AB 223: Change of gender and sex identifier.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-09-23
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-09-23: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 221, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law authorizes a person to file a petition with the superior court seeking a judgment recognizing their change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary, including a person who is under 18 years of age. Existing law authorizes a person to file a single petition to simultaneously change the petitioners name and recognize the change to the petitioners gender and sex identifier, as specified.
This bill would require any petition for a change of gender and sex identifier or a petition for change of gender, sex identifier, and name filed by a person under 18 years of age, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be kept confidential by the court. The bill would require the court to limit access to these records to specified individuals, including, among others, the minor, the minors parents, and their attorneys.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law authorizes a person to file a petition with the superior court seeking a judgment recognizing their change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary, including a person who is under 18 years of age. Existing law authorizes a person to file a single petition to simultaneously change the petitioners name and recognize the change to the petitioners gender and sex identifier, as specified.
This bill would require any petition for a change of gender and sex identifier or a petition for change of gender, sex identifier, and name filed by a person under 18 years of age, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be kept confidential by the court. The bill would require the court to limit access to these records to specified individuals, including, among others, the minor, the minors parents, and their attorneys.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law authorizes a person to file a petition with the superior court seeking a judgment recognizing their change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary, including a person who is under 18 years of age. Existing law authorizes a person to file a single petition to simultaneously change the petitioners name and recognize the change to the petitioners gender and sex identifier, as specified.
This bill would require any petition for a change of gender and sex identifier or a petition for change of gender, sex identifier, and name filed by a person under 18 years of age, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be kept confidential by the court. The bill would require the court to limit access to these records to specified individuals, including, among others, the minor, the minors parents, and their attorneys.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law authorizes a person to file a petition with the superior court seeking a judgment recognizing their change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary, including a person who is under 18 years of age. Existing law authorizes a person to file a single petition to simultaneously change the petitioners name and recognize the change to the petitioners gender and sex identifier, as specified.
This bill would require any petition for a change of gender and sex identifier or a petition for change of gender, sex identifier, and name filed by a person under 18 years of age, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be filed under seal. kept confidential by the court. The bill would require the court to limit access to these records to specified individuals, including, among others, the minor, the minors parents, and their attorneys.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law authorizes a person to file a petition with the superior court seeking a judgment recognizing their change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary, including a person who is under 18 years of age. Existing law authorizes a person to file a single petition to simultaneously change the petitioners name and recognize the change to the petitioners gender and sex identifier, as specified.
This bill would require any petition for a change of gender and sex identifier or a petition for change of gender, sex identifier, and name filed by a person under 18 years of age, and any papers associated with the proceeding, to be filed under seal.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
If a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or a single petition for change to the petitioners name and to recognize the change of the petitioners gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435 is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding shall be kept confidential by the court. The court shall limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minors parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 103437 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is in the best interest for the public to keep these records confidential to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
If a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or a single petition for change to the petitioners name and to recognize the change of the petitioners gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435 is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding shall be kept confidential by the court. The court shall limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minors parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 103437 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is in the best interest for the public to keep these records confidential to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
If a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or a single petition for change to the petitioners name and to recognize the change of the petitioners gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435 is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding shall be kept confidential by the court. The court shall limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minors parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 103447 103437 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is in the best interest for the public to keep these records confidential to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
If a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or a single petition for change to the petitioners name and to recognize the change of the petitioners gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435 is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding shall be filed under seal. kept confidential by the court. The court shall limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minors parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 103447 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is in the best interest for the public to seal keep these records from the public confidential to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
If a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or a single petition for change to the petitioners name and to recognize the change of the petitioners gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435 is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding shall be filed under seal.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 103447 to the Health and Safety Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is in the best interest for the public to seal these records from the public to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 23, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 221, Statutes of 2023. |
| Sep 23, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 64. Noes 8. Page 3037.). |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Page 3011.) |
| Sep 6, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 8 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 32. Noes 6. Page 2402.). |
| Aug 24, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 23, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (June 13). |
| Jun 5, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 3, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 63. Noes 0. Page 889.) |
| Mar 15, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 14, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 10. Noes 1.) (March 14). |
| Mar 14, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jan 26, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 11, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 10. |
| Jan 10, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2023 | AB 223 Ward Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB223 Ward et al. By Padilla | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 13, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 23, 2023 | AB 223 Ward Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 14, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Support | |
| American Association Of University Women - California | ** Support | |
| Bridge Network | ** Against | |
| California Behavioral Health Directors Association of California | ** Support | |
| California Capitol Connection | ** Against | |
| California Coalition For Youth | ** Support | |
| California Family Council | ** Against | |
| California Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| California Rise Up | ** Against | |
| California’s Legislative Voice | ** Against | |
| California Teachers Association | ** Support | |
| Carlsbad Citizens for Community Oversight | ** Against | |
| City Of Huntington Beach | ** Against | |
| City Of Sacramento | ** Support | |
| County Behavioral Health Directors Association | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter | ** Support | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Our Duty | ** Against | |
| Pacific Justice Institute | ** Against | |
| Real Impact. | ** Against | |
| Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women | ** Against | |
| The National Center for Law & Policy | ** Against | |
| The Salt & Light Council | ** Against | |
| Transfamily Support Services | ** Support | |
| Trans Youth Liberation | ** Support | |
| Victory Baptist Church | ** Against | |
| Woman II Woman | ** Against |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 223
Author:(Ward)
As Amended Ver:August 23, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Enhances protections for minors seeking changes of name or gender by making the proceedings presumptively confidential.
Major Provisions
- Provides that if a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier, or a single petition for change to the petitioner's name and to recognize the change of the petitioner's gender and sex identifier, is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding are to be kept confidential by the courts.
- Clarifies that the confidentiality provisions of 1), above, do not apply to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minor's parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
- Makes various findings and declarations related to the need to limit information for the public.
Senate Amendments
Revise the code section slated to be amended by the bill and clarify that the bill's confidentiality provisions do not apply to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minor's parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
COMMENTS
In 2013, the Legislature enacted AB 1121 (Atkins), Chapter 651, Statutes of 2013, which reduced burdens for transgender individuals seeking a name change. AB 1121 required courts to grant petitions for a change of name sought to conform an individual's name to the individual's gender identity without a hearing if no timely objection is made. The legislation also exempted such requests from the publication requirement. AB 1121 also created an administrative process by which California-born individuals can submit an affidavit of a physician attesting that they have undergone clinically appropriate treatment for the purpose of a gender transition directly to the State Registrar and thereby change the person's gender on the person's birth certificate. This eliminated the need for the court to review a gender change petition, simplifying the process for transgender individuals to update the gender marker on their birth certificates and therefore allowing persons to more easily update their birth certificate to match their gender remotely.
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins), Chapter 853, Statutes of 2017, further refined and updated the required documentation to reflect an evolved understanding of gender identity. The bill created a standalone statute governing legal name changes sought to conform a person's legal gender with their gender identity. The new provision requires the court to make an order reciting the filing of the person's petition. It provided that if no objection is received to the proposed name change, the court must grant the name change. There is no requirement for publication. A hearing is not set unless a timely objection shows good reason against the change of name. In addition, realizing the reality that gender identity is not contingent on whether an individual has received any medical treatment for purposes of a gender transition, SB 179 of 2017 removed the requirement that individuals submit medical documentation in order to change the individual's gender on a birth certificate or to obtain a court-ordered gender change. A person instead must provide an affidavit in which the person attests, under penalty of perjury, that the request for a change in gender is to conform the person's legal gender to the person's gender identity. For a court-ordered gender change, the court is required to accept the individual's affidavit as conclusive proof of gender change.
SB 179 of 2017 also required the State Registrar to issue a new birth certificate, reflecting a change of gender, without a court order for any person born in this state who submits directly to the State Registrar an application to change the gender on the birth certificate and an affidavit attesting under penalty of perjury that 1) the request for a change of gender is to conform the person's legal gender to the person's gender identity, and 2) is not made for any fraudulent purpose. In 2021, AB 218 (Ward), Chapter 577, Statutes of 2021, aligned the process for updating transgender marriage certificates and the birth certificates of their children's with the process for updating the person's own birth certificate.
