AB 560: Civil actions: immigration status.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-08-10
Existing law declares that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law are available to all individuals in the state who have applied for employment or are employed, regardless of immigration status, as specified. Existing law also declares, for the purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a persons immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and that discovery into a persons immigration status is prohibited unless the person seeking to make the inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy and would prohibit discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding into a minor childs immigration status, with specified exceptions.
Existing law declares that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law are available to all individuals in the state who have applied for employment or are employed, regardless of immigration status, as specified. Existing law also declares, for the purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a persons immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and that discovery into a persons immigration status is prohibited unless the person seeking to make the inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy and would prohibit discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding into a minor childs immigration status, with specified exceptions.
Existing law declares that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law are available to all individuals in the state who have applied for employment or are employed, regardless of immigration status, as specified. Existing law also declares, for the purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a persons immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and that discovery into a persons immigration status is prohibited unless the person seeking to make the inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy and would prohibit discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding into a minor childs immigration status, with specified exceptions.
Existing law declares that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law are available to all individuals in the state who have applied for employment or are employed, regardless of immigration status, as specified. Existing law also declares, for the purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a persons immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and that discovery into a persons immigration status is prohibited unless the person seeking to make the inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy and would prohibit discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding into a minor childs immigration status, with specified exceptions.
Existing law declares that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law are available to all individuals in the state who have applied for employment or are employed, regardless of immigration status, as specified. Existing law also declares, for the purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a persons immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and that discovery into a persons immigration status is prohibited unless the person seeking to make the inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy and would prohibit discovery into a minor childs immigration status, with specified exceptions.
(a)The immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
(b)Discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor childs immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor childs claims place the minor childs immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
(c)The provisions of this section are declaratory of existing law.
(d)The express application of this act to minors is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
(a)The immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
(b)Discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor childs immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor childs claims place the minor childs immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
(c)The provisions of this section are declaratory of existing law.
(d)The express application of this act to minors is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
(a)The immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
(b)Discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor childs immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor childs claims place the minor childs immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
(c)The provisions of this section are declaratory of existing law.
(d)The express application of this act to minors is not intended to address in any way imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
(a)The immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
(b)Discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor childs immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor childs claims place the minor childs immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
(c)The provisions of this section are declaratory of existing law.
(d)The express application of this act to minors is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
(a)The immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
(b)Discovery relating to a minor childs immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor childs claims place the minor childs immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
(c)The provisions of this section are declaratory of existing law.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 10, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 10, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 151, Statutes of 2015. |
| Aug 3, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Jul 16, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 56. Noes 21. Page 2414.). |
| Jul 16, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after July 15 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 30. Noes 4. Page 1898.). |
| Jul 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 23, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 22, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 16). |
| May 7, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 27, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 27, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 54. Noes 22. Page 1140.) |
| Apr 27, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 20, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 16, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (April 14). |
| Mar 5, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 24, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 26. |
| Feb 23, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2015 | AB 560 GOMEZ Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 13, 2015 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB560 Gomez By Hueso | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 16, 2015 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 27, 2015 | AB 560 GOMEZ Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 14, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 560
Page 3
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
AB 560
(Gomez)
As Amended June 23, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: |
54-22 |
(April 27, 2015) |
SENATE: |
30-4 |
(July 13, 2015) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Adds a section to the Code of Civil Procedure that bars the consideration of a child's immigration status in civil actions involving liability or remedy. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that in actions involving a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law, the child’s immigration status is irrelevant.
Provides that discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status is impermissible, except where the minor child's claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
Provides that the express application of this act is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
The Senate amendments make a technical change and add co-authors.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state.
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person's immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, a person's immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person's immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: A lawsuit by more than 80 elementary school children against the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) for alleged sexual misconduct by one of the district’s former teachers was recently settled. The plaintiffs attended Miramonte Elementary School, which is located in a community in South Los Angeles. Many of the victims in the lawsuit are undocumented. During the litigation phase of the case, attorneys for the plaintiffs filed motions to preclude inquiry into the immigration status of the plaintiffs in the case. In response, the attorneys for the LAUSD requested that the court deny the plaintiffs' motion based on the holding in Hernández v. Paicius (2003) 109 Cal. App. 4th 425, 460, which held that if a plaintiff is seeking damages for loss of earnings or lost wages, the plaintiff’s immigration status is relevant to the determination of the plaintiff's potential for earning money in the future. The defendants argued that evidence of the students' immigration status was directly relevant to the determination of their potential future earning capacity, and should therefore be considered for determination of damages in the case.
