AB 1931: Criminal procedure: protective orders.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-03-18
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-24: From committee: Without further action pursuant to Joint Rule 62(a).)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law allows the court to issue a protective order restraining a defendant from any contact with the victim if the defendant has been convicted of a crime of domestic violence, human trafficking, a crime in furtherance of a criminal street gang, or a registerable sex offense. Under existing law, the protective order may be valid for up to 10 years, as determined by the court.
This bill would additionally allow the court to issue a permanent protective order restraining a defendant from any contact with the victim if the defendant has been convicted of any serious or violent felony, as defined, or any felony requiring registration as a sex offender. The bill would also authorize the court to permanently extend certain previously issued orders under certain circumstances. The bill would require the Judicial Council to develop forms, instructions, and rules relating to these orders.
The bill would make other conforming changes.
By authorizing the issuance of protective orders in certain circumstances and the extension of certain protective orders, a violation of which is punishable as a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law generally regulates criminal procedure, including, among other matters, arrests, arraignment, and pretrial motions.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to criminal procedure.Existing law generally regulates criminal procedure, including, among other matters, arrests, arraignment, and pretrial motions.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to criminal procedure.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as Kayleighs Law.
SEC. 2.Section 6383 of the Family Code is amended to read:6383.(a)A temporary restraining order, emergency protective order, or an order issued after hearing pursuant to this part shall, on request of the petitioner, be served on the respondent, whether or not the respondent has been taken into custody, either by a law enforcement officer, excluding those defined in subdivision (a) of Section 830.5 of the Penal Code, who is present at the scene of reported domestic violence involving the parties to the proceeding or who receives a request from the petitioner to provide service of the order.
(b)(1)The petitioner shall provide the officer with an endorsed copy of the order and a proof of service that the officer shall complete and transmit to the issuing court.
(2)Service shall be provided pursuant to Section 6389 of the Family Code.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, a fee shall not be charged to the petitioner for service of an order described in subdivision (a).
(4)If a firearm is obtained at the scene of a domestic violence incident or during service as provided in this section, law enforcement shall enter, or cause to be entered, the firearm into the Department of Justice Automated Firearms System pursuant to Section 11108.2 of the Penal Code.
(c)It is a rebuttable presumption that the proof of service was signed on the date of service.
(d)Upon receiving information at the scene of a domestic violence incident that a protective order has been issued under this part, or that a person who has been taken into custody is the respondent to that order, if the protected person cannot produce an endorsed copy of the order, a law enforcement officer shall immediately inquire of the California Restraining and Protective Order System to verify the existence of the order.
(e)If the law enforcement officer determines that a protective order has been issued but not served, the officer shall immediately notify the respondent of the terms of the order and where a written copy of the order can be obtained, and the officer shall, at that time, also enforce the order. The law enforcement officers verbal notice of the terms of the order shall constitute service of the order and is sufficient notice for the purposes of this section and for the purposes of Sections 273.6 and 29825 of the Penal Code.
(f)If a report is required under Section 13730 of the Penal Code, or if no report is required, then in the daily incident log, the officer shall provide the name and assignment of the officer notifying the respondent pursuant to subdivision (e) and the case number of the order.
(g)Upon service of the order outside of the court, a law enforcement officer shall advise the respondent to go to the local court to obtain a copy of the order containing the full terms and conditions of the order.
(h)(1)There shall be no civil liability on the part of, and no cause of action for false arrest or false imprisonment against, a peace officer who makes an arrest pursuant to a protective or restraining order that is regular upon its face, if the peace officer, in making the arrest, acts in good faith and has reasonable cause to believe that the person against whom the order is issued has notice of the order and has committed an act in violation of the order.
(2)If there is more than one order issued and one of the orders is an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 136.2 of the Penal Code, the peace officer shall enforce the emergency protective order. If there is more than one order issued, none of the orders issued is an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement, and one of the orders issued is a no-contact order, as described in Section 6320, the peace officer shall enforce the no-contact order. If there is more than one civil order regarding the same parties and neither an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement nor a no-contact order has been issued, the peace officer shall enforce the order that was issued last. If there are both civil and criminal orders regarding the same parties and neither an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement nor a no-contact order has been issued, the peace officer shall enforce the criminal order issued last, subject to the provisions of subdivisions (h) and (i) (h), (i), and (j) of Section 136.2 of the Penal Code. This section does not exonerate a peace officer from liability for the unreasonable use of force in the enforcement of the order. The immunities afforded by this section shall not affect the availability of any other immunity that may apply, including, but not limited to, Sections 820.2 and 820.4 of the Government Code.
(i)A peace officer listed in Section 18250 of the Penal Code shall take temporary custody of any firearm or other deadly weapon in plain sight or discovered pursuant to a consensual or otherwise lawful search as necessary for the protection of the peace officer or other persons present in any of the following circumstances:
(1)The peace officer is at the scene of a domestic violence incident involving a threat to human life or a physical assault.
(2)The peace officer is serving a protective order issued pursuant to this part.
(3)The peace officer is serving a gun violence restraining order issued pursuant to Division 3.2 (commencing with Section 18100) of Title 2 of Part 6 of the Penal Code.
SEC. 3.Section 136.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:136.2.(a)(1)Upon a good cause belief that harm to, or intimidation or dissuasion of, a victim or witness has occurred or is reasonably likely to occur, a court with jurisdiction over a criminal matter may issue orders, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)An order issued pursuant to Section 6320 of the Family Code.
(B)An order that a defendant shall not violate any provision of Section 136.1.
(C)An order that a person before the court other than a defendant, including, but not limited to, a subpoenaed witness or other person entering the courtroom of the court, shall not violate any provision of Section 136.1.
(D)An order that a person described in this section shall have no communication whatsoever with a specified witness or a victim except through an attorney under reasonable restrictions that the court may impose.
(E)An order calling for a hearing to determine if an order described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, should be issued.
(F)(i)An order that a particular law enforcement agency within the jurisdiction of the court provide protection for a victim, witness, or both, or for immediate family members of a victim or a witness who reside in the same household as the victim or witness or within reasonable proximity of the victims or witness household, as determined by the court. The order shall not be made without the consent of the law enforcement agency except for limited and specified periods of time and upon an express finding by the court of a clear and present danger of harm to the victim or witness or immediate family members of the victim or witness.
(ii)For purposes of this paragraph, immediate family members include the spouse, children, or parents of the victim or witness.
(G)(i)An order protecting a victim or witness of violent crime from all contact by the defendant or contact with the intent to annoy, harass, threaten, or commit acts of violence by the defendant. The court or its designee shall transmit orders made under this paragraph to law enforcement personnel within one business day of the issuance, modification, extension, or termination of the order pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 6380 of the Family Code. It is the responsibility of the court to transmit the modification, extension, or termination orders made under this paragraph to the same agency that entered the original protective order into the California Restraining and Protective Order System.
(ii)(I)If a court does not issue an order pursuant to clause (i) when the defendant is charged with a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 of this code or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, the court, on its own motion, shall consider issuing a protective order upon a good cause belief that harm to, or intimidation or dissuasion of, a victim or witness has occurred or is reasonably likely to occur, that provides as follows:
(ia)The defendant shall not own, possess, purchase, receive, or attempt to purchase or receive a firearm while the protective order is in effect.
(ib)The defendant shall relinquish ownership or possession of any firearms pursuant to Section 527.9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(II)A person who owns, possesses, purchases, or receives, or attempts to purchase or receive a firearm while this protective order is in effect is punishable pursuant to Section 29825.
(iii)An order issued, modified, extended, or terminated by a court pursuant to this subparagraph shall be issued on forms adopted by the Judicial Council that have been approved by the Department of Justice pursuant to subdivision (i) of Section 6380 of the Family Code. However, the fact that an order issued by a court pursuant to this section was not issued on forms adopted by the Judicial Council and approved by the Department of Justice shall not make the order unenforceable.
(iv)A protective order issued under this subparagraph may require the defendant to be placed on electronic monitoring if the local government, with the concurrence of the county sheriff or the chief probation officer with jurisdiction, adopts a policy to authorize electronic monitoring of defendants and specifies the agency with jurisdiction for this purpose. If the court determines that the defendant has the ability to pay for the monitoring program, the court shall order the defendant to pay for the monitoring. If the court determines that the defendant does not have the ability to pay for the electronic monitoring, the court may order electronic monitoring to be paid for by the local government that adopted the policy to authorize electronic monitoring. The duration of electronic monitoring shall not exceed one year from the date the order is issued. The electronic monitoring shall not be in place if the protective order is not in place.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, a minor who was not a victim of, but who was physically present at the time of, an act of domestic violence is a witness and is deemed to have suffered harm within the meaning of paragraph (1).
(b)A person violating an order made pursuant to subparagraphs (A) to (G), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) may be punished for a substantive offense described in Section 136.1 or for a contempt of the court making the order. A finding of contempt shall not be a bar to prosecution for a violation of Section 136.1. However, a person held in contempt shall be entitled to credit for punishment imposed therein against a sentence imposed upon conviction of an offense described in Section 136.1. A conviction or acquittal for a substantive offense under Section 136.1 shall be a bar to a subsequent punishment for contempt arising out of the same act.
(c)(1)(A)Notwithstanding subdivision (e), an emergency protective order issued pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 6250) of Part 3 of Division 10 of the Family Code or Section 646.91 shall have precedence in enforcement over any other restraining or protective order, provided the emergency protective order meets all of the following requirements:
(i)The emergency protective order is issued to protect one or more individuals who are already protected persons under another restraining or protective order.