It should be noted that as a result of these bills, special procedures were adopted for minors seeking legal name and gender changes. The existing law requires a minor seeking a court-recognized name and gender change to have the signature of at least one parent or guardian, or if those cannot be found, the signature of another close relative. Persons, including other relatives, are permitted to object to these proceedings and show cause as to why the name change should not proceed so long as the objection is done in accordance with the procedural guidelines set forth in existing law.
According to the Trevor Project, transgender youth are nearly twice as likely as youth at large to seriously consider suicide or self-harm (Dorison, Greene & Price-Feeny, Understanding the Mental Health of Transgender and Nonbinary Youth (2019) 66 Journal of Adolescent Health 684, 686.). Many of the ideations towards self-harm stem from the stressors created by the "perceived discrimination and physical harm" directed toward transgender and nonbinary youth. (Id. at 689.) To better protect transgender and nonbinary youth from this discrimination, the bill seeks to prevent a youth from being "outed" as a result of a public court record that reveals a past name and gender change. Accordingly, this measure simply directs that all legal matters in which a minor seeks a name and gender change are to be kept confidential except in limited circumstances and may be provided to specified persons.
Opposition raises several perplexing arguments against this relatively straightforward measure, many of which demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of transgender individuals and the legal system. First, the opposition appears to conflate changing one's legal name, gender, sex identifier with undergoing sex reassignment surgery and receiving gender-affirming medical care. For example, in opposition to this measure, the California Family Council argues, "our laws should encourage children to love their bodies, not change them by cutting off their healthy body parts and taking sterilizing hormones for the rest of their lives." However, existing provisions of the Health and Safety Code contain no provisions requiring a person to have undergone sexual reassignment surgery, or to be undergoing gender affirming care, in order to be eligible for a court-granted change to their legal name and gender identity. Thus, these concerns appear unfounded as that is not what this measure seeks to accomplish.
Secondly, the opposition appears to misunderstand the existing legal procedures required before a minor can legally change their name and gender identity. The group Real Impact claims this bill will, "require the court to withhold a minor's legal petition for a change of gender and sex identifier from the public and more importantly, the minor's parents." The Pacific Justice Institute appears to further misunderstand the process, contending, "Judges, not politicians, are in the best position to determine which documents should be filed under seal in the cases before them. Imposing a blanket exception for a politically connected sexual minority group does not advance the interests of justice." It should be noted that simply because a record is filed under seal does not remove any authority for a judge as to whether or not to grant a petition for a name change. Secondly, nothing in this bill limits a parent's right to weigh in on their child's request to change their name and gender identity. In fact, existing law generally requires a parent or legal guardian to sign off on the petition to the court. In the event one parent approves of the minor's wishes and the other disapproves, nothing in this measure circumvents the disapproving parent's ability to show cause to the court as to why the petition should not be granted. Only in the case where a minor's parents could not be found, perhaps because the parents are deceased or a minor was forced to flee the home of transphobic parents, is the minor permitted to have a non-parental family member or legal guardian sign the petition for the name and gender identity change.
The opposition also contends that the measure violates the general principle that court records be open to the public. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court has held that the public possesses a First Amendment right to access court records and proceedings, holding that public access can only be denied in the presence of, "an overriding interest based on findings that closure is essential to preserve higher values and is narrowly tailored to serve those values." (Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court (1986) 478 U.S. 1, 9.) Nonetheless, the Supreme Court has also held that absent a near complete closure of court proceedings, the public's right to access judicial proceedings is judged via a common law standard whereby the, "decision whether to permit access is best left to the sound discretion of the trial court, a discretion to be exercised in light of the relevant facts and circumstances of the particular case." (Nixon v. Time Warner Communications, Inc., (1978) 435 U.S. 589, 598-99.) Given that nothing in this bill directly closes the court proceeding itself, the common law standard would almost certainly apply. In certain instances of applying the common law, the Ninth Circuit has gone so far as to apply a mere "good cause" standard for sealing records. (Center for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Group, LLC, (2016) 809 F.3d 1092.) Additionally, the Legislature is also free to refine the standards utilized by a court absent direct constitutional direction to the contrary. Looking at the "relevant facts and circumstances," and in light of the statics that transgender youth are far more likely to self-harm than their non-transgender peers, this bill appears to easily satisfy the legal standards necessary for sealing court records.
Finally, the opposition contends that sealing the record of a minor's change of name, gender, and sexual identity may impede law enforcement or private civil actions. One organization, Women II Women argues, "Should this bill pass, California will be placing females in precarious positions with no ability for safeguarding. This bill will be a [sic.] impediment for females that feel a male gaze on their bodies in the changing facilities to have the evidence to provide their Title IX claims, if they are not able to show evidence of the sex of the perpertrator [sic.]." Beyond rehashing the tired and hateful stereotype that transgender persons simply want to use facilities of the opposite sex for nefarious purposes, again, this interpretation of the bill misunderstands or misconstrues basic court procedures. In fact, no record necessarily is sealed forever. Rule 2.551 of the California Rules of Court explicitly provides a process for unsealing any court record. The existing procedure has largely been in place since 2007.
According to the Author
Being 'outed' is a traumatic event for anyone – but especially traumatic for someone under the age of 18 years old. The Transgender Youth Privacy Act gives transgender youth the confidence to navigate their gender identity without fear of retaliation from someone who discovers that information in the public record.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making common sense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change to place the petition and resulting paperwork under seal. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
Arguments in Support
This modest and straightforward measure is supported by ACLU California Action and Oakland Privacy. In support of the measure the ACLU writes:
California has provided the tools needed for minors to change their vital records to match their gender identity; however, the petition and paperwork are a matter of public information discoverable with a simple internet search. In some cases, this becomes known when a third party, such as a classmate, discovers this information and "outs" them to their peers.
A 2020 study by The Trevor Project's researchers found that transgender and non-binary youth were 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBTQ peers. These higher levels of mental health related issues are attributable in part to the psychological effects of gender non-affirmation, be that by their family and peers, or on government-issued vital records that do not conform to their gender identity.
Arguments in Opposition
As noted several religious and other groups who oppose transgender individuals oppose this measure. Representative of the coalition, the California Family Council writes:
Please stop and consider the unintended consequences of telling every kid their biology has nothing to do with their gender, then letting them falsify governments regarding their sex and hiding that as though it never happened.
Until recently, no country in all of human history has let people legally change their sex. If anyone can become a woman, a man, or another made-up gender as a matter of law, then sex and gender as meaningful categories disappear.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-1-0
YES: Maienschein, Essayli, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Sanchez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0-17
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Maienschein, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
SENATE FLOOR: 32-6-2
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dahle, Ochoa Bogh
UPDATED
VERSION: August 23, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001352
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 223 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 223
Author: Ward (D), et al.
Amended: 8/23/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-2, 6/13/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 3/23/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Change of gender and sex identifier
SOURCE: TransFamily Support Services
TransYouth Liberation
DIGEST:
This bill provides for specified records to be kept confidential by the courts where minors petition for a change of gender and sex identifier, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/23/23 renumber the added section and expand the list of those that can access the relevant records related to the minor’s petition.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that a person may file a petition with a superior court seeking a judgment recognizing the change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary. If requested, the judgment shall include an order that a new birth certificate be prepared reflecting the change of gender and any name change accomplished by an order of a court of this state, another state, the District of Columbia, or any territory of the United States. (Health & Saf. Code § 103425.)
- Provides the process for a petitioner seeking a court order to recognize a change in the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier as female, male, or nonbinary and to direct the issuance of new administrative documents to reflect those changes. Such petitions must be accompanied by an affidavit from the petitioner and a certified copy of the court order changing the petitioner’s name, if applicable. The petitioner’s affidavit shall be accepted as conclusive proof of gender change if it contains substantially the following language: “I, (petitioner’s full name), hereby attest under penalty of perjury that the request for a change in gender to (female, male, or nonbinary) is to conform my legal gender to my gender identity and is not for any fraudulent purpose.” (Health & Saf. Code § 103430.)
- Requires the court to grant the above petition without a hearing if no written objection is timely filed. The relevant court order can include an order for a new birth certificate reflecting the petitioner’s change in gender and name, where applicable. The law provides additional processes for a petitioner under 18 years of age. (Health & Saf. Code § 103430.)
- Authorizes a single petition to be filed to change the petitioner’s name and recognize the change to the petitioner’s gender, and, if requested, to order the issuance of a new birth certificate. (Health & Saf. Code §§ 103435, 103445, 103725.)
