AB 1932: Personal income tax: mortgage interest deduction.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Personal Income Tax Law allows various deductions in computing the income that is subject to the taxes imposed by that law, including, in modified conformity with federal income tax laws, a deduction for a limited amount of interest paid on acquisition indebtedness, as defined, with respect to a qualified residence of the taxpayer. Existing law limits the aggregate amount treated as acquisition indebtedness for these purposes to $1,000,000, or $500,000 in the case of a married individual filing a separate return. Existing law specifies for these purposes that a qualified residence includes the taxpayers principal residence and one other residence selected by the taxpayer, as provided.
This bill, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, would disallow the deduction of acquisition indebtedness with respect to a qualified residence of a taxpayer other than the principal residence.
This bill would require the Franchise Tax Board, in consultation with the Department of Finance, to estimate the amount of additional revenue resulting from the above-described modifications made with respect to the calculation of taxable income under the Personal Income Tax Law by this bill and to notify the Controller of that amount, as provided.
The bill would establish the continuously appropriated Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund in the State Treasury, and would direct the Controller to transfer an amount from the General Fund to that fund equal to the above-described estimates. The bill would require the moneys be used for housing purposes, as specified. By establishing a continuously appropriated fund, this bill would make an appropriation.
This bill would include a change in state statute that would result in a taxpayer paying a higher tax within the meaning of Section 3 of Article XIIIA of the California Constitution, and thus would require for passage the approval of 2/3 of the membership of each house of the Legislature.
Existing law establishes the California Statewide Housing Plan, developed in cooperation with the private housing industry, regional and local housing and planning agencies, and other agencies of the state, to serve as a state housing plan. Existing law requires the plan to incorporate specified segments, including a review of housing assistance policies, goals, and objectives affecting the homeless.This bill would recast that provision to require the plan to incorporate, in consultation with the Interagency Council on Homelessness and utilizing data from the Homeless Data Integration system, a review of housing assistance, policies, goals, and objectives affecting people experiencing homelessness.Existing law establishes the California Statewide Housing Plan, developed in cooperation with the private housing industry, regional and local housing and planning agencies, and other agencies of the state, to serve as a state housing plan. Existing law requires the plan to incorporate specified segments, including a review of housing assistance policies, goals, and objectives affecting the homeless.
This bill would recast that provision to require the plan to incorporate, in consultation with the Interagency Council on Homelessness and utilizing data from the Homeless Data Integration system, a review of housing assistance, policies, goals, and objectives affecting people experiencing homelessness.
(a)The Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund is established in the State Treasury.
(b)Upon receiving the notifications from the Franchise Tax Board pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 17225.5 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, the Controller shall transfer an amount, equal to the amount estimated by the Franchise Tax Board in those notifications, from the General Fund to the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund.
(c)Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, moneys in the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund are hereby continuously appropriated, without regard to fiscal year, as follows:
(1)Fifty percent of the moneys shall be used in accordance with the Multifamily Housing Program (Chapter 6.7 (commencing with Section 50675) of Part 2).
(2)Twenty-five percent of the moneys shall be used for supporting homeownership opportunities for first-time homebuyers.
(3)Twenty-five percent of the moneys shall be used for distribution to local public housing authorities to provide housing navigation services and landlord incentives for housing voucher recipients.
SEC. 2.Section 17225.5 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:17225.5.(a)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, Sections 163(h)(4)(A)(i)(II) and 163(h)(4)(A)(ii)(II) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to qualified residence, shall not apply.
(b)(1)No later than June 1, 2025, the Franchise Tax Board, in consultation with the Department of Finance, shall estimate the amount of revenue that would have resulted if the modifications made with respect to the calculation of taxable income by this section had applied to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2025, and notify the Controller of that amount.
(2)No later than June 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board, in consultation with the Department of Finance, shall estimate the amount of additional revenue resulting from the modifications made with respect to the calculation of taxable income by this section for the taxable years beginning on or after January 1 of the calendar year immediately preceding the year in which the estimate is made and before January 1 of the calendar year in which the estimate is made and notify the Controller of that amount.
