AB 1333: Single-family dwelling units: bundled sales.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-10
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-07-02: In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law regulates the transfer of property. Existing law generally permits any kind of property to be transferred, subject to specified exceptions.
This bill would prohibit a developer homebuilder of residential one to 4 dwelling units, inclusive, a new single-family dwelling unit, as defined, from conducting a bundled sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential single-family dwelling units, inclusive, under a single assessors parcel number, in a single transaction to an institutional investor, as defined, if the certificate of occupancy permit was issued for a single-family dwelling unit within the bundled sale and the contract of sale was entered into on or after January 1, 2025. The bill would exempt a homebuilder from this prohibition if the homebuilder obtains an affidavit signed under penalty of perjury from the buyer that the buyer is not an institutional investor, among other things. By expanding the crime of perjury, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would authorize the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring a civil action to enforce these provisions. If the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney prevails in the civil action, the bill would authorize a court to order the payment of a civil penalty, as specified, and reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law prescribes various requirements to be satisfied before the exercise of a power of sale under a mortgage or deed of trust and prescribes a procedure for the exercise of that power. Existing law, until January 1, 2031, for purposes of the exercise of a power of sale, prohibits a trustee from bundling properties for the purpose of sale, instead requiring each property to be bid on separately, unless the deed of trust or mortgage provides otherwise. Existing law also prohibits specified institutions that, during their immediately preceding annual reporting period, as established with their primary regulator, foreclosed on 175 or more residential real properties, containing no more than 4 dwelling units, from conducting a sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential dwelling units, inclusive, at least 2 of which have been acquired through foreclosure under a mortgage or deed of trust.
This bill would prohibit a developer of residential one to 4 dwelling units, inclusive, from conducting a sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential dwelling units, inclusive, in a single transaction to an institutional investor, as defined, if the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2024. 2025.
Existing law prescribes various requirements to be satisfied before the exercise of a power of sale under a mortgage or deed of trust and prescribes a procedure for the exercise of that power. Existing law, until January 1, 2031, for purposes of the exercise of a power of sale, prohibits a trustee from bundling properties for the purpose of sale, instead requiring each property to be bid on separately, unless the deed of trust or mortgage provides otherwise. Existing law also prohibits specified institutions that, during their immediately preceding annual reporting period, as established with their primary regulator, foreclosed on 175 or more residential real properties, containing no more than 4 dwelling units, from conducting a sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential dwelling units, inclusive, at least 2 of which have been acquired through foreclosure under a mortgage or deed of trust.
This bill would prohibit a developer of residential one to 4 dwelling units, inclusive, from conducting a sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential dwelling units, inclusive, if the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2024.
Existing law establishes a Department of Transportation in the Transportation Agency. Existing law authorizes the department to assist regional transportation planning agencies, as specified.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those provisions relating to assistance provided by the department to regional transportation planning agencies.Existing law establishes a Department of Transportation in the Transportation Agency. Existing law authorizes the department to assist regional transportation planning agencies, as specified.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to those provisions relating to assistance provided by the department to regional transportation planning agencies.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Accessory dwelling unit has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 66313 of the Government Code.
(1)(2)Bundled sale means the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four residential single-family dwelling units, inclusive, under a single assessors parcel number, in a single transaction.
(2)(A)(3)Institutional investor means an investor, investor with portfolios containing more than 1,000 units, single-family dwelling units that is not a natural person and is an entity including, but not limited to, a limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or real estate investment trust.
(4)Junior accessory dwelling unit has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 66313 of the Government Code.
(B)(5)Real estate investment trust means a publicly traded limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or other entity that may have multiple affiliated or linked entities serving as a subsidiary or parent company. has the same meaning as defined in Section 856 of the Internal Revenue Code.
(6)New single-family dwelling unit means a single-family dwelling unit, including, but not limited to, an accessory dwelling unit or a junior accessory dwelling unit, that has not been previously sold.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, a developer homebuilder of residential one to four dwelling units, inclusive, a new single-family dwelling unit shall not conduct a bundled sale to an institutional investor if the certificate of occupancy permit for a single-family dwelling unit in the bundled sale was issued and the contract of sale for the bundled sale was entered into on or after January 1, 2025.
(c)This section shall not apply to a homebuilder if the homebuilder obtains an affidavit signed under penalty of perjury from the buyer that the buyer is not an institutional investor.
(d)This section shall not limit either of the following:
(1)A homebuilders ability to construct and own a rental single-family dwelling unit for its own portfolio or the homebuilders ability to transfer a rental single-family dwelling unit to a subsidiary or parent of the homebuilder, which may be an institutional investor.
(2)An institutional investors ability to construct and own a rental single-family dwelling unit for the institutional investors own portfolio if the institutional investor acquired a controlling interest in the land before the issuance of a development permit.
(e)This section shall not affect the title of a parcel of real property. An escrow agent, settlement agent, title company, or title insurer has no duty to ensure compliance with this section and shall have no liability for a violation of this section.
(f)(1)The Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney, in the name of the people of the State of California, may bring civil action to enforce this section. If the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney prevails in an action brought pursuant to this section, the court may order both of the following:
(A)A civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each parcel of real property sold in violation of this section.
(B)Reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(2)This subdivision is the exclusive means for enforcing this section.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)For purposes of this section, bundled the following definitions apply:
(1)Bundled sale means the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive. inclusive, in a single transaction.
(2)(A)Institutional investor means an investor, with portfolios containing more than 1,000 units, that is not a natural person and is an entity including, but not limited to, a limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or real estate investment trust.
(B)Real estate investment trust means a publicly traded limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or other entity that may have multiple affiliated or linked entities serving as a subsidiary or parent company.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, a developer of residential one to four dwelling units, inclusive, shall not conduct a bundled sale to an institutional investor if the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2024. 2025.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)For purposes of this section, bundled sale means the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, a developer of residential one to four dwelling units, inclusive, shall not conduct a bundled sale if the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2024.
SECTION 1.Section 14032.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:14032.5.The department may assist regional transportation planning agencies to prepare regional transportation plans and improvement programs by providing technical services and other assistance, as determined by the director and the transportation planning agency, as necessary for the timely and comprehensive discharge of the responsibilities of the transportation planning agency.The department may assist regional transportation planning agencies with the preparation of to prepare regional transportation plans and improvement programs by providing technical services and other assistance assistance, as determined by the director and the transportation planning agency agency, as necessary for the timely and comprehensive discharge of the responsibilities of the transportation planning agency.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 2, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 1, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 48. Noes 1. Page 3883.) |
| Jan 12, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 11, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (January 11). |
| Jan 11, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jan 4, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 18, 2024 | AB 1333 Ward Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 11, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alliance Of Californians For Community Empowerment | ** Support | |
| Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Roundtable | ** Against | |
| California community builders | ** Support | |
| California Hotel & Lodging Association | ** Against | |
| California Mortgage Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Housing Now! CA Coalition | ** Support | |
| Livable California | ** Support | |
| Mission Street Neighbors | ** Support | |
| National Rental Home Council | ** Against | |
| Orange County Business Council | ** Against | |
| Southern California Leadership Council | ** Against |
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1333 (Author:Ward)
Version: June 10, 2024
Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Single-family dwelling units: bundled sales
DIGEST
This bill prohibits a homebuilder of a new single-family dwelling unit, as defined, from conducting a bundled sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 single-family dwelling units, inclusive, under a single assessor’s parcel number, in a single transaction to an institutional investor, as defined, if the certificate of occupancy was issued for a single-family dwelling unit within the bundled sale and the contract of sale was entered into on or after January 1, 2025. The bill exempts a homebuilder from this prohibition if the homebuilder obtains an affidavit signed under penalty of perjury from the buyer that the buyer is not an institutional investor, among other things. The bill authorizes the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring a civil action to enforce provisions of the bill, as specified. If the public prosecutor prevails in the civil action, the bill authorizes a court to order the payment of a civil penalty, as specified, and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The author brings this bill as a response to what he asserts is “growth in institutional investor activity in the single-family housing market.” The author specifies that the bill “is addressing the relatively recent trend of build-to rent communities, in which institutional investors will purchase large quantities of new single-family homes in bulk (typically at discount).” Materials that were submitted to the Committee do not show that entities that own 1,000 or more single-family residential properties are buying up large amounts of single-family residences in California. In 2018, investors with at least 1,000 properties owned just 2% of single-family homes and multifamily structures with 2-4 units.[1] The same report noted that mom and pop landlords with 1-2 units owned two-thirds of all small rental properties.[2] A recent Los Angeles Times article noted that the “percentage of single-family home rentals owned by large institutional investors remains small, just over 3% of the total, according to a recent Brookings Institution estimate…”[3] No California specific data was submitted to the Committee regarding investors who own 1,000 or more single-family homes. It is unclear that prohibiting homebuilders from conducting bundled sales of single-family homes to these investors will provide relief to single-family home buyers without leading to unintended consequences as described by opponents of this bill in Comment 4 of this analysis.
