AB 2355: Political Reform Act of 1974: political advertisements: artificial intelligence.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-17
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-17: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 260, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, requires certain advertisements to contain specified disclosures. The Fair Political Practices Commission is charged with administering and implementing the act, and may, when it determines a violation has occurred, bring an administrative action and issue an order requiring the violator to cease and desist the violation, file specified documents, or pay a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. The commission may also, in certain instances, bring a civil action against any person who violates any provision of the act.
This bill would require a committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would prescribe formatting requirements for this disclosure depending on the medium of the qualified political advertisement. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any advertisement, as specified, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize the commission to enforce a violation of these disclosure requirements by seeking injunctive relief to compel compliance or pursuing any other administrative or civil remedies available to the commission under the act. The bill would specify that a violation of these disclosure requirements does not constitute a misdemeanor.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, requires certain advertisements to contain specified disclosures. The Fair Political Practices Commission is charged with administering and implementing the act, and may, when it determines a violation has occurred, bring an administrative action and issue an order requiring the violator to cease and desist the violation, file specified documents, or pay a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. The commission may also, in certain instances, bring a civil action against any person who violates any provision of the act.
This bill would require a committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would prescribe formatting requirements for this disclosure depending on the medium of the qualified political advertisement. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any advertisement, as specified, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize the commission to enforce a violation of these disclosure requirements by seeking injunctive relief to compel compliance or pursuing any other administrative or civil remedies available to the commission under the act. The bill would specify that a violation of these disclosure requirements does not constitute a misdemeanor.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, requires certain advertisements to contain specified disclosures. The Fair Political Practices Commission is charged with administering and implementing the act, and may, when it determines a violation has occurred, bring an administrative action and issue an order requiring the violator to cease and desist the violation, file specified documents, or pay a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. The commission may also, in certain instances, bring a civil action against any person who violates any provision of the act.
This bill would require a committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would prescribe formatting requirements for this disclosure depending on the medium of the qualified political advertisement. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any advertisement, as specified, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize the commission to enforce a violation of these disclosure requirements by seeking injunctive relief to compel compliance or pursuing any other administrative or civil remedies available to the commission under the act. The bill would specify that a violation of these disclosure requirements does not constitute a misdemeanor.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, requires certain advertisements to contain specified disclosures. The Fair Political Practices Commission is charged with administering and implementing the act, and may, when it determines a violation has occurred, bring an administrative action and issue an order requiring the violator to cease and desist the violation, file specified documents, or pay a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. The commission may also, in certain instances, bring a civil action against any person who violates any provision of the act.
This bill would require a committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any advertisement, as specified, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize the commission to enforce a violation of these disclosure requirements by seeking injunctive relief to compel compliance or pursuing any other administrative or civil remedies available to the commission under the act. The bill would specify that a violation of these disclosure requirements does not constitute a misdemeanor.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Existing law requires a paid political advertisement, as defined, that refers to an election or to any candidate for state or local elective office and that is contained or distributed with a newspaper to include the printed disclosure Paid Political Advertisement, as specified. Existing law, until January 1, 2027, prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from, except as specified, distributing, with actual malice, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate for elective office with the intent to injure the candidates reputation or to deceive the voter into voting for or against the candidate.This bill would require a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any paid advertisement, as specified, that relates to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize any registered voter to bring an action in superior court seeking a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that violates these disclosure requirements.Existing law requires a paid political advertisement, as defined, that refers to an election or to any candidate for state or local elective office and that is contained or distributed with a newspaper to include the printed disclosure Paid Political Advertisement, as specified. Existing law, until January 1, 2027, prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from, except as specified, distributing, with actual malice, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate for elective office with the intent to injure the candidates reputation or to deceive the voter into voting for or against the candidate.
This bill would require a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any paid advertisement, as specified, that relates to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize any registered voter to bring an action in superior court seeking a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that violates these disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires a paid political advertisement, as defined, that refers to an election or to any candidate for state or local elective office and that is contained or distributed with a newspaper to include the printed disclosure Paid Political Advertisement, as specified. Existing law, until January 1, 2027, prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from, except as specified, distributing, with actual malice, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate for elective office with the intent to injure the candidates reputation or to deceive the voter into voting for or against the candidate.
This bill would require a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any paid advertisement, as specified, that relates to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, or a bond issue, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence. The bill would specify that any image, audio, video, or other media is generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence if it is entirely created using artificial intelligence or materially altered by artificial intelligence such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version. The bill would authorize any registered voter to bring an action in superior court seeking a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that violates these disclosure requirements.
Existing law requires a paid political advertisement, as defined, that refers to an election or to any candidate for state or local elective office and that is contained or distributed with a newspaper to include the printed disclosure Paid Political Advertisement, as specified. Existing law, until January 1, 2027, prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from, except as specified, distributing, with actual malice, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate for elective office with the intent to injure the candidates reputation or to deceive the voter into voting for or against the candidate.
This bill would require a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement to include in the advertisement a specified disclosure that the advertisement was generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence, as defined. The bill would define qualified political advertisement to include any paid advertisement, as specified, that relates to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, a ballot measure, or a bond issue, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence. The bill would authorize any registered voter to bring an action in superior court seeking a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that violates these disclosure requirements.
(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated over the radio or by telephonic means shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement, read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, radio and prerecorded telephonic advertisements shall disclose only the top two contributors of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more unless the advertisement lasts 15 seconds or less or the disclosure statement would last more than eight seconds, in which case only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more shall be disclosed.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.1.(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated as a video, including advertisements on television and videos disseminated over the Internet, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement.
(b)The disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall be written and displayed for at least five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for at least 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(1)The written disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall appear on a solid black background on the entire bottom one-third of the television or video display screen, or bottom one-fourth of the screen if the committee does not have or is otherwise not required to list top contributors, and shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type, and the type size for capital letters in the written disclosure shall be 4 percent of the height or width of the television or video display advertisement, whichever is less.
(2)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall be white and appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen.
(3)The disclosures required by Section 84502 shall be white and shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, shall be yellow, such as HTML hex value #FFFF00, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Section 84502 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen. The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. All disclosure text shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area. If there are any top contributors, the written disclosures shall be underlined in a manner clearly visible to the average viewer, except for the names of the top contributors, if any.
(4)The names of the top contributors shall not have their type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(5)If the name of one or more top contributor exceeds the width of the screen and is required to wrap onto a second line, then the names of contributors shall be clearly marked, using a highly visible symbol or minimum vertical separation defined by the Commission, to indicate where one top contributor name ends and the next begins.
(c)An advertisement that is an independent expenditure supporting or opposing a candidate shall include the appropriate statement from Section 84506.5 printed immediately above the background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer.
(d)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
SEC. 3.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 5 of Chapter 777 of the Statutes of 2018, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in an Arial equivalent type with a type size of at least 10-point for printed advertisements designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, mailers, flyers, and door hangers.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(4)The disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed Arial equivalent type.
(6)A committee subject to Section 84506.5 shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert Commission Internet Website), which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text.
(b)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (5) of subdivision (a), the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 on a printed advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, yard signs or billboards, shall be in Arial equivalent type with a total height of at least 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and printed on a solid background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
SEC. 4.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 12 of Chapter 887 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a mailer, flyer, or door hanger, that is paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 10-point.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(4)The disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(6)An advertisement supporting or opposing a candidate that is paid for by an independent expenditure shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert link to Secretary of State internet website page with top 10 contributor lists], which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text at the bottom of the disclosure area.
(8)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the largest top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
(b)A print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a yard sign or billboard, paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures pursuant to Section 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 in a printed or drawn box with a solid white background on the bottom of the advertisement that is set apart from any other printed matter. Each line of the written disclosures shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type no less than 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and shall not be condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or provided by applicable law.
SEC. 5.Section 84504.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.3.(a)This section applies to an electronic media advertisement if either of the following is true:
(1)The advertisement is paid for by a committee other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate.
(2)The advertisement is paid for by a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and is either of the following:
(A)Paid for by an independent expenditure.
(B)An advertisement supporting or opposing a ballot measure.
(b)An electronic media advertisement that is a graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to link to an internet website paid for by a committee shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Unless the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) includes the full disclosure text required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, the advertisement shall contain a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 in a contrasting color and in no less than 11-point font.
(2)The advertisement shall include, for the duration of the advertisement, the disclosures required by Section 84514, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84502, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, displayed according to the following:
(A)The disclosure area shall have a solid white or black background and shall be in a box on the bottom of the advertisement. The text in the disclosure area shall be in a contrasting color and in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 11-point and shall not have its type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(B)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosure required by Section 84502 by a blank line.
(C)Notwithstanding Section 84503, the disclosure area may disclose only the largest top contributor to the committee paying for the advertisement, and the disclosure area may include the words Top Funder or Top Funders instead of Ad Committees Top Funders or Ad Committees Top Funder.
(D)The disclosure required by Section 84506.5 may be displayed at the bottom of the disclosure box, separated from the disclosures required by Section 84503 by a blank horizontal line. This text is not required to be displayed in the disclosure area if the advertisement hyperlinks to a website containing the disclosures as described by paragraph (1).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), if the image takes up fewer than 65,000 square pixels, i.e., is smaller than a standard 728 by 90 pixel leaderboard image advertisement, then the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) may instead include the text Who funded this ad?. This text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 8-point.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), the disclosure area required by paragraph (2) is not required if it would take up more than 10 percent of the graphic or image even using the Who funded this ad? option allowed by paragraph (3). In those circumstances, the advertisement need only include a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514.
(5)Any text or image not required by this subdivision shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), an email message or internet website paid for by a committee shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 printed clearly and legibly in a contrasting color and in no less than 8-point font at the top or bottom of the email message, or at the top or bottom of every publicly accessible page of the internet website, as applicable.
(d)An internet website that is linked as provided for in paragraphs (1) and (4) of subdivision (b) shall remain online and available to the public until 30 days after the date of the election in which the candidate or ballot measure supported or opposed by the advertisement was voted upon.
(e)An advertisement made via a form of electronic media that is audio only and therefore cannot include either of the disclosures in subdivision (b) shall comply with the disclosure requirements for radio advertisements in Section 84504.
(f)An electronic media advertisement that is disseminated as a video shall comply with the disclosure requirements of Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5, depending on the type of committee that paid for it. If the video is longer than 30 seconds, the disclosures required by Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5 shall be made at the beginning of the advertisement.
(g)An advertisement in the form of a post, comment, or similar communication made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, is not required to include the disclosure provided in subdivision (b) if both of the following apply:
(1)The advertisement was posted directly by the social media page or account of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)(A) The disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 are included on the cover or header photo of the committees profile, landing page, or similar location for the committees page or account from which the post, comment, or similar communication was made in a contrasting color that is easily readable by the average viewer and in no less than 10-point font. The disclosures specified in this subparagraph shall be fully visible on the cover or header photo when the profile, landing page, or similar location is viewed from any electronic device that is commonly used to view this form of electronic media, including, but not limited to, a computer screen, laptop, tablet, or smart phone.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if making the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A) fully visible on a commonly used electronic device would be impracticable, the cover or header photo of the profile, landing page, or similar location need only include a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab to an internet website containing the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A).
(h)The disclosures required by this section do not apply to advertisements made via social media for which the only expense or cost of the communication is compensated staff time unless the social media account where the content is posted was created only for the purpose of advertisements governed by this title.
SEC. 6.Section 84504.4 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.4.(a)A radio or television advertisement that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 and the disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, subject to the following requirements:
(1)In a radio advertisement, the words shall be included at the beginning or end of the advertisement and read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
(2)In a television advertisement, the words shall appear in writing for at least four seconds with letters in a type size that is greater than or equal to 4 percent of the height of the screen.
(b)An advertisement that is made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 in accordance with subdivision (g) of Section 84504.3.
SEC. 7.Section 84504.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.5.An advertisement that is an independent expenditure and paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84506.5, and 84514. An advertisement that supports or opposes a ballot measure and is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502. A disclosure that is included in an advertisement pursuant to this section is subject to the following requirements:
(a)A radio or telephone advertisement shall include the required disclosures at the beginning or end of the advertisement and be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)A video advertisement, including television and videos disseminated over the internet, shall include the required disclosures in writing at the beginning or end of the advertisement in a text that is of sufficient size to be readily legible to an average viewer and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement for at least four seconds. The required disclosure must also be spoken during the advertisement if the written disclosure appears for less than five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for less than 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(c)(1)A print advertisement shall include the required disclosures in no less than 10-point font and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), each line of the required disclosures on a print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, such as a yard sign or billboard, shall in total constitute no less than 5 percent of the total height of the advertisement and shall appear in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(d)An electronic media advertisement shall include the disclosures required by Section 84504.3.
SEC. 8.Section 84514 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 84513, to read:84514.(a)(1)If a committee, as defined in Section 82013, creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: Ad generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
(2)The disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be displayed or spoken in the manner prescribed in Section 84504, 84504.1, 84504.2, 84504.3, 84504.4, or 84504.5, as applicable.
(b)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(c)(1)If a committee does not comply with the requirements of subdivision (a), the Commission may take either of the following actions:
(A)Seek injunctive relief to compel compliance pursuant to Section 90009.
(B)Pursue any administrative or civil remedies available under Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 83100) or Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(2)A violation of subdivision (a) shall not constitute a misdemeanor under Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
(2)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(3)Qualified political advertisement means an advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
SEC. 9.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated over the radio or by telephonic means shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement, read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, radio and prerecorded telephonic advertisements shall disclose only the top two contributors of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more unless the advertisement lasts 15 seconds or less or the disclosure statement would last more than eight seconds, in which case only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more shall be disclosed.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.1.(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated as a video, including advertisements on television and videos disseminated over the Internet, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement.
(b)The disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall be written and displayed for at least five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for at least 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(1)The written disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall appear on a solid black background on the entire bottom one-third of the television or video display screen, or bottom one-fourth of the screen if the committee does not have or is otherwise not required to list top contributors, and shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type, and the type size for capital letters in the written disclosure shall be 4 percent of the height or width of the television or video display advertisement, whichever is less.
(2)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall be white and appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen.
(3)The disclosures required by Section 84502 shall be white and shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, shall be yellow, such as HTML hex value #FFFF00, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Section 84502 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen. The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. All disclosure text shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area. If there are any top contributors, the written disclosures shall be underlined in a manner clearly visible to the average viewer, except for the names of the top contributors, if any.
(4)The names of the top contributors shall not have their type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(5)If the name of one or more top contributor exceeds the width of the screen and is required to wrap onto a second line, then the names of contributors shall be clearly marked, using a highly visible symbol or minimum vertical separation defined by the Commission, to indicate where one top contributor name ends and the next begins.
(c)An advertisement that is an independent expenditure supporting or opposing a candidate shall include the appropriate statement from Section 84506.5 printed immediately above the background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer.
(d)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
SEC. 3.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 5 of Chapter 777 of the Statutes of 2018, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in an Arial equivalent type with a type size of at least 10-point for printed advertisements designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, mailers, flyers, and door hangers.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(4)The disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed Arial equivalent type.
(6)A committee subject to Section 84506.5 shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert Commission Internet Website), which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text.
(b)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (5) of subdivision (a), the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 on a printed advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, yard signs or billboards, shall be in Arial equivalent type with a total height of at least 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and printed on a solid background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
SEC. 4.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 12 of Chapter 887 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a mailer, flyer, or door hanger, that is paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 10-point.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(4)The disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(6)An advertisement supporting or opposing a candidate that is paid for by an independent expenditure shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert link to Secretary of State internet website page with top 10 contributor lists], which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text at the bottom of the disclosure area.
(8)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the largest top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
(b)A print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a yard sign or billboard, paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures pursuant to Section 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 in a printed or drawn box with a solid white background on the bottom of the advertisement that is set apart from any other printed matter. Each line of the written disclosures shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type no less than 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and shall not be condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or provided by applicable law.
SEC. 5.Section 84504.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.3.(a)This section applies to an electronic media advertisement if either of the following is true:
(1)The advertisement is paid for by a committee other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate.
(2)The advertisement is paid for by a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and is either of the following:
(A)Paid for by an independent expenditure.
(B)An advertisement supporting or opposing a ballot measure.
(b)An electronic media advertisement that is a graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to link to an internet website paid for by a committee shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Unless the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) includes the full disclosure text required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514, the advertisement shall contain a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 in a contrasting color and in no less than 11-point font.
(2)The advertisement shall include, for the duration of the advertisement, the disclosures required by Section 84514, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84502, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, displayed according to the following:
(A)The disclosure area shall have a solid white or black background and shall be in a box on the bottom of the advertisement. The text in the disclosure area shall be in a contrasting color and in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 11-point and shall not have its type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(B)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosure required by Section 84502 by a blank line.
(C)Notwithstanding Section 84503, the disclosure area may disclose only the largest top contributor to the committee paying for the advertisement, and the disclosure area may include the words Top Funder or Top Funders instead of Ad Committees Top Funders or Ad Committees Top Funder.
