AB 1851: Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health. The act requires the state board law establishes the office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction, who serves as the director of the State Department of Education and has numerous other duties, including superintending the schools of the state. Existing law requires the State Water Resources Control Board to establish a grant program, in consultation with the State Department of Education, department, to award grants to local educational agencies for the purposes of improving access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and preschools and child daycare facilities located on public school property.
This bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction, if an appropriation is made for this purpose, Instruction to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at participating local educational agency facilities with plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010. The bill would require the Superintendent to select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies for participation in the pilot program and, if a selected local educational agency consents to participate in the pilot program, the bill would require the Superintendent to provide grants to the participating local educational agencies for testing and remediating drinking water lead levels at eligible facilities. If sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for in water at any potable water system outlet, the bill would require a participating local educational agency to notify the parents and guardians of pupils who attend the school of the elevated lead levels, as provided, to take immediate steps to shut down all potable water use at potable water system outlets where excess lead levels may exist, and to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down.
The bill would require a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent to provide technical assistance to participating local educational agencies on the requirements of the pilot program, as provided. The bill would require participating local educational agencies to report specified information about the pilot program to the technical assistance provider on or before January 1, 2028. The bill would require the technical assistance provider to provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results on or before July 1, 2028. The bill would require the Superintendent to provide the report to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature on or before July 15, 2028, and would require the Superintendent to make the report publicly available on the State Department of Educations internet website.
Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health. The act requires the state board to establish a grant program, in consultation with the State Department of Education, to award grants to local educational agencies for the purposes of improving access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and preschools and child daycare facilities located on public school property.
This bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction, if an appropriation is made for this purpose, to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at participating local educational agency facilities with plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010. The bill would require the Superintendent to select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies for participation in the pilot program and, if a selected local educational agency consents to participate in the pilot program, the bill would require the Superintendent to provide grants to the participating local educational agencies for testing and remediating drinking water lead levels at eligible facilities. If sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the bill would require a participating local educational agency to notify the parents and guardians of pupils who attend the school of the elevated lead levels, as provided, to take immediate steps to shut down all potable water system outlets where excess lead levels may exist, and to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down.
The bill would require a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent to provide technical assistance to participating local educational agencies on the requirements of the pilot program. program, as provided. The bill would require participating local educational agencies to report specified information about the pilot program to the technical assistance provider on or before January 1, 2028. The bill would require the technical assistance provider to provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results on or before July 1, 2028. The bill would require the Superintendent to provide the report to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature on or before July 15, 2028, and would require the Superintendent to make the report publicly available on the State Department of Educations internet website.
Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health. The act requires the state board to establish a grant program, in consultation with the State Department of Education, to award grants to local educational agencies for the purposes of improving access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and preschools and child daycare facilities located on public school property.
This bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction to contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization, for purposes of a pilot program applicable to unspecified school districts, to sample all potable water system outlets on the campuses of the school district for lead contamination, except as provided, and to identify and remediate any potable water system outlet emitting water containing lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion. The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization, if sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, to take immediate steps to shut down all potable water system outlets where excess lead levels may exist and to work to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down.The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization to notify the school district of the sampling results, and would require the school district to notify the parents and guardians of pupils enrolled at a school in which a water sample of a potable water system outlet contains lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion, as provided. By increasing the duties on school districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization to report the sampling results for all potable water system outlets to the Superintendent and to any other state agency that requests the information. The bill would also require the nonprofit technical assistance organization, on or before January 1, 2028, to perform an analysis of the remediation methods employed during the pilot program and provide recommendations to the department for remediating lead in drinking water in schools.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.This bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction, if an appropriation is made for this purpose, to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at participating local educational agency facilities with plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010. The bill would require the Superintendent to select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies for participation in the pilot program and, if a selected local educational agency consents to participate in the pilot program, the bill would require the Superintendent to provide grants to the participating local educational agencies for testing and remediating drinking water lead levels at eligible facilities. If sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the bill would require a participating local educational agency to notify the parents and guardians of pupils who attend the school of the elevated lead levels, as provided, to take immediate steps to shut down all potable water system outlets where excess lead levels may exist, and to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down.
The bill would require a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent to provide technical assistance to participating local educational agencies on the requirements of the pilot program. The bill would require participating local educational agencies to report specified information about the pilot program to the technical assistance provider on or before January 1, 2028. The bill would require the technical assistance provider to provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results on or before July 1, 2028. The bill would require the Superintendent to provide the report to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature on or before July 15, 2028, and would require the Superintendent to make the report publicly available on the State Department of Educations internet website.
Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, requires the State Water Resources Control Board to administer provisions relating to the regulation of drinking water to protect public health. The act requires the state board to establish a grant program, in consultation with the State Department of Education, to award grants to local educational agencies for the purposes of improving access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and preschools and child daycare facilities located on public school property.
This bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction to contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization, for purposes of a pilot program applicable to unspecified school districts, to sample all potable water system outlets on the campuses of the school district for lead contamination, except as provided, and to identify and remediate any potable water system outlet emitting water containing lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion. The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization, if sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, to take immediate steps to shut down all potable water system outlets where excess lead levels may exist and to work to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down.
The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization to notify the school district of the sampling results, and would require the school district to notify the parents and guardians of pupils enrolled at a school in which a water sample of a potable water system outlet contains lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion, as provided. By increasing the duties on school districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the nonprofit technical assistance organization to report the sampling results for all potable water system outlets to the Superintendent and to any other state agency that requests the information. The bill would also require the nonprofit technical assistance organization, on or before January 1, 2028, to perform an analysis of the remediation methods employed during the pilot program and provide recommendations to the department for remediating lead in drinking water in schools.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention states that there is no safe level of lead in children.
(2)The State Department of Public Health reports that lead exposure at very low levels can cause learning, behavioral, and attention difficulties in children, and nervous system and organ damage. Exposure to high levels of lead can be fatal.
(3)No effective treatments ameliorate the long-lasting developmental effects of lead toxicity, and it is believed that these effects are permanent.
(4)As of December 2023, the United States Environmental Protection Agency estimated that as much as 20 percent of a childs lead exposure comes from lead in drinking water, when water lead levels are five parts per billion. Drinking water can be an even larger source of lead exposure for infants who consume mostly water-based formula.
(5)The United States Environmental Protection Agencys maximum contaminant level goal, the value the agency deems acceptable for health, is zero for lead in water.
(6)In 2016, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that state and local governments take steps to ensure that water fountains in schools do not exceed water lead concentrations of one part per billion.
(7)Recent drinking water testing at over 6,500 California childcare centers found high levels of lead in one in four childcare centers drinking water. Many childcare centers lead levels were 10 to 1,000 times the allowable amount. One childcare centers water contained 11,500 parts per billion of lead, which is 2,200 times the allowable amount.
(8)The federal Lead and Copper Rule Improvements proposed rule would require only voluntary, limited testing of the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities, and would not require any remediation of elevated lead levels in those facilities. Instead, states are tasked with ensuring that the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities is safe. The pilot program developed by this act will provide the state needed data and analysis to take informed action to protect children.
(9)California has received federal funding pursuant to the federal Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds program and according to federal regulations applicable to that program, these funds must be used proactively on new and eligible projects, which explicitly include lead testing and remediation in schools.
(b)It is therefore the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion of lead.
SEC. 2.Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 32247) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 19 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:4.5.Schoolsite Lead Testing32247.For the purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Eligible facility means a facility that is on a schoolsite and that has plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010.
(b)Local educational agency means a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
(c)Participating local educational agency means a local educational agency that has been selected by the Superintendent to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation pursuant to Section 32247.5.
(d)Pilot program means the program established in this article.
(e)Potable water system outlet means all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual.
(f)Technical assistance provider means a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent that provides technical assistance to participating local educational agencies for purposes of the pilot program.
32247.5.(a)The Superintendent shall establish a pilot program to accomplish both of the following:
(1)Test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating local educational agencies.
(2)Inform recommendations, developed pursuant to Section 32248, for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in local educational agencies across the state.
(b)The Superintendent shall select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes and notify those local educational agencies of their selection by July 1, 2025. In selecting local educational agencies, the Superintendent shall give priority to the following:
(1)Local educational agencies with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled in the school are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, as defined in Section 42238.01.
(2)Local educational agencies with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)A local educational agency shall not be required to participate in the pilot program.
(2)A local educational agency choosing to participate in the pilot program shall provide the following to the Superintendent within 90 days of the Superintendents decision and notification pursuant to subdivision (b):
(A)Written consent.
(B)Information deemed necessary by the Superintendent to confirm that the local educational agency has at least one eligible facility and to calculate the amount of grant funding to be issued to the local educational agency pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)(1)The Superintendent shall provide grants to participating local educational agencies for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with the technical assistance provider.
(2)(A)For purposes of providing grants to participating local educational agencies pursuant to paragraph (1), the Superintendent shall provide grant funding to each participating local educational agency according to the enrollment from the most recent year available at the schoolsites with the eligible facilities.
(B)Any unspent funds after July 1, 2027, shall be returned to the Superintendent and disbursed by the Superintendent to other grantees in need of additional funding for testing or remediation. A local educational agency that receives additional redistributed funds after July 1, 2027, may use those funds for testing or remediation until December 31, 2027.
(3)Administrative and managerial contracts entered into under this section are exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code and the Superintendent may award those contracts on a noncompetitive bid basis as necessary to implement the purposes of this article.
(e)The technical assistance provider shall advise participating local educational agencies on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(f)Participating local educational agencies shall ensure that drinking water sampling pursuant to this article meets all of the following requirements:
(1)Sampling for lead in drinking water shall be conducted at all potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
(2)Sampling shall be conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual, or subsequent United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance as identified by the State Water Resources Control Board. Flushing shall not be used to collect a first draw sample.
(3)A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for purposes of this section shall have current accreditation pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 100825) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 101 of the Health and Safety Code.
(g)(1)If sampling results show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion for in water at any potable water system outlet, the participating local educational agency shall do all of the following:
(A)(i)Notify the parents and guardians of the pupils who attend the school where the elevated lead levels are found no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results during the school year, or otherwise within 60 days after receiving the sampling results, and provide information developed by the State Department of Public Health on the impact of elevated lead levels on children.
(ii)The participating local educational agency may include a description of a remediation plan as part of the notice provided pursuant to clause (i).
(B)Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water use at potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist.
(C)(i)Ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
(ii)For purposes of clause (i), providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that may be contributing to the elevated lead levels, potable water system outlets, providing onsite water filtration, or providing bottled water.
(D)Retest water at potable water system outlets where replacement was used to remediate excess levels of lead, to determine if replacement the remediation successfully reduced lead levels to below five parts per billion.
(E)Conduct additional sampling of water at potable water system outlets as recommended by the technical assistance provider to investigate the source of lead contamination, and consult with the technical assistance provider to identify additional remediation options, if results from the sampling required under subparagraph (D) continue to show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion.
(2)A potable water system outlet shall not be used to provide potable water until test results show lead levels below five parts per billion.
(3)In meeting the requirements of this subdivision, the participating local educational agency shall select the remediation method, except that a participating local educational agency shall not attempt to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in through a potable water system outlet.
(4)If onsite water filtration is used to meet the requirements of this subdivision, the onsite water filtration device shall be certified by an independent American National Standards Institute (ANSI) accredited third-party certification body to NSF/ANSI 53 for lead reduction and NSF/ANSI 42 for particulate reduction (Class 1).
(5)In meeting the requirements of this subdivision, a fixture shall meet the requirements of Sections 116875 and 116876 of the Health and Safety Code.
32248.(a)On or before September 1, 2027, the technical assistance provider shall make testing results received from participating local educational agencies to date available upon request.
(b)On or before January 1, 2028, participating local educational agencies shall report to the technical assistance provider, and the technical assistance provider shall report to the Superintendent, the following information in a standard electronic format:
(1)The name of the participating local educational agency.
(2)The name of the school where sampling was conducted pursuant to this article.
(3)The school address.
(4)The identification number for the potable water system outlet.
(5)The date sampling was conducted.
(6)The amount of lead contained in the sample, in parts per billion.
(7)A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following categories:
(A)Faucet replaced.(A)Replacement of potable water system outlets.
(B)Filter Filtration device installed.
(C)Faucet Potable water system outlet decommissioned.
(D)Replaced faucet potable water system outlet failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(E)Alternative Bottled water or other alternative source of water provided.
(F)Other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet potable water system outlet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(c)On or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider shall provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results. The analysis shall analyze the pilot programs sampling results, and the sampling, remediation, and notification methods employed during the pilot program. The analysis shall also do all of the following:
(1)Provide a better understanding of the level and sources of lead contamination in drinking water in Californias public schools. A full description of the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (b) shall be provided, as well as the number and location of schools that found water at a potable water system outlet with lead levels exceeding five parts per billion.
(2)Provide recommendations on all of the following:
(A)The most health-protective and cost-effective sampling and remediation strategies for addressing drinking water lead contamination in schools, and reducing lead levels in drinking water in at all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than five parts per billion.
(B)Strategies for protecting the health of all pupils, especially pupils attending schools in which at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, and schools located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)Addressing the needs, implementation, and capacity challenges of local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes, and of varying geographic locations.
(D)Promoting effective communication between local educational agencies and parents, caregivers, and the public on drinking water lead level concerns, and supporting the ability of local educational agencies to engage in effective collaboration with partners to accomplish drinking water lead sampling and remediation.
(3)Compare the cost effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, feasibility, and potential challenges and health benefits of implementing the short-term and permanent control measures specified in Module 6 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual on school campuses.
(d)On or before July 15, 2028, the Superintendent shall provide the report developed pursuant to subdivision (c) to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature, consistent with Section 9795 of the Government Code. The Superintendent shall make the report and the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (b) publicly available on the departments internet website.
32248.5.This article shall be implemented only upon the enactment of an appropriation in the annual Budget Act or another statute for these purposes.32248.5.To the extent available, moneys deposited in the Federal Trust Fund, which were received under the federal State and Local Fiscal Recovery Fund program and are available for expenditure on water infrastructure projects, shall be used for purposes of this article.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention states that there is no safe level of lead in children.
(2)The State Department of Public Health reports that lead exposure at very low levels can cause learning, behavioral, and attention difficulties in children, and nervous system and organ damage. Exposure to high levels of lead can be fatal.
(3)No effective treatments ameliorate the long-lasting developmental effects of lead toxicity, and it is believed that these effects are permanent.
(4)As of December 2023, the United States Environmental Protection Agency estimated that as much as 20 percent of a childs lead exposure comes from lead in drinking water, when water lead levels are five parts per billion. Drinking water can be an even larger source of lead exposure for infants who consume mostly water-based formula.
(5)The United States Environmental Protection Agencys maximum contaminant level goal, the value the agency deems acceptable for health, is zero for lead in water.
(6)In 2016, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that state and local governments take steps to ensure that water fountains in schools do not exceed water lead concentrations of one part per billion.
(7)Recent drinking water testing at over 6,500 California childcare centers found high levels of lead in one in four childcare centers drinking water. Many childcare centers lead levels were 10 to 1,000 times the allowable amount. One childcare centers water contained 11,500 parts per billion of lead, which is 2,200 times the allowable amount.
(8)The federal Lead and Copper Rule Improvements proposed rule would require only voluntary, limited testing of the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities, and would not require any remediation of elevated lead levels in those facilities. Instead, states are tasked with ensuring that the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities is safe. The pilot program developed by this act will provide the state needed data and analysis to take informed action to protect children.
(b)It is therefore the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion of lead.
SEC. 2.Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 32247) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 19 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:4.5.Schoolsite Lead Testing32247.For the purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Eligible facility means a facility that is on a schoolsite and that has plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010.
(b)Local educational agency means a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
(c)Participating local educational agency means a local educational agency that has been selected by the Superintendent to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation pursuant to Section 32247.5.
(d)Pilot program means the program established in this article.
(e)Potable water system outlet means all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual.
(f)Technical assistance provider means a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent that provides technical assistance to participating local educational agencies for purposes of the pilot program.
32247.5.(a)The Superintendent shall establish a pilot program to accomplish both of the following:
(1)Test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating local educational agencies.
(2)Inform recommendations, developed pursuant to Section 32248, for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in local educational agencies across the state.
(b)The Superintendent shall select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes and notify those local educational agencies of their selection by December July 1, 2025. In selecting local educational agencies, the Superintendent shall give priority to the following:
(1)Local educational agencies with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled in the school are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, as defined in Section 42238.01.
(2)Local educational agencies with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)A local educational agency shall not be required to participate in the pilot program.
(2)A local educational agency choosing to participate in the pilot program shall provide the following to the Superintendent within 90 days of the Superintendents decision and notification pursuant to subdivision (b):
(A)Written consent.