- Provides that whenever a person born in this state has their name changed by order of a court of this state, another state, the District of Columbia, or any territory of the United States, an application including an affidavit of this fact may be filed with the office of the State Registrar upon a form provided for that purpose. (Health & Saf. Code § 103400.)
- Provides the court procedures for effectuating the above changes. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1275 et seq.)
This bill:
- Requires the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding to change an individual’s gender or sex identifier or change their name and to recognize the change in gender and sex identifier to be kept confidential by the courts where the petitioner is under 18 years of age.
- Requires the court to limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minor’s parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
Background
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins, Chapter 853, Statutes of 2017) restructured the processes for individuals to change their names and genders to conform with their gender identity and to have these changes reflected on their birth certificates. In addition, a streamlined process was established for changing one’s name and gender and having an updated birth certificate issued as part of a single petition. Specific guidelines and required procedures were laid out for petitioners.
A number of bills last session further honed these processes and fine tuned the applicable provisions, in part in response to issues identified by the Judicial Council of California. Special procedural rules apply when the petitioner is a minor. In response to concerns about the privacy and wellbeing of these minor petitioners, this bill requires petitions and associated papers to be kept confidential by the courts when a minor petitions for a change of gender and sex identifier or a name change and recognition of the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier. The court is required to limit access to the records to only the minor and specified representatives of the minor, including the minor’s parents or guardians and any legal representatives. Recent amends also allow access for individuals subject to an order to show cause related to the petition.
This bill is sponsored by TransFamily Support Services and TransYouth Liberation. It is supported by the California Federation of Teachers and the National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter. There is opposition from a number of faith groups and other organizations, including the California Family Council and the Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women.
Comments
California’s efforts to address these issues
To address the barriers faced by transgender individuals going through the court process for name changes, AB 1121 (Atkins, Ch. 651, Stats. 2013) was introduced and enacted into law. It required courts to grant petitions for a change of name sought to conform an individual’s name to the individual’s gender identity without a hearing if no timely objection is made. The legislation also exempted such requests from the publication requirement. AB 1121 also created an administrative process by which California-born individuals can submit an affidavit of a physician attesting that the person has undergone clinically appropriate treatment for the purpose of a gender transition, along with a fee, directly to the State Registrar and thereby change the person’s gender on the person’s birth certificate. This eliminated the need for the court to review a gender change petition, simplifying the process for transgender individuals to update the gender marker on their birth certificates and allowing persons born in California, but now residing out of state, to update their birth certificate to match their gender remotely. This administrative process to change one’s gender on a birth certificate is far more cost-effective and accessible for transgender individuals.
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins, Chapter 853, Statutes of 2017) streamlined these processes even further and updated the required documentation to reflect an evolved understanding of gender identity. The bill created a standalone statute governing legal name changes sought to conform one’s legal gender to the person’s gender identity. The new section requires the court to make an order reciting the filing of the person’s petition. It provided that if no objection is received to the proposed name change within six weeks of the order, the court must grant the name change. There is no requirement for publication. A hearing is not to be set unless a timely objection shows good reason against the change of name.
In addition, realizing that an individual’s gender identity is not contingent on whether the individual has received any associated medical treatment, SB 179 removed the requirement that individuals submit medical documentation in order to change the individual’s gender on a birth certificate or to obtain a court-ordered gender change. A person instead must provide an affidavit in which the person attests under penalty of perjury that the request for a change in gender is to conform the person’s legal gender to the person’s gender identity. For a court-ordered gender change, the court is required to accept the individual’s affidavit as conclusive proof of gender change.
Expansion of existing processes for additional documents
Last session, several bills further honed the processes. AB 218 (Ward, Chapter 577, Statutes of 2021) took the next step in providing more inclusive processes for the transgender and gender nonconforming communities. That bill extended the existing framework for petitioners changing their names and/or genders on their own birth certificates to further update their marriage licenses and certificates and the birth certificates of their children. It also extended eligibility for certain processes to persons not born or residing within the state and recognized orders in foreign jurisdictions for purposes of sufficient documentation.
Section 103425 of the Health and Safety Code provides that a person may file a petition with the superior court in any county seeking a judgment recognizing the change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary. A petitioner can request that a new birth certificate be ordered in the judgment, reflecting the change in gender and a change in name, as specified. AB 218 allowed for the judgment to additionally include an order for a new marriage certificate reflecting the change of gender and a similar change of name. Furthermore, an order for a new birth certificate for the petitioner’s child could also be included in such a judgment. These avenues to updated documentation were subject to specific procedures. (Health & Saf. Code § 103430; Code Civ. Proc. § 1275 et seq.) The new marriage certificate can reflect the gender of the petitioner, as specified in the judgment of the court, and reflect any change of name, as specified in the court order.
AB 218 applied a detailed set of rules for petitions requesting new documentation specifying who must sign such petitions and who must be served with notice and an order to show cause. Subsequent to that law being passed, in conjunction with AB 1578 (Committee on Judiciary, Chapter 401, Statutes of 2021), the Judicial Council highlighted a number of internal inconsistencies that created problems with rulemaking around the proper forms to effectuate the intent of these laws. The Judicial Council requested the changes made by this bill.
Under previously existing law, if the person whose gender is to be changed is under 18 years of age, the petition is required to be signed by at least one of the minor’s parents or a guardian or attorney of the minor, or if both parents are deceased and there is no guardian of the minor, by a near relative or friend of the minor. If the petition does not include a signature from one of those persons, the court is required to make an order directing the person or persons whose required signatures are not on the petition to show cause why the petition should not be granted by filing a written objection.
Last year, AB 421 (Ward, Chapter 40, Statutes of 2022) required the court, if the petition is not signed by all living parents, to make that order and to direct the parent or parents who did not sign the petition to show cause why the petition should not be granted by filing a written objection. AB 421 also required the court, where all parents are deceased or cannot be located, to make an order directing the living grandparents to show cause why the petition for a court order to recognize a change in the minor’s gender and sex identifier should not be granted, as specified.
This bill again amends these processes for minors. Concerns have arisen regarding the privacy of minor petitioners seeking a change in gender or sex identifier. This bill addresses these concerns by requiring petitions and associated papers submitted by minors to be kept confidential by the courts. This applies where the minor is seeking a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or seeking a change to the petitioner’s name and to also recognize the change of the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435. The court is required to limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the following people:
- the minor;
- any adult who signed the petition;
- the minor’s parents or guardians or guardians ad litem;
- any individual who is subject to an order to show cause related to the petition; and
- any attorneys representing these individuals.
The author states the purpose of the bill:
Being “outed” is a traumatic event for anyone –– but especially traumatic for someone under the age of 18 years old, The Transgender Youth Privacy Act gives transgender youth the confidence to navigate their gender identity without fear of retaliation from someone who discovers that information in the public record.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making common sense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change to make the petition and resulting paperwork confidential. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/24/23)
TransFamily Support Services (co-source)
TransYouth Liberation (co-source)
ACLU California Action
American Association of University Women - California
California Behavioral Health Directors Association of California
California Coalition for Youth
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California Teachers Association
City of Sacramento
County Behavioral Health Directors Association
Disability Rights California
Equality California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Oakland Privacy
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/24/23)
Bridge Network
California Family Council
California Rise Up
California’s Legislative Voice
Carlsbad Citizens for Community Oversight
City of Huntington Beach
Our Duty
Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women
26 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Teachers Association writes:
CTA believes in equal rights for all and supports eliminating sex, perceived sex, gender, gender identity and/or gender expression discrimination in educational programs, activities, and facilities. According to the Trevor Project, transgender and non-binary youth face elevated risk for depression, thoughts of suicide, and suicide compared to youth who are cisgender and straight, including cisgender members of the LGBTQ+ community. These higher levels of mental health related issues are attributable in part to the psychological effects of gender non-affirmation, be that by their family and peers, or on government issued vital records that do not conform to their gender identity.