SECTION 1.Section 50422 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:50422.The plan shall incorporate a statement of housing goals, policies, and objectives, as well as all of the following segments:(a)An evaluation and summary of housing conditions throughout the state, with particular emphasis upon the availability of housing for all economic segments of the state. The evaluation shall include summary statistics for all counties, all multicounty metropolitan areas, and rural areas, as defined and designated by the Bureau of the Census of the United States Department of Commerce, rather than as defined in Section 50101. The evaluation shall include the existing distribution of housing by type, size, gross rent, value, and, to the extent data is available, condition, and the existing distribution of households by gross income, size, and ethnic character for each of those areas.(b)A determination of the statewide need for housing development for the plan period. The determination of statewide need shall be established as the minimum number of units necessary to be built or rehabilitated in order to provide sufficient housing to house all residents of the state in standard, uncrowded units in suitable locations.(c)Goals for the provision of housing assistance for the plan period. The goals shall be established as the minimum number of households to be assisted that will result in achieving, by the fourth subsequent year, a substantial reduction in the number of very low income households and other persons and families of low or moderate income constrained to pay more than 30 percent of their gross income for housing. Income groups to be considered in establishing the goals shall be designated by the department and shall include households a significant number of which are required to pay more than 30 percent of their gross income for housing in the fiscal year the plan is revised, as determined by the department.(d)An identification of governmental and nongovernmental constraints and obstacles and specific recommendations for their removal.(e)An analysis of state and local housing and building codes and their enforcement. The analysis shall include consideration of whether those codes contain sufficient flexibility to respond to new methods of construction and new materials.(f)Recommendations for actions by federal, state, and local governments and the private sector that will contribute to the attainment of the housing goals established for California.(g)A housing strategy that coordinates the housing assistance and activities of state and local agencies, including the provision of housing assistance for various population groups, including, but not limited to, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, veterans, large families, families where a female is the head of the household, farmworker households, and other specific population groups as deemed appropriate by the department. To inform the strategy, the department shall, to the extent possible, do the following:(1)Consider information compiled by relevant state and local agencies on aging, and from provider and consumer organizations as available.(2)Consult with various state departments, including the California Department of Aging, the State Department of Social Services, the State Department of Health Care Services, the Employment Development Department, the State Department of Developmental Services, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and other state departments or agencies to obtain information deemed relevant to the housing needs of populations addressed in the housing strategy. This paragraph shall not be construed to require activity beyond the customary scope of the departments planning process.(h)In consultation with the Interagency Council on Homelessness and utilizing data from the Homeless Data Integration System required by paragraph (13) of subdivision (b) of Section 8257 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, a review of housing assistance policies, goals, and objectives affecting people experiencing homelessness.The plan shall incorporate a statement of housing goals, policies, and objectives, as well as all of the following segments:
(a)An evaluation and summary of housing conditions throughout the state, with particular emphasis upon the availability of housing for all economic segments of the state. The evaluation shall include summary statistics for all counties, all multicounty metropolitan areas, and rural areas, as defined and designated by the Bureau of the Census of the United States Department of Commerce, rather than as defined in Section 50101. The evaluation shall include the existing distribution of housing by type, size, gross rent, value, and, to the extent data is available, condition, and the existing distribution of households by gross income, size, and ethnic character for each of those areas.
(b)A determination of the statewide need for housing development for the plan period. The determination of statewide need shall be established as the minimum number of units necessary to be built or rehabilitated in order to provide sufficient housing to house all residents of the state in standard, uncrowded units in suitable locations.
(c)Goals for the provision of housing assistance for the plan period. The goals shall be established as the minimum number of households to be assisted that will result in achieving, by the fourth subsequent year, a substantial reduction in the number of very low income households and other persons and families of low or moderate income constrained to pay more than 30 percent of their gross income for housing. Income groups to be considered in establishing the goals shall be designated by the department and shall include households a significant number of which are required to pay more than 30 percent of their gross income for housing in the fiscal year the plan is revised, as determined by the department.
(d)An identification of governmental and nongovernmental constraints and obstacles and specific recommendations for their removal.
(e)An analysis of state and local housing and building codes and their enforcement. The analysis shall include consideration of whether those codes contain sufficient flexibility to respond to new methods of construction and new materials.
(f)Recommendations for actions by federal, state, and local governments and the private sector that will contribute to the attainment of the housing goals established for California.
(g)A housing strategy that coordinates the housing assistance and activities of state and local agencies, including the provision of housing assistance for various population groups, including, but not limited to, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, veterans, large families, families where a female is the head of the household, farmworker households, and other specific population groups as deemed appropriate by the department. To inform the strategy, the department shall, to the extent possible, do the following:
(1)Consider information compiled by relevant state and local agencies on aging, and from provider and consumer organizations as available.
(2)Consult with various state departments, including the California Department of Aging, the State Department of Social Services, the State Department of Health Care Services, the Employment Development Department, the State Department of Developmental Services, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and other state departments or agencies to obtain information deemed relevant to the housing needs of populations addressed in the housing strategy. This paragraph shall not be construed to require activity beyond the customary scope of the departments planning process.
(h)A In consultation with the Interagency Council on Homelessness and utilizing data from the Homeless Data Integration System required by paragraph (13) of subdivision (b) of Section 8257 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, a review of housing assistance policies, goals, and objectives affecting the homeless. people experiencing homelessness.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 3.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to REV. & TAX. suspense file. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on H. & C.D. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 5, 2024 | Referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Jan 26, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 25. |
| Jan 25, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 22, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| All Home A Project Of Tides Center | ** Support | |
| Brilliant Corners | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Against | |
| California Housing Partnership Corporation | ** Support | |
| California Mortgage Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| California Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Community Corporation of Santa Monica | ** Support | |
| Homes & Hope | ** Support | |
| Housing California | ** Support | |
| MidPen Housing Corporation | ** Support | |
| Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California | ** Support | |
| Resources for Community Development | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Housing Alliance | ** Support | |
| Southern California Association of Non-Profit Housing | ** Support | |
| United Way of Greater Los Angeles | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1932
Author:(Ward) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Housing and Community Development | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
Revenue and Taxation | 4 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill disallows the mortgage interest deduction (MID) under the Personal Income Tax (PIT) Law on a taxpayer’s second home and allocates the revenue gain to the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund.