(B)Information deemed necessary by the Superintendent to confirm that the local educational agency has at least one eligible facility and to calculate the amount of grant funding to be issued to the local educational agency pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)(1)The Superintendent shall provide grants to participating local educational agencies for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with the technical assistance provider.
(2)(A)For purposes of providing grants to participating local educational agencies pursuant to paragraph (1), the Superintendent shall provide grant funding to each participating local educational agency according to the enrollment from the most recent year available at the schoolsites with the eligible facilities.
(B)Any unspent funds after July 1, 2027, shall be returned to the Superintendent and disbursed by the Superintendent to other grantees in need of additional funding for testing or remediation. A local educational agency that receives additional redistributed funds after July 1, 2027, may use those funds for testing or remediation until December 31, 2027.
(3)Administrative and managerial contracts entered into under this section are exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code and the Superintendent may award those contracts on a noncompetitive bid basis as necessary to implement the purposes of this article.
(e)The technical assistance provider shall advise participating local educational agencies on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(f)Participating local educational agencies shall ensure that drinking water sampling pursuant to this article meets all of the following requirements:
(1)Sampling for lead in drinking water shall be conducted at all potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
(2)Sampling shall be conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual, or subsequent United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance as identified by the State Water Resources Control Board. Flushing shall not be used to collect a first draw sample.
(3)A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for purposes of this section shall have current accreditation pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 100825) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 101 of the Health and Safety Code.
(g)(1)If sampling results show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the participating local educational agency shall do all of the following:
(A)(i)Notify the parents and guardians of the pupils who attend the school where the elevated lead levels are found no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results during the school year, or otherwise within 60 days after receiving the sampling results, and provide information developed by the State Department of Public Health on the impact of elevated lead levels on children.
(ii)The participating local educational agency may include a description of a remediation plan as part of the notice provided pursuant to clause (i).
(B)Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist.
(C)(i)Ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
(ii)For purposes of clause (i), providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that may be contributing to the elevated lead levels, providing onsite water filtration, or providing bottled water.
(D)Retest potable water system outlets where replacement was used to remediate excess levels of lead, to determine if replacement successfully reduced lead levels to below five parts per billion.
(E)Conduct additional sampling of potable water system outlets as recommended by the technical assistance provider to investigate the source of lead contamination, and consult with the technical assistance provider to identify additional remediation options, if results from the sampling required under subparagraph (D) continue to show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion.
(2)A potable water system outlet shall not be used to provide potable water until test results show lead levels below five parts per billion.
(3)In meeting the requirements of this subdivision, the participating local educational agency shall select the remediation method, except that a participating local educational agency shall not attempt to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.
32248.(a)On or before September 1, 2027, the technical assistance provider shall make testing results received from participating local educational agencies to date available upon request.
(b)On or before January 1, 2028, participating local educational agencies shall report to the technical assistance provider, and the technical assistance provider shall report to the Superintendent, the following information in a standard electronic format:
(1)The name of the participating local educational agency.
(2)The name of the school where sampling was conducted pursuant to this article.
(3)The school address.
(4)The identification number for the potable water system outlet.
(5)The date sampling was conduced. conducted.
(6)The amount of lead contained in the sample, in parts per billion.
(7)A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following categories:
(A)Faucet replaced.
(B)Filter installed.
(C)Faucet decommissioned.
(D)Replaced faucet failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(E)Alternative source of water provided.
(F)Other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(b)(c)On or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider shall provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results. The analysis shall analyze the pilot programs sampling results, and the sampling, remediation, and notification methods employed during the pilot program. The analysis shall also do all of the following:
(1)Provide a better understanding of the level and sources of lead contamination in drinking water in Californias public schools. A full description of the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (a) (b) shall be provided, as well as the number and location of schools that found a potable water system outlet with lead levels exceeding five parts per billion.
(2)Provide recommendations on all of the following:
(A)The most health-protective and cost-effective sampling and remediation strategies for addressing drinking water lead contamination in schools, and reducing lead levels in drinking water in all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than five parts per billion.
(B)Strategies for protecting the health of all pupils, especially pupils attending schools in which at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, and schools located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)Addressing the needs, implementation, and capacity challenges of local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes, and of varying geographic locations.
(D)Promoting effective communication between local educational agencies and parents, caregivers, and the public on drinking water lead level concerns, and supporting the ability of local educational agencies to engage in effective collaboration with partners to accomplish drinking water lead sampling and remediation.
(3)Evaluate the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and the potential challenges and health benefits of installing certified, lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of other remediation efforts.(3)Compare the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and potential challenges and health benefits of implementing the short-term and permanent control measures specified in Module 6 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual on school campuses.
(c)(d)On or before July 15, 2028, the Superintendent shall provide the report developed pursuant to subdivision (b) (c) to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature, consistent with Section 9795 of the Government Code. The Superintendent shall make the report and the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (a) (b) publicly available on the departments internet website.
32248.5.This article shall be implemented only upon the enactment of an appropriation in the annual Budget Act or another statute for these purposes.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention states that there is no safe level of lead in children.
(2)The State Department of Public Health reports that lead exposure at very low levels can cause learning, behavioral, and attention difficulties in children, and nervous system and organ damage. Exposure to high levels of lead can be fatal.
(3)No effective treatments ameliorate the long-lasting developmental effects of lead toxicity, and it is believed that these effects are permanent.
(4)As of December 2023, the United States Environmental Protection Agency estimated that as much as 20 percent of a childs lead exposure comes from lead in drinking water, when water lead levels are 5 five parts per billion. Drinking water can be an even larger source of lead exposure for infants who consume mostly water-based formula.
(5)The United States Environmental Protection Agencys maximum contaminant level goal, the value the agency deems acceptable for health, is zero for lead in water.
(6)In 2016, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that state and local governments take steps to ensure that water fountains in schools do not exceed water lead concentrations of one part per billion.
(7)Recent drinking water testing at over 6,500 California childcare centers found high levels of lead in one in four childcare centers drinking water. Many childcare centers lead levels were 10 to 1,000 times the allowable amount. One childcare centers water contained 11,500 parts per billion of lead, which is 2,200 times the allowable amount.
(8)The federal Lead and Copper Rule Improvements proposed rule would require only voluntary, limited testing of the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities, and would not require any remediation of elevated lead levels in those facilities. Instead, states are tasked with ensuring that the drinking water in schools and childcare facilities is safe. The pilot program developed by this act will provide the state needed data and analysis to take informed action to protect children.
(b)It is therefore the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion of lead.
SEC. 2.Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 32247) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 19 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:4.5.Schoolsite Lead Testing32247.(a)The pilot program described in this section shall apply to all of the following school districts: ____.(b)The Superintendent shall contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization pursuant to subdivision (f) to do both of the following, on or before January 1, 2028, for a school district identified in subdivision (a):(1)(A)Sample all potable water system outlets on the campuses of the school district for lead contamination.(B)A school campus is not subject to sampling pursuant to subparagraph (A) if the campus does not include at least one building that was built before January 1, 2010, or if all potable water system outlets on the campus have been tested for lead on or after January 1, 2019.(C)Sampling shall be conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual, or subsequent United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance as identified by the State Water Resources Control Board.(2)Identify and remediate any potable water system outlet emitting water containing lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion, with a goal of reducing lead levels to zero.(c)(1)If the sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall do both of the following:(A)Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist.(B)(i)Work to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.(ii)For purposes of clause (i), providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that are contributing to the elevated lead levels, providing onsite water filtration, or providing alternative sources of lead-free drinking water.(2)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall not attempt to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.(3)If a potable water system outlet is replaced because of excess levels of lead found as a result of sampling pursuant to this section, the contractor shall retest replaced potable water system outlets within 3 months of the failed test to ensure compliance. Replaced potable water system outlets shall be tested and shown to not emit water with lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion before they are to be used for drinking or cooking. Water from a remediated potable water system outlet, or water from any other source provided to pupils after sampling, shall not contain lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion.(d)(1)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall notify the school district of the sampling results for potable water system outlets on the school districts campuses upon receipt from the laboratory.(2)(A)The school district shall notify the parents and guardians of pupils enrolled at a school in which a water sample of a potable water system outlet contains lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion.(B)The notice provided pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall occur within 2 days of the receiving the sampling results from the nonprofit technical assistance organization. The notification shall provide information developed by the State Department of Public Health on the impact of elevated lead levels on children.(3)The notice provided by the nonprofit technical assistance organization to the school district, and the notice provided by the school district to parents and guardians, shall include information about the potable water system outlet where the elevated lead level was found, whether the potable water system outlet was decommissioned, and what measures were taken to remediate the elevated lead levels, including measures to provide an alternate source of water for drinking or cooking.(e)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall report the sampling results for all potable water system outlets to the Superintendent and to any other state agency that requests the information. A report of sampling results shall be provided in a standard electronic format and include all of the following information:(1)The name of the school district.(2)The name of the school.(3)The school address.(4)The identification number for the potable water system outlet.(5)Date of the test.(6)The amount of lead contained in the sample, in parts per billion.(7)A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following:(A)Faucet replaced.(B)Filter installed.(C)Faucet decommissioned.(D)Replaced faucet failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 parts per billion.(E)Other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 parts per billion.(F)Alternative source of water provided.(f)(1)For purposes of implementing this section, the Superintendent shall contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization to conduct the water sampling, assist schools with remediation, and collect and report the sampling results.(2)A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for purposes of this section shall have current accreditation pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 100825) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 101 of the Health and Safety Code.(g)(1)On or before January 1, 2028, the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall perform an analysis of the remediation methods employed during the pilot program and provide recommendations to the department for remediating lead in drinking water in schools. The analysis and recommendations shall inform the department about the most health-protective and cost-effective remediation methods that will do all of the following:(A)Reduce lead levels in drinking water in all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than 5 parts per billion.(B)Protect the health of all pupils, especially the health of the most vulnerable, disadvantaged pupils, and pupils in schools that receive funding pursuant to Title I of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 6301 et seq.).(C)Address the needs and implementation challenges of both large, medium, and small school districts, as well as school districts that are located in disadvantaged communities, that serve primarily schools that receive funding pursuant to Title I of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965, or that are chronically underfunded.(2)As part of the analysis described in paragraph (1), the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall evaluate the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and health benefits of installing lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of sampling and other remediation efforts.(h)For purposes of this section, potable water system outlet means all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.SEC. 2.Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 32247) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 19 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:4.5.Schoolsite Lead Testing32247.For the purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Eligible facility means a facility that is on a schoolsite and that has plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010.
(b)Local educational agency means a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
(c)Participating local educational agency means a local educational agency that has been selected by the Superintendent to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation pursuant to Section 32247.5.
(d)Pilot program means the program established in this article.
(e)Potable water system outlet means all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual.
(f)Technical assistance provider means a public institution of higher education selected by the Superintendent that provides technical assistance to participating local educational agencies for purposes of the pilot program.
32247.5.(a)The Superintendent shall establish a pilot program to accomplish both of the following:
(1)Test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating local educational agencies.
(2)Inform recommendations, developed pursuant to Section 32248, for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in local educational agencies across the state.
(b)The Superintendent shall select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes and notify those local educational agencies of their selection by December 1, 2025. In selecting local educational agencies, the Superintendent shall give priority to the following:
(1)Local educational agencies with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled in the school are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, as defined in Section 42238.01.
(2)Local educational agencies with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)A local educational agency shall not be required to participate in the pilot program.
(2)A local educational agency choosing to participate in the pilot program shall provide the following to the Superintendent within 90 days of the Superintendents decision and notification pursuant to subdivision (b):
(A)Written consent.
(B)Information deemed necessary by the Superintendent to confirm that the local educational agency has at least one eligible facility and to calculate the amount of grant funding to be issued to the local educational agency pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)(1)The Superintendent shall provide grants to participating local educational agencies for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with the technical assistance provider.
(2)(A)For purposes of providing grants to participating local educational agencies pursuant to paragraph (1), the Superintendent shall provide grant funding to each participating local educational agency according to the enrollment from the most recent year available at the schoolsites with the eligible facilities.
(B)Any unspent funds after July 1, 2027, shall be returned to the Superintendent and disbursed by the Superintendent to other grantees in need of additional funding for testing or remediation.
(3)Administrative and managerial contracts entered into under this section are exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code and the Superintendent may award those contracts on a noncompetitive bid basis as necessary to implement the purposes of this article.
(e)The technical assistance provider shall advise participating local educational agencies on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(f)Participating local educational agencies shall ensure that drinking water sampling pursuant to this article meets all of the following requirements:
(1)Sampling for lead in drinking water shall be conducted at all potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
(2)Sampling shall be conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual, or subsequent United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance as identified by the State Water Resources Control Board. Flushing shall not be used to collect a first draw sample.
(3)A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for purposes of this section shall have current accreditation pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 100825) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 101 of the Health and Safety Code.
(g)(1)If sampling results show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the participating local educational agency shall do all of the following:
(A)(i)Notify the parents and guardians of the pupils who attend the school where the elevated lead levels are found no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results during the school year, or otherwise within 60 days after receiving the sampling results, and provide information developed by the State Department of Public Health on the impact of elevated lead levels on children.
(ii)The participating local educational agency may include a description of a remediation plan as part of the notice provided pursuant to clause (i).
(B)Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist.
(C)(i)Ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
(ii)For purposes of clause (i), providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that may be contributing to the elevated lead levels, providing onsite water filtration, or providing bottled water.
(D)Retest potable water system outlets where replacement was used to remediate excess levels of lead, to determine if replacement successfully reduced lead levels to below five parts per billion.
(E)Conduct additional sampling of potable water system outlets as recommended by the technical assistance provider to investigate the source of lead contamination, and consult with the technical assistance provider to identify additional remediation options, if results from the sampling required under subparagraph (D) continue to show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion.
(2)A potable water system outlet shall not be used to provide potable water until test results show lead levels below five parts per billion.
(3)In meeting the requirements of this subdivision, the participating local educational agency shall select the remediation method, except that a participating local educational agency shall not attempt to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.
32248.(a)On or before January 1, 2028, participating local educational agencies shall report to the technical assistance provider, and the technical assistance provider shall report to the Superintendent, the following information in a standard electronic format:
(1)The name of the participating local educational agency.
(2)The name of the school where sampling was conducted pursuant to this article.
(3)The school address.
(4)The identification number for the potable water system outlet.
(5)The date sampling was conduced.
(6)The amount of lead contained in the sample, in parts per billion.
(7)A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following categories:
(A)Faucet replaced.
(B)Filter installed.
(C)Faucet decommissioned.
(D)Replaced faucet failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(E)Alternative source of water provided.
(F)Other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than five parts per billion.
(b)On or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider shall provide the Superintendent with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot programs results. The analysis shall analyze the pilot programs sampling results, and the sampling, remediation, and notification methods employed during the pilot program. The analysis shall also do all of the following:
(1)Provide a better understanding of the level and sources of lead contamination in drinking water in Californias public schools. A full description of the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be provided, as well as the number and location of schools that found a potable water system outlet with lead levels exceeding five parts per billion.
(2)Provide recommendations on all of the following:
(A)The most health-protective and cost-effective sampling and remediation strategies for addressing drinking water lead contamination in schools, and reducing lead levels in drinking water in all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than five parts per billion.
(B)Strategies for protecting the health of all pupils, especially pupils attending schools in which at least 75 percent of the pupils enrolled are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals, and schools located in a disadvantaged community identified pursuant to Section 39711 of the Health and Safety Code.
(C)Addressing the needs, implementation, and capacity challenges of local educational agencies of varying enrollment sizes, and of varying geographic locations.
(D)Promoting effective communication between local educational agencies and parents, caregivers, and the public on drinking water lead level concerns, and supporting the ability of local educational agencies to engage in effective collaboration with partners to accomplish drinking water lead sampling and remediation.
(3)Evaluate the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and the potential challenges and health benefits of installing certified, lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of other remediation efforts.
(c)On or before July 15, 2028, the Superintendent shall provide the report developed pursuant to subdivision (b) to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature, consistent with Section 9795 of the Government Code. The Superintendent shall make the report and the information provided to the technical assistance provider pursuant to subdivision (a) publicly available on the departments internet website.
32248.5.This article shall be implemented only upon the enactment of an appropriation in the annual Budget Act or another statute for these purposes.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention states that there is no safe level of lead in children.
(2)The State Department of Public Health reports that lead exposure at very low levels can cause learning, behavioral, and attention difficulties in children, and nervous system and organ damage. Exposure to high levels of lead can be fatal.
(3)No effective treatments ameliorate the long-lasting developmental effects of lead toxicity, and it is believed that these effects are permanent.
(4)As of December 2023, the United States Environmental Protection Agency estimated that as much as 20 percent of a childs lead exposure comes from lead in drinking water, when water lead levels are 5 parts per billion. Drinking water can be an even larger source of lead exposure for infants who consume mostly water-based formula.
(5)The United States Environmental Protection Agencys maximum contaminant level goal, the value the agency deems acceptable for health, is zero for lead in water.