(D)The disclosure required by Section 84506.5 may be displayed at the bottom of the disclosure box, separated from the disclosures required by Section 84503 by a blank horizontal line. This text is not required to be displayed in the disclosure area if the advertisement hyperlinks to a website containing the disclosures as described by paragraph (1).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), if the image takes up fewer than 65,000 square pixels, i.e., is smaller than a standard 728 by 90 pixel leaderboard image advertisement, then the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) may instead include the text Who funded this ad?. This text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 8-point.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), the disclosure area required by paragraph (2) is not required if it would take up more than 10 percent of the graphic or image even using the Who funded this ad? option allowed by paragraph (3). In those circumstances, the advertisement need only include a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514.
(5)Any text or image not required by this subdivision shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), an email message or internet website paid for by a committee shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 printed clearly and legibly in a contrasting color and in no less than 8-point font at the top or bottom of the email message, or at the top or bottom of every publicly accessible page of the internet website, as applicable.
(d)An internet website that is linked as provided for in paragraphs (1) and (4) of subdivision (b) shall remain online and available to the public until 30 days after the date of the election in which the candidate or ballot measure supported or opposed by the advertisement was voted upon.
(e)An advertisement made via a form of electronic media that is audio only and therefore cannot include either of the disclosures in subdivision (b) shall comply with the disclosure requirements for radio advertisements in Section 84504.
(f)An electronic media advertisement that is disseminated as a video shall comply with the disclosure requirements of Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5, depending on the type of committee that paid for it. If the video is longer than 30 seconds, the disclosures required by Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5 shall be made at the beginning of the advertisement.
(g)An advertisement in the form of a post, comment, or similar communication made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, is not required to include the disclosure provided in subdivision (b) if both of the following apply:
(1)The advertisement was posted directly by the social media page or account of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)(A) The disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, 84506.5, and 84514 are included on the cover or header photo of the committees profile, landing page, or similar location for the committees page or account from which the post, comment, or similar communication was made in a contrasting color that is easily readable by the average viewer and in no less than 10-point font. The disclosures specified in this subparagraph shall be fully visible on the cover or header photo when the profile, landing page, or similar location is viewed from any electronic device that is commonly used to view this form of electronic media, including, but not limited to, a computer screen, laptop, tablet, or smart phone.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if making the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A) fully visible on a commonly used electronic device would be impracticable, the cover or header photo of the profile, landing page, or similar location need only include a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab to an internet website containing the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A).
(h)The disclosures required by this section do not apply to advertisements made via social media for which the only expense or cost of the communication is compensated staff time unless the social media account where the content is posted was created only for the purpose of advertisements governed by this title.
SEC. 6.Section 84504.4 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.4.(a)A radio or television advertisement that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 and the disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, subject to the following requirements:
(1)In a radio advertisement, the words shall be included at the beginning or end of the advertisement and read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
(2)In a television advertisement, the words shall appear in writing for at least four seconds with letters in a type size that is greater than or equal to 4 percent of the height of the screen.
(b)An advertisement that is made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 in accordance with subdivision (g) of Section 84504.3.
SEC. 7.Section 84504.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.5.An advertisement that is an independent expenditure and paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84506.5, and 84514. An advertisement that supports or opposes a ballot measure and is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502. A disclosure that is included in an advertisement pursuant to this section is subject to the following requirements:
(a)A radio or telephone advertisement shall include the required disclosures at the beginning or end of the advertisement and be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)A video advertisement, including television and videos disseminated over the internet, shall include the required disclosures in writing at the beginning or end of the advertisement in a text that is of sufficient size to be readily legible to an average viewer and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement for at least four seconds. The required disclosure must also be spoken during the advertisement if the written disclosure appears for less than five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for less than 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(c)(1)A print advertisement shall include the required disclosures in no less than 10-point font and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), each line of the required disclosures on a print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, such as a yard sign or billboard, shall in total constitute no less than 5 percent of the total height of the advertisement and shall appear in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(d)An electronic media advertisement shall include the disclosures required by Section 84504.3.
SEC. 8.Section 84514 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 84513, to read:84514.(a)(1)If a committee, as defined in Section 82013, creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: Ad generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
(2)The disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be displayed or spoken in the manner prescribed in Section 84504, 84504.1, 84504.2, 84504.3, 84504.4, or 84504.5, as applicable.
(b)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(c)(1)If a committee does not comply with the requirements of subdivision (a), the Commission may take either of the following actions:
(A)Seek injunctive relief to compel compliance pursuant to Section 90009.
(B)Pursue any administrative or civil remedies available under Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 83100) or Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(2)A violation of subdivision (a) shall not constitute a misdemeanor under Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
(2)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(3)Qualified political advertisement means an advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
SEC. 9.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated over the radio or by telephonic means shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement, read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, radio and prerecorded telephonic advertisements shall disclose only the top two contributors of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more unless the advertisement lasts 15 seconds or less or the disclosure statement would last more than eight seconds, in which case only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more shall be disclosed.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.1 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.1.(a)An advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, that is disseminated as a video, including advertisements on television and videos disseminated over the Internet, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 84502, 84503, and 84514 at the beginning or end of the advertisement.
(b)The disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall be written and displayed for at least five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for at least 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(1)The written disclosure required by subdivision (a) shall appear on a solid black background on the entire bottom one-third of the television or video display screen, or bottom one-fourth of the screen if the committee does not have or is otherwise not required to list top contributors, and shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type, and the type size for capital letters in the written disclosure shall be 4 percent of the height or width of the television or video display advertisement, whichever is less.
(2)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall be white and appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen.
(2)(3)The disclosures required by Section 84502 shall be white. white and shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, shall be yellow, such as HTML hex value #FFFF00, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Section 84503 84502 by a blank horizontal space at least 2 percent of the height of the television or video display screen. The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. All disclosure text shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area. If there are any top contributors, the written disclosures shall be underlined in a manner clearly visible to the average viewer, except for the names of the top contributors, if any.
(3)(4)The names of the top contributors shall not have their type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(4)(5)If the name of one or more top contributor exceeds the width of the screen and is required to wrap onto a second line, then the names of contributors shall be clearly marked, using a highly visible symbol or minimum vertical separation defined by the Commission, to indicate where one top contributor name ends and the next begins.
(c)An advertisement that is an independent expenditure supporting or opposing a candidate shall include the appropriate statement from Section 84506.5 printed immediately above the background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer.
(d)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
SEC. 3.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 5 of Chapter 777 of the Statutes of 2018, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in an Arial equivalent type with a type size of at least 10-point for printed advertisements designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, mailers, flyers, and door hangers.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(3)(4)The top of the disclosure area shall include the disclosure disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503. 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(4)(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed Arial equivalent type.
(5)(6)A committee subject to Section 84506.5 shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(6)(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert Commission Internet Web site], Website), which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text.
(b)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (4) (5) of subdivision (a), the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 on a printed advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, yard signs or billboards, shall be in Arial equivalent type with a total height of at least 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and printed on a solid background with sufficient contrast that is easily readable by the average viewer. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the single top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
SEC. 4.Section 84504.2 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 12 of Chapter 887 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:84504.2.(a)A print advertisement designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a mailer, flyer, or door hanger, that is paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5, 84506.5, and 84514, displayed as follows:
(1)The disclosure area shall have a solid white background and shall be in a printed or drawn box on the bottom of at least one page that is set apart from any other printed matter. All text in the disclosure area shall be in contrasting color and centered horizontally in the disclosure area.
(2)The text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 10-point.
(3)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503 by a blank line.
(3)(4)The top of the disclosure area shall include the disclosure disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84503. 84503 shall follow the disclosure required by Section 84514. The text of the disclosure shall be underlined if there are any top contributors.
(4)(5)The top contributors, if any, shall each be disclosed on a separate horizontal line separate from any other text, in descending order, beginning with the top contributor who made the largest cumulative contributions on the first line. The name of each of the top contributors shall be centered horizontally in the disclosure area and shall not be underlined. The names of the top contributors shall not be printed in a type that is condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(5)(6)An advertisement supporting or opposing a candidate that is paid for by an independent expenditure shall include the disclosure required by Section 84506.5, which shall be underlined and on a separate line below any of the top contributors.
(6)(7)A committee subject to Section 84223 shall next include the text Funding Details At [insert link to Secretary of State internet website page with top 10 contributor lists], which shall be underlined and printed on a line separate from any other text at the bottom of the disclosure area.
(7)(8)Notwithstanding the definition of top contributors in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 84501, newspaper, magazine, or other public print advertisements that are 20 square inches or less shall be required to disclose only the largest top contributor of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more.
(b)A print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, including, but not limited to, a yard sign or billboard, paid for by a committee, other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, shall include the disclosures pursuant to Section 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 in a printed or drawn box with a solid white background on the bottom of the advertisement that is set apart from any other printed matter. Each line of the written disclosures shall be in a contrasting color in standard Arial Regular type no less than 5 percent of the height of the advertisement, and shall not be condensed to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type. The text may be adjusted so it does not appear on separate horizontal lines, with the top contributors separated by a comma.
(c)Any text or image not required in this section shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or provided by applicable law.
SEC. 5.Section 84504.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.3.(a)This section applies to an electronic media advertisement if either of the following is true:
(1)The advertisement is paid for by a committee other than a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate.
(2)The advertisement is paid for by a political party committee or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and is either of the following:
(A)Paid for by an independent expenditure.
(B)An advertisement supporting or opposing a ballot measure.
(b)An electronic media advertisement that is a graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to link to an internet website paid for by a committee shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Unless the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) includes the full disclosure text required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5, 84506.5, and 84514, the advertisement shall contain a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 in a contrasting color and in no less than 11-point font.
(2)The advertisement shall include, for the duration of the advertisement, the disclosures required by Section 84502 84514, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84502, if any, followed by the disclosures required by Section 84503, if any, displayed according to the following:
(A)The disclosure area shall have a solid white or black background and shall be in a box on the bottom of the advertisement. The text in the disclosure area shall be in a contrasting color and in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 11-point and shall not have its type condensed or have the spacing between characters reduced to be narrower than a normal non-condensed standard Arial Regular type.
(B)The disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, shall appear at the top of the disclosure area, and shall be separated from the disclosure required by Section 84502 by a blank line.
(B)(C)Notwithstanding Section 84503, the disclosure area may disclose only the largest top contributor to the committee paying for the advertisement, and the disclosure area may include the words Top Funder or Top Funders instead of Ad Committees Top Funders or Ad Committees Top Funder.
(C)(D)The disclosure required by Section 84506.5 may be displayed at the bottom of the disclosure box, separated from the disclosures required by Section 84503 by a blank horizontal line. This text is not required to be displayed in the disclosure area if the advertisement hyperlinks to a website containing the disclosures as described by paragraph (1).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), if the image takes up fewer than 65,000 square pixels, i.e., is smaller than a standard 728 by 90 pixel leaderboard image advertisement, then the disclosure area described in paragraph (2) may instead include the text Who funded this ad?. This text shall be in standard Arial Regular type with a type size of at least 8-point.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), the disclosure area required by paragraph (2) is not required if it would take up more than 10 percent of the graphic or image even using the Who funded this ad? option allowed by paragraph (3). In those circumstances, the advertisement need only include a hyperlink to an internet website containing the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5. 84506.5, and 84514.
(5)Any text or image not required by this subdivision shall not appear in the disclosure area, except as provided in Section 84504.8 and as otherwise authorized or required by applicable law.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), an email message or internet website paid for by a committee shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 printed clearly and legibly in a contrasting color and in no less than 8-point font at the top or bottom of the email message, or at the top or bottom of every publicly accessible page of the internet website, as applicable.
(d)An internet website that is linked as provided for in paragraph (1) paragraphs (1) and (4) of subdivision (b) shall remain online and available to the public until 30 days after the date of the election in which the candidate or ballot measure supported or opposed by the advertisement was voted upon.
(e)An advertisement made via a form of electronic media that is audio only and therefore cannot include either of the disclosures in subdivision (b) shall comply with the disclosure requirements for radio advertisements in Section 84504.
(f)An electronic media advertisement that is disseminated as a video shall comply with the disclosure requirements of Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5, depending on the type of committee that paid for it. If the video is longer than 30 seconds, the disclosures required by Sections 84504.1 and 84504.5 shall be made at the beginning of the advertisement.
(g)An advertisement in the form of a post, comment, or similar communication made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, is not required to include the disclosure provided in subdivision (b) if both of the following apply:
(1)The advertisement was posted directly by the social media page or account of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)(A) The disclosures required by Sections 84502, 84503, and 84506.5 84506.5, and 84514 are included on the cover or header photo of the committees profile, landing page, or similar location for the committees page or account from which the post, comment, or similar communication was made in a contrasting color that is easily readable by the average viewer and in no less than 10-point font. The disclosures specified in this subparagraph shall be fully visible on the cover or header photo when the profile, landing page, or similar location is viewed from any electronic device that is commonly used to view this form of electronic media, including, but not limited to, a computer screen, laptop, tablet, or smart phone.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if making the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A) fully visible on a commonly used electronic device would be impracticable, the cover or header photo of the profile, landing page, or similar location need only include a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab to an internet website containing the disclosures specified in subparagraph (A).
(h)The disclosures required by this section do not apply to advertisements made via social media for which the only expense or cost of the communication is compensated staff time unless the social media account where the content is posted was created only for the purpose of advertisements governed by this title.
SEC. 6.Section 84504.4 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.4.(a)A radio or television advertisement that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 and the disclosure required by Section 84514, if any, subject to the following requirements:
(1)In a radio advertisement, the words shall be included at the beginning or end of the advertisement and read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
(2)In a television advertisement, the words shall appear in writing for at least four seconds with letters in a type size that is greater than or equal to 4 percent of the height of the screen.
(b)An advertisement that is made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, that is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate, and that does not support or oppose a ballot measure and is not paid for by an independent expenditure, shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502 in accordance with subdivision (h) (g) of Section 84504.3.
SEC. 7.Section 84504.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.5.An advertisement that is an independent expenditure and paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosures required by Sections 84502 and 84506.5. 84502, 84506.5, and 84514. An advertisement that supports or opposes a ballot measure and is paid for by a political party or a candidate controlled committee established for an elective office of the controlling candidate shall include the disclosure required by Section 84502. A disclosure that is included in an advertisement pursuant to this section is subject to the following requirements:
(a)A radio or telephone advertisement shall include the required disclosures at the beginning or end of the advertisement and be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement, and shall last no less than three seconds.
(b)A video advertisement, including television and videos disseminated over the internet, shall include the required disclosures in writing at the beginning or end of the advertisement in a text that is of sufficient size to be readily legible to an average viewer and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement for at least four seconds. The required disclosure must also be spoken during the advertisement if the written disclosure appears for less than five seconds of a broadcast of 30 seconds or less or for less than 10 seconds of a broadcast that lasts longer than 30 seconds.
(c)(1)A print advertisement shall include the required disclosures in no less than 10-point font and in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), each line of the required disclosures on a print advertisement that is larger than those designed to be individually distributed, such as a yard sign or billboard, shall in total constitute no less than 5 percent of the total height of the advertisement and shall appear in a color that has a reasonable degree of contrast with the background of the advertisement.
(d)An electronic media advertisement shall include the disclosures required by Section 84504.3.
SECTION 1.SEC. 8.Section 84514 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 84513, to read:84514.(a)(1)If a committee, as defined in Section 82013, creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been Ad generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:(A)Audio(B)Image.(C)Video.(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner at the beginning or end of the advertisement and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.(2)The disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be displayed or spoken in the manner prescribed in Section 84504, 84504.1, 84504.2, 84504.3, 84504.4, or 84504.5, as applicable.
(b)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(c)(1)If a committee does not comply with the requirements of subdivision (a), the Commission may take either of the following actions:
(A)Seek injunctive relief to compel compliance pursuant to Section 90009.
(B)Pursue any administrative or civil remedies available under Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 83100) or Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(2)A violation of subdivision (a) shall not constitute a misdemeanor under Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
(2)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(3)Qualified political advertisement means an advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
SEC. 2.SEC. 9.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)If a committee, as defined in Section 82013, creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
(A)Audio
(B)Image.
(C)Video.
(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.
(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner at the beginning or end of the advertisement and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
(b)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(c)(1)If a committee does not comply with the requirements of subdivision (a), the Commission may take either of the following actions:
(A)Seek injunctive relief to compel compliance pursuant to Section 90009.
(B)Pursue any administrative or civil remedies available under Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 83100) or Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(2)A violation of subdivision (a) shall not constitute a misdemeanor under Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 91000).
