AB 2521: Criminal procedure: confidentiality and DNA testing.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-18
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-07-18: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 153, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, in the trial of a capital case or specified murder cases, authorizes an indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, to request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for preparation or presentation of the defense. Existing law requires the fact that an application has been made to be confidential and the contents of the application to be confidential. Existing law provides that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents protected by these provisions when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record relates to the issue raised.
This bill would, instead, provide that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with that access.
Existing law authorizes a person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion for performance of forensics deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing. Existing law requires the DNA testing, if granted by the court, to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, and the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion, as specified.
This bill would instead require that DNA testing to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney or Attorney General and the person filing the motion, regardless of the type of case.
Existing law, in the trial of a capital case or specified murder cases, authorizes an indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, to request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for preparation or presentation of the defense. Existing law requires the fact that an application has been made to be confidential and the contents of the application to be confidential. Existing law provides that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents protected by these provisions when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record relates to the issue raised.
This bill would, instead, provide that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with that access.
Existing law authorizes a person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion for performance of forensics deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing. Existing law requires the DNA testing, if granted by the court, to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, and the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion, as specified.
This bill would instead require that DNA testing to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney or Attorney General and the person filing the motion, regardless of the type of case.
Existing law, in the trial of a capital case or specified murder cases, authorizes an indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, to request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for preparation or presentation of the defense. Existing law requires the fact that an application has been made to be confidential and the contents of the application to be confidential. Existing law provides that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents protected by these provisions when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record relates to the issue raised.
This bill would, instead, provide that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with that access.
Existing law authorizes a person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion for performance of forensics deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing. Existing law requires the DNA testing, if granted by the court, to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, and the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion, as specified.
This bill would instead require that DNA testing to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney or Attorney General and the person filing the motion, regardless of the type of case.
(a)In the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, may request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The application for funds shall be by affidavit and shall specify that the funds are reasonably necessary for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. Upon receipt of an application, a judge of the court, other than the trial judge presiding over the case in question, shall rule on the reasonableness of the request and shall disburse an appropriate amount of money to the defendants attorney. The ruling on the reasonableness of the request shall be made at an in camera hearing. In making the ruling, the court shall be guided by the need to provide a complete and full defense for the defendant.
(b)(1)The Controller shall not reimburse any county for costs that exceed Department of General Services standards for travel and per diem expenses. The Controller may reimburse extraordinary costs in unusual cases if the county provides sufficient documentation of the need for those expenditures.
(2)At the termination of the proceedings, the attorney shall furnish to the court a complete accounting of all moneys received and disbursed pursuant to this section.
(c)The Controller shall adopt regulations pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, controlling reimbursements under this section. The regulations shall consider compensation for investigators, expert witnesses, and other expenses that may or may not be reimbursable pursuant to this section. Notwithstanding the provisions of Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the Controller shall follow any regulations adopted until final approval by the Office of Administrative Law.
(d)The confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with access to documents protected by this section when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record, created pursuant to this section, relates to the issue raised. When the defendant raises that issue either on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding at their request. In this case, the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding.
SEC. 2.Section 1405 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1405.(a)A person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment may make a written motion, pursuant to subdivision (d), before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in their case, for performance of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing.
(b)(1)An indigent convicted person may request appointment of counsel in order to prepare a motion pursuant to subdivision (d) by sending a written request to the court. The request shall include the persons statement that they were not the perpetrator of the crime and shall explain how the DNA testing is relevant to their assertion of innocence. The request also shall include the persons statement as to whether they previously have had counsel appointed under this section.
(2)If any of the information required in paragraph (1) is missing from the request, the court shall return the request to the convicted person and advise them that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(3)(A)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, they have included the information required in paragraph (1), and counsel has not previously been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(B)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, and counsel previously has been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court may, in its discretion, appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(4)This section does not provide for a right to the appointment of counsel in a postconviction collateral proceeding, or to set a precedent for any such right, in any context other than the representation being provided an indigent convicted person for the limited purpose of filing and litigating a motion for DNA testing pursuant to this section.
(c)Upon request of the convicted person or convicted persons counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, the following documents that are in their possession or control, if the documents exist:
(1)Copies of DNA lab reports, with underlying notes, prepared in connection with the laboratory testing of biological evidence from the case, including presumptive tests for the presence of biological material, serological tests, and analyses of trace evidence.
(2)Copies of evidence logs, chain of custody logs and reports, including, but not limited to, documentation of current location of biological evidence, and evidence destruction logs and reports.
(3)If the evidence has been lost or destroyed, a custodian of record shall submit a report to the prosecutor and the convicted person or convicted persons counsel that sets forth the efforts that were made in an attempt to locate the evidence. If the last known or documented location of the evidence prior to its loss or destruction was in an area controlled by a law enforcement agency, the report shall include the results of a physical search of this area. If there is a record of confirmation of destruction of the evidence, the report shall include a copy of the record of confirmation of destruction in lieu of the results of a physical search of the area.
(d)(1)The motion for DNA testing shall be verified by the convicted person under penalty of perjury and shall include all of the following:
(A)A statement that they are innocent and not the perpetrator of the crime.
(B)Explain why the identity of the perpetrator was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(C)Make every reasonable attempt to identify both the evidence that should be tested and the specific type of DNA testing sought.
(D)Explain, in light of all the evidence, how the requested DNA testing would raise a reasonable probability that the convicted persons verdict or sentence would be more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction.
(E)Reveal the results of any DNA or other biological testing that was conducted previously by either the prosecution or defense, if known.
(F)State whether any motion for testing under this section previously has been filed and the results of that motion, if known.
(2)Notice of the motion shall be served on the Attorney General, the district attorney in the county of conviction, and, if known, the governmental agency or laboratory holding the evidence sought to be tested. Responses, if any, shall be filed within 90 days of the date on which the Attorney General and the district attorney are served with the motion, unless a continuance is granted for good cause.
(e)If the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, it shall order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing.