(6)In 2016, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that state and local governments take steps to ensure that water fountains in schools do not exceed water lead concentrations of one part per billion.
(b)It is therefore the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion of lead.
SEC. 2.Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 32247) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 19 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:4.5.Schoolsite Lead Testing32247.(a)The pilot program described in this section shall apply to all of the following school districts: ____.
(b)The Superintendent shall contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization pursuant to subdivision (f) to do both of the following, on or before January 1, 2028, for a school district identified in subdivision (a):
(1)(A)Sample all potable water system outlets on the campuses of the school district for lead contamination.
(B)A school campus is not subject to sampling pursuant to subparagraph (A) if the campus does not include at least one building that was built before January 1, 2010, or if all potable water system outlets on the campus have been tested for lead on or after January 1, 2019.
(C)Sampling shall be conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual, or subsequent United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance as identified by the State Water Resources Control Board.
(2)Identify and remediate any potable water system outlet emitting water containing lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion, with a goal of reducing lead levels to zero.
(c)(1)If the sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion for any potable water system outlet, the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall do both of the following:
(A)Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist.
(B)(i)Work to ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
(ii)For purposes of clause (i), providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that are contributing to the elevated lead levels, providing onsite water filtration, or providing alternative sources of lead-free drinking water.
(2)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall not attempt to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.
(3)If a potable water system outlet is replaced because of excess levels of lead found as a result of sampling pursuant to this section, the contractor shall retest replaced potable water system outlets within 3 months of the failed test to ensure compliance. Replaced potable water system outlets shall be tested and shown to not emit water with lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion before they are to be used for drinking or cooking. Water from a remediated potable water system outlet, or water from any other source provided to pupils after sampling, shall not contain lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion.
(d)(1)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall notify the school district of the sampling results for potable water system outlets on the school districts campuses upon receipt from the laboratory.
(2)(A)The school district shall notify the parents and guardians of pupils enrolled at a school in which a water sample of a potable water system outlet contains lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion.
(B)The notice provided pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall occur within 2 days of the receiving the sampling results from the nonprofit technical assistance organization. The notification shall provide information developed by the State Department of Public Health on the impact of elevated lead levels on children.
(3)The notice provided by the nonprofit technical assistance organization to the school district, and the notice provided by the school district to parents and guardians, shall include information about the potable water system outlet where the elevated lead level was found, whether the potable water system outlet was decommissioned, and what measures were taken to remediate the elevated lead levels, including measures to provide an alternate source of water for drinking or cooking.
(e)The nonprofit technical assistance organization shall report the sampling results for all potable water system outlets to the Superintendent and to any other state agency that requests the information. A report of sampling results shall be provided in a standard electronic format and include all of the following information:
(1)The name of the school district.
(2)The name of the school.
(3)The school address.
(4)The identification number for the potable water system outlet.
(5)Date of the test.
(6)The amount of lead contained in the sample, in parts per billion.
(7)A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following:
(A)Faucet replaced.
(B)Filter installed.
(C)Faucet decommissioned.
(D)Replaced faucet failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 parts per billion.
(E)Other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 parts per billion.
(F)Alternative source of water provided.
(f)(1)For purposes of implementing this section, the Superintendent shall contract with a nonprofit technical assistance organization to conduct the water sampling, assist schools with remediation, and collect and report the sampling results.
(2)A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for purposes of this section shall have current accreditation pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 100825) of Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 101 of the Health and Safety Code.
(g)(1)On or before January 1, 2028, the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall perform an analysis of the remediation methods employed during the pilot program and provide recommendations to the department for remediating lead in drinking water in schools. The analysis and recommendations shall inform the department about the most health-protective and cost-effective remediation methods that will do all of the following:
(A)Reduce lead levels in drinking water in all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than 5 parts per billion.
(B)Protect the health of all pupils, especially the health of the most vulnerable, disadvantaged pupils, and pupils in schools that receive funding pursuant to Title I of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 6301 et seq.).
(C)Address the needs and implementation challenges of both large, medium, and small school districts, as well as school districts that are located in disadvantaged communities, that serve primarily schools that receive funding pursuant to Title I of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965, or that are chronically underfunded.
(2)As part of the analysis described in paragraph (1), the nonprofit technical assistance organization shall evaluate the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and health benefits of installing lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of sampling and other remediation efforts.
(h)For purposes of this section, potable water system outlet means all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agencys 3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities manual.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 3). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 12, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 12). Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and E.Q. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 72. Noes 0. Page 5403.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| Apr 24, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 8, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 3). |
| Mar 19, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on ED. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 19). Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 13, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 12, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and ED. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 17. |
| Jan 17, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2024 | AB 1851 Holden Assembly Third Reading By ARAMBULA | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Mar 19, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Education] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Active San Gabriel Valley | ** Support | |
| American Academy Of Pediatrics, California | ** Support | |
| American Nurses Association/California | ** Support | |
| Association Of Regional Center Agencies | ** Support | |
| A Voice for Choice Advocacy | ** Support | |
| California Association Of School Business Officials | ** Against | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Dental Association | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Support | |
| California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice | ** Support | |
| California State Pipe Trades Council | ** Support | |
| Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice | ** Support | |
| Children Now | ** Support | |
| Children'S Specialty Care Coalition | ** Support | |
| cleanearth4kids.org | ** Support | |
| Clean Water Action | ** Support | |
| Climate Health Now | ** Support | |
| Educate. Advocate. | ** Support | |
| Environmental Health Trust | ** Support | |
| Environmental Working Group | ** Support | |
| Facts Families Advocating for Chemical and Toxics Safety | ** Support | |
| Families Advocating for Chemical and Toxics Safety | ** Support | |
| First 5 California | ** Support | |
| Friends Committee On Legislation Of California | ** Support | |
| GENup | ** Support | |
| Jonas Philanthropies | ** Support | |
| Lilla Arts | ** Support | |
| Lutheran Office Of Public Policy - California | ** Support | |
| Non Toxic Communities | ** Support | |
| Nontoxic Schools | ** Support | |
| Perk Advocacy | ** Support | |
| recolte energy | ** Support | |
| Resource Renewal Institute | ** Support | |
| Safe Passages | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Bay Area Physicians for Social Responsibility | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility | ** Support | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Support | |
| SoCal 350 Climate Action | ** Support | |
| Sunflower Alliance | ** Support | |
| Sustainable St. Helena | ** Support | |
| Sustainable St. Helena-An Environmental Alliance | ** Support | |
| UndauntedK12 | ** Support | |
| Union Of Concerned Scientists | ** Support | |
| western center on law and poverty | ** Support | |
| Western States Policy Advocate Union of Concerned Scientists | ** Support | |
| Wholly H2O | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1851 (Holden) - Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SSPI) to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead in drinking water in the schools of 6-10 local educational agencies (LEAs).
Fiscal Impact:
This bill would result in one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs, potentially in the hundreds of thousands to low millions of dollars, to establish the pilot program. The program would provide grants for six to ten LEAs of varying enrollment sizes to test and remediate lead contamination. However, the bill does not specify the amount of the grants to be provided under the pilot program.
Background:
Existing law requires, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) and the California SDWA, drinking water to meet specified standards for contamination as set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) or the State Water Board (SWB).
Existing law establishes the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act and requires the State Department of Health Services to conduct a sample survey of schools in this state for the purpose of developing risk factors to predict lead contamination in public schools. The law requires the California Department of Public Health to work with the California Department of Education (CDE) to develop voluntary guidelines for distribution to schools to ensure that lead hazards are minimized in the course of school repair and maintenance programs and abatement procedures.
Existing law prohibits, beginning January 1, 1994, the use of lead-based paint, lead plumbing, and solders, or other potential sources of lead contamination in the construction of any new school facility or the modernization or renovation of any existing school facility.
Existing law requires a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in the food service areas of the schools under its jurisdiction, including, but not necessarily limited to, areas where reimbursable meals under the National School Lunch Program or the federal School Breakfast Program are served or consumed. It authorizes a school district to comply with this requirement by, among other means, providing cups and containers of water or soliciting or receiving donated bottled water.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs and inform recommendations for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state. It requires the SSPI to select no fewer than six and no more than ten LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify them of their selection by July 1, 2025.
This bill requires the SSPI, in selecting LEAs, to give priority to LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75 percent of the pupils in the school are eligible for free and reduced-price meals; and LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community.
This bill requires the SSPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance provider; requires that the SSPI provide grant funding to each participating LEA based on enrollment, for the most recent year available, at the schools with the eligible facilities. It requires the technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements under the pilot program.
This bill requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets specified requirements, including that sampling is conducted at all of the potable water system outlets of an eligible facility. It requires, if lead levels exceed 5 parts per billion (ppb) for any potable water system outlet, a participating LEA to perform specified actions, including the provision of a lead-free source of drinking water at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
This bill requires, on or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider to submit a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program's results and recommendations on specified topics to the SSPI.
Related Legislation:
AB 249 (Holden, 2023) would have required, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's potable water system outlets and to report the results to the SWB and applicable schoolsite or LEA; would have required LEAs or schoolsites, if lead levels exceeded five ppb, to perform specified actions. This bill was vetoed by the Governor, with the following message:
Minimizing childhood exposure to lead in drinking water is a critical issue. While I support the author's commitment to ensure safe drinking water in schools, this bill contains several problematic provisions and cannot be implemented as drafted. The bill constitutes an entirely new enforcement role for the State Water Board, requires the creation of a costly database for tracking compliance and enforcement, and contains an infeasible implementation timeline.
Although some funding was included in the 2023 budget for testing and remediation, the bill lacks key provisions for efficiently administering the funding and is inadequate to cover the full cost of implementation. Additionally, this bill creates a reimbursable state mandate with ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs that could range into the hundreds of millions of dollars.
In partnership with the Legislature, we enacted a budget that closed a shortfall of more than $30 billion through balanced solutions that avoided deep program cuts and protected education, health care, climate, public safety, and social service programs that are relied on by millions of Californians. This year, however, the Legislature sent me bills outside of this budget process that, if all enacted, would add nearly $19 billion of unaccounted costs in the budget, of which $11 billion would be ongoing.
With our state facing continuing economic risk and revenue uncertainty, it is important to remain disciplined when considering bills with significant fiscal implications, such as this measure.
AB 746 (Gonzalez), Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017, required a community water system that serves a schoolsite with a building constructed before January 1, 2010, to test for lead in up to five drinking water sources of the schoolsite by July 1, 2019.
Staff Comments:
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), research shows that there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead’s health impacts, the US EPA maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero. The CDC states that childhood lead exposure can seriously harm a child’s health and cause well-documented adverse effects, including brain and nervous system damage, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, and hearing and speech problems. These health impacts can in turn lead to decreased attention and underperformance in school among lead-exposed children.
According to the author, “Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead’s toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 1851 Hearing Date: June 12, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: | June 3, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Ian Johnson | ||
Subject: Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program.
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Environmental Quality. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Environmental Quality.
SUMMARY
This bill requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SSPI) to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead in drinking water in the schools of 6-10 local educational agencies (LEAs).
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Establishes as a policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code (WC) 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) and the California SDWA, drinking water to meet specified standards for contamination as set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) or the State Water Board (SWB). (42 United States Code § 300(f), et seq.; Health and Safety Code (HSC) 116270, et seq.)
- Establishes the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act and requires the State Department of Health Services to conduct a sample survey of schools in this state for the purpose of developing risk factors to predict lead contamination in public schools. (Education Code (EC) 32240-32245)
- Requires, pursuant to the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act, that the California Department of Public Health work with the California Department of Education (CDE) to develop voluntary guidelines for distribution to schools to ensure that lead hazards are minimized in the course of school repair and maintenance programs and abatement procedures. (EC 32242(g))
- Prohibits, beginning January 1, 1994, the use of lead-based paint, lead plumbing, and solders, or other potential sources of lead contamination in the construction of any new school facility or the modernization or renovation of any existing school facility. (EC 32244)
- Requires a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in the food service areas of the schools under its jurisdiction, including, but not necessarily limited to, areas where reimbursable meals under the National School Lunch Program or the federal School Breakfast Program are served or consumed. Authorizes a school district to comply with this requirement by, among other means, providing cups and containers of water or soliciting or receiving donated bottled water. (EC 38086)
- Requires a school district to notify parents, pupils, teachers, and other school personnel of drinking water results immediately if the school district is required to provide alternative drinking water sources, and authorizes a school district to comply with that requirement by providing notification of the test results during the next regularly scheduled public school meeting. (HSC 116450)
- Prohibits the use of any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting or fixture, solder, or flux that is not “lead-free” in the installation or repair of any public water system or any plumbing in a facility providing water for human consumption. (HSC 116875(a))
- Defines, for the purposes of the federal Lead and Copper Rule (LCR), a “school” to mean any building associated with public, private, or charter institutes that primarily provide teaching and learning for elementary or secondary students. (40 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 141.2)
- Requires all community water systems to conduct lead monitoring at the schools and child care facilities they serve if those schools or child care facilities were constructed prior to January 1, 2014, or the date the state adopted standards that meet the definition of “lead-free” under the federal SDWA, whichever is earlier. (40 CFR 141.92)
- Requires each community water system to compile a list of schools and child care facilities served by the system by October 16, 2024. (40 CFR 141.92(a)(1))
- Requires community water systems to collect samples from at least 20 percent of elementary schools and 20 percent of child care facilities served by the system per year, or according to a schedule approved by the state, until all schools and child care facilities identified on the list, developed pursuant to 40 CFR 141.92(a)(1), have been sampled or declined to participate. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(1))
- Requires community water systems to sample all elementary schools and child care facilities at least once in the five years following October 16, 2024. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(2))
- Requires community water systems, after they have completed one cycle of sampling in all elementary schools and child care facilities, to sample at the request of an elementary school or child care facility. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(3))
- Requires community water systems to sample at the request of a secondary school. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(4))
- Requires a community water system to collect five samples per school and two samples per child care facility at outlets typically used for consumption; prohibits, except under specified conditions, outlets from having point-of-use devices. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1))
- Requires a community water system to collect samples from schools from specified fixture types, as follows: two drinking water fountains, one kitchen faucet used for food or drink preparation, one classroom faucet or other outlet used for drinking, and one nurse's office faucet, as available. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1)(i))
- Requires a community water system to sample all outlets used for consumption, if a facility has fewer than the required number of outlets. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1)(iii))
- Requires the governing board of a school district to adopt a local control and accountability plan (LCAP) and specifies state priorities, including the priority for school facilities to be maintained in good repair. (EC 52060(d))
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs and inform recommendations for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state.
- Requires the SSPI to select no fewer than six and no more than ten LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify them of their selection by July 1, 2025.
- Requires the SSPI, in selecting LEAs, to give priority to: (1) LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75 percent of the pupils in the school are eligible for free and reduced-price meals; and, (2) LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community.
- Requires the SSPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance provider; requires that the SSPI provide grant funding to each participating LEA based on enrollment, for the most recent year available, at the schools with the eligible facilities.
- Requires the technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements under the pilot program.
- Requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets specified requirements, including that sampling is conducted at all of the potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
- Requires, if lead levels exceed 5 parts per billion (ppb) for any potable water system outlet, a participating LEA to perform specified actions, including the provision of a lead-free source of drinking water at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider to submit a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program's results and recommendations on specified topics to the SSPI.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead’s toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards.”
- Lead Testing in California's K-12 Schools. The passage of AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017) mandated that community water systems serving schools with buildings constructed before January 2010 test up to five drinking water sources for lead by July 1, 2019. According to the SWB, lead testing was conducted in 8,027 schools, revealing that approximately 1.1 percent of these schoolsites had lead levels exceeding the US EPA's recommended level of 15 ppb. LEAs were exempt from testing if they met any of the following criteria:
- Schoolsites built or modernized on or after January 1, 2010;
- LEAs that conducted lead testing after January 1, 2009, and posted the results online;
- LEAs that requested testing from their community water system;
- LEAs that are permitted as a public water system and are currently testing water for lead;
Additionally, AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2018) requires LEAs to shut down any faucets or fountains where lead levels exceed 15 ppb.
In January 2017, the Division of Drinking Water of the SWB and Local Primacy Agencies amended the domestic water supply permits for about 1,200 community water systems. This allowed schools to request assistance from their public water systems for lead sampling and to receive technical assistance if elevated lead levels were detected. School administrators could request up to five water samples be collected and analyzed at each K-12 schoolsite served by the water system. These provisions also permitted private schools to continue requesting sampling and assistance following the passage of AB 746. Community water systems were responsible for the costs of collecting, analyzing, and reporting, while schools were responsible for any necessary maintenance or corrections.