Specifically, this bill:
- Disallows, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, the deduction of acquisition indebtedness with respect to a qualified residence of a taxpayer that is not the taxpayer’s principal residence.
- Requires, by June 1, 2025, the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), in consultation with the Department of Finance (DOF), to annually estimate the amount of additional revenue resulting from the disallowance in the prior calendar year and notify the State Controller’s Office (SCO) of that amount.
- Establishes the continuously appropriated Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund (Fund) in the State Treasury and directs the SCO, beginning June 1, 2026, to transfer the estimated amount from the General Fund (GF) to the Fund.
- Requires moneys from the Fund to be continuously appropriated, as follows: (a) 50% to the Multifamily Housing Program, (b) 25% to support homeownership opportunities for first-time homebuyers, and (c) 25% to local public housing authorities to provide housing navigation services and landlord incentives for housing voucher recipients.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- GF revenue gain of approximately $110 million in fiscal year (FY) 2024-25, $190 million in FY 2025-26, and $190 million in FY 2026-27 by disallowing the MID on second homes. By increasing PIT revenue, this bill also likely increases Proposition 98 GF spending by approximately 40% of the GF revenue gain (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee).
- GF costs of an unknown, but potentially significant, amount to FTB to annually estimate the revenue gain from the disallowance. FTB would likely need to develop a new form or worksheet to determine the estimate and make accompanying processing and system updates.
- Likely minor costs to DOF and the SCO to facilitate specified calculations and transfers.
- GF costs of an unknown amount to the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to administer additional MHP funds. MHP provides low-interest, long-term deferred-payment loans for new construction, rehabilitation, and preservation of permanent and transitional rental housing for lower-income households.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author notes the state’s largest housing program is the MID, despite the state’s “unprecedented housing affordability crisis.” According to the author:
We invest $3.5 billion a year in individuals who have already purchased homes while over half of our state is made up of renters. In addition, we invest approximately $200 million to subsidize owners with the means to purchase not one, but two homes. In the face of our severe housing crisis and a budget shortfall which has led the Governor to propose eliminating $1.2 billion in housing programs, it is necessary to reevaluate this wasteful tax expenditure and redirect the revenues currently subsidizing those with second homes to address this crisis.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by various housing groups, with Housing California arguing, “Investing this funding into homeownership and housing solutions ensures that those without a home receive one before the state helps subsidize those well-off enough to purchase a second.”
This bill is opposed by real estate and taxpayer groups, led by the California Association of Realtors, which argues, “Many hardworking homeowners have relied on [the MID] to make a major financial decision in the purchase of a qualifying home and enacting this proposal would only exacerbate the effects of federal tax laws enacted under the prior federal Administration.”
- MID. In conformity with federal law, as it read on January 1, 2015, the MID under PIT Law allows a taxpayer to deduct the interest on a mortgage that is secured by a qualified home in which the taxpayer has an ownership interest. The state deduction is limited to $1 million or less in mortgages used to buy, build, or improve the home. Under current federal law, the deduction is limited to $750,000 for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2017, and beginning before January 1, 2026, after which the federal MID limit returns to $1 million. This limitation applies to the combined mortgages of the first and second home. The second home may be rented out for part of the year, but the taxpayer must live in the home for part of the year. This bill disallows, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, the state MID for second homes, even if the home was purchased years ago, and transfers the revenue gain to support housing and homelessness prevention programs.
- Prior Legislation. AB 946 (Lee), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, and AB 1905 (Chiu), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, were similar to this bill. The bills were not heard by the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee and Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee, respectively, at the request of the authors.
AB 71 (Chiu), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have disallowed the MID on second homes to fund additional Low-income Housing Tax Credits. AB 71 was ordered to the Assembly Inactive File at the request of the author.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Jacqui Irwin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1932 (
Author:Ward) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
2/3 vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Personal income tax: mortgage interest deduction.
SUMMARY: Disallows the mortgage interest deduction (MID) on any property that is not a taxpayer's primary residence, as specified, and allocates new revenues from the disallowance to the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund. Specifically, this bill:
- Disallows, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, the MID for any property that is not a taxpayer's primary residence.
- Requires, no later than June 1, 2026, the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), in consultation with the Department of Finance (DOF), to estimate the amount of additional revenue that would have resulted if the disallowance had applied for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2025, and notify the State Controller of that amount.
- Requires, no later than June 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the FTB, in consultation with DOF, to estimate the amount of additional revenue resulting from the repeal of the MID on second homes for taxable years beginning on or after January 1 of the calendar year immediately preceding the year in which the estimate is made and before January 1 of the calendar year in which the estimate is made and notify the State Controller of that amount.