Sealing these petitions will allow the child to develop their gender identity without the pressure of having it become a public matter. Our students deserve to be seen as their authentic self, to live a life that is consistent with their gender identity and expression, and to have that gender identity recognized and affirmed in their home, school, and community.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Our Duty writes in opposition:
The real intent of AB223 is clarified in its last sentence: “Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.” (Emphasis added.) The Supermajority in our Legislature is on a relentless crusade to break up the family unit by granting unprecedented power to children and the adults who cater to their whims. In 2022, the Legislature passed Health & Safety Code 103430, which requires the assent of only one parent in order to permanently change the birth sex and name of their child on official records. While an opposing parent can certainly file a motion to show cause to prevent the changes, that parent never prevails.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 3/23/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Maienschein, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/25/23 13:49:05
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 223 (Author:Ward)
Version: June 5, 2023
Hearing Date: June 13, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Change of gender and sex identifier
DIGEST
This bill provides for specified records to be kept confidential by the courts where minors petition for a change of gender and sex identifier, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins, Ch. 853, Stats. 2017) restructured the processes for individuals to change their names and genders to conform with their gender identity and to have these changes reflected on their birth certificates. In addition, a streamlined process was established for changing one’s name and gender and having an updated birth certificate issued as part of a single petition. Specific guidelines and required procedures were laid out for petitioners.
A number of bills last session further honed these processes and fine tuned the applicable provisions, in part in response to issues identified by the Judicial Council of California. Special procedural rules apply when the petitioner is a minor. In response to concerns about the privacy and wellbeing of these minor petitioners, this bill requires petitions and associated papers to be kept confidential by the courts when a minor petitions for a change of gender and sex identifier or a name change and recognition of the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier. The court is required to limit access to the records to only the minor and specified representatives of the minor, including the minor’s parents or guardians and any legal representatives.
This bill is sponsored by TransFamily Support Services and TransYouth Liberation. It is supported by the California Federation of Teachers and the National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter. There is opposition from a number of faith groups and other organizations, including the California Family Council and the Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that a person may file a petition with a superior court seeking a judgment recognizing the change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary. If requested, the judgment shall include an order that a new birth certificate be prepared reflecting the change of gender and any name change accomplished by an order of a court of this state, another state, the District of Columbia, or any territory of the United States. (Health & Saf. Code § 103425.)
- Provides the process for a petitioner seeking a court order to recognize a change in the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier as female, male, or nonbinary and to direct the issuance of new administrative documents to reflect those changes. Such petitions must be accompanied by an affidavit from the petitioner and a certified copy of the court order changing the petitioner’s name, if applicable. The petitioner’s affidavit shall be accepted as conclusive proof of gender change if it contains substantially the following language: “I, (petitioner’s full name), hereby attest under penalty of perjury that the request for a change in gender to (female, male, or nonbinary) is to conform my legal gender to my gender identity and is not for any fraudulent purpose.” (Health & Saf. Code § 103430.)
- Requires the court to grant the above petition without a hearing if no written objection is timely filed. The relevant court order can include an order for a new birth certificate reflecting the petitioner’s change in gender and name, where applicable. The law provides additional processes for a petitioner under 18 years of age. (Health & Saf. Code § 103430.)
- Authorizes a single petition to be filed to change the petitioner’s name and recognize the change to the petitioner’s gender, and, if requested, to order the issuance of a new birth certificate. (Health & Saf. Code §§ 103435, 103445, 103725.)
- Provides that whenever a person born in this state has their name changed by order of a court of this state, another state, the District of Columbia, or any territory of the United States, an application including an affidavit of this fact may be filed with the office of the State Registrar upon a form provided for that purpose. (Health & Saf. Code § 103400.)
- Provides the court procedures for effectuating the above changes. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1275 et seq.)
This bill:
- Requires the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding to change an individual’s gender or sex identifier or change their name and to recognize the change in gender and sex identifier to be kept confidential by the courts where the petitioner is under 18 years of age.
- Requires the court to limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the minor, any adult who signed the petition, the minor’s parents or guardians or guardians ad litem, and any attorneys representing these individuals.
COMMENTS
- Civil rights and government documents
Over the past decade, the struggles of the transgender and gender nonconforming communities have become part of the American zeitgeist, particularly as various media have explored the institutional challenges facing these communities. In order to live safe, full, and authentic lives, it is essential that transgender and gender nonconforming people have access to identity documents that accurately reflect their true name, gender identity, and gender expression. The ability to change one’s documentation or status can have a significant impact on all other aspects of a person’s life including employment, marriage, and inheritance rights. A National Transgender Discrimination Survey found that 90 percent of transgender people experienced mistreatment or discrimination at work or took actions to avoid such discrimination.[1] Nearly 47 percent of those surveyed lost their jobs, were denied a promotion, or were denied a job as a direct result of being transgender.
Difficulty is created by the fact that each state (and, for foreign-born United States residents and citizens, each country) and the federal government have their own rules and restrictions on changing names and gender marker information. Even within California, the various agencies that issue identity documents have different requirements for changing name and gender markers, as well as a separate process for doing so.
- California’s efforts to address these issues
In recent years, the Legislature has addressed the hurdles faced by the transgender community. To address the barriers faced by transgender individuals going through the court process for name changes, AB 1121 (Atkins, Ch. 651, Stats. 2013) was introduced and enacted into law. It required courts to grant petitions for a change of name sought to conform an individual’s name to the individual’s gender identity without a hearing if no timely objection is made. The legislation also exempted such requests from the publication requirement.
AB 1121 also created an administrative process by which California-born individuals can submit an affidavit of a physician attesting that the person has undergone clinically appropriate treatment for the purpose of a gender transition, along with a fee, directly to the State Registrar and thereby change the person’s gender on the person’s birth certificate. This eliminated the need for the court to review a gender change petition, simplifying the process for transgender individuals to update the gender marker on their birth certificates and allowing persons born in California, but now residing out of state, to update their birth certificate to match their gender remotely. This administrative process to change one’s gender on a birth certificate is far more cost-effective and accessible for transgender individuals.
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins, Ch. 853, Stats. 2017) streamlined these processes even further and updated the required documentation to reflect an evolved understanding of gender identity. The bill created a standalone statute governing legal name changes sought to conform one’s legal gender to the person’s gender identity. The new section requires the court to make an order reciting the filing of the person’s petition. It provided that if no objection is received to the proposed name change within six weeks of the order, the court must grant the name change. There is no requirement for publication. A hearing is not to be set unless a timely objection shows good reason against the change of name.
In addition, realizing that an individual’s gender identity is not contingent on whether the individual has received any associated medical treatment, SB 179 removed the requirement that individuals submit medical documentation in order to change the individual’s gender on a birth certificate or to obtain a court-ordered gender change.
A person instead must provide an affidavit in which the person attests under penalty of perjury that the request for a change in gender is to conform the person’s legal gender to the person’s gender identity. For a court-ordered gender change, the court is required to accept the individual’s affidavit as conclusive proof of gender change.
- Expansion of existing processes for additional documents
Last session, several bills further honed the processes. AB 218 (Ward, Ch. 577, Stats. 2021) took the next step in providing more inclusive processes for the transgender and gender nonconforming communities. That bill extended the existing framework for petitioners changing their names and/or genders on their own birth certificates to further update their marriage licenses and certificates and the birth certificates of their children. It also extended eligibility for certain processes to persons not born or residing within the state and recognized orders in foreign jurisdictions for purposes of sufficient documentation.
Section 103425 of the Health and Safety Code provides that a person may file a petition with the superior court in any county seeking a judgment recognizing the change of gender to female, male, or nonbinary. A petitioner can request that a new birth certificate be ordered in the judgment, reflecting the change in gender and a change in name, as specified. AB 218 allowed for the judgment to additionally include an order for a new marriage certificate reflecting the change of gender and a similar change of name. Furthermore, an order for a new birth certificate for the petitioner’s child could also be included in such a judgment. These avenues to updated documentation were subject to specific procedures. (Health & Saf. Code § 103430; Code Civ. Proc. § 1275 et seq.) The new marriage certificate can reflect the gender of the petitioner, as specified in the judgment of the court, and reflect any change of name, as specified in the court order.
AB 218 applied a detailed set of rules for petitions requesting new documentation specifying who must sign such petitions and who must be served with notice and an order to show cause. Subsequent to that law being passed, in conjunction with AB 1578 (Committee on Judiciary, Chapter 401, Statutes of 2021), the Judicial Council highlighted a number of internal inconsistencies that created problems with rulemaking around the proper forms to effectuate the intent of these laws. The Judicial Council requested the changes made by this bill.
