AB 1513: Electrical corporations: financing orders: wildfire mitigation expenses.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-05-01
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to fix the rates and charges for every public utility, and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. Existing law authorizes an electrical corporation to file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of costs and expenses related to a catastrophic wildfire, including fire risk mitigation capital expenditures, through the issuance of bonds by the electrical corporation that are secured by a rate component, as provided.
This bill would, in addition to capital expenditures related to wildfires, authorize the use of bonds secured by a rate component for recovery of wildfire mitigation efforts, operational and maintenance expenses related to an electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan, wildfire risk mitigation costs, and vegetation management costs and expenses.
Existing law requires the commission, upon application, to issue the financing order if: (1) the recovery costs to be reimbursed have been found to be just and reasonable, or are allocated to ratepayers as specified; (2) the issuance of the recovery bonds, including all material terms and conditions, is just and reasonable; (3) the issuance of the recovery bonds is consistent with the public interest; and (4) the recovery of the recovery costs through a fixed recovery charge that is assessed as a rate component, to the maximum extent possible, reduces the rate on a present value basis that consumers within the electrical corporations service territory would pay as compared to the use of traditional utility financing mechanisms, as specified.
This bill would, in regards to the determination that the issuance of the financing order recovery bonds is consistent with the public interest in (3) above, require the commission commission, when considering whether a proposed financing order provides both short-term and long-term economic benefits in the public interest, to presume that the financing order provides short-term economic benefits to ratepayers in furtherance of the public interest if the commission has authorized an amortization period in excess of 12 months, as specified.
This bill would allow the condition for issuing recovery bonds using a fixed recovery charge stated in (4) above, which requires a reduction in consumer rates on a present value basis for that issuance, to alternatively be satisfied if the issuance of the recovery bonds would provide short-term rate stability.Existing law authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to fix the rates and charges for every public utility, and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. Existing law authorizes an electrical corporation to file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of costs and expenses related to a catastrophic wildfire, including fire risk mitigation capital expenditures, through the issuance of bonds by the electrical corporation that are secured by a rate component, as provided.
This bill would, in addition to capital expenditures related to wildfires, authorize the use of bonds secured by a rate component for recovery of wildfire mitigation efforts, operational and maintenance expenses related to an electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan, wildfire risk mitigation costs, and vegetation management costs and expenses.
Existing law requires the commission, upon application, to issue the financing order if: (1) the recovery costs to be reimbursed have been found to be just and reasonable, or are allocated to ratepayers as specified; (2) the issuance of the recovery bonds, including all material terms and conditions, is just and reasonable; (3) the issuance of the recovery bonds is consistent with the public interest; and (4) the recovery of the recovery costs through a fixed recovery charge that is assessed as a rate component, to the maximum extent possible, reduces the rate on a present value basis that consumers within the electrical corporations service territory would pay as compared to the use of traditional utility financing mechanisms, as specified.
This bill would, in regards to the determination that the issuance of the financing order is consistent with the public interest in (3) above, require the commission to presume that the financing order provides short-term economic benefits to ratepayers in furtherance of the public interest if the commission has authorized an amortization period in excess of 12 months, as specified.
This bill would allow the condition for issuing recovery bonds using a fixed recovery charge stated in (4) above, which requires a reduction in consumer rates on a present value basis for that issuance, to alternatively be satisfied if the issuance of the recovery bonds would provide short-term rate stability.
(a)This article applies in any of the following circumstances:
(1)If an electrical corporation applies to the commission for recovery of costs and expenses related to a catastrophic wildfire and the commission finds some or all of the costs and expenses to be reasonable pursuant to Section 451.1, or for the amount of costs and expenses determined pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2, then the electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize these costs and expenses to be recovered through fixed recovery charges pursuant to this article.
(2)If an electrical corporation submits an application for recovery of costs and expenses related to catastrophic wildfires or wildfire mitigation efforts, including fire risk mitigation capital expenditures identified in subdivision (e) of Section 8386.3, operational and maintenance expenses related to the electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan, wildfire risk mitigation costs identified in subdivision (b) of Section 8386.4, or vegetation management costs and expenses in a proceeding to recover costs and expenses in rates and the commission finds that some or all of the costs and expenses identified in the electrical corporations application are just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451, the electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of those just and reasonable costs and expenses by means of a financing order, with those costs and expenses being recovered through a fixed charge pursuant to this article. This paragraph does not apply for costs and expenses incurred by the electrical corporation after December 31, 2035.
(3)(A)An electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of verified incremental undercollection amounts for calendar year 2020 through fixed recovery charges pursuant to this article, if an electrical corporations annual true-up advice letter is accepted and either or both of the following incremental undercollection amounts are verified for calendar year 2020:
(i)An incremental undercollection amount equal to the difference between the forecasted amount of billed revenues for that year, based on the authorized sales forecast, and the revenues actually billed by an electrical corporation with respect to all revenue balancing accounts, if the incremental amount as a percent of the forecasted amount of billed revenues for that year is at least 5 percent.
(ii)An incremental undercollection amount equal to the residential and small business customer bad debt expense recorded for that year that exceeds the bad debt expense for that year that was adopted by the commission in the general rate case, if the incremental undercollection amount is otherwise eligible for recovery in rates.
(B)The incremental undercollection amounts subject to a commission-approved financing order shall be prohibited from being recovered through any other cost recovery application, mechanism, or request by the electrical corporation.
(C)The commission shall ensure any costs included in incremental undercollections described in this paragraph and subject to a financing order are just and reasonable consistent with the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 850.1.
(D)In resolving a request for the issuance of a financing order, the commission may assign cost recovery to each customer class based on their contribution to the incremental undercollection described in this paragraph.
(b)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Ancillary agreement means a bond insurance policy, letter of credit, reserve account, surety bond, swap arrangement, hedging arrangement, liquidity or credit support arrangement, or other similar agreement or arrangement entered into in connection with the issuance of recovery bonds that is designed to promote the credit quality and marketability of the bonds or to mitigate the risk of an increase in interest rates.
(2)Catastrophic wildfire amounts means the portion of costs and expenses the commission finds to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451.1 or the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2.
(3)Consumer means any individual, governmental body, trust, business entity, or nonprofit organization that consumes electricity that has been transmitted or distributed by means of electric transmission or distribution facilities, whether those electric transmission or distribution facilities are owned by the consumer, the electrical corporation, or any other party.
(4)Financing costs means the costs to issue, service, repay, or refinance recovery bonds, whether incurred or paid upon issuance of the recovery bonds or over the life of the recovery bonds, if they are approved for recovery by the commission in a financing order. Financing costs may include any of the following:
(A)Principal, interest, and redemption premiums that are payable on recovery bonds.
(B)A payment required under an ancillary agreement.
(C)An amount required to fund or replenish reserve accounts or other accounts established under an indenture, ancillary agreement, or other financing document relating to the recovery bonds.
(D)Taxes, franchise fees, or license fees imposed on fixed recovery charges.
(E)Costs related to issuing and servicing recovery bonds or the application for a financing order, including, without limitation, servicing fees and expenses, trustee fees and expenses, legal fees and expenses, accounting fees, administrative fees, underwriting and placement fees, financial advisory fees, original issue discount, capitalized interest, rating agency fees, and any other related costs that are approved for recovery in the financing order.
(F)Other costs as specifically authorized by a financing order.
(5)Financing entity means the electrical corporation or any subsidiary or affiliate of the electrical corporation that is authorized by the commission to issue recovery bonds or acquire recovery property, or both.
