AB 54: Disability access: construction-related accessibility claims: demand letters.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-30
Existing law prohibits discrimination on the basis of various specified personal characteristics, including disability. The Construction-Related Accessibility Standards Compliance Act establishes standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities and provides for construction-related accessibility claims for violations of those standards. Existing law requires that a copy of the demand letter and the complaint be sent to the California Commission on Disability Access.
This bill would, in addition, require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the commission in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site. The bill would require the commission to post a new standard format on its Internet Web site at least 30 days before requiring information be in the new standard format.
Existing law prohibits discrimination on the basis of various specified personal characteristics, including disability. The Construction-Related Accessibility Standards Compliance Act establishes standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities and provides for construction-related accessibility claims for violations of those standards. Existing law requires that a copy of the demand letter and the complaint be sent to the California Commission on Disability Access.
This bill would, in addition, require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the commission in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site. The bill would require the commission to post a new standard format on its Internet Web site at least 30 days before requiring information be in the new standard format.
Existing law prohibits discrimination on the basis of various specified personal characteristics, including disability. The Construction-Related Accessibility Standards Compliance Act establishes standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities and provides for construction-related accessibility claims for violations of those standards. Existing law requires that a copy of the demand letter and the complaint be sent to the California Commission on Disability Access.
This bill would, in addition, require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the commission in a standard format specified by the commission. commission on the commissions Internet Web site. The bill would require the commission to post a new standard format on its Internet Web site at least 30 days before requiring information be in the new standard format.
(1)Existing
Existing law prohibits discrimination on the basis of various specified personal characteristics, including disability. The Construction-Related Accessibility Standards Compliance Act establishes standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities and provides for construction-related accessibility claims for violations of those standards. Existing law requires that a copy of the demand letter and the complaint be sent to the California Commission on Disability Access.
This bill would, in addition, require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the commission in a standard format specified by the commission.
(2)Existing law specifies that a violation of construction-related accessibility standards personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
This bill would exclude certain technical violations from the scope of this provision, if specified conditions are met.
(3)Under existing law, a defendant is liable for actual damages plus minimum statutory damages for each instance of discrimination relating to a construction-related accessibility standard.
This bill would exempt a defendant from liability for minimum statutory damages with respect to a structure or area inspected by a certified access specialist (CASp) for a period of 120 days if specified conditions are met. The bill would require a defendant who claims the benefit of this provision to disclose the date and findings of any CASp inspection to the plaintiff.
(4)Existing law requires the State Architect to establish and publicize a program for the voluntary certification by the state of any person who meets specified criteria as a CASp. Existing law requires the State Architect to annually publish a list of CASps. Existing law requires each applicant for CASp certification or renewal to pay certain fees, and requires the State Architect to periodically review those fees, as specified. Existing law provides for the deposit of those fees into the Certified Access Specialist Fund, which is continuously appropriated for use by the State Architect to implement the CASp program.
This bill would additionally require the State Architect to publish, and regularly update, easily accessible lists of businesses that file prescribed notices of inspection, and businesses which have been inspected by a CASp on or after January 1, 2017, including the date of the inspection. The bill would require the State Architect to develop a process by which a small business may notify the State Architect that a structure or area has had a CASp inspection and to develop a form for businesses to notify the public that the business has obtained a CASp inspection. The bill would also require applicants for CASp certification or renewal to additionally provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant intends to provide or has provided services, and would require the Division of the State Architect to post that information on its Internet Web site.
(5)Existing law establishes the California Commission on Disability Access for purposes of developing recommendations to enable persons with disabilities to exercise their right to full and equal access to public facilities and facilitating business compliance with applicable state and federal laws and regulations. Existing law sets forth the powers and duties of the commission, including developing educational materials and information for businesses, building owners, tenants, and building officials, posting that information on the commissions Internet Web site, and coordinating with other state agencies and local building departments to ensure that information provided to the public on disability access requirements is uniform and complete.
This bill would additionally require the commission to provide a link on its Internet Web site to the Internet Web site of the Division of the State Architects CASp certification program, and make the commissions educational materials and information available to other state agencies and local building departments.
(6)The Permit Streamlining Act establishes procedures for the application, and review of an application, for a development project. Existing law requires a public agency to notify applicants for development permits of specified information, including the time limits established for the review and approval of development permits.
This bill would additionally require local agencies to develop and provide to applicants materials relating to the requirements of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, or to instead provide similar materials developed by the California Commission on Disability Access. The bill would require a local agency to notify an applicant that approval of a permit does not signify that the applicant has complied with that act. The bill would also require local agencies to expedite review of projects for which the applicant provides a copy of a disability access certificate, demonstrates that the project is necessary to address an alleged violation of a construction-related access standard or a violation noted in a CASp report, and, if project plans are necessary for approval, has had a CASp review the project plans for compliance with all applicable construction-related accessibility standards. The bill would declare that these provisions constitute a matter of statewide concern and shall apply to charter cities and charter counties.
By imposing additional duties on local agencies with respect to the receipt and review of applications for development projects, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(7)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law prohibits discrimination on the basis of various specified personal characteristics, including disability. The Construction-Related Accessibility Standards Compliance Act establishes standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities and provides for construction-related accessibility claims for violations of those standards. Existing law requires that a copy of the demand letter and the complaint be sent to the California Commission on Disability Access.
This bill would, in addition, require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the commission in a standard format specified by the commission.
(2)Existing law specifies that a violation of construction-related accessibility standards personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
This bill would exclude certain technical violations from the scope of this provision, if specified conditions are met.
(3)Under existing law, a defendant is liable for actual damages plus minimum statutory damages for each instance of discrimination relating to a construction-related accessibility standard.
This bill would exempt a defendant from liability for minimum statutory damages with respect to a structure or area inspected by a certified access specialist (CASp) for a period of 120 days if specified conditions are met. The bill would require a defendant who claims the benefit of this provision to disclose the date and findings of any CASp inspection to the plaintiff.
(4)Existing law requires the State Architect to establish and publicize a program for the voluntary certification by the state of any person who meets specified criteria as a CASp. Existing law requires the State Architect to annually publish a list of CASps. Existing law requires each applicant for CASp certification or renewal to pay certain fees, and requires the State Architect to periodically review those fees, as specified. Existing law provides for the deposit of those fees into the Certified Access Specialist Fund, which is continuously appropriated for use by the State Architect to implement the CASp program.
This bill would additionally require the State Architect to publish, and regularly update, easily accessible lists of businesses that file prescribed notices of inspection, and businesses which have been inspected by a CASp on or after January 1, 2017, including the date of the inspection. The bill would require the State Architect to develop a process by which a small business may notify the State Architect that a structure or area has had a CASp inspection and to develop a form for businesses to notify the public that the business has obtained a CASp inspection. The bill would also require applicants for CASp certification or renewal to additionally provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant intends to provide or has provided services, and would require the Division of the State Architect to post that information on its Internet Web site.
(5)Existing law establishes the California Commission on Disability Access for purposes of developing recommendations to enable persons with disabilities to exercise their right to full and equal access to public facilities and facilitating business compliance with applicable state and federal laws and regulations. Existing law sets forth the powers and duties of the commission, including developing educational materials and information for businesses, building owners, tenants, and building officials, posting that information on the commissions Internet Web site, and coordinating with other state agencies and local building departments to ensure that information provided to the public on disability access requirements is uniform and complete.
This bill would additionally require the commission to provide a link on its Internet Web site to the Internet Web site of the Division of the State Architects CASp certification program, and make the commissions educational materials and information available to other state agencies and local building departments.
(6)The Permit Streamlining Act establishes procedures for the application, and review of an application, for a development project. Existing law requires a public agency to notify applicants for development permits of specified information, including the time limits established for the review and approval of development permits.
This bill would additionally require local agencies to develop and provide to applicants materials relating to the requirements of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, or to instead provide similar materials developed by the California Commission on Disability Access. The bill would require a local agency to notify an applicant that approval of a permit does not signify that the applicant has complied with that act. The bill would also require local agencies to expedite review of projects for which the applicant provides a copy of a disability access certificate, demonstrates that the project is necessary to address an alleged violation of a construction-related access standard or a violation noted in a CASp report, and, if project plans are necessary for approval, has had a CASp review the project plans for compliance with all applicable construction-related accessibility standards. The bill would declare that these provisions constitute a matter of statewide concern and shall apply to charter cities and charter counties.
By imposing additional duties on local agencies with respect to the receipt and review of applications for development projects, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(7)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(2)Existing law grants an owner or tenant of a site, defined as a place of public accommodation, that has been inspected by a certified access specialist (CASp) and determined to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards specified rights in an action that includes a construction-related accessibility claim.
The Personal Income Tax Law and the Corporation Tax Law, in specified conformity to federal law, allow a credit against the taxes imposed by those laws, to eligible small businesses for 50% of eligible access expenditures, which are defined as those amounts paid or incurred by the taxpayer to comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, as provided, not to exceed $250.
This bill, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, would include as an eligible access expenditure any amount paid or incurred by a taxpayer to receive an inspection by a CASp.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
(1)Existing law allows a plaintiff to collect statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff was denied full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, as specified. Existing law imposes a $1,000 limit on statutory damages when a defendant demonstrates that the defendant has, among other things, cured the construction-related accessibility violation within 60 days of being served with a complaint. Existing law requires a demand letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim to, among other things, state facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the claim.
This bill would, when a plaintiff brings a claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within 3 years of a change in that standard, allow a plaintiff to collect statutory damages only if the plaintiff also provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place in violation with a written notice or demand letter at least 60 days prior to filing any action and the violation is not cured. The bill would require the written notice or demand letter to contain specified information.
(2)Existing law grants an owner or tenant of a site, defined as a place of public accommodation, that has been inspected by a certified access specialist (CASp) and determined to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards specified rights in an action that includes a construction-related accessibility claim.
The Personal Income Tax Law and the Corporation Tax Law, in specified conformity to federal law, allow a credit against the taxes imposed by those laws, to eligible small businesses for 50% of eligible access expenditures, which are defined as those amounts paid or incurred by the taxpayer to comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, as provided, not to exceed $250.
This bill, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, would include as an eligible access expenditure any amount paid or incurred by a taxpayer to receive an inspection by a CASp.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
Existing
(1)Existing law allows a plaintiff to collect statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff was denied full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, as specified. Existing law imposes a $1,000 limit on statutory damages when a defendant demonstrates that the defendant has, among other things, cured the construction-related accessibility violation within 60 days of being served with a complaint. Existing law requires a demand letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim to, among other things, state facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the claim.
This bill would, when a plaintiff brings a claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within 3 years of a change in that standard, allow a plaintiff to collect statutory damages only if the plaintiff also provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place in violation with a written notice or demand letter at least 60 days prior to filing any action and the violation is not cured. The bill would require the written notice or demand letter to contain specified information.
(2)Existing law grants an owner or tenant of a site, defined as a place of public accommodation, that has been inspected by a certified access specialist (CASp) and determined to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards specified rights in an action that includes a construction-related accessibility claim.
The Personal Income Tax Law and the Corporation Tax Law, in specified conformity to federal law, allow a credit against the taxes imposed by those laws, to eligible small businesses for 50% of eligible access expenditures, which are defined as those amounts paid or incurred by the taxpayer to comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990, as provided, not to exceed $250.
This bill, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, would include as an eligible access expenditure any amount paid or incurred by a taxpayer to receive an inspection by a CASp.
Existing law allows a plaintiff to collect statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff was denied full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, as specified. Existing law imposes a $1,000 limit on statutory damages when a defendant demonstrates that the defendant has, among other things, cured the construction-related accessibility violation within 60 days of being served with a complaint. Existing law requires a demand letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim to, among other things, state facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the claim.
This bill would, when a plaintiff brings a claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within 3 years of a change in that standard, allow a plaintiff to collect statutory damages only if the plaintiff also provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place in violation with a written notice or demand letter at least 60 days prior to filing any action and the violation is not cured. The bill would require the written notice or demand letter to contain specified information.
Existing law allows a plaintiff to collect statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff was denied full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, as specified. Existing law imposes a $1,000 limit on statutory damages when a defendant demonstrates that the defendant has, among other things, cured the construction-related accessibility violation within 60 days of being served with a complaint. Existing law requires a demand letter alleging a construction-related accessibility claim to, among other things, state facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the claim.
This bill would, when a plaintiff brings a claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within 3 years of a change in that standard, allow a plaintiff to collect statutory damages only if the plaintiff also provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place in violation with a written notice or demand letter at least 60 days prior to filing any action and the violation is not cured. The bill would require the written notice or demand letter to contain specified information.
(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Contemporaneously with providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to the State Bar of California by facsimile transmission at 1-415-538-2171, or by mail to 180 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105, Attention: Professional Competence.
(3)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) or (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney where a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, or a copy of the demand letter is not sent to the State Bar within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the State Bar of California or the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from either the sender or recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)Paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(i)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2013.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from the recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before July 31, 2019, and annually thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)The expiration of any ground for discipline of an attorney shall not affect the imposition of discipline for any act prior to the expiration. An act or omission that constituted cause for imposition of discipline of an attorney when committed or omitted prior to January 1, 2019, shall continue to constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of that attorney on and after January 1, 2019.
(i)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 3.Section 8299.08.1 is added to the Government Code, to read:8299.08.1.At least thirty days before requiring a new standard format of the information to be sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site the new standard format and the date by when the commission will begin requiring that information sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code be in the new standard format.
(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Contemporaneously with providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to the State Bar of California by facsimile transmission at 1-415-538-2171, or by mail to 180 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105, Attention: Professional Competence.
(3)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) or (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney where a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, or a copy of the demand letter is not sent to the State Bar within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the State Bar of California or the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from either the sender or recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)Paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(i)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2013.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from the recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before July 31, 2019, and annually thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)The expiration of any ground for discipline of an attorney shall not affect the imposition of discipline for any act prior to the expiration. An act or omission that constituted cause for imposition of discipline of an attorney when committed or omitted prior to January 1, 2019, shall continue to constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of that attorney on and after January 1, 2019.
(i)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 3.Section 8299.08.1 is added to the Government Code, to read:8299.08.1.At least thirty days before requiring a new standard format of the information to be sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site the new standard format and the date by when the commission will begin requiring that information sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code be in the new standard format.
(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Contemporaneously with providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to the State Bar of California by facsimile transmission at 1-415-538-2171, or by mail to 180 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105, Attention: Professional Competence.
(3)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access, Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission: commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) or (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney where a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, or a copy of the demand letter is not sent to the State Bar within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the State Bar of California or the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from either the sender or recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)Paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(i)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2013.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access, Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission: commission on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access in the standard format specified on the commissions Internet Web site pursuant to Section 8299.08.1 of the Government Code within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from the recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before July 31, 2019, and annually thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)The expiration of any ground for discipline of an attorney shall not affect the imposition of discipline for any act prior to the expiration. An act or omission that constituted cause for imposition of discipline of an attorney when committed or omitted prior to January 1, 2019, shall continue to constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of that attorney on and after January 1, 2019.
(i)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 3.Section 8299.08.1 is added to the Government Code, to read:8299.08.1.At least thirty days before requiring a new standard format of the information to be sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, the commission shall post on its Internet Web site the new standard format and the date by when the commission will begin requiring that information sent to the commission pursuant to Section 55.32 of the Civil Code be in the new standard format.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a well-intentioned law empowering private citizens to bring claims against businesses that do not make their establishments accessible to those with disabilities. However, a large number of businesses in California are out of compliance with the ADA.
(b)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Current law permits defendants to request a court stay and an early evaluation conference upon being served with a construction-related accessibility claim if, among other things, the site in question had new construction approved by a local public building department inspector who is a certified access specialist (CASp), no subsequent modifications or alterations have been made, and all violations are corrected within 60 days.
(2)The purpose of this act is to promote increased compliance with disabled accessibility building codes throughout the state by encouraging business and property owners to become CASp certified. Using the relief provided by this act, business and property owners will be more likely to obtain a CASp inspection whenever modifying or altering a site.
SECTION 1.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 2 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Contemporaneously with providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to the State Bar of California by facsimile transmission at 1-415-538-2171, or by mail to 180 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105, Attention: Professional Competence.
(3)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access. Access, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint to and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) or (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney where a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, or a copy of the demand letter is not sent to the State Bar within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the State Bar of California or the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from either the sender or recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)Paragraphs (2) and (3) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(i)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2013.
(j)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2019, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from the recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before July 31, 2019, and annually thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)The expiration of any ground for discipline of an attorney shall not affect the imposition of discipline for any act prior to the expiration. An act or omission that constituted cause for imposition of discipline of an attorney when committed or omitted prior to January 1, 2019, shall continue to constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of that attorney on and after January 1, 2019.
(i)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 3.Section 55.53 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.53.(a)For purposes of this part, a certified access specialist shall, upon completion of the inspection of a site, comply with the following:
(1)For a meets applicable standards site, if the CASp determines the site meets all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a written inspection report to the requesting party that includes both of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A signed and dated statement that includes both of the following:
(i)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site meet construction-related accessibility standards. The statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(ii)If corrections were made as a result of the CASp inspection, an itemized list of all corrections and dates of completion.
(2)For an inspected by a CASp site, if the CASp determines that corrections are needed to the site in order for the site to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a signed and dated written inspection report to the requesting party that includes all of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)The date of the inspection.
(C)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site need correction to meet construction-related accessibility standards. This statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(D)An identification and description of the structures or areas of the site that need correction and the correction needed.
(E)A schedule of completion for each of the corrections within a reasonable timeframe.
(3)The CASp shall provide, within 30 days of the date of the inspection of a business that qualifies for the provisions of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56, a copy of a report prepared pursuant to that subparagraph to the business.
(4)The CASp shall file, within 10 days of inspecting a business pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56, a notice with the State Architect for listing on the State Architects Internet Web site, as provided by subdivision (d) of Section 4459.7 of the Government Code, indicating that the CASp has inspected the business, the name and address of the business, the date of the filing, the date of the inspection of the business, the name and license number of the CASp, and a description of the structure or area inspected by the CASp.
(5)The CASp shall post the notice described in paragraph (4), in a form prescribed by the State Architect, in a conspicuous location within five feet of all public entrances to the building on the date of the inspection and instruct the business to keep it in place until the earlier of either of the following:
(A)One hundred twenty days after the date of the inspection.
(B)The date when all of the construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp are corrected.
(b)For purposes of this section, in determining whether the site meets applicable construction-related accessibility standards when there is a conflict or difference between a state and federal provision, standard, or regulation, the state provision, standard, or regulation shall apply unless the federal provision, standard, or regulation is more protective of accessibility rights.
(c)Every CASp who conducts an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon completing the inspection of the site, provide the building owner or tenant who requested the inspection with the following notice, which the State Architect shall make available as a form on the State Architects Internet Web site:
NOTICE TO PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER/TENANT:
YOU ARE ADVISED TO KEEP IN YOUR RECORDS ANY WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTATION CONCERNING YOUR PROPERTY SITE THAT IS GIVEN TO YOU BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST.
IF YOU BECOME A DEFENDANT IN A LAWSUIT THAT INCLUDES A CLAIM CONCERNING A SITE INSPECTED BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, YOU MAY BE ENTITLED TO A COURT STAY (AN ORDER TEMPORARILY STOPPING ANY LAWSUIT) OF THE CLAIM AND AN EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE.
IN ORDER TO REQUEST THE STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE, YOU WILL NEED TO VERIFY THAT A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST HAS INSPECTED THE SITE THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE CLAIM. YOU WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE COURT AND THE PLAINTIFF WITH THE COPY OF A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT BY THE CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.54. THE APPLICATION FORM AND INFORMATION ON HOW TO REQUEST A STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE MAY BE OBTAINED AT www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-start.htm.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO REQUEST, FROM A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST WHO HAS CONDUCTED AN INSPECTION OF YOUR PROPERTY, A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND OTHER DOCUMENTATION AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.53. YOU ARE ALSO ENTITLED TO REQUEST THE ISSUANCE OF A DISABILITY ACCESS INSPECTION CERTIFICATE, WHICH YOU MAY POST ON YOUR PROPERTY.
(d)(1)Commencing July 1, 2010, a local agency shall employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a certified access specialist. The certified access specialist shall provide consultation to the local agency, permit applicants, and members of the public on compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards with respect to inspections of a place of public accommodation that relate to permitting, plan checks, or new construction, including, but not limited to, inspections relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(2)Commencing January 1, 2014, a local agency shall employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are certified access specialists to conduct permitting and plan check services to review for compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards by a place of public accommodation with respect to new construction, including, but not limited to, projects relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(3)If a permit applicant or member of the public requests consultation from a certified access specialist, the local agency may charge an amount limited to a reasonable hourly rate, an estimate of which shall be provided upon request in advance of the consultation. A local government may additionally charge or increase permitting, plan check, or inspection fees to the extent necessary to offset the costs of complying with this subdivision. Any revenues generated from an hourly or other charge or fee increase under this subdivision shall be used solely to offset the costs incurred to comply with this subdivision. A CASp inspection pursuant to subdivision (a) by a building inspector who is a certified access specialist shall be treated equally for legal and evidentiary purposes as an inspection conducted by a private CASp. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude permit applicants or any other person with a legal interest in the property from retaining a private CASp at any time.
(e)(1)Every CASp who completes an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon a determination that the site meets applicable standards pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) or is inspected by a CASp pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), provide the building owner or tenant requesting the inspection with a numbered disability access inspection certificate indicating that the site has undergone inspection by a certified access specialist. The disability access inspection certificate shall be dated and signed by the CASp inspector, and shall contain the inspectors name and license number. Upon issuance of a certificate, the CASp shall record the issuance of the numbered certificate, the name and address of the recipient, and the type of report issued pursuant to subdivision (a) in a record book the CASp shall maintain for that purpose.
(2)Beginning March 1, 2009, the State Architect shall make available for purchase by any local building department or CASp sequentially numbered disability access inspection certificates that are printed with a watermark or other feature to deter forgery and that comply with the information requirements specified in subdivision (a).
(3)The disability access inspection certificate may be posted on the premises of the place of public accommodation, unless, following the date of inspection, the inspected site has been modified or construction has commenced to modify the inspected site in a way that may impact compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(f)Nothing in this section or any other law is intended to require a property owner or tenant to hire a CASp. A property owners or tenants election not to hire a CASp shall not be admissible to prove that persons lack of intent to comply with the law.
SEC. 4.Section 55.56 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.56.(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)(1)The following technical violations are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, as set forth in subdivision (c), where the defendant is a small business, as described by subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (g), the defendant has corrected, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim or receipt of a written notice, whichever is earlier, all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim, and the claim is based on one or more of the following violations:
(A)Interior signs, other than directional signs or signs that identify the location of accessible elements, facilities, or features, when not all such elements, facilities, or features are accessible.
(B)The lack of exterior signs, other than parking signs and directional signs, including signs that indicate the location of accessible pathways or entrance and exit doors when not all pathways, entrance and exit doors are accessible.
(C)The order in which parking signs are placed or the exact location or wording of parking signs, provided that the parking signs are clearly visible and indicate the location of accessible parking and van-accessible parking.
(D)The color of parking signs, provided that the color of the background contrasts with the color of the information on the sign.
(E)The color of parking lot striping, provided that it exists and provides sufficient contrast with the surface upon which it is applied to be reasonably visible.
(F)Faded, chipped, damaged, or deteriorated paint in otherwise fully compliant parking spaces and passenger access aisles in parking lots, provided that it indicates the required dimensions of a parking space or access aisle in a manner that is reasonably visible.