Under previously existing law, if the person whose gender is to be changed is under 18 years of age, the petition is required to be signed by at least one of the minor’s parents or a guardian or attorney of the minor, or if both parents are deceased and there is no guardian of the minor, by a near relative or friend of the minor. If the petition does not include a signature from one of those persons, the court is required to make an order directing the person or persons whose required signatures are not on the petition to show cause why the petition should not be granted by filing a written objection.
Last year, AB 421 (Ward, Ch. 40, Stats. 2022) required the court, if the petition is not signed by all living parents, to make that order and to direct the parent or parents who did not sign the petition to show cause why the petition should not be granted by filing a written objection. AB 421 also required the court, where all parents are deceased or cannot be located, to make an order directing the living grandparents to show cause why the petition for a court order to recognize a change in the minor’s gender and sex identifier should not be granted, as specified.
This bill again amends these processes for minors. Concerns have arisen regarding the privacy of minor petitioners seeking a change in gender or sex identifier. TransFamily Support Services and TransYouth Liberation, the sponsors of the bill, explain:
Transgender youth have been outed by ill intended individuals conducting searches on the internet, revealing public records of gender marker and name changes. This leads to social humiliation, bullying and outing that has long lasting mental consequences to an individual who is already experiencing the impacts of marginalization and the internal distress that they may be experiencing from gender dysphoria. The very real consequences of neglecting to protect these youth may mean higher rates of anxiety, depression, and hospitalizations due to mental health concerns, and can escalate to heightened risks of self harm and suicide attempts.
This bill addresses these concerns by requiring petitions and associated papers submitted by minors to be kept confidential by the courts. This applies where the minor is seeking a change of gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103430 or seeking a change to the petitioner’s name and to also recognize the change of the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier pursuant to Section 103435. The court is required to limit access to the court records in the proceeding, including the register of actions, to the following people:
- the minor;
- any adult who signed the petition;
- the minor’s parents or guardians or guardians ad litem; and
- any attorneys representing these individuals.
The author states the purpose of the bill:
Being “outed” is a traumatic event for anyone –– but especially traumatic for someone under the age of 18 years old, The Transgender Youth Privacy Act gives transgender youth the confidence to navigate their gender identity without fear of retaliation from someone who discovers that information in the public record.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making common sense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change to make the petition and resulting paperwork confidential. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
Given that the bill places a limitation on the public’s right of access to public records, the bill states the following justification:
It is in the best interest for the public to keep these records confidential to ensure the privacy and safety of transgender and nonbinary youth. Transgender and nonbinary youth are 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBQ peers. Being outed is a traumatic event for any individual, especially for individuals under 18 years of age. Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.
- Additional support and opposition
The California Teachers Association writes in support:
CTA believes in equal rights for all and supports eliminating sex, perceived sex, gender, gender identity and/or gender expression discrimination in educational programs, activities, and facilities. According to the Trevor Project, transgender and non-binary youth face elevated risk for depression, thoughts of suicide, and suicide compared to youth who are cisgender and straight, including cisgender members of the LGBTQ+ community. These higher levels of mental health related issues are attributable in part to the psychological effects of gender non-affirmation, be that by their family and peers, or on government issued vital records that do not conform to their gender identity.
Sealing these petitions will allow the child to develop their gender identity without the pressure of having it become a public matter. Our students deserve to be seen as their authentic self, to live a life that is consistent with their gender identity and expression, and to have that gender identity recognized and affirmed in their home, school, and community.
Our Duty writes in opposition:
The real intent of AB223 is clarified in its last sentence: “Allowing our children to choose when and how they decide to share their personal details is vital in protecting their mental and physical health.” (Emphasis added.) The Supermajority in our Legislature is on a relentless crusade to break up the family unit by granting unprecedented power to children and the adults who cater to their whims. In 2022, the Legislature passed Health & Safety Code 103430, which requires the assent of only one parent in order to permanently change the birth sex and name of their child on official records. While an opposing parent can certainly file a motion to show cause to prevent the changes, that parent never prevails.
SUPPORT
TransFamily Support Services (co-sponsor)
TransYouth Liberation (co-sponsor)
ACLU California Action
American Association of University Women - California
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California Teachers Association
Disability Rights California
Equality California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Oakland Privacy
OPPOSITION
Bridge Network
California Family Council
California’s Legislative Voice
Our Duty
Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 760 (Wilson, 2023) facilitates students, staff, and faculty to declare an affirmed name and/or gender identification to be used in records where their legal names are not required in the California State University and University of California college systems. AB 760 is currently in this Committee.
AB 1720 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023) makes numerous provisions within the Education Code gender neutral, and makes additional non-substantive changes. AB 1720 is currently in this Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 421 (Ward, Ch. 40, Stats. 2022) See Comment 3.
AB 1578 (Assembly Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 401, Stats. 2021) See Comment 3.
AB 218 (Ward, Ch. 577, Stats. 2021) See Comment 3.
SB 179 (Atkins, Ch. 853, Stats. 2017) See Comment 2.
AB 1121 (Atkins, Ch. 651, Stats. 2013) See Comment 2.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 63, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 1)
**************
Jaime M. Grant et al., Injustice at Every Turn: A Report of the National Transgender Discrimination Survey (2011) National Center for Transgender Equality and National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/resources/NTDS_Report.pdf [as of June 1, 2023]. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 223
Author:(Ward)
As Introduced Ver:January 10, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Enhances protections for minors seeking changes of name or gender by making the proceedings presumptively confidential.
Major Provisions
- Provides that if a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier, or a single petition for change to the petitioner's name and to recognize the change of the petitioner's gender and sex identifier, is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding are to be filed under seal.
- Makes various findings and declarations related to the need to limit information for the public.
COMMENTS
In recent years, California courts and the Legislature have worked together to revise and streamline the procedures for Californians wishing to change their legal name, official gender, and sex identifier. Additional procedures were added for minors wishing to change their name and identifiers by generally requiring that the minors obtain the permission of parents, legal guardians, or other living relatives. Seeking to protect these minors from additional and unnecessary bullying, this bill simply ensures that the proceedings to change a minor's legal name, official gender, and sex identifier are presumptively filed under seal so they are confidential and not subject to public disclosure.
Existing name change and gender change procedures for transgender individuals. In 2013, the Legislature enacted AB 1121 (Atkins), Chapter 651, Statutes of 2013, which reduced burdens for transgender individuals seeking a name change. AB 1121 required courts to grant petitions for a change of name sought to conform an individual's name to the individual's gender identity without a hearing if no timely objection is made. The legislation also exempted such requests from the publication requirement. AB 1121 also created an administrative process by which California-born individuals can submit an affidavit of a physician attesting that they have undergone clinically appropriate treatment for the purpose of a gender transition directly to the State Registrar and thereby change the person's gender on the person's birth certificate. This eliminated the need for the court to review a gender change petition, simplifying the process for transgender individuals to update the gender marker on their birth certificates and therefore allowing persons to more easily update their birth certificate to match their gender remotely.
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins), Chapter 853, Statutes of 2017, further refined and updated the required documentation to reflect an evolved understanding of gender identity. The bill created a standalone statute governing legal name changes sought to conform a person's legal gender with their gender identity. The new provision requires the court to make an order reciting the filing of the person's petition. It provided that if no objection is received to the proposed name change, the court must grant the name change. There is no requirement for publication. A hearing is not set unless a timely objection shows good reason against the change of name. In addition, realizing the reality that gender identity is not contingent on whether an individual has received any medical treatment for purposes of a gender transition, SB 179 of 2017 removed the requirement that individuals submit medical documentation in order to change the individual's gender on a birth certificate or to obtain a court-ordered gender change. A person instead must provide an affidavit in which the person attests, under penalty of perjury, that the request for a change in gender is to conform the person's legal gender to the person's gender identity. For a court-ordered gender change, the court is required to accept the individual's affidavit as conclusive proof of gender change.
SB 179 of 2017 also required the State Registrar to issue a new birth certificate, reflecting a change of gender, without a court order for any person born in this state who submits directly to the State Registrar an application to change the gender on the birth certificate and an affidavit attesting under penalty of perjury that (1) the request for a change of gender is to conform the person's legal gender to the person's gender identity, and (2) is not made for any fraudulent purpose. In 2021, AB 218 (Ward) Chapter 577, Statutes of 2021 aligned the process for updating transgender marriage certificates and the birth certificates of their children's with the process for updating the person's own birth certificate.
