AB 1865: Personal income taxes: exclusion: homeownership savings accounts.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-18
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Personal Income Tax Law, in modified conformity with federal income tax laws, allows various exclusions from gross income, and allows various deductions in computing the income that is subject to the taxes imposed by that law, including miscellaneous itemized deductions that are allowed only to the extent that the aggregate amount of those deductions exceeds 2% of adjusted gross income. generally defines gross income as income from whatever source derived, except as specifically excluded, and provides various exclusions from gross income for purposes of computing tax liability.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, would allow a deduction, not to exceed specified amounts, of the amount a qualified taxpayer, as defined, contributed in any taxable year to a homeownership savings account and would exclude from gross income any income earned on the moneys contributed to a homeownership savings account. The bill would provide that a qualified taxpayer may withdraw amounts from a homeownership savings account to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses, defined as expenses paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a principal residence in this state. The bill would provide that any amount withdrawn from that account that is not used for these expenses would be included as income for that taxpayer. The bill would define various terms for its purposes. 2025, and before January 1, 2030, would exclude from gross income any amount accruing to a first-time homeownership savings account, as defined, whose beneficiary is a qualified taxpayer. The bill would also, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, and before January 1, 2030, exclude from gross income any amount withdrawn from a first-time homeownership savings account that is used to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account. The bill would define a first-time homeownership savings account as an account with a financial institution that is designated as a first-time homeownership savings account by the person establishing the account that meets specified requirements.
Existing law requires a bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain, among other things, specific goals, purposes, and objectives the tax expenditure will achieve, detailed performance indicators, and data collection requirements.
This bill would include additional information required for any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
The Personal Income Tax Law, in modified conformity with federal income tax laws, allows various exclusions from gross income, and allows various deductions in computing the income that is subject to the taxes imposed by that law, including miscellaneous itemized deductions that are allowed only to the extent that the aggregate amount of those deductions exceeds 2% of adjusted gross income.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, would allow a deduction, not to exceed specified amounts, of the amount a qualified taxpayer, as defined, contributed in any taxable year to a homeownership savings account and would exclude from gross income any income earned on the moneys contributed to a homeownership savings account. The bill would provide that a qualified taxpayer may withdraw amounts from a homeownership savings account to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses, defined as expenses paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a principal residence in this state. The bill would provide that any amount withdrawn from that account that is not used for these expenses would be included as income for that taxpayer. The bill would define various terms for its purposes.
Existing law requires a bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain, among other things, specific goals, purposes, and objectives the tax expenditure will achieve, detailed performance indicators, and data collection requirements.
This bill would include additional information required for any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
The Personal Income Tax Law, in modified conformity with federal income tax laws, allows various exclusions from gross income, and allows various deductions in computing the income that is subject to the taxes imposed by that law, including miscellaneous itemized deductions that are allowed only to the extent that the aggregate amount of those deductions exceeds 2% of adjusted gross income.
This bill, on and after January 1, 2024, would allow a deduction, not to exceed specified amounts, of the amount a qualified taxpayer, as defined, contributed in any taxable year to a homeownership savings account and would exclude from gross income any income earned on the moneys contributed to a homeownership savings account. The bill would provide that a qualified taxpayer may withdraw amounts from a homeownership savings account to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses, defined as expenses paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a principal residence in this state. The bill would provide that any amount withdrawn from that account that is not used for these expenses would be included as income for that taxpayer. The bill would define various terms for its purposes.
Existing law requires a bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain, among other things, specific goals, purposes, and objectives the tax expenditure will achieve, detailed performance indicators, and data collection requirements.
This bill would include additional information required for any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, and before January 1, 2029, 2030, gross income does not include, under the same conditions as provided in Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, any income accruing during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, as defined in Section 17204.5. include the following:
(1)Any amount accruing to a first-time homeownership savings account whose beneficiary is a qualified taxpayer.
(2)Any amount withdrawn from a first-time homeownership savings account that is used to pay for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)First-time homeownership savings account means an account with a financial institution that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)Is designated as a first-time homeownership savings account by the accountholder.
(B)Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.
(C)The written governing instrument creating the account provides for the following:
(i)All contributions to the account are required to be in cash.
(ii)The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this section, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.
(D)Is the only first-time homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.
(2)Principal residence has the same meaning as that term is used in Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Qualified homeownership savings expenses means expenses, including a downpayment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayers principal residence, within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, in this state for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the first-time homeownership savings account.
(4)Qualified taxpayer means an individual, or individuals spouse, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence during the preceding three-year period ending either on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, contribution to a first-time homeownership savings account or on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the first-time homeownership savings account.
(c)Any amount withdrawn from a first-time homeownership savings account shall be included in the income of the qualified taxpayer for the taxable year in which the payment or distribution is made, unless the payment or distribution is used to pay for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account.
(b)(d)(1)For purposes of complying with Section 41, the goal, purpose, objective, performance indicators, and data collection requirements for the exclusion allowed by this section shall be as specified in subdivision (e) of Section 17204.5. as it applies to the exclusion provided by this section, the Legislature finds and declares as follows:
(A)The specific goal, purpose, and objective of the exclusion is to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. Home ownership is the key to a strong and healthy California but there is little state and federal assistance for first-time home buyers.
(B)The performance indicators for the Legislature to use in determining whether the exclusion achieves its stated goal shall be the following:
(i)The number of taxpayers excluding income pursuant to this section.
(ii)The average amount of the income excluded.