Current law provides that immigration status is irrelevant for the purposes of liability in enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, unless the person making the inquiry can show by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. While, existing law specifies a number of situations where immigration status is not to be considered, it does not address protections for minor children or personal injury matters. This bill establishes that the immigration status of a minor child, under any applicable law, is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, unless the status is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill prohibits discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding about a child's immigration status, except in situations where the child places his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking to make the inquiry shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill clearly states that its provision are not intended to address that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
Future loss of earnings as damages. According to an article by Ken LaMance, Future Loss of Earnings or Wages (Legal Match www.legalmatch.com/law-library), future loss of earnings are damages awarded in personal injury cases when the injury has permanently limited the plaintiff's ability to earn wages. The plaintiff is then entitled to recover the reduction in value of his or her future earning capacity. Awards of loss of future earnings are based on the person’s potential to make money, even if that person has never exercised earning potential. For the child plaintiffs in the lawsuit against the LAUSD, an award for future loss of earnings would be calculated based on each child’s ability to earn money.
The nexus between future loss of earnings and citizenship. The problem with determining future loss of earnings for undocumented children is that current case law allows an award of damages to be based on a person’s projected earning capacity, but also assumes that an undocumented plaintiff will be deported to his or her country of lawful citizenship. So although the children in the Miramonte case suffered similar harms, those who are United States citizens are awarded future earnings based on wages in the United States, while the undocumented children are awarded future earnings based upon wages in Mexico or another country outside of the United States, which tend to be much lower. This result is unfair, especially because it involves children who all reside in the United States, attend school in the United States, and suffered harm in the United States.
In Rodriguez v. Kline (1986) 186 Cal. App. 3rd 1145, the California Court of Appeals found that damages for loss of earnings to a defendant who is undocumented should be awarded based upon his projected earning capacity after deportation to the country of his lawful citizenship. This is the reason why the LAUSD sought to keep the issue of immigration status relevant in the case before it ultimately settled. In all fairness to the defendant, the LAUSD did move to strike that defense during litigation of the case.
Necessity of this bill. Existing law prohibits inquiry into a person's immigration status for specific purposes, namely for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws. Existing law also provides that a person's immigration status is irrelevant to specific inquiries – the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws – and that no inquiry shall be permitted into a person's immigration status in those contexts.
These existing laws protect adults from inquiry into their immigration status when they are fighting for their civil and other legal rights, but there is nothing that specifically addresses children. This bill provides a slightly more broad protection to children, prohibiting all discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child's immigration status, except where the minor child's claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This broader protection is appropriate and necessary to ensure that children are protected and that bad actors cannot commit egregious acts against children and later hide behind the child's immigration status to reduce liability. This bill will settle the issue, as least in regard to children, providing that the life of one child is as valuable as the life of another child, and that the life and well-being of a child must be protected, regardless of that child's country of citizenship. This bill includes language to ensure that although its provisions are specific to children, adults deserve the same protections in the same situations.
Analysis Prepared by: Khadijah Hargett / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001073
AB 560
Page 5
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 560
Amended: 6/23/15 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/16/15
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-22, 4/27/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Civil actions: immigration status
SOURCE: Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund
DIGEST: This bill specifies that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law. This bill generally prohibits discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status except as specified. This bill further states that its provisions are declaratory of existing law and that the express application of this act to minors is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
ANALYSIS: Existing law provides that the Legislature finds and declares the following:
All protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state.
For purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
These provisions are declaratory of existing law.
The provisions are severable. If any provision of the above provisions or their application is held invalid, that invalidity is prohibited from affecting other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
This bill:
Provides that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
Provides that discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor child’s claims place the minor child’s immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
States that its provisions are declaratory of existing law.
Provides that the express application of this act to minors is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
Background
In 2002, the United States Supreme Court, in Hoffman Plastic Compounds Inc. v. NLRB (2002) 535 U.S. 137, held that the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) is precluded from awarding backpay to undocumented workers because an award to these specific workers would be beyond the bounds of NLRB’s remedial discretion and run counter to the federal Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA). Even though the workers might be victims of unfair labor practices, the workers were never legally authorized to work in the United States, and as a result, the Court held that awarding backpay to undocumented immigrants would “unduly trench upon explicit statutory prohibitions critical to federal immigration policy,” as expressed in IRCA and “would encourage the successful evasion of apprehension by immigration authorities, condone prior violations of the immigration laws, and encourage future violations.” (Id. at 151, noting at 152 that NLRB’s “lack of authority to award backpay does not mean that the employer gets off scot-free. The Board here has already imposed other significant sanctions against Hoffman – sanctions Hoffman does not challenge.”)
