AB 2210: Driving under the influence: ignition interlock devices.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-01
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, until January 1, 2026, requires a person, upon a criminal conviction for driving under the influence (DUI) with a prior conviction for DUI, to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device (IID) for a specified period of time. Existing law also authorizes a court, upon the first criminal conviction of a person for DUI, to order installation of an IID for a specified period of time, or, if the court does not order the installation of the device, authorizes the person to apply for a restricted license, as specified.
This bill would instead require the court, upon the persons first criminal conviction for DUI, to order installation of the IID.This bill would establish a pilot program under the Department of Motor Vehicles that would, between July 1, 2025, and July 1, 2030, require the courts in the Counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego, to order the installation of an IID for any DUI conviction, as specified. The bill would require the department to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature, after the conclusion of the program, summarizing the effect of the program on reducing first-time and repeat DUI offenses.
Existing law, until January 1, 2026, requires a person, upon a criminal conviction for driving under the influence (DUI) with a prior conviction for DUI, to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device (IID) for a specified period of time. Existing law also authorizes a court, upon the first criminal conviction of a person for DUI, to order installation of an IID for a specified period of time, or, if the court does not order the installation of the device, authorizes the person to apply for a restricted license, as specified.
This bill would instead require the court, upon the persons first criminal conviction for DUI, to order installation of the IID.
(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall establish a pilot program in the Counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego to reduce the number of first-time violations of Sections 23152 and 23153, as follows:
(1)The Department of Motor Vehicles, upon receipt of the courts abstract of conviction for a violation listed in paragraph (7), shall inform the convicted person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified ignition interlock device installed. The records of the department shall reflect the mandatory use of the device for the term required and the time when the device is required to be installed by this code.
(2)The department shall advise the person that installation of an ignition interlock device on a vehicle does not allow the person to drive without a valid drivers license.
(3)Before a drivers license may be issued, reissued, or returned to a person after a suspension or revocation of that persons driving privilege that requires the installation of an ignition interlock device, a person who is notified by the department pursuant to paragraph (1) shall complete all of the following:
(A)Arrange for each vehicle owned or operated by the person to be fitted with an ignition interlock device by a certified ignition interlock device provider under Section 13386.
(B)Notify the department and provide to the department proof of installation by submitting the Verification of Installation form described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 13386.
(C)Pay the fee, determined by the department, that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of this section.
(4)The department shall place a restriction on the drivers license record of the convicted person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a certified ignition interlock device.
(5)(A)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to paragraph (1) shall arrange for each vehicle with an ignition interlock device to be serviced by the installer at least once every 60 days in order for the installer to recalibrate and monitor the operation of the device.
(B)The installer shall notify the department if the device is removed or indicates that the person has attempted to remove, bypass, or tamper with the device, or if the person fails three or more times to comply with any requirement for the maintenance or calibration of the ignition interlock device.
(6)The department shall monitor the installation and maintenance of the ignition interlock device installed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(7)A person is required to install an ignition interlock device for the applicable term as a condition of being issued a restricted drivers license, being reissued a drivers license, or having the privilege to operate a motor vehicle reinstated subsequent to a conviction for a violation or a suspension of a persons drivers license, as follows:
(A)A person convicted of a violation of Section 23152 shall be required to install an ignition interlock device, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of six months.
(B)A person convicted of a violation of Section 23153 shall install an ignition interlock device, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.
(C)The terms prescribed in this paragraph shall begin once a person has provided to the department proof of installation pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 13386 and upon restoration of the driving privilege pursuant to Section 13352.
(8)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to this subdivision, is exempt from the requirements of this subdivision if, within 30 days of the notification, the person certifies to the department all of the following:
(A)The person does not own a vehicle.
(B)The person does not have access to a vehicle at their residence.
(C)The person no longer has access to the vehicle being driven by the person at the time they were arrested for a violation that subsequently resulted in a conviction for a violation listed in this subdivision.
(D)The person acknowledges that they are only allowed to drive a vehicle that is fitted with a functioning ignition interlock device.
(E)The person acknowledges that they are required to have a valid drivers license before they can drive.
(F)The person is subject to the requirements of this section when they purchase or have access to a vehicle.
(9)Subdivisions (j), (k), (l), (m) and (n) of Section 23575 apply to this section.
(10)If a person fails to comply with any of the requirements regarding ignition interlock devices, the mandatory term for which the ignition interlock device is required to be installed shall be reset by the department.
(b)(1)Every manufacturer and manufacturers agent certified by the department to provide ignition interlock devices, under Section 13386, shall adopt the following fee schedule that provides for the payment of the costs of the certified ignition interlock device, the administration of the program, installation of the device, maintenance and recalibration of the device, and any other costs associated with the device by persons subject to this chapter in amounts commensurate with that persons income relative to the federal poverty level, as defined in Section 127400 of the Health and Safety Code:
(A)A person with an income at 125 percent of the federal poverty level and below is responsible for 10 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device. The ignition interlock device provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the ignition interlock device that is not paid by the person.
(B)A person with an income at 126 to 225 percent of the federal poverty level is responsible for 25 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device. The ignition interlock device provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the ignition interlock device that is not paid by the person.
(C)A person with an income at 226 to 325 percent of the federal poverty level is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device. The ignition interlock device provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the ignition interlock device that is not paid by the person.
(D)A person who is receiving CalFresh benefits and who provides proof of those benefits to the manufacturer or manufacturers agent or authorized installer is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(E)A person with an income at 326 to 425 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 90 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(F)All other persons are responsible for 100 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device.
(G)The manufacturer is responsible for the percentage of costs that the person ordered to install an ignition interlock device is not responsible for pursuant to subparagraphs (A) to (E), inclusive.
(2)The ignition interlock device provider shall verify the income of the person ordered to install an ignition interlock device to determine the cost of the ignition interlock device and associated costs pursuant to this subdivision by verifying any of the following documents from the person:
(A)The previous years state or federal income tax return.
(B)The previous three months of weekly or monthly income statements.
(C)Employment Development Department verification of unemployment benefits.
(3)At any point during which a device is installed and in use, an individual shall be permitted to apply for reduced costs and shall be credited for any previously paid costs that were in excess of the fee schedule set forth in paragraph (1). An individual shall also be permitted to apply for reduced costs based on a change of income.
(4)(A)The ignition interlock device provider shall post conspicuously on its internet website and contracts, the information set forth in this subdivision. Prior to an individuals execution of a contract for an ignition interlock device, the provider shall also give verbal notification of the fee schedule and how to apply for reduced costs.
(B)Installation service and repair providers shall post conspicuously in their place of business and verbally inform a person of the information set forth in this subdivision prior to installation and servicing of the device.
(C)A copy of this information set forth in this subdivision shall also be provided to an individual together with the court order requiring the installation of an ignition interlock device.
(D)The department shall post the information set forth in this subdivision on its internet website. The department shall also include the information included in this subdivision in any mailed notice of revocation or suspension that notifies an individual of the requirement to install an ignition interlock device.
(5)The Department of Consumer Affairs may impose a civil assessment not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) upon a manufacturer or manufacturers agent certified to provide ignition interlock devices who fails to inform a person subject to this chapter of the provisions of this subdivision, or who fails to comply with the provisions of this subdivision.
(c)This section does not permit a person to drive without a valid drivers license.
(d)The requirements of this section are in addition to any other requirements of law.
(e)For the purposes of this section, the term vehicle does not include a motorcycle until the state certifies an ignition interlock device that can be installed on a motorcycle. A person subject to an ignition interlock device restriction shall not operate a motorcycle for the duration of the ignition interlock device restriction period.
(f)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2025.
