AB 1537: Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-02-17
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-29: Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Stern.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of health facilities, including skilled nursing facilities, by the State Department of Public Health. A violation of those provisions is a crime. Existing law requires health facilities to submit specified financial reports to the Department of Health Care Access and Information. Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services and under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services.
This bill would require, no later than July 1, 2024, the establishment of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for skilled nursing facilities, with exceptions. Under the direct patient-related services spending requirement, the bill would require that a minimum of 85% of a facilitys total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year be expended on residents direct patient-related services, as defined.
The bill would require a facility to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to the State Department of Health Care Services by June 30 of each calendar year, with certification signed by a duly authorized official, as specified.
The bill would require the State Department of Health Care Services to conduct an audit of the financial information reported by the facilities, to ensure its accuracy and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed limit, as specified. The bill would require the department to conduct the audit every 3 years, at the same time as the facilitys Medi-Cal audit.
If a skilled nursing facility fails to comply with the direct patient-related services spending requirement, the bill would require the facility to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the facility for resident services, as specified. The bill would require the State Department of Health Care Services to ensure that those payments are made and to impose sanctions, as specified. The bill would also authorize the department to withhold certain payments from a skilled nursing facility licensee for failure to fully disclose information, as specified.
Because a violation of these requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)No later than July 1, 2024, a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement shall be established pursuant to this section for skilled nursing facilities that are certified under the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), except as described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (j).
(1)A skilled nursing facility shall report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to the department, in a form to be determined by the department, by June 30 of each calendar year. All information submitted pursuant to this section shall be accompanied by a report certification signed by a duly authorized official of the skilled nursing facility or of the skilled nursing facilitys home office that certifies that, to the best of the officials knowledge and information, each statement and amount in the accompanying report is believed to be true and correct.
(2)Both the expenditures and revenues related to a facilitys state-mandated quality assurance fees and licensure fees shall not be included in their calculations for purposes of this section.
(3)The direct patient-related services spending requirement shall require a minimum of 85 percent of a facilitys total non-Medicare health revenues, including Medicare fee-for-service and Medicare Advantage, from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents.
(4)For purposes of this section, a continuing care retirement community, as defined in Section 1771, subject to this section shall report revenues to the department consistent with the revenues reported on its skilled nursing facility annual consolidated financial report pursuant to Section 128734.1, and shall not include revenue from continuing care entrance fees, monthly fees, or other charges incurred while the continuing care contractholder resides in a residential or assisted living unit.
(b)(1)Direct patient-related services shall include all of the following:
(A)Staffing services, including wages and benefits for nursing managers, nursing staff, and other personnel, who may include registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, certified nurse aides, noncertified or resident care aides, directors of nurses, in-house clerical staff regularly interacting with residents and caregivers, receptionists, evaluation nurses, minimum data set coordinators, and medical directors.
(B)Ancillary services, including, but not limited to, therapy services, supplies, pharmacy services, consultants, and laboratory services.
(C)Support services, including plant operations and maintenance, laundry and linen, housekeeping, resident activities, social services, services by a social service worker, services by a behavioral health consultant, dietary services, and in-service education.
(D)Rent, lease, or ownership costs that are not more than the facilitys fair rental value cost element as calculated by the department.
(E)Professional liability insurance costs that include the following:
(i)The full value of professional liability insurance costs, as long as the payment is not directed to a related party.
(ii)Professional liability insurance costs as adjusted by the department for profit elimination as part of the Medi-Cal auditing process if the payment is directed to a related party.
(2)Any administrative costs and profits paid to any management company or related party entities for staffing services, ancillary services, or support services shall be excluded from the definition of direct care.
(3)For purposes of calculating purchased and contracted services not covered by paragraph (2), the total number used shall be discounted at 85 percent of the contracted or purchased amount.
(c)(1)Nondirect patient-related services shall include all of the following:
(A)All administrative costs, including management and executive wages and benefits, all costs to management companies, administrative service companies, home office expenses for parent companies and holding companies, legal expenses, trade association fees and dues, insurance costs, licensing fees, and quality assurance fees. All administrative costs and profits paid to contractors or related party entities for staffing services, ancillary services, support services, or other services are considered nondirect patient-related services.
(B)Capital costs, including depreciation, interest rates, property taxes, corporate taxes, and property insurance, in excess of the facilitys fair rental value cost element as calculated by the department.
(C)Other expenses, including other interest rates and provision for bad debts.
(D)Profits, including net income and any profits paid to related parties on leases and property, and any profits paid to management companies.
(2)Excluded costs may be excluded from nondirect patient-related services and may include special high-cost equipment or improvements of the physical plant that directly benefit residents, such as establishing single rooms and private bathrooms, upon approval by the department.
(d)(1)The department shall conduct an audit, as described in Section 14170 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, of the financial information reported by skilled nursing facilities pursuant to this section, to ensure the accuracy of the information reported and compliance with the requirements of this section, and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed direct care limit for administrative costs and profits. These audits may also include any audits of contractors or related party entities.
(2)In reviewing financial reports provided to the department for compliance with this section, the department shall consider the skilled nursing facilitys annual consolidated financial reports filed with the Department of Health Care Access and Information pursuant to Sections 128734.1, 128735, and 128740.
(3)The department shall conduct the audit of the financial information reported by skilled nursing facilities pursuant to this section every three years, at the same time as the facilitys Medi-Cal audit, as described in Section 14170 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(e)If a skilled nursing facility fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement established pursuant to this section, the facility shall issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the skilled nursing facility for resident services, in an amount sufficient to ensure that the aggregate amount was paid for direct care as prescribed in this section.
(f)The department shall ensure that any pro rata dividend or credit shall be paid by the skilled nursing facility to the appropriate individuals and entities by September 30 of each calendar year.
(g)The department shall impose sanctions for the failure to comply with this section, in the form of an administrative fine set at double the percentage of the pro rata payments that the facility failed to distribute. Failure to comply with this section is also subject to any other applicable enforcement mechanisms described in this chapter.
(h)The department may withhold Medi-Cal payments from any skilled nursing facility licensee that fails to fully disclose accurate and complete information on the direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services costs under this section.
(i)A facility may appeal the departments determinations pursuant to Article 5.3 (commencing with Section 14170) of Chapter 7 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(j)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Department means the State Department of Health Care Services.
(2)Related party has the same meaning as set forth in Section 128734, and may include, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Home offices.
(B)Management organizations.
(C)Owners of real estate.
(D)Entities that provide staffing, therapy, pharmaceutical, marketing, administrative management, consulting, or insurance services.
(E)Providers of supplies and equipment.
(F)Financial advisers or consultants.
(G)Banking or financial entities.
(H)Any parent companies, holding companies, or sister organizations.
(I)Any entity in which an immediate family member of an owner of those organizations has an ownership interest of 5 percent or more. For purposes of this subparagraph, immediate family member includes spouse, natural parent, child, sibling, adopted child, adoptive parent, stepparent, stepchild, stepsister, stepbrother, father-in-law, mother-in-law, sister-in-law, brother-in-law, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, grandparent, and grandchild.
(3)Skilled nursing facility has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 1250, except that the term excludes skilled nursing facilities that are not certified to participate in the Medi-Cal program and are not subject to audit under Section 14170 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, government-owned or government-operated facilities, hospital-based distinct part facilities, as defined in Section 483.5 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and inpatient hospice programs.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2024 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Stern. |
| Jun 18, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 17, 2024 | Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 17, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Stern. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (September 1). |
| Aug 14, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (July 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 64. Noes 2. Page 2046.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 1.) (May 18). |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 18, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 1537 Wood Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform | ** Support | |
| California Association of Long Term Care Medicine | ** Support | |
| California Commission on Aging | ** Support | |
| California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association | ** Support | |
| California Retired Teachers Association | ** Support | |
| Flagstone Healthcare | ** Against | |
| Justice in Aging | ** Support | |
| PROVIDENCE ADMINISTRATIVE CONSULTING SERVICES( ) | ** Against | |
| The Geriatric Circle | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1537 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1537
Author: Wood (D)
Introduced: 2/17/23
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 10-0, 7/12/23
AYES: Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Roth, Rubio, Wahab, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-1, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Seyarto
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/31/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill establishes a requirement that skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) report revenues and expenses to the Department of Health Care Services, and based on these reports, requires 85% of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents. Requires a SNF that does not meet this minimum spending requirement on direct patient services to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and anyone that made non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, in an amount to bring the total spending up to 85%.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure of health facilities, including SNFs, by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), and defines a SNF as a health facility that provides skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis. [HSC §1250(c)]
- Requires CDPH to develop regulations that establish staff-to-patient ratios for direct caregivers (defined as registered nurses, licensed vocational nurses, psychiatric technicians, or certified nurse assistants) working in a SNF. Requires, effective July 1, 2018, freestanding SNFs to have a minimum number of direct care services hours of 3.5 per patient day, including a minimum of 2.4 hours per patient day for certified nurse assistants. [HSC §1276.65]
- Requires an organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a health facility, which includes hospitals, SNFs, and other facilities providing inpatient care, to annually file with the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), for each separately licensed facility that is operated, conducted, or maintained by the reporting organization, reports that include a balance sheet detailing the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the health facility; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; and, a statement of cashflows, including ongoing and new capital expenditures and depreciation. [HSC §128735]
- Requires each organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a SNF to file with HCAI, as part of the information required in 3) above, whether the licensee, or a general partner, director or officer of the licensee, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF. Requires the licensee, if the licensee or the general partner, director, or officer of the licensee has such an interest, to disclose all services provided to the SNF, the number of individuals who provide that service at the SNF, and any other information requested by HCAI. [HSC §128734
- Requires the disclosure in 5) above, if goods, fees, and services collectively worth $10,000 or more per year are delivered to the SNF, to include the related party’s profit and loss statement. [HSC §128734]
- Defines “related party,” for purposes of 5) and 6) above, as an organization related to the licensee provider, or that is under common ownership or control, as defined in specified provisions of the federal regulations. [HSC §128734 (b)(3)]
- Requires SNFs, commencing with fiscal years ending December 31, 2023, to file an annual consolidated report, reviewed by a certified public accountant, that includes specifies statements, including the following: a balance sheet; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; a statement of cashflows; and, a combined financial statement. Requires this information from all operating entities, licenseholders, and related parties in which the organization has an ownership of 5% or more and that provides any service, facility, or supply to the SNF. [HSC §128734.1]
- Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to develop and implement a cost-based reimbursement rate methodology for freestanding nursing facilities for purposes of the Medi-Cal program, reflecting the sum of the projected cost of each cost category and passthrough costs, as specified. [WIC §14126.021, §14126.023]
- Requires DHCS to develop the SNF Quality and Accountability Supplemental Payment System to provide supplemental payments to SNFs that improve the quality and accountability of care rendered to residents in SNFs and to penalize those facilities that do not meet measurable standards. [WIC §14126.022]
This bill:
- Requires the establishment, by July 1, 2024, of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs that are CMS-certified, except government-owned or government-operated facilities, or hospital-based distinct part facilities.
