AB 2221: Broadband projects: electric power design approval.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-22
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations, while local publicly owned electric utilities are under the direction of their governing boards. Under existing law, the Legislature finds and declares that given the importance of broadband for public safety, public health, economic growth, education, and job creation, it is in Californias best interest for public and private broadband project permits to be processed as quickly and efficiently as possible.
This bill would require an electric utility, defined as an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility, to adopt, publish, and make easily accessible to the public rules, requirements, and standards applicable to its applications for approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project, as defined. The bill would require an electric utility to approve or deny a complete application within 45 60 or 90 days, and, if the application is incomplete, would require the electric utility to provide written notice within 10 days to the applicant that the application is incomplete and would establish a timeline and process by which the application could be made complete, as specified. If an application is approved, the bill would require the electric utility, within 14 30 days, to provide the applicant with a cost estimate, if applicable, for any necessary work required to accommodate the electric power design described in the application. If the applicant accepts the cost estimate within 45 30 days, the bill would require the electric utility to complete energization to the broadband project location within 30 days, a commission-determined time period, as specified. The bill would prohibit an application from being subject to any rule, requirement, or standard that has not been published and made easily accessible to the public 12 months before the date of the applications submittal to an electric utility for review.
Under existing law, a violation of any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Additionally, by imposing new duties on local publicly owned electric utilities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations, while local publicly owned electric utilities are under the direction of their governing boards. Under existing law, the Legislature finds and declares that given the importance of broadband for public safety, public health, economic growth, education, and job creation, it is in Californias best interest for public and private broadband project permits to be processed as quickly and efficiently as possible.
This bill would require an electric utility, defined as an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility, to adopt, publish, and make easily accessible to the public rules, requirements, and standards applicable to its applications for approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project, as defined. The bill would require an electric utility to approve or deny a complete application within 45 days, and, if the application is incomplete, would require the electric utility to provide written notice within 10 days to the applicant that the application is incomplete and would establish a timeline and process by which the application could be made complete, as specified. If an application is approved, the bill would require the electric utility, within 14 days, to provide the applicant with a cost estimate, if applicable, for any necessary work required to accommodate the electric power design described in the application. If the applicant accepts the cost estimate within 45 days, the bill would require the electric utility to complete energization to the broadband project location within 30 days, as specified. The bill would prohibit an application from being subject to any rule, requirement, or standard that has not been published and made easily accessible to the public 12 months before the date of the applications submittal to an electric utility for review.
Under existing law, a violation of any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of a commission action implementing this bills requirements would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Additionally, by imposing new duties on local publicly owned electric utilities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.
Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law requires the commission to develop, implement, and administer the California Advanced Services Fund program to encourage the deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, as specified. Existing law requires the commission, on or before April 1, 2023, and biennially thereafter, to conduct a fiscal and performance audit of the implementation and effectiveness of the program to ensure that funds have been expended in accordance with the approved terms of the grant awards and loan agreements and to report its findings to the Legislature.This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that reporting requirement.Existing law vests the Public Utilities Commission with regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law requires the commission to develop, implement, and administer the California Advanced Services Fund program to encourage the deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, as specified. Existing law requires the commission, on or before April 1, 2023, and biennially thereafter, to conduct a fiscal and performance audit of the implementation and effectiveness of the program to ensure that funds have been expended in accordance with the approved terms of the grant awards and loan agreements and to report its findings to the Legislature.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to that reporting requirement.
For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Application means a written request, application, or other document submitted by a broadband provider to an electrical corporation or local publicly owned electric utility for approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project.
(b)Broadband project means a proposed broadband facility, including the support structure and any supporting equipment necessary for operation of the proposed broadband facility. A broadband project may comprise one or more components, including, but not limited to, a wireless facility, a fiber optic connection, and other supporting equipment, each of which may require a separate permit or authorization.
(c)Days means calendar days.
(d)Electric utility means an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility.
(e)Electrical corporation has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 218.
(f)Local publicly owned electric utility has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 224.3.
(g)Submittal means the delivery or proffer of an application to an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility.
8396.(a)An electric utility shall adopt, publish, and make easily accessible to the public, including an applicant, all rules, requirements, and standards applicable to applications submitted to the electric utility. An application shall not be subject to any rule, requirement, or standard that has not been published and made easily accessible to the public 12 months before the date of the applications submittal to an electric utility for review.
(b)(1)(A)(i)An electric utility shall approve or deny a complete application within 45 60 days of the date of the applications submittal, submittal for applications for installation on existing infrastructure, and within 90 days of the date of the applications submittal for all other applications, consistent with subdivision (d). An application that is not approved or denied within that time period shall be deemed approved as a matter of law. If the application includes requests to attach to over 300 pieces of infrastructure, the electric utility shall have 15 additional days to respond for existing infrastructure and 30 additional days for new infrastructure.
(ii)If an applicant has outstanding corrective orders from the electric utility involving safety violations, the electric utility shall provide written notice to the applicant upon the submittal of subsequent applications by the applicant, and request the applicant propose a plan for complying with the corrective orders within a designated time period. If the applicant is limited in its ability to process the corrective orders within the designated time period, the electric utility shall work with the applicant to reach a modified timeline, pursuant to subparagraph (C), for the electric utility to process subsequent applications.
(B)A colocation or siting application for a wireless telecommunications facility, as defined in Section 65850.6 of the Government Code, shall be deemed approved if all of the following occur:
(i)The electric utility fails to approve or disapprove the application within a reasonable period of time in accordance with the time periods and procedures established in subparagraph (A). The reasonable period of time may be tolled to accommodate timely requests for information required to complete the application.
(ii)The applicant has provided all public notices regarding the application that the applicant is required to provide under applicable laws consistent with the public notice requirements for the application.
(iii)The applicant has provided notice to the electric utility that the reasonable time period has lapsed and that the application is deemed approved pursuant to this section.
(iv)Within 30 days of being provided the notice described in clause (iii), the electric utility may seek judicial review of the operation of this section on the application.
(B)(C)All timelines established by this section, including in subparagraph (A), may be extended or otherwise modified upon written, mutual agreement of the electric utility and the applicant.
(2)If an application is denied, the denial shall be in writing and include the reason for the denial and how the application could be revised in order to be subsequently approved.
(c)(1)If an application is approved, within 14 30 days of that approval, the electric utility shall provide the applicant with a cost estimate, if applicable, based on actual cost, for any necessary work required to accommodate the electric power design described in the application. The applicant shall accept or reject the cost estimate within 45 30 days.
(2)Following acceptance of the cost estimate, estimate and receipt of notice of the applicants completion of all required construction, inspections, or other approvals required by the electric utility or other authority, the electric utility shall complete energization to the broadband project location within 30 days of receiving notice of the applicants completion of all required construction, inspections, or other approvals required by the electric utility or other authority. a time period determined by the commission in Rulemaking 24-01-018 (January 30, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking to Establish Energization Timelines, or a subsequent rulemaking.
(d)(1)If an electric utility cannot approve or deny an application within the timeframe established in subdivision (b) because the application is incomplete, the electric utility shall provide written notice to the applicant that the application is incomplete within 10 days of the applications submittal. incomplete. An applicant shall have 30 days from the date of the written notice of incompleteness to correct and resubmit the application. The resubmitted application shall not be subject to any additional application or processing fees. If the applicant does not submit a corrected application within 30 days from the date of the written notice of incompleteness, the application shall be canceled.
(2)A written notice of incompleteness shall specify every item and any information missing from the application and shall cite the specific published rule, requirement, or standard that states that the missing item or information is required to make the application complete.
(3)If an electric utility deems an application incomplete and complies with the requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2), the time period specified in subdivision (b) shall be tolled beginning on the date the electric utility issues the written notice of incompleteness.
(4)On the date of an applicants submittal of the requested supplemental item or information described in the written notice of incompleteness, the time period specified in subdivision (b) shall resume.
(5)If an electric utility does not provide written notice to an applicant that its application is incomplete within the 10-day period established in paragraph (1), the time period for approving or denying the application shall not be tolled.(6)(5)Upon submittal of a corrected application, the electric utility may issue subsequent written notices of incompleteness if the application remains incomplete. Subsequent notices shall identify which of the previously requested items or information remain missing from the application. A subsequent written notice of incompleteness shall not include new items or information outside the scope of the original written notice of incompleteness.
(e)If an electric utility is unable to process a complete application within the applicable time period pursuant to subdivision (b), the electric utility shall provide written notice to the applicant upon the applications submittal and propose a plan for complying with the applicable time period. If the electric utility is limited in its ability to process an application because of its limited resources, the electric utility shall work with the applicant, in good faith, to resolve the resource limitations, which may include, but is not limited to, the applicants provision of supplemental resources.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act or because costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Application means a written request, application, or other document submitted by a broadband provider to an electrical corporation or local publicly owned electric utility for approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project.
(b)Broadband project means a proposed broadband facility, including the support structure and any supporting equipment necessary for operation of the proposed broadband facility. A broadband project may comprise one or more components, including, but not limited to, a wireless facility, a fiber optic connection, and other supporting equipment, each of which may require a separate permit or authorization.
(c)Days means calendar days.
(d)Electric utility means an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility.
(e)Electrical corporation has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 218.
(f)Local publicly owned electric utility has the same meaning as that term is defined in Section 224.3.
(g)Submittal means the delivery or proffer of an application to an electrical corporation or a local publicly owned electric utility.