In response to Hoffman, this Legislature enacted an urgency measure, AB 1818 (Romero, Chapter 1071, Statutes of 2002) to limit the potential effects of that decision on this state’s labor and civil rights laws. The bill codified substantially similar legislative findings and declarations throughout the Civil Code, the Government Code, the Labor Code, and the Health and Safety Code relative to enforcement actions relating to the rights of immigrants. For example, the following findings and declarations were codified in Section 3339 of the Civil Code: (1) all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals, regardless of immigration status, who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state; (2) for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except when necessary to comply with federal immigration law; and (3) the bill’s provisions are declaratory of existing law.
This bill, sponsored by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, now codifies that the immigration status of children is irrelevant, except as specified. This bill similarly states that such information is generally inadmissible for purposes of discovery.
Comments
As stated by the author:
Existing law specifies a number of situations where immigration status is not to be considered, but it does not specifically address protections for minor children or personal injury matters.
California continues to be a leader in protecting undocumented children and families. AB 560 seeks to end the legal argument that immigrant children deserve less, when seeking recovery under the law, simply because they are undocumented. This is achieved by declaring that a minor’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability or remedy and by prohibiting the discovery into a minor child’s immigration status.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (source)
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – Sacramento
California Association for Bilingual Education
California Catholic Conference, Inc.
California Communities United Institute
California Equity Leaders Network
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
Californians Together
Consumer Attorneys of California
Equality California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
Latino Health Alliance
National Association of Social Workers-California Chapter
Service Employees International Union-California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/24/15)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The sponsor of this bill, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, writes that “a loophole in California law intended to protect undocumented workers permits tortfeasors, including intentional violators who choose their victims, to argue that a child victim’s recovery should be limited because of immigration status. Recently, the Los Angeles Unified School District asserted such an argument in defending an action brought by children sexually abused in the classroom. No intentional tortfeasor should be sent the message that he can avoid the full consequences of his actions by choosing undocumented victims. And no child should ever be led to understand that California courts value her future less than that of other children. AB 560 would close the loophole in current law, clarifying that our law treats children equally regardless of status, and foreclosing any argument to the contrary.”
In support, the California Catholic Conference writes that “AB 560 sends a strong message that predatory behavior toward the immigrant population will not be tolerated and that the State of California aims to protect underage individuals from becoming victims of discrimination, thereby, fulfilling its process to implement the law and uphold the rights and dignity of all immigrants.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-22, 4/27/15
AYES: Alejo, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Mathis, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NOES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Dahle, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Jones, Kim, Lackey, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Wagner, Waldron, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Campos, Chang, Maienschein, Olsen
Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/24/15 17:33:33
**** END ****
AB 560 (Gomez)
Page 7 of 7
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
AB 560 (Gomez)
Version: April 20, 2015
Hearing Date: June 16, 2015
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
RD
SUBJECT
Civil actions: immigration status
DESCRIPTION
This bill would specify that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law. This bill would generally prohibit discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status except as specified.
This bill would further state that its provisions are declaratory of existing law and prohibit these provisions from having any implications for adults.
BACKGROUND
In 2002, the United States Supreme Court, in Hoffman Plastic Compounds Inc. v. NLRB (2002) 535 U.S. 137, held that the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) is precluded from awarding backpay to undocumented workers because an award to these specific workers would be beyond the bounds of NLRB’s remedial discretion and run counter to the federal Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA). Even though the workers might be victims of unfair labor practices, the workers were never legally authorized to work in the United States, and as a result, the Court held that awarding backpay to undocumented immigrants would “unduly trench upon explicit statutory prohibitions critical to federal immigration policy,” as expressed in IRCA and “would encourage the successful evasion of apprehension by immigration authorities, condone prior violations of the immigration laws, and encourage future violations.” (Id. at 151, noting at 152 that NLRB’s “lack of authority to award backpay does not mean that the employer gets off scot-free. The Board here has already imposed other significant sanctions against Hoffman – sanctions Hoffman does not challenge.”)