- Requires a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to DHCS by June 30 of each calendar year. Requires all submitted information to be accompanied by a report certification signed by a duly authorized official of the SNF that certifies that, to the best of the official’s knowledge, each statement and amount in the accompanying report is true and correct.
- Excludes the expenditures and revenues related to a SNF’s state-mandated quality assurance fees and licensure fees from being included in the calculations for purposes of this bill.
- Requires 85% of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be spent on direct patient-related services.
- Defines “direct patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- Staffing services, including wages and benefits for nursing managers, nursing staff, and other personnel, who may include registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, certified nurse aides, noncertified or resident care aides, directors of nurses, in-house clerical staff regularly interacting with residents and caregivers, receptionists, evaluation nurses, minimum data set coordinators, and medical directors;
- Ancillary services, including, but not limited to, therapy services, supplies, pharmacy services, consultants, and laboratory services;
- Support services, including plant operations and maintenance, laundry and linen, housekeeping, resident activities, social services, services by a social worker, services by a behavioral health consultant, and in-service education;
- Rent, lease or ownership costs that are not more than the SNF’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by the DHCS; and,
- Professional liability insurance costs that include the full value of professional liability insurance costs, as long as the payment is not directed to a related party, or professional liability costs as adjusted by DHCS for profit elimination as part of the Medi-Cal auditing process if the payment is directed to a related party.
- Excludes from the definition of “direct patient-related services” in 5) above any administrative costs and profits paid to any management company or related parties for staffing services, ancillary services, or support services. Requires, for purposes of calculating purchased and contracted services not covered by this exclusion, the total number used to be discounted at 85% of the contracted or purchased amount.
- Defines “nondirect patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- All administrative costs, including management and executive wages and benefits, all costs to management companies, administrative services companies, home office expenses for parent companies and holding companies, legal expenses, trade association fees and dues, insurance costs, licensing fees, and quality assurance fees. Requires all administrative costs and profits paid to contractors or related party entities for staffing services, ancillary services, support services, or other services are considered nondirect patient-related services;
- Capital costs, including depreciation, interest rates, property taxes, corporate taxes, and property insurance, in excess of the facility’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by DHCS;
- Other expenses, including other interest rates and provisions for bad debts; and,
- Profits, including net income and any profits paid to related parties on leases and property, and any profits paid to management companies.
- Permits excluded costs to be excluded from nondirect patient-related services and to include special high-cost equipment or improvements of the physical plant that directly benefit residents, such as establishing single rooms and private bathrooms, upon approval by DHCS.
- Requires DHCS to conduct an audit, as described in existing law, of the financial information reported by SNFs pursuant to this bill, to ensure the accuracy of the information reported and compliance with the requirements of this bill, and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed direct care limit for administrative costs and profits. Permits these audits to also include any audits of contractors or related party entities.
- Requires DHCS, in reviewing financial reports for compliance with this bill, to consider the SNF’s annual consolidated financial reports filed with HCAI pursuant to existing law, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to conduct the audit of the financial information reported by the SNFs pursuant to this bill every three years, at the same time as the SNF’s Medi-Cal audit that is required under existing law.
- Requires a SNF, if it fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement under this bill, to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, in an amount sufficient to ensure that the aggregate amount was paid for direct care as prescribed under this bill.
- Requires DHCS to impose sanctions for the failure to comply with this bill, in the form of an administrative fine set at double the percentage of the pro rata payments that the facility failed to distribute. Specifies that failure to comply with this bill is also subject to any other applicable enforcement mechanism described in the health facility licensing law.
- Permits DHCS to withhold Medi-Cal payments from any SNF that fails to fully disclose accurate and complete information on the direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services costs under this bill.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, nearly 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex corporate ownership structures, often including separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of holding companies and subsidiaries in control of each facility. This complexity is designed to shield operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight and conceal profits. The goal is to ensure that most of SNFs operating costs are spent on direct care of vulnerable residents, and while there are some financial controls on Medi-Cal spending, there are no controls on spending for Medicare, managed care and private payers. Therefore, SNFs can cut staffing, wages and benefits while increasing spending on administration, profits and property. The author concludes that residents of California SNFs need our support and protection and this bill continues year-after-year efforts to ensure that our most vulnerable Californians get quality care that ensures their safety while still allowing the facilities to earn profits that are appropriate and fair.
- Reports cited by author in support of this bill.
- According to a 2023 National Consumer Voice report (the report), “Where do the billions of dollars go?” in 2020, nursing homes received $67.9 billion dollars from the Medicare and Medicaid programs to care for residents. The report notes that each year, SNFs must file Medicare cost reports with CMS. In these reports, the facilities are required to disclose how they spend their revenue from all payment sources, including Medicare and Medicaid dollars, however, it is unclear to what extent CMS reviews these cost reports. SNFs frequently make payments to providers of services that far exceed the reported costs, which draws into question how the money is being used, and whether the reports are being reviewed by CMS. This apparent lack of scrutiny of SNF cost reports has allowed the industry to develop and employ accounting measures that appear to divert taxpayer dollars. The mechanism SNFs use to potentially hide profits are entities known as “related parties.” These are companies owned or controlled by SNF operators that do business with their own SNFs. Nursing home operators pay billions of dollars each year to “related party” companies. The report found that the amount of money paid to related parties far exceeded the costs reported by the related party, and CMS cost reports do not require this discrepancy to be explained. To illustrate, Pruitt Health, a nursing home chain that owns roughly 90 nursing homes, reported related party costs of nearly $482 million for the years from 2018 to 2020. At the same time, Pruitt reported paying to these related parties roughly $570 million dollars, a payment in excess of 18%. The CMS cost report provides no information on why Pruitt made nearly $90 million in excess payments to its related parties.
- A 2015 study published in the International Journal of Health Services, “Hidden ownership, hidden profits, and poor quality of nursing home care: A case study,” examined the ownership transparency, financial accountability, and quality indicators of a regional for-profit nursing home chain in California, and compared this chain to other for-profit chains, for-profit non-chains, and nonprofit nursing home groups in 2011. The chain's complex, interlocking individual and corporate owners and property companies obscured its ownership structure and financial arrangements. Nursing and support services expenditures were lower than nonprofits and administrative costs were higher than for-profit non-chains. The chain's nurse staffing was lower than expected staffing levels; its deficiencies and citations were higher than in nonprofits; and a number of lawsuits resulted in bankruptcy. Profits were hidden in the chain's management fees, lease agreements, interest payments to owners, and purchases from related-party companies.
- Washington Post article on Brius Healthcare. On December 31, 2020, the Washington Post published a lengthy investigative article focused on the largest nursing home operator in California, known as Brius Healthcare (Brius) and owned by Shlomo Rechnitz. According to this article, Brius operates about 80 nursing homes, and like the majority of the industry nationwide, utilizes a business practice of paying related companies for goods, services, and rent. According to the article, in 2018 alone, Brius nursing homes paid related parties $13 million for supplies, $10 million for administrative services and financial consulting, and $16 million for workers’ compensation insurance. The homes also sent a total of $64 million in rent to dozens of related land companies. The article notes that the practice is legal and widely support by the industry as a way to help control costs and limit financial liability. Watchdog groups argue that nursing home owners can reap excessive profits from public funds by overpaying their own companies, and that related parties generally do not have to disclose profits, leaving regulators with little way to assess the financial gains of owners. The Washington Post obtained tax returns from 2013 for five companies connected to Brius, four of which were holding companies that draw income from companies in which they invest or own. The tax returns showed that the four holding companies took in a total of $38 million from Brius nursing homes in 2013, and of that, nearly $28 million was paid in distributions to Rechnitz and his wife. All but 18 Brius homes pay rent to related companies, which either own the properties outright or lease the buildings from unrelated owners and then sublease them to the nursing homes. According to the article, in the Eureka area, a company managed by Rechnitz in 2011 leased five nursing homes, agreeing to pay the property owner a total of $3 million in rent per year. Rechnitz’s company then subleased the buildings to the nursing homes for $3.5 million. Overall, Brius’ rent payments for buildings and equipment were 20% higher per bed than comparable for-profit nursing homes in California.
- California State Auditor report and related party transactions. At the request of the Joint Legislative Audit Committee, the California State Auditor published an audit of SNFs in May of 2018, subtitling the report “Absent Effective State Oversight, Substandard Quality of Care Has Continued.” The report concluded that the State has not adequately addressed ongoing deficiencies related to the quality of care that SNFs provide, and that from 2006 to 2015, the number of substandard care deficiencies that SNFs received increased by 31%, while deficiencies that caused or were likely to cause serious injury, harm, or death increased by 35%. The State Auditor reviewed three of the largest private operators of SNFs in California: Brius, Plum, and Longwood. According to the State Auditor, while the net income of the rest of the industry in California decreased, the net income of these three companies increased by tens of millions of dollars. The State Auditor found that the owners of these three companies were able to earn income, separate from the revenue their facilities earned from Medicare, Medi-Cal, or managed care, when their facilities obtained goods and services from related parties, or other businesses that they or their family members owned or controlled. For example, related parties may provide goods such as medical supplies and equipment, laundry and linens, and food to the SNF. Related parties may also provide therapy services, maintenance services, financial consulting, and administrative services, and SNFs frequently lease their buildings from related-party property owners. These related party transactions are common in the industry, and are legally allowable, although CMS and Medi-Cal take measures to limit the possibility that it might pay for profits from related party transactions. For example, the cost for such transactions are not allowed to exceed the price of comparable transactions procured elsewhere. According to the State Auditor, the three companies paid between $37.2 million and $65.7 million to related parties from 2007 through 2015; however, the report also found that the companies properly disclosed most of the potential related-party transactions, and that the Medi-Cal audit process ensured that Medi-Cal did not pay for profits realized from any of these transactions.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- CDPH estimates ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 (Licensing and Certification Program Fund) to enforce the provisions as licensing requirements.
- Unknown, ongoing General Fund costs, likely millions, for the DHCS for state administration.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/21/23)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Association of Long Term Care Medicine
California Commission on Aging
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Retired Teachers Association
Justice in Aging
The Geriatric Circle
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/21/23)
Flagstone Healthcare
Providence Administrative Consulting Services
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Geriatric Circle (GC) supports this bill and notes that SNFs are receive government funding of more than $10 billion a year, but the lack of transparency and accountability for how that money is spent is alarming. GC states that in 2020, only 64% of nursing home revenues were used for direct resident care in California, and that this bill will ensure that much needed funds go into direct care services and away from profits, administration, and property.
The Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program (Ombudsman) states in support that inadequate staffing has plagued nursing homes for decades, and studies have repeatedly shown that significant numbers of our nation’s nursing homes fail to adequately staff their facilities. According to the Ombudsman, about 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex ownership structures, with separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of companies, holding companies, and subsidiaries in control of each SNF. The Ombudsman states that this bill would require DHCS to conduct an audit of the financial information reported by the facilities, to ensure its accuracy and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed limit.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Providence Administrative Consulting Services (PACS), which states it is the largest skilled nursing company in California with more than 125 affiliated facilities throughout the state, states it has significant concerns regarding this bill to mandate direct care spending, reporting, and rebate requirements. PACS states that the bill projects to be nothing short of devastating to the industry. Flagstone Health also opposes this bill, stating, among other concerns, that the definitions are either too narrow or too broad, and the true cost of care is not being considered. Additionally, Flagstone argues that only the daily rate for Medi-Cal services should be considered as “applicable health care revenue,” and that incentive payments should not be counted as revenue.
Letter of concern. The California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) submitted a letter of concern regarding possible future amendments that might be coming from DHCS. CAHF states that as the bill currently stands in print, it contains substantively the same language as AB 2079 (Wood) from last year that was vetoed, which CAHF was neutral on when it was sent to the Governor. CAHF states that the author is seeking technical assistance (TA) from DHCS and may amend this bill based on this TA. CAHF wanted to share some concerns on key issues that it would like considered in any forthcoming amendments. First, CAHF states that the direct cost ratio requirements should consider the constraints faced by facilities related to capital expenditures. As drafted, this bill limits the inclusion of rent, lease, or ownership costs to the facility’s fair rental value costs (FRVC) as calculated by DHCS. Under this FRVS methodology, the state establishes a price for the use of space that is not based on actual costs paid by an operated to the owner of the building, which is currently at about 25% of their actual capital costs. CAHF states that any amendments to this bill should recognize appropriate capital costs that preserve incentives for facilities to invest in long-term ownership and maintaining and upgrading the physical plant. Second, CAHF states that Medicare should continue to be excluded from the base revenue for calculating a direct care ratio. In 2022, CAHF negotiated amendments to AB 2079 that the spending requirement would be based on a facility’s non-Medicare health revenues (which is primarily Medi-Cal). CAHF states that this provision was important because California has authority only over how facilities expend payment from the Medi-Cal program, and that Medicare beneficiaries are different and facilities are subject to different requirements in how Medicare funding is utilized for patient care needs. Limiting AB 2079 to non-Medicare revenues was a key amendment for CAHF removing their opposition to that bill and moving to a neutral position. CAHF also states that analysis is needed to develop an accurate ratio of direct to indirect care, and that applying 85% to an industry with different costs and reimbursement structure compared to the insurance industry, with which this bill is attempting to align its spending ratio, may not be appropriate. Prior to implementing any penalties, CAHF argues that DHCS should collect and analyze cost data over multiple years to determine the appropriate ratio. Finally, CAHF states that the direct costs definition should align with the existing definition of Costs Related to Patient Care established by the federal Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-2, 5/31/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Davies, Gallagher
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Wallis
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
9/2/23 12:11:09
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1537 (Wood) - Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement
Version: February 17, 2023 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 10 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
AB 1537 would establish a requirement that skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) report revenues and expenses to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), and based on these reports, would require 85 percent of a SNF’s revenues be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 (Licensing and Certification Program Fund) to enforce the provisions as licensing requirements.
- Unknown, ongoing General Fund costs, likely millions, for the DHCS for state administration.
Background:
The CDPH is responsible for the licensure of health facilities, including SNFs. A SNF is defined as a health facility that provides skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis.
Current law requires certain health facilities, including SNFs, to annually file with the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), for each separately licensed facility that is operated, conducted, or maintained by the reporting organization, reports that include a balance sheet detailing the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the health facility; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; and, a statement of cashflows, including ongoing and new capital expenditures and depreciation.
Under the Medi-Cal program, DHCS is required to develop and implement a cost-based reimbursement rate methodology for freestanding nursing facilities reflecting the sum of the projected cost of each cost category and pass-through costs, as specified. The DHCS administers a program to provide supplemental payments to SNFs that improve the quality and accountability of care rendered to residents in SNFs and to penalize those facilities that do not meet measurable standards. DHCS is also responsible for auditing amounts paid for services provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Require the establishment, by July 1, 2024, of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs, as specified.
- Require a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to DHCS by June 30 of each calendar year.
- Require 85 percent of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be spent on direct patient-related services, as specified.
- Require that if a SNF fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement, the facility must issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, as specified.
- Require DHCS to conduct audits, impose sanctions, and withhold Medi-Cal payments, as specified.
Related Legislation:
AB 2079 (Wood, 2022) was similar to this bill. AB 2079 was vetoed by the Governor,
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1537 (Wood) - Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement
Version: February 17, 2023 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 10 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
AB 1537 would establish a requirement that skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) report revenues and expenses to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), and based on these reports, would require 85 percent of a SNF’s revenues be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 (Licensing and Certification Program Fund) to enforce the provisions as licensing requirements.
- Unknown, ongoing General Fund costs, likely millions, for the DHCS for state administration.
Background:
The CDPH is responsible for the licensure of health facilities, including SNFs. A SNF is defined as a health facility that provides skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis.
Current law requires certain health facilities, including SNFs, to annually file with the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), for each separately licensed facility that is operated, conducted, or maintained by the reporting organization, reports that include a balance sheet detailing the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the health facility; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; and, a statement of cashflows, including ongoing and new capital expenditures and depreciation.
Under the Medi-Cal program, DHCS is required to develop and implement a cost-based reimbursement rate methodology for freestanding nursing facilities reflecting the sum of the projected cost of each cost category and pass-through costs, as specified. The DHCS administers a program to provide supplemental payments to SNFs that improve the quality and accountability of care rendered to residents in SNFs and to penalize those facilities that do not meet measurable standards. DHCS is also responsible for auditing amounts paid for services provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Require the establishment, by July 1, 2024, of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs, as specified.
- Require a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to DHCS by June 30 of each calendar year.
- Require 85 percent of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be spent on direct patient-related services, as specified.
- Require that if a SNF fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement, the facility must issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, as specified.
- Require DHCS to conduct audits, impose sanctions, and withhold Medi-Cal payments, as specified.
Related Legislation:
AB 2079 (Wood, 2022) was similar to this bill. AB 2079 was vetoed by the Governor,
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Susan Talamantes Eggman, Chair
BILL NO: AB 1537
AUTHOR: | Wood | ||
VERSION: | February 17, 2023 | ||
HEARING DATE: | July 12, 2023 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement
SUMMARY:
Establishes a requirement that skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) report revenues and expenses to the Department of Health Care Services, and based on these reports, requires 85% of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents. Requires a SNF that does not meet this minimum spending requirement on direct patient services to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and anyone that made non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, in an amount to bring the total spending up to 85%.
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure of health facilities, including SNFs, by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), and defines a SNF as a health facility that provides skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis. [HSC §1250(c)]
- Requires CDPH to develop regulations that establish staff-to-patient ratios for direct caregivers (defined as registered nurses, licensed vocational nurses, psychiatric technicians, or certified nurse assistants) working in a SNF. Requires, effective July 1, 2018, freestanding SNFs to have a minimum number of direct care services hours of 3.5 per patient day, including a minimum of 2.4 hours per patient day for certified nurse assistants. [HSC §1276.65]
- Designates the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) as the state agency designated to collect health facility data for use by all state agencies, including data required in Medi-Cal cost reports, and various financial data reports. [HSC §128730]
- Requires an organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a health facility, which includes hospitals, SNFs, and other facilities providing inpatient care, to annually file with HCAI, for each separately licensed facility that is operated, conducted, or maintained by the reporting organization, reports that include a balance sheet detailing the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the health facility; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; and, a statement of cashflows, including ongoing and new capital expenditures and depreciation. [HSC §128735]
- Requires each organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a SNF to file with HCAI, as part of the information required in 4) above, whether the licensee, or a general partner, director or officer of the licensee, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF. Requires the licensee, if the licensee or the general partner, director, or officer of the licensee has such an interest, to disclose all services provided to the SNF, the number of individuals who provide that service at the SNF, and any other information requested by HCAI. [HSC §128734
- Requires the disclosure in 5) above, if goods, fees, and services collectively worth $10,000 or more per year are delivered to the SNF, to include the related party’s profit and loss statement. [HSC §128734]
- Defines “related party,” for purposes of 5) and 6) above, as an organization related to the licensee provider, or that is under common ownership or control, as defined in specified provisions of the federal regulations. [HSC §128734 (b)(3)]
- Requires SNFs, commencing with fiscal years ending December 31, 2023, to file an annual consolidated report, reviewed by a certified public accountant, that includes specifies statements, including the following: a balance sheet; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; a statement of cashflows; and, a combined financial statement. Requires this information from all operating entities, licenseholders, and related parties in which the organization has an ownership of 5% or more and that provides any service, facility, or supply to the SNF. [HSC §128734.1]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), under which low-income individuals are eligible for medical coverage. [WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Requires DHCS to develop and implement a cost-based reimbursement rate methodology for freestanding nursing facilities reflecting the sum of the projected cost of each cost category and passthrough costs, as specified. [WIC §14126.021, §14126.023]
- Requires DHCS to develop the SNF Quality and Accountability Supplemental Payment System to provide supplemental payments to SNFs that improve the quality and accountability of care rendered to residents in SNFs and to penalize those facilities that do not meet measurable standards. [WIC §14126.022]
- Requires amounts paid for services provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries to be audited by DHCS. Requires DHCS to maintain adequate controls to ensure responsibility and accountability for the expenditure of federal and state funds. Requires cost reports and other data submitted by providers for the purpose of determining reasonable costs for services or establishing rates of payment to be consider true and correct unless audited or reviewed by DHCS within three years. [WIC §14170]
This bill:
- Requires the establishment, by July 1, 2024, of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs that are CMS-certified, except government-owned or government-operated facilities, or hospital-based distinct part facilities.
- Requires a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to DHCS by June 30 of each calendar year. Requires all submitted information to be accompanied by a report certification signed by a duly authorized official of the SNF that certifies that, to the best of the official’s knowledge, each statement and amount in the accompanying report is true and correct.