(G)The presence or condition of detectable warning surfaces on ramps, except where the ramp is part of a pedestrian path of travel that intersects with a vehicular lane or other hazardous area.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof and is rebuttable by evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the plaintiff did, in fact, experience difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment on the particular occasion as a result of one or more of the technical violations listed in paragraph (1).
(f)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(g)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendant shall not be liable for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, with respect to a violation noted in a report by a certified access specialist (CASp), for a period of 120 days following the date of the inspection if the defendant demonstrates compliance with each of the following:
(i)The defendant is a business that has employed 100 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Employment Development Department.
(ii)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected by a CASp.
(iii)The inspection predates the filing of the claim by, or receipt of a demand letter from, the plaintiff regarding the alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard, and the defendant was not on notice of the alleged violation prior to the CASp inspection.
(iv)The defendant has corrected, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report that are the basis of the claim.
(B)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendant who claims the benefit of the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision shall disclose the date and findings of any CASp inspection to a plaintiff if relevant to a claim or defense in an action.
(4)A defendant may assert the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision only once for each structure or area inspected by a CASp, unless the inspected structure or area has undergone modifications or alterations that affect the compliance with construction-related accessibility standards of those structures or areas after the date of the last inspection, and the defendant obtains an additional CASp inspection within 30 days of final approval by the building department or certificate of occupancy, as appropriate, regarding the modification or alterations.
(5)If the defendant has failed to correct, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report, the defendant shall not receive any reduction of minimum statutory damages, unless a building permit is required for the repairs which cannot reasonably be completed by the defendant within 120 days and the defendant is in the process of correcting the violations noted in the CASp report, as evidenced by having, at least, an active building permit necessary for the repairs to correct the violation that was noted, but not corrected, in the CASp report and all of the repairs are completed within 180 days of the date of the inspection.
(6)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(7)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(8)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Chapter 383 of the Statutes of 2012, except for paragraphs (3), (4), and (5), which shall apply to claims filed on or after January 1, 2017. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(h)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(i)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
(j)For purposes of this section, the structure or area inspected means one of the following: the interior of the premises, the exterior of the premises, or both the interior and exterior.
SEC. 5.Section 4459.7 of the Government Code is amended to read:4459.7.(a)(1)No later than October 31 of each year, the State Architect shall publish and make available to the public a list of certified access specialists who have met the requirements of Section 4459.5.
(2)The State Architect shall publish and regularly update on its Internet Web site easily accessible lists of all of the following:
(A)Businesses that have obtained a CASp inspection and have filed, or a CASp has filed on their behalf, a notice pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code.
(B)Businesses which have been inspected by a certified access specialist on or after January 1, 2017, including the date of the inspection.
(3)The lists required pursuant to this section shall include a written disclaimer of liability as specified in subdivision (b).
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a state agency or employee of a state agency may not be held liable for any injury or damages resulting from any service provided by a certified access specialist whose name appears on the list published pursuant to subdivision (a).
(c)The State Architect may perform periodic audits of work performed by a certified access specialist as deemed necessary to ensure the desired standard of performance. A certified access specialist shall provide an authorized representative of the State Architect with complete access, at any reasonable hour of the day, to all technical data, reports, records, photographs, design outlines and plans, and files used in building inspection and plan review, with the exception of proprietary and confidential information.
(d)By January 1, 2017, the State Architect shall develop a process by which a certified access specialist (CASp) may notify the State Architect that a structure or area on the premises of a business has been inspected by a CASp and to notify the public that the business has a CASp determination pending, or has been Inspected by a CASp, as provided by paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56 of the Civil Code, which shall include the name and address of the business, the date of the notification, the date of the inspection of the business, the name and license number of the CASp, and a description of the structure or area inspected by a CASp.
(e)By January 1, 2017, the State Architect shall develop a form for a business to notify the public that the business has obtained a CASp inspection pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56 of the Civil Code, which shall include the date of the notification, the date of the inspection, and a description of the structure or area inspected by a CASp.
(f)For purposes of this section, the structure or area inspected means one of the following: the interior of the premises, the exterior of the premises, or both the interior and exterior.
SEC. 6.Section 4459.8 of the Government Code is amended to read:4459.8.(a)The certification authorized by Section 4459.5 is effective for three years from the date of initial certification and expires if not renewed. The State Architect, upon consideration of any factual complaints regarding the work of a certified access specialist or of other relevant information, may suspend certification or deny renewal of certification.
(b)(1)The State Architect shall require each applicant for certification as a certified access specialist to do both of the following:
(A)Pay fees, including an application and course fee and an examination fee, at a level sufficient to meet the costs of application processing, registration, publishing a list, and other activities that are reasonably necessary to implement and administer the certified access specialist program.
(B)Provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant intends to provide services.
(2)The State Architect shall require each applicant for renewal of certification to do both of the following:
(A)Pay a fee sufficient to cover the reasonable costs of reassessing qualifications of renewal applicants.
(B)Provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant has provided services since the last day of certification by the State Architect.
(3)The State Architect shall periodically review his or her schedule of fees to ensure that the fees for certification are not excessive while covering the costs to administer the certified access specialist program. The application fee for a California licensed architect, landscape architect, civil engineer, or structural engineer shall not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)All fees collected pursuant to this section shall be deposited into the Certified Access Specialist Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340, this fund is continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal years for use by the State Architect to implement Sections 4459.5 to 4459.8, inclusive.
(d)The State Architect shall post on his or her Internet Web site the name of the city, county, or city and county in which each certified access specialist provides or intends to provide services.
SEC. 7.Section 8299.06 of the Government Code is amended to read:8299.06.(a)A priority of the commission shall be the development and dissemination of educational materials and information to promote and facilitate disability access compliance.
(b)The commission shall work with other state agencies, including the Division of the State Architect and the Department of Rehabilitation, to develop educational materials and information for use by businesses to understand its obligations to provide disability access and to facilitate compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(c)The commission shall develop and make available on its Internet Web site, or make available on its Internet Web site if developed by another governmental agency, including Americans with Disabilities Act centers, toolkits or educational modules to assist a California business to understand its obligations under the law and to facilitate compliance with respect to the top 10 alleged construction-related violations, by type, as specified in subdivision (a) of Section 8299.08. Upon completion of this requirement, the commission shall develop and make available on its Internet Web site, or work with another agency to develop, other toolkits or educational modules that would educate businesses of the accessibility requirements and to facilitate compliance with that requirement.
(d)The commission shall post the following on its Internet Web site:
(1)Educational materials and information that will assist building owners, tenants, building officials, and building inspectors to understand the disability accessibility requirements and to facilitate compliance with disability access laws. The commission shall at least annually review the educational materials and information on disability access requirements and compliance available on the Internet Web site of other local, state, or federal agencies, including Americans with Disabilities Act centers, to augment the educational materials and information developed by the commission.
(2)A link to the Internet Web site of the Division of the State Architects certified access specialist (CASp) program to assist building owners and tenants in locating or hiring a CASp.
(e)The commission shall, to the extent feasible, coordinate with other state agencies and local building departments to ensure that information provided to the public on disability access requirements is uniform and complete, and make its educational materials and information available to those agencies and departments.
SEC. 8.Section 65941.6 is added to the Government Code, to read:65941.6.(a)Each local agency shall develop materials relating to the requirements of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.). The local agency shall provide these materials to an applicant along with notice that approval of a permit does not signify that the applicant has complied with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
(b)For the purposes of complying with the requirements of subdivision (a), a local agency may, in lieu of developing its own materials, provide applicants with those materials which the California Commission on Disability Access has developed and made available pursuant to Section 8299.06.
SEC. 9.Article 4 (commencing with Section 65946) is added to Chapter 4.5 of Division 1 of Title 7 of the Government Code, to read:4.Expedited Review65946.(a)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Certified access specialist or CASp means any person who has been certified pursuant to Section 4459.5.
(2)Construction-related accessibility standard means a provision, standard, or regulation under state or federal law requiring compliance with standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities, including, but not limited to, any provision, standard, or regulation set forth in Section 51, 54, 54.1, or 55 of the Civil Code, Section 19955.5 of the Health and Safety Code, the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations), the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-336; 42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.), and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines (Appendix A to Part 36 of Title 28 of the Code of Federal Regulations).
(3)Written inspection report means the CASp report required to be provided pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code.
(b)A local agency shall expedite review of a project application if the project applicant meets all of the following conditions:
(1)The applicant provides a copy of a disability access inspection certificate, provided by a CASp pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code, pertaining to the site of the proposed project.
(2)The applicant demonstrates that the proposed project is necessary to address either an alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard or a violation noted in a written inspection report.
(3)If project plans are necessary for the approval of a project, the applicant has had a CASp review the project plans for compliance with all applicable construction-related accessibility standards.
SEC. 10.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 8 and 9 of this act, pertaining to the review and approval of development permit applications, constitute matters of statewide concern, and shall apply to charter cities and charter counties. These sections shall supersede any inconsistent provisions in the charter of any city, county, or city and county.
SEC. 11.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a well-intentioned law empowering private citizens to bring claims against businesses that do not make their establishments accessible to those with disabilities. However, a large number of businesses in California are out of compliance with the ADA.
(b)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Current law permits defendants to request a court stay and an early evaluation conference upon being served with a construction-related accessibility claim if, among other things, the site in question had new construction approved by a local public building department inspector who is a certified access specialist (CASp), no subsequent modifications or alterations have been made, and all violations are corrected within 60 days.
(2)The purpose of this tax credit act is to promote increased compliance with disabled accessibility building codes throughout the state by encouraging business and property owners to become CASp certified. Using the relief provided by this tax credit, act, business and property owners will be more likely to obtain a CASp inspection whenever modifying or altering a site.
(c)The California Commission on Disability Access shall post information about this tax credit on its Internet Web site and include in its annual report to the Legislature the impact the tax credit has had on reducing ADA compliance lawsuits.
SEC. 2.Section 17053.42 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:17053.42.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the net tax, as defined in Section 17039, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44(c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the net tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the net tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
SEC. 3.Section 23642 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:23642.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the tax, as defined in Section 23036, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44(c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
SEC. 2.Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 755 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:55.32.(a)An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1)Include the attorneys State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2)Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access. Access, to the commission.
(b)An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1)Send a copy of the complaint to and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
(2)Notify the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days of judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint of the following information in a standard format specified by the commission:
(A)The date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal.
(B)Whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3.
(C)If the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, as defined by Section 55.3, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter.
(D)Whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection.
(c)A violation of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney if a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the demand letter, complaint, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or subdivision (b) has been violated.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), an attorney is not required to send to the California Commission on Disability Access a copy of any subsequent demand letter or amended complaint in the same dispute following the initial demand letter or complaint, unless that subsequent demand letter or amended complaint alleges a new construction-related accessibility claim.
(e)A demand letter or notification of a case outcome sent to the California Commission on Disability Access shall be for the informational purposes of Section 8299.08 of the Government Code. A demand letter received by the State Bar from the recipient of the demand letter shall be reviewed by the State Bar to determine whether subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31 has been violated.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, on or before July 31, 2019, and annually thereafter, the State Bar shall report to the Legislature and the Chairs of the Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees, both of the following with respect to demand letters received by the State Bar:
(A)The number of investigations opened to date on a suspected violation of subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 55.31.
(B)Whether any disciplinary action resulted from the investigation, and the results of that disciplinary action.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(g)The California Commission on Disability Access shall review and report on the demand letters, complaints, and notifications of case outcomes it receives as provided in Section 8299.08 of the Government Code.
(h)The expiration of any ground for discipline of an attorney shall not affect the imposition of discipline for any act prior to the expiration. An act or omission that constituted cause for imposition of discipline of an attorney when committed or omitted prior to January 1, 2019, shall continue to constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of that attorney on and after January 1, 2019.
(i)Paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) and subdivision (b) shall not apply to a demand letter or complaint sent or filed by an attorney employed or retained by a qualified legal services project or a qualified support center, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, when acting within the scope of employment in asserting a construction-related accessibility claim. The Legislature finds and declares that qualified legal services projects and support centers are extensively regulated by the State Bar of California, and that there is no evidence of any abusive use of demand letters or complaints by these organizations. The Legislature further finds that, in light of the evidence of the extraordinarily small number of construction-related accessibility cases brought by regulated legal services programs, and given the resources of those programs, exempting regulated legal services programs from the requirements of this section to report to the California Commission on Disability Access will not affect the purpose of the reporting to, and tabulation by, the commission of all other construction-related accessibility claims.
(j)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 3.Section 55.53 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.53.(a)For purposes of this part, a certified access specialist shall, upon completion of the inspection of a site, comply with the following:
(1)For a meets applicable standards site, if the CASp determines the site meets all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a written inspection report to the requesting party that includes both of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A signed and dated statement that includes both of the following:
(i)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site meet construction-related accessibility standards. The statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(ii)If corrections were made as a result of the CASp inspection, an itemized list of all corrections and dates of completion.
(2)For an inspected by a CASp site, if the CASp determines that corrections are needed to the site in order for the site to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a signed and dated written inspection report to the requesting party that includes all of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)The date of the inspection.
(B)
(C)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site need correction to meet construction-related accessibility standards. This statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(C)
(D)An identification and description of the structures or areas of the site that need correction and the correction needed.
(D)
(E)A schedule of completion for each of the corrections within a reasonable timeframe.
(3)The CASp shall provide, within 30 days of the date of the inspection of a business that qualifies for the provisions of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56, a copy of a report prepared pursuant to that subparagraph to the business.
(4)The CASp shall file, within 10 days of inspecting a business pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56, a notice with the State Architect for listing on the State Architects Internet Web site, as provided by subdivision (d) of Section 4459.7 of the Government Code, indicating that the CASp has inspected the business, the name and address of the business, the date of the filing, the date of the inspection of the business, the name and license number of the CASp, and a description of the structure or area inspected by the CASp.
(5)The CASp shall post the notice described in paragraph (4), in a form prescribed by the State Architect, in a conspicuous location within five feet of all public entrances to the building on the date of the inspection and instruct the business to keep it in place until the earlier of either of the following:
(A)One hundred twenty days after the date of the inspection.
(B)The date when all of the construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp are corrected.
(b)For purposes of this section, in determining whether the site meets applicable construction-related accessibility standards when there is a conflict or difference between a state and federal provision, standard, or regulation, the state provision, standard, or regulation shall apply unless the federal provision, standard, or regulation is more protective of accessibility rights.
(c)Every CASp who conducts an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon completing the inspection of the site, provide the building owner or tenant who requested the inspection with the following notice, which the State Architect shall make available as a form on the State Architects Internet Web site:
NOTICE TO PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER/TENANT:
YOU ARE ADVISED TO KEEP IN YOUR RECORDS ANY WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTATION CONCERNING YOUR PROPERTY SITE THAT IS GIVEN TO YOU BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST.
IF YOU BECOME A DEFENDANT IN A LAWSUIT THAT INCLUDES A CLAIM CONCERNING A SITE INSPECTED BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, YOU MAY BE ENTITLED TO A COURT STAY (AN ORDER TEMPORARILY STOPPING ANY LAWSUIT) OF THE CLAIM AND AN EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE.
IN ORDER TO REQUEST THE STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE, YOU WILL NEED TO VERIFY THAT A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST HAS INSPECTED THE SITE THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE CLAIM. YOU WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE COURT AND THE PLAINTIFF WITH THE COPY OF A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT BY THE CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.54. THE APPLICATION FORM AND INFORMATION ON HOW TO REQUEST A STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE MAY BE OBTAINED AT www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-start.htm.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO REQUEST, FROM A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST WHO HAS CONDUCTED AN INSPECTION OF YOUR PROPERTY, A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND OTHER DOCUMENTATION AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.53. YOU ARE ALSO ENTITLED TO REQUEST THE ISSUANCE OF A DISABILITY ACCESS INSPECTION CERTIFICATE, WHICH YOU MAY POST ON YOUR PROPERTY.
(d)(1)Commencing July 1, 2010, a local agency shall employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a certified access specialist. The certified access specialist shall provide consultation to the local agency, permit applicants, and members of the public on compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards with respect to inspections of a place of public accommodation that relate to permitting, plan checks, or new construction, including, but not limited to, inspections relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(2)Commencing January 1, 2014, a local agency shall employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are certified access specialists to conduct permitting and plan check services to review for compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards by a place of public accommodation with respect to new construction, including, but not limited to, projects relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(3)If a permit applicant or member of the public requests consultation from a certified access specialist, the local agency may charge an amount limited to a reasonable hourly rate, an estimate of which shall be provided upon request in advance of the consultation. A local government may additionally charge or increase permitting, plan check, or inspection fees to the extent necessary to offset the costs of complying with this subdivision. Any revenues generated from an hourly or other charge or fee increase under this subdivision shall be used solely to offset the costs incurred to comply with this subdivision. A CASp inspection pursuant to subdivision (a) by a building inspector who is a certified access specialist shall be treated equally for legal and evidentiary purposes as an inspection conducted by a private CASp. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude permit applicants or any other person with a legal interest in the property from retaining a private CASp at any time.
(e)(1)Every CASp who completes an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon a determination that the site meets applicable standards pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) or is inspected by a CASp pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), provide the building owner or tenant requesting the inspection with a numbered disability access inspection certificate indicating that the site has undergone inspection by a certified access specialist. The disability access inspection certificate shall be dated and signed by the CASp inspector, and shall contain the inspectors name and license number. Upon issuance of a certificate, the CASp shall record the issuance of the numbered certificate, the name and address of the recipient, and the type of report issued pursuant to subdivision (a) in a record book the CASp shall maintain for that purpose.
(2)Beginning March 1, 2009, the State Architect shall make available for purchase by any local building department or CASp sequentially numbered disability access inspection certificates that are printed with a watermark or other feature to deter forgery and that comply with the information requirements specified in subdivision (a).
(3)The disability access inspection certificate may be posted on the premises of the place of public accommodation, unless, following the date of inspection, the inspected site has been modified or construction has commenced to modify the inspected site in a way that may impact compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(f)Nothing in this section or any other law is intended to require a property owner or tenant to hire a CASp. A property owners or tenants election not to hire a CASp shall not be admissible to prove that persons lack of intent to comply with the law.
SEC. 4.Section 55.56 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.56.(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)(1)The following technical violations are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, as set forth in subdivision (c), where the defendant is a small business, as described by subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (g), the defendant has corrected, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim or receipt of a written notice, whichever is earlier, all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim, and the claim is based on one or more of the following violations:
(A)Interior signs, other than directional signs or signs that identify the location of accessible elements, facilities, or features, when not all such elements, facilities, or features are accessible.
(B)The lack of exterior signs, other than parking signs and directional signs, including signs that indicate the location of accessible pathways or entrance and exit doors when not all pathways, entrance and exit doors are accessible.
(C)The order in which parking signs are placed or the exact location or wording of parking signs, provided that the parking signs are clearly visible and indicate the location of accessible parking and van-accessible parking.
(D)The color of parking signs, provided that the color of the background contrasts with the color of the information on the sign.
(E)The color of parking lot striping, provided that it exists and provides sufficient contrast with the surface upon which it is applied to be reasonably visible.
(F)Faded, chipped, damaged, or deteriorated paint in otherwise fully compliant parking spaces and passenger access aisles in parking lots, provided that it indicates the required dimensions of a parking space or access aisle in a manner that is reasonably visible.
(G)The presence or condition of detectable warning surfaces on ramps, except where the ramp is part of a pedestrian path of travel that intersects with a vehicular lane or other hazardous area.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof and is rebuttable by evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the plaintiff did, in fact, experience difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment on the particular occasion as a result of one or more of the technical violations listed in paragraph (1).
(e)
(f)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(f)
(g)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendant shall not be liable for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, with respect to a violation noted in a report by a certified access specialist (CASp), for a period of 120 days following the date of the inspection if the defendant demonstrates compliance with each of the following:
(i)The defendant is a business that has employed 100 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Employment Development Department.
(ii)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected by a CASp.
(iii)The inspection predates the filing of the claim by, or receipt of a demand letter from, the plaintiff regarding the alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard, and the defendant was not on notice of the alleged violation prior to the CASp inspection.
(iv)The defendant has corrected, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report that are the basis of the claim.
(B)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendant who claims the benefit of the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision shall disclose the date and findings of any CASp inspection to a plaintiff if relevant to a claim or defense in an action.
(4)A defendant may assert the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision only once for each structure or area inspected by a CASp, unless the inspected structure or area has undergone modifications or alterations that affect the compliance with construction-related accessibility standards of those structures or areas after the date of the last inspection, and the defendant obtains an additional CASp inspection within 30 days of final approval by the building department or certificate of occupancy, as appropriate, regarding the modification or alterations.
(5)If the defendant has failed to correct, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the structure or area inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report, the defendant shall not receive any reduction of minimum statutory damages, unless a building permit is required for the repairs which cannot reasonably be completed by the defendant within 120 days and the defendant is in the process of correcting the violations noted in the CASp report, as evidenced by having, at least, an active building permit necessary for the repairs to correct the violation that was noted, but not corrected, in the CASp report and all of the repairs are completed within 180 days of the date of the inspection.
(3)
(6)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(4)
(7)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(5)
(8)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Senate Bill 1186 of the 201112 Regular Session of the Legislature. Chapter 383 of the Statutes of 2012, except for paragraphs (3), (4), and (5), which shall apply to claims filed on or after January 1, 2017. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(g)
(h)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(h)
(i)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
(j)For purposes of this section, the structure or area inspected means one of the following: the interior of the premises, the exterior of the premises, or both the interior and exterior.
SEC. 5.Section 4459.7 of the Government Code is amended to read:4459.7.(a)(1)No later than October 31 of each year, the State Architect shall publish and make available to the public a list of certified access specialists who have met the requirements of Section 4459.5. This list shall include a written disclaimer of liability as specified in subdivision (b).
(2)The State Architect shall publish and regularly update on its Internet Web site easily accessible lists of all of the following:
(A)Businesses that have obtained a CASp inspection and have filed, or a CASp has filed on their behalf, a notice pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code.
(B)Businesses which have been inspected by a certified access specialist on or after January 1, 2017, including the date of the inspection.
(3)The lists required pursuant to this section shall include a written disclaimer of liability as specified in subdivision (b).
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a state agency or employee of a state agency may not be held liable for any injury or damages resulting from any service provided by a certified access specialist whose name appears on the list published pursuant to subdivision (a).
(c)The State Architect may perform periodic audits of work performed by a certified access specialist as deemed necessary to ensure the desired standard of performance. A certified access specialist shall provide an authorized representative of the State Architect with complete access, at any reasonable hour of the day, to all technical data, reports, records, photographs, design outlines and plans, and files used in building inspection and plan review, with the exception of proprietary and confidential information.
(d)By January 1, 2017, the State Architect shall develop a process by which a certified access specialist (CASp) may notify the State Architect that a structure or area on the premises of a business has been inspected by a CASp and to notify the public that the business has a CASp determination pending, or has been Inspected by a CASp, as provided by paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56 of the Civil Code, which shall include the name and address of the business, the date of the notification, the date of the inspection of the business, the name and license number of the CASp, and a description of the structure or area inspected by a CASp.
(e)By January 1, 2017, the State Architect shall develop a form for a business to notify the public that the business has obtained a CASp inspection pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (g) of Section 55.56 of the Civil Code, which shall include the date of the notification, the date of the inspection, and a description of the structure or area inspected by a CASp.
(f)For purposes of this section, the structure or area inspected means one of the following: the interior of the premises, the exterior of the premises, or both the interior and exterior.
SEC. 6.Section 4459.8 of the Government Code is amended to read:4459.8.(a)The certification authorized by Section 4459.5 is effective for three years from the date of initial certification and expires if not renewed. The State Architect, upon consideration of any factual complaints regarding the work of a certified access specialist or of other relevant information, may suspend certification or deny renewal of certification.