(f)If the court determines that the convicted person has met all of the requirements of subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the court may, as it deems necessary, order a hearing on the motion. The judge who conducted the trial, or accepted the convicted persons plea of guilty or nolo contendere, shall conduct the hearing unless the presiding judge determines that judge is unavailable. Upon request of either party, the court may order, in the interest of justice, that the convicted person be present at the hearing of the motion. Either party, upon request, may request an additional 60 days to brief issues raised in subdivision (g).
(g)The court shall grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
(1)The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion.
(2)The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect.
(3)The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(4)The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted persons identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence. The convicted person is only required to demonstrate that the DNA testing they seek would be relevant to, rather than dispositive of, the issue of identity. The convicted person is not required to show a favorable result would conclusively establish their innocence.
(5)The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted persons verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction. The court in its discretion may consider any evidence whether or not it was introduced at trial. In determining whether the convicted person is entitled to develop potentially exculpatory evidence, the court shall not decide whether, assuming a DNA test result favorable to the convicted person, they are entitled to some form of ultimate relief.
(6)The evidence sought to be tested meets either of the following conditions:
(A)The evidence was not tested previously.
(B)The evidence was tested previously, but the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results.
(7)The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community.
(8)The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay.
(h)(1)If the court grants the motion for DNA testing, the court order shall identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used.
(2)The testing shall be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney and the person filing the motion. If the parties cannot agree, the court shall designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards. Laboratories accredited by the following entities have been determined to satisfy this requirement: the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA), the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board (ASCLD/LAB), and Forensic Quality Services (ANSI-ASQ National Accreditation Board FQS).
(3)If the accredited laboratory selected by the parties or designated by the court to conduct DNA testing is not a National DNA Index System (NDIS) participating laboratory that takes or retains ownership of the DNA data for entry into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), the laboratory selected to perform DNA testing shall not initiate analysis for a specific case until documented approval has been obtained from an appropriate NDIS participating laboratorys technical leader of acceptance of ownership of the DNA data from the selected laboratory that may be entered into or searched in CODIS.
(i)In accordance with the courts order pursuant to subdivision (h), the laboratory may communicate with either party, upon request, during the testing process. The result of any testing ordered under this section shall be fully disclosed to the person filing the motion, the district attorney, and the Attorney General. If requested by any party, the court shall order production of the underlying laboratory data and notes.
(j)(1)The cost of DNA testing ordered under this section shall be borne by the state or the applicant, as the court may order in the interests of justice, if it is shown that the applicant is not indigent and possesses the ability to pay. However, the cost of any additional testing to be conducted by the district attorney or Attorney General shall not be borne by the convicted person.
(2)In order to pay the states share of any testing costs, the laboratory designated in subdivision (h) shall present its bill for services to the superior court for approval and payment. It is the intent of the Legislature to appropriate funds for this purpose in the 200001 Budget Act.
(k)An order granting or denying a motion for DNA testing under this section shall not be appealable, and shall be subject to review only through petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed by the person seeking DNA testing, the district attorney, or the Attorney General. The petition shall be filed within 20 days after the courts order granting or denying the motion for DNA testing. In a noncapital case, the petition for writ of mandate or prohibition shall be filed in the court of appeal. In a capital case, the petition shall be filed in the California Supreme Court. The court of appeal or California Supreme Court shall expedite its review of a petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed under this subdivision.
(l)DNA testing ordered by the court pursuant to this section shall be done as soon as practicable. However, if the court finds that a miscarriage of justice will otherwise occur and that it is necessary in the interests of justice to give priority to the DNA testing, a DNA laboratory shall be required to give priority to the DNA testing ordered pursuant to this section over the laboratorys other pending casework.
(m)DNA profile information from biological samples taken from a convicted person pursuant to a motion for postconviction DNA testing is exempt from any law requiring disclosure of information to the public.
(n)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the right to file a motion for postconviction DNA testing provided by this section is absolute and shall not be waived. This prohibition applies to, but is not limited to, a waiver that is given as part of an agreement resulting in a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(o)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)In the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, may request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The application for funds shall be by affidavit and shall specify that the funds are reasonably necessary for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. Upon receipt of an application, a judge of the court, other than the trial judge presiding over the case in question, shall rule on the reasonableness of the request and shall disburse an appropriate amount of money to the defendants attorney. The ruling on the reasonableness of the request shall be made at an in camera hearing. In making the ruling, the court shall be guided by the need to provide a complete and full defense for the defendant.
(b)(1)The Controller shall not reimburse any county for costs that exceed Department of General Services standards for travel and per diem expenses. The Controller may reimburse extraordinary costs in unusual cases if the county provides sufficient documentation of the need for those expenditures.
(2)At the termination of the proceedings, the attorney shall furnish to the court a complete accounting of all moneys received and disbursed pursuant to this section.
(c)The Controller shall adopt regulations pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, controlling reimbursements under this section. The regulations shall consider compensation for investigators, expert witnesses, and other expenses that may or may not be reimbursable pursuant to this section. Notwithstanding the provisions of Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the Controller shall follow any regulations adopted until final approval by the Office of Administrative Law.
(d)The confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with access to documents protected by this section when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record, created pursuant to this section, relates to the issue raised. When the defendant raises that issue either on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding at their request. In this case, the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding.
SEC. 2.Section 1405 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1405.(a)A person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment may make a written motion, pursuant to subdivision (d), before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in their case, for performance of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing.
(b)(1)An indigent convicted person may request appointment of counsel in order to prepare a motion pursuant to subdivision (d) by sending a written request to the court. The request shall include the persons statement that they were not the perpetrator of the crime and shall explain how the DNA testing is relevant to their assertion of innocence. The request also shall include the persons statement as to whether they previously have had counsel appointed under this section.
(2)If any of the information required in paragraph (1) is missing from the request, the court shall return the request to the convicted person and advise them that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(3)(A)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, they have included the information required in paragraph (1), and counsel has not previously been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(B)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, and counsel previously has been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court may, in its discretion, appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(4)This section does not provide for a right to the appointment of counsel in a postconviction collateral proceeding, or to set a precedent for any such right, in any context other than the representation being provided an indigent convicted person for the limited purpose of filing and litigating a motion for DNA testing pursuant to this section.
