AB 1633: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-11
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-11: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and to meet one or more of specified criteria, and to meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, abuse of discretion, as defined, or failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within a specified time period of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and to meet one or more of specified criteria, and to meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, abuse of discretion, as defined, or failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within a specified time period of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and to meet one or more of specified criteria, and to meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, an abuse of discretion, as defined, or a failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located on a legal parcel or parcels in any of specified locations within an urbanized area and to meet one or more of specified criteria, and to meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill, until January 1, 2031, would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, an abuse of discretion, as defined, or a failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill bill, until January 1, 2031, would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located within an urbanized area, as defined, on a legal parcel or parcels in any of specified locations and meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill bill, until January 1, 2031, would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, an abuse of discretion, as defined, or a failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located within an urbanized area, as defined, and meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, an abuse of discretion, as defined, or a failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to issue a project an exemption from CEQA for which it is eligible, as described, make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, as specified, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located within an urbanized area, as defined, and meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA CEQA, an abuse of discretion, as defined, or a failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed a final disapproval of the housing project final for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the applicant gives timely written notice to the local agency, as specified, and the agency does not issue the exemption or adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document the local agency did not make a final decision on whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA, as specified, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to issue a project an exemption from CEQA for which it is eligible, as described, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located within an urbanized area, as defined, and meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA or failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed a final disapproval of the housing project for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the applicant gives timely written notice to the local agency, as specified, and the agency does not issue the exemption or adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Housing Accountability Act, prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing development project, as described, unless it makes certain written findings based on a preponderance of the evidence in the record. The act defines disapprove the housing development project as including any instance in which a local agency either votes and disapproves a proposed housing development project application, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit, or fails to comply with specified time periods. Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that the lead agency proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if the lead agency finds that the project will not have that effect.
This bill would define disapprove the housing development project as also including any instance in which a local agency fails to issue a project an exemption from CEQA for which it is eligible, as described, or fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if certain conditions are satisfied. Among other conditions, the bill would require a housing development project subject to these provisions to be located within an urbanized area, as defined, and meet or exceed 15 dwelling units per acre. By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law requires a petition to enforce the Housing Accountability Act to be brought pursuant to a specified procedure and be filed no later than 90 days from the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving of, or any other final action taken on a housing development project.
This bill would provide that a local agencys failure to make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA or failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed a final disapproval of the housing project for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the applicant gives timely written notice to the local agency, as specified, and the agency does not issue the exemption or adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants notice.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, as defined by this bill, constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow an applicant for a housing development project to provide notice to a local government of the evidence that supports the finding required by Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
(b)The bills provisions will become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(ia)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(ib)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(ic)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (ii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(id)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall contain all of the following:
(Ia)The information specified in paragraphs (1), (2), (5), and (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(Ib)A citation to the section of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations or the statute under which the applicant asserts that the project is exempt.
(Ic)A brief statement of reasons supporting the assertion that the project is exempt.
(Id)A copy of the excerpts from the record constituting substantial evidence that the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, are satisfied.
(ib)Within five working days of receiving the applicants written notice required by sub-subclause (ia), the local agency shall file the notice with the county clerk of each county in which the project will be located. The county clerk shall post the notice and make it available for public inspection in the manner set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code. Compliance with this sub-subclause is not a condition that must be satisfied in order to find that the local agency has disapproved the housing development project under this subparagraph.
(ic)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 additional days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(id)If the local agency has given the applicant written notice of the local agencys determination that the project is not exempt, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave the applicant notice of the local agencys determination.
(ie)If the local agency has not given the applicant the written notice described in sub-subclause (id), the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency does not determine that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for exemption.
(iv)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(I)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(II)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(III)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (vii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(IV)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)(I)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall include a copy of those excerpts from the record that constitute substantial evidence that the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, are satisfied.
(II)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave written notice of its decision to the applicant.
(III)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)(ia)Abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(Ia)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(Ib)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(ib)This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(viii)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(7)(A)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)(ia)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within the time period set forth in subclause (V) of clause (i) of that subparagraph after the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(3)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)(1)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(2)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, as defined by this bill, constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow an applicant for a housing development project to provide notice to a local government of the evidence that supports the finding required by Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
(b)The bills provisions will become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(ia)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(ib)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(ic)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (ii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(id)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall contain all of the following:
(Ia)The information specified in paragraphs (1), (2), (5), and (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(Ib)A citation to the section of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations or the statute under which the applicant asserts that the project is exempt.
(Ic)A brief statement of reasons supporting the assertion that the project is exempt.
(Id)A copy of the excerpts from the record constituting substantial evidence that the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, are satisfied.
(ib)Within five working days of receiving the applicants written notice required by sub-subclause (ia), the local agency shall file the notice with the county clerk of each county in which the project will be located. The county clerk shall post the notice and make it available for public inspection in the manner set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code. Compliance with this sub-subclause is not a condition that must be satisfied in order to find that the local agency has disapproved the housing development project under this subparagraph.
(ic)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 additional days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(id)If the local agency has given the applicant written notice of the local agencys determination that the project is not exempt, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave the applicant notice of the local agencys determination.
(ie)If the local agency has not given the applicant the written notice described in sub-subclause (id), the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency does not determine that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for exemption.
(iv)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(I)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(II)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(III)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (vii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(IV)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)(I)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall include a copy of those excerpts from the record that constitute substantial evidence that the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, are satisfied.
(II)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave written notice of its decision to the applicant.
(III)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)(ia)Abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(Ia)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(Ib)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(ib)This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(viii)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(7)(A)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)(ia)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within the time period set forth in subclause (V) of clause (i) of that subparagraph after the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(3)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)(1)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(2)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) as defined by this bill, constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to rectify a failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion without risking HAA litigation. an applicant for a housing development project to provide notice to a local government of the evidence that supports the finding required by Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
(b)The bills provisions will become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency, notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraph (C), agency does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)(i)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(ii)(I)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).(II)This clause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(ia)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(ib)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(ic)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (ii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(id)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion. contain all of the following:
(Ia)The information specified in paragraphs (1), (2), (5), and (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(Ib)A citation to the section of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations or the statute under which the applicant asserts that the project is exempt.
(Ic)A brief statement of reasons supporting the assertion that the project is exempt.
(Id)A copy of the excerpts from the record constituting substantial evidence that the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, are satisfied.
(ib)Within five working days of receiving the applicants written notice required by sub-subclause (ia), the local agency shall file the notice with the county clerk of each county in which the project will be located. The county clerk shall post the notice and make it available for public inspection in the manner set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 21152 of the Public Resources Code. Compliance with this sub-subclause is not a condition that must be satisfied in order to find that the local agency has disapproved the housing development project under this subparagraph.
(ib)(ic)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 additional days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(ic)(id)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, given the applicant written notice of the local agencys determination that the project is not exempt, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given delivered to the local agency within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision. the date that the local agency gave the applicant notice of the local agencys determination.
(id)(ie)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, given the applicant the written notice described in sub-subclause (id), the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency determines not to proceed under Sections 15061 and 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations. does not determine that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for exemption.
(iv)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(I)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(II)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(III)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (vii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(IV)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion. discretion, as defined in this subparagraph.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)(I)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies include a copy of those excerpts from the record that constitute substantial evidence that the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion. are satisfied.
(I)(II)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision. delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave written notice of its decision to the applicant.
(II)(III)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)(ia)Abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(ia)(Ia)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(ib)(Ib)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(ib)This subclause sets forth the exclusive definition of abuse of discretion for purposes of this subparagraph.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(viii)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(7)(a)For (A)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(b)(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)(ia)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the time period set forth in subclause (V) of clause (i) of that subparagraph after the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(3)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)(1)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(2)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to rectify a failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
(b)The bills provisions will become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency, notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraph (C), does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)(i)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(ii)(I)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(II)This clause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels in any of the following locations: within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(ia)In a city where the city boundaries include some portion of either an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, or in an unincorporated area, and the legal parcel or parcels are wholly within the boundaries of an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau.(ib)Within(ia)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(ic)In(ib)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(id)Proximal(ic)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (ii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(ie)(id)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(ib)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(ic)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(id)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency determines not to proceed under Sections 15061 and 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for exemption.
(iv)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located on a legal parcel or parcels in any of the following locations: within an urbanized area and meets one or more of the following criteria:
(I)In a city where the city boundaries include some portion of either an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, or in an unincorporated area, and the legal parcel or parcels are wholly within the boundaries of an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau.(II)Within(I)The housing development project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(III)In(II)The housing development project is located in a very low vehicle travel area.
(IV)Proximal(III)The housing development project is proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (vii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(V)(IV)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(ia)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(ib)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(viii)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(7)(a)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(b)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)(ia)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(3)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)(1)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(2)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares that the the following:
(a)The purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to rectify a failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
(b)The bills provisions will become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency, notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraph (C), does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)(i)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(ii)(I)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(II)This clause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code. on a legal parcel or parcels in any of the following locations:
(ia)In a city where the city boundaries include some portion of either an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, or in an unincorporated area, and the legal parcel or parcels are wholly within the boundaries of an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau.
(ib)Within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(ic)In a very low vehicle travel area.
(id)Proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (ii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(ie)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(ib)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(ic)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(id)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency determines not to proceed under Sections 15061 and 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for exemption.
(iv)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code. on a legal parcel or parcels in any of the following locations:
(I)In a city where the city boundaries include some portion of either an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, or in an unincorporated area, and the legal parcel or parcels are wholly within the boundaries of an urbanized area or urban cluster, as designated by the United States Census Bureau.
(II)Within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop.
(III)In a very low vehicle travel area.
(IV)Proximal to six or more amenities pursuant to subclause (IV) of clause (vii) as of the date of submission of the application for the project.
(V)Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sides of a foursided project site. For purposes of this clause, parcels that are only separated by a street or highway shall be considered to be adjoined.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse the following definitions apply:
(I)Abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(I)(ia)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(II)(ib)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(II)High-quality transit corridor has the same meaning defined in subdivision (b) of Section 21155 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)Major transit stop has the same meaning as defined in Section 21064.3 of the Public Resources Code.
(IV)Proximal to an amenity means either of the following:
(ia)Within one-half mile of either of the following amenities:
(Ia)A bus station.
(Ib)A ferry terminal.
(ib)Within one mile, or for a parcel in a rural area, as defined in Section 50199.21 of the Health and Safety Code, within two miles, of any of the following amenities:
(Ia)A supermarket or grocery store.
(Ib)A public park.
(Ic)A community center.
(Id)A pharmacy or drugstore.
(Ie)A medical clinic or hospital.
(If)A public library.
(Ig)A school that maintains a kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(V)Urbanized area has the same meaning as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(VI)(ia)Very low vehicle travel area means an urbanized area, as designated by the United States Census Bureau, where the existing residential development generates vehicle miles traveled per capita that is below 85 percent of either regional vehicle miles traveled per capita or city vehicle miles traveled per capita.
(ib)For purposes of sub-subclause (ia), area may include a travel analysis zone, hexagon, or grid.
(ic)For the purposes of determining regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to sub-subclause (ia), a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(viii)This subparagraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(7)(a)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(b)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)(ia)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(3)(A)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(B)This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)(1)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(2)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2031.
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code), and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to rectify a failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency, notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraph (C), does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)(i)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(ii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the requirements specified in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this subclause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone. is not located in either of the following:
(ia)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ib)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(II)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the exception does not apply to the project. application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions set forth in Section 15300.2 of those guidelines.
(V)(ia)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7), determination within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(ib)The local agency may, by providing a written response to the applicant within 90 days of the applicants written notice, extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is substantial evidence in the record that the housing development project is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
(ia)(ic)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(ib)(id)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified by Section 21080.2 of the Public Resources Code for determining whether the project requires an environmental impact report or negative declaration has passed. 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, or 60 days from the date on which the project application has been determined or deemed to be complete within the meaning of Section 65943, whichever is earlier.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclause (iv) subclauses (I) to (IV), inclusive, of clause (i) are satisfied, but the local agency determines not to proceed under Section Sections 15061 or and 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to adopt or certify a negative declaration, addendum, or environmental impact report determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, that environmental review document does not comply with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code). the project is not eligible for exemption.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the conditions set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this subparagraph shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone, unless the development is on a site that also satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4. is not located on either of the following:
(I)On a site specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or subparagraphs (E) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(II)Within a very high fire hazard severity zone, as determined by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 51178, or within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone as indicated on maps adopted by the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection pursuant to Section 4202 of the Public Resources Code.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the environmental review document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (vii). discretion.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (vii), and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document, as defined in paragraph (7), document within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action to require further environmental study was an abuse of discretion.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(I)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(II)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(7)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) document that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7) of subdivision (h), determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(3)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7) of subdivision (h), determination within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) subclauses (I), (II), and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h). (h) or clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to approve a legally sufficient exercise discretion, or a local agencys abuse of discretion, under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) review of a constitutes a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code) protected project constitutes a violation of the HAA, Code), and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to correct an improper CEQA clearance denial rectify a failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the disapproval of a legally sufficient CEQA review failure to exercise discretion or abuse of discretion constitutes a violation of the HAA.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency agency, notwithstanding the provisions of subparagraph (C), does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)(i)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(ii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)(i)Fails to make a determination that of whether the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) Code), or commits an abuse of discretion, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the requirements specified in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause subclause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone.
(ii)(II)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)(III)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)(IV)Both of the following criteria are met:
(I)(ia)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(II)(ib)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the exception does not apply to the project.
(v)(V)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination that the project is exempt and the local agency did not approve the exemption or an abuse of discretion, as defined in this subparagraph, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7), within 90 days of the applicants written notice: notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action was an abuse of discretion.
(I)(ia)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)(ib)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified by Section 21080.2 of the Public Resources Code for determining whether the project requires an environmental impact report or negative declaration has passed.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse of discretion means that the conditions set forth in subclause (iv) are satisfied, but the local agency determines not to proceed under Section 15061 or 15062 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(iii)This subparagraph shall not be construed to require a local agency to adopt or certify a negative declaration, addendum, or environmental impact report if, on the record before the local agency, that environmental review document does not comply with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the conditions set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause subparagraph shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone, unless the development is on a site that also satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt that negative declaration, has held a meeting at which the negative declaration was on the agenda and could have been adopted, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.(v)The local agency or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document has held a meeting at which the environmental review document was on the agenda and could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency did either of the following:
(I)Committed an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (vii).
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or adopt the negative declaration. to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
(vi)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document, has held a meeting at which the environmental review document was on the agenda and could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document.(vii)(vi)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, decide or an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (vii), and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify the document, as applicable, make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document, as defined in paragraph (7), within 90 days of the applicants written notice. The applicants written notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency that satisfies the criteria of clauses (i) to (iv), inclusive, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agencys action to require further environmental study was an abuse of discretion.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(vii)For purposes of this subparagraph, abuse of discretion means either of the following:
(I)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(II)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, abuse of discretion means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(7)For purposes of this section, lawful determination means any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove a statutory or categorical exemption or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) document that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) or clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6).
(7)(8)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(8)(9)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(9)(10)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)A local agencys failure to issue an exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)) shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency, as specified in clause (v) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the agency did not issue the exemption within 90 days of the applicants notice.(3)A local agencys failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)), shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency as specified in clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, within 90 days of the applicants notice.(2)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7) of subdivision (h), within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(3)A disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) shall be final for purposes of this subdivision, if the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined in paragraph (7) of subdivision (h), within 90 days of the applicants timely written notice.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to approve a legally sufficient California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) review of a Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code) protected project constitutes a violation of the HAA, and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to correct an improper CEQA clearance denial without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the disapproval of a legally sufficient CEQA review constitutes a violation of the HAA.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall homeownership home ownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in homeownership home ownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific specific, adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(D)Fails to make a determination that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the requirements specified in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)Both of the following criteria are met:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(II)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the exception does not apply to the project.
(v)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination that the project is exempt and the local agency did not approve the exemption within 90 days of the applicants written notice. notice:
(I)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified by Section 21080.2 of the Public Resources Code for determining whether the project requires an environmental impact report or negative declaration has passed.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the conditions set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone, unless the development is on a site that also satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt that negative declaration, has held a meeting at which the negative declaration was on the agenda and could have been adopted, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:
(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or adopt the negative declaration.