This bill is author sponsored. It is supported by entities that support home affordability, including Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment, Housing Now!, Livable California, and the California Association of Realtors. The bill is opposed by the California Apartment Association, the California Business Roundtable, California Mortgage Bankers Association, and National Rental Home Council.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that all property has an owner, whether that owner is the state and the property is public, or the owner is an individual and the property is private. Provides that the State may also hold property as a private proprietor. (Civ. Code § 669.)
- Bans properties from being bundled for sale at foreclosure auctions. (Civ. Code § 2924g.)
- Defines “bundled sale” as the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive, at least two of which have been acquired through foreclosure under a mortgage or deed of trust. (Civil Code § 2924p.)
- Defines “real estate investment trust” as a corporation, trust, or association which, among other things, is managed by one or more trustees or directors; the beneficial ownership of which is evidenced by transferable shares; which would be taxable as a domestic corporation; and has a beneficial ownership held by 100 or more persons. (26 USC § 856(a); Corp. Code §§ 174.5, 5063.5, 12242.5, 23000.)
This bill:
- Provides that notwithstanding any other law, a homebuilder of a new single-family dwelling unit, as defined in 10), below, shall not conduct a bundled sale, as defined in 10), below, to an institutional investor, as defined in 10), below, if the certificate of occupancy for a single-family dwelling unit in the bundled sale was issued and the contract of sale for the bundled sale was entered into on or after January 1, 2025.
- Exempts a homebuilder from the prohibitions in this bill if the homebuilder obtains an affidavit signed under penalty of perjury from the buyer that the buyer is not an institutional investor.
- Provides that this bill shall not limit a homebuilder’s ability to construct and own a rental single-family dwelling unit for its own portfolio or the homebuilder’s ability to transfer a rental single-family dwelling unit to a subsidiary or parent of the homebuilder, which may be an institutional investor.
- Provides that this bill shall not limit an institutional investor’s ability to construct and own a rental single-family dwelling unit for the institutional investor’s own portfolio if the institutional investor acquired a controlling interest in the land before the issuance of a development permit.
- Provides that this bill shall not affect the title of a parcel of real property.
- Provides that an escrow agent, settlement agent, title company, or title insurer has no duty to ensure compliance with the provisions of this bill and shall have no liability for a violation of this bill.
- Provides that the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney, in the name of the people of the State of California, may bring a civil action to enforce the provisions of this bill.
- Provides that if the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney prevails in an action brought pursuant to the provisions of this bill, the court may order both of the following: a civil penalty of $100,000 for each parcel of real property sold in violation of this bill; and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
- Specifies that the above enforcement mechanisms in 7) and 8) are the exclusive means for enforcing the provisions of this bill.
- Defines the following term:
- “accessory dwelling unit” as it is defined in Government Code § 66313 (a);
- “bundled sale” as the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four single-family dwelling units, inclusive, under a single assessor’s parcel number, in a single transaction;
- “institutional investor” as an investor with portfolios containing more than 1,000 single-family dwelling units that is not a natural person and is an entity including, but not limited to, a limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or real estate investment trust;
- “junior accessory dwelling unit” as it is defined in Government Code § 66313 (d);
- “real estate investment trust” as it is defined in Internal Revenue Code § 856;
- “new single-family dwelling unit” as a single-family dwelling unit, including, but not limited to, an accessory dwelling unit or a junior accessory dwelling unit, that has not been previously sold.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
As California continues to face an unprecedented housing crisis, investors have used their assets to take advantage of single family bulk home sales. These transactions occur when two or more homes are sold at a discounted rate of up to 20%. This growing trend allows investors to leverage their funds to take advantage of a bulk home discount and sometimes purchase hundreds of homes at a time. These transactions take the opportunity for first time home buyers to enter the market.
AB 1333 addresses this concerning trend and prohibits the bulk sale of single family homes. This will ensure that families have the ability to make an offer on a home and the opportunity to acquire generational wealth.
A report by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University specified the following[4]:
Large rental operators own a small share of the single-family rental stock
According to one estimate by Adam Travis tabulating Zillow ZTRAX data for 2018, investors with at least 1,000 properties owned just 2 percent of small rental properties (single-family homes and multifamily structures with 2-4 units), though 12 percent of properties owned by some corporate entity. By comparison, micro investors or mom and pop landlords with 1-2 units owned two-thirds (66 percent) of all small rental properties.
The same report noted that mom and pop landlords with 1-2 units owned two-thirds of all small rental properties.[5] A recent Los Angeles Times article noted that the “percentage of single-family home rentals owned by large institutional investors remains small, just over 3% of the total, according to a recent Brookings Institution estimate…”[6] The Committee was not provided with California specific data regarding investors who own 1000 or more single-family dwelling units.
The Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis for this bill explains the following regarding bundled sales and corporate landlords:
Bundled sales of real estate parcels further enhances the profitability of the corporate “build-to-rent” model. Bundled or bulk sales of real property involve the combined offering of two or more parcels as a single transaction, often at a discounted price. This can present advantages to both the buyer and the seller. For buyers, bundled transactions can offer economies of scale and cost savings. By purchasing multiple properties, buyers may obtain more strategic pricing and negotiation, as the combined value of the bundled properties can create synergies that wouldn’t be achievable in separate transactions. For the seller, bundled transactions offer at-scale sales, and decreased uncertainty. Within regions, researchers find that large corporate investors buying single-family rentals and rent-to-own units tend to concentrate their purchases at the neighborhood level, primarily in “low income, historically non-white neighborhoods that have suffered from disinvestment, but where gentrification or real estate cycle dynamics predict medium term price increases.” (Raymond, E., et al., Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta., Large corporate buyers of residential rental housing during the COVID19 pandemic in three southeastern metropolitan areas (2022), available at https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/sites.gatech.edu/dist/d/2497/files/2022/01/ERaymond-2022-CorporateLandlords_PandemicPurchases.pdf.) Supporters of this bill find this concentration of the build-to-rent model in low-income, non-white neighborhoods to be troubling. In a zero-sum housing environment, where demand far exceeds supply, resulting in higher home prices, corporate winners means individual losers. A large majority of Americans report wanting to own a home and seeing homeownership as the best marker of financial success and security. (Schmidt, G., Homeownership Remains the American Dream, Despite Challenges, (June 2, 2022) The New York Times, available at https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/02/realestate/homeownership-affordability-survey.html.)
[ . . . ]
Corporate landlords. In addition to depriving individual buyers of the opportunity to purchase homes, the rise of the corporate home ownership poses other problems. Corporate landlords are usually detached from the communities where the rental properties are located, and may be more motivated by profit-maximizing than the average “mom-and-pop” landlord. A 2017 study published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta found that corporate landlords, especially those which are large institutional investors, were far likelier than other owners to evict their tenants. (Raymond, E., et al., FRB Atlanta Community and Economic Development Discussion Paper No. 2016-4, Corporate Landlords, Institutional Investors, and Displacement: Eviction Rates in Singlefamily Rentals (2016), available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2893552.) In 2018, a Reuters special investigation of Invitation Homes, a creation of private equity giant Blackstone Group LP, found after “interviews with scores of the company’s tenants in neighborhoods across the United States, the picture that emerges isn’t as much one of exceptional service as it is one of leaky pipes, toxic mold, nonfunctioning appliances, and months-long waits for repairs.” (Michelle Conlin, Reuters, Spiders, sewage and a flurry of fees – the other side of renting a house from Wall Street (July 27, 2018), available at https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-housing-invitation/.) And just today, Attorney General Bonta announced a $3.7 million settlement with Invitation Homes to resolve allegations that it violated California’s rent cap law. (Liam Dillon, Los Angeles Times, Nation’s largest single-family home landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case (January 8, 2024), available at https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2024-01-08/invitation-homes-tenant-rent-gouging-settlement.)