(2)(A)By May 1, 2027, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board shall submit a written report, in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, to the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, the Assembly Committee on Budget, the Senate and Assembly Committees on Appropriations, the Senate Committee on Revenue and Taxation, and the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation. The report shall detail, to the extent the information is available, the number of taxpayers excluding income pursuant to this section and the average amount of income excluded.
(B)The disclosure provisions of this paragraph shall be treated as an exception to Section 19542.
(c)(e)This section shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2029, 2030, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 17204.5 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:17204.5.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, there shall be allowed a deduction in the amount equal to the amount contributed by a qualified taxpayer during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, not to exceed the amounts specified in subdivision (b).(b)The deduction allowed under subdivision (a) shall not exceed the following amounts:(1)Twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) for qualified taxpayers filing a joint, head of household, or surviving spouse, as defined in Section 17046, return.(2)Ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the case of a qualified taxpayer filing a return other than as described in paragraph (1).(c)Any amount withdrawn from a homeownership savings account shall be included in the income of the qualified taxpayer for the taxable year in which the payment or distribution is made, unless the payment or distribution is used to pay for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account.(d)For purposes of this section:(1)Homeownership savings account means a trust that meets all of the following requirements:(A)Is designated as a homeownership savings account by the trustee.(B)Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of any qualified taxpayer establishing the account where the written governing instrument creating the account provides for the following:(i)All contributions to the account are required to be in cash.(ii)The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this section, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.(C)Is, except as otherwise required or authorized by this section, subject to the same requirements and limitations as an individual retirement account established under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.(D)Is the only homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.(2)Qualified homeownership savings expenses means expenses, including a downpayment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayers principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, in this state for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the homeownership savings account.(3)Qualified taxpayer means any individual, or individuals spouse, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, during the preceding three-year period ending either on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, contribution to a homeownership savings account or on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the individuals, or individuals spouses, homeownership savings account.(4)Trustee shall have the same meaning as that term has under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.(e)(1)For purposes of complying with Section 41, as it applies to the exclusion allowed by Section 17141.7 and the deduction allowed by this section, the Legislature finds and declares as follows:(A)The specific goal, purpose, and objective of the exclusion and deduction is to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. Home ownership is the key to a strong and healthy California but there is little state and federal assistance for first time home buyers.(B)To measure whether the exclusion and the deduction achieve their intended purpose, the Franchise Tax Board shall prepare a written report on the following information, to the extent the information is available:(i)The number of taxpayers allowed a deduction pursuant to this section.(ii)The average amount of the deduction allowed.(2)By May 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board shall provide the written report prepared pursuant to paragraph (1) to the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, the Assembly Committee on Budget, the Senate and Assembly Committees on Appropriations, the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance, and the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation.(3)The disclosure requirements of this subdivision shall be treated as exceptions to Section 19542.(f)This section shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 3.SEC. 2.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, gross income does not include, under the same conditions as provided in Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, any income accruing during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, as defined in Section 17204.5.
(b)For purposes of complying with Section 41, the goal, purpose, objective, performance indicators, and data collection requirements for the exclusion allowed by this section shall be as specified in subdivision (e) of Section 17204.5.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 17204.5 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:17204.5.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, there shall be allowed a deduction in the amount equal to the amount contributed by a qualified taxpayer during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, not to exceed the amounts specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The deduction allowed under subdivision (a) shall not exceed the following amounts:
(1)Twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) for qualified taxpayers filing a joint, head of household, or surviving spouse, as defined in Section 17046, return.
(2)Ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the case of a qualified taxpayer filing a return other than as described in paragraph (1).
(c)Any amount withdrawn from a homeownership savings account shall be included in the income of the qualified taxpayer for the taxable year in which the payment or distribution is made, unless the payment or distribution is used to pay for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Homeownership savings account means a trust that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)Is designated as a homeownership savings account by the trustee.
(B)Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of any qualified taxpayer establishing the account where the written governing instrument creating the account provides for the following:
(i)All contributions to the account are required to be in cash.
(ii)The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this section, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.
(C)Is, except as otherwise required or authorized by this section, subject to the same requirements and limitations as an individual retirement account established under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.
(D)Is the only homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.
(2)Qualified homeownership savings expenses means expenses, including a downpayment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayers principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, in this state for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the homeownership savings account.
(3)Qualified taxpayer means any individual, or individuals spouse, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, during the preceding three-year period ending either on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, contribution to a homeownership savings account or on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the individuals, or individuals spouses, homeownership savings account.
(4)Trustee shall have the same meaning as that term has under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.
(e)(1)For purposes of complying with Section 41, as it applies to the exclusion allowed by Section 17141.7 and the deduction allowed by this section, the Legislature finds and declares as follows:
(A)The specific goal, purpose, and objective of the exclusion and deduction is to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. Home ownership is the key to a strong and healthy California but there is little state and federal assistance for first time home buyers.
(B)To measure whether the exclusion and the deduction achieve their intended purpose, the Franchise Tax Board shall prepare a written report on the following information, to the extent the information is available:
(i)The number of taxpayers allowed a deduction pursuant to this section.
(ii)The average amount of the deduction allowed.
(2)By May 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board shall provide the written report prepared pursuant to paragraph (1) to the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, the Assembly Committee on Budget, the Senate and Assembly Committees on Appropriations, the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance, and the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
(3)The disclosure requirements of this subdivision shall be treated as exceptions to Section 19542.
(f)This section shall remain in effect only until December 1, 2029, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, gross income does not include, under the same conditions as provided in Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, any income accruing during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, as defined in Section 17204.5.
(b)For purposes of complying with Section 41, the goal, purpose, objective, performance indicators, and data collection requirements for the exclusion allowed by this section shall be as specified in subdivision (e) of Section 17204.5.
