSA which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS. Current law authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and to designate a local EMS agency responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system.
In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the county, entered into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the county established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is in Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the county of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the county not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the county from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained certain rights. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. However, the appellate court decided that regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the county’s consent.
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Provide that, notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city must be treated as if it had retained its specified authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the city’s territorial jurisdiction, under certain conditions.
- Require that if a city’s assertion of its specified authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, certain provisions must apply.
- Require that, for a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024 between a county and a city or fire district, the city or fire district must retain its existing specified authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement.
- Make the bill contingent on the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner), which, among other provisions, would limit the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services.
Related Legislation:
SB 443 (Hertzberg, 2021) would have required a city or fire district to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS, when they enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or cease to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura. These provisions were amended into the bill in the Assembly and the bill was not set for a hearing.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1168 (Bennett) - Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
Version: July 13, 2023 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 10 - 0, GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
AB 1168 would allow the City of Oxnard the right to administer prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $1.6 million for staffing resources; one-time General Fund contract costs of $200,000 to assist with developing regulations; and one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 and ongoing General Fund costs of $50,000 for automation.
- Costs to local EMS agencies would be potentially reimbursable by the state (General Fund), subject to a determination by the Commission on State Mandates.
Background:
Current law establishes the Emergency Medical Services (EMS) System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act to provide for a statewide system for EMS and establishes the EMSA which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS. Current law authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and to designate a local EMS agency responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system.
In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the county, entered into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the county established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is in Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the county of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the county not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the county from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained certain rights. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. However, the appellate court decided that regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the county’s consent.
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Provide that, notwithstanding City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, a city must be treated as if it had retained its specified authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services within the city’s territorial jurisdiction, under certain conditions.
- Require that if a city’s assertion of its specified authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area by the local EMS agency to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, certain provisions must apply.
- Require that, for a joint powers agreement regarding prehospital EMS initially executed on or after January 1, 2024 between a county and a city or fire district, the city or fire district must retain its existing specified authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS, if any, following entry into the joint powers agreement.
- Make the bill contingent on the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner), which, among other provisions, would limit the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services.
Related Legislation:
SB 443 (Hertzberg, 2021) would have required a city or fire district to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS, when they enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or cease to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura. These provisions were amended into the bill in the Assembly and the bill was not set for a hearing.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Anna M. Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1168 | Hearing Date: | 7/12/23 |
Author: | Bennett | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 7/5/23 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Rounds | ||
Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
Allows a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county to provide EMS will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if the city or fire district withdraws from the JPA, among other changes.
Background
Joint powers agencies. The Joint Exercise of Powers Act allows two or more public agencies to use their powers in common if they sign a joint powers agreement. Sometimes an agreement creates a new, separate public entity called a joint powers agency or joint powers authority (JPA). Agencies that can exercise joint powers include federal agencies, state departments, counties, cities, special districts, school districts, federally recognized Indian tribes, and even other JPAs.
The EMS Act. The Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Act comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. The Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. The intent of the EMS Act was to create a comprehensive, integrated, and coordinated system of prehospital emergency medical services in the state. While, California’s Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services in the state, under the Act, counties are given the responsibility and authority to develop an EMS program and to also designate to a Local EMS Agency (LEMSA) responsibility for planning and implementing an EMS system. This responsibility includes medical management and oversight of day-to-day operations and service delivery.
LEMSAs. Under the EMS Act, LEMSA’s can take a variety of forms, including a county health department, some other agency established and operated by the county, an entity with which the county contracts for the purposes of local emergency medical services administration, or a joint powers agency created for the administration of emergency medical services by agreement between counties or between cities and counties pursuant to a joint powers agreement. California currently has 33 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Seven regional multi-county LEMSA systems manage and oversee services for several small, rural, less-populated counties. Twenty-six single-county LEMSAs oversee and manage services in counties that are typically more urban and densely populated. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to state standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. A geographic map of the 33 geographic areas served by the LEMSAs can be found here: ArcGIS (ca.gov).
Exclusive Operating Areas under the EMS Act. The Act permits a LEMSA to create one or more “exclusive operating areas” for emergency services, including ambulance transport, when developing an EMS plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider pursuant to the plan. When a LEMSA elects to create an exclusive operating area, it must submit for approval to EMSA, as part of the local EMS plan, its competitive process for selecting providers and determining the scope of their operations. The plan must also include provisions for a competitive process to be held at periodic intervals.
“201 Rights.” Section 1797.201 (aka “Section 201”) of the Health and Safety Code, is a portion of the EMS Act that seeks to address concerns that cities and fire districts had about the potential impact of the Act on their authority to continue providing EMS programs in their cities. It allows a local agency to continue administering EMS services if they were doing so, and have been continuing to do so, since June 1, 1980. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide integrated and coordinated system for emergency medical response, Section 201 allows cities and fire districts to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached [with the county]. Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Act still requires “Section 201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of a legal battle, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and San Bernardino County, County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997), 15 Cal, 4th, 909. The court case involved, among other things, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three questions: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until such a time that they entered into an agreement with a local EMS agency to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the LEMSA. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the LEMSA to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021). In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the county, entered into a JPA regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the county established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is inside Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider.
According to the court, in the 2010s, the City of Oxnard grew dissatisfied with the provision of ambulance services by Gold Coast Ambulance, determining that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses than residents in more affluent areas, among other complaints. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the county of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the county not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the county from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained its 201 rights because it was indirectly contracting for those services as part of the JPA when the EMS Act was adopted. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. Among other points, Oxnard argued that because the statute does not specifically require the city to be “directly” contracting for services to have 201 rights, the court should not “insert what has been omitted.” However, the Appellate Court decision entered April 30, 2021, the 5th Court of Appeals, stated that 201 rights permit a city only to “continue to do what it had been doing as of June 1, 1980,” not “resume what it had ceased to do,” City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1017. As a result, it may not now resume providing those services absent the county’s consent, even if it withdraws from the JPA.
The League of California Cities wants to revise the EMS Act to allow the City of Oxnard to operate as if it had Section 201 rights, thereby allowing the city to provide EMS services in the same manner as other cities who have continuously retained the ability to administer such services under the EMS Act.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 1168 has three primary parts: granting Oxnard 201 rights notwithstanding the decision of the court; providing a path to transition affected services and workers; and, prospectively, providing a means for cities to join and then exit LEMSA JPAs, in a manner that preserves their 201 rights.
“201 Rights” Exception to Court Ruling. AB 1168 provides that “notwithstanding” the court decision in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, the city shall be treated as if it had retained its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS ambulance services pursuant to Section 201 of the EMS Act. The bill explicitly limits the reach of its “notwithstanding” language so that it only applies to Oxnard.
Transition of Services in Exclusive Operating Area 6. AB 1168 includes provisions that provide the county with multiple ways to transition services in those affected areas of Exclusive Operating Area 6 which are outside the city of Oxnard:
- Under the bill, the LEMSA must provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s current designated provider or providers to continue providing the services in a new exclusive operating area composed of the areas outside of the city.
- If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services, the county would be empowered to transition the services in other ways including the following:
- by using the county fire department or a separate county department created to provide the services;
- by creating a new exclusive operating area that included the affected areas outside the city of Oxnard and selecting a new contracted service provider under the competitive processes required by the EMS Act;
- by assigning the work to and contracting with Oxnard to provide the services. In the last instance, the county could require Oxnard to provide the services if the county determined that other options are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care, or are not in the county’s best interests.
- If the designated provider or providers decline to continue services after being given the right of first refusal, Oxnard would be required to provide the services until the county makes a determination as to which of the permissible ways it will transition services.
Response Times in Affected Areas. The bill requires that transitioned services must meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the LEMSA for that area and comply with both the LEMSA’s EMS system requirements and response time standards.
LEMSA Authorities Preserved. AB 1168 says that it does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a LEMSA. Similarly, it says it does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge LEMSA’s ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area, including Oxnard.
Treatment of Contractor’s or Subcontractor’s Workforce and Incumbent Workers. The bill cross-references existing EMS Act language that requires counties, when entering a new contract or subcontract for EMS services, to adopt, by ordinance or resolution, a written policy that may include requirements pertaining to contractor retention of incumbent employees. It further cross-references existing language requiring contracts and subcontracts to pay wages and benefits comparable and consistent with those paid to other ambulance services employees in the region and requires maintenance of staffing levels comparable to those in the prior contract. AB 1168 also proposes new incumbent workforce protections specific to this particular situation that would require—to the extent allowed by law—contracts for transitioned services in Exclusive Area 6 to also provide for the recruitment, and the preservation of the seniority status, of the incumbent workforce. The bill also requires a new contractor or subcontractor for transitioned services to meet with the incumbent workforce’s recognized employee organization or official representative, review and discuss the collective bargaining agreement for the incumbent workforce, and request and review any other existing collective bargaining agreements for ambulance service employees in the region. Proposed new incumbent worker protections only apply for the work that would come under contract as a result of the transitioning of services triggered by Oxnard exercising the “201 rights” newly granted to it by this bill.
Prospective Rights to Withdraw from LEMSA JPAs for Other Cities. AB 1168 proposes to give cities and fire districts that have “201 rights” the ability to enter and subsequently withdraw from a JPA without forfeiting their “201” rights. Unlike the other provisions of the bill specific to Oxnard and Ventura County, these provisions of AB 1168 would apply more generally.
Contingent Enactment. AB 1168 contains language that makes its enactment contingent on the enactment of Assembly Bill 716 (Boerner) which would limit the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services, prohibit the ground ambulance provider from billing more than a specified amount, and require the health plan or insurer to directly reimburse a ground ambulance provider according to established or approved amounts,
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or ‘201 rights.’ Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in my district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. AB 1168 allows Oxnard to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption this bill also contains a failsafe that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with the county. Finally, this bill clarifies that entities retain their 201 rights when joining a JPA, unless they explicitly give up those rights. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they join a JPA.”
2. Fragmenting an integrated system in ways that undermine equity? The intent of the EMS Act was to create a comprehensive, integrated, and coordinated system of prehospital emergency medical services in the state with counties having the primary responsibility and authority for ensuring the development of a responsive service delivery system. Opponents of AB 1168, such as the Emergency Medical Services Administrators’ Association of California, contend that the bill would undo “an extensive statutory and case law record that has repeatedly affirmed county responsibility for the administration of emergency medical services and with that, the flexibility to design systems to equitably serve residents throughout their jurisdiction.” The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors state that, “AB 1168 would establish a foundation upon which cities could break apart and effectively dismantle well established emergency ambulance response areas.” Other opponents assert that AB 1168 “causes a great deal of uncertainty for counties who are the responsible local government entity for providing equitable emergency medical services for all of their residents . . . [T]his measure creates a system where there will be haves and have nots – well-resourced cities or districts will be able to provide robust services whereas disadvantaged communities, with a less robust tax base, will have a patchwork of providers.” While most of the language in the bill specifies that it only applies to Oxnard, opponents believe that passage of the bill will set bad precedent by encouraging other cities to attempt to legislatively opt out of existing agreements for coordinated services in other county jurisdictions.
3. Until death do us part? What if service levels and response times would improve for a party if they were to provide the services themselves? The current statutory framework, expected cities, to whom it granted 201 rights, to eventually enter into agreements with counties, who would them make controlling decisions as to how best to serve the residents of a county, including city residents inside that county. The existing statutory framework appears to imply that once a city comes to agreement with a county on coordinated services, the city loses its 201 rights to continue to administer services the way that it had. Decades after EMSA’s enactment, should cities be locked into agreements or partnerships that may have served them at one time but no longer do? Should cities party to an emergency services agreement, whether through a JPA or some other formal agreement, be required to continue, in perpetuity, operating under arrangements they no longer feel serve them?
