AB 252: The College Athlete Protection Act.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-30
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-26: In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Student Athlete Bill of Rights requires intercollegiate athletic programs at certain 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual income derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law authorizes an institution of higher education, as defined, to establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws. Existing law requires an institution of higher education to post in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes a notice detailing certain student athlete rights. Existing law prohibits an institution of higher education from intentionally retaliating against a student athlete for making or filing a complaint about, testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into, or opposing any practice that the student athlete believes is, a violation of student athlete rights.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. The bill instead would require certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided. The bill instead would require an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified. The bill instead would prohibit an institution of higher education, and its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under the CAP Act. By imposing new duties on community college districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of the CAP Act. The bill would establish a 21-member 13-member CAP Panel comprised composed of appointed individuals to serve on 4 CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of administer the CAP Act, as provided. The bill would require certain institutions of higher education to be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of college athletes. The bill would require an institution of higher education to complete an evaluation regarding its compliance with Title IX, as specified, and to publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution. The bill would require an institution of higher education to administer a financial and life skills development workshop program, and would require the institutions college athletes to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program, as provided. The bill would require an institution of higher education to pay an annual fee, as specified, to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The bill would establish the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, Program director, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Student Athlete Bill of Rights requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual income derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law authorizes an institution of higher education, as defined, to establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws. Existing law requires an institution of higher education to post in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes a notice detailing certain student athlete rights. Existing law prohibits an institution of higher education from intentionally retaliating against a student athlete for making or filing a complaint about, testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into, or opposing any practice that the student athlete believes is, a violation of student athlete rights.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. The bill instead would require certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided. The bill instead would require an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified. The bill instead would prohibit an institution of higher education, and its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under the CAP Act. By imposing new duties on community college districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of the CAP Act. The bill would establish a 21-member CAP Panel comprised of appointed individuals to serve on 4 CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of the CAP Act, as provided. The bill would establish the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Student Athlete Bill of Rights requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue income derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law authorizes an institution of higher education, as defined, to establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws. Existing law requires an institution of higher education to post in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes a notice detailing certain student athlete rights. Existing law prohibits an institution of higher education from intentionally retaliating against a student athlete for making or filing a complaint about, testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into, or opposing any practice that the student athlete believes is, a violation of student athlete rights.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. The bill instead would require certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided. The bill instead would require an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified. The bill instead would prohibit an institution of higher education, and its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete athletes rights provided in under the CAP Act. By imposing new duties on community college districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of the CAP Act. The bill would establish a 21-member CAP Panel comprised of appointed individuals to serve on 4 CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of the CAP Act, as provided. The bill would establish the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Student Athlete Bill of Rights requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law authorizes an institution of higher education, as defined, to establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws. Existing law requires an institution of higher education to post in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes a notice detailing certain student athlete rights. Existing law prohibits an institution of higher education from intentionally retaliating against a student athlete for making or filing a compliant complaint about, testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into, or opposing any practice that the student athlete believes is, a violation of student athlete rights.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. The bill instead would require certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided. The bill instead would require an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified. The bill instead would prohibit an institution of higher education, its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of college athlete rights provided in the CAP Act. By imposing new duties on community college districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program as a program in the State Department of Education Office of Planning and Research for purposes of the CAP Act. The bill would establish a 21-member CAP Panel comprised of appointed individuals to serve on 4 CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of the CAP Act, as provided. The bill would establish the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Student Athlete Bill of Rights requires intercollegiate athletic programs at 4-year private universities or campuses of the University of California or the California State University that receive, as an average, $10,000,000 or more in annual revenue derived from media rights for intercollegiate athletics to comply with prescribed requirements relating to student athlete rights. Existing law authorizes an institution of higher education, as defined, to establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws. Existing law requires an institution of higher education to post in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes a notice detailing certain student athlete rights. Existing law prohibits an institution of higher education from intentionally retaliating against a student athlete for making or filing a compliant about, testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into, or opposing any practice that the student athlete believes is, a violation of student athlete rights.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. The bill instead would require certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided. The bill instead would require an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified. The bill instead would prohibit an institution of higher education, its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of college athlete rights provided in the CAP Act. By imposing new duties on community college districts, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would establish the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program as a program in the State Department of Education for purposes of the CAP Act. The bill would establish a 21-member CAP Panel comprised of appointed individuals to serve on 4 CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of the CAP Act, as provided. The bill would establish the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
For purposes of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 67450) and this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from an institution of higher education within six years of initial enrollment at that institution, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(g)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452.3 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 67454 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Section 67455 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 5.SEC. 4.Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 67460) is added to Part 40.3 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:3.The College Athlete Protection Act67460.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the College Athlete Protection Act.
1.Definitions67461.As used in this chapter, unless the context requires otherwise, the following definitions apply:
(a)Affiliated medical personnel means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education. Affiliated medical personnel include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
(b)Aggregate athletic grants means the total amount of athletic grants that an institution of higher education annually reports spends on each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution pursuant to its annual report to the United States Department of Education under the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. established pursuant to Section 485 of the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1092). Aggregate athletic grants shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institutions in-state or out-of-state college athletes.
(c)All revenue includes revenue that is not allocated by sport pursuant to federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act reporting standards.(d)(c)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(e)(d)Athletic grant means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete to cover a portion or all of the institutions cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1087ll). An athletic grant shall not exceed the institutions cost of attendance.
(f)(e)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at an institution of higher education.
(g)(f)CAP Fund means the California Athlete Protection Fund established pursuant to this chapter.
(h)(g)CAP Panel means the California Athlete Protection Panel established pursuant to this chapter.
(i)(h)CAP Program means the California Athlete Protection Program established pursuant to this chapter.
(j)(i)College athlete means a student who is enrolled at an institution of higher education and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
(k)Fair market value compensation means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic teams aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic teams revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team. This fair market value compensation calculation does not include revenue that is not allocated by sport.(l)Institutional funds means the amount of an institution of higher educations revenue that is not derived from any intercollegiate athletics source for an academic year that exceeds the amount of its revenue that did not derive from any intercollegiate athletics source reported for the 202122 academic year.(m)(j)Grand total revenue means all revenue that is calculated and reported as grand total revenue pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act established pursuant to Section 485 of the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092) by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education.
(k)Institution of higher education or institution means any campus of the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
(n)(l)Intercollegiate athlete means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
(o)(m)NCAA means the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
(p)(n)NIL means the use of a college athletes name, image, and likeness.
(q)(o)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(r)(p)Revenue means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education. Revenue includes intercollegiate athletics revenue paid directly by an intercollegiate athletic conference, an athletic association, or a source designated by an institution of higher education, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association to cover any athletic program expense or to compensate a college athlete for participating in intercollegiate athletics at the institution.
(s)(q)Title IX means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.)
2.Findings67462.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, intercollegiate athletic conferences, and athletic associations and the state.
(b)Institutions of higher education exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance.
(c)To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred.(d)(c)The state needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death.
(e)(d)Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety.
(f)(e)College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athletes interests are always put first.
(g)(f)Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decisionmaking related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences.
(h)(g)To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes sports-related injuries.
(i)(h)Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athletes NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements.
(j)(i)A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes.
(k)(j)Intercollegiate athletic laws and rules in other states affect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes.
(l)(k)In National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141, the United States Supreme Court ruled unanimously that NCAA educational-related compensation limits imposed on college athletes violated federal antitrust law, and acknowledged that the NCAA did not dispute that NCAA college athlete compensation limits decrease college athletes compensation.
3.General Provisions67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants pursuant to this section.(b)An institution of higher education shall use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution pursuant to this section.(c)College athletes on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year shall be designated an equal payment from that institutions degree completion fund for that academic year.(d)(1)All degree completion funds of up to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) shall be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year. (2)Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in paragraph (1) shall be made in an amount based on the institutions revenue reported for the previous academic year.(e)An institution shall not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.(f)(1)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.(2)All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university shall be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.(g)(1)An institution of higher education shall accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution shall not undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.(2)The CAP Panel may audit an institution of higher educations aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance with this section. This audit may include review of the institutions aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This paragraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.(h)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds shall be deposited in the institutions degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.(i)(1)(A)In making annual degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, an institution of higher education shall use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds all revenue reported for the 202122 academic year. The institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund so long as all of the conditions in this paragraph and subdivision (k) are satisfied.(B)Except as provided in subparagraph (F), the institution shall use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A), in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations.(C)The institution shall make, in aggregate, for an academic year, one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its female college athletes, and one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its male college athletes.(D)From the portion of the total amount allocated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C), the institution shall make degree completion fund payment designations for female college athletes on each womens intercollegiate athletics team who have not received fair market value compensation for the academic year. In making the degree completion fund payment designations, the institution shall comply with all of the following:(i)Determine the percentage of the total fair market value compensation owed to female college athletes on each womens intercollegiate athletics team at the institution that represents the total fair market compensation owed to all female college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport.(ii)Ensure that female college athletes on the same womens intercollegiate athletics team, regardless of sport, collectively receive the percentage determined pursuant to clause (i) of the total amount designated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).(iii)If the portion of the total amount allocated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C) exceeds the total aggregate fair market value compensation owed to all female college athletes on womens intercollegiate athletics teams at the institution, regardless of sport, the institution shall pay each of its female college athletes who receive an athletic grant an equal amount of the portion for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).(E)From the portion of the total amount allocated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C), the institution shall make degree completion fund payment designations for male college athletes on each mens intercollegiate athletics team who have not received fair market compensation. In making the degree completion fund payment designations, the institution shall comply with all of the following:(i)Determine the percentage of the total fair market compensation owed to male college athletes on each mens intercollegiate athletics team at the institution that represents the total fair market compensation owed to all male college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport.(ii)Ensure that male college athletes on the same mens intercollegiate athletics team, regardless of sport, collectively receive the percentage determined pursuant to clause (i) of the total amount designated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).(iii)If the portion of the total amount allocated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C) exceeds the total aggregate fair market value compensation owed to all male college athletes on mens intercollegiate athletics teams at the institution, regardless of sport, the institution shall pay each of its male college athletes who receive an athletic grant an equal amount of the portion for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).(F)Except to comply with subparagraphs (D) and (E), and subdivision (k), degree completion fund payment designations shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.(G)Notwithstanding subparagraph (B), an institution of higher education that gives fair market compensation to all of its male and female college athletes and complies with this section may use any remaining revenue for other purposes as determined by the institution.(H)The institution may spend institutional funds on intercollegiate athletic expenses without the funds counting as revenue if, within the academic year, the institutional funds are exhausted or the institutional funds are unused and do not remain in an athletic teams or athletic programs budget. This subparagraph authorizes an institution to increase athletics spending for athletic program needs without including it in revenue directed to degree completion funds pursuant to this section.(I)The amount of funds that the institution paid for any athletic teams expenses for the 202122 academic year shall be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution did not count the funds as revenue for that academic year.(J)Notwithstanding subparagraph (I), the amount of funds that an institution paid for any athletic teams nonregular capital expenses for the 202122 academic year shall not be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution counted the funds as revenue for that academic year.(2)An institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees pursuant to this chapter before using revenue described in paragraph (1) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.(j)Degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education shall have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.(k)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution shall adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics. For any adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision, the institution shall comply with all of the following requirements:(1)The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institutions college athletes shall not be reduced.(2)The institution shall comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.(3)On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution shall publish on its internet website and submit to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and include both of the following in this written explanation:(A)Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.(B)The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.(l)Degree completion fund payment designations or payments shall not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.(m)Within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, each institution of higher education shall submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athletes intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.(n)An institution of higher education and its personnel shall not make, or attempt to make, formal or informal agreements, policies, or practices with other institutions of higher education, out-of-state colleges and universities, athletic conferences, and athletic associations or their personnel, or other entities with intercollegiate athletics governance powers, to determine degree completion fund payment amounts to college athletes.(o)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.67464.67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
(1)A college athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(2)An individual notice stating: All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the United States Department of Justice, the United States Department of Educations Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.
(3)A college athletes rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A college athletes rights under this chapter.
(5)Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
(b)The notice distributed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.
(2)The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting.
(3)The internet website address used by the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters pursuant to Section 11165.7 of the Penal Code and the obligations of these mandated reporters.
(5)The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter.
(6)The telephone number of the United States Department of Justice.
(c)An institution of higher education shall post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institutions athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
(d)Upon the commencement of each academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
67465.67464.(a)The College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program is hereby established as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of this chapter.
(b)The CAP Program shall be administered by the CAP Panel. Program director hired pursuant to paragraph (3). The CAP Program director shall implement the regulations, standards, and policies adopted by the CAP Panel pursuant to this chapter. The CAP Panel shall be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
(1)(A)The 21-member 13-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
(i)Eleven Seven members appointed by the Governor.
(ii)Five Three members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(iii)Five Three members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(B)The 21-member 13-member CAP Panel shall consist of at least four two former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
(2)CAP Panel members shall be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member shall be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panels members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
(3)(A)The Office of Planning and Research shall hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director shall be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director shall hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. chapter, including a CAP Program general counsel who has expertise in adjudicating complaints alleging violations of law. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, shall initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024. 2025.
(B)The CAP Program director shall provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to help them fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter.
(C)The CAP Panel shall consult with the CAP Program director when establishing adopting CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter.
(D)The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
(E)The CAP Panel, at the discretion of the CAP Program director and consistent with the requirements of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), shall seek to conduct meetings, solicit information, and conduct its other duties and powers virtually, and use other methods to minimize costs of the CAP Program.
(4)(A)A CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member 13-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member 13-member CAP Panels members serve staggered terms.
(B)All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member 13-member CAP Panel is appointed shall be six-year terms with no term limits.
(C)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)(A)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director shall not have served, within five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports athletics conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), two CAP Panel members shall be employees of institutions of higher education. These two CAP Panel members shall not be employees of the same institution of higher education.
(6)The racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California shall be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
(7)(A)The CAP Panel shall consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise: who have expertise as follows:
(A)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:(i)One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury.
(ii)One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports.
(iii)One member with expertise in mental health.
(iv)One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations.
(v)One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations.
(vi)Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
(B)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:(i)One member with expertise in contract law.(ii)One member with expertise in college sports recruiting.(iii)One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law.(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.(C)The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:(i)One member with expertise in sports agent certification.(ii)One member with expertise in financial advising standards.(iii)One member with expertise in marketing standards.(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.(D)The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:(i)(vii)One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104191).
(ii)(viii)One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics.
(iii)(ix)One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations.
(x)One member with expertise in adjudicating complaints alleging violations of the law.
(iv)(xi)One member with expertise in arbitration.
(v)(xii)One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
(vi)One member with expertise in producing educational materials.(B)CAP Panel members may have overlapping areas of expertise.
(c)The In accordance with the regulations, standards, and policies adopted by the CAP Panel Panel, the CAP Program director shall have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
(1)Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations of this chapter.
(2)Issue subpoenas, If approved by the CAP Program general counsel, issue subpoenas pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with Section 11180) of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its their duties pursuant to this chapter.
(3)Require an institution of higher education and out-of-state college or university that is subject to this chapter to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter.
(4)(A)Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed pursuant to subdivision (d) to the Attorney General a district attorney for prosecution, as appropriate.
(B)The Attorney General A district attorney may prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
(5)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.(6)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.(7)Hold quarterly meetings.(8)(5)Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, 2026, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each institution of higher education, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code, on the state of college athlete protections established adopted pursuant to this chapter.
(9)(6)Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this chapter.
(10)(7)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
(d)The CAP Panel shall have all of the following duties and powers:
(1)Adopt regulations, standards, and policies for the implementation and enforcement of this chapter.
(2)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.
(3)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate athletics conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.
(4)Hold quarterly meetings.
(d)(e)(1)In addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations shall include a system to appeal the CAP Panels rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
(A)Training to help prevent future violations.
(B)Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.(C)Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel.(B)Issuance of citations.
(C)Requiring the institution of higher education to notify its college athletes, prospective college athletes, and the public about citations issued pursuant to subparagraph (B) due to violations committed by its employees, volunteers, or affiliated medical personnel.
(D)Issuance of monetary fines and other remedies.
(E)Bringing a CAP Program violation against an individual to an administrative law judge for adjudication.
(i)An administrative law judge who rules that an individual has committed a violation of this chapter may uphold CAP Program penalties and remedies or impose alternative penalties and remedies, including, but not limited to, requiring the institution to notify its college athletes, its prospective college athletes, and the public of the violation, including any penalties and remedies imposed due to the violation.
(ii)An administrative law judge may suspend or permanently ban an individual from participating in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the administrative law judge finds any of the following:
(I)That the individuals violation of this chapter caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(II)That the individual knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in the investigation of a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death in violation of this chapter.
(III)That the individual threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported a violation of this chapter that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(IV)That the individual failed to adequately respond to a complaint that would have prevented a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(2)Before a CAP Program penalty or remedy may be imposed on an individual pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation of this chapter.
(2)(3)The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
(A)The number and duration of violations.
(B)Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action.
(C)The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
67466.67465.(a)An institution of higher education shall meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465. Panel. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel shall do all of the following:
(1)Consult with athletic associations, the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community.
(2)Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers Association.
(3)Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
(b)(1)All reports of suspected health and safety violations at complaints related to athlete safety, including evidence cited and information in complaints, received by an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, 2024, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, shall be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice shall forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director established hired pursuant to Section 67465 67464 once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section.
(2)Within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanels Panels health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to subdivision (a), an institution of higher education shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards.
(B)Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, choice and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director.
(C)Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel the point of contacts email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, Panel, the institutions athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel may require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
(c)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel Panel shall have all of the following duties and powers: powers related to athlete safety:
(1)Require transparency from institutions of higher education on injury treatment options for college athletes.
(2)Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks.
(3)Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athletes participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request.
(4)Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities under this section.
(5)Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes.
(6)Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary.
(7)Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program.
(8)Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance with this section.
(9)Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned pursuant to subdivision (e) clause (ii) of subparagraph (E) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 67464 from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education.
(10)Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
(d)All athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, shall report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
(e)(1)An individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:(A)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.(B)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.(C)Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.(D)Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).(f)(1)Any individual or entity designated by an institution of higher education to investigate allegations of a violation of this section that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.(2)Before a penalty may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual or entity shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).(g)(e)Except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel shall have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel shall not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
(h)(f)Affiliated medical personnel shall be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher educations office or department that is independent of the institutions athletic department.
67467.67466.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that reports twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) or more in annual grand total revenue to the United States Department of Education shall be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(b)(1)An institution of higher education that reports fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) or more in annual grand total revenue to the United States Department of Education shall comply with both of the following:
(A)Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance shall be paid for by the institution. The institution shall not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance.
(B)Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(c)If a college athlete at an institution of higher education that is responsible for the college athletes medical expenses pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) chooses to receive medical care that is not provided pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution shall offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
(1)The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care.
(2)The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
(d)(1)An institution of higher education shall pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not withhold a college athletes medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1), or otherwise impede a college athletes right to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1).
(e)(1)No later than three days after the end of a college athletes teams season in the final year of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institutions receipt of a college athletes notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education shall provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)A former college athlete shall be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
67468.67467.(a)On or before July 1 of each year, an institution shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation shall include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
(A)Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institutions male and female college athletes.
(B)Whether the institutions male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
(C)Whether the interests and abilities of the institutions male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation pursuant to this subparagraph shall include measures of the institutions performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979.
(D)The institutions determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
(2)Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
(b)At the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), the institution shall include the following statement: To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator.
(c)(1)An individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with this section, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), shall be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), an individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).67469.67468.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant shall provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant shall be provided regardless of the college athletes lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(2)The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year shall be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
(b)(1)A college athlete who transfers to an institution of higher education shall receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to subdivision (a) for up to one academic year beyond the college athletes remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first.
(2)Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the institution of higher educations leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, subdivision (a) shall only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year.
(3)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory.
(4)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
(A)Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion.
(B)Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters.
(C)Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements.
(D)Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022. 2024.
(d)An individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not do either any of the following:
(1)Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion.
(2)Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athletes selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
(3)Impose more stringent restrictions on the speech of college athletes than those imposed on other students attending the institution.
(4)Impose any fines on college athletes that do not also apply to other students attending the institution.
(e)An individual employed by an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a member of, or volunteer for, an organization, program, or event, so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic programs mandatory team activities.
(f)An institution of higher education shall not comply with any athletic associations or intercollegiate athletic conferences policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
(g)An institution of higher education shall not reduce any discretionary grand total revenue during the academic year below the discretionary grand total revenue reported for the 202122 202223 academic year.
(h)(1)An institution of higher education shall not reduce any aggregate funds the amount of aggregate funds in an academic year below the amount of aggregate funds used in the 202223 academic year for any college athletes academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, nutritional, diversity, equity, and inclusion support for college athletes, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 202122 202223 academic year.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), an institution of higher education may reduce the amount of aggregate funds in an academic year below the amount of aggregate funds used in the 202223 academic year for college athlete medical, mental health, or athletic training care if this care is not medically necessary.
(3)This subdivision shall apply to all intercollegiate athletic sports at the institution, including, but not limited to, all intercollegiate female sports and Olympic sports. These sports include, but are not limited to, gymnastics, rowing, soccer, swimming, track and field, and volleyball.
(4)This subdivision only applies to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2024.
(i)Subdivisions (g) and (h) shall not apply to an institution of higher education that is unable to generate, for an academic year, all revenue in an amount that meets or exceeds all revenue reported for the 202122 202223 academic year due to war, civil unrest, or fire, flood, or other unforeseen disaster or cause beyond the institutions control as determined by the CAP Panel.
67470.(a)(1)An institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:(A)A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete.(B)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes choice of athlete representation.(C)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes representation to NIL activities.(D)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.(2)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel shall solicit the information described in paragraph (1) and post information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described in paragraph (1) shall be regularly updated.(b)An institution of higher education shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed pursuant to this subdivision may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:(1)The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.(2)The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.(3)The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.(4)The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.(5)The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institutions in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panels internet website pursuant to this section.(6)Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policys benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes.(7)A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed.(8)The disclosures described in subdivision (a), as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.(c)This section does not prohibit an institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university that is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.67471.(a)The CAP Certification Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 shall certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.(b)No later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanels certification operations, an individual or entity shall not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanels certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.(c)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:(1)Certify all of the following:(A)College athlete agents.(B)Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents.(C)Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state.(D)Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state.(2)Revoke certifications provided pursuant to paragraph (1).(3)Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.(d)(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant to subdivision (c). Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.(2)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity pursuant to paragraph (1).(3)Fees and fines collected pursuant to subdivision (d) shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.(e)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall not adopt a standard pursuant to this section that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associates degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.(f)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel.(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities.(2)To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel shall not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.(g)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.67472.67469.(a)On or before January 15, 2024, 2025, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, shall pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to subdivision (b), to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven six million dollars ($7,000,000) ($6,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476. 67475.
(b)The CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institutions total athletics grand total revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act established pursuant to Section 485 of the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092) to the United States Department of Education. The CAP Panel shall establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)Institutions of higher education with athletic grand total revenue of less than two million four hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($2,499,999) shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(2)Institutions of higher education with athletic grand total revenue between two million five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000) and nineteen million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($19,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their grand total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(3)Institutions of higher education with athletic grand total revenue between twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and twenty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($29,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1 percent of their grand total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(4)Institutions of higher education with athletic grand total revenue between thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) and fifty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($59,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3 percent of their grand total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(5)Institutions of higher education with athletic grand total revenue of at least sixty million dollars ($60,000,000) shall each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3 percent of their grand total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on institutions of higher education, an institution of higher educations annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution pursuant to subdivision (b).
(2)(A)If the total amount of annual fees collected pursuant to paragraph (1) exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven six million dollars ($7,000,000), ($6,000,000), the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), six million dollars ($6,000,000), is returned:
(i)Institutions described in paragraphs (1) and (6) of subdivision (b) shall receive first priority.
(ii)Institutions described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) shall receive second priority.
(iii)Institutions described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) shall receive third priority.
(iv)Institutions described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) shall receive fourth priority.
(v)Institutions described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) shall receive fifth priority.
(B)It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
67473.67470.(a)An institution of higher education shall administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An institution of higher education shall require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athletes first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
(b)A program developed pursuant to this section shall include, but is not limited to, information on both all of the following:
(1)The rights of college athletes under this chapter.
(2)State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
(3)Information about the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 18895) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code).
(4)Information about the importance of job experience in the job market, how to write a resume, and strategies and skills regarding employment interviews.
(c)A program developed pursuant to this section shall not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
67474.67471.An institution of higher education shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
(a)For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source.
(b)For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics.
(c)For a college athletes family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
67475.67472.(a)An institution of higher education and the institutions employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel shall not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under this chapter.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, retaliation shall include all of the following:
(1)A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher educations policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws.
(2)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation.
(3)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete.
(4)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athletes housing owned by the institution of higher education.
(5)A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment.
(6)Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint.
(7)Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
67473.(a)An institution of higher education shall operate its athletic programs. An institution of higher education shall not contract or license away operational control of an athletic program.
(b)This section does not apply to the hiring of intercollegiate athletics personnel positions at an institution of higher education, including, but not limited to, athletic program directors, coaches, and staff.
67474.(a)An athlete agent shall provide any current or prospective college athlete that the agent seeks to represent and the college athletes legal guardian or guardians, if applicable, a completed copy of the athlete agent disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 18895) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code).
(b)A college athlete who enters into an agreement with an athlete agent who does not comply with subdivision (a) or the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 18895) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code), shall not be required to comply with the agreement, and shall have all remedies available under the law.
67476.67475.The California Athlete Protection (CAP) Fund (CAP Fund) is hereby established. The CAP Panel Program director shall administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund shall serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except for moneys described in Section 67463. chapter. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established Program director hired pursuant to Section 67465 67464 for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established Program director hired pursuant to Section 67465 67464 for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing this chapter.
67477.67476.The CAP Panel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
67478.67477.This chapter does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators of this chapter from liability.
67479.67478.The provisions of this chapter are severable. If any provision of this chapter or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 6.SEC. 5.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
For purposes of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 67450) and this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from an institution of higher education within six years of initial enrollment at that institution, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(g)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452.3 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 67454 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 67455 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 5.Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 67460) is added to Part 40.3 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:3.The College Athlete Protection Act67460.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the College Athlete Protection Act.
1.Definitions67461.As used in this chapter, unless the context requires otherwise, the following definitions apply:
(a)Affiliated medical personnel means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education. Affiliated medical personnel include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
(b)Aggregate athletic grants means the total amount of athletic grants that an institution of higher education annually reports pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. Aggregate athletic grants shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institutions in-state or out-of-state college athletes.
(c)All revenue includes revenue that is not allocated by sport pursuant to federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act reporting standards.
(c)(d)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(d)(e)Athletic grant means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete to cover a portion or all of the institutions cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1087ll). An athletic grant shall not exceed the institutions cost of attendance.
(e)(f)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at an institution of higher education.
(f)(g)CAP Fund means the California Athlete Protection Fund established pursuant to this chapter.
(g)(h)CAP Panel means the California Athlete Protection Panel established pursuant to this chapter.
(h)(i)CAP Program means the California Athlete Protection Program established pursuant to this chapter.
(i)(j)College athlete means a student who is enrolled at an institution of higher education and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
(j)(k)Fair market value compensation means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic teams aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic teams revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team. This fair market value compensation calculation does not include revenue that is not allocated by sport.
(l)Institutional funds means the amount of an institution of higher educations revenue that is not derived from any intercollegiate athletics source for an academic year that exceeds the amount of its revenue that did not derive from any intercollegiate athletics source reported for the 202122 academic year.
(k)(m)Institution of higher education or institution means any campus of the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
(l)(n)Intercollegiate athlete means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
(m)(o)NCAA means the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
(n)(p)NIL means the use of a college athletes name, image, and likeness.
(o)(q)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(p)(r)Revenue means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education. Revenue includes intercollegiate athletics revenue paid directly by an intercollegiate athletic conference, an athletic association, or a source designated by an institution of higher education, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association to cover any athletic program expense or to compensate a college athlete for participating in intercollegiate athletics at the institution.
(q)(s)Title IX means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.)
2.Findings67462.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, conferences, and associations and the state.
(b)Institutions of higher education exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance.
(c)To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred.
(d)The state needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death.
(e)Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety.
(f)College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athletes interests are always put first.
(g)Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decisionmaking related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences.
(h)To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes sports-related injuries.
(i)Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athletes NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements.
(j)A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes.
(k)Intercollegiate athletic laws and rules in other states affect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes.
(l)In National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141, the United States Supreme Court ruled unanimously that NCAA educational-related compensation limits imposed on college athletes violated federal antitrust law, and acknowledged that the NCAA did not dispute that NCAA college athlete compensation limits decrease college athletes compensation.
3.General Provisions67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year. pursuant to this section.
(b)An institution of higher education shall use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution, but does not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year, in a total amount that provides fair market compensation to the college athlete for the academic year. institution pursuant to this section.
(c)College athletes on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year shall be designated an equal payment from that institutions degree completion fund for that academic year.
(d)(1)All degree completion funds of up to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) shall be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year.
(2)Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in paragraph (1) shall be made in an amount based on the institutions revenue reported for the previous academic year.
(e)An institution shall not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
(f)(1)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(2)All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university shall be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(g)(1)An institution of higher education shall accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution shall not undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
(2)The CAP Panel may audit an institution of higher educations aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance with this section. This audit may include review of the institutions aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This paragraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(h)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds shall be deposited in the institutions degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
(i)(1)(A)In making annual degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, an institution of higher education may opt to only shall use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds all revenue reported for the 202122 academic year. As used in this subdivision, all revenue includes revenue that is not allocated by sport pursuant to federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act reporting standards. Notwithstanding subdivision (b), if the institution uses this option, the The institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as all of the conditions in this paragraph and subdivision (k) are satisfied.
(B)The Except as provided in subparagraph (F), the institution shall use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A), in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this paragraph. designations.
(C)The institution shall determine, for an academic year, the percentage of the total fair market compensation that college athletes on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution represent of the total fair market compensation owed to all college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport. College athletes on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, shall collectively receive this percentage of the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A) for the academic year.(D)Each college athlete on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, at the institution who qualifies for a degree completion fund payment designation pursuant to this paragraphshall receive an equal share of moneys calculated pursuant to this paragraph.(E)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this paragraph shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.(F)The institution of higher education shall not reduce any discretional revenue during the academic year below the discretional revenue reported for the 202122 academic year.(C)The institution shall make, in aggregate, for an academic year, one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its female college athletes, and one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its male college athletes.
(D)From the portion of the total amount allocated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C), the institution shall make degree completion fund payment designations for female college athletes on each womens intercollegiate athletics team who have not received fair market value compensation for the academic year. In making the degree completion fund payment designations, the institution shall comply with all of the following:
(i)Determine the percentage of the total fair market value compensation owed to female college athletes on each womens intercollegiate athletics team at the institution that represents the total fair market compensation owed to all female college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport.
(ii)Ensure that female college athletes on the same womens intercollegiate athletics team, regardless of sport, collectively receive the percentage determined pursuant to clause (i) of the total amount designated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).
(iii)If the portion of the total amount allocated for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C) exceeds the total aggregate fair market value compensation owed to all female college athletes on womens intercollegiate athletics teams at the institution, regardless of sport, the institution shall pay each of its female college athletes who receive an athletic grant an equal amount of the portion for female college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).
(E)From the portion of the total amount allocated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C), the institution shall make degree completion fund payment designations for male college athletes on each mens intercollegiate athletics team who have not received fair market compensation. In making the degree completion fund payment designations, the institution shall comply with all of the following:
(i)Determine the percentage of the total fair market compensation owed to male college athletes on each mens intercollegiate athletics team at the institution that represents the total fair market compensation owed to all male college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport.