SEC. 2.Section 17204.5 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:17204.5.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2024, there shall be allowed a deduction in the amount equal to the amount contributed by a qualified taxpayer during the taxable year to a homeownership savings account, not to exceed the amounts specified in subdivision (b).
(b)The deduction allowed under subdivision (a) shall not exceed the following amounts:
(1)Twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) for qualified taxpayers filing a joint, head of household, or surviving spouse, as defined in Section 17046, return.
(2)Ten thousand dollars ($10,000) in the case of a qualified taxpayer filing a return other than as described in paragraph (1).
(c)Any amount withdrawn from a homeownership savings account shall be included in the income of the qualified taxpayer for the taxable year in which the payment or distribution is made, unless the payment or distribution is used to pay for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer who established the account.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Homeownership savings account means a trust that meets all of the following requirements:
(A)Is designated as a homeownership savings account by the trustee.
(B)Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of any qualified taxpayer establishing the account where the written governing instrument creating the account provides for the following:
(i)All contributions to the account are required to be in cash.
(ii)The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this section, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.
(C)Is, except as otherwise required or authorized by this section, subject to the same requirements and limitations as an individual retirement account established under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.
(D)Is the only homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.
(2)Qualified homeownership savings expenses means expenses, including a downpayment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayers principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, in this state for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the homeownership savings account.
(3)Qualified taxpayer means any individual, or individuals spouse, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence within the meaning of Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to exclusion of gain from sale of principal residence, during the preceding three-year period ending either on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, contribution to a homeownership savings account or on the date of the individuals, or individuals spouses, purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the individuals, or individuals spouses, homeownership savings account.
(4)Trustee shall have the same meaning as that term has under Section 408 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to individual retirement accounts, and any regulations adopted thereunder.
(e)(1)For purposes of complying with Section 41, as it applies to the exclusion allowed by Section 17141.7 and the deduction allowed by this section, the Legislature finds and declares as follows:
(A)The specific goal, purpose, and objective of the exclusion and deduction is to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. Home ownership is the key to a strong and healthy California but there is little state and federal assistance for first time home buyers.
(B)To measure whether the exclusion and the deduction achieve their intended purpose, the Franchise Tax Board shall prepare a written report on the following information, to the extent the information is available:
(i)The number of taxpayers allowed a deduction pursuant to this section.
(ii)The average amount of the deduction allowed.
(2)By May 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board shall provide the written report prepared pursuant to paragraph (1) to the Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, the Assembly Committee on Budget, the Senate and Assembly Committees on Appropriations, the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance, and the Assembly Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
(3)The disclosure requirements of this subdivision shall be treated as exceptions to Section 19542.
SEC. 3.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 29). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 4, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to REV. & TAX. suspense file. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 12, 2024 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jan 19, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 18. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 29, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Credit Union League | ** Support | |
| California Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO | ** Against | |
| California Teachers Association | ** Against | |
| Habitat For Humanity California | ** Support | |
| Habitat for Humanity Greater Fresno Area | ** Support | |
| Housing Action Coalition | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1865
Author:(Jim Patterson) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill excludes from gross income, under the Personal Income Tax (PIT) Law, interest and investment gains accruing to a homeownership savings account (HSA).
Specifically, this bill:
- Excludes from gross income, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, and before January 1, 2030, any amount accruing to a first-time HSA whose beneficiary is a qualified taxpayer, as well as any amount withdrawn from the account to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses.
- Defines a “first-time HSA” to mean an account with a financial institution that is designated as a first-time HSA and established by a “qualified taxpayer,” which means an individual or their spouse who had no present ownership in a principal residence during a preceding three-year period.
- Declares the goals and performance indicators of the new exclusion and requires, by May 1, 2027, the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to annually submit a report with specified data to the Legislature.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- General Fund (GF) revenue loss of $830,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2024-25, $1.5 million in FY 2025-26, and $1.7 million in FY 2026-27. By decreasing PIT revenue, this bill also likely decreases Proposition 98 GF spending by approximately 40% of the GF revenue loss (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee).
- Costs of an unknown, but potentially significant, amount to FTB to administer the exclusion and prepare the report.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
We aim to empower families by providing them with the chance to save money tax-free for their inaugural home purchase. Considering the already elevated cost of living in California, coupled with the considerable burden on first-time homebuyers, our goal is to lighten their financial load and make the dream of homeownership more attainable.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by the California Association of Realtors (CAR), California Credit Union League, and various housing organizations. CAR argues this bill “seeks to provide a resource for purchasing a home which is one of the most valuable assets in achieving wealth building opportunities for the state’s diverse communities.”
This bill is opposed by the California Teachers Association (CTA) and California Federation of Teachers, with the former arguing that while this bill is well intended, “CTA does not support this approach, as it would reduce overall funding for education. CTA believes that Proposition 98 should be protected from reductions through the creation of new or expanding existing tax expenditures, especially as the state is facing a budget deficit.”
- Tax-advantaged Savings Accounts. Federal and state law authorizes several types of retirement savings plans that allow reduced or deferred income taxes to encourage workers to save for retirement. Generally, federal law imposes a 10% withdrawal penalty on an early distribution from an individual retirement account (IRA), with a similar 2.5% penalty under state law. However, recognizing that some significant events might require a person to withdraw money from their retirement account earlier than expected, federal and state law allow a waiver of the early withdrawal penalty in certain situations – including, notably, a distribution of up to $10,000 used for a first-time home purchase. This bill creates a separate tax-advantaged savings mechanism for first-time homebuyers in California by excluding any interest or investment income accruing to a first-time HSA, as well as funds withdrawn to pay for qualified homeownership savings expenses, from gross income.