4. Service quality. Proponents of the bill suggest that ambulance response times in Oxnard’s low and moderate income neighborhoods were more than twice as likely to be substandard than in more affluent areas of the city and provided to committee staff court documents containing data to support this assertion. Opponents of the measure also provided data to committee staff showing that response times in the city of Oxnard—as a whole—are the fastest in Ventura County. What, if any, role should quality and responsive service play in determining which agency provides EMS services?
5. EMS Act revisions needed? Health and Safety Code section 1797.204 states that, “The local EMS agency shall plan, implement, and evaluate an emergency medical services system, in an organized pattern of readiness and response services [that is] based on public and private agreements and operational procedures.” Nevertheless, the Act gives primary decision-making and operational authority to the counties, and the current statutory framework does not appear to provide for a formal process of dispute mediation or resolution for circumstances when cities and counties are in disagreement about prehospital emergency medical services. And while EMSA—the state authority which provides oversight of county LEMSA’s—can reject LEMSA plans, there appears to be no formal process for cities to raise concerns about LEMSA operations. Where does that leave cities who are unhappy with the status quo? Opponents of the bill, indicate that LEMSAs try to work with cities and fire districts to resolve disputes when they arise. However, absent the legislature creating a more formal statutory mechanism for dispute resolution, it seems likely that city and county conflicts pertaining to prehospital medical services will continue to end up in the courts as well as legislative committee rooms.
6. Fate of incumbent workers. Author amendments of July 5th insert provisions that provide incumbent workers a seat at the table, a process for recruitment, and the preservation of the seniority status of the incumbent workforce if services are transitioned to another direct service provider. Because transitioned services could wind up being provided by either public or private providers, the means by which incumbent workers transition from the current service provider remains unclear. In the case of public sector provision of emergency services, workers may need to navigate civil service rules to follow the work, potentially creating obstacles to worker retention and the preservation of seniority. If transitioned services are provided by a private provider, the work would fall under the National Labor Relations Act. While the language of the bill creates a process for these workers to meet with any new provider and discuss the extant collective bargaining agreement as well as other comparable agreements for the same work, the workers would still need to comply with the relevant provisions of the NLRA to select an employee representative and engage in collective bargaining. As such, continued representation of the workers currently represented and doing the work is not a foregone conclusion.
5. Mandate. Because the bill creates new duties for local EMS agencies, Legislative Counsel says the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local governments for the costs of new or expanded state mandated local programs. The bill requires the state to reimburse local agencies if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill imposes a reimbursable mandate.
6. Double referral. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double-referral of AB 1168 – first to the Senate Health Committee where it passed 10-0 and second to the Governance & Finance Committee.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Health Committee 12-1
Assembly Emergency Management Committee 6-1
Assembly Appropriations 12-2
Assembly Floor 72-2
Support and Opposition
(7/7/23)
Support: League of California Cities (Sponsor)
911 Ambulance Provider's Medi-cal Alliance
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
City of Oxnard
City of Santa Rosa
Fire Districts Association of California
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
Opposition: American Medical Response (AMR) West
California State Association of Counties (CSAC)
County Health Executives Association of California (CHEAC)
County of Contra Costa
County of Fresno
County of Kern
County of Los Angeles
County of Merced
County of Monterey
County of Nevada
County of Orange
County of Placer
County of San Mateo
County of Shasta
County of Tulare
County of Ventura
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California (EMSAAC)
Health Officers Association of California
International Association of Emts and Paramedics
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Mateo County
Urban Counties of California (UCC)
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Susan Talamantes Eggman, Chair
BILL NO: AB 1168
AUTHOR: | Bennett | ||
VERSION: | May 26, 2023 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 28, 2023 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
SUMMARY:
Reverses a court decision in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura to allow the City of Oxnard the right to administer or contract for prehospital EMS, establishes a process to determine who will provide prehospital EMS to the remaining portion of the exclusive operating area if the City of Oxnard exercises its right to provide prehospital EMS in the City, and clarifies going forward that a city or fire district providing prehospital EMS that enters into a joint powers of authority agreement (JPA) with a county will retain its rights to administer prehospital EMS if the city or fire district withdraws from the JPA.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for EMS, and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. [HSC §1797, et seq.]
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a local EMS agency responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. [HSC §1797.200, et seq.]
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. [HSC §1797.201]
- Permits a local EMS agency to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if the local EMS agency develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. [HSC §1797.224]
- Permits a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that will provide those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service; and permits a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for the purpose of contracting with a county. [HSC §1797.230, §1797.231]
- Requires, when a fire agency is contracting with a county to provide emergency ambulance services through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service, the written subcontract with the private ambulance service to be awarded pursuant to a competitive bidding process, and to set forth issues to be considered during the competitive bidding process, including whether safeguards are in place to prevent an entity submitting a bid from participating in the deliberations of the fire agency awarding the subcontract. [HSC §1797.231(b)]
- Prohibits anything in a provision of law that prohibits cities or counties from establishing equipment and personnel standards for the furnishing of nonemergency medical transportation services for Medi-Cal beneficiaries from being construed to prevent a city or county from permitting both emergency and nonemergency medical transportation services to operate within its jurisdiction under a sole franchise when such a franchise has been determined necessary to assure the economic viability of those services. [WIC §14136(e)]
This bill:
- Requires a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through a JPA with a county that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021), on or before December 31, 2022, to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to existing law governing “201 rights.”
- Requires a city or fire district that is providing prehospital EMS as of January 1, 2024, pursuant to 201 rights, and enters a JPA with a county regarding prehospital EMS, to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to the laws governing 201 rights. Requires the JPA to provide terms to address the withdrawal of the city or fire district from the agreement and the effect of a withdrawal on the EMS system and exclusive operating areas, if any.
- Establishes a process for what happens if a city or fire district asserts its 201 rights pursuant to 1) above and it causes a local EMS area that is currently designated as an exclusive operating area to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, as follows:
- Requires the local EMS agency to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s designated provider or providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which is required to be deemed an exclusive operating area created with a competitive process, as specified;
- Permits the county, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under paragraph a) above, to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis by doing one of the following:
- Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department or a separate county department created for those purposes; or,
- Creating a new exclusive operating area, which is required to encompass, at a minimum, the remainder of the local EMS area, through a competitive process, as specified under existing law. Prohibits the exclusive operating are from including the city or fire district specified in 1) above, unless that city or fire district is selected to be the provider of the exclusive operating area pursuant to the competitive process;
- If the county determines that the options in b) above are not economically viable, would reduce the level or quality of care available in the remainder of the local EMS area, or are not in the county’s best interests, requires the city or fire district specified in 1) above to enter into an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with provisions of law permitting a county to authorize a sole franchise to provide emergency medical transport, as described in Existing Law 7) above;
- Requires contracting parties, in developing contracts under this bill, to collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which are required to meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area;
- Requires contracts developed under this bill to include the local EMS agency’s EMS system requirements and the response time standards;
- Requires a contract, or subcontract for emergency ambulance services, developed under this bill to comply with specified provisions of existing law governing the contracting process for emergency ambulance services, and governing the subcontracting process when fire agencies subcontract ambulance services to a private ambulance service, as specified; and,
- Requires the city or fire district specified in 1) above, if the designated provider or providers decline to continue services under a) above, to provide services within the local EMS area until the time the county completes the requirements in b) to e) above, pursuant to the same contractual, permitting, or regulatory terms, conditions, and requirements of the county for that area, except as otherwise agreed to by the county and the city or fire district.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a local EMS agency.
- Specifies that this bill does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agency’s ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
- Makes various legislative findings and declarations, including the following:
- Local governments’ provision, directly or by contract, administration, and regulation of prehospital EMS is a matter of public safety, and that local control over the types, levels, and availability of these services is a longstanding tradition that the Legislature intends to retain;
- One of the ways in which local governments coordinate, plan, and achieve the most effective countywide or regional EMS and leverage their combine resources is through JPAs;
- Achieving these policies has been hindered, and the validity of existing and contemplated agreements for JPAs regard EMS has been called into questions, by the holding of the City of Oxnard v. County of Venture, which states that a city was ineligible for, and could no longer exercise, its 201 rights following the city’s entry into a JPA with a county regarding prehospital EMS;
- In enacting this bill, it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the effect of JPA agreements regarding prehospital EMS on the rights, obligations, and authorities of counties, local EMS agencies, cities, fire districts, and EMS providers to preserve the utility and desirability of those agreements for EMS purposes, to reduce resulting disruptions to existing county and regional EMS systems, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura; and,
- The provisions of this bill do not authorize the substantial impairment of contractual obligations of an agreement to provide services within an exclusive operating area, as specified.
- Makes this bill contingent on the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner), which limits the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services, prohibits the ground ambulance provider from billing more than the specified amount, and, requires the health plan or insurer to directly reimburse a ground ambulance provider according to authorized reimbursement amounts, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of the prior version of this bill, which had a broader impact than just the City of Oxnard:
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) estimates General Fund costs of approximately $159,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and ongoing for one full-time, permanent health program specialist. EMSA reports it might also need changes to the California Emergency Medical Services Information System for addition and modification of fields, which could cost $200,000 in FY 2023-24, and $50,000 annually thereafter for maintenance (General Fund).
EMSA notes additional cost pressure if the bill results in changes to the EMS areas and sub-areas, which could have downstream impacts on EMSA. To the extent there is a reduced private provider revenue for exclusive operating areas/sub-areas, EMSA states it would need to have more oversight on plans and changes to plans.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 72 - 2 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 12 - 2 |
Assembly Emergency Management Committee: | 6-1 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 12-1 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201 rights.” Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in my district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. This bill permits Oxnard to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption this bill also contains a failsafe that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. Finally, this bill clarifies that entities retain their 201 rights when joining a JPA, unless they explicitly give up those rights. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they join a JPA.
- Background on EMS. While EMSA is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services, day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional EMS agencies. California has 33 local EMS agency systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county local EMS agencies. The EMS Act comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system.
- “201 rights.” Health and Safety Code §1797.201, generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to passage of the EMS Act. This section was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, §1797.201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts….” Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the local EMS agency medical director.
- Creation of exclusive operating areas. Health and Safety Code §1797.224 permits a local EMS agency to create one or more “exclusive operating areas” for emergency services, including ambulance transport, when developing an EMS plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services pursuant to the plan (although no competitive process is required if the plan continues the use of existing providers operating without interruption since January 1, 1981). When a local EMS agency elects to create an exclusive operating area, it is required to submit for approval to EMSA, as part of the local EMS plan, its competitive process for selecting providers and determining the scope of their operations. The plan is also required to include provisions for a competitive process to be held at periodic intervals.
- County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997). The issue of medical control of EMS systems was the subject of a legal battle, decided in 1997, between the City of San Bernardino and the San Bernardino County. The court case involved, among other things, an attempt by the City of San Bernardino to take over ambulance transport services in the city that had been performed by a private ambulance operator. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court ruled on three questions: First, that cities and fire districts may maintain administrative control of their emergency medical services that they provided as of June 1, 1980 (their “201 rights”), until they enter into an agreement with a local EMS agency to integrate their systems. Second, that this administrative control does not give a city or fire district the prerogative to expand into services it did not provide prior to June 1, 1980, without the consent of the local EMS agency. And third, a fire department having administrative control pursuant to its “201 rights” does not take away the ability of the local EMS agency to exercise medical control, including implementing dispatch protocols.
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: (1) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; (2) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; (3) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or (4) contracting with private ambulance companies.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021). In 1971, the County of Ventura and the City of Oxnard, as well as several other municipalities within the County, entered into a JPA regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, the county administers a county-wide ambulance system, and is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the JPA. To implement the JPA, the County established seven exclusive operating areas in which private companies provide ambulance services. The City of Oxnard is in Exclusive Operating Area 6, where Gold Coast Ambulance is the service provider. According to the court, in the 2010s, the City of Oxnard grew dissatisfied with the provision of ambulance services by Gold Coast Ambulance, determining that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses than residents in more affluent areas, among other complaints. In December of 2020, Oxnard notified the County of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. Oxnard requested that the County not approve a contract extension with Gold Coast Ambulance so it could instead contract with another ambulance service provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the contract extension. Oxnard sought a preliminary injunction to prevent the County from providing ambulance services within Oxnard city limits, claiming it retained its 201 rights because it was indirectly contracting for those services as part of the JPA when the EMS Act was adopted. The trial court denied the injunction, and Oxnard appealed. Among other points, Oxnard argued that because the statute does not specifically require the city to be “directly” contracting for services to have 201 rights, the court should not “insert what has been omitted.” However, the court, citing precedent, stated that 201 rights permit a city only to “continue to do what it had been doing as of June 1, 1980,” not “resume what it had ceased to do.” The court stated that in this case, Oxnard “ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971.” Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County’s consent. The appellate court’s judgment was entered on April 30, 2021.
- Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
- Related legislation. AB 716 (Boerner) limits the amount a health plan enrollee, insured, or uninsured person who receives services from a ground ambulance provider has to pay for services, prohibits the ground ambulance provider from billing more than the specified amount, and, requires the health plan or insurer to directly reimburse a ground ambulance provider according to authorized reimbursement amounts, as specified. AB 716 is set to be heard in this Committee on July 5, 2023.
AB 40 (Rodriguez) requires EMSA to develop a system for an electronic signature for use between the emergency department and ambulance personnel that captures the points in time when a hospital receives notification of ambulance arrival and when transfer of care is executed for documentation of ambulance patient offload time (APOT). AB 40 requires EMSA to develop a statewide standard of 30 minutes, 90% of the time for APOT, and requires a general acute care hospital to develop an APOT reduction protocol, that addresses specified factors. Finally, AB 40 requires EMSA, on or after March 1, 2024, to monitor APOT for each facility that is required to report. AB 40 is set to be heard in this Committee on July 5, 2023.
AB 379 (Rodriguez) requires a local EMS agency to adopt policies and procedures for calculating and reporting APOT, and to establish a process for hospitals and ambulance providers to review and validate the reported data. AB 379 requires a local EMS agency to develop and submit an EMS system plan to EMSA, and requires this plan to be made accessible. AB 379 is set to be heard in this Committee on July 5, 2023.
SB 767 (Gipson) extends the sunset date of the Community Paramedicine or Triage to Alternate Destination Act of 2020, from January 1, 2024 to January 1, 2031, and adds short-term, post-discharge follow-up for persons recently discharged from a hospital due to a serious health condition to the list of program specialties that can be part of a community paramedicine program. SB 767 passed the Senate Health Committee by a vote of 11-0 on June 21, 2023. - Prior legislation. SB 443 (Hertzberg of 2022) would have required a city or fire district to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS, when they enter into a JPA agreement with a county regarding prehospital EMS, or cease to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura. States that it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the scope and breadth of medical control, restrict local EMS agencies medical control authority over public safety agencies, clarify that a public safety agency does not transfer any of the public safety agency’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS by adhering, or agreeing to adhere, to a local EMS agency’s medical control authority, and abrogate (or do away with) any contrary holdings in County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino and other judicial decisions. These EMS-related provisions were amended into SB 443 in the Assembly, where it was not hearing in the Assembly Health Committee, and was never heard in the Senate.
AB 389 (Grayson, Chapter 460, Statutes of 2021) permits a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that will provide those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service; and permits a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for the purpose of contracting with a county.
AB 1544 (Gipson, Chapter 138, Statutes of 2020) enacted the Community Paramedicine or Triage to Alternate Destination Act of 2019, which permits local emergency medical services agencies, with approval by the Emergency Medical Services Authority, to develop programs to provide community paramedic or triage to alternate destination services in one of the following specialties: (1) providing directly observed tuberculosis therapy; (2) providing case management services to frequent emergency medical services users; (3) providing hospice services to treat patients in their homes; and, (4) providing patients with transport to an alternate destination, which can either be an authorized mental health facility, or an authorized sobering center. Sunsets the provisions of this bill on January 1, 2024.
SB 438 (Hertzberg, Chapter 389, Statutes of 2019) prohibited a public agency from entering into a contract for 911 call processing regarding the dispatch of emergency response resources unless the contract is with another public agency, with specified exceptions. - Support. This bill is sponsored by the League of California Cities (League) to clarify a city or fire district’s right to retain its authority over emergency ambulance services if a city or fire district enters into a JPA agreement with a county for emergency ambulance services. According to the League, the need for local control when the EMS Act was created was explicitly recognized in the Act with the inclusion of 201 rights. Unfortunately, the League states that 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA. The League states that the findings in the City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura call into question any future efforts to enter into a JPA to provide ambulance services for fire agencies that currently have 201 rights for fear that those rights will be lost, even though an agency is working to provide the best service to the residents in the immediate and surrounding area. The California Professional Firefights, along with the local affiliates of the International Association of Fire Fighters representing firefighters in Oxnard, the City of Ventura, and Ventura County, make similar arguments in support, stating that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of providing efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of 201 rights, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over these services. The finding in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura has left Oxnard unable to address the systematic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services. Signatories to JPA agreements should not lose their 201 rights because they cooperated with other public agencies to provide better services to residents.
- Oppose unless amended. American Medical Response (AMR) and the 911 Ambulance Providers Medi-Cal Alliance submitted similar letters opposing this bill unless amended. According to AMR, this bill goes beyond simply addressing the City of Oxnard and seeks to overturn decades of case law which has protected the EMS Act. Specifically, this bill seeks to completely overturn the holding in Oxnard v. County of Ventura, not just for the city itself, but for any provider in a similar situation. AMR points to language stating that it is the intent of the Legislature to “clarify the effect” of JPAs “on the rights, obligations, and authorities of counties, local EMS agencies, cities, fire districts, and EMS providers…and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura.” AMR states that other provisions in the bill reinforce this intent to open up 201 rights, and states that while it is drafted to make it look like it only applies to the City of Oxnard, it suggests that any city or fire district that provided prehospital EMS through a JPA with a county in 1980 was both “contracting for or providing” prehospital EMS, which expands what it means for a city or fire district to have contracted for or provided prehospital EMS as that term is used under section .201. AMR points to other problems with the language in the bill that could be interpreted as granting an expanded interpretation of 201 rights, and opposes this bill unless it can be amended to address their concerns.
- Opposition. The California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, the County Health Executives Association of California, and the Health Officers Association of California, submitted a joint letter of opposition. These groups state that this bill seeks to overturn an extensive statutory and case law record that has repeatedly affirmed county responsibility for the administration of EMS and with that, the flexibility to design systems to equitably serve residents throughout their jurisdiction. These groups state this bill seeks to abrogate unsuccessful legal action where the court determined their case “would disrupt the status quo, impermissible broaden Health and Safety Code Section 1797.201’s exception in such a fashion that would swallow the EMS Act itself, fragment the long-integrated emergency medical system, and undermined the purposes of the EMS Act.” In addition, these groups state that while the author and sponsors contend that recent amendments make this a district only measure, the intent language could suggest that 201 rights should be restored for any city or fire district that previously lost their 201 rights while entering into an agreement with the county, including a JPA. This abrogation of Oxnard v. County of Ventura could have significant implications on how EMS is structured today. The EMS Administrators Association of California, the EMS Medical Directors Association of California, the California Ambulance Association, numerous individual counties, and other groups make similar arguments in opposition.
- Policy comment. While the author’s stated intent is for this bill to just apply to the City of Oxnard to ensure that the city is provided 201 rights in order to provide emergency ambulance services, as opponents note, there are provisions in the bill, including codified intent language, that could have a broader reach than just the City of Oxnard. There is codified intent language stating that “the validity of existing…agreements for the joint exercise of powers regarding EMS has been called into question,” and that it is the intent of the Legislature to “abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura.” This language could be used by other cities or fire districts to try and assert 201 rights that other stakeholders believe do not exist. Given the author’s intent to limit the application of this bill to just the City of Oxnard, the Committee may wish to consider amendments to ensure this bill does not place a thumb on the scale in the interpretation of 201 rights in other jurisdictions.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: League of California Cities (sponsor)
Alameda Fire Department
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
City of Oceanside
City of Ukiah
Clovis Fire Department
Fire Districts Association of California
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Sanger Fire Department
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
Oppose: 911 Ambulance Providers Medi-Cal Alliance (unless amended)
Ambulance Association of Orange County
American Ambulance
American Medical Response (unless amended)
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service
California Ambulance Association
California State Association of Counties
CALSTAR Air Medical Services
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Butte Board of Supervisors
County of Contra Costa Board of Supervisors
County of Fresno Board of Supervisors
County of Kern Board of Supervisors
County of Kings Department of Public Health
County of Lassen Board of Supervisors
County of Madera
County of Mariposa Board of Supervisors
County of Merced Board of Supervisors
County of Modoc Board of Supervisors
County of Monterey Board of Supervisors
County of Napa Board of Supervisors
County of Nevada Board of Supervisors
County of Placer Board of Supervisors
County of Plumas Board of Supervisors
County of Sacramento Board of Supervisors
County of San Bernardino County Administrative Office
County of San Mateo Board of Supervisors
County of Shasta Board of Supervisors
County of Trinity Board of Supervisors
County of Tulare Board of Supervisors
County of Tuolumne Board of Supervisors
County of Ventura
County of Yolo Board of Supervisors
Covalent Health
Desert Ambulance Service, INC.
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California
EMS Medical Directors Association of California
Gold Coast Health Plan
Health Officers Association of California
International Association of EMTs and Paramedics
Lifewest Ambulance
Los Angeles County Ambulance Association
MaxCare Ambulance
Medic Ambulance
Northern California EMS, INC.
Rural County Representatives of California
Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency
Urban Counties of California
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett)
As Amended Ver:May 26, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Returns the authority regarding, and the administration of, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) to the City of Oxnard. Clarifies that a city or fire district currently exercising their "201" rights may enter a Joint Powers Agreement (JPA) for the provision of prehospital EMS without automatically losing their 201 rights. Provides that this bill will become operative only if AB 716 (Boerner) of the current legislative session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional local emergency medical services areas (LEMSAs). California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The Emergency Medical Services Act (the Act) comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health & Safety Code (HSC) §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as "201 rights," was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act's potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district "until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts..." Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required "Section 201" cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
- City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) (Oxnard). In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county's authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- Inequities in service? According to information supplied by the author, a study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas consistently had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. Specifically, the study evaluated ambulances from time of assignment to time arriving on scene using two different thresholds for priority (anything over eight minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards) and non-priority calls (anything over 15 minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards). Oxnard Fire Department then combined this with data from the US Department of Urban Development regarding Low and Moderate Income (LMI) residents. Their analysis found that areas with a population of LMI residents over 50% had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulances (4,373) compared to areas with areas with a population of LMI residents that was less than 50% (2,270). This trend was shown to be persistent, going back to 2017. Additionally, Oxnard Fire Department found that the units with Oxnard's service area spent 12% of their total time outside of the city's service area, without full reciprocation from surrounding areas.
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: a) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; b) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; c) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, d) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of the county if/when the City of Oxnard re-asserts their "201" rights.
- Emergency ground medical transportation (EGMT) and payment methodologies. EGMT is provided by emergency medical technicians (EMTs) and/or paramedics who staff land ambulances. EMTs, who receive approximately 150 hours of training, can provide noninvasive basic life support (BLS) maneuvers such as oxygen therapy, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and bleeding control. Paramedics, who receive approximately 1,100 hours of training beyond that of EMTs, can provide invasive advanced life support (ALS), such as intravenous therapy, medication administration, and breathing tube insertion. In response to 911 calls, trained emergency medical dispatchers use software to triage whether an emergency is life threatening (necessitating a paramedic-level ALS response) or non-life threatening (necessitating an EMT-level BLS response). BLS ambulances consist of two EMTs, whereas ALS ambulances are staffed by either two paramedics or one paramedic and one EMT.
