AB 1809: Recall and resentencing.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-03-13
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-05: Referred to Coms. on PUB S. and APPR.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to recommend that an incarcerated persons sentence be recalled if the incarcerated person has a serious and advanced illness with an end-of-life trajectory or is permanently medically incapacitated with a medical condition or functional impairment that renders them permanently unable to complete basic activities of daily living, as specified. Existing law exempts an incarcerated person who was convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under these provisions.
Existing law additionally authorizes, when a defendant has been committed to the state prison or to a county jail for the commission of a felony, the court to recall the sentence and either reduce a defendants term by modifying the sentence, or vacate the conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense, and resentence the defendant to a reduced term, as specified.
This bill would additionally prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under the provision permitting the court to recall and resentence a defendant convicted of a felony offense. The bill would specify that an individual would not be rendered ineligible for relief under these provisions if there is evidence that the incarcerated persons constitutional rights were violated in the proceedings related to the conviction or sentence at issue, or if there was evidence that undermines the integrity of the underlying conviction or sentence.
Existing law requires the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to recommend that an incarcerated persons sentence be recalled if the incarcerated person has a serious and advanced illness with an end-of-life trajectory or is permanently medically incapacitated with a medical condition or functional impairment that renders them permanently unable to complete basic activities of daily living, as specified. Existing law exempts an incarcerated person who was convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under these provisions.
Existing law additionally authorizes, when a defendant has been committed to the state prison or to a county jail for the commission of a felony, the court to recall the sentence and either reduce a defendants term by modifying the sentence, or vacate the conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense, and resentence the defendant to a reduced term, as specified.
This bill would additionally prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under the provision permitting the court to recall and resentence a defendant convicted of a felony offense.
An (a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), an incarcerated person is not eligible for resentence or recall pursuant to Section 1172.1 or 1172.2 if they were convicted of first-degree murder, if the victim was a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.1, 830.2, 830.3, 830.31, 830.32, 830.33, 830.34, 830.35, 830.36, 830.37, 830.4, 830.5, 830.6, 830.10, 830.11, or 830.12, who was killed while engaged in the performance of their duties, and the individual knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties, or the victim was a peace officer or a former peace officer under any of the above-enumerated sections and was intentionally killed in retaliation for the performance of their official duties.
(b)An incarcerated person described in subdivision (a) is not ineligible for recall and resentencing pursuant to Section 1172.1 if there is evidence that their constitutional rights were violated in the proceedings related to the conviction or sentence at issue, or there is any other evidence that undermines the integrity of the underlying conviction or sentence.
A prisoner An incarcerated person is not eligible for resentence or recall pursuant to Section 1172.1 or 1172.2 if they were convicted of first-degree murder, if the victim was a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.1, 830.2, 830.3, 830.31, 830.32, 830.33, 830.34, 830.35, 830.36, 830.37, 830.4, 830.5, 830.6, 830.10, 830.11, or 830.12, who was killed while engaged in the performance of their duties, and the individual knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duties, or the victim was a peace officer or a former peace officer under any of the above-enumerated sections and was intentionally killed in retaliation for the performance of their official duties.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on PUB S. and APPR. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 64. Noes 0. Page 5552.) |
| Mar 14, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 13, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Mar 12, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (March 12). |
| Feb 22, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jan 22, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jan 10, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 9. |
| Jan 9, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 22, 2024 | AB 1809 Rodriguez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 12, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| Arcadia Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Burbank Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Highway Patrolmen | ** Support | |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | ** Against | |
| California Coalition of School Safety Professionals | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Support | |
| California Narcotic Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Californians United for a Responsible Budget | ** Against | |