23599.1.On or before January 1, 2031, the Department of Motor Vehicles shall report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the pilot program authorized under this chapter in reducing the number of first-time violations and repeat offenses of Sections 23152 and 23153 in the Counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
23599.2.This chapter shall remain in effect only until July 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
SECTION 1.Section 23575.3 of the Vehicle Code is amended to read:23575.3.(a)In addition to any other requirement imposed by law, a court shall notify a person convicted of a violation listed in subdivision (h) that the person is required to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and that the person is prohibited from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in accordance with this section.(b)The Department of Motor Vehicles, upon receipt of the courts abstract of conviction for a violation listed in subdivision (h), shall inform the convicted person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified ignition interlock device installed. The records of the department shall reflect the mandatory use of the device for the term required and the time when the device is required to be installed by this code.(c)The department shall advise the person that installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on a vehicle does not allow the person to drive without a valid drivers license.(d)(1)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) shall do all of the following:(A)Arrange for each vehicle operated by the person to be equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device by a certified ignition interlock device provider under Section 13386.(B)Provide to the department proof of installation by submitting the Verification of Installation form described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 13386.(C)Pay a fee, determined by the department, that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of this section.(2)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b), is exempt from the requirements of this subdivision until the time the person purchases or has access to a vehicle if, within 30 days of the notification, the person certifies to the department all of the following:(A)The person does not own a vehicle.(B)The person does not have access to a vehicle at their residence.(C)The person no longer has access to the vehicle that the person was driving at the time the person was arrested for a violation that subsequently resulted in a conviction for a violation listed in subdivision (h).(D)The person acknowledges that they are only allowed to drive a vehicle that is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device.(E)The person acknowledges that they are required to have a valid drivers license before they can drive.(F)The person acknowledges that they are subject to the requirements of this section when the person purchases or has access to a vehicle.(e)In addition to any other restrictions the department places on the drivers license record of the convicted person when the person is issued a restricted drivers license pursuant to Section 13352 or 13352.4, the department shall place a restriction on the drivers license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term.(f)(1)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) shall arrange for each vehicle with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device to be serviced by the installer at least once every 60 days in order for the installer to recalibrate and monitor the operation of the device.(2)The installer shall notify the department if the device is removed or indicates that the person has attempted to remove, bypass, or tamper with the device, or if the person fails three or more times to comply with any requirement for the maintenance or calibration of the ignition interlock device.(g)The department shall monitor the installation and maintenance of the ignition interlock device installed pursuant to subdivision (d).(h)A person is required to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device pursuant to this section for the applicable term, as follows:(1)A person convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (g) of Section 23152 shall be required to do the following, as applicable:(A)Upon a conviction with no priors, punishable under Section 23536, the court shall order installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. The term shall be determined by the court for a period not to exceed six months from the date of conviction. The court shall notify the department of the conviction as specified in subdivision (a) of Section 1803 or Section 1816, and shall specify the terms of the ignition interlock device restriction in accordance with subdivision (a) of Section 1804. The department shall place the restriction on the drivers license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term.(B)Upon a conviction with one prior, punishable under Section 23540, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.(C)Upon a conviction with two priors, punishable under Section 23546, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 24 months.(D)Upon a conviction with three or more priors punishable under Section 23550, or a conviction punishable under Section 23550.5, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 36 months.(2)A person convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (g) of Section 23153 shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device, as follows:(A)Upon a conviction with no priors, punishable under Section 23554, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.(B)Upon a conviction with one prior, punishable under Section 23560, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 24 months.(C)Upon a conviction with two priors, punishable under Section 23550 or 23566, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 36 months.(D)Upon a conviction with one prior punishable under Section 23550.5, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 48 months.(3)For the purposes of paragraphs (1) and (2), prior means a conviction for a separate violation of Section 23103, as specified in Section 23103.5, or Section 23152 or 23153, subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 191.5 of, or subdivision (a) of Section 192.5 of, the Penal Code, or subdivision (b), (c), (d), (e), or (f) of Section 655 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, that occurred within 10 years of the current violation.(4)The terms prescribed in this subdivision shall begin once a person has complied with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) and either upon the reinstatement of the privilege to drive pursuant to Section 13352 or the issuance of a restricted drivers license pursuant to Section 13352. A person shall receive credit for any period in which the person had a restricted drivers license issued pursuant to Section 13353.6 or 13353.75.(i)Subdivisions (g), (h), (j), and (k) of Section 23575 apply to this section.(j)If a person fails to comply with any of the requirements regarding ignition interlock devices, the period in which the person was not in compliance shall not be credited towards the mandatory term for which the ignition interlock device is required to be installed.(k)(1)Every manufacturer and manufacturers agent certified by the department to provide ignition interlock devices, under Section 13386, shall adopt the following fee schedule that provides for the payment of the costs of the certified ignition interlock device by offenders subject to this chapter in amounts commensurate with that persons income relative to the federal poverty level, as defined in Section 127400 of the Health and Safety Code:(A)A person with an income at 100 percent of the federal poverty level or below and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 10 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.(B)A person with an income at 101 to 200 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 25 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.(C)A person with an income at 201 to 300 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.(D)A person who is receiving CalFresh benefits and who provides proof of those benefits to the manufacturer or manufacturers agent or authorized installer is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.(E)A person with an income at 301 to 400 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 90 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.(F)All other offenders are responsible for 100 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device.(G)The manufacturer is responsible for the percentage of costs that the offender is not responsible for pursuant to subparagraphs (A) to (E), inclusive.(2)The ignition interlock device provider shall verify the offenders income to determine the cost of the ignition interlock device pursuant to this subdivision by verifying one of the following documents from the offender:(A)The previous years federal income tax return.(B)The previous three months of weekly or monthly income statements.(C)Employment Development Department verification of unemployment benefits.(l)The Department of Consumer Affairs may impose a civil assessment not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) upon a manufacturer or manufacturers agent certified to provide ignition interlock devices who fails to inform an offender subject to this chapter of the provisions of subdivision (k), or who fails to comply with the provisions of subdivision (k).(m)This section does not permit a person to drive without a valid drivers license.(n)The requirements of this section are in addition to any other requirements of law.(o)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:(1)Bypass means either of the following:(A)Failure to take any random retest.(B)Failure to pass a random retest with a breath alcohol concentration not exceeding 0.03 percent, by weight of alcohol, in the persons blood.(2)Operates includes operating a vehicle that is not owned by the person subject to this section.(3)Owned means solely owned or owned in conjunction with another person or legal entity.(4)Random retest means a breath test performed by the driver upon a certified ignition interlock device at random intervals after the initial engine startup breath test and while the vehicles motor is running.(5)Vehicle does not include a motorcycle until the state certifies an ignition interlock device that can be installed on a motorcycle. A person subject to an ignition interlock device restriction shall not operate a motorcycle for the duration of the ignition interlock device restriction period.(p)The requirements of this section shall apply only to a person who is convicted for a violation of Section 23152 or 23153 that occurred on or after January 1, 2019.(q)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.(r)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2026, deletes or extends that date.(a)In addition to any other requirement imposed by law, a court shall notify a person convicted of a violation listed in subdivision (h) that he or she the person is required to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and that he or she the person is prohibited from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in accordance with this section.
(b)The Department of Motor Vehicles, upon receipt of the courts abstract of conviction for a violation listed in subdivision (h), shall inform the convicted person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified ignition interlock device installed. The records of the department shall reflect the mandatory use of the device for the term required and the time when the device is required to be installed by this code.
(c)The department shall advise the person that installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on a vehicle does not allow the person to drive without a valid drivers license.
(d)(1)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) shall do all of the following:
(A)Arrange for each vehicle operated by the person to be equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device by a certified ignition interlock device provider under Section 13386.
(B)Provide to the department proof of installation by submitting the Verification of Installation form described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 13386.
(C)Pay a fee, determined by the department, that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of this section.
(2)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b), is exempt from the requirements of this subdivision until the time he or she the person purchases or has access to a vehicle if, within 30 days of the notification, the person certifies to the department all of the following:
(A)The person does not own a vehicle.
(B)The person does not have access to a vehicle at his or her their residence.
(C)The person no longer has access to the vehicle he or she that the person was driving at the time he or she the person was arrested for a violation that subsequently resulted in a conviction for a violation listed in subdivision (h).
(D)The person acknowledges that he or she is they are only allowed to drive a vehicle that is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device.
(E)The person acknowledges that he or she is they are required to have a valid drivers license before he or she they can drive.
(F)The person acknowledges that he or she is they are subject to the requirements of this section when he or she the person purchases or has access to a vehicle.
(e)In addition to any other restrictions the department places on the drivers license record of the convicted person when the person is issued a restricted drivers license pursuant to Section 13352 or 13352.4, the department shall place a restriction on the drivers license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term.
(f)(1)A person who is notified by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) shall arrange for each vehicle with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device to be serviced by the installer at least once every 60 days in order for the installer to recalibrate and monitor the operation of the device.
(2)The installer shall notify the department if the device is removed or indicates that the person has attempted to remove, bypass, or tamper with the device, or if the person fails three or more times to comply with any requirement for the maintenance or calibration of the ignition interlock device.
(g)The department shall monitor the installation and maintenance of the ignition interlock device installed pursuant to subdivision (d).