(6)Financing order means an order of the commission adopted in accordance with this article, which shall include, without limitation, a procedure to require the expeditious approval by the commission of periodic adjustments to fixed recovery charges and to any associated fixed recovery tax amounts included in that financing order to ensure recovery of all recovery costs and the costs associated with the proposed recovery, financing, or refinancing thereof, including the costs of servicing and retiring the recovery bonds contemplated by the financing order.
(7)Fixed recovery charges means those nonbypassable rates and other charges, including, but not limited to, distribution, connection, disconnection, and termination rates and charges, that are authorized by the commission in a financing order to recover both of the following:
(A)Recovery costs specified in the financing order.
(B)The costs of recovering, financing, or refinancing those recovery costs through a plan approved by the commission in the financing order, including the costs of servicing and retiring recovery bonds.
(8)Fixed recovery tax amounts means those nonbypassable rates and other charges, including, but not limited to, distribution, connection, disconnection, and termination rates and charges, that are needed to recover federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with fixed recovery charges authorized by the commission in a financing order, but are not approved as financing costs financed from proceeds of recovery bonds.
(9)Recovery bonds means bonds, notes, certificates of participation or beneficial interest, or other evidences of indebtedness or ownership, issued pursuant to an executed indenture or other agreement of a financing entity, the proceeds of which are used, directly or indirectly, to recover, finance, or refinance recovery costs, and that are directly or indirectly secured by, or payable from, recovery property.
(10)Recovery costs means any of the following:
(A)The catastrophic wildfire amounts or costs pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) authorized by the commission in a financing order for recovery.
(B)The incremental undercollection amounts that the commission authorizes for recovery in a financing order pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a).
(C)Federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with recovery of the amounts pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (B).
(D)Financing costs.
(E)Professional fees, consultant fees, redemption premiums, tender premiums, and other costs incurred by the electrical corporation in using proceeds of recovery bonds to acquire outstanding securities of the electrical corporation, as authorized by the commission in a financing order.
(11)(A)Recovery property means the property right created pursuant to this article, including, without limitation, the right, title, and interest of the electrical corporation or its transferee:
(i)In and to the fixed recovery charges established pursuant to a financing order, including all rights to obtain adjustments to the fixed recovery charges in accordance with Section 850.1 and the financing order.
(ii)To be paid the amount that is determined in a financing order to be the amount that the electrical corporation or its transferee is lawfully entitled to receive pursuant to the provisions of this article and the proceeds thereof, and in and to all revenues, collections, claims, payments, moneys, or proceeds of or arising from the fixed recovery charges that are the subject of a financing order.
(B)Recovery property shall not include a right to be paid fixed recovery tax amounts.
(C)Recovery property shall constitute a current property right, notwithstanding the fact that the value of the property right will depend on consumers using electricity or, in those instances where consumers are customers of the electrical corporation, the electrical corporation performing certain services.
(12)(A)Revenue balancing account means a balancing account reflecting the balance between the electrical corporations authorized revenue requirements relating to the volumetric sale of electricity and billed revenues associated with those sales. A revenue balancing account includes accounts reflecting the balance between the electrical corporations authorized distribution base revenue requirements and recorded billed revenues from authorized distribution rates, and accounts reflecting the difference between the amount of the discount provided to consumers enrolled in the California Alternative Rates for Energy (CARE) program and the CARE surcharge charged to non-CARE consumers.
(B)Revenue balancing account shall not include amounts reflecting the balance between costs and expenses relating to fuel and purchased electricity by the electrical corporation.
(13)Service territory means the geographical area that the electrical corporation provides with electric distribution service.
(14)True-up adjustment means a formulaic adjustment to the fixed recovery charges as they appear on customer bills that is necessary to correct for any overcollection or undercollection of the fixed recovery charges authorized by a financing order and to otherwise ensure the timely and complete payment and recovery of recovery costs over the authorized repayment term.
SEC. 2.Section 850.1 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:850.1.(a)If an electrical corporation files for recovery of recovery costs and the commission finds some or all of those costs and expenses to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451 or 451.1, as applicable, or the commission allocates to the ratepayers some or all of those costs and expenses pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2, the commission may issue a financing order to allow recovery through fixed recovery charges, which would therefore constitute recovery property under this article, and order that any portion of the electrical corporations federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with those fixed recovery charges and not financed from proceeds of recovery bonds may be recovered through fixed recovery tax amounts.
(1)(A)Following application by an electrical corporation, the commission shall issue a financing order if the commission determines that both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)The recovery costs to be reimbursed from the recovery bonds have been found to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451 or 451.1, as applicable, or are allocated to the ratepayers pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2.
(ii)The issuance of the recovery bonds, including all material terms and conditions of the recovery bonds, including, without limitation, interest rates, rating, amortization redemption, and maturity, and the imposition and collection of fixed recovery charges as set forth in an application satisfy all of the following conditions, as applicable:
(I)They are just and reasonable.
(II)They are consistent with the public interest. For purposes of considering whether the financing order is consistent with the public interest, When considering whether a proposed financing order provides both short-term and long-term economic benefits in the public interest, the commission shall presume that the financing order provides short-term economic benefits to ratepayers in furtherance of the public interest if the commission has authorized an amortization period under traditional utility financing mechanisms in excess of 12 months for the just and reasonable costs. costs that are seeking to be financed through recovery bonds.
(III)The recovery of recovery costs through the designation of the fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, and the issuance of recovery bonds in connection with the fixed recovery charges, would either reduce, to the maximum extent possible, the rates on a present value basis that consumers within the electrical corporations service territory would pay as compared to the use of traditional utility financing mechanisms, which shall be calculated using the electrical corporations corporate debt and equity in the ratio approved by the commission at the time of the financing order, or provide short-term rate stability. order.
(B)The electrical corporation may request the determination specified in subparagraph (A) by the commission in a separate proceeding, in an existing proceeding, or both. If the commission makes the determination specified in subparagraph (A), the commission shall establish, as part of the financing order, a procedure for the electrical corporation to submit applications from time to time to request the issuance of additional financing orders designating fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts as recoverable. The electrical corporation may submit an application with respect to recovery costs that an electrical corporation (i) has paid, (ii) has an existing legal obligation to pay, or (iii) would be obligated to pay pursuant to an executed settlement agreement. The commission shall, within 180 days of the filing of that application, issue a financing order, which may take the form of a resolution, if the commission determines that the amounts identified in the application are recovery costs.
(2)Fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts shall be imposed only on existing and future consumers in the service territory. Consumers within the service territory shall continue to pay fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts until the recovery bonds and associated financing costs are paid in full by the financing entity.
(3)An electrical corporation may exercise the same rights and remedies under its tariff and applicable law and regulation based upon a consumers nonpayment of fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax as it could for a consumers failure to pay any other charge payable to that electrical corporation.
(b)The commission may establish in a financing order an effective mechanism that ensures recovery of recovery costs through nonbypassable fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts from existing and future consumers in the service territory, and those consumers shall be required to pay those charges until the recovery bonds and all associated financing costs are paid in full by the financing entity, at which time those charges shall be terminated. Fixed recovery charges shall be irrevocable, notwithstanding the true-up adjustment pursuant to subdivision (g).
(c)Recovery bonds authorized by the commissions financing orders may be issued in one or more series on or before December 31, 2035.