| California Police Chiefs Association | ** Support | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | |
| California Reserve Peace Officers Association | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| City of Turlock, Office of the Mayor | ** Support | |
| CLAREMONT POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice | ** Against | |
| Corona Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Culver City Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Deputy Sheriffs Association of Monterey County | ** Support | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Against | |
| Friends Committee On Legislation Of California | ** Against | |
| Fullerton Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Against | |
| Initiate Justice Action | ** Against | |
| LA Defensa | ** Against | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles School Police Management Association | ** Support | |
| los angeles school police officers association | ** Support | |
| Murrieta Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Newport Beach Police Association | ** Support | |
| Novato Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Palos Verdes Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| PLACER COUNTY DEPUTY SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Pomona Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| RIVERSIDE POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Against | |
| Santa Ana Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Uncommon Law | ** Against | |
| Upland Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Young Women's Freedom Center | ** Against |
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1809
Author:(Rodriguez)
As Amended Ver:March 13, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
: Makes an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer ineligible for recall and resentencing under the provision permitting the court to recall and resentence a defendant convicted of a felony offense in the interests of justice, unless there is evidence of a constitutional violation or other evidence undermining the integrity of the conviction or sentence.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
According to the Author
"Law enforcement officers answer the call of duty every day with selflessness and dedication. They place themselves at risk to make their communities safer for all residents. Dreadfully, seven officers in California made the ultimate sacrifice last year in the line of duty. At least four of these officers were feloniously murdered. These violent offenders must be held accountable.
"AB 1809 would prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of murdering a peace officer from seeking a reduced sentence. This bill aligns with the previous legislative intent of holding these violent offenders accountable for their actions against law enforcement officers. For example, existing law already prevents these offenders from receiving a reduced sentence under compassionate release despite being medically incapacitated and terminally ill. These offenders are also ineligible for medical parole at a health care facility in the community. Given the serious nature of their crime, the state must close a loophole in statute that allows an opportunity for offenders who murder a peace officer to be eligible for a reduced sentence."
Arguments in Support
According to the California District Attorneys Association, "This bill reasonably limits use of the wide-open discretion provided under section 1172.1 to ensure that individuals who commit first degree murder of a peace officer when they are aware (or should be aware) they are killing an officer engaged in the performance of their duties are not eligible for resentencing. The same moral and philosophical concerns that underlie the current version of Penal Code section 1170.02 (enacted by SB 6 in 2016) limiting early release of offenders underlie your proposed amendment to section 1170.02. As stated in the analysis of Senate Bill 6: 'The honorable work that our men and women in law enforcement perform on a daily basis is crucial to ensuring that our neighbors and families live in safe communities. Senate Bill 6 is necessary to guarantee that individuals convicted of these heinous crimes serve their entire sentences given to them by a jury of their peers'.
"Moreover, it is consistent with the reasoning behind the current limitation on resentencing of persons under section 1172.2 as that limitation exists even when the person being resentenced has an advanced illness with an end-of-life trajectory or is permanently medically incapacitated with a medical condition or functional impairment.
"Finally, the legislature is entitled to decide who is or is not eligible for recall and resentencing based on the nature and severity of the crime committed. Drawing such distinctions does not violate equal protection or require judges to ignore evidence of constitutional violations in convictions or sentences. And this bill has no impact on a defendant's ability to challenge their conviction on grounds their constitutional rights were violated either by way of appeal (see Penal Code, Section 1237) or a habeas petition in state court (see Penal Code, Section 1473), or via a habeas petition in federal courts (see 28 USCA Section 2254)."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the California Public Defenders Association, "AB 1809 would amend Penal Code section 1170.02 to render completely ineligible for recall or resentencing pursuant to Penal Code section 1172.1, an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer, no matter who recommended such action, the district attorney, the prison, or the sentencing court and no matter for what reason, including constitutional violations.