Payer reimbursement rates typically vary by patient acuity. Rates are higher for life-threatening emergencies with ALS ambulances than for non-life-threatening emergencies with BLS ambulances. In addition to the response and transportation charge, there are sometimes additional charges such as mileage, oxygen, and miscellaneous supplies. Plans and policies may adopt Medicare ambulance coverage policies, classifying EGMT reimbursement into BLS and two ALS levels: ALS Level 1 when a paramedic assessment or intervention is provided, or ALS Level 2 when a defined complex paramedic intervention is provided, such as endotracheal intubation or three intravenous injections.
A variety of systems deliver EMS, including public entities (fire departments, public ambulance districts, hospital systems) and private nonprofit or for-profit entities (hospitals and ambulance companies). Although 78% of the EGMT providers in California are in the public sector, these public entities only operate 19% of ambulances and account for 24% of 911 transports. While fire departments respond to most 911 medicals calls in California and employ EMTs and paramedics on their fire apparatus, most fire departments do not provide ambulance transport services. Two companies in the private sector (Global Medical Response and Falck and their subsidiaries) operate nearly half of private ambulances and provide over 75% of all California EGMT transports.
Ambulance transportation charges, including the response, mileage, and supplies components, are regulated at a local level by LEMSAs. LEMSAs set a maximum billed charge, which can vary considerably by county. The most recent comprehensive review of California's LEMSAs, in 2014, reported that the maximum billed ambulance response charge, if inflated to 2022 dollars, can average up to $3,200 depending on the region (Los Angeles County EMS Agency, 2014). These maximum billed charges represent the ceiling; contracted or allowed rates may be substantially lower.
According to the Author
The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or "201" rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows Oxnard, to regain their right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS services, this bill contains a "failsafe" provisions that would require Oxnard to cover the surrounding EMS service area, while the County decides whether or not it wants to continue providing services outside the city. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
Arguments in Support
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today's EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. CPF states that this has left Oxnard unable to address the systemic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services.
Arguments in Opposition
The 911 Ambulance Providers Alliance (911 Ambulance Providers) is opposed to this bill and states that, taken together, the three sections of this bill undermine the very heart of the EMS Act. Rather than a LEMSA coordinating prehospital emergency medical services for an entire county, its coordination can be undermined at any time by a city or fire department that chooses to opt into providing whatever level of services it deems to be financially profitable. This requires the LEMSA to then carve certain areas of its geography out from its coordination and disrupts established expectations between a LEMSA and any exclusive ambulance provider with which the LEMSA had contracted. The 911 Ambulance Providers state that such a result would be the death knell of the coordinated and integrated EMS delivery system California has spent 40 years building. Countywide exclusive operating area ambulance systems are fully funded by patient charges set by the county, and they ensure an equitable, efficient, sustainable, and coordinated response to medical emergencies. The 911 Ambulance Providers contend that cities and fire districts seek to operate ambulances so that they can use ambulance transport revenues to address skyrocketing and unsustainable public safety pension costs that have forced numerous cities into bankruptcy, including Stockton, San Bernardino, and Vallejo.
The American Federation of State and County Municipal Employees AFL-CIO states that under this bill, fire agencies would have the authority to take over ground ambulance services and then subcontract the labor back to the same private EMS companies. This would result in a system delivery model that would increase charges to patients and suppress the wages and benefits for private EMTs and paramedics, as private ambulance services would need to re-negotiate or even terminate county contracts due to a reduction in service territory. This reduction in service territory would then fracture coordinated EMS response and deprive rural and unincorporated areas of a dedicated ambulance provider.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, EMSA estimates General Fund costs of approximately $159,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and ongoing for one full-time, permanent health program specialist. EMSA reports it might also need changes to the California Emergency Medical Services Information System for addition and modification of fields, which could cost $200,000 in FY 2023-24, and $50,000 annually thereafter for maintenance (General Fund).
EMSA notes additional cost pressure if the bill results in changes to the EMS areas and sub-areas, which could have downstream impacts on EMSA. To the extent there is a reduced private provider revenue for exclusive operating areas/sub-areas, EMSA states it would need to have more oversight on plans and changes to plans.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 12-1-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Weber
NO: Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Villapudua
ASM EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Rodriguez, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Calderon, Schiavo
NO: Megan Dahle
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-2-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: May 26, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0001018
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett)
As Amended Ver:May 1, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Deems, in response to the court decision City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, a city or fire district that, as of June 1, 1980, provided prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), to retain its authorities regarding the prehospital EMS if that city or fire district: 1) entered into an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS; or, 2) ceased to provide prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding; or, 3) as of January 1, 2024, provides prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district. Provides that this bill will become operative only if AB 716 (Boerner) of the current legislation session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional local emergency medical services areas (LEMSAs). California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The Emergency Medical Services Act (the Act) comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. Health & Safety Code (HSC) §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as "201 rights," was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district "until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts..." Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required "Section 201" cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.
- Oxnard. In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the Joint Powers Authority (JPA). However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county’s authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- Inequities in service? According to information supplied by the author, a study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas consistently had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. Specifically, the study evaluated ambulances from time of assignment to time arriving on scene using two different thresholds for priority (anything over eight minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards) and non-priority calls (anything over 15 minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards). Oxnard Fire Department then combined this with data from the US Department of Urban Development regarding Low and Moderate Income (LMI) residents. Their analysis found that areas with a population of LMI residents over 50% had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulances (4,373) compared to areas with areas with a population of LMI residents that was less than 50% (2,270). This trend was shown to be persistent, going back to 2017. Additionally, Oxnard Fire Department found that the units with Oxnard’s service area spent 12% of their total time outside of the city’s service area, without full reciprocation from surrounding areas.
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: a) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; b) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; c) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, d) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of a county if/when a city re-asserts their "201" rights.
- Emergency ground medical transportation (EGMT) and payment methodologies. EGMT is provided by emergency medical technicians (EMTs) and/or paramedics who staff land ambulances. EMTs, who receive approximately 150 hours of training, can provide noninvasive basic life support (BLS) maneuvers such as oxygen therapy, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and bleeding control. Paramedics, who receive approximately 1,100 hours of training beyond that of EMTs, can provide invasive advanced life support (ALS), such as intravenous therapy, medication administration, and breathing tube insertion. In response to 911 calls, trained emergency medical dispatchers use software to triage whether an emergency is life threatening (necessitating a paramedic-level ALS response) or non-life threatening (necessitating an EMT-level BLS response). BLS ambulances consist of two EMTs, whereas ALS ambulances are staffed by either two paramedics or one paramedic and one EMT.
Payer reimbursement rates typically vary by patient acuity. Rates are higher for life-threatening emergencies with ALS ambulances than for non-life-threatening emergencies with BLS ambulances. In addition to the response and transportation charge, there are sometimes additional charges such as mileage, oxygen, and miscellaneous supplies. Plans and policies may adopt Medicare ambulance coverage policies, classifying EGMT reimbursement into BLS and two ALS levels: ALS Level 1 when a paramedic assessment or intervention is provided, or ALS Level 2 when a defined complex paramedic intervention is provided, such as endotracheal intubation or three intravenous injections.
A variety of systems deliver EMS, including public entities (fire departments, public ambulance districts, hospital systems) and private nonprofit or for-profit entities (hospitals and ambulance companies). Although 78% of the EGMT providers in California are in the public sector, these public entities only operate 19% of ambulances and account for 24% of 911 transports. While fire departments respond to most 911 medicals calls in California and employ EMTs and paramedics on their fire apparatus, most fire departments do not provide ambulance transport services. Two companies in the private sector (Global Medical Response and Falck and their subsidiaries) operate nearly half of private ambulances and provide over 75% of all California EGMT transports.
Ambulance transportation charges, including the response, mileage, and supplies components, are regulated at a local level by LEMSAs. LEMSAs set a maximum billed charge, which can vary considerably by county. The most recent comprehensive review of California’s LEMSAs, in 2014, reported that the maximum billed ambulance response charge, if inflated to 2022 dollars, can average up to $3,200 depending on the region (Los Angeles County EMS Agency, 2014). These maximum billed charges represent the ceiling; contracted or allowed rates may be substantially lower.
- Who are we talking about? According to information provided by the California Professional Firefighters (one of the sponsors of this bill), there are 62 JPAs that have some element of Fire-EMS Services. There are an additional 10 JPAs (Including Oxnard/Ventura County) that provide ambulance services and are likely to fall under the provisions of this bill.
According to the Author
The EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or "201" rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows cities in a similar position as Oxnard, cities that were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established, to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS areas, this bill also contains a "failsafe" provisions that would require the city, or fire district, that is choosing to retain their 201 rights to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
Arguments in Support
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. CPF states that this has left Oxnard unable to address the systemic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services. CPF concludes that this bill affords jurisdictions greater flexibility in how they serve their communities during emergency situations and this measure will ensure that fire departments do not lose 201 rights as a result of this court decision.
Arguments in Opposition
The 911 Ambulance Providers Alliance (911 Ambulance Providers) is opposed to this bill and states that, taken together, the three sections of this bill undermine the very heart of the EMS Act. Rather than a LEMSA coordinating prehospital emergency medical services for an entire county, its coordination can be undermined at any time by a city or fire department that chooses to opt into providing whatever level of services it deems to be financially profitable. This requires the LEMSA to then carve certain areas of its geography out from its coordination and disrupts established expectations between a LEMSA and any exclusive ambulance provider with which the LEMSA had contracted. The 911 Ambulance Providers state that such a result would be the death knell of the coordinated and integrated EMS delivery system California has spent 40 years building. Countywide exclusive operating area ambulance systems are fully funded by patient charges set by the county, and they ensure an equitable, efficient, sustainable, and coordinated response to medical emergencies. The 911 Ambulance Providers contend that cities and fire districts seek to operate ambulances so that they can use ambulance transport revenues to address skyrocketing and unsustainable public safety pension costs that have forced numerous cities into bankruptcy, including Stockton, San Bernardino, and Vallejo.
The American Federation of State and County Municipal Employees AFL-CIO states that under this bill, fire agencies would have the authority to take over ground ambulance services and then subcontract the labor back to the same private EMS companies. This would result in a system delivery model that would increase charges to patients and suppress the wages and benefits for private EMTs and paramedics, as private ambulance services would need to re-negotiate or even terminate county contracts due to a reduction in service territory. This reduction in service territory would then fracture coordinated EMS response and deprive rural and unincorporated areas of a dedicated ambulance provider.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, EMSA estimates General Fund costs of approximately $159,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and ongoing for one full-time, permanent health program specialist. EMSA reports it might also need changes to the California Emergency Medical Services Information System for addition and modification of fields, which could cost $200,000 in FY 2023-24, and $50,000 annually thereafter for maintenance (General Fund).
EMSA notes additional cost pressure if the bill results in changes to the EMS areas and sub-areas, which could have downstream impacts on EMSA. To the extent there is a reduced private provider revenue for exclusive operating areas/sub-areas, EMSA states it would need to have more oversight on plans and changes to plans.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 12-1-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Weber
NO: Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Villapudua
ASM EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Rodriguez, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Calderon, Schiavo
NO: Megan Dahle
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-2-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: May 1, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000654
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett) – As Amended Ver:May 1, 2023
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 12 - 1 |
Emergency Management | 6 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
In response to the court decision City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, this bill deems a city or fire district that, as of June 1, 1980, provided prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), to retain its authorities regarding the prehospital EMS if that city or fire district: (1) entered into an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or (2) ceased to provide prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, or (3) as of January 1, 2024, provides prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district.
This bill provides that it will become operative only if AB 716 (Boerner) of the current legislation session is enacted and takes effect on or before January 1, 2024.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) estimates General Fund costs of approximately $159,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and ongoing for one full-time, permanent health program specialist. EMSA reports it might also need changes to the California Emergency Medical Services Information System for addition and modification of fields, which could cost $200,000 in FY 2023-24, and $50,000 annually thereafter for maintenance (General Fund).