- Excludes the expenditures and revenues related to a SNF’s state-mandated quality assurance fees and licensure fees from being included in the calculations for purposes of this bill.
- Requires 85% of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be spent on direct patient-related services.
- Defines “direct patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- Staffing services, including wages and benefits for nursing managers, nursing staff, and other personnel, who may include registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, certified nurse aides, noncertified or resident care aides, directors of nurses, in-house clerical staff regularly interacting with residents and caregivers, receptionists, evaluation nurses, minimum data set coordinators, and medical directors;
- Ancillary services, including, but not limited to, therapy services, supplies, pharmacy services, consultants, and laboratory services;
- Support services, including plant operations and maintenance, laundry and linen, housekeeping, resident activities, social services, services by a social worker, services by a behavioral health consultant, and in-service education;
- Rent, lease or ownership costs that are not more than the SNF’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by the DHCS; and,
- Professional liability insurance costs that include the full value of professional liability insurance costs, as long as the payment is not directed to a related party, or professional liability costs as adjusted by DHCS for profit elimination as part of the Medi-Cal auditing process if the payment is directed to a related party.
- Excludes from the definition of “direct patient-related services” in 5) above any administrative costs and profits paid to any management company or related parties for staffing services, ancillary services, or support services. Requires, for purposes of calculating purchased and contracted services not covered by this exclusion, the total number used to be discounted at 85% of the contracted or purchased amount.
- Defines “nondirect patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- All administrative costs, including management and executive wages and benefits, all costs to management companies, administrative services companies, home office expenses for parent companies and holding companies, legal expenses, trade association fees and dues, insurance costs, licensing fees, and quality assurance fees. Requires all administrative costs and profits paid to contractors or related party entities for staffing services, ancillary services, support services, or other services are considered nondirect patient-related services;
- Capital costs, including depreciation, interest rates, property taxes, corporate taxes, and property insurance, in excess of the facility’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by DHCS;
- Other expenses, including other interest rates and provisions for bad debts; and,
- Profits, including net income and any profits paid to related parties on leases and property, and any profits paid to management companies.
- Permits excluded costs to be excluded from nondirect patient-related services and to include special high-cost equipment or improvements of the physical plant that directly benefit residents, such as establishing single rooms and private bathrooms, upon approval by DHCS.
- Requires DHCS to conduct an audit, as described in existing law, of the financial information reported by SNFs pursuant to this bill, to ensure the accuracy of the information reported and compliance with the requirements of this bill, and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed direct care limit for administrative costs and profits. Permits these audits to also include any audits of contractors or related party entities.
- Requires DHCS, in reviewing financial reports for compliance with this bill, to consider the SNF’s annual consolidated financial reports filed with HCAI pursuant to existing law, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to conduct the audit of the financial information reported by the SNFs pursuant to this bill every three years, at the same time as the SNF’s Medi-Cal audit that is required under existing law.
- Requires a SNF, if it fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement under this bill, to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, in an amount sufficient to ensure that the aggregate amount was paid for direct care as prescribed under this bill.
- Requires DHCS to impose sanctions for the failure to comply with this bill, in the form of an administrative fine set at double the percentage of the pro rata payments that the facility failed to distribute. Specifies that failure to comply with this bill is also subject to any other applicable enforcement mechanism described in the health facility licensing law.
- Permits DHCS to withhold Medi-Cal payments from any SNF that fails to fully disclose accurate and complete information on the direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services costs under this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs to DHCS are unknown, but would likely be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, ongoing, to develop processes and guidance for SNFs to report data, and to conduct the financial audits and enforce this bill (General Fund, federal funds).
CDPH estimates annual, ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 to enforce the provisions of this bill as licensing requirements (Licensing and Certification Fund). These costs would cover 2.0 full time employee positions to verify SNFs appropriately and timely pay any required proportional dividends or credits; sanction SNFs that fail to appropriately and timely issue those dividends or credits; and ensure compliance with bill requirements during a SNF’s re-licensure application review.
CDPH notes the bill assigns DHCS responsibility to verify whether SNFs pay required dividends or credits and to sanction those who fail to do so. However, CDPH notes existing law assigns this responsibility to CDPH. CDPH anticipates reviewing facility compliance with the requirements of this bill as part of CDPH’s routine annual licensure renewal process because SNFs must submit re-licensure applications, update any information, and submit licensing fees annually.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 64 - 2 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 1 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 13 - 0 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, nearly 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex corporate ownership structures, often including separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of holding companies and subsidiaries in control of each facility. This complexity is designed to shield operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight and conceal profits. The goal is to ensure that most of SNFs operating costs are spent on direct care of vulnerable residents, and while there are some financial controls on Medi-Cal spending, there are no controls on spending for Medicare, managed care and private payers. Therefore, SNFs can cut staffing, wages and benefits while increasing spending on administration, profits and property. The author concludes that residents of California SNFs need our support and protection and this bill continues year-after-year efforts to ensure that our most vulnerable Californians get quality care that ensures their safety while still allowing the facilities to earn profits that are appropriate and fair.
- Background on costs provided by the author. According to information provided by the author, in 2020, HCAI SNF cost reports showed total net revenues were $10.8515 billion for 947 nursing facilities (excluding intermediate care, mentally disordered, developmentally disabled and hospital-based facilities). Of the total net health revenues, 38.4% were from Medicare, 36.9% were from Medi-Cal, 16.5% were from Medicare and Medi-Cal managed care, 3.9% were from self-pay, and 4.3% from other payers. That year, of the total revenues, 37.3% was spent on routine nursing care, 9.8% on ancillary services, 16.9% on support services (including social services, dietary, housekeeping and maintenance) for a total of 64.0% spent on direct care costs. The non-direct care costs were: 20.6% on administration, including licensing and quality assurance fees, 8.2% on property, 1.6% on other (interest and bad debts), and 5.6% profit of their total revenues for a total of 36.0% spent on non-resident services.
- Reports cited by author in support of this bill.
- A 2016 Government Accountability Office study, “Skilled nursing facilities: CMS should improve accessibility and reliability of expenditure data,” found that nursing homes owned by private equity (PE) firms had increased costs for operation and capital, along with higher profit margins compared to other for-profit or nonprofit homes. PE-owned facilities (about 11% of nursing facilities nationwide), had 10% increases in 90-day mortality for short-stay Medicare patients, with increases in taxpayer spending. After for-profit PE buyouts, nursing homes have sharp declines in resident health and compliance with care standards because of cuts in nursing staff and higher bed utilization compared to acquisitions by non-PE corporate chains.
- According to a 2023 National Consumer Voice report (the report), “Where do the billions of dollars go?” in 2020, nursing homes received $67.9 billion dollars from the Medicare and Medicaid programs to care for residents. The report notes that each year, SNFs must file Medicare cost reports with CMS. In these reports, the facilities are required to disclose how they spend their revenue from all payment sources, including Medicare and Medicaid dollars, however, it is unclear to what extent CMS reviews these cost reports. SNFs frequently make payments to providers of services that far exceed the reported costs, which draws into question how the money is being used, and whether the reports are being reviewed by CMS. This apparent lack of scrutiny of SNF cost reports has allowed the industry to develop and employ accounting measures that appear to divert taxpayer dollars. The mechanism SNFs use to potentially hide profits are entities known as “related parties.” These are companies owned or controlled by SNF operators that do business with their own SNFs. Nursing home operators pay billions of dollars each year to “related party” companies. The report found that the amount of money paid to related parties far exceeded the costs reported by the related party, and CMS cost reports do not require this discrepancy to be explained. To illustrate, Pruitt Health, a nursing home chain that owns roughly 90 nursing homes, reported related party costs of nearly $482 million for the years from 2018 to 2020. At the same time, Pruitt reported paying to these related parties roughly $570 million dollars, a payment in excess of 18%. The CMS cost report provides no information on why Pruitt made nearly $90 million in excess payments to its related parties.
- A 2015 study published in the International Journal of Health Services, “Hidden ownership, hidden profits, and poor quality of nursing home care: A case study,” examined the ownership transparency, financial accountability, and quality indicators of a regional for-profit nursing home chain in California, and compared this chain to other for-profit chains, for-profit non-chains, and nonprofit nursing home groups in 2011. The chain's complex, interlocking individual and corporate owners and property companies obscured its ownership structure and financial arrangements. Nursing and support services expenditures were lower than nonprofits and administrative costs were higher than for-profit non-chains. The chain's nurse staffing was lower than expected staffing levels; its deficiencies and citations were higher than in nonprofits; and a number of lawsuits resulted in bankruptcy. Profits were hidden in the chain's management fees, lease agreements, interest payments to owners, and purchases from related-party companies.
- Medical loss ratio in the insurance market. The requirement to spend a certain percentage of revenues on direct care expenses versus administrative costs is often called a medical loss ratio (MLR). In the insurance market, in general terms, an MLR is the percentage of each dollar a health plan or insurer receives in premiums that the plan spends on health care services, as defined, versus administration, sales, marketing and profit. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) required states to establish an MLR for health plans and insurers serving commercial populations. Dental plans are exempt from the ACA-required MLR. For plans in the large group market, the ACA-required MLR is 85% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. For individual and small group plans, the MLR is 80% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. The federal Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) secretary can adjust small group and individual market MLR if he or she determines that the 80% requirement may destabilize the individual market in a state. If a plan fails to meet the federal MLR requirements, rebates are required to be issued to the plans’ customers.
In May of 2016, CMS issued a rule requiring states to ensure that each Medicaid managed care plan calculates and reports a MLR, and to develop plan rates in a way that the plan would reasonably achieve a MLR standard of at least 85% for the rate year. To implement this requirement, SB 171 (Hernandez, Chapter 768, Statutes of 2017) was enacted to require Medi-Cal managed care plans, commencing July 1, 2019, to comply with a minimum 85% MLR, consistent with federal regulations. SB 171 required, effective on or after July 1, 2023, a Medi-Cal managed care plan to provide a remittance for an MLR reporting year if the ratio does not meet the minim standard of 85%. - Los Angeles County Office of Inspector General (LAC OIG) report highlights complex ownership structures. In February 2021, LAC OIG published “Improving Oversight and Accountability Within Skilled Nursing Facilities: Second Interim Report,” which followed publication of the first interim report in October of 2020. These reports were directed by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors in response to the devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on SNF residents and staff. While the two reports focus primarily on COVID-19 mitigation efforts and the capacity of the County’s Health Facilities Inspection Division’s to accomplish its oversight role, this second interim report also looked at the corporate ownership structures of large SNF chains in California. According to LAC OIG, large SNF chains have developed specific strategies to increase their profitability, including creating complex ownership structures to reduce liability by establishing multiple layers of related companies which separately own, manage, and operate their component facilities. Some SNF chains implement complicated ownership structures which utilize separate management companies and service providers owned by the same ownership group via a series of limited liability companies (LLCs). This can result in a complex and interlocking structure of related individual and corporate owners, management companies and service providers that obscures the ownership and the financial relationships between the various LLCs and lead to higher administrative costs. A study of one of California’s largest SNF chains found that corporate profits were hidden in management fees, lease agreements, and various payments for ancillary support services that were made to companies related to the chain. The LAC OIG cited a 2014 article in the Sacramento Bee which found that a SNF owner had created a network of nearly 80 separate business entities which managed or provided services to 54 SNFs throughout California. The LAC OIG stated that large ownership groups may use complex and overlapping systems of dissimilarly named companies to create confusing corporate structures that complicate accountability efforts. According to LAC OIG, inadequate oversight and accountability mechanisms may also inadvertently aid those who are inclined to engage in corporate conflicts of interest, self-dealing, or other financial crimes or abuses. The LAC OIG stated that it will further analyze the complex issues involving ownership structures, and make corresponding recommendations, in its final report.