8396.(a)An electric utility shall adopt, publish, and make easily accessible to the public, including an applicant, all rules, requirements, and standards applicable to applications submitted to the electric utility. An application shall not be subject to any rule, requirement, or standard that has not been published and made easily accessible to the public 12 months before the date of the applications submittal to an electric utility for review.
(b)(1)(A)An electric utility shall approve or deny a complete application within 45 days of the date of the applications submittal, consistent with subdivision (d). An application that is not approved or denied within that time period shall be deemed approved as a matter of law.
(B)All timelines established by this section, including in subparagraph (A), may be extended or otherwise modified upon written, mutual agreement of the electric utility and the applicant.
(2)If an application is denied, the denial shall be in writing and include the reason for the denial and how the application could be revised in order to be subsequently approved.
(c)(1)If an application is approved, within 14 days of that approval, the electric utility shall provide the applicant with a cost estimate, if applicable, based on actual cost, for any necessary work required to accommodate the electric power design described in the application. The applicant shall accept or reject the cost estimate within 45 days.
(2)Following acceptance of the cost estimate, the electric utility shall complete energization to the broadband project location within 30 days of receiving notice of the applicants completion of all required construction, inspections, or other approvals required by the electric utility or other authority.
(d)(1)If an electric utility cannot approve or deny an application within the timeframe established in subdivision (b) because the application is incomplete, the electric utility shall provide written notice to the applicant that the application is incomplete within 10 days of the applications submittal. An applicant shall have 30 days from the date of the written notice of incompleteness to correct and resubmit the application. The resubmitted application shall not be subject to any additional application or processing fees. If the applicant does not submit a corrected application within 30 days from the date of the written notice of incompleteness, the application shall be canceled.
(2)A written notice of incompleteness shall specify every item and any information missing from the application and shall cite the specific published rule, requirement, or standard that states that the missing item or information is required to make the application complete.
(3)If an electric utility deems an application incomplete and complies with the requirements of paragraphs (1) and (2), the time period specified in subdivision (b) shall be tolled beginning on the date the electric utility issues the written notice of incompleteness.
(4)On the date of an applicants submittal of the requested supplemental item or information described in the written notice of incompleteness, the time period specified in subdivision (b) shall resume.
(5)If an electric utility does not provide written notice to an applicant that its application is incomplete within the 10-day period established in paragraph (1), the time period for approving or denying the application shall not be tolled.
(6)Upon submittal of a corrected application, the electric utility may issue subsequent written notices of incompleteness if the application remains incomplete. Subsequent notices shall identify which of the previously requested items or information remain missing from the application. A subsequent written notice of incompleteness shall not include new items or information outside the scope of the original written notice of incompleteness.
(e)If an electric utility is unable to process a complete application within the applicable time period pursuant to subdivision (b), the electric utility shall provide written notice to the applicant upon the applications submittal and propose a plan for complying with the applicable time period. If the electric utility is limited in its ability to process an application because of its limited resources, the electric utility shall work with the applicant, in good faith, to resolve the resource limitations, which may include, but is not limited to, the applicants provision of supplemental resources.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act or because costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Section 912.2 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:912.2.On or before April 1, 2023, and biennially thereafter, the commission shall conduct a fiscal and performance audit of the implementation and effectiveness of the California Advanced Services Fund to ensure that funds have been expended in accordance with the approved terms of the grant awards and loan agreements pursuant to Section 281 or 281.2 and shall report its findings to the Legislature. The reports shall include an update to the maps in the final report of the California Broadband Task Force and data on the types and numbers of jobs created as a result of the program administered by the commission pursuant to Section 281 or 281.2 and shall include the information specified in Section 914.7.On or before April 1, 2023, and biennially thereafter, the commission shall conduct a fiscal and performance audit of the implementation and effectiveness of the California Advanced Services Fund to ensure that funds have been expended in accordance with the approved terms of the grant awards and loan agreements pursuant to Section 281 or 281.2 and shall report its findings to the Legislature. The reports shall include an update to the maps in the final report of the California Broadband Task Force and data on the types and numbers of jobs created as a result of the program administered by the commission pursuant to Section 281 or 281.2 and shall include the information specified in Section 914.7.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on C. & C. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (April 17). |
| Apr 18, 2024 | (Pending re-refer to Com. on C. & C.) |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on U. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on U. & E. and C. & C. |
| Feb 8, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 7, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Communications and Conveyance] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Burbank/Burbank Redevelopment Agency, City Of | ** Against | |
| CalBroadband | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Communications Association | ** Support | |
| California Municipal Utilities Association | ** Against | |
| California Retailers Association | ** Support | |
| California Special Districts Association | ** Against | |
| California Wireless Association | ** Support | |
| City of Rancho Cucamonga | ** Against | |
| City of Shasta Lake | ** Against | |
| Coalition of California Utility Employees | ** Against | |
| Crown Castle | ** Support | |
| CTIA | ** Support | |
| Edison International And Affiliates, Including Southern California Edison | ** Against | |
| Environmental Defense Action Fund | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation | ** Support | |
| Pacific Gas And Electric Company | ** Against | |
| Pasadena Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Pasadena Chamber of Commerce and Civic Association | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| San Diego Gas & Electric | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| San Mateo County Economic Development Association | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Leadership Group | ** Support | |
| Southern California Edison | ** Against | |
| Southern California Public Power Authority | ** Against | |
| United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom The Broadband Association | ** Support | |
| wireless infrastructure association | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2221
Author:(Juan Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2024
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
Communications and Conveyance | 10 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes timeframes and procedures that govern an electric utility’s consideration of an application by a broadband provider for approval of an electrical power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project (application), such as a wireless facility, a fiber optic connection and other supporting equipment.
Specifically, this bill, among other things:
- Requires an electrical utility—meaning an electrical utility (also known as an investor-owned electrical utility, or an IOU) or a publicly owned electric utility (POU)—to publish all rules governing applications and provides an application is not subject to any rule not published before the date of the application.
- Provides timeframes within which an electrical utility is to approve or deny a complete application, generally being 60 days from the date of submittal for installation on existing infrastructure and 90 days from the date of submittal for all other applications. Requires an electric utility to provide written notice to an applicant that has outstanding corrective orders and request the applicant propose a plan to comply with the corrective orders.
- When an electrical utility denies an application, requires the denial be in writing and include reasons for the denial.
- When an electrical utility approves an application, requires the electrical utility to provide the applicant with a cost estimate for any necessary work required to accommodate the electric power design, and provides the applicant 30 days to accept or reject the cost estimate.
- Following acceptance of the cost estimate described above and receipt of notice of the applicant’s completion of all required construction, inspections or other approvals, provides the electrical utility is to complete energization to the broadband project location with a time period determined by California Public Utility Commission (CPUC) Rulemaking 24-01-018 (January 30, 2024), Order Instituting Rulemaking to Establish Energization Timelines, or a subsequent rulemaking.
- Deems an application approved if the electric utility fails to approve or disapprove an application within a reasonable period of time, consistent with the timeframes established by the bill, and the applicant has taken certain actions, including having notified the electrical utility that the reasonable timeframe has lapsed, and allows the electrical utility to seek judicial review within 30 days of such notice.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill requires an IOU to complete energization of a project according to applicable rules of the CPUC. In and of itself, this requirement does not create costs for the CPUC. However, the CPUC anticipates, as a result of this bill, needing additional resources to enforce IOU compliance with its energization requirements, nonetheless. This is because the CPUC assumes it will receive a very large volume of such complaints as (1) the state distributes hundreds of millions in federal dollars to fund buildout of broadband infrastructure and (2) the IOUs hire and train staff to comply with the CPUC timelines.
In addition, it is reasonable to expect the IOUs to not readily comply with the CPUC energization timelines and, rather, seek remedy at the CPUC. This is because the bill “deems approved” an application the IOU fails to approve or disapprove within a reasonable period of time, as the bill defines that term. Representatives of the IOUs and of the electrical workers employed by the IOUs have described energization of an unexamined facility unsafe, and it seems likely neither the IOUs nor their workers will energize such a facility, regardless of the requirements of the law. The predictable result of such noncompliance is an increase of complaints to the CPUC.
It is difficult to estimate the amount of resources the CPUC will need following enactment of this bill. However, given the amount of federal monies flowing to the state for broadband infrastructure deployment, and the contentiousness of this bill’s requirements, it seems reasonable to assume the CPUC will need resources well in excess of $150,000 in any given year.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author intends this bill to speed up the deployment of broadband infrastructure. According to the author:
Billions in public and private funding for broadband projects are trying to be built as fast as possible in 2024, 2025 & 2026 to help close the digital divide. $6 billion in federal broadband dollars need to be allocated by the end of 2024 and projects need to be built by the end of 2026 or we risk sending money back to D.C. The legislature has enacted laws in recent years ensuring that local governments streamline broadband deployment and process broadband permits within 60-90 days. Electric utilities don’t have any required timeframes for broadband application timelines and typically take between 7-12 months to process the initial power design application then another 7-12 months to connect power to the broadband project. California won’t be able to meet its Broadband for All objectives unless legislation is passed creating a consistent and transparent process for public and private utilities to follow when processing broadband project applications. AB 2221 creates reasonable procedures and timelines for both utilities and applicants to follow so broadband applications can be handled efficiently in a reasonable amount of time.