(d)The commission shall issue financing orders in accordance with this article to facilitate the recovery, financing, or refinancing of recovery costs. A financing order may be adopted only upon the application of the electrical corporation and shall become effective in accordance with its terms only after the electrical corporation files with the commission the electrical corporations written consent to all terms and conditions of the financing order. A financing order may specify how amounts collected from a consumer shall be allocated between fixed recovery charges, any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, and other charges.
(e)Notwithstanding Section 455.5 or 1708, or any other law, and except as otherwise provided in subdivision (g), with respect to recovery property that has been made the basis for the issuance of recovery bonds and with respect to any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, the financing order, the fixed recovery charges, and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts shall be irrevocable. The commission shall not, either by rescinding, altering, or amending the financing order or otherwise, revalue or revise for ratemaking purposes the recovery costs or the costs of recovering, financing, or refinancing the recovery costs, in any way reduce or impair the value of recovery property or of the right to receive any associated fixed recovery tax amounts either directly or indirectly by taking fixed recovery charges or any associated fixed recovery tax amounts into account when setting other rates for the electrical corporation or when setting charges for the Department of Water Resources. The amount of revenues shall not be subject to reduction, impairment, postponement, or termination. The State of California does hereby pledge and agree with the electrical corporation, owners of recovery property, financing entities, and holders of recovery bonds that the state shall neither limit nor alter, except as otherwise provided with respect to the true-up adjustment of the fixed recovery charges pursuant to subdivision (i), the fixed recovery charges, any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, recovery property, financing orders, or any rights under a financing order until the recovery bonds, together with the interest on the recovery bonds and associated financing costs, are fully paid and discharged, and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts have been satisfied or, in the alternative, have been refinanced through an additional issue of recovery bonds, provided that nothing contained in this section shall preclude the limitation or alteration if and when adequate provision shall be made by law for the protection of the electrical corporation and of owners and holders of the recovery bonds. The financing entity is authorized to include this pledge and undertaking for the state in these recovery bonds. When setting other rates for the electrical corporation, nothing in this subdivision shall prevent the commission from taking into account either of the following:
(1)Any collection of fixed recovery charges in excess of amounts actually required to pay recovery costs financed or refinanced by recovery bonds.
(2)Any collection of fixed recovery tax amounts in excess of amounts actually required to pay federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with fixed recovery charges, provided that this would not result in a recharacterization of the tax, accounting, and other intended characteristics of the financing, including, but not limited to, either of the following:
(A)Treating the recovery bonds as debt of the electrical corporation or its affiliates for federal income tax purposes.
(B)Treating the transfer of the recovery property by the electrical corporation as a true sale for bankruptcy purposes.
(f)(1)Neither financing orders nor recovery bonds issued under this article shall constitute a debt or liability of the state or of any political subdivision thereof, nor shall they constitute a pledge of the full faith and credit of the state or any of its political subdivisions, but are payable solely from the funds provided therefor under this article and shall be consistent with Sections 1 and 18 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. All recovery bonds shall contain on the face thereof a statement to the following effect: Neither the full faith and credit nor the taxing power of the State of California is pledged to the payment of the principal of, or interest on, this bond.
(2)The issuance of recovery bonds under this article shall not directly, indirectly, or contingently obligate the state or any political subdivision thereof to levy or to pledge any form of taxation therefor or to make any appropriation for their payment.
(g)The commission shall establish procedures for the expeditious processing of an application for a financing order, which shall provide for the approval or disapproval of the application within 120 days of the application. Any fixed recovery charge authorized by a financing order shall appear on consumer bills. The commission shall, in any financing order, provide for a procedure for periodic true-up adjustments to fixed recovery charges, which shall be made at least annually and may be made more frequently. The electrical corporation shall file an application with the commission to implement any true-up adjustment.
(h)Fixed recovery charges are recovery property when, and to the extent that, a financing order authorizing the fixed recovery charges has become effective in accordance with this article, and the recovery property shall thereafter continuously exist as property for all purposes, and all of the rights and privileges relating to that property accorded by this article shall continuously exist for the period and to the extent provided in the financing order, but in any event until the recovery bonds are paid in full, including all principal, premiums, if any, and interest with respect to the recovery bonds, and all associated financing costs are paid in full. A financing order may provide that the creation of recovery property shall be simultaneous with the sale of the recovery property to a transferee or assignee as provided in the application of the pledge of the recovery property to secure the recovery bonds.
(i)Recovery costs shall not be imposed upon customers participating in the California Alternative Rates for Energy or Family Electric Rate Assistance programs discount pursuant to Section 739.1.
(j)Any successor to a financing entity shall be bound by the requirements of this article and shall perform and satisfy all obligations of, and have the same rights under a financing order as and to the same extent as, the financing entity, including the obligation to collect and pay energy transition revenues to persons entitled to receive the revenues.
(k)This article and any financing order made pursuant to this article do not amend, reduce, modify, or otherwise affect the right of the Department of Water Resources to recover its revenue requirements and to receive the charges that it is to recover and receive pursuant to Division 27 (commencing with Section 80000) and Division 28 (commencing with Section 80500) of the Water Code, or pursuant to any agreement entered into by the commission and the Department of Water Resources pursuant to the applicable division.
(a)This article applies in any of the following circumstances:
(1)If an electrical corporation applies to the commission for recovery of costs and expenses related to a catastrophic wildfire and the commission finds some or all of the costs and expenses to be reasonable pursuant to Section 451.1, or for the amount of costs and expenses determined pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2, then the electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize these costs and expenses to be recovered through fixed recovery charges pursuant to this article.
(2)If an electrical corporation submits an application for recovery of costs and expenses related to catastrophic wildfires, wildfires or wildfire mitigation efforts, including fire risk mitigation capital expenditures identified in subdivision (e) of Section 8386.3, operational and maintenance expenses related to the electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan, wildfire risk mitigation costs identified in subdivision (b) of Section 8386.4, or vegetation management costs and expenses in a proceeding to recover costs and expenses in rates and the commission finds that some or all of the costs and expenses identified in the electrical corporations application are just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451, the electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of those just and reasonable costs and expenses by means of a financing order, with those costs and expenses being recovered through a fixed charge pursuant to this article. This paragraph does not apply for costs and expenses incurred by the electrical corporation after December 31, 2035.
(3)(A)An electrical corporation may file an application requesting the commission to issue a financing order to authorize the recovery of verified incremental undercollection amounts for calendar year 2020 through fixed recovery charges pursuant to this article, if an electrical corporations annual true-up advice letter is accepted and either or both of the following incremental undercollection amounts are verified for calendar year 2020:
(i)An incremental undercollection amount equal to the difference between the forecasted amount of billed revenues for that year, based on the authorized sales forecast, and the revenues actually billed by an electrical corporation with respect to all revenue balancing accounts, if the incremental amount as a percent of the forecasted amount of billed revenues for that year is at least 5 percent.
(ii)An incremental undercollection amount equal to the residential and small business customer bad debt expense recorded for that year that exceeds the bad debt expense for that year that was adopted by the commission in the general rate case, if the incremental undercollection amount is otherwise eligible for recovery in rates.
(B)The incremental undercollection amounts subject to a commission-approved financing order shall be prohibited from being recovered through any other cost recovery application, mechanism, or request by the electrical corporation.
(C)The commission shall ensure any costs included in incremental undercollections described in this paragraph and subject to a financing order are just and reasonable consistent with the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 850.1.
(D)In resolving a request for the issuance of a financing order, the commission may assign cost recovery to each customer class based on their contribution to the incremental undercollection described in this paragraph.