(h)A person is required to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device pursuant to this section for the applicable term, as follows:
(1)A person convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (g) of Section 23152 shall be required to do the following, as applicable:
(A)Upon a conviction with no priors, punishable under Section 23536, only one of the following may occur:
(i)The court may the court shall order installation of a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. If the court orders the ignition interlock device restriction, the The term shall be determined by the court for a period not to exceed six months from the date of conviction. The court shall notify the department of the conviction as specified in subdivision (a) of Section 1803 or Section 1816, and shall specify the terms of the ignition interlock device restriction in accordance with subdivision (a) of Section 1804. The department shall place the restriction on the drivers license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term.
(ii)The person may apply to the department for a restriction of the driving privilege under Section 13352.4.(iii)The person may apply to the department for a restriction of the driving privilege under paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 13352 or subdivision (c) of Section 13352.1.(B)Upon a conviction with one prior, punishable under Section 23540, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.
(C)Upon a conviction with two priors, punishable under Section 23546, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 24 months.
(D)Upon a conviction with three or more priors punishable under Section 23550, or a conviction punishable under Section 23550.5, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 36 months.
(2)A person convicted of a violation of subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (g) of Section 23153 shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device, as follows:
(A)Upon a conviction with no priors, punishable under Section 23554, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.
(B)Upon a conviction with one prior, punishable under Section 23560, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 24 months.
(C)Upon a conviction with two priors, punishable under Section 23550 or 23566, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 36 months.
(D)Upon a conviction with one prior punishable under Section 23550.5, the person shall install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device in the vehicle, as ordered by the court, that is operated by that person for a mandatory term of 48 months.
(3)For the purposes of paragraphs (1) and (2), prior means a conviction for a separate violation of Section 23103, as specified in Section 23103.5, or Section 23152 or 23153, subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 191.5 of, or subdivision (a) of Section 192.5 of, the Penal Code, or subdivision (b), (c), (d), (e), or (f) of Section 655 of the Harbors and Navigation Code, that occurred within 10 years of the current violation.
(4)The terms prescribed in this subdivision shall begin once a person has complied with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) and either upon the reinstatement of the privilege to drive pursuant to Section 13352 or the issuance of a restricted drivers license pursuant to Section 13352. A person shall receive credit for any period in which he or she the person had a restricted drivers license issued pursuant to Section 13353.6 or 13353.75.
(i)Subdivisions (g), (h), (j), and (k) of Section 23575 apply to this section.
(j)If a person fails to comply with any of the requirements regarding ignition interlock devices, the period in which the person was not in compliance shall not be credited towards the mandatory term for which the ignition interlock device is required to be installed.
(k)(1)Every manufacturer and manufacturers agent certified by the department to provide ignition interlock devices, under Section 13386, shall adopt the following fee schedule that provides for the payment of the costs of the certified ignition interlock device by offenders subject to this chapter in amounts commensurate with that persons income relative to the federal poverty level, as defined in Section 127400 of the Health and Safety Code:
(A)A person with an income at 100 percent of the federal poverty level or below and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 10 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(B)A person with an income at 101 to 200 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 25 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(C)A person with an income at 201 to 300 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(D)A person who is receiving CalFresh benefits and who provides proof of those benefits to the manufacturer or manufacturers agent or authorized installer is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(E)A person with an income at 301 to 400 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification pursuant to paragraph (2) is responsible for 90 percent of the cost of the manufacturers standard ignition interlock device program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
(F)All other offenders are responsible for 100 percent of the cost of the ignition interlock device.
(G)The manufacturer is responsible for the percentage of costs that the offender is not responsible for pursuant to subparagraphs (A) to (E), inclusive.
(2)The ignition interlock device provider shall verify the offenders income to determine the cost of the ignition interlock device pursuant to this subdivision by verifying one of the following documents from the offender:
(A)The previous years federal income tax return.
(B)The previous three months of weekly or monthly income statements.
(C)Employment Development Department verification of unemployment benefits.
(l)The Department of Consumer Affairs may impose a civil assessment not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) upon a manufacturer or manufacturers agent certified to provide ignition interlock devices who fails to inform an offender subject to this chapter of the provisions of subdivision (k), or who fails to comply with the provisions of subdivision (k).
(m)This section does not permit a person to drive without a valid drivers license.
(n)The requirements of this section are in addition to any other requirements of law.
(o)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Bypass means either of the following:
(A)Failure to take any random retest.
(B)Failure to pass a random retest with a breath alcohol concentration not exceeding 0.03 percent, by weight of alcohol, in the persons blood.
(2)Operates includes operating a vehicle that is not owned by the person subject to this section.
(3)Owned means solely owned or owned in conjunction with another person or legal entity.
(4)Random retest means a breath test performed by the driver upon a certified ignition interlock device at random intervals after the initial engine startup breath test and while the vehicles motor is running.
(5)Vehicle does not include a motorcycle until the state certifies an ignition interlock device that can be installed on a motorcycle. A person subject to an ignition interlock device restriction shall not operate a motorcycle for the duration of the ignition interlock device restriction period.
(p)The requirements of this section shall apply only to a person who is convicted for a violation of Section 23152 or 23153 that occurred on or after January 1, 2019.
(q)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
(r)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2026, deletes or extends that date.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 8, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 2, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| May 2, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 30, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 23). |
| Apr 16, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 8, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 7, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah | ** Support | |
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety | ** Support | |
| Automobile Club of Southern California | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Highway Patrolmen | ** Support | |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | ** Against | |
| California Police Chiefs Association | ** Support | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Against | |
| Debt Free Justice California | ** Against | |
| Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility | ** Support | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Against | |
| Merced County District Attorney's Office | ** Support | |
| Mothers Against Drunk Driving | ** Support | |
| National Transportation Safety Board | ** Support | |
| Peace Officers Research Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Root & Rebound | ** Against | |
| Sacramento County District Attorney's Office | ** Support | |
| Safe: Safety and Advocacy for Empowerment | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Against | |
| Streets for All | ** Support | |
| Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC. | ** Against |
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2210
Author:(Petrie-Norris) – As Amended Ver:May 1, 2024
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to operate a five-county pilot project for installation of an ignition interlock device (IID) in the vehicle of a first-time driving under the influence (DUI) offender.
Specifically, among other provisions, this bill:
- Requires the DMV to establish an IID pilot program in the counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego.
- Requires a person to install an IID as a condition of being issued a restricted driver’s license, being reissued a driver’s license, or having the privilege to operate a motor vehicle reinstated following a conviction for a violation or a suspension of the person’s driver’s license, as follows:
- Requires a person convicted of a DUI violation to install an IID, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of six months.
- Requires a person convicted of a DUI involving injury violation to install an IID, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.
- Requires the DMV to inform a qualifying person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified IID installed.
- Requires a qualifying person to complete all of the following before their driver’s license maybe issued, reissued, or returned:
- Arrange for each vehicle owned or operated by the person to be fitted with a certified IID.
- Notify the DMV and provide to the DMV proof of IID.
- Pay the fee, determined by the DMV, that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of the IID program.
- Requires the DMV to monitor the installation and maintenance of each IID installed.
- Provides that, if a person fails to comply with any of the requirements regarding IIDs, the mandatory term for which the IID is required to be installed shall be reset by the DMV.
- Requires every manufacturer and manufacturer’s agent certified by DMV to provide IIDs to adopt a specified income-based fee schedule for the payment of the costs of the IID and other costs associated with the device, and specifies that for certain lower income levels the IID provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the IID that is not paid by a low-income qualifying person.
- Requires the DMV to post information relating to fee schedules on its website and include the information in specified mailed notices.
- Authorizes the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to impose a civil assessment not to exceed $1,000 upon a manufacturer or manufacturer’s agent certified to provide IIDs who fails to inform a person required to install an IID of the fee schedules or who fails to comply with the fee scheduling provisions.
- Requires the DMV to report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the pilot program in reducing the number of first-time DUI violations in the pilot counties.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Costs to the DMV (Motor Vehicle Fund) of an unknown but potentially significant amount to establish and operate the pilot program. The DMV reports that implementation of this bill requires programming modifications that the department cannot complete by the bill’s operative date. The DMV is currently undertaking an IT modernization project that will be ongoing through fiscal year 2025-26. If the DMV is required to build a temporary IT solution to implement this bill outside of that project, the department anticipates “significantly high” costs for additional programming and, potentially, acquisition of new technology and services. The DMV also reports it would be required to promulgate regulations, modify forms, publications, and other content, and would incur ongoing costs associated with increased traffic in field offices and with the proposed evaluation. Costs may be offset to an unknown extent by fees. The bill requires a qualifying person to pay a fee to the DMV that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of the pilot, with the fee amount set by the DMV. However, the DMV indicates this is an administrative service fee that will not cover the department’s administration costs.