- Background. The CPUC regulates the rates and service provided by IOUs. POUs, in contrast, are municipal entities that are generally not subject to CPUC regulation. Both IOUs and POUs, however, are subject to the requirements of state law. And state law makes timelines by which a local government must decide upon a request to permit certain broadband projects.
Energization refers to physically interconnecting a facility to the electrical grid. Electrical utilities—IOUs and POUs—are responsible for considering applications for energization and for providing a connection to the grid. Recently, backlogs for utilities to fulfill requests for energization have grown. The utilities and CPUC have responded by forming committees to work on the interconnection process. The Legislature, however, last year, directed the CPUC to establish criteria for timely energization, applicable to the IOUs, by January 1, 2025. The CPUC is undertaking this rulemaking and expects to issue a decision later this year.
This bill would create timelines specific to requests to energize broadband facilities. According to bill supporters—mainly industry associations and private companies—this is appropriate because connection to the internet is vital to all Californians and, with billions in federal dollars supporting broadband deployment, delays in utility approval of energization requests unreasonably denies Californians this critical benefit.
Opponents disagree. Electric utilities—public and private—argue that the bill’s requirement that a broadband energization request be automatically approve jeopardizes grid reliability and worker and public safety. The Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) supports rapid deployment of critical infrastructure, including broadband infrastructure; however, EDF opposes this bill nonetheless. As EDF summarizes:
EDF appreciates the challenges slow energization presents to communities and households, and for that reason we support efforts to speed up this process for all projects, not only a select few. Unfortunately, AB 2221 would only benefit one category of projects at the expense of all the rest, and so we must oppose this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Tasha Boerner, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2221 (
Author:Juan Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2024
SUBJECT: Broadband projects: electric power design approval
SUMMARY: Establishes timelines for an electric utility, as defined, to approve or deny a complete application, as defined, for a broadband project. This bill provides that a colocation or siting application for a wireless telecommunications facility are deemed approved under specified circumstances. Additionally, this bill establishes other requirements and procedures on an electric utility and applicants regarding the submittal and review of applications for broadband projects.
Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes definitions:
- “Application” means a written request, application, or other document submitted by a broadband provider to an electrical corporation or local publicly owned electric utility for approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project.
- “Electric utility” includes both an electrical corporation and a local publicly owned electric utility.
- Requires an electric utility to adopt and make publicly available all rules, requirements, and standards applicable to applications submitted to the electric utility. Exempts applications from any rule, requirement or standard that was not published and made publicly available before the date of submission of the application.
- Requires an electric utility to approve or deny a complete application within 60 days or 90 days, depending on whether application is for installation on existing infrastructure. This bill includes limited exemptions to this requirement for projects that propose to attach to over 300 pieces of infrastructure or for applicants with outstanding safety violations.
- Authorizes any timeline established by this bill to be extended upon mutual agreement of the electric utility and the applicant.
- Provides that a colocation or siting application for a wireless telecommunications facility shall be deemed approved only if certain conditions are met. The conditions include that the electric utility did not approve or disapprove the application within the periods of time established in this bill, taking into account tolling of the timeline to accommodate reasonable requests for information required to complete the application; and that the applicant has provided notice to the electric utility that the application is deemed approved.
- Specifies that after a cost estimate has been provided to the applicant within 30 days and accepted, the electric utility shall complete energization to the broadband project location within a time period determined by the California Public Utilities Commission.
- Requires an electric utility to notify an applicant if the application is incomplete, specifying every item and information missing from the application. This bill establishes the obligation of an applicant to resubmit the application within 30 days, and authorizes the electric utility to issue subsequent notices of incompleteness.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires local publicly owned electric utilities (POUs) to make ready infrastructure for use by a broadband service provider within 45 days of the date of receipt of the request, or 60 days if the request is to attach to more than 300 utility poles. Also requires POUs to provide a cost estimate within 14 days of a request’s approval. (Public Utilities Code § 9511)
- Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to determine criteria for timely service for electric customers by January 1, 2025 that shall include timely start of service for new connections, timely fulfillment of requests for increased load, and reenergization of customers following a power outage. (Public Utilities Code § 933.5)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for electric distribution line extensions necessary to finish permanent electric service. (Electric Rule 15)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for the extension of electric service from an investor-owned utility (IOU) distribution line (Electric Rule 16)
- Requires cities and counties to process broadband projects within a reasonable period of time in accordance with the time periods and procedures established by applicable Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rules. (Government Code § 65964.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “Billions in public and private funding for broadband projects are trying to be built as fast as possible in 2024, 2025 & 2026 to help close the digital divide. $6 billion in federal broadband dollars need to be allocated by the end of 2024 and projects need to be built by the end of 2026 or we risk sending money back to D.C. The legislature has enacted laws in recent years ensuring that local governments streamline broadband deployment and process broadband permits within 60-90 days. Electric utilities don’t have any required timeframes for broadband application timelines and typically take between 7-12 months to process the initial power design application then another 7-12 months to connect power to the broadband project. California won’t be able to meet its Broadband for All objectives unless legislation is passed creating a consistent and transparent process for public and private utilities to follow when processing broadband project applications. AB 2221 creates reasonable procedures and timelines for both utilities and applicants to follow so broadband applications can be handled efficiently in a reasonable amount of time.”
- Is federal funding at risk? In recent years the federal government, through the states, has invested billions of dollars into broadband infrastructure programs. In 2021, pursuant to SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review. Chapter 112, Statutes of 2021) the Legislature invested $6 billion dollars into broadband infrastructure projects and programs. This pot of money was a mix of federal pandemic relief funds and state general funds. Specifically, SB 156 appropriated $2 billion dollars to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) over a 3 year period, of which only a portion[1] was federal funds. Pursuant to SB 156, those funds must be spent corresponding with federal rules and requirements. For example, federal guidelines applicable to those funds require them to be encumbered by December 31, 2024 and spent down by December 31, 2026. In addition to SB 156, California will in the near future receive an additional $1.86 billion from the federal government through the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) Program. Those funds will also be administered by the California Public Utilities Commission, under the authority and supervision of the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA). The NTIA will establish its own timelines for awarding the funds to project, which is expected to be a one year process.
In summary, there will be pressure in the state in the coming years to fully permit, construct, and make operational new broadband infrastructure within federal timelines. Awarding such a large sum of funding will be a huge undertaking on its own, and unfortunately the CPUC has been over 18 months delayed in awarding funds. Under current estimates, the first projects from SB 156 will not be awarded funding until June 2024. In turn, entities that are awarded the funding will be under pressure to permit and construct their projects before 2026. If they do not meet those deadlines, the federal funding that is supporting those projects may have to be returned to the federal government. Given this potential risk, by placing timelines on electric utilities to complete electrical design review and energize broadband projects that might be funded by those federal funds, this bill may help alleviate some of that pressure for the broadband projects covered by this bill.
A final point on federal funds, it is worth noting that broadband projects are not the only infrastructure projects being funded with federal funds that may also have a need for expedited electrical permitting. For example, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) will also fund a slew of other electric projects such as vehicle chargers and energy efficiency projects for homes, and those projects may also benefit from expedited treatment to meet federal deadlines. While this bill does not intend to include all types of projects, from a statewide policy perspective it is worth pondering whether a more comprehensive strategy would also be reasonable.
- What “applications” are covered by this bill? This bill establishes a narrow definition for the term “application” that specifically pertains to approval of an electric power design related to the construction and operation of a broadband project. Notably, electric power design is not the only phase of a broadband project lifecycle and it is not the only phase of a project lifecycle that requires coordination between an electric utility and project applicant. To complicate matters further, each step in the application process is not necessarily a separate formal filing from the applicant to the electric utility. Nonetheless, thinking of a project lifecycle is useful for understanding how this bill is intended to apply to different segments of a project lifecycle. Generally speaking, the phases of a project can be broken-up into distinct steps as follows:
- Application Submittal: A broadband provider [“applicant”] prepares to submit a request for approval, which could include fees, construction drawings, pole loading calculations, and other documents per the utility’s submittal requirements. If one or more of those elements is missing from the application package, the utility responds to the applicant informing them that a document is missing and must be submitted prior to the next step in the utility power process. Provisions of this bill would apply to this phase.
- Design Review Phase: A utility engineer reviews the application to confirm that the utility can deliver power to the proposed site consistent with the utility’s published standards. If the utility engineer determines that the application does not meet the utility standards and the utility cannot deliver power as proposed by the applicant, the application may be rejected and sent back to the applicant for revision and resubmittal. Sometimes resubmittal of a corrected application may result in additional issues arising, which reflects the complex and dynamic nature of a design review process. Provisions of this bill would apply to this phase.
- Utility Cost Estimate: If the utility approves the application, and, if the utility must perform activities to deliver power to the applicant, a cost estimate is prepared by the utility and sent to the applicant. The applicant reviews and approves the cost estimate, then informs the utility to proceed with the project. Existing law and regulations govern this process.
- Construction Phase: Upon approval of the power application, the applicant performs applicable construction activities on its side of the utility meter/demarcation point. The applicant’s construction activities may be subject to other jurisdictional approvals, for example if the project is being constructed on a city owned pole instead of a utility owned pole. In that case, the utility or local jurisdiction may also be required to perform construction activities [“make ready work”] to deliver power to the applicant’s location, such as pole replacements, power line extensions, transformer additions, etc. Existing law and regulations govern this process.
- Power Delivery/Energization: Upon completion of construction activities by the applicant and utility, as necessary, the applicant must obtain inspections from either the utility and/or a jurisdiction prior to requesting energization from the utility. Existing law and forthcoming regulations govern this process.