(vi)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document, has held a meeting at which the environmental review document was on the agenda and could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:
(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document.
(vii)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify the document, as applicable, within 90 days of the applicants written notice.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(7)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(8)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(9)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)A local agencys failure to issue an exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)) shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency, as specified in clause (v) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the agency did not issue the exemption within 90 days of the applicants notice.
(3)A local agencys failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)), shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency as specified in clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (d) (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares that the purpose of this bill is to refine and clarify the standards, as to certain sites, for whether a local agencys failure to approve a legally sufficient California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) review of a Housing Accountability Act (HAA) (Section 65589.5 of the Government Code) protected project constitutes a violation of the HAA, and to establish procedures that will allow local governments to correct an improper CEQA clearance denial without risking HAA litigation. As to other sites, it is the intent of the Legislature that the bill not affect judicial decisions about whether, or under what circumstances, the disapproval of a legally sufficient CEQA review constitutes a violation of the HAA.
SEC. 2.Section 65589.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:65589.5.(a)(1)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(A)The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California.
(B)California housing has become the most expensive in the nation. The excessive cost of the states housing supply is partially caused by activities and policies of many local governments that limit the approval of housing, increase the cost of land for housing, and require that high fees and exactions be paid by producers of housing.
(C)Among the consequences of those actions are discrimination against low-income and minority households, lack of housing to support employment growth, imbalance in jobs and housing, reduced mobility, urban sprawl, excessive commuting, and air quality deterioration.
(D)Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.
(2)In enacting the amendments made to this section by the act adding this paragraph, the Legislature further finds and declares the following:
(A)California has a housing supply and affordability crisis of historic proportions. The consequences of failing to effectively and aggressively confront this crisis are hurting millions of Californians, robbing future generations of the chance to call California home, stifling economic opportunities for workers and businesses, worsening poverty and homelessness, and undermining the states environmental and climate objectives.
(B)While the causes of this crisis are multiple and complex, the absence of meaningful and effective policy reforms to significantly enhance the approval and supply of housing affordable to Californians of all income levels is a key factor.
(C)The crisis has grown so acute in California that supply, demand, and affordability fundamentals are characterized in the negative: underserved demands, constrained supply, and protracted unaffordability.
(D)According to reports and data, California has accumulated an unmet housing backlog of nearly 2,000,000 units and must provide for at least 180,000 new units annually to keep pace with growth through 2025.
(E)Californias overall homeownership rate is at its lowest level since the 1940s. The state ranks 49th out of the 50 states in homeownership rates as well as in the supply of housing per capita. Only one-half of Californias households are able to afford the cost of housing in their local regions.
(F)Lack of supply and rising costs are compounding inequality and limiting advancement opportunities for many Californians.
(G)The majority of California renters, more than 3,000,000 households, pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent and nearly one-third, more than 1,500,000 households, pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent.
(H)When Californians have access to safe and affordable housing, they have more money for food and health care; they are less likely to become homeless and in need of government-subsidized services; their children do better in school; and businesses have an easier time recruiting and retaining employees.
(I)An additional consequence of the states cumulative housing shortage is a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions caused by the displacement and redirection of populations to states with greater housing opportunities, particularly working- and middle-class households. Californias cumulative housing shortfall therefore has not only national but international environmental consequences.
(J)Californias housing picture has reached a crisis of historic proportions despite the fact that, for decades, the Legislature has enacted numerous statutes intended to significantly increase the approval, development, and affordability of housing for all income levels, including this section.
(K)The Legislatures intent in enacting this section in 1982 and in expanding its provisions since then was to significantly increase the approval and construction of new housing for all economic segments of Californias communities by meaningfully and effectively curbing the capability of local governments to deny, reduce the density for, or render infeasible housing development projects and emergency shelters. That intent has not been fulfilled.
(L)It is the policy of the state that this section be interpreted and implemented in a manner to afford the fullest possible weight to the interest of, and the approval and provision of, housing.
(3)It is the intent of the Legislature that the conditions that would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health and safety, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), arise infrequently.
(b)It is the policy of the state that a local government not reject or make infeasible housing development projects, including emergency shelters, that contribute to meeting the need determined pursuant to this article without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with subdivision (d).
(c)The Legislature also recognizes that premature and unnecessary development of agricultural lands for urban uses continues to have adverse effects on the availability of those lands for food and fiber production and on the economy of the state. Furthermore, it is the policy of the state that development should be guided away from prime agricultural lands; therefore, in implementing this section, local jurisdictions should encourage, to the maximum extent practicable, in filling existing urban areas.
(d)A local agency shall not disapprove a housing development project, including farmworker housing as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 50199.7 of the Health and Safety Code, for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, or condition approval in a manner that renders the housing development project infeasible for development for the use of very low, low-, or moderate-income households, or an emergency shelter, including through the use of design review standards, unless it makes written findings, based upon a preponderance of the evidence in the record, as to one of the following:
(1)The jurisdiction has adopted a housing element pursuant to this article that has been revised in accordance with Section 65588, is in substantial compliance with this article, and the jurisdiction has met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need allocation pursuant to Section 65584 for the planning period for the income category proposed for the housing development project, provided that any disapproval or conditional approval shall not be based on any of the reasons prohibited by Section 65008. If the housing development project includes a mix of income categories, and the jurisdiction has not met or exceeded its share of the regional housing need for one or more of those categories, then this paragraph shall not be used to disapprove or conditionally approve the housing development project. The share of the regional housing need met by the jurisdiction shall be calculated consistently with the forms and definitions that may be adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 65400. In the case of an emergency shelter, the jurisdiction shall have met or exceeded the need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. Any disapproval or conditional approval pursuant to this paragraph shall be in accordance with applicable law, rule, or standards.
(2)The housing development project or emergency shelter as proposed would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete. The following shall not constitute a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety:
(A)Inconsistency with the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation.
(B)The eligibility to claim a welfare exemption under subdivision (g) of Section 214 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(3)The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households or rendering the development of the emergency shelter financially infeasible.
(4)The housing development project or emergency shelter is proposed on land zoned for agriculture or resource preservation that is surrounded on at least two sides by land being used for agricultural or resource preservation purposes, or which does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities to serve the project.
(5)The housing development project or emergency shelter is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation as specified in any element of the general plan as it existed on the date the application was deemed complete, and the jurisdiction has adopted a revised housing element in accordance with Section 65588 that is in substantial compliance with this article. For purposes of this section, a change to the zoning ordinance or general plan land use designation subsequent to the date the application was deemed complete shall not constitute a valid basis to disapprove or condition approval of the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(A)This paragraph cannot be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project if the housing development project is proposed on a site that is identified as suitable or available for very low, low-, or moderate-income households in the jurisdictions housing element, and consistent with the density specified in the housing element, even though it is inconsistent with both the jurisdictions zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation.
(B)If the local agency has failed to identify in the inventory of land in its housing element sites that can be developed for housing within the planning period and are sufficient to provide for the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need for all income levels pursuant to Section 65584, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve a housing development project proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for residential uses or designated in any element of the general plan for commercial uses if residential uses are permitted or conditionally permitted within commercial designations. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does identify adequate sites with appropriate zoning and development standards and with services and facilities to accommodate the local agencys share of the regional housing need for the very low, low-, and moderate-income categories.
(C)If the local agency has failed to identify a zone or zones where emergency shelters are allowed as a permitted use without a conditional use or other discretionary permit, has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones include sufficient capacity to accommodate the need for emergency shelter identified in paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, or has failed to demonstrate that the identified zone or zones can accommodate at least one emergency shelter, as required by paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583, then this paragraph shall not be utilized to disapprove or conditionally approve an emergency shelter proposed for a site designated in any element of the general plan for industrial, commercial, or multifamily residential uses. In any action in court, the burden of proof shall be on the local agency to show that its housing element does satisfy the requirements of paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583.
(e)Nothing in this section shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with the congestion management program required by Chapter 2.6 (commencing with Section 65088) of Division 1 of Title 7 or the California Coastal Act of 1976 (Division 20 (commencing with Section 30000) of the Public Resources Code). Neither shall anything in this section be construed to relieve the local agency from making one or more of the findings required pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code or otherwise complying with the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(f)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring the housing development project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions share of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density permitted on the site and proposed by the development.
(2)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from requiring an emergency shelter project to comply with objective, quantifiable, written development standards, conditions, and policies that are consistent with paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583 and appropriate to, and consistent with, meeting the jurisdictions need for emergency shelter, as identified pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (a) of Section 65583. However, the development standards, conditions, and policies shall be applied by the local agency to facilitate and accommodate the development of the emergency shelter project.
(3)Except as provided in subdivision (o), nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit a local agency from imposing fees and other exactions otherwise authorized by law that are essential to provide necessary public services and facilities to the housing development project or emergency shelter.
(4)For purposes of this section, a housing development project or emergency shelter shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision if there is substantial evidence that would allow a reasonable person to conclude that the housing development project or emergency shelter is consistent, compliant, or in conformity.
(g)This section shall be applicable to charter cities because the Legislature finds that the lack of housing, including emergency shelter, is a critical statewide problem.
(h)The following definitions apply for the purposes of this section:
(1)Feasible means capable of being accomplished in a successful manner within a reasonable period of time, taking into account economic, environmental, social, and technological factors.
(2)Housing development project means a use consisting of any of the following:
(A)Residential units only.
(B)Mixed-use developments consisting of residential and nonresidential uses with at least two-thirds of the square footage designated for residential use.
(C)Transitional housing or supportive housing.
(3)Housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households means that either (A) at least 20 percent of the total units shall be sold or rented to lower income households, as defined in Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or (B) 100 percent of the units shall be sold or rented to persons and families of moderate income as defined in Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code, or persons and families of middle income, as defined in Section 65008 of this code. Housing units targeted for lower income households shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 60 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the lower income eligibility limits are based. Housing units targeted for persons and families of moderate income shall be made available at a monthly housing cost that does not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income with adjustments for household size made in accordance with the adjustment factors on which the moderate-income eligibility limits are based.
(4)Area median income means area median income as periodically established by the Department of Housing and Community Development pursuant to Section 50093 of the Health and Safety Code. The developer shall provide sufficient legal commitments to ensure continued availability of units for very low or low-income households in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision for 30 years.
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, deemed complete means that the applicant has submitted a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 or, if the applicant has not submitted a preliminary application, has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(6)Disapprove the housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does any of the following:
(A)Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit.
(B)Fails to comply with the time periods specified in subdivision (a) of Section 65950. An extension of time pursuant to Article 5 (commencing with Section 65950) shall be deemed to be an extension of time pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)Fails to meet the time limits specified in Section 65913.3.
(D)Fails to make a determination that the project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the requirements specified in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)Both of the following criteria are met:
(I)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant.
(II)If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of the California Environmental Quality Act (Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 15000) of Division 6 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations), there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the exception does not apply to the project.
(v)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination that the project is exempt and the local agency did not approve the exemption within 90 days of the applicants written notice.
(I)If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified by Section 21080.2 of the Public Resources Code for determining whether the project requires an environmental impact report or negative declaration has passed.
(E)Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment pursuant to Section 21155.2 of the Public Resources Code, as required pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code), if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the site of the housing development project satisfies the conditions set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4, except that this clause shall not apply to a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone, unless the development is on a site that also satisfies the requirements of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 65913.4.
(ii)The housing development project is located within an urbanized area as defined in Section 21071 of the Public Resources Code.
(iii)The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre.
(iv)There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) with respect to the project.
(v)If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt that negative declaration, has held a meeting at which the negative declaration was on the agenda and could have been adopted, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:
(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or adopt the negative declaration.
(vi)If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, the local agency, or a body or official to which the agency has delegated authority to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document, has held a meeting at which the environmental review document was on the agenda and could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following:
(I)Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
(II)Failed to decide whether to require further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document.
(vii)The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify the document, as applicable, within 90 days of the applicants written notice.
(I)If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agencys decision.
(II)If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agencys consideration, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the time period specified in Section 21151.5 of the Public Resources Code or another applicable provision of that code for completing the addendum, negative declaration, environmental impact report, or other comparable environmental review document, as applicable, has passed. If the Public Resources Code does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
(7)Lower density includes any conditions that have the same effect or impact on the ability of the project to provide housing.
(8)Until January 1, 2030, objective means involving no personal or subjective judgment by a public official and being uniformly verifiable by reference to an external and uniform benchmark or criterion available and knowable by both the development applicant or proponent and the public official.
(9)Notwithstanding any other law, until January 1, 2030, determined to be complete means that the applicant has submitted a complete application pursuant to Section 65943.
(i)If any city, county, or city and county denies approval or imposes conditions, including design changes, lower density, or a reduction of the percentage of a lot that may be occupied by a building or structure under the applicable planning and zoning in force at the time the housing development projects application is complete, that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial of the development or the imposition of conditions on the development is the subject of a court action which challenges the denial or the imposition of conditions, then the burden of proof shall be on the local legislative body to show that its decision is consistent with the findings as described in subdivision (d), and that the findings are supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, and with the requirements of subdivision (o).
(j)(1)When a proposed housing development project complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards and criteria, including design review standards, in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, but the local agency proposes to disapprove the project or to impose a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, the local agency shall base its decision regarding the proposed housing development project upon written findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence on the record that both of the following conditions exist:
(A)The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density. As used in this paragraph, a specific, adverse impact means a significant, quantifiable, direct, and unavoidable impact, based on objective, identified written public health or safety standards, policies, or conditions as they existed on the date the application was deemed complete.
(B)There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact identified pursuant to paragraph (1), other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density.
(2)(A)If the local agency considers a proposed housing development project to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision as specified in this subdivision, it shall provide the applicant with written documentation identifying the provision or provisions, and an explanation of the reason or reasons it considers the housing development to be inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity as follows:
(i)Within 30 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains 150 or fewer housing units.
(ii)Within 60 days of the date that the application for the housing development project is determined to be complete, if the housing development project contains more than 150 units.
(B)If the local agency fails to provide the required documentation pursuant to subparagraph (A), the housing development project shall be deemed consistent, compliant, and in conformity with the applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision.
(3)For purposes of this section, the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or reduction of development standards pursuant to Section 65915 shall not constitute a valid basis on which to find a proposed housing development project is inconsistent, not in compliance, or not in conformity, with an applicable plan, program, policy, ordinance, standard, requirement, or other similar provision specified in this subdivision.
(4)For purposes of this section, a proposed housing development project is not inconsistent with the applicable zoning standards and criteria, and shall not require a rezoning, if the housing development project is consistent with the objective general plan standards and criteria but the zoning for the project site is inconsistent with the general plan. If the local agency has complied with paragraph (2), the local agency may require the proposed housing development project to comply with the objective standards and criteria of the zoning which is consistent with the general plan, however, the standards and criteria shall be applied to facilitate and accommodate development at the density allowed on the site by the general plan and proposed by the proposed housing development project.
(k)(1)(A)(i)The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce this section. If, in any action brought to enforce this section, a court finds that any of the following are met, the court shall issue an order pursuant to clause (ii):
(I)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (d), disapproved a housing development project or conditioned its approval in a manner rendering it infeasible for the development of an emergency shelter, or housing for very low, low-, or moderate-income households, including farmworker housing, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(II)The local agency, in violation of subdivision (j), disapproved a housing development project complying with applicable, objective general plan and zoning standards and criteria, or imposed a condition that the project be developed at a lower density, without making the findings required by this section or without making findings supported by a preponderance of the evidence.
(III)(ia)Subject to sub-subclause (ib), the local agency, in violation of subdivision (o), required or attempted to require a housing development project to comply with an ordinance, policy, or standard not adopted and in effect when a preliminary application was submitted.
(ib)This subclause shall become inoperative on January 1, 2030.
(ii)If the court finds that one of the conditions in clause (i) is met, the court shall issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days, including, but not limited to, an order that the local agency take action on the housing development project or emergency shelter. The court may issue an order or judgment directing the local agency to approve the housing development project or emergency shelter if the court finds that the local agency acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section. The court shall retain jurisdiction to ensure that its order or judgment is carried out and shall award reasonable attorneys fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, except under extraordinary circumstances in which the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section. provided however, that the court shall not award attorneys fees in either of the following instances:
(I)The court finds, under extraordinary circumstances, that awarding fees would not further the purposes of this section.