(b)(1)The State Architect shall require each applicant for certification as a certified access specialist to pay do both of the following:
(A)Pay fees, including an application and course fee and an examination fee, at a level sufficient to meet the costs of application processing, registration, publishing a list, and other activities that are reasonably necessary to implement and administer the certified access specialist program. The
(B)Provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant intends to provide services.
(2)The State Architect shall require each applicant for renewal of certification to pay do both of the following:
(A)Pay a fee sufficient to cover the reasonable costs of reassessing qualifications of renewal applicants.
(B)Provide to the State Architect the name of the city, county, or city and county in which the applicant has provided services since the last day of certification by the State Architect.
(2)
(3)The State Architect shall periodically review its his or her schedule of fees to ensure that its the fees for certification are not excessive while covering the costs to administer the certified access specialist program. The application fee for a California licensed architect, landscape architect, civil engineer, or structural engineer shall not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)All fees collected pursuant to this section shall be deposited into the Certified Access Specialist Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 13340, this fund is continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal years for use by the State Architect to implement Sections 4459.5 to 4459.8, inclusive.
(d)The State Architect shall post on his or her Internet Web site the name of the city, county, or city and county in which each certified access specialist provides or intends to provide services.
SEC. 7.Section 8299.06 of the Government Code is amended to read:8299.06.(a)A priority of the commission shall be the development and dissemination of educational materials and information to promote and facilitate disability access compliance.
(b)The commission shall work with other state agencies, including the Division of the State Architect and the Department of Rehabilitation, to develop educational materials and information for use by businesses to understand its obligations to provide disability access and to facilitate compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(c)The commission shall develop and make available on its Internet Web site, or make available on its Internet Web site if developed by another governmental agency, including Americans with Disabilities Act centers, toolkits or educational modules to assist a California business to understand its obligations under the law and to facilitate compliance with respect to the top 10 alleged construction-related violations, by type, as specified in subdivision (a) of Section 8299.08. Upon completion of this requirement, the commission shall develop and make available on its Internet Web site, or work with another agency to develop, other toolkits or educational modules that would educate businesses of the accessibility requirements and to facilitate compliance with that requirement.
(d)The commission shall post the following on its Internet Web site educational site:
(1)Educational materials and information that will assist building owners, tenants, building officials, and building inspectors to understand the disability accessibility requirements and to facilitate compliance with disability access laws. The commission shall at least annually review the educational materials and information on disability access requirements and compliance available on the Internet Web site of other local, state, or federal agencies, including Americans with Disabilities Act centers, to augment the educational materials and information developed by the commission.
(2)A link to the Internet Web site of the Division of the State Architects certified access specialist (CASp) program to assist building owners and tenants in locating or hiring a CASp.
(e)The commission shall, to the extent feasible, coordinate with other state agencies and local building departments to ensure that information provided to the public on disability access requirements is uniform and complete. complete, and make its educational materials and information available to those agencies and departments.
SEC. 8.Section 65941.6 is added to the Government Code, to read:65941.6.(a)Each local agency shall develop materials relating to the requirements of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.). The local agency shall provide these materials to an applicant along with notice that approval of a permit does not signify that the applicant has complied with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
(b)For the purposes of complying with the requirements of subdivision (a), a local agency may, in lieu of developing its own materials, provide applicants with those materials which the California Commission on Disability Access has developed and made available pursuant to Section 8299.06.
SEC. 9.Article 4 (commencing with Section 65946) is added to Chapter 4.5 of Division 1 of Title 7 of the Government Code, to read:4.Expedited Review65946.(a)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Certified access specialist or CASp means any person who has been certified pursuant to Section 4459.5.
(2)Construction-related accessibility standard means a provision, standard, or regulation under state or federal law requiring compliance with standards for making new construction and existing facilities accessible to persons with disabilities, including, but not limited to, any provision, standard, or regulation set forth in Section 51, 54, 54.1, or 55 of the Civil Code, Section 19955.5 of the Health and Safety Code, the California Building Standards Code (Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations), the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-336; 42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.), and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines (Appendix A to Part 36 of Title 28 of the Code of Federal Regulations).
(3)Written inspection report means the CASp report required to be provided pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code.
(b)A local agency shall expedite review of a project application if the project applicant meets all of the following conditions:
(1)The applicant provides a copy of a disability access inspection certificate, provided by a CASp pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 55.53 of the Civil Code, pertaining to the site of the proposed project.
(2)The applicant demonstrates that the proposed project is necessary to address either an alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard or a violation noted in a written inspection report.
(3)If project plans are necessary for the approval of a project, the applicant has had a CASp review the project plans for compliance with all applicable construction-related accessibility standards.
SEC. 10.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 8 and 9 of this act, pertaining to the review and approval of development permit applications, constitute matters of statewide concern, and shall apply to charter cities and charter counties. These sections shall supersede any inconsistent provisions in the charter of any city, county, or city and county.
SEC. 11.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a well-intentioned law empowering private citizens to bring claims against businesses that do not make their establishments accessible to those with disabilities. However, because the ADA authorizes damages of up to $4,000 on top of legal fees, California is a hotbed for predatory, serial litigants seeking to win settlements from a large number of businesses in California are out of compliance with the ADA.
(b)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Current law permits defendants to request a court stay and an early evaluation conference upon being served with a construction-related accessibility claim if, among other things, the site in question had new construction approved by a local public building department inspector who is a certified access specialist (CASp), no subsequent modifications or alterations have been made, and all violations are corrected within 60 days.
(2)The purpose of this tax credit is to promote increased compliance with disabled accessibility building codes throughout the state by encouraging business and property owners to become CASp certified. Using the relief provided by this tax credit, business and property owners will be more likely to obtain a CASp inspection whenever modifying or altering a site.
(c)The California Commission on Disability Access shall post information about this tax credit on its Internet Web site and include in its annual report to the Legislature the impact the tax credit has had on reducing ADA compliance lawsuits.
SEC. 2.Section 55.53 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.53.(a)For purposes of this part, a certified access specialist shall, upon completion of the inspection of a site, comply with the following:
(1)For a meets applicable standards site, if the CASp determines the site meets all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a written inspection report to the requesting party that includes both of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A signed and dated statement that includes both of the following:
(i)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site meet construction-related accessibility standards. The statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(ii)If corrections were made as a result of the CASp inspection, an itemized list of all corrections and dates of completion.
(2)For an inspected by a CASp site, if the CASp determines that corrections are needed to the site in order for the site to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a signed and dated written inspection report to the requesting party that includes all of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site need correction to meet construction-related accessibility standards. This statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(C)An identification and description of the structures or areas of the site that need correction and the correction needed.
(D)A schedule of completion for each of the corrections within a reasonable timeframe.
(b)For purposes of this section, in determining whether the site meets applicable construction-related accessibility standards when there is a conflict or difference between a state and federal provision, standard, or regulation, the state provision, standard, or regulation shall apply unless the federal provision, standard, or regulation is more protective of accessibility rights.
(c)Every CASp who conducts an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon completing the inspection of the site, provide the building owner or tenant who requested the inspection with the following notice, which the State Architect shall make available as a form on the State Architects Internet Web site:
NOTICE TO PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER/TENANT:
YOU ARE ADVISED TO KEEP IN YOUR RECORDS ANY WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTATION CONCERNING YOUR PROPERTY SITE THAT IS GIVEN TO YOU BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST.
IF YOU BECOME A DEFENDANT IN A LAWSUIT THAT INCLUDES A CLAIM CONCERNING A SITE INSPECTED BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, YOU MAY BE ENTITLED TO A COURT STAY (AN ORDER TEMPORARILY STOPPING ANY LAWSUIT) OF THE CLAIM AND AN EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE.
IN ORDER TO REQUEST THE STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE, YOU WILL NEED TO VERIFY THAT A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST HAS INSPECTED THE SITE THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE CLAIM. YOU WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE COURT AND THE PLAINTIFF WITH THE COPY OF A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT BY THE CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.54. THE APPLICATION FORM AND INFORMATION ON HOW TO REQUEST A STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE MAY BE OBTAINED AT www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-start.htm.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO REQUEST, FROM A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST WHO HAS CONDUCTED AN INSPECTION OF YOUR PROPERTY, A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND OTHER DOCUMENTATION AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.53. YOU ARE ALSO ENTITLED TO REQUEST THE ISSUANCE OF A DISABILITY ACCESS INSPECTION CERTIFICATE, WHICH YOU MAY POST ON YOUR PROPERTY.
(d)(1)Commencing July 1, 2010, a local agency shall employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a certified access specialist. The certified access specialist shall provide consultation to the local agency, permit applicants, and members of the public on compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards with respect to inspections of a place of public accommodation that relate to permitting, plan checks, or new construction, including, but not limited to, inspections relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(2)Commencing January 1, 2014, a local agency shall employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are certified access specialists to conduct permitting and plan check services to review for compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards by a place of public accommodation with respect to new construction, including, but not limited to, projects relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(3)If a permit applicant or member of the public requests consultation from a certified access specialist, the local agency may charge an amount limited to a reasonable hourly rate, an estimate of which shall be provided upon request in advance of the consultation. A local government may additionally charge or increase permitting, plan check, or inspection fees to the extent necessary to offset the costs of complying with this subdivision. Any revenues generated from an hourly or other charge or fee increase under this subdivision shall be used solely to offset the costs incurred to comply with this subdivision. A CASp inspection pursuant to subdivision (a) by a building inspector who is a certified access specialist shall be treated equally for legal and evidentiary purposes as an inspection conducted by a private CASp. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude permit applicants or any other person with a legal interest in the property from retaining a private CASp at any time.
(e)(1)Every CASp who completes an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon a determination that the site meets applicable standards pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) or is inspected by a CASp pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), provide the building owner or tenant requesting the inspection with a numbered disability access inspection certificate indicating that the site has undergone inspection by a certified access specialist. The disability access inspection certificate shall be dated and signed by the CASp inspector, and shall contain the inspectors name and license number. Upon issuance of a certificate, the CASp shall record the issuance of the numbered certificate, the name and address of the recipient, and the type of report issued pursuant to subdivision (a) in a record book the CASp shall maintain for that purpose.
(2)Beginning March 1, 2009, the State Architect shall make available for purchase by any local building department or CASp sequentially numbered disability access inspection certificates that are printed with a watermark or other feature to deter forgery and that comply with the information requirements specified in subdivision (a).
(3)The disability access inspection certificate may be posted on the premises of the place of public accommodation, unless, following the date of inspection, the inspected site has been modified or construction has commenced to modify the inspected site in a way that may impact compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(f)Nothing in this section or any other law is intended to require a property owner or tenant to hire a CASp. A property owners or tenants election not to hire a CASp shall not be admissible to prove that persons lack of intent to comply with the law.
(g)An owner or tenant of a site that a CASp has determined meets applicable standards may be allowed for a tax credit, as described in Section 17053.43 or 23643 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, to offset a portion of the costs of obtaining the CASp inspection.
SEC. 3.Section 55.56 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.56.(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, and the requirements of Section 55.565 have been met, if applicable.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Employment Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(4)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(5)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Senate Bill 1186 of the 201112 Regular Session of the Legislature. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(g)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(h)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
SEC. 4.Section 55.565 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.565.(a)When a plaintiff brings a construction-related accessibility claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within three years of a change in that standard, statutory damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred with sufficient written notice of the allegations and alleged access barriers on which the claim is based at least 60 days prior to the filing of any action and the alleged access barriers are not removed.
(b)A written notice is sufficient for the purposes of subdivision (a) if either of the following conditions is met:
(1)The notice states facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim under subdivision (a) of Section 55.31 and states that the recipient may be civilly liable for actual and statutory damages for a violation of a construction-related accessibility requirement if the access barriers that constitute the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim are not removed within 60 days.
(2)The notice is a written demand letter that offers prelitigation settlement negotiations in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 55.31.
(c)For the purposes of this section, construction-related accessibility claim, construction-related accessibility standard, and place of public accommodation have the meanings set forth in Section 55.52.
SEC. 5.SEC. 2.Section 17053.42 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:17053.42.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the net tax, as defined in Section 17039, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44 (c)(2) 44(c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the net tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the net tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
SEC. 6.SEC. 3.Section 23642 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:23642.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the tax, as defined in Section 23036, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44 (c)(2) 44(c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
SEC. 4.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a well-intentioned law empowering private citizens to bring claims against businesses that do not make their establishments accessible to those with disabilities. However, because the ADA authorizes damages of up to $4,000 on top of legal fees, California is a hotbed for predatory, serial litigants seeking to win settlements from businesses out of compliance with the ADA.
(b)The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Current law permits defendants to request a court stay and an early evaluation conference upon being served with a construction-related accessibility claim if, among other things, the site in question had new construction approved by a local public building department inspector who is a certified access specialist (CASp), no subsequent modifications or alterations have been made, and all violations are corrected within 60 days.
(2)The purpose of this tax credit is to promote increased compliance with disabled accessibility building codes throughout the state by encouraging business and property owners to become CASp certified. Using the relief provided by this tax credit, business and property owners will be more likely to obtain a CASp inspection whenever modifying or altering a site.
(c)The California Commission on Disability Access shall include in its annual report to the Legislature the impact the tax credit has had on reducing ADA compliance lawsuits.
SEC. 2.Section 55.53 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.53.(a)For purposes of this part, a certified access specialist shall, upon completion of the inspection of a site, comply with the following:
(1)For a meets applicable standards site, if the CASp determines the site meets all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a written inspection report to the requesting party that includes both of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A signed and dated statement that includes both of the following:
(i)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site meet construction-related accessibility standards. The statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(ii)If corrections were made as a result of the CASp inspection, an itemized list of all corrections and dates of completion.
(2)For an inspected by a CASp site, if the CASp determines that corrections are needed to the site in order for the site to meet all applicable construction-related accessibility standards, the CASp shall provide a signed and dated written inspection report to the requesting party that includes all of the following:
(A)An identification and description of the inspected structures and areas of the site.
(B)A statement that, in the opinion of the CASp, the inspected structures and areas of the site need correction to meet construction-related accessibility standards. This statement shall clearly indicate whether the determination of the CASp includes an assessment of readily achievable barrier removal.
(C)An identification and description of the structures or areas of the site that need correction and the correction needed.
(D)A schedule of completion for each of the corrections within a reasonable timeframe.
(b)For purposes of this section, in determining whether the site meets applicable construction-related accessibility standards when there is a conflict or difference between a state and federal provision, standard, or regulation, the state provision, standard, or regulation shall apply unless the federal provision, standard, or regulation is more protective of accessibility rights.
(c)Every CASp who conducts an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon completing the inspection of the site, provide the building owner or tenant who requested the inspection with the following notice, which the State Architect shall make available as a form on the State Architects Internet Web site:
NOTICE TO PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER/TENANT:
YOU ARE ADVISED TO KEEP IN YOUR RECORDS ANY WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTATION CONCERNING YOUR PROPERTY SITE THAT IS GIVEN TO YOU BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST.
IF YOU BECOME A DEFENDANT IN A LAWSUIT THAT INCLUDES A CLAIM CONCERNING A SITE INSPECTED BY A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, YOU MAY BE ENTITLED TO A COURT STAY (AN ORDER TEMPORARILY STOPPING ANY LAWSUIT) OF THE CLAIM AND AN EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE.
IN ORDER TO REQUEST THE STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE, YOU WILL NEED TO VERIFY THAT A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST HAS INSPECTED THE SITE THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE CLAIM. YOU WILL ALSO BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE COURT AND THE PLAINTIFF WITH THE COPY OF A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT BY THE CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST, AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.54. THE APPLICATION FORM AND INFORMATION ON HOW TO REQUEST A STAY AND EARLY EVALUATION CONFERENCE MAY BE OBTAINED AT www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-start.htm.
YOU ARE ENTITLED TO REQUEST, FROM A CERTIFIED ACCESS SPECIALIST WHO HAS CONDUCTED AN INSPECTION OF YOUR PROPERTY, A WRITTEN INSPECTION REPORT AND OTHER DOCUMENTATION AS SET FORTH IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 55.53. YOU ARE ALSO ENTITLED TO REQUEST THE ISSUANCE OF A DISABILITY ACCESS INSPECTION CERTIFICATE, WHICH YOU MAY POST ON YOUR PROPERTY.
(d)(1)Commencing July 1, 2010, a local agency shall employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a certified access specialist. The certified access specialist shall provide consultation to the local agency, permit applicants, and members of the public on compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards with respect to inspections of a place of public accommodation that relate to permitting, plan checks, or new construction, including, but not limited to, inspections relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(2)Commencing January 1, 2014, a local agency shall employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are certified access specialists to conduct permitting and plan check services to review for compliance with state construction-related accessibility standards by a place of public accommodation with respect to new construction, including, but not limited to, projects relating to tenant improvements that may impact access. If a local agency employs or retains two or more certified access specialists to comply with this subdivision, at least one-half of the certified access specialists shall be building inspectors who are certified access specialists.
(3)If a permit applicant or member of the public requests consultation from a certified access specialist, the local agency may charge an amount limited to a reasonable hourly rate, an estimate of which shall be provided upon request in advance of the consultation. A local government may additionally charge or increase permitting, plan check, or inspection fees to the extent necessary to offset the costs of complying with this subdivision. Any revenues generated from an hourly or other charge or fee increase under this subdivision shall be used solely to offset the costs incurred to comply with this subdivision. A CASp inspection pursuant to subdivision (a) by a building inspector who is a certified access specialist shall be treated equally for legal and evidentiary purposes as an inspection conducted by a private CASp. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude permit applicants or any other person with a legal interest in the property from retaining a private CASp at any time.
(e)(1)Every CASp who completes an inspection of a place of public accommodation shall, upon a determination that the site meets applicable standards pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) or is inspected by a CASp pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), provide the building owner or tenant requesting the inspection with a numbered disability access inspection certificate indicating that the site has undergone inspection by a certified access specialist. The disability access inspection certificate shall be dated and signed by the CASp inspector, and shall contain the inspectors name and license number. Upon issuance of a certificate, the CASp shall record the issuance of the numbered certificate, the name and address of the recipient, and the type of report issued pursuant to subdivision (a) in a record book the CASp shall maintain for that purpose.
(2)Beginning March 1, 2009, the State Architect shall make available for purchase by any local building department or CASp sequentially numbered disability access inspection certificates that are printed with a watermark or other feature to deter forgery and that comply with the information requirements specified in subdivision (a).
(3)The disability access inspection certificate may be posted on the premises of the place of public accommodation, unless, following the date of inspection, the inspected site has been modified or construction has commenced to modify the inspected site in a way that may impact compliance with construction-related accessibility standards.
(f)Nothing in this section or any other law is intended to require a property owner or tenant to hire a CASp. A property owners or tenants election not to hire a CASp shall not be admissible to prove that persons lack of intent to comply with the law.
(g)An owner or tenant of a site that a CASp has determined meets applicable standards may be allowed for a tax credit, as described in Section 17053.43 or 23643 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, to offset a portion of the costs of obtaining the CASp inspection.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 55.56 of the Civil Code is amended to read:55.56.(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, and the requirements of Section 55.565 have been met, if applicable.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Employment Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(4)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(5)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Senate Bill 1186 of the 201112 Regular Session of the Legislature. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(g)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(h)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
SEC. 2.SEC. 4.Section 55.565 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.565.(a)When a plaintiff brings a construction-related accessibility claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within three years of a change in that standard, statutory damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred with sufficient written notice of the allegations and alleged access barriers on which the claim is based at least 60 days prior to the filing of any action and the alleged access barriers are not removed.
(b)A written notice is sufficient for the purposes of subdivision (a) if either of the following conditions is met:
(1)The notice states facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim under subdivision (a) of Section 55.31 and states that the recipient may be civilly liable for actual and statutory damages for a violation of a construction-related accessibility requirement if the access barriers that constitute the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim are not removed within 60 days.
(2)The notice is a written demand letter that offers prelitigation settlement negotiations in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 55.31.
(c)For the purposes of this section, construction-related accessibility claim, construction-related accessibility standard, and place of public accommodation have the meanings set forth in Section 55.52.
SEC. 5.Section 17053.42 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:17053.42.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the net tax, as defined in Section 17039, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44 (c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(c)
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the net tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the net tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
SEC. 6.Section 23642 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:23642.(a)For each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 1996, there shall be allowed as a credit against the tax, as defined in Section 23036, the amount paid or incurred for eligible access expenditures. The credit shall be allowed in accordance with Section 44 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to expenditures to provide access to disabled individuals, except that the credit amount specified in subdivision (b) shall be substituted for the credit amount specified in Section 44(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. Code, relating to general rule.
(b)The credit amount allowed under this section shall be 50 percent of so much of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year as do not exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250).
(c)(1)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, Section 44 (c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to certain expenditures included, is modified to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CASp, which is a certified access specialist.
(2)Certified access specialist, inspected by a CASp, and site shall have the same meanings as those terms are defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.52 of the Civil Code.
(c)
(d)In the case where the credit allowed by this section exceeds the tax, the excess may be carried over to reduce the tax in the following year, and succeeding years if necessary, until the credit is exhausted.
(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion, and the requirements of Section 55.565 have been met, if applicable.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(4)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(5)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Senate Bill 1186 of the 201112 Regular Session of the Legislature. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(g)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(h)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
SEC. 2.Section 55.565 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.565.(a)When a plaintiff brings a construction-related accessibility claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within three years of a change in that standard, statutory damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred with sufficient written notice of the allegations and alleged access barriers on which the claim is based at least 60 days prior to the filing of any action and the alleged access barriers are not removed.
(b)A written notice is sufficient for the purposes of subdivision (a) if either of the following conditions is met:
(1)The notice states facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim under subdivision (a) of Section 55.31 and states that the recipient may be civilly liable for actual and statutory damages for a violation of a construction-related accessibility requirement if the access barriers that constitute the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim are not removed within 60 days.
(2)The notice is a written demand letter that offers prelitigation settlement negotiations in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 55.31.
(c)For the purposes of this section, construction-related accessibility claim, construction-related accessibility standard, and place of public accommodation have the meanings set forth in Section 55.52.
(a)Statutory damages under either subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion. occasion, and the requirements of Section 55.565 have been met, if applicable.
(b)A plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if the plaintiff personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion, or the plaintiff was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion.
(c)A violation personally encountered by a plaintiff may be sufficient to cause a denial of full and equal access if the plaintiff experienced difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment because of the violation.
(d)A plaintiff demonstrates that he or she was deterred from accessing a place of public accommodation on a particular occasion only if both of the following apply:
(1)The plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation or violations that prevented or reasonably dissuaded the plaintiff from accessing a place of public accommodation that the plaintiff intended to use on a particular occasion.
(2)The violation or violations would have actually denied the plaintiff full and equal access if the plaintiff had accessed the place of public accommodation on that particular occasion.