It should be noted that as a result of these bills, special procedures were adopted for minors seeking legal name and gender changes. The existing law requires a minor seeking a court-recognized name and gender change to have the signature of at least one parent or guardian, or if those cannot be found, the signature of another close relative. Persons, including other relatives, are permitted to object to these proceedings and show cause as to why the name change should not proceed so long as the objection is done in accordance with the procedural guidelines set forth in existing law.
This bill, according to the Trevor Project, transgender youth are nearly twice as likely as youth at large to seriously consider suicide or self-harm (Dorison, Greene & Price-Feeny, Understanding the Mental Health of Transgender and Nonbinary Youth (2019) 66 Journal of Adolescent Health 684, 686.). Many of the ideations towards self-harm stem from the stressors created by the "perceived discrimination and physical harm" directed toward transgender and nonbinary youth. (Id. at 689.) To better protect transgender and nonbinary youth from this discrimination, the bill seeks to prevent a youth from being "outed" as a result of a public court record that reveals a past name and gender change. Accordingly, this measure simply directs that all legal matters in which a minor seeks a name and gender change are to be consider sealed, thus preventing the records from becoming public.
Enabling minor's petitions for changes in name and gender does not usurp parental rights, promote or require any medical interventions, unnecessarily infringe on the public's right to access the courts, or present evidentiary burdens in other legal proceedings. Opposition raises several perplexing arguments against this relatively straightforward measure, many of which demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of transgender individuals and the legal system. First, the opposition appears to conflate changing one's legal name, gender, sex identifier with undergoing sex reassignment surgery and receiving gender-affirming medical care. For example, in opposition to this measure, the California Family Council argues, "our laws should encourage children to love their bodies, not change them by cutting off their healthy body parts and taking sterilizing hormones for the rest of their lives." However, existing provisions of the Health and Safety Code contain reveals no provisions requiring a person to have undergone sexual reassignment surgery, or to be undergoing gender affirming care, in order to be eligible for a court-granted change to their legal name and gender identity. Thus, these concerns appear unfounded as that is not what this measure seeks to accomplish.
Secondly, the opposition appears to misunderstand the existing legal procedures required before a minor can legally change their name and gender identity. The group Real Impact claims this bill will, "require the court to withhold a minor's legal petition for a change of gender and sex identifier from the public and more importantly, the minor's parents." The Pacific Justice Institute appears to further misunderstand the process, contending, "Judges, not politicians, are in the best position to determine which documents should be filed under seal in the cases before them. Imposing a blanket exception for a politically connected sexual minority group does not advance the interests of justice." It should be noted that simply because a record is filed under seal does not remove any authority for a judge as to whether or not to grant a petition for a name change. Secondly, nothing in this bill limits a parent's right to weigh in on their child's request to change their name and gender identity. In fact, existing law generally requires a parent or legal guardian to sign off on the petition to the court. In the event one parent approves of the minor's wishes and the other disapproves, nothing in this measure circumvents the disapproving parent's ability to show cause to the court as to why the petition should not be granted. Only in the case where a minor's parents could not be found, perhaps because the parents are deceased or a minor was forced to flee the home of transphobic parents, is the minor permitted to have a non-parental family member or legal guardian sign the petition for the name and gender identity change.
The opposition also contends that the measure violates the general principle that court records be open to the public. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court has held that the public possesses a First Amendment right to access court records and proceedings, holding that public access can only be denied in the presence of, "an overriding interest based on findings that closure is essential to preserve higher values and is narrowly tailored to serve those values." (Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court (1986) 478 U.S. 1, 9.) Nonetheless, the Supreme Court has also held that absent a near complete closure of court proceedings, the public's right to access judicial proceedings is judged via a common law standard whereby the, "decision whether to permit access is best left to the sound discretion of the trial court, a discretion to be exercised in light of the relevant facts and circumstances of the particular case." (Nixon v. Time Warner Communications, Inc., (1978) 435 U.S. 589, 598-99.) Given that nothing in this bill directly closes the court proceeding itself, the common law standard would almost certainly apply. In certain instances of applying the common law, the Ninth Circuit has gone so far as to apply a mere "good cause" standard for sealing records. (Center for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Group, LLC, (2016) 809 F.3d 1092.) Additionally, the Legislature is also free to refine the standards utilized by a court absent direct constitutional direction to the contrary. Looking at the "relevant facts and circumstances," and in light of the statics that transgender youth are far more likely to self-harm than their non-transgender peers, this bill appears to easily satisfy the legal standards necessary for sealing court records.
Finally, the opposition contends that sealing the record of a minor's change of name, gender, and sexual identity may impede law enforcement or private civil actions. One organization, Women II Women argues, "Should this bill pass, California will be placing females in precarious positions with no ability for safeguarding. This bill will be a [sic.] impediment for females that feel a male gaze on their bodies in the changing facilities to have the evidence to provide their Title IX claims, if they are not able to show evidence of the sex of the perpertrator [sic.]." Beyond rehashing the tired and hateful stereotype that transgender persons simply want to use facilities of the opposite sex for nefarious purposes, again, this interpretation of the bill misunderstands or misconstrues basic court procedures. In fact, no record necessarily is sealed forever. Rule 2.551 of the California Rules of Court explicitly provides a process for unsealing any court record. The existing procedure has largely been in place since 2007, and this Committee is unaware of any serious complaints from law enforcement or the plaintiff's bar regarding their inability to unseal records that are necessary for investigation or litigation.
According to the Author
Being ‘outed' is a traumatic event for anyone –– but especially traumatic for someone under the age of 18 years old. The Transgender Youth Privacy Act gives transgender youth the confidence to navigate their gender identity without fear of retaliation from someone who discovers that information in the public record.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making common sense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change to place the petition and resulting paperwork under seal. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
Arguments in Support
This modest and straightforward measure is supported by ACLU California Action and Oakland Privacy. In support of the measure the ACLU writes:
California has provided the tools needed for minors to change their vital records to match their gender identity; however, the petition and paperwork are a matter of public information discoverable with a simple internet search. In some cases, this becomes known when a third party, such as a classmate, discovers this information and "outs" them to their peers.
A 2020 study by The Trevor Project's researchers found that transgender and non-binary youth were 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBTQ peers. These higher levels of mental health related issues are attributable in part to the psychological effects of gender non-affirmation, be that by their family and peers, or on government-issued vital records that do not conform to their gender identity.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making commonsense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change in placing the petition and resulting paperwork under seal. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
Arguments in Opposition
As noted several religious and other groups who oppose transgender individuals oppose this measure. Representative of the coalition, the California Family Council writes:
Please stop and consider the unintended consequences of telling every kid their biology has nothing to do with their gender, then letting them falsify governments regarding their sex and hiding that as though it never happened.
Until recently, no country in all of human history has let people legally change their sex. If anyone can become a woman, a man, or another made-up gender as a matter of law, then sex and gender as meaningful categories disappear.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-1-0
YES: Maienschein, Essayli, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: January 10, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000022
Date of Hearing: March 14, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 223
Author:(Ward) – As Introduced Ver:January 10, 2023
SUBJECT: Change of gender and sex identifier
KEY ISSUE: in order to better protect transgender youth from inadvertent outing, needless bullying, and discriminatory harassment, should a petition to the court for the change of a person’s name, gender, and sex identifier be presumptively filed under seal, and therefore confidential, if the person is a minor?
SYNOPSIS
In recent years the Legislature, and specifically this Committee, have sought to clarify and streamline the process for persons seeking to legally change their name, gender, and sex identifier for the purposes of official records. This modest measure builds on those efforts, and seeks to protect transgender youth, by presumptively sealing the petition for a name, gender and sex identifier change if the petition is filed by a minor. It should be noted that nothing in the measure changes the existing procedures for a minor seeking a name, gender and sex identifier change, including the general requirement that a parent or guardian sign the petition for a name gender, or sex identifier change and that the petition is subject to challenge.