3. Support
The Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment writes the following in support of AB 1333:
This would grant families and individuals the same opportunity to purchase homes, which would otherwise be sold directly to institutional investors in bulk transactions, without ever entering the market, once an occupancy permit is issued.
As California continues to face a housing crisis, investors are turning to the single family housing market to significantly increase their return on investment (ROI) for stakeholders. In 2021, it was estimated that capital investment in the single family housing market topped $45 billion dollars and expected to grow.
The surge of “build-to-rent communities” facilitated by bulk sales, is a rapidly expanding trend in California, severely limiting the ability of first-time and first-generation homeowners from competing for homes. More and more developers are selling in bulk to investors, who were not part of a housing project’s upfront financing or construction process, at a discounted rate before they are listed on the housing market. This uncompetitive practice is particularly difficult for lower income Californians as it reduces new housing stock, increasing home prices and rents.
Furthermore, homes favored by investors tend to be higher-density single family units, which are the same units most affordable to working class Californian families. In 2022, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 2170 (Grayson). This bill prohibited the “bulk sale” of foreclosed homes and required that institutions only accept offers from eligible bidders (defined as owner-occupants and affordable housing providers) during the first 30 days. Similarly, AB 1333 would grant families and individuals the opportunity to purchase homes, which would otherwise be sold directly to institutional investors in bulk, without ever entering the housing market.
Livable California writes the following in support of the bill:
California is in the midst of an affordable housing crisis. In particular, the ever increasing cost of purchasing a home is forcing more and more Californians to become long-term renters. That, in turn, prevents them from gaining a foothold in the equity that home ownership provides. Instead, more and more Californians are leaving the state in favor of places where affordable housing is available for purchase – something California cannot afford to continue to happen.
Increasingly, very large and wealthy institutional investors are buying up single-family homes and then renting them out. In the process, they deplete the pool of properties available for prospective individual homeowners. AB 1333 represents a modest effort toward leveling the playing field for individual homebuyers by preventing institutional investors from cornering the market on single-family homes. While some business interests have opposed this bill, they offer no alternative to prevent institutional investors from continuing to monopolize the housing market to the exclusion of individuals attempting to become residential homeowners.
The CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO writes the following in support of AB 1333:
As institutional investors acquire a larger number of homes, they may contribute to an increase in property prices, making it more challenging for individual households, especially first-time buyers, to enter the housing market. With their deep pockets, these institutional buyers can often outbid individual homebuyers, driving up prices in the process. This leaves first-time homebuyers struggling to compete in real estate markets where affordability already is a concern.
Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate “build-to-rent” model by prohibiting the bulk sale of single-family homes in a single transaction, and thus level the playing field between institutional investors and individual home buyers. Current “bulk sale” practices in the new home developments effectively exclude first-time and first generation homeowners from having the opportunity to submit offers on newly constructed single-family homes, affordable to our states working families for wealth generation opportunities. AB 1333 seeks to eliminate Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) ability to engage in a hidden “bulk sale” contract process.
As the state continues to grapple with housing supply deficiencies and our state’s persistent generational wealth gap, those Californians unable to own homes are denied the opportunity to generate home equity and intergenerational wealth. Study after study shows housing ownership remains the best way for working Californians to have true economic security, which has presented an even bigger affordability issue to first-time and first-generation buyers as mortgage rates climbed to a high around 8% in the past year. In fact, 43% of REALTORS® note that housing affordability is the primary reason for their clients to change county, reinforcing the “drive until you can buy” practice, which is not in alliance with our state’s environmental policy priorities.
Since 2010, the median price of single families’ homes more than doubled from $305,010 to $659,380 in 2020. Today, our median single-family home in California costs $822,200, likely due to seasonal factors, as the median price of housing has remained near $840,000 since its peak high of $849,000 in March 2022.
This is a widespread problem for educators in the state, many of whom cannot afford to live in the districts in which they work. One of the foundational blocks of public education is that the education workforce should also be members of the school community. Educators are able to connect with students and have greater accountability when they live in the communities in which they teach. Furthermore, long commutes for educators lead to higher rates of burn-out for certificated and classified staff alike.
Housing Now! writes the following in support of the bill:
As California continues to face a housing crisis, investors are turning to the single family housing market to significantly increase their return on investment (ROI) for stakeholders. In 2021, it was estimated that capital investment in the single family housing market topped $45 billion dollars and expected to grow.
The surge of “build to rent communities” facilitated by bulk sales, is a rapidly expanding trend in California, severely limiting the ability of first-time and first- generation homeowners from competing for homes. More and more developers are selling in bulk to investors at a discounted rate before they are listed on the housing market. This practice is particularly difficult for lower income Californians because it reduces new housing stock increasing home prices and rents.
Furthermore, homes favored by investors tend to be higher density single family units, which provide higher ROI’s, but are the same units affordable to working class Californian families.
The California Association of Realtors writes the following in support of AB 1333:
REITs have evolved their investment strategies to include the purchase of NEWLY constructed market rate housing. REITs were established during the Great Recession and flourished with their initial investments and “bulk” purchase opportunities that were facilitated by a robust foreclosure market, which negatively impacted a generation of homebuyers affected by the foreclosure crisis. REITs retain ownership of parcels that have the largest return on investment (ROI), which tend to be higher density single family attached and detached units, most affordable to our states working families who desire to owner occupy an entry level market rate home. These investments have paid large dividends to their stockholders. However, federal regulations eventually eliminated “bulk” sales practices for federally backed loan securities, which has been codified into California state statute.
As REITs looked for new investment opportunities with their vast resources, build-to-rent single family, attached and detached, neighborhoods presented an opportunity to increase property holdings, provided the REIT can purchase a large number of homes in “bulk,” at a discounted price from new home developers. Focused on generating larger ROI earnings for their stockholders, the REITs have found that investment in “build-to-rent” homes has a much higher ROI then an apartment with the same number of bedrooms because tenants are willing to pay significantly higher amount in rent for a house with a yard, garage, and storage space. As a result, rental rates for single-family homes have been growing almost 50% faster than rates for multi-family buildings.
Build-to-rent properties are usually smaller, more basic home models, affordable to first-time and first-generation homebuyers. The number of US renters has been steadily rising since the housing market crash of 2007. Thanks to student debt and lagging incomes, many millennials are renting, instead of owning a home, as they begin starting their families, while they contend with their existing debt obligations.
[ . . . ]
Renting costs more over time to families. Through homeownership families have the opportunity to eventually pay off the mortgage. It is also almost impossible for families to compete these large scale investors, a trend which began during the great recession and has persisted since growing into this new threat to familial homeownership opportunities as many markets, especially large metropolitan areas, little is available under $500,000.
[ . . . ]
Currently, families wishing to purchase an existing median-priced single-family home in November 2023 of $822,320 must make a minimum annual income of $186,800 in 2023. The 2022 California median income for Whites was $105,640, $120,040 for Asians, $76,310 for Hispanics/Latinos and $64,190 for Blacks (California Association of REALTORS®: Research and Economics Department).
“Build-to-rent” investments within the single-family attached and detached housing market has increased in popularity. A major driver of build-to-rent growth is the immense available capital. Since 2007, REIT investment in the single-family home market has significantly grown in popularity as financing is readily available from various lending sources (i.e., banks, insurance companies, quasi-government lending agencies - Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) along with real estate crowdfunding (e.g., Crowdstreet raised $2.1 billion in capital for property investments with an advertised rate of return on investment of 17.1%) and retirement investment platforms, akin to mutual funds that hold real estate instead of stocks and bonds, which invest billions of dollars annually into new home acquisition.