EMSA notes additional cost pressure if the bill results in changes to the EMS areas and sub-areas, which could have downstream impacts on EMSA. To the extent there is a reduced private provider revenue for exclusive operating areas/sub-areas, EMSA states it would need to have more oversight on plans and changes to plans.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The Emergency Medical Services Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201”, rights. Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in district, Oxnard, because they were part of a Joint Powers Authority (JPA) when 201 rights were established.
AB 1168 allows cities in a similar position to Oxnard, cities that were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established, to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS areas, this bill also contains a failsafe that would require the city, or fire district, that is choosing to retain their 201 rights to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. Our cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
- Background. In 1971, Ventura County (County), the City of Oxnard, and several other municipalities entered into a joint powers agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, County: (1) administers and pays for a countywide ambulance system, and (2) is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other JPA signatories. To implement the JPA, County established seven exclusive operating areas (EOAs) in which private companies provide ambulance services.
The JPA permits parties to withdraw from the agreement.
In 1980, the Legislature enacted the EMS Act, establishing statewide policies for the provision of EMS in California and granting counties the authority to designate a local emergency medical services agency (LEMSA) to administer services countywide. The EMS Act also includes a “transitional” provision that allows cities that were providing EMS services on June 1, 1980, to continue to do so until they cede the provision of services to the local agency. Pursuant to the EMS Act, County established Ventura County Emergency Medical Services Agency (VCEMSA) as the LEMSA. For more than 40 years, VCEMSA has administered the countywide EMS program, contracted with EMS providers, and submitted EMS plans for state approval. Each plan indicated VCEMSA is County’s exclusive EMS provider.
In the 2010s, Oxnard officials determined that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses as residents in more affluent areas. Consequently, in December 2020, Oxnard notified County of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could administer its own ambulance services, effective July 1, 2021. The City of Ventura requested that County not approve a contract extension with GCA, a subsidiary of American Medical Response since 2010, so it could instead contract with another ambulance provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the GCA contract extension.
Oxnard moved for a preliminary injunction to prevent County from providing ambulance services within city limits after June 30, 2021, claiming it retained authority under the EMS Act to provide such services because it was indirectly contracting for those services through the JPA. The trial court disagreed and denied Oxnard’s motion. Oxnard appealed, and the appeals court concluded there was no error in the trial court's determination that Oxnard lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. Oxnard contends it meets the criteria for grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided the JPA empowered County, not Oxnard, to contract for and administer ambulance services. The court explained Oxnard ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether Oxnard withdraws from the JPA, the city may not now resume providing those services without County's consent. This bill seeks to overturn the court’s decision in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura, to allow Oxnard to administer its own ambulance services.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
Freddie Rodriguez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1168 (
Author:Bennett) – As Amended Ver:April 19, 2023
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS
SUMMARY: Overturns existing “Oxnard” decision, and instead requires a city or fire district that contracted for, or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district enters into an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, or contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district. Specifically, this bill:
1) Requires that a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS and enters an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
2) Requires a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021), to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
3) Requires a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, which contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to existing law to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
4) Requires, if a city’s or fire district’s assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS under 1), 2), or 3) above causes a local EMS area (LEMSA) to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, all of the following to apply:
a) Requires the LEMSA to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which must be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process;
b) Authorizes, if the designated providers decline to continue services under a) above, the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
i) Creating a separate county department to provide such services;
ii) Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department;
iii) Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district to provide such services; or,
iv) Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
4) Requires, if the county determines that the service options in b) are not economically viable, the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of prehospital EMS, to enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis, as specified in existing law.
5) States that the provisions of this bill do not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a LEMSA.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point. Defines public agency to include the state, any city or county, or any public district that provides or has authority to provide firefighting, police, ambulance, or other emergency services. Prohibits these provisions of law from prohibiting or discouraging the formation of multijurisdictional or regional systems. (Government Code Section 53100)
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a public safety agency provides ambulance emergency services, to include such public safety agencies. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services. (Government Code Section 53110)
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for EMS, and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. (Health and Safety Code Section 1797)
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a LEMSA responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. (Health and Safety Code Section 1797.200)
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. (Health and Safety Code Section 1797.201)
- Permits a LEMSA to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if a LEMSA develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. (Health and Safety Code Section 1797.224)
- Establishes the Fire Protection District Law of 1987, which provides for the organization and powers of fire protection districts, and authorizes these districts to have the power to provide fire protection services, rescue services, EMS, hazardous material emergency response services, ambulance services, and any other services relating to the protection of lives and property. (Health and Safety Code Section 13800)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of the bill: According to the author, “The Emergency Medical Services Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201”, rights. Unfortunately, a recent court ruled against a city in district, Oxnard, because they were part of a Joint Powers Authority (JPA) when 201 rights were established.”
“AB 1168 allows cities in a similar position to Oxnard, cities that were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established, to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS areas, this bill also contains a failsafe that would require the city, or fire district, that is choosing to retain their 201 rights to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. Our cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them. We should not prohibit our cities and fire districts from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA,” the author concludes.
Background: In 1971, Ventura County, the City of Oxnard, and several other municipalities entered into a joint powers agreement (JPA) regarding ambulance services. Pursuant to the agreement, County: (1) administers (and pays for) a countywide ambulance system, and (2) is the only party authorized to contract with ambulance service providers on behalf of the other JPA signatories. To implement the JPA, County established seven exclusive operating areas (EOAs) in which private companies provide ambulance services. The city of Oxnard is located in EOA6, where Gold Coast Ambulance (GCA) is the service provider.
The JPA has no definite term. It permits parties to withdraw from it by providing written notice at least 180 days prior to the end of the fiscal year. Withdrawal becomes effective at the beginning of the next fiscal year. In 1980, the Legislature enacted legislation to establish statewide policies for the provision of emergency medical services (EMS) in California. The EMS Act, among other things, grants counties the authority to designate a local EMS agency to administer services countywide. The EMS Act also includes a “transitional” provision that allows cities that were providing EMS services on June 1, 1980, to continue to do so until they cede the provision of services to the local agency.
Pursuant to the EMS Act, Ventura County established Ventura County Emergency Medical Services Agency (VCEMSA) as the local EMS agency. For more than 40 years, VCEMSA has administered the countywide EMS program, contracted with EMS providers, and submitted EMS plans for state approval. Each plan has indicated that VCEMSA is County’s exclusive EMS provider.
In the 2010s, the City of Oxnard officials grew dissatisfied with the provision of ambulance services. City officials determined that residents in low- and moderate-income areas were twice as likely to experience delayed ambulance responses than residents in more affluent areas.
In December 2020, the City of Oxnard notified Ventura County of its intent to withdraw from the JPA so it could begin administering its own ambulance services effective July 1, 2021. The City of Ventura requested that Ventura County not approve a contract extension with GCA, a subsidiary of American Medical Response since 2010, so it could instead contract with another ambulance services provider. County officials rejected this request and approved the GCA contract extension.
The City of Oxnard moved for a preliminary injunction to prevent Ventura County from providing ambulance services within City limits after June 30, 2021, claiming it retained authority under the EMS Act to provide such services because it was indirectly contracting for those services through the JPA. The trial court disagreed and denied City’s motion.
In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
Ventura County’s EMS System: The Ventura County EMS System is comprised of various disciplines, including fire departments, law enforcement, ambulance services, hospitals, and other provider agencies. These agencies respond to provide lifesaving care to those in need 24 hours a day, seven days a week. From the dispatchers who talk with 9-1-1 callers and the responders who provide care in the field and transport patients, to the emergency room staff who receive the patients, the EMS Agency ensures the highest quality pre-hospital care for those in need of emergency medical services in Ventura County through an integrated and coordinated system of services.
The County of Ventura has 9 primary Public Safety Answering Points (PSAPs), including California Highway Patrol, California State University Channel Islands, Naval Base Ventura County, Oxnard Police Department, Port Hueneme Police Department, Santa Paula Police Department, Simi Valley Police Department, Ventura City Police Department and Ventura County Sheriff’s Office. When a primary PSAP receives a call for a medical or fire emergency, the call is transferred to the secondary PSAP at the Ventura County Fire Communications Center (FCC), where fire and ambulance resources are coordinated. All Fire and EMS resources in Ventura County are dispatched by FCC.
Ambulance Providers in Ventura County EMS System:
American Medical Response (AMR) - Covers the cities of Simi Valley, Moorpark, Thousand Oaks, Camarillo, Ventura, Santa Paula, Fillmore, and unincorporated areas within exclusive operating areas 2, 3, 4, 5 and 7.
Gold Coast Ambulance, a subsidiary of AMR since 2010 - Covers the city of Ojai, as well as the unincorporated areas of Oak View, Meiners Oaks and Casitas Springs designated and exclusive operating area 1 and covers the cities of Oxnard and Port Hueneme, and the surrounding unincorporated areas designated as exclusive operating area 6.
Lifeline Medical Transport (1935-2021) - On June 1, 2021, LifeLine Medical Transport (LMT), formerly known as Ojai Ambulance (OAS), sold all operating assets and transferred complete operations to Gold Coast Ambulance Service, Inc., who will continue to serve the Ojai Valley in the same scope and manner, according to VCEMSA
Other Joint Power Authorities in California: According to information provided by the California Professional Firefighters (one of the sponsors of this bill), there are 62 JPAs that have some element of Fire-EMS Services. There are 10 JPAs (Including Oxnard/Ventura County) that provide ambulance services and are likely to fall under the provisions of this bill.
The breakdown of the 61 JPAs are as follows:
- Twenty-five are dispatch only JPAs. It is unlikely that those JPAs would be impacted by this bill because all dispatch is required to be done by public agencies, as described in 2) of existing law, above.
- Twenty-five JPAs provide first responder EMS services, meaning that these agencies cooperate to respond to medical emergencies but do not provide the transportation/ambulance service.
- One JPA provides first responder EMS and dispatch services. For the reasons outlined in 1) and 2) above, it is highly unlikely that this JPA would be impacted by this bill.
- Ten JPAs currently provide ambulance service (including Oxnard). Some, as noted below, also provide additional services but it is most likely that JPAs with ambulance service would exercise the provisions of this bill. The 10 JPAs are as follows:
- El Dorado County: El Dorado County Emergency Services Authority ("West Slope JPA"). Provides ambulance services;
- El Dorado County: California Tahoe Emergency Services Operations Authority ("Cal Tahoe JPA"). Provides ambulance services;
- Marin County: Ross Valley Paramedic Authority. Provides ambulance services;
- Monterey County: Carmel Regional Fire Ambulance. Provides ambulance services;
- Ventura County: Ventura County Ambulance System Joint Powers Agreement. Provides ambulance services;
- Alameda County: Livermore-Pleasanton Fire Department Joint Powers Authority. First Responder EMS, provides ambulance services;
- Los Angeles County: Burbank-Glendale-Pasadena Airport Authority. First Responder EMS, and provides ambulance services;
- San Bernardino County: Big Bear Fire Authority. First Responder EMS, and provides ambulance services;
- Sonoma County: Sonoma Valley Fire Rescue Authority. First Responder EMS, provides ambulance services; and,
- Orange County: Orange County Fire Authority. First Responder EMS, Dispatch, and provides ambulance services.
Double Referral: The Assembly Committee on Health passed this bill on April 11, 2023.
Health Committee Amendments and AB 716 (Boerner Horvath): The Health Committee’s analysis included the following suggested amendments:
“In order to narrow the potential disruptive affect the bill could have on the 911 system, the Committee may wish to amend this bill as follows:
a) To limit the return of 201 rights to only those entities that were providing pre-hospital ambulance services as part of a JPA as of December 31, 2022, or stopped providing ambulance services as a result of the Oxnard decision on December 31, 2022;
b) To clarify that entities currently exercising their 201 rights may join a JPA for the provision of ambulance services, but still retain their 201 rights; and,
c) To make the provisions of this bill contingent upon the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner Horvath).