The Motor Vehicle Account (MVA) is the DMV’s main funding source. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO), the MVA is expected to fully exhaust its reserves and become insolvent in fiscal year 2025-26. The LAO further warns that the MVA, absent corrective action, such as revenue increases or spending reductions, will experience a negative fund balance of $1.4 billion in fiscal year 2028 29.
- Costs (special funds) of an unknown amount to DCA to impose assessments on non-complying IID manufacturers and manufacturer’s agents. DCA expects this workload to be minor and absorbable.
Consistent with Assembly Appropriations Committee rules and practice, this bill is eligible for placement on the suspense file because it has the primary purpose of creating a pilot program.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Nearly 105,000 drivers in California were arrested for DUI in 2022. In its most recent report, the Office of Traffic Safety cited a 16.1% increase in alcohol-impaired crashes vs. previous years and that nearly 1 out of 3 traffic fatalities involved drivers above the .08 blood alcohol legal limit…Current law in California requires Judges to order Ignition Interlock Devices (IIDs) only for all repeat (2nd or more) offenders. This is despite the fact that a DMV study from 2016 found that ignition interlocks are 74% more effective in reducing DUI recidivism than license suspension alone for first offenders during the first 6 months after conviction. In addition, 35 other states plus Washington D.C. require IIDs for all offenders.
- Background. Under existing law, a judge may – but is not required to – order a person convicted of a DUI offense for the first time to install an IID in their vehicle. This bill establishes a pilot program in which, in participating counties, a person convicted of a specified DUI offense for the first time is required to install an IID in their vehicle before they can lawfully drive. The bill contains provisions that exempt an otherwise qualifying individual from complying with the IID requirement by certifying, among other things, that they do not own or have access to a vehicle at their residence.
As summarized in more detail in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Public Safety, the DMV previously administered a similar IID pilot program for first-time DUI offenders, which concluded in 2016. The DMV found that “pilot participants had lower DUI recidivism rates than other DUI offenders, but these lower rates significantly diminished over time…Individuals obtaining an IID-restricted license had a higher increase in crashes, including fatal/injury crashes, compared to DUI offenders whose licenses remained suspended or revoked.” The DMV also found no evidence that the pilot program had a general deterrence effect – it “was not associated with a reduction in the number of first-time and repeat DUI convictions in the pilot counties.”
The DMV is currently operating a statewide IID pilot program for all repeat DUI offenders and all injury-involved DUI offenders, which will run from January 1, 2019, through December 31, 2025.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
Counsel: Andrew Ironside
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
UPDATED
As Proposed to be Amended in Committee
SUMMARY:
Establishes pilot programs in the Counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego requiring a court to order an ignition interlock device (IID) for a first time DUI offenders. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to establish a pilot program in the Counties of Los Angeles, Orange, Sacramento, San Bernardino, and San Diego to reduce the number of first-time DUI violations, as follows:
- Requires the DMV, upon receipt of the court’s abstract conviction for a first time DUI violation, to inform the convicted person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified IID installed. The records of the DMV shall reflect the mandatory use of the device for the term required and the time when the device is required to be installed.
- Requires the DMV to advise the person that installation of an IID on a vehicle does not allow the person to drive without a valid driver’s license.
- Provides that, before a driver’s license may be issued, reissued, or returned to a person after a suspension or revocation of that person’s driving privilege that requires the installation of an IID, a person who is notified by the DMV shall complete all of the following:
- Arrange for each vehicle owned or operated by the person to be fitted with a certified IID;
- Notify the DMV and provide to the DMV proof of installation by submitting the “Verification of Installation” form, as specified; and,
- Pay the fee, determined by the DMV, that is sufficient to cover the costs of administration of the IID program.
- Arrange for each vehicle owned or operated by the person to be fitted with a certified IID;
- Requires the DMV to place a restriction on the driver’s license record of the convicted person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a certified IID.
- Requires a person who is notified by the DMV to arrange for each vehicle with an IID to be serviced by the installer at least once every 60 days in order for the installer to recalibrate and monitor the operation of the device.
- Requires the installer to notify the DMV if the device is removed or indicates that the person has attempted to remove, bypass, or tamper with the device, or if the person fails three or more times to comply with any requirement for the maintenance or calibration of the IID.
- Requires the DMV to monitor the installation and maintenance of the IID installed, as specified.
- Provides that A person is required to install an ignition interlock device for the applicable term as a condition of being issued a restricted driver’s license, being reissued a driver’s license, or having the privilege to operate a motor vehicle reinstated subsequent to a conviction for a violation or a suspension of a person’s driver’s license, as follows:
- Requires a person convicted of a DUI violation to install an IID, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of six months.
- Requires a person convicted of a DUI involving injury violation to install an IID, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of 12 months.
- Requires a person convicted of a DUI violation to install an IID, upon a first offense, in all vehicles owned or operated by that person for a mandatory term of six months.
- Provides that a person who is notified by the DMV, as specified, is exempt from the requirements to install an IID if within 30 days of the notification, the person certifies to the DMV all of the following:
- The person does not own a vehicle;
- The person does not have access to a vehicle at his or her residence;
- The person no longer has access to the vehicle being driven by the person at the time he or she was arrested for a violation that subsequently resulted in the conviction;
- The person acknowledges that he or she is only allowed to drive a vehicle that is fitted with a functioning IID;
- The person acknowledges that he or she is required to have a valid driver’s license before he or she can drive; and,
- The person is subject to the program requirements if he or she purchases or has access to a vehicle.
- The person does not own a vehicle;
- Provides that, if a person fails to comply with any of the requirements regarding IIDs, the mandatory term for which the IID is required to be installed shall be reset by the DMV.
- Requires the DMV, upon receipt of the court’s abstract conviction for a first time DUI violation, to inform the convicted person of the requirements of this section, including the term for which the person is required to have a certified IID installed. The records of the DMV shall reflect the mandatory use of the device for the term required and the time when the device is required to be installed.
- Requires every manufacturer and manufacturer’s agent certified by DMV to provide IIDs to adopt the following fee schedule that provides for the payment of the costs of the certified IID, the administration of the program, installation of the device, maintenance and recalibration of the device, and any other costs associated with the device by persons in amounts commensurate with that person’s income relative to the federal poverty level, as specified:
- A person with an income at 125 percent of the federal poverty level and below is responsible for 10 percent of the cost of the IID. The IID provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the IID that is not paid by the person.
- A person with an income at 126-225 percent of the federal poverty level is responsible for 25 percent of the cost of the IID. The IID provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the IID that is not paid by the person.
- A person with an income at 226-325 percent of the federal poverty level is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of IID. The IID provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the IID that is not paid by the person.
- A person who is receiving CalFresh and who provides proof of those benefits to the manufacturer or manufacturer’s agent or authorized installer is responsible for 50 percent of the cost of the manufacturer’s standard IID program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
- A person with an income at 326-425 percent of the federal poverty level and who provides income verification is responsible for 90 percent of the cost of the manufacturer’s standard IID program costs, and any additional costs accrued by the person for noncompliance with program requirements.
- All other persons are responsible for 100 percent of the cost of the IID.
- The manufacturer is responsible for the percentage of costs that the person ordered to install an IID is not responsible for, as specified.
- A person with an income at 125 percent of the federal poverty level and below is responsible for 10 percent of the cost of the IID. The IID provider is responsible for absorbing the cost of the IID that is not paid by the person.
- Requires the IID provider to verify the income of the person ordered to install an IID to determine the cost of the IID and associated costs by verifying any of the following documents from the person:
- The previous year’s state or federal income tax return.
- The previous three months of weekly or monthly income statements.
- Employment Development Department verification of unemployment benefits.
- The previous year’s state or federal income tax return.
- Provides that the individual, at any point during which a device is installed and in use, shall be permitted to apply for reduced costs and shall be credited for any previously paid costs that were in excess of the fee schedule. An individual shall also be permitted to apply for reduced costs based on a change of income.
- Requires the IID provider to post conspicuously on its internet website and contracts the information pertaining to the fee schedule. Prior to an individual’s execution of a contract for an IID, the provider shall also give verbal notification of the fee schedule and how to apply for reduced costs.
- Requires installation service and repair providers to post conspicuously in their place of business and verbally inform a person of the information relating to fee schedules prior to installation and servicing of the device.
- A copy of this information to be provided to an individual together with the court order requiring the installation of an IID.