Research published in 2021 in Preventing Chronic Disease, titled "Water Safety in California Public Schools Following Implementation of School Drinking Water Policies," found that 3% (6) of the 174 schools tested through the state program had at least one water sample exceeding the 15 ppb state action level for lead. Additionally, 16% (28) of schools had at least one sample exceeding the FDA's threshold for bottled water of 5 ppb. Furthermore, 16% (28) of schools were supplied by water systems with a history of noncompliance with water and sanitation regulations, which included issues like elevated levels of contaminants or failure to follow disinfectant protocols. Schools served by noncompliant water systems were more likely to have smaller enrollments, be located in urban areas, and serve predominantly racial/ethnic minority students or students eligible for free and reduced-price meals.
- Effects of childhood lead exposure. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), research shows that there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead’s health impacts, the US EPA maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero. The CDC states that childhood lead exposure can seriously harm a child’s health and cause well-documented adverse effects, including brain and nervous system damage, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, and hearing and speech problems. These health impacts can in turn lead to decreased attention and underperformance in school among lead-exposed children.
- Inequities in childhood lead exposure. According to the CDC, people with low incomes and people of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with outdated infrastructure, and are thus more likely to be exposed to lead-based paint and pipes, faucets, and plumbing fixtures containing lead. Children from low-income families and communities of color can also be further disadvantaged through the cumulative impacts of lead and other challenges they may face, including higher rates of poverty, malnutrition, exposure to multiple pollutants, and enrollment in under-resourced schools.
- Student’s exposure to lead in the drinking water at school. In the 2021 report, How States Are Handling Lead in School Drinking Water, the National Association of State Boards of Education states, “Due in part to their frequent closures and uneven water use patterns during weekends, holidays, summer break, or extenuating circumstances like the pandemic, the topic of lead in drinking water is of special relevance to schools. Water is more likely to stagnate in school pipes and fixtures during closures, potentially making the water more corrosive and increasing the chances that lead leaches into the water.” The impacts of lead in drinking water on children's health gained national attention after news broke of the water crisis in Flint, Michigan. In 2014, a switch in Flint’s water sources caused lead to leach from service lines into drinking water at dangerously high levels. In the wake of the Flint drinking water crisis, part of the national conversation has focused on strategies for improving the safety of drinking water in schools and child care facilities and the importance of lead testing.
- California requirements for testing lead in drinking water in child care centers. In 2018, the State Legislature enacted AB 2370 (Holden, Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018) which requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010, to have their drinking water tested for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years after the initial test. Similar to AB 249, AB 2370 requires the SWB to post test results for lead in licensed child day care centers on its website, and requires centers to:
- Cease using fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist;
- Obtain a potable source of water for children and staff; and,
- Notify parents or guardians of the test results.
In SB 862 (Budget Committee, Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018), the Legislature appropriated $5 million, which the SWB is using to assist child care centers with the costs of testing and fixture replacement.
- Related legislation.
AB 249 (Holden, 2023) would have required, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's potable water system outlets and to report the results to the SWB and applicable schoolsite or LEA; would have required LEAs or schoolsites, if lead levels exceeded five ppb, to perform specified actions. This bill was vetoed by the Governor, with the following message:
Minimizing childhood exposure to lead in drinking water is a critical issue. While I support the author's commitment to ensure safe drinking water in schools, this bill contains several problematic provisions and cannot be implemented as drafted. The bill constitutes an entirely new enforcement role for the State Water Board, requires the creation of a costly database for tracking compliance and enforcement, and contains an infeasible implementation timeline.
Although some funding was included in the 2023 budget for testing and remediation, the bill lacks key provisions for efficiently administering the funding and is inadequate to cover the full cost of implementation. Additionally, this bill creates a reimbursable state mandate with ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs that could range into the hundreds of millions of dollars.
In partnership with the Legislature, we enacted a budget that closed a shortfall of more than $30 billion through balanced solutions that avoided deep program cuts and protected education, health care, climate, public safety, and social service programs that are relied on by millions of Californians. This year, however, the Legislature sent me bills outside of this budget process that, if all enacted, would add nearly $19 billion of unaccounted costs in the budget, of which $11 billion would be ongoing.
With our state facing continuing economic risk and revenue uncertainty, it is important to remain disciplined when considering bills with significant fiscal implications, such as this measure.
SUPPORT
Children Now (Sponsor)
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California Dental Association
California Federation of Teachers
Educate. Advocate.
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Western Center on Law and Poverty
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 1851
Author: | Holden | ||
Version: | 6/3/2024 | Hearing Date: | 7/3/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program
DIGEST: Requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SSPI) to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at participating local educational agency (LEA) facilities with plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires a licensed child day care center that is located in a building constructed before January 1, 2010, to have its drinking water tested for lead contamination levels on or after January 1, 2020, but no later than January 1, 2023, and every five years after the date of the initial test. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 1597.16(a)(1))
- Requires a licensed child day care center subject to HSC § 1597.16(a)(1) to collect and submit drinking water samples to an accredited laboratory; requires the laboratory to, in a timely manner, electronically submit its test results to the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board). (HSC § 1597.16(a)(2)(A))
- Requires, upon notification of elevated lead levels, a licensed child day care center to immediately make inoperable and cease using the fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist, and to obtain a potable source of water for children and staff. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(3))
- Requires a licensed child day care center to notify parents or guardians of children enrolled in the center of the requirement to test a facility's drinking water and of the test results. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(4))
- Requires, pursuant to the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act, that the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) work with the California Department of Education (CDE) to develop voluntary guidelines for distribution to schools to ensure that lead hazards are minimized in the course of school repair and maintenance programs and abatement procedures. (EC § 32242(g))
- Requires a school district to notify parents, pupils, teachers, and other school personnel of drinking water results immediately if the school district is required to provide alternative drinking water sources, and authorizes a school district to comply with that requirement by providing notification of the test results during the next regularly scheduled public school meeting. (HSC § 116450)
- Requires each community water system to compile a list of schools and child care facilities served by the system by October 16, 2024. (40 CFR § 141.92(a)(1))
- Requires community water systems to sample all elementary schools and child care facilities at least once in the five years following October 16, 2024. (40 CFR § 141.92(c)(2))
This bill:
- Makes several findings and declarations, including that it is the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion (ppb) lead.
- Requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program to: 1) test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs; and, 2) inform recommendations for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state.
- Requires the SSPI to select no fewer than six and no more than 10 LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify them of their selection by July 1, 2025.
- Requires the SSPI, in selecting LEAs, to give priority to: 1) LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75% of the pupils in the school are eligible for free and reduced-price meals; and, 2) LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community, identified through the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment's CalEnviroScreen tool.
- Requires the SSPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance provider; requires that the SSPI provide grant funding to each participating LEA based on enrollment, for the most recent year available, at the schools with the eligible facilities.
- Requires the technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements under the pilot program.
- Requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets specified requirements, including that sampling is conducted at all of the potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
- Requires, if lead levels exceed 5 parts per billion (ppb) in water for any potable water system outlet, a participating LEA to perform specified actions, including notifying parents of pupils no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results and ensuring that specified lead-free sources of drinking water are provided to pupils.
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider to submit a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program's results and recommendations on specified topics to the SSPI.
- Requires, on or before July 15, 2028, the SSPI to provide the report to the Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature and make the report and the information provided to the technical assistance provider available on the department’s internet website.
- Specifies that, to the extent available, moneys deposited in the Federal Trust Fund, which were received under the federal State and Local Fiscal Recovery Fund program and are available for expenditure on water infrastructure projects, shall be used for purposes of this bill.
Background
- No safe level of lead. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead's health impacts, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero. According to the CDC, people with low incomes and people of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with outdated infrastructure and are thus more likely to be exposed to lead.
- Sources of childhood exposure to lead. The US EPA states that children can be exposed to lead in paint, dust, soil, air, and food, as well as drinking water, and that drinking water can make up 20% or more of a person’s total lead exposure. According to a 2012 article published in the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (Brown and Margolis), lead is unlikely to be present in source water, unless a specific source of contamination exists. More commonly, lead enters drinking water through the corrosion of plumbing materials and solders that contain lead. Lead can enter a building's drinking water by leaching from lead service lines, lead solder used in copper piping, and brass fixtures. The amount of lead in tap water can depend on several factors, including the age and material of the pipes and fixtures, concentration of lead in water delivered by the public utility, and corrosiveness of the water.
Compared to other states, California has a relatively small share of the nation's lead service lines. In 2016, the American Water Works Association released a national survey of lead service line occurrence, finding that California had, at that time, about 1 percent of the nation's lead service lines (or 65,000 out of 6.1 million lead service lines nationally). Under state law—added by Senate Bill (SB) 1398 (Leyva, Chapter 731, Statutes of 2016) and amended by SB 427 (Leyva, Chapter 238, Statutes of 2017)—all community water systems were required to compile an inventory of known lead user service lines in its distribution system by July 1, 2018. Community water systems were further required to propose a schedule by July 1, 2020, to replace all known lead user service lines and user service lines constructed of unknown material.
- The federal Lead and Copper Rule and subsequent revision. On January 15, 2021, the US EPA issued substantial changes, called the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions (LCRR), to the federal Lead and Copper Rule to provide greater and more effective protection of public health. The LCRR contains regulations that would, for the first time, require community water systems to test for lead in drinking water in schools and child care facilities.
On January 20, 2021, federal Executive Order 13990 directed all federal agencies to undertake review and action to address the promulgation of federal regulations during the prior four years. Of those actions, the LCRR was specifically identified as requiring review. As a result, the US EPA delayed the effective and compliance dates established in the LCRR to December 16, 2021, and October 16, 2024, respectively.
On November 30, 2023, the US EPA announced the proposed Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI), which maintain most of the LCRR requirements for community water systems to conduct public education and offer sampling to schools and child care facilities. The LCRI, like the LCRR, does not require sampling at all potable drinking water outlets, or remediation if sampling reveals lead contamination in a school's drinking water. The US EPA states that the LCRI is intended to provide a "baseline level of sampling information," and that "States are likely better positioned than EPA to administer lead testing and remediation programs because States can establish regulations for schools and child care facilities that would provide for greater consistency of education, testing, remediation activities, and public communication across all schools and child care facilities throughout a State."
- State action on lead in drinking water. In 2017, AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) was enacted to require community water systems to test for lead in the potable faucets of schoolsites on or before July 1, 2019. A 2020 study of AB 746 implementation in Preventing Chronic Disease (Umunna et al.) found that among 240 randomly selected California public schools, roughly 3% of schools that tested had at least one sample that exceeded 15 ppb. Among the schools they examined, the authors estimated that an action level of 5 ppb—the threshold in AB 1851 that triggers specified actions by participating LEAs—would have resulted in a 9-fold increase in the proportion of schools required to take steps to remediate their drinking water. The authors also found a wide range in implementation among schools, stating that "although some schools tested only one tap, others tested as many as 76. Schools that test fewer taps may be less likely to adequately capture the risk of elevated lead in drinking water than schools that test a greater number of taps."
In 2018, the Legislature enacted AB 2370 (Holden), Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018, which requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010, to have their drinking water tested for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years after the initial test. Subsequent written directives from the California Department of Social Services specified an action level of 5 ppb for lead in water in child care centers.
- This bill. AB 1851 requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program that will help high-need schools and schools in disadvantaged communities conduct comprehensive testing and remediation for lead in drinking water. By requiring a technical assistance provider to compile lessons learned from the pilot program, this bill could provide California with information that can help the state identify next steps for scaling up statewide efforts to reduce, to the greatest extent possible, students' exposure to lead in drinking water.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead’s toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards.”
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Education Committee on June 12, 2024, and passed out of committee with a vote of 7-0.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 249 (Holden, 2023) would have required, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's potable water system outlets and to perform specified actions, if lead levels exceeded 5 ppb. This bill was vetoed.
AB 100 (Holden, Chapter 692, Statutes of 2021) requires, commencing January 1, 2023, manufacturer compliance with a specified lower lead leaching standard for faucets and other endpoint devices used for providing drinking water; prohibits sales of products that do not meet the new standard beginning July 1, 2023; and, requires labeling of products that comply with the definition of "lead free" to indicate compliance in an easily identifiable manner.
AB 2370 (Holden, Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018) requires licensed child day care facilities to, upon enrolling any child, provide parents or guardians with certain written information related to the risks and effects of lead exposure and blood lead testing recommendations and requirements, and subjects certain child day care centers to requirements related to testing drinking water for lead contamination levels.
AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017) requires a community water system that serves a schoolsite built before January 1, 2010, to test for lead in the potable water system of the schoolsite on or before July 1, 2019.
SOURCE:
Children Now and Environmental Working Group
SUPPORT:
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California Catholic Conference
California State Pipe Trades Council
Cft- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, Aft, Afl-cio
Cleanearth4kids.org
Educate. Advocate.
First 5 California
Perk Advocacy
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
OPPOSITION:
None received
Positions reflect letters received by noon one week prior to the hearing.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1851
Author:(Holden)
As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SSPI) of the California Department of Education (CDE) to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead in drinking water in the schools of 6-10 local educational agencies (LEAs); requires a technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on meeting the requirements of the pilot program, analyze the pilot program's outcomes, and provide recommendations to the state on reducing lead in drinking water in schools across California.
Major Provisions
- Establishes several definitions, including the following:
- "Eligible facility" means a facility on a school site, where the facility's plumbing was installed before January 1, 2010;
- "Local educational agency" means a school district, county office of education, or charter school;
- "Participating local educational agency" means an LEA that has been selected by the SSPI to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation; and,
- "Technical assistance provider" means a public institution of higher education, selected by the SSPI, that provides technical assistance to participating LEAs for the purposes of the pilot program.
- Requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program to: 1) test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs; and, 2) inform recommendations for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state.
- Requires the SSPI to select no fewer than six and no more than 10 LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify them of their selection by July 1, 2025.
- Requires the SSPI, in selecting LEAs, to give priority to: 1) LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75% of the pupils in the school are eligible for free and reduced-price meals; and, 2) LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community, identified through the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment's CalEnviroScreen tool.
- Requires the SSPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance provider; requires that the SSPI provide grant funding to each participating LEA based on enrollment, for the most recent year available, at the schools with the eligible facilities.
- Requires the technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements under the pilot program.
- Requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets specified requirements, including that sampling is conducted at all of the potable water system outlets of an eligible facility.
- Requires, if lead levels exceed 5 parts per billion (ppb) for any potable water system outlet, a participating LEA to perform specified actions, including the provision of a lead-free source of drinking water at each potable water system outlet that been shut down due to elevated lead levels.
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider to submit a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program's results and recommendations on specified topics to the SSPI.
COMMENTS
No safe level of lead: According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead's health impacts, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero. According to the CDC, people with low incomes and people of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with outdated infrastructure, and are thus more likely to be exposed to lead.
The federal Lead and Copper Rule and subsequent revision: On January 15, 2021, the US EPA issued substantial changes, called the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions (LCRR), to the federal Lead and Copper Rule to provide greater and more effective protection of public health. The LCRR contain regulations that would, for the first time, require community water systems to test for lead in drinking water in schools and child care facilities.
On January 20, 2021, federal Executive Order 13990 directed all federal agencies to undertake review and action to address the promulgation of federal regulations during the prior four years. Of those actions, the LCRR was specifically identified as requiring review. As a result, the US EPA delayed the effective and compliance dates established in the LCRR to December 16, 2021 and October 16, 2024, respectively.
On November 30, 2023, the US EPA announced the proposed Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI), which maintain most of the LCRR requirements for community water systems to conduct public education and offer sampling to schools and child care facilities. The LCRI, like the LCRR, do not require sampling at all potable drinking water outlets, or remediation if sampling reveals lead contamination in a school's drinking water. The US EPA states that the LCRI are intended to provide a "baseline level of sampling information," and that "States are likely better positioned than EPA to administer lead testing and remediation programs because States can establish regulations for schools and child care facilities that would provide for greater consistency of education, testing, remediation activities, and public communication across all schools and child care facilities throughout a State."
State action on lead in drinking water: In 2017, AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher), Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017 was enacted to require community water systems to test for lead in the potable faucets of schoolsites on or before July 1, 2019. A 2020 study of AB 746 implementation in Preventing Chronic Disease (Umunna et al.) found that among 240 randomly selected California public schools, roughly 3% of schools that tested had at least one sample that exceeded 15 ppb. Among the schools they examined, the authors estimated that an action level of 5 ppb—the threshold in AB 1851 that triggers specified actions by participating LEAs—would have resulted in a 9-fold increase in the proportion of schools required to take steps to remediate their drinking water. The authors also found a wide range in implementation among schools, stating that "although some schools tested only one tap, others tested as many as 76. Schools that test fewer taps may be less likely to adequately capture the risk of elevated lead in drinking water than schools that test a greater number of taps."
In 2018, the Legislature enacted AB 2370 (Holden), Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018, which requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010 to have their drinking water tested for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years after the initial test. Subsequent written directives from the California Department of Social Services specified an action level of 5 ppb for lead in water in child care centers.