Generally, state conformity with federal rules promotes greater simplicity and eases administration of complex tax laws. This bill would bring California further out of conformity with federal law, as any income excluded by this bill would still be subject to federal income tax. This bill also allows an individual who has previously owned a home to qualify for this tax benefit and does not require a homeowner who utilizes the tax benefit to reside in the home as a principal residence for a specific period. Thus, after the home purchase, the homeowner could transition the property into an investment property.
- Prior Legislation. AB 1317 (Brough), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill, except AB 1317 included additional limitations on the household income of a qualified taxpayer and the value of a home that may be purchased. AB 1317 was held on this committee’s suspense file.
AB 1979 (Bonta), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was similar to AB 1317. AB 1979 was held on this committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Jacqui Irwin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1865 (
Author:Jim Patterson) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
SUSPENSE
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Personal income taxes: exclusion: homeownership savings accounts
SUMMARY: Excludes from gross income, under the Personal Income Tax (PIT) Law, interest and investment gains accruing to a "homeownership savings account", as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Excludes from gross income, for the 2025 through 2030 taxable years, any income accrued during the taxable year to a "first-time homeownership savings account" whose beneficiary is a "qualified taxpayer."
- Excludes from gross income any amount withdrawn from a "homeownership savings account" that is used to pay for the "qualified homeownership savings expenses" of a "qualified taxpayer" who established the account.
- Provides that any amount withdrawn from a first-time homeownership savings account that is not used for qualified homeownership savings expenses of a "qualified taxpayer" must be included in gross income.
- Defines a "qualified taxpayer" as an individual, or a married couple if filing a joint return, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence during the preceding three-year period prior to the date of the contribution to a homeownership savings account or purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the homeownership savings account.
- Defines a "first-time homeownership savings account" as an account with a financial institution that meets all of the following requirements:
- Is designated as a first-time homeownership savings account by the accountholder;
- Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of any qualified taxpayer establishing the account where the written governing instrument creating the account provides for both of the following:
- All contributions to the account are required to be in cash; and,
- The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this bill, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account; and,
- All contributions to the account are required to be in cash; and,
- Is the only homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.
- Defines "qualified homeownership savings expenses" as expenses, including a down payment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayer's principal residence within the meaning of Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 121 in California for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the first-time homeownership savings account.
- Finds and declares the following for the purposes of satisfying the requirements of Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of the income exclusion is to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home; and,
- To measure whether this bill achieves its intended purpose, the performance indicator is the number of taxpayers excluding income and the average amount of income excluded.
- Requires the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), by May 1, 2027 and annually thereafter, to prepare a report, to the extent information is available, that details the number of taxpayers excluding income pursuant to this bill and the average amount of income excluded.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
- Sunsets these provisions on January 1, 2030.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows a deduction equal to the amount of interest a taxpayer pays on a mortgage secured by their principal or secondary residence, subject to certain limitations. (IRC Section 163(h) and R&TC Section 17201.)
- Provides for two types of Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) under federal law, to which state law automatically conforms: traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. (R&TC Section 17501.5.)
- Limits the total amount of qualified contributions to both traditional and Roth IRAs to the lesser of $6,500 ($7,500 for taxpayers 50 years of age or older), or the taxpayer's taxable compensation for the year. (IRC Section 415.)
- Provides that amounts held in a traditional IRA are generally includible in gross income when withdrawn. In contrast, qualified distributions from a Roth IRA are excludable from gross income (although interest earned on contributions is taxable if withdrawn for a non- qualified distribution). (R&TC Sections 17081 and 17131.)
- Provides that withdrawals from a traditional IRA and non-qualified withdrawals of interest income from a Roth IRA are generally subject to an additional tax of 10% under federal law and 2.5% under state law if withdrawn prior to age 59 1⁄2, death, or disability, with some exceptions. Most notably, the taxpayer is not subject to the early withdrawal tax if the withdrawal is used for first-time homebuyer expenses of up to $10,000. Such first-time homebuyer expenses of up to $10,000 are also included as "qualified distributions" from a Roth IRA. (IRC Section 72(t)(2)(F).)
- Requires any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain all of the following:
- Specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve;
- Detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets the goals, purposes, and objectives stated in the bill; and,
- Data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax expenditure is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding those specific goals, purposes, and objectives. The requirements shall include the specific data and baseline measurements to be collected and remitted in each year the expenditure is in effect, for the Legislature to measure the change in performance indicators, and the specific taxpayers, state agencies, or other entities required to collect and remit data. (R&TC Section 41.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the FTB, the income exclusion created by this bill would result in General Fund (GF) revenue losses of $830,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2024-25, $1.5 million in FY 2025-26, and $1.7 million in FY 2026-27.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
We aim to empower families by providing them with the chance to save money tax-free for their inaugural home purchase. Considering the already elevated cost of living in California, coupled with the considerable burden on first-time homebuyers, our goal is to lighten their financial load and make the dream of homeownership more attainable.
- The California Association of Realtors, writing in support of AB 1865, notes, in part:
Ultimately, the lack of continued investment and resources that would help more first-time buyers save and purchase a home has led to California ranking third-lowest in statewide ownership rates. Data from the National Association of REALTORS® reports that Black/African Americans are using 401k/pension (17%) for their down payment which is higher than any other group. As we seek to solve our state's wealth gap among our diverse communities it is important that California offers resources to bridge the wealth gap.