(ii)Ensure that male college athletes on the same mens intercollegiate athletics team, regardless of sport, collectively receive the percentage determined pursuant to clause (i) of the total amount designated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).
(iii)If the portion of the total amount allocated for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C) exceeds the total aggregate fair market value compensation owed to all male college athletes on mens intercollegiate athletics teams at the institution, regardless of sport, the institution shall pay each of its male college athletes who receive an athletic grant an equal amount of the portion for male college athletes pursuant to subparagraph (C).
(F)Except to comply with subparagraphs (D) and (E), and subdivision (k), degree completion fund payment designations shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
(G)Notwithstanding subparagraph (B), an institution of higher education that gives fair market compensation to all of its male and female college athletes and complies with this section may use any remaining revenue for other purposes as determined by the institution.
(G)(H)The institution may spend additional institutional funds on intercollegiate athletic expenses without the funds counting as revenue if, within the academic year, the additional institutional funds are exhausted or the additional institutional funds are unused and do not remain in an athletic teams or athletic programs budget. This subparagraph authorizes an institution to increase athletics spending for athletic program needs without including it in revenue directed to degree completion funds pursuant to this section.
(H)(I)The amount of funds that the institution paid for any athletic teams expenses for the 202122 academic year shall be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution did not count the funds as revenue for that academic year.
(I)(J)Notwithstanding subparagraph (H), (I), the amount of funds that an institution paid for any athletic teams nonregular capital expenses for the 202122 academic year shall not be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution counted the funds as revenue for that academic year.
(2)An institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees pursuant to this chapter before using revenue described in paragraph (1) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
(3)(A)On or before June 15, 2025, and on or before every June 15 thereafter, each institution of higher education shall disclose publicly on its internet website, to its college athletes, to prospective college athletes it is recruiting for intercollegiate athletics, and to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 whether the institution, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the subsequent academic year, will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b). (B)Each institution of higher education shall include the information disclosed pursuant to subparagraph (A) in all of its written athletic grant agreement offers.(C)On or before February 1, 2024, each institution of higher education shall disclose, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the 202324 academic year, whether the institution will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b).(j)Degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education shall have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
(k)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution may shall adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as all of the following conditions are met: athletics. For any adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision, the institution shall comply with all of the following requirements:
(1)The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institutions college athletes is shall not be reduced.
(2)The institution is in compliance shall comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
(3)On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution publishes shall publish on its internet website and submits submit to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and includes include both of the following in this written explanation:
(A)Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.
(B)The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(l)Degree completion fund payment designations or payments shall not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
(m)Within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, each institution of higher education shall submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athletes intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(n)An institution of higher education and its personnel shall not make, or attempt to make, formal or informal agreements, policies, or practices with other institutions of higher education, out-of-state colleges and universities, athletic conferences, and athletic associations or their personnel, or other entities with intercollegiate athletics governance powers, to determine degree completion fund payment amounts to college athletes.
(o)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a an NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
67464.(a)An institution of higher education shall distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
(1)A college athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(2)An individual notice stating: All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the Attorney General, United States Department of Justice, the United States Department of Educations Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.
(3)A college athletes rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A college athletes rights under this chapter.
(5)Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
(b)The notice distributed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.
(2)The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting.
(3)The internet website address used by the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters pursuant to Section 11165.7 of the Penal Code and the obligations of these mandated reporters.
(5)The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter.
(6)The telephone number of the Attorney General. United States Department of Justice.
(c)An institution of higher education shall post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institutions athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
(d)Upon the commencement of each academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
67465.(a)The College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program is hereby established as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of this chapter.
(b)The CAP Program shall be administered by the CAP Panel. The CAP Panel shall be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
(1)(A)The 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
(i)Eleven members appointed by the Governor.
(ii)Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(iii)Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(B)The 21-member CAP Panel shall consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
(2)CAP Panel members shall be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member shall be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panels members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
(3)(A)The Office of Planning and Research shall hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director shall be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director shall hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, shall initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024.
(B)The CAP Program director shall provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter.
(C)The CAP Panel shall consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter.
(D)The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
(4)(A)A CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panels members serve staggered terms.
(B)All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed shall be six-year terms with no term limits.
(C)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director shall not have served, within five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
(6)The racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California shall be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
(7)The CAP Panel shall consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
(A)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury.
(ii)One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports.
(iii)One member with expertise in mental health.
(iv)One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations.
(v)One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations.
(vi)Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
(B)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in contract law.
(ii)One member with expertise in college sports recruiting.
(iii)One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
(C)The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports agent certification.
(ii)One member with expertise in financial advising standards.
(iii)One member with expertise in marketing standards.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
(D)The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104191).
(ii)One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics.
(iii)One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations.
(iv)One member with expertise in arbitration.
(v)One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
(vi)One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
(c)The CAP Panel shall have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
(1)Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations of this chapter.
(2)Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties pursuant to this chapter.
(3)Require an institution of higher education and out-of-state college or university that is subject to this chapter to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter.
(4)(A)Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed pursuant to subdivision (d) to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate.
(B)The Attorney General may prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
(5)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.
(6)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.
(7)Hold quarterly meetings.
(8)Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each institution of higher education, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter.
(9)Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this chapter.
(10)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
(d)(1)In addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations shall include a system to appeal the CAP Panels rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
(A)Training to help prevent future violations.
(B)Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(C)Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel.
(2)The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
(A)The number and duration of violations.
(B)Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action.
(C)The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
67466.(a)An institution of higher education shall meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall do all of the following:
(1)Consult with athletic associations, the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community.
(2)Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers Association.
(3)Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
(b)(1)All reports of suspected health and safety violations at an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, shall be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice shall forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director established pursuant to Section 67465 once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section.
(2)Within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanels health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to subdivision (a), an institution of higher education shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards.
(B)Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director.
(C)Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel the point of contacts email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, the institutions athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel may require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
(c)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall have all of the following duties and powers:
(1)Require transparency from institutions of higher education on injury treatment options for college athletes.
(2)Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks.
(3)Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athletes participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request.
(4)Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities under this section.
(5)Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes.
(6)Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary.
(7)Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program.
(8)Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance with this section.
(9)Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned pursuant to subdivision (e) from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education.
(10)Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
(d)All athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, shall report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
(e)(1)An individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
(A)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(B)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(C)Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(D)Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(f)(1)Any individual or entity designated by an institution of higher education to investigate allegations of a violation of this section that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.
(2)Before a penalty may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual or entity shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(g)Except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel shall have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel shall not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
(h)Affiliated medical personnel shall be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher educations office or department that is independent of the institutions athletic department.
67467.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that reports twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(b)(1)An institution of higher education that reports fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall comply with both of the following:
(A)Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance shall be paid for by the institution. The institution shall not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance.
(B)Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(c)If a college athlete at an institution of higher education that is responsible for the college athletes medical expenses pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) chooses to receive medical care that is not provided pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution shall offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
(1)The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care.
(2)The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
(d)(1)An institution of higher education shall pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not withhold a college athletes medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1), or otherwise impede a college athletes right to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1).
(e)(1)No later than three days after the end of a college athletes teams season in the final year of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institutions receipt of a college athletes notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education shall provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)A former college athlete shall be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
67468.(a)On or before July 1 of each year, an institution shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation shall include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
(A)Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institutions male and female college athletes.
(B)Whether the institutions male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
(C)Whether the interests and abilities of the institutions male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation pursuant to this subparagraph shall include measures of the institutions performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979.
(D)The institutions determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
(2)Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
(b)At the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), the institution shall include the following statement: To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator.
(c)(1)An individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with this section, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), shall be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), an individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
67469.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant shall provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant shall be provided regardless of the college athletes lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(2)The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year shall be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
(b)(1)A college athlete who transfers to an institution of higher education shall receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to subdivision (a) for up to one academic year beyond the college athletes remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first.
(2)Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the institution of higher educations leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, subdivision (a) shall only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year.
(3)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory.
(4)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
(A)Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion.
(B)Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters.
(C)Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements.
(D)Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
(c)(1)If the CAP Panel determines in an administrative hearing that an institution of higher education has reduced aggregate funds for a college athletes academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, eliminated roster slots on an athletic programs team, reduced aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminated an intercollegiate sport entirely, the athletic director or the representative of the institution of higher education who is primarily responsible for directing the athletic program shall be suspended from involvement in intercollegiate athletics at an institution of higher education for, at minimum, three academic years, as determined by the CAP Panel.(2)Before a suspension may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).(c)Subdivisions (a) and (b) shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
(d)An individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not do either of the following:
(1)Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion.
(2)Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athletes selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
(e)An individual employed by an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic programs mandatory team activities.
(f)An institution of higher education shall not comply with any athletic associations or athletic conferences policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
(g)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.(g)An institution of higher education shall not reduce any discretionary revenue during the academic year below the discretionary revenue reported for the 202122 academic year.
(h)An institution of higher education shall not reduce any aggregate funds for any college athletes academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 202122 academic year.
(i)Subdivisions (g) and (h) shall not apply to an institution of higher education that is unable to generate, for an academic year, all revenue in an amount that meets or exceeds all revenue reported for the 202122 academic year due to war, civil unrest, or fire, flood, or other unforeseen disaster or cause beyond the institutions control as determined by the CAP Panel.
67470.(a)(1)An institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:
(A)A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete.
(B)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes choice of athlete representation.
(C)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes representation to NIL activities.
(D)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
(2)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel shall solicit the information described in paragraph (1) and post information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described in paragraph (1) shall be posted on or before October 1, 2024, and regularly updated thereafter. updated.
(b)An institution of higher education shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed pursuant to this subdivision may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
(1)The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(2)The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(3)The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(4)The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(5)The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institutions in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panels internet website pursuant to this section.
(6)Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policys benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes.
(7)A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed.
(8)The disclosures described in subdivision (a), as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)This section does not prohibit an institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university this that is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.
67471.(a)The CAP Certification Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 shall certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
(b)No later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanels certification operations, an individual or entity shall not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanels certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
(c)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
(1)Certify all of the following:
(A)College athlete agents.
(B)Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents.
(C)Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state.
(D)Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state.
(2)Revoke certifications provided pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
(d)(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant to subdivision (c). Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
(2)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Fees and fines collected pursuant to subdivision (d) shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(e)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall not adopt a standard pursuant to this section that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associates degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
(f)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel.
(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities.
(2)To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel shall not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
(g)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
67472.(a)On or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, shall pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to subdivision (b), to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(b)The CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institutions total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education. The CAP Panel shall establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of less than two million four hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($2,499,999) shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(2)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between two million five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000) and nineteen million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($19,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(3)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and twenty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($29,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(4)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) and fifty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($59,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(5)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of at least sixty million dollars ($60,000,000) shall each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on institutions of higher education, an institution of higher educations annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution pursuant to subdivision (b).
(2)(A)If the total amount of annual fees collected pursuant to paragraph (1) exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
(i)Institutions described in paragraphs (1) and (6) of subdivision (b) shall receive first priority.
(ii)Institutions described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) shall receive second priority.
(iii)Institutions described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) shall receive third priority.
(iv)Institutions described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) shall receive fourth priority, priority.
(v)Institutions described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) shall receive fifth priority.
(B)It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
67473.(a)An institution of higher education shall administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An institution of higher education shall require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athletes first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
(b)A program developed pursuant to this section shall include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
(1)The rights of college athletes under this chapter.
(2)State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
(c)A program developed pursuant to this section shall not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
67474.An institution of higher education shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
(a)For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source.
(b)For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics.
(c)For a college athletes family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
67475.(a)An institution of higher education and the institutions employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel shall not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under this chapter.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, retaliation shall include all of the following:
(1)A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher educations policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws.
(2)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation.
(3)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete.
(4)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athletes housing owned by the institution of higher education.
(5)A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment.
(6)Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint.
(7)Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
67476.The California Athlete Protection Fund (CAP Fund) is hereby established. The CAP Panel shall administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund shall serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except for moneys described in Section 67463. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing this chapter.
67477.The CAP Panel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
67478.This chapter does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators of this chapter from liability.
67479.The provisions of this chapter are severable. If any provision of this chapter or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
For purposes of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 67450) and this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from an institution of higher education within six years of initial enrollment at that institution, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(g)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452.3 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 67454 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 67455 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 5.Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 67460) is added to Part 40.3 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:3.The College Athlete Protection Act67460.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the College Athlete Protection Act.
1.Definitions67461.As used in this chapter, unless the context requires otherwise, the following definitions apply:
(a)Affiliated medical personnel means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education. Affiliated medical personnel include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
(b)Aggregate athletic grants means the total amount of athletic grants that an institution of higher education annually reports pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. Aggregate athletic grants shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institutions instate in-state or out-of-state college athletes.
(c)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(d)Athletic grant means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete. athlete to cover a portion or all of the institutions cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1087ll). An athletic grant shall not exceed the institutions cost of attendance.
(e)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at an institution of higher education.
(f)CAP Fund means the California Athlete Protection Fund established pursuant to this chapter.
(g)CAP Panel means the California Athlete Protection Panel established pursuant to this chapter.
(h)CAP Program means the California Athlete Protection Program established pursuant to this chapter.
(i)College athlete means a student who is enrolled at an institution of higher education and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
(j)Fair market value compensation means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic teams aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic teams revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team. This fair market value compensation calculation does not include revenue that is not allocated by sport.
(k)Institution of higher education or institution means any campus of the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
(l)Intercollegiate athlete means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
(m)NCAA means the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
(n)NIL means the use of a college athletes name, image, and likeness.
(o)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(p)Revenue means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education.
(q)Title IX means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.)
2.Findings67462.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, conferences, and associations and the state.
(b)Institutions of higher education exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance.
(c)To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred.
(d)The state needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death.
(e)Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety.
(f)College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athletes interests are always put first.
(g)Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decisionmaking related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences.
(h)To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes sports-related injuries.
(i)Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athletes NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements.
(j)A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes.
(k)Intercollegiate athletic laws and rules in other states affect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes.
(l)In National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141, the United States Supreme Court ruled unanimously that NCAA educational-related compensation limits imposed on college athletes violated federal antitrust law, and acknowledged that the NCAA did not dispute that NCAA college athlete compensation limits decrease college athletes compensation.
3.General Provisions67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
(b)An institution of higher education shall use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution, but does not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year, in a total amount that provides fair market compensation to the college athlete for the academic year.
(c)A college athlete College athletes on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year shall be designated an equal payment from that institutions degree completion fund for that academic year.
(d)(1)All degree completion funds of up to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) shall be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year.
(2)Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in paragraph (1) shall be made in an amount based on the institutions revenue reported for the previous academic year.
(e)An institution shall not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
(f)(1)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(2)All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university shall be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(g)(1)An institution of higher education shall accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution shall not undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
(2)The CAP Panel may audit an institution of higher educations aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance with this section. This audit may include review of the institutions aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This paragraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(h)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds shall be deposited in the institutions degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
(i)(1)(A)In making annual degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, an institution of higher education may opt to only use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds its all revenue reported for the 202122 academic year. As used in this subdivision, all revenue includes revenue that is not allocated by sport pursuant to federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act reporting standards. Notwithstanding subdivision (b), if the institution uses this option, the institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as all of the conditions in this paragraph are satisfied.
(B)The institution shall use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A), in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)The institution shall determine, for an academic year, the percentage of the total fair market compensation that college athletes on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution represent of the total fair market compensation owed to all college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport. College athletes on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, shall collectively receive this percentage of the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A) for the academic year.
(D)Each college athlete on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, at the institution who qualifies for a degree completion fund payment designation pursuant to this paragraph shall receive an equal share of moneys calculated pursuant to this paragraph.
(E)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this paragraph shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
(F)The institution of higher education shall not reduce any discretional revenue during the academic year below the discretional revenue reported for the 202122 academic year.
(G)The institution may spend additional institutional funds on intercollegiate athletic expenses without the funds counting as revenue if, within the academic year, the additional funds are exhausted or the additional funds are unused and do not remain in an athletic teams or athletic programs budget. This subparagraph authorizes an institution to increase athletics spending for athletic program needs without including it in revenue directed to degree completion funds pursuant to this section.
(H)The amount of funds that the institution paid for any athletic teams expenses for the 202122 academic year shall be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution did not count the funds as revenue for that academic year.
(I)Notwithstanding subparagraph (H), the amount of funds that an institution paid for any athletic teams nonregular capital expenses for the 202122 academic year shall not be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution counted the funds as revenue for that academic year.
(2)An institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees pursuant to this chapter before using revenue described in paragraph (1) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
(3)(A)On or before June 15, 2025, and on or before every June 15 thereafter, each institution of higher education shall disclose publicly on its internet website, to its college athletes, to prospective college athletes it is recruiting for intercollegiate athletics, and to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 whether the institution, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the subsequent academic year, will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b).
(B)Each institution of higher education shall include the information disclosed pursuant to subparagraph (A) in all of its written athletic grant agreement offers.
(C)On or before February 1, 2024, each institution of higher education shall disclose, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the 202324 academic year, whether the institution will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b).
(j)Degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education shall have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
(k)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution may adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institutions college athletes is not reduced.
(2)The institution is in compliance with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
(3)On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution publishes on its internet website and submits to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and includes both of the following in this written explanation:
(A)Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.
(B)The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(l)Degree completion fund payment designations or payments shall not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
(m)Within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, each institution of higher education shall submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athletes intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(n)An institution of higher education and its personnel shall not make, or attempt to make, formal or informal agreements, policies, or practices with other institutions of higher education, out-of-state colleges and universities, athletic conferences, and athletic associations or their personnel, or other entities with intercollegiate athletics governance powers, to determine degree completion fund payment amounts to college athletes.
(n)(o)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
67464.(a)An institution of higher education shall distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
(1)A college athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(2)An individual notice stating: All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the Attorney General, the United States Department of Educations Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.
(3)A college athletes rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A college athletes rights under this chapter.
(5)Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
(b)The notice distributed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.
(2)The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting.
(3)The internet website address used by the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters pursuant to Section 11165.7 of the Penal Code and the obligations of these mandated reporters.
(5)The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter.
(6)The telephone number of the Attorney General.
(c)An institution of higher education shall post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institutions athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
(d)Upon the commencement of each academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
67465.(a)The College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program is hereby established as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of this chapter.
(b)The CAP Program shall be administered by the CAP Panel. The CAP Panel shall be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
(1)(A)The 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
(i)Eleven members appointed by the Governor.
(ii)Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(iii)Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(B)The 21-member CAP Panel shall consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
(2)CAP Panel members shall be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member shall be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panels members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
(3)(A)The Office of Planning and Research shall hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director shall be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director shall hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, shall initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024.
(B)The CAP Program director shall provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter.
(C)The CAP Panel shall consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter.
(D)The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
(4)(A)A CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panels members serve staggered terms.
(B)All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed shall be six-year terms with no term limits.
(C)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director shall not have served, within 5 five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
(6)The racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California shall be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
(7)The CAP Panel shall consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
(A)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury.
(ii)One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports.
(iii)One member with expertise in mental health.
(iv)One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations.
(v)One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations.
(vi)Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
(B)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in contract law.
(ii)One member with expertise in college sports recruiting.
(iii)One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
(C)The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports agent certification.
(ii)One member with expertise in financial advising standards.
(iii)One member with expertise in marketing standards.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
(D)The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104191).
(ii)One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics.
(iii)One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations.
(iv)One member with expertise in arbitration.
(v)One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
(vi)One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
(c)The CAP Panel shall have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
(1)Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations of this chapter.
(2)Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties pursuant to this chapter.
(3)Require an institution of higher education and out-of-state college or university that is subject to this chapter to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter.
(4)(A)Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed pursuant to subdivision (d) to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate.
(B)The Attorney General shall have the authority to may prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
(5)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.
(6)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.
(7)Hold quarterly meetings.
(8)Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each institution of higher education, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter.
(9)Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this chapter.
(10)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
(d)(1)In addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations shall include a system to appeal the CAP Panels rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
(A)Training to help prevent future violations.
(B)Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(C)Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel.
(2)The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
(A)The number and duration of violations.
(B)Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action.
(C)The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
67466.(a)An institution of higher education shall meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall do all of the following:
(1)Consult with athletic associations, the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community.
(2)Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers Association.
(3)Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
(b)(1)All reports of suspected health and safety violations at an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, shall be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice shall forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director established pursuant to Section 67465 once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section.
(2)Within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanels health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to subdivision (a), an institution of higher education shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards.
(B)Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director.
(C)Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel the point of contacts email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, the institutions athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel may require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
(c)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall have all of the following duties and powers:
(1)Require transparency from institutions of higher education on injury treatment options for college athletes.
(2)Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks.
(3)Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athletes participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request.
(4)Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities under this section.
(5)Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes.
(6)Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary.
(7)Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program.
(8)Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance with this section.
(9)Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned pursuant to subdivision (e) from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education.
(10)Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
(d)All athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, shall report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
(e)(1)An individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
(A)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(B)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(C)Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(D)Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(f)(1)Any individual or entity designated by an institution of higher education to investigate allegations of a violation of this section that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.
(2)Before a penalty may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual or entity shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(g)Except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel shall have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel shall not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
(h)Affiliated medical personnel shall be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher educations office or department that is independent of the institutions athletic department.
67467.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that reports twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state higher education institution college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(b)(1)An institution of higher education that reports fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall comply with both of the following:
(A)Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance shall be paid for by the institution. The institution shall not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance.
(B)Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(c)If a college athlete at an institution of higher education that is responsible for the college athletes medical expenses pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) chooses to receive medical care that is not provided pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution shall offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
(1)The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care.
(2)The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
(d)(1)An institution of higher education shall pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not withhold a college athletes medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1), or otherwise impede a college athletes right to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1).
(e)(1)No later than three days after the end of a college athletes teams season in the final year of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institutions receipt of a college athletes notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education shall provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)A former college athlete shall be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
67468.(a)On or before July 1 of each year, an institution shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation shall include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
(A)Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institutions male and female college athletes.
(B)Whether the institutions male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
(C)Whether the interests and abilities of the institutions male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation pursuant to this subparagraph shall include measures of the institutions performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979.
(D)The institutions determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
(2)Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
(b)At the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), the institution shall include the following statement: To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator.
(c)(1)An individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with this section, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), shall be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), an individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
67469.(a)(1)An institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022, or becomes a member of a NCAA Division I sport thereafter, and that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant shall provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant shall be provided regardless of the college athletes lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(2)The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year shall be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
(b)(1)A college athlete who transfers to an institution of higher education shall receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to subdivision (a) for up to one academic year beyond the college athletes remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first.
(2)Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the institution of higher educations leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, subdivision (a) shall only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year.
(3)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory.
(4)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
(A)Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion.
(B)Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters.
(C)Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements.
(D)Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
(c)(1)If the CAP Panel determines in an administrative hearing that an institution of higher education has reduced aggregate funds for a college athletes academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, eliminated roster slots on an athletic programs team, reduced aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminated an intercollegiate sport entirely while paying an athletics administrator or coach an annual salary of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) or more, entirely, the athletic director or equivalent the representative of the institution of higher education who is primarily responsible for directing the athletic program shall be suspended from involvement in intercollegiate athletics at an institution of higher education for, at minimum, three academic years, as determined by the CAP Panel.
(2)Before a suspension may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(d)An individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not do either of the following:
(1)Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion.
(2)Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athletes selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
(e)An individual employed by an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic programs mandatory team activities.
(f)An institution of higher education shall not comply with any athletic associations or athletic conferences policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
(g)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
67470.(a)(1)An institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:
(A)A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete.
(B)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes choice of athlete representation.
(C)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes representation to NIL activities.
(D)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
(2)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel shall solicit the information described in paragraph (1) and post information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described in paragraph (1) shall be posted on or before October 1, 2024, and regularly updated thereafter.
(b)An institution of higher education shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident shall only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed pursuant to this subdivision may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
(1)The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(2)The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(3)The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(4)The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(5)The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institutions in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panels internet website pursuant to this section.
(6)Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policys benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes.
(7)A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed.
(8)The disclosures described in subdivision (a), as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)This section does not prohibit an institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university this is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.
67471.(a)The CAP Certification Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 shall certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
(b)No later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanels certification operations, an individual or entity shall not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanels certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
(c)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
(1)Certify all of the following:
(A)College athlete agents.
(B)Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents.
(C)Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state.
(D)Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state.
(2)Revoke certifications provided pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
(d)(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant to subdivision (c). Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
(2)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Fees and fines collected pursuant to subdivision (d) shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(e)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall not adopt a standard pursuant to this section that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associates degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
(f)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel.
(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities.
(2)To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel shall not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
(g)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
67472.(a)On or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, shall pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to subdivision (b), to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(b)The CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institutions total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education. The CAP Panel shall establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of less than two million four hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($2,499,999) shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(2)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between two million five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000) and nineteen million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($19,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(3)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and twenty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($29,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(4)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) and fifty-nine million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($59,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(5)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of at least sixty million dollars ($60,000,000) shall each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on institutions of higher education, an institution of higher educations annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution pursuant to subdivision (b).
(2)(A)If the total amount of annual fees collected pursuant to paragraph (1) exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
(i)Institutions described in paragraphs (1) and (6) of subdivision (b) shall receive first priority.
(ii)Institutions described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) shall receive second priority.
(iii)Institutions described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) shall receive third priority.
(iv)Institutions described in paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) shall receive forth fourth priority,
(v)Institutions described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) shall receive fifth priority.
(B)It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
67473.(a)An institution of higher education shall administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An institution of higher education shall require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athletes first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
(b)A program developed pursuant to this section shall include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
(1)The rights of college athletes under this chapter.
(2)State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
(c)A program developed pursuant to this section shall not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
67474.An institution of higher education shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
(a)For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source.
(b)For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics.
(c)For a college athletes family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
67475.(a)An institution of higher education and the institutions employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel shall not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under this chapter.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, retaliation shall include all of the following:
(1)A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher educations policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws.
(2)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation.
(3)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete.
(4)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athletes housing owned by the institution of higher education.
(5)A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment.
(6)Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint.
(7)Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
67476.The California Athlete Protection Fund (CAP Fund) is hereby established. The CAP Panel shall administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund shall serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except for moneys described in Section 67463. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing this chapter.
67477.The CAP Panel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
67478.This chapter does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators of this chapter from liability.
67479.The provisions of this chapter are severable. If any provision of this chapter or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
For purposes of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 67450) and this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from an institution of higher education within six years of initial enrollment at that institution, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(g)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452.3 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 67454 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 67455 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 5.Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 67460) is added to Part 40.3 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:3.The College Athlete Protection Act67460.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the College Athlete Protection Act.
1.Definitions67461.As used in this chapter, unless the context requires otherwise, the following definitions apply:
(a)Affiliated medical personnel means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education. Affiliated medical personnel include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
(b)Aggregate athletic grants means the total amount of athletic grants that an institution of higher education annually reports pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. Aggregate athletic grants shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institutions instate or out-of-state college athletes.
(c)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(d)Athletic grant means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete.
(e)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at an institution of higher education.
(f)CAP Fund means the California Athlete Protection Fund established pursuant to this chapter.
(g)CAP Panel means the California Athlete Protection Panel established pursuant to this chapter.
(h)CAP Program means the California Athlete Protection Program established pursuant to this chapter.
(i)College athlete means a student who is enrolled at an institution of higher education and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
(j)Fair market value compensation means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic teams aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic teams revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team.
(k)Institution of higher education or institution means any campus of the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
(l)Intercollegiate athlete means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
(m)NCAA means the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
(m)(n)NIL means the use of a college athletes name, image, and likeness.
(n)(o)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(o)(p)Revenue means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education.
(p)(q)Title IX means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.)
2.Findings67462.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, conferences, and associations and the state.
(b)Institutions of higher education exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance.
(c)To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred.
(d)The state needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death.
(e)Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety.
(f)College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athletes interests are always put first.
(g)Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decisionmaking related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences.
(h)To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes sports-related injuries.
(i)Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athletes NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements.
(j)A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes.
(k)Intercollegiate athletic laws and rules in other states affect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes.
3.General Provisions67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
(b)An institution of higher education shall use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution institution, but does not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year. year, in a total amount that provides fair market compensation to the college athlete for the academic year.
(c)A college athlete on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year shall be designated an equal payment from that institutions degree completion fund for that academic year.
(d)(1)All degree completion funds of up to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) shall be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year. Payments described in this subdivision shall be made annually no later than 60 days after the institution of higher education submits its annual report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education.
(2)Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in paragraph (1) shall be made in an amount based on the institutions revenue reported for the previous academic year.
(e)An institution shall not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
(f)(1)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(2)All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university shall be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(g)(1)An institution of higher education shall accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution shall not undercount undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
(2)The CAP Panel may audit an institution of higher educations aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance with this section. This audit may include review of the institutions aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This paragraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(h)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds shall be deposited in the institutions degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
(i)(1)(A)In making annual degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, an institution of higher education may opt to only use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds its revenue for the previous academic year. If an academic year that exceeds its revenue reported for the 202122 academic year. Notwithstanding subdivision (b), if the institution uses this option, the institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as both all of the following conditions are met: in this paragraph are satisfied.
(A)(i)All of the institutions revenue that was not categorized by gender or sport in the institutions report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for that academic year that exceeds the institutions revenue that was not categorized by gender or sport in the institutions report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for the previous academic year is used to make degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes and is not used for any other purpose.(B)The institution shall use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A), in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this paragraph.
(C)The institution shall determine, for an academic year, the percentage of the total fair market compensation that college athletes on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution represent of the total fair market compensation owed to all college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport. College athletes on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, shall collectively receive this percentage of the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to subparagraph (A) for the academic year.
(ii)(D)Each college athlete, athlete on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, at the institution who qualifies for a degree completion fund payment designation pursuant to this subparagraph receives paragraph shall receive an equal share of moneys calculated pursuant to this subparagraph. paragraph.
(iii)(E)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this subparagraph do paragraph shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
(B)(i)All revenue of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution for that academic year that exceeds that teams revenue for the previous academic year is used to make degree completion fund payment designations for that teams college athletes.(ii)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this subparagraph shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market compensation for any academic year.(2)An institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees pursuant to this chapter before using revenue described in paragraph (1) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
(3)(A)On or before June 15, 2025, and on or before every June 15 thereafter, each institution of higher education shall disclose publicly on its internet website, to its college athletes, to prospective college athletes it is recruiting for intercollegiate athletics, and to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 whether the institution, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the subsequent academic year, will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b).
(B)Each institution of higher education shall include the information disclosed pursuant to subparagraph (A) in all of its written athletic grant agreement offers.
(C)On or before February 1, 2024, each institution of higher education shall disclose, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the 202324 academic year, whether the institution will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision (b).
(j)Degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education shall have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
(k)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution may adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as both all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institutions college athletes is not reduced.
(2)The institution is in compliance with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
(3)On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution publishes on its internet website and submits to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and includes both of the following in this written explanation:
(A)Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.
(B)The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(l)Degree completion fund payment designations or payments shall not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
(m)Within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, each institution of higher education shall submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athletes intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
(m)(n)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
67464.(a)An institution of higher education shall distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
(1)A college athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(2)An individual notice stating: All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the Attorney General, the United States Department of Educations Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.
(3)A college athletes rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A college athletes rights under this chapter.
(5)Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
(b)The notice distributed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.
(2)The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting.
(3)The internet website address used by the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters pursuant to Section 11165.7 of the Penal Code and the obligations of these mandated reporters.
(5)The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter.
(6)The telephone number of the Attorney General.
(c)An institution of higher education shall post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institutions athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
(d)Upon the commencement of each academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
67465.(a)The College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program is hereby established as a program in the department Office of Planning and Research for purposes of this chapter.
(b)The CAP Program shall be administered by the CAP Panel. The CAP Panel shall be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
(1)(A)The 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
(i)Eleven members appointed by the Governor.