(c)Upon request of the convicted person or convicted persons counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, the following documents that are in their possession or control, if the documents exist:
(1)Copies of DNA lab reports, with underlying notes, prepared in connection with the laboratory testing of biological evidence from the case, including presumptive tests for the presence of biological material, serological tests, and analyses of trace evidence.
(2)Copies of evidence logs, chain of custody logs and reports, including, but not limited to, documentation of current location of biological evidence, and evidence destruction logs and reports.
(3)If the evidence has been lost or destroyed, a custodian of record shall submit a report to the prosecutor and the convicted person or convicted persons counsel that sets forth the efforts that were made in an attempt to locate the evidence. If the last known or documented location of the evidence prior to its loss or destruction was in an area controlled by a law enforcement agency, the report shall include the results of a physical search of this area. If there is a record of confirmation of destruction of the evidence, the report shall include a copy of the record of confirmation of destruction in lieu of the results of a physical search of the area.
(d)(1)The motion for DNA testing shall be verified by the convicted person under penalty of perjury and shall include all of the following:
(A)A statement that they are innocent and not the perpetrator of the crime.
(B)Explain why the identity of the perpetrator was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(C)Make every reasonable attempt to identify both the evidence that should be tested and the specific type of DNA testing sought.
(D)Explain, in light of all the evidence, how the requested DNA testing would raise a reasonable probability that the convicted persons verdict or sentence would be more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction.
(E)Reveal the results of any DNA or other biological testing that was conducted previously by either the prosecution or defense, if known.
(F)State whether any motion for testing under this section previously has been filed and the results of that motion, if known.
(2)Notice of the motion shall be served on the Attorney General, the district attorney in the county of conviction, and, if known, the governmental agency or laboratory holding the evidence sought to be tested. Responses, if any, shall be filed within 90 days of the date on which the Attorney General and the district attorney are served with the motion, unless a continuance is granted for good cause.
(e)If the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, it shall order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing.
(f)If the court determines that the convicted person has met all of the requirements of subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the court may, as it deems necessary, order a hearing on the motion. The judge who conducted the trial, or accepted the convicted persons plea of guilty or nolo contendere, shall conduct the hearing unless the presiding judge determines that judge is unavailable. Upon request of either party, the court may order, in the interest of justice, that the convicted person be present at the hearing of the motion. Either party, upon request, may request an additional 60 days to brief issues raised in subdivision (g).
(g)The court shall grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
(1)The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion.
(2)The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect.
(3)The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(4)The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted persons identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence. The convicted person is only required to demonstrate that the DNA testing they seek would be relevant to, rather than dispositive of, the issue of identity. The convicted person is not required to show a favorable result would conclusively establish their innocence.
(5)The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted persons verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction. The court in its discretion may consider any evidence whether or not it was introduced at trial. In determining whether the convicted person is entitled to develop potentially exculpatory evidence, the court shall not decide whether, assuming a DNA test result favorable to the convicted person, they are entitled to some form of ultimate relief.
(6)The evidence sought to be tested meets either of the following conditions:
(A)The evidence was not tested previously.
(B)The evidence was tested previously, but the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results.
(7)The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community.
(8)The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay.
(h)(1)If the court grants the motion for DNA testing, the court order shall identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used.
(2)The testing shall be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney and the person filing the motion. If the parties cannot agree, the court shall designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards. Laboratories accredited by the following entities have been determined to satisfy this requirement: the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA), the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board (ASCLD/LAB), and Forensic Quality Services (ANSI-ASQ National Accreditation Board FQS).
(3)If the accredited laboratory selected by the parties or designated by the court to conduct DNA testing is not a National DNA Index System (NDIS) participating laboratory that takes or retains ownership of the DNA data for entry into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), the laboratory selected to perform DNA testing shall not initiate analysis for a specific case until documented approval has been obtained from an appropriate NDIS participating laboratorys technical leader of acceptance of ownership of the DNA data from the selected laboratory that may be entered into or searched in CODIS.
(i)In accordance with the courts order pursuant to subdivision (h), the laboratory may communicate with either party, upon request, during the testing process. The result of any testing ordered under this section shall be fully disclosed to the person filing the motion, the district attorney, and the Attorney General. If requested by any party, the court shall order production of the underlying laboratory data and notes.
(j)(1)The cost of DNA testing ordered under this section shall be borne by the state or the applicant, as the court may order in the interests of justice, if it is shown that the applicant is not indigent and possesses the ability to pay. However, the cost of any additional testing to be conducted by the district attorney or Attorney General shall not be borne by the convicted person.
(2)In order to pay the states share of any testing costs, the laboratory designated in subdivision (h) shall present its bill for services to the superior court for approval and payment. It is the intent of the Legislature to appropriate funds for this purpose in the 200001 Budget Act.
(k)An order granting or denying a motion for DNA testing under this section shall not be appealable, and shall be subject to review only through petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed by the person seeking DNA testing, the district attorney, or the Attorney General. The petition shall be filed within 20 days after the courts order granting or denying the motion for DNA testing. In a noncapital case, the petition for writ of mandate or prohibition shall be filed in the court of appeal. In a capital case, the petition shall be filed in the California Supreme Court. The court of appeal or California Supreme Court shall expedite its review of a petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed under this subdivision.
(l)DNA testing ordered by the court pursuant to this section shall be done as soon as practicable. However, if the court finds that a miscarriage of justice will otherwise occur and that it is necessary in the interests of justice to give priority to the DNA testing, a DNA laboratory shall be required to give priority to the DNA testing ordered pursuant to this section over the laboratorys other pending casework.
(m)DNA profile information from biological samples taken from a convicted person pursuant to a motion for postconviction DNA testing is exempt from any law requiring disclosure of information to the public.