- Washington Post article on Brius Healthcare. On December 31, 2020, the Washington Post published a lengthy investigative article focused on the largest nursing home operator in California, known as Brius Healthcare (Brius) and owned by Shlomo Rechnitz. According to this article, Brius operates about 80 nursing homes, and like the majority of the industry nationwide, utilizes a business practice of paying related companies for goods, services, and rent. According to the article, in 2018 alone, Brius nursing homes paid related parties $13 million for supplies, $10 million for administrative services and financial consulting, and $16 million for workers’ compensation insurance. The homes also sent a total of $64 million in rent to dozens of related land companies. The article notes that the practice is legal and widely support by the industry as a way to help control costs and limit financial liability. Watchdog groups argue that nursing home owners can reap excessive profits from public funds by overpaying their own companies, and that related parties generally do not have to disclose profits, leaving regulators with little way to assess the financial gains of owners. The Washington Post obtained tax returns from 2013 for five companies connected to Brius, four of which were holding companies that draw income from companies in which they invest or own. The tax returns showed that the four holding companies took in a total of $38 million from Brius nursing homes in 2013, and of that, nearly $28 million was paid in distributions to Rechnitz and his wife. All but 18 Brius homes pay rent to related companies, which either own the properties outright or lease the buildings from unrelated owners and then sublease them to the nursing homes. According to the article, in the Eureka area, a company managed by Rechnitz in 2011 leased five nursing homes, agreeing to pay the property owner a total of $3 million in rent per year. Rechnitz’s company then subleased the buildings to the nursing homes for $3.5 million. Overall, Brius’ rent payments for buildings and equipment were 20% higher per bed than comparable for-profit nursing homes in California.
The article also examined poor quality of care issues at Brius facilities, citing several examples of incidences where state or federal regulators took action against Brius facilities for violations of health and safety standards. According to this article, in 2014 the California Attorney General filed an emergency motion to block Rechnitz from purchasing 19 homes in bankruptcy court, calling Rechnitz a “serial violator of rules within the skilled nursing industry.” However, a judge dismissed the state’s motion, and Brius was able to add purchase the homes. In 2016, CDPH denied change of ownership license applications for five facilities the Brius network had acquired, citing 370 state and federal health and safety violations from 2013 to 2016. However, Brius is still operating the homes through an interim management agreement with the former operator, who is still licensed. - California State Auditor report and related party transactions. At the request of the Joint Legislative Audit Committee, the California State Auditor published an audit of SNFs in May of 2018, subtitling the report “Absent Effective State Oversight, Substandard Quality of Care Has Continued.” The report concluded that the State has not adequately addressed ongoing deficiencies related to the quality of care that SNFs provide, and that from 2006 to 2015, the number of substandard care deficiencies that SNFs received increased by 31%, while deficiencies that caused or were likely to cause serious injury, harm, or death increased by 35%. The State Auditor reviewed three of the largest private operators of SNFs in California: Brius, Plum, and Longwood. According to the State Auditor, while the net income of the rest of the industry in California decreased, the net income of these three companies increased by tens of millions of dollars. The State Auditor found that the owners of these three companies were able to earn income, separate from the revenue their facilities earned from Medicare, Medi-Cal, or managed care, when their facilities obtained goods and services from related parties, or other businesses that they or their family members owned or controlled. For example, related parties may provide goods such as medical supplies and equipment, laundry and linens, and food to the SNF. Related parties may also provide therapy services, maintenance services, financial consulting, and administrative services, and SNFs frequently lease their buildings from related-party property owners. These related party transactions are common in the industry, and are legally allowable, although CMS and Medi-Cal take measures to limit the possibility that it might pay for profits from related party transactions. For example, the cost for such transactions are not allowed to exceed the price of comparable transactions procured elsewhere. According to the State Auditor, the three companies paid between $37.2 million and $65.7 million to related parties from 2007 through 2015; however, the report also found that the companies properly disclosed most of the potential related-party transactions, and that the Medi-Cal audit process ensured that Medi-Cal did not pay for profits realized from any of these transactions.
- Related legislation. AB 486 (Kalra) repeals the process whereby long-term care facilities can appeal more severe types of citations by filing a civil action in the superior court, and instead subjects these appeals to hearings by an administrative law judge that are currently used for lower level citations. AB 486 passed the Senate Health Committee by a vote of 9-1 on June 28, 2023.
- Prior legislation. AB 2079 (Wood of 2022) was nearly identical to this bill. AB 2079 was vetoed by the Governor, whose veto message stated:
“AB 2079 would establish, no later than July 1, 2023, a direct patient related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), as specified, which would be reported to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS).
As part of the Budget Act of 2022 and AB 186 (Budget Committee), Chapter 46, Statutes of 2022), a new Medi-Cal reimbursement rate structure for SNFs was established to focus on quality and includes a per patient per day penalty for not meeting quality metrics in addition to a quality award for meeting certain patient quality metrics. Unfortunately, AB 2079's takeback methodology does not align with the quality payments under this new program and may result in instances where a facility's quality payment is recouped because it does not meet the specific benchmarks noted in the bill. It is unclear how DHCS would successfully operationalize a system of simultaneous takebacks and quality payments. Efforts to incentivize direct patient care and quality through SNF financing should leverage the existing framework and be considered in the annual budget process. Therefore, I cannot sign this bill.”
AB 1502 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 578, Statutes of 2022) revises the licensure application and approval process for SNFs, and prohibits any person, including an applicant for licensure, or change of ownership, or change of management, from acquiring, either directly or indirectly, an ownership interest in a SNF, or from operating, establishing, managing, conducting, or maintaining a SNF, prior to review, approval, and issuance of a license by CDPH.
AB 1042 (Jones-Sawyer, Chapter 475, Statutes of 2021) authorizes CDPH, when a SNF fails to pay certain penalties, and all appeals have been exhausted, to provide written notice to the SNF and any “related parties” (businesses in which the SNF owner has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more), that CDPH may take legal action to recover the unpaid penalty amount from the SNF’s financial interest in the related party. AB 1042 requires CDPH to give written notice to related parties when a citation has been issued against a SNF, and to advise the related parties of the potential action if the violation is not remedied. AB 1042 requires DHCS to give notice to related parties that it may take legal action to recover unpaid quality assurance fees from the SNF’s financial interest in a related party.
SB 650 (Stern, Chapter 493, Statutes of 2021) requires an organization that operates, conducts, owns, manages, or maintains a SNF to prepare and file with HCAI an annual consolidated financial report that includes data from all operating entities, license holders, and related parties in which the organization has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more and that provides any service, facility, or supply to the SNF. SB 650 requires HCAI to post those reports and related documents to its internet website.
AB 1953 (Wood, Chapter 383, Statutes of 2018) requires SNFs to disclose to the OSHPD whether the SNF, or any partner, director or officer of the SNF, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF.
AB 251 (Bonta of 2017) would have established an MLR for chronic dialysis clinics that would have required these clinics to spend at least 85% of their revenue on direct patient care, health care quality improvement, and taxes and license fees, and if the clinics did not meet this ration, to issue rebates to non-government payers in an amount sufficient to meet the minimum spending of 85%. AB 251 was amended to deal with another subject.
- Support. The Geriatric Circle (GC) supports this bill and notes that SNFs are receive government funding of more than $10 billion a year, but the lack of transparency and accountability for how that money is spent is alarming. GC states that in 2020, only 64% of nursing home revenues were used for direct resident care in California, and that this bill will ensure that much needed funds go into direct care services and away from profits, administration, and property.
The Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program (Ombudsman) states in support that inadequate staffing has plagued nursing homes for decades, and studies have repeatedly shown that significant numbers of our nation’s nursing homes fail to adequately staff their facilities. According to the Ombudsman, about 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex ownership structures, with separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of companies, holding companies, and subsidiaries in control of each SNF. The Ombudsman states that this bill would require DHCS to conduct an audit of the financial information reported by the facilities, to ensure its accuracy and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed limit. - Letter of concern. The California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) submitted a letter of concern regarding possible future amendments that might be coming from DHCS. CAHF states that as the bill currently stands in print, it contains substantively the same language as AB 2079 (Wood) from last year that was vetoed, which CAHF was neutral on when it was sent to the Governor. CAHF states that the author is seeking technical assistance (TA) from DHCS and may amend this bill based on this TA. CAHF wanted to share some concerns on key issues that it would like considered in any forthcoming amendments. First, CAHF states that the direct cost ratio requirements should consider the constraints faced by facilities related to capital expenditures. As drafted, this bill limits the inclusion of rent, lease, or ownership costs to the facility’s fair rental value costs (FRVC) as calculated by DHCS. Under this FRVS methodology, the state establishes a price for the use of space that is not based on actual costs paid by an operated to the owner of the building, which is currently at about 25% of their actual capital costs. CAHF states that any amendments to this bill should recognize appropriate capital costs that preserve incentives for facilities to invest in long-term ownership and maintaining and upgrading the physical plant. Second, CAHF states that Medicare should continue to be excluded from the base revenue for calculating a direct care ratio. In 2022, CAHF negotiated amendments to AB 2079 that the spending requirement would be based on a facility’s non-Medicare health revenues (which is primarily Medi-Cal). CAHF states that this provision was important because California has authority only over how facilities expend payment from the Medi-Cal program, and that Medicare beneficiaries are different and facilities are subject to different requirements in how Medicare funding is utilized for patient care needs. Limiting AB 2079 to non-Medicare revenues was a key amendment for CAHF removing their opposition to that bill and moving to a neutral position. CAHF also states that analysis is needed to develop an accurate ratio of direct to indirect care, and that applying 85% to an industry with different costs and reimbursement structure compared to the insurance industry, with which this bill is attempting to align its spending ratio, may not be appropriate. Prior to implementing any penalties, CAHF argues that DHCS should collect and analyze cost data over multiple years to determine the appropriate ratio. Finally, CAHF states that the direct costs definition should align with the existing definition of Costs Related to Patient Care established by the federal Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Association of Long Term Care Medicine
California Commission on Aging
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Retired Teachers Association
Justice in Aging
The Geriatric Circle
Oppose: None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1537
Author:(Wood)
As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires, no later than July 1, 2024, the establishment of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), with certain exceptions. Requires that a minimum of 85% of a facility's total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year be expended on residents' direct patient-related services, as defined.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
- Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) SNF cost reports. In 2020, HCAI SNF cost reports showed total net revenues were $10.8515 billion for 947 nursing facilities (excluding intermediate care, mentally disordered, developmentally disabled, and hospital-based facilities). Of the total net health revenues, 38.4% were from Medicare, 36.9% were from Medi-Cal, 16.5% were from Medicare and Medi-Cal managed care, 3.9% were from self-pay, and 4.3% from other payers in 2020. In 2020, of the total revenues, 37.3% was spent on routine nursing care, 9.8% on ancillary services, 16.9% on support services (including social services, dietary, housekeeping and maintenance) for a total of 64.0% spent on direct care costs. The non-direct care costs were: 20.6% on administration, including licensing and quality assurance fees, 8.2% on property, 1.6% on other (interest and bad debts), and 5.6% profit of their total revenues for a total of 36.0% spent on non-resident services.
