AB 2339: Medi-Cal: telehealth.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-08-31
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-09-20: Vetoed by Governor.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services and under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. The Medi-Cal program is, in part, governed and funded by federal Medicaid program provisions.
Under existing law, subject to federal approval, in-person, face-to-face contact is not required under Medi-Cal when covered health care services are provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet certain criteria. Existing law defines asynchronous store and forward as the transmission of a patients medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site.
This bill would expand that definition, for purposes of the above-described Medi-Cal provisions, to include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
Existing law prohibits a health care provider from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as specified. Among those exceptions, existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
This bill would expand that exception to include asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services, as specified.
Existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests that they do not have access to video, as specified.
This bill would remove, from that exception, the option of the patient attesting that they do not have access to video.
Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services and under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. The Medi-Cal program is, in part, governed and funded by federal Medicaid program provisions.
Under existing law, subject to federal approval, in-person, face-to-face contact is not required under Medi-Cal when covered health care services are provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet certain criteria. Existing law defines asynchronous store and forward as the transmission of a patients medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site.
This bill would expand that definition, for purposes of the above-described Medi-Cal provisions, to include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
Existing law prohibits a health care provider from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as specified. Among those exceptions, existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
This bill would expand that exception to include asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services, as specified. The bill would also authorize a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality, as specified.
Existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests that they do not have access to video, as specified.
This bill would remove, from that exception, the option of the patient attesting that they do not have access to video.
Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services and under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. The Medi-Cal program is, in part, governed and funded by federal Medicaid program provisions.
Under existing law, subject to federal approval, in-person, face-to-face contact is not required under Medi-Cal when covered health care services are provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet certain criteria. Existing law defines asynchronous store and forward as the transmission of a patients medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site.
This bill would expand that definition, for purposes of the above-described Medi-Cal provisions, to include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
Existing law prohibits a health care provider from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as specified. Among those exceptions, existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
This bill would expand that exception to include asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services, as specified. The bill would also authorize a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality, as specified.
Existing law authorizes a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests that they do not have access to video, as specified.
This bill would remove, from that exception, the option of the patient attesting that they do not have access to video.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Border community means border areas adjacent to the State of California where it is customary practice for California residents to use medical resources in adjacent areas outside the state. Under these circumstances, program controls and limitations are the same as for services rendered by health care providers within the state.
(2)Health care provider has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, and shall be either enrolled as a Medi-Cal rendering provider, or a nonphysician medical practitioner affiliated with an enrolled Medi-Cal provider group. Health care provider also includes any provider type designated by the department pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b). The enrolled Medi-Cal provider or provider group for which the health care provider renders services via telehealth shall meet all Medi-Cal requirements and shall be located in the state or a border community.
(3)Health care service plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (f) of Section 1345 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Medi-Cal managed care plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (j) of Section 14184.101.
(5)Network provider has the same meaning as set forth in Section 438.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(6)Telehealth has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(b)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), in-person, face-to-face contact between a health care provider and a patient is not required under the Medi-Cal program for covered health care services and provider types designated by the department, when provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, as defined in subdivision (n), audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)(A)In implementing this section, the department shall designate and periodically update the covered health care services and provider types, including required licensing and credentialing criteria, as applicable, which may be appropriately delivered via the telehealth modalities described in this subdivision.
(B)Applicable health care services appropriately provided through video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities are subject to billing, reimbursement, and utilization management policies imposed by the department. Subject to subdivision (k), utilization management protocols adopted by the department pursuant to this section shall be consistent with, and no more restrictive than, those authorized for health care service plans pursuant to Section 1374.13 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)(A)Pursuant to an effective date designated by the department that is no sooner than January 1, 2024, a Medi-Cal provider furnishing applicable health care services via audio-only synchronous interaction shall also offer those same health care services via video synchronous interaction to preserve beneficiary choice.
(B)(i)The department may provide specific exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), based on a Medi-Cal providers access to requisite technologies, which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(ii)In making exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), in addition to the provisions in clause (i), the department may also take into consideration the availability of broadband access based on speed standards set by the Federal Communications Commission, pursuant to Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (Pub. L. No. 104-104) or other applicable federal law or regulation.
(2)Effective on the date designated by the department pursuant to paragraph (1), a provider furnishing services through video synchronous interaction or audio-only synchronous interaction shall also maintain and follow protocols to do one of the following:
(A)Offer those services via in-person, face-to-face contact.
(B)(i)Arrange for a referral to, and a facilitation of, in-person care that does not require a patient to independently contact a different provider to arrange for that care.
(ii)Clause (i) does not require a provider to schedule an appointment with a different provider on behalf of a patient.
(3)In implementing this subdivision, the department shall consider additional recommendations from affected stakeholders regarding the need to maintain access to in-person services without unduly restricting access to telehealth services.
(4)A health care provider may establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via video synchronous interaction consistent with any requirements imposed by the department.
(5)(A)A health care provider shall not establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as set forth in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(B)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), the department may provide for specific exceptions to this prohibition, the department may provide for specific exceptions described in clauses (i) and (ii), which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(i)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction, or asynchronous store and forward, when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined in subdivision (s) of Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
(ii)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
(6)Subject to subdivision (k), the department may establish separate fee schedules for applicable health care services delivered via remote patient monitoring or other permissible virtual communication modalities.
(7)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(d)In addition to any existing law requiring beneficiary consent to telehealth, including, but not limited to, subdivision (b) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, all of the following shall be communicated by a health care provider to a Medi-Cal beneficiary, in writing or verbally, on at least one occasion prior to, or concurrent with, initiating the delivery of one or more health care services via telehealth to a Medi-Cal beneficiary: an explanation that beneficiaries have the right to access covered services that may be delivered via telehealth through an in-person, face-to-face visit; an explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn at any time by the Medi-Cal beneficiary without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future; an explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted; and the potential limitations or risks related to receiving services through telehealth as compared to an in-person visit, to the extent that any limitations or risks are identified by the provider.
(1)The provider shall document in the patient record the provision of this information and the patients verbal or written acknowledgment that the information was received.
(2)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, model language for purposes of the communication described in this subdivision.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(e)(1)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, an informational notice to be distributed to fee-for-service Medi-Cal beneficiaries and for use by Medi-Cal managed care plans in communicating to their enrollees. Information in the notice shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(A)The availability of Medi-Cal covered telehealth services.
(B)The beneficiarys right to access all medically necessary covered services through in-person, face-to-face visits, and a providers and Medi-Cal managed care plans responsibility to offer or arrange for that in-person care, as applicable.
(C)An explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn by the Medi-Cal beneficiary at any time without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future.
(D)An explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted.
(E)Notification of the beneficiarys right to make complaints about the offer of telehealth services in lieu of in-person care or about the quality of care delivered through telehealth.
(2)The informational notice shall be translated into threshold languages determined by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 14029.91 and provided in a format that is culturally and linguistically appropriate.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(f)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), the department shall reimburse health care providers of applicable health care services delivered via video synchronous interaction, synchronous audio-only modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the provider would receive if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, so long as the services or settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)Subject to subdivision (k), for applicable health care services appropriately provided by a network provider via video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, to an enrollee of a Medi-Cal managed care plan, the Medi-Cal managed care plan shall reimburse the network provider at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the network provider would have received if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, unless the Medi-Cal managed care plan and network provider mutually agree to reimbursement in different amounts.
(g)On or before January 1, 2023, the department shall develop a research and evaluation plan that does all of the following:
(1)Proposes strategies to analyze the relationship between telehealth and the following: access to care, access to in-person care, quality of care, and Medi-Cal program costs, utilization, and program integrity.
(2)Examines issues using an equity framework that includes stratification by available geographic and demographic factors, including, but not limited to, race, ethnicity, primary language, age, and gender, to understand inequities and disparities in care.
(3)Prioritizes research and evaluation questions that directly inform Medi-Cal policy.
(h)Applicable health care services provided through asynchronous store and forward, video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities as described in this section shall comply with the privacy and security requirements contained in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 found in Parts 160 and 164 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the Medicaid State Plan, and any other applicable state and federal statutes and regulations.
(i)Notwithstanding Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the department may implement, interpret, and make specific this section by means of all-county letters, plan letters, provider bulletins, and similar instructions, without taking any further regulatory action.
(j)Consistent with the requirements of this section and subject to subdivision (k), a PACE organization approved by the department pursuant to Chapter 8.75 (commencing with Section 14591) may use video telehealth to conduct initial assessments and annual reassessments for eligibility for enrollment in the PACE program.
(k)The department shall seek any federal approvals that it deems necessary to implement this section. This section shall be implemented only to the extent that any necessary federal approvals are obtained and federal financial participation is available and is not otherwise jeopardized.
(l)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2023, or on the operative date or dates reflected in the applicable federal approvals obtained by the department pursuant to subdivision (k), whichever is later.
(m)This section does not apply to health care services provided via telehealth in an FQHC or RHC visit as described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(n)For purposes of this section, asynchronous store and forward has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code. For purposes of this section, the transmission under asynchronous store and forward also includes asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Border community means border areas adjacent to the State of California where it is customary practice for California residents to use medical resources in adjacent areas outside the state. Under these circumstances, program controls and limitations are the same as for services rendered by health care providers within the state.
(2)Health care provider has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, and shall be either enrolled as a Medi-Cal rendering provider, or a nonphysician medical practitioner affiliated with an enrolled Medi-Cal provider group. Health care provider also includes any provider type designated by the department pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b). The enrolled Medi-Cal provider or provider group for which the health care provider renders services via telehealth shall meet all Medi-Cal requirements and shall be located in the state or a border community.
(3)Health care service plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (f) of Section 1345 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Medi-Cal managed care plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (j) of Section 14184.101.
(5)Network provider has the same meaning as set forth in Section 438.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(6)Telehealth has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(b)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), in-person, face-to-face contact between a health care provider and a patient is not required under the Medi-Cal program for covered health care services and provider types designated by the department, when provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, as defined in subdivision (n), audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)(A)In implementing this section, the department shall designate and periodically update the covered health care services and provider types, including required licensing and credentialing criteria, as applicable, which may be appropriately delivered via the telehealth modalities described in this subdivision.