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
(2)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(3)Qualified political advertisement means an advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 20050) is added to Division 20 of the Elections Code, to read:1.5.Artificial Intelligence in Political Advertisements20050.(a)(1)If a person, committee, as defined in Section 82013 of the Government Code, or other entity creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:(A)Audio(B)Image.(C)Video.(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener.(b)(1)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.(2)Subdivision (a) does not apply to any of the following:(A)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, that broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events.(B)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.(C)An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events.(D)A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.(c)The superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, may issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement in violation of this section, and all cases of this nature shall be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure the speedy disposition of cases of this nature.(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:(1)Artificial intelligence means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.(2)Ballot measure includes any of the following:(A)City ballot measures.(B)County ballot measures.(C)School and district ballot measures.(D)Statewide ballot measures.(3)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.(4)Qualified political advertisement means any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.(a)(1)If a person, committee, as defined in Section 82013 of the Government Code, or other entity creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
(A)Audio
(B)Image.
(C)Video.
(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.
(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener, at the beginning of the audio, at the end of the audio, and, if the audio is greater than two minutes in length, interspersed within the audio at intervals of not greater than two minutes each. listener.
(b)(1)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(2)This section Subdivision (a) does not apply to any of the following:
(A)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, that broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or a disclosure, in a manner that can be easily heard or read by the average listener or viewer, that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence. events.
(B)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.
(C)An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement, if the publication clearly states that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence. advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events.
(D)A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.
(c)The superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, may issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement in violation of this section, and all cases of this nature shall be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure the speedy disposition of cases of this nature.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means a an engineered or machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments, and that uses machine and human-based inputs to do all of the following: varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
(A)Perceive real and virtual environments.(B)Abstract such perceptions into models through analysis in an automated manner.(C)Use model inference to formulate options for information or action.(2)Ballot measure includes any of the following:
(A)City ballot measures.
(B)County ballot measures.
(C)School and district ballot measures.
(D)Statewide ballot measures.
(3)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence. intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(4)Qualified political advertisement means any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole generated or substantially, substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 1.(a)(1)If a person, committee, as defined in Section 82013 of the Government Code, or other entity creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence.
(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
(A)Audio
(B)Image.
(C)Video.
(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.
(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener, at the beginning of the audio, at the end of the audio, and, if the audio is greater than two minutes in length, interspersed within the audio at intervals of not greater than two minutes each.
(b)(1)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(2)This section does not apply to any of the following:
(A)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, that broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or a disclosure, in a manner that can be easily heard or read by the average listener or viewer, that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence.
(B)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.
(C)An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement, if the publication clearly states that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence.
(D)A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.
(c)The superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, may issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement in violation of this section, and all cases of this nature shall be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure the speedy disposition of cases of this nature.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means a machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments, and that uses machine and human-based inputs to do all of the following:
(A)Perceive real and virtual environments.
(B)Abstract such perceptions into models through analysis in an automated manner.
(C)Use model inference to formulate options for information or action.
(2)Ballot measure includes any of the following:
(A)City ballot measures.
(B)County ballot measures.
(C)School and district ballot measures.
(D)Statewide ballot measures.
(3)Bond issue has the same meaning as the term is defined in Section 9400.(3)(A)Any image, audio, video, or other media is generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence if either of the following conditions are met:
(i)The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence.
(ii)The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
(B)Any image, audio, video, or other media is not generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image.
(4)Qualified political advertisement means means any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, or a bond issue, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole or in part, substantially, using artificial intelligence.
(a)(1)If a person, committee, as defined in Section 82013 of the Government Code, or other entity creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: This _____ has been generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence.
(2)The blank in the disclosure required by paragraph (1) shall be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
(A)Audio
(B)Image.
(C)Video.
(3)(A)For visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video.
(B)If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener, at the beginning of the audio, at the end of the audio, and, if the audio is greater than two minutes in length, interspersed within the audio at intervals of not greater than two minutes each.
(b)(1)This section does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
(2)This section does not apply to any of the following:
(A)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, that broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or a disclosure, in a manner that can be easily heard or read by the average listener or viewer, that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence.
(B)A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.
(C)An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement, if the publication clearly states that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence.
(D)A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.
(c)The superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, may issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement in violation of this section, and all cases of this nature shall be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure the speedy disposition of cases of this nature.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Artificial intelligence means a machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments, and that uses machine and human-based inputs to do all of the following:
(A)Perceive real and virtual environments.
(B)Abstract such perceptions into models through analysis in an automated manner.
(C)Use model inference to formulate options for information or action.
(2)Ballot measure includes any of the following:
(A)City ballot measures.
(B)County ballot measures.
(C)School and district ballot measures.
(D)Statewide ballot measures.
(3)Bond issue has the same meaning as the term is defined in Section 9400.
(4)Qualified political advertisement means means any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, a ballot measure, or a bond issue, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 17, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 260, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 17, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 9, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 75. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 30 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A., JUD. and APPR. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 64. Noes 0. Page 5471.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (April 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 15, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 15, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (April 10). |
| Mar 21, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on ELECTIONS, P. & C.P. and JUD. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2024 | AB 2355 Wendy Carrillo Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2355 Wendy Carrillo et al By Wilk | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2024 | AB 2355 Wendy Carrillo Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Clean Money Campaign | ** Support | |
| California Contract Cities Association | ** Support | |
| Chamber Of Progress | ** Support | |
| City of Pico Rivera | ** Support | |
| Computer And Communications Industry Association | ** Support | |
| Context Fund | ** Support | |
| Electronic Frontier Foundation | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Software And Information Industry Association | ** Support | |
| Technet | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2355
Author:(Wendy Carrillo and Cervantes)
As Amended Ver:August 15, 2024
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Requires any political advertisement, as specified, that is published or distributed by a political committee, to include a disclaimer if content in the ad was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence (AI).
Senate Amendments
- Move the provisions of the bill from the Elections Code to the Political Reform Act (PRA), and make the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) responsible for enforcement of its provisions.
- Repeal provisions of the bill that would have allowed a superior court, in a case brought by a registered voter, to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of a covered advertisement in violation of this bill, and instead permit the FPPC to seek injunctive relief or to pursue administrative or civil remedies that generally are available for violations of the PRA.
- Limit the provisions of the bill to advertisements that are published or distributed by political committees, thereby excluding advertisements that are published or distributed by a person or other entity that does not qualify as a political committee.
- Repeal provisions that specified the manner in which the required disclaimers were to be included in visual and audio media, and instead generally requires the disclaimers to comply with rules similar to those governing the inclusion of other required disclaimers in political advertisements.
- Make minor, conforming, and technical changes.
COMMENTS
The use of false and deceptive information in campaigns to influence election outcomes is not a new phenomenon. Laws aimed at curbing such practices and preserving the integrity of elections have a long history in California. In 1850, the First Session of the California State Legislature created penalties for election misconduct, including for "deceiving [an elector] and causing him to vote for a different person for any office than such elector desired or intended to vote for" (Chapter 38, Statutes of 1850).
Advancements in technology have made it increasingly simple to produce false and misleading media that closely resembles authentic content. Moreover, platforms like social media have facilitated the rapid dissemination of deceptive media to large audiences at minimal cost. Given these developments, the potential threat posed by manipulated media to future elections' integrity may be more significant than in the past.
This bill would require disclaimers on paid political advertisements that are generated or substantially altered using AI. Unlike other legislation that is being considered by the Legislature dealing with campaign communications that have been altered using digital tools including AI, this bill does not apply to deceptive and misleading elections-related communications that are not paid advertisements.
A question could be raised about whether this bill is consistent with the right to freedom of speech that is guaranteed by the United States and California constitutions. This bill compels speech by requiring a disclaimer on a political advertisement containing AI-generated media. Courts have consistently recognized that laws that compel speech can impact free speech rights, because the associated burden and penalties for noncompliance may discourage people from speaking altogether. In Citizens United v. FEC, the Supreme Court applied exacting scrutiny to requirements that certain political advertisements include disclaimers, and described exacting scrutiny as requiring a "'substantial relation' between the disclosure requirement and a 'sufficiently important' governmental interest" Citizens United v. FEC (2010), 558 US 310, 366-367.
This bill targets content that is generated by AI that falsely appears to be authentic to a reasonable person, or that is materially altered by AI in a way that causes a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media compared to an unaltered version. This AI-generated and manipulated media could undermine trust in elections and distort the electoral process.
The Senate amendments move the provisions of this bill to the PRA, thereby making the FPPC responsible for administration and enforcement of the bill. The amendments also generally require the disclaimer that is required by this bill to be included in the advertisement in a manner that is consistent with rules similar to those governing the inclusion of other required disclaimers in political advertisements.
According to the Author
“Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvements in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.”
Arguments in Support
In support of this bill, Chamber of Progress writes, “Combating the purposeful use of electoral misinformation and deceptive campaigning practices is a goal we share. However, there is nothing inherently wrong with the use of generative, synthetic content in the context of political advertising – so long as the use of such content is adequately disclosed. AB 2355 strikes this balance by focusing on the intention of the committee or individual making use of such content for political purposes while not attributing liability to the platforms used to create synthetic media. Furthermore, AB 2355 does not distinguish between the type of media being created or the delivery method used to distribute that media. Instead, the bill offers a grounded, common-sense approach to the disclosure of the use of synthetic media based upon similar disclosure practices that most voters are already familiar with.”
Arguments in Opposition
None received.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The FPPC indicates that it would incur first-year costs of $651,000, and $630,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund). These amounts reflect new positions for both enforcement and legal activities. In addition, FPPC would require AI-detection software to carry out its administrative duties, the cost of which is unknown.
- By authorizing FPPC to seek injunctive relief, this bill could result in an increased number of civil actions. Consequently, the bill could result in potentially significant cost pressures to the courts; the magnitude is unknown (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). The specific number of new actions that could be filed under the bill also is unknown; however, it generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Courts are not funded on the basis of workload, and increased pressure on TCTF may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The enacted 2024-25 budget includes $37 million in ongoing support from the General Fund to continue to backfill TCTF for revenue declines.
VOTES:
ASM ELECTIONS: 7-1-0
YES: Pellerin, Lackey, Bennett, Berman, Cervantes, Low, Weber
NO: Essayli
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-1-1
YES: Joe Patterson, Bryan, Dixon, Irwin, Lowenthal, Ortega, Ward, Wicks, Wilson
NO: Hoover
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-1-2
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez
NO: Essayli
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, McKinnor
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-2
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Ta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-0-16
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Friedman, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Luz Rivas, Ta, Wallis
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: August 15, 2024
CONSULTANT: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0004232
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2355 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2355
Author: Wendy Carrillo (D) and Cervantes (D)
Amended: 8/15/24 in Senate
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/18/24
AYES: Blakespear, Allen, Menjivar, Newman, Portantino, Umberg
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 7/2/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Niello, Roth, Stern, Wahab
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/15/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-0, 5/22/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: political advertisements: artificial intelligence
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing artificial intelligence (AI) to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA).
- Prohibits anyone from, until January 1, 2027, distributing within 60 days of an election materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate.
- Prohibits anyone from, beginning January 1, 2027, producing, distributing, publishing, or broadcasting campaign material that contains a superimposed image of a candidate unless the campaign material includes a disclaimer that the picture is an inaccurate representation of fact.
This bill:
- Requires a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing AI to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
- Permits the FPPC to seek injunctive relief or pursue any administrative or civil remedies available to compel compliance. Provides a violation of this bill do not constitute a misdemeanor.
Background
Artificial Intelligence and Elections. On June 4, 2024, the Senate Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments and the Assembly Committee on Elections held a joint information hearing focusing on AI and elections. The purpose of the hearing was to inform and assist the Legislature in making informed decisions on legislation related to AI-generated and altered content. It became evident that the ease with which people can create and spread mis- and disinformation creates a world where many people may have trouble determining what is fact and what is fiction. The development of increasingly advanced AI tools has made once time-consuming activities much easier to complete, while also enabling the completion of tasks that are otherwise too complex for humans to tackle alone.
State Action. In 2018, the Legislature approved and Governor Brown signed AB 3075 (Berman, Chapter 241, Statutes of 2018) to establish the Office of Elections Cybersecurity (OEC) in the Secretary of State’s (SOS) office. The OEC has two primary missions. First, it is responsible for coordinating efforts between the SOS and local elections officials to reduce the likelihood and severity of cyber incidents that could interfere with the security or integrity of elections in California. The OEC is also tasked with monitoring and counteracting false or misleading information regarding the electoral process that is published online or on other platforms that may suppress voter participation, cause confusion, or disrupt the ability to ensure a secure election. According to the OEC’s website, the office serves California with the sole purpose of keeping every Californian’s vote safe from online interference, especially the spread of mis- and disinformation.
In 2019, the Legislature approved and Governor Newsom signed AB 730 (Berman, Chapter 493, Statutes of 2019). AB 730 sought to address concerns that deepfake technology could be used to spread misinformation in political campaigns. Legislative analyses of AB 730 described “deepfake technology” as software capable of producing a realistic looking video of someone saying or doing something they did not actually say or do. AB 730 prohibits anyone from distributing deceptive audio or visual media with actual malice and the intent to injure a candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter, unless the media includes a disclaimer that it has been manipulated. AB 730 does not apply exclusively to deepfakes, it also applies to any intentional manipulation of audio or visual images where a reasonable person would be misled into believing it was authentic. Notably, AB 730 focused on materially deceptive representations of candidates, and not on deceptive media of other aspects of the electoral process. AB 730 included a January 1, 2023 sunset date, but in 2022 the Legislature approved AB 972 (Berman, Chapter 745, Statutes of 2022) to extend the sunset date to January 1, 2027.
Tech Accord to Combat Deceptive Use of AI in 2024. In February 2024, 20 technology companies signed the “Tech Accord to Combat Deceptive Use of AI in 2024 Elections.” This set of commitments seeks to combat harmful AI-generated content meant to deceive voters. The signatories included Adobe, Amazon, Anthropic, Arm, ElevenLabs, Google, IBM, Inflection AI, LinkedIn, McAfee, Meta, Microsoft, Nota, OpenAI, Snap Inc., Stability AI, TikTok, Trend Micro, Truepic, and X. The signatories committed to taking the following steps through this year:
- Develop and implement technology to mitigate risks related to deceptive AI content.
- Assess and better understand the risks presented by deceptive AI election content.
- Seek ways to detect the distribution of deceptive AI election content.
- Seek to address deceptive AI election content.
- Share best practices and explore pathways to share tools throughout the industry.
- Provide transparency to the public.
- Continue to engage with stakeholders to better understand the global risk landscape.
- Support efforts to raise public awareness regarding deceptive AI election content.
Comments
According to the Author: “Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvement in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy by updating the disclosure requirements in the PRA.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2655 (Berman, 2024) requires large online social media platforms to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, before and after an election. The bill is being considered by the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
AB 2839 (Pellerin, 2024) prohibits the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications containing materially deceptive and digitally altered or created images or audio or video files with the intent to influence an election or solicit funds for a candidate or campaign. The bill is being considered by the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) indicates that it would incur first-year costs of $651,000, and $630,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund). These amounts reflect new positions for both enforcement and legal activities. In addition, FPPC would require AI-detection software to carry out its administrative duties, the cost of which is unknown.
- By authorizing FPPC to seek injunctive relief, this bill could result in an increased number of civil actions. Consequently, the bill could result in potentially significant cost pressures to the courts; the magnitude is unknown (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). The specific number of new actions that could be filed under the bill also is unknown; however, it generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Courts are not funded on the basis of workload, and increased pressure on TCTF may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The enacted 2024-25 budget includes $37 million in ongoing support from the General Fund to continue to backfill TCTF for revenue declines.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/16/24)
California Clean Money Campaign
California Contract Cities Association
Chamber of Progress
Computer and Communications Industry Association
Context Fund
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Oakland Privacy
Software and Information Industry Association
TechNet
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/16/24)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-0, 5/22/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Mike Fong, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Friedman, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Luz Rivas, Ta, Wallis
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
8/19/24 10:47:30
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2355 (Wendy Carrillo) - Political Reform Act of 1974: political advertisements: artificial intelligence
Version: June 11, 2024 | Policy Vote: E. & C.A. 6 - 0, JUD. 11 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 15, 2024 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
AB 2355 would require a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing artificial intelligence (AI) to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 15, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
- The Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) indicates that it would incur first-year costs of $651,000, and $630,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund). These amounts reflect new positions for both enforcement and legal activities. In addition, FPPC would require AI-detection software to carry out its administrative duties, the cost of which is unknown.
- By authorizing FPPC to seek injunctive relief, this bill could result in an increased number of civil actions. Consequently, the bill could result in potentially significant cost pressures to the courts; the magnitude is unknown (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). The specific number of new actions that could be filed under the bill also is unknown; however, it generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Courts are not funded on the basis of workload, and increased pressure on TCTF may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The enacted 2024-25 budget includes $37 million in ongoing support from the General Fund to continue to backfill TCTF for revenue declines.
Author Amendments:
Modify the text size and other formatting requirements of the required disclosure.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2355 (Wendy Carrillo) - Political Reform Act of 1974: political advertisements: artificial intelligence
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 2355 would require a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing artificial intelligence (AI) to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) indicates that it would incur first-year costs of $651,000, and $630,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund). These amounts reflect new positions for both enforcement and legal activities. In addition, FPPC would require AI-detection software to carry out its administrative duties, the cost of which is unknown.