(ii)The emergency protective order restrains the individual who is the restrained person in the other restraining or protective order specified in clause (i).
(iii)The provisions of the emergency protective order are more restrictive in relation to the restrained person than are the provisions of the other restraining or protective order specified in clause (i).
(B)An emergency protective order that meets the requirements of subparagraph (A) shall have precedence in enforcement over the provisions of any other restraining or protective order only with respect to those provisions of the emergency protective order that are more restrictive in relation to the restrained person.
(2)Except as described in paragraph (1), a no-contact order, as described in Section 6320 of the Family Code, shall have precedence in enforcement over any other restraining or protective order.
(d)(1)A person subject to a protective order issued under this section shall not own, possess, purchase, or receive, or attempt to purchase or receive, a firearm while the protective order is in effect.
(2)The court shall order a person subject to a protective order issued under this section to relinquish ownership or possession of any firearms pursuant to Section 527.9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(3)A person who owns, possesses, purchases, or receives, or attempts to purchase or receive a firearm while the protective order is in effect is punishable pursuant to Section 29825.
(e)(1)When the defendant is charged with a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 of this code or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, or a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, including, but not limited to, commercial sexual exploitation of a minor in violation of Section 236.1, the court shall consider issuing the above-described orders on its own motion. All interested parties shall receive a copy of those orders. To facilitate this, the courts records of all criminal cases involving domestic violence, a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, or a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, including, but not limited to, commercial sexual exploitation of a minor in violation of Section 236.1, shall be marked to clearly alert the court to this issue.
(2)When a complaint, information, or indictment charging a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, or a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, including, but not limited to, commercial sexual exploitation of a minor in violation of Section 236.1, has been issued, except as described in subdivision (c), a restraining order or protective order against the defendant issued by the criminal court in that case has precedence in enforcement over a civil court order against the defendant.
(3)Custody and visitation with respect to the defendant and the defendants minor children may be ordered by a family or juvenile court consistent with the protocol established pursuant to subdivision (f), but if it is ordered after a criminal protective order has been issued pursuant to this section, the custody and visitation order shall make reference to and, if there is not an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) or a no-contact order, as described in Section 6320 of the Family Code, acknowledge the precedence of enforcement of an appropriate criminal protective order. On or before July 1, 2014, the Judicial Council shall modify the criminal and civil court forms consistent with this subdivision.
(f)On or before January 1, 2003, the Judicial Council shall promulgate a protocol, for adoption by each local court in substantially similar terms, to provide for the timely coordination of all orders against the same defendant and in favor of the same named victim or victims. The protocol shall include, but shall not be limited to, mechanisms for ensuring appropriate communication and information sharing between criminal, family, and juvenile courts concerning orders and cases that involve the same parties and shall permit a family or juvenile court order to coexist with a criminal court protective order subject to the following conditions:
(1)An order that permits contact between the restrained person and the persons children shall provide for the safe exchange of the children and shall not contain language, either printed or handwritten, that violates a no-contact order issued by a criminal court.
(2)The safety of all parties shall be the courts paramount concern. The family or juvenile court shall specify the time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as provided in Section 3100 of the Family Code.
(g)On or before January 1, 2003, the Judicial Council shall modify the criminal and civil court protective order forms consistent with this section.
(h)(1)When a complaint, information, or indictment charging a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, has been filed, the court may consider, in determining whether good cause exists to issue an order under subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), the underlying nature of the offense charged and the information provided to the court pursuant to Section 273.75.
(2)When a complaint, information, or indictment charging a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, or a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, including, but not limited to, commercial sexual exploitation of a minor in violation of Section 236.1, has been filed, the court may consider, in determining whether good cause exists to issue an order under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), the underlying nature of the offense charged, the defendants relationship to the victim, the likelihood of continuing harm to the victim, any current restraining order or protective order issued by a civil or criminal court involving the defendant, and the defendants criminal history, including, but not limited to, prior convictions for a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, including, but not limited to, commercial sexual exploitation of a minor in violation of Section 236.1, any other forms of violence, or a weapons offense.
(i)(1)When Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (j), a criminal defendant has been convicted of a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, a violation of subdivision (a), (b), or (c) of Section 236.1 prohibiting human trafficking, Section 261, 261.5, former Section 262, subdivision (a) of Section 266h, or subdivision (a) of Section 266i, a violation of Section 186.22, or a crime misdemeanor that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, the court, at the time of sentencing, shall consider issuing an order restraining the defendant from any contact with a victim of the crime. The order may be valid for up to 10 years, as determined by the court. This protective order may be issued by the court regardless of whether the defendant is sentenced to the state prison or a county jail, whether the defendant is subject to mandatory supervision, or whether imposition of sentence is suspended and the defendant is placed on probation. The order may be modified by the sentencing court in the county in which it was issued throughout the duration of the order. It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this subdivision that the duration of a restraining order issued by the court be based upon the seriousness of the facts before the court, the probability of future violations, and the safety of a victim and the victims immediate family.
(2)When a criminal defendant has been convicted of a crime involving domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700 or in Section 6211 of the Family Code, a violation of Section 261, 261.5, or former Section 262, a violation of Section 186.22, or a crime that requires the defendant to register pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 290, the court, at the time of sentencing, shall consider issuing an order restraining the defendant from any contact with a percipient witness to the crime if it can be established by clear and convincing evidence that the witness has been harassed, as defined in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 527.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, by the defendant.
(j)(1)When a criminal defendant has been convicted of a violent felony, as defined in Section 667.5, a serious felony, as defined in Section 1192.7, or a felony offense that requires registration pursuant to Section 290, the court shall, in the discretion of the court and unless the victim otherwise requests, consider issuing a protective order that prohibits the defendant from contacting any victim of the crime. Any victim of an offense described in this section may petition the court for the issuance of such an order.
(2)A protective order issued pursuant to this subdivision shall not expire and shall be valid for the defendants lifetime or until any of the following occur.
(A)The victim dies.
(B)The underlying conviction is dismissed or overturned.
(C)The court, at the request of the victim, removes the protective order. The victim may petition the court for removal of the order at any time and the court may hold a hearing to verify the victims request to dismiss the protective order.
(3)The court shall serve the defendant with any protective order issued pursuant to this subdivision at the time of sentencing.
(4)The provisions of Section 6380 of the Family Code shall apply to a protective order issued pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)A protective order issued pursuant to this subdivision may be issued by the court regardless of whether the defendant is sentenced to incarceration in the state prison or a county jail, whether the defendant is subject to mandatory supervision, or whether imposition of sentence is suspended and the defendant is placed on probation. The order may be modified throughout the duration of the order by the court in the county in which the order was issued.
(k)An order that was issued pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) before January 1, 2025, and that is still in effect may be extended for more than ten years and be valid for the lifetime of the defendant if, during the duration of the order, the defendant has violated the terms and conditions of the order, the defendant has been convicted of an offense described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (j), and the court finds that, based upon the seriousness of the facts before the court, the probability of future violations, and the safety of a victim and the victims immediate family, that extension of the protective order is appropriate. Orders extended pursuant to this subdivision shall be subject to the provisions of paragraph (2) and (4) of subdivision (j).
(3)(l)An order under this subdivision issued pursuant to subdivision (i) or (j) may include provisions for electronic monitoring if the local government, upon receiving the concurrence of the county sheriff or the chief probation officer with jurisdiction, adopts a policy authorizing electronic monitoring of defendants and specifies the agency with jurisdiction for this purpose. If the court determines that the defendant has the ability to pay for the monitoring program, the court shall order the defendant to pay for the monitoring. If the court determines that the defendant does not have the ability to pay for the electronic monitoring, the court may order the electronic monitoring to be paid for by the local government that adopted the policy authorizing electronic monitoring. The duration of the electronic monitoring shall not exceed one year from the date the order is issued.
(m)The Judicial Council shall develop forms, instructions, and rules relating to protective orders issued or extended pursuant to subdivisions (j) and (k).
(j)(n)For purposes of this section, local government means the county that has jurisdiction over the protective order.
SEC. 4.Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1203.4.(a)(1)When a defendant has fulfilled the conditions of probation for the entire period of probation, or has been discharged prior to the termination of the period of probation, or in any other case in which a court, in its discretion and the interest of justice, determines that a defendant should be granted the relief available under this section, the defendant shall, at any time after the termination of the period of probation, if they are not then serving a sentence for an offense, on probation for an offense, or charged with the commission of an offense, be permitted by the court to withdraw their plea of guilty or plea of nolo contendere and enter a plea of not guilty; or, if they have been convicted after a plea of not guilty, the court shall set aside the verdict of guilty; and, in either case, the court shall thereupon dismiss the accusations or information against the defendant and except as noted below, the defendant shall thereafter be released from all penalties and disabilities resulting from the offense of which they have been convicted, except as provided in Section 13555 of the Vehicle Code. The probationer shall be informed, in their probation papers, of this right and privilege and the right, if any, to petition for a certificate of rehabilitation and pardon. The probationer may make the application and change of plea in person or by attorney, or by the probation officer authorized in writing. However, in any subsequent prosecution of the defendant for any other offense, the prior conviction may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if probation had not been granted or the accusation or information dismissed. The order shall state, and the probationer shall be informed, that the order does not relieve them of the obligation to disclose the conviction in response to any direct question contained in any questionnaire or application for public office, for licensure by any state or local agency, or for contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
(2)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not permit a person to own, possess, or have custody or control of a firearm or to prevent conviction under Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 29800) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6.
(3)Dismissal of an accusation or information underlying a conviction pursuant to this section does not permit a person prohibited from holding public office as a result of that conviction to hold public office.