Families seeking to owner occupy a home can’t compete with an all-cash REIT offers and won’t get a chance to make an offer when REITs purchase homes in “bulk”. 41% of households in new build-to-rent homes are under 35, versus 25% of households in new, owner occupied single-family homes. The median household income for renters living in newly built single family rentals is $77,000, compared to just $42,000 among all renter households. This indicates build-to-rent properties are becoming increasingly popular even among higher-income households as entry level homeownership housing opportunities remain scarce. If the price of single-family homes continues to rise, as it has in the past several decades, we may see an entire generation of renters and our single-family neighborhoods dominated by renters and not homeowners who traditionally are more vested in their communities, which only serves to widen our states generational wealth gap, as working families face exclusion from the dream of homeownership if we continue to favor large scale “bulk” purchases of our states NEW market rate homeownership housing stock.
4. Opposition
The National Rental Home Council writes the following in opposition to AB 1333:
AB 1333 seeks to limit bundled sales to institutional investors of newly constructed single family homes to no more than two units per transaction. The bill presumes that investors purchase homes after they are constructed, issued a certificate of occupancy and offered for sale to the public, where companies are competing with traditional new home buyers. This is not how Build to Rent communities are developed and the perceived competition with new buyers is not taking place at all.
The construction of Build to Rent communities is financed by institutional investors, including public pension funds. The new housing units would not be constructed at all but for the initiative of Build to Rent developers. The homes do not go on sale to the general public and thus, there is no competition with traditional homebuyers, which AB 1333 purports to prevent. The Build to Rent activity in California is in fact adding to our housing stock and providing a contribution to solving our state’s housing shortage. The language of AB 1333 will have a detrimental effect by discouraging investment in new housing and will slow California's emergence from the housing crisis.
The California Apartment Association and California Mortgage Bankers Association write the following in opposition to AB 1333:
[ . . . ] our organizations continue to oppose (unless amended) AB 1333, your bill that would prohibit a homebuilder of a new single-family dwelling unit, as defined, from conducting a bundled sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four single family dwelling units, inclusive, under a single assessor’s parcel number, in a single transaction to an institutional investor, as defined, if the certificate of occupancy was issued for a single-family dwelling unit within the bundled sale and the contract of sale was entered into on or after January 1, 2025.
AB 1333, in its current form, would prohibit the development of new “build to rent” (BTR) communities in California, despite the clear need for more housing across the State. We acknowledge that AB 1333 provides that a bundled sale does not limit an institutional investor’s ability to construct and hold single family dwelling units or BTR communities if the institutional investor acquired a controlling interest in the land before the issuance of a development permit. The language, however, appears to prohibit the sale of BTR communities as a single asset (as a bundled sale) at a later time, despite the fact that they were purposely built as rental home communities from the outset.
This prohibition on the sale of BTR communities as a single asset would deter or completely eliminate institutional investor interest in financing the construction of new BTR communities despite the strong market demand for rental home communities as an alternative to home ownership. The financing for construction of these communities—which, at times, comes from pension funds like CalSTRS—often requires that the communities be sold as a single asset as a condition of that investment. For these reasons, we believe that AB 1333 must be amended to ensure that BTR communities—which are adding to California’s much needed housing supply—can continue to be built.
The California Business Roundtable writes the following in opposition to AB 1333[7]:
AB 1333 imposes undue restrictions on business entities by limiting the sale of new single-family residential properties by homebuilders. This limitation undermines the principles of free enterprise and hampers investment opportunities in the real estate market. By restricting business entities' ability to participate in property acquisition and leasing, the bill reduces choices for both property owners and tenants.
This bill is also likely to increase rental costs by further constraining the rental market's ability to keep up with demand, thereby undermining the very intent of the bill to increase housing affordability. Research from the University of Amsterdam and Erasmus University in 2023 showed that similar bans in the Netherlands reduced investor purchases without significantly impacting home prices or property sales. Instead, the ban led to higher rental prices.
Given California’s current economic challenges—including a projected $45 billion budget deficit, the highest electricity and gas prices, and the highest unemployment rate in the nation, all of which affect housing affordability for homeowners and renters alike—it is imperative to consider the long-term unintended consequences of this legislation. According to the LAO, California’s budgetary challenges are partly due to a decline in new business investments in the state. Businesses need certainty to invest and grow here. California needs more housing, and corporations play a critical role in building it.
We are particularly concerned that AB 1333 will have a chilling effect on development. A recent LA Times article highlights the growing demand for build-for-rent developments. For businesses to meet this demand, they need certainty that they can exit the market in order to enter it. Limiting this ability increases the risk for businesses to enter, especially when compounded by impending multibillion-dollar tax increases on businesses outlined in the budget. Continuously stripping away economic tools, as AB 1333 seeks to do, is likely to exacerbate the state’s business climate without effectively addressing housing affordability.
AB 1333 fails to address the root causes of housing affordability and supply in California. Instead, we urge you to focus on comprehensive solutions that address supply constraints and promote affordable and market-rate housing development.
5. California Building Industry Association desired amendments
Should this bill pass out of this Committee, the author would like to amend the bill with provisions that will remove the opposition of the California Building Industry Association, the California Hotel & Lodging Association, California Business Properties Association, Orange County Business Council, Southern California Leadership Council, and Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles. According to the California Building Industry Association:
CBIA represents the state’s approximately 3,000 member companies within the home construction industry who collectively produce over 80% of all new homes built and sold annually in California. The other organizations listed above have a vested interest in increasing the supply of housing of all types to meet the needs of California workers. We appreciate the author and sponsor’s willingness to work with us to minimize the damage to the production of new homes that may have resulted from AB 1333 unintentionally. We have one outstanding issue – ensuring that when a homebuilder buys another homebuilder, the acquiring homebuilder is not considered an institutional investor. We suggest the following amendment to address this issue:
(a) ….
(3) (A) “Institutional investor” means an investor with portfolios containing more than 1,000 single family dwelling units that is not a natural person and is an entity including, but not limited to, a limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or real estate investment trust.
(B) A homebuilder that is not a real estate investment trust is not an institutional investor when merging with, or acquiring assets from, or control of another homebuilder. However, single family dwelling units acquired in the merger or acquisition shall not be considered “sold” for the purpose of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a), and the next sale of those dwelling units may not be in a bundled sale.
To be clear, this amendment would not remove the opposition of the other entities that are opposed to this bill.
SUPPORT
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment
California Association of Realtor
California Community Builders
CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO
Housing Now! CA Coalition
Livable California
Mission Street Neighbors
OPPOSITION
Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
National Rental Home Council
Orange County Business Council
Southern California Leadership Council
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 1212 (Skinner, 2024) places restrictions on Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) purchasing housing, as defined, and places restrictions on REITs selling housing, as provided. AB 2584 is currently in this Committee.
AB 2230 (Bennett, 2024) enacts the Residential Housing Unfair Practices Act of 2023, to: (1) bring residential housing within the purview of the Cartwright Act, the Unfair Practices Act, and the Unfair Competition Law to prevent market manipulation of housing prices and supply during the period of the previously declared statewide housing emergency; and (2) ensure that residential housing is developed and managed to be responsive to the needs, demands, and pricing affordable to residents of our state and not to the needs, demands, and pricing desired by nonresident investors or speculators. The bill is currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2584 (Lee, 2024) prohibits a business entity, as defined, that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. If the business entity violates this law then the Attorney General is entitled to bring an action in court. If the Attorney General prevails then the court is required to make the business entity pay $100,000 in civil penalties and the court is required to force the business entity to sell the property to an independent entity, which is not defined, within one year of the date the court enters judgment. The Court must also order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to be paid to the Attorney General and any other relief the court deems appropriate. This bill is scheduled to be heard in this Committee on the same day as AB 1333.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2170 (Grayson, Ch. 865, Stats. 2022) established a state-level “First Look” program, in which individuals, nonprofits, and public entities would have a 30-day window to make offers on post-foreclosure properties that are put up for sale by large lending institutions.