(B)Applicable health care services appropriately provided through video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities are subject to billing, reimbursement, and utilization management policies imposed by the department. Subject to subdivision (k), utilization management protocols adopted by the department pursuant to this section shall be consistent with, and no more restrictive than, those authorized for health care service plans pursuant to Section 1374.13 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)(A)Pursuant to an effective date designated by the department that is no sooner than January 1, 2024, a Medi-Cal provider furnishing applicable health care services via audio-only synchronous interaction shall also offer those same health care services via video synchronous interaction to preserve beneficiary choice.
(B)(i)The department may provide specific exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), based on a Medi-Cal providers access to requisite technologies, which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(ii)In making exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), in addition to the provisions in clause (i), the department may also take into consideration the availability of broadband access based on speed standards set by the Federal Communications Commission, pursuant to Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (Pub. L. No. 104-104) or other applicable federal law or regulation.
(2)Effective on the date designated by the department pursuant to paragraph (1), a provider furnishing services through video synchronous interaction or audio-only synchronous interaction shall also maintain and follow protocols to do one of the following:
(A)Offer those services via in-person, face-to-face contact.
(B)(i)Arrange for a referral to, and a facilitation of, in-person care that does not require a patient to independently contact a different provider to arrange for that care.
(ii)Clause (i) does not require a provider to schedule an appointment with a different provider on behalf of a patient.
(3)In implementing this subdivision, the department shall consider additional recommendations from affected stakeholders regarding the need to maintain access to in-person services without unduly restricting access to telehealth services.
(4)A health care provider may establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via video synchronous interaction consistent with any requirements imposed by the department.
(5)(A)A health care provider shall not establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as set forth in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(B)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), the department may provide for specific exceptions to this prohibition, the department may provide for specific exceptions described in clauses (i) through (iii), and (ii), which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(i)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction, or asynchronous store and forward, when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined in subdivision (s) of Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
(ii)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
(iii)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.(6)Subject to subdivision (k), the department may establish separate fee schedules for applicable health care services delivered via remote patient monitoring or other permissible virtual communication modalities.
(7)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(d)In addition to any existing law requiring beneficiary consent to telehealth, including, but not limited to, subdivision (b) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, all of the following shall be communicated by a health care provider to a Medi-Cal beneficiary, in writing or verbally, on at least one occasion prior to, or concurrent with, initiating the delivery of one or more health care services via telehealth to a Medi-Cal beneficiary: an explanation that beneficiaries have the right to access covered services that may be delivered via telehealth through an in-person, face-to-face visit; an explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn at any time by the Medi-Cal beneficiary without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future; an explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted; and the potential limitations or risks related to receiving services through telehealth as compared to an in-person visit, to the extent that any limitations or risks are identified by the provider.
(1)The provider shall document in the patient record the provision of this information and the patients verbal or written acknowledgment that the information was received.
(2)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, model language for purposes of the communication described in this subdivision.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(e)(1)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, an informational notice to be distributed to fee-for-service Medi-Cal beneficiaries and for use by Medi-Cal managed care plans in communicating to their enrollees. Information in the notice shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(A)The availability of Medi-Cal covered telehealth services.
(B)The beneficiarys right to access all medically necessary covered services through in-person, face-to-face visits, and a providers and Medi-Cal managed care plans responsibility to offer or arrange for that in-person care, as applicable.
(C)An explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn by the Medi-Cal beneficiary at any time without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future.
(D)An explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted.
(E)Notification of the beneficiarys right to make complaints about the offer of telehealth services in lieu of in-person care or about the quality of care delivered through telehealth.
(2)The informational notice shall be translated into threshold languages determined by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 14029.91 and provided in a format that is culturally and linguistically appropriate.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(f)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), the department shall reimburse health care providers of applicable health care services delivered via video synchronous interaction, synchronous audio-only modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the provider would receive if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, so long as the services or settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)Subject to subdivision (k), for applicable health care services appropriately provided by a network provider via video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, to an enrollee of a Medi-Cal managed care plan, the Medi-Cal managed care plan shall reimburse the network provider at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the network provider would have received if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, unless the Medi-Cal managed care plan and network provider mutually agree to reimbursement in different amounts.
(g)On or before January 1, 2023, the department shall develop a research and evaluation plan that does all of the following:
(1)Proposes strategies to analyze the relationship between telehealth and the following: access to care, access to in-person care, quality of care, and Medi-Cal program costs, utilization, and program integrity.
(2)Examines issues using an equity framework that includes stratification by available geographic and demographic factors, including, but not limited to, race, ethnicity, primary language, age, and gender, to understand inequities and disparities in care.
(3)Prioritizes research and evaluation questions that directly inform Medi-Cal policy.
(h)Applicable health care services provided through asynchronous store and forward, video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities as described in this section shall comply with the privacy and security requirements contained in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 found in Parts 160 and 164 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the Medicaid State Plan, and any other applicable state and federal statutes and regulations.
(i)Notwithstanding Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the department may implement, interpret, and make specific this section by means of all-county letters, plan letters, provider bulletins, and similar instructions, without taking any further regulatory action.
(j)Consistent with the requirements of this section and subject to subdivision (k), a PACE organization approved by the department pursuant to Chapter 8.75 (commencing with Section 14591) may use video telehealth to conduct initial assessments and annual reassessments for eligibility for enrollment in the PACE program.
(k)The department shall seek any federal approvals that it deems necessary to implement this section. This section shall be implemented only to the extent that any necessary federal approvals are obtained and federal financial participation is available and is not otherwise jeopardized.
(l)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2023, or on the operative date or dates reflected in the applicable federal approvals obtained by the department pursuant to subdivision (k), whichever is later.
(m)This section does not apply to health care services provided via telehealth in an FQHC or RHC visit as described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(n)For purposes of this section, asynchronous store and forward has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code. For purposes of this section, the transmission under asynchronous store and forward also includes asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Border community means border areas adjacent to the State of California where it is customary practice for California residents to use medical resources in adjacent areas outside the state. Under these circumstances, program controls and limitations are the same as for services rendered by health care providers within the state.
(2)Health care provider has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, and shall be either enrolled as a Medi-Cal rendering provider, or a nonphysician medical practitioner affiliated with an enrolled Medi-Cal provider group. Health care provider also includes any provider type designated by the department pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b). The enrolled Medi-Cal provider or provider group for which the health care provider renders services via telehealth shall meet all Medi-Cal requirements and shall be located in the state or a border community.
(3)Health care service plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (f) of Section 1345 of the Health and Safety Code.
(4)Medi-Cal managed care plan has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (j) of Section 14184.101.
(5)Network provider has the same meaning as set forth in Section 438.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(6)Telehealth has the same meaning as set forth in paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(b)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), in-person, face-to-face contact between a health care provider and a patient is not required under the Medi-Cal program for covered health care services and provider types designated by the department, when provided by video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, (n), audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities, when those services and settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)(A)In implementing this section, the department shall designate and periodically update the covered health care services and provider types, including required licensing and credentialing criteria, as applicable, which may be appropriately delivered via the telehealth modalities described in this subdivision.
(B)Applicable health care services appropriately provided through video synchronous interaction, asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities are subject to billing, reimbursement, and utilization management policies imposed by the department. Subject to subdivision (k), utilization management protocols adopted by the department pursuant to this section shall be consistent with, and no more restrictive than, those authorized for health care service plans pursuant to Section 1374.13 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(1)(A)Pursuant to an effective date designated by the department that is no sooner than January 1, 2024, a Medi-Cal provider furnishing applicable health care services via audio-only synchronous interaction shall also offer those same health care services via video synchronous interaction to preserve beneficiary choice.
(B)(i)The department may provide specific exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), based on a Medi-Cal providers access to requisite technologies, which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(ii)In making exceptions to the requirement specified in subparagraph (A), in addition to the provisions in clause (i), the department may also take into consideration the availability of broadband access based on speed standards set by the Federal Communications Commission, pursuant to Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (Pub. L. No. 104-104) or other applicable federal law or regulation.
(2)Effective on the date designated by the department pursuant to paragraph (1), a provider furnishing services through video synchronous interaction or audio-only synchronous interaction shall also maintain and follow protocols to do one of the following:
(A)Offer those services via in-person, face-to-face contact.
(B)(i)Arrange for a referral to, and a facilitation of, in-person care that does not require a patient to independently contact a different provider to arrange for that care.
(ii)Clause (i) does not require a provider to schedule an appointment with a different provider on behalf of a patient.
(3)In implementing this subdivision, the department shall consider additional recommendations from affected stakeholders regarding the need to maintain access to in-person services without unduly restricting access to telehealth services.
(4)A health care provider may establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via video synchronous interaction consistent with any requirements imposed by the department.
(5)(A)A health care provider shall not establish a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via asynchronous store and forward, telephonic (audio-only) synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities, except as set forth in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(B)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), the department may provide for specific exceptions to this prohibition, the department may provide for specific exceptions described in clauses (i) and (ii), through (iii), which shall be developed in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in departmental guidance.
(i)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction interaction, or asynchronous store and forward, when the visit is related to sensitive services, as defined in subdivision (p) (s) of Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state law, regulations, and guidance.
(ii)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video, and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
(iii)Notwithstanding the prohibition in subparagraph (A), a health care provider may establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with department-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
(6)Subject to subdivision (k), the department may establish separate fee schedules for applicable health care services delivered via remote patient monitoring or other permissible virtual communication modalities.
(7)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(d)In addition to any existing law requiring beneficiary consent to telehealth, including, but not limited to, subdivision (b) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code, all of the following shall be communicated by a health care provider to a Medi-Cal beneficiary, in writing or verbally, on at least one occasion prior to, or concurrent with, initiating the delivery of one or more health care services via telehealth to a Medi-Cal beneficiary: an explanation that beneficiaries have the right to access covered services that may be delivered via telehealth through an in-person, face-to-face visit; an explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn at any time by the Medi-Cal beneficiary without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future; an explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted; and the potential limitations or risks related to receiving services through telehealth as compared to an in-person visit, to the extent that any limitations or risks are identified by the provider.
(1)The provider shall document in the patient record the provision of this information and the patients verbal or written acknowledgment that the information was received.
(2)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, model language for purposes of the communication described in this subdivision.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(e)(1)The department shall develop, in consultation with affected stakeholders, an informational notice to be distributed to fee-for-service Medi-Cal beneficiaries and for use by Medi-Cal managed care plans in communicating to their enrollees. Information in the notice shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(A)The availability of Medi-Cal covered telehealth services.