(e)Statutory damages may be assessed pursuant to subdivision (a) based on each particular occasion that the plaintiff was denied full and equal access, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred. If the place of public accommodation consists of distinct facilities that offer distinct services, statutory damages may be assessed based on each denial of full and equal access to the distinct facility, and not upon the number of violations of construction-related accessibility standards identified at the place of public accommodation where the denial of full and equal access occurred.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates that it has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint, and the defendant demonstrates any of the following:
(A)The structure or area of the alleged violation was determined to be CASp-inspected or meets applicable standards and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with construction-related accessibility standards with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the date of that determination and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(B)The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating CASp determination pending or Inspected by a CASp, and the defendant has either implemented reasonable measures to correct the alleged violation before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access, or the defendant was in the process of correcting the alleged violation within a reasonable time and manner before the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(C)For a claim alleging a construction-related accessibility violation filed before January 1, 2018, the structure or area of the alleged violation was a new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, the local building department permit and inspection process on or after January 1, 2008, and before January 1, 2016, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that impacted compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(D)The structure or area of the alleged violation was new construction or an improvement that was approved by, and passed inspection by, a local building department official who is a certified access specialist, and, to the best of the defendants knowledge, there were no modifications or alterations that affected compliance with respect to the plaintiffs claim that were completed or commenced between the completion date of the new construction or improvement and the particular occasion on which the plaintiff was allegedly denied full and equal access.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a defendants liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is reduced to a minimum of two thousand dollars ($2,000) for each offense if the defendant demonstrates both of the following:
(A)The defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint.
(B)The defendant is a small business that has employed 25 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department, and has average annual gross receipts of less than three million five hundred thousand dollars ($3,500,000) over the previous three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by federal or state income tax returns. The average annual gross receipts dollar amount shall be adjusted biannually by the Department of General Services for changes in the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, as compiled by the Department of Industrial Relations. The Department of General Services shall post that adjusted amount on its Internet Web site.
(3)This subdivision shall not be applicable to intentional violations.
(4)Nothing in this subdivision affects the awarding of actual damages, or affects the awarding of treble actual damages.
(5)This subdivision shall apply only to claims filed on or after the effective date of Senate Bill 1186 of the 201112 Regular Session of the Legislature. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to affect a complaint filed before that date.
(g)This section does not alter the applicable law for the awarding of injunctive or other equitable relief for a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards, nor alter any legal obligation of a party to mitigate damages.
(h)In assessing liability under subdivision (d), in an action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, the court shall consider the reasonableness of the plaintiffs conduct in light of the plaintiffs obligation, if any, to mitigate damages.
SEC. 2.Section 55.565 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.565.(a)When a plaintiff brings a construction-related accessibility claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within three years of a change in that standard, statutory damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or subdivision (a) of Section 54.3 may be recovered against a place of public accommodation only if the plaintiff provides the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred with sufficient written notice of the allegations and alleged access barriers on which the claim is based at least 60 days prior to the filing of any action and the alleged access barriers are not removed.
(b)A written notice is sufficient for the purposes of subdivision (a) if either of the following conditions is met:
(1)The notice states facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim under subdivision (a) of Section 55.31 and states that the recipient may be civilly liable for actual and statutory damages for a violation of a construction-related accessibility requirement if the access barriers that constitute the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim are not removed within 60 days.
(2)The notice is a written demand letter that offers prelitigation settlement negotiations in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 55.31.
(c)For the purposes of this section, construction-related accessibility claim, construction-related accessibility standard, and place of public accommodation have the meanings set forth in Section 55.52.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 25, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 5 p.m. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 6050.). |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 5021.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 18 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Jun 27, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 15, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 14). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 24, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 4, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 27, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 27, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 3508.) |
| Jan 21, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jan 21, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (January 21). |
| Jan 15, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (January 15). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 15, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 3426.) |
| Jan 14, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 13, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 12, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jan 5, 2016 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on JUD. Re-referred. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (January 5). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 4, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 4, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jan 4, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| May 11, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 22, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 21). |
| Mar 17, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 16, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 19, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 18, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 22, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Dec 2, 2014 | From printer. May be heard in committee January 1. |
| Dec 1, 2014 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 22, 2016 | AB 54 OLSEN Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB54 Olsen By Roth | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jan 27, 2016 | AB 54 OLSEN Consent Calendar Second Day | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 21, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 15, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jan 5, 2016 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| Apr 21, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 54
Author:(Olsen)
As Amended Ver:May 24, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 78-0 | (January 27, 2016) | SENATE: | 38-0 | (August 16, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Modifies existing requirements for the reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission). Specifically, in construction-related accessibility claim cases, this bill:
- Requires an attorney who provides a demand letter, within five business days of doing so, to submit information about the demand letter to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission on its Web site, as provided by this bill.
- Requires an attorney who sends or serves a complaint, within five business days of doing so, to submit information about the complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission on its Web site, as provided by this bill.
- Clarifies that these requirements shall apply upon the effective date of this legislation and shall not be repealed with other related reporting provisions that are scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2019.
The Senate amendments:
- Require the Commission to post on its Web site a new standard format and the date by when the Commission will begin requiring information to be submitted in that format, at least 30 days before requiring information to be in that new standard format.
- Clarify throughout the bill that the standard format specified by the Commission is that format specified on the Commission's Web site as required by this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, one-time costs to the CCDA of $90,000 to $110,000 (General Fund) which includes 1) $40,000 to $60,000 for the development and implementation of a digital data capture format necessary to collect and conduct analysis of the reported information, and, 2) a $50,000 limited-term contract to transition the data to the automated system. Ongoing costs for the revised data collection process are estimated at about $15,000 per year. Potential future cost savings are likely to be realized through administrative efficiencies created by streamlining the existing manual process of data entry and storage of these public records.
COMMENTS: As introduced last year, this bill would have established a controversial notice and right-to-cure procedure limited to construction-related accessibility standards that had changed within the previous three years. In addition, this bill sought to authorize a tax credit of up to $250 for business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. On April 21, 2015, the author agreed to amend the bill in the Assembly Judiciary Committee to eliminate the notice and right-to-cure procedure, but retain the tax credit. This bill was approved by the Judiciary Committee and referred to the Revenue and Taxation Committee, where it subsequently was held as a two-year bill.
In January 2016, the author made wholesale amendments to the bill to delete the tax credit provisions and replace the contents of the bill. As amended, the bill furthers legislation enacted last year by seeking to facilitate more efficient reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access.
Last year the Legislature approved and the Governor signed into law AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2015, which, among other things, requires attorneys in disability access cases to notify the Commission, within five business days of any judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint, of certain information in a standard format specified by the Commission. Specifically, the information required to be reported to the Commission includes: the date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal; whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter; and other specified information. (See Civil Code Section 55.32(b)(2).) Existing law also requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or who sends or serves a complaint in a construction-related accessibility case to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the Commission within five business days. Existing law also requires a copy of the demand letter to be sent to the State Bar, but only until January 1, 2019.
This bill would require these attorneys to submit additional information about the demand letter or complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission, so that data about accessibility claims can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature. The amendments also clarify that the above requirement for reporting in a standard format is intended to apply upon the effective date of this legislation, and not intended to be repealed with other related reporting provisions that are scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2019. Recent Senate amendments require the Commission, at least 30 days before requiring information to be sent in a new standard format, to post on its Web site the new standard format and the date by when the Commission will begin requiring such information to be submitted in that standard format. In addition, a number of technical amendments are made throughout the bill to clarify that the new standard format specified by the Commission is that format specified on the Commission's Web site, as now required by this bill.
According to Commission staff, the Commission has already received approximately 300 total documents from attorneys (including demand letters, complaints, and other reportable information) since AB 1521 went into effect on October 21, 2015. This bill, like AB 1521, may help the Commission better organize and review the information it receives from attorneys by requiring such information to be submitted in a standard format—thereby increasing the efficiency of Commission staff resources. As the Commission continues to adjust to recent changes to the law, it is thought that additional clarification may be identified and potentially addressed in the future.
The changes proposed by this bill will help the Commission further compile and report information that provides an empirical profile of recent Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA)-related litigation. Past data compiled by the Commission indicate that it is a handful of highly litigious plaintiffs that have targeted small businesses, often those without the financial resources and sophistication to challenge such lawsuits on their merits. According to the Commission, more than half (54%) of the construction-related accessibility complaints filed between 2012 and 2014 were filed by two law firms; and 46% of all complaints were filed by just 14 parties. These figures indicate that the vast majority of all construction-related accessibility claims filed in this state are initiated by a very small number of plaintiffs (and their attorneys). As a result, small businesses are justifiably fearful about being sued, while disabled consumers are often viewed with blame or suspicion, even though they have a legal right to full and equal access and justifiably should be able to expect all public accommodations to comply with the 25-year old requirements of the ADA.
But it is also important to put these figures into perspective. According to data compiled by the Commission, from January 2014 until January 2015, there were 3,468 demand letters and complaints sent or filed in the state. In contrast, according to the Judicial Council of California, a total of 800,091 lawsuits were filed in the state in 2013 (the most recent year data are available). Meanwhile, California has approximately 3.3 million small businesses. These figures mean that less than 1% of small businesses (and a far smaller percentage of all businesses) were sued in 2014 for access violations; and the 3,468 demand letters or complaints regarding accessibility violations represent less than one-half of 1% (0.43%) of the total number of lawsuits filed in the state. The actual percentage is even smaller, because the Commission figure includes demand letters that are not complaints.
At the same time, there is no evidence that lawsuits filed by high-frequency litigants are "frivolous." The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines "frivolous" as "of little weight or importance," or "having no sound basis (as in fact or law) <a frivolous lawsuit>." In other words, a lawsuit alleging a violation of the Unruh Act because of a denial of access would only be "frivolous" if it had no basis in the law (i.e. it did not state an actual violation). In fact, there is no evidence that the complaints which are filed are without merit. According to data collected by the Commission, most complaints identify multiple access violations. For example, of the cases filed in July 2014, most complaints identified multiple or significant single violations, such as missing grab bars. By contrast, only two out of 201 complaints reviewed identified a single violation, such as a soap or seat cover dispenser being too high.
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004304
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 54
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/14/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 1/27/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Commission on Disability Access
DIGEST: This bill modifies existing requirements related to the reporting of information about demand letters and complaints regarding construction-related accessibility violations to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA). Specifically, this bill requires the information about demand letters and complaints to be submitted in a standard format as specified by the CCDA.
Existing law:
- Provides, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
- Declares, pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, and entitles persons to $4000 minimum statutory damages for violations of Unruh. (Civ. Code Sec. 51 et seq.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code Secs. 54, 54.1.)
- Provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Sections 54 or 54.1, and entitles a prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.)
- Prohibits a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages, and provides that a violation of this provision constitutes cause for attorney discipline. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.31.)
- Requires an attorney who serves a demand letter upon a defendant to, within five business days, submit a copy of the demand letter to the CCDA. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
- Requires an attorney who files a complaint to submit a copy of the complaint to the CCDA within five business days, and requires that the attorney notify the CCDA of any settlement, judgment, or dismissal, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
This bill requires an attorney serving a demand letter or complaint to send a copy to the CCDA and submit information in a standard form specified by the CCDA.
Background
Since 1969, persons with disabilities have enjoyed protection under Civil Code
Sections 54 and 54.1, which entitle individuals with disabilities and medical conditions to full and free access to and use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. After Congress enacted the ADA in 1990, the state made a violation of the ADA also a violation of Section 54 or 54.1. The state protections provided to disabled persons are comparatively higher than those provided under the ADA and are independent of the ADA. Additionally, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. (Civil Code Sec. 51.) A violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Section 51.
In 2003 and 2005, several bills were introduced after multiple lawsuits were filed in state court by a few plaintiffs and attorneys against business owners and operators for allegedly technical violations of the state’s access or ADA regulations. (SB 69 (Oller, 2003), AB 209 (Leslie, 2003), AB 20 (Leslie, 2005), SB 855 (Poochigian, 2005).) Three of those bills would have required a plaintiff to undertake prelitigation steps prior to the filing of a complaint, including providing notice to the owner of the property or business of the alleged violations, and provided a specified time period for the owner or business to cure the violations. One bill, (AB 20, Leslie, 2005) would have precluded an action for damages for a de minimus violation, allowing only injunctive relief and attorney’s fees. All of those bills failed passage in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses. In 2008, two bills were introduced relating to disability access. AB 2533 (Keene, 2008) and SB 1766 (McClintock, 2008) would have both imposed prelitigation hurdles on plaintiffs claiming violations of construction-related disability access laws. Both of these bills failed in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses. In 2011, SB 783 (Dutton, 2011) would have established notice requirements for an aggrieved party to follow before he or she can bring a disability access suit and given the business owner a 120-day time period to remedy the violation. That bill failed passage.
Alternatively, SB 1608 (Corbett et al., Chapter 549, Statutes of 2008), which took effect January 1, 2009, did not create any pre-litigation hurdles for a person with a disability but instead, among other things, provided for an early evaluation of a filed complaint if the defendant is a qualified defendant who had the identified place of public accommodation inspected and determined to meet applicable physical access standards by a state Certified Access Specialist (CASp) prior to the filing of the complaint. In 2012, Senators Steinberg and Dutton authored SB 1186 (Chapter 383, Statutes of 2012) which sought to comprehensively address continued issues with disability litigation.
Ultimately, the bipartisan effort was viewed as a compromise that hoped to end the abusive litigation tactics of some attorneys, protect the rights of disabled persons, and promote compliance with state and federal access laws. SB 1186 created a number of protections for small businesses and defendants who had, prior to a claim being filed, sought out a CASp inspection. These protections included reduced minimum statutory damages, early evaluation conferences, and mandatory stays of court proceedings while the violations were corrected. That bill also prevented the stacking of multiple claims to increase damages, banned pre-litigation demands for money, and increased data collection regarding alleged access violations.
Last year a number of bills were introduced to further combat perceived issues with disability litigation. AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary, Chapter 755, Statutes of 2015) created a new class of plaintiff, a “high frequency litigant,” upon which it imposed additional costs and procedural burdens. Two bills, one which created a tax credit for certain access expenditures to businesses, and the other that would have provided funding to the CCDA, were vetoed by the Governor, who stated that such legislation is more appropriately considered in the annual budget process (SB 251 (Roth) and AB 1342 (Steinorth)). This bill, seeking to aid the CCDA in its charge to collect and analyze data related to construction-related accessibility claims, authorizes the CCDA to create a standard format that attorneys would need to follow when submitting information to the CCDA.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, one-time costs to the CCDA of $90,000 to $110,000 (General Fund) which includes (1) $40,000 to $60,000 for the development and implementation of a digital data capture format necessary to collect and conduct analysis of the reported information, and, (2) a $50,000 limited-term contract to transition the data to the automated system. Ongoing costs for the revised data collection process are estimated at about $15,000 per year. Potential future cost savings are likely to be realized through administrative efficiencies created by streamlining the existing manual process of data entry and storage of these public records.
California Commission on Disability Access (source)
California Grocers Association
California Small Business Association
Civil Justice Association of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes in support:
AB 1521 was created to set up a database of high-frequency litigants to “crack down” on individuals filing frivolous claims. Requiring the complaint letters to be sent in a standard format was going to make it easier for the Commission on Disability Access to quickly review the letters and quickly identify who was abusing the legal system. However, the standardized format requirement doesn’t take effect until 2019.
AB 54 “fills in the gap.” Rather than waiting until 2019, this law will take effect so that the demand letters will be required to be sent in a standardized format developed by the Commission.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 1/27/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Mathis
8/15/16 20:01:51
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 54 (Olsen) - Disability access: construction-related accessibility claims: demand letters
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 54 would modify existing requirements related to the reporting of information about demand letters and complaints regarding construction-related accessibility violations to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA). Specifically, this bill would require the information about demand letters and complaints to be submitted in a standard format as specified by the CCDA.
Fiscal Impact:
One-time costs to the CCDA of $90,000 to $110,000 (General Fund) which includes (1) $40,000 to $60,000 for the development and implementation of a digital data capture format necessary to collect and conduct analysis of the reported information, and, (2) a $50,000 limited-term contract to transition the data to the automated system. Ongoing costs for the revised data collection process are estimated at about $15,000 per year. Potential future cost savings are likely to be realized through administrative efficiencies created by streamlining the existing manual process of data entry and storage of these public records.
Background:
The California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) was established pursuant to SB 1608 (Corbett) Chapter 549/2008, to act as an information resource; to research and prepare advisory reports of findings to the Legislature on issues related to disability access, compliance inspections and continuing education; to increase coordination between stakeholders; to make recommendations to promote compliance with federal and state laws and regulations; and to provide uniform information about programmatic and architectural disability access requirements to stakeholders.
In 2012, SB 1186 (Steinberg) Chapter 383/2012 established the additional review and reporting of demand letters by the CCDA. Subsequent legislation, including AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary) Chapter 755/2015 was signed into law as an urgency measure with the requirement for the CCDA to additionally collect and study case outcomes.
Existing law requires an attorney who serves a demand letter and/or files a complaint alleging a violation of any construction-related accessibility standard, to submit a copy of the letter and/or complaint to the CCDA within five business days of serving or sending the letter or complaint on the defendant. (Civil Code § 55.32.)
The CCDA currently has limited resources to fulfill its numerous duties and obligations. This bill seeks to aid the CCDA in its charge to collect and analyze data obtained from construction-related accessibility claims through a more efficient data collection process.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require an attorney serving a demand letter or complaint to send a copy to the CCDA and submit information in a standard form as specified by the CCDA on its internet website. Additionally, this bill would require the CCDA to, at least 30 days before requiring a new standard format, post on its internet website the new standard format and the start date that the CCDA will begin requiring that information sent to the CCDA be submitted in the new standard format.
Related Legislation:
SB 1406 (Mendoza) 2016 would require an attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility violation against a public entity to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the CCDA, as specified. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 54 (Author:Olsen)
Version: May 24, 2016
Hearing Date: June 14, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: NR
SUBJECT
Disability access: construction-related accessibility claims: demand letters
DESCRIPTION
With regard to construction-related accessibility violations, this bill would require that information about the demand letter and the complaint be submitted to the California Commission on Disability Access in a standard format specified by the Commission.
BACKGROUND
Since 1969, persons with disabilities have enjoyed protection under Civil Code
Sections 54 and 54.1, which entitle individuals with disabilities and medical conditions to full and free access to and use of roadways, sidewalks, buildings and facilities open to the public, hospitals and medical facilities, and housing. After Congress enacted the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in 1990, the state made a violation of the ADA also a violation of Section 54 or 54.1. The state protections provided to disabled persons are comparatively higher than those provided under the ADA and are independent of the ADA. Additionally, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. (Civil Code Sec. 51.) A violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Section 51.
In 2003 and 2005, several bills were introduced after multiple lawsuits were filed in state court by a few plaintiffs and attorneys against business owners and operators for allegedly technical violations of the state’s access or ADA regulations. (SB 69 (Oller, 2003), AB 209 (Leslie, 2003), AB 20 (Leslie, 2005), SB 855 (Poochigian, 2005).) Three of those bills would have required a plaintiff to undertake prelitigation steps prior to the filing of a complaint, including providing notice to the owner of the property or business of the alleged violations, and provided a specified time period for the owner or business to cure the violations. One bill, (AB 20, Leslie, 2005) would have precluded an action for damages for a de minimus violation, allowing only injunctive relief and attorney’s fees. All of those bills failed passage in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses. In 2008, two bills were introduced relating to disability access. AB 2533 (Keene, 2008) and SB 1766 (McClintock, 2008) would have both imposed prelitigation hurdles on plaintiffs claiming violations of construction-related disability access laws. Both of these bills failed in the Judiciary Committees of their respective houses. In 2011, SB 783 (Dutton, 2011) would have established notice requirements for an aggrieved party to follow before he or she can bring a disability access suit and given the business owner a 120-day time period to remedy the violation. That bill failed passage in this Committee.
Alternatively, SB 1608 (Corbett et al., Ch. 549, Stats. 2008), which took effect January 1, 2009, did not create any pre-litigation hurdles for a person with a disability but instead, among other things, provided for an early evaluation of a filed complaint if the defendant is a qualified defendant who had the identified place of public accommodation inspected and determined to meet applicable physical access standards by a state Certified Access Specialist (CASp) prior to the filing of the complaint. In 2012, Senators Steinberg and Dutton authored SB 1186 (Ch. 383, Stats. 2012) which sought to comprehensively address continued issues with disability litigation.
Ultimately, the bipartisan effort was viewed as a compromise that hoped to end the abusive litigation tactics of some attorneys, protect the rights of disabled persons, and promote compliance with state and federal access laws. SB 1186 created a number of protections for small businesses and defendants who had, prior to a claim being filed, sought out a CASp inspection. These protections included reduced minimum statutory damages, early evaluation conferences, and mandatory stays of court proceedings while the violations were corrected. That bill also prevented the stacking of multiple claims to increase damages, banned pre-litigation demands for money, and increased data collection regarding alleged access violations.
Last year a number of bills were introduced to further combat perceived issues with disability litigation. AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 755, Stats. 2015) created a new class of plaintiff, a “high frequency litigant,” upon which it imposed additional costs and procedural burdens. Two bills, one which created a tax credit for certain access expenditures to businesses, and the other that would have provided funding to the Commission on Disability Access, were vetoed by the Governor, who stated that such legislation is more appropriately considered in the annual budget process (SB 251 (Roth) and AB 1342 (Steinorth); see Prior Legislation below). This bill, seeking to aid the Commission in its charge to collect and analyze data related to construction-related accessibility claims, would authorize the Commission to create a standard format that attorneys would need to follow when submitting information to the Commission.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, declares that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, and entitles persons to $4000 minimum statutory damages for violations of Unruh. (Civ. Code Sec. 51 et seq.)
Existing law provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities, and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code Secs. 54, 54.1.)
Existing law provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Sections 54 or 54.1, and entitles a prevailing party to recover reasonable attorney’s fees. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.)
Existing law prohibits a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages, and provides that a violation of this provision constitutes cause for attorney discipline. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.31.)
Existing law requires an attorney who serves a demand letter upon a defendant to, within five business days, submit a copy of the demand letter to the California Commission on Disability Access. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
Existing law requires an attorney who files a complaint to submit a copy of the complaint to the Commission within five business days, and requires that the attorney notify the Commission of any settlement, judgment, or dismissal, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
This bill would require an attorney serving a demand letter or complaint to send a copy to the Commission and submit information in a standard form specified by the Commission.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
AB 1521 was created to set up a database of high-frequency litigants to “crack down” on individuals filing frivolous claims. Requiring the complaint letters to be sent in a standard format was going to make it easier for the Commission on Disability Access to quickly review the letters and quickly identify who was abusing the legal system. However, the standardized format requirement doesn’t take effect until 2019.
AB 54 “fills in the gap.” Rather than waiting until 2019, this law will take effect so that the demand letters will be required to be sent in a standardized format developed by the Commission.
- Increased data collection helps the Legislature evaluate allegations of predatory practices
Existing law requires attorneys who serve demand letters and/or file complaints alleging violations of any construction-related accessibility standard, to send a copy of the letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission) within five business days of sending or serving the letter or complaint on the defendant. Additionally, the attorney must notify the Commission of any judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint within five business days and provide the Commission with the following information: (1) the date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal; (2) whether or not the violations alleged in the complaint were remedied after the plaintiff filed a complaint; and (3) if the violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied, whether or not another favorable result was achieved.
In 2015, the Commission released a report indicating that of the 5,392 access-related complaints filed between September 2012 and October 2014, 54 percent of the cases were filed by two law firms, and 14 plaintiffs were involved in 46 percent of the cases. That report was used to support the need for a number of bills seeking further reform of construction-related access litigation. This bill, which would allow the Commission to more efficiently process data, will arguably help ensure that lawmakers have access to up-to-date and accurate information in evaluating legislation related to disability access.
- California Commission on Disability Access has limited resources
As noted above, despite significant legislation, the business community continues to call for action to curb the allegedly predatory practices of a handful of attorneys. In seeking to better understand the issues related to serial construction-related accessibility litigation, a number of bills have called for increased data collection, analysis, and reporting by the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission). Beginning with SB 1186 (see Background) the Commission has routinely been charged with new responsibilities. SB 1186 provided that “a priority of the Commission shall be the development and dissemination of educational materials” to promote and facilitate disability access, and required the Commission to create educational materials and toolkits and to make those items available on its Internet Web site. SB 1186 also called for increased data collection, required that the data be reported to the public, and additionally created annual reporting requirements to the Legislature. This year, two bills (SB 269 (Roth) and AB 2093 (Steinorth)) would further require the Commission to develop and/or educate the public about resources and educational materials related to disability access, and SB 1407 would require the Commission to begin collecting and analyzing data on disability access litigation brought against public entities.