(n)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the right to file a motion for postconviction DNA testing provided by this section is absolute and shall not be waived. This prohibition applies to, but is not limited to, a waiver that is given as part of an agreement resulting in a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(o)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
(a)In the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, through the defendants counsel, may request the court for funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The application for funds shall be by affidavit and shall specify that the funds are reasonably necessary for the preparation or presentation of the defense. The fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. Upon receipt of an application, a judge of the court, other than the trial judge presiding over the case in question, shall rule on the reasonableness of the request and shall disburse an appropriate amount of money to the defendants attorney. The ruling on the reasonableness of the request shall be made at an in camera hearing. In making the ruling, the court shall be guided by the need to provide a complete and full defense for the defendant.
(b)(1)The Controller shall not reimburse any county for costs that exceed Department of General Services standards for travel and per diem expenses. The Controller may reimburse extraordinary costs in unusual cases if the county provides sufficient documentation of the need for those expenditures.
(2)At the termination of the proceedings, the attorney shall furnish to the court a complete accounting of all moneys received and disbursed pursuant to this section.
(c)The Controller shall adopt regulations pursuant to Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, controlling reimbursements under this section. The regulations shall consider compensation for investigators, expert witnesses, and other expenses that may or may not be reimbursable pursuant to this section. Notwithstanding the provisions of Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the Controller shall follow any regulations adopted until final approval by the Office of Administrative Law.
(d)The confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with access to documents protected by this section when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record, created pursuant to this section, relates to the issue raised. When the defendant raises that issue, issue either on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the Attorney General at the Attorney Generals prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding at their request. In this case, the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding.
SEC. 2.Section 1405 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1405.(a)A person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment may make a written motion, pursuant to subdivision (d), before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in his or her their case, for performance of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing.
(b)(1)An indigent convicted person may request appointment of counsel in order to prepare a motion pursuant to subdivision (d) by sending a written request to the court. The request shall include the persons statement that he or she was they were not the perpetrator of the crime and shall explain how the DNA testing is relevant to his or her their assertion of innocence. The request also shall include the persons statement as to whether he or she previously has they previously have had counsel appointed under this section.
(2)If any of the information required in paragraph (1) is missing from the request, the court shall return the request to the convicted person and advise him or her them that the matter cannot be considered without the missing information.
(3)(A)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, he or she has they have included the information required in paragraph (1), and counsel has not previously been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(B)Upon a finding that the person is indigent, and counsel previously has been appointed pursuant to this subdivision, the court may, in its discretion, appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, to file a motion for DNA testing under this section and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing under this section.
(4)This section does not provide for a right to the appointment of counsel in a postconviction collateral proceeding, or to set a precedent for any such right, in any context other than the representation being provided an indigent convicted person for the limited purpose of filing and litigating a motion for DNA testing pursuant to this section.
(c)Upon request of the convicted person or convicted persons counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, the following documents that are in their possession or control, if the documents exist:
(1)Copies of DNA lab reports, with underlying notes, prepared in connection with the laboratory testing of biological evidence from the case, including presumptive tests for the presence of biological material, serological tests, and analyses of trace evidence.
(2)Copies of evidence logs, chain of custody logs and reports, including, but not limited to, documentation of current location of biological evidence, and evidence destruction logs and reports.
(3)If the evidence has been lost or destroyed, a custodian of record shall submit a report to the prosecutor and the convicted person or convicted persons counsel that sets forth the efforts that were made in an attempt to locate the evidence. If the last known or documented location of the evidence prior to its loss or destruction was in an area controlled by a law enforcement agency, the report shall include the results of a physical search of this area. If there is a record of confirmation of destruction of the evidence, the report shall include a copy of the record of confirmation of destruction in lieu of the results of a physical search of the area.
(d)(1)The motion for DNA testing shall be verified by the convicted person under penalty of perjury and shall include all of the following:
(A)A statement that he or she is they are innocent and not the perpetrator of the crime.
(B)Explain why the identity of the perpetrator was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(C)Make every reasonable attempt to identify both the evidence that should be tested and the specific type of DNA testing sought.
(D)Explain, in light of all the evidence, how the requested DNA testing would raise a reasonable probability that the convicted persons verdict or sentence would be more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction.
(E)Reveal the results of any DNA or other biological testing that was conducted previously by either the prosecution or defense, if known.
(F)State whether any motion for testing under this section previously has been filed and the results of that motion, if known.
(2)Notice of the motion shall be served on the Attorney General, the district attorney in the county of conviction, and, if known, the governmental agency or laboratory holding the evidence sought to be tested. Responses, if any, shall be filed within 90 days of the date on which the Attorney General and the district attorney are served with the motion, unless a continuance is granted for good cause.
(e)If the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, it shall order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing.
(f)If the court determines that the convicted person has met all of the requirements of subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), the court may, as it deems necessary, order a hearing on the motion. The judge who conducted the trial, or accepted the convicted persons plea of guilty or nolo contendere, shall conduct the hearing unless the presiding judge determines that judge is unavailable. Upon request of either party, the court may order, in the interest of justice, that the convicted person be present at the hearing of the motion. Either party, upon request, may request an additional 60 days to brief issues raised in subdivision (g).
(g)The court shall grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
(1)The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion.
(2)The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect.
(3)The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
(4)The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted persons identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence. The convicted person is only required to demonstrate that the DNA testing he or she seeks they seek would be relevant to, rather than dispositive of, the issue of identity. The convicted person is not required to show a favorable result would conclusively establish his or her their innocence.
(5)The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted persons verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction. The court in its discretion may consider any evidence whether or not it was introduced at trial. In determining whether the convicted person is entitled to develop potentially exculpatory evidence, the court shall not decide whether, assuming a DNA test result favorable to the convicted person, he or she is they are entitled to some form of ultimate relief.
(6)The evidence sought to be tested meets either of the following conditions:
(A)The evidence was not tested previously.
(B)The evidence was tested previously, but the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results.
(7)The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community.
(8)The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay.