(b)For the purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings: definitions apply:
(1)Ancillary agreement means a bond insurance policy, letter of credit, reserve account, surety bond, swap arrangement, hedging arrangement, liquidity or credit support arrangement, or other similar agreement or arrangement entered into in connection with the issuance of recovery bonds that is designed to promote the credit quality and marketability of the bonds or to mitigate the risk of an increase in interest rates.
(2)Catastrophic wildfire amounts means the portion of costs and expenses the commission finds to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451.1 or the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2.
(3)Consumer means any individual, governmental body, trust, business entity, or nonprofit organization that consumes electricity that has been transmitted or distributed by means of electric transmission or distribution facilities, whether those electric transmission or distribution facilities are owned by the consumer, the electrical corporation, or any other party.
(4)Financing costs means the costs to issue, service, repay, or refinance recovery bonds, whether incurred or paid upon issuance of the recovery bonds or over the life of the recovery bonds, if they are approved for recovery by the commission in a financing order. Financing costs may include any of the following:
(A)Principal, interest, and redemption premiums that are payable on recovery bonds.
(B)A payment required under an ancillary agreement.
(C)An amount required to fund or replenish reserve accounts or other accounts established under an indenture, ancillary agreement, or other financing document relating to the recovery bonds.
(D)Taxes, franchise fees, or license fees imposed on fixed recovery charges.
(E)Costs related to issuing and servicing recovery bonds or the application for a financing order, including, without limitation, servicing fees and expenses, trustee fees and expenses, legal fees and expenses, accounting fees, administrative fees, underwriting and placement fees, financial advisory fees, original issue discount, capitalized interest, rating agency fees, and any other related costs that are approved for recovery in the financing order.
(F)Other costs as specifically authorized by a financing order.
(5)Financing entity means the electrical corporation or any subsidiary or affiliate of the electrical corporation that is authorized by the commission to issue recovery bonds or acquire recovery property, or both.
(6)Financing order means an order of the commission adopted in accordance with this article, which shall include, without limitation, a procedure to require the expeditious approval by the commission of periodic adjustments to fixed recovery charges and to any associated fixed recovery tax amounts included in that financing order to ensure recovery of all recovery costs and the costs associated with the proposed recovery, financing, or refinancing thereof, including the costs of servicing and retiring the recovery bonds contemplated by the financing order.
(7)Fixed recovery charges means those nonbypassable rates and other charges, including, but not limited to, distribution, connection, disconnection, and termination rates and charges, that are authorized by the commission in a financing order to recover both of the following:
(A)Recovery costs specified in the financing order.
(B)The costs of recovering, financing, or refinancing those recovery costs through a plan approved by the commission in the financing order, including the costs of servicing and retiring recovery bonds.
(8)Fixed recovery tax amounts means those nonbypassable rates and other charges, including, but not limited to, distribution, connection, disconnection, and termination rates and charges, that are needed to recover federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with fixed recovery charges authorized by the commission in a financing order, but are not approved as financing costs financed from proceeds of recovery bonds.
(9)Recovery bonds means bonds, notes, certificates of participation or beneficial interest, or other evidences of indebtedness or ownership, issued pursuant to an executed indenture or other agreement of a financing entity, the proceeds of which are used, directly or indirectly, to recover, finance, or refinance recovery costs, and that are directly or indirectly secured by, or payable from, recovery property.
(10)Recovery costs means any of the following:
(A)The catastrophic wildfire amounts or costs pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) authorized by the commission in a financing order for recovery.
(B)The incremental undercollection amounts that the commission authorizes for recovery in a financing order pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a).
(C)Federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with recovery of the amounts pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (B).
(D)Financing costs.
(E)Professional fees, consultant fees, redemption premiums, tender premiums, and other costs incurred by the electrical corporation in using proceeds of recovery bonds to acquire outstanding securities of the electrical corporation, as authorized by the commission in a financing order.
(11)(A)Recovery property means the property right created pursuant to this article, including, without limitation, the right, title, and interest of the electrical corporation or its transferee:
(i)In and to the fixed recovery charges established pursuant to a financing order, including all rights to obtain adjustments to the fixed recovery charges in accordance with Section 850.1 and the financing order.
(ii)To be paid the amount that is determined in a financing order to be the amount that the electrical corporation or its transferee is lawfully entitled to receive pursuant to the provisions of this article and the proceeds thereof, and in and to all revenues, collections, claims, payments, moneys, or proceeds of or arising from the fixed recovery charges that are the subject of a financing order.
(B)Recovery property shall not include a right to be paid fixed recovery tax amounts.
(C)Recovery property shall constitute a current property right, notwithstanding the fact that the value of the property right will depend on consumers using electricity or, in those instances where consumers are customers of the electrical corporation, the electrical corporation performing certain services.
(12)(A)Revenue balancing account means a balancing account reflecting the balance between the electrical corporations authorized revenue requirements relating to the volumetric sale of electricity and billed revenues associated with those sales. A revenue balancing account includes accounts reflecting the balance between the electrical corporations authorized distribution base revenue requirements and recorded billed revenues from authorized distribution rates, and accounts reflecting the difference between the amount of the discount provided to consumers enrolled in the California Alternative Rates for Energy (CARE) program and the CARE surcharge charged to non-CARE consumers.
(B)Revenue balancing account shall not include amounts reflecting the balance between costs and expenses relating to fuel and purchased electricity by the electrical corporation.
(13)Service territory means the geographical area that the electrical corporation provides with electric distribution service.
(14)True-up adjustment means a formulaic adjustment to the fixed recovery charges as they appear on customer bills that is necessary to correct for any overcollection or undercollection of the fixed recovery charges authorized by a financing order and to otherwise ensure the timely and complete payment and recovery of recovery costs over the authorized repayment term.
SEC. 2.Section 850.1 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:850.1.(a)If an electrical corporation files for recovery of recovery costs and the commission finds some or all of those costs and expenses to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451 or 451.1, as applicable, or the commission allocates to the ratepayers some or all of those costs and expenses pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2, the commission may issue a financing order to allow recovery through fixed recovery charges, which would therefore constitute recovery property under this article, and order that any portion of the electrical corporations federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with those fixed recovery charges and not financed from proceeds of recovery bonds may be recovered through fixed recovery tax amounts.
(1)(A)Following application by an electrical corporation, the commission shall issue a financing order if the commission determines that both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)The recovery cost costs to be reimbursed from the recovery bonds have been found to be just and reasonable pursuant to Section 451 or 451.1, as applicable, or are allocated to the ratepayers pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 451.2.
(ii)The issuance of the recovery bonds, including all material terms and conditions of the recovery bonds, including, without limitation, interest rates, rating, amortization redemption, and maturity, and the imposition and collection of fixed recovery charges as set forth in an application satisfy all of the following conditions, as applicable:
(I)They are just and reasonable.
(II)They are consistent with the public interest. For purposes of considering whether the financing order is consistent with the public interest, the commission shall presume that the financing order provides short-term economic benefits to ratepayers in furtherance of the public interest if the commission has authorized an amortization period under traditional utility financing mechanisms in excess of 12 months for the just and reasonable costs.
(III)The recovery of recovery costs through the designation of the fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, and the issuance of recovery bonds in connection with the fixed recovery charges, would either reduce, to the maximum extent possible, the rates on a present value basis that consumers within the electrical corporations service territory would pay as compared to the use of traditional utility financing mechanisms, which shall be calculated using the electrical corporations corporate debt and equity in the ratio approved by the commission at the time of the financing order. order, or provide short-term rate stability.