- Requires the DMV to post the information relating to fee schedules on its website. The DMV shall also include the information in any mailed notice of revocation or suspension that notifies an individual of the requirement to install an IID.
- Authorizes the Department of Consumer Affairs to impose a civil assessment not to exceed $1,000 upon a manufacturer or manufacturer’s agent certified to provide IIDs who fails to inform a person required to install an IID of the fee schedules or who fails to comply with the fee scheduling provisions.
- Requires DMV, on or before January 1, 2031, to report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the pilot program in reducing the number of first-time violations DUI in the Counties of Orange and Sacramento.
- Provides that pilot programs last until July 1, 2030, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2030, deletes or extends that date.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides it is unlawful for any person who is under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle. (Veh. Code, § 23152 subds. (a), (f), & (g).)
- Provides that it is unlawful for any person, while having 0.08 percent or more, by weight, of alcohol in their blood to drive a vehicle. (Veh. Code, § 23512(b).)
- States that a person who is convicted of a first DUI is subject to the following penalties when given probation:
- Possible 48 hours to 6 months in jail;
- A fine of $390 to $1,000 plus penalty assessments;
- Completion of a 3-month treatment program or a 9-month program if the BAC was .20% or more; and,
- Six month license suspension or 10 month suspension if 9-month program is ordered, and;
- States that a restricted license may be sought upon proof of enrollment or completion of program, proof of financial responsibility and payment of fees. However, the court may disallow the restricted license. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(1), 13352.1, 13352.4, 23538(a)(3).)
- Authorizes the court to order a first-time DUI offender to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle for up to six months unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i).)
- Requires the DMV, if the court orders the installation of an IID, to place the restriction on the driver’s license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i).)
- Provides that a person convicted of a first DUI offense may apply to the DMV for a restricted license, as specified. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(ii) & (iii).)
- Provides that a person convicted of a first-time DUI may apply for a restricted license for driving to and from work and to and from a driver-under-influence program if specified requirements are met, paying all applicable fees, submitting proof of insurance and proof of participation in a program. (Veh. Code, § 13352.4.)
- States that a person convicted of a first DUI offense, if not given probation, faces punishment of up to six months in jail, 96 hours of which is required, a suspension of their driver’s license contingent upon completion of a specified DUI program, and applicable fines and penalty assessments. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(1), 13352.1, 13352.4, 23536.)
- States that if a first time DUI offender is found to have a blood concentration of .20% BAC or above, or refused to take a chemical test, the court shall refer the offender to participate in a 9-month licensed program. (Veh. Code, § 23538 subd. (b)(2).)
- States that a first-time DUI offender sentenced to a 9-month program because of a high BAC or a refusal shall have their license suspended for 10 months. The license may not be reinstated until the person gives proof of insurance and proof of completion of the required program. (Veh. Code, § 13352.1.)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury, if not given probation, faces punishment with 16 months, 2 or 3 years state prison, or 90 days to one year in county jail. Applicable fines and penalty assessments, a specified DUI program, and a one year driver’s license suspension also apply. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(2), 23554.)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury, if given probation, faces punishment of 5 days to one year in jail, applicable fines and penalty assessments, applicable DUI programs, and a one year driver’s license suspension. (Veh. Code §§ 13352, subd. (a)(2), 23554.)
- Creates a pilot project that requires a person convicted of a second or subsequent DUI or DUI causing injury to install and maintain an IID for 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a third offense and for 36 months for a fourth or subsequent offense. Proof of installation of the IID, along with other requirements, permits a person to get a restricted license after a specified period of time. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; & 13353.75.)
- Provides that the existing IID pilot project shall sunset on January 1, 2026. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; & 13353.75.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “DUI statistics offer a somber reminder of the dangers intoxicated drivers pose to our communities.
“Nearly 105,000 drivers in California were arrested for DUI in 2022. In its most recent report, the Office of Traffic Safety cited a 16.1% increase in alcohol-impaired crashes vs. previous years and that nearly 1 out of 3 traffic fatalities involved drivers above the .08 blood alcohol legal limit.
“Drivers suspended for highway safety reasons are three times more likely to be involved in a crash, due in part to the lack of effective accountability for their initial unsafe behavior.
“According to the CDC and Mothers Against Drunk Driving, up to 75% of convicted drunk drivers continue to drive on a suspended license.
“Current law in California requires Judges to order Ignition Interlock Devices (IIDs) only for all repeat (2nd or more) offenders. This is despite the fact that a DMV study from 2016 found that ignition interlocks are 74% more effective in reducing DUI recidivism than license suspension alone for first offenders during the first 6 months after conviction. In addition, 35 other states plus Washington D.C. require IIDs for all offenders.
“AB 2210 would align California’s laws with these other states and require that first time DUI offenders be required to install an Ignition Interlock Device on their vehicle for a period of 6 months. This is an important step in our fight against drunk driving and will help keep our roads safe.” - Required Use of IIDs: Existing law gives courts discretion to impose an IID upon a first time DUI offender. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3.) By allowing the courts discretion to impose an IID on first time offenders, it provides the court an opportunity to tailor the sentence in the appropriate manner to the facts of the crime, the person’s history, and the person’s current circumstances.
A judge may determine that an IID is not the most appropriate remedy when a person has been convicted of a first time DUI and there is no evidence of alcohol abuse or other history of poor judgment. A court might find that imposition of an IID is not the best remedy if the defendant is part of a household where a single car is shared between the defendant and other family members and requiring an IID on that car will burden family members that have engaged in no wrongdoing.
"Society receives maximum protection when the penalty, treatment or disposition of the offender is tailored to the individual case. Only the trial judge has the knowledge, ability and tools at hand to properly individualize the treatment of the offender." (People v. Williams (1970) 30 Cal.3d 470,482, citation and internal quotation marks omitted.)
A June 17, 2016 DMV report on the IID pilot project evaluated the project from two perspectives—an “intent to treat” evaluation and “the restricted license evaluation.” “Intent to Treat” was the group of individuals subject to the requirement that they install and IID, regardless of whether they installed an IID and complied with the law. “The restricted license evaluation” consisted of the individuals that were subject to the IID mandate and complied with the requirements of the program. DMV found that the IID-restricted license program had “mixed traffic safety impacts.”
For first time DUI offenders in the pilot project, the study found in the Intent-to-Treat Evaluation:
- The AB 91 program is not associated with an increase or decrease in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction over the 12-month time period.
- The AB 91 program is not associated with a reduction or increase in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident over the 12-month time period.
First offenders in non-pilot counties have a 6.1% lower hazards or odds of a subsequent crash relative to those in the pilot counties over the 12-month time period. (California DMV. Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California. p. xi, June 17, 2016” https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/b1eba1e5-9155-40ba-9a74-0e6e19a0d1bc/S5-251.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
For first offenders in the Restricted License Evaluation portion the study found that for people with an IID, while there was an initial lower rate DUI in the first 182 days following their conviction, that lower rate diminished over time. In addition, there was a higher rate of hazards or subsequent crashes with those with the IID and that trend increased over the 12 month period. (Id. p. xii)
The study also found that:
The study findings indicate a negative association between having an IID-restricted license and subsequent crash involvement for all DUI offender groups. For the first and second DUI offenders, higher crash risk among those with the AB 91 IID-restricted license increases over time relative to DUI offenders with a suspended license. Therefore, although the AB 91 IID program is associated with a significant reduction in DUI recidivism among all DUI offender groups, the program is also associated with an increase in crash involvement among all DUI offenders that are subject to the program. This is particularly problematic since a substantial proportion of these crashes are those involving injuries and/or fatalities (of the overall crash involvement measured in the study, the proportion of fatal/injury crashes ranged from mid-30% to low-40% for different DUI offender groups—which is consistent with what prior California evaluations have reported for these offender groups). (Id. p. xv)
This bill would require that an IID be installed for a period of 12 months for those diverted. The question posed by this requirement is whether an IID would be necessary in all cases given the findings by the DMV.
- Existing IID pilot project: In 2009, AB 91 (Feuer) created an IID pilot project in four counties which mandated the use of an IID for all DUI offenders. DMV issued a report in June 2016 on the specific deterrent of the pilot project.