In response to Hoffman, this Legislature enacted an urgency measure, AB 1818 (Romero, Ch. 1071, Stats. 2002) to limit the potential effects of that decision on this state’s labor and civil rights laws. The bill codified substantially similar legislative findings and declarations throughout the Civil Code, the Government Code, the Labor Code, and the Health and Safety Code relative to enforcement actions relating to the rights of immigrants. For example, the following findings and declarations were codified in Section 3339 of the Civil Code: (1) all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals, regardless of immigration status, who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state; (2) for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability and no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except when necessary to comply with federal immigration law; and (3) the bill’s provisions are declaratory of existing law.
This bill, sponsored by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, would codify that the immigration status of children is irrelevant, except as specified. The bill would similarly state that such information is generally inadmissible for purposes of discovery.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that the Legislature finds and declares the following:
All protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state.
For purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
These provisions are declaratory of existing law.
The provisions are severable. If any provision of the above provisions or their application is held invalid, that invalidity is prohibited from affecting other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application. (Civ. Code Sec. 3339; see also similar provisions at Lab. Code Sec. 1171.5, Gov. Code Sec. 7285, Health & Saf. Code Sec. 24000.)
This bill would additionally provide that the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law.
This bill would provide that discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor child’s claims place the minor child’s immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would state that its provisions are declaratory of existing law.
This bill would further provide that the express application of this act to minors is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Existing law specifies a number of situations where immigration status is not to be considered, but it does not specifically address protections for minor children or personal injury matters.
California continues to be a leader in protecting undocumented children and families. AB 560 seeks to end the legal argument that immigrant children deserve less, when seeking recovery under the law, simply because they are undocumented. This is achieved by declaring that a minor’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability or remedy and by prohibiting the discovery into a minor child’s immigration status.
The sponsor of this bill, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF) adds that “a loophole in California law intended to protect undocumented workers permits tortfeasors, including intentional violators who choose their victims, to argue that a child victim’s recovery should be limited because of immigration status. Recently, the Los Angeles Unified School District asserted such an argument in defending an action brought by children sexually abused in the classroom. No intentional tortfeasor should be sent the message that he can avoid the full consequences of his actions by choosing undocumented victims. And no child should ever be led to understand that California courts value her future less than that of other children. AB 560 would close the loophole in current law, clarifying that our law treats children equally regardless of status, and foreclosing any argument to the contrary.”
In support, the California Catholic Conference writes that “AB 560 sends a strong message that predatory behavior toward the immigrant population will not be tolerated and that the State of California aims to protect underage individuals from becoming victims of discrimination, thereby, fulfilling its process to implement the law and uphold the rights and dignity of all immigrants.”
2. Existing law on admissibility of immigration status
This bill appears to have arisen in part out of a Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) case wherein LAUSD made an argument that California law allows for immigration status to be considered when a jury discusses damages for future potential loss of earnings or wages. This engendered much controversy, and it was claimed that it was a scare tactic intended to instill fear in the plaintiffs. The school district noted in a statement that it “has not and does not intend to raise immigration status in this case unless first raised by the plaintiffs.” (See Klimack, LAUSD Asks Judge to Reveal Immigration Status of Miramonte Victims (Oct. 8, 2014) NBC Los Angeles <http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/LAUSD-Asks-Judge-to-Reveal-Immigration-Status-Of-Miramonte-Victims-278616021.html> [as of Jun. 8, 2015].)
Generally, as a matter of law, the immigration status of a personal injury plaintiff is inadmissible as evidence for most purposes. On the other hand, when the plaintiff raises certain issues, immigration status may become relevant and thereby admissible. Accordingly, the courts have recognized a longstanding exception to this rule of inadmissibility where the plaintiff seeks future earnings damages because those future earnings are dependent upon whether or not the individual would likely be subject to deportation under federal law. The rule was first articulated by a California Court of Appeal in Rodriguez v. Kline (1986) 186 Cal.App.3d 1145, a case where an appeal was taken from a personal injury award of $99,000 arising out of a traffic accident and the court was asked to decide whether a person who is within this country illegally is entitled to be compensated for his personal injuries based upon his projected earning capacity in (1) the United States, or (2) the country of his lawful citizenship.