(II)In a case concerning a disapproval within the meaning of subparagraph (D) or (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h), the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the housing development project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
(B)Upon a determination that the local agency has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with this section within 60 days issued pursuant to subparagraph (A), the court shall impose fines on a local agency that has violated this section and require the local agency to deposit any fine levied pursuant to this subdivision into a local housing trust fund. The local agency may elect to instead deposit the fine into the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund. The fine shall be in a minimum amount of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per housing unit in the housing development project on the date the application was deemed complete pursuant to Section 65943. In determining the amount of fine to impose, the court shall consider the local agencys progress in attaining its target allocation of the regional housing need pursuant to Section 65584 and any prior violations of this section. Fines shall not be paid out of funds already dedicated to affordable housing, including, but not limited to, Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Funds, funds dedicated to housing for very low, low-, and moderate-income households, and federal HOME Investment Partnerships Program and Community Development Block Grant Program funds. The local agency shall commit and expend the money in the local housing trust fund within five years for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households. After five years, if the funds have not been expended, the money shall revert to the state and be deposited in the Building Homes and Jobs Trust Fund for the sole purpose of financing newly constructed housing units affordable to extremely low, very low, or low-income households.
(C)If the court determines that its order or judgment has not been carried out within 60 days, the court may issue further orders as provided by law to ensure that the purposes and policies of this section are fulfilled, including, but not limited to, an order to vacate the decision of the local agency and to approve the housing development project, in which case the application for the housing development project, as proposed by the applicant at the time the local agency took the initial action determined to be in violation of this section, along with any standard conditions determined by the court to be generally imposed by the local agency on similar projects, shall be deemed to be approved unless the applicant consents to a different decision or action by the local agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, housing organization means a trade or industry group whose local members are primarily engaged in the construction or management of housing units or a nonprofit organization whose mission includes providing or advocating for increased access to housing for low-income households and have filed written or oral comments with the local agency prior to action on the housing development project. A housing organization may only file an action pursuant to this section to challenge the disapproval of a housing development by a local agency. A housing organization shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys fees and costs if it is the prevailing party in an action to enforce this section.
(l)If the court finds that the local agency (1) acted in bad faith when it disapproved or conditionally approved the housing development or emergency shelter in violation of this section and (2) failed to carry out the courts order or judgment within 60 days as described in subdivision (k), the court, in addition to any other remedies provided by this section, shall multiply the fine determined pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (k) by a factor of five. For purposes of this section, bad faith includes, but is not limited to, an action that is frivolous or otherwise entirely without merit.
(m)(1)Any action brought to enforce the provisions of this section shall be brought pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the local agency shall prepare and certify the record of proceedings in accordance with subdivision (c) of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure no later than 30 days after the petition is served, provided that the cost of preparation of the record shall be borne by the local agency, unless the petitioner elects to prepare the record as provided in subdivision (n) of this section. A petition to enforce the provisions of this section shall be filed and served no later than 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h). Upon entry of the trial courts order, a party may, in order to obtain appellate review of the order, file a petition within 20 days after service upon it of a written notice of the entry of the order, or within such further time not exceeding an additional 20 days as the trial court may for good cause allow, or may appeal the judgment or order of the trial court under Section 904.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If the local agency appeals the judgment of the trial court, the local agency shall post a bond, in an amount to be determined by the court, to the benefit of the plaintiff if the plaintiff is the project applicant.
(2)A local agencys failure to issue an exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)) shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency, as specified in clause (v) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the agency did not issue the exemption within 90 days of the applicants notice.
(3)A local agencys failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000)), shall be deemed final for purposes of this subdivision if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency as specified in clause (vii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h) and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, as applicable, within 90 days of the applicants notice.
(n)In any action, the record of the proceedings before the local agency shall be filed as expeditiously as possible and, notwithstanding Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure or subdivision (m) of this section, all or part of the record may be prepared (1) by the petitioner with the petition or petitioners points and authorities, (2) by the respondent with respondents points and authorities, (3) after payment of costs by the petitioner, or (4) as otherwise directed by the court. If the expense of preparing the record has been borne by the petitioner and the petitioner is the prevailing party, the expense shall be taxable as costs.
(o)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2), (6), and (7), and subdivision (d) of Section 65941.1, a housing development project shall be subject only to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when a preliminary application including all of the information required by subdivision (a) of Section 65941.1 was submitted.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not prohibit a housing development project from being subject to ordinances, policies, and standards adopted after the preliminary application was submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 in the following circumstances:
(A)In the case of a fee, charge, or other monetary exaction, to an increase resulting from an automatic annual adjustment based on an independently published cost index that is referenced in the ordinance or resolution establishing the fee or other monetary exaction.
(B)A preponderance of the evidence in the record establishes that subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, or standard beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to mitigate or avoid a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, as defined in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and there is no feasible alternative method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the adverse impact.
(C)Subjecting the housing development project to an ordinance, policy, standard, or any other measure, beyond those in effect when a preliminary application was submitted is necessary to avoid or substantially lessen an impact of the project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(D)The housing development project has not commenced construction within two and one-half years, or three and one-half years for an affordable housing project, following the date that the project received final approval. For purposes of this subparagraph:
(i)Affordable housing project means a housing development that satisfies both of the following requirements:
(I)Units within the development are subject to a recorded affordability restriction for at least 55 years for rental housing and 45 years for owner-occupied housing, or the first purchaser of each unit participates in an equity sharing agreement as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 65915.
(II)All of the units within the development, excluding managers units, are dedicated to lower income households, as defined by Section 50079.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(ii)Final approval means that the housing development project has received all necessary approvals to be eligible to apply for, and obtain, a building permit or permits and either of the following is met:
(I)The expiration of all applicable appeal periods, petition periods, reconsideration periods, or statute of limitations for challenging that final approval without an appeal, petition, request for reconsideration, or legal challenge having been filed.
(II)If a challenge is filed, that challenge is fully resolved or settled in favor of the housing development project.
(E)The housing development project is revised following submittal of a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 such that the number of residential units or square footage of construction changes by 20 percent or more, exclusive of any increase resulting from the receipt of a density bonus, incentive, concession, waiver, or similar provision, including any other locally authorized program that offers additional density or other development bonuses when affordable housing is provided. For purposes of this subdivision, square footage of construction means the building area, as defined by the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations).
(3)This subdivision does not prevent a local agency from subjecting the additional units or square footage of construction that result from project revisions occurring after a preliminary application is submitted pursuant to Section 65941.1 to the ordinances, policies, and standards adopted and in effect when the preliminary application was submitted.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, ordinances, policies, and standards includes general plan, community plan, specific plan, zoning, design review standards and criteria, subdivision standards and criteria, and any other rules, regulations, requirements, and policies of a local agency, as defined in Section 66000, including those relating to development impact fees, capacity or connection fees or charges, permit or processing fees, and other exactions.
(5)This subdivision shall not be construed in a manner that would lessen the restrictions imposed on a local agency, or lessen the protections afforded to a housing development project, that are established by any other law, including any other part of this section.
(6)This subdivision shall not restrict the authority of a public agency or local agency to require mitigation measures to lessen the impacts of a housing development project under the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code).
(7)With respect to completed residential units for which the project approval process is complete and a certificate of occupancy has been issued, nothing in this subdivision shall limit the application of later enacted ordinances, policies, and standards that regulate the use and occupancy of those residential units, such as ordinances relating to rental housing inspection, rent stabilization, restrictions on short-term renting, and business licensing requirements for owners of rental housing.
(8)(A)This subdivision shall apply to a housing development project that submits a preliminary application pursuant to Section 65941.1 before January 1, 2030.
(B)This subdivision shall become inoperative on January 1, 2034.
(p)Upon any motion for an award of attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agencys approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agencys approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorneys fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (d) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
(p)(q)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the Housing Accountability Act.
(r)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 11, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 768, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 11, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 21, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 67. Noes 2. Page 3489.). |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. (Page 3489.) |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 21. Noes 3. Page 2726.). |
| Sep 11, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (September 1). |
| Aug 14, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 12). |
| Jun 21, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HOUSING and E.Q. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 70. Noes 1. Page 2029.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 18). |
| May 18, 2023 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1580.) |
| May 17, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 19, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Apr 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 12). |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and NAT. RES. |
| Feb 18, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2023 | AB 1633 TING Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1633 Ting et al. By Wiener | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 1633 Ting Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Abundant Housing LA | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Council | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California community builders | ** Support | |
| California Housing Consortium | ** Support | |
| California Housing Partnership Corporation | ** Support | |
| California Native Plant Society | ** Against | |
| California YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Against | |
| Circulate San Diego | ** Support | |
| CivicWell | ** Support | |
| Council of Infill Builders | ** Support | |
| East Bay for Everyone | ** Support | |
| East Bay YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Endangered Habitats League | ** Against | |
| Fieldstead And Company, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Grow the Richmond | ** Support | |
| Habitat For Humanity California | ** Support | |
| Housing Action Coalition | ** Support | |
| How to ADU | ** Support | |
| Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| MidPen Housing | ** Support | |
| Mountain View YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Napa-Solano for Everyone | ** Support | |
| Northern Neighbors | ** Support | |
| Peninsula for Everyone | ** Support | |
| People For Housing Orange County | ** Support | |
| Planning And Conservation League | ** Against | |
| Progress Noe Valley | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Yimby | ** Support | |
| San Luis Obispo Yimby | ** Support | |
| Santa Cruz Yimby | ** Support | |
| Santa Rosa Yimby | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Leadership Group | ** Support | |
| SLO County YIMBY | ** Support | |
| South Bay Yimby | ** Support | |
| Southside Forward | ** Support | |
| SPUR | ** Support | |
| State Building and Construction Trades Council of California | ** Against | |
| Sustainable Tamalmonte | ** Against | |
| Urban Environmentalists | ** Support | |
| Ventura County YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Westside for Everyone | ** Support | |
| Yimby Action | ** Support |
(Without Reference to File)
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1633
Author:(Ting)
As Amended Ver:September 8, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes a local agency's failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), abuse of discretion, or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes, until January 1, 2031.
Senate Amendments
- Specify that a housing development project must meet one or more of the following locational criteria in order to be protected by the HAA under a failure to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA, an abuse of discretion, or a failure to adopt certain environmental documents:
- The project is located within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop;
- The project is located in a very low vehicle travel area;
- The project is proximal to six or more amenities, as specified, as of the date of submission of the application for the project; or
- Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of the project site or at least three sites of a foursided project site.
- Require an applicant's written notice to the local agency of action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination of CEQA exemption or an abuse of discretion to contain all of the following:
- The identifying information specified in California Code of Regulations (CCR) Title 14, Sections 15062(a)(1), (2), (5) and (6);
- A citation to the section of Title 14 of the CCR or the statute under which the applicant asserts the project is exempt from CEQA;
- A brief statement of reasons supporting the assertion that the project is exempt; and
- A copy of the excerpts from the record constituting substantial evidence that specified criteria in the bill are satisfied.
- Require the local agency to file a notice received under 2), above, within five working days of receipt with the county clerk of each county in which the project will be located, and requires the county clerk to post the notice and make it available for public inspection.
- Revise the definition of "abuse of discretion," for purposes of failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA or commits an abuse of discretion, to mean that the conditions set forth in specified criteria in the bill are satisfied, but the local agency does not determine that the project is exempt from CEQA.
- Add various other locational definitions, make other technical changes, and revise the findings and declarations.
- Sunset the provisions of the bill on January 1, 2031.
COMMENTS
CEQA and Housing: CEQA requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed changes to the physical environment, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. If a development project would make significant negative changes to the physical environment, and those impacts could not be mitigated, CEQA requires that the governmental entity approving the project to make findings that justify why the change is merited despite its environmental impact. CEQA provides multiple opportunities for public involvement, and enables members of the public to sue a governmental entity that they believe did not properly follow the process.
For housing projects, it can be complicated to untangle and assess the possible impacts a new development might have on the variety of aspects CEQA requires local governments to look at. Development inevitably causes new impacts and patterns of activity that differ from the baseline status quo on a site. CEQA calls for careful deliberation of every possible environmental impact, and requires exhaustive analysis if there is a fair argument that a project might have a significant impact on any number of criteria. Infill housing, by its nature, is located in places where there are existing uses on adjacent sites, meaning there will always be neighbors or others nearby who become aware of the development – a significant contrast with sprawl developments that are proposed on agricultural land or in other areas where there are simply very few neighbors or no existing communities interested in raising CEQA challenges. In essence, CEQA gives local governments and the public procedural deference to request that exhaustive analysis, even when it is not always warranted. Some local agencies conduct redundant environmental review to avoid CEQA lawsuits from neighbors or interest groups at best, or to delay a project indefinitely in the hopes of shrinking or killing it at worst.
The HAA and CEQA: The first provisions of the HAA state: "The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California…Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects." (Government Code 65589.5(a)(1))
The HAA requires local governments to approve housing development projects that are consistent with their objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards, unless the developments pose a risk to public health and safety that cannot be addressed without denying projects or reducing their size. The HAA also facilitates timely decision making by using the established timeframes of the Permit Streamlining Act. The HAA generally puts the burden of proof on the local agency to demonstrate that its decisions meet the HAA's requirements. Finally, the HAA facilitates private enforcement of these provisions.
As described, the HAA and CEQA take different approaches to housing development. The intersection of these two Acts therefore can result in gray areas or conflict. For example, the HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction's zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues that cannot be mitigated. The HAA explicitly states that it does not restrict the authority of a public agency to require mitigation measures under CEQA. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible or unreasonably delays it by requiring CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
469 Stevenson Street: In 2021 in San Francisco, the Board of Supervisors (BOS) required a 500-unit downtown project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops to undertake additional studies related to the project's EIR. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the local government, "the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified." However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was in violation of the HAA.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to "disapprove the housing development project" in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion in that determination; and
- When a local agency fails to either require further study or adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an EIR, or approve another environmental document for the project, or commits an abuse of discretion in that instance.
By adding these two criteria to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
The bill only applies to projects that meet the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017 must meet, which eliminates many of the state's most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in high or very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. Further, the project must meet at least one of a set of infill location criteria, including proximity to transit, amenities, or where at least three-quarters of the parcel is surrounded by other urban developed parcels. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California's statewide housing production needs.
The bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney's fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. The bill states the intent of the Legislature that attorney's fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
All of these provisions will sunset on January 1, 2031.
According to the Author
"The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA."
Arguments in Support
According to the Bay Area Council, a cosponsor, "The Council agrees that environmental protection is an important endeavor, but as it operates against infill housing, this law is having effects that harm the environment. Infill housing is the most powerful policy tool we have to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, something that CEQA implicitly fails to recognize by giving this veto power to local governments. AB 1633 establishes that a city that wrongfully denies a project by laundering the denial through the false pretenses of environmental review will be subject to the same penalties that would apply if the city illegally denied the project by other means. This bill still allows the normal CEQA and environmental review process, and, by creating a punishment for non-environmental denials, the bill implicitly strengthens CEQA as an environmental law."
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of environmental organizations including the Planning and Conservation League, Center for Biological Diversity, and Surfrider Foundation raise a number of concerns, including that this bill was prompted by one isolated incident of an infill project being required to undergo additional review, it could open up local governments to litigation if a developer disagrees with the decision to require preparation of a CEQA document, and the limiting of attorney's fees could discourage environmental justice organizations from filing legitimate lawsuits against certain projects.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $474,000 annually until 2031 and 2.0 PY of staff with specific knowledge of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle Housing Accountability Unit casework resulting from this bill. Specific duties include research, environmental documentation review, providing technical assistance, drafting opinions of legal sufficiency of environmental studies, issuing notices of violation, and referring cases to the Attorney General's office. (General Fund)
- Unknown local mandated costs. While the bill could impose new costs on local agencies to revise planning requirements and considerations for certain housing developments, these costs are not state-reimbursable because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses associated with new planning mandates. (local funds)
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures due to increased court workload to adjudicate additional cases filed for the new violation of the HAA established by this bill. Staff notes that, in addition to cases referred to the Attorney General by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include, project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. (Special Fund – Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
VOTES:
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 8-0-0
YES: Wicks, Joe Patterson, Wendy Carrillo, Gabriel, Kalra, Quirk-Silva, Sanchez, Ward
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 8-0-3
YES: Luz Rivas, Flora, Friedman, Hoover, Mathis, Pellerin, Ward, Wood
ABS, ABST OR NV: Addis, Muratsuchi, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 70-1-9
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Rendon
NO: Boerner
ABS, ABST OR NV: Addis, Connolly, Essayli, Flora, Hart, Muratsuchi, Rodriguez, Valencia, Zbur
UPDATED
VERSION: September 8, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0002420
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1633 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1633
Author: Ting (D), et al.