This bill is supported by several civil rights organizations, including ACLU California Action and Oakland Privacy. The proponents of this measure note that transgender youth are significantly more likely to contemplate or engage in acts of self-harm when compared with their cisgender peers. These proponents note that sealing these sensitive court records will reduce the instances of a minor being inadvertently outed and exposed to social stigma and bullying. This measure is opposed by a coalition of religious, “pro-family,” and other groups who oppose transgender individuals. These groups make several arguments that misconstrue and misrepresent the legal process for changing a person’s name, gender, and sex identifier, and rehash several discriminatory and inaccurate stereotypes regarding transgender individuals, including by attempting to cite a Reddit page as evidence to support their claims. Despite the opposition’s contentions, this modest measure will support and protect transgender youth and follows this Committee’s prior approval of measures clarifying the court processes for approving petitions for change in a person’s legal name, gender and sex identifier.
SUMMARY: Enhances protections for minors seeking changes of name or gender by making the proceedings presumptively confidential. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that if a person who seeks a change of gender and sex identifier, or a single petition for change to the petitioner’s name and to recognize the change of the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier, is under 18 years of age, the petition and any papers associated with the proceeding are to be filed under seal.
- Makes various findings and declarations related to the need to limit information for the public.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all applications for changes of names to be made in the superior court of the county where the person whose name is to be changed resides by either of the following methods:
- By petition signed by the person or, if the person is under 18 years of age, by one of the person’s parents, by any guardian of the person; or
- If both parents are deceased and there is no guardian of the person, then by some near relative or friend of the person, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1276 (a).)
- Requires, upon the application described in 1), the court to make an order reciting the filing of the petition, the name of the person by whom it is filed, and the name proposed, and order all persons interested in the matter to appear before the court at a time and place specified, which is not to be less than 6 weeks nor more than 12 weeks from the time of making the order, unless the court orders a different time, to show cause why the application for change of name should not be granted. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1277 (a)(1).)
- Requires the court to direct all persons interested in the matter described in 1) to make known any objection that they may have to the granting of the petition for change of name by filing a written objection, which includes the reasons for the objection, with the court at least two court days before the matter is scheduled to be heard and by appearing in court at the hearing to show cause why the petition for change of name should not be granted. (Ibid.)
- Provides that a petition for a court order to recognize a change in the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier as female, male, or nonbinary and to direct the issuance of new administrative documents to reflect those changes must be accompanied by an affidavit from the petitioner and a certified copy of the court order changing the petitioner’s name, if applicable. The petitioner’s affidavit must be accepted as conclusive proof of gender change if it contains substantially the following language: “I, (petitioner’s full name), hereby attest under penalty of perjury that the request for a change in gender to (female, male, or nonbinary) is to conform my legal gender to my gender identity and is not for any fraudulent purpose.” (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (a).)
- Requires if the person whose gender is to be changed in accordance with 4) is under 18 years of age, the petition must be signed by either of the following:
- By at least one of the minor’s parents, any guardian of the minor, or a specified person; or
- If both parents are deceased and there is no guardian of the minor, by either a near relative or friend of the minor. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (b)(1).)
- Requires, if the person whose gender is to be changed in accordance with 4), requests in their petition the issuance of a new marriage license and certificate or confidential marriage license and certificate to be signed by the spouse who shares the marriage license and certificate or confidential marriage license and certificate that would be changed by granting the petition if the spouse is living and capable of signing the petition or, if not signed by a living and capable spouse, notice to be given to the nonsigning spouse. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (b)(2).)
- Provides that if a petition to recognize a change of gender of a minor does not include the signature of all living parents, then upon receipt of the petition, the court must make an order directing the parent or parents who did not sign the petition to show cause as to why the petition for a court order to recognize a change in the minor’s gender and sex identifier to female, male, or nonbinary should not be granted by filing a written objection, which includes any reasons for the objection, within six weeks of the making of the order, and state that if no objection showing good cause to oppose the gender recognition is timely filed, the court must, without hearing, enter the order that the gender and sex identifier recognition is granted. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (e)(1).)
- Provides that if a petition to recognize a change of gender of a minor is filed, and all parents are deceased or cannot be located, then upon receipt of the petition, the court must make an order directing the living grandparents to show cause why the petition for a court order to recognize a change in the minor’s gender and sex identifier to female, male, or nonbinary should not be granted by filing a written objection, which includes any reasons for the objection, within six weeks of the making of the order, and state that if no objection showing good cause to oppose the gender recognition is timely filed, the court must, without hearing, enter the order that the gender and sex identifier recognition is granted. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (e)(2).)
- Requires, if the person whose gender is to be changed requests in their petition the issuance of a new birth certificate for their adult child the petition must be signed by the child whose birth certificate would be changed by granting the petition if the child is 18 years of age or older. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (b)(3).)
- Requires that if the petition and the order to show cause is made in accordance with 7) or 8) it must be served on the required person or persons who did not sign the petition, as specified, within four weeks from the date on which the order is made by the court, and that if service cannot reasonably be accomplished, the court may order that service be accomplished in a manner that the court determines is reasonably calculated to give actual notice to the person who did not sign the petition. (Health and Safety Code Section 103430 (f).)
- Provides that, in lieu of separate proceedings, a single petition may be filed with the superior court to change the petitioner’s name and recognize the change to the petitioner’s gender and sex identifier and, if requested, to order the issuance of a new birth certificate, marriage license and certificate, confidential marriage license and certificate, or birth certificate of the petitioner’s child. (Health and Safety Code Section 103435 (a).)
- Specifies the procedure for alerting various state agencies of a petitioner’s successfully approved new name, gender and sex identifier. (Health and Safety Code Section 103435 (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: In recent years, California courts and the Legislature have worked together to revise and streamline the procedures for Californians wishing to change their legal name, official gender, and sex identifier. Additional procedures were added for minors wishing to change their name and identifiers by generally requiring that the minors obtain the permission of parents, legal guardians, or other living relatives. Seeking to protect these minors from additional and unnecessary bullying, this bill simply ensures that the proceedings to change a minor’s legal name, official gender, and sex identifier are presumptively filed under seal so they are confidential and not subject to public disclosure. In support of the bill, the author states:
Being ‘outed’ is a traumatic event for anyone –– but especially traumatic for someone under the age of 18 years old. The Transgender Youth Privacy Act gives transgender youth the confidence to navigate their gender identity without fear of retaliation from someone who discovers that information in the public record.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making common sense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change to place the petition and resulting paperwork under seal. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
Background on name change and the procedures. It is well established in the common law that a person has the right to change their name. (In re Ross (1937) 8 Cal.2d 608, 609.) Although the statutory procedure is merely a way to record that name change, a formal process is generally required to change a person’s other identity documents, such as a California’s driver’s license, a U.S. passport, or Social Security records. Under the statutory framework, a person seeking a name change files a petition with the court, where the court thereafter issues an order to show cause (an order that provides other parties with notice about the opportunity to object to the name change petition at a scheduled hearing). In many cases, the order to show cause must be published in a newspaper of general circulation. If no objections are filed with the court, the court may grant the name change petition without a hearing. The name change procedures can vary slightly for certain individuals deemed to be at risk by the courts or the Legislature (e.g., minors, victims of domestic violence, and transgender individuals).
Existing name change and gender change procedures for transgender individuals. In 2013, the Legislature enacted AB 1121 (Atkins), Chap. 651, Stats. 2013, which reduced burdens for transgender individuals seeking a name change. AB 1121 required courts to grant petitions for a change of name sought to conform an individual’s name to the individual’s gender identity without a hearing if no timely objection is made. The legislation also exempted such requests from the publication requirement. AB 1121 also created an administrative process by which California-born individuals can submit an affidavit of a physician attesting that they have undergone clinically appropriate treatment for the purpose of a gender transition directly to the State Registrar (along with a fee) and thereby change the person’s gender on the person’s birth certificate. This eliminated the need for the court to review a gender change petition, simplifying the process for transgender individuals to update the gender marker on their birth certificates and therefore allowing persons to more easily update their birth certificate to match their gender remotely.
In 2017, SB 179 (Atkins), Chap. 853, Stats. 2017, streamlined these processes even further and updated the required documentation to reflect an evolved understanding of gender identity. The bill created a standalone statute governing legal name changes sought to conform a person’s legal gender with their gender identity. The new provision requires the court to make an order reciting the filing of the person’s petition. It provided that if no objection is received to the proposed name change, the court must grant the name change. There is no requirement for publication. A hearing is not set unless a timely objection shows good reason against the change of name. In addition, realizing the reality that gender identity is not contingent on whether an individual has received any medical treatment for purposes of a gender transition, SB 179 removed the requirement that individuals submit medical documentation in order to change the individual’s gender on a birth certificate or to obtain a court-ordered gender change. A person instead must provide an affidavit in which the person attests, under penalty of perjury, that the request for a change in gender is to conform the person’s legal gender to the person’s gender identity. For a court-ordered gender change, the court is required to accept the individual’s affidavit as conclusive proof of gender change.