- By authorizing FPPC to seek injunctive relief, this bill could result in an increased number of civil actions. Consequently, the bill could result in potentially significant cost pressures to the courts; the magnitude is unknown (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). The specific number of new actions that could be filed under the bill also is unknown; however, it generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Courts are not funded on the basis of workload, and increased pressure on TCTF may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The enacted 2024-25 budget includes $37 million in ongoing support from the General Fund to continue to backfill TCTF for revenue declines.
Background:
Generative AI is a type of artificial intelligence that can create new content, including text, images, code, or music, by learning from existing data. Generative AI models can produce realistic and novel artifacts that resemble the data they were trained on, but do not copy it. For example, generative AI can write a poem, draw a picture, or compose a song based on a given prompt or theme. Generative AI enables users to quickly generate new content based on a variety of inputs. Generative AI models use neural networks to identify the patterns and structures within existing data to generate new and original content.
Current law includes various provisions criminalizing deceptive tactics that undermine election integrity or interfere with voters’ ability to participate in elections. This includes laws that prohibit distribution of false and misleading information about qualifications to vote or about the days, dates, times, and places where voting may occur; prohibit the misleading use of government seals in campaign literature; and prohibit coercing or deceiving people into voting in a way that was inconsistent with the person’s intent.
In June 2024, a joint hearing was conducted by the Legislature’s two elections committees focusing on artificial intelligence (AI) and elections. The hearing’s purpose was to assist the Legislature in making informed decisions on legislation related to AI-generated and altered content. The ease with which people can create and spread misinformation and disinformation creates a world where many people may have trouble determining what is fact and what is fiction. The development of increasingly advanced AI tools has made once time-consuming activities much easier to complete, while also enabling the completion of tasks that are otherwise too complex for humans to complete on their own.
In 2018, the Legislature and Governor established the Office of Elections Cybersecurity (OEC) within SOS. OEC has two primary missions. First, it is responsible for coordinating efforts between SOS and local elections officials to reduce the likelihood and severity of cyber incidents that could interfere with the security or integrity of state elections. Second, OEC is tasked with monitoring and counteracting false or misleading information regarding the electoral process that is published online or on other platforms that may suppress voter participation, cause confusion, or disrupt the ability to ensure a secure election.
In 2019, the Legislature enacted AB 730 (Berman), which sought to address concerns that deepfake technology could be used to spread misinformation in political campaigns. AB 730 prohibits anyone from distributing deceptive audio or visual media with actual malice and the intent to injure a candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter, unless the media includes a disclaimer that it has been manipulated. AB 730 does not apply exclusively to deepfakes; it also applies to any intentional manipulation of audio or visual images where a reasonable person would be misled into believing it was authentic. The bill focused on materially deceptive representations of candidates, and not on deceptive media of other aspects of the electoral process. AB 730’s provisions have been extended, and currently sunset on January 1, 2027.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Provide that if a committee creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, as defined, it shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: "This _____ has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence." The blank must indicate if it is audio, an image, or video.
- Require the text of the disclosure, for visual media, to appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video. If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner at the beginning or end of the advertisement and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
- Authorize FPPC, if a committee does not comply, to seek injunctive relief to compel compliance and pursue any administrative or civil remedies available.
Related Legislation:
- AB 2655 (Berman) would require large online social media platforms to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, before and after an election. The bill is currently pending in this Committee.
- AB 2839 (Pellerin) would prohibit the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications containing materially deceptive and digitally altered or created images or audio or video files with the intent to influence an election or solicit funds for a candidate or campaign. AB 2839 is being considered by this committee.
Staff Comments:
The $37 million in General Fund support for TCTF in 2024-25 is down sharply (over 50 percent) from previous years. The comparative figure was $74 million in 2023-24, $72 million in 2022-23, and $84 million in 2021-22.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2355 (Author:Wendy Carrillo)
Version: June 11, 2024
Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Political advertisements: artificial intelligence
DIGEST
This bill requires committees that create, publish, or distribute a political advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence (AI) to include a disclosure in the advertisement disclosing that the content has been so altered.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Certain forms of media – audio recordings, video recordings, and still images – can be powerful evidence of what truly took place. While such media have always been susceptible to some degree of manipulation, until recently, fakes were relatively easy to detect. The rapid advancement of AI technology, specifically the wide-scale introduction of generative AI models, has made it drastically cheaper and easier to produce synthetic content – audio, images, text, and video recordings that are not real, but that are so realistic that they are virtually impossible to distinguish from authentic content, including so-called “deepfakes.”
In the context of election campaigns, such deepfakes can be weaponized to deceive voters into thinking that a candidate said or did something which the candidate did not. In an attempt to prevent deepfakes from altering the outcome of an election in this way, this bill requires committees to disclose when certain images, video, or audio in political advertisements have been generated or altered by AI.
The bill is author-sponsored. It is supported by various organizations, including the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce and Oakland Privacy. No timely opposition has been received by the Committee. The bill passed out of the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee on a 6 to 0 vote.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that “Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech...” (U.S. Const., amend. 1.)
- Applies the First Amendment to the states through operation of the Fourteenth Amendment. (Gitlow v. New York (1925) 268 U.S. 652; NAACP v. Alabama (1925) 357 U.S. 449.)
- Provides that no provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated for liability purposes as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. (47 U.S.C. § 230.)
4) Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media” as an image or an audio or video recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech, or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner such that both of the following conditions are met:
a) the image or audio or video recording would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic; and
b) the image or audio or video recording would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the image or audio or video recording than that person would have if the person were hearing or seeing the unaltered, original version of the image or audio or video recording. (Elec. Code § 20010(e).)
5) Prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from distributing with actual malice materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate within 60 days of an election at which a candidate for elective office will appear on the ballot, as specified, and unless specified conditions are met. (Elec. Code § 20010(a).)
6) Exempts audio or visual media that includes a disclosure stating: “This _____ has been manipulated.” Requires the blank in the disclosure to be filled with a term that most accurately describes the media, as specified. Requires the following disclosures for visual and audio-only media:
a) for visual media, the text of the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, then the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. Requires, for visual media that is video, the disclosure to be displayed throughout the duration of the video;
b) for audio-only media, the disclosure shall be read in the clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener, at the beginning of the audio, at the end of the audio, and, if the audio is greater than two minutes in length, interspersed within the audio at intervals of not greater than two minutes each. (Elec. Code § 20010(b).)
7) Permits a candidate for elective office whose voice or likeness appears in a materially deceptive audio or visual media distributed in violation of the above provisions, to seek injunctive or other equitable relief prohibiting the distribution of audio or visual media in violation of the provisions of this bill. (Elec. Code § 20010(c)(1).)
9) Permits a candidate for elective office whose voice or likeness appears in materially deceptive audio or visual media distributed in violation of the provisions of this bill to bring an action for general or special damages against the person, committee, or other entity that distributed the materially deceptive audio or visual media, as specified. Requires the plaintiff to bear the burden of establishing the violation through clear and convincing evidence in any civil action alleging a violation of the provisions of this bill, as specified. (Elec. Code § 21101(c)(2).)
13) Provides that the provisions of the above statute shall not be construed to alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under the federal Communications Decency Act. (Elec. Code § 20010(d)(1).)
This bill:
- Provides that if a committee creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, the qualified political advertisement shall include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: “This _____ has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.” The blank must indicate if it is audio, an image, or video.
- Defines “qualified political advertisement” as an advertisement that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence. Any image, audio, video, or other media is “generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence” if either of the following conditions are met:
- The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
- The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
- Requires the text of the disclosure, for visual media, to appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, the disclosure shall appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, the disclosure shall appear for the duration of the video. If the media consists of audio only, the disclosure shall be read in a clearly spoken manner at the beginning or end of the advertisement and in a pitch and tone substantially similar to the rest of the advertisement.
- Authorizes the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), if a committee does not comply, to seek injunctive relief to compel compliance and pursue any administrative or civil remedies available.
- Clarifies that it does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
COMMENTS
- Blurring reality: AI-generated content
Generative AI is a type of artificial intelligence that can create new content, including text, images, code, or music, by learning from existing data. Generative AI models can produce realistic and novel artifacts that resemble the data they were trained on, but do not copy it. For example, generative AI can write a poem, draw a picture, or compose a song based on a given prompt or theme. Generative AI enables users to quickly generate new content based on a variety of inputs. Generative AI models use neural networks to identify the patterns and structures within existing data to generate new and original content.
The world has been in awe of the powers of this generative AI since the widespread introduction of AI systems such as ChatGPT. However, the capabilities of these advanced systems leads to a blurring between reality and fiction. The Brookings Institution lays out the issue:
Over the last year, generative AI tools have made the jump from research prototype to commercial product. Generative AI models like OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini can now generate realistic text and images that are often indistinguishable from human-authored content, with generative AI for audio and video not far behind. Given these advances, it’s no longer surprising to see AI-generated images of public figures go viral or AI-generated reviews and comments on digital platforms. As such, generative AI models are raising concerns about the credibility of digital content and the ease of producing harmful content going forward.
Against the backdrop of such technological advances, civil society and policymakers have taken increasing interest in ways to distinguish AI-generated content from human-authored content.[1]
One expert at the Copenhagen Institute for Future Studies estimates that should large generative-AI models run amok, up to 99 percent of the internet’s content could be AI-generated by 2025 to 2030.[2] The problematic applications are seemingly infinite, whether it be deepfakes to blackmail or shame victims, false impersonations to commit fraud, or other nefarious purposes. Infamously, in January of this year, Taylor Swift was the victim of sexually explicit, nonconsensual deepfake images using AI that were widely spread across social media platforms.[3] Perhaps more disturbingly, a trend has emerged in schools of students creating such images: “At schools across the country, people have used deepfake technology combined with real images of female students to create fraudulent images of nude bodies. The deepfake images can be produced using a cellphone.”[4] As more of the population becomes aware of the potential to realistically fake images, video, and text, some will use the skepticism that creates to challenge the authenticity of real content, a phenomena coined the “liar’s dividend.”[5]
Relevant here, AI and specifically generative AI can spread misinformation regarding elections with ease, both in California and across the world:
Artificial intelligence is supercharging the threat of election disinformation worldwide, making it easy for anyone with a smartphone and a devious imagination to create fake – but convincing – content aimed at fooling voters.
It marks a quantum leap from a few years ago, when creating phony photos, videos or audio clips required teams of people with time, technical skill and money. Now, using free and low-cost generative artificial intelligence services from companies like Google and OpenAI, anyone can create high-quality “deepfakes” with just a simple text prompt.
A wave of AI deepfakes tied to elections in Europe and Asia has coursed through social media for months, serving as a warning for more than 50 countries heading to the polls this year.
“You don’t need to look far to see some people ... being clearly confused as to whether something is real or not,” said Henry Ajder, a leading expert in generative AI based in Cambridge, England.
The question is no longer whether AI deepfakes could affect elections, but how influential they will be, said Ajder, who runs a consulting firm called Latent Space Advisory.
As the U.S. presidential race heats up, FBI Director Christopher Wray recently warned about the growing threat, saying generative AI makes it easy for “foreign adversaries to engage in malign influence.”[6]
On that last note, in February of this year, voters in New Hampshire received robocalls that are purported to have used an AI voice resembling President Joe Biden advising them against voting in the presidential primary and saving their vote for the November general election.[7] The examples are endless:
Former President Donald Trump, who is running in 2024, has shared AI-generated content with his followers on social media. A manipulated video of CNN host Anderson Cooper that Trump shared on his Truth Social platform on Friday, which distorted Cooper’s reaction to the CNN town hall this past week with Trump, was created using an AI voice-cloning tool.
A dystopian campaign ad released last month by the Republican National Committee offers another glimpse of this digitally manipulated future. The online ad, which came after President Joe Biden announced his reelection campaign, and starts with a strange, slightly warped image of Biden and the text “What if the weakest president we’ve ever had was re-elected?”
A series of AI-generated images follows: Taiwan under attack; boarded up storefronts in the United States as the economy crumbles; soldiers and armored military vehicles patrolling local streets as tattooed criminals and waves of immigrants create panic.
“An AI-generated look into the country’s possible future if Joe Biden is re-elected in 2024,” reads the ad’s description from the RNC.
The RNC acknowledged its use of AI, but others, including nefarious political campaigns and foreign adversaries, will not, said Petko Stoyanov, global chief technology officer at Forcepoint, a cybersecurity company based in Austin, Texas. Stoyanov predicted that groups looking to meddle with U.S. democracy will employ AI and synthetic media as a way to erode trust.[8]
Legislatures across the country are pushing legislation that would address this looming threat.
- AI generated or altered content in political advertisements
According to the author:
Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvement in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy by updating the disclosure requirements in the Political Reform Act.
This bill institutes baseline protections in political advertisements. It requires a clear and conspicuous disclosure when an image, audio, or video in a political advertisement is generated or substantially altered using AI. This means that the content is either entirely created using AI and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or it is materially altered by AI such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
Given the narrow scope of the requirement and the fact that no content is prohibited, but simply requires disclosure as to its provenance, there is likely little concern regarding offending the First Amendment, and no such concerns have been raised with regard to the current version of the bill.
The bill borrows from existing law. In anticipation of the possibility that deepfakes might be used to try to influence the outcome of the 2020 election, California enacted AB 730 (Berman, Ch. 493, Stats. 2019). AB 730 prohibited the use of deepfakes depicting a candidate for office within 60 days of the election unless the deepfake is accompanied by a prominent notice that the content of the audio, video, or image has been manipulated. (Elec. Code § 20010(a),(b).) Additionally, AB 730 authorized a candidate who was falsely depicted in a deepfake to seek rapid injunctive relief against further publication and distribution of the deepfake. (Code Civ. Proc. §35(a); Elec. Code § 20010(c).) AB 972 (Berman, Ch. 745, Stats. 2022) later extended the sunset date placed on these provisions to January 1, 2027.
- Stakeholder positions
Oakland Privacy writes in support:
Generative artificial intelligence can now create fake (i.e. artificial) content that can seem to decisively indicate that someone said something they didn’t say, was at a location they never visited or that statistics and other factual material that impacts policy are not accurate when they are. Unlike mere “claims” that can be rebutted; generative AI can provide what seems like dispositive evidence of truth or falsity, but is a mere computer projection of bits and bytes. This can wreak havoc on a voter’s ability to research what is true and what is not and make their decisions accordingly.
Assembly Bill 2355 seeks to help voters in this position by simply requiring that synthetic content be labeled as such, so it is therefore harder to use generative AI election content as evidence of truth or falsity. This provision is literally structured in the same manner as long-standing California election law that requires the labeling of paid political advertisements. As such, the requirement is straightforward, understandable to those that would have to abide by it, doesn’t depend on unreliable technologies like watermarking, and shouldn’t confuse voters or require them to understand a lot about AI to benefit from the legislation.
Because AB 2355 is transparency legislation, it does not trigger significant First Amendment concerns and would not suppress or censor any properly-labeled content nor is it likely to be gamed by candidates to gain an advantage in a hard-fought election.
Writing in support, the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce states:
It is understood that Generative Artificial Intelligence can create fake content that can seem to decisively indicate that someone said something they didn't say, was at a location they never visited or that statistics and other factual material that impacts policy are not accurate when they are. This “deepfake” content can be extremely misleading and can negatively impact elections. AB 2355 seeks to help voters by simply requiring that synthetic content used in advertisements be labeled as such, so it is harder to use generative AI election content as evidence of truth or falsity. The potential threat posed by manipulated media to future elections' integrity is more significant now than it has ever been. Action must be taken in order to ensure election integrity.
SUPPORT
California Clean Money Campaign
California Contract Cities Association
Computer & Communications Industry Association
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Oakland Privacy
Software & Information Industry Association
Technet
OPPOSITION
None received
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 942 (Becker, 2024) establishes the California AI Transparency Act, requiring covered providers to create and make freely available an AI detection tool to detect content as AI-generated and to include disclosures in content generated by the provider’s system. SB 942 is currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SB 970 (Ashby, 2024) ensures that media manipulated or generated by artificial intelligence (AI) technology is incorporated into the right of publicity law and criminal false impersonation statutes. The bill requires those providing access to such technology to provide a warning to consumers about liability for misuse. SB 970 was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2655 (Berman, 2024) establishes the Defending Democracy from Deepfake Deception Act of 2024, which requires a large online platform to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, during specified periods before and after an election. It requires these platforms to label certain additional content inauthentic, fake, or false during specified periods before and after an election and to provide mechanisms to report content. AB 2655 is currently in this Committee.
AB 2839 (Pellerin, 2024) prohibits a person, committee, or other entity from knowingly distributing an advertisement or other election communication that contains materially deceptive content, as defined and specified, with malice, except as provided, within 120 days of a California election, and in specified cases, 60 days thereafter. AB 2839 is currently in this Committee.