Amended: 9/8/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/20/23
AYES: Wiener, Ochoa Bogh, Blakespear, Caballero, Cortese, McGuire, Padilla, Seyarto, Skinner, Umberg, Wahab
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/12/23
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 70-1, 5/31/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
SOURCE: Bay Area Council
California Housing Partnership Corporation
California YIMBY
Housing Action Coalition
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association
DIGEST:
This bill provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes a local agency's failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), abuse of discretion, or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/8/23 (1) provide that if a project applicant believes a local agency’s action or inaction constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, the application shall provide a written notice that shall contain specified information; (2) provide that if a project applicant believes a local agency has failed to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report, or approve another comparable environmental document, the applicant shall provide written notice that shall include evidence that constitute substantial evidence that specified criteria are met; and (3) make clarifying changes regarding notice requirements.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires a local jurisdiction to give public notice of a hearing whenever a person applies for a zoning variance, special use permit, conditional use permit, zoning ordinance amendment, or general or specific plan amendment.
- Requires the board of zoning adjustment or zoning administrator to hear and decide applications for conditional uses or other permits when the zoning ordinance provides therefore and establishes criteria for determining those matters, and applications for variances from the terms of the zoning ordinance.
- Establishes CEQA, which generally requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects, and to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government.
- Prohibits a local agency, pursuant to the HAA, from disapproving a housing project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate income renters, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the housing project infeasible, unless it makes specified findings, based upon substantial evidence in the record.
- Defines “disapprove the housing development project” as any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building project.
- Fails to comply with specified time periods for approving or disapproving development projects.
This bill:
- Adds to the definition of “disapprove the housing development project” the following situations:
- Fails to meet timelines specified for the issuance of post-entitlement permits;
- Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an “abuse of discretion,” as specified, if all the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined, within ½ mile of a major transit stop, in a low vehicle travel area, close to specified amenities, or developed with urban uses that adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of the project site;
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant, and if the exception is subject to a CEQA exception, there is substantial evidence in the record that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the specified exceptions; and
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice. The notice shall contain specified information.
- The agency may extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is a substantial evidence that the housing development is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
- If the local agency has given the applicant written notice of the local agency’s determination that the project is not exempt, the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave the applicant notice off the local agency’s determination.
- If the local agency has not given the applicant the written notice described in (1)(b)(v)(2), the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency or 60 days from the date on which the project was deemed complete.
- Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project to certify an environmental impact report for the project or to approve another comparable environmental document, as required under CEQA, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined, within ½ mile of a major transit stop, in a low vehicle travel area, close to specified amenities, or developed with urban uses that adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of the project site;
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, that if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of CEQA;
- The local agency which has the authority to adopt, approve, or certify the relevant environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency committed an abuse of discretion or failed to decide whether to further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document; and
- The applicant has given timely written to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice. The applicants notice shall include a copy of those excerpts from the record that constitute substantial evidence that specified criteria are met.
- If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving or certifying the appropriate environmental review document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it was delivered to the local agency within 35 days of the date that the local agency gave written notice of its decision to the applicant.
- If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the appropriate environmental document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the specified review for specified documents has passed.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney's fees in cases concerning disapprovals within the meaning of 1) or 2) if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- Sunsets the provisions of the bill on January 1, 2031.
Background
HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted HAA, commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the housing need determined pursuant to the Housing Element Law without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a city’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the localities share of the regional housing needs assessment.
CEQA, exemptions, and ministerial approvals. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government agency. When a local agency has the discretion to approve a project, its CEQA evaluation begins with deciding whether an activity qualifies as a project subject to CEQA review. If an activity is deemed a “project,” the agency decides whether it is exempt from compliance with CEQA under either a statutory or a categorical exemption. Statutory exemptions are activities the Legislature has excluded from CEQA despite potential environmental impacts. If a project is statutorily exempt, it can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation.
In addition to statutory exemptions, the Legislature specifically directed the Secretary of the California Natural Resources Agency to designate categorical exemptions from CEQA. Categorical exemptions include projects that the Secretary deems do not have a significant impact on the environment. The CEQA Guidelines, set forth in the California Code of Regulations, set forth more than two dozen categorical exemptions covering a wide range of projects, from minor alterations of existing facilities to construction of certain types of buildings. As with statutory exemptions, if the project is categorically exempt, no formal evaluation is required, and the project can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation. Despite the creation of new by-right and development streamlining measures that bypass the CEQA process, if a city chooses not to grant the permits – in violation of state law – a developer’s only recourse is to sue.
Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. In addition, before building new housing, housing developers must obtain one or more permits from local planning departments and must also obtain approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially, or by-right, require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to review under the CEQA, while projects permitted ministerially generally are not.
Comments
Ambiguities in the HAA related to CEQA. The HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible by requiring extended environmental analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to "disapprove the housing development project" in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion in that determination; and
- When a local agency fails to either require further study or adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an EIR, or approve another environmental document for the project, or commits an abuse of discretion in that instance.
By adding these two criteria to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
This bill only applies to projects that meet the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) must meet, which eliminates many of the state's most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in high or very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California's statewide housing production needs.
This bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney's fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. This bill states the intent of the Legislature is that attorney's fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $474,000 annually until 2031 and 2.0 PY of staff with specific knowledge of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle Housing Accountability Unit casework resulting from this bill. Specific duties include research, environmental documentation review, providing technical assistance, drafting opinions of legal sufficiency of environmental studies, issuing notices of violation, and referring cases to the Attorney General’s office. (General Fund)
- Unknown local mandated costs. While this bill could impose new costs on local agencies to revise planning requirements and considerations for certain housing developments, these costs are not state-reimbursable because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses associated with new planning mandates. (local funds)
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures due to increased court workload to adjudicate additional cases filed for the new violation of the HAA established by this bill. Staff notes that, in addition to cases referred to the Attorney General by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include, project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. (Special Fund – Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/1/23)
Bay Area Council (co-source)
California Housing Partnership Corporation (co-source)
California YIMBY (co-source)
Housing Action Coalition (co-source)
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (co-source)
Abundant Housing LA
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
Circulate San Diego
CivicWell
Council of Infill Builders
East Bay for Everyone
East Bay YIMBY
Fieldstead and Company, Inc.
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
How to ADU
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
MidPen Housing
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
SLO County YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
SPUR
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County YIMBY
Westside for Everyone
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/1/23)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Sustainable Tamalmonte
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The State Building and Construction Trades Council of California are opposed to the April 21st version of this bill, stating this bill gives developers a shortcut to court. They are also concerned that this bill will “undermines the ability of Californians to have a voice in the environmental outcome and decision-making process of projects that impact their health and their communities by violating basic public participation mandates. Sustainable Tamalmonte is opposed to the bill asserting local governments may approve projects that will harm the environment and also may result in litigation initiated by developers who are dissatisfied with local government decisions.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 70-1, 5/31/23
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Boerner
NO VOTE RECORDED: Addis, Connolly, Essayli, Flora, Hart, Muratsuchi, Rodriguez, Valencia, Zbur
Prepared by: Alison Hughes / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
9/11/23 12:50:04
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1633 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1633
Author: Ting (D), et al.
Amended: 9/1/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/20/23
AYES: Wiener, Ochoa Bogh, Blakespear, Caballero, Cortese, McGuire, Padilla, Seyarto, Skinner, Umberg, Wahab
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/12/23
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 70-1, 5/31/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
SOURCE: Bay Area Council
California Housing Partnership Corporation
California YIMBY
Housing Action Coalition
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association
DIGEST:
This bill provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes a local agency's failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), abuse of discretion, or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires a local jurisdiction to give public notice of a hearing whenever a person applies for a zoning variance, special use permit, conditional use permit, zoning ordinance amendment, or general or specific plan amendment.
- Requires the board of zoning adjustment or zoning administrator to hear and decide applications for conditional uses or other permits when the zoning ordinance provides therefore and establishes criteria for determining those matters, and applications for variances from the terms of the zoning ordinance.
- Establishes CEQA, which generally requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects, and to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government.
- Prohibits a local agency, pursuant to the HAA, from disapproving a housing project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate income renters, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the housing project infeasible, unless it makes specified findings, based upon substantial evidence in the record.
- Defines “disapprove the housing development project” as any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building project.
- Fails to comply with specified time periods for approving or disapproving development projects.
This bill:
- Adds to the definition of “disapprove the housing development project” the following situations:
- Fails to meet timelines specified for the issuance of post-entitlement permits;
- Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an “abuse of discretion,” as specified, if all the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined, within ½ mile of a major transit stop, in a low vehicle travel area, close to specified amenities, or developed with urban uses that adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of the project site.
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant, and if the exception is subject to a CEQA exception, there is substantial evidence in the record that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the specified exceptions.
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- The agency may extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is a substantial evidence that the housing development is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
- If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision.
- If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency or 60 days from the date on which the project was deemed complete.
- Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project to certify an environmental impact report for the project or to approve another comparable environmental document, as required under CEQA, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined, within ½ mile of a major transit stop, in a low vehicle travel area, close to specified amenities, or developed with urban uses that adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of the project site;
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, that if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of CEQA.
- The local agency which has the authority to adopt, approve, or certify the relevant environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency committed an abuse of discretion or failed to decide whether to further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
- The applicant has given timely written to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice. The applicants notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency, and if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agency’s action as an abuse of discretion.
- If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving or certifying the appropriate environmental review document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it was given 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision.
- If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the appropriate environmental document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the specified review for specified documents has passed.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney's fees in cases concerning disapprovals within the meaning of 1) or 2) if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- Sunsets the provisions of the bill on January 1, 2031.
Background
HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the housing need determined pursuant to the Housing Element Law without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a city’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the localities share of the regional housing needs assessment.
CEQA, exemptions, and ministerial approvals. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government agency. When a local agency has the discretion to approve a project, its CEQA evaluation begins with deciding whether an activity qualifies as a project subject to CEQA review. If an activity is deemed a “project,” the agency decides whether it is exempt from compliance with CEQA under either a statutory or a categorical exemption. Statutory exemptions are activities the Legislature has excluded from CEQA despite potential environmental impacts. If a project is statutorily exempt, it can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation.
In addition to statutory exemptions, the Legislature specifically directed the Secretary of the California Natural Resources Agency to designate categorical exemptions from CEQA. Categorical exemptions include projects that the Secretary deems do not have a significant impact on the environment. The CEQA Guidelines, set forth in the California Code of Regulations, set forth more than two dozen categorical exemptions covering a wide range of projects, from minor alterations of existing facilities to construction of certain types of buildings. As with statutory exemptions, if the project is categorically exempt, no formal evaluation is required, and the project can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation. Despite the creation of new by-right and development streamlining measures that bypass the CEQA process, if a city chooses not to grant the permits – in violation of state law – a developer’s only recourse is to sue.
Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. In addition, before building new housing, housing developers must obtain one or more permits from local planning departments and must also obtain approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially, or by-right, require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to review under the CEQA, while projects permitted ministerially generally are not.
Comments
- Ambiguities in the HAA related to CEQA. The HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible by requiring extended environmental analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to "disapprove the housing development project" in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion in that determination; and
- When a local agency fails to either require further study or adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an EIR, or approve another environmental document for the project, or commits an abuse of discretion in that instance.
By adding these two criteria to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
The bill only applies to projects that meet the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017 must meet, which eliminates many of the state's most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in high or very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California's statewide housing production needs.
The bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney's fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. The bill states the intent of the Legislature is that attorney's fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
- Senate Appropriations Amendments. Senate Appropriations amendments make technical, clarifying changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $474,000 annually until 2031 and 2.0 PY of staff with specific knowledge of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle Housing Accountability Unit casework resulting from this bill. Specific duties include research, environmental documentation review, providing technical assistance, drafting opinions of legal sufficiency of environmental studies, issuing notices of violation, and referring cases to the Attorney General’s office. (General Fund)
- Unknown local mandated costs. While the bill could impose new costs on local agencies to revise planning requirements and considerations for certain housing developments, these costs are not state-reimbursable because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses associated with new planning mandates. (local funds)
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures due to increased court workload to adjudicate additional cases filed for the new violation of the HAA established by this bill. Staff notes that, in addition to cases referred to the Attorney General by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include, project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. (Special Fund – Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/1/23)
Bay Area Council (co-source)
California Housing Partnership Corporation (co-source)
California YIMBY (co-source)
Housing Action Coalition (co-source)
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (co-source)
Abundant Housing LA
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
Circulate San Diego
Civicwell
Council of Infill Builders
East Bay for Everyone
East Bay YIMBY
Fieldstead and Company, Inc.
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
How to ADU
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Midpen Housing
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Slo County YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
SPUR
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County YIMBY
Westside for Everyone
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/1/23)
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Sustainable Tamalmonte
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The State Building and Construction Trades Council are opposed to the April 21st version of the bill, stating the bill gives developers a shortcut to court. They are also concerned that this bill will “undermines the ability of Californians to have a voice in the environmental outcome and decision-making process of projects that impact their health and their communities by violating basic public participation mandates. Sustainable Tamalmonte is opposed to the bill asserting local governments may approve projects that will harm the environment and also may result in litigation initiated by developers who are dissatisfied with local government decisions.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 70-1, 5/31/23
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Boerner
NO VOTE RECORDED: Addis, Connolly, Essayli, Flora, Hart, Muratsuchi, Rodriguez, Valencia, Zbur
Prepared by: Alison Hughes / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
9/2/23 14:46:05
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1633 (Ting) - Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1633 would specify that a local agency’s disapproval of a housing project proposed in specified locations is a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) if the agency fails to make a determination that a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), or fails to adopt, certify, or approve certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, or commits a specified abuse of discretion in those cases. These provisions would sunset on January 1, 2031.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on September 1, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $474,000 annually until 2031 and 2.0 PY of staff with specific knowledge of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle Housing Accountability Unit casework resulting from this bill. Specific duties include research, environmental documentation review, providing technical assistance, drafting opinions of legal sufficiency of environmental studies, issuing notices of violation, and referring cases to the Attorney General’s office. (General Fund)
- Unknown local mandated costs. While the bill could impose new costs on local agencies to revise planning requirements and considerations for certain housing developments, these costs are not state-reimbursable because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses associated with new planning mandates. (local funds)
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures due to increased court workload to adjudicate additional cases filed for the new violation of the HAA established by this bill. Staff notes that, in addition to cases referred to the Attorney General by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include, project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. (Special Fund – Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).
Author Amendments:
- Require a housing development project subject to the bill’s provisions to be located on a parcel within an urbanized area and meet one or more specified criteria.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1633 (Ting) - Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
Version: July 13, 2023 | Policy Vote: HOUSING 11 - 0, E.Q. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
AB 1633 would specify that a local agency’s disapproval of a housing project proposed in specified locations is a violation of the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) if the agency fails to make a determination that a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), or fails to adopt, certify, or approve certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, or commits a specified abuse of discretion in those cases. These provisions would sunset on January 1, 2031.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing costs of approximately $474,000 annually until 2031 and 2.0 PY of staff with specific knowledge of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle Housing Accountability Unit casework resulting from this bill. Specific duties include research, environmental documentation review, providing technical assistance, drafting opinions of legal sufficiency of environmental studies, issuing notices of violation, and referring cases to the Attorney General’s office. (General Fund)
- Unknown local mandated costs. While the bill could impose new costs on local agencies to revise planning requirements and considerations for certain housing developments, these costs are not state-reimbursable because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses associated with new planning mandates. (local funds)
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures due to increased court workload to adjudicate additional cases filed for the new violation of the HAA established by this bill. Staff notes that, in addition to cases referred to the Attorney General by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include, project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. (Special Fund – Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund). See Staff Comments.