- Medical loss ratio (MLR) in the insurance market. The requirement to spend a certain percentage of revenues on direct care expenses versus administrative costs is often called an MLR. In the insurance market, in general terms, an MLR is the percentage of each dollar a health plan or insurer receives in premiums that the plan spends on health care services, as defined, versus administration, sales, marketing and profit. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) required states to establish an MLR for health plans and insurers serving commercial populations. Dental plans are exempt from the ACA-required MLR. For plans in the large group market, the ACA-required MLR is 85% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. For individual and small group plans, the MLR is 80% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. The federal Department of Health and Human Services Secretary can adjust small group and individual market MLR if he or she determines that the 80% requirement may destabilize the individual market in a state. If a plan fails to meet the federal MLR requirements, rebates are required to be issued to the plans' customers. In May of 2016, the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare (CMS) issued a rule requiring states to ensure that each Medicaid managed care plan calculates and reports a MLR, and to develop plan rates in a way that the plan would reasonably achieve a MLR standard of at least 85% for the rate year. To implement this requirement, SB 171 (Hernandez), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2017, was enacted to require Medi-Cal managed care plans, commencing July 1, 2019, to comply with a minimum 85% MLR, consistent with federal regulations. SB 171 required, effective on or after July 1, 2023, a Medi-Cal managed care plan to provide a remittance for an MLR reporting year if the ratio does not meet the minim standard of 85%.
- Where do the billions of dollars go? According to a 2023 National Consumer Voice report (the report), "Where do the billions of dollars go?" in 2020, nursing homes received $67.9 billion dollars from the Medicare and Medicaid programs to care for residents. The report notes that each year, SNFs must file Medicare cost reports with CMS. In these reports, the facilities are required to disclose how they spend their revenue from all payment sources, including Medicare and Medicaid dollars, however, it is unclear to what extent CMS reviews these cost reports. SNFs frequently make payments to providers of services that far exceed the reported costs, which draws into question how the money is being used, and whether the reports are being reviewed by CMS. This apparent lack of scrutiny of SNF cost reports has allowed the industry to develop and employ accounting measures that appear to divert taxpayer dollars. The mechanism SNFs use to potentially hide profits are entities known as "related parties." These are companies owned or controlled by SNF operators that do business with their own SNFs. Nursing home operators pay billions of dollars each year to "related party" companies.
Every year, CMS requires SNFs to identify any related parties and report all payments made to them on the facility's Medicare cost report. Federal regulations define related parties (organizations) largely based on common ownership and control. Generally, if an entity providing services or goods to a nursing home is owned in significant part or controlled by the nursing home owner, then it is a related party, regardless of whether it is a separate legal entity. CMS requires nursing home providers to be "prudent buyers," meaning they must actively seek to minimize costs by ordering in bulk, negotiating with suppliers, and obtaining multiple quotes for goods or services. In other words, related parties may not inflate costs, but can only charge what they would pay on the open market.
The report found that the amount of money paid to related parties far exceeded the costs reported by the related party, and CMS cost reports do not require this discrepancy to be explained. To illustrate, Pruitt Health, a nursing home chain that owns roughly 90 nursing homes, reported related party costs of nearly $482 million for the years from 2018 to 2020. At the same time, Pruitt reported paying to these related parties roughly $570 million dollars, a payment in excess of 18%. The CMS cost report provides no information on why Pruitt made nearly $90 million in excess payments to its related parties.
Brius owns and operates roughly 50 nursing homes, mainly in California. According to the report, Brius cost reports routinely contained missing information. For instance, it was common to find payments to related parties without any reported costs. This omission appears to have gone unnoticed by CMS, since some of the reports are nearly five years old. In addition, Brius's cost reports show exorbitant excess payments to related parties, with some payments being almost 1,700% higher than the reported costs.
If these excess payments are profits, it serves an important function. It allows a SNF owner and operator to show losses or reduce profit margins in its facility cost report, while potentially hiding significant profits paid to themselves in related parties. Related party costs and payments show up as expenses on cost reports, even though that money is in fact being paid to the owners themselves. In the reports' review of cost reports, the payments made to related parties sometimes exceeded the reported costs by nearly 1,200%.
According to the Author
Nearly 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex corporate ownership structures, often including separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of holding companies and subsidiaries in control of each facility. This complexity is designed to shield operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight, and conceal profits. The goal of this bill is to ensure that most of SNFs operating costs are spent on direct care of vulnerable residents, and while there are some financial controls on Medi-Cal spending, there are no controls on spending for Medicare, managed care and private payers. Therefore, SNFs can cut staffing, wages, and benefits while increasing spending on administration, profits, and property. The author concludes that residents of California SNFs need our support and protection and this bill continues year-after-year efforts to ensure that our most vulnerable Californians get quality care that ensures their safety while still allowing the facilities to earn profits that are appropriate and fair.
Arguments in Support
The Geriatric Circle (GC) supports this bill and states that California SNFs received about $11 billion in 2020, mostly from government sources. However, the quality of resident care has been poor and wages are low in many facilities. If more money is spent on direct resident care, SNF residents will benefit from higher quality care with a reduction in problems that can be prevented or mitigated such as infections, serious injuries, neglect, loss of life, isolation, and emotional distress. GC notes that over 90% of California SNFs are for profit and 80% are part of for-profit chains, with a growing percentage (about 9%) owned by private equity companies. These private equity companies have been shown to have lower staffing and poorer quality outcomes compared to other SNFs. GC also notes that there is extensive evidence-based research describing the strong association between for-profit ownership and failure to meet recommended staffing minimums that are necessary to prevent harm and jeopardy to SNF residents.
GC states that in 2020, the average California SNF had $12 million in net revenues and average profits of over $713,000 (7% profits). This was higher than average reported profits of 2.6% in 2019. In 2020, SNF profits ranged from 74% to a loss of 48%, showing that some are taking excessive profits at a cost of reduced direct care services to residents. The multiple layers of related-party entities (with whom they share ownership) provide services such as management, nursing services, and therapy to their own organization often at above market rates. Such practices protect operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight, and hide profits, while increasing administrative and management costs at the expense of resident care. GC notes that in 2020, only 64% of California SNF revenues were used for direct resident care. This bill requires that most revenues are allocated to direct resident care, and limits profits and administrative costs. GC concludes that if this bill had been law in 2020, it would have shifted billions in revenues away from profits and administration and into direct care services that would have improved quality of care and quality of life for California SNF residents.
Arguments in Opposition
There is no known opposition.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) are unknown, but would likely be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, ongoing, to develop processes and guidance for SNFs to report data, and to conduct the financial audits and enforce this bill (General Fund, federal funds).
The Department of Public Health (DPH) estimates annual, ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 to enforce the provisions of this bill as licensing requirements (Licensing and Certification Fund). These costs would cover 2.0 full time employee positions to verify SNFs appropriately and timely pay any required proportional dividends or credits; sanction SNFs that fail to appropriately and timely issue those dividends or credits; and ensure compliance with bill requirements during a SNF's re-licensure application review.
DPH notes the bill assigns DHCS responsibility to verify whether SNFs pay required dividends or credits and to sanction those who fail to do so. However, DPH notes existing law assigns this responsibility to DPH. DPH anticipates reviewing facility compliance with the requirements of this bill as part of DPH's routine annual licensure renewal process because SNFs must submit re-licensure applications, update any information, and submit licensing fees annually.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 13-0-2
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Villapudua, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, Vince Fong
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-1-4
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Mathis, Robert Rivas, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: February 17, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000823
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1537
Author:(Wood) – As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the establishment of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), with certain exceptions. The bill requires a minimum of 85% of a facility’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year be expended on residents’ direct patient-related services, as defined.
Specifically, this bill does the following, among other things:
- Requires a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, as defined, to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), consistent with the reporting requirements to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) under existing law, by June 30 of each calendar year. All submitted information must be certified by an authorized official of the SNF.
- Requires a SNF to expend no less than 85% of its total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year on direct patient-related services for residents.
- Defines “direct patient-related services” and “nondirect patient-related services”.
- Requires DHCS to audit, as described in existing law, the financial information reported by a SNF pursuant to this bill, to ensure the accuracy of the information reported and compliance with the requirements of this bill, and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed direct care limit for administrative costs and profits.
- Requires DHCS to audit the financial information reported by a SNF every three years, at the same time as the SNF’s Medi-Cal audit.
- Requires a SNF that fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement under this bill to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services and requires DHCS to impose an administrative fine set at double the percentage of the pro rata payments that the SNF failed to distribute.
- Permits DHCS to withhold Medi-Cal payments from any SNF that fails to fully disclose accurate and complete information on the direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services costs.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs to DHCS are unknown, but would likely be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, ongoing, to develop processes and guidance for SNFs to report data, and to conduct the financial audits and enforce this bill (General Fund, federal funds).
The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) estimates annual, ongoing costs of approximately $286,000 to enforce the provisions of this bill as licensing requirements (Licensing and Certification Fund). These costs would cover 2.0 full time employee positions to verify SNFs appropriately and timely pay any required proportional dividends or credits; sanction SNFs that fail to appropriately and timely issue those dividends or credits; and ensure compliance with bill requirements during a SNF’s re-licensure application review.