The rationale for a pilot project was to see what impact a mandatory IID program has on recidivism in California. While the impact of IID has been studied elsewhere, with mixed results, the comparisons are not perfect because while some of the other states began mandating IID at the same time they strengthened other sanctions, California has had a complex group of sanctions including high fines, jail time, licensing sanctions, mandatory drinker-driver treatment programs and optional IID in place since the mid-1980’s with sanctions being evaluated, changed and strengthened on an ongoing basis since. The thought was that with a pilot project, DMV can evaluate how best a mandatory IID system should work in California. By evaluating four counties, the counties without the mandatory programs act like a control group for the researchers at DMV. Evaluating how the DUI sanctions work is something DMV researchers have been doing with great success since 1990. DMV’s reports have helped inform the Legislature on where changes needed to be made and have helped reduce recidivism in California.
SB 1046 (Hill) deleted the four county pilot project when it created a statewide IID pilot project for repeat offender DUI. - DUI Sanctions: Most people convicted of a first DUI are given probation. As part of probation, as well as a condition for getting relicensed a person must attend a licensed treatment program, in addition to fines, fees, and license sanctions. The fine for a first-time DUI is between $390 and $1,000. (Veh. Code, § 23536.) However, with additional fees and assessments, the cost of a first-time DUI is almost always considerably higher than the base fine. For example, a base fine of $390 would be subject to the following additional fees and assessments:
Penal Code section 1464 state penalty on fines: $390 ($10 for every $10)
Penal Code section 1465.7 state surcharge: $78 (20% surcharge)
Penal Code section 1465.8 court operation assessment: $40 ($40 fee per criminal offense)
Government Code section 70372 court construction penalty: $195 ($5 for every $10)
Government Code section 70373 assessment: $35 ($35 for each infraction)
Government Code section 76000 penalty: $273 ($7 for every $10)
Government Code section 76000.5 EMS penalty: $78 ($2 for every $10)
Government Code section 76104.6 DNA fund penalty: $39 ($1 for every $10)
Government Code section 76104.7 additional DNA fund penalty: $156 ($4 for every $10)
As such, after additional fees and assessments, the minimum fine for a first-time DUI could end up costing $1,674. This amount does not include the cost of the required DUI program, lasting either three or nine months depending on the person’s blood alcohol level. (Veh. Code, § 23538, subd. (b).) A 3 months DUI program generally costs between $500 and $800; a 9-month program can cost upwards of $1,500. Most programs charge for missed activities, transfers, and late payments. (https://www.dhcs.ca.gov/individuals/Pages/DUI-Program-Fees.aspx) A DUI program participant may receive a program fee reduction after a financial assessment. (Ibid.) For a restricted license with an IID, the DMV also charges a $55 reissue fee, a $15 restriction fee, and an additional IID restriction fee. (https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/file/1st-offender-alcohol-non-injury-pdf)
In addition to the base fine and the cost the DUI program, this bill would require the installation of an ignition interlock device for a first time DUI conviction. Existing law provides a fee scale for the payment of “the costs of the certified ignition interlock device” that limits “program costs” based on a person’s income. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (k)(1).). According to the opposition, “Current law does not make clear that all costs of the device are subject to the fee reduction, including the regular maintenance and calibration cost charged by installers. Current law also does not require adequate notification of the right to request a reduced fee for an ignition interlock device. Individuals often report not knowing that a sliding scale was available that could make the device affordable or how to request it.”
- Argument in Support: According to National Transportation Safety Board, “Progress addressing alcohol-impaired driving has stalled. In fact, the problem has gotten worse. In 2022, there were 13,542 alcohol-impaired driving fatalities in the United States—only a .7-percent decrease from 2021, which saw the highest number of alcohol-impaired driving fatalities since 2008. The state of California alone lost 1,479 lives to alcohol-impaired driving in 2022, accounting for 33 percent of all motor vehicle fatalities.
“In our 2013 report, Reaching Zero-Actions to Eliminate Alcohol-Impaired Driving, we reiterated our recommendation that ignition interlock devices (IIDs) be installed in the vehicles of all drivers convicted of driving while intoxicated (DWI). This was part of a comprehensive set of targeted interventions and supporting research that included stronger laws, swifter enforcement, and expanded use of technology.
“Evaluation of ignition interlock programs over the last two decades has found that IIDs effectively reduce recidivism among DUI/DWI offenders, sometimes by as much as 62 to 75 percent. Additionally, a study released by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that the number of impaired drivers involved in fatal crashes decreased by 16 percent for states that require IIDs for all DUI offenders comparted to states with no interlock law.
“Progress toward eliminating impaired-driving fatalities has unnecessarily stagnated. More can—and should—be done to prevent these tragedies. The NTSB believes that the only acceptable number of deaths on our roads is zero, and it has been our charge since our founding to determine how to eliminate transportation fatalities. Deaths due to impaired driving are 100-percent preventable, and mandating the use of IIDs for all DUI offenders will prevent impaired driving and save lives on California roads.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Root & Rebound, “The financial consequences of a DUI conviction are considerable and are disproportionately burdensome for low-income drivers. Furthermore, DUI convictions and the consequences that follow are unequally levied on Black and Brown drivers. In addition to the standard penalty fines, drivers also face the – often much more burdensome - costs of DUI class fees, high-cost insurance premiums, DMV licensing fees, and other charges. This bill would add the cost of an ignition interlock device to this list for all first-time convictions. For low-income drivers who are trying to comply with their legal obligations, the cumulative financial costs often prevent them from meeting these obligations and leave them with an indefinitely suspended license. Because of both the racial disparities in convictions as well as the racial wealth gap, the financial costs result in the form of racialized wealth extraction. Importantly, the public safety impact of mandatory IIDs is questionable. A recent study by the DMV on the impact of AB 91 (Fauer) that created a pilot for mandatory installation of IIDs found that ‘mandatory ignition interlock installation did not reduce county-wide DUI recidivism below that of comparison counties.’
“Without a license, individuals face decreased employment opportunities and obstacles in caring for family members or getting to medical appointments. Individuals who have no other choice but to drive face additional consequences of driving on a suspended license - not because they want to violate the law, but simply because they cannot afford to comply. The inequities of the mandate will also disproportionately impact low-income and marginalized communities of color, who are overrepresented in traffic stops. Without addressing the financial and logistical barriers, the result will be two different systems: one for higher income drivers who can easily pay to comply with the heightened consequences and one of lower income drivers who cannot afford to pay them and therefore will have longer suspensions and bear collateral economic and criminal consequences.
“Even though current law provides a sliding scale for ignition interlock devices it is inadequate. The scale does not provide significant enough reductions, especially given the cumulative costs a driver convicted of a DUI is required to pay. Current law does not make clear that all costs of the device are subject to the fee reduction, including the regular maintenance and calibration cost charged by installers. Current law also does not require adequate notification of the right to request a reduced fee for an ignition interlock device. Individuals often report not knowing that a sliding scale was available that could make the device affordable or how to request it.
“Imposing additional consequences without accounting for the financial and logistical barriers of these consequences will undermine the public safety goals of the bill, cause economic hardship, and result in low-income drivers shouldering a different and more severe punishment than individuals who can afford the device in addition to the other fines and fees imposed for a DUI.” - Related Legislation: AB 2823 (Joe Patterson), would require the period of probation for a person granted probation for vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated to be at least three years. AB 2823 is pending hearing in this committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 1021 (Bradford), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have permitted a diversion program including an IID requirement. This bill was not heard in Assembly Public Safety.
- SB 421 (Bradford) of the 2021-2022 legislative session, would have authorized diversion for specified DUI offenses. SB 421 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 282 (Lackey) of the 2021-2022 legislative session, would have explicitly prohibited diversion for specified DUI offenses. AB 282 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 3234 (Ting) Chapter 334, Statutes of 2020, created diversion for most misdemeanor offenses, as specified.
- SB 545 (Hill) of the 2019-2020 legislative session, would have required IIDs to be installed for a period of six months for first time convicted DUI offenders. The hearing SB 545 in the Assembly Public Safety Committee was cancelled at the request of the author.
- SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, extended the IID pilot program in certain counties and required installation of IIDs for specified DUI offenses.
- SB 1021 (Bradford), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have permitted a diversion program including an IID requirement. This bill was not heard in Assembly Public Safety.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
Automobile Club of Southern California
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Police Chiefs Association
Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility (RESPONSIBILITY.ORG)
Merced County District Attorney’s Office
Mothers Against Drunk Driving
National Transportation Safety Board
Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC)
Sacramento County District Attorney's Office
Safe: Safety and Advocacy for Empowerment
Streets for All
Opposition
ACLU California Action
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Debt Free Justice California
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
San Francisco Public Defender
Root & Rebound
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Analysis Prepared by:
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
Counsel: Andrew Ironside
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Removes the discretion of the court to only order an ignition interlock device (IID) for a first time DUI offender when appropriate based on an individualized evaluation of the facts. Specifically, this bill: Requires the court to order, for a period of six months, installation of a functioning, certified IID on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified IID.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides it is unlawful for any person who is under the influence of any alcoholic beverage or drug, or under the combined influence of any alcoholic beverage and drug, to drive a vehicle. (Veh. Code, § 23152 subds. (a), (f), & (g).)