- Requires the State Controller to transfer an amount from the General Fund (GF) to the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund that is equal to the amount estimated by the FTB, and continuously appropriates money in the fund as follows:
- 50% to the Multifamily Housing Program;
- 25% to support homeownership opportunities for first-time homebuyers; and,
- 25% to local public housing authorities to provide housing navigation services and landlord incentives for housing voucher recipients.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Allows qualified residence interest as an itemized deduction, subject to limitations. (Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 163(h).)
- Provides that acquisition indebtedness is indebtedness that is incurred in acquiring, constructing, or substantially improving a qualified residence of the taxpayer and which is secured by the residence. (IRC Section 163(h)(4).)
- Provides, for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2017, and beginning before
January 1, 2026, that a taxpayer may treat no more than $750,000 as acquisition indebtedness. In the case of acquisition indebtedness incurred before December 16, 2017, the limitation is $1 million. For taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025, a taxpayer may treat up to $1 million of indebtedness as acquisition indebtedness, regardless of when the indebtedness was incurred. (IRC Section 163(h)(3)(B).) - Defines a “qualified residence” as:
- A principal residence; or,
- A second residence that is either not rented out for any portion of the year or a second home that is used for a portion of the year. If a second residence is rented out for a portion of the year, a taxpayer must use this home for more than 14 days, or more than 10% of the number of days during the year that the residence is rented at a fair rental, whichever is longer. (IRC 163(h)(4)(A)(i)(II).)
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Provides, for acquisition indebtedness incurred on or after October 13, 1987, the aggregate amount of acquisition indebtedness may not exceed $1 million ($500,000 in the case of married persons filing separately).
- Conforms to the federal law that defines a qualified residence as the taxpayer's principal residence and one other residence of the taxpayer selected to be a qualified residence, as of January 1, 2015. (Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 17201.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the FTB, this bill would result in a GF revenue gain of $110 million in fiscal year (FY) 2024-25, $190 million in FY 2025-26, and $190 million in FY 2026-27.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
California is undergoing an unprecedented housing affordability crisis with nearly 70% of low- and very low-income households spending more than half of their income on housing. The crisis has contributed to a growing population of people experiencing homelessness, increased pressure on local public safety nets, and the outward migration of thousands of long-time California residents. Despite this, the state's largest housing program is the mortgage interest deduction. We invest $3.5 billion a year in individuals who have already purchased homes while over half of our state is made up of renters. In addition, we invest approximately $200 million to subsidize owners with the means to purchase not one, but two homes. In the face of our severe housing crisis and a budget shortfall which has led the Governor to propose eliminating $1.2 billion in housing programs, it is necessary to reevaluate this wasteful tax expenditure and redirect the revenues currently subsidizing those with second homes to address this crisis. An additional $200 million per year for housing programs to build affordable housing, promote first-time homebuyer opportunities, and boost housing voucher utilization will allow us to make crucial investments for the long term. We should ensure those without a home in our state receive one before the state helps subsidize those well enough to purchase a second.
- Supporters state that their reasons for support include: (a) the deduction disproportionately benefits those with higher incomes and larger mortgages as filers with mortgages who take the standard deduction get no benefit; (b) owning even one home is financially out of reach for millions of Californians; and, (c) the state is facing a multibillion-dollar deficit, which may continue in upcoming years and necessitate the cutting of affordable housing and homelessness prevention programs.
- Opponents state that their reasons for opposition include: (a) the amount of the MID is already capped regardless of whether the taxpayer has one home or two homes; (b) families rely on second homes, such as accessory dwelling units, to reduce commute distances and maintain hybrid work arrangements; (c) reforms at the federal level bring much uncertainty to the current tax structure; and, (d) families have made significant financial decisions based on the access to this tax benefit.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- The MID: In conformity with federal law as it read on January 1, 2015, California law allows taxpayers to deduct the mortgage interest paid on up to $1 million in debt for a principal and second residence. A second residence is limited to a home that is either not rented out at any point in the year or one that the taxpayer can rent out but must also live in for part of the year. This limitation applies to the combined mortgages of the first and second home.