(B)The electrical corporation may request the determination specified in subparagraph (A) by the commission in a separate proceeding or proceeding, in an existing proceeding proceeding, or both. If the commission makes the determination specified in subparagraph (A), the commission shall establish, as part of the financing order, a procedure for the electrical corporation to submit applications from time to time to request the issuance of additional financing orders designating fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts as recoverable. The electrical corporation may submit an application with respect to recovery costs that an electrical corporation (i) has paid, (ii) has an existing legal obligation to pay, or (iii) would be obligated to pay pursuant to an executed settlement agreement. The commission shall, within 180 days of the filing of that application, issue a financing order, which may take the form of a resolution, if the commission determines that the amounts identified in the application are recovery costs.
(2)Fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts shall be imposed only on existing and future consumers in the service territory. Consumers within the service territory shall continue to pay fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts until the recovery bonds and associated financing costs are paid in full by the financing entity.
(3)An electrical corporation may exercise the same rights and remedies under its tariff and applicable law and regulation based upon a consumers nonpayment of fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax as it could for a consumers failure to pay any other charge payable to that electrical corporation.
(b)The commission may establish in a financing order an effective mechanism that ensures recovery of recovery costs through nonbypassable fixed recovery charges and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts from existing and future consumers in the service territory, and those consumers shall be required to pay those charges until the recovery bonds and all associated financing costs are paid in full by the financing entity, at which time those charges shall be terminated. Fixed recovery charges shall be irrevocable, notwithstanding the true-up adjustment pursuant to subdivision (g).
(c)Recovery bonds authorized by the commissions financing orders may be issued in one or more series on or before December 31, 2035.
(d)The commission shall issue financing orders in accordance with this article to facilitate the recovery, financing, or refinancing of recovery costs. A financing order may be adopted only upon the application of the electrical corporation and shall become effective in accordance with its terms only after the electrical corporation files with the commission the electrical corporations written consent to all terms and conditions of the financing order. A financing order may specify how amounts collected from a consumer shall be allocated between fixed recovery charges, any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, and other charges.
(e)Notwithstanding Section 455.5 or 1708, or any other law, and except as otherwise provided in subdivision (g), with respect to recovery property that has been made the basis for the issuance of recovery bonds and with respect to any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, the financing order, the fixed recovery charges, and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts shall be irrevocable. The commission shall not, either by rescinding, altering, or amending the financing order or otherwise, revalue or revise for ratemaking purposes the recovery costs or the costs of recovering, financing, or refinancing the recovery costs, in any way reduce or impair the value of recovery property or of the right to receive any associated fixed recovery tax amounts either directly or indirectly by taking fixed recovery charges or any associated fixed recovery tax amounts into account when setting other rates for the electrical corporation or when setting charges for the Department of Water Resources. The amount of revenues shall not be subject to reduction, impairment, postponement, or termination. The State of California does hereby pledge and agree with the electrical corporation, owners of recovery property, financing entities, and holders of recovery bonds that the state shall neither limit nor alter, except as otherwise provided with respect to the true-up adjustment of the fixed recovery charges pursuant to subdivision (i), the fixed recovery charges, any associated fixed recovery tax amounts, recovery property, financing orders, or any rights under a financing order until the recovery bonds, together with the interest on the recovery bonds and associated financing costs, are fully paid and discharged, and any associated fixed recovery tax amounts have been satisfied or, in the alternative, have been refinanced through an additional issue of recovery bonds, provided that nothing contained in this section shall preclude the limitation or alteration if and when adequate provision shall be made by law for the protection of the electrical corporation and of owners and holders of the recovery bonds. The financing entity is authorized to include this pledge and undertaking for the state in these recovery bonds. When setting other rates for the electrical corporation, nothing in this subdivision shall prevent the commission from taking into account either of the following:
(1)Any collection of fixed recovery charges in excess of amounts actually required to pay recovery costs financed or refinanced by recovery bonds.
(2)Any collection of fixed recovery tax amounts in excess of amounts actually required to pay federal and State of California income and franchise taxes associated with fixed recovery charges, provided that this would not result in a recharacterization of the tax, accounting, and other intended characteristics of the financing, including, but not limited to, either of the following:
(A)Treating the recovery bonds as debt of the electrical corporation or its affiliates for federal income tax purposes.
(B)Treating the transfer of the recovery property by the electrical corporation as a true sale for bankruptcy purposes.
(f)(1)Neither financing orders nor recovery bonds issued under this article shall constitute a debt or liability of the state or of any political subdivision thereof, nor shall they constitute a pledge of the full faith and credit of the state or any of its political subdivisions, but are payable solely from the funds provided therefor under this article and shall be consistent with Sections 1 and 18 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. All recovery bonds shall contain on the face thereof a statement to the following effect: Neither the full faith and credit nor the taxing power of the State of California is pledged to the payment of the principal of, or interest on, this bond.
(2)The issuance of recovery bonds under this article shall not directly, indirectly, or contingently obligate the state or any political subdivision thereof to levy or to pledge any form of taxation therefor or to make any appropriation for their payment.
(g)The commission shall establish procedures for the expeditious processing of an application for a financing order, which shall provide for the approval or disapproval of the application within 120 days of the application. Any fixed recovery charge authorized by a financing order shall appear on consumer bills. The commission shall, in any financing order, provide for a procedure for periodic true-up adjustments to fixed recovery charges, which shall be made at least annually and may be made more frequently. The electrical corporation shall file an application with the commission to implement any true-up adjustment.
(h)Fixed recovery charges are recovery property when, and to the extent that, a financing order authorizing the fixed recovery charges has become effective in accordance with this article, and the recovery property shall thereafter continuously exist as property for all purposes, and all of the rights and privileges relating to that property accorded by this article shall continuously exist for the period and to the extent provided in the financing order, but in any event until the recovery bonds are paid in full, including all principal, premiums, if any, and interest with respect to the recovery bonds, and all associated financing costs are paid in full. A financing order may provide that the creation of recovery property shall be simultaneous with the sale of the recovery property to a transferee or assignee as provided in the application of the pledge of the recovery property to secure the recovery bonds.
(i)Recovery costs shall not be imposed upon customers participating in the California Alternative Rates for Energy or Family Electric Rate Assistance programs discount pursuant to Section 739.1.
(j)Any successor to a financing entity shall be bound by the requirements of this article and shall perform and satisfy all obligations of, and have the same rights under a financing order as and to the same extent as, the financing entity, including the obligation to collect and pay energy transition revenues to persons entitled to receive the revenues.
(k)This article and any financing order made pursuant to this article do not amend, reduce, modify, or otherwise affect the right of the Department of Water Resources to recover its revenue requirements and to receive the charges that it is to recover and receive pursuant to Division 27 (commencing with Section 80000) and Division 28 (commencing with Section 80500) of the Water Code, or pursuant to any agreement entered into by the commission and the Department of Water Resources pursuant to the applicable division.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2024 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 18, 2023 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 18, 2023 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1580.) |
| May 17, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 2, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 26). |
| Mar 14, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Feb 18, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 26, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| CalChamber | ** Support | |
| California Large Energy Consumers Association | ** Against | |
| Pacific Gas & Electric Company | ** Support | |
| Sempra Energy And Its Affiliates: San Diego Gas & Electric Company And Southern California Gas Company | ** Support | |
| Southern California Edison | ** Support | |
| The Utility Reform Network | ** Against |
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1513
Author:(Calderon) – As Amended Ver:May 1, 2023
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill lists an electrical corporation’s wildfire and wildfire mitigation plan operation and maintenance (O&M) expenses as those that the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) may issue an order for long-term financing, the costs of which are to be recovered through a fixed charge on ratepayers.