CDPH notes the bill assigns DHCS responsibility to verify whether SNFs pay required dividends or credits and to sanction those who fail to do so. However, CDPH notes existing law assigns this responsibility to CDPH. CDPH anticipates reviewing facility compliance with the requirements of this bill as part of CDPH’s routine annual licensure renewal process because SNFs must submit re-licensure applications, update any information, and submit licensing fees annually.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Nearly 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex corporate ownership structures, often including separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of holding companies and subsidiaries in control of each facility. This complexity is designed to shield operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight, and conceal profits. The goal of this bill is to ensure that most of SNFs’ operating costs are spent on direct care of vulnerable residents, and while there are some financial controls on Medi-Cal spending, there are no controls on spending for Medicare, managed care and private payers. Therefore, SNFs can cut staffing, wages, and benefits while increasing spending on administration, profits, and property. Residents of California SNFs need our support and protection and this bill continues year-after-year efforts to ensure that our most vulnerable Californians get quality care that ensures their safety while still allowing the facilities to earn profits that are appropriate and fair.
- Background.
SNF Revenues and Costs. In 2020, HCAI SNF cost reports showed total net revenues were $10.85 billion for 947 nursing facilities (excluding intermediate care, mentally disordered, developmentally disabled, and hospital-based facilities). In 2020, the sources of the net health revenues were Medicare (38.4%), Medi-Cal (36.9%), Medicare and Medi-Cal managed care (16.5%), self-pay (3.9%), and other payers (4.3%). In 2020, 37.3% of the total revenues was spent on routine nursing care, 9.8% on ancillary services, and 16.9% on support services (including social services, dietary services, housekeeping, and maintenance) for a total of 64.0% spent on direct care costs. The remaining 36.0% was spent on non-resident services, as follows: administration, including licensing and quality assurance fees (20.6%); property (8.2%); other, including interest and bad debt (1.6%); and profit (5.6%).
Related Parties: “Where do the billions of dollars go?” According to a 2023 National Consumer Voice report (the report), “Where do the billions of dollars go?” nursing homes in 2020 received $67.9 billion dollars from the Medicare and Medicaid programs to care for residents. SNFs must file annual Medicare cost reports with the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). In these reports, the SNFs must disclose how they spend their revenue from all payment sources, including Medicare and Medicaid dollars, however, the extent to which CMS reviews these cost reports is not clear. SNFs frequently make payments to providers of services that far exceed the reported costs, which raises the question of how the money is being used. The industry appears to have developed accounting measures that divert taxpayer dollars. The mechanism SNFs use to potentially hide profits are entities known as “related parties.” These are companies owned or controlled by SNF operators that do business with their own SNFs. Nursing home operators pay billions of dollars each year to “related party” companies.
To illustrate, Brius owns and operates roughly 50 nursing homes, mainly in California. According to the report, Brius cost reports were routinely missing information. For instance, it was common to find payments to related parties without any reported costs. This omission appears to have gone unnoticed by CMS. In addition, Brius’s cost reports show exorbitant excess payments to related parties, with some payments being almost 1,700% higher than the reported costs. If these excess payments are profits, they allow a SNF owner and operator to show losses or reduce profit margins in its facility cost report, while potentially hiding significant profits paid to themselves in related parties. Related party costs and payments show up as expenses on cost reports, even though that money is in fact being paid to the owners themselves. In the report’s review of cost reports, the payments made to related parties sometimes exceeded the reported costs by nearly 1,200%.
- Prior Legislation.
- SB 650 (Stern), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2021, requires an organization that owns or operates a SNF to prepare and file an annual consolidated financial report with HCAI, requires the financial report to include data from all related parties in which the organization has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more and that provides any services or supplies to the SNF, and requires the financial report to be reviewed by a certified public accountant.
- AB 1953 (Wood), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2018, requires SNFs to disclose to HCAI whether the SNF, or any partner, director or officer of the SNF, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1537
Author:(Wood) – As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
SUBJECT: Skilled nursing facilities: direct care spending requirement.
SUMMARY: Requires, no later than July 1, 2024, the establishment of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), with certain exceptions. Requires that a minimum of 85% of a facility’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year be expended on residents’ direct patient-related services, as defined. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the establishment, by July 1, 2024, of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs that are certified under the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), except government-owned or government-operated facilities, or hospital-based distinct part facilities.
- Requires a SNF to report total revenues collected from all revenue sources, along with the portion of revenues that are expended on all direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services, to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), consistent with the reporting requirements to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) under existing law, by June 30 of each calendar year. Requires all submitted information to be accompanied by a report certification signed by a duly authorized official of the SNF that certifies that, to the best of the official’s knowledge, each statement and amount in the accompanying report is true and correct.
- Excludes the expenditures and revenues related to a SNF’s state-mandated quality assurance fees and licensure fees from being included in the calculations for purposes of this bill.
- Requires 85% of a SNF’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year to be expended on the direct patient-related services of residents.
- Requires a continuing care retirement community, as defined, to report revenues to DHCS consistent with the revenues reported on its SNF annual consolidated financial report, and prohibit including revenue from continuing care entrance fees, monthly fees, or other charges incurred with the continuing care contractholder resided in a residential or assisted living unit.
- Defines “direct patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- Staffing services, including wages and benefits for nursing managers, nursing staff, and other personnel, who may include registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, certified nurse aides, noncertified or resident care aides, directors of nurses, in-house clerical staff regularly interacting with residents and caregivers, receptionists, evaluation nurses, minimum data set coordinators, and medical directors;
- Ancillary services, including, but not limited to, therapy services, supplies, pharmacy services, consultants, and laboratory services;
- Support services, including plant operations and maintenance, laundry and linen, housekeeping, resident activities, social services, services by a social service worker, services by a behavioral health consultant, dietary services, and in-service education;
- Rent, lease, or ownership costs that are not more than the SNF’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by the DHCS; and,
- Professional liability insurance costs that include the full value of professional liability insurance costs, as long as the payment is not directed to a related party, or professional liability costs as adjusted by DHCS for profit elimination as part of the Medi-Cal auditing process if the payment is directed to a related party.
- For purposes of the definition of “direct patient-related services” in 6) above:
- Requires any administrative costs and profits paid to contractors or related parties for staffing services, ancillary services, or support services to be excluded from the definition of direct care; and,
- Requires, for purposes of calculating purchased and contracted services, the total number used to be discounted at 85% of the contracted or purchased amount.
- Defines “nondirect patient-related services” as including all of the following:
- All administrative costs, including management and executive wages and benefits, all costs to management companies, administrative services companies, home office expenses for parent companies and holding companies, legal expenses, trade association fees and dues, insurance costs, licensing fees, and quality assurance fees. Requires all administrative costs and profits paid to contractors or related party entities for staffing services, ancillary services, support services, or other services are considered nondirect patient-related services;
- Capital costs, including depreciation, interest rates, property taxes, corporate taxes, and property insurance in excess of the facility’s fair rental value cost element as calculated by HCAI;
- Other expenses, including other interest rates and provisions for bad debts; and,
- Profits, including net income and any profits paid to related parties on leases and property, and any profits paid to management companies.
- Permits excluded costs to be excluded from nondirect patient-related services and to include special high-cost equipment or improvements of the physical plant that directly benefit residents, such as establishing single rooms and private bathrooms, upon approval by DHCS.
- Requires DHCS to conduct an audit, as described in existing law, of the financial information reported by SNFs pursuant to this bill, to ensure the accuracy of the information reported and compliance with the requirements of this bill, and to identify and recover any payments that exceed the allowed direct care limit for administrative costs and profits. Permits these audits to also include any audits of contractors or related party entities.
- Requires DHCS, in reviewing financial reports for compliance with this bill, to consider the SNFs annual consolidated financial reports filed with HCAI pursuant to existing law, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to conduct the audit of the financial information reported by the SNFs pursuant to this bill every three years, at the same time as the SNF’s Medi-Cal audit, as specified in existing.
- Requires a SNF, if it fails to comply with the direct care spending requirement under this bill, to issue a pro rata dividend or credit to the state and to all individuals and entities making non-Medicare payments to the SNF for resident services, in an amount sufficient to ensure that the aggregate amount was paid for direct care as prescribed under this bill.
- Requires DHCS to ensure that any pro rata dividend or credit is paid by the SNF to the appropriate individuals and entities by September 30 of each calendar year.
- Requires DHCS to impose sanctions for the failure to comply with this bill, in the form of an administrative fine set at double the percentage of the pro rata payments that the facility failed to distribute. Specifies that failure to comply with this bill is also subject to any other applicable enforcement mechanism described in the health facility licensing law.
- Permits DHCS to withhold Medi-Cal payments from any SNF that fails to fully disclose accurate and complete information on the direct patient-related services and nondirect patient-related services costs under this bill.
- Permits a SNF to appeal DHCS’s determinations pursuant to procedures established under existing law.
- Defines “related party” as having the same definition as in 7) of existing law below, and can include, but is not limited to: home offices; management organizations; owners of real estate; entities that provide staffing, therapy, pharmaceutical, marketing, administrative management, consulting, or insurance services; providers of supplies and equipment; financial advisors or consultants; banking or financial entities; any parent companies, holding companies, or sister organizations; and, any entity in which a family member of an owner of those organizations has an ownership interest of 5% or more.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for the licensure of health facilities, including SNFs, by the Department of Public Health (DPH), and defines a SNF as a health facility that provides skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 1250(c)]
- Requires DPH to develop regulations that establish staff-to-patient ratios for direct caregivers (defined as registered nurses, licensed vocational nurses, psychiatric technicians, or certified nurse assistants) working in a SNF. Requires, effective July 1, 2018, freestanding SNFs to have a minimum number of direct care services hours of 3.5 per patient day, including a minimum of 2.4 hours per patient day for certified nurse assistants. [HSC § 1276.65]
- Designates HCAI as the state agency designated to collect health facility data for use by all state agencies, including data required in Medi-Cal cost reports, and various financial data reports. [HSC § 128730]
- Requires an organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a health facility, which includes hospitals, SNFs, and other facilities providing inpatient care, to annually file with HCAI, for each separately licensed facility that is operated, conducted, or maintained by the reporting organization, reports that include a balance sheet detailing the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the health facility; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; and, a statement of cashflows, including ongoing and new capital expenditures and depreciation. [HSC § 128735]
- Requires each organization that operates, conducts, owns, or maintains a SNF to file with HCAI, as part of the information required in 4) above, whether the licensee, or a general partner, director, or officer of the licensee, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF. Requires the licensee, if the licensee or the general partner, director, or officer of the licensee has such an interest, to disclose all services provided to the SNF, the number of individuals who provide that service at the SNF, and any other information requested by HCAI. [HSC § 128734]
- Requires the disclosure in 5) above, if goods, fees, and services collectively worth $10,000 or more per year are delivered to the SNF, to include the related party’s profit and loss statement. [HSC § 128734]
- Defines “related party,” for purposes of 5) and 6) above, as an organization related to the licensee provider, or that is under common ownership or control, as defined in specified provisions of the federal regulations. [HSC § 128734 (b)(3)]
- Requires SNFs, commencing with fiscal years ending December 31, 2023, to file an annual consolidated report, reviewed by a certified public accountant, that includes specified statements, including the following: a balance sheet; a statement of income, expenses, and operating surplus or deficit; a statement detailing patient revenue by payer; a statement of cashflows; and, a combined financial statement. Requires this information from all operating entities, licenseholders, and related parties in which the organization has an ownership of 5% or more and that provides any service, facility, or supply to the SNF. [HSC § 128734.1]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by DHCS, under which low-income individuals are eligible for medical coverage. [Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) § 14000, et seq.]