"The Legislative Counsel's Digest for this bill incorrectly understates the bill's effect. The Digest states that the bill would 'prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under [Penal Code section 1172.1].' That is incorrect because Penal Code section 1172.1 already does that: Subdivision (c) states that [a] defendant is not entitled to file a petition seeking relief from the court . . . . If a defendant requests consideration . . . the court is not required to respond.' (Emphasis added.) In other words, the defendant cannot seek recall and resentencing, only 'the secretary (CDCR) or the Board of Parole Hearings in the case of a defendant incarcerated in state prison, the county correctional administrator in the case of a defendant incarcerated in county jail, the district attorney of the county in which the defendant was sentenced, or the Attorney General….' or the court can seek recall and resentencing.
"CPDA understands the sentiment and pain motivating singling out murderers of peace officers and making them ineligible for many types of relief. Indeed, as the Legislative Counsel's Digest points out Penal Code section 1170.02 already singles them out and makes them ineligible for compassionate end of life relief that may be granted to all other prisoners."
FISCAL COMMENTS
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
UPDATED
VERSION: March 13, 2024
CONSULTANT: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0002656
Date of Hearing:
Chief Counsel: Sandy Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1809
Author:(Rodriguez) – As Introduced Ver:January 9, 2024
As Proposed to be Amended in Committee
SUMMARY:
Makes an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer ineligible for recall and resentencing under the provision permitting the court to recall and resentence a defendant convicted of a felony offense in the interests of justice, unless there is evidence of a constitutional violation or other evidence undermining the integrity of the conviction or sentence.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the purpose of sentencing for crime is public safety achieved through punishment, rehabilitation, and restorative justice. When a sentence includes incarceration, this purpose is best served by terms that are proportionate to the seriousness of the offense with provision for uniformity in the sentences of offenders committing the same offense under similar circumstances. (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (a)(1).)
- Provides that when a defendant has been sentenced to be incarcerated on a felony, the court may, on its own motion, within 120 days of the date of commitment or at any time if the applicable sentencing laws have subsequently changed, recall the sentence and commitment previously ordered and resentence the defendant in the same manner as if they had not previously been sentenced. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(1).)
- Authorizes the court also to recall and resentence at any time upon the recommendation of the Secretary of the California Department of Corrections or the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH) in the case of state prison inmates, the county correctional administrator in the case of county jail inmates, the district attorney of the county in which the defendant was sentenced, or the Attorney General if the Department of Justice (DOJ) initially prosecuted the case. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(1).)
- Provides that the new sentence cannot be greater than the initial sentence. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(1).)
- Makes recall and resentencing applicable whether or not the person is still in custody. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(1).)
- Requires the court, in recalling and resentencing, to apply the sentencing rules of the Judicial Council and any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion so as to eliminate disparity and to promote uniformity of sentences. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(2).)
- States the resentencing court may, in the interest of justice and regardless of whether the original sentence was imposed after a trial or plea agreement, do the following:
- Reduce a defendant’s term of imprisonment by modifying the sentence; or,
- Vacate the defendant’s conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense, whether or not that offense was charged in the original pleading, with the concurrence of the defendant, and then resentence the defendant to a reduced term of imprisonment. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(3).)
- Prohibits the court, if it has recalled the sentence on its own motion, from imposing a judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense if the conviction was a result of a plea bargain without the concurrence of both the defendant and the district attorney, or the Attorney General if the DOJ originally prosecuted the case. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(4).)
- Requires the court to consider post-conviction factors, including, but not limited to, the defendant’s disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation while incarcerated, evidence that reflects whether age, time served, and diminished physical condition, if any, have reduced the defendant’s risk for future violence, and evidence that reflects that circumstances have changed since the original sentencing so that the defendant’s continued incarceration is no longer in the interest of justice. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(5).)
- States that evidence that the defendant’s incarceration is no longer in the interest of justice includes, but is not limited to, evidence that the defendant’s constitutional rights were violated in the proceedings related to the conviction or sentence at issue, and any other evidence that undermines the integrity of the underlying conviction or sentence. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(5).)
- Requires the court, to consider if the defendant has experienced psychological, physical, or childhood trauma, including, but not limited to, abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence, if the defendant was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking prior to or at the time of the commission of the offense, or if the defendant is a youth or was a youth, as defined, at the time of the commission of the offense, and whether those circumstances were a contributing factor in the commission of the offense. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(5).)