This bill: requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program that will help high need schools and schools in disadvantaged communities conduct comprehensive testing and remediation for lead in drinking water. By requiring a technical assistance provider to compile lessons learned from the pilot program, this bill may also provide California with information that can help the state identify next steps for scaling up statewide efforts to reduce, to the greatest extent possible, students' exposure to lead in drinking water.
According to the Author
"Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead's toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards."
Arguments in Support
A coalition of supporting organizations writes:
"This bill comes at a crucial time. The [US EPA's] proposed [LCRI], which may be finalized this year, offer little clarity or support to schools with lead exceedances. Notably, while the updated LCRI promotes voluntary testing of some school drinking water outlets each year, the LCRI does not require schools to test and remediate outlets, or lower water lead levels. The pending rule doesn't regulate schools, only the water systems that would perform the testing. In the absence of federal action to actually reduce lead in school drinking water, it is critical that California schools understand the scope of their lead-in-water problem, and the most health protective, cost effective, ways to remediate lead exceedances…This pilot project could provide the state needed data and analysis to effectively adopt its own LCRI regulations, and ensure that schools are adequately remediating lead in their water."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could lead to costs between the mid-hundreds of thousands to low millions of dollars for grants to 6-10 LEAs, and an ongoing annual cost of $80,000 for four years for CDE staff to implement the pilot program.
VOTES
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 7-0-0
YES: Garcia, Hoover, Connolly, McKinnor, Papan, Reyes, Ta
ASM EDUCATION: 6-0-0
YES: Muratsuchi, Addis, Alvarez, Bonta, Hoover, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: April 8, 2024
CONSULTANT: Naomi Ondrasek / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0002981
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1851
Author:(Holden) – As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Education | 7 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires, subject to appropriation, the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to create a pilot program to test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at local education agency (LEA) schoolsites.
Specifically, the bill requires the SPI to select between six and 10 LEAs of varying sizes by July 1, 2025, to participate in the pilot program. The SPI is to (1) give priority to LEAs with schools serving low-income students, (2) select a public institution of higher education to serve as the program’s technical assistance provider, and (3) distribute grants to selected LEAs to test drinking water lead levels at schoolsites, remediate lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contract with the technical assistance provider. The amount of grant funding provided to a grantee LEA is to depend on student enrollment at its schoolsites with plumbing installed before January 1, 2010.
The program requires a grantee to sample eligible water outlets and, if sampling results show lead levels in excess of five parts per billion (ppb), requires the LEA to notify parents and guardians and shut down all outlets where the excess lead levels may exist. The bill then requires the LEA to take steps to remediate the elevated lead levels.
The bill directs any grantee LEA with unspent grant funds to return these funds to the SPI by July 1, 2027, and allows the SPI to disburse these funds to other grantees. Grantees are also required, by January 1, 2028, to report certain data, including water sample information, the amount of lead contained in samples, and remediation action taken to the technical assistance provider. The technical assistance provider, by July 1, 2028, is to provide the SPI with a report analyzing the pilot’s results and provide recommendations for remediation of lead at schools, among other topics.
The bill requires the SPI, by July 15, 2028, to provide this report to the Legislature and Department of Finance.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of an unspecified amount, potentially in the mid-hundreds of thousands of dollars to low millions of dollars, for grants to between six and 10 LEAs to test and remediate lead contamination.
According to the California Department of Education (CDE) if the program were to select nine LEAs with 115 eligible schoolsites for grants, costs to meet this bill’s requirements would be about $400,000 in total for grantees to contract with a technical assistance provider and replace 10% of potable water outlets. In addition, LEAs would need to report certain data and notify parents and guardians of certain information, if necessary.
- Ongoing costs of about $80,000 annually for four years for staff at CDE to implement the pilot program. This assumes grant funding of about $400,000.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Background. There are about 10,000 schools in California. Most schools are served by one of more than 3,000 community water systems. While community water systems regularly test their drinking water sources for lead, lead may enter drinking water at schools through corroded pipes or old faucets.
AB 746 (Gonzalez), Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017, required a community water system that serves a schoolsite with a building constructed before January 1, 2010, to test for lead in up to five drinking water sources of the schoolsite by July 1, 2019. Additionally, AB 746 required LEAs to take steps to shut down faucets where lead levels exceeded 15 ppb. According to the State Water Board, 8,027 schools were tested and about 1.1% of schoolsites sampled were found with lead levels that exceeded 15 ppb.
AB 2370 (Holden), Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018, requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010, to test their drinking water for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years thereafter. If elevated levels of lead are found, AB 2370 requires the center to cease using the faucets where elevated levels were found, and obtain another sources of drinking water. SB 862 (Budget Committee), Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018, appropriated $5 million for the State Water Board to assist this effort.
- Related Legislation. AB 249 (Holden) requires, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's drinking water system outlets and to report the results to the State Water Board and the schoolsite’s LEA. The bill requires a schoolsite, if lead levels exceeded five ppb, to perform specified actions to remediate the lead levels. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
- Prior Legislation. SB 1144 (Weiner), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, would have required state agencies and LEAs to complete a water efficiency and quality assessment report on their facilities and remedy any problems at the earliest practical time, subject to funding. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Al Muratsuchi, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1851 (
Author:Holden) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2024
[Note: This bill was double referred to the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee and was heard by that Committee as it relates to issues under its jurisdiction.]
SUBJECT: Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program
SUMMARY: Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to provide grants to participating local educational agencies (LEAs) for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance (TA) provider. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Eligible facility” to mean a facility that is on a schoolsite and that has plumbing that was installed before January 1, 2010;
- “LEA” to mean a school district, county office of education (COE), or charter school;
- “Participating LEA” to mean an LEA that has been selected by the SPI to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation;
- “Pilot program” to mean the program established by this bill;
- “Potable water system outlet” to mean all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in Module 4 of the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s (US EPA) “3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities” manual;
- “TA provider” to mean a public institution of higher education selected by the SPI that provides TA to participating LEAs for purposes of the pilot program.
- Requires the SPI to establish a pilot program to accomplish both of the following:
- Test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs; and
- Inform recommendations, for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state.
- Requires the SPI to select no fewer than 6 and no more than 10 LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify those LEAs of their selection by December 1, 2025. Requires, in selecting LEAs, the SPI to give priority to the following:
- LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten (TK), kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75% of the pupils enrolled in the school are eligible for free and reduced-priced meals (FRPM); and
- LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community, as specified.
- States that an LEA not be required to participate in the pilot program.
- Requires an LEA choosing to participate in the pilot program to provide written consent, and specified information to the SPI within 90 days of the SPI’s selection of proposed participating LEAs.
- Requires the SPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with the TA provider.
- Requires any unspent funds after July 1, 2027, to be returned to the SPI and disbursed by the SPI to other grantees in need of additional funding for testing or remediation.
- Requires administrative and managerial contracts entered into to be exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code (PCC) and authorizes the SPI to award those contracts on a noncompetitive bid basis.
- Requires the TA provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and specified notification requirements.
- Requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets specified requirements.
- Requires, if sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 parts per billion (ppb) for any potable water system outlet, the participating LEA to do all of the following:
- Notify the parents and guardians of the pupils who attend the school where the elevated lead levels are found no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results during the school year, or otherwise within 60 days after receiving the sampling results, and provide information developed by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) on the impact of elevated lead levels on children; and authorizes the participating LEA to include a description of a remediation plan as part of the notice;
- Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist;
- Ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided for pupils at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels. States that providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing any fixtures that may be contributing to the elevated lead levels, providing onsite water filtration, or providing bottled water;
- Retest potable water system outlets where replacement was used to remediate excess levels of lead, to determine if replacement successfully reduced lead levels to below 5 ppb; and
- Conduct additional sampling of potable water system outlets as recommended by the TA provider to investigate the source of lead contamination, and consult with the TA provider to identify additional remediation options, if results from the required sampling continue to show lead levels in excess of 5 ppb.
- Requires a potable water system outlet to not be used to provide potable water until test results show lead levels below 5 ppb.
- Requires the participating LEA to select the remediation method, except that a participating LEA is prohibited from attempting to remediate excess levels of lead by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2028, participating LEAs to report to the TA provider, and the TA provider shall report to the SPI, the following information in a standard electronic format:
- The name of the participating LEA;
- The name of the school where sampling was conducted;
- The school address;
- The identification number for the potable water system outlet;
- The date sampling was conducted;
- The amount of lead contained in the sample, in ppb; and
- A description of any remediation action taken, reported as any of the following categories: faucet replaced, filter installed, faucet decommissioned, replaced faucet failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 ppb, alternative source of water provided, or other, including alternative remediation actions in which a replaced faucet has failed to reduce lead levels to less than 5 ppb.
- Requires on or before July 1, 2028, the TA provider to provide the SPI with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program’s results. Requires the analysis to analyze the pilot program’s sampling results, and the sampling, remediation, and notification methods employed during the pilot program. Requires the analysis to also do all of the following:
- Provide a better understanding of the level and sources of lead contamination in drinking water in California’s public schools. Requires a full description of the information provided to the TA provider to be provided, as well as the number and location of schools that found a potable water system outlet with lead levels exceeding 5 ppb.
- Provide recommendations on all of the following:
- The most health-protective and cost-effective sampling and remediation strategies for addressing drinking water lead contamination in schools, and reducing lead levels in drinking water in all potable water system outlets in schools to as close to zero lead as possible, but no more than 5 ppb;
- Strategies for protecting the health of all pupils, especially pupils attending schools in which at least 75% of the pupils enrolled are eligible for FRPM, and schools located in a disadvantaged community, as specified;
- Addressing the needs, implementation, and capacity challenges of LEAs of varying enrollment sizes, and of varying geographic locations; and
- Promoting effective communication between LEAs and parents, caregivers, and the public on drinking water lead level concerns, and supporting the ability of LEAs to engage in effective collaboration with partners to accomplish drinking water lead sampling and remediation.
- Evaluate the cost-effectiveness, feasibility, and potential challenges and health benefits of installing certified, lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of other remediation efforts.
- Requires, on or before July 15, 2028, the SPI to provide the report to the Department of Finance (DOF) and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature. Requires the SPI make the report and the information provided to the TA provider publicly available on the CDE’s website.
- States that these requirements are required to be implemented only upon the enactment of an appropriation in the annual Budget Act or another statute for these purposes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes as a policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code (WC) 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) and the California SDWA, drinking water to meet specified standards for contamination as set by the US EPA or the State Water Board (SWB). (42 United States Code § 300(f), et seq.; Health and Safety Code (HSC) 116270, et seq.)
- Requires a licensed child day care center that is located in a building constructed before January 1, 2010, to have its drinking water tested for lead contamination levels on or after January 1, 2020, but no later than January 1, 2023, and every five years after the date of the initial test. (HSC 1597.16(a)(1))
- Requires a licensed child day care center to collect and submit drinking water samples to an accredited laboratory; requires the laboratory to, in a timely manner, electronically submit its test results to the SWD; and if the test results show elevated levels, requires the SWD to report, in a timely manner, the test results to the California Department of Social Services (CDSS). (HSC 1597.16(a)(2)(A))
- Requires the SWB to post all test results received for lead in licensed child day care centers on its internet website in a timely manner and to make test results readily accessible to the public. (HSC 1597.16(a)(2)(B)(ii))
- Requires, upon notification of elevated lead levels, a licensed child day care center to immediately make inoperable and cease using the fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist, and to obtain a potable source of water for children and staff. (HSC 1597.16(a)(3))
- Requires a licensed child day care center to notify parents or guardians of children enrolled in the center of the requirement to test a facility’s drinking water and of the test results. (HSC 1597.16(a)(4))
- Establishes the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act and requires the State Department of Health Services to conduct a sample survey of schools in this state for the purpose of developing risk factors to predict lead contamination in public schools. (Education Code (EC) 32240-32245)
- Requires, pursuant to the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act, that the CDPH work with the California Department of Education (CDE) to develop voluntary guidelines for distribution to schools to ensure that lead hazards are minimized in the course of school repair and maintenance programs and abatement procedures. (EC 32242(g))
- Prohibits, beginning January 1, 1994, the use of lead-based paint, lead plumbing, and solders, or other potential sources of lead contamination in the construction of any new school facility or the modernization or renovation of any existing school facility. (EC 32244)
- Requires a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in the food service areas of the schools under its jurisdiction, including, but not necessarily limited to, areas where reimbursable meals under the National School Lunch Program or the federal School Breakfast Program are served or consumed. Authorizes a school district to comply with this requirement by, among other means, providing cups and containers of water or soliciting or receiving donated bottled water. (EC 38086)
- Requires a school district to notify parents, pupils, teachers, and other school personnel of drinking water results immediately if the school district is required to provide alternative drinking water sources, and authorizes a school district to comply with that requirement by providing notification of the test results during the next regularly scheduled public school meeting. (HSC 116450)
- Prohibits the use of any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting or fixture, solder, or flux that is not “lead-free” in the installation or repair of any public water system or any plumbing in a facility providing water for human consumption. (HSC 116875(a))
- Defines, for the purposes of the federal Lead and Copper Rule (LCR), a “school” to mean any building associated with public, private, or charter institutes that primarily provide teaching and learning for elementary or secondary students. (40 CFR 141.2)
- Defines, for the purposes of the federal LCR, “child care facility” to mean a location that houses a licensed provider of child care, day care, or early learning services to children, as determined by the state, local, or tribal licensing agency. (40 CFR 141.2)
- Requires all community water systems to conduct lead monitoring at the schools and child care facilities they serve if those schools or child care facilities were constructed prior to January 1, 2014, or the date the state adopted standards that meet the definition of “lead-free” under the federal SDWA, whichever is earlier. (40 CFR 141.92)
- Requires each community water system to compile a list of schools and child care facilities served by the system by October 16, 2024. (40 CFR 141.92(a)(1))
- Requires community water systems to collect samples from at least 20% of elementary schools and 20% of child care facilities served by the system per year, or according to a schedule approved by the state, until all schools and child care facilities identified on the list, developed pursuant to 40 CFR 141.92(a)(1), have been sampled or declined to participate. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(1))
- Requires community water systems to sample all elementary schools and child care facilities at least once in the five years following October 16, 2024. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(2))
- Requires community water systems, after they have completed one cycle of sampling in all elementary schools and child care facilities, to sample at the request of an elementary school or child care facility. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(3))
- Requires community water systems to sample at the request of a secondary school. (40 CFR 141.92(c)(4))
- Requires a community water system to collect five samples per school and two samples per child care facility at outlets typically used for consumption; prohibits, except under specified conditions, outlets from having point-of-use devices. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1))
- Requires a community water system to collect samples from schools from specified fixture types, as follows: two drinking water fountains, one kitchen faucet used for food or drink preparation, one classroom faucet or other outlet used for drinking, and one nurse's office faucet, as available. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1)(i))
- Requires a community water system to sample all outlets used for consumption, if a facility has fewer than the required number of outlets. (40 CFR 141.92(b)(1)(iii))
- Provides that the state's competitive bidding requirements for contracts for services do not apply to contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency. (PCC 10335(a))
- Requires the governing board of a school district to adopt a local control and accountability plan (LCAP) and specifies state priorities, including the priority for school facilities to be maintained in good repair. (EC 52060(d))
- Requires the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to identify disadvantaged communities for investment opportunities. Requires these communities to be identified based on geographic, socioeconomic, public health, and environmental hazard criteria, and may include, but are not limited to, either of the following:
- Areas disproportionately affected by environmental pollution and other hazards that can lead to negative public health effects, exposure, or environmental degradation; and
- Areas with concentrations of people that are of low income, high unemployment, low levels of homeownership, high rent burden, sensitive populations, or low levels of educational attainment. (HSC 39711)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill. The author states, “Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead’s toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards.”
Key provisions of the bill. AB 1851 requires the SPI to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead in drinking water at the eligible facilities of LEAs, prioritizing those with at least one school that serves pupils in TK-3 where at least 75% of the pupils are eligible for FRPM and LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community, as defined by the CalEPA. The SPI is required to select 6-10 eligible LEAs to participate in the grant program, but LEAs may decline their participation in the program; they are not required to participate. The bill requires the SPI to contract with a TA provider, a public institution of higher education, to provide assistance to the participating LEAs in the pilot as they test and remediate for lead in drinking water. If sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 ppb, participating LEAs are required to notify parents, take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down the impacted potable water systems, ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided, retest the impacted potable water system, and conduct additional sampling. A participating LEA is also required to select the remediation method, and then carry out and pay for the selected remediation. The bill states that the requirements are to be implemented only upon the enactment of an appropriation in the annual Budget Act or another statute for these purposes. The Committee may wish to consider that the bill does not specify a total amount for the pilot program, so it is possible that a participating LEA will be required to test and remediate for lead found in drinking water, but the cost of the work may exceed the amount provided for the pilot.