The court began by noting that the plaintiff in that case (the respondent) candidly admitted he was in the country illegally, writing that “[a]s a consequence, respondent’s status unquestionably bore upon the amount of his anticipated future earnings. That is to say, if respondent were to return, voluntarily or involuntarily [pursuant to federal law would make such an individual subject to deportation], to Mexico, the income he could expect to receive there would be markedly less than a figure derived from his earnings during his sojourn here. To date the California courts that have considered this proposition at all have recognized its soundness.” (Id. at 1148.) Even then, the Court recognized the potential prejudice that such evidence could pose to the plaintiff, writing that this could be remedied “by treating any question regarding a plaintiff’s citizenship or lawful place of residence as one of law, to be decided exclusively by the trial court outside the presence of the jury. Resolution of this question is, of course, prerequisite to any ruling upon the admissibility of evidence regarding future earnings.” (Id.) As held by the court in Rodriguez:
[W]henever a plaintiff whose citizenship is challenged seeks to recover for loss of future earnings, his status in this country shall be decided by the trial court as a preliminary question of law. (See Evid. Code, [Sec.] 310.) At the hearing conducted thereon, the defendant will have the initial burden of producing proof that the plaintiff is an alien who is subject to deportation. If this effort is successful, then the burden will shift to the plaintiff to demonstrate to the court’s satisfaction that he has taken steps which will correct his deportable condition. A contrary rule, of course, would allow someone who is not lawfully available for future work in the United States to receive compensation to which he is not entitled. (Id. at 1149, citing Alonso v. State of California (1975) 50 Cal.App.3d 242.)
More recently, in Hernandez v. Paicius (2003) 109 Cal.App.4th 452, a California Court of Appeal, relying in part upon the public policy reflected in the Civil Code, Government Code and Labor Code with regard to the irrelevance of immigration status in the enforcement of state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing rights, held:
[The trial] court absolutely should have granted plaintiff’s motion to exclude reference to his residency status. Only relevant evidence is admissible. (Evid. Code [Sec.] 350.) The court lacks discretion to admit irrelevant evidence. [Citations and footnote omitted.] The evidence was irrelevant to the issue of liability under Rodriguez v. Kline . . . a decision plaintiff cited to the court below. Plaintiff was not claiming loss of future earnings. Thus, his potential for making money did not matter. In fact, plaintiff was not claiming loss of any earnings, past or future. [Footnote omitted, emphasis in original.] Not only was the evidence entirely irrelevant; it was, as the court illustrated only too early in its comments, highly inflammatory. As the Rodriguez court observed, ‘(E)vidence relating to citizenship and liability to deportation almost surely would be prejudicial to the party whose status was in question.’ (Rodriguez, at p. 1148).” (Id. at 460.)
3. Bill limits admissibility of children’s immigration status in personal injury cases
Existing law codifies in the Civil, Labor, Government, and Health and Safety codes, various legislative findings intended to protect immigrants. In the Civil Code, these codified findings include, for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law. (See Civ. Code Sec. 3339(b).)
While a person could presumably include a child, this bill, sponsored by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF), seeks to close what is perceived as a loophole. The bill would codify similar provisions relating to the immigration status of children and provide that they are declaratory of existing law. Those provisions would provide that: (1) the immigration status of a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, except for employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law; and (2) discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status shall not be permitted except where the minor child’s claims place the minor child’s immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
This bill would appear to be consistent with the general rule, discussed in Comment 2, above, against the admissibility of immigration status evidence, but could potentially impact the longstanding exception to that rule because it would declare immigration status of a child irrelevant except in regard to limited employment-related prospective injunctive relief that would directly violate federal law. At the same time, the bill would allow discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status where the minor child’s claims place the minor child’s immigration status directly in contention or the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
Notably, this bill would also codify a statement that its provisions are “declaratory of existing law.” As a matter of public policy, it is preferable to ensure that bills apply prospectively, so as not to change the outcome of ongoing litigation in favor of one party. The sponsor argues this provision is both appropriate and needed in this bill, because, “[b]y stating that it is declaratory of existing law, the bill also ensures that its rule would apply in all future cases, including those that relate to tortious actions that occurred prior to passage of this legislation. This is particularly important in this area because the time between an intentional tort against a child and when legal action is pursued (often when the child becomes an adult) can be significant. The bill thus ensures that courts will apply a uniform rule in this area of law.”
4. Suggested amendments
This bill currently provides that “[t]he express application of this act to minors is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.” To clarify the intended meaning of this language, the following language is suggested to provide instead that “[t]he express application of this act to minors is not intended to imply that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.”