Specifically, this bill explicitly references the following when describing an application in which an electrical corporation requests the CPUC to issue financing orders for cost recovery: (1) O&M expenses related to the electrical corporation’s wildfire mitigation plan, (2) certain wildfire risk mitigation costs and (3) vegetation management costs and expenses.
In addition, the bill obligates the CPUC, when it considers issuing a financing order to authorize recover of costs through bonds prompted by an electrical corporation’s application as described above, to presume such recovery bonds provide short-term economic benefits if the CPUC has authorized an amortization period under traditional utility financing mechanisms in excess of 12 months for the just and reasonable costs that the electrical corporation seeks to be financed through the recovery bonds.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The CPUC estimates this bill will result in at least two additional financing application requests from the electric corporation’s each year, and the CPUC describes these applications as particularly complex. Existing law requires the CPUC to complete this work quickly.
To conduct this work, CPUC estimates costs of approximately $977,000 annually. These costs cover expenses for one administrative law judge, two attorneys and one regulatory analyst.
The CPUC describes this work as ongoing. In contrast, the large investor-owned utilities (IOUs) together contend the bill will limit each IOU to filing just one request for cost recovery. SCE’s position is that the bill limits the O&M costs in question to just those related to wildfire mitigation expenses from the year 2019 through the year 2023 and that, eventually, the electrical corporations would not file financing orders to securitize wildfire under collections because “we will not always have future wildfire undercollections at today’s exorbitant amount. Wildfire mitigation costs will be included in the next GRC cycle.”
In any case, the costs for the CPUC to consider even on financing application request surpasses the committee’s threshold of $150,000 in any given year, making this bill a candidate for the committee’s suspense file.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose and Background. State law authorizes the CPUC to allow an IOU to “securitize”—that is, to issue a bond or some other type of financial instrument—for costs that are approved by the CPUC as just and reasonable and related to catastrophic wildfires occurring in either 2017, or in or after 2019. The CPUC allows the cost of financing any such securitization to be repaid through reoccurring charges on the bills of the IOU’s ratepayers.
Typically, costs of a capital project are securitized. This is because capital costs tend to be expensive and because the benefits provided by the capital project last over the period of time needed to pay off the cost of securitization—principal, interest and financing charges. Hardening of facilities is an example of a capital project.
In contrast, reoccurring projects, especially those with short-lived benefits, generally are not securitized. Rather, these costs are paid immediately, or, before the benefits of such a project expire and the project, and expense for the project, must be realized anew. These types of reoccurring projects are oftentimes referred to as O&M. Tree trimming is an example of such an O&M project with short-lived benefits.
In October 2021, the CPUC denied a request by Southern California Edison to securitize certain O&M expenses. The CPUC explained, “we find that the time-value-of-money benefits associated with securitizing the O&M expenses over a 25-year bond term is substantially outweighed by associated financing costs and higher utility rates for future customers.” The CPUC notes it rejected the electrical corporation’s securitization request not because it lacked the authority to approve such a request for O&M costs but, rather, because “SCE’s proposal failed the public interest test.”
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by, collectively, Pacific Gas and Electric, Sempra Energy (parent company of Southern California Gas and San Diego Gas and Electric) and Southern California Energy, which write the bill will provide the CPUC with “clear authority to approve the financing of authorized costs and expenses related to wildfire mitigation efforts” and that “Securitization of these costs – which are necessary to promote safe, reliable energy – will help stabilize electric rates while addressing the need for affordability.”
The bill is opposed by The Utility Reform Network (TURN) and the California Large Energy Consumers Association (CLECA), the latter of which writes:
O&M expenses are incurred either to support day-to-day operations or to maintain utility plant, property or equipment to keep it operational for day-to-day operations…should be paid through rates for that period by the ratepayers who benefit from those services. This bill would push those costs, as well as the financing costs, to future ratepayers, while the benefits of the O&M are enjoyed by today’s ratepayers. This would not be just and reasonable, nor is it consistent with the public interest.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1513 (
Author:Calderon) – As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
SUBJECT: Electrical corporations: financing orders: wildfire mitigation expenses
SUMMARY: Authorizes categories of costs and expenses arising from electrical investor-owned utility (IOU) wildfire work to be eligible for recovery through bonds that are secured by a fixed customer charge (securitization) if the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) determines the costs and expenses are just and reasonable. Additionally, changes the conditions the CPUC uses to evaluate whether the bonds should be authorized.
Specifically, this bill:
- Allows costs and expenses related to wildfire mitigation efforts, operational and maintenance expenses related to the IOU’s wildfire mitigation plan, wildfire risk mitigation costs, and vegetation management costs and expenses to be eligible for recovery through securitization, if the CPUC determines the costs and expenses are just and reasonable.
- Mandates that the CPUC presume, as part of its public interest test, that a financing order provides short-term economic benefit to ratepayers, if the CPUC has authorized an amortization period in excess of 12 months for the just and reasonable costs.
- Modifies the conditions the securitized bond must satisfy in order to receive authorization from the CPUC. The new conditions may be satisfied if the bond either provides short-term rate stability, or reduces, to the maximum extent possible, the rates that IOU customers would pay as compared to a traditional IOU financing mechanism. Previously, the securitized bond must have reduced the rates the IOU customers would pay as compared to a traditional IOU financing mechanism.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that all charges demanded or received by any public utility for any product, commodity or service be just and reasonable, and that every unjust or unreasonable charge is unlawful. (Public Utilities Code § 451)
- Prohibits a public utility from issuing bonds, or any form of indebtedness at periods of more than 12 months, unless first authorized by the CPUC. (Public Utilities Code § 818)
- Permits the CPUC to allow for the recovery of costs and expenses arising from a covered wildfire occurring after January 1, 2019, if the CPUC finds the costs and expenses just and reasonable. Establishes a standard of reasonable conduct of an IOU, for purposes of cost recovery, based on whether a reasonable utility would have undertaken the action in good faith under similar circumstances. Specifies the IOU bears the burden to demonstrate that its conduct was reasonable, unless it has a valid safety certificate; at which point, the IOU’s conduct is deemed reasonable unless a third party creates serious doubt as to the reasonableness of the IOU’s conduct. (Public Utilities Code § 451.1)
- Authorizes an IOU to request the CPUC issue a financing order to authorize the recovery, through securitization, of costs and expenses related to a catastrophic wildfire (with an ignition date in 2017 or after January 1, 2019) or undercollection amounts accrued in 2020. (Public Utilities Code § 850)
- Specifies the conditions that must be satisfied, as determined by the CPUC, for recovery bonds eligible for securitization. These conditions include that the costs to be recovered in bonds are just and reasonable, the bonds are consistent with the public interest, and the bonds reduce (to the maximum extent possible) the rates consumers would pay compared to traditional financing mechanisms. (Public Utilities Code § 850.1)
- Authorizes an IOU to request securitization of costs and expenses from 2017 wildfires that were either determined by the CPUC as recoverable from ratepayers or disallowed by the CPUC for rate recovery but in excess of a CPUC determination of the maximum amount the IOU can pay without harming ratepayers or materially impacting its ability to provide service. This CPUC determination was known as the “stress test” or “customer harm threshold.” (Public Utilities Code § 451.2)
- Authorizes an IOU to request securitization to finance its share of the first $5 billion of approved wildfire mitigation capital expenditures and the debt financing costs of those expenditures. Prohibits the CPUC from allowing the large IOUs to earn a return on equity on the mandated fire risk mitigation capital expenditures. (Public Utilities Code § 8386.3)
- Authorizes the CPUC to issue a financing order for securitized bonds to finance the unamortized balance of the regulatory asset awarded to Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) following the energy crisis. (Public Utilities Code § 840)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal and will be referred to the Committee on Appropriations for its review.