AB 2930 (Bauer-Kahan, 2024) requires, among other things, a deployer and a developer of an automated decision tool to perform an impact assessment for any automated decision tool the deployer uses that includes, among other things, a statement of the purpose of the automated decision tool and its intended benefits, uses, and deployment contexts. AB 2930 requires a deployer to, at or before the time an automated decision tool is used to make a consequential decision, notify any natural person that is the subject of the consequential decision that an automated decision tool is being used to make, or be a substantial factor in making, the consequential decision and to provide that person with, among other things, a statement of the purpose of the automated decision tool. AB 2930 is currently in this Committee.
AB 3211 (Wicks, 2024) establishes the California Provenance, Authenticity and Watermarking Standards Act, which requires a generative AI system provider to take certain actions to assist in the disclosure of provenance data to mitigate harms caused by inauthentic content, including placing imperceptible and maximally indelible watermarks containing provenance data into content created by an AI system that the generative AI system provider makes available. AB 3211 also requires a large online platform, as defined, to, among other things, use labels to prominently disclose the provenance data found in watermarks or digital signatures in content distributed to users on its platforms, as specified. AB 3211 is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 972 (Berman, Ch. 745, Stats. 2022) See Comment 2.
AB 730 (Berman, Ch. 493, Stats. 2019) See Comment 2.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Elections Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 64, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 1)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 1)
Assembly Elections Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 1)
**************
Siddarth Srinivasan, Detecting AI fingerprints: A guide to watermarking and beyond (January 4, 2024) Brookings Institution, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/detecting-ai-fingerprints-a-guide-to-watermarking-and-beyond/#:~:text=Google%20also%20recently%20announced%20SynthID,model%20to%20detect%20the%20watermark. All internet citations are current as of June 21, 2024. ↑
Lonnie Lee Hood, Experts Say That Soon, Almost The Entire Internet Could Be Generated by AI (March 4, 2022) The Byte, https://futurism.com/the-byte/ai-internet-generation. ↑
Brian Contreras, Tougher AI Policies Could Protect Taylor Swift—And Everyone Else—From Deepfakes (February 8, 2024) Scientific American, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tougher-ai-policies-could-protect-taylor-swift-and-everyone-else-from-deepfakes/. ↑
Hannah Fry, Laguna Beach High School investigates ‘inappropriate’ AI-generated images of students (April 2, 2024) Los Angeles Times, https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2024-04-02/laguna-beach-high-school-investigating-creation-of-ai-generated-images-of-students. ↑
Bobby Chesney & Danielle Citron, Deep Fakes: A Looming Challenge for Privacy, Democracy, and National Security (July 14, 2018) 107 California Law Review 1753 (2019), https://ssrn.com/abstract=3213954. ↑
Ali Swenson & Kelvin Chan, Election disinformation takes a big leap with AI being used to deceive worldwide (March 14, 2024) Associated Press, https://apnews.com/article/artificial-intelligence-elections-disinformation-chatgpt-bc283e7426402f0b4baa7df280a4c3fd. ↑
Em Steck & Andrew Kaczynski, Fake Joe Biden robocall urges New Hampshire voters not to vote in Tuesday’s Democratic primary (January 22, 2024) CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/22/politics/fake-joe-biden-robocall/index.html. ↑
David Klepper & Ali Swenson, AI-generated disinformation poses threat of misleading voters in 2024 election (May 14, 2023) PBS News, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/ai-generated-disinformation-poses-threat-of-misleading-voters-in-2024-election. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 6/18/24
Author: | |||
Version: | 6/11/24 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Scott Matsumoto | ||
Subject: Political Reform Act of 1974: political advertisements: artificial intelligence
DIGEST
This bill requires a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing artificial intelligence (AI) to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA).
- Prohibits anyone from, until January 1, 2027, distributing within 60 days of an election materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate.
- Prohibits anyone from, beginning January 1, 2027, producing, distributing, publishing, or broadcasting campaign material that contains a superimposed image of a candidate unless the campaign material includes a disclaimer that the picture is an inaccurate representation of fact.
This bill:
- Requires a campaign committee that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement utilizing AI to include a disclosure stating that the audio, image, or video was generated or substantially altered using AI.
- Permits the FPPC to seek injunctive relief or pursue any administrative or civil remedies available to compel compliance. Provides a violation of the provisions of this bill do not constitute a misdemeanor.
BACKGROUND
Artificial Intelligence and Elections. On June 4, 2024, the Senate Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments and the Assembly Committee on Elections held a joint information hearing focusing on AI and elections.
The purpose of the hearing was to inform and assist the Legislature in making informed decisions on legislation related to AI-generated and altered content. It became evident that the ease with which people can create and spread mis- and disinformation creates a world where many people may have trouble determining what is fact and what is fiction. The development of increasingly advanced AI tools has made once time-consuming activities much easier to complete, while also enabling the completion of tasks that are otherwise too complex for humans to tackle alone.
State Action. In 2018, the Legislature approved and Governor Brown signed AB 3075 (Berman), Chapter 241, Statutes of 2018 to establish the Office of Elections Cybersecurity (OEC) in the Secretary of State’s (SOS) office. The OEC has two primary missions. First, it is responsible for coordinating efforts between the SOS and local elections officials to reduce the likelihood and severity of cyber incidents that could interfere with the security or integrity of elections in California. The OEC is also tasked with monitoring and counteracting false or misleading information regarding the electoral process that is published online or on other platforms that may suppress voter participation, cause confusion, or disrupt the ability to ensure a secure election. According to the OEC’s website, the office serves California with the sole purpose of keeping every Californian’s vote safe from online interference, especially the spread of mis- and disinformation.
In 2019, the Legislature approved and Governor Newsom signed AB 730 (Berman), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2019. AB 730 sought to address concerns that deepfake technology could be used to spread misinformation in political campaigns. Legislative analyses of AB 730 described “deepfake technology” as software capable of producing a realistic looking video of someone saying or doing something they did not actually say or do.
AB 730 prohibits anyone from distributing deceptive audio or visual media with actual malice and the intent to injure a candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter, unless the media includes a disclaimer that it has been manipulated. AB 730 does not apply exclusively to deepfakes, it also applies to any intentional manipulation of audio or visual images where a reasonable person would be misled into believing it was authentic. Notably, AB 730 focused on materially deceptive representations of candidates, and not on deceptive media of other aspects of the electoral process.
AB 730 included a January 1, 2023 sunset date, but in 2022 the Legislature approved AB 972 (Berman), Chapter 745, Statutes of 2022, to extend the sunset date to January 1, 2027.
Tech Accord to Combat Deceptive Use of AI in 2024. In February 2024, 20 technology companies signed the “Tech Accord to Combat Deceptive Use of AI in 2024 Elections.” This set of commitments seeks to combat harmful AI-generated content meant to deceive voters. The signatories included Adobe, Amazon, Anthropic, Arm, ElevenLabs, Google, IBM, Inflection AI, LinkedIn, McAfee, Meta, Microsoft, Nota, OpenAI, Snap Inc., Stability AI, TikTok, Trend Micro, Truepic, and X.
The signatories committed to taking the following steps through this year:
- Develop and implement technology to mitigate risks related to deceptive AI content.
- Assess and better understand the risks presented by deceptive AI election content.
- Seek ways to detect the distribution of deceptive AI election content.
- Seek to address deceptive AI election content.
- Share best practices and explore pathways to share tools throughout the industry.
- Provide transparency to the public.
- Continue to engage with stakeholders to better understand the global risk landscape.
- Support efforts to raise public awareness regarding deceptive AI election content.
Other States. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 16 states (Alabama, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, New Mexico, Oregon, Texas, Utah, Washington, and Wisconsin) enacted legislation designed to address deceptive media, including but not limited to, AI.
COMMENTS
- According to the Author: “Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvement in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy by updating the disclosure requirements in the PRA.”
- FPPC Enforcement. AB 2355 was recently amended to move its provisions from the Elections Code to the PRA, meaning the FPPC would be responsible for overseeing the bill’s implementation. It is unknown whether the FPPC has the capacity to decide what media is authentic and what is AI generated, as well as being able to seek relief in a timely fashion.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, AB 2355 will be referred to the Committee on Judiciary for further consideration.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 2655 (Berman) of 2024 requires large online social media platforms to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, before and after an election. AB 2655 is being considered by this committee.
AB 2839 (Pellerin) of 2024 prohibits the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications containing materially deceptive and digitally altered or created images or audio or video files with the intent to influence an election or solicit funds for a candidate or campaign. AB 2839 is being considered by this committee.
PRIOR ACTION
Assembly Floor: | |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | |
Assembly Elections Committee: |
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: Computer and Communications Industry Association
Software and Information Industry Association
TechNet
Oppose: None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2355
Author:(Wendy Carrillo and Cervantes)
As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires any political advertisement, as specified, that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence (AI), to include a disclaimer stating that fact.
Major Provisions
- Requires a person, political committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a paid advertisement related to a candidate for office or a ballot measure, and that is generated or substantially altered using AI, to include the following disclaimer in the advertisement in a clear and conspicuous manner and as specified: "This [audio/image/video] has been generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence."
- Provides that this bill does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to any of the following:
- A broadcasting station or a regularly-published news periodical that distributes a covered advertisement.
- A radio or television broadcasting station, when it is paid to broadcast a covered advertisement.
- A covered advertisement that is satire or parody.
- Permits a superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of a covered advertisement in violation of this bill. Provides that such cases are in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal.
COMMENTS
The use of false and deceptive information in campaigns to influence election outcomes is not a new phenomenon. Laws aimed at curbing such practices and preserving the integrity of elections have a long history in California. In 1850, the First Session of the California State Legislature created penalties for election misconduct, including for "deceiving [an elector] and causing him to vote for a different person for any office than such elector desired or intended to vote for" (Chapter 38, Statutes of 1850).
Advancements in technology have made it increasingly simple to produce false and misleading media that closely resembles authentic content. Moreover, platforms like social media have facilitated the rapid dissemination of deceptive media to large audiences at minimal cost. Given these developments, the potential threat posed by manipulated media to future elections' integrity may be more significant than in the past.
Past legislative efforts have addressed concerns about manipulated media's use to deceive voters during elections. Those laws, however, are limited, and are designed primarily to target the harms to candidates that may result from the distribution of manipulated media of those candidates.
This bill would require disclaimers on paid political advertisements that are generated or substantially altered using AI. Unlike other legislation that is being considered by the Legislature dealing with campaign communications that have been altered using digital tools including AI, this bill does not apply to deceptive and misleading elections-related communications that are not paid advertisements.
A question could be raised about whether this bill is consistent with the right to freedom of speech that is guaranteed by the United States and California constitutions. This bill compels speech by requiring a disclaimer on a political advertisement containing AI-generated media. Courts have consistently recognized that laws that compel speech can impact free speech rights, because the associated burden and penalties for noncompliance may discourage people from speaking altogether. In Citizens United v. FEC, the Supreme Court applied exacting scrutiny to requirements that certain political advertisements include disclaimers, and described exacting scrutiny as requiring a "'substantial relation' between the disclosure requirement and a 'sufficiently important' governmental interest" Citizens United v. FEC (2010), 558 US 310, 366-367.
This bill targets content that is generated by AI that falsely appears to be authentic to a reasonable person, or that is materially altered by AI in a way that causes a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media compared to an unaltered version. This AI-generated and manipulated media could undermine trust in elections and distort the electoral process.
AB 2655 (Berman), which is pending on the Assembly Floor, requires large online platforms, as defined, to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, during specified periods before and after an election.
AB 2839 (Pellerin), which is pending on the Assembly Floor, prohibits the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications that contain media that has been digitally altered in a deceptive way, except as specified.
According to the Author
"Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvements in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy."
Arguments in Support
In support of this bill, Oakland Privacy writes, "Generative artificial intelligence can now create fake (i.e. artificial) content that can seem to decisively indicate that someone said something they didn't say, was at a location they never visited or that statistics and other factual material that impacts policy are not accurate when they are. Unlike mere 'claims' that can be rebutted; generative AI can provide what seems like dispositive evidence of truth or falsity, but is a mere computer projection of bits and bytes. This can wreak havoc on a voter's ability to research what is true and what is not and make their decisions accordingly. Assembly Bill 2355 seeks to help voters in this position by simply requiring that synthetic content be labeled as such, so it is therefore harder to use generative AI election content as evidence of truth or falsity. This provision is literally structured in the same manner as long-standing California election law that requires the labeling of paid political advertisements. As such, the requirement is straightforward, understandable to those that would have to abide by it, doesn't depend on unreliable technologies like watermarking, and shouldn't confuse voters or require them to understand a lot about AI to benefit from the legislation."
Arguments in Opposition
The Electronic Frontier Foundation writes in opposition to this bill, "We recognize the complex issues raised by potentially harmful artificially generated election ads. However, this bill's 'exceptions' for only some re-publishers…does not reflect the full First Amendment protection due the republication of speech pertaining to matters of public interest by those not connected with the creation of the offending material. The First Amendment requires this distinction between those who create synthetic media and those not directly involved in it. The Fourth Circuit relied on this distinction in striking down a Maryland law that extended the reach of campaign finance law to include 'online platforms,' thus imposing disclosure requirements on them when they ran online ads. AB 2355, as written, suffers from the same constitutional defect."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, by authorizing a registered voter to bring an action to enjoin the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of an advertisement in violation of the disclosure requirement, this bill may result in an increased number of civil actions that may also receive precedence when filed in court, resulting in potentially significant cost pressures of an unknown amount to the courts (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). It is unclear how many new actions may be filed statewide, but disinformation and hostility regarding elections has grown in recent years and one hour of court time is estimated to cost $1,000 in workload. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. The Governor's proposed 2024-25 state budget includes $83.1 million ongoing GF to backfill declining TCTF revenue.
According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
VOTES
ASM ELECTIONS: 7-1-0
YES: Pellerin, Lackey, Bennett, Berman, Cervantes, Low, Weber
NO: Essayli
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-1-1
YES: Joe Patterson, Bryan, Dixon, Irwin, Lowenthal, Ortega, Ward, Wicks, Wilson
NO: Hoover
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-1-2
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez
NO: Essayli
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, McKinnor
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-2
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: April 18, 2024
CONSULTANT: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0003033
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2355
Author:(Wendy Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
Policy Committee: | Elections | Vote: | 7 - 1 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 9 - 1 | ||
Judiciary | 9 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires certain political advertisements to include a disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence (AI).
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a paid political advertisement regarding a federal, state, or local office or ballot measure to include in the advertisement a disclosure that the advertisement was generated or substantially altered using AI. The covered advertisement must falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or be such that a reasonable person would have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to the unaltered version.
- Authorizes a registered voter to bring an action in superior court seeking a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of an advertisement in violation of the disclosure requirement. Such a case must be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, to assure speedy disposition of the case.
FISCAL EFFECT:
By authorizing a registered voter to bring an action to enjoin the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of an advertisement in violation of the disclosure requirement, this bill may result in an increased number of civil actions that may also receive precedence when filed in court, resulting in potentially significant cost pressures of an unknown amount to the courts (Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). It is unclear how many new actions may be filed statewide, but disinformation and hostility regarding elections has grown in recent years and one hour of court time is estimated to cost $1,000 in workload. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. The Governor’s proposed 2024-25 state budget includes $83.1 million ongoing GF to backfill declining TCTF revenue.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by Oakland Privacy and the City of Pico Rivera, with the former arguing this bill, as “transparency legislation…does not trigger significant First Amendment concerns and would not suppress or censor any properly-labeled content nor is it likely to be gamed by candidates to gain an advantage in a hard-fought election.”
This bill is opposed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which argues, “By extending beyond the direct publishers of the content and toward re-publishers, [AB] 2355 burdens and holding liable re-publishers of content in a manner that has been found unconstitutional.”
- Manipulated Campaign Communications. The use of false and deceptive information in campaigns to influence elections is not a new phenomenon, with laws aimed at curbing such practices and preserving the integrity of elections dating back to 1850, the first session of the state legislature. However, advancements in technology have made it increasingly simple to produce false and misleading media that closely resembles authentic content. Moreover, platforms like social media have facilitated the rapid dissemination of deceptive media to large audiences at minimal cost. In response, AB 730 (Berman), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2019, prohibited the distribution of materially deceptive audio or visual media with actual malice and intent to injure a candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter to vote for or against a candidate, unless the media includes a disclaimer that the content is manipulated. As such, AB 730, as well as most previous laws, was designed primarily to target the harm caused to a candidate by the distribution of manipulated media, and not the harm caused to the general electorate.
In contrast, this bill addresses the threat of materially deceptive political advertising made or altered with AI by requiring a person or entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes such an advertisement to disclose the use of AI in developing the advertisement. This bill creates a separate enforcement framework outside of the Political Reform Act administered by the Fair Political Practices Commission, which regulates how a political advertisement must disclose the entity or entities that paid for the advertisement and establishes penalties for non-compliance. Instead, this bill allows a registered voter to bring an action to enjoin publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of an advertisement in violation of the disclosure requirement.
- Related Legislation. AB 2655 (Berman) requires, during specified periods before and after an election, a large online platform to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, and to label certain additional content as inauthentic, fake, or false. AB 2655 is pending on this committee’s suspense file.