(h)(1)If the court grants the motion for DNA testing, the court order shall identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used.
(2)The testing shall be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney in a noncapital case, or the Attorney General in a capital case, attorney and the person filing the motion. If the parties cannot agree, the court shall designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Directors Quality Assurance Standards. Laboratories accredited by the following entities have been determined to satisfy this requirement: the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA), the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board (ASCLD/LAB), and Forensic Quality Services (ANSI-ASQ National Accreditation Board FQS).
(3)If the accredited laboratory selected by the parties or designated by the court to conduct DNA testing is not a National DNA Index System (NDIS) participating laboratory that takes or retains ownership of the DNA data for entry into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), the laboratory selected to perform DNA testing shall not initiate analysis for a specific case until documented approval has been obtained from an appropriate NDIS participating laboratorys technical leader of acceptance of ownership of the DNA data from the selected laboratory that may be entered into or searched in CODIS.
(i)In accordance with the courts order pursuant to subdivision (h), the laboratory may communicate with either party, upon request, during the testing process. The result of any testing ordered under this section shall be fully disclosed to the person filing the motion, the district attorney, and the Attorney General. If requested by any party, the court shall order production of the underlying laboratory data and notes.
(j)(1)The cost of DNA testing ordered under this section shall be borne by the state or the applicant, as the court may order in the interests of justice, if it is shown that the applicant is not indigent and possesses the ability to pay. However, the cost of any additional testing to be conducted by the district attorney or Attorney General shall not be borne by the convicted person.
(2)In order to pay the states share of any testing costs, the laboratory designated in subdivision (h) shall present its bill for services to the superior court for approval and payment. It is the intent of the Legislature to appropriate funds for this purpose in the 200001 Budget Act.
(k)An order granting or denying a motion for DNA testing under this section shall not be appealable, and shall be subject to review only through petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed by the person seeking DNA testing, the district attorney, or the Attorney General. The petition shall be filed within 20 days after the courts order granting or denying the motion for DNA testing. In a noncapital case, the petition for writ of mandate or prohibition shall be filed in the court of appeal. In a capital case, the petition shall be filed in the California Supreme Court. The court of appeal or California Supreme Court shall expedite its review of a petition for writ of mandate or prohibition filed under this subdivision.
(l)DNA testing ordered by the court pursuant to this section shall be done as soon as practicable. However, if the court finds that a miscarriage of justice will otherwise occur and that it is necessary in the interests of justice to give priority to the DNA testing, a DNA laboratory shall be required to give priority to the DNA testing ordered pursuant to this section over the laboratorys other pending casework.
(m)DNA profile information from biological samples taken from a convicted person pursuant to a motion for postconviction DNA testing is exempt from any law requiring disclosure of information to the public.
(n)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the right to file a motion for postconviction DNA testing provided by this section is absolute and shall not be waived. This prohibition applies to, but is not limited to, a waiver that is given as part of an agreement resulting in a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(o)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 18, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 153, Statutes of 2024. |
| Jul 18, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 18, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 12:30 p.m. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 4850.). |
| Jun 26, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| May 15, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 2, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 2, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 73. Noes 0. Page 5090.) |
| Apr 25, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 23). |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB2521 Waldron | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2024 | AB 2521 Waldron Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Support | |
| Riverside County District Attorney | ** Support | |
| San Diego County District Attorney's Office | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2521 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 2521
Author: Waldron (R)
Introduced: 2/13/24
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/25/24
AYES: Wahab, Seyarto, Bradford, Skinner, Wiener
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-0, 5/2/24 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Criminal procedure: confidentiality and DNA testing
SOURCE: San Diego County District Attorney
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies that a court may grant any prosecuting agency representing the state on appeal in a capital case access to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant when relevant to an issue raised by the defendant.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes an indigent defendant, in the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, to request through defense counsel that funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. (Penal Code, § 987 (a))
- Provides that the fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. (Penal Code, § 987 (a))
- Provides that the confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents relating to an indigent defendant’s application for funds when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record on the application for funds relates to the issue raised. (Penal Code § 987 (b))
- Provides that when the defendant raises that issue, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the Attorney General at the Attorney General’s request, in which case the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding. (Penal Code § 987 (b))
- Authorizes a person convicted of a felony and currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion, as specified, before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in their case, for DNA testing. (Penal Code, § 1405, subd. (a))
- Requires the request to include the person’s statement that they were not the perpetrator of the crime and to explain how the DNA testing is relevant to their assertion of innocence. (Penal Code § 1405 (b)(1))
- Provides that upon request of the convicted person or convicted person’s counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, if the documents exist, among other documents, copies of DNA lab reports and copies of evidence logs. (Penal Code § 1405 (c)(1)(2))
- Requires the court, if the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, to order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing. (Penal Code § 1405 (e))
- Requires the court to grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
- The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect;
- The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case;
- The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted person’s identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence;
- The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted person’s verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction;
- The evidence sought was not tested previously of, the evidence was previously tested, the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results;
- The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community; and,
- The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay. (Penal Code, § 1405 (g)(1)-(8))
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
- Requires the court order granting the motion to identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used. (Penal Code, § 1405 (h)(1))
- Requires the testing to be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, or the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion. (Penal Code, § 1405 (h)(2))
- Requires the court, if the parties cannot agree on a laboratory, to designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards. (Penal Code, § 1405 (h)(2))
This bill:
- Clarifies that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, may access documents relating to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant in a capital case when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review and the recorded portion of the record relating to the application for funds also relates to the issue raised.
- Provides that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, shall be provided with funding records at their request when the defendant raises an issue related to the application for funds on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued.
- Clarifies that, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the person filing the motion and the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital.