- Historical background: It is a common misconception that the MID was created as a subsidy to encourage homeownership. When the income tax laws were first enacted after the passage of the 16th Amendment, Congress viewed interest payments as an expense of earning business and investment income and therefore not part of a taxpayer's net income. Congress, however, did not differentiate between interest paid to generate income and non-income generating purchases. When the 1986 Tax Reform Act was passed, Congress eliminated the deductibility of all consumer interest except for the MID. As such, the provision is more of a "left over" from prior tax policies and less of an incentive that encourages the purchasing of homes.[1]
- The MID leads to higher home prices: In regards to the MID, the FTB stated the following in a 2011 report:
Whether or not increasing home ownership is a valid goal, most economists believe that the value of the tax break is generally capitalized into the value of housing. In other words, on average, housing prices should increase by the expected tax savings over the time period that the house will be owned. Therefore, this deduction does not actually make housing more affordable for homeowners. Instead, it results in a transfer from the state treasury to people who already owned homes at the time the deduction was granted or, in the case of new construction, to whomever owned the land at the time it becomes obvious that the land will be zoned for residential use. In fact, homeowners who do not itemize or whose income places them in low rate brackets are likely to find housing less affordable because they will not receive a tax reduction large enough to offset the increasing prices of housing. Additionally if the goal is to encourage homeownership, there is no reason to extend the benefit to second homes.[2]
According to a 1988 report issued by the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO), "The tax subsidy made available under this program undoubtedly accrues as a windfall benefit to taxpayers who would have purchased homes anyway, and it encourages the purchase of bigger and more expensive homes, as well as vacation homes rather than basic housing." The report goes on to make recommendations to reform the MID and "to reduce the incentives it currently provides to purchase luxury homes and vacation homes", including to limit the total amount of interest deducted each year or to disallow interest deductions on second homes.[3]
- Recent federal changes: In 2017, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) dramatically changed the way in which mortgage interest is deducted. Although still an itemized deduction, the TCJA lowered the value of mortgages on which homebuyers could deduct interest from $1 million to $750,000. Additionally, the TCJA increased the standard deduction from $6,500 to $12,550 for single filers and from $13,000 to $25,100 for joint filers. Prior to the TCJA, about 30% of filers itemized versus 10 to 15% of filers that itemized after the TCJA. These changes, of course, are only representative of federal tax filers since California did not conform to these provisions. According to Debunking 3 Myths About the Mortgage Interest Deduction, MID reform does not hurt the middle class because the MID is only available to those that itemize and those that do itemize tend to be wealthier individuals.
- Who benefits from itemized deductions? In California, just over 15% of filers itemized deductions in 2020.[4] The U.S. Treasury Office of Tax Analysis, in a working paper analyzing the distribution of eight major tax expenditures across different income levels and racial and ethnic groups, found that itemized deductions disproportionately benefit White families: 84% of the benefits of the deductibility of mortgage interest were received by White families, which make up only 67% of the population studied. The average dollar benefit per family for the mortgage interest deduction was estimated to be $213 for White families, $77 for Hispanic families, and $63 for Black families.[5] Across all racial and ethnic categories, families in the upper middle-income ranges benefitted from the home mortgage deduction at higher rates than families in lower income deciles.
A deduction is generally more valuable to high-income taxpayers because the "value" of a deduction varies with the marginal tax rate (or tax bracket) of the taxpayer. For example, an individual taxpayer in a 10% tax bracket would receive a tax benefit of $10 on a $100 deduction. In contrast, a taxpayer in a 25% tax bracket would save $25 in taxes for every $100. Thus, assuming the same level of deductions, a high-income taxpayer, presumably with a greater ability to pay taxes, receive a greater tax benefit from the deduction than a lower income taxpayer. - What does this bill do? This bill would eliminate the MID that is available for second homes, and transfer the additional GF revenue that is generated from the elimination to the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund. Additionally, this bill would require the FTB, in consultation with the DOF, to estimate the amount of additional revenue that would have resulted from the disallowance of the MID on second homes for the 2024 taxable year and notify the State Controller of that amount.
- Implementation consideration: As described above, this bill requires the FTB to estimate the amount of additional revenue that would have resulted if this bill's provisions had been effective for the taxable year prior to the effective date of this bill. Currently, only the total amount of mortgage interest being claimed by the taxpayer is captured on the California income tax return; the amount of interest being claimed on each home is not specified. As such, the FTB currently lacks the ability to determine mortgage interest deduction amounts that would be disallowed from a second home and would need to develop a new form or worksheet, with related processing and system updates, to determine the estimated annual amounts of additional revenue that are required by the bill.
- Double-referred: In addition to this Committee, this bill was referred to the Assembly Committee on Housing and Community Development, which passed this bill on April 17th on a vote of 7-to-2. For additional discussion regarding issues that fall under that Committee's jurisdiction, including the allocation of revenues raised from the elimination of the MID, please refer to that Committee's analysis.
- Prior legislation:
- AB 946 (Lee), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 946 was not heard by this Committee.
- AB 1905 (Chiu & Wicks), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 1905 was not heard by this Committee.