AB 2839 (Pellerin) prohibits, during specified periods before and after an election, the distribution of certain campaign advertisements and other election communications that include materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content. AB 2839 is pending hearing in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2355
Author:(Wendy Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
SUBJECT: Political advertisements: artificial intelligence
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD ENTITES THAT DEVELOP OR DISTRIBUTE POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENTS CREATED EITHER completely OR SUBSTANTIALLY by USe of ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE BE REQUIRED TO INCLUDE A DISCLAIMER REGARDING THE USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE?
SYNOPSIS
Misleading or deceptive content is not a novel feature of this country’s political discourse. Candidates for office have regularly faced false claims about themselves or their families, as exemplified by the conspiracy theory during the 2008 presidential election that then-candidate Barack Obama was not eligible for the presidency because he was not born in the United States. Since the growth of artificial intelligence (AI), the threat of political misinformation has only increased. What was once a resource available to a select few with the skill and time necessary to manipulate images in such a way as to mislead consumers is now readily accessible through low or no-cost AI tools. According to the author: Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvement in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.
This bill builds upon the existing legal framework addressing the proliferation of materially deceptive political advertising by requiring someone who creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a “qualified political advertisement,” as defined, to include a specified disclaimer regarding the use of artificial intelligence in the development of the ad. It also authorizes a court to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the continued distribution of an AI-generated ad that violates the provisions of the bill in a claim brought by a registered voter.
This bill is supported by the City of Pico Rivera and Oakland Privacy. A coalition of technology industry trade organizations have submitted a position of support if amended. It is opposed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF). The Chamber of Progress has submitted a position of oppose, unless amended. This bill was previously heard by the Assembly Committee on Elections where it was approved on a vote of 7-1, and the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection where it was approved on a vote of 9-1.
SUMMARY: Requires a person, committee or entity who creates and distributes a qualified political advertisement, as defined, to include a disclosure regarding the use of artificial intelligence in the development of the advertisement. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines all of the following for purposes of this bill:
- “Artificial intelligence” means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments;
- “Ballot measure” includes any of the following: city ballot measures, county ballot measures, school and district ballot measures, statewide ballot measures;
- Any image, audio, video, or other media is “generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence” if either of the following conditions are met:
- The visual or audio media is entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic;
- The visual or audio media is materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
- Any image, audio, video, or other media is not “generally or substantially altered using artificial intelligence” if the media is immaterially altered by artificial intelligence, including a cosmetic adjustment, color edit, cropped image, or resized image;
- “Qualified political advertisement” means any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, or a ballot measure, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.
- If a person, committee, as defined in the specified provision of the Government Code, or other entity creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, requires the qualified political advertisement to include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: “This ____ has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.”
- Requires the blank in 2) to be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
- Audio
- Image
- Video
- Requires the blank in 2) to be filled with whichever of the following terms most accurately describes the media:
- For visual media, requires the text of the disclosure to appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer and no smaller than the largest font size of other text appearing in the visual media. If the visual media does not include any other text, requires the disclosure to appear in a size that is easily readable by the average viewer. For visual media that is video, requires the disclosure to appear for the duration of the video.
- If the media consists of audio only, requires the disclosure to be read in a clearly spoken manner and in a pitch that can be easily heard by the average listener.
- Specifies that the bill’s provisions do not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
- Exempts all of the following from the requirements in 2) – 4):
- A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, that broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events;
- A radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement;
- An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide news cast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events;
- A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.
- Authorizes a registered voter to bring a claim in superior court and authorizes the court to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement in violation of 2) – 4) and grants all cases of this nature a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure the speedy disposition of cases of this nature.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person, committee, or other entity, until January 1, 2027, from distributing with actual malice, within 60 days of an election at which a candidate for elective office will appear on the ballot, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate.
- Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media,” for these purposes, as an image or an audio or visual recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner that both of the following are true about the image or audio or video recording: (1) It would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic; and (2) it would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the image or audio or video recording than the person would have if the person were hearing or seeing the unaltered, original version of the image or audio or video recording.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply if the audio or visual media includes a disclaimer stating “This (image/video/audio) has been manipulated,” and the disclaimer complies with specified requirements.
- Permits a candidate whose voice or likeness appears in a deceptive audio or visual media distributed in violation of this provision to seek injunctive relief, as specified, and general or special damages and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, as specified. Specifies that in any civil action brought pursuant to these provisions, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing the violation through clear and convincing evidence.
- Provides that this prohibition shall not be construed to alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply to a radio or television broadcasting station; an internet website; a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication; or media that constitutes satire or parody. (Elections Code Section 20010.)
- Prohibits a person, firm, association, corporation, campaign committee, or organization, beginning January 1, 2027, with actual malice, from producing, distributing, publishing, or broadcasting campaign material, as defined, that contains either of the following types of pictures or photographs, as specified, unless the campaign material includes a disclaimer that the picture is not an accurate representation of fact:
- A picture or photograph of a person or persons into which the image of a candidate for public office is superimposed.
- A picture or photograph of a candidate for public office into which the image of another person or persons is superimposed. (Elections Code Section 20010.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Misleading or deceptive content is not a novel feature of this country’s political discourse. Candidates for office have regularly faced false claims about themselves or their families, as exemplified by the conspiracy theories during the 2008 presidential election that then-candidate Barack Obama was not eligible for the presidency because he was not born in the United States as required by the Constitution. The conspiracy grew and eventually included “evidence,” such as a fake birth certificate claiming to prove Obama was born in Kenya, rather than his birthplace of Hawai’i. Despite being disproved repeatedly, the lie was arguably able to take root due to bigoted sentiment towards Obama’s Kenyan background, persisted and ultimately resulted in Obama’ releasing his actual Hawai’ian birth certificate. The saga of the “birther” movement demonstrates the potential of disinformation to both use up resources to disprove a false claim, and to sway voters’ opinions.
Since the growth of artificial intelligence (AI), the threat of political misinformation has only increased. What was once a resource available to a select few with the skill and time necessary to manipulate images to mislead consumers is now readily accessible through low or no-cost AI tools. Shortly after the Biden campaign announced plans for President Biden to run for reelection, the Republican National Committee released an entirely AI-generated advertisement depicting an apocalyptic future under a second Biden administration. (Beat Biden (GOP) April 25, 2023 available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLMMxgtxQ1Y.) The video’s hyper-realistic depictions of cities across the world in disarray claimed to show the potential of a second Biden term. While the caption of the RNC’s video on YouTube included a disclaimer that the ad was created using artificial intelligence, not all examples of AI-generated political advertisements do.
According to the author: Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvement in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.
Existing legal framework addressing political advertisements. In 1850, the First Session of the California State Legislature created penalties for “deceiving [an elector] and causing him to vote for a different person for any office than such elector desired or intended to vote for.” (Chapter 38, Statutes of 1850.) Existing California law has greatly elaborated on these initial legislative efforts. For example, provisions in the Elections Code prohibit the distribution of false and misleading information about qualifications to vote or about the days, dates, times, and places where voting may occur; prohibit the misleading use of government seals in campaign literature (Elections Code Section 18304); and prohibit coercing or deceiving people into voting in a way that is inconsistent with the person’s intent (Elections Code Sections 18302, 18304, 18573 and 18573.5).
In the last five years, the Legislature has turned its attention to “materially deceptive” audio and visual materials that portray a candidate. For example, AB 730 (Chap. 493, Stats. 2019) responded to reports of so-called “deepfake” technology, software that allows someone to produce audios and videos that look and appear remarkably real to even the most discerning person. For example, in 2018, BuzzFeed and the film director Jordan Peele published a very realistic-looking deepfake showing former President Obama calling then-President Donald Trump a “total and complete dipshit.” Obama did not say that. Peele and BuzzFeed did not use the video to try to influence a political election – indeed halfway through the video the ruse was revealed – but to show the potential for abuse of deepfake technology. Responding to this and similar reports, AB 730 prohibited the distribution of materially deceptive audio or visual media with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against a candidate.
AB 730 was itself an amendment to California’s “Truth in Political Advertising Act” of 1998, which had prohibited campaign material that deceptively altered a picture of a candidate (for example by superimposing one person’s image upon another) unless the picture contained a disclaimer. This 1998 bill was introduced in response to the use of technologies like “photo shopping,” which now seem quaint compared to deepfakes, including deepfakes generated by artificial intelligence.
This bill requires someone who creates or disseminates a political advertisement that was generated or substantially altered using AI to include a specified disclosure. The bill applies this requirement to “qualified political advertisements,” which is defined as “any paid advertisement, […] relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal state or local office, or a ballot measure, that contain any image, audio, or video that is generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.” The bill further identifies content “generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence” as content that is either entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic, or content that is materially altered by AI in such a way that it would cause a reasonable person to have a “fundamentally different understanding” of the media when compared to the original. Under both categories, the disclosure requirement would only apply if the use of AI results in deceptive material. Importantly for the purposes of this Committee, the bill authorizes any registered voter to bring a claim in superior court to enforce the bill’s requirements and grants the court the ability to issue either a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of the ad.
The First Amendment and this bill. The First Amendment to the United States Constitution provides that, “Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.” [Emphasis added.] As applied to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment, and as interpreted by the courts, the First Amendment prohibits any law or policy, at any level of government, from abridging freedom of speech. Legislation seeking to regulate speech can generally be distinguished as either content-based or content-neutral. Content-based laws, or laws that target a particular type of speech, must meet a strict scrutiny standard and must therefore be the least restrictive means to achieve a compelling government purpose in order to withstand legal challenge. Content neutral laws, or laws which serve a purpose unrelated to the speech itself, need only pass intermediate scrutiny. Under this standard, the law “need not be the least restrictive or least intrusive means of serving the government’s interests,” but “may not regulate expression in a manner that a substantial portion of the burden on speech does not serve to advance its goals.”
Political speech, including political advertisements, is granted the broadest application of First Amendment protections. (McIntyre v Ohio Election Commission (1997) 514 U.S. 334.) Thus, this bill would need to demonstrate that it is narrowly tailored to addressing a compelling government interest in order to pass legal muster. With regard to the second element at least, the proponents are likely able to clear the hurdle. The author identifies a need to ensure continued trust in the electoral process. Certainly, promoting faith in one of the foundational elements of our country’s democracy – fair and free elections – would be considered a compelling interest. Thus, the success of this new measure would rest on whether the requirement is narrowly tailored to address the compelling interest.
In a letter submitted on April 4, opponents of the bill argue that the bill may fail strict scrutiny due to its exceptions. Specifically they write, “this bill’s ‘exceptions’ for only some re-publishers, and by requiring them to assert that the ad ‘may have been generated by artificial intelligence,’ does not reflect the full First Amendment protection due the republication of speech pertaining to matters of public interest by those not connected with the creation of the offending material. […] By extending beyond the direct publishers of the content and toward re-publishers, A.B. 2355 burdens and [holds] liable re-publishers of content in a manner that has been found unconstitutional.”
Since the submission of this letter, the bill has been amended to seemingly address this concern. A prior version of this bill exempted certain publications, such as radio or television broadcasting stations and regularly published newspapers, that disseminated the qualified political advertisement as part of news coverage, “if the [broadcast or publication] states that the qualified political advertisement may have been generated, in whole or substantially, using artificial intelligence.” The quoted language has since been removed, and the subdivision in question now exempts radio or television broadcasting stations, or an internet website, newspaper, or magazine that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, that broadcast a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide news coverage.
Interestingly, the subdivision also exempts a radio or television broadcasting station when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement. As detailed in the Existing Law section, above, this language mirrors current prohibitions on materially deceptive audio or visual media relating to a candidate for office. However, in reviewing the legislative history that enacted that provision, it is not entirely clear what function this exemption serves. Arguably, at least in the context of this measure, this exemption is either redundant or risks creating a loophole in the intent of the bill. It is potentially redundant insofar as the definition of “qualified political advertisement” already requires the advertisement to be paid. Thus the exemption arguably reads that a television or radio broadcaster that pays for a paid political advertisement is exempt. Second, it creates a potential loophole for a television or broadcasting station that knows a qualified political ad is missing a requisite disclosure; as long as they receive some level of payment for it, they are not obligated to impose the disclosure themselves. Whether this loophole functions to undermine the intent of the bill is a different matter that ultimately rests on who the obligation is appropriately imposed upon. This issue is discussed in further detail in the areas of potential clarity below.
Section 230 and this bill. Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act (CDA) confers specified immunities to providers and users of interactive computer services. (47 USC Sec. 230 (c).) Subdivision (c) of the CDA breaks down the immunities into two separate categories – “treatment of publisher or speaker,” and “civil liability.” Under its language, an internet service provider cannot “be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.” Put plainly, websites and platforms cannot be held legally liable for the speech of another user on their platform. The purpose of this immunity is to acknowledge the role platforms play as conduits of information, rather than speakers themselves. Potentially contradictorily, the second immunity grants platforms protections from civil liability for decisions by a platform to remove or restrict content. It’s important to note that platforms are largely private businesses that can make decisions to remove content they disagree with or simply dislike without running afoul of the First Amendment.
For purposes of this measure, Section 230’s first immunity is the most relevant. As currently written, this bill authorizes a court to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the continued distribution of a qualified political advertisement that failed to include the requisite disclaimers. Like the language exempting television and radio broadcasters referenced above, this language mirrors existing law, and authorizes a court to order a stop to the publication or distribution of a qualified political advertisement that is not compliant with the disclosure requirement. To the extent the political advertisement is being distributed on internet platforms, however, that power may be significantly limited. The order may be issued against a user on a platform, however, Section 230 appears to immunize the platform itself from any liability.
Areas of potential clarity. As currently written, this bill imposes the disclosure requirement on a person, committee (as defined), or other entity that “creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes” a qualified political advertisement. It is not entirely clear what “originally publishes or originally distributes” refers to. It is possible to read this language as imposing a responsibility on multiple distinct parties – the creator, original publisher, original distributor, or any combination thereof. If it is only as to the creator who does not ultimately distribute or publish the material, then the disclosure may have no impact, nor serve any underlying purpose. If it is only the original publisher, then it is possible that the responsibility lies solely with whichever entity published first, although it may have been sold to multiple publishers. It is also possible that a creator does not disclose the fact that the ad was made using AI and thus an original publisher would have no way of knowing that the ad meets the bill’s qualifications. It is also possible to read “original distributor” or “original publisher” to capture someone who simply shares the ad – which could be either the creator or a completely distinct entity altogether. Finally, including both original distributor and original publisher creates additional ambiguity by raising the potential that the two are distinct – someone who provides an ad to be published may be considered a distributor while the entity that formally prints or disseminates the ad may be the publisher.
Take, for example, a political action committee that contracts first with a marketing firm to develop a qualified political advertisement and subsequently with a local newspaper to run the ad. Based on the language as currently written, the following are all potential parties responsible for imposing the disclosure: the marketing firm as the creator, the PAC as the distributor, or the newspaper as the publisher. The PAC could also arguably be considered the creator as they requested the ad from the marketing agency.
Additionally, a coalition of internet trade associations has submitted a position of support-if-amended and argue that “it is unclear if the deployers of AI systems could be held liable as an ‘entity that creates’ a political advertisement if a user chooses to use such a system to create some component that is subsequently published and distributed as a covered political advertisement. […] [I]t is impossible for the developers or deployers of such systems to predict how each and every individual may use generated audio or visual media. This places deployers of such technologies in the untenable scenario of having to predict each and every use of their product and risks chilling innovation.” Their suggested amendment adds the following as an exemption to the requirements of the bill:
20050 (b)(2)(E) A generally accessible generative AI system, if that system solely provides the generated content to the requesting user and does not itself further publish or distribute the generated content beyond.
Understanding that the intent of the bill is to promote labelling of content developed with AI that has potential to misinform or mislead voters, it seems a more accurate description of who is ultimately responsible for the disclaimer may be someone who both creates and disseminates the ad – in the case of the example above, the PAC itself. Specifying the scope of responsibility to an entity that creates and disseminates the product also serves a secondary purpose of narrowing the application of this new requirement, thus increasing chances of success on both a First Amendment and Section 230 challenge. As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider specifying who ultimately bears the responsibility of the disclosure requirements contemplated by this measure and may wish to specify that the person or entity that creates and disseminates the ad has the responsibility.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by the City of Pico Rivera and Oakland Privacy. A number of internet trade associations have submitted a position of support if amended. The City of Pico Rivera submits:
As a city that embraces technology and modern business practices, we recognize the increasing significance of AI in modern elections. With the proliferation of AI technologies, it is essential to ensure that constituents are aware of the tools employed in political advertising. By requiring disclosure that an advertisement was generated using AI, AB 2355 empowers voters to understand the technology behind ad creation, thus enhancing transparency in our electoral process.
The bill’s provisions resonate with our commitment to fostering accountability and transparency in governance, as outlined in the 2024 Pico Rivera Legislative Platform. By providing voters with essential information about the origin of political advertisements, AB 2355 promotes informed decision-making and strengthens the relationship between elected officials and the community.