- Requires credits to be given for time served. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(6).)
- Requires the court to state on the record the reasons for its decision to grant or deny recall and resentencing. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(7).)
- States that resentencing may be granted without a hearing upon stipulation of the parties. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(8)(A).)
- Provides, however, that if a victim of a crime wishes to be heard the victim shall notify the prosecution of their request to be heard within 15 days of being notified that resentencing is being sought and the court shall provide an opportunity for the victim to be heard. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(8)(B).)
- Defines murder as the unlawful killing of a human being, or a fetus, with malice aforethought. (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a).)
- Defines first degree murder, in part, as any other kind of willful, deliberate, and premeditated killing, or that is committed in the perpetration of, or attempt to perpetrate, specified felonies (felony murder rule). (Pen. Code, § 189.)
- Limits the felony-murder rule to cases in which the defendant was either the actual killer, aided and abetted the actual killer in the commission of first degree murder, or was a major participant in the underlying felony and acted in a manner that was recklessly indifferent to human life. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (e).)
- Allows, however, a defendant to be convicted of first degree murder if the victim is a peace officer who was killed in the course of duty, where the defendant was a participant in one of specified felonies and the defendant knew, or reasonably should have known, that the victim was a peace officer engaged in the performance of their duty. (Pen. Code, § 189, subd. (f).)
- Prescribes the penalty for first degree murder as death, LWOP, or imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 25 years to life, as provided. (Pen. Code, § 190, subd. (a).)
- Provides that when a prosecutor charges a special circumstance and it is found true, a person found guilty of first degree murder shall be punished by death or LWOP. (Pen. Code, §§ 190.2, 190.4.)
- Enumerates special circumstances, including where the victim was a peace officer who was intentionally killed while performing their duties and the defendant knew or should have known that; or the peace officer/former peace officer was intentionally killed in retaliation for performing their duties. (Pen. Code, § 190.2, subd. (a)(7).)
- Prohibits a judge from striking or dismissing any special circumstance which is admitted by a plea of guilty or nolo contendere or is found by a jury or court. (Pen. Code, § 1385.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “Law enforcement officers answer the call of duty every day with selflessness and dedication. They place themselves at risk to make their communities safer for all residents. Dreadfully, seven officers in California made the ultimate sacrifice last year in the line of duty. At least four of these officers were feloniously murdered. These violent offenders must be held accountable.
“AB 1809 would prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of murdering a peace officer from seeking a reduced sentence. This bill aligns with the previous legislative intent of holding these violent offenders accountable for their actions against law enforcement officers. For example, existing law already prevents these offenders from receiving a reduced sentence under compassionate release despite being medically incapacitated and terminally ill. These offenders are also ineligible for medical parole at a health care facility in the community. Given the serious nature of their crime, the state must close a loophole in statute that allows an opportunity for offenders who murder a peace officer to be eligible for a reduced sentence.” - Recall and Resentencing Provisions – Second Look Sentencing: As a general matter, a court typically loses jurisdiction over a sentence when the sentence begins. (Dix v. Superior Court (1991) 53 Cal.3d 442, 455.) Once the defendant has been committed on a sentence pronounced by the court, the court no longer has the legal authority to increase, reduce, or otherwise alter the defendant’s sentence. (Ibid.)
However, the Legislature has created limited statutory exceptions allowing a court to recall a sentence and resentence the defendant. (Dix, supra, 53 Cal.3d at p. 455; see e.g., Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a).) Specifically, within 120 days of commitment, the court has the ability to resentence the defendant as if it had never imposed sentence to begin with. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a).) In addition, the Secretary of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), the Board of Parole Hearings (BPH), the county correctional administrator, the district attorney, or the Attorney General can make a recommendation for resentencing at any time. (Ibid.)