SB 179 also required the State Registrar to issue a new birth certificate, reflecting a change of gender, without a court order for any person born in this state who submits directly to the State Registrar an application to change the gender on the birth certificate and an affidavit attesting under penalty of perjury that (1) the request for a change of gender is to conform the person's legal gender to the person's gender identity, and (2) is not made for any fraudulent purpose. In 2021, AB 218 (Ward) Chap. 577, Stats. 2021 aligned the process for updating transgender marriage certificates and the birth certificates of their children’s with the process for updating the person’s own birth certificate.
It should be noted that as a result of these bills, special procedures were adopted for minors seeking legal name and gender changes. The existing law requires a minor seeking a court-recognized name and gender change to have the signature of at least one parent or guardian, or if those cannot be found, the signature of another close relative. Persons, including other relatives, are permitted to object to these proceedings and show cause as to why the name change should not proceed so long as the objection is done in accordance with the procedural guidelines set forth in existing law.
This bill. According to the Trevor Project, transgender youth are nearly twice as likely as youth at large to seriously consider suicide or self-harm. (Dorison, Greene & Price-Feeny, Understanding the Mental Health of Transgender and Nonbinary Youth (2019) 66 Journal of Adolescent Health 684, 686.) Many of the ideations towards self-harm stem from the stressors created by the “perceived discrimination and physical harm” directed toward transgender and nonbinary youth. (Id. at 689.) To better protect transgender and nonbinary youth from this discrimination, the bill seeks to prevent a youth from being “outed” as a result of a public court record that reveals a past name and gender change. Accordingly, this measure simply directs that all legal matters in which a minor seeks a name and gender change are to be consider sealed, thus preventing the records from becoming public.
Enabling minor’s petitions for changes in name and gender does not usurp parental rights, promote or require any medical interventions, unnecessarily infringe on the public’s right to access the courts, or present evidentiary burdens in other legal proceedings. This Committee has received numerous letters in opposition to the bill that provide several perplexing arguments against this relatively straightforward measure, many of which demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of transgender individuals and the legal system. First, the opposition appears to conflate changing one’s legal name, gender, sex identifier with undergoing sex reassignment surgery and receiving gender-affirming medical care. For example, in opposition to this measure, the California Family Council argues, “our laws should encourage children to love their bodies, not change them by cutting off their healthy body parts and taking sterilizing hormones for the rest of their lives.” However, as noted above, an examination of the existing provisions of the Health and Safety Code, regarding legal gender or sexual identity changes, reveals no provisions requiring a person to have undergone sexual reassignment surgery, or to be undergoing gender affirming care, in order to be eligible for a court-granted change to their legal name and gender identity. Thus, these concerns appear unfounded as that is not what this measure seeks to accomplish.
Secondly, the opposition appears to misunderstand the existing legal procedures required before a minor can legally change their name and gender identity. The group Real Impact claims this bill will, “require the court to withhold a minor’s legal petition for a change of gender and sex identifier from the public and more importantly, the minor’s parents.” The Pacific Justice Institute appears to further misunderstand the process, contending, “Judges, not politicians, are in the best position to determine which documents should be filed under seal in the cases before them. Imposing a blanket exception for a politically connected sexual minority group does not advance the interests of justice.” It should be noted that simply because a record is filed under seal does not remove any authority for a judge as to whether or not to grant a petition for a name change. Secondly, nothing in this bill limits a parent’s right to weigh in on their child’s request to change their name and gender identity. In fact, existing law generally requires a parent or legal guardian to sign off on the petition to the court. In the event one parent approves of the minor’s wishes and the other disapproves, nothing in this measure circumvents the disapproving parent’s ability to show cause to the court as to why the petition should not be granted. Only in the case where a minor’s parents could not be found, perhaps because the parents are deceased or a minor was forced to flee the home of transphobic parents, is the minor permitted to have a non-parental family member or legal guardian sign the petition for the name and gender identity change.
The opposition also contends that the measure violates the general principle that court records be open to the public as well as (somewhat confusingly given that it does not directly apply to courts), the California Public Records Act. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court has held that the public possesses a First Amendment right to access court records and proceedings, holding that public access can only be denied in the presence of, “an overriding interest based on findings that closure is essential to preserve higher values and is narrowly tailored to serve those values.” (Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court (1986) 478 U.S. 1, 9.) Nonetheless, the Supreme Court has also held that absent a near complete closure of court proceedings, the public’s right to access judicial proceedings is judged via a common law standard whereby the, “decision whether to permit access is best left to the sound discretion of the trial court, a discretion to be exercised in light of the relevant facts and circumstances of the particular case.” (Nixon v. Time Warner Communications, Inc., (1978) 435 U.S. 589, 598-99.) Given that nothing in this bill directly closes the court proceeding itself, the common law standard would almost certainly apply. In certain instances of applying the common law, the Ninth Circuit has gone so far as to apply a mere “good cause” standard for sealing records. (Center for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Group, LLC, (2016) 809 F.3d 1092.) Additionally, the Legislature is also free to refine the standards utilized by a court absent direct constitutional direction to the contrary. Looking at the “relevant facts and circumstances,” and in light of the statics that transgender youth are far more likely to self-harm than their non-transgender peers, this bill appears to easily satisfy the legal standards necessary for sealing court records.
Finally, the opposition contends that sealing the record of a minor’s change of name, gender, and sexual identity may impede law enforcement or private civil actions. One organization, Women II Women argues, “Should this bill pass, California will be placing females in precarious positions with no ability for safeguarding. This bill will be a [sic.] impediment for females that feel a male gaze on their bodies in the changing facilities to have the evidence to provide their Title IX claims, if they are not able to show evidence of the sex of the perpertrator [sic.].” Beyond rehashing the tired and hateful stereotype that transgender persons simply want to use facilities of the opposite sex for nefarious purposes, again, this interpretation of the bill misunderstands or misconstrues basic court procedures. In fact, no record necessarily is sealed forever. Rule 2.551 of the California Rules of Court explicitly provides a process for unsealing any court record. The existing procedure has largely been in place since 2007, and this Committee is unaware of any serious complaints from law enforcement or the plaintiff’s bar regarding their inability to unseal records that are necessary for investigation or litigation.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This modest and straightforward measure is supported by ACLU California Action and Oakland Privacy. In support of the measure the ACLU writes:
California has provided the tools needed for minors to change their vital records to match their gender identity; however, the petition and paperwork are a matter of public information discoverable with a simple internet search. In some cases, this becomes known when a third party, such as a classmate, discovers this information and “outs” them to their peers.
A 2020 study by The Trevor Project’s researchers found that transgender and non-binary youth were 2 to 2.5 times as likely to experience depressive symptoms, seriously consider suicide, and attempt suicide compared to their cisgender LGBTQ peers. These higher levels of mental health related issues are attributable in part to the psychological effects of gender non-affirmation, be that by their family and peers, or on government-issued vital records that do not conform to their gender identity.
AB 223 protects the privacy and mental health of our transgender and non-binary youth by making commonsense changes to the process for minors seeking a gender or sex identifier change in placing the petition and resulting paperwork under seal. This will allow the individual to retain control over when and where they share their private information.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted several religious and other groups who oppose transgender individuals oppose this measure. Representative of the coalition, the California Family Council writes:
Please stop and consider the unintended consequences of telling every kid their biology has nothing to do with their gender, then letting them falsify governments regarding their sex and hiding that as though it never happened.
Until recently, no country in all of human history has let people legally change their sex. If anyone can become a woman, a man, or another made-up gender as a matter of law, then sex and gender as meaningful categories disappear.
Do you really think you can change the nature of what it means to be a human being without far-reaching consequences? How do you expect future generations to form families? This is cultural suicide. God help us.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
ACLU California Action
Oakland Privacy
Opposition
California Capitol Connection
California Family Council
Our Duty
Pacific Justice Institute
Real Impact.
Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women
The National Center for Law & Policy
The Salt & Light Council
Victory Baptist Church
Woman II Woman
23 Individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):