(B)The beneficiarys right to access all medically necessary covered services through in-person, face-to-face visits, and a providers and Medi-Cal managed care plans responsibility to offer or arrange for that in-person care, as applicable.
(C)An explanation that use of telehealth is voluntary and that consent for the use of telehealth can be withdrawn by the Medi-Cal beneficiary at any time without affecting their ability to access covered Medi-Cal services in the future.
(D)An explanation of the availability of Medi-Cal coverage for transportation services to in-person visits when other available resources have been reasonably exhausted.
(E)Notification of the beneficiarys right to make complaints about the offer of telehealth services in lieu of in-person care or about the quality of care delivered through telehealth.
(2)The informational notice shall be translated into threshold languages determined by the department pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 14029.91 and provided in a format that is culturally and linguistically appropriate.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to Medi-Cal covered services delivered by providers via any telehealth modality to eligible inmates in state prisons, county jails, or youth correctional facilities.
(f)(1)Subject to subdivision (k), the department shall reimburse health care providers of applicable health care services delivered via video synchronous interaction, synchronous audio-only modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the provider would receive if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, so long as the services or settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed.
(2)Subject to subdivision (k), for applicable health care services appropriately provided by a network provider via video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction modality, or asynchronous store and forward, as applicable, to an enrollee of a Medi-Cal managed care plan, the Medi-Cal managed care plan shall reimburse the network provider at payment amounts that are not less than the amounts the network provider would have received if the services were delivered via in-person, face-to-face contact, unless the Medi-Cal managed care plan and network provider mutually agree to reimbursement in different amounts.
(g)On or before January 1, 2023, the department shall develop a research and evaluation plan that does all of the following:
(1)Proposes strategies to analyze the relationship between telehealth and the following: access to care, access to in-person care, quality of care, and Medi-Cal program costs, utilization, and program integrity.
(2)Examines issues using an equity framework that includes stratification by available geographic and demographic factors, including, but not limited to, race, ethnicity, primary language, age, and gender, to understand inequities and disparities in care.
(3)Prioritizes research and evaluation questions that directly inform Medi-Cal policy.
(h)Applicable health care services provided through asynchronous store and forward, video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities as described in this section shall comply with the privacy and security requirements contained in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 found in Parts 160 and 164 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the Medicaid State Plan, and any other applicable state and federal statutes and regulations.
(i)Notwithstanding Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the department may implement, interpret, and make specific this section by means of all-county letters, plan letters, provider bulletins, and similar instructions, without taking any further regulatory action.
(j)Consistent with the requirements of this section and subject to subdivision (k), a PACE organization approved by the department pursuant to Chapter 8.75 (commencing with Section 14591) may use video telehealth to conduct initial assessments and annual reassessments for eligibility for enrollment in the PACE program.
(k)The department shall seek any federal approvals that it deems necessary to implement this section. This section shall be implemented only to the extent that any necessary federal approvals are obtained and federal financial participation is available and is not otherwise jeopardized.
(l)This section shall be operative on January 1, 2023, or on the operative date or dates reflected in the applicable federal approvals obtained by the department pursuant to subdivision (k), whichever is later.
(m)This section does not apply to health care services provided via telehealth in an FQHC or RHC visit as described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 14132.100.
(n)For purposes of this section, asynchronous store and forward has the same meaning as set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 2290.5 of the Business and Professions Code. For purposes of this section, the transmission under asynchronous store and forward also includes asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 20, 2024 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 77. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 30 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 34. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 23, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 71. Noes 0. Page 5441.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| Apr 17, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2024 | AB 2339 Aguiar-Curry Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2339 Aguiar-Curry et al. By Atkins | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2024 | AB 2339 Aguiar-Curry Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aids Healthcare Foundation | ** Support | |
| American College Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists District Ix | ** Support | |
| American Telemedicine Association Action | ** Support | |
| California Academy Of Family Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Legislative Women Caucus | ** Support | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Against | |
| California Podiatric Medical Association | ** Support | |
| California Society of Health System Pharmacists | ** Support | |
| California Telehealth Policy Coalition | ** Support | |
| City of Glendale | ** Support | |
| Elderly Care Everywhere | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| Hims and Hers | ** Support | |
| National Health Law Program | ** Support | |
| OCHIN, INC. | ** Support | |
| Planned Parenthood Affiliates Of California | ** Support | |
| Reproductive Freedom for All | ** Support | |
| Teladoc Health, Inc. | ** Support | |
| The Council of Autism Service Providers | ** Support |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 2339
Author:(Aguiar-Curry)
As Enrolled Ver:August 31, 2024
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Expands the situations in which health care providers can be reimbursed by Medi-Cal for services rendered to patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
Senate Amendments
Slightly narrow the bill by removing a provision that allows providers to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous telehealth based on patient request only.
Governor's Veto Message
This bill would authorize Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient using an asynchronous store-and-forward interaction, including through a mobile application, when the visit is related to sensitive services.
My Administration, in collaboration with the Legislature and the Telehealth Advisory Workgroup, worked to develop and implement one of the strongest telehealth policies in the country. Under the current Medi-Cal telehealth policy, licensed providers have substantial flexibility to make clinically appropriate decisions regarding the use of both synchronous and asynchronous telehealth modalities, and Medi-Cal pays the same rate for services provided via telehealth as services provided in-person.
I believe that robust telehealth policies increase access and reduce barriers to health care, including the use of asynchronous telehealth. However, there are details of a patient's medical history and personal health information that are best gathered during a synchronous appointment. For example, this bill would allow a patient to receive treatment and medications for reproductive and behavioral health services without ever seeing or talking directly to a provider. I believe that there are consumer protections provided through a live interaction between a patient and provider.
COMMENTS
- Telehealth. Telehealth is a mode of delivering health care services remotely using information technology. The three primary modalities are video, audio (including telephone), and asynchronous store and forward, which can be used when a real-time interaction is not needed. A large body of research supports the use of telehealth for a range of health care services, although the available evidence is mostly discipline-specific. Telehealth has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with chronic conditions and behavioral health needs. According to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), from the beneficiary perspective, telehealth can improve access to care and enhance satisfaction by making care more convenient and reducing some of the logistical burdens of seeking in-person care.
Telehealth utilization in Medi-Cal increased dramatically in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Long-term utilization trends are unclear, but telehealth appears likely to remain much more prevalent than it was prior to COVID-19.
- Recent History of Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy Development. Prior to the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), DHCS had expanded the availability of telehealth in Medi-Cal by allowing most clinically appropriate services to be provided through telehealth. During the PHE, DHCS implemented additional telehealth flexibilities to allow Medi-Cal providers to meet the health care needs of enrollees. After significant stakeholder engagement and legislative agreement on final trailer bill language, post-PHE Medi-Cal telehealth policies were codified through the 2022-23 health trailer bill, SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022. Subsequently, AB 32 (Aguilar-Curry), Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022, and AB 1241 (Weber), Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023, made minor and clarifying changes to telehealth policy. These post-PHE policies permanently maintained many flexibilities granted during the PHE.
- Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy. According to DHCS, California has been a leading state in the expansiveness of its coverage and reimbursement for services delivered via telehealth. DHCS has committed to continuing to enable broad telehealth coverage for all Medi-Cal covered benefits and services, as long as the provider is able to meet the standard of care, subject to billing, reimbursement and utilization management policies developed by DHCS. In addition, DHCS notes Medi-Cal is unique among other state Medicaid programs in regard to payment parity, in that the state reimburses a broad array of services at parity when delivered via audio-only visits.
- Establishment of New Patients via Telehealth. A health care provider may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via video. Pursuant to AB 32, a provider also may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via audio-only telehealth (e.g., phone or other audio device), but only under certain circumstances. These circumstances include when the visit is related to "sensitive services," including behavioral health and reproductive health services, or when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. Additional exceptions may be made by DHCS in consultation with stakeholders. This bill would expand establishment of new patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
According to the DHCS Post-COVID-19 PHE Final Telehealth Policy Proposal published in 2022, the rationale for the policy related to new patients is to increase access to care by allowing the establishment of new patients via telehealth while supporting consumer protections. The restrictions address concerns that initial visits may require a higher level of two-way communication to ensure quality of care. However, stakeholders have raised various scenarios where synchronous communication may not be critical to care for a new patient or where timely access concerns outweigh the potential benefit of synchronous communication—for instance, for a patient seeking emergency contraception. As noted above, statute allows DHCS to make exceptions to these policies in consultation with stakeholders.
- Effect of This Bill: This bill would essentially make such an exception to current policy that restricts the establishment of new patients via telehealth, expanding the circumstances under which a health care provider may bill for an asynchronous encounter with a new patient. Specifically, this bill would allow asynchronous store and forward to be used for new patient visits when a visit is related to "sensitive services." It would also include, in the definition of asynchronous store and forward, electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications ("apps"). According to the bill's sponsors, this is important because it allows Medi-Cal patients to access asynchronous services through apps, often the same apps used for synchronous telehealth services.
According to the Author
In 2022, AB 32 expanded access to telehealth services and was intended to facilitate Medi-Cal coverage of telehealth services through mobile apps. The author indicates these apps are particularly important for working Californians so they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, the author states that Medi-Cal coverage is more restrictive than private insurance plans, which already cover these services. The author contends that this bill will ensure state policy supports expanded access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage. Planned Parenthood of California (PPAC) is the bill's sponsor.
Arguments in Support
PPAC argues asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. The Council of Autism Service Providers writes in support that research demonstrates the effectiveness of telehealth in Applied Behavior Analysis, and telehealth may be used to establish new patients or conduct portions of an initial assessment.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Nurses Association (CNA) writes in opposition to this bill's expansion of the use of telehealth to include mobile apps, arguing such tools are an unacceptable substitute for in-person care. CNA writes that nurses understand that mobile apps can never replace the in-person care that nurses and other health care workers provide, especially for the vulnerable populations Medi-Cal serves. CNA also objects to features of telehealth that it contends jeopardize patient care, such as limiting patient-provider communication, which would be particularly problematic when delivered through an app.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 15-0-1
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0-9
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Friedman, Gabriel, Holden, Mathis, McCarty, Luz Rivas
SENATE FLOOR: 34-0-6
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0-2
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cervantes, Ortega
UPDATED
VERSION: August 31, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lisa Murawski / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0005138
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2339
Author:(Aguiar-Curry)
As Amended Ver:August 23, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the situations in which health care providers can be reimbursed by Medi-Cal for services rendered to patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
Senate Amendments
Slightly narrow the bill by removing a provision that allows providers to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous telehealth based on patient request only.