This bill clarifies, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital, and the person filing the motion.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 1342 (Burton, Chapter 821, Statutes of 2000) created a process for a person currently incarcerated for a felony to make a motion for performance of DNA testing. At that time the bill provided that the testing should be done at a lab that meets specified accreditation standards and mutually agreed upon by the attorney general and the person filing the motion in a capital case or by the district attorney and the person filing the motion in a non-capitol case.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/25/24)
San Diego County District Attorney's Office (source)
California District Attorneys Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The sponsor, the San Diego District Attorney’s Office supports this bill stating:
The San Diego County District Attorney’s Office is pleased to sponsor Assembly Bill (AB) 2521 and would like to thank Assemblymember Waldron for authoring this important legislation. AB 2521 will fix two procedural gaps in the Penal Code, which derive from the now-outdated premise that the California Attorney General will handle all petitions for writ of habeas corpus in capital cases. Based on a policy change, these matters are increasingly delegated to District Attorneys. Thus, it is important to update the Penal Code in two areas to reflect these policy changes. Additionally, it is crucial to provide the District Attorney the same authority to access documents and to agree to additional DNA testing in order to litigate habeas petitions pending in the Superior Court.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-0, 5/2/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Megan Dahle, Flora, Low, Mathis, Weber, Robert Rivas
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
6/26/24 14:28:15
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 2521 Hearing Date: June 25, 2024
Author: | Waldron | ||
Version: | February 13, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Criminal procedure: confidentiality and DNA testing
HISTORY
Source: San Diego County District Attorney
Prior Legislation: SB 243 (Wiener) held Sen. Approps. 2021
SB 1134 (Leno) Chapter 785, Stats. 2016
SB 694 (Leno) held Assembly Approps 2015
SB 980 (Lieu) Chapter 554, Stats. 2014
SB 1058 (Leno), Chapter 623, Stats. 2014,
SB 618 (Leno), Chapter 800, Stats. 2013
AB 1593 (Ma), Chapter 809, Stats. 2012
SB 83 (Burton) Chapter 943, Stats. 2001
SB 1342 (Burton) Chapter 821, Stats 2000
Support: California District Attorneys Association
Opposition: None known
Assembly Floor Vote: 73 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to clarify that a court may grant any prosecuting agency representing the state on appeal in a capital case access to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant when relevant to an issue raised by the defendant.
Existing law authorizes an indigent defendant, in the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, to request through defense counsel that funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. (Penal Code, § 987 (a).)
Existing law provides that the fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. (Penal Code, § 987 (a).)
Existing law provides that the confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents relating to an indigent defendant’s application for funds when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record on the application for funds relates to the issue raised. (Penal Code § 987 (b).)
Existing law provides that when the defendant raises that issue, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the Attorney General at the Attorney General’s request, in which case the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding. (Pen. Code § 987 (b).)
Existing law authorizes a person convicted of a felony and currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion, as specified, before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in their case, for DNA testing. (Penal Code, § 1405, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires the request to include the person’s statement that they were not the perpetrator of the crime and to explain how the DNA testing is relevant to their assertion of innocence. (Penal Code § 1405 (b)(1).)
Existing law provides that upon request of the convicted person or convicted person’s counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, if the documents exist, among other documents, copies of DNA lab reports and copies of evidence logs. (Penal Code § 1405 (c)(1) & (2).)
Existing law requires the court, if the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, to order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing. (Penal Code § 1405 (e).)
Existing law requires the court to grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
- The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect;
- The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case;
- The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted person’s identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence;
- The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted person’s verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction;
- The evidence sought was not tested previously of, the evidence was previously tested, the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results;
- The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community; and,
- The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay. (Pen. Code, § 1405 (g)(1)-(8).)
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
Existing law requires the court order granting the motion to identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used. (Pen. Code, § 1405 (h)(1).)
Existing law requires the testing to be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, or the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion. (Pen. Code, § 1405 (h)(2).)
Existing law requires the court, if the parties cannot agree on a laboratory, to designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards. (Pen. Code, § 1405 (h)(2).)
This bill clarifies that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, may access documents relating to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant in a capital case when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review and the recorded portion of the record relating to the application for funds also relates to the issue raised.
This bill provides that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, shall be provided with funding records at their request when the defendant raises an issue related to the application for funds on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued.
This bill clarifies that, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the person filing the motion and the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
AB 2521 recognizes recent policy changes by tasking District Attorneys with managing vital legal challenges following appeals in death penalty cases. By delegating the oversight of capital habeas corpus petitions to District Attorneys, we grant them authority over DNA testing requests and access to funding records in capital cases, roles previously exclusive to the Attorney General. This shift is crucial for District Attorneys, providing them with equal responsibilities in post-trial capital litigation, and reducing delays.
2. Post-Conviction proceedings
Approved by California voters in November 2016, Death Penalty Reform and Savings Act of 2016 was “intended to facilitate the enforcement of judgments and achieve cost savings in capital cases.” (Briggs v. Brown (2017) 3 Cal.5th 808, 822.)
Proposition 66 includes a series of findings and declarations to the effect that California's death penalty system is inefficient, wasteful, and subject to protracted delay, denying murder victims and their families justice and due process. (Voter Information Guide, Gen. Elec. (Nov. 8, 2016) § 2, p. 212 (Voter Guide).) The measure enacts a series of statutory reforms, which may be grouped into three general categories: (1) provisions to expedite review in capital appeals and habeas corpus proceedings; (2) provisions governing the confinement of prisoners sentenced to death and the administration of the death penalty; and (3) provisions pertaining to California's Habeas Corpus Resource Center. (Id. at p. 823.)
As part of the effort to expedite review of capital cases, Proposition 66 shifted responsibility for habeas proceedings from the California Supreme Court to county courts:
The measure requires that habeas corpus petitions first be heard in trial courts instead of the California Supreme Court. (Direct appeals would continue to be heard in the California Supreme Court.) Specifically, these habeas corpus petitions would be heard by the judge who handled the original murder trial unless good cause is shown for another judge or court to hear the petition. The measure requires trial courts to explain in writing their decision on each petition, which could be appealed to the Courts of Appeal. The decisions made by the Courts of Appeal could then be appealed to the California Supreme Court. The measure allows the California Supreme Court to transfer any habeas corpus petitions currently pending before it to the trial courts.