SB 1079 (Skinner, Ch. 202, Stats. 2020) prohibited a foreclosure trustee from bundling properties for sale at a foreclosure auction, instead requiring that each property be bid on separately. Provided an eligible bidder, as defined, 45 days after a home foreclosure auction to make an offer for the home that exceeds the highest bid.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 48, Noes 1)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 0)
**************
8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-family Rental Market, Alexander Hermann (July 18, 2023) available at: 8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-Family Rental Market | Joint Center for Housing Studies (harvard.edu) as of June 20, 2024. ↑
Id. ↑
Nation’s largest single-family home landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case, Los Angeles Times, Liam Dillon (Jan. 8, 2024), available at: Landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case - Los Angeles Times (latimes.com) [as of June 30, 2024] ↑
8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-family Rental Market, Alexander Hermann (July 18, 2023) available at: 8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-Family Rental Market | Joint Center for Housing Studies (harvard.edu) as of June 20, 2024. ↑
Id. ↑
Nation’s largest single-family home landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case, Los Angeles Times, Liam Dillon (Jan. 8, 2024), available at: Landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case - Los Angeles Times (latimes.com) [as of June 30, 2024] ↑
This is the Los Angeles Times article cited in this block quote: Dillon, L. (2024, June 13). New rental developments are changing the American dream of suburban homeownership. The Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/build-to-rent-american-dream-homeownership; This is the Netherlands study cited to in the block quote: Francke, M., Hans, L., Korevaar, M., & van Bekkum, S. (2023, June 15). Buy-to-live vs. buy-to-let: The impact of real estate investors on housing costs and neighborhoods. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4480261 ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1333
Author:(Ward)
As Amended Ver:January 3, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits institutional investors from purchasing more than one parcel of real property in a single transaction.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits a developer of residential one to four dwelling units from conducting a bundled sale of real property to an institutional investor.
- Applies the restriction in 1) only to properties for which the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2025.
- Defines "bundled sale" as the sale of two or more parcels real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive, in single transaction.
- Defines "institutional investor" as an entity that is not a natural person and having portfolios containing more than 1,000 units.
- Defines "real estate investment trust" as a publicly traded limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or other entity that may have multiple affiliated or linked entities serving as a subsidiary or parent company.
COMMENTS
California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially of affordable entry-level homes—is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate "build-to-rent" model by prohibiting the bulk sale of single-family homes in a single transaction, and thus level the playing field between institutional investors and individual home buyers.
The rise of the corporate single-family rental. The overwhelming majority of single-family rentals are owned by smaller landlords. In June 2021, the Urban Land Institute reported that small-scale investors own 97 percent of the nation's single-family rental inventory, meaning that the share of institutional investors is just three percent. (Congressional Research Service, Single-Family Market Rents and Institutional Investors, October 3, 2022, available at https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12225.) This report defined "institutional investors" as those owning more than 2,000 units. According to a 2022 report by the National Association of Realtors, institutional buyers—which they defined as companies, corporations, or limited liability companies (LLCs) regardless of the number of units owned—made up 13% of the residential sales market in 2021, with the median purchase price of institutional buyers typically 26 percent lower than the states' median purchase prices. (National Association of Realtors, Impact of Institutional Buyers on Home Sales and Single Family Rentals (May 2022), available at https://www.nar.realtor/sites/default/files/documents/2022-impact-of-institutional-buyers-on-home-sales-and-single-family-rentals-05-12-2022.pdf.) Thus, though currently small, the influence of corporate landlords raises serious concerns about home affordability and availability—particularly in a market with constrained inventory.
Institutional investors had long avoided the single-family market because of the challenge of managing dispersed properties. (Mari, New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/04/magazine/wall-street-landlords.html.) Digital technologies, including improved data and analytics, however, have transformed the single-family rental market. (Fields, D., Vergerio, UC Berkeley, Corporate landlords and market power: What does the single-family rental boom mean for our housing future? (2022), available at https://escholarship.org/uc/item/07d6445s.) Technology has made both purchasing and managing dispersed rental properties more efficient and profitable. Corporate owners can use digital tools to acquire property quickly and can use other tools to screen applicants, accept payments, manage maintenance requests, and gather data on rental markets.
Bundled sales of real estate parcels further enhances the profitability of the corporate "build-to-rent" model. Bundled or bulk sales of real property involve the combined offering of two or more parcels as a single transaction, often at a discounted price. This can present advantages to both the buyer and the seller. For buyers, bundled transactions can offer economies of scale and cost savings. By purchasing multiple properties, buyers may obtain more strategic pricing and negotiation, as the combined value of the bundled properties can create synergies that wouldn't be achievable in separate transactions. For the seller, bundled transactions offer at-scale sales, and decreased uncertainty. Within regions, researchers find that large corporate investors buying single-family rentals and rent-to-own units tend to concentrate their purchases at the neighborhood level, primarily in "low income, historically non-white neighborhoods that have suffered from disinvestment, but where gentrification or real estate cycle dynamics predict medium term price increases." (Raymond, E., et al., Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta., Large corporate buyers of residential rental housing during the COVID19 pandemic in three southeastern metropolitan areas (2022), available at https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/sites.gatech.edu/dist/d/2497/files/2022/01/ERaymond-2022-CorporateLandlords_PandemicPurchases.pdf.) Supporters of this bill find this concentration of the build-to-rent model in low-income, non-white neighborhoods to be troubling. In a zero-sum housing environment, where demand far exceeds supply, resulting in higher home prices, corporate winners means individual losers. A large majority of Americans report wanting to own a home and seeing homeownership as the best marker of financial success and security. (Schmidt, G., Homeownership Remains the American Dream, Despite Challenges, (June 2, 2022) The New York Times, available at https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/02/realestate/homeownership-affordability-survey.html.)
Opponents of this bill see the concentration of institutional capital in low-income areas as a societal positive: corporate rentals provide a desired product for those wanting the advantages of single-home living without the burden. They point to single mothers and professional women who do not want the maintenance costs, responsibilities, and interruptions of their daily schedules that come with owner occupancy of older homes, but who do want the quiet, privacy, and space that living in a single-family home provides.
This bill seeks to stem the tide of corporate "build-to-rent" single-family home ownership in the state. The author's concern in bringing this measure is that as institutional investors acquire a larger number of homes, they may contribute to an increase in property prices, making it more challenging for individual households, especially first-time buyers, to enter the housing market. With their deep pockets, these buyers can often outbid individual homebuyers, driving up prices in the process. This leaves first-time homebuyers struggling to compete in markets where affordability is already a concern. As institutional buyers purchase large numbers of homes, the reduced inventory further exacerbates the problem. Furthermore, the concentration of single-family homes in the hands of institutional investors can lead to a reduction in the overall supply of affordable rental properties. This dynamic may exacerbate housing shortages and may also drive up rental prices, negatively affecting lower-income families who rely on affordable rental housing.
How this bill works. Rather than prohibiting institutional investors from purchasing single-family homes, this bill attempts to reduce the financial incentive for institutional investors from entering the "build-to-rent" model by targeting the bulk-purchase process. This bill does not prohibit any buyer from purchasing single-family homes; nor does it prohibit a home from being built for the purpose of becoming a rental. This bill is narrowly tailored to apply to bulk purchases of residential dwelling units, defined as two or more parcels containing one to four units in a single transaction, by institutional investors on new properties.
Opponents of this measure raise certain issues about the impact of the bill that the author may wish to address as this bill moves through the Legislature, such as its impact on sales that occur as a result of mergers, acquisitions, bankruptcies, or foreclosures. In such cases, the acquirer is acquiring homes under construction or just finished and in the process of being sold. By preventing these types of homes from being bundled and sold, the result may be them sitting vacant and un-financeable by an individual buyer, further decreasing the inventory of available property—whether for sale or rent. As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to exempt transactions that take place as mergers, acquisitions, bankruptcies, or foreclosures from the bill. The author may also wish to consider replacing the term "developer" with the term "home builder" to better capture the bill's intent.