Proponents of this bill have specifically raised concerns about Steps I and II, claiming that the electrical design review process could take months because existing timelines for other steps don’t necessarily apply to those steps. Additionally, proponents have raised their concerns to staff noting that there is sometimes a lack of clarity around whether an application is complete. In response, electric utilities have noted that because electric design review has significant safety and therefore legal liability implications, sometimes applications may take multiple steps of revisions before approved. Further, the utilities have claimed that sometimes the applicants are responsible for delays because of missing or incomplete information.
- How this bill fits into the complex landscape of project permitting. The aim of this bill is to establish timelines for the electrical design review process for a broadband project conducted by an electrical utility. While electric utilities, both public and private, may already have timelines applicable to them for certain steps in a project lifecycle, as discussed above, those rules do not apply to portions of the process targeted by this bill. To put this bill in context, it is worth reviewing how this bill fits into the landscape of the laws and regulations applicable to different stages in permitting and constructing a project.
In September 2018 the Federal Communication Commission adopted an order[2] (“FCC Small Cell Order”) in a proceeding focused on streamlining the rollout of infrastructure for broadband services, specifically small cell wireless. The order summarily had two parts: the first was a new set of regulations that govern “shot-clocks” and other aspects of the rollout of small cells; the second part of the order was regarding the fees governments may charge to provide access to local government infrastructure, such as street light poles. The order established several shot-clocks, or permit review time frames, by which local governments should respond to applications to install small cells on public property. In summary, the FCC shot-clocks gave local governments 60-days to act on applications to collocate small cells on existing sites or 90-days for applications to construct new small cell facilities. The order also provided for the resetting or pausing of the shot clock when a local government determines that an application is incomplete.
For application and use fees, the FCC did not place a specific cap on fees, however, the FCC did make other notable determinations in this space. For example, the FCC provided a “safe-harbor” rate[3], or a rate that is presumed to be reasonable for local governments to use. The Public Utilities Code[4] also establishes requirements for fees charged by a publicly owned electric utility (POU) for attachments by communications service providers. Notably, this bill would require an applicant to respond to a cost estimate within 30 days.
Following the decisions by the FCC, in 2021 California adopted AB 537 (Quirk) Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021 which updated state statute to reflect the FCC’s small cell order. That bill included a deemed approved standard as a remedy, however it specifically was about the siting and construction phase. More recently, two bills address the energization phase of a project lifecycle. Two bills last year, SB 410 (Becker) and AB50 (Wood), passed and directed the CPUC to establish timelines for the energization process. While neither bill specifically adopted timelines for reviewing applications, the bills punted the decision to the CPUC. In that proceeding, the CPUC will consider to the energization needs of various industries and weigh the factors that impact an electric utility’s ability to provide safe and reliable service, as well as aspects of the energization process that may outside their control. Given the existence of this process, some have argued that this bill is not necessary.
In between the varied perspectives on a complex set of laws and regulations, what seems to be clear is that this bill is attempting to legislate a particular stage in a process for which there has not previously been standards applied. By establishing timelines for the electrical design review process, this bill may help expedite the entire project lifecycle by building off previous efforts in other bills and regulatory decisions. On the other hand, prioritizing safety is of course a paramount goal of public policy that has been carefully weighed in previous bills, especially regarding the electric utility sector. For that reason, and in the interest of finding balance between safety and timeliness, it is worth being thoughtful about whether this bill provides sufficient time for a design review and whether a deemed approved standard is the most appropriate remedy when a utility fails to meet their obligations. There are certainly other alternatives to deemed approved, such as meeting and conferring, which this bill does lay out a process for.
- Overview of recent amendments. Significant amendments were agreed to and adopted in the Assembly Utilities & Energy (U&E) Committee. The following is a summary of the amendments, which are reflected in the current version of this bill:
- Aligns application review period for power design approval to AB 537: 60 days for installation on existing infrastructure, 90 days for all others. Aligns additional time provided to applications requesting attachment to over 300 pieces of infrastructure: 15 days for installation on existing infrastructure, 30 days for all others. The amendments also provided some exemptions and qualifications as follows:
- If a broadband provider has outstanding safety violations, requires broadband applicants to provide a plan to address those violations, and allows mutually agreed upon modification of timelines for new applications if broadband applicants are limited in ability to address those timely.
- Removes 10 day shot clock for notification of incompleteness
- Limits deemed-approved to colocation or siting applications, but provides utilities recourse if the timeline is not sufficient, including public notice and judicial review.
- Removes fee waivers for resubmission by broadband providers.
- Give utilities and broadband providers the same amount of time, 30 days, to provide and accept a cost estimate, respectively.
- Aligns shot clocks for the energization step to the forthcoming timeline that the CPUC will establish in their existing rulemaking (R. 24-01-018).
- Strikes a provision of the bill specifying that applications are only subject to rules published 12 months prior to their submission.
The U&E committee amendments significantly altered the previous procedures in this bill in the interest of balancing timeliness with safety and the reality that design review can be an iterative, not linear, process. These changes to this bill were necessary and reasonable. Nonetheless, in the interest of providing greater clarity to the intent of those amendments, staff suggests the author continue to work with both committees to consider revisions that may provide more clarity to the language.
- Similar/related legislation.
- AB 965 (Carrillo) requires local governments to utilize batch broadband permit processing. Status: Chapter 553, Statutes of 2023.
- AB 50 (Wood) requires the CPUC to determine the criteria for customers to receive timely electricity service when requesting new service connections or upgraded service. Also proposes several policies to address delays in connecting customers to the electrical grid, including improved information sharing with local governments and reporting by IOUs. Status: Chapter 317, Statutes of 2023.
- SB 410 (Becker) establishes targets by which electrical utilities are to energize and authorizes such a utility to annually recover the costs of energization from its ratepayers. Status: Chapter 394, Statutes of 2023.
- AB 537 (Quirk) updates existing law establishing a timeline and process through which broadband applications will be deemed approved. Status: Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021.
- SB 378 (Gonzalez) prohibits local governments from denying microtrenching projects for fiber installation. Status: Chapter 677, Statutes of 2021.
- AB 1027 (Buchanan) requires local publicly owned electric utilities to make accommodations on their utility poles or support structures for communications service providers, pursuant to reasonable terms and conditions. Establishes timelines for local publicly owned electric utilities to respond to such requests. Status: Chapter 580, Statutes of 2011.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Calbroadband
California Apartment Association
California Communications Association
California Retailers Association
California Wireless Association
Crown Castle
CTIA
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED)
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZFED)
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce and Civic Association
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Mateo County Economic Development Association (SAMCEDA)
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom - the Broadband Association
Wireless Infrastructure Association
Opposition
Burbank/Burbank Redevelopment Agency; City of
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
California Special Districts Association
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Edison International and Affiliates, Including Southern California Edison
Environmental Defense Action Fund
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
San Diego Gas & Electric
Southern California Edison
Analysis Prepared by: Emilio Perez C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
The specific breakdown of federal and state general funds has shifted since the signing of SB 156. As of the 2023-2024 budget year, of the $2 billion dollars appropriated to the CPUC, only $550 million consists of federal funds with the rest being general fund. ↑
2018 FCC Small Cell Order. https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/FCC-18-133A1.pdf ↑
The safe harbor amounts are: (a) $500 for a single up-front application that includes up to five small cell wireless facilities, with an additional $100 for each small cell beyond five, (b) $270 per small cell facility per year for all recurring fees, including any possible right-of-way (ROW) access fee or fee for attachment to municipally-owned structures in the ROW, and (c) $1,000 for non-recurring fees for a new pole. ↑
Public Utilities Code §9512 ↑
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Cottie Petrie-Norris, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2221 (
Author:Juan Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUBJECT: Broadband projects: electric power design approval
SUMMARY: Establishes timelines for electric utilities, private and public, to approve and energize a broadband project, and grants the broadband project automatic approval should the utility not take action within the timeline. Requires electric utilities to publish all rules and standards necessitated in project applications, and to only subject applications to those rules and standards that were published 12 months before the date of the application’s submission to an electric utility for review.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires electric utilities make easily accessible to the public all rules, requirements, and standards for broadband project applications submitted to the electric utility. Prohibits an application from being subject to any standard that had not been published 12 months before its date of submission.
- Establishes timelines for electric utilities to review and energize broadband projects. Allows timelines to be extended or otherwise modified upon written, mutual agreement of the electric utility and the broadband provider. The timelines include:
- Issuing a written notice of incompleteness, which shall specify every item and any information missing from the application, within 10 days from the application’s date of submittal, if needed.
- Approval or denial of a complete application within 45 days of receiving the application. If a notice of incompleteness is provided to the applicant within the first 10 days, the countdown would pause and resume when the applicant resubmits.
- A cost estimate for any utility work necessary to accommodate the broadband project within 14 days of the approval.
- Energization within 30 days of receiving notice of the applicant’s completion of all required work for the broadband project.
- Establishes timelines for broadband providers to respond to electric utilities. The timelines include:
- Resubmission of an application deemed incomplete within 30 days of the notice, otherwise the application will be canceled.
- Acceptance or rejection of the utility’s cost estimate within 45 days from when it is provided.