The Commission currently employs only four staff members: an executive director, two program analysts, and an office technician. Supported largely by volunteers that input data, the Commission has continuously satisfied the new responsibilities assigned by the Legislature. This bill, which would authorize the Commission to designate a “standard format” by which attorneys must submit information related to demand letters and complaints, could arguably reduce (if not eliminate) the onerous task of data entry, thereby allowing the Commission to spend its limited resources instead on analyzing data and creating educational materials.
- Disciplinary action for non-compliance
Regarding disability access litigation, existing law requires an attorney who provides a demand letter and/or serves a complaint to submit a copy of the letter or complaint, along with other related information, to the Commission on Disability Access (Commission) within five business days, as specified. Failure to submit the required copy and/or information “shall constitute cause for the imposition of discipline of an attorney where a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome is not sent to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, or a copy of the demand letter is not sent to the State Bar within five business days. In the event the State Bar receives information indicating that an attorney has failed to send a copy of the complaint, demand letter, or notification of a case outcome to the California Commission on Disability Access within five business days, the State Bar shall investigate to determine whether [this requirement] has been violated.” (Civ. Code Sec. 55.32.)
Thus, failure to submit the requisite information and documents within five business days subjects an attorney to disciplinary action by the State Bar which could negatively affect an attorney’s career. Furthermore, the Commission has noted that because of its limited resources (see Comment 3 above), law firms that wait to submit information to the Commission until they have acquired a large batch, are not only potentially in violation of the law, but often jam the data entry process and make it difficult for the Commission to properly staff its office with volunteers.
Staff notes that because this bill would allow the Commission, at any time after January 1, 2017, to determine the format in which attorneys must submit specified information, and that failure to comply with that format could result in disciplinary action, it is imperative that attorneys receive adequate notice as to any changes in required format. This bill, as amended on May 24, 2016, requires that the Commission post any “standard format” by which it wishes to receive information on its Internet Web site 30 days prior to that format being required, and would additionally require the Commission to clearly post the date the new format would need to be followed. This will arguably ensure that attorneys who are seeking, in good faith, to comply with the law will have adequate notice and afford them the time to update their internal processes to reflect the format specified by the Commission.
Support: California Grocers Association; California Small Business Association; Civil Justice Association of California
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: California Commission on Disability Access
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 269 (Roth, 2016) is substantially similar to SB 251 (see below), with the exception of the tax credit, which the author removed to address the Governor’s concerns. This bill is currently in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 1142 (Moorlach) would have established notice requirements for an aggrieved party to follow before he or she can bring a disability access suit and would have given the business owner a 120-day time period to remedy the violation. The bill would have also provided that in the event of any difference between the ADA and state law, that the ADA controls. This bill failed passage in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 1406 (Mendoza) would require an attorney who sends or serves a complaint alleging a construction-related accessibility violation against a public entity to send a copy of the complaint and submit the notification of judgment, settlement, or dismissal to the California Commission on Disability Access, as specified.
Prior Legislation:
AB 52 (Gray, 2015) would have provided that the defendant’s maximum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is $1,000 for each offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations within 180 days of being served with the complaint. This bill was never heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1230 (Gomez, Ch. 787, Stats. 2015) establishes the California Americans with Disabilities Act Small Business Compliance Finance Act to provide loans to assist small businesses to finance the costs of projects that alter or retrofit existing small business facilities to comply with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.
AB 1342 (Steinorth, 2015) would have provided additional revenue to the California Commission on Disability Access. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated that it was “something more appropriately addressed in the annual budget process.”
AB 1468 (Baker, 2015) would have provided that a public entity’s possession of a close out letter from the State Architect certifying that the buildings, facilities, and other places meet the applicable construction-related accessibility standards of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act, serves as presumptive evidence of compliance with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act. This bill was never heard in the Assembly Judiciary Committee. See Background; Comments 2, 4, and 6.
AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 755, Stats. 2015) See Background.
SB 67 (Galgiani, 2015) would have limited recovery against a small business for construction-related accessibility claims to injunctive relief and reasonable attorney’s fees, and would allow businesses who have undergone a CASp inspection 120 days to correct violations in order to qualify for reduced statutory minimum damages. This bill was never heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 251 (Roth, 2015) would have made various changes to access laws, including: exempting a defendant from liability for minimum statutory damages if corrections were made within 120 days of receiving a CASp report; requiring the State Architect to publish a list of CASp inspected businesses; and providing a tax credit for elibible access expenditures, as specified. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who argued that tax credits are more appropriately addressed in the annual budget process.
SB 1186 (Steinberg and Dutton, Ch. 383, Stats. 2012) reduced statutory damages and provided litigation protections for specified defendants who timely correct construction-related accessibility violations of the Unruh Civil Rights Act. That bill also banned prelitigation “demands for money” and created rules for demand letters and complaints in claims involving construction-related accessibility violations.
AB 2282 (Berryhill, 2012) would have authorized an aggrieved person to bring a disability access suit only if: (1) the person has suffered an injury in fact; (2) the injury in fact was caused by the violation; and (3) the violation is redressable, was held under submission in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1878 (Gaines, 2011) which is substantially similar to SB 1163 but applies to “microbusinesses,” defined by the bill, failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SB 1163 (Walters, 2012) would have established notice requirements for an aggrieved party to follow before he or she can bring a disability access suit and would have given the business owner a 120-day time period to remedy the violation. If the property owner cured the violation, this bill would have prohibited the plaintiff from receiving any damages or attorney’s fees, except for special damages. This bill failed passage in this Committee.
SB 783 (Dutton, 2011), which was identical to SB 1163, failed passage in this Committee.
SB 384 (Evans, Ch. 419, Stats. 2011) clarified that attorneys who file complaints or send demand letters related to disability access violations must provide a written notice of legal rights and obligations whether or not the attorney intends to file an action in state or federal court.
SB 209 (Corbett & Harman, Ch. 569, Stats. 2009) required a CASp inspection report to remain confidential rather than be under seal and subject to protective order.
SB 1608 (Corbett et al., Ch. 549, Stats. 2008) See Background; Comment 6.
SB 1766 (McClintock, 2008) See Background.
AB 2533 (Keene, 2008) See Background.
SB 855 (Poochigian, 2005) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 78, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 17, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
Assembly Rules Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing: January 21, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 54
Author:(Olsen) – As Amended Ver:January 13, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill modifies existing requirements for the reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) regarding construction-related accessibility cases. Specifically, this bill requires an attorney who provides copies of a demand letter or complaint to the CCDA to also submit information about the demand letter or complaint in a standard format as specified by the commission.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor absorbable one-time costs for the commission to develop a standard reporting format for information to be submitted with demand letters and claims.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. Current law already requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or who sends or serves a complaint in a construction-related accessibility case to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the Commission within five business days. As recently amended, AB 54 requires these attorneys to submit additional information about the demand letter or complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission, so that data about accessibility claims can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: January 15, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 54 (
Author:Olsen) – As Amended Ver:January 13, 2016
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: CALIFORNIA COMMISSION ON DISABILITY ACCESS: DEMAND LETTERS AND COMPLAINTS: STANDARDIZED REPORTING
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD INFORMATION ABOUT DEMAND LETTERS OR COMPLAINTS IN CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY CLAIM CASES THAT MUST BE SUBMITTED TO THE CALIFORNIA COMMISSION ON DISABILITY ACCESS ADHERE TO A STANDARD FORMAT SPECIFIED BY THE COMMISSION IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE EFFICIENCY OF THE COMMISSION'S REVIEW AND EVALUATION OF SUCH INFORMATION?
SYNOPSIS
As introduced last year, this bill would have established a controversial notice and right-to-cure procedure limited to construction-related accessibility standards that had changed within the previous three years. In addition, this bill sought to authorize a tax credit of up to $250 for business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. On April 21, 2015, the author agreed to amend the bill in this Committee to eliminate the notice and right-to-cure procedure, but retain the tax credit. AB 54 was approved by this Committee and referred to the Revenue and Taxation Committee, where it subsequently was held as a two-year bill. On January 4, 2016, the author made wholesale amendments to the bill to delete the tax credit provisions and replace the contents of the bill with substantially the same language contained in the enrolled version of SB 251 (Roth), which was vetoed by Governor Brown in October 2015. The bill was then re-referred by Rules Committee back to this Committee for hearing.
As most recently amended on January 13th, the bill no longer seeks to enact the majority of the language from last year’s SB 251. Instead, the author has amended the bill to facilitate more efficient reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access ("Commission"). Specifically, with respect to construction-related accessibility claim cases, this bill would require attorneys to submit information about the demand letter or complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission. The requirement for submission in a standard format is intended to ensure that this data can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature, while maximizing efficient use of Commission staff resources. The recent amendments also clarify that the above requirement is intended to apply upon the effective date of this legislation, and not intended to be repealed with other related reporting provisions that are scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2019. As a result of these amendments, all of the disability advocates who opposed the bill in its previous form have now taken a neutral position on this bill, and there is no known opposition to the bill. If approved by this Committee, the bill will be referred to the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SUMMARY: Modifies existing requirements for the reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access. Specifically, in construction-related accessibility claim cases, this bill:
- Requires an attorney who provides a demand letter, within five business days of doing so, to submit information about the demand letter to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission.
- Requires an attorney who sends or serves a complaint, within five business days of doing so, to submit information about the complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission.
- Clarifies that these requirements shall apply after the effective date of this legislation and shall not be repealed with other related reporting provisions that are scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2019.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides the California Commission on Disability Access ("Commission"), an independent state agency composed of 19 members, with general responsibility for monitoring disability access compliance in California, and with authority to make recommendations to the Legislature for necessary changes in order to facilitate implementation of state and federal laws on disability access. (Gov. Code Section 8299 et seq.)
- Requires an attorney, when serving a demand letter or a complaint on a defendant alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance, to provide a written advisory with each demand letter or complaint, as defined. The written advisory shall include information about the defendant’s rights and obligations, including the right of a qualified defendant to request a stay and an early evaluation conference regarding the allegations in the complaint. The written advisory is only required from any attorney, and not from a pro per plaintiff. (Civil Code Section 55.3. All further references are to this code unless otherwise stated.)
- Requires an attorney alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance to state facts sufficient to allow the defendant to identify the basis for the claim. (Section 55.31.)
- Prohibits such a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury or special damages. After receiving a duly-provided demand letter, a building owner, tenant, authorized agent or employee may request a settlement figure or specification of damages. Upon such a request, an attorney may present a settlement figure or specification of damages. (Section 55.31.)
- Requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter to the Commission and the State Bar, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the Commission, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Section 55.32.)
- Requires the Commission to review and report on the demand letters and complaints it receives until January 1, 2016. Also requires the State Bar, commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, to report specified information to the Legislature regarding the demand letters that it receives. (Section 55.32.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: As introduced last year, this bill would have established a controversial notice and right-to-cure procedure limited to construction-related accessibility standards that had changed within the previous three years. In addition, this bill sought to authorize a tax credit of up to $250 for business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. On April 21, 2015, the author agreed to amend the bill in this Committee to eliminate the notice and right-to-cure procedure, but retain the tax credit. AB 54 was approved by this Committee and referred to the Revenue and Taxation Committee, where it subsequently was held as a two-year bill.
On January 4, 2016, the author made wholesale amendments to the bill to delete the tax credit provisions and replace the contents of the bill with substantially the same language contained in the enrolled version of SB 251 (Roth), which was vetoed by Governor Brown in October 2015. The bill was then re-referred by the Rules Committee back to this Committee for hearing. After negotiations with the Committee, the author agreed to amend the bill to facilitate more efficient reporting of information about demand letters and complaints to the California Commission on Disability Access. As such, the bill no longer seeks to enact the majority of the language from SB 251. (However, that language has recently been amended into another bill currently in this Committee’s possession, SB 269 (Roth and Vidak).)
Data reported to and compiled by CCDA provides an empirical profile of recent ADA-related litigation. There has been widespread media coverage about the problem of what has been described as "serial ADA litigation." For example, in 2014, the Modesto Bee and the Merced Sun-Star reported a series of articles, describing “how the Americans with Disabilities Act has been misused to create profit centers for opportunistic lawyers. These attorneys recruit people – some with minor disabilities, some with criminal records, some here illegally – to visit small businesses in hopes of spotting the most minute ADA violations. The lawyers then demand $4,000 for each violation.” The author contends further that "businesses up and down the state have become vulnerable targets for frivolous lawsuits, forcing many small businesses to lay off employees or shut their doors."
Empirical data, however, indicate that it is a handful of highly litigious plaintiffs that have targeted small businesses, often those without the financial resources and sophistication to challenge such lawsuits on their merits. According to data compiled by the Commission, more than half (54 percent) of the construction-related accessibility complaints filed between 2012 and 2014 were filed by two law firms; and 46 percent of all complaints were filed by just 14 parties. These figures indicate that the vast majority of all construction-related accessibility claims filed in this state are initiated by a very small number of plaintiffs (and their attorneys). As a result, small businesses are justifiably fearful about being sued, while disabled consumers are often viewed with blame or suspicion, even though they have a legal right to full and equal access and justifiably should be able to expect all public accommodations to comply with the 25-year old requirements of the ADA.
But it is also important to put these figures into perspective. According to data compiled by the Commission, from January 2014 until January 2015, there were 3,468 demand letters and complaints sent or filed in the state. In contrast, according to the Judicial Council of California, a total of 800,091 lawsuits were filed in the state in 2013 (the most recent year data are available). Meanwhile, California has approximately 3.3 million small businesses. These figures mean that less than one percent of small businesses (and a far smaller percentage of all businesses) were sued in 2014 for access violations; and the 3,468 demand letters or complaints regarding accessibility violations represent less than one-half of one percent (0.43%) of the total number of lawsuits filed in the state. The actual percentage is even smaller, because the Commission figure includes demand letters that are not complaints.
At the same time, there is no evidence that lawsuits filed by high-frequency litigants are “frivolous.” The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines “frivolous” as “of little weight or importance,” or “having no sound basis (as in fact or law) <a frivolous lawsuit>.” In other words, a lawsuit alleging a violation of the Unruh Act because of a denial of access would only be “frivolous” if it had no basis in the law (i.e. it did not state an actual violation). In fact, there is no evidence that the complaints which are filed are without merit. According to data collected by the Commission, most complaints identify multiple access violations. For example, of the cases filed in July 2014, most complaints identified multiple or significant single violations, such as missing grab bars. By contrast, only two out of 201 complaints reviewed identified a single violation, such as a soap or seat cover dispenser being too high.
As amended, this bill furthers recent legislation intended to facilitate more efficient data collection and reporting by the Commission. Last year the Legislature approved and the Governor signed into law AB 1521, authored by this Committee, which, among other things, requires attorneys in disability access cases to notify the Commission, within five business days of any judgment, settlement, or dismissal of the claim or claims alleged in the complaint, of certain information in a standard format specified by the Commission. Specifically, the information required to be reported to the Commission includes: (1) the date of the judgment, settlement, or dismissal; (2) whether or not the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter; (3) if the construction-related accessibility violations alleged in the complaint were not remedied in whole or in part after the plaintiff filed a complaint or provided a demand letter, whether or not another favorable result was achieved after the plaintiff filed the complaint or provided the demand letter; and (4) whether or not the defendant submitted an application for an early evaluation conference and stay pursuant to Civil Code Section 55.54, whether the defendant requested a site inspection, the date of any early evaluation conference, and the date of any site inspection. (See Civil Code Section 55.32(b)(2).)
Existing law already requires an attorney who provides a demand letter or who sends or serves a complaint in a construction-related accessibility case to send a copy of the demand letter or complaint to the Commission within five business days. (Existing law also requires a copy of the demand letter to be sent to the State Bar, but only until January 1, 2019.) As recently amended, this bill would require these attorneys to submit additional information about the demand letter or complaint to the Commission in a standard format specified by the Commission, so that data about accessibility claims can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature. The amendments also clarify that the above requirement for reporting in a standard format is intended to apply upon the effective date of this legislation, and not intended to be repealed with other related reporting provisions that are scheduled to sunset on January 1, 2019.
According to Commission staff contacted by the Committee, the Commission has already received approximately 300 total documents from attorneys (including demand letters, complaints, and other reportable information) since AB 1521 went into effect on October 21, 2015. This bill, like AB 1521, may help the Commission better organize and review the information it receives from attorneys by requiring such information to be submitted in a standard format—thereby increasing the efficiency of CCDA staff resources. As the Commission continues to adjust to recent changes to the law, it is thought that additional clarification may be identified and potentially addressed in the future. The author has agreed to work closely with the Committee if additional amendments are needed to address those concerns with this bill.
Related pending legislation. AB 52 (Gray) provides, among other things, that the defendant’s maximum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is $1,000 for each offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations within 180 days of being served with the complaint. This bill is currently in this Committee as a two-year bill.
AB 1468 (Baker) seeks to provide, among other things, that a public entity’s possession of a close out letter from the State Architect certifying that the buildings, facilities, and other places meet the applicable construction-related accessibility standards of the ADA, serves as presumptive evidence of compliance with the ADA. This bill is currently in this Committee as a two-year bill.
SB 67 (Galgiani) seeks to exempt small businesses from statutory damage liability in connection with a construction-related accessibility claim and to extend the period for correcting construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim from 60 days to 120 days of being served with the complaint, for purposes of reducing a defendant’s minimum statutory damage liability to $1,000. This bill is currently in Senate Judiciary as a two-year bill.
SB 269 (Roth and Vidak) is substantially similar to SB 251 (Roth) of 2015 (see below), with the notable exception that it does not contain tax incentives for eligible access expenditures by businesses. This bill is currently in this Committee.
Related previous legislation. AB 1230 (Gomez), Chapter 787, Statutes of 2015, establishes the California Americans With Disabilities Act Small Business Capital Access Loan Program within the California Capital Access Loan Program in order to create a self-sustaining program to provide loans to assist small businesses in financing the costs of projects that alter or retrofit existing small business facilities according to certain criteria, to comply with the ADA.
AB 1342 (Steinorth) would have provided additional revenue to the California Commission on Disability Access. In addition, the bill would have required a commercial property owner to state on every lease form or rental agreement executed after July 1, 2016, whether or not the property being leased has undergone inspection by a CASp, and would have required a commercial property owner to provide additional information to the tenant or lessor about the condition of the rented or leased property. AB 1342 was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1521 (Assembly Committee on the Judiciary), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2015, establishes new pre-filing procedures for "high-frequency litigants" and provides new tools for businesses to use when they are served with complaints alleging violations of construction-related accessibility claims.
SB 251 (Roth), among other things, would have established a list of "technical violations" that are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of awarding the plaintiff minimum statutory damages, where certain conditions are satisfied. This would have protected a business from liability for minimum statutory damages for violations of construction-related accessibility standards during the 120 day period after the business obtains a CASp inspection of the interior, the exterior, or the entirety of the premises, provided that all violations were corrected within the 120 period and other conditions were satisfied. The bill also would have provided a tax credit for eligible expenditures to increase accessibility. SB 251 was vetoed by the Governor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Grocers Association
California Small Business Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: January 12, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 54
Author:(Olsen) – As Amended Ver:January 4, 2016
SUBJECT: CIVIL RIGHTS: DISABILITY ACCESS
KEY ISSUES:
- Should existing state laws governing construction-related accessibility claims be modified to create a rebuttable presumption that certain specified “technical violations” of construction-related accessibility standards do not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages, where the defendant is a small business, the defendant has, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint, corrected all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim?
- Should a business with 100 or fewer employees be protected from liability for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim during the 120-day period after the business has obtained an inspection of its premises by a Certified access specialist, allowing the business to identify and correct violations during that period under certain conditions?
SYNOPSIS
As introduced last year, this bill would have established a controversial notice and right-to-cure procedure limited to construction-related accessibility standards that had changed within the previous three years. In addition, this bill sought to authorize a tax credit of up to $250 for business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. On April 21, 2015, the author agreed to amend the bill in this committee to eliminate the notice and right-to-cure procedure, but retain the tax credit. AB 54 was approved by this Committee and referred to the Revenue and Taxation Committee, where it subsequently was held as a two-year bill. On January 4, 2016, the author made wholesale amendments to the bill to delete the tax credit provisions and replace the contents of the bill with substantially the same language contained in the enrolled version of SB 251 (Roth), which was vetoed by Governor Brown in October 2015. In short, the present bill is substantially similar to last year's SB 251, with the notable exception that it does not contain any tax incentives for eligible access expenditures by businesses. It also is a competing effort to SB 269 (Roth), a bill currently in this committee, which represents that Senate author's continuing efforts in the second year of this session to enact substantially similar changes in law that he developed and articulated last year, with input from this Committee, in his bill SB 251.
Proponents of this bill assert that additional tools are necessary to protect small businesses from high-frequency litigants and to encourage compliance with longstanding federal and state disability access laws. Therefore, this bill seeks to establish several changes to existing law in order to provide financial relief to small businesses and encourage compliance by businesses with construction-related accessibility standards so that disabled consumers can exercise their civil rights to fully and equally access all of the public accommodations in the state. In perhaps its most significant provision, this bill seeks to protect a business with 100 employees or less from liability for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim for the 120-day period after the business has obtained an inspection of its premises by a Certified Access Specialist (CASp), allowing the business to identify and correct violations during that period under certain conditions, including the following: 1) the structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating “CASp determination pending” or “Inspected by a CASp”; 2) the inspection predates the filing of the claim by, or receipt of a demand letter; and 3) the defendant corrects, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report and which are the basis of the claim.
This bill also would establish a rebuttable presumption that certain “technical violations” do not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, if the following are true: (1) the defendant is a small business, as defined; (2) the defendant has corrected all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim or receipt of a written notice, whichever is earlier; and (3) the claim is based on a number of specified violations, including but not limited to, the lack of exterior signs; the order in which parking signs are placed or the exact location or wording of parking signs; the color of parking signs; and the color of parking lot striping, among other things.
The Legislature has frequently heard and consistently rejected the idea that people with disabilities should be required to comply with special procedural barriers not faced by others who endure discrimination before they can assert legal claims against businesses that violate their rights, and has also rejected the idea that a disabled consumer should be precluded from recovering the minimum statutory damages to which he or she is entitled if the business that has violated the disabled person’s rights, after being notified of the violation, corrects the illegal condition at some point in the future.
It should also be noted that there is no governmental entity charged with administrative or judicial enforcement of construction-related accessibility claims. Like other civil rights statutes that prohibit discrimination in businesses open to the public, the statutory scheme for enforcement of disability access laws rests on voluntary compliance and individual legal actions. Unfortunately, a very small number of highly litigious plaintiffs and attorneys is abusing the law by making a practice of filing and quickly settling lawsuits from small businesses without getting the underlying access issue corrected. According to information from the California Commission on Disability Access, more than half (54%) of construction-related accessibility complaints filed between 2012 and 2014 were filed by two law firms. Forty-six percent of all complaints were filed by 14 parties. These figures indicate that the vast majority of the construction-related accessibility lawsuits filed in this state are filed by a very small number of plaintiffs. As a result, small businesses are justifiably fearful and angry about being sued, while disabled consumers, who reasonably expect businesses to be compliant with 25 year-old access laws so they can exercise their civil rights, are unfairly viewed by some businesses and policymakers with blame or suspicion.