(ii)Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(iii)Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(B)The 21-member CAP Panel shall consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
(2)CAP Panel members shall be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member shall be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panels members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
(3)(A)The department Office of Planning and Research shall hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director shall be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director shall hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, shall initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024.
(B)The CAP Program director shall provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter.
(C)The CAP Panel shall consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter.
(D)The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
(4)(A)A CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panels members serve staggered terms.
(B)All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed shall be six-year terms with no term limits.
(C)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director shall not have served at any time served, within 5 years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
(6)The racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California shall be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
(7)The CAP Panel shall consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
(A)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury.
(ii)One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports.
(iii)One member with expertise in mental health.
(iv)One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations.
(v)One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations.
(vi)Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
(B)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in contract law.
(ii)One member with expertise in college sports recruiting.
(iii)One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
(C)The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports agent certification.
(ii)One member with expertise in financial advising standards.
(iii)One member with expertise in marketing standards.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
(D)The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104191).
(ii)One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics.
(iii)One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations.
(iv)One member with expertise in arbitration.
(v)One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
(vi)One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
(c)The CAP Panel shall have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
(1)Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations of this chapter.
(2)Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties pursuant to this chapter.
(3)Require an institution of higher education and out-of-state college or university that is subject to this chapter to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter.
(4)(A)Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed pursuant to subdivision (d) to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate.
(B)The Attorney General shall have the authority to prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
(5)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.
(6)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.
(7)Hold quarterly meetings.
(8)Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each institution of higher education, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter.
(9)Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this chapter.
(10)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
(d)(1)In addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations shall include a system to appeal the CAP Panels rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
(A)Training to help prevent future violations.
(B)Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(C)Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel.
(2)The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
(A)The number and duration of violations.
(B)Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action.
(C)The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
67466.(a)An institution of higher education shall meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall do all of the following:
(1)Consult with athletic associations, the University of California, the California State University, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community.
(2)Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers Association.
(3)Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
(b)(1)All reports of suspected health and safety violations at an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, shall be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice shall forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director established pursuant to Section 67465 once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section.
(2)Within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanels health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to subdivision (a), an institution of higher education shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards.
(B)Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director.
(C)Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel. Subpanel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel the point of contacts email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, the institutions athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel may require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
(c)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall have all of the following duties and powers:
(1)Require transparency from institutions of higher education on injury treatment options for college athletes.
(2)Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks.
(3)Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athletes participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request.
(4)Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities under this section.
(5)Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes.
(6)Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary.
(7)Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program.
(8)Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance with this section.
(9)Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned pursuant to subdivision (e) from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education.
(10)Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
(d)All athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, shall report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
(e)(1)An individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
(A)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(B)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(C)Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(D)Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life threatening life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(f)(1)Any individual or entity designated by an institution of higher education to investigate allegations of a violation of this section that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.
(2)Before a penalty may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual or entity shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(g)Except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel shall have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel shall not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
(h)Affiliated medical personnel shall be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher educations office or department that is independent of the institutions athletic department.
67467.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that reports twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state higher education institution and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(b)(1)An institution of higher education that reports fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall comply with both of the following:
(A)Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance shall be paid for by the institution. The institution shall not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance.
(B)Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(c)If a college athlete at an institution of higher education that is responsible for the college athletes medical expenses pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) chooses to receive medical care that is not provided pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution shall offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
(1)The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care.
(2)The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
(d)(1)An institution of higher education shall pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not withhold a college athletes medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1), or otherwise impede a college athletes right to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1).
(e)(1)No later than three days after the end of a college athletes teams season in the final year of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institutions receipt of a college athletes notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education shall provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)A former college athlete shall be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
67468.(a)On or before July 1 of each year, an institution shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation shall include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
(A)Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institutions male and female college athletes.
(B)Whether the institutions male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
(C)Whether the interests and abilities of the institutions male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation pursuant to this subparagraph shall include measures of the institutions performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979.
(D)The institutions determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
(2)Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
(b)At the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), the institution shall include the following statement: To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact(contact contact (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator.
(c)(1)An individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with this section, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), shall be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), an individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
67469.(a)(1)An institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association NCAA Division 1 I sport on or after January 1, 2022, or becomes a member of a National Collegiate Athletic Association NCAA Division I sport thereafter, and that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant shall provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant shall be provided regardless of the college athletes lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(2)The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year shall be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
(b)(1)A college athlete who transfers to an institution of higher education shall receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to subdivision (a) for up to one academic year beyond the college athletes remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first.
(2)Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the institution of higher educations leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, subdivision (a) shall only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year.
(3)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory.
(4)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
(A)Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion.
(B)Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters.
(C)Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements.
(D)Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
(c)(1)If the CAP Panel determines in an administrative hearing that an institution of higher education has eliminated roster slots on an athletic programs team, reduced aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminated an intercollegiate sport entirely while paying an athletics administrator or coach an annual salary of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) or more, the athletic director or equivalent representative of the institution of higher education shall be suspended from involvement in intercollegiate athletics at an institution of higher education for, at minimum, three academic years, as determined by the CAP Panel.
(2)Before a suspension may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(d)An individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not do either of the following:
(1)Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion.
(2)Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athletes selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
(e)An individual employed by an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic programs mandatory team activities.
(f)An institution of higher education shall not comply with any athletic associations or athletic conferences policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
67470.(a)(1)An institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Panel, Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Panel: Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:
(A)A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete.
(B)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes choice of athlete representation.
(C)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes representation to NIL activities.
(D)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
(2)The CAP Panel Recruiting Transparency Subpanel shall collect solicit the information described in paragraph (1) and post it information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described in paragraph (1) shall be posted on or before October 1, 2024, and regularly updated thereafter.
(b)An institution of higher education shall only use a document created by the CAP Panel Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident shall only use a document created by the CAP Panel Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed pursuant to this subdivision may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
(1)The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(2)The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(3)The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(4)The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(5)The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institutions in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panels internet website pursuant to this section.
(6)Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policys benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes.
(7)A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed.
(8)The disclosures described in subdivision (a), as determined by the CAP Panel, Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)This section does not prohibit an institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university this is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.
67471.(a)The CAP Certification Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 shall certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
(b)No later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanels certification operations, an individual or entity shall not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanels certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
(c)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
(1)Certify all of the following:
(A)College athlete agents.
(B)Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents.
(C)Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state.
(D)Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state.
(2)Revoke certifications provided pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Ensure fair fees are charged to college athletes Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
(d)(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant to subdivision (c). Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
(2)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Fees and fines collected pursuant to subdivision (d) shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(e)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall not adopt a standard pursuant to this section that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associates degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
(f)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel.
(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities.
(2)To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel shall not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
(g)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
67472.(a)On or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the National Collegiate Athletic Association NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, shall pay an annual fee to the department, Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to subdivision (b), to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(b)The CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institutions total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education. The CAP Panel shall establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of less than two million, million four hundred ninety-nine thousand, thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($2,499,999) shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(2)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between two million, million five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000) and nineteen million, million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($19,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(3)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and twenty-nine million, million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($29,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(4)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) and fifty-nine million, million nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, thousand nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($59,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(5)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of at least sixty million dollars ($60,000,000) shall each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on institutions of higher education, an institution of higher educations annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution pursuant to subdivision (b).
(2)(A)If the total amount of annual fees collected pursuant to paragraph (1) exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
(i)Institutions described in paragraphs (1) and (6) shall receive first priority.
(ii)Institutions described in paragraph (2) shall receive second priority.
(iii)Institutions described in paragraph (3) shall receive third priority.
(iv)Institutions described in paragraph (4) shall receive forth priority,
(v)Institutions described in paragraph (5) shall receive fifth priority.
(B)It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
67473.(a)An institution of higher education shall administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An institution of higher education shall require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athletes first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
(b)A program developed pursuant to this section shall include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
(1)The rights of college athletes under this chapter.
(2)State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
(c)A program developed pursuant to this section shall not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
67474.An institution of higher education shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
(a)For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source.
(b)For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics.
(c)For a college athletes family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
67475.(a)An institution of higher education and the institutions employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel shall not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under this chapter.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, retaliation shall include all of the following:
(1)A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher educations policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws.
(2)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation.
(3)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete.
(4)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athletes housing owned by the institution of higher education.
(5)A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment.
(6)Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint.
(7)Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
67476.The California Athlete Protection Fund (CAP Fund) is hereby established. The CAP Panel shall administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund shall serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except for moneys described in Section 67463. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing this chapter.
67477.The CAP Panel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
67478.This chapter does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators of this chapter from liability.
67479.The provisions of this chapter are severable. If any provision of this chapter or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
For purposes of this part: Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 67450) and this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(b)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at any institution of higher education within the meaning of subdivision (d).
(c)Graduation success rate means the percentage of student athletes who graduate from an institution of higher education within six years of initial enrollment at that institution, excluding outgoing transfers in good academic standing with athletic eligibility remaining, and including incoming transfers. The rate is to be calculated by combining the rates of the four most recent classes that are available in the exact manner as the rate is calculated under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules.
(d)Institution of higher education means any campus of the University of California or the California State University, or any four-year private university located in California, that maintains an intercollegiate athletic program.
(e)Media rights means the rights to media coverage of intercollegiate athletics included in contracts that are entered into by intercollegiate athletic conferences and television networks and that generate monetary payments to individual institutions of higher education.
(f)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(g)Student athlete means any college student who participates in an intercollegiate athletic program of an institution of higher education, and includes student athletes who participate in basketball, football, and other intercollegiate sports.
SEC. 2.Section 67452.3 of the Education Code is repealed.67452.3.An institution of higher education may establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws of the governing body of the institution and applicable rules and bylaws of any athletic association of which the institution is a member.SEC. 3.Section 67454 of the Education Code is repealed.67454.(a)An institution of higher education shall prepare a notice detailing the following rights:(1)A student athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).(2)A student athletes reporting rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).(b)The notice developed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall identify the contact information through which a student athlete may file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice, including, but not necessarily limited to, contact information for all of the following:(1)The Office for Civil Rights, as well as the appropriate Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.(2)The Office for Civil Rights Title IX enforcement office.(3)The enforcement office of the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act.(c)Every institution of higher education shall post, and keep posted in a conspicuous location in its athletic department that is frequented by student athletes where it is easily accessible and readable during campus business hours, including, but not necessarily limited to, athletic training facilities, the notice developed pursuant to subdivision (a).(d)At the beginning of every academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide to every student athlete each of the following:(1)A copy of the notice developed pursuant to subdivision (a).(2)A current copy of the National Collegiate Athletic Association Concussion Diagnosis and Management of Sports-Related Concussion Best Practices.(3)A copy of any written policies related to concussions or other sports medicine practices specific to the institution of higher education.SEC. 4.Section 67455 of the Education Code is repealed.67455.(a)An institution of higher education shall not intentionally retaliate against a student athlete for any of the following:(1)Making or filing a complaint, in good faith, about a violation of student athlete rights granted under any applicable statute, regulation, or policy.(2)Testifying or otherwise assisting in any investigation into violations of student athlete rights granted under any applicable statute, regulation, or policy.(3)Opposing any practices that the student athlete, in good faith, believes are a violation of student athlete rights granted under any applicable statute, regulation, or policy.(b)(1)For purposes of this section, retaliation includes, but is not necessarily limited to, each of the following:(A)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including scholarships and stipends.(B)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to a student athlete.(C)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to a student athlete, including the relocation of a student athlete to different housing owned by the institution of higher education.(2)For purposes of subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, of paragraph (1), retaliation does not mean an action taken, in good faith, by an institution of higher education on the basis of conduct other than that described in subdivision (a).(c)This section shall not be construed to restrict the authority of an institution of higher education to impose interim measures or, upon a finding of responsibility, permanent consequences on a student athlete who has been accused of sexual harassment or violence.SEC. 5.Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 67460) is added to Part 40.3 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:3.The College Athlete Protection Act67460.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the College Athlete Protection Act.
1.Definitions67461.As used in this chapter, unless the context requires otherwise, the following definitions apply:
(a)Affiliated medical personnel means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education. Affiliated medical personnel include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
(b)Aggregate athletic grants means the total amount of athletic grants that an institution of higher education annually reports pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(c)Athletic association means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
(d)Athletic grant means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete.
(e)Athletic program means an intercollegiate athletic program at an institution of higher education.
(f)CAP Fund means the California Athlete Protection Fund established pursuant to this chapter.
(g)CAP Panel means the California Athlete Protection Panel established pursuant to this chapter.
(h)CAP Program means the California Athlete Protection Program established pursuant to this chapter.
(i)College athlete means a student who is enrolled at an institution of higher education and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
(j)Fair market value compensation means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic teams aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic teams revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team.
(k)Institution of higher education or institution means any campus of the University of California, the California State University, the California Community Colleges, an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
(l)Intercollegiate athlete means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A students participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
(m)NIL means the use of a college athletes name, image, and likeness.
(n)Office for Civil Rights means the Office for Civil Rights within the United States Department of Education.
(o)Revenue means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education.
(p)Title IX means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.)
2.Findings67462.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, conferences, and associations and the state.
(b)Institutions of higher education exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance.
(c)To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred.
(d)The state needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death.
(e)Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety.
(f)College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athletes interests are always put first.
(g)Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decisionmaking related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences.
(h)To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes sports-related injuries.
(i)Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athletes NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements.
(j)A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes.
3.General Provisions67463.(a)An institution of higher education shall establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
(b)An institution of higher education shall use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution but does not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
(c)A college athlete on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year shall be designated an equal payment from that institutions degree completion fund for that academic year.
(d)All degree completion funds of up to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) shall be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year. Payments described in this subdivision shall be made annually no later than 60 days after the institution of higher education submits its annual report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education.
(e)An institution shall not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
(f)(1)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(2)All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university shall be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
(g)An institution of higher education shall accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution shall not undercount or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
(h)All degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) designated for a college athlete shall be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds shall be deposited in the institutions degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
(i)(1)In making annual degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this section, an institution of higher education may opt to only use all revenue for an academic year that exceeds its revenue for the previous academic year. If the institution uses this option, the institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as both of the following conditions are met:
(A)(i)All of the institutions revenue that was not categorized by gender or sport in the institutions report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for that academic year that exceeds the institutions revenue that was not categorized by gender or sport in the institutions report pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education for the previous academic year is used to make degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes and is not used for any other purpose.
(ii)Each college athlete, regardless of sport, at the institution who qualifies for a degree completion fund payment designation pursuant to this subparagraph receives an equal share of moneys calculated pursuant to this subparagraph.
(iii)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this subparagraph do not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
(B)(i)All revenue of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution for that academic year that exceeds that teams revenue for the previous academic year is used to make degree completion fund payment designations for that teams college athletes.
(ii)Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this subparagraph shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market compensation for any academic year.
(2)An institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees pursuant to this chapter before using revenue described in paragraph (1) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
(j)Degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education shall have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
(k)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution may adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institutions college athletes is not reduced.
(2)The institution is in compliance with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
(l)Degree completion fund payment designations or payments shall not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
(m)This section shall apply only to an institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
67464.(a)An institution of higher education shall distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
(1)A college athletes rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
(2)An individual notice stating: All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the Attorney General, the United States Department of Educations Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.
(3)A college athletes rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A college athletes rights under this chapter.
(5)Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
(b)The notice distributed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights regional enforcement office.
(2)The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting.
(3)The internet website address used by the United States Department of Education for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)).
(4)A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters pursuant to Section 11165.7 of the Penal Code and the obligations of these mandated reporters.
(5)The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter.
(6)The telephone number of the Attorney General.
(c)An institution of higher education shall post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institutions athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
(d)Upon the commencement of each academic year, the institution of higher education shall provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
67465.(a)The College Athlete Protection (CAP) Program is hereby established as a program in the department for purposes of this chapter.
(b)The CAP Program shall be administered by the CAP Panel.
(1)(A)The 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
(i)Eleven members appointed by the Governor.
(ii)Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(iii)Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(B)The 21-member CAP Panel shall consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
(2)CAP Panel members shall be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member shall be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panels members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
(3)The department shall hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director shall be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director shall hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter.
(4)(A)A CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panels members serve staggered terms.
(B)All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed shall be six-year terms with no term limits.
(C)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position pursuant to this subdivision.
(5)A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director shall not have served at any time as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
(6)The racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California shall be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
(7)The CAP Panel shall consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
(A)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury.
(ii)One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports.
(iii)One member with expertise in mental health.
(iv)One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations.
(v)One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations.
(vi)Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
(B)The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in contract law.
(ii)One member with expertise in college sports recruiting.
(iii)One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
(C)The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in sports agent certification.
(ii)One member with expertise in financial advising standards.
(iii)One member with expertise in marketing standards.
(iv)One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
(D)The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
(i)One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104191).
(ii)One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics.
(iii)One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations.
(iv)One member with expertise in arbitration.
(v)One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
(vi)One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
(c)The CAP Panel shall have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
(1)Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations of this chapter.
(2)Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties pursuant to this chapter.
(3)Require an institution of higher education and out-of-state college or university that is subject to this chapter to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter.
(4)(A)Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed pursuant to subdivision (d) to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate.
(B)The Attorney General shall have the authority to prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
(5)Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public.
(6)At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states.
(7)Hold quarterly meetings.
(8)Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each institution of higher education, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, pursuant to Section 9795 of the Government Code, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter.
(9)Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this chapter.
(10)Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
(d)(1)In addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations shall include a system to appeal the CAP Panels rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
(A)Training to help prevent future violations.
(B)Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(C)Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel.
(2)The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
(A)The number and duration of violations.
(B)Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action.
(C)The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
67466.(a)An institution of higher education shall meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall do all of the following:
(1)Consult with athletic associations, the University of California, the California State University, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community.
(2)Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers Association.
(3)Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
(b)(1)All reports of suspected health and safety violations at an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, shall be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice shall forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director established pursuant to Section 67465 once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section.
(2)Within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanels health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to subdivision (a), an institution of higher education shall comply with all of the following:
(A)Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards.
(B)Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director.
(C)Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.
(c)The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel shall have all of the following duties and powers:
(1)Require transparency from institutions of higher education on injury treatment options for college athletes.
(2)Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks.
(3)Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athletes participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request.
(4)Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities under this section.
(5)Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes.
(6)Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary.
(7)Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program.
(8)Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance with this section.
(9)Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned pursuant to subdivision (e) from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education.
(10)Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
(d)All athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, shall report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
(e)(1)An individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
(A)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(B)Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section.
(C)Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(D)Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(f)(1)Any individual or entity designated by an institution of higher education to investigate allegations of a violation of this section that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel.
(2)Before a penalty may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual or entity shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(g)Except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel shall have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel shall not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
(h)Affiliated medical personnel shall be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher educations office or department that is independent of the institutions athletic department.
67467.(a)(1)An institution of higher education that reports twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state higher education institution and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(b)(1)An institution of higher education that reports fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) or more in annual revenue to the United States Department of Education shall comply with both of the following:
(A)Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance shall be paid for by the institution. The institution shall not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance.
(B)Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
(2)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution.
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a college athletes medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athletes intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(c)If a college athlete at an institution of higher education that is responsible for the college athletes medical expenses pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) chooses to receive medical care that is not provided pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b) or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution shall offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
(1)The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care.
(2)The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
(d)(1)An institution of higher education shall pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not withhold a college athletes medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1), or otherwise impede a college athletes right to obtain an independent second opinion pursuant to paragraph (1).
(e)(1)No later than three days after the end of a college athletes teams season in the final year of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institutions receipt of a college athletes notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education shall provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
(2)Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel shall not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)A former college athlete shall be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination pursuant to paragraph (1).
67468.(a)On or before July 1 of each year, an institution shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation shall include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
(A)Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institutions male and female college athletes.
(B)Whether the institutions male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities.
(C)Whether the interests and abilities of the institutions male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation pursuant to this subparagraph shall include measures of the institutions performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979.
(D)The institutions determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
(2)Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
(b)At the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), the institution shall include the following statement: To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact(contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institutions Title IX coordinator.
(c)(1)An individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with this section, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation published pursuant to subdivision (a), shall be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
(2)Before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), an individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
67469.(a)(1)An institution of higher education with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association Division 1 sport on or after January 1, 2022, or becomes a member of a National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I sport thereafter, and that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant shall provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant shall be provided regardless of the college athletes lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
(2)The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year shall be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
(b)(1)A college athlete who transfers to an institution of higher education shall receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to subdivision (a) for up to one academic year beyond the college athletes remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first.
(2)Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the institution of higher educations leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, subdivision (a) shall only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year.
(3)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory.
(4)Subdivision (a) shall not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
(A)Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion.
(B)Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters.
(C)Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements.
(D)Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
(c)(1)If the CAP Panel determines in an administrative hearing that an institution of higher education has eliminated roster slots on an athletic programs team, reduced aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminated an intercollegiate sport entirely while paying an athletics administrator or coach an annual salary of five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) or more, the athletic director or equivalent representative of the institution of higher education shall be suspended from involvement in intercollegiate athletics at an institution of higher education for, at minimum, three academic years, as determined by the CAP Panel.
(2)Before a suspension may be imposed pursuant to paragraph (1), the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation described in paragraph (1).
(d)An individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not do either of the following:
(1)Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion.
(2)Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athletes selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
(e)An individual employed by an athletic program at an institution of higher education shall not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic programs mandatory team activities.
(f)An institution of higher education shall not comply with any athletic associations or athletic conferences policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
67470.(a)(1)An institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Panel, all of the following information to the CAP Panel:
(A)A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete.
(B)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes choice of athlete representation.
(C)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athletes, college athletes, or intercollegiate athletes representation to NIL activities.
(D)Whether or not the institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
(2)The CAP Panel shall collect the information described in paragraph (1) and post it on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes.
(b)An institution of higher education shall only use a document created by the CAP Panel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident shall only use a document created by the CAP Panel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed pursuant to this subdivision shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
(1)The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(2)The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(3)The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(4)The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
(5)The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athletes intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institutions in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panels internet website pursuant to this section.
(6)Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policys benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes.
(7)A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed.
(8)The disclosures described in subdivision (a), as determined by the CAP Panel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)This section does not prohibit an institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university this is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.
67471.(a)The CAP Certification Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 shall certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
(b)No later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanels certification operations, an individual or entity shall not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanels certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
(c)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
(1)Certify all of the following:
(A)College athlete agents.
(B)Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents.
(C)Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state.
(D)Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This subparagraph does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state.
(2)Revoke certifications provided pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Ensure fair fees are charged to college athletes for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
(d)(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant to subdivision (c). Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
(2)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)Fees and fines collected pursuant to subdivision (d) shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(e)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall not adopt a standard pursuant to this section that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associates degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
(f)Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel.
(1)The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities.
(2)To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel shall not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
(g)The CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
67472.(a)On or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the National Collegiate Athletic Association on or after January 1, 2022, shall pay an annual fee to the department, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to subdivision (b), to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund established pursuant to Section 67476.
(b)The CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institutions total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act to the United States Department of Education. The CAP Panel shall establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of less than two million, four hundred ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($2,499,999) shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
(2)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between two million, five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000) and nineteen million, nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($19,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(3)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and twenty-nine million, nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($29,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(4)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue between thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) and fifty-nine million, nine hundred ninety-nine thousand, nine hundred ninety-nine dollars ($59,999,999), inclusive, shall each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(5)Institutions of higher education with athletic revenue of at least sixty million dollars ($60,000,000) shall each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) to (5), inclusive, two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one hundred dollars ($100).
67473.(a)An institution of higher education shall administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An institution of higher education shall require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athletes first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
(b)A program developed pursuant to this section shall include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
(1)The rights of college athletes under this chapter.
(2)State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
(c)A program developed pursuant to this section shall not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
67474.An institution of higher education shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
(a)For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source.
(b)For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics.
(c)For a college athletes family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
67475.(a)An institution of higher education and the institutions employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel shall not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athletes rights under this chapter.
(b)For purposes of this chapter, retaliation shall include all of the following:
(1)A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher educations policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws.
(2)A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation.
(3)A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete.
(4)A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athletes housing owned by the institution of higher education.
(5)A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment.
(6)Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint.
(7)Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
67476.The California Athlete Protection Fund (CAP Fund) is hereby established. The CAP Panel shall administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund shall serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except for moneys described in Section 67463. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel established pursuant to Section 67465 for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing this chapter.
67477.The CAP Panel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
67478.This chapter does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators of this chapter from liability.
67479.The provisions of this chapter are severable. If any provision of this chapter or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 26, 2024 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 30, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jul 5, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 19, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 42. Noes 15. Page 2131.) |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 3.) (May 18). |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 7, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Mar 6, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HIGHER ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 2, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Jan 20, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 19. |
| Jan 19, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 1, 2023 | AB 252 Holden Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Academic Senate of the California State University | ** Against | |
| Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities | ** Against | |
| Big Sky Conference | ** Against | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Support | |
| California State University | ** Against | |
| California State University, Office Of The Chancellor | ** Against | |
| College Swimming & Diving Coaches Association of America | ** Against | |
| Community College League of California | ** Against | |
| National College Players Association | ** Support | |
| Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | ** Against | |
| Stanford Student-Athlete Advisory Committee | ** Support | |
| Stanford University | ** Against | |
| Team USA Athletes' Commission | ** Against | |
| United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee | ** Against | |
| United Steelworkers District 12 | ** Support | |
| University of California | ** Against | |
| University of Southern California | ** Against | |
| USA Artistic Swimming | ** Against | |
| Usa Swimming | ** Against | |
| USA Swimming Athletes’ Advisory Council | ** Against | |
| USA Track & Field | ** Against | |
| USA Volleyball | ** Against | |
| USA Water Polo | ** Against | |
| USA Wrestling | ** Against | |
| U.S. Ski & Snowboard | ** Against | |
| Women's Sports Foundation | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 26, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: .
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Judiciary. A “do pass” motion should include a referral to the Committee on Judiciary.
SUMMARY
Establishes the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act and program for the purpose of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes.
BACKGROUND
Existing Law:
- Any coeducational Institution of Higher Education (IHE) that participates in Title IV, the federal student aid program, and has an intercollegiate athletics program, must comply with the Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act (EADA) by preparing an annual report, officially called The Report on Athletic Program Participation Rates and Financial Support Data. (34 Code of Federal Regulation (CFR) § 668.47)
- A postsecondary educational institution shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a student of that institution participating in intercollegiate athletics from earning compensation due to the use of the student’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation. Earning a reward for using a student’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation shall not affect the student’s scholarship eligibility. (Education Code (EC) § 67456(a))
- A postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics shall not provide a prospective student-athlete with compensation in relation to the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation. (EC § 67456(b))
- A postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics shall not prevent a California student participating in intercollegiate athletics from obtaining professional representation in relation to contracts or legal matters, including, but not limited to, representation provided by athlete agents or legal representation provided by attorneys. (EC § 67456(c))
- A scholarship from the postsecondary educational institution in which a student is enrolled that provides the student with the cost of attendance at that institution is not compensation for purposes of this section, and a scholarship shall not be revoked as a result of earning compensation or obtaining legal representation pursuant to this section. (EC § 67456(d))
- A student-athlete shall not enter into a contract providing compensation to the athlete for the use of the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation if a provision of the contract is in conflict with a provision of the athlete’s team contract. A student-athlete who enters into a contract providing compensation to the athlete for the use of the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation shall disclose the contract to an official of the institution to be designated by the institution. An institution asserting a conflict shall disclose to the athlete or the athlete’s legal representation the relevant contractual provisions that are in conflict. (EC § 67456 (e))
- Requires an athletic program that does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student-athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the IHE’s medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, to provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the student-athlete, will be provided for a total of up to five academic years or until the student-athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter. (EC § 67452 (a)(1))
- Requires each athletic program to conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all its first-year and third-year student-athletes at the beginning of the academic year. (EC § 67452 (a)(2))
- Requires an IHE to grant a student-athlete the same rights as other students concerning any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid. (EC § 67452 (a)(3))
- Requires an athletic program to respond within seven business days with an answer to a student athlete’s written request to transfer to another IHE. (EC § 67452 (a)(4))
ANALYSIS
This bill:
Establishes the CAP Program within the Office of Planning and Research
- Establishes the CAP Program in the Office of Planning and Research and requires the program to be administered by the CAP Panel Program director, hired by the Office of Planning and Research as specified in 5) to implement the rules and regulations, standards, and policies adopted by the CAP panel board members.
- Establishes the CAP Panel board and specifies the 13 members to be appointed to the board in the following manner:
- Seven members appointed by the Governor;
- Three members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly; and,
- Three members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Specifies that out of the 13-members, at least two members must be former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
- Specifies that CAP Panel board members are voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director and that one member, appointed by a majority vote, must serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
- Requires the Office of Planning and Research to hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. Specifies the CAP Program director is a full-time position that must serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. Allows the CAP Program director will hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this Act. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, will initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024. Additionally:
- The CAP Program director will provide CAP panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties under the Act;
- The CAP Panel will consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program’s regulations, standards, and policies under the Act;
- The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections under this Act; and,
- Requires the CAP Panel board members, at the discretion of the CAP Program director and consistent with the requirements of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, to conduct meetings, solicit information, and conduct its other duties and powers virtually, and use other methods to minimize costs of the CAP Program.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel board member on the initial 13 member board to serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. Additionally:
- It is the intent of the Legislature that the 13 member CAP Panel board members serve staggered terms;
- All subsequent appointments made after the initial 13 member CAP Panel board is appointed will be six-year terms with no term limits; and,
- A CAP Panel board member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position as specified.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel board member and the CAP Program director must not have served, within five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel board member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an IHE, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association, but requires two of the 13 CAP panel board members to be from a IHE, but not from the same IHE.
- Requires the racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California to be considered by the appointing authority, as specified in 2), when appointing CAP Panel board members.
- Requires the appointed CAP Panel board members to have the following consistency, while maintaining that at least two of the CAP Panel board members are former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy, and allows CAP Panel board members to have overlapping areas of expertise:
- One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury;
- One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports;
- One member with expertise in in mental health;
- One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations;
- One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations;
- One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations;
- Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues;
- One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104–191);
- One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics;
- One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations;
- One member with expertise in adjudicating complaints alleging violations of the law;
- One member with expertise in arbitration; and,
- One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes.
- Requires the CAP Panel program director, in accordance with the regulations, standards, and policies adopted by the CAP Panel, to have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
- Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations, as specified;
- If approved by the CAP Program general counsel, issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties;
- Require an IHE and out-of-state college or university that are subject to the provision of the Act to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this Act;
- Refer individuals, IHEs, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this Act and, who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed as specified, to the a district attorney for prosecution, and allows a district attorney to prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate;
- Distribute, on or before January 15, 2026, on an annual basis, a report to each IHE, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature on the state of college athlete protections adopted under this Act;
- Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve this Act; and,
- Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this Act.
- Requires the CAP Panel to have all of the following duties and powers:
- Adopt regulations, standards, and policies for the implementation and enforcement of this Act;
- Determine, the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public;
- At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states; and,
- Hold quarterly meetings.
- Specifies that, in addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this Act may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations include a system to appeal the CAP Panel’s rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
- Training to help prevent future violations;
- Issuance of citations;
- Requiring the IHE to notify its college athletes, prospective college athletes, and the public about citations issued due to violations committed by its employees, volunteers, or affiliated medical personnel;
- Issuance of monetary fines and other remedies; and,
- Bringing a violation against an individual to an administrative law judge for adjudication.