Suggested amendment:
On page 2, line 17, strike “address in any way” and insert “imply”
Support: Asian Americans Advancing Justice – Sacramento; California Communities United Institute California Equity Leaders Network; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Labor Federation; California Catholic Conference, Inc.; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation; Consumer Attorneys of California; Equality California; Latino Coalition for a Healthy California; Latino Health Alliance; National Association of Social Workers-California Chapter
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: SB 1818 (Romero, Ch. 1071, Stats. 2002) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 54, Noes 22)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 2)
**************
AB 560
Page 3
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 560
(Gomez)
As Amended April 20, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Judiciary |
8-2 |
Mark Stone, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, O'Donnell |
Wagner, Gallagher |
SUMMARY: Adds a section to the Code of Civil Procedure that bars the consideration of a child’s immigration status in civil actions involving liability or remedy. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that in actions involving a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law, the child’s immigration status is irrelevant.
Provides that discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status is impermissible, except where the minor child’s claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
Provides that the express application of this act is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state.
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: A lawsuit by more than 80 elementary school children against the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) for alleged sexual misconduct by one of the district’s former teachers was recently settled. The plaintiffs attended Miramonte Elementary School, which is located in a community in South Los Angeles. Many of the victims in the lawsuit are undocumented. During the litigation phase of the case, attorneys for the plaintiffs filed motions to preclude inquiry into the immigration status of the plaintiffs in the case. In response, the attorneys for the LAUSD requested that the court deny the plaintiffs’ motion based on the holding in Hernández v. Paicius (2003) 109 Cal. App. 4th 425, 460, which held that if a plaintiff is seeking damages for loss of earnings or lost wages, the plaintiff’s immigration status is relevant to the determination of the plaintiff’s potential for earning money in the future. The defendants argued that evidence of the students’ immigration status was directly relevant to the determination of their potential future earning capacity, and should therefore be considered for determination of damages in the case.
Current law provides that immigration status is irrelevant for the purposes of liability in enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, unless the person making the inquiry can show by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. While, existing law specifies a number of situations where immigration status is not to be considered, it does not address protections for minor children or personal injury matters. This bill establishes that the immigration status of a minor child, under any applicable law, is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, unless the status is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill prohibits discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding about a child’s immigration status, except in situations where the child places his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking to make the inquiry shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill clearly states that its provision are not intended to address that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
Future loss of earnings as damages. According to an article by Ken LaMance, Future Loss of Earnings or Wages (Legal Match www.legalmatch.com/law-library), future loss of earnings are damages awarded in personal injury cases when the injury has permanently limited the plaintiff’s ability to earn wages. The plaintiff is then entitled to recover the reduction in value of his or her future earning capacity. Awards of loss of future earnings are based on the person’s potential to make money, even if that person has never exercised earning potential. For the child plaintiffs in the lawsuit against the LAUSD, an award for future loss of earnings would be calculated based on each child’s ability to earn money.
The nexus between future loss of earnings and citizenship. The problem with determining future loss of earnings for undocumented children is that current case law allows an award of damages to be based on a person’s projected earning capacity, but also assumes that an undocumented plaintiff will be deported to his or her country of lawful citizenship. So although the children in the Miramonte case suffered similar harms, those who are United States citizens are awarded future earnings based on wages in the United States, while the undocumented children are awarded future earnings based upon wages in Mexico or another country outside of the United States, which tend to be much lower. This result is unfair, especially because it involves children who all reside in the United States, attend school in the United States, and suffered harm in the United States.
In Rodriguez v. Kline (1986) 186 Cal. App. 3rd 1145, the California Court of Appeals found that damages for loss of earnings to a defendant who is undocumented should be awarded based upon his projected earning capacity after deportation to the country of his lawful citizenship. This is the reason why the LAUSD sought to keep the issue of immigration status relevant in the case before it ultimately settled. In all fairness to the defendant, the LAUSD did move to strike that defense during litigation of the case.
Necessity of the Bill. Existing law prohibits inquiry into a person’s immigration status for specific purposes, namely for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws. Existing law also provides that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to specific inquiries – the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws – and that no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status in those contexts.
These existing laws protect adults from inquiry into their immigration status when they are fighting for their civil and other legal rights, but there is nothing that specifically addresses children. This bill provides a slightly more broad protection to children, prohibiting all discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status, except where the minor child’s claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This broader protection is appropriate and necessary to ensure that children are protected and that bad actors cannot commit egregious acts against children and later hide behind the child’s immigration status to reduce liability. This bill will settle the issue, as least in regard to children, providing that the life of one child is as valuable as the life of another child, and that the life and well-being of a child must be protected, regardless of that child’s country of citizenship. This bill includes language to ensure that although its provisions are specific to children, adults deserve the same protections in the same situations.