According to the Health Committee Chair, “the committee learned this morning from stakeholders that the committee amendments proposed have raised concerns about inadvertently broadening the bill. The intent of the amendments was to narrow the bill, protect patients and not create undue disruption within the system. Should the bill pass out of Health Committee today, my staff is committed to continuing work with stakeholders and the next policy committee to assure our amendments accomplish what was intended without the unintended consequences.”
Committee Amendments: During the Assembly Committee on Health’s hearing of this bill, concerns were expressed regarding the extent to which a fire department that withdraws from an existing Joint Powers Agreement would be held to local EMS performance standards. To address these concerns, the author may wish to take the following amendments:
d)(4) In developing contracts pursuant to this subdivision (d), the contracting parties shall collaborate on response time standards for the local EMS area, which shall meet or exceed the response time standards previously established by the local EMS agency for that area.
(d)(5) Contracts developed pursuant to this subdivision (d) shall include the local EMS agency’s EMS system requirements and the response time standards from subdivision (d)(4).
(f) This section does not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair or enlarge the local EMS agency’s ability to set response time standards for all providers within a local EMS area.
Arguments in support: The California Professional Firefighters Association write in support, “The EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of Health and Safety Code Section 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services (known as 201 rights). Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a Joint Powers Authority (JPA), an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. However, due to existing interpretation of the EMS Act, Oxnard, and cities in a similar situation, are not empowered to serve their residents and address inequities in ambulance services. The findings in Oxnard also called into question any future efforts to enter a JPA to provide ambulance services for fire agencies that currently have .201 rights, for fear that those rights will be lost, even though an agency is working to provide the best service to the residents in the immediate and surrounding area.”
The League of Cities write in support, “Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a Joint Powers Authority (JPA), an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. The Oxnard decision fundamentally misconstrues the plain language of the EMS Act as well as the nature and purpose of a Joint Powers Agreement (JPA). Additionally, Oxnard completely ignores the applicable legal principles pursuant to the Joint Exercise of Powers Act, Government Code section 6500 et seq. (JEPA), primary of which is that the parties’ delegation of powers in a JPA does not equate to a surrender of such powers. The precedent set by this ruling undermines the JEPA itself and threatens cooperative efforts among all types and levels of public agencies in California.”
Arguments in opposition: The 911 Ambulance Providers Alliance write in opposition, “As amended, AB 1168 will decimate California’s 43-year effort to coordinate and integrate prehospital ambulance services. Simply put, AB 1168 would gut the EMS Act, reduce ambulance service availability, and harm patients. AB 1168 will: 1. Deteriorate the administrative authority at local emergency medical service agencies (LEMSAs) by allowing fire chiefs to impose their will within their geographic boundaries; 2. Decimate coordination and planning by LEMSAs by giving cities and fire districts carte blanche to create fiefdoms within each county; 3. Take the wealthy and densely populated geographic regions out of the control of counties, leaving them with the impossible task of coordinating an EMS system in communities that are predominantly poor, rural and Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) in a system that is predicated on volume to support the economics; 4. Increase costs to patients and payors, including a potential $1.3 billion increase in costs to the Medi-Cal program; and 5. Fragment a coordinated system at the cost of the lives and wellbeing of Californians.”
The California State Association of Counties (CSAC), Urban Counties of California (UCC), Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC), the County Health Executives Association of California (CHEAC), and the Health Officers Association of California (HOAC), write in opposition, “AB 1168, as recently amended ,seeks to overturn an extensive statutory and case law record that has repeatedly affirmed county responsibility for the administration of emergency medical services and with that, the flexibility to design systems to equitably serve residents throughout their jurisdiction. With the passage of the Emergency Medical Services Act in 1980, California created a framework for a two-tiered system of EMS governance through both the state Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA) and LEMSAs. Counties are required by the EMS Act to create a local EMS system that is timely, safe, and equitable for all residents. To do so, counties honor .201 rights and contract with both public and private agencies to ensure coverage of underserved areas regardless of the challenges inherent in providing uniform services throughout geographically diverse areas.”
Related legislation: AB 40 (Rodriguez) of this Session. Would require EMSA to develop a public education campaign related to the use of the 911 service, and to develop a system requirement for an electronic signature for use between the emergency department (ED) and an EMT that captures the points in time when a hospital receives notification of ambulance arrival and when transfer of care is executed for documentation of ambulance patient offload time (APOT). Requires EMSA to develop a statewide standard of 30 minutes, 90% of the time for APOT. (Pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.)
AB 379 (Rodriguez) of this Session. Would require a LEMSA to adopt policies and procedures for calculating and reporting APOT. Requires a LEMSA to develop and submit an EMS system plan to the EMSA and requires the LEMSA to annually submit its emergency medical services plan for the EMS area to the authority. Require LEMSAs and EMSA to make the plans accessible on the LEMSA’s and EMSA’s internet websites within 30 days of approval by EMSA. (Pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.)
AB 716 (Boerner-Horvath) of this Session. Would delete the direct reimbursement requirement to covered medical transportation services providers that allows specified providers to balance bill enrollees and insureds and instead requires a health plan contract or a health insurance policy issued, amended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2024, to require an enrollee or insured who receives covered services from a noncontracting ground ambulance provider to pay no more than the same cost-sharing amount that the enrollee or insured would pay for the same covered services received from a contracting ground ambulance provider. (Pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.)
AB 1164 (Lowenthal) of this Session. Would require a licensed General Acute Care hospital (GACH) with an ED to determine the range of crowding scores that constitute each category of the crowding scale, as provided, for its ED. Requires the hospital to calculate and record a crowding score at a minimum every four hours, except as specified, to assess the crowding condition of the hospital’s ED. (Pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.)
Prior legislation: SB 443 (Hertzberg) of the 2021-2022 Session. Requires a city or fire district to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS, when they enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or cease to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) [Oxnard]. States that it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the scope and breadth of medical control, restrict local EMS agencies’ (LEMSAs) medical control authority over public safety agencies, clarify that a public safety agency does not transfer any of the public safety agency’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS by adhering, or agreeing to adhere, to a LEMSA’s medical control authority, and abrogate (or do away with) any contrary holdings in County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997)15 Cal.4th 909 (San Bernardino) and other judicial decisions. (Died in the Assembly Health Committee.)
AB 389 (Grayson), Chapter 460, Statutes of 2021, authorizes a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that provides those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service, and authorizes a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for these purposes. Prohibits, on and after January 1, 2022, a county from entering into or renewing these contracts unless the county board of supervisors has adopted, by ordinance or resolution, a written policy setting forth issues to be considered for inclusion in the county contract for emergency ambulance services, and the fire agency adopts a written policy that requires the subcontract to be awarded pursuant to a competitive bidding process.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Professional Firefighters
City of Hanford Fire Department
City of Oceanside
City of Oxnard
City of Ukiah
Clovis Fire Department
League of California Cities
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Sanger Fire Department
Southern Marin Fire Protection District
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
Opposition
9-1-1 Ambulance Provider's Alliance
Ambulance Association of Orange County
American Ambulance
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
American Medical Response West
Association of California Healthcare Districts; the
Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service
Board of Supervisors County of Tuolumne
Butte County Administration
California Ambulance Association
California State Association of Counties (CSAC)
Calstar Air Medical Services
Contra Costa County
County Health Executives Association of California (CHEAC)
County of Fresno
County of Kern
County of Kings
County of Lassen
County of Madera
County of Merced
County of Modoc
County of Monterey
County of Napa
County of Nevada
County of Nevada, California
County of Placer
County of Plumas
County of Sacramento
County of San Bernardino
County of Shasta
County of Tulare
County of Ventura
County of Yolo
Covalent Health
Desert Ambulance Service, INC.
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California (EMSAAC)
EMS Medical Directors Association of California (EMDAC)
Gold Coast Health Plan
International Association of EMTs and Paramedics
Lifewest Ambulance
Los Angeles County Ambulance Association
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Maxcare Ambulance
Medic Ambulance
North Coast EMS
Northern California Ems, INC.
Public Health
Opposition (continued)
Riggs Ambulance
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Joaquin County Emergency Medical Services Agency
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency
Sierra County Board of Supervisors
Trinity County Board of Supervisors
Tuolumne County Board of Supervisors
Urban Counties of California (UCC)
Analysis Prepared by: Mike Dayton / E.M. / (916) 319-3802
Date of Hearing: April 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1168
Author:(Bennett) – As Amended Ver:March 16, 2023
SUBJECT: Emergency medical services (EMS): prehospital EMS.
SUMMARY: Overturns existing “Oxnard” decision, and instead requires a city or fire district that contracted for, or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital emergency medical services (EMS), to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS when a city or fire district enters into an agreement with a county for the join exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of a judicial finding, or that contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS and enters an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
- Requires a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS through an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers that ceased to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010, to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
- Requires a city or fire district that contracted for or provided, as of June 1, 1980, prehospital EMS, which contracts with a county to provide prehospital EMS in areas outside of that city or fire district pursuant to existing law to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS.
- Requires, if a city’s or fire district’s assertion of its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS under 1), 2), or 3) above causes a local EMS area (LEMSA) to no longer satisfy the requirements for an exclusive operating area, all of the following to apply:
- Requires the LEMSA to provide a right of first refusal to the exclusive operating area’s designated providers to continue providing services in a new exclusive operating area comprised of the remainder of the local EMS area outside of the city or fire district, which must be deemed an exclusive operating area created without a competitive process;
- Authorizes, if the designated providers decline to continue services under a) above, the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, in the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis by any of the following service options:
- Creating a separate county department to provide such services;
- Assigning the duty of providing such services to the county fire department;
- Contracting with cities, districts, and other local agencies, including a city or fire district under 1), 2), or 3) above, to provide such services; or,
- Contracting with private ambulance services to provide such services.
- Requires, if the county determines that the service options in b) are not economically viable, the city or fire district asserting its authorities regarding, and administration of, the prehospital EMS pursuant to 1), 2), or 3) above, to enter an agreement with the county to provide prehospital EMS, including emergency ambulance services, within the remainder of the local EMS area on an exclusive basis consistent with 9) in existing law below.
- States that the provisions of this bill do not affect, modify, limit, or otherwise impair the medical control of the medical director of a LEMSA.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Warren-911-Emergency Assistance Act, which requires every public agency to have in operation a telephone service which automatically connects a person dialing the digits “911” to an established public safety answering point. Defines public agency to include the state, any city or county, or any public district that provides or has authority to provide firefighting, police, ambulance, or other emergency services. Prohibits these provisions of law from prohibiting or discouraging the formation of multijurisdictional or regional systems. [Government Code (GOV) §53100, et seq.]
- Requires every 911 system to include police, firefighting, and emergency medical and ambulance services. Requires every 911 system, in those areas in which a public safety agency provides ambulance emergency services, to include such public safety agencies. Permits 911 systems to incorporate private ambulance services. [GOV §53110]
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services System and the Prehospital Emergency Medical Care Personnel Act (EMS Act) to provide for a statewide system for EMS, and establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), which is responsible for the coordination and integration of all state activities concerning EMS, including the establishment of minimum standards, policies, and procedures. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1797, et seq.]
- Authorizes counties to develop an EMS program and designate a LEMSA responsible for planning and implementing an EMS system, which includes day-to-day EMS system operations. [HSC §1797.200, et seq.]
- Requires the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts providing such services as of June 1, 1980, to be retained by those cities and fire districts and to be continued at not less than the existing level until such time that a written agreement is reached between a city or fire district and a county. [HSC §1797.201]
- Permits a LEMSA to create one or more exclusive operating areas in the development of a local plan, if a competitive process is utilized to select the provider or providers of the services. Specifies that no competitive process is required if a LEMSA develops or implements a local plan that continues the use of existing providers operating within a local EMS area in the manner and scope in which the services have been provided without interruption since January 1, 1981. [HSC §1797.224]
- Establishes the Fire Protection District Law of 1987, which provides for the organization and powers of fire protection districts, and authorizes these districts to have the power to provide fire protection services, rescue services, EMS, hazardous material emergency response services, ambulance services, and any other services relating to the protection of lives and property. [HSC §13800 et seq.]