(https://repository.uclawsf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2358&context=ca_ballot_props)
Existing law provides that the “Attorney General has direct supervision over the district attorneys of the several counties of the state.” (Cal. Const., art. 5, § 13; Gov. Code, § 12550.) Under this authority, the Attorney General has delegated some responsibility for post-conviction litigation to district attorneys.
This bill would clarify that a court may grant any prosecuting agency representing the state on appeal in a capital case access to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant when relevant to an issue raised by the defendant. Existing law limits access to only the Attorney General.
3. Post-conviction DNA testing
SB 1342 (Burton) Chapter 821, Statutes of 2000 created a process for a person currently incarcerated for a felony to make a motion for performance of DNA testing. At that time the bill provided that the testing should be done at a lab that meets specified accreditation standards and mutually agreed upon by the attorney general and the person filing the motion in a capital case or by the district attorney and the person filing the motion in a non-capitol case.
This bill clarifies, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital, and the person filing the motion.
4. Argument in Support
The sponsor, the San Diego District Attorney’s Office supports this bill stating:
The San Diego County District Attorney’s Office is pleased to sponsor Assembly Bill (AB) 2521 and would like to thank Assemblymember Waldron for authoring this important legislation. AB 2521 will fix two procedural gaps in the Penal Code, which derive from the now-outdated premise that the California Attorney General will handle all petitions for writ of habeas corpus in capital cases. Based on a policy change, these matters are increasingly delegated to District Attorneys. Thus, it is important to update the Penal Code in two areas to reflect these policy changes. Additionally, it is crucial to provide the District Attorney the same authority to access documents and to agree to additional DNA testing in order to litigate habeas petitions pending in the Superior Court.
-- END –
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
Counsel: Andrew Ironside
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Clarifies that a court may grant any prosecuting agency representing the state on appeal in a capital case access to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant when relevant to an issue raised by the defendant. Specifically, this bill:
- Clarifies that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, may access documents relating to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant in a capital case when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review and the recorded portion of the record relating to the application for funds also relates to the issue raised.
- Provides that the prosecuting agency representing the state, not just the Attorney General, shall be provided with funding records at their request when the defendant raises an issue related to the application for funds on appeal or in a collateral review where an order to show cause has issued.
- Clarifies that, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the person filing the motion and the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes an indigent defendant, in the trial of a capital case or a case under subdivision (a) of Section 190.05, the indigent defendant, to request through defense counsel that funds for the specific payment of investigators, experts, and others for the preparation or presentation of the defense. (Pen. Code, § 987, subd. (a).)
- Provides that the fact that an application has been made shall be confidential and the contents of the application shall be confidential. (Pen. Code, § 987, subd. (a).)
- Provides that the confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents relating to an indigent defendant’s application for funds when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record on the application for funds relates to the issue raised. (Pen. Code, § 987, subd. (b).)
- When the defendant raises that issue, the funding records, or relevant portions thereof, shall be provided to the Attorney General at the Attorney General’s request, in which case the documents shall remain under seal and their use shall be limited solely to the pending proceeding. (Pen. Code, § 987, subd. (b).)
- Authorizes a person convicted of a felony and currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion, as specified, before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in their case, for DNA testing. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (a).)
- Requires the request to include the person’s statement that they were not the perpetrator of the crime and to explain how the DNA testing is relevant to their assertion of innocence. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (b)(1).)
- Upon request of the convicted person or convicted person’s counsel, the court may order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, if the documents exist, among other documents, copies of DNA lab reports and copies of evidence logs. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (c)(1) & (2).)
- Requires the court, if the court finds evidence was subjected to DNA or other forensic testing previously by either the prosecution or defense, to order the party at whose request the testing was conducted to provide all parties and the court with access to the laboratory reports, underlying data, and laboratory notes prepared in connection with the DNA or other biological evidence testing. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (e).)
- Requires the court to grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
- The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not been substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect;
- The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case;
- The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted person’s identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence;
- The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted person’s verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction;
- The evidence sought was not tested previously of, the evidence was previously tested, the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results;
- The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community; and,
- The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (g)(1)-(8).)
- The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit the DNA testing requested in the motion;
- Requires the court order granting the motion to identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (h)(1).)
- Requires the testing to be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, or the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (h)(2).)
- Requires the court, if the parties cannot agree on a laboratory, to designate a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (h)(2).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “AB 2521 recognizes recent policy changes by tasking District Attorneys with managing vital legal challenges following appeals in death penalty cases. By delegating the oversight of capital habeas corpus petitions to District Attorneys, we grant them authority over DNA testing requests and access to funding records in capital cases, roles previously exclusive to the Attorney General. This shift is crucial for District Attorneys, providing them with equal responsibilities in post-trial capital litigation, and reducing delays.”
- Need for the Bill: Approved by California voters in November 2016, Death Penalty Reform and Savings Act of 2016 was “intended to facilitate the enforcement of judgments and achieve cost savings in capital cases.” (Briggs v. Brown (2017) 3 Cal.5th 808, 822.)
Proposition 66 includes a series of findings and declarations to the effect that California's death penalty system is inefficient, wasteful, and subject to protracted delay, denying murder victims and their families justice and due process. (Voter Information Guide, Gen. Elec. (Nov. 8, 2016) § 2, p. 212 (Voter Guide).) The measure enacts a series of statutory reforms, which may be grouped into three general categories: (1) provisions to expedite review in capital appeals and habeas corpus proceedings; (2) provisions governing the confinement of prisoners sentenced to death and the administration of the death penalty; and (3) provisions pertaining to California's Habeas Corpus Resource Center.
(Id. at p. 823.)
As part of the effort to expedite review of capital cases, Proposition 66 shifted responsibility for habeas proceedings from the California Supreme Court to county courts:
The measure requires that habeas corpus petitions first be heard in trial courts instead of the California Supreme Court. (Direct appeals would continue to be heard in the California Supreme Court.) Specifically, these habeas corpus petitions would be heard by the judge who handled the original murder trial unless good cause is shown for another judge or court to hear the petition. The measure requires trial courts to explain in writing their decision on each petition, which could be appealed to the Courts of Appeal. The decisions made by the Courts of Appeal could then be appealed to the California Supreme Court. The measure allows the California Supreme Court to transfer any habeas corpus petitions currently pending before it to the trial courts.