COMMENTS
- Telehealth. Telehealth is a mode of delivering health care services remotely using information technology. The three primary modalities are video, audio (including telephone), and asynchronous store and forward, which can be used when a real-time interaction is not needed. A large body of research supports the use of telehealth for a range of health care services, although the available evidence is mostly discipline-specific. Telehealth has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with chronic conditions and behavioral health needs. According to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), from the beneficiary perspective, telehealth can improve access to care and enhance satisfaction by making care more convenient and reducing some of the logistical burdens of seeking in-person care.
Telehealth utilization in Medi-Cal increased dramatically in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Long-term utilization trends are unclear, but telehealth appears likely to remain much more prevalent than it was prior to COVID-19.
- Recent History of Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy Development. Prior to the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), DHCS had expanded the availability of telehealth in Medi-Cal by allowing most clinically appropriate services to be provided through telehealth. During the PHE, DHCS implemented additional telehealth flexibilities to allow Medi-Cal providers to meet the health care needs of enrollees. After significant stakeholder engagement and legislative agreement on final trailer bill language, post-PHE Medi-Cal telehealth policies were codified through the 2022-23 health trailer bill, SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022. Subsequently, AB 32 (Aguilar-Curry), Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022, and AB 1241 (Weber), Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023, made minor and clarifying changes to telehealth policy. These post-PHE policies permanently maintained many flexibilities granted during the PHE.
- Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy. According to DHCS, California has been a leading state in the expansiveness of its coverage and reimbursement for services delivered via telehealth. DHCS has committed to continuing to enable broad telehealth coverage for all Medi-Cal covered benefits and services, as long as the provider is able to meet the standard of care, subject to billing, reimbursement and utilization management policies developed by DHCS. In addition, DHCS notes Medi-Cal is unique among other state Medicaid programs in regard to payment parity, in that the state reimburses a broad array of services at parity when delivered via audio-only visits.
- Establishment of New Patients via Telehealth. A health care provider may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via video. Pursuant to AB 32, a provider also may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via audio-only telehealth (e.g., phone or other audio device), but only under certain circumstances. These circumstances include when the visit is related to "sensitive services," including behavioral health and reproductive health services, or when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. Additional exceptions may be made by DHCS in consultation with stakeholders. This bill would expand establishment of new patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
According to the DHCS Post-COVID-19 PHE Final Telehealth Policy Proposal published in 2022, the rationale for the policy related to new patients is to increase access to care by allowing the establishment of new patients via telehealth while supporting consumer protections. The restrictions address concerns that initial visits may require a higher level of two-way communication to ensure quality of care. However, stakeholders have raised various scenarios where synchronous communication may not be critical to care for a new patient or where timely access concerns outweigh the potential benefit of synchronous communication—for instance, for a patient seeking emergency contraception. As noted above, statute allows DHCS to make exceptions to these policies in consultation with stakeholders.
- Effect of This Bill: This bill would essentially make such an exception to current policy that restricts the establishment of new patients via telehealth, expanding the circumstances under which a health care provider may bill for an asynchronous encounter with a new patient. Specifically, this bill would allow asynchronous store and forward to be used for new patient visits when a visit is related to "sensitive services." It would also include, in the definition of asynchronous store and forward, electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications ("apps"). According to the bill's sponsors, this is important because it allows Medi-Cal patients to access asynchronous services through apps, often the same apps used for synchronous telehealth services.
According to the Author
In 2022, AB 32 expanded access to telehealth services and was intended to facilitate Medi-Cal coverage of telehealth services through mobile apps. The author indicates these apps are particularly important for working Californians so they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, the author states that Medi-Cal coverage is more restrictive than private insurance plans, which already cover these services. The author contends that this bill will ensure state policy supports expanded access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage. Planned Parenthood of California (PPAC) is the bill's sponsor.
Arguments in Support
PPAC argues asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. The Council of Autism Service Providers writes in support that research demonstrates the effectiveness of telehealth in Applied Behavior Analysis, and telehealth may be used to establish new patients or conduct portions of an initial assessment.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Nurses Association (CNA) writes in opposition to this bill's expansion of the use of telehealth to include mobile apps, arguing such tools are an unacceptable substitute for in-person care. CNA writes that nurses understand that mobile apps can never replace the in-person care that nurses and other health care workers provide, especially for the vulnerable populations Medi-Cal serves. CNA also objects to features of telehealth that it contends jeopardize patient care, such as limiting patient-provider communication, which would be particularly problematic when delivered through an app.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 15-0-1
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0-9
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Friedman, Gabriel, Holden, Mathis, McCarty, Luz Rivas
SENATE FLOOR: 34-0-6
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto
UPDATED
VERSION: August 23, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lisa Murawski / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004567
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2339 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2339
Author: Aguiar-Curry (D), et al.
Amended: 8/23/24 in Senatein Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/19/24
AYES: Roth, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/21/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Medi-Cal: telehealth
SOURCE: National Health Law Program
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
DIGEST:
This bill permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward, when the visit is related to sensitive services and when established in accordance with requirements set by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) and is consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/23/24 delete the authority to also allow for the use of asynchronous telehealth when requested by the patient.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “telehealth” as the mode of delivering health care services and public health via information and communication technologies to facilitate the diagnosis, consultation, treatment, education, care management, and self-management of a patient’s health care. [Business Professions Code (BPC) §2290.5]
- Defines “asynchronous store and forward” as the transmission of a patient’s medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site. Defines “synchronous interaction” as a real-time interaction between a patient and a health care provider located at a distant site. [BPC §2290.5]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by the DHCS, under which low-income individuals are eligible for medical coverage. [Welfare & Institutions Code (WIC) §14000, et seq.]
- Prohibits Medi-Cal providers from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal recipient via asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities except for visits provided by specified federally qualified health center or rural health center providers using asynchronous store and forward and audio-only synchronous interaction when services delivered through that interaction meet the applicable standard of care. [WIC §14132.725]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship via the use of audio-only synchronous interactions when the visit is related to sensitive services as defined in state law in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. Sensitive services includes all health care services related to mental or behavioral health, sexual and reproductive health, sexually transmitted infections, substance use disorder, gender affirming care, and intimate partner violence, HIV testing, including the related sensitive services that minors can consent to. [WIC §14132.725, Civil Code §56.05]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video, and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. [WIC §14132.725]
This bill:
- Permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward, when the visit is related to sensitive services and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
- Adds to the definition of “asynchronous store and forward” as used in the Medi-Cal program to also include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in 2022, she authored AB 32 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022) to expand access to telehealth services for all Californians. At the time, her intention was for Medi-Cal to cover telehealth services including mobile apps, which provide patient-initiated care that can be established through asynchronous messaging. These apps are particularly important for working Californians because they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, restrictive policies currently prohibit Medi-Cal coverage of certain telehealth services, even though private insurance plans cover these services. This bill would expand access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage.
- Telehealth in Medi-Cal. Medi-Cal’s telehealth policy was established pursuant to the Telemedicine Development Act of 1996 [SB 1665 (Thompson, Chapter 864, Statutes of 1996)] and updated in compliance with AB 415 (Logue, Chapter 547, Statutes of 2011), known as the Telehealth Advancement Act of 2011. In 2019, DHCS undertook a policy review process, following extensive stakeholder engagement and public comment, to inform policy refinement. The revised 2019 policy afforded flexibility to licensed providers to make clinically appropriate decisions regarding the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth modalities. The finalized policy was published in the Medi-Cal provider manual and disseminated to Medi-Cal managed care plans via an All Plan Letter. In 2020, due to the COVID-19 public health emergency, DHCS implemented additional broad flexibilities relative to telehealth modalities via blanket waivers and Disaster Relief state plan amendments. This enabled Medi-Cal’s health care delivery systems to meet the health care needs of Medi-Cal beneficiaries where in-person encounters were not recommended or available. Such expansions included expanding which providers could use telehealth, allowing telehealth to be used for new patients, allowing many services to be provided audio-only, expanding payment parity for telehealth services, waiving site limitations for federally qualified health centers and rural health centers, and expanding access through non-public technology platforms.
In 2021, several of these COVID-19 flexibilities were extended via budget trailer bill AB 133 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021), along with a requirement for DHCS to convene a Telehealth Advisory Workgroup to inform the development of telehealth policies beyond the public health emergency. One outcome of the workgroup was a policy paper published by DHCS making a number of telehealth policy recommendations, many of which were subsequently incorporated into SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022), including the existing requirements on the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth both generally and when establishing a new patient relationship.
While California Medi-Cal telehealth policy is broad, it is more restrictive on the use of asynchronous telehealth (also known as “store and forward”), particularly in the establishment of new patient relationships, where it is prohibited. Despite California’s otherwise expansive Medi-Cal telehealth coverage and reimbursement policies, according to a September 2023 California Health Care Foundation Report on telehealth use experiences, people on Medi-Cal use less telehealth than people with other forms of health coverage. Those who do use telehealth tend to like it as much or better than in-person care.
- Expansion of asynchronous telehealth in reproductive health services. The use of asynchronous telehealth has become more popular particularly for sensitive services such as reproductive health services. According to a 2019 issue brief by the Kaiser Family Foundation, telemedicine’s use in reproductive health care has shown promise in offering innovative solutions to unmet health needs, particularly in areas with few health care providers. While long acting reversible contraceptives require in-person care, providers can prescribe a variety of other contraceptive methods via telemedicine, including oral contraceptives. As of June 2019, 14 online platforms existed that all determined eligibility and prescribed oral contraceptives in the same manner:
- Using a smartphone or computer, the patient provides a health history via a questionnaire (asynchronous) or video consultation (synchronous) with a clinician.
- The clinician reviews the information remotely and determines eligibility for oral contraceptives. The provider may be a doctor, nurse practitioner, physician assistant or certified nurse midwife, often depending on state law.
- The patient receives the oral contraceptives by pharmacy pick-up or mail. Prescriptions are valid for three to 12 months, with up to a 12 month supply at a time, depending on the platform and insurance provider.