AB 600 (Ting), Chapter 446, Statutes of 2023, recently amended this provision and authorized the court to also recall and resentence, on its own motion, at any time, as opposed to within 120 days, if the applicable sentencing laws at the time of original sentencing are subsequently changed by new statutory authority or case law.
When resentencing under the recall statute, the court is required to “apply any changes in law that reduce sentences or provide for judicial discretion so as to eliminate disparity of sentences and to promote uniformity in sentencing.” (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(2).) Additionally, where the recall request is initiated by CDCR, BPH, a county correctional administrator, a district attorney, or the Attorney General, the court must apply a presumption in favor of recall that can be overcome only by a finding that the defendant currently poses an unreasonable risk to public safety, as defined. (Pen. Code, §§ 1170.18, 1172.1, subd. (b)(2).)
Resentencing may generally be granted without a hearing if the parties stipulate. However, the court must provide a crime victim an opportunity to be heard under Marsy’s law or any applicable law, if they make a timely request. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(8).)
At resentencing, the court must consider postconviction factors, including the defendant’s disciplinary record and record of rehabilitation while incarcerated, evidence reflecting whether age, time served, and diminished physical condition have reduced the defendant’s risk of future violence, and evidence of changed circumstances reflecting that incarceration is no longer in the interests of justice. Evidence that incarceration is no longer in the interests of justice includes the defendant’s constitutional rights having been violated in proceedings related to the conviction or sentence and any other evidence undermining the integrity of the conviction or sentence. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(5).) As stated, in part, in the legislative findings and declaration of AB 600, “Consistent with the California Racial Justice Act, it is the intent of the Legislature to provide remedies that ameliorate discriminative practices in the criminal justice system, including discrimination in seeking or obtaining convictions or imposing sentences.” (See Pen. Code, § 745 [“The state shall not seek or obtain a criminal conviction or seek, obtain, or impose a sentence on the basis of race, ethnicity, or national origin.”].)
Additionally, at resentencing, the court must consider if the defendant has experienced psychological, physical, or childhood trauma, including, but not limited to, abuse, neglect, exploitation, or sexual violence, if the defendant was a victim of intimate partner violence or human trafficking prior to or at the time of the commission of the offense, or if the defendant is or was under 26 years of age at the time of the commission of the offense. If any of these circumstances is present, the court must then consider whether they were a contributing factor in the commission of the offense. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(5).)
In resentencing, the court is not bound by the terms of an earlier plea agreement. (People v. Pillsbury (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 776, 787-788.) However, the new sentence cannot be greater than the initial sentence. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(1).) If it’s in the interests of justice, the resentencing court can reduce the defendant’s sentence. Alternatively, the court can vacate the defendant’s conviction and impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense, whether or not it was charged, provided the defendant concurs. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(3).) Importantly, however, if the court has recalled the sentence on its own motion, it cannot impose judgment on any necessarily included lesser offense or lesser related offense if the conviction was a result of a plea bargain, unless both the defendant and the prosecution concur. (Pen. Code, § 1172.1, subd. (a)(4).)
As introduced, this bill would prohibit recall and resentencing where the individual was convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer. The Legislature has excluded classes of people from eligibility for relief under other resentencing provisions. For example, as the author points out, existing law prevents individuals incarcerated for first degree murder of a peace officer from receiving a reduced sentence under compassionate release despite being medically incapacitated and terminally ill. (Pen. Code, § 1172.2.)
However, the general recall and resentencing provision at issue here is distinguishable from compassionate release. Importantly, unlike recall and resentencing under the general resentencing provision, compassionate release does not seek to redress constitutional violations or other circumstances undermining the integrity of the underlying conviction or sentence, for example violations of the Racial Justice Act or limitations to the felony murder rule. Rather, compassionate release is a resentencing and release process based on compassion for the person’s terminal medical condition.