(https://repository.uclawsf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2358&context=ca_ballot_props)
Existing law provides that the “Attorney General has direct supervision over the district attorneys of the several counties of the state.” (Cal. Const., art. 5, § 13; Gov. Code, § 12550.) Under this authority, the Attorney General has delegated some responsibility for post-conviction litigation to district attorneys.
According to the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office, “This bill facilitates the long-established practice where large local prosecutor’s offices with expertise in writs and appeals handle post-conviction work at the Superior Court level (and sometimes the Court of Appeal) at the behest of the Attorney General. This practice has been long recognized by Penal Code section 4750 which provides a reimbursement mechanism for some cases and was further extended by Proposition 66 shifting capital habeas work to the Superior Court level. AB 2521 eliminates a barrier to this long-established practice in cases in which the records of trial counsel requests for investigative resources are under scrutiny after conviction.”
This bill would clarify that a court may grant any prosecuting agency representing the state on appeal in a capital case access to the application and contents of the application for specified funds by an indigent defendant when relevant to an issue raised by the defendant. Existing law limits access to only the Attorney General.
This bill also provides that, if a court grants a motion for DNA testing in a felony case where the person is serving a term of imprisonment, the laboratory conducting the test must be mutually agreed upon by the Attorney General or district attorney, regardless of whether the case is capital or noncapital, and the person filing the motion. Existing law provides that the Attorney General may approve of the laboratory testing in capital cases, and that the district attorney’s authority extends only to noncapital ones.
- Argument in Support: According to the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office, the bill’s sponsor, “AB 2521 will fix two procedural gaps in the Penal Code, which derive from the now-outdated premise that the California Attorney General will handle all petitions for writ of habeas corpus in capital cases. Based on a policy change, these matters are increasingly delegated to District Attorneys. Thus, it is important to update the Penal Code in two areas to reflect these policy changes and provide the District Attorney the same authority to access documents and to agree to additional DNA testing in order to litigate habeas petitions pending in the Superior Court.
“On November 8, 2016, California voters approved Proposition 66, which sought to fix the death penalty in California by increasing its efficiency. One of Prop. 66’s changes shifted capital petitions for writ of habeas corpus from the California Supreme Court (where the Attorney General predominantly practices) to the county Superior Courts (where District Attorneys routinely practice). Due to this shift, the Attorney General has delegated much of the work of responding to capital habeas petitions to District Attorneys. However, the Penal Code has not yet been amended to reflect that change. Thus, there are two Penal Code sections requiring amendment: 987.9 and 1405.
“Confidential Defense Funding Applications
“Penal Code section 987.9 outlines the regulations controlling funds used in preparation of the defense of indigent defendants in a capital case, including that the funding applications are made confidential. However, under subdivision (d), ‘The confidentiality provided in this section shall not preclude any court from providing the Attorney General with access to documents protected by this section when the defendant raises an issue on appeal or collateral review where the recorded portion of the record, created pursuant to this section, relates to the issue raised.’ (Pen. Code, § 987.9, subd. (d).)
“This bill would, instead, provide that this confidentiality does not preclude any court from providing the prosecuting agency representing the state in the proceeding with that access. In some cases, the prosecuting agency will be the Attorney General; in others, it will be the District Attorney.
“DNA Testing Laboratory Selection
“Penal Code section 1405 controls the motion and parameters of an inmate’s request for DNA testing in relation to their case. It states in relevant part, ‘[t]he testing shall be conducted by a laboratory that meets the FBI Director’s Quality Assurance Standards and that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney in a noncapital case, or the Attorney General in a capital case, and the person filing the motion.’ (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (h)(2), italics added.)
“This bill would instead require that DNA testing to be conducted by a laboratory that is mutually agreed upon by the district attorney or Attorney General and the person filing the motion, regardless of the type of case.
“AB 2521 provides a needed legislative fix to complement the Attorney General’s policy changes that require local district attorneys to handle more capital case habeas litigation in the Superior Court that were not contemplated when Penal Code sections 987.9 and 1405 were drafted.” - Prior Legislation:
- SB 243 (Wiener), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have expanded the definition of “false evidence” for the purpose of habeas corpus relief and required the court to make specified determinations when considering the admission of expert testimony in criminal proceedings. SB 243 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
- SB 1134 (Leno) Chapter 785, Statutes of 2016, codified a standard for habeas corpus petitions filed on the basis of new evidence.
- SB 694 (Leno), of the 2015-2016 Legislative Session, would have codified a standard for habeas corpus petitions filed on the basis of new evidence. SB 694 was held in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 1058 (Leno), Chapter 623, Statutes of 2014, allowed a writ of habeas corpus to be prosecuted when evidence given at trial has subsequently been repudiated by the expert that testified or undermined by later scientific research or technological advances.
- SB 618 (Leno), Chapter 800, Statutes of 2013, streamlined the process for compensating persons who have been exonerated after being wrongfully convicted and imprisoned.
- AB 1593 (Ma), Chapter 809, Statutes of 2012, allows a writ of habeas corpus to be prosecuted if expert testimony relating to intimate partner battering and its effects was received into evidence but was limited at the trial court proceedings relating to a prisoner’s incarceration for the commission of a violent felony committed prior to August 29, 1996, and there is a reasonable probability, sufficient to undermine confidence in the judgment of conviction, that if the testimony had not been limited, the result of the proceedings would have been different.
- SB 243 (Wiener), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have expanded the definition of “false evidence” for the purpose of habeas corpus relief and required the court to make specified determinations when considering the admission of expert testimony in criminal proceedings. SB 243 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
San Diego County District Attorney's Office (Sponsor)
California District Attorneys Association
Riverside County District Attorney
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by:
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):