The bill also includes participating LEAs to report to the TA provider, and the TA provider to report to the SPI information regarding the testing and remediation in order for the TA provider to provide the SPI with a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program’s results, as well as provide recommendations related to future strategies for lead testing and remediation in schools, including an evaluation of cost-effectiveness of specified remediation methods. Finally, the SPI is required to provide the report to the DOF and the relevant policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature by July 15, 2028.
AB 1851 Implementation Activities | Date |
AB 1851 takes effect | January 1, 2025 |
SPI identifies potential LEA grantees, conducts outreach | January 1, 2025-November 30, 2025 (not explicitly stated in bill) |
SPI notifies LEA grantees | December 1, 2025 |
LEAs send consent to participate to SPI | March 1, 2026 (bill says 90 days after December 1, 2025) |
LEAs begin testing and remediation | March 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027 (not explicitly stated in bill) |
LEAs send unused funds back to SPI for redistribution | July 1, 2027 |
LEAs finish remediation (as needed) with redistributed unspent funds | July 1, 2027-January 1, 2028 (not explicitly stated in bill) |
LEAs send collection data to CDE and TA provider sends data to CDE | January 1, 2028 |
TA provider sends CDE the report (analysis of sampling and remediation results, etc.) | July 1, 2028 |
CDE sends final report to DOF and Legislature | July 15, 2028 |
Consequences of childhood lead exposure. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), research shows that there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead’s health impacts, the US EPA maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero. The CDC states that childhood lead exposure can seriously harm a child’s health and cause well-documented adverse effects, including brain and nervous system damage, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, and hearing and speech problems. These health impacts can in turn lead to decreased attention and underperformance in school among lead-exposed children.
Inequities in childhood lead exposure. Lead exposure is not equally distributed across the United States, and young children at the highest risk for exposure are those living in housing built before 1978, Black or African American children, and children living in areas with higher poverty rates, according to a 2021 article in Environmental Health Perspectives, Blood Lead Levels in U.S. Children Ages 1-11 Years, 1976-2016. According to a 2020 study in Nature Medicine, Association of Lead-Exposure Risk and Family Income with Childhood Brain Outcomes, with increasing risk of exposure, children from lower-income families had lower cognitive test scores, and brain changes (including reduced volume of the cortex, a part of the brain that plays a role in higher level processes, including problem solving, planning, critical thinking, and memory). A 2015 study in Environmental Health, The Impact of Low-Level Lead Toxicity on School Performance Among Children in the Chicago Public Schools, found that among nearly 58,000 children attending Chicago public schools, blood lead levels were highest in black children (relative to Hispanic and white children) and higher in low-income children. Children from low-income families and communities of color can also be further disadvantaged through the cumulative impacts of lead and other challenges they may face, including higher rates of poverty, malnutrition, exposure to multiple pollutants, and enrollment in under-resourced schools.
Sources of childhood exposure to lead. The US EPA states that children can be exposed to lead in paint, dust, soil, air, and food, as well as drinking water and that drinking water can make up 20% or more of a person’s total lead exposure. The most prevalent sources of lead in drinking water are pipes, fixtures, and associated hardware from which lead can leach. According to a 2012 National Center for Environmental Health report, Lead in Drinking Water and Human Blood Levels in the United States, nearly all lead in users’ tap water originates from the corrosion of lead-containing materials that can occur through contact with water, rather than from the primary water source or treatment plant. Lead can enter a building’s drinking water by leaching from lead service lines, lead solder used in copper piping, and from brass fixtures. The amount of lead in tap water can depend on several factors, including the age and material of the pipes and fixtures, the concentration of lead in water delivered by the public utility, and the corrosiveness of the water. Compared to other states, California has a relatively small share of the nation's lead service lines. In 2016, the American Water Works Association released a national survey of lead service line occurrence, finding that California had, at that time, about 1% of the nation's lead service lines.
Student’s exposure to lead in the drinking water at school. In the 2021 report, How States Are Handling Lead in School Drinking Water, the National Association of State Boards of Education states, “Due in part to their frequent closures and uneven water use patterns during weekends, holidays, summer break, or extenuating circumstances like the pandemic, the topic of lead in drinking water is of special relevance to schools. Water is more likely to stagnate in school pipes and fixtures during closures, potentially making the water more corrosive and increasing the chances that lead leaches into the water.” The impacts of lead in drinking water on children's health gained national attention after news broke of the water crisis in Flint, Michigan. In 2014, a switch in Flint’s water sources caused lead to leach from service lines into drinking water at dangerously high levels. In the wake of the Flint drinking water crisis, part of the national conversation has focused on strategies for improving the safety of drinking water in schools and child care facilities and the importance of lead testing.
Lead testing in California’s K-12 schools. AB 746 (Gonzalez), Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017, required a community water system that serves a schoolsite with a building constructed before January 2010 to test for lead in up to five drinking water sources of the schoolsite by July 1, 2019. According to the SWB, 8,027 schools were tested with approximately 1.1% of schoolsites sampled were found with lead levels that exceed the US EPA recommended level of 15 ppb. LEAs were exempt from testing if they met the following:
- Schoolsites built or modernized on or after January 1, 2010;
- LEAs that completed lead testing after January 1, 2009, and posted information about the lead testing online;
- LEAs that have requested testing from their community water system; or
- LEAs that are permitted as a public water system and are currently testing water for lead.
Additionally, the provisions of AB 746 (2018) require LEAs to take steps to shut down faucets and fountains where lead levels exceed 15 ppb.
In January 2017, the Division of Drinking Water of the SWB and Local Primacy Agencies issued permit amendments to the domestic water supply permits of approximately 1,200 community water systems. This was done to allow schools that are served by a community water system to request assistance from their public water system to conduct water sampling for lead and receive TA if an elevated lead sample is found. School administrators could request that their community water system collect and analyze up to five water samples at each K-12 schoolsite served by the water system. These provisions also allowed, but did not require, private schools to continue to request sampling and assistance after the passage of AB 746. Community water systems were responsible for the costs associated with collecting, analyzing, and reporting. Schools are responsible for any maintenance or corrections needed at their school.
According to 2021 original research in Preventing Chronic Disease, Water Safety in California Public Schools Following Implementation of School Drinking Water Policies, 3% (6) of the 174 schools that tested their taps for lead through the state program had at least one drinking water sample that exceeded 15 ppb, the California state action level for lead. 16% (28) of schools that tested through the program had at least one drinking water sample that exceeded 5 ppb, the FDA threshold for bottled water. 16% (28) of schools received water from a water system with a history of noncompliance with water and sanitation regulations (such as elevated levels of contaminants or failure to adhere to disinfectant protocols). Schools served by water systems with a history of noncompliance were more likely to have a smaller enrollment, be located in a city, and serve more than 50% of students who were from racial/ethnic minority backgrounds or eligible for free and reduced-price meals.
Drinking Water for Schools Grant Program. The SWB’s Drinking Water For Schools (DWFS) Grant Program has awarded $9.5 million in grant funds to school districts to improve access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools (Round 1) under SB 828 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 29, Statutes of 2016, consistent with the DWFS Guidelines adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWB) on May 16, 2017.
An additional $6.8 million was authorized for the DWFS Grant Program (Round 2) pursuant to SB 862 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018. Guidelines for this additional funding were approved in June of 2019. Grant funds were awarded to nonprofit organizations Self-Help Enterprises and Rural Community Assistance Corporation, which act as Program Administrators. These Program Administrators are working directly with eligible school districts to develop and fund projects for disadvantaged community schools, prioritizing schools with impaired water quality. Maximum grant amounts are $100,000 for a single school and $1 million for an LEA. Eligible project types under Round 2 funding include, but are not limited to:
- Installation or replacement of water bottle filling stations or drinking water fountains, with or without treatment devices capable of removing contaminants present in the school’s water supply;
- Installation of point-of-entry (POE), or point-of-use (POU) treatment devices for water bottle filling stations, drinking fountains, and other fixtures that provide water for human consumption, including up to three years of replacement filters, continuing operation and maintenance and monitoring of POE or POU devices;
- Installation, replacement, or repairs of drinking water fixtures and associated plumbing appurtenances that are necessary to address lead contamination that requires a corrective action; and
- Provision of interim alternative water supplies for applicants in the process of implementing a permanent solution, including the purchase of temporary transfer water and hauled water.
School Energy Efficiency Stimulus Program. AB 841 (Ting), Chapter 372, Statutes of 2020, established the School Energy Efficiency Stimulus Program which establishes the School Noncompliant Plumbing Fixture and Appliance Program to provide grants to LEAs to replace noncompliant plumbing fixtures and appliances that fail to meet water efficiency standards and waste potable water and the energy used to convey that water, with water-conserving plumbing fixtures and appliances. The California Energy Commission was authorized to design, administer, and implement the California Schools Healthy Air, Plumbing, and Efficiency Program (CalSHAPE). CalSHAPE provides worksheets to help program participants gather the information needed to complete an application for the California Schools Healthy Air, Plumbing, and Efficiency (CalSHAPE) Plumbing Program, which includes documentation of existing noncompliant plumbing fixtures and appliances, proposed replacement water-conserving plumbing fixtures and appliances, and replacement costs. Worksheets are available for automatic ice makers, clothes washers, commercial dishwashers, interior faucets, showerheads, toilets, and urinals. Funding for CalSHAPE Plumbing Program (Round 3) is approximately $65 million and applications are based on a utility service territory location.
California requirements for testing lead in drinking water in child care centers. In 2018, the State Legislature enacted AB 2370 (Holden) Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018, which requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010, to have their drinking water tested for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years after the initial test. Similar to AB 249, AB 2370 requires the State Water Board to post test results for lead in licensed child day care centers on its website, and similar to AB 1851, requires centers to:
- Cease using fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist;
- Obtain a potable source of water for children and staff; and,
- Notify parents or guardians of the test results.
Subsequent written directives from the CDSS specified an action level of 5 ppb, with a minimum reporting threshold of 1 ppb, for lead in water in child care centers. In SB 862 (Budget Committee) Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018, the Legislature appropriated $5 million, which the SWB is using to assist child care centers with the costs of testing and fixture replacement.
The federal Lead and Copper Rule (LCR) and subsequent revision (LCRR). In 1991, the US EPA promulgated the LCR, a body of regulations established to minimize lead and copper in drinking water. On January 15, 2021, the US EPA issued substantial changes, called the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions (LCRR), to the LCR, to provide greater and more effective protection of public health. The LCRR contains federal regulations that would, for the first time, require community water systems to test for lead in drinking water in schools and child care facilities. If unchanged by the Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI; described below), rules established under the LCRR will require community water systems, beginning on October 16, 2024, to conduct lead sampling at a certain number of faucets at each elementary school and child care facility they serve within five years; provide testing to secondary schools upon request during the 5 years of mandatory elementary and child care facility testing; and provide testing to elementary schools and child care facilities upon request after the first round of mandatory testing. Notably, the US EPA states that the sampling efforts required under the LCRR should not serve as a replacement for the more comprehensive testing recommended in the agency's "3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities" manual, which recommends, for example, that schools sample all fixtures used for consumption. This guidance is consistent with AB 1851's requirement for testing at all potable water system outlets in a school.
The Lead and Copper Rule Improvements. On January 20, 2021, federal Executive Order 13990 directed all federal agencies to undertake review and action to address the promulgation of federal regulations during the prior four years. The LCRR was specifically identified as requiring review. As a result, the US EPA delayed the effective and compliance dates established in the LCRR to December 16, 2021 and October 16, 2024, respectively. The US EPA committed to propose and revise the LCRR by October 2024 with the LCRI.
On November 30, 2023, the US EPA announced the proposed LCRI, which maintain most of the LCRR requirements for community water systems to conduct public education and offer sampling to schools and child care facilities. The LCRI clarify that community water systems do not have to sample in schools and child care facilities that underwent full plumbing replacement after January 1, 2014, or the date that a state adopted standards meeting the federal definition of "lead-free" (January 1, 2010, in California). The LCRI, like the LCRR, does not require sampling at all potable drinking water outlets, or remediation if sampling reveals lead contamination in a school's drinking water. The US EPA states that the LCRI is intended to provide a "baseline level of sampling information," and that "States are likely better positioned than EPA to administer lead testing and remediation programs because States can establish regulations for schools and child care facilities that would provide for greater consistency of education, testing, remediation activities, and public communication across all schools and child care facilities throughout a State."
Recommended Committee Amendments. Staff recommends that the bill be amended as follows:
- Adjust implementation timelines by providing six months for the SPI to identify potential participating LEA, and providing participating LEAs from October 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027 to test and remediate.
- Require the report written by the technical assistance provider to compare the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and the potential challenges and health benefits of implementing the short-term and permanent control measures specified in Module 6 of the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s “3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities” manual on school campuses.
- Require, on or before September 1, 2027, the technical assistance provider to make testing results received from participating LEA to date available upon request.
Arguments in support. The Environmental Working Group writes, “This bill comes at a crucial time. The [US EPA's] proposed LCRI, which may be finalized this year, offer little clarity or support to schools with lead exceedances. Notably, while the updated LCRI promotes voluntary testing of some school drinking water outlets each year, the LCRI does not require schools to test and remediate outlets, or lower water lead levels. The pending rule doesn't regulate schools, only the water systems that would perform the testing. In the absence of federal action to actually reduce lead in school drinking water, it is critical that California schools understand the scope of their lead-in-water problem, and the most health protective, cost effective, ways to remediate lead exceedances…California continues to chart the path forward for environmental justice, but it lags in lead poisoning prevention. There are 18 states with mandatory lead in water testing requirements for schools and/or childcare centers, and 23 have a statewide voluntary lead testing program. Washington State, for example, passed laws in 2021 that requires lead testing of all drinking water outlets in public schools that were built before 2016.”
Related legislation. AB 249 (Holden) of the 2023-24 Session would have required, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's potable water system outlets and to report the results to the SWB and applicable schoolsite or LEA; would have required LEAs or schoolsites, if lead levels exceeded five ppb, to perform specified actions. This bill was vetoed by the Governor, with the following message:
Minimizing childhood exposure to lead in drinking water is a critical issue. While I support the author's commitment to ensure safe drinking water in schools, this bill contains several problematic provisions and cannot be implemented as drafted. The bill constitutes an entirely new enforcement role for the State Water Board, requires the creation of a costly database for tracking compliance and enforcement, and contains an infeasible implementation timeline.
Although some funding was included in the 2023 budget for testing and remediation, the bill lacks key provisions for efficiently administering the funding and is inadequate to cover the full cost of implementation. Additionally, this bill creates a reimbursable state mandate with ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs that could range into the hundreds of millions of dollars.
In partnership with the Legislature, we enacted a budget that closed a shortfall of more than $30 billion through balanced solutions that avoided deep program cuts and protected education, health care, climate, public safety, and social service programs that are relied on by millions of Californians. This year, however, the Legislature sent me bills outside of this budget process that, if all enacted, would add nearly $19 billion of unaccounted costs in the budget, of which $11 billion would be ongoing.
With our state facing continuing economic risk and revenue uncertainty, it is important to remain disciplined when considering bills with significant fiscal implications, such as this measure.
SB 1144 (Weiner) of the 2021-22 Session would have required state agencies and public schools to complete a water efficiency and quality assessment report on their facilities, as specified. This bill would have required the operating agency, if the report identified noncompliant plumbing fixtures and appliances or contaminants, to remedy the problem at the earliest practical time, subject to dedicated funding. This bill was vetoed by the Governor, with the following message:
Improving the quality of drinking water in our state's buildings and schools is a priority we share. California’s Safe Drinking Water Act tasks the State Water Board with ensuring that public water systems provide uncontaminated, quality, potable water to consumers. The Board regulates water systems; however, oversight of internal plumbing at the individual building level is not a function of the Board. Developing new expertise to adequately implement this bill and develop regulations would require significant new staff and resources.
The scope of this bill is broad, including not just public schools, charter schools, and state buildings, but also buildings leased, maintained, and occupied by a state agency. Implementing this policy would result in substantial, ongoing General Fund and Prop 98 costs in the hundreds of millions of dollars not accounted for in the budget.
With our state facing lower-than-expected revenues over the first few months of this fiscal year, it is important to remain disciplined when it comes to spending, particularly spending that is ongoing. We must prioritize existing obligations and priorities, and this bill could force state agencies and public schools to choose between its implementation and other critical needs.
The Legislature sent measures with potential costs of well over $20 billion in one-time spending commitments and more than $10 billion in ongoing commitments not accounted for in the state budget. Bills with significant fiscal impact, such as this measure, should be considered and accounted for as part of the annual budget process.
AB 75 (O’Donnell) of the 2021-22 Session would have authorized the allocation of state funds for the replacement of school buildings that are at least 75 years old, for specified assistance to school districts with a school facility located on a military installation, as specified, and small school districts, as defined, and for the testing and remediation of lead levels in water fountains and faucets used for drinking or preparing food on schoolsites. Additionally, it would have authorized modernization grants to be used for the control, management, or abatement of lead. This bill was held in the Senate Education Committee.