(4)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not release the defendant from the terms and conditions of an unexpired criminal protective order that has been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of of, or subdivision (j) of, Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying accusation or information.
(5)This subdivision shall apply to all applications for relief under this section which are filed on or after November 23, 1970.
(b)Subdivision (a) of this section does not apply to a misdemeanor that is within the provisions of Section 42002.1 of the Vehicle Code, to a violation of subdivision (c) of Section 286, Section 288, subdivision (c) of Section 287 or of former Section 288a, Section 288.5, subdivision (j) of Section 289, Section 311.1, 311.2, 311.3, or 311.11, or a felony conviction pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 261.5, or to an infraction.
(c)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), subdivision (a) does not apply to a person who receives a notice to appear or is otherwise charged with a violation of an offense described in subdivisions (a) to (e), inclusive, of Section 12810 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)If a defendant who was convicted of a violation listed in paragraph (1) petitions the court, the court in its discretion and in the interest of justice, may order the relief provided pursuant to subdivision (a) to that defendant.
(3)(A)A petition for relief under this section shall not be denied due to an unfulfilled order of restitution or restitution fine.
(B)An unfulfilled order of restitution or a restitution fine shall not be grounds for finding that a defendant did not fulfil the condition of probation for the entire period of probation.
(C)When the court considers a petition for relief under this section, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, an unpaid order of restitution or restitution fine shall not be grounds for denial of the petition for relief.
(d)(1)Relief shall not be granted under this section unless the prosecuting attorney has been given 15 days notice of the petition for relief. The probation officer shall notify the prosecuting attorney when a petition is filed, pursuant to this section.
(2)It shall be presumed that the prosecuting attorney has received notice if proof of service is filed with the court.
(e)If, after receiving notice pursuant to subdivision (d), the prosecuting attorney fails to appear and object to a petition for dismissal, the prosecuting attorney may not move to set aside or otherwise appeal the grant of that petition.
(f)Notwithstanding the above provisions or any other law, the Governor shall have the right to pardon a person convicted of a violation of subdivision (c) of Section 286, Section 288, subdivision (c) of Section 287 or of former Section 288a, Section 288.5, or subdivision (j) of Section 289, if there are extraordinary circumstances.
SEC. 5.Section 1203.4a of the Penal Code is amended to read:1203.4a.(a)Every defendant convicted of a misdemeanor and not granted probation, and every defendant convicted of an infraction shall, at any time after the lapse of one year from the date of pronouncement of judgment, if they have fully complied with and performed the sentence of the court, are not then serving a sentence for an offense and are not under charge of commission of a crime, and have, since the pronouncement of judgment, lived an honest and upright life and have conformed to and obeyed the laws of the land, be permitted by the court to withdraw their plea of guilty or nolo contendere and enter a plea of not guilty; or if they have been convicted after a plea of not guilty, the court shall set aside the verdict of guilty; and in either case the court shall dismiss the accusatory pleading against the defendant, who shall be released from all penalties and disabilities resulting from the offense of which they have been convicted, except as provided in Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 29900) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6 of this code or Section 13555 of the Vehicle Code.
(b)If a defendant does not satisfy all the requirements of subdivision (a), after a lapse of one year from the date of pronouncement of judgment, a court, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, may grant the relief available pursuant to subdivision (a) to a defendant convicted of an infraction, or of a misdemeanor and not granted probation, or both, if the defendant has fully complied with and performed the sentence of the court, is not then serving a sentence for any offense, and is not under charge of commission of a crime.
(c)(1)The defendant shall be informed of the provisions of this section, either orally or in writing, at the time they are sentenced. The defendant may make an application and change of plea in person or by attorney, or by the probation officer authorized in writing, provided that, in any subsequent prosecution of the defendant for any other offense, the prior conviction may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if relief had not been granted pursuant to this section.
(2)Dismissal of an accusatory pleading pursuant to this section does not permit a person to own, possess, or have in their custody or control a firearm or prevent their conviction under Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 29800) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6.
(3)Dismissal of an accusatory pleading underlying a conviction pursuant to this section does not permit a person prohibited from holding public office as a result of that conviction to hold public office.
(4)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not release the defendant from the terms and conditions of an unexpired criminal protective order that has been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of of, or subdivision (j) of, Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying accusation or information.
(d) This section applies to a conviction specified in subdivision (a) or (b) that occurred before, as well as those occurring after, the effective date of this section, except that this section does not apply to the following:
(1)A misdemeanor violation of subdivision (c) of Section 288.
(2)A misdemeanor falling within the provisions of Section 42002.1 of the Vehicle Code.
(3)An infraction falling within the provisions of Section 42001 of the Vehicle Code.
(e)(1)A petition for relief under this section shall not be denied due to an unfulfilled order of restitution or restitution fine.
(2)An unfulfilled order of restitution or a restitution fine shall not be grounds for finding that a defendant did not fully comply with and perform the sentence of the court or a finding that a defendant has not lived an honest and upright life and has not conformed to and obeyed the laws of the land.
(3)When the court considers a petition for relief under this section, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, an unpaid order of restitution or restitution fine shall not be grounds for denial of the petition for relief.
(f)A petition for dismissal of an infraction pursuant to this section shall be by written declaration, except upon a showing of compelling need. Dismissal of an infraction shall not be granted under this section unless the prosecuting attorney has been given at least 15 days notice of the petition for dismissal. It shall be presumed that the prosecuting attorney has received notice if proof of service is filed with the court.
(g)Any determination of amount made by a court under this section shall be valid only if either (1) made under procedures adopted by the Judicial Council or (2) approved by the Judicial Council.
SEC. 6.Section 1203.4b of the Penal Code is amended to read:1203.4b.(a)(1)If a defendant successfully participated in the California Conservation Camp program as an incarcerated individual hand crew member, as determined by the Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, or successfully participated as a member of a county incarcerated individual hand crew, as determined by the appropriate county authority, or participated at an institutional firehouse, as determined by the Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, and has been released from custody, the defendant is eligible for relief pursuant to this section, except that incarcerated individuals who have been convicted of any of the following crimes are automatically ineligible for relief pursuant to this section:
(A)Murder.
(B)Kidnapping.
(C)Rape as defined in paragraph (2) or (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 261 or paragraph (1) or (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 262.
(D)Lewd acts on a child under 14 years of age, as defined in Section 288.
(E)Any felony punishable by death or imprisonment in the state prison for life.
(F)Any sex offense requiring registration pursuant to Section 290.
(G)Escape from a secure perimeter within the previous 10 years.
(H)Arson.
(2)Any denial of relief pursuant to this section shall be without prejudice.
(3)For purposes of this subdivision, successful participation in a conservation camp program or a program at an institutional firehouse and successful participation as a member of a county incarcerated individual hand crew, as determined by the appropriate county authority, means the incarcerated individual adequately performed their duties without any conduct that warranted removal from the program.
(b)(1)The defendant may file a petition for relief with the court in the county where the defendant was sentenced. The court shall provide a copy of the petition to the secretary, or, in the case of a county incarcerated individual hand crew member, the appropriate county authority.
(2)If the secretary or appropriate county authority certifies to the court that the defendant successfully participated in the incarcerated individual conservation camp program, or institutional firehouse, or successfully participated as a member of a county incarcerated individual hand crew, as determined by the appropriate county authority, as specified in subdivision (a), and has been released from custody, the court, in its discretion and in the interests of justice, may issue an order pursuant to subdivision (c).
(3)To be eligible for relief pursuant to this section, the defendant is not required to complete the term of their probation, parole, or supervised release. Notwithstanding any other law, the court, in providing relief pursuant to this section, shall order early termination of probation, parole, or supervised release if the court determines that the defendant has not violated any terms or conditions of probation, parole, or supervised release prior to, and during the pendency of, the petition for relief pursuant to this section.
(4)All convictions for which the defendant is serving a sentence at the time the defendant successfully participates in a program as specified in subdivision (a) are subject to relief pursuant to this section.
(5)(A)A defendant who is granted an order pursuant to this section shall not be required to disclose the conviction on an application for licensure by any state or local agency.
(B)This paragraph does not apply to an application for licensure by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, a position as a peace officer, public office, or for contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
(c)(1)If the requirements of this section are met, the court, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, may permit the defendant to withdraw the plea of guilty or plea of nolo contendere and enter a plea of not guilty, or, if the defendant has been convicted after a plea of not guilty, the court shall set aside the verdict of guilty, and, in either case, the court shall thereupon dismiss the accusations or information against the defendant and the defendant shall thereafter be released from all penalties and disabilities resulting from the offense of which the defendant has been convicted, except as provided in Section 13555 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)The relief available pursuant to this section shall not be granted if the defendant is currently charged with the commission of any other offense.
(3)The defendant may make the application and change of plea in person or by attorney.
(4)(A) A petition for relief under this section shall not be denied due to an unfulfilled order of restitution or restitution fine.
(B)An unfulfilled order of restitution or restitution fine shall not be grounds for finding that a defendant did not successfully participate in the California Conservation Camp program as an incarcerated individual hand crew member or at an institutional firehouse, or that the defendant did not successfully participate as a member of a county incarcerated individual hand crew.
(C)When the court considers a petition for relief under this section, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, an unpaid order of restitution or restitution fine shall not be grounds for denial of the petition for relief.
(d)Relief granted pursuant to this section is subject to the following conditions:
(1)In any subsequent prosecution of the defendant for any other offense, the prior conviction may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if the accusation or information had not been dismissed.