Background:
Under the HAA a local government must approve a housing development project that is consistent with its objective general plan and zoning and subdivision standards, unless the project poses a risk to public health and safety that cannot be addressed without denying the project or reducing its size. The HAA explicitly prohibits a local agency from disapproving a housing project containing units affordable to very low-, low-, or moderate income renters, or conditioning the approval in a manner than renders the housing project infeasible, unless it makes one of a specified list of findings, based on substantial evidence in the record. The HAA also facilitates timely decision making by using the established timeframes of the Permit Streamlining Act.
The HAA facilitates private enforcement of these provisions by allowing a project applicant, a person who would be eligible to reside in the proposed development, or a housing organization, as defined, to bring an action to enforce the HAA. If a court finds a local agency to be in violation of the HAA, it may issue an order or judgement compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days. The HAA also allows a court, upon a determination that the locality has failed to comply with the order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, to approve the housing development project, and impose fines on a local agency that has violated the HAA and to deposit any fine into a local housing trust fund or elect to deposit the fine in a state account. The fine must be a minimum of $10,000 per unit, and additional fines may be imposed if the court finds that the locality acted in bad faith. Litigants supporting affordable housing projects can also recover their attorney’s fees.
CEQA requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed developments, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. If a development project would make significant negative changes to the physical environment, and those changes could not be mitigated, CEQA requires the governmental entity approving the project to make findings that justify why the project is merited despite its environmental impact. CEQA provides multiple opportunities for public involvement, and enables members of the public to sue a governmental entity they believe has not properly followed the process.
Proposed Law:
AB 1633 would, until January 1, 2031, expand the definition of what constitutes a disapproval of a housing development project that is considered a violation of the HAA to include instances in which a local agency fails to make a determination that a project proposed on a parcel in certain geographic locations is exempt from CEQA, or fails to adopt, certify, or approve certain environmental documents. Specifically, this bill would do the following:
- Define “disapprove the housing development project” as also including any instance in which a local agency:
- Fails to issue a project an exemption from CEQA for which it is eligible, as described, or commits an abuse of discretion, if specified conditions are satisfied.
- Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document, if specified conditions are satisfied.
- Specify certain site-specific criteria that must be met as part of the expanded definition noted above, including that a housing development must not be located within specified environmentally sensitive areas or fire hazard severity zones, and that the development must be at least 15 dwelling units per acre and located on a legal parcel in any of the following locations:
- In an urbanized area or urban cluster, as specified.
- Within one-half mile walking distance to either a high-quality transit corridor or a major transit stop, as specified.
- In a very low vehicle travel area, as specified.
- Proximal to six or more specified amenities as of the date of the application.
- Parcels that are developed with urban uses adjoin at least 75% of the perimeter of a project site, or at least three sides of a four sided project.
- Provide that a local agency’s failure to issue an exemption or make a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA or failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, is deemed a final disapproval of the housing project for purposes of filing a petition to enforce the provisions of the act if the applicant gives timely written notice to the local agency, as specified, and the agency does not issue the exemption or adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document within 90 days of the applicant’s notice.
- Limit the ability of a court to award attorney’s fees in cases concerning CEQA disapprovals if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provide that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- Sunset these changes to the HAA on January 1, 2031.
- Make the provisions of the HAA severable.
Related Legislation:
AB 2656 (Ting), which was held on this Committee’s Suspense File last year, was substantially similar to this bill, but AB 2656 did not limit its application to housing development projects proposed in specified locations, and did not contain a sunset clause.
Staff Comments:
Housing developers point to instances where a local government may not directly deny a project, but instead effectively render it infeasible by requiring CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. AB 1633 would address these circumstances by specifying that the wrongful denial or withholding of a CEQA clearance to which a housing development is legally entitled violates the HAA. This gives a plaintiff (the AG, a project applicant, a person who would be eligible to reside in the proposed development, or a housing organization) access to the legal remedies provided in the HAA, including the ability to sue a local agency the plaintiff believes is using CEQA delay as a means to disapprove or downsize a project without having voted to do so.
It is unknown how many additional lawsuits would be filed for violations of the HAA, including additional proceedings for determining attorney’s fees, as a result of this bill’s expansion of the definition of what constitutes disapproval of a housing project for purposes of the HAA. However, it generally costs about $8,000 to operate a courtroom for one eight-hour day. Consequently, if an eligible plaintiff filed suit under the provisions of this measure that would otherwise not be authorized under existing law, and combined, those additional cases take 50 or more hours of court involvement, the cost pressures of this measure to the courts would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund and staff workload may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. Numerous trial court operations are funded through the imposition and collection of criminal fines and fees. However, the Legislature has reduced and eliminated criminal fines and fees in recent years. As a result, the 2023-24 budget includes an ongoing annual allocation of $105.1 million backfill from the General Fund in order to address declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
The bill’s mandated local costs would not be subject to state reimbursement because local agencies have the authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees as necessary to cover administrative costs. Existing law authorizes planning and zoning fees to “include the costs reasonably necessary to prepare and revise the plans and policies that a local agency is required to adopt before it can make any necessary findings and determinations.” Case law and previous decisions by the Commission on State Mandates support the position that local governments’ planning costs are not reimbursable when the state imposes new planning mandates.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No. | AB 1633 | Hearing Date: | 7/12/2023 |
Author: | Ting | ||
Version: | 4/27/2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brynn Cook | ||
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
DIGEST: This bill adds two actions under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) –failing to determine if a project is exempt and failing to adopt or certify environmental review documents – to the definition of “disapproval” of a housing development project under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA). This allows persons to sue local agencies for these failings and seek a court order for the agency to comply with the HAA, which could include requiring the local agency to approve the project.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Under CEQA, a lead agency determines whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or if it must do an initial study to determine if a project will have significant effects on the environment. If a project has no effect on the environment or if it has effects that can be mitigated, the lead agency prepares a negative declaration (ND) or mitigated negative declaration (MND). If the project will have significant impacts, the lead agency prepares an environmental impact report (EIR) to evaluate and propose mitigation measures for any effects on the environment, including impacts or likely impacts to land, air, water, minerals, flora, fauna, ambient noise, and historic or aesthetic significance. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §§21000 et seq.)
- Authorizes judicial review of CEQA actions taken by public agencies, following the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR doesn't comply with CEQA, must be filed in the Superior Court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. Challenges alleging that a public agency has improperly determined that a project is not subject to CEQA must be filed within 35 days of the filing of the notice of exemption, or within 180 days of the agency’s approval of the project if no notice is filed. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. (PRC § 21167, et seq.)
- Creates numerous exemptions for residential projects, including:
- Small residential housing projects with low environmental impact that are for affordable agriculture, affordable urban, or urban infill housing projects. (PRC § 21159.20-21159.24)
- Mixed-use, and "employment center" projects located within "transit priority areas," if the project is consistent with an adopted specific plan or other planning document that aligns transportation and housing elements to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. (PRC § 21155.4)
- Multi-family residential and mixed-use housing projects on infill sites within cities and unincorporated areas that are within urbanized areas or urban clusters. (PRC § 21159.25)
- Establishes a ministerial approval process (i.e., not subject to CEQA) for certain multifamily affordable housing projects in local jurisdictions that have not met regional housing needs. Eligibility is contingent on labor standards and site specifics. (GC § 65913.4)
- Establishes the HAA (Government Code (GC) § 65589.5), which provides the following:
- That a local government must not disapprove or render infeasible a housing development project that includes 20% of its units for lower income households or all of its units for moderate-income households unless it makes written findings, supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, that specified conditions are met.
- That a local government must not disapprove or reduce the proposed density of a housing development project that does not meet affordability criteria, but complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, unless it makes specified written findings.
- That disapproval of a housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit; or
- Fails to comply with the time periods specified in the Permit Streamlining Act (PSA).
- Authorizes the applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project to bring an action to enforce this section; and if the court finds the local agency in violation of the HAA, a judge may order compliance with the HAA, including requiring the local agency to approve the project.
- Provides that a petition to enforce the HAA must be filed within 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods under the PSA.
- Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, except under extraordinary circumstances in which the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA.
- Permits the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to enforce the HAA, and authorizes HCD to refer violations of the HAA to the Attorney General.
- Provides that nothing in the HAA shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with CEQA.
- Defines “abuse of discretion” for purposes of CEQA (PRC 21168.5: “Abuse of discretion is established if the agency has not proceeded in a manner required by law or if the determination or decision is not supported by substantial evidence.”) and for writ proceedings generally (Code of Civil Procedure § (CCP) 1094.5)
This bill:
- Adds two actions under CEQA to the definition of “disapprove the housing development project” under the HAA. These two actions are:
- Failing to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or committing an “abuse of discretion.” Only projects in certain site specific criteria and failure to make a determination on certain timelines will fall under this definition.
- Failing to adopt a ND or addendum, failing to certify an EIR for the project or failing to approve another comparable environmental document, as required under CEQA. Only projects in certain site specific criteria and failure to make a determination on certain timelines, including that the public agency must make a decision in 90 days after an applicant has, with the option of extension, will fall under this definition.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney’s fees in cases concerning CEQA disapprovals if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
4) Makes the provisions of the HAA severable.
Background
- The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
- CEQA Process and timeline. A lead agency reviewing a project under CEQA takes three progressive steps of environmental review. First, a lead agency looks at the footprint of the project to determine if it can be exempted from CEQA. If it is not exempt, the lead agency then conducts an initial study to look at potential environmental impacts. If there are no significant environmental impacts, or if those impacts can be fully mitigated, the lead agency prepares an ND or MND. If there are environmental impacts that cannot be mitigated, the lead agency proceeds with the most extensive level of environmental review: a full EIR. The EIR is a comprehensive document that evaluates all the environmental impacts that a project might have, and proposes mitigation measures for impacts that have a significant effect on the environment.
Under CEQA, state and local agencies must complete and adopt a ND in 180 days, and certify an EIR within a year. If there is a compelling circumstance to extend this timeline, agencies may take longer, but only if the project applicant consents.
3) CEQA exemptions for housing. Projects are not subject to CEQA if they do not involve discretionary decisions (if they are ministerial projects). Projects can also be exempt from CEQA if they meet certain criteria. Statutory exemptions, those created by the Legislature, apply to a project even if a project has the potential to significantly affect the environment. In contrast, categorical exemptions, which are listed in the CEQA guidelines, generally do not apply if there are significant environmental impacts associated with the project.
Some eligible housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially, or by-right, require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety.
Recent legislation (SB 35, Wiener, 2017 and AB 2011 Wicks, 2022) has established a ministerial approval processes for affordable housing projects, in which CEQA review is waived for housing projects that meet high labor requirements and are located outside of specified sensitive sites.
In addition to these ministerial ‘CEQA bypasses’, there are now at least 14 distinct CEQA exemptions for housing projects. Each exemption includes specific requirements for prior planning-level review, as well as limitations on the location and characteristics of the site. These conditions are intended to prevent granting exemptions to projects that could have significant environmental impacts that go undisclosed and unmitigated.
Housing projects frequently use CEQA exemptions. One study surveyed jurisdictions that built over half of all housing units that were subject to CEQA review in California between 2015 -2017 found that of housing projects with 5+ units, 9.3% had exemptions, and 42.3% were eligible for streamlining or other exemptions. In comparison, of the the 144,111 housing units captured in this survey, just 5.6% underwent a full EIR.
- Motivation for AB 1633. According to information provided by the author, AB 1633 was motivated, in part, by a specific case in which a housing project was delayed due to an unusually lengthy CEQA review, 469 Stevenson Street project. In October 2021, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors (BOS) voted to overturn a final EIR certified by the City’s Planning Commission for a 495-unit housing project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the city, “the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified.” However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was definitively in violation of the HAA. Upon release of an updated EIR, in November 2022, HCD wrote another letter on the project, stating “The purpose of this letter is to express HCD’s support of the Project and to urge the City/County to approve the Project, which is protected by the Housing Accountability Act. Any further delay or additional conditions on the Project’s approval may subject the City to the HAA’s provisions regarding bad faith.” HCD’s letters suggest that current provisions of the HAA can be used to enforce, or at least threaten to enforce, unfavorable CEQA actions.
The 469 Stevenson Street project has since been approved by the San Francisco Planning Commission on April 20, 2023 and even received certification as an Environmental Leadership Development Project pursuant to SB 7 (Atkins), Chapter 19, Statutes of 2021, making it eligible for expedited judicial review.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.”
- Conflict Between CEQA and HAA. AB 1633 introduces a new potential conflict between CEQA and the HAA by allowing a project applicant to take a local agency to court before the agency has completed its CEQA review or administrative record. This measure allows the applicant to appeal a public agency’s action or inaction during the CEQA process. This gives project applicants a tool to take agencies to court if they are not getting the outcome they want on a CEQA case. In the case of an exemption, this bill lays out a path for the applicant to bring a HAA lawsuit based on an interim action (or inaction), before the record is complete, before administrative remedies are exhausted, and before the project has been approved or denied. HAA and CEQA should both be complementary and complete: this bill could cut short CEQA review under these new provisions of the HAA.
- CEQA Balancing Act. Implications of AB 1633. AB 1633 addresses the concern that CEQA can be misused to slow or block new housing based on motives other than identifying and mitigating significant impacts to the environment identified in CEQA review. Preventing this misuse of CEQA is important, but it can be challenging to accomplish while keeping the essentials of CEQA intact. In order for CEQA to accomplish its primary directive of providing information on environmental impacts to decision-makers and the community, it requires a process that allows for complete and sometimes iterative environmental review. Likewise, in order for CEQA litigation to be a useful tool for community members, there must be a low barrier of entry to bring CEQA lawsuits.
- Exemptions. AB 1633 could motivate locals to use existing, eligible CEQA exemptions for projects. Currently, public agencies may choose not to use CEQA exemptions for projects that meet the list criteria for those exemptions. This may be motivated by many reasons, including fear of invoking lawsuits contending that the CEQA exemption was applied incorrectly.
It is difficult to assess whether avoidance of CEQA exemptions is a significant issue, given that there is no “evidence of absence” on CEQA exemption applications. As discussed in the background section, housing projects with five or more units are more likely to use CEQA exemptions than undergo full EIRs. However, numerous sources report this as a serious policy issue. AB 1633 seeks to address this problem by pulling in the opposite direction: under the provisions of this bill, cities and counties could be subject to lawsuit if they opt to prepare CEQA documents like an EIR or MND rather than using an eligible CEQA exemption. However, the outcome of this policy may not be to create equal pressure for locals deciding whether or not to apply potential eligible CEQA exemptions, but instead to create more litigation from numerous directions for public agencies.
Moreover, the provisions in AB 1633 may skew, over the course of many projects, towards over-applying CEQA exemptions, as sought by developers, as opposed to under-applying CEQA exemptions, as primarily sought by community members, neighborhood groups, NIMBYs, advocates etc. The resources available to developers to bring lawsuits is likely to be greater than resources available to most community groups.
- Capping Environmental Review. Under AB 1633, public agencies could be sued under the HAA if they fail to make a decision on appropriate CEQA documents after they have had at least one meeting where they could have voted to adopt or certify the documents. The public agency has 90 days after an applicant notifies the local agency that they intend to sue under the HAA to finish their environmental review and make a decision on the CEQA documents. Imposing this new time limit will prevent public agencies from unduly prevaricating on making a decision on a project when the environmental review documents are ready. The trade-off of this policy is that in some cases this 90-day window may not be enough time to conduct a sufficiently thorough environmental review, as guaranteed under CEQA.
- Threading the Needle. AB 1633 seeks to ensure that locals are not under-apply CEQA exemptions or delaying projects by requiring unnecessary environmental review. At the same time, it introduces the potential to tip the scales in the opposite direction, leading to over-application of CEQA exemptions or limiting necessary environmental review. Given the uncertainty on whether or not the policies in AB 1633 will lead to inappropriate application of CEQA exemptions to projects, result in more lawsuits for locals, or create a situation where environmental review is cut short before approval of CEQA documents, it may be prudent to narrow the scope of the bill and add a sunset provision to evaluate the impact of this policy shift.