According to the Author
As California continues to face an unprecedented housing crisis, investors have used their assets to take advantage of single family bulk home sales. These transactions occur when two or more homes are sold at a discounted rate of up to 20%. This growing trend allows investors to leverage their funds to take advantage of a bulk home discount and sometimes purchase hundreds of homes at a time. These transactions take the opportunity for first time home buyers to enter the market.
AB 1333 addresses this concerning trend and prohibits the bulk sale of single family homes. This will ensure that families have the ability to make an offer on a home and the opportunity to acquire generational wealth.
Arguments in Support
According to the California Association of Realtors:
Current "bulk sale" practices in the new home developments effectively exclude first-time and first-generation homeowners from having the opportunity to submit offers on newly constructed single-family homes, affordable to our states working families for wealth generation opportunities. As proposed to be amended, AB 1333 seeks to eliminate Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) ability to engage in a hidden "bulk sale" contract process.
As the state continues to grapple with housing supply deficiencies and our states persistent generational wealth gap, those Californians unable to owner occupy homes are denied the opportunity to generate home equity and intergenerational wealth. Study after study shows ownership housing remains the best way for working Californians to have true economic security, has presented an even bigger affordability issue to first-time and first-generation buyers as mortgage rates climbed to a high around 8% in the past year. In fact, 43% of REALTORS® note that housing affordability is the primary reason for their clients to change county, reinforcing the "drive until you can buy" practice, which is not in alliance with our states environmental policy priorities.
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of business organizations, including the California Building Industry Association and California Apartment Association, list this measure as a "Housing Killer" and argue as follows:
The intent of this bill appears to be directed at eliminating single family detached residential projects as rental communities to the extent that they are owned by institutional investors. It is important that this bill be narrowly tailored to avoid unintended consequences. The leading demographic for this type of project is single mothers and professional women who do not want the maintenance costs and interruptions of their daily schedules, that come with owner occupancy of older homes. In addition, they are looking for a yard for their children to play in and the quiet and privacy that comes from living in a structure without shared walls. While renting does not come with the same payment stability as ownership, there are legitimate reasons why people choose to rent, including but not limited to: 1) jobs that require frequent moving, 2) needing time to save for a down payment, or 3) not wanting the responsibility of homeownership. In any case, people need shelter and rental housing is a part of the solution.
According to the Department of Housing and Community Development, California needs 2.5 million more homes. Even if the bill were amended to narrow the prohibition on selling homes to apply to a larger number of units to the same buyer, it would still make no sense to prohibit the construction and sale of more housing of the types of housing mentioned above, whether for sale or for rent. We need more of both. AB 1333 moves California in the opposite direction.
The National Home Rental Council also opposes this measure:
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. AB 1333 could result in unintended consequences for Californians who wish to live in a single family home, but purchasing may be out of reach in this high-cost market. NRHC members can make single family rental opportunities available in brand new homes to Californians where living in a single family home is the preferred choice. In our current high interest rate environment, coupled with high housing costs, brand new rental homes can be very suitable opportunities for those seeking single family home housing options. AB 1333 will artificially slow this availability, which will be counterproductive to bringing new rental housing to market for Californians as quickly as possible.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-0-3
YES: Kalra, Wicks, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, Pacheco, McKinnor
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Sanchez, Waldron
UPDATED
VERSION: January 3, 2024
CONSULTANT: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002575
Date of Hearing: January 11, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1333
Author:(Ward) – As Amended January 3, 2024Ver:January 3, 2024
SUBJECT: Residential real property: bundled sales
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO INCREASE OWNER OCCUPANCY OF SINGLE-FAMILY HOMES, SHOULD CALIFORNIA PROHIBIT HOUSING DEVELOPERS FROM SeLling TWO OR MORE “Bundled” PARCELS OF LAND TO INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS WHOSE PORTFOLIOS CONTAIN MORE THAN 1,000 HOUSING UNITS?
SYNOPSIS
California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially affordable entry-level homes—in the state is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. As institutional investors acquire a larger number of homes, they may contribute to an increase in property prices, making it more challenging for individual households, especially first-time buyers, to enter the housing market. With their deep pockets, these institutional buyers can often outbid individual homebuyers, driving up prices in the process. This leaves first-time homebuyers struggling to compete in real estate markets where affordability already is a concern.
Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate “build-to-rent” model by prohibiting the bulk sale of single-family homes in a single transaction, and thus level the playing field between institutional investors and individual home buyers. This author-sponsored bill is modeled after AB 2170, which prohibited the bulk sale of foreclosed properties in order to afford more individuals—as opposed to institutional investors—the opportunity to purchase single-family homes. Opponents of this bill argue that institutional investors make up a tiny fraction of landlords in California. They argue that this measure would not produce the desired result, but instead could unintentionally result in fewer homes being built, and a reduced supply of rentals, when those are also deeply needed. This measure is supported by the California Association of Realtors, and is opposed by the National Rental Home Council and a coalition of business organizations, including the California Building Industry Association and the California Apartment Association.
SUMMARY: Prohibits institutional investors from purchasing more than one parcel of real property in a single transaction. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a developer of residential one to four dwelling units from conducting a bundled sale of real property to an institutional investor.
- Applies the restriction in 1) only to properties for which the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2025.
- Defines “bundled sale” as the sale of two or more parcels real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive, in single transaction.
- Defines “institutional investor” as an entity that is not a natural person and having portfolios containing more than 1,000 units.
- Defines “real estate investment trust” as a publicly traded limited liability company, limited liability partnership, or other entity that may have multiple affiliated or linked entities serving as a subsidiary or parent company.
EXISTING LAW:
- Bans properties from being bundled for sale at foreclosure auctions. (Civil Code Section 2924g.)
- Defines “bundled sale” as the sale of two or more parcels of real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive, at least two of which have been acquired through foreclosure under a mortgage or deed of trust. (Civil Code Section 2924p.)
- Defines “real estate investment trust” as a corporation, trust, or association which, among other things, is managed by one or more trustees or directors; the beneficial ownership of which is evidenced by transferable shares; which would be taxable as a domestic corporation; and has a beneficial ownership held by 100 or more persons. (26 United States Code Section 856(a); Corporations Code Sections 174.5, 5063.5, 12242.5, 23000.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially of affordable entry-level homes—is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate “build-to-rent” model by prohibiting the bulk sale of single-family homes in a single transaction, and thus level the playing field between institutional investors and individual home buyers.
According to the author:
As California continues to face an unprecedented housing crisis, investors have used their assets to take advantage of single family bulk home sales. These transactions occur when two or more homes are sold at a discounted rate of up to 20%. This growing trend allows investors to leverage their funds to take advantage of a bulk home discount and sometimes purchase hundreds of homes at a time. These transactions take the opportunity for first time home buyers to enter the market.
AB 1333 addresses this concerning trend and prohibits the bulk sale of single family homes. This will ensure that families have the ability to make an offer on a home and the opportunity to acquire generational wealth.
The housing affordability crisis. Housing affordability is a primary concern of this California legislature—and rightfully so. According to C.A.R.’s Traditional Housing Affordability Index (HAI), California hit a peak high affordability index of 56 percent in 2012. Ten years later, however, only 21 percent of California households could afford to purchase the median-priced home $790,020, down from 27 percent at the end of 2021. (California Association of Realtors Housing Affordability Index, Data for the 4th quarter of 2022, available at https://www.car.org/marketdata/data/haitraditional.) A major cause of our housing crisis is the mismatch between the supply of housing and the demand for housing. In 2022, the Statewide Housing Plan adopted by the Housing and Community Development Department (HCD) found that California needs approximately 2.5 million units of housing, including one million units that are affordable to lower income households, in order to address this mismatch. (HCD, California Statewide Housing Plan: A Home for Every Californian (March 2022), available at https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/94729ab1648d43b1811c1698a748c136.) That would require production of over 300,000 units a year, including over 120,000 units a year of housing affordable to lower income households. By contrast, housing production in the past decade has been under 80,000 units per year. (HCD, Addressing a Variety of Housing Challenges, available at https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-and-research/addressing-variety-housing-challenges (last accessed Jan. 8, 2024).