(2)The order shall state, and the defendant shall be informed, that the order does not relieve the defendant of the obligation to disclose the conviction in response to any direct question contained in any questionnaire or application for licensure by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, a peace officer, public office, or for contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
(3)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not permit a person to own, possess, or have in the persons custody or control any firearm or prevent their conviction under Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 29800) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6.
(4)Dismissal of an accusation or information underlying a conviction pursuant to this section does not permit a person prohibited from holding public office as a result of that conviction to hold public office.
(5)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not release the defendant from the terms and conditions of any unexpired criminal protective order that has been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of of, or subdivision (j) of, Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying accusation or information.
(e)(1)Relief shall not be granted under this section unless the prosecuting attorney has been given 15 days notice of the petition for relief.
(2)It shall be presumed that the prosecuting attorney has received notice if proof of service is filed with the court.
(f)If, after receiving notice pursuant to subdivision (e), the prosecuting attorney fails to appear and object to a petition for dismissal, the prosecuting attorney may not move to set aside or otherwise appeal the grant of that petition.
SEC. 7.Section 1203.41 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1203.41.(a)If a defendant is convicted of a felony, the court, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, may order the following relief, subject to the conditions of subdivision (b):
(1)The court may permit the defendant to withdraw their plea of guilty or plea of nolo contendere and enter a plea of not guilty, or, if the defendant has been convicted after a plea of not guilty, the court shall set aside the verdict of guilty, and, in either case, the court shall dismiss the accusations or information against the defendant and the defendant shall be released from all penalties and disabilities resulting from the offense of which they have been convicted, except as provided in Section 13555 of the Vehicle Code.
(2)The relief available under this section may be granted only after the lapse of one year following the defendants completion of the sentence, if the sentence was imposed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or after the lapse of two years following the defendants completion of the sentence, if the sentence was imposed pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h) of Section 1170 or if the defendant was sentenced to the state prison.
(3)The relief available under this section may be granted only if the defendant is not on parole or under supervision pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (h) of Section 1170, and is not serving a sentence for, on probation for, or charged with the commission of, an offense.
(4)The defendant shall be informed, either orally or in writing, of the provisions of this section and of their right, if any, to petition for a certificate of rehabilitation and pardon at the time of sentencing.
(5)The defendant may make the application and change of plea in person or by attorney, or by a probation officer authorized in writing.
(6)If the defendant seeks relief under this section for a felony that resulted in a sentence to the state prison, the relief available under this section may only be granted if that felony did not result in a requirement to register as a sex offender pursuant to Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 290) of Title 9 of Part 1.
(b)Relief granted pursuant to subdivision (a) is subject to all of the following conditions:
(1)In any subsequent prosecution of the defendant for any other offense, the prior conviction may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if the accusation or information had not been dismissed.
(2)The order shall state, and the defendant shall be informed, that the order does not relieve them of the obligation to disclose the conviction in response to a direct question contained in a questionnaire or application for public office, for licensure by a state or local agency or by a federally recognized tribe, for enrollment as a provider of in-home supportive services and waiver personal care services pursuant to Article 7 (commencing with Section 12300) of Chapter 3 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or pursuant to Section 14132.95, 14132.952, 14132.956, or 14132.97 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or for contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
(3)Dismissal of an accusation or information pursuant to this section does not permit a person to own, possess, or have in their custody or control a firearm or prevent their conviction under Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 29800) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6.
(4)Dismissal of an accusation or information underlying a conviction pursuant to this section does not permit a person prohibited from holding public office as a result of that conviction to hold public office.
(c)This section applies to any conviction specified in subdivision (a) that occurred before, on, or after January 1, 2021.
(d)When the court considers a petition for relief under this section, in its discretion and in the interest of justice, an unpaid order of restitution or restitution fine shall not be grounds for denial of the petition for relief.
(e)(1)Relief shall not be granted under this section unless the prosecuting attorney has been given 15 days notice of the petition for relief. The probation officer shall notify the prosecuting attorney when a petition is filed, pursuant to this section.
(2)It shall be presumed that the prosecuting attorney has received notice if proof of service is filed with the court.
(f)If, after receiving notice pursuant to subdivision (e), the prosecuting attorney fails to appear and object to a petition for dismissal, the prosecuting attorney shall not move to set aside or otherwise appeal the grant of that petition.
(g)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not release the defendant from the terms and conditions of any unexpired criminal protective orders that have been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of of, or subdivision (j) of, Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying accusation or information.
(h)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not affect the authority to receive, or take adverse action based on, criminal history information, including the authority to receive certified court records received or evaluated pursuant to Section 1522, 1568.09, 1569.17, or 1596.871 of the Health and Safety Code, or pursuant to any statutory or regulatory provisions that incorporate the criteria of those sections. Relief granted pursuant to this section does not make eligible a person who is otherwise ineligible under state or federal law or regulation to provide, or receive payment for providing, in-home supportive services and waiver personal care services pursuant to Article 7 (commencing with Section 12300) of Chapter 3 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or pursuant to Section 14132.95, 14132.952, 14132.956, or 14132.97 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
SEC. 8.Section 1203.425 of the Penal Code, as amended by Section 1 of Chapter 444 of the Statutes of 2023, is amended to read:1203.425.(a)(1)(A)Commencing July 1, 2024, and subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, on a monthly basis, the Department of Justice shall review the records in the statewide criminal justice databases, and based on information in the state summary criminal history repository and the Supervised Release File, shall identify persons with convictions that meet the criteria set forth in subparagraph (B) and are eligible for automatic conviction record relief.
(B)A person is eligible for automatic conviction relief pursuant to this section if they meet all of the following conditions:
(i)The person is not required to register pursuant to the Sex Offender Registration Act.
(ii)The person does not have an active record for local, state, or federal supervision in the Supervised Release File.
(iii)Based upon the information available in the departments record, including disposition dates and sentencing terms, it does not appear that the person is currently serving a sentence for an offense and there is no indication of pending criminal charges.
(iv)The conviction meets either of the following criteria:
(I)The conviction occurred on or after January 1, 1973, and meets either of the following criteria:
(ia)The defendant was sentenced to probation and, based upon the disposition date and the term of probation specified in the departments records, appears to have completed their term of probation without revocation.
(ib)The defendant was convicted of an infraction or misdemeanor other than one eligible under sub-subclause (ia), and, based upon the disposition date and the term specified in the departments records, the defendant appears to have completed their sentence, and at least one calendar year has elapsed since the date of judgment.
(II)The conviction occurred on or after January 1, 2005, the defendant was convicted of a felony other than one for which the defendant completed probation without revocation, and based upon the disposition date and the sentence specified in the departments records, appears to have completed all terms of incarceration, probation, mandatory supervision, postrelease community supervision, and parole, and a period of four years has elapsed since the date on which the defendant completed probation or supervision for that conviction and during which the defendant was not convicted of a new felony offense. This subclause does not apply to a conviction of a serious felony defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1192.7, a violent felony as defined in Section 667.5, or a felony offense requiring registration pursuant to Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 290) of Title 9 of Part 1.
(2)(A)Except as specified in subdivision (b), the department shall grant relief, including dismissal of a conviction, to a person identified pursuant to paragraph (1) without requiring a petition or motion by a party for that relief if the relevant information is present in the departments electronic records.
(B)The state summary criminal history information shall include, directly next to or below the entry or entries regarding the persons criminal record, a note stating relief granted, listing the date that the department granted relief and this section. This note shall be included in all statewide criminal databases with a record of the conviction.
(C)Except as otherwise provided in paragraph (4) and in Section 13555 of the Vehicle Code, a person granted conviction relief pursuant to this section shall be released from all penalties and disabilities resulting from the offense of which the person has been convicted.
(3)(A)Commencing July 1, 2022, and subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, on a monthly basis, the department shall electronically submit a notice to the superior court having jurisdiction over the criminal case, informing the court of all cases for which a complaint was filed in that jurisdiction and for which relief was granted pursuant to this section. Commencing on January 1, 2023, for any record retained by the court pursuant to Section 68152 of the Government Code, except as provided in paragraph (4), the court shall not disclose information concerning a conviction granted relief pursuant to this section or Section 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.41, or 1203.42, to any person or entity, in any format, except to the person whose conviction was granted relief or a criminal justice agency, as defined in Section 851.92.
(B)If probation is transferred pursuant to Section 1203.9, the department shall electronically submit a notice as provided in subparagraph (A) to both the transferring court and any subsequent receiving court. The electronic notice shall be in a mutually agreed upon format.
(C)If a receiving court reduces a felony to a misdemeanor pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 17, or dismisses a conviction pursuant to law, including, but not limited to, Section 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.41, 1203.42, 1203.43, or 1203.49, it shall furnish a disposition report to the department with the original case number and CII number from the transferring court. The department shall electronically submit a notice to the superior court that sentenced the defendant. If probation is transferred multiple times, the department shall electronically submit a notice to all other involved courts. The electronic notice shall be in a mutually agreed upon format.
(D)If a court receives notification from the department pursuant to subparagraph (B), the court shall update its records to reflect the reduction or dismissal. If a court receives notification that a case was dismissed pursuant to this section or Section 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.41, or 1203.42, the court shall update its records to reflect the dismissal and shall not disclose information concerning a conviction granted relief to any person or entity, in any format, except to the person whose conviction was granted relief or a criminal justice agency, as defined in Section 851.92.
(4)Relief granted pursuant to this section is subject to the following conditions:
(A)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not relieve a person of the obligation to disclose a criminal conviction in response to a direct question contained in a questionnaire or application for employment as a peace officer, as defined in Section 830.