- The California Teachers Association, writing in opposition to AB 1865, notes, in part:
According to the Department of Finance, the state provided over $87.5 billion in General Fund tax expenditures in 2023-24 (including income, sales and use, corporate and other taxes). This number continues to grow each year. This revenue would have otherwise gone to the General Fund, of which approximately 39 percent would have gone toward Proposition 98 for K-14 education. This means approximately $34 billion is redirected away from schools and community colleges each year due to existing tax expenditures. While we understand these bills are well intended, CTA does not support this approach, as it would reduce overall funding for education.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What would this bill do? This bill would create a new tax-advantaged saving mechanism for first-time homebuyers in California by excluding from gross income any interest or investment income accruing to a first-time homeownership account. In other words, this bill would provide that any gains accrued by the first-time homeownership savings account are not treated as taxable income. Additionally, this bill would allow a taxpayer to withdraw funds from their homeownership savings account tax-free when they are spent on a down payment or closing costs relating to the purchase of a qualified taxpayer's principal residence.
- Tax-advantaged savings accounts and retirement plans: Congress has authorized several types of retirement savings plans that qualify for reduced or deferred income taxes to encourage workers to save for retirement. For example, traditional IRAs allow for investment of a portion of wages on a pre-tax basis that remains untaxed until the money is withdrawn. Roth IRA investment contributions are made on an after-tax basis, but allow for tax-free qualified distributions (with interest earned on contributions subject to tax and penalty if withdrawn for a non-qualified distribution).
- The IRA "first-time homebuyer" withdrawal exception: Existing federal law imposes a 10% withdrawal penalty on early distributions made from an IRA to a taxpayer under the age of 591/2. California imposes a similar penalty, but at the rate of 2.5%. However, recognizing that some significant event might require a person to withdraw money from their retirement account earlier than expected, Congress has provided for a waiver of the early withdrawal penalty in some situations, to which California has conformed. Most notably, an exception from the penalty applies to distributions up to $10,000 that are used for first-time home purchases, and such distributions are also included as a "qualified distribution" from a Roth IRA. The creation of a separate homeownership savings account may allow taxpayers to keep these tax advantaged savings accounts untouched for their original retirement-related purpose.
- Federal resources for first-time homebuyers: Multiple programs exist at both the Federal and state level to assist individuals in purchasing a home. There are several federal agencies that facilitate mortgage lending programs for Americans, including the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). Additionally, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and the U.S. Department of Food and Agriculture offer homeownership assistance programs for specific populations.
The FHA provides mortgage insurance to approved lenders. The FHA home loan program is designed for borrowers who do not have the funds for a large down payment and/or have a lower than average credit score. In general, borrowers will find that an FHA loan is much easier to obtain than a standard mortgage because the credit score requirements are lower and individuals who have gone through bankruptcy or foreclosure may still be eligible. With an FHA loan, a homebuyer can borrow up to 96.5% of the value of a home, meaning the amount required as a down payment can be as little as 3.5% of the purchase price. - State resources for first-time homebuyers: The California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA) offers several options for down payment and closing cost assistance, including the California Dream for All Shared Appreciation Loan and the MyHome Assistance Program.[1] This type of assistance is often called a "second" or "subordinate" loan. CalHFA's subordinate loans are "silent seconds", meaning payments on this loan are deferred so borrowers do not have to make a payment on this assistance until the home is sold, refinanced or paid in full, which helps to keep the monthly mortgage payment affordable.
The state allocated $300 million in 2022 for the Dream for All loan program. Demand for the program was so high that nearly all of the budgeted funds were claimed in just 11 days. The program was relaunched for 2023 with a new lottery system to replace the "first come, first served" process and will distribute an additional $250 million in down payment assistance. The state expects that between 1,700 and 2,000 lottery winners will receive vouchers that they will then have 90 days to spend on a home.[2] The program is limited to individuals with incomes of up to 150% of the area median income and now requires that at least one homebuyer in each transaction be a first-generation homebuyer, defined as a person who has never owned a home and whose parents also did not own a home, or a person who grew up in foster care. - What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are typically reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: Both R&TC Section 41 and Committee policy require any tax expenditure bill to outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements.
In its current form, this bill states that the income exclusion is intended to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. In addition, this bill provides that the expenditures' effectiveness shall be measured by the number of taxpayers excluding income pursuant to this bill and the average dollar amount excluded. This bill requires the FTB to submit a report to the Legislature by May 1, 2027, and annually thereafter, estimating, to the extent data is available, the number of taxpayers excluding income pursuant to this bill and the average amount excluded.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to this policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" means five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" means ten years. This bill contains a five-year sunset provision and therefore complies with the Committee's policy on sunset dates.
- Implementation considerations:
- Conformity issues: California generally conforms to federal law regarding income exclusions. In general, state conformity with federal law promotes greater simplicity and eases administration of complex tax laws. This bill would bring California further out of conformity with federal law as the income excluded by this bill would still be subject to federal income tax. In the absence of similar federal treatment, taxpayers will need to keep separate accounting for state and federal tax purposes.
- Residing in the home: This bill does not specify a requirement to reside in the home as a principal residence for a specific period. After the home purchase, the property could be transitioned to investment property. If this is contrary to the author's intent, the author may wish to amend this bill.
- Principal investment: This bill provides that any amounts withdrawn that are not used for qualified homeownership expenses are considered taxable income. The author may wish to amend this bill to specify that only amounts earned on the principal investment are considered taxable, rather than the entire amount including the principal investment.
- Prior legislation:
- AB 1317 and AB 2115 (Brough), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, would have established a homeownership savings account for qualified low-income taxpayers and excluded from gross income any income earned during the taxable year from the homeownership savings account. AB 1317 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense File and AB 2115 was never heard by the Housing and Community Development Committee.