- Specifies an administrative law judge who rules that an individual has committed a violation of this Act, may uphold CAP Program penalties and remedies or impose alternative penalties and remedies, including, but not limited to, requiring the institution to notify its college athletes, its prospective college athletes, and the public of the violation, including any penalties and remedies imposed due to the violation. And that an administrative law judge may suspend or permanently ban an individual from participating in intercollegiate athletics at any IHE if the administrative law judge finds any of the following:
- That the individual’s violation of this Act caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death;
- That the individual knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in the investigation of a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death in violation of this Act;
- That the individual threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported a violation of this Act that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death; and,
- That the individual failed to adequately respond to a complaint that would have prevented a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
- Requires the CAP Program, before imposing a penalty or remedy on an individual described in 13) be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation of this Act.
- Requires the CAP Panel to consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this Act:
- The number and duration of violations;
- Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action; and,
- The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
CAP Panel Fees For California Community Colleges, IHEs, and PEIs
- Requires, on or before January 15, 2025, and annually thereafter, each IHE to pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel, as specified in 17) to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed six million dollars ($6,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund as specified.
- Requires that the CAP Panel to base the annual fees on each institution’s total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal EADA to the United States Department of Education (USDE). The CAP Panel must establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined as specified:
- IHEs with athletic revenue of less than $2,499,999 shall each pay an annual fee of up to $100;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $2,500,000 and $19,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $20,000,000 and $29,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $30,000,000 and $59,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue of at least $60,000,000 will each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year; and,
- Two-year IHEs shall each pay an annual fee of up to one $100.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding 16) and 17) above, for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on IHEs, an IHE’s annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution. Additionally, if the total amount of annual fees collected exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to $6,000,000, the CAP program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by IHEs pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($6,000,000), is returned in the following order:
- Institutions described in 17a) and 17f) shall receive first priority;
- Institutions described in 17b) shall receive second priority;
- Institutions described in 17c) shall receive third priority;
- Institutions described in 17d) shall receive fourth priority; and,
- Institutions described in 17e) shall receive fifth priority.
- States it is intent of the Legislature that the CAP program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
Health and Safety Standards Developed and Established By the CAP Panel
- Requires an IHE to meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Panel. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Panel must do all of the following:
- Consult with athletic associations, the UC, the CSU, the CCC, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community;
- Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers’ Association; and,
- Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
- Specifies that all reports of suspected health and safety violations at an IHE that occur on or after January 1, 2024, but before the CAP Panel adopts health and safety standard, will be submitted to the CAP Program director once the CAP Panel commences enforcing the health and safety standards.
- Requires, within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Panel’s health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to 21) above, an IHE to comply with all of the following:
- Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards;
- Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice and, once the CAP Panel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP program director.
- Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Panel and submit to the CAP Panel the point of contact’s email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Panel, the institution’s athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
- Allows the CAP Panel to require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Panel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
- Requires the CAP Panel to have all of the following:
- Require transparency from IHEs on injury treatment options for college athletes;
- Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks;
- Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athlete’s participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request;
- Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities as specified;
- Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes;
- Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary;
- Require assistance from IHE to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program;
- Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance as specified;
- Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned as specified from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education; and,
- Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this Act.
- Requires all athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel to report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
- Provides that, except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel will have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel must not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
- Requires that affiliated medical personnel will be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an IHE’s office or department that is independent of the institution’s athletic department.
Adds Specificity to Title IX Posting in Frequented Areas by Student Athletes
- Requires a IHE to distribute a notice to each college athlete with all of the following information:
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.);
- An individual notice stating: “All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the United States Department of Justice, the USDE Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)’s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)’s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.”;
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f));
- A college athlete’s rights, as specified; and,
- Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
- Requires the notice distributed pursuant to 28) above to contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information must include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
- The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights’ regional enforcement office;
- The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights’ online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting;
- The internet website address used by the USDE for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act, as specified;
- A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters, as specified, and the obligations of these mandated reporters;
- The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter; and,
- The telephone number of the United States Department of Justice.
- Requires an IHE to post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institution’s athletic training facilities, the notice distributed.
- Requires that, upon the commencement of each academic year, the IHE will provide each college athlete a copy of the notice.
Title IX Compliance Evaluation
- Requires that, on or before July 1 of each year, an IHE must comply with both of the following:
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institution’s male and female college athletes;
- Whether the institution’s male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities;
- Whether the interests and abilities of the institution’s male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation as specified will include measures of the institution’s performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979; and,
- The institution’s determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
- Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Requires that, at the beginning of the evaluation, pursuant to 32) above, the institution shall include the following statement: “To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact” (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator.
Medical Coverage For Post Athletic Careers
- Requires an IHE that reports $20,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE to be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 34) above does not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another IHE or out-of-state higher education institution and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 34) above does not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Requires an IHE that reports $50,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE to comply with both of the following:
- Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance will be paid for by the institution. The institution must not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance; and,
- Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 35) above does not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another IHE or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 35) above does not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Establishes that, if a college athlete at an IHE that is responsible for the college athlete’s medical expenses, as specified in i) and ii) above, chooses to receive medical care that is not provided as specified or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution will offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
- The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care; and,
- The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
- Requires an IHE to pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete and prohibits IHE personnel and affiliated medical personnel from withhold a college athlete’s medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion, or otherwise impede a college athlete’s right to obtain an independent second opinion.
- Requires that, no later than three days after the end of a college athlete’s team season in the final year of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institution’s receipt of a college athlete’s notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an IHE must provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
- Prohibits a IHE education personnel and affiliated medical personnel from discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination; and requires that a former college athlete is provided with no less than 60 days to complete an injury.
Financial Literacy and Life Skills Workshops
- Requires an IHE to administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An IHE will require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athlete’s first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
- Specifies that a program developed pursuant to this section will include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
- The rights of college athletes, as specified;
- State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information;
- Information about the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act; and,
- Information about the importance of job experience in the job market, how to write a résumé, and strategies and skills regarding employment interviews.
- Prohibits a service, when an IHE offers the information described in 40) above, from any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
Requires Sports Agents To Distribute Information Under the Miller-Ayala Act
- Requires an athlete agent to provide any current or prospective college athlete that the agent seeks to represent and the college athlete’s legal guardian or guardians, if applicable, a completed copy of the athlete agent disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act and allows any college athlete who enters into an agreement with an athlete agent who does not provide information about themselves, as specified in the disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act, to not comply with the agreement, and have all remedies available under the law.
Prohibits an IHE from Upholding Any Rule Related to Benefits
- An IHE will not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
- For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source;
- For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics; and,
- For a college athlete’s family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
Prohibits an IHE’s Employees from Retaliating against Student-Athletes
- Requires that an IHE and the institution’s employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete’s rights as specified.
- For purposes of this Act, “retaliation” includes all of the following:
- A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher education’s policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws;
- A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation;
- A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete;
- A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athlete’s housing owned by IHE;
- A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment;
- Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint; and,
- Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
Prohibits the Elimination of Sports Programs and Decrease in Funding
- Requires an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2024, that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant to provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant must be provided regardless of the college athlete’s lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. Further, the amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year will be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
- Specifies that a college athlete who transfers to an IHE will receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to 47) above for up to one academic year beyond the college athlete’s remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. Additionally:
- Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the IHE’s leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, 47) above will only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year;
- Specifies 47) above will not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory; and,
- Specifies 47) above will not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
- Is found by the IHE to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion;
- Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters;
- Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements; or,
- Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
- Specifies in 47) and 48) above will only applies to an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sports on or after January 1, 2024.
- Specifies that an individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an IHE will not do either of the following:
- Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion; and,
- Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athlete’s selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
- Requires an individual employed by an athletic program at an IHE to not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic program’s mandatory team activities.
- Specifies that an IHE must not comply with any athletic association’s or athletic conference’s policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
- Prohibits an IHE, with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2024, from reducing the amount of aggregate funds in an academic year below the amount of aggregate funds used in the 2022–23 academic year, for academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, nutritional, diversity, equity, and inclusion support for college athletes, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2022–23 academic year, but allows a IHE to reduce the amount of aggregate funds in an academic year below the amount of aggregate funds used in the 2022–23 academic year for college athlete medical, mental health, or athletic training care if this care is not medically necessary.
- Allows a IHE to reduce any discretionary grand total revenue during the academic year below the discretionary grand total revenue reported for the 2022–23 academic year and reduce the amount of aggregate funds in an academic year below the amount of aggregate funds used in the 2022–23 academic year, for academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, nutritional, diversity, equity, and inclusion support for college athletes, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2022–23 if the IHE s unable to generate, for an academic year, all revenue in an amount that meets or exceeds all revenue reported for the 2022–23 academic year due to war, civil unrest, or fire, flood, or other unforeseen disaster or cause beyond the institution’s control as determined by the CAP Panel.
General Provisions
- Establishes the CAP Fund. The CAP Panel will administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund will serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except as specified. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing these provisions.
- Authorizes the CAP Panel to promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
- Specifies that the Act does not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators from liability.
- Declares that the provisions of the Act are severable. If any provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
- Makes findings and declarations related to increasing protections for college athletes.
Definitions
- “Affiliated medical personnel” means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an IHE. “Affiliated medical personnel” include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel.
- “Aggregate athletic grants” means the total amount of athletic grants that an IHE annually reports pursuant to the federal EADA to the USDE for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. “Aggregate athletic grants” shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institution’s instate or out-of-state college athletes.
- “Athletic association” means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs.
- “Athletic grant” means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete to cover a portion or all of the institution’s cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1087ll). An athletic grant shall not exceed the institution’s cost of attendance.
- “Athletic program” means an intercollegiate athletic program at an IHE.
- “CAP Fund” means the Fund established as specified.
- “CAP Panel” means the Panel established as specified.
- “CAP Program” means the Program established as specified.
- “College athlete” means a student who is enrolled at an IHE and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete.
- “Grand total revenue” means all revenue that is calculated and reported as “grand total revenue” pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act established pursuant to Section 485 of the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092) by an institution of higher education to the United States Department of Education.
- “IHE” or “institution” means any campus of the University of California (UC), the California State University (CSU), the California Community Colleges (CCC), an independent IHE, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program.
- “Intercollegiate athlete” means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete.
- “NCAA” means the National Collegiate Athletic Association.
- “NIL” means the use of a college athlete’s name, image, and likeness.
- “Office for Civil Rights” means the Office for Civil Rights within the USDE.
- “Revenue” means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal EADA by an IHE to the USDE “Revenue” includes intercollegiate athletics revenue paid directly by an intercollegiate athletic conference, an athletic association, or a source designated by an IHE, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association to cover any athletic program expense or to compensate a college athlete for participating in intercollegiate athletics at the institution.
- “Title IX” means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.).
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “There is a tremendous need for AB 252 because California’s college athletes are governed by athletic associations that do not enforce health and safety standards to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death; and impose rules that have violated antitrust laws and have caused athletes economic harm. College athletes’ athletic time demands result in unacceptably low federal graduation rates among Black college athletes that produce the most athletic revenue, there is a lack of transparency and accountability regarding important athletic program policies for college athletes and recruits, and there is a need to ensure that athletic agents provide any current or prospective college athlete that the agent seeks to represent and the college athlete’s legal guardian or guardians, if applicable, a completed copy of the athlete agent disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State to help prevent college athletes from bad actors.
“College athletes are often put in harm's way as the institutions they represent prioritize winning over athlete safety. Coaches are incentivized to secure victories as it can lead to job stability and salary increments, while athletic trainers are often driven by the fear of being fired if they raise concerns that could potentially impact the team's performance. This misplaced emphasis on winning over athlete well-being is a concerning trend that requires immediate attention and resolution. It is an ongoing hazard to allow universities to police the treatment of their athletes when the universities’ negligence and mistreatment are primary forces in harming the well-being of so many athletes.”
- House v. NCAA – Athletes May Be Paid Directly By IHEs Soon.
On May 23, 2024, the NCAA agreed to a court settlement that could have the effect of further expanding athletes' rights to monetize their NIL. The settlement in House v. NCAA would end the prohibition against colleges directly compensating their athletes, including for the use of their NIL. As part of the settlement, the NCAA also agreed to pay nearly $2.8 billion to current and former athletes who lost out on opportunities to capitalize on their NIL as a result of the old rules.
As a result, the author on May 30, 2024, removed provisions of the bill related to revenue sharing. What remains of the bill are provisions related to the establishment of the CAP panel, its health and safety standards, and its fees, in addition to various protections and benefits to student athletes.
- The Equity In Athletics Disclosure Act. The EADA (34 CFR § 668.4) requires IHEs to disclose information about their varsity teams and the financial resources and personnel the school dedicates to those teams. The EADA Report must be published by October 15 each year and made available upon request to students, prospective students, and the public.
Revenues: The October 15th report requires separate revenues for Football, Men’s Basketball, Women’s Basketball, All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball, All Women’s teams except Basketball, and all sports combined. Revenues for All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball and All Women’s teams except Basketball are not collected web-based data collection.
“Revenues” as defined in EADA are revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities. This includes revenues from appearance guarantees and options, an athletic conference, tournament or bowl games, concessions, contributions from alumni and others, institutional support, program advertising and sales, radio and television, royalties, signage and other sponsorships, sports camps, state or other government support, student activity fees, ticket and luxury box sales, and any other revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities.
“Grand Total Revenue” as defined in EADA are a combination of “Total Revenues by Team” (The Total Revenues for Men’s teams, the Total Revenues for Women’s teams and the Total Revenues for Coed teams) and “Not Allocated Revenues” (Amount entered into the Not Allocated by Gender/Sport field).
NOTE: The graphic above represents the California State University, Sacramento’s revenue and expenses as provided in their 2022-23 EADA report.
Is EADA Accurate?
While the EADA provides a snapshot of an IHE’s expenses and revenue, this information is not disaggregated into individual line items and, therefore difficult to differentiate between the revenue generated from the athletic conferences, tournament or bowl games, concessions, and ticket sales, from others, such as alumni contributions, student activity fees, and state or other government support. Moreover, the report does not separately demonstrate revenue generated in other sports, such as track and field, soccer, tennis, etc. Sports other than basketball and football are located under “Total Revenue of all Sports, Except Football and Basketball, combined.”
Further, per EADA’s guidelines, “Grand Total Revenues must be equal to or greater than your Grand Total Expenses.” This means that an IHE can only be shown as being cost-neutral or revenue generate, even if the IHE did not generate revenue. This can be shown in the graphic above.
It should be noted that athletic departments finance their programs using a variety of different revenue sources. Student fees or institutional subsidies (from tuition, state appropriations, endowments, or other revenue-generating activities on campus) often support even the most extensive NCAA Division I college sports programs. A 2013 study published by the Delta Project at the American Research Institute found that only Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) teams (I.e., Rose Bowl, Sugar Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, etc.) generate more revenue than expenses incurred. The study, Academic Spending Versus Athletic Spending: Who Wins?, finds that “even among the largest FBS programs, student fees and institutional subsidies typically provided between 4 percent and 14 percent of total athletic revenues.” The study concluded that in 2010, “more than 80 percent of the budget at the typical FBS colleges came from “generated” revenues, such as ticket sales, conference payouts, and donations. In contrast, more than 70 percent of athletic budgets in the smaller FCS and DI-NF programs came from revenues “allocated” by the university; this athletic subsidy includes money from student fees, institutional support, and government appropriations.”
This bill would use “grand total revenue” as defined by use an IHE’s EADA report, to determine what fees are paid to the CAP Panel and determine how long an IHE is required to cover a student athletes out of pocket medical expenses. The Committee may consider whether the data in a IHE’s EADA is sufficient to determine an IHE’s athletic department’s revenue considering that revenue includes 1) alumni contributions, student activity fees, and state or other government support; 2) does not outline revenue made by other sports other than basketball and football; and 3) cannot show if an IHE’s athletic department absorbed cost. Should “grand total revenue” be redefined to more accurately capture earned revenue or be based on other sources of funding earned by an athletic department?
- Bolstering Or Making It Difficult To Comply With Title IX?
Title IX is a Federal civil rights law. It prohibits schools that receive Federal funding from discriminating based on sex in their programs or activities. The Department’s Title IX regulations include requirements for how schools must comply with Title IX, including in their athletic programs.
Three-pronged Test.
The Title IX regulations require schools to provide equal opportunity based on sex. This requirement applies to schools’ athletic programs, including club, intramural, and intercollegiate teams. Equal opportunity in college and university athletic programs is measured by the three-pronged test, in which a schools can demonstrate compliance by showing any one of three criteria:
- Test One – proportionality; provide intercollegiate or interscholastic participation opportunities for women and men at rates that are proportionate to their respective rates of enrollment; or
- Test Two – continued program expansion for the underrepresented sex; show that opportunities have been added for the underrepresented sex (nearly always girls and women) as their interests and abilities have developed and evolved; or
- Test Three – full accommodation of the underrepresented sex; fully accommodate the underrepresented sex by offering every team for which there is sufficient interest and ability for a viable team, and sufficient competition in the geographic areas where the institution normally competes.
Does The Inability to Manage Rosters Make It Difficult To Use Test One?
At the collegiate level, meeting test one means that participation opportunities are proportionate to the full-time undergraduate enrollment. if women are 52 percent of the full-time undergraduate students, then 52 percent of the intercollegiate athletics participants should be women. This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, in addition to reducing any aggregate funds for any college athlete’s academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminating any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2022–23 academic year.
This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating roster slots that existed during the 2022- 23 academic year. The Committee may wish to consider if more flexibility should be built-in to allow IHE to have the option to comply with test one.
Does The Inability to Eliminate Programs Discourage Expansion (Test Two)?
Test two applies only if students of one sex are underrepresented. An IHE can meet test two by showing that it has added opportunities for women as their interests in different sports develop. This can mean either adding a women’s team or teams or adding opportunities on existing teams.
This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2022–23 academic year. As new sports, emerge popularity and participation sway, it may be difficult for an IHE to establish a new sport while managing existing sports that has lost interest but must maintain as required by this bill. The Committee may wish to consider whether it is more appropriate to eliminate a sport, only if the IHE has plans to adopt a new sport.
- CAP Panel: New Body with Broad Regulatory and Fee Authority. As established by this bill, the CAP Panel, located within the Office of Planning and Research, would include a 13-member panel (7 members appointed by the Governor and 3 members appointed by the Senate and Assembly each) to develop health and safety standards in addition to enforcing the various provision established by this bill.
Health and Safety Standards
This bill empowers the CAP Panel to develop and enforce health and safety standards it develop. Further, this bill specifies the course of action in the event a community college or IHE violates it rules.
According to the 2023-24 manuals across Division I, II, and III, all members of the NCAA must, among other items specified in each manual “Establish an administrative structure that provides independent medical care for student-athletes, affirms the autonomous authority of primary athletics health care providers and implements NCAA guidance, rules and policies based on consensus of the medical, scientific, sports medicine, and sport governing communities. The physicians and health care staff at each member institution have the ultimate decision-making authority over the health and welfare of student-athletes. Consistent with the member institutions’ primary obligation with respect to student-athlete health and safety, member institutions will make NCAA guidance, rules and policies available to student-athletes. Member institutions shall be responsible for the oversight and administration of coach, administrator and staff education on relevant student-athlete physical and mental health topics, prevailing consensus for engaging student-athletes about physical and mental health, how to most effectively support student-athlete physical and mental health, and appropriate resources on campus or in the local community. Member institutions are responsible for regulating practice schedules, taking into consideration the health of student athletes and their academic success.”
The manual (a more than 400 page document for Division I schools, 300 page document for Division II schools, and more than 200 page document for Division III schools) outlines the various rules and regulations in which member schools, athletic staff and trainers, and member schools teams’ must comply with to maintain active status or avoid penalties.
The author may wish consider ways in which the intended goal to ensure health and safety measures for student athletes can be met within the existing structure that IHEs must operate under.
Various Protections and Benefits Enforced By the CAP Panel Program
Title IX Posting and Evaluation
This bill requires CCC and IHE to provide a notice detailing the student athlete’s rights under Title IX, the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f)), and the contact information of The Office for Civil Rights, The Office for Civil Rights Title IX enforcement office, and the enforcement office of the USDE for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act. This bill also requires and IHE Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations.
It should be noted that a similar notice already existing in EC 67454. Further, this year several Title IX bills have bene introduced to ensure compliance with Title IX.
Financial Literacy and Life Skills
This bill requires an IHE to administer a financial and life skills development workshop program and to include certain information regarding, but not limited The rights of college athletes, state and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information, Information about the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act, and information about the importance of job experience in the job market, how to write a résumé, and strategies and skills regarding employment interviews.
It should be noted that similar provisions already exist in EC 67452 (a)(2) for Division I and II student athletes, but this bill adds specific topics to be covered.
IHE Employee Retaliation
This bill prohibits IHE and the institution’s employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel from retaliating and from retailing against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete’s rights as specified.
It should be noted that similar provisions already exist in EC 67455(a)(2), but this bill includes additional prohibitions.
Coverage of Out-Of-Pocket Medical Expenses
This bill requires a IHE that reports $20,000,000 or more in annual grand total revenue to the USDE to be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete or be responsible for covering the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete if the IHE reports $50,000,000 or more in annual grand total revenue.
It should be noted that beginning August 2024, all Division I school must provide former college athletes medical coverage for athletically related injuries for at least two years after graduation. This bill creates another class for medical coverage based on grand total revenue.
Distribution of Information About the Miller-Ayala Act
This bill requires an athlete agent to provide any current or prospective college athlete that the agent seeks to represent and the college athlete’s legal guardian or guardians, if applicable, a completed copy of the athlete agent disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act and allows any college athlete who enters into an agreement with an athlete agent who does not provide information about themselves, as specified in the disclosure statement that the agent submitted to the Secretary of State pursuant to the Miller-Ayala Athlete Agents Act, to not comply with the agreement, and have all remedies available under the law.
Expands Protections of Benefits to Student Athletes
This bill prohibits an IHE will not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty related to 1) food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source; 2) receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics; and 3) a college athlete’s family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
It should be noted that a similar protection exist in statute, but is limited to Name, Image, and Likeness.
- New Benefits For Students Athletes Coming in August 2024
In April of 2023, the NCAA Board of Directors unanimously adopted new rules for all Division I schools that will require increased support for college athletes. The benefits, often referred to as the “holistic student-athlete benefits model,” were supported by the Division I Council earlier this month and were originally recommended by the Transformation Committee in January. All Division I members who do not do so already will be required to do the following:
- Provide medical coverage for athletically related injuries for at least two years after graduation;
- Cover out-of-pocket medical expenses (copayments, deductibles, etc.) during a student-athlete's playing career;
- Attest that they provide mental health services and support consistent with the NCAA's mental health best practices;
- Attest that they follow concussion management protocols in line with the NCAA Concussion Safety Protocol Checklist;
- Offer degree completion funds for up to 10 years after a college athlete's eligibility concludes, if that college athlete was previously on full scholarship or received financial aid in a head count sport;
- Provide the same scholarship protections already required of autonomy conferences; and,
- Attest that they provide academic support services in line with NCAA rules.
- Attest that they provide career counseling for current and former college athletes and life skills development across a range of topics, including at a minimum:
- Mental health.
- Strength and conditioning.
- Nutrition.
- Name, image, and likeness opportunities.
- Financial literacy.
- Career preparation.
- Transfer requirements
- Diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging.
- Sexual violence prevention.
The requirements take effect August 2024. Schools can begin offering these benefits at any time prior to August 2024.
- Argument in Support. According to the National College Players Association, “Currently, it is not against NCAA rules to return an athlete with a concussion to the same game, sexually abuse an athlete, or kill an athlete in a hazardous workout. These scenarios have happened among California colleges. The mistreatment of college athletes is not rare, it is rampant.
- The National Athletic Trainers Association’s 2019 survey revealed the following:
- Approximately 59% of responding trainers reported being pressured by a coach or non-medical administrator to make a medical decision that is not in the best interest of their college athletes.
- Approximately 19% of coaches return athletes to play who are deemed medically ineligible.
- An NCAA survey found that 50% of athletic trainers return players with concussions to the same game.
In addition, Black men’s basketball players, women’s basketball players, and FBS football players have unacceptably low graduation rates – 42.6%, 62.7%, and 63.9%, respectively. Chronically low graduation rates among Black athletes persist as do the 40-50 hours/week athletes report spending on their sport. AB 252 would be a powerful counterweight to structural obstacles that work against athletes’ academic success because it would protect college athletes’ athletic scholarships through the earlier of undergraduate degree completion or six years. We are in the 50th year anniversary of Title IX, but there is still a glaring difference between the college sports participation between men and women. There are 9088 fewer female college athletes compared to male college athletes in California (this gap has increased by more than 1400 athletes since 2017). This is a red flag that screams for both transparency and accountability related to California colleges’ Title IX compliance. And while there while antitrust lawsuits and progress toward college athlete employee status are generating promising momentum toward college athletes finally receiving an equitable portion of the revenue that they generate, it has never been more important to prevent athletic programs from using this progress as an excuse to cut nonrevenue/Olympic sports. AB 252 will:
- Identify and enforce athlete health and safety protections to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death among college athletes.
- Improve athlete graduation rates.
- Protect athletic scholarships of permanently injured athletes.
- Require colleges to publicly post an annual Title IX compliance transparency report.
- Preserve all sports.
For these reasons, the NCPA urges the passage of AB 252.”
- Argument in Opposition. According to the California State University, “The CSU is dedicated to ensuring that our student athletes are supported academically and in their athletic endeavors. While we appreciate the author’s interest in the wellbeing of our student athletes, this bill would require the redistribution of critical revenues that our campuses use to provide essential academic and athletic support services for all student athletes. Services include grants, tutoring, medical support, and mental health resources. This is a ‘one size fits all’ proposal that is not appropriate for the broad diversity of size, scope, and competitiveness of athletics programs across the CSU system. CSU athletic departments operate under tight budgets, and this reallocation of revenue would harm smaller, non-revenue generating athletic programs and the services provided to all student athletes. The revenue sharing framework may also create gender inequities among our student athletes and place CSU campuses out of compliance with federal Title IX regulations. Our analysis shows that the redistribution of revenue between male and female student athletes would be disproportional. At one campus, for example, male student athletes make up thirty-eight percent of all student athletes but would receive sixty-five percent of the funds. The majority of funds would go to football, men’s basketball, and women’s basketball players, which are only a small portion of all student athletes. The College Athlete Protection Panel established by the bill would also duplicate and conflict with existing oversight bodies such as the Pac-12 and NCAA and would create an immense bureaucracy with the power to issue subpoenas, perform investigations, and impose penalties and lifetime bans. This panel would be given authority over areas currently under the jurisdiction of the Department of Justice and the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights. While we appreciate any effort to help our students, AB 252 would unfortunately result in negative impacts to many of the student athletes that it seeks to empower. The CSU respectfully requests a “no” vote on AB 252.”
- Related Legislation.
SB 1401 (Bradford, 2022) would have required postsecondary institutions to establish degree completion funds for their student-athletes that consider the revenues generated by the sport and the amount of athletic scholarship aid provided to athletes participating. This bill was held in Senate Appropriations.
AB 1435 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2017) would have established an appointed panel within the California Department of Education to create and distribute to every IHE with an intercollegiate athletic program best practices to minimize injuries, develop guidelines and mandates, perform compliance inspections, exercise subpoena power, investigate complaints, and issue penalties. This bill requires every IHE with an intercollegiate athletic program to pay an annual fee for the administration and activities of this panel. This bill was held in the Senate Education Committee.
SB 906 (Skinner, 2024) would require any entity that provides compensation or any item of value or service to a student athlete, or to the student athlete’s immediate family, to disclose information, as specified, to the student athlete’s postsecondary educational institution (PEI) and requires the PEI to make that information publicly available. Requires a PEI that shares revenues with student athletes to make publicly available the total value of the revenues shared with all of the PEI’s student athletes, as provided.
SB 661 (Bradford, Chapter 625, Statutes of 2023) Expands the rights that student athletes who attend an IHE, as defined, and removes the requirement on IHE, to rely exclusively on revenue derived from media to defray any costs accrued from affording these benefits to student athletes.
SB 26 (Skinner, Chapter 159, Statutes of 2021) expanded the existing authority for a collegiate student-athlete to receive compensation also to include compensation earned from the use of the student’s athletic reputation and moves up the implementation date of existing statutes relative to compensation earned from the use of a student athlete’s NIL.
AB 1573 (Holden, Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019) added three provisions of law designed to support and protect student-athletes rights at higher learning institutions. Expressly, the bill: 1) authorizes schools to establish degree completion funds; 2) directs schools to develop, post, and disseminate specified information regarding existing student-athlete rights; and 3) prohibits schools from retaliating against student-athletes who report violations of student-athletes rights.
SB 206 (Skinner, Chapter 383, Statutes of 2019) allows, commencing on January 1, 2023, college student-athletes to earn compensation for using their NIL (athletic endorsements). This bill allows student-athletes to obtain professional legal representation about their college athletics, such as that provided by a sports agent. This bill protects student-athletes who elect to engage in the compensation and representation activities described therein.
SB 1525 (Padilla, Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012) enacted a Student Athlete Bill of Rights and placed specified requirements on collegiate athletic programs commencing with the 2013-14 academic year and ending January 1, 2021.
SUPPORT
National College Players Association (Sponsor)
California Labor Federation
Stanford Student-Athlete Advisory Committee
United Steelworkers District 12
OPPOSITION
Academic Senate of the California State University
Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities
Big Sky Conference
California State University
College Swimming & Diving Coaches Association of America
Community College League of California
Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference
Stanford University
Team USA Athletes' Commission
U.S. Ski & Snowboard
United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee
University of California
University of Southern California
USA Artistic Swimming
USA Swimming
USA Swimming Athletes’ Advisory Council
USA Track & Field
USA Volleyball
USA Water Polo
USA Wrestling
Women's Sports Foundation
10 Individuals
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 252 Hearing Date: July 5, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: | March 6, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Kordell Hampton | ||
Subject: The College Athlete Protection Act.
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Judiciary. A "do pass" motion should include a referral to the Committee on Judiciary.
SUMMARY
Establishes the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for the purpose of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes.
BACKGROUND
Existing Law:
Federal Law
- Any coeducational Institution of Higher Education (IHE) that participates in Title IV, the federal student aid program, and has an intercollegiate athletics program, must comply with the Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act (EADA) by preparing an annual report, officially called The Report on Athletic Program Participation Rates and Financial Support Data. (34 Code of Federal Regulation (CFR) § 668.47)
- To the extent that a recipient awards athletic scholarships or grants-in-aid, it must provide reasonable opportunities for such awards for members of each sex in proportion to the number of students of each sex participating in interscholastic or intercollegiate athletics. (34 CFR § 106.37)
State Law
Name, Image, and Likeliness (NIL) Provisions
- A postsecondary educational institution shall not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a student of that institution participating in intercollegiate athletics from earning compensation due to the use of the student’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation. Earning a reward for using a student’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation shall not affect the student’s scholarship eligibility.
- A postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics shall not provide a prospective student-athlete with compensation in relation to the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation.
- A postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics shall not prevent a California student participating in intercollegiate athletics from obtaining professional representation in relation to contracts or legal matters, including, but not limited to, representation provided by athlete agents or legal representation provided by attorneys.
- A scholarship from the postsecondary educational institution in which a student is enrolled that provides the student with the cost of attendance at that institution is not compensation for purposes of this section, and a scholarship shall not be revoked as a result of earning compensation or obtaining legal representation pursuant to this section.
- A student-athlete shall not enter into a contract providing compensation to the athlete for the use of the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation if a provision of the contract is in conflict with a provision of the athlete’s team contract. A student-athlete who enters into a contract providing compensation to the athlete for the use of the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation shall disclose the contract to an official of the institution to be designated by the institution. An institution asserting a conflict shall disclose to the athlete or the athlete’s legal representation the relevant contractual provisions that are in conflict. (Education Code (EC) § 67456 et seq.)
Student-Athlete Bill of Rights
- Requires an athletic program that does not renew an athletic scholarship of a student-athlete-athlete who suffers an incapacitating injury or illness resulting from his or her participation in the athletic program, and the IHE’s medical staff determines that he or she is medically ineligible to participate in intercollegiate athletics, to provide an equivalent scholarship that, combined with the total duration of any previous athletic scholarship or scholarships received by the student-athlete, will be provided for a total of up to five academic years or until the student-athlete completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter.