Nevertheless, proponents contend the bill is necessary because many small businesses remain out of compliance with longstanding state and federal disability access laws, leaving them vulnerable to lawsuits. Some of these suits, they contend (and even some of the opponents concede), are brought by plaintiffs for personal financial benefit, not out of a desire to improve access for disabled consumers and have access barriers removed, and some of these suits are brought against businesses that are willing to comply but are hampered by the complexity of the law. Disability rights advocates who oppose the bill do agree with the supporters on a number of points, including that many businesses are not in compliance with access laws despite these laws’ long-standing existence and that many lawsuits are filed, some by plaintiffs seeking monetary recovery, rather than improved access. These advocates argue, however, that they have supported prior legislation to increase business awareness of access obligations, improve voluntary compliance, and reward responsible behavior and that those reforms should be furthered, not circumvented. In opposition, these advocates contend the bill singles out people with disabilities for unprecedented obstacles to the enforcement of their civil rights, deprives them of a remedy for actual violations, and will deter, rather than encourage, compliance with disability discrimination laws. Moreover, the opponents state that the promise of the bill may be misleadingly unattainable because the requirements it would impose are inconsistent with federal disability discrimination law and therefore would not preclude many of the lawsuits (in federal court) against which businesses seek protection.
SUMMARY: Makes a number of changes to provide financial relief to businesses, and encourage compliance with construction-related accessibility standards so that disabled consumers can exercise their rights to fully and equally access public accommodations in the state. Specifically, this bill:
- Effective January 1, 2019, require an attorney who provides a demand letter or who sends or serves a complaint to also submit information about the demand letter or complaint to the California Commission on Disability Access (commission) in a standard format specified by the commission.
- Establishes a presumption that certain “technical violations” are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim, where the defendant is a small business, the defendant has corrected, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim or receipt of a written notice, whichever is earlier, all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim, and the claim is based on one or more of the following violations:
- Interior signs, other than directional signs or signs that identify the location of accessible elements, facilities, or features, when all such elements, facilities or features are accessible;
- The lack of exterior signs, other than parking signs and, directional signs (including, signs that indicate the location of accessible pathways or entrance and exit doors when not all pathways, entrance and exit doors are accessible);
- The order in which parking signs are placed or the exact location or wording of parking signs, provided that the parking sign is clearly visible and indicates the location of accessible parking and van-accessible parking;
- The color of parking signs, provided that the color of the background contrasts with the color of the information on the sign;
- The color of parking lot striping, provided that it exists and provides sufficient contrast with the surface upon which it is applied is reasonably visible;
- Faded, chipped, damaged or deteriorated paint in otherwise fully compliant parking spaces and passenger access aisles in parking lots, provided that it indicates the required dimensions of a parking space or access aisle in a manner that is reasonably visible; or
- The presence or condition of detectable warning surfaces on ramps, except where the ramp is part of a pedestrian path of travel that intersects with a vehicular lane or other hazardous area.
- States that the above presumption affects the plaintiff’s burden of proof and is rebuttable by evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the plaintiff did, in fact, experience difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment on the particular occasion as a result of one or more of the technical violations listed in 2), above.
- Protects a business from liability for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim made during the 120 day period after the business obtains an inspection of its premises by a CASp, allowing the business to identify and correct violations during that period, under the following conditions:
- The defendant is a business that has employed 100 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department.
- The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating “CASp determination pending” or “Inspected by a CASp.”
- The inspection predates the filing of the claim by, or receipt of a demand letter from, the plaintiff regarding the alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard, and the defendant was not on notice of the alleged violation.
- Within ten days of the date of the inspection, the CASp files a notice with the State Architect for listing on the State Architect’s Internet Web site, stating that the defendant has obtained a CASp inspection, the date of the filing, and the date of the inspection.
- The CASp posts the notice described in (d), above, in a form prescribed by the State Architect, in a conspicuous location within five feet of all public entrances to the building on the date of the inspection and the defendant kept it in place until the earlier of the following: 120 days after the date of the inspection, or the date when all of the construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp are corrected.
- The defendant has corrected, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report which are the basis of the claim.
- Requires a CASp to provide, within 30 days of the date when it is requested by a qualifying business, a copy of a report prepared pursuant to the provisions described in 4), above, to the business that requested it.
- Requires a CASp to file, within ten days of inspecting a business pursuant to the provisions of this bill, a notice with the State Architect for listing on the State Architect’s Internet Web site, indicating that the CASp has inspected the business, the name and address of the business, the date of the filing, the date of the inspection of the business, the name and license number of the CASp, and a description of the area or structure inspected by the CASp.
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other law, a defendant who claims the benefit of the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision shall disclose the date and findings of any CASp inspection to a plaintiff if relevant to a claim or defense in an action.
- Allows a defendant to assert the reduction of minimum statutory damages under this subdivision only once for each area or structure inspected by a CASp, unless the inspected area or structure has undergone modifications or alterations that affect the compliance with construction-related accessibility standards of those areas after the date of the last inspection, and the defendant obtains an additional CASp inspection within 30 days of final approval by the building department or certificate of occupancy, as appropriate, regarding the modification or alterations.
- Provides that if the defendant fails to correct, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp that are noted in the CASp report, the defendant shall not receive any reduction of minimum statutory damages (allowing a business that qualifies for reduced minimum statutory damages may receive them for violations not noted in the CASp report).
- Provides an exception to 9), above, when a building permit is required for the repairs which cannot reasonably be completed by the defendant within 120 days and the defendant is in the process of correcting the violations noted in the CASp report, as evidenced by having, at least, an active building permit necessary for the repairs to correct the violation that was noted, but not corrected, in the CASp report and all of the repairs are completed within 180 days of the date of the inspection.
- Requires the State Architect to do the following:
- Publish and regularly update, on its existing Internet Web site, an easily accessible list of small businesses that have filed a notice that they have obtained a CASp inspection.
- Develop a process by which businesses may notify the State Architect of an inspection by a certified access specialist indicating “CASp determination pending” or “Inspected by a CASp,” which shall include the date of the notification, the date of the inspection, and a description of the structure or area inspected.
- Develop a form for businesses to notify the public that the business has obtained a CASp inspection, which shall include the date of the notification, the date of the inspection, and a description of the structure or area inspected.
- Provides that the “area or structure inspected” by a CASp means either the interior of the premises, the exterior of the premises, or the interior and exterior of the premises.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to federal law, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Section 12182.)
- Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh), provides that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. A violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh. A violation of this section subjects a person to actual damages incurred by an injured party, treble actual damages but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. (Civil Code Section 51 et seq. All further statutory references are to the California Civil Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities and other public places. Further provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Section 54.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to public accommodations, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law, or state or federal regulation, and applicable alike to all persons. Further provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to all housing accommodations offered for rent or lease, subject to conditions and limitations established by law. (Section 54.1.)
- Provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Section 54.1. A violation of Section 54.1 subjects a person to injunctive and actual damages – plus treble actual damages but not less than $1,000, and attorney’s fees as the court deems proper. (Section 55.)
- Provides the California Commission on Disability Access, an independent state agency composed of 19 members, with general responsibility for monitoring disability access compliance in California, and with authority to make recommendations to the Legislature for necessary changes in order to facilitate implementation of state and federal laws on disability access. (Gov. Code Section 8299 et seq.)
- Requires an attorney, when serving a demand letter or a complaint on a defendant alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance, to provide a written advisory with each demand letter or complaint, as defined. The written advisory shall include information about the defendant’s rights and obligations, including the right of a qualified defendant to request a stay and an early evaluation conference regarding the allegations in the complaint. The written advisory is only required from any attorney, and not from a pro per plaintiff. (Section 55.3.)
- Requires an attorney alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance to state facts sufficient to allow the defendant to identify the basis for the claim. (Section 55.31.)
- Prohibits such a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money, unless the claim involves a physical injury or special damages. After receiving a duly-provided demand letter, a building owner, tenant, authorized agent or employee may request a settlement figure or specification of damages. Upon such a request, an attorney may present a settlement figure or specification of damages. (Section 55.31.)
- Requires, until January 1, 2019, an attorney to submit a copy of any demand letter to the Commission and the State Bar, and to submit a copy of a complaint to the Commission, and subjects the attorney to possible disciplinary action for violations of this requirement. (Section 55.32.)
- Requires the Commission to review and report on the demand letters and complaints it receives until January 1, 2016. Also requires the State Bar, commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, to report specified information to the Legislature regarding the demand letters that it receives. (Section 55.32)
- Provides that upon being served with a complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim, a defendant may move for a court stay and early evaluation conference if the defendant is: (A) Until January 1, 2018, a defendant whose site had new construction or improvement between January 1, 2008, and January 1, 2016 and was approved pursuant to the local building permit and inspection process; (B) a defendant whose site had new construction or improvement that was approved by a local public building department inspector who is a CASp; or (C) a defendant who is a small business, as described. The stay to the construction-related accessibility claim, as provided, may be for 90-days unless the plaintiff has obtained temporary injunctive relief. (Section 55.54.)
- Authorizes a defendant who does not qualify for an early evaluation conference pursuant to these provisions, or who forgoes those provisions, to request a mandatory evaluation conference, as specified, and authorizes a plaintiff to make that request if the defendant does not make that request. (Section 55.54.)
- Requires a local planning agency to employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a CASp a local building department to employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are CASps. (Section 55.53.)
- Provides that statutory damages may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion. Existing law specifies that a plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if he or she personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion or was deterred from accessing the public accommodation on a particular occasion. (Section 55.56.)
- Requires the court, in assessing liability in any action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, to consider the reasonableness of the plaintiff’s conduct in light of the plaintiff’s obligation, if any, to mitigate damages. (Section 55.56.)
- Reduces a defendant’s minimum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation to $1,000 for each unintentional offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of the claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint and other specified conditions apply, and reduces that minimum liability to $2,000 for each unintentional offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of the claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint and the defendant is a small business, as specified. (Section 55.56.)
- Requires the Department of General Services to make a biannual adjustment to financial criteria defining a small business for these purposes, and to post those adjusted amounts on its Internet Web site. (Section 55.56.)
- Requires a commercial property owner to state on a lease form or rental agreement executed on or after July 1, 2013, if the property being leased or rented has undergone inspection by a CASp. (Section 1938.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: As introduced last year, this bill would have established a controversial notice and right-to-cure procedure limited to construction-related accessibility standards that had changed within the previous three years. In addition, this bill sought to authorize a tax credit of up to $250 for business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. On April 21, 2015, the author agreed to amend the bill in this committee to eliminate the notice and right-to-cure procedure, but retain the tax credit. AB 54 was approved by this Committee and referred to the Revenue and Taxation Committee, where it subsequently was held as a two-year bill.
On January 4, 2016, the author made wholesale amendments to the bill to delete the tax credit provisions and replace the contents of the bill with substantially the same language contained in the enrolled version of SB 251 (Roth), which was vetoed by Governor Brown in October 2015. It should be noted that at the time of this analysis, the author of SB 251 has another bill, SB 269, in possession of this Committee that seeks to enact substantially similar language as his bill from last year. One notable exception is that SB 269, in response to concerns expressed by opponents and some Members of the Legislature about the size of the business that would be eligible for the 120-day protection from liability for minimum statutory violations provided in SB 251, reduced the size of such businesses from those which employ 100 of fewer employees to those which employee 50 or fewer employees. It should be noted that this bill retains the original 100 employee threshold.
Background on public accommodation laws in California under the ADA and the Unruh Act. Under the twenty-five year old federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a business that constitutes a place of public accommodation (e.g., many places of lodging, entertainment, recreation, restaurants, bars, theaters, stores, health clubs, etc.) is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce. Prohibited discrimination can take a number of forms – e.g., denial of participation in the facility, or a service, benefit, or good of the business; denial of equal participation in a good, service, or facility; or provision of a different or separate facility, service or good (unless necessary to provide services and are as effective as that provided to others). Government facilities are also covered by the access obligations of the ADA.
According to the California Supreme Court, “In 1992, shortly after passage of the ADA, the Legislature amended the state's disability protections ‘to strengthen California law in areas where it is weaker than the [ADA] and to retain California law when it provides more protection for individuals with disabilities than the [ADA].’ Two overlapping laws, the Unruh Civil Rights Act (§ 51) and the Disabled Persons Act (§§ 54–55.3), are the principal sources of state disability access protection.” (Jankey v. Lee (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1038, 1044 [Citation to internal quotation deleted].) As a result of incorporating the ADA into the state’s Unruh Civil Rights, a plaintiff who prevails in a construction-related accessibility claim, like all plaintiffs in other civil rights cases, is entitled to minimum statutory damages of $4,000 per violation (although later amendments to Unruh, affecting only disabled plaintiffs in only construction-related disability claims, reduced the minimum statutory damages to only $1,000 in some cases, such as when a small business previously obtained a CASp inspection).
Therefore, since 1992, public accommodations in California have been required to comply with not only the ADA, but also with the state’s Unruh Act, which incorporates the ADA into its provisions and makes a violation of the ADA punishable as a violation of Unruh. (Section 51.) All violations of Unruh are subject to statutory damages of at least $4,000 per violation, except some cases where the violation is based on a construction-related accessibility claim, in which case lower damages (a minimum of $1,000, or $2,000, depending on the circumstances of the case) apply.
Media coverage and objective data give different perspectives about the magnitude of the problem sought to be addressed by this bill. There has been widespread media coverage about the problem of what has been described as "serial ADA litigation." For example, in 2014, the Modesto Bee and the Merced Sun-Star reported a series of articles, describing “how the Americans with Disabilities Act has been misused to create profit centers for opportunistic lawyers. These attorneys recruit people – some with minor disabilities, some with criminal records, some here illegally – to visit small businesses in hopes of spotting the most minute ADA violations. The lawyers then demand $4,000 for each violation.”
It is certainly true that a handful of highly litigious plaintiffs have targeted small businesses, especially those without the financial resources and sophistication to challenge such lawsuits on their merits. According to data compiled by the California Commission on Disability Access, more than half (54 percent) of the construction-related accessibility complaints filed between 2012 and 2014 were filed by two law firms; and 46 percent of all complaints were filed by just 14 parties. These figures indicate that the vast majority of all construction-related accessibility claims filed in this state are initiated by a very small number of plaintiffs (and their attorneys). As a result, small businesses are justifiably fearful and angry about being sued, while disabled consumers are viewed with blame or suspicion, even though they have a right to full and equal access and should be able to expect all public accommodations to comply with the 25-year old requirements of the Americans with Disability Act. Disabled consumers just want to go about their daily lives without difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment, and with the basic dignity that comes from being able to go to the same places and have the same access to services as non-disabled persons. The vast majority would only resort to the extreme measure of filing a lawsuit in response to the most egregious, humiliating, and pervasive violations of their rights. It is unfair for business owners or policymakers to assume that disabled persons are somehow trying to “game the system” or take advantage of small businesses when they expect compliance with the ADA. Compliance should be something they can count on as they go about their daily lives.
But it is also important to put these figures into perspective. According to data compiled by the Commission, from January 2014 until January 2015, there were 3,468 demand letters and complaints sent or filed in the state. In contrast, according to the Judicial Council of California, a total of 800,091 lawsuits were filed in the state in 2013 (the most recent year available). Meanwhile, California has approximately 3.3 million small businesses. These figures mean that less than one percent of small businesses (and a far smaller percentage of all businesses) were sued in 2014 for access violations; and the 3,468 demand letters or complaints regarding accessibility violations represent less than one-half of one percent (0.43%) of the total number of lawsuits filed in the state. And the actual percentage is even smaller, because the Commission figure includes demand letters that are not complaints.
What can be done or should be done about (the small number of) plaintiffs and attorneys who file large numbers of Unruh Act-ADA lawsuits? The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals addressed this issue in Molski v. Evergreen Dynasty Corp. (9th Cir. 2007) 500 F.3d 1047. Molski, the plaintiff, was paralyzed from the chest down, needed a wheelchair to get around, and filed about 400 lawsuits in the federal courts within the districts in California. (Id. at p. 1051.) Upon motion of the defendant businesses (including the named defendant, a restaurant) the district court declared Molski a vexatious litigant and granted the defendants' request for a pre-filing order (requiring court approval before Molski could file additional lawsuits). (Ibid.) The Ninth Circuit acknowledged that “pre-filing orders are an extreme remedy that should rarely be used” and that courts “should not enter pre-filing orders with undue haste because such sanctions can tread on a litigant's due process right of access to the courts.” (Id. at p. 1057.) Nevertheless, the Ninth Circuit upheld the order, finding that it was within the district court’s power, “In light of the district court's finding that Molski did not suffer the injuries he claimed . . . to conclude that the large number of complaints filed by Molski containing false or exaggerated allegations of injury were vexatious” and the pre-filing requirement could be issued. (Id. at p. 1059.)
At the same time, there is no evidence that lawsuits filed by high-frequency litigants, such as Molski, are “frivolous.” The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines “frivolous” as “of little weight or importance,” or “having no sound basis (as in fact or law) <a frivolous lawsuit>.” In other words, a lawsuit alleging a violation of the Unruh Act because of a denial of access would only be “frivolous” if it had no basis in the law (i.e. it did not state an actual violation). In fact, there is no evidence that the complaints which are filed are without merit. According to data collected by the Commission, most complaints identify multiple access violations. For example, of the cases filed in July 2014, most complaints identified multiple or significant single violations, such as missing grab bars. Only two out of 201 complaints reviewed identified a single violation, such as a soap or seat cover dispenser being too high.
While the Molski case shows that existing law provides businesses with a way to deal with a vexatious litigant, the process is difficult. As the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals observed in Molski, obtaining a “pre-filing order” is an “extreme remedy that should rarely be used.” (Molski v. Evergreen Dynasty Corp., supra, at p. 1059.) This bill takes the approach that other tools are necessary to protect small businesses from high-frequency litigants and to encourage compliance with the 25 year-old state and federal laws. Therefore, the bill proposes a number of changes to the law that provide financial relief to businesses, and encourage businesses to obtain CASp inspection and comply with construction-related accessibility standards so that disabled consumers can exercise their rights to fully and equally access public accommodations in the state.
Rebuttable presumption that certain “technical violations” do not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of an award of minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim. This bill establishes a list of “technical violations” that are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of awarding the plaintiff minimum statutory damages, where all three of the following conditions precedent are satisfied: (1) the defendant is a small business, (2) the defendant has corrected, within 15 days of the service of a summons and complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim or receipt of a written notice, whichever is earlier, all of the technical violations that are the basis of the claim, and (3) the claim is based on one or more of the following violations:
- Interior signs, other than directional signs or signs that identify the location of accessible elements, facilities, or features, when all such elements, facilities or features are accessible.
- The lack of exterior signs, other than parking signs and, directional signs (including, signs that indicate the location of accessible pathways or entrance and exit doors when not all pathways, entrance and exit doors are accessible).
- The order in which parking signs are placed or the exact location or wording of parking signs, provided that the parking sign is clearly visible and indicates the location of accessible parking and van-accessible parking.
- The color of parking signs, provided that the color of the background contrasts with the color of the information on the sign.
- The color of parking lot striping, provided that it exists and provides sufficient contrast with the surface upon which it is applied to be reasonably visible.
- Faded, chipped, damaged or deteriorated paint in otherwise fully compliant parking spaces and passenger access aisles in parking lots, provided that it indicates the required dimensions of a parking space or access aisle in a manner that is reasonably visible.
- The presence or condition of detectable warning surfaces on ramps, except where the ramp is part of a pedestrian path of travel that intersects with a vehicular lane or other hazardous area.
The presumption affects the plaintiff’s burden of proof. This is appropriate because a “presumption affecting the burden of proof is a presumption established to implement some public policy other than to facilitate the determination of the particular action in which the presumption is applied.” (Evidence Code Section 605.) As a practical matter, the presumption means that the plaintiff will recover no minimum statutory damages for these specific violations. However, the presumption is rebuttable, rather than conclusive. This is also appropriate because some of these conditions could, in some circumstances, cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of awarding the plaintiff minimum statutory damages. Therefore, it is appropriate to allow a plaintiff to overcome the presumption with evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that he or she did, in fact, experience difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment on the particular occasion as a result of one or more of the technical violations listed above.
There are aspects of this provision that remain troubling to the Committee. First, it could be interpreted by some that these “technical violations” are not real violations of the ADA, when they clearly are. Second, this provision may provide a false sense of protection from liability to a business because even if a business met the conditions precedent and qualified for this presumption by correcting these violations within 15 days, the business could still be sued in federal court during that 15-day period. Third, this provision establishes a first precedent that a business is not liable for violations about which the business is notified and has an opportunity to cure. This Committee has consistently rejected such proposals.
Finally, this provision opens the door to the possibility that the Legislature may expand the list of “technical violations” in the future to the point that they are no longer technical and are substantial. However, this list of technical violations is carefully, deliberately, and narrowly crafted in an effort to focus on those violations of construction-related accessibility standards which are more about formal than substantive compliance with those standards and reportedly lead to “frivolous” complaints that are designed to extract quick settlements from business owners, rather than to improve access. Importantly, the bill does allow a plaintiff to prove that one or more of these “technical violations” did, in fact, cause difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of awarding the plaintiff minimum statutory damages. Because the bill provides greater specificity and guidance about specific types of minor violations that are considered “technical,” this provision appears to be sufficiently limited that it will help small businesses avoid paying minimum statutory damages to high-frequency litigants who sue them for truly trivial and inconsequential matters without violating the access rights of disabled consumers in an egregious and unacceptable manner.
Protection for businesses that employee 100 or fewer employees and obtain a CASp inspection against liability for violations of accessibility standards that occur in the 120 day period after the inspection. This bill protects a business from liability for minimum statutory damages for violations of construction-related accessibility standards during the 120 day period after the business obtains a CASp inspection of the interior, the exterior, or the entirety of the premises. The 120-day protection period only exists if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- The defendant is a business that has employed 100 or fewer employees on average over the past three years, or for the years it has been in existence if less than three years, as evidenced by wage report forms filed with the Economic Development Department.
- The structure or area of the alleged violation was the subject of an inspection report indicating “CASp determination pending” or “Inspected by a CASp.”
- The inspection predates the filing of the claim by, or receipt of a demand letter from, the plaintiff regarding the alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard, and the defendant was not on notice of the alleged violation prior to the CASp inspection.
- Within ten days of the date of the inspection, the CASp files a notice with the State Architect for listing on the State Architect’s Internet Web site, stating that the defendant has obtained a CASp inspection, the date of the filing, and the date of the inspection.
- The CASp posts a notice, in a form prescribed by the State Architect, in a conspicuous location within five feet of all public entrances to the building on the date of the inspection and the defendant kept it in place until the earlier of the following: 120 days after the date of the inspection, or the date when all of the construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp are corrected.
- The defendant has corrected, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp that are the basis of the claim.
This provision allows the business to identify and correct violations during that 120-day period. It does not preclude a lawsuit by a plaintiff who suffers actual damages (i.e. from an injury) on the premises of the business during the 120-day period. The provision would not impact such a plaintiff’s ability to recover those damages. Furthermore, it does not protect a business that does not correct violations on the premises during the 120-day period, providing that if the defendant fails to correct, within 120 days of the date of the inspection, all construction-related violations in the area or structure inspected by the CASp, the defendant shall not receive any reduction of minimum statutory damages. Also, a defendant is allowed to assert the reduction of minimum statutory damages set forth here only once for each area or structure inspected by a CASp.