- Specifies that if an electric utility does not approve or deny within the 45-day period, the application shall be automatically deemed approved.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires local publicly owned electric utilities (POUs) to make ready infrastructure for use by a broadband service provider within 45 days of the date of receipt of the request, or 60 days if the request is to attach to more than 300 utility poles. Also requires POUs to provide a cost estimate within 14 days of a request’s approval. (Public Utilities Code § 9511)
- Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to determine criteria for timely service for electric customers by January 1, 2025 that shall include timely start of service for new connections, timely fulfillment of requests for increased load, and reenergization of customers following a power outage. (Public Utilities Code § 933.5)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for electric distribution line extensions necessary to finish permanent electric service. (Electric Rule 15)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for the extension of electric service from an investor-owned utility (IOU) distribution line (Electric Rule 16)
- Requires cities and counties to process broadband projects within a reasonable period of time in accordance with the time periods and procedures established by applicable Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rules. (Government Code § 65964.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal and will be referred to the Committee on Appropriations for its review.
BACKGROUND:
Broadband for All – California has been focused on providing universal access to broadband since at least 2007, when the state established the California Advanced Services Fund to incentivize broadband providers to build out projects to unserved and underserved areas. In 2021, the state redoubled its efforts to close the digital divide by enacting SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2021), which committed $6 billion to build out broadband infrastructure. The $6 billion was appropriated from both the state’s general fund and from the federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA).[1] The federal funds presently left over are available for allocation until 2024 and for encumbrance and liquidation until the end of 2026. The CPUC is expected to make grant awards, prioritizing the nearly $600 million left in federal funds, as seen in Table 1, by the end of June 2024.[2] Meanwhile, the state has allocated more to the General Fund in support of Broadband for All since 2021, and has extended deadlines for the allocation and encumbrance of these funds. Utilizing the federal dollars before the 2026 deadline has given many in the broadband space a sense of urgency, and resulted in vocal concerns when any project delay arises.
Table 1. Broadband Infrastructure Spending Plan as of the 2023-24 Budget Act (in Millions)2
Connecting Broadband – The newest generation of mobile networks being deployed by broadband providers today, 5G, offers higher speeds and connectivity than its predecessors.[3] The rollout of 5G relies on “small cell” technology, which are installed on existing infrastructure – typically utility poles – rather than needing large cellular towers to be built. Simplified, there are 3 main steps to getting a small cell up and running:
- Power design – this is the engineering blueprint in which broadband providers lay out the details of a project, including, among a host of others, construction drawings and pole loadbearing (weight and electrical capacity) calculations;
- Attachment to utility infrastructure;
- Energization – this is the act of physically connecting the equipment to the grid and powering the equipment.
In 2011, the Legislature passed AB 1027 (Buchanan, Chapter 580, Statutes of 2011), establishing timelines for POUs to make infrastructure ready for Step 2. However, some small cell technologies, such as small cell radios on a city street lamp,[4] may not need utilities for Steps 2 or 3. Other small cell technologies may need Steps 1 and 3, but not Step 2. Since “shot clocks” that set specified time limits have only been statutorily mandated for Step 2, broadband providers have voiced concern over delays that may occur with regards to Steps 1 and 3.
Moreover, these steps and timelines can vary greatly depending on utility territory, system upgrades necessitated by the project application, or events outside the utilities’ control such as supply chain delays, weather, or pending customer application information or permit completion, among others. Projects can take anywhere from a month to years depending on these various factors. As shown in Figure 1, there are many steps – and thus many opportunities for delay – in the customer energization lifecycle.
Figure 1: Customer Project Lifecycle (for complex projects)[5]
Timelines for electric lines – The demands for new service connections and/or upgrades to existing distribution lines have been increasing, especially as California advances policies to deploy more infrastructure to charge electric vehicles, shift from natural gas to electricity in buildings, and increase the housing supply.[6] These projects, alongside broadband, all rely on access to the electrical grid and often require upgrades to the distribution system. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has created supply shortages and challenges affecting many sectors of the economy, including limiting access to electrical equipment, such as transformers, needed to connect new customers or expand energy load.[7] Taken together, electric utilities currently face a big backlog of energization projects. While utilities have taken internal steps to attempt to better manage their project queue, the Legislature passed a pair of bills last year, AB 50 (Wood, Chapter 317, Statutes of 2023) and SB 410 (Becker, Chapter 394, Statutes of 2023), requiring the CPUC to step in and create criteria for timely energization by January 1, 2025. The CPUC opened a rulemaking (R. 24-01-018) in January 2024 to solicit public comment and host workshop discussions of energization timeline issues, and is expected to release a decision in September 2024.
The FCC’s 2018 Wireless Deployment Order – In 2009 and 2014, the FCC adopted orders to lower barriers to wireless facility deployment and reduce permitting delays at the local level. As part of the 2009 and 2014 orders, the FCC established shot clocks on a local government’s review of a wireless facility permit application:
- 60 days for a project that is an “eligible facilities request,” which is defined by the FCC as a collocation on an existing facility that does not substantially change its physical dimensions;
- 90 days for a project that is a collocation that substantially changes the dimensions of the facility, but does not substantially change its size; and
- 150 days for projects that are new sites for wireless facilities.
Following the FCC’s 2014 order, the Legislature passed AB 57 (Quirk, Chapter 685, Statutes of 2015). Amongst other permit streamlining changes, AB 57 codified the above-detailed shot clocks.
In 2018, the FCC updated its wireless deployment orders related to local government permitting. As part of this update, the FCC expanded the types of wireless facilities covered by the FCC’s permit streamlining rules and also shortened the shot clocks for local government permit application reviews. The 2018 order adopted the following shot clocks:
- 60 days for applications for installations on existing infrastructure
- 90 days for all other applications
AB 537 (Quirk, Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021) updated state statute to reflect the more recent FCC rules regarding wireless permit timelines by replacing references to the 2009 and 2014 orders with a reference to the 2018 FCC rules.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “Billions in public and private funding for broadband projects are trying to be built as fast as possible in 2024, 2025 & 2026 to help close the digital divide. $6 billion in federal broadband dollars need to be allocated by the end of 2024 and projects need to be built by the end of 2026 or we risk sending money back to D.C. The legislature has enacted laws in recent years ensuring that local governments streamline broadband deployment and process broadband permits within 60-90 days. Electric utilities don’t have any required timeframes for broadband application timelines and typically take between 7-12 months to process the initial power design application then another 7-12 months to connect power to the broadband project. California won’t be able to meet its Broadband for All objectives unless legislation is passed creating a consistent and transparent process for public and private utilities to follow when processing broadband project applications. AB 2221 creates reasonable procedures and timelines for both utilities and applicants to follow so broadband applications can be handled efficiently in a reasonable amount of time.”
- Front of the line. As alluded to above, utilities receive energization requests for a wide variety of projects. Utilities have reported to this committee that annual completed requests range from around 4,500 to 8,000 depending on how many distinct project types are counted.[8] Yet the utilities report these numbers represent less than a third of projects that are requested, as many energization requests drop out during various stages of the project pipeline. Utilities are required to consider these requests in a “first in, first out” basis, without bias. Since the timelines this bill establishes would only be applicable to broadband projects, this bill would effectively put all broadband projects at the front of the queue. Moreover, the timelines in this bill jump ahead of the CPUC’s energization proceeding, which seeks to establish energization timelines for all project types.
The author motivates the need for broadband-specific shot clocks by noting the 2024 and 2026 deadlines SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2021) obligated to allocate and liquidate, respectively, the $6 billion committed to broadband projects. But similar concerns have been expressed about being unable to meet other state goals in time as a result of electric utility backlog, such as the target for 60% renewable energy resources by 2030 established under SB 100 (de León, Chapter 312, Statutes of 2018). In conversations with the committee, the sponsor has indicated that they have been a party in the CPUC’s rulemaking proceeding to establish energization timelines, suggesting that the venue is open to considering broadband’s specific concerns. Moreover, statute mandates the CPUC must consider “project types that justify unique or extended energization timelines,”[9] by which broadband could make the case for its unique status. As noted by the author, this bill does establish more shot clocks for specific steps in the project application timeline than what is currently required for the CPUC to establish per statute. However, it is unclear how this measure’s timelines would work in concert with those determined by the CPUC, particularly if the CPUC establishes an energization shot clock greater than that enacted in this bill, 30 days. Since the CPUC is actively working towards a decision, the committee recommends amending the specified 30-day energization timeline called for in this bill to instead be tied to the forthcoming timeline that the CPUC will establish in their existing rulemaking (R. 24-01-018).
- Shot clock mismatches. This bill would require electric utilities to provide to an applicant written notice of incompleteness, specifying each and every piece of information missing from the application, within 10 days of the application’s date of submission. Although 45 days for review and approval of broadband project applications by electric utilities would mirror the guidelines the Southern California Joint Pole Committee follows in reviewing joint pole authorizations,[10] electric utilities would effectively have only 10, not 45, days accorded by this bill to review an entire power design application. Given the variable degrees of complexity between projects and the high level of technicality inherent to a power design, it is unclear if the level of “completeness” of an application can be captured without scrutiny of the accuracy in design and calculations that may be involved, leading to skepticism that neither 10 nor 45 days may be enough time for an electric utility to review some applications. Though the bill provides a clause for electric utilities and broadband providers to flex timelines in mutual agreement, it is impossible to predict how often a mutual agreement may be reached. In such cases where a mutual agreement cannot be reached, the electric utilities would have to challenge through litigation, which could siphon resources away from other responsibilities, including the timely processing of the energization queue that this bill seeks to support. Since incompleteness or inaccuracy of an application could be due to the fault of the applicant, the committee recommends striking the provisions requiring utilities to notify applicants of incompleteness within 10 days of submittal and waiving any additional fees for a resubmission.