Currently, the bill only applies to certain areas, including infill sites, and excluding some habitats and high fire hazard severity zone. The definition of infill currently in the bill, however, does not capture the State objectives around infill to reduce VMTs. A narrower and more VMT-aligned definition of infill for CEQA purposes was evaluated in this committee in AB 1449 (Alvarez), which passed out of Senate Environmental Quality earlier this year.
Narrowing the application of this provision to certain infill sites and adding a seven-year sunset to the measure will limit the scope of the policy and allow the Legislature to evaluate whether this policy has resulted in the outcomes it is intended to produce—more application of exemptions—or if it has resulted in an excessive number of lawsuits against cities and counties from developers and decision making by public agencies without complete environmental review.
Suggested Amendment. The committee and author may wish to narrow the scope of AB 1633 to certain infill sites and add a seven year sunset to the provision, recognizing the substantial yet uncertain implications for CEQA lawsuits and review that may result from this policy.
- Limits to Recovery. AB 1633 would add a new specification that petitioners shall “rarely, if ever” be awarded attorney’s fees when challenging a housing development that meets the by-right right standards laid out in SB 35.
This policy begs the question: who is most likely to be deterred from bringing lawsuits if recovery of attorney fees is restricted? Advocacy groups and community groups often rely on pro-bono attorneys to bring CEQA lawsuits and are dependent on the option to recover attorney’s fees if they win the case. Preventing recovery in cases that challenged the application of the CEQA bypass in SB 35 could jeopardize advocacy and community groups’ ability to bring such cases.
- Committee amendments. Staff recommends the committee adopt the bolded amendments contained in comments 6 above.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was considered in the Senate Housing Committee on June 26, 2023
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2656 (Ting, 2022) was substantially similar to this bill. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 35 (Wiener Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) creates a streamlined, ministerial approval process for infill developments in specified sites and in localities that have failed to meet their regional housing needs assessment numbers.
AB 785 (Santiago, 2023) creates a CEQA exemption for transitional and affordable housing projects carried out by the City of Los Angeles, County of Los Angeles, or specified eligible public agencies in the City of Los Angeles until 2033. The bill is currently in the Senate Housing Committee.
AB 1449 (Alvarez, 2023) exempts from CEQA, until 2033, the planning, funding, and development of affordable housing projects that meet specified location and labor requirements. The bill is currently in the Senate Housing Committee.
SOURCE:
Bay Area Council (Co-Sponsor)
California Housing Partnership Corporation (Co-Sponsor)
California YIMBY (Co-Sponsor)
Housing Action Coalition (Co-Sponsor)
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR) (Co-Sponsor)
SUPPORT:
Abundant Housing LA
Bay Area Council
California Apartment Association
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
California Housing Partnership Corporation
California Yimby
Cbia
Civicwell
East Bay Yimby
Fieldstead and Company, INC.
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
Housing Action Coalition
How to Adu
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Midpen Housing
Mountain View Yimby
Napa-solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco Yimby
Santa Cruz Yimby
Santa Rosa Yimby
Slo County Yimby
South Bay Yimby
Southside Forward
Spur
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County Yimby
Yimby Action
OPPOSITION:
California Native Plant Society
Center for Biological Diversity
Endangered Habitats League
Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability
Planning and Conservation League
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
California Yimby writes in support, saying: “The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) ensures that any proposed development in the state maintains rigorous standards of environmental review and performance and minimizes impacts on human health and the environment. In addition to providing urgently needed housing to city residents, “infill” housing projects, or homes built in developed urban areas, typically result in improved environmental performance due to their more efficient land, energy, and water use, greater economies of scale for city infrastructure and services. State housing law recognizes these types of housing projects as environmentally beneficial, making them eligible for exemptions of environmental review through a process referred to as a “CEQA clearance.” Unfortunately, in a deliberate effort to delay or permanently block new housing projects, some jurisdictions demand additional CEQA review – beyond what is required for CEQA clearance.
The HBA is committed to supporting legislation that will rapidly and predictably increase housing production in our state and address our affordability and availability crisis. AB 1633 is a straightforward solution that will end local governments’ abuse of CEQA, blocking new housing developments that have already been found in compliance with local and state land use and environmental regulations.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The Planning and Conservation League and other environmental groups write in opposition to the bill, stating: “AB 1633 will expose cities and counties to meritless developer lawsuits. The bill will force cities and counties into the unenviable position of being exposed to potentially meritless developer lawsuits when cities/counties simply do what is required by CEQA and prepare a CEQA document for discretionary projects that have potential environmental impacts and are not otherwise exempt from CEQA. Under-resourced cities/counties may succumb to developer pressure and decide not to prepare a CEQA document due to the risk of litigation, or rush the process and conduct an inadequate review. Cities could also be sued simply for taking what a developer perceives as “too long” to prepare or amend a CEQA document. Decision-makers and the public would be deprived of an opportunity to participate in a thorough process and ensure that environmental impacts are analyzed and mitigated to the extent feasible.
The bill would give developers and project proponents the ability to sue a city/county if they disagree with a city/county’s decision to require preparation of a CEQA document such as a mitigated negative declaration, addendum, or environmental impact report. The developer or project proponent could sue—or simply threaten to sue—a city/county that is concerned about the environmental and public health impacts of a discretionary project and has determined that CEQA review is required to inform the decision-making process and ensure public participation. The risk of litigation and its attendant costs may pressure counties and cities—particularly smaller ones with less resources—to forgo necessary environmental review.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 1633 Hearing Date: 6/20/2023
Author: | Ting | ||
Version: | 4/27/2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alison Hughes | ||
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
DIGEST: This bill provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes a local agency's failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), abuse of discretion, or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires a local jurisdiction to give public notice of a hearing whenever a person applies for a zoning variance, special use permit, conditional use permit, zoning ordinance amendment, or general or specific plan amendment.
- Requires the board of zoning adjustment or zoning administrator to hear and decide applications for conditional uses or other permits when the zoning ordinance provides therefore and establishes criteria for determining those matters, and applications for variances from the terms of the zoning ordinance.
- Establishes CEQA, which generally requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects, and to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government.
- Prohibits a local agency, pursuant to the HAA, from disapproving a housing project containing units affordable to very low-, low- or moderate income renters, or conditioning the approval in a manner that renders the housing project infeasible, unless it makes one of the following findings, based upon substantial evidence in the record:
- The jurisdiction has adopted an updated housing element in substantial compliance with the law, and the jurisdiction met its share of the regional housing need for that income category.
- The project will have a specific, adverse impact on the public health or safety and there is no feasible method to mitigate or avoid the impact without rendering the housing development unaffordable to very low-, low- or moderate-income renters.
- The denial or imposition of conditions is required to comply with state or federal law.
- The project is located on agricultural or resource preservation land that does not have adequate water or wastewater facilities.
- The jurisdiction has identified sufficient and adequate sites to accommodate its share of the regional housing need and the project is inconsistent with both the general plan land use designation and the zoning ordinance.
- Defines “disapprove the housing development project” as any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building project.
- Fails to comply with specified time periods for approving or disapproving development projects.
This bill:
- Adds to the definition of “disapprove the housing development project” the following situations:
- Fails to meet timelines specified for the issuance of post-entitlement permits;
- Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA or commits an “abuse of discretion,” as specified, if all the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined;
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant, and if the exception is subject to a CEQA exception, there is substantial evidence in the record that the application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the specified exceptions.
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion and the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- The agency may extend the time period to make a lawful determination by no more than 90 days if the extension is necessary to determine if there is a substantial evidence that the housing development is eligible for the exemption sought by the applicant.
- If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision.
- If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicant’s notice shall be deemed timely if given after 60 days from the date on which the project application has been received and accepted as complete by the lead agency or 60 days from the date on which the project was deemed complete.
- Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project to certify an environmental impact report for the project or to approve another comparable environmental document, as required under CEQA, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence that the housing development is not located on specified environmentally sensitive sites;
- The housing development project is located within an urbanized area, as defined;
- The density of the housing development project meets or exceeds 15 units per acre;
- There has been prepared a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document, that if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of CEQA.
- The local agency which has the authority to adopt, approve, or certify the relevant environmental review document has held a meeting at which adoption, approval, or certification of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the document could have been adopted, approved, or certified, as applicable, but the agency committed an abuse of discretion or failed to decide whether to further study or to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental document.
- The applicant has given timely written to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice. The applicants notice shall identify the evidence in the record before the local agency, and if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, shall state the reasons why the agency’s action as an abuse of discretion.
- If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving or certifying the appropriate environmental review document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if and only if it was given 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision.
- If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the appropriate environmental document, the applicants notice shall be deemed timely if given after the specified review for specified documents has passed.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney's fees in cases concerning disapprovals within the meaning of 1) or 2) if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- Makes the provisions of the HAA severable.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. “The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.”
- HAA. In 1982, in response to the housing crisis, which was viewed as threatening the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California, the Legislature enacted the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), commonly referred to as the Anti-NIMBY Law. The purpose of the HAA is to help ensure that a city does not reject or make infeasible housing development projects that contribute to meeting the housing need determined pursuant to the Housing Element Law without a thorough analysis of the economic, social, and environmental effects of the action and without complying with the HAA. The HAA restricts a city’s ability to disapprove, or require density reductions in, certain types of residential projects. The HAA does not preclude a locality from imposing developer fees necessary to provide public services or requiring a housing development project to comply with objective standards, conditions, and policies appropriate to the localities share of the regional housing needs assessment.
If a locality denies approval or imposes conditions that have a substantial adverse effect on the viability or affordability of a housing development for very low-, low-, or moderate-income households, and the denial or imposition of conditions is subject to a court challenge, the burden is on the local government to show that its decision is consistent with specified written findings.
If a court finds that a locality violated the HAA, a court must issue an order or judgment compelling compliance with the HAA within 60 days, including but not limited to, an order that the locality take action on the housing development project or shelter. The plaintiff shall be entitled to attorney’s fees unless the court find that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA. If a locality fails to comply within 60 days, the court shall impose fines, a minimum of $10,000 per housing unit in the housing development project, which shall be deposited in a local housing trust fund. The court may also approve the housing development project. If the court finds the locality acted in bad faith, in addition to other remedies, the court shall multiply the fine by a factor of five.
- CEQA, exemptions, and ministerial approvals. CEQA applies when a development project requires discretionary approval from a local government agency. When a local agency has the discretion to approve a project, its CEQA evaluation begins with deciding whether an activity qualifies as a project subject to CEQA review. If an activity is deemed a “project,” the agency decides whether it is exempt from compliance with CEQA under either a statutory or a categorical exemption. Statutory exemptions are activities the Legislature has excluded from CEQA despite potential environmental impacts. If a project is statutorily exempt, it can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation.
In addition to statutory exemptions, the Legislature specifically directed the Secretary of the California Natural Resources Agency to designate categorical exemptions from CEQA. Categorical exemptions include projects that the Secretary deems do not have a significant impact on the environment. The CEQA Guidelines, set forth in the California Code of Regulations, set forth more than two dozen categorical exemptions covering a wide range of projects, from minor alterations of existing facilities to construction of certain types of buildings. As with statutory exemptions, if the project is categorically exempt, no formal evaluation is required, and the project can be implemented without a CEQA evaluation. Despite the creation of new by-right and development streamlining measures that bypass the CEQA process, if a city chooses not to grant the permits – in violation of state law – a developer’s only recourse is to sue.
Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. In addition, before building new housing, housing developers must obtain one or more permits from local planning departments and must also obtain approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially, or by-right, require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to review under the CEQA, while projects permitted ministerially generally are not.
- Ambiguities in the HAA related to CEQA. The HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible by requiring extended environmental analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
- 469 Stevenson Street. In 2021 in San Francisco, the Board of Supervisors (BOS) required a 500-unit downtown project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops to undertake additional studies related to the project's EIR. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the local government, "the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified." However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was in violation of the HAA.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to "disapprove the housing development project" in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion in that determination; and
- When a local agency fails to either require further study or adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an EIR, or approve another environmental document for the project, or commits an abuse of discretion in that instance.
By adding these two criteria to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
The bill only applies to projects that meet the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017 must meet, which eliminates many of the state's most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in high or very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California's statewide housing production needs.
The bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney's fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. The bill states the intent of the Legislature is that attorney's fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
- Opposition. The State Building and Construction Trades Council are opposed to a prior version of the bill, stating the bill gives developers a shortcut to court. They are also concerned that this bill will “undermines the ability of Californians to have a voice in the environmental outcome and decision-making process of projects that impact their health and their communities by violating basic public participation mandates.
- Double referral. This bill was also referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
Related Legislation:
AB 2656 (Ting, 2022) — was substantially similar to this bill. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
SB 167 (Skinner, Chapter 368, Statutes of 2017) — made a number of changes to the HAA to ensure local agency compliance during the approval process for proposed housing developments. The measure also clarified existing provisions of the HAA and imposed added penalties on agencies that violate the HAA without proper findings.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 14, 2023.)
SUPPORT:
Bay Area Council (Co-Sponsor)
California Housing Partnership Corporation (Co-Sponsor)
California YIMBY (Co-Sponsor)
Housing Action Coalition (Co-Sponsor)
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR) (Co-Sponsor)
Abundant Housing LA
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association (CBIA)
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
Civicwell
Council of Infill Builders
East Bay for Everyone
East Bay YIMBY
Fieldstead and Company, INC.
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
How to ADU
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Midpen Housing
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County YIMBY
Westside for Everyone
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION:
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1633
Author:(Ting)
As Amended Ver:April 27, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes a local agency's failure to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), abuse of discretion, or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes.
Major Provisions
- Expands the HAA's definition of "disapproval of a housing development project" to mean any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located on a site ineligible for the streamlined, ministerial approval process established by SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, or on a site within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone;
- The project is located within an urbanized area, as specified;
- The density of the project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre;
- Both of the following criteria are met:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant; and
- If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of CEQA, as specified, there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that application of that categorical exemption is not barred by one of the exceptions identified in the guidelines; and
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination that the project is exempt and that the local agency did not make a lawful determination within 90 days of the applicant's written notice. The applicant's written notice must identify the evidence in the record that satisfies 1) a) through 1) d) above, and, if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, must state the reasons why the agency's action was an abuse of discretion.
- Provides that 1) does not require a local agency to determine that a project is exempt if, on the record before the local agency, the project is not eligible for the exemption.
- Expands the HAA's definition of "disapproval of a housing development project" to mean any instance in which a local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for a project, fails to certify an environmental impact report (EIR) for the project, or fails to approve another comparable environmental document such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is not located on a site ineligible for the streamlined, ministerial approval process established by SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017, or on a site within a high or very high fire hazard severity zone;
- The project is located within an urbanized area, as specified;
- The density of the project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre;
- A negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document has been prepared that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of CEQA with respect to the project;
- The local agency or a body or official has held a meeting at which adoption of the environmental review document was on the agenda and the document could have been adopted or certified, but the agency did either of the following:
- Committed an abuse of discretion; or
- Failed to decide whether to require further study or adopt, approve, or certify the environmental review document.
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to decide or an abuse of discretion, and the local agency did not make a lawful determination about whether to adopt, approve, or certify the document within 90 days of the applicant's written notice. The applicant's written notice must identify the evidence in the record that satisfies 2) a) through 2) d) above, and if the applicant asserts that the local agency committed an abuse of discretion, must state the reasons why that action was an abuse of discretion.
- Provides that the inclusion of a local agency's failure to meet time limits specified in existing law in the definition of "disapproval of a housing development project" must not be construed to require a local agency to approve an exemption for a project that, on the record before the local agency, is not exempt from CEQA.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney's fees in cases concerning disapprovals within the meaning of 1) or 2) if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney's fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency's approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency's approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- States the intent of the Legislature that attorney's fees and costs must rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development that satisfies certain site location and density criteria, as specified.
- Makes the provisions of the HAA severable.
- Provides that no reimbursement is required by the bill.