Furthermore, AB 2355 serves as a vital safeguard against the dissemination of deceptive media, reinforcing our collective commitment to upholding the integrity of elections. By prohibiting the distribution of materially deceptive media intended to influence voter perception, the bill bolsters the credibility of our democratic process.
The California Chamber of Commerce, the Computer and Communications Industry Association, TechNet, and the Software and Information Industry Association request two amendments:
We appreciate that the bill has been amended to clarify that “a person, committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes'' a political advertisement to include certain disclosures to indicate whether the content was generated, in whole or substantially, using AI. However, further clarity is still needed to ensure that the appropriate party that knows how and for what purpose the content was created is held liable for disclosing whether it was generated using AI. While digital services may employ tools to identify and detect these materials with some degree of certainty, it is an evolving and imperfect science in its current form. It is therefore critical to ensure that liability for disclosures is appropriately targeted to the party who is responsible for originally publishing content for wider dissemination, as is the case under AB 2355. To that end, we request an amendment to clarify that this section does not apply to:
(B) An internet service provider, cloud provider, interactive computer service, or online service, an internet website, radio or television broadcasting station, including a cable or satellite television operator, programmer, or producer, when it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.
By requiring the original creators and publishers to adhere to AB 2355’s disclosure provisions, this will assist responsible digital platforms in being able to more easily discern between lawful election-related speech and misleading, deceptive speech intended to nefariously influence elections.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF). EFF writes:
We respectfully oppose A.B. 2355, authored by Assemblymember Carrillo, which not only requires that political advertisements generated through artificial intelligence have a disclosure stating so, but requires those who republish such advertisements to publish a vague and conditional disclaimer, even if they played no role in the creation of the advertisement or had any knowledge of its inauthenticity. We recognize the complex issues raised by potentially harmful artificially generated election ads. However, this bill’s “exceptions” for only some re-publishers, and by requiring them to assert that the ad “may have been generated by artificial intelligence,” does not reflect the full First Amendment protection due the republication of speech pertaining to matters of public interest by those not connected with the creation of the offending material.
The First Amendment requires this distinction between those who create synthetic media and those not directly involved in it. The Fourth Circuit relied on this distinction in striking down a Maryland law that extended the reach of campaign finance law to include ‘online platforms,’ thus imposing disclosure requirements on them when they ran online ads. AB 2355, as written, suffers from the same constitutional defect.
By extending beyond the direct publishers of the content and toward re-publishers, A.B. 2355 burdens and holding liable re-publishers of content in a manner that has been found unconstitutional.
The Chamber of Progress has submitted a position of oppose unless amended. The Chamber of Progress writes:
AB 2355 should hold advertisers responsible for disclosing gen-AI content in political ads
Requiring disclosure of AI generated content in political ads recognizes the First Amendment rights of candidates and helps voters cast informed ballots. However, as drafted AB 2355 includes obligations on online platforms regarding generative AI content. This obligation should instead reside with the advertiser. Advertisers have control over the content they produce, including digitally altered images, audio, and videos.
AB 2355 applies the disclosure requirement only to online media
Singling out online media for disclosure requirements regarding AI generated political advertisements while leaving out offline media creates differential treatment. This puts consumers of offline media at an informational disadvantage. Additionally, this may stifle innovation by discouraging the use of AI technologies and digital advertising. Ensuring equitable measures across both online and offline media platforms is essential to foster a level playing field and promote innovation.
AB 2355 needs additional clarity
The term “artificial intelligence” as currently defined in this bill is vague. Having an unclear definition of AI may cause confusion in the application of the requirements imposed by this bill. It is important to clarify this definition to eliminate ambiguity regarding what qualifies as AI and when the requirements are applied.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Pico Rivera
Oakland Privacy
Support if amended
California Chamber of Commerce
Computer and Communications Industry Association
Software & Information Industry Association
TechNet
Opposition
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Oppose unless amended
Chamber of Progress
Analysis Prepared by: Manuela Boucher-de la Cadena / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2355 (
Author:Wendy Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2024
SUBJECT: Political advertisements: artificial intelligence
SYNOPSIS
The creation of audio and visual media by generative artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to change the world by automating repetitive tasks and fostering creativity. When employed by bad actors, however, these capabilities have the potential to destroy lives and destabilize societies. In the context of election campaigns, such deepfakes can be weaponized to deceive voters into thinking that a candidate said or did something the candidate did not. In an attempt to prevent deepfakes from altering the outcome of an election in this way, California enacted laws in 2019 that restrict the use of deepfakes within 60 days of an election and that provide impacted candidates with a legal mechanism for trying to prevent deepfakes from circulating during that time period.
Since that time, the capabilities of generative AI have advanced dramatically. The author argues that “[s]ince the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvements in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled.”
This author-sponsored measure would require specified disclosures in political advertisements that are either wholly generated by AI and falsely appear to be authentic, or that are deceptively manipulated by AI. Because the bill was recently narrowed, stakeholders have not had an opportunity to register updated positions. However, this analysis details some of their positions on the prior iteration of the bill.
This bill was passed by the Elections Committee on a 7-1 vote. If it passes this Committee, it will next be heard in the Judiciary Committee.
SUMMARY: Requires an entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a political advertisement that was generated or substantially altered using AI to include a clear and conspicuous disclosure stating this fact. Enables registered voters to go to superior court to seek a temporary or permanent restraining order against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any such political advertisement that does not comply with the disclosure requirement. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires any entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a “qualified political advertisement”—any paid advertisement, relating to a candidate for elective office or a ballot message, that is “generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence”—to include, in a clear and conspicuous manner, the following disclosure: “This (audio, image, or video, as applicable) has been generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence.”
- Defines “generated or substantially altered using artificial intelligence” as visual or audio media that is either of the following:
- Entirely created using artificial intelligence and would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic.
- Materially altered by artificial intelligence such that the alteration would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding of the altered media when comparing it to an unaltered version.
- Specifies the form of the disclosure depending on whether the qualified political advertisement is in visual or audio media.
- Provides that the bill does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code.
- Excludes from the disclosure requirement the following:
- Radio or television broadcasting stations that broadcast a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide news communication or for compensation.
- Internet websites and periodicals that routinely carry news and commentary that publishes a qualified political advertisement as part of a bona fide news communication.
- Qualified political advertisements that constitute satire or parody.
- Enables registered voters to go to superior court to seek a temporary or permanent restraining order against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that does not comply with the disclosure requirement set forth above. Requires that cases of this nature be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal, so as to assure speedy disposition of cases of this nature.
- Defines other key terms, including “artificial intelligence,” which means an engineered or machine-based system that varies in its level of autonomy and that can, for explicit or implicit objectives, infer from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual environments.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person, committee, or other entity, until January 1, 2027, from distributing with actual malice, within 60 days of an election at which a candidate for elective office will appear on the ballot, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate.
- Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media,” for these purposes, as an image or an audio or visual recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner that both of the following are true about the image or audio or video recording:
- It would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic; and,
- It would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the image or audio or video recording than the person would have if the person were hearing or seeing the unaltered, original version of the image or audio or video recording.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply if the audio or visual media includes a disclaimer stating “This (image/video/audio) has been manipulated,” and the disclaimer complies with specified requirements.
- Permits a candidate whose voice or likeness appears in deceptive audio or visual media distributed in violation of this provision to seek the following relief:
- Injunctive or other equitable relief prohibiting the distribution of the materially deceptive audio or visual media in violation of this bill. Provides that such an action is entitled to precedence in court, as specified.
- General or special damages against the person, committee, or other entity that distributed that audio or visual media. Permits the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to a prevailing party in such an action.
- Provides that in any civil action brought pursuant to these provisions, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing the violation through clear and convincing evidence.
- Provides that this prohibition shall not be construed to alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply to any of the following:
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- When it broadcasts materially deceptive audio or visual media as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or disclosure that there are questions about the authenticity of the audio or visual media, as specified.
- When it is paid to broadcast materially deceptive audio or visual media.
- When it broadcasts materially deceptive audio or visual media as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or disclosure that there are questions about the authenticity of the audio or visual media, as specified.
- An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes materially deceptive audio or visual media covered by this prohibition, if the publication clearly states that the media does not accurately represent the speech or conduct of the candidate.
- Materially deceptive audio or visual media that constitute satire or parody. (Elections Code §20010.)
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media,” for these purposes, as an image or an audio or visual recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner that both of the following are true about the image or audio or video recording:
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print, the bill is keyed nonfiscal.
COMMENTS:
- Political deepfakes. AI technology is being used around the world to spread disinformation and propaganda. 2024 is a major election year in democracies around the globe: at least 64 countries will hold elections, representing close to 49% of the world’s population. It is also likely to be the first of many election years in which AI plays a pivotal role, as the technology becomes more widely available and easier to use. This has already been observed in Slovakia, where AI-generated audio influenced an election in 2023:
Days before a pivotal election in Slovakia to determine who would lead the country, a damning audio recording spread online in which one of the top candidates seemingly boasted about how he’d rigged the election. And if that wasn’t bad enough, his voice could be heard on another recording talking about raising the cost of beer. The recordings immediately went viral on social media, and the candidate, who is pro-NATO and aligned with Western interests, was defeated in September by an opponent who supported closer ties to Moscow and Russian President Vladimir Putin.[1]
Similar technologies have now been deployed in the United States in advance of the 2024 presidential election. In late January, between 5,000 and 20,000 New Hampshire residents received AI-generated phone calls impersonating President Biden that told them not to vote in the state’s primary.[2] The call told voters: “It’s important that you save your vote for the November election.” Concern about this call has led at least 14 states to introduce legislation targeting AI-powered disinformation. It is still unclear how many people might not have voted based on these calls.
Deepfakes are not only being deployed by third parties; they can be used by the candidates themselves, either to improve their own self-images or to detract from their opponents. In mid-2023, former Republican presidential candidate Governor Ron DeSantis used AI to add fighter jets to one of his campaign videos.[3] Around the same time, Governor DeSantis’ super PAC released an ad containing an AI-generated speech by former president Donald Trump.[4] The Republican National Committee also released a 30-second ad that displayed images of disorder and destruction, with a voiceover that described the “consequences” of re-electing President Biden.[5] None of the images in this ad were real.
2) Author’s statement. According to the author:
Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvements in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.
3) Comparison with existing elections deepfake laws. AB 730 (Berman, Ch. 493, Stats. 2019) added Elections Code section 20010 to target political deepfakes that manipulate original media of a candidate for elective office in the run-up to an election. That section prohibits distribution of “materially deceptive audio or visual media” within 60 days of an election when done with actual malice and intent to deceive a voter into voting for or against a candidate.[6] This prohibition, however, does not apply if the media includes a disclosure stating that it has been manipulated.[7] “Materially deceptive audio or visual media” means an image or audio recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech, or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated such that it would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic and would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the recording, as compared to the original version.[8] That section enables candidates whose likeness appears in deepfakes to seek injunctive relief and recover damages.[9]
Whereas section 20010 narrowly focuses on manipulated imagery that is essentially defamatory, this bill more broadly focuses on any content that is generated by AI. In several additional respects it exceeds the scope of its predecessor. First, it applies to “qualified political advertisements” about not just candidates but ballot measures as well. Second, the original creator or publisher of the content need not have “actual malice” nor intend to induce voters to vote differently. Third, the bill applies to advertisements that, regardless of the intent of the creator, would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic or would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the recording, as compared to the original version. Fourth, section 20010 applies only within 60 days of an election. This bill has no such time limitations. Fifth, it enables any registered voter—not just an affected candidate—to seek injunctive relief. The bill does not, however, provide for civil damages.
In its support letter on a prior iteration of the bill that appears to be broadly applicable to the policy focus of the revised bill, Oakland Privacy wrote:
Generative artificial intelligence can now create fake (i.e. artificial) content that can seem to decisively indicate that someone said something they didn’t say, was at a location they never visited or that statistics and other factual material that impacts policy are not accurate when they are. Unlike mere “claims” that can be rebutted; generative AI can provide what seems like dispositive evidence of truth or falsity, but is a mere computer projection of bits and bytes. This can wreak havoc on a voter’s ability to research what is true and what is not and make their decisions accordingly.
Assembly Bill 2355 seeks to help voters in this position by simply requiring that synthetic content be labeled as such, so it is therefore harder to use generative AI election content as evidence of truth or falsity. This provision is literally structured in the same manner as long-standing California election law that requires the labeling of paid political advertisements. As such, the requirement is straightforward, understandable to those that would have to abide by it, doesn’t depend on unreliable technologies like watermarking, and shouldn’t confuse voters or require them to understand a lot about AI to benefit from the legislation.
4) Who is subject to enforcement? Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act of 1996 states that “[n]o provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.”[10] That section also provides that “[n]o cause of action may be brought and no liability may be imposed under any State or local law that is inconsistent with this section.”[11] This bill does not subject online platforms to damages for republication of a qualified political advertisement that lacks a disclosure; rather it simply enables voters to obtain injunctive relieve—that is, a temporary or permanent restraining order—to remove the offending content.
However, section 230 still immunizes such intermediaries from such injunctive relief. As the California Supreme Court stated in 2018: “For almost two decades, courts have been relying on section 230 to deny plaintiffs injunctive relief when their claims inherently treat an Internet intermediary as a publisher or speaker of third party conduct. . . . Yet Congress has declined to amend section 230 to authorize injunctive relief against mere republishers, even as it has limited immunity in other ways.”[12] The broad language of section 230 “conveys an intent to shield Internet intermediaries from the burdens associated with defending against state law claims that treat them as the publisher or speaker of third party content, and from compelled compliance with demands for relief that . . . assign them the legal role and responsibilities of a publisher qua publisher.”[13] The court concluded, “Section 230 allows these litigation burdens to be imposed upon the originators of online speech. But the unique position of Internet intermediaries convinced Congress to spare republishers of online content, in a situation such as the one here, from this sort of ongoing entanglement with the courts.”[14] As such, section 230 appears to immunize online republishers from suits to remove noncompliant advertisements under this bill.
Moreover, although some stakeholders suggest that the bill could be construed to apply to GenAI systems that are used by content creators who create advertisements, injunctive relief is only available against “publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution”—not the creation of such advertisements. Nevertheless, the author may wish to continue to work with stakeholders to fully clarify the scope of the bill.
5) First Amendment considerations. The United States and California Constitutions prohibit abridging, among other fundamental rights, freedom of speech.[15] This bill implicates speech in two ways.
First, the bill compels speech by requiring a disclaimer on a political advertisement containing AI-generated media. Because the right to speak encompasses the right not to speak, this provision implicates the First Amendment.[16] Because the disclaimer does not “‘alter[] the content’”[17] of the actual message of a political advertisement, it is content neutral. As such it would be subject to the “intermediate scrutiny” test, which requires that the law “be ‘narrowly tailored to serve a significant government interest.’”[18] In other words, the law “‘need not be the least restrictive or least intrusive means of’ serving the government’s interests,” but “‘may not regulate expression in such a manner that a substantial portion of the burden on speech does not serve to advance its goals.’”[19]
Second, the bill restricts speech by enabling registered voters to seek a temporary or permanent injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of any qualified political advertisement that does not contain a required disclosure. Because it pertains to a particular subject matter—political advertisements relating to candidates or ballot measures—the restriction is specific to a type of content.[20] Content-based restrictions on protected speech are subject to “strict scrutiny” and thus are presumptively unconstitutional, valid only if the government proves they are narrowly tailored to further a compelling interest—meaning the law must use the least restrictive means available to further that interest.[21]
Here, the disclosure requirement is intended to advance the author’s goal of making the public aware of when it encounters political advertisements with synthetic content, much of which could be deeply misleading. Such labeling will also help the public differentiate authentic content, enabling voters to confidently make choices informed through an accurate understanding of the provenance of what they’re seeing and hearing in political advertisements—a compelling government interest.
As to the means of serving that interest, the introduced version of the bill would have covered virtually any content that was at least partially generated by AI. This not only risked diluting the effectiveness of the disclosure requirement but likely ran afoul of the First Amendment by burdening portions of speech beyond that necessary to achieve the author’s goals. The bill has since been substantially narrowed to encompass those circumstances in which the content was generated entirely by AI and falsely appears to be authentic, or those in which the content has been manipulated such that it would cause a reasonable person to experience the expressive conduct in a fundamentally different way. Nevertheless, given the exacting standard this bill must meet, the author is encouraged to continue seeking ways of tightening the scope of the bill to insulate it from constitutional challenge. These issues will continue to be addressed in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
6) Related Legislation. AB 2655 (Berman, 2024) requires large online platforms to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, during specified periods before and after an election. The bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2839 (Pellerin, 2024) prohibits the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications that are materially deceptive and digitally altered or created, except as specified. The bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 972 (Berman, Ch. 745, Stats. 2020) extended the sunset date on AB 730 to 2027.