(B)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not relieve a person of the obligation to disclose the conviction in response to a direct question contained in a questionnaire or application for public office, for enrollment as a provider of in-home supportive services and waiver personal care services pursuant to Article 7 (commencing with Section 12300) of Chapter 3 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code or pursuant to Section 14132.95, 14132.952, 14132.956, or 14132.97 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or for contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
(C)Relief granted pursuant to this section has no effect on the ability of a criminal justice agency, as defined in Section 851.92, to access and use records that are granted relief to the same extent that would have been permitted for a criminal justice agency had relief not been granted.
(D)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not limit the jurisdiction of the court over a subsequently filed motion to amend the record, petition or motion for postconviction relief, or collateral attack on a conviction for which relief has been granted pursuant to this section.
(E)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not affect a persons authorization to own, possess, or have in the persons custody or control a firearm, or the persons susceptibility to conviction under Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 29800) of Division 9 of Title 4 of Part 6, if the criminal conviction would otherwise affect this authorization or susceptibility.
(F)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not affect a prohibition from holding public office that would otherwise apply under law as a result of the criminal conviction.
(G)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not release a person from the terms and conditions of any unexpired criminal protective order that has been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of of, or subdivision (j) of, Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying conviction.
(H)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not affect the authority to receive, or take adverse action based on, criminal history information, including the authority to receive certified court records received or evaluated pursuant to Section 1522, 1568.09, 1569.17, or 1596.871 of the Health and Safety Code, or pursuant to any statutory or regulatory provisions that incorporate the criteria of those sections.
(I)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not make eligible a person who is otherwise ineligible under state or federal law or regulation to provide, or receive payment for providing, in-home supportive services and waiver personal care services pursuant to Article 7 (commencing with Section 12300) of Chapter 3 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or pursuant to Section 14132.95, 14132.952, 14132.956, or 14132.97 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(J)In a subsequent prosecution of the defendant for any other offense, the prior conviction may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if the relief had not been granted.
(K)(i)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not affect the authority to receive, or take adverse action based on, criminal history information, including the authority to receive certified court records received or evaluated pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 44000) of Chapter 1, Article 3 (commencing with Section 44240) and Article 8 (commencing with Section 44330) of Chapter 2, Article 1 (commencing with Section 44420) of Chapter 3, Article 3 (commencing with Section 44930) of Chapter 4, Article 1 (commencing with Section 45100) and Article 6 (commencing with Section 45240) of Chapter 5, of Part 25 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code, or pursuant to any statutory or regulatory provisions that relate to, incorporate, expand upon, or interpret the authority of those provisions.
(ii)Notwithstanding clause (i) or any other law, information for a conviction for a controlled substance offense listed in Section 11350 or 11377, or former Section 11500 or 11500.5, of the Health and Safety Code that is more than five years old, for which relief is granted pursuant to this section, shall not be disclosed.
(L)Relief granted pursuant to this section does not release the defendant from the terms and conditions of any unexpired criminal protective orders that have been issued by the court pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (i) of Section 136.2, subdivision (j) of Section 273.5, subdivision (l) of Section 368, or subdivision (k) of Section 646.9. These protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, despite the dismissal of the underlying accusation or information.
(5)This section does not limit petitions, motions, or orders for relief in a criminal case, as required or authorized by any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 1016.5, 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.4b, 1203.41, 1203.42, 1203.49, and 1473.7. This section does not limit petitions for a certificate of rehabilitation or pardon pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 4852.01) of Title 6 of Part 3.
(6)Commencing July 1, 2022, and subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, the department shall annually publish statistics for each county regarding the total number of convictions granted relief pursuant to this section and the total number of convictions prohibited from automatic relief pursuant to subdivision (b), on the OpenJustice Web portal, as defined in Section 13010.
(7)Upon request from the subject of the record, the department shall provide confirmation that relief was granted pursuant to this section.
(b)(1)The prosecuting attorney or probation department may, no later than 90 calendar days before the date of a persons eligibility for relief pursuant to this section, file a petition to prohibit the department from granting automatic relief pursuant to this section, based on a showing that granting that relief would pose a substantial threat to the public safety. If probation was transferred pursuant to Section 1203.9, the prosecuting attorney or probation department in either the receiving county or the transferring county shall file the petition in the county of current jurisdiction.
(2)The court shall give notice to the defendant and conduct a hearing on the petition within 45 days after the petition is filed.
(3)At a hearing on the petition pursuant to this subdivision, the defendant, the probation department, the prosecuting attorney, and the arresting agency, through the prosecuting attorney, may present evidence to the court. Notwithstanding Sections 1538.5 and 1539, the hearing may be heard and determined upon declarations, affidavits, police investigative reports, copies of state summary criminal history information and local summary criminal history information, or any other evidence submitted by the parties that is material, reliable, and relevant.
(4)The prosecutor or probation department has the initial burden of proof to show that granting conviction relief would pose a substantial threat to the public safety. In determining whether granting relief would pose a substantial threat to the public safety, the court may consider any relevant factors, including, but not limited to, either of the following:
(A)Declarations or evidence regarding the offense for which a grant of relief is being contested.
(B)The defendants record of arrests and convictions.
(5)If the court finds that the prosecutor or probation department has satisfied the burden of proof, the burden shifts to the defendant to show that the hardship of not obtaining relief outweighs the threat to the public safety of providing relief. In determining whether the defendants hardship outweighs the threat to the public safety, the court may consider any relevant factors, including, but not limited to, either of the following:
(A)The hardship to the defendant that has been caused by the conviction and that would be caused if relief is not granted.
(B)Declarations or evidence regarding the defendants good character.
(6)If the court grants a petition pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall furnish a disposition report to the Department of Justice pursuant to Section 13151, stating that relief pursuant to this section was denied, and the department shall not grant relief pursuant to this section. If probation was transferred pursuant to Section 1203.9, the department shall electronically submit a notice to the transferring court, and, if probation was transferred multiple times, to all other involved courts.
(7)A person denied relief pursuant to this section may continue to be eligible for relief pursuant to law, including, but not limited to, Section 1203.4, 1203.4a, 1203.4b, or 1203.41. If the court subsequently grants relief pursuant to one of those sections, the court shall furnish a disposition report to the Department of Justice pursuant to Section 13151, stating that relief was granted pursuant to the applicable section, and the department shall grant relief pursuant to that section. If probation was transferred pursuant to Section 1203.9, the department shall electronically submit a notice that relief was granted pursuant to the applicable section to the transferring court and, if probation was transferred multiple times, to all other involved courts.
(c)At the time of sentencing, the court shall advise a defendant, either orally or in writing, of the provisions of this section and of the defendants right, if any, to petition for a certificate of rehabilitation and pardon.
(d)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2024.
SEC. 9.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to criminal procedure. REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to criminal procedure.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 24, 2024 | From committee: Without further action pursuant to Joint Rule 62(a). |
| Apr 17, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. |
| Mar 19, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 18, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 18, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jan 26, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 25. |
| Jan 25, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| Arcadia Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Burbank Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| California Coalition of School Safety Professionals | ** Support | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | |
| California Reserve Peace Officers Association | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| CLAREMONT POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Corona Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Culver City Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Deputy Sheriffs Association of Monterey County | ** Support | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Against | |
| Felony Murder Elimination Project | ** Against | |
| Fullerton Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles School Police Management Association | ** Support | |
| los angeles school police officers association | ** Support | |
| Murrieta Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Newport Beach Police Association | ** Support | |
| Novato Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Orange County Sheriff's Department | ** Support | |
| Palos Verdes Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| PLACER COUNTY DEPUTY SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Pomona Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| power + Resilience Project | ** Support | |
| RIVERSIDE POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| San Bernardino County Sheriff'S Department | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Against | |
| Santa Ana Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Smart Justice California, a project of Tides Advocacy | ** Against | |
| Upland Police Officers Association | ** Support |
Date of Hearing:
Counsel: Ilan Zur
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1931
Author:(Dixon) – As Amended Ver:March 18, 2024
SUMMARY:
Requires courts, to consider issuing a lifetime criminal protective order prohibiting a convicted defendant from contacting any victim of the crime, for any serious felony any violent felony, or any felony offense requiring registration as a sex-offender. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a court, when a criminal defendant has been convicted of any violent felony, any serious felony, or any felony offense requiring registration as a sex-offender to consider issuing a lifetime criminal protective order that prohibits the defendant from contacting any victim of the crime for their lifetime, unless the victim requests otherwise.
- Provides that any victim of an above offense may petition the court to issue a lifetime protective order.
- Provides that such a lifetime protective order will expire if the victim dies, the underlying conviction is dismissed or overturned, or the court, at the request of the victim, removes the lifetime protective order.
- Allows a victim to petition the court for removal of a lifetime protective order at any time and the court may hold a hearing to verify the victim’s request to dismiss the lifetime protective order.
- Provides that a protective order still in effect that was issued before January 1, 2025, against a defendant convicted of domestic violence, human trafficking, gang activity, rape, statutory rape, spousal rape, pimping and pandering, offenses requiring sex offender registration, elder abuse, and willfully, malicious, and repeated stalking, may be extended into a lifetime protective order against the defendant. This is applicable, if, during the duration of the order, even if prior to this bill becomes effective, the defendant has violated the terms and conditions of the order, the defendant has been convicted of a violent felony, serious felony, or felony sex-offender offense, and the court finds there is a probability of future violations, and the safety of a victim and the victim’s immediate family, would make the extension of the protective order appropriate.
- Provides that such extended protective orders could similarly expire if the victim dies, the underlying conviction is dismissed or overturned, or the court, at the request of the victim, removes the lifetime protective order, and requires the Department of Justice (DOJ) to be immediately notified upon the issuing of such an order.