Additionally, the shot clocks outlined in this bill seem to provide more latitude to broadband providers than afforded to the utilities. Where the utility companies would get 10 days to review and provide a written notice of every item that the broadband companies missed in an application, the broadband companies would get 30 days to fix and resubmit. Where the utility companies are accorded 14 days to provide a cost estimate, the broadband companies are accorded 45 days to approve the cost estimate.
Following FCC guidelines, local governments in California have 60 to 90 day shot clocks to review and approve broadband projects. It is unclear to this committee why local governments received double or triple the amount of time to review broadband applications than what is provided to utilities under this measure. Given these considerations, the committee recommends amending the review timelines for electric utilities to be in alignment with local governments, according 60 days to approve or deny a complete application involving installation on existing infrastructure and 90 days for all other applications. The committee additionally recommends amending the timelines around cost estimation to create parity between applicants and utilities, namely 30 days.
As mentioned above, AB 1037 establishes timelines for POUs to make utility poles ready for a broadband provider. While utilities are granted 45 days from the receipt of a request for most applications, applications requesting attachment to more than 300 poles yield an additional 15 days to utilities, given the greater volume of work. Since AB 1037 provides a distinction between requests to prepare less than 300 utility poles versus more, presumably a request for attachment (i.e. Step 2) would mirror its power design application (i.e. Step 1), indicating that a power design application could also involve more than 300 poles. Since more complications can arise in bigger projects, the committee recommends similarly providing 15 and 30 extra days in the review timelines for applications involving installation on existing infrastructure and for all others, respectively, should the application involve more than 300 sites of attachment.
- Safety first. This bill seeks to create transparency of the rules, requirements, and standards utilities use to evaluate broadband project applications. Rules governing the ability of new projects to connect to the electric distribution grid are generally determined by statute, CPUC rules, and tariffs for each of the IOUs.[11] While POUs are not regulated by the CPUC, they must meet applicable federal, state, and industry standards, and they have in many instances aligned with the rules set forth by the agency, such as on General Order 95,[12] which governs the design, construction, and maintenance of overhead electrical supply and communication facilities. These standards do not stay static. For example, GO 95 was initially promulgated in 1941 and has been updated approximately 60 times since then – most recently in January 2020.[13] Adherence to these standards is critical to ensuring a safe and reliable electric system. Exempting broadband applications from any rules and standards that were not published by the electric utility 12 months prior to its submission – as put forward by this measure – could, in effect, allow a project to circumvent safety requirements. This could have dire consequences for utilities and ratepayers as utilities would be liable for any blackouts, fires, or other disasters that originate from their grid systems.
Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (LADWP) has reported to this committee that out of about 900 installations for 5G small cell site installations since 2019, 754 were incorrectly installed.[14] Non-compliant attachments may increase safety risks for fire and electric shock to the linemen and to the public. LADWP projects to spend 270 hours per week between September 2023 and July 2024 to de-energize poles and allow correction of non-compliant installations. However, the 5G provider, Crown Castle, has noted that these infractions were due to new rules implemented after LADWP had already inspected and energized the projects. They refute that their applications were incorrect, or that safety was compromised. These disparate accounts show how communication between applicant and utility is critical in ensuring correct and safe installations, especially in circumstances involving a rule change. Regardless, all seem to agree that safety and reliability standards are updated to the benefit of worker and public safety, and should be implemented as expediently as possible. As such, the committee recommends striking the provision exempting broadband project applications from any rules, requirements, or standards that had not been published 12 months prior to the date of its submission.
This bill also proposes to remedy any instances where electric utilities do not approve or deny a permit design application within 45 days by automatically “deeming approved” those applications. The author notes that the Legislature passed a similar remedy, AB 537, for broadband applications undergoing local government review. However, this “deemed approved” clause only narrowly applies to collocation or siting applications and if the following conditions are met:
- The city or county fails to approve or disapprove the application within the reasonable time periods in the FCC rules;
- All required public notices have been provided regarding application; and
- The applicant has provided a notice to the city or county that the reasonable time period has lapsed.
A local government is also allowed to challenge the operation of the applicant’s notice to the local government that the reasonable time period has lapsed and the application is deemed approved. This bill does not grant these guardrails to electric utilities, instead providing a blanket “deemed approved” for all power design applications when the shot clock winds down. Although the sponsor has claimed, in conversations with the committee, that local government applications are broader in scope and therefore more difficult to review, it is unclear to this committee if it is reasonable to assume that electric utility applications are indeed less demanding. As mentioned previously, the complexity of broadband projects can vary greatly, raising doubt for this committee as to whether 10 or 45 days is enough for electric utilities to comprehensively review some applications for all safety concerns. Again, this can have significant consequences for utilities and ratepayers. Thus, the committee recommends tailoring when “deemed approved” may be appropriate to be in alignment with local governments, and providing recourse for electric utilities to seek judicial review.
With ever-evolving safety standards and an ever-growing multitude of participants and projects needing to be energized, the CPUC routinely audits utility electric systems to ensure all construction and maintenance, including non-utility attachments, comply with GOs 95 and 128.[15] Most recently, the CPUC audited Southern California Edison’s system in the Wildomar District and Pacific Gas and Electric’s system in the Sacramento Division, and found in both cases – as seems normal in most audits – several violations.[16] Utilities have 30 days to respond to the audit summary with a plan to correct all noted violations; if these infractions are in regards to non-utility attachments, the utilities subsequently notify the owner of the attachment. Writing in opposition to this measure, the Coalition of California Utility Employees questions if allowing any possibility of “deemed approved” could “perpetuate the proliferation of serious health and safety violations.” Although this committee maintains concerns that mutual agreement between electric utilities and broadband providers may not be reached in some or many circumstances, it may be prudent to address the Coalition of California Utility Employees’ concern and provide additional control to utilities for the safety of linemen, whom are employed by the utilities. As such, this committee recommends affording latitude to utilities to flex or suspend shot clocks in the power design application phase until outstanding safety violations by the applicant are addressed. However, safety violations can be unequal in severity; they can vary in degree (e.g. an update to a fuse vs. a downed power line) and relevance to a specific area (e.g. Sacramento is a low-wildfire risk area compared to the Sonoma Valley).
- Prior legislation.
AB 965 (Carrillo) requires local governments to utilize batch broadband permit processing. Status: Chapter 553, Statutes of 2023.
AB 50 (Wood) requires the CPUC to determine the criteria for customers to receive timely electricity service when requesting new service connections or upgraded service. Also proposes several policies to address delays in connecting customers to the electrical grid, including improved information sharing with local governments and reporting by IOUs. Status: Chapter 317, Statutes of 2023.
SB 410 (Becker) establishes targets by which electrical utilities are to energize and authorizes such a utility to annually recover the costs of energization from its ratepayers. Status: Chapter 394, Statutes of 2023.
AB 537 (Quirk) updates existing law establishing a timeline and process through which broadband applications will be deemed approved. Status: Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021.
SB 378 (Gonzalez) prohibits local governments from denying microtrenching projects for fiber installation. Status: Chapter 677, Statutes of 2021.
AB 1027 (Buchanan) requires local publicly owned electric utilities to make accommodations on their utility poles or support structures for communications service providers, pursuant to reasonable terms and conditions. Establishes timelines for local publicly owned electric utilities to respond to such requests. Status: Chapter 580, Statutes of 2011.
- Double referral. This bill is double-referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Communications and Conveyance.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CalBroadband
California Apartment Association
California Communications Association
California Retailers Association
California Wireless Association
Crown Castle
CTIA
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZFED)
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Mateo County Economic Development Association
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom – the Broadband Association
Wireless Infrastructure Association
Opposition
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
California Special Districts Association
City of Rancho Cucamonga
City of Shasta Lake
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Environmental Defense Action Fund
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
San Diego Gas & Electric
Southern California Edison
Southern California Public Power Authority (SCPPA)
Analysis Prepared by: Kathleen Chen / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
LAO; “The 2021-22 California Spending Plan: Broadband Infrastructure”; October 2021. ↑
Governor’s 2024-2025 Budget Plan proposes to extend $1.25 million in funding for the Middle-Mile Network in FY 2025-26. LAO; “The 2024-25 Budget: Broadband Infrastructure”; February 2024. ↑
MIT Lincoln Laboratory; “Field campaign assesses vulnerabilities of 5G networks”; August 2023. ↑
The Verge; “AT&T begins testing and deployment of discreet 5G radios on city street lamp posts”; February 2022. ↑
Example provided by SDG&E and representative of their territory. Timelines and activities reflect those for complex projects (e.g., subdivisions, developments involving design by SDG&E). Requests that do not involve SDG&E design tend to have shorter timelines. Duration of the project phases are estimates only and represent activities managed by SDG&E; i.e., do not include time for activities that are the customer responsibility. ↑
California Energy Markets; “Interconnection Delays Disrupting Housing Markets, Causing ‘Chaos’”; March 2023. ↑
San Francisco Chronicle; “Big holdup for new Northern California housing? PG&E”; March 2023. ↑
Per data request to the committee on April 21st, 2023 from PG&E, SCE, and SDG&E. ↑
PUC § 933.5(a)(1)(B) ↑
Southern California Joint Pole Committee; https://scjpc.net/. ↑
Documents that specify rates, charges, rules, and conditions under which an IOU will provide service. ↑
LADWP; Wildfire Mitigation Plan; June 2022. ↑
Davis Wright Tremaine LLP; “Obligations for Owners of Overhead Communications and Electric Facilities in California”; January 2022. ↑
Per data request to the committee on March 25th, 2024 from LADWP. ↑
See each CPUC audit report at https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/regulatory-services/safety/electric-safety-and-reliability-branch/electric-and-cip-audits-introduction/electric-and-communication-facilities-audit-reports. ↑
CPUC; “Electric and CIP Audits”; https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/regulatory-services/safety/electric-safety-and-reliability-branch/electric-and-cip-audits-introduction. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Cottie Petrie-Norris, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2221 (
Author:Juan Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUBJECT: Broadband projects: electric power design approval
SUMMARY: Establishes timelines for electric utilities, private and public, to approve and energize a broadband project, and grants the broadband project automatic approval should the utility not take action within the timeline. Requires electric utilities to publish all rules and standards necessitated in project applications, and to only subject applications to those rules and standards that were published 12 months before the date of the application’s submission to an electric utility for review.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires electric utilities make easily accessible to the public all rules, requirements, and standards for broadband project applications submitted to the electric utility. Prohibits an application from being subject to any standard that had not been published 12 months before its date of submission.