The report states that almost all risk factors precluding use of hormonal birth control can be assessed online; and evaluations screen for age, smoking history, and conditions posing significant health risks, including clotting disorders, heart disease, breast cancer, and migraines with aura. These platforms cannot measure blood pressure, typically a necessity before initiating oral contraceptives, but most require the user input a reading from the last year; a method deemed acceptable by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) if a provider cannot measure the blood pressure. The report cited a 2019 New England Journal of Medicine study of tele-contraception, defined as the provision of contraception through a website or smartphone app, that found higher adherence to CDC guidelines by telehealth providers than in-person providers did, though many of the telehealth providers did not inform patients of the availability of long-acting reversible contraceptive methods. Since 2019, the use of asynchronous telehealth for reproductive services has expanded significantly. Other reproductive health services provided via asynchronous telehealth include urinary tract infection treatment, emergency contraception, medication abortion, testing or treatment for selected sexually transmitted diseases (often with mail-in, self-collected samples), treatment for symptoms related to perimenopause or menopause, and treatment for erectile dysfunction.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/23/24)
National Health Law Program (co-source)
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California (co-source)
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
American Telemedicine Association Action
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Legislative Women’s Caucus
California Podiatric Medical Association
California Society of Health System Pharmacists
City of Glendale
Elderly Care Everywhere
Equality California
Hims and Hers
Ochin, Inc.
Reproductive Freedom for All
Teladoc Health, Inc.
The Council of Autism Service Providers
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/23/24)
California Nurses Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California write that their affiliates proudly offer asynchronous telehealth services for oral contraceptives, urinary tract infection treatment, and emergency contraception. While Planned Parenthood health centers have been offering these services on an affordable and sliding scale, cash-pay basis for several years, current policies prevent Planned Parenthood from offering these services using asynchronous telehealth modalities to Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients. Restricting how Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients access health care services, especially when those restrictions do not exist for commercial patients, only exacerbates health care disparities. Cosponsor National Health Law Program writes that asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. Inequitable implementation of telehealth service delivery can actually worsen pre-existing health disparities, as people who lack reliable broadband or have low-tech literacy are more likely to have low incomes or lower levels of education. Comprehensive coverage of asynchronous telehealth in Medi-Cal is crucial to maximize patient flexibility and choice when seeking care.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Nurses Association writes that this bill would weaken the right to in-person health care for Medi-Cal recipients by allowing mobile phone application-based interactions to substitute for in-person care. They state that telehealth will jeopardize patient care by creating barriers to effective communication, inhibiting the formation of strong provider-patient relationships necessary to establish trust, and increasing the risk of diagnostic error due to the inability to perform physical assessments.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/21/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Friedman, Gabriel, Holden, Mathis, McCarty, Luz Rivas
Prepared by: Jen Flory / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/26/24 11:53:16
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2339 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2339
Author: Aguiar-Curry (D)
Introduced: 2/12/24
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/19/24
AYES: Roth, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/21/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Medi-Cal: telehealth
SOURCE: National Health Law Program
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
DIGEST:
This bill permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services or when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with requirements set by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “telehealth” as the mode of delivering health care services and public health via information and communication technologies to facilitate the diagnosis, consultation, treatment, education, care management, and self-management of a patient’s health care. [BPC §2290.5]
- Defines “asynchronous store and forward” as the transmission of a patient’s medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site. Defines “synchronous interaction” as a real-time interaction between a patient and a health care provider located at a distant site. [BPC §2290.5]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by the DHCS, under which low-income individuals are eligible for medical coverage. [Welfare & InstitionsWIC §14000, et seq.]
- Prohibits Medi-Cal providers from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal recipient via asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities except for visits provided by specified federally qualified health center or rural health center providers using asynchronous store and forward and audio-only synchronous interaction when services delivered through that interaction meet the applicable standard of care. [WIC §14132.725]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship via the use of audio-only synchronous interactions when the visit is related to sensitive services as defined in state law in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. Sensitive services includes all health care services related to mental or behavioral health, sexual and reproductive health, sexually transmitted infections, substance use disorder, gender affirming care, and intimate partner violence, HIV testing, including the related sensitive services that minors can consent to. [WIC §14132.725, CIV §56.05]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video, and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. [WIC §14132.725]
This bill:
- Permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services or when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
- Adds to the definition of “asynchronous store and forward” as used in the Medi-Cal program to also include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in 2022, she authored AB 32 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022) to expand access to telehealth services for all Californians. At the time, her intention was for Medi-Cal to cover telehealth services including mobile apps, which provide patient-initiated care that can be established through asynchronous messaging. These apps are particularly important for working Californians because they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, restrictive policies currently prohibit Medi-Cal coverage of certain telehealth services, even though private insurance plans cover these services. This bill would expand access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage.
- Telehealth in Medi-Cal. Medi-Cal’s telehealth policy was established pursuant to the Telemedicine Development Act of 1996 [SB 1665 (Thompson, Chapter 864, Statutes of 1996)] and updated in compliance with AB 415 (Logue, Chapter 547, Statutes of 2011), known as the Telehealth Advancement Act of 2011. In 2019, DHCS undertook a policy review process, following extensive stakeholder engagement and public comment, to inform policy refinement. The revised 2019 policy afforded flexibility to licensed providers to make clinically appropriate decisions regarding the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth modalities. The finalized policy was published in the Medi-Cal provider manual and disseminated to Medi-Cal managed care plans via an All Plan Letter. In 2020, due to the COVID-19 public health emergency, DHCS implemented additional broad flexibilities relative to telehealth modalities via blanket waivers and Disaster Relief state plan amendments. This enabled Medi-Cal’s health care delivery systems to meet the health care needs of Medi-Cal beneficiaries where in-person encounters were not recommended or available. Such expansions included expanding which providers could use telehealth, allowing telehealth to be used for new patients, allowing many services to be provided audio-only, expanding payment parity for telehealth services, waiving site limitations for federally qualified health centers and rural health centers, and expanding access through non-public technology platforms.
In 2021, several of these COVID-19 flexibilities were extended via budget trailer bill AB 133 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021), along with a requirement for DHCS to convene a Telehealth Advisory Workgroup to inform the development of telehealth policies beyond the public health emergency. One outcome of the workgroup was a policy paper published by DHCS making a number of telehealth policy recommendations, many of which were subsequently incorporated into SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022), including the existing requirements on the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth both generally and when establishing a new patient relationship.
While California Medi-Cal telehealth policy is broad, it is more restrictive on the use of asynchronous telehealth (also known as “store and forward”), particularly in the establishment of new patient relationships, where it is prohibited. Despite California’s otherwise expansive Medi-Cal telehealth coverage and reimbursement policies, according to a September 2023 California Health Care Foundation Report on telehealth use experiences, people on Medi-Cal use less telehealth than people with other forms of health coverage. Those who do use telehealth tend to like it as much or better than in-person care.
- Expansion of asynchronous telehealth in reproductive health services. The use of asynchronous telehealth has become more popular particularly for sensitive services such as reproductive health services. According to a 2019 issue brief by the Kaiser Family Foundation, telemedicine’s use in reproductive health care has shown promise in offering innovative solutions to unmet health needs, particularly in areas with few health care providers. While long acting reversible contraceptives require in-person care, providers can prescribe a variety of other contraceptive methods via telemedicine, including oral contraceptives. As of June 2019, 14 online platforms existed that all determined eligibility and prescribed oral contraceptives in the same manner:
- Using a smartphone or computer, the patient provides a health history via a questionnaire (asynchronous) or video consultation (synchronous) with a clinician.
- The clinician reviews the information remotely and determines eligibility for oral contraceptives. The provider may be a doctor, nurse practitioner, physician assistant or certified nurse midwife, often depending on state law.
- The patient receives the oral contraceptives by pharmacy pick-up or mail. Prescriptions are valid for three to 12 months, with up to a 12 month supply at a time, depending on the platform and insurance provider.
The report states that almost all risk factors precluding use of hormonal birth control can be assessed online; and evaluations screen for age, smoking history, and conditions posing significant health risks, including clotting disorders, heart disease, breast cancer, and migraines with aura. These platforms cannot measure blood pressure, typically a necessity before initiating oral contraceptives, but most require the user input a reading from the last year; a method deemed acceptable by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) if a provider cannot measure the blood pressure. The report cited a 2019 New England Journal of Medicine study of telecontraception, defined as the provision of contraception through a website or smartphone app, that found higher adherence to CDC guidelines by telehealth providers than in-person providers did, though many of the telehealth providers did not inform patients of the availability of long-acting reversible contraceptive methods. Since 2019, the use of asynchronous telehealth for reproductive services has expanded significantly. Other reproductive health services provided via asynchronous telehealth include urinary tract infection treatment, emergency contraception, medication abortion, testing or treatment for selected sexually transmitted diseases (often with mail-in, self-collected samples), treatment for symptoms related to perimenopause or menopause, and treatment for erectile dysfunction.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/28/24)
National Health Law Program (co-source)
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California (co-source)
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
American Telemedicine Association Action
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Legislative Women’s Caucus
California Podiatric Medical Association
California Society of Health System Pharmacists
Elderly Care Everywhere
Equality California
Hims and Hers
Ochin, Inc.
Reproductive Freedom for All
Teladoc Health, Inc.
The Council of Autism Service Providers
1 individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/28/24)
California Nurses Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Co-sponsor Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California write that their affiliates proudly offer asynchronous telehealth services for oral contraceptives, urinary tract infection treatment, and emergency contraception. While Planned Parenthood health centers have been offering these services on an affordable and sliding-scale cash-pay basis for several years, current policies prevent Planned Parenthood from offering these services using asynchronous telehealth modalities to Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients. Restricting how Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients access health care services, especially when those restrictions do not exist for commercial patients, only exacerbates health care disparities. Cosponsor National Health Law Program writes that asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. Inequitable implementation of telehealth service delivery can actually worsen pre-existing health disparities, as people who lack reliable broadband or have low-tech literacy are more likely to have low incomes or lower levels of education. Comprehensive coverage of asynchronous telehealth in Medi-Cal is crucial to maximize patient flexibility and choice when seeking care.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Nurses Association writes that this bill would weaken the right to in-person health care for Medi-Cal recipients by allowing mobile phone application-based interactions to substitute for in-person care. They state that telehealth will jeopardize patient care by creating barriers to effective communication, inhibiting the formation of strong provider-patient relationships necessary to establish trust, and increasing the risk of diagnostic error due to the inability to perform physical assessments.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 71-0, 5/21/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Friedman, Gabriel, Holden, Mathis, McCarty, Luz Rivas
Prepared by: Jen Flory / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
7/2/24 9:32:00
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
BILL NO: AB 2339
AUTHOR: | Aguiar-Curry | ||
VERSION: | February 12, 2024 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 19, 2024 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Jen Flory | ||
SUBJECT: Medi-Cal: telehealth.