- Establishes contracting requirements for fire protection districts, and permits fire districts to contract for special services. Requires, in the case of a district with a budget in excess of $1 million, the district to follow the contracting and purchasing procedures which apply to the county government of its principal county. Requires, in the case of a district with a budget of less than $1 million, contracts in excess of $25,000 to be given to the lowest responsible bidder, and provides for a process of inviting bids. [Public Contract Code §20812]
- Prohibits a city or county from establishing equipment and personnel standards for the furnishing of nonemergency medical transportation services for eligible Medi-Cal beneficiaries which are in conflict with equipment and personnel standards for reimbursement established by the Department of Health Care Services. Prohibits a standard adopted by a city or county from requiring the use of ambulances to supply nonemergency medical transportation. Prohibits a city or county from establishing any permit, license, or inspection fees in excess of the actual cost of providing services directly associated with the provision of a permit, license, or inspection of nonemergency medical transportation vehicles. Prohibits these provisions from being construed to prevent a city or county from allowing both emergency and nonemergency medical transportation services to operate within its jurisdiction under a sole franchise when such a franchise has been determined necessary to assure the economic viability of those services. [Welfare and Institutions Code §14136)
- Finds and declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify that a city’s or fire district’s entry into a written agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS does not make the city or fire district ineligible for Section 1797.201 “201” rights, or result in the transfer, termination, relinquishment, or extinguishment of that city’s or fire district’s authorities regarding, or administration of, prehospital EMS, and to abrogate any contrary holdings in City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 1010 (Oxnard).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the EMS Act was important in establishing a statewide emergency response system so that regions could coordinate their responses effectively, but when it was passed there was an acknowledgement that certain localities should retain their EMS, or “201” rights. The author notes that, unfortunately, a court ruled against a city in his district, Oxnard, because they were part of a Joint Powers Authority (JPA) when 201 rights were established. The author states that this bill allows cities in a similar position as Oxnard, cities that were part of a JPA when 201 rights were established, to be treated like any other city and fire district and retain their legal right to provide ambulance services to their community. To minimize disruption to existing EMS areas, this bill also contains a “failsafe” provisions that would require the city, or fire district, that is choosing to retain their 201 rights to cover the surrounding EMS service area, if they cannot reach an agreement with a county. The author concludes that cities and fire districts have a deep knowledge of their communities and how to serve them, and we should not prohibit them from retaining their 201 rights, just because they were part of JPA.
- BACKGROUND. EMSA is the lead agency and centralized resource to oversee emergency and disaster medical services. Day-to-day EMS system management is the responsibility of the local and regional LEMSAs. California has 34 LEMSA systems that provide EMS for California's 58 counties. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. There are seven regional EMS agencies comprised of 32 counties and 26 single-county LEMSAs. Both single and multi-county LEMSAs develop and submit five-year EMS plans and annual updates to EMSA for a local emergency EMS system according to the state system standards and guidelines. The purpose of the local EMS plans is to meet community EMS needs through the effective utilization of local resources. Between 2019 and June 2022, there were 33 LEMSAs. In July 2022, Stanislaus County separated from Mountain-Valley EMS (a multi-county LEMSA) bringing the total number of LEMSAs to 34.
The EMS Act comprehensively regulates emergency medical care in California. Enacted in 1980, the Act provides for the creation of emergency medical procedures and protocols, certification of emergency medical personnel, and coordination of emergency responses by fire departments, ambulance services, hospitals, specialty care centers, and other providers within the local EMS system. HSC §1797.201 (Section 201), generally known as “201 rights,” was added late in the legislative process that led to the passage of the EMS Act. Section 201 was included to address concerns some cities expressed about the EMS Act’s potential impact on their authority to continue providing EMS programs they had previously started in their cities. While the goal of the EMS Act was to establish a statewide system for emergency medical response, Section 201 acknowledged the concerns of the cities and fire districts by allowing them to continue to administer EMS within the city or fire district “until such time that an agreement is reached, prehospital emergency medical services shall be continued at not less than the existing level, and the administration of prehospital EMS by cities and fire districts presently providing such services shall be retained by those cities and fire districts...” Although qualified cities and fire districts were permitted to retain administration of their EMS programs, the Legislature required “Section 201” cities and fire districts to operate in accordance with the medical control of the LEMSA medical director.- Oxnard. In Oxnard, the court concluded that there was no error in the trial court's determination that the City lacks the authority to contract for its own ambulance services under the EMS Act. In this case, the City contends it meets the criteria for Section 201 grandfathering because it contracted for ambulance services on June 1, 1980, as one of the signatories to the JPA. However, the court decided, on that date the JPA empowered the County, not the City, to contract for and administer ambulance services. Therefore, this fact challenged the City's contention. Furthermore, even if the court assumed that the provision of ambulance services is a police power, the exercise of that power is subject to constitutional constraints. The court explained that the City ceased contracting for, providing, and administering ambulance services when it signed the JPA in 1971. Regardless of whether it withdraws from the JPA, it may not now resume providing those services absent the County's consent. In two separate cases, the courts have ruled against the cities and/or fire districts and affirmed the county’s authority to ensure timely, safe, and equitable medical services via medical control. This bill seeks to overturn the Oxnard decision.
- Inequities in service? According to information supplied by the author, a study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas consistently had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. Specifically, the study evaluated ambulances from time of assignment to time arriving on scene using two different thresholds for priority (anything over eight minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards) and non-priority calls (anything over 15 minutes was evaluated as not meeting response standards). Oxnard Fire Department then combined this with data from the US Department of Urban Development regarding Low and Moderate Income (LMI) residents. Their analysis found that areas with a population of LMI residents over 50% had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulances (4,373) compared to areas with areas with a population of LMI residents that was less than 50% (2,270). This trend was shown to be persistent, going back to 2017. Additionally, Oxnard Fire Department found that the units with Oxnard’s service area spent 12% of their total time outside of the city’s service area, without full reciprocation from surrounding areas.
- City of Lomita vs County of Los Angeles (1983). This case involved cities that sued to compel the County of Los Angeles to pay for emergency ambulance services rendered to indigent residents of those cities. In finding that it was the obligation of Counties to provide emergency ambulance service for all residents of the county in need of medical care, the Court also outlined the ways in which this obligation may be fulfilled, including: i) creating a separate county department to provide emergency ambulance service; ii) assigning the duty of providing emergency ambulance service to an existing county department; iii) contracting with cities or local agencies located within the county to provide emergency ambulance services; or, iv) contracting with private ambulance companies. The provisions of this bill utilize these suggested methods to provide services to all residents of a county if/when a city re-asserts their “201” rights.
- Emergency ground medical transportation (EGMT) and payment methodologies. EGMT is provided by emergency medical technicians (EMTs) and/or paramedics who staff land ambulances. EMTs, who receive approximately 150 hours of training, can provide noninvasive basic life support (BLS) maneuvers such as oxygen therapy, cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), and bleeding control. Paramedics, who receive approximately 1,100 hours of training beyond that of EMTs, can provide invasive advanced life support (ALS), such as intravenous (IV) therapy, medication administration, and breathing tube insertion. In response to 911 calls, trained emergency medical dispatchers use software to triage whether an emergency is life threatening (necessitating a paramedic-level ALS response) or non-life threatening (necessitating an EMT-level BLS response). BLS ambulances consist of two EMTs, whereas ALS ambulances are staffed by either two paramedics or one paramedic and one EMT.
Payer reimbursement rates typically vary by patient acuity. Rates are higher for life-threatening emergencies with ALS ambulances than for non-life-threatening emergencies with BLS ambulances. In addition to the response and transportation charge, there are sometimes additional charges such as mileage, oxygen, and miscellaneous supplies. Plans and policies may adopt Medicare ambulance coverage policies, classifying EGMT reimbursement into BLS and two ALS levels: ALS Level 1 when a paramedic assessment or intervention is provided, or ALS Level 2 when a defined complex paramedic intervention is provided, such as endotracheal intubation or three intravenous injections.
A variety of systems deliver EMS, including public entities (fire departments, public ambulance districts, hospital systems) and private nonprofit or for-profit entities (hospitals and ambulance companies). Although 78% of the EGMT providers in California are in the public sector, these public entities only operate 19% of ambulances and account for 24% of 911 transports. While fire departments respond to most 911 medicals calls in California and employ EMTs and paramedics on their fire apparatus, most fire departments do not provide ambulance transport services. Two companies in the private sector (Global Medical Response and Falck and their subsidiaries) operate nearly half of private ambulances and provide over 75% of all California EGMT transports.
Ambulance transportation charges, including the response, mileage, and supplies components, are regulated at a local level by LEMSAs. LEMSAs set a maximum billed charge, which can vary considerably by county. The most recent comprehensive review of California’s LEMSAs, in 2014, reported that the maximum billed ambulance response charge, if inflated to 2022 dollars, can average up to $3,200 depending on the region (Los Angeles County EMS Agency, 2014). These maximum billed charges represent the ceiling; contracted or allowed rates may be substantially lower.
e) Who are we talking about? According to information provided by the California Professional Firefighters (one of the sponsors of this bill), there are 62 JPAs that have some element of Fire-EMS Services. There are 10 JPAs (Including Oxnard/Ventura County) that provide ambulance services and are likely to fall under the provisions of this bill.
The breakdown of the 61 JPAs are as follows:
- Twenty-five are dispatch only JPAs. It is unlikely that those JPAs would be impacted by this bill because all dispatch is required to be done by public agencies, as described in 2) of existing law, above.
- Twenty-five JPAs provide first responder EMS services, meaning that these agencies cooperate to respond to medical emergencies but do not do the transportation/ambulance service.
- One JPA provides first responder EMS and dispatch services. For the reasons outlined in 1) and 2) above, it is highly unlikely that this JPA would be impacted by this bill.
- Ten JPAs currently provide ambulance service (including Oxnard). Some, as noted below, also provide additional services but it is most likely that JPAs with ambulance service would exercise the provisions of this bill. The 10 JPAs are as follows:
- El Dorado County: El Dorado County Emergency Services Authority ("West Slope JPA"). Provides ambulance services;
- El Dorado County: California Tahoe Emergency Services Operations Authority ("Cal Tahoe JPA"). Provides ambulance services;
- Marin County: Ross Valley Paramedic Authority. Provides ambulance services;
- Monterey County: Carmel Regional Fire Ambulance. Provides ambulance services;
- Ventura County: Ventura County Ambulance System Joint Powers Agreement. Provides ambulance services;
- Alameda County: Livermore-Pleasanton Fire Department Joint Powers Authority. First Responder EMS, provides ambulance services;
- Los Angeles County: Burbank-Glendale-Pasadena Airport Authority. First Responder EMS, and provides ambulance services;
- San Bernardino County: Big Bear Fire Authority. First Responder EMS, and provides ambulance services;
- Sonoma County: Sonoma Valley Fire Rescue Authority. First Responder EMS, provides ambulance services; and,
- Orange County: Orange County Fire Authority. First Responder EMS, Dispatch, and provides ambulance services.
- SUPPORT. The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) supports this bill and states that the EMS Act was intended to balance state and local control in the interest of proving efficient and effective EMS services. The fire service plays a critical role in today’s EMS system and has been supported by the inclusion of HSC 1797.201, which explicitly allows cities and fire districts to administer emergency ambulance services within the city or fire district unless they consent to giving up their authority over emergency ambulance services, known as 201 rights. Unfortunately, 201 rights have not been interpreted as applying to cities or fire districts that were part of a JPA, an entity composed of multiple public agencies, when the EMS Act was enacted. Specifically, in City of Oxnard v County of Ventura (Oxnard) the court found that the city did not have 201 rights because when the EMS Act was established, it had already given up its right to a JPA that administers emergency ambulance services in the area. CPF states that this has left Oxnard unable to address the systemic inequities of the local emergency ambulance services. A study by the Oxnard Fire Department found that low-income areas, consistently, had nearly twice as many underperforming ambulance response times. However, due to existing interpretation of the EMS Act, Oxnard, and cities in a similar situation, are not empowered to serve their residents and address inequities in ambulance services. The findings in Oxnard also called into question any future efforts to enter a JPA to provide ambulance services for fire agencies that currently have 201 rights, for fear that those rights will be lost, even though an agency is working to provide the best service to the residents in the immediate and surrounding area.