Analysis Prepared by: Khadijah Hargett / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000173
AB 560
Page 5
Date of Hearing: April 14, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
AB 560
(Gomez) – As Introduced February 23, 2015
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: CIVIL ACTIONS: IMMIGRATION STATUS OF CHILDREN
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE IMMIGRATION STATUS OF A CHILD SEEKING RECOVERY UNDER ANY APPLICABLE LAW BE BARRED FROM CONSIDERATION, IN A CIVIL ACTION WHEN COMPLIANCE WITH FEDERAL IMMIGRATION LAW IS NOT AT ISSUE?
SYNOPSIS
As proposed to be amended, this bill establishes that in actions involving minor children who are seeking recovery under any applicable law, the child’s immigration status is irrelevant and that inquiry into the minor’s immigration status in discovery or similar inquiries is prohibited. The bill limits such inquiry to claims where the child has placed his or her immigration status directly in contention and where the person seeking the inquiry can show by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill arises out of a recent disturbing case in which a teacher employed by the Los Angeles Unified School District engaged in egregious sexual misconduct with elementary school students at Miramonte Elementary School located in South Los Angeles. According to news reports, more than 80 students sued the school district for negligence and personal injury as a result of the teacher’s conduct. During the litigation of the plaintiffs’ claims, the issue of future loss of earnings was raised by the plaintiffs in a motion in limine, seeking an order that the immigration status of the plaintiffs was irrelevant to the issue of damages in the case. The defendant initially fought the motion, stating that the immigration status of the children was relevant to the calculation of their future loss of earnings or loss of wages. Current case law allows an award of damages to be based on the projected earning capacity of a plaintiff based on the premise that he or she will be deported from the U.S. and returned to his or her country of origin. So although all of the children in the Miramonte case suffered similar harms, those who are U. S. citizens can be awarded future earnings based on wages in the United States, while the undocumented children’s award would be based upon wages in Mexico or another country outside of the United States, which tend to be much lower. This bill makes it clear that immigration status of children under any applicable law is irrelevant, that inquiry into immigration status of a child in discovery or similar inquiries is prohibited unless either the plaintiff places his or her status at issue, or the inquiry is proven to be necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill is supported by MALDEF and several other organizations. It has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Adds a section to the Code of Civil Procedure that bars the consideration of a child’s immigration status in civil actions involving liability or remedy. Specifically, this bill:
Provides that in actions involving a minor child seeking recovery under any applicable law, the child’s immigration status is irrelevant.
Provides that discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status is impermissible, except where the minor child’s claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law.
Provides that the express application of this act is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state. (Civil Code Section 3339(a) and Labor Code Section 1171.5(a).)
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that this inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law. (Civil Code Section 3339 (b).)
Provides that for purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law. (Labor Code Section 117.5(b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: A lawsuit by more than 80 elementary school children against the Los Angeles Unified School District for alleged sexual misconduct by one of the district’s former teachers was recently settled. The plaintiffs attended Miramonte Elementary School, which is located in a community in South Los Angeles. Many of the victims in the lawsuit are undocumented. During the litigation phase of the case, attorneys for the plaintiffs filed motions to preclude inquiry into the immigration status of the plaintiffs in the case. In response, the attorneys for the Los Angeles Unified School District requested that the court deny the plaintiffs’ motion based on the holding in Hernández v. Paicius which held that if a plaintiff is seeking damages for loss of earnings or lost wages, the plaintiff’s immigration status is relevant to the determination of the plaintiff’s potential for earning money in the future. The defendants argued that evidence of the students’ immigration status was directly relevant to the determination of their potential future earning capacity, and should therefore be considered for determination of damages in the case. (Hernández v. Paicius (2003) 109 Cal. App. 4th 425, 460)
Current law provides that immigration status is irrelevant for the purposes of liability in enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws, unless the person making the inquiry can show by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law (Civil Code Section 3339, Labor Code Section 1171.5). While, existing law specifies a number of situations where immigration status is not to be considered, it does not address protections for minor children or personal injury matters. AB 560 establishes that the immigration status of a minor child, under any applicable law, is irrelevant to the issues of liability or remedy, unless the status is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This bill prohibits discovery or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding about a child’s immigration status, except in situations where the child places his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking to make the inquiry shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. As proposed to be amended, the bill will clearly state that its provision are not intended to address that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
According to the author:
Undocumented children who seek recovery are disadvantaged by their immigration status. More often a child does not have the ability to determine their immigration status and are put in a position to be treated unfairly when the suffer some of the most egregious acts.