- Clarifies that a court may impose a protective order for up to 10 years prohibiting a defendant from having any contact with a victim of the crime, in the case of a criminal defendant convicted of a misdemeanor offense that requires a person to register as a sex-offender.
- Requires a court to serve the defendant with any lifetime protective order that has been issued at the time of sentencing.
- Requires, upon issuing a lifetime protective order, the DOJ to be immediately notified of the contents of the order, specified demographic information, the names of protected persons, the date of issuance of the order, the duration of the order, the terms and conditions of the order, and other specified information.
- Provides that a lifetime protective order may be issued by the court regardless of whether the defendant is sentenced to incarceration in the state prison or a county jail, whether the defendant is subject to mandatory supervision, or whether imposition of sentence is suspended and the defendant is placed on probation.
- Provides that the lifetime protective order may be modified throughout the duration of the order by the court in the county in which the order was issued.
- Provides that such a lifetime protective order may include provisions for electronic monitoring for up to one year, subject to the applicable local government adopting a policy pertaining to electronic monitoring.
- Provides if the defendant must pay for the electronic monitoring if the court determines they have the ability to pay, but if the defendant does not have the ability to pay for the monitoring, the court may order the electronic monitoring to be paid for by the local government that adopted the policy authorizing electronic monitoring.
- Requires the Judicial Council to develop forms, instructions, and rules relating to lifetime protective orders issued or the extension of orders already in place, under this bill.
- Specifies that such lifetime protective orders shall remain in full effect until expiration or until any further order by the court modifying or terminating the order, even if the underlying accusation or information is dismissed, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines the following offenses as “serious” felonies:
- Murder or voluntary manslaughter;
- Mayhem;
- Rape;
- Sodomy by force, violence, duress, menace, or threat or fear of bodily injury;
- Oral copulation by force, violence, duress, menace or threat or fear of bodily injury;
- Lewd act with child under fourteen years of age;
- Any felony punishable by death or life imprisonment;
- Any felony in which defendant personally inflicts great bodily injury on any person other than an accomplice or personally uses a firearm;
- Attempted murder;
- Assault with intent to commit rape or robbery;
- Assault with a deadly weapon or instrument on a peace officer;
- Assault by a life prisoner on a non-inmate;
- Assault with a deadly weapon by an inmate;
- Arson;
- Exploding a destructive device or any explosive with intent to injure;
- Exploding a destructive device or any explosive causing bodily injury, great bodily injury, or mayhem;
- Exploding a destructive device or any explosive with intent to murder;
- Burglary of an inhabited dwelling;
- Robbery or bank robbery;
- Kidnapping;
- Holding a hostage by an inmate;
- Attempt to commit a crime punishable by life imprisonment or death;
- Any felony where defendant personally used a dangerous or deadly weapon;
- Sale or furnishing heroin, cocaine, PCP, or methamphetamine to a minor;
- Forcible penetration with a foreign object;
- Grand theft involving a firearm;
- carjacking
- Any gang-related felony;
- Assault with the intent to commit mayhem or specified sex offenses;
- Maliciously throwing acid or flammable substances;
- Witness intimidation;
- Assault with a deadly weapon or firearm or assault on a peace officer or firefighter;
- Assault with a deadly weapon on a public transit employee;
- Criminal threats;
- Discharge of a firearm at an inhabited dwelling, vehicle, or aircraft;
- Commission of rape or sexual penetration in concert;
- Continuous sexual abuse of a child;
- Shooting from a vehicle;
- Any attempt to commit a “serious” felony other than assault;
- Any violation of the 10 years, 20 years, 25 years to life gun law;
- Possession or use of any weapon of mass destruction,
- Human trafficking of a minor, except where the person who committed the offense was a victim of human trafficking at the time of the offense, as specified.
- Murder or voluntary manslaughter;
- Any conspiracy to commit a “serious” felony. (Pen. Code, § 1192.7, subd. (c).)
- Defines a “violent felony” as any of the following:
- Murder or voluntary manslaughter;
- Mayhem;
- Rape accomplished by means of force or threats of retaliation;
- Sodomy by force or fear of immediate bodily injury on the victim or another person or with a child under the age of 14 years, as specified;
- Oral copulation by force or fear of immediate bodily injury on the victim or another person or with a child under the age of 14 years, as specified;
- Lewd acts on a child under the age of 14 years, as defined;
- Any felony punishable by death or imprisonment in the state prison for life;
- Any felony in which the defendant inflicts great bodily injury on any person other than an accomplice, or any felony in which the defendant has used a firearm, as specified;
- Any robbery;
- Arson of a structure, forest land, or property that causes great bodily injury or that causes an inhabited structure or property to burn;
- Arson that causes an inhabited structure or property to burn;
- Sexual penetration accomplished against the victim's will by means of force, menace or fear of immediate bodily injury on the victim or another person, by threats of retaliation, or of a child under the age of 14 years, as specified;
- Attempted murder;
- Explosion or attempted explosion of a destructive device with the intent to commit murder;
- Explosion or ignition of any destructive device or any explosive which causes bodily injury to any person;
- Explosion of a destructive device which causes death or great bodily injury;
- Kidnapping;
- Assault with intent to commit mayhem or specified sex offenses;
- Continuous sexual abuse of a child;
- Carjacking;
- Rape or sexual penetration in concert;
- Felony extortion;
- Threats to victims or witnesses, as specified;
- First degree burglary, as defined, where it is proved that another person other than an accomplice, was present in the residence during the burglary;
- Use of a firearm during the commission of specified crimes; and,
- Possession, development, production, and transfers of weapons of mass destruction. (Pen. Code § 667.5, subd. (c).)
- Murder or voluntary manslaughter;
- Authorizes the trial court in a criminal case to issue criminal protective orders when there is a good cause belief that harm to, or intimidation or dissuasion of, a victim or witness has occurred or is reasonably likely to occur. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (a).)
- Requires a court to consider issuing up to a 10 year post-conviction protective order prohibiting a convicted defendant from any contact with a victim of a crime, for convictions pertaining to domestic violence (including domestic violence resulting in corporal injury), human trafficking, gang activity, rape, statutory rape, spousal rape, pimping and pandering, offenses requiring sex offender registration, elder abuse, and willfully, malicious, and repeated stalking. (Pen. Code, §§ 136.2, subd. (i)(1); 273.5, subd. (j); 368, subd. (l); 646.9, subd. (k); 1201.3, subd. (a).)
- Provides that such an order may be modified by the sentencing court in the county in which it was issued throughout the duration of the order. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(1).)
- Provides that a criminal protective order may be issued by the court regardless of whether the defendant is sentenced to the state prison, or a county jail, or subject to mandatory supervision, or whether the defendant is placed on probation. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(1).)
- Provides that the duration of a criminal protective order issued by the court should be based upon the seriousness of the facts before the court, the probability of future violations, and the safety of the victim and the victim’s immediate family. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(1).)
- Authorizes a court to place conditions on a 10 year restraining order that can include electronic monitoring for up to one year, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(3).)
- Requires a court to consider issuing up to a 10 year criminal protective order for protecting a percipient witness to a crime, upon clear and convincing evidence of witness harassment, in cases with convictions including, but not limited to domestic violence, rape, statutory rape, gang activity, and sex registerable offenses. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(2).)
- Provides that a person violating a criminal protective order may be punished for any substantive offense described in provisions of law related to intimidation of witnesses or victims, or for contempt of court, which is punishable as a misdemeanor. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (b).)
- Provides that a willful and knowing violation of a criminal protective order constitutes contempt of court, a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in county jail for up to one year or a fine of $1,000. (Pen. Code, §§ 273.6, subd. (a), 166, subd. (a)(4).)
- Prohibits a person who is subject to a protective order from owning, possessing, purchasing, attempting to purchase or receive, a firearm while the protective order is in effect, and the court shall order a person subject to the protective order to relinquish ownership or possession of any firearms. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (d).)
- States that cases where the defendant is charged with a crime involving domestic violence, rape, or a sex registerable offense must be clearly marked to alert the court of their nature. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (e)(1).)
- Civil Protective Orders
- Allows a court to issue civil harassment restraining orders for up to five years upon a showing of clear and convincing evidence of unlawful harassment. An order can be issued for up to 5 years, or renewed for an additional five years. An order that does not state an expiration date on the face of the form will be deemed to last for 3 years. (Civ. Pro. Code, §§ 527.6.)
- Allows the court to issue workplace violence restraining orders for up to three years upon a showing of clear and convincing evidence. (Civ. Pro. Code, § 527.8.) An order can be renewed for an additional five years. An order that does not state an expiration date on the face of the form will be deemed to last for 3 years. (Civ. Pro. Code, §§ 527.6.)
- Permits a court to issue a civil domestic violence or elder abuse restraining order enjoining a party from, among other things contacting or coming within a specified distance of a specified person. Such orders can be issued for up to five years, may be renewed upon a request of a party for five years or permanently, without a showing of any further abuse since the issuance of the order. Failure to state the expiration date on the face of the order creates an order with duration of 3 years. (Fam. Code, §§ 6320, 6345; Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15657.03.)
- Provides that if there are both civil and criminal orders regarding the same parties and neither an emergency protective order that has precedence in enforcement nor a no-contact order has been issued, the peace officer shall enforce the criminal order issued last. (Fam. Code, § 6383, subd. (h)(2).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "AB 1931 will allow a judge the discretion to issue a lifetime injunction against a defendant at the time of sentencing for a serious felony, a violent felony, or a felony sex offense. Currently, California law allows temporary restraining orders that only provide short term relief. Survivors of these heinous acts are forced to face their trauma in the courtroom over and over again to get basic protections. Additionally, the bill gives a judge the ability to lift the order if the victim has passed away, the conviction was dismissed, expunged, or overturned or the victim has petitioned for the order to be removed. AB 1931 will provide critical protections for survivors from their abusers by allowing judges the discretion to issue a lifetime injunction. Because you matter.”