BACKGROUND:
What is Securitization – To securitize a utility bond means to tie a rate collection mechanism—usually a fixed charge on utility customer bills —to the issued bond (i.e., an asset-backed security). Because securitized bonds are backed by dedicated ratepayer charges, borrowing costs for the long-term debt is usually more favorable. These bonds—like any bond—are used to spread out the recovery of large electric IOU costs over many years in order to reduce the immediate impact on ratepayers.
The Legislature has provided the CPUC with statutory authority to issue “financing orders” that commit electric ratepayers to paying fixed charges on their bills to support an electric IOU bond issuance.[1] Once a financing order is issued, electric IOU ratepayers must pay principal, interest, and other costs of the bonds until those bonds are fully paid off (amortized). These fixed charges are assessed on all bundled and unbundled ratepayer bills. Since a financing order is an unavoidable commitment to charge ratepayers for bond costs until the bonds are fully paid off, these bonds generally yield low interest rates in comparison to unsecured bonds.
Securitization in Action – SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) and AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019), allowed financing and securitization of costs and expenses that are approved by the CPUC as just and reasonable and related to catastrophic wildfires occurring in either 2017 or in or after 2019. The securitization authority specifically includes, but is not limited to, $5 billion of “fire risk mitigation capital expenditures” the large electric IOUs are required to spend. Additionally, AB 913 (Calderon, Chapter 253, Statutes of 2020) allowed securitization of COVID-19 undercollections.
In 2021, the CPUC issued several financing orders authorizing the issuance of recovery bonds for the electric IOUs:
- In May 2021, the CPUC issued a financing order authorizing PG&E to issue recovery bonds for $7.5 billion to fund costs related to the 2017 North Bay Wildfires. [2]
- In June 2021, the CPUC issued another financing order[3] for PG&E to issue $1.2 billion in Wildfire Hardening Recovery Bonds to finance fire risk mitigation plan capital expenditures authorized by Public Utilities Code § 8386.3(e).
- In October 2021, the CPUC issued a financing order[4] for Southern California Edison (SCE) to issue bonds to recover approximately $526 million in wildfire-related capital expenditures. The CPUC denied SCE’s request for operations and maintenance (O&M) expenses to be recovered through this financing order.
O&M Costs versus Capital Expenditures – State law authorizes the CPUC to allow an IOU to “securitize”—that is, to issue a bond or some other type of financial instrument—for costs that are approved by the CPUC as just and reasonable and related to catastrophic wildfires occurring in either 2017, or in or after 2019. The CPUC allows the cost of financing any such securitization to be repaid through reoccurring charges on the bills of the IOU’s ratepayers.
Typically, costs of a capital project are securitized. This is because capital costs tend to be expensive and because the benefits to ratepayers provided by the capital project last over the period of time needed to pay off the cost of securitization—principal, interest and financing charges. Building a new transmission line is an example of a capital project, where the benefits of the new line persist for the lifetime of that line.
Capital expenditures for long-lived assets are financed over a period greater than one year. Capital expenditures are typically included in an electric IOU’s calculation for determining their profit, and are financed over the useful life of the assets. Bonds—either traditional or securitized—are typically taken out to fund capital projects. The upside to this method is it matches the benefits received from the capital expenditures with the same time-period of the financing from the ratepayers receiving the benefits (i.e., an asset with a 30 year lifetime could be financed on a 30 year loan). This also allows very large capital expenditures, which can be expensive to finance, to be spread out over time. However, the total costs associated with recovery from bonds will be larger than the annual pass-through recovery of typical O&M expenses. This is due to bond issuance having not only the principal but interest, utility profit, and taxes accruing as part of the bond financing.
In contrast, reoccurring projects, especially those with short-lived benefits, generally are not securitized. Rather, these costs are paid immediately, or, before the benefits of such a project expire and the project, and expense for the project, must be realized anew. These types of reoccurring projects are oftentimes referred to as operations and maintenance (O&M). Tree trimming is an example of such an O&M project with short-lived benefits.
O&M expenses are generally pass-through costs and collected in rates over the course of a year, as forecasted during electric IOU general rate cases. These expenses include all labor and non-labor expenses for the operation and maintenance of utility infrastructure, as well as general administrative expenses. They also do not have a profit mark up to shareholders. O&M expenses are meant to provide short-term benefits; such as maintenance to a powerplant which provides benefits within the year of that maintenance.[5] The O&M expenses are matched to the ratepayers that are paying for them, avoiding intergenerational equity issues (i.e., seeking to avoid a ratepayer 20 years from now paying for work that only benefitted a ratepayer today). There is also no need to incur financing costs (from bonds) since they are short expenses recovered in rates annually. One downside of traditional O&M cost recovery is that if a large O&M expenditure arises, ratepayers must absorb the entire costs in their rates in a single year. This could lead to rate shock and other bill volatility issues, such as large increases one year and potential decreases the next.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “With an increase of prolonged destructive wildfires, megadroughts, and other serious effects of climate change, climate resiliency efforts are imperative. All financing mechanisms should be made available so that electric utilities can continue investing in climate resiliency without subjecting California families to significant electric bill spikes. Assembly Bill 1513 will allow an electric utility to request authorization from the California Public Utilities Commission for the securitization of their ongoing wildfire mitigation efforts to achieve greater rate stabilization for electric utility ratepayers.”
- Impact of Wildfire Costs on Customer Rates. As highlighted in many discussions—most recently in this Committee’s informational hearing on February 22, 2023—California’s electric rates are increasing and forecasted to continue to increase at an alarming pace. According to the CPUC’s 2022 Senate Bill 695 Report,[6] electric costs have been on the rise, with wildfire mitigation efforts significantly contributing to rate growth beginning in 2021.[7]
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) and AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019) permitted the IOUs to open accounts in 2019 to track spending to implement their wildfire mitigation plans (WMPs). The IOUs are allowed to seek recovery of this spending in their general rate cases or through a separate application, after the conclusion of the period covered by the WMP. Therefore, there is lag between when spending takes place and when it is reflected in rates.
Table 1 shows wildfire spending related reflected in 2020-2021 rates. These values are inclusive of wildfire mitigation, wildfire insurance, and catastrophic event costs by CPUC and FERC jurisdiction. Total wildfire costs placed in rates between 2019 and 2021 are approximately $11.3 billion.