- Provides that it is unlawful for any person, while having 0.08 percent or more, by weight, of alcohol in their blood to drive a vehicle. (Veh. Code, § 23512(b).)
- States that a person who is convicted of a first DUI is subject to the following penalties when given probation:
- Possible 48 hours to 6 months in jail;
- A fine of $390 to $1,000 plus penalty assessments;
- Completion of a 3-month treatment program or a 9-month program if the BAC was .20% or more; and,
- Six month license suspension or 10 month suspension if 9-month program is ordered, and;
- States that a restricted license may be sought upon proof of enrollment or completion of program, proof of financial responsibility and payment of fees. However, the court may disallow the restricted license. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(1), 13352.1, 13352.4, 23538(a)(3).)
- Authorizes the court to order a first-time DUI offender to install a functioning, certified ignition interlock device on any vehicle that the person operates and prohibit that person from operating a motor vehicle for up to six months unless that vehicle is equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i).)
- Requires the DMV, if the court orders the installation of an IID, to place the restriction on the driver’s license record of the person that states the driver is restricted to driving only vehicles equipped with a functioning, certified ignition interlock device for the applicable term. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(i).)
- Provides that a person convicted of a first DUI offense may apply to the DMV for a restricted license, as specified. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (h)(1)(A)(ii) & (iii).)
- Provides that a person convicted of a first-time DUI may apply for a restricted license for driving to and from work and to and from a driver-under-influence program if specified requirements are met, paying all applicable fees, submitting proof of insurance and proof of participation in a program. (Veh. Code, § 13352.4.)
- States that a person convicted of a first DUI offense, if not given probation, faces punishment of up to six months in jail, 96 hours of which is required, a suspension of their driver’s license contingent upon completion of a specified DUI program, and applicable fines and penalty assessments. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(1), 13352.1, 13352.4, 23536.)
- States that if a first time DUI offender is found to have a blood concentration of .20% BAC or above, or refused to take a chemical test, the court shall refer the offender to participate in a 9-month licensed program. (Veh. Code, § 23538 subd. (b)(2).)
- States that a first-time DUI offender sentenced to a 9-month program because of a high BAC or a refusal shall have their license suspended for 10 months. The license may not be reinstated until the person gives proof of insurance and proof of completion of the required program. (Veh. Code, § 13352.1.)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury, if not given probation, faces punishment with 16 months, 2 or 3 years state prison, or 90 days to one year in county jail. Applicable fines and penalty assessments, a specified DUI program, and a one year driver’s license suspension also apply. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352 subd. (a)(2), 23554.)
- Provides that a person who is convicted of a first DUI with injury, if given probation, faces punishment of 5 days to one year in jail, applicable fines and penalty assessments, applicable DUI programs, and a one year driver’s license suspension. (Veh. Code §§ 13352, subd. (a)(2), 23554.)
- Creates a pilot project that requires a person convicted of a second or subsequent DUI or DUI causing injury to install and maintain an IID for 12 months for a second offense, 24 months for a third offense and for 36 months for a fourth or subsequent offense. Proof of installation of the IID, along with other requirements, permits a person to get a restricted license after a specified period of time. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; & 13353.75.)
- Provides that the existing IID pilot project shall sunset on January 1, 2026. (Veh. Code, §§ 13352; 13352.4; 13353.3; 13353.6; & 13353.75.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “DUI statistics offer a somber reminder of the dangers intoxicated drivers pose to our communities.
“Nearly 105,000 drivers in California were arrested for DUI in 2022. In its most recent report, the Office of Traffic Safety cited a 16.1% increase in alcohol-impaired crashes vs. previous years and that nearly 1 out of 3 traffic fatalities involved drivers above the .08 blood alcohol legal limit.
“Drivers suspended for highway safety reasons are three times more likely to be involved in a crash, due in part to the lack of effective accountability for their initial unsafe behavior.
“According to the CDC and Mothers Against Drunk Driving, up to 75% of convicted drunk drivers continue to drive on a suspended license.
“Current law in California requires Judges to order Ignition Interlock Devices (IIDs) only for all repeat (2nd or more) offenders. This is despite the fact that a DMV study from 2016 found that ignition interlocks are 74% more effective in reducing DUI recidivism than license suspension alone for first offenders during the first 6 months after conviction. In addition, 35 other states plus Washington D.C. require IIDs for all offenders.
“AB 2210 would align California’s laws with these other states and require that first time DUI offenders be required to install an Ignition Interlock Device on their vehicle for a period of 6 months. This is an important step in our fight against drunk driving and will help keep our roads safe.” - Required Use of IIDs: Existing law gives courts discretion to impose an IID upon a first time DUI offender. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3.) By allowing the courts discretion to impose an IID on first time offenders, it provides the court an opportunity to tailor the sentence in the appropriate manner to the facts of the crime, the person’s history, and the person’s current circumstances.
A judge may determine that an IID is not the most appropriate remedy when a person has been convicted of a first time DUI and there is no evidence of alcohol abuse or other history of poor judgment. A court might find that imposition of an IID is not the best remedy if the defendant is part of a household where a single car is shared between the defendant and other family members and requiring an IID on that car will burden family members that have engaged in no wrongdoing.
"Society receives maximum protection when the penalty, treatment or disposition of the offender is tailored to the individual case. Only the trial judge has the knowledge, ability and tools at hand to properly individualize the treatment of the offender." (People v. Williams (1970) 30 Cal.3d 470,482, citation and internal quotation marks omitted.)
A June 17, 2016 DMV report on the IID pilot project evaluated the project from two perspectives—an “intent to treat” evaluation and “the restricted license evaluation.” “Intent to Treat” was the group of individuals subject to the requirement that they install and IID, regardless of whether they installed an IID and complied with the law. “The restricted license evaluation” consisted of the individuals that were subject to the IID mandate and complied with the requirements of the program. DMV found that the IID-restricted license program had “mixed traffic safety impacts.”
For first time DUI offenders in the pilot project, the study found in the Intent-to-Treat Evaluation:
- The AB 91 program is not associated with an increase or decrease in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI conviction over the 12-month time period.
- The AB 91 program is not associated with a reduction or increase in the odds or hazards of a subsequent DUI incident over the 12-month time period.
First offenders in non-pilot counties have a 6.1% lower hazards or odds of a subsequent crash relative to those in the pilot counties over the 12-month time period. (California DMV. Specific Deterrent Evaluation of the Ignition Interlock Pilot Program in California. p. xi, June 17, 2016” https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/b1eba1e5-9155-40ba-9a74-0e6e19a0d1bc/S5-251.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
For first offenders in the Restricted License Evaluation portion the study found that for people with an IID, while there was an initial lower rate DUI in the first 182 days following their conviction, that lower rate diminished over time. In addition, there was a higher rate of hazards or subsequent crashes with those with the IID and that trend increased over the 12 month period. (Id. p. xii)
The study also found that:
The study findings indicate a negative association between having an IID-restricted license and subsequent crash involvement for all DUI offender groups. For the first and second DUI offenders, higher crash risk among those with the AB 91 IID-restricted license increases over time relative to DUI offenders with a suspended license. Therefore, although the AB 91 IID program is associated with a significant reduction in DUI recidivism among all DUI offender groups, the program is also associated with an increase in crash involvement among all DUI offenders that are subject to the program. This is particularly problematic since a substantial proportion of these crashes are those involving injuries and/or fatalities (of the overall crash involvement measured in the study, the proportion of fatal/injury crashes ranged from mid-30% to low-40% for different DUI offender groups—which is consistent with what prior California evaluations have reported for these offender groups). (Id. p. xv)
This bill would require that an IID be installed for a period of 12 months for those diverted. The question posed by this requirement is whether an IID would be necessary in all cases given the findings by the DMV.
- Existing IID pilot project: In 2009, AB 91 (Feuer) created an IID pilot project in four counties which mandated the use of an IID for all DUI offenders. DMV issued a report in June 2016 on the specific deterrent of the pilot project.