There are aspects of this provision that also continue to be deeply troubling to the Committee. First, it is unprecedented for a civil rights law, including the Unruh Act, to excuse violations of the law for a specific period of time on the basis that a defendant is trying (but not succeeding) to comply with the law. Second, unlike virtually all other past “reforms” to state law regarding construction-related accessibility standards, this provision applies to relatively large businesses. Although all businesses that obtain a CASp inspection are entitled to reduced minimum statutory damages ($2,000 instead of $4,000), all of the other past reforms designed to reduce damages and provide early evaluation conferences apply to small businesses employing 25 or fewer employees. Also, this provision – like the one dealing with “technical” violations – may provide illusory relief to businesses. Even if a business met the conditions precedent and qualified for this 120-day amnesty period by correcting all violations noted in a CASp report within 120 days of the CASp inspection, the business could still be sued in federal court during that period.
Other miscellaneous changes to the law. In addition to the main provisions of the bill, discussed above, the bill also makes several minor but important changes. Among other things, the bill requires that information about complaints and demand letters, which under current law must be submitted by attorneys to the Commission, is provided in a “standard format specified by the [Commission]” so that data about accessibility claims can be more effectively compiled by the Commission and provided to the Legislature. The bill also requires the State Architect to publish and regularly update a list of businesses that have filed a notice with the State Architect stating that the business has obtained a CASp inspection and will correct any violations of accessibility standards within 120 days of the date of the inspection. In addition, the bill requires a CASp to note, on his or her inspection report, the date of the inspection.
Amendments recommended by the Committee. In light of the concerns expressed above, the Committee suggests the following amendments.
- Strike out Sections ONE, and THREE through TEN in their entirety from the bill.
- Add the version of Section 55.32 of the Civil Code, in effect until January 1, 2019 (enacted by Senate Bill 1186 of the 2011–12 Regular Session of the Legislature and to become inoperative under conditions prescribed by Stats. 2008, Ch. 549, Sec. 12, subd. (b)) and incorporate language requiring that information about complaints and demand letters, which under current law must be submitted by attorneys to the Commission, is provided in a “standard format specified by the [Commission],” as follows:
55.32
(a) An attorney who provides a demand letter, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do all of the following:
(1) Include the attorney’s State Bar license number in the demand letter.
(2) Contemporaneously with providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to the State Bar of California by facsimile transmission at 1-415-538-2171, or by mail to 180 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105, Attention: Professional Competence.
(3) Within five business days of providing the demand letter, send a copy of the demand letter to letter, and submit information about the demand letter in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access. Access, to the commission.
(b) An attorney who sends or serves a complaint, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 55.3, shall do both of the following:
(1) Send a copy of the complaint to and submit information about the complaint in a standard format specified by the California Commission on Disability Access to the commission within five business days of sending or serving the complaint.
[Remainder of this section would have no additional changes]
Related pending legislation. AB 52 (Gray) provides, among other things, that the defendant’s maximum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is $1,000 for each offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations within 180 days of being served with the complaint. This bill is currently in this Committee as a two-year bill.
AB 1468 (Baker) seeks to provide, among other things, that a public entity’s possession of a close out letter from the State Architect certifying that the buildings, facilities, and other places meet the applicable construction-related accessibility standards of the ADA, serves as presumptive evidence of compliance with the ADA. This bill is currently in this Committee as a two-year bill.
SB 67 (Galgiani) seeks to exempt small businesses from statutory damage liability in connection with a construction-related accessibility claim and to extend the period for correcting construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim from 60 days to 120 days of being served with the complaint, for purposes of reducing a defendant’s minimum statutory damage liability to $1,000. This bill is currently in Senate Judiciary as a two-year bill.
SB 269 (Roth) is substantially similar to SB 251 (Roth) of 2015 (see below), with the notable exception that it does not contain tax incentives for eligible access expenditures by businesses. This bill is currently in this Committee.
Related previous legislation. AB 1230 (Gomez), Chapter 787, Statutes of 2015, establishes the California Americans With Disabilities Act Small Business Capital Access Loan Program within the California Capital Access Loan Program in order to create a self-sustaining program to provide loans to assist small businesses in financing the costs of projects that alter or retrofit existing small business facilities according to certain criteria, to comply with the ADA.
AB 1342 (Steinorth) would have provided additional revenue to the California Commission on Disability Access. In addition, the bill would have required a commercial property owner to state on every lease form or rental agreement executed after July 1, 2016, whether or not the property being leased has undergone inspection by a CASp, and would have required a commercial property owner to provide additional information to the tenant or lessor about the condition of the rented or leased property. AB 1342 was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1521 (Assembly Committee on the Judiciary), Chapter 755, Statutes of 2015, establishes new pre-filing procedures for "high-frequency litigants" and provides new tools for businesses to use when they are served with complaints alleging violations of construction-related accessibility claims.
SB 251 (Roth), among other things, would have established a list of "technical violations" that are presumed to not cause a person difficulty, discomfort or embarrassment for the purpose of awarding the plaintiff minimum statutory damages, where certain conditions are satisfied. This would have protected a business from liability for minimum statutory damages for violations of construction-related accessibility standards during the 120 day period after the business obtains a CASp inspection of the interior, the exterior, or the entirety of the premises, provided that all violations were corrected within the 120 period and other conditions were satisfied. The bill also would have provided a tax credit for eligible expenditures to increase accessibility. SB 251 was vetoed by the Governor.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters of the bill contend that the notice and right-to-cure provisions of the bill will help to address abusive lawsuits against businesses. For example, the California Grocers Association states in support:
Significant lawsuit abuse exists with regard to compliance with requirements of the ADA. California grocers are committed to accessibility for all customers, including those with physical disabilities. However, we have unfortunately seen opportunistic attorneys file abusive litigation with profit motive rather than public benefit in mind. We support AB 54 as a means to begin to address this abuse and help well-intentioned businesses reach and maintain compliance.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In addition to the arguments in opposition described previously, opponents of the bill contend that the bill goes too far in extending protection from damages to virtually all businesses in California. Disability Rights California states:
Current state access laws define "small business" as a business with 25 employees or less. AB 54 goes too far because it extends protections and limits liability for civil rights damages to any business with up to 100 employees. The U.S. Census data reports that 98% of California businesses have up to 100 employees [citing data that only 17,716 (2%) of 701,899 businesses in California have more than 100 employees.] This extension is too expansive and should be stricken from the bill. A business with 100 employees is not small. They have resources to identify and correct access violations and when they do not do so, they should be responsible for civil rights damages. Any protections from civil rights damages in the context of access laws should apply to small businesses of 25 or fewer employees.
The ACLU also argues that the immunity provisions of this bill will not promote compliance, and may in fact promote a false hope that access lawsuits will be prevented. They state:
[The bill's] offer of immunity will be highly misleading to the businesses that obtain a CASp inspection because it will not prevent lawsuits—including liability for attorney's fees and equitable relief—brought under the federal ADA, which of course the state is powerless to affect. We would do California businesses a serious disservice and only cause greater frustration and cynicism if we were to mislead them into believing they cannot be sued for access violations when in fact they can be.
Businesses already have strong incentives to obtain a CASp inspection, including statutory penalties that are reduced by 75 percent compared to other violators, an automatic stay of any lawsuit, and special court oversight to protect against improper allegations and promote quick resolution of the dispute. The effect of these protections is already sufficient to largely prevent CASp-inspected businesses from being sued. It is not necessary or helpful in preventing baseless litigation to increase the value of a CASp inspection by giving businesses immunity from statutory damages.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Grocers Association (CGA)
California Small Business Association
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)
California Foundation for Independent Living Centers (CFILC)
Disability Rights California
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees and Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
AB 54
Page 4
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Philip Ting, Chair
AB 54 (
Olsen) – As Amended April 22, 2015
Majority vote. Fiscal committee. Tax levy.
SUBJECT: Public accommodations: construction-related accessibility standards: tax credit.
SUMMARY: Modifies the Disability Access for Eligible Small Business Credit (Disabled Access Credit) to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a certified access specialist (CAS). Specifically, this bill:
Modifies, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2016, under the Personal Income Tax (PIT) and Corporations Tax (CT) Law, the Disability Access credit to include the amount paid or incurred for a site to be inspected by a CAS.
Defines the terms “CAS,” “inspected by a CAS,” and “site” as having the same meaning as provided for by Civil Code Section 55.52.
Makes findings and declarations.
Takes effect immediately as a tax levy.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
Allows a credit to eligible small businesses related to costs paid or incurred for complying with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). An eligible small business means an electing taxpayer with either gross receipts for the preceding taxable year of $1 million or less, or not more than 30 full-time employees during the preceding taxable year. The credit is computed as 50% of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year in excess of $250 but not more than $10,250.
Provides that eligible access expenditures must be made to enable the qualified small business to comply with the ADA requirements, including costs to remove the architectural, communication, physical, or transportation barriers of persons with disabilities. Costs also include qualified interpreters or equipment to make materials available to person with hearing impairments, costs of qualified readers or equipment to make material available to persons with visual impairments, and costs to acquire or modify equipment for persons with disabilities.
Provides that the tax credit may be used against the net tax of the taxpayer and the excess, while not refundable, is available for carryback to the immediately preceding tax year and may be carried forward to the following 20 taxable years or until exhausted. Taxpayers may not increase the adjusted basis of property or claim any deduction for eligible access expenditures that qualify for the credit.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
Allows, in modified conformity to federal law, a tax credit for the amount paid or incurred by eligible small business for the improvements to the property in order to provide access to disabled individuals of up to 50% of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year, but not to exceed $250. The maximum allowed to a small business is $125.
Defines a “CAS” as a person that has met the certification requirements as provided for by the State Architect.
FISCAL EFFECT: The Franchise Tax Board (FTB) estimate General Fund revenue loss of $1,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2015-16, $4,000 in FY 2016-17, and $4,000 in FY 2017-18.
COMMENTS:
Arguments in Support: According to the California Chamber of Commerce, “small businesses have, unfortunately, been targeted by a limited group of attorneys to leverage extortion-type settlements for technical construction-related standards, which do not actually impeded physical access to the facility for disabled patrons. For example, the California Commission on Disability Access has a top 10 list of construction-related accessibility claims set forth in demand letters or complaints, which includes alleged violations for failure to have the appropriate signage or symbol. Such violations do not necessarily impede physical access to the facility and could easily be resolved. However, businesses are pressured into paying settlements for these lawsuits instead of focusing their financial resources on improving access at their place of business.”
Tax Expenditure vs. Direct Expenditure: Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as “expenditures” since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues). Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan has stated that tax expenditures are “misclassified” because they are identical to outlays. Additionally, Gregory Mankiw, who led President George W. Bush’s Council of Economic Advisers, calls expenditures “stealth spending implemented through the tax code.”1
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures once they are put in place. While this affords taxpayers greater financial predictability, it can also result in tax expenditures remaining a part of the tax code without demonstrating any public benefit. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date, effectively resulting in a “one-way ratchet” whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by a majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their cost or efficacy, without a supermajority vote. This bill creates an appropriation of funds, in the form of a tax credit, as a way of encouraging individuals to move forward with a site inspection.
Certified Access Specialist Program (CASP): The CASP was created by SB 262 (Kuehl), Chapter 872, Statutes of 2003, and is designed to meet the public’s need for experienced, trained, and tested individuals who can inspect buildings and sites for compliance with applicable state and federal construction accessibility standards. Federal and state disability laws are considered to be complicated and the CASP helps businesses become aware of potential violations. After reaching out to several certified specialists, it was found that a site inspection can cost anywhere between $500 and $3,000, depending on the workload. Some inspections are conducted early in the designs and construction process but others are conducted post-construction because of litigation or fear of litigation.
Encouraging Compliance: It is unclear to Committee staff if a nominal amount of $125 will have the desired effect of encouraging compliance with federal and state disability laws. As noted above, inspections can cost upwards of $3,000, and several certified specialists cited $1,500 as the average cost for an inspection. The $125 tax credit would be less than 10% of the average cost of inspecting a facility. Additionally, individuals may not be aware that a credit exists. According to the FTB, in 2012 taxpayers claimed a total of $40,000 in Disability Access Credits. If awareness is an issue, taxpayers may be less likely to be influenced by a tax credit, irrespective of the amount. Finally, according to several specialists, conducting a site inspection does not always lead to greater compliance. The cost may be too expensive for the owner to comply with recommendations, even though the modifications could qualify the taxpayer for a maximum federal Disability Access Credit of $5,125. As a result, accessibility is not always improved. If anything, having the site inspected by a CAS may serve only to put the owner on notice that the property fails to meet disability access standards.
Ignorance of the Law Excuses No One: When opening a business, an individual must become knowledgeable of extremely complicated areas of the law: environmental, employment, privacy, worker safety, health, intellectual property, advertising, and tax law to name a few. Despite the broad range of local, state, and federal laws effecting business owners, the legal system is based on the principle that ignorance of the law excuses no one. If ignorance was an excuse, individuals charged with criminal offenses or subject to civil suits could escape liability by claiming ignorance. The principal also holds that a person engaged in an activity outside what is common must make themselves aware of the law that is necessary to engage in that activity. Furthermore, the government does not, in general, subsidize a business owner’s education of relevant laws. The government does not pay for a tax attorney to advise a business owner on how to properly structure his/her company, nor does the government pay for a certified public account to certify that a business owner’s financial statements comply with generally accepted accounting principles. As such, the Committee may wish to consider whether it is appropriate to subsidize the education of relevant disability access laws, especially since it may not actually lead to greater disability access.
Double Referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, which passed this bill on April 21, 0215, with a vote of 10-0. For additional discussion of this bill, please refer to the analysis prepared by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Auburn Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association California
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chamber of Commerce Alliance Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Chamber of Commerce Mountain View
Chamber of the Santa Barbara Region
Civil Justice Association of California
Fairfield-Suisun City Chamber of Commerce
Fullerton Chamber of Commerce
Goleta Chamber of Commerce
Greater Fresno Area Chamber of Commerce
Half Moon Bay Coastside Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers
Lake Tahoe South Shore Chamber of Commerce
Lodi Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP – Commercial Real Estate Development Association
North Lake Tahoe Chamber of Commerce
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce & Visitors Bureau
San Diego County Apartment Association
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
1 Ezra Klein, Wonkbook: Tax Spending vs. Government Spending, Washington Post, 2012.
AB 54
Page 15
Date of Hearing: April 21, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
AB 54
(Olsen) – As Amended March 16, 2015
SUBJECT:
PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS: CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY CLAIMS
KEY ISSUES:
SHOULD A PERSON WHO IS DENIED FULL AND EQUAL ACCESS TO A PLACE OF PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION IN VIOLATION OF THE UNRUH CIVIL RIGHTS ACT BECAUSE OF A CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY STANDARD WHICH HAS CHANGED IN THE PAST THREE YEARS BE REQUIRED TO COMPLETE A PROCEDURAL HURDLE BEFORE FILING A LAWSUIT --NOTIFYING THE OWNER, AGENT, OR OTHER PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PREMISES ABOUT THE VIOLATION -- THAT NO OTHER VICTIM OF DISCRIMINATION IN VIOLATION OF THE UNRUH CIVIL RIGHTS ACT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLETE?
SHOULD A PERSON WHO IS DENIED FULL AND EQUAL ACCESS TO A PLACE OF PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION BASED UPON A VIOLATION OF A CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY STANDARD WHICH HAS CHANGED IN THE PAST THREE YEARS BE PRECLUDED FROM BRINGING A COMPLAINT AGAINST THE OWNER OR OPERATOR OF THE PLACE OF PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION BASED UPON THE VIOLATION IF THE OWNER CORRECTS THE VIOLATION WITHIN 60 DAYS OF NOTICE ABOUT THE VIOLATION?
DOES THIS MEASURE, IN ITS EFFORT TO PROVIDE RELIEF TO SMALLER BUSINESSES THAT FEEL THEY ARE UNFAIRLY SUBJECT TO LAWSUITS UNDER OUR DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION LAWS, INADVERTENTLY AND UNFAIRLY SINGLE OUT PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES BY FORCING THEM TO OVERCOME ADDITIONAL AND SUBSTANTIAL NEW BARRIERS TO THE ENFORCEMENT OF THEIR CIVIL RIGHTS AND BY DENYING REMEDIES TO VICTIMS OF DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION?
SHOULD A BUSINESS OWNER WHO SPENDS MONEY TO BRING A PLACE OF PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION INTO COMPLIANCE WITH CONSTRUCTION-RELATED ACCESSIBILITY STANDARDS BE GRANTED A TAX CREDIT FOR UP TO 50 PERCENT OF THE EXPENDED FUNDS, NOT TO EXCEED 250 DOLLARS?
SYNOPSIS
There are two main provisions of this bill. One enacts a notice and right to cure procedure similar to ones that have been repeatedly rejected by the Legislature in recent years: prior to filing a lawsuit alleging a construction-related accessibility claim based upon a denial of access to a place of public accommodation, the plaintiff must somehow notify some person who is responsible for the premises and give the owner of the facility an opportunity to correct the violation within the next 60 days. The distinguishing feature about this bill’s version of notice and right to cure is the fact that it is limited to those construction-related accessibility standards which have changed within the past three years. This aspect of the bill is not only controversial and the reason why the bill is opposed by groups which advocate for the rights of the disabled, who argue that it imposes an onerous requirement on the victims of just one form of discrimination, but it also presents a number of logistical problems. This provision requires a disabled plaintiff to know which construction-related accessibility standard caused the denial of their access to the public accommodation and whether it has changed within the past three years; if so, to identify the owner of the public accommodation which has discriminated against them; provide written notice of their allegation that they were denied access, with “facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim;” wait at least 60 days after providing this written notice to verify whether the violation has been remedied; and if so, they are prohibited from either filing a complaint, collecting damages, or being reimbursed for legal fees. Likewise, if notice is not provided or is inadequate, the disabled person has no legal remedy, even if the public accommodation is in clear violation of Unruh.
The other main provision is a tax credit for the owner of a business that is a public accommodation who spends money to hire a certified access specialist to advise the owner about how to bring the business into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. It is similar to, and really an expansion of, an existing tax credit which allows the owner of a business that is a public accommodation to claim a tax credit of up to half of the expended funds, not to exceed 250 dollars, for the construction costs of bringing the facility into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards. This provision is non-controversial and is likely supported by both the business groups that are in support of the bill, as well as the groups advocating for the rights of the disabled, that oppose it.
According to the author, the bill is necessary because many small businesses are out of compliance with longstanding state and federal disability access laws, leaving them vulnerable to lawsuits. Some of these suits, the author and supporters allege, are brought by plaintiffs for personal financial benefit, not out of an altruistic desire to improve disability access for disabled consumers, and some of these suits are brought against businesses that are willing to comply but are hampered by the complexity of the law. Disability rights advocates oppose the bill, but they agree with the supporters on a number of points, including that many businesses are not in compliance with access laws despite their long duration and that many lawsuits are filed, some by plaintiffs seeking monetary recovery. Opponents argue that they have supported prior legislation to increase business awareness of access obligations, improve voluntary compliance, and reward responsible behavior and those reforms should be furthered, not circumvented. Opponents argue that this bill singles out people with disabilities for unprecedented obstacles to the enforcement of civil rights, deprives them of a remedy for actual violations, and will deter, not encourage, compliance with disability discrimination law. Moreover, opponents state that the promise of the bill may be misleadingly unattainable because the requirements it would impose are inconsistent with federal disability discrimination law and therefore would not preclude the law suits from which businesses seek protection.
Unlike two prior measures, SB 1608 (Corbett and Harman) of 2008 and SB 1186 (Steinberg and Dutton) of 2012, historic bipartisan and bicameral measures to reduce disability access violations and unnecessary lawsuits, this bill is not the result of open stakeholder meetings and mutual compromise. Rather, it reflects no input from disabled advocates or amendments as a result of its harsh impact on disabled citizens and their rights. This bill is supported by business groups, including the California Chamber of Commerce and the Civil Justice Association of California, and opposed by disability rights advocates, including Disability Rights California and the American Civil Liberties Union of California.
SUMMARY:
Provides that statutory damages recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation resulting in a denial of full and equal access to the place of public accommodation that is based upon a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard which has changed within the past three years can only be recovered by that plaintiff under certain conditions and allows business owners who spend money to bring a place of public accommodation into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards a tax credit of up to 250 dollars. Specifically, this bill:
Requires that at least 60 days prior to bringing a claim for damages based upon a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard which has changed within the past three years, the plaintiff must provide a written notice regarding the violation to the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred.
Requires that the written notice of the violation must do one of the following:
State facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related disability claim and state that the recipient of the notice may be civilly liable for actual and statutory damages for a violation of a construction-related accessibility requirement if the access barriers that constitute the basis of the construction related accessibility claim are not removed within 60 days;
Offer, in a written demand letter, pre-litigation settlement negotiations in accordance with Section 55.31.
Prevents any claim for damages based upon the denial of the plaintiff’s access to the place of public accommodation if the barriers that are alleged to have prevented the plaintiff’s access to the accommodation and which are described in a written notice meeting the above criteria, are removed within 60 days of the date when the written notice is provided to the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred.
Allows a business owner who hires a certified access specialist (CASp) to advise the owner about how to provide access to disabled customers and come into compliance with construction-related accessibility standards to claim a tax credit for up to half of the expended funds paid to the CASp, not to exceed two hundred and fifty dollars ($250).
EXISTING LAW:
Pursuant to federal law, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12182.)
Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh), provides that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. A violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh. A violation of this section subjects a person to actual damages incurred by an injured party, treble actual damages but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. (Civil Code Section 51 et seq. All further statutory references are to the California Civil Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
Provides that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities and other public places. It also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Section 54.)
Provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to public accommodations, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law, or state or federal regulation, and applicable alike to all persons. It further provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to all housing accommodations offered for rent or lease, subject to conditions and limitations established by law. (Section 54.1.)
Provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Section 54.1. A violation of Section 54.1 subjects a person to injunctive and actual damages – plus treble actual damages but not less than $1,000, and attorney’s fees as the court deems proper. (Section 55.)
Provides the California Commission on Disability Access (Commission), an independent state agency composed of 19 members, with general responsibility for monitoring disability access compliance in California, and with authority to make recommendations to the Legislature for necessary changes in order to facilitate implementation of state and federal laws on disability access. (Gov. Code Sec. 8299 et seq.)
Requires an attorney, when serving a demand letter or a complaint on a defendant alleging a construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance, to provide a written advisory with each demand letter or complaint, as defined. The written advisory shall include information about the defendant’s rights and obligations, including the right of a qualified defendant to request a stay and an early evaluation conference regarding the allegations in the complaint. The written advisory is only required from any attorney, and not from a pro per plaintiff. (Section 55.3.)
Requires an attorney alleging the construction-related accessibility claim or noncompliance to state facts sufficient to allow the defendant to identify the basis for the claim. (Section 55.31.)
Prohibits such a demand letter from including a request or demand for money or an offer or agreement to accept money unless the claim involves a physical injury and special damages. After receiving a duly-provided demand letter, a building owner, tenant, authorized agent or employee may request a settlement figure or specification of damages. Upon such a request, an attorney may present a settlement figure or specification of damages. (Section 55.31.)
Requires, until January 1, 2016, an attorney to submit a copy of the complaint to the Commission and subjects the attorney to disciplinary action for violation. (Section 55.31.)
Requires the Commission to review and report on the demand letters and complaints it receives until January 1, 2016. Also requires the State Bar, commencing July 31, 2013, and annually each July 31 thereafter, to report specified information to the Legislature regarding the demand letters that it receives. (Section 55.31)
Requires an attorney to include his or her State Bar license number in such a demand letter, and to submit copies of the demand letter to the Commission and, until January 1, 2016, to the State Bar. (Section 55.32.)