- Requires DHCS to develop and implement a cost-based reimbursement rate methodology for freestanding nursing facilities reflecting the sum of the projected cost of each cost category and passthrough costs, as specified. [WIC § 14126.021, § 14126.023]
- Requires DHCS, subject to an appropriation by the Legislature, to implement the Workforce and Quality Incentive Program, which would render a network provider furnishing skilled nursing services to a Medi-Cal managed care enrollee eligible to earn performance-based directed payments for the managed care plan with which they contract. [HSC § 1276.66]
- Requires amounts paid for services provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries to be audited by DHCS. Requires DHCS to maintain adequate controls to ensure responsibility and accountability for the expenditure of federal and state funds. Requires cost reports and other data submitted by providers for the purpose of determining reasonable costs for services or establishing rates of payment to be consider true and correct unless audited or reviewed by DHCS within three years. [WIC § 14170]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, nearly 60% of SNFs are owned or leased by multi-facility organizations that have developed increasingly complex corporate ownership structures, often including separate property companies and as many as seven to eight layers of holding companies and subsidiaries in control of each facility. This complexity is designed to shield operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight, and conceal profits. The goal of this bill is to ensure that most of SNFs operating costs are spent on direct care of vulnerable residents, and while there are some financial controls on Medi-Cal spending, there are no controls on spending for Medicare, managed care and private payers. Therefore, SNFs can cut staffing, wages, and benefits while increasing spending on administration, profits, and property. The author concludes that residents of California SNFs need our support and protection and this bill continues year-after-year efforts to ensure that our most vulnerable Californians get quality care that ensures their safety while still allowing the facilities to earn profits that are appropriate and fair.
- BACKGROUND.
- HCAI SNF cost reports. In 2020, HCAI SNF cost reports showed total net revenues were $10.8515 billion for 947 nursing facilities (excluding intermediate care, mentally disordered, developmentally disabled, and hospital-based facilities). Of the total net health revenues, 38.4% were from Medicare, 36.9% were from Medi-Cal, 16.5% were from Medicare and Medi-Cal managed care, 3.9% were from self-pay, and 4.3% from other payers in 2020. In 2020, of the total revenues, 37.3% was spent on routine nursing care, 9.8% on ancillary services, 16.9% on support services (including social services, dietary, housekeeping and maintenance) for a total of 64.0% spent on direct care costs. The non-direct care costs were: 20.6% on administration, including licensing and quality assurance fees, 8.2% on property, 1.6% on other (interest and bad debts), and 5.6% profit of their total revenues for a total of 36.0% spent on non-resident services.
- Medical loss ratio (MLR) in the insurance market. The requirement to spend a certain percentage of revenues on direct care expenses versus administrative costs is often called an MLR. In the insurance market, in general terms, an MLR is the percentage of each dollar a health plan or insurer receives in premiums that the plan spends on health care services, as defined, versus administration, sales, marketing and profit. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) required states to establish an MLR for health plans and insurers serving commercial populations. Dental plans are exempt from the ACA-required MLR. For plans in the large group market, the ACA-required MLR is 85% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. For individual and small group plans, the MLR is 80% or a higher percentage determined by the state through regulation. The federal Department of Health and Human Services Secretary can adjust small group and individual market MLR if he or she determines that the 80% requirement may destabilize the individual market in a state. If a plan fails to meet the federal MLR requirements, rebates are required to be issued to the plans’ customers. In May of 2016, CMS issued a rule requiring states to ensure that each Medicaid managed care plan calculates and reports a MLR, and to develop plan rates in a way that the plan would reasonably achieve a MLR standard of at least 85% for the rate year. To implement this requirement, SB 171 (Hernandez), Chapter 768, Statutes of 2017, was enacted to require Medi-Cal managed care plans, commencing July 1, 2019, to comply with a minimum 85% MLR, consistent with federal regulations. SB 171 required, effective on or after July 1, 2023, a Medi-Cal managed care plan to provide a remittance for an MLR reporting year if the ratio does not meet the minim standard of 85%.
- Where do the billions of dollars go? According to a 2023 National Consumer Voice report (the report), “Where do the billions of dollars go?” in 2020, nursing homes received $67.9 billion dollars from the Medicare and Medicaid programs to care for residents. The report notes that each year, SNFs must file Medicare cost reports with CMS. In these reports, the facilities are required to disclose how they spend their revenue from all payment sources, including Medicare and Medicaid dollars, however, it is unclear to what extent CMS reviews these cost reports. SNFs frequently make payments to providers of services that far exceed the reported costs, which draws into question how the money is being used, and whether the reports are being reviewed by CMS. This apparent lack of scrutiny of SNF cost reports has allowed the industry to develop and employ accounting measures that appear to divert taxpayer dollars. The mechanism SNFs use to potentially hide profits are entities known as “related parties.” These are companies owned or controlled by SNF operators that do business with their own SNFs. Nursing home operators pay billions of dollars each year to “related party” companies.
Every year, CMS requires SNFs to identify any related parties and report all payments made to them on the facility’s Medicare cost report. Federal regulations define related parties (organizations) largely based on common ownership and control. Generally, if an entity providing services or goods to a nursing home is owned in significant part or controlled by the nursing home owner, then it is a related party, regardless of whether it is a separate legal entity. CMS requires nursing home providers to be “prudent buyers,” meaning they must actively seek to minimize costs by ordering in bulk, negotiating with suppliers, and obtaining multiple quotes for goods or services. In other words, related parties may not inflate costs, but can only charge what they would pay on the open market.
The report found that the amount of money paid to related parties far exceeded the costs reported by the related party, and CMS cost reports do not require this discrepancy to be explained. To illustrate, Pruitt Health, a nursing home chain that owns roughly 90 nursing homes, reported related party costs of nearly $482 million for the years from 2018 to 2020. At the same time, Pruitt reported paying to these related parties roughly $570 million dollars, a payment in excess of 18%. The CMS cost report provides no information on why Pruitt made nearly $90 million in excess payments to its related parties.
Brius owns and operates roughly 50 nursing homes, mainly in California. According to the report, Brius cost reports routinely contained missing information. For instance, it was common to find payments to related parties without any reported costs. This omission appears to have gone unnoticed by CMS, since some of the reports are nearly five years old. In addition, Brius’s cost reports show exorbitant excess payments to related parties, with some payments being almost 1,700% higher than the reported costs.
If these excess payments are profits, it serves an important function. It allows a SNF owner and operator to show losses or reduce profit margins in its facility cost report, while potentially hiding significant profits paid to themselves in related parties. Related party costs and payments show up as expenses on cost reports, even though that money is in fact being paid to the owners themselves. In the reports’ review of cost reports, the payments made to related parties sometimes exceeded the reported costs by nearly 1,200%.
- SUPPORT. The Geriatric Circle (GC) supports this bill and states that California SNFs received about $11 billion in 2020, mostly from government sources. However, the quality of resident care has been poor and wages are low in many facilities. If more money is spent on direct resident care, SNF residents will benefit from higher quality care with a reduction in problems that can be prevented or mitigated such as infections, serious injuries, neglect, loss of life, isolation, and emotional distress.
GC notes that over 90% of California SNFs are for profit and 80% are part of for-profit chains, with a growing percentage (about 9%) owned by private equity companies. These private equity companies have been shown to have lower staffing and poorer quality outcomes compared to other SNFs. GC also notes that there is extensive evidence-based research describing the strong association between for-profit ownership and failure to meet recommended staffing minimums that are necessary to prevent harm and jeopardy to SNF residents.
GC states that in 2020, the average California SNF had $12 million in net revenues and average profits of over $713,000 (7% profits). This was higher than average reported profits of 2.6% in 2019. In 2020, SNF profits ranged from 74% to a loss of 48%, showing that some are taking excessive profits at a cost of reduced direct care services to residents. The multiple layers of related-party entities (with whom they share ownership) provide services such as management, nursing services, and therapy to their own organization often at above market rates. Such practices protect operating companies from litigation, reduce regulatory oversight, and hide profits, while increasing administrative and management costs at the expense of resident care. GC notes that in 2020, only 64% of California SNF revenues were used for direct resident care. This bill requires that most revenues are allocated to direct resident care, and limits profits and administrative costs. GC concludes that if this bill had been law in 2020, it would have shifted billions in revenues away from profits and administration and into direct care services that would have improved quality of care and quality of life for California SNF residents.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 48 (Aguiar-Curry) creates the Nursing Facility Resident Informed Consent Protection Act of 2023 which requires a prescriber, prior to prescribing a psychotherapeutic drug for a resident of a SNF or intermediate care facility to personally examine and obtain the informed written consent of the resident or the resident’s representative. AB 48 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 486 (Kalra) removes the ability of a LTC facility to adjudicate the validity of a citation issued by DPH in a county superior court, and instead requires all citation appeals to be made through an administrative law judge. AB 486 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- SB 650 (Stern), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2021, requires an organization that operates, conducts, owns, manages, or maintains a SNF to prepare and file an annual consolidated financial report with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD, now HCAI), requires the financial report to include data from all related parties in which the organization has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more and that provides any services or supplies to the SNF, and requires the financial report to be reviewed by a certified public accountant.
- AB 1953 (Wood), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2018, requires SNFs to disclose to the OSHPD whether the SNF, or any partner, director or officer of the SNF, has an ownership or control interest of 5% or more in a related party that provides any service to the SNF.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Association of Long Term Care Medicine
California Commission on Aging
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California Retired Teachers Association
Justice in Aging
The Geriatric Circle
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):