- Establishes timelines for electric utilities to review and energize broadband projects. Allows timelines to be extended or otherwise modified upon written, mutual agreement of the electric utility and the broadband provider. The timelines include:
- Issuing a written notice of incompleteness, which shall specify every item and any information missing from the application, within 10 days from the application’s date of submittal, if needed.
- Approval or denial of a complete application within 45 days of receiving the application. If a notice of incompleteness is provided to the applicant within the first 10 days, the countdown would pause and resume when the applicant resubmits.
- A cost estimate for any utility work necessary to accommodate the broadband project within 14 days of the approval.
- Energization within 30 days of receiving notice of the applicant’s completion of all required work for the broadband project.
- Establishes timelines for broadband providers to respond to electric utilities. The timelines include:
- Resubmission of an application deemed incomplete within 30 days of the notice, otherwise the application will be canceled.
- Acceptance or rejection of the utility’s cost estimate within 45 days from when it is provided.
- Specifies that if an electric utility does not approve or deny within the 45-day period, the application shall be automatically deemed approved.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires local publicly owned electric utilities (POUs) to make ready infrastructure for use by a broadband service provider within 45 days of the date of receipt of the request, or 60 days if the request is to attach to more than 300 utility poles. Also requires POUs to provide a cost estimate within 14 days of a request’s approval. (Public Utilities Code § 9511)
- Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to determine criteria for timely service for electric customers by January 1, 2025 that shall include timely start of service for new connections, timely fulfillment of requests for increased load, and reenergization of customers following a power outage. (Public Utilities Code § 933.5)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for electric distribution line extensions necessary to finish permanent electric service. (Electric Rule 15)
- Establishes guidelines for the design, cost allocation, and responsibilities of a project applicant and a utility for the extension of electric service from an investor-owned utility (IOU) distribution line (Electric Rule 16)
- Requires cities and counties to process broadband projects within a reasonable period of time in accordance with the time periods and procedures established by applicable Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rules. (Government Code § 65964.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal and will be referred to the Committee on Appropriations for its review.
BACKGROUND:
Broadband for All – California has been focused on providing universal access to broadband since at least 2007, when the state established the California Advanced Services Fund to incentivize broadband providers to build out projects to unserved and underserved areas. In 2021, the state redoubled its efforts to close the digital divide by enacting SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2021), which committed $6 billion to build out broadband infrastructure. The $6 billion was appropriated from both the state’s general fund and from the federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA).[1] These funds would be available for allocation until 2024 and for encumbrance and liquidation until 2026. Utilizing these dollars before the deadline has given many in the broadband space a sense of urgency, and resulted in vocal concerns when any project delay arises.
Connecting Broadband – The newest generation of mobile networks being deployed by broadband providers today, 5G, offers higher speeds and connectivity than its predecessors.[2] The rollout of 5G relies on “small cell” technology, which are installed on existing infrastructure – typically utility poles – rather than needing large cellular towers to be built. Simplified, there are 3 main steps to getting a small cell up and running:
- Power design – this is the engineering blueprint in which broadband providers lay out the details of a project, including, among a host of others, construction drawings and pole loadbearing (weight and electrical capacity) calculations;
- Attachment to utility infrastructure;
- Energization – this is the act of physically connecting the equipment to the grid and powering the equipment.
In 2011, the Legislature passed AB 1027 (Buchanan, Chapter 580, Statutes of 2011), establishing timelines for POUs to make infrastructure ready for Step 2. However, some small cell technologies, such as small cell radios on a city street lamp,[3] may not need utilities for Steps 2 or 3. Other small cell technologies may need Steps 1 and 3, but not Step 2. Since “shot clocks” that set specified time limits have only been statutorily mandated for Step 2, broadband providers have voiced concern over delays that may occur with regards to Steps 1 and 3.
Moreover, these steps and timelines can vary greatly depending on utility territory, system upgrades necessitated by the project application, or events outside the utilities’ control such as supply chain delays, weather, or pending customer application information or permit completion, among others. Projects can take anywhere from a month to years depending on these various factors. As shown in Figure 1, there are many steps – and thus many opportunities for delay – in the customer energization lifecycle.
Figure 1: Customer Project Lifecycle (for complex projects)[4]
Timelines for electric lines – The demands for new service connections and/or upgrades to existing distribution lines have been increasing, especially as California advances policies to deploy more infrastructure to charge electric vehicles, shift from natural gas to electricity in buildings, and increase the housing supply.[5] These projects, alongside broadband, all rely on access to the electrical grid and often require upgrades to the distribution system. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has created supply shortages and challenges affecting many sectors of the economy, including limiting access to electrical equipment, such as transformers, needed to connect new customers or expand energy load.[6] Taken together, electric utilities currently face a big backlog of energization projects. While utilities have taken internal steps to attempt to better manage their project queue, the Legislature passed a pair of bills last year, AB 50 (Wood, Chapter 317, Statutes of 2023) and SB 410 (Becker, Chapter 394, Statutes of 2023), requiring the CPUC to step in and create criteria for timely energization by January 1, 2025. The CPUC opened a rulemaking (R. 24-01-018) in January 2024 to solicit public comment and host workshop discussions of energization timeline issues, and is expected to release a decision in September 2024.
The FCC’s 2018 Wireless Deployment Order – In 2009 and 2014, the FCC adopted orders to lower barriers to wireless facility deployment and reduce permitting delays at the local level. As part of the 2009 and 2014 orders, the FCC established shot clocks on a local government’s review of a wireless facility permit application:
- 60 days for a project that is an “eligible facilities request,” which is defined by the FCC as a collocation on an existing facility that does not substantially change its physical dimensions;
- 90 days for a project that is a collocation that substantially changes the dimensions of the facility, but does not substantially change its size; and
- 150 days for projects that are new sites for wireless facilities.
Following the FCC’s 2014 order, the Legislature passed AB 57 (Quirk, Chapter 685, Statutes of 2015). Amongst other permit streamlining changes, AB 57 codified the above-detailed shot clocks.
In 2018, the FCC updated its wireless deployment orders related to local government permitting. As part of this update, the FCC expanded the types of wireless facilities covered by the FCC’s permit streamlining rules and also shortened the shot clocks for local government permit application reviews. The 2018 order adopted the following shot clocks:
- 60 days for applications for installations on existing infrastructure
- 90 days for all other applications
AB 537 (Quirk, Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021) updated state statute to reflect the more recent FCC rules regarding wireless permit timelines by replacing references to the 2009 and 2014 orders with a reference to the 2018 FCC rules.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “Billions in public and private funding for broadband projects are trying to be built as fast as possible in 2024, 2025 & 2026 to help close the digital divide. $6 billion in federal broadband dollars need to be allocated by the end of 2024 and projects need to be built by the end of 2026 or we risk sending money back to D.C. The legislature has enacted laws in recent years ensuring that local governments streamline broadband deployment and process broadband permits within 60-90 days. Electric utilities don’t have any required timeframes for broadband application timelines and typically take between 7-12 months to process the initial power design application then another 7-12 months to connect power to the broadband project. California won’t be able to meet its Broadband for All objectives unless legislation is passed creating a consistent and transparent process for public and private utilities to follow when processing broadband project applications. AB 2221 creates reasonable procedures and timelines for both utilities and applicants to follow so broadband applications can be handled efficiently in a reasonable amount of time.”
- Front of the line. As alluded to above, utilities receive energization requests for a wide variety of projects. Utilities have reported to this committee that annual completed requests range from around 4,500 to 8,000 depending on how many distinct project types are counted.[7] Yet the utilities report these numbers represent less than a third of projects that are requested, as many energization requests drop out during various stages of the project pipeline. Utilities are required to consider these requests in a “first in, first out” basis, without bias. Since the timelines this bill establishes would only be applicable to broadband projects, this bill would effectively put all broadband projects at the front of the queue. Moreover, the timelines in this bill jump ahead of the CPUC’s energization proceeding, which seeks to establish energization timelines for all project types.