AB 841 (Ting), Chapter 372, Statutes of 2020, requires the Energy Commission to develop and administer the School Noncompliant Plumbing Fixture and Appliance program to provide grants to state agencies and LEAs to replace noncompliant plumbing fixtures and appliances that fail to meet water efficiency standards and waste potable water and the energy used to convey that water, with water-conserving plumbing fixtures and appliances.
AB 48 (O’Donnell), Chapter 530, Statutes of 2019, placed the $15 billion Public Preschool, K-12, and College Health and Safety Bond Act of 2020 on the March 2020 statewide ballot and authorized the allocation of funds to test for lead in water outlets used for drinking or preparing food on schoolsites serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, that were constructed before January 1, 2010, and for the remediation of any water outlet used for drinking or preparing food with lead levels in excess of 15 ppb.
AB 2370 (Holden) Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018, requires licensed child day care facilities to, upon enrolling any child, provide parents or guardians with certain written information related to the risks and effects of lead exposure and blood lead testing recommendations and requirements, and subjects certain child day care centers to certain requirements related to testing drinking water for lead contamination levels.
SB 862 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018, appropriates $6.8 million to be used for the State Water Resources Control Board’s Safe Drinking Water for Schools grant program, including up to $1 million in TA.
AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher), Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017, requires community water systems to test lead levels, by July 1, 2019, in drinking water at all California public, K-12 school sites that were constructed before January 1, 2010.
SB 427 (Leyva), Chapter 238, Statutes of 2017, requires, by July 1, 2020, a community water system, instead of a public water system, to provide a timeline for replacement of known lead user service lines in use in its distribution system to the SWB.
SB 828 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 29, Statutes of 2016, requires the SWB to establish a grant program, in consultation with the CDE, to award grants to LEAs for the purposes of improving access to, and the quality of, drinking water in public schools serving kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and preschools and child day care facilities located on public school property. This bill appropriated $9.5 million from the General Fund to the SWB.
SB 1398 (Leyva), Chapter 731, Statutes of 2016, requires a public water system to identify and replace known leaded plumbing.
AB 685 (Eng), Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012, establishes in law a state policy that all residents of the state have a right to clean, affordable, and accessible water for human consumption, and directs relevant state agencies to implement the policy.
SB 1413 (Leno), Chapter 558, Statutes of 2010, requires a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in school food service areas by July 1, 2011, unless the governing board of a school district adopts a resolution stating that it is unable to comply with this requirement and demonstrates the reasons why it is unable to comply due to fiscal constraints or health and safety concerns.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Active San Gabriel Valley
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
American Nurses Association/California
California Dental Association
California Environmental Voters
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
California State Pipe Trades Council
Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice
Children Now
Children's Specialty Care Coalition
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Clean Water Action
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Health Now
Environmental Health Trust
Environmental Working Group
Facts Families Advocating for Chemical and Toxics Safety
Families Advocating for Chemical and Toxics Safety
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
GenUp (Generation Up)
Jonas Philanthropies
Lilla Arts
Lutheran Office of Public Policy - California
Non Toxic Communities
Nontoxic Schools
Recolte Energy
Resource Renewal Institute
Safe Passages
San Francisco Bay Area Physicians for Social Responsibility
San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility
Sierra Club California
Socal 350 Climate Action
Sunflower Alliance
Sustainable St. Helena
Sustainable St. Helena-an Environmental Alliance
Undauntedk12
Union of Concerned Scientists
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Western States Policy Advocate Union of Concerned Scientists
Wholly H2O
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Date of Hearing: March 19, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1851 (
Author:Holden) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2024
SUBJECT: Drinking water: schoolsites: lead testing pilot program
SUMMARY: Requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SSPI) of the California Department of Education (CDE) to establish a pilot program to test for and remediate lead in drinking water in the schools of 6-10 local educational agencies (LEAs); requires a technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on meeting the requirements of the pilot program, analyze the pilot program's outcomes, and provide recommendations to the state on reducing lead in drinking water in schools across California. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes several findings and declarations, including that it is the goal of the state to ensure that water served to or consumed by children while they attend school or are cared for in licensed childcare facilities contains no more than zero parts per billion (ppb) lead.
- Defines "eligible facility" to mean a facility on a school site, where the facility's plumbing was installed before January 1, 2010.
- Defines "local educational agency" to mean a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
- Defines "participating local educational agency" to mean an LEA that has been selected by the SSPI to participate in the pilot program and has consented to participation.
- Defines "potable water system outlet" to mean all cold water outlets, including single-handle faucets that dispense both hot and cold water, which are reasonably expected to be used for drinking and food preparation as depicted in the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (US EPA) "3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities" manual.
- Defines "technical assistance provider" to mean a public institution of higher education, selected by the SSPI, that provides technical assistance to participating LEAs for the purposes of the pilot program.
- Requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program to accomplish the following:
- Test for and remediate lead contamination in drinking water at eligible facilities of participating LEAs.
- Inform recommendations for addressing lead contamination in drinking water in LEAs across the state.
- Requires the SSPI to select no fewer than six and no more than 10 LEAs of varying enrollment sizes and notify them of their selection by December 1, 2025.
- Requires the SSPI, in selecting LEAs, to give priority to the following:
- LEAs with at least one school that serves pupils in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, where at least 75% of the pupils in the school are eligible for free and reduced-price meals.
- LEAs with schools that are located in a disadvantaged community, identified through the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment's (OEHHA) CalEnviroScreen tool.
- Prohibits LEAs from being required to participate in the pilot program.
- Requires an LEA choosing to participate in the pilot program to provide the following to the SSPI, within 90 days of the SSPI's notification to the LEA that it has been selected:
- Written consent; and,
- Information deemed necessary by the SSPI to confirm that the LEA has at least one eligible facility and to calculate the amount of grant funding to be issued to the LEA.
- Requires the SSPI to provide grants to participating LEAs for testing drinking water lead levels, remediating lead in drinking water at eligible facilities, and contracting with a technical assistance provider; requires that the SSPI provide grant funding to each participating LEA based on enrollment, for the most recent year available, at the schools with the eligible facilities.
- Requires any unspent funds after July 1, 2027 to be returned to the SSPI and disbursed to other grantees in need of additional funding for testing or remediation.
- Provides that administrative and managerial contracts entered into under the pilot program are exempt from specified contracting requirements, and authorizes the SSPI to award contracts on a noncompetitive bid basis as necessary to implement the pilot program.
- Requires the technical assistance provider to advise participating LEAs on the drinking water lead level sampling, remediation, and notification requirements under the pilot program.
- Requires participating LEAs to ensure that drinking water sampling meets the following requirements:
- Sampling is conducted at all of the potable water system outlets of an eligible facility;
- Sampling is conducted in accordance with Modules 4 and 5 of the US EPA's "3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities" manual, and flushing is not used to collect a first draw sample; and,
- A laboratory that evaluates a water sample for lead has current accreditation under the state's Environmental Laboratory Accreditation Program.
- Requires, if sampling results show lead levels in excess of 5 ppb for any potable water system outlet, the participating LEA to do all of the following:
- Notify the parents and guardians of the pupils attending the school where elevated lead levels were found, no later than 30 schooldays after receiving the test results during the school year, or otherwise within 60 days after receiving the test results, and provide information developed by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) on the impact of elevated lead levels on children;
- Take immediate steps to make inoperable and shut down from use all potable water system outlets where the excess lead levels may exist;
- Ensure that a lead-free source of drinking water is provided at each potable water system outlet that has been shut down due to elevated lead levels;
- Retest potable water system outlets where fixture replacement was used to remediate excess lead, to determine if replacement reduced lead levels to below 5 ppb; and,
- Conduct additional testing of potable water system outlets, as recommended by the technical assistance provider, to investigate the source of lead contamination, and consult with the technical assistance provider to identify additional remediation options, if testing continues to show lead levels in excess of 5 ppb after fixture replacement.
- Specifies that providing a lead-free source of drinking water may include, but is not limited to, replacing fixtures, providing onsite water filtration, or providing bottled water.
- Prohibits the use of a potable water system outlet until test results show lead levels below 5 ppb.
- Provides that the participating LEA shall select the remediation method, where remediation is required, except that the LEA shall not remediate by flushing the water in a potable water system outlet.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2028, participating LEAs to report to the technical assistance provider, and the technical assistance provider to report to the SSPI, specified data in a standard electronic format, including the names of participating LEAs, the identification numbers for potable water system outlets, sampling dates, the amount of lead contained in samples, and a description of remediation actions taken.
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2028, the technical assistance provider to submit a report containing a completed analysis of the pilot program's results to the SSPI.
- Requires the analysis to provide a better understanding of the level and sources of lead contamination in drinking water in California's public schools; evaluate the cost effectiveness, feasibility, and potential challenges and health benefits of installing certified, lead-removing filtration devices on school campuses in lieu of other remediation efforts; and provide recommendations on the following:
- The most health-protective and cost-effective sampling and remediation strategies for addressing drinking water lead contamination in schools, and reducing lead levels in drinking water in schools to no more than 5 ppb;
- Strategies for protecting the health of all pupils, especially those attending schools where 75% of the population are eligible for free and reduced-price meals, and schools located in disadvantaged communities identified using OEHHA's CalEnviroScreen tool;
- Addressing the needs, implementation, and capacity challenges of LEAs of varying enrollment sizes, and of varying geographic locations; and,
- Promoting effective communication between LEAs, parents and caregivers, and the public on drinking water lead level concerns, and supporting the ability of LEAs to engage in effective collaboration with partners to accomplish drinking water lead sampling and remediation.
- Requires, on or before July 15, 2028, the SSPI to transmit the above report to the California Department of Finance and the relevant policy and fiscal committees in the Legislature.
- Requires the SSPI to make the above report, and information that participating LEAs were required to provide to the technical assistance provider under the pilot program, publicly available on CDE's website.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes as policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code § 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) and California SDWA, drinking water to meet specified standards for contamination as set by the US EPA or the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board). (42 United States Code § 300(f), et seq.; Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 116270, et seq.)
- Requires a licensed child day care center that is located in a building constructed before January 1, 2010 to have its drinking water tested for lead contamination levels on or after January 1, 2020, but no later than January 1, 2023, and every five years after the date of the initial test. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(1))
- Requires a licensed child day care center subject to HSC § 1597.16(a)(1) to collect and submit drinking water samples to an accredited laboratory; requires the laboratory to, in a timely manner, electronically submit its test results to the State Water Board; and if the test results show elevated levels, requires the State Water Board to report, in a timely manner, the test results to the California Department of Social Services (CDSS). (HSC § 1597.16(a)(2)(A))
- Requires the State Water Board to post all test results received for lead in licensed child day care centers on its internet website in a timely manner and to make test results readily accessible to the public. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(2)(B)(ii))
- Requires, upon notification of elevated lead levels, a licensed child day care center to immediately make inoperable and cease using the fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist, and to obtain a potable source of water for children and staff. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(3))
- Requires a licensed child day care center to notify parents or guardians of children enrolled in the center of the requirement to test a facility's drinking water and of the test results. (HSC § 1597.16(a)(4))
- Establishes the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act and requires CDPH to conduct a sample survey of schools, for the purpose of developing risk factors to predict lead contamination in public schools. (Education Code (EC) § 32240-32245)
- Requires, pursuant to the Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act, that the CDPH work with CDE to develop voluntary guidelines for distribution to schools to ensure that lead hazards are minimized in the course of school repair and maintenance programs and abatement procedures. (EC § 32242(g))
- Prohibits, beginning January 1, 1994, the use of lead-based paint, lead plumbing and solders, or other potential sources of lead contamination in the construction of any new school facility or the modernization or renovation of any existing school facility. (EC § 32244)
- Requires a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in the food service areas of the schools under its jurisdiction, including, but not necessarily limited to, areas where reimbursable meals under the National School Lunch Program or the federal School Breakfast Program are served or consumed. Authorizes a school district to comply with this requirement by, among other means, providing cups and containers of water or soliciting or receiving donated bottled water. (EC § 38086)
- Requires a school district to notify parents, pupils, teachers, and other school personnel of drinking water results immediately if the school district is required to provide alternative drinking water sources, and authorizes a school district to comply with that requirement by providing notification of the test results during the next regularly scheduled public school meeting. (HSC § 116450)
- Prohibits the use of any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting or fixture, solder, or flux that is not "lead free" in the installation or repair of any public water system or any plumbing in a facility providing water for human consumption. (HSC § 116875(a))
- Defines "lead free" as not containing more than 0.2 percent lead when used with respect to solder and flux and not more than a weighted average of 0.25 percent lead when used with respect to the wetted surfaces of pipes and pipe fittings, plumbing fittings, and fixtures. (HSC § 116875(e))
- Requires, by July 1, 2018, a public water system to compile an inventory of known lead user service lines in use in its distribution system and identify areas that may have lead user service lines in use in its distribution system. (HSC § 116885 (a))
- Defines, for the purposes of the federal Lead and Copper Rule (LCR), a "school" to mean any building associated with public, private, or charter institutes that primarily provide teaching and learning for elementary or secondary students. (40 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) § 141.2)
- Requires each community water system to compile a list of schools and child care facilities served by the system by October 16, 2024. (40 CFR § 141.92(a)(1))
- Requires community water systems to collect samples from at least 20% of elementary schools and 20% of child care facilities served by the system per year, or according to a schedule approved by the state, until all schools and child care facilities identified on the above list have been sampled or declined to participate. (40 CFR § 141.92(c)(1))
- Requires community water systems to sample all elementary schools and child care facilities at least once in the five years following October 16, 2024. (40 CFR § 141.92(c)(2))
- Requires community water systems, after they have completed one cycle of sampling in all elementary schools and child care facilities, to sample at the request of an elementary school or child care facility. (40 CFR § 141.92(c)(3))
- Requires community water systems to sample at the request of a secondary school. (40 CFR § 141.92(c)(4))
- Requires a community water system to collect five samples per school and two samples per child care facility at outlets typically used for consumption; prohibits, except under specified conditions, outlets from having point-of-use devices. (40 CFR § 141.92(b)(1))
- Requires a community water system to collect samples from schools from specified fixture types, as follows: two drinking water fountains, one kitchen faucet used for food or drink preparation, one classroom faucet or other outlet used for drinking, and one nurse's office faucet, as available. (40 CFR § 141.92(b)(1)(i))
- Requires a community water system to sample all outlets used for consumption, if a facility has fewer than the required number of outlets. (40 CFR § 141.92(b)(1)(iii))
- Provides that the state's competitive bidding requirements for contracts for services do not apply to contracts between state agencies, or contracts between a state agency and local agency or federal agency. (Public Contract Code § 10335(a))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author: "Lead consumption among youth and disenfranchised communities occurs at a higher rate. Assisting schools with the resources and appropriate standards to ensure the water fountains our children drink from are safe will help us protect our schools, students and communities. Children do not become more resistant to lead’s toxic effects once they transition from daycare to kindergarten, so California should take the responsible step of aligning childcare and school lead testing standards."
Human right to water: In 2012, the Legislature enacted Assembly Bill (AB) 685 (Eng, Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012), making California the first state in the nation with a Human Right to Water law. AB 685 established a state policy that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitation. However, water supply issues, climate change, contaminants, aging infrastructure, and failing and at-risk systems, especially in disadvantaged communities, are among the multiple factors that continue to challenge progress in implementing the Human Right to Water.
Short- and long-term consequences of childhood lead exposure: According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), research shows that there is no safe level of lead in drinking water and even very low levels can have negative and irreversible health effects, especially for children and pregnant persons. Because of lead's health impacts, the US EPA maintains a maximum contaminant level goal of zero, and some organizations, such as the American Association of Pediatrics, have called for national and state efforts to bring lead levels in drinking water closer to zero ppb. The CDC states that childhood lead exposure can seriously harm a child's health and cause well-documented adverse effects, including brain and nervous system damage, slowed growth and development, learning and behavior problems, and hearing and speech problems. These health impacts can in turn lead to decreased attention and underperformance in school among lead-exposed children. One study by Evens et al. (2015), published in Environmental Health, examined data for nearly 58,000 children attending Chicago public schools and found that increasing blood lead levels were associated with increasing failure rates on standardized reading and math tests. Among children with the lowest blood lead levels, even small increases in blood lead levels were associated with what the authors described as "steeper failure rates."
While children, pregnant persons, and developing fetuses are particularly susceptible to the harmful effects of lead, lead in blood can also result in an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, and kidney and nervous system problems for adults. Because the human body can store lead in bone, even temporary environmental exposures in childhood can result in many years to decades of recurring or ongoing elevations in blood lead levels. One study by Nie et al. (2009), published in the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, reported that lead stored in bone can release back into the blood, resulting in elevated blood lead levels during periods of illness (e.g., with skeletal or dental disease) and during multiple life stages, including childhood, pregnancy, lactation, and menopause.