The decline of owner-occupancy rates in California. The lack of affordable housing, likely in combination with other interrelated factors, such as demographic shifts delaying in life-cycle milestones such as marriage and childbearing (or the decision to forego those milestones altogether), has resulted in a decline in home ownership. In 2022, California’s homeownership rate—the percentage of California homes owned by their occupants—stood at 55.3%, one percent higher than the preceding year. (U.S Census Bureau, Homeownership Rate for California, available at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CAHOWN.) This rate is down from a high of 60.2 percent in 2006, at the peak of the housing bubble, and represents a trend of decreasing home-ownership since the Great Recession. (Ibid.) The decline was even more stark for younger Californians aged 35–45. For that group, the share who owned a home declined from 49.5 percent to 39.7, almost 10 percentage points from 2000 to 2021. (Shoag, et al., Terner Center for Housing Innovation, U.C. Berkeley, The First Step Is The Hardest: California’s Sliding Homeownership Ladder (May 2023), available at https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Homeownership-Ladder-May-2023-Final.pdf,)
While more pronounced in California, this reflects a national trend. According to census data, between 2007 and 2017, the United States added less than 1 million households in owner-occupied homes, but 6.5 million in renter-occupied homes. The national homeownership rate bottomed out at 62.9 percent in 2016, down from a high of 69 percent in 2005. (U.S. Census Bureau, Homeownership Rate in the United States, available at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N.) The decline in homeownership has resulted in a corresponding increase in rental demand, and a corresponding untenable increase in rental rates. The majority of Californian renters—more than 3 million households—pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent, and nearly one-third—more than 1.5 million households—pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent. (https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-and-research/addressing-variety-housing-challenges.) Those renting are increasingly looking for single-family residences. An estimated 39 percent of rental housing units in the United States are single-family dwellings. (Real Estate Consulting, Single-Family Rental Housing – Institutional Opportunities (August 9, 2022) available at https://www.rclco.com/publication/prea-quarterly-single-family-rental-housing-institutional-opportunities/.)
The rise of the corporate single-family rental. The overwhelming majority of single-family rentals are owned by smaller landlords. In June 2021, the Urban Land Institute reported that small-scale investors own 97 percent of the nation’s single-family rental inventory, meaning that the share of institutional investors is just three percent. (Congressional Research Service, Single-Family Market Rents and Institutional Investors, October 3, 2022, available at https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12225.) This report defined “institutional investors” as those owning more than 2,000 units. According to a 2022 report by the National Association of Realtors, institutional buyers—which they defined as companies, corporations, or limited liability companies (LLCs) regardless of the number of units owned—made up 13 percent of the residential sales market in 2021, with the median purchase price of institutional buyers typically 26 percent lower than the states’ median purchase prices. (National Association of Realtors, Impact of Institutional Buyers on Home Sales and Single Family Rentals (May 2022), available at https://www.nar.realtor/sites/default/files/documents/2022-impact-of-institutional-buyers-on-home-sales-and-single-family-rentals-05-12-2022.pdf.) Thus, though currently small, the influence of corporate landlords raises serious concerns about home affordability and availability—particularly in a market with constrained inventory.
Corporate ownership of single-family homes is a newer phenomenon. The increase in institutional investors began during the Great Recession, when housing prices dropped precipitously and credit tightened. (Lambie-Hanson, L. et al., Leaving Households Behind: Institutional Investors and the U.S. Housing Recovery (2019), available at https://www.philadelphiafed.org/-/media/frbp/assets/working-papers/2019/wp19-01.pdf.) During the financial crisis, investors bought foreclosed properties, often at a discount, with institutional buyers joining the usual cash investors. (Francesca Mari, New York Times, A $60 Billion Housing Grab By Wall Street (March 4. 2020), available at New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/04/magazine/wall-street-landlords.html.) Institutional buyers are entities with substantial financial resources, such as real estate investment trusts (REITs), private equity firms, and hedge funds. Unlike individual homebuyers who depend on federally-backed financing to purchase homes, institutional investors can purchase properties with cash. They were thus uniquely situated to purchase large numbers of foreclosed properties that might have not qualified for federally-backed loans. As hundreds of thousands of homes went into foreclosure, the federal government sought to stabilize housing prices by increasing demand for the homes by creating incentives for private investors to make bulk purchases. (Alana Semuels, When Wall Street Is Your Landlord, The Atlantic, (February 13, 2019) available at https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/02/single-family-landlords-wall-street/582394/.) Thus, institutional investors’ entry into the market for single-family residences came against the backdrop of staggering foreclosure rates, economic uncertainty, and government incentives.
The rate of investor purchases surged again during the COVID-19 pandemic. In the first quarter of 2022, investor purchases of single- family homes averaged 28 percent per month, compared with 19 percent the previous year: significant increases from the average of 16 percent between 2017 and 2019. (Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, State of the Nation’s Housing (2022), available at https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/state-nations-housing-2022.)
Institutional investors had long avoided the single-family market because of the challenge of managing dispersed properties. (Mari, New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/04/magazine/wall-street-landlords.html.) Digital technologies, including improved data and analytics, however, have transformed the single-family rental market. (Fields, D., Vergerio, UC Berkeley, Corporate landlords and market power: What does the single-family rental boom mean for our housing future? (2022), available at https://escholarship.org/uc/item/07d6445s.) Technology has made both purchasing and managing dispersed rental properties more efficient and profitable. Corporate owners can use digital tools to acquire property quickly and can use other tools to screen applicants, accept payments, manage maintenance requests, and gather data on rental markets.
Bundled sales of real estate parcels further enhances the profitability of the corporate “build-to-rent” model. Bundled or bulk sales of real property involve the combined offering of two or more parcels as a single transaction, often at a discounted price. This can present advantages to both the buyer and the seller. For buyers, bundled transactions can offer economies of scale and cost savings. By purchasing multiple properties, buyers may obtain more strategic pricing and negotiation, as the combined value of the bundled properties can create synergies that wouldn’t be achievable in separate transactions. For the seller, bundled transactions offer at-scale sales, and decreased uncertainty. Within regions, researchers find that large corporate investors buying single-family rentals and rent-to-own units tend to concentrate their purchases at the neighborhood level, primarily in “low income, historically non-white neighborhoods that have suffered from disinvestment, but where gentrification or real estate cycle dynamics predict medium term price increases.” (Raymond, E., et al., Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta., Large corporate buyers of residential rental housing during the COVID19 pandemic in three southeastern metropolitan areas (2022), available at https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/sites.gatech.edu/dist/d/2497/files/2022/01/ERaymond-2022-CorporateLandlords_PandemicPurchases.pdf.) Supporters of this bill find this concentration of the build-to-rent model in low-income, non-white neighborhoods to be troubling. In a zero-sum housing environment, where demand far exceeds supply, resulting in higher home prices, corporate winners means individual losers. A large majority of Americans report wanting to own a home and seeing homeownership as the best marker of financial success and security. (Schmidt, G., Homeownership Remains the American Dream, Despite Challenges, (June 2, 2022) The New York Times, available at https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/02/realestate/homeownership-affordability-survey.html.)
Opponents of this bill see the concentration of institutional capital in low-income areas as a societal positive: corporate rentals provide a desired product for those wanting the advantages of single-home living without the burden. They point to single mothers and professional women who do not want the maintenance costs, responsibilities, and interruptions of their daily schedules that come with owner occupancy of older homes, but who do want the quiet, privacy, and space that living in a single-family home provides.