SUMMARY:
- Permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services or when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with requirements set by the Department of Health Care Services and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
Existing law:
- Defines “telehealth” as the mode of delivering health care services and public health via information and communication technologies to facilitate the diagnosis, consultation, treatment, education, care management, and self-management of a patient’s health care. [BPC §2290.5]
- Defines “asynchronous store and forward” as the transmission of a patient’s medical information from an originating site to the health care provider at a distant site. Defines “synchronous interaction” as a real-time interaction between a patient and a health care provider located at a distant site. [BPC §2290.5]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), under which low-income individuals are eligible for medical coverage. [WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Prohibits Medi-Cal providers from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal recipient via asynchronous store and forward, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other virtual communication modalities except for visits provided by specified federally qualified health center or rural health center providers using asynchronous store and forward and audio-only synchronous interaction when services delivered through that interaction meet the applicable standard of care. [WIC §14132.725]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship via the use of audio-only synchronous interactions when the visit is related to sensitive services as defined in state law in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. Sensitive services includes all health care services related to mental or behavioral health, sexual and reproductive health, sexually transmitted infections, substance use disorder, gender affirming care, and intimate partner violence, HIV testing, including the related sensitive services that minors can consent to. [WIC §14132.725, CIV §56.05]
- Permits Medi-Cal providers to establish a new patient relationship using an audio-only synchronous interaction when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video, and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance. [WIC §14132.725]
This bill:
- Permits a Medi-Cal provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward when the visit is related to sensitive services or when the patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality and when established in accordance with DHCS-specific requirements and consistent with federal and state laws, regulations, and guidance.
- Adds to the definition of “asynchronous store and forward” as used in the Medi-Cal program to also include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill has ongoing costs of an unknown amount, but likely exceeding $150,000 per year, to DHCS (General Fund, federal funds).
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 71 - 0 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 15 - 0 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 15 - 0 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in 2022, she authored AB 32 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022) to expand access to telehealth services for all Californians. At the time, her intention was for Medi-Cal to cover telehealth services including mobile apps, which provide patient-initiated care that can be established through asynchronous messaging. These apps are particularly important for working Californians because they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, restrictive policies currently prohibit Medi-Cal coverage of certain telehealth services, even though private insurance plans cover these services. This bill would expand access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage.
- Telehealth in Medi-Cal. Medi-Cal’s telehealth policy was established pursuant to the Telemedicine Development Act of 1996 [SB 1665 (Thompson, Chapter 864, Statutes of 1996)] and updated in compliance with AB 415 (Logue, Chapter 547, Statutes of 2011), known as the Telehealth Advancement Act of 2011. In 2019, DHCS undertook a policy review process, following extensive stakeholder engagement and public comment, to inform policy refinement. The revised 2019 policy afforded flexibility to licensed providers to make clinically appropriate decisions regarding the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth modalities. The finalized policy was published in the Medi-Cal provider manual and disseminated to Medi-Cal managed care plans via an All Plan Letter. In 2020, due to the COVID-19 public health emergency, DHCS implemented additional broad flexibilities relative to telehealth modalities via blanket waivers and Disaster Relief state plan amendments. This enabled Medi-Cal’s health care delivery systems to meet the health care needs of Medi-Cal beneficiaries where in-person encounters were not recommended or available. Such expansions included expanding which providers could use telehealth, allowing telehealth to be used for new patients, allowing many services to be provided audio-only, expanding payment parity for telehealth services, waiving site limitations for federally qualified health centers and rural health centers, and expanding access through non-public technology platforms.
In 2021, several of these COVID-19 flexibilities were extended via budget trailer bill AB 133 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021), along with a requirement for DHCS to convene a Telehealth Advisory Workgroup to inform the development of telehealth policies beyond the public health emergency. One outcome of the workgroup was a policy paper published by DHCS making a number of telehealth policy recommendations, many of which were subsequently incorporated into SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022), including the existing requirements on the use of synchronous and asynchronous telehealth both generally and when establishing a new patient relationship.
While California Medi-Cal telehealth policy is broad, it is more restrictive on the use of asynchronous telehealth (also known as “store and forward”), particularly in the establishment of new patient relationships, where it is prohibited. Despite California’s otherwise expansive Medi-Cal telehealth coverage and reimbursement policies, according to a September 2023 California Health Care Foundation Report on telehealth use experiences, people on Medi-Cal use less telehealth than people with other forms of health coverage. Those who do use telehealth tend to like it as much or better than in-person care.
- Expansion of asynchronous telehealth in reproductive health services. The use of asynchronous telehealth has become more popular particularly for sensitive services such as reproductive health services. According to a 2019 issue brief by the Kaiser Family Foundation, telemedicine’s use in reproductive health care has shown promise in offering innovative solutions to unmet health needs, particularly in areas with few health care providers. While long acting reversible contraceptives require in-person care, providers can prescribe a variety of other contraceptive methods via telemedicine, including oral contraceptives. As of June 2019, 14 online platforms existed that all determined eligibility and prescribed oral contraceptives in the same manner:
- Using a smartphone or computer, the patient provides a health history via a questionnaire (asynchronous) or video consultation (synchronous) with a clinician.
- The clinician reviews the information remotely and determines eligibility for oral contraceptives. The provider may be a doctor, nurse practitioner, physician assistant or certified nurse midwife, often depending on state law.
- The patient receives the oral contraceptives by pharmacy pick-up or mail. Prescriptions are valid for three to 12 months, with up to a 12 month supply at a time, depending on the platform and insurance provider.
The report states that almost all risk factors precluding use of hormonal birth control can be assessed online; and evaluations screen for age, smoking history, and conditions posing significant health risks, including clotting disorders, heart disease, breast cancer, and migraines with aura. These platforms cannot measure blood pressure, typically a necessity before initiating oral contraceptives, but most require the user input a reading from the last year; a method deemed acceptable by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) if a provider cannot measure the blood pressure. The report cited a 2019 New England Journal of Medicine study of telecontraception, defined as the provision of contraception through a website or smartphone app, that found higher adherence to CDC guidelines by telehealth providers than in-person providers did, though many of the telehealth providers did not inform patients of the availability of long-acting reversible contraceptive methods. Since 2019, the use of asynchronous telehealth for reproductive services has expanded significantly. Other reproductive health services provided via asynchronous telehealth include urinary tract infection treatment, emergency contraception, medication abortion, testing or treatment for selected sexually transmitted diseases (often with mail-in, self-collected samples), treatment for symptoms related to perimenopause or menopause, and treatment for erectile dysfunction.
- Related legislation. AB 1943 (Weber) requires DHCS to use Medi-Cal data and other data sources available to DHCS, to produce a public report on telehealth in the Medi-Cal program covering issues of access, utilization, quality of care, clinical outcomes, and preventive care. AB 1943 is set for hearing on June 17, 2024 in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- Prior legislation. AB 1241 (Weber, Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023) clarifies that Medi-Cal providers of telehealth services are not required to schedule an appointment with a different provider in order to meet the requirement in existing law that they facilitate in-person care.
SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022) among other provisions, prohibits face-to-face requirements for Medi-Cal services provided by video synchronous interaction, audio-only synchronous interaction, remote patient monitoring, or other permissible virtual communication modalities when those services and settings meet certain criteria. SB 184 requires providers to also offer services in person or arrange for a referral to in-person care and authorizes providers to establish patient relationships via video synchronous interaction.
AB 32 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022) permits DHCS to allow new patients to be established with health care providers in the Medi-Cal program using audio-only synchronous and other telehealth modalities.
AB 133 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021) among other provisions, extended, until December 31, 2022, flexibilities in reimbursement for care provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries via telehealth, including through audio-only modalities, implemented during the COVID-19 public health emergency, and required DHCS to convene a Telehealth Advisory Workgroup.
- Support. Cosponsor Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California write that their affiliates proudly offer asynchronous telehealth services for oral contraceptives, urinary tract infection treatment, and emergency contraception. While Planned Parenthood health centers have been offering these services on an affordable and sliding-scale cash-pay basis for several years, current policies prevent Planned Parenthood from offering these services using asynchronous telehealth modalities to Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients. Restricting how Medi-Cal and Family PACT patients access health care services, especially when those restrictions do not exist for commercial patients, only exacerbates health care disparities. Cosponsor National Health Law Program writes that asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. Inequitable implementation of telehealth service delivery can actually worsen pre-existing health disparities, as people who lack reliable broadband or have low tech literacy are more likely to have low incomes or lower levels of education. Comprehensive coverage of asynchronous telehealth in Medi-Cal is crucial to maximize patient flexibility and choice when seeking care.
- Opposition. The California Nurses Association writes that this bill would weaken the right to in-person health care for Medi-Cal recipients by allowing mobile phone application-based interactions to substitute for in-person care. They state that telehealth will jeopardize patient care by creating barriers to effective communication, inhibiting the formation of strong provider-patient relationships necessary to establish trust, and increasing the risk of diagnostic error due to the inability to perform physical assessments.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California (cosponsor)
National Health Law Program (cosponsor)
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
American Telemedicine Association Action
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Legislative Women’s Caucus
California Podiatric Medical Association
California Society of Health System Pharmacists
Elderly Care Everywhere
Equality California
Hims and Hers
Ochin, Inc.
Reproductive Freedom for All
Teladoc Health, Inc.
The Council of Autism Service Providers
One individual
Oppose: California Nurses Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2339
Author:(Aguiar-Curry)
As Introduced Ver:February 12, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the situations in which health care providers can be reimbursed by Medi-Cal for services rendered to patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
- Telehealth. Telehealth is a mode of delivering health care services remotely using information technology. The three primary modalities are video, audio (including telephone), and asynchronous store and forward, which can be used when a real-time interaction is not needed. A large body of research supports the use of telehealth for a range of health care services, although the available evidence is mostly discipline-specific. Telehealth has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with chronic conditions and behavioral health needs. According to the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), from the beneficiary perspective, telehealth can improve access to care and enhance satisfaction by making care more convenient and reducing some of the logistical burdens of seeking in-person care.
Telehealth utilization in Medi-Cal increased dramatically in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Long-term utilization trends are unclear, but telehealth appears likely to remain much more prevalent than it was prior to COVID-19.