AB 730 (Berman, Ch. 493, Stats. 2019) was identical to this bill except that its sunset provision repeals the statute it enacted effective January 1, 2023.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The City of Pico Rivera writes that “[w]ith the proliferation of AI technologies, it is essential to ensure that constituents are aware of the tools employed in political advertising. By requiring the disclosure that an advertisement was generated using AI, AB 2355 empowers voters to understand the technology behind ad creation, thus enhancing transparency in our electoral process.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Pico Rivera
Oakland Privacy
Support If Amended
California Chamber of Commerce
Computer and Communications Industry Association
Software & Information Industry Association
Technet
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tosney / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Curt Devine, Donie O'Sullivan, Sean Lyngass, “A fake recording of a candidate saying he’d rigged the election went viral. Experts say it’s only the beginning,” CNN, Feb. 1, 2024, www.cnn.com/2024/02/01/politics/election-deepfake-threats-invs/index.html. ↑
Cat Zakrzewski and Pranshu Verma, “New Hampshire opens criminal probe into AI calls impersonating Biden,” Washington Post, Feb. 6, 2024, www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2024/02/06/nh-robocalls-ai-biden/. ↑
Ana Faguy, “New DeSantis Ad Superimposes Fighter Jets In AI-Altered Video Of Speech,” Forbes, May 25, 2023, www.forbes.com/sites/anafaguy/2023/05/25/new-desantis-ad-superimposes-fighter-jets-in-ai-altered-video-ofspeech/. ↑
Alex Isenstadt, “DeSantis PAC uses AI-generated Trump voice in ad attacking ex-president,” Politico, July 17, 2023, www.politico.com/news/2023/07/17/desantis-pac-ai-generated-trump-in-ad-00106695. ↑
GOP, “Beat Biden,” April 25, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLMMxgtxQ1Y. ↑
Id. at (a). ↑
Id. at (b). ↑
Id. at (e). ↑
Id. at (c). ↑
47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1). ↑
Id. at (e)(3), emphasis added. ↑
Hassell v. Bird (2018) 5 Cal.5th 522, 547. ↑
Id. at p. 544. ↑
Id. at p. 545. ↑
U.S. Const., 1st and 14th Amends; Cal. Const. art. I, § 2. ↑
U.S. v. United Foods, Inc. (2001) 533 U.S. 405, 410. ↑
Nat’l Inst. of Family & Life Advocates v. Becerra (2018) 138 S.Ct. 2361, 2371. ↑
Packingham v. North Carolina (2017) 582 U.S. 98, 98. ↑
McCullen v. Coakley (2014) 573 U.S. 464, 486. ↑
See FCC v. League of Women Voters (1984) 468 U.S. 364, 383. ↑
Sable Communications of Cal. v. FCC (1989) 492 U.S. 115, 126.; Ashcroft v. ACLU (2004) 542 U.S. 656, 670; see Reed v. Town of Gilbert (2015) 135 S.Ct. 2218, 222; United States v. Playboy Entertainment Group (2000) 529 U.S. 803, 813. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
Gail Pellerin, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2355 (
Author:Wendy Carrillo) – As Introduced Ver:February 12, 2024
SUBJECT: Political advertisements: artificial intelligence.
SUMMARY: Requires any political advertisement, as specified, that is generated in whole or in part using artificial intelligence (AI), to include a disclaimer stating that fact. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person, political committee, or other entity that creates, originally publishes, or originally distributes a qualified political advertisement, as defined, to include the following disclaimer in the advertisement in a clear and conspicuous manner: “This [audio/image/video] has been generated, in whole or in part, using artificial intelligence.”
Requires this disclaimer to comply with the following:- In the case of visual media, requires the text of the disclaimer to appear in a size that is easily readable, as specified.
- In the case of a video, requires the disclaimer to appear for the duration of the video.
- In the case of media that consists of audio only, requires the disclaimer to be read in a manner that can be easily heard by the average listener at both the beginning and the end of the audio. For audio that is longer than two minutes, the disclaimer must also be included during the audio at intervals of not more than two minutes each.
- In the case of visual media, requires the text of the disclaimer to appear in a size that is easily readable, as specified.
- Provides that this bill does not alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to any of the following:
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- When it broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of bona fide news coverage if the broadcast clearly acknowledges that the advertisement may have been generated using AI, as specified.
- When it is paid to broadcast a qualified political advertisement.
- When it broadcasts a qualified political advertisement as part of bona fide news coverage if the broadcast clearly acknowledges that the advertisement may have been generated using AI, as specified.
- An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes a qualified political advertisement, if the publication clearly states that the advertisement may have been generated using AI.
- A qualified political advertisement that constitutes satire or parody.
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- Permits a superior court, in a case brought before it by a registered voter, to issue a temporary or permanent restraining order or injunction against the publication, printing, circulation, posting, or distribution of a qualified political advertisement in violation of this bill. Provides that all cases of this nature shall be in a preferred position for purposes of trial and appeal.
- Defines the following terms, for the purpose of this bill:
- “Artificial intelligence” to mean a machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments, and that uses machine and human-based inputs to do all of the following:
- Perceive real and virtual environments.
- Abstract such perceptions into models through analysis in an automated manner.
- Use model inference to formulate options for information or action.
- Perceive real and virtual environments.
- “Qualified political advertisement” to mean any paid advertisement, including search engine marketing, display advertisements, video advertisements, native advertisements, issue advertisements, printed advertisements, messaging service advertisements, mobile application advertisements, prerecorded telephone message advertisements, or sponsorships, relating to a candidate for federal, state, or local office, any election to federal, state, or local office, a ballot measure, or a bond issue, that contains any image, audio, or video that is generated, in whole or in part, using AI.
- “Artificial intelligence” to mean a machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments, and that uses machine and human-based inputs to do all of the following:
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Prohibits a person, committee, or other entity, until January 1, 2027, from distributing with actual malice, within 60 days of an election at which a candidate for elective office will appear on the ballot, materially deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate with the intent to injure the candidate’s reputation or to deceive a voter into voting for or against the candidate.
- Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media,” for these purposes, as an image or an audio or visual recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner that both of the following are true about the image or audio or video recording:
- It would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be authentic; and,
- It would cause a reasonable person to have a fundamentally different understanding or impression of the expressive content of the image or audio or video recording than the person would have if the person were hearing or seeing the unaltered, original version of the image or audio or video recording.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply if the audio or visual media includes a disclaimer stating “This (image/video/audio) has been manipulated,” and the disclaimer complies with specified requirements.
- Permits a candidate whose voice or likeness appears in deceptive audio or visual media distributed in violation of this provision to seek the following relief:
- Injunctive or other equitable relief prohibiting the distribution of the materially deceptive audio or visual media in violation of this bill. Provides that such an action is entitled to precedence in court, as specified.
- General or special damages against the person, committee, or other entity that distributed that audio or visual media. Permits the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to a prevailing party in such an action.
- Provides that in any civil action brought pursuant to these provisions, the plaintiff bears the burden of establishing the violation through clear and convincing evidence.
- Provides that this prohibition shall not be construed to alter or negate any rights, obligations, or immunities of an interactive service provider under Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.
- Provides that this prohibition does not apply to any of the following:
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- When it broadcasts materially deceptive audio or visual media as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or disclosure that there are questions about the authenticity of the audio or visual media, as specified.
- When it is paid to broadcast materially deceptive audio or visual media.
- When it broadcasts materially deceptive audio or visual media as part of a bona fide newscast, news interview, news documentary, or on-the-spot coverage of bona fide news events, if the broadcast clearly acknowledges through content or disclosure that there are questions about the authenticity of the audio or visual media, as specified.
- An internet website, or a regularly published newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation, including an internet or electronic publication, that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest, and that publishes materially deceptive audio or visual media covered by this prohibition, if the publication clearly states that the media does not accurately represent the speech or conduct of the candidate.
- Materially deceptive audio or visual media that constitute satire or parody. (Elections Code §20010, as amended by Section 3 of Chapter 745 of the Statutes of 2022)
- A radio or television broadcasting station, as specified, in either of the following circumstances:
- Defines “materially deceptive audio or visual media,” for these purposes, as an image or an audio or visual recording of a candidate’s appearance, speech or conduct that has been intentionally manipulated in a manner that both of the following are true about the image or audio or video recording:
- Prohibits a person, firm, association, corporation, campaign committee, or organization, beginning January 1, 2027, with actual malice, from producing, distributing, publishing, or broadcasting campaign material, as defined, that contains either of the following types of pictures or photographs, as specified, unless the campaign material includes a disclaimer that the picture is not an accurate representation of fact:
- A picture or photograph of a person or persons into which the image of a candidate for public office is superimposed.
- A picture or photograph of a candidate for public office into which the image of another person or persons is superimposed. (Elections Code §20010, as amended by Section 4 of Chapter 745 of the Statutes of 2022)
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW provides, pursuant to Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, that no provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. (47 U.S.C. §230)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. As currently in-print, this bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
Since the broad public release of generative AI applications to create sound, video, photos, and text since 2022, we have seen widespread adoption of and noticeable technological improvements in these tools. In a world where fabricated material is easier to create than ever before, protections are needed to ensure that content created by digital tools is properly labelled. Sensible regulation of this type of digital content balances free speech protections with the need to protect and uphold faith in our electoral democracy.
- Broad Application and Suggested Amendments: As currently drafted, this bill requires every qualified political advertisement that contains any audio, image, or video that was in any way created or altered by AI to contain a disclaimer on the advertisement. Even in situations where the alterations made by AI were not misleading, and did not fundamentally change a reasonable person’s understanding of the content, this bill would require the advertisement to include a disclaimer that it was generated using AI.
The definition of the term AI in this bill appears to be broad enough to apply to a large number of common tools that are regularly used without any deceptive intent or effect. For example, the cameras on smartphones typically include tools that automatically make adjustments to the images captured by those cameras, including changes like color correction and adjustments to contrast and lighting. Even an autofocus feature on a camera appears to fall within this bill’s definition of AI.
While the definition of the term AI is outside the scope of this committee’s jurisdiction, given this broad application, it is possible that this bill could require a disclaimer to appear on virtually every campaign advertisement that contains any audio, photo, or video that was generated and captured in the last few years. In many of these cases, the person who captured the audio, photo, or video may not necessarily know that the media was generated in whole or in part using AI.
To the extent that this bill requires a large percentage of campaign advertisements to include disclaimers that they were generated using AI, the value of those disclaimers is unclear. While disclaimers can provide the public with important information, if the effect of this bill is to require disclaimers to appear on virtually every campaign advertisement, it is less clear whether the public will pay attention to those disclaimers or attach any significance to their inclusion on a campaign advertisement. Alternately, the widespread inclusion of disclaimers on political advertisements stating that those advertisements were generated in whole or in part using AI could cause voters to distrust political advertisements that they receive even when there is no basis for that distrust. If the only way that AI is used in the creation of a political advertisement is with standard photo processing tools like autofocus and minor lighting adjustments, will a disclaimer that the advertisement was generated or altered using AI be useful and meaningful information for the viewer, or is it more likely to give that viewer an inaccurate impression that the advertisement has been altered in more substantive ways?
Unlike other legislation that is being heard in this committee today dealing with campaign communications that have been altered using digital tools including AI, nothing in this bill limits its application to materials that have been altered in ways that are deceptive or that otherwise leave a viewer with a materially different understanding of the content when compared to the unaltered material. While the author has expressed concern about AI being used to mislead voters or to suppress participation in elections, nothing in this bill limits the disclaimer requirement to applications of AI that are likely to have those effects.
According to background information provided by the author’s office, this bill is modeled after legislation that was recently enacted in Michigan. That bill – House Bill (HB) 5141 – is indeed similar to the text of this bill. There is, however, a significant difference between this bill and Michigan’s HB 5141. While this bill requires a disclaimer on a political advertisement that contains an image, audio, or video that is generated in whole or in part using AI, Michigan’s law applies only if an image, audio, or video was generated in whole or substantially with the use of AI. While Michigan’s law does not appear to define the term “substantially,” that difference could have significant implications for the types of communications that are (or are not) required to include disclaimers. In particular, there is a strong argument that Michigan’s bill does not require the inclusion of a disclaimer on a political advertisement where AI was responsible for only minor alterations to an image, audio, or video, and where those alterations did not materially change a viewer’s understanding when compared to the unaltered media.
To address these concerns, committee staff recommends that this bill be amended to apply not to images, audio, and video that were generated in whole or in part using AI, but instead to apply to images, audio, and video that were generated in whole or substantially using AI. Committee staff further recommends that the bill be amended to provide that media is considered to have been generated substantially using AI only if the media was created or materially altered using AI, and that an image, audio, or video is not substantially generated using AI if it has only minor alterations. - Free Speech Considerations: The First Amendment to the United States (US) Constitution, which also applies to states under the Fourteenth Amendment, provides in relevant part “Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech…” Similarly, Section 2 of Article I of the California Constitution provides in relevant part "Every person may freely speak, write, and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. A law may not restrain or abridge liberty of speech or press.”
Courts have consistently recognized that laws that compel speech can impact free speech rights, because the associated burden and penalties for noncompliance may discourage people from speaking altogether. In Citizens United v. FEC, the Supreme Court applied exacting scrutiny to requirements that certain political advertisements include disclaimers, and described exacting scrutiny as requiring a “‘substantial relation’ between the disclosure requirement and a ‘sufficiently important’ governmental interest” Citizens United v. FEC (2010), 558 US 310, 366-367.
Whether the disclaimer requirement that this bill imposes would be susceptible to a potential constitutional challenge is a question that falls more squarely within the jurisdiction of the Assembly Judiciary Committee. However, as discussed in greater detail above, the current version of this bill appears to require disclaimers to appear on political advertisements that contain media that was generated using AI even when the alterations to the media made by AI were minor, and did not fundamentally change the expressive content of the media. Limiting the disclaimer requirement to situations where political advertisements include media that was materially altered by AI, as proposed above, may help strengthen the argument that the disclaimer requirements in this bill are tailored to address the potential harms posed by misleading and deceptive campaign materials. - Bond Issues and Suggested Amendments: The definition of “qualified political advertisement” that appears in this bill includes advertisements that relate to ballot measures and bond issues. To the extent that a bond issue is appearing on the ballot for the voters’ consideration, however, that bond issue is already considered a ballot measure under existing law. As such, the inclusion of bond issues within the definition of “qualified political advertisement” seems duplicative and unnecessary. Accordingly, committee staff recommends that this bill be amended to delete all references to bond issues.
- Technical Amendment: Committee staff recommends the following technical amendment to this bill: On page 4, line 13 of the bill, delete one of the duplicative uses of the word “means.”
- Arguments in Support: In support of this bill, Oakland Privacy writes:
Generative artificial intelligence can now create fake (i.e. artificial) content that can seem to decisively indicate that someone said something they didn’t say, was at a location they never visited or that statistics and other factual material that impacts policy are not accurate when they are. Unlike mere “claims” that can be rebutted; generative AI can provide what seems like dispositive evidence of truth or falsity, but is a mere computer projection of bits and bytes. This can wreak havoc on a voter’s ability to research what is true and what is not and make their decisions accordingly.
Assembly Bill 2355 seeks to help voters in this position by simply requiring that synthetic content be labeled as such, so it is therefore harder to use generative AI election content as evidence of truth or falsity. This provision is literally structured in the same manner as long-standing California election law that requires the labeling of paid political advertisements. As such, the requirement is straightforward, understandable to those that would have to abide by it, doesn’t depend on unreliable technologies like watermarking, and shouldn’t confuse voters or require them to understand a lot about AI to benefit from the legislation.
- Arguments in Opposition: The Electronic Frontier Foundation writes in opposition to this bill:
We respectfully oppose A.B. 2355, authored by Assemblymember Carrillo, which not only requires that political advertisements generated through artificial intelligence have a disclosure stating so, but requires those who republish such advertisements to publish a vague and conditional disclaimer, even if they played no role in the creation of the advertisement or had any knowledge of its inauthenticity. We recognize the complex issues raised by potentially harmful artificially generated election ads. However, this bill’s “exceptions” for only some re-publishers, and by requiring them to assert that the ad “may have been generated by artificial intelligence,” does not reflect the full First Amendment protection due the republication of speech pertaining to matters of public interest by those not connected with the creation of the offending material.
The First Amendment requires this distinction between those who create synthetic media and those not directly involved in it. The Fourth Circuit relied on this distinction in striking down a Maryland law that extended the reach of campaign finance law to include ‘online platforms,’ thus imposing disclosure requirements on them when they ran online ads. AB 2355, as written, suffers from the same constitutional defect.
- Related Legislation: AB 2655 (Berman), which is also being heard in this committee today, requires large online platforms to block the posting or sending of materially deceptive and digitally modified or created content related to elections, or to label that content, during specified periods before and after an election.
AB 2839 (Pellerin), which is also being heard in this committee today, prohibits the distribution of campaign advertisements and other election communications that are materially deceptive and digitally altered or created, except as specified. - Triple-Referral: This bill has also been referred to the Assembly Privacy & Consumer Protection Committee and the Assembly Judiciary Committee. This committee analysis focuses primarily on issues that fall within the jurisdiction of the Assembly Elections Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Chamber of Commerce (if amended)
Computer and Communications Industry Association (if amended)
Oakland Privacy
Software & Information Industry Association (if amended)
TechNet (if amended)
Opposition
Chamber of Progress (unless amended)
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):