- Civil and Criminal Protective Orders: Protective orders and restraining orders are, in the outcome, very similar – both are orders issued or approved by a court that prevents a person from contacting another person under specific circumstances and may also restrict other conduct to prevent contact, harassment, threats, or violence. (See generally, Fam. Code, § 6218, subd. (a)-(c).) There are some differences. For example, criminal protective orders are typically requested by district attorneys on behalf of the victim, while civil restraining orders are typically sought by one of the parties involved in a civil dispute. This bill pertains to criminal protective orders.
There are several types of civil restraining orders available to victims of specified crimes. For example, a victim of domestic violence needing immediate protection may seek a temporary restraining order on an ex parte basis. The court may issue a short-term temporary order enjoining the abuser from a range of conduct, including harassing, threatening, and contacting the victim. (Fam. Code, § 6320 et seq.) After a noticed hearing, the court may issue an order protecting the survivor against a range of actions for a term of up to five years. (Fam. Code, § 6340 et seq.) At the end of the term of the protective order issued after a hearing, the court may renew the order at the request of any party, subject to any modifications ordered by the court or stipulated to by the parties. (Fam. Code, § 6345.)
Criminal protective orders can be issued during a criminal proceeding. Specifically, a trial court in a criminal case can issue criminal protective orders when there is a good cause to believe that harm to, or intimidation or dissuasion of, a victim or witness has occurred or is reasonably likely to occur. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (a).) Such protective orders are valid only during the pendency of the criminal proceedings. (People v. Ponce (2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 378, 382.). When criminal proceedings have concluded, the court has authority to issue protective orders as a condition of probation. For example, when domestic violence criminal proceedings have concluded, the court can issue a "no-contact order" as a condition of probation. (Pen. Code, § 1203.097.)
Lastly, and most relevant here, courts can issue up to a 10 year post-conviction protective order prohibiting a convicted defendant from any contact with a victim of a crime. This 10 year “no contact” remedy is available for a narrow list of crimes; convictions pertaining to domestic violence, human trafficking, gang activity, rape, pimping and pandering, offenses requiring sex offender registration, elder abuse, and willfully, malicious, and repeated stalking. (Pen. Code, §§ 136.2, subd. (i)(1); 273.5, subd. (j); 368, subd. (l); 646.9, subd. (k); 1201.3, subd. (a).) Specific to domestic violence and offenses requiring sex offender registration, the case file must be clearly marked so that the court is aware of their nature for purposes of considering a protective order. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (e)(1).) Additionally, a court may issue a 10 year criminal protective order for protecting a percipient witness to a crime, upon clear and convincing evidence of witness harassment, in cases with convictions including, but not limited to domestic violence, rape, statutory rape, gang activity, and sex registerable offenses. (Pen. Code, § 136.2, subd. (i)(2).). Such orders may be modified throughout the duration of the order.
As a general rule, civil courts may issue a civil restraining order up to five years. For example, civil harassment restraining orders can last up to five years, and be renewed for another five years. (Civ. Pro. Code, §§ 527.6.) Similarly, a workplace violence order can be issued for up to three years, and renewed for an additional five years. (Civ. Pro. Code, §§ 527.6.) Additionally, civil domestic violence or elder abuse restraining orders can be issued for up to five years. Notably these particular orders can renewed for another five years, or permanently. (Fam. Code, §§ 6320, 6345; Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15657.03.)
- Effect of this Bill: This bill would constitute a drastic expansion of both the duration of criminal protection orders and the type of crimes where courts may order criminal protective orders. Under existing law, courts can issue a criminal protective order lasting up to 10 years against defendants convicted of certain specified crimes (domestic violence, human trafficking, gang activity, rape, pimping and pandering, offenses requiring sex offender registration, elder abuse, and willfully, malicious, and repeated stalking). This bill would require courts to consider issuing a lifetime criminal protective order preventing a defendant from having any contact with a victim of the crime, for any serious felony, any violent felony, or any felony offense requiring registration as a sex-offender. As noted above, courts are already permitted to issue 10 year criminal protective orders for offenses requiring registration as a sex offender. The list of serious and violent felonies is lengthy - there over 40 crimes that are considered serious felonies, and over 20 crimes that are considered violent felonies. These range from murder, rape, and possession of weapons of mass destruction, to first degree burglary, robbery, attempting to commit any crime punishable by life imprisonment, sale of specified controlled substances to a minor, grand theft involving a firearm, carjacking, any gang-related felony, witness intimidation, or any conspiracy to commit a serious felony. By expanding the availability of criminal protective orders to the long list of violent or serious felonies, and authorizing courts to issue lifetime protective order (rather than 10 years for a narrow list of felonies) for all such felonies, this bill can be expected to significantly increase the number of protective orders that are sought and issued, and the amount of time that such persons are subject to such orders. Although, such lifetime orders could expire in certain circumstances (death of the victim, underlying conviction is dismissed or overturned, or a court removes the order at request of the victim).
Additionally, this bill would apply retroactively to certain criminal protective orders already in effect. Specifically, it would allow a protective order still in effect that was issued before January 1, 2025, against a defendant convicted of domestic violence, human trafficking, gang activity, rape, statutory rape, spousal rape, pimping and pandering, offenses requiring sex offender registration, elder abuse, and willfully, malicious, and repeated stalking, to be extended into a lifetime protective order against the defendant. This would only occur, if during the duration of the order, the defendant has violated the terms of the order, the defendant has been convicted of a violent felony, serious felony, or felony sex-offender offense, and the court finds there is a probability of future violations and that the safety of a victim and the victim’s immediate family, would make the extension of the protective order appropriate. For example, take a person convicted of a domestic violence related offense that resulted in a 10 year protective order prohibiting them from contacting or approaching their former spouse, who, prior to this bill, had violated the terms of their order and was convicted of separate serious felony such as robbery or carjacking. Under this bill, a court would be required to consider extending their 10 year order into a lifetime order based on their prior conduct, upon a finding of a probability of future violations and a threat to the safety of the victim.
- Impact of Lifetime Protective Orders on Criminal Contempt Charges: By expanding the availability of criminal protective orders to every type of serious and violent felony, and permitting such orders to last a defendant’s lifetime, this bill can be expected to create a significant increase in the number of criminal contempt misdemeanor convictions associated with violating protective orders.
Disobedience of a court order may be punished as criminal contempt. The crime of contempt is a general intent crime. It is proven by showing that the defendant intended to commit the prohibited act, without any additional showing that he or she intended “to do some further act or achieve some additional consequence.” (People v. Greenfield (1982) 134 Cal.App.3d Supp. 1, 4.) Nevertheless, a violation must also be willful, which in the case of a court order encompasses both intent to disobey the order, and disregard of the duty to obey the order.” (In re Karpf (1970) 10 Cal.App.3d 355, 372.)
Criminal contempt is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in county jail for up to one year or a fine of $1,000. (Pen. Code, §§ 273.6, subd. (a), 166, subd. (a)(4).) Proceedings under the statute are conducted like any other misdemeanor offense. (In re McKinney (1968) 70 Cal.2d 8, 10; In re Kreitman (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 750, 755.) Therefore, the criminal contempt power is vested in the prosecution; the trial court has no power to institute criminal contempt proceedings under the Penal Code. (In re McKinney, supra, 70 Cal.2d at p. 13.) A defendant charged with the crime of contempt is “entitled to the full panoply of substantive and due process rights.” (People v. Kalnoki (1992) 7 Cal.App.4t Supp. 8, 11.) Therefore, the defendant has the right to a jury trial, regardless of the sentence imposed. (People v. Earley (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 542, 550.)
This bill can be expected to increase future prosecutions for violating such orders – subjecting persons who have completed their sentences, and all conditions of probation or supervision, to the threat of lifetime prosecution. This can reasonably be expected to increase the number of incarcerated persons and associated prison costs.
- Impact of Lifetime Criminal Protective Orders on Families, Housing, Employment, and Immigration Status: The consequences of having the court issue a restraining order, let alone a lifetime restraining order, can be very severe. A criminal protective order under this bill could prohibit a defendant from any contact or going within a certain distance of any victim of any serious or violent felony for the entirety of the defendant’s lifetime.
First, such an order could threaten an individual’s housing and community interests by forcing them to vacate their home or leave their family. For example, a person who lives with their family, but is convicted of robbing a nearby house or carjacking of a car on their street, could be subject to criminal protective order that could force that person to move out of their home and away from their family. This could undermine economic security and increase the likelihood of a person becoming unhoused.
Second, this bill could create lifetime criminal consequences for minors and young adults convicted of serious felonies such as gang related offenses, robberies, carjacking, and selling of specified drugs to other minors. Allowing judges to issue criminal protective orders in such circumstances, let alone for a lifetime, could force minors to vacate their schools, communities, and even families. Further, a person convicted of domestic violence, subject to a lifetime protective order prohibiting them from going near the victim of the abuse, could be subject to an order severely limiting their ability to visit their child for the rest of their life.