- Requires each athletic program to conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all its first-year and third-year student-athletes at the beginning of the academic year.
- Requires an IHE to grant a student-athlete the same rights as other students concerning any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including, but not necessarily limited to, actions involving athletically related financial aid.
- Requires an athletic program to respond within seven business days with an answer to a student athlete’s written request to transfer to another IHE. (EC § 67452 et seq.)
Degree Completion Fund
- Establishes that an IHE may establish a degree completion fund in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws of the institution’s governing body and applicable rules and bylaws of any athletic association of which the institution is a member. (EC § 67452.3)
ANALYSIS
Establishes the CAP Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. Specifically, this bill:
Degree Completion Fund
- Requires an IHE to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants.
- Specifies that an IHE must use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution.
- Requires that a college athlete on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year will be designated an equal payment from that institution’s degree completion fund for that academic year.
- Specifies that all degree completion funds of up to $25,000 must be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year.
- Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in 9) must be made in an amount based on the institution’s revenue reported for the previous academic year.
- Requires an institution to not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
- Specifies that all degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to #9 designated for a college athlete must be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
- All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another IHE or an out-of-state college or university must be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
- Requires an IHE to accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution must not undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
- The CAP Panel may audit an IHE’s aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance, as specified. This audit may include review of the institution’s aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This will be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Declares that all degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to 9) above designated for a college athlete will be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds must be deposited in the institution’s degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
- In making annual degree completion fund payment designations, an IHE shall use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds all revenue for the 2021-22 academic year, as specified in a IHE’s Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act (EADA) report and specifies an IHE does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation, as long as it satisfies 9) and 12).
- Except as provided in 13) the institution shall use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to 9), in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations.
- Requires an IHE to make, in aggregate for the academic year, one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its female college athletes, and one-half of the total amount of degree completion fund payment designations for its male college athletes.
- Specifies for the portion allocated of the total amount allocated for men and women, the IHE must make degree completion fund payment designations for men and women college athletes on each intercollegiate athletics team who have not received fair market value compensation for the academic year. In the following manner:
- Determine the percentage of the total fair market value compensation owed to men and women college athletes on each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution that represents the total fair market compensation owed to all college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport.
- Ensure that men and women college athletes on the same intercollegiate athletics team, regardless of sport; collectively receive the percentage determined pursuant to clause 12a) of the total amount designated for college athletes pursuant to 11).
- If the portion of the total amount allocated for men and women female college athletes pursuant to 11) exceeds the total aggregate fair market value compensation owed to all college athletes on a intercollegiate athletics teams at the institution, regardless of sport, the institution shall pay each of its athletes who receive an athletic grant an equal amount of the portion.
- Except to comply with 12) and 19), inclusive, degree completion fund payment designations shall not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
- Notwithstanding 10), andIHE that gives fair market value to all of its male and female college athletes and complies with this section may use any remaining revenue for other purposes as determined by the institution.
- Authorizes an IHE to spend institutional funds on intercollegiate athletic expenses without the funds counting as revenue if, within the academic year, the institutional funds are exhausted or the institutional funds are unused and do not remain in an athletic team’s or athletic program’s budget and authorizes an institution to increase athletics spending for athletic program needs without including it in revenue directed to degree completion funds.
- Specifies the amount of funds that an institution paid for any athletic team’s non regular capital expenses for the 2021-22 academic year shall be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution did not count the funds as revenue for that academic year.
- Specifies, notwithstanding 16), the amount of funds that the institution paid for any athletic team’s expenses for the 2021–22 academic year shall be included as revenue for that academic year, even if the institution did not count the funds as revenue for that academic year.
- Specifies that an institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees before using revenue described in 9) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
- Specifies that degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of IHE. IHEs will have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
- Establishes that, if an IHE deems it necessary, the institution must adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as all of the following conditions are met:
- The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institution’s college athletes is not reduced.
- The institution must comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
- On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution must publish on its internet website and submits to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and includes both of the following in this written explanation:
- Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.
- The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Declares that degree completion fund payment designations or payments will not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
- Specifies that, within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations, each IHE will submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athlete’s intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Prohibits an IHE from reducing any discretionary revenue during the academic year below the discretionary revenue reported for the 2021–22 academic year.
- Prohibits an IHE from reducing any aggregate funds for any college athlete’s academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2021–22 academic year.
- Specifies 22) and 23) do not apply to an IHE that is unable to generate, for an academic year, all revenue in an amount that meets or exceeds all revenue reported for the 2021–22 academic year due to war, civil unrest, fire, flood, or other unforeseen disaster or cause beyond the institution’s control as determined by the CAP Panel.
- Establishes that these provisions will apply only to an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
Required Notices
- Establishes that an IHE will distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.);
- An individual notice stating: “All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the United States Department of Justice, the United State Department of Education’s (USDE) Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)’s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)’s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.”;
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f));
- A college athlete’s rights, as specified; and,
- Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
- Requires the notice distributed pursuant 26) above will contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information must include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
- The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights’ regional enforcement office;
- The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights’ online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting;
- The internet website address used by the United State Department of Education (USDE) for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act , as specified;
- A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters, as specified, and the obligations of these mandated reporters;
- The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter; and,
- The telephone number of the United States Department of Justice.
- Specifies that an IHE will post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institution’s athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
- Requires that, upon the commencement of each academic year, the IHE will provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
CAP Program
- Establishes the CAP Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research.
- Specifies that the CAP Program will be administered by the CAP Panel. The CAP Panel will be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
- Establishes the 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
- Eleven members appointed by the Governor;
- Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly; and,
- Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Specifies that the 21-member CAP Panel will consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
- Specifies that CAP Panel members will be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member will be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panel’s members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
- Requires the Office of Planning and Research to hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director will be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director will hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, will initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024. Additionally:
- The CAP Program director will provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter;
- The CAP Panel will consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter; and,
- The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. Additionally:
- It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panel’s members serve staggered terms;
- All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed will be six-year terms with no term limits; and,
- A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position as specified.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director must not have served, within five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an IHE, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
- Requires the racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California to be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
- Specifies that the CAP Panel will consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
- The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury;
- One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports;
- One member with expertise in mental health;
- One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations;
- One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations; and,
- Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
- The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in contract law;
- One member with expertise in college sports recruiting;
- One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law; and,
- One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
- The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in sports agent certification;
- One member with expertise in financial advising standards;
- One member with expertise in marketing standards; and,
- One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
- The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, as specified;
- One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics;
- One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations;
- One member with expertise in arbitration;
- One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes; and,
- One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
- The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- Establishes that the CAP Panel will have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
- Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations, as specified;
- Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties;
- Require an IHE and out-of-state college or university, as specified, to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter;
- Refer individuals, IHEs, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed as specified to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate;
- Establishes that the Attorney General will have the authority to prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
- Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public;
- At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states;
- Hold quarterly meetings;
- Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each IHE, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, as specified, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter;
- Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve these provisions; and,
- Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers.
- Specifies that, in addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations will include a system to appeal the CAP Panel’s rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
- Training to help prevent future violations;
- Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education;
- Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel; and,
- The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
- The number and duration of violations;
- Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action; and,
- The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
Health and Safety Standards, CAP Health and Safety Subpanel
- Requires an IHE to meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established as specified. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel must do all of the following:
- Consult with athletic associations, the University of California (UC), the California State University (CSU), and the athlete health and safety advocacy community;
- Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the NCAA, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers’ Association; and,
- Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
- Specifies that all reports of suspected health and safety violations at an IHEthat occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, will be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice must forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted as specified.
- Requires, within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel’s health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to 42) above, an IHE to comply with all of the following:
- Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards;
- Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director; and,
- Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel the point of contact’s email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, the institution’s athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
- Notwithstanding 43 a) above, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel may require IHE to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
- Requires, within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel’s health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to 42) above, an IHE to comply with all of the following:
- Specifies that the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel will have all of the following duties and powers:
- Require transparency from IHEs on injury treatment options for college athletes;
- Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks;
- Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athlete’s participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request;
- Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities as specified;
- Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes;
- Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary;
- Require assistance from IHE to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program;
- Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance as specified;
- Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned as specified from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education; and,
- Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
- Specifies that all athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, must report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
- Specifies that an individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any IHE if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
- Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted as specified;
- Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section;
- Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death; and,
- Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
- Requires that, before a ban may be imposed in 46) above, the individual will be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
- Requires any individual or entity designated by an IHE to investigate allegations of a violation of these provisions that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel. Additionally:
- Before a penalty may be imposed as specified, the individual or entity must be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
- Provides that, except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel will have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel must not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
- Requires that affiliated medical personnel will be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher education’s office or department that is independent of the institution’s athletic department.
Medical Expenses
- Requires an IHE that reports $20,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE will be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 50) above will not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another IHEor out-of-state higher education institution and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 50) above will not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Requires an IHE that reports $50,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE to comply with both of the following:
- Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance will be paid for by the institution. The institution must not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance; and,
- Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 51) above will not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another IHE or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 51) above will not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Establishes that, if a college athlete at an IHE that is responsible for the college athlete’s medical expenses, as specified, chooses to receive medical care that is not provided as specified or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution will offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
- The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care; and,
- The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
- Requires an IHE to pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete. Additionally:
- IHE personnel and affiliated medical personnel must not withhold a college athlete’s medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion as specified, or otherwise impede a college athlete’s right to obtain an independent second opinion.
55) Requires that, no later than three days after the end of a college athlete’s team season in the final year of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institution’s receipt of a college athlete’s notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education must provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
- Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel must not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination; and,
- A former college athlete will be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination.
Title IX Compliance Evaluation
- Requires that, on or before July 1 of each year, an IHE must comply with both of the following:
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institution’s male and female college athletes;
- Whether the institution’s male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities;
- Whether the interests and abilities of the institution’s male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation as specified will include measures of the institution’s performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979; and,
- The institution’s determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
- Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Requires that, at the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to 55) above, the institution shall include the following statement: “To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact” (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator.
- Requires that an individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with these provisions, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation will be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
- Before a ban may be imposed, an individual must be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
Six year athletic grants, punishment for program reduction
- Requires an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022, or becomes a member of a NCAA Division I sport thereafter, and that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant to provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant must be provided regardless of the college athlete’s lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
- The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year will be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
- Specifies that a college athlete who transfers to an IHE will receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to 59) above for up to one academic year beyond the college athlete’s remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. Additionally:
- Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the IHE’s leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, 59) above will only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year;
- 59) above will not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory; and,
- 59) above will not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
- Is found by the IHE to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion;
- Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters;
- Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements; or,
- Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
- Specifies 59) and 60) only applies to an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Division I sports on or after January 1, 2022
- Specifies that an individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an IHE will not do either of the following:
- Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion; and,
- Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athlete’s selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
- Requires an individual employed by an athletic program at an IHE to not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic program’s mandatory team activities.
- Specifies that an IHE must not comply with any athletic association’s or athletic conference’s policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
Recruiting Transparency
- Requires an IHE or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:
- A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete;
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athlete’s, college athlete’s, or intercollegiate athlete’s choice of athlete representation;
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athlete’s, college athlete’s, or intercollegiate athlete’s representation to NIL activities; and,
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
- Requires that the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel must solicit the information described in 65) above and post information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described must be regularly updated.
- Specifies that an IHE will only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident will only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed as specified may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and must include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
- The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institution’s in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panel’s internet website pursuant to this section;
- Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policy’s benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes;
- A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed; and,
- The disclosures described in 66) above, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
- Specifies that this section does not prohibit an IHE or out-of-state college or university this is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required.
CAP Certification Subpanel
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel established as specified to certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
- Specifies that, no later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanel’s certification operations, an individual or entity will not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanel’s certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel to develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
- Certify all of the following:
- College athlete agents;
- Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents;
- Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state;
- Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state;
- Revoke certifications provided pursuant to 71a) above; and,
- Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
- Certify all of the following:
- Specifies that the CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant 71) above. Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
- The CAP Certification Subpanel must develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity; and,
- Fees and fines collected must be deposited in the CAP Fund as specified.
- Specifies that the CAP Certification Subpanel will not adopt a standard that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associate’s degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other provision, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel. Additionally:
- The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities; and,
- To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel will not certify college athlete representation provided by an IHE, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
CAP Panel IHE Fees
- Requires that, on or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each IHE that was a member of the NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, must pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to 77) below, to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund as specified.
- Specifies that the CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institution’s total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal EADA to the USDE. The CAP Panel must establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined as specified:
- IHEs with athletic revenue of less than $2,499,999 shall each pay an annual fee of up to $100;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $2,500,000 and $19,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $20,000,000 and $29,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $30,000,000 and $59,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue of at least $60,000,000 will each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year; and,
- Two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one $100.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding 76) and 77) above, for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on IHEs, an IHE’s annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution. Additionally,
- If the total amount of annual fees collected exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to $7,000,000, the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
- Institutions described in 77a) and 77f) shall receive first priority;
- Institutions described in 77b) shall receive second priority;
- Institutions described in 77c) shall receive third priority;
- Institutions described in 77d) shall receive forth priority; and,
- Institutions described in 77e) shall receive fifth priority;
- It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
- If the total amount of annual fees collected exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to $7,000,000, the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
Financial workshops
- Requires an IHE to administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An IHE will require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athlete’s first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
- Specifies that a program developed pursuant to this section will include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
- The rights of college athletes, as specified; and,
- State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
- Requires a program developed as specified will not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
Penalty Exemptions For College Athletes
- An IHE will not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
- For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source;
- For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics; and,
- For a college athlete’s family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
Retaliation
- Requires that an IHE and the institution’s employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel will not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete’s rights as specified.
- For purposes of this chapter, “retaliation” includes all of the following:
- A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher education’s policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws;
- A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation;
- A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete;
- A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athlete’s housing owned by IHE;
- A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment;
- Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint; and,
- Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
CAP Fund
- Establishes the CAP Fund. The CAP Panel will administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund will serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except as specified. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing these provisions.
Broad Regulatory Authority
- Authorizes the CAP Panel to promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
Enforcement provision
- Specifies that the Act not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators from liability.
Severability
- Declares that the provisions of the Act are severable. If any provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
Repeals elements of current law
- Repeals sections of current law pertaining to the degree completion fund, a notice of student rights, and retaliation.
Reimbursement
- If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this Act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
Definitions
- Establishes the following definitions for the CAP Act:
- “Affiliated medical personnel” means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an IHE. “Affiliated medical personnel” include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel;
- “Aggregate athletic grants” means the total amount of athletic grants that an IHE annually reports pursuant to the federal EADA to the USDE for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. “Aggregate athletic grants” shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institution’s instate or out-of-state college athletes;
- “Athletic association” means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs;
- “Athletic grant” means an athletics scholarship or grant that an institution of higher education pays to a college athlete to cover a portion or all of the institution’s cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1087ll). An athletic grant shall not exceed the institution’s cost of attendance.;
- “Athletic program” means an intercollegiate athletic program at an IHE;
- “CAP Fund” means the Fund established as specified;
- “CAP Panel” means the Panel established as specified;
- “CAP Program” means the Program established as specified;
- “College athlete” means a student who is enrolled at an IHE and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete;
- “Fair market value compensation” means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic team’s aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic team’s revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team;
- “IHE” or “institution” means any campus of the UC, the CSU, the California Community Colleges (CCC), an independent IHE, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program;
- “Intercollegiate athlete” means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete;
- “NCAA” means the National Collegiate Athletic Association;
- “NIL” means the use of a college athlete’s name, image, and likeness;
- “Office for Civil Rights” means the Office for Civil Rights within the USDE;
- “Revenue” means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal EADA by an IHE to the USDE “Revenue” includes intercollegiate athletics revenue paid directly by an intercollegiate athletic conference, an athletic association, or a source designated by an IHE, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association to cover any athletic program expense or to compensate a college athlete for participating in intercollegiate athletics at the institution;
- “All revenue” includes revenue that is not allocated by sport pursuant to federal EADA reporting standards;
- “Institutional Funds” means the amount of an IHE’s revenue that is not derived from any intercollegiate athletics source for an academic year that exceeds the amount of its revenue that did not derive from any intercollegiate athletics source reported for the 2021–22 academic year; and
- “Title IX” means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.).
Legislative findings
- Makes findings and declarations related to increasing protections for college athletes.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “There is a tremendous need for AB 252 because California’s college athletes are governed by athletic associations that do not enforce health and safety standards to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death; and impose rules that have violated antitrust laws and have caused athletes economic harm. College athletes’ athletic time demands result in unacceptably low federal graduation rates among Black college athletes that produce the most athletic revenue, there is a lack of transparency and accountability regarding important athletic program policies for college athletes and recruits, and there is a need to certify athlete agent representatives to help prevent college athletes from bad actors. College athletes are often put in harm's way as the institutions they represent prioritize winning over athlete safety. Coaches are incentivized to secure victories as it can lead to job stability and salary increments, while athletic trainers are often driven by the fear of being fired if they raise concerns that could potentially impact the team's performance. This misplaced emphasis on winning over athlete well-being is a concerning trend that requires immediate attention and resolution. It is an ongoing hazard to allow universities to police the treatment of their athletes when the universities’ negligence and mistreatment are primary forces in harming the well-being of so many athletes.”
- The California Student Athlete’s Bill of Rights (SABR). Before starting, it is essential to highlight current benefits and protections specified in state law. Several protections provided for California student-athletes are contained in the SABR (EC 67452 and 67453) are limited to universities that receive, on average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. This number is a minority of California colleges and universities and has traditionally only included UC Berkeley, Stanford, the University of Southern California (USC), and UC Los Angeles. The rapid increase in athletics media rights deals – and the lack of inflation growth built into current law – means that other universities with robust athletics programs might also soon fall under these specific provisions of SABR.
It is important to note that earlier this Legislative year, this committee heard a similar bill, SB 661 (Bradford, 2023), that removed the $10 million media rights for intercollegiate athletics threshold to allow all student-athletes to be afforded the benefits listed below. SB 661 passed the committee unanimously with no opposition.
Specifically, these SABR provisions require an intercollegiate athletic program at any campus of the UC, CSU, or private four-year university in California to provide to students whose athletic scholarship is not renewed an equivalent scholarship (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic or other scholarship received by the student) for a total of at least five years or until the student completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter.
The law also requires athletic programs to promptly approve a qualifying student athlete's written request to transfer to another institution without actively or passively imposing any restrictions or condition. Implementation must include granting other institutions permission to contact the student athlete and waiving residency requirements, as permitted by athletic association rules.
The SABR also requires an athletic program to be responsible for any and all medical expenses of its student athletes resulting from their participation in the athletic program, irrespective of whether the student athlete is still in school, has graduated, or is no longer enrolled in the school, so long as the medical expenses result from the student athlete's participation in the athletic program, and to adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration, and exercise and supervision guidelines for any student athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
Colleges must also grant a student-athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including actions involving his or her participation in the athletic program.
- Alston v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). In Alston v. NCAA, the athletes challenged the NCAA compensation limits as reducing competition among colleges and universities as to what those schools would otherwise provide the athletes. Given this restriction on competition, the NCAA relied on its longstanding position that the uniqueness of its product – the status of student-athletes as amateurs – required antitrust deference and pointed for support to the 1984 decision in NCAA v. Board of Regents. Specifically, the NCAA’s procompetitive justification for the status quo (whereby the NCAA limits athlete compensation tied to academics and athletics and primarily prohibits athlete monetization of NIL rights) was that the survival of the product of college athletics depends on such restrictions by the NCAA. It reasoned that intercollegiate athletics differentiates itself from professional sports chiefly through the amateur status of its athletes; therefore, diminishing the purity of amateurism through direct athlete payment—even for educational expenses—would render intercollegiate athletics obsolete.
The Alston decision rejected this argument, holding that the Board of Regents decision was inapplicable to questions of athlete compensation and that the decision’s oft-cited commentary that the NCAA enjoys “ample latitude” under federal antitrust law was mere dicta that could not insulate the NCAA from antitrust scrutiny. Specifically, the Court found that the NCAA had failed to show any economic analysis of how or why the consumer market for college sports might be irrevocably destroyed by teenage athletes receiving unrestrained educational benefits. The Court noted, in contrast, that the Alston plaintiffs could show the opposite—namely, that the popularity of college sports had increased in the years following increased allowances in educational benefits allocation.
Justice Gorsuch found that by limiting education-related compensation that college athletes can receive from their schools, the NCAA violated Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which prohibits any “contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce.” The Court reached this conclusion by affirming the lower court’s application of the “rule of reason” – a judicial doctrine of antitrust law.
The Supreme Court unanimously ruled in Alston v. NCAA that the NCAA violated anti-trust law and that the NCAA was not legally allowed to limit any education-related payments to students.
- Name, Image, and Likeliness. On September 30, 2019, California became the first state to introduce and enact legislation to prohibit IHE, amateur athletic associations and athletic conferences, and any other organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics from preventing student-athletes from earning compensation in connection with the use of the athlete’s name, image, and likeness (see EC § 67456 et seq). California began a nationwide conversation and initiative to address primarily NCAA bylaws that have historically prohibited student-athletes from using or permitting others to use their NIL to earn compensation or promote the athlete’s athletic skills and abilities.
The popular phrasing - NIL - refers to what is legally defined as “publicity rights.” Publicity rights are the property rights associated with the personality and identity of an individual. These rights enable an individual to control the commercial use of their identity. The public image of a celebrity or athlete is of immense value and can produce significant amounts of money for the individual celebrity or athlete. The State of California protects publicity rights both through statute and common law. California Civil Code § 3344 covers a person’s name, image, signature, photograph, and likeness. California courts use a “readily identifiable” test to determine if some characteristic or indicia of identity would fall into one of these five categories. Thus, if an individual is readily identifiable by the user’s representation of identity, it would be subject to the provisions of § 3344. California jurisprudence on publicity rights is well-developed, frequently relied upon, and cited by courts outside California.
Whether a student-athlete postsproducts on their social media, signs autographs, teach camps, or promotes a local business it is the decision of an student-athlete to use their name image a\and likeliness.
- The Equity In Athletics Disclosure Act. The EADA (34 CFR § 668.4) requires IHE to disclose information about their varsity teams and the financial resources and personnel the school dedicates to those teams. The EADA Report must be published by October 15 each year and made available upon request to students, prospective students, and the public.
Revenues: The October 15th report requires separate revenues for Football, Men’s Basketball, Women’s Basketball, All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball, All Women’s teams except Basketball, and all sports combined. Revenues for All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball and All Women’s teams except Basketball are not collected web-based data collection.
“Revenues” as defined in EADA are revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities. This includes revenues from appearance guarantees and options, an athletic conference, tournament or bowl games, concessions, contributions from alumni and others, institutional support, program advertising and sales, radio and television, royalties, signage and other sponsorships, sports camps, state or other government support, student activity fees, ticket and luxury box sales, and any other revenues attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities.
Expenses: The October 15th report requires separate expenses for Football, Men’s Basketball, Women’s Basketball, All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball, All Women’s teams except Basketball, and all sports combined. Expenses for All Men’s teams except Football and Basketball and All Women’s teams except Basketball are not collected in the web-based data collection.
“Expenses” as defined in EADA are expenses attributable to intercollegiate athletic activities. This includes appearance guarantees and options, athletically related student aid, contract services, equipment, fundraising activities, operating expenses, promotional activities, recruiting expenses, salaries and benefits, supplies, travel, and other expenses attributable to intercollegiate athletics activities.
“Revenue Not Allocated by Sport” as defined by EADA include revenues not attributable to a particular sport or sports. These funds can be earned revenue or institutional support. Earned revenue is derived from various sources such as: alumni contributions to the athletic department not targeted to a particular sport or sports, investment interest income, athletic conference money, radio and advertising sales, royalties, signage or other sponsorships, and any other earned revenue not attributable to a team (e.g., fundraising activities). Revenues should also include institutional, state or other government support that is used to pay for athletic director's, assistant athletic director's, department support staff, and trainers salaries, bonuses and benefits, general administrative overhead, conference and NCAA dues, costs for teams for which there were no participants (e.g., start-up or discontinued teams)
NOTE: The graphic above represents the California State University, Sacramento’s revenue and expenses as provided in their 2021-22 EADA report.
Is EADA Accurate? While the EADA provides a snapshot of an IHE’s expenses and revenue, this information is not disaggregated into individual line items and, therefore difficult to differentiate between the revenue generated from the athletic conferences, tournament or bowl games, concessions, and ticket sales, from others, such as alumni contributions, student activity fees, and state or other government support. Moreover, the report does not separately demonstrate revenue generated in other sports, such as track and field, soccer, tennis, etc. Sports other than basketball and football are located under “Total Revenue of all Sports, Except Football and Basketball, combined”
Further, per EADA’s guidelines, “Grand Total Revenues must be equal to or greater than your Grand Total Expenses.” This means that an IHE can only be shown as being cost-neutral or revenue generate, even if the IHE did not generate revenue. This can be shown in the graphic above.
This bill will use an IHE’s EADA report to determine if new revenue has been generated and aligns the definition of revenue with EADA. The committee may consider whether the data in an IHE’s EADA is sufficient to determine an IHE’s athletic department’s revenue considering that revenue includes 1) alumni contributions, student activity fees, and state or other government support; 2) does not outline revenue made by other sports other than basketball and football; and 3) cannot show if an IHE’s athletic department absorbed cost.
- What Is a Degree Completion Fund? A Degree Completion Fund is a benefit that IHE can offer to student-athletes after they have exhausted their four years of athletic eligibility and no longer receive an athletic grant. A degree completion fund recognizes that a now former student-athlete may need to remain in college for additional time to complete their degree. A degree completion fund essentially serves as an equivalent scholarship to help former student athletes pay for college to help complete their degree. The duration of a degree completion in which it is eligible to a student-athlete varies from institution-to-institution and athletic conferences.
AB 252 (Holden) recasts and expands upon the degree completion fund established in current law by AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019. As noted in the Assembly Higher Education Analysis, “when AB 1573 was moving through the process, the Degree Completion Fund was instituted, in part, to allow California to comply with new NCAA Bylaws creating such funds for former basketball student-athletes. The bylaw, now known as Bylaw 15.01.5.2.1, specifies that “an institution that provides athletically related financial aid to basketball student-athletes shall provide, at a minimum, tuition and fees, and course-related books to a former basketball student-athlete who requests financial aid to complete his or her first baccalaureate degree, provided:
- The former student-athlete received athletically related financial aid while previously enrolled at the institution.
- Fewer than 10 years have elapsed since the former student-athlete's departure from the institution.
- The former student-athlete's most recent enrollment as a full-time student occurred at the institution.
- The former student-athlete was previously enrolled as a full-time student at the institution for a minimum of two academic years (four semesters or six quarters).
- The former student-athlete meets all institutional admissions and financial aid requirements.
- The former student-athlete has exhausted other available degree completion funding options (e.g., funds from a professional league or contract).
- The former student-athlete is in good academic standing at the institution and meets NCAA and institutional progress-toward-degree requirements. This requirement applies to initial and continuing eligibility for degree completion funds.”
This bill allows eligible student-athletes to earn up to $25,000 annually [see Analysis 4)]. Any amount over $25,000 will be held by the IHE until the students graduates [see Analysis 6)]. The committee may wish to consider whether this bill deviates from original meaning and purpose of a degree completion fund and renders the degree completion fund establish by AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019 unnecessary.
- NIL and this Bill: Before continuing, it is essential to note that NIL and this bill, regarding student-athlete compensation, are not the same and are distinct.
Who Is Eligible To Be Compensated Under NIL and This Bill? Under NIL, all student-athletes (no matter the division or association) can use their name image and likeliness.
Under this bill, the provisions specify that only scholarship athletes participating in Division NCAA I sports [see Analysis 1) & 25)], who meet fair market value, are eligible to receive degree completion funds. This bill excludes nonscholarship athletes (walk-ons) who participate in an NCAA Division I sport and all athletes in Division II, III, and community college athletics.
How Are Student-Athletes Compensated Under NIL and This Bill? Under NIL, student-athletes are compensated by the business or organization they have entered into contract with to post products on social media, teach camps, or promote a local business.
Under this bill, an IHE revenue, as reported in their 2021-22 EADA report, would serve as their base year [see Analysis 4)] . Any revenue generated beyond the base year in any given EADA reporting year is considered new revenue that is first prioritized to compensate student-athletes [see Analysis 11)]. The total amount that is reserved to compensate student-athletes by calculating the fair market value. This is calculated by subtracting 50% of the new revenue from the total aggregate of both men’s and women’s athletic grants [see Analysis 91j)]. After performing the calculation, if there is a remaining balance, that amount is then owed to all student-athletes [see Analysis 10)]. Of the owed amount, 50% is reserved for men’s teams, and 50% is reserved for women’s teams [see Analysis 11)]. The bill then proposes the 50% for both men’s and women’s be dispensed equally to all players as specified [see Analysis 12, inclusive)].
If the IHE does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a student-athlete into a degree completion fund so long as the funds are exhausted and in compliance with Title IX.
Is The New Revenue Really Split 50/50 Among Men’s and Women’s Athletes? As defined in this bill, an “athletic grant” is a “an athletics scholarship or grant that an IHE pays to a college athlete to cover a portion or all of the institution’s cost of attendance for a full-time, in-state, on-campus undergraduate student determined pursuant to the federal Higher Education Act of 1965. ” [see Analysis 91 j)] Further, the bill specifies that “if an institution of higher education deems it necessary, the institution shall adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics.” [see Analysis 19 inclusive)].
With regard to athletics, Title IX requires female and male college athletes to receive athletics scholarship dollars proportional to their participation. Regarding compensation under Title IX, Title IX does not expressly address compensation.
Subpart D of Title 34 CFR § 106.37 expressly addresses Title IX’s application to the provision of athletic scholarships by stating, “To the extent that a recipient awards athletic scholarships or grants-in-aid, it must provide reasonable opportunities for such awards for members of each sex in proportion to the number of students of each sex participating in interscholastic or intercollegiate athletics” (34 CFR § 106.37 (c)). For example, if 45% of the athletes at a college are female and 55% male, 45% of the total amount of athletic scholarship funding the college grants should go to female athletes and 55% to male athletes.
While the bill proposes a 50/50 split, compliance with Title IX would require an IHE to split the new revenue generated in accordance with the ratio of an IHE team.
The 2021-22 Base Year Does Not Account For Inflation. This bill establishes an IHE’s athletic revenue, as identified in their 2021-22 EADA report, as their base year [see Analysis 9)]. Any new revenue generated over the base year, upon calculating the fair market value, goes to student-athlete. While an IHE athletic revenue and expense may fluctuate from year-to-year, an IHE does not base adjust over time to account for inflation, therefore assuming that the base is sufficient to maintain an IHE athletic department’s operation. The bill specifies that an IHE “shall not reduce any discretionary revenue during the academic year below the discretionary revenue reported for the 2021–22 academic year and any aggregate funds for any college athlete’s academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, eliminate roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, reduce aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminate any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2021–22 academic year.” [see Analysis 22) & 23].
The committee may wish to consider if using an institution of higher education’s 2021-22 EADA report as a base year may harm athletic programs, as this bill does not allow the base to be adjusted for inflation.
What Is the Fair Market Value (FMV) of a Student-Athlete? As specified in the bill, FMV is 50% of the new revenue generated over the 2021-22 base year[see Analysis 91sj)]. According to the Assembly Education Committee Analysis, “revenue share varies greatly based on the sport. For example, while athletes in the National Basketball Association and Major League Baseball receive close to 50%, fighters in the United Fighting Championship receive 16-20%, while athletes in the Women’s National Basketball Association receive approximately 25%.”
The committee may wish to consider if 50% is the appropriate FMV of a college athlete player and whether the FMV of the National Basketball Association or Major League Baseball should be seen as the exception rather than the average.