- AB 1779 (Bonta), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have established a similar homeownership savings account, but extended eligibility to persons whose income did not exceed 120% of Adjusted Median Income. AB 1779 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense File.
- AB 53 and AB 1758 (Steinorth), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have also created homeownership savings accounts. AB 53 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense File. AB 1758 was never heard by the Housing and Community Development Committee.
- Implementation considerations:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Catholic Conference
California Credit Union League
Habitat for Humanity California
Habitat for Humanity Greater Fresno Area
Housing Action Coalition (UNREG)
Opposition
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California Teachers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Wesley Whitaker / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
First Mortgage Programs and Down Payment Assistance Programs, CalHFA. https://www.calhfa.ca.gov/homebuyer/programs/index.htm. ↑
Mello, Dream for All: Down payment assistance for first-time California homebuyers relaunches with new lottery, Calmatters (January 18, 2024). https://calmatters.org/california-divide/2024/01/dream-for-all-california/. ↑
Date of Hearing: March 4, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Jacqui Irwin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1865 (
Author:Jim Patterson) – As Amended Ver:February 15, 2024
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Personal income taxes: exclusion: deduction: homeownership savings accounts
SUMMARY: Allows, under the Personal Income Tax (PIT) Law, certain tax benefits for "qualified taxpayers" who contribute to a "homeownership savings account", similar to an individual retirement account (IRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Allows, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2029, under the PIT Law, a deduction equal to the monetary contribution made by a "qualified taxpayer" during the taxable year to a "homeownership savings account", not to exceed $20,000 per taxable year for joint filers or $10,000 per taxable year for single filers.
- Excludes from gross income any income accrued during the taxable year to a "homeownership savings account", provided the same conditions are met as provided in Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 408.
- Excludes from gross income any amount withdrawn from a "homeownership savings account" that is used to pay for the "qualified homeownership savings expenses" of a "qualified taxpayer" who established the account.
- Defines a "qualified taxpayer" as an individual, or a married couple if filing a joint return, who had no present ownership interest in a principal residence during the preceding three-year period prior to the date of the contribution to a homeownership savings account or purchase of the principal residence for which any amount is withdrawn from the homeownership savings account.
- Defines a "homeownership savings account" as a trust that meets all of the following requirements:
- Is designated as a homeownership savings account by the trustee;
- Is established by a qualified taxpayer, or by qualified taxpayers who are spouses, for the exclusive benefit of any qualified taxpayer establishing the account where the written governing instrument creating the account provides for both of the following:
- All contributions to the account are required to be in cash; and,
- The account is established to pay, pursuant to the requirements and limitations of this bill, for the qualified homeownership savings expenses of a qualified taxpayer establishing the account.
- All contributions to the account are required to be in cash; and,
- Is subject to the same requirements and limitations as an individual retirement account (IRA) established under IRC Section 408, relating to IRAs, and any applicable regulations; and,
- Is the only homeownership savings account established by the qualified taxpayer.
- Defines "qualified homeownership savings expenses" as expenses, including a down payment or closing costs, paid or incurred in connection with the purchase of a qualified taxpayer's principal residence within the meaning of IRC Section 121 in California for use by that qualified taxpayer who established the homeownership savings account.
- Defines "trustee" by cross-reference to federal law.
- Finds and declares the following for the purposes of satisfying the requirements of Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of the deduction are to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home; and,
- To measure whether this bill achieves its intended purpose, the performance indicator is the number of taxpayers claiming the deduction and the average deduction allowed.
- Requires the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), by May 1, 2026 and annually thereafter, to prepare a report on the number of taxpayers claiming the deduction and the average amount of the deduction allowed.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
- Sunsets these provisions on January 1, 2029.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows a deduction equal to the amount of interest a taxpayer pays on a mortgage secured by their principal or secondary residence, subject to certain limitations. (IRC Section 163(h) and R&TC Section 17201.)
- Provides for two types of IRAs under federal law, to which state law automatically conforms: traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. (R&TC Section 17501.5.)
- Limits the total amount of qualified contributions to both traditional and Roth IRAs to the lesser of $6,500 ($7,500 for taxpayers 50 years of age or older), or the taxpayer's taxable compensation for the year. (IRC Section 415.)
- Provides that amounts held in a traditional IRA are generally includible in gross income when withdrawn. In contrast, qualified distributions from a Roth IRA are excludable from gross income (although interest earned on contributions is taxable if withdrawn for a non- qualified distribution). (R&TC Sections 17081 and 17131.)
- Provides that withdrawals from a traditional IRA and non-qualified withdrawals of interest income from a Roth IRA are generally subject to an additional tax of 10% under federal law and 2.5% under state law if withdrawn prior to age 59 1⁄2, death, or disability, with some exceptions. Most notably, the taxpayer is not subject to the early withdrawal tax if the withdrawal is used for first-time homebuyer expenses of up to $10,000. Such first-time homebuyer expenses of up to $10,000 are also included as "qualified distributions" from a Roth IRA. (IRC Section 72(t)(2)(F).)
- Requires any bill authorizing a new tax deduction to contain all of the following:
- Specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax deduction will achieve;
- Detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax deduction meets the goals, purposes, and objectives stated in the bill; and,
- Data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax deduction is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding those specific goals, purposes, and objectives. The requirements shall include the specific data and baseline measurements to be collected and remitted in each year the deduction is in effect, for the Legislature to measure the change in performance indicators, and the specific taxpayers, state agencies, or other entities required to collect and remit data. (R&TC Section 41.)