The author motivates the need for broadband-specific shot clocks by noting the 2024 and 2026 deadlines SB 156 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 112, Statutes of 2021) obligated to allocate and liquidate, respectively, the $6 billion committed to broadband projects. But similar concerns have been expressed about being unable to meet other state goals in time as a result of electric utility backlog, such as the target for 60% renewable energy resources by 2030 established under SB 100 (de León, Chapter 312, Statutes of 2018). In conversations with the committee, the sponsor has indicated that they have been a party in the CPUC’s rulemaking proceeding to establish energization timelines, suggesting that the venue is open to considering broadband’s specific concerns. Moreover, statute mandates the CPUC must consider “project types that justify unique or extended energization timelines,”[8] by which broadband could make the case for its unique status. As noted by the author, this bill does establish more shot clocks for specific steps in the project application timeline than what is currently required for the CPUC to establish per statute. However, it is unclear how this measure’s timelines would work in concert with those determined by the CPUC, particularly if the CPUC establishes an energization shot clock greater than that enacted in this bill, 30 days. Since the CPUC is actively working towards a decision, the committee may wish to amend the specified 30-day energization timeline called for in this bill to instead be tied to the forthcoming timeline that the CPUC will establish in their existing rulemaking (R. 24-01-018).
- Shot clock mismatches. This bill would require electric utilities to provide to an applicant written notice of incompleteness, specifying each and every piece of information missing from the application, within 10 days of the application’s date of submission. Although 45 days for review and approval of broadband project applications by electric utilities would mirror the guidelines the Southern California Joint Pole Committee follows in reviewing joint pole authorizations,[9] electric utilities would effectively have only 10, not 45, days accorded by this bill to review an entire power design application. Given the variable degrees of complexity between projects and the high level of technicality inherent to a power design, it is unclear if the level of “completeness” of an application can be captured without scrutiny of the accuracy in design and calculations that may be involved, leading to skepticism that neither 10 nor 45 days may be enough time for an electric utility to review some applications. Though the bill provides a clause for electric utilities and broadband providers to flex timelines in mutual agreement, it is impossible to predict how often a mutual agreement may be reached. In such cases where a mutual agreement cannot be reached, the electric utilities would have to challenge through litigation, which could siphon resources away from other responsibilities, including the timely processing of the energization queue that this bill seeks to support. Since incompleteness or inaccuracy of an application could be due to the fault of the applicant, the committee may wish to strike the provisions requiring utilities to notify applicants of incompleteness within 10 days of submittal and waiving any additional fees for a resubmission.
Additionally, the shot clocks outlined in this bill seem to provide more latitude to broadband providers than afforded to the utilities. Where the utility companies would get 10 days to review and provide a written notice of every item that the broadband companies missed in an application, the broadband companies would get 30 days to fix and resubmit. Where the utility companies are accorded 14 days to provide a cost estimate, the broadband companies are accorded 45 days to approve the cost estimate.
Following FCC guidelines, local governments in California have 60 to 90 day shot clocks to review and approve broadband projects. It is unclear to this committee why local governments received double or triple the amount of time to review broadband applications than what is provided to utilities under this measure. Given these considerations, the committee may wish to amend the review timelines for electric utilities to be in alignment with local governments, according 60 days to approve or deny a complete application involving installation on existing infrastructure and 90 days for all other applications. The committee may additionally wish to amend the timelines around cost estimation to create parity between applicants and utilities, namely 30 days.
- Safety first. This bill seeks to create transparency of the rules, requirements, and standards utilities use to evaluate broadband project applications. Rules governing the ability of new projects to connect to the electric distribution grid are generally determined by statute, CPUC rules, and tariffs for each of the IOUs.[10] While POUs are not regulated by the CPUC, they must meet applicable federal, state, and industry standards, and they have in many instances aligned with the rules set forth by the agency, such as on General Order 95,[11] which governs the design, construction, and maintenance of overhead electrical supply and communication facilities. These standards do not stay static. For example, GO 95 was initially promulgated in 1941 and has been updated approximately 60 times since then – most recently in January 2020.[12] Adherence to these standards is critical to ensuring a safe and reliable electric system. Exempting broadband applications from any rules and standards that were not published by the electric utility 12 months prior to its submission – as put forward by this measure – could, in effect, allow a project to circumvent safety requirements. This could have dire consequences for utilities and ratepayers as utilities would be liable for any blackouts, fires, or other disasters that originate from their grid systems.
In an investigation of Crown Castle’s 5G small cell site installations since 2019,[13] Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (LADWP) found that out of about 900 installations, 754 were incorrectly installed. Since non-compliant 5G pole attachments increase safety risks for fire and electric shock to the linemen and to the public, LADWP projects to spend 270 hours per week between September 2023 and July 2024 to de-energize poles and allow Crown Castle to correct non-compliant installations.
Since possible exemptions from updated safety and reliability standards could heighten risks to worker and public safety, the committee may wish to strike the provision exempting broadband project applications from any rules, requirements, or standards that had not been published 12 months prior to the date of its submission.
This bill also proposes to remedy any instances where electric utilities do not approve or deny a permit design application within 45 days by automatically “deeming approved” those applications. The author notes that the Legislature passed a similar remedy for broadband applications undergoing local government review. However, this “deemed approved” clause only narrowly applies to collocation or siting applications and if the following conditions are met:
- The city or county fails to approve or disapprove the application within the reasonable time periods in the FCC rules;
- All required public notices have been provided regarding application; and
- The applicant has provided a notice to the city or county that the reasonable time period has lapsed.
A local government is also allowed to challenge the operation of the applicant’s notice to the local government that the reasonable time period has lapsed and the application is deemed approved. This bill does not grant these guardrails to electric utilities, instead providing a blanket “deemed approved” for all power design applications when the shot clock winds down. Although the sponsor has claimed, in conversations with the committee, that local government applications are broader in scope and therefore more difficult to review, it is unclear to this committee if it is reasonable to assume that electric utility applications are indeed less demanding. As mentioned previously, the complexity of broadband projects can vary greatly, raising doubt for this committee as to whether 10 or 45 days is enough for electric utilities to comprehensively review some applications for all safety concerns. Again, this can have significant consequences for utilities and ratepayers. Thus, the committee may wish to tailor when “deemed approved” may be appropriate to be in alignment with local governments, and providing recourse for electric utilities to seek judicial review.
- Prior legislation.
AB 965 (Carrillo) requires local governments to utilize batch broadband permit processing. Status: Chapter 553, Statutes of 2023.
AB 50 (Wood) requires the CPUC to determine the criteria for customers to receive timely electricity service when requesting new service connections or upgraded service. Also proposes several policies to address delays in connecting customers to the electrical grid, including improved information sharing with local governments and reporting by IOUs. Status: Chapter 317, Statutes of 2023.
SB 410 (Becker) establishes targets by which electrical utilities are to energize and authorizes such a utility to annually recover the costs of energization from its ratepayers. Status: Chapter 394, Statutes of 2023.
AB 537 (Quirk) updates existing law establishing a timeline and process through which broadband applications will be deemed approved. Status: Chapter 467, Statutes of 2021.
SB 378 (Gonzalez) prohibits local governments from denying microtrenching projects for fiber installation. Status: Chapter 677, Statutes of 2021.
AB 1027 (Buchanan) requires local publicly owned electric utilities to make accommodations on their utility poles or support structures for communications service providers, pursuant to reasonable terms and conditions. Establishes timelines for local publicly owned electric utilities to respond to such requests. Status: Chapter 580, Statutes of 2011.
- Double referral. This bill is double-referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Communications and Conveyance.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CalBroadband
California Communications Association
California Retailers Association
California Wireless Association
Crown Castle
CTIA
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZFED)
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce
Rural County Representatives of California
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
San Mateo County Economic Development Association
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
United States Telecom Association Dba Ustelecom – the Broadband Association
Wireless Infrastructure Association
Opposition
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
California Special Districts Association
Environmental Defense Action Fund
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
San Diego Gas & Electric
Southern California Edison
Southern California Public Power Authority (SCPPA)
Analysis Prepared by: Kathleen Chen / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
LAO; “The 2021-22 California Spending Plan: Broadband Infrastructure”; October 2021. ↑
MIT Lincoln Laboratory; “Field campaign assesses vulnerabilities of 5G networks”; August 2023. ↑
The Verge; “AT&T begins testing and deployment of discreet 5G radios on city street lamp posts”; February 2022. ↑
Example provided by SDG&E and representative of their territory. Timelines and activities reflect those for complex projects (e.g., subdivisions, developments involving design by SDG&E). Requests that do not involve SDG&E design tend to have shorter timelines. Duration of the project phases are estimates only and represent activities managed by SDG&E; i.e., do not include time for activities that are the customer responsibility. ↑
California Energy Markets; “Interconnection Delays Disrupting Housing Markets, Causing ‘Chaos’”; March 2023. ↑
San Francisco Chronicle; “Big holdup for new Northern California housing? PG&E”; March 2023. ↑
Per data request to the committee on April 21st, 2023 from PG&E, SCE, and SDG&E. ↑
PUC § 933.5(a)(1)(B) ↑
Southern California Joint Pole Committee; https://scjpc.net/. ↑
Documents that specify rates, charges, rules, and conditions under which an IOU will provide service. ↑
LADWP; Wildfire Mitigation Plan; June 2022. ↑
Davis Wright Tremaine LLP; “Obligations for Owners of Overhead Communications and Electric Facilities in California”; January 2022. ↑
Per data request to the committee on March 25th, 2024 from LADWP. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):