Provides that upon being served with a complaint asserting a construction-related accessibility claim, a defendant may move for a court stay and early evaluation conference if the defendant is any of the following: (A) Until January 1, 2018, a defendant whose site had new construction or improvement between January 1, 2008, and January 1, 2016 and was approved pursuant to the local building permit and inspection process; (B) a defendant whose site had new construction or improvement that was approved by a local public building department inspector who is a CASp; or (C) a defendant who is a small business, as described. The stay to the construction-related accessibility claim, as provided, may be provided for 90-days unless the plaintiff has obtained temporary injunctive relief. (Section 55.54.)
Authorizes a defendant who does not qualify for an early evaluation conference pursuant to these provisions, or who forgoes those provisions, to request a mandatory evaluation conference, as specified, and authorizes a plaintiff to make that request if the defendant does not make that request. (Section 55.54.)
Requires a local agency, commencing on July 1, 2010, to employ or retain at least one building inspector who is a CASp. Commencing on January 1, 2014, a local agency shall employ or retain a sufficient number of building inspectors who are CASp. (Section 55.53.)
Provides that statutory damages may be recovered in a construction-related accessibility claim only if a violation or violations of one or more construction-related accessibility standards denied the plaintiff full and equal access to the place of public accommodation on a particular occasion. Existing law specifies that a plaintiff is denied full and equal access only if he or she personally encountered the violation on a particular occasion or was deterred from accessing the public accommodation on a particular occasion. (Section 55.56.)
Requires the court, in assessing liability in any action alleging multiple claims for the same construction-related accessibility violation on different particular occasions, to consider the reasonableness of the plaintiff’s conduct in light of the plaintiff’s obligation, if any, to mitigate damages. (Section Sec. 55.56.)
Reduces a defendant’s minimum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation to $1,000 for each unintentional offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of the claim within 60 days of being served with the complaint and other specified conditions apply, and would reduce that minimum liability to $2,000 for each unintentional offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations that are the basis of the claim within 30 days of being served with the complaint and the defendant is a small business, as specified. (Section 55.56.)
Requires the Department of General Services to make a biannual adjustment to financial criteria defining a small business for these purposes, and to post those adjusted amounts on its Internet Web site. (Section 55.56.)
Requires a commercial property owner to state on a lease form or rental agreement executed on or after July 1, 2013, if the property being leased or rented has undergone inspection by a certified access specialist. (Section 1938.)
Allows a tax credit for the amount paid or incurred by the owner of a public accommodation for improvements to the property in order to provide access to disabled individuals of up to 50 percent of the eligible access expenditures for the taxable year, but not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars ($250). (Revenue & Taxation Code Section 23642.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
The author describes the purpose of this bill as follows:
The spirit of the ADA is being violated each and every time we allow small businesses to serve as an ATM for abusive attorneys and plaintiffs. We need to curb lawsuit abuses that wreak havoc on communities across California and harm small business owners, employees, and consumers alike.
AB 54 will help small businesses stay open and employ people by providing them with a 60-day window to fix an alleged violation of a construction-related accessibility standard, if the standard related to the alleged violation has changed within three years.
Recent and objective evidence gives perspective about the magnitude of this problem. California has approximately 3.3 million small businesses. According to data compiled by the Commission, from January 2014 until January 2015, 3,468 demand letters and complaints were filed in the state. This means that less than one percent of small businesses (and a far smaller percentage of all businesses) were sued in 2014 for violations of construction-related accessibility standards.
Nevertheless, some of the information reported to the Commission is alarming in terms of the number and frequency of construction-related accessibility lawsuits being filed by a small number of law firms in California. According to the Commission, between September 2012 and October 2014, 5,392 complaints (including demand letters) were filed (in both state and federal courts). More than half (54%) of the complaints were filed by just two law firms. Forty-six percent of all complaints were filed by just 14 parties.
However, data from the Commission shows that more attorneys are choosing to file lawsuits in federal court, perhaps to avoid complying with California-specific requirements, such as sending demand letters to the Commission and the State Bar. Interestingly, the Commission reports that the state’s total share of complaints and demand letters has gone down. Between September 2012 and December 2013, state complaints/demand letters represented 68% of all the complaints/demand letters that the Commission received. However, between January 2014 and October 2014, state complaints/demand letters represented only 46% of all complaints/demand letters that the Commission received. In other words, more complaints are now being filed in federal court than in state court, which undermines the author’s argument that plaintiffs are solely choosing to file lawsuits in state court in order to obtain damages.
What can be done or should be done about (the small number of) attorneys who file large numbers of Unruh Act-ADA lawsuits? The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals addressed this issue in Molski v. Evergreen Dynasty Corp. (9th Cir. 2008) 521 F.3d 1215. The plaintiff, Molski, was paralyzed from the chest down, needed a wheelchair to get around, and filed about 400 lawsuits in the federal courts within the districts in California. (Id. at p. 1051.) Upon motion of the defendant businesses (including the named defendant, a restaurant) the district court declared Molski a vexatious litigant and granted the defendants' request for a pre-filing order (requiring court approval before Molski could file additional lawsuits). (Ibid.) The Ninth Circuit acknowledged that “pre-filing orders are an extreme remedy that should rarely be used” and that courts “should not enter pre-filing orders with undue haste because such sanctions can tread on a litigant's due process right of access to the courts.” (Id. at p. 1057.) Nevertheless, the Ninth Circuit upheld the order, finding that it was within the district court’s power, “In light of the district court's finding that Molski did not suffer the injuries he claimed . . . to conclude that the large number of complaints filed by Molski containing false or exaggerated allegations of injury were vexatious” and the pre-filing requirement could be issued. (Id. at p. 1059.)
Also, there is no evidence that these lawsuits are “frivolous.” The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines “frivolous” as “of little weight or importance,” or “having no sound basis (as in fact or law) <a frivolous lawsuit>.” In other words, a lawsuit alleging a violation of the Unruh Act because of a denial of access would only be “frivolous” if it had no basis in the law (i.e. it did not state an actual violation). In fact, there is no evidence that the complaints which are filed are without merit. According to data collected by the Commission, most complaints identify multiple access violations. For example, of the cases filed in July 2014, most complaints identified multiple or significant single violations, such as missing grab bars. Only two out of 201 complaints identified a single violation, such as a soap or seat cover dispenser being too high.
Should state law single out one minority group for special barriers to enforcement of civil rights protections? Under the federal ADA, a business that constitutes a place of public accommodation (e.g., many places of lodging, entertainment, recreation, restaurants, bars, theaters, stores, health clubs, etc.) is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce. Prohibited discrimination can take a number of forms – e.g., denial of participation in the facility, or a service, benefit, or good of the business; denial of equal participation in a good, service, or facility; or provision of a different or separate facility, service or good (unless necessary to provide services and the like that are as effective as that provided to others). Government facilities are also covered by the access obligations of the ADA.
Public accommodations in California are required to comply with not only the ADA, but also with the state’s Unruh Act, which incorporates the ADA into its provisions and makes a violation of the ADA punishable as a violation of Unruh. (Section 51.) All violations of Unruh are subject to statutory damages of at least four thousand dollars per violation, except some cases where the violation is based on a construction-related accessibility claim, in which case lower damages (a minimum of one thousand or two thousand dollars, depending on the circumstances of the case) apply.
Persons with disabilities are just one of the many groups protected from discrimination in the use and enjoyment of public facilities and accommodations. Under the state's Unruh Civil Rights Act, other protected characteristics include race, national origin, sex and sexual orientation. In recent years, Unruh has been amended in a manner which has affected only the rights and remedies of disabled citizens under the Act. Depending on one’s perspective, these amendments are either modest and necessary reforms, or changes that singled out and significantly undermined civil rights. Regardless of one’s perspective, however, it is undeniable that current law already imposes a number of special limits and barriers on the legal remedies available to the disabled who are denied access to public accommodations for violations of construction-related accessibility standards. For example, statutory damages are already significantly lower for some violations of Unruh that are based upon denial of access to the disabled (as low as one thousand dollars ($1,000) in some cases) than for any other types of Unruh violations. Attorneys for plaintiffs who are denied access to public accommodations on the basis of construction-related accessibility claims are required to send copies of their complaints to the State Bar and to the Commission, but are not required to do so for clients who are denied access for any other reason.
This bill would impose new obstacles on the disabled, requiring them to know which construction-related accessibility standard caused the denial of their access to the public accommodation and whether it has changed within the past three years; if so, to identify the owner of the public accommodation which has discriminated against them; provide written notice of their allegation that they were denied access, with “facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim’; wait at least 60 days after providing this written notice to verify whether the violation has been remedied; and if so, they are prohibited from either filing a complaint, collecting damages, or being reimbursed for legal fees. Likewise, if notice is not provided or is inadequate, the disabled person has no legal remedy, even if the public accommodation is in clear violation of Unruh.
These proposals significantly alter the Unruh Act, which is designed to ensure access to public accommodations for all persons in the state and provide special protections and remedies to those who are particularly vulnerable to discrimination because of “sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, marital status, or sexual orientation.” (Section 51 (b).) The Committee should be wary of any proposed law that limits access to the courts, especially for vulnerable minority groups. “Because the right to access the courts implicates due process and First Amendment rights, courts have been exceedingly reluctant to restrict such access” (Moy v. United States (9th Cir. 1990) 906 F.2d 467, 470.), especially one which appears on its face to discriminate against a class of citizens who are entitled by state and federal law to special protections.
Notification requirement. The bill requires, in “a construction-related accessibility claim alleging a violation of a construction-related accessibility standard within three years of a change in that standard,” the disabled person who has been denied access to a public accommodation to provide “the owner, agent, or other party responsible for the place of public accommodation where the alleged violation occurred with sufficient written notice of the allegations and alleged access barriers on which the claim is based at least 60 days prior to the filing of any action[.]” In addition, the notice must state “facts sufficient to allow a reasonable person to identify the basis of the construction-related accessibility claim under subdivision (a) of Section 55.31.” This notice is obviously crucial because a disabled person is prohibited from either filing a complaint, or collecting damages if he or she fails to satisfy the pre-filing notice requirement.
There are many logistical and procedural questions about these notification requirements, any of which could lead, if not satisfied, to a disabled consumer being deprived of legal redress for discrimination, including but not limited to, the following:
How would the disabled person know what the construction-related accessibility standard is which has prevented or obstructed his or her access to the public accommodation? The disabled person knows that he or she has been denied access, but may not know anything about the specific standard which caused the denial of access.
Assuming the disabled person could identify the construction-related accessibility standard which caused the denial of access, how would the disabled person know whether that particular standard has changed within the past three years? The plaintiff should not have to be an expert on state building standards, or federal ADA law in order to file (or have the right to file) a complaint.
How would the disabled person know the identity and location of the business owner, landlord or other violator when the disabled person has been denied access to the facility? He or she may not have any information beyond the name of the business and the address of the facility.
It is unlikely that a person who is not represented by an attorney would be able to satisfy these notice requirements given the specific requirements of the bill. Since the information contained in the notice must apparently be specific to each and every violation, this obligation would likely result in most claimants needing the assistance of an attorney. However, the need for an attorney would be frustrated by the prospect that attorney's fees would not be awarded, even if the plaintiff's claims were meritorious. That is because the bill provides that if a disabled person finds the right person to assist him or her, crafts exactly the right notice, and accomplishes the required delivery to the right person by the prescribed method, the victim would nevertheless be prohibited from any recovery, including recovery for attorney’s fees for a genuine act of discrimination if the cause of the problem were later rectified. The defendant would not be required to compensate the plaintiff for the denial of his or her rights, only to address the problem in the future.
It is highly unusual for a violation of any law to be overlooked or forgiven because the victim has not given notice in advance. It is even more unusual for a violator to avoid any legal responsibility for the violation simply by correcting the problem in response to the violation. The general principle of our civil (and criminal) laws is that everyone is held accountable for the wrongs they have committed, even if they are not warned in advance and even if they comply with the law in the future. The Committee is unaware of any comparable provision in civil rights law.
This bill would remove all incentive for a business to comply with construction-related accessibility standards until and unless they are sued. Apart from the question of precedent, it may be asked whether this bill promotes voluntary compliance and prevents violations, as should be the goal of any law, or whether it might instead inadvertently encourage and reward noncompliance by allowing a business to avoid taking any steps to follow the law -- unless and until a notice is provided, at which point it can avoid responsibility for the legal wrongs and injuries it has caused.
At the same time, businesses could potentially be misled about their exposure to liability under the federal ADA. This bill might immunize many ADA violations as a matter of state law. But the ADA itself imposes none of the requirements of this bill. Of course, state legislation cannot affect liability under federal law, and acts that violate the ADA would therefore still be actionable in state and federal court. Thus, despite the beguiling appeal of protection from state law violations, businesses that violate the ADA would continue to be subject to costly litigation, including money damages, civil penalties and attorney's fees, irrespective of this bill.
Frequency of changes to construction-related accessibility standards. According to the author, the main premise for the notice and right to cure provision of this bill is that “Construction-related accessibility standards often change and are hard for small businesses to stay on top of. AB 54 is a commonsense bill that will allow small businesses to keep their doors open, while increasing access to the disabled community.”
How often do standards change and how hard is it for businesses to comply with them? The federal ADA Standards for Accessible Design (Standards) were originally published in 1991 and updated in 2010. However, because of safe harbor provisions, revised Standards do not necessarily affect existing businesses. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division, Disability Access Section’s ADA Compliance Primer for Small Businesses:
If your business facility was built or altered in the past 20 years in compliance with the 1991 Standards, or you removed barriers to specific elements in compliance with those Standards, you do not have to make further modifications to those elements – even if the new standards have different requirements for them – to comply with the 2010 Standards. This provision is applied on an element-by-element basis and is referred to as the "safe harbor."
State building codes change because of changes in state law, as well as (very infrequent) changes in federal ADA Standards. Because of changes in state law, the Division of State Architect (DSA) updates the California Building Code every three years. The last time the federal ADA Standards changed (in 2010), the DSA released Bulletin BU 11-07 in order to “describe the applicability of the accessibility provisions in the California Building Code . . . and the Americans with Disabilities Act Standards for Accessible Design . . .for Title II and Title III construction projects in California.” According to the DSA:
New construction shall comply with the 1991 Standards if the date when the last application for a building permit or permit extension is certified to be complete by a State, county, or local government . . . is after January 26, 1992, and before September 15, 2010 . . . Alterations shall comply with the 1991 Standards if the physical alteration begins after January 26, 1992, and before September 15, 2010.
. . . New construction and alterations shall comply with the 2010 Standards if the date when the last application for a building permit or permit extension is certified to be complete by a State, county, or local government (or, in those jurisdictions where the government does not certify completion of applications, if the date when the last application for a building permit or permit extension is received by a State, county, or local government) is on or after March 15, 2012, or if no permit is required, if the start of physical construction or alterations occurs on or after March 15, 2012. (http://www.documents.dgs.ca.gov/dsa/bulletins/BU_11-07.pdf)
While these timelines can be complicated, the bottom line is that, because of “safe harbor” provisions similar to those in the federal ADA Standards, a business is only required to comply with standards that are in place when the business is originally constructed, or if later altered, the standards that were in place at that time. Health and Safety Code Section 18938.5 makes it clear that a “public accommodation” must only comply with “the standards in effect on the day the initial permit was submitted to the building department.” (Health and Safety Code Section 18938.5.)
If a business is only subject to the laws in place when the business is constructed or altered, under what scenario could a business be liable for violation of a standard which has changed in the past three years, as envisioned by this bill? The only scenario for a business being liable for a recently enacted standard would seem to be where the facility was constructed or altered within the past three years and did not comply with the ADA Standards or state laws that were in effect at that time. The Committee may wish to consider whether it is reasonable to excuse a business from complying with the law when it opens. Not surprisingly, the author provides no examples of businesses that were compliant with construction-related accessibility standards, but found to be liable under either the Unruh Act or the federal ADA because standards later changed and they were sued for those violations within three years. It is possible that no such cases exist.
High price for minimal benefit. This bill alters the Unruh Act in a way that hurts only one protected class of vulnerable persons: the disabled. It imposes onerous new requirements on disabled persons to file lawsuits and obtain compensation for discrimination. At the same time, as explained above, these changes are likely to decrease access, decrease compliance and solve a problem – businesses that comply with construction-related accessibility standards when they open and are held liable for standards that later changed—that may not exist.
This bill undermines recent bipartisan negotiated collaboration and compromise on disability access reform, pre-litigation relief to small businesses, and the important role and work of the Commission. In response to complaints that small businesses were the victims of predatory lawsuits alleging ADA violations, a bipartisan and bicameral effort with disability rights organizations and business advocates over a period of years ultimately led to the adoption of SB 1608 (Corbett and Harman) in 2008. It was the product of extended and careful consideration by thoughtful legislators and input and support from members of the disability and business communities including Disability Rights California, California Chamber of Commerce, California Foundation for Independent Living Centers, California Restaurant Association, Business Properties Association, California Hotel Association, and several others.
SB 1608 enacted several reforms to increase voluntary compliance with state and federal laws requiring access to the disabled in any place of public accommodation. It established incentives for compliance and protection from litigation by responsible businesses, including a process by which businesses, if sued for violation of accessibility standards, could obtain a temporary stay of any litigation along with an in-person early evaluation conference with the court, attended by persons with authority to resolve the dispute between the parties, for the purpose of deterring frivolous cases and evaluating prospects for early settlement. Moreover, it clarified the standards for awarding damages and attorney's fees with respect to a claim alleging a violation of construction-related accessibility standards. It also required an attorney, when serving a written demand for money or a complaint on a defendant, to include a written advisory to the defendant of the defendant’s rights and obligations. In addition, the bill required architects to complete coursework regarding disability access requirements and imposed continuing education requirements on local building officials relating to disability access requirements and established the Commission “to develop[] recommendations that will enable persons with disabilities to exercise their right to full and equal access to public facilities, and that will facilitate business compliance with the laws and regulations to avoid unnecessary litigation.” (Government Code section 8299.)
Four years after SB 1608 was signed into law, Senate Bill 1186 enacted a number of additional reforms to the laws governing construction-related accessibility claims. According to the Senate Judiciary Committee’s analysis of SB 1186, Senator and President Pro Tempore Darrell Steinberg, who was the joint author of the bill, described it as follows [emphasis added]:
SB 1186 is a compromise that applies a common sense approach to resolve difficult issues. It maintains the hard-fought civil rights of the disabled community while helping to protect California businesses from predatory demand for money letters and lawsuits. Support for important laws like the Unruh Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act are weakened when those laws are abused for personal gain. This measure bans the unscrupulous practice of ‘demand for money’ letters, stops the stacking of claims based on alleged repeat violations to force a business into a quick settlement, while encouraging businesses to fix their violations to comply with the law. Thus, SB 1186 provides some relief to businesses who show good faith in trying to follow the law and are willing to correct the violation, which ultimately promotes compliance and brings greater access to the disabled community.
Senator Dutton, the Senate Minority Leader and joint author of SB 1186, described the bill as:
. . . the culmination of months of hard work with staff and all the various stakeholders in the community. [The bill] will not only provide a reasonable amount of time for small businesses to fix minor infractions, but will also help expand the California Access Specialist Program in California and provide many more tools for businesses to comply with this vital civil rights law.
The policy goal of SB 1186, according to the authors, was “to incentivize property owners to correct their violations, as opposed to settling the case and doing nothing, by reducing the minimum statutory damages and potential attorney’s fees award to the plaintiff when they correct the violation.”
Unlike both SB 1608 and SB 1186, this bill is not the product of compromise or negotiation. It has never been amended in response to or consideration of concerns raised by the persons who are directly impacted by the widespread lack of compliance with construction-related access standards: the disabled community. There is no indication that anyone who is affected by construction-related disability access standards and litigation, other than business groups, has been consulted in the development of the bill’s provisions. It is also noteworthy that many of the business groups that now support this bill supported SB 1186 when it was before the Legislature and claimed that it would greatly improve existing law by deterring frivolous lawsuits and serial litigants from filing Unruh Act-ADA lawsuits.
Amendments recommended by the Committee. In light of the concerns expressed above, the Committee suggests the following amendments.
Amend SECTION 1 of the bill as follows:
(a) The Legislature finds and declares that the federal
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) is a well-intentioned
law empowering private citizens to bring claims against businesses
that do not make their establishments accessible to those with
disabilities. However, because the ADA authorizes damages of
up to $4,000 on top of legal fees, California is a hotbed for
predatory, serial litigants seeking to win settlements from
a large number of businesses in California
are out of compliance with the ADA.
(b) The Legislature further finds and declares all of the following:
(1) Current law permits defendants to request a court stay and an early evaluation conference upon being served with a construction-related accessibility claim if, among other things, the site in question had new construction approved by a local public building department inspector who is a certified access specialist (CASp), no subsequent modifications or alterations have been made, and all violations are corrected within 60 days.
(2) The purpose of this tax credit is to promote increased compliance with disabled accessibility building codes throughout the state by encouraging business and property owners to become CASp certified. Using the relief provided by this tax credit, business and property owners will be more likely to obtain a CASp inspection whenever modifying or altering a site.
(c) The California Commission on Disability Access shall post information about this tax credit on its website and include in its annual report to the Legislature the impact the tax credit has had on reducing ADA compliance lawsuits.
Strike SECTIONS THREE and FOUR from the bill in their entirety.
Similar pending legislation. AB 52 (Gray) - provides, among other things, that the defendant’s maximum liability for statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim against a place of public accommodation is $1,000 for each offense if the defendant has corrected all construction-related violations within 180 days of being served with the complaint. This bill is currently in this Committee.
AB 1230 (Gomez) - establishes, among other things, the California Americans with Disabilities Act Small Business Compliance Finance Act, which would provide loans, funded in part by bond issuances, to assist small businesses finance the costs of projects that alter or retrofit existing small business facilities to comply with the federal American with Disabilities Act. This bill is currently in Assembly Banking and Finance.
AB 1342 (Steinorth) - provides, among other things, additional revenue to the California Commission on Disability Access. This bill is currently in this Committee.
AB 1468 (Baker) - provides, among other things, that a public entity’s possession of a close out letter from the State Architect certifying that the buildings, facilities, and other places meet the applicable construction-related accessibility standards of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act, serves as presumptive evidence of compliance with the federal Americans with Disabilities Act. This bill is currently in this Committee.
SB 67 (Galgiani) - among other things, exempts a small business from statutory damage liability in connection with a construction-related accessibility claim and extends the period for correcting construction-related violations that are the basis of a claim from 60 days to 120 days of being served with the complaint, for purposes of reducing a defendant’s minimum statutory damage liability to $1,000. This bill is currently in Senate Judiciary.
SB 251 (Roth) - relating to civil rights and disability access, is currently in Senate Rules.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Air Conditioning Trade Association
Apartment Association, California Southern Cities
Apartment Association of Orange County
Building Owners and Managers Association California
California Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
California Chamber of Commerce
California Building Industry Association
California Small Business Association
California Restaurant Association
California Business Properties Association
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
California Small Business Association
California Southern Cities
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chamber of Commerce Mountain View
Chamber of the Santa Barbara Region
Civil Justice Association of California
Council of California Goodwill Industries
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Fairfield – Suisun City Chamber of Commerce
Fullerton Chamber of Commerce
Goleta Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Fresno Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers Lake Tahoe South Shore Chamber of Commerce
Lodi Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP –Commercial Real Estate Development Association
North Lake Tahoe Chamber Commerce
Nor Cal Rental Properties Association
North Valley Property Owners Association
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce & Visitors Bureau
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Solano Economic Development Corporation
San Diego County Apartment Association
San Diego County
Tahoe Chamber of Commerce
Plumbing-Heating-Cooling Contractors Association of California
Western Electrical Contractors Association
(Two individuals)
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Association of California
California Foundation for Independent Living Centers
Californians for Disability Rights, Inc.
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
United African-Asian Abilities Club
(One individual)
Analysis Prepared by:
Alison Merrilees and Anthony Lew /JUD./(916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):