- Intercollegiate Athletics: A Combination of Different Funding Sources. Athletic departments finance their programs using a variety of different revenue sources. Student fees or institutional subsidies (from tuition, state appropriations, endowments, or other revenue-generating activities on campus) often support even the most extensive NCAA Division I college sports programs. A 2013 study published by the Delta Project at the American Research Institute found that only Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) teams (I.e., Rose Bowl, Sugar Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, etc.) generate more revenue than expenses incurred. The study, Academic Spending Versus Athletic Spending: Who Wins?, finds that “even among the largest FBS programs, student fees and institutional subsidies typically provided between 4 percent and 14 percent of total athletic revenues.”
The study goes on to mention that “Without access to television contracts and large stadiums with sizable ticket sales revenue, the budgets at smaller Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) and Division I Non-Football (DI-NF) subdivisions are heavily subsidized by student fees, institutional support, and alumni donations. FCS programs are more likely to rely on institutional support. At the same time, DI-NF schools rely on student fees to fund much of their budget.”
The study concluded that in 2010, “more than 80 percent of the budget at the typical FBS colleges came from “generated” revenues, such as ticket sales, conference payouts, and donations. In contrast, more than 70 percent of athletic budgets in the smaller FCS and DI-NF programs came from revenues “allocated” by the university; this athletic subsidy includes money from student fees, institutional support, and government appropriations.”
- Bolstering Or Making It Difficult To Comply With Title IX? Title IX is a Federal civil rights law. It prohibits schools that receive Federal funding from discriminating based on sex in their programs or activities. The Department’s Title IX regulations include requirements for how schools must comply with Title IX, including in their athletic programs.
Three-pronged Test. The Title IX regulations require schools to provide equal opportunity based on sex. This requirement applies to schools’ athletic programs, including club, intramural, and intercollegiate teams. Equal opportunity in college and university athletic programs is measured by the three-pronged test, in which a schools can demonstrate compliance by showing any one of three criteria:
- Test One – proportionality; provide intercollegiate or interscholastic participation opportunities for women and men at rates that are proportionate to their respective rates of enrollment; or
- Test Two – continued program expansion for the underrepresented sex; show that opportunities have been added for the underrepresented sex (nearly always girls and women) as their interests and abilities have developed and evolved; or
- Test Three – full accommodation of the underrepresented sex; fully accommodate the underrepresented sex by offering every team for which there is sufficient interest and ability for a viable team, and sufficient competition in the geographic areas where the institution normally competes.
Does The Inability to Manage Rosters Make It Difficult To Use Test One? At the collegiate level, meeting test one means that participation opportunities are proportionate to the full-time undergraduate enrollment. if women are 52% of the full-time undergraduate students, then 52% of the intercollegiate athletics participants should be women. This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating roster slots on any intercollegiate athletics team, in addition to reducing any aggregate funds for any college athlete’s academic, medical, mental health, athletic training, or nutritional support, aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminating any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2021–22 academic year.
This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating roster slots that existed during the 2021- 22 academic year [see Analysis 22)]. The committee may wish to consider if more flexibility should be built-in to allow IHE to have the option to comply with test one.
Does The Inability to Eliminate Programs Discourage Expansion (Test Two)? Test two applies only if students of one sex are underrepresented. An IHE can meet test two by showing that it has added opportunities for women as their interests in different sports develop. This can mean either adding a women’s team or teams or adding opportunities on existing teams.
This bill prohibits an IHE from eliminating any intercollegiate athletics sport entirely that existed during the 2021–22 academic year [see Analysis 23j)].. As new sports, emerge popularity and participation sway, it may be difficult for an IHE to establish a new sport while managing existing sports that may have lost interest but must maintain as required by this bill. The committee may wish to consider whether it is more appropriate to eliminate a sport, only if the IHE has plans to adopt a new sport.
- College Athlete Protection Panel: New Body with Broad Regulatory and Fee Authority. As established by this bill, the CAP Panel, located within the Office of Planning and Research, would include a 21-member panel (11 members appointed by the Governor and five members appointed by the Senate and Assembly each) to create and distribute to every IHE with an intercollegiate athletic program best practices to minimize injuries, develop guidelines and mandates, perform compliance inspections, exercise subpoena power, investigate complaints, and issue penalties.
Expertise of The Panel Members: This bill requires that several specified areas of expertise be considered when appointing members to the panel and provides that no two members are to have the same expertise [see Analysis 32) - 39), inclusive]. However, this bill does not actually require the members of the panel to have any of the specified expertise.
Should this bill specifically require each panel member to hold expertise in one of the specified areas, with no two members having the same area of expertise?
This bill does not provide for personnel of any IHE to be included as panel members, [see Analysis 32) – 39), inclusive]. Should the 21-member panel membership include at least a minimal representation from IHEs?
Is it sufficient to allow representatives of IHEs to participate in each advisory board that the panel may establish?
Penalties: This bill authorizes the panel to impose penalties upon IHEs or its personnel, including civil penalties, temporary or permanent prohibition from employment at IHEs, or other penalties as determined by the panel [see Analysis 46), 47), & 71)].
Is it appropriate for an appointed panel of individuals who may not be trained in adjudicating complaints of violations of law and impose potentially serious penalties?
The panel is specifically authorized to temporarily or permanently prohibit an individual from employment at an IHE [see Analysis 46) & 47)]. Many athletic personnel, such as coaches, are faculty or have a contract with the employing IHE.
It is unclear how an appointed panel can have authority over the employment decisions of IHEs. Instead, should the panel be authorized to recommend to the employing IHE that the individual be temporarily or permanently prohibited from being employed?
Regulations: This bill requires the panel to adopt regulations to implement the provisions of this bill [see Analysis 85)]. Is it appropriate for an appointed panel to adopt regulations?
- NCAA – Increased Benefits For Division I Athletes Beginning August 2024. In April, the Board of Directors unanimously adopted new rules for all Division I schools that will require increased support for college athletes. The benefits, often referred to as the "holistic student-athlete benefits model," were supported by the Division I Council earlier this month and were originally recommended by the Transformation Committee in January. All Division I members who do not do so already will be required to do the following:
- Provide medical coverage for athletically related injuries for at least two years after graduation.
- Cover out-of-pocket medical expenses (copayments, deductibles, etc.) during a student-athlete's playing career.
- Attest that they provide mental health services and support consistent with the NCAA's mental health best practices.
- Attest that they follow concussion management protocols in line with the NCAA Concussion Safety Protocol Checklist.
- Offer degree completion funds for up to 10 years after a college athlete's eligibility concludes, if that college athlete was previously on full scholarship or received financial aid in a head count sport.
- Provide the same scholarship protections already required of autonomy conferences.
- Attest that they provide academic support services in line with NCAA rules.
- Attest that they provide career counseling for current and former college athletes and life skills development across a range of topics, including at a minimum:
- Mental health.
- Strength and conditioning.
- Nutrition.
- Name, image, and likeness opportunities.
- Financial literacy.
- Career preparation.
- Transfer requirements
- Diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging.
- Sexual violence prevention.
The requirements take effect August 2024. Schools can begin offering these benefits at any time.
- Argument In Opposition. According to the Women’s Sport Foundation, “We write today to urge you to oppose AB 252. We feel it poses very real concerns for gender equity and broad-based sports offerings in this country.
AB 252 seeks to:
- Funnel sports programs’ revenue to the student-athlete with “fair market value” as defined by the bill,
- Create a Degree Completion Fund to distribute additional payments to student-athletes after graduation (within six years)
- Provide student athletes with additional healthcare benefits and protections, and
- Create a College Athlete Protection Panel to oversee and regulate the bill.
Although several amendments have been are in AB 252 in an attempt to address gender equity concerns in the original bill, these fall short.
The Arms Race has Stunted Investment in Women’s Sports
Despite the milestone celebration of the 50th anniversary of Title IX last year, we know far too many schools and institutions are out of compliance with this law. Our country’s current collegiate sports model needs reform. For too long, the system has allowed unchecked growth, creating an “arms race” among many schools and an inequitable investment in football and men’s basketball programs, with women’s sports and men’s Olympic sports often serving as an afterthought. The current arms race has done nothing to expand broad-based sports offerings. In fact, between 1988‑2016, NCAA schools saw a net gain in the number of teams offered, with 594 added in Division II and 751 added in Division III, however, at the Division I level where the arms race is pervasive, schools saw a net loss of 330 men’s teams in Division I (Wilson, 2017)
Although this bill seeks to prohibit schools from cutting sports and roster spots, the reality is that if schools don’t have the budget to fund sports, they will cut sports. We cannot be naïve to that that schools will not find ways around this provision. If this were the case, we know from history that women’s sports and men’s Olympic sports would be among the first to be cut.
Limiting Growth of Women’s Sports
One needs to look no further than the NCAA Gender Equity Review and the Media & Sponsorship Addendum to see that women’s sports have too long been undervalued. As is currently structured, women’s marquee championships are bundled as part of a package deal which has been woefully undervalued in media negotiations. Despite this, women’s sports continue to see unprecedented growth, for example, the 2022 NCAA Women’s Basketball Championship averaged 9.2 million viewers (12.6 million peak) and was the most watched college basketball game to date. We caution you that AB 252’s structure could do very little to protect women’s sports offerings and instead would stifle the growth potential of women’s sports
Title IX
Amendments were introduced into the current bill version, seemingly to address gender equity concerns raised regarding its previous iteration, unfortunately, these amendments still fall short. Title IX regulations are based on the premise of equity and proportionality. AB252 now dictates a 50/50 split of degree completion funds between men and women athletes. This comma, however, is a comma. That does not mean payments will be gender equitable, period. On average would make up to 60% of undergraduate enrollment, and for schools complying with prong one of the three-part test, their women student-athletes would also like to be very close to that same proportion. A rudimentary 50/50 split of funds does not address the representation of women in our colleges and universities and would likely shortchange women at many institutions.
Though there are many points of view on the future of college sports, we can all agree that change and evolution is needed, however, a disjointed state by state solution is not the answer. College sports are in need of reform, but must be create that change and a broad federal level top of mind”
- Argument in Support. According to the California Labor Federation, “The California Labor Federation supports AB 252 (Holden), which will provide critically important rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. Far too many college athletes needlessly suffer serious injury, abuse, and even death as a result of their grueling work. Inadequately enforced—or nonexistent—health and safety standards, unjust compensation policies, and burdensome athletic time demands can combine to create a toxic and dangerous environment that can particularly harm Black college athletes, many of whom are from low-income homes. These Black college athletes make up the majority of revenue for sport athletes yet, suffer some of the lowest graduation rates. And although Title IX—federal law that sought to ensure gender equity in education settings—has been in place for 50 years, a clear lack of Title IX compliance in athletics programs persists across many colleges. Heightening the need to address these concerns are the significant state funds and income tax exemptions California colleges receive. We strongly believe the state of California’s role in funding these programs creates a public duty to address such harms. AB 252 will introduce more strictly enforced health and safety standards, more equitable athletic revenue share with athletes, improved Title IX compliance transparency, and a sports-related medical expense benefit for athletes, among other reforms. These changes will take major steps towards guaranteeing a safer working environment for these vulnerable young athletes. For these reasons, we urge you to vote “AYE” on AB 252 (Holden) when it comes before you in the Senate Education Committee for Wednesday, July 5, 2023”
- Related Legislation
SB 661 (Bradford, 2023) Expands the rights that student athletes who attend an IHE, as defined, and removes the requirement on IHE, to rely exclusively on revenue derived from media to defray any costs accrued from affording these benefits to student athletes. This bill is Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 1401 (Bradford, 2022) would have required postsecondary institutions to establish degree completion funds for their student-athletes that consider the revenues generated by the sport and the amount of athletic scholarship aid provided to athletes participating. This bill was held in Senate Appropriations.
SB 26 (Skinner), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2021, expanded the existing authority for a collegiate student-athlete to receive compensation also to include compensation earned from the use of the student’s athletic reputation and moves up the implementation date of existing statutes relative to compensation earned from the use of a student athlete’s NIL.
AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019, added three provisions of law designed to support and protect student-athletes rights at higher learning institutions. Expressly, the bill: 1) authorizes schools to establish degree completion funds; 2) directs schools to develop, post, and disseminate specified information regarding existing student-athlete rights; and 3) prohibits schools from retaliating against student-athletes who report violations of student-athletes rights.
SB 206 (Skinner), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2019, allows, commencing on January 1, 2023, college student-athletes to earn compensation for using their NIL (athletic endorsements). This bill allows student-athletes to obtain professional legal representation about their college athletics, such as that provided by a sports agent. This bill protects student-athletes who elect to engage in the compensation and representation activities described therein.
SB 1525 (Padilla) Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012, enacted a SABR and placed specified requirements on collegiate athletic programs commencing with the 2013-14 academic year and ending January 1, 2021.
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation
OPPOSITION
Academic Senate of The California State University
Association of Independent California Colleges & Universities
Big Sky Conference
California State University
Community College League of California
Stanford University
Team USA Athletes' Commission
U.S. Ski & Snowboard
United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee
University of California
University of Southern California
USA Artistic Swimming
USA Swimming
USA Swimming Athletes’ Advisory Council
USA Track & Field
USA Volleyball
USA Water Polo
USA Wrestling
Women's Sports Foundation
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 252
Author:(Holden)
As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Establishes the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes
Major Provisions
- Establishes the CAP Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes.
- Requires certain institutions of higher education to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes, as provided.
- Requires an institution of higher education to distribute to each college athlete a notice containing college athlete rights and would require the institution to post this notice in a conspicuous location frequented by college athletes, as specified.
- Prohibits an institution of higher education, and its employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, as defined, from retaliating against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete's rights provided under the CAP Act.
- Establishes the CAP Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research for purposes of the CAP Act.
- Establishes a 21-member CAP Panel comprised of appointed individuals to serve on four CAP Subpanels, as specified, for the administration of the CAP Act, as provided.
- Establishes the California Athlete Protection Fund under the administration of the CAP Panel, with moneys in the fund appropriated to the CAP Panel, upon appropriation of the Legislature, for purposes of the CAP Act, as provided.
- Provides that the provisions of the measure are severable.
- Makes various findings and declarations, as provided.
- Establishes various definitions, as provided.
For a detailed breakdown of AB 252 (Holden), see the Higher Education Committee analysis.
COMMENTS
Background- what is the NCAA? The NCAA is a voluntary, membership association of nearly 1,100 colleges and universities, athletics conferences and sports organizations that administer intercollegiate athletics. Although the NCAA promotes intercollegiate athletics and student-athletes, its core function is to create rules and ensure a level playing field in intercollegiate athletic competition. Representatives from member schools and conferences propose, debate, and vote on bylaws that govern the association. The NCAA enforces these rules, which govern, among other things, student-athlete financial aid, employment, and transfer eligibility.
The Student Athlete's Bill of Rights (SABR). Several of the protections provided for California student athletes contained under current law in the SABR are limited to universities that receive, on average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. This number is a minority of California colleges and universities, and has traditionally only included University of California (UC) Berkeley, Stanford, the University of Southern California (USC), and UC Los Angeles. The rapid increase in athletics media rights deals – and the lack of inflation growth built into current law – means that other universities with robust athletics programs might also soon fall under these specific provisions of SABR.
Fair market value compensation. Fair market value is defined in this bill as "an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic team's aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic team's revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team. This fair market value compensation calculation does not include revenue that is not allocated by sport."
Title IX. Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in all educational institutions that receive federal funding. This applies to all aspects of education and types of sex discrimination including athletics, sexual harassment and assault, harassment based on gender identity, science and math education, and facilities and course offerings.
CAP Program. The CAP Program and Panel established pursuant to this bill is a wide-ranging oversight body that is similar to the body proposed in AB 1435 (Gonzalez Fletcher), of 2017. This Program, located in the Office of Planning and Research, would include a 21-member panel comprised of individuals with specific backgrounds and experiences. The body would also have the authority to conduct investigations, issue subpoenas, create regulations, evaluate misconduct, and determine sanctions up to and including a lifetime ban from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
Opposition raised major concerns about the Cap Panel. The Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities (AICCU) wrote that, "the creation of the CAP Panel, funded by a mandatory fee structure imposed on all colleges and universities, creates a new layer of state bureaucracy. The powers of the panel are extensive, with duties and powers that include, but are not limited to, investigating complaints for violations of the bill provisions, issuing subpoenas, referring colleges and universities to the Attorney General for prosecution, and implementing cost-reduction efforts with other states and sports conferences. It is unclear why a new state entity is needed, or appropriate, to carry out the duties proposed for the CAP Panel, and what compelling reason there is to create a framework that further diminishes institutional athletics budgets to fund it."
According to the Author
According to the author, "there is a tremendous need for AB 252 because California's college athletes are governed by athletic associations that do not enforce health and safety standards to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death; and impose rules that have violated antitrust laws and have caused athletes economic harm. College athletes' athletic time demands result in unacceptably low federal graduation rates among Black college athletes that produce the most athletic revenue, there is a lack of transparency and accountability regarding important athletic program policies for college athletes and recruits, and there is a need to certify athlete agent representatives to help prevent college athletes from bad actors."
The author also noted that "college athletes are often put in harm's way as the institutions they represent prioritize winning over athlete safety. Coaches are incentivized to secure victories as it can lead to job stability and salary increments, while athletic trainers are often driven by the fear of being fired if they raise concerns that could potentially impact the team's performance. This misplaced emphasis on winning over athlete well-being is a concerning trend that requires immediate attention and resolution. It is an ongoing hazard to allow universities to police the treatment of their athletes when the universities' negligence and mistreatment are primary forces in harming the well-being of so many athletes."
Arguments in Support
The sponsor of AB 252 (Holden), the National College Players Association (NCPA), writes that "California colleges impose a collusive athlete compensation limit that is far below fair market compensation. The US Supreme Court's 9-0 ruling against the NCAA in NCAA v Alston affirms this fact. Collusive athlete pay limits violate antitrust laws and California colleges are participating in this illegal activity. This multibillion college sports enterprise imposes discriminatory practices that disproportionately harm Black athletes, while predominantly White coaches and administrators make millions of dollars. College athletes throughout predominantly White sports receive fair market compensation, but athletes in the only predominantly Black sports (FBS football and men's and women's basketball) do not. All college athletes should have the opportunity to receive fair market pay."
NCPA continues that "this racially unjust exploitation is amplified by the fact that Black men's basketball players, women's basketball players, and FBS football players have unacceptably low graduation rates – 42.6%, 62.7%, and 63.9%, respectively. Chronically low graduation rates among Black athletes persist as do the 40-50 hours/week athletes report spending on their sport. AB 252 (Holden) would be a powerful counterweight to structural obstacles that work against athletes' academic success because it would condition much of the pay on degree completion. This is a much better use for athletic revenue that will otherwise be spent on ever increasing raises for coaching salaries. Head football coaches at UC Berkeley, UCLA, Stanford, and USC are $4.75 million, $4.8 million, $8.9 million, and $11 million, respectively."
As noted by NCPA, this reenvisioning of the Degree Completion Fund would condition the payment of funds upon graduation, and is designed "for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year".
Arguments in Opposition
Multiple intuitions wrote in opposition the degree completion fund and fair market value compensation formula contained within AB 252. The UC Office of the President wrote that "AB 252 would create numerous problems for UC athletic programs, including diverting funds to a select group of UC student-athletes and limiting a program's ability to fund and support other athletic teams, notably women's teams. UC athletic departments use their revenues to fund student-athlete-related support for all teams, including meals, nutritional services, team travel, academic counseling, athletic trainers, medical personnel and treatment, team equipment, mental health counseling, and more. UC estimates that requirements outlined in AB 252 to create, manage, and distribute degree completion funds for qualifying student-athletes would have a fiscal impact in the range of $38 million to $40 million annually systemwide."
The University of Southern California wrote that "AB 252 would require a massive rerouting of funds away from sports that do not generate revenue—women's and Olympic sports—in order to make substantial payments to male student-athletes (specifically, football and men's basketball players). USC Athletics operates with the expectation that almost all of our 21 sports programs will not generate revenue to cover their costs. Instead, those programs rely on funding from the positive revenue generated by football and men's basketball. USC projects that AB 252's revenue scheme would direct payments to its male football and basketball student-athletes each year that would be nearly equal to the entire combined annual cost of operating its other 19 sports. The net result is that AB 252 will force USC and other California universities to cut funding to and potentially eliminate, non-revenue and lower-revenue sports programs. One of the devastating potential effects of this change would be to drive Olympic athletes out of California."
The concern about fund redistribution negatively impacting non-revenue generating sports is echoed by opposition from the Team USA Athletes' Commission, which wrote that "we are very concerned that the bill as drafted positively impacts a few athletes in revenue generating sports to the detriment of many. We believe that there must be a better solution to help athletes with high-market value access funding and enhance the student-athlete experience that does not have such significant negative impacts on the broad-based athletics system. Without requiring a specific reallocation of athletic department dollars, we believe the ramifications of the passage of AB 252 would likely result in the loss of Olympic and Paralympic sport opportunities. The redirection of compensation as proposed in this bill will likely result in the loss of sports and/or the reduction of other sport/athlete support."
The California State University (CSU) Chancellor's Office also expressed Title IX concerns, writing that "CSU athletic departments operate under tight budgets, and this reallocation of revenue would harm smaller, non-revenue generating athletic programs and the services provided to all student athletes. The revenue sharing framework may also create gender inequities among our student athletes and place CSU campuses out of compliance with federal Title IX regulations. Our analysis shows that the redistribution of revenue between male and female student athletes would be disproportional. At one campus, for example, male student athletes make up thirty-eight percent of all student athletes but would receive sixty-five percent of the funds. The majority of funds would go to football, men's basketball, and women's basketball players, which are only a small portion of all student athletes."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- Likely ongoing revenue losses to UC campuses with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Conference Division I to establish and provide required funding to a degree completion fund. Ongoing CAP program fees of about $3.5 million annually total, across all campuses, from the revenues UC generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division. Ongoing medical costs of about $2 million annually, from the revenues UC generates from intercollegiate athletics.
- Likely ongoing revenue losses to CSU campuses with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Conference Division I to establish and provide required funding to a degree completion fund. Ongoing CAP program fees of about $1.3 million annually total, across all campuses, from the revenues CSU generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division. Ongoing medical costs of an unknown, but potentially significant amount, from the revenues CSU generates from intercollegiate athletics.
- Ongoing CAP program fees of about $11,500 annually total for the California Community Colleges (CCC), across all campuses, from the revenues CCC generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division. Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of about $125,000 annually to CCC to distribute Title IX notifications and provide a financial and life skills workshop.
- Fiscal effects to private institutions of higher education (IHE) similar to those described above. Because this bill applies to both public and private IHEs, certain private institutions would also be required to pay into a degree completion fund, pay a CAP program fee, and incur other costs to otherwise comply with this bill.
VOTES
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 8-3-1
YES: Mike Fong, Addis, Arambula, Gabriel, Low, Ortega, Santiago, Weber
NO: Ta, Sanchez, Wallis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Irwin
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-3-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: May 18, 2023
CONSULTANT: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0000938
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 252
Author:(Holden) – As Amended Ver:March 6, 2023
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 8 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act, and makes expansive changes to college athletes’ rights, benefits, and protections.
Specifically, this bill, among other provisions:
- Requires certain institutions of higher education (IHE) to establish a degree completion fund.
This bill requires, beginning March 15, 2024, and every year thereafter, an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022, to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
To determine how much funding an IHE must contribute to the degree completion fund annually, the bill provides two options. Option 1: An IHE subtracts the intercollegiate athletic team’s aggregate athletic grants (also known as athletic scholarships) from one-half of the revenue generated by the intercollegiate athletic team. Option 2: An IHE contributes all revenue generated from intercollegiate athletics reported for an academic year that exceeds the revenue it reported for the 2021-22 academic year. An IHE may change between options from year to year.
The bill specifies that each eligible college athlete is to be paid up to $25,000 from the degree completion fund in an academic year. All degree completion fund payments above this amount are to be paid to a college athlete within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree. If a college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree within six years of full-time college enrollment, the college athlete must forfeit these funds.
The bill allows an IHE to adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations to comply with Title IX, described in more detail in Comment 6.
- Creates the CAP program.
This bill creates the CAP program at the Office of Planning and Research. The program is to be administered by a director, who may hire staff, and led by a 21-member CAP panel with four subpanels: a general subpanel, a health and safety subpanel, a recruiting transparency subpanel, and a certification subpanel. The CAP program is to be funded by fees paid by IHE athletics programs, with a progressive fee schedule based on the athletic program revenue. The CAP program is to adopt standards in various areas related to college athletics.
- Requires certain IHEs to pay certain medical expenses of college athletes.
This bill requires an IHE with annual revenues generated from college athletics in excess of $20 million to pay for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period after the athlete leaves the IHE. The bill requires an IHE with annual revenues generated from college athletics in excess of $50 million to offer portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution, pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period after the athlete leaves the IHE.
- Requires IHEs to perform various other duties related to college athlete welfare.
This bill requires IHEs to perform other duties, such as providing certain Title IX notifications to students, providing a financial and life skills workshop to student athletes, and complying with certain health and safety standards and other requirements the CAP program develops as required by this bill. In addition, the bill expands anti-retaliation statute in current law for college athletes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- University of California (UC)
- Likely ongoing revenue losses to UC campuses with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Conference Division I to establish and provide required funding to a degree completion fund.
Costs would depend on whether a UC campus opts to use Option 1 or Option 2 to calculate its required annual contributions to their degree completion fund. Using Option 1, UC estimates losses in revenue it would otherwise have generated through Division I intercollegiate athletics but would instead contribute to the degree completion fund would total in the tens of millions of dollars annually. Using Option 2, if a UC campus did not generate more total revenue through intercollegiate athletics than it did in the 2021-22 academic year, it would not be required to contribute any funding to its degree completion fund. However, although revenue estimates for the 2022-23 academic year are not yet available, UC athletics revenue has been growing over time. Revenue for UCLA, for example, will increase significantly when it joins the Big Ten conference in 2024.
In the 2021-22 academic year, UC’s Division I sports generated about $250 million and total revenue generated by UC intercollegiate athletics was about $380 million.
- Ongoing CAP program fees of about $3.5 million annually, from the revenues UC generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division.
- Ongoing medical costs of about $2 million annually, from the revenues UC generates from intercollegiate athletics. These costs would only be assessed at institutions with athletic programs generating annual revenue of $50 million or more for more expansive medical benefits, and institutions with athletic programs generating annual revenue of $20 million or more for certain medical benefits. At UC, UCLA and UC Berkeley generate more than $50 million annually and UC Davis, UC Santa Barbara, and UC San Diego generate more than $20 million annually.
- Unknown General Fund costs to UC to distribute Title IX notifications, provide a financial and life skills workshop, and comply with the health and safety standards and other requirements the CAP program requires or develops as required by this bill.
- California State University (CSU)
- Likely ongoing revenue losses to CSU campuses with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in an NCAA Conference Division I to establish and provide required funding to a degree completion fund.
Costs would depend on whether a CSU campus opts to use Option 1 or Option 2 to calculate its required annual contributions to their degree completion fund. This decision would likely depend on the unique circumstances at each CSU campus.
- Ongoing CAP program fees of about $1.3 million annually, from the revenues CSU generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division.
- Ongoing medical costs of an unknown, but potentially significant amount, from the revenues CSU generates from intercollegiate athletics. These costs would only be assessed at institutions with athletic programs generating annual revenue of $50 million or more for more expansive medical benefits, and institutions with athletic programs generating annual revenue of $20 million or more for certain medical benefits. At CSU, CSU San Diego and CSU Fresno generate more than $50 million annually, and CSU Fullerton, CSU Long Beach, CSU Northridge, CSU Sacramento, CSU San Jose, and CSU San Luis Obispo each generate more than $20 million annually.
- Unknown General Fund costs to CSU to distribute Title IX notifications, offer a financial and life skills workshop, and comply with the health and safety standards and other requirements the CAP program requires or develops as required by this bill.
- California Community Colleges (CCC)
- Ongoing CAP program fees of about $11,500 annually, from the revenues CCC generates from intercollegiate athletics. All intercollegiate athletic programs would be assessed this fee, regardless of division.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of about $125,000 annually to CCC to distribute Title IX notifications and provide a financial and life skills workshop.
- Unknown, ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs to CCC to comply with the health and safety standards and other requirements the CAP program requires or develops as required by this bill.
The state would need to reimburse these Proposition 98 General Fund costs to CCC, if the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill’s requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate.
- Fiscal effects to private IHEs similar to those described above. Because this bill applies to both public and private IHEs, certain private institutions would also be required to pay into a degree completion fund, pay a CAP program fee, and incur other costs to otherwise comply with this bill. IHEs with the largest revenues include Stanford University and the University of Southern California (USC). In 2021, Stanford University’s revenue was $157 million and USC’s revenue was $188 million. In addition, USC will move into the Big Ten conference with UCLA, which will result in additional revenue.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the National College Players Association, the sponsor of this bill:
California college athletes are subject to exploitative college sports governance rules that prioritize university revenue over their physical, academic, and financial well-being. These colleges receive state tax-exemptions on lucrative athletics revenue and many directly receive state funds. California has the power and duty to address key issues that harm its college athletes.
Currently, it is not against NCAA rules to return an athlete with a concussion to the same game, sexually abuse an athlete, or kill an athlete in a hazardous workout. All of these scenarios have happened among California colleges and will continue to happen unless AB 252 is signed into law.
In addition, California colleges impose a collusive athlete compensation limit that is far below fair market compensation. The US Supreme Court’s 9-0 ruling against the NCAA in NCAA v Alston affirms this fact. Collusive athlete pay limits violate antitrust laws and California colleges are participating in this illegal activity. This multibillion college sports enterprise imposes discriminatory practices that disproportionately harm Black athletes, while predominantly White coaches and administrators make millions of dollars. College athletes throughout predominantly White sports receive fair market compensation, but athletes in the only predominantly Black sports (FBS football and men’s and women’s basketball) do not. All college athletes should have the opportunity to receive fair market pay.
- NCAA. NCAA is a nonprofit, voluntary membership association of nearly 1,300 colleges and universities, athletics conferences, and sports organizations that administers intercollegiate athletics. Representatives from member schools and conferences propose, debate, and vote on bylaws that govern the association. The NCAA enforces these rules, which govern, among other things, student-athlete financial aid, employment, and transfer eligibility. The NCAA competitions take place among colleges and universities that share the same division, of which there are three. Division I and Division II schools offer athletic scholarships, while Division III schools may or may not. Generally, larger schools compete in Division I and smaller schools in Divisions II and III. In California, 58 schools compete in one of the NCAA divisions.
With regard to student athlete compensation, NCAA bylaws determine student athletes may receive financial aid only as permitted by the NCAA, which typically is capped at the cost of attending the university at which a student athlete competes.
- College Athletics Revenues and Expenditures. Like NCAA, all IHEs that compete in NCAA in California are considered nonprofit entities. According to NCAA, recent data indicate Division I athletic programs generate about $16 billion in revenues annually, and men’s basketball and football generate the vast majority of these revenues. Of this total revenue, 35% is spent on administrative and coach compensation, 18% on facilities, 18% is returned to college athletes in the form of athletics scholarships, and 1% is spent on medical treatment and insurance protections. In California, head football coach salaries at UC Berkeley, UCLA, Stanford University, and USC are $4.8 million, $4.8 million, $8.9 million, and $11 million, respectively.
According to the NCAA, athletic programs are supported by various fund sources, including revenue generated by athletics programs (such as ticket sales, media rights, and merchandise), institutional and government support, and student fees. While some college athletics programs are revenue generating and self-supporting, such as football and basketball, many athletic programs, such as wrestling, fencing, and archery, for example, generally are not. According to IHEs, revenue generating sports often subsidize non-revenue generating sports. Research has found that college athletes that benefit from this practice are more likely to be white and more likely to come from higher-income neighborhoods than college athletes who compete in revenue generating sports. (Who Profits From Amateurism? Rent-Sharing in Modern College Sports, National Bureau of Economic Research, 2020.)