- AB 71 (Chiu), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have disallowed the deduction of mortgage interest paid on a second home and modified the existing Low-Income Housing Credit. AB 71 died on the Assembly Inactive File.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
All Home, a Project of Tides Center
Brilliant Corners
California Housing Partnership Corporation
Community Corporation of Santa Monica
Homes & Hope
Housing California
MidPen Housing Corporation
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California
Resources for Community Development
Sacramento Housing Alliance
Southern California Association of Non-profit Housing
United Way of Greater Los Angeles
Opposition
California Association of Realtors
California Mortgage Bankers Association
California Taxpayers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Wesley Whitaker / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Ventry, The Accidental Deduction: A History and Critique of the Tax Subsidy for Mortgage Interest, Journal of Law and Contemporary Problems, Vol. 73, p. 233 (Winter 2010). https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1561&context=lcp. ↑
California Income Tax Expenditures: Compendium of Individual Provisions, Updated December 2011, FTB, Economic and Statistical Research Bureau (December, 2011). https://arev.assembly.ca.gov/sites/arev.assembly.ca.gov/files/hearings/Maitland%20FTB%20Tax_Expenditure_Report_2011_2-22-12.pdf. ↑
Report on the 1988-89 Tax Expenditure Budget, Office of the Legislative Analyst (December 1988). https://lao.ca.gov/reports/1988/12_88_report_on_the_1988_89_tax_expenditure_budget.pdf. ↑
Villanova, Where Americans Write Off the Most in Taxes – 2023 Study, SmartAsset (April 6, 2023). https://smartasset.com/data-studies/where-americans-write-off-the-most-in-taxes-2023. ↑
Cronin, Tax Expenditures by Race and Hispanic Ethnicity: An Application of the U.S. Treasury Department's Race and Hispanic Ethnicity Imputation, U.S. Treasury Office of Tax Analysis (January 2023). https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/131/WP-122.pdf. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Christopher M. Ward, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1932 (
Author:Ward) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
SUBJECT: Personal income tax: mortgage interest deduction
SUMMARY: Disallows the mortgage interest deduction (MID) for second homes and deposits revenue saved into the Housing, Homeownership, and Homelessness Prevention Response Fund (Fund), to be allocated to specified housing programs. Specifically, this bill:
- Disallows the MID on acquisition indebtedness with respect to a qualified residence other than a principal residence.
- Requires the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), no later than June 1, 2025 and in consultation with the Department of Finance (DOF), to estimate the amount of revenue that would have resulted if the modifications made with respect to the calculation of taxable income by this bill had applied to taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2024, and before January 1, 2025, and notify the Controller of that amount.
- Requires FTB, no later than June 1, 2026 and annually thereafter, and in consultation with DOF, to estimate the amount of additional revenue resulting from the modifications made with respect to the calculation of taxable income by this bill for the taxable years beginning on or after January 1 of the calendar year immediately preceding the year in which the estimate is made and before January 1 of the calendar year in which the estimate is made and notify the Controller of that amount.
- Establishes the Fund in the State Treasury.
- Requires the Controller, upon receiving the notifications from the FTB under 2) and 3), to transfer an amount, equal to the amount estimated by the FTB in those notifications, from the General Fund to the Fund.
- Provides that, notwithstanding specified law, moneys in the Fund are continuously appropriated, without regard to fiscal year, as follows:
- Fifty percent of the moneys must be used in accordance with the Multifamily Housing Program, as specified;
- Twenty-five percent of the moneys must be used for supporting homeownership opportunities for first-time homebuyers; and
- Twenty-five percent of the moneys must be used for distribution to local public housing authorities to provide housing navigation services and landlord incentives for housing voucher recipients.
EXISTING LAW:
- Federal Internal Revenue Service (IRS) law allows a taxpayer to deduct the mortgage interest paid on up to $750,000 in mortgage debt on a “qualified residence” for taxable years 2018 through 2025, for mortgages entered into after December 15, 2017. On January 1, 2026, the limit rises to up to $1 million in mortgage debt without regard to when the mortgage was incurred. State law allows a deduction for up to $1 million in mortgage debt on a qualified residence. (Federal Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 163(h)(3)(F) and 163(h)(3)(B))
- Federal IRS law defines a “qualified residence” as:
- A principal residence; or
- A second residence that is either not rented out for any portion of the year or a second home that you use for a portion of the year. If a second residence is rented out for a portion of the year a taxpayer must use this home more than 14 days or more than 10% of the number of days during the year that the residence is rented at a fair rental, whichever is longer. (IRC 163(h)(4)(A)(i)(II))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. 2/3 vote.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “California is undergoing an unprecedented housing affordability crisis with nearly 70% of low- and very low-income households spending more than half of their income on housing. The crisis has contributed to a growing population of people experiencing homelessness, increased pressure on local public safety nets, and the outward migration of thousands of long-time California residents. Despite this, the state's largest housing program is the mortgage interest deduction. We invest $3.5 billion a year in individuals who have already purchased homes while over half of our state is made up of renters. In addition, we invest approximately $200 million to subsidize owners with the means to purchase not one, but two homes. In the face of our severe housing crisis, and a budget shortfall which has led the Governor to propose eliminating $1.2 billion in housing programs, it is necessary to reevaluate this wasteful tax expenditure and redirect the revenues currently subsidizing those with second homes to address this crisis. An additional $200 million per year for housing programs to build affordable housing, promote first-time homebuyer opportunities, and boost housing voucher utilization will allow us to make crucial investments for the long term. We should ensure those without a home in our state receive one before the state helps subsidize those well enough to purchase a second.”