- Recent History of Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy Development. Prior to the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), DHCS had expanded the availability of telehealth in Medi-Cal by allowing most clinically appropriate services to be provided through telehealth. During the PHE, DHCS implemented additional telehealth flexibilities to allow Medi-Cal providers to meet the health care needs of enrollees. After significant stakeholder engagement and legislative agreement on final trailer bill language, post-PHE Medi-Cal telehealth policies were codified through the 2022-23 health trailer bill, SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022. Subsequently, AB 32 (Aguilar-Curry), Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022, and AB 1241 (Weber), Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023, made minor and clarifying changes to telehealth policy. These post-PHE policies permanently maintained many flexibilities granted during the PHE.
- Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy. According to DHCS, California has been a leading state in the expansiveness of its coverage and reimbursement for services delivered via telehealth. DHCS has committed to continuing to enable broad telehealth coverage for all Medi-Cal covered benefits and services, as long as the provider is able to meet the standard of care, subject to billing, reimbursement and utilization management policies developed by DHCS. In addition, DHCS notes Medi-Cal is unique among other state Medicaid programs in regard to payment parity, in that the state reimburses a broad array of services at parity when delivered via audio-only visits.
- Establishment of New Patients via Telehealth. A health care provider may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via video. Pursuant to AB 32, a provider also may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via audio-only telehealth (e.g., phone or other audio device), but only under certain circumstances. These circumstances include when the visit is related to "sensitive services," including behavioral health and reproductive health services, or when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. Additional exceptions may be made by DHCS in consultation with stakeholders. This bill would apply similar reimbursement rules to the establishment of new patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
According to the DHCS Post-COVID-19 PHE Final Telehealth Policy Proposal published in 2022, the rationale for the policy related to new patients is to increase access to care by allowing the establishment of new patients via telehealth while supporting consumer protections. The restrictions address concerns that initial visits may require a higher level of two-way communication to ensure quality of care. However, stakeholders have raised various scenarios where synchronous communication may not be critical to care for a new patient or where timely access concerns outweigh the potential benefit of synchronous communication—for instance, for a patient seeking emergency contraception. As noted above, statute allows DHCS to make exceptions to these policies in consultation with stakeholders.
- Effect of This Bill: This bill would essentially make such an exception to current policy that restricts the establishment of new patients via telehealth, expanding the circumstances under which a health care provider may bill for an asynchronous encounter with a new patient. Specifically, this bill would allow asynchronous store and forward to be used for new patient visits when a visit is related to "sensitive services" or when a patient requests one. It would also include, in the definition of asynchronous store and forward, electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications ("apps"). According to the bill's sponsors, this is important because it allows Medi-Cal patients to access asynchronous services through apps, often the same apps used for synchronous telehealth services.
According to the Author
In 2022, AB 32 expanded access to telehealth services and was intended to facilitate Medi-Cal coverage of telehealth services through mobile apps. The author indicates these apps are particularly important for working Californians so they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, the author states that Medi-Cal coverage is more restrictive than private insurance plans, which already cover these services. The author contends that this bill will ensure state policy supports expanded access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage. Planned Parenthood of California (PPAC) is the bill's sponsor.
Arguments in Support
PPAC argues asynchronous care delivery can alleviate access barriers associated with synchronous telehealth, including technological barriers, scheduling constraints, and privacy concerns. The Council of Autism Service Providers writes in support that research demonstrates the effectiveness of telehealth in Applied Behavior Analysis, and telehealth may be used to establish new patients or conduct portions of an initial assessment.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Nurses Association (CNA) writes in opposition to this bill's expansion of the use of telehealth to include mobile apps, arguing such tools are an unacceptable substitute for in-person care. CNA writes that nurses understand that mobile apps can never replace the in-person care that nurses and other health care workers provide, especially for the vulnerable populations Medi-Cal serves. CNA also objects to features of telehealth that it contends jeopardize patient care, such as limiting patient-provider communication, which would be particularly problematic when delivered through an app.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to Assembly Appropriations:
Ongoing costs of an unknown amount, but likely exceeding $150,000 per year, to DHCS (General Fund, federal funds).
According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 15-0-1
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: February 12, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lisa Murawski / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0003130
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2339
Author:(Aguiar-Curry) – As Introduced Ver:February 12, 2024
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 15 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the situations in which Medi-Cal may reimburse a health care provider for services rendered to patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward telehealth when the visit is otherwise consistent with Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) guidance and other requirements, and either (a) the patient requests this modality, or (b) the visit is related to sensitive services.
- Redefines “asynchronous store and forward” to include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Ongoing costs of an unknown amount, but likely exceeding $150,000 per year, to DHCS (General Fund, federal funds).
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California and the National Health Law Program. According to the author:
In 2022, I authored AB 32 (Aguiar-Curry), Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022 to expand access to telehealth services for all Californians. At the time, my intention was for Medi-Cal to cover telehealth services including mobile apps, which provide patient-initiated care that can be established through asynchronous messaging. These apps are particularly important for working Californians because they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, restrictive policies currently prohibit Medi-Cal coverage of certain telehealth services, even though private insurance plans cover these services. This bill would expand access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage.
- Budget Request. The author submitted a request for funding through the state budget for the implementation of this bill; however, the request did not specify an amount.
- Background.
Telehealth. Telehealth is a mode of delivering health care services remotely using information technology. The three primary modalities are video, audio (including telephone), and asynchronous store and forward, which can be used when a real-time interaction is not needed. A large body of research supports the use of telehealth for a range of health care services. Telehealth has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with chronic conditions and behavioral health needs. According to DHCS, telehealth can improve a beneficiary’s access to care and enhance satisfaction by making care more convenient and reducing some of the logistical burdens of seeking in-person care.
Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy. Prior to the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), DHCS had expanded the availability of telehealth in Medi-Cal by allowing most services to be provided through telehealth if clinically appropriate. During the PHE, DHCS implemented additional telehealth flexibilities. SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022, the 2022-23 health trailer bill, codified post-PHE Medi-Cal telehealth policies. Subsequently, AB 32 and AB 1241 (Weber), Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023, made minor and clarifying changes to telehealth policy.
Establishment of New Patients via Telehealth. DHCS allows a health care provider to bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient when the visit is conducted via video. Medi-Cal also allows a provider to bill for a new patient visit conducted via audio-only telehealth only under certain circumstances, such as when the visit is related to “sensitive services,” including behavioral health and reproductive health services, or when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. This bill would allow a provider to bill for a new patient visit conducted through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
- Opposition. The California Nurses Association opposes this bill’s expansion of the use of telehealth to include mobile apps, arguing such tools are an unacceptable substitute for in-person care, especially for the vulnerable populations Medi-Cal serves, among other objections.
- Related Legislation. AB 1943 (Weber) requires DHCS, in collaboration with the California Health and Human Services Agency, to collect specified data on telehealth access and health outcomes, and use the data to measure the health outcomes of populations using a specified list of determinants. AB 1943 is pending in the Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2339
Author:((Aguiar-Curry) – As Introduced Ver:February 12, 2024
SUBJECT: Medi-Cal: telehealth.
SUMMARY: Expands the situations in which health care providers can be reimbursed by Medi-Cal for services rendered to patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a health care provider to establish a new patient relationship using asynchronous store and forward telehealth when otherwise consistent with Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) guidance, and either one of the following is true:
- The visit is related to sensitive services; or,
- A patient requests an asynchronous store and forward modality.
- Redefines “asynchronous store and forward” to include asynchronous electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications.
- Removes the option whereby a patient can attest they do not have access to video, in order to establish the need for an audio-only visit for a new patient.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “telehealth” to:
- Mean the mode of delivering health care services and public health via information and communication technologies to facilitate the diagnosis, consultation, treatment, education, care management, and self-management of a patient’s health care; and,
- Include synchronous interactions and asynchronous store and forward transfers. [Business and Professions Code § 2290.5 (a)(6)]
- Establishes the Medi-Cal Program, administered by DHCS, to provide comprehensive health benefits to low-income individuals who meet specified eligibility criteria. [Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) §14000 et seq.]
- Establishes a schedule of benefits under the Medi-Cal program. [WIC §14132]
- Establishes Medi-Cal coverage for health care services provided through telehealth, including specifying that in-person, face-to-face contact between a health care provider and a patient is not required under the Medi-Cal program for covered health care services and provider types designated by DHCS, when those services and settings meet the applicable standard of care and meet the requirements of the service code being billed. [WIC §14132.725 and §14132.100]
- Prohibits a health care provider from establishing a new patient relationship with a Medi-Cal beneficiary via telehealth modalities other than video, except as follows:
- When exceptions are developed by DHCS in consultation with affected stakeholders and published in DHCS guidance.
- When a visit is conducted through an audio-only synchronous interaction and is otherwise consistent with DHCS guidance, and either one of the following is true:
- The visit is related to sensitive services; or,
- A patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. [WIC §14132.725]
- Defines “sensitive services” to include health care services related to mental or behavioral health, pregnancy, sexual and reproductive health, sexually transmitted infections, substance use disorder, gender affirming care, and intimate partner violence, and also includes health care services minors may independently consent to receive [Civil Code §56.05]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, in 2022, AB 32 (Aguilar-Curry), Chapter 515, Statutes of 2022, expanded access to telehealth services and was intended to facilitate Medi-Cal coverage of telehealth services through mobile apps. The author indicates these apps are particularly important for working Californians because they can get medical care on their own schedule, without having to take time away from work and their families. However, the author states that Medi-Cal coverage is more restrictive than private insurance plans, which already cover these services. The author contends that this bill will ensure state policy supports expanded access to app-based telehealth services for Californians on Medi-Cal, who need accessible, convenient care regardless of their insurance coverage. Planned Parenthood of California is the bill’s sponsor.
- BACKGROUND.
- Telehealth. Telehealth is a mode of delivering health care services remotely using information technology. The three primary modalities are video, audio (including telephone), and asynchronous store and forward, which can be used when a real-time interaction is not needed. A large body of research supports the use of telehealth for a range of health care services, although the available evidence is mostly discipline-specific. Telehealth has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with chronic conditions and behavioral health needs. According to DHCS, from the beneficiary perspective, telehealth can improve access to care and enhance satisfaction by making care more convenient and reducing some of the logistical burdens of seeking in-person care.