California continues to be a leader in protecting undocumented children and families. AB 560 seeks to end the legal argument that immigrant children deserve less, when seeking recovery under the law, simply because they are undocumented. Undocumented children deserve the same protections as any other child that suffers intentional or negligent harm. The financial discounting of any child because of their immigration status is unacceptable.
Future loss of earnings as damages. According to an article by Ken LaMance, Future Loss of Earnings or Wages, future loss of earnings are damages awarded in personal injury cases when the injury has permanently limited the plaintiff’s ability to earn wages. The plaintiff is then entitled to recover the reduction in value of his or her future earning capacity. (Ken LaMance, Future Loss of Earnings or Wages Legal Match www.legalmatch.com/law-library.) Awards of loss of future earnings are based on the person’s potential to make money, even if that person has never exercised earning potential. For the child plaintiffs in the lawsuit against the Los Angeles Unified School District, an award for future loss of earnings would be calculated based on each child’s ability to earn money.
The nexus between future loss of earnings and citizenship. The problem with determining future loss of earnings for undocumented children is that current case law allows an award of damages to be based on a person’s projected earning capacity, but also assumes that an undocumented plaintiff will be deported to his or her country of lawful citizenship. So although the children in the Miramonte case suffered similar harms, those who are U. S. citizens are awarded future earnings based on wages in the United States, while the undocumented children are awarded future earnings based upon wages in Mexico or another country outside of the United States, which tend to be much lower. This result is unfair, especially because it involves children who all reside in the United States, attend school in the United States, and suffered harm in the United States.
In Rodriguez v. Kline, the California Court of Appeals found that damages for loss of earnings to a defendant who is undocumented should be awarded based upon his projected earning capacity after deportation to the country of his lawful citizenship. This is the reason why the Los Angeles Unified School District sought to keep the issue of immigration status relevant in the case before it ultimately settled. In all fairness to the defendant, the Los Angeles Unified School District did move to strike that defense during litigation of the case. (Rodriguez v. Kline, (1986) 186 Cal. App. 3rd 1145.)
Necessity of the Bill. Existing law prohibits inquiry into a person’s immigration status for specific purposes, namely for purposes of enforcing state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws. (Civil Code Section 3339(a).) Existing law also provides that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to specific inquiries--the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce state labor, employment, civil rights, and employee housing laws—and that no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status in those contexts. (Civil Code Section 3339(b).)
These existing laws protect adults from inquiry into their immigration status when they are fighting for their civil and other legal rights, but there is nothing that specifically addresses children. The bill provides a slightly more broad protection to children, prohibiting all discovery or any similar inquiry in a civil action or proceeding relating to a minor child’s immigration status, except where the minor child’s claims have placed his or her immigration status directly in contention, or the person seeking such discovery shows by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary to comply with federal immigration law. This broader protection is appropriate and necessary to ensure that children are protected and that bad actors cannot commit egregious acts against children and later hide behind the child’s immigration status to reduce liability. The bill will settle the issue, as least in regard to children, providing that the life of one child is as valuable as the life of another child, and that the life and well-being of a child must be protected, regardless of that child’s country of citizenship. The bill includes language to ensure that although its provisions are specific to children, adults deserve the same protections in the same situations.
Author’s Amendments. In an effort to avoid any confusion regarding the legislative intent about the bill’s provisions and how adults in similar circumstances may be treated, the author has agreed to the following amendments to the bill:
On page 2, line 7 after “discovery” insert: or other inquiry in a civil action or proceeding
On page 2, line 15 insert: (d) The express application of this act to minors is not intended to address in any way that adults are not likewise protected by existing law in the same circumstances.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill enjoys support from a wide range of groups, including human rights organizations, social workers, immigrant advocacy groups, labor and religious groups. According to the sponsor, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF):
No child victim of a serious tort, intentional or negligent, should have their recovery limited because of immigration status or ever be required to have their status discussed or debated in court. No wrongdoer, particularly an abuser, should face reduced consequences because the child victim was undocumented. Immigrant children deserve equal treatment. Their lives are worth the same as other children, and that fact must be reflected in the law.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Catholic Conference, Inc.
National Association of Social Workers-California Chapter
California Communities United Institute
35 Individuals
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Khadijah Hargett / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):