COMMENTS
CEQA and Housing: CEQA requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed changes to the physical environment, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. If a development project would make significant negative changes to the physical environment, and those impacts could not be mitigated, CEQA requires that the governmental entity approving the project to make findings that justify why the change is merited despite its environmental impact. CEQA provides multiple opportunities for public involvement, and enables members of the public to sue a governmental entity that they believe did not properly follow the process.
For housing projects, it can be complicated to untangle and assess the possible impacts a new development might have on the variety of aspects CEQA requires local governments to look at. Development inevitably causes new impacts and patterns of activity that differ from the baseline status quo on a site. CEQA calls for careful deliberation of every possible environmental impact, and requires exhaustive analysis if there is a fair argument that a project might have a significant impact on any number of criteria. Infill housing, by its nature, is located in places where there are existing uses on adjacent sites, meaning there will always be neighbors or others nearby who become aware of the development – a significant contrast with sprawl developments that are proposed on agricultural land or in other areas where there are simply very few neighbors or no existing communities interested in raising CEQA challenges. In essence, CEQA gives local governments and the public procedural deference to request that exhaustive analysis, even when it is not always warranted. Some local agencies conduct redundant environmental review to avoid CEQA lawsuits from neighbors or interest groups at best, or to delay a project indefinitely in the hopes of shrinking or killing it at worst.
The HAA and CEQA: The first provisions of the HAA state: "The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California…Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects." (Government Code 65589.5(a)(1))
The HAA requires local governments to approve housing development projects that are consistent with their objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards, unless the developments pose a risk to public health and safety that cannot be addressed without denying projects or reducing their size. The HAA also facilitates timely decision making by using the established timeframes of the Permit Streamlining Act. The HAA generally puts the burden of proof on the local agency to demonstrate that its decisions meet the HAA's requirements. Finally, the HAA facilitates private enforcement of these provisions.
As described, the HAA and CEQA take different approaches to housing development. The intersection of these two Acts therefore can result in gray areas or conflict. For example, the HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction's zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues that cannot be mitigated. The HAA explicitly states that it does not restrict the authority of a public agency to require mitigation measures under CEQA. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible or unreasonably delays it by requiring CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
469 Stevenson Street: In 2021 in San Francisco, the Board of Supervisors (BOS) required a 500-unit downtown project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops to undertake additional studies related to the project's EIR. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the local government, "the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified." However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was in violation of the HAA.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to "disapprove the housing development project" in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency fails to make a determination of whether a project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion in that determination; and
- When a local agency fails to either require further study or adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, certify an EIR, or approve another environmental document for the project, or commits an abuse of discretion in that instance.
By adding these two criteria to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
The bill only applies to projects that meet the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017 must meet, which eliminates many of the state's most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in high or very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California's statewide housing production needs.
The bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney's fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. The bill states the intent of the Legislature that attorney's fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
According to the Author
"The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA."
Arguments in Support
According to the Bay Area Council, a cosponsor, "The Council agrees that environmental protection is an important endeavor, but as it operates against infill housing, this law is having effects that harm the environment. Infill housing is the most powerful policy tool we have to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, something that CEQA implicitly fails to recognize by giving this veto power to local governments. AB 1633 establishes that a city that wrongfully denies a project by laundering the denial through the false pretenses of environmental review will be subject to the same penalties that would apply if the city illegally denied the project by other means. This bill still allows the normal CEQA and environmental review process, and, by creating a punishment for non-environmental denials, the bill implicitly strengthens CEQA as an environmental law."
Arguments in Opposition
The Planning and Conservation League and the Center for Biological Diversity raise a number of concerns, including that the bill was prompted by two isolated incidents of infill projects being required to undergo additional review, it could open up local governments to frivolous litigation if a developer disagrees with the decision to require preparation of a CEQA document, and it does not contain exceptions for moderate fire hazard severity zones, which they contend still have significant wildfire risk.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing General Fund (GF) costs of $474,000 annually for two additional staff positions with specific knowledge of implementation of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle the Housing Accountability Unit cases that invoke these new provisions, including making determinations of HCDs opinions on the legal sufficiency of the environmental studies and issuing notice of violations and referrals to the Attorney General's (AG's) office.
- Cost pressures (Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount, but potentially significant, for trial courts to hear and adjudicate civil actions for new alleged violations of the HAA. In addition to cases referred to the AG by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. If 10 cases are filed in civil court annually requiring seven to ten days (56 to 80 hours) of court time, at an average cost per hour of $1,000 in workload costs, the cost to the trial courts would be between $560,000 and $800,000 annually. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund and staff workload may create a need for increased funding for courts from the GF to perform existing duties.
- Local costs resulting from this bill are not reimbursable by the state because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses.
VOTES
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 8-0-0
YES: Wicks, Joe Patterson, Wendy Carrillo, Gabriel, Kalra, Quirk-Silva, Sanchez, Ward
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 8-0-3
YES: Luz Rivas, Flora, Friedman, Hoover, Mathis, Pellerin, Ward, Wood
ABS, ABST OR NV: Addis, Muratsuchi, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: April 27, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0000483
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1633
Author:(Ting) – As Amended Ver:April 27, 2023
Policy Committee: | Housing and Community Development | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Natural Resources | 8 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill adds failing to determine if a project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and failing to adopt an environmental impact report (EIR) in a timely manner to the list of actions taken by a local agency to “disapprove the housing development project” under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA).
Specifically, this bill:
Adds the following actions by a local agency, pursuant to CEQA, to the HAA definition of “disapprove the housing development project:”
- Failing to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion.
- Failing to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document.
- For purposes of CEQA-related disapprovals, requires a housing development project to meet specified requirements and limitations, including the project is not on a list of excluded sites, is located within an urbanized area, or has a density of at least 15 units per acre, and there is substantial evidence in the record to support such a CEQA determination.
- Requires the applicant to give timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion, so the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined, within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- Redefines the established definitions of “abuse of discretion” for purposes of CEQA determinations.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney’s fees in cases concerning CEQA disapprovals if the court finds the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides, upon any motion for an award of attorney’s fees, a court must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency’s approval furthers specified policies of the HAA when weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate.
- States the intent of the Legislature that attorney’s fees and costs must rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development that satisfies certain site location and density criteria.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates ongoing General Fund (GF) costs of $474,000 annually for two additional staff positions with specific knowledge of implementation of environmental law and CEQA analysis to handle the Housing Accountability Unit cases that invoke these new provisions, including making determinations of HCDs opinions on the legal sufficiency of the environmental studies and issuing notice of violations and referrals to the Attorney General’s (AG’s) office.
- Cost pressures (Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount, but potentially significant, for trial courts to hear and adjudicate civil actions for new alleged violations of the HAA. In addition to cases referred to the AG by HCD to enforce violations of the HAA, eligible litigants include project applicants, persons who would be eligible to reside in a proposed development, and specified housing organizations. If 10 cases are filed in civil court annually requiring seven to ten days (56 to 80 hours) of court time, at an average cost per hour of $1,000 in workload costs, the cost to the trial courts would be between $560,000 and $800,000 annually. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund and staff workload may create a need for increased funding for courts from the GF to perform existing duties.
- Local costs resulting from this bill are not reimbursable by the state because local agencies have general authority to charge and adjust planning and permitting fees to cover their administrative expenses.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The Legislature first passed the HAA in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. [This bill] requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.
- Background. The HAA requires a local government to approve a housing development project that is consistent with its objective general plan and zoning and subdivision standards, unless the project poses a risk to public health and safety that cannot be addressed without denying the project or reducing its size. The HAA also facilitates timely decision making by using the established timeframes of the Permit Streamlining Act. The HAA also facilitates private enforcement of these provisions.
CEQA requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed developments, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. If a development project would make significant negative changes to the physical environment, and those changes could not be mitigated, CEQA requires the governmental entity approving the project to make findings that justify why the project is merited despite its environmental impact. CEQA provides multiple opportunities for public involvement, and enables members of the public to sue a governmental entity they believe has not properly followed the process.
Under the HAA, a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues. Housing builders point to instances where a local government may not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders the project infeasible by requiring CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
This bill remedies this situation by specifying that the wrongful denial or withholding of a CEQA clearance to which a housing development is legally entitled violates the HAA. This gives a plaintiff access to the legal remedies provided in the HHA, including the ability to sue a local agency the plaintiff believes is using CEQA delay as a means to disapprove or downsize a project without having voted to do so.
- Arguments in Support. According to the California Housing Partnership, a cosponsor:
Many providers of affordable housing have been denied CEQA exemptions for which their developments are eligible or have been subject to a full environmental impact report when a mitigated negative declaration is appropriate. In most cases, these local government actions reflect discriminatory community opposition and result in years of delay as well as significant additional costs at the public’s expense. [This bill] codifies HCD’s guidance on this matter and holds local governments accountable to their duty to facilitate the development of affordable homes. It will also serve to increase certainty and decrease the time and cost of producing new affordable homes.
- Arguments in Opposition. The State Building and Construction Trades Council, writes in opposition:
The bill’s purpose is to create a litigation tool for developers to challenge state and local agencies’ decisions to conduct an environmental review before the environmental review is complete. In doing so, the bill weakens the environmental protection and public participation mandates of CEQA, conflicts with multiple laws, elevates private developers’ interests over the rights of the public, and puts decision-making in the hands of the courts, instead of the agencies with jurisdiction over the project. [This bill] would increase litigation costs and open the door to agencies paying developers attorneys’ fees and fines under the HAA, just for complying with CEQA. This is inconsistent with the purposes of both laws and would not further the State’s housing goals.
- Prior Legislation. AB 2656 (Ting) of the 2021-22 Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 2656 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Luz Rivas, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1633 (
Author:Ting) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2023
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
SUMMARY: Adds two actions under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review process – failing to determine if a project is exempt and failing to adopt an environmental review document – to the definition of “disapproval” of a housing development project under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA), creating a private right of action under the HAA to sue a local agency over these CEQA actions and seek a court order to comply with the HAA, including requiring the local agency to approve the project.
EXISTING LAW:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA. CEQA includes several statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines, for housing projects. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 21000, et seq.)
- Authorizes judicial review of CEQA actions taken by public agencies, following the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR doesn't comply with CEQA, must be filed in the Superior Court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. Challenges alleging that a public agency has improperly determined that a project is not subject to CEQA must be filed within 35 days of the filing of the notice of exemption, or within 180 days of the agency’s approval of the project if no notice is filed. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. (PRC 21167, et seq.)
- Establishes the HAA (Government Code (GC) 65589.5), which provides the following:
- That a local government must not disapprove or render infeasible a housing development project that includes 20% of its units for lower income households or all of its units for moderate-income households unless it makes written findings, supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, that specified conditions are met.
- That a local government must not disapprove or reduce the proposed density of a housing development project that does not meet affordability criteria, but complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, unless it makes specified written findings.
- That disapproval of a housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit; or
- Fails to comply with the time periods specified in the Permit Streamlining Act (PSA).
- Authorizes the applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization to bring an action to enforce this section; and if the court finds the local agency in violation of the HAA, a judge may order compliance with the HAA, including requiring the local agency to approve the project.
- Provides that a petition to enforce the HAA must be filed within 90 days from the later of (1) the effective date of a decision of the local agency imposing conditions on, disapproving, or any other final action on a housing development project or (2) the expiration of the time periods under the PSA.
- Requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of suit to the plaintiff or petitioner, except under extraordinary circumstances in which the court finds that awarding fees would not further the purposes of the HAA.
- Permits the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to enforce the HAA, and authorizes HCD to refer violations of the HAA to the Attorney General.
- Provides that nothing in the HAA shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with CEQA.
- Establishes the PSA, which, among other things, establishes time limits within which state and local government agencies must either approve or disapprove permits. (GC 65920)
- Defines “abuse of discretion” for purposes of CEQA (PRC 21168.5: “Abuse of discretion is established if the agency has not proceeded in a manner required by law or if the determination or decision is not supported by substantial evidence.”) and for writ proceedings generally (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) 1094.5: e.g., “Abuse of discretion is established if the respondent has not proceeded in the manner required by law, the order or decision is not supported by the findings, or the findings are not supported by the evidence.”)
THIS BILL:
- Adds local agency actions, and inactions, pursuant to CEQA to the HAA definition of “disapprove the housing development project.” Specifically, this bill adds:
- Fails to make a determination of whether the project is exempt from CEQA, or commits an abuse of discretion; and,
- Fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, to certify an environmental impact report for the project, or to approve another comparable environmental document.
- For purposes of CEQA-related disapprovals, requires a housing development project to meet specified requirements and limitations, including the project is not on a list of excluded sites, is located within an urbanized area, has a density of at least 15 units per acre, and there is substantial evidence in the record to support the CEQA determination.
- Requires the applicant to give timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination or an abuse of discretion and the local agency did not make a lawful determination, as defined, within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- Redefines the established definitions of “abuse of discretion” for purposes of CEQA determinations as follows:
- For purposes of exemption determinations, defines “abuse of discretion” as the local agency determines not proceed to determine that the project is exempt or issue a notice of exemption when a project has satisfied the relevant conditions in the bill.
- For purposes of environmental document approvals, defines “abuse of discretion” as either of the following:
- If the local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration, “abuse of discretion” means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting the negative declaration.
- If the local agency fails to adopt an addendum for the project, certify an environmental impact report for the project, or approve another comparable environmental document, “abuse of discretion” means that the agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record that further environmental study is legally required to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the environmental review document.
- Defines “lawful determination” as any final decision about whether to approve or disapprove an exemption, or a negative declaration, addendum, environmental impact report, or comparable environmental review document under CEQA that is not an abuse of discretion, as defined.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney’s fees in cases concerning CEQA disapprovals if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney’s fees, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency’s approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- States the intent of the Legislature that attorney’s fees and costs must rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development that satisfies certain site location and density criteria, as specified.
- Adds a severability clause to the HAA.
- Makes related findings.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
The Legislature first passed the HAA in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.
- The poster child: 469 Stevenson Street. In October 2021, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors (BOS) voted to overturn a final EIR certified by the City’s Planning Commission for a 495-unit housing project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the city, “the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified.” However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was definitively in violation of the HAA.
Upon release of an updated EIR, in November 2022, HCD wrote another letter on the project, stating “The purpose of this letter is to express HCD’s support of the Project and to urge the City/County to approve the Project, which is protected by the Housing Accountability Act. Any further delay or additional conditions on the Project’s approval may subject the City to the HAA’s provisions regarding bad faith.” HCD’s letters suggest that current provisions of the HAA can be used to enforce, or at least threaten to enforce, unfavorable CEQA actions.
The 469 Stevenson Street project was approved by the San Francisco Planning Commission on April 20, 2023. The project was also recently certified as an Environmental Leadership Development Project pursuant to SB 7 (Atkins), Chapter 19, Statutes of 2021, which provides for expedited judicial review.
- In some cases, the 90-day shot clock may not permit completion of legitimate CEQA review. Notwithstanding the existing requirement that nothing in the HAA “shall be construed to relieve the local agency from complying with CEQA,” this bill sets up a conflict between CEQA and the HAA, allowing a project applicant to take a local agency to court before the agency’s CEQA review, and the administrative record, may be complete. This seems to be the point of the bill – to allow the applicant to call the question, and appeal the agency’s action or inaction to court, if they aren’t getting the result they want. While the bill includes conditions to protect the agency and provide a defense in court, those conditions don’t prevent the applicant from filing a HAA lawsuit before the agency’s CEQA process is complete. Particularly in the case of an exemption, this bill lays out a path for the applicant to bring a HAA lawsuit based on an interim action (or inaction), before the record is complete, before administrative remedies are exhausted, and before the project has been approved or denied.