- Trends in Telehealth Utilization. Telehealth utilization in Medi-Cal increased dramatically in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. According to data published by DHCS, prior to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, telehealth represented around 300 claims per 100,000 Medi-Cal member months. By April 2020, telehealth claims increased to over 12,000 claims per 100,000 member months and remained relatively stable through March 2021. Following March 2021, telehealth claims per 100,000 member months remained significantly higher than pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels but declined from the peak to around 7,700 claims per 100,000 member months. Similarly, according to an October 2023 analysis by the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, “Telehealth and the Future of Health Care Access in California,” about half (49%) of California adults reported using telehealth to seek care in 2021, and decreased to 46.7% in 2022. Overall, the report notes telehealth remained a popular way to access care, even after declining from utilization levels seen during the pandemic. Long-term utilization trends are unclear, but telehealth appears likely to remain much more prevalent than it was prior to COVID-19.
- Recent History of Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy Development. Prior to the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), DHCS had expanded the availability of telehealth in Medi-Cal by allowing most clinically appropriate services to be provided through telehealth. During the PHE, DHCS implemented additional telehealth flexibilities to allow Medi-Cal providers to meet the health care needs of enrollees. After significant stakeholder engagement and legislative agreement on final trailer bill language, post-PHE Medi-Cal telehealth policies were codified through the 2022-23 health trailer bill, SB 184 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 47, Statutes of 2022. Subsequently, AB 32 and AB 1241 (Weber), Chapter 172, Statutes of 2023, made minor and clarifying changes to telehealth policy. These post-PHE policies permanently maintained many flexibilities granted during the PHE.
- Medi-Cal Telehealth Policy. According to DHCS, California has been a leading state in the expansiveness of its coverage and reimbursement for services delivered via telehealth. DHCS has committed to continuing to enable broad telehealth coverage for all Medi-Cal covered benefits and services, as long as the provider is able to meet the standard of care, subject to billing, reimbursement and utilization management policies developed by DHCS. In addition, DHCS notes Medi-Cal is unique among other state Medicaid programs in regard to payment parity, in that the state reimburses a broad array of services at parity when delivered via audio-only visits. General Medi-Cal telehealth policies are described below, while the policies related to establishment of new patients is discussed in the next section.
- Provider Requirements: A health care provider rendering Medi-Cal covered benefits and services via telehealth must be:
- Licensed in California or otherwise authorized by law; and,
- Enrolled as a Medi-Cal rendering provider or be a non-physician medical practitioner affiliated with an enrolled Medi-Cal provider group.
- Provider Requirements: A health care provider rendering Medi-Cal covered benefits and services via telehealth must be:
Unlicensed providers designated by DHCS, such as doulas, may provide services within their scope through telehealth, as specified in the Medi-Cal Provider Manual.
- Telehealth Covered Services: Telehealth services are reimbursable if the health care provider believes that the service being provided is clinically appropriate. The telehealth service must meet the procedural definition of the Current Procedural Terminology or Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System code associated with the service, as well as follow any additional guidance provided by DHCS (e.g., through the Medi-Cal Provider Manual).
- Telehealth Covered Modalities: Medi-Cal reimburses for telehealth visits conducted via audio-only telehealth (e.g., telephone), video telehealth, or through asynchronous telehealth (i.e., store and forward and e-consults).
- Telehealth Payment Parity: The amount paid by Medi-Cal, through both fee-for-service and Medi-Cal managed care plans, for a service rendered via any telehealth modality is the same as the amount paid for the applicable service when rendered in-person.
- Telehealth Modifiers: Providers must designate telehealth modality with an appropriate modifier when billing for telehealth services.
- Patient Consent. A health care provider must inform the patient once prior to the initial delivery of telehealth services about the use of telehealth and obtain verbal or written consent from the patient for the use of telehealth as an acceptable mode of delivering health care services. Statute specifies information that must be shared with a patient.
Statute also establishes two policies that are not currently implemented, which will be implemented no sooner than January 1, 2024.
- Patient Choice of Telehealth Modality: No sooner than January 1, 2024, DHCS will phase in an approach that requires a provider offer both video and audio-only telehealth to ensure patients have their choice of telehealth modality. DHCS is developing guidance on exceptions to this requirement, to include exceptions based on a Medi-Cal provider’s lack of access to adequate broadband speeds to effectively stream video.
- Patient Right to In-Person Services: No sooner than January 1, 2024, DHCS will phase in an approach where providers who offer services via telehealth will be required to either offer those same services in-person or arrange for a referral to, and a facilitation of, in-person care that does not require a patient to independently contact a different provider to arrange for that care.
- Establishment of New Patients via Telehealth. According to DHCS policy, a health care provider may bill Medi-Cal for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via video. Pursuant to AB 32, Medi-Cal also allows a provider to bill for a visit with a new patient that is conducted via audio-only telehealth (e.g., phone or other audio device), but only under certain circumstances. These circumstances include when the visit is related to “sensitive services,” including behavioral health and reproductive health services, or when the patient requests an audio-only modality or attests they do not have access to video. Additional exceptions may be made by DHCS in consultation with stakeholders. This bill would apply similar reimbursement rules to the establishment of new patients through asynchronous store and forward telehealth.
According to the DHCS Post-COVID-19 PHE Final Telehealth Policy Proposal published in 2022, the rationale for the policy related to new patients is to increase access to care by allowing the establishment of new patients via telehealth while supporting consumer protections. The restrictions address concerns that initial visits may require a higher level of two-way communication to ensure quality of care. However, stakeholders have raised various scenarios where synchronous communication may not be critical to care for a new patient or where timely access concerns outweigh the potential benefit of synchronous communication—for instance, for a patient seeking emergency contraception. As noted above, statute allows DHCS to make exceptions to these policies in consultation with stakeholders. - Effect of This Bill: This bill would essentially make such an exception to current policy that restricts the establishment of new patients via telehealth, expanding the circumstances under which a health care provider may bill for an asynchronous encounter with a new patient. Specifically:
- This bill would allow asynchronous store and forward to be used for new patient visits when a visit is related to “sensitive services” or when a patient requests one. The author and sponsor explain this exception is needed to reduce barriers to care for patients who may not have an existing relationship with a provider and who may struggle to arrange an audio or video visit. For instance, patients commonly reach out to a provider outside of their normal source of care for birth control, emergency contraception, and urinary tract infection treatment.
- This bill also includes, in the definition of asynchronous store and forward, electronic transmission initiated directly by patients, including through mobile telephone applications (“apps”). According to the bill’s sponsors, this is important to allow for Medi-Cal patients to be able to access asynchronous services from Medi-Cal providers through apps, often the same apps used for synchronous telehealth services.
- As it relates to audio-only, this bill also removes the option whereby a patient can attest they do not have access to video, in order to establish the need for an audio-only visit for a new patient. The author and sponsor explain this as expanding access to care, but this change is technically slightly more limiting than current law. However, from a practical standpoint, the ability for a patient to request the new patient visit through audio-only telehealth already exists and arguably is adequate to allow these visits to occur, regardless of the deletion of the option to attest that they do not have video.
- SUPPORT. The Council of Autism Service Providers (CASP) writes in support that research demonstrates the effectiveness of telehealth in Applied Behavior Analysis, and telehealth may be used to establish new patients or conduct portions of an initial assessment. OCHIN, Inc. writes in support that many patients in the clinics to which they offer technological support must overcome social drivers of health, and the varied telehealth modalities (synchronous and asynchronous) have been essential tools for expanding access.
- OPPOSITION. The California Nurses Association (CNA) writes in opposition to this bill’s expansion of the use of telehealth to include mobile apps, arguing such tools are an unacceptable substitute for in-person care. CNA writes that nurses understand that mobile apps can never replace the in-person care that nurses and other health care workers provide, especially for the vulnerable populations Medi-Cal serves. CNA also objects to features of telehealth that it contends jeopardize patient care, which would be particularly problematic when delivered through an app. These include barriers to effective communication, inhibiting the formation of strong provider-patient relationship necessary to establish trust, and increased risk of diagnostic error due to inability to perform physical assessments. CNA asserts California must not steer Medi-Cal patients toward substandard care because such care will exacerbate health inequities, and that this bill is unnecessary because current law already accounts for establishment of new patients through audio-only telehealth.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. AB 1943 (Weber) requires DHCS, in collaboration with the California Health and Human Services Agency, to collect specified data on telehealth access and individual and population health outcomes, and use the data to measure the health outcomes of populations using a specified list of determinants. AB 1943 is pending in this Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 1241 clarifies two provisions of current law requiring a provider furnishing services through video or audio telehealth to offer services in-person or facilitate in-person care.
- AB 32 establishes Medi-Cal coverage for establishment of new patients through audio telehealth under specified circumstances, including for reproductive health and behavioral health services, and clarified DHCS shall consider a Medi-Cal provider’s access to broadband at specified speeds, in establishing exceptions to the requirement that providers offering audio-only telehealth also offer video telehealth.
- SB 184 establishes Medi-Cal telehealth policy, including coverage, reimbursement patient consent standards, informational notices, DHCS authority to designate providers who may provide services through telehealth, treatment of telehealth for network adequacy purposes and a research and evaluation plan.
- AB 133 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021, extended until December 31, 2022, flexibilities in reimbursement for care provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries via telehealth, implemented during the COVID-19 PHE and required DHCS to convene a telehealth advisory workgroup, as specified.
- AB 457 (Santiago), Chapter 439, Statutes of 2021, established requirements on health plans and health insurers intended to ensure care offered through third-party telehealth providers remain coordinated with a patient’s primary care providers.
- AB 1022 (Mathis) of 2022 would have expanded the ability of an approved Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly organization, which provides Medi-Cal and Medicare services, authority to use video telehealth to conduct all assessments, as specified. AB 1022 was referred to the Assembly Health Committee and not heard.
- POLICY COMMENT. WIC §14132.100 establishes telehealth policy for federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) and rural health clinics (RHCs), which is largely but not entirely consistent with Medi-Cal telehealth policy for other providers. The author may wish to engage with stakeholders and consider whether to similarly amend telehealth policy that applies to FQHCs/RHCs related to establishment of new patients through asynchronous store and forward, unless there is a specific reason to maintain the current restrictions for these clinics. Those current restrictions that apply to FQHCs/RHCs are different but appear slightly more restrictive than that proposed by this bill.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California (sponsor)
National Health Law Program (cosponsor)
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, District IX
ATA Action
California Telehealth Policy Coalition
Equality California
OCHIN, Inc.
Reproductive Freedom for All
The Council of Autism Service Providers
Opposition
California Nurses Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):