- Name, Image, and Likeness. “Name, image, and likeness compensation” pertains to the ability to profit from the use of an athlete’s name or appearance. The term is broad and could include revenue from a video game with a player resembling a student athlete or a sponsorship agreement with a merchandiser. However, it also can apply to less high-profile activities, such as income from coaching a summer sports camp.
On June 30, 2021, the NCAA Division I Board of Directors approved an interim name, image, and likeness policy. This new policy allows all NCAA Division I, II, and III student-athletes to be compensated for their NIL as of July 1, 2021, regardless of whether their state has an NIL law in place or not. California was the first state to establish an NIL policy, as passed by SB 206 (Skinner), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2019, and strongly influenced the implementation of NCAA’s policy.
Various organizations were in opposition to SB 206, including many who are in opposition to this bill. When Governor Newsom signed SB 206, the Pac-12 wrote, “The Pac-12 is disappointed in the passage of SB 206… [it] will likely reduce resources and opportunities for student-athletes in Olympic sports and have negative disparate impact on female student-athletes.”
- Anti-Trust Issues. In NCAA v. Alston (January 2021), the Supreme Court found in a 9-0 ruling that by limiting education-related compensation that college athletes are permitted to receive from their IHEs, the NCAA is acting in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which prohibits any “contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce.” In other words, that the NCAA’s restrictions on college athlete pay are collusive and violate anti-trust law. In addition, the National Labor Relations Board announced earlier this year that it plans to pursue unfair labor practice charges against USC, the Pac 12, and the NCAA as single and joint employers of Football Bowl Subdivision football players and Division I men’s and women’s basketball players.
- Title IX Substantial Proportionality. Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in all educational institutions that receive federal funding. This applies to all aspects of education and types of sex discrimination including athletics, sexual harassment and assault, harassment based on gender identity, science and math education, and facilities and course offerings. With regard to athletics, Title IX substantial proportionality means an IHE’s ratio of female athletic participation must be close to the ratio of female enrollment at the institution. Title IX also requires that female and male college athletes receive athletics scholarship dollars proportional to their participation.
- Opposition. This bill is opposed by the UC Office of the President, the CSU Chancellor’s Office, the Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities (an organization that represents private, nonprofit postsecondary institutions), and others. The opposition indicates the bill would result in cuts to non-revenue generating sports and could have Title IX implications.
- Prior Legislation. AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019, authorizes postsecondary schools to establish degree completion funds and directs them to develop, post, and disseminate specified information regarding existing student athlete rights. The bill also prohibits schools from retaliating against student athletes who report violations of student athletes' rights.
SB 1401 (Bradford), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill as it created a similar degree completion fund. SB 1401 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Mike Fong, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 252 (
Author:Holden) – As Amended Ver:March 6, 2023
SUBJECT: The College Athlete Protection Act
SUMMARY: Establishes the College Athlete Protection Act for purposes of providing various rights, benefits, and protections to college athletes. Specifically, this bill:
- Creates the College Athlete Protection (CAP) Act.
Definitions
- Establishes the following definitions for the CAP Act:
- “Affiliated medical personnel” means individuals who provide medical, rehabilitation, or athletic training diagnoses, opinions, or services to college athletes, in collaboration with an institution of higher education (IHE). “Affiliated medical personnel” include, but are not limited to, physicians, mental health professionals, physical therapists, and athletic trainers. Individuals do not have to receive compensation from an institution of higher education to be affiliated medical personnel;
- “Aggregate athletic grants” means the total amount of athletic grants that an IHE annually reports pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act (EADA) to the United States Department of Education (USDE) for each intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. “Aggregate athletic grants” shall not include any difference in athletic grant amounts based on cost of attendance disparities between an institution’s instate or out-of-state college athletes;
- “Athletic association” means any organization that is responsible for governing intercollegiate athletic programs;
- “Athletic grant” means an athletics scholarship or grant that an IHE pays to a college athlete;
- “Athletic program” means an intercollegiate athletic program at an IHE;
- “CAP Fund” means the Fund established as specified;
- “CAP Panel” means the Panel established as specified;
- “CAP Program” means the Program established as specified;
- “College athlete” means a student who is enrolled at an IHE and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an institution does not meet the definition of college athlete;
- “Fair market value compensation” means an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic team’s aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic team’s revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team;
- “IHE” or “institution” means any campus of the University of California (UC), the California State University (CSU), the California Community Colleges (CCC), an independent institution of higher education, as defined in Section 66010, or a private postsecondary educational institution, as defined in Section 94858, that maintains an athletic program;
- “Intercollegiate athlete” means a California resident who is enrolled at an out-of-state college or university and is listed as a member of an intercollegiate athletics team at the out-of-state college or university. A student’s participation in club or intramural sports at an out-of-state college or university does not meet the definition of intercollegiate athlete;
- “NCAA” means the National Collegiate Athletic Association;
- “NIL” means the use of a college athlete’s name, image, and likeness;
- “Office for Civil Rights” means the Office for Civil Rights within the USDE;
- “Revenue” means annual intercollegiate athletics revenue as calculated and reported pursuant to the federal Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act by an institution of higher education to the USDE; and,
- “Title IX” means Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.).
Legislative findings
- Establishes the following findings and declarations of the Legislature:
- The safety, transparency, and quality education for college athletes should be prioritized for athletic programs, conferences, and associations and the state;
- IHEs exist to educate all students. Once athletic recruits sign an agreement to attend a particular university, they should feel confident that they will be able to complete their degrees regardless of sports-related injury or poor athletic performance;
- To increase graduation rates and ensure economic equity, institutions of higher education need to establish a degree completion fund for each college athlete with specified rules and manage that fund as a fiduciary for the college athlete without charging the college athlete for any costs incurred;
- The State needs to design and enforce vital safety standards and return-to-play protocols to protect college athletes from serious injuries, sexual abuse, and death;
- Student sexual abuse is an important issue on college campuses. Providing information and notice to college athletes about their rights under Title IX and other pertinent statutes is necessary to ensure their physical and psychological safety;
- College athletes face intense pressure to return to play when injured. Intercollegiate sports programs, including coaches and team medical staff, should collaborate to ensure that a college athlete’s interests are always put first;
- Athletic programs must have a health care model that vests autonomous medical management decisions in primary athletic health care providers, such as team physicians and athletic trainers. These providers, their decision-making related to the health and safety of college athletes, and their health care delivery should be protected from outside, nonmedical influences;
- To prevent college athletes from being left to pay an excessive financial burden, institutions of higher education should pay medical costs for college athletes’ sports-related injuries;
- Transparency in athletic recruiting is a high priority given the complexities created by various athletic program policies, including the use of a college athlete’s NIL. Institutions of higher education should disclose to college athletes the financial benefits and risks associated with NIL agreements;
- A proper oversight system should be developed to ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place to avoid the exploitation of college athletes; and
- Intercollegiate athletic laws and rules in other states affect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes.
Degree Completion Fund
- Requires an IHE to establish a degree completion fund for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year.
- Specifies that an IHE must use degree completion funds to compensate each college athlete who receives an athletic grant at the institution, but does not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year, in a total amount that provides fair market compensation to the college athlete for the academic year.
- Requires that a college athlete on the same intercollegiate athletics team at an institution of higher education during the same academic year will be designated an equal payment from that institution’s degree completion fund for that academic year.
- Specifies that all degree completion funds of up to $25,000 must be paid to each college athlete for their participation on the intercollegiate athletics team in an academic year.
- Commencing on or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, payments described in paragraph 7) must be made in an amount based on the institution’s revenue reported for the previous academic year.
- Requires an institution to not use payment designations in its degree completion fund as a reason to reduce or cancel athletic grants provided to any college athlete.
- Specifies that all degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to subdivision 7) designated for a college athlete must be paid within 60 days of the college athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
- All degree completion fund payments designated for a college athlete who transferred to another institution of higher education or an out-of-state college or university must be paid within 60 days of the athlete earning a baccalaureate degree or submitting proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program.
- Requires an IHE to accurately account its aggregate athletic grants and revenue. An institution must not undercount, overcount, or fail to accurately categorize its aggregate athletic grants or revenue.
- The CAP Panel may audit an IHE’s aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods, materials, and information to ensure compliance, as specified. This audit may include review of the institution’s aggregate athletic grant and revenue accounting methods reported by the institution in its previous revenue reports. This will be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Declares that all degree completion fund payments above the amount determined pursuant to 7) above designated for a college athlete will be forfeited if the college athlete does not complete a baccalaureate degree program within six years of full-time college enrollment or submit proof, as determined by the CAP Panel, of having a severe medical condition that prevents the college athlete from completing a baccalaureate degree program. All forfeited funds must be deposited in the institution’s degree completion fund and used for degree completion fund payments to college athletes pursuant to this section.
- In making annual degree completion fund payment designations, an institution of higher education may:
- Opt to only use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds its revenue reported for the 2021–2022 academic year. Notwithstanding 5) above, if the institution uses this option, the institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as all of the conditions are satisfied, as specified.
- The institution will use the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to 12(a) above in its entirety, to make degree completion fund payment designations pursuant to this paragraph;
- The institution will determine, for an academic year, the percentage of the total fair market compensation that college athletes on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution represent of the total fair market compensation owed to all college athletes at the institution, regardless of sport. College athletes on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, shall collectively receive this percentage of the difference in revenue calculated pursuant to 12(a) for the academic year;
- Each college athlete on the same intercollegiate team, regardless of sport, at the institution who qualifies for a degree completion fund payment designation pursuant to this paragraph shall receive an equal share of moneys calculated; and,
- Degree completion fund payment designations made pursuant to this paragraph will not result in any college athlete being designated more than fair market value compensation for any academic year.
- Specifies that an institution may opt to pay CAP Program fees before using revenue described in 12(a) for degree completion fund payment designations for college athletes.
- Requires that on or before June 15, 2025, and on or before every June 15 thereafter, each IHE must disclose publicly on its internet website, to its college athletes, to prospective college athletes it is recruiting for intercollegiate athletics, and to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, as specified, whether the institution, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the subsequent academic year, will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to subdivision 5) above.
- Each IHE will include the information disclosed pursuant to 12(c) above in all of its written athletic grant agreement offers.
- On or before February 1, 2024, each institution of higher education shall disclose, for college athlete degree completion fund payment designations in the 2023–24 academic year, whether the institution will use revenue calculated pursuant to this subdivision or provide fair market value compensation to qualifying college athletes pursuant to 5) above.
- Opt to only use all revenue reported for an academic year that exceeds its revenue reported for the 2021–2022 academic year. Notwithstanding 5) above, if the institution uses this option, the institution does not have to pay any remaining fair market value compensation owed to a college athlete into the degree completion fund for the academic year in which the institution uses this option so long as all of the conditions are satisfied, as specified.
- Specifies that degree completion funds are the property of college athletes and not the property of institutions of higher education. Institutions of higher education will have a fiduciary duty to its college athletes to manage these funds.
- Establishes that, if an IHE deems it necessary, the institution may adjust the amounts of degree completion fund payment designations only to comply with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics, so long as all of the following conditions are met:
- The aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institution’s college athletes is not reduced.
- The institution is in compliance with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
- On or before March 15, 2024, and on or before every March 15 thereafter, the institution publishes on its internet website and submits to the CAP Panel a written explanation about why an adjustment made pursuant to this subdivision is necessary to comply with Title IX proportionality comparisons in athletics, and includes both of the following in this written explanation:
- Published communications, determinations, and rulings by the Office for Civil Rights used as the basis for the adjustment, as applicable.
- The amount of funds in aggregate and per college athlete directed from college athletes in one sport to college athletes in another sport, the names of each sport involved in the adjustment, and the corresponding fair market value compensation paid to college athletes in each sport involved in the adjustment. This subparagraph shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Declares that degree completion fund payment designations or payments will not serve as evidence of an employment relationship.
- Specifies that, within 15 days of making degree completion fund payment designations, each IHE will submit annually to the CAP Panel a list of all college athletes qualifying for a degree completion fund payment designation, each qualifying college athlete’s intercollegiate team, the amount paid to each qualifying college athlete, and the aggregate amount paid to qualifying college athletes by team. This subdivision shall be implemented only in a manner that protects the personally identifiable information of college athletes consistent with state and federal privacy laws.
- Establishes that these provisions will apply only to a IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Conference Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022.
Required notices
- Establishes that an institution of higher education will distribute a notice to each college athlete at the institution containing all of the following information:
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to Title IX of the federal Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.);
- An individual notice stating: “All students have the right to report a sexual assault, without retaliation, to law enforcement, the office of the Attorney General, the USDE’s Office for Civil Rights, (insert name of institution)’s mandated reporters, (insert name of institution)’s Title IX office, and the College Athlete Protection Program director.”;
- A college athlete’s rights pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1092(f));
- A college athlete’s rights, as specified; and,
- Additional rights that the state affords specifically to college athletes.
- Requires the notice distributed pursuant 18) above will contain sufficient information to enable a college athlete to file a complaint for a violation of any of the rights identified in the notice. This information must include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
- The telephone number used by the Office for Civil Rights for complaint reporting intake, and the telephone number of the Office for Civil Rights’ regional enforcement office;
- The internet website address of the Office for Civil Rights’ online complaint form for Title IX complaint reporting;
- The internet website address used by the USDE for reporting violations of the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act , as specified;
- A list of the job classifications employed by the institution that are deemed mandated reporters, as specified, and the obligations of these mandated reporters;
- The telephone number and internet website address for the CAP Program, once the program is operational pursuant to this chapter; and,
- The telephone number of the Attorney General.
- Specifies that an IHE will post on campus in conspicuous locations frequented by college athletes, including, but not limited to, the institution’s athletic training facilities, the notice distributed pursuant to this section.
- Requires that, upon the commencement of each academic year, the IHE will provide each college athlete a copy of the notice described in this section.
CAP Program
- Establishes the CAP Program as a program in the Office of Planning and Research.
- Specifies that the CAP Program will be administered by the CAP Panel. The CAP Panel will be housed in the Office of Planning and Research.
- Establishes the 21-member CAP Panel shall be appointed as follows:
- Eleven members appointed by the Governor;
- Five members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly; and,
- Five members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Specifies that the 21-member CAP Panel will consist of at least four former college athletes with experience in college athlete protection advocacy.
- Specifies that CAP Panel members will be voluntary positions that receive per diem and paid travel accommodations, as determined by the CAP Program director. One member will be appointed by a majority vote of the CAP Panel’s members to serve as chairperson of the CAP Panel.
- Requires the Office of Planning and Research to hire and establish compensation for a CAP Program director. The CAP Program director will be a full-time position and serve a six-year term that may be renewed with no term limits. The CAP Program director will hire additional staff to assist in the implementation and enforcement of this chapter. The CAP Program director, within 10 days of being hired, will initiate staff hiring activities with the goal of completing hiring activities by April 15, 2024. Additionally:
- The CAP Program director will provide CAP Panel members with the information necessary to fulfill their duties pursuant to this chapter;
- The CAP Panel will consult with the CAP Program director when establishing CAP Program regulations, standards, and policies pursuant to this chapter; and,
- The CAP Program director may engage with intercollegiate athletics stakeholders, including state and federal legislators and agencies, to provide information and encourage policies and action to support the implementation, operation, and expansion of college athlete rights and protections pursuant to this chapter.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel member on the initial 21-member board shall serve a four-year, five-year, or six-year term, as determined by the appointing authority. Additionally:
- It is the intent of the Legislature that the 21-member CAP Panel’s members serve staggered terms;
- All subsequent appointments made after the initial 21-member CAP Panel is appointed will be six-year terms with no term limits; and,
- A CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director may be reappointed to their position or appointed to a new position as specified.
- Specifies that a CAP Panel member and the CAP Program director must not have served, within five years of being appointed as a CAP Panel member or hired as the CAP Program director, respectively, as an affiliated medical personnel, employee, or member of a governing body of an IHE, an out-of-state college or university that has an intercollegiate sports program, an intercollegiate sports conference, or an intercollegiate sports association.
- Requires the racial, ethnic, gender, and geographic diversity of California to be considered by the appointing authority when appointing CAP Panel members.
- Specifies that the CAP Panel will consist of members who shall serve on the following CAP Subpanels, according to their expertise:
- The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in sports medicine and traumatic brain injury;
- One member with expertise in athletic training or physical therapy in sports;
- One member with expertise in mental health;
- One member with expertise in workplace health and safety compliance and investigations;
- One member with expertise in sexual misconduct investigations; and,
- Two members who are former college athletes with experience in athlete health and safety issues.
- The CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in contract law;
- One member with expertise in college sports recruiting;
- One member with expertise in college athlete publicity rights law; and,
- One member who is a former college athlete with experience in the recruiting process.
- The CAP Certification Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in sports agent certification;
- One member with expertise in financial advising standards;
- One member with expertise in marketing standards; and,
- One member who is a former college athlete with experience in agreements related to CAP certification duties.
- The General CAP Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- One member with expertise in health care administration, medical claims, and the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, as specified;
- One member with expertise in compliance with Title IX in athletics;
- One member who is a certified public accountant with expertise in corporate financial audits and corporate compliance investigations;
- One member with expertise in arbitration;
- One member with expertise in grievance and appeals processes; and,
- One member with expertise in producing educational materials.
- The CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, which shall consist of all of the following:
- Establishes that the CAP Panel will have all of the following enforcement duties and powers:
- Receive, track, and investigate complaints regarding reported violations, as specified;
- Issue subpoenas, if necessary, to obtain information necessary to carry out its duties;
- Require an IHE and out-of-state college or university, as specified, to provide athletic grants, make payments for college athlete medical coverage and expenses, and provide other remedies that the CAP Panel deems necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter;
- Refer individuals, institutions of higher education, and out-of-state colleges and universities that are subject to this chapter who do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy imposed as specified to the Attorney General for prosecution, as appropriate;
- Establishes that the Attorney General will have the authority to prosecute individuals and entities that do not comply with a CAP Panel penalty or remedy, as appropriate.
- Determine the best practice guidelines, health and safety standards, policies, or other informational materials that may benefit high school athletes, high school sports programs, and the California Interscholastic Federation, and make them available and easily accessible to the public;
- At its discretion, implement collaborative and cost-reduction efforts with other states, local governments, intercollegiate sports conferences, intercollegiate sports associations, or other stakeholders to help protect the well-being of intercollegiate athletes in other states;
- Hold quarterly meetings;
- Distribute, on or before January 15, 2025, and each year thereafter, an annual report to each IHE, intercollegiate athletic conference, athletic association, and the Legislature, as specified, on the state of college athlete protections established pursuant to this chapter;
- Communicate with the Legislature about ways to improve these provisions; and,
- Upon appropriation by the Legislature, use funds in the CAP Fund to execute its duties and powers under this chapter.
- Specifies that, in addition to any other remedy or penalty authorized by law, individuals who violate this chapter may be subject to remedies and penalties established pursuant to regulations adopted by the CAP Panel. These regulations will include a system to appeal the CAP Panel’s rulings. Penalties and remedies established by the CAP Panel may include any, or any combination, of the following:
- Training to help prevent future violations;
- Temporary or permanent prohibition from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education;
- Other penalties and remedies imposed by the CAP Panel; and,
- The CAP Panel shall consider all of the following factors when imposing penalties and remedies for a violation of this chapter:
- The number and duration of violations;
- Whether the violation was the result of an intentional or negligent action; and,
- The nature and extent of harm caused by the violation.
Health and Safety Standards, CAP Health and Safety Subpanel
- Requires an IHE to meet the health and safety standards that are developed, published, adopted, and enforced by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel established as specified. In developing the health and safety standards, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel must do all of the following:
- Consult with athletic associations, the UC, the CSU, and the athlete health and safety advocacy community;
- Consider existing health and safety guidelines of relevant entities, including, but not limited to, the NCAA, intercollegiate athletic conferences, professional sports leagues, and the National Athletic Trainers’ Association; and,
- Develop health and safety standards to prevent serious sports-related injuries, abuse, health conditions, and death, including, but not limited to, those related to traumatic brain injury, sexual harassment and abuse, athlete mistreatment, interpersonal violence, mental health, heat illnesses, sickle cell trait, rhabdomyolysis, asthma, cardiac health, weight management, and pain management.
- Specifies that all reports of suspected health and safety violations at an institution of higher education that occur on or after January 1, 2023, but before the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel adopts the health and safety standards pursuant to this section, will be submitted to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice must forward the reports of suspected health and safety violations to the CAP Program director once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the health and safety standards adopted as specified.
- Requires, within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel’s health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to 34) above, an IHE to comply with all of the following:
- Inform its athletic program employees and affiliated medical personnel of their responsibilities established pursuant to the standards;
- Inform college athletes of their rights and protections established pursuant to the standards, and inform college athletes of their right to report suspected violations of the standards to the athletic program personnel of their choice, the Attorney General, and, once the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel commences enforcing the standards adopted pursuant to this section, the CAP Program director; and,
- Designate at least one employee to oversee compliance with this section and to serve as a point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel and submit to the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel the point of contact’s email address, telephone number, and mailing address. If the institution of higher education fails to designate the point of contact for the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel, the institution’s athletic director shall serve as the point of contact.
- Notwithstanding 35(a) above, the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel may require institutions of higher education to comply with the health and safety standards earlier than 90 days after they are adopted if the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel determines, in its discretion, that such compliance is important to prevent great harm to college athletes.
- Requires, within 90 days of implementation of the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel’s health and safety standards developed, published, and adopted pursuant to 34) above, an IHE to comply with all of the following:
- Specifies that the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel will have all of the following duties and powers:
- Require transparency from IHEs on injury treatment options for college athletes;
- Provide up-to-date information about sports-related health risks;
- Ensure that physician, physical therapy, and athletic training records for all treatments of a college athlete by athletic program personnel in the course of the college athlete’s participation in an athletic program are maintained for a period of 10 years after the college athlete leaves the athletic program. These records shall be provided to the college athlete or former college athlete in a timely manner upon request;
- Ensure college athletes, athletic program personnel, and affiliated medical personnel are informed about their rights and responsibilities as specified;
- Prevent deceptive or fraudulent practices that harm college athletes;
- Calibrate mandates in consideration of athletic program size and resources when it deems it appropriate or necessary;
- Require assistance from institutions of higher education to help survey college athletes and athletic program personnel, as necessary, under the CAP Program;
- Conduct site visits and audits of athletic departments, as necessary, to verify compliance as specified;
- Maintain and make publicly available on its internet website a list of individuals who are banned as specified from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at institutions of higher education; and,
- Adopt regulations to implement and enforce this section.
- Specifies that all athletic program personnel, including employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel, must report suspected violations of this section to the president or chancellor of the institution, the athletic director of the institution, and the CAP Program director.
- Specifies that an individual shall be banned for life from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any IHE if the individual has been found by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel or a court of law to have done any of the following:
- Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death due to noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted as specified;
- Caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death by failing to address noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section;
- Threatened or retaliated against a college athlete or any individual or entity that reported noncompliance with a standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death; and,
- Obstructed or knowingly provided false information related to an investigation of noncompliance with a health and safety standard adopted pursuant to this section that caused a life-threatening medical condition, sexual abuse, or death.
- Requires that, before a ban may be imposed pursuant to paragraph 38) above, the individual will be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
- Requires any individual or entity designated by an IHE to investigate allegations of a violation of these provisions that knowingly omits evidence, conceals or obscures wrongdoing, undermines an investigation, or fails to carry out the responsibilities required by this section may be subject to a penalty imposed by the CAP Health and Safety Subpanel. Additionally:
- Before a penalty may be imposed as specified, the individual or entity must be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge at which the individual or entity shall have the right to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
- Provides that, except as determined by a college athlete, affiliated medical personnel will have the autonomous, unchallengeable authority to determine medical management and return-to-play decisions for the college athlete. Coaches and athletic program personnel who are not affiliated medical personnel must not give the college athlete medical advice or attempt to influence or disregard affiliated medical personnel decisions.
- Requires that affiliated medical personnel will be supervised and held accountable to comply with the health and safety standards adopted pursuant to this section by an institution of higher education’s office or department that is independent of the institution’s athletic department.
Medical expenses
- Requires an IHE that reports $20,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE will be financially responsible for the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the two-year period beginning on the date on which the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 43) above will not apply to a college athlete who transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state higher education institution and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 43) above will not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Requires an IHE that reports $50,000,000 or more in annual revenue to the USDE to comply with both of the following:
- Offer nationally portable primary medical insurance to each college athlete who is enrolled at the institution. This insurance will be paid for by the institution. The institution must not discourage a college athlete from accepting this insurance; and,
- Pay the out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses of each college athlete at the institution, and during the four-year period beginning on the date the college athlete officially becomes a former college athlete.
- 44) above will not apply to a college athlete that transfers to another institution of higher education or out-of-state college or university and participates on an intercollegiate athletics team at that institution; and,
- 44) above will not apply to a college athlete’s medical expenses for medical conditions unrelated to the college athlete’s intercollegiate sports participation that arise after the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility.
- Establishes that, if a college athlete at an IHE that is responsible for the college athlete’s medical expenses, as specified, chooses to receive medical care that is not provided as specified or is not otherwise provided or paid for by the institution, the institution will offer to the college athlete to pay an amount that is the lesser of the following:
- The out-of-pocket expenses for that medical care; and,
- The amount the institution would have paid if the college athlete had received the medical care provided or paid for by the institution.
- Requires an IHE to pay for a college athlete to obtain an independent second opinion on an athletic program-related injury or medical condition endured by the college athlete. Additionally:
- IHE personnel and affiliated medical personnel must not withhold a college athlete’s medical or athletic training records if the college athlete requests that those records be released to obtain an independent second opinion as specified, or otherwise impede a college athlete’s right to obtain an independent second opinion.
47) Requires that, no later than three days after the end of a college athlete’s team season in the final year of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or in the case of a transfer, no later than three days after the institution’s receipt of a college athlete’s notice of intent to transfer to another college or university, an institution of higher education must provide the college athlete notice of, and an opportunity to undergo, a physical examination within or independent of the institution for the purpose of diagnosing an athletic program-related injury or medical condition.
- Institution of higher education personnel and affiliated medical personnel must not discourage a college athlete or former college athlete from obtaining a physical examination; and,
- A former college athlete will be provided no less than 60 days to complete a physical examination.
Title IX compliance evaluation
- Requires that, on or before July 1 of each year, an IHE must comply with both of the following:
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Whether financial aid is provided on a substantially proportional basis to the number of the institution’s male and female college athletes;
- Whether the institution’s male and female college athletes receive equivalent nonfinancial aid athletic treatment, benefits, and opportunities;
- Whether the interests and abilities of the institution’s male and female college athletes are equally effectively accommodated. Evaluation as specified will include measures of the institution’s performance on each part of the three-part test described in the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations published on December 11, 1979; and,
- The institution’s determination about whether it is in compliance with Title IX in athletics and the specific indicators that provide evidence of its compliance or noncompliance.
- Publish the evaluation on a publicly accessible internet website of the institution.
- Complete an evaluation of its compliance with Title IX in athletics and the Office for Civil Rights’ Title IX in athletics regulations. The evaluation must include an aggregate analysis to determine all of the following:
- Requires that, at the beginning of the evaluation published pursuant to 47) above, the institution shall include the following statement: “To submit a Title IX complaint, you may contact” (contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator) and state the appropriate contact information of the Office for Civil Rights and the institution’s Title IX coordinator.
- Requires that an individual who is determined by the CAP Panel in an administrative hearing to have knowingly refused to comply with these provisions, or knowingly provided misleading information or knowingly omitted information that created an inaccuracy in an evaluation will be banned from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
- Before a ban may be imposed, an individual must be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation as specified.
Six year athletic grants, punishment for program reduction
- Requires an IHE with an intercollegiate sports team that participated in a NCAA Division I sport on or after January 1, 2022, or becomes a member of a NCAA Division I sport thereafter, and that provides a college athlete with an athletic grant to provide the college athlete with an athletic grant for each subsequent year in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution for up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. The athletic grant must be provided regardless of the college athlete’s lack of participation due to injury or poor athletic performance on an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution.
- The amount of an athletic grant provided to a college athlete each subsequent award year will be no less than the sum of the amount of the athletic grant provided to the college athlete for the previous year plus the amount of any increase in the cost of attendance at the institution from the previous year to the subsequent award year.
- Specifies that a college athlete who transfers to an IHE will receive an athletic grant in an amount determined pursuant to 50) above for up to one academic year beyond the college athlete’s remaining intercollegiate athletics eligibility in which the college athlete is enrolled at the institution, or until the college athlete receives a baccalaureate degree from the institution, whichever occurs first. Additionally:
- Unless a college athlete is granted a leave of absence in accordance with the IHE’s leave of absence policies that apply to the general student body, 50) above will only apply to a college athlete who is enrolled as a full-time student for each regular academic term of an award year;
- 50) above will not apply to a college athlete who provides a written notice of voluntary withdrawal from an intercollegiate athletics team at the institution, or who fails to consistently participate in mandatory team athletics activities for nonmedical reasons after having been fully informed that their participation in those activities is mandatory; and,
- 50) above will not apply to a college athlete who meets any of the following:
- Is found by the institution of higher education to have committed academic fraud or other misconduct that would ordinarily result in expulsion;
- Earns a grade point average of less than the grade point average required for the college athlete to maintain intercollegiate athletics eligibility for two or more semesters;
- Fails to meet intercollegiate athletic association progress toward degree completion requirements; or,
- Is found guilty of a criminal act by a court.
- Specifies that, if the CAP Panel determines in an administrative hearing that an IHE has eliminated roster slots on an athletic program’s team, reduced aggregate athletic grant amounts, or eliminated an intercollegiate sport entirely while paying an athletics administrator or coach an annual salary of $500,000 or more, the athletic director or equivalent representative of the institution of higher education shall be suspended from involvement in intercollegiate athletics at an institution of higher education for, at minimum, three academic years, as determined by the CAP Panel.
- Before a suspension may be imposed, the individual shall be provided adequate notice and an opportunity for an administrative hearing conducted by an administrative law judge to defend themselves against any allegation of a violation.
- Specifies that an individual employed by or volunteering for an athletic program at an IHE will not do either of the following:
- Attempt to discourage or in any way punish a college athlete from selecting a course or an academic major unless it prevents the college athlete from intercollegiate athletic association progress towards baccalaureate or postgraduate degree completion; and,
- Punish, reduce intercollegiate athletics eligibility, or otherwise retaliate against a college athlete based on the college athlete’s selection of any course, academic major, or baccalaureate or postgraduate degree program at the institution.
- Requires an individual employed by an athletic program at an IHE to not interfere with or discourage any college athlete from securing employment or internships, participating in student groups or events, or serving as a volunteer so long as those activities do not interfere with mandatory class time, examination periods, or the athletic program’s mandatory team activities.
- Specifies that an IHE must not comply with any athletic association’s or athletic conference’s policy that does not count completed high school financial education and personal finance coursework toward athletic eligibility standards for incoming college athletes.
Recruiting transparency
- Requires an IHE or an out-of-state college or university conducting college athlete recruiting activities in the state shall submit, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, all of the following information to the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel:
- A complete list of companies and industries that the institution prohibits a prospective college athlete from entering into an NIL agreement with as a college athlete or intercollegiate athlete;
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university may interfere with or otherwise attempt to influence a prospective college athlete’s, college athlete’s, or intercollegiate athlete’s choice of athlete representation;
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university may limit a prospective athlete’s, college athlete’s, or intercollegiate athlete’s representation to NIL activities; and,
- Whether or not the IHE or out-of-state college or university receives any payment or benefit from an individual or entity in exchange for granting the individual or entity access to their college athletes or intercollegiate athletes for any NIL-related purpose.
- Requires that the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel must solicit the information described in 56) above and post information obtained on a publicly accessible internet website for prospective college athletes, college athletes, and intercollegiate athletes. The information described must be posted on or before October 1, 2024, and regularly updated thereafter.