“A basic requirement of due process is that a defendant be accorded a fair trial in a fair tribunal.” (Turner v. Louisiana (1965) 379 U.S. 466, 472–473.) Further, the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and article I, section 7 of the California Constitution guarantee all persons the equal protection of the laws.” (People v. Edwards (2019) 34 Cal.App.5th 183, 195.) “The concept of equal protection recognizes that persons who are similarly situated with respect to a law's legitimate purposes must be treated equally. (People v. Brown (2012) 54 Cal.4th 314, 328 [citation omitted].)
In light of these constitutional principles, the committee amendments would make the recall and resentencing prohibition inapplicable if there is evidence that the incarcerated person’s constitutional rights were violated in the proceedings related to the conviction or sentence at issue, or if there is any other evidence that undermines the integrity of the underlying conviction or sentence. While there may be other avenues to obtain relief on these grounds like direct appeal and habeas, these proceedings are typically lengthier and may not be as efficient in providing relief to the individual as recall and resentencing. These proceedings can also be fraught with procedural bars to relief. As amended in committee, this bill would still prohibit recall and resentencing in all other circumstances if the individual was convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer.
“The constitutional guaranty of equal protection of the laws has been judicially defined to mean that no person or class of persons shall be denied the same protection of the laws which is enjoyed by other persons or other classes in like circumstances in their lives, liberty and property and in their pursuit of happiness. The concept recognizes that persons similarly situated with respect to the legitimate purpose of the law receive like treatment, but it does not require absolute equality. To prevail on an equal protection claim, the proponent must show that the state has imposed a classification which affects two or more similarly situated groups. The constitutional guaranty of equal protection does not mandate uniform laws with respect to different persons or classes. Instead, …the Legislature may make a reasonable classification of persons and pass special legislation applying to certain classes. The classification cannot be arbitrary, but must be based on some difference in the classes having a substantial relation to a legitimate objective to be accomplished. The presumption is in favor of the classification, which will not be rejected unless plainly arbitrary. (People v. Eddy (1995) 32 Cal.App.4th 1098, 1108-1109 [citations and quotations omitted; italics in original].)
According to the author’s statement, this bill is intended to align with the previous legislative intent of holding this class of persons accountable for their violent actions against law enforcement officers. To the extent this bill as amended in committee would still deny this avenue of resentencing relief to one class of persons, even where it would otherwise be in the interests of justice, is this a reasonable classification of persons sufficient to pass constitutional muster? - Argument in Support: According to the California District Attorneys Association, “This bill reasonably limits use of the wide-open discretion provided under section 1172.1 to ensure that individuals who commit first degree murder of a peace officer when they are aware (or should be aware) they are killing an officer engaged in the performance of their duties are not eligible for resentencing. The same moral and philosophical concerns that underlie the current version of Penal Code section 1170.02 (enacted by SB 6 in 2016) limiting early release of offenders underlie your proposed amendment to section 1170.02. As stated in the analysis of Senate Bill 6: ‘The honorable work that our men and women in law enforcement perform on a daily basis is crucial to ensuring that our neighbors and families live in safe communities. Senate Bill 6 is necessary to guarantee that individuals convicted of these heinous crimes serve their entire sentences given to them by a jury of their peers.’
“Moreover, it is consistent with the reasoning behind the current limitation on resentencing of persons under section 1172.2 as that limitation exists even when the person being resentenced has an advanced illness with an end-of-life trajectory or is permanently medically incapacitated with a medical condition or functional impairment.
“Finally, the legislature is entitled to decide who is or is not eligible for recall and resentencing based on the nature and severity of the crime committed. Drawing such distinctions does not violate equal protection or require judges to ignore evidence of constitutional violations in convictions or sentences. And this bill has no impact on a defendant’s ability to challenge their conviction on grounds their constitutional rights were violated either by way of appeal (see Pen. Code, § 1237) or a habeas petition in state court (see Pen. Code, § 1473), or via a habeas petition in federal courts (see 28 USCA § 2254).” - Argument in Opposition: According to the California Public Defenders Association, “AB 1809 would amend Penal Code section 1170.02 to render completely ineligible for recall or resentencing pursuant to Penal Code section 1172.1, an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer, no matter who recommended such action, the district attorney, the prison, or the sentencing court and no matter for what reason, including constitutional violations.