Inequities in childhood lead exposure: According to the CDC, people with low incomes and people of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with outdated infrastructure, and are thus more likely to be exposed to lead-based paint and pipes, faucets, and plumbing fixtures containing lead. Evens et al. (2015) found that among nearly 58,000 children attending Chicago public schools, blood lead levels were highest in black children (relative to Hispanic and white children) and higher in low-income children.
Children from low-income families and communities of color can also be further disadvantaged through the cumulative impacts of lead and other challenges they may face, including higher rates of poverty, malnutrition, exposure to multiple pollutants, and enrollment in under-resourced schools. A 2020 study published in Nature Medicine (Marshall et al.) reported that the combination of lead exposure and being from a low-income family can result in worse impacts for children, when compared to children who have only one of these risk factors. Specifically, children from low-income families and with the highest risk levels for lead exposure showed reduced cognitive performance and changes in parts of the brain that regulate the capacity for problem solving, planning, critical thinking, and memory.
The state of California uses various means of evaluating socioeconomic disadvantage among children and families, and the cumulative impacts of environmental, health, and socioeconomic burdens on communities. For example, educational programs like the state's Expanded Learning Opportunities Program have used student eligibility for federal Free and Reduced-Price Meals—provided to children from families that meet specified income limits based on federal income poverty guidelines—as a proxy for identifying LEAs with concentrations of poverty. In addition, a screening tool called CalEnviroScreen, developed by OEHHA, has been used to target state climate investments to disadvantaged communities that are disproportionately burdened by multiple sources of pollution and have population characteristics that increase their sensitivity to pollution. AB 1851 targets the pilot program's resources—including grants and technical assistance—to high need schools by requiring the SSPI, when selecting LEA participants, to prioritize LEAs with at least one school where at least 75% of the students are eligible for Free and Reduced-Price Meals, or LEAs with schools that are located in disadvantaged communities identified using CalEnviroScreen.
Sources of childhood exposure to lead: The US EPA states that children can be exposed to lead in paint, dust, soil, air, and food, as well as drinking water, and that drinking water can make up 20% or more of a person’s total lead exposure. According to a 2012 article published in the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (Brown and Margolis), lead is unlikely to be present in source water, unless a specific source of contamination exists. More commonly, lead enters drinking water through the corrosion of plumbing materials and solder that contain lead. Lead can enter a building's drinking water by leaching from lead service lines, lead solder used in copper piping, and from brass fixtures. The amount of lead in tap water can depend on several factors, including the age and material of the pipes and fixtures, concentration of lead in water delivered by the public utility, and corrosiveness of the water. More corrosive water can cause greater leaching from pipes.
Compared to other states, California has a relatively small share of the nation's lead service lines (defined under the LCR, described further below, as a "portion of pipe that is made of lead, which connects the water main to the building inlet" (40 CFR § 141.2)). In 2016, the American Water Works Association released a national survey of lead service line occurrence, finding that California had, at that time, about 1 percent of the nation's lead service lines (or 65,000 out of 6.1 million lead service lines nationally). Under state law—added by Senate Bill (SB) 1398 (Leyva, Chapter 731, Statutes of 2016) and amended by SB 427 (Leyva, Chapter 238, Statutes of 2017)—all community water systems were required to compile an inventory of known lead user service lines in its distribution system by July 1, 2018. Community water systems were further required to propose a schedule by July 1, 2020 to replace all known lead user service lines and user service lines constructed of unknown material.
State and federal laws also regulate the lead content of fixtures. Beginning January 1, 2010, California law (AB 1953, Chan, Chapter 853, Statutes of 2006) banned for sale and use any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting, or fixture intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking that is not "lead free." That law defines "lead free" as not more than 0.2 percent lead when used with respect to solder and flux; not more than a weighted average of 0.25 percent when used with respect to the wetted surfaces of pipes and pipe fittings, plumbing fittings, and fixtures; and not more than 8 percent when used with respect to pipes and pipe fittings. This definition applies to kitchen faucets, bathroom faucets, and any other endpoint device intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking. AB 1851 requires testing of potable water system outlets in facilities in which the plumbing was installed before January 1, 2010, when AB 1953 went into effect.
Lead in drinking water and schools: In a 2021 report, How States Are Handling Lead in School Drinking Water, the National Association of State Boards of Education states: "Due in part to their frequent closures and uneven water use patterns during weekends, holidays, summer break, or extenuating circumstances like the pandemic, the topic of lead in drinking water is of special relevance to schools. Water is more likely to stagnate in school pipes and fixtures during closures, potentially making the water more corrosive and increasing the chances that lead leaches into the water." The impacts of lead in drinking water on children's health gained national attention after news broke of the water crisis in Flint, Michigan. In 2014, a switch in Flint’s water sources caused lead to leach from service lines into drinking water at dangerously high levels. In the wake of the Flint drinking water crisis, part of the national conversation has focused on strategies for improving the safety of drinking water in schools and child care facilities and the importance of lead testing.
The federal Lead and Copper Rule and subsequent revision: In 1991, the US EPA promulgated the Lead and Copper Rule (LCR) to minimize lead and copper in drinking water. On January 15, 2021, the US EPA issued substantial changes, called the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions (LCRR), to the LCR, to provide greater and more effective protection of public health. The LCRR contain federal regulations that would, for the first time, require community water systems to test for lead in drinking water in schools and child care facilities. If unchanged by the Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI; described below), rules established under the LCRR will require community water systems, beginning on October 16, 2024, to conduct lead sampling at a certain number of faucets at each elementary school and child care facility they serve within five years; provide testing to secondary schools upon request during the 5 years of mandatory elementary and child care facility testing; and provide testing to elementary schools and child care facilities upon request after the first round of mandatory testing. Notably, the US EPA states that the sampling efforts required under the LCRR should not serve as a replacement for the more comprehensive testing recommended in the agency's "3Ts for Reducing Lead in Drinking Water in Schools and Child Care Facilities" manual, which recommends, for example, that schools sample all fixtures used for consumption. This guidance is consistent with AB 1851's requirement for testing at all potable water system outlets in a school.
The Lead and Copper Rule Improvements: On January 20, 2021, federal Executive Order 13990 directed all federal agencies to undertake review and action to address the promulgation of federal regulations during the prior four years. The LCRR were specifically identified as requiring review. As a result, the US EPA delayed the effective and compliance dates established in the LCRR to December 16, 2021 and October 16, 2024, respectively. The US EPA committed to propose and revise the LCRR by October 2024 with the LCRI.
On November 30, 2023, the US EPA announced the proposed LCRI, which maintain most of the LCRR requirements for community water systems to conduct public education and offer sampling to schools and child care facilities. The LCRI clarify that community water systems do not have to sample in schools and child care facilities that underwent full plumbing replacement after January 1, 2014, or the date that a state adopted standards meeting the federal definition of "lead free" (January 1, 2010, in California). The LCRI, like the LCRR, do not require sampling at all potable drinking water outlets, or remediation if sampling reveals lead contamination in a school's drinking water. The US EPA states that the LCRI are intended to provide a "baseline level of sampling information," and that "States are likely better positioned than EPA to administer lead testing and remediation programs because States can establish regulations for schools and child care facilities that would provide for greater consistency of education, testing, remediation activities, and public communication across all schools and child care facilities throughout a State."
State action on lead in drinking water: Lead has been listed under Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects, and has been on the list of chemicals known to cause cancer since 1992. In 2009, OEHHA established a public health goal of 0.2 ppb for lead in drinking water. In addition, the State Water Board enforces the California Lead and Copper Rule (CA LCR), which is aligned with the federal LCR to protect the public’s drinking water from metals that can adversely affect public health. The CA LCR requires water systems to monitor lead and copper levels at consumers’ taps. If the action level for lead—which is aligned with the federal LCR at 15 ppb—is exceeded, state regulations require installation or modifications to corrosion control treatment and public notification.
Under the state's Lead-Safe Schools Protection Act, originally passed in the mid-1990s, the CDPH conducted a sample survey of schools to determine the likely extent and distribution of childhood lead exposure from paint, soil in play areas, drinking water, and other potential sources. The resulting report, based on data collected from 200 randomly selected schools between 1995 and 1997, was submitted to the Legislature in 1998. The report demonstrates that lead in drinking water in schools constitutes a long-standing concern in California, finding that an estimated 18.1% of California schools were, at that time, likely to have lead in drinking water at or above the federal action level (15 ppb). The report concluded that "in some situations drinking water from school water outlets could contribute to children's lead exposure, and demonstrate a need for monitoring lead from drinking water outlets in schools."
In 2017, the State Water Board required approximately 1,200 community water systems to test the drinking water for lead at any school that requested it. The same year, AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017) was enacted to require community water systems that serve a schoolsite built before January 1, 2010, to test for lead in the potable faucets of the schoolsite on or before July 1, 2019. Although AB 1851 has some similarities to AB 746, there are notable differences. For example, AB 1851 requires LEAs to take notification and remediation steps if the level of lead exceeds 5 ppb, while AB 746 required an action level of 15 ppb. Also, AB 1851 requires testing at every potable water outlet of an eligible facility, while AB 746 did not specify the number of outlets where testing was required.
In 2018, EdSource concluded after analyzing data on lead testing from nearly 3,700 California schools that "gaps in [AB 746]…could leave children vulnerable to the toxic metal." The analysis found that 4 percent of schools tested—about 150 schools—recorded a lead level over the 15 ppb action level specified in AB 746. The analysis also showed that at 897 schools, at least one water outlet tested between 5 and 15 ppb, which required no remediation under AB 746. A 2020 study of AB 746 implementation in Preventing Chronic Disease (Umunna et al.) found that among 240 randomly selected California public schools, roughly 3% of schools that tested had at least one sample that exceeded 15 ppb. Among the schools they examined, the authors estimated that an action level of 5 ppb would have resulted in a 9-fold increase in the proportion of schools required to take steps to remediate their drinking water. The authors also found a wide range in implementation among schools, stating that "although some schools tested only one tap, others tested as many as 76. Schools that test fewer taps may be less likely to adequately capture the risk of elevated lead in drinking water than schools that test a greater number of taps." A 2021 report by the National Association of State Boards of Education, How States Are Handling Lead in School Drinking Water, states that because it is not possible to see, smell, or taste lead in drinking water, testing is the only way to identify its presence. The report recommends that schools test all cooking and drinking water sources, since lead levels can vary across taps, seasons, and with changes in water usage, temperature, the amount of time water sits in pipes, and the flow rate at the time of collection.
In 2018, the Legislature enacted AB 2370 (Holden, Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018), which requires licensed child day care centers operating in buildings constructed before January 1, 2010 to have their drinking water tested for lead by January 1, 2023, and every five years after the initial test. AB 2370 also mandated collaboration between the CDSS, which oversees child care programs, and the State Water Board in the implementation of the bill's requirements.
Similar to AB 1851, AB 2370 requires centers to:
- Cease using fountains and faucets where elevated lead levels may exist;
- Obtain a potable source of water for children and staff; and,
- Notify parents or guardians of the test results
Subsequent written directives from the CDSS specified an action level of 5 ppb, with a minimum reporting threshold of 1 ppb, for lead in water in child care centers. Through SB 862 (Budget Committee, Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018), the California State Legislature appropriated $5 million, which the State Water Board is using to assist child care centers with the costs of testing and fixture replacement.
Arguments in support: A coalition of supporting organizations writes:
"This bill comes at a crucial time. The [US EPA's] proposed Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI), which may be finalized this year, offer little clarity or support to schools with lead exceedances. Notably, while the updated LCRI promotes voluntary testing of some school drinking water outlets each year, the LCRI does not require schools to test and remediate outlets, or lower water lead levels. The pending rule doesn't regulate schools, only the water systems that would perform the testing. In the absence of federal action to actually reduce lead in school drinking water, it is critical that California schools understand the scope of their lead-in-water problem, and the most health protective, cost effective, ways to remediate lead exceedances…California continues to chart the path forward for environmental justice, but it lags in lead poisoning prevention. There are 18 states with mandatory lead in water testing requirements for schools and/or childcare centers, and 23 have a statewide voluntary lead testing program. Washington State, for example, passed laws in 2021 that requires lead testing of all drinking water outlets in public schools that were built before 2016.
For these reasons, we urge you to support AB 1851, and protect thousands of children, educators, and staff from harmful lead exposure."
Arguments in opposition: Writing in opposition to a prior version of AB 1851 (as introduced on January 17, 2024), the California Association of School Business Officials states:
"We appreciate the bill's intention aimed to reduce lead exposure by aligning with California's current permissible exposure levels to those in childcare facilities, however, we express the following concerns:
- Cost for the potential burden on districts chosen for the pilot program. With no funding allocated and concerns about feasibility, we are concerned that the strain on resources could be significant if such measures are implemented without adequate support.
- Scope for how parameters would be established around which school districts would be selected to participate in the pilot program and how many.
- Undefined scope of who would be considered a nonprofit technical assistant organization."
This bill: AB 1851 requires the SSPI to establish a pilot program that will help high need schools and schools in disadvantaged communities conduct comprehensive testing and remediation for lead in drinking water. By requiring a technical assistance provider to compile lessons learned from the pilot program, AB 1851 may also provide California with information that can help the state identify next steps for scaling up statewide efforts to reduce, to the greatest extent possible, students' exposure to lead in drinking water.
Double referral: Should AB 1851 be approved by the Assembly Environmental Safety & Toxic Materials Committee, it will be re-referred to the Assembly Education Committee.
Related legislation:
- AB 249 (Holden, 2023). Would have required, on or before January 1, 2027, a community water system that serves a schoolsite receiving federal Title I funds to test for lead in each of the schoolsite's potable water system outlets and to perform specified actions, if lead levels exceeded 5 ppb. This bill was vetoed.
- AB 1931 (Rivas, 2022). Would have required a community water system to create an inventory of lead service lines in its distribution system and a timeline for the replacement or removal of lead service lines. This bill was held on the suspense file in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 1144 (Wiener, 2022). Would have required, by January 1, 2027, the operator of a building owned or operated by a state agency or public school to complete a water efficiency and quality assessment report for each covered building. This bill was vetoed.
- AB 100 (Holden, Chapter 692, Statutes of 2021). Requires, commencing January 1, 2023, manufacturer compliance with a specified lower lead leaching standard for faucets and other end point devices used for providing drinking water; prohibits sales of products that do not meet the new standard beginning July 1, 2023; and, requires labeling of products that comply with the definition of "lead free" to indicate compliance in an easily identifiable manner.
- AB 2060 (Holden, 2020). Would have established a "lead free" performance standard for end use plumbing fixtures, required labeling of such products, and set an implementation schedule for compliance with the new standard. This bill was held on the suspense file in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2370 (Holden, Chapter 676, Statutes of 2018). Requires licensed child day care facilities to, upon enrolling any child, provide parents or guardians with certain written information related to the risks and effects of lead exposure and blood lead testing recommendations and requirements, and subjects certain child day care centers to requirements related to testing drinking water for lead contamination levels.
- SB 862 (Budget Committee, Chapter 449, Statutes of 2018). Appropriated $5 million to the State Water Board to provide grants or contracts for drinking water testing for lead at licensed child care centers, remediation of lead in plumbing and drinking water fixtures, and technical assistance for licensed child day care providers to apply for testing and remediation.
- AB 746 (Gonzalez Fletcher, Chapter 746, Statutes of 2017). Requires a community water system that serves a schoolsite built before January 1, 2010 to test for lead in the potable water system of the schoolsite on or before July 1, 2019.
- SB 427 (Leyva, Chapter 238, Statutes of 2017). Requires, by July 1, 2020, a community water system that has identified lead user service lines in use in its distribution system to provide a timeline for replacement of those service lines to the State Water Board.
- SB 1398 (Leyva, Chapter 731, Statutes of 2016). Requires a public water system to identify and replace known leaded plumbing.
- AB 2124 (E. Garcia, Lackey, 2016). Would have required a public water system to include in its water analysis samples from schools, day care facilities, and health care facilities, to the extent those locations are within the public water system. This bill was held in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
- SB 334 (Leyva, 2015). Would have required the CDPH to test drinking water for lead at a sample of schoolsites, and establish the intent of the Legislature to prioritize testing of schoolsites that have high risk factors. This bill was vetoed.
- AB 1953 (Chan, Chapter 853, Statutes of 2006). Banned for sale and use any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting, or fixture intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking that is not "lead free."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Children Now (CO-SPONSOR)
Environmental Working Group (CO-SPONSOR)
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Active San Gabriel Valley
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
California Dental Association
California Environmental Voters
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice
Children's Specialty Care Coalition
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Clean Water Action
Climate Health Now
Environmental Health Trust
Families Advocating for Chemical and Toxics Safety
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Jonas Philanthropies
Lutheran Office of Public Policy - California
Recolte Energy
Safe Passages
Socal 350 Climate Action
Sustainable St. Helena-An Environmental Alliance
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Western States Policy Advocate Union of Concerned Scientists
Opposition
California Association of School Business Officials (CASBO)
Analysis Prepared by: Naomi Ondrasek / E.S. & T.M. /
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):