Corporate landlords. In addition to depriving individual buyers of the opportunity to purchase homes, the rise of the corporate home ownership poses other problems. Corporate landlords are usually detached from the communities where the rental properties are located, and may be more motivated by profit-maximizing than the average “mom-and-pop” landlord. A 2017 study published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta found that corporate landlords, especially those which are large institutional investors, were far likelier than other owners to evict their tenants. (Raymond, E., et al., FRB Atlanta Community and Economic Development Discussion Paper No. 2016-4, Corporate Landlords, Institutional Investors, and Displacement: Eviction Rates in Singlefamily Rentals (2016), available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2893552.) In 2018, a Reuters special investigation of Invitation Homes, a creation of private equity giant Blackstone Group LP, found after “interviews with scores of the company’s tenants in neighborhoods across the United States, the picture that emerges isn’t as much one of exceptional service as it is one of leaky pipes, toxic mold, nonfunctioning appliances, and months-long waits for repairs.” (Michelle Conlin, Reuters, Spiders, sewage and a flurry of fees – the other side of renting a house from Wall Street (July 27, 2018), available at https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-housing-invitation/.) And just today, Attorney General Bonta announced a $3.7 million settlement with Invitation Homes to resolve allegations that it violated California’s rent cap law. (Liam Dillon, Los Angeles Times, Nation’s largest single-family home landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case (January 8, 2024), available at https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2024-01-08/invitation-homes-tenant-rent-gouging-settlement.)
This bill seeks to stem the tide of corporate “build-to-rent” single-family home ownership in the state. The author’s concern in bringing this measure is that as institutional investors acquire a larger number of homes, they may contribute to an increase in property prices, making it more challenging for individual households, especially first-time buyers, to enter the housing market. With their deep pockets, these buyers can often outbid individual homebuyers, driving up prices in the process. This leaves first-time homebuyers struggling to compete in markets where affordability is already a concern. As institutional buyers purchase large numbers of homes, the reduced inventory further exacerbates the problem. Furthermore, the concentration of single-family homes in the hands of institutional investors can lead to a reduction in the overall supply of affordable rental properties. This dynamic may exacerbate housing shortages and may also drive up rental prices, negatively affecting lower-income families who rely on affordable rental housing.
This bill is modeled after AB 2170, which prohibited the bundled sale of foreclosed properties. In 2009, the Federal Housing Finance Agency announced a program, entitled “First Look” in which eligible nonprofits and public entities would be given the first opportunity to make offers on properties acquired by government-sponsored entities (i.e., Fannie Made and Freddie Mac) through foreclosure and subsequently resold. (Federal Housing Administration (FHA) First Look Sales Method for Grantees, Nonprofit Organizations, and Subrecipients Under the Neighborhood Stabilization Programs (Jul. 15, 2010) 75 Fed. Reg. 41225.) California created a state equivalent of the First Look program with its passage of AB 2170 (Grayson, Chap. 865, Stats. 2022). Importantly for purposes of this bill, the First Look program imposed a restriction of bundled or bulk sales on foreclosed properties. In other words, an institution was required to sell each foreclosed property individually, rather than packaging properties together for sale. In a bundled sale, a lending institution sells off a series of properties that it has foreclosed upon all at once. This method of sale is efficient for the lender and helps them to sell off less-desirable properties by grouping them with more-desirable properties. However, bundled sales effectively exclude everyone apart from institutional investors because in order to buy the bundled properties, the purchaser must have a lot more money (in cash) available to invest and they must be prepared to manage multiple properties. By requiring individual sales of all properties being offered in the wake of foreclosure, AB 2170 sought to ensure that prospective owner-occupants, in particular, have a better chance of acquiring the property.
The Committee is unaware of any comprehensive data on the success of the First Look program in California, and therefore cannot properly assess whether the thesis that prohibiting bundled sale of single-family homes results in more individual buyers purchasing those homes.
How this bill works. Rather than prohibiting institutional investors from purchasing single-family homes, this bill attempts to reduce the financial incentive for institutional investors from entering the “build-to-rent” model by targeting the bulk-purchase process. This bill does not prohibit any buyer from purchasing single-family homes; nor does it prohibit a home from being built for the purpose of becoming a rental. This bill is narrowly tailored to apply to bulk purchases of residential dwelling units, defined as two or more parcels containing one to four units in a single transaction, by institutional investors on new properties.
Opponents of this measure raise certain issues about the impact of the bill that the author may wish to address as this bill moves through the Legislature, such as its impact on sales that occur as a result of mergers, acquisitions, bankruptcies, or foreclosures. In such cases, the acquirer is acquiring homes under construction or just finished and in the process of being sold. By preventing these types of homes from being bundled and sold, the result may be them sitting vacant and un-financeable by an individual buyer, further decreasing the inventory of available property—whether for sale or rent. As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to exempt transactions that take place as mergers, acquisitions, bankruptcies, or foreclosures from the bill. The author may also wish to consider replacing the term “developer” with the term “home builder” to better capture the bill’s intent.
Congress is proposing to ban all corporate ownership of single-family homes. The End Hedge Fund Control of American Homes Act of 2023 would require hedge funds, defined as corporations, partnerships, or real estate investment trusts that manage funds pooled from investors, to sell off all the single-family homes they own over a 10-year period, and eventually prohibit such companies from owning any single-family homes at all. During the decade-long phase-out period, the bill would impose stiff tax penalties, with the proceeds reserved for down-payment assistance for individuals looking to buy homes from corporate owners. If this measure were to succeed, institutional investors would be prohibited from owning any single-family homes anywhere, including in California, whether purchased in bulk or on an individual basis.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the California Association of Realtors:
Current “bulk sale” practices in the new home developments effectively exclude first-time and first-generation homeowners from having the opportunity to submit offers on newly constructed single-family homes, affordable to our states working families for wealth generation opportunities. As proposed to be amended, AB 1333 seeks to eliminate Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) ability to engage in a hidden “bulk sale” contract process.
As the state continues to grapple with housing supply deficiencies and our states persistent generational wealth gap, those Californians unable to owner occupy homes are denied the opportunity to generate home equity and intergenerational wealth. Study after study shows ownership housing remains the best way for working Californians to have true economic security, has presented an even bigger affordability issue to first-time and first-generation buyers as mortgage rates climbed to a high around 8% in the past year. In fact, 43% of REALTORS® note that housing affordability is the primary reason for their clients to change county, reinforcing the “drive until you can buy” practice, which is not in alliance with our states environmental policy priorities.
Since 2010 the median price of single families’ homes more than doubled from $305,010 to $659,380 in 2020. Today, our median single-family home in California costs $822,200, likely due to seasonal factors, as the median price of housing has remained near $840,000 since its peak high of $849,000 in March 2022.
Currently, families wishing to purchase an existing median-priced single-family home in November 2023 of $822,320 must make a minimum annual income of $186,800 in 2023. The 2022 California median income for Whites was $105,640, $120,040 for Asians, $76,310 for Hispanics/Latinos and $64,190 for Blacks.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of business organizations, including the California Building Industry Association and California Apartment Association, list this measure as a “Housing Killer” and argue as follows:
The intent of this bill appears to be directed at eliminating single family detached residential projects as rental communities to the extent that they are owned by institutional investors. It is important that this bill be narrowly tailored to avoid unintended consequences. The leading demographic for this type of project is single mothers and professional women who do not want the maintenance costs and interruptions of their daily schedules, that come with owner occupancy of older homes. In addition, they are looking for a yard for their children to play in and the quiet and privacy that comes from living in a structure without shared walls. While renting does not come with the same payment stability as ownership, there are legitimate reasons why people choose to rent, including but not limited to: (1) jobs that require frequent moving, (2) needing time to save for a down payment, or (3) not wanting the responsibility of homeownership. In any case, people need shelter and rental housing is a part of the solution.
According to the Department of Housing and Community Development, California needs 2.5 million more homes. Even if the bill were amended to narrow the prohibition on selling homes to apply to a larger number of units to the same buyer, it would still make no sense to prohibit the construction and sale of more housing of the types of housing mentioned above, whether for sale or for rent. We need more of both. AB 1333 moves California in the opposite direction.
The National Home Rental Council also opposes this measure:
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. AB 1333 could result in unintended consequences for Californians who wish to live in a single family home, but purchasing may be out of reach in this high-cost market. NRHC members can make single family rental opportunities available in brand new homes to Californians where living in a single family home is the preferred choice. In our current high interest rate environment, coupled with high housing costs, brand new rental homes can be very suitable opportunities for those seeking single family home housing options. AB 1333 will artificially slow this availability, which will be counterproductive to bringing new rental housing to market for Californians as quickly as possible.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
Opposition
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Hotel & Lodging Association
National Rental Home Council
Orange County Business Council
Southern California Leadership Council
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):