California’s Housing Crisis: California is in the midst of a severe housing crisis. Over two-thirds of low-income renters are paying more than 30% of their income toward housing, a “rent burden” that means they have to sacrifice other essentials such as food, transportation, and health care.[1] In 2023, over 181,000 Californians experienced homelessness on a given night, with a sharp increase in the number of people who became homeless for the first time.[2] The crisis is driven in large part by the lack of affordable rental housing for lower income people. According to the California Housing Partnership’s (CHP) Housing Need Dashboard, in the current market, nearly 2 million extremely low-income and very low-income renter households are competing for roughly 687,000 available and affordable rental units in the state. Over three-quarters of the state’s extremely low-income households and over half of the state’s very low-income households are severely rent burdened, paying more than 50% of their income toward rent each month. CHP estimates that the state needs an additional 1.3 million housing units affordable to very low-income Californians to eliminate the shortfall.[3] By contrast, production in the past decade has been under 100,000 housing units per year – including less than 10,000 units of affordable housing per year.[4]
Mortgage Interest Deduction: The largest permanent investment the state makes in housing is through the MID – a deduction that disproportionately benefits those with higher incomes and larger mortgages.[5] State law allows a taxpayer to deduct interest on up to $1 million in acquisition indebtedness on a “qualified interest.” A qualified interest includes a primary residence and a second residence. To qualify, a second residence may be rented out for a portion of the year but a taxpayer must use the home more than 14 days or more than 10% of the number of days during the year that the residence is rented at a fair rental rate, whichever is longer. Non-qualifying rentals are not subject to the MID as landlords have access to other business tax deductions and rental depreciation mechanisms that impact their tax owed on those properties.
This bill would disallow the state MID on second homes for taxable years beginning in 2025, and would utilize the savings from this disallowance to permanently fund three key housing and homeownership priorities:
- The state’s flagship affordable housing finance program, the Multifamily Housing Program, would receive 50% of the savings annually, to bolster the state’s severe lack of affordable housing available to low-income renters and people experiencing homelessness;
- Programming to support first-time homebuyer opportunities would receive 25% of the savings appropriated annually, so that the state’s resources are supporting first-time buyers rather than providing tax benefits to those able to purchase not just a first but a second home; and
- The final 25% would be allocated to public housing authorities to use for housing navigation services, landlord incentive payments, holding deposits, and other supports to ensure recipients of federal housing vouchers can successfully locate and lease a unit. According to HUD data from 2023, the average annual income of a California-based household receiving a housing choice voucher is $21,521.[6]
Filers could continue to claim a MID for a primary and second home on their federal taxes, for mortgages up to a cumulative total of $750,000, until Congress decides how to approach the upcoming expiration of the tax code changes made in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA). If no changes are made to this provision or the TCJA sunsets on January 1, 2026, the federal MID would revert back to allowing a deduction on up to $1 million in acquisition indebtedness for a primary and second home.
Who Benefits from MID? The MID is only available to taxpayers who itemize their deductions. Those who take the standard deduction receive no benefit, even if they pay interest on a mortgage. The majority of taxpayers who benefit from the MID make more than $100,000 per year. In 2020, 90% of the federal MID expenditure went to homeowners with incomes above $100,000, and 62.8% went to homeowners with incomes over $200,000 per year.[7]
The Congressional Research Service analyzed the federal MID in 2020 and noted the following:
The value of the [mortgage interest] deduction generally increases with a taxpayer’s income. There are two primary reasons for this. First, the value of the mortgage interest deduction, like all deductions, depends on an individual’s marginal tax rate. For example, an individual in the 25% marginal tax bracket, paying $10,000 in mortgage interest, would realize a reduction in taxes of $2,500 ($10,000 multiplied by 25%). In comparison, for someone in the 35% tax bracket the reduction in taxes for deducting the identical amount of interest would be $3,500 ($10,000 multiplied by 35%). Second, higher-income individuals tend to purchase more expensive homes, which results in larger mortgage interest payments, and hence, a larger deduction.[8]
Thus, the MID itself is a benefit that is poorly targeted to assist lower income families purchase homes, instead benefiting wealthier individuals who purchase larger or more expensive homes. The allowance of a MID not just for a primary but also for a secondary or vacation home further exacerbates this inequity. According to the FTB, the estimated impact of the vacation home MID on the General Fund averages roughly $200 million every year, and tax filers that take a deduction on a second home receive approximately $1,100 in tax benefit per filer. According to FTB, under current law the estimated average second home deduction is approximately $11,500. Applying an average state tax rate of 9% reduces the tax owed by the taxpayer by approximately $1,100. Should the second home MID be disallowed, the average second home owner would owe about $1,100 more in tax per year.
Renter’s Tax Credit: The state renter’s tax credit, in stark contrast to the MID, has been frozen at a sparse $60 for single filers and $120 for joint filers for over four decades – and has an income cap, which the MID notably does not have. It is also nonrefundable, meaning any excess after a taxpayer’s tax owed is reduced to $0 does not accrue to the taxpayer. The income limit for single filers or filers who are married filing separately to claim the renter’s credit is $50,746, and for married filers filing jointly, heads of households, or widowers, the income limit is $101,492.[9]
It would take over 18 years for a single filer and over nine years for a joint filer receiving a yearly renter tax credit to net even one year of the $1,100 housing tax benefit the average second home owner receives via the MID.