Signatories to JPA agreements should not lose their 201 rights because they cooperated with other public agencies to provide better service to residents. CPF concludes that this bill affords jurisdictions greater flexibility in how they serve their communities during emergency situations and this measure will ensure that fire departments do not lose 201 rights as a result of this court decision.
- OPPOSITION. The 911 Ambulance Providers Alliance (911 Ambulance Providers) is opposed to this bill and states that, taken together, the three sections of this bill undermine the very heart of the EMS Act. Rather than a LEMSA coordinating prehospital emergency medical services for an entire county, its coordination can be undermined at any time by a city or fire department that chooses to opt into providing whatever level of services it deems to be financially profitable. This requires the LEMSA to then carve certain areas of its geography out from its coordination and disrupts established expectations between a LEMSA and any exclusive ambulance provider with which the LEMSA had contracted. The 911 Ambulance Providers state that such a result would be the death knell of the coordinated and integrated EMS delivery system California has spent 40 years building. Countywide exclusive operating area (EOA) ambulance systems are fully funded by patient charges set by the county, and they ensure an equitable, efficient, sustainable, and coordinated response to medical emergencies. LEMSAs would be left with the impossible task of trying to purchase emergency ambulance services for incongruous, sparsely populated, and less affluent communities (which will be disproportionately where Black, Indigenous, People of Color individuals reside). Failing that, they will be unable to ensure the provision of EMS services in their counties.
The 911 Ambulance Providers also note that they estimate approximately 70% of the current EOA providers’ staff is represented by labor unions. Every entry of a new city or fire district in the EMS system will result in a loss of jobs, creating significant disruption for the paramedics, emergency medical technicians, and other staff currently supporting the EMS system. This will only be aggravated as cities and fire districts disregard LEMSA staffing guidelines, which help ensure that ambulance crews have the medical capacity to handle prehospital emergencies in the field.
The 911 Ambulance Providers contend that cities and fire districts seek to operate ambulances so that they can use ambulance transport revenues to address skyrocketing and unsustainable public safety pension costs that have forced numerous cities into bankruptcy, including Stockton, San Bernardino, and Vallejo. Cities and fire districts will not be constrained by the charges set by a LEMSA. Instead, they will demand astronomical rates from patients in exchange for ambulance services to offset their high overhead costs. Even in the case of Medi-Cal patients, who are individually protected from charges from ambulance providers, cities and fire districts will seek exorbitant rate increases pursuant to AB 1705 (Bonta), Chapter 544, Statutes of 2019. Under AB 1705, DHCS has approved an increase to the Medi-Cal rate for emergency ambulance services by public providers by $946.92, a nearly ten-fold increase. Through this intergovernmental transfer program, DHCS estimates that Medi-Cal fee-for-service (FFS) expenditures for emergency ambulance transports will increase from $25 million to $65 million (a 2.6 times increase). Assuming that the FFS program constitutes approximately 15% of Medi-Cal transports and that public providers provide 20% of Medi-Cal transports, this would mean an increase in Medi-Cal expenditures (FFS and managed care (MCMC)) of approximately $1.3 billion for the Medi-Cal program as a whole.
The 911 Ambulance Providers conclude that without this legislation, cities and fire districts can competitively bid on county EOA ambulance contracts, but choose not to do so. This bill is an attempt to take it by force at the expense of the EMS Act and all of its successes.
The American Federation of State and County Municipal Employees (AFSCME) AFL-CIO states that under this bill, fire agencies would have the authority to take over ground ambulance services and then subcontract the labor back to the same private EMS companies. This would result in a system delivery model that would increase charges to patients and suppress the wages and benefits for private EMTs and paramedics, as private ambulance services would need to re-negotiate or even terminate county contracts due to a reduction in service territory. This reduction in service territory would then fracture coordinated EMS response and deprive rural and unincorporated areas of a dedicated ambulance provider.
When the EMS Act was passed in 1980, it was in response to the state’s historically haphazard city by city approach to prehospital emergency care, which put the safety of citizens and patients at risk. The EMS Act helped coordinate county medical control and oversight to protect patients and ensure all Californians have access to high quality emergency medical care regardless of their city of residence or socioeconomic status. AFSCME concludes that this bill would erode equitable access to emergency medical care and negatively impact the wages and benefits of EMTs and paramedics.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 40 (Rodriguez) requires EMSA to develop a public education campaign related to the use of the 911 service, and to develop a system requirement for an electronic signature for use between the emergency department (ED) and an EMT that captures the points in time when a hospital receives notification of ambulance arrival and when transfer of care is executed for documentation of ambulance patient offload time (APOT). Requires EMSA to develop a statewide standard of 20 minutes, 90% of the time for APOT. Requires a general acute care hospital (GACH) with an ED, by June 1, 2024, to develop an APOT reduction protocol, that addresses specified factors. Requires EMSA, on or after March 1, 2024, to monitor APOT for each facility that is required to report. AB 40 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- AB 379 (Rodriguez) requires a LEMSA to adopt policies and procedures for calculating and reporting APOT. Requires a LEMSA to develop and submit an EMS system plan to the EMSA and requires the LEMSA to annually submit its emergency medical services plan for the EMS area to the authority. Require LEMSAs and EMSA to make the plans accessible on the LEMSA’s and EMSA’s internet websites within 30 days of approval by EMSA. AB 379 is pending in the Assembly Committee on Emergency Management.
- AB 716 (Boerner-Horvath) deletes the direct reimbursement requirement to covered medical transportation services providers that allows specified providers to balance bill enrollees and insureds and instead requires a health plan contract or a health insurance policy issued, amended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2024, to require an enrollee or insured who receives covered services from a noncontracting ground ambulance provider to pay no more than the same cost-sharing amount that the enrollee or insured would pay for the same covered services received from a contracting ground ambulance provider. Prohibits a noncontracting ground ambulance provider from billing or sending to collections a higher amount, and prohibits a ground ambulance provider from billing an uninsured or self-pay patient more than the established payment by Medi-Cal or Medicare FFS amount, whichever is greater. Requires a plan or insurer to reimburse for ground ambulance services at the authorized rate for the specific exclusive operating area, unless it reaches another agreement with the noncontracting ground ambulance provider. AB 716 is pending in the Assembly Committee on Emergency Management.
- AB 1164 (Lowenthal) requires a licensed GACH with an ED to determine the range of crowding scores that constitute each category of the crowding scale, as provided, for its ED. Requires the hospital to calculate and record a crowding score at a minimum every four hours, except as specified, to assess the crowding condition of the hospital’s ED. Requires, by January 1, 2025, the hospital to develop and implement a full-capacity protocol for each of the categories of the crowding scale, and requires the hospital to file its protocol with the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) and to annually report any revisions to its protocol. AB 1165 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- SB 443 (Hertzberg) of 2022, requires a city or fire district to be deemed to retain its authorities regarding, and administration of, prehospital EMS, when they enter an agreement with a county for the joint exercise of powers regarding prehospital EMS, or cease to contract for, provide, or administer prehospital EMS as a result of City of Oxnard v. County of Ventura (2021) [Oxnard]. States that it is the intent of the Legislature to clarify the scope and breadth of medical control, restrict local EMS agencies’ (LEMSAs) medical control authority over public safety agencies, clarify that a public safety agency does not transfer any of the public safety agency’s authorities regarding the administration of EMS by adhering, or agreeing to adhere, to a LEMSA’s medical control authority, and abrogate (or do away with) any contrary holdings in County of San Bernardino v. City of San Bernardino (1997)15 Cal.4th 909 (San Bernardino) and other judicial decisions. SB 443 was not heard in the Assembly Health Committee.
- AB 389 (Grayson), Chapter 460, Statutes of 2021, authorizes a county to contract for emergency ambulance services with a fire agency that provides those services, in whole or in part, through a written subcontract with a private ambulance service, and authorizes a fire agency to enter into a written subcontract with a private ambulance service for these purposes. Prohibits, on and after January 1, 2022, a county from entering into or renewing these contracts unless the county board of supervisors has adopted, by ordinance or resolution, a written policy setting forth issues to be considered for inclusion in the county contract for emergency ambulance services, and the fire agency adopts a written policy that requires the subcontract to be awarded pursuant to a competitive bidding process.
- AB 1705 requires a new Medi-Cal Public Provider Intergovernmental Transfer Program for public ground emergency medical transportation providers (public ambulance providers) that would provide additional payments to these providers in FFS Medi-Cal and MCMC plans. Replaces the existing certified public expenditures program used to fund FFS public ground providers with the new intergovernmental transfer-funded program. Exempts public ambulance providers from the current Quality Assurance Fee (QAF) and the resulting Medi-Cal add on payments resulting from revenue from the QAF. Requires implementation of the new program to be on July 1, 2021
- AB 72 (Bonta and Wood), Chapter 492, Statutes of 2016, establishes a payment rate, which is the greater of the average of a health plan or health insurer’s contracted rate, as specified, or 125% of the amount Medicare reimburses for the same or similar services; and an independent dispute resolution process for claims and claim disputes related to covered services provided at a contracted health facility by a non-contracting individual health care professional for health plan contracts and health policies issued, amended, or renewed on or after July 1, 2017. Limits enrollee and insured cost sharing for these covered services to no more than the cost sharing required had the services been provided by a contracting health professional.
- DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double-referred, upon passage of this committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Emergency Management.
- POLICY COMMENT. This bill has the potential to have a significant impact on consumers. The Department of Managed Health Care has issued an All Plan Letter clarifying that ambulances are subject to the “balance billing” provisions of AB 72. However, if this bill is enacted, it is unclear whether or not fire departments would continue to be subject to AB 72. If not, they would be the only entities that would be able to balance bill (charge over contracted rates) for ambulance services, which would make providing those services much more lucrative for fire departments than for private ambulances, and provide a significant incentive to leaving a JPA in order to provide those services.
- SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS. In order to narrow the potential disruptive affect the bill could have on the 911 system, the Committee may wish to amend this bill as follows:
- To limit the return of 201 rights to only those entities that were providing pre-hospital ambulance services as part of a JPA as of December 31, 2022, or stopped providing ambulance services as a result of the Oxnard decision on December 31, 2022;
- To clarify that entities currently exercising their 201 rights may join a JPA for the provision of ambulance services, but still retain their 201 rights; and,
- To make the provisions of this bill contingent upon the enactment of AB 716 (Boerner Horvath).
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Professional Firefighters (sponsor)
League of California Cities (sponsor)
City of Oxnard
Oxnard Firefighters Local 1684
Ventura City Firefighters Association Local 3431
Ventura County Professional Firefighters Association Local 1364
Opposition
9-1-1 Ambulance Provider's Alliance
Ambulance Association of Orange County
American Ambulance
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
American Medical Response West
Association of California Healthcare Districts; the
Bell's Healdsburg Ambulance Service
California Ambulance Association
California State Association of Counties
Contra Costa County
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Lassen
County of Placer
County of Ventura
County of Yolo
Covalent Health
Desert Ambulance Service, INC.
Emergency Medical Services Administrators' Association of California (EMSAAC)
EMS Medical Directors Association of California (EMDAC)
International Association of EMTs and Paramedics
LifeWest Ambulance
Los Angeles County Ambulance Association
Madera; County of
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
MaxCare Ambulance
Medic Ambulance
Modoc County
Plumas County
Public Health
Riggs Ambulance
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
Sacramento; County of
Shasta; County of
Sierra - Sacramento Valley EMS Agency
Trinity County Board of Supervisors
Tulare; County of
Urban Counties of California (UCC)
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Emergency Management
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):