The rationale for a pilot project was to see what impact a mandatory IID program has on recidivism in California. While the impact of IID has been studied elsewhere, with mixed results, the comparisons are not perfect because while some of the other states began mandating IID at the same time they strengthened other sanctions, California has had a complex group of sanctions including high fines, jail time, licensing sanctions, mandatory drinker-driver treatment programs and optional IID in place since the mid-1980’s with sanctions being evaluated, changed and strengthened on an ongoing basis since. The thought was that with a pilot project, DMV can evaluate how best a mandatory IID system should work in California. By evaluating four counties, the counties without the mandatory programs act like a control group for the researchers at DMV. Evaluating how the DUI sanctions work is something DMV researchers have been doing with great success since 1990. DMV’s reports have helped inform the Legislature on where changes needed to be made and have helped reduce recidivism in California.
SB 1046 (Hill) deleted the four county pilot project when it created a statewide IID pilot project for repeat offender DUI. - DUI Sanctions: Most people convicted of a first DUI are given probation. As part of probation, as well as a condition for getting relicensed a person must attend a licensed treatment program, in addition to fines, fees, and license sanctions. The fine for a first-time DUI is between $390 and $1,000. (Veh. Code, § 23536.) However, with additional fees and assessments, the cost of a first-time DUI is almost always considerably higher than the base fine. For example, a base fine of $390 would be subject to the following additional fees and assessments:
Penal Code section 1464 state penalty on fines: $390 ($10 for every $10)
Penal Code section 1465.7 state surcharge: $78 (20% surcharge)
Penal Code section 1465.8 court operation assessment: $40 ($40 fee per criminal offense)
Government Code section 70372 court construction penalty: $195 ($5 for every $10)
Government Code section 70373 assessment: $35 ($35 for each infraction)
Government Code section 76000 penalty: $273 ($7 for every $10)
Government Code section 76000.5 EMS penalty: $78 ($2 for every $10)
Government Code section 76104.6 DNA fund penalty: $39 ($1 for every $10)
Government Code section 76104.7 additional DNA fund penalty: $156 ($4 for every $10)
As such, after additional fees and assessments, the minimum fine for a first-time DUI could end up costing $1,674. This amount does not include the cost of the required DUI program, lasting either three or nine months depending on the person’s blood alcohol level. (Veh. Code, § 23538, subd. (b).) A 3 months DUI program generally costs between $500 and $800; a 9-month program can cost upwards of $1,500. Most programs charge for missed activities, transfers, and late payments. (https://www.dhcs.ca.gov/individuals/Pages/DUI-Program-Fees.aspx) A DUI program participant may receive a program fee reduction after a financial assessment. (Ibid.) For a restricted license with an IID, the DMV also charges a $55 reissue fee, a $15 restriction fee, and an additional IID restriction fee. (https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/file/1st-offender-alcohol-non-injury-pdf)
In addition to the base fine and the cost the DUI program, this bill would require the installation of an ignition interlock device for a first time DUI conviction. Existing law provides a fee scale for the payment of “the costs of the certified ignition interlock device” that limits “program costs” based on a person’s income. (Veh. Code, § 23575.3, subd. (k)(1).) In practice, these costs likely exclude the cost of installing an IID and ongoing costs for calibration and maintenance of the device.
- Argument in Support: According to National Transportation Safety Board, “Progress addressing alcohol-impaired driving has stalled. In fact, the problem has gotten worse. In 2022, there were 13,542 alcohol-impaired driving fatalities in the United States—only a .7-percent decrease from 2021, which saw the highest number of alcohol-impaired driving fatalities since 2008. The state of California alone lost 1,479 lives to alcohol-impaired driving in 2022, accounting for 33 percent of all motor vehicle fatalities.
“In our 2013 report, Reaching Zero-Actions to Eliminate Alcohol-Impaired Driving, we reiterated our recommendation that ignition interlock devices (IIDs) be installed in the vehicles of all drivers convicted of driving while intoxicated (DWI). This was part of a comprehensive set of targeted interventions and supporting research that included stronger laws, swifter enforcement, and expanded use of technology.
“Evaluation of ignition interlock programs over the last two decades has found that IIDs effectively reduce recidivism among DUI/DWI offenders, sometimes by as much as 62 to 75 percent. Additionally, a study released by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that the number of impaired drivers involved in fatal crashes decreased by 16 percent for states that require IIDs for all DUI offenders comparted to states with no interlock law.
“Progress toward eliminating impaired-driving fatalities has unnecessarily stagnated. More can—and should—be done to prevent these tragedies. The NTSB believes that the only acceptable number of deaths on our roads is zero, and it has been our charge since our founding to determine how to eliminate transportation fatalities. Deaths due to impaired driving are 100-percent preventable, and mandating the use of IIDs for all DUI offenders will prevent impaired driving and save lives on California roads.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Root & Rebound, “The financial consequences of a DUI conviction are considerable and are disproportionately burdensome for low-income drivers. Furthermore, DUI convictions and the consequences that follow are unequally levied on Black and Brown drivers. In addition to the standard penalty fines, drivers also face the – often much more burdensome - costs of DUI class fees, high-cost insurance premiums, DMV licensing fees, and other charges. This bill would add the cost of an ignition interlock device to this list for all first-time convictions. For low-income drivers who are trying to comply with their legal obligations, the cumulative financial costs often prevent them from meeting these obligations and leave them with an indefinitely suspended license. Because of both the racial disparities in convictions as well as the racial wealth gap, the financial costs result in the form of racialized wealth extraction. Importantly, the public safety impact of mandatory IIDs is questionable. A recent study by the DMV on the impact of AB 91 (Fauer) that created a pilot for mandatory installation of IIDs found that ‘mandatory ignition interlock installation did not reduce county-wide DUI recidivism below that of comparison counties.’
“Without a license, individuals face decreased employment opportunities and obstacles in caring for family members or getting to medical appointments. Individuals who have no other choice but to drive face additional consequences of driving on a suspended license - not because they want to violate the law, but simply because they cannot afford to comply. The inequities of the mandate will also disproportionately impact low-income and marginalized communities of color, who are overrepresented in traffic stops. Without addressing the financial and logistical barriers, the result will be two different systems: one for higher income drivers who can easily pay to comply with the heightened consequences and one of lower income drivers who cannot afford to pay them and therefore will have longer suspensions and bear collateral economic and criminal consequences.
“Even though current law provides a sliding scale for ignition interlock devices it is inadequate. The scale does not provide significant enough reductions, especially given the cumulative costs a driver convicted of a DUI is required to pay. Current law does not make clear that all costs of the device are subject to the fee reduction, including the regular maintenance and calibration cost charged by installers. Current law also does not require adequate notification of the right to request a reduced fee for an ignition interlock device. Individuals often report not knowing that a sliding scale was available that could make the device affordable or how to request it.
“Imposing additional consequences without accounting for the financial and logistical barriers of these consequences will undermine the public safety goals of the bill, cause economic hardship, and result in low-income drivers shouldering a different and more severe punishment than individuals who can afford the device in addition to the other fines and fees imposed for a DUI.” - Related Legislation: AB 2823 (Joe Patterson), would require the period of probation for a person granted probation for vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated to be at least three years. AB 2823 is pending hearing in this committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 1021 (Bradford), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have permitted a diversion program including an IID requirement. This bill was not heard in Assembly Public Safety.
- SB 421 (Bradford) of the 2021-2022 legislative session, would have authorized diversion for specified DUI offenses. SB 421 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 282 (Lackey) of the 2021-2022 legislative session, would have explicitly prohibited diversion for specified DUI offenses. AB 282 was held in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 3234 (Ting) Chapter 334, Statutes of 2020, created diversion for most misdemeanor offenses, as specified.
- SB 545 (Hill) of the 2019-2020 legislative session, would have required IIDs to be installed for a period of six months for first time convicted DUI offenders. The hearing SB 545 in the Assembly Public Safety Committee was cancelled at the request of the author.
- SB 1046 (Hill), Chapter 783, Statutes of 2016, extended the IID pilot program in certain counties and required installation of IIDs for specified DUI offenses.
- SB 1021 (Bradford), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have permitted a diversion program including an IID requirement. This bill was not heard in Assembly Public Safety.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety
Automobile Club of Southern California
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Police Chiefs Association
Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility (RESPONSIBILITY.ORG)
Merced County District Attorney’s Office
Mothers Against Drunk Driving
National Transportation Safety Board
Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC)
Sacramento County District Attorney's Office
Safe: Safety and Advocacy for Empowerment
Streets for All
Opposition
ACLU California Action
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Debt Free Justice California
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
San Francisco Public Defender
Root & Rebound
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by:
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):