FISCAL EFFECT: To determine the magnitude of the potential impact to the General Fund (GF), it must be known whether any financial institutions currently offer the type of savings account envisioned by this bill. The FTB was unable to verify whether any savings accounts currently being offered would satisfy the federal requirements and limitations provided in IRC Section 408 and regulations adopted thereunder, which this bill references. If no such savings mechanism exists, this bill would not impact state income or franchise tax revenue because no taxpayer would be able to claim the deduction. If, however, such a savings account does in fact exist, the FTB estimates GF revenue losses of approximately $350,000 for every $5 million in qualified contributions.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
We aim to empower families by providing them with the chance to save money tax-free for their inaugural home purchase. Considering the already elevated cost of living in California, coupled with the considerable burden on first-time homebuyers, our goal is to lighten their financial load and make the dream of homeownership more attainable.
- The California Association of Realtors, writing in support of AB 1865, notes, in part:
Ultimately, the lack of continued investment and resources that would help more first-time buyers save and purchase a home has led to California ranking third-lowest in statewide ownership rates. Data from the National Association of REALTORS® reports that Black/African Americans are using 401k/pension (17%) for their down payment which is higher than any other group. As we seek to solve our state's wealth gap among our diverse communities it is important that California offers resources to bridge the wealth gap.
- The California Teachers Association, writing in opposition to AB 1865, notes, in part:
According to the Department of Finance, the state provided over $87.5 billion in General Fund tax expenditures in 2023-24 (including income, sales and use, corporate and other taxes). This number continues to grow each year. This revenue would have otherwise gone to the General Fund, of which approximately 39 percent would have gone toward Proposition 98 for K-14 education. This means approximately $34 billion is redirected away from schools and community colleges each year due to existing tax expenditures. While we understand these bills are well intended, CTA does not support this approach, as it would reduce overall funding for education.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What would this bill do? This bill would create a new tax-advantaged saving mechanism, similar to IRAs, for first-time homebuyers in California by allowing them to deduct an equivalent amount of their qualifying contributions in a taxable year, up to $10,000 per year for single filers and $20,000 per year for married or joint filers. This bill would provide that any gains accrued by the homeownership savings account are not treated as taxable income. Additionally, this bill would allow a taxpayer to withdraw funds from their homeownership savings account tax-free when they are spent on a down payment or closing costs relating to the purchase of a qualified taxpayer's principal residence.
- Who is likely to benefit? The deduction for qualified contributions to a homeownership savings account created by this bill would only be available to taxpayers who itemize deductions when filing their taxes. Filers claiming the standard deduction would not be able to claim the deduction created by this bill. In California, just over 15% of filers itemized deductions in 2020.[1] The U.S. Treasury Office of Tax Analysis, in a working paper analyzing the distribution of eight major tax expenditures across different income levels and racial and ethnic groups, found that itemized deductions disproportionately benefit White families: 84% of the benefits of the deductibility of mortgage interest were received by White families, which make up only 67% of the population studied. The average dollar benefit per family for the mortgage interest deduction was estimated to be $213 for White families, $77 for Hispanic families, and $63 for Black families.[2] Additionally, across all racial and ethnic categories, families in the upper middle-income ranges benefitted from the home mortgage deduction at higher rates than families in lower income deciles.
- Deductions tend to benefit higher income households: A deduction is generally more valuable to high-income taxpayers because the "value" of a deduction varies with the marginal tax rate (or tax bracket) of the taxpayer. For example, an individual taxpayer in a 10% tax bracket would receive a tax benefit of $10 on a $100 deduction. In contrast, a taxpayer in a 25% tax bracket would save $25 in taxes for every $100. Thus, assuming the same level of deductions, high-income taxpayers, presumably with a greater ability to pay taxes, would receive a greater tax benefit from the proposed deduction than the lower income taxpayer. Irrespective of tax incentives, it may be challenging to encourage families to save for a down payment towards a home when they have little or no disposable income.
- Tax-advantaged savings accounts and retirement plans: Congress has authorized several types of retirement savings plans that qualify for reduced or deferred income taxes to encourage workers to save for retirement. For example, traditional IRAs allow for investment of a portion of wages on a pre-tax basis that remains untaxed until the money is withdrawn. Roth IRA investment contributions are made on an after-tax basis, but allow for tax-free qualified distributions (with interest earned on contributions subject to tax and penalty if withdrawn for a non-qualified distribution).
- The IRA "first-time homebuyer" withdrawal exception: Existing federal law imposes a 10% withdrawal penalty on early distributions made from an IRA to a taxpayer under the age of 591/2. California imposes a similar penalty, but at the rate of 2.5%. However, recognizing that some significant event might require a person to withdraw money from their retirement account earlier than expected, Congress has provided for a waiver of the early withdrawal penalty in some situations, to which California has conformed. Most notably, an exception from the penalty applies to distributions up to $10,000 that are used for first-time home purchases, and such distributions are also included as a "qualified distribution" from a Roth IRA. The creation of a separate homeownership savings account may allow taxpayers to keep these tax advantaged savings accounts untouched for their original retirement-related purpose.
- Federal resources for first-time homebuyers: Multiple programs exist at both the Federal and state level to assist individuals in purchasing a home. There are several federal agencies that facilitate mortgage lending programs for Americans, including the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). Additionally, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and the U.S. Department of Food and Agriculture offer homeownership assistance programs for specific populations.