“The Legislative Counsel’s Digest for this bill incorrectly understates the bill’s effect. The Digest states that the bill would ‘prohibit an incarcerated person convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer from seeking recall and resentencing under [Penal Code section 1172.1].’ That is incorrect because Penal Code section 1172.1 already does that: Subdivision (c) states that [a] defendant is not entitled to file a petition seeking relief from the court . . . . If a defendant requests consideration . . . the court is not required to respond.’ (Emphasis added.) In other words, the defendant cannot seek recall and resentencing, only ‘the secretary (CDCR) or the Board of Parole Hearings in the case of a defendant incarcerated in state prison, the county correctional administrator in the case of a defendant incarcerated in county jail, the district attorney of the county in which the defendant was sentenced, or the Attorney General….’ or the court can seek recall and resentencing.
“CPDA understands the sentiment and pain motivating singling out murderers of peace officers and making them ineligible for many types of relief. Indeed, as the Legislative Counsel’s Digest points out Penal Code section 1170.02 already singles them out and makes them ineligible for compassionate end of life relief that may be granted to all other prisoners.” - Related Legislation: SB 94 (Cortese), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have created a process for a person who has been sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole (LWOP) before June 5, 1990, and had served at least 25 years in custody, to seek a recall of their sentence and be resentenced to a lesser sentence. Would have been inapplicable under specified circumstances, including where the individual was convicted of first degree murder of a peace. SB 94 has been ordered to the inactive file.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 600 (Ting), Chapter 446, Statutes of 2023, allows a court to recall a sentence at any time if applicable sentencing laws are subsequently changed due to new statutes or case law, and makes changes to the procedural requirements to be followed when requests for recall are made.
- AB 124 (Kamlager), Chapter 695, Statutes of 2021, in relevant part, requires courts to consider whether specified trauma to a defendant and other factors contributed to the commission of an offense when making sentencing and resentencing determinations.
- AB 1540 (Ting), Chapter 719, Statutes of 2021, requires the court to provide counsel for the defendant when there is recommendation from CDCR, the BPH, the sheriff, or the prosecuting agency, to recall an inmate's sentence and resentence that inmate to a lesser sentence. AB 1540 also created a presumption favoring recall and resentencing, as specified, when the recommendation has been made by one of these agencies.
- AB 2942 (Ting), Chapter 1001, Statutes of 2018, allows the district attorney of the county where a defendant was convicted and sentenced to make a recommendation that the court recall and resentence the defendant.
- SB 6 (Galgiani), Chapter 886, Statutes of 2016, exempts from medical parole and compassionate release eligibility an incarcerated individual convicted of first-degree murder of a peace officer and applied the prohibition retroactively.
- AB 1156 (Brown), Chapter 378, Statutes of 2015, provides, in pertinent part, that when a defendant is sentenced to the county jail under the 2011 Realignment Act, the court may, within 120 days of the date of commitment on its own motion, or upon the recommendation of the county correctional administrator, recall the sentence previously ordered and resentence the defendant in the same manner as if they had not previously been sentenced, provided the new sentence, if any, is no greater than the original sentence.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Coalition of School Safety Professionals
California District Attorneys Association
California Narcotic Officers' Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Reserve Peace Officers Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
City of Turlock, Office of the Mayor
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
Los Angeles School Police Management Association
Los Angeles School Police Officers Association
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Novato Police Officers Association
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Association
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
Opposition
ACLU California Action
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Initiate Justice
Initiate Justice Action
La Defensa
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
San Francisco Public Defender
Uncommon Law
Young Women's Freedom Center
Analysis Prepared by:
Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):