Budget Challenges: Although final revenues are not in, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) estimates that the state is facing a $58 billion budget deficit. The Governor’s January budget proposes to cut $1.2 billion in existing budget commitments to affordable housing programs, including eliminating $250 million from MHP, a core program necessary to fund deeply income-targeted affordable multi-family and supportive housing. Over 95% of units assisted by MHP in recent years have been targeted to families making 60% of their area’s median income or below.[10] The January budget also proposes to eliminate $152.5 million for the CalHome program, which makes grants to local public agencies and nonprofits for first-time homebuyer and housing rehabilitation assistance, homebuyer counseling, and technical assistance activities to enable low- and very-low-income individuals to become or remain homeowners. The last voter-approved housing bond, Proposition 1 from 2018, provided $3 billion for various affordable housing programs, the vast majority of which will be exhausted by this year.
LAO Recommendation to Eliminate the Second Home MID: The LAO recently published an analysis of tax policy changes in the Governor’s January Budget proposal, given the budget challenge facing the state this year. The following is an excerpt related to the MID:
Better Target the Mortgage Interest Deduction. Homeowners can reduce their taxable income by deducting the costs of their mortgage interest payments. California law allows taxpayers to deduct interest costs related to up to $1.1 million in mortgage debt. The mortgage interest deduction generally is an inefficient and inequitable way of achieving the policy’s primary goal: promoting homeownership. The vast majority of the $3.5 billion in statewide tax savings from the deduction go to higher income households who, for the most part, do not require assistance to afford a home. This is because taxpayers must be able to itemize their deductions to claim the mortgage interest deduction, something which is much more common among higher income taxpayers. One option to better target the mortgage interest deduction is to convert it to a tax credit, which would be available to a broader range of taxpayers. Such a conversion could be structured to also reduce the overall revenue loss to the state. For example, converting the mortgage interest deduction to a credit equal to two percent of mortgage interest paid on up to $1 million of debt likely would increase income tax revenue by $1 billion or more per year.
Eliminate Mortgage Interest Deduction for Second Homes. The mortgage interest deduction is not limited to interest paid on a taxpayer’s primary residence. Taxpayers also can deduct interest paid for vacation homes and other second homes, as long as they are not used to generate rental income. This policy provides little benefit in the way of promoting homeownership or improving housing affordability and primarily benefits higher-income taxpayers. Eliminating the mortgage interest deduction for second homes could increase income tax revenue by $100 million to $150 million per year.[11]
Arguments in Support: According to the California Housing Partnership, “The largest investment the state makes in housing is the MID, yet it promotes no public policy purpose and accrues disproportionately to high-income earners who do not need housing assistance. The vacation home deduction alone costs the state more than $200 million per year. This revenue is better utilized to meet California’s unmet housing needs, especially the development of homes affordable to low-income families and persons experiencing homelessness. AB 1932 will align our funding with our priorities by eliminating the vacation home MID and permanently investing resources saved in programs that create housing stability and homeownership opportunities, including the Multifamily Housing Program, first-time homebuyer assistance, and boosting housing voucher utilization.”
Arguments in Opposition: According to the California Association of Realtors, the California Mortgage Bankers Association, and the California Taxpayers Association, “This tax increase unfairly impacts California homeowners who have scrimped and saved for years and are now eligible to use this provision in order to better the lives of their families. Many hardworking homeowners have relied on this provision in the law to make a major financial decision in the purchase of a qualifying home and enacting this proposal would only exacerbate the effects of federal tax laws enacted under the prior federal Administration, which has hurt California families. AB 1932 would negatively impact families who are already struggling with the high cost of essential services required in securing a mortgage, such as the rising cost of insurance.”
Related Legislation:
AB 1905 (Chiu) of 2020 would have disallowed the MID on second homes and increased the amount of ongoing funding the state would have provided to address homelessness. That bill died pending a vote in this committee.
AB 71 (Chiu) of 2017 would have disallowed the MID on second homes, increased the state Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) Program by $300 million, and made changes to the LIHTC. That bill died pending a vote on the Assembly Floor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
All Home, a Project of Tides Center
Brilliant Corners
California Housing Partnership Corporation
Community Corporation of Santa Monica
Homes & Hope
Housing California
MidPen Housing Corporation
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California
Resources for Community Development
Sacramento Housing Alliance
Southern California Association of Non-profit Housing
The United Way of Greater Los Angeles
Opposition
California Association of Realtors
California Mortgage Bankers Association
California Taxpayers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/ahar/2023-ahar-part-1-pit-estimates-of-homelessness-in-the-us.html ↑
https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-research/housing-challenges.shtml ↑
https://chpc.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/California-Affordable-Housing-Needs-Report-2024-1.pdf ↑
https://bipartisanpolicy.org/explainer/is-it-time-for-congress-to-reconsider-the-mortgage-interest-deduction/ ↑
https://www.ftb.ca.gov/file/personal/credits/nonrefundable-renters-credit.html ↑
https://lao.ca.gov/handouts/socservices/2024/Housing-Augmentation-Updates-031124.pdf ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation
Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):