The FHA provides mortgage insurance to approved lenders. The FHA home loan program is designed for borrowers who do not have the funds for a large down payment and/or have a lower than average credit score. In general, borrowers will find that an FHA loan is much easier to obtain than a standard mortgage because the credit score requirements are lower and individuals who have gone through bankruptcy or foreclosure may still be eligible. With an FHA loan, a homebuyer can borrow up to 96.5% of the value of a home, meaning the amount required as a down payment can be as little as 3.5% of the purchase price. - State resources for first-time homebuyers: The California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA) offers several options for down payment and closing cost assistance, including the California Dream for All Shared Appreciation Loan and the MyHome Assistance Program.[3] This type of assistance is often called a "second" or "subordinate" loan. CalHFA's subordinate loans are "silent seconds", meaning payments on this loan are deferred so borrowers do not have to make a payment on this assistance until the home is sold, refinanced or paid in full, which helps to keep the monthly mortgage payment affordable.
The state allocated $300 million in 2022 for the Dream for All loan program. Demand for the program was so high that nearly all of the budgeted funds were claimed in just 11 days. The program was relaunched for 2023 with a new lottery system to replace the "first come, first serve" process and will distribute an additional $250 million in down payment assistance. The state expects that between 1,700 and 2,000 lottery winners will receive vouchers that they will then have 90 days to spend on a home.[4] The program is limited to individuals with incomes of up to 150% of the area median income and now requires that at least one homebuyer in each transaction be a first-generation homebuyer, defined as a person who has never owned a home and whose parents also did not own a home, or a person who grew up in foster care. - An incentive or a reward? Typically, tax expenditures are provided prospectively as a matter of legislative grace to encourage taxpayers to behave in ways they might not absent a financial incentive. This expenditure, in turn, is intended to encourage taxpayers to save for home ownership and begins providing this deduction for taxable years beginning on January 1, 2024. Tax expenditures with retroactive application, however, cannot incentivize past behavior that has already occurred. If this is contrary to the author's intent, the bill should be amended to remove the retroactive application and provide the deduction prospectively.
- Double tax benefit: As currently drafted, taxpayers contributing to a homeownership savings account receive the tax benefit of having their earnings on their contributions grow tax free if they spend the earned amount on qualified expenses, a "back-end" tax break. This bill would also provide a "front-end" tax break by allowing taxpayers to receive an immediate tax benefit in the form of deductions equal to their contribution, up to the prescribed limits. This Committee may wish to consider the merits of providing a double tax benefit for one type of behavior.
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are typically reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: Both R&TC Section 41 and Committee policy require any tax expenditure bill to outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements.
In its current form, this bill states that the deduction and exclusions are intended to provide assistance to those seeking to save to buy a home. In addition, this bill provides that the expenditures' effectiveness shall be measured by the number of taxpayers claiming the deduction pursuant to this bill and the average dollar amount of allowed deductions. This bill requires the FTB to submit a report to the Legislature by May 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, estimating the number of taxpayers claiming the deduction and the average dollar amount of the allowed deductions.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to this policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" means five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" means ten years. This bill contains a five-year sunset provision and therefore complies with the Committee's policy on sunset dates.
- Implementation Considerations:
- Conformity issues: California generally conforms to federal law regarding income exclusions. In general, state conformity with federal law promotes greater simplicity and eases administration of complex tax laws. This bill would bring California further out of conformity with federal law as the income excluded by this bill would still be subject to federal income tax. In the absence of similar federal treatment, taxpayers will need to keep separate accounting for state and federal tax purposes.
- Residing in the home: This bill does not specify a requirement to reside in the home as a principal residence for a specific period. After the home purchase, the property could be transitioned to investment property. If this is contrary to the author's intent, the author may wish to amend this bill.
- Lack of penalties: This bill does not contain penalty provisions if the taxpayer withdraws funds that are not used to purchase a home or if the taxpayer already owns (or previously owned) a home. As such, it may be possible for taxpayers to use this as a tax-free investment vehicle for purposes unrelated to a home purchase. The Committee may wish to include a penalty for amounts withdrawn and used for purposes other than a home purchase.
- Prior legislation:
- AB 1317 and AB 2115 (Brough), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, would have established a homeownership savings account for qualified low-income taxpayers and excluded from gross income any income earned during the taxable year from the homeownership savings account. AB 1317 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense and AB 2115 never heard by the Housing and Community Development Committee.
- AB 1779 (Bonta), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have established a similar homeownership savings account, but extended eligibility to persons whose income did not exceed 120% of Adjusted Median Income. AB 1779 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense File.
- AB 53 and AB 1758 (Steinorth), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have also created homeownership savings accounts. AB 53 was held on the Assembly Committee on Appropriations' Suspense File. AB 1758 was never heard by the Housing and Community Development Committee.
- Implementation Considerations:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Catholic Conference
Habitat for Humanity California
Habitat for Humanity Greater Fresno Area
Opposition
California Teachers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Wesley Whitaker / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Villanova, Where Americans Write Off the Most in Taxes – 2023 Study. SmartAsset (April 6, 2023). https://smartasset.com/data-studies/where-americans-write-off-the-most-in-taxes-2023. ↑
Cronin, Tax Expenditures by Race and Hispanic Ethnicity: An Application of the U.S. Treasury Department's Race and Hispanic Ethnicity Imputation, U.S. Treasury Office of Tax Analysis (January 2023). https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/WP-122.pdf. ↑
First Mortgage Programs and Down Payment Assistance Programs, CalHFA. https://www.calhfa.ca.gov/homebuyer/programs/index.htm. ↑
Mello, Dream for All: Down payment assistance for first-time California homebuyers relaunches with new lottery, Calmatters (January 18, 2024). https://calmatters.org/california-divide/2024/01/dream-for-all-california/. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):