Third, such a significant expansion of criminal protective orders can additionally be expected to create consequences for a person’s future employment, housing, professional licenses, and immigration status, particularly for lifetime orders. For example, a violation of a protective order is a deportable offense. Section 237(a)(2)(E)(ii) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) states:
“Any [undocumented person] who at any time after entry is enjoined under a protection order issued by a court an whom the court determines has engaged in conduct that violates the portion of a protection order that involves protection against credible threats of violence, repeated harassment, or bodily injury to the person or persons for whom the protection order was issued is deportable.”
Further, a person who has served their time, completed all terms of their probation, and otherwise is seeking to be a law abiding member of the community, could face difficulties securing employment or housing for the rest of their lives. Employers or landlords running background checks may be discouraged from hiring or providing housing to persons with active criminal protective orders. This is particularly true given that this bill provides that such lifetime protective orders shall remain in full effect (unless they expire as specified) even if the underlying accusation or information is dismissed, as specified.
While this bill admirably intends to protect victims from having to go through the pain and trauma of having to seek a modification or renewal of a restraining order, authorizing lifetime protective orders for any violent or serious felony may undermine person’s successful reentry into the community, increase a person’s likelihood to commit new crimes, and detrimentally impact public safety. This is counterintuitive to legislative action the state has taken in recent years to make it easier for convicted person’s to reintegrate into communities and secure housing and employment, by sealing and reclassifying criminal records, including felony convictions. (See SB 731 (Durazo), Chapter 814, Statutes of 2022 (expanding arrest and conviction relief to include felonies); AB 1076 (Ting), Chapter 578, Statutes of 2019 (requiring the DOJ, on a monthly basis, to review the records in the statewide criminal justice databases grant relief to persons who identify persons who are eligible for relief by having their arrest records, or their criminal conviction records, withheld from disclosure, as specified.); AB 1418 (McKinnor), Chapter 476, Statutes of 2023 (prohibiting a local government from requiring or encouraging a landlord to evict or penalize a tenant because of the tenant’s association with another tenant or household member who has had contact with a law enforcement agency or has a criminal conviction or to perform a criminal background check of a tenant or a prospective tenant).)
- Constitutional Concerns - Fifth Amendment, Sixth Amendment, Eight Amendment, Fourteenth Amendment, Ex-Post Facto: The expansion of current law to allow post-conviction restraining orders to last for a lifetime for over 40 types of crimes raises numerous questions about the constitutionality of such an expansion, such as right to travel, due process or cruel and unusual punishment.
First, a lifetime protective prohibiting a defendant from being within a certain distance of the person named in the order, could undermine the defendant’s right to travel under the Fifth Amendment. Second, this bill may be vulnerable to a constitutional challenge under the Eight, Fifth or Fourteen Amendment. The Eighth Amendment prohibits the government from imposing cruel and unusual punishment and the right to due process is found in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, which ensures that a defendant is treated fairly during criminal proceedings. A cruel and unusual punishment claim could be raised when the punishment is disproportionate to the crime. Allowing lifetime criminal protective orders to be issued against minors who have been convicted of robbery, carjacking, or sale of specified drugs to other minors, in addition to the criminal sentence associated with that penalty, is constitutionally suspect. For decades, California law has only permitted criminal protective orders for up to 10 years for a narrow list of crimes, and allowing lifetime criminal protective orders to be issued for any serious or violent felony, may result in numerous legal challenges. This is particularly true given that protective orders are a frequent topic of litigation.
Third, when a court sentences a defendant the court generally loses jurisdiction over the case. However, there are instances where the court retains limited jurisdiction for purposes such as adjudicating probation-related issues. In situations where a post-conviction protective order has been issued, the court retains limited jurisdiction to modify or terminate the order. However, if a court were to issue a protective order to last up to a defendant’s life, would this also extend a court’s jurisdiction over the defendant for life? The bill does not require the court to make any additional findings when issuing a post-conviction protective order for a lifetime, rather than ten years (except for when it would apply retroactively). This may violate due process and the prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.
Fourth, an argument can be made that a lifetime criminal protective order, in addition to the sentence associated with the crime, runs afoul of the Sixth Amendment. In Apprendi v. United States (2000) 530 U.S. 466, the United States Supreme Court held that "other than the fact of a prior conviction, any fact that increases the penalty for a crime beyond the prescribed statutory maximum must be submitted to a jury, and proved beyond a reasonable doubt." (Id. at p. 490.) Subsequently, in Blakely v. Washington (2004) 542 U.S. 296, the Court explained that “the ‘statutory maximum’ for Apprendi purposes is the maximum sentence a judge may impose solely on the basis of the facts reflected in the jury verdict or admitted by the defendant.” (Id. at p. 303). Because restraining orders are enforceable by way of contempt proceedings, arguably they constitute criminal punishment over and above the terms mandated by the offense of conviction. As such, they could be considered elements of an offense, and could not be mere findings of a court at sentencing. Thus, it is possible that the orders cannot be imposed unless the defendant had an opportunity for a jury trial and findings beyond a reasonable doubt under Blakely and Apprendi.
Fifth, because this bill would apply retroactively to extend certain criminal protective orders already in effect, it may run afoul of state and federal prohibitions on ex post facto laws (See Cal Const, Art. I § 9 (providing “a bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts may not be passed.”). (See also United States Const. art. I, § 10, cl 1 (No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts; pass any Bill of Attainder, ex post facto Law, or Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts, or grant any Title of Nobility.”) This bill contains a provision allowing for previously issued 10 year protective orders to be extended into lifetime prohibitions, based on prior conduct that occurs prior to this bill’s effective date. For example, take a person convicted of a domestic violence related offense that resulted in a 10 year protective order prohibiting them from contacting or approaching their former spouse, who, prior to this bill, had violated the terms of their order and was convicted of separate serious felony such as robbery or carjacking. Under AB 1931 a court could extend their 10 year order into a lifetime order based on their prior conduct, upon a finding of a probability of future violations and a threat to the safety of the victim. This retroactive increase of a prior criminal protective order, based on prior criminal conduct, could make this bill vulnerable to an ex-post facto legal challenge.
- Argument in Support: According to the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department “As the Sheriff of San Bernardino County, I have seen the immense challenges faced by victims of sexual crimes and the lasting impacts it has on their lives. “Kayleigh’s Law,” named after Kayleigh Kozack, a survivor and victim’s rights activist, represents a critical step forward ensuring that victims have the necessary legal protections to safeguard themselves from further harm.
By allowing victims to petition for lifetime injunctions against their offenders, "Kayleigh's Law" provides a vital layer of protection and peace of mind to survivors, enabling them to live their lives without fear of further contact or harassment. AB 1931 not only empowers survivors but also sends a clear message that our justice system stands with them and prioritizes their safety and well-being.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to the California Public Defenders Association, “Current law provides courts discretion to impose protective orders for a sufficient amount of time and in an appropriate range of cases. Imposing permanent protective orders would create circumstances in which individuals who have served their sentences, satisfied their supervision, and are otherwise living law abiding lives, are subject to the threat of lifetime prosecution because of a permanent restraining order. Setting a maximum length for a protective order ensures individuals have judicial review of existing orders, have notice of changes in victims’ geographic location (areas they are prohibited), and allows an end date for orders that no longer serve a purpose.”
- Related Legislation: AB 2308 (Davies), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would extend the amount of time a criminal protective order can be issued against a defendant convicted of domestic violence involving corporal injury to a spouse, cohabitant, fiancé, or parent of the offender’s child, from 10 years to 15 years. AB 2308 is pending in this committee
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 467 (Gabriel), Chapter 14, Statutes of 2023, clarifies that a court that sentenced a defendant and issued a 10-year criminal protective order, may make modifications to it throughout the duration of the order.
- AB 818 (Petrie-Norris), Chapter 242, Statutes of 2023, expands the requirement for law enforcement officers to serve domestic violence orders and specifies that law enforcement must enter a firearm obtained during service of domestic violence restraining order or obtained at the scene of a domestic violence incident into the Automated Firearms System (AFS).
- SB 853 (Hurtado), of the 2019-2020 Legislative Session, would have required courts to consider issuing a post-conviction restraining order for up to the duration that a defendant is required to register as a sex offender. SB 853 failed passage in Senate Public Safety.
- SB 382 (Caballero), Chapter 87, Statutes of 2022, includes commercial exploitation of a minor in existing provisions of law that authorize courts to issue a restraining order during the pendency of criminal proceedings and upon conviction of specified offenses.
- SB 352 (Block) Chapter 279, Statutes of 2015, authorized courts to issue a 10 year protective order upon convictions of certain elder abuse offenses.
- AB 307 (Campos), Chapter 291, Statutes of 2013, allows a court to issue a protective order for up to 10 years when a defendant is convicted of specified sex crimes, regardless of the sentence imposed.
- SB 723 (Pavley), Chapter 155, Statutes of 2011, allows a court to issue a protective order for up to 10 years when a defendant is convicted for an offense involving domestic violence.
- AB 289 (Spitzer), Chapter 582, Statutes of 2007, allows courts to issue a protective order for up to 10 years for a conviction stemming from a domestic violence causing corporal injury conviction.
- SB 834 (Florez), Chapter 627, Statutes of 2010, authorizes a court to issue a protective order for up to 10 years when a defendant is convicted for a sexual offense involving a minor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
(EM) power + Resilience Project
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California Coalition of School Safety Professionals
California Reserve Peace Officers Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
Los Angeles School Police Management Association
Los Angeles School Police Officers Association
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Novato Police Officers Association
Orange County Sheriff's Department
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Association
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
Opposition:
ACLU California Action
California Public Defenders Association
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Felony Murder Elimination Project
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
San Francisco Public Defender
Smart Justice California, a Project of Tides Advocacy
Analysis Prepared by:
Ilan Zur / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):