- Prior legislation. AB 2656 (Ting, 2022) was similar to this bill, enabling HAA lawsuits challenging an agency’s action to deny a CEQA exemption or require further environmental study. AB 2656 passed this committee last April, but was later held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- Double referral. This bill passed the Housing and Community Development Committee on April 12 by a vote of 8-0.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Abundant Housing LA
Bay Area Council
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
California YIMBY
CBIA
Civicwell
Council of Infill Builders
East Bay for Everyone
East Bay YIMBY
Fieldstead and Company
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
Housing Action Coalition
How to ADU
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
MidPen Housing
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing - Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR)
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County YIMBY
Westside for Everyone
YIMBY Action
Opposition
Center for Biological Diversity
Planning and Conservation League
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: April 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1633 (
Author:Ting) – As Introduced Ver:February 17, 2023
SUBJECT: Housing Accountability Act: disapprovals: California Environmental Quality Act
SUMMARY: Provides that a disapproval under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) includes failure to issue an exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) or failure to adopt certain environmental documents under specified circumstances, and makes several other changes. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands the HAA’s definition of disapproval of a housing development project to mean any instance in which a local agency fails to make a determination that a project is exempt from CEQA if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project satisfies the siting requirements of the streamlined, ministerial approval process established by SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017), except for a project in a very high fire hazard severity zone;
- The project is located within an urbanized area, as specified;
- The density of the project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre;
- Both of the following criteria are met:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project is eligible for an exemption sought by the applicant; and
- If the exemption sought by the applicant is subject to an exception under the Guidelines for Implementation of CEQA, as specified, there is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the exception does not apply to the project; and
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to make a determination that the project is exempt and that the local agency did not approve the exemption within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- If the local agency has voted to deny the exemption, the applicant’s notice is deemed timely if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision.
- If the local agency has not taken action on the exemption, the applicant’s notice is deemed timely if 30 days have passed since the application was received and accepted as complete by the lead agency, unless the lead agency and the applicant agree to extend that determination period by 15 days, as specified.
- Expands the HAA’s definition of disapproval of a housing development project to mean any instance in which a local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for a project, fails to certify an EIR for the project, or fails to approve another comparable environmental document such as a sustainable communities environmental assessment, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- There is substantial evidence in the record before the local agency that the housing development project satisfies the siting requirements of the streamlined, ministerial approval process established by SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017), except for a development in a very high fire hazard severity zone, unless the development is on a site where at least 75 percent of the perimeter of the site adjoins parcels that are developed with urban uses, as specified;
- The project is located within an urbanized area, as specified;
- The density of the project meets or exceeds 15 dwelling units per acre;
- A negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document has been prepared that, if duly adopted, approved, or certified by the local agency, would satisfy the requirements of CEQA with respect to the project;
- The agency, in bad faith or without substantial evidence in the record to support a fair argument that further environmental study is necessary to identify or analyze potentially significant impacts on the physical environment, did either of the following at a meeting at which an environmental review document was on the agenda and could have been adopted:
- Decided to require further environmental study rather than adopting a negative declaration, adopting an addendum for the project, certifying an EIR for the project, or approving another comparable environmental document; or
- Failed to decide whether to require further study or adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration or other environmental review document.
- The applicant has given timely written notice to the local agency of the action or inaction that the applicant believes constitutes a failure to adopt, approve, or certify the negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document, and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify the document within 90 days of the applicant’s written notice.
- If the local agency has voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agency’s consideration, the applicant’s notice is deemed timely if and only if it is given within 35 days of being notified of the agency’s decision;
- If the local agency has not voted to require further study, rather than adopting, approving, or certifying the negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document in the form it was presented for the agency’s consideration, the applicant’s notice is deemed timely if it is given after the time period established by the local agency pursuant to specified law for completing the document has passed. If specified law does not specifically describe the deadline to complete the applicable environmental document, a 180-day deadline is the applicable time period.
- Limits the ability of a court to award attorney’s fees in cases concerning disapprovals within the meaning of 1) or 2) if the court finds that the local agency acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to disapprove the project due to the existence of a controlling question of law about the application of CEQA or implementing guidelines as to which there was a substantial ground for difference of opinion at the time of the disapproval.
- Specifies that, for purposes of the provisions relating to how actions must be brought to enforce the HAA, the following applies:
- A local agency’s failure to issue an exemption from CEQA is deemed “final” if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency, as specified in 1)e); and
- A local agency’s failure to adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document pursuant to CEQA is deemed “final” if the applicant gave timely written notice to the local agency, as specified in 2)f), and the local agency did not adopt, approve, or certify a negative declaration, addendum, EIR, or comparable environmental review document within 90 days of the applicant’s notice.
- Provides that, upon any motion for an award of attorney’s fees pursuant to specified law, in a case challenging a local agency’s approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, must give due weight to the degree to which the local agency’s approval furthers specified policies of the HAA.
- States the intent of the Legislature that attorney’s fees and costs must rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development that satisfies certain site location and density criteria, as specified.
- Makes the provisions of the HAA severable, such that if any provision of the HAA or its application is held invalid, that invalidity will not affect other provisions or applications that can be given without the invalid provision or application.
- Provides that no reimbursement is required by this bill pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, pursuant to existing law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes CEQA, which includes the following:
- That state and local government agencies are required to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects that would result in changes to the physical environment, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. This process includes multiple opportunities for public input;
- That the type of the analysis is dependent upon the potential impact to the physical environment, as determined by the government agency, including that:
- Projects with no impact or beneficial impacts, and that qualify for a specified exemption, may be exempt from environmental review;
- Projects with less than significant impacts to the environment, with or without mitigation, may conduct an Initial Study; and
- Project with impacts to the environment that cannot be mitigated to a less than significant level must undertake an Environmental Impact Report.
- The government agency, upon completion of the environmental analysis, must adopt the findings of the environmental analysis before approving the project. (Public Resources Code Sections 21000-21189.70.10 and Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations)
- Establishes the HAA, which provides the following:
- A local government must not disapprove or render infeasible a housing development project that includes 20 percent of its units for lower income households or all of its units for moderate-income households unless it makes written findings, supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, that specified conditions are met. These specified conditions include that:
- The city or county has met its share of the regional housing needs for that planning period for lower or moderate-income households;
- The project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety, and there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific adverse impact without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households;
- The denial of the housing development project or imposition of conditions is required in order to comply with specific state or federal law, and there is no feasible method to comply without rendering the development unaffordable to low- and moderate-income households; and
- The jurisdiction has a substantially compliant housing element, and the development project is inconsistent with both the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan land use designation. (Government Code (GC) Section 65589.5(d)-(h))
- A local government must not disapprove or reduce the proposed density of a housing development project that does not meet the affordability criteria described in a), but complies with applicable, objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards in effect at the time that the application was deemed complete, unless it makes written findings, supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, that both of the following conditions are met:
- The housing development project would have a specific, adverse impact upon the public health or safety unless the project is disapproved or approved upon the condition that the project be developed at a lower density; and
- There is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the identified adverse impact other than the disapproval of the housing development project or the approval of the project upon the condition that it be developed at a lower density. (GC 65589.5(j)(1))
- Disapproval of a housing development project includes any instance in which a local agency does either of the following:
- Votes on a proposed housing development project application and the application is disapproved, including any required land use approvals or entitlements necessary for the issuance of a building permit; or
- Fails to comply with the time periods specified in the Permit Streamlining Act. (GC 65589.5(h)(6))
- Regarding enforcement, that:
- The applicant, a person who would be eligible to apply for residency in the housing development project or emergency shelter, or a housing organization may bring an action to enforce the HAA; and
- If the court finds the local agency in violation of the HAA, a judge may order compliance with the HAA, including requiring the local agency to approve the project. (GC 65589.5(k)(1)(A)(i))
- A local government must not disapprove or render infeasible a housing development project that includes 20 percent of its units for lower income households or all of its units for moderate-income households unless it makes written findings, supported by a preponderance of the evidence in the record, that specified conditions are met. These specified conditions include that:
- Permits the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to enforce the HAA, including that they may refer violations of the HAA to the Attorney General. (GC 65585)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “The Legislature first passed the Housing Accountability Act (HAA) in 1982 to limit the ability of local agencies to deny qualifying housing projects from being built in their jurisdiction. Over the past several years, the Legislature has strengthened the HAA and, in response, some cities resorted to far-fetched arguments to deny valid CEQA clearances to projects the HAA protects. For example, agencies have used redundant environmental review to delay a project from being built to the point that the project is no longer economically feasible. AB 1633 requires local agencies to exercise their responsibilities to approve housing projects under CEQA in good faith or be in violation of the HAA.”
CEQA and Housing: CEQA requires state and local government agencies to inform decision makers and the public about the potential environmental impacts of proposed changes to the physical environment, and to reduce those environmental impacts to the extent feasible. If a development project would make significant negative changes to the physical environment, and those impacts could not be mitigated, CEQA requires that the governmental entity approving the project to make findings that justify why the change is merited despite its environmental impact. CEQA provides multiple opportunities for public involvement, and enables members of the public to sue a governmental entity that they believe did not properly follow the process.
For housing projects, it can be complicated to untangle and assess the possible impacts a new development might have on the variety of aspects CEQA requires local governments to look at. Development inevitably causes new impacts and patterns of activity that differ from the baseline status quo on a site. CEQA calls for careful deliberation of every possible environmental impact, and requires exhaustive analysis if there is a fair argument that a project might have a significant impact on any number of criteria. Infill housing, by its nature, is located in places where there are existing uses on adjacent sites, meaning there will always be neighbors or others nearby who become aware of the development – a significant contrast with sprawl developments that are proposed on agricultural land or in other areas where there are simply very few neighbors or no existing communities interested in raising CEQA challenges. In essence, CEQA gives local governments and the public procedural deference to request that exhaustive analysis, even when it is not always warranted. Some local agencies conduct redundant environmental review to avoid CEQA lawsuits from neighbors or interest groups at best, or to delay a project indefinitely in the hopes of shrinking or killing it at worst.
The HAA and CEQA: The first provisions of the HAA state: “The lack of housing, including emergency shelters, is a critical problem that threatens the economic, environmental, and social quality of life in California…Many local governments do not give adequate attention to the economic, environmental, and social costs of decisions that result in disapproval of housing development projects, reduction in density of housing projects, and excessive standards for housing development projects.” (GC 65589.5(a)(1))
The HAA requires local governments to approve housing development projects that are consistent with their objective general plan, zoning, and subdivision standards, unless the developments pose a risk to public health and safety that cannot be addressed without denying projects or reducing their size. The HAA also facilitates timely decision making by using the established timeframes of the Permit Streamlining Act. The HAA generally puts the burden of proof on the local agency to demonstrate that its decisions meet the HAA’s requirements. Finally, the HAA facilitates private enforcement of these provisions.
As described, the HAA and CEQA take different approaches to housing development. The intersection of these two Acts therefore can result in gray areas or conflict. For example, the HAA requires that a local government cannot disapprove a housing development project that is consistent with the jurisdiction’s zoning ordinance and general plan designation, unless the preponderance of evidence shows that certain conditions are met, such as the project would cause health and safety issues that cannot be mitigated. The HAA explicitly states that it does not restrict the authority of a public agency to require mitigation measures under CEQA. However, it is unclear what happens when a local government does not directly deny a project, but instead effectively renders it infeasible or unreasonably delays it by requiring CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project.
469 Stevenson Street: In 2021 in San Francisco, the Board of Supervisors (BOS) required a 500-unit downtown project on a parking lot near multiple major transit stops to undertake additional studies related to the project’s EIR. According to a November 2021 letter from HCD to the local government, “the BOS cited various vague concerns about EIR deficiencies, including seismic concerns, effects (e.g., shadowing) on historic resources, and gentrification. It appears that the BOS has tasked city planners to prepare a new environmental study and recirculate the EIR or portions of the EIR. To date, no written findings have been published or provided to the project applicant nor has any substantial evidence in support of these findings been identified.”[1] However, the letter stopped short of stating that San Francisco was definitively in violation of the HAA.
This bill attempts to settle the law regarding what happens when a local government requires CEQA analysis beyond what the courts may consider sufficient to make a reasonable determination of the environmental implications of a project. It does so by adding, to the definition of what it means to “disapprove the housing development project” in the HAA, the following two instances:
- When a local agency denies or fails to take action on an exemption from CEQA for which the project is eligible; and
- When a local agency fails to adopt a negative declaration or addendum for the project, fails to certify an EIR, or fails to approve another comparable environmental document for the project in bad faith or without sufficient evidence that continued environmental review is necessary for the project.
By adding these two instances to the HAA, plaintiffs could utilize the legal remedies in the HAA to sue local agencies that utilize CEQA delays as a means to disapprove, render financially infeasible, or downsize a project without having actually voted to do so.
The bill only applies to projects that meet many of the environmental criteria that projects under SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) must meet, which eliminates many of the state’s most environmentally sensitive areas: the coastal zone, prime farmland, wetlands, hazardous waste sites, flood hazard areas, habitat for protected species, and others. It further exempts projects in very high fire hazard severity zones. The bill is also limited to specified urbanized areas, and only applies to projects with a density of at least 15 units/acre, meaning low-density sprawl developments would not be covered by these enhanced HAA protections. Finally, the local government must have required additional environmental study in bad faith or without substantial evidence. These provisions are narrowly tailored to ensure the new disapproval criteria only applies to environmentally beneficial projects that are in the right locations, at the right densities, and where local governments have specifically acted counter to California’s statewide housing production needs.
The bill also provides some additional protections for local governments who have been sued by neighbors or interest groups for approving a housing development project. In certain circumstances where plaintiffs in such a suit challenging a housing approval are seeking the award of attorney’s fees, the court would be charged with carefully considering various priorities in the HAA, the suitability of the site for housing, and the reasonableness of the local agency. The bill states the intent of the Legislature that attorney’s fees and costs rarely, if ever, be awarded to plaintiffs if the local agency acted in good faith to approve a housing development that is in the areas and at the densities mentioned above.
Arguments in Support: According to the Bay Area Council, a cosponsor, “The Council agrees that environmental protection is an important endeavor, but as it operates against infill housing, this law is having effects that harm the environment. Infill housing is the most powerful policy tool we have to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, something that CEQA implicitly fails to recognize by giving this veto power to local governments. AB 1633 establishes that a city that wrongfully denies a project by laundering the denial through the false pretenses of environmental review will be subject to the same penalties that would apply if the city illegally denied the project by other means. This bill still allows the normal CEQA and environmental review process, and, by creating a punishment for non-environmental denials, the bill implicitly strengthens CEQA as an environmental law.”
Arguments in Opposition: The Planning and Conservation League and the Center for Biological Diversity raise a number of concerns, including that the bill was prompted by two isolated incidents of infill projects being required to undergo additional review, it could open up local governments to frivolous litigation if a developer disagrees with the decision to require preparation of a CEQA document, and it does not contain exceptions for high and moderate fire hazard severity zones, which still have significant wildfire risk.
Committee Amendments:
- In order to correct a drafting error in GC 65589.5(p), make the following amendment:
65589.5(p). Upon any motion for an award of attorney’s fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in a case challenging a local agency’s approval of a housing development project, a court, in weighing whether a significant benefit has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons and whether the necessity of private enforcement makes the award appropriate, shall give due weight to the degree to which the local agency’s approval furthers policies of this section, including, but not limited to, subdivisions (a), (b), and (c), the suitability of the site for a housing development, and the reasonableness of the decision of the local agency. It is the intent of the Legislature that attorney’s fees and costs shall rarely, if ever, be awarded if a local agency, acting in good faith, approved a housing development project that satisfies conditions established in clauses (i), (ii), and (iii) of subparagraph (d) (D) of paragraph (6) of subdivision (h).
Related Legislation:
AB 2656 (Ting) of the 2021-22 Session was substantially similar to this bill. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1515 (Daly), Chapter 378, Statutes of 2017 established, for purposes of the HAA, a reasonable person standard for deeming consistency, as specified, for a housing development project or emergency shelter.
SB 167 (Skinner), Chapter 368, Statutes of 2017 made a number of changes to the HAA to ensure local agency compliance during the approval process for proposed housing developments. The measure also clarified existing provisions of the HAA and imposed added penalties on agencies that violate the HAA without proper findings.
Double Referred: This bill was also referred to the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources, where it will be heard should it pass out of this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Bay Area Council (Sponsor)
San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (Sponsor)
Abundant Housing LA
California Community Builders
California Housing Consortium
California YIMBY
CBIA
CivicWell
Council of Infill Builders
East Bay YIMBY
Fieldstead and Company
Grow the Richmond
Habitat for Humanity California
Housing Action Coalition
How to ADU
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
MidPen Housing
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
SPUR
Urban Environmentalists
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
Opposition
Center for Biological Diversity
Planning and Conservation League
State Building and Construction Trades Council of CA
Analysis Prepared by: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Housing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):