Table 1: Wildfire Mitigation and Wildfire Insurance Costs in Rates ($ millions)[8]
2019 | 2020 | 2021 | ||||
O&M | Capital | O&M | Capital | O&M | Capital | |
PG&E | 68.9 | 5.7 | 718.8 | 24.4 | 2,572.1 | 83.1 |
SCE | 288.5 | - | 1,005.8 | 0.6 | 1,627.5 | 90.8 |
SDG&E | 114.4 | 11.8 | 145.1 | 37.4 | 278.5 | 44.7 |
As Table 1 demonstrates, wildfire costs—especially operational costs—began to show up in rates in significant amounts starting in 2021. It should be noted, while these costs are high and growing, they make up less than a fifth of the total system costs of the utilities.[9] The impact of this incremental revenue requirement on bundled residential average bills in 2021 is shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Wildfire Costs Portion of 2021 Monthly Bill, Bundled Residential Customers
(Year-end, $/month)[10]
Total Bill | Wildfire Mitigation Portion | Wildfire Mitigation Portion (%) | |
PG&E | $139.68 | $22.14 | 15.9% |
SCE | $135.48 | $16.19 | 12.0% |
SDG&E | $183.21 | $13.95 | 7.6% |
The values in Table 1 and Table 2 show the actual costs of the wildfire efforts in rates. However the utilities have recorded costs far in excess of these values into the billions of dollars.[11] This gap between what are recorded expenses versus what appears in rates during a given year indicates the lag inherent in the CPUC ratemaking process, where costs are authorized based on forecasts; costs are recorded based on authorized spending plus other costs that arise from emergencies and CPUC orders; then costs are trued up in the recovery process. Most amortization periods for wildfire O&M costs, for instance, are for a 24-month cycle and will appear in subsequent years on customer bills.[12]
This bill seeks to alleviate this customer issue by proposing rate design strategies to redistribute the costs, so that the direct impact on customer bills is lessened. This is a laudable goal that has been discussed in various venues both in this Committee and at the CPUC. For example, the proponents of this measure put forward a sample calculation of how a $300 wildfire expense could be smoothed if securitized. If the $300 is only spread out over the year, as may be the case for some O&M expenses, that would result in $25/month increase to bills; which, based on Table 2 above is somewhere around a 15% increase in average residential monthly bills. If the $300 is securitized under a 10-year bond, the proponents estimate this would result in a $3/month increase to bills, closer to a 2% increase. In the securitization example, the total long-term cost to ratepayers would increase by $60[13] over the traditional spending mechanism; but it would cause less bill shock to customers in the short-term.
- CPUC Denial of O&M in Bonds. As mentioned previously, capital expenditures are typically financed through bonds. Once adopted by the CPUC, the fixed ratepayer charges used to pay for securitized bonds must be collected until bonds are fully paid off. As a result, bond charges take up space in customer rates for long periods of time. For example, the securitized bonds issued in 2003 to cover some of the costs from the energy crisis were finally paid off in September 2020.[14] Bonds are more expensive, over the long term, but do help smooth cost spikes that could adversely impact customer bills.
The CPUC thus weighs for each IOU application whether bond financing will provide short-term and long-term economic benefits to ratepayers. In October 2021, when considering SCE’s application to recover various wildfire-related capital expenditures, certain O&M expenses, and certain uncollectible COVID-19 arrears, the CPUC approved bonds for some, but not all, of the requested costs. Specifically, the CPUC denied securitized bonding for O&M expenses, noting: “We find that the time-value-of-money benefits associated with securitizing the O&M expenses over a 25-year bond term is substantially outweighed by associated financing costs and higher utility rates for future customers.”[15] The CPUC goes on to note that adjustments to conventional rate recovery approaches, such as paying off O&M over three years (versus the traditional one year term), can help ease bill shock concerns while not obligating ratepayers to a 25-year bond for costs that only benefit current ratepayers.
This bill reverses this CPUC decision by explicitly including O&M cost as eligible for securitization and by changing the factors the CPUC must weigh when deciding whether a bonds provides economic benefits to ratepayers. Specifically, this bill no longer requires that bonds must reduce rates (as compared to traditional financing). Instead, this bill requires only that the bonds provide short-term rate stability, which is presumed as being met—per the language in the bill—if the CPUC has authorized the costs to be paid off over more than a year. As noted above, most amortization periods for wildfire O&M costs are for a 24-month cycle, almost guaranteeing the “short-term economic benefit” would be satisfied under this measure. This could have the effect of endorsing an expensive transaction solely on the grounds that it is rate smoothing in the near-term, despite higher long-term overall costs.
The author has noted her intent is to clarify that O&M is eligible for securitization, given the recent and projected increases in these costs, largely from wildfire mitigation efforts. Providing the CPUC with more tools to ease the cost burden on ratepayers is aligned with broader efforts of this Committee, however, such tools must be used judiciously to minimize unintended consequences. This bill upends a CPUC ratemaking decision. When the Legislature modifies such decisions, caution is necessary, as changes to one aspect of rate design can have unanticipated effects on other aspects of the rate structure. As such, the Committee may wish to consider amending this bill to modify the presumption of public interest to give equal weight between short-term and long-term economic benefits when the CPUC determines whether recovery bonds are appropriate. Moreover, the committee and author should consider retaining the consideration that securitized bonds must reduce rates, as appears in current law.
- Prior Legislation.
AB 2937 (Calderon, 2022), largely similar to this bill, sought to expand the categories of expenses for which an electric IOU may request the CPUC allow the IOU to finance through issuance of a bond, backed by a reoccurring charge to the IOU’s ratepayers. Status: Died – Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 913 (Calderon) authorizes the CPUC to approve the securitization by electric IOUs of undercollection of utility bill amounts for the year 2020. Additionally, the measure aligns the "eligible claims" period with a utility's insurance policy period for purposes of wildfire related claims. Status: Chapter 253, Statutes of 2020.
AB 1054 (Holden), among its many provisions, authorizes the issuance of financing orders for the recovery of costs and expenses related to catastrophic wildfires (in 2019 and after). Also permits securitization of fire risk mitigation capital expenditures associated with the IOU's proportionate share of $5 billion in safety improvements. Status: Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019.
SB 901 (Dodd) among its many provisions, authorizes the issuance of financing orders to finance costs, in excess of insurance proceeds, incurred, or that are expected to be incurred, by an electrical corporation, excluding fines and penalties, related to 2017 wildfires. Status: Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CalChamber
Pacific Gas & Electric Company
Sempra Energy and Its Affiliates: San Diego Gas & Electric Company and Southern California Gas Company
Southern California Edison
Oppose
California Large Energy Consumers Association
The Utility Reform Network (TURN)
Analysis Prepared by: Laura Shybut / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
See Public Utilities Code §§ 850, 451.2, and 8386.3 ↑
D. 21-05-015 ↑
D. 21-06-030 ↑
D. 21-10-025 ↑
whereas the powerplant itself provides benefits for the lifetime of its generation (capital expenses) ↑
Pg. 13, CPUC, 2022 Senate Bill 695 Report, May 2022. ↑
Pg. 7, “Utility Costs and Affordability of the Grid of the Future: An Evaluation of Electric Costs, Rates, and Equity Issues Pursuant to P.U. Code Section 913.1,” Submitted pursuant to SB 695 (Kehoe, Chapter 337, Statutes of 2009); CPUC, February 2021 ↑
Pg. 42, CPUC, 2022 Senate Bill 695 Report, May 2022. ↑
Estimates from charts on pgs 43-47, Ibid. ↑
Pg. 47 CPUC, 2022 Senate Bill 695 Report, May 2022. ↑
Data request from Committee to PG&E, SCE, and SDG&E, April 2023. ↑
This was the case for the 2021 O&M costs in rates from Table 1; they were largely attributed to amortized costs from 2020. ↑
$3/month x 12 months x 10 years = $360 ↑
At which point the DWR bond charge expired, but an equivalent charge to support the participation of large IOUs in to the Wildfire Fund was established pursuant to AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019). ↑
Pg. 27-28, D. 21-10-025. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):