- Specifies that an IHE will only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an athletic grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a prospective college athlete. An out-of-state college or university offering an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident will only use a document created by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel to offer an intercollegiate athletics grant or intercollegiate athletics participation opportunity to a California resident. A document developed as specified may be annually updated by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel and must include, but is not limited to, all of the following disclosures:
- The amount of intercollegiate sports grants to be offered to the prospective college athlete, relative to the most recent cost of attendance at the institution, for each academic year of the prospective athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The total amount of possible annual education-related compensation allowable in accordance with the United States Supreme Court decision in National Collegiate Athletic Association v. Alston (2021) 141 S.Ct. 2141 and the annual amount of education-related compensation to be offered to the prospective college athlete at the institution throughout the prospective college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The amount of an intercollegiate sports grant, if any, that will be provided to assist the prospective college athlete with undergraduate and graduate school degree completion at the institution following the expiration of the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The percentage of comprehensive medical coverage, including any minimum required coverage to participate in intercollegiate athletics and enroll as a student at the institution, that will be paid for by the institution throughout the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility;
- The percentage of any out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, that will be paid by the institution during the college athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility, and the duration for which those expenses will be covered after the prospective athlete’s intercollegiate athletics eligibility expires. The percentage of out-of-pocket sports-related medical expenses covered by the institution’s in-network and out-of-network services shall be stated on the CAP Panel’s internet website pursuant to this section;
- Whether or not the institution will pay for a disability insurance policy for the college athlete in order to cover any future loss of earnings by the athlete due to a sports-related injury or medical condition, and any limits to that policy’s benefits or coverage, including the maximum possible benefits based on similarly situated college athletes;
- A list of all colleges and universities, if any, that the institution will not allow the athlete to freely transfer to once the agreement to attend the institution is executed; and,
- The disclosures described in 56) above, as determined by the CAP Recruiting Transparency Subpanel, at the beginning of the first page of a document provided to a college athlete pursuant to this subdivision.
- Specifies that this section does not prohibit an IHE or out-of-state college or university this is subject to this section from providing protections or benefits that exceed those required by this section.
CAP Certification Subpanel
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel established as specified to certify an individual or entity to provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services to college athletes.
- Specifies that, no later than six months after the launch of the CAP Certification Subpanel’s certification operations, an individual or entity will not provide intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes without the CAP Certification Subpanel’s certified approval or receipt of other certification to provide those services established under law.
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel to develop and adopt standards for it to do all of the following:
- Certify all of the following:
- College athlete agents;
- Agencies and entities that employ college athlete agents;
- Attorneys that represent college athletes in NIL contracts. This does not replace or preempt any other state or local regulation of attorneys in the state;
- Individuals and entities that provide financial advising or marketing services to college athletes. This does not replace or preempt any federal, state, or local regulation of financial advising or marketing services in the state;
- Revoke certifications provided pursuant to 62(a) above; and,
- Protect college athletes from unfair fees and conditions for intercollegiate athletics agent, marketing, and financial advising services.
- Certify all of the following:
- Specifies that the CAP Certification Subpanel may assess certification fees, certification renewal fees, fines, and penalties on individuals and entities that do not comply with the standards developed and adopted pursuant 62) above. Fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the reasonable regulatory costs incurred by the CAP Certification Subpanel incident to issuing certifications, performing investigations, inspections, and audits related to certification, and the administrative enforcement and adjudication of the certification process.
- The CAP Certification Subpanel must develop an appeals process for an individual or entity to challenge a certification denial or revocation or any fee, fine, or penalty levied against the individual or entity; and,
- Fees and fines collected must be deposited in the CAP Fund as specified.
- Specifies that the CAP Certification Subpanel will not adopt a standard that requires an individual to have a baccalaureate degree, an associate’s degree, or a graduate degree to provide athletic agency, marketing, or financial advising services to college athletes.
- Establishes that, notwithstanding any other provision, the CAP Certification Subpanel may authorize individuals and entities who have college athlete representation certifications issued by other states or entities to operate as college athlete representatives without obtaining certification from the CAP Certification Subpanel or paying certification fees assessed by the CAP Certification Subpanel. Additionally:
- The CAP Certification Subpanel may enter into collaborative college athlete certification program agreements with other states or entities; and,
- To prevent conflicts of interest, the CAP Certification Subpanel will not certify college athlete representation provided by an institution of higher education, an out-of-state college or university, an intercollegiate athletic conference, or an athletic association.
- Requires the CAP Certification Subpanel shall promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this section, as necessary.
CAP Panel IHE fees
- Requires that, on or before January 15, 2024, and annually thereafter, each institution of higher education that was a member of the NCAA on or after January 1, 2022, must pay an annual fee to the Office of Planning and Research, in an amount determined by the CAP Panel pursuant to 68) below, to cover the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program. The annual fees collected pursuant to this section shall not exceed seven million dollars ($7,000,000) in aggregate per year. The CAP Panel may increase the annual fee limit to account for inflation. The annual fees shall be deposited in the CAP Fund as specified.
- Specifies that the CAP Panel shall base the annual fees on each institution’s total athletics revenue in the most recently published report that was submitted pursuant to the federal EADA to the USDE. The CAP Panel must establish the annual fees pursuant to all of the following requirements, and may adjust these fees, without exceeding the annual aggregate limit determined as specified:
- IHEs with athletic revenue of less than $2,499,999 shall each pay an annual fee of up to $100;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $2,500,000 and $19,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.01 percent of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $20,000,000 and $29,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.1% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue between $30,000,000 and $59,999,999, inclusive, will each pay an annual fee of up to 0.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year;
- IHEs with athletic revenue of at least $60,000,000 will each pay an annual fee of up to 1.3% of their total athletics revenue from the previous year; and,
- Two-year institutions of higher education shall each pay an annual fee of up to one $100.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding 67) and 68) above, for the first year in which an annual fee is assessed on IHEs, an IHE’s annual fee shall be the maximum amount that may be assessed to the institution. Additionally,
- If the total amount of annual fees collected exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to $7,000,000, the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
- Institutions described in paragraphs (1) and (6) shall receive first priority;
- Institutions described in paragraph (2) shall receive second priority;
- Institutions described in paragraph (3) shall receive third priority;
- Institutions described in paragraph (4) shall receive forth priority; and,
- Institutions described in paragraph (5) shall receive fifth priority;
- It is the intent of the Legislature that the CAP Program director return annual fees pursuant to this paragraph within 60 days of being hired.
- If the total amount of annual fees collected exceeds the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to $7,000,000, the CAP Program director shall return from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature, one-half of the annual fee paid by institutions of higher education pursuant to the following priority schedule until the total amount exceeding the reasonable regulatory costs of the CAP Program, up to seven million dollars ($7,000,000), is returned:
Financial workshops
- Requires an IHE to administer a financial and life skills development workshop program. An IHE will require each college athlete at the institution to attend the financial and life skills development workshop program during the college athlete’s first and third year of participation in an athletics program at the institution.
- Specifies that a program developed pursuant to this section will include, but is not limited to, information on both of the following:
- The rights of college athletes, as specified; and,
- State and federal tax information, including NIL-related taxes, time management skills, personal budgeting, debt management, credit management, and interest rates information.
- Requires a program developed as specified will not include any marketing, advertising, referral, or solicitation by providers of commercial products or services.
Penalty exemptions for college athletes
- An IHE will not uphold any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a college athlete at the institution from fully participating in intercollegiate athletics without penalty for any of the following:
- For receiving food, shelter, medical expenses, or medical or disability insurance from any source;
- For receiving payment to cover expenses, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for purposes of transportation, room, board, and incidentals at college, or for purposes of meeting with legislators, providing testimony, or meeting with government agencies regarding intercollegiate athletics; and,
- For a college athlete’s family member or friend receiving payment, direct provisions, or in-kind benefits from any source for transportation, room, board, and incidentals to support the college athlete during any period in which the college athlete is addressing a physical or mental health concern.
Retaliation
- Requires that an IHE and the institution’s employees, coaches, and affiliated medical personnel will not retaliate against a college athlete for filing a complaint or reporting a violation of a college athlete’s rights as specified.
- For purposes of this chapter, “retaliation” includes all of the following:
- A reduction in or loss of playing time that is not justified by objective measures of athletic performance or compliance with team or the institution of higher education’s policies that do not conflict with this chapter or any federal or state laws;
- A reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including athletic grants, merit-based scholarships, or any other compensation;
- A reduction in or loss of any meal benefits provided to the college athlete;
- A reduction in or loss of any housing benefits provided to the college athlete, including the relocation of the college athlete’s housing owned by the institution of higher education;
- A reduction in or loss of athletics or team communications, academic support or records, access to training facilities, or medical treatment;
- Pressure to not file a complaint or to withdraw a complaint; and,
- Threats, ridicule, or physical punishment.
CAP Fund
- Establishes the CAP Fund. The CAP Panel will administer the CAP Fund. The CAP Fund will serve as the repository of all moneys appropriated or collected pursuant to this chapter, except as specified. Moneys in the fund may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter. Up to 5 percent of moneys in the CAP Fund, unless otherwise encumbered, may be used, upon appropriation by the Legislature, by the CAP Panel or a CAP Subpanel for administrative costs of implementing and enforcing these provisions.
Broad regulatory authority
- Authorizes the CAP Panel to promulgate regulations for purposes of implementing and enforcing this chapter, as the CAP Panel deems appropriate or necessary.
Enforcement provision
- Specifies that the Act not limit the enforcement authority of any state or federal agency or shield violators from liability.
Severability
- Declares that the provisions of the Act are severable. If any provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
Repeals elements of current law
- Repeals sections of current law pertaining to the degree completion fund, a notice of student rights, and retaliation.
Reimbursement
- If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a “postsecondary educational institution” as any campus of the University of California or the California State University, an independent institution of higher education, or a private postsecondary educational institution. (Education Code (EDC) Section 67456)
- Establishes that an IHE may establish a degree completion fund, in accordance with applicable rules and bylaws of the governing body of the institution and applicable rules and bylaws of any athletic association of which the institution is a member. (EDC Section 67452.3)
- Requires each athletic program at an IHE to conduct a financial and life skills workshop for all of its first-year and third-year student athletes at the beginning of the academic year. (EDC Section 67452)
- Clarifies retaliation by an IHE includes but is not necessarily limited to, a reduction in or loss of any education benefits, including scholarships and stipends; meal benefits provided to a student athlete; or any housing benefits provided to a student athlete, including the relocation of a student athlete to different housing owned by the IHE. (EDC Section 67455)
- Prohibits a postsecondary educational institution from upholding any rule, requirement, standard, or other limitation that prevents a student of that institution participating in intercollegiate athletics from earning compensation as a result of the use of the student’s name, image, or likeness. Earning compensation from the use of a student’s name, image, or likeness shall not affect the student’s scholarship eligibility. (EDC Section 67456(a)(1).)
- Prohibits an athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics, including the NCAA, from preventing a student of a postsecondary educational institution participating in intercollegiate athletics from earning compensation as a result of the use of the student’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation, and from preventing a postsecondary educational institution from participating in intercollegiate athletics as a result of that compensation. (EDC Sections 67456(a)(2) & (3).)
- Restricts a postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics from providing a prospective student athlete with compensation in relation to the athlete’s name, image, likeness, or athletic reputation. (EDC Sections 67456(b).)
- Prohibits a postsecondary educational institution, athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics from preventing a California student participating in intercollegiate athletics from obtaining professional representation in relation to contracts or legal matters, including, but not limited to, representation provided by athlete agents or legal representation provided by attorneys. Representation obtained by student athletes shall be from persons licensed by the state, as specified. (EDC Sections 67456(c).)
- States that no public funds should be used in connection with any athletic program conducted under the auspices of a public postsecondary educational institution, or any student organization within the postsecondary educational institution, that does not provide an equivalent opportunity to both sexes for participation and use of facilities. The factors considered when determining whether an educational institution has provided equivalent opportunity include, but are not limited to, travel arrangements, scholarships, medical facilities, and compensation of coaches. (EDC Section 66271.8)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Purpose. According to the author, “there is a tremendous need for AB 252 because California’s college athletes are governed by athletic associations that do not enforce health and safety standards to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death; and impose rules that have violated antitrust laws and have caused athletes economic harm. College athletes’ athletic time demands result in unacceptably low federal graduation rates among Black college athletes that produce the most athletic revenue, there is a lack of transparency and accountability regarding important athletic program policies for college athletes and recruits, and there is a need to certify athlete agent representatives to help prevent college athletes from bad actors.”
The author also noted that “college athletes are often put in harm's way as the institutions they represent prioritize winning over athlete safety. Coaches are incentivized to secure victories as it can lead to job stability and salary increments, while athletic trainers are often driven by the fear of being fired if they raise concerns that could potentially impact the team's performance. This misplaced emphasis on winning over athlete well-being is a concerning trend that requires immediate attention and resolution. It is an ongoing hazard to allow universities to police the treatment of their athletes when the universities’ negligence and mistreatment are primary forces in harming the well-being of so many athletes.”
Background- what is the NCAA? The NCAA is a voluntary, membership association of nearly 1,100 colleges and universities, athletics conferences and sports organizations that administer intercollegiate athletics. Although the NCAA promotes intercollegiate athletics and student-athletes, its core function is to create rules and ensure a level playing field in intercollegiate athletic competition. Representatives from member schools and conferences propose, debate, and vote on bylaws that govern the association. The NCAA enforces these rules, which govern, among other things, student-athlete financial aid, employment, and transfer eligibility.
The Intercollegiate Athletic Association, the predecessor of the NCAA, was founded in 1906 to address the violence then plaguing college football. More broadly, the founders sought to set national standards for all collegiate sports. It adopted the NCAA name in 1910. The NCAA constitution states that the organization’s purpose is to “provide student-athletes with the opportunity to participate in sports and compete as a vital, co-curricular part of their educational experience. The member schools and conferences likewise are committed to integrity and sportsmanship in their athletics programs and to institutional control of and responsibility for those programs. The basic purpose of the NCAA is to support and promote healthy and safe intercollegiate athletics, including national championships, as an integral part of the education program and the student-athlete as an integral part of the student body.” To achieve its goals, the NCAA issues and enforces rules that govern aspects such as recruiting, eligibility, academic standards, and the requirements for schools to be classified into Divisions I, II, and III.
Name, Image, Likeness: On June 30, 2021, the NCAA Division 1 Board of Directors approved an interim name, image and likeness (NIL) policy. This new policy allows all NCAA Division I, II, and III student-athletes to be compensated for their NIL as of July 1, 2021, regardless of whether their state has a NIL law in place or not. California was one of the first states to establish an NIL policy, as passed by SB 206 (Skinner), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2019, and strongly influenced the implementation of NCAA’s policy.
The NCAA NIL rules do not override state, college/university or conference specific NIL rules. This means student-athletes need to review the NIL rules in the state where their school is located and check with their athletic department for any school and conference-specific rules to understand what limitations they will have on their NIL.
NCAA v. Alston (Jan. 2021). The Supreme Court found that by limiting education-related compensation that college athletes are permitted to receive from their schools, the NCAA is acting in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which prohibits any “contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce.” The Court reached this conclusion by affirming the lower court’s application of the “rule of reason” – a judicial doctrine of antitrust law.
In Alston, the athletes challenged the NCAA compensation limits as reducing competition among colleges and universities as to what those schools would otherwise provide the athletes. Given this restriction on competition, the NCAA relied on its longstanding position that the uniqueness of its product – the status of student athletes as amateurs – required antitrust deference and pointed for support to the 1984 decision in NCAA v. Board of Regents. Specifically, the NCAA’s procompetitive justification for the status quo (whereby the NCAA limits athlete compensation tied to academics and athletics and mostly prohibits athlete monetization of name, image, and likeness rights) was that the survival of the product of college athletics depends on such restrictions by the NCAA. It reasoned that intercollegiate athletics differentiates itself from professional sports chiefly through the amateur (read, unpaid) status of its athletes, therefore diminishing the purity of amateurism through unrestrained athlete payment—even for academic expenses—would render intercollegiate athletics obsolete.
The Alston Court rejected this argument, holding that the Board of Regents was inapplicable to questions of athlete compensation and that the decision’s oft-cited commentary that the NCAA enjoys “ample latitude” under federal antitrust law was mere dicta that could not insulate the NCAA from antitrust scrutiny. Specifically, the Court found the NCAA had failed to show any economic analysis as to how or why the consumer market for college sports might be irrevocably destroyed by teenage athletes receiving from their school’s unrestrained educational benefits. The Court noted, in contrast, that the Alston plaintiffs were able to show the very opposite—namely that the popularity of college sports had increased in the years following increased allowances in educational benefits allocation.
In its unanimous 9-0 decision in NCAA v. Alston, the Supreme Court upheld a ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit that struck down NCAA caps on student athlete academic benefits (i.e. reimbursements and pay for academic-related expenses) on antitrust grounds.
The Student Athlete’s Bill of Rights (SABR). Several of the protections provided for California student athletes contained in the SABR (specifically EDC Sections 67452 and 67453) are limited to universities that receive, on average, at least $10 million in annual income from media rights for intercollegiate athletics. This number is a minority of California colleges and universities, and has traditionally only included UC Berkeley, Stanford, the University of Southern California (USC), and UC Los Angeles. The rapid increase in athletics media rights deals – and the lack of inflation growth built into current law – means that other universities with robust athletics programs might also soon fall under these specific provisions of SABR.
Specifically, these SABR provisions requires an intercollegiate athletic program at any campus of the UC, CSU, or private four-year university in California to provide to students whose athletic scholarship is not renewed, an equivalent scholarship (when combined with the total duration of any previous athletic or other scholarship received by the student) for a total of at least five years or until the student completes his or her undergraduate degree, whichever period is shorter.
The law also requires athletic programs to promptly approve a qualifying student athlete's written request to transfer to another institution without actively or passively imposing any restrictions or condition. Implementation must include granting other institutions permission to contact the student athlete and waiving residency requirements, as permitted by athletic association rules.
The SABR also requires an athletic program to be responsible for any and all medical expenses of its student athletes resulting from their participation in the athletic program, irrespective of whether the student athlete is still in school, has graduated, or is no longer enrolled in the school, so long as the medical expenses result from the student athlete's participation in the athletic program, and to adopt and implement guidelines to prevent, assess, and treat sports-related concussions and dehydration, and exercise and supervision guidelines for any student athlete identified with potentially life-threatening health conditions who participates in an athletic program.
Colleges must also grant a student athlete the same rights as other students with regard to any and all matters related to possible adverse or disciplinary actions, including actions involving his or her participation in the athletic program.
Committee staff notes that the provisions of AB 252 (Holden) significantly exceed those outlined in SABR - specifically the requirement to provide medical care following the conclusion of one’s athletic career and the addition provision for six years of scholarship time for athletes receiving an athletic grant both. The annual revenue metric used for expanded medical care detailed 43) and 44) above makes it difficult to account for the change from media rights fees; however, the requirement that all Division I athletes receiving an athletic grant be granted up to six academic years of total full-time college attendance detailed in 50) above significantly expands on the provisions of EDC Section 67452.
Degree completion fund. AB 252 (Holden) recasts and expands upon the degree completion fund established in current law by AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019. As was noted in Committee analyses when AB 1573 was moving through the process, the Degree Completion Fund was instituted, in part, to allow California to comply with new NCAA Bylaws creating such funds for former basketball student-athletes. The bylaw, now known as Bylaw 15.01.5.2.1, specifies that “an institution that provides athletically related financial aid to basketball student-athletes shall provide, at a minimum, tuition and fees, and course-related books to a former basketball student-athlete who requests financial aid to complete his or her first baccalaureate degree, provided:
- The former student-athlete received athletically related financial aid while previously enrolled at the institution.
- Fewer than 10 years have elapsed since the former student-athlete's departure from the institution.
- The former student-athlete's most recent enrollment as a full-time student occurred at the institution.
- The former student-athlete was previously enrolled as a full-time student at the institution for a minimum of two academic years (four semesters or six quarters).
- The former student-athlete meets all institutional admissions and financial aid requirements.
- The former student-athlete has exhausted other available degree completion funding options (e.g., funds from a professional league or contract).
- The former student-athlete is in good academic standing at the institution and meets NCAA and institutional progress-toward-degree requirements. This requirement applies to initial and continuing eligibility for degree completion funds.
Committee staff notes that provisions of AB 252 (Holden) detailed starting with 50) above will, if implemented, likely render the current version of the degree completion fund unnecessary.
The sponsor of AB 252 (Holden), the National College Players Association (NCPA), writes that “California colleges impose a collusive athlete compensation limit that is far below fair market compensation. The US Supreme Court’s 9-0 ruling against the NCAA in NCAA v Alston affirms this fact. Collusive athlete pay limits violate antitrust laws and California colleges are participating in this illegal activity. This multibillion college sports enterprise imposes discriminatory practices that disproportionately harm Black athletes, while predominantly White coaches and administrators make millions of dollars. College athletes throughout predominantly White sports receive fair market compensation, but athletes in the only predominantly Black sports (FBS football and men’s and women’s basketball) do not. All college athletes should have the opportunity to receive fair market pay.”
NCPA continues that “this racially unjust exploitation is amplified by the fact that Black men’s basketball players, women’s basketball players, and FBS football players have unacceptably low graduation rates – 42.6%, 62.7%, and 63.9%, respectively. Chronically low graduation rates among Black athletes persist as do the 40-50 hours/week athletes report spending on their sport. AB 252 (Holden) would be a powerful counterweight to structural obstacles that work against athletes’ academic success because it would condition much of the pay on degree completion. This is a much better use for athletic revenue that will otherwise be spent on ever increasing raises for coaching salaries. Head football coaches at UC Berkeley, UCLA, Stanford, and USC are $4.75 million, $4.8 million, $8.9 million, and $11 million, respectively.”
As noted by NCPA, this reenvisioning of the Degree Completion Fund would condition the payment of funds upon graduation, and is designed “for its college athletes who receive athletic grants but do not receive fair market value compensation in an academic year” (see 4) above).
Fair market value compensation. Fair market value is defined in 252 (Holden) (see 2(j) above) as “an amount of compensation for each college athlete who receives an athletic grant that is determined annually by subtracting the intercollegiate athletic team’s aggregate athletic grants from one-half of the intercollegiate athletic team’s revenue and dividing that difference by the number of athletic grants provided to college athletes on that team”.
The author noted in his committee background sheet that “AB 252 would ensure Division I college athletes have a potential path toward receiving 50% of the revenue their team generates. This percentage is defined as Fair Market Value pay in AB 252 because it reflects a revenue share percentage based on agreements that professional athletes and their respective leagues negotiate in good faith.”
Committee staff notes that revenue share varies greatly based on the sport. For example, while athletes in the National Basketball Association and Major League Baseball receive close to 50% fighters in the United Fighting Championship receive 16-20%, while athletes in the Women’s National Basketball Association receive approximately 25%.
The mechanisms for determining revenue distribution in AB 252 (Holden) are outlined beginning with 5) and 12) above, respectively.
Multiple intuitions wrote in opposition the degree completion fund and fair market value compensation formula contained within AB 252. The UC Office of the President wrote that “AB 252 would create numerous problems for UC athletic programs, including diverting funds to a select group of UC student-athletes and limiting a program's ability to fund and support other athletic teams, notably women's teams. UC athletic departments use their revenues to fund student-athlete-related support for all teams, including meals, nutritional services, team travel, academic counseling, athletic trainers, medical personnel and treatment, team equipment, mental health counseling, and more. UC estimates that requirements outlined in AB 252 to create, manage, and distribute degree completion funds for qualifying student-athletes would have a fiscal impact in the range of $38 million to $40 million annually systemwide.”
The University of Southern California wrote that “AB 252 would require a massive rerouting of funds away from sports that do not generate revenue—women’s and Olympic sports—in order to make substantial payments to male student-athletes (specifically, football and men’s basketball players). USC Athletics operates with the expectation that almost all of our 21 sports programs will not generate revenue to cover their costs. Instead, those programs rely on funding from the positive revenue generated by football and men’s basketball. USC projects that AB 252’s revenue scheme would direct payments to its male football and basketball student-athletes each year that would be nearly equal to the entire combined annual cost of operating its other 19 sports. The net result is that AB 252 will force USC and other California universities to cut funding to and potentially eliminate, non-revenue and lower-revenue sports programs. One of the devastating potential effects of this change would be to drive Olympic athletes out of California.”
The concern about fund redistribution negatively impacting non-revenue generating sports is echoed by opposition from the Team USA Athletes’ Commission, which wrote that “we are very concerned that the bill as drafted positively impacts a few athletes in revenue generating sports to the detriment of many. We believe that there must be a better solution to help athletes with high-market value access funding and enhance the student-athlete experience that does not have such significant negative impacts on the broad-based athletics system. Without requiring a specific reallocation of athletic department dollars, we believe the ramifications of the passage of AB 252 would likely result in the loss of Olympic and Paralympic sport opportunities. The redirection of compensation as proposed in this bill will likely result in the loss of sports and/or the reduction of other sport/athlete support.”
Title IX. Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in all educational institutions that receive federal funding. This applies to all aspects of education and types of sex discrimination including athletics, sexual harassment and assault, harassment based on gender identity, science and math education, and facilities and course offerings.
The California Labor Federation wrote that “Black college athletes make up the majority of revenue for sport athletes yet, suffer some of the lowest graduation rates. And although Title IX—federal law that sought to ensure gender equity in education settings—has been in place for 50 years, a clear lack of Title IX compliance in athletics programs persists across many colleges.”
The sponsor, NCPA, also wrote that “We are in the 50th year anniversary of Title IX, but there is still a glaring difference between the college sports participation between men and women. There are 8000 fewer female college athletes compared to male college athletes in California. This is a red flag that screams for both transparency and accountability related to California colleges’ Title IX compliance.”
Yet, Title IX implications regarding the degree completion fund and revenue sharing implications were a major note of opposition to AB 252 (Holden). Stanford University wrote that “The Title IX implications of AB 252 are of great concern. Whereas AB 252 purports to provide equal opportunity among all student-athletes, pragmatic application of the bill will result in substantial revenue payments to the benefit of a disproportionate number of male student-athletes. Additionally, in order to maintain gender equity and comply with their federal law compliance obligations, schools will be required to make legal arguments to a body not charged or employed to enforce Title IX before allocating athletics-related financial assistance equitably. The convoluted revenue sharing model proposed in AB 252 and the burdensome requirements related to Title IX would make it exceptionally challenging for California higher education institutions to comply with their Title IX obligations.”
The California State University Chancellor’s Office also expressed Title IX concerns, writing that “CSU athletic departments operate under tight budgets, and this reallocation of revenue would harm smaller, non-revenue generating athletic programs and the services provided to all student athletes. The revenue sharing framework may also create gender inequities among our student athletes and place CSU campuses out of compliance with federal Title IX regulations. Our analysis shows that the redistribution of revenue between male and female student athletes would be disproportional. At one campus, for example, male student athletes make up thirty-eight percent of all student athletes but would receive sixty-five percent of the funds. The majority of funds would go to football, men’s basketball, and women’s basketball players, which are only a small portion of all student athletes.”
AB 252 (Holden) address the proportionality requirement in Title IX, making explicit provisions that IHEs may make adjustments to degree completion fund payments, provided the aggregate total amount of degree completion fund payment designations made to the institution’s college athletes is not reduced, and that the IHE is in compliance with Title IX financial aid proportionality comparisons in athletics independent of degree completion fund payment designations.
CAP Program. The CAP Program and Panel established pursuant to AB 252 (Holden) is a wide-ranging oversight body that is similar to the body proposed in AB 1435 (Gonzalez Fletcher), of 2017. This Program, located in the Office of Planning and Research, would include a 21-member panel comprised of individuals with specific backgrounds and experiences. The body would also have the authority to conduct investigations, issue subpoenas, create regulations, evaluate misconduct, and determine sanctions up to and including a lifetime ban from being involved in intercollegiate athletics at any institution of higher education.
The author wrote in his background sheet that this CAP Program and Panel will be crucial in identifying and enforcing health and safety standards to prevent serious injury, abuse, and death among college athletes. The author also contends that the various subpaenls will:
- Require California colleges to provide transparency about the degree to which they are complying with Title IX;
- Prioritizes the preservation of all sports by suspending an athletic director that chooses to cut sports participation while paying athletic personnel $500,000 or more;
- Establishes an athlete representative certification program; and,
- Creates a state program funded by college athletic revenue fees to carry out functions to fulfill and enforce the Act.
Opposition raised major concerns about the Cap Panel. The Association of Independent California Colleges and Universities (AICCU) wrote that, “the creation of the CAP Panel, funded by a mandatory fee structure imposed on all colleges and universities, creates a new layer of state bureaucracy. The powers of the panel are extensive, with duties and powers that include, but are not limited to, investigating complaints for violations of the bill provisions, issuing subpoenas, referring colleges and universities to the Attorney General for prosecution, and implementing cost-reduction efforts with other states and sports conferences. It is unclear why a new state entity is needed, or appropriate, to carry out the duties proposed for the CAP Panel, and what compelling reason there is to create a framework that further diminishes institutional athletics budgets to fund it.”
Committee comments. Should the Committee wish to pass AB 252 (Holden), the author may wish to consider the following:
- Modifying implementation dates. The implementation dates in AB 252 (Holden) are extremely ambitious, and would likely be impossible to meet in practice. For example, the bill would require payment of fees for the CAP Panel to be paid on January 15, 2024, a mere 14 days after this legislation would go in effect (see 67) above). The author may wish to consider delaying all dates by at least one year to give the CAP Program time to hire a Director.
- Panel composition. The CAP Panel composition is very complex. The split in appointment authority, combined with the requirement that nearly all members have a relevant expertise, will likely make it difficult to manage Panel appointment and thus impact the work for the Subpanels. The author may wish to consider alternate options for committee appointment and membership that create flexibility and build in the possibility for membership vacancies.
- Degree Completion Fund Construct and Distribution. The author may consider working with stakeholders to find an appropriate mechanism that properly compensates student athletes while ensuring an institution of higher education’s athletic program continues to be sustained and equitable. This is especially true when considering the impact that degree completion fund distribution would have on non-revenue generating programs.
Prior legislation. SB 26 (Skinner), Chapter 159, Statutes of 2021, expanded the existing authority for a collegiate student athlete to receive compensation to also include compensation earned from the use of the student’s athletic reputation and moves up the implementation date of existing statutes relative to compensation earned from the use of a student athlete’s name, image, or likeness.
AB 609 (Kamlager, 2021) would have required institutions of higher learning to (1) pay their athletes in sports generating high revenue in comparison to the amount of scholarships awarded; (2) comply with federal law requiring equal opportunity to participate in college athletics, regardless of gender and to suspend an athletic director from intercollegiate athletics responsibilities in the state for three years if such compliance is not achieved; and (3) limit compensation for athletics administrative personnel. AB 609 died in the Assembly Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media.
AB 1573 (Holden), Chapter 382, Statutes of 2019, added three provisions of law designed to support and protect the rights of student athletes at institutions of higher learning. Specifically, the bill: 1) authorizes schools to establish degree completion funds; 2) directs schools to develop, post, and disseminate specified information regarding existing student athlete rights; and, 3) prohibits schools from retaliating against student athletes who report violations of student athletes' rights.
SB 206 (Skinner), Chapter 383, Statutes of 2012, allows, commencing on January 1, 2023, college student athletes to earn compensation for the use of their own name, image, or likeness (athletic endorsements). This bill allows student athletes to obtain professional legal representation, such as that provided by a sports agent, in relation to their college athletics. This bill provides protections for student athletes that elect to engage in the compensation and representation activities described therein.
SB1525 (Padilla) Chapter 625, Statutes of 2012, enacted a SABR and places specified requirements on collegiate athletic programs commencing with the 2013-14 academic year and ending January 1, 2021. (Chapter 625; 2012)
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
National College Players Association
United Steelworkers District 12
5 Individuals
Opposition
Association of Independent California Colleges & Universities (AICCU)
California State University, Office of the Chancellor
Stanford University
Team USA Athletes' Commission
United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee
University of California
University of Southern California
USA Swimming
USA Track & Field
USA